<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by bram towbin on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by bram towbin on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@hihoau?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 21:32:37 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@hihoau/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Did you know I’d be on this call?]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/did-you-know-id-be-on-this-call-7c40330a43a9?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7c40330a43a9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[you-can-see-everything]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nathan-fielder]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elizabeth-holmes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theranos]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Nov 2026 03:40:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-01T16:08:54.537Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>REVIEW OF FILM: <em>You Can See Everything</em></p><p><strong>“So I turned myself to face me</strong></p><p><strong>But I’ve never caught a glimpse</strong></p><p><strong>How the others must see the faker</strong></p><p><strong>I’m much too fast to take that test”</strong></p><p><strong>-</strong> David Bowie, Changes</p><p><strong>“I’m a creep. I’m a weirdo”</strong></p><p><strong>-</strong> Radiohead, Creep</p><p><strong>“Use all your well-learned politeness….</strong></p><p><strong>or I’ll lay your soul to waste</strong>,<strong>”</strong></p><ul><li>Rolling Stones, Sympathy for the Devil</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J4ABAkvR14U9MgY_d7JVIA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>You Can See Everything</em> is a masterwork about the human condition. Many have mistaken it for a documentary about the infamous company Theranos, a much ballyhooed biotechnology firm that turned out to be a billion dollar fraud scheme. The enigmatic founder, Elizabeth Holmes, explains the name is a portmanteau of “therapy” &amp; “diagnosis”. The movie goes beyond the confines of the journalistic expository, fact-based genre.<a href="http://documentary.it/">.</a> It is an in depth examination of psychopathology, rather than the chronology of a specific instance of depraved criminality. Think <em>Crime &amp; Punishment</em> not <em>60 Minutes</em>. In fact for viewers interested in the nitty gritty of the Theranos’ implosion there are many critical facts omitted. There is no mention of the chief Scientfic officer’s suicide prior to a court mandated deposition. There is little mention of Theranos’ President and COO Sunny Balwani, Ms. Holme’s secret paramour. There isn’t much color on the financial scope of the fraud, the company was valued at $9 Billion at one point. The thousands of patients, who were given false information about their life changing medical conditions, are completely absent. There is almost no mention of the parade of luminaries who served on the board: Former Sec.s of State George P. Shultz &amp; Henry A. Kissinger, Former General James N. Mattis, Former Sec of Defense William J. Perry, Former Sen. Sam Nunn, Former Chief of Naval Operations Admiral Gary Roughead, Former Senate Majority Leader, William H. Frist, Former Director of the Centers of Disease &amp; Prevention, William H. Foege, Former CEO of Wells Fargo Richard Kovacevich, Billionaire investor Riley P. Bechtel, Apple Software guru Avie Tevanian, and Stanford Chemical Engineering Professor Channing Robertson. A lesser storyteller would have been distracted by all the glitter but directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim have a laser focus on the most interesting aspect of the story: CEO Elizabeth Holmes and her, post-scandal, husband Billy Evans. One might think, given the films nearly 3 hours of screentime it would be a strategic error to have a monomaniacal focus on these pathological grifters. Their star-studded accomplices and the thousands of financial and medical victims might seem the obvious anchors of this exposee. On the contrary. These directors’ spin Liz &amp; Billy’s mendacity into a fable of our time.</p><p>There are many innovative aspects to the production of the work. Nathan Fielder is an integral, on screen, presence in the drama. We not only plumb the depths of Billy &amp; Liz’s foibles but the director/actor isn’t merely a narrator; he is a distinct character whose neuro diversity informs the story. It is likely that the subjects chose Nathan as they felt his “thinking out of the box” worldview would somehow render them as victims… fortunately for us the opposite is true. The title <em>You Can See Everything</em> applies not only to the central protagonists — but the filmmaker himself. He incorporates the fact that he suspects Holmes &amp; hubby chose him due to his non- science background, thinking this would limit his ability to challenge the facts of the case. The couple clearly fails to understand this film is not about the tedious details of corporate fraud, but rather a close look at the couple’s ongoing charade. Ironically having someone who is impervious to being bogged down in a kubokee dance of legalistic sophistry is the sword of Damocles the villains failed to anticipate.</p><p>Nathan is the child who asks the empress if she has any clothes. The answers are beyond disconcerting. Elizabeth claims to have absolutely no idea where things went wrong… not a clue… she did absolutely nothing wrong. Nathan only tries to pin her down on two specific points, both related to statements she made to the press prior to the companies’ collapse. Did Holmes tell the New York Times she was playing a character she invented. Holmes and her husband are emphatic that she was misquoted and that she claimed she was portrayed as a character THE PRESS invented. Interestingly both Holmes and the NYT recorded the interview and neither side, despite repeated requests, chose to play the tapes for the filmmakers. They each stuck to their interpretation. Nathan’s second line of factual inquiry is significantly more revealing. Nathan plays a recording where she states that the blood analyzing device, the centerpiece of the company, was able to give accurate data on a number of diseases. Here the audience is exposed to Holmes’ penchant for doublespeak. She produces a large complicated hardware device, something most people working for the company had never seen, and rambles on about the POTENTIAL for the machine to accurately produce results for a myriad of diseases. Nathan does not let up. He points out that most people would interpret her statement as the machine being in working order. Elizabeth smiles and softly deflects and says that’s not the way she hears it. An interesting coda to this sequence stems from the choice of the hardware she presented. Reliable sources, in discussing the film post screening, point out she is purposely presenting the wrong machine. She is showcasing a prototype created in the later stages of the companies’ demise, not the “Edison” model which sent her to prison. The reason for this subterfuge, which is not mentioned in the film, might stem from the prototype being more physically impressive or this machine will spearhead her efforts to revive the technology in yet another manifestation of her scam.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2ZGhrdmiAc4xTnAHIESylA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Nathan’s artistry in exposing her purposeful opacity goes well beyond traditional narrative documentary practices. In order to illustrate Holmes’ does not communicate within the normal bellcurve of human comprehension, he plays her a video of the famous Abbott &amp; Costello routine, Who’s On First. The results show someone who is seemingly both sheltered and dense. Not only has she never heard of the gag, she can’t seem to follow the basis of the jokes — ie the first baseman’s name is WHO. This begs the question as to her veracity. Has she really never heard of this gag? Does she really not understand or is she hedging her bets as she is not sure of the “correct” response. This odd moment is replayed in another brilliant moment involving the actress Amanda Seyfried, who played Elizabeth Holmes in the TV mini-series, <em>The Dropout</em>, in which she portrayed Holmes’ rise and fall. The filmmaker has the real-life Holmes talk on the phone with the actress. Amanda asks Elizabeth, “did you know I’d be on this call?”. Holmes’s reply is “I’m not sure if I knew”. Hmmm. Post the encounter, Amanda is so befuddled by the response she brings it up with Nathan. They both theorize about what she meant to say. Did she know, but wasn’t admitting? Did she remember? Was she unsure of what to say? As filmmakers Nathan &amp; Lance are demonstrating the rabbit hole reality of engaging with Elizabeth. You can see everything, but nothing is revealed. Elizabeth maintains her steely opaqueness throughout the entire 3 hours. The much publicized clip of her eyes wide shut response to Nathan, “I don’t have anything to deceive you on… of course I’m not deceiving you”, encapsulates the entire ebb and flow of her performance. There is a sense that this deadpan obliviousness is her trademark default mode in life. Perhaps this was key to seducing the chorus line of successful male business and political titans who feathered her nest until everyone had to flee the coop.</p><p>On the screen she is creepy &amp; repulsive, but there is a hint that some saw charm in this svengali stare. Even Amanda confronts Nathan with her suspicion that he has a crush on this bedeviling anti-hero. Kudos to the filmmakers for including Amanda’s damning take. It is not without some on screen support. Nathan gives Elizabeth a farewell gift when she departs for prison. There is also their warm embrace after months of not seeing each other. He speaks of her “vibrating” during the hug in the prison visitors’ lounge. Near the film’s end is a sequence of him playfully swimming with Liz in the pacific in front of their beach rental. Did Nathan metaphorically “take the plunge”? Is this film supportive of Liz? No. His momentary fawning is a purposeful ruse to expose her as a creepy manipulator. His unremitting “straightman” persona is the perfect antidote to her soulless grin. At times one feels they are experiencing the famous Monty Python skit about the dead parrot. While Liz keeps on insisting the parrot is “resting”. Nathan’s incredulous facial expressions show the parrot is definitely DEAD.</p><p>Whereas Elizabeth is a lodestar of the worst in human nature hiding behind a blank smile, her husband, Billy, has a character arc that plunges downward. At first blush he seems like a clueless dolt who is being used for his money and seems genuinely in love with this misanthropic anti-hero. What could possess someone to father two babies with a universally despised figure on the brink of over a decade in prison? The romance began AFTER her downfall had started. Why in the world would he and his partner think it’s a good idea to invite a film crew to intimately cover their remaining 35 days together before she reports to the penitentiary? The mask of a fool in love quickly falls with the filmmakers’ careful probing. There is the odd scene where he allows the cameraman to film him naked in the shower. Then there is the small gesture that reveals someone exerting control in an unpleasant way. Elizabeth is making scrambled eggs and he disapproves of how she is whisking, leading to him, without permission, to take the bowl from her. The ever vigilant Nathan asks him to explain and he says he prefers the way he scrambles the eggs. A very small moment but a precursor to his becoming a completely dominating brute. He begins attempting to sabotage Nathan’s interview mid-stream while questions are being asked. In an awkward re-creation it is revealed that when Elizabeth is out of the room, he demands money for participation in the project. This is eventually resolved when he drops the request… but not after Nathan brings it to Elizabeth’s attention. Did she initially conspire with him and pretend to be ignorant? Are they scheming as a team? Once again there is the fog of motivation in this strange couple. Unfortunately the oddness turns downright scary. Towards the end of the film Billy seems completely unhinged and his loathing of Nathan is palpable. His sanity can be called into question. Why would Billy, seething with rage, verbally assault Amanda on camera then, in a later scene, admit that he constantly carries a firearm and is completely bent on revenge. He claims his enemies are following him but he assures Nathan he will destroy those who go against him. I felt for the kids and Nathan and Amanda as he was giving a very convincing portrayal of an armed homicidal lunatic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*v1wujg_Y5cVXKTI8JdPRUA.jpeg" /></figure><p>His behavior begs the question of what are the exact roles being played? Is he simply an abuser? Amanda certainly believes that he poses an existential threat to Elizabeth. She points out the track record of being involved with Sunny, the COO. Note: Sunny ended up being sentenced to approximately the same amount of time as our wide-eyed CEO. Since Sunny isn’t a young mother it is doubtful he will be granted halfway house privileges accorded to Elizabeth — happens to start next year. Prior to viewing the film it would seem cruel and inhuman to suggest Elizabeth deliberately became a mother to soften her punishment. The film shows this to be a very believable behavior. No doubt she has formulated an elongated obtuse response to this accusation. As for her being a victim of Billy’s insanity… time will tell. Certainly Billy is capable of violence. There is a scene where he confronts Nathan who has the misfortune to interview the tech guru for Billy and Elizabeth’s new blood screening venture… who can make this up? In fact the young mother joins Billy in soliciting investors by phone during the final days together before the slammer. Getting back to the encounter, the new executive is honest with Nathan about the relationship between honesty and entrepreneurs — something along the lines of “they’ll tell you anything to get the cash”. Billy steps in and tries to stop the interview. Nathan shows real backbone and stays the course. Given Billy’s anger and subsequent admission that he carries a firearm Nathan put himself in real danger.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yQyWDPhLJEMBbARnbZGRxg.jpeg" /></figure><p>At this point it should be clear these filmmakers knew exactly how to tell this story and had their heart on the side of truth in a grand manner. The particulars of the scam or not as critical as knowing the warped world of the scammers. It might be interesting to know Elizabeth’s response to receiving a message from the Chief Science Officer’s wife of his suicide. No return phone call just goons from the company appearing at her house to collect his laptop and other company property. After seeing Elizabeth in action this would come as no surprise. It might be interesting to know that board member, former Sec. of State George Shultz, had a massive falling out with his beloved grandson Tyler. The young man started his professional career as a Theranos employee. He witnessed the house of cards and bravely tried to alert his grandfather. He was summarily fired then hounded by a team of private detectives and high priced lawyers. It got to a point where his parents, both teachers, were ready to mortgage their home. Not only did the esteemed granddad take Elizabeth’s side he continued to invite her to family holiday dinners. Of course the situation with the nephew didn’t stop Liz from attending. Tyler, being a human being, found it deplorable and awkward. Everyone seeing this film would find Elizabeth’s acceptance of the invite to be in character. She’d probably enjoy having some chit chat with Tyler before the meal. Maybe she was hoping he’d follow the path of the Science Officer? The conduct of the grandfather/board member is unconscionable but even this prestigious national figure fell completely under Liz’s spell and threw his own grandson under Liz’s bus.</p><p>These horrific facts are startling but the filmmakers had what they needed without a catalogue of the couples’ heinous actions. As for motivation? Despite the opacity around Billy &amp; Liz one need only look at the people who were hurt. All the victims were people who stood in their path to being lauded as successful heroes of our time. Power, prestige, privilege and money were the 4 horsemen of their apocalypse. Their evil genius was a complete lack of empathy for anyone other than themselves; this includes her parents and their children. Despite the formidable ability to raise money and generate hype these villains were rather commonplace in their desire to be rich and famous. Shakespear’s Iago is an interesting counterpoint. This is a monster for monster’s sake. No clue what spurred his hatred for Othello and his destruction of Desdemona. Leave it to our time to produce such mediocre ogres. The filmmakers make it all very interesting. At heart these are base dullards chasing bling and power whose exceptionalism lies in the scale of their success.