<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Hugh Allen on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Hugh Allen on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@hughbris?source=rss-166972cc6db0------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 22:27:35 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@hughbris/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Grenfell Fire and the Great British Class War]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hughbris/how-the-grenfell-fire-illuminated-the-british-class-war-3bdc92dc397d?source=rss-166972cc6db0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3bdc92dc397d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[britain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grenfell-tower]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[left-wing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brexit]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugh Allen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Jun 2018 16:34:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-16T16:53:37.156Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Q2UoyFy83LlArsEHowSIdw.jpeg" /><figcaption>All photos taken at the Grenfell Kensington Protests 16th June 2017</figcaption></figure><p>A year has passed since the Grenfell Tower erupted into flames on June the 14th 2017 and host of late night Londoners turned furrowed brows to a flickering orange dawn. It is hard, for anyone who witnessed it, to forget the black, opaque smoke that billowed up, blanketing a city skyline as residents from adjacent buildings pressed their faces to glass windows in both awe and horror at a twenty-floor, towering inferno that would go on to claim the lives of no less than seventy people. The event was immediately cemented in the nations’ consciousness as an inconceivable nightmare, to be relived in the fears of every apartment-dweller across the country in the succeeding months, but it was what followed the fire — the protests, the government response, the media scrutiny and the inquiry — that has marked Grenfell as one of the most rapidly politicised injustices in recent history; a battle ground for the conflicting ideologies of the left/right wings and a microcosm indicative of the current dichotomy of opinion, which lies at the very centre of British politics.</p><p>* * *</p><p>The smoke clears late afternoon on the 14th of June, before the firefighters have reached the top floor of the building. It is at this point, seemingly in an effort to pre-empt scrutiny, that Kensington and Chelsea Tenant Management Organisation admits that it had prior knowledge of the fire concerns from residents. The whispers of ‘cladding’ from an informed few are already beginning to accumulate. Whilst the general public opinion is one of overwhelming sympathy and concern, for both victims and emergency services, an inquisition in to who is responsible begins on both sides of the political spectrum. The battle of blame begins, undoubtedly catalysed, if not directly caused, by the events’ close proximity to a general election that had seen a recently unprecedented and unforeseen reactionary swing vote towards an ever-leaning-left Labour party. For any critic of the austerity policies implemented in the last decade, Grenfell quickly begins to resemble the perfect allegory for the disastrous consequences of public spending cuts on a local and national scale: a council underfunded and fire service reduced. More damaging than accusations of negligence though, is an ill-conceived visit by the Prime Minister on the 15th to the Grenfell site, in which she seemingly refuses to speak to any victims, only focusing on the fire services. Contrast this with Jeremy Corbyn’s visit the same day, whose <em>literal </em>embrace of a bereaved mother is seen by thousands, and the analysis that begins to emerge is less one of bureaucratic laxity and more one resembling outright conservative distain for an increasingly disenfranchised working class and a mostly afro-Caribbean community; a narrative of Dickensian moral simplicity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ih16eo0Eejh7JUu5FrgLjQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Suddenly, less than a week after the fire had subsided, and perhaps due to the stark imagery of the injustice of un-housed survivors, Grenfell had become a proverbial ‘Tale of Two Cities,’ both of which resided in the borough of London with the highest inequality, where the average mean salary is £123,000, among the highest in Britain, but the median (the point which half the population is above and half below) is just £32,700. Here was a community that existed in the public consciousness as hosting the dizzying heights of celebrity TV dynasties and Oligarch holiday homes just three streets away from some of the lowest-earning families in the United Kingdom. The same families who now were failing to receive the practical and monetary relief they required due to failures of the council. This was now a story of ‘haves and have-nots,’ the legitimacy of which, the left was aware it could exploit to its’ gain. But it wasn’t until Jeremy Corbyn’s call — to rehouse the victims in some of the 1,300 empty luxury apartments within the borough — was met with the condemnations of Marxism from conservative MP’s, that the outward heartlessness of the government drove the west London community and its’ supporters to the point of action.