<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by IfeOluwa Nihinlola on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by IfeOluwa Nihinlola on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 01:26:33 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Will We Feel Alright?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/will-we-feel-alright-fdf1d768bcff?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fdf1d768bcff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[highlife]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Aug 2020 09:14:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-26T11:17:54.605Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Igbo Highlife According to The Cavemen.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*l0ICYmIkDVWR2SJB6miqKg.jpeg" /><figcaption>L-R: Benjamin James and Kingsley Okorie of The Cavemen.</figcaption></figure><h4>1.</h4><p>Mr Eazi’s paean to his multiple identities in <em>Life is Eazi, Vol. 2</em> begins with its most earworming number: a short highlife chant called ‘Lagos Gyration’ that is filled with the kind of energy that sets the tone for the listening experience to come. It also feels imported from another universe, one filled with boisterous boys and the few women who don’t mind their company, semi-drunk on palm wine, raising christo-inspired songs in call and response, recalling joys and sadness, unrequited loves and indefatigable aspirations through the rhythm of palms slapping agbamole drums and sticks beating gongs or the plates usually deployed in their place. Anyone familiar with kegite groups continuing that raucous tradition in Nigerian campuses knows this gyration; but it also carries in it a genuine callback to earlier iterations of that musical tradition: highlife, of guitar men and big bands playing across the West African coast.</p><p>That song made me want an album filled with that spirit, a desire Mr Eazi wasn’t open to fulfilling. But the liner notes of ‘Lagos Gyration’ show that it was co-written by Kingsley Chukwudi Okorie. Kingsley Okorie and his brother Benjamin James are The Cavemen. and <em>Roots, </em>their debut album, was produced at home, with their regular collaborator Lady Donli, also featured in ‘Lagos Gyration.’</p><p>In <em>Roots,</em> my desire is fulfilled.</p><h4>2.</h4><p>The boys that make up The Cavemen. are calcified in my mind as wide-grinning, energetic, and possessing of a personal style — loose linen and plaid dresses in earthy colours — that projects an ease many stumble through life trying to find. This image was imprinted when I first saw them on stage at Lights Camera Africa film festival, where they played in the company of Jazz trumpeter Etuk Ubong. I say ‘boys’ intentionally, because I continue to be surprised by their youth. It is easy to forget that highlife, in spite of how it has aged into the music of old people, originated as a craft of young men. The Cavemen. embrace the juvenile masculinity of this form in its inherent enthusiasm, willingness to party, and unending — even problematic — pining after women.</p><p>Accompanying this ebullience is the other side of highlife: its ability to be poured into reflective forms, danceable ballads that travel beyond erotic playfulness and into sentimental world-weary emotions. This is the journey The Cavemen. travel in <em>Roots.</em> The tracks are mostly brief chants with simple verses accompanied by pared down percussion and the rhythm guitar, before crescendoing into call and response choruses and full band sound. The album has a delightful bounce, product of a consistently strong rhythm section that The Cavemen. rely upon —Okorie and James play the bass guitar and drum — over heavy guitar and brass sections that highlife fans will be familiar with. I’m a fan of the album’s latter tracks like ‘Beautiful Rain’ and ‘Osondu’, because some part of me latches on to their melancholy; yet, the rest of my body, ever reluctant to dance, answers the exuberant calls of The Cavemen. Listening to songs like ‘Akaraka’ and ‘Bolo Bolo’, I, too, grin and bound with energy from my bed to my desk, to the kitchen where I just made okro and eba, and back to my bed. The routine motions of my day are momentarily elevated by my outspread arms, my shimmying shoulders, and the attempt of my stiff waist to animate my upper body. It is impossible to resist the happiness of the Cave.</p><h4>3.</h4><p>My response to highlife is an involuntary reflex that I suspect was codified into my muscles in church, through years of dancing to singers deploying its rhythm in praise songs. But that is just my story. You don’t have to sweat through pentecostal services to be indoctrinated into the charm of this eminently danceable genre. Highlife demands dance from our bodies in ways that feel primal — like the guitar, drums and brass instruments are pulling us back into dance floors across time, to clubs where the genre flourished in the Nigerian South, before guns and bombs came to staunch its growth, all the way to sites along the West African coast where,<a href="https://www.musicinafrica.net/magazine/short-history-palmwine-guitar"> as described by Ed Keazor</a>, “Portuguese, Spanish and Caribbean sailors whose merchant ships docked at the ports of Freetown (Sierra Leone), Lagos (Nigeria), Monrovia (Liberia) and Accra or Tema (Ghana) lent their guitars and style to their African shipmates, who formulated a unique new style that fused native rhythms with the Latin styles bequeathed by their benefactors.”</p><h4>4.</h4><p>Consider an etymology of ‘highlife’, which, according to Yebuah Mensah, originates from the divide in Accra between those who could pay to go into clubs where big bands played for patrons to dance, and those who remained on the outside looking in. A hierarchy of class in sound. This sound itself, <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/931273?seq=1">according to John Collins</a>, is a fusion of local black rhythms and visiting white influences that “emerged as three distinct streams, each dependent on which particular western musical influence was assimilated and utilised by the African musicians who fused it with their own tradition.” The Cavemen. call their music highlife fusion, an unnecessary tautology, because the origin of highlife itself is fusion. Collins continues: “First there was the imported influences of foreign sailors that became ‘palm-wine’ highlife; second, that of the colonial military brass-bands that became adaha highlife; and third, that of the christianised black elite which became dance-band highlife.”</p><p>If we ditch that recorded history, potent as it is, and feel for what highlife means in Igbo, the language of The Cavemen., perhaps we can extract much more from its name than from the facts of its creation. High. Life. To listen to <em>Roots</em> as an Igbo album is to recognize that these are songs weighted by war, a yet unresolved trauma with losses unaccounted for in its wake. The story of Igbo highlife contains gaps, and the bodies that are supposed to fill these are buried in fossilizing rubble. “The goal is for people — our generation — to experience our highlife now, to show people what highlife would have been if it stayed,” says Okorie <a href="https://thelagosreview.ng/the-cavemen-say-our-music-is-for-those-unafraid-to-explore-adaku-nwakanma/">in an interview</a>, a conscious reference to the war that is weaved into the album — most apparent in ‘Beautiful Rain’ and ‘Osondu’, where The Cavemen. stuff playfulness into solemnity — but also present in ‘Anita’, ‘Ifeoma Odoo’, and ‘Bena’, happy songs about lovers who stay, those about to leave, and those lost and are never to be seen again.</p><h4>5.</h4><p>I am loath to move beyond the known to the unknown, yet my body demands a clarification between the kind of dance Afropop wants — beautifully practiced and realised enactments that my body continues to rebel at — and that automatic response of muscles happening as I type these words and listen to <em>Roots</em>, which my brain only reckons with in retrospect. The only conclusion I can reach (here the reader is free to consider this a reach in all its connotative weakness) is that the former dance is only possible as a public display of momentary pleasure — either to invoke it, as is possible when we want to make ourselves happy by going out to dance with friends, or to confirm it, as in the wedding videos popular on the internet, where men and women move in choreographed steps — and the latter, the kind <em>Roots</em> evokes, connects to a different kind of ecstasy, a joy that isn’t only realised in the company of others, but comes from a deep need to affirm the presence of our bodies and the lives they contain, the kind of joyful reaction that is possible, even if yours is a body that has been through battles or is still at war.</p><p>If you recognise the difference between that dance you perform when you’re out with friends and want to participate in the communal camaraderie possible as you all hit the Zanku in unison, and the one you do in your room when your favourite music comes on and your body can’t help but move, then you’re familiar with the distinction I’m trying to make. It’s not just the difference in public displays and private expressions, but between learned pleasures and joys encoded into our bloods, which carry more (anti) bodies than the ones we own, more histories than we have cognitively absorbed. “Oso ndu,” The Cavemen. sing. Life. In this walk, this race, this thing called life, what can we do if we can no longer dance?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fdf1d768bcff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Even When It Ends in Tears]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/even-when-it-ends-in-tears-826d41bc18e3?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/826d41bc18e3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lucid]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 25 Oct 2019 03:35:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-25T05:38:25.346Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Notes on “Lucid”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Y5OIuQpt3N42KGOv5muZnQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4>1.</h4><p>“Asa’s career trajectory seems blunted.” This was <a href="https://thelagosreview.ng/asa-is-lucid-dami-ajayi/">Dami Ajayi’s conclusion</a> in his review of <em>Lucid</em>, Asa’s latest album. That sentence has stuck in my mind for a couple of days now, so this is my attempt at excising it. In another life, I would be writing a review of <em>Lucid</em>, mounting impassioned arguments for why it is a masterpiece, but I have lost the arrogant earnestness my old life demanded. While working as a critic who writes reviews, conclusions like Dami’s were necessary: I was only worth the weight of my judgements. Right now, I don’t even know what my opinions mean. All I have are questions. Yet, Dami’s conclusion is hard to ignore, perhaps because I’ve been wondering how different it would be if he had asked what Asa intended when she titled her album <em>Lucid</em>.</p><h4>2.</h4><p>To say Asa’s music is formulaic is to state the obvious. Dami argues that Asa doesn’t stray from her past predilections, and he’s right. He declares this tendency to tread old paths a failure, suggesting that innovation is an inherent success—even a virtue. Moral absolutes are always dicey, and it’ll be unfair to conclude that this is what Dami gestures at in his review. Yet, it is easy to see the attraction of innovation. Tech companies around the world have made this a way of life. Nigerian artists require it to stay alive. And the world makes extreme accommodations for those we anoint innovators. I’m however convinced that to constantly change is to betray an existential anxiety. It’s a quality associated with youth and its uncertainties. When we spot it in an adult, we conclude that they’re going through a crisis.