<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Rahul Sahu on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Rahul Sahu on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@iRahulSahu?source=rss-c35034a5ca09------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 17:33:14 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@iRahulSahu/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is basic structure in a Democracy?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iRahulSahu/what-is-basic-structure-in-a-democracy-c570cc96f151?source=rss-c35034a5ca09------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c570cc96f151</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[basic-structure-doctrine]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parliament]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[people]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rahul Sahu]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Jan 2019 18:37:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-25T19:48:35.547Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The perennial fight that has been part of countries with democracy and Constitution to wrest control of major share of power of State been largely between Parliament and Judiciary. When it comes to India that is Bharat there are plethora of such cases which almost on daily basis either take an inch or cede an inch to Parliament. <strong><em>Kesavananda Bharati vs State of Kerala</em></strong> takes the cake in this regard.</p><p>In this case, Supreme Court by 7–6 verdict ruled that Parliament can not alter the “basic structure” of the Constitution. Though it is called 7–6 majority judgment but with 13 judges bench authoring 11 separate judgments is major cause of confusion. They declared it to be inviolable and something cast in stone which is not amendable by Parliament with the procedure provided in Article 368 for the amendment of the Constitution. The complexity and lack of clarity on many questions it left answered doesn’t stop it from being a celebrated judgement in corridors of legal powers and some elites. The doctrine established in this case came to be popularly referred as “Doctrine of Basic Structure”. The dissent by 6 Judges has been buried deep without much thought and discussion thus this judgement has not received its fair share of scrutiny from the people.</p><p>The leader of a Hindu mutt Srimad Jagadguru Sri Sri Sankaracharya Thotakacharya <strong>Keshavananda Bharati</strong> Sripadangalavaru challenged the attempts of Kerala government to impose the restriction on property management through two land reforms acts. With this his challenge to those acts was also the challenge to 24th, 26th and 29th amendment of Constitution as these amendments gave basis for the land reforms acts.</p><p><strong>The question that was attempted to be answered in this case was whether Parliament can amend any part of Constitution following the procedure provided for its amendment or are there certain limitations on power of Parliament to amend Constitution which makes certain “core” of Constitution unamendable?</strong></p><p>To answer this question most important place to look for is the Constituent Assembly Debates and there no part of Constitution has been placed at higher pedestal against the rest making the former essential part of Constitution. There is no such distinction made between “basic” and “non-basic” feature of Constitution. <br>If at all anything can be regarded as more fundamental and basic than the others then it can be seen from the Article giving amending power and process to Parliament which is Article 368. Clause 2 of Article 368 classifies 5 items which envisages the ratification by the Legislature of not less than one half of the States by resolution to that effect passed by those Legislatures before the Bill making provision for such amendment is presented to the President for assent.</p><p>This makes it clear that there is nothing called “basic”(thus no “non-basic”) and whatever part of Constitution deemed more significant than others by Constitution framers is the part which in the process of amendment have to be ratified by more than half of the States before sending to President for his assent. Yes, Constitution framers thought certain parts more important than others thus making it follow more rigorous process for amendment and beyond that there is nothing on this. The idea that nothing in this Constitution will be unamendable was so obvious that there was no discussion at all as to what is amendable and what is not. Further the First Constitutional amendment done by more or less same set of people present in Constituent Assembly did not even see any need to talk about powers to amend and limitations though it made important amendment to Fundamental Rights. What more is needed to get the intention of Constitution framers that there is no part unamendable in the Constitution?</p><p><strong>Thus if at all there can be any “Basic Structure” in Constitution then it has to be the parts mentioned in 368(2)(a)-(e). Even in such scenario it has to be noted that it is not to make it unamendable but only to recognize the fundamental importance of these provisions shown by special requirement for its amendment.</strong></p><p>Below are the provisions which require ratification from more than half of the States —</p><p><em>(a) Article 54, Article 55, Article 73, Article 162 or Article 241, or <br>(b) Chapter IV of Part V, Chapter V of Part VI, or Chapter I of Part XI, or <br>(c) any of the Lists in the Seventh Schedule, or <br>(d) the representation of States in Parliament, or <br>(e) the provisions of this article,</em></p><p>These provisions relate to Election of President (Article 54), Manner of election of President (Article 55), Extent of executive power of the Union (Article 73), Extent of Executive power of the State (Article 162), High Courts for Union Territories (Article 241), Chapter IV of Part V, Chapter V of Part VI, Chapter I of Part XI, the Lists in the Seventh Schedule, Representation of the States in Parliament and the amending power of Parliament(Article 368).