</p><p>In the end I think Thomas Jefferson had the best advice for an encounter with the Bill and Liz’s of this world. His political nemesis was Chief Justice John Marshall:</p><p><em>“When conversing with Marshall I never admit anything. So sure as you admit any position to be good, no matter how remote from the conclusion he seeks to establish, you are gone! Why, if he were to ask me if it were daylight or not, I’d reply, ‘Sir, I don’t know, I can’t tell”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*u69D4y-W-epGheGv3eOkmA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Our founding father’s exasperation is the clarion call of our time. Every frank discussion about important truths seems an invitation to a house of mirrors. Why would these intelligent people invite a team of filmmakers into their home after such a disaster if they didn’t have anything to hide? It’s a compelling question that gets to the heart of the matter — what if merely the act of talking about them is the point? How could anyone, especially Billy, think that this movie would serve them well? I suggest Billy take note of what happened to Sunny and ponder his fate. Perhaps Liz has the black magic to turn this round of celebrity into a cash cow for her next project. After all her track record seems to affirm the maxim: there is a seat for every ass. How can they believe this is going to end well? Liz might respond by borrowing a phrase from another prestigious American political figure. Here is President Bill Clinton’s response during a deposition regarding the Monica Lewisky affair:</p><p><em>It depends on what the meaning of the word ‘is’ is. If the — if he — if ‘is’ means is and never has been, that is not — that is one thing. If it means there is none, that was a completely true statement.”</em></p><p>We can join Nathan and Lance in looking at the camera and collectively rolling our eyes. We can also thank them for showing us that seeing and hearing everything doesn’t necessarily equate with being “real”. Despite the concision and efficiency of our time the human-paced measure of people in a seemingly random analogue setting is a superior path to truth than a slick digital A. I., fact-based summary. That standard relies on age-old virtues such as empathy and honesty. No need for extensive therapy, diagnosis or panels of esteemed experts with great reputations. It’s more of a gut feeling. Goes beyond the flash of programmable algorithms. We know evil. It’s in our blood.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UN1mDK5bbOUvugKTaYVbGg.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7c40330a43a9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[E. T. Has Legs… Or Does He?]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/e-t-has-legs-or-does-he-52230752e6a2?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52230752e6a2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 07 Sep 2026 14:21:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-07T14:21:35.197Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>REVIEW OF FILM <em>Disclosure Day</em></p><p><strong>“This is going to be hard to watch” -</strong> lead character in Disclosure Day to co-star regarding a video of government thugs torturing aliens</p><p><strong>“Beware of false knowledge. It is more dangerous than ignorance” -</strong> George Bernard Shaw</p><p><strong>“But he has nothing at all on!” -</strong> Hans Christian Anderson, the emperor’s new clothes</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zyfrYiBXBe4mUDYqQU-xSQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I stepped into a time warp last week. I physically went to a movie theater to watch a Steven Spielberg movie about aliens; talk about deja vu. I had gone to movie theaters in my youth to see the debuts of <em>Close Encounters</em> and <em>E.T.</em> I was nervous about <em>Disclosure Day</em> when I glimpsed at the running time of 2 hours and twenty five minutes, but as a nod to the pop-film icon of our time… I decided to climb on board for the long ride.</p><p>A Spielberg film was a right of passage for late stage baby boomers. Many of his works have become cultural touchstones: <em>Jaws, Close Encounters</em>, the <em>Indiana Jones</em> franchise, <em>E.T.</em>, the <em>Jurassic Park </em>franchise,<em> Saving Private Ryan,Shindeler’s List</em>… Spielberg’s corpus evokes a certain time and place and a walk-away catch phrase; “We’re going to need a bigger boat”, “ET phone home” or musical earworms such as 5 notes from Close Encounters or the string ostinato from <em>Jaws</em> or the Raiders March from <em>Raiders of the Lost Arc</em>. It would be hard to think of any other contemporary director who so effectively channeled the zeitgeist. Is there anyone reading this who has not engaged in conversations regarding at least a few of the films I mentioned? The challenge for someone with this unsurpassed track record is staying relevant. The last few releases have shown someone older and, do I dare say it, out of touch. Did anyone, aside of Mr. Spielberg, think a remake of <em>West Side Story</em> or <em>War of the Worlds</em> was a good idea? Ditto for <em>The Post</em>, a feature based on the release of the pentagon papers. Did anyone go and see <em>BFG</em> or <em>Ready Player One</em>? Or how about the cold war thriller <em>Bridge of Spies</em> or his bringing to life the European comic book <em>Tin Tin</em>? Attempts at social statements have also fallen short. <em>AI Artificial Intelligence</em> is barely referenced by anyone, even though decades after the film we are faced with the real thing. Ditto for <em>Minority Report</em>, a bloated bore which shed no light on the future or social justice. Nevertheless I felt a sort of obligation to join in the larger conversations. UFOs are back in the news — or more properly renamed UTFs — lets see if the old saw can deliver some new tricks…. Unfortunately the seasoned director might want to consider the tag line in the final scene: LISTEN!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hEkqg01TYi9vgLvqjpmcXg.jpeg" /></figure><p>What is remarkable about <em>Disclosure Day</em> is its stagnancy. It is akin to running into an elderly relative at a family gathering and having them, once again, recite their theory on Big Foot. As a child, this might be charming, as an adult it is tedious. Mr. Spielberg thinks he has a great deal to say and, unfortunately, the commercial success and widespread praise of<em> Schindler’s List</em> and <em>Lincoln</em> gave him the self-confidence to weigh in on things that matter, rather than merely entertain. Prior to this recent work he directed a very personal coming of age film, The <em>Fabelmans</em> based on his journey to being a filmmaker. The serious Spielberg films are well crafted and beautifully rendered with world class performances. In effect he has become the Ken Burns’ of entertainment; wildly successful, professionally capable, but lacking gravitas. Fortunately for Mr. Burns can dependably deliver solid products with recognized experts. In Spielberg’s case he, via his script and choices, weighs in on the red meat of the matter. It is a meager feast of tasteless gruel as his collaborators are cowed by the master chef’s success.</p><p>One of the challenges of being so successful is a lack of candor from friends and coworkers. Who has the courage to say to the recognized master: even for a pop-culture movie, this is REALLY DUMB.. Better to take the pay check and the credit and move on with your career. Disclosure Day is weighted down by pretentious statements about religion and current events delivered in the stilted drama, which in terms of acting, dialogue and plot bears a striking resemblance to old style TV movies. Everyone knows this but no one is brave enough to speak truth to power. The irony is the theme of the film is — speak truth to power.</p><p>There is a great deal to say about the prospect that we are not alone. Sadly sifting through the hours of dialogue will yield no interesting insights into alien life. Instead there is a feast of insipid conversations squeezed between ham-handed chase scenes and set-piece escapes and near misses. The plot is too tedious to delve into particulars but the set up surrounds “evil” government officials &amp; and corporate flak suppressing “the truth”. Some Spielberg’s troupes are revised in the telling: we have the earnest, clueless earthlings, the blinding white lights around the aliens; spoiler alert: the aliens themselves are plus-sized ET’s with legs and no magic finger. This omission speaks volumes. It is as if Spielberg is caught up in the conundrum of whether this movie is “serious”. The film is an attempt at gravitas that brushes against Spielberg’s bread and butter: catchy pop-culture set-pieces. It is as if a Taylor Swift song suddenly morphs into Theonious Monk solo for the chorus.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zWzrq5xAUWvb_MHpPI-DCA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The best examples of this thematic dissonance come with the strange plot twists. The director reprises the urban legend of President Nixon showing Jackie Gleason the bodies of dead aliens. We can all be thankful Spielberg chose not to explore the extensive number of urban legends surrounding extraterrestrials having sex with earthlings. We can only imagine how that dialogue would have sounded. The aliens, in this film speak a language akin to a very serious bout of indigestion. One of the characters can understand this speech as the english language, supposedly based on mathematical equations. He is bewildered when everyone else hears a human imitating a cat throwing up a hairball. And what are we to make of another lead character fleeing to a Christian convent and clutching rosary beads to fend off a bad guy using an alien device to read her mind. She clutches the small crucifix so hard blood is dripping from her hand Maybe he hit that note too hard? And what about the evil government men filming and torturing aliens? This thinly veiled reference to current events is particularly troubling as it might be read as exploitative virtue signaling. Whatever one’s view on US government immigration policy, is this particular film the right venue to sound a note on government exploitation? The director of War of the Worlds, HG Wells’ classic of alien invasion, never once considers the possibility of the not so little green men being a threat. What if E.T. is here to “Serve Mankind” in the twilight zone sense of the phrase.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WMWsY2hcRaodQPuWjFH3YA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Perhaps the best approach to this film is to sit back and bask in petty drama. Imagine this is 2 ½ hours of TV commercial montages that happen to form a drama about aliens. All things considered, it passes relatively quickly. Spielberg isn’t making <em>District 9</em>, an interesting feature about “the other”. Unlike <em>Disclosure Day</em>, that film has resonance. It will get you thinking about justice and mankind’s honest reactions to difference. The characters and message of the Spielberg “drama” has the staying power of an office elevator ride. The remarkable forgettableness of this film lies in stark contrast to the resources available to this director. You have the ability to make and hire the best writers, actors and technicians and the result is an obvious turkey. In the “serious” films,<em> Schindler’s List, Lincoln, The Fabelmans</em>, the lack of insight was masked by the gravitas of the subject matter i.e. the Civil War, the Holocaust and his own personal journey to filmmaking. There was enough flash to pull things along and garner praise (think Ken Burns) <em>Disclosure Day</em>, although harkening back to his earlier work, is overwhelmed by an attempt to relive the past. Rather than being a springboard into new perspectives the channeling of themes from his golden period exposed an older artist recycling ideas with a lesser effect. Think of the Rolling Stones latest album. In the end we are left with no one-liners or earworms, just forgettable fluff from an old man who never bothered to do the work required. It’s tough reliving the past. This proves the isolation at the top. The trick is to know you’re in a bubble and step outside yourself to remember your own strengths. You need to LISTEN! Just like the alien says. Sometimes a trip down memory lane is best experienced in silent contemplation.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52230752e6a2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Remembering Carlotta]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/remembering-carlotta-2cda674b3dcf?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2cda674b3dcf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[remembrance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[salute]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[memorial]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 23 Nov 2025 23:39:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-11-23T23:39:49.588Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Kcvnj4CYA6R4LaroTYc2JQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Remembering Carlotta</strong></p><p>“Riding a Stutz Bearcat… those were different times”<br>Lou Reed, Sweet Jane</p><p>“ She had no tolerance for scenes which were not of her own making. ” -Edith Wharton, <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/1652564">The House of Mirth</a></p><p>Carlotta was a force of nature from a different time. Even her name evokes the past. Nowadays, at least in the U.S., who is named Carlotta? She steadfastly refused to bend a knee to what she considered to be contemporary vulgarity, but she never broadcasted her disappointment to a wide audience. She was never a prig, or a scold, or a snob. Ironically she had every opportunity to flaunt her blue-blooded credentials… she didn’t. She was who she was… take it or leave it. She might have had a front row seat to much of the history of 20th century America… but she was more interested in your story. She naturally knew the great lesson that is lost on many born into privilege… ALL people are simply…. people.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MVSGR0SOfOtzd62XVFTZ-g.jpeg" /></figure><p>I remember the first time I visited her lakeside mansion. I went to boarding school with her daughter Holly, a person who shares her mother’s indomitable spirit, charm and good looks. The decor was formal, but comfortable and very much of an era when people dressed for the theater, dinner and travel. Carolotta put me at ease with a warm embrace and a presentation of an immaculately curated display of food. Carotta spent a great deal of time on details, both in herself and her household. The careful layout of the interior rooms extended to the grounds and her magnificent garden. Nothing was haphazard or unkempt. But most of all nothing felt strained. This was not a hostess whom you felt was running a marathon. It all came naturally. Being a fan of flowers she asked numerous questions about my work on my lilac farm but her curiosity extended to my spouse’s work in social services. Carlotta’s generation expected people to be civically engaged on many levels. Tend to EVERY guest at a party and think about your community in your professional life.</p><p>I suspect her sense of duty came from being the scion of a notable military family. Her father was a confidant of his West Point classmate, Gen. Dwight Eisenhower. Of course if I had relations of such standing, I would have relayed this fact to anyone within the first moments of introduction to establish my credentials. It is telling that with both Carlotta and Holly, the discovery was made…. in passing. I happened to notice an oil portrait of a military man displayed in the living room. It wasn’t simply that Carlotta’s dad was a general… the oil canvass was made by Eisenhower himself. Further conversation revealed that Carlotta personally knew the most storied military leaders from World War II: Patton, Bradley, Marshall…. These historical figures were her parents’ friends… and their children were her contemporaries. Once again these revelations were made after pressing her for details… for her this was simply how she grew up.