<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Imani Mosley on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Imani Mosley on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@imanidmosley?source=rss-4f6401953066------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 08:36:52 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@imanidmosley/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Grieving]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@imanidmosley/on-grieving-d213a0963725?source=rss-4f6401953066------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d213a0963725</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pandemic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blacklivesmatter]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[grief]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Imani Mosley]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 May 2020 00:32:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-31T00:51:25.081Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RgKrUTT-krnhQMSLcw_riA.jpeg" /></figure><p>On May 8, 2020, my partner of ten years, my fiancé, and the love of my life Stephen Llewellyn died from the coronavirus, alone in a hospital in Ipswich, Suffolk.</p><p>Two years ago, he suffered from an accident where he broke his neck, leaving him partially paralyzed. Though he made amazing strides, regaining motion in all of his limbs, he spent most of the last two years in hospital. He continued to charm everyone around him, including no-nonsense matrons and unsmiling doctors, much to my amusement and sometimes chagrin. But one incident stuck in my mind. While he was at a spinal rehabilitation facility in Sheffield, he saw a psychologist, something I had been urging him to do for some time. After he saw her, he called me and said, “I can’t do this.” I bristled at the statement; getting him to see a mental health expert had been no easy feat. I asked him what had transpired and he responded with “she didn’t know On Death and Dying.” I pressed him on this. “She didn’t know Elisabeth Kübler-Ross’s <em>On Death and Dying</em>, how could I possibly talk to her about anything?” I found this odd for several reasons. Stephen was not one who had experienced a great deal of loss in his life. His father had died some time ago, a complicated relationship. More recently, his mother had died after an amazingly full life and his brother had died somewhat unexpectedly. And while those losses lay heavy on him, that was his general personal experience with death and grieving. He was in his early seventies so more of his friends and colleagues were passing away but nothing quite as close as these familial losses. Also, he knew what a thing that was to say to me. My life has been shaped by grief. The loss of my grandparents as a child traumatized me as I watched them die slow agonizing deaths to colon cancer. At one point, my schedule was defined by funerals. I tried to commit suicide. My best friend was killed when I was eighteen. I closed myself off. As such, I was struck that this would be the thing that would stop him from continuing seeing this person.</p><p>I muse on it now because I think it was after that conversation that I began to think more about grief. That may need to be explained because as I said before, grief has been the prevailing actor in my life. I started to think about grief as a mode of being, one that exists beyond the model with which we often associate it. That these stages of death and dying appear and reappear throughout our lives as we experience loss — loss of ourselves, loss of the things that make us who we are, loss of trust, loss of reason. And in this moment, we are all grieving. We have all become grief. As such, these stages become embodied, more than just ways of thinking or dealing with situations. We exhibit them in our actions, speech, relationships. This writing is an examination of this physicality of grief, both from my personal perspective and from what I see around me. The hope is that at some point, we’ll reach acceptance but I would like to re-term that for in some of these cases, acceptance is negative, not neutral. Perhaps, we will reach peace or joy or blessedness. More likely, we will continue to re-present grief until we have worn ourselves out.</p><h4>Denial</h4><p>When we think of denial in terms of grief, it is more protective than foolhardy. Recognizing loss, especially at the outset, can be more than our psyches can bear so we hide the truth from ourselves, just slightly out of view, in order to survive. When we embody grief as a result of the continual failing of our societal institutions, denial is less of a protective mechanism and more a way of rationalizing how we could even exist within said institutions. “We’re a city on a hill, there’s no way we would allow 100,000 of our fellow Americans to die needlessly.” “Of course our healthcare system is the best in the world.” “I’m sure we will provide for everyone who is out of work at this time.” “The police are here to serve and protect.” Denial keeps (some of) us from the pain and painful work of divestment. To divest means giving up on that subtle (and not-so-subtle) indoctrination that affects all of us at one point or another in our lives as Americans. Buying in to the American promise is key; the belief built around the idea of specialness, men aspiring to greatness, present at a predestined time to build a nation is what motivates us to continue the project that is <em>America</em>. That belief does not allow any space for questioning. There is no room for discussion. So we find ourselves left with two choices: either wean ourselves from the breast of manifest destiny or live continually, actively, disastrously in denial.