<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Hilary Sutcliffe on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Hilary Sutcliffe on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@hilary-4230?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 18:17:21 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@hilary-4230/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Un-addiction the Easyway!]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/un-addiction-the-easyway-bc77bbafbc59?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bc77bbafbc59</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Jan 2024 17:57:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-09T17:57:50.428Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FGv_ERcwx-6clPeZxa1oow.png" /></figure><h4>Un-addiction the Easyway!</h4><p>It seems churlish not to start the New Year the traditional way, with some thoughts on unhooking ourselves from the products that we wish we weren’t quite so dependent on — like vapes, cigarettes, booze, ultra-processed food, gambling, social media or computer games!</p><p>And who better to ask about that than the CEO of the most successful un-addiction company in the world, Allen Carr’s Easyway. They have helped millions of people, sold more than 20 million books, and helped hundreds of thousands of smokers quit via their live seminars — all mainly through word of mouth. The system works so well that live seminars of Allen Carr’s EasyWay to Quit Smoking are now available free to smokers on the NHS.</p><p>Regular readers will know it’s not like me to puff up a commercial company, but today I am making an exception! We first came across their approach when Joe was making his Vaping Dilemma film and wanted to send people somewhere useful and positive if they wanted help to stop. The NHS website only offered guidance for smokers on how to start vaping, so we were very relieved when we discovered The EasyWay to Quit Vaping written by John Dicey and team, based in the unassuming South London suburb of Raynes Park.</p><p>When we read it in full, followed by the EasyWay to Quit Smoking, and saw the stats on their success rates, we were intrigued. Unlike UK government policy which focuses on pharmacological approaches, and even gold standard services like Alcoholics Anonymous which advocate a lifelong commitment, the EasyWay claims to work after just one 6-hour seminar, or for many just one reading of a book. Many celebs are vocal converts, such as actor Antony Hopkins, Businessman Richard Branson, comedian Lee Mack and Newsreader Krishnan Guru-Murthy and if you can’t quit after the seminar, you get your money back!</p><p>We wanted to know, how does this actually work? Dealing with addiction is supposed to be hard and they are making it seem, err, easy!</p><p>We were invited to visit John in Raynes Park and he kindly agreed to this Q&amp;A article to talk us through the process of un-addiction without pharmaceuticals and without a backward glance. We are focusing here on vaping and smoking as that’s our current focus, but they have books and seminars on many other addictions too.</p><p>John, thank you very much for agreeing to talk to me about your special approach to un-addiction. Let’s start with the most obvious question:</p><p><strong><em>How do you manage to have people quit their addictions without a backward glance, when it is supposed to be so hard?</em></strong></p><p>Most addiction programmes focus on willpower — pitting the addict’s will against their compulsion to take the drug. An emphasis is often placed on highlighting the professional, social, relationship, and physical <em>damage</em> caused by the addiction. This is generally counterproductive because it generates guilt, fear, and stress which most addicts respond to by…taking the drug to which they’re addicted. Addicts already know and understand the downsides of their predicament — they don’t need telling again and again. Instead, Allen Carr’s Easyway focuses not on the arguments against taking the drug, but on the other side of the equation, what’s so great about taking it?</p><p>The method dismantles all the individual arguments “for” taking the drug. The addict realises they are a victim of a flawed belief system created and nurtured by the physical and mental process of addiction. If the arguments “for” taking the drug are stripped away — becoming valueless (a process, we call cognitive reconfiguration) then the need for huge amounts of willpower is eradicated, along with the sense of deprivation an addict feels when they pit their willpower against an addiction they don’t understand.</p><p>Easyway effectively helps addicts rewire their own brain — restoring it to its pre-addicted condition. They simply don’t see the value of using the product again.</p><p><strong><em>But nicotine, for example, is supposed to be one of the most addictive substances there is, what about the chemical hook and the withdrawal cravings?</em></strong></p><p>It’s perfectly consistent to say that nicotine is one of the most highly addictive substances on the planet — whilst also maintaining that it can be easy to escape from the addiction…as long as you understand how the addiction works.</p><p>Nicotine’s strength is in the speed with which it hooks its victims, one puff of a cigarette, cigar, or vape is all it can take. Another strength is the subtlety with which it addicts people. The physical withdrawal is so slight, most addicts are not aware that they’re addicted until they attempt to stop and realise that they cannot.</p><p>During the initial, often lengthy period of blissful ignorance, (in advance of the addict’s first quit attempt), they subconsciously begin to believe that nicotine does make them feel better each time they smoke or vape. When they smoke or vape, rather than realising that the slight sense of relief they experience is simply the ending of a barely noticeable, mildly dissatisfied feeling (caused by nicotine withdrawal) they associate the sense of partial relief as adding something to the social occasion, a cup of coffee, a drink in a pub, or the easing of their general stress level. The longer they remain addicted — the more powerful this phoney belief system appears to be.</p><p>The belief system develops every time the addict attempts to quit…they confuse the craving caused by their brain’s flawed belief that they have “given up” something which enhanced every aspect of their lives (an entirely mental process) with the physical withdrawal from nicotine — which remains extremely mild even amongst heavy smokers/vapers.</p><p><strong>So it’s not about whether or not you have enough will power?</strong></p><p>No. When they attempt to quit — most nicotine addicts brace themselves in the hope that they can battle the temptation to smoke or vape — not realising that the driver of the battle is entirely mental. The habit of having a vape as they join friends in a pub, step off a bus or take a break from work can trigger this thought process causing immense discomfort, as can the mild sense of nicotine withdrawal. It’s the mental process that causes physical discomfort — not nicotine withdrawal. Remember the physical discomfort caused by a spoilt child whose toy is suddenly taken away: red face, bulging eyes, high blood pressure, a horrible wailing sound coming out of their mouths!</p><p>Once a nicotine addict understands how their moods, feelings, emotions, and behaviour has been manipulated, mainly by a flawed belief system — and that it is easy to dismantle that belief system — they are left with the mild, barely noticeable feeling of nicotine withdrawal to deal with.</p><p>Every time they experience a moment when they remember that they previously smoked or vaped — it becomes a moment of enjoyment and celebration of an addiction free life, instead of a moment of concern or struggle.</p><p><strong><em>We were intrigued by the feeling of freedom that many people talk about. We’ve been amazed just how many friends, or people we randomly speak to, have given up smoking or vaping with your programme. They are all so keen to tell us how great it is, and so many say that for the first time they felt ‘free’ from the mental health aspects as well as the physical aspects of their addiction. The opposite of the gritty battle with one’s will power that most quitting or dieting systems promote.</em></strong></p><p>As a former chainsmoker this is what was such a revelation to me. I’d tried so many times to quit using willpower methods: cold turkey, patches, gum, herbal remedies, and aversion therapy to name just a few, it genuinely felt like a miracle! How could something that had previously been impossible, painful, and tortuous suddenly become so easy? When addicts realise that everything they do is controlled by a drug over which they appear to have no control it destroys their self-respect, self-esteem, their entire sense of self. Suddenly becoming free from that life sentence is incredibly empowering and joyous — quite aside from escaping the health fears and expense.</p><p><strong><em>One of the important aspects of the EasyWay method is that you carry on vaping or smoking throughout the session and then have your final ritual one at the end. This is almost counterintuitive, but I saw Dr Chris Van Tulleken and Krishnan Guru-Murthy on Channel 4 agreeing this is just the way his own book on the addictive qualities of Ultra Processed Foods could be approached — tell us why that’s a good idea.</em></strong></p><p>Yes, we’re really grateful to former smokers who quit with the method and are happy to talk about it — all our celebrity endorsements are entirely unsolicited and unpaid.</p><p>Carrying on smoking or vaping while you are progressing through the method is important. Towards the end of the programme the flawed belief system that keeps an addict trapped is entirely dismantled — it collapses like a house of cards. Trying to quit before that point would be problematic and rely on an element of willpower.</p><p>Chris Van Tulleken is right — we use the same process with all our programmes including the one for sugar and carb addiction (which majors on Ultra Processed Foods)</p><p><strong><em>We liked the way you explore with participants how companies manipulate our belief systems as an intrinsic part of your method. Our research about vaping with young people for our Vaping Dilemma film showed that knowledge of how they were being manipulated was an important trigger for many of them to rethink. Tell us more about that.</em></strong></p><p>Yes, this is all very deliberate on the part of companies. There is already lots of misinformation and manipulation surrounding vaping propagated by the nicotine industry: it’s harmless, fun, stylish, sophisticated, sexy, social, relaxing, rebellious, grown up, helps with stress, helps with focus/concentration, tastes good, smells good, and it’s buzzy — all nonsense, and exactly the misinformation being peddled when I cured my first ever nicotine addict of cigarettes in 1998. It all adds up to a lifetime of slavery, depriving the addict and their family of their happiness, freedom and wealth.</p><p>We expose the elements of manipulation and show how this is deliberately designed to create a false belief that nicotine is providing a benefit people can’t live without. When they are freed from this mental baggage people no longer wish to take part in the charade.</p><p>Understanding how the addiction economy works is important and is why I think your work is so incredibly valuable in shining a light on it.</p><p><strong><em>We were surprised how much our own belief systems hamper us until we read your work. In fact, we were speculating from our research that things like warning signs ‘Nicotine is Addictive’ on vaping packs could work in the companies favour by actually increasing our belief that we are addicted and can’t do anything about it. Do you agree? We thought it was odd they embraced them so easily!</em></strong></p><p>Certainly, the extent to which smokers or vapers are constantly told that quitting is very, very hard, the more powerful the flawed belief system appears</p><p>In our live seminars we examine how health warnings on cigarette packs were exploited by tobacco companies. Not just the warnings but the images they were deliberately paired with. My favorite example is the B &amp; H “Mobile”.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/692/1*jQOfnQfUL3GKa0XtnTZQ1g.png" /></figure><p>We ask the clients what the picture is…wait for them to recognise it as a baby’s mobile….ask them where a baby’s mobile normally hangs…wait for them to answer — that it hangs above a baby’s cot…ask them what happens if the packet of cigarettes is taken away…wait for them to answer that everything falls on the baby…it’s appalling.</p><p>Then we highlight the health warning that the tobacco company chose to use with the image…even more appalling. We then point out that this advert was placed opposite the page of a women’s magazine feature highlighting the dangers of smoking whilst pregnant and that (at the time) the tobacco industry actually targeted specific pages in certain magazines when they covered certain issues.</p><p>It’s an old example but still resonates even with young smokers and vapers. The same strategy and micro-targeting is being used now on TikTok, Facebook and Instagram, for the same purpose.</p><p>In essence, escaping addiction is a little like being trapped in a room with a combination lock standing in the way of freedom…if a 10 number combination is required to open the lock, then the addict might get free by repeatedly entering random combinations of numbers — but the chances of success are slim, the task appears impossible, and each failed attempt becomes increasingly disheartening. However, something that appears impossible can suddenly become extremely easy, when you are given the correct numbers, in the correct sequence.</p><p><strong><em>We will be doing more on that interaction between belief systems and addiction in the future, but to focus for a minute on vaping in the UK now — I have been reading your blogs and you warned about vaping, and describing almost exactly how the market has played out, from 2011 onwards and were totally ignored, which must be very depressing. Why do you think that is?</em></strong></p><p>It is a tragedy and a predictable one at that. How did it happen? I think it’s a horrible example of confirmation bias — defined as “the tendency of people to favor information that confirms or strengthens their beliefs or values and is difficult to dislodge once affirmed”.</p><p>For more than 30 years nicotine has been considered by the key decision and policymakers as the silver bullet for helping smokers to quit. When nicotine patches and gum disappointed, they decided that the problem was that the addict wasn’t getting enough nicotine, frequently or efficiently enough. The harm reduction objectives were understandable, but anyone with any knowledge of how the addiction industry works knew that young people would be the primary targets…and that’s exactly what happened. And it happened quickly. The early warnings of kids taking up vaping — even as recently as a year or two ago — were dismissed as hysteria — even when the US Surgeon General announced an epidemic of vaping amongst the young.</p><p>You don’t have to be a medical expert to know that near constant, repeated inhalation of vapour containing a host of unregulated, unpleasant ingredients is bad news — yet those tasked with protecting the nation’s health left our children entirely unprotected from the vaping industry and even today they reject the notion of plain packaging in the belief that it might deter adult smokers from switching from cigarettes to vapes. Since 2011 it’s been a nicotine ‘gold rush’ and the biggest victims of it can be found in our schools, youth clubs, bars, and clubs.</p><p>For more than 10 years we’ve been helping former smokers and young vaping addicts to get free from nicotine addiction and it should be noted that we haven’t sought them out, we haven’t attracted them with any fear-mongering marketing campaigns…they approach us for help.</p><p>It’s quite the opposite of the claims that vaping nicotine is no more worrying than having a cup of coffee. Vapes were deliberately allowed to be easily available, sexily, stylishly, aspirationally marketed, advertised, and packaged in the name of helping smokers quit. How anyone thought kids wouldn’t be attracted to them is a mystery…or maybe they just didn’t care.</p><p><strong><em>But all this is not just theory for you John is it. You gave up smoking because of a live Allen Carr seminar, left your job and joined Allen and the company. A great story! What was the trigger that made you see this as something worthy of devoting your life to?