</p><p>For anyone (as I did) who attended the protests outside the Kensington and Chelsea town hall on the 16th of June will remember that it did not take the form of passive, anaesthetised rally sometimes exhibited by crowds during demonstration. What was etched in the faces of almost everyone attending was the tangible pain shared by members of a community, nearly all of whom, knew of someone killed just days prior. Those in mourning wept on concrete steps and handed out photos of relatives with desperate urgency; whilst a series of charged speeches by victims of varying ages, condemned the council authorities, tenant management organisation and the building contractor Rydon for their actions, or lack thereof. But what resounded most in the midst of the chants and vigils, and what was echoed the loudest, was the belief that the conservative government, along with allies in the right-wing media, were not only conducting a war that was equally motivated by racial, as well as class, prejudices, but they were also intending to paint the victims as the villains. And, within a matter of hours, as the anguished cries of ‘they don’t care!’ grew louder, and the bandanas pulled above the nose began to proliferate amongst the crowd, the florescent line that stood between the council staff and those demanding answers, began to thicken. At the very same time, in the north of the borough, at the site of the fire, Theresa May was chased from her second meeting with the survivors, the screams of ‘<em>Coward</em>’ hurled at the reflective windows of an escape vehicle. As news of her panicked departure reached the public, hundreds of protestors broke through the police line and stormed the ground floor of the Town Hall, demanding an explanation they felt already overdue. It was neither quiet, nor peaceful. It was frenzied and furious. The financial gulf that separated the two-tiers of housing within Kensington had momentarily been abridged and, without sensationalising the incendiary atmosphere of the day, the residents of the adjacent flats, (merely two roads away from Kensington palace) who now peered through their windows to witness where the shouts of <em>‘No Peace, No Justice</em>’ were coming from, could be forgiven for fearing that this inconsolable anger from their neighbours would be the beginning of something far bigger.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mxnG1v87Wq7_L_im8Ap3Ag.jpeg" /><figcaption>An elderly lady looks on from her flat as the protests develop.</figcaption></figure><p>And it was, though not an incentive for further action, or the social upheaval that many hoped. It would be the first battle of a war of ideals that has yet to subside a year later. If the demonstrators had any concern that the Grenfell community would be vilified, they had good reason to, especially with regards to the Murdoch press’ long history of victim blaming in order to direct public scrutiny away from those truly culpable (Hillsborough comes immediately to mind.) What the protestors didn’t realise was that this had already begun a day earlier. It was on June the 15th 2017, that the right wing media’s campaign to defame the reputation of bereaving families really began. <em>The Daily Mail </em>handpicked an Ethiopian Asylum Seeker turned mini-cab driver, fulfilling their penchant for xenophobic scapegoating, to deviate attention away from the innumerable systematic failures of a conservative council and government. Somehow it was suggested that Behailu Kebede’s faulty fridge had caused a twenty-four-storey building to erupt into flames; an accusation that, weeks later (and recently in developments in the inquiry), was proven to be implausibly moronic. Of course, the force displayed by protestors the following day, justified or otherwise, did nothing to quell the right wing cries of ‘<em>thuggery,</em>’ laden as <em>that </em>word is with bigoted, racially charged undertones, and the press’ public diatribe against the Grenfell community could begin, abetted by the presumption that the first punch thrown was not their own.</p><p>Labour, acknowledging the prevailing shock at the government’s admittance of fallibility in both response and pre-emption to the fire, emphasises these failures to the nation recurrently. Activists of a leftist persuasion begin to openly condemn the actions of conservative governments preceding Theresa May’s, with rapper Akala expressing his belief that ‘the victims died because they were poor,’ an opinion reiterated by John McDonnell weeks later at Glastonbury festival, renouncing the deaths as ‘murders by political decisions.’ But it isn’t until Lily Allen openly accuses conservative policies of directly attributing to the fire, that the right wing realises what its’ next course of action should be. Met with the reactionary, vitriolic bile customary in response to a woman using her platform to discuss political matters, Allen is faced with a barrage of abuse, all of which question her legitimacy as an altruist and liberal. ‘Who is she, in all her affluence, with her clear <em>Marxist </em>agenda, to care for the displaced families?’ became the rallying cry of those lurking in the opinion columns and reddit message boards. But more subversive than this, was the ability and promptness with which the right wing successfully detached the event from the political discourse that ran parallel to it. Boris Johnson (of all people) accused Labour of ‘outrageous politicking’ after a video emerged of him scoffing at fire-cuts before the general assembly, and unconfirmed murmurs suggested that SWP/Momentum members were ‘hijacking’ survivor support groups<em>.