<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Hills r pro on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Hills r pro on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@hillsrpro?source=rss-5449e0380ba2------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 22:17:59 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@hillsrpro/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Understanding Manu 2.31]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hillsrpro/understanding-manu-2-31-493c2f9f4ecc?source=rss-5449e0380ba2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/493c2f9f4ecc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hills r pro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 Apr 2026 09:13:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-27T04:26:09.850Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>People often see this verse and say its discrimination against Śūdras ect. saying they cannot even have a good name citing this verse of Manu:</p><blockquote>मङ्गल्यं ब्राह्मणस्य स्यात् क्षत्रियस्य बलान्वितम् ।<br>वैश्यस्य धनसंयुक्तं शूद्रस्य तु जुगुप्सितम् ॥ ३१ ॥</blockquote><blockquote>The name of the Brāhmaṇa should be auspicious, that of the Kṣatriya connected with power, that of the Vaiśya associated with wealth; while that of the Śūdra <strong>contemptible</strong>.</blockquote><p><em>~ Manusmṛti 2.31</em></p><p>Now let us begin the refutation:</p><p>If we look into texts like the Puranas we find the names of Śūdras given as things such as ‘Nityodaya’ (Padma-purāṇa Kriyākhaṇḍa, ch. 23) and ‘Kāladvija’ (Padma-purāṇa Brahmakhaṇḍa, ch. 16). Even in Mahābhārata, Rāmāyaṇa, and Purāṇa-s, there have been a wide variety of names which don’t follow this order at all like Śambūka and Vidura (whose name literally means intelligent) and the ones mentioned earlier. So, perhaps, it’s better to consider this not as mandatory but more of a recommendatory karma such that by not doing it, one wouldn’t really incur sin. So even if we grant this there is no need to name a Śūdra as ‘contemptible’.</p><p>Now getting to the crux of the matter, the word given in the verse is जुगुप्सितम् which comes from the root गुप् which means to protect</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1-gw-dhwOy77xkxH" /></figure><p>The word ‘ जुगुप्सा ’ is made by the root गुप् + the affix सन्. Usually, adding the suffix सन्/San to a root makes it “desiderative” — meaning “to desire to do something.” (e.g., गुप्/Gup [to protect] + सन्/San usually becomes जुगुप्सा/Jugupsa [to desire to protect oneself], which evolved into “to be on guard/shun/despise”). However here, the affix सन् is not altering the meaning of the verbal sense at all, which means the root sense ‘protection’ remains unaltered, this is a rule called Svartha स्वार्थ in grammar also known as स्वार्थे प्रत्यय Svārthe Pratyaya where a suffix added to a word that does not change its meaning. The word remains “in its own sense”. The suffix Kta/ क्त turns the verb into a past passive participle (like adding “-ed” in English). Gup (Protect) → Jugupsa (Protect) → Jugupsita (Protected).</p><p>So the naming convention of the Śūdra should be such that the name carries with it an explicit sense that he or she is [or needs to be]protected, and the protection of Śūdra in general. The Viṣṇu purāṇa says:</p><blockquote>शर्मवत् ब्राह्मणस्योक्तं वर्मेति क्षत्र संयुतम्।<br>गुप्त दासात्मकं नाम प्रशस्तं वैश्य शूद्रयोः।।3.10.9।।</blockquote><blockquote>“Next, upon the tenth day after birth, let the father give a name to his child; the first term of which shall be the appellation of a god, the second of a man, as Śarman or Varman; the former being the appropriate designation of a Brahman, the latter of a warrior; whilst Gupta and <strong>Dāsa </strong>are best fitted for the names of Vaiśyas and <strong>Śūdras</strong>.”</blockquote><p>Here there is nothing ‘contemptible’ being talked about while naming the children of each varna. Instead the word Dāsa is used which roughly translates to ‘Servant<strong>’ [Note this is different to being a slave.] </strong>So if a Śūdra was to have a name like देवदास/devadaas is given it means ‘servant of the devas’ and also implies that <strong>this person is under the protection and dependent </strong>of the devas, for a servant of someone is dependent on them only and seeks their protection. In this way we often say we are the Dāsa of bhagavan and the acharyas. Similarly Kullūka Bhaṭṭa and<strong> </strong>Govindarāja both give Śivadāsa (servant of Śiva) as a proper name for a Śūdra while commenting on this verse, Kullūka gives other examples as well like Brahmaṇadāsa<strong> </strong>(Servant of the Brahmana) and the Vīramitrodaya suggests Naradāsa<strong> </strong>(Servant of men). But it is also true that Medhātithi takes a more harsh approach giving names like ‘Kṛpaṇaka<em>’</em>, and ‘Dīna<em>’ </em>meaning miserly and humble respectively, but he himself says in the commentary to his next verse:</p><blockquote>‘Preṣya’ is ‘submissive’; such names as ‘Brāhmaṇa-dāsa,’ and ‘Devadāsa,’ which means (respectively) ‘submissive to, dependent upon, the Brāhmaṇa’ and ‘submissive to and dependent upon a deity.