<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Hilary Anthony on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Hilary Anthony on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony?source=rss-3d245f3789fd------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 19:48:07 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Which Pleasants Married Which Woodson: Sorting Joseph and John Pleasants’ Eighteenth Century…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony/which-pleasants-married-which-woodson-sorting-joseph-and-john-pleasants-eighteenth-century-2d09a9ce24d7?source=rss-3d245f3789fd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2d09a9ce24d7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[quaker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virginia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history-and-genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy-research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Anthony]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Sep 2026 18:56:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-29T21:56:31.153Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*B8wOAFkCgaAG_fUwbRnF0g.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Which Pleasants Married Which Woodson: Sorting Joseph and John Pleasants’ Eighteenth Century Marriages</h3><p>Early generations of the Pleasants in Virginia present a familiar challenge for family history research. Immigrant John Pleasants in the first generation is followed by another John Pleasants in the second generation, and in the third generation, as many John Pleasants as there were sons. In the case of the Pleasants of Virginia, by the second generation, the Josephs joined in.</p><p>Researching Colonial Pleasants of Henrico County Virginia, I came across conflicting information about the marriages of more than one John Pleasants. Errors from secondary sources have been repeated and reposted in online family trees. John and Jane Pleasants’ children and grandchildren were birthright Quakers. The extant Quaker meeting records are, mostly, contemporaneous sources. I used Quaker documents to sort out the marriages and some of the parental relationships. The three secondary sources I compared are:</p><p><strong>The Edward Valentine Papers </strong>Volumes II and IV edited by Clayton Torrence, originally published 1927. (Valentine Papers)</p><p><strong>The Encyclopedia of Quaker Genealogy Volume 6</strong>, Virginia by William Wade Hinshaw. Originally published 1950. (Hinshaw)</p><p><strong>Historical Genealogy of the Woodsons and their Connections Part I</strong> by Henry Morton Woodson, originally published 1915. (Woodson Connections)</p><p>The conflicting information addressed here were within the second and third generations of the Pleasants family men who married women from the Woodson family. The Valentine Papers show many more John and Joseph Pleasants in the third and fourth generations, but this discussion focuses on three marriages.</p><h3><strong>The Edward Pleasants Valentine Papers</strong></h3><p>The Valentine Papers is 4 volumes of abstracts of deeds, court orders, and other records related to select colonial and early American families in Virginia. Volume IV has some partial family trees, constructed by the author.</p><p>Below is a partial descendant list for John Pleasants and Jane Lacome Tucker that includes the resolutions I have settled on. Throughout this essay, I used the number system from The Valentine Papers, volume IV to distinguish between the Pleasants. Arabic numerals are the unique numbers assigned to family members with biographical sketches. Roman numerals show the listing order of siblings. Most often that is neither birth order nor the order they are listed in the parents’ wills. I have tabbed indentations to indicate generations and listed children under parents.</p><p>My additions/changes are in bold. My abbreviations: m=married, m2=second marriage.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LHqQ41ka-Cvq0J25TO0cjA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Compiled by author from Valentine Papers Vol IV, additions/corrections in bold</figcaption></figure><p>Comparing the resolved family tree to The Edward Valentine Papers trees in Volume 4, pp2290–2297, to correct or clarify portions of the trees I have: 1. Added the parents of the wives from the Woodson family; 2. Used the more accepted Martha Cocke in place of Martha Coke; 3. Added 9 Joseph Pleasant’s second wife, Elizabeth Woodson. My reasons are as follows:</p><h4>a. Adding Mary Woodson’s parents</h4><p>i. 5. II John Pleasants of Curles III second wife Mary Woodson is listed on page 2292 of the Valentine Papers, referring to p 1203 for information about her. That reference goes to an abstract of Henrico Monthly Meeting Minutes for 3rd day, 1st month, 1749 in which John Pleasants and Mary Woodson declare their intention of marriage. The transcription of the marriage certificate follows on pp 1203–1204.</p><p>ii. The Valentine’s transcription shows: “John Pleasants, Senr, of the County of Henrico and Mary Woodson, daughter of Tarleton Woodson of the County of Chesterfield….” Recorded in the White Oak Swamp minutes (part of Henrico) 7th day, 2nd month, 1750. Tarleton Woodson Sr was one of the witnesses. The scanned copy of the marriage certificate online at Ancestry.com is in the Henrico Record Book for 1699–1767. The Ancestry.com screen is 361/437, linked here <a href="https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/2189/images/42483_1821100519_4136-00361?pId=1101907223">https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/2189/images/42483_1821100519_4136-00361?pId=1101907223</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oLkCNKrHYovo03pqmxN_XA.jpeg" /><figcaption>From Henrico Monthly Meeting Record Book</figcaption></figure><p>iii. Tarleton Woodson’s will was recorded in Chesterfield County in 1761, and lists Mary Pleasants (and Susannah Pleasants) as daughters. See documents for Tarleton Woodson L1JC-7HF on Family Search; a link to the will is under “sources.”</p><p>iv. The marriage of Tarleton Woodson, son of John, and Ursula Fleming, daughter of Charles, was recorded in Henrico Minutes for 23rd day, 6th month, 1710.</p><p>v. Mary Woodson’s death is reflected in Hinshaw’s as “1766, 11, 2 Mary, late of Curles &amp; w of John, d.” That is, Mary late of Curles, wife of John, died.</p><h4>b. Adding Susannah Woodson’s parents</h4><p>i. 8 John Pleasants of Picquinocque’s wife Susannah Woodson is listed on Valentine Papers p. 2293 with a reference to page 1194. The reference is to the transcription of their Quaker wedding certificate.</p><p>ii. The transciption is dated 7th day 9th month 1731. Susannah Woodson is called the daughter of Tarleton Woodson of Henrico. The Valentines abstracted omitted one witness: Ursula Woodson who was on the original, Susannah’s mother. The Ancestry scan of the certificate: <a href="https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/2189/images/42483_1821100519_4136-00209?pId=1101906917">https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/2189/images/42483_1821100519_4136-00209?pId=1101906917</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sn__1Kha0333ISngiCyStQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>From Henrico Monthly Meeting Record Book</figcaption></figure><h4>c. Adding Elizabeth Woodson and her parents</h4><p>i. Elizabeth Woodson, second wife, and eventual widow, of 9 Joseph Pleasants was omitted from The Valentine Papers family tree. Most of the children they had together were included, but without clarifying who their mothers were.</p><p>ii. According to the Henrico Record book, following Joseph’s first wedding, Quakers sent a letter to him condemning his marriage to a non-Quaker, noted on 2nd day, 5th month, 1726. Joseph was disowned by the Quakers. Valentine papers quote a severely worded letter with words like evil, Satan, and repentance on page 1192. Joseph’s repentance was recorded on the 5th day of the 6th month of 1732 and reproduced on Valentine’s page 1194. The Quaker Record book notes that Joseph presented a letter that led to being accepted back into unity. Valetines uses another source to find the spicier language they quoted. Joseph wrote “since my Committing ye said Evell I haive been much Troubled becaus thereof and Having through the mercy and goodness of God Been favored with a sense of his Forgiveness.” He did not mention that Sarah Goode had since died. The Quakers readmitted him to their Society.</p><p>iii. On the 5th day of the 9th month of 1732, 9 Joseph Pleasants, son of 3 Joseph Pleasants, decd, of Henrico married Elizabeth Woodson, daughter of John Woodson of Henrico at the Curles Meeting House.<a href="https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/2189/images/42483_1821100519_4136-00213?pId=1101783239">https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/2189/images/42483_1821100519_4136-00213?pId=1101783239</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BdlWc0aGEcI5cPdk6n4yZw.jpeg" /><figcaption>From Henrico Record Book</figcaption></figure><p>iv. According to Woodson Connections, Elizabeth was the youngest sister of Tarleton Woodson. Without being able to present an entire proof of Elizabeth’s identity, I can say that John Woodson, husband of Judith Tarleton, died in 1715 and left a will that names Tarleton, five other sons, Elizabeth, and one other daughter. Tarleton was listed first in the will, probably being the oldest son; the Woodson family history shows Elizabeth as the youngest, with a birth year of 1708. The will from John Woodson LC7D-BKD, showing Elizabeth, starts on this page of Family Search <a href="https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89P6-SGMY?i=41&amp;lang=en">https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-89P6-SGMY?i=41&amp;lang=en</a></p><p>v. The two children last in the Valentine’s list of 9 Joseph Pleasants’ children (Valentine pp 2295–2296), Joseph and William are listed as grandchildren in Joseph Goode’s will (see Family Search LZT7-D39 will dated 14 August 1761); those two were Sarah Goode’s sons, the others, Elizabeth’s children.</p><p>vi. Surviving court records show that Joseph left a will, and it was used by the court to appoint executors, including his widow, Elizabeth. See Valentine Papers page 1041.</p><h3><strong>Hinshaw’s Encyclopedia of Quaker Genealogy Volume IV Virginia</strong></h3><p>The Woodson marriages are a stumbling block for the Hinshaw Encyclopedia of Quaker Genealogy, Vol VI, Virginia.</p><p>To compile the Encyclopedia of Quaker Genealogy. William Wade Hinshaw, and several other researchers, extracted items from original Quaker documents they judged to be useful for genealogical research. The information is condensed. The Encyclopedia is best used as a finding guide, rather than as a source. Each chapter is a single “meeting” which had changing composition; within chapters, the listings are grouped by surnames.</p><p>Using Ancestry.com to access Quaker minutes has its own quirks. Ancestry has a hodgepodge of folios scanned, not always labelled correctly. Quakers kept minutes of local and regional meetings, and, sometimes, separate records of events like marriages, disownments and births. Their records also contain some collections of seemingly random documents. The researcher may find it helpful to read up, if not familiar, to appreciate the dynamics of the Society. To trace from Hinshaw to Quaker minutes, the researcher must keep in mind that the Quakers list dates as Day of the Month, Number of the Month, Year. Hinshaw lists dates as Year, Number of the month, Day. That is 8th day, 6 month, 1720 in a Quaker document would be 1720, 6,8 in Hinshaw. After 1752, when the calendar changed, Quaker documents occasionally mention the pagan name of the month as well as the number. Hinshaw does not reference if the source material was Men’s monthly meetings minutes, the Meeting Record, or Women’s Meeting Minutes, or Quarterly Meetings Minutes; sometimes all of those sources are used. It appears to me that each change of source document within a surname listing resets the chronological order of the Hinshaw entries. Ancestry does not have complete sets of all Quaker documents on online. We yearn for a universal search function.</p><p>To decipher the Hinshaw listings below: s = son of; m = married; MH = Meeting House; dt= daughter of; dec= deceased; Frs MH = Friends’ Meeting House; dis= disowned aka membership to Quakers revoked; mou= married out of unity aka married a non Quaker; con mou= condemned former action of marrying out of unity; rst= reinstated to membership; rmt= reported married to, information in lieu of presenting marriage certificate with witnesses.</p><p>For this project, here are the relevant entries under Henrico Monthly Meeting:</p><h4>PLEASANTS</h4><p>1731, 9,7 John, s Joseph, dec, Henrico Co; m.at Frs MH near Curles, Henrico Co., Susanna Woodson, dt Tarleton, Henrico, Co.</p><p>1732, 9,5, Joseph, s Joseph, dec, Henrico Co.; m in Curles MH Henrico Co, Elizabeth Woodson dt John, dec, Henrico, Co.</p><p>1750, 2, 7, John Senior, Henrico Co.; m in Frs MH near White Oak Swamp, Henrico Co., Mary Woodson, Henrico Co.</p><p>1726, 5,2, Joseph dis mou</p><p>1732, 6, 5, Joseph con mou &amp; rst</p><p>1732, 10, 2, Joseph rmt Elizabeth Woodson</p><p>1732, 3, 7 John rmt Mary Woodson</p><h4>WOODSON</h4><p>1732, 9,5, Susannah dt. John, Henrico Co.; m Joseph Pleasants</p><p>1750, 3, 7, Mary rmt John Pleasants</p><p>In the PLEASANTS section, the listings for John &amp; Susannah and Joseph and Elizabeth tie to the marriage certificates reproduced in the Quaker minutes.</p><p>The listing for John Senior and Mary Woodson are dated 2, 7, 1750. The notice from the 2nd month ties to the copy of the wedding certificate in the Henrico Record Book, and the entries for the 3rd month were for the announcements of the intent to marry. Meetings. Hinshaw omitted Mary’s father, Tarleton Woodson who was named in the certificate.</p><p>Under Hinshaw’s WOODSON section, Joseph Pleasant (shown with no parentage) is listed with his accurate marriage date, but shown marrying Susannah Woodson, daughter of John Woodson. He should have been shown as marrying Elizabeth Woodson, daughter of John Woodson. His brother John Pleasants’ marriage to Susannah Woodson, daughter of Tarleton Woodson was omitted.</p><p>I suspect that the editors of the Hinshaw Encyclopedia threw up their arms at trying to sort these characters. Here is my resolution:</p><p>John Pleasants Senior was John Pleasants of Curles III. He was the most prominent, and wealthiest, of these men in his day. He is also the most historically significant because of the lawsuit over his will, Pleasants v. Pleasants. In 1750, he was 53 years old. His first wife, Margaret Jordan had died. He married Mary Woodson. Woodson Connections lists her as the fifth child of Tarleton Woodson and born in 1718. If that is correct, she was 32 when she married. I don’t see any primary sources for that birth year. What did survive, and is transcribed on page 1027 of the Valentine Papers, is a premarital agreement of what assets the young wife would get if she were to survive the second marriage of her filthy rich husband.</p><p>Two of John Pleasants of Curles III brother’s sons had already married into the Woodson family.</p><p>In 1731, John Pleasants, Senior’s nephew, John Pleasants of Picquinocque had married Mary’s older sister Susannah. That is, in 1750, the uncle, John Pleasants Sr, married the sister of his nephew’s wife.</p><p>In 1732, John Pleasants Senior’s other nephew, Joseph Pleasants, had married Elizabeth Woodson, daughter of John Woodson. Elizabeth was Mary’s aunt. The uncle’s new bride was also the niece of his other nephew’s wife.</p><p>It appears that the Hinshaw editors missed some of the nuance of these connections.</p><h3><strong>Historical Genealogy of the Woodsons and their Connections Vol I</strong></h3><p>Here are selected listings from the Woodson line as reflected in the Woodson Connections. These descriptions are from the Woodson Family books. Errors are shown in italics.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_gnDeMxBCUky0u0gGNmBbA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Compiled by author from Woodson Connections with errors in bold italics</figcaption></figure><p>Woodson Connections mixes up the generations of Pleasants. Trying to make sense of the marriages that crossed generations, Woodson Connections author confused which Pleasants was which. In italics below are the incorrect mates from Woodson Connections, ordered from the point of view of the Pleasants’ tree, with Pleasants numbers from Valentines and Woodson numbers from Woodson Connections:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bzLAdBpiWcEakeUo3J_2Vg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Pleasants with numbers from Valentines. Woodsons with numbers from Woodson Connections.</figcaption></figure><p>The John Pleasants of Pickanockie/Susannah Woodson marriage is correct. John Pleasants of Curles II died in 1715; his widow, Dorothy, presented his will to the court. (Valentines p 1080). Mary Woodson married a John Pleasants in 1750. Joseph Pleasants Sr died in 1725; he listed his wife, Martha in his will. (Valentines pp 1092–1093) 28 Elizabeth married in 1732.</p><p>Here is the corrected version:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PUZGHmdJAmeMI5HQAgnjAw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Marriages reflecting the connections that agree to Quaker Record Book</figcaption></figure><p>Woodson Connections also confuses who was associated with “of Picquinocque” as an identifier. 3 Joseph Pleasants Sr inherited land at Picquinocque; when he left it to his sons, Joseph and John, he split it and described the tenants who lived on in. His will separately bequeathed his home, which was downriver from there. (Valentines 1092) There are no documents contemporary to him that call him Joseph Pleasants of Pickanockie. His son 9 Joseph, who inherited the larger share of the land at Pickanockie, has an estate inventory that distinguished between his home and the plantation at Pickanocky. (Valentines 1101–1102) There are no contemporaneous documents that refer to him as Joseph Pleasants of Picquinocque.</p><p>8 John Pleasants, son of Joseph, lived at Picquinocque. His oldest son, John was born there and lived there when he married. The Quaker meeting minutes began to use John Pleasants, Jr of Picquinocque to distinguish the father and son, but soon moved on to referring to the son as John Pleasants Jr, carp, or carpenter and the father as John Pleasants (8) of Picquinocque. The father continued to appear as John Pleasants of Picquinocque through the remainder of his life, and was noted as such in his will (Valentine p 1135).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OqD7TLj_m3752FixJip-rQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Henrico Monthly Meeting Minutes 1768 showing John Pleasants of Picquinocque and his son John Pleasants, Carpenter in the right column</figcaption></figure><p><strong>To Sum Up</strong></p><p>None of these books can be used as stand-alone sources. The Valentine Papers contains a partial family tree for the Pleasants, and contains transcripts of many source documents; there are occasional errors in both. The Hinshaw Encyclopedia is good as a finding aid if the researcher will navigate the quirks and verify the listings. Woodson Connections is a descendant project, with varying quality documentation throughout. It’s good reading, and hard to judge for veracity. Using these references as starting points, it is possible to follow up with more authoritative sources. For this project, I have relied on scans of Quaker minutes, transcribed documents in Valentines and some wills and deed read online from scans of the originals.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*pu8Zt48jIA7H0cN_t5qmPA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2d09a9ce24d7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Place Once Called Pickanocky: A Homeland Nearly Forgotten]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony/a-place-once-called-pickanocky-a-homeland-nearly-forgotten-8ccc8d5e52b8?source=rss-3d245f3789fd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ccc8d5e52b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[place-names]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virginia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quaker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[colonial-history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Anthony]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 03 Sep 2026 18:10:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-20T14:14:43.919Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_FuqTVMgOvN3lDP9xhqxwQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Author sketch of Henrico County between James and Chickahominy Rivers. The star marks Pickanocky.</figcaption></figure><p>The Picquinockey Quaker Meeting was held on the plantation belonging to John Pleasants of Picquinocque¹, a few miles north of Richmond Virginia. Trying to learn more about the place, I found a confusion of spellings, but I couldn’t find any on modern maps. There was Pequanocke and Pickanockey Plantation. There was Pequienock, Pickquanockque, and Pequenocky in deeds and wills; Picquanoque and Picquanockey meadow in court orders. From 1690 to1784 it was a meadow, a path, a plantation, a place, a person and a meeting house.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/941/1*pI7TdGW6mrK2obEY5Hp1kQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Variants of “Picquinocque” from Virginia Records. Secondary sources are not authoritative.</figcaption></figure><p>The Pleasants family handed down land in Pickanocky for five generations. Before that, Pickanocky was part of the homelands of the Chickahominy People. Under colonists, Pequanock became investment property, farmland run by tenants, then family-run plantations worked by enslaved people, one or two parcels possibly worked for a few years by emancipated former slaves, and eventually, back to commercial property. Descendants of the original investor generations clashed over their inherited land, and by the mid-1800s, their children and grandchildren looked elsewhere for a livelihood. The place name, knowledge of its original extent, and some of the families, disrupted by the tumult.</p><h4><strong>Beginnings and endings: Colonial Origin Stories</strong></h4><p>John Pleasants (1644–1698), the Immigrant, was the son of an English weaver. Soon after arriving in Virginia, he married Jane Lacomb Tucker. In 1678 John and Jane settled at Curles, on the James River just east of Richmond. Their neighbors included Randolphs, Woodsons, Cockes, and Byrds. Just 50 miles west of Jamestown, these colonists were at the western boundary of Virgina. In the aftermath of a failed rebellion led by Nathaniel Bacon,² Pleasants was among the colonists who petitioned for reforms that became a foundation for their fortunes. They petitioned for expanded claims on Indian lands, lower taxes, and fewer favors for Virginia’s elites. Pleasants and some of the Woodsons, as Quakers, also benefited from more accepting policies toward religious dissenters. They still “suffered” fines for not paying church tithes and war taxes but were free to attend Quaker meetings.</p><p>John Pleasants traded as an agent for London merchants, sometimes with local partners, sometimes on his own account. He brokered land, general merchandise, tobacco, and, at least once, kidnapped, enslaved Africans.³ Virginia was on the cusp of phasing out the labor of indentured and indigenous people for the labor of enslaved Africans. The Immigrant was part of the slave trade when it was a trickle; it grew to be a tsunami. Virginian Quakers participated in the slave trade as it was growing then transformed into an anti-slavery religion during the 1700s.</p><p>John Pleasants the Immigrant and Jane had two sons and one daughter together. They shared about 20 grandchildren, and dozens of great grandchildren.⁴ This narrative will focus on those who owned Picquinocque.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JEMn5HGrKlojKgeYfZ_LnQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Partial family tree. Use of mothers’ middle maiden names as children’s middle names is for identifying purposes only. The Valentine Papers identify Sarah Goode as Joseph Cocke Pleasants’ wife; Quaker records and subsequent civil documents, reflect his second wife, Elizabeth Woodson.</figcaption></figure><p>In his original will of 1690, and the codicil, written in 1698, Pleasants bequeathed about 10,000 acres, about 4000 to each of his sons. The codicil included newly acquired tracts he called Poquenackee and Poqunoke.⁵</p><h4><strong>Early English claims in Land Known as Pickanoque</strong>.</h4><p>In 1679, Henry Wyatt filed a claim, or patent, for a 900 acre tract along the south side of the Chickahominy River. The parcel was about 20 miles upriver from the clusters of population near Curles. Wyatt’s property was likely reached by old Indian Paths, perhaps Pickanocky Path. The path appeared in several patents of the time; in one, it crossed Shockoe creek, in others it crossed Ufnam creek (which has multiple spellings and eventually came to be called “The Brook,”) and in a couple, crossed Powhite Swamp and near Mattequin. In 1714, Wyatt’s neighbor Gilly Gormorin patented 292 acres “known by the name of Peckeynockey.” Wyatt’s claim was the heart of what became known as Picquinoque.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*33trWWUoZX8TWD2yPU1zJQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Wyatt’s 900 acre patent claim from Du Lac recreation, this drawn by author. The Chickahominy River runs from the NW to the SE, not W to E as shown in this sketch.</figcaption></figure><p>In <em>Henrico County Virginia Land Patent Abstracts with Some Plat Maps</em>, Bert and Selena Mayes Du Lac recreated the plat drawings for Henrico land patents from the metes and bounds descriptions. Henry Wyatts’ patent description starts from a gum tree on the Chickahominy River and includes four branches/creeks. Three are numbered. Only Cattail Branch is named, and that does not appear on modern maps. My sketches rely on their dimensions. I think the mouths of Upham Brook and Horse Swamp/Creek were included in the patent. It could be that Spring Creek was between Horse Swamp and Cattail.</p><p>In 1692, John Pleasants bought “2121 (sic) acres below Cattail Branch, part of a tract taken up by Wyatt called Pequenocky.”⁶ Other references to this parcel call it 212 acres.</p><p>In 1697, Wyatt sold the upriver 184 acres of the patent to Daniel Blanch. The deed calls the parcel “Locust Neck at Pequanock.”⁷ More than 50 years later, one of the Immigrant’s second-great granddaughters, Susanna Pleasants, married the owner of that tract.</p><p>In 1697 The Immigrant bought “all that tract of land being the remainder of a tract granted said Wyatt containing about 900 acres yet unsold…commonly known as Pequanocka plantation adjoining land lately sold Daniel Branch [Blanch], being part of aforesaid patent called Locust Neck on Chickahominy Swamp and run, against mouth of Cattail Swamp, running to land formerly sold (to) said Pleasants.”⁸</p><p>Looking past the grammar and punctuation, Pleasants bought what was remaining of Wyatt’s 900 acre patent. To add up, Blanch bought 184 acres, John bought a 212 parcel, then bought what was left, which in his will, was described as 330. Either some of the measurements or recordings were wrong, or a portion of the 900 acre patent went to another buyer. This second purchase by Pleasants, without a stated acreage, is the core of the property that stayed in the family for five generations. The Immigrant left it to his younger son, Joseph Pleasants. As the oldest of the Josephs in this narrative, we will call him Joseph Pleasants, Sr.</p><p>Here is how The Immigrant’s will described the property left to Joseph:</p><blockquote>that plantacon or tract of Land, by me lately bought of Henry [Wyatt] called Poqunoke containing about three hundred and thirty acres with all the stock of cattle of mine now upon it as well [also hogs and horses]….and that plantacon or dividend of Land by me bought of Giles Webb containing about 100 acres joyning upon the head of the Land bought of Henry Wyat now given him⁹</blockquote><p>John Pleasants the Immigrant added language in his will that would entail his bequests — that is, he placed a deed restriction to ensure the properties would stay in the line of succession and not be sold (except in the case of debt). Entailed property could pass to heirs outside of probate, adding another complication to tracing the Pleasants property.¹⁰</p><p>The Immigrant’s older son, John Pleasants of Curles II, inherited the 212-acre parcel. He took over the family business and home at Curles, continued trading, and patented and sold land, often holding mortgages. He married Dorothy Cary, had six children with her, and died in 1714, leaving Curles and the business to his second son, John Pleasants of Curles III. The will of John Pleasants of Curles III became the subject of the landmark case <em>Pleasants v. Pleasants</em>, in which his executor, son Robert Pleasants, challenged family members who refused to free the people he instructed them to. The older son, Thomas, inherited most of the entailed property and sold much of it; at his death, he was recognized for pursuing a spiritual path. Because of extensive land deals and property passing outside probate, the 212-acre tract is difficult to trace. We know it was no longer owned by a Pleasants in the 1770s, when a deed between a Pleasants and a Smith, who lived just south of Cattail Branch, defined the property line. Land sales and exchanges between John Pleasants and members of the Smith family had taken place for decades, going back to the 1720s. It may be possible to trace the tract’s ownership, but that is beyond the scope of my research.