</em>Within two weeks after the fire, the right wing press had carefully cultivated a culture of shaming anyone who sought to connect the fire to the political decisions that had preceded it. In an astounding reversal of roles, those who claimed to be seeking justice for the victims through emancipation suddenly became the proverbial villains, disingenuously exploiting a crisis for their political gain. The protests subsided, the accusations of ‘whitewashing’ against the inquiry diminished, the investigations slowed, the undertones of socialist rhetoric dissipated, labour councillors felt excluded from the ensuing meetings and most crucially, the impassioned response exhibited by the left in those charged moments after the event, was well and truly neutralised. The anger towards the conservatives, the Prime Minister in particular, was anaesthetised and the shouts for justice fell comparatively silent.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yNOy-jjQZTTYbyYhKlEAPQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The crowds gathered outside the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea town hall.</figcaption></figure><p>But it shouldn’t have mattered that labour were seeking to exploit the political capital that existed within the framing of Grenfell, an argument for which there is some evidence, because if there were ever a crisis worthy of politicisation, Grenfell is it. The calls for the urban disaster to be fully separated from the current national-political narrative exhibits the apathetic ease at which we, as a public, attempt to detach ourselves from the responsibility of a discussion that goes beyond mere mourning. To claim that this situation has arisen from an ever-British sentiment of mere ‘<em>rotten luck</em>’ is a declaration of abandonment. It is a lackadaisical shrug of ‘<em>unavoidable tragedy</em>’ that lifts the blame from shoulders of the perpetrators whilst depriving the victims of the relief they deserve, that can only come from the just conviction of criminals responsible.A year since the fire began; it has become clear just who those criminals are. It has since emerged that there was sustained pressure from Kensington and Chelsea council to cut costs on the project, despite being in a position of financial security (under-spending on its’ budget for services by £23m and switching contractors to Rydon in order to save around £3m), a program it aptly named <em>‘Value Engineering.’</em>The following summer, the TMO, under the instruction of the conservative council deputy leader, removed £300,000 from the cladding budget, and zinc panels were replaced with combustible aluminium material with plastic core. The following crimes of the refurbishment included ill fitted doors and poorly replaced windows, all of which seem to have been committed in the name of frugality. Yet still, as the evidence emerges, there exists within the public sphere, those who cannot grasp that post-crash governmental spending policy and the ensuing death of 71 people are in anyway entwined. There exists an inability within the British consciousness to connect, albeit a long and intricately mapped, string of dots. The right wings’ ease in attributing Grenfell to inevitable chance as opposed to alterable circumstance — combined with the natural sedative of passing time — has allowed the initial rage, accurately concentrated at austerity policy, to be well and truly gelded, misshapen and redirected at a very different entity.</p><p>* * *</p><p>Despite the justified scepticism that should be levelled at any notion of <em>democratised information </em>on social media, Facebook can, despite recent revelations, provide a semblance of insight into the opinions endemic of the British public as a whole. In particular, the comment section on news articles, ranked in order of approval rating, resembles a cross section of sentiment, at least from the parties on the platform who feel engaged enough to partake. In the months following the disaster, it was incredible to see a change occur, of Kafka-esque proportions, within the attitudes towards any article pertaining towards the Grenfell survivors. And unexpectedly, no mention of the fire itself lingered in the psyche of the British public, its’ horror and magnitude fading fast. What were once sympathetic tones of commiseration for victims had mutated into a diatribe of scorn. <em>The Daily Mail </em>and <em>The Sun, </em>successful in shaming those who had intentions to emphasise the political and circumstantial nature of event, now incentivised their readers to take issue in the face of a great injustice, that lay in perpetuation of the belief that Grenfell victims, in all their affluence, were receiving something that the British public should have been demanding from the government themselves; housing and handouts.</p><p>Much of the outcry concerned the idea that the victims were receiving the luxury accommodation that lay within the wealthiest borough of London. The occupants of one of the most despised extremes of the housing spectrum were to be transported instantaneously to the antithesis. The victims were transcending boundaries of class, which many believed existed for a reason, with a comparable ease that infuriated their new neighbours. It didn’t matter that these people had suffered one of the most heinous fires in British history, seen the death of their family members and friends, lost their homes and community, or even that the apartments they had been allocated were usually modest compared to what was initially suggested; to those who had watched from afar (with a seeming lack of humanity) the Grenfell survivors became the socio-political leeches the media so wanted them to become. Calls were made to BBC talk shows, a woman declaring