<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by matt polsky on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by matt polsky on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@innovator3?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 01:45:42 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@innovator3/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Unexpected Barriers to Sustainability Transitions: How Do We Speed Up Transitions?: Part 2]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/unexpected-barriers-to-sustainability-transitions-how-do-we-speed-up-transitions-part-2-5fc5a80104d4?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5fc5a80104d4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[speeding-up-transitions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mindset-barriers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cognitive-barriers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transitions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Jun 2026 04:09:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-11T04:09:06.159Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8V7yc5kqqKCj-nyjLjYqjw.jpeg" /></figure><p>“…you’re tripping over your own feet”</p><p>— Foghorn Leghorn</p><p>In <a href="https://medium.com/p/8d13025f0265?postPublishedType=initial">Part 1,</a> I reviewed the conceptualization offered by Roberts et al (2026) about failed sustainability transitions. This was their “The anatomy of <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2210422426000420">failed historical transitions</a>: An approach to expand the study of socio-technical change.” They showed that failures and successes in the pursuit of sustainability transitions are not the extreme opposites they are purported to be. There can be a lot of grey.</p><p>I added to their nuances based on 49 years of participation in failed big sustainability projects. Further trying to take some positives from that sad track record, here I pick up on their finish that we need to go deeper into asking “Why the failures?” My thinking is that could help us achieve — and even speed up, more unambiguous sustainability transition successes.</p><p>To that end, a few years ago, in <em>“</em>Leverage points meets sustainable transformation: Speeding up sustainability progress and 101 <a href="https://oidaijsd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/12-12-2-130.pdf">mindset barriers</a>”, in the <em>OIDA International Journal on Sustainable Development, </em>I wrote, in part, on both failures and one key unappreciated factor that helps explain them, mindset barriers<em>. </em>These are <strong>not </strong>the “tech” stuff in the above-picture — not that these are unimportant. But this is not their inning.</p><p>While each failure was unique, as there were other reasons, there were common problems with the way we think, or mindset barriers. These include somewhat well-known cognitive barriers, such as confirmation bias and recency bias; problematic assumptions such as obsolete common sense; and false binaries. There are a lot of these. (See the “Appendix” of that article.)</p><p>A summary of mindset barriers, shaped by my thinking since then, include:</p><p>· The most frequent one I see, in a variety of situations, are false binaries. This is when supposedly hard and often stark choices between poles are really not. An example was in Part 1 where failures and successes were discussed and found can very much be non-opposites. An even worse subset of a false binary is when someone is nominally aware that “Either”/”Ors”, a binary, could be converted to “Both”/”Ands.” This could be desirable as this realization of a more accurate reality might open up new possibilities. And yet, sometimes that advocate resorts to an “Either”/”Or” in practice — anyway</p><p>The Chart below shows four false binaries or problematic assumptions. (You would need to know three terms. <a href="https://masscommtheory.com/theory-overviews/framing-theory/">Framing</a> is ”… how something is presented to the audience (called ‘the frame’) influences the choices people make about how to process that information”. While <a href="https://wefixbrains.com/resources/what-is-reframing-and-how-can-it-help">reframing</a> is “seeing any situation in a new light”. <a href="https://naturalsciences.ch/sustainability/transformation/explanations_of_terms/sustainability_transformations_transitions">Sustainability transformation</a> is even larger scale societal change.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mOwIH2V8Utwe8ygujSXG0w.png" /></figure><p>The icons in the chart show four specific apparent set of hard choices that actually are not, such as going from seeing science and indigenous thought as rivals; that is, you must choose just one or the other approach to the pursuit of knowledge — to looking to combine them, taking the best from both. If you can reframe these, you open up new possibilities.