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PE8deODbbMgMF4CI9DmRCQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Wyatt’s 900 acre patent. John Pleasants of Curles II inherited the 212 acres below Cattail Branch. Daniel Blanch bought the uppermost 184 acres, not defined by a branch, probably including the mouth of The Brook. Joseph Pleasants’ 330 acres was between those two parcels, but probably not the entirety. This more closely approximates the angle of the Chickahominy River than the Du Lac’s presentation.</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Joseph Pleasants, aka Joseph Pleasants, Sr in this narrative, second son of the Immigrant</strong></h4><p>Joesph Pleasants, Sr. married Martha Cocke around 1700. After a short rebuke for marrying out of the Quaker faith, he returned and became a pillar of the Curles Quaker meeting, along with his mother and brother.¹¹ Joseph dealt in land and mortgages on his own account, sometimes in partnership with his brother. When he died in 1725, he made a specific bequest of one tract of land to each of his 5 sons. Most of the 4000 acres he inherited was not listed in his will. From deeds and contracts made in the following decades, it is clear that his oldest son, Joseph Cocke Pleasants (using his mother’s maiden name to identify him, not to establish it as his middle name), inherited a great deal of it outside of probate.¹²</p><p>The oldest son’s specific bequest, Joseph Cocke Pleasants’, was 300 acres of the Pickanockey property. His brother, John Cocke Pleasant, got a specific bequest of 150 acres of Pickanockey.</p><p>Joseph Pleasants, Sr’s will read:</p><blockquote>(to) Son Joseph Pleasants, land and plantation whereon Richd. Baze now lives known by name of Pickanockey, beginning at the mouth of Horse Swamp thence up said swamp to a large branch of the same, parting that plantation and the one which Richard Baze’s wife no lives at, thence up said branch until it meets Obediah Smith’s line thence along said line to head, including in said bounds the 100 acres formerly Thomas Robinsons, the whole tract containing by estimate 300 acres. Son John Pleasants, land and plantation whereon William Ferris formerly lived above Horse Swamp; also land below Horse Swamp from the great Branch bounding my son Joseph up the said Swamp and Obediah Smith’s line to head of my land, including the plantation whereon Richard Baze’s wife now lives; containing (both tracts) 150 acres by estimation.¹³</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PgBq4jmh6bReOvEFHRdr6g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Sketch by author. Interpretation of John and Joseph’s bequests in relation to Horse Swamp.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Joseph Cocke Pleasants, oldest son of Joseph Pleasants, Sr., and Grandson of the Immigrant</strong></p><p>In 1726, a year after his father died, Joseph Cocke Pleasants was also disowned by the Quakers for marrying out of unity. Sarah Goode was not a Quaker. They had two children, Joseph and William, before Sarah died about 1731. Widowed, Joseph rejoined the Quakers, married Elizabeth Woodson in 1732, and had more children.¹⁴</p><p>Joseph bought and sold land. He sold the half-share of a mill that had been his grandfather’s. He sold his inherited 150-acre parcel at Turkey Island to his cousin Thomas, who sold it to Ryland Randolph. His largest sale of the entailed property was over 1000 acres to Richard Randolph in 1729; Randolph subdivided and sold the tract.</p><p>I see no evidence that Joseph ever lived at Pickanocky. The areas closer to the Varina Courthouse, Curles, Four Mile Creek, and Turkey Island, were more settled, more developed, more desirable. His widow, while probating his estate, lived at Four Mile Creek,¹⁵ which I think is the most credible guess for where they lived together.</p><p>Joseph’s will is referred to by deeds and court orders, but the will is missing. (I say that after enlisting the reference desk at Library of Virginia to help me look for it.) What can be pieced together is that Joseph’s widow Elizabeth and his son Jesse were appointed as executors. An estate appraisal was made in 1757. The estate landed in court a few times. Elizabeth went to a judge to block her oldest stepson’s efforts to claim the entailed land Joseph had sold.¹⁶ Elizabeth made a deal that obligated her youngest son, Josiah, to ratify her sale of his bequest once he came of age.¹⁷</p><p>In Joseph’s estate inventory, the appraisers listed 3 working plantations: the home, Dover, and Pickanocque. Each listed tobacco, enslaved people, and personal property. The Pickanocque plantation had the fewest assets of the three and included Ned, Robin, Jemmy. and Doll, three “Negro” men and one woman.¹⁸</p><p>Joseph’s son Jacob appeared as a landowner in processioning records in 1767. I think this is about the time he moved onto what had been his father’s Pickanocque plantation. Soon after, he and his uncle were contesting their shared boundary line.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/435/1*0sHdb9Z4NhDDsVOzJNZV5A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Section of Fry Jefferson Map of Virginia 1751. Meadow Bridge appears directly north of Richmond.</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Upriver at Pickanockey where John Cocke Pleasants Lived</strong></h4><p>John Cocke Pleasants may have moved to the 150 acres he inherited at Pickanockey as early as the 1730s. In 1731, he and Susanna Woodsom married at the Curles Meeting House. John is in road orders and processioning records each decade beginning in 1735.¹⁹ He outlived his older brother by 20 years. He may have lived at Picquinocque for over 40 years.</p><p>Tenants had been on the site since Wyatt first patented it. To seat the claim, Wyatt would have directed some development of the property as early as 1679. Some clearing, some building, some drainage; people were required to live there. The outline of how the property would be managed began then. I suspect that John Cocke Pleasants increasingly took over the management of the properties, both his and his brother’s.</p><p>Picquinoque, somewhat remote when John inherited it, became more travelled and more populated as roads and bridges were improved and large tracts were subdivided. In 1721, residents of Pickonocky successfully petitioned the county for a road to connect them to the tobacco warehouses near the falls, that is, Richmond.²⁰ In 1741, Henrico County hired a professional builder to construct “Bridges over Chickahominy Swamp at Pickanocky Meadow, and the Causeways adjoining said Bridges.”²¹ The bridges were known as Meadow Bridges. The road connecting it, Meadow Bridge Road, became a major throughfare. In 1741, John Pleasants was appointed surveyor of the road from Meadow Bridge to the fork of the Road. Surveyors were responsible for road maintenance, and would oversee the work of “tithables,” that is free men or enslaved men and women laborers enlisted for public projects. The road went through John’s property.</p><p>John’s neighbors complained to the county that he was not keeping the road maintained, and that he had created an alternate route. They took him to court. In 1760, after a site visit, the court ordered that John was to either open the old road or make the new one convenient. Four years later, the county was involved again, responding to a proposed road through John Pleasant’s land to Meadow Bridges. The next year, a grand jury dismissed charges that he was not keeping the road repaired, and he was reappointed as surveyor of the road.²²</p><p>Quaker records include John and Susanna’s children as they begin to marry and move. Daughter Susanna married in 1762. Their son John married at his aunt’s house in 1764. James married for the first time in 1765, Ursula in 1768, Joseph married Elizabeth Jordan in 1768. In 1768, Archibald, James, and Phillip were all recorded as being in the limits of the Circular Meeting; they had moved to Goochland. With James’ second marriage, to Ann Randolph, in 1768, he left the Quakers. John’s oldest son, another John, and a younger son, Joseph stayed at Picquinocque.</p><h4><strong>When did he Become John Pleasants of Picquinocque?</strong></h4><p>The John Pleasants who married Susanna Woodson is referred to in several ways in modern family histories: John Cocke Pleasants, Captain John Cocke Pleasants, or John Pleasants of Picquinoque. In his time, he was sometimes recorded in Quaker minutes and deeds as John Pleasants, son of Joseph. He sometimes appears as “John Pleasants,” as do his uncle and several first and second cousins; context may or may not sort out which.</p><p>The first use I see of John Pleasants of Picquinoque is by the Quakers, in 1764, in reference to his son.</p><blockquote>Report being made that John Pleasants Jun., of pequenocy has….acted a very disorderly part of taken Sarah Cox to wife, contrary to the usual form among Friends.²³</blockquote><p>Three months later, the son was called “John Pleasants, Jun.” In the next monthly meeting, he was called, “John Pleasants, Ju. Carpenter.” By then he was making amends for his “disorderly conduct.” In the following years, Sarah joined the Quakers.</p><p>In 1768, when the Quakers were mediating between the elder John Pleasants and Jacob, “John Pleasants of Picquinocy” is used to indicate the dad. “John Pleasants of Pickeynockey informed this meeting…”²⁴</p><p>From 1768 on, John Pleasants, husband of Susanna, son of Joseph, was distinguished from his son, cousins and uncle being called John Pleasants of Picquinoque, including in his will. Over time the son was commonly called John Pleasants, Carpenter. Or John Pleasants, Carp.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/653/1*Yt_kI0yb4Yfr_NctgINaag.jpeg" /><figcaption>From Henrico Quaker Meeting Minutes, 1768, showing John Pleasants of Picquinoque, and his son, John Pleasants, Carpenter.</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Quakers Move to Pickanocky</strong></h4><p>In the 1760s, other Quakers moved to the Piquinocque area. Joshua Storrs bought Locust Neck, the 184-acre plantation just north of Horse Swamp. Storrs married John of Picquinoque’s daughter Susanna. She moved next door, bringing a Pleasants to that portion of Wyatt’s Pickanocky. An extended family, the Parsons, spread out to the north. Steven Woodson, related to both the Parsons and the Pleasants, inherited a 100-acre plantation adjacent to Storrs. Jacob Pleasants, Joseph Cocke Pleasants’ son, brought his bride Sarah to Pickanockey. They married in 1767, soon after his mother died. Sarah was the daughter of John Pleasants of Baileys, the oldest son of Thomas, who was the oldest grandson of the Immigrant. There were enough Quakers that the Henrico Monthly Meeting granted permission to meet for worship on the property of John Pleasants. The Picquinocque Particular Meeting started in 1768.</p><h4><strong>Certainly, This Was Not What The Immigrant Intended</strong></h4><p>Conflict brewed at Picquinoque. In December 1766, Jacob Pleasants and his uncle signed a boundary line settlement mediated by fellow Quakers. The agreement was to accept a newly marked line, in place of Horse Swamp, as the boundary between John and Jacob’s land. In 1768, John reported to the Quaker meeting that the boundary dispute continued. It may have been Jacob who filed the 1766 agreement in Henrico Court that year. To stay on the right side of Quakers, members had to get permission to take a dispute to court. In this case, the Quakers did not object to this issue going to court. We can assume that the Quakers, as well as John and Jacob, took the matter seriously. The microfilm copy of the court record is blurred; I can’t tell what portion of Horse Swamp is referenced.</p><p>The Court ratified the property line from the mediation. John told the court he would not honor the order. He said he would have his attorney, Dabney Carr, file his objections.²⁵</p><p>John’s new daughter-in-law, Ann Randolph Pleasants, was Thomas Jefferson’s aunt. Dabney Carr was Thomas Jefferson’s best friend and new brother-in-law. Carr and Jefferson were both attorneys, young, but well connected to the Randolph family. I don’t find other court proceedings about the dispute. Carr died within 5 years.</p><p>Perhaps for good measure, Jacob filed a property line settlement with his southern neighbor, John Smith, in 1773, replacing Cattail Branch as their boundary with a marked line.²⁶</p><p>Two hundred and fifty years later, I have a hard time sorting out where the original property lines were. Creeks have disappeared; some redirected. The old metes and bounds descriptions often use trees as landmarks. Over time, maps show different routes for roads. The location of Meadow Bridges changed from below the mouth of The Brook, to above. The Pleasants bought and sold other parcels in the area, and the size of the Pleasants’ holdings shifts. John and Jacob each ended up with more land in Pickanocky than the Immigrant and Joseph Sr. had devised there.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5ZvHYMWhtpb7tCNmdxBOFw.jpeg" /><figcaption>This section of John Wood’s 1819 map of Henrico county shows Horse Swamp as “Swamp.” The “Road to Meadow Bridges” cross the Chickahominey below the mouth of the Brook. Just west of Meadow Bridges, the Chickahominy River extends west, and The Brook branches off in a southwesterly direction. Gervas Storr’s house is marked, as is William Burton. Burton’s land may the parcel once owned by Stephen Woodson, and later sold to William Burton by the Parsons.</figcaption></figure><p>Seven years after the dispute went to court, in the spring of 1775, the Quaker meeting got word that John of Picquinoque and Jacob were again in conflict. The meeting appointed a mediator who learned that John had never abided by the terms of the earlier agreement. In the fall, the mediator reported a settlement.</p><p>My read is that John, and the tenants before him, had managed his 150 acres and his brother’s 300 acres as one plantation. There were outbuildings, fields, paths, drainage, and fencing established decades before Jacob inherited. John was forced to accommodate Meadow Bridge Road; he tried to reroute it. Parts of the land were swampy. He had two grown sons settled there, as well as over 30 enslaved people. He hosted Quaker Meetings. He may have been adding acreage during these years, in part because portions of his original tract were not useable. Then young Jacob moved in and challenged John to retreat from some of the land he was using. Maybe the issue was not overcrowding, but the location of built or natural features — fields, buildings, access, or woodlots. The last settlement brokered by the Quakers was not included in the minutes.</p><h4><strong>Quaker Era in Picquinocque Draws to a Close</strong></h4><p>In February 1776, Jacob died; just 9 years after he had married. By the end of the year, John of Picquinocque was also dead, at about 65 years old.</p><p>In 1770, John of Picquinocque had gifted his son Joseph Woodson Pleasants 50 acres that held the house the son lived in.²⁷ When John wrote his will in 1776, he was willing to divide his remaining acreage between Joseph and his oldest son, John the Carpenter. But if Joseph wanted all the land, he could buy his brother out:²⁸ that appears to have happened. John Pleasants the Carpenter bought 2 acres close to Richmond. Joseph of the 4th generation stayed in Picquinocque. John of Picquinocque’s will gave no land to the other sons and daughters. All seven adult children and two grandchildren were bequeathed between 2 and 8 enslaved people. The fate of those people held in bondage was set by that will. When the Virginia Manumission Act of 1782 passed, Virginia Quakers began to require their members to free people they held in bondage. The enslaved people in John’s will who were assigned to Quakers would be freed by 1788; those inherited by the children who had left the faith might not be.</p><p>Jacob Pleasants bequeathed his land in Pickanocky to his son John Scott Pleasants, with a life estate in half of it to his widow Sarah.²⁹ She married one of the other Picquinocque Meeting Quakers, Samuel Parsons. Their oldest son, Samuel Pleasants Parson, would become well known in Richmond. In 1783 Sam and Sarah joined the Quakers in Goochland, returning to Henrico in 1799.³⁰</p><p>In 1779 Joshua Storrs died, leaving “the land and plantation where I now live” to his young son, Gervas, with a widow’s interest to his wife. Gervas, by directions of the will, was sent to England to finish school.</p><p>Steven Woodson deeded his “100 acres at Piccanocqucy” to one of the Parsons children in 1770. In 1783, the Parsons children sold it, “a certain tract of land….known by the name of Pickey Nockey Plantation,” to William Burton. It was adjacent to Joshua Storrs’ Estate.³¹ The next year, William Burton bought 200 acres from Richard Adams, Jr., “on the Chickahominy commonly called and known by the name of Pickenockey.”</p><p>The Picquinocque Quaker meeting was put down, that is, closed, in 1778. John Pleasants the Carpenter and his brother Joseph transferred their membership to the new Beaverdam Meeting a few miles to the east and were eventually disowned.</p><p>As an adult, John Scott Pleasants, Jacob’s son, returned to Henrico County, running a mercantile business in Richmond. In 1791 he and his mother sold “429 acres on Chickahominy Swamp.” The deed includes a metes and bounds description that includes the phrase, “thence down Horse Swamp 98p, and continuing down said Swamp to an irregular chopped line between the Estate of Joseph Pleasants and said John S. Pleasants.”³² That line may be the one that Jacob and John Pleasants of Picquinoque took to court. Carter Braxton, Esq, a signer of the Declaration of Independence, bought the plantation and soon after put it in trust for his wife who could not sell it, but could pass it on in her will.³³ She lived there during her widowhood, then left it to her son Corbin Braxton, calling it “Strawberry Hill.”³⁴ Between 1948 and 2008, it was the site of the State Fair of Virginia.</p><p>After John of Picquinocque died in 1776, his son Joseph appears to have continued to live on the tract his father inherited. That is the homesite he referred to in his 1785 will, leaving it to his infant son, Joseph Carlin Pleasants. His mother retained rights to use the property during her life and was referred to as the property owner in 1799. In 1809 Joseph C. Pleasants married Susanna Burton, daughter of Daniel Burton. After Joseph C. Pleasants’ death, Susanna and their oldest son, Daniel, transferred the Picquinoque plantation, described at 400 acres, to members of the Haxall family. In 1841, there was reference to a lawsuit between the Pleasants and the Haxalls. Documents at the time called the property “Picquinocqui.” The Haxalls prevailed as the owners,³⁵ and soon transferred the land to a family business entity. I don’t have a deed by deed explanation for how it came to be that Joseph C. Pleasants died with 400 acres in Picquinoque when his grandfather inherited 150.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3AEJRHxwOkh2Kr6wvJvctw.jpeg" /><figcaption>This is a section of Stephenson’s 1864 Civil War map. The upper blue line is the Chickahominy River. Meadow Bridge Road has been redirected, and crosses above the mouth of the Brook Run. Storrs’ place is marked. Strawberry Hill is marked. “Piquenackey” is written along Horse Swamp/Creek. The first branch, that divided John Pleasants of Picquinocque’s inherited lower tract from his brother’s is visible. Entire map is on the Library of Congress website. <a href="https://lccn.loc.gov/2002627451">https://lccn.loc.gov/2002627451</a></figcaption></figure><p>There were still Pleasants descendants in Picquinoque. When Gervais Storrs, grandson of John Pleasants of Picquinoque, returned to Virginia, he didn’t use the name Pickanocky or Locust Neck for his country manor; he called it Hunslet Hall. Eventually, the railroad went through Storrs’ land. The railroad station was called Hunslet Hall. The property passed through several relatives and was leased out for years. In newspapers “Hunslet Hall” was used to refer to the surrounding area. The house Hunslet Hall was sold out of the Storrs/Pleasants family in 1891,³⁶ thus ending the Pleasants’ run in Picquinoque.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*gBhYRPGKAWWiXTOBq2E9LQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>1891 Richmond announcement of sale of Hunslett Hall.</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Holding onto a place once known as Pickanocky</strong></h4><p>There is a chance that the roots of “Pickanocky” are in the Algonquian language group. Very little of the Chickahominy Indians’ dialect has survived. Canadian geographer Eugene Rouillard, identified Picanock as Algonquian, meaning “walnut.”³⁷ If the Chickahominy of Virginia also used the word it may have used it as the name of a nut, a tree, a place, a path, a people, or a combination of those.</p><p>By the time of John Pleasants of Picquinocque, the spelling of the place more often appears similar to a French spelling of piquenique, or picnic. Could it be that the French Hougenot population had an effect on local spelling?</p><p>How big was the area Pickanocky? In 1721, the court records refer to “inhabitants about Pickonocky” requesting a road.³⁸ At least one other seventeenth century patent used a variation as a place name. I think it was a regional name, but not for a large space. At least 4 plantations were referred to with a variant of Picquinoque. Ultimately, the name became associated with the plantation owned by Joseph C. Pleasants.</p><p>I take the unsettled spelling of Pickanocky as a marker that the colonists didn’t have a common understanding of the place and its history. It was known locally, but perhaps not well known by the clerks who lived in the county seat, just a few miles away.</p><p>I find a poignancy about Pickanocky. For generations it was the home of the independent Chickahominy Indians, ending with the tumult of colonization and war. Then, more briefly, home to Quakers, through the tumult of religious dissent, revolutions, and slavery. They also had an independent streak — culminating in Virginia with their pacifism in the face of the American Revolution, and their increasingly anti-slavery stance. The Quakers were on the decline in Virginia at the end of the 1700s. The Quakers community at Picquinocque split and the family ties to the land there frayed.</p><p>And the enslaved people of Picquinoque? Was their time there affected by the Quaker population that was on the verge of renouncing slavery? Robert Pleasants of Curles was leading Quakers that way. Robert was a first cousin, once removed of both John Pleasants of Picquinocque and Sarah Pleasants Parsons. The Black families of Picquinocque would have been aware of the efforts some Quakers were making to stop slavery — and that not all the Quakers were supportive. After 1782, the Black people of Picquinoque would have known freed relatives and friends. The population of free Black people was growing in Richmond. At least one family freed by the Parsons bought property nearby. People owned by the Pleasants and their neighbors may have had a sliver of hope of change. Their connection to the land, like their chance of freedom, was conditional and tenuous. By 1800, the area surrounding Picquinocque was the nexus of the attempt to overthrow slavery known as Gabriel’s Rebellion. Gabriel was raised on a plantation just north of the Pleasants, just south of the Parsons. The tensions over slavery rose to a boiling point. The Quakers of Picquinocque were the generation that rejected slavery — but without eliminating slavery universally, the mitigation of suffering was limited. The enslaved people of Henrico weren’t waiting for the Quakers to bring hope.</p><p>The Chickahominy Indians, enslaved families, and the Quakers had generations of connection to a place once known as Pickanocky. The Pleasants’ family tenure there started with a windfall of land. Over generations, what may have seemed to be a chance to start a dynasty became a large, dispersed family with no continuity of religion or wealth.</p><p>The Chickahominy lived there for many more generations, but the memory they have passed on of the place is not complete. Their ability to tell the story of their land in their language was disrupted. The lives and stories of the Black families of the area are more centered on their difficult journeys than on their problematic ties to the land and place.</p><p>The poignancy of Pickanocky is like the fragility of the hopes we have for our coming generations. People there hoped for homeland, for wealth, for religious liberty, for liberty, or for family. Each generation had new realities to navigate. Memory of past struggles, like the name of the place, grows fainter.</p><h4>Notes</h4><ol><li>Quaker Meeting Minutes, Virginia, Henrico Monthly Meeting 1757–1780, page 151. Microfilm 78/160 on Ancestry.com.</li><li>Rice, James. Tales from a Revolution: Bacon’s Rebellion and the Transformation of Early America. Oxford University Press 2012.</li></ol><p>3. Valentine papers, p 1069.</p><p><a href="#_ednref4">4. </a>Valentine papers, pp 2290–2299. This family tree has some errors and omissions. It references transcribed wills.</p><p><a href="#_ednref5">5. </a>Valentine papers, pp 1061–1062.</p><p><a href="#_ednref6">6. </a>Valentine papers, p 1071.</p><p><a href="#_ednref7">7. </a>Add reference for blanch purchase</p><p><a href="#_ednref8">8. </a>Valentine papers, p 1072.</p><p><a href="#_ednref9">9. </a>Valentine papers, p 1062.</p><p><a href="#_ednref10">10. </a>Primogeniture and Entail in Colonial Virginia. C. Ray Keim. The William and Mary Quarterly, Oct 1968, Vol 25, No 4. P 561. Via JStor.</p><p><a href="#_ednref11">11. </a>Valentine papers, p 204.</p><p><a href="#_ednref12">12. </a>Valentine papers, 1092–1103.</p><p><a href="#_ednref13">13. </a>Valentine papers, 1092.</p><p><a href="#_ednref14">14. </a>Valentine papers p 2295–6 list wife Sarah Goode and sons Joseph and William. Hinshaw p 204 show Joseph returning to the Quakers and marrying Elizabeth Woodson in 1732. The settlement of Joseph’s estate refer to Elizabeth as his widow, and sons, Josiah, Jacob, Jesse.</p><p><a href="#_ednref15">15. </a>Valentine papers, p 1052.</p><p><a href="#_ednref16">16. </a>Deeds for eliz and joseph re sale</p><p><a href="#_ednref17">17. </a>Valentine papers, p 1052.</p><p><a href="#_ednref18">18. </a>Valentine papers, pp1101–2.</p><p><a href="#_ednref19">19. </a>Valentine papers, p 1262.</p><p><a href="#_ednref20">20. </a>Valentine papers, p. 858.</p><p><a href="#_ednref21">21. </a>Valentine papers, p 3.</p><p><a href="#_ednref22">22. </a>Valentine papers, pp 1042–1044.</p><p><a href="#_ednref23">23. </a>Henrico Meeting 1757–1780. P 85, in original. Microfilm 45/160 on Ancestry.com.</p><p><a href="#_ednref24">24. </a>Henrico Meeting 1757–1780. P 150. Microfilm 78/160 on Ancestry.com. Hinshaw’s Quaker Encyclopedia VI, page 206, incorrectly lists this dispute as being between John and Joseph.</p><p><a href="#_ednref25">25. </a>Henrico County, Wills &amp; Deeds, 1767–1774. Library of Virginia Reel 10, pp 59–60.</p><p><a href="#_ednref26">26. </a>Valentine papers, p 1053.</p><p><a href="#_ednref27">27. </a>Henrico County, Court Records: County Court, Deeds &amp; Wills 1767–1774, Part 1, P, 1–261.p 237–237a. Photocopy of microfilm via Library of Virginia. Note that The Valentine Papers, page 1051 incorrectly reference this transaction as being with John Pleasants and his son John Pleasants. The original shows John Pleasants deeded 50 acres to his son Joseph Pleasants on 3 December 1770.</p><p><a href="#_ednref28">28. </a>Valentine papers, p 1135.</p><p><a href="#_ednref29">29. </a>Valentine papers, p 1129.</p><p><a href="#_ednref30">30. </a>Hinshaw Encyclopedia of Quaker Genealogy, Vol VI, William Wade Hinshaw et. al, Geneological Printing Co, 1993. p 202.</p><p><a href="#_ednref31">31. </a>Henrico County Virginia Deeds 1750–1774 compiled by Virginia Lee Hutcheson Davis andGary Murdoick Williams, Heritage Books 2007. p 202. Henrico County Virginia Deed Book 2, p 4. Henrico County Deed Book 1, Cypalcorp, pp 38 &amp; 34.</p><p><a href="#_ednref32">32. </a>Henrico Virginia Deeds Book 3, 5 January 1789–11 May 1792. Cypalcorp. Iberian Publishing Company, Athens GA, 2014. p 44.</p><p><a href="#_ednref33">33. </a>Henrico County Deed Book 3. p 65.</p><p><a href="#_ednref34">34. </a>Elizabeth Corbin Braxton will on Family Search <a href="https://www.familysearch.org/en/tree/person/sources/L8V9-GJL">https://www.familysearch.org/en/tree/person/sources/L8V9-GJL</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref35">35. </a>Henrico Deed Book 56, pp 127–128.</p><p><a href="#_ednref36">36. </a>Richmond Times Dispatch. January 18,1891. Page 2. Via Newspapers.com <a href="https://www.newspapers.com/article/richmond-times-dispatch-hunslett-hall-sa/205080641/">https://www.newspapers.com/article/richmond-times-dispatch-hunslett-hall-sa/205080641/</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref37">37. </a><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picanoc_River">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Picanoc_River</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref38">38. </a>Henrico Virginia Court Minute Book 1719–1724, p. 131. Photo copy of microfilm via Library of Virginia.