</p><h4>3.</h4><p>To be lucid is to be clear, easy to understand, filled with light. To be lucid is to shine. How else are paths made clear other than being well tread? To make an object shine, you have to burnish it, that is, rub it repeatedly until the surface is smooth, capable of reflecting light.</p><h4>4.</h4><p>Here is a list of things you can burnish:</p><ul><li>leather</li><li>wood</li><li>metal</li><li>stones</li><li>gemstones</li></ul><p>The diamond is the most famous gemstone.</p><h4>5.</h4><p>At the release of her debut in 2007, the enchanting thing about Asa’s music wasn’t the words or the beat. You couldn’t even dance to her songs. She can play the guitar, piano, trumpet and probably others I don’t know about. Yet, her most important instrument is her voice. (If you’re reading this outside the Nigerian context, this is where you say duh, but any Nigerian knows the voice is a non-essential part of contemporary Nigerian music.) ‘Bibanke’ is arguably the vocal peak of that debut. It is where she pours all the pathos of her voice into a plea for a lover to leave her alone. Pleading for lovers to do or refrain from doing has now become an Asa specialty. As her career has progressed from ‘Bibanke’ to ‘My Dear’, it is obvious the lyrics haven’t become denser. On the contrary, they have achieved a kind of minimalism. The emotions, however, have been heightened. When Asa sings “Won la won o fe wa mo” (they say they don’t want us anymore), the ache of abandonment reverberates across language barriers. I haven’t even been ditched at the altar before, yet I hear all the pain that experience can bring in the plaintive “My Dear.”</p><h4>6.</h4><p>It is easy to assume Asa’s music is personal. It’s an inherent flaw of love songs. But consider for a moment the scope of love she has covered in her four albums and you will realise how nuts it will be for just one person to feel it all. This is all an illusion. Illusions are a play on the senses, especially sight. They depend on the assumptions our eyes make about the information they receive in the presence of light. Asa’s illusions are aural, and they stick because of her voice. She has burnished her instrument so that it can shine just enough to lure the listener into the emotions she has carefully crafted. Perhaps it has taken four albums to perfect that art. I write as a fan full of positive bias, but to my ears, that doesn’t sound like failure.</p><h4>7.</h4><p>I have <a href="https://artsandafrica.com/reclaiming-asa-90cf68aa399e">said it before</a> that I love Asa best when she deploys her voice in the service of the quotidian: the tale of a philandering man in ‘Awe’, the rude sister of a lover in ‘Bimpe’, and women going out for Saturday parties in ‘Happy People’. It will be silly, however, not to admit that these are mere asides in the Asa oeuvre. A bulk of her carrer is devoted to love in all its vagaries — love deliberated, desired and denied. Marianne Moore wrote that “marriage is a Crusade; there is always tragedy in it.” Asa seems to extend this ascertion to the whole of love. In more contemporary terms: it will end in tears. This isn’t a unique conclusion. The history of love in song has always been tragic. We are all Orpheus, forever singing after lost Eurydice. But rather than approach this melancholic preposition with despair, Asa insists on hope. She returns to love knowing its perils. This, too, is a kind of failure, but it’s the Sisyphean kind we’re all fated to if we will live complete lives.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=826d41bc18e3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Write These Things to Make Our Joy Complete]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/we-write-these-things-to-make-our-joy-complete-f00de9e143c7?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f00de9e143c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[oris-aigbokhaevbolo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[amatesiro-dore]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nigerian-writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 09 Feb 2019 13:08:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-12T09:54:42.443Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Thoughts on the appeal of writing about trauma</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DpaROwy_PVUdJ8ZZLXYITQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Brad Bird’s <em>Tomorrowland</em> is one of the few science-fiction films of recent years set in an Utopia. It is about a futuristic city ruled by a scorned scientist who will do anything to keep a tachyon machine running, so it can continue to project visions of an apocalyptic future, a self-fulfilling prophecy that he had hoped will stop the world from destructive tendencies but has only bred a people eager to embrace the coming doom. For a while, there’s been chatter among young Nigerian writers that the evolving culture of personal essays, bold and admirable as it is, is like <em>Tomorrowland</em>: writers writing sad stories and publishing them all over the world, creating a feedback loop that suggests that this is the only kind of story worth telling by young Nigerians. There was <a href="https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/where-are-the-essays-on-clapback-as-nigerian-literary-criticism-ba2a3711b6cb">brouhaha over this when Oris Aigbokhaevbolo talked about essays published in Catapult magazine</a>, which appears to have a predilection for publishing Nigerian narratives marked by trauma. Oris was skewered by those who thought he was trying to act like a gatekeeper. And in a recent iteration of this discourse, through <a href="https://johannesburgreviewofbooks.com/2019/01/14/conversation-issue-letter-to-a-young-queer-intellectual-by-amatesiro-dore/">an essay by Amatesiro Dore</a> published in the Johannesburg Review of Books, Oris was referenced again.</p><p>“Don’t be like my acclaimed friend, Orimalu,” writes Dore, “who currently has no story to tell so he bullies everyone with the techniques of dead white men in order to hide the fact that his pedestrian existence as a straight, mildly-achieving, middle-class Nigerian with girlfriend issues and concerns about our sociopolitical nightmare is unworthy (just my jealous opinion) of a full-length novel.” Anyone who knows Oris knows he is the one being referred to as Orimalu in that quote.</p><p>Oris is a critic with an affinity for style, especially the kind that makes music out of the restraints of English syntax. He loves stories that shine, not by the glamour of their subjects, but the grace of the writing, and he’s vocal about this to the point of being a dick. So maybe Dore is right when he says Oris bullies writers with techniques of dead white men, but this is only true if the critic’s continued proselyting on Twitter about the use and misuse of semicolons and other persnickety pronouncements can be counted as bullying.</p><p>The question of whether Oris is a bully or not isn’t my concern. He’s a grown man who can defend himself against such allegations. The telling part of that passage is that Dore refers to Oris as someone “who currently has no story to tell” on account of being a “straight, mildly-achieving, middle-class Nigerian with girlfriend issues and concerns about our sociopolitical nightmare….” What does it mean for someone to have “no story to tell”? Dore ties Oris to Updike, that scapegoat for stylistic writing sans substance, who he writes, “glorified the mundane lives of straight white men during the era of the Civil Rights movement in America, apartheid in South Africa and other exotic world problems of our time.” It therefore surmises that Dore believes stories worth telling are those that aren’t mundane, that are about the “exotic world problems of our time.”</p><p>Dissing Updike isn’t novel. The narrator of Teju Cole’s <em>Everyday for the Thief</em> famously said, “Had John Updike been African, he would have won the Nobel prize long ago. Shillington Pennsylvania simply did not measure up to his extravagant gifts.” Our problems as Nigerians are a source of such rich material for stories, especially the kind that appeals to foreign establishments who have their own interests and agenda. And there’s nothing wrong in embracing this. If you have a traumatic story and the requisite skill to transform it into something that keeps the world in rapture, you’ll be a fool not to tell that story. But the possession of a Nobel-worthy tragedy isn’t enough to earn you a prize in literature if you do not pay attention to the craft of writing. “Tell your own Abiku story. Leave the critics to argue about form,” writes Dore, a statement that looks nice, but ignores the fact that the only Nobel prize winner from Nigeria, who also has an Abiku poem, is so devoted to form his work is almost incomprehensible to the uneducated reader. Form is not the enemy; mediocrity is.</p><p>Dore also considers the kind of stories that need to be written about “exotic world problems of our time,” an indication of what he thinks is valuable about his writing and that of the young queer intellectual he’s addressing. But to whom are these problems exotic, and whose exoticism have we prioritised? If there’s as much distance between a gay boy in Anambra state and a western audience interested in Nigeria’s collective homophobia as there is between me, a straight Yoruba boy who grew up in the South West hinterlands, and a rich kid in Ikoyi who controls the oil that powers my I better pass my neighbour, then whose parameters are we using to decide what is exotic?</p><p>Class is the single most important origin of injustice in Nigeria. Not sexuality. Not Ethnicity. Not gender. Class. And if my one year of working with Oris — during which he was a fantastic line editor of my work — was not spent with a man who has created a mirage of himself, I do not believe Dore can say Oris is not capable of telling a unique story about how class works in Nigeria. Now, if Oris can tell a Nigerian story about class, and has the writing skill to pull it off, who does that story appeal to? If the audience that funds our storytelling isn’t interested in how the quotidian life of a Benin boy living in Lagos illustrates the class structures that define contemporary Nigeria — which I assume they aren’t, at least not to the degree of other ‘exotic’ problems — it follows that Dore’s conclusion that Oris “currently has no story to tell” can be accepted as gospel albeit in error.</p><p>“Harvest your pain, tell your stories and leave Orimalu to bother himself about your use of colons and semicolons,” Dore tells the young queer intellectual. Like the tachyon machine in <em>Tomorrowland</em>, admonitions like Dore’s combine with the realities of publishing in Nigeria to create a cottage industry of harvested pain. There are groups on social media platforms like Facebook and WhatsApp where young writers support themselves to practice and improve in the art of writing trauma. Nigerians are smart and ingenuous. So, this sounds like a practical response to a perceived demand. (I know there is catharsis in writing down traumatic events, but this value, in my experience, doesn’t carry over into publishing.) The appeal of trauma in writing is universal; what isn’t common is the elevation of this to the point where we can say to have no pain to write about is to have no story.