<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Hila Shachar on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Hila Shachar on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@hilashachar?source=rss-aecc6ed1b245------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 01:08:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@hilashachar/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sink and swim: stories of anti-Semitism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hilashachar/sink-and-swim-stories-of-anti-semitism-123d9e985003?source=rss-aecc6ed1b245------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/123d9e985003</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hila Shachar]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Mar 2015 13:44:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-25T08:16:01.418Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There is a rather depressing folder on my laptop with saved articles on anti-Semitism. The breadth of these articles is enough to convince you that as a species, we are doomed. As an academic, I do what other academics tend to do with this collected ‘data’: I turn it into narratives. Truthfully though, that is what many human beings do. We can turn even the most unpalatable, irrational, unexplainable and abhorrent aspects of ourselves and our culture into easy narratives. What worries me is the lack of difficult and nuanced narratives, especially amongst my fellow ‘progressives’.</p><p>So, while I’ve been collecting ‘data’, I’ve also been collecting stories. These are the grand stories into which many smaller news items fit; they are trends, fashions, ways of simplifying Jews as a homogeneous group. They are ways to make the unpalatable accessible. They are neat packages of boxing Jews and Jewish identity which I intend to unpack. And I do so while directly pointing the finger at those with whom I previously thought I had a natural affinity: left-wingers, progressives.</p><p>I say previously, because I am increasingly alienated from left-wing groups and sense that many of my fellow Jewish friends and acquaintances are too. I refer to ‘the left’ in this article knowing I make a generalisation. But here, I am specifically referring to the dominant discourses practised and supported by dominant left voices which, quite simply, are immature and rather demeaning.</p><p><a href="https://davidmacailean.wordpress.com/2015/02/15/the-rise-of-antisemitism-in-the-uk-infographic/">But let’s start with some ‘data’</a> , shall we? The kind of data that is blithely ignored by most of the left-wing progressive voices I follow on social media. Or, you know, the fact that a lot of this data comes from contemporary left-wing narratives constructed around Jews.</p><p>Let me tell you some stories…</p><p><strong><em>The ‘Other’, Jews, and Israel</em></strong></p><p><a href="http://tabletmag.com/jewish-arts-and-culture/books/189204/a-polite-hatred-1-jacobson">“Israel has desacralized the subject. It’s a space in which everything is allowed again.”</a></p><p>Desacralized is the word. For a while there after the Holocaust, it was hard to find an easy narrative for those with an unconscious and conscious hatred of the Jews to express their fundamental suspicion of Jews as alien beings who bring all their troubles on themselves. But then Israel came to the rescue, and boy, isn’t it used to such metaphorical perfection these days?</p><p>I don’t write this lightly, despite my sarcasm. It is perfectly reasonable to criticise a country, a government, politicians and specific policies. It is not, however, reasonable to demonise a country and every one of its inhabitants as the epitome of all evil in the world and focus on it with an almost hysterical fanaticism that feeds a wider narrative of the Jew as ‘Other’.</p><p>Now, I’ve listened to the ‘it’s anti-Zionism not anti-Semitism’ arguments countless times, but they’re about as convincing as saying that attacking a mosque isn’t about Islamophobia but about ‘anti-terrorism’. Really, do you think we’re all idiots?</p><p>The narrative here is a convenient one: The Jew as Other made palatable via the existence of Israel. It’s hard to beat on a minority group when they’re weak if you’re a self-proclaimed progressive, but, if there is an existence of a country with a military you can direct your attention to, well, nuance and complexity can fly out the window and it’s easy to construct a self-congratulatory bed-time story of the ‘goodies’ and ‘baddies’. Because the world always fits so neatly into binaries, huh?</p><p>In the process, <a href="http://tabletmag.com/scroll/189810/attack-in-the-london-shtetl">in Ben Judah and Josh Glancy’s words</a>, “Jews are yet again becoming a weird, subterranean target for those wishing to practice hate and express their atavistic urge for aggression and tribalism. That a growing obsession with ‘Zionist’ crimes makes Jews vulnerable to sudden, flash floods of violence whenever tempers boil over in their vicinity.” We are once again becoming the Other, but have we really been anything else to Europe?