</p><p>The argument that the preamble which is the face of Constitution presenting what it contain within can be used to deduce certain things as Basic Structure of Constitution is not able to answer that why then Constituent Assembly did not mention it explicitly. In any case, since Constitution itself can be amended as per the procedure then how can Preamble, a part of Constitution be unamendable when nothing expressly mentioned about it in Article 368. It is fanciful and wishful to think that inn 2 years 11 months 18 days preparing lengthiest Constitution of the world Constituent Assembly would miss to make a mention of such an important matter and even not consider worthy enough to be debated even.</p><p>To say otherwise and hold that there is some “core”,”essential”,”basic” structure in Constitution which can not be amended is to go against the Constituent Assembly which drafted this Constitution.</p><p>The term “Basic Structure” was used in the neighboring country in the case of <em>Fazulal Quader Chawdry v. Mohd. Abdul Haque [1963 PLD 486(SC)] </em>by CJP Alvin Cornelius. Not difficult to see that the country where it originated itself failed to save the fundamental rights of its own citizen many times but ironically it is mentioned as something which has saved and still saving the democracy and fundamental rights in India. <br>It did not take much time to show what Kesavananda Bharati case secured the Indian citizens as claimed by many when the then PM Indira Gandhi decided to impose the Emergency within two years of this judgement. Indira Gandhi crushed the democracy as best as she could and the Basic Structure could not do anything about it. The 42nd amendment(whatever left of it still) is another remnant showing what Basic Structure meant. <br>The Indian democracy like any other democracy was saved by its people when people delivered crushing blows to Indira Gandhi in 1977 General Elections. It was the people by their voting choice that brought the Indira Gandhi to knees and shown what democracy means; not the Courts.</p><p>That the words “socialist” and “secular” are still part of Preamble surviving the Basic Structure which changed the nature of the Constitution giving it permanent character of one kind goes onto show that Judiciary if something appeals to its morality latches onto it. The worse is the immortalization of these words into the Jurisprudence of India and in our Preamble, courtesy Basic Structure doctrine which makes it seemingly unamendable now. The good question is if it could lock in the Preamble how did it allow the Preamble to be amended giving space to these words in the first place?</p><p>1973 Basic Structure doctrine came , in 1976 by 42nd amendment Preamble was amended inter alia to include the “socialist” and “secular” in it and now according to Basic Structure these words can not be removed by amendment. Doesn’t it show certain things can come in as for them doors are open and key here seems to be the morality that appeals to judiciary. Nowadays in vogue with phrase “Constitutional Morality”. The argument that it only mentioned expressly what it stood for thus passes the Basic Structure test is incorrect.</p><p>Here is what Dr Ambedkar replied to Prof. KT Shah while rejecting his suggestion to add these very words in Preamble —</p><p><em>Constitution is <br>“merely a mechanism for the purpose of regulating the work of the various organs of the State. It is not a mechanism where by particular members or particular parties are installed in office. What should be the policy of the State, how the Society should be organised in its social and economic side are matters which must be decided by the people themselves according to time and circumstances.</em></p><p><em>It cannot be laid down in the Constitution itself, because that is destroying democracy altogether. If you state in the Constitution that the social organisation of the State shall take a particular form, you are…taking away the liberty of the people to decide what should be the social organisation in which they wish to live.”</em></p><p>More and more features to the cast in stone thus unamendable premium list of “basic” has been added thus making them immune from removal. It only reeks of certain ideology and morality imposition on the people of India and its democracy through not so legitimate means.</p><p>What Basic Structure was supposed to ensure Parliament does not become has molded the Judiciary into it. It has made the Judiciary supreme in some sense while trying to stop the Parliament from being supreme.</p><p>The power of amendment conferred upon Parliament must be coextensive with the power of judicial review conferred upon the judiciary, to check the tyranny of the unelecteds in world’s biggest democracy.</p><p>That not being the case shows the blatant disregard and utmost disrespect for electoral democracy. Ironically, the democracy being part of Basic Structure must have been saved by Basic Structure rather than perpetuating the unelecteds’ morality and ideology on all crushing the democracy.