<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Iain Clowes on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Iain Clowes on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@iain.clowes?source=rss-fc86998d7fdb------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 13:14:58 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@iain.clowes/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Reflections on Arcade Fire’s “The Suburbs”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-people/reflections-on-arcade-fires-the-suburbs-63346f1aee83?source=rss-fc86998d7fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/63346f1aee83</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blog]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Iain Clowes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Apr 2020 20:16:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-03T20:16:36.281Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*O_7pr846oAPYtb_w.jpg" /></figure><p>I listened to <em>The Suburbs </em>for the first time when I was 12 years old. I was very convinced at the time that rock’n’roll was the best genre and a family friend had a large album collection of which she had to ease the size so that she still had room in her car for CDs. She told me specifically which albums she thought I would like more or like less, and with this one I remember her clearly saying “This is not something I think you’d like, but give it a try anyway.”</p><p>Since then, I think I have listened to this album 3 times. While I’ve actually listened to it at least a hundred times or more over the last decade, there’s been at least three distinct interpretations I’ve had: the one I had from ages 12–15, the second from ages 15–18, and the one I’m in now from 18–22.</p><p>On first listen, most of the themes didn’t really present themselves to me. I was vaguely aware of a powerful sense of alienation, a displacement. The sound made me feel like I could see a world that was brushable, one I could tiptoe across or perhaps even hold for a brief moment, but contact would never last. Embracing this world was impossible. There was only the option of a distant viewing, a stare from a veil of my own making, with a faint sense of nostalgia for times that never happened and an eternal mourning for the thing that never was. If 10 year old me were interviewed then, I doubt he’d be able to express this, and yet the feeling has imprinted itself so heavily upon me. The title track of the album sets this tone of unease, this unstable relationship between heaven and earth, within the very music. You don’t need the lyrics to reach this — I certainly didn’t need to, I couldnt understand them. The F# major chord that really does not belong there, for example, should be an F# minor — to make it fit even less, it’s often covered as F#6 where an F#b6 would be far more appropriate. The long, drawn out “-ming” in “screaming” holds an incredibly unstable position— a C# note! against a piece that’s ambiguously in B minor or D major! — that begs to be resolved, clashing in an incredibly beautiful piece of disharmony against the band playing behind it. The lead singer stands in open defiance against the coherent sound of Arcade Fire’s (incredibly large, it’s like an orchestra) backing instrumentals. I rejected things around this time for the first time. Politics opened up to me, as Tony Blair resigned from office around this time, and I began to start asking questions like every other bland coming-of-age article you’ve ever read. All alienation requires separation, separation is by definition alien. It was around this time that this album introduced me, paradoxically, to alienation. As reality, once my childhood toy, drifted apart from me, I moved off on a line of flight only to brush against it now or perhaps to hold it for a brief moment.</p><p>The album sat on my shelf for a good few years after that as I settled into being an edgy teenager with unpleasant habits, both social and hygienic. I raged against the dying light of my childhood by actually holding and questioning opinions for the first time, with such incredibly novel and unheard-of insights like capitalism is bad and dudes are hot. At this point, celebration of the incomprehensible veil of separation was something I intended to celebrate. I read fantasy books for some reason and fell in love with the Avatar series, I dabbled in hipster aesthetics but never so much as to actually fit in, I held controversial views — I was a professional disagreer. Such a perfect crock of shit for mental illness to flourish in, devouring my bullshit to poison my bloodstream, had never before been seen. To my viewpoint, I was both a gleaming star of promise and also a deep and brooding intellectual, yet the contradiction never struck me for all my supposed enlightenment. The Suburban War of this album had come, a celebration of all the destruction inherent in my desire to relish in alienation, to destroy myself for the sheer joy in denying others a label for me, <em>“before your war against the suburbs begins, before it began”. </em>The desire to cut my hair and never be seen again reached untold heights at this point, and the melancholy of this track’s simple yet aching lead guitar intertwining with mourning backing vocals shows this. A song filled with pride with violence, determination laced with a deep sadness, I was now priding myself on finally understanding the lyrics of this album as I listened again. I was new, I was different, I was impactful. If you said otherwise, you were wrong. I cut my hair, I never saw me again.