<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Dave B on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Dave B on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 15:13:31 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Apple Music is in Rough Shape. Here’s How to Fix It.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/apple-music-is-in-rough-shape-heres-how-to-fix-it-55f25d25fd20?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/55f25d25fd20</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[user-experience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Dec 2021 00:37:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-08T01:16:01.332Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The Apple Music app has some big problems. It has significant shortcomings in terms of technical performance, design, and missing features. Here’s why the app is so controversial and what can be done about it.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*FK_BGgjj_mF7JATuCKDQrw.png" /><figcaption>Apple Music for iOS, iPadOS, and macOS are in rough shape.</figcaption></figure><p>In the 6+ years since Apple Music was released in June of 2015, it has been a controversial app, to put it mildly. In those 6 years, I’ve written extensively on Apple Music’s flaws — both big and small. Some of these flaws have been resolved, many haven’t, and some new ones have been introduced. It’s been a while since my <a href="https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/some-pain-points-in-the-ios-11-music-app-57eba435e3b2">2017 list</a> of Apple Music’s shortcomings, so it’s time for a 2021 update.</p><p>As a music lover, longtime Apple fan, and design enthusiast, I really want to like this app, but it has so many problems, of both a design nature and a technical nature. There are also many missing features. For a company with so many fantastic products and such high standards, the Apple Music app is a rare misstep.</p><p>Here’s why the app is so controversial, has so many shortcomings, and what Apple can do to improve it.</p><h3><strong>Summary:</strong></h3><p>If I could provide a 30,000 foot summary of what I see as the major problem inherent to Apple Music’s design, it’s that it doesn’t quite know what it wants to be.</p><p>There are two primary types of music listeners — those who maintain libraries and those who don’t. Some people like to collect hundreds, if not thousands of albums, organize them, maintain them, and play back the specific music they want to hear at that specific moment. Others prefer the streaming method, where they might have certain genres, styles of music, and even artists they enjoy, but they’re happy letting a curator (human or algorithmic) send them an endless stream of songs roughly based on their tastes.</p><p><strong>Group A</strong> are the people who collected vinyl records/cassettes/CDs/iTunes libraries throughout their lives. The physical media are mostly gone, but the desire to collect and organize is not. They know exactly what they like, and while they enjoy suggestions and curation and recommendations to add to their library, they tend to listen to specific artists, specific albums, and specific songs, not simply music within a general style or overall genre.</p><p><strong>Group B</strong> are those who are more oriented around radio stations, mix tapes, Top 40 hits, and of course, Spotify streams. Some would call them more casual listeners. That’s not at all a denigrating term, rather, it simply points to the fundamental difference in how they consume music compared to Group A.</p><p><strong>Apple Music is trying to appeal to both crowds and in my opinion, it doesn’t get either one right. It’s stuck in the middle, doing a sort of half-hearted job at both. The result is that it provides a mediocre product to both Group A and Group B.</strong></p><p>Most <strong>Group B</strong> people will tell you that Apple Music’s recommendations are simply not as good as Spotify’s. Whatever suggestion algorithms Apple uses just aren’t nearly as accurate as they ought to be. They’ve improved over time, but they still have a long way to go. And it’s worth noting that tapping the ‘Love’ hearts or the ‘Suggest Less Like This’ button is supposed to improve the suggestion algorithms, but it doesn’t seem to work very well in practice. The curation often feels more like advertising, where the feature is less catered around what the end user wants, and more around what the content providers (i.e. Apple and/or the record labels) wish to foist upon them. That’s a problem, as <a href="https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/curation-should-be-a-feature-not-a-user-interface-ae52384bc30c">it makes the app feel like a collection of billboards</a>, rather than a user-focused experience.</p><p>And for <strong>Group A</strong> people (of which I am one), the tools to be able to organize, sort, sift through, maintain, and play back a music library — are just sorely lacking and lead to a terrible experience.</p><p><em>There are significant shortcomings in terms of the technical performance, design, and missing features that really hurt the experience for both groups.</em></p><p>That’s the 30,000 foot summary of the problem. For a little more detail and specificity on these problems, on what needs to be fixed and improved, and on why the Apple Music app doesn’t meet the standards we normally expect from Apple, here’s a list of some of these problems, broken out into the three main categories — <strong>Technicals</strong>, <strong>Design</strong>, and <strong>Missing Features</strong>:</p><h3><strong>The Problems with Apple Music:</strong></h3><p><strong>Technicals</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Backend tech.</strong> The entire Apple Music backend needs dramatic improvement in terms of album organization, matching, and even genre listings. We’re 6+ years into Apple Music and it’s still a mess. For example, albums still get broken up all the time (i.e. it will match half your album to one version on Apple’s database and half to a remaster of the same album, meaning it now thinks you have half of two albums). This even frequently occurs with individual songs, where Apple Music will take a song in your library, see that you like it, and then suggest back to you an alternative version of that song, such as in the Apple ‘Favorites Mix’ playlist, which somehow has plenty of songs you know and love from your Library, but that are listed as being from the Apple Music database. This creates all sorts of problems with metadata, with organization and analytics, and even with Siri requests.</li><li><strong>Matching.</strong> These above matching problems occur even with music I’ve downloaded right from Apple Music, where I’ll download an album and then when I go back to it later, it will have been broken up due to numerous matching errors. This results in so much library duplication and messiness, as the music you download from Apple Music is never on solid footing, and the interplay between what’s part of your Library and what isn’t — is a mess. It also creates problems for when you may not have an internet connection.</li><li><strong>Terrible performance.</strong> The app is slow to load and it frequently refreshes, even on my iPhone 12. I don’t know if this is some sort of memory limitation, but performance this awful on a main first party Apple app is a big problem. This needs to be improved dramatically.</li></ol><p><strong>Design</strong></p><ol><li><strong>‘Up Next’ is awful.</strong> The ‘Up Next’ song queuing system needs a rethink in terms of how ‘Play Next’ / ‘Play Last’ work. Functionally, the old ‘Play Later’ feature made more sense than the current ‘Play Last’ feature that replaced it, but I’m guessing it was changed a few years ago because ‘Later’ is an ambiguous term that was confusing to users regarding where exactly it would insert the music. Perhaps a possible solution to this is to have some sort of visual aid, where you press and hold an ‘Up Next’ button, a little horizontal visual representation of the timeline pops up above your thumb, and you can slide your thumb over to the insertion point (ie. with markers at Next/Later/Last), you release your thumb, and the music you had selected gets inserted at that point in the timeline. I think a simple graphical gesture system like that would be a lot better than having discrete ‘Play Next’ / ‘Play Last’ buttons, as we currently have.</li><li><strong>The ‘Now Playing’ screen needs a redesign. </strong>Visually it’s fine, but navigating feels like a chore — everything from jumping in and out of Lyrics and ‘Up Next’, to tapping a name and hitting ‘Go To’ — all feels cumbersome and unnatural, even after years of use. I’d like to see Apple Music adopt the ‘pillbox’ gesture system from the iPhone X and now from Safari for iOS 15. Instead of tapping buttons randomly scattered on the Now Playing screen to enter into these various ‘modes’, you would swipe between tabs (i.e. the Lyrics/Now Playing/Up Next tabs), and then you’d swipe upward to get an overview that acts as a sort of Control Center with all the key functionality you need for the Music app.</li><li><strong>Playlist management. </strong>Playlist management needs to be improved, with better folder functionality, more views, and a better use of space. Even a 5.4&quot; and 6.1” iPhone screen <a href="https://imgur.com/a/oLUwoTI">only displays 5 line items at a time</a>. By comparison, my old 2.5” iPod Classic displayed 9 line items. With only 5 lines, that means you have to scroll so much to get anywhere. And you still can’t place Apple Music playlists in folders. It also seems odd to me that the “New Playlist…” function is a line item rather than a button.</li><li><strong>Use of space.</strong> In addition to the above points, the playlist tiles/icons on the left are too large and don’t serve a purpose. All they do is push the text over to the right, which reduces the horizontal space, and thus creates too much vertical space for each line. You end up with a lot of white space. So the Playlists screen lacks functionality and has a poor use of space. It’s even aesthetically ugly due to the visual imbalance of having those large tiles on the left third of the screen.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*zIVe3oCphTUH-SnmtjmrFQ@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Playlists screen is awful. Between the needlessly large tiles that serve no purpose, the excessive white space, the very limited sorting options and lack of Views, the odd choice to make “New Playlist…” a line item rather than a button, the fact that Apple Music Playlists can’t even be placed in folders, and of course, the excessive scrolling due the fact that only 5 line items are visible at a time even on a large 5.4&quot; or 6.1” device, this entire screen is a usability nightmare. It’s hard to believe something so bad was created by Apple, and it’s even harder to believe it STILL hasn’t been fixed after all these years.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Design (continued)</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Gestures.</strong> More gestures are needed, like two-finger drag to select multiple items (just like in Mail &amp; Reminders) and pinch-to-zoom to resize and change information density (like in Photos).</li><li><strong>Discographies. </strong>Artist discographies need better organization. Remasters/Deluxe versions should never be in the main discography. The main discog should be original releases organized by original release date. Everything else should be in separate sections. It’s worth noting that Wikipedia handles album organization better than Apple Music does. This area has seen some notable improvement over the years (i.e. EPs and singles were rightfully given a separate section a few years ago), but it needs to improve further.</li><li><strong>Animations.</strong> Excessive animations when navigating. The purpose of the animations is to give the user a sense of placement in the app, but these animations don’t have that effect in practice. For example, using the aforementioned ‘Go To’ feature causes all sorts of panels to slide up and over, and it just makes the app feel unnecessarily slow. The whole method of getting around the app feels much slower and more cumbersome than it should. I think a key problem is that these animations ‘take you’ somewhere. For example, the original Steve Jobs iPhone demo of tapping an album cover to flip it over and show the track list is a good animation because it retains your sense of placement in the UI. But with the current app, when you tap ‘Go To Album’, it uses animations to take you to a new ‘place’, which is disorienting, along with being slow.