it wasn’t <em>fair </em>that these people were to live in a flat as nice as hers, after all, she’d worked very hard to buy this lavish apartment. Others reiterated this banality, emphasising their racially charged fear of having the dispossessed from the heart of darkest Kensington living alongside them. To the British public, this was about more than just charity; it was about class, and the adherence to a neo-liberalist dogma that has governed our social consciousness since its’ inception with Thatcherism. No matter what they did, whether they were accepting the luxury accommodation, or pleading for more time in temporary dwellings to consider the offer, the displaced Grenfell community began to represent everything that the ideology of meritocracy seeks to defame. These were people, who had not worked for what they were being given, they were not reaping anything they had sown, and they were not the cream rising to the top. To some of the more morally reprehensible of our society, in Grenfell lies an extension of social Darwinism taken to its’ extreme conclusion. Put simply, before the fire had even entered the national cognisance, these people were supposedly at the bottom rung of the socio-economic ladder precisely because they <em>deserved </em>to be. Their tenable position was apparently one of their own design, through the belief that they had not earned what existed in such close proximity to them, yet remained so far from experience. In its’ shaming of the Grenfell community, as with its’ shaming of benefit claimants and food bank users. The British public had once again fallen under the spell of an ideology so toxic that it divided people within the same sects of class. The Grenfell community was now held in contempt by its’ social superiors, but also viewed with an enviable distain by its’ socio-economic peers. Under the discerning eye of neoliberal individualism, no one deserves anything for free, especially those without anything to offer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ABY8V9HLt6wo9vUD-yRXtg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A young girl, her mother still unaccounted for, speaks passionately at the protests, tears in her eyes. The rapper Akala stands to her left, staring into the crowd.</figcaption></figure><p>It is within this mantra of individualism that Grenfell acts as a microcosmic example of the identity crisis facing Britain today; an individualism, which not only ennobles the role of the self over the society, but also governs the way in which we are able to channel our protest. From the initial accusation levelled at Behailu Kebede, to the vilification of homeless families receiving compensation, the reaction of the British establishment and its’ supporters has been one of inconceivable selfishness. In the response of the media, the ministers, and indeed much of the public, Grenfell has proven the means through which members of our society find it easier to direct disdain at certain individuals as opposed to the institutions that have failed them. And this, is where the true separation, between the two forces a breadth a sociopolitical chasm, really begins. It returns to the fundamental divergence of ideology that lies within the respective purities of the political spectrums; the question of whether it is the responsibility of the individual to provide for themselves, or whether it is the role of the state to provide for the people. The right wing — whose belief, that triumph of will surpasses all circumstance, has grown so monstrously engorged — cannot, or does not, wish to grant clemency to those who have failed in its’ estimations, succeeding only in abetting a culture of self-deprecation amongst its’ believers. The lefts&#39; reaction exhibits a contrasting willingness to absolve the individual — who becomes a mere product of environment — and direct its’ anger at the systems, bodies and traditions that have contributed to their failure. It is clear, with regards to the tragedy that has unfolded since Grenfell, that one of these political attitudes enables analysis and connects an effect to its’ cause, whilst the other revels in a reactionary satisfaction against the presumed culprit, as though it were a doctor treating a patient’s symptoms as opposed to the disease itself.</p><p>It is our impatience for retribution as a society, our libidinal penchant for justice that causes us to trust the first finger pointing out any culprit, even if pointed in the wrong direction. But this about more than just patient pragmatism, it is about empathy; the ability for us, as a society, to understand our fallibility as human beings, to see that the plans of individuals’ often go awry, to acknowledge that the means are not always in place for success to be <em>proportional</em> to genuine effort. We cannot look to our neighbour as our enemy, merely for lack of a clear opponent, or because the task of toppling the monolith seems too daunting, or too time-consuming, or too complex. People find it easy to blame <em>people</em>. People contain no lengthy acronyms or bureaucratic jargon, they are recognisable entities to us, made up of flesh and faults, more tangible villains than the weighty concepts or economic measures that lie behind their actions. As the failures of austerity grow with its’ continued implementation, more regular combustions of public services and regional facilities will occur. Our resolve in these coming years should be to remember that it is <em>an ideal</em>, which acts as the fuel to an already raging fire.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z08-7lpTRV4C54dCwRV6iA.