</p><h4>Anger</h4><p>The anger of grief is one of frustration, unfairness, deprival, anguish, and deep pain. We feel as if we are suffering a blow that no one shares and that in and of itself brings about anger and rage — why is it that we are to go it alone? That distance and isolation is not unlike the anger of this moment, the anger of a lived and embodied grief. While Stephen was definitely in the category of “at risk,” his death was not foretold. He caught the coronavirus while in the hospital for something else. And while I know that the doctors, nurses, and all the staff were doing everything they could for him, in the past two years I have become intimately acquainted with the NHS. I have seen what the underfunding and undermining of an institution looks like and the disastrous results that follow. And as I struggle to plan a funeral I cannot attend in a country I cannot go to, I have to reconcile myself with my own anger and rage when I see government officials flouting their own rules for their benefit.</p><p>And now I find myself teeming with a different but related kind of anger, one that can only come from the manifestation of grief.</p><blockquote>To be Black in America is to live in a <em>state of siege</em>. This siege-ness has become ever more palpable following the protests in Ferguson, Missouri, in response to the murder of Mike Brown in 2014 … The plantation, as a quasi-sovereign territory ruled by the white men who had nearly absolute control over the land and people they owned, was an exercise in biopower (control of and subjugation over bodies) and necropower (control over life and death) … The plantation and subsequent violence of Reconstruction and the Jim Crow era created, enacted, and solidified a gendered binary of violence regarding black men and black women that is still in practice today.¹</blockquote><p>That Mbembian <em>state of siege</em> to which I allude directly leads to a fomenting of anger that is unbridled, seething, grieving. It is the kind of anger that can only come from centuries of anguish. Those Black people who are descendants of slaves are unwilling participants in trauma, both past and ongoing, what Joy DeGruy terms “post-traumatic slave syndrome.”² And trauma, like grief, can manifest in the body. Trauma, like siege, can paralyze, numb, terrify, and enrage. We are seeing it now — trauma made real, anger as action, bodies and voices, fire and flesh. Rioting is an act of grief just as much as it is an act of anger. It is the making visible of wounds, asking the question “why is it that we are to go it alone?” Why are we to endure this pain, this suffering that was foisted upon us that we experience in darkness? Why? — ever the question screamed by those facing the unimaginable.</p><h4>Bargaining</h4><p>Bargaining is perhaps the most futile of these steps, in our own personal grief as well as in this embodied grieving, for how can you bargain with systems built upon the ensuring of your destruction, failure, and ill-being? Pleading with the afterlife is always more for ourselves and the soothing of our own souls than anything else; if only we could have one more day, one more hour, we could say everything we ever wanted to say to the people we loved. But in this grief made realized, to bargain is to deny ourselves, to remain ensnared in a trap that will devour us, eventually. Bargaining is about control, it’s about power. We yearn to reclaim power over something so incredibly insurmountable. But is capitalism as fixed as death? Are governments?</p><p>For so much of this model, these steps are intertwined. Parsing them out might play to our reason but grief is unreasoned as so this should be. To bargain is to deny. Bargaining arises from frustration. I cry and plead for more time with Stephen because I’m angry that he was taken away from me. We were not yet finished. I bargain not because I think it will bring him back but because my love acts beyond reason. So perhaps, while bargaining may be futile, it might be the most complex, the most earnest, the most sanctified. Because tucked away inside those pleas is hope, hope that there is something out there, something that you could wield or control, that would be able to do the unthinkable.</p><h4>Depression</h4><p>Depression is a tool wielded against the body politic in this age of grief.</p><p>I’ll start by saying that I’m not totally comfortable with the term depression here as someone who has long suffered from chronic depression; in this case, I’d like to think of <em>depressing</em> as an act, the creating of a state that thrives on hopelessness and despair rather than depression as a mental illness.