</li><li><strong>Aesthetics.</strong> Much of the app is too thin and flat, like it’s still stuck in the iOS 7 design ethos, even though much of iOS has evolved a fair bit since then. For example, the minimized ‘Now Playing’ bar should be rounded and less thin, like the iOS 15 Safari URL bar.</li><li><strong>Search prioritization.</strong> Search and Siri should place priority on your music Library. If I have an artist/album/song in my Library, then when I search for it (either via text or via Siri), Apple Music should not be grabbing some alternative file from their database. That results in so much duplication and messy metadata and analytics. This is actually a problem that also exists in several other apps, including Maps and Calendar, where your own relevant info like an address or contact is given less priority than some random POI or search result Apple found in one of its databases.</li><li><strong>Too much focus on curation.</strong> The entire app is far too heavily focused on curation. 4 of the 5 main tabs are about curated content — ‘Listen Now’, ‘Browse’, ‘Radio’, and now even the ‘Search’ tab are all about <em>“Here’s music we want you to listen to”</em>. Only the Library tab is about the user’s own preferences, and that tab has gotten very little attention from Apple over the years. As a result, the whole app feels like it was built for content providers, not for end users. It feels like a collection of billboards advertising content at you. Curation is good, but in the right place. Apple Music has not found the right balance. Curation should be a feature, not the entire basis of the app’s design.</li><li><strong>Permanency.</strong> To expound on point #2 in the ‘Technicals’ section earlier, the matching problems result in a constant feeling of <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/AppleMusic/comments/jpx2d3/my_petty_annoyance_with_apple_music/gbhu3yk/?context=1">your library being ephemeral and inconsistent</a>. The streaming ecosystem feels like it exists in a quantum state, where things just appear and disappear out of existence. Albums get split up. A song you downloaded from an album gets matched back to a single or greatest hits album. The ‘Show Complete Album’ feature often brings you to a compilation. Music you’ve downloaded gets greyed out and removed. And so on. Your library never feels like it’s on solid ground. Perhaps a solution to the matching problems would be to introduce a manual component to the process, where the user can confirm/deny the correctness of a match and submit errors, similar to how the error-reporting system works in Apple Maps. <strong>The fact is that even though this is a streaming service we pay for monthly, music we download should have a feeling of permanency. <em>Just because we’re renting our stuff monthly doesn’t mean we don’t want to maintain collections of that rented stuff.</em></strong></li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*b8bG04oQGpid2QXXyFRTxw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*EkjcxFBEOGtqGXlwqUVGDw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*fxbM2AD0Ua9WWrA0jyX9kQ@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Filter systems for Maps, Fitness, and the Apple Store app. This type of functionality is very much needed in Apple Music to sort through your Library using music metadata. It’s also worth noting that while these three screens serve the same purpose in their respective apps, they have wildly inconsistent design languages. This type of filter UI screen is great and should become a new UI paradigm across Apple apps— including in Apple Music.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Missing Features</strong></p><ol><li><strong>Smart Playlists/filters.</strong> Apple Music is <em>still</em> missing a Smart Playlist/filter system to sort through your Library and find the music you want. Apple keeps throwing curated playlists at us, but no matter how many <em>“Here’s a playlist based on a mood or activity or time of day that our Apple curator put together”</em> type playlists that Apple provides, they will never be a substitute for the user actually being able to set his own criteria to determine the music he wants to listen to. Curation is no substitute for smart filters. So many other first party Apple apps have introduced tag/filter systems, like Reminders, Notes, and Apple Maps. Even Fitness and the Apple Store app have a filter feature (see above images). Apple Music needs something similar.</li><li><strong>Continuity. </strong>There’s still no handoff between devices. After all these years, your iPhone, iPad, and Mac are still siloed off from each other in terms of music playback. The HomePod and HomePod mini are the only Apple devices where you can continue from one device to another.</li><li><strong>Pinned music. </strong>There really ought to be some sort of ‘Favorites’ section where users can pin their favorite artists, albums, and songs for easy access.</li><li><strong>Star Ratings.</strong> Star Ratings should be available next to each line item, rather than having stars buried in the menu system. Stars are incredibly important for two reasons. Firstly, they serve the base human desire to rate things as a way to organize and make sense of the world around us (i.e. we rate apps, restaurants, Uber drivers, movies, video games, and so on). Secondly, Star Ratings serve as a sort of flag on your music, so when you’re scrolling through an album or playlist, you can immediately see and be reminded of the music you love. This feature is absolutely key to the aforementioned <strong>Group A</strong> of music listeners.</li><li><strong>Tags and filters.</strong> This works in conjunction with #1. The app really needs a tag/filter system. So many other Apple first party apps have added nice filter systems where you can select criteria to delve down into what you’re looking for. Maps, Fitness, the Apple Store app, and several others have filters, and even Notes and Reminders now having Tags and Smart Lists. Apple Music desperately needs something similar to use music metadata (Artist, Genre, Year, Star Rating, Last Played etc…) to sift through and delve into the music you want to hear. For example, a user should be able to select “metal”, “1985”, and “3 stars and above” and get a dynamic playlist of all his favorite metal songs from 1985. Change the criteria and it immediately populates a new dynamic playlist. The idea is that you get the kind of functionality from classic iTunes Smart Playlists, but dramatically simplified for iOS as dynamic filters, where you don’t have to create/manage/delete playlists, and can simply set filters whenever you want. Apple Maps recently added something analogous for POIs, and this would be great for Apple Music. It would be so simple from a user’s perspective, and yet so powerful with so many possibilities.</li><li><strong>Tags and filters (continued). </strong>With the above filters, you could select your favorite artist, select 3+ Stars, and immediately be presented with a playlist of all your favorite songs by your favorite artist. That kind of functionality sure beats having to rely on ‘Essentials’ playlists. Sometimes you want to play your own favorites by an artist, not the favorites from a random Apple curator who likely has different tastes than you do.</li><li><strong>Audio type.</strong> There’s no simple way to switch between 256/Lossless/Atmos. I enjoy Atmos spatial audio files (well, some of them), but spatial audio is not a replacement for regular stereo; it’s complementary. It should be treated as a different flavor, much like how artists have studio recordings and live recordings, which are separate beasts. Same thing here. There should be a way to swap between stereo and spatial with a simple button. Having to fiddle in Settings is not sufficient. There should be a quick toggle between 256 AAC, Lossless, and Atmos, where you simply tap that badge on the Now Playing screen to alternate between the file types. Currently, if you have one file type, you have to manually delete it, change the setting to the other type (i.e. Lossless to Atmos or vice versa) and then manually redownload the song. It’s a pain.</li><li><strong>Genres.</strong> Genre categorizations are terrible. For as long as I can remember, there have been overlapping or duplicative genres (i.e. “Hip Hop” vs “Hip-Hop” vs “Hip-Hop/Rap”), and then on the other side of the spectrum, some genres are way too broad, like “Alternative”, which can mean almost anything. I believe the entire genre categorization method should be replaced with a keyword system, where artists/albums/songs can be given multiple labels, either by Apple Music curators, by the individual user, or perhaps even crowdsourced among all Apple Music users. That way, multiple genres or descriptors can be used to tag each artist/album/song. This goes back to a broad point of mine regarding how Apple Music’s organizational system is too rigid. <em>Everything about Apple Music obeys a nested folder structure, when it should obey a tag structure. The Music Library should feel permanent and the sorting and organizational tools should be light and dynamic.</em> Apple Music is the precise opposite. The organizational tools are stiff and heavy, while the music library has no permanency or solid footing to it. This applies to genre listings, as well.</li><li><strong>Viewing and editing metadata.</strong> As of iOS 15, Apple Photos now allows you to view the metadata by selecting a photo and swiping up. Music should have something similar. This is no longer the early iPhone days when the Music app on your device was a mere companion to the main iTunes app on your Mac/PC. Now Apple Music on iPad/iPhone is a primary experience, so it needs more powerful tools and greater access to info like music metadata.</li><li><strong>Low information density. </strong>The iPhone app doesn’t display song lengths and I can’t view Star Ratings. They should be visible on each line so that you can see how you rate everything, as that acts as a sort of flag on your music. Instead, you have to dive deep into the menu system to see and adjust Star Ratings, which renders them almost useless. Just as in the above point, this is no longer just a companion app to your PC, so it needs to be more powerful and perhaps more customizable with greater information density. That includes making song lengths and Star Ratings visible on every line item.</li><li><strong>Viewing analytics, such as playback stats.</strong> This is self-explanatory. There’s a whole lot of great information like this in iTunes that is not visible in Apple Music. It’s time to pull back the curtain a little, as your iPhone is no longer a mere satellite device to your Mac, and it hasn’t been for a number of years now.</li><li><strong>Year-end summaries.</strong> The Apple Music ‘Replay’ playlists are fun, but I don’t think it’s any secret that Apple Music users are envious of the Spotify feature. It’s become almost a cultural event, where Spotify users discuss their end-of-year stats, while Apple Music users are left out in the cold.</li><li><strong>More View/Sort/Grouping options across your Library.</strong> This is one area where 3rd party music apps like Marvis Pro are far better than Apple’s app. I don’t expect Apple to offer that <a href="https://imgur.com/a/KWuwO13">insane level of customizability</a>, as those types of power user features are often left to 3rd parties. However the current offerings are far too limiting. When I’m going through my Library, there ought to be a whole lot more ways to View, Sort, and Group content. As mentioned earlier, this also includes the ability to pinch to resize content.</li></ol><h3>What comes next?</h3><p>I previously wrote a popular piece about <a href="https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/the-reinvention-of-ipad-f52a2fa60af9">how Apple finally solved its iPad problem</a> by subtly but comprehensively reimagining the iPad’s entire form factor. The iPad Pro used to be a refrigerator-toaster, to use the classic Tim Cook parlance. It tried to be both a tablet and a laptop in one, as exemplified by the 2018 folding Smart Keyboard Folio. It was a poor laptop because the keyboard was mediocre, it had no trackpad, and there was no pointer system. Similarly, it wasn’t a great tablet because that folio case added weight and thickness, and wasn’t very nice to hold, with the keyboard keys folding over the back and remaining exposed, feeling like you were holding an accordion.