</blockquote><p><em>~Medhātithi’s Manubhāṣya on 2.32</em></p><p>So clearly he accepts the notion of being dependent and protected by xyz (whats at the start of the name). Even then words like Dīna and Hīna (as given by Parāśaramādhava) just mean humble servant or lowly servant[ in conjunction with Dasa]. Words like Kṛpaṇaka (miserly) and Śavaraka (savage) which were given by Medhātithi need not be accepted for it has no precedent in the Śāstras, as we have already shown from the other commentaries like Kullūka and Govindarāja and from the Viṣṇu purāṇa that it is mainly being a Dāsa under protection which is talked about[Which Medhātithi himself accepts]. We can see precedent for these types of names for Śūdras in the Śāstras like in the Skanda Purāṇa it is mentioned:</p><blockquote>एतस्मिन्नेव काले तु पांड्यदेशात्समागतः ।<br>बाल्यात्प्रभृति शूद्रोऽपि विष्णुभक्तिसमन्वितः ॥ १७ ॥<br>अथ रंगदासस्य श्रीनिवाससेवार्थं श्रीशेषाचलागमनम् ।<br>नारायणपुरीं प्राप्य श्रीवराहं प्रणम्य च ।<br>तत्र श्रुत्वा श्रीनिवासं वेंकटाद्रिनिवासिनम् ॥ १८ ॥</blockquote><blockquote>In the meantime a devotee named <strong>Raṅgadāsa</strong> came to this place from Pāṇḍya territory. Though he was a <strong>Śūdra</strong>, he was endowed with great devotion to Viṣṇu ever since his childhood.</blockquote><p><em>~ Skanda Purāṇa 2.1.9.17–18</em></p><p>So here a Śūdra by the name of Raṅgadāsa is being talked about. As mentioned before in the Puranas and other scriptures there are many Śūdras who’s names dont follow the conventions of Manu at all so clearly these were just guidelines rather then strict rules, and clearly there is nothing ‘contemptible<strong>’ </strong>about the names here.</p><p>Similar to Manu, there is a verse in Viṣṇu Smṛti saying the same thing :</p><blockquote>मङ्गल्यं ब्राह्मणस्य ॥ ६ ॥ बलवत्’ क्षत्रियस्य ॥ ७ ॥<br>धनोपेतं वैश्यस्य ॥ ८ ॥ जुगुप्सितं शूद्रस्य ॥ ९ ॥</blockquote><p>~ Viṣṇu Smṛti 27.6–9<br>Notice it has the same word जुगुप्सितं ( जुगुप्सितम् in manu is the same word its just that in vishnu smriti the word is used before a consonant so its written as जुगुप्सितं), so the same explanation should suffice. The Kesava-Vaijayanti commentary of Nanda Pandita says the following:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/587/1*GxQHEM3MuCzr_FhL3lALAw.png" /></figure><p>Which when translated (only relevant sections) means:</p><blockquote>There is no contradiction. That which is auspicious is fit for a Brahmin. “Mangala” (auspicious) refers to a thing that indicates a happy outcome. A name for a Brahmin should be of that nature; for example, “Lakshmidhara” and so on. Because of the inclusion of the word “Mangala,” names like “Palaka” and others [are also appropriate]. || 6 ||</blockquote><blockquote>“Balavat” means expressing strength, prowess, and similar qualities. Such should be the name for a Kshatriya; for example, “Yudhisthira” and so on. || 7 ||</blockquote><blockquote>“Dhanayukta” means connected to wealth and prosperity for a Vaishya; for example, “Arthapati.” || 8 ||</blockquote><blockquote><strong>“Jugupsita” means signifying service and the like for a Shudra; for example, “Lokadasa.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Alternatively, “Mangala” and other terms refer to suffixes like “Sharman.” A name ending in “Sharman” is for a Brahmin. One ending in “Varman,” which denotes a means of protection (strength), is for a Kshatriya, such as “Bhimavarman.” One ending in “Gupta,” indicating protected wealth, is for a Vaishya, such as “Devagupta.” <strong>One ending in “Dasa,” which is “Jugupsita” because it signifies service, is for a Shudra, such as “Dharmadasa.”</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Even in the absence of words like “Mangala” and others, Manu gives a rule:</blockquote><blockquote>“The name of a Brahmin should be auspicious (Sharman), that of a Kshatriya should be connected with power (Varman), that of a Vaishya with wealth (Gupta), and that of a Shudra with service (Dasa).”</blockquote><blockquote>In the words “Brahmana” and others, gender is not intended to be restrictive because it is used for the entire class. Therefore, these suffixes apply to women as well. Thus, Ashvalayana says: “For women also, in the same manner.”</blockquote><blockquote>Accordingly, “Sharman” is the ending. Even though there is a rule “na-lopa” (dropping of ‘n’), the ’n’ is not dropped in names like “Gargisharman” because it is a compound. By the rule “da-vabhyam…” there is an option for the long vowel, resulting in “Gargisharman” or “Gargisharmana.” He also states another distinction: “Even-syllabled names for men, and odd-syllabled names for women.” This means names for men should have an even number of syllables, and for women, an odd number; for example, “Subhadra,” “Savitri,” and so on.</blockquote><p>So clearly he accepts the same principle we have discussed here where he takes Juguspita as signifying service. Can one explain how the names given here like ‘Lokadasa’ and ‘Dharmadasa’ are somehow ‘contemptible’?</p><p>With that our discussion on this verse comes to a close.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/813/0*hkwR5h5MFkwF0sqA.