</p><p>· Some participants in a sustainability transitions project may not be fully motivated because, while they have some level of concern or interest, or they would not be part of it, they are not aware of just how bad certain things are. This includes the exceedance of seven of the nine <a href="https://www.stockholmresilience.org/research/planetary-boundaries.html">Planetary Boundaries</a> that sets the baselines that allows us to survive and thrive. Therefore, they are making a false assumption. Further, there is pressure on some of us who do know (depending on the context) to keep this information to ourselves, so as not to overwhelm, worsen the possible depression of participants, crush hope, or discourage action. These must be reconciled. (I recently successfully did this with a new PhD graduate of my program at Prescott College, whose theme was the importance of “hope.” Our discussion found a “Both” situation. We could still encourage hope, while realizing the actual stakes.) Participants must have enough motivation to see the project through and enough resilience to tolerate the frustrations, I believe are almost inevitable, that come with sustainability transitions projects</p><p>· Curiously, few fellow participants in these failures brought up the “Why” question. It was almost as if this question was not important, or that it was better to focus on the next project. So I did not hear full perspectives on the reasons for these failures. That would have been valuable. Post-mortems for big failures should be done</p><p>· Another explanation for failure, so mundane that it escapes attention, is the failure of people to connect, the false assumption (at least I would like to think so) that decisions by the “Names” in fields, and others, that emails and messages to them can simply be ignored. When I reach out with an idea or suggested resource to the sustainable transitions community, the broader sustainability/environmental community, or those outside of these who could be brought into a sustainability project, I rarely receive a response. I did not originally expect such lack of courtesy from those in the sustainability field (Who made that false assumption?) that proclaims that values are important. So the conversation never happens. “Mindset barriers within gatekeeper groups may be one reason why sustainability initiatives and ideas not only fail, but can be non-starters” (Polsky, 2020, p. 20). You will never know what has fallen through the cracks — that did not have to be cracks. Perhaps something that could have catalyzed an unexpected innovation. This conceivably should be the easiest problem to fix, despite peoples’ rationalizations, such as their overloaded in-boxes. As each side has a legitimate interest (one wants to be heard; the other needs to manage their workload), keeping to the ”Both”/”And” reframe, how about socially agreed-upon limited use of <a href="https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/mark-a-message-as-high-or-low-importance-in-outlook-44be4160-d3d9-4f26-97bd-46359b845ae3#:~:text=When%20you%20want%20people%20to,the%20message%20as%20low%20importance.">tags</a> to show relative urgency.</p><p>Roberts et al (2026) note a number of benefits of their work, including “offering a first step toward reflecting more systemically on transition failure by enabling historically grounded analysis” (p. 11). They succeed at this first step.</p><p>They do underplay that reflecting on the reasons for failures, while not necessarily pleasant for former participants (especially with PTSD-like experiences from it), and observers of these initiatives, might help accelerate clearer and urgently needed successes.</p><p>We need to take Sustainability itself, from the <a href="https://gat04-live-1517c8a4486c41609369c68f30c8-aa81074.divio-media.org/filer_public/6f/85/6f854236-56ab-4b42-810f-606d215c0499/cd_9127_extract_from_our_common_future_brundtland_report_1987_foreword_chpt_2.pdf">Brundtland Repor</a>t in 1987, which put sustainability on the map — or at least certain maps, from somewhere in the mixed success category, and get on track to actually fully achieving it. Difficult obstacles will always exist. But we could use fewer of the unnecessary ones.</p><p>(If readers have never heard of this Report from almost 40 years ago, also called Our Common Future, that lack of knowledge of a classic is yet another barrier.)</p><p>If some of my points are accepted as a second step, the questions become: “How can we move on from unconscious business-as-usual?” “How could a field that talks about community, innovation, empathy, values, cooperation; and sometimes about curiosity, humility, and vision; do better at practicing them?</p><p>I thank my editors on this two-parter, Sandy Polsky and Claire Polsky.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5fc5a80104d4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Are Failures And Successes in Sustainability Transitions Really Opposite?: Part 1]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/are-failures-and-successes-in-sustainability-transitions-really-opposite-part-1-8d13025f0265?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8d13025f0265</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transitions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[false-binaries]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[learning-from-failure]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Jun 2026 11:31:18 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-09T11:31:18.025Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/370/1*MNpjm4aXCJIaH_PoD7XRcQ.png" /></figure><p>We don’t usually like to talk about the failures of our projects aimed at achieving large societal change, or sustainability transitions. <a href="https://www.transitionsnetwork.org/">Sustainability transitions</a> is a subfield of sustainability, which is not that well known in the U.S.</p><p>Professors Cameron Roberts, Daniel Rosenbloom, and James Meadowcraft, all from the School of Public Policy and Administration, Carleton University, Ontario, Canada, wrote an important article this year entitled “The anatomy of <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2210422426000420">failed historical transitions</a>: An approach to expand the study of socio-technical change,” in <em>Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions. </em>They explain that studying failures can help guide us on how to do better.