</p><p>It is often seen that Court do more based on what they think Constitution stands for than what Constitution says thus rendering power of Judicial Review being misused which does not reflect the wisdom of Constituent Assembly. What could be the better example of it than the case of Kesavananda Bharati case itself. <br>The more damaging thing here is being in democracy there is not much that can be done in such situations when Judiciary decides to interpret things what Constitution doesn’t say. On the other hand say if people are unsatisfied with the amendments in Constitution they can always vote the incumbents out and newly constituted legislature can change it back based on what people’s wishes are. There could be maximum 5 years duration after which people invariably get a chance to show through their voting choices what they want. <br>Another argument against this is do you want your Constitution to be amended every 5 years? Of course not but that is the extreme possibility and in any case there has been 124 attempts to amend the Constitution and out of those 103 have succeeded in last 70 years of our Republic which shows the rate of more than one amendment a year thus no earth shattering thing will happen if in some extreme situation it were to be amended in 5 years according to wishes of people.</p><p><strong>Basic Structure doctrine has established the supremacy not of the Constitution but of the judiciary.</strong></p><p>Time has come to reargue the premises and judgement rendered in Kesavananda Bharati case and it is the fervent hope that democracy loving eloquent judges of Honorable Supreme Court will restore the Constitution’s old glory by reverting it to amending procedure intended by Constituent Assembly which itself is fundamentally more important provision.</p><p>The basis to reargue the Kesavananda Bharati is — <strong>no generation should bind the course of generations to come and laws are for the people not the other way around.<br></strong>The principles worth preserving and worth fighting for securing the democratic right and right to be what they want of current and future generations. These are inviolable principles of democracy.</p><p><strong>PONDER: Which country has the system of judges appointing judges? Where did we get concept of Judicial Independence from? What do they follow to preserve and secure the Judicial Independence? Should in a democracy any part of codified law be cast in stone? How long a system will last if the medium in which it functions is foreign language(not understood by more than 10% of the population it covers) and having its mooring in alien value system? How long it will last if such system is to operate on oldest and only continuing civilization? How long before in this age of information spearheaded by social media, thus removing the gatekeepers out of the equation who used to curate what information people could consume, such system will crumble?</strong></p><h3>जय श्री कृष्ण</h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c570cc96f151" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Securing the civilization: Broad framework]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iRahulSahu/securing-the-civilization-broad-framework-54a98e3e5c47?source=rss-c35034a5ca09------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/54a98e3e5c47</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[india]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hinduism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[legal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civilization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rahul Sahu]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 25 Nov 2018 17:22:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-26T07:14:17.492Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Just like on any usual day I was going through my YouTube feed and there popped up this <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmgLJcmTeHI">video</a> of Dr Subramanian Swamy. I was always intrigued by the way our civilization has been hammered by foreign invaders since 1000 AD first by Islamic invaders and then came the ideological elder brother of Islam, Christianity to loot, plunder and convert to their religion and way of life.</p><p>We have been quite a success in defending ourselves from the onslaught by both Islam and Christianity when we see at the other examples where these ideologies went to conquer. They simply converted the whole population to their religion and way of living 100% in most of the parts. Examples for this are abound such as Europe, Egypt, Iraq etc. Living testimony to the resistance our ancestors showed to them is in the land we still have and the Dharma that we still follow. Sure, we lost considerable part of the land and shrank in percentage as population but unlike most other civilization where these invading ideologies went we are still here resisting the attempts which want us to leave the Dharma. How long we can is a question in the belly of time. It is time to get our acts together to secure and defend our civilization.</p><p>But how do secure the civilization? Any civilization.</p><p>Any civilization which wants not to be obliterated to UNESCO list only has to have the control of these three institutions <strong>— Schools, Temples &amp; Family.</strong></p><p>I have taken the term <em>Idea of India </em>from <a href="https://twitter.com/realitycheckind/">RCI</a> to address the machination that we are facing now here in Bharat. It has characteristics of those foreign invaders which has imperialistic ruling mindset. Most of our current leaders specially the ones espousing Hindutva lacks it. IOI uses the education to make our kids behave in certain ways and controls our places of worship and family through policy and legal framework to make us something we are not — <em>homogenized disciplined zombies</em>.