</p><p>Big thanks to my early readers, Jain Elliott and Norma Sax. Deep gratitude to Mary Ann Soldano of the Henrico Historical Society for clarifying documents and great leads.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ccc8d5e52b8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Samuel Parsons (1751–1820): A Quaker in the Web of Gabriel’s Conspiracy]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony/samuel-parsons-1751-1820-a-quaker-in-the-web-of-gabriels-conspiracy-6c27f052f4a3?source=rss-3d245f3789fd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6c27f052f4a3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[slavery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quaker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[freedom]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virginia-history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Anthony]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 May 2025 20:32:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-21T03:35:50.236Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Samuel Parsons (1751–1820): A Quaker in the Web of Gabriel’s Conspiracy (American version. see post script)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/815/1*3nRtTgoD_W_VWeShIE2ULw.png" /></figure><p>In the 1780s, Samuel Parsons sold a plantation a few miles north of Richmond Virginia. One of his neighbors, Thomas Prosser, owned three young brothers, Martin, Gabriel, and Solomon, who would be implicated in a conspiracy to overthrow slavery.</p><p>The rebellion, attempted in 1800, was thwarted by a deluging rainstorm and two recruits who betrayed the plan. In the aftermath, dozens of men were tried and hanged. Most of the evidence was testimony of a few enslaved men claiming firsthand knowledge of the conspiracy. Some said hundreds of rebels had committed to the rebellion; others said thousands.</p><p>During the trial, Samuel Parson’s name was mentioned as the possible owner of a man named Moses. Conflicting statements said maybe Moses belonged to Joseph Woodson. Or maybe Moses was free, or maybe Moses would be freed soon.</p><p>Those fleeting references to Parsons are recounted in <em>Whispers of Revolution</em> by Michael L. Nicholls.<a href="#_edn1">[1]</a> Samuel Parsons has a slight historic footprint. In contrast, his son, Samuel Pleasants Parsons, is commemorated in Richmond Virginia with a historic marker in front of his former home, stating “The Parsons family was part of a network of important Richmond Quaker families that were collectively involved in a series of abolition and prison reform activities.”</p><p>According to one trial witness, the rebels would spare Quakers, Methodists, and French men — all thought to be sympathetic to ending slavery. Testimony revealed plans to set fire to tobacco warehouses, fight white men with makeshift swords, seize the militia’s guns, kidnap Governor James Monroe, and inspire a revolution of liberation. “Death or Liberty.” There would be carnage.</p><p>Though historians have given Quakers little notice in accounts of Gabriel’s Conspiracy, Quakers and former Quakers had deep ties in Richmond and the rural neighborhood to the north, The Brook. I’m using Samuel Parsons as my reference point to trace Quakers through families in the conspiracy web — the network of enslavers and enslaved, neighbors, magistrates, journalists, and sheriffs. I contend that Quakers’ influence was a noteworthy factor, creating tensions and expectations in the years leading up to hundreds, maybe thousands, of men daring to attempt to overthrow slavery on a stormy summer night in 1800.</p><h4><strong>Section 1: Where Samuel was a child, 1751–1764</strong></h4><p>Samuel grew up on a 250 acre<a href="#_edn2">[2]</a> plantation about 9 miles up Brook Road from Richmond, Virginia. Richmond was getting started as Henrico’s county seat, not yet the state capital. It was a growing shipping hub at the falls of the James River. The closest Quaker meeting for worship was The Swamp, north over the Chickahominy River. Samuel’s parents were married at the White Oak Swamp meeting house, about 20 miles to the east. His mother, Susanna, travelled there regularly to represent The Swamp at the Women’s Henrico Monthly Meetings. Bits of information from wills hint that the Parsons grew wheat and tobacco; raised some livestock; and harvested timber. We have no information on the ages and skills of the folks Samuel’s dad, Joseph Parsons, held in bondage. With fewer than ten enslaved laborers, the Parsons probably participated in some of the farm work. In March 1763, when Samuel was about 12, his dad expanded the plantation, buying another 230 acres.<a href="#_edn3">[3]</a></p><p>Five months later, Joseph wrote his will,<a href="#_edn4">[4]</a> leaving Samuel 480 acres, half of which he would control when he turned 21, the other half after Susanna Parsons’ widowhood ended. The tracts were near the current day I-95 and I-295 intersection. By the standards of the day, 480 acres was a middling sized plantation.</p><p>Susanna Woody Parsons was Joseph’s second wife; the first, Sarah Woodson, had married him about 1717;<a href="#_edn5">[5]</a> Susanna in 1750.<a href="#_edn6">[6]</a> According to Joseph’s will, he had five children; the first three, Agnes, Elizabeth, and Joseph Jr, were adults when Joseph died. Susanna’s children, Samuel and Judith, were minors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-IFt_F2tAGlYvj-P_9fQ1w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Samuel, the second son, was the primary beneficiary of his dad’s will. Before remarrying, Joseph had gifted his first son, Joseph Jr, 464 acres,<a href="#_edn7">[7]</a> of land that he had owned for over 30 years.<a href="#_edn8">[8]</a> Deeds referred to that property as “near Half Sink” and “bound by Turner’s Run” that is, also near the I-95 and I-295 intersection, and the major north south road of the era, Brook Road. Joseph started the second chapter of his family nearby.</p><p>In his will, Joseph “lent” Susanna the 250 acres that he bought in 1749. Additionally, he bequeathed her Mille, and lent, during her widowhood, Abraham, Jemmie, Tobia, Isam, Izac, Dulse, and Sarah. Samuel and Judith would inherit the enslaved people after their mother died, or remarried.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qj2tdbxLzHegRrpioIiQfg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Joseph wrote a couple of caveats into his will. One, Susannah was to educate their children, as well as the enslaved children. Two, Joseph directed that no enslaved folks be sold to make distribution of his estate among his heirs.</p><p>Joseph chose three Quakers as executors, the first being Robert Pleasants.</p><p>Robert Pleasants (1723–1801), of Curles, was the 44-year-old son of the extremely wealthy John Pleasants (1697–1771) who owned thousands of acres, an international trading business, mills, taverns, orchards, and, by the end of his life, over 200 enslaved people. The Pleasants of Curles had been active as Quakers since the late 1600s.<a href="#_edn9">[9]</a></p><p>When Joseph Parsons wrote his will, it was illegal in Virgina to free enslaved people, with limited exceptions.</p><p>In 1757, with John Woolman in attendance, the Virginia Yearly Meeting adopted the Philadelphia Queries opposing buying and selling people, but the Virginians tweaked the language to allow for buying folks for one’s own use. The query also set out the expectation to “use those well which they are possessed of by inheritance”<a href="#_edn10">[10]</a> and to give them religious education. In 1764, the Yearly meeting directed care and concern for the clothing, education, food, state, and station for people held in bondage. Woolman’s influence of advocating the golden rule had permeated. Colonial Yearly meetings eventually reached consensus (some after reversing course) on prohibiting Quakers from buying or selling people.<a href="#_edn11">[11]</a> Virginia Friends arrived at that position in 1772<a href="#_edn12">[12]</a>.</p><p>Joseph Parsons seems to have complied with small steps Virginian Quakers had made toward rejecting slavery; he entrusted his estate to Robert Pleasants who would become a leader in anti-slavery activism.</p><h4><strong>Section 2. Samuel’s teenage years 1764–1769</strong></h4><p>At age 14, Samuel Parsons could choose his own guardian. In 1765, he chose Robert Pleasants.<a href="#_edn13">[13]</a> As a minor with a deceased father and an inheritance, Samuel was required to have a guardian to manage his assets and make financial reports to the county.</p><p>Meanwhile, Samuel was getting new neighbors. Directly south, Thomas Prosser began piecing together a two-thousand-acre plantation from tracts inherited and purchased.<a href="#_edn14">[14]</a> The Prossers moved in about 1765. The Prosser property was between the Parsons and Picquinoque, where two of Robert’s Quaker second cousins had recently settled on land they inherited. The parcels are further described as being south of the Chickahominy Swamp at the mouth of Horse Creek. In 1765, Quaker Joshua Storrs bought 184 acres “at a place called “Pickquanockeque,’ commonly known by the name of Locust Neck”<a href="#_edn15">[15]</a> Storrs then married one of the Pleasants girls. The older generations of the Owens family had sold land to the Parsons and Prossers, and gifted smaller tracts to the younger generations. Hobson Owen received 150 acres; Thomas Owen, Jr, 300, adjacent to the Parsons and the Prossers.<a href="#_edn16">[16]</a> At one time, Woodsons and Pleasants had large land holdings in the area; those holdings were being broken up by sale and inheritance.</p><p>One of the Pleasants cousins began hosting meetings for worship, and the Picquinoque Meeting was soon recognized as part of the Henrico Monthly Meeting. It was a small meeting, with Samuel’s nuclear family and several extended Pleasants families spanning three generations, about 3 dozen members.<a href="#_edn17">[17]</a></p><p>Over time, the Prosser plantation, Brookfield, stood in contrast to Samuel’s. The Prosser home was a five bay, two story building, with wings. Brookfield had two outbuildings devoted to cloth manufacturing; a black smith shop; two barns; and housing for almost 60 enslaved people.<a href="#_edn18">[18]</a> In 1783, Samuel offered Level Green for sale, noting that 300 acres was 2/3 cleared, “the plantation under tolerable repair, and includes 40 acres cultivated.” The house was 40’x18’, or 720 square feet, with a smoke house and free-standing kitchen; there were gardens, a woodlot, and orchards.<a href="#_edn19">[19]</a> Modest compared to the Prossers.</p><p>In addition to building a robust plantation, Prosser assumed prominent civic and business roles. He served as executor of several large estates. In 1772, he partnered with the Trents to buy a lot in Richmond near the old public warehouse; they described themselves as merchants.<a href="#_edn20">[20]</a> During the Revolutionary War, he brokered supplies and served briefly in the militia. After the war he helped recreate the county’s deed and estate files.<a href="#_edn21">[21]</a> He served as the Henrico High Sheriff, then a magistrate. Prosser was a force. I imagine him as bold, energetic, and on the make. Before moving to Henrico County, he was expelled from a Cumberland County seat in the House of Burgesses “for antedating deeds to his own advantage and for packing a jury to assess lands he wished to purchase.”<a href="#_edn22">[22]</a></p><p>In 1771, when he was about 20, Samuel participated in Henrico Monthly Meetings. His first assignment was to attend the Quarterly Meeting.<a href="#_edn23">[23]</a> Over the next 30 years, Samuel and Robert Pleasants attended many Monthly, Quarterly, and Yearly meetings together.</p><h4><strong>Section 3. Samuel’s family had more shattering changes</strong></h4><p>In 1767, when he was about 50 years old, Joseph Parsons, Jr, Samuel’s older half-brother, deeded the 464 acres near Half Sink to his two oldest sons, William and Josiah.<a href="#_edn24">[24]</a> Possibly Joseph Jr was sick. Maybe his wife had died, and he was providing for his adult male children before seeking a second wife. In a separate deed, he named his nine children and transferred ownership of a specific enslaved person to each of them.<a href="#_edn25">[25]</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sdr3MqDNVCtEqG7PnUZexA.jpeg" /></figure><p>A year later Joseph’s cousin, Stephen Woodson, made a bargain deed to benefit the nine children. Stephen gave Woodson Parsons, the youngest son, one hundred acres at “Piccanocqucy.” The three sons would split three hundred acres at Malvern Hills, near Curles. All the children would split the rest of the estate: household items, livestock, and twenty enslaved people.<a href="#_edn26">[26]</a> Stephen Woodson was a Quaker, but he made no special provisions for the enslaved folks.</p><p>Joseph Parsons’ estate inventory is dated 1769;<a href="#_edn27">[27]</a> it lists nine enslaved people, as well as farm equipment and livestock.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gP4uLicJSciN099TtKNZrA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Joseph Jr’s will seems to be missing. If the people from the inventory were also divided equally among his children, each child would now own 4 people.</p><p>One term of Joseph Jr’s will appears in a 1770 contract signed by Josiah, the second oldest son. “Pursuant to his father’s will” the contract bound Josiah as an apprentice to learn “the art and mystery of building houses, and joinery.” He was bound to a carpenter in nearby Hanover County until he reached age 21.<a href="#_edn28">[28]</a></p><p>By 1771, Joseph Parsons, Jr had died. His oldest daughter, Sarah had died, leaving a will that distributes assets from her father and Stephen Woodson among her 8 remaining siblings.</p><h4><strong>Section 4. Samuel comes of age 1771–1778</strong></h4><p>In 1772, within a couple of years of his brother’s death, Samuel turned 21. The Henrico Monthly Meeting made a big ask. They said that his brother’s children had no appointed guardian. And considering that Samuel lived nearby, and as he was executor of his brother’s estate, would he be the guardian for the minor children?<a href="#_edn29">[29]</a></p><p>There are 1773/4 guardian accounts for the three youngest children, Woodson, Agnes, and Judith. Samuel charged Woodson’s account for clothing, a teacher, and boarding. The girls’ estate accounts he charged for “maintenance” paid to Nathaniel Clark.<a href="#_edn30">[30]</a></p><p>Woodson’s expenses were paid, in part, with the proceeds from the hire of the boy Moses, and “sundry Negroes” from his brother William’s estate. Agnes and Judith were funded by the hire of Mima, her two children, a boy Isaac, and “sundry Negroes” of William’s estate. There is no indication who these folks were hired to, nor for what type of labor. This document is the earliest indication that the oldest of the nine siblings, William, had died and that the remaining siblings inherited the people he had owned.</p><p>At the same Monthly Meeting in which they asked Samuel to be guardian, Friends disowned Joseph Jr’s second oldest daughter, Mary. She had married out of unity.</p><p>Soon after, the Monthly Meeting had another ask. The “Picquinocy” Meeting needed an overseer. When consulted, the members said they thought Samuel Parsons most proper. He accepted,<a href="#_edn31">[31]</a></p><p>In 1774, Samuel’s sister, Judith, married the neighbor, Hobson Owen. She was disowned.<a href="#_edn32">[32]</a> Joshua Storrs, delivered the letter of disunity to Judith and read it aloud at the Picquinoque meeting.<a href="#_edn33">[33]</a></p><p>That same year, Samuel and his mother wrote to the Henrico Monthly Meeting seeking advice. They wanted to free the people they held in bondage, but as it was illegal to do so, what should they do?<a href="#_edn34">[34]</a> The Henrico Monthly Meeting noted that other Friends’ minds were weighed down by the same consideration.</p><p>In 1775, the Henrico Monthly Meeting questioned Samuel’s nephew Josiah about an act contrary to unity. He had bought an enslaved person from his brother’s estate. Josiah explained that he bought the person for humanitarian reasons.<a href="#_edn35">[35]</a> He maintain his standing as a Quaker until a couple of years later when he hired someone to enlist in the Continental Army in his place. Then he was disowned.</p><p>During the 1770s, three big issues dominated Virginia monthly meetings: young people marrying out of unity, pacifism in the face of revolution and owning people. The Virginia Yearly meetings focused on slavery and war; Samuel was in those meetings. In 1776 the Philadelphia Yearly Meeting invited the other five American Yearly Meetings to meet together for the first time to discuss the Quaker response to the conflict with the motherland. Samuel was one of seven representatives from Virginia.<a href="#_edn36">[36]</a> He was 25 years old.</p><p>Then Samuel’s niece Ursula married out of unity. She was disowned.</p><p>Niece Elizabeth married out of unity. Disowned.</p><p>Nephew Woodson enlisted in the Continental army. Disowned.</p><p>At The Swamp Particular Meeting, five of Micajah Woody’s children were disowned for marrying out and enlisting.<a href="#_edn37">[37]</a> At Picquinoque, at least 4 of the younger generation of Pleasants were disowned.</p><p>No doubt, some of the enlistees were inspired by the patriot cause. Some rejected the sufferings and simplicity of a Quaker life. Others anticipated challenges of a livelihood not supported by unpaid labor. To paraphrase Thomas E. Drake, leave the Society or leave the plantation.<a href="#_edn38">[38]</a></p><p>The dynamic of the Quakers was playing out among the Parsons. Samuel became increasingly involved in Friends’ efforts to oppose slavery; simultaneously large numbers of young Quakers left the Society.</p><p>The Virginia Yearly Meeting attempted to reach consensus about ending slavery among members. It was a slow go, continued from year to year. Early responses said it was necessary to involve Quaker women in this discussion, and that Quakers must take a stance on changing the law. The Yearly Meeting encouraged Quakers to talk to lawmakers if they knew any. Robert Pleasants certainly did.</p><p>After years of debate, in 1779, the Yearly Meeting said that Quakers should manumit enslaved adults. It was not legal in Virginia. The Yearly asked Monthly Meetings to report back the next year who did and who did not comply.</p><blockquote>We do therefore most earnestly recommend to all who continue to with hold from any their just right to freedom, as they prise their own present peace, and future happiness, to clear their hands of this inequity by executing manumissions for all those held by them in slavery<a href="#_edn39">[39]</a></blockquote><p>Here and there, the monthly minutes mention self-reported manumissions. Particular meetings were to keep a book of manumissions. These emancipations were not legally binding, and not filed with the county.</p><p>Meeting representatives checked if Quakers paid the people they had “freed” for their work. As for the Quakers who continued to hold people in bondage, representatives visited them; that continued until 1788 when enslavers were disowned. After that date, Quakers might own a person pending their coming of age, or if a person was too old or infirm to work, or under extenuating circumstances evaluated by the Monthly Meeting.</p><p>As beneficiary, executor, and guardian, Samuel had dozens of enslaved people under his care over decades. Complying with both Quaker discipline and civil laws was not always a smooth path.</p><h4><strong>Section 5. Samuel’s turn 1779–1798</strong></h4><p>In 1779, at 28, Samuel married Sarah Pleasants.<a href="#_edn40">[40]</a> She was Robert Pleasants’ cousin, once removed, and the widow of Jacob Pleasants of Picquinoque. She came into the marriage with two sons, and a daughter.<a href="#_edn41">[41]</a> Sam and Sarah married in a traditional Quaker service. Samuel’s only sibling to sign the certificate was his older half-sister, Agnes Woodson. She was still a Quaker.</p><p>The Revolutionary War was in full swing. Quakers advised one another to be neutral. Whether it was their pacificism or their close ties with English business partners, Quakers were suspected of not being loyal to the Patriot cause. A few were confined. Some forcibly drafted. Some tortured. The war took a toll on all Americans, with human, property, and business losses. The Quakers’ reputations and standing in the community took a hit as well.</p><p>Enslaved people found a few doors to freedom due to the revolution. The British offered freedom for runaways who joined their army. Some enslaved folks self-liberated by running, or sailing, away. After the hostilities ended, a law passed to free folks who fought with the Patriots. Laws passed to protect free Blacks’ right to defend their freedom in court, resist kidnapping, and have their children be free. Certainly, the talk of freedom and legislative changes raised hopes for folks longing to be free.</p><p>During the war, some Quakers who made illegal manumissions did what they could to follow through. Robert Pleasants set up about 80 people he inherited on a Henrico plantation named Gravelly Hill. They had a farm and a school. A plantation with 80 Black people acting as if they were free caught the attention of a neighbor whose letters of complaint survive.<a href="#_edn42">[42]</a> Early in 1782, Robert was charged with “slaves at large,” that is, “letting his Negroes go at large as freemen.”<a href="#_edn43">[43]</a></p><p>Samuel Parsons was brought to court on the same charge. Both Parsons and Pleasants faced a grand jury that let the cases proceed.<a href="#_edn44">[44]</a></p><p>Samuel’s plantation was about 600 acres. (He had expanded his holdings by 160 acres, in 1777.<a href="#_edn45">[45]</a>) Were the folks he inherited living in quasi-liberty just to the north of the Prosser plantation? As Woodson’s guardian (up to 1783), Samuel was responsible for managing Woodson’s 100 acres at Picquinoque and the people Woodson inherited; some of the enslaved folks “at large” may have lived there, near Prosser’s southern property line.</p><p>Both Pleasants and Parsons demanded a jury trial instead of being judged by the magistrates, who in addition to Prosser, included Isaac Younghusband (a non-Quaker in an acrimonious marriage with Robert Pleasants’ cousin), William Foushee (who owned 10 people in 1787); Nathaniel Wilkinson (who lived beside Prosser’s Brookfield and owned about 50 people).<a href="#_edn46">[46]</a></p><p>Robert was convicted of having slaves at large. He paid a fine, which he appealed.<a href="#_edn47">[47]</a></p><p>Samuel was acquitted.<a href="#_edn48">[48]</a></p><p>The Parsons/Prosser neighborhood was a checkboard of Quakers, ousted Quakers, and never Quakers. Joshua Storrs of the Picquinoque Meeting, had died during the war, instructing his executors that his two enslaved men should live with as much liberty as possible. John Pleasants of Picquinoque died about the same time, bequeathing enslaved folks among his children, some of whom remained Quakers.</p><p>Among Prosser’s non-Quaker neighbors were several who had been raised Quaker, including Woodson Parsons and Judith Parsons Owens. To the near north and west, there were more Quakers: Bells, Johnsons, Woodys, and more Parsons. Enslaved family members, divided by gift deeds and wills among Quaker and non-Quaker siblings, found their status of free or enslaved linked to the religious affiliation of who they were assigned to.</p><p>Freedom was a cause of the day — whether the revolutionary rhetoric about freedom applied to all people was still unsettled.</p><p>Before the Treaty of Paris was signed, a manumission bill came before the Virginia assembly. Quakers Warner Mifflin and John Parrish came from Delaware and Philadelphia to lobby alongside Virginian Edward Stabler. During the session, Mifflin and Parrish stayed three nights at Parsons’ place. In June, after two weeks of the Quaker lobbyists’ close watch, the Assembly passed the Virginia Manumission Act of 1782, making it legal to free enslaved men over twenty-one and women over 18.<a href="#_edn49">[49]</a> There was a surge of manumissions.</p><p>In Henrico, Robert Pleasants freed 78 people, more in the following years. The county court assigned Isaac Younghusband to assess whether Pleasants’ enslaved folks qualified for emancipation, that is could they support themselves were they old enough, but not too old?.</p><p>Samuel Parsons freed nine people. Five of the nine were under the age of full manumission and would remain under Parsons’ care until they were old enough to be freed.<a href="#_edn50">[50]</a> The court assigned Thomas Prosser to assess the people named in Parsons’ deed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bfXyKndmDCmj-f2Tb7d4_g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Also in Henrico County, Quaker William Binford freed 18. Non-Quaker Joseph Mayo, Jr, freed about 150. Others freed one, two or a handful of people.</p><p>Gabriel was about 6 years old during the “slaves at large” trials. He and his brothers lived with dozens of people who had little hope that Prosser would free them. Across Virginia, Black folks’ lives were changing — some freed, some promised freedom, some with family freed.</p><p>As Samuel traversed the maze of slave laws, had Prosser become the face of enforcement? As high sherriff for Henrico County, Prosser could seize assets for fines or taxes. According to the manumission act, the sheriff could seize free Black people who had not paid taxes and hire them out. From a separate new law, he could pick up “slaves at large” and offer them for sale. Would the children under Samuel’s care be safe? Had Prosser had a hand in the “slaves at large” charges? The risk and tension must have been high.</p><p>Soon after the slaves at large trials, Samuel put his property up for sale and moved 30 miles west to Goochland County.<a href="#_edn51">[51]</a> Samuel and Sarah joined the Genito Quaker meeting, part of the Cedar Creek Monthly Meeting. <a href="#_edn52">[52]</a> Samuel continued to be involved with the Quarterly and Yearly meetings.</p><p>He bought a 500-acre tract of land.<a href="#_edn53">[53]</a> The 1787 personal property tax list shows he had 15 Black children, under age 16, living there; the number of Black adults living with him was obscured by a tear in the original census paper.<a href="#_edn54">[54]</a> It’s possible that some parents of the children lived there, too.</p><p>Samuel, with several others, signed a deed as trustees for a half-acre tract for a school.<a href="#_edn55">[55]</a> Several of his neighbors were Pleasants — a few also recently relocated from Henrico.</p><p>In 1792, Sarah Parsons and her children from her first marriage, freed a 43-year-old woman named Silvie along with other adults and children.<a href="#_edn56">[56]</a> Was that the same Silvie Sarah’s dad left to her when she was a minor, over 25 years earlier?<a href="#_edn57">[57]</a> Had she waited for her own children to come of age to be able to sign off on the emancipation of people inherited from her first husband 15 years earlier? Sarah’s daughter, Elizabeth T. Pleasants, was widowed when she wrote a 1794 deed emancipating Cupid Dean;<a href="#_edn58">[58]</a> had Cupid come to Elizabeth through her husband?</p><p>Some of the Pleasants of Goochland were still Quakers, some not. The Pleasants of Goochland emancipated several dozen people. Thomas Pleasants held over 29 emancipated minors “in his care.” Within 15 years, the Overseers of the Poor had bound 14 “free negro children” to Thomas Pleasants — being either minors he had freed, or the children of people he had freed.<a href="#_edn59">[59]</a></p><p>In 1803, Joseph Foster released “all future demands of service a mulatto girl called Nancy White, alias Nancy Lewis emancipated by deed recorded in Goochland County court the servant of whose service I purchased from Samuel Parsons.” <a href="#_edn60">[60]</a> Sarah Parsons emancipated nine-year-old Nancy White in 1794; nine years later, Nancy was freed from bound service. The surname “Foster” is not among the Quakers appearing in the Cedar Creek Monthly Meeting. The release does not state how long the service contract had bound Nancy White or for what type of labor.</p><p>In 1774, the Parsons’ guardian report showed the income from enslaved minors’ labor supporting the Parsons children. Were circumstances any different, over 20 years later, for children who were freed, but contracted out pending their majority? The mind reels with all that was problematic about that situation. Not only was there potential for abuse, but also for family separation. More work is needed to establish how widespread this practice was, and whether Quakers, who were forbidden from purchasing the services of enslaved labor, were permitted to lease “free” minors.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s1Tfc3dOKVuz3HVcp_WX0A.jpeg" /></figure><h4>S<strong>ection 6. Samuel moves to Richmond 1799</strong></h4><p>In 1799, Samuel and his family moved and joined the new Richmond Quaker Meeting with his wife, Sarah, son Samuel Pleasants Parsons, daughter Margaret, and stepdaughter Elizabeth T. Pleasants.<a href="#_edn61">[61]</a></p><p>Samuel partnered with Joseph Anthony, and a third Quaker, Thomas Ladd, to rehab and run a merchant mill off a new canal.