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Vidura, a Śūdra guiding the Pāndavas</strong></figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=493c2f9f4ecc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Arcāvatāra of the lord]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hillsrpro/the-arc%C4%81vat%C4%81ra-of-the-lord-b6d2dd6205b8?source=rss-5449e0380ba2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b6d2dd6205b8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hills r pro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 16 Apr 2026 04:23:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-16T04:23:45.407Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Perhaps, one of the most misunderstood parts of <strong>Sanātana Dharma<br></strong>is the Arcāvatāra of the lord and is often a subject of criticism from other religions and even newer sects like Arya samaj. So today we will be discussing the Arcāvatāra of the lord by clarifying what is is, why the lord takes this form and the process by which this happens.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/0*6xc-zsCApMb7BTNd" /><figcaption><strong>Bhagavān Śrī Rāma in the form of Arcāvatāra</strong></figcaption></figure><p>So, what is the Arcāvatāra?</p><blockquote><strong>अर्चायां</strong> स्थण्डिलेऽग्नौ वा सूर्ये वाप्सु हृदि द्विज: ।<br>द्रव्येण भक्तियुक्तोऽर्चेत् स्वगुरुं माममायया ॥ ९ ॥</blockquote><blockquote>A twice-born person should worship Me, his worshipable Lord, without any deception. Endowed with devotion, he should <strong>offer appropriate paraphernalia to My Deity form</strong> or to a form of Me appearing upon the ground, in fire, in the sun, in water, or within his own heart</blockquote><p><em>~ ŚrīmadBhāgavataMahāpurāṇa 11.27.9</em></p><p>So the Arcāvatāra is the physical manifestation of the deity where a devotee can offer various things to him. The lord out of his boundless mercy comes down to earth and allows those devotees who are not as spiritually advanced to worship him in any form they have faith in. The lord says:</p><blockquote>ये यथा मां प्रपद्यन्ते तांस्तथैव भजाम्यहम् । मम वर्त्मानुवर्तन्ते मनुष्याः पार्थ सर्वशः ॥ ११ ॥<br>In whatever way people surrender unto Me, in that same way I reciprocate with them. O Arjuna, everyone follows My path in all respects.</blockquote><p><em>~ Bhagavad gītā 4.11</em></p><p>This extends to the Arcāvatāra and is displayed in the Bhāgavata as:</p><blockquote><strong>अर्चादिषु </strong>यदा यत्र श्रद्धा मां तत्र चार्चयेत् । सर्वभूतेष्वात्मनि च सर्वात्माहमवस्थित: ॥ ४८ ॥”<br>Whenever and wherever one has faith, <strong>one should worship Me in the Deity and other such mediums</strong>. I, the Soul of all, am situated in all living beings and in one’s own self.</blockquote><p><em>~ ŚrīmadBhāgavataMahāpurāṇa 11.27.48</em></p><p>Now let us get into the history of the Arcāvatāra why the lord takes up this form, it has been established that the lord can go into any form in which the devotee desires and has faith in but there is another underlying reason — the decline of spirituality and knowledge across yugas. In Satya yuga one could easily worship the lord as Paramātman and see him in all beings, and they could also worship the lord via yagnas. In Dvāpara yuga dharma goes down hence people are not capable of doing these things anymore hence for their benefit the Āgama Śāstra-s were revealed by Bhagavān to the sages to make worship of the Arcāvatāra mainstream, they did exist in earlier yugas but were not the primary way of worship because people could directly experience the Paramātman. The Bhāgavatam says:</p><blockquote>कृते यद्ध्यायतो विष्णुं त्रेतायां यजतो मखैः । द्वापरे परिचर्यायां कलौ तद्धरिकीर्तनात् ॥ ५२ ॥</blockquote><blockquote>In the Satya-yuga, the spiritual goal is achieved by meditating on Vishnu. In the Treta-yuga, it is achieved through performing sacrifices. In the Dvapara-yuga, it is achieved by worshipping the Lord in the temple can be achieved In the Kali-yuga by chanting the holy names of the Lord.</blockquote><p><em>~ ŚrīmadBhāgavataMahāpurāṇa 12.3.52</em></p><p>In this way the difficulty of spiritual activity is reduced in every yuga, although maintaining the same result. The Bhāgavatam also gives the reason for the Arcāvatāra as:</p><blockquote>पुराण्यनेन सृष्टानि नृतिर्यगृषिदेवता: । शेते जीवेन रूपेण पुरेषु पुरुषो ह्यसौ ॥ ३७ ॥<br>तेष्वेव भगवान् राजंस्तारतम्येन वर्तते । तस्मात्पात्रं हि पुरुषो यावानात्मा यथेयते ॥ ३८ ॥<br>द‍ृष्ट्वा तेषां मिथो नृणामवज्ञानात्मतां नृप । त्रेतादिषु हरेरर्चा क्रियायै कविभि: कृता ॥ ३९ ॥</blockquote><blockquote>The Supreme Lord created various residential bodies such as those of human beings, animals, sages, and demigods. Indeed, this very Supreme Person then entered these bodies, residing within them in the form of the living entity.O King, the Supreme Lord certainly exists among all living entities in different degrees. Therefore, a person is a worthy vessel for worship to the extent that the Supreme Soul is manifested within them. O King, having seen the mutual contempt among men, the learned sages established the Deity worship of Lord Hari in the Tretā-yuga and other ages for the sake of religious activities.