</p><p>The ‘Other’ is a term used a lot in academia. I use it a lot in classes. But let’s think about what it means to individual human beings as opposed to theory.</p><p>Being an Other means you are dehumanised.</p><p>Being an Other means that the complexity of who you are, all those small details, memories, experiences, histories, are co-opted by someone else who defines you for yourself. It is a feeling of utter helplessness. It is a feeling of dread and unreasonable shame when someone stares at me for wearing a Star of David, or that uncomfortable silence that comes from saying I’m Jewish or was born in Israel, as if admitting a secret crime, as if people are countries.</p><p>Being an Other is a simplistic, almost animalistic instinct to categorise, subjugate, demean and ignore. <a href="http://www.timesofisrael.com/jewish-graves-vandalized-human-remains-scattered-in-hungary/">Like being scattered human remains</a> — something abject.</p><p>Being an Other is functioning as the empty repository for collective hate, frustration, and projection. It is like being an insubstantial metaphor rather than an individual. It is like being a word rather than flesh. It is being an alien in your own home.</p><p>Being an Other means you fool yourself if you think you are accepted in the country in which you choose to live.</p><p>And acceptance is waved in front of Jews’ faces like a magic wand by many progressive voices I have personally encountered. Swear a loyalty oath! Denounce Israel as the root of all evil! Separate yourself from your roots, where you grew up, your family, and all will be forgiven! Become one of us and we’ll accept you! <em>The truth is though, I don’t want you, or your ‘acceptance’. I know what I am to the core of my being, and you can’t touch that because you can’t understand it. You are too swallowed up by easy narratives to see what I am. </em>That is my internal monologue to anyone who suggests this line of thought to me.</p><p>But it’s still disturbing to encounter it again and again, especially when it comes from fellow Jews, <a href="http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/mar/20/why-does-the-left-ignore-antisemitism-all-forms-of-racism-should-be-abhorred">as Dean Sherr recently pointed out</a>:</p><p>“That attitude was shown by leftwing Jewish actress Miriam Margolyes’ astonishing performance on a recent episode of the ABC’s Q&amp;A programme. Answering a straightforward question on whether antisemitism garners as much sympathy as Islamophobia, Margolyes’ response was to bring up Israel’s ‘evil’ actions in Gaza as a likely cause of antisemitism. Her solution was for Australians to see that ‘not all Jews behave in the way Israelis are doing’ — suggesting all the Jew has to do is denounce Israel loudly enough, or perhaps wear a sign, that indicates that we aren’t all ‘evil’ like Israelis are, to avoid being victimised.</p><p>[…]</p><p>It is surely obvious that mitigating bigotry or racism with victim-blaming is wrong regardless of the victim’s ethnic or religious background. Yet it persists in some left-wing circles that Jews are the exception to this rule — our communal connection to Israel makes us somehow more legitimate targets, unless we denounce the Jewish state.”</p><p>At the heart of this logic is a misguided, and I admit, often well-meaning, attempt to separate us into ‘good’ and ‘bad’ Jews. It doesn’t get more condescending than that, as if Jews are to be managed like toddlers. Which leads me to the next story…</p><p><strong><em>Hiding and assimilation: The pseudo-peace</em></strong></p><p>Everyone wants peace right? Well, there’s peace and then there’s hiding behind it — I call this pseudo-peace, the kind of self-delusion that keeps you in your place while seeming to do the right thing. It’s peace without freedom, <a href="http://tabletmag.com/jewish-news-and-politics/189642/peace-the-grand-delusion?utm_source=fb&amp;utm_medium=post&amp;utm_content=Peace%2C+the+Grand+Delusion+of+the+Jews&amp;utm_campaign=march2015">as Chloe Valdary so eloquently wrote</a>:</p><p>“If a Jew is lynched and no one in the community fights back, that is — by definition — a peaceful situation. It is also unjust.</p><p>If a swastika is painted on the building of a Jewish organization or school, and no one in the community fights back, that is — by definition — a peaceful situation. It is also unjust.</p><p>If racists promote the wholesale discrimination of Jews on campus, and no one in the community fights back, that is — by definition — a peaceful situation. It is also unjust.</p><p>Therein lies the rub: We conflate ‘peace’ with virtue while sacrificing the latter on the altar of the former. As a result, there will never be real peace because there is no justice.”