</em></strong></p><p>I was so surprised and elated to have finally become free from smoking it really was a revelation. I honestly thought I’d be a smoker for the rest of my life and only really attended the live seminar to prove to my wife that it wouldn’t work. I told her I’d give it a go, as long as when it didn’t work, she’d let me smoke in peace for at least another year! No-one was more surprised than me that it worked. It was so easy, and I just felt compelled to get in touch with Easyway to see if I could help in any way. I was so grateful and inspired to help Allen’s mission and I am incredibly honoured to have worked so closely with him and played a part in helping so many addicts across the world to freedom.</p><p>It’s an inspiration to talk to you and hear about your work. Thank you very much John Dicey for your time.</p><p><strong>If anyone wants to know more about Allen Carr’s EasyWay and this and other areas of addiction they help people with — alcohol, gambling, ultra-processed foods, phone addiction, cannabis and more — in live group seminars, videos, books and one-to-one, take a look at their website </strong><a href="https://www.allencarr.com/"><strong>www.allencarr.com</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bc77bbafbc59" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The explosion of ‘Recreational Vaping’ requires new research and a different approach to regulation]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/the-explosion-of-recreational-vaping-requires-new-research-and-a-different-approach-to-regulation-c4ec572c6cd9?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c4ec572c6cd9</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Jun 2023 17:04:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-30T08:22:39.791Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>The explosion of ‘Recreational Vaping’ means planned regulation will fail the group most likely to be harmed by disposable vapes</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2_SJEpXnwFAtG_mADa1CcA.png" /><figcaption>Rapid growth in disposable e-cigarette vaping among young adults in Great Britain from 2021 to 2022: a repeat cross-sectional survey. Harry Tattan-Birch, Sarah E. Jackson, Loren Kock, Martin Dockrell, Jamie Brown. © 2022 The Authors. Addiction published by John Wiley &amp; Sons Ltd on behalf of Society for the Study of Addiction…<strong>NB: these statistics do not reflect sales of the new disposables eg Lost Mary which currently dominate the sector and were launched in Spring 2022.</strong></figcaption></figure><h4>‘Recreational vaping’ among 18–25 year olds overlooked by government and activists</h4><p>The understandable focus of the government and others on reducing the accessibility of vapes to under 18’s, while actively promoting e-cigarettes to help people stop smoking, overlooks the explosion of ‘recreational vaping’ among 18–25 year olds, with potentially serious consequences for their health, says responsible innovation not-for-profit SocietyInside.</p><blockquote>“Vaping is nothing to do with smoking. It’s a lifestyle thing, a youth thing. A vape is sort of like an accessory”</blockquote><blockquote>22 year old male — personal interview, SocietyInside scoping study, May 2023.</blockquote><p>“The findings of our scoping study among young adults shows that ‘recreational vaping’, particularly among the majority of users who have never smoked, shows very different drivers and motivations for 18–24 year olds than those of children and smokers”, explains Director Hilary Sutcliffe, “Most research to date has been broad and quantitative, there is no qualitative and ethnographic research about ‘recreational vaping’ as a phenomenon and so proposed regulations will fail to take into consideration the appropriate measures to prevent this becoming public health disaster for these young adults.</p><p><strong>“As a matter of urgency, the development of the regulation should be led by a broad and open societal debate, underpinned by better research, particularly involving this group. We need an open honest discussion about the appropriate role of vaping in the UK and how best to balance the urgent need to help smokers quit, with the rise of vapes as legal destination lifestyle products with increasingly visible negative public health effects on young people.</strong></p><p><strong>Sutcliffe concludes: “We cannot let the market dictate the health of our young people, we must learn the lessons of smoking, social media, opioids, gambling and other products of the ‘addiction economy’ and stop these harms in their tracks, whilst also incentivising and supporting those who want to quit smoking with the appropriate help and technologies.”</strong></p><h4>Recreational vaping is now a normal social activity for 18–24&#39;s</h4><p>Scoping research to assess the need for a larger study by SocietyInside’s Joe Woof, aged 22, (as part of a Master’s dissertation in Science Communication at UCL) shows that recreational vaping has become a normal social activity for many. “The barrier to having a cigarette in public is huge, for a disposable vape there is no barrier. Vapes are ubiquitous, there is no social stigma to using them and they are now used everywhere, including indoors in virtually every social setting. Using and sharing vapes with different flavours is totally acceptable, even, perhaps especially, for those who wouldn’t normally buy one themselves. They are totally legal for this age group and can be easily purchased on and offline, including recently inside bars and clubs. In just over two years, disposable vapes have become a completely normal part of the culture of young adults.”</p><blockquote>“Basically I reach for my vape before I open my eyes in the morning, before I even look at my phone and it’s the last thing I touch before I go to sleep, and when I wake up in the night. There is pretty much nowhere that I can’t vape .”</blockquote><blockquote>21 year old male — personal interview, SocietyInside scoping study, June 2023.</blockquote><p>“It is essential that the social context and motivations of young adults are better understood and the potential effects of vapes on their health and mental health are considered separately to the needs of smokers when deciding what to do about vapes” concluded Woof. “My small scoping study (with 28 21–23 year olds) indicated that many young people themselves are beginning to wish the choice was taken out of their hands and that the government would do more to restrict their use.</p><p>“Until I did this research I was a vaper myself. Finding out about how companies deliberately try to addict us and hearing about <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/aug/07/when-i-see-kids-vaping-i-warn-them-thats-what-killed-my-daughter">young people harmed, even dying from using vapes</a>, caused me to quit. Eventually”</p><h4>Beware behavioural science and vape product design and marketing</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ITK3Snhr9X5uCKf1ZEq5WQ.png" /><figcaption>Behavioural science used to create e-cigarrettes and vapes</figcaption></figure><p>The original e-cigarette was a large, fiddly, device which, quite rightly, was designed using <a href="https://inews.co.uk/opinion/government-smoking-age-21-science-work-1675894">cutting-edge behavioural science</a> to help smokers quit cigarettes. <em>“They offer a familiar physical sensation: allowing users to replicate smoking habits (for example, stepping outside, holding something in their hand, inhaling and exhaling a vapour)”</em> explained the UK Behavioural Insights Team, <a href="https://inews.co.uk/opinion/government-smoking-age-21-science-work-1675894">explaining the importance of behavioural science in e-cigarette product design</a>.</p><p>But new small, brightly coloured products, with sweet fruity flavours and catchy names like Lost Mary and Elf Bar have changed all that. Using their own behavioural science, including sophisticated marketing via TikTok and Instagram, companies making these new vapes (e-cigarettes is what old people call them!) have deliberately created a new and much larger customer base for the sector as the new big thing for young adults.</p><p>Lessons from behavioural psychology mean that if, as proposed by the government, the bright colours of disposable vape packaging are to be banned, the companies producing them will use similar manipulative design techniques to target their largest legal customer base — young adults. Disposable vapes will be redesigned and re-marketed to reflect their specific purchasing triggers.</p><p>The government must therefore think more deeply about the measures, including the potential for banning disposable vapes altogether, to prevent this predictable process. We must learn from previous attempts to restrict flavours, where flavoured vape pods were banned, <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/jun/26/us-bans-juul-young-people-newer-products">leading to the development of the current disposable vape products</a>. Continuing this regulatory ‘whack-a-mole’ is not a viable option for this sector and a recognition of company marketing practices and a more innovative approach to restrict their incentives is needed.</p><blockquote>“You buy cigarettes and the advertising says its going to kill you but with vapes it looks so nice and pretty like surely that’s completely fine, that’s why so many people get them. If it was bad, surely the government wouldn’t allow it?”</blockquote><blockquote>22 year old female —personal interview, SocietyInside scoping study, June 2023.</blockquote><h4>The many specific harms of disposable vapes underplayed</h4><p>The importance of promoting vapes as an alternative to smoking, and so comparisons of resulting harms, can distract from research and evidence about harms of vaping in its own right, particularly to those who do not smoke.</p><p>The huge popularity of vapes, one could conclude, as have many in the media, is just a new craze, something young people will get bored of and get over. Except nicotine is one of the most addictive substances there is and quitting a nicotine habit is not easy. In addition to that there are significant additional harms emerging.</p><p>Public health epidemiologist <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emily_Banks">Professor Emily Banks</a> has conducted a meta study of research worldwide — <a href="https://nceph.anu.edu.au/research/projects/health-impacts-electronic-cigarettes#health_outcomes">Health Impacts of Electronic Cigarettes</a> — that <a href="https://www.channel4.com/news/vaping-causing-significant-harm-to-non-smokers-says-epidemiologist">shows clear evidence that vaping does carry significant harms</a>, particularly for non-smokers, children and young people. Her research shows the nicotine and or the chemicals used in the vapes can cause addiction, poisoning, trauma, burns, lung injury and illnesses, mental health issues, impairs the development of children and adolescents, affects reproduction, sleep, wound healing, and looks likely to cause neurological conditions and conditions of the mouth and throat - with long term studies needed to assess cardiovascular and carcinogenic risks which cannot be ruled out given the current use of the technology used in disposables over approximately 2 years.</p><blockquote>Comparing recreational vaping with smoking is incorrect, “it should be compared with breathing” for non-smokers.</blockquote><blockquote><a href="https://www.channel4.com/news/vaping-causing-significant-harm-to-non-smokers-says-epidemiologist">Professor Emily Banks, Channel 4 News</a></blockquote><p>She went on to show that “there is also growing evidence of the effects of nicotine on the developing brain…with conclusive evidence that nicotine is one of most addictive substances that we know and we can see with these young people they are getting addicted. …We tend to trivialise addiction, but being addicted… to these products … is a very serious problem”.</p><p>Each vape contains the nicotine of 20 cigarettes, though there are none of the problems associated with the tobacco which accompanies cigarettes, there are additional concerns about the flavours, sweeteners and solvents which thought they are considered ‘generally recognised as safe’ by the US and UK. However, the studies have been about ingestion not inhalation leading to widespread concerns by health professionals. Furthermore concerns from outside the UK, particularly <a href="https://nceph.anu.edu.au/files/E-cigarettes%20health%20outcomes%20review%20summary%20brief%202022.pdf">Australia</a> and the <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/health/vaping-illness-tracker-evali.html">US</a> where 59 deaths have been reported, do not appear to be adequately reflected in <a href="https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/nicotine-vaping-in-england-2022-evidence-update">UK government assesment or guidance</a>.</p><blockquote>“The medical profession was hoodwinked by the tobacco industry years ago and endorsed cigarettes and we are now endorsing vaping. As a colleague of mine has said: ‘Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.”</blockquote><blockquote>Sarah Brown, Consultant in Paediatric Respiratory Medicine Royal London Children’s Hospital</blockquote><h4>The new culture wars battleground — vaping — a deliberate distraction from focus on harms</h4><p>Vaping has become the latest battleground in the culture wars demonstrates an <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jun/18/lobbyists-with-links-to-big-tobacco-fund-pro-vaping-facebook-campaigns">expose by journalists from The Observer </a>on 18th June 2023. Manufacturers and free market lobby groups are seeking to block UK regulation by inciting vapers to <em>‘stand up for their rights’</em> by opposing new vaping laws. Advertising and campaigns such as ‘We Vape UK’ on Facebook and Twitter which appear to be from ordinary members of the public are according to Observer’s research set up by the Adam Smith Institute with long running ties to the tobacco industry.</p><p>Advertisements also seek to undermine the World Health Organisation which has been vocal about the health risks of e-cigarettes — “<em>Who are the men in dark suits trying to control your lives? #SayNoToWho!”</em> Others feature devils, “top secret” files and show the WHO logo on puppet strings controlled by China and Russia”.</p><p>Comparisons with Alcopops in 1990s in which pre-mixed, fruity flavoured alcoholic drinks targeted at young people <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcopop#:~:text=In%20the%20United%20Kingdom%2C%20a,withdrawing%20them%20from%20their%20shelves.">were voluntarily withdrawn </a>due to pressure and reputational risk for large domesstic alcohol producers will not work here. However, it may prove difficult to provide similar reputational market incentives to the manufacturers of the UK’s leading vapes. It is difficult to track the company manufacturing the UK’s leading brands Lost Mary and Elf Bar but the Financial Times indicates they are own by the same Chinese company <a href="https://www.dnb.com/business-directory/company-profiles.shenzhen_imiracle_technology_co_ltd.4518afbb90769c951780a993c2bed67c.html">IMiracle Technologies</a> distributed through HeavenGifts and <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/d6147d64-ae1b-474a-bb80-170d131f3eec">Green Fun Alliance in the UK.</a></p><p>However it is encouraging to see <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/1c5a5217-3d5b-4ec1-b002-b6714acb38e5">Lawsuits in the US seem likely to bankrupt previous market leader Juul </a>because of it’s marketing to children, and the <a href="https://www.ashscotland.org.uk/news-and-events/news/2023/02/advertising-regulator-upholds-health-charity-s-complaint-against-vaping-company-s-medicinal-smoking-cessation-claims-about-e-cigarettes/">Advertising Standards Agency upholding a a complaint</a> from health charity ASH (Action on Smoking and Health) Scotland that profit-making companies like VPZ, (funded by tobacco company Phillip Morris) should not advertise themselves as ‘clinics’, or as giving ‘health advice’ as they have no trained staff to provide this guidance and are simply retailers of vapes.</p><h4><strong>Vapes are already an environmental catastrophe</strong></h4><p>The House of Commons study <a href="https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CDP-2022-0216/CDP-2022-0216.pdf">The Environmental impact of disposable vapes</a> shows that in 2022, 5.4 million single use vapes are thrown away each month, incorporating 10 tonnes of lithium a year, equivalent to the batteries inside 1200 electric cars.</p><p>In recycling terms they are categorised as ‘hazardous waste’ and research by <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/society/2023/jun/18/disposable-vapes-cause-fires-and-cost-taxpayer-english-and-welsh-councils-say">The Guardian</a> found that the Local Government Association, which represents councils in England and Wales, have said that “single-use vapes such as Elf bars, Lost Mary and Juul were almost impossible to recycle. They are designed as one unit so batteries cannot be separated from the plastic.”