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3bdc92dc397d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bursting the Bubble: Liberal Millennials must escape the Echo Chambers of their own design]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@hughbris/bursting-the-bubble-liberal-millennials-must-escape-the-echo-chambers-of-their-own-design-66155bc25f8c?source=rss-166972cc6db0------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/66155bc25f8c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brexit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[millennials]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Hugh Allen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Jan 2017 17:55:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-17T15:18:34.376Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*biypvZiKGhKZGFTkhy867Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>2016 is over. The earth has finally completed a turbulent cycle around the sun that has already garnered the accolade of that fetid<em>, </em>irredeemable, hate-filled child that the 21st century is so desperate to forget it ever spawned. Thankfully, we, as humans, now enter the cyclical pageantry of self-delusion in which we assure ourselves that this new year will be different, while simultaneously refusing to alter anything about our obviously infallible attitudes towards life.</p><p>This joyous period, where everyone wipes that disingenuous, festively spirited smile off their face and begins to engage in family-prescribed, ethanol-induced masochism, is often punctuated by attempts to steer your grandparents away from sensitive subjects of race, immigration, gender, sexuality, the euro, globalisation, UKIP, the Queen, refugees, collectivisation and religion, all in a futile effort to spare yourself the trouble of resenting the relatives who granted you your existence. But more than anything else, the beginning of a New Year is about reflection and mourning and nobody, during the ochlocratic smear that has been 2016, has more to reflect on and mourn than left-leaning liberals.</p><p>Like most of my millennial brethren, I viewed the entirety of 2016 through a 13inch LED backlit screen, and between all the <em>Game Of Thrones</em> reruns and the constant refreshing of the BBC’s online obituary page, I managed to catch a small amount of pixelated political content. Considering 2016 was preceded by a year in which it emerged our prime minister allegedly engaged in coitus with a dead pig, I’m glad the annual effort to convince the public that we’re all existing within a satirists’ dystopian wet-dream was not abandoned.</p><p>It was a year of historically incriminating tax-evasion leaks, strangely un-incriminating sexual abuse charges, and the year in which the worth of a Gorilla’s life transcended that of a child’s within the public consciousness. It was not to say, an uneventful year. We were shown the escalation of a horrific five-year civil war in Syria, a legitimised power-consolidation in Turkey and a war in Yemen abetted using Western arms exports to name but a few of the many political happenings of 2016 that had continental and global ramifications. Yet, if you were to take a quick glance down any of my social media news feeds, you would not be amiss to presume that the three incidents which proved to be of most polarising, global significance were Brexit, the US election, and the time when a reality TV star had her jewellery stolen in Paris.</p><p>And this is where the current problem lies, that by some estimations, 60% of the millennial generation use Facebook as their primary source of news. Fellow binary backpackers, scrolling through the catacombs of content and comment, have hooked themselves to an ideological drip that delivers opinion straight to their doorstep, granting them an idyllic and simplistic view of an increasingly complex political climate. Though this particular brand of click-bait social awareness affects both ends of the political spectrum, it is the left who have suffered the greatest decimation of their fantasy when measured with the reality of 2016.</p><p>Back in June, when Brexit was still just an amusing neologism, and the four apocalyptic horsemen were distant on the horizon — though lacking the prophetic titles of ‘Greed’ and ‘Pestilence,’ they were simply called Nigel, Boris, Mike and Liam — things were simpler for liberals residing in the UK . We were smugly convinced of our impending victory, thanks to a collective unity of efforts, with all our shared articles and loquacious posts. So when the Brexiteers snatched a narrow victory in the referendum, the more liberally inclined members of the online sphere had no choice but to regress to a natural state of playing accusatory, sectarian, omni-shambolic blame games.</p><p>The Brexit vote was, without gross over-simplification, a blue-collar protest vote, an upheaval against an establishment that had neglected rising inequality in favour of austerity policies, an ultimately intolerant measure against the political classes who arrogantly thought they had achieved invulnerability through misdirection. Considering the popular vote was so reactionary itself, the counter-reactionary venomous zeal of defeated liberals, proved to be no less irrational.