</p><p>I hear the word ‘peace’ in many left-wing Jewish groups and communities I actively participate in. At its core, peace is an admirable goal. It is not however, a sacrificial altar to which we must subjugate ourselves. And I don’t think it’s peace at all, it’s hiding under the guise of ‘assimilation’ and <a href="https://instagram.com/p/z-zTpLOQ5k/">to rephrase Audre Lorde’s words</a>, using the master’s tools to dismantle ourselves, not the master.</p><p>Let’s consider what assimilation is when it is demanded and enacted as an avenue for ‘acceptance’. Assimilation often requires the dismantling of what makes you ‘different’ to fit in. It means not rocking the boat when your difference is the root of hatred directed at you, but rather, trying to sweep it under the carpet in the hopes that it will go away. It is a mentality that many of my fellow diaspora Jews have advocated for — the idea that if you hide, keep your mouth shut, remove your difference or at least try not to draw attention to it too often, they will leave us alone. It is a fool’s paradise, and one which hasn’t been convincingly been put into practice, if we’re honest with ourselves.</p><p>Because they come for you whether you identify with your Jewish identity or not. We have learned this from history, time and again. Or, perhaps, we haven’t learned.</p><p>For practical reasons, understandably, European Jews have been encouraged <a href="http://www.jta.org/2014/08/08/news-opinion/world/citing-security-concerns-copenhagen-jewish-school-forbids-religious-symbols">to avoid wearing religious symbols</a> or <a href="http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-31993763">display their Jewish identity</a>. It is the equivalent of telling women not to wear short skirts to avoid rape. And it doesn’t work, because they come for you anyway. So this easy narrative of hide and all will be okay needs to stop. Name the problem. Direct the finger of responsibility to where it properly belongs. Stop blaming the victims for their own victimisation. In other words, act like grown ups rather than infantilising a minority group as beings who need to cower before their masters.</p><p><strong><em>But what are you doing for us?</em></strong></p><p>This leads me to the final narrative I will explore, and while it starts simply, I hope its ends will be more complex. <em>What are you actually doing for us? </em>That is my question to progressives. Why should we fight alongside you if you won’t fight <em>with</em> us?</p><p>This is the opposite of assimilation, this is a recognition that us humans are multifaceted, complicated and contradictory. That within us exist so many stories, we can’t be narrowed down, asked to swear loyalty oaths, boycott and blanket essential parts of who we are. It is the knowledge that goodies and baddies exist in two-minute news reports and fairy tales, not in reality. It is the truth that criticism must come hand in hand with nuance.</p><p>A long time ago, I wrote these words about my family:</p><p>“It must be the lulling affect of the sea, and the sense of being kept company in your aloneness. I often feel alone in crowds of people, but sitting by the sea on my own, I feel full, like I’m sitting next to a good friend. In those moments, I feel the closest to my family on the other side of the world. In those moments, I allow myself to think about all the fragments I’ve been collecting, and how to shape them into words. Maybe the lulling affect of the sea acts like a lullaby, taking me back to childhood, when I felt enveloped by my family, and when I wasn’t old enough to differentiate myself from them, or see the differences between us. It’s a nice feeling. I know I can’t live in this feeling, but it’s good to have it there. It makes the process of turning things into narrative seem less daunting — it just feels right. So I’ve moved from Brazil to the sea, and that’s where I’ll leave you, for the time being.”</p><p>Within these words and the narratives I create around myself and my family are hints of all the things that make us what we are. You can choose to meet me halfway and see what I am made of — you can choose to share in my stories — or you can choose to co-opt me into one of your easy narratives.</p><p>You can choose the pose of progressiveness and openness as a simple ideology, or you can sink and swim with me in my complicated stories, which are not a pose but a practice, a life. I will offer you no easy tales, I will not be your Other, I will not be your scapegoat, your trophy, your token.</p><p>This is up to you, but don’t expect me to cower in the corner because you refuse to see me, and others like me, for what I am.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=123d9e985003" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>