<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Idzie Desmarais on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Idzie Desmarais on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@idziedesmarais?source=rss-ae0655e6339e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 01:19:53 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@idziedesmarais/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Smoky Skies and Fireflies]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@idziedesmarais/smoky-skies-and-fireflies-9dcc1d3db999?source=rss-ae0655e6339e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9dcc1d3db999</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-grief]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[childhood-memories]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Idzie Desmarais]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 18 Jul 2023 16:04:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-07-18T16:04:15.657Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I step out of the door, masked, into a world made hazy with smoke. (When I tell a friend later, she says isn’t it strange putting a mask on to go <em>outside</em> instead of <em>in</em>?)</p><p>The wildfires have been burning for weeks now, sunlight often glowing a soft orange, a quality I’ve come to recognize over the past few years, as the haze of Western forest fires has come to drift more often across a whole continent to hang in the skies over Quebec. But this is the first time my own province has been on fire.</p><p>After several days at a friend’s house, it’s time to head home, so we duck quickly into her car, and pull out into a world transformed. Farm fields and roadways are hazy, those big signs that always loom up beside highways advertising fast food restaurants and hotels are wreathed in smoke. “It’s like driving through clouds,” I say, “like the mountains on the way to Gaspe” — “or in upstate New York,” my friend agrees. It’s like clouds, but not, the consistency somehow drier and less agile than mist or fog or clouds, more dispersed. I can’t stop craning around, looking in every direction out the car windows, as my friend, shaken, can’t stop saying how apocalyptic it all feels, like the end of days.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tRRMEnNJssF1xS6bj_rBPg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@vixenly?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Kym MacKinnon</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/JyhO97U2i6w?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>I’m bewildered, and embarrassed to realize that I thought this wasn’t the sort of thing that would happen here. Climate crisis? Yes. Canada is a wealthy country that has spent most of its existence either directly exporting the worst ravages of climate destruction across the ocean, or backing the larger imperial powers of America or the United Kingdom as they do the same, yet the impact of this State’s actions could not be kept at bay forever. Worsening heat and new diseases carried by insects moving south and increased flooding and collapsing insect populations have all been starkly, vividly brought home in recent years, the absurdity of borders slashed across land and air made ever clearer as the whole planet warms. But somehow I didn’t think <em>fires</em> in particular would come here with such intensity. Those are things that happen on the West Coast of this continent, or Australia, or a dozen other places I’ve seen burning on the news, not in the damp, verdant green of the boreal forests, or among the rustling deciduous trees of the eastern woodlands.</p><p>I have since learned that many plants I love here evolved with fire, that controlled burning was a practice among Indigenous nations here, too. Fire doesn’t have to be like this, wild with hunger.</p><p>Yet here it is, stinging my throat and tickling my nose, a presence impossible to escape.</p><p>My mother used to liberate plants from areas of development, tramping onto city lands or quietly trespassing (often I don’t think she knew which one it was) in order to dig up black raspberries and trilliums and anything else she recognized, soon to be churned under heavy tires and dug up by backhoes to make room for housing tracts and malls. Trilliums–along with a host of spring ephemerals–where flowers I knew should not normally be disturbed, but that was because we had to help them survive, and sometimes surviving meant digging up as many as we could and stuffing them into the trunk, giving them a chance of blooming again in a different home.</p><p>When I was a small child, the island I live on had a lot more forest, a shady canopy holding dog tooth violets and ferns under branching arms. It also had a lot more wetlands, filled with cattails and frogs and red-winged blackbirds, absorbing the flooding from the swollen river each spring, then drying out to welcome the summer wildlife, like lungs expanding and contracting. (Houses here never used to flood much when I was young, and now it’s a threat every year, more and more river floodplains trapped under suffocating layers of cement and asphalt and gravel).</p><p>My entire childhood was marked by memories of these living places being slowly whittled away, one street after another of overpriced houses snaking out.