</p><p>They aim to break new ground by taking a “Learning from Failure” motif to a somewhat deeper and more analytically based level. They cite a predecessor, Turnheim &amp; Sovacool’s 2020 “Exploring the role of <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eist.2020.09.005">failure</a> in socio-technical transitions research“, but do not use much of it. For example, the latter article recommends “counterfactual analyses” “of transitions that never happened” (Gooday, 1998 as cited in Turnheim &amp; Sovacool, 2020, p. 38). Turnheim &amp; Sovacool also invoke biases as a reason for less attention given to the study of failure. (This is a very different way of looking at biases as used in Part II.)</p><p>Roberts et al’s (2026) conceptualization of failure, and the nuances within it, such as how to even know your project has failed, as opposed to being a “success,” or even something “mixed,” is outstanding. This includes distinguishing a transitions failure from any other kind of failure (e.g. such as a technology failure, or a failure to even get going).</p><p>As a sustainability change-agent, I have the dubious “asset” of being a part of almost 50 years of <a href="https://sustainablebrands.com/read/is-sustainable-business-complicit-a-distraction-and-duplicitous-a-response-part-1">failed</a> sustainable transitions projects, large and small. (Not that we ever said “transition,” but that was my goal.) To try to get something positive out of the recurrent emotional pounding a sustainability change-agent can experience, I have tried to figure out “Why?”</p><p>I focus on that in Part 2. Here I use that experience to add three things to their conceptualization:</p><p>· The authors state that the success versus failures categories is not a fixed binary, contrary to many of the images about their relationship I saw in <em>Google Images</em>. They provide some grey examples. However, the “mixed” category has even more varieties. The authors state that failures or mixed projects can turn into successes in the long term, and what success even is can be subjective. However, while they bring up nuclear power, they miss that it may now be in the early phase of the conversion to success. Another in the mixed category is that with enough time, some core aspect(s) of a failed initiative may be implemented, even in another form. Or some young person working on a failed project learns some important lessons that helps make another transitions project in their future lives a success</p><p>· Another variable is whether the goal of “transition” is ever explicit enough so that all participants know exactly that that is the goal they are seeking to achieve. In my experience, they did not. Arguably, making it absolutely clear could scare away non-sustainability transitions-oriented folk willing to participate for their own reasons, at least at the start when they are most needed. Perhaps a skilled facilitator could make these others feel comfortable enough to tolerate us “systems changers” and the unfamiliar things we bring up. And, over time, the former come to change how they see things and join us in aiming higher</p><p>· Only slightly implicit in the article, there needs to be an explicit category, the even worse “backlash,” when society actually reverses course from the intended transition. Possibly even it could be alleged the backlash was somewhat connected to the attempt itself. Even worse is when the transition had made some progress on the way to success. It is painful to remember Trump I reversing Obama (<a href="https://oidaijsd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/12-12-2-130.pdf">Polsky, 2020</a>); or, yet again, Trump II demolishing Biden’s initiatives. We could ask: “Were these inevitable?” Or could we have aimed at transitions in somewhat different ways? What could we take from that for the next one?</p><p>The Roberts et al (2026) article ends at a point where it is worthwhile to go deeper into asking “Why the Failure’s?” I discuss some unexpected reasons in Part 2, which could be helpful in speeding up successful sustainability transitions — the holy grail.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8d13025f0265" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Are Failures And Successes in Sustainability Transitions Really Opposite?: Part 1]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/are-failures-and-successes-in-sustainability-transitions-really-opposite-part-1-dee3cf855eb2?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/dee3cf855eb2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transitions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[false-binaries]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[learning-from-failure]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 Jun 2026 11:01:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-09T11:01:42.721Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/667/1*UjK6eeD8yWe1RbpeJebtpw.jpeg" /></figure><p>We don’t usually like to talk about the failures of our projects aimed at achieving large societal change, or sustainability transitions. <a href="https://www.transitionsnetwork.org/">Sustainability transitions</a> is a subfield of sustainability, which is not that well known in the U.S.</p><p>Professors Cameron Roberts, Daniel Rosenbloom, and James Meadowcraft, all from the School of Public Policy and Administration, Carleton University, Ontario, Canada, wrote an important article this year entitled “The anatomy of <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2210422426000420">failed historical transitions</a>: An approach to expand the study of socio-technical change,” in <em>Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions. </em>They explain that studying failures can help guide us on how to do better.