</p><p>The irony of this is that some of the most successful Nigerian essayists of the past decade write about “mundane” subjects. Yemisi Aribisala, whose <em>Longthroat Memoirs</em> is perhaps the best collection of essays published by a Nigerian in the past five years, writes about food. Since its publication, every time I return to Ibadan, I remember her essays and how they have animated that city for me. Aribisala, through her unique obsessions and excellent writing, has expanded my sense of humanity. The same is possible for every aspect of our lives. I hope the queer intellectual Nigerian harvests her pain and collects her coins. But I also hope she does this knowing that the world we desire is one where she can also be free to write about cooking for her lover on a humid Sunday morning with windows open and the voice of a church choir singing in perfect harmony wafting in with the breeze.</p><p>The world’s interest in our stories as historically marginalised people is rational. There are stories that need to be told, histories whose excavations are necessary for an understanding of how we got here. We may be tired of the straight white man’s navel gazing, but we do not know enough about ourselves as Nigerians — gay or straight, rich or poor, male or female — to scoff at anyone’s story. The world may demand our trauma and be ready to pay premium for it, but to be woke is to be aware of how these stories affect us and know that our duty is to create a vision of ourselves that is capable of bringing forth freedom. In writing fiction and personal essays, I’ve discovered there’s an inherent appeal for stories about my misery, and little regard for stories that “spark joy.” We may mine our pain so others can witness them, but I do not know anyone who writes so they can retain the pain. We write to make our joys complete.</p><p>In his <a href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&amp;rct=j&amp;q=&amp;esrc=s&amp;source=web&amp;cd=4&amp;cad=rja&amp;uact=8&amp;ved=2ahUKEwjNstD0267gAhUQL1AKHfluCk4QFjADegQICRAC&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwordsfollowme.files.wordpress.com%2F2010%2F10%2Fteju-cole-eight-letters-to-a-young-writer2.pdf&amp;usg=AOvVaw2_VlURjFmP4yi9K6IFS_jL"><em>Eight Letters to a Young Writer</em></a>, Teju Cole writes, “Be courageous: Nothing human should be far from you. Write about murder and exam cheats; about depression and borrowed money. Write about the senator who lives in constant fear that her thievery will be found out, or the grandmother who wants to sleep with her son-in-law. What about the imam who realises one Friday afternoon that he’s become an atheist? What of the anti-gay activist who himself is secretly gay? Tell the story you need to tell.”</p><p>From Rainer Maria Rilke to Cole to Colum McCann, there’s a tradition of writers passing on wisdom gained through experience to others. Dore fits well into this genre. He writes in hope that the young queer intellectual will read and be able to navigate living as a writer in Nigeria in ways that will be safe and financially rewarding. And that is admirable. But as we bend to foreign benefactors with paternalistic desires and local mentors with misguided ideals, we cannot tell stories exclusively for those who need to turbocharge their failing empathy machines.</p><p>“You are writing so that you and the reader can share a solidarity in the complications of the human condition,” writes Cole. Prescribing a guide for what any artist should create may be fraught with potential misdirections. Yet, we have instructions that can save us from ourselves, such as the words of Mary Oliver, the recently departed “queer intellectual” writer of poetry who said, “To pay attention, this is our endless and proper work.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f00de9e143c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Whitewashing Sepulchres]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/whitewashing-sepulchres-1c123802342a?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1c123802342a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[enkare-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basit-jamiu]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jekwu-anyaegbuna]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pedophilia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 31 Jan 2019 07:43:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-02-03T03:35:53.958Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Enkare Review has taken down the story; what next?</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-HgE1cucDvaweTKcCb2gEA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Cover image for Enkare Review’s Inclusivity Issue. Photo: Enkare.org</figcaption></figure><p>“This is always a risk in art. The solution remains as it has always been: Get out (of the gallery) or go deeper in (to the argument). Write a screed against it. Critique the hell out of it. Tear it to shreds in your review or paint another painting in response. But remove it? Destroy it?” Those are the words of Zadie Smith in an <a href="https://harpers.org/archive/2017/07/getting-in-and-out/">essay published in Harper’s Magazine</a> where she writes about <em>Open Casket, </em>Dana Schutz’s painting of Emmett Till, after calls for it to be taken down in a letter written to the curators of the Whitney Biennial. That question of our collective response to what we perceive as bad art is worthy of consideration after the magazine Enkare Review pulled down a short story titled ‘Little Entertainment Centres’ written by Jekwu Anyaegbuna and published in their <a href="https://enkare.org/archive/inclusivity/">‘Inclusivity’ issue</a>.</p><p>In ‘Little Entertainment Centres’, Wilson, the son of divorced parents, was sent to his aunt Chimoge after his father “won the custody battle — not through the law courts but by sheer display of muscles.” The story begins as his aunt sends him back to his father after discovering he is a pedophile, and from there he narrates his journey back to his sexually aberrant father, who attempts to cure him by sending him to a mother-son sex-working duo. He defends his predilection for children in multiple diary entries, and talks to his mother who is undergoing abuse in the hand of her new husband. This story is noteworthy for how many ‘freaks’ it tries to pack into a single narrative like a collage of knock-off Diane Arbus postcards.</p><p>Anyaegbuna’s story was touted by Enkare Review editors as Lolita-esque, and it’s easy to see why they made that statement. Humbert, the unreliable narrator of Vladmir Nabokov’s masterpiece, claims his hebephilic nature is tied to a relationship he had in his early teenage years with a girl his age who went away before they could have sex. Anyaegbuna’s Wilson states that his own peadophilia is a result of his aunt forcing him to have sexual interactions with a little girl, who also went away, long before he became a teenager. But if Nabokov’s Lolita is a masterpiece, and Anyaegbuna’s story has been deleted off the internet, it can be surmised that the problem isn’t simply pedophilia. Anyaegbuna’s story has attracted ire from its critics because it portrays a character who justifies pedophilia by comparing it to homosexuality, a device often deployed by homophobic Nigerians as reasons for their hatred. The argument against this is simple: sexual interaction with children is reprehensible, even when it’s legal, because children do not have the agency to give consent to adults.</p><p>Yet, the reason Nabokov’s story is celebrated and Anyaegbuna’s story is received with spite isn’t just moral. The mere existence of disgusting characters who perform reprehensible acts has never been enough reason for its censorship. ‘Little Entertainment Centres’ is a poorly written story. The characters are barely human. They’re a collection of what one assumes is the writer’s list of deviants: A woman who has sexual interactions with her dog; a man who has orgies with widows; a mother and son who practice sex work in the same hotel; and a driver who brags to his passengers about having sex on the seat of his vehicle and makes sexual passes at them. You can write one or two of these characters into a good story where they’re humanised despite their flaws, but putting them all into a short story feels like the fever dream of a man who thinks all deviations from sexual norms are evil and needs to create a sexual boogeyman for readers to prove his point.</p><p>Skilled writers know there are no taboo subjects. What exists, however, are people who should not touch those taboos because they lack the tools to handle them with grace. Anyaegbuna, by his own admission, is only interested in shocking his readers. And mere shock is no value. Stories, even when they’re crafted to scare us, are valued for what they reveal about our humanity. ‘Little Entertainment Centres’ tells us nothing about being human beyond the fact that there are monsters among us, and it does this poorly than the metro section of a newspaper.</p><p>In their mea culpa on Twitter, Enkare review writes that their hope was that the story “gives you a headache, makes you angry but hopefully also makes you curious about this world that was built.” I’m eager to inform them that all it did was give me a headache. It wasn’t cohesive enough induce anger and definitely had nothing to make me curious about how the world was built. I admit this blasé reaction to it may be a function of who I am. Queer folks are angry at it because, through his shoddy excuse for storytelling, Anyaegbuna furthers a rationale for hatred without complicating it. The reader who agrees with the narrator leaves the story with nothing but a validation for their thoughts. So, while people who worry about humanity are angered by the story, those who already perpetuate hate will celebrate it in their closet and perhaps even in public, considering the currency of hatred in Nigerian media.</p><p>This conclusion should be obvious to any reasonable reader, and this makes the words and actions of the editors at Enkare review all the more befuddling. “This new issue is all about inclusivity and you will find brilliant, brilliant stuffs [<em>sic</em>] in it,” wrote Basit Jamiu, the fiction editor, on Facebook. “There is a story that will hit you hard for its bold theme and execution too.” (Let’s ascribe the pluralisation of stuff to the tendency, which I share, to relax grammatical rules while posting on social media.) Why did Jamiu consider a story about pedophilia fit for an issue about inclusivity? Why did he think it is bold to write about pedophilia in a way that conflates it with homosexuality? And what does he consider bold in Anyaegbuna’s poor execution of an unreliable narrator and pornographic details.</p><p>In their mea culpa on Twitter before retracting the story, the editors state their errors as not including a “trigger warning at the onset regarding the content,” a failure to “properly handle the particular sensitivity of the story involving children,” and the lack of an “Inside Fiction piece to accompany the story,” referring to an interview that would have illuminated the story from the perspective of the writer. On Facebook, however, Jamiu the fiction editor wrote “Everywhere STEW :D” an obvious expression of glee at the activity that followed the release of the story. That note on Twitter is obviously in opposition to Jamiu’s Facebook exhilaration, and this contradiction is at the centre of my concern that the story has been taken down from Enkare review website, with the promise that it will be returned in a sanitised state.