</p><p><strong>Apple solved this in 2020.</strong> It added a comprehensive (and beautifully designed) pointer system and it released the Magic Keyboard, which essentially separated the iPad out into two distinct ‘modes’ — it had a great keyboard and trackpad for laptop mode, and then you would just pop the iPad off the magnetic back to bring it into tablet mode. Apple also improved landscape support and added UI paradigms like sidebars and drop-down menus. It later followed that up with an excellent keyboard shortcut system to improve things further.</p><p>Essentially, instead of a mediocre refrigerator-toaster, the iPad Pro was now a great refrigerator that transformed into a great toaster.<em> </em>Instead of trying to be two things at the same time, it became a <em>quantum superposition</em> of two different things. It became one thing that transformed into another thing, depending on what you needed. That made the experience so much better in both ‘modes’. It’s a fantastic tablet, and while there’s still room to improve, it’s becoming a formidable laptop for a whole lot of people. That’s a big change from where it was just a couple years ago.</p><p><strong>That’s what Apple Music needs to be.</strong></p><p>Instead of serving <strong>Group A</strong> and <strong>Group B</strong>, each in a half-hearted way, Apple Music should go full throttle in both directions. It should be a streaming music service that is better than Spotify and it should be a library management tool that is better than iTunes ever was. And it should seamlessly switch between these two ‘modes’.</p><p>Some would argue that Apple, as a company, caters to the mainstream and not to enthusiasts in any direction, but I disagree. Apple is such a successful company because it is able to provide amazing tools to the enthusiasts, while simultaneously being able to simplify and abstract away the complexity so that it can appeal to the mainstream. Look at the whole Mac situation. After spending several years trying to water down and mainstream-ify the experience for enthusiasts (i.e. see the 2013 ‘trashcan’ Mac Pro and the 2016 MacBook Pro), Apple realized that that was a mistake, and then corrected the path with the excellent 2019 Mac Pro tower and 2021 MacBook Pro, which both launched to rave reviews and are universally considered to be improvements over their more mainstream-oriented predecessors.</p><p><strong>The point is that when you have multiple groups to appeal to, taking a middle-of-the-road approach doesn’t satisfy any of them; it just waters down the experience for everyone. Apple clearly came to this realization several years ago with hardware, and has been making fantastic hardware products ever since. Hopefully we see that same process play out with software next — and Apple Music is a prime candidate for this transformation.</strong></p><p>I’m looking forward to what’s in store next for Apple Music. Hopefully we see a big improvement in iOS 16, iPadOS 16, macOS 13, and the addition of a Windows app. WWDC 2022 can’t come soon enough!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=55f25d25fd20" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[WWDC 2020]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/wwdc-2020-cda71a41ae83?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cda71a41ae83</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ui]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wwdc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Jun 2020 21:06:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-18T21:06:09.363Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/1*32PLNVInxqXeuUgqa2XIEw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>WWDC 2020 is less than a week away, and since people love putting together their wish lists, I thought I’d throw my hat in the ring.</p><p>Here are the biggest things I’d like to see next week:</p><ol><li><strong>SiriOS. </strong>This topic has been done to death, with countless Siri discussions and complaints every year, but I have a good feeling about this year. I’m hoping (and I firmly believe) that Apple has been working behind the scenes for years on a Siri 2.0 type product, built on the <a href="https://reddit.com/r/apple/comments/aoisqf/_/eg22u3p/?context=1">VocalIQ technology</a> Apple acquired in 2015 and reinforced by the many AI/ML companies it has acquired since then. Rather than release the new technologies gradually like Google and Amazon have been doing, I believe Apple has been working quietly and diligently with its <a href="https://i.imgur.com/89DZmN7.jpg">many acquisitions</a>, its <a href="https://i.imgur.com/FGwGZrR.jpg">many new Siri employees</a>, and of course, John Giannandrea, towards a big Siri 2.0 type product built from the ground up, similar to what it did with Apple Maps in 2018. Perhaps I’ll eat crow for saying this, but I have a feeling that this could finally be the year.</li><li><strong>Fixed auto-correct.</strong> Auto-correct this past year has been awful. People criticize it every year, but on iOS 13 in particular, it got so aggressive in its predictive nature, that it was just <a href="https://reddit.com/r/apple/comments/eugn38/dear_ios_autocorrect_duck_you/">infuriating</a> due to its tendency to not only predict, but to go back and ‘correct’ what you’ve already written earlier in the sentence. In my 9 years of owning iPhones, I have never been as frustrated with typing as I have been this year. The reason is simple — typos are preferable to incorrect ‘corrections’. I’d rather have a misspelled word than an over aggressive auto-correct that is continually inferring what it thinks I <em>meant</em> to say — and continually getting it wrong.</li><li><strong>Reimagined iPad multitasking.</strong> I’ll leave this discussion to <a href="https://daringfireball.net/2020/01/the_ipad_awkwardly_turns_10">Daring Fireball</a>. I completely agree with Gruber on that.</li><li><strong>New SpringBoard.</strong> It’s time for a new iPhone home screen that finally moves away from the static set of icons. Arranging and shifting icons continues to be a pain. It’s even worse on iPad, where the home screen icons and Dock icons have such radically different functionality, especially when it comes to multitasking. There are rumors of some sort of home screen list view coming. I’m very hopeful and curious to see what that entails.</li><li><strong>Expanded pointer support.</strong> I’d like to see wider support across iPadOS for the new iPad pointer. A lot of apps needs to be updated to make full use of the feature with their menus and icons.</li><li><strong>External monitor support. </strong>Current monitor support for iPad is extremely limited. This year, we finally saw the iPad take on a role as a <a href="https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/the-reinvention-of-ipad-f52a2fa60af9">legitimate laptop alternative</a>. I’m hoping to see real monitor support so that it can take on the desktop role as well.</li><li><strong>Music app.</strong> I’ve been writing about this for literally years (see my several other Medium articles). The Apple Music app is bad. Full stop. It is so heavily focused on curation and suggestions that it doesn’t offer users what they actually want. Curation is important, but when the entire app is based around saying <em>“Judging by your tastes, here’s what you MIGHT like”</em> and it never really says <em>“Here’s what you DO like”</em>, that becomes a problem. I’d like to see Apple completely rebuild the Library tab from the ground up, offering all sorts of ways for users to sift through and organize their music libraries. And Smart Playlists/filters should play a major role in this. <em>“Hey Siri, play my favorite rock songs from the 1990s that I haven’t heard in a while”</em>. That’s the functionality I’d like to see — both via Siri and via the visual UI in the app. You should be able to specify the criteria for music (in this example, <em>“my favorite”</em>, <em>“rock”</em>, <em>“1990s”</em>, and <em>“haven’t heard in a while”</em>) and it should use those criteria to auto-generate an on-the-fly playlist for you. Think of iTunes Smart Playlists, but dynamically generated and with no need to create, manage, and delete them. That focus on your own music library and the tools to sort through it — is precisely what the app is sorely lacking and why so many music lovers are frustrated by it. For more suggestions for the Music app, see <a href="https://reddit.com/r/apple/comments/chr92u/_/euyas82/?context=1">this</a> and <a href="https://link.medium.com/upFZYZfUf7">this</a>.</li><li>A<strong> new TV app.</strong> Similar to my criticism of the Music app, the TV app has a <a href="https://reddit.com/r/apple/comments/drm8tb/this_is_quite_possibly_the_single_biggest/">problem with curation</a>. Frankly, this app is awful. It feels like it was built for content providers and not for users. It needs to be more user-focused. It needs to place greater emphasis on the content you want to watch and the shows you’re current following. Like the Music app, it currently feels like one giant ad for shows and movies Apple wants you to see. It needs more emphasis on what you want to see, not what Apple wants you to see.</li><li><strong>Stability/performance.</strong> Self-explanatory, given all the problems with iOS 13. Rumor is that they’re focusing on that this year, like they did with iOS 12.</li><li><strong>More playfulness, depth, and color across iOS.</strong> We got some of that 4 years ago, as iOS 10 was a step away from the iOS 7 design language, but I’d like to see another step in that direction. For example, I still hate how hierarchy is shown in iOS. If you’re looking at a column of items on the left (i.e. the Notes or Files app), it’s separated from your content on the right by just a thin vertical line. I find this vertical line really doesn’t give you a sense of hierarchy between folders and content. It’s too flat. I’d like to see a sense of depth (and more color) added across iOS.</li><li><strong>Improved health algorithms in watchOS.</strong> This means everything from auto-workout detection to analysis of bodily functions like your heart. Apple has something new in that category every year, so I doubt this year will be any different.</li><li><strong>Fixed audio problems.</strong> I’d like to see improved AirPlay for better HomePod connectivity with Apple TV, and perhaps even support for surround sound or Atmos. I use my HomePod pair, both as TV speakers and for music, and I find that switching the audio source continually creates problems. It’s very buggy, with audio often going out of sync, volume issues, and even one HomePod not playing while the other does. I also sometimes experience this audio bug with my AirPods Pro.</li><li><strong>User-centric audio output. </strong>People often talk about the need for Handoff for media playback, but it should go even further than than. There’s still a general lack of media cohesion across devices. For example, if I’m listening to a podcast on my iPhone via AirPods while using my iPad, the iPad should also output sound to the AirPods. <em>Media playback should be user-centric, not device-centric.</em></li><li><strong>Various UI problems.</strong> For example, dragging and dropping items on a list is incredibly fiddly. Whether it’s items in the Reminders app, bookmarks in Safari, or anything else of that nature across iOS, the entire method of dragging items up/down on a list and in/out of folders — is very messy. I continually have problems with this — both via trackpad and via the touch screen. There are many UI problems of that nature that I still come across in Apple’s first party apps.</li><li><strong>Noise notifications.</strong> The Apple Watch detects loud noises and warns you in order to prevent long-term hearing loss. That’s a good idea in theory, but in reality, the current feature should just be renamed “hand dryer detector”. It still needs work. I’d like to see this fixed so that it stops thinking I’m going deaf every time I wash my hands.</li></ol><p>As far as hardware and what’s realistically rumored, I’d like to see:</p><ol><li><strong>Apple headphones.