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yzTTUBvx-N2Qa6hJS4Q09A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Carlotta in charge</figcaption></figure><p>She also let slip some details about her experience being with her father in post-war Germany. The conditions for the civilians were horrific with shortages of basic goods. Her mother organized a drive to get shoes for the local children which a young Carlotta played a part. I thought about that when I saw the debutant portrait of the mother in a formal gown. This was someone who knew glamor did not prevent her from trying to alleviate suffering of those less fortunate. Interestingly her young adulthood was marred by the horrific death of her father in a boat explosion on the Potomac after the war. The loss of a beloved father was made even more difficult by the unfavorable treatment of women at that time. Certainly the family had friends and status but they were vulnerable. Carlotta stood firm and went on to be the matriarch of a wonderful family.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V74IXUElj3PV7Jg5oiuB0Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>Gen. Prichard, portrait by Eisenhower</figcaption></figure><p>She married a former naval intelligence officer who became a very successful business executive, ending up a Chairman of the Board of American Motors. Carlotta had a front row seat in post WWII American business dominance as she escorted her husband in many of his assignments in Europe and South America for such storied companies as Ford, STP, Singer and P&amp;G. No doubt organizing these many transitions, while raising two children was something that was not formally recognized in that era. It was customary to refer to spouses with their husband’s name after the MRS…. I don’t know but I think Carlotta accepted the custom and did not dwell on the chauvinism. Contemporary people might see this as a fault but I am reminded of the matriarch, Aunt Emily, in Walter Percy’s The Moviegoer. There is a scene where she confronts her nephew and I can hear Carlotta in this riposte:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VE5sIK540WD9t6UrDiHSLg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Our civilization has achieved a distinction of sorts. It will be remembered not for its technology nor even its wars but for its novel ethos. Ours is the only civilization in history which has enshrined mediocrity as its national ideal. Others have been corrupt, but leave it to us to invent the most undistinguished of corruptions. No orgies, no babies thrown off cliffs. No, we’re sentimental people and we horrify easily. True, our moral fiber is rotten. Our national character stinks to high heaven. But we are kinder than ever. No prostitute ever responded with a quicker spasm of sentiment when our hearts are touched. Nor is there anything new about thievery, lewdness, lying, adultery. What is new is that in our time liars and thieves and whores and adulterers wish also to be congratulated and are congratulated by the great public, if their confession is sufficiently psychological or strikes a sufficiently heartfelt and authentic note of sincerity. Oh, we are sincere. I do not deny it. I don’t know anybody nowadays who is not sincere. Didi Lovell is the most sincere person I know every time she crawls in bed with somebody else, she does so with the utmost insincerity. We are the most sincere Laodiceans who ever got flushed down the sinkhole of history. No, my young friend, I am not ashamed to use the word class. They say out there we think we’re better. You’re damn right we’re better. And don’t think they don’t know it.” -Aunt Emily, Walker Percy’s The Moviegoer</em></p><p>Maybe my assessment is wrong. Certainly Carlotta would never utter such a harsh sentiment out loud. The monologue captures the spirit of unwavering defiance in the face of an unrecognizable world, which is how I will always remember her. It is easy to focus on the out of date styling and old fashioned way of doing things… I, for one, cherish Carlotta’s sense of place and upholding their versions of “class”. She was a loveable blue-blood who, to quote Clark Gable, could “give a damn” about being perceived as “out of touch”.</p><p>Carlotta I will miss your wonderful holiday gatherings. The perfectly set table in the wonderfully designed glass porch with the fine cutlery, porcelain and flowers. The carefully arranged seating. Everyone taking note of your subtle affirmations/criticisms, and then following your discrete direction. I will miss your running the show. Even as your health issues made it difficult, there was never a doubt about who set the tone for those many wonderful gatherings. The sense of loss is immense as we are saying goodbye to both you as a person, and as our last tangible connection to a generation that lived through the Great Depression, WWII and Pax Americana…. As we face uncertain times we will miss your reassuring presence. You saw your share of turbulence and heartache…. But managed not only to survive but to thrive. You led by example…The perfectly coiffed hair, the pearls, the bespoke outfits, the unflagging politeness and warmth, were all familiar touchstones in an ever-changing world of unwelcome surprises. This Thanksgiving won’t be the same this year…. but I will give thanks for having known you. It is reassuring to known there was a time when polite society was… polite.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IfpQ_mOd_6iAkbs92esOJA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2cda674b3dcf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[JimmyDMook]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/jimmydmook-3e4831abc6ff?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3e4831abc6ff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[jimmy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Apr 2025 10:58:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-23T00:26:47.482Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7JH3C8_4yy2DmuRBRcnMLw.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>“Boxes don’t complain about the heat” - Jimmy G. explaining why he invested in warehouses and not rental housing.</blockquote><p>Up until his passing a few days ago, Jimmy’s personal email was an AOL account, JIMMYDMOOK, referencing a scene in Martin Scorsese’s MEAN STREETS. A character asks what a MOOK is and it triggers a head-cracking pool hall brawl. MEAN STREETS was shot on a 14th street location in the basement of the former Palladium, then known as Howard Stein’s Academy of music next to the old Luchow’s restaurant. This is also where the seminal 1973 Lou Reed album “Rock’n’Roll Animal” was recorded the same year MEAN STREETS premiered. 1973 is also the year the twin towers were finally completed. None of this means much to anyone born in the last thirty years but Jimmy and I shared a large part of our lives embedded in New York City of a very specific, generative time. Jimmy and I watched the Trade Center slowly rise above the lower Manhattan skyline for half a decade. We came of age in a world of subway tokens, LPs and payphones.</p><p>When I first met Jimmy G, he was a coach at my grade school, St. Davids located next to the Gugenheim museum on the upper eastside. But this was before Manhattan was a fancy place filled with international billionaires. When I was a school kid, the subways were covered in graffiti and you could get a 3 bedroom apartment on park avenue for 90K. It was a city some people of means tried to avoid and felt much more like a small town with a lot of crime. Jimmy, however, did not live on the Upper East Side. He was strictly “bridge and tunnel” and damn proud of it. He wore “wife-beater” tank tops which prominently displayed his marijuana leaf tattoo on his upper arm. It’s hard to explain how radical a gesture this was at the time. His hair was Carlos Santana at Woodstock, complete with mustache. He was physically chiseled and sometimes wore short T’s that showcased his 6 pack. St. David’s wouldn’t let someone like Jimmy in the front door these days. His sports were gymnastics, basketball and boxing. It might be hard for his recent acquaintances to square this portrait with the gray-haired polo-shirt wearing, portly older man he became, holding court with an array of successful businessmen at prominent golf clubs. But make no mistake, he was the exact same person. Jimmy was always himself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1MISILbGg6TTDjvoRdq6Zg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Many years ago Jimmy was invited to a lunch with my family at the Top of the Sixes, a high-end hot spot in midtown where a certain attire was required. I can’t remember the occasion but I do remember the look on my grandmother’s face when Jimmy appeared. He was wearing a sweatshirt with a colorfully emblazoned full size image of a bikini clad water skier. Adding to the awkwardness of the moment was the insistence of the restaurant staff that he wear an equally garish jacket they had on hand for those who didn’t follow the dress code. Jimmy joked to the waiter, in his heavy New York accent, that he wanted another color. The staff didn’t think it was funny. I’m happy to report that after he met his wife, Geralynne, his sartorial choices improved dramatically. Geralynne’s beneficial influence extended well beyond clothes.</p><p>Geralynne was a driving force behind Jimmy’s transition from jock, lady’s man, stoner to sober, family-man, successful entrepreneur. She was never judgemental, never a scold. She led by quiet example. I think her getting up every morning in her exquisite business attire to report to her job on Wall Street helped Jimmy aspire to his potential. At that point Jimmy was in the nascent stages of forming his company. He had worked as a taxi driver and been taken hostage at gunpoint which certainly aided in his decision to embark on a different career path. I remember him discussing his idea with us of establishing a moving company and calling it Celebrity Moving. I thought it might work but I thought the name was dumb. He insisted. The rest is history because he turned it into a huge success. I actually reflected on this one day walking around his massive warehouse when I ran into a movie star inspecting his boxes. Jimmy had been right: celebrities called up Celebrity Moving to do their moving and storage. Dear God.</p><p>In the early days of Celebrity moving, when he and his number 2, Chuck, did the actual moving themselves, I asked them to help me haul some furniture to New Hampshire where I was attending school. I met Jimmy on 48th Ave in front of his one room office where he and Chuck ran “operations”. Chuck was the Scottie Pippen of Celebrity Moving. We boarded the large third-hand, rusting former water-hauling truck to begin our journey. Jimmy told me we were making a delivery to Boston before NH. We were on 95 in Old Lyme CT when the sneaker he had been using to prop up the radiator dislodged, producing a torrent of antifreeze as it made contact with the fan. Eight hours later Jimmy’s brother arrived from Jersey with a tow truck. I remember a somewhat tense conversation crammed in the truck cab as his brother expressed some skepticism about the prospects for his new venture. How their father and he “had solid pensions which they gained BEFORE doing anything else.” Jimmy was not receptive. It was a long drive back to the city.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MSv086uyjVXQaDT466GzmA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I had noticed Jimmy’s makeshift repair had used a sneaker from his award-winning run.</p><p>Jimmy was the unlikely winner of a feminist-themed 5K race put on by Betty Friedan. T<em>he New York Times </em>interviewed him after his win. When asked why he entered the race he responded: “I thought I’d meet some girls.”</p><p>Before Celebrity Moving, Jimmy spent a huge amount of time at my family’s house near the beach. One summer he was in residence, working odd jobs and helping while the house was being refurbished. He was also keeping an eye on my younger brother who was experiencing some challenges. In addition to his running success, he landed the job of being the chaperone for a very prominent writer who didn’t trust himself driving home after parties. This was prior to Jimmy’s commitment to sobriety, so being a hired designated driver was a mighty odd choice, but Jimmy’s natural charm and trustworthiness won everyone over.</p><p>My father and mother were both smitten with Jimmy. In fact, they consented to him in a chaperone role for a cross country adventure with myself, my brother and another close friend. Since no one else was old enough to have a license Jimmy handled all the driving of the camper. He was 25, my friend and I were 16 and Zach was 11. In hindsight I wonder about my parent’s judgement. A drug addict chaperoning children for a cross country trip sounds like a case for child protective services. But you had to know Jimmy. Surprisingly, this streetwise Queens boy has an encyclopedic knowledge of the Western National Parks. I remember paddling down the snake river and having Jim talk about the rock formations in the eroded canyon walls. You might not know but Jimmy finished an undergraduate degree in… geology. It was great fun, but not without its terror. It was the 1970s. No cell phones, no tracking, to backstop. We had paper maps and a giant bag of highly illegal cannabis and other substances. Perhaps the scariest moment was when we had just visited Bryce &amp; Zion and suddenly came upon what appeared to be a toll booth. There were uniformed officers searching vehicles. We were driving an enclosed camper and quickly began fumigating. We considered making a U turn but it would have been too obvious. So we hid the bag of weed in the freezer and stuffed the bag of peyote in a couch pillow. The officer entered. I’m sure we looked like a backup band for Alice Cooper as we feigned being responsible good citizens. The officer b-lined it to the fridge. We were crest-fallen. He grabbed a bag of lettuce tomatoes and asked “Can I have these?” SURE!!!! Turns out this was an agricultural checkpoint and they were guarding against pests to protect the crops in the central states.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pJoVqvcJBHW_UTYD758eaQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Another fright was on the return trip. We pulled into a rural town in Louisiana. We were trying to find an old friend of Jimmy’s. Our NY plates garnered more attention than we expected. Not sure if this crowd ever encountered anyone outside their Parrish (the Louisiana term for County) In the end we found the friend who was a “bean farmer”. It is true that there were beans on the farm but there was a completely different crop that brought home the bacon… magic mushrooms. We had a wonderful dinner in his trailer with his wife and infant son. I tried to help with the dishes but the wife insisted the men needed to sit and have a smoke while she cleaned up. I invited the farmer to visit us in NY. Jimmy shot me a look meaning “SHUT UP.” The guy gave a cryptic answer, “I’d love to but that’s not in the cards. I had a rough trip up in those parts”. Jimmy explained later that he was wanted for armed robbery in New Jersey. I should not have been surprised. Years earlier I went with Jimmy to pick up two friends at the airport who had just returned from Thailand… I don’t think they went to tour the sites. We were crossing the Triborough Bridge when one of them leaped forward from the back seat and covered Jimmy’s eyes — sending the car careening across lanes of honking traffic. We managed to avoid hitting the wall but paused in the breakdown lane where Jimmy threatened to kill his backseat jokester. Needless to say, it was a long rest of the ride as the friend, obviously high on something, didn’t seem to understand Jimmy’s warning and kept laughing at odd intervals. This makes me reflect on the career choices of two of Jimmy’s kids. No doubt the prosecutor and the State Trooper would have probably had some professional encounters with Jimmy’s old crowd. I’m not sure that any of his kids know that Jimmy once got into a spitting match with the Ramones at CBGB’s back in the day.