</p><p>Eventually, this all caught up with me. I moved to a different country entirely for college and stumbled around as my desire to be something better clashed with my destructive impulse that I called a personality, once used against culture, politics, logic, and now against myself. Eventually, I had a mental breakdown and had to start over, <em>“I was left standing in the wilderness downtown”, </em>on my own personality and who or what exactly I was<em>. </em>We Used To Wait gave me a vehicle by which to carry and understand this tension. Refusing to touch or glance that world of childhood or of comprehension would no longer do, spitting at it was not good enough for anyone or myself now. I used to wait for it to come to me, as some times of childhood reality never came. Intolerable. Absolutely intolerable. This track has spoken to me in recent years primarily because it is the first track to truly make demands of the listeners. Some demands are quite mild — a staccato piano part of just two notes that just continues through most of the song, setting the tempo but also somewhat putting you at unease, the just slightly off beat snare drum that hits on beats 2 and 3.5 rather than 2 and 4, and the shout “<em>Wait for it!” </em>at the song’s climax. Wait for it, wait for it, you can be different but restrain yourself, would you? We all know you’re behind that veil, we all are, so simmer down a bit and make something of it. We all used to wait. I used to sign letters, I used to write my name, but perhaps that was the grand error I made this whole time. To destroy the self in the name of the self is not only contradictory, it is a snake eating itself. This is not to say that we simply resolve to let the ego fester, staring forwards at nothing. No, we have options, lines of flight and crisscrossing muddles. So much of my attempts to slash and burn at reality itself had been in a misguided attempt to cut my way out of the wilderness of my veil and find solid ground again, but it seems what I really needed was to wait for it and move again, walk through the pain.</p><p>While most reviews of this album seem to mention Sprawl as the grand finale, I’d prefer not to. For me, We Used To Wait holds much more resonance at this point. Trying to end this article with the end of the album itself would be premature — this is not the end of my life, or at least I hope not. The Sprawl, part II especially, is also completely unlike the rest of the album in terms of its sound. The lead singer for the entire album, Win Butler, is switched out for Régine Chassagne, while the guitars and drums are replaced with synths and drum machines, and the strings are gone entirely. Whereas the other tracks operated at the in-between of treble and bass, this one leaps up to the high end of treble. Sprawl II does not slow down or mumble its sadness down to the dirt, it proclaims it to the heavens. While Sprawl I lumbers itself to look the listener in the eye, Sprawl II presents the most vicious eye-contact, an unflinching stare with intensity untold. While Sprawl is not the last track of the album (that would be the reprise of The Suburbs), it represents a massive departure from the album’s themes as a whole. While the lyrics lend into the motifs of the album — suburbia and the tension of having the gall to exist in a world of conformity — it refuses to engage with the ground at all, the land of suburbia. We have spent an entire album, an entire lifetime, thus far swirling with energy or grinding to self-apologetic halts down on the surface level. Sprawl takes us to the absolute lowest point possible of the Flatland by having you talk to the cops who made this whole reality into the dire mess it is, only to then break you out with a dream of Mountains Beyond Mountains.</p><p>Perhaps this flight will be possible to me too, as I continue to progress in the quest of maturity, of realising just how stupid I am. Perhaps I can reconcile the Modern Man I am presently, apathetic and filled with critiques without substance, with the vivid and charged reality I once saw. Then again, perhaps reality isn’t all it’s cracked up to be. Such emphasis is placed upon this word, after all, “reality” — perhaps we should stop paying so much attention to it. That certain indignity we feel when someone isn’t relating to reality as we see it or even outright lying, why should we care? Why does it bother us so much while we still enjoy fantasies, a controlled contradiction of reality as they are? This reality, this dream of living on Earth, may not be the useful tool we presuppose. We may be able to model it to near perfection with such searing analysis that all things present themselves to us in the future as simply information to be shown, as concealers of information rather than what they truly are. We may also be able to stop and listen to the harmony, and if that’s true, perhaps it’s time to begin my 4th listen. I suspect this album will follow me for a considerable portion of my life, if not most of it, not that it really matters how long exactly. The Suburbs remains, with houses built to change, and tomorrow means nothing. There is something wild in the night — can you hear it breathing?