</strong> AirPods Studio? HeadPods? AirHeads? Whatever they call them, I’m hoping Apple goes all out in terms of audio quality. Additionally, they should be well-built, resilient to the weather (including in wintertime, when headphones function as earmuffs), and they should offer noise cancellation that’s even better than that of the AirPods Pro, along with all the nifty sensors and features that make AirPods so beloved.</li><li><strong>New Apple TV Remote.</strong> It’s time for a redesign. <a href="https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/its-time-for-a-new-remote-58533fb036e5">It’s time for a new remote.</a> We’ve had this remote since 2015, aside from one minor tweak in 2017 (the white ring) and it has always been <em>controversial</em>, to say the least. The current remote is from that 2012–2016 period at Apple, where they shifted too far in the direction of aesthetics and away from function. Think of iOS 7, the original watchOS design, the 2013 Mac Pro, the Butterfly keyboard, and so on. Most of those problems have been fixed with significant redesigns over the past couple years. The Apple TV remote may be the last straggler from that era. It’s time for something new.</li><li><strong>Apple display.</strong> This should take some of the tech from the Pro Display XDR, offer it in a much less expensive package, and allow for greater iPad integration so that you can essentially use your iPad Pro as a desktop when you’re in front of the monitor at your desk.</li><li><strong>Tile-like trackers.</strong> The rumor mill strongly believes these are coming this year, so I added them to my list. I’m very curious to see what these can do in conjunction with the U1 chip in current iPhones.</li></ol><p><strong>That about wraps it up. I’m sure I missed a lot of things, but these are the main items that I, as a user and a non-developer, would love to see at WWDC 2020. We’ll know on June 22nd how many items on this list I can tick off. I can’t wait.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cda71a41ae83" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It’s Time for a New Remote]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/its-time-for-a-new-remote-58533fb036e5?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/58533fb036e5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wwdc]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple-tv]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ui]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Jun 2020 00:55:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-16T00:55:02.114Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*khQ5mMUgGt5XA0nHTSoe3A@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>The current Apple TV 4K box and Siri Remote</figcaption></figure><p>We’ve seen rumors that a new Apple TV box is imminent, and given that it’s been nearly 3 years since the Apple TV 4K was released, I think we’re overdue for an update.</p><p>People often ask if a new box is really needed, as this 2017 device still has a very powerful processor compared to most of its competitors (the A10X is still very capable), plus, this device already supports 4K, HDR, Atmos, Bluetooth 5.0, and most other modern technologies in the industry. But there is still room for improvement — namely, with HDMI 2.1, AV1 hardware support, WiFi 6, an updated SoC, and a few other items. <em>But far more important than any of that is a new remote.</em></p><p>The current Apple TV Siri Remote is 5 years old. It’s from 2015, with one minor revision added in 2017 (the white ring to help with physical orientation by reducing symmetry). From the day the Siri Remote was released, it has been <em>controversial </em>to put it mildly. There are some things to love (namely, the simplicity and minimalism), but there’s also a lot to hate. It’s time for something new.</p><blockquote>From the day the Siri Remote was released, it has been <em>controversial </em>to put it mildly. There are some things to love (namely, the simplicity and minimalism), but there’s also a lot to hate. It’s time for something new.</blockquote><p>The current Apple TV Siri Remote design is from 2015. It’s from that 2012 — 2016 era at Apple, which I felt was a design weak point for the company. The 2013 Mac Pro. iOS 7. The original watchOS UI. The Butterfly Keyboard. The iPhone 6 hardware design. The iPad’s period of stagnation. And so on. That was an era at Apple in which too much emphasis was placed on aesthetics, at the expense of usability.</p><p>Since then, things have gotten a whole lot better. The new Mac Pro. The iOS 7 aesthetic was scaled back considerably with iOS 10. WatchOS was rethought in significant ways with watchOS 3. The Butterfly Keyboard is gone. The iPhone 6 design has been replaced. And of course, the iPad has made considerable advances in both hardware and software design.</p><p><strong><em>It’s the Apple TV remote’s turn.</em></strong> It may be the last vestige of that era at Apple, so it deserves the upgrade treatment. It deserves the usability boost. It’s time to move away from the monolithic-art-museum-piece design from that post-Steve, just-Jony era — and to move towards a friendlier, more user-focused design language.</p><p>In that spirit, here are some suggestions on how it can be improved:</p><ol><li><strong>Ergonomics.</strong> The remote needs to be thicker and more ergonomic so that it’s more comfortable in hand as well as easier to pick up. Right now, it’s like picking up a stick of gum. And once you’re holding it, it’s too thin to be comfortable in hand. There’s also the couch cushion issue, where it’s so thin that it easily slides between your sofa cushions and gets lost. I’d like to see that change.</li><li><strong>Shape.</strong> The shape should be less symmetrical. The white ring added in 2017 helped a bit, but I still find I sometimes pick it up reversed. I still sometimes find that it takes my brain half a second to determine the orientation. That should not be the case. It should be second nature.</li><li><strong>Improved navigation.</strong> The trackpad experience was never quite up to Apple’s standards. Firstly, I’d like to see the tvOS UI move to a more iPadOS-like UI. MacOS has a free moving pointer while tvOS has the ‘Focus Engine’ that is stuck moving from icon to icon. Recently, iPadOS added pointer support which is sort of like a hybrid between those two extremes. Something along those lines could be better for tvOS as well. And I’m sure the trackpad hardware will need to improve to support this. The current trackpad isn’t ideal because I find I often overshoot what I’m aiming for. Because of the Focus Engine, you’re so heavily magnetized to each icon that the momentum needed to move away causes you to overshoot where you were intending to go. It’s never felt quite right and isn’t as precise as it could be. I think an improvement is needed in both hardware and software. The sensitivity should be adjusted, the Focus Engine should be revised, and perhaps even the physical trackpad should be made larger and more spacious for more pinpoint accuracy.</li><li><strong>Forward/back buttons.</strong> The edge click to skip forward/back 10 seconds should be made into standardized buttons that are both easier to use, and more prevalent so that you don’t have as many third party apps ignoring them (*cough* YouTube *cough*).</li><li><strong>Button rethinking.</strong> The Menu and TV buttons need a rethink. ‘Menu’ functions more as a back button, and one of the most used features — going home — doesn’t have a button, but rather, requires you to hold the Menu button. And then the TV button takes you to the TV app, which you can already get to via the home screen. That arrangement just doesn’t feel right. There are ways to tinker with this in the Settings, but that’s more of a Band-Aid solution. I think these two buttons need to be renamed and remapped.</li><li><strong>Biometric identification.</strong> This one’s more of a long shot but I’d love to have a remote with biometric identification (ie. Touch ID) where you activate it and it automatically signs in to your account. And the account system needs to be improved, of course. A TV is a communal device, not a personal device like an iPhone is, so there needs to be better support for multiple profiles/accounts. I’d love to see that built into the remote hardware. And while they’re at it, add a beacon to the remote so that if you lose it, you can press a button on the TV box and it pings the remote.</li><li><strong>New UI possibilities?</strong> The last thought I had is perhaps there’s something Apple can do with local positioning. Now that they have the U1 chip in iPhones (which has been barely used thus far but may have a very bright future ahead), I’ll bet there are all sorts of things Apple can do to enhance the tvOS interface via the U1 ultra-wideband (UWB) chip. Perhaps it could even replace the need for a trackpad. Perhaps the U1, combined with improved gyroscopes and accelerometers, could make the remote more akin to a next generation LG Magic Remote. I think I’d honestly prefer that to the trackpad. I don’t like how complex that LG remote is, but the actual pointer functionality is a joy to use. While I far prefer tvOS to LG’s current smart tv webOS, I actually find LG’s Wii-like pointing system to be more intuitive and just more fun than the swipes on Apple’s remote. It’s more Apple-y than Apple’s system is. Alas, the rest of the Magic Remote and webOS is nowhere near as well designed as Apple’s offering. If Apple could maintain its own simplicity while providing a pointer UI, I think that would be the best of all worlds. Perhaps they could even add a Taptic Engine for a more tactile feel when navigating the UI.</li></ol><p>The Apple A10X is still a beast of a processor. It’s still very capable. It has a GPU that’s more than half as fast as the GPU in the incredibly powerful A12Z from the latest iPad Pro and it has a CPU that’s about 75% as fast. Those are impressive figures for a streaming TV box, even in 2020. The Apple TV could always use a boost to an A12Z or perhaps even an A13X, but even now, it’s still not really necessary. Unless Apple plans on realigning Apple Arcade to compete more heavily with consoles in the graphics department, there’s no real urgency to upgrade the processor. What there <em>is</em> an urgency to upgrade is the remote.</p><p><strong>Design at Apple has gotten a whole lot better recently compared to that 2012–2016 era. The Apple TV remote seems to be the last remnant from that era. It’s time for a new remote.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=58533fb036e5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Reinvention of iPad]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/the-reinvention-of-ipad-f52a2fa60af9?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f52a2fa60af9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ipad-pro]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ipad]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 May 2020 22:39:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-18T06:36:28.812Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Apple Has Finally Solved Its iPad Problem</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/1*KXCxm9uqTVKAW78dkqORlA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The new Magic Keyboard for iPad Pro</figcaption></figure><p>Two weeks ago, I was eagerly awaiting the arrival of my 11” Magic Keyboard when something occurred to me. I read everything I could about this accessory and watched all the early unboxing videos I could find, and I came to a realization: <em>This is a fundamentally different product than the Smart Keyboard Folio is.</em></p><p>When I first saw the Magic Keyboard unveiled, I viewed it as just an updated version of the Smart Keyboard Folio, with some advantages and some drawbacks. But after a while, I came to the realization that that’s not correct. <strong><em>This isn’t an update; Apple has fundamentally rethought the iPad form factor.</em></strong></p><ol><li>The Smart Keyboard Folio was a refrigerator-toaster, to use the old Tim Cook analogy. It tried to be two things at once. It tries to offer a laptop-like typing experience, but it does a mediocre job of it because the keyboard isn’t great, it has no trackpad, and the weight balance doesn’t make it ideal for the lap. Conversely, it tries to offer a tablet-like experience by making the device fold back on itself so that the keyboard is out of the way. But that’s not great either because you’re touching all the inactive keys when you’re holding it, and it’s still much heavier in ‘tablet mode’ than the plain iPad is.