</p><p>In general users of vapes are unaware of the harms of the disposables on the environment and issues with recycling. Councils are concerned that even when they are recycled the recovery of these substances may also cause dangers to those undertaking the recycling including fires in recycling centres.</p><p>According to the Guardian, local councils are calling on the Environment Agency to proactively enforce retailer duties on paying into a producer compliance scheme and reform of the producer responsibility scheme. A spokesperson for DEFRA proposed “we will consider what changes in legislation are needed to ensure the vaping sector foots the bill for the collection and treatment of their used products.”</p><p>In the SocietyInside scoping study young people were concerned about the environmental hazards of vapes where they knew about them, but awareness was low.</p><h4>Conclusion: A new approach to regulation needed for vapes in the UK</h4><p>SocietyInside Director Hilary Sutcliffe proposed that a new approach to regulating vapes is needed.</p><p><strong>“As a matter of urgency, the development of the regulation should be led by a broad and open societal debate, underpinned by better research, particularly involving this 18–24 year old group. We need an open honest discusssion about the appropriate role of vaping in the UK and how best to balance the urgent need to help smokers quit, with the rise of vapes as legal destination lifestyle products, with increasingly visible negative public health effects on young people.</strong></p><p><strong>Sutcliffe concludes: “We cannot let the market dictate the health of our young people, we must learn the lessons of smoking, social media, opioids, gambling and other products of the ‘addiction economy’ and stop these harms in their tracks, whilst also incentivising and supporting those who want to quit smoking with the appropriate help and technologies.”</strong></p><h3>ENDS</h3><p>To discuss this further with SocietyInside please contact</p><p>Hilary Sutcliffe on hilary@societyinside.com or Joe Woof on joe@societyinside.com</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c4ec572c6cd9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Trustworthiness, trust and the Edelman Trust Barometer]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/trustworthiness-trust-and-the-edelman-trust-barometer-15d71711ce93?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/15d71711ce93</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 18 Jan 2023 14:09:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-18T15:55:35.492Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NBuVyswZKUtjdrcu5GdPHA.png" /><figcaption>AFP and Getty images — interesting choice of pic and subhead!</figcaption></figure><p>Lots of talk about trust this week ahead of Edelman Trust Barometer launched today at the World Economic Forum at Davos. Here’s my quick attempt at exploring the issues one at a time, as they are all getting rather unhelpfully conflated, and I think they are distinct.</p><p>The discussions also illuminate how complicated trust is; how difficult it is to pick apart what contributes to being trusted and the perception and reality of being trustworthy.</p><p>There appear to be a series of interesting issues. I am going to focus in this article on Edelman themselves and post another on the Barometer.</p><p>Part A</p><ol><li>Is Edelman a trustworthy organisation?</li><li>Are they even ‘experts’ on trust and competent at offering advice on trust?</li><li>How does one’s knowledge and perception of 1 affect 2?</li></ol><p>Part B to come.</p><ol><li>Is the Edelman Trust Barometer a legitimate piece of research? Is it even about trust or is it about reputation, the state of the world, an unreliable self-serving business generator, or something else?</li><li>How does knowledge and perception of 1, 2 and 4 affect the credibility and usefulness of the Barometer?</li><li>Does the WEF have a role in trust and distrust of the Barometer?</li></ol><h4>1. Is Edelman a trustworthy organisation?</h4><p>Let’s use Edelman’s own scale of trust here, which is a scale of Competence — “is it good at what it does” and Ethical Perception, chart below and <a href="https://www.edelman.com/sites/g/files/aatuss191/files/2023-01/2023%20Edelman%20Trust%20Barometer%20Global%20Report_0.pdf">page 60 on this year’s Barometer report</a>.</p><p>This is OK, and better than some trust metrics and not as bad as I thought. But it is missing two areas which are high in my findings on the <a href="https://www.tigtech.org/insights/7-drivers-of-trust">drivers of trust</a> — the intent behind the actions and openness and transparency.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M-a1K1aOfzOBsA0ZvKmnRw.png" /><figcaption>Edelman Ethical Perception framework for their Trust Barometer</figcaption></figure><p>I will focus on ethical perception with observations on competence observed alongside. I have swapped them around, you will see why.</p><p>Articles <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/jan/15/edelman-pr-firm-davos-trust?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other">like this one in the Guardian</a> are useful in giving us knowledge to help inform this decision. (Of course some will consider the Guardian not to be a trustworthy source themselves, but links show other sources do support their main allegations).</p><h4><strong>Vision</strong></h4><p>Edelman do appear to have a strong vision for business as social actors and their place in supporting that. <a href="https://www.edelman.com/">Their own website </a>has lots about their aspirations and how business should take a lead on social issues in the Trust Barometer. They may even be ‘effective agents of positive change’ in this regard through the Trust Barometer and their work with companies, highlighting the importance of business responsibility and positive interventions on social issues. (Whether you trust or distrust them for this is another matter!)</p><p>However, through their work for organisations such as the Saudi Government, Purdue Pharma and Exxon Mobil, Shell, Chevron, the National Mining Association and the American Petroleum Institution they could easily have undermined positive change in the important areas of the opioid crisis, human rights and climate change.</p><p>Under pressure from activists <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/business/2015/feb/19/edelman-public-relations-ends-relationship-american-petroleum-institute">they announced in 2015 </a>they would no longer work for climate deniers or coal producers, including the API which at one point was worth 10% of their international income. Is this a genuine attempt to move with the times, and walk their own talk, earn trust, or just an example of ‘trustwashing’?</p><h4><strong>Honest</strong></h4><p>Our perception and the reality of their honesty and integrity is tainted by their work for these clients, justaposed with their claims to be experts in trust and a socially responsible business. Can one even work, for example, for the Saudi government without being dishonest, corrupt and failing to uphold their stated values and vision?</p><p>At the heart of <em>distrust</em> is the perceptions with evidence, that an organisation has been saying one thing and doing another. Edelman, like many others, including many of their clients, are belatedly realising how important this mismatch is for trustworthiness and trust.</p><h4><strong>Fairness</strong></h4><p>Do Edelman <em>‘serve the interests of everybody equally and fairly’. </em>Fairness is an important trust driver, and again, what you do, not what you say it the yardstick for judgement. Perhaps their recent extensive work in <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/dec/22/edelman-saudi-arabia-pr-image">Saudi Arabia</a> indicates otherwise. Especially as at almost the same time they released a special report on Geopolitics, highlighting the finding that 95% of respondents to their research said that businesses should ‘get out’ of countries with repressive governments.</p><p>This lack of alignment between what they say and what they do could be evidence that the reality is that they serve themselves and their bottom line at the expense of others. It certainly shows where red lines can be drawn when trying to balance the interests of ethics and trust against the bottom line and working on the inside to change ‘bad actors’.</p><h4><strong>Purpose-driven</strong></h4><p>Their purpose is ‘<em>Earning Trust Through Communications’. </em>They are a <em>‘global communications firm that partners with businesses and organisations to evolve, promote and protect their brands and reputations.” </em>Here is the crux of their trust problem. Does their purpose <em>‘to promote and protect’</em> their clients, override their vision for social good and commitments to ethical and trustworthy behaviour? This is at the heart of the Intent trust driver.</p><p>CEO Richard Edelman is adamant, as are many activists, ESG organisations and others, that the best way to change organisations is from the inside out. I have some sympathy with this view. It needs activism from the outside to stimulate the need to change, but having someone who is a critical friend to help embed new ways of working is more effective in making change being in denial and having insiders prop up the status quo. Are they that company, is the question?</p><p>But this purpose of trust through communications also undermines their ethical claims, especially about their competence in helping organisations earn trust. Earning trust (as this article clearly demonstrates!) is first and foremost about how you behave, and how that correlates with what you say about yourself. You cannot communicate yourself out of a behavioural problem. By promoting communications as THE solution to trust they are simultaneously undermining their reputation for competence in helping organisations earn trust.</p><p><strong>Openness </strong>— Openness is another trust driver which is worth a mention here. Openness and initiating conversations about what they are doing, and about trade offs may at least uphold the honesty driver.</p><p>Providing ‘evidence of trustworthiness’, is important for the earning of trust. It is important for trusted organisations, but particularly essential where trust in you or your sector is suspect. This is a communications job, but it relies on communication about action. Not puff without substance.</p><p>Edelman are trying here. They have joined the United Nations Global Compact (more about trust in and trustworthiness of that another day!) and produce an annual update about its progress. This includes a <a href="https://www.edelman.com/sites/g/files/aatuss191/files/2021-01/Human%20Rights%20Policy,%2012-2020.pdf">human rights policy</a> and commitments to uphold human rights. Again, what you do must stack up with your commitments.</p><p>As an aside, some communications companies propose to companies to keep their heads down, don’t make public statements and commitments because it will may backfire. It is disappointing that they are often right, so undermining both the sector and trust.</p><h4>Are Edelman trusted and why?</h4><p>Are they trusted is a slightly different question. (Not, ‘can they be trusted’, but ‘are they’). Trust is contextual. You don’t distrust your plumber because they can’t mend your computer.</p><p>So trusted by who, for what is the is real question.</p><p>Edelman is a PR company, and though, disappointingly, the <a href="https://www.ipsos.com/en-uk/ipsos-veracity-index-2022">Ipsos Veracity Index</a> below, doesn’t include PR, I am fairly confident they will be down at the bottom with advertising execs, estate agents and government ministers!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C-KOxIj0y5oxJt3dOFZo3A.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is because in the eyes of the general public, their intent is not focused on the public interest, but helping their clients <em>‘protect their brands and reputations’, </em>which may or may not coincide with what is best for me as an individual or society as a whole.</p><p>Are they trusted by their clients? It seems that for many they are. They are a $1bn PR firm which is pretty big for the sector.</p><p>Why? Because they do a good job of communicating how they ‘protect brands and reputations’, and might be pretty good at it, even for for the dodgy, socially irresponsible ones. And because they have done a spectacular job with the Trust Barometer in becoming a household name for trust, which no-one really understands anyway, so to adapt the quote, ‘you never get fired for hiring the IBM of trust’.</p><p>Familiarity is another important driver of trust. The link to the WEF gives it credibility with this audience (and detracts from its credibility with other audiences) and, it is pretty interesting as a temperature check on what people think about businesses and governments.</p><p>Will this last though. With the growing criticism of them not walking their talk will they lose the trust of their current or potential clients. Communications will matter there for sure.</p><p>Is it too late? Can they earn it back? Not by communications alone they can’t, let’s see how their actions go! Perhaps they should look at the module of my Trustworthiness online course <a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBfzGdJlK_ztZl1sM25xUjg">‘How is trust lost and can it be regained’?</a></p><h4>Disclosure!</h4><p>I used to be in PR, for a few different companies in the 80s. I was in consumer PR, making up recipes for dubious slimming aids, promoting supermarket wine and once got my client Spillers in the Guinness Book of Records for holding the Biggest Dog’s Dinner in the World. But I didn’t think much about ethics at that point, but ‘evolved’ during the 1990’s stimulated by dissatisfaction with such pointless stuff and when the novelty of free wine wore off.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=15d71711ce93" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My two word construct of the year!]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/my-two-word-construct-of-the-year-4e8ad1ff52e0?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4e8ad1ff52e0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Dec 2022 14:28:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-12-16T14:36:26.639Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eQAVreonU9Zr4JwJL4a3yA.png" /></figure><p>We’ve had the Word of the Year from The Oxford Dictionary (‘goblin mode’), Cambridge Dictionary (<a href="https://dictionary.cambridge.org/editorial/woty">homer</a>) Collins (<a href="https://www.collinsdictionary.com/us/dictionary/english/permacrisis">‘permacrisis’</a>), Merrium Webster (<a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/word-of-the-year">gaslighting</a>) Dictionary.com (<a href="https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/world/dictionarycom-reveals-woman-as-its-2022-word-of-the-year/ar-AA15gjBj">Woman)</a>, the Economist (hybrid work), and the most Googled (<a href="https://www.theweek.co.uk/news/world-news/958803/most-googled-word-of-the-year-revealed">wordle</a>) and here is my two word construct of the year!</p><p>Regular readers will know that I have been researching Bullshit language for a while and have become intrigued by what Emeritus Professor of Science, Language and Society at Nottingham, Brigitte Nerlich, kindly told me are called ‘lexical compounds’. They compress complex information into usually two simple words allowing us to communicate difficult concepts in new and useful ways.</p><p>Sometimes, they are just tedious buzzwords, but <a href="https://medium.com/@hilary-4230/some-buzzwords-are-not-irritating-they-are-tiny-works-of-genius-my-top-5-best-and-worst-e54fddd96944">as I explore in this article</a> they can, almost miraculously, create new understanding and open up conversations, which didn’t happen before the phrase was invented. Matthew Syed in his excellent podcast Sideways explored this recently in an episode <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001fmyw">All in a name — how finding the right words can help us tackle big wrongs</a> — about how the creation of the term Sexual Harrassment changed everything for women in the workplace.</p><p>‘Coercive control’ was top of the list of my list those at the genius end of the spectrum, ‘circle back’ the most hated term by participants in my ‘Bullish*t workshops’ (to help people ditch the tedious language and irritating buzzwords and become better understood). Collatoral damage was top of my Scary 5 - those which have been invented specifically for malign purposes as the user tries to distance themselves, consciously or not, from the consequences of their actions.