</p><p>My attention was drawn to ‘Little Entertainment Centres’ by a writer friend who wanted to understand if his disgust at it was grounded in literature. I ignored the story at first, hoping to read it later after I was done with my chores. But I was shown the reaction of Romeo Oriogun to the story on Twitter, where he asked that the magazine take down his poems from their site, and knew that story would be pulled soon. A few hours afterwards, it was deleted and anyone who wanted to read it had to rely on people who had made copies in anticipation of the take down. It is important for writers to have a strong moral voice that responds to bad ideas with but what happens when people who have bad ideas understand that mere removal of the ideas from public space is enough to stave criticism?</p><p>Bad <a href="https://theconversation.com/when-bad-ideas-refuse-to-die-the-denial-of-human-individuality-61667">ideas have resilient lives</a>. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/science/2016/jun/28/why-bad-ideas-refuse-die">They rarely die</a> and have the capacity to survive underground for years, festering in the minds of people who are firm in their belief that they’re right and the world is wrong and someday they shall be proven right. It’s also well known that debating bad ideas often does nothing but give them a platform to spread. But rather than push these ideas underground or help pollinate them, I wish our impulse is to “write a screed against it. Critique the hell out of it. Tear it to shreds in your review.”</p><p>The fact that an editor like Jamiu, who is well regarded among young writers on the continent for the work he has done in curating a celebrated anthology can describe bad writing that furthers repressive thinking as bold should offer a pause to anyone interested in progressiveness among young African creatives. Some ideas that are believed to be consensus, accepted without debate, are simply not spoken about. The assumed consensus isn’t arrived upon via conversation, but fostered by silence.</p><p>There is little by the way of ideologies among many young people who have become champions of thought in Nigeria (I do not know enough about young people in other part of Africa to speak about them). With the exception of feminists, and perhaps those who have a background in religious thought, there’s little in the public space by that articulates what we believe in as supposed “progressives.” What this leads to is an attempt to enforce behaviour without establishing the thought that undergirds them, seeking to reap where we haven’t sown.</p><p>There are truths we believe to be self-evident and hope that all people agree with. But some do not know, many refuse to accept these truths, and we’ll be fools if we think there’s an homogeneity of belief. Outrage is useful. “We use whatever strengths we have fought for, including anger,” writes Audre Lorde. But I hope we don’t accept that reality that the response to anger has become hiding out and banking on temporary amnesia.</p><p>The last time a Nigerian poet was accused of sexual assault, his response was to disappear, hiding away to survive the storm and return triumphant. There’s a loss of opportunity when we do not perform a postmortem of misbehaviour, especially among people who traffic in thoughts and stories. We may get a sanitised version of Anyaegbuna’s story in the coming days, but I hope Jamiu is honest enough, if he still believes in the boldness of the story he published, to articulate the thinking behind his actions and open them to rigorous criticism. Otherwise, we’re simply here to whitewash sepulchres.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1c123802342a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Future Restricted by Affordances of the Present]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/a-future-restricted-by-affordances-of-the-present-9ee9610a83a6?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9ee9610a83a6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[tj-benson]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[afrosff]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fade-into-darkness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 Jan 2019 13:15:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-28T13:40:34.295Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Review of TJ Benson’s We Won’t Fade into Darkness</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gKyMfRe7YgqQcJ5v8zP9Kg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Image by IfeOluwa Nihinlola</figcaption></figure><p>Sometime between the mid 2000s and mid 2010s young Nigerians wrote short short fiction in online destinations like AfroSays, Naija Stories, The Naked Convos and on platforms like Facebook. Buoyed by the ease of sharing these works in personal blogs and on social media, and the exhilaration of finding an audience that might have been otherwise averse to other forms of fiction, this form thrived and became the breeding ground for what is now a generation of publishing authors out of Nigeria. It is out of that class that a writer like Bunmi Familoni arose with his debut collection of stories titled <em>Smithereens of Death</em>, which comprised absurdist short short fiction. His book won The Abubakar Gimba Prize for Short Stories at the 2015 Association of Nigerian Authors (ANA) prize just before his publishers disappeared, sunk into the quicksand of unresolved pecadiloes between its founders. It is from that class, and in that mode, that TJ Benson’s debut <em>We Won’t Fade Into the Darkness</em> has arisen, this time published by Parresia Books, a much stable publisher by Nigerian standards.</p><p>Most of the stories in <em>We Won’t Fade Into the Darkness</em> are tied together by a kind of high-concept science fiction idea: a future dystopian Nigeria is filled with a poisonous gas called Nigerium, the by-product of continued exploration of oil in the country, which leads to effects such as cannibalism, a matriarchal society and something the author calls “the great translocation.” These different effects are explored in fabulist stories that sometimes read like they’re from the same universe, and other times like they’re all alternate universes.</p><p>Short short fiction, or flash fiction as it is usually called, isn’t a green form. Writers like Lydia Davis and Diane Williams have fine-tuned its brevity and tendency towards minimalism to near perfection, combining turns of phrases and well executed punctuation with the economy of poets to create brilliant stories. In its Nigerian reincarnation, there were certain predilections that defined flash fiction: it favoured experimentation, economy of words, and a tendency towards writing for the end twist/cliffhanger. Benson’s work reflects the best and worst of these tendencies.</p><p>‘The Killing Mountain’, perhaps the collection’s best story, bears semblance to Ted Chiang’s ‘Tower of Babel’. (There’s rarely a better compliment in Science fiction than comparison to Chiang.) In Benson’s story, a man falls down on a mountain where he’s supposed to meet his end, but misses the tip that’s supposed to gore him and begins descent down a hill where encounters creatures that hint both at a humanity and hope behind what feels like a drop into hell. It’s a story that at times reads like a parable for anything that is supposed to kill a person yet doesn’t. Benson, however, doesn’t possess Chiang’s gift for naturalism. There’s little regard for a logical explication of the story’s premise, instead, the focus is on evocative imagery and emotions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*3fVEpMG5v9JO6OhUmfcogw.png" /><figcaption>Portrait of TJ Benson and the cover of his collection, We Won’t fade into Darkness</figcaption></figure><p>“The business of a dying world is survival,” Benson writes in ‘I Can’t Breathe’ and it’s disappointing that, despite Benson’s preference for descriptive sentences that approach the lyrical, the collection isn’t filled with more pithy lines like this. Some of the sentences in <em>We Won’t Fade Into the Darkness</em> are actually sloppy, confusing in their paradoxical clumsiness. “No one could ignore the poetry raining from the sky that day, but no one paid it too much mind,” he writes in ‘An Abundance of Yellow Paper’. That sentence falls apart upon close inspection.</p><p>In the same story he writes, “When the elevator doors slid open to Room 101, there was no one in but out of the room, through a small door beside the wardrobe, a figure was bent over a table littered with crumbled yellow paper shoulders jerking as the hands worked furiously.” The imagery is clear, yet the sentence opens with a stutter that is hard to dismiss. Sometimes the let down is due to misplaced punctuations, which may be forgivable in longer stories that do not depend on taut sentences. But short fiction isn’t forgiving of sloppiness. Some paragraphs are chock-ful of world-building details, that take a while to figure out. ‘Jidenna’, a story about a matriarchal society where men are endangered tools for child making contains this paragraph:</p><blockquote>“He had jumped out of the sweet dream and pulled the helmet off. The alarm system was linked to a chip lodged in Jidenna’s neck, programmed crudely of course, to set off once the bearer’s chip wandered too far away to receive signal. He calmed down a bit when he saw Jidenna’s cancer diaper on the empty bunk bed suspended above his by nothing but the sheer magnetic strength of like poles. Jidenna always thought this aptly reflected their relationship. “Relationship” was another clingy word from Jidenna’s vocabulary. The father feared gravely for the boy. If he did not man up soon, he would be pumping babies in one of those skyscraper apartments.”</blockquote><p>The stories in <em>We Won’t Fade into Darkness</em>, with few exceptions, build up to abrupt endings, often stopping just short of a revelation. This happens so much that the collection feels like a setup waiting for a punchline. The cliffhangers read like escapes from staying with the emotional intensity of the worlds the writer has created, and twist endings do not carry the weight the stories portend because the emotional investment required for this to happen aren’t made, yet. The colleciton feels rushed, and this isn’t just because the stories it contains are short short fiction. Benson seems to be stuffing his brilliant ideas into brief packages that barely convey their import, when they could be better served by further exploration. <em>We Wont Fade into Darkness</em> was a runner up in the Saraba Manuscript Prize, which set it on the path to publishing. It therefore appears to have arrived in a complete form to the publishers, and maybe this precluded it from further editorial support, which would have done it a world of good.</p><p>In ‘An Abundance of Yellow Paper’, the collection’s final story, the world has become averse to poetry. Words are rationed and poets are hunted down and killed. The need to extinguish their work beyond traceable digital footprints has also led to a worldwide ban on paper. Poets, therefore, write in secret on yellow paper cut from old novels. The writer in the story is about to write on an old copy of George Orwell’s 1984, and he contemplates what to write that “would be worthy of these pages?” He is killed while writing his poems, and in the aftermath pages of his writing disperse into the air and land in front of a boy who picks it up and reads the words, “We won’t fade into darkness.”