</p><p><strong>What can be done to resist this and as an alternative to replace the IOI? <br>Here is what could be possibly done — <br> 1. Absolute Parity in education sector <br> 2. No sectarian division of public purse(apply pro-rata) <br> 3. Wrest control of temples to Community back <br> 4. Take out native practices out of PIL(without locus standi)</strong></p><p>Here the point preceding the others gives us chance to work upon it further and we can get things done mentioned below it. <br>For instance if we have equal rights in education sector then we can teach our kids and train them in such a way that they can fight against sectarian purse. Likewise our kids can take the control of temple back if they are taught in such a way that they understand the importance of temple. They can secure our practices/customs/traditions which is point 4.</p><p>So we can get things done — anything and everything — if we have autonomy in education.</p><p>Now let’s do it reverse. Presently we don’t have control over what our kids are taught. This value-ed(what is non value education by the way?), experiential learning(bogus social justice) and life skills is disaster to produce zombies. If we go further down the road, most of our leaders aren’t able to see how this sectarian purse is unheard of in any parts of the world specially against the majority community but do you see any leader worth his name talking about it?<br>Have you seen any mainstream politician talking of taking the control of temples out of state control and give it back to its rightful owners Hindu community? There may be sporadic cases here and there but otherwise nobody interested in legislating in this regard. Why?<br>How many times you have seen leaders standing shoulder to shoulder with people fighting for their traditions. Even if they are espousing the Hindutva they actually become ‘reformist’(brown sepoys?) and try to ‘civilize’ and ‘uniformalize’ the natives and their traditions. What do you think is the reason that even so called Hindutva party with powers in more than 18 states and at Center is not working on it? They can’t fear the press because we don’t want any thing pro but only parity and equal rights.</p><p>How do you test leader and party claiming to fight for you? <br><em>The test is very simple — Are you able to see how it is going to play out in future and hit us — at institutional level and then at individual level ? This is the rightful fight. This is what is worth fighting for.</em></p><p><strong><em>You get the education back in your control and see the magic. Imagine 100 schools run by Sabarimala, Siddhi Vinayak and Tirupati Balaji each. What do you think kids coming out of them will stand for? You need the kids with saffron hue through institutions not by state. Trying to get it from state is very fragile strategy which will have in built pre-condition that you remain in power in perpetuity — simply impossible task.</em></strong></p><p>What is the population of Christians in India and in any particular area. Get the list of top 25 schools and see how many of them are run by them. Why do they latch onto education? Why do they focus on education? <br>Because it is the best way to teach and imbibe your values to kids in their formative years and they will he molded into it for life. We can’t do the same because of article 30(1) and article 15(5) of Constitution of India and with our temples in controls of supposedly secular state. But which Hindutva leader talks about it. Ponder WHY? <br>The day leaders on our side get this clear in their heads (about seeing what is important and what is mere symbolism) we will get rightful place in the world. Unless that happens you can keep fighting all you want but won’t get the place we deserve and realize our potential.<br>Does that mean I’m opposed to things which are symbolic and ornamental in nature such as — <br>1. Changing names of places/monuments. <br>2. Removing words from preamble <br>3. Building temples and fighting corruption.</p><p>No. <br>But if you give me article 30 and preamble I will happily choose article 30. <br>Because as explained earlier with article 30 I can train my kids and down the line in next decade or so we will change the preamble too and change the names of places/monuments and rebuild temples etc. But what if our kids get the education which is rooted in Hinduphobia? They will never have sense of temples, importance of monuments and places so they won’t care whether it is named X or Y.<br>In this demographic hump those who have education in control will get the kids molded in their favour and once you get that game is done and dusted. Your own kids would turn against you for your cultural and civilizational agenda. Do you want that?</p><p>If not then understand and fight for <strong>equal rights in education sector</strong> —<strong> mother of everything</strong>. <br>If we lose this we are going to lose every other thing we have, eventually.</p><p><strong>PONDER: Which country in the world has given complete autonomy in education to minorities and heavy breath taking legal framework to majority communities? Which country has vastly disproportionate budgeting in favour of minorities? Which country claiming to be secular in its preamble controls the religious places of majority? Worst of all, symbolically, in which part of the world practices/festivities of majority community are mercilessly attacked?