</p><p>They aim to break new ground by taking a “Learning from Failure” motif to a somewhat deeper and more analytically based level. They cite a predecessor, Turnheim &amp; Sovacool’s 2020 “Exploring the role of <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eist.2020.09.005">failure</a> in socio-technical transitions research“, but do not use much of it. For example, the latter article recommends “counterfactual analyses” “of transitions that never happened” (Gooday, 1998 as cited in Turnheim &amp; Sovacool, 2020, p. 38). Turnheim &amp; Sovacool also invoke biases as a reason for less attention given to the study of failure. (This is a very different way of looking at biases as used in Part II.)</p><p>Roberts et al’s (2026) conceptualization of failure, and the nuances within it, such as how to even know your project has failed, as opposed to being a “success,” or even something “mixed,” is outstanding. This includes distinguishing a transitions failure from any other kind of failure (e.g. such as a technology failure, or a failure to even get going).</p><p>As a sustainability change-agent, I have the dubious “asset” of being a part of almost 50 years of <a href="https://sustainablebrands.com/read/is-sustainable-business-complicit-a-distraction-and-duplicitous-a-response-part-1">failed</a> sustainable transitions projects, large and small. (Not that we ever said “transition,” but that was my goal.) To try to get something positive out of the recurrent emotional pounding a sustainability change-agent can experience, I have tried to figure out “Why?”</p><p>I focus on that in Part 2. Here I use that experience to add three things to their conceptualization:</p><p>· The authors state that the success versus failures categories is not a fixed binary, contrary to many of the images about their relationship I saw in <em>Google Images</em>. They provide some grey examples. However, the “mixed” category has even more varieties. The authors state that failures or mixed projects can turn into successes in the long term, and what success even is can be subjective. However, while they bring up nuclear power, they miss that it may now be in the early phase of the conversion to success. Another in the mixed category is that with enough time, some core aspect(s) of a failed initiative may be implemented, even in another form. Or some young person working on a failed project learns some important lessons that helps make another transitions project in their future lives a success</p><p>· Another variable is whether the goal of “transition” is ever explicit enough so that all participants know exactly that that is the goal they are seeking to achieve. In my experience, they did not. Arguably, making it absolutely clear could scare away non-sustainability transitions-oriented folk willing to participate for their own reasons, at least at the start when they are most needed. Perhaps a skilled facilitator could make these others feel comfortable enough to tolerate us “systems changers” and the unfamiliar things we bring up. And, over time, the former come to change how they see things and join us in aiming higher</p><p>· Only slightly implicit in the article, there needs to be an explicit category, the even worse “backlash,” when society actually reverses course from the intended transition. Possibly even it could be alleged the backlash was somewhat connected to the attempt itself. Even worse is when the transition had made some progress on the way to success. It is painful to remember Trump I reversing Obama (<a href="https://oidaijsd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/12-12-2-130.pdf">Polsky, 2020</a>); or, yet again, Trump II demolishing Biden’s initiatives. We could ask: “Were these inevitable?” Or could we have aimed at transitions in somewhat different ways? What could we take from that for the next one?</p><p>The Roberts et al (2026) article ends at a point where it is worthwhile to go deeper into asking “Why the Failure’s?” I discuss some unexpected reasons in Part 2, which could be helpful in speeding up successful sustainability transitions — the holy grail.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=dee3cf855eb2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Silly Rhyming The UNSDGs]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/silly-rhyming-the-unsdgs-6996acc9c28e?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6996acc9c28e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[meeting-the-sdgs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[unsdgs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rhyming-the-sdgs]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[silly-poems]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 22 Oct 2024 07:14:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-22T07:14:52.294Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*pEs9EyH7SlTqf0Pq2Co7gQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Redbubble</figcaption></figure><p>Many times I’ve asked The New York Times to run articles on the 17 United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UNSDGs)</p><p>They never responded, for all I know throwing my requests into a ditch</p><p>One week in September they briefly mentioned it thrice, but just one Poverty Goal</p><p>But we need more, so desperate, I resorted to taking their unusual offer to readers to let loose and poem my pitch.</p><p>The Goals created in 2015 are hard and interrelated</p><p>We’re supposed to meet all 17 by 2030</p><p>How can we possibly when Americans don’t even know about them?</p><p>But if we don’t, Mother Earth will still be dirty.</p><p>They are: No Poverty; Zero Hunger; Good Health &amp; Well Being</p><p>Quality Education; Gender Equality; Clean Water &amp; Sanitation</p><p>Affordable &amp; Clean Energy; Decent Work &amp; Economic Growth; Industry, Innovation, &amp; Infrastructure</p><p>Reduced Inequalities; Sustainable Cities &amp; Communities; Responsible Consumption &amp; Production.