</p><p>So here is my two word compound of the year, plus a shortlist of potential contenders. Like those Words of the Year above they don’t need to have been invented this year, but have come to prominence and caught my attention.</p><h3><strong>Two word construct of the year:</strong></h3><h3><strong>Performative Politics</strong></h3><p><a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/world-politics/article/abs/performative-governance/AAC558378BEA651DB7E2480ECFFB4E10">The theatrical deployment of language, symbols, and gestures to foster an impression of good governance</a>…” (used to describe the term Performative Governance in World Politics, The Quarterly Journal of International Relations and adapted by me!)</p><p>I chose this, although it is not in wide usage, because it should be, and because it beautifully encapsulates the turbulent year we have had in UK politics which has been a mesmerising feature of the 2022!</p><p>Of course Brexit was Performative Politics at its worst, but 2022 has been another vintage year for watching Performative Politics in action.</p><p>Ex PM Boris Johnson was a master of the art. His unassailable belief that flamboyant rhetoric and his innate bumbling charm were enough to make him a PM of Churchillian stature was Performative Politics at its most deluded and damaging. Competence, integrity, the public interest are irrelevant to the performative politician, and sadly, sometimes, also to voters.</p><p>A less flamboyant, but equally arrogant strand of PP was practiced by our next PM Liz Truss. She also set aside such trifles as the best interest of UK citizens to perform for the totally unrepresentative 172,437 members of the Conservative Party (or 0.3% of the country), whose decision it was to choose the country’s next leader. This involved throwing ‘red meat’ policies which were divisive, often just wrong, and unpoplular with the many UK citizens, but chosen specifically to capture the attention of this small subset of the population.</p><p>What is perhaps pleasing is that Performative Politics has backfired for both of these Prime Ministers. Their superficiality, entrenched ideology and emphasis on form over substance made a significant contribution to their downfall in the end.</p><p>Is this the end of Performative Politics heyday in the UK? Did it blaze like a shooting star in the political fermament to fall to earth and be replaced by a stable, sane respectful politics focused on the public interest? I fear not.</p><p>Two consecutive home secretaries, first Priti Patel and the current incumbent Suella Braverman have failed to see it is not a great idea, particularly in their approach to immigration. Braverman seems to have fully embraced the performative approach which eschews respectful language, evidence, substance and empathy in favour of further red meat rhetroic for a small but influential group, referring to an ‘invasion’ of undeserving migrants who are economic chancers and here under false pretences, as the justification for a vicious immigration policy. (Another whole article could be written on this, but I will move on!)</p><p>Of course we know that all politics is performative, very often, though thankfully not always, at the expense of substance. A perfunctory viewing of Prime Ministers Questions in the House of Commons will confirm that. But I dearly hope that one of the lessons of our harrowing last 12 months in politics is to learn that putting performance over substance is ultimately misguided and that Performative Politics is an idea who’s time has been and gone.</p><h3>Other 2022 faves</h3><p>Here are a few more which resonated. These are mostly not new, but came to my attention in 2022.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/business-60353916"><strong>Lying flat </strong></a>— is fabulous, emerging from China and meaning taking a break from relentless work. 2022 was a year that made most of us want to lie flat for one reason or another.</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_twin"><strong>Digital twin</strong></a><strong> </strong>— we will be hearing more of — this is a digital version of a product, system or process which allows testing, monitoring and prototyping of new ideas.</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtue_signalling"><strong>Virtue Signalling</strong></a><strong> </strong>— lots of it about this year. “An attempt to show other people that you are a good person, for example by expressing opinions that will be acceptable to them, especially on social media. The expression is often used to imply that the virtue being signalled is exaggerated or insincere.” Interesting to see a a corporate manifestation of this ‘greenwashing’ come under scrutiny with new <a href="https://www.gov.uk/government/news/greenwashing-cma-puts-businesses-on-notice">Green Claims Code </a>to ensure the UK Competition and Markets Authority can investigate firms who make green claims which can’t be substantiated.</p><p><a href="https://www.tijmenschep.com/socialcooling/"><strong>Social cooling</strong></a><strong> </strong>— describing ‘the long-term negative side-effects of living in a data driven society when digital systems greatly amplify social pressure, which could lead to more conformity’. Another year of frenzied activity on the negative effects of social media culminating in Elon Musk’s take over of Twitter and alot of us cooling towards him and leaving Twitter in droves.</p><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism"><strong>Effective altruism</strong> </a>— “a philosophical and social movement that advocates using evidence and reason to figure out how to benefit others as much as possible, and taking action on that basis”. An interesting put peculiar concept, which has been undermined by the dramatic downfall of one of its leading advocates Sam Bankman-Fried founder of the bancrup FTX currency exchange <a href="https://medium.com/r?url=http%3A%2F%2FFTX+was+part+of+an+aggressively+utilitarian+project+to+make+as+much+money+as+possible%2C+in+order+to+donate+it+as+effectively+as+possible+for+the+future+of+the+happiness+of+humanity.">who claimed this venture</a> was “part of an aggressively utilitarian project to make as much money as possible, in order to donate it as effectively as possible for the future of the happiness of humanity’. Hmm. Maybe another two word construct <a href="https://www.tigtech.org/insights/rriec">Responsible Innovation</a> needs to go hand in hand with EA.</p><p><strong>Re-humanising — </strong>Used in lots of different ways, but I am making it the opposite of dehumanising, which is what we seem to be doing with our approach to technology at the moment by, making humans more like machines and machines more like humans. Madness.</p><p>Re-humanising means celebrating everything that makes us human and rebelling against all that is dehumanising, everywhere. I am taking it as a watchword for my next year’s work.</p><p>Happy Christmas and holiday season everyone!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4e8ad1ff52e0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Do I want a robot to clean my house?]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/do-i-want-a-robot-cleaning-my-house-9a33326f9f51?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9a33326f9f51</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 12 Oct 2022 18:49:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-13T13:02:32.832Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZW-O2xCLZrHiS0TNrstp2A.png" /><figcaption>Robot Ai-Da presenting at House of Lords, Mail Online.</figcaption></figure><p>I am giving in and getting another cleaner. My husband retired early and the idea was he was going to do the housework and before the miraculous day dawned, covid was on us and we weren’t allowed one anyway. I work full time, and let’s be honest, and the house husband idea not going according to plan, so I am getting another.</p><p>The footage of Ai-Da (pronounced Ada, not Ay-dar, some sort of Welsh/Scouse mash up as I originally thought!) ‘talking’ to the House of Lords yesterday made me wonder what I would do if I could have a robot cleaner. What would it have to look like and what would have to happen for me trust it.</p><h4><strong>1. It has to work</strong></h4><p>It doesn’t break down at random times (like pretty much every other tech I have used) or do weird things like run manically around the house brandishing a toilet brush and talking gibberish.</p><p>But <a href="https://www.dyson.co.uk/newsroom/overview/news/may-22/Robotics">a peek into James Dyson’s robotics lab </a>where his team of hundreds of engineers have been working for over a decade getting robotic arms to do the many tasks required of a robot cleaner. It might break down, but not sure it will be attacking me with my bread knife. (Aaah unless the software is hacked by a nutcase who want to kill me? No wait, I think Dyson might have thought of that, so I’ll probably take my chance on that one just like I do that my human cleaner is not going to kill me or rob me.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NClVgwsXAX9FL_zysG4ZMA.png" /><figcaption>Capture from Dyson promo video of robot vacuuming a chair</figcaption></figure><p>What about the Bot Handy Samsung recently launched in the US, which is like a robot vacuum with robotic arms. Shown here below putting stuff in the dishwasher in an irritatingly slow way.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fm-3c9Pt3_J0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dm-3c9Pt3_J0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fm-3c9Pt3_J0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f7ec9dc8e92b74f8b6a301ac7e3297d6/href">https://medium.com/media/f7ec9dc8e92b74f8b6a301ac7e3297d6/href</a></iframe><p>Frankly I can’t see it managing to get the three day old ingrained tomato sauce off my filthy worktops, put the right lid on the 15 things I have used to make my dinner and put them all away in the right place. Let alone manage the bag of flour with the slight slit in it, which goes back fine if you fold it in the right way and keep your thumb on while putting it in the cupboard at the right angle.</p><p>What about lumpen <a href="https://www.unlimited-robotics.com/gary">“Gary The Service Robot”</a> who Unlimited Robotics tells us <em>‘can do (potentially) anything. How? Because it has an internal app market, in which you can download the relevant app and get the services you need. Look at your mobile: it has an app store, but can it water your plants or throw the garbage? Gary can!”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G1uYaqg8XMNKVvwGdo_iJQ.png" /></figure><p>It can supposedly ‘<em>take out laundry, pick toys from the floor, ironing, work the dishwasher, hoover, bring casual items, drinks and snacks, water the plants, wash the floor and schedule activities.</em> It can also <em>clean the toilet sit</em> — their misspelling not mine — eye for detail… very important in robot development guys!</p><p>So I am presumeably to download yet another app, tell it to make me a cup of tea — at the right temperature, with the right teabags, in the right teapot, with the right amount of the right milk for me, (from the three we currently have in the fridge for different family members), in the mug I like depending on the time of day?</p><p>Will I have to tell it all this, or show it where I have put everything when I put it away, or tell it where to put the things I have bought (or the Internet of Things fridge has ordered for me because I ran out even tho it’s only been sitting on the side going off for a couple of days?) Or God Forbid spend even one minute programming the app for that ??</p><p>Read my lips. <strong>NOT. A. CHANCE.</strong></p><h4>2. It has to look right</h4><p>So let’s say it all works without me having to programme any apps, faff about telling it where everything is, or having to put everything in the same place all the time or the robot won’t know where it is.</p><p>So what will it look like and how will it move? I know from previous work with the lovely folks at <a href="https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/sheffieldrobotics">Sheffield Robotics</a> and their work on the robot dog Miro and Paro the seal that roboticists will think hard about this.</p><p>So here are my preferences:</p><p>(a) It can’t move in a spooky and weird way like Boston Dynamics Dancing Robot below. Or look like a robot Arnie Schwartzeneger</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Ffn3KWM1kuAw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Dfn3KWM1kuAw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Ffn3KWM1kuAw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/51204587a2586eba31107a3af9611284/href">https://medium.com/media/51204587a2586eba31107a3af9611284/href</a></iframe><p>(b) Or have a clueless sappy expression like the very irritating <a href="https://www.robotlab.com/pepper-robot">Peppa the Robot</a> who is doing the rounds and showing up in banks and shopping malls with a sign on its front iPad (below). I met it once, and honestly I had to restrain a very physical urge to push it over and see what happened.</p><p>I am being mean, but how did the brainstorm go on what it should look like?<em>“I know, everyone likes kittens and things with big round eyes, let’s have those. And it better not look too threatening and smart so a sort of half smile might work. Also we need it to pivot half way down so we could give it a sort of waist like a woman (but not too like a woman or the feminists will be onto us) so it’s not threatening and muscular (like the Boston Dynamics one) And everyone is use to seeing white robots now, lets make it nice and white. Maybe it doesn’t matter that much, it is just a mobile iPad after all.”</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bGJ6_GrTr5_wwczHnT-yZg.png" /></figure><p>(c) Or be too lumpen and ugly like Gary, a dishwasher on wheels. I have enough large metal white goods in my house and I don’t need another one cluttering up the place.</p><p>And I certainly don’t need yet another warranty to fill in, another hotline to call because the bldy thing doesn’t work and another bot on another website telling me I probably haven’t read the manual properly.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uxfyTw_b-dIohDFc7GPFfw.png" /></figure><p>(d ) Or be too hybrid roboty like Ai-Da — not keen on all the wires sticking out everywhere. Anyway my cat eats any wires she can get her teeth on, so it wouldn’t last long in our house anyway.</p><p>Also no weird rubbery face. Can you imagine looking that in the eye and asking it to do the toilet? Also not keen on the dungerees, tho it is supposed to be an artist, so I see the point here. Maybe a sort of white lab coat look? No scrap that, then I’d have to wash it if it got dirty.</p><p>Gary is looking better by the minute.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5VwPEt5yWrpoVFo9Wt6Wag.png" /></figure><p>(e). But definitely not too human and scary like those lot on the TV programme Humans. You can tell as soon as you look at them it’s all going to end badly. And really, no one in their right mind would have a robot looking like that hanging around the house making dinner for their husband and looking after the kids.</p><p>Also, as above, does it wash it’s own clothes? How will it know when they are dirty.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l32o4caTwKLOgrkX7NlCJQ.png" /></figure><h4>3. What about the cost?</h4><p>Apart from the cost of buying it, what about my electric bills? It will surely eat power, or run out half way through stacking the dishwasher and then how will I move it?</p><p>Presumably it will tell me in one of the many voices I will be able to choose from (Peppa with an East End accent, might be fun!) it is just about to run out of juice and will go and stand on its charger looking blankly at me as I go past it in the hall. Weird. But as I don’t have a cupboard big enough thats where it would have to go.</p><h4>4. It has to be ethical.</h4><p>Look, I do ethics for a living (and yes I do vet my cleaning company and don’t do cash and only hire the ones who pay for sicktime and holidays etc). So is it even ethical in the first place to deprive a person of a job?</p><p>Could I rationalise it because cleaners are like gold dust, so there clearly aren’t hoards of the unemployed clamouring for a job like this anyway?</p><p>What about the plastic, the rare earths, the energy use from the AI and the machinary — and <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/50131136-atlas-of-ai">Kate Crawfords excellent book The Atlas of AI</a> doesn’t cover cleaning robots, but there is bound to be power imbalances and exploitation somewhere down the supply chain. How will I tell? What will the regulation say about all this. Maybe they will be designed according to the <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10676-016-9409-x"><em>‘Care Centered Value Sensitive Design (CCVSD)’</em></a><em> </em><a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10676-016-9409-x">principles proposed for care robots. Who knows</a>.