<a href="#_edn62">[62]</a></p><p>Richmond had changed since Samuel left. The Richmond canal was just completed, allowing shipments from above the fall line to be barged into the city. Samuel bought three half-acre lots close to the turn basin, using part of one to build a house, others to build an office, warehouse, and storefront. He offered warehouse space for flour and grain. He offered “extraordinary wages” for an employee of good moral character to build Windsor Chairs. He owned a mercantile specializing in hardware for farming and milling.<a href="#_edn63">[63]</a></p><p>Richmond was a boom town,<a href="#_edn64">[64]</a> small and rough by the standards of northern cities. The population had increased fivefold since Samuel left to 5000. It was the center of Virginia’s political and economic life. Merchants dealt in tobacco, wheat, coal, luxury imports, and people. The town was an unpaved construction zone, going from dusty to muddy and back again. Three story brick buildings were rising from the ashes of a wood town that had recently burnt.</p><p>Of the 5000 inhabitants, half were white. Among the non-white population, 20% were free, 80% enslaved. People filled the streets — on the docks, near the taverns, driving wagons, washing clothes, gambling, debating news. Free, enslaved, or leased, Black folks came and went. The enforcement of pass laws was lax. So much was under construction — roads, bridges, the penitentiary, the canals. Sailors and merchants arrived from the ocean; watermen arrived from the Piedmont plantations. Politicians came for business at the capitol; the courthouse attracted locals. Lodgings were rough for all but the wealthy — with dozens of bed frames crammed into hot rooms. Plenty of places to eat, drink, sleep, gamble, and carouse. White men loved the horse racing; those who could afford to, bred horses and traced blood lines, sometimes gambling fortunes away.</p><p>The town was a hotbed of politics. The degree of national control over states was in play, as was the status of slavery.</p><p>Several of Samuel Parson’s former neighbors from the Brook had property or work in Richmond — Storrs, Mosbys, Prosser, Pleasants, Owens.</p><p>Thomas Prosser had died a couple of years earlier. His 24-year-old son, Thomas Henry Prosser, inherited the plantation and town property, and about 55 people, including Gabriel and his brothers.</p><p>There were other deaths in the old neighborhood. Samuel’s nephew, Woodson Parsons had died in 1797. His will contrasts those of his richer relatives.<a href="#_edn65">[65]</a> Generally, the first listed “Item” would be to bequeath the oldest son real estate, and to provide for a widow. In Woodson’s will, the first Item directs his executors to sell “my man Moses” and use the proceeds to settle his debts. Subsequently, he gives directions to raise a blaze colt to 4 years of age, then sell the horse for the benefit of the children. Other assets he refers to in bulk and leaves them to his widow, Anne Parsons. If he held on to the land Stephen Woodson gave him, that would include one hundred acres, south of the Prossers, in Picquinocque.</p><p>Samuel’s sister, Judith was widowed. Her husband, Hobson Owen, had died in 1796. Hobson had bought and inherited at least 300 acres, some on Brook Road, adjacent to the Prossers and the Parsons old place.</p><p>In 1778, The Monthly Meeting combined The Swamp and the Picquinoque Meetings into Beaverdam Meeting.<a href="#_edn66">[66]</a> Quaker numbers were on the decline, not only in the Brook, but across Virginia.</p><p>The momentum of the Quaker manumission project had shifted. Enslavers were disowned in 1788; with exceptions for enslaved folks “in the care of” who were mostly minors or elders. The number of free Black people in Virginia had grown to an estimated 20,000. Some freed people remained in bondage due to heirs not recognizing their manumission, or kidnappers, or other failures. Quakers had actively pursued “freedom suits” to enforce the recognition of freed peoples’ status. Robert Pleasants initiated the mother of all freedom suits, challenging his relatives to free hundreds of people, as directed by his father’s will.</p><p>A law passed in 1796 to restrict Quakers’ testifying in freedom suits on behalf of folks held illegally. The House of Delegates tabled St George Tucker’s proposal to gradually eliminate slavery. Joseph Anthony reported to a national assembly of abolitionists in 1797 that feelings were low in Virginia. There was an opposition who saw a literate, mobile Black population as a threat to enslavers’ ability to hold people in bondage. Any heady optimism from the 1782 manumission act had faded. Legal paths to freedom were disappearing.</p><p>No doubt, Samuel was busy when he arrived in Richmond. In addition to his business interests, he became an overseer of the Richmond Quaker Meeting. He still had freed minors in his care, pending their coming of age.</p><h4><strong>Section 7. A year later. In the web of the conspiracy 1800</strong></h4><p>Amid a deluging rainstorm on the evening of August 30, 1800, members of the militia responded to a report of a slave uprising in progress. In the next few days, word spread that there had indeed been a plan that had washed out along with the roads and bridges. Conspirators were hunted down and arrested.<a href="#_edn67">[67]</a></p><p>By September 11, six men had been convicted and hanged. Of the first six, Samuel had a connection to five.</p><p>The rebel Solomon belonged to Thomas Henry Prosser, and was one of the brothers who lived next door when Samuel was in the Brook.</p><p>Ned had belonged to Anne Parsons, nephew Woodson Parsons’ widow.</p><p>Will belonged to John Mosby, Anne Parsons’ father.</p><p>Michael belonged to Samuel’s sister, Judith Parsons Owen.</p><p>Isaac belonged to William Burton; former neighbor, maybe the son of the deputy sheriff who seized assets from Samuel and William’s estate in 1774.</p><p>Among the men hanged the next day, two were from Roger Gregory’s plantation — the one Samuel sold in 1785. The other three were from Thomas Henry Prosser’s plantation.</p><p>Governor James Monroe appointed Miles Seldon and Gervas Storrs to investigate the conspiracy. They returned the judgement that Gabriel was the lead instigator. When Gervas Storrs (1771–1848) was a child, he lived at Picquinoque. His family and the Parsons worshipped together.</p><p>Gervas, the son of Joshua Storrs, was a birthright Quaker, his mother a Pleasants of Picquinoque, and his father a transplant from Brigghouse MM, Yorkshire, England.<a href="#_edn68">[68]</a> Gervas was six when his dad died. He was educated in England, then he returned to Richmond to claim the plantation and town property his mother and uncle had managed. Gervas’ inherited the inn where Mifflin and Parrish lodged as they lobbied for the1782 manumission act; Parrish called it “Widow Storr’s” place. Gervas did not continue his Quaker membership into adulthood.</p><p>Samuel Pleasants Jr (1772–1814) spent part of his childhood as a Quaker in Picquinoque. In 1800 he was the publisher of the paper The Virginia Argus, and of the political tract that landed James Thompson Callender in jail on charges of sedition. Callender went on to write jail house accounts of the conspiracy as the accused rebels cycled in and out of the jail.<a href="#_edn69">[69]</a></p><p>Samuel Parsons knew, or knew of, several other players in the legal fallout of the conspiracy. Mosbys were former neighbors and related by several marriages. Anne Parsons (Woodson Parson’s widow) was a Mosby. Samuel’s niece, Martha Owen, was married to a Mosby. Several Mosbys, as sheriffs, carried out the orders to hang the convicted men. Anne Parson’s nephew, Mosby Sheppard, and older brother, William Mosby, received information that betrayed the conspiracy.<a href="#_edn70">[70]</a></p><p>The Mosby family’s forebear, Edward Mosby was an uncle of Joseph Parsons’s first wife.<a href="#_edn71">[71]</a> White Oak Swamp Meeting worshiped in Edward Mosby’s house, until the meeting contracted him in 1722 to build the first White Oak Swamp meeting house. He worshiped with Quaker families that grew rich, including Pleasants, Woodsons, and Ladds. Edward left the Quakers, likely disgruntled, after delays and disputes about paying him for building the meeting house. Edward did not become rich. Older connections show up in Vestry records that order an Edward Mosby to pay for the burial of a Joseph Parsons and be guardian for a Judith Parsons — -in 1656, almost 100 years before Samuel’s birth.<a href="#_edn72">[72]</a></p><p>Among the magistrates at the Henrico trials, Pleasants Younghusband, was the son of an unhappy marriage between Robert Pleasants’ cousin Mary and Isaac Younghusband. In his 1795 will Isaac railed against Mary’s financial support for Quakers. Attempting to disown her, he wrote “I thought her a whore the first ten minits I was in bed with her.” Soon after the conspiracy trials, Samuel’s widowed stepdaughter, Elizabeth T. Pleasants, married Pleasants Younghusband.<a href="#_edn73">[73]</a></p><p>The landowning families had plenty of connections. Logically, the enslaved Black families did as well. The historic footprints of antebellum free and enslaved Black folks can be faint; but there are discoverable traces.</p><h4><strong>Section 8. Looking at the web of connections</strong></h4><p>What about Moses?</p><p>In 1768, Woodson Parson was deeded ownership of Moses. In the 1774 guardian report Samuel called Moses a boy. A rough guess is that he was born about 1760.</p><p>In Woodson’s 1797 will he directed his executors to sell “my man Moses.” Moses, under our thought exercise, would have been 37.</p><p>Suppose Samuel decided strangers should not buy Moses. Suppose he approached Woodson Parsons’ relative Joseph Woodson and said, let’s get Moses. So, they bought Moses, got him a job at the coal pits, and agreed that Moses could pay them back to buy his freedom.</p><p>Michael Nicolls describes the conflicting testimony about Moses, Parsons, and Woodson like this:</p><blockquote>A man named Moses is named three times by Gilbert, though never prosecuted. On the Foster list of September 9, he appears as ‘living at the Coal Pitts of Tuckahoe,’…. Moses was initially described as belonging to Samuel Parsons, but that was corrected to Joseph Woodson of Goochland, which could be in the mines. In a third statement, dated 23 September, Gilbert reasserted the ownership of Samuel Parsons and said Moses was to become free “at a certain age.” It is possible they are all the same man.<a href="#_edn74">[74]</a></blockquote><p>The name Moses was common; my thought exercise is not proof that this is the same person. Perhaps Woodson’s Moses was never freed.</p><p><strong>Section 9. Samuel’s final years 1800–1820</strong></p><p>The partnership between Samuel Parsons, Joseph Anthony, and Thomas Ladd ended in dispute around 1801. The conflict stretched out for several years. Samuel continued a mercantile business with his son, but in the last ten years of his life, his businesses were overcome with debt. He and his son dissolved their partnership. Samuel was forced to sell two downtown lots — the creditors, his former mill partner, Thomas Ladd, and his dad Amos Ladd. Other creditors forced the sale of his partially completed home. It was a rough finale.<a href="#_edn75">[75]</a></p><p>Samuel’s son, Samuel Pleasants Parsons continued as a merchant. More famously, he became the prison superintendent of the new, massive penitentiary. Through him, some memory of the original Virginian Quakers lives on.</p><h4><strong>Section 10. “Permitting the African race to enjoy those rights endowed by nature”</strong></h4><p>Samuel’s 1820 obituary follows:</p><blockquote>Departed this life at his son’s, near this city, on the 25th last. SAMUEL PARSONS, (an old and respectable member of the society of Friends) after a short illness which he bore with that resignation characteristic of the true christian. From early life he was a strong advocate for those principles set forth in the declaration of independence and the Virginia Bill of Rights, “that all men are by nature equally free.”…[ellipses in original] Under this influence he was amongst first in Virginia convinced of the injustice of slavery, and emancipated those that he inherited coeval with the law, permitting the African race to enjoy those rights endowed by nature to all mankind.<a href="#_edn76">[76]</a></blockquote><p>There are possible traces of the folks Parsons freed.</p><p>In Henrico County Personal Property tax rolls, Pompey Parsons, FN (free negro) appeared in 1789 with two horses and 5 head of cattle.<a href="#_edn77">[77]</a> A Pompey was in Joseph Parsons estate inventory 20 years earlier. In 1784, Josiah, Joseph Jr’s second oldest son, freed Pompey by deed.<a href="#_edn78">[78]</a></p><p>In 1802 Make Parsons FN had one horse; Make appears in the list of folks Samuel freed in 1782. So does, Tabitha. In 1803 Tabitha Parsons FN was listed owning one slave over 16 and one horse. In 1811 Tabitha had 18 ½ acres on Turnpike Road. According to Samuel’s 1782 deed, Makey was born in 1762, Tabitha in 1771.<a href="#_edn79">[79]</a></p><p>Nancy, born in 1760, was freed in 1782. Is she Nancy Parsons, “a free woman of color,” who was arrested the early 1800s in Richmond? The first arrest was for stabbing “Nelly a mulatto female slave.” The second for running a disorderly house with men and women, “drinking, whoring, tippling, and otherwise misbehaving themselves.” And third, two years later, running a faro bank. Rough and tumble.<a href="#_edn80">[80]</a></p><p>Near Half Sink, the Sheppard Family’s Meadow Farm is preserved as a park, with an interpretive center, “Parsons Community Center,” named after the family of enslaved folks on the plantation in the 1800s. Nancy Parsons of Caroline County was the matriarch. Is this Nancy related to other Henrico Parsons?</p><p>There was “Charles Dilsey alias Parsons” who was able to emancipate his own wife in 1792<a href="#_edn81">[81]</a>.</p><p>Aaron Parsons, waterman, petitioned to stay in Virginia after he was emancipated. He was freed after the 1806 law requiring newly freed people to leave Virginia. Aaron’s emancipation papers linked him to Quakers that Samuel had business ties to — Maules and Ladds.<a href="#_edn82">[82]</a></p><p>There are many names and lives that can only be remembered as part of the sweep of history, but there are lives that can be discovered, if we will take the time to find the traces they left. In Richmond, public historians and activists working with descendants and community members to honor the lives of forebears who struggled for freedom. Historians, archivists, genealogists and librarians are bringing light to lives previously not well represented in historic accounts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KMz0DHr9cheU-7uIf6JICQ.png" /></figure><h4><strong>Section 11. The web of conspiracy and the influence of Quakers</strong></h4><p>In the aftermath of the conspiracy trials, newspapers debated whether talk of “Liberty and Equality” had given enslaved people dangerous ideas. Blame was cast at southerners, particularly the Francophiles like Presidential candidate Thomas Jefferson. Liberty and equality became a partisan issue. Journalists then, and to a large degree, historians of the era, have overlooked that Quakers were advocating for freedom and the natural rights of all people in the geographic nexus of Gabriel’s conspiracy.</p><p>In Richmond, Warner Mifflin lobbied for the emancipation act referring to the founding documents’ support for natural rights of all people;<a href="#_edn83">[83]</a> Parsons’ obituary emphasized the universality of natural rights as stated in the Declaration of Independence. Many Quaker-written emancipation documents gave natural rights as the justification for freeing people.</p><p>The 20 years following the revolution dashed hopes of the enslaved and the would-be abolitionists that the American Revolution would bring freedom for all people. I would like to emphasize that the limited reach of private manumission, and the subsequent legal roadblocks, were among the factors that pointed enslaved folks toward direct action.</p><p>Some great scholarship has been done on Gabriel’s Conspiracy in the past couple of decades. There is more to be done to connect threads of the complicated web. I started this project wondering if I could trace who Samuel Parsons was related to. I ended it with three insights: 1. that Gabriel, Solomon, Martin, and Thomas Prosser had lived among Quakers as the Religious Society of Friends transformed to reject slavery; 2. The Virginia Manumission Act of 1782 could have put children in harm’s way and contributed to family separation. 3. More can be done to investigate Black families’ connections in the web of Gabriel’s Conspiracy.</p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — -</p><p>Postscript: A revised version of this essay was published in the Summer 2025 issue of a British journal, Quaker Studies. This American version is less formal and has not been subject to the same rigor in editing. The British version of this essay is here. <a href="https://doi.org/10.16995/qs.23858">https://doi.org/10.16995/qs.23858</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref1">[1]</a> Nicholls, Michael L. <em>Whispers of Rebellion: Narrating Gabriel’s Conspiracy</em>. First. Virginia: University of Virginia Press, 2013.</p><p><a href="#_ednref2">[2]</a> Davis, Virginia Lee Hutcheson, and Gary Murdock Williams, eds. <em>Henrico County Virginia Deed 1750–1774</em>. Westminister MD: Heritage Books, 2007, p. 1; Weisiger, III, Benjamin B, ed. <em>Henrico County Virginia Colonial Deeds 1737–1750</em>. Reprinted 1995. Athens, GA: Iberian Publishing Company, 1985, p. 75.</p><p><a href="#_ednref3">[3]</a> Davis, <em>Henrico Deeds</em> 1750–1774, p. 114.</p><p><a href="#_ednref4">[4]</a> Miscellaneous Wills of Virginia, 1675–1884; Henry E. Huntington Library. (via Ancestry.com, 177/379) other locator: Brook Collection (BR Box 221) The Huntington Library, San Marino California.</p><p><a href="#_ednref5">[5]</a> Torrence, Clayton, ed. <em>The Edward Pleasants Valentine Papers</em>. Vol. I–IV. 4 vols. Richmond, VA: Clearfield, 1927, III, 1998, p. 1998.</p><p><a href="#_ednref6">[6]</a> Monthly Meeting of Friends in Henrico County, via Ancestry.com microfilm; The Record Book 1699–1757; 356/437, screen; p. 347.</p><p><a href="#_ednref7">[7]</a> Weisiger, Henrico Deeds 1737–1750, p. 130.</p><p><a href="#_ednref8">[8]</a> Torrence, Valentine Papers, III 2006, acquiring 464 acres in 2 purchases, p. 1886, selling land in Goochland gifted to Sarah after marriage.</p><p><a href="#_ednref9">[9]</a> Hardin, William Fernandez. “Litigating the Lash: Quaker Emancipator Robert Pleasants, The Law of Slavery, and the Meaning of Manumission in Revolutionary and Early National Virginia.” PhD dissertation, Vanderbilt University, 2013.</p><p><a href="#_ednref10">[10]</a> Virginia Yearly Meeting, via Ancestry.com microfilm. Typed mss; p. 95.</p><p><a href="#_ednref11">[11]</a> Drake, Thomas E., Quakers and Slavery in America; Glouster MA USA; Yale University Press; 1950; 1965 reprint, pp. 59–60.</p><p><a href="#_ednref12">[12]</a> Virginia Yearly Meeting, via Ancestry.com microfilm. Typed mss; p. 156.</p><p><a href="#_ednref13">[13]</a> Henrico Order Book 1763–67; October 7, 1765, document page 526; image page 213/578. (via Nicholls)</p><p><a href="#_ednref14">[14]</a> <a href="https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:Henry_Stokes_(8)">https://www.werelate.org/wiki/Person:Henry_Stokes_(8)</a> online profile for Henry Stokes references will recorded 6 Nov 1766; and purchase deed Henrico County Wills and Deeds and Wills #2, 148, 30 Sept 1727. Davis, Henrico Deeds 1750–1774, 30.</p><p><a href="#_ednref15">[15]</a> Davis, Henrico Deeds 1750–1774, p. 151.</p><p><a href="#_ednref16">[16]</a> Davis, Henrico Deeds 1750–1774, p. 107.</p><p><a href="#_ednref17">[17]</a> Hinshaw, William Wade. <em>Encyclopedia of American Quaker Genealogy</em>. Edited by Thomas Worth Marshall. 3rd ed. Vol. VI. Baltimore: Genealogical Publishing Co Inc, 1993, pp. 145–241; Henrico Monthly Meeting, at White Oak Swamp Meeting House 1757–1780, 1–160 (Ancestry.com pagination of microfilm); these minutes are miss-labeled as Charles City: Henrico Monthly Minutes 1757–1780 on Ancestry.com.</p><p><a href="#_ednref18">[18]</a> Henrico County Historical Society Website. <a href="https://www.henricohistoricalsociety.org/lostarchitecture.brookfieldplantation.html">https://www.henricohistoricalsociety.org/lostarchitecture.brookfieldplantation.html</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref19">[19]</a> The Virginia Gazette, Saturday, September 13, 1783, <a href="https://newspapers.com/image/604845654/">https://newspapers.com/image/604845654/</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref20">[20]</a> Davis, Henrico Deeds, 1750–1774, 240.</p><p><a href="#_ednref21">[21]</a> Ward, Harry M. and Harold E. Greer, Jr., Richmond During the Revolution1775–83; VA; University Press of Virginia;1977; 94–96 and more. Cypalcorp. <em>Henrico County Virginia Court Order Book №1 Part I 1 Oct 1781- 9 July 1783</em>. Athens, GA: Iberian Publishing Co, 2019, multiple.</p><p><a href="#_ednref22">[22]</a> Pargellis, S. M. “The Procedure of the Virginia House of Burgesses.” <em>The William and Mary College Quarterly Historical Magazine</em> 7, no. 3 (1927): 143–57. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/1922239.">https://doi.org/10.2307/1922239</a> page 144 in original. P 2 of article as accessed on jStor.</p><p><a href="#_ednref23">[23]</a> Henrico Monthly Meeting Minutes, 1757–1780. Original page number, 176; Ancestry.com microfilm slide 91/160.</p><p><a href="#_ednref24">[24]</a> Davis, Henrico Deeds 1757–1774, p. 167.</p><p><a href="#_ednref25">[25]</a> Davis, Henrico Deeds, 1757–1774, p. 167.</p><p><a href="#_ednref26">[26]</a> Davis, Henrico Deeds, 1757–1774, p. 202.</p><p><a href="#_ednref27">[27]</a> Henrico County Miscellaneous Records, Vol 7, Library of Virginia, p. 2089.</p><p><a href="#_ednref28">[28]</a> Davis, Henrico Deeds, 1750–1774, p. 198.</p><p><a href="#_ednref29">[29]</a> Henrico Monthly Meeting Minutes, 1757–1780. Original page 193. Ancestry.com microfilm 99/160.</p><p><a href="#_ednref30">[30]</a> Parsons, Joseph; Guardian accounts for Woodson, Agnes and Judith Parsons, January 22, 1774, Misc Court Records, Vol 7 Library of Virginia {1770–1807} (Reel 3) 2236–2238.</p><p><a href="#_ednref31">[31]</a> Henrico Monthly Meeting Minutes 1757–1780. Original page 201. Ancestry microfilm 103/160.</p><p><a href="#_ednref32">[32]</a> Hinshaw, Quaker Encyclopedia Vol VI, p. 201.</p><p><a href="#_ednref33">[33]</a> Henrico Monthly Meeting Minutes 1757–1780. Original page 205. Ancestry microfilm 105/160.</p><p><a href="#_ednref34">[34]</a> Henrico Monthly Meeting Minutes 1757–1780. Original page 215. Ancestry microfilm 110/160.</p><p><a href="#_ednref35">[35]</a>[35] Hinshaw, Quaker Encyclopedia Vol VI, 201–202.</p><p><a href="#_ednref36">[36]</a> Worrall, Jr, Jay, <em>The Friendly Virginians: America’s First Quakers, </em>(Atnens (sic), GA: Iberian Publishing Company, 1994), p. 197.</p><p><a href="#_ednref37">[37]</a> Hinshaw, Quaker Encyclopedia Vol VI, p. 220.</p><p><a href="#_ednref38">[38]</a> Drake, Quakers and Slavery, p. 82.</p><p><a href="#_ednref39">[39]</a> Virginia Yearly Meeting Minutes. 1672–1836. On Ancestry.com, 159/1836.</p><p><a href="#_ednref40">[40]</a> Hinshaw, Quaker Encyclopedia Vol VI, p. 202.</p><p><a href="#_ednref41">[41]</a> Torrence, Valentine Papers, Pleasants’ family trees, IV 2290–2299. Jacob Pleasants’ will, II 1129–1130.</p><p><a href="#_ednref42">[42]</a> Hardin, Litigating the Lash, pp. 87–88.</p><p><a href="#_ednref43">[43]</a> Cypalcorp. <em>Henrico County Virginia Court Order Book №1 Part I 1 Oct 1781- 9 July 1783</em>. Athens, GA: Iberian Publishing Co, 2019, p. 19.</p><p><a href="#_ednref44">[44]</a> Cypalcorp, Henrico Order Book Oct 1781–1783, p. 19.</p><p><a href="#_ednref45">[45]</a> Davis, Henrico Deeds 1750–1774, p. 239.</p><p><a href="#_ednref46">[46]</a>Cypalcorp, Henrico Order Book Oct 1781–1783, pp. 50–51.</p><p><a href="#_ednref47">[47]</a> Cypalcorp, Henrico Order Book Oct 1781–1783, p. 50.</p><p><a href="#_ednref48">[48]</a> Cypalcorp, Henrico Order Book 1781–1783, p. 70.</p><p><a href="#_ednref49">[49]</a> Gary B. Nash, Michael R. McDowell, and John Parrish, “Notes on a Journey to Virginia,” <em>Quaker History</em> III, no. №1 (2022): 1–50. Gary B Nash, <em>Warner Mifflin: Unflinching Quaker Abolitionist</em> (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2017), pp. 122–123.</p><p><a href="#_ednref50">[50]</a>. Charles; etc.: Deed of Emancipation, 1782 (7800740 0001 0001) Virginia Untold: The African American Narrative Digital Collection, Library of Virginia, Richmond VA.</p><p><a href="#_ednref51">[51]</a> The Virginia Gazette, Saturday, September 13, 1783. (Multiple listings over span of time)</p><p><a href="#_ednref52">[52]</a> Hinshaw, Quaker Encyclopedia, Vol VI 202, p. 262.</p><p><a href="#_ednref53">[53]</a> Ruth Sparacio and Sam Sparacio, eds., <em>Goochland County, Virginia Land Tax Books 1782–1788</em> (Berwyn Heights, MD: Heritage Books, Inc, 1997), 27, p. 38.</p><p><a href="#_ednref54">[54]</a> Schreiner-Yantis and Florene Speakman Love, eds., “The 1787 Census of Virginia; Goochland County; Personal Tax Lists,” in <em>1787 Census of Virginia</em> (Springfield VA: Genealogical Books in Print, 1987), 784–805; 797.</p><p><a href="#_ednref55">[55]</a> Torrence, Valentine Papers, Vol II, p. 989.</p><p><a href="#_ednref56">[56]</a> “1792 — Parsons, et al to Silvia, et al — Goochland Co, VA,” <em>Manumission Project</em>, accessed April 2, 2025, <a href="https://manumissionproject.omeka.net/items/show/1534.">https://manumissionproject.omeka.net/items/show/1534.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref57">[57]</a> Torrence, Valentine Papers, II, p. 1114.</p><p><a href="#_ednref58">[58]</a> 1794 — Pleasants to Cupide — Goochland Co, VA,” <em>Manumission Project</em>, accessed April 2, 2025, <a href="https://manumissionproject.omeka.net/items/show/1539.">https://manumissionproject.omeka.net/items/show/1539.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref59">[59]</a> <a href="https://freeafricanamericans.com/virginiafreeafter1782.htm">https://freeafricanamericans.com/virginiafreeafter1782.htm</a> , Henrico County.</p><p><a href="#_ednref60">[60]</a> White, Nancy alias: Nancy Lewis): Deed of Emancipation, 1803 (7800740_0006_0009), Virginia Untold: The African American Narrative Digital Collection, Library of Virginia, Richmond VA.</p><p><a href="#_ednref61">[61]</a> Hinshaw, Quaker Encyclopedia VI, 202, p. 262.</p><p><a href="#_ednref62">[62]</a> Anthony, Hilary“Joseph Anthony 1767–1833: Virginian Quaker in Time of Calamity,” 2022. Jefferson-Madison Regional Library. <a href="https://dp.la/item/612a40f4e8d73df313d59d1c327465aa.">https://dp.la/item/612a40f4e8d73df313d59d1c327465aa.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref63">[63]</a> Richmond Enquirer, June 29, 1819; Richmond Enquirer Oct 19, 1810; Richmond Enquirer April 6, 1819; Virginia Argus January 24, 1806; Virginia Argus February 3, 1801.</p><p><a href="#_ednref64">[64]</a> Sidbury, James. <em>Ploughshares into Swords: Race, Rebellion, and Identity in Gabriel’s Virginia, 1730–1810</em>. First. University of Cambridge Press, 1997. Ward, Harry M, and Harold E Greer, Jr. <em>Richmond During the Revolution 1775–83</em>. First. The University Press of Virginia, 1977.</p><p><a href="#_ednref65">[65]</a> Henrico County Records, Mixed Records, Vol 2–3, 1766–1852, via Ancestry.com, U.S., Wills and Probate Records, 1652–1900; Probate date 15 Feb 1797, screen 216/633.</p><p><a href="#_ednref66">[66]</a> Henrico Monthly Meeting Minutes 1757–1780, Ancestry.com, microfilm August 5, 1778.</p><p><a href="#_ednref67">[67]</a> Nicholls, <em>Whispers,</em> pp. 156–158<em>.</em></p><p><a href="#_ednref68">[68]</a> Hinshaw, Quaker Encyclopedia Vol VI, p 214. Gish, Agnes Evans. <em>Virginia Taverns, Ordinaries and Coffee Houses: 18th -Early 19th Century Entertainment Along the Buckingham Road</em>. Westminister MD: Heritage Books an Imprint of Heritage Books, Inc, 2009, pp. 145–150. Torrence, Valentine Papers, IV, 2293. Nash, Notes on Journey to Virginia.</p><p><a href="#_ednref69">[69]</a> Torrence, Valentine Papers, IV, p. 2295; Index of Virginia Printing-Samuel Pleasants, Jr.</p><p><a href="#_ednref70">[70]</a> Torrence, Valentine Papers, IV, pp. 2275–2279. Nicholls, Whispers, pp. 56–57.</p><p><a href="#_ednref71">[71]</a> Woodson, Henry Morton. <em>Historical Genealogy of the Woodsons and Their Connections, Part I</em>. Published by the Author, 1915. Reprinted by The Apple Manor Press, nd. pp.27,33. Hinshaw, Quaker Encyclopedia, VI, p. 199–200.</p><p><a href="#_ednref72">[72]</a> Historical Southern Families. Volume XII Record for Historical Southern Families. Volume XII. Page 154 <a href="https://media.geni.com/p13/29/19/31/9c/53444839f837422f/jane_mosby_2_original.jpg?hash=533aac200fa63eda9e9681147ca665a1376b12aa60cb993d4c74e42e17480477.1743749999">link</a>, page 156 <a href="https://media.geni.com/p13/7e/25/05/d9/53444839f837422e/jane_mosby_3_original.jpg?hash=31205a45722415833f818f591e005fa7cc9b0f1c899c724bacb32ca6b5d59751.1743749999">link</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref73">[73]</a> Gish, Agnes Evans. <em>Virginia Taverns,</em> 109–113. Leatherwood, David. <em>Acrimony: The Younghusband Brothers at the Dawn of American Independence</em>. First. Reston, VA: self-published, 2024.</p><p><a href="#_ednref74">[74]</a> Nicholls, <em>Whisper</em>s, p. 163.</p><p><a href="#_ednref75">[75]</a> Richmond Enquirer, June 30, 1809, July 7, 1809, July 12, 1815,</p><p><a href="#_ednref76">[76]</a> Library of Virginia Index Entry, Samuel Parsons Obituary, March 25, 1820. Read on Library of Congress website.