</p><p>Climate Action; Life Below Water; Life on Land</p><p>Peace, Justice, &amp; Strong Institutions; Partnerships For The Goals</p><p>All with targets and strategies</p><p>Meet them or the ozone layer won’t be the only thing with a hole.</p><p>An awful poem, but you try rhyming infrastructure</p><p>I can live with no future as a poet</p><p>The UNSDGs will give us a more fighting chance</p><p>Instead of business as usual and blowing it.</p><p>So, no, they didn’t print it</p><p>It might have catalyzed creative new approaches and helped get us out of our oblivious zone</p><p>I’d even promised never to submit Editors and readers to this again</p><p>Remember, the UNSDGs are a way to do more to protect the Earth, our only home.</p><p>The ones they did were all poems song to a classic tune</p><p>But what melody could fit a theme of “Do some stories on this, already!”</p><p>They say “We only manage what we measure”</p><p>So tell us what we’re supposed to be shooting for, how ‘bout it Dear Gray Lady?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6996acc9c28e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Can We Say “Climate Change” to Deal with Climate Change?:]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/when-can-we-say-climate-change-to-deal-with-climate-change-147e629e88c6?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/147e629e88c6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[new-jersey]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[farming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[agriculture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-smart-agriculture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Aug 2024 07:31:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-08-01T07:33:46.759Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>When Can We Say “Climate Change” to Deal with Climate Change?: Farmers Helping to Address One of the Biggest Challenges We Have: Part Two</h3><p>August 1, 2024</p><p>“We have to name a problem to solve a problem”</p><p>— — Laura Bates, Writer</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*5s2BEcXah42-DoAB_P4Pdw.png" /></figure><p><em>Jack’s Solar Farm — Photo by Werner Slocum: NREL</em></p><p><a href="https://innovator3.medium.com/when-can-we-say-climate-change-to-deal-with-climate-change-cf6f9e46ea37">Part 1</a> of this series discussed the sheer ambition of New Jersey’s climate change goals, how difficult it will be to reach them and the need to be prepared to develop new strategies, including raising the expectations from agriculture.</p><p>It focused on Climate-Smart, an initiative, with available funding assistance and technical support, to help farmers take measures to reduce their carbon emissions and sequester carbon in their soil. Examples include using more cover crops or practicing agro-forestry. But there is resistance by most organizations involved with it to link it to climate change, preferring to emphasize the economic benefits to farmers.</p><p>Nevertheless, some of them, and some farming organizations, are beginning to accept and use the phrase: “climate change,” and position Climate-Smart as part of addressing it.</p><p>My argument is that more can be achieved from agriculture if the mindset against using the phrase, and, at times, bringing in the larger picture of what is at stake, can be overcome.</p><p>Part 1 also discussed other obstacles to wider application of Climate-Smart, that would have to be overcome, such as its somewhat vague nature; and the still unknowns about how carbon sequestration in soil can be most successful.</p><p>Part 2 focuses on recommendations, both for the New Jersey Department of Agriculture (NJDA) and any organizations involved or interested in the connection between the environment and farming. It also shows References for the entire series.</p><p><strong>Recommendations for NJDA and Other Organizations at the Farming-Environment Nexus</strong></p><p>Twenty-one recommendations are:</p><p>· NJDA and other farm-supporting organizations like North Jersey RC&amp;D (NJRC&amp;D), should be bolder about and less hesitant to say “climate change.” While regional environmental groups in the northwest part of New Jersey, such as the Musconetcong Watershed Association and the Foodshed Alliance, have begun to use the phase, and even hold some webinars about it, they have been selective about it. They, too, should be bolder, as well as link it to their other initiatives as appropriate. It should be clear both what the bigger picture is, and that Climate-Smart is part of that</p><p>· Climate-Smart should be more widely promoted to farmers, including the increased availability of technical and financial assistance</p><p>· While the term “Climate-Smart” should be commonly used, it should be clear whether a narrow or broader set of categories and strategies are being expressed. Where feasible and appropriate, excluded categories that are relatively similar in their carbon mitigation or sequestration intent, also could be added. It is sometimes helpful to remind audiences that, in some ways, these are just a continuation of certain good farming techniques and/or an extension of programs that already exist</p><p>· Regardless, it should be stressed that there are many ways to implement Climate-Smart</p><p>· The National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition recommendation at the national level can be adapted to the State-Level: “…make…carbon sequestration a…<a href="https://sustainableagriculture.net/our-work/campaigns/emerging-issue-climate-change-and-agriculture/">priority</a>” (2019, p.40)</p><p>· NJDA, through its partnership with the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (NJDEP) on