</p><p>The day of the polls, my news feed erupted into a vile catalogue of ad-hominum shit slinging, characteristic of an angry mob lacking in both factual information and patience. The bitter spite directed at the older generation bordered on euthanasiastic, and according to many of my peers, responsibility for the outcome lay solely with previous generations, despite the fact that only 64% of 18–24 year-olds even voted. Next of the subsequent backlash, came the Facebook posts calling to turn London into a segregated city-state, practically demanding we erect walls around the very word ‘Metropolitan,’ as though the rest of the country didn’t feel excluded from the capital affluence enough already. Perhaps most prominent though, was the use of the word ‘racist’ to describe all leave voters, a childish tarnishing that only exhibited a defamatory oversimplification. It only succeeded in revealing that, in our piety, liberal millennials actually had very little intention of understanding any opposition to our own opinion.</p><p>We were angry, confused and foolishly baying for the blood of the 52%. We lacked any wish to understand whether the aims or motivations of our neighbours were misguided or grounded. It became evident that the progressives of the web were far better at protesting the repulsive symptoms of our society, as opposed to their causes. In the short aftermath of the referendum, I saw no chastising of a Tory government who had stoked the fires of nationalist sentiment (having since been engulfed by the flames), few of my peers called for the heads of a British media conglomerate so intent on popularising the politics of division, and only a minority of liberals assumed that growing inequality, two shrugged-off financial crashes and the constant neglect of British manufacturing could have had anything to do with the Leave sentiment, and consequently the outcome of Brexit.</p><p>It was far easier for us on the left, as the smoke of the referendum cleared, to decry half of the population as regressively opinionated thugs, instead directing genuine protest against a system that we so readily contributed to, day in, day out. Our reaction only illustrated the comparative ease with which we were able to direct reproach at individuals as opposed to institutions. Our constant online sermons to a choir that was clearly already converted, and our unwillingness to treat those of a politically adverse opinion as acquirable votes, resulted in the loss of 2016 to a brand of blinkered, dogmatic nationalism that openly lauded truth as an enemy.</p><p>When facts bear no consequence on a debate, to maintain an air of intellectual and moral superiority is political suicide. We should have sought to understand our opponents instead of adopting the condescension we so gracelessly exhibited.</p><p>Our hasty response to Brexit within the social media sphere, revealed liberals for what we had become online: unwittingly apathetic, grossly ill informed and desperately looking for somebody other than ourselves to blame. By the time the consequence of Brexit had been reduced to a delayed parliamentary vote, looming over the distant horizon of 2020, liberal millennials had managed to absolve themselves of almost all responsibility, though this time by blaming a non-human entity, mysteriously reviled, known only as the echo chamber.</p><p>In his book <em>The Big Sort, </em>Bill Bishop shows how, over the last 30 years, American citizens, and indeed citizens of most western countries, have sorted themselves into like-minded neighbourhoods. The echo chamber, or the social media bubble as it has been called, mirrored this theory online. After Brexit and before Trump, came a moment of rare enlightenment for the left, in which it finally dawned on us that the news being fed to us via our Facebook feeds might not be accurately representative of current affairs or universal opinion. Millennials were outraged. The Internet was not acting as the infallible democratiser of information, free of policing and content manipulation. Instead, through a series of online algorithms, similar to those that personalise adverts catered to your search history, facebook had been performing a curative function previously held by news editors. We were evidently trapped in a chamber of political news in which all we heard was ourselves.</p><p>The left was relieved; finally we had an explanation for the democratic Taser to the testicles that had been Brexit. Of course! It was the echo chamber of facebook and Zuckerburg that was leaving us unprepared and unexpected for the resurgence of right-wing populism, not our own inadequate efforts. We had successfully found a means to re-instate our collective identity as muffled voices against a machination beyond our control, we were the downtrodden, algorithmically oppressed we so longed to be.</p><p>Except none of it was true. We just desperately wanted it all to be. Liberals were wilfully neglecting the fact that the echo chamber’s existence is dependent on our contribution. Millennials assumed the news algorithms were intellectually strangling them, yet the overall design of the echo chamber can be attributed to three culpable architects.</p><ul><li>Firstly, who our friends are and what stories they share.</li><li>Secondly, amongst all the stories they share, which ones are displayed by the news feed algorithms.</li><li>And third and final, which of the displayed news stories do we actually click on.</li></ul><p>If the second factor is the primary driver of the echo chamber, then the omnipotent powers of Facebook and their force-feeding algorithms are responsible. In contrast, if the first or third factor are responsible, then it becomes clear we, as the information providers, have only created our own echo chambers.