<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ian Blair on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ian Blair on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ian.blair?source=rss-d338ec52c9d5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 08:51:48 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ian.blair/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why We Should All be Against Bitcoin (no, really)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ian.blair/why-we-should-all-be-against-bitcoin-no-really-1f3c3e78b62f?source=rss-d338ec52c9d5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1f3c3e78b62f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Blair]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Jan 2018 18:45:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-30T18:04:27.266Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*xY0EJdPgTL55ElJtfs1U-w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Like most populist ideas, the origin story of cryptocurrency is noble and pure. In the beginning, there was Satoshi Nakamoto, and there were sinister banks and governments dragging the people into financial crisis. Nakamoto wanted the people to throw off their fiat currency shackles and live free. And in 2009 he made Bitcoin from nothing, and it was good.</p><p>The early adopters wanted to use bitcoins for daily commerce. Unfortunately, most of what they were actually buying was drugs, as few merchants were accepting bitcoin. (For those unfamiliar, check out Wired’s account of the <a href="https://www.wired.com/2015/04/silk-road-1/">saga of Silk Road — great read</a>.)</p><p>But now in 2018, we have turned the corner, and the headlines tell us that Bitcoin and its cousins have arrived and are ready for the mainstream. We are ready to buy furniture on overstock.com, xBox games from Microsoft, or pay small businesses via Intuit. There’s just one problem — relative to the hype, nobody is spending them.</p><p>Instead, backers claim, cryptocurrencies have evolved into an “asset class” that is (a) secure (b) scarce and (c) broadly accepted. And the prices have risen. To such unimaginable heights. And they shall double and treble and quintuple further… until fiat currency bows down before crypto and we all forget — that once upon a time we used quaint paper money issued by countries. And that’s exactly why you should be rooting against bitcoin and the rest.</p><h3>The Crypto Hype Machine</h3><p>In my first job as a financial analyst I was assigned an odd fund that had a perpetual track record of ascent — Lancer Group. It held some very small, thinly-traded public companies and I often think of it when I read about cryptocurrencies.</p><p>Every quarter the fund’s managers would mark-to-market on their holdings’ then-current prices, and everyone was happy. Until the redemptions started and the founder couldn’t quite produce the cash. Much of the revenue from one of the fund’s companies came from trade deals with a captive entity, ominously named the Alpha Omega Corp. The company’s South Florida “headquarters” was a terracotta-roofed Mediterranean next to a golf course, along with 3 related companies. The odd HQ led us to more suspicious stock transactions right before the big fund’s valuation day, work which the SEC later incorporated into their indictment. The information was public all along, but nobody thought to look until the wheels came off.</p><p>Indeed, the earnestness of many cryptocurrency advocates is nothing like those pump-and-dump scammers. (<a href="http://www.businessinsider.com/how-traders-pump-and-dump-cryptocurrencies-2017-11">That said, there is a lively cottage industry developing to pump small cryptocurrencies</a>) But there is one key similarity: <strong>the numbers that get tracked are the <em>price </em>of the thing, not the <em>use </em>of the thing</strong>. That’s what always gets lost. Not repeat customers and their spending, but stickiness and stock price. Not real estate rents or costs, but market comps. “But look at the prices! Clearly someone knows something I don’t!” Just because someone is selling tickets to see a perpetual motion machine doesn’t mean it works.</p><p>Recall— the root of the mythos of cryptocurrencies is that they will someday be USED. Their values are being compared to pools of national fiat currency because the supposition is that someday they will supplant the dollar, the euro etc. In no less than 5 articles I’ve read, a reasonable value for Bitcoin of over $100,000 is based on the fact that it would STILL just be in the single digit percentages of global circulating currency.</p><p>Totes reasonable.