the Natural &amp; Working Lands Report for Agriculture, should develop targets for how much Climate-Smart measures can contribute to New Jersey’s overall carbon reduction goals, even if these cannot be quantified at this time. Their precision could be improved in the future as new data come in. Hopefully, sequestration through farming can do better than staying even, such as helping agriculture as a whole reach carbon-neutrality. (National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, 2019)</p><p>· Relatedly, monitor the progress of the science as more is learned about the efficacy of carbon sequestration, what affects its permanence in the soil, and what farmers may have to do differently, if anything, to keep it there. How do possible complementary developments in monitoring technology, thinking about economic incentives, the fields of finance and marketing, and perhaps law facilitate this. Perhaps New Jersey could innovate something either in the former and/or the latter that if successful could be picked up in other parts of the world</p><p>· Regarding positioning Climate-Smart around farmers’ economic self-interest, the National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition offers a two-part perspective, but these must be viewed as a set. “Yes, But.” Their frame is: (1) economic incentives provided to farmers by government are acceptable “Because such forms (that is, sustainable systems and practices) of well-being support us all…we must, in turn, support the efforts that farmers…make to be better stewards of our world.” But, at the same time, (2) values such as diversity, equity, dignity, and circular economies are important. “Farming needs to prioritize the well-being of the land, air, water, and people/community.” And, especially, “We (farmers) are stewards of future generations.” (National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, n.d., pgs. 5, 8) This larger framing is worth adopting to move beyond just a single bottom-line mindset</p><p>· NJDA should work with sister agencies, beyond NJDEP, where complementary, such as the State Agricultural Development Committee (SADC); the New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs (NJDCA) if claims for being “Climate-Smart” become questionable; The Governor’s Climate Action &amp; The Green Economy Office, to include farms and farm workers who practice Climate-Smart as “Green Jobs,” the New Jersey Economic Development Administration (NJEDA) to consider spurring a biochar sector; and the New Jersey Department of Treasury if economic incentives for farmers need to be restructured to make them easier and more effective</p><p>· Biochar is not well known but is worth giving more attention to as it has useful soil-building properties that enhance sequestration. It also came up during two Climate-Smart webinars viewed for this series. A NJDA staffer even suggested a pilot project to better understand how to use and possibly regulate it (DeFlumeri, 2023)</p><p>· To facilitate Climate-Smart-grown food products being able to charge a premium in the marketplace, in order to help justify any increased costs, the “Jersey Fresh” labeling program should find a way to identify and promote them (Jersey Fresh, n.d.)</p><p>· Climate-Smart, even apart from its link to other good farming measures, is not the only way for farmers to address climate change. Other ways also should get attention in the now-2024 federal Farm Bill, and supported by organizations at the farming-environmental nexus. This includes adjusting crop subsidies, such as crop insurance premiums, to favor farmers who implement ways to address climate change and take other environmental measures, and away from those who do not (Shaver &amp; Avanzini, 2023). Net savings could be used for research to support reducing agriculture’s carbon emissions (Vos, Martin, &amp; Resnick, 2024). Farmers also can address climate change through sustainable biomass (DePillis, 2024), if it is done right; and undertake whole farm audits that look at <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZTDn7igl0U">energy efficiency</a> and renewable energy (Eisemen, 2023), such as agrivoltaics, or photovoltaics solar power on farms. While it is beyond the scope of this analysis, these organizations should consider supporting the Agriculture Resilience Act, developed by the National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, as part of the Farm Bill. It builds upon the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) and includes “a purpose to accelerate the ability of agriculture and the food system to first achieve<a href="https://sustainableagriculture.net/blog/the-agriculture-resilience-act-in-2023/"> zero net</a> carbon emissions and then go further.” (National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition, 2023, p. 7) This is the most ambitious goal seen for agriculture, and one whose achievement might be needed</p><p>· Photovoltaics is not a part of Climate-Smart, despite its use on farms reduces carbon emissions. It is usually not seen by environmental groups as appropriate on farmland, as it can detract from food production and is inconsistent with taxpayer-supported farmland preservation programs. Yet, there may be room for creative exceptions. See the cover picture</p><p>· Rutgers Agriculture Extension Agents, who advise farmers, should be knowledgeable about Climate-Smart. The recruitment of a Rutgers Agriculture Extension Agent for Warren County should seek candidates familiar with this</p><p>· It was suggested by an interview respondent that Pennsylvania’s Reserve Enhancement &amp; Protection Program (REAP) has a better structure of financial incentives for farmers. (Personal Communication, Tessiero, L., 2024, June 25). It includes income tax