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=63346f1aee83" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-people/reflections-on-arcade-fires-the-suburbs-63346f1aee83">Reflections on Arcade Fire’s “The Suburbs”</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-people">The People</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The death of the British centre]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-people/the-death-of-the-british-centre-322dd77a2ae7?source=rss-fc86998d7fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/322dd77a2ae7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2019]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-kingdom]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Iain Clowes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jan 2020 22:16:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-08T22:23:24.366Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TuKEesS3RKaRkw-P" /></figure><p>The demagogue rises to the stage. To his crowd of devoted fans, he is their only option, their one true leader. With his jaw hanging and spittle flying, the orator begins his prattling. He denounces those insidious elements, those traitors in our midst, and condemns them for destroying the nation as we know it. The crowd roars in approval, although all of them knew they would and it’s unlikely that the wider public’s opinion of him will change — not from this speech alone, certainly. This man may be labelled a bigot, a hate figure, and a criminal, but it doesn’t matter — he’ll be Prime Minister soon.</p><p>Depending on political inclination, you may have read this a few weeks ago as either Jeremy Corbyn or as Boris Johnson. Not only that, you’d have had articles, videos, tweets, and other sources on hand ready to not only justify but <em>prove</em> that this was the case. Don’t worry — this will not be an article of some smug centrism for me to smirk about how <em>actually </em>both sides are bad which I can pretend is somehow a useful point to make. Instead, I’ll say the real problem is Ed Miliband announcing his candidacy for Labour leadership in the coming weeks.</p><p>Let’s clarify — it’s unlikely he will run again, even if there are rumours of him doing a lot more networking than would be normal at the present time. No, Miliband is a specific form of British centrist. He’s not a Liberal Democrat, he’s not a One Nation Tory, and he’s not even most centrists within the Labour party. No, Miliband is a sort of New Reaction that is highly specific. It is left wing — sort of — not right. It is progressive, broadly speaking. Miliband specifically appeals to often centre-left white cis men, but it does have its share of minority and women supporters. Miliband is a memory, a dead ideal with those in grieving still yet to accept that the death has passed and it isn’t coming back.</p><p>The UK is in a complex state currently, unparalleled in the depth of its constitutional crisis that hasn’t been seen since the Second World War. The monarchy has had to intervene on democratic procedure based on lies given by a Prime Minister elected by a slim 60 thousand people in a population of over 66 million, the economy is set to collapse in the near future from withdrawal from the single largest trading bloc in the world based on “we’ll get good deals” with all 1.8% of the world’s FDI. Scotland, just five years on from an independence referendum, is vying for independence and could take a third of British territory and a good 10% of its GDP if it succeeds in this endeavour. A racist homophobe from Eton is in charge, however, so things may be somewhat more normal than they seem.</p><p>The underlying cause for a lot of these is sourced directly from the results of the 2016 Brexit referendum. I could talk here about the dangerous tendency that the Tories have had since Thatcher, drifting further and further to the right until their current point where fascists are actively recruited into the party and every electoral success of theirs sees a surge in hate crimes, and indeed, I could also talk about the sudden rise to prominence of the post-Thatcher Corbyn whose base launched to the national stage to give them something new, refreshed, and better than what had been seen before with the two largest mandates ever given to a Labour leader. However, the centre has been critically ignored by current analysis, so I will focus on them: the Liberal Democrats, the “moderate” Tories, and Miliband.</p><p>The Lib Dems, facing electoral disaster after their catastrophic and backstabbing coalition with David Cameron in 2010, found a light at the end of the tunnel in 2016 — an avowedly liberal party, the opportunity to present a new case for remaining in the EU and doubling down on neoliberal institutions would give them a monopoly for defending centre-progressivism and noughties-style gradual social reforms, perceived as abandoned by the ever-rightwards Tories and the “Stalinist zeal” of Labour. Unfortunately, this dream proved to be hopeless as it turns out that there was a reason people didn’t want to support those institutions in the first place. While a great deal of press attention was certainly devoted to the “politically homeless”, the middle class who dedicated themselves to the “socially progressive, fiscally conservative” label that felt abandoned by both parties rather than realising the oxymoronic nature of their own views. With all three of their past leaders having to resign in the last three elections, none are notable with no point in really giving any attention to this party in terminal decline. Centrism, as a position in its own right, is a death sentence in the modern climate of the UK — “balance” isn’t a policy, “compromise” mandates your party not even being in control.