</p><p>Did you know that the volume of bitcoin alone sent each day (press time: Jan 5 2018) is hovering around $40 billion USD? It certainly seems like folks are using it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UK3bn84KB9ejSACBmjmiow.jpeg" /></figure><p>But what exactly is exchanged to the tune of $14 Trillion per year? Overstock.com is often cited as an early adopter of bitcoin and a place to use it for purchases. Conveniently a Nasdaq listed public company, Overstock takes investor questions including this gem about bitcoin sales last fall:</p><blockquote>Overstock.com CEO Patrick Byrne: “We have seen a material change, in part because of everything in the news it spiked and then [bitcoin purchases] settled back down to about $50,000 per week.”</blockquote><p>$50,000 per week!! Surely it’s higher now than the $2.6 Million/year since Bitcoin has hit fever pitch! I also imagine that international crypto remittances have increased instead of Western Union (a $26 Billion/year market). And there are a dozen other small buckets we can bail into the gaping void of daily cryptocurrency volume.</p><p><strong>But repeat the number back to yourself: $14 trillion a year — the entire annual GDP of China is $12 Trillion. Do you see $14 Trillion that just recently went missing from conventional trade?</strong></p><p>I’m not even trying to make a case that the inherent value of Bitcoin is irrational. But it is relevant when the world starts pumping billions of dollars of savings into this system because of its potential… Because it’s different this time, because the blockchain is can’t be corrupted, because of distributed trust and thousands of validation nodes, because … reasons.</p><p><strong>The font is larger but it’s the same story. As Texans like to say, this is a case of all hat and no cattle — it’s just speculation.</strong> While use may be increasing, rabid greed is the only animal spirit driving the price. And in the spirit of those South Florida slimers, there’s a great reason why nobody wants to rock the boat — they’re getting rich.</p><h3>There Can Be Only Some</h3><p><em>“All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.”<br>-Orwell, Animal Farm</em></p><p>I know I’m inviting derision with this article. Anyone who has profited from cryptocurrencies can lord their expertise. I’m not saying speculation for fun and profit is bad. Just please don’t “invest” or heaven forbid, borrow to invest — unless you plan to moonlight as a trader and glue your face to a screen.</p><p>But back to creation myths: Cryptocurrency is good because it is (a) secure (b) scarce and (c) broadly accepted by virtue of adoption. For this article, I have no interest in addressing (a) because in general the blockchain seems worthwhile. There will be thefts at weak points (wallets, storage), but don’t count on them being reported (Google “MtGox Timeline”).</p><p>But (b)— this horseshit about a constrained supply? <a href="http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2018/01/02/why-bitcoin-is-stupid/">Here’s a good frame that puts this in perspective:</a></p><blockquote>… imagine that someone had found a cure for cancer and posted the step-by-step instructions on how to make it on-line, freely available for anyone to use. Now imagine that the same person also created a product called “Cancer-Pill” using their own instructions, trademarked it, and started selling it to the highest bidders.</blockquote><blockquote>I think we can all agree a cure for cancer is immensely valuable to society (blockchain may or may not be, we still have to see), however, how much is a Cancer-Pill worth?</blockquote><p>.. especially when there are (Jan 2018) over 1,300 other variants of Cancer-Pill, each with a different logo, ticker and fun distinctive quirk. For example, did you know there’s a SexCoin? From its website: “The SexCoin development team is committed to make a coin BY the adult industry FOR the adult industry.” And who stands to benefit the most from the adult industry adopting their standard? The creators of SexCoin, who hold the plurality of the coins and at the lowest cost.</p><p>For a more eye-popping example, check out Ripple, where the company that created and administers the coin still holds over half of the supply that ever will be (Jan 5th, 2018: currently priced at more than $50 billion.) It’s impossible to know for sure, my estimate is that founders/insiders usually hold about 20% of their coins, usually at basis costs approaching 0.</p><p><a href="https://coinmarketcap.com/all/views/all/">A good full list of the current offering, including Byteball Bytes, Viberate, SexCoin and DeepOnion (!?) can be found at coinmarketcap.com</a> — most are valued at 8 figures and above, which should disabuse you of any notions of scarcity. <strong>In fact — today — there is a near-infinite supply of cryptocurrency that smarmily awaits your trust and savings</strong>.