</p><p>The collection ends on that line from Swedish DJ Avicii’s song ‘Fade into Darkness’ delivered with the defiance of Dylan Thomas’s famous vilanelle ‘Do not go gentle into that good night’. It is funereal, yet hopeful, and reflective of the state in which young writers living in Nigeria practice their craft. Many want to write “worthy” stories, but are also aware of of the limited possibility of that while they remain in Nigeria. Yet, writers like Benson continue to create worlds that pulse with vivid imagination even when reward isn’t promised. For all its flaws, <em>We Won’t Fade into the Darkness</em> is a reflection of that desire to write and publish and exist despite dire odds.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9ee9610a83a6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Singing and Writing in Tongues]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/singing-and-writing-in-tongues-151490efc1d8?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/151490efc1d8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[nigeria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[wande-coal]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tenis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Jan 2019 10:02:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-22T22:25:21.619Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Style in the spirit that binds Teni and Wande Coal</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0A85ilLqELPiX4mzOY4uNA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Teni performing at the December 2017 edition of Afropolitan Vibes, in Muri Okunola Park, Lagos. Photo: IfeOluwa Nihinlola</figcaption></figure><p>Teni the Entertainer is an artist of the social media age. She became popular through Instagram skits, which led to her first hit song <a href="https://www.musicinafrica.net/magazine/teni-entertainer-offers-fresh-fuji-twist-fargin">‘Fargin’</a>. And ‘Uyo Meyo’, her most recent track, was at first a viral tweet celebrating the completion of her degree, which she performed seated in a car with her graduation gown on her back. She has turned that into a full track, which also went viral over the December 2018 holidays. “Uyo meyo le oun osan. O kan mi,” she sings in Ondo, a dialect of the Yoruba language that is difficult to comprehend even for native Yoruba speakers. The central meaning of the song is captured in that line: I have been happy for other people’s successes; now it’s my turn. The gratitude of the song was a perfect end of the year mood-setter for Nigerians who are used to turning the final days of the year into moments of spiritual reckoning.</p><p>Teni’s career has been remarkable, not just in how it has blossomed through the agency of social media, but in the kind of defiance it represents. There have been suggestions that she change her brand from her now tradmark butchness to something that appeals to the Nigerian ideal of femininity. Yet she has stuck to being herself, appearing in a<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/01/style/nigeria-lagos-fashion-experimental.html"> New York Times article by Ayodeji Rotinwa</a>, where she said there are people in the industry who want her to be more girlie, before concluding, “I want people to say I did what I wanted to, not because they wanted me to.” Beyond voice and a unique fashion style, her use of language has also been central to her brand. Her sister <a href="https://www.musicinafrica.net/magazine/how-niniola-exploits-yoruba-sing-about-sex">Niniola has already turned Yoruba into a tool for subverting Nigerian prudishness</a>, and Teni also done the same in ‘Askamaya’. But ‘Uyo Meyo’ is interesting because of how most of the people listening to the song have no idea what she’s saying in the chorus, yet they understand the spirit of the song.</p><p>Ondo language and how its cadence is used in music isn’t new to some Nigerians. It was made popular by gospel singer Funmi Aragbaye, whose influence, writ large in Yoruba gospel music in the 1990s, can be found on Adekunle Gold’s ‘Ire’. Yet, even at the height of Aragbaye’s career, she didn’t go full Ondo the way Teni has done in ‘Uyo Meyo’ and certainly didn’t enjoy the mainstream support the song is garnering. I watched a friend on instagram close her eyes and and lift her hands as she sang ‘Uyo Meyo’ and I was reminded again of how songs possess the power to transport without the need for language.</p><p>In Nigeria’s very pentecostal christian culture, speaking in tongues is the ultimate sign of being filled in the spirit. It’s so popular it has become the trope for satirising Nigerian christianity. At the core of this idea of speaking in tongues is the nature of language and how it can be subverted. If language, as some say, is a conspiracy between two people, then speaking in tongues works based on the idea that two parties—man-to-deity, man-to-man—can still participate in that conspiracy through their spirits without understanding the syntax of their words.</p><p>Of course language doesn’t always depend on words to complete its magic, and music is the apotheosis of this. Beyond the obvious way in which music notation works as a language that can be translated without words, a song can also carry a mood — joy, contention, melancholy — just by a simple progression of sounds and rhythms that will be recognised across cultures. This kind of tongue is what Teni understands and puts to good use in ‘Uyo Meyo’.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FjV4TJmik9bY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DjV4TJmik9bY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FjV4TJmik9bY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ee49c8bbd5a80576d8d0b1f9d295f10b/href">https://medium.com/media/ee49c8bbd5a80576d8d0b1f9d295f10b/href</a></iframe><p>Another Nigerian who has made this understanding of tongues at the level of glossolalia a tool to hoodwink his audience is Wande Coal. After years of wandering the wilderness of Nigerian music post Mo’hits, the premier Nigerian male pop vocalist started a come back that now needs a solid album to be complete. If he pulls this off, it’ll be the first time since Fatai Rolling Dollar that a beloved Nigerian artist has left the limelight and made a successful return. Of the songs he has released on this comeback trail, perhaps the most popular have been ‘Iskaba’ and ‘So mi so’. If Teni’s work in ‘Uyo Meyo’ can be likened to the pentecostal idea of speaking in known tongues, Wande Coal’s work is speaking in unknown tongues.</p><p>When ‘Iskaba’ was released, I made the mistake of treating it like every other Nigerian pop song: filled with nonsensical words but mixed with great melody and a fantastic beat that is mastered to make people move their bodies. YouTube dance videos that contributed to the popularity of the song was all the evidence I needed to dismiss it. It was popular, but vacuous; nothing to think about. Then Wande Coal released ‘So Mi So’ and I was forced to review my assessment. He wasn’t just performing mediocre lyrics, a la Wizkid. Once I paid attention to the rumblings in ‘So Mi So’, which, really, are mostly mumbled Yoruba words, I realised how I missed its glossolalic undertone. The man was speaking in tongues, and it was flying over my head.</p><p>My elevation of Wande Coal’s gibberish to glossolalia probably flatters his intentions. After all, where Teni uses her Ondo tongue to praise in a way that her audience connects with, Wande Coal sticks to a more carnal use of glossolalia: his songs are sexual, and therefore do not stray away from the theme of male Nigerian pop artists: sex, money and sometimes god. Yet, the way these pop artists use language is fascinating, because they achieve in their work what the most Nigerian writers aspiring towards the avant-garde still struggle to figure out.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FIbPv2C8R__0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DIbPv2C8R__0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FIbPv2C8R__0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/325fccc1f49426bcab0f91d82d754d49/href">https://medium.com/media/325fccc1f49426bcab0f91d82d754d49/href</a></iframe><p>From the days of Amos Tutuola’s <em>The Palmwind Drunkard</em>, the idea of an English language that is able to translate the cadence of Nigerian speech while retaining all the qualities of the finest literature has been a concern for writers. Chinua Achebe achieved the efficiency and simplicity of his work by translating Igbo sayings in to English and incorporating them into conversation, Ken Saro Wiwa wrote entirely in pidgin English in his novel <em>Sozaboy</em>, a feat that was repeated by Eghosa Imasuen in <em>Fine Boys</em>, and Lola Shoneyin and Ayobami Adebayo have used a combination of transliterations and the the cadence of Yoruba language to great effect in their novels <em>The Secret Lives of Baba Segi’s Wives</em> and <em>Stay With Me</em>. Poets like Niyi Osundare have also taken Yoruba oral traditions and made them the hallmark of their poetry in English language. Some of these writers have done “unheard of things” with the English language, yet there’s a freedom with which the contemporary Nigerian pop artist approaches language that writers can only dream of.</p><p>This isn’t an attempt to establish that what Nigerian artists accomplish with words in song exceeds what their writing counterparts can pull off. But comfort with language and the freedom to experiment with it is an asymptote writers are still approaching. Nigerian artists know that no matter how they bend language in their songs, the audience will pay attention. This is because they can always bank on dance to propagate their music. But with that knowledge comes confidence. The publishing industry may not accommodate this, yet, but that confidence is necessary for freedom that births the best kind of art.</p><p>My hope is that there’s something on the horizon in Nigerian art that changes our relationship to the English language. A kind of writing that Tope Folarin in his essay<a href="https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/accessibility-robert-irwin-chinua-achebe-chimamanda-ngozi-adichie-imbolo-mbues-behold-dreamers/"> <em>Against Accessiblity</em></a> describes as:</p><blockquote>“This restlessness, this stopping and starting and landing on something new, then moving past the new to something almost incomprehensible but not quite, this initial inaccessibility that coalesces into something almost transcendent … <em>this </em>is art, or what art should be.”</blockquote><p>In an essay titled <a href="https://www.nybooks.com/daily/2017/08/21/glossing-africa/"><em>Glossing Africa</em></a>, Namwali Serpell writes, “It is striking that, given the robustness of African fiction now — it has been heralded as “a new wave” at least thrice in the last decade — its experimentalism still seems to be limited to linguistic play, genre bending, and narrative convolutions of time and space. What about playing with the <em>book</em>?” But I do not even think contemporary Nigerian writing has extended its experimetalism to lingustic play. There’s a lot of thematic experimentalism heralded by writers who have long written outside the margins of realism. But the freedom I hope for is one that is allowed to play with the English language, and bend it into shapes that fit our local desires in ways pop artists have accomplished with music.