</p><p>There was one area, though, that remained untouched for a long time, a space of shifting wetlands filled with frogs that I walked out to all the time, increasingly with local friends. We’d pass giant vehicles, their brand name an insult to caterpillars, muttering darkly about what sugar does in gas tanks (though none of us were ever brave enough to do more than study them with contemplative resentment), trying to ignore the sounds of building behind a thin screen of trees.</p><p>One day stands out vividly, when stepped out of the woods into that marshy space, only to find it flattened, greenery torn up, water pooling in vicious gouges cut through the muddy earth. It <em>hurt</em>, a twisting grief that had me struggling to catch my breath, even though I’d suspected it was coming. When I think of how bitter I became as a teenager, how cynical, I think of that moment. I think of the decision, mostly subconscious, to moderate caring, to try not to love a world so deeply that was being taken apart, piece by piece.</p><p>Shortly afterwards, the destruction in that small patch stopped, and the city put up a small sign warning that this was habitat for the boreal chorus frog, and threatening fines for anyone who disturbed them. That sign in muddy earth felt pathetically ironic, the very definition of too little too late.</p><p>Yet over 15 years later, that small bit of wetlands remains, along with the sign. Someone–or someones–had to have fought for that sign, fought for that small bit of habitat. And every year, I can hear the frogs calling, the spring peepers and the wood frogs and yes, the boreal chorus frog, there despite it all.</p><p>Sometime last year, in a fit of nostalgia, I started re-watching the original The Magic Schoolbus, and for a while I was watching an episode or two before bed every night. I was shocked by how many I actually remembered: the one where they go through Arnold’s digestive system, and the Halloween episode where they all turn into bats. But there was one episode I definitely did not remember. A holiday special, released in 1996, when I was 5 years old, which centers on recycling. Upset to have accidentally recycled a toy she’d meant to donate as a present, young student Val declares that she wishes recycling had never been invented, and the titular school bus sets about erasing all evidence of it, leaving the town–and presumably, the whole world–covered in tree stumps and trash. I couldn’t finish the episode, because I remember that simplistic story pushed in the 90’s (and, to a lesser extent, still in effect today) too well, that comforting belief that as long as you made these small environmentally friendly personal choices, everything would be fine. The trees would be left standing, the air would be clear, the oceans clean.</p><p>The gulf between the hopeful vision of a 90’s children’s show and the reality now, nearly 30 years later, is hard to comprehend. Sometimes it seems like things move so slowly, and other times so fast. The looming warnings of climate change morphing into a reality of smoky skies, floods, increasingly violent storms, habitat collapse. What’s been lost in the short few decades I’ve been alive is staggering. I often think about how I’m part of the last generation who will have known a world before the promise of climate crisis became a desperate reality, how we’ll be holders of the memories of a different world. That’s true to an extent for every generation; change is impossible to avoid, but human caused destruction on a scale such as this is not.</p><p>This summer, there are more fireflies in our yard than I’ve ever seen before. At dusk I step outside to watch them flickering, a net of fairy lights stretched out across milkweed and woodland sunflowers.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*boAkxSSMojE_t-daUPiSIg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@tengyart?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Tengyart</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/photos/5LxaPqywLwQ?utm_source=unsplash&amp;utm_medium=referral&amp;utm_content=creditCopyText">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Our yard, both front and back, grows as wild as we can make it. Robins, northern cardinals, and sparrows nest in the maple and apple trees, and in the multiple tangles of grapevines. When the neighbouring yards–made up of nothing but sterile, short, non-native grasses–are quiet and still, ours is alive with the bright flashes of fireflies, the buzzing of bees, and, later in the season, the calls of crickets.</p><p>We’re currently trying to leave this place in the suburbs. It’s not a good living situation, and it’s not a place my sister or I ever wanted to call home as adults. I look at new property listings every day, increasingly desperate, as we try to find the right land, the right house, somewhere where we can finally breathe freely. I won’t miss the crumbling bungalow, the lack of control I have over my life, the volatility of someone I’m currently depending on for housing. But the yard… The yard I’ll miss.