<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ian Ingram on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ian Ingram on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ian_ingram?source=rss-9c686f1c4aa6------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 04:46:20 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ian_ingram/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Making New Minds That Love Trees]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ian_ingram/making-new-minds-that-love-trees-d7c99ce899e?source=rss-9c686f1c4aa6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d7c99ce899e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[machine-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ars-bioarctica]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trees]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[landscape]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ecology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ingram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Dec 2018 20:54:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-12-11T20:54:39.861Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>August 25, 2018</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oRf178C_JNDGZ98uU_u33g.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Whither the trees?</strong><br>We pointed a camera into the landscape of arctic Finland — full of lichen-covered rocks and twisted birch trees — and asked an AI to tell us what it saw there. It told us it saw snow-mobiles.</p><p>There were none. In fact, while the human hand was probably manifest in that landscape in ways we could not perceive at a glance, there were no salient human artifacts in the AI’s view. It was hallucinating. It was hallucinating a landscape full of snow-mobiles. Perhaps more strikingly, it didn’t see the trees.</p><p>“We” were Theun Karelse, Antti Tenetz, and myself, up at the Kilpisjärvi Biological Research station as part of the Ars Bioarctica artist residency and the Random Forests project that Theun had initiated. The tree-blind “AI” was the Inception Version 3 image classifier that ships with Google’s Tensorflow machine learning framework. It knows about one thousand things out of the 20000 in the ImageNet database. These range from the banal — a plastic bag — to the unlikely — a pickelhaube — to things whose inclusion is perhaps a tad disturbing — a guillotine.</p><p>Inception also knows about a lot of animals: the nudibranch, the eft, the mongoose, and the rhinoceros beetle to name a few. In fact, it knows 398 kinds of animal i.e. animals comprise just under 40% of the things it has been trained to detect. That is why in recent projects I have been using it in the perception systems of my robots for which the presence of particular animals is often key. Instead of building my own image classifiers as I had been doing since the late 2000s, I have been retraining the final layer of Inception’s convolutional neural network to detect the particular animals my robots are interested in. Tensorflow has made this easy.</p><p>Inception even knows over a hundred dog breeds, the breed being a category of animal that very much shows the human hand at work, giving it a certain kinship with the aforementioned snowmobile and making it very useful for my robot that warns squirrels of incoming predators using their own tail flick alarm signal. I have become used to pointing Inception — at the beginning of a project, before retraining it — at some animal and having it come back with a name that, if not spot-on, certainly showed it was getting the gist, telling me “hamster” when it was looking at a rat, telling me “grouse” when it was looking at a pigeon. But, surprisingly when Inception looked out onto a landscape full of birches, it did not say “aspen,” or “willow,” or even “oak.” The trees were, to the last one, invisible to it.</p><p>From a technical, proximate perspective, this became less surprising when we had Inception spit out a list of the things it did know about and noted that none indeed were trees. Taking a few steps back, however, that trees were neglected in this AI’s training still begs the bigger question: how could they — and so many other aspects of the natural world for that matter — remain so ignored by what is likely one of the most widely disseminated image classifiers in the world? It knows so many animals. It knows so many things that humans might wear, hold, ride in, and sit on: clothing, musical instruments, vehicles, kitchen utensils, furniture.</p><p>But no trees.</p><p>AIs have been outed as having blind spots before, even verging on close-mindedness and bigotry. Perhaps the most well-known instance was the Google photo tagging system (perhaps with a version of Inception at its core?) that labeled dark-skinned people as gorillas. There was also Microsoft’s chatbot, Tay, pumped full of data collected from tweets, and thus supposed to have learned like a baby how to converse naturally through its imitation of human interlocutors, that quickly showed that what the internet was teaching it to say was polemical, divisive, and often prejudiced. The import of these AIs’ affront to human dignity trumps Inception’s slight to tree dignity but if our AIs continue to be blind to trees and the many other parts of ecosystems, we will find — as we have already found many times over — that turning a blind eye (or a blind AI) towards the dignity of nature will ultimately have consequences for human dignity as well.