</blockquote><p><em>~ ŚrīmadBhāgavataMahāpurāṇa 7.14.37–39</em></p><p>In the later yugas people started looking at each other with hate, envy and a range of other emotions, stopping them from seeing the Paramātman established within every living being. Because of this they couldnt see god, so for their benefit the sages were given the Āgama Śāstra-s. As mentioned before the Arcāvatāra was present in the Tretā yuga, hence this verse mentions it as it is at this time where corruption starts but has not reached the majority, which is in Dvāpara where the Arcāvatāra becomes mainstream as mentioned in the earlier verse of the Bhāgavatam (12.3.52).<br>The pramana for the Arcāvatāra in Tretā, is in Vālmīki Rāmāyaṇa where he is mentioned worshipping Viṣṇu in a temple:</p><blockquote>शेषं च हविषस्तस्य प्राश्याशास्यात्मनः प्रियम् |<br>ध्यायन्नारायणं देवं स्वास्तीर्णे कुशसंस्तरे || २-६-३<br>वाग्यतः सह वैदेह्या भूत्वा नियतमानसः |<br>श्रीमत्यायतने विष्णोः शिश्ये नरवरात्मजः || २-६-४</blockquote><p><em>~ Vālmīki Rāmāyaṇa 2.6.3–4</em></p><p>In this way the tradition of worshipping the Arcāvatāra has been going since time immemorial. The need of the Arcāvatāra has also been explained, as people could not realise the Paramātman in themselves anymore they needed a way to concentrate and worship the lord, so until one reaches that level we should worship the Arcāvatāra. The Bhāgavatam says:</p><blockquote>अर्चादावर्चयेत्तावदीश्वरं मां स्वकर्मकृत् । यावन्न वेद स्वहृदि सर्वभूतेष्ववस्थितम् ॥ २५ ॥</blockquote><blockquote>Performing his prescribed duties, one should worship the Deity of the Supreme Personality of Godhead until one realizes My presence in his own heart and in the hearts of other living entities as well.</blockquote><p><em>~ŚrīmadBhāgavataMahāpurāṇa 3.29.25</em></p><p>Furthermore the worship of Nirguṇa brahman is very hard for beginners, hence a form of the lord is needed to meditate on :</p><blockquote>क्लेशोऽधिकतरस्तेषामव्यक्तासक्तचेतसाम् । अव्यक्ता हि गतिर्दुःखं देहवद्भिरवाप्यते ॥ ५ ॥</blockquote><blockquote>The struggle of those whose minds are attached to the unmanifested is greater,<br>for the embodied soul, the goal of the unmanifested is attained with difficulty.</blockquote><p><em>~ Bhagavad gītā 12.5</em></p><p>It is safe to say 99.9% of people on the earth cannot realise the Paramātman yet so this is definitely a valid practise. Now we shall get into how the lord takes up this form, and along with this answer some critiques of those who say god cannot be known through images or idols.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/880/0*nh0IpHaxS9PmR51L.jpg" /><figcaption><strong>Pañcamukhi Hanumān in the form of Arcāvatāra</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The theology behind the Arcāvatāra has been briefly done by Śrī Vedānta Deśika in his Tātparya Candrikā while commenting on verse 4.11 of the Bhagavad gītā. It is quite important to understand this before anything else, why the lord comes down in this form.</p><blockquote>।।4.11।।एवं साधुपरित्राणाद्यर्थदेवमनुष्यादिसजातीयस्वेच्छावतारवर्णनमुखेनोपासनोपयुक्तं स्वस्य सौलभ्यमुक्तम्। अथ तस्यैव काष्ठाप्राप्तां दशां दर्शयति ये यथा इति श्लोकेन। अत्र कृष्णावतारवृत्तान्तेन सहार्चावतारवृत्तान्तोऽपि सङ्गृहीतः।ये यथा तांस्तथैव इति शब्दाः पूर्वोक्ताधिकारितदनुष्ठानप्रकारादिनियमनिवृत्तिपरा इत्यभिप्रायेणाह न केवलमिति।स्वापेक्षानुरूपमिति पतित्वपुत्रत्वसारथित्ववाराहनारसिंहादिप्रक्रिययेत्यर्थः।सङ्कल्प्य मनोरथविषयं कृत्वेत्यर्थः। एतदेवात्र प्रपदनमित्याह समाश्रयन्त इति।तांस्तथैव भजाम्यहम् इत्यत्र तद्भजनप्रकारेणाहमपि तान्भजामीत्येतदसङ्गतमिति शङ्कानिरासाय तथैवेत्यस्यार्थमाह तन्मनीषितप्रकारेणेति। न तु स्वकीयपरत्वानुरूपप्रकारेणेति भावः। अत्र यथाभिलषितफलप्रदानेन पक्षपातपरिहारार्थत्वं परोक्तं पूर्वोत्तराभ्यां नात्यन्तसङ्गतम्चातुर्वर्ण्यम् 4।13 इत्यादिनाऽर्थतः पुनरुक्तिश्च स्यात्। सेवकान् प्रति सेव्यस्य भजनं नाम सुलभदर्शनत्वमित्यभिप्रायेणमां दर्शयामीत्युक्तम्।</blockquote><p>We will attempt to summarise what he is saying (we will not cover parts unrelated to the topic at hand), here the acharya is elaborating on the words “ ये यथा (ye yathā) ” meaning in ‘whatever way’ the lord is showing the ultimate state of Saulabhya (accessibility) where [by his own divine will for the protection of the righteous] through his many incarnations in the forms of animals humans ect. the lord becomes accessible to the devotee in whatever way he desires like a son, father, charioteer and this includes the form of the Arcāvatāra, the acharya corroborates this with Rāmānujas<br>commentary which states “Svāpekṣānurūpam”( [In a manner] corresponding to their own expectations). Then there is an elaboration on “ तांस्तथैव भजाम्यहम् (Tāṃstathaiva bhajāmyaham)” where the lord states “I approach/favour them in that very way”, there is a doubt on if the lord ‘worships’ us back as he says he reciprocates back in the same way, the acharya clarifies that : “to dismiss the doubt that it would be inconsistent for the Lord to ‘worship’ them in the same way they worship Him, the meaning of ‘tathaiva’ is given[by Rāmānuja] as ‘तन्मनीषितप्रकारेण<br>(tanmanīṣitaprakāreṇeti<em>)’ </em>meaning in the manner desired by them ie. If a devotee wants God as a child, He becomes their son (like Krishna to Yashoda). The idea is: ‘not in a manner corresponding to My own Supreme nature.’ By not the supreme nature it is meant that the lord reciprocate by approaching them as the supreme ruler of the universe, but rather as an intimate companion according the the devotees desire. With this, the understanding that for a servant, ‘भजाम्यहम्<strong>(</strong>bhajāmyaham<strong>)’ </strong>meaning ‘worship’ by the Lord means being easily visible[in the manner they desire], it is said: ‘I reveal Myself’ (mam darsayami).” The act of surrender is rewarded by the lord in this manner of revealing himself. The commentary continues:</p><blockquote>उक्तार्थस्य लोकेऽपि प्रदर्शनपरमुत्तरार्धम् न पुनःयदि ह्यहं न वर्तेयम् 3।23 इत्यादाविव स्वस्य लोकानुविधेयानुष्ठानवत्त्वपरम् तस्येहासङ्गतत्वादित्यभिप्रायेण वाङ्मनसागोचरसौलभ्यपरतां विवृणोति किमत्र बहुनेति। मनुष्यशब्दः स्त्र्यादीनामपि सङ्ग्राहक इत्यभिप्रायेण सर्वशब्दः। अत्र वर्त्मशब्दो न साक्षात्सरणिवाचकः असङ्गतवाक्यार्थत्वप्रसङ्गात्। नाप्याचारपरः तस्याप्यत्रासङ्गतत्वेनोक्तदूषणत्वात्। अत एवएवं प्रवर्तितं चक्रम् 3।16तेनैव स्थापिता ब्रह्ममर्यादा लोकभाविनी इत्याद्युक्तशास्त्रमर्यादानुवर्तनपरत्वमपि निरस्तम्। अतोऽत्र सौलभ्योपदेशप्रकरणे स्वासाधारणविग्रहचेष्टासौशील्यादिस्वभावसमुदायपरत्वमेवोचितमित्यभिप्रायेणोक्तं मम वर्त्म मत्स्वभावं सर्वमिति। सरणिवाचकमपि हिशब्दमुपचारात् स्वभावविषयतया प्रयुञ्जते। यथाकोऽयं पन्था यदसि विमुखो मन्दभाग्ये मयीत्थम् इति।मनुष्याः इत्यनेन सूचितमुच्यते योगिनामिति। योगपरिशुद्धमनसां वाङ्मनसागोचरमपि मां सचक्षुषो मनुष्या बाह्येन्द्रियैरप्यनुभवन्तीत्यर्थः।प्रियतमपितृपुत्रसुहृद्भ्रातृभृत्यसारथित्वादिरूपाण्यर्चावताररूपाणि चसर्वशः इत्यनेन विवक्षितानीत्याहस्वापेक्षितैरिति।अनुभूयानुवर्तन्ते अनुभवन्तो वर्तन्त इत्यर्थः। अलङ्करणयात्रोत्सवसेवादिर्वाऽत्र प्रकारः। अत्र योगिनां वाङ्मनसागोचरमपिचक्षुरादिकरणैः इति वचनादर्चावताररूपेऽपि पररूपत्वानुसन्धानं दर्शितम्। यथा स्मरन्तितामेव ब्रह्मरूपिणीम् वि.ध.103।29 इति। वक्ष्यति च भगवान्भुजैश्चतुर्भिः इत्यादि। एवं प्रसङ्गात् सौलभ्यातिरेकं सारथ्यादिना पश्यतोऽपि पाण्डवस्योपासिसिषापूर्त्यर्थं कण्ठोक्त्याप्युपदिदेश।</blockquote><p>The second half of the verse “Everyone follows My path in all respects, O son of Pritha” is meant to demonstrate what has been said in the first line but for the context of everyone in the world, but it should not be mistaken as the lords following of worldly conduct [as stated in BG 3.23] when referring to the path everyone is following, for it would be inconsistent with the current topic, as the first half of the verse is talking about the Lords accessibility (Saulabhya) and worship, while also being redundant as it is already stated all men follow his path in the above cited verse. Any other interpretations of the word ‘vartma’ like road, āchāra and scriptural boundaries[BG 3.16] fail for the same reasons. With the intention of explaining how He, who is beyond speech and mind, makes Himself easily accessible, the commentator ( Rāmānuja) expands on this with the phrase, <em>‘What more is there to say?’ </em>The word ‘men’ (manushyah) is used in a general sense to include women and others as well; this is the intent behind the word ‘all’ (sarva). Therefore, in this context of teaching Saulabhya (Ease of Access), it is appropriate that ‘path’ refers to refers to his entire nature (svabhava), which is a collection of His extraordinary form, activities and his gracious disposition (saushilya). This is the This is the intent behind the phrase[in Rāmānujas commentary] : मम वर्त्म मत्स्वभावं सर्वं meaning ‘My path is My very nature (mat-svabhāva).’ Indeed, even words meaning ‘pathway’ are used metaphorically to refer to one’s nature. For example: ‘What path (nature) is this, that You are thus indifferent to me, the unfortunate one?’<br>By the word <strong>“</strong>manushya<strong>,”</strong> it is suggested that even those whose minds are purified by Yoga (Yogis) — to whom I am otherwise beyond speech and mind — perceive Me with their very eyes. This means that men experience Me even through their external senses. The forms of beloved father, son, friend, brother, servant, charioteer, etc., as well as the Arcāvatāra , are what is meant by “in all ways” (sarvaśaḥ) — ; thus the commentary[of Rāmānuja]says, ‘according to their own desires.’</p><p>With this understanding the phrase ‘they follow’ (anuvartante) means ‘they exist while experiencing Him[his nature(which we clarified was his path)].’<br>This includes modes of service such as decorating Him(the Arcāvatāra), taking Him on processions (Yatra), festivals, and other forms of worship.<br>Here, by the statement[of Rāmānuja]saying that He [the lord] is experienced as “ that which is beyond the reach of the speech and mind of the yogis<strong> [is made accessible] through the senses like the eyes</strong>,” — shows that even in the form of the Arcāvatāra [which is what is meant by experiencing him through the eyes and using other senses in other ways like serving him mentioned above], the contemplation of the Supreme Form (Para-rupa) is shown and demonstrated, for the scripture says: ‘That very [image/form] is of the nature of Brahman’ (Vishnu Dharma 103.29) and the Lord will say later: <em>‘</em>With four arms…<em>’</em> (Gītā 11.46). Thus, having shown the height of His accessibility through roles like being a charioteer, He [the Lord] also explicitly taught this to Arjuna to fulfill his desire to worship Him. So here the acharya is talking about<br> <strong>“इति वचनादर्चावताररूपेष्वपि पररूपानुसन्धानं दर्शितम्।”