</p><p>What is that Lou Reed line, “those were different times”. We like to think all the flashy technology makes life easier.No doubt if we had had a rearview camera in the camper Jimmy wouldn’t have backed up into that tree at the forest campsite in Montana. Full confession: I was supposed to be his lookout. No rearview camera. No google maps. No way to call for help. It was insane for Jimmy, as a novice surfer, to try and swim out to the second break during a hurricane, but he was not confining his life to a swimming pool. Jimmy didn’t play it safe but he was not reckless either . He knew how to turn his weakness for drugs into the backbone of his success in life. You didn’t doubt him because you knew he’d lived it. The pot leaf tattoo was re-inked as a prohibition sign. Everyone respects someone whose trustworthiness is based on real world experiences. Jimmy lived the lesson but never preached. This is why he had fans from all walks of life: tycoons, mobsters and street people in Long Island City, the suburban crowd from the Island, all those friends in FLA…</p><p>For a number of years in my 20s, I had the neighboring apartment to Jimmy’s on Vernon Boulevard in Queens. Jimmy had kindly introduced me to the landlord, Mr. Chichillini, who showed off the shrine to the Virgin Mary in the backyard. The interview consisted of Jimmy hugging me in front of Mr. Chichillini and saying “BRAM IS MY GOOMBAH”. Jimmy also helped me negotiate the re-rigging of the clothesline of the upstairs apartment as their underwear and sheets were obscuring my view of the East River. He introduced me to Uncle Louie, whom I dutifully bought coffee for on the weekends. The non-alternate-side-of-the-street parking was coveted and it was always good to have Uncle Louie on your side. Jimmy also explained that the occasional smell of death on the first floor was from the tenant who made homemade wine in his bathtub. He also gave insight into the always empty perfume store next to the bar across the street. The girlfriend of another mobster was running some sort of money laundering operation. There was always a group of elderly Italian women in lawn chairs on the sidewalk in front of the pizzeria. They would be brought to tears when they had to let go of Jimmy’s baby son, James, after babysitting him. I once made the mistake of leaning out on the fire escape in an attempt to calm a rowdy group of drunks. I threatened to call the 108th precinct, which was around the corner if they didn’t shut up. Turns out they were the cops from the 108 — unwinding after their shift. I had another memorable moment on the fire escape which connected out apartments.. It was the halfway point for the NYC marathon and we were all overlooking the action. The lead woman runner went by and had a very serious bathroom accident in her tight running shorts. I fell back into my bedroom and barfed on the rug. I’m sure Jimmy and Geralynne noticed but Geralynne made sure Jimmy didn’t rib me about it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D_aeSK2CMSLAbBZX4bVL6g.jpeg" /></figure><p>This was not the only awkward moment in the hood. In my attempt to be a friend, I bought Jimmy and Geralynne a colorful tropical fish to try and cheer them up after the sudden passing of Geralynne’s mother. A few days later I dropped in and saw their fish tank was drained. I asked “what happened” only to be met with a glare of silence from Jimmy that resembled his expression on our after dinner conversation in Louisiana. Geralynne explained in a reassuring tone. It turns out my fish had eaten all of their fish and died after gorging himself. I redeemed myself by volunteering to give their sick cat pills for a few days so they could take a long delayed vacation. After that week it took me years to be near any cat again.</p><p>Jimmy was the paradigm family man. I came from a culture where children were relegated to the kid’s table and generally excluded from adult affairs. Metaphorically speaking, JImmy was a kid’s table. He loved ALL children. Even the one upstairs who terrorized him by constantly running across the floor in heavy shoes making the lights in Jimmy’s apartment shake. I was so moved that his first grandchild arrived just a few weeks before he departed. He also bore witness to all his children’s successes. It is interesting that no matter what field they chose to pursue, they have all made their mark. Obviously Geralynne deserves much credit as well. She raised 5 kids (if you include Jimmy) and still is as charming and beautiful as the day I met her nearly half a century ago.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HQtIQGpW2j-xCBYvjsEPYA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Of course parenting came with the burdens of adulthood. Early on it became necessary for Jimmy to give up his beloved dog. For some reason the animal had begun threatening James. Jimmy did his best to make accommodations, but the aggression couldn’t be curbed. He made the tough choice, but not without streams of tears. Hard choices were made in the workplace as well. I recall a strike as well as several tough conversations with employees when they ran astray. He gave second chances but not thirds. Celebrity became a haven for those seeking work and sobriety. Jimmy’s ability to read a situation and not hide from conflict was remarkable. Once he called my father, who was on vacation in Italy, to berate him for not supporting my young brother during a rough patch. He really tore my father a new one, and this was a man Jimmy, in many respects, hero-worshipped.</p><p>This characteristic did not always win him friends. I’m specifically recalling his giving opinions about fouls in local street basketball games. Jimmy was a tough competitor whether on the court or the course and never stifled his opinions. Everyone in NYC who lived above the third story probably remembers Jimmy’s post-9/11 message to Mr. Bin Laden. It was strategically painted on the top of each of the fleet of Celebrity Moving trucks. I asked him if he thought people would be offended by the vulgarity? His response: “Fuck them &amp; Bid Laden.”</p><p>That really sums it up. He was who he was. Perhaps this confidence came from having to earn his keep from a very young age. Maybe his zeal for achievement came from insecurity about his own family. He would sometimes say, derisively, that his father worked as a garbage man. I failed to see the shame in that, but then again I remember my own father’s ambivalence about my grandfather’s vocation as spice salesman. It was a long journey from a stoned playboy dressed as a nurse at a Frank Zappa Halloween show at the Fillmore East to being a sober, respected, family man, and wildly successful entrepreneur on the links.</p><p>I called his office when I heard the news via Facebook. The receptionist confirmed what I had read. She said she had worked there for decades and he was like a father. Through my tears I explained he was family to me as well. He was my goombah. My favorite celebrity. What a mook.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FwKf-mX3RRE1RaOd0iHLUA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The last time I saw Jimmy &amp; Geralynne I came down from my farm in Vermont to visit after his operation. We sat by the pool in the backyard of his Rockville Centre mansion and I took some photos. It was quite the contrast from Vernon boulevard. At one point Geralynne went inside the house. Jimmy quickly turned to me, the extended post-op slumber seemed to vanish. He wanted me to photograph his operation scar. I tried to dissuade him but that relentless mischievous 9 year old boy spark was in his tone. “Quick BEFORE Geralynne gets back!!!” I thought it was gross and inappropriate but I was glad the operation hadn’t bent his spirit. I enclose the photograph below. I think he’d want you to know he’s still smiling.</p><p>XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX</p><h3><strong>TRIGGER WARNING</strong></h3><p>PS — BELOW IS A PHOTOGRAPH JIMMY INSISTED I TAKE.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KGdmO7ZA6x2BZV6wsl9nxA.jpeg" /></figure><p>A special thank you to my spouse, Erica, who patiently edited and helped write. What’s that Paul McCartney line: take a sad song and make it better.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3e4831abc6ff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In The Zone]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/in-the-zone-8573a6046f8b?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8573a6046f8b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[reflections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jonathan-glazer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-zone-of-interest]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 07 Jul 2024 22:14:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-07T22:18:56.227Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>REVIEW OF FILM <em>THE ZONE OF INTEREST</em></p><p>“”No. Only two and one half million — the rest died from disease and starvation.””</p><p><strong>- Rudolf Höss, Commandant of Auschwitz Concentration Camp when asked if he’d kill 3.5 million people</strong></p><p>“The man sitting next to me was Hitler and he made so little impression on me I can’t remember a second of it”</p><ul><li><strong>Orson Welles, On Meeting the Führer in the 1920s</strong></li></ul><p>“I did not see any murders, I did not see any torture. I did not know at all such a thing there”</p><p><strong>- Adolf Eichmann, at his trial in Jerusalem</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EevZD-f8KI33SGGKouxZwQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Paradise, for most people, would not consist of millions of people being tortured, killed and incinerated just over the garden wall. Not so for Hedwig Hoss, the wife of the Auschwitz commandant, obersturmbannfuhrer Rudolf Hoss. Even her mother-in-law, an overt anti-semite who gleefully mused about her former boss being in the death camp, found the constant burning of bodies to be… a bridge too far. Yet the rest of the Hoss’ family seemed quite at home adjacent to the carnage. The children played in back yard with the slave labor, while Ms. Hoss sorted clothes confiscated from inmates, who were probably dead by the time she tried on the coats etc…. Jonathan Glazer’s <em>The Zone of Interest</em> is certainly a different take on the nadir of 20th century barbarity…. Yet there is no overt violence, only the humdrum family drama. The couple has disagreements. The prospect of a sudden reassignment triggers raised voices. There is the occasional angry jab when “the help” slips-up. And yet there are sounds….. haunting sounds just over the wall. The film is about distance… or maybe the wish for distance. Sylvan domesticity is pitted next door to Dante’s Inferno… and yet everyone manages to play house without a hitch. The result is a terrifying portrait of the capacity for ordinary people to become monsters beyond the imagining of any fiction writer’s sociopathic villain.</p><p>Glazer opens the film in complete darkness. It goes on for so long an audience member might think something has gone wrong with the projection. Is this supposed to happening? Yes. This film will be an inquisitive experience going beyond simply following a well drawn linear narrative. It is a akin to the opening of Alfonso Cuaron’s <em>Roma</em>, which consisted of 5 minutes of washing a tiled floor. It is as if the directors are signaling the audience to leave if they can’t be bothered actively engage in ALL aspects of the film.… listening as well as seeing. The soundtrack is as critical as the visuals in parsing meaning. The never-ending black leader is accompanied by a chorus of voices. Is it murmuring? It’s nor quiet threatening… or is it? The whispering swells into a terrifying off-key dissonance. Something is desperately WRONG. Given the context we might think we are in a box car filled with human cargo awaiting the terror of selection. Perhaps we are within the infamous gas chambers themselves at the moment the Zyklon B gas is dropping. Then, in the midst of trying to decipher the ghoulishness, an image of serenity appears. A domestic setting of a family in the midst of a sylvan bliss. A casual picnic outing which seems set in an Hudson-River school oil painting. Once again Glazer never permits too much comfort. The pater familias, fishing mid-stream without a shirt, is too white. He is separate from the pastoral background. The distinctly military buzz-cut adds to a sense of foreboding regarding the nature of his character.</p><p>The film continues to meander through the dissonant, tranquil domesticity. The children play in the make-shift back yard pool. The father’s equestrian passion is revealed with a number of rides, accompanied by his eldest, through the lush vegetation. A beautiful family on beautiful animals riding down to the river… except the sounds of yelling and the awkward encounter with a work detail. I remember as a child driving on a family vacation in Florida witnessing a chain gang along the highway. Nothing was said but… the overt cruelty of the adult world drifted, momentarily, into endless-summer fun. A sour chord in an otherwise lighthearted ditty. The children in this film play in the same way all children play but even in their innocent fantasies the creepiness of their circumstance rises to the surface. They are lying in their bunk beds and fooling with some things that they picked up in the garden. It turns out that ash for the crematorium is used as fertilizer. They are toying with a human jaw bone…. At least I thought it was…. It’s hard to tell when nothing is in close up.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_Jkp29Fd1YtxZqcOA_1xdQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Distance is at the heart of this film. It would be difficult to recognize any of the central actors outside of their roles as we never really see anyone except through a broad wide shot. They are metaphorical… everybody. Unexceptional in their demeanor, yet terrifyingly extraordinary in their wicked lack of empathy. The only intimate moment where the closeness creeps in is, strangely, between the commandant and his… horse. It is part of the bizarre dynamic of this portrait of a inhuman human that somehow, despite his obvious psychopathology, there is connection with any sort of living soul. The intimate moment of saying goodbye to his horse contrasts with his somewhat formal relationship with his family and his professional attachment to his soldiers. The troops throw him a birthday party but it has the same staid quality that permeates his domestic life. Much of the life takes place in his “villa”, which posses the charm one would expect of well-off upwardly mobil family with some means. There are ‘servants’ strutting around the garden and acting as domestics. It is only when the Frau of the house makes the remark to a misbehaving charge that she could “have my husband spread your ashes all over the field” that the audience understands the conceit behind all the seeming normalcy. The setting might evoke simplified elegant country living, the context renders it a portrait of hell on earth. It is the film equivalent of Karl Hocker’s photo album. This SS officer put together a photographic record of all of his comrades performing formal official duties and kidding around in their spare time. It all looks fun and funny… until you realize the people laughing at the Solahutte resort south of the Auschwitz camp were key player in perpetuating the Holocaust. The film’s protagonist is pictured in the album standing next to Jospeh Mengele. They are in the front row of a chorus of officers singing in front of an accordion player. The bulk film is metaphorically taken from the same home-movie angle. But there are key moments that depart from the script.</p><p>The film leaves the seemingly staid tranquility to launch into abstract sequences that evoke the angelic little girl in the red coat in Spielberg’s <em>Schindler’s List</em>. There are eerie black and white negative images of a little girl who secretly gathers the bountiful fruit of the commandant’s garden to clandestinely deliver to the starving work gangs. The transition features a red flower morphing into a blanket of red then the abstraction of a photographic negative of the little girl on her mission of mercy outside the window of the house. The ending of the film also breaks from the domesticity. Our hero is in the city with Nazi big-wigs accepting his promotion to an eponymous mission to kill over 700,000 prisoners waiting for transport. It is an odd moment where we see the commandant awkwardly mingling with the dignitaries in an elaborate building. He breaks from the festivities to call his wife and gossip. After the call he descends into a labyrinth akin to the setting in Orson Welles’ <em>The Trial</em>. A landscape of hallways and stairways leading nowhere and everywhere. It all ends as we reveal the building is now the site of a holocaust remembrance. The institutional setting is now a warehouse of horror. There are neat glass sealed dioramas of suitcases, glasses, shoes…. The jetsam and flotsam of lives ripped from everyday living by an ideology of hate that recruited an army of thoughtless, colorless bureaucrats such as Rudolph Hoss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EqixQeeK5hAOBNbCyxP79Q.