</p><p>To <em>be depressed</em> here is to be made numb, immobilized by the sheer weight of emotion. I often think of that scene in <em>The Phantom Tollbooth</em> where Milo sinks into the swamp that is the Doldrums. He becomes sleepy, almost content to be catatonic, rather than engage in the fight necessary to pull him back to his journey. Depressed people cannot fight and that knowledge is weaponized. In grief, that catatonia can exist to protect ourselves and our psychic well-being, just like denial. In choosing to survive, we succumb to apathy. There is no shame in this. But it is not sustainable. A depressed populus cannot be healthy, a depressed populus can be manipulated. But I do not say this as if leaving these doldrums is easy. I feel the weight of my own personal depressing as well as what comes from the news every hour of every day. I have not seen my family in months, I’ve had almost no human contact, my home has become an echo chamber, days and nights are the same, time has no meaning. The strength I need to contribute to the fights around me is non-existent. And this continues, for every person, in every house. This is the power of an actualized grieving. There may be a reason why this is the last step before acceptance. There is an aspect of reluctance to both depression and acceptance, to be satisfied with the way things are whatever those things might be, to both bury and be buried by grief. To move past depression requires action, the antithesis of depression. But is the way forward that might come from such action really acceptance? How do we not find ourselves replaying these steps over and over ad infinitum? When we grieve collectively, as a nation, as a people, can there ever be acceptance?</p><h4>A Final Stage</h4><p>At the beginning, I said that I find the term acceptance problematic here. To be honest, I find it problematic in my own grieving process. Sure, one day I will understand that Stephen is gone, I will know it and face it with clear eyes. But is that what acceptance is? I will never be happy about it. My anger may be tempered by love as time goes on but I will never <em>accept</em> it. Similarly, I refuse to accept the cause of this embodied grief — the pain of people struggling, dying alone, in constant fear, using their last breaths to call out to those they love while systems — built to be unjust — profit, terrorize, and control. Acceptance signifies an ending. The grieving has stopped or at least has become manageable. And perhaps that’s a survival tactic, so we don’t spend our lives mired in an entrenched sadness. But that’s not a real ending and it is perhaps foolish to believe that such a thing exists.</p><p>So what does the end of my grief look like? It’s hard to say. There is a fear that if you stop grieving, you’ll stop remembering, stop loving. I understand that fear. Everything around me reminds me of my life with Stephen and nothing will change that. My hope is that I will react with love rather than sadness but I don’t read that as acceptance. It’s something else, something better. Acceptance is passive and I choose to be active. I think as such, in this moment of confusion, pain, anger, this moment of grief, that we should also strive for action over acceptance. Death is what causes grief in our individual lives and that can not be removed. But we can remove what causes our collective grief, or at least strive to. As much as we may want to change things within, whether we believe that to be community relations, a change in who governs and leads, etc, that will not do it. Because like death, grief stems from without, not within. It is made and thrives in systems built to oppress. So for those calling for personal responsibility and respectability politics, please understand that not one of us can cause this kind of collective pain. And there is no freedom from that pain without action.</p><p>Action over acceptance for action is love. Action lives in the reality of pain and uses it to thrive and make change. To act is to honor those we love and those we have lost. To act is to keep them alive. To act is not to end grief, but to live.</p><p>¹ Imani Danielle Mosley, “Say Her Name: Invocation, Remembrance, and Gendered Trauma in Black Lives Matter,” in <em>Performing Commemeration: Musical Reenactment and the Politics of Trauma,</em> eds. Annegret Fauser and Michael A. Figueroa (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 2020).</p><p>² Joy DeGruy, <em>Post-traumatic Slave Syndrome: America’s Legacy of Enduring Injury and Healing</em> (Portland, OR: Uptone Press, 2005).</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d213a0963725" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“It’s a Life of the Two of Us”: Britten, Pears, and Narratives of Erasure]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@imanidmosley/its-a-life-of-the-two-of-us-britten-pears-and-narratives-of-erasure-81ce9bc565e8?source=rss-4f6401953066------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/81ce9bc565e8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[benjamin-britten]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[music]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peter-pears]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Imani Mosley]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Apr 2019 17:40:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-25T21:42:39.203Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*BVykhJeEnUpxd6xOI_g1OA.png" /><figcaption>Peter Pears; Benjamin Britten by Kenneth Green (1943), National Portrait Gallery</figcaption></figure><p>On March 22nd, 2019, the Britten-Pears Foundation —the legacy of composer Benjamin Britten and tenor Peter Pears— announced a merger with their sister organization just a few miles down the road, Snape Maltings. A merger long in the making, <a href="https://brittenpears.org/2019/03/the-benjamin-britten-foundation/">the press release</a> discussed how this had always been the two’s goal: to have the home of the Aldeburgh Festival under the same organizational umbrella as what would become their archive, their library, and their home, the Red House.