</p><p>In the seeming death of independent centrists, initially there was hope of moderate Tories coming to the rescue of institutions threatened by autocrats within the Tories and the progression of history by Labour. It was often pointed out, shortly after the Brexit referendum result became apparent, that “Remain Tories outnumber Leave Tories in Westminster”. This was, once again, not to be. Angry local party members took to their party offices to summarily vote their own MPs out on grounds of no confidence for defying what they perceived as the will of the people. Yet more of these Remainers would soon be lost as the party’s continual right drift continued as they defected to the Liberal Democrats, such as Sam Gyimah from East Surrey who was once held as a potential future Prime Minister, or to form doomed new parties in the name of Change UK. None of these have survived — Gyimah and the entirety of Change UK lost their seats in the 2019 election. With the influx of new Tory seats, the centre or “One Nation” faction of the Tories has been destroyed and a rigidly far-right party remains in its place. While some have claimed that the sheer size of the Tory majority may give Boris Johnson the ability to pass relatively centrist legislation, the question one must ask is why? Centrism, in the modern day, is defined by compromise — balance, process, crossing the aisle — which the very majority that supposedly will cause this centrist surge renders unnecessary. The only way this might happen is if Johnson is himself a closet-centrist — I invite people who believe this to read the things he has said while relatively isolated from power. No, it is highly unlikely that we will see a renewal of centrist or even centre-right sentiments within the Tories — it’s all Right from here on.</p><p>Having discussed the death of the “pure” centrists and the centre-right, what of the centre-left? Here, we return to Miliband. Ed Miliband was the Labour leader for the 2015 general election which was, after five years of relative failure by David Cameron, set to be a tight race with a narrow Labour majority. Confidence was so high in the Labour camp that Miliband actually unveiled, weeks before polling day, a giant stone column signed by him as prime minister commemorating his inevitable victory and successes in government. Come election day, Labour actually lost seats compared to the last election — which itself had seen a drop of almost 100 after Blair’s successor, Gordon Brown, had failed to revive the centre-right image of the party that had been so carefully cultivated during the late 90s. Miliband was <em>supposed</em> to fix this, Miliband was to be the way forward. It was the clear successor of history, as far as the British left could see: Thatcherism had long been established as the political order of the day as of the 1980s. After 20 years of failed attempts from “conventional” left viewpoints trying to overturn this, Blairism emerged, a significant capitulation wherein ideas of the left were to be merged with Thatcherist ideals of government and economy as part of a new centrism, a New Labour. Having surged to power in 1997 and only being eventually ousted a good decade later, Tony Blair’s successor Gordon Brown attempted to keep this ideal going with some leftward steps amidst an increasingly bold Conservative party who were keen to return to more orthodox neoliberalism, to rewind to a digitised orthodoxy of Thatcher. This failed with almost 100 seats lost and the beginning of the disastrous Tory coalition. Enter Miliband — the reform wing of Blairism. Miliband was to be the solution to Thatcherism’s tendency to crisis, to bust-boom, and not only should but was <em>guaranteed </em>to win for it was the future and thus could grasp at possibilities that were off-limits to the orthodox Blairists and the Tories, intent on ruling over a decaying domain of 1980s Britain well into the 2010s. So Miliband thrived, as at last the future was here — just one pesky election to get out of the way first.</p><p>Of course, we know what happened. Miliband lost yet more seats, resigned the leadership in disgrace, and the election of Jeremy Corbyn — the first declaration of post-Thatcherism in the UK, a slash-and-burn rejection of the old order — has left what conventional analysis would name the centre-left in disarray ever since. They have shuffled around between the failed Tory project of Change UK, the Liberal Democrats, and once even a failed leadership bid with a piece of blank paper which has somehow been named “Owen Smith”.</p><p>While Neverland isn’t real, the power of its idyllic image is not to be shrugged at — thus, the Thatcherists, staring dreamily into their dusted out cupboard of 80s Britain and reminiscing of the imperial glory in the past when they could starve millions of Indians at their hearts content, have won yet another election. Corbyn is set to resign, and with the party institutionally captured by the activist left components, it is likely that his successor will be somewhat similar in policies rather than the significant departures that the last four leadership elections have all signalled for the party. Ed Miliband is unlikely to run (despite some rumours), but it is likely that Miliband will emerge as a loud, now ignorant, strain.