</p><p><a href="#_ednref77">[77]</a> Schreiner-Yantis. Personal Property 1787, Henrico, p. 1077.</p><p><a href="#_ednref78">[78]</a>Pompy (alias: Pompey) Deed of Emancipation, Henrico County, May 1784. Via Library of Virginia.</p><p><a href="#_ednref79">[79]</a> Henrico County Personal Property Tax 1782–1814. Library of Virginia Microfilm reel 171; Land tax 1799–1816 Library of Virginia reel 143. Accessed by website: wwwfreeafricanamericans.com/henrico.htm</p><p><a href="#_ednref80">[80]</a> Parsons, Nancy. Commonwealth Cause, 1818 (7845248_0001_0025). Parsons, Nancy Commonwealth Cause, 1816 (7846963_0003_0021). Parsons, Nanney (alias Naney, Nancy) Commonwealth Cause 1811 (7846965_0003_0025). Virginia Untold: The African American Digital Collection, Library of Virginia, Richmond VA.</p><p><a href="#_ednref81">[81]</a> <a href="https://freeafricanamericans.com/virginiafreeafter1782.htm">https://freeafricanamericans.com/virginiafreeafter1782.htm</a> , Henrico County.</p><p><a href="#_ednref82">[82]</a> Parsons, Aaron: Deed, 1813 (1179462_0001_0023). Virginia Untold: The African American Narrative Digital Collection, Library of Virginia, Richmond, Va. <br> Parsons, Aaron: Petition to Remain in the Commonwealth, 1821 (1186850_0002_0007). Virginia Untold: The African American Narrative Digital Collection, Library of Virginia, Richmond, Va.</p><p><a href="#_ednref83">[83]</a> Nash, <em>Warner Mifflin</em>, p. 120.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6c27f052f4a3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Joseph Anthony 1767–1833: Virginian Quaker in Time of Calamity]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony/joseph-anthony-1767-1833-virginian-quaker-in-time-of-calamity-15915f03390f?source=rss-3d245f3789fd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/15915f03390f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[quaker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[revolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[slavery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virginia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Anthony]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Feb 2022 18:22:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-02-07T22:19:05.512Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LVBJpc2rlrxUk4iSBSXoNw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Selected eighteenth century Virginia Quaker meetings for worship. South River in present day Lynchburg; Sugarloaf Mt, Charlottesville; Whiteoak Swamp, Richmond.</figcaption></figure><p>My fourth great-grandfather had some business problems. Joseph Anthony made “unfortunate endorsements on commercial paper;” [<a href="#_edn1">1]</a> he over-extended credit to friends. I learned that from a family history written by Frederic Anthony Swain (1872–1963). Later, I learned Joseph was disowned by the Religious Society of Friends, the Quakers, over a partnership dispute. For years, I thought Joseph had a sad little life.</p><p>The strong Virginia Quaker Church of the 1700s divided and dispersed over slavery; as I learned about that split, Joseph began to emerge. Swain had the mistaken belief that Quakers had always been anti-slavery and didn’t recognize that some of our enslaver ancestors were Quakers. Over several decades in the latter half of the 1700s, Quaker activists, followed by church leaders, transformed the Society into the abolitionist faith that acted in the nineteenth century. That change was messy and shook the lives of enslaved and free people.</p><p><strong>Josephs’ Quaker Community</strong></p><p>Joseph Anthony (1767–1833) was born into a small, predominantly Quaker community, at the western edge of colonial Virginia. Friends to the east called the region wilderness — for the thick forests and conflicts with Monacan people who remained after the French-Indian War and colonial land theft.</p><p>The Quakers who settled near Lynchburg were part of a three-generation migration from eastern Virginia. Several families came from indentured servants and the rabble of New Kent County — the powder-keg of a middling class who supported Bacon’s Rebellion. The Friends, religious dissenters and tax-resisters, none-the-less had enough privilege to go west to patent land and buy people. The Anthonys, Clarks, Moormans, Johnsons, Terrells, Lynches and related families moved from New Kent County in 1722, to Louisa, some on to Albemarle around 1740 and some farther on to Bedford after 1756.<a href="#_edn2">[2]</a> The migration occurred over the same time that slavery was on the rise in Virginia, and as the Virginia Quakers church went from being silent on slavery to opposing it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Hx1-DtPtvrrJBM7E14E4Qw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Joseph was born a decade after his great aunt invited Friends to worship in her new home, starting the South River Meeting in Bedford County. Joseph’s dad’s cousin, John Lynch, built a toll ferry across the James River and named Lynchburg after himself; another mined saltpeter for patriot gunpowder and raised tobacco with enslaved workers. Some relatives claimed and re-sold parcels of land, first in Albemarle, then in Bedford. Joseph’s dad was referred to as a merchant, and later as a Quaker minister.</p><p>Compared to eastern Virginia, farms in Bedford County were smaller and more likely owner-occupied. Boatsmen moved hogsheads of tobacco and wheat downriver, and trade goods back up. Joseph’s family was connected by business to the communities that became Charlottesville and Richmond. Quaker networks connected the western Friends to Philadelphia and London. People, publications, and church directives went back and forth among them.</p><p><strong>Revolution for Whom? Freedom for Whom</strong>?</p><p>In 1779, freedom was on peoples’ minds. Joseph’s relatives in Albemarle County were neighbors of the Jeffersons, the Madisons and Patrick Henry’s family. Ideas that shaped the nation were local issues. The Revolutionary War was underway.</p><p>In meeting minutes, Friends recorded their “sufferings.” They resisted conscription, and so suffered seizure of crops and valuables. Some were jailed and beaten. Several prominent Quakers were confined on suspicion of being Tories because of their pacifism and London trade partners. Other Friends left the church to fight with the Patriots. Even the Quakers who refused to fight had a stake in the outcome of the revolution.</p><p>The questions “freedom for whom? Democracy for whom?” had to be answered. What about the religious dissenters? What about the poor whites? What about the enslaved? What about the Native populations? The Founders’ views were narrower than the Quakers’.</p><p>In 1779 Virginia Yearly Meeting made its strongest anti-slavery statement, to date:</p><blockquote>We do give as our clear sense a Judgement that we are loudly called upon in this time of calamity and close trial to minister Justice and Judgment to black and white, rich and poor, and free our hands from every species of oppression…We do therefore most earnestly recommend to all who continue to withhold from any their just right to freedom, as they prise their own present peace, and future happiness, to clear their hands of this inequity by executing manumissions for all those held by them in slavery who are arrived at full age….we believe the time is come in which every member of our religious society who continue to support or countenance this crying evil, either by continuing their fellow creatures in bondage, or hiring such who may be kept in that state, should be admonished and advised to discontinue such practices…<a href="#_edn3">[3]</a></blockquote><p>They could not dictate a course to the state, but Friends could end slaveholding within their membership. They directed local meetings to assign Friends to visit with members who still held people in bondage. Further, the Yearly meeting gave authority to the Monthly Meetings, that is the local business meetings, to disown members who refused to manumit people they enslaved.<strong> </strong>Other Yearly Meetings (London, New England and Philadelphia) were already disowning enslavers. Virginia Quakers had previously forbidden buying and selling people, but the revolution inspired them to call for freedom and justice for all.</p><p>The Yearly letter directed members to assist freed people and their children with worldly needs, religious education, and advice. This passage outlined Quakers’ moral obligation:</p><blockquote>From a desire to promote the spiritual and temporal welfare of such negros and their children who have been restored to freedom, it is recommended to friends in their several quarterly meetings, seriously to consider the circumstances of those poor people and the obligations we are under to discharge our religious duties to them… As also to advise them in their worldly concerns as occasions offer. And it is advised that friends of judgement and experience may be nominated for this necessary service, it being the solid sense of this meeting that we of the present generation are under strong obligations to manifest our care and concern for the offspring of those people, who by their labors have greatly contributed toward the cultivation of these colonies, under the afflicting disadvantage of enduring hard bondage, and many among us are enjoying the benefit of their toil.</blockquote><p>Many among the Quakers were enjoying the benefits of the toil of people held in hard bondage, and all were being called on to care for them. Members were told to report back next year. In the next year, Virginia Yearly Meeting continued to advocate for change, including advising Friends to stop using the term “negro” and instead using the term “black” man or woman.</p><p>A hand-written copy of this Yearly letter arrived at South River/Lynchburg when Joseph was twelve years old. His father, Christopher Anthony (1744–1815), accepted the assignment to visit Friends who held people in bondage. He and William Johnson rode from house to house to “labor” with Friends, many of whom were relatives, to convince them to free the people they enslaved.</p><p>No doubt they visited Friends who refused. Since 1723, Virginia Law forbade manumitting, or freeing, enslaved people without government permission. If manumissions were legal, those who depended on enslaved labor would need to pay their workers or find another livelihood.</p><h3><strong>Manumissions, Robert Pleasants, and Quaker wills</strong></h3><p>Robert Pleasants (1723–1801) was a driving force transforming the Virginia Society of Friends. He was a fourth generation Quaker from a wealthy planter family. Robert was deeply connected, by family and business, to Quakers in London, Philadelphia, and across Virginia — including the Anthonys. Joseph’s stepmother, Mary Jordan, was related to Robert’s mother, Margaret Jordan.</p><p>By the late 1760s Robert’s abolitionist position solidified. The law prohibiting freeing enslaved people was a problem. Legalizing manumissions became his legislative priority as he continued to promote education for Black people.</p><p>Robert’s father, John Pleasants’ (1697–1771) fortune was in land and people. He owned about 200 people near the end of his life. Robert collaborated with him to write a will that could free all of them — if the law permitted.</p><p>John’s will left eighty enslaved people in Robert’s care. The will instructed John’s other children to care for the remaining 120 people and to free them, and their offspring, who were over age 30, when it was legal.</p><p>William Hernandez Hardin wrote how John’s intent was, and was not, carried out, in “Litigating The Lash: Quaker Emancipator Robert Pleasants, The Law of Slavery, and the Meaning of Manumission in Revolutionary and Early National Virginia,” a PhD dissertation [<a href="#_edn4">4]</a>. My summary does not do justice to the level of detail and analysis in Hardin’s writing.</p><p>Robert moved the eighty people in his care to Gravelly Hill, a 350-acre farm southeast of Richmond. They built homes and farmed. Over time, they built a church and school. While the residents of Gravelly Hill were enslaved in the eyes of Virginia law, they had more freedom of movement and less supervision than most enslaved people. That was apparent to the neighbors, who harassed the residents and took Robert to court for having “slaves at large.”</p><p>In 1782, The Virginia Manumission Act passed, allowing for the freeing of adult enslaved people. A rush of manumissions followed. Robert, as executor of his father’s will, went to work.</p><p>One of Robert’s sisters refused to free the people entrusted to her. Robert sued. The 200 people named in John’s will had children and totaled about 400 people by the time the litigation ended. The first ruling changed the legal status of enslaved people in Virginia from property to humans with rights. The ruling awarded freedom and reparations to the people who had been held illegally. Robert’s sister appealed. The final ruling came in 1798, awarding freedom, no reparations, to the formerly enslaved and their offspring. This case was the largest of Virginia’s freedom suits. According to Hardin, the Pleasants framed this case carefully to have judicial impact on manumissions.</p><p><strong>Joseph’s Maternal Grandfather Gave Instructions to Free People</strong></p><p>At least three other Quaker families failed to carry out testamentary instructions to free enslaved people.<a href="#_edn5">[5]</a> Joseph’s maternal granddad, Charles Moorman (1715–1778), intended that his heirs free the people whose labor he “lent” to them. His will said:</p><blockquote>I lend to my son Robert the labor of the five following slaves, viz, Phyllis, (Toby’s daughter), Judy, John (Toby’s son) Easter and Rachel, the males until they attain the age of 21 respectively, and females to the age of 18 years, and then after that time tis my will and desire that the said five slaves and their increase shall forever hereafter be discharged to all intents and purposes from slavery or the service of any person whatsoever and that the said slaves and increase shall enjoy all the benefits of freedom in the same manner as if they had been born free.<a href="#_edn6">[6]</a></blockquote><p>Later in the will there was a clause that acknowledged the law may not change to permit manumission:</p><blockquote>It is my will and desire that the slaves hereafter named: Jack, Allen, Rachel, Dinah, Hannah, Sarah, Toby, Let, Beck, Venus and Annis, in consideration of their faithful service, be immediately free and enjoy all the benefits thereof as person born free. In case the laws of the land will not admit of such freedom that then the said last mentioned slaves and their increase be equally divided amongst my other legatees…<a href="#_edn7">[7]</a></blockquote><p>Moorman assigned the thirty-three enslaved people among his wife and seven of his children — until manumissions were legal. The will was probated in 1788.</p><p>Some of Moorman’s children did not free the people “lent” to them. Two of the heirs sold people whose labor they were lent.<a href="#_edn8">[8]</a> Christopher Johnson, Moorman’s son-in-law, Joseph’s uncle, and executor of the will, made 14 trips to South Carolina and Georgia between 1788 and 1797 to free the people who were sold illegally.<a href="#_edn9">[9]</a></p><p>Charles Moorman’s son Robert Moorman (1753–1813) died in South Carolina [<a href="#_edn10">10]</a>; other offspring appear in Virginia records into the 1800s. Could it be that Robert took the five children, and his allocated share the adults, and moved to South Carolina? Did he organize coffles of chained people going south?</p><p>Coffles were disgraceful tragedies in motion. In this case, people promised freedom, shackled and marched south to unending bondage, would have the weight of betrayal added to the tragedy of family separation and enslavement. A will that Moorman meant to bring liberation, could not overcome the bad faith of his children and the reach of slavery.</p><p>What happened on Christopher Johnson’s fourteen trips south? The number of trips indicates continuing difficulties. First, he had to find the people. If negotiations or threats failed, he had to take the enslavers to court, which he did. Worrall wrote that Johnson was partly successful, but I don’t know how many people he recovered. South Carolina and Georgia were the only states that didn’t have a manumission law.</p><p>The South River, Lynchburg, minutes reflect what, I think, is a related event. In 1797, a committee affirmed that the meeting owed Joseph Anthony 19 pounds. By 1799, South River had raised 24 pounds, part of which they intended to use to expand the meeting house. In May, two elders agreed to talk to Joseph and ask if he would take 10 pounds in settlement of his debt. In June, the elders, reported that they had made a settlement with Joseph,</p><blockquote>and produced a receipt to this meeting as also a statement of the business which sets fourth a balance of £18.17 now in hand which they are directed to pay into the hands of Christopher Johnson to be applied for the benefit of a black woman by the name of Rachel.<a href="#_edn11">[11]</a></blockquote><p>There are two Rachels in Charles Moorman’s will, a woman and a child. A woman named Rachel appeared on Moorman’s tithable list since before Joseph’s mother was born. Had Joseph grown up knowing the older Rachel? His mother probably did. Had Robert taken Rachel to South Carolina, and Christopher Johnson retrieved her? As in many families, was there a blood connection? I have few answers for all the questions raised.</p><p>The Quaker Church was changing. In 1757, Philadelphia Quaker John Woolman visited Cedar Creek Meeting; he heard a Quaker use the bible to defend slavery. If the unnamed apologist was not one of Joseph’s relatives, he was certainly someone his relatives worshiped with. In 1767, Cedar Creek meeting was the first to call on Virginia Yearly Meeting to oppose slavery. By 1779, they did. In 1788, Cedar Creek got serious about disowning members who continued as enslavers and disowned about 15 members.<a href="#_edn12">[12]</a> Roughly by 1800, all Virginia Quakers were antislavery in action and sympathy; those who were not had left the church or been disowned.</p><p><strong>Joseph’s Paternal Grandfather Could Have, but Didn’t</strong></p><p>Joseph’s namesake and paternal grandfather may have been a Quaker just long enough to marry one. Joseph Anthony (1713–1784) married Elizabeth, daughter of Christopher Clark, and was noted as a member of Clarksville and Fork Creek Quaker Meetings, short-lived meetings on the trail west.<a href="#_edn13">[13]</a> The internet has lots of conflicting family history on the older Joseph Anthony. I see two documented life events: he patented land near Peter Jefferson (Thomas’ father) in 1744; his will was probated in Henry County, south of Lynchburg.</p><p>In his will, the senior Joseph “lent” nine people to his wife until she died or remarried, when the estate would reclaim the enslaved people. He gave and bequeathed thirteen people, by name, to six of his children.<a href="#_edn14">[14]</a> He could have freed them. He didn’t.</p><p>He left only 1 shilling each, and no people, to eight of his children, including Joseph’s dad, Christopher, and wrote:</p><blockquote>…further it is my will that if any of my Children should Refuse to Keep the Negroes which I will to them, that they be Returned to my Estate and Equally Divided Amongst the Rest of my Children.</blockquote><p>The heirs were prohibited from freeing the enslaved people left to them. I suspect Joseph Sr. knew which of his children would accept his bequest. I also suspect that family gatherings were tense. Soon after the probate, Joseph’s widow and her children who inherited enslaved people, moved to Wilkes County, Georgia.</p><p>The author of my family history assumes that Elizabeth, Christopher’s mother, remained a Quaker, the Anthony children who moved to Georgia did not. Those Anthonys chose to be enslavers rather than Friends.</p><p>Differences over slavery were dividing Quaker families. Sarah Lynch Terrell, Christopher’s cousin, was memorialized by a collection of her anti-slavery sayings that was distributed among Quakers in the 1770s. Another cousin, Bowling Clark, left the church and took a job as an overseer at Thomas Jefferson’s Poplar Forest plantation.<a href="#_edn15">[15]</a> The free and enslaved families had complicated connections, some built over generations. Some Quaker families embraced abolition, others did not. Enslaved families felt the effects of that divide.</p><h3><strong>Joseph Reversed a Tradition by Moving East</strong></h3><p>When Joseph was 19, in 1786, he moved east to Genito in Goochland County. Soon after, he married Rhoda Moorman. They had two sets of great grandparents in common, and so, were second cousins twice over. She grew up in the Cedar Creek monthly meeting, perhaps attending the Golansville Meeting for worship. They both had family among the Quaker meeting houses that stretched from Louisa County to Bedford. As far as I can tell, Rhoda and Joseph never owned people; their parents complied with Quaker discipline. I don’t know if they employed formerly enslaved people in their home or on their farm.</p><p>Before canals made Richmond navigable, Goochland, just upriver from the James River fall line, was a milling and transportation hub, with a mix of rich and middling property owners. To move wheat or tobacco from the west past Richmond to large ports, the cargo had to be unloaded from barges in Goochland, moved overland, then reloaded onto outward bound ships. Once Richmond had canals, Genito’s role diminished.</p><p>In 1792, Joseph and Rhoda had their first child — Samuel Parsons Anthony. They didn’t name him after either of their parents or grandparents. They named him for Samuel Parsons (1748–1815), another Quaker who recently transferred his church membership to Genito.<a href="#_edn16">[16]</a></p><p>After his father died, in 1774, Parsons and his widowed mother asked Henrico Monthly Meeting for advice on how to free the enslaved people left by his father, noting that it was illegal. The meeting minutes did not record an answer.<a href="#_edn17">[17]</a> It is possible that Parsons and Joseph were both in Genito in pursuit of a livelihood not dependent on enslaved labor. About 1796, they partnered with Thomas Ladd to run a mill in Richmond.</p><p>Milling was a good business for Quakers. Millers were exempt from military service, and so escaped the onerous fines and seizures that Quakers had suffered. Small mills were all over colonial Virginia, but milling was being revolutionized by Oliver Evan’s patented machinery that decreased the need for labor and created a product that was shelf stable — suitable for export. As Virginian farmers were switching from tobacco to wheat, the advances in milling created a boom industry — just as the partnership got started.</p><h3><strong>Life in the Boom town of Richmond</strong></h3><p>In 1796, Joseph requested transferring his membership to White Oak Swamp Monthly Meeting, home meeting of the Pleasants family, just east of Richmond.</p><p>Joseph was busy. White Oak Swamp elders appointed him to a committee to build a meetinghouse in downtown Richmond. He employed his brother in a mercantile business. He joined a benevolent organization: The Amicable Society, aiding the needy. Joseph also joined the Virginia Society for the Promotion of the Abolition of Slavery (VAS).</p><p>Robert Pleasants led the creation of the VAS in 1790. Like other Abolition Societies of the time, VAS took on “freedom suits,” suing on behalf of people who were held in bondage illegally. The state societies joined in an annual convention — reporting the number of people manumitted and collectively committing to educating freed Blacks. Philadelphia and New York had some successes with schools for free Black people.<a href="#_edn18">[18]</a></p><p>Richmond was growing. The new capital’s commercial potential was huge as a center of manufacturing, shipping, trade and flour production. The flurry of building had been massive: the Capitol building, designed by Thomas Jefferson; the canal system promoted by George Washington; a penitentiary, the bridges, canal basin, port and warehouse district, with a foundry and quarry central to the construction.</p><p>The city had a demand for skilled and unskilled laborers: blacksmiths, carpenters, coopers, masons, cooks, teamsters, brewers, boatmen, household workers, prostitutes, and preachers.</p><p>In “Ploughshares into Swords: Race, Rebellion, and Identity in Gabriel’s Virginia 1730–1810,” James Sidbury describes Richmond as rapidly evolving with a dynamic workforce.<a href="#_edn19">[19]</a> The city had transient workers, boarding houses, gambling, drinking, dangerous work and lots of money. Free and enslaved workers came and went with no pass system; they moved about town, up and down the James River and to and from nearby farms. Some enslaved people worked for wages in town, with their enslavers collecting their wages. Sidbury said that the throngs of people coming and going could not be sorted out visually as whether they were free or enslaved; resident or transient.</p><p>By 1800, Richmond’s population was about 5,700. Which roughly broke down as: free white people, half the population; free people of color, about 600; enslaved people, about 2300.</p><p>As canals were finished, the foundry burned hot, workers pounded clay into brick and masons laid them into walls, Ladd Anthony and Company began operations in the center of things, on a millrace between the warehouse district, the capitol, and the penitentiary.</p><p>Anthony and Parsons third partner, Thomas Ladd (1769–1834) was in the brokerage/finance business with his father, Amos. The Ladds were longtime neighbors of the Pleasants, also Quakers, also wealthy. The Ladds entered many partnerships. They had a Richmond counting house and made deals happen with loans, shipping, storage, and brokerage services. In a time of unstable currency and tremendous uncertainty, the Ladds built a business of managing transaction details and risk.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/546/1*zDgVBJ7Yi7nlf6uHwhB7-A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Virginia Argus. Thomas and his father, Amos, ran a counting house in Richmond</figcaption></figure><p>In Quaker minutes, Joseph Anthony was called the “acting partner” of Ladd Anthony and Company.<a href="#_edn20">[20]</a> Ladd was likely instrumental to obtaining the lease for the land, from his brother-in-law, Ebenezer Maule. Parsons may have had technical knowledge of milling; per newspaper ads, he continued in the flour business. Joseph likely had an eclectic set of skills, picked up from his dad the merchant, his cousin the ferryman, his cousin the planter, and dozens of relatives building, milling, harvesting, and shipping on the James.</p><p>As an observant Quaker, Joseph would have hired free workers — Black or white, in order to be unity with his church discipline. The new mills reduced the number of operators needed, but making barrels, the hogsheads, remained labor intensive as did loading filled barrels onto ships. I have no information as to who worked for the partnership and if Joseph employed any of the people freed by Quakers he knew.</p><h3><strong>Tensions on the Rise</strong></h3><p>Joseph was the sole representative from Virginia to the National Convention of Abolition Societies in 1797. Joseph reported that tensions were high, “new laws fueled by a growing hostility to antislavery and free blacks” were grinding the Virginia Abolitionists freedom suits to a halt. <a href="#_edn21">[21]</a> A decade after the Virginia Manumission Act, the US Congress passed a fugitive slave law. In 1795, Virginia passed a law restricting the involvement of Abolitionists in freedom suits.</p><p>The free Black population of Virginia had been growing since 1782, from under 3,000 to over 12,000 in the 1790 census. The 1795 law restricting abolitionists’ freedom suits was part of a white backlash aimed to stop the rapid growth of the free population.</p><p>The revolution of Saint-Dominque, now known as Haiti, was underway; enslaved people violently overthrowing a regime that depended on slavery struck terror in some Virginians, and inspired others. The ones who were scared already had their revolution, and they were making the laws.</p><p>Closer to home, Gabriel’s Conspiracy was uncovered in August 1800. The plan was to set fires in the warehouse district for distraction, seize weapons from the penitentiary and Capitol, and wage a war to end slavery. In the aftermath to the failed rebellion, word spread that the conspirators would have spared Quakers. Whether that was true or not, it added to the tensions. The partners’ mill was geographically in the center of the plan.</p><p>More laws restricting enslaved and free Black people followed. A pass law was instituted, requiring passes for enslaved workers who had previously travelled without documentation. Leasing enslaved workers was restricted. Gatherings of Black people were restricted — including in church — especially Quaker churches. By 1806, newly emancipated people were required to leave Virginia.</p><h3><strong>The Partners got in on Tension and Conflict</strong></h3><p>In October 1800, as Gabriel’s co-conspirators were still being hunted, tried, and hanged, the White Oak Swamp Monthly Meeting reported that a few Friends had failed to resolve differences among the partners of Ladd Anthony and Company. The meeting formed a committee.