</p><p>In the years I’ve spent both at the Red House and at the Maltings, I have always felt a slight disconnect between Aldeburgh and Snape. I would often chalk it up to my usual desire to project my New York City-based sense of physical distance onto an English landscape. Despite being <a href="https://goo.gl/maps/GvD3sqoYrWRiN4JF7">only six miles away</a>, they felt worlds apart. Landscape plays a large part in this personal separation. Surrounded by the reeds of the Suffolk marshes and covered in mist that would roll in from the sea and settle on the land, the Maltings at Snape were a magical place. Having risen from the ashes after burning down in a fire two years after its opening, Snape Maltings has become one of those musical houses of the holy where devotees and pilgrims come to worship. The Red House, Britten’s and Pears’s home in Aldeburgh, invokes a different type of pilgrimage. For those who visit for the tour of the home, it is about experiencing the life Britten and Pears built together, not frozen in time but somehow still living, still radiating, still exuding their presence. (This is where I admit that the first time I went to the Red House as a baby musicologist over a decade ago, I cried when I saw the bed where Britten died in 1976, thinking about him being held by Pears in those last hours) For those like myself who come to do work in the archive or give performances in the library, it is a place of unending joy and discovery. It becomes so clear the plan both Britten and Pears had for their work beyond them. I often blush when I think about how pleasant my archival work has been in comparison to some of my colleagues. The Red House becomes a home to us just as it was a home to them. That drive on the A1094 becomes more than a winding country road. It is a journey between an earth and a heaven, the tangible and the transcendent. But despite the metaphysical distance between the two, it has always been clear that both Aldeburgh and Snape are and have been instrumental parts in Britten’s and Pears’s vision of the future, their musical future.</p><p>However, after the announcement was made, there was talk online about a key detail within this merger. The organization that would house the Britten-Pears Foundation, Snape Maltings and all of their entities would be called the Benjamin Britten Foundation. While the press release emphasized that this was a continuation of both Britten’s and Pears’s legacy, people asked if that could be possible when Pears’s name was being removed. The comments on the press release page testify to this friction. While there were some who supported the move, others voiced concern:</p><blockquote>It seems to make sense but a pity PP has been dropped from the name. — Stephen Mead, 22 March 2019.</blockquote><blockquote>I also agree with the sentiment regarding the decision to drop Peter Pears’ name as a consequence of the recent merger of the two organisations. Sad. — Lynne Bentley, 1 April 2019.</blockquote><p>Communications Manager Ella Roberts deftly responded to those comments but it seemed that her responses fell on deaf ears. Despite the insistence in the release that Pears would not be lost in this process, it seemed to many that a kind of erasure had already begun.</p><p><em>Erasure</em> is an important word, one full of weighty implications. And the conversation around the merger’s new name started to focus on this concept, specifically that of <em>queer erasure</em>. The headline for <a href="https://www.gaystarnews.com/article/benjamin-britten-peter-pears/#gs.7poz6t">Ben Baglio’s article</a> about the merger read “Why is gay composer’s partner being erased from his foundation’s name?” and over several days, I found myself coming back to this again and again. Something about it never felt right and in trying to discover just why this was my reaction helped me to understand why I had been so concerned about the naming of this new foundation. In the days following the announcement, many people asked for my thoughts as well as sharing their initial feelings and in the first few days, I too thought that the removal of Pears’s name was a kind of queer erasure. But I stepped back from that feeling in order to try to evaluate it with some kind of distance. Just what do we mean when we invoke the politics of erasure?</p><p>Queer erasure as a concept has a cultural history, often applied to the kind of revisionism that has taken place in cultural objects such as <a href="https://janetmock.com/2015/08/14/stonewall-film-lgbt-history/">movies</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@caitlyncads/bisexual-erasure-in-popular-televison-series-e8461ddf635c">television</a>, and <a href="https://www.themarysue.com/harry-potter-and-the-goblet-of-queer-erasure/">books</a>. There is a scholarly parallel as well, focusing on such issues as canon formation, archives, and institutional memory. <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.14321/qed.1.2.0205#metadata_info_tab_contents">Jamie Scot writes</a> about the creation of the ONE Archives and the role this and other archival institutions play in the halting of queer erasure in academia. The story of the archive mirrors the ways in which underground and marginalized cultures protect and preserve themselves:</p><blockquote>Starting with <em>The Well of Loneliness </em>in 1942, [Jim] Kepner soon amassed a large library of gay and lesbian related materials in his Torrance, California apartment, and began allowing researchers access to his collection … the collection was incorporated as the National Gay Archives in 1979 and then … the International Gay &amp; Lesbian Archives in 1984.