</p><p>But is it exploitative anyway to hire a real person to clean up my muck because I and my husband are too lazy, err busy? Lots of different views even <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/money/2008/mar/28/workandcareers.pay">from Guardian readers</a> on that one. Maybe it is more ethical to get a robot after all?</p><p>Luckily, this is taken out of my hands as there are no robot cleaners to buy. But if there were, which one would I choose? I think the Dyson, because it will be clever, it will work and do what I want it to do and they aren’t obsessed about making robots that look just like humans or trying to re-purpose some AI software they invented for something else. And hopefully, they will have thought about the ethics of production as well. They will have a good helpline and repair systema and I’ll buy it from John Lewis, like everything else, so it will be good value and I can send it back if I don’t like it.</p><p>The replacement of existing human cleaners is one I am ducking for now and will make the decision on what’s going on in the world when it happens.</p><p>And back in the real world, Rhea starts on Friday and instead of the usual manic house clean, I am looking forward to a relaxing Saturday morning reading the papers and planning my weekend. Bliss. Thank you Rhea.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9a33326f9f51" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Keep Buggering On — My long & winding road to Tech Ethics and beyond (via CSR, Stakeholder…]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/the-long-winding-road-to-tech-ethics-and-beyond-via-csr-stakeholder-capitalism-rri-9ce0f5e41fae?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9ce0f5e41fae</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 05 Oct 2022 10:02:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-27T13:17:28.878Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Keep Buggering On — My long &amp; winding road to Tech Ethics and beyond (via CSR, Stakeholder Capitalism &amp; RRI)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/998/1*5zqpa0nn69dXxQTI0VTaHQ.png" /></figure><p>Tech Ethics is a hot topic and I’m having a deja vu moment. There is nothing new about thinking about how to develop innovations which put people and not profit first, whilst also navigating inherent moral dilemmas. It has been called a number of different things, even in my lifetime, but while the names change, the technologies change, the overarching dilemma of how to develop innovations which don’t cause more problems than they solve remains the same.</p><p>When I entered the scene in the late 1980s, environmentalists were considered cranks, human rights and business wasn’t even thought about. I and many others were more worried about the size of our shoulder pads than the state of the world. This is a meander through my own personal journey and should not be seen as a through analysis of the evolution of business responsibility.</p><p>My awakening was gradual, no damascene conversion. It started with the clients I was doing PR for at the time, such as Co-op, Kelloggs and KP Foods to translate their annual reports to make them meaningful for employees. It had struck me the very people who needed to know what’s going on in the company and plans for the future are the employees and they never get told. Annual Reports were for finance people how were companies going to bring their employees with them in the next year if they don’t know what’s going on?</p><p>I gradually got drawn in to the human rights area with what was then called Corporate Social Responsibility or CSR, in the 1990s. The problems CSR was trying to solve was initially focused on</p><p>(a) environmental impacts, which shot to prominence by United Nations report Our Common Future, which became knows as the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Our_Common_Future">Brundtland Report of 1987</a> , the 1989 Exxon Valdez Alaska oil spill and by the huge furore in the UK caused by the 1995 Greenpeace campaign to prevent oil company Shell from disposing of its Brent Spar oil platform by sinking it off the coast of Scotland.</p><p>(b) human rights issues, particularly shocking practices coming to light of forced and child labour in clothing supply chains and mining.</p><p>As you can see I have deja vu moments alot, as these subjects recur and recur and remain unsolved!</p><p>It was clear companies needed to be held to account for their social, environmental and economic impacts — <a href="https://johnelkington.com/archive/TBL-elkington-chapter.pdf">The Triple Bottom Line</a> as coined by eco guru John Elkington in 1994. (I worked for him for a bit translating the TBL into the language of the financial and accounting community to try to sell them the importance of this work for mainstream finance and so get it taken more seriously in the ‘real’ world of business).</p><p>So SRI, Socially Responsible Investing was born which morphed more recently to become ESG Environmental and Social Governance. To help take this work more into the mainstream the United Nations 6<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principles_for_Responsible_Investment"> Principles for Responsible Investment</a> were developed and launched at the New York Stock Exchange in 2006 to encourage signatories from mainstream investment to understand the implications of social and environmental factors and apply the principles in their investment decisions.</p><p>In the absence of any regulation, standards evolved — the rationale was that by encouraging more transparency, measurement and reporting of the environmental, social and economic impacts of companies there would be a race to the top, or at least a way of highlighting and penalising the laggards.</p><p>The <a href="https://www.oecd.org/daf/inv/mne/oecdguidelinesformultinationalenterprises.htm">OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises</a> probably kicked things off in 1976. The <a href="https://ceres.org/homepage">CERES Principles</a> for environmental stewardship were created in 1989 in response to Exxon Valdez and ISO launched its first environmental <a href="https://www.iso.org/about-us.html">standard 14001</a> in 1996. A more general corporate responsibility standard followed from the UK standards body Accountability, started it with <a href="https://www.accountability.org/standards/aa1000-accountability-principles/">AA1000</a> in 1997 (I was peripherally involved in that and more with its later sister publication <a href="https://www.boreal-is.com/blog/aa1000-stakeholder-engagement-standard/">AA1000SES the stakeholder engagement standard</a>). <a href="https://sa-intl.org/">Social Accountability International </a>in New York launched SA8000 the first mainstream standard on human rights and business, particularly in supply chains (I was involved in promoting that here in the UK). <a href="https://www.globalreporting.org/about-gri/mission-history/">The Global Reporting Initiative</a> followed in 2000 and United Nations <a href="https://www.unglobalcompact.org/">Global Compac</a>t in 2000.</p><p>But gradually it became clear it wasn’t really doing the job because companies were seen to be signing up to these initiatives but beneath the surface it was business as usual. CSR was discredited as a solution and a brand. <em>‘Washing’</em> as a term wasn’t invented then, but that was the accusation — all spin and no action. Deja vu again.</p><p>The main reason for the failure it was identified was the dominance of shareholder primacy as the only driver and incentive for business behaviour. A fledgling movement stimulated by corporate governance shenanigans and corporate social and environmental misdeeds began to distill the idea of and business as a force for good in society and Stakeholder Capitalism was born.</p><p>The UK lead in this with the report in 1996 of the <a href="https://www.tomorrowscompany.com/">RSA Inquiry: Tomorrow’s Company</a>, (which I also worked on). It sought to refocus the core purpose of business away from purely shareholder value and consider how it creates value for staff, shareholders and society through a focus on purpose, values, business relationships and a long term view of corporate success. It’s come and gone a few times since then, and the damascene conversion of the <a href="https://www.businessroundtable.org/business-roundtable-redefines-the-purpose-of-a-corporation-to-promote-an-economy-that-serves-all-americans">US Business Round Table</a> in 2019 just the latest group to get with the programme and think they just invented it!</p><p>The problem it and ESG and Tomorrow’s Company proposed to solve was to change the metrics of success. This seems to fall foul of system inertia, and incumbents and elites resisting change to the system. Why should they, it’s what’s making them rich and they are in charge!</p><p>So moving on to around 2008 and Responsible Research and Innovation became the Next Big Thing, particularly in Europe. The problem this was supposed to solve was the furore around the values clash and potential environmental impact of GMOs, harmful chemicals and scary upcoming tech like Nanotech (digital and data ethics wasn’t mainstream then). The issue was exacerbated by the hype about technology progress (essential to getting money out of government and investors) — <em>electricity too cheap to meter</em> (Nuclear Power ), <em>an end to hunger </em>(GMO’s ) <em>elimination of cancer by 2015</em> (Nanotechnology ) and soon to join the puff-fest was AI promising an end of work and melding our minds with machines.</p><p>The idea was that science and tech should be created to align with societal values and that this should be embedded ‘upstream’ in academic research and company R&amp;D rather wait to have the conversation when it was all too late and the tech was out there doing its thing. Being a bit unfair here, as there was some great moral underpinnings in many areas, but a large part of the impetus for this was to avoid another problem like the social rejection in Europe of Genetically Modified Foods, or GMOs —<em> “How do we create new products and make loads of money without society kicking off”</em>.</p><p>I initiated a multi-stakeholder initiative on responsibility in nanotech, resulting in a <a href="https://www.tigtech.org/insights/si-pri">Responsible Nano Code of Conduct</a> and a website for citizens called <a href="https://www.tigtech.org/insights/nanoandme">Nano&amp;me</a>. The EC also did a similar Responsible Nano Code around the same time, mine focused on companies and theirs on research. We launched it at the same meeting.</p><p>But as a very smart guy on my steering group from Unilever told me —<em> “In the end these principles for Nano are just the same whatever the tech.”</em> He was right. Take the name of the old tech out and put in the name of the next one and the principles and values desired from them were the same. Responsible Innovation was the name which evolved.</p><p>I was commissioned by the EC to write a primer <a href="https://ec.europa.eu/programmes/horizon2020/sites/default/files/rri-report-hilary-sutcliffe_en.pdf">‘An Introduction to Responsible Research and Innovation’</a> in 2010 which roughly sums up the approach. I heard from a well respected academic recently that because of this I was supposed to have ‘invented’ RRI!</p><p>It got more traction in Europe because of the EU Framework and Horizon 2020 research programmes which have spent perhaps by now €170+million with mainly academic institutions in its ‘Science With and For Society’ type programmes which focused on 5 rather artificially prescribed Pillars of RRI (ethics, gender, open access, public engagement, governance).</p><p>UK academics did some innovative work, notably with the<a href="https://www.ukri.org/about-us/epsrc/our-policies-and-standards/framework-for-responsible-innovation/"> AREA Framework for Responsible Innovation — Anticipate, Reflect, Engage, Act,</a> much of which I was a stakeholder or peripherally involved. The most interesting for me was working with Professor Richard Jones at the University of Sheffield with a working group considering how to embed the principles of responsible innovation throughout the whole university and focusing attention on three areas, robotics, genetic modification and disability studies. We were really getting somewhere, but he was the driving force and it petered out when he moved on.</p><p>Has this ‘worked’ in shaping academic science and social science towards a more ‘responsible’ approach? Certainly not in my book in relation to the money spent. Many reasons for this — including</p><p>(a) the incentives for academics were equally perverse (academic papers and not real world impact),</p><p>(b) because businesses and practical policy folks didn’t want to come to their meetings or read their findings because they were very often full of incomprehensible academic jargon and</p><p>(c )the research really lead nowhere because the academic system meant you had to move on to the next project which may not be much connected. And all the other reasons above about business and shareholder primacy.</p><p>Because the money was pointed mainly at academia business got off the hook a bit. But Responsible Innovation from a company perspective began to have some traction post 2010 with new tech like AI, Self Driving Cars, Robotics, Drones and new gene editing techniques like CRISPR. These were scary, and we were gradually beginning to see how digital tech, in for form of social media was affecting society in a negative way.</p><p>It also worked well funding wise becuase the academics could work with the governments to do something together and which are close to actual citizens. Also similar thinking evolved around the monikers of Sustainable by Design, Design Thinking Safe By Design.</p><p>Then we reach now and the same issues are being described as Tech Ethics. The problem being solved here is perhaps a meld of the three areas and focuses almost totally on digital platforms, data analytics, and artificial intelligence and machine learning.</p><p>As usual we had to wait until the harms were visible to take action — Facebook and Cambridge Analytica, the dramatic changes to society brought about by social media, the increasing surveillance of society through biometrics and facial recognition to name just a few. (BTW, the environment is pretty much nowhere in this. It should be and will be soon.) It covers lots of things and there are literally hundreds of ethics frameworks, particularly for AI. (Here is not the place to nitpick those!)</p><p>I think it was called ethics because the technologies originated in the US where ethics was still the dominant terminology. In the UK the <a href="https://www.ibe.org.uk/">Institute of Business Ethics</a> had started in the mid 1980’s. And seemed to focus on the internal behaviours of companies, particularly business integrity, corruption and the negative impacts on their employees and embedding cultures which supported those who spoke out against company misbehaviour. It did begin to evolve and perhaps later morphed into CSR — I recall in 1998 doing work for BT — <em>101 Reasons why Ethics Matters </em>full of jokes and quotes and cartoons. I dug it out recently and it made a great starting point in co-creating the 2020 booklet I wrote for the World Economic Forum Values Ethics and Innovation Council — <a href="https://www.tigtech.org/insights/wefvaluesbooklet">A How To Guide for Tech Ethics for Start Ups and SMEs</a> !</p><p>There was also medical ethics of course which has a long history, but I don’t think really got attached to companies as well as it might have, a pity as there is really useful learning to be had, but I see it moving more to the the fore with Neurotech and assistive robotics.</p><p>So has that worked? Not really. I am stilll puzzled as to why we seem no further on after all this thinking. Why has this failed in the main to alter the innovation development mindset?</p><p>Probably for all the same reasons as the previous initiatives weren’t. The mindset of senior management which is primed by the metrics of neoliberal capitalism, which in turn is primed by narrow GDP metrics. The wilful blindness is all too easy because those in charge are distant from the impact of their actions and focused on a seeming ‘right to make money’ which trumps all else. And also of course because new tech entrepreneurs are convinced they are right and the rest of the world will find out how right they are very soon! Which is essential to survive in a dog eat dog world and if they didn’t we wouldn’t have many of the fabulous innovations we use, we love and which have transformed our world. I have written a short blog on this for the World Economic Forum post Covid <a href="https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2020/08/building-blocks-of-the-great-reset/">The 4 Building Blocks for the Great Reset</a></p><p>So, disheartened with all this failure a chance meeting at the WEF Global Futures Council in 2017 led to a shift in my focus onto trust and governance. After all, everyone was saying that trust was the most important thing of all — but what it really meant in practice seemed very half baked and obscure.