</p><p>In November, the committee reported. Parsons and Ladd accused Joseph of mismanagement resulting in losses to them. Joseph “utterly refused” to give his account. Further, Joseph refused the committee’s advice to work with Friends to bring about a reconciliation, “and more ever has lately instituted lawsuits against Samuel Parsons and Thomas Ladd contrary to the rules of our discipline.”</p><p>The monthly meeting assigned a smaller group to meet with Joseph to tell him his acts were highly disorderly and if he didn’t condemn the action, they would prepare papers of disunion to present at the next meeting. If he didn’t drop his lawsuit and submit to Quaker mediation, they would kick him out of the church.</p><p>In February 1801, the small group reported no success with Joseph Anthony. They were ready to disown him. Robert Pleasants asked them to wait. The eighty-year-old was not only a leader in Quaker abolition efforts; he had been a church leader for decades. Robert would talk to Joseph. He could step in and stop the process of a committee.</p><p>At the next meeting, 3rd month, 1801 the report was:</p><blockquote>The Friend who had the case of Joseph Anthony put under his care at the last meeting, being since deceased, the meeting cannot obtain a regular report therein, but having received a favorable account from another Friend respecting him, it…may be proper to continue… under the care of George Winston, Samuel Ladd and Edward Bates.<a href="#_edn22">[22]</a></blockquote><p>Robert Pleasants died on March 4, 1801. By July, the new committee recommended disowning Joseph.</p><p>Joseph appealed to the Upper Quarterly (regional) meeting. What were the specific mismanagement allegations about? Labor? Spending? What was the basis of Joseph’s lawsuits against his partners? Breach of contract? Defamation? Did the attempted slave revolt affect the partnership? Did Joseph’s lawsuit proceed? I’m still looking for answers.</p><p>At every level, the tangled web of Quaker families and businesses appear. Joseph’s brother was engaged to Thomas Ladd’s cousin Elizabeth; that wedding got postponed. Parsons was married to a Pleasants. The property lessor, Ebenezer Maule, was married to Thomas Ladd’s sister Sarah. Thomas’ cousin was appointed to most of the investigative committees. Thomas’s dad, Amos, appeared in the lease negotiations. Parsons and Ladd were often the Monthly Meeting representatives at the Quarterly Meetings that considered Joseph’s case. In 1804, Parsons’ son married Thomas Ladd’s sister Elizabeth.</p><p>I’ve found several sources with hints of what transpired among the partners, but no full accounting. I’ve looked at Quaker minutes, family histories, milling histories and deed books. What am I to make of the Maule brothers’ role in the business failure? Thomas and Ebenezer Maule moved to Richmond from Philadelphia and obtained a leasehold for a prime mill seat (and wrote home to their mother about the debauchery they saw in Richmond).<a href="#_edn23">[23]</a> In “The Rise of Flour Milling in Richmond,” Thomas Berry treats the brothers as acting in tandem — leasing the mill location to Ladd Anthony and Company, then canceling the lease and leasing the same site to Joseph Gallego in 1799 for about 10 times the amount. Berry wrote, the price “suggests the previous lessees had accumulated a considerable equity in the property.” Does that mean that Joseph Anthony’s operation of the mill had increased the value of the underlying lease?</p><p>A 2007 draft paper by Robert Lundegard, “Country and City Mills in Early American Flour Manufacture and Export” [<a href="#_edn24">24]</a> indicates to me that a mill was on the site by 1795, before the Ladd Anthony and Company lease. The mill was the new Oliver Evan’s patented style, but poorly built. If Berry was correct that the increase in value of the lease was due to improvements, it could be that Parsons and Anthony successfully retooled the mill.</p><p>If I read an abstract of the Henrico deed books correctly, Ebenezer Maule alone had the original lease. He was in debt. Helping him out, his brother, Thomas, partnered with him to sublease the mill to Ladd Anthony and Company for four to six years in February 1797. A year and a half later, Thomas Maule put the mill lease up to secure a debt due in ninety days. It appears he lost his security. “Original deed of mortgage delivered to Joseph Anthony” December 1798.<a href="#_edn25">[25]</a> Had Joseph loaned the Maules money? Did Joseph receive the mortgage on his own behalf or the partnership? Was the partners’ conflict more about the lease than the mill operation? I have not been able to sort this out.</p><p>Ebenezer Maule died in 1799. Soon after, Joseph Gallego acquired the site and went on to become one of the three largest millers in Richmond, providing the flour that fueled the California gold rush and using that site for half a century.<a href="#_edn26">[26]</a></p><h3><strong><em>Wheels of Quaker Justice Grinding</em></strong></h3><p>In First month, 1802, the Upper Quarterly meeting heard Joseph’s appeal of his disownment. He told the Quarterly committee that if he knew their sentiments, he would be more willing to talk. He was persistent in his efforts to stay in the church without using Quaker dispute resolution. The Quarterly meeting referred the matter back to White Oak Swamp to address specific issues.</p><p>Again, going outside of his Quaker circles, Joseph wrote to Thomas Jefferson. Joseph knew Jefferson as a neighbor of his relatives, a customer for nail-making supplies, as the employer of his dad’s cousin, and as an associate of Robert Pleasants. The letter is on the website “Founders Online.”<a href="#_edn27">[27]</a></p><p>Joseph built a case that Robert Pleasants’ Gravelly Hill School offered a path to the end of slavery. Remember that Pleasants had located 80 free Black people on the Gravelly Hill Farm, twenty years earlier; presumably, that population had grown. Joseph wrote that the United State revolution had been a chance to end slavery, and that “emancipation is a natural force, and it is human contrivance to resist.” So, lawmakers can seek a peaceful transition.</p><p>Joseph’s proposal aimed to end “eternal bondage.” He advocated education, training, and no use of force. His proposal was to prepare “blacks, mulattos, and slaves” for self-rule — including making a living. He wrote of setting aside land to educate and train people. Joseph advocated using an organization with some military-like structure: discipline, education, skills building. That training would be a condition of emancipation and a preparation for independence.</p><p>Joseph pitched a call to action: Congress could set aside money the President could administer for a trial run. Joseph said he had researched this plan deeply at Gravelly Hill. For the past year, Joseph had taught at the school; with students ages 12- 30. He asked for funding to continue his work there. He had stepped into the role of advocate and supporter for the residents since Robert Pleasant’s death a year earlier, and he was accepted, in part, because the residences knew of the “intimacy between Robert Pleasants and myself.”</p><p>As Joseph wrote, a committee of Friends was working on the instructions in Robert Pleasants’ will to put Gravelly Hill in trust for the benefit of the residents, to collect rents and to pay a teacher to keep the school going. The committee may have also been working to cut Joseph’s ties to Gravelly Hill.</p><p>Jefferson, of course, heard all sorts of proposals on how to end slavery. I don’t know if Jefferson replied to Joseph, but the President did not adopt Gravelly Hill as a pilot project for emancipation.</p><p>For most of 1802 and 1803, committees from White Oak Swamp and the Quarterly Meeting went back and forth with Joseph Anthony’s case. At the same time, White Oak Swamp was struggling to follow the instructions in Robert Pleasants will and get Gravelly Hill operating as instructed. Eventually, they hired Benjamin Ladd as the teacher, Thomas Ladd’s brother. Like the Pleasants, the Ladds had deep roots in the White Oak Swamp Quaker meeting.</p><p><strong>Does this Conflict Make the Rules Grow?</strong></p><p>Simultaneously, the Virginia Yearly meeting was working on a project to update the Virginia Quaker Rules of Discipline. When revised rules were completed, the section that prohibited Friends from going outside the Society for disputes among Quakers was expanded from about 100 words to about 8 pages.</p><p>The 1802 Rules of Discipline described how to make a complaint and the appeals process. And I’d bet a dime that the section on how Friends should comport themselves during the process had some bearing on my 4th great grandfather’s case. Friends should approach conflict resolution with brotherly love “that it be done with decency and moderation, without letting on shewing any anger or animosity or using any provoking or unbecoming language.” <a href="#_edn28">[28]</a></p><p>White Oak Swamp Monthly Meeting never changed its position that Joseph Anthony should be disowned. Maybe the restated Rules of Discipline bolstered their position. By the end of 1803, the Upper Quarterly Meeting yielded to White Oak Swamp to recommend disownment.</p><p>Joseph had a final appeal: to the Virginial Yearly Meeting, to be held at Blackwater, Surry County in 1804.</p><p>Friends were frequently disowned — for marrying out of the faith, for taking up arms, for drunken behavior, for buying people. Monthly Meetings typically made quick business of disowning offenders. The Friend may then apologize, come into unity, or may accept being disowned. Joseph’s case is extraordinary. He refused to comply with the “advice” of Friends, and he continued years of appeal to retain his standing in the Society.</p><p>The Yearly Meetings minutes note Joseph’s appeal. No one was there to represent his case, so the Quarterly Meeting decision stood. Joseph was disowned.<a href="#_edn29">[29]</a></p><p>Christopher Anthony, at age 60, had made the 150-mile trek from Goose Creek Bedford, to attend as the representative of the newly recognized Western Quarterly Meeting. Joseph, who lived about 60 miles away, did not attend or send a representative. I assume he had given up.</p><h3><strong>Meanwhile at the South River Monthly Meetings</strong></h3><p>To back track, about the same time his partnership was falling apart, 1799, Joseph Anthony had assigned the 18 pounds the South River Monthly Meeting owed him to Christopher Johnson for the benefit of a Black woman named Rachel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rAo9Epq0Wu7VhFuqemYRvw.jpeg" /><figcaption>South River Monthly Minutes 1810</figcaption></figure><p>That led to his last appearance in Virginia Quaker records. In 1810, South River monthly meeting was attempting to make a claim on the estate of Christopher Johnson on Rachel’s behalf. Rachel was trying to get the money that he received for her. After months of trying to get the money from the estate, the meeting reported that Rachel was dead and the claim would revert to Joseph, for him to collect. A sad way for Christopher to go out.</p><h3><strong>Quakers Move to the Northwest Territories</strong></h3><p>The Northwest Ordinance of 1787 decreed that Ohio would be open to settlers in 1800, as a free state. Quakers from South Carolina and Virginia began to migrate — thousands of them.</p><p>In 1808, Joseph listed a farm, just west of Richmond, for sale.<a href="#_edn30">[30]</a> In 1812, Rhoda Anthony and her children transferred to the Miami Monthly meeting in Ohio. Samuel Parsons Anthony was 20. My family history says that he served as a teamster — driving mules pulling supply wagons — during the War of 1812 and had learned the difficult trail between Virginia and Ohio.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/252/1*-59N2k6Nxj-VgPBSjAJOzw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Virginia Argus Feb 5, 1808</figcaption></figure><p>Rhoda remained a Quaker.<a href="#_edn31">[31]</a> Being disowned, Joseph could not attend business meetings or serve on committees, but he could have attended meetings for worship. Near the end of Joseph’s life, one of his sons wrote of his father as, “having left the state of Virginia in consequence of his aversion to educating his family where slavery was tolerated and where the influence of its principles might be installed in the minds of his children.” [<a href="#_edn32">32]</a></p><p>My Swain family history says that Joseph went into business with Samuel Parsons Anthony establishing a store and the first tobacco warehouse west of the Allegheny mountains. That business didn’t last long. Swain said that in Cincinnati, Joseph broke the family finances by overextending credit. Samuel moved away. He became a doctor and wealthy real estate dealer in Indiana.</p><h3><strong>Meanwhile, Across Virginia and Ohio</strong></h3><p>By 1813, Christopher Anthony and a large portion of the South River membership moved to Ohio. Christopher is noted as being the first minister of the Cincinnati Quaker Church. He died within a couple of years of moving.</p><p>I don’t yet know to what extent free Black and mixed-race families were part of the migration from Virginia to Ohio. Members of some well-known families made the move, including Fossetts and Hemings. According to a history of the Cincinnati Quaker Meeting, at least one Black family moved north with the group accompanying Christopher Anthony.<a href="#_edn33">[33]</a></p><p>Cincinnati was just across the Ohio river from a slave state and became an important part of the Underground Railroad. Enslaved and formerly enslaved Black people successfully supported tens of thousands of people escaping slavery. Quaker Levi Coffin openly supported the railroad and collaborated with others who were not in the open. Quaker Achilles Pugh published and abolitionist newsletter. Jesse and Elizabeth Harvey started the first school in Ohio for Black children — as public schools refused to serve them.</p><p>Ultimately, Ohio was not a welcoming state for Black people to settle. The state started as free, but state laws and local violence were oppressive. Free people of color who stayed in Ohio endured obstacles to landownership, school attendance and voting. Following mob violence in 1829, half of Cincinnati’s Black residents moved to Canada and started the Wilburforce colony.</p><p>In Virginia, the Quaker church was on the decline. Through the 1700s, there were about 90 meetings for worship. As numbers declined, meetings were “put down,” that is, closed. In 1848, the Virginia Yearly meeting was put down, combined with the Baltimore meeting. In 1860, 15 Quaker meetings for worship remained in Virginia.<a href="#_edn34">[34]</a> Where the Religious Society of Friends persisted, the remaining members opposed slavery in thought and action — that is what the Society asked of Friends.</p><h3><strong>How did Free Black People fare in Virginia?</strong></h3><p>A common conclusion about the Virginia Manumission act of 1782 is that the backlash was so strong that the act had little effect. Laws did become more oppressive. Some of newly freed people left, but thousands stayed. They stood their ground in Virginia, where their ancestors had been for generations, close to family who couldn’t move, and where they had a livelihood. Some owned farms that housed extended families. Some could read and write. Some had connections across the state and into Ohio and into the professional and governing communities. Virginians lived with the dynamic tension of people striving for freedom within a system that denied it to them.</p><p>From the 1780 to 1810 the number of free Black people in Virginia went from under 3,000 to about 30,000. By the start of the civil war, about 50,000 free Black people lived in Virginia, ten percent of the Black people in the state. Free Black people were a larger and larger portion of the total. The rate of increase of the enslaved population slowed as Virginia enslavers sold large numbers of people to the deep south. Selling people was replacing growing tobacco as a primary business for enslavers with large numbers of people in bondage.</p><p>A few stories are being told about free Black people of antebellum Virginia. The colonists Anthony Johnson and John Punch, and his Bunch descendants, come to mind, and, of course, the extended Fossett and Hemmings families. I hope we uncover and tell more of these stories. In my look into Quaker history, I have seen descendants of John Punch who were members Cedar Creek meeting. I learned that Free State, a land-based community that Critta Hemmings married into, was on property that Amy Bowles-Farrow, a free Black woman, bought in 1788; that land continued into the 20th century by as Free State. Quaker William Johnson, and my sixth great-grandfather, Charles Moorman, had originally patented the property that became Free State. I suspect that there are many families that had free and enslaved members — these with ties to the well-documented likes of Thomas Jefferson and the Quakers may emerge from the archives more easily than some. But people are looking hard for those stories.</p><p><strong>And, If We Knew More Stories?</strong></p><p>If I were to construct a dramatization to explore some of the stories lost, I might start with the people named in Charles Moorman’s will. Here’s a fictionalized scenario:</p><p><em>Rachel and her son John were among the people Robert Moorman took to South Carolina to avoid Charles’ directions to free them. John was born into slavery in 1767, the same year Joseph Anthony was born. They may have been related. John’s extended family knew that Quakers were beginning to question slavery; and some Quakers were choosing to own people rather than to be Quakers. As a child, John learned to read, write, and cipher. He had some religious training from the Quakers, spiritual guidance from his birth family.</em></p><p><em>John was about 11 when Robert stole his family; John walked to South Carolina with his mother who occasionally cried. A few years later, Christopher Johnson brought both back to Virginia and settled Rachel with family in Bedford. John joined Joseph Anthony’s workforce in Richmond. While enslaved, John had worked in mills. Joseph knew him, trusted him and hired him as the mill operator. As a free man, John had dreams of owning land and protecting his family.</em></p><p><em>When the Ladd Anthony mill came online, John was central to its success. Richmond was changing from a chaotic construction zone to the capital city. Revolution was in the air; Haiti was emerging. Gabriel’s plans became known among enslaved, leased, and free Black people around Richmond. John decided what role he had in the plan.</em></p><p><em>Just after pounding rain and betrayal washed away Gabriel’s revolt, the milling partnership dissolved. The white backlash in Richmond was severe — curfews, passes, punishments. For a year, John joined Joseph farming and building a school at Gravelly Hill. He remembered the joys of a more rural life; made sweeter by living in a community of free Black people. The extended family of Quakers that John’s family had been intertwined with for 3 generations was in disarray.</em></p><p><em>Joseph Anthony asked him to join the move to Ohio. John refused. He had family who could not move. He returned to Albemarle. There he joined other free Black people — subsistence farming, with some cash crops, and paid labor as needed. He worked to keep his family safe, and teaching his children to read, farm, and mill.</em></p><p><em>Sometimes John woke from a nightmare — dreaming of his brothers and sisters enslaved in South Carolina. He often had chances to bruise the force of slavery for a person or two — by writing a note, giving the name of someone across the Ohio river, reading reports of Black resistance to friends, adding to funds to buy a loved one, sharing a good meal or giving his children hope. John and his community lived with the horror of thousands of people a day marched south to the brutality of cotton and sugar production</em>.</p><p>While the string of events I describe may not match any one person’s life — the individual incidents are certainly within the bounds of the lives of free Black people of the time and place. Of course, there are scenarios in which free Blacks of Virginia did not have land, family, food, security or even a lifetime of freedom — also in the bounds of reality.</p><h3><strong>Joseph’s Not Exactly Sad or Little Life</strong></h3><p>I no longer think that Joseph Anthony had a sad, little life. He’s not a giant of abolitionism — like Robert Pleasants. He was a young man who embraced The Religious Society of Friends’ becoming an anti-slavery church, and then rode rough currents of church rules, economic and technological change, and the politics of freedom. He had a spectacular falling out with the namesake of his first son, a name, Samuel, that has persisted in my family through my generation; did it have a bitter taste in Joseph’s mouth?</p><p>He had the will to leave a slave state, at age 40, with what his family could pack onto a few wagons. I think he was stubborn and earnest.</p><p>I don’t know if he mismanaged the mill; I’ll keep researching. By the time he moved to Ohio, his family had scattered across at least 5 states. He spent the last 25 years of his life with Rhoda, raising their children, running businesses and a small farm. In his will, he left the homestead to “my loving wife.”</p><p>Love is core to Quakerism. Telling Joseph’s story, I have found so much about conflict, but I think core Quaker values of peace, love and equality motivated him. He advocated for the people who had unjustly toiled in hard bondage. He challenged authority. He lived the upheaval of massive social change and didn’t see an end to slavery. Six generations later, I am inspired by him; I see him as a man who raised his voice and believed in peace. He wrote to Jefferson that emancipation is a natural force, he acted as if he knew it needed helpers. Still does.</p><h3>Notes:</h3><p><a href="#_ednref1">[1]</a> Swain, Frederic Anthony. <em>Mark and Joseph Anthony Families of Virginia: With Contributory Data on Capt. Christopher Clark and Moorman Families</em>. typed, mimeographed, photocopied, 1933.</p><p><a href="#_ednref2">[2]</a> Worrall, Jr, Jay. “The Albemarle Quakers, 1742–1754.” <em>The Magazine of Albemarle County History</em> 40 (1982): pp 25 to 44.</p><p><a href="#_ednref3">[3]</a> “Virginia Yearly Meeting Minutes.” Virginia Religious Society of Friends, 1779.</p><p><a href="#_ednref4">[4]</a> Hardin, William Fernandez. “Litigating the Lash: Quaker Emancipator Robert Pleasants, The Law of Slavery, and the Meaning of Manumission in Revolutionary and Early National Virginia.” PhD dissertation, Vanderbilt University, 2013. <a href="https://ir.vanderbilt.edu/bitstream/handle/1803/11711/HardinWF.pdf?sequence=1&amp;isAllowed=y.">https://ir.vanderbilt.edu/bitstream/handle/1803/11711/HardinWF.pdf?sequence=1&amp;isAllowed=y.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref5">[5]</a> Worrall, Jr, Jay. <em>The Friendly Virginians</em>. Atnens (sic), GA: Iberian Publishing Company, 1994, p 231.</p><p><a href="#_ednref6">[6]</a> “Will of Charles Moorman,” 1778. <a href="http://piedmontvahistory.org/archives14/files/original/94996a57cba9f2d0593329126a1b2999.pdf">http://piedmontvahistory.org/archives14/files/original/94996a57cba9f2d0593329126a1b2999.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref7">[7]</a> “Will of Charles Moorman,” 1778. <a href="http://piedmontvahistory.org/archives14/files/original/94996a57cba9f2d0593329126a1b2999.pdf">http://piedmontvahistory.org/archives14/files/original/94996a57cba9f2d0593329126a1b2999.pdf</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref8">[8]</a>[8] Hardin, p 238.</p><p><a href="#_ednref9">[9]</a> Worrall, Friendly, p 231.</p><p><a href="#_ednref10">[10]</a> Woods, Edgar. <em>Albemarle County in Virginia</em>. Charlottesville VA: The Michie Company Printers, 1901. P.286.</p><p><a href="#_ednref11">[11]</a> South River Monthly Meeting Minutes. 6th month 1799.</p><p><a href="#_ednref12">[12]</a> Hinshaw, Vol VI, pp 227–282.</p><p><a href="#_ednref13">[13]</a> Worrall, Albemarle.</p><p><a href="#_ednref14">[14]</a> “Will of Joseph Anthony,” 1785. <a href="http://freepages.rootsweb.com/~genealogyquest/genealogy/anthony_joseph_will.htm.">http://freepages.rootsweb.com/~genealogyquest/genealogy/anthony_joseph_will.htm.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref15">[15]</a> Worrall, Jr, Jay. “The Albemarle Quakers, 1742–1754.” <em>The Magazine of Albemarle County History</em> 40 (1982): 25 of 99.</p><p><a href="#_ednref16">[16]</a> Hinshaw, Vol VI, p 262.</p><p><a href="#_ednref17">[17]</a> Hinshaw, Vol VI, p 201.</p><p><a href="#_ednref18">[18]</a> Poole, William Frederick. <em>AntiSlavery Opinions Before the Year 1800</em>. Cincinnati OH: Robert Clarke &amp; Company, 1873.</p><p><a href="#_ednref19">[19]</a> Sidbury, James. <em>Ploughshares into Swords: Race, Rebellion, and Identity in Gabriel’s Virginia, 1730–1810</em>. First. University of Cambridge Press, 1997.</p><p><a href="#_ednref20">[20]</a> Whiteoak Swamp Monthly minutes</p><p><a href="#_ednref21">[21]</a> Hardin, quoting Joseph Anthony, page 202.</p><p><a href="#_ednref22">[22]</a> Whiteoak Swamp Monthly minutes.</p><p><a href="#_ednref23">[23]</a> Maule, James Edward. <em>The History and Genealogy of the Maule Family</em>, 1981. maulefamily.com. Individual detail, Thomas Maule.</p><p><a href="#_ednref24">[24]</a> Lundegard, Robert. “Country and City Mills in Early Amercian Flour Manufacture and Export, Draft,” September 18, 2007. <a href="https://spoommidatlantic.org/uploads/editor/files/Mid-Atlantic_Mills/Country_and_City_Mills-September_2007.pdf.">https://spoommidatlantic.org/uploads/editor/files/Mid-Atlantic_Mills/Country_and_City_Mills-September_2007.pdf.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref25">[25]</a> <em>Henrico County Virginia Deed Book 5</em>. Deeds 4 April 1796 to 8 May 1800. Iberian Publishing Company, 2014.</p><p><a href="#_ednref26">[26]</a> Berry, Thomas S. “The Rise of Flour Milling in Richmond.” <em>The Virginia Magazine of History and Biography</em> 78, no. 4 (October 1970): 337–408. <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/4247594.">https://www.jstor.org/stable/4247594.</a></p><p><a href="#_ednref27">[27]</a> “To Thomas Jefferson from Joseph Anthony, 22 January 1802,” <em>Founders Online, </em>National Archives, <a href="https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/01-36-02-0260.">https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/01-36-02-0260.</a> [Original source: <em>The Papers of Thomas Jefferson</em>, vol. 36, <em>1 December 1801–3 March 1802</em>, ed. Barbara B. Oberg. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2009, pp. 409–414.]</p><p><a href="#_ednref28">[28]</a> Virginia Yearly minutes, 1802.</p><p><a href="#_ednref29">[29]</a> Virginia Yearly minutes, 1804.</p><p><a href="#_ednref30">[30]</a> Sale of farm</p><p><a href="#_ednref31">[31]</a> Hinshaw Vol V, Ohio.</p><p><a href="#_ednref32">[32]</a> Steel, David Warren. “Secular Music in Shape Notes.” In <em>Rethininking American Music</em>, 50–67. Illinois: University of Illinois Press, 2019.</p><p><a href="#_ednref33">[33]</a> Darnowsky, Sabrina. <em>Friends Past and Present: The Bicentennial History of Cincinnati Friends Meeting (1815–2015)</em>. Darnowsky, Sabrina, 2015.</p><p><a href="#_ednref34">[34]</a> Worrall, Vol VI, pp 537–540</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=15915f03390f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Anthony Diamonds Family Research Project]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony/the-anthony-diamonds-family-research-project-b72355377d4d?source=rss-3d245f3789fd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b72355377d4d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[florida-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[muncie-indiana]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[family]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wealth]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Anthony]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2020 01:59:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-19T18:50:33.635Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How a Great Muncie Fortune Fared on a Florida Adventure</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z6PYyHdUTbQgwPfQ8wKmaQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Harriet’s shoe, as pictured in the Washington Post, 1912. glitter-enhancement by the author</figcaption></figure><p>Decades ago, my Dad’s aunt sent him a yellowed newspaper clipping. Dad took it to Josephine Pickett.</p><p>He had recently met Josephine at a work event. She had looked at his name tag and said, “Anthony. Edwin C. Anthony. Are you from the Ocala Anthonys?”</p><p>He was. So was she. They were second cousins, that is, their grandparents were siblings. Josephine Pickett had lived in Florida since she was a child, and Dad had not since he was two years old.</p><p>He showed her the clipping:</p><blockquote><strong>Mrs. H. M. Anthony is Dead at Muncie</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Mrs. Harriet Mitchell Anthony, owner of large real estate holdings in Indianapolis and Muncie, died yesterday morning in her apartment in the Hotel Roberts in Muncie. She had been in failing health since last Christmas when she became ill while in New York….</blockquote><blockquote><strong>She attracted national attention about 30 years ago by wearing diamonds in the heels of her shoes in New York……</strong></blockquote><p>Josephine Pickett was furious. “Those diamonds were intended for our education.”</p><p>She knew exactly who Harriet Mitchell Anthony was — the wife of their grandparents’ brother — Josephine and my dad’s great-aunt by marriage. Josephine had a long-standing issue with Harriet. And Josephine made clear to Dad that “our education” included all the cousins.