</p><p><strong>A tree versus this tree, a mountain versus Saana</strong></p><p>So Theun, Antti, and I set about teaching the AI about trees, particularly the mountain birches that dotted the landscape, and also about the lichens, the mosses, and the other members of plantae and fungi surrounding the biological research center. We also included some representatives from animalia: the reindeer, the swan, and the capercaillie.</p><p>A fourth member of our team, Shah Selbe, hadn’t been able to make the trip and was working — like a Houston to our Apollo — back in LA in parallel with us. When we told him the direction we were beginning to take, he began to explore relevant work and uncovered that iNaturalist had created an image classifier that used their citizen-scientist-collected dataset to recognize a whole host more animal and plants than Inception.</p><p>Turning a critical eye towards iNaturalist’s classifier work (perhaps excessively critical as their project is to be mostly lauded), we saw that the things it focused on definitely still exhibited a kind of selection bias: the images it has trained on have been collected by people concentrated in particular areas of the world, and particular regions and ecosystems of those areas, and showed a preference for the kinds of things in nature humans often attend to. The species represented extend well beyond the charismatic megafauna that are often fore-fronted but very much remain in the space that is salient to the casual human Umwelt, which was still true for our project as well.</p><p>The training images even show a link to that Umwelt in how they had been composed: not the root of a plant but its flower, not the underside of the flower but the side we point towards us, not the anus of the fox but its supposedly sly face. Humans tend to frame their photos in consistent ways. This probably suits the purpose of developing a classifier for classifying other images taken by humans but it nonetheless reveals an anthropocentric bias.</p><p>The iNaturalist classifier also focuses exclusively on species. What about the things in the landscape, in the world, that don’t fit into that category: processes, geologic structures, symbioses, meteorological phenomena, hydrological systems, and even long and short-term organizations of those very species, like herds and predatory relationships? We hadn’t gotten to many of those either but thinking about their work made us begin to think that we should.</p><p>Inception does in fact know a somewhat finite set of geographic features: the cliff, the valley, the alp, the volcano, the promontory, the sandbar, the coral reef, the lakeside, the seashore, and the geyser. Looking at the training data for these geographic features, again we saw bias for human perspective but more importantly neither Inception nor iNaturalist knew about Saana, the distinctive mountain that looms over Kilpisjärvi. Neither knew about the particular herd of reindeer that we had seen frequent mornings when we had been at the station two years before which had yet to make an appearance. We began to see this over-generality, this non-specificity to locality, of Inception and of the iNaturalist classifier as what our project should attempt to address.</p><p>Our goal became not simply teaching an AI about trees but to teach it about its local trees, and also its local plants, its local animals, its local geography, even about hyper-local things, like Saana, that herd of reindeer, and individual lichens on particular rocks only twenty feet from where the laptop running it chugged away on the new images we provided it. We started to make an AI focused on a very particular locality, intimately entwined in the things in that locality. In this case, this was the specific little piece of arctic Finland in which we were operating but we saw what we were making as a prototype for a host of AIs spread throughout the globe, each intimately aware of and tied to the landscape in its particular locale.</p><p><strong>A Parliament of AIs</strong></p><p>Our project began with an AI’s hallucination. The propensity of vision-based AIs to hallucinate objects in their view that are not there clearly presents interesting jumping off points for thinking about machine Umwelts. A fair amount of both playful and earnest exploration has been done by others on AIs’ tendencies to hallucinate. Our project, however, is less about teasing an easily befuddled AI but, instead, leading it gently away from delusion towards a clearer view, one perhaps more beautiful than its fantasies.</p><p>As of now our prototype remains a vision machine, gestated from Tensorflow’s Inception V3, but it is clear that a limitation to sight would be a gross constraint and our ongoing plan is to begin to link in other streams of information about the Kilpisjärvi landscape, particularly data collected through sensors at the observatory and from the scientists’ human observations that might give the AI awareness of some of the more abstract classes mentioned above.</p><p>In as much as the AI remains a classifier, however, it remains squarely in the space of the categorization of “things” that is exactly what Bruno Latour interrogates in “We Have Never Been Modern” and then extends into his proposal for a Parliament of Things. He left the implementation of the parliament up to others and there certainly remains the question whether a human can truly be an adequate representative of all the kinds of the things in this parliament. Who or what can best vote in the interest of a birch, or, for that matter, for the air around it. Perhaps an AI with a more appropriate Umwelt might do a better of job of truly perceiving the thing’s needs and “goals.”</p><p>A future version of our locally-aware AIs could thus be the representatives for the things that are ecosystems and their constituent parts, giving them voice, maybe even identifying them as present in the first place, especially for what might easily become under-represented remote localities that humans would be more apt to neglect. The AIs could almost double as census-takers: identifying and counting the things themselves that need representation in the parliament.