</p><p>The closest contemporary Nigerian writing has come to this involves imitations. For example, there’s a crop of writers who attempt to copy the style of Kenyan writer Biyavanga Wainana, but that aspirational project has produced a total of two good essays by <a href="https://granta.com/africas-future-has-no-space/">Pwaangulogii Dauod</a> and <a href="https://enkare.org/2017/07/17/finding-binyavanga/">Sada Malumfashi</a>. I’m a fan of imitation, or as we like to say, “fake it till you make it.” But <a href="https://www.narrativemagazine.com/issues/spring-2012/classics/lesson-master-cynthia-ozick">Cynthia Ozick wrote</a>, “Rapture and homage are not the way. Influence is perdition,” and forever made me wary of my own chameleonic abilities. What I really I want is for Nigerian writers to be more like pop singers. I want an Ondo writer who can craft a transcedent style out of English language based on her own dialect or one that can make apparent gibberish sane. In <a href="https://lithub.com/eileen-myles-in-conversation-with-ben-lerner/">an interview about her work, the poet Eileen Myles said</a>, “I think that’s avant-garde — the meeting of need and language.” It will require, confidence, skill and maybe some movement of the spirit, but that meeting of language and need will happen someday.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=151490efc1d8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Falz and the Limits of Sentimentality]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/falz-and-the-limits-of-sentimentality-b78e044b6e84?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b78e044b6e84</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[up-north]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[knock-out-blessing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sentimentality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[falz]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Jan 2019 20:01:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-19T11:51:55.725Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why the crutch works for Nigerian films but fails the rapper</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LF-VMkE5Vvx7-2qVJyqNiA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Rapper Falz performing at See Me Live in December 2017. Photo: IfeOluwa Nihinlola</figcaption></figure><p>In 2018, Brandon Stanton, the creator of Humans of New York, <a href="https://thenerveafrica.com/22705/the-story-collector-humans-of-new-york-takes-on-egypt-and-nigeria/">visited Nigeria as part of a trip to various countries in Africa</a>. He shared stories from the country across social media and they were received positively. Stanton was showing Nigerian stories that were “touching” in their realness and many Nigerians were grateful. But there was a minority that witnessed the storytelling and recognised in it the kind of flaws that made <a href="http://www.warscapes.com/opinion/sentimentality-critique-humans-new-york">Melissa Smythe write in Warscapes</a>: “HONY presents photographs derived from this tradition but divorced from its vast potential for social import. Its brand of “humanity” requires no scrutiny, for it is designed to do what photography’s critics have accused the medium of doing at its worst: to capture, to possess, and to provoke in the viewer unprocessable, useless emotion. Yet this is precisely why the blog has not only garnered such an audience, but has also engendered a mass of imitators.”</p><p>Admirers of Stanton’s work believed Nigerians attempting a critique of it were ungrateful ‘haters’ or haughty middle-class folk who did not appreciate his good work. Yet, the idea that a work of both artistic and social import precludes criticism feels like an automatic critique of its creation. I’ve thought of that episode again as I’ve followed the response to the release of the single ‘Talk’ and album <em>Moral Instruction</em> by rapper Folarin Falana, popularly known as Falz. His embrace of social activism in songs and quest to become a champion of political music has made him the darling of many in Nigeria. If he had fans before, he now has fanatics ready to defend his honour in the face of anyone who thinks they have any reasoned objection to his work. He’s the messiah who, in the words of popular rapper MI Abaga, “…needs to be protected at all at all all all cost people.”</p><p>Falz knows that by declaring that he takes politics seriously and anchoring his music to that of Fela Anikulapo Kuti he would secure the love of a Nigerian audience that seems starved for conscious music. His work often feels like the product of a focus group survey titled “How to Be Popular and Distinct from Your Nigerian Peers in Music.” While this may sound like an uncharitable reading of his work, it’s one that can be applied to other forms of cultural production in Nigeria. The assumption in Nigeria, it seems, is that to create art that is widely accepted, all you have to do is pay attention to quality production and back that up with extreme sentimentality.</p><p>December 2018. I sat in a theatre to watch <em>Knock Out Blessing</em>, the second film by filmmaker Dare Olaitan, whose debut feature <em>Ojukokoro</em> was the standout Nigerian film of 2016. Olaitan is part of a growing crop of young Nigerian filmmakers who feel a fidelity to the form as art. Their impulses aren’t first of all commercial, as it has always been with the Nigerian film industry, but a need find unique ways to tell very Nigerian stories. When I entered the theatre, I was the only one there to watch <em>Knock Out Blessing</em>. A few minutes later, another man sauntered in and together we experienced Olaitan’s work. I knew with an audience like that the film would not stay in the cinemas beyond the usual two weeks. Later that day, I saw <em>Up North</em>, a Tope Oshin film that had been garnering rave reviews on the internet. The theatre was now full, but once the film rolled, it was obvious I was witnessing a lesser work of art. But <em>Up North</em>’s wide reception isn’t for nothing. It’s a well shot advert for the landscapes of Bauchi and the cultures of Northern Nigeria. Yet, it features a story so basic it can pass for parody. This was part of a pattern I used to categorise the big Nigerian movie releases of late 2018 into works of art or sentimental spectacles: <em>Kasala</em> is an artful piece of guerilla filmmaking, <em>Lionheart</em> is a beautiful appeal to women and Igbo culture; King of Boys is brilliant film noir, <em>Chief Daddy</em> is whatever marketing nonsense EbonyLife wants to call its recent releases.</p><p>The problem with sentimentality isn’t that it’s an inherent evil, but when a supposed work of art is predicated on it, the result is a bludgeoning of the audience into an emotion, which cannot move them into any kind of action. The audience isn’t told a story complex enough to allow them a myriad of feelings, or detailed enough to allow them see beyond the creator’s narrow intentions. Instead, they are shepherded into a room of canned feeling when they could be exploring a world of emotional possibilities. In <em>Knock Out Blessing</em>, the viewer leaves the final scene having gone through a story where they’ve been allowed sadness, laughter, suspense, relief. But <em>Up North</em> is so monotone you can plot the story arc from the first scene: it’s a flat line with occasional emotional bumps, all in their expected spots.</p><p>It’s easy to see why Nigerian filmmakers have bound their wagons of ambition to wheels of sentimentality. Nigerian audiences have established, through the success of mediocre films like <em>The Wedding Party</em>, that they are partial to unearned sentiment. <em>Up North,</em> therefore, takes the Nigerian Youth Service Corps, a program designed to spur Nationalism, as the film’s conceit. And people respond: thank you for showing our culture to the rest of Nigeria. <em>Knock Out Blessing</em> doesn’t appeal to your emotions in this manner. Even sex workers who are at the core of the film are allowed to be full people. You love them, you hate them, but they do not become vehicles for a PSA about the need to legalise sex work in Nigeria. This isn’t a dismissal of sentimental movies. The Nigerian movie ecosystem is at a stage where it needs to celebrate the artistic and the sentimental. The former is needed to push the boundaries of film, <a href="https://qz.com/africa/1516445/nollywoods-lionheart-up-north-chief-daddy-score-at-box-office/">while the latter is needed to make money</a>. In this case, the elevation of sentimentality because of its potential for commercial success can be treated as benign, but when it is evident in an artist who enjoys the moral high-horse like Falz does, it becomes malignant.</p><p>“If the signal of art is emotional freedom,” <a href="http://avidly.lareviewofbooks.org/2014/07/29/feel-free-on-the-difference-between-art-and-sentimentality/">writes Ashley Barnes in Los Angeles Review of Book’s Avidly</a>, “then an artist who wants to move her audience to group action, say to redress some real-life suffering, is in a tight spot.” Falz’s problem is that he doesn’t recognise that he’s in a tight spot. He thinks his mission to inspire Nigerians towards political consciousness doesn’t require other forms of awareness. His response to <a href="https://www.bellanaija.com/2019/01/olutimehin-adegbeye-falzs-hatred-of-transactional-sex-is-entry-level-misogyny/">criticism of his misogynist comments</a> was emblematic of this. Instead of reflectively considering opinions that have been repeated about his music, especially after ‘Child of the World’, and how they paint the picture of vanilla misogyny, he doubled down on his attitude towards women in general, and sex workers in particular. It’s not enough in the 21st century to claim that you “hate transactional sex” and expect your audience will accept that as gospel. Fela got away with his misogyny because he was a genius who lived in less socially-aware times. Falz is no genius whose flaws can be excused, neither can he torpedo his audience into the dark ages of social justice.</p><p>Falz fancies himself a moral arbiter who can speak about the ills plaguing Nigeria the way Fela did. His mistake, of course, is that he doesn’t realise Fela didn’t always assume moral superiority over his audience, and even when he did, the audience knew he was a deeply flawed man whose didn’t pretend to be perfect. Falz wants to be a crusader, a moral and political beacon in what he perceives to be a wilderness of music filled with hedonism. His challenge, which he doesn’t seem to appreciate, is well articulated by <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-accidental-wisdom-of-chris-jansons-drunk-girl">Kathryn Schulz in the New Yorker</a>: “What Eudora Welty observed about the novel is also true of the song: if it hopes to succeed it cannot crusade. That isn’t to say it can’t look serious political issues in the eye — only that, if it ceases to animate and start to sermonize, it will fail.”</p><p>Fela understood that the mystique of his work lay not just in the sermons he preached, but the music he created. He produced a unique blend of horns and drums that animates the body in ways no other brand of music can. Words are important to Fela’s art, but they are not preeminent. This is what an artist like Burna Boy understands: You can approach Fela’s essence without a regard for the words if you pay attention to the sounds. And those who aspire to Fela’s brand of consciousness cannot assume moral superiority over the Burna Boys of Nigerian music. Making bad music is a cardinal sin, no matter how righteous you are. There’s value in having words that move the listener, but all of that is wasted if you do not have the sound.