</li><li>The new Magic Keyboard doesn’t try to do that. It doesn’t fold back on itself and it doesn’t try to offer a tablet experience. If you want to use the iPad in ‘tablet mode’, you simply remove it from the keyboard, which is now much easier to do. So in ‘tablet mode’, you’re just using the iPad. And in ‘laptop mode’, you now have a better typing experience, backlit keys, a USB C port for power, better angle adjustment, and a trackpad so that you don’t have to keep reaching up to the screen.</li></ol><p>Basically, the Magic Keyboard should be thought of as a dock, not as a convertible case.</p><p>With the Smart Keyboard Folio, the iPad was a multipurpose device. It was a jack of all trades, where it tried to do everything, but did nothing well. With the new Magic Keyboard, the iPad is now a convertible device with two distinct ‘modes’ — laptop mode and tablet mode. These modes are separate, but they allow the iPad to be a better tablet and a better laptop than it was previously.</p><p><strong>This is a significant change to how Apple sees the iPad form factor.</strong></p><p>Let’s take a step back for a second.</p><p>For several years, there have been reports and even personal anecdotes about how Apple executives didn’t know what to do with the iPad. What was its path forward? Should it remain a ‘big iPod Touch’ or should it become a MacBook replacement? Should it remain dead-simple but lacking in functionality and ‘real work’, or should it aim to replace the laptop, but lose its simplicity in the process and thus, fall short of the touchscreen revolution, falling back on old computing paradigms?</p><p>This was a debate that had been ongoing for years, and it’s evident that Apple was stricken by a sort of paralysis for almost half a decade. This wasn’t just evident in falling sales numbers, but also in the general atmosphere surrounding the iPad. The device seemed to have plateaued and there was a growing sense of skepticism that the iPad would be the computing revolution we were all promised.</p><p>Well, Apple tried to rectify this in fall of 2015 with the unveiling of the first iPad Pro along with the first Apple Pencil. It also began adding iPad-centric features to iOS in 2015 with iOS 9, and then it doubled down with iOS 11 two years later, adding more powerful features, including more advanced multitasking and Slide Over functionality. The idea was that the iPad would move away from ‘big iPod Touch’ territory and the device would become more powerful and more capable, culminating in the 2018 major iPad Pro redesign, along with the Smart Keyboard Folio for an improved typing experience.</p><p>There was only one problem: <em>Apple was building a refrigerator-toaster. </em>It was going about its iPad plans all wrong and creating a confusing product that tried to be two products in one, both of which felt significantly compromised.</p><p>That brings us to 2020. And to paraphrase a classic Steve Jobs line from 2007, today Apple is going to reinvent the iPad.</p><blockquote>To paraphrase a classic Steve Jobs line from 2007, today Apple is going to reinvent the iPad.</blockquote><p>Now that I’ve had my hands on this thing for about two weeks, I’m doubling down on my above theory. Not only have I been typing on my iPad more than ever. Not only has the trackpad been a game-changer in how it has obviated the need to keep reaching up for the screen and thus, encouraged me to use the iPad for longer time periods and more frequently, as I don’t have to worry about my arm getting tired. But on top of all of that, I’ve found myself using both the Apple Pencil and the iPad by itself a whole lot more.</p><p>The reason for that is simple. By making it so easy to just pull it off the case, my entire perception of the iPad form factor has changed. It’s no longer merely a tablet that I <em>can</em> detach from the keyboard; it’s now a tablet that <em>I want to</em> detach from the keyboard. That means that when I want to walk around my apartment or recline on the couch or watch some TV, I gleefully pull the iPad off the magnetic back, use it like a simple, light tablet, and the second I want to get back to a more laptop-like experience, I just throw it back on. Easy peasy.</p><blockquote>It’s no longer merely a tablet that I can detach from the keyboard; it’s now a tablet that I want to detach from the keyboard.</blockquote><p>That’s the secret sauce.</p><p>The Magic Keyboard wasn’t the first detachable keyboard case, just like AirPods weren’t the first truly wireless headphones. The reason AirPods took off is because they were so well-designed and provided such a seamless experience, that you just <em>wanted</em> to use them any chance you got. That’s how I feel about my iPad Pro with its Magic Keyboard. I <strong><em>want</em></strong> to detach it to use as a light tablet and I <strong><em>want</em></strong> to reattach it to use as a laptop with a trackpad. This is a true bimodal device, not just a collection of checklist features that you <em>can</em> do. Ease-of-use makes the product. Or to mention an overused term, it’s all about the UX.</p><p>That’s the hardware. Of course, the final ingredient is software.</p><p>iPadOS 13.4 is what gave us pointer support so you can attach your favorite mouse, trackpad, or the Magic Keyboard and navigate the UI with a cool new cursor that feels like a hybrid between the indirect cursor in classic computing and the direct manipulation of touchscreen computing. This is still early on and doesn’t yet have broad support, but we’re going to see it become a whole lot more ubiquitous in the coming months, as both Apple and third party developers big and small add support to their apps. That, combined with the ‘Two Finger Secondary Click’ that is becoming consistent with iPhone’s long press menu and has evolved to be the iOS functional equivalent of the right click — allows for a much more powerful, more laptop-like experience.</p><p>The other software component is app design.</p><p>iPad apps have traditionally been more akin to smartphone apps than to full Mac apps. Sure, they make use of the larger display and are more tablet-y than what you’ll typically see on other non-Apple tablets, but at the end of the day, they still use the same design language and the same over-simplicity as smartphone apps, often even using smartphone UI elements like bottom tabs.</p><p>That’s about to change.</p><p>In late April, Apple released its brand new ‘Apple Support’ app version 4.0 for iPhone and iPad. While the iPhone version was much nicer and more intuitive than before, the iPad version tells a bigger story. Previously, it was very much a tablet app, whether you used it in landscape or portrait orientation. It rejiggered the UI elements to suit the orientation, but even in landscape, it still felt like a tablet app. Not anymore. In portrait, it’s a tablet app. In landscape, it feels more akin to a Mac app, eschewing bottom tabs for a column UI. It still uses large touch targets and the iOS design language, but this was clearly redesigned with the new pointer support in mind.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BbcU-eWzLAvZzTXoTmhogA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The new Apple Support app in ‘Laptop Mode’</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xyzOBREs3xo6wWZOVBG0gA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The new Apple Support app in ‘Tablet Mode’</figcaption></figure><p>I think that’s going to be a big story of iPadOS 14. I suspect more apps are going to be following this same path. Landscape and portrait orientation won’t merely be two aspect ratios of the same basic thing. Portrait orientation will continue to be designed for use as ‘Tablet Mode’, and landscape will now be designed as the de facto ‘Laptop Mode’.</p><p>To put it another way, portrait and landscape will not merely be two screen variations on the same basic thing; they’ll become the two discrete ways of viewing content, representing the two sides to the new form factor. Remove your iPad from the Magic Keyboard and you’ve got a classic tablet-like UI best used in portrait orientation. Reattach the iPad and you’ve got a landscape screen with a more laptop-like UI.</p><p>That’s what iPad is evolving into. That’s the new form factor and that’s the software piece of the puzzle to complement the new hardware.</p><p><strong>Wrap-up</strong></p><p>This is not a refrigerator-toaster. This is a refrigerator that magically turns into a toaster. This is Schrödinger’s iPad. It’s not two devices in one; it’s a quantum superposition of two devices. When you observe a tablet, it’s a tablet. When you observe a laptop, it’s a laptop.</p><p>This is the future of iPad. After years of reports about how Apple execs didn’t know where to take the device or what to do with it, they finally figured it out. After wandering through the wilderness and moving from the ‘big iPod Touch’ era to the ‘We-have-no-idea-what-to-do’ era to the ‘refrigerator-toaster’ era, Apple has finally cracked it. They finally landed on the proper form factor. <em>Apple finally solved iPad.</em></p><p>Now if they could only solve the <a href="https://daringfireball.net/2020/01/the_ipad_awkwardly_turns_10">multitasking problem</a>. Perhaps iPadOS 14 at this year’s WWDC 2020 will have something to say about that. June 22nd can’t come soon enough!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f52a2fa60af9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My 2020 Apple Wishlist]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/my-2020-apple-wishlist-f755d74eba84?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f755d74eba84</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ui]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[software-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ios]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Jan 2020 02:35:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-16T02:35:29.297Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It’s a new year and a new time for Apple wishlists and rumors, so I’ve put together some of the areas of focus I’d love to see Apple take on in 2020. Most of these are not specific, minor upgrades and features I’d like to see, but rather, major areas of focus where the great Apple ecosystem is still lacking and could uses a kick into high gear.</p><p>Without further ado, here’s where I’d like to see Apple go in 2020:</p><ol><li><strong>A readjustment in Apple’s design philosophy surrounding streaming services.</strong> Right now, Apple Music, Apple News, and most recently, Apple TV, have UIs that are built around a stream of suggestions. They call this curation, but in reality, it feels more like being bombarded with advertisements. Suggestions are important, but they should be a feature, not the foundation of the UI. <a href="https://reddit.com/r/apple/comments/drm8tb/this_is_quite_possibly_the_single_biggest/?utm_source=reddit&amp;utm_medium=usertext&amp;utm_name=apple&amp;utm_content=t1_fa7p0hg">Here’s what I mean.</a> These streaming services need to provide better functionality in which the user can build and maintain his own library of content, organize it, rate it, and sift through it. You’d have a tab for curation/suggestions and a tab for your content library.</li><li><strong>A redesigned Music app.</strong> Along with what I said above, the Music app could still use <a href="https://reddit.com/r/apple/comments/chr92u/_/euyas82/?context=1&amp;utm_source=reddit&amp;utm_medium=usertext&amp;utm_name=apple&amp;utm_content=t1_fa7p0hg">a lot of work</a>. That means dramatically improved matching algorithms so that your albums don’t keep getting broken up, unmatched, or replaced by singles and live versions. That means a better use of space. That means more focus on the Library tab so you can actually search through your library with more powerful tools (ie. think of the Photos app with its many great features and tools). That means better organization. And of course, that means the addition of Smart Playlists/filters to sort through your music.</li><li><strong>SiriOS.