</p><p>Let us be clear — Miliband is dead. Miliband harks from an era where the most significant things to discuss in Britain were train infrastructure, public spending, and what this newfangled ‘3G’ could mean for the still relatively new ‘Internet’ on these ‘smartphones’ that Apple seems to be making. The UK today has discussions such as what it means to be British and what the role of history plays in that, the value of its own institutions, and whether it is better to be weak yet independent in hatred while clinging to a dead ideal of imperial glory, or a cog in a machine designed to grind profits out of a populace who can then blame their suffering on brown people and PC gone mad. Miliband doesn’t answer these questions — it was never designed to. Miliband will answer questions like “how can we improve public transportation such that the current rail contract distribution may be more efficient?”, “how can we cultivate an image of Britain as a digital global hub?”, or even “what electoral system might be best such that citizens’ votes are properly reflected in government?”, but it cannot answer any of these questions without the axioms of a British identity that is stable, a faith in institutions that is relatively unquestioned, and an acceptance of neoliberal capitalist hegemony in the post-Soviet world that can be simply cosied up at the edges. As 2020 approaches, none of these things are really acceptable to just take for granted any more.</p><p>The reason that this writer suspects Miliband will only grow stronger, not finally die, from this fundamental error at the very root of its ideas, its methods and its conflicts, is precisely because if you accept them, you don’t have to realise a problem. If British identity is stable can be taken as axiomatic, then we don’t need to worry or even think about the surge of hate crimes in recent years or the active courting of fascists by the party that has been in power for the past decade and set to continue likely for another decade. If British institutions are held in strong faith as axiomatic, then we don’t need to question the inevitable economic and political fallout that comes from slicing off the past 50 years of economic integration nor the clear demands from young people for a set of new institutions that can resolve concerns regarding the climate, their careers, and housing, that no party even wants to consider solving for it being “too unrealistic”. If neoliberal capitalism is hegemonic and that’s just the way of the world, then there is no future to grapple for, there is no better state that we can strive for — there are only modifications, alterations and bug fixes upon a fundamentally Tory society.</p><p>Miliband is reassuring because if you can just ignore these crises that rock the UK’s political foundations to their very core and threaten to actively destroy the United Kingdom as both United or as Kingdom, then you are spared from the anxiety of realising firstly that Miliband is dead, and secondly, the future is struggling to be born and the powerful are willing for it to be stillborn. Rather than praise the birth of new life and herald the coming of change, Miliband praises an ideal of change that the corpse it holds once promised them and spits in the face of the future trying to formulate in front of it.</p><p>It is unclear if the crises of UK identity will result in actual fallout or, like some modern Crisis of the Third Century, Westminster will drag itself on until someone finally puts it out of its misery. Regardless, until that day happens, Miliband will be there the entire way promising change to the homeless and then asking them for change for a fiver, promising it’ll sort this climate mess out in a year or two when the timing’s right. Miliband will fix everything, but not too fast or too dramatic — that would be far too much. Miliband will kill you for its own idea of the greater good but it will send you a polite note of apology for the inconvenience beforehand. If you want any more than that, well, you just don’t understand how the real world works, do you?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=322dd77a2ae7" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-people/the-death-of-the-british-centre-322dd77a2ae7">The death of the British centre</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-people">The People</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nature and Society]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/the-people/nature-and-society-2263ce043293?source=rss-fc86998d7fdb------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2263ce043293</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-people]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Iain Clowes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 16 Dec 2019 12:01:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-12-16T12:01:02.115Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ACk7N3HM8F1H_TlO.jpg" /></figure><h4><strong>Duality</strong></h4><p>The word “nature” is a fairly messy term, in large part because of its relativity. I grew up in a rural area, so I consider nature to be forests but not fields, because those are more akin to an asset. On the other hand,friends of mine from urban backgrounds disagree and see them very much as nature. The key reason for this messiness is that nature is defined not by what it is but by what it is not. Nature is “not society”, the other side of that coin — all things are either in nature or society but they cannot be neither. Insofar as “society” is a vague term, nature as “not society” will be too.</p><p>This dichotomy is an intuitive one. We are all familiar with and probably have experienced common desires like retiring to a cottage, living on a farm, running away into the woods, and so forth — these are methods of escaping society which are achieved by entering society’s opposite in nature. However, the messiness of these terms reveals a crucial element of our understanding of these two things — this declaration, this creation of a society-nature binary — is not real in the sense that it cannot be tracked to some atomistic level. The distinction between what is natural and what is social is entirely arbitrary and has no fixed basis at all, instead being found solely in one’s interpretation thereof.