</p><p>My sister tells me that she feels like she’s betraying all the insects who’ve made their home here over the past decades, since it’s likely that once my parents are divorced, once my mother and my sister and I are all gone, that my father will mow most of it down, if he doesn’t just sell the house outright (in which case, the new owners are likely to make as sterile a canvas as our neighbours). I can’t say that that knowledge doesn’t weigh on me, doesn’t make my eyes prickle with imagined loss. But what I keep saying to her, and what I keep saying to myself, is that every single year, every season that the sweat bees and great black wasps, the milkweed beetles and the tiger moths and the fireflies have been able to thrive here matters. Even if–even when–someone destroys this small habitat we’ve carved out, that won’t take away the important work that was done for so long. For a while, this was such a wonderful home.</p><p>I am both less bitter than when I was a teenager, and more closed off. I couldn’t live like that, a raw nerve, the grief and terror that humans and non-humans alike must live with in these structures of violence and control and destruction that have been forced on us, all too close and too sharp. I had to muffle things a little, to hold on to the cynicism that was in large part realism, to make this bearable. But it’s a balance, because to be too numb is to not want to live at all anymore.</p><p>I am neither hopeful or hopeless. It hurts, still, every single day, the continuing loss, the desperation to save everything and everyone we can for as long as we can, and the helplessness of not knowing what my place is in this great fight for survival that we have no choice but to engage in (well, I suppose there is another option, but it doesn’t end well).</p><p>And also, because I’m aware enough to grieve, I love this world so fiercely (there’s nothing you mourn so strongly as that which you love). I love the way the moon shimmers in a long strip across the river, and the cacophonous descent of a flock of bohemian waxwings. I love my friend’s faces lit by firelight, and the last crickets calling in the fall. I want as many years of fireflies as I can get, I’m greedy for it.</p><p>The uncertainty of these times is terrifying, but in that terror I also find slivers of possibility. Things are going to get a lot worse. But they might also–if enough things go right, if the fighting is hard enough, if we get lucky–eventually get better.</p><p>Smoky skies and fireflies. I hope it’s enough.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9dcc1d3db999" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Art of Giving Up: On Anti-Productivity, “Lazy” Education, and the Acceptance of Limitations]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@idziedesmarais/the-art-of-giving-up-on-anti-productivity-lazy-education-and-the-acceptance-of-limitations-a9abad8ccf52?source=rss-ae0655e6339e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a9abad8ccf52</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-directed-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[laziness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Idzie Desmarais]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Nov 2021 00:50:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-11-19T00:50:40.111Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I used to think I was lazy. I got called lazy sometimes in my teens, because that’s what happens when you have undiagnosed illnesses which cause fatigue (among other things). I haven’t believed that for a long time, just as I haven’t believed in “laziness” itself, but its afterimage persists, colouring my present in fainter yet still damaging ways.</p><p>I haven’t managed to finish a nonfiction book since May (and that one a mere 100 pages long — thank you Fragments of an Anarchist Anthropology for being too interesting to put down). I’ve started plenty of books, but I can’t maintain focus. I forget they exist as soon as I put them down, and suddenly they’re three days past the due date at the library, my time having run out.</p><p>This has caused me a lot of frustration. I’m stalled on writing my own book, motivation a struggle even before the spectre of seasonal depression — gloriously bedecked in vibrant reds and oranges and yellows — made its usual autumn arrival. While I’m not actively writing, I thought, now is the time to focus on research, to dive deep into books on education and schooling, colonialism and capitalism, disability justice and radical parenting; all the topics that help shape my understanding of the way children, caregiving, schooling and education fit into the broader webs of oppression and liberation on which I want to write.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J7AePxtbR1tgCUBVTRyQMw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I can’t, though. It feels like waging battles against my own mind, ones where I feel progressively worse each time I lose.</p><p>I am against the violent enforcement of productivity, and against the more subtle yet no less destructive ways people are trained to see their worth as existing solely in what they can produce.