</strong> Many have already covered this, so I won’t go into too much detail, but Siri needs to be more consistent across devices (ie. via a mesh network), it needs to be more reliable, and it needs to get a whole lot more powerful, which I’m confident it will be once it fully integrates the <a href="https://reddit.com/r/apple/comments/aoisqf/_/eg22u3p/?context=1&amp;utm_source=reddit&amp;utm_medium=usertext&amp;utm_name=apple&amp;utm_content=t1_fa7p0hg">VocalIQ</a> tech from its major acquisition. I’ve seen comments from reputable sources that something big is underway, and that Apple has been working on a ground-up rewrite, like it did with Apple Maps recently. That would explain the huge <a href="https://i.imgur.com/89DZmN7.jpg">ramp-up in AI/ML acquisitions</a> over the last few years, the <a href="https://i.imgur.com/FGwGZrR.jpg">significant increase in Siri hirings</a>, and of course, the hiring of <a href="https://i.imgur.com/xIyyyaA.jpg">John Giannandrea</a>, who is reporting straight to Tim Cook, signifying a huge focus on AI.</li><li><strong>Apple as a home theater company.</strong> Right now, HomePod is a niche music device. It sounds good, but the functionality is severely limited. It still doesn’t even offer native Apple TV support. You have to manually pair it via AirPlay 2 and it’s not exactly ideal. Here’s where I see <a href="https://link.medium.com/MfbUKqpmg2">the future of HomePod</a>. Basically, I’d like to see it transform from a niche Apple Music device into a device that is central to your living room. That means native Apple TV support. That means surround sound. That means APIs to allow 3rd party devices like gaming consoles to output sound to HomePod. And perhaps Apple could add more devices to the family, like a subwoofer (SubPod? HomeWoof?) to give you real surround sound or even Dolby Atmos. This would function as a real home theater and obviate any need for an AV Receiver. AirPlay 2 would basically be your AV Receiver.</li><li><strong>Some clarity on iPad Pro and its UI input methods.</strong> I love my iPad Pro and everything it can do. It’s really closing in on becoming capable of replacing primary computers for most people, but it’s not quite there yet. The reason is that the UI input is becoming too complex. For example, when you’re using your iPad with a keyboard case, how do you operate it? Via the touch screen? Via keyboard shortcuts? Via Voice Control? Via Siri? Via the Apple Pencil? The problem with all these great technologies is that they create confusion with the basic functionality. On a laptop, you have a trackpad for movement/selection and a keyboard for typing. It’s all simple and your hands can rest. With iPad, you have to keep reaching up for the screen (which isn’t ergonomic and which is the whole reason why Apple never implemented touch screens on its Macs). So should Apple implement a trackpad? A mouse? Something new? The whole system seems unfocused to me. In my opinion, there should be one primary way to operate the device in tablet mode (ie. the touch screen) and one primary way to operate it in laptop mode. And when you’re using it at home, it should connect to a big Apple monitor (a cheaper version of the Pro Display XDR). In other words, the usage for ‘tablet’ mode, for ‘laptop’ mode, and for ‘home’ mode is still very muddy and unclear. Apple needs to tell this story and provide a more focused vision on the iPad Pro and its use cases.</li></ol><p>Some runners up:</p><ul><li><strong>An improved Apple TV remote.</strong> First and foremost, it needs to be more ergonomic. The general concept is good, but it’s just not comfortable to hold, and it always gets lost in couch cushions due to its unnecessary thinness. The current remote is still from that 2013–2016 Apple era where under Jony, they went too extreme with aesthetics and lost some focus on functionality. Apple has gotten a lot better over the past couple years (ie. see the new Mac Pro, WatchOS improvements, iOS moving away from the iOS 7 aesthetic, the new keyboards etc…), so now it’s the Siri Remote’s turn to leave that 2013–2016 era. I’d like a new remote that is more comfortable in hand and perhaps has some other improvements with the trackpad and with edge clicking.</li><li><strong>All the standard iPhone stuff.</strong> 5G. Smaller notch. Faster processors. Improved cameras. And so on. But the big one is the U1 chip for Ultra-wideband technology and precise positioning.</li><li><strong>All the standard Apple Watch improvements.</strong> Thinner. Faster. Better battery. Improved always-on display. More health sensors for various health conditions like the long-rumored non-invasive glucose monitoring, more heart and stroke analysis, and so on.</li><li>And then there are all the major projects like the car (Project Titan) the AR glasses, and so on, but I don’t expect to see anything there for a couple years.</li></ul><p>I’m excited to see what Apple has in store for 2020. We’re undoubtedly going to get some stability and reliability improvements this year after a shaky iOS 13 release last year, but it’s also looking like a big year for hardware, software, and services. WWDC 2020 can’t come soon enough!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f755d74eba84" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Curation Should Be A Feature, Not A User Interface]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/curation-should-be-a-feature-not-a-user-interface-ae52384bc30c?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ae52384bc30c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ui]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Oct 2019 20:48:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-26T20:48:56.484Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Recently there was a minor uproar among Apple TV owners due to a notable change that was made in the recently released tvOS 13 for the device. In addition to the new features like multiple profiles, Xbox/PS4 controller support, Control Center, and new screen savers, tvOS 13 also added autoplaying full-screen previews on the Home Screen, replacing the Up Next items that would display when highlighting an app in the top row.</p><p>The reason this was controversial is that unlike the Up Next items, which were useful in showing you what’s on deck, the new full screen previews served no functional purpose and were essentially advertisements for content to watch. Firstly, this is a problem because it frequently suggests content you don’t even have access to without paying extra. But even more importantly, this speaks to a much bigger issue that has spread across the tech world — <em>curation is destroying the user interface.</em></p><h4><strong>This may be the single biggest design problem in the tech world today.</strong></h4><p>I mean that sincerely. There is this ubiquitous tendency where “recommendation” has become another word for “advertisement”. Entire UIs are designed around how curators (both human and algorithmic) can suggest content for you.</p><p>Allow me to be a little blunt here:</p><p>I’m sick and tired of “curation”. Whether we’re talking about Apple TV, Apple Music, Netflix, YouTube, or just about any other content distribution platform, what we’ve been seeing in recent years is that these services have all been designed entirely around recommendations. From Netflix’s shift from stars to thumbs up/down to YouTube’s autoplay and its focus on recommendations, to Apple eliminating (and then bringing back but hiding) star ratings in favor of ‘Loved’ hearts, entire user interfaces are being designed around recommending content to you.</p><p>I don’t want recommendations. I want content that I want. In other words, I want a content library. I want to be able to select the TV shows and movies and artists and albums and news articles and books and YouTube videos that I want. I don’t want some human curator or machine algorithm telling me <em>what it thinks I may want</em>. I want <em>what I want</em>.</p><p>To put it another way, I want to be able to create libraries of content and I want tools to be able to organize, sort through, and consume this content. I want Smart Playlists/filters for my music library. I want YouTube to serve videos I want. I want to add TV shows to a list so that I can always follow what’s on my list, what episodes I’ve watched so far, and what episodes I haven’t. I want libraries of movies and news and so on. Think of TV tracker apps like <a href="https://apps.apple.com/ca/app/television-time/id969714962">Television Time</a>. That’s what I want for all my content and I want it built into the streaming services. I suspect that millions of others share the same view.</p><p><strong>Recommendations are important. Curation should not go away. After all, it’s great to see suggestions for new music and movies and TV and books to check out. But recommendations should be a feature; they should not be the foundation upon which the entire UI is built.</strong></p><blockquote>We still want collections of our “stuff”. Just because we’re renting the stuff monthly doesn’t mean we don’t want to maintain collections of that rented stuff.</blockquote><p>Even though we’re in a world of streaming services, human beings still have the innate desire to collect things. We still want collections of our “stuff”. Just because we’re renting the stuff monthly doesn’t mean we don’t want to maintain collections of that rented stuff. We want to build libraries of content, we want the ability to evaluate or rate this content, and we want the tools to organize this content so that we can refer back to it later. These tech companies need to dial back the curation by several notches and focus on user libraries. That’s what the tech world needs. This applies to Netflix. This applies to Google/YouTube. And yes, this applies to Apple.</p><h3>Addendum</h3><p>A few points I want to add to this:</p><ol><li>One way to improve the TV app would be to transform what the middle “Library” tab is. Instead of “Library” meaning “Purchases”, it should mean “Shows I’m watching”. In other words, I should be able to select all the shows I’m currently watching across all services and add them to that tab. So that tab may consist of 10 or 15 shows across all the content sources that the app supports, and I’ll be able to go into each of those shows, keep track of exactly what I’ve watched, rate it, and then click to watch the next episode. The idea is that this will be a central repository for everything I’m watching and have previously watched. And if I want recommendations for something new to add to this list, I can simply jump back to the “Watch Now” tab and grab the curated items there. This would combine content streaming with the aforementioned TV tracker type apps — all in one simple, attractive Apple interface.</li><li>Regarding Apple Music, <a href="https://reddit.com/r/apple/comments/chr92u/_/euyas82/?context=1&amp;utm_source=reddit&amp;utm_medium=usertext&amp;utm_name=appletv&amp;utm_content=t1_f2e1vwt">here</a>’s a good way to fix it. One of the biggest points there is that instead of focusing so heavily on curated playlists, it should focus on your own user library and provide simple but powerful tools to sift through your library. So if I want to listen to “heavy metal I love from the late 80s” or “classic rock from the 60s that I recently added” or “my own favorite Led Zeppelin songs”, there should be a simplified Smart Playlist type system that allows you to select criteria (ie. genre, artist, year, star rating, recently added, etc…) in order to auto-generate a dynamic, on-the-fly playlist. It would function more like a filter rather than like a playlist that you normally have to create, manage, and delete in iTunes. You just select criteria and get the music you want. The idea is that you’re being given tools to organize your own music library, as opposed to living in a world of curation and recommendation.</li><li>And of course, for all of this to function, there should be an increased focus on personal ratings. In Apple Music, the ‘Love’/’Suggest Less’ system is primarily catered towards suggestions and curation. What’s needed is a renewed focus on Star Ratings, where I can easily rate any song, album, or artist, and then I can use those personal ratings for the aforementioned sorting tools, so that I can organize and find what I’m in the mood for, and perhaps even share it with a friend. This system is perfect for music but would also be great for TV shows, movies, and any other form of media. Star Ratings were one of my favorite parts of iTunes. The fact that they’re deeply hidden in iOS, — to the point of being useless — and the fact that no Smart Playlist type system ever made its way to iOS — is one of the biggest shortcomings in iOS. I’d love to see that change.