¹</blockquote><p>The image of a library starting in someone’s home growing into a repository of foundational and, perhaps, hidden objects and histories shares a similarity with the story of the Red House. And this, to me, seems to actively conflict with the idea of an erasure-in-process.</p><p>For Baglio, what appears to comprise the heart of his argument is how the removal of Pears’s name decenters (or in his words, “straightwashes”) Britten’s own homosexuality. Baglio calls the decision “an insult to the LGBTQI community at large,” and that the renaming “sidesteps the issue of Britten’s homosexuality altogether.” The takeaway here is erasure, specifically the erasure of Britten’s own queerness. But this implication seems reductive, only allowing for a one-dimensional reading of both Britten and Pears, a reading that confines them to their homosexuality. Baglio mentions, albeit briefly, that the removal of Pears’s name “consigns Peter Pears to the status of an associate of Britten and denies his central role not only in Britten’s life and works, but in the work they did side by side,” but leaves this to once again highlight their status as gay men, rather than highlight in detail Pears’s own artistic legacy. My issue is not with Baglio here; his article reflects the issues that inflect discussions around artists from marginalized backgrounds. For example, how do we talk about Florence Price’s blackness and womanness without reducing her to those traits alone? (If you want to see <em>how</em> to do that, read <a href="https://nmbx.newmusicusa.org/plus-ca-change-florence-b-price-in-the-blacklivesmatter-era/">this piece by Douglas Shadle</a>) Britten, even Britten-as-composer, was more than his homosexuality and his relationship with Pears was more than a relationship between two gay men.</p><p>I find it difficult to agree with the narrative of erasure here for so many reasons. Britten and Pears have been retroactively afforded some of the privileges that allow for a continued queer storytelling: their status as British, white, male elites provides a frame in which talking about Britten and Pears as gay men is possible, permissible. This does not mean that queer erasure cannot and does not occur to all queer people. But historical negationism often favors the victors, regardless of the story, and race, gender, and class play a strong hand in who those “victors” are believed to be. The double portrait of Britten and Pears that hangs in the National Portrait Gallery in London is, I believe, a testament to this. So if this is not an instance of queer erasure, there needs to be something else that motivated my feelings of concern surrounding the removal of Pears’s name. I realized that my concern did center around a reductive reading of Britten. But unlike Baglio and others, it was not Britten-as-homosexual, but rather, Britten-as-genius.</p><blockquote>Our conceptions of creativity are inspired by these 19th-century images: …the genius composer with the stub of a chewed pencil, working out a symphony in her head, while she lies in bed, sick and alone.²</blockquote><p>We, as citizen-thinkers of the twenty-first century, are still beholden to the those intellectuals of the nineteenth century. Our ideas of genius, creativity, and innovation all stem from stories the Romantics told about themselves when coming face to face with the bourgeoning importance of the individual. And those who perform and study Western art music now are the most susceptible to those stories. Mahler composing in his solitary cabin at <a href="https://www.gustav-mahler.eu/index.php/plaatsen/168-austria/steinbach-am-attersee/3255-composing-cottage">Steinbach am Attersee</a>, Beethoven alone, writing furiously in his Viennese apartments, these images are fundamental in constructing the way in which we have come to understand not only the creative process but genius at work. It is always alone, sometimes tortured, even sacred at times. It removes any possible collaborators, performers, and even the audience. Composition as an act becomes communing with the divine and wrestling with the earthly — in solitude — to create a masterpiece. Work has been done, trying to counter, if not break that image but it persists. The canon is made up of composers who exemplify that lone genius myth, placing primacy on a specific if not embellished ontology. This kind of being removes the composer from the real world and the real world work of creating and performing musical works.</p><p>Britten’s greatest skill was as a collaborator, or rather, someone who was best inspired by the talents of others. This cannot be said of all composers; Britten’s ability to identify and isolate the foremost talents of the people with whom he worked was unparalleled. He wrote <em>for </em>people. Pears is the greatest and longest-running example of this: Pears served as a muse of sorts from song cycles to operas but was more than this. Pears was Britten’s co-librettist for <em>A Midsummer Night’s Dream </em>(1960), worked on the English-language adaptation of Mozart’s <em>Idomeneo</em>, and of course, helped to create the Aldeburgh Festival in 1948. But Pears was far from the only person with whom Britten would collaborate: singers such as Heather Harper, John Shirley-Quirk, Janet Baker, Alfred Deller, and Kathleen Ferrier, all singers who had a vocal quality that appealed to Britten (he often composed operatic roles for specific people and the specific qualities of their voices, envisioning a unique soundworld for his compositions that relied upon the performances of others); instrumentalists such as Dennis Brain, Mstislav Rostropovich, Osian Ellis, and Léon Goossens; and others such as John Culshaw, John Piper, and Imogen Holst, all people whose unique talents and strengths Britten was able to draw upon.