</p><p>Falz’s <em>Moral Instruction</em> is an improvement on his <a href="https://thenerveafrica.com/19168/woke-falz-this-is-nigeria/">agitprop in ‘This Is Nigeria’</a>. It’s an album that aspires towards excellence with exquisite production. He milks all he can out of the Fela samples, and mixes them in ways that enhance his hip hop curd. But if the chatter about his work seems negative, he has himself to blame. Nigerians aren’t averse to politically sound music. The first hip hop production in the country in 2019 was Show Dem Camp’s <em>Clone Wars IV</em>, a mixtape as politically charged as anything Falz has attempted in his career, yet well received by the group’s growing fanbase. The difference, of course, is that Falz has commercial ambitions the SDC duo do not share.</p><p>Falz’s sentimental desires wouldn’t be onerous if he doesn’t want to be so popular for his political consciousness. He needs the audience to listen and be angry as a way to validate his direction and he’s annoyed when the response is anything but that. His desire for sentimentality has also led to a place where response to his work can only be singular: We will comment about it — either for or against — but it is impotent to move us into action. Right now, he can only have ‘fanatics’ and ‘haters’, but nothing close to the movement he wants. For that to happen, he needs to become something more than a caricature of consciousness. He should return to making works of art, not the ten commandments. Until then, his pronouncements will sound like that of a charlatan who has found a shortcut to distinction in a crowded field.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b78e044b6e84" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sharing the Transport]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/series/sharing-the-transport-844e120e3082?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/844e120e3082</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 02 Jan 2019 17:05:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-02T17:05:35.628Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=844e120e3082" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[We Don’t Have an Argument; We Have a Real Disagreement]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/we-dont-have-an-argument-we-have-a-real-disagreement-63e36c19e519?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/63e36c19e519</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[listen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nigeria]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[men]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patriarchy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 01 Jan 2019 11:52:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-01-17T10:48:36.302Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Listen: We Don’t Have an Argument; We Have a Real Disagreement</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BO26KbIclGZnmIJHFo3FFg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Women pausing during a procession at the 2018 Osunosogbo festival. Photo: IfeOluwa Nihinlola</figcaption></figure><p>I find engaging online discourse in Nigeria a challenge because of the sheer number of people talking. But I’ve tried to follow conversations on Twitter in silence for most of the year, because if you’re interested in Nigerians, you can’t afford to not pay attention to what they’re saying. Online chatter moves quickly from politics to culture to health to gender and injustice, with many making pronouncements that are loud but ignorant, or muted but sound. In trying to make sense of the noise, the most important thing I came across in 2018 was <a href="http://mocada-museum.tumblr.com/post/73421979421/revolutionary-hope-a-conversation-between-james">a conversation between Audre Lorde and James Baldwin</a>, two Americans who, as much as anyone else who has lived, understood the way injustice works and spoke about it in lucid, intelligent ways.</p><p>Baldwin is the grand patron of “wokeness”, yet Lorde spends time trying to make him see beyond his chosen framework for understanding injustice in America. This conversation has been an example to me in how even the best of us can be blinded by their passions and why listening to people, even in subjects we’re supposed experts, can be useful, especially if they’re living the realities of what we know in theory. Online exchanges are the opposite of that Baldwin-Lorde conversation. We rarely communicate with one another to expand our views of the world and therefore spend more time shouting into the ether than listening to ourselves. This has created a space where experts aboud, but knowledge is rarely transmitted.</p><p>This, for me, is most apparent in conversations about social justice. For a while, Nigerian men online were hung up on the way patriarchy functions as a label. Many wanted women to talk about the evil people do to one another rather than brand them with a specific men-focused label, and they were eager to let the world know that. I do not like labels too and I understand how they can preclude conversation, but as someone privy to Yoruba worldview, I also know the value of naming things as they are (I assume this is present in other cultures too). To figure out the specific name of a phenomenon is to be closer to conquering it. A pattern of behaviour can be a symptom of an overarching problem, yet it’s the responsibility of all who are invested in figuring out the problem to label the behaviour properly.</p><p>I understood this for the first time a few years ago while working as a research assistant on a project on Female Genital Mutilation (FGM). Our role as research assistants was to collect data through interviews conducted with the use of extensive questionnaires. Before administering the questionnaires, however, we were taken through a series of lectures on FGM. Through the use of props, anecdotes and studies, we were made to understand the way FGM is practised in different cultures, the danger it inflicts on children and adults made to go through it, and the reasons different people have for its continuance in spite of its documented harm. Yet, our charge as assistants was to simply conduct the interviews without trying to change minds. We were there to listen and write down responses, not proselyte and transform worldviews. The project sought a holistic solution to the problem of FGM, one that was better served by simple data collection than evangelistic verve to change one person on the field.</p><p>For the first time in my life, through conducting those interviews, I was able to witness how one aspect of culture can illuminate the way systemic oppressions are perpetuated. There were young teenage girls who had gone through the procedure and were ashamed of talking about it, old women who administered it and defended its practise, sometimes with superstitions, but other times with practical reasons such as acceptability in the community. Then there were men who were largely removed from the process, yet were the primary reasons it was carried out at all. Some of them remained aloof, telling me it was a matter for the women, yet they had wives who needed their permission before even broaching the subject. One man looked at me and asked, “Are you married?” I replied no. “Imagine if you were married and your woman is at home right now as you’re here working. Won’t you want to be sure that she does not go around misbehaving?” I didn’t reply. “That’s why we do it. Because we know those who don’t do it are going to be wayward women.”</p><p>You may think this was the opinion of one man. But this was consistent with the literature we’d been exposed to. The pattern that started to form, even in my own small sample size, was that the practice is continued to keep women in control, to keep them chaste for their men. We can call the practice of cutting off parts of the female sexual organ evil of a generic kind, but once we establish that its existence is to benefit men, we must file it where it belongs: patriarchy. Thankfully, FGM is one of those practices where the consensus on its nature has long been established and many organisations are at work to eradicate all over the world.</p><p>After my involvement in that research, I studied many more practices like it. Before then, I had ideas about feminism that were shallow at best. So, I made a choice to read everything I could find on the internet about feminism and followed feminists on Twitter, where I could witness them react in realtime to people and issues. Everywhere I turned, women were already at the vanguard of eliminating different practices whose manifestations are particularly harmful to women and other marginalised groups. All I had to do was pay attention.</p><p>Like everything else created by humans, feminism is plural. It exists over a range, with different historical iterations. There are many who take the differences in feminism as evidence of its weakness, but it wasn’t difficult for me, a practicing christian, to understand how a movement can take on many appearances. If I was going to understand feminism, I had to listen to those who had been doing the work, in good faith, without prejudice or thoughts that I knew anything about what they were saying. This was another lesson from that FGM study: Our training as research assistants, however rigorous, didn’t eliminate the need to pay attention to lived experiences. The studies were nothing if they didn’t inform those experiences, and only in listening without responding to the urge to lecture others were we able to capture reality.</p><p>“Listening is hard when the sounds around us grow mean and ugly,” <a href="https://medium.com/wordsthatmatter/why-listen-is-the-word-of-the-year-7136ffee99c5">writes Nancy Gibbs in Medium’s Words that Matter</a>. She makes a case for listening not just as a passive endeavour, but an active practice. Gibbs also says: “<a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/06/upshot/when-beliefs-and-facts-collide.html">Social scientists who study</a> how our beliefs are formed find that in politically freighted conversations, we may keep listening but stop <em>hearing</em> once our settled views are challenged, our alarms tripped.”</p><p>I’ve seen Nigerian men who are otherwise intelligent and reasonable raise their guards when confronted with the ways our cultures actively oppress women. Perhaps they believe an indictment of their gender is a stain on their “spotless” personalities. And they’re right to feel this. But in many ways, the world is built to cater to our needs as men to the detriment of women, whether we actively participate in this or not. If our reaction to evidences of systemic oppression is defensive, then we become more than mere bystanders, but actors complicit in the continued oppression of people we sometimes claim to care about.</p><p>One of the more interesting things I see on Twitter is that whenever women talk about how an aspect of Nigerian culture affects them disproportionately, men respond by citing instances of men going through similar experiences. We know the idea that men are more logical than women is hogwash, but nothing emphasises this like Nigerian men trying to argue against what women try to establish as a rule by citing exceptions. Yorubas say, “Orisa boo le gbemi, se mi bi o se bami.” If men can’t join women in working to eliminate these injustices, the least we can do is keep quiet and listen. And not just listening to see people trip up in their arguments or pick out holes in their stories, but listening because it is the most humane thing to do when confronted with experiences outside our lived realities.