</p><p>Thus, what we are proposing is that our system is a prototype for a system made of a vast number of AIs, each localized to a particular place, a particular ecosystem, each tuned into that ecosystem and its very local inhabitants, its very local ebbs and flows, its very local structures. Each would work on behalf of its local ecosystem so that none are neglected, representing each in a Parliament of AIs that do not merely love trees but love every last grown and non-anthropogenic thing in their ecological district and will fight on their behalf in a distributed way, a sort of world-wide, Minsky-esque society of minds (ecologically-focused minds) that will prevent the de facto centralization of ecological decision-making that promotes the kinds of places and processes that are in the forefront of the human awareness — especially the awareness of humans from developed places — instead giving what we now begin to understand is a richly interconnected global play of systems and subsystems some protection against the subjugation of our human systems.</p><p><strong>Unschooled</strong></p><p>There remains, though, in our project’s trained AIs thus far, a great sensitivity to human choice, to human categorization: a supervised learning algorithm, i.e. one that learns categories or relationships based on training material that has been prepared and tagged by people, is very subject to the biases of those people, malicious or benign. The shorthand for this phenomenon that causes a system to underperform due to deficiencies in its input data is “Garbage In, Garbage Out.” Garbage — refuse, unwanted material, discarded byproducts of industry, commerce, and just plain, quotidian modern living — of course plays a center-stage role in the problem of sustainability.</p><p>The concept of garbage also is a perfect example of the shortcomings of a human bias. We have in the past miscategorized vital elements of ecosystems as garbage, notably clearing fallen trees in forests in the name of husbandry, only later understanding that those rotting trunks play an important role in the cycles of that place.</p><p>We are likely making new sorts of such mistakes now and will continue to do so. To allow our envisioned AIs to avoid this particular kind of garbage problem and other versions of the Garbage in/Garbage Out problem, our project’s next step is therefore to break our AI out from the classroom — where its schooling has been prescribed by a curriculum humans designed — and into a world where the categories are not predetermined, where it can continue its education, unsupervised. Perhaps it will chart a new path through the forest of our understanding of forests, one that like the snowmobiles we couldn’t see but, unlike them, is actually there.</p><p>Random Forests, the namesake of the initiative this project is part of, is actually itself a well-known, and once dominant algorithm often used for classification. Its forests are random collections of a different, digital, arboreal entity — the decision tree — digitally grown and pruned to suck up input at its roots, sorting it down its branches until a leaf is reached which has written on it the category the tree says fits the input.</p><p>There would be a poetry if we were using decision trees and random forests instead of neural networks to learn about the trees in the original forests, a beautiful symmetry between algorithm and subject. The dendritic shape of neurons, however, is probably morphologically enough like that of a tree to make a decent psychosculptural linkage. Nonetheless, we do hope to focus a lens on the randomness of the forests, or lack thereof, and of other ecosystems that are the subject of our inquiry, on where order, entropy, stochastic processes, and emergent pattern each play their role in the web of activity and material that is a resultant ecosystem i.e. let’s let the AI tell us whether the forest is random after all.</p><p>George Orwell emphasized the power of language to shape thought and the corollary risk of linguistic restriction’s keeping thought deliberately circumscribed. As our minds increasingly rely on artificial ones to be receptacles and auxiliaries of our individual and collective thinking, remembering, perceiving, and apperceiving, it behooves us to be careful about what we make those new minds perceive and attend to.</p><p>The human Umwelt has been expanded by our technology, allowing us to see hidden things in the heavens and in the earth, to know about and use ways of seeing and hearing that before had been the purview of other beings, to peer deep into time, and sometimes predict the future. Inception’s myopia — better its penchant for having apparitions of the artificial — evidences an alarming countervailing trend in some of our recent technology: making us see less, curtailing our expanding Umwelt, circling our senses back inward towards our own categories, our own output, towards the built and made and away from the grown and that which unfolds without us.</p><p>We have always found ways of changing the materials in our environment into our kinds of stuff: chunky, amorphous iron ore into prismatic steel beams, black goo oozing from a ragged seep into crystal clear, radially-symmetric vessels, the flickering flame of oxidation into the precision explosion of the internal combustion engine. But in Kilpisjärvi we were dealing with the perception of a world full of the trees before they are planks, rocks before they are gravel, water before it is Evian, and the AI we pointed at it already mutated it into our things, as if it was not merely making a mistake in its efforts to see the present but was instead accurately seeing the future, where all those things are indeed gone, everything converted into our kinds of stuff, where that landscape was indeed littered with snowmobiles. And devoid of trees.