</p><p>It is difficult to think about Britten without Pears solely based on the strength and impact of their collaboration. And that has always been what their names together have meant for me. As I mentioned, Baglio uses the term “straightwash” but for me, I think the analogous term is “geniuswash.” Just as Baglio states that he does not think that the straightwashing is intentional (but is inevitable nonetheless), I also do not think that the geniuswashing is intentional. But I do fear the repercussions. Our reticence as musicologists, musicians, music-lovers to give up on that solitary genius myth as a necessary part of determining what music is worthy of keeping, leads us down a path of narrowing the stories of our composers. The myth of the composer is reductive and reinforces a hegemonic viewpoint that is detrimental to the genre and only re-presents the worst take on who and what is musically valid and worthy. Britten was never alone. And the constant reiteration of that statement not only helps us understand Britten as a composer but helps to fight against the kind of musical gatekeeping that allows only certain types of composers into the canon.</p><p>I trust my friends and colleagues at the Britten-Pears Foundation. I know they are committed to the legacy to which Britten and Pears dedicated their lives. I know that Pears will not be forgotten or pushed aside. I also recognize that the merger and the naming may be rooted in practical, administrative, and logistical reasons to which I am not privy. But I do wonder what the name “Benjamin Britten Foundation” suggests to those unfamiliar with the composer. Does it tell the story of one whose artistic and compositional life was so deeply enmeshed with others or does it reinforce the idea of one man and one man only, creating art in monastic conditions? The story of Benjamin Britten and Peter Pears is compelling not just because they loved each other (<a href="https://boydellandbrewer.com/my-beloved-man-hb.html">an amazing thing, to be sure</a>) but because they were together in <em>all </em>things. As artists, impresarios, teachers, supporters, creators, they were together. And that union stands as a reminder to all of us who continue to look upon composers and their ilk as tortured, solitary geniuses to move away from the hagiographical and the deification. Their union stresses the very real world in which art lives and is created. It demystifies the creative process while simultaneously enlivening it. It makes them, their music, and their musical vision accessible to all of us and, in the end, I believe that is what Britten and Pears would have wanted.</p><p>¹ Jamie Scot, “A Revisionist History: How Archives are Used to Reverse the Erasure of Queer People in Contemporary History,” <em>QED: A Journal in GLBTQ Worldmaking</em> 1 (2014), 205–209.</p><p>² R. Keith Sawyer, “Writing as a Collaborative Act,” in <em>The Psychology of Creative Writing</em>, eds. Scott Barry Kaufman and James C. Kaufman (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009), 168.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=81ce9bc565e8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Left, the Right, and the Center (of Paris)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@imanidmosley/the-left-the-right-and-the-center-of-paris-93c1d5b0c5d?source=rss-4f6401953066------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/93c1d5b0c5d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[notre-dame]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[musicology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[paris]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Imani Mosley]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Apr 2019 02:20:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-04-18T06:59:11.507Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It is strange, the things that make us weep.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4wmgDMjfbTNWGwoYNLQMsw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Monday started off as a banner day for me; I officially submitted my PhD dissertation on composer Benjamin Britten and postwar Britain to ProQuest and had my examination card signed by my advisor and delivered to the Graduate School. While having lunch, I received a text message from my friend: “holy fuck Notre Dame is on fire.” Lunch stopped as I checked Twitter for news, only to see what we all saw that day: Notre-Dame de Paris, the cathedral in the center of Paris, was engulfed in flames. Watching the roof burn and the spire collapse consumed the rest of my day. In various spaces online, friends and colleagues speculated about the survival of L’orgue — the Great organ, the largest in France, the place where Louis Vierne played that final, resonating note before dying of a heart attack — and its future. Even knowing that cathedrals are sites of ruin and rebuilding (my work on Coventry Cathedral and Britten’s <em>War Requiem </em>taught me that), I grieved with musicians and musicologists over a place that was always more than a church for so many of us. Some of my brilliant colleagues have written and spoken about what Notre