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>The Zone of Interest</em> is a fable resurrecting the central point in Hannah Arendt’s essay Eichmann in Jerusalem. The mundane masks the horrific. One can comfortably distant themselves from Hannibal Lecter, a ruthless cannibal hiding behind the facade of an erudite doctor. But what if an upscale suburban neighbor, the logistics chief for a Fortune 500 company, turns out to be even more savage? Rudolph and Hedwig are forgettable yuppies and yet they posses the ability to supervise the gruesome slaughter of millions. The film is a seemingly quiet meditation on the remarkably unremarkable people who find a comfortable path of normalcy in a seat of unspeakable depravity. It reminds us that polite society is rooted in power, not justice. Being the instrument of slavery, deprivation, famine might very well bring status and riches. The key is telling ourselves we’ve never overtly crossed the line into being the Hoss family, with a chateau nestled next to their human crematoriums. As we watch the solidly middle class family play and go about their days it raises an eerie specter about questions we might not be asking ourselves.</p><p>Ten percent of the planet goes to bed hungry. Most people in first world countries have house-hold products and food staples made and or harvested by enslaved people. The film asks us to examine our very own zone of interest. Once again distance is what brings it all home. How big is our zone? At one point does the proximity to evil blur our morality? How close do we have to be to make up stories that justify our actions? These questions linger and make <em>The Zone of Interest</em> a film that hits too close. Horror films scare. Films about horror haunt. Rudolph and Hedwig are the stuff of nightmares and day dreams. On a tranquil sunny day while out with the family on a picnic, do you ever hear anything in the distance?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8573a6046f8b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Remembering Pizza-the-dog]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/remembering-pizza-the-dog-49748c2425c6?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/49748c2425c6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[dog-memorial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remembering-the-dead]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[memorial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remembrance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dogs]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 Jan 2024 20:36:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-09T01:07:56.749Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>By Bram with contributions by Erica</strong></p><p><em>“The dog does not have an opinion about you… that’s why you love the dog so much.” -Eckhart Tolle, On Dogs</em></p><p>You arrived via a Craigslist ad from a loving, but hard pressed, family that couldn’t handle you. You were advertised as a Lab… you weren’t. You were a pure maniac. Too big and narrow to be a lab, but with the personality of a Lab on speed. You were about 9 months — old enough that bad habits were part of the package.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZqClh53NmUvTVw2cSies-Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>You tore up the apartment of the previous guardians when left to your devices. What’s an overworked family to do when the parents must work and the kids are in school. It was a tough act of love for them to turn their guardianship over to us.</p><p>You trashed the house, chased the sheep, chased the chickens, found the holes in the fence and barked and barked and barked…. We thought having you fixed would help calm you down. It did nothing. You continued to bark and lunge at everyone when we walked on public paths.</p><p>I recall one trek through the Marshfield forest where you serenaded this poor woman who was out for a quiet walk in the country. It was a very long 4 miles for all of us. No matter how far she disappeared on separate trails, you positioned yourself so the full force of your bark was 100% targeted in her direction. I don’t think my shouted apologies improved the situation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*R2hfs3eL4RwKLaoKBrIAtA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Back on the farm you only ran free from the leash with a first rate tracking collar. And that collar got A LOT of use. We took regular, adrenaline filled car rides ending miles away in remote woods or stranger’s yards. It is established law in Vermont that a dog that chases livestock or deer can be shot. This fact certainly added to the drama. I distinctly remember being in the middle of a forest and hearing this rushing sound thrashing the silence. The tracker told me you were moving at the speed of light. Suddenly a huge buck tore past me, mere feet away — I could feel the wake….. followed by you. It was pure joy. FOR YOU. Not for me. Beet-red, arm-waving screaming and totally invisible.</p><p>Then there were the encounters with the skunks, porcupines, ermines, groundhogs… and the endless flocks of turkeys. You were always close to them… but never fast enough.. Not all the encounters ended up with stitches and vet bills.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*E7zq08pxU2J6CDZa4pjVpQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Mr. Z, our quiet, contemplative, short-haired, Rhodesian Ridgeback, was generally aghast and often left the room when you entered. It took several years before he was willing to be friendly.</p><p>Pizza was usually too much but he was never aggressive. Pizza might have a live chicken in his mouth or the sheep on their backs… but would never bite. It was never about the kill.</p><p>Our highest form of play was the daily walk. For over a decade I would take Pizza &amp; Z in the upper field, 10 laps around the shrubs (I grow flowers) and it would take a bit over an hour. It was so routine. I only now realize it was a sacred ritual. Some go to the house of worship, some meditate, some recite prayers…. We walked amongst the pearl pink, blue and dark wine varieties of French hybrid lilac .</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Z8S_lOlRRIDe2GrlKELh6Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>It would begin with a short but very steep ascent from the house into a patch of Beauty of Moscow and rise further to the rows of Maiden’s Blush. You were permitted a few laps without being on the leash, usually towards the end of the walk. Without the restriction, you left the farm. Even this way, every few months you’d break the trust and flee with abandon into the woods or roads. Z, generally more mature and happy to obey the rules even unleashed, would join your jail-break.</p><p>Why did I keep on playing the fool? I knew part of my job was accommodating Pizza’s lack of respect for boundaries. The stress probably put years on my life, but that is the price I pay for honoring the spirit of my charge.</p><p>I remember being on the trail walk on Cape Cod and we encountered a young family with two small dogs. I was pulling to the side with all my might to avoid any chance of an encounter. Pizza sprung into action nearly ripping my arms from my sockets as I leaned back hard to counterbalance. I was the first to tumble over the embankment, followed by Mr. Z and finally the barking behemoth…… I remember the small kids peering over the side looking down on us. Z and I were scowling. The father spoke up: Everything Okay? Pizza answered, “absolutely.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BtM46ITa-dwxaUlJfVoYkQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Even at the hardest moments… It was all good. During worst bouts of Pizza’s failing health, he never lost his enthusiasm. I certainly did… but he didn’t. Let that be an example. Years before, chronic kidney disease was discovered by our conventional vet. They prescribed the standard food that is formulated for this condition. I winced at the smell when I opened the bag and Pizza wouldn’t touch it. He began losing weight and even losing interest in traditional food. It looked as if he would perish within weeks. We turned to a magnificent doctor who practiced Eastern as well as Western medicine. Exotic herbs were added to special vegetable based raw food that had to be cooked . It was as much of a hassle as it sounds and I, being a natural skeptic, went through the paces only due to lack of any alternative. But Pizza rebounded. I didn’t and still don’t understand the wonderful physician’s explanations about energy and flow…. But the proof is in the Pizza. He thrived.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3Nt8ynGovyZUvZsEoxI2IA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The condition eventually returned after a reprieve of several years. We stepped up our diet and medical game.</p><p>We learned about delivering IVs fluids. We struggled to master loading numerous pills at once via hollow horse capsules. We marveled at the dexterity of the Vet’s assistant’s ability to smoothly load and administer the medicine. When I tried, Pizza never failed to spit them out after the careful application of coconut oil and a water syringe. The sense of accomplishment when the pills finally went down was akin to crossing the finish line of a marathon. Some days he ate meat and some days only crackers. One day only processed meat, then the next only fresh. Chicken nuggets were more successful than anything else. Drinking became an issue. He agreed to drink out of the toilet but not the water bowl. Then came… no food, no water. He wasted away but his tail never stopped wagging. He stopped having to use the leash, then he stopped completing the 10 laps, then less than 5, then simply climbing the hill to the top of the loop.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*B_6tiLHS-EFeubnCihTzUg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Just a couple days before he died, Pizza would still climb the initial precipice and then wait, shivering in the cold. Each lap I would place my heavy winter coat over him… and each lap he’d have shed it standing proud and shivering. Then he kept it on.</p><p>The next day he failed to climb the hill and lay in the yard looking up at us.</p><p>The ground is now cold, preventing any hope of a quick burial. What to do? I run a flower farm so I went to the barn and converted two large shipping boxes into a make-shift cardboard coffin. It sits next to the wood-pile adjacent to the house. We’ll wait for the ground to soften.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s3tMY-61aSYhwI9IAA_RLg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Of course it is sentimental and self-indulgent for a silly man to prattle on about the death of his silly dog. Most people keep these end-points of their animals’ lives private, but for some reason, I don’t. I can only point out a very old tale from one of the wisdom traditions that suggests that man’s best friend is the touchstone to salvation. The story of Yudhisthira’s dog in the Mahabharata reveals a person who refuses an invitation into heaven, unless he is permitted to bring his faithful canine companion. He is rewarded when the animal turns out to be the incarnation of his beloved father. The hero passes the test by not forsaking the sacred bond even for the promise of paradise.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1ZRSSsu7eiUwl29SkC0aZA.jpeg" /></figure><p>The hard facts about Pizza would describe an undesirable dog. He always smelled bad. The intermittent incontinence in his last year did not help our constant battle against the stench. The final weeks left the house covered in urine and vomit which usually was bookended by mad rushes to the door at all hours trying to get him to exit in time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hKf8DozUAJiXd2ooLNCIig.jpeg" /><figcaption>photo by Erin</figcaption></figure><p>But I find myself looking at my tracker on my lonely walks with Mr. Z hoping the “?” next to your deactivated collar will miraculously light up and warn me you’ve “once again” jumped the fence. What I wouldn’t do now to feel the adrenaline of another maddening adventure in the forest. It is fitting that the dog I wanted least turns out to be the one I miss the most. Pizza had an expert ability to gently block your path just as you were trying to walk across the room. It was maddening but I believe it was his sense of humor. He also had a goofy run which included awkward unpredictable leaps and I was never quite able to capture it in a picture. This one comes closest:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PmKNPvoIs3YHL75BV-xCZQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>As the cold-hard-ground drags on and your cardboard coffin sits next to the wood, I imagine what I would say if someone drove up and asked me what was in the box. In honor of your comic spirit, I would just say: Pizza. It’s a Pizza box.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tGh4aGjnpUPSoNfEq9FW0A.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cPoHT0hKEzI1rv09BnoZtQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P-HVeQUq5Lay-1-8fOxamA.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/957/1*Jol_iAH2M3WULrkRikivqA.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>GOODBYE</strong></h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=49748c2425c6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Jennifer Saved My Dog’s Life]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/jennifer-saved-my-dogs-life-e2ab7d1ee955?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e2ab7d1ee955</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[memorial]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remembrance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[friendship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[remembering]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[friends]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Oct 2023 15:24:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-23T16:20:05.942Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Jennifer saved my dog’s life. She knew about dogs. I am a dog person as well. I wasn’t always. Neither was Jennifer. We knew each other a lifetime ago. I was a young independent filmmaker in living in NYC. One day I crossed paths with a young for writer for Town &amp; Country magazine at a gilded-age mansion turned grade-school. For those not familiar with the publication this is from their website: <em>The trusted source of inside information on access and influence, taste, elegant living, and unpretentious fun — an irreplaceable guide to the very best. </em>We were in the Sacred Heart chapel located in the James A. Burdon House for a memorial service celebrating a mutual friend, François-Xavier Bagnoud, a dashing young Swiss helicopter pilot who died in a crash while surveying the Paris-Dakar rally. It was not surprising that Jennifer would be a close friend of a modern day version of the Little Prince; Francois’ mother was a Countess and his father ran an air-rescue operation in the Alps.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d-m9F4THC8QAhhWHRhp1Ig.jpeg" /><figcaption>at the memorial</figcaption></figure><p>If this all seems like a cross between a Henry James and James Bond, you have an idea of Jennifer’s world at that time. Her specific job was to survey the most exotic, exclusive resorts in the company of world-renowned photographers. It was all very glamorous and showy. Jennifer mastered the part, but that does not mean she loved to play the role. I always imaged Jennifer walking along a stone garden path in a 18th century French Chalet interviewing a pompous blue-blood. She would be unfailingly polite and did her homework knowing the pedigree and building history. She would ask the perfect question that would satisfy the ego while gleaning valuable information. But all the while I imagine her replaying in her mind that Dorthy Parker quote: “If you want to know what God thinks of money, just look at the people he gave it to.” Jennifer didn’t hate the rich, but I believe she felt she had a front row seat to missed opportunities to uphold the truths she ALWAYS held dear.</p><p>Behind the prim and proper lady from Greenwich was a subversive who knew the golden rule and had real respect for those who sought to make the world a more equitable, beautiful place. Those who had more should do more. Choosing to simply feather your nest was, quite simply, a waste, despite the finery. Life is about community and respect. She’d NEVER preach or scold. She lived by example.