</p><p>When Dad told me about the diamonds, he wasn’t mad. Dad’s Dad had pulled him out of school to work. Dad was 40 before he finished high school and went to college on the GI bill. Why he was more curious than mad, I could not tell you.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iKkE339kc5gSnCOpVpB0VQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Partial Anthony family tree compiled by Hilary Anthony</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The Anthonys of Muncie and Florida</strong></p><p>Josephine shared a family history compiled by Frederic Swain. Josephine’s and my Dad’s great grandfather, Edwin Clark Anthony, inherited a fortune in 1876.</p><p>Edwin’s father, Samuel Parsons Anthony, had brought the family to Muncie, Indiana about 1833, when it was a pioneer town. He had been one of the first doctors, and very active in real estate. He traveled the area, first making house calls, then acquiring land, and then collecting for the land he sold or rented.</p><p>Edwin had gone to a private boarding school in Richmond, as Muncie didn’t yet have a high school. When he graduated, he requested that a wagon come to pick him up “because his many books could not be carried on horseback.” Frederic wrote, “Books were precious in those days and the Anthonys all seemed to treasure them.”</p><p>Edwin had six children with his wife, Rebecca Vanneman. They sent their 3 sons to boarding school. Their oldest child, Florence, stayed at home, and in 1868 was the valedictorian of the first graduating class of Muncie High School. The Anthony family graduation rate was substantially higher than the national average.</p><p>As the children began to start their own families, the Anthony home was central to their lives: a place to marry, to set up housekeeping, to live in or return to periodically. Frederic Swain wrote:</p><blockquote>For the children of this generation, the environment of affluence made a very enjoyable existence, and it is fraught with many precious memories for this writer who was the oldest grandchild and the recipient of many favors and attention.</blockquote><p>Frederic describes pies bursting with sugar. Newspaper articles describe large parties in a mansion-sized house. Several generations had living quarters within.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*3-MrvAkzo-Eddz8HWj2usQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>According to my Dad, this is the Anthony home in Muncie, now gone. from family collection</figcaption></figure><p>Edwin ran a mercantile business in Muncie, and had the money to travel, race horses and initiate development projects. When the Civil War broke out, he was over 40. He organized a Union Calvary unit but resigned his commission after a fall and broken arm. The family history says that his health suffered, and he wanted to escape the Indiana winters.</p><p>When Edwin first travelled to Florida in the 1870s, he likely took a train to Jacksonville, then a steamboat south. Touring the wilds of Florida from a cruise down the St Johns river was adventure tourism. The river was lined with cypress trees dotted with egrets and vultures. In the tannin-brown water, alligators drifted. The thick vegetation hid panthers. And perhaps the most dangerous, mosquitoes swarmed, carrying malaria and yellow fever. To travel away from the river, Edwin would have travelled by horse or, mostly likely, ox cart on rough roads through sand and swamp.</p><p>In 1876, Edwin proceed to repeat a pattern of his ancestors: obtain land recently seized from indigenous peoples, then develop and resell. He got land patents, bought acreage, invested in a citrus grove, established a ranch, and named a town after himself — Anthony Place, just outside of Ocala. A passenger railroad was scheduled to reach the area soon.</p><p>In the years between 1876 and 1884, Edwin involved his young adult children in developing interests in Florida. The family travelled back and forth between Muncie and Florida regularly.</p><p>His son, Samuel Parsons Anthony, Jr, who went by SP, invested in the burgeoning phosphate industry, and ran a boarding house for visitors and new arrivals to Anthony. He raised his family more in Florida than in Muncie.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ebDReiB_c16khBciy5E_wQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>SP Anthony’s boarding house in Anthony Florida. From Anthony family collection</figcaption></figure><p>Florence built a large home, and donated land for the Anthony Methodist Church. She supported the local schools. Her husband was an early mayor and postmaster of Anthony. For a time, the Anthony community was thriving and growing. Florence was counted as a pillar of the community, even as Muncie continued to consider her one of their own.</p><p>Charles, the youngest son, came to Florida, but once he married Harriet Mitchell, he centered his life in Muncie.</p><p>The other 3 of Edwin’s children died in their twenties. According to Frederic, one from malaria, caught while clearing land in Florida, and another from complication of a horse-riding accident.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DZicL9EuvFUfioYq4_tBwQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>In Ocala, Florida, estimated 1885, SP Anthony driving. From Anthony family collection</figcaption></figure><p>In 1884, Edwin Anthony died in Florida. The family took his body to Muncie for burial. Josephine Pickett said that the Anthony fortune went north, too.</p><p>From Frederic’s family history, we hear that Edwin “did not succeed in conserving the wealth of his father.” But he gives very few hints of what happened. There is mention of paying off large debts of a son-in-law, and the impression of indulgences. Years ago, Dad and I had enough questions about the family money, that we took a trip to the courthouse in Marion County, Florida to find wills, probate, land records, anything.</p><p>Edwin left no will. We found a partial probate for Edwin, and several family members, including Harriet. She had assets. Dad and I couldn’t tell from the probate what had happened to all the Anthony real estate.</p><p><strong>Searching for clues</strong></p><p>My dad was born in 1922. By then, there was no Anthony fortune in Florida. I grew up hearing that Dad’s family were celery farmers in Sanford, Florida. When they lost a crop, they lost their farm and had to move in with relatives. An aunt in Houston, Texas took them in. Dad grew up poor. He didn’t return to Florida until after he had completed 21 years in the Navy.</p><p>Dad didn’t know much about his family. As an adult, he took up old-school genealogy: court houses, cold calls, letters, microfiche and hand-written lineages. So, when the minister of Anthony Methodist church asked Dad to find who owned the piece of property behind the church, he went to the right man. The property was held in what Dad called a “blind trust.” The church wanted the land for expansion. Both thought it had been part of the original acreage Edwin Clark Anthony owned.</p><p>That led to Dad knocking on a door in Connecticut. He asked for Ruth Anthony, the daughter-in-law of Harriet Mitchell Anthony, who had diamonds on the heels of her shoes.</p><p>Dad was met by Ruth’s daughter, his second cousin, Ann, and her husband. They said Mother lived in the carriage house out back. She was frail, and they didn’t want to disturb her. They did not invite him in. They answered no questions about the trust or the family. Ann stepped away. Before closing the door, her husband asked, “has the value of land there gone up much?”</p><p>Dad told that story, not with anger, but wry bemusement. “The carriage house” out back referenced grandeur, but that was the only hint he gave that some money had landed with them.</p><p>When Dad died in 2009, we couldn’t confirm or refute Josephine Pickett’s conviction that the Muncie Anthonys had cheated the Florida Anthonys out of promised funds for education. When I took on the puzzle of family history, the amazing powers of the internet turbo-charged my research.</p><p>I found the obituary for Samuel Parsons Anthony. It estimated his wealth at $250,000 to $500,000 in 1876. He was described as the richest man in Muncie on his death.</p><p>It’s hard to convert 1876 values into current values. You can use an inflation calculator. Or you can incorporate other factors, like the cost of labor, or the return on investments, or what portion of the population had similar wealth. By any of those standards, the estate was significant. The estate might be worth about $15 million in 2020 dollars; maybe a lot more, even by a factor of ten, or $150 million dollars. Samuel’s widow, his second wife Emily, inherited 1/3 in a life estate, and the remaining 2/3 went to Edwin. If he had outlived her, he would have inherited Emily’s share when she died.</p><p>I saw why Josephine Pickett expected some of that money to be spread around.</p><p><strong>Where did the fortune go?</strong></p><p>My search also led me to Harriet Mitchell Anthony. Jumping forward almost 3 decades after Edwin’s death, in 1912, Harriet made the front page of the Washington Post. She set society aghast and eclipsed Mrs. Nicholas Longworth by wearing diamonds on the heels of her shoes. That was Alice Roosevelt Longworth she eclipsed, Teddy Roosevelt’s daughter. Longworth had been making a sensation with cut glass shimmering on the heels of her shoes. The season in DC was dominated by the Republican primary race. Roosevelt was challenging Taft for the Republican nomination. Roosevelt ran on a progressive platform against Taft’s pro-business conservatism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4V47VvdHGaT_2bZYdbIQVA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Washington Post Front Page Feb 14, 1912.</figcaption></figure><p>Had Harriet intended to steal Alice’s thunder? I think so. Was Harriet intending a spectacle of support for continuing the gilded age? Did she and her husband show up in Washington to stand with the industrialists and the new fortunes despite the rise of labor? Charles was there supporting Taft. Were both the Anthonys aiming at showing up Theodore Roosevelt as much as his daughter?</p><p>Or, was Harriet, as she appeared in one interview, a woman hungry for attention, using jewels and furs to create a furor that would get her into society pages and upper crust events?</p><p>After a few weeks in DC, she went on to New York City. She got more press there for parading her diamond studded slippers on the Waldorf-Astoria’s Peacock Alley. It was a see and be seen place for rich women aspiring to fashion. She and her shoes appeared in papers in New York, DC, Indianapolis, Tampa, and Palm Beach.</p><p>When she next visited Florida, the Tampa Times repeated a story that was starting to vex her:</p><blockquote>The World contacted her husband, who had returned to Muncie. ‘He said the diamonds cost about $5 a quart. Mrs. A indignantly refutes this.’ She was quoted:</blockquote><blockquote>‘You old rascal, you, can’t you ever learn to keep still?… that husband of mine…always says the wrong thing always! Wait till I get home. I’ll read him the Indiana riot act. Do you wonder I’m a suffragette? Besides, it isn’t true.</blockquote><blockquote>‘You see, we have to pay a tax and when he starts in to swear off taxes somehow he always begins to belittle my jewelry, though, goodness knows, I pay my own taxes and buy my own jewelry. That is, I buy some of it.’</blockquote><p>Was it true? Were the diamonds worth little more than Alice Roosevelt Longfellow’s cut glass?</p><p>Or was Harriet’s response true that he was trying to play down the value for the tax man?</p><p>There are other possibilities. Was this reflecting a larger marital conflict? Five years earlier, Harriet had filed for divorce. She said he lost money speculating on horses; that they were estranged. He was abusive. He had converted an office in the Anthony Building into an apartment. There, she alleged, he served drinks. The apartment became known as a harem into which women of bad repute, in company with men, went for immoral purposes. That was from The Star Press of Muncie in 1907.</p><p>They did not divorce. He wasn’t above making comments to irritate Harriet, or to belittle her diamonds and her newly minted fame.</p><p>Or maybe he was trying some damage control. In addition to fawning press coverage of Harriet’s fashion, other articles criticized her. Labor representatives of the IWW criticized her in public meetings in Indiana.</p><p>Maybe Charles was attempting some damage control among his own family as well. For the past 15 years, his brother, SP had worked for wages as a customs collector in Cedar Key. The phosphate mines were gone. The boarding house in Anthony was gone. The citrus grove was gone. His sister, Florence, had no large business interests. Neither SP nor Florence were in the diamond and fur markets.</p><p>Was Josephine Pickett’s outrage justified? I continued looking for newspaper coverage, probates, anything that would tell me more. I learned that when the Delaware County Court House considered getting rid of many old documents, the Muncie library took them to keep them available. Thanks to the librarians, I got copies of several Anthony probates.</p><p>The Indiana probate for Edwin’s estate took 5 years, 1884–1889. His debts exceeded his liquid assets; the court ordered his real estate sold at auction. The Muncie paper lists the real estate to be sold.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/1*qG4Q2J91vOTxcQFjAot9fw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Edwin Anthony’s real estate sold off. Muncie Morning News July 23, 1885</figcaption></figure><p>It was a hard time for the family; three of Edwin’s adult children died between 1881 and 1884; they were all in their twenties. The three surviving adult children got small cash settlements. Edwin’s step-mother, Samuel’s widow, Emily, already had a life estate in the big family house; Edwin’s widow, Rebecca, continued to live there with Emily, her younger sister. That tangled sentence correctly reflects the tangled family relations. Each widow had been entitled to a one third interest of their deceased spouse, held as a life estate. Emily got 1/3 of Samuel’s very large estate; Rebecca got 1/3 of what was left when Edwin’s estate was settled. Except that some of both of their interests were sold to settle Edwin’s estate. Did any real estate besides the house pass on to family? Did Charles, SP and Florence already own other parcels?</p><p>From newspapers, I can see that both SP and Charles were constructing office buildings in downtown Muncie around the time their Dad died. Charles’ project, The Anthony Block, was completed. SP appeared in the Muncie paper for bad debts.</p><p>Emily and Rebecca had one other sister, Amanda, who also lived in the Anthony mansion. After Edwin’s death, the women continued the tradition of hosting family and friends. Frederic’s happy childhood memories had centered around those 3 women, who were now in their late 70s. The Florida Anthonys continued to use the house as their northern base and threw large events there.</p><p>By 1900, about a decade after Edwin’s estate was settled, the widows were both dead. Like Edwin, their debts exceeded the value of their personal property. They died with no wills. When Rebecca died, Charles was appointed executor by a judge who was Ruth’s, his daughter-in-law’s, father. Small town. That is the same Ruth Anthony who later lived in the carriage house out back.</p><p>According to the probate, because the children didn’t want a forced sale of the real estate, they agreed to contribute money to pay the debts of their mother’s estate, and they agreed to purchase any of the personal property they chose to keep. The probate doesn’t list the real estate that transferred to them. The mansion stayed in the family. The 1910 census shows Josephine (who was 3 years old and not yet a Pickett) as living in the Anthony mansion with her mother and grandmother, Florence. The era was ending. According to the Muncie newspaper, Florence sold the house in 1910, and moved her family permanently to Florida. Josephine didn’t know the affluence and pleasures of that home, but her mother certainly did.</p><p>Rebecca’s probate says, “that the personal estate of said decedent consists principally of household items and the diamonds….”</p><p>Diamonds. Rebecca left diamonds.</p><p>Oral history is tricky. Subtleties can be lost.</p><p>I may have understood Josephine Pickett as having meant, “the money that bought Harriet’s diamonds was intended for our education.”</p><p>I’m not sure if Dad quoted her correctly and if I remember correctly. Maybe she did literally say and mean, “those diamonds were intended for our education.”</p><p>Were the widows living their last years on borrowed funds? Did Rebecca tell Josephine’s mother that, despite a reversal of fortune, she had a plan to ensure her children would get an education? Had Rebecca shown Josephine’s mom sparkling rings and necklaces and made promises? Had Josephine heard that diamonds would be used to send her to college?</p><p>The closing report of the probate says that the surviving children contributed the value of the goods they took from the estate “and said Charles H Anthony taking said diamonds and findings and contributing the estimated value thereof.”</p><p>Charles, Harriet’s husband, bought the diamonds from his mother’s estate.</p><p>Had Josephine assumed that it was Rebecca’s diamonds in the shoes? By the time my dad showed Josephine that little yellowed clipping, those diamonds were a point of contention for fifty years. Whether or not the Florida Anthonys had figured things out correctly.</p><p>I haven’t been able to sort out whether Charles, Florence and SP got equal treatment. I can see so many ways the fortune was depleted. Edwin took on expensive, ambitious projects; the town of Anthony was a gamble as an investment, and it lost out to Tampa and Miami. The citrus grove was destroyed by the 1885 big freeze. The boarding house was destroyed by fire. A yellow fever outbreak in 1888 slowed travel to Florida. The phosphate mine was quickly depleted.</p><p><strong>What can be passed on</strong></p><p>Charles, staying in Muncie, invested in an industry that was on the rise — natural gas. His fortunes increased. SP had most of his business interests in Florida at a time when industries were rising and falling with the accelerant of speculative money. Fires, frosts, and competition were spendy adversaries. Florence was more focused on church, schools, and community than business; several of her children settled in Florida and made good lives there. It was possible for each of the heirs to get an equal share of what passed to their generation, and still end with dramatically different fortunes.</p><p>When Charles married Harriet, the Muncie paper said two of the wealthiest families in town were joined. That was not quite true; Edwin’s estate was already in probate and his debt was apparent. Harriet was the only surviving child of another pioneer doctor and real estate investor. Both of Harriet’ s parents died in 1909 — three years before she began her diamond and fur fashion media blitz.</p><p>So, did Harriet buy diamonds with her own money? Had Charles gotten more than his fair share of the Anthony fortune? Had any family fortune passed to Edwin’s children? How much had been lost to debts, speculation, horses, and indulgence?</p><p>I can’t tell. The older probates treat real estate and personal property separately. Probates don’t show what property had already been gifted or put into trust. But I can tell, that when Harriet died, decades after the Anthonys of her generation, she left a will that included lots of gems, and lots of real estate — both in Muncie and in Anthony, Florida. The trusts established by her will are likely the trusts that held the real estate behind the Anthony Methodist church in Florida. I can think of several ways that Harriet ended up with that Florida real estate. Perhaps Charles acquired it as a young man, when the family first ventured south; or perhaps the parcels were part of the estate his brother Edwin Anthony, Jr. left. According to the Muncie paper, he wrote a will when he was sick and bequeathed everything he owned to Charles. Maybe the property came to Harriet by way of another probate transfer: her father-in-law, Edwin Sr., or her son. She outlived the others of her generation, as well as her only son.</p><p>I’ve been working as an accountant for over 30 years. I’ve learned that wealth is not stable. I have learned that family members do not often share equally in fortune and tragedy. That is certainly true in the Anthony family. I think that Josephine Pickett wasn’t impressed by the diamonds as much as she was outraged by her belief that she was cheated out of an education. Josephine never went to college; she worked as a clerk in a school. I’d like to think that Rebecca, my 2nd great grandmother, valued education over diamonds, and that she was intending a fair settlement.</p><p>My Dad had the Anthony love of books. In that spirit, his second career was high school librarian. My parents gave me the gift of treating my desire to go to college as a natural and good thing. In-state tuition was something of a bargain in 1970s Florida. I qualified for some financial aid; I worked; and my parents were there when I needed. I am grateful for their support. I consider the value they put on education to be a family legacy.</p><p>Even Harriet, who loved her diamonds and all the glitter, was of a family that valued education. Her only son, Harvey Mitchell Anthony, went to Harvard. Then he chose to be an educator in a Muncie public school, before pursuing more education. His branch of the Anthony family had enough wealth that he could have indulged in other pleasures beside education and hard work.</p><p><strong>Epilogue</strong></p><p>Family history is the ever-expanding project. Not only does it evolve, the project expands as more family members come into sharper focus. The research and story-telling can go on and on. I’m pausing to tell this story, and I know it is not complete.</p><p>My research can continue to trace more of the real estate transfers. That may answer some mysteries. There are other questions I haven’t brought into this story. For almost 100 years, SP was the only Anthony buried in Anthony in Florida. Now both of my parents have joined them. Just as it seemed that Anthonys were, once again, disappearing from Florida, my family has learned we have more relatives to weave into the story. Stay tuned.</p><p>As a family historian, I am an amateur. I am trying to use good research methods and not make unsupported conclusions. Any errors in my analysis are mine. For this essay I have relied on: the family history written by Frederic Swain in 1933; probates of various family members and archived newspaper articles hosted on line.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b72355377d4d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Simon Built Community with Art]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony/simon-built-community-with-art-92fbf6e921f1?source=rss-3d245f3789fd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/92fbf6e921f1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[community-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[seattle]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Anthony]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 May 2019 19:01:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-04T17:05:59.477Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0gkbA6q1QGlKOYpYZLExfw@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Simon Neale and friend copywrite Hilary Anthony</figcaption></figure><p>On the West Coast of the US, there are large and small arts festivals with music, vaudeville, theater, costumes, floats and seasonal celebrations. Art builds community. We get messy painting floats. Get giddy creating skits. And reveal ourselves with costumes and characters. The trained and the amateurs make art together.</p><p>Simon Neale showed up early with tools; and unpacked more and more of his costumes as show time approached. He sang and joked from the stage, then danced away the night at the after party. He could build a stage, then play the lead in a Panto performance. And he had greater talents.</p><p>At Oregon Country Fair, he joined the set-up crews a week before the event to rebuild the Morningwood Odditorium. He always had time to tease and joke — often affectionate absurdities for those passing by. During the OCF prefair, he dressed for dinner. He’d put on a formal jacket with a pith helmet, to join hundreds of hippies in the camp kitchen. He had a booming laugh, and a gift for making other people feel they were the funny one. He knew people’s names. He used finesse and charm to get the materials and help he needed to set up the stage — and a good place in the food line.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5Eqe8k7Wsg-tk5esl174vw.png" /><figcaption>Simon the Emcee photo by John Cornicello</figcaption></figure><p>Simon’s greatest talent was to weave us deeper into community. He made people welcome. He let them in on the joke.</p><p>He chose us — us being west coast arts festies. I met him 20 years ago at Burning Man. The Fremont Arts Council was operating a passport bureau. I got in line to be ushered through an experience like waking up in the movie Brazil. Simon was among the fake bureaucrats who demandied paperwork then insisted on a random skill performance — singing, reciting, stripping, posing, whatever. The bureaucrats sent most people back to the end of the line before, finally, issuing and stamping Arts Council passports. The passport staff were dressed in uniforms from a disturbing, sexy dream.</p><p>He was born and raised in Stewkley, England. Once I asked what a Brit would know about him from his accent, he said, “that I was working class from the south.” He had a trade, finish carpentry. He had been in the Navy. And the weight of the tight British class structure didn’t suit him. Eventually, he settled in Seattle. One year at Burning Man a Brit invited him to a proper English tea, for Brits only. Simon declined. He said to me, “I came to America to experience what is here.” While there were English people he loved dearly, his prankish spirit, his streak of independence, his ambition, and his love of community arts all made the community he found on the West Coast of the US a good fit.</p><p>He chose the Fremont Arts Council. BurningMan. Oregon Country Fair. The Fremont Players. Islewild. Cirque du Flambe. The Moisture Festival. He thrived among people who made art that celebrates whimsy and champions justice.</p><p>I’ve sewn and fabricated beside him for weekends on Vashon Island, when the audience that comes to the plays are the same size as the cast. Simon and I were at the Islewild Festival in years that it was a shadow of its former glory — but still a vital community arts event. After the days’ efforts, dozens of makers huddled under the builders’ tent where we had a talent show for each other. A cast of kids, puppeteers, and community members singing songs and telling stories to each other. Community arts comes in events of all sizes. Simon was all in.</p><p>The Fremont Arts Council was at the base of Simon’s community arts involvement in Seattle — he found kindred spirits who make stuff and perform. The Arts Council brings in a summer parade, a winter feast, a fall lantern walk, and a Maypole dance. Simon loved to be a free-spirited clown in the Fremont Solstice parade — engaging the crowd and splashing those who were willing. After he had put in time with tools — getting the hand-pulled floats ready for the human powered parade. His Seattle community arts echoed what he had grown up with in England — the fires of Guy Fawkes Day, the spring maypoles and the winter Panto.</p><p>Cirque du Flambé was a spinoff of the Arts Council. Cirque du Flambé was no ordinary fire troupe — it was more dangerous, with leaf blowers moving fire. It was also sillier, with 200 pound men performing fire poi routines <em>ala</em> the young women in leather bikinis — but using 5 gallon buckets as platform shoes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1002/1*uti_c8Dx2ztQ_IR5h891ww@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Simon and Maque with leaf blowers. photo, by permission, Brian Foley.</figcaption></figure><p>The Fremont Players was another spin off of the Arts Council that Simon played a key role in. The Players presented Panto at OCF in the summer, and in Fremont during the winter. Panto for the winter holiday is an old English tradition; Simon introduced it to the Northwest arts community.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/621/1*sEodU0I-g6SpSxa0UMcfCA@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Panto at Morningwood Odditorium by Fremont Players</figcaption></figure><p>At OCF, he’d work at the Morningwood Odditorium from set up to breakdown. We assemble an outdoor stage for a weekend of shows. Whether I dropped by when it was only him with a hammer, or while the backstage was a flurry of costumes, wigs, puppets, instruments and performers, Simon was welcoming. Warm. He was part of a gracious and joyful tone carried by all the Fremont Players and Orchestra. Whether I have made art with him, or acted as his coordinator, Simon brought the same degree of engagement and fun to our relationship.