Dame and its history means to music historians, namely <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TE25qyusAL8">Margot Fassler’s interview with the BBC</a> and <a href="https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-cuthbert-notre-dame-music-20190416-story.html">Michael Cuthbert’s piece for the Los Angeles Times</a> (over on my blog <a href="http://www.imanimosley.com/humanistmachines/afuturenotredame">Humanist in the Machine</a>, I speak more about this piece, as well as sound studies, geospatial mapping, &amp; how the digital humanities can help reframe acoustics) But as I reflected on my own time at Notre Dame, every music history survey class I’ve taught explaining Notre Dame polyphony, and on the work of my friends, medievalists and Gallicists alike, for whom Notre Dame was central, I noticed something else occuring.</p><p>If you, like me, participate in a generalized political discourse on Twitter, then your feed is most likely home to retweets (and perhaps even tweets) representing the ends of the political spectrum. And what I realized was that Notre Dame was happening there, too. My surprise came, not at its appearance, but at the speed that it appeared. I knew at that moment that the Notre Dame fire would become something far greater than the destruction of a historical building. It became a flashpoint for both the Right and the Left, a battle between the so-called collapse of Western Civilization and the reminders of the destructive history of imperialism and colonialism. We in Musicology-land had our fights about this but more on that later.</p><p>“When people say more about a church in France than three black churches burned in Louisiana…” “A magnificent monument to <em>Western civilization </em>collapsing…” This may sound familiar to you. You may have seen worse, or perhaps let’s say, more hyperbolic than this. It was all present on social media as the flames rose. I mention both not because I think they are arguments with equal weight (I do <em>not</em>) but because they speak to something I have been experiencing over the last few years. History and its objects have never been off limits as far as becoming tools of propaganda but the last few years have put history in the center of debates about the now. And it can be a fairly destructive and problematic tool. Let’s start with the Western Civ portion. Remember how above I mentioned some squabbles among musicologists? Well, I’ll admit, I was a part of those squabbles. Lots of tweets and <em>very early </em>think-pieces about the importance of Notre Dame from the standpoint of music called Notre Dame the home to the “<a href="https://twitter.com/tonyprinciotti/status/1117880019965992960">first composers of record</a>” (a statement <a href="https://twitter.com/tonyprinciotti/status/1117952472188895233">later clarified</a> that tweet but got nowhere near the same engagement), or “<a href="https://radio.wosu.org/post/notre-dame-cathedral-birthplace-music-we-know-it-today#stream/0">the birthplace of music as we know it</a>,” and I won’t lie, those descriptions made me uncomfortable. Not because the Notre Dame school and its polyphony were not hugely important in the history of Western art music but because, perhaps due to our grief, we painted with terrifyingly broad strokes. [For a more nuanced &amp; thoughtful discussion around this history, please read Jeannete DiBernado Jones’s <a href="https://www.diberjones.com/blog/fire-at-notre-dame-de-paris-an-open-letter-to-my-students">letter to her students</a> about Notre Dame.] I worried because I have a long history with those to the right of me who would use classical music as a tool to reassert the idea of a dominant, superior West, creators of unmatched culture. For presenting the “radical” ideas that white European men where not the only people who composed art music or that the present-day performance of clapping (and shaming around certain types of clapping) is a form of gatekeeping rooted in class and race, I have been threatened with violence against my person. And I knew that even one word in a statement that hints at this supposed cultural superiority would become ammunition in the larger fight, a tool used to convince others that Western civilization (whatever that is supposed to mean), is decaying before our eyes, is “<a href="https://www.newstatesman.com/world/2019/04/notre-dame-was-built-last-until-end-world">never permanent</a>.” But this is a fight that more seasoned historians than myself have been readily engaging in as medievalists, those who specialize in Scandinavian and Germanic studies, classicists, and others see their work being taken up by the alt-right. Notre Dame is another example of how we musicologists are not safe from this, how things we love and value can be twisted beyond recognition. The social media landscape forces us, more than ever, to think about how we present these topics and how they live beyond us. I must acknowledge the medieval musicologists who recognized what was happening on Monday and how they combatted against it but I can’t help but wonder: when will there be another time when major news outlets are consulting us and asking for our expertise? It is already quite rare. Are we prepared, in that moment, to think beyond the music history sequence talking points? (Hopefully, it will not be in a moment of sorrow because I don’t know if I would have been as eloquent as Fassler in her interview.)