credits of up to 90%, and allows farmers to sell their credits to other parties, including to those who pay for the Climate-Smart project. (Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture, n.d.) To the degree that it is desirable and feasible, such a structure should be considered in New Jersey</p><p>· If and when policy makers become willing to seriously consider a carbon tax, the argument that it would raise the economic value of carbon sequestration, thus giving it more careful attention, should be included in the case for it</p><p>· If participation in carbon markets proves to be greatly handicapped by the requirement for “additionality,” “that the project that resulted in reduced greenhouse gas reductions (or increased sequestration) would not have occurred had it not been for the carbon credits,” (Lutz, J. &amp; Welsh, C., 2021, p. 4) this condition may have to be softened</p><p>· Over time, as the environmental and economic benefits of Climate-Smart and related actions become better understood, along with the upfront and ongoing costs, and change, this should influence the size of economic incentives offered to farmers. There also is no reason that, in principle, the same could not be true for any other <a href="https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/15041-opinion-why-we-need-a-broader-perspective-to-help-farmers-meet-the-climate-crisis">ecosystem service</a> provided by farmers over and beyond addressing climate change, such as helping with water quality and conserving biodiversity (Schonbeck &amp; Zoebisch, 2020)</p><p>· To the degree the urgency of climate change becomes inescapably and widely accepted, and if the potential of Climate-Smart and related strategies are understood to be large but under-utilized, then strongly consider changing this voluntary, incentive-based system to one that is required. (Education and some incentives could still be kept.) One suggestion made at a Natural &amp; Working Lands Strategy Stakeholder meeting is to implement this even now for State Wildlife Management areas that are leased to farmers (Maestro, 2023)</p><p>· Similar thinking from these two articles can be applied to other sub-sectors under the jurisdiction of the NJDA</p><p>· These ideas could also be considered for any other state’s agriculture policy.</p><p>References</p><p>Action Aid. Why ‘Climate Smart Agriculture’ won’t save the planet. <em>Actionaid Newsletter. </em><a href="https://www.actionaidusa.org/insight/climate-smart-agriculture/#:~:text=Climate%20Smart%20Agriculture%20will%20not,Agroecology%20does">https://www.actionaidusa.org/insight/climate-smart-agriculture/#:~:text=Climate%20Smart%20Agriculture%20will%20not,Agroecology%20does</a></p><p>Bates, L. (n.d.) We have to name a problem to solve a problem. <em>Az Quotes. </em><a href="https://www.azquotes.com/quote/1573553#google_vignette">https://www.azquotes.com/quote/1573553#google_vignette</a></p><p>Cornell Climate Smart Farming Program. Climate-Smart farming decision tools. (n.d.) <a href="http://climatesmartfarming.org/">http://climatesmartfarming.org/</a></p><p>DeFlumeri, R. (2023, March, 23) Major components of the strategy for agriculture. Natural &amp; Working Lands Strategy Stakeholder Meeting: Agricultural Lands. <em>NJDEP.</em> [video] YouTube. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsQo5VzmhQc">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsQo5VzmhQc</a></p><p>DeFlumeri, R. (2024, June 18) Climate Smart farming: Conservation practices that can make you money! <em>Foodshare Alliance. [Video] You Tube.</em> <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ib24sfx3NrM">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ib24sfx3NrM</a></p><p>DePillis, Lydia. (2024, May 30). Can billions in new subsidies keep family farms in business? The Biden Administration aims to better support small farmers while aiding big operations and rewarding carbon-friendly practices. It’s a tall order. <em>The New York Times. </em><a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/30/business/economy/small-farms-usda-biden.html">https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/30/business/economy/small-farms-usda-biden.html</a></p><p>Eisemen, D. (2023, June 11) Climate-Smart agriculture in the northeast: Six key strategies for farmers. <em>The Foodshed Alliance.</em> [Video] YouTube. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZTDn7igl0U">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZTDn7igl0U</a></p><p>Gee-Burney, B. (2024, July 23) Bringing back earth-friendly, high-value small grains to the Highlands Region. Beginning Farmers, Environment, Organization New. https://foodshedalliance.org/2024/07/23/0710-grains-day-copy/</p><p>Goldelnik, R. (2021, July) Forget about the business case for sustainability. <em>Medium.</em> <a href="https://medium.com/age-of-awareness/forget-about-the-business-case-for-sustainability-c3d8c1d65ddf">https://medium.com/age-of-awareness/forget-about-the-business-case-for-sustainability-c3d8c1d65ddf</a></p><p>Jersey Fresh. (n.d.) What is Jersey Fresh. <a href="https://findjerseyfresh.com/JerseyFresh/facts">https://findjerseyfresh.com/JerseyFresh/facts</a></p><p>Lilliston, B. (2015, September 30) What’s wrong with ‘Climate-Smart’ Agriculture? Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy. <a href="https://www.iatp.org/blog/201509/whats-wrong-climate-smart-agriculture">https://www.iatp.org/blog/201509/whats-wrong-climate-smart-agriculture</a></p><p>Lutz, J. &amp; Welsh, C. (2021) Soil carbon sequestration: Myths, Realities, and the Biden Administration’s Proposals. <em>Center for Strategic and International Studies. </em><a href="https://www.csis.org/analysis/soil-carbon-sequestration-myths-realities-and-biden-administrations-proposals">https://www.csis.org/analysis/soil-carbon-sequestration-myths-realities-and-biden-administrations-proposals</a></p><p>Maestro, K. (2023, March, 23) Natural &amp; Working Lands Strategy Stakeholder Meeting: Agricultural Lands. <em>NJDEP.