</p><p>I had also concluded that regulation and forcing organisations to behave in a certain way by law was about the only thing that worked. So with support from the World Economic Forum and funding and a research partnership from Fraunhofer Institute for Systems Innovation in Germany I set out to research the interlinkages between societal trust and tech and governance. The trust literature was a minefield and the connections to tech governance not easy to make, but the key findings of the report <a href="https://www.tigtech.org/">Trust and Tech Governance</a> and exploring embedding the three new competencies — <a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fc12cea2cf09257bd6dcc01/t/5fceb2d586f8e37a92a65407/1607381718267/2_competency.pdf">Building Trusted Environments for Collaborative Governance</a>, <a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fc12cea2cf09257bd6dcc01/t/5fceb31a0d4311364642c532/1607381788515/3_competency.pdf">‘Nothing about us without us’ Embedding the Involvement of Citizen</a>s and having <a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fc12cea2cf09257bd6dcc01/t/5fceb2845c72243a4f129e95/1607381637570/1_competency.pdf">Evidence of Trustworthiness be the focus for communications</a> from companies and regulators area all keeping me busy.</p><p>But hey, guess what. People aren’t that interested in trust either! They love the theory, and love talking about the importance of trust. But when it comes to the hard bit of changing their culture, questioning their business model and potentially making less money by upholding the<a href="https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBfzGdJlK_ztZl1sM25xUjg"> 7 Drivers of Trust — Good Intent, Integrity, Openness, Inclusion, Fairness, Respect and Competence </a>don’t seem worth the effort and trust not as important as they thought after all!</p><p>But I am now involved with a new approach to governance to incentivise organisation into thinking what they don’t want to think and doing what they don’t want to do — Professor Chris Hodges work on <a href="https://www.bloomsbury.com/in/outcomebased-cooperation-9781509962501/">Outcome-based Cooperative Regulation</a> and <a href="https://www.koganpage.com/product/culture-audit-in-financial-services-9781789667752">Conduct Auditing</a>. The problem this was designed to solve was the financial crash and answer the question posed by Queen Elizabeth II and the rest of us <em>‘How did they not see this coming?.</em></p><p>The starting point is that values clashes and misconduct problems stem from corporate cultures which reward putting money before anything else, that repress speaking out about problems in response and reward individualistic behaviours over collaborative goals. A regulatory system which puts evidence of effectiveness, trust and cooperation at its heart may be better placed to make corporatations behave in the public interest. I’ll work on that premise until I come across anything better!</p><p>I wrote this as COP26 in Glasgow was closing and Covid has rocked everyone’s world which I think has genuinely brought home to us what really matters. It has shone a light on inequalities, wellbeing, and the problems facing society. The Great Resignation is underway (I wrote my Master’s thesis predicting this as a rectifier of corporate behaviour in 2000, so won’t be holding my breath on that!). Add to this the looming climate crisis and the recognition of the devastating social negative impact of digital technologies and I feel a dawning in the minds of serious politicians and business leaders that business as usual is not an option. This gives me a glimmer of hope.</p><p>I am pinning most of my hopes on the growing dissatisfaction and empowerment of us citizens and civil society groups, particularly young people to put our foot down to force governments and business to make a dramatic change. Though the transition will not be easy, and many will find ourselves worse off in the shorter term, change is not inevitable. So I’ll finish with a 2017 blog that was perhaps a bit premature ‘<a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/lets-make-1st-empowerment-revolution-4th-industrial-hilary-sutcliffe/">Let’s make this the 1st Empowerment Revolution and not the 4th Industrial Revolution’</a>.</p><p>I had a tattoo put under my watch in 2019 with the letters KBO, this is Winston Churchill’s mantra Keep Buggering On. Looking back on this little resume of my working life, I think that’s all there is to be done. Keep going, keep curious and keep trying to make things better tomorrow than they were yesterday.</p><p>I wrote this at the kind request of someone who I greatly admire, who was interested in my journey and the arc of tech development it describes. They wanted to publish it as a blog, but I thought it was too boring and I would rather have the attention on my current work, rather than my meanderings about the past.</p><p>But I have just found it quite useful for drafting a new report — <strong><em>Innovation is Society in the making </em></strong><em>— How innovation can work better for people and planet, without causing more problems than it solves. </em>This will be a reflection and update of thinking on Responsible Innovation over the last 15 years.</p><p>I am promoting it here because sod it, I did the work!</p><p><em>.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9ce0f5e41fae" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Trust measurement— start with feeling the pain of distrust]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/trust-measurement-start-with-feeling-the-pain-of-distrust-db3333d022ae?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/db3333d022ae</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Sep 2022 13:16:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-09-01T13:32:42.492Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ewCpMTS2wDs6Hs217On9tQ.png" /><figcaption>For SocietyInside by Aine Cassidy, Effusion.</figcaption></figure><p>In the first article I explored <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/taking-trust-seriously-a-starting-point-for-companies-8aa3861411bf">Taking Trust Seriously</a> and the <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/measuring-trust-why-you-might-be-wasting-your-money-3216903809d5">second about measuring trust </a>I looked at the sorts of trust measures going around for companies and civic institutions, but with a warning that measures skew incentives and incentives skew behaviours, so to think carefully about why you want to measure trust and how you intend to respond to the results. Here I am reflecting on why and where to start on trust measurement.</p><h4>What do you mean by trust?</h4><p>When organisations put trust as one of their Core Values (<a href="https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/when-it-comes-to-culture-does-your-company-walk-the-talk/">as 17% of US companies in an MIT study did</a>), it often isn’t clear what they mean by it. Is it an airy aspiration — ‘<em>we want to be trusted</em>’, a commitment — ‘<em>we commit to trust people by default</em>’, or a strategy — ‘<em>we want to be trustworthy, so people know they can trust us and we get the benefits of that”?</em></p><p>If they aren’t really clear what they mean, what they will measure? I also saw among the Core Values in the MIT study were many of the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47iH4w9WQ-g">7 signals or qualities of trustworthiness</a> (below). Those things which multidisciplinary research shows are the foundational ‘drivers’ of trust and distrust. Integrity was top with 65%, Respect 4th with 35%, Accountability 29%, Transparency 13%, Fairness 6%. But as the study also found that <em>‘there is no correlation between the cultural values a company emphasizes in its published statements and how well the company lives up to those values in the eyes of employees</em>”. One could surmise that they aren’t clear what they mean by those, and don’t take them seriously either.</p><p>I was intrigued talking to three organisations who really did take trust seriously, to find that they also had a set of organisational values. These weren’t connected to their trust work, even though some were not dissimilar to their chosen ‘trust values’ (usually 4 or more of these below) and certainly measurement of how they uphold them not considered. This must be very confusing, particularly to staff.</p><p>Perhaps these are a specific set of values that are oriented towards trust. Is therefore earning trust about taking seriously these Trust/Trustworthiness Values?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jeKn99b1MDa4ijV1mx4jgQ.png" /></figure><p>I went a bit pale at this point, because this meant I had to start to delve into all the stuff about embedding values. So I took a deep breath and, albeit not in an in-depth way, started to look. Here’s what I found:</p><ul><li>Core values are described (<a href="http://author Jim Collins">by Good to Great author Jim Collins</a> ) as — <em>values you hold to be so fundamental that you would hold them regardless of whether or not they are rewarded?</em> Sounds like a trust building thing to commit to.</li><li>These Trust Values are ubiquitous when people talk about trust and when they talk about organisational values.</li><li>But the measurement ideas I found uninspiring. I looked at <em>measuring adherence to values</em>, <em>aligning action and values</em>, <em>ethical assessment and measurement</em>, not much really detailed or serious stuff I could find there, and surprisingly nothing in HBR for example. There are bits on measuring individual areas, such as Integrity, but the most sensible and aligned to the sort of work I had been thinking of came under <em>measuring ethical culture</em>, <em>cultural assessment</em>, <em>measuring culture, cultural audit</em>.</li></ul><p><strong>Is measuring trust about understanding how in your culture and stakeholder relationships you uphold these Trust Values?</strong></p><p>I warmed to this idea and it is the basis of the ideas below.</p><h3>Taking Trust and Trust Measurement Seriously</h3><h4><strong>The galvanising power of the pain of distrust</strong></h4><p>Stephen Covey his book <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36076.The_Speed_of_Trust">The Speed of Trust</a> talks about trust as<em> ‘The One Thing That Changes Everything’. </em><a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fc12cea2cf09257bd6dcc01/t/5fce0a306f0099009e8a3140/1607338562569/TigTech_Trust_and_Tech_Governance.pdf">My own trust research</a> brought home to me just how important trust is, ‘<em>We make many trust-based decisions each day. Every time we pay for something, choose what to eat, what to buy, or who’s advice to act upon, dismiss or endorse — we consciously and unconsciously place trust in institutions, information, people, processes. Without these generalised and specific acts of trust our societies simply wouldn’t work”.</em></p><p>I won’t go into this in any more depth here, as lots of people, organisations and governments get by OK on low trust; but it is most definitely better to be trusted than not, and while as a society we might not want blind trust, (though companies might), organisations that can be trusted, and that we trust, make all our lives better.</p><p>Many years work on embedding ethics and values has shown me that the reason so many companies don’t take their values seriously, is because they are a bit nebulous and it’s hard to pin down why they are so important. And also why the companies that do take them seriously are the ones who have really felt the pain of distrust.</p><p>I did some research for my Masters dissertation in Responsibility in Business Practice and found that every company, except one, of those widely considered leaders in ethics or corporate responsibility, had at one time another had a disaster which led them to transform themselves from the bottom up. The head of CSR for this one outlier company, Novo Nordisk, was on the course and I approached her excitedly for her secret. <em>“Oh no’ </em>she said. “<em>we had a terrible disaster…</em>”</p><p>But how to feel the pain of distrust, when you don’t think it will happen to you and, err, you haven’t really felt it!?</p><h4>Get clear, get stories, on the pain of distrust and power of trust</h4><p>If you want your organisation to take trust seriously you need as clearly and <em>viscerally </em>as possible to feel the pain of distrust and understand the power of trust. If people don’t think it matters and there are not concrete reasons why and compelling stories to back those up, they will never take on the spade work that is needed. Needless to say if the leaders don’t feel this pain, it definitely won’t happen.</p><p>For some organisations it is clear why trust matters, which makes it easier to take it seriously. The UK Food Standards Agency, for example, a leader in trust measurement, was specifically set up to rebuild<em> </em>public trust in the food system<em> </em>following the failings resulting in the BSE (Mad Cow Disease) disaster in the early 1990s. Their mission is<em> ‘Food we can trust’ </em>to ensure<em> ‘that it is safe and what it says it is’. </em><a href="https://www.food.gov.uk/research/behaviour-and-perception/trust-in-a-changing-world">They researched trust</a> and now track public trust and attitudes to how it is delivering on its mandate together with the cultural values and activities internally which will help make that happen.</p><p>Similarly for healthcare organisations — it is not an exaggeration to say that for them trust is a matter of life and death. If people trust the healthcare system, particular health services, individual hospitals and GPs, they are more likely to seek help at the right time, report symptoms, follow treatment plans, attend screenings, show up for surgery and follow health advice. More likely to live, less likely to die.</p><p>As trust is an outcome and is bestowed on you by others the only way to see this clearly is to involve your stakeholders and simply ask (more of that later). But that is a big deal, and you will perhaps need your ‘business case’ for trust to get the money and the mandate to take that scary step.</p><p>This is not an insignificant exercise I know. But you could start small, with brainstorms. You will need to speak to all the major departments and people at all levels. Everyone needs another brainstorm like a hole in the head, but it is often surprising how intriguing the subject of trust is, though only if the purpose is serious, and not just a tick box exercise because it is the latest management fad.</p><p>Steven Covey distills the benefits down to Speed and Cost, but there will many day-to-day implications, inconveniences and problems of how work is made easier by trust and more difficult by the lack of it.</p><p>You could start by naming your important stakeholders on wall charts or mural boards or you could do some fun games or scenarios. The aim is to get some detailed answers to these questions and stories to support them:</p><ul><li><strong>What might they do and not do if they distrust us?</strong></li><li><strong>What might they do and not do if they trust us?</strong></li><li><strong>What could the implications be for us?</strong></li><li><strong>What behaviours of ours might cause these actions.</strong></li></ul><p>For some general prompts, have a look at this short vid on <em>The </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3D3k_6_2W1M&amp;t=94s"><em>Effects of trust and distrust here</em></a><em> </em>or a shorter 90sec version <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bNXhq4BPdsU&amp;t=35s"><em>6 things that happen when you are distrusted is here</em></a><em>)</em></p><p>It is also be worth remembering that trust is not a black and white thing. It is on a spectrum, from passionate trust to passionate distrust, with various states in between — see below. So think of gradations too rather than just one static state of trust or distrust. Not all distrust may be bad. Passive distrust, a sort of Trust but Verify state may even be healthy way to be. An illustration of how trust can move up and down that spectrum, and the contribution of the Trust Values, can be found in this short vid — <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fpctsYacUY&amp;t=2s">How trust is lost and can it be regained</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QK7y3zFyrio54C0OwultKg.png" /></figure><h4><strong>Mapping causes and </strong>behaviours <strong>against the Trust Values</strong></h4><p>Lots of factors might contribute to why people trust and distrust individuals and institutions — explored a little in the previous article on <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/taking-trust-seriously-a-starting-point-for-companies-8aa3861411bf">Taking trust Seriously </a>and <a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fc12cea2cf09257bd6dcc01/t/5fce0a306f0099009e8a3140/1607338562569/TigTech_Trust_and_Tech_Governance.pdf">page 60–67 of TIGTech report</a>.