</p><p>As a musicologist, I wept as this unfolded before my eyes. But as an African-American woman, I once again bristled at the immediacy of sadness poured out for Notre Dame and not for the three churches burned down in Louisiana. And as more and more stories appeared about Louis Vuitton and Apple pledging large sums of money toward the rebuilding of the cathedral, I writhed, thinking about the rush for an accrual of cultural capital, capitalism looking to make itself feel good while ignoring its own sins. And when it was finally announced that the White House would also contribute money to Notre Dame, I fumed as I remembered Flint, Houston, my home of Eastern North Carolina, and Puerto Rico. The critiques made around these issues are valid ones that must continually be made. But I also wondered in that moment whether or not Notre Dame had become a tool for the left just as it had for the right? The response to the fire definitely highlighted the glaring inconsistencies of how Americans prioritize certain events but another story that emerged was Notre Dame as a symbol of the imperial West, one that cared nothing for the destruction of indigenous histories and sacred spaces. As a result, how dare anyone weep for the destruction of a <em>building</em>, one that represents centuries of oppression. But is that a fair claim to place at the feet of Notre Dame? It would be wrong to say that France was not and has not been involved in an expansive imperialist enterprise that has ravaged various parts of the world. However, the mapping of that imperialist history onto a medieval site is not only inaccurate but short-sighted. This abstract formation of “the West” undermines the real damage from centuries of colonialism. Just as Notre Dame is not some great monument to the triumph of the West, it is also not a monument to the destruction perpetrated <em>by </em>the West. If history were ever as neat as that, I would be out of a job. I also bristled over the statement that my grief over Notre Dame meant that I could only value histories of oppression and religious terror over the suffering of now. That my grief could only be over the materiality of the structure rather than what it really was: a lost sound, a story now with a new path, a memory. Buildings, like other objects, can and do carry and convey meaning but that meaning is and always will be in flux, seldom tangible, often contradictory, but never static. The question that then arises from all of this is: is there a center?</p><p>I use the term center more as an allusion to Notre Dame’s geographical and poetic history as the center of Paris rather than an evocation of some kind of centrist reasoning. (Think Disney’s <em>The Hunchback of Notre Dame</em>, here) But the word also used to describe Notre Dame is <em>le cœur</em>, the heart. Many of the arguments, critiques, and conversations that have arisen from the Notre Dame fire are a strange combination of heart and head, logic and feeling; something that tells you that there is something inherently problematic with a government — that has time and again proved itself to be against the interests and rights of marginalized people — giving money to a Western European nation rather than use its money to provide for all of its own citizens. It’s something that tells you that we should be wary of conversations that center Notre Dame while other sacred spaces, the Al-Asqa mosque in Jerusalem and the three churches in Louisiana, burn. It’s something that tells you that buildings should not matter more than people but that buildings and their histories can matter, in weird ways that are hard to convey. And those somethings, that nexus of heart and mind, can make for an awful mess. But just as Notre Dame is sorting through its rubble, so should we.</p><p>Speaking to the historians and musicologists, <em>we </em>should ever be on the front lines, providing both empathy and reason, dismissing the inaccuracy of nationalists and contextualizing the narratives of the marginalized and oppressed. To everyone else, as participants in these formative and shared social moments, we should emote —whether that’s rage or grief— but also find a moment to think about where those emotions come from and what they do. Do they feed insular points of view, rigid with no flexibility and room? Or will those emotions reflect something far more complex? Notre Dame will not be the last experience like this that we will face. Venice and Mexico City sink into the earth and the sea. Everest is covered with human waste. The Great Barrier Reef will die. And in those moments, we will be faced with these same questions and problems. People will grieve. And those moments will always highlight the glaring inequalities present on a global scale, what tragedies we ignore, what people we leave to suffer in silence. And instead of falling into the trap of picking a side or furthering a narrative, perhaps we move to the center; a messy place that forces us to confront the problematic nature of doing history, reading and reacting to the past, contextualizing it, loving it, loathing it, and seeing it used by any and all who would dare. Notre Dame is central because just like that messy center of discourse, it lives in a similar place, that of doing history now. It lives between ideas of Western greatness and Western destruction. It concretizes the interconnectedness of the medieval, decentering it from an abstract West, as well as locating it in a present that asks us how we think about contemporary issues.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=93c1d5b0c5d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>