</p><p>I always felt that her neighborhood in Manhattan reflected her wonderful ability to travel in different circles. She lived in a building that was on the cusp of Sutton Place, Midtown and the Upper East Side. It was near the entrance to the 59th Street Bridge, the gateway to the outer-boroughs, which was where her boyfriend at the time lived. He happened to be my film partner. We had graduated to Long Island City after doing time in Manhattan’s flower district at the height of the crack epidemic. Jennifer used to visit and I always remember her un-phased demeanor. Walking on 28th street at night was a slice of long vanished 80s NYC. You would encounter the homeless families from the Welfare Hotels, the street-walkers who lived in those same grim buildings, the crack dealers, the gay bathhouse crowd and the ever-present wholesale florists and Korean businessmen who had storefronts that sold various hats, shirts and trinkets . The small deli featured “loosies”, single cigarettes, and while online you would be badgered by people trying to bargain their food stamps for cash. Jennifer treated everyone with the same attention and politeness she would extend to her subjects in her work at Town and Country.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kp7yMv7opM--Utj3HmywEg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jennifer’s old stomping ground</figcaption></figure><p>Over the years I was with Jennifer in many different settings and she was unflaggingly put-together and immaculate. Attending a Fifth Ave cocktail party, watching a floor show at a Russian mob restaurant in Brighton Beach Brooklyn, sunbathing on Georgica Beach in East Hampton, standing the graffiti covered subway cars….. Jennifer’s wonderful sense of style only enhanced the surroundings. I have a memory of siting with her at an Italian Restaurant on 4th Ave when none other than John Gotti himself, yes that John Gotti, walked past the table in one his famous dapper don suits. Jennifer didn’t flinch. She simply smiled and laughed. That freeze frame tableau of the rakish villain and polite society- lady sticks in my head. Except this Jennifer, unlike many of her compatriots in Greenwich, understood that the forefathers of the ruling class bear a stronger resemblance to Mr. Gotti than the polished, polite members of the Metropolitan Club.</p><p>Jennifer was an expert on New York ruling class social world. She could have written the dialogue in the Mad Men episode where the boss explains why a troublesome employee, from a NY blue-blood family, can’t be fired:</p><p><em>I don’t want Dorthy Dyckman Cambell standing on the dock at Fisher’s Island this summer talking about how badly Sterling Cooper treated her son. We lose him, we lose our entree to Buckley, Deke (DKE), The Maidstone Club, The Century Club, Dartmouth…. Gracie Mansion sometimes… it’s a marque issue for us.</em></p><p>Knowing the rules of the game meant seeing, first hand, the racism and classism of those in power. Tribalism runs deep. People in Fairfield County often say, with pointed antisemitism, “you must be from the city”, just as residents of Manhattan tag someone or someplace as very “bridge and tunnel”. There are dividing lines and an unspoken competition for mammon. Even the most privileged are not immune from the hidden savagery. One of Jennifer’s first boyfriends was the scion of a prominent “old money” family. His younger brother, a kind and gentle soul and grade-school classmate, was the first friend I knew to take their own life. Attributes such as empathy and compassion are not as prized as fierceness and dominance. Jennifer’s facade appeared as a preppy lady from Greenwich, who wrote puff pieces about the WASP establishment. In reality she was part of a different tribe, and to boot she dated a guy living in Queens whose day job was shooting film for a private investigator.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f91PY8Ou2hRDB_C9Z4SSww.jpeg" /><figcaption>Josie watching carefully</figcaption></figure><p>Jennifer and I were mutually gobsmacked when, after two decades of not being in touch, we ran into each other on Main Street in Montpelier:. What are YOU doing HERE?! Then she gave me her email address that featured the word “sylvan”…. WHAT? You have a DOG? In retrospect it should not have been a surprise. We were twinned in being consummate city-folk, with our fluency in the social mores of our birth-world, but a profound uneasiness about our assigned roles. It didn’t help that we both shared difficult mothers. Our travels might be seen as spiritually akin to that of a certain Beat Gernation icon. Allen Ginsberg escaped the seemingly placid New Jersey suburbs to the comfortable tumult of San Francisco and New York, where he thrived. We shared that burning desire to break from the familiar skyscraper routine and ended taking refuge in the Green Mountains. Vermont is a place where you actually know the families whose names grace the roads. A place where nature and animals are prized and ubiquitous. A place where you feel your own impact on the surroundings. A place where celebrity &amp; power are accorded less standing than being a good neighbor. A place where winter is still… winter.</p><p>Jennifer was, of course, a flatlander, but she had found home. Always one to be professional and prepared she earned a degree in environmentalism. Jennifer cleverly combined her studies with her vast knowledge of the ruling class. She became a fundraiser for the Nature Conservancy but that didn’t keep her away from the nitty-gritty of being involved in hands-on solutions to actual problems. In my work on the local Selectboard I would use her as a resource to find the contacts for various environmental challenges. She always knew the name and department of the person in charge. Her work came home and was home. I remember her speaking to me passionately about invasive species, flooding, the changing forest and her beloved dogs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jLcroe4LGEaPEqoQhGVNmA.jpeg" /><figcaption>shower curtain in the new house</figcaption></figure><p>No one could have had a better guardian than Jennifer. I remember the meticulous care which included a supervised diet of raw meat and intravenous fluids for Josie, who had a kidney problem. Jennifer was also an amazing resource in terms of finding value in products. I noted the exorbitant cost of raw dog food and she tipped me off to a way of buying chicken-back in bulk from the processor. This involved repackaging into smaller baggies, no small feat as raw chicken can be dangerous to handle. She showed me her process, which involved bleach and rubber gloves. Did I mention that Jennifer was obsessively detail oriented? :)</p><p>Her social life also flourished in the new surroundings. Jennifer always had a posse of real friend but, it is in Vermont where she found the love of her life, Paul. Jennifer wrote to me shortly before her passing about throwing her arms around him as he finished one of his runs. I can’t remember the specific words but it brought to mind that line in the a song that was popular in our youth, Never Gonna Give Ya Up: <em>I found what the world is searching for, here, right here my dear, I don’t have to look no more</em>. Together they built something eternal… and I’m not just speaking about their eco-friendly house in the woods. They were a real team. When I think about what it means to have a partner… that delicate balance of respect, dedication, trust and perseverance….. Paul and Jennifer set the bar high. They were formally married for a little over a year but it brought many lifetimes of joy to them and everyone around.</p><p>I have had friends pass, but not since the death of my grade-school classmate, Jennifer’s ex-boyfriend’s brother, has it felt so unjust. Obviously explanations are in the realm beyond this world. It cannot make sense otherwise. But I take comfort in the warmth I felt in seeing her on her deathbed. It was only two days till the end and she looked radiant with a strong grip. She never lost her sense of grace. In that brief encounter we talked of old friends, past times. Without the support of my spouse I would not have been able to retain my composure. I spoke many times before the visit about Jennifer’s ability to endure the unspeakable without complaint or self-pity. It was the least I could do not to go to pieces. I stand strong with the hordes of CT friends, NYC friends, Vermont friends and seek to give support and comfort…. Just as she did to me in many difficult times over the years. I think I mentioned that she saved my dog’s life.</p><p>I was heartbroken when my dog wasn’t responding to traditional veterinary treatment. Jennifer had a plan. She put my in touch with a doctor who combined Eastern and Western approaches to medicine. At the time he wasn’t taking new patients but… Jennifer always had the kind of standing that opened doors. That was a couple of years ago. He is strong. You saved him Jennifer. Thank you. Thank you for everything.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*peonnJzjaovlBjRKnUQBjw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Paul &amp; Jennifer at environmental event</figcaption></figure><p>I don’t know who I’m going to call to ask advice on environmental remediation measures or why Fire Island’s Point O’Woods is so exclusive or the best place to buy incontinence blankets for the dogs or the difference between the Union Club and the Union League Club. But I know you were the master of adaptation. Who else has been born &amp; raised in a suburb, came of age in a city and made a life in the country? All this with such elan and in every new neighborhood winning the respect of the most cherished group of people: those you respect. We take inspiration in knowing you will thrive in the new undiscovered country and give us quiet guidance as we comfort each other in our current state of shock.</p><p>You never were one for formal religion or verse poetry. Talk like this would have made you roll your eyes. But bare with me I as I bring up Shakespeare’s Sonnet #30. The English may be old, but the message isn’t. It is a timely reminder of one of her most comforting attributes in this time of mourning. It speaks to Jennifer’s ability to pull people out of the emotional ruts of regret, sulking and self-pity.</p><p><em>When to the sessions of sweet silent thought</em></p><p><em>I summon up remembrance of things past,</em></p><p><em>I sigh the lack of many a thing I sought,</em></p><p><em>And with old woes new wail my dear time’s waste:</em></p><p><em>Then can I drown an eye, unus’d to flow,</em></p><p><em>For precious friends hid in death’s dateless night,</em></p><p><em>And weep afresh love’s long since cancell’d woe,</em></p><p><em>And moan th’ expense of many a vanish’d sight;</em></p><p><em>Then can I grieve at grievances foregone,</em></p><p><em>And heavily from woe to woe tell o’er</em></p><p><em>The sad account of fore-bemoaned moan,</em></p><p><em>Which I new pay as if not paid before.</em></p><p><em>But if the while I think on thee, dear friend,</em></p><p><em>All losses are restor’d, and sorrows end.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*n5QXxCKMJ2NCCwuSO4HzSQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Jennifer had the soothing presence and knew the right gesture or word. I contacted a mutual friend from the NY days who had not seen you in four decades. She wrote the following to her which I relayed but want all to hear:</p><p><em>I had just arrived in NY, right after Francois’ accident, lost in youth and sadness and you were there, an angel, lovely detail after detail you dropped off magazines, you gave me a copy of Eloise (at the Plaza) which I still have.</em></p><p>This brings to mind the time when the NY Post astrologer Patric Walker passed away sending most of the city into a panic :). Jennifer called me to break the news and offered calm. Message to Jennifer: Say HI to Patric &amp; Francois I’m not sure if you’ll run into Mr. Gotti, as I think he might be in a different place, but if you do I’m sure you’ll know what to say…. You always did.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CHXVg-fmaNr10WL5zl7hdA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e2ab7d1ee955" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[REBEL YELL/ PLAINTIVE CRY: Reflections on ‘Rich Men North of Richmond’]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/rebel-yell-plaintive-cry-reflections-on-rich-men-north-of-richmond-4abd3f5ba5f1?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4abd3f5ba5f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[woke]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oliver-anthony]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tribalism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Aug 2023 13:09:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-22T17:06:06.532Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VA8G9O7lBDxwN-J2hreznQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Let this song I’m singing be a warnin’. When you’re runnin’ down my country, man you’re walkin’ on the fightin’ side of me</em> — <strong>Merle Haggard, The Fightin’ Side of Me</strong></p><p><em>as I went walking I saw a sign there, and the sign said “No Trespassing.” but on the other side it didn’t say nothing. That side was made for you and me </em><strong>— Woody Guthrie, This Land Is Made for You and Me</strong></p><p><em>Meanwhile back at home the finance company took his car. Just another poor boy off to fight a rich man’s war </em><strong>— Steve Earle, Rich Man’s War</strong></p><p><strong><em>Splitting</em></strong><em> (also called </em><strong><em>black-and-white thinking</em></strong><em>, </em><strong><em>thinking in extremes</em></strong><em> or </em><strong><em>all-or-nothing thinking</em></strong><em>) is the failure in a person’s thinking to bring together the dichotomy of both perceived positive and negative qualities of something into a cohesive, realistic whole. It is a common defense mechanism wherein the individual tends to think in extremes (e.g., an individual’s actions and motivations are all good or all bad with no middle ground). This kind of dichotomous interpretation is contrasted by an acknowledgement of certain nuances known as “shades of gray”. — </em><strong>Wikipedia Definition of the Psychological term ‘Splitting’</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8VzbgFYfwYPMuHinYmO70g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Oliver Anthony can strike a cord, musically and emotionally. He has come from nowhere to captivate the internet with well over twenty million views in less than two weeks with his acoustic guitar ballad, ”Rich Men North of Richmond”. Many on the left have excoriated the work and linked it with another summer culture-war anthem, Jason Aldean’s “Try That in A Small Town.<strong>” </strong>Both songs channel anger triggered by rural people feeling they have been ignored by the ruling class, which they see as ‘liberal’ and out of touch with their values. Anthony, however, has a genuine grass roots feeling, whereas Aldean is the product of music industry executives cashing in on a specific kind of rage. Anthony doesn’t rely on a team of songwriters and the publicity department of a major label. In fact this is what he said to Billboard Magazine:</p><p><em>“I don’t want to be in the spotlight. I wrote the music I wrote because I was suffering with mental health and depression.People in the music industry give me blank stares when I brush off 8 million dollar offers. I don’t want 6 tour buses, 15 tractor trailers and a jet. I don’t want to play stadium shows”</em></p><p>One can only imagine the despair of the music executives. They are standing in front of a Scots-Irish Appalachian Elvis and he wants to talk values, instead of money. Who is this guy with a wavy red beard, mountain good-looks and a voice channeling a male version of Janis’ scream? It turns out that the singer’s full name is Christopher Anthony Lunsford. His stage name derives from honoring his Appalachian grandfather, who lived a hard luck life, working numerous jobs after earning a GED. Whatever the veracity of Mr. Anthony’s claims, which I believe to be true, his work stands on its own and should be closely watched by those on both the left and right. The open &amp; closing stanzas tells a dispiriting truth felt in both urban ghettos on the coast and small towns in Appalachia:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ICN0KvHs8dkPCu0Y0iAALA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>I’ve been selling’ my soul, workin’ all day Overtime hours for bullshit pay</em></p><p>It is unfortunate that culture warriors focus on the bogeymen and not the overall message. Mr. Anthony puts forth the familiar tropes that are the reason for all the problems: the government, pedophile billionaires and underclass people receiving welfare. He feels the biggest problem is Rich men north of Richmond. For those unfamiliar with civil war history Richmond was the capital of the Confederacy. Obviously this somewhat subtle homage to the good ole antebellum era is disconcerting. The lyric about the morbidly obese welfare receipt is also unsettling. Both references are the type of non-starter message that pushes listeners into their respective corners of the political divide. The echo of states rights and the glorification of the Jim Crow South is a widely used device in many conservative circles. Ronald Reagan opened his campaign in Philadelphia Mississippi and spoke about, “states right.” The former President also used the term “welfare queen”, an effective political dog whistle for those skeptical of those on public assistance. Anthony recycles standard red meat of the conservatives, but he also breaks new ground. He talks about the overall system. The bottom line: America is no longer the land of opportunity for average people.