</p><h3>Appreciating Volatile Currency: Financial Frenemy</h3><p>And (c): adoption. Assuming Bitcoin and the rest continue to rise in price, most people will be happy — their saving is rewarded. But that tendency to rise has a cost; because transaction fees are denominated in each respective crypto, they become more expensive to spend. Crypto fans scoff at fiat currency for its near-certain inflation, but what would happen if all money didn’t inflate, but just rose ever upward?</p><p>The velocity of money would screw us all. Put another way, if the public is less likely to spend money, the money multiplier decreases (how many times a new dollar or yen changes hands in a given time period) and trade slows down. If I hoard my bitcoin and don’t buy a lemonade from my neighbor’s stand, he is slower to buy sugar and glasses. The grocery owner reorders these goods less often, etc.. If there’s one thing that’s worse than a inflationary currency, it’s a deflating economy.</p><p>Wasn’t this whole story about making sending money to people you don’t know easier, faster and cheaper?</p><p>Widespread adoption of cryptocurrencies in their current format could be the economic equivalent of bariatric surgery, limiting appetite for consumption, in favor of an economically inert asset that creates few jobs. Even the wealth effect would only favor the few who have meaningful gains.</p><p>And as the icing on the cake, because of the price appreciation structure and the early founder stakes, <strong>capital participating in the crypto economy would flow disproportionately to those few who create the currency instruments, just as Satoshi Nakamoto intended.</strong></p><p>Oh wait. No, nevermind that last bit.</p><h3>Blockchains are Forever (TM)</h3><p>There is a counterargument as to why currency issues don’t matter: <strong>crypto is digital gold. </strong>And, if the physical yellow metal can be worth $7 Trillion or so, why can’t its digital cousin? After all, producers mine it at great effort (electricity).</p><p>Gold is an element with a true limited supply on earth — born of the deaths of ancient stars, bedeviling alchemists for centuries. Diamonds, on the other hand, are made of carbon, which is everywhere. The myth surrounding diamonds is that they are amazingly rare and only forged naturally over billions of years. <a href="https://www.brilliantearth.com/news/how-lab-created-diamonds-are-made/">The truth surrounding diamonds is that they can be grown in labs using (surprise!) huge amounts of energy in about 28 days</a>.</p><p>And the gap between the myth and the truth: marketing. As extensively documented on <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Beers">Wikipedia</a> and <a href="https://are.berkeley.edu/~sberto/debers.pdf">elsewhere</a>, De Beers and other diamond producers manipulated supply and propped up demand, most notably with their marketing campaign: <em>a diamond is forever.</em></p><p>One of the big selling points of cryptocurrencies is that they are “fungible”, or all exactly equivalent and therefore equally useful as a store of value. So the bitcoin mined today in a computer lab is exactly as valuable as the first 50 bitcoins ever mined by Satoshi Natakmoto. There is no “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hope_Diamond">Hope Bitcoin</a>.”</p><p>So why wouldn’t the latest new cryptocurrency have just as much use as a store of value as the original?</p><p>The only real argument is that the new ones aren’t broadly accepted. Well, folks, we have definitely passed that threshold as shown in this chart of the market for all cryptos:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fd-aJt9-U2Pvhls9a1PD2Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>The large area is Bitcoin’s share of value of all the cryptocurrency values. With 1300 clamoring entrants to the field, bitcoin seems to be less appealing to store that value lately. Blessed is the mania though; the pie has grown and obscured the wholesale abandonment of Bitcoin for newer entrants.</p><p>In the medium- and longer-term, eventually all the money that wants to be stored in cryptos will arrive, and equilibrium will return. If you saw that market share for Coke or Microsoft or Amazon, would you hold patiently? <strong>Thanks to the open-source environment, there is literally zero chance that shiny new things with lower costs won’t compete for digital money demand. And why wouldn’t they? The reward for establishing a new digital asset is in the billions of dollars.