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ae52384bc30c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[watchOS keeps getting better and that’s disappointing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/watchos-keeps-getting-better-and-thats-disappointing-32bfdf377ec9?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/32bfdf377ec9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple-watch]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Aug 2018 21:02:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-09-03T20:48:11.923Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>That may seem like a bizarre statement to make but allow me to explain.</p><p>The Apple Watch is not the same device it was in 2015 — particularly when it comes to software. watchOS has gone through quite a few significant UI changes that have not merely tweaked and altered the interface, but thoroughly reimagined how the device functions. Some of these changes include:</p><ul><li>The side button was repurposed from the Friends menu to the new Dock (watchOS 3)</li><li>Glances were eliminated, with the upward swipe now being used to bring up an iOS-style Control Center (watchOS 3)</li><li>Watch face selection was changed from a 3D Touch gesture to a simple sideways swipe (watchOS 3)</li><li>That weird Time Travel option was added and then removed as a default (watchOS 2 and then 3), followed by a full removal (watchOS 5)</li><li>The usage of 3D Touch was made less prevalent in apps (ie. to end a workout) (watchOS 3)</li><li>The Music app was redesigned at least twice (watchOS 2 and then 4)</li><li>Apple played around with the ‘honeycomb’ screen in terms of how the Digital Crown button functions. It used to center you and then a second click was needed to bring you back to the home screen. Now it’s just one click. (watchOS 2?)</li><li>The Maps app was completely redesigned to simplify it (watchOS 2?)</li><li>Now Playing was made the default when you raise your wrist and have audio in the background (watchOS 4)</li><li>The basic navigation within the Weather app was fiddled with at least twice (watchOS 2 and watchOS 5)</li><li>List View was added as an alternative to the ‘honeycomb’ screen (watchOS 4)</li><li>Siri no longer requires “Hey Siri” — just a wrist raise — to be invoked (watchOS 5)</li><li>Control Center and Notification Center are now accessible within apps (watchOS 5)</li><li>Various other UI changes and bandaid solutions, such as a watch face shortcut to Workouts, and shortcut to Now Playing (watchOS 5), and within the workout app, slide over to get to Now Playing controls</li><li>And of course, the entire focus of the device was changed from being a general purpose wrist device into being streamlined as a health and notification device</li></ul><p>I’m sure I’m forgetting a few others.</p><p>The thing about virtually all of these changes is that they’ve changed things for the better. Almost all of them have genuinely improved the watchOS experience. That’s a good thing, right? Well, yes. But there’s a key point to keep in mind. Virtually all of the changes listed above did NOT come from technological advancement. Software improves with technology. That’s the nature of things. We can all name a million different software features on iPhone, Apple Watch, and every other Apple platform that were not possible with older technology. As technology improves, you can do new things with software. That’s a good thing.</p><p>However, when you look at the above list, those items really are NOT the result of new tech. They’re not the result of new R&amp;D that could only make them possible at the time they were released. Most of those changes are simple design changes that were absolutely possible on the very first Apple Watch. In other words, these changes did not come from advancement, but rather, from correcting previous bad decisions. They came from bad design decisions that were only realized once they were rolled out to millions of people.</p><p>Design is naturally an iterative process that takes countless revisions before you get it right, but Apple has always been so renowned for their designs because most of those iterations occurred internally before the product ever saw the light of day and because Apple’s high level designers and decision-makers had a natural intuition and uncanny ability to spot the right path faster than just about anyone. This, in particular, was Steve Jobs’s greatest talent.</p><p>So as much as I hate to say it, I don’t think watchOS was a well designed OS at all. It is becoming one, but the sheer number of design mistakes that had to be corrected with watchOS 2, 3, 4, and now 5 — is astounding. Design is an iterative and arduous process that takes time to get right, but I would have expected Apple to figure out a lot of these mistakes internally a lot sooner. Why did it take so long to figure these things out? For example, knowing that people want to access Control Center from inside their apps — should not have taken until watchOS 5. Why didn’t internal testing catch that by watchOS 3?</p><p>I love my Apple Watch and it gets better every year, but sometimes it feels like Apple put their B team of designers on it. It’s so iterative and takes so long to get to the ‘right’ design on so many items, that it just feels frustrating at times. It’s been almost <em>Microsoftian</em>. Perhaps I’m holding Apple to too high of a standard, as watchOS is still light-years ahead of any other smartwatch OS in existence, but I can’t help but feel a little disappointed at the long and winding path Apple has taken.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=32bfdf377ec9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Future of HomePod]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/the-future-of-homepod-ce04fd802f5e?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ce04fd802f5e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Apr 2018 22:59:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-15T23:15:00.858Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There have been a lot of stories lately about how HomePod hasn’t met expectations for Apple. Bloomberg <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-04-12/apple-s-stumbling-homepod-isn-t-the-hot-seller-company-wanted">says</a> that its market share is falling and that inventory is piling up, while KGI Securities analyst, Ming-Chi Kuo, expects annual shipments to be quite a bit <a href="https://www.macrumors.com/2018/04/13/kgi-lower-priced-homepod-rumor/">lower</a> than the market had anticipated. There have even been word-of-mouth reports about daily HomePod sales being in the single digits at certain Apple stores.</p><p>The conventional wisdom is that this is because Siri isn’t good enough and because $350 is too much for the device. In other words, people are arguing that it’s not selling well because it’s not a good enough personal assistant.</p><p><strong>I think people have this precisely backwards. HomePod’s weakness isn’t that it’s not a good enough assistant; it’s that it’s not yet a good enough home audio device.</strong></p><p>HomePod isn’t meant to compete with Google Home or the Amazon Echo. It is not a personal assistant, nor was it ever meant to be one. As Rene Ritchie <a href="https://www.imore.com/understanding-homepod">put it</a>, HomePod <em>was designed to be yang to AirPods’ yin</em>. <strong>HomePod is AirPods for your home.</strong> It is an audio device, not a personal assistant, so comparing it to the devices by Amazon and Google — in terms of both price and functionality — is precisely the mistake that many people made with just about every other Apple device in history that has been compared to a competitor’s device and labeled too expensive.</p><p>So then what’s the problem with HomePod? Put simply, it’s not a good enough home audio device <strong><em>yet</em></strong>. The hardware is excellent and the sound quality is near audiophile grade, but there’s one major blunder the device has had to face — namely, launching without AirPlay 2 and Apple TV support means it can’t yet replace a home audio system.</p><p>As much as I love my HomePod, $350 for a dedicated music speaker is a tough sell for a lot of people. Turn the thing into a full-fledged audio solution for your home — namely, music, movies, tv, and everything in between — and suddenly the value proposition changes in a big way.</p><p>That’s why I think the solution isn’t with Siri or with a price decrease. Yes, Siri could use a huge improvement, but that’s not what’s holding HomePod back. To turn HomePod into a real success, here’s what I think it needs:</p><ol><li><strong>AirPlay 2 and native Apple TV support.</strong></li><li><strong>Surround sound.</strong></li><li><strong>Speaker stands (3rd party would suffice).</strong></li><li><strong>An API for all other electronic devices to feed audio into HomePod. Think of Apple’s MFI (Made For iPhone) program, but designed for tvs and cable boxes and game consoles and accessories to feed audio straight into HomePod, allowing it to function as the central ‘brain’ of audio in the home.</strong></li><li><strong>Perhaps more devices in the family, like a SubPod (WoofPod? HomeWoof?)</strong></li></ol><p>Put those together and you’ve got a full audio platform for your home. It’s not about making HomePod a better assistant. It’s about turning HomePod into a complete platform, where you can buy them, throw them anywhere you want, and have a full audio ecosystem. In other words, think Sonos, not Alexa. A Sonos-style device that leverages Apple’s incredible A-series processors, offers even better sound quality, and has native integration into the entire Apple ecosystem — would be one heck of a proposition for millions of people.</p><p>That’s where HomePod needs to go and I suspect that Apple is already well along this path, despite all the misplaced calls for the company to build an Apple-branded Echo. When HomePod gets there, it won’t just be competing with smart speakers; it will be competing with soundbars and stereo systems and home theater receivers and most importantly, it will be competing with internal tv speakers, much like how Apple Watch’s main competition wasn’t another smartwatch, but your bare wrist.</p><p>Apple wants HomePod to be the one stop shop for all your home audio needs and it wants to get there by bolstering its ecosystem with sound quality that most consumers just aren’t used to.</p><p>That’s what Apple is truly after with HomePod — a complete home audio experience that is worthy of the Apple name.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ce04fd802f5e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Some Pain Points in the iOS 11 Music App]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/some-pain-points-in-the-ios-11-music-app-57eba435e3b2?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/57eba435e3b2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[apple-music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 20 Nov 2017 18:18:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-11-20T18:18:13.911Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The iOS Music app has been controversial for a few years. It has received a lot of criticism — some deserved, some not. I’ve never been aboard the “I hate the iOS 11 Music app” train, but it still has a number of notable flaws that harm the experience for me. As a music lover, design enthusiast, and longtime Apple fan, I’d like to present a few pain points in the iOS Music app that I believe can be improved:</p><ol><li><strong>Better discographies.</strong> Artist discographies should just display the main studio albums. The artist’s EPs, b-sides, singles, deluxe editions, and live albums should be in a separate folder. Right now, everything is thrown together and it’s far too cluttered and unorganized.</li><li><strong>A better playlist UI</strong>. The “Playlists” screen is far too big. The album art on the left doesn’t serve a purpose and just forces the text over to the right and makes each line much taller. This results in a lot of scrolling every time you want to find a playlist. A mere 4 line items on a 4.7&quot; screen is a bit silly when I want to browse through my playlists. <a href="https://imgur.com/a/7Bzqd">Even my new iPhone X only displays 5 items at a time</a>. That’s a lot of scrolling.