</p><p>It would be very easy for both sides to seize on Anthony’s hot button rhetoric to prove their own perspectives. But it is important to recognize the opening and closing lines about selling your soul for bullshit pay. Those words go beyond the left right divide. That sort of lyric would fit into a Woody Guthrie ballad. There is also the reference to the Clinton-friend, Trump-neighbor, Jeffrey Epstein, whose sins span the political spectrum. The billionaire pedophile was a certified member of the ruling class who could call upon favors by a prominent Harvard Law professor, titans of the business world and political heavy hitters. Those rich men north of Richmond work for richer men who haunt the background. Mr. Anthony’s anthem identifies the injustice, but strays from the set script about who is to blame. There is the familiar government scapegoat combined with the feckless parasites that take advantage of a corrupt system… but there is also the feeling of marginalization DUE TO THAT SYSTEM. He is screaming, literally, “I work at a bullshit job for no pay. WHO IS TO BLAME?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gSKI3d6XHSKMHcxpYNngcA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Everyone who engages in modern American life knows the gangsterism of major corporations when managing communications, banking, online accounts, cable, energy…. No one is spared the endless wait times and never-ending unresolved issues often triggered by the company’s own mistakes. We can all agree the current power structure is invasive and terrifying. Regulators are asleep at the switch and, with the flip of a switch, your life will become chaotic and the entities will not be sanctioned. How many people do you know who have, due to no fault of their own, their credit or communications or reputation hurt by actions of large corporations? In Anthony’s telling:</p><p><em>Lord knows they all just wanna have total control, wanna know what you think, wanna know what you do ’cause your dollar ain’t shit and it’s taxed to no end… CAUSE OF RICH MEN NORTH OF RICHMOND </em>(my emphasis)</p><p>Unfortunately this is a half truth. As Anthony states, politicians in DC are at fault. Fair enough, but who is really behind the push to allow our privacy and financial security to be up for grabs? The answer to that question lies in who benefits. There are powerful interests who back the straw men in Washington. Anthony focuses on the government. The next line hints at the man metaphorically behind the curtain:</p><p><em>I wish politicians would look out for miners and not just minors on an island somewhere.</em></p><p>This reference to the symbol of ruling class greed, speaks to a larger truth that Anthony, for all his passion, never addresses head on. There are immensely rich, powerful people, behind the scenes, who bend the system to their own personal ends. Regular order does not apply to them. Rather than develop that line of thinking, Anthony sticks to the right’s favorite whipping boy, the government. His outrage is selective as it extends exclusively to those holding office and the most vulnerable poor, rather than those who buy their services and profit the most.</p><p>His assessment of the government’s failure to address poverty extends this strange tendency to shoot at the wrong target. In this case it is both naive and mean.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h_vWgqtk5VrhA4IbWz_LnA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Lord, we got folks in the street, ain’t got nothin’ to eat</em></p><p><em>And the obese milkin’ welfare</em></p><p><em>Well, God, if you’re 5-foot-3 and you’re 300 pounds</em></p><p><em>Taxes ought not to pay for your bags of fudge rounds</em></p><p><em>Young men are puttin’ themselves six feet in the ground</em></p><p><em>’Cause all this damn country does is keep on kickin’ them down</em></p><p>Certainly there are people who cheat social assistance programs, but how does that measure in the larger system? In a country that has a beleaguered primary school system, little basic regulation protecting consumer’s privacy, basic health care that is out of reach for many, a codified taxation code that has corporations and the wealthy individuals paying a MUCH lower share of their income; not to mention a higher education system that puts many into indentured servitude while ensuring banks and universities are indemnified — is the short 300 lb person on the dole the primary problem? This point of view certainly props up the “us vs. them, black and white, all good-all bad” paradigm which has allowed the Rich Men North of Richmond to ignore solutions that might alleviate everyone’s suffering. A great example would be the regulation of drug pricing. Is there a sentient being in the world who thinks American government policy is fair to anyone, except those entrenched entities that gouge the sick at will?</p><p>In the social media age, brought to us by Zuckerberg, Dorsey, etc, cruelty has been completely unchained and overt piggery is no longer a cause for shame. In today’s news I read about groups of tourists snorkeling off the beach while Hawaiian families searched for their loved ones after the devastating wildfire. Is it any wonder, if this is the general tenor of things, that the Supreme Court needs to rule on whether the Sackler family should be allowed to retain billions of dollars they “earned” by creating the opioid crisis? Is it any wonder that Harvard University, with a $53 billion endowment, openly encourages its own graduate students to apply for food stamps? Walmart and McDonalds also have thousands of workers receiving help from this government program. These systematic examples are excluded in Mr. Anthony’s justifiable outrage against powerful interests working against working people. The problem is that speaking too clearly and plainly about fundamental flaws in the system goes against the orthodoxy of his tribe. If you take the bogeyman of government out of the bullshit pay equation, you start drifting against an orthodoxy of free market solutions. Despite the artful portrayals of corrupt politicians and fat lazy welfare recipients, one senses Mr. Anthony knows the problems are really institutional. To paraphrase his own lyrics: he don’t think he knows, but he knows that he does. The song has a broadness that suggests it wants to break free of the low earth orbit of ideological set piece villains.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mMmvGlVTYjX5OWSfPhNMBw.jpeg" /></figure><p>It would be unkind and thoughtless to mock Mr. Anthony’s pain and the hurt that many in his community feel. It is easy to seize on his tone deaf reference to the Confederacy and dismiss his simplistic scapegoating. But he is pointing out real systemic problems. The irony is that any gap that currently exists between the 300 lb welfare receipt, the working stiff, the man in the gray flannel suit, blue collar, white collar, college instructor… are all being swept away by the brave new world of AI and automation… We are all old souls in a brave new world. I would have appreciated seeing Mr. Anthony on the late night shows… but they’re on strike due to corporate greed via AI threatening their livelihood. Meanwhile two ruling class titans, Mr. Musk and Mr. Zuckerberg, debate on whether they should engage in a physical cage fight against each other. They have assured us the proceeds would go to charity…. To quote Mr. Anthony:</p><p><em>It’s a damn shame what the world’s gotten to</em></p><p><em>For people like me and people like you</em></p><p><em>Wish I could just wake up and it not be true</em></p><p><em>But it is, oh, it is</em></p><p>In the end who is to blame for Mr. Anthony working long hours for bullshit pay? Elon Musk and Red Bear have a similar point of view. Regulation, safeguards, restraints, are the source of all our ills. “Sink or swim” will save us. In reality it will save Mr. Musk, not Mr. Anthony. Fat cats love it when regular people fight amongst themselves: HEY FATTY, TRY THAT IN A SMALL TOWN! I can feel them laughing… all the way to the bank. When they fight each other, it’s just for fun. When Mr. Anthony, and most others, struggle, they pay a real price. They sink. That’s the way the system works.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4abd3f5ba5f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The New Barbie Outfit]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/the-new-barbie-outfit-91254d9cb6be?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/91254d9cb6be</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[barbie]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[barbie-movies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 07 Aug 2023 13:30:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-08-07T13:30:24.716Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Review of the film Barbie</p><p>“Fuck the patriarchy”</p><ul><li><strong>Taylor Swift, extended version of ‘All Too Well’</strong></li></ul><p>“She’s everything. He’s just Ken”</p><ul><li><strong>Tag line for Barbie Movie</strong></li></ul><p>“Peace in patriarchy is war against women”</p><ul><li><strong>Maria Miles</strong></li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kaZJecoO4n1LanLi3eKSpw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Barbie has been a strange tabula rasa since its creation in 1959. It was based on a German doll sold as a gag-gift to mostly men in European tobacco shops. One can only imagine the role play ideas for the original crowd. The American redesign was crafted by an aerospace engineer who worked on American military missiles. He also had been the sixth husband of actress Zsa Zsa Gabor and he died by suicide… this isn’t covered in the film. The force behind Barbie’s creation was Ruth Handler, who named the doll, and her companion Ken, after her children. The sibling roots of their namesakes were also not covered in the film. Ruth’s forced resignation from the parent toy company, Mattel, was mentioned, but financial fraud is not something you want to dwell on… which brings us to the strange questions surrounding the storyline of a <strong><em>Barbie</em></strong> movie. What to talk about?</p><p>Ms. Gerwig &amp; Mr. Baumbach are art house sensations. How do the creator of <strong><em>Lady Bird</em></strong>, a film showcasing the struggles of girls in 21st century America and the co-creators of <strong><em>Frances Ha</em></strong>, a movie showcasing a struggling woman artist, keep their credibility? They will be making what is essentially a product placement film for Mattel, “the leading toy company &amp; owner of one of the strongest portfolios of children’s and family entertainment franchises in the world”. The boilerplate from Mattel’s website reads like fodder for corporate shills, rather than respected artists. And then there is the doll itself… yes Barbie has “evolved,” eschewing the pre-civil rights, <em>Mad Men</em> world of her birth by embracing careers et al. But does any woman, aside from the mentally ill , want to be Barbie? Isn’t the name itself still a pejorative term for any female over the age of 14? How on earth can Ms. Gerwig create a film that won’t end in career suicide or corporate disaster? Talk about building tension!</p><p>Well they did it… sort of. The film is a smash hit. Warner Brothers is making bank. Mattel’s girl is on everyone’s lips and audiences are stampeding, many in pink, to the theaters. There are some humorless cranks who are offended, but this only adds to cache. Ms. Gerwig and Mr. Baumbach worked very hard… and you feel it. That’s the problem. The sweat of pleasing the many interested parties produces an extremely clever film… but not a good one.</p><p>Things begin very well.<strong><em> Barbie</em></strong> parodies the paradigm cinema moment of man’s achievement from Kubrick’s <strong><em>2001</em></strong>. Instead of the bone morphing into a space station, Barbie the astronaut floats above the world,. As we enter Barbieland, the portrait of this pink plastic paradise is… pitch perfect. Margot Robbie is a superb incarnation of the “stereotypical ” Barbie, with her trademark blonde locks. Sharing the synthetic aryan look is Ryan Gosling as the paradigm Ken. Both these characters are individuals, but they exist in a world of types. In other words Barbieland is ruled by the Barbies, plural, with a cast of supporting Kens (plural). Gosling’s Ken rival is an Asian “Ken”. They both exist to attract the attention of the Margo Robie . The weird and wonderful land feels as if the <strong><em>Wizard of Oz</em></strong>’s Emerald City was dropped on the beaches of Malibu.</p><p>There is a strange conceit that gives this world the simulacrum of an actual child’s play area. All liquids are hard or invisible. Imagine a little girl giving Barbie a “pretend” drink and you witness what it is like for stereotype Barbie to sip coffee in the morning. Ken tries to “surf” the ocean and is blocked by hard plastic water . The playfulness and slick recreations are marvelous. Sadly the tone of the film shifts and we enter a very convoluted drama that relies on Barbie having an existential crisis, interacting with the “real world”and confronting, for the first time, the dreaded PATRIARCHY.</p><p>Ken, played delightfully by Ryan Gosling, is the foil in the story, but this never quite works because he is, by definition, a subservient dolt. One can feel the screenplay writers bending over backwards to give this professional idiot some standing. Are we really to believe that upon entering the real world Ken goes to a library to read about patriarchy? The gags regarding male arrogance and macho foolishness are hysterically funny, but in the end there is a narrative pull for Barbie to say that things will change in Barbieland in terms of Ken. She feels she has taken him for granted. Ken can stand tall. Ummmm…. No. I’m sure of few things in life but one might be: no one will ever buy a Ken doll without him being subservient to Barbie… The movie forces a very adult notion that fails to mesh with child’s play. It’s never a good thing when kids are forced to act as if they are adults. It doesn’t work dramatically either.</p><p>This film is strongest when it simply plays, rather than preaches. The tone instead resembles that of the social satire of <em>Citizen Ruth</em>, a film poking fun at both sides of the abortion debate. It would seem more appropriate, given that subject matter is a doll designed for pre teen girls, if the film had the spirit of a lighthearted musical comedy, like <strong><em>Mamma Mia</em></strong>, or issue-less satire, like the original <strong><em>Batman</em></strong> TV Series. In both cases fun is paramount while concerns about messaging take a back seat. Obviously this is a tall order given Barbie’s odd place in the social order. As I write this a news story broke about a sports commentator who was fired for using the term “Barbie” to describe another reporter. How could the writer/director avoid making our heroine more than a… Barbie doll. Strangely this also forces the issue of Ken’s status a professional flunky. In the world of Barbie… who cares? but the real world has real cultural baggage. And how to manage the baggage-handler?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2dxRMNK3Py1fIRFxn0a7GQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Whereas Ken is a miscast delightful character, Will Ferrell, the CEO of Mattel in the “real world,” and his male Mattel minions, are simply a drag. Their role as clownish, corporate villains is muddled. Their cartoonishness belongs in Barbieland, rather than the “real world”. Kudos to the real Mattel executives for green-lighting the project. Certainly the filmmakers pushed the limit in directing jokes at the corporation. They are openly marked as chauvinistic with Barbie’s outfits being dictated by taking advantage of social changes, rather than championing women. The real life suits are now laughing all the way to the bank, but had <strong><em>Barbie</em></strong> laid an egg, they might have lost their jobs. There’s some real drama.