</p><p>This dichotomy constructed as such also reveals certain characteristics of how we communicate on other topics. The humanities, as a set of fields, broadly seek to understand society, whereas what we consider the sciences seek to understand nature. This can somewhat explain why there is a great degree of contempt held for the humanities, while STEM is held in fairly high regard. Nature is “more unknown” and therefore more intimidating to approach; hence, the study of it and attempts to understand it are more impressive.</p><p>It is important that we recognise that nature is deeper than appearances. It isn’t just woodlands and fields, things we typically associate with the word “nature”. Biology would qualify as nature, even though biology is literally inside of us as the mechanisms that keep us alive. The universe is nature, but we haven’t actually observed most of it. Our unconscious minds are nature, even though by definition they cannot be directly observed.</p><h4><strong>Horror</strong></h4><p>Nature holds and inspires fear in us because of this — Nature is unknown. Paraphrasing a certain 20th century author whose racial beliefs are too questionable to warrant naming, the greatest fear is fear of the unknown. The fear of the unknown aspects of Nature therefore command both respect, out of recognition of the power it may hold over us, as well as derision, out of a desire to suppress this fear and assert our supremacy as masters of the universe. While the interpretation of the character of Nature can vary (some seeing it as pure and untainted, some seeing it as spiritual and ethereal, some seeing it as messy and backward), these interpretations are usually determined by how a given society has interpreted its own existence in relation to Nature. Nature being unknown and therefore fear-inspiring is true in all cases, however, so either respecting Nature or holding it in derision will be true regardless of the character of the society viewing it.</p><p>Due to its unknown character, Nature is rather uncomfortable to deal with and generally unpleasant because it reflects life as a whole — namely, that the universe is mostly apathetic to our problems. This is not to say that life is all suffering, because suffering implies intent or direction from some cruel torturer figure. Life is not rigged in this way to cause suffering either deliberately or even inadvertently — it just doesn’t care. This indifference is confusing because it alienates us from our very understanding of it and has seemingly no motive or actor, making it difficult to track mechanisms or make any sense of it at all. To this end, we flee — we seek any and all methods necessary to understand and in doing so, feel safe and comforted against the benign hostility of Nature against us. Individually, no single person can reasonably attempt to control their destiny while seemingly held captive by Nature. With “fight” therefore no longer a viable option, they are left with either doing nothing — a guaranteed method for failure — or “flight”, which we can see in the formation of networks of solidarity.</p><h4><strong>Creation</strong></h4><p>This fear of Nature — motivated by seemingly random suffering perpetrated by Nature — is escaped from through Society, and now we see the reason why this “Nature v Society” dichotomy exists. Society gives us many things — love, family, nation, ideology, class, work, and so forth. These elements help to constitute our identity both as individuals and as participants in wider Society, but also as a group member within specific identities (religion, nationality, political beliefs, etc) <em>and </em>as part of the wider whole. Cumulatively, these factors act as a barrier against the force that is Nature by providing networks of solidarity by which it can somewhat be overcome and tamed, further reinforcing the Nature-Society dichotomy’s very existence.</p><p>This declaration and formation of identity through the construction of Society is, ultimately, somewhat disingenuous or fabricated. Society isn’t real or fixed; it is merely declared to be real. Some may point to a biological predisposition for humans to form societies, as we are social animals, but this doesn’t change the key truth that Society exists because we declare that it exists. Because of this, Nature will inevitably “seep in” into the environments we inhabit our networks of solidarity in and make its presence known once again, because it is the state of a physical reality whether we like it or not, whereas Society is simply what we have declared to be real in opposition to this. as a result, the manner in which we conceptualize and consequently execute society is grounded in, stems from, and is motivated by what we’re opposing from and within Nature and how we conceptualise Society in its ideal form, i.e. ideology. It should be noted that doing so is not a lie or somehow innately false, for it is formed by sincere belief which in turn makes it real as far as we’re concerned — a social construct is still constructed and therefore real.</p><h4><strong>Resist</strong></h4><p>While Nature <em>qua </em>physical conditions moving independently of ourselves may certainly penetrate into Society, ideas of how Society is or should be — also known as ideology — help us to dispel the horror as the unavoidable fear encroaches further via the networks of solidarity aforementioned. Over time, however, these collective ideals of Society will run dry, as ideology are philosophical texts written in a certain time and context for that time — the world will change as solutions to a bygone time become increasingly irrelevant. They will no longer provide reassurances to us against our fears, in a manner not unlike how our childhood toys, once more reassuring than any other, will eventually lose their meaning and just be a toy.