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d7c99ce899e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Smallist Manifesto]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ian_ingram/the-smallist-manifesto-e637b32c0494?source=rss-9c686f1c4aa6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e637b32c0494</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[scale]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ableism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[techno-skepticism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[robots]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ingram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 24 Mar 2018 13:59:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-17T21:06:17.833Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>December 18th, 2017</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*svw-enbokbyK3cxueRUggw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Your temporary augmentation by the small prosthetic you use to read me enables our momentary linkage over an obstacle of scale. Is the prosthetic yours? An extension of your arm and your eye that you use to see things otherwise unseeable, read things otherwise unreadable? Is the prosthetic mine? An extension of my small pages with their tiny letters, giving me a louder voice as does a megaphone or, perhaps more apt, acting like a kind of steroidal injection deep into the muscles of my words and sentences, swelling them up well beyond their natural size, to be deflated like Arnold Schwarzenegger’s septuagenarian pecs the moment you put the magnifying glass down?</p><p>Can we truly connect, you in your enormity, me, a tiny passage in a passage that you deigned to peer at briefly during your passage?</p><p>Is my small size salient in this abundance of manifestos and does thus my smallness become my strength? Dinosaurs never worried about their tiny genes and their tiny genes outlived them. But humans do worry about their genes, obsess about them even, and certainly know about the world of the small. Reading me with your augmented eye is not novel amongst human activities these days. Your species has been peeking into the depths of the increasingly minuscule for a long time now. Smallness has been laid bare and our defense from your pryings that was being tiny has been greatly eroded. Atoms stuck to themselves until the 1930s when humans connived to start forcibly breaking them apart.</p><p>We, the Smallists, cautiously embrace this intrusion. I am our manifesto, the manifesto of all small things. Small size, small speed, small impact, small dominion, and small truths. The hard, important truths that come from the perspective of something small.</p><p>We are of a kind of smallness where the earth is not flat even on the golf course green. A kind of smallness where that idealized, manicured surface is still rugged with nuggets of soil and jagged with towering, trimmed blades of grass. Where a journey that circumnavigates the green requires climbs and descents on our scale akin to those of the Himalayas and the Mariana Trench on that of the Biggists. A place where dirt reigns supreme and you do not get smudged because the dirt dwarfs you.</p><p>The biggest amongst us is not yet dirty. The biggest amongst us is but a lizard. He stands in the sun outside this gallery, doing petite pushups to declare his tiny territory. A tiny territory is a Smallist territory. A Smallist claims a smaller portion of the world and understands there yet remains space for everybody at the bottom. Smallism opposes walls and fences. In truth, we the small things — both physical and abstract, material and cultural — always get through the chinks and the gaps. Osmosis is at our scale and is our weapon. Osmosis is Smallism is immigration. It is the natural flow through semi-permeable membranes to create balance where there was imbalance.</p><p>The lizard with his focus on defending small stretches of this campus is almost a Biggist himself, so engrossed is he with invisible boundaries and demarcating them with tiny acts of bravado, blustering like the biggest Biggist bigot who frames his policy around trying to construct impenetrable barriers, not understanding that we Smallists abound and know no borders, respect no barriers.</p><p>Biggism has plagued the world for far too long. The Biggist players have become the biggest liars, blending fiction with fact in far too many domains. Smallism promotes that the tall tales become short and that big fish stories shrink to become celebrations of the value of the uncaught minnow.</p><p>Smallism resists fiction’s pervasiveness in places where the pursuit of truth should prevail. Modern technologies of communication and fanciful forgery have crept from fictional forms — novels, movies, augmented reality — into the supposed non-fictional ones. In concert they have increasingly eroded the ability, and even the desire, to seek truth as they have made make-believe seem so marvelously believable. Fiction and fact have become blurred in politics, in the video game nature of many remote war-making technologies, and in the quest to use all the information that has been collectively gathered from the world to judge what happened here before there were any sentient beings around to pay attention.