</p><p>As for Gerwig and Baumbach, their creation might not be an artistic triumph, but has been genuine gold for the bottom line. The blatant errors are there and go beyond the odd storyline and the portrayal of the corporation. Does this film need to be 2 hours long? That’s the same length as the the bio pic of Alan Turing, and he invented computers. And what are we to make of Michael Cera as Allan? Mattel never really knew what to do with Ken’s brief sidekick and neither does Gerwig. Then there was an odd technical matter. This is a first rate spectacle with the fantasyland brimming with state-of-the-art props and special effects. There is a divine smoothness to the fakery — the houses, the ocean, the campfires. These are moving dioramas that are really captivating. I felt like a child pushing my nose against the glass in the Museum of Natural History. I also wanted to jump in during the choreography of Ken’s ridiculous battle where weapons never hurt… and despite all this I felt the character’s faces to be under-lit in many of the scenes. It is as if the basics were ignored in order to spend artistic energy on complicated social satire.</p><p>Perhaps there would have been more gold for everyone if the film stuck to Barbieland and eschewed reality and its never-ending source of conflict. This fantasy world already had its strange corner of intrigue: the character, “Weird Barbie”, played by the brilliant comedic actress Kate McKinnon. She represented dolls that were mistreated by their guardians. Interestingly when Barbie is faced with thoughts of death, the other Barbies point her to “Weird Barbie”. It seems not all little girls have wholesome role-play fantasies with dolls. In some cases Barbie becomes a whipping post for anger and aggression. It is interesting to note that McKinnon is often splayed on the floor, as if being nearly torn apart is “natural”. Once again there is no need for this film to plumb the depths of all social ills, but it is interesting that the filmmakers felt the need to go outside. Perhaps they were channeling the Wizard of Oz’s use of a separate plane of fantasy. The failure of Barbie is that the split between Barbieland and “the real world” is cloudy and confusing. There is no neat black and white vs. color delineation that showcases the clear line between the drudgery of real world cruelty and the joy of escapist fantasy. Would Barbie, while experiencing Los Angeles, ever want to click her heels three times and return to Barbieland? It’s a complicated question and that’s a problem. Why not simplify everything? There is enough drama “in house” to shape a story about Barbie facing her demons. The arc of the plot, however, needs to be rooted in the anodyne innocence of playfulness, rather than the meanness of adults.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4SfrN7Tk0ua3HAHSEFav5Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>I might be the wrong demographic to comment on this movie but I did find the most profound aspect of the film lay in the audience’s laughter. In my years of going to movie theaters I have never heard so many older women guffawing. This film touches something, despite what I perceive as a strangely muddled script. I never played with Barbie dolls and maybe to get the overall joke, you need to really live that experience. I felt this modern take on the meaning of Barbie fell short… too much stereotypical Barbie, not enough Weird Barbie… too much real world, not enough Barbieland…. Too much talk, not enough dancing…. Too much figuring out, not enough enjoying the moment.… but maybe I’m just another Ken, without the looks; or worse yet… an exploitative male Mattel executive. But in the end Gerwig’s work has grossed over a billion dollars. At present she is at the top of the pecking order of ALL Hollywood directors… including the Kens. For that, everyone can thank… Barbie.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=91254d9cb6be" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Review of Tar (2022)]]></title>
            <link>https://hihoau.medium.com/review-of-tar-2022-c3709306ad5c?source=rss-7b063dbd05f6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c3709306ad5c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[movie-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tár]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cate-blanchett]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[bram towbin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 Feb 2023 20:05:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-26T20:05:13.659Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Requiem for a Maestro</strong></p><p>“In music one doesn’t make the end of the composition the point of the composition. If that were so, the best conductors would be those who played fastest. ”</p><p><strong><em>Alan Watts, commenting on purposelessness</em></strong></p><p>“This will be our reply to violence: to make music more intensely, more beautifully, more devotedly than ever before.”</p><p><strong><em>Leonard Bernstein</em></strong></p><p>“Here’s to the battle, whatever it’s for.”</p><p><strong><em>Winners, song by Joe Raposo</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mo2LjHv-hTHniawugXnD9A.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the masterful documentary about the pianist Glen Gould, <em>32 Short Films About Glen Gould</em>, the filmmakers never once showed him playing the piano. This disagreeable misanthrope shines despite never being seen tickling the ivories. This is how the writer/director Todd Field might have conceived of portraying the classical music virtuoso in his feature, <em>Tar</em>. Her story is the the off-key song of life, not the beautiful sounds of the orchestra. Sadly the breath her virtuosity matched her abhorrence as a character. The film needed less music, more art.</p><p>Would a person, who violently attacks a rival conductor on stage in front of an audience, react quietly to being banished from seeing their beloved child by an angry spouse? Imagine if Dickens decided to have Ebenezer Scrooge focus on improving his business practices rather than saving Tiny Tim. It is a tribute to the artistry of Todd Field, Cate Blanchett and an ensemble of pros that, despite the flaws, there is no hiding superb craftsmanship. This feature falls in the “uncanny valley” of greatness, having all the appearances of being sublime, but lacking the essential element of, attraction. The critics have been merciless, one going so far as to use the word “Tar-ible” in the title of her review. There have been some Oscar nominations but the project has lost Universal Pictures $50 million to date. Financial failure and critical scorn is not surprising given the film’s premise.</p><p>In an era where audience’s focus has been shaped by Tik Tok’s 3 minute limit, Mr. Field created a nearly 3 hour feature about: a classical music maestro; or as some would say maestra. Whatever quips one has with the final version, it is important to give a nod to the audacity of completing this project. No doubt there were a chorus of pre-production executives texting one another fire breathing emojis or simply…“WTF?” Given the films reception these have morphed into laughing smiley faces celebrating the downfall of the colleagues who gave the green light. But if you think feature film making is Machiavellian, wait until the curtain unveils the world of classical music. <em>Tar</em> isn’t so much a meditation on art as a portrait of a gangster. One associates such people with money and crime but the real mobsters show their colors when everything centers on prestige, not mammon.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cTrtE9_-hlWD0p8QVW4Nxg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Cate Blanchett is the protagonist, Linda Tar, a girl from a cultural nether region of a blue collar, Long Island suburb. Her first move is to drop her first name for the more exotic “Lydia”. The film is a view of her journey to the apex of the, male dominated, classical music world…. Field tracks our heroine as she stalks the cultural landscape. At the New Yorker Festival Tar’s assistant polishes her charge and mouths the words as the the real-life Adam Gopnik reads the bio from of Lydia’s latest book. The audience coos at the endless list of formidable accomplishments. Lydia has the sang-froid of a K-pop boy-band making a public appearance. She is flawlessly hitting her marks and giving NYers exactly what is expected. She also radiates contempt for her assistant whose life is eternally bonded to the master, think of Tom Courtenay in <em>The Dresser</em>.</p><p>After an interminable title sequence, the first image is our anti-hero getting ready to take the stage. Field rejects instantaneous clear meaning. Most mainstream features avoid pauses. Field gives Lydia life though the inaction of alone-time. Field’s character delineation relies on gesture and mood, more than the spoken word. Add to this unconventional presentation the use of obscure cutaways which build a sense of wonder. Who is changing Lydia’s Wikipedia profile? Who is spying and mocking Lydia via Instant Messenger? All this blurriness tends to collide with the ham-handed use of interviews and dinner conversation to move the exposition forward. The bloated backstory is too heavy a lift for the writer/director.</p><p>The words are the scaffolding that unpacks the complicated intrigue. Lydia is bringing a noted piece of Gustav Mahler’s work to life in a specially produced recording based on a live performance at Berlin’s most prestigious concert hall. The choice of Mahler underscores her connection the legendary New York classical wunderkind Leonard Bernstein, who was her original mentor/inspiration. The concert coincides with a book release, which is the basis of the New Yorker interview. Blanchett’s character devolves, as her life decomposes. The performative, self-assured, superstar morphs into the strident, defensive, crank. The expository dialogue slows as we see our heroine do battle with her family, colleagues, landlords, lovers, neighbors…. The film is precise, but a grind. Audience members might want to yell the old Led Zepplin line to the maestro and her writer/director: “does anyone remember laughter?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oiQC5FjFVjOeBQQyxq-oKg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Both Blanchett and Field strangely fall into the same deadening trap as Lydia. The protagonist, the filmmaker and the actress are brimming with talent. There is a parallel between Tar’s self-destruction and the film’s excruciating documentation of the downfall. They were both avoidable. Lydia stage-manages her fall by, needlessly, scorning those with the ability to destroy her career. Her backstabbing cleverness falls prey to seemingly wanton cruelty fueled by blinding narcissism. It didn’t have to happen, even for the meanest of the mean girls. A touch of restraint combined with a kind word every now and then and her demise would have been averted. The monster would pass as a lovable hero, except only to the most intimate and the post mortem biographer. The director and Blanchett are equally blind to a conceit that seems so elemental as to be the first lesson for those interested in drama: the audience must care. Tar is a humorless, self obsessed, mean-spirited bore. It’s not impossible to win the audience over to cheer-on the monster…. But you have to try. This film is an unvarnished procedural, rather than an empathetic portrait of a troubled individual.</p><p>The Lydia of the first fifth of the film has a profession-obsessed weariness that repulses even the most ardent admirers of an anti-hero. The New Yorker interview sequence and the following meetings and diners with classical music insiders buttress her credentials as a genuine expert. Everything is… pitch perfect. Everything except the director’s ability to create empathy for this narcissist superstar. The memorable performance is accurate, but undesirable. Why would students passionately climb into bed with her; or executives trip over themselves to spend any time with her? Her exquisite taste and command of music never matches her supposed elan. She is the mirror image of her universally beloved mentor, Leonard Bernstein. The tragedy of <em>Tar</em> is that, despite the phenomenal craftsman of these immensely talented artists, the denouement leads to the strange emptiness at the heart of those poor soul’s afflicted by personality disorders. The point is for the audience to care for this person who doesn’t care. Instead we have a superb clinical portrait of a sociopath.</p><p>Strangely there is one relationship that proves Lydia isn’t completely heartless. Her spouse comments on the fact that the only non-transactional bond she has formed is with their daughter. The unbridled love is illustrated by tender moments and one of the most chilling scenes in the film. Her child is being bullied at school and Lydia channels Tony Soprano in the moment when another mobster propositions his daughter. Lydia doesn’t shatter teeth, but her warning to the classmate is equally chilling; in fact more so, as the maestro simply uses words without even raising her voice. The bully is immediately vanquished and even the most ardent detractor of our anti-hero is happy that the daughter, Petra, will be free of abuse. The actress, Mila Bogojevic, gives a remarkable performance that radiates pathos and warmth. If the audience had felt the same about Tar this would have been a film for the ages.</p><p>The way to artfully hide Lydia’s deficits would be the mask of abstraction. Sadly Field clings to the straightforward chronological narrative. This only serves to place the story in the low earth orbit of Lydia’s zero-sum-game. Fields gives the narrative a rise and fall arc of gleaning lessons from a parable. Weirdly this is the un-nuanced world-view of deluded sociopaths living under the perpetual yoke of striving. Lydia will either win or lose….PERIOD! This might work for comic books but not character studies of complicated people. A careful portrait of a life should reject absolutism in favor of rendering the the infinite small moments that are more ambiguous.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cWzFUN40vQUfHfIGNxagyg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Tar</em> is at its best with the small moments: the tailoring of the suit, the realization of being in a brothel, the mysterious noises, the metronome ticking onward…. There is too much on point proselytizing. The nadir is when she humiliates a student who finds fault with the heroes of the established canon. It seems a contrived set-piece to give commentary on the raging culture wars. Tar, unsurprisingly, champions the established order. The back and forth has a tiresome quality of assigned characters towing the party line. We needed more of Tar’s time in Queens as a child or her genuine interactions with her mentors…. Or even, perhaps, her time with the aboriginals in a South American jungle. These interactions would show vulnerability, rather than gloating. The tragedy isn’t her professional suicide, but her never-ending isolation. The denouement should have been the breakup with her daughter in Berlin, rather than exile as a leader of a cosplay video-game orchestra in a remote Asian backwater. The spectacle of her public downfall is breathtaking but rings hollow compared to the missing crescendo of the emotional cataclysm. The superstar pitcher banished to the grapefruit league is not as compelling as the loving mother who has forever lost her child; or the striver who realizes they have spent a lifetime on a fool’s errand….. think the final scene in <em>Mephisto</em> when the actor realizes he’s playing Faustus NOT Mephistopheles.</p><p>Field and Blanchett seem to be captivated by the pyrotechnics of Lydia on stage. The real drama, however, is in the wings. What makes this film so frustrating is the glimmers of what might have been. There are moments of our anti-hero slides into the gooey, unmotivated…. tenderness. Lydia’s acrobatics, rather than the torment of her diseased soul, are center stage in <em>Tar</em>. The misstep bring to mind The Shakespearian actor Ian McKellen commenting on playing <em>Macbeth</em>. The epiphany came when a fellow actor gave him a small note regarding a famous soliloquy. When playing, “tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow” the emphasis should be on the word “and”, not “tomorrow.” This seemingly incidental direction helped the great thespian unpack the force of the tale “full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.” No doubt it would have been a memorable performance without the insight, but it might only have been “sound and fury.” This is <em>Tar</em>’s fate, to be merely impressive, rather than sublime.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4qa1bQHaP3q8m6yJ45YcHg.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c3709306ad5c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>