</p><p>There are Fair children who have seen 6 performances by the Fremont Players in one weekend. They point and shout “Behind you!” Warning the hero of the villain. They know when to yell, “Oh no she didn’t”, or “Oh yes she did.” Those kids have experienced traditional Panto, complete with double entendres, over the top characters, life sized cow puppets, cross-dressing heroes and original songs.</p><p>Simon could not have pulled it off alone — but he laid the mortar at the foundation.</p><p>True to the whimsical transgressions of Panto, Simon, one year, as a preshow emcee, asked the audience if anyone spoke a language other than English. All weekend of the fair, many hands went up. He offered sharpies and asked if people knew a poetic way that other languages referred to morningwood. If so, would they write it on the bench they were sitting on? He delighted in the results.</p><p>For us, he stood out as English, with his accent and those manners. On the first 4th of July that he had US citizenship, he showed up in a red play-British officer’s jacket, festooned with medals. The teapot medal. The polka dot medal. The spoon medal. He was happy to describe the services marked. Valor in tea drinking during the great sugar shortage. Endurance in the face of a warm lager. Good cheer through summer heat.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/621/1*561q98T9OeDtRnHYrE0HfA@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Simon celebrated freedom. photo by Hilary Anthony</figcaption></figure><p>Like many clowns, he wagged a finger at arbitrary authority and injustice. I like to think that was at the core of his attraction to America, arts communities and hippies. I loved celebrating freedom with him — whether it was cheering on a kickball game, raising a toast or shooting off fireworks.</p><p>He was proud of his contributions to formation of the Moisture Festival. Years ago, Hale’s Brewery was his primary client for fine woodworking. He built out the pub interior. In exchange, he talked the owner into letting him convert a storage room into a theater. The other exchange he got was a generous supply of good beer.</p><p>The Moisture Festival had started as some vaudeville performances under a tent in Fremont, Seattle parking lot. Soon, it moved to Hales, and expanded to several venues.</p><p>Years ago, when the expansion had just started, Simon called me and said I had to come up for a weekend. He said you can’t understand unless you see it. But Simon, it’s my busy season. But Simon, it’s five hours up and back. But Simon. “The work will wait. You have to see this.” And I went. I was there for one of the shows he emceed.</p><p>Simon was a great emcee. In his tux jacket, black kilt and boater hat with the red ribbon, his good spirit bathed the audience. The Moisture Festival is magnificent — international variety acts — circus, vaudeville, magic, and music. Aerial burlesque. Acrobats doing archery with their feet. Jugglers in the dark with glowing props. Always a band, or orchestra. Many of the people who have brought vaudeville to the Oregon Country Fair all these years, have brought together this amazing festival that celebrates vaudeville and propels it into the future.</p><p>Simon was one of the many people who laid the foundation for that festival. The Moisture Festival is blessed with many skilled performers, organizers, carpenters and theater people. Simon had great solo moments, but he worked best in community. He had a knack for working hard and sharing his conviviality over dinner and a beer.</p><p>Last year, in one of our quiet moments during fair set up, Simon told me he had had a hard year. I touched his hand and didn’t ask. I knew he had disappointed his fellow performers. His drinking had caused problems for him and those he loved. His knees were failing him. There had been another breakup. I lost the chance to ask more. He spent the rest of the fair, as usual, jovial and engaged. Each person who came by to see him got some laughs, and most got called by name. Any teasing he did was playful, kind and smart. When I wasn’t carried away by the sheer joy of being near Simon, I thought about the tears of a clown.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*heoyx-SwQ3_oN3nRBMhuMg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Remembering Simon photo by H Anthony</figcaption></figure><p>Simon Neale died of multiple organ failure on 9 May 2019. He was 58 years old. He left behind a web of friends and family, including his beloved son, Keith Neale. The Moisture Festival will continue. The Morningwood Odditorium will, too. Our arts community will continue to build, sing and play together. But, damn, we are going to miss Simon. We are better for having had him weaving hard work and joy into our communities.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=92fbf6e921f1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Study Slavery to Understand My Family History]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony/i-study-slavery-to-understand-my-family-history-cea8a4063e49?source=rss-3d245f3789fd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cea8a4063e49</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[slavery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[quaker]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[family]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Anthony]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 Mar 2019 00:25:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-13T16:45:32.133Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gNWCBNAGmpa2OTq_-j4PyA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>About 20 years ago, my dad handed me a 10 generation history of our Anthony line. Amazing. Stories about colonial Virginia, bonnets, churches, pies…. But when I got to the page that showed my 7th great grandfather’s will, I was horrified. He left 9 enslaved people to his wife. He left one or two enslaved people to some of his children. Some of his children he left one shilling.</p><p>I looked away. I shut the history and didn’t return to the Virginia generations until my dad died ten years later.</p><p>In those ten years, Dad pulled me into other parts of the family history. I learned how the family came to Florida. Dad’s great grandfather assembled a Union Calvary unit from Indiana. Edwin Clark Anthony was close to 40 years old and the only son of a rich doctor. He raced horses. But after six months of service, and no battles, he fell from a horse and hurt his arm. The family story says that he went to Florida in 1866 to have a warm place to recuperate. Fine. I think he went for adventure and land speculation. Florida was not a vacation paradise in 1866 — there was yellow fever (which took one of his sons), bugs, snakes, and alligators. No air conditioning. He would have traveled by train, then steamboat, then by horse over sand and wooden roads.</p><p>I was able to engage with the history of an ancestor who had fought for the Union. And I had no idea how the family line had gone from owning slaves to fighting against the Confederacy.</p><p>There were 4 generations of Anthonys born in Virginia between 1719 to 1792. I knew so little about colonial Virginia. I didn’t know how to research family history. I saw Quakers mentioned in our history. In 2009, I searched on-line, and literally ordered old books about specific Quaker meetings. That was the start of my research.</p><p>With all the shame I felt about having ancestors who had owned people, I found it easier to read about my ancestor, Christopher Anthony, who was appointed by his Quaker meeting to spread the word that slave owning was no longer acceptable in the Quaker church. I had little context for understanding the strategy and political environment.</p><p>Eventually, I learned that the Virginia Quaker strategy started by encouraging Quakers to treat enslaved people well, and free them by will. By 1757, Virginia Quakers were directed to no longer hold enslaved people. I read books that were specifically about southern Quakers and slavery. The Quakers tended to believe in universal education and dignity; but strong veins of racism can be found in some of the members. The moral authority of the several early Quaker activists prevailed over time.</p><p>I struggled with my pride about Christopher, and his son, Joseph Anthony, who was a member of the Virginia Abolition Society. I was very aware that if I had any reflected glory for the stances of Christopher and Joseph, I also have the reflected guilt of the ancestors who owned people. My understanding of white privilege began to grow more complicated.</p><p>John Woolman, one of the early antislavery Quaker activists, visited South River meeting in 1745 and noted some of the harshest treatment he had seen Quakers mete out to enslaved people. That is the same meeting that was one of the first to prohibit its members from owning people — and the meeting that sent Christopher on his mission to spread the antislavery word in the 1770s.</p><p>I began to study slavery in Virginia more generally. What a hot mess. Years of tobacco production had depleted the soils of the richest plantations in the east. To the west, the poorer yeomen were struggling. Almost half of all the people enslaved in the colonies were in Virginia. The richest whites began to consider their bondsmen as inventory to sell farther south to the cotton plantations of Mississippi and Louisiana. Black families were increasingly being broken up. Resistance and rebellion of enslaved people was a constant concern of the rich whites who enlisted the poor whites as patrollers. Slavery was enforced by torture and murder. Tensions were high. The economy was shifting.</p><p>As I learned about slavery in colonial Virginia, I began to get over my focus on how slave-holding reflected on my family’s heritage. Chattel slavery reflects on the entire history of the United States. We need to look back farther than the 1860s to understand how slavery imprinted our country. The Civil War provides a crisp delineation of north/south free/enslaved. But that doesn’t tell the larger story of how slavery permeated the colonies economically and psychologically.</p><p>Debates about the morality and practicalities of slavery were going on all over the Western world. Thomas Jefferson summed up the position of many rich white Virginians on slavery “we have the wolf by the ear, and we can neither hold him nor safely let him go.” Various scenarios were debated. Send them to Africa. Give them land out West. We know what it took for the die-hard defenders of slavery to let go.</p><p>Virginia laws were stacked against enslaved people and their descendants. For a time, Virginia laws prohibited freeing and enslaved person for anything other than meritorious service. Eventually, the law allowed for freeing enslaved people, and by 1805 they were required to leave Virginia or get special permission to stay. A small number of enslaved people were freed in Quakers’ wills. One of my ancestors, Charles Moorman, who died in 1788, attempted to liberate enslaved people in his will. Some of his children moved out of state — with the enslaved people. They were sued by their siblings who sought to enforce the will. Charles’ son-in-law made 14 trips to Georgia and North Carolina in an effort to free the people named in the will — he met with some success. But some of the people were not freed.</p><p>The Anthony family lore says that Christopher Anthony freed slaves as a young man. Christopher was the son of my 7th great grandfather whose will I read. Christopher received one shilling as his inheritance. The will also said that if any of the beneficiaries intended to free the slaves they inherited, those enslaved people would go to another family member who would keep them.</p><p>By 1800, Quakerism in Virginia was falling apart. Christopher, and several of his family, moved to Ohio. The Ohio Anthonys say that formerly enslaved families moved with them. Christopher’s mother, and his siblings who accepted the enslaved people they inherited, moved to Georgia.</p><p>In elementary school, I had heard that brother fought against brother in the Civil War. I never suspected that my family had some of the brothers who went different directions over slavery. My family history is an American story. It is a southern story.</p><p>When I opened my eyes and began to learn about my ancestors’ participation in the slave-economy, I began to develop a deeper understanding of how central slavery is to United States history and current social issues. I began to have a better historic framework for racism, economic disparity and events of the years since the Civil War. The stake I have in confronting the lingering effects of centuries of slavery has become more urgent and personal. I am sad to say, I should have had that same sense of urgency, even if I had not used family history to initiate this study.</p><p>As an American, and descendant of colonial Virginians, I should have been better educated about slavery. I challenge fellow family historians to use history as the framework for personal stories. I challenge schools to do a better job teaching about slavery. And I challenge my fellow Southerners to stop confusing the Confederacy with the much larger and more complicated history of the South.</p><p>I’m going to try to do a better job of keeping my eyes open to how our ancestors — both enslaved and free — built this country and the work we need to do to fix the problems with centuries old roots.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cea8a4063e49" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[My Ancestor Escaped from Pirates only to be Abducted by the Internet:]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hilaryanthony/my-ancestor-escaped-from-pirates-only-to-be-abducted-by-the-internet-52b44d59dd9d?source=rss-3d245f3789fd------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/52b44d59dd9d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[genealogy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pirates]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[virginia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hilary Anthony]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 Dec 2018 15:38:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-07T03:13:04.529Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The family passed down the story that Mark Anthony was abducted by pirates. Now the internet won’t let go.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WgmqTPgJkJpGomVGs5LHEg.jpeg" /></figure><p>My relatives passed down a story about Mark Anthony escaping from pirates. They published it in family and local history books 100 years ago. In the mid-twentieth century, relatives repeated the story for their family histories — sometimes editing, sometimes not; sometimes citing, sometimes not. More recently, Mark’s pirate story spread on the internet. Ironically, the technology that has made it possible to read 17th century documents at your kitchen table, also has allowed the easy acquisition of ancestors from unsourced websites.</p><p>A version of the story printed in “Men of Mark of Georgia” from 1910 goes like this:</p><blockquote>This Mark Anthony had a remarkable career. His father was a native of Genoa, in Italy, and being driven from that country for some reason — religious persecution possibly being the cause — emigrated to Holland…he sent his young son Mark back to Italy to be educated. At the school, being ill-treated, Mark ran away to sea with a companion, and was captured by Algerian pirates. The two young men were sold as slaves, put in chains under guard and were set to cutting wood. Being mercilessly treated they determined to escape, and while the attention of the guard wandered for a moment, they knocked him on the head with an axe, broke their chains, and hid themselves in a wood. At night they boarded a British ship in the harbor and persuaded the captain to hide them in a hogshead, on which he piled sacks of coffee…When the ship left the harbor, they were released and transferred to a ship bound for Virginia, in which new country they decided to settle.</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/634/1*HAC6hEMs0ocZXqLlibMwNA.gif" /><figcaption>Hogsheads held tobacco, wine, and stowaways</figcaption></figure><p>Meanwhile, my distant cousin, Governor Allen Candler, had already tried to tamp down the pirate story in a 1896 book. After quoting Mark’s granddaughter, who said Mark was Genoese Italian, the author says, “the foregoing is <em>all</em> the written history we have.” Boom. No pirate story.</p><p>The tone was set by these two accounts. The story gets repeated. The story is questioned. The pirate story is a backdrop to the mission of the historians — commemorating the significance of Mark’s descendants. Those books were scattered among libraries, historic societies and homes when another wave of my distant family started their research.</p><h3>A legend persists…</h3><p>In 1933, Frederic Swain wrote “Mark and Joseph Anthony of Virginia.” It is a chatty history that goes from Mark Anthony to my Dad’s Dad in 8 generations. My dad got a blurred carbon-copy when he tracked down Swain’s son, (Dad’s first cousin once removed) in the 1970s. Swain started his history with Anthonys in the English court, Anthonys in the Virginia Company and Anthonys in Cromwell’s service, and then launched into:</p><p>“A legend persists however through the entire Anthony family that we are of Italian origin.” He continued with the pirate story. Swain went on to say that Mark Anthony was indentured in Virginia, and eventually appeared as a landowner in the vestry records of St. Paul’s parish of New Kent County, Virginia.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QN9roDmH4gsnbThJMUJU7A.jpeg" /><figcaption>My great great aunt, Florence Virginia Anthony Swain, told the pirate story in a 1908 letter</figcaption></figure><p>Another distant cousin, Nancy Anthony Vashti Jacobs, in the 1970s, included the pirate story in an extensive family history she called “Anthony Roots and Branches.” She quoted the earlier histories.</p><p>Dad didn’t believe it. His said there were no British trade routes from Algiers in the 17th century. Couldn’t have happened. Don’t know why that story caught on. No sense in wasting research effort on the pirate story.</p><p>Dad was doing old school genealogy in court houses and libraries; he never got on the internet. At times, he’d enlist me to fire up Netscape Navigator to research some elusive relative. In the 1990s I looked around enough to see that family histories were proliferating.</p><p>When my dad died in 2009, I took Frederic Swain’s history and searched like crazy online. I looked for names, places, publications, events. The pirate story was widespread; Mark Anthony could have millions of descendants. Over and over I found versions of the story in family trees. Google had been digitizing books; I’d find preview panes with the pirate story. By that time Amazon was robust enough that I was able to purchase old self-published family and local histories — sometimes the originals, sometimes reprints.</p><h3>It’s likely to be true of someone….</h3><p>Some family historians questioned whether the story was true, but many included the story with no wink, no nod, and no citation. In the late 1990s, Arlene Anthony flat out said she didn’t believe the pirate story and went England to look for Anthonys in records of the 1500s and 1600s. She found several Anthony lines — a royal engraver and crown jeweler to Elizabeth I, a goldsmith, a brewer, and even an Anthony who was John Smith’s cabin boy.</p><p>Arlene Anthony was a retired Latin teacher with failing eyesight and six file cabinets; she collected a dazzling assortment of scattered details. Her published results were speculative, fragmentary and inconclusive. But she was a significant online voice among the descendants of the Virginia Anthonys. Without a genealogical proof, she challenged the pirate story as being too far-fetched.</p><p>Maybe. Maybe not. A simple search of Algerian pirates told me those were the infamous Barbary pirates. The 17th century was their heyday. By 1650, Barbary pirates kidnapped between 20,000 and 30,000 Europeans and took some to Algiers as slaves.</p><p>Maybe I didn’t know enough about the 17th century to judge what stories were far-fetched. And thus began my reading about colonial Virginia. I was reminded of an Aristotle quote I had jotted down in college, “At least that’s the story that’s told, and if it’s not true of him, it’s likely to be true of someone else.”</p><p>I have no idea if John Smith of Jamestown’s autobiography was reliable, but he told a story that had striking similarities to Mark Anthony’s. Smith was not happy that his dad apprenticed him to a merchant. He ran away, and after some adventures, was captured by Turks, sold at a slave market, (many complicating details omitted here), and put to work in grain fields. He hit his captor in the head then escaped. And eventually, he ended up in Virginia.</p><p>Were both Mark Anthony and John Smith enslaved by pirates–escaping after cracking their guards’ skulls? Maybe. Maybe not.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aVfJQ1mtIIOjKCX2R0Yf4Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>Arlene Anthony didn’t ask “could it have happened?” She asked, why was the pirate story told? Arlene died before she found a connection between the English Anthonys and Mark. Other family researchers have agreed that Mark was hiding something — maybe that he was Jewish.</p><h3>Looking where the light don’t shine…</h3><p>Were the Anthonys trying to hide Jewish heritage? Or maybe some African ancestors? Or hiding a connection to Thomas Anthony who spirited a boatload of Irish to the colonies? Were Anthonys trying to hide crime or poverty?</p><p>Or had the story been a mix up? Pirate stories were common in the 18th century. Did a kid get confused hearing a pirate story, and years later retell it as family history? Mark’s children married into families that had come to Virginia by way of Barbados. Could Mark have stowed away in a ship sailing to Virginia from Barbados? Could it have happened?</p><p>We may never know. I suspect many family researchers are like the man looking under the streetlight for his lost keys. Not because he lost them there, but because that’s where the light is the best.</p><p>Most of the 60,000 people of European and Africa descent in Virginia in 1700 were not connected to a royal court. Most were not members of the elite Tidewater families. Most were not wealthy. Many of the English had been desperate, displaced and poor. There were thousands indentured and enslaved people brought to Virginia against their will. Most people did not leave a good trail of written documentation about their origins.</p><p>The walls that African American family historians can hit with the Civil War and the middle passage are widely recognized. People were torn from their histories. The genealogical research methods that work for wealthy literate families don’t work for most African American families before 1865.</p><p>I suggest that many family researchers of primarily European descent don’t recognize walls hiding their colonial ancestors. In Virginia, somehow the research keeps leading back to the House of Burgesses, to the land-owning families, to Pocahontas, to royalty. Of the hundreds of ancestors we may have from the 1700s, we find ourselves on a few well-worn trails. Some of those lines have been established by good genealogical methodology. Some have been passed down as stories families have repeated about themselves.</p><h3>We have been admonished to respect and revere our ancestors….</h3><p>Some of the family-passed stories were written with the best information the author had: family bible records, a great aunt’s recollection and letters from a cousin. The stories I have read are tinged with the authors’ efforts to impart a familial-civic pride. My great great aunt bragged about governors, generals and doctors in the family. Jacobs takes a wider stance; she starts “Anthony Roots and Branches”:</p><blockquote>We are what we are because of what our ancestors were. Many of our ancestors were settlers in Virginia. “Colonial Virginia: Its people and customs” by Mary Newton Stanard: ‘Not a single instance of a Virginian family descended from a convict has ever been found by any genealogist.’</blockquote><p>I’m tempted to just leave that there, but I can’t. Her version of the pirate story, that follows on the next page, says that Mark and his enslaved companion took their guard “unawares and killed him with an axe.” Okay, technically, he was not convicted.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/225/1*JfQhq1vjlT1B4dqJqTyccQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>John Smith had a threshing bat</figcaption></figure><p>In some cases, family pride was packaged with racism. As a 1959 family history by my distant cousin, Robert J. Rodenberry, Jr starts: “Through all recorded history we have been admonished to respect and revere our ancestors and preserve our racial and family integrity.”</p><p>The effort to present a family story inspired by pride can lead to omissions. If a family historian emphasized lineages that lead to the rich, the royal and the ruling, and if that historian’s mission was to depict a lineage that could be shared with the Daughters of the American Revolution, a certain tone is set.</p><p>In my family, writers were okay with saying that Mark Anthony was a murderer, but details about his descendants are framed by the family-pride theme. I’ve found some details about Mark’s progeny that are missing from Swain’s account; two examples:</p><p>Mark’s great grandson, Joseph Anthony, Jr, was kicked out of the Quaker church for taking his business partners to court when they accused him of mismanagement. Swain just mentions “unfortunate endorsements on commercial paper ‘to accommodate friends’.”</p><p>Mark’s great great grandson, Samuel Parsons Anthony, had two children with a woman on the edge of town who he never married. Silence. Swain did not include those children in the history.</p><h3>We have more cousins than we know….</h3><p>I’m left to wonder if there are other events and people omitted. Were there mixed-race half-siblings? There were slave-owners among the early generations. What were the disputes with native people as this family moved to the perimeter of European settlement four times and retreated once? And the ancestors who came to Virginia by way of Barbados, who did they bring with them?</p><p>The history of colonial America includes indigenous people, rich Europeans, poor Europeans, abducted Africans and their descendants. I suspect that the old published family histories of the white folk under-represent the poor, the enslaved and the criminal. If we rely exclusively on those histories, and just use the internet to repackage them, we risk repeating mistakes and omissions.</p><p>Today amazing resources are available for researching colonial ancestors. Genealogists are using maritime logs, land records, wills and slave rolls to explore peoples’ lives. It is possible to trace neighbors, friends and business relationships from 300 years ago. By starting with the documents of the day — where we find our ancestors — family historians can use the internet to move beyond the well-worn and poorly sourced stories that have been repeated for centuries. Some of us have more cousins than appear in our family trees.</p><p>Professional genealogists focus on how to document and prove relationships and events. Let’s find space in genealogical studies to treat the old stories as a research subject — not to prove so much as to trace and put in context. Where do these old stories fit in the future of genealogy research that is likely to be better and better sourced?</p><p>I may never know if Mark Anthony was abducted by Barbary pirates. But I do understand the world my family lived in better for trying to figure out, “Could it have happened?” And I’m going to keep asking what else happened — starting where we found him documented in New Kent County, Virginia.</p><h3>Because I’m all for sourced information, here are the books and documents referenced:</h3><p>Candler, Allen D. 2018. <em>Colonel William Candler, of Georgia: His Ancestry and Progeny; Org. 1896</em>. Classic Reprint Series. Forgotten Books of FB&amp;c LLC.</p><p>Jacobs, Nancy Vashti Anthony. 1971. “Anthony Roots and Branches.” Professional Business Services. <a href="https://www.santhony.com/AnthonyFamily/arb1.pdf">https://www.santhony.com/AnthonyFamily/arb1.pdf</a>.</p><p>Northen, William J., ed. 1910. <em>Men of Mark In Georgia: A Complete and Elaborate History of the State from Its Settlement to the Present Time, Chiefly Told in Biographies and Autobiographies of the Most Eminent Men of Each Period of Georgia’s Progress and Development</em>. Volume II. Kessinger Legacy Reprints. Kessinger Publishing, LLC.</p><p>Roddenbery, Jr., Robert S. 1959. <em>Ancestors and Descendants of Cader Atkins Parker, 1810–1886</em>. Adel, Georgia: Press of the Patten Publishers. <a href="https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=wu.89069612372;view=1up;seq=6">https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=wu.89069612372;view=1up;seq=6</a>.</p><p>Stanard, Mary Newton. 1917. <em>Colonial Virginia: Its People and Customs. Org 1917</em>. Kessinger Publishing, LLC, reprint.</p><p>Swain, Frederic Anthony. 1933. “Mark and Joseph Anthony Families of Virginia: With Contributory Data on Capt. Christopher Clark and Moorman Families.” typed, mimeographed, photocopied. Hilary’s Library.</p><p>Swain, Florence Virginia Anthony. 1908. Letter to cousin Christopher Clark. photocopy. Hilary’s Library.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=52b44d59dd9d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>