</p><p>People are also taught to see their worth as existing in what they consume in order to better produce in the future. This is visible in both the obsession with making sure children are always engaged in “educational” activities, and the guilt adults feel when enjoying pursuits they deem “useless.” Everything must have a purpose, must be done in service to improving yourself, your output, your value to capital, your habits, your health. Time not spent on the right things is thought to be wasted.</p><p>I wish I could say that this doesn’t matter to me, and that surely even if I was affected, it wouldn’t impact those things which I truly WANT to do, but that’s not actually true. No matter how much internal motivation exists in an abstract sense, as soon as an external component is introduced, as soon as there’s some element of creating for the consumption of others, I start to feel the weight of imagined expectations bearing down on me.</p><p>There aren’t people hanging over my shoulder making demands. But there is internalized ableism, the earnings numbers on Patreon, the part of my self-worth I’ve tied into performing intellectually, all crowding in close behind me.</p><p>I’ve had the phrase ‘’lazy education’’ in my head for a few months now. As with any intriguing new idea or way of looking at things, I tend to savor it for a while, turn it around, look at it from different angles and see if any useful perspective can be gained from it. Sometimes the answer is no, and it gets discarded. Other times it leads me in exciting new directions.</p><p>I’m not sure yet whether ‘’lazy education’’ is worth keeping around in the long term, but my thought process at the moment, the reason my mind keeps returning to that phrasing, is that it presents a direct and provocative challenge to much of what ‘’education’’ is supposed to be.</p><p>Devon Price, a social psychologist and author of Laziness Does Not Exist, describes <a href="https://freedom.to/blog/dr-devon-price-fighting-back-against-the-laziness-lie/">the main tenets of what they term “the laziness lie”</a> thusly:</p><ul><li>Your worth is your productivity.</li><li>You cannot trust your own feelings or limits.</li><li>There’s always more that you could be doing.</li></ul><p>I think about how this relates to childhood and education, of all the ways that young people are derided and belittled — are labeled as ‘’lazy’’ — for engaging in activities and interests which are not sanctioned or respected by the adults in their lives. Playing video games, daydreaming, refusing to do homework, not paying attention to teachers, napping, talking to friends, reading comics, watching TV, sleeping late…</p><p>All of those things can be roughly divided into two categories: attempting to meet needs that are otherwise not being met (for rest, relaxation, fun, and socializing), or refusing to engage in things that are making their lives worse (homework, classes or teachers they dislike).</p><p>So what would a lazy education entail? It would be one where rest, daydreaming, and decompression were valued, where there was always enough free time to sleep when you needed to (and the flexibility to change your schedule when there was not enough time for rest). An education that centered consent and self-direction, allowing each person the autonomy needed to learn what they wanted, when they wanted to, from those they chose, in the structures (or lack of structure) that suited them best. One where play, fun, and joy was always more important than meeting arbitrary benchmarks set by those who care more about the functioning of an institution than about actual people. An education where what you care about and what you love matters. One where your needs and limitations are simply part of life, instead of being treated as an imposition, or you yourself as a defect in the system. I am speaking about self-directed education to some extent, but I am also speaking of a deeper examination of the harmful understandings that we have all internalized, a deconstruction that only some people in the world of self-directed education engage in.</p><p>I wonder what it would mean, how it would change the way we relate to both others and ourselves, if we were to truly reject the lie that is laziness.</p><p>To recognize that limitations exist in a general sense, and further that it’s perfectly normal and fine for <em>other</em> people to have limitations (and ones which should be respected and accommodated as a matter of course), is a much easier thing, I have found, than recognizing my own limits, whether big or small.</p><p>Sometimes it’s obvious: when a migraine is too severe, I can’t leave the house, I can’t look at a screen, I need to cancel any meetings or plans I had made and simply exist — in quiet, in stillness, in darkness — until it passes.</p><p>Sometimes it’s harder: I can’t read books, but I SHOULD be able to read books, so if I just keep trying over and over, surely I’ll finally succeed?</p><p>Yet when it was clear that my “strategy,” such as it was, of simply attempting to push myself through this block was not working, I made the decision to free myself from having to read books, or if I did start them, from having to finish them. There are so many rules each of us have internalized, correct paths we believe we must follow: books are the superior way in which to ingest knowledge, as compared to shorter works or those in formats not based on the written word. And you’re supposed to finish those books (or at least the important ones).