</strong></p><h3><strong>जय श्री कृष्ण</strong></h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=54a98e3e5c47" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[India: Apartheid State restricting the 90% of its Population by use of English]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iRahulSahu/india-apartheid-state-restricting-the-90-of-its-population-by-use-of-english-6f1bb95c0f7c?source=rss-c35034a5ca09------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6f1bb95c0f7c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[bharat]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[language]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sanskrit]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hindi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tamil]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Rahul Sahu]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Jun 2018 19:36:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-11-08T09:34:59.157Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Today while I was going through my feeds on social media accounts I stumbled upon <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/hindi-mother-tongue-of-44-in-india-bangla-second-most-spoken/articleshow/64755458.cms">this news link</a>. Anything in this news item was not to my surprise or what I have discussed when talking to people but it made me do a thread on the power of language and how India is destroying its talent pool and ways to harness it. <br>I am surprised to see that I have not found single politician worth his name who has made the case of Indian languages in official works of State and its use replacing the remnants of Invaders from Britain, English. <br>So what does this new item tell us? <br>It says,” Hindi mother tongue of 44% in India, Bangla second most spoken.” <br>This tells you about a particular disease which is harming India and nobody seems to care about it who can solve it. <br>In 10 years span from 2001 to 2011 Hindi speakers have added 260 basis points from 41.03% to 43.63%. It is the question of the business and fundamentals that sooner or later people across the India will have to learn the Hindi out of compulsion. I would like this not to be this ‘kitab’ Hindi as used in Bollywood but ‘Pustak’ Hindi as much Sanskritized as possible which comes from Constitution. That is the way ahead. This is the effect of changing demography in India.</p><p>Government at center should go ahead with Sanskritized Hindi as per Constitution and remove the English as official language. All those who claim that it is not workable as how would States &amp; Center communicate then answer is the way EU does.</p><p>This language barrier which stops our talent (more than 90%) from actually flourishing to change lives of family/community and in effect of nation has to go. Any leader who can champion this after detailed planning will outlive all of our leaders after 1900s in my opinion.</p><p>This will be such a life changing and civilizational renaissance that will transcend and assimilate all other progresses and good things done.</p><p>This only needs one careful planned step to make people understand that English is not something which gets you intelligence.</p><p>This messaging has to be careful and measured and sensitive to thinking of people. Learning English or for that matter any other language is good but English as a medium to learn and function in a country where 90% doesn’t understand or speak it just makes India apartheid state.</p><p>But before you can see anyone doing it, of course it has to be Politicians only, you will need someone who understands the basics so clearly that he/she does not suffer from even indirect inferiority complex.</p><p><a href="https://swarajyamag.com/politics/a-look-at-what-the-adityanath-government-is-really-doing-with-uttar-pradeshs-madrassa-and-sanskrit-boards">Like recently Bureaucrat in UP in charge of Madarssa Board after seeing that Madarssa educated people could not understand notices in airport which were in english decided to modernize the Madarssa. This is not the solution. Use of the Indian languages in such places is needed.</a></p><p>Such hair brained and quick fix entirely in wrong direction would lead us to more friction and violence in society.<br>We have to see the fundamental. You can not suddenly teach 100+ Cr people English or in few decades. In any case why do you want that ? To be bodyshopper in US/West?</p><p><strong>It was really sad to see that out of 22 Official Languages in India Sanskrit was the least spoken one. It was listed by only 24,821 people as mother tongue.That is deflated number as there would be many people knowing more than one language specially those knowing Sanskrit.</strong></p><p>We have to reverse the changes and this is something people can not do as the game and rules are set by the people in power at the top. Only the government by its policies can do this. Today or tomorrow, BJP or somebody more sane will do it. When I see a man earning 2000 rupees per month still spending 1000 rupees per month on his kids education and his only hope is that his kid should be able to speak in good English, the heart of Bharat mata cries so loud. She cries not because half of the money earned is being spent on education in a poor family but because it is being spent to learn only a foreign language rather than subjects such as Mathematics, Science, Social Studies, Economics etc. This wrong direction of families for which blame squarely lies on Governments is the reason for such daily cries.</p><p><strong>Let me say it again that it is not English which faces my opposition as a language being taught in schools in India but rather education in English medium which is a curse.</strong></p><h4>Ponder: How is Japan able to save its civilization in the post modern world? Which languages are used by Russia, Korea, Taiwan, China, Germany to make advancement in Technology and Scientific field? Is functioning in a foreign language, understood by many other countries, for a sovereign nation strategically good?</h4><h3>जय श्री कृष्ण</h3><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6f1bb95c0f7c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>