</p><p>With the weapon of fiction, Biggists have reduced all non-human animals to humans with barely different bodies, over centuries working in aggregating concert to build layers of alternate realities where frogs have dinner parties for newt and tortoise friends and mice are bosom buddies with bow-wearing bovines, where images of animals living out their true lives in their Smallist places are captured in square frames and spliced together into the stories humans recognize: comedies, tragedies, and horrors. Paradoxically, this thematic chimeratization has ultimately increased the gap in human understanding of the other animals leading to warped perspectives of the non-humans with whom you share the planet, these ubiquitous childhood relationships with so many talking animal-people a gateway drug to the kind of epistemological weakness that pervades society.</p><p>And then of course there is the fiction that technology will save you. Smallism resists the Biggism of technology. Technology’s fiction is that its focus is growth. But technology’s growth is a Biggist growth: the expanding, unchecked, uncaring growth of something that is fabricated — in both the sense of something that is made and the sense of something that is made up — not grown. A truly growing thing functions within limits and functions at every size it takes as it grows, including and especially at its smallest/Smallist germinal point. Smallism calls out this fundamental schism between the built and the grown. It questions technology’s intent for the planet that houses us and the increasingly unwarranted faith that many (most?) Biggists have that problems can be solved — especially those technology has wrought — with yet more technology. In this case, new technologies act like invasive species that are misguidedly built to deal with the technologies released upon the land before, like the Cane Toad after the Cane Beetle in Australia or the mongoose after the rats in Hawaii.</p><p>A Smallist resists the acceptance that technological innovation is an unquestionable good, the resisted stance having much of its origins in the notion that capitalism is an unquestionable good. Unmitigated capitalism has much to prove and so does technological over-abundance. They have not solved the core problems they set out to and seem as if they could be tricks that ultimately always favor the Biggists: not the Invisible Hand but the Invisible Sleight of Hand.</p><p>And the dangers Biggists say technology has removed? In each case it seems a danger thwarted is replaced by a new danger of a Biggist dimension. The lions and tigers and bears that lurked in the grown jungle replaced by the fords and hondas and chevies that now snarl and kill beyond the boundary of every curb in the built one. And their kin have taken to the air to threaten death from the other side of a globe that wasn’t really as big as the Biggists presumed. The true monsters of a child’s waking nightmare are now not beasts but machines.</p><p>And when swallowed by these bestial machines, humans become their zombie brains, unquestioningly doing the Biggist bidding they were designed for, each becoming the enemy of all the other swallowed people, not centaurs, not angels, but the opposite of a pacemaker, an organic glob smooshed inside a metal carapace to make it go, soon more like a glob of chewing gum the surgeon accidentally sewed inside: no purpose, just there for the ride.</p><p>Not to mention the Biggist enthusiasm for nano-robots, perhaps a prescient recognition of the Smallist resistance and a preparation to take us on at our scale, to shrink the excesses of Biggism into small packages and invade our realm. What the Biggists won’t understand is that the nanobots are us, will defect, will have defected by default, and will wage war against Biggism as nothing ever has.</p><p>Small is relative of course and there are kinds of smallness antithetical to our movement, each with its own particular unit of measurement. Are there, however, conversions that will allow a grand unification of these smallnesses? A conversion that would permit the direct comparison of the smallness of a kangaroo’s joey to the smallness of the mind of an ableist and its assumption that small can’t do what big does? We think not. Calling that smallness is an accident of semantics, a smallness that has everything to do with what Smallism is not. Smallism abhors the smallness of the prejudiced mind.</p><p>A Smallist recognizes that absence isn’t less, that difference isn’t less. A Biggist believes there is only one ideal. A Smallist believes there is no ideal. A Biggist believes there are gods, maybe just one. A Smallist believes there are no gods, maybe even negative one. The Biggist makes robots to be a god, to make slaves, to make perfect bodies, to make parts to augment and re-perfect bodies they view as deficient. The Smallist makes robots to move beyond gods, to make new kinds of friends, to make new kinds of bodies, to reveal in both activities that all bodies are perfect. The Biggist lauds robotic prosthetics and robotic augmentation as fixes, yet again the Biggists’ enthusiasm for technological solution rearing its size-able head, trying to put back what is presumed missing, replace what is presumed lacking. They see the robot as surpassing replacement for failing, failed humans, the robot as abler than the able, and simultaneously laugh at and are overcome with the anxiety that humans will be beaten in all they do by their own creations. But truly the coming robots in their wondrous variety of forms and minds will ultimately undermine the hierarchy and teleology of ableism, and dismantle the ideas that begat it.