</p><p>When I stopped trying to read books, several things became clearer. First, I realized how much I’ve been reading this whole year (essays and papers and articles and interview transcripts), and I recognized the value in the videos and podcasts I had watched and listened to. I saw how much knowledge and expertise I’d been ingesting and engaging with, despite my stats on Goodreads. This wasn’t some shocking new realization, you must understand; I knew the valorization of books as the only good source of knowledge was suspect at best, and that the idea that there is one best way to learn is both absurd and ableist. Yet when researching for my book, something I was feeling anxious and insecure about, I’d allowed myself to believe that “research” meant reading, reading books in particular, and reading those books in their entirety (silly, I know).</p><p>The second thing that happened was that suddenly, I could read again. Free from the need to finish, I could read a chapter or two, absorbing new perspectives and ideas, and that could be enough (or enough for now). I was still learning, thinking, making connections, forming new ideas.</p><p>This, too, was not new. I have found it to be a pattern that once I release the guilt of what I <em>should</em> be doing, <em>should</em> be focusing on, <em>should </em>be capable of, it opens up a new space in which I can do some things, some times, that I was not able to do while paralyzed by feelings of shame and inadequacy. Absent that, I am able to approach the things I actually wish to do joyfully, with curiosity. I might not be thrilled about all aspects of my current reality, but at least I’ve accepted their inevitable existence. It’s cold enough for sweaters now, the sun sets earlier, and I can’t finish books. Whether I like these things or not, resentment does nothing but make my life worse.</p><p>Author and activist carla bergman has spoken of “embodied anti-capitalism,” which applies well to the resistance inherent in refusal (of work, school, the pressure to perform and produce), but which I believe can also encompass a broader ethos centering wellbeing.</p><p>I am trying to become a person who embodies anti-capitalism. I am trying to quiet the frustration that claws at me when my body and brain are unable to do what I wish of them. I am trying to learn, to think deeply and engage enthusiastically with ideas, without feeling that I must produce something tangible from my thinking to make that effort worthwhile. I am continuously re-learning the ability to quit freely and without guilt, to stop reading when I want or need to (and to banish the anxiety which seems to suggest that a book will vanish if I do not finish it, as if it’s something I only get one try at instead of a resource which will wait for me to be ready for it).</p><p>There are brief moments of balance, of peace, where I feel the contentment of knowing that I am okay, I am enough. There are other moments where I am immersed in something which matters deeply to me — a fascinating book, the arc of a raspberry cane as I place it carefully into the ground, an animated conversation with someone I care about — where I feel a sense of what a lazy education should be: a deep love for the connections we make with people, with words, with other living beings, whether those connections with the world are usually thought to be “useful” (to be educational) or not.</p><p>I am still feeling out the contours of what this means, in what ways I wish for these ideas to guide my life choices, but it feels like they provide at least fragmentary answers.</p><p>And for now, they’ve allowed me to give up on endlessly trying to finish books.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a9abad8ccf52" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Self-Directed Education, Scalability, and “School”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@idziedesmarais/self-directed-education-scalability-and-school-22973a0e663b?source=rss-ae0655e6339e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/22973a0e663b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[school-abolition]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-directed-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unschooling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Idzie Desmarais]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Sep 2021 02:04:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-19T21:20:19.704Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Months ago I had someone ask me if I thought unschooling would “scale up,” and I answered explaining there were multiple self-directed models and ways of approaching education-without-coercion. “So the answer is no, it won’t” was their unimpressed reply.</p><p>In that exchange lies a crucial misunderstanding of what education can and should look like. To me, I’d answered the question in the affirmative. To the other person, I had not.