</strong></p><p>Unlike Coke or Microsoft (or really DeBeers and the diamond cartel), there is no single entity or group that will be organized enough to control distribution or mount a marketing campaign to support the price for a commodity with infinite supply. For now, we have a salivating press and good price momentum, but eventually <strong>new entrants will soak up demand, the tide will wash out and the price wont just fall. It will ugly fall.</strong></p><h3>The Solution that Nobody is Begging For</h3><p>I am no blockchain hater. I think a lot of good can come from the technology, but the coins are answers to a question (relative to value), nobody is asking.</p><p>If I’m wrong, and it’s not just speculators and flush founders, there should be a glaring example in the world of everyday people who find salvation in Bitcoin.</p><p>If ANYONE needs cryptocurrency, it’s the Venezuelans. Their national currency is hyperinflating and access to US dollars and other foreign currency is highly restricted to the point of crisis. Indeed, there’s evidence of a huge uptick in use: <em>“weekly bitcoin trading volume through one popular website has soared from about $US225,000 earlier this year to nearly $US2.1 million in the first week of December.” [</em><a href="http://www.news.com.au/technology/online/venezuelans-seeing-bitcoin-boom-as-survival-not-speculation/news-story/b4ee91a802ed265a237699aa2ed4dd44"><em>Link: news.com.au</em></a><em>]</em></p><p>Having been to Venezuela, and changed USD on the black market, I can understand the appeal of not having to meet a moneychanger in a half-abandoned night market. So of course, I found another quote in the article relevant:</p><blockquote>Even as the use of bitcoin becomes more prevalent, few businesses openly advertise that they accept cryptocurrency out of concern they will be extorted. It’s still difficult to make many purchases in Venezuela with bitcoin, so people have to convert it into bolivars to buy food and other items.</blockquote><p>So, they still have to reconvert and spend bolivars? Seems like a shitty last resort to hang on to savings.</p><p>And again do the math — <strong>even after the surge in December, 31 million Venezuelans were exchanging around $2.1 million per week in cryptocurrency. That’s $0.07 per person per week, or $7 per person per week at 1% adoption.</strong> Oh, and it includes the speculators who were lucky enough to keep US dollars around before hyperinflation took off.</p><h3>What We Really Need</h3><p>Truth be told, I’m annoyed it feels necessary to write this all down. Capitalism, especially tech-driven capitalism is sloppy, and it depends on perverse incentives to make breakthroughs. Something good will come of all this froth, but in the meantime a staggering amount of human effort and electricity is going to waste.</p><p>Shortly after I publish this, I’m sure a new world’s richest person will be crowned by cryptocurrency. It’s just sad — he won’t have invented the cure for cancer or solved our world’s environmental issues, but did convince around a million people to “invest.”</p><p>Why should any private individual or group own the monetary system? Let’s just move on to Crypto 2.0 where we don’t have to suffer a rigged game. If ever there was a time with a call for a true public good, it is currency. Owned by the people, for their use, without the 20% haircut to founders.</p><p>On that path, I think the answer should be “DollarCoin”, <a href="https://blog.chain.com/why-central-banks-will-issue-digital-currency-5fd9c1d3d8a2">detailed in a great, if nerdy speech given by Adam Ludwig of Chain</a> to the Federal Reserve in Summer 2016:</p><blockquote>A better model, ultimately, is central bank digital currency. This would mean that a central bank, like the Federal Reserve, would participate on the network and would digitally mint U.S. dollars onto it. Since the Fed is the legal issuer of dollars, this would make digital dollars a native digital asset. There would be no need to “convert” back to some underlying “real” dollar because these digital dollars would be real, just in a new medium. In the same way that dollars already exist today in multiple mediums — notes, coins, electronic reserves — we would treat these digital dollars as just dollars in a new medium, backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government.</blockquote><p>He is specifically referring to credit creation via commercial paper, but since that depends on holding trust in the issuer (i.e. a cryptocurrency creator), the bright line to current cryptos is clear.</p><p><strong>Rather than make a new currency, let’s just upgrade an existing one. Have the Fed create DollarCoin and the public could realize the benefits of the Blockchain at a relatively stable value without paying homage to its promoters.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1f3c3e78b62f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>