</p><p>It only takes a little introspective reflection on your own online activity to realise which of the three is true. How many people have you unfriended for conflicting political standing points? How many articles have you dismissed as propaganda? Who is it supplying that ever-valuable data fed into personalisation algorithms? If we are content to blame the echo chamber for our own disengagement from the realities of the political world, we are blaming a creature of our own design.</p><p>But even if the accusations of totalitarian Internet Stalinism levelled at facebook and its founder were entirely true, far more upsetting, is the growing revelation that Millennials expect facebook to provide them with a balanced political discourse. Facebook is first and foremost, a business venture. If I appear to be satisfied with the news I like, why should Facebook not optimise the reach for their business if we are unwilling to vote with our clicks? We clearly prefer news stories that are likely to reinforce our existing views rather than challenge them. Why did we, as those so often skeptical of social media, expect anything else?</p><p>Social media has always acted as a shimmering narcissistic puddle, in which we can happily gaze upon the reflection of a preened, filtered and perfected perception of ourselves. Part of that idealised perception facebook delivers, lies in the belief that we are accepted as part of a like-minded community, a community morally united, a community we wish to remain a part of. In recent years, liberals of my generation have chosen to lose ourselves in this reflection of our reality, allowing us to view ourselves as engaged and accepted, yet leaving us oblivious to the looming, leather-skinned, blonde-wigged demagogue that now threatens to guide the western world into a new age of plutocratic isolationism.</p><p>As facebook, instagram and twitter become necessities for the generations that succeed us, we must acknowledge the intellectual narcissism and pageantry that drives social media activism, and the how ineffectual to the betterment of society it is. We must stop waging meme warfare, an act that led thousands to believe a falsity that Harambe had garnered 11,000 votes in the US election. We must stop reducing complex political issues to 140 characters for a quantifiable measure of approval. We must stop believing that sharing several Guardian articles a month is an active substitute for political engagement.</p><p>2016 was no political anomaly, but it was not a reiteration of that age-old political binary; in which the left concentrated on the analysis of reality, while the Right sought to create their own reality. The difference in 2016 was that while the right was re-writing their reality, the left was helping them to create it. While we scrolled from injustice to injustice, submitting to a paralysing content nausea, simply nodding along with our peers, musing on how the world was indeed a terrible place, we allowed the right to spin sycophantic tales of how they ‘would make it great again.’ It is not enough to blame social media for our nihilistic pacifism in the face of crypto-fascism. We lost 2016 because, though we paraded our knowledge of the crimes taking place, we failed to do anything about them. In our characterising, often justified pessimism, we failed to offer the one thing any practicing idealistic voter requires, hope.</p><p>And that is not to say that the power of social media has no value. We cannot yet forget the call to arms facebook so loudly amplified during the Arab spring. As a means to spread social awareness it’s power is irrefutable, but it is action, not awareness that brings about change, and if 2016 has taught us anything, it is that ‘change’ is a currency through which votes are bought. The few, intermittent victories for liberals over the year, have been the result of forceful, passionate, and actively engaged grassroots campaigning: the recent Dakota pipeline ruling, the repudiation of TTIP in Europe, the CAAT taking legal action against the arms trade, even the recent snowballing popularity of socialist parliamentary parties in Europe. These fleeting moments of social justice were not achieved through the efforts of a twenty-something’s retweets, they were achieved through functional protest and organised public demonstration.</p><p>In 2017, to save us the confusion from reactionary voter spasms that so defined last year, liberal millennials must escape the world of passive support. It accomplishes nothing. We must seek out the movements and causes we so often read about, mobilise for meetings and rallies that matter, make donations if time is scarce. We cannot go on calling ourselves ‘politically engaged’ merely because we apply a filter to our profile picture every time there is a short lived crisis in Europe. We must recognise it is too easy an absolution from our own sense of moral obligation. Social media activism encourages a form of solidarity that will always end exactly how it began, with the click of a button.</p><p>I’d like to say I’m confident that this moment of enlightenment will arrive in 2017, that we’ll stop swapping likes and retweets, breeding apathy, reading those laborious opinion posts you’ve seen so many of this year. The blog posts so long that they should be accompanied by a bibliography and Harvard referencing. The posts so blatantly narcissistic you can practically see an ego massaged into a happy ending, while the writer continually refers to himself in the third person. I’d like to say that we’ll eventually stop screaming into the echo chamber, acting surprised when all we hear is ourselves, while the planet burns around us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=66155bc25f8c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>