</p><p>Culturally, people have become accustomed to a school system — singular. Sure, there are private schools as well, but they account for a minority of students overall, and most of them adhere to the exact same model as the conventional system: divisions based on age and “ability,” compulsory curriculum, students under the strict management of teachers and without real power to shape their own education (and teachers with only slightly more power over the structure they work in). So when people hear terms such as “school abolition,” the ideology of abolishing conventional school as we know it, I think they expect there to be a replacement — singular. What (school) will we replace school with?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*V59Wl9Fd_6z_2eCouCwBkw.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/david-graeber-fragments-of-an-anarchist-anthropology">Anarchist author and anthropologist David Graeber</a> explores a similar problem when it comes to communicating what an anarchist society would look like: “when the skeptic says ‘society,’ what he really means is ‘state,’ even ‘nation-state.’ Since no one is going to produce an example of an anarchist state — that would be a contradiction in terms — what we’re really being asked for is an example of a modern nation-state with the government somehow plucked away…There is a way out, which is to accept that anarchist forms of organization would not look anything like a state. That they would involve an endless variety of communities, associations, networks, projects, on every conceivable scale, overlapping and intersecting in any way we could imagine, and possibly many that we can’t.” In much the same way, the answer often being sought by educational skeptics bears no resemblance to what school abolitionists want.</p><p>Those of us in favour of consent-based, self-directed education do not envision replacing one all-encompassing institution with another (school). Instead, what I personally see as a desirable replacement is hundreds, thousands of different ways of living and learning: unschooling, Agile Learning Centers, freeschools, educational co-ops, apprenticeships, multi-age learning spaces, expanded community centers and libraries, and so many more possibilities dreamt up by a diversity of people within their own unique contexts. “[P]rojects, on every conceivable scale, overlapping and intersecting in any way we could imagine, and possibly many that we can’t.”</p><p>When it comes to scalability, I don’t actually think there is anything inherently “un-scalable” about self-directed education, if what is meant by that is spaces with access to a variety of resources and supportive adults in which children can spend their time. If instead what is truly meant by such a concern is whether <em>assessment</em> (in the form of standardized testing of standardized content) is scalable in self-directed settings, then my response to that is no, it isn’t, and what a relief that is (the point, after all, is not simply to recreate schooling under a different name, but to do away with it entirely).</p><p>But whatever is intended by the question, I also don’t think it <em>matters</em> if it scales up.</p><p>As <a href="https://twitter.com/SJinnit/status/1383543177659838466">Sarah Jane K-M put it</a>, “perhaps it’s more important [if] it is ‘repeatable’ — so that other communities don’t have to start from scratch. The more we start to think of infrastructure from a bottom up level rather than top down the more we need to find good practice to imitate rather than scalability.”</p><p>Another aspect that needs to be examined, I believe, is the issue of flexibility and adaptability. When people’s reference is a schooling system which has remained remarkably similar since its inception some 200 odd years ago, I think there’s a tendency — one that is definitely encouraged by the power structures of state and industry who benefit from shaping children in their desired image — to believe that this is the best educational model we’ve got (though sure, some reformist tweaking may be needed). And further, that there can BE one “best” model for all children.</p><p>If that’s the case, what those who wish for a radically different approach to education must want is a <em>new</em> best, which when shaped into its ideal form, can then remain as it is, a project completed.</p><p>But what works for some people, at some times, may change. The circumstances and needs of a community do not remain stagnant. And for education to remain nourishing and useful, no matter the form it takes, often necessitates that it must change, too.</p><p>I don’t at all wish to suggest that each generation should build anew, without the benefit of existing infrastructure or experience (there are after all models of self-directed education which have already stood the test of time), merely that adaptability — both for individuals and educational spaces — is a strength, not something which should be resisted based on a primary concern with continuing institutions as they exist (in their “best” form).</p><p>To fight for and create radically different ways of living and organizing necessitates imagination and flexibility, rejecting false dichotomies and refusing to accept either/or options, instead learning to value complexity and diversity.</p><p>No one school system — singular. Instead, ways of learning that are every bit as varied as we are ourselves.