, </strong>ie. contemplation of the supreme state via the Arcāvatāra,<strong> which is the supreme essence itself</strong> as supported by the shloka from Vishnu dharma purana which the acharya quoted. Thus the lord that is incomprehensible even to the mind of yogis makes himself accessible to the external senses via the Arcāvatāra and allows for contemplating and serving the supreme — on account of the lords Saulabhya<strong>.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/863/1*uakM5egEGDAYsMy8j9RrPA.png" /><figcaption><strong>Śrī Varadarāja Perumāḷ the Iṣṭa of Vedānta Deśika</strong></figcaption></figure><p>Now, we will elaborate on the divine nature of the Arcāvatāra, in the shastras, there seems to be contradicting statements in regards to the Arcāvatāra, all to do with the question — is Bhagavān himself actually present in the ‘idol’? Consider the two statements from Śāstra-s:</p><blockquote>arcye viṣṇau śilā-dhīr guruṣu nara-matir vaiṣṇave jāti-buddhir viṣṇor vā vaiṣṇavānāṁ kali-mala-mathane pāda-tīrthe ‘mbu-buddhiḥ | śrī-viṣṇor nāmni mantre sakala-kaluṣa-he śabda-sāmānya-buddhir viṣṇau sarveśvareśe tad-itara-sama-dhīr yasya vā nārakī saḥ ||</blockquote><blockquote>“<strong>One who thinks the Deity in the temple to be made of wood or stone</strong>, who thinks of the spiritual master in the disciplic succession as an ordinary man, who thinks the Vaiṣṇava in the Acyuta-gotra to belong to a certain caste or creed or who thinks of<em> </em>caraṇāmṛta<em> </em>or Ganges water as ordinary water <strong>is taken to be a resident of hell.</strong>”</blockquote><p><em>~ Padma Purāṇa(quoted by acharyas)</em></p><p>and</p><blockquote>na kāśṭhe vidyate devo na śilāyam na mrutsuca <br>bhāve hi vasate devastasmādbhāvo hi kāraṇam</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Deva (god) is neither present in the wood nor in the stone</strong> or in the soil (i.e. idols made of these things). He resides only in the emotion or feelings (<em>bhava</em>), hence <em>bhava</em> (devotion / emotion) is the only reason.</blockquote><p><em>~ Garuda purana 2.28.11</em></p><p>At first glance it may seem like these statements are contradicting, but this is not the case, here the Garuda purana is critisizing the idea that the idol itself, as material stone is god and that the physical object is automatically divine. When we do Prāṇa pratiṣṭhā we still do not say that the stone itself is god, we say that Bhagavān is present through this consecrated form, before it was just stone and now it is divinely inhabited/manifest. Both these verses together say that Bhagavān is not reducible to matter but he can truly manifest through it [as discussed in Vedānta Deśika section]. As an example you can think of a phone wherewith just the hardware nothing happens, but with a signal real communication happens, the phone is not the person but the person is truly present through the phone. In simple terms the Arcāvatāra is matter + the divine presence by the will of the lord [as discussed in Vedānta Deśika section], which transforms it altogether.</p><p>Now let us answer some common objections to the Arcāvatāra</p><p>Abrahamic logic often suggests that God is too “infinite” or “transcendent” to be contained in a statue, ie. how can the omnipresent being be confined into one idol?</p><p>The answer is given in a conversation between Piḷḷān and Jīyar :</p><blockquote>One day while Jīyar(Nanjīyar) was on his way to the Temple of Lord Ranganātha, he met Piḷḷān( = Tiruk-kurugaip-pirān-Piḷḷān) and asked him : — “Holy Sire, is God’s omnipresence confined to His essence (svarūpa) being present everywhere (vyāpti), or is He also specially present in His Beautiful Person (vigraha-vyāpti)?” Answered Piḷḷān: — “The omnipresence by essence is universal, or generic, whereas presence by Person is particular or specific, -an act of benign Grace on His part to so become manifest, and a reward to sanctity on man’s part. When both grace and sanctity co-operate, the Divine Person of God who abides latent in the heart becomes manifest.”</blockquote><p><em>~ The Divine Wisdom of the Dravida Saints (1902)</em></p><p>Essentially there is a difference between Bhagavāns Svarūpa-vyāpti (universal presence) and Vigraha-vyāpti (specific presence). This is the generic presence of God in all atoms If God is everywhere, He is already “in” the stone or wood. Piḷḷān says that while God is everywhere by essence, He chooses to be present in the Archa by Grace. To say God cannot manifest specifically in an Image is actually a limitation on His omnipotence. If He is truly All-Powerful, He has the freedom to focus His presence for the sake of the believer and thus does not violate his omnipresence because <strong>the Archa is where God’s generic presence becomes a specific, accessible encounter by his own grace. The<br> Image is not a replacement for God, but the “condensed” focus<br> of His omnipresence.</strong></p><p>Another objection raised is that if the idol cannot help itself (ie. getting damaged ect.) how can it help you?