</p><p>Not all of these are under your direct control, but even if not (the weather in this pic), they will affect you and you need to try to understand them and factor them into your thinking on trust and distrust.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_B5bqGTQyaZi7e4uwagswA.png" /></figure><p>The next stage of taking trust seriously will be to start to understand and map causes and behaviours against the Trust Values and find out any gaps and surprises. This means you have to go directly to the stakeholders, internally and externally.</p><p>Trust remember is bestowed on you by someone who perceives you to be worthy of it. So you have to ask them. As my primary school teacher Miss Rowe told me: <em>“Do not Assume. Assume, makes an Ass of U and Me”.</em> This is very very true of trust.</p><p>Also remember, Inclusion, Respect and Fairness are two of the Trust Values. This is not about just about you. It is the first step in walking your talk and taking the Trust Values seriously.</p><p>This is the third article in a series that I thought I could do in one article!</p><p>The first is about <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/taking-trust-seriously-a-starting-point-for-companies-8aa3861411bf">Taking Trust Seriously</a>, the second on <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/measuring-trust-why-you-might-be-wasting-your-money-3216903809d5">Measuring trust — why you might be wasting your money</a>, and the next will explore methodologies for taking the Trust Values seriously.</p><p>PPS, sorry I promised first 4, then 5 mins, and this is 8! It can’t be done in the time I have, apologies for ‘not doing what I said I would do’ a cross in the integrity values box!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=db3333d022ae" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Measuring trust —why you might be wasting your money]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/measuring-trust-why-you-might-be-wasting-your-money-3216903809d5?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3216903809d5</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 30 Aug 2022 13:09:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-30T14:50:05.028Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*E5XPGtJbaeBG-7jPt8Go9Q.png" /><figcaption>SocietyInside, Aine Cassidy, Effusion</figcaption></figure><p>If you are an organisation who <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/taking-trust-seriously-a-starting-point-for-companies-8aa3861411bf">Takes Trust Seriously — the subject of my previous article</a>, you might be thinking about measuring trust. After all, <em>‘what gets measured gets managed’</em> right?</p><p>Yes and no. As journalist Simon Caulkin is widely quoted as saying <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/business/2008/feb/10/businesscomment1"><em>“What gets measured gets managed — even when it’s pointless to measure and manage it, and even if it harms the purpose of the organisation to do so”.</em></a><em> </em>Many well-meaning measures are not thought through and end up undermining the very goals they were designed for— any <a href="https://medium.com/centre-for-public-impact/what-gets-measured-gets-managed-its-wrong-and-drucker-never-said-it-fe95886d3df6">random Google search</a> <a href="https://nesslabs.com/what-gets-measured-gets-managed">will show</a> <a href="https://nesslabs.com/what-gets-measured-gets-managed">a variety of amusing, but sometimes terrible examples</a>.</p><p>This is because of another management mantra, <a href="https://hbr.org/2005/07/the-balanced-scorecard-measures-that-drive-performance?_ptid=%7Bkpdx%7DAAAA_2U9gDXyqQoKbWJzNzdxdHpVehIQbDc3Y2V5bXg5M2QxMzd3MhoMRVhTM04yRExGRkVIIiUxODA1djhnMGM4LTAwMDAzMG1ldGxmdm1zMDk0ZGNwdm1xcDk4KhpzaG93VGVtcGxhdGVIRDdGRjlQMDRNSUIzMzABOgxPVFVKNkxSUVRBUVJKM2hvdXNlYWRzLnNpdGUucGF5d2FsbC1hcnRpY2xlLXN1YnRvdXQ6MTY2MTE1ODAyNTE4MlISdi2qAPAybjRpbmtxeWY3dVomMmEwMjpjN2M6Mzk1NjphYjAwOjhjZDY6Y2U1YTphYTM5OjZlYTRiA2Rtc2iP4JyYBnASeAQ">what you measure is what you get</a>. Using measures and targets you are likely to get <em>precisely</em> what you measure and incentivise, and not the outcome which stimulated the measure in the first place. It is the reason the measures backfired in the stories above and the biggest problem with others. (Such as GDP and neoliberal capitalism — but that’s for another day!) It’s why I don’t recommend common trust measures like <em>‘we deliver on our promises’</em> because taking this seriously as a target could lead to organisations making only easy win, popular promises, not those which seek to address really big and difficult challenges the organisation faces. This is where Goodhart’s Law comes in — <em>“when a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure”.</em></p><p>Another reason to think carefully about measurement is that <em>‘what you measure is what you get’ </em>doesn’t actually apply to trust. If you measure and incentivise trust, you won’t automatically get more trust, you might not even get a better understanding of what it is and how it is affecting you or, more importantly, what to do to earn trust and avoid distrust.</p><p>This is not to say don’t try to understand how trust and distrut is affecting your relationships and organisational goals, but a warning that measures skew incentives and incentives skew behaviours, so think carefully about why you want it and what to do.</p><p>Many organisations have ‘Trust’ as one of their Core Values. But it rarely clear what they actually mean by that and so what to measure. Do they mean ‘<em>we want to be trusted</em>’ or ‘<em>we are going to trust people by default</em>’, or ‘<em>we want to be seen as trustworthy, so people know they can trust us”, </em>or is it, as proposed by author and academic Prof Joe Moran, more about <a href="https://www.timeshighereducation.com/cn/features/university-guide-depressives">“<em>hocus-pocus spells, bits of primitive word magic that are trying to make something true merely by incanting it</em></a><em>.” </em>Maybe!</p><p>Either way, the approach to understanding trust might be an indicator of how seriously it is taken. Based on their extensive research Barbara Brooks Kimmel and author Steven Covey have an amusing take on <a href="https://www.trustacrossamerica.com/blog/?p=5222">What Not To Do </a>in organisations who say trust is important, but without knowing, or perhaps caring, what it means.</p><h4>The 3 big areas of trust measurement</h4><p>Trust measurement is <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/323219380_Measuring_Trust">a vast and mind-boggling academic field</a>. It is genuinely hard to assess the relevance and usefulness of the many approaches. Here I am looking more at trust and companies and civic institutions, though drawing also on excellent work on trust and government from the<a href="https://www.oecd.org/wise/trustlab.htm"> OECD TrustLab</a> (and others) which focuses on trust in governments, societal trust and the effects of interpersonal trust more generally.</p><p>For companies or other institutions there appears to be broadly three types of measurement, or is it simply research, going on:</p><h4><strong>1. The external ‘Temperature Check’ — how much do ‘they’ trust us?</strong></h4><p>Leaders like numbers, so this is often a percentage — x% of people trust this organisation alot, a little, not at all. Sometimes the score is compared with competitors or other sectors. Often it is a proxy for a measure of reputation or focused on perception of brands.</p><p>Some more high level research like the <a href="https://www.edelman.com/trust/2022-trust-barometer">Edelman Trust Barometer</a> may provide top line issues which may have implications for trust— “companies need to worry more about x these days if they want to earn trust’.</p><p>A type of Net Trust Score, based on the <a href="https://hbr.org/2021/11/net-promoter-3-0?ab=at_art_art_1x4_s02">Net Promoter Score</a> concept may also be attempted. Organisations might try to find the indicator/s which distill the complexity of trust to one or a small number of vital elements which are seen to be important for earning trust — eg doing what you say you will do, communicating clearly, being honest and open — and figuring out how they are doing.</p><p>The board will then have a stat that says the company has a Net Trust Score of say 47%, or 56% or 75% . They might use it as a comparator with competitors or others and feel good or bad. They might be tempted to use it as a target — “We must increase our Trust Score to x% within 2 years,” but the data may not give relevant information on how to do that. Goodhart’s law kicks in and the door is opened to lots of methodological and comms tricks, rather than the cultural transformation which is likely to be required. Or, because it won’t move dramatically, except for obvious disasters, no-one will care and it is mainly ignored.</p><p>‘They’ is usually the general public, rarely does the trust question (as opposed to general satisfaction etc) seem to be focused on the various individual stakeholders of an organisation, each of whom will have a different relationship and trust the organisation, or not, for different reasons. A missed opportunity.</p><h4>2. The internal ‘Temperature Check’ — who trusts who</h4><p>(a) Interpersonal trust — do our employees trust each other?</p><p>(b) Leadership trust — do our employees trust us, the leaders?</p><p>These can be methodologically similar — questionnaires with a scale from 1–10 — sometimes, but not always, with qualitative sub-questions, often taken from academic literature, probing rationales for the scores.</p><p>This is popular currently under the umbrella ‘building high-trust teams’ and ‘trustworthy leadership’. It’s tempting to speculate from studies like MIT’s research <a href="https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/when-it-comes-to-culture-does-your-company-walk-the-talk/">When it comes to culture — does your company walk the talk</a>, which includes trust, commitments to building internal trust don’t seem to result in high-trust teams or trustworthy leaders, but I can’t find anything credible which will tell me either way.</p><h4>3. Internal and external — qualitative understanding of causes of trust and distrust and perceptions of trustworthiness</h4><p>Without real qualitative understanding of the causes of distrust and trust, the ability to use trust research, even measures, to guide leadership and develop a meaningful response will be limited.</p><p>Taking trust measurement seriously requires more than just a temperature check, it needs a commitment to deep understanding and to taking action in response to findings. Without it, particularly with staff, it is just another attempt at ‘trust-washing’ and will increased distrust and dissatisfaction, with the accompanying disbenefits. Less importantly, it will also be a big waste of money.</p><h4>The Trust Mindset</h4><p>Trust is a bit like ethics — if you are serious at being worthy of trust this commitment needs to permeate everything you do — your every decision, strategy, incentive, action matters. No wonder, like ethics, it easily becomes something to talk about, but not take seriously. It is really, really hard.</p><p>The hardest bit is a trust mindset which takes the commitment seriously. Particularly because this requires trusting first, in the hope and belief, though no guarantee, that you will be trusted back. Trusting first <a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fc12cea2cf09257bd6dcc01/t/5fce0a306f0099009e8a3140/1607338562569/TigTech_Trust_and_Tech_Governance.pdf">significantly increases the likelihood of being trusted</a>, it also <a href="https://www.trustacrossamerica.com/blog/?p=4595">increases the prospect of the other party acting in a trustworthy way themselves</a>. Automatically distrusting and so exhibiting more defensive, uncooperative or disrespectful behaviour yourself is, unsurprisingly, less likely to generate trust in return.</p><p>The next article in this series will be on <em>Why and How to Measure Trust — Starting with Distrust</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3216903809d5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Taking trust seriously — a starting point for companies]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/taking-trust-seriously-a-starting-point-for-companies-8aa3861411bf?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8aa3861411bf</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Aug 2022 13:17:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-19T17:45:02.178Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Taking trust seriously — a starting point for companies</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qcTo_r1MSg4Ave-tfUBPoQ.png" /><figcaption>For SocietyInside by Aine Cassidy, Effusion</figcaption></figure><h4>Being trusted is usually good</h4><p>Being trusted makes a big difference to what organisations can do —<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3D3k_6_2W1M&amp;t=178s"> if people trust you they are more likely to</a> want to work for you, fund you, buy your products or services, collaborate with you, be open to your new ideas, talk about you positively and give you the benefit of the doubt if things go wrong. If they don’t trust you, they probably won’t want to do any of those things. This is not good for business — t<a href="https://barbarabrookskimmel.medium.com/trustworthy-companies-offer-superior-investment-returns-with-less-risk-734456283727">he most trusted companies are in general the most profitable</a> <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/connection-between-employee-trust-financial-tim-vanderhoof">and have the most loyal employees</a>. (Though too much trust, especially of the untrustworthy, may not be good, and blind trust can sometimes be bad for all parties, more of that in another post!)</p><p>The extent to which you are trusted, or distrusted, depends mostly on how you behave, but can also be complicated by the ‘weather’ of external factors — such as shifting context, values and preferences (See pic above). The <a href="https://www.edelman.com/news-awards/2022-edelman-trust-barometer-reveals-even-greater-expectations-business-lead-government-trust">2022 Edelman Trust Barometer shows</a> increasing and fast changing expectations of companies and greater scrutiny of how they uphold and express their values, which may have big implications for trust.</p><p>And to make things more complicated, different people trust you for different reasons — trust after all is a lot about expectation fulfilled. If you are a business for example, staff may trust you because you treat them well, give them autonomy, fulfilling work and good remuneration. Shareholders because you earn them good returns, politicians because you provide useful products, good jobs, pay taxes and don’t embarrass them with bad behaviours. Customers may trust you because you deliver a product or service that they like, citizens and NGOs because you uphold the values they consider important. And all those groups are more likely to distrust you if you fail to deliver against those expectations.</p><p>So, it’s pretty obvious it’s good to be trusted and bad to be distrusted. But how to get more of one and less of the other?</p><p>Here are some ideas:</p><h4>1. Understand these 3 essential things about trust</h4><ol><li>Trust is an outcome — not a slogan, not a destination. It is bestowed upon you by others who perceive you worthy of it.</li><li>Perhaps like love and happiness, the more doggedly trust is pursued for its own sake, the more elusive it may become. Also like love and happiness, it is more likely to result from turning one’s attention outwards towards the needs of others, than focusing only on personal goals.</li><li>Trusting first, with the hope and belief, though no guarantee, that you will be trusted back, <a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fc12cea2cf09257bd6dcc01/t/5fce0a306f0099009e8a3140/1607338562569/TigTech_Trust_and_Tech_Governance.pdf">significantly increases the likelihood of being trusted</a>. It also <a href="https://www.trustacrossamerica.com/blog/?p=4595">increases the prospect of the other party acting in a trustworthy way themselves</a>. Automatically distrusting and so exhibiting more defensive, uncooperative or disrespectful behaviour yourself is, unsurprisingly, less likely to generate trust in return.