</li><li><strong>Greater information density. </strong>iOS strives for simplicity, but in a world where the iPhone is no longer a satellite device to your PC, the iOS Music app needs some of the power that you formerly relied on iTunes for. This includes more information about your music. For example, song lengths should be more visible. The fact that each line only includes the song title and iCloud icon just isn’t enough, in my opinion. Perhaps when you download a song and the iCloud icon disappears, it can be replaced by the song length and/or star rating. I’m not asking for a cluttered UI, but length and rating are two essential pieces of information for music lovers. For example, I love glancing at ratings as a reminder for which songs I love. It helps the user select what to play next.</li><li><strong>Shorter animations.</strong> The animation when you add something to “Up Next” is too long. Tapping “Play Next” or “Play Later” should be less intrusive. This is similar to the infamous iOS volume HUD criticism.</li><li><strong>Ratings.</strong> The 5 Star menu should be more easily accessible. While it’s nice that Apple brought it back after having eliminated it last year, hiding it away in a popup menu within the 3D Touch menu isn’t ideal. In my opinion, rating systems shouldn’t merely exist to improve the recommendation algorithms, but should also serve as flags on the user’s own library so that she can return to her favourite songs and albums. This connects to #3 above.</li><li><strong>An improved swipe gesture.</strong> The mini-player swipe gesture introduced in iOS 10 (and maintained in iOS 11) is a big step down from iOS 9. It used to have a one-to-one feel, where it smoothly transitioned as you raised and lowered the mini-player bar. This not only felt right, but was fun to fiddle with. iOS 10 changed that by giving it a more binary open/closed interaction, as opposed to following the motion of your thumb. This feels a lot worse and is less fun to use. (I should note that the iOS 11.2 beta improves the behavior, but only when you’re raising the mini-player. Lowering it still has the binary feel.)</li><li><strong>Finding songs we love. </strong>Songs we love are easily lost in our giant libraries. There should be a way to easily get back to our favourites. The ‘My Favourites Mix’ playlist is a start, but it needs to go much deeper than that. I’ve downloaded and ‘Loved’ or starred so many songs, only to have them get lost in my 15,000 song library, never to be played again. We need better tools to sort through and get back to the music we love. We can do that in iTunes via Smart Playlists, but there’s no iOS equivalent.</li><li><strong>Better matching.</strong> Apple still needs to do a lot of work with matching songs and displaying the correct one. For example, the ‘My Favourites Mix’ playlist, which assembles some of your favourite songs from your library, frequently uses alternative versions of a song, like ones taken from the Deluxe version of the album. So even though I have the normal album, that particular song will be treated as if it’s not in my library. I’ll frequently see the “+”, asking me to add it, even though I already have the song.</li><li><strong>Combined artist pages. </strong>When you tap an artist’s name (i.e. in red text at the top of an album or in the ‘Featured Artists’ circles below a playlist), you should be taken to that artist in your Library, not to that artist’s general page. Apple Music has two separate pages for every artist in your library — one for the artist’s main ‘page’ and one for your library of that artist’s albums. This separation is confusing and I think they need to be consolidated.</li><li><strong>Too much focus on recommendations.</strong> Apple Music focuses too much on treating artist pages like advertisements instead of like these folders that exist in your library. Across the entire Music app, there’s too little emphasis on the user’s own music library and too much emphasis on always recommending something new. Recommendations are important, but in my opinion, Apple Music hasn’t found the right balance yet. The entire Apple Music experience is far too skewed in the direction of <em>”Hey, check out these things you might like!”</em> and not enough in the direction of “<em>Hey, here are these things that you </em><strong><em>DO</em></strong><em> like.”</em></li></ol><p>That brings me to my last and most desired feature:</p><ul><li><strong>Smart Playlists. </strong>This is directly related to #7 above. The Music app needs better sorting tools for your library. I’d love to be able to specify that I want to play my favourite songs by [Artist]. Imagine if you could say <em>“Hey Siri, play my favourite songs by Johnny Cash”</em> and you immediately get a playlist of all the Johnny Cash songs that you’ve ‘Loved’ or given high star ratings to or songs that have high play counts in your library. We should be able to do this via Siri or via filters in the UI (perhaps similar to the filters in Apple Maps when searching for POIs. I love the Maps UI for POIs). Apple’s curated playlists are nice, but those aren’t enough. Playing Apple’s <em>‘Pink Floyd Essentials’</em> playlist is NOT the same as being able to auto-generate playlists of my own favourite tracks by Pink Floyd. Think of iTunes Smart Playlists, but dramatically simplified for the iOS world. Instead of functioning like playlists that you have to create, manage, and delete, they’d operate more like filters that dynamically generate playlists on-the-fly from your own music library.</li></ul><h4><strong>Lightning Round:</strong></h4><ul><li>An “Add” button right in the Up Next screen.</li><li>A progress bar in the watchOS Music app.</li><li>The ability to 3D Touch the shuffle button so you can play something next in shuffle mode without having to shuffle what’s currently playing.</li><li>The 3D Touch menu in the app should never be scrollable.</li><li>When sorting your library by genre, it should be Genre →Artist →Album, not Genre →Album.</li></ul><p>I’m excited for the future of Apple Music. It’s still a pretty new service that has only been around since 2015, and so it’s still navigating some growing pains. The matching and suggestion algorithms have clearly improved over the past two years and the big UI redesign with iOS 10 was a nice improvement over the previous version, whose interface was burdened by too many tabs, toggles, menus and switches, to the point that it affected the ease-of-use. But Apple Music has made some impressive progress in the short time it has been around and I hope it continues down this path, with Apple incorporating some of the proposals above.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=57eba435e3b2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[One of the biggest design challenges Apple has yet to solve]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@heyyoudvd/one-of-the-biggest-design-challenges-apple-has-yet-to-solve-830e859c49fb?source=rss-129b8b1ad41c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/830e859c49fb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ux]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dave B]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Oct 2017 02:10:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-17T02:10:51.438Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve noticed that as Apple has released great new products like the Apple Watch and AirPods, we’ve started to see a lot of duplication in functionality. There are many features and functions now that can be carried out in multiple places.</p><p>For example:</p><p>1. <strong>I want to check the weather today.</strong> Do I open the weather app? Do I 3D Touch the app icon and see the weather widget? Do I slide over to the left to see the weather widget on the widget screen? Do I go into the weather app on my Apple Watch? Do I check the weather Complication on my Watch? That’s 5 separate ways to check the weather.</p><p>2. <strong>I want to verbally send a text message.</strong> Do I open the Messages app on my phone and dictate? Do I open Messages on my Watch and dictate? Do I invoke Siri?</p><p>3. <strong>I want check the baseball scores. </strong>Do I open an app on my phone? Do I open an app on my Watch? Do I check a Watch Complication? Do I slide down on my phone’s Home screen to get to the Siri search (formerly called Spotlight)? Do I invoke Siri? And speaking of Siri:</p><p>4. <strong>I want to use Siri for any number of tasks.</strong> Do I hold the Home button on my iPhone? Do I say “Hey Siri” to my iPhone? Do I hold the Digital Crown on my Watch? Do I say “Hey Siri” to my Watch? Do I tap the icon on my Siri watch face? Do I double tap my AirPods? That’s at least 6 ways to invoke Siri.</p><p>My point is that there are <strong>A LOT</strong> of different ways to accomplish the same task in Apple’s ecosystem. You might argue that this gives the user choice, but I would argue that it’s actually detrimental because it increases the <em>cognitive load</em>. The user wants to accomplish a certain task; she doesn’t want to have to think about and decide between the many different ways to accomplish said task. She just wants it done.</p><p>This is a difficult design problem to solve because you don’t want to artificially limit the capabilities of each device, but at the same time, you don’t want too much redundancy. The goal is to create an ecosystem in which every task can be accomplished simply and without thought. <strong>You want all the devices to be powerful and capable. but you also want to instill muscle memory into the user so that he automatically knows which device and method to use for what, without having to make a conscious choice.</strong> After all, too much choice can actually slow down your task. <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/barry_schwartz_on_the_paradox_of_choice">Choice paralysis</a> is a real thing.</p><h3>So what’s the solution?</h3><p>I believe that in order to solve this, we’ll need a massive paradigm shift in computing. We’ll need to see a shift away from the current app-based paradigm to a more function-based paradigm. Instead of thinking <em>“use this app to do X”</em> or <em>“use this device to accomplish Y”</em>, you have to essentially reverse that and put the task ahead of the entry point. <em>“I want to do X”</em>.</p><p>I think we’ve seen hints of that in certain places. For example, look at the Maps app that was redesigned in iOS 10. Previously, the app was a collection of features. It had different options for different things. If you wanted driving directions, you’d tap one thing. If you wanted to search for a place, you’d tap another thing. And so on. That’s all well and good, but when you’re opening a Maps app, the primary thing you have in mind is <em>“How do I get there”</em>? iOS 10 did that. The UI change in the Maps app from <a href="https://cdn.cultofmac.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/turn-by-turn-maps-ios-7.jpg">iOS 7/8/9</a> to <a href="http://images.techhive.com/images/article/2016/09/ios10_maps_destinations-100683165-large.png">iOS 10</a> was far more than aesthetic. It redesigned the interface to put your task in the forefront. You’d get directions, and then if you wanted to change how you get there, you can play with the features. But the point is that it puts the task in front of the options instead of the options in front of the task.</p><p>Another example of this is how the Maps app now integrates Uber. If I want to Uber somewhere, instead of going to the Uber app, I once again use the Maps app and think <em>“I want to get there”</em>, at which point the Uber option is available via the newly added extension. The Uber app is no longer the focus. The <em>“I want to get there”</em> is the focus, and Uber is merely one of the means through which to get there.</p><p><strong>That’s the kind of paradigm shift we need to see.</strong> The Maps app redesign was great, but we need to see a whole lot more of that design philosophy elsewhere. We need to see the focus pulled away from the apps and devices and access points, and shifted towards the task at hand. This is a monumental design challenge that will require the best design minds in software and hardware to take a step back and rethink things from the ground up, but if any company can do it, it’s Apple. Now that we’re seeing the voice-first world start to emerge, along with the birth of identity computing (thanks to Face ID), I think and I hope we’re on the precipice of this major paradigm shift.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=830e859c49fb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>