</p><p>Well as we have clarified earlier the stone itself is not the god, but only acts as a vessel and the god remains unaffected. For example if a mirror is shattered it cannot reflect your face properly, <strong>this doesnt mean your face is actually broken , it means the medium of reflection is no longer functional. </strong>Similarly when the Archa is damaged, the material is damaged but the Lords essence remains unaffected. Furthermore this objection totally misses to point of the Arcāvatāra , as clarified earlier in the Vedānta Deśika section in this form the lord chooses to come down in this dependent form out of love for his devotees, so that they may serve him in whatever way they please. This is a testament to Bhagavāns Saulabhya and love. As for the ‘how can it help you’ part we have already discussed the divine nature of the Arcāvatāra as a place where Bhagavān may manifest so it makes complete sense for the lord to help us in this form. For the lord says:</p><blockquote>एवं क्रियायोगपथैः पुमान् वैदिकतान्त्रिकैः ।<br>अर्चन्नुभयतः सिद्धिं मत्तो विन्दत्यभीप्सिताम् ॥ ४९ ॥</blockquote><blockquote>“By worshiping Me through the various methods prescribed in the Vedas and Tantras, a person will gain from Me his desired perfection in both this life and the next.”</blockquote><p><em>~ ŚrīmadBhāgavataMahāpurāṇa 11.27.49</em></p><p>Furthermore we have direct experience, people have been worshipping the lord in the form of the Arcāvatāra for thousands of years and have been getting their wishes fulfilled, surely if there was no benefit we wouldve stopped a very long time ago.</p><p>This brings us to the end of the article. I would like to end on the following words:</p><p><strong><em>“If God could be suspected incapable of even such a most insignificant feat as manifesting Himself in images for the sake of the poor little-witted humanity, for blessing misguided mankind, it is far more reasonable to deny Him (i.e., deny His existence) altogether.”</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*NkLDYZU-Zk7QLjAe" /><figcaption><strong>Naṭarāja</strong></figcaption></figure><p>I would like to credit this website which has helped me make this article:<br><a href="https://worldsavior.org/idolatry-or-deity/">https://worldsavior.org/idolatry-or-deity/</a></p><p>Jaya Śrī Rāma</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b6d2dd6205b8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Clarifying verses of Śiva Purāṇa]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hillsrpro/clarifying-verses-of-%C5%9Biva-pur%C4%81%E1%B9%87a-ecaf97b0c34e?source=rss-5449e0380ba2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ecaf97b0c34e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hills r pro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Feb 2026 11:01:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-13T11:21:43.557Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There is often an allegation put on the Śiva Purāṇa<strong> </strong>saying that it supports wife beating, the source of the claim being this verse :</p><blockquote>पत्युर्नाम न गृह्णीयात् कदाचन पतिव्रता ।<br>आक्रुष्टापि न चाक्रोशेत्प्रसीदेत्ताडितापि च ।<br>हन्यतामिति च ब्रूयात्स्वामिन्निति कृपां कुरु ॥ १९ ॥ <strong><em><br></em></strong>A chaste lady shall never mention her husband’s name. If the husband scolds or rebukes her she shall not abuse him in return. Even when beaten by him she shall remain glad and say “I may even be killed, O lord. Be kind to me.”</blockquote><p><em>~ Śiva Purāṇa 2.3.54.19</em></p><p>People will show this verse out of the context of Śāstras, which naturally causes doubts in peoples minds leading them to reject this verse by saying its “interpolated” or even rejecting the whole Śiva Purāṇa. So this article will aim to resolve this issue.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XmUhDsPfgOhb_mBY.jpg" /><figcaption><strong><em>Śiva and </em>Umā</strong></figcaption></figure><p>First of all we should understand one thing, who is being spoken about here? Here the पतिव्रता<strong>/</strong>Pativratā women is being talked about here, so this is not talking about all women. The translations of Pativratā given is just ‘chaste’ which is quite basic and does not give justice nor encompass its full meaning. It is given in Śāstras as :</p><blockquote>नारायणात्परं कान्तं ध्यायते सततं सती । परपुंसां मुखं चैव सुवेषपुरुषं परम् ।। ११३ ।।</blockquote><blockquote>A pativrata wife constantly meditates upon her beloved husband as superior even to Narayana. She does not look at the face of another man, even if he is well-dressed and handsome.</blockquote><p><em>~ Brahmavaivarta Purāṇa 4.83.113</em></p><p>So as we can see a Pativratā women is someone who is solely devoted too her husband, even as god. Ofcourse there are other path for women who may become Brahmacāriṇī ect. so we should understand who’s Dharma is being talked about. The Dharma of women in this chapter of Śiva Purāṇa is for those women only who are fully dependent on their husband. Now that we have understood this let us get too the crux of the matter.