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=22973a0e663b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Anarchist Education and Child-Shaping]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@idziedesmarais/anarchist-education-and-child-shaping-e19ce074f5ce?source=rss-ae0655e6339e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e19ce074f5ce</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self-directed-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[radical-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchist-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anarchism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Idzie Desmarais]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Sep 2021 01:50:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-23T01:50:10.830Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When it comes to writing about education, my main focus has always been unschooling (and self-directed education more broadly). But as I’m also an anarchist (and have identified as such for over a decade), I wanted to devote a bit more time to exploring some of the range of practices, models, and theories housed under the umbrella of “anarchist education.” This isn’t a deep exploration that I’m sharing with you today, just a few thoughts, mixed feelings, and generalized frustration over how many radicals either don’t think deeply about children and schooling, or when they do, can’t let go of many of the core (authoritarian) structures that shape children’s lives.<br>__</p><p>In 2019, the online magazine <a href="https://www.self-directed.org/tipping-points/">Tipping Points</a> published a series of excerpts from the book Anarchist Pedagogies edited by Robert H. Haworth. I read these excerpts as they were released, and two years later a passage from one remains fresh in my mind because of just how much I hated the concept.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/317/1*N8r2rOq5b0xtIGPV15ISOA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In <a href="https://www.self-directed.org/tp/anarchist-pedagogy-1/">Anarchist Pedagogy in Action: Paideia, Escuela Libre</a> the authors detail their visit to an anarchist school in Spain, including their own observations and interviews with school staff. They describe it as “collectively [run] without coercion or authority,” which makes the description of a routine practice at the school even more jarring:</p><p>“Due to the number of students who have returned from summer holidays with ‘tendencies toward dependence,’ as the adults call it, the school is temporarily under what is known as Mandado — which roughly translates as ‘to be ordered.’ It is a state of exception, sometimes applied to individual students but in this case applied to the entire school. As the students are seen to no longer be able [to] take the initiative to do things themselves and are asking the authority figures (the adults) what to do, they are mandado-ed, told what to do by the staff. This state of exception remains until the students decide to call for an assembly where they will discuss collectively whether they have returned to a state of freedom and responsibility. If there is consensus for the Mandado to be lifted, then the school will return to normal and no one will be told what to do anymore. ‘They need to re-find their anarchist values,’ concludes Martin Luengo. ‘It doesn’t take long. No one likes being told what to do all the time. But if they want to be free they have to fight for it.’”</p><p>It would seem that, in this scenario, the adults have a benchmark for how “independent” they wish the children to be, and when those children do not live up to it, they decide that the appropriate course of action is to exert their authority by ordering the children about (en masse or individually — I invite you to imagine what it must feel like to be singled out as too dependent, and therefore in need of adult control until you start behaving in a way deemed correct by those same adults). As much as this is a state of affairs which can be ended by assembly (when all the children are implicated — no mention is made of the resolution when it is individual children), it seems clear that it is the adults who hold more power, adults who set behavioural expectations, and adults who institute a punishment of sorts in reverting to authoritarianism when they deem it appropriate.</p><p>This essay is but a small glimpse into the functioning of this school, written by people who spent only a few days there, conducting interviews which may not have been in English, or if they were with people whose first language likely wasn’t, so I know I am not seeing the full picture. However, when the school’s main theorist states that “if [the children] want to be free they have to fight for it,” I find myself thinking that, when you have to fight against a group or class of people for your freedom, those people are your oppressors. If this concept in the school is being communicated correctly, then I would consider it to still very much uphold the oppression of children, and I would say that calling such strategies “anarchist” — an ideology which holds as fundamental precepts a rejection of rulers, hierarchies, and authoritarianism — does a great disservice to the word and concept. For children, even in a space which nominally eschews hierarchies, their freedom is conditional.