</p><p>Historically, we have fled backwards at this point. When an ideology runs dry and loses its potency to resist, a different ideology is brought in, which may genuinely alter the face of Nature and provide new reassurances. This does not, however, resist the benign cruelty of Nature’s inevitable reemergence. Over time, these conditions are no longer sufficient; Nature creeps back in, leading to either reform to establish either new, stronger conditions, or instead conflict. In the latter case, Nature is unleashed for a short period until a new ideology takes hold, where participants of the new Society agree that Nature was horrifying and should never be unleashed again, and so new conditions are established to push against it. The cycle repeats, we continue onward in a path of war and violence, such as seen in the Russian civil war or in the collapse of Austria-Hungary.</p><h4><strong>Alien</strong></h4><p>It should be clarified here that a perceived need to strip Society back to being indistinguishable from Nature is cruel and immoral — after all, Society’s protection remains valuable and not all people are able to withstand Nature. Morally, these vulnerable individuals should not be ignored nor neglected by the rest of us. It would certainly seem, however, that no ideology which is able to keep itself alive forever exists, or even can exist, because endless energy from both its participants, its authors, and its advocates is required to do so. Nature cannot be resisted forever, and people will eventually replace a tool that doesn’t do its job properly.It is also true that some ideologies resist not only Nature but also Society, so long as they are not the ideology in power in that Society and are trying to dislodge that which is (such as Marxist resistance to capitalist structures). However, whether or not one aligns in the same direction of resistance as these forces is optional, often depending on whether the potential participant in question feels that they are engaging in meaningful resistance or simply meaningless acts of politics.</p><p>Ideologies, therefore, are not tied to Nature through any aspect because of their Nature-defying character.We have only one true connection with Nature as this force of pure alienation we fear so greatly, and that is the knowledge of our own existence. Rooted in Nature, it is still opposed to Nature but it is not part of Society. It is not social either. This is because Society is part of an external reality, Society is outside of our own self, so we cannot be sure of its ultimate validity — it lies indistinguishable to us in much the same way we are uncertain of the validity of a dream even upon realising we are dreaming, for it feels too real to ignore yet beyond proof. We give the benefit of the doubt in most cases, but all we can truly say with certainty is that there is some mechanism that makes us feel something that seems to be what we call our body, even if what we feel isn’t really there at all.</p><p>Because of this uncertainty over the validity of all that is external to us, we must see things external to us as what they are — ideas, dreams. Much like how we reject being held hostage by Nature, we must in turn reject being held hostage by these ideas and dreams — “I” must come above all other concepts. “I” is the one thing we are to be sure of, in much the same way that we are sure of our own selves being safe as opposed to the hostility of the external world of Nature pre-Society. In order to do this, we must therefore hold these ideas and dreams in absolute contempt at all times, for this is the one power that “I”, an individual uncertain of the outside world’s character or existence, cannot lose — an ability that can never be taken from “me”. Ideology, as part of these ideas and dreams, must be destroyed at all times so as to ensure that new ones can flourish.</p><h4>Contempt</h4><p>Nature acts as an omnipresent threat to Society as it, to some degree, is the threat of material degradation, of entropy, of the inevitable collapse and death of things. It reminds us of our mortality, it reminds us of the temporariness of all things, it reminds us of how fragile our life is. To find a method by which we can resist Society, as discussed previously, but not have to somehow become comfortable with the intrinsically alienating force that is Nature — something I would contend is a project that is doomed from its very conception — there would appear to be only one option. Resistance against Society must be coordinated so as to be in the same direction as that of Nature.</p><p>Nature, as a force that has no meaning at all from cold indifference, paradoxically holds the greatest meaning of all due to it being the most unstoppable omnipresent force that could possibly contend with the seemingly unstoppable omnipresent force that can be found in ideology. Through this, the only way that we can embrace the alienation of Nature and solve this perpetual dilemma of fear, violence, destruction, and existential terror is to alienate against Society <em>qua </em>ideology in a direction of purpose that is unique only to oneself.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2263ce043293" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/the-people/nature-and-society-2263ce043293">Nature and Society</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/the-people">The People</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>