</li></ol><h4>2. Take trust seriously</h4><p>Companies taking trust seriously is rare. Trust is talked about incessantly; it features in <a href="https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/when-it-comes-to-culture-does-your-company-walk-the-talk/">many corporate mission statments and sets of ‘core values</a>’, but as trust expert <a href="https://globescan.com/2017/03/14/barbara-kimmel-ceo-and-co-founder-trust-across-america/">Barbara Brooks Kimmel observes</a>: in reality <em>‘it is viewed as a soft intangible or ignored altogether until a crisis hits the organization. Then leaders talk about rebuilding trust when it never really existed in the first place.’</em></p><p>So the brown stuff hits the fan and there’s lots of headless-chickening and many, many workshops asking the question <em>‘How do we get them to trust us again?’ </em>Very often<em> </em>better communications and public education are the favoured solutions. But you can’t communicate your way out of a behavioural problem.</p><p>So let’s say you are unusual, you really mean it about taking trust seriously.(It’s unusual because, as <a href="https://sloanreview.mit.edu/article/when-it-comes-to-culture-does-your-company-walk-the-talk/">an MIT Sloane School report shows,</a> the correlation between a company’s commitment to its values, including trust, and how well it lives up to them is mostly zero, or reverse correlated!). Where to start?</p><h4>3. Focus on being trustworthy</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QUXMoKkEuYimkP8LnwaNdw.png" /></figure><p>Back to the iceberg again, and my favourite trust quote from guru <a href="https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p00ghvd8">Baroness Onora O’Neill:</a><em> ‘How can we restore trust is the question on everyone’s lips — the answer is simple. First be trustworthy. Second provide evidence that you are trustworthy.” </em>So why not start there.</p><p><em>Being trustworthy is the bit below the surface</em>. The outcome of the culture and incentives of the organisation and all the many many things leaders and staff do day-in-day-out. It is the cumulative effect of these actions which can enhance or destroy trust.</p><p>Then there is the <em>evidence of your trustworthiness</em>, which is your behaviour and communications as experienced by the outside world.</p><p><em>And then there’s the ‘weather’</em>. It’s also important that you are alert to how values and expectations are changing in response to what you and others do. (Open, inclusive, listening companies will find that easier than others.)</p><h4><strong>4. Get to grips with the 7 Qualities of Trustworthiness:</strong></h4><p>These 7 qualities are not just abstract concepts, or academic theories they are deeply rooted in our individual and collective psychology and the fundamental ways our societies work and have evolved. They are a great stepping off point for taking trust seriously.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xomh6t2NhNv1NrpV4abjmA.png" /></figure><p>They were the distillation of three years work on how <a href="https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fc12cea2cf09257bd6dcc01/t/5fce0a306f0099009e8a3140/1607338562569/TigTech_Trust_and_Tech_Governance.pdf">Tech governance can earn public trust</a>. I also used them as a framework for a commission by the <a href="https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/9639891">IEEE and Arizona State University to explore how AI soft law can earn public trust</a> (<a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/if-trust-is-a-must-for-ai-governance-what-do-regulators-have-to-do-12800b841b50">without paywall here</a>) to think about how the current <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/4-ideas-to-restore-citizen-trust-in-politicians-and-government-473a6d3e53c0">UK government might dig itself out of the trust hole it has dug for itself</a>; ongoing work on <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/people-are-not-the-problem-deterrence-is-not-the-key-learnings-from-healthcare-for-everyone-ec29f8615118">Trust and Healthcare</a>; <a href="https://www.tigtech.org/events/eccollaboration">Trust and Collaboration</a> and considering <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/why-the-question-how-can-we-be-sure-we-can-trust-the-contact-tracing-app-is-the-most-important-cc55d7fe4e05">Trust and Contact Tracing Apps</a> and <a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/trust-and-covid-19-bb63d61def90">Trust and government response to Covid</a> in the early days of the pandemic.</p><h4><strong>Getting started — more trust resources for companies:</strong></h4><p>To learn more about the 7 qualities here are <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47iH4w9WQ-g&amp;t=2s">30 second</a> and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_cSjcZLMmc&amp;t=66s">10 minute </a>YouTube videos about them and <a href="https://www.tigtech.org/">my report with other aspects of trust</a>.</p><p>There is also a free online micro-course <a href="https://app.mural.co/t/greaterthanexperience9110/m/greaterthanexperience9110/1626187166963/7068c59ce631a347e993894135d172e3555383ba?sender=ued56b27ef41d487ca07f0988">An Introduction to Trust and Trustworthiness in Practice on Mural</a> you can access any time you like. The course will give you an introduction to the foundational concepts of trust and help you explore how to better earn trust in the eyes of your stakeholders.</p><p>Or contact me on hilary@societyinside.com for a chat.</p><p>This is the 6th in a series of 10 Articles for August I challenged myself to do — The others are below and the next will be about Measuring Trust.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8aa3861411bf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[New letter to blood donors — response to a challenge!]]></title>
            <link>https://hilary-4230.medium.com/new-letter-to-blood-donors-response-to-a-challenge-d1346e538ab8?source=rss-8905a51ed4d1------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d1346e538ab8</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Sutcliffe]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 16 Aug 2022 14:31:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-16T16:02:12.280Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>New letter to blood donors — response to a challenge!</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/978/1*4fYASGvzS3pUv1ROitU89Q.png" /></figure><p>I got this slightly irritating note from the NHS, so posted it as my <a href="https://www.tigtech.org/trust-thought-for-the-day"><em>Trust Thought for the Day</em></a><em> </em>to see other’s views. I <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/posts/hilary-sutcliffe-01235220_trust-thought-for-today-manipulation-authenticity-activity-6964873409176428544-SrYO?utm_source=linkedin_share&amp;utm_medium=member_desktop_web">got some really interesting contributions on what is wrong and why it is heavy-handed</a> and also had a constructive and interesting direct conversation with the sender.</p><p>I was also asked what I thought it should say, as someone genuinely wanted to know <em>‘what a ‘good’ appeal looks like’.</em> Great challenge to stop simply pointing the finger and make things better! As I also work as an advisor on Trust for another non-UK health service, I thought it worth thinking about for that work too ( I won’t charge them don’t worry!).</p><h4>Why communications are vital</h4><p>I often think it is a crazy and wonderful thing that hundreds of thousands of people give their <em>actual blood</em> to help others, without payment, on a regular basis. If it was a new campaign promise now by some politician we would say it was ridiculous and people would never do it. But we do, <a href="http://I often think it is a crazy thing that millions of people give their actual blood to help others, for no money on a regular basis. If it was a campaign promise now by some politician we would say it was ridiculous!">and in increasing number</a>s. More than <a href="https://www.nhsbt.nhs.uk/who-we-are/a-history-of-donation-transfusion-and-transplantation/">5–6,000 blood donations are needed every day</a> in the UK, and around<a href="https://www.nhsbt.nhs.uk/what-we-do/blood-services/blood-donation/"> two million donations</a> are recieved and processed every year.</p><p>Without them many people would die, so the communications which inspire and motivate us to donate are vital. They have improved in recent years, the <a href="https://www.blood.co.uk/the-donation-process/the-nhsgiveblood-app/"><em>NHS GiveBlood App</em></a> helps you make appointments as near to you as possible and the emails are the stimulus which usually reminds me to go, are the sole reason I am a more regular donor than I was. I would donate more, if the donation centres close to me were open more regularly.</p><p>It’s no exaggeration to say that getting communications as good as they can be is a matter of life and death.</p><h4><strong>What about it didn’t work?</strong></h4><h4><strong>Overt use of ‘nudge’ techniques?</strong></h4><p>It felt like it was written by someone who has just gone on an Introduction to Behavioural Science course. <em>‘A committed blood donor like yourself’ and ‘as someone we know we can rely on’</em> are techniques to include me with the good guys, which supposedly makes me more likely to comply, than if I was pitched as part of an ‘out group’ —<em> ‘everyone is donating blood except you — </em>which used to be an approach, but was shown to be less effective.</p><h4>Too corporate, too blatant?</h4><p>This one felt too corporate in tone, too blatant in its approach. A LinkedIn commenter referred to the <em>‘transparent direct-marketing-speak of “that’s why we’re asking you, [</em><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/feed/hashtag/?keywords=insertnamehere"><em>#insertnamehere</em></a><em>], as someone we know…’. </em>That second ‘Hilary’ was a bad idea!</p><p>The fact that it came from someone with the title of Head of Donor Experience, rather than Head of Blood Stocks or something more operational or senior, didn’t help. And when I looked him up and found he was previously with Starbucks and the Virgin loyalty programme, it seemed to resonate with the approach taken by companies which is irritating but expected in a corporate setting, but felt inappropriate for the NHS.</p><h4>Trying too hard, seeming insincere?</h4><p>A few LinkedIn commentators agreed that this somehow looked like <em>‘trying too hard’</em>, <em>‘laying it on a bit thick’ </em>which feels insincere and ‘<em>more like a clumsy attempt at emotional blackmail’. </em>Also<em> </em>a very excellent point that most of it <em>“isn’t necessary if they actually believe you “know how vital it is” and are “someone we know we can rely on”!</em></p><p><em>‘Be that helping hand’ </em>as a heading, <em>‘book an appointment to save a life’</em> and <em>‘Please, do something amazing’ </em>are what I would classify in my work on<a href="https://hilary-4230.medium.com/some-buzzwords-are-not-irritating-they-are-tiny-works-of-genius-my-top-5-best-and-worst-e54fddd96944"> Bullshit as ‘Fluff’.</a> Essentially pointless, meaningless, patronising, more the style of advertising slogans or social media homilies than an emergency request from the NHS.</p><p>Another query stimulated by the odd tone, was whether this was indeed a ‘real’ emergency, or just a boiler plate email every so often churned out as part of the general donor appeal process.</p><h4><strong>Thanks to David Rose for the positive response!</strong></h4><p>Thank you to David Rose (the sender) for replying to my direct message on LinkedIn (for some reason I couldn’t tag him). He responded promptly and constructively: <em>“You’re absolutely right in recognising our templates were written several years ago when the ‘social nudging’ model was the norm in our organisation. Recognising that, and that our consumer sentiment has changed post-pandemic, we are updating most of our content in the coming months as well as investing in a new marketing platform to help us better personalise our emails.”</em></p><p>NB: Two important drivers of trust fulfilled here — responsiveness, honesty!</p><h4>So what to do instead!</h4><ul><li><strong>Explanations</strong> are important for trust. I am pleased to hear from David it is a template for when the stocks are genuinely low, but could there be some explanation for why that is, the school holiday period, concern about catching Covid? Does the service know why they are running short? It might then be helpful to respond with something relevant in relation to why, eg reassurance about covid security if their research showed this was a concern.</li><li><strong>Easier response </strong>— David says that they are doing more personalise this, that would be great. In particular links to location, as the proximity of the donation centre is an important factor for me, I live near London and I’d rather wait a month or two until it comes to the church hall or donation van a mile or so away than go 2.5–4 miles to another centre. If it came to me more often I would donate more often, poor show I know!</li><li><strong>Respect </strong>is a big driver of trust and while this is perhaps meant to demonstrate respect by showing that it knew I was a regular donor, and using my christian name, the association of this approach with corporate direct marketing techniques backfired and appeared disrespectful.</li></ul><h4><strong>How about….?</strong></h4><h4><strong>The heading:</strong></h4><p>Instead of a bland ‘Be a helping hand’, which is meaningless — it should have a recognisable alert heading that is only received when getting emails when stocks are low. The heading that only appears on the App, see below, does that well. But despite having notifications on, this doesn’t come to my phone and I only saw it when looking up the app for this article.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/518/1*_71TaGwivEesTw-t342dDA.png" /></figure><h4><strong>Proposed new letter</strong></h4><p><em>Dear Mrs Sutcliffe</em></p><p><em>We are running low on blood stocks at the moment, which often coincides with the summer holiday season, but can leave us short in the Autumn. It would be very helpful if you could make one of your regular donations in the next month or so to help ensure we have all we need.</em></p><p><em>If you are able to do that, this link will show your nearest donation venues and available dates — or just call us on xyz to make an appointment.</em></p><p><em>Thank you either way,</em></p><p><em>Yours sincerely,</em></p><p><em>Wendy Clarke, CEO, NHS Blood and Transplant Service</em></p><h4><em>Rationale</em></h4><ul><li>I wonder if a more respectful address than a christian name, which is OK in the app, but might be more appropriate in an email from a CEO? Unsure.</li><li>Intro gets straight to the point and doesn’t waste time and waffle.</li><li>Reason and explanation is given for the need, making it more current and less like a circular.</li><li>Clear and actionable ask stated.</li><li>Acknowledges regular donations without smarm.</li><li>Gives easy as possible way to respond in as personalised way as poss.</li><li>‘We’ is the blood service, not the stuff about the hospitals and patients and saving lives, we know full well what it’s for and the reminder is patronising.</li><li>Dithering about ‘Thank you either way, or Thanks you for your continued support of the Blood and Transplant Service’, or just Thank you. Or something better than support, which sounds like you are giving money. Want to thank them if they do or they don’t do it in response, for what they have done already.</li><li>Sign off from the CEO and no-one else.</li><li>Tempting to put some stats in about the numbers of people and 2million donations needed each year, but resisted, it makes it more salesy. Some great stats could be in the bit of the email below the letter?</li><li>‘Do something amazing, give blood’, is an OK strapline when used here, but not floating around in the initial letter.</li><li>And finally, I hope the job title ‘Head of Donor Experience’ also covers what happens when we are at the donor centres. I have had reliably pleasant experiences but others haven’t. That’s important too, the best letter in the world will struggle to get someone to donate if they have had multiple awful experiences, even to save lives.</li></ul><h4>Please feel free to be as blunt and critical as I was about the first one in the comments below!</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1012/1*ueDdbT5tdANZ_bkpO6r2hA.png" /></figure><p>This is the 5th in a series of 10 articles I am writing in August about things that interest me. The others are below.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d1346e538ab8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>