<br>__</p><p>In an essay by Emma Goldman first published in 1916 titled “<a href="https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/emma-goldman-the-child-and-its-enemies">the child and its enemies</a>,” she expresses frustration with the state of radical parenting:</p><p>“That compulsion is bound to awaken resistance, every parent and teacher ought to know. Great surprise is being expressed over the fact that the majority of children of radical parents are either altogether opposed to the ideas of the latter, many of them moving along the old antiquated paths, or that they are indifferent to the new thoughts and teachings of social regeneration. And yet there is nothing unusual in that. Radical parents, though emancipated from the belief of ownership in the human soul, still cling tenaciously to the notion that they own the child, and that they have the right to exercise their authority over it. So they set out to mould and form the child according to their own conception of what is right and wrong, forcing their ideas upon it with the same vehemence that the average Catholic parent uses. And, with the latter, they hold out the necessity before the young ‘to do as I tell you and not as I do.’”</p><p>Here Goldman expresses a crucial contradiction within the approaches radicals take towards children, where stated beliefs in liberation frequently don’t include the liberation of children, or when they nominally do what is termed “liberatory” for the young somehow ends up looking no more revolutionary than your average slightly further left liberal. It is a vision which softens adult authority by a few degrees, eschewing outright violence or harshness, but which still places children firmly under the dominion of adults.</p><p>I recently tried to describe what I see as the division between radical camps when it comes to children. On one side, children are considered valuable because of their perceived future liberatory potential, which is what Emma Goldman is discussing, and what the Spanish anarchist school Paideia seems to be aiming for when it is described as “a lifelong process of character building in preparation for direct democracy.” On the other side, some radicals see youth liberation — the destruction of the systems of power which oppress children — as a worthy liberatory goal in and of itself: Children are oppressed, and as anarchists or others who oppose systems of oppression, it is essential for the oppressor-class of adults to fight for an end of that oppression.<br>__</p><p>In <a href="https://www.progressiveeducation.org/voices-from-the-sector/education-provider-voices/education-provider-voice-11/">an interview with Alexander Khost</a> — anarchist, facilitator of self-directed education, and editor-in-chief of Tipping Points magazine — he pushes back against the idea that his role is to shape children into a specific form:</p><p>“I am not at all interested in progressive education or equipping students for anything; I do not equip. I let the young people equip themselves. I just push back against the society that oppresses young people to make enough room so that those young people have the space and time to go equip themselves however they see fit. And that is the fundamental difference between a progressive education and one of liberation.”</p><p>That is a perspective on anarchist education (a term he uses to describe the methodology embraced by the Flying Squads community he is part of) that I can fully support, and it is at the intersection of self-directed education and anti-authoritarian politics where I feel most at home.</p><p>I’ve just started working on a longer-form essay on how trusting kids acts as a practice of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prefigurative_politics">preconfiguration</a>, the ways that environment shapes behaviour, and my own teenage years spent without rules and punishments, so I’ve been thinking about these topics a lot. It is both possible and necessary to strive to exist in community, to center liberation, and to make sure important ideas are part of children’s lives without resorting to coercion and control (which is both <a href="https://yes-i-can-write.blogspot.com/2019/08/yes-there-are-things-every-kid-should.html">oppressive and counter-productive</a>). I would like to see a greater depth in how anarchists understand their role, if they are adults, in relation to children; a recognition of the ways that they continue to uphold child oppression; and a realization that by refusing to challenge the hierarchies that place adults over children, they are actively betraying the principles they claim to hold.</p><p>My own anarchistic beliefs grew quite directly out of my unschooling experience, as I started realizing that, if almost all the largely unquestioned beliefs in wider society about children, childhood, and education were simply not true, not whole or accurate, than how many other structuring ideas were just as suspect? And I would just like to see people who came to anarchism from very different places extend that same principled opposition to hierarchy and authority to children as well.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e19ce074f5ce" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>