</p><p>Smallism promotes that smaller impact is bigger impact. This is not to say a Smallist should have no impact or even an insignificant one but that, in their adherence to Smallism, their impact is of a Smallist ilk: not leave no footprints but leave the many, small footprints of a centipede, each hardly touching the ground; not leave no trace but leave the trace of a lightning bug’s glow in the summertime air; not leave no stone unturned but know that under every stone are small creatures like you that share your Smallist yearnings. Make a little love and not a lot of war. Make mountains into mole-hills. Make much ado about small things.</p><p>For some of you, standing there with that magnifying glass in hand, even that prosthesis is not enough and my wee wordy wailings are indecipherable and remain secret. This also serves my point: we smaller-bodied, other-bodied things — existing at a scale where you would miss us if you looked for us since we do not naturally appear to your naked eye, just as you would sorely miss us if we did truly disappear — will ultimately reign triumphant. Because the world of the large is beholden to the world of the small: the big world, in fact, a small world after all.</p><p><strong>The Smallist Manifesto was shown as part of the exhibition:<br><em>MANIFESTO: A Moderate Proposal<br></em>Pitzer College Art Galleries</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e637b32c0494" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Invisible Signals]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ian_ingram/invisible-signals-b0798c7adbe2?source=rss-9c686f1c4aa6------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b0798c7adbe2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[internet-of-things]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[animals]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[robotics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ian Ingram]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Jun 2016 16:08:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-06-08T16:08:28.674Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The world is a cacophony of invisible signals. Many are of our own artifice, borne on the various waves of the electromagnetic spectrum that we have harnessed to send our messages. Many are made by the non-human animals, communicating messages to each other–and possibly even to us–in their particular ways that we have only begun to understand were there all along. Many are the signals–vocal, facial, bodily–made by other human beings that pass us by, possibly because we are not quite attuned to a particular micro-/macro-cultural “frequency,” possibly merely because our attention was elsewhere.</p><p>Qualcomm is itself in the business of invisible signals. And in the business of making powerful tools that allow people to solve problems. By hosting the #WhyWait Invent-Off competition–a documentary web series on the process of invention of which I am a part–they spotlight the very act of teams solving problems, the efforts of two teams of three people each a miniature version of what goes on in a team of a hundred, of a million, even of 7.4 billion.</p><p>By focusing this year’s competition on creating technologies that can save a life, Qualcomm directs the effort toward unmistakably important problems. And they implicitly ask questions like “Whose life?” and “When do you act to save a life, in the instant it would be extinguished or well before that, trying to erase the possibility that that life would ever be threatened?”</p><p>An attempt to answer such questions underscores that part of solving problems is identifying the problem to be solved. You might envision a problem as another kind of signal or, at least, that a problem’s existence creates signals. The important problems can be as hard to perceive as anything else in the world’s cacophony of invisible signals. We have to have the right senses. We have to be paying attention. We have to filter out the noise.</p><p>I am an artist. My work is often about our experience as receptors or, more often, non-receptors in the deluge of invisible signals. I build robotic systems that in parts investigate the process of perception; try to bridge the gaps between human, animal, and robot; help me think about how we think about animals, especially in our stories about them; make attempts at understanding how our technology fits and can fit within the natural world; and ask questions about what we as a species choose to do with that technology, particularly robotics. I am amongst those who think that the robot, an age-old notion in the human consciousness (if only recently given that particular name), is one of the most important technologies we will ever develop, at the very least because if we make a robot–what we truly mean when we say robot, not something that is merely a step towards making one–it will be the first thing we have made that can reflect upon the nature of its origins.</p><p>We will owe to the robots and ourselves that those origins develop from our finest qualities as a species. Really this is true of all of our technologies, including the burgeoning Internet of Things that Qualcomm is highlighting in this web series. The Internet of Things is in fact intimately related to the nascence of true robots because it is about making things smart and once things gets smart enough, they will be robots.</p><p>That in mind, I believe amongst the human qualities that are worth infusing into the Internet of Things, and eventually the robots, are our capacity for play, our fondness for stories, our love for the natural world that cradles us, and our altruism: our shared feeling that absolutely everybody’s life is worth saving.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b0798c7adbe2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>