</p><p>In that conversation between Baldwin and Lorde, Baldwin keeps saying “I hear you…, I’m not disagreeing with you…, I agree with you…,” yet it is obvious he doesn’t understand the point Lorde is trying to make until deep into the conversation. “It’s vital for me to be able to listen to you,” says Lorde, “to hear what is it that defines you and for you to listen to me, to hear what is it that defines me — because so long as we are operating in that old pattern, it doesn’t serve anybody, and it certainly hasn’t served us.”</p><p>We men who think we don’t actively participate in the things women identify as the scourge of patriarchy may think we are not in an argument with feminists, and we may be right. We are not like those men in suits on Twitter who say absurd things that they should be quartered for. We may even be smart enough to not fall for the nonsense spewed by men like Jordan Peterson, who know how to hide their misogyny under faux-intellectualism. But for all our protests, if we’re not actively trying to change from that old pattern that doesn’t serve anybody, maybe we do not have an argument with the feminists; “What we have,” like Lorde said to Baldwin, “is a real disagreement.” We may have the soundest theories in the world, but they’re useless if we don’t pay attention to those for whom “feminism has always been primal” like Wana Udobang says in her essay <a href="https://brittlepaper.com/2016/12/feminism-remembering-scream-wana-udobang/"><em>Remembering to Scream</em></a>.</p><p>It isn’t enough to be the kind of man who won’t rape women. We must be the kind who is invested in making sure other men do not see rape as acceptable human behaviour. We can’t be satisfied with a world where women feel unsafe. We can’t be the kind of men who only realise the humanity of women when they give birth to daughters. We must expand our understanding of the human condition by making space for women and people who exist in the margins to openly share their experiences without fear and listen to what they say as they give us the privilege of bring privy to their lives. Maybe we think women should listen and stop labelling us too. But there are more things at stake than the discomfort of inaccurate labels. We need to liberate ourselves, and the first step to that is listening.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=63e36c19e519" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where Are the Essays: On Clapback as Nigerian Literary Criticism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ifemmanuel/where-are-the-essays-on-clapback-as-nigerian-literary-criticism-ba2a3711b6cb?source=rss-13021d8f060e------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ba2a3711b6cb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[oris-aigbokhaevbolo]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nnedi-okorafor]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nigerian-literature]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[IfeOluwa Nihinlola]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Oct 2018 13:52:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-23T15:24:16.110Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*C0JxZHucjyuraq59UsusQQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ouidah Books authors at the 2017 Ake Arts and Book Festival (L-R: Dami Ajayi, Hadiza El-Rufai, Lola Shoneyin, Ayobami Adebayo, Nnedi Okorafor)</figcaption></figure><p>We are in the golden age of internet outrage, and Naijamerican writer Nnedi Okorafor was recently at its receiving end. In the early hours of 22 October, I woke up to tweets directed at the award-winning writer of sci fi, Africanfuturism, and mystical realism in response to a reply she tweeted at Twitter User @OniZay, who had said “I’m going to be one of the best writers to come out of Nigeria.” Okorafor said, “Talk is cheap,” and netizens came for blood. Twitter commentators described her response as unnecessary and mean, and the sum of the outrage was that Nnedi the writer is a trash person.</p><p>Okorafor doubled down on her response — which she deleted — claiming it was her way of encouraging the lady in a manner similar to what she says to her students. A bit of twitter sleuthing confirms that “talk is cheap” is indeed favoured by Okorafor in response to people talking about writing. But in the world of Twitter gaffes, Nnedi was a repeat offender who is also notorious for being openly brittle towards criticism of her work. Therefore, there was no room for carefully considering her statement and parsing it for intent; only attacks that extended beyond her personality to the quality of her work. She went from being a trash person to a producer of trash writing.</p><p>Appraisal and criticism of Okorafor’s massive oeuvre will require more space than Twitter provides. But this much is clear: to type “talk is cheap” in reply to a stranger’s desire isn’t a typical show of encouragement. It is an expression of doubt that the person stating the desire lacks the ability to follow through on it. It is understandable if Nnedi has always used this as a means to encourage her students. But the internet is not her classroom, neither are Twitter strangers her students. The art of <em>unlooking</em> is essential on Twitter, and those who consider the reply condescending and unnecessary aren’t wrong. Okorafor, however, has her defenders, some of them Nigerian writers who agree with her version of tough love. And it is one of their responses that reminded me of a similar outrage in Nigerian letters, which occurred in January 2018, this time on Twitter’s rival: Facebook.</p><p>After a series of essays by young Nigerian writers were published on American magazine Catapult, critic and essayist Oris Aigbokhaevbolo made <a href="https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=10156056777883328&amp;id=829213327">a post on his Facebook wall</a> about the nature of the essays, which he claims have ‘slim thematic pickings for such a large country.’ The theme, according to him, is trauma, trauma, trauma. “As a reader, I’d like to read some good Nigerian writing about your pain, yes,” he writes, “but also about traumatic mosquito bites and dances and roasted plantain and spurned love and suya in respectable publications. If you insist on exclusive trauma-trafficking and mournful prose, be reminded that you’ll have too much time to be sober when you’re old.”</p><p>Aigbokhaevbolo is the kind of writer who will go for a literary flourish wherever it presents itself, so it’s easy to see how he couldn’t have let the alliteration in “trauma-trafficking” go to waste, especially when it fits his mission so well. The problem, of course, was that some of the young writers in question took offence at his criticism, and they, too, took their outrage to the internet. On Facebook, Twitter and Instagram, Aigbokhaevbolo was called names and his right to be the judge of good writing was questioned by writers like Socrates Mbamalu, who tweeted: “So writing about pain is now an issue. A sentence overlord says we should not write ‘trauma trafficking and mournful prose’. We should write about happy things. This is why a Ministry of Happiness was definitely created.” Mbamalu was ticked off, and more tweets followed. He was one of the writers who had an essay published in Catapult and it seemed Aigbokhaevbolo’s attack was aimed at him and his kin. Another writer who was angered by the criticism was Tolu Daniel. “That post was genuinely upsetting and reductionist,” he tweeted. “He could as well have written that, please if you can’t write happy stories you have no business in writing. What Rubbish.”</p><p>Beyond the pure drama of the outbursts, my concern at the time was how these supposedly fine writers were not putting their objections to criticism in decent essays that can survive the ephemeral nature of social media. I’m a Zadie Smith Stan, so <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/books/2001/oct/13/fiction.afghanistan">her brilliant response</a> to <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/books/2001/oct/06/fiction">James Wood’s criticism </a>of novels by her contemporaries, which he described as “hysterical realism”, always comes to mind. So does<a href="https://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2014/dec/30/african-writers-instructions-ben-okri"> Sofia Somatar’s response</a> to<a href="https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/dec/27/mental-tyranny-black-writers"> Ben Okri’s claim</a> that “A mental tyranny is keeping black writers from greatness.” But there’s always been a <em>bolekaja</em> attitude to arguments in Nigerian literary spaces, a tendency to fight rather than consider the statement of the other person, which reached its nadir following an out-of-context quote by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie in 2013.</p><p>In Nigeria, proper literary criticism written for public consumption is sparsely available outside the meagre efforts of places like <a href="https://brittlepaper.com/">Brittle Paper</a>, <a href="http://wawabookreview.com/">Wawa Book Review</a>, and <a href="https://www.thebookbanque.com/">The Book Banque</a>. Therefore, everything exists in a state of <em>faux-kumbaya</em> until someone breaks the hedge and makes a statement no one expects. What follows are ad-hominem attacks, wagon-circling and curses lobbed at opponents over the internet. Eventually the circus ends, but no conversation of substance occurs, at least not in the public sphere. The arguments either calcify into deep resentments or they’re dissolved over bottles of beer in Freedom Park, outside of the view of the public that experienced the drama.</p><p>Sometimes these arguments that hold over the internet are brilliant, like the conversation that occured after Kola Tubosun reviewed and misread Tope Folarin’s Caine Prize-shortlisted story in 2016. But these are lost to the sea of Facebook posts and Twitter threads, only remembered by the few privileged to follow them at the time. I remember the Catapult-arguments now, in October, nine months after their occurrence, because Mbamalu and Daniel are some of the writers who tweeted in defence of Okorafor. Daniel said: “but you people. talk is indeed cheap. you can call yourself anything you want. but can you put in the work?” Then he said: “you know what is cheaper? Outrage!” But the better tweet was by Mbamalu, who said, “The only thing many young Nigerian writers can do is talk. You are triggered by just two words? Write a fucking essay.”</p><p>Memory can be fickle, so perhaps these characters have forgotten that in their own moments of emotional outburst, what came out weren’t reasoned arguments made in essays but abrasive quips shouted over Twitter. Yet, here they are asking people caught on the other side of an argument to be measured. Outrage is difficult to sustain over an essay. Writing is hard work. It is easier to tweet a response than structure it into well-written paragraphs that will require rigour, which can’t be sustained by pure emotion but has to be coupled with sound reasoning. There are no high-horses to be climbed by writers who think they have a better understanding of Okorafor’s position, especially when they exist in the same culture as readers calling Okorafor’s work trash, and barely display better sensibilities in expressing their literary misgivings.</p><p>“And so today’s theme on Naija Twitter was clapback as Literary Criticism,” tweeted Aigbokhaevbolo. But where are the actual essays? *crickets*” And with that, a concern that started in my head in January finds its closure. So here is a hypothesis: in any argument among and about Nigerian writers, the essays will never come. I can’t wait to be proven wrong.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ba2a3711b6cb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>