</p><p>The verse mentions that the wife is beaten physically using the word <strong>ताडितापि, </strong>but the word itself “ताडन” meaning punishing may also refer to Vāgdāṇḍa ( verbal warning), Manu gives four stages for punishments with Vāgdāṇḍa clearly mentioned :</p><blockquote><strong>वाग्दण्डं </strong>प्रथमं कुर्याद् धिग्दण्डं तदनन्तरम् । तृतीयं धनदण्डं तु वधदण्डमतः परम् ॥ १२९ ॥</blockquote><p><em>~ Manusmṛti 8.129</em></p><p>Now one may argue here saying</p><blockquote>Why cant we take the primary meaning of beating here, when in the same verse even killing the women is mentioned ?</blockquote><p>This is a valid question, to answer the first part beating cannot be taken here as wife beating is never to be done as per shastras, even if she commits Pāpa:</p><blockquote>प्रहरन्ति न वै स्त्रीषु कृताग:स्वपि जन्तव: । किमुत त्वद्विधा राजन् करुणा दीनवत्सला: ॥ २० ॥</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Even if a woman does commit some sinful activity, no one should place his hand upon her</strong>. And what to speak of you, dear King, who are so merciful. You are a protector, and you are affectionate to the poor.</blockquote><p><em>~ Śrīmad Bhāgavatam 4.17.20</em></p><p>And to answer your question about why killing is mentioned in the verse, there is an interesting mention of this in our Smṛti Śāstras :</p><blockquote>मान्या चेन्म्रियते पूर्वं भार्य्या पतिविमानिता , त्रीणि जन्मानि सा पुंस्त्वं पुरुषः स्त्रीत्वर्महि ।</blockquote><blockquote>If a respectable/honoured wife <strong>dies before her husband,</strong> <strong>having been insulted by him</strong>, for three births, she is born as a man and the man becomes a woman.</blockquote><p><em>~</em><strong><em> </em></strong><em>Kātyāyana Smṛti 20.13</em></p><p>The type of women is clarified in Dakṣa Smṛti :</p><blockquote>अदृष्टापतितां भार्य्यां यौवने यः परित्यजेत् । स जीवनान्ते स्त्रित्वञ्च बन्ध्यत्वञ्च समाप्नुयात् ॥</blockquote><blockquote>He who abandons his wife in her youth, though she has done nothing wrong/faultless, attains womanhood and <strong>barrenness at the end of life (in the beginning of his next life).</strong></blockquote><p><em>~ Dakṣa Smṛti 4.17</em></p><p>If we recall in the verse it is actually the wife who brings up death saying “I may even be killed” after being verbally abused by her husband (as mentioned previously in the verse) and given a Vāgdāṇḍa (verbal warning as clarified earlier as the proper meaning of ताडन in this verse), now I ask is this not exactly what is described in the verse of Kātyāyana Smṛti? This is why Pativratā call for death quite boldly in this verse <strong>in front of the husband abusing them.</strong></p><p>In the same chapter in Śiva Purāṇa it is clearly mentioned that the Dharma of the<strong> </strong>Pativratā women is documented in the smriti texts as well, so the passages from Kātyāyana and Dakṣa Smṛti apply fully and both the house members are aware of it :</p><blockquote>महान्पतिव्रताधर्म्मश्श्रुतिस्मृतिषु नोदितः । यथैष वर्ण्यते श्रेष्ठो न तथान्योऽस्ति निश्चितम् ॥ १५ ॥</blockquote><p><em>~ Śiva Purāṇa 2.3.54.15</em></p><p>So this is why Pativratā women do not fear death, and may even call for it boldly, declaring they have done no wrong. It is her prerogative to call him out for her innocence and his bad judgment as he is verbally abusing her, as well as a challenge, for they both know what is awaiting for him if he abuses her without any justification. Thus we can see that this verse of Śiva Purāṇa is a replica situation mentioned in Kātyāyana Smṛti 20.13, which is also confirmed to be the source of Dharma for Pativratā women which the Śiva Purāṇa is just quoting in verse 15 as mentioned above.</p><p>And just as an extra, When listing Mahāpātaka(Major sins) Śāstras do state it is a Pāpa to stay around those who despise and insult women :</p><blockquote>इन्धनार्थमशुष्काणां दुमाणाञ्चैव पातनं । योषितां ग्रहणञ्चैव <strong>स्त्रीनिन्दकसमागमः</strong> ॥ ३४ ॥</blockquote><p><em>~ Agni Purāṇa 168.34</em></p><p>The chapter is named “ Kinds of Major Sins (Mahāpātaka) ”</p><p>I hope this has helped clarify the meaning of the verse of Śiva Purāṇa.</p><p>I would also like to thank my fellow Hindu&#39;s for help explaining this verse too me, one of them being a writer on medium himself by the name of <a href="https://medium.com/u/6ab8967a2676">कालविजयः</a>, do check out his work if you have time.</p><p>Thus, too end this I quote the same chapter of Śiva Purāṇa praising Pativratā women, which these people will not show you :</p><blockquote>यथा गंगावगाहेन शरीरं पावनं भवेत् । तथा पतिव्रतां दृष्ट्वा सकलम्पावनं भवेत् ॥ ६८ ॥<br>न गङ्गाया तया भेदो या नारी पतिदेवता । उमाशिवसमौ साक्षात्तस्मात्तौ पूजयेद्बुधः ॥ ६९ ॥</blockquote><blockquote>68. Just as the body is purified by a plunge in the Gaṅgā, so everything is sanctified on seeing a chaste woman.</blockquote><blockquote>69. A chaste lady is not different from Gaṅgā. She and her husband are like Pārvatī and Śiva. Hence a sensible man shall worship them.</blockquote><p><em>~ Śiva Purāṇa 2.3.54.68–69</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/818/0*Sw_420A5qYeKXqC0.jpg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ecaf97b0c34e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>