</em> [Video] YouTube. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsQo5VzmhQc">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsQo5VzmhQc</a></p><p>Mitchell, A. ‘Climate-Smart’ agriculture is catching on with NJ farmers. Here’s how. <em>NorthJersey.com.</em> <a href="https://www.njconservation.org/climate-smart-agriculture-catching-on-with-farmers/">https://www.njconservation.org/climate-smart-agriculture-catching-on-with-farmers/</a></p><p>National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition. (2023, March 29) The Agriculture Resilience Act in 2–23. <em>NSAC’s Blog. </em><a href="https://sustainableagriculture.net/blog/the-agriculture-resilience-act-in-2023/">https://sustainableagriculture.net/blog/the-agriculture-resilience-act-in-2023/</a></p><p>National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition. (2019, November) Agriculture and climate change: Policy imperatives and opportunities to help producers meet the challenge. <a href="https://sustainableagriculture.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/NSAC-Climate-Change-Policy-Position_paper-112019_WEB.pdf">https://sustainableagriculture.net/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/NSAC-Climate-Change-Policy-Position_paper-112019_WEB.pdf</a></p><p>National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition. (n.d.) Climate change and agriculture. <a href="https://sustainableagriculture.net/our-work/campaigns/emerging-issue-climate-change-and-agriculture/">https://sustainableagriculture.net/our-work/campaigns/emerging-issue-climate-change-and-agriculture/</a></p><p>New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection. (2020A) 2020 New Jersey scientific report on climate change at-a-glance. <a href="https://www.nj.gov/dep/climatechange/pdf/scientific-report-on-climate-change-at-a-glance.pdf">https://www.nj.gov/dep/climatechange/pdf/scientific-report-on-climate-change-at-a-glance.pdf</a></p><p>New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection. (2020B, October, 15) New Jersey’s 80X50 Report. <a href="https://dep.nj.gov/wp-content/uploads/climatechange/nj-gwra-80x50-report-2020.pdf">https://dep.nj.gov/wp-content/uploads/climatechange/nj-gwra-80x50-report-2020.pdf</a></p><p>New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection. (2024, March) New Jersey’s priority climate action plan. <a href="https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2024-03/nj-pcap.pdf">https://www.epa.gov/system/files/documents/2024-03/nj-pcap.pdf</a></p><p>New Jersey’s Global Warming Response Act. (2007) <a href="https://www.njleg.state.nj.us/bill-search/2018/S3207/bill-text?f=S3500&amp;n=3207_S2">https://www.njleg.state.nj.us/bill-search/2018/S3207/bill-text?f=S3500&amp;n=3207_S2</a></p><p>New Jersey Farm Bureau. (2024) Policies adapted by the delegates to the New Jersey Farm Bureau’s 105th Annual Meeting. <a href="https://njfb.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/NJFB-2024-Policies.pdf">https://njfb.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/NJFB-2024-Policies.pdf</a></p><p>New Jersey Interagency Sustainability Working Group. (2001, December) Governing with the future in mind: Working together to enhance New Jersey’s Sustainability &amp; quality of life. <a href="https://dspace.njstatelib.org/items/f74c4c2f-819f-4a23-a618-9fbe44ec7a99">https://dspace.njstatelib.org/items/f74c4c2f-819f-4a23-a618-9fbe44ec7a99</a></p><p>NRCS. Climate. <a href="https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/conservation-basics/natural-resource-concerns/climate">https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/conservation-basics/natural-resource-concerns/climate</a></p><p>North Jersey RC&amp;D. Grazing initiative: Climate-Smart commodities grant. <a href="https://www.northjerseyrcd.org/grazing">https://www.northjerseyrcd.org/grazing</a></p><p>Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture. (n.d.) Reserve enhancement &amp; protection program (REAP). <a href="https://www.agriculture.pa.gov/Plants_Land_Water/StateConservationCommission/REAP/Pages/default.aspx">https://www.agriculture.pa.gov/Plants_Land_Water/StateConservationCommission/REAP/Pages/default.aspx</a></p><p>Pho, T. (2023, March, 23) Background. Natural &amp; working lands strategy stakeholder meeting: Agricultural lands. <em>NJDEP.</em> [Video] YouTube. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsQo5VzmhQc">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsQo5VzmhQc</a></p><p>Polsky, M. (2017, July 28) Forget Trump for a day: But is it past time for Trump loathers and Trump voters to talk?: Part 1 of 8. <em>Medium.</em> <a href="https://medium.com/@innovator3/forget-trump-for-a-day-but-is-it-past-time-for-trump-loathers-and-trump-voters-to-talk-part-1-ffb647c16401">https://medium.com/@innovator3/forget-trump-for-a-day-but-is-it-past-time-for-trump-loathers-and-trump-voters-to-talk-part-1-ffb647c16401</a></p><p>Polsky, M. (2023, November 30) Where New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection and stakeholders could take their climate change efforts: 30 suggestions for continual state leadership. <em>Medium</em>. https://innovator3.medium.com/where-new-jersey-department-of-environmental-protection-and-stakeholders-could-take-their-climate-5e6c55b3d502</p><p>Popkin, G. (2020, April 16) Is carbon sequestration on farms actually working to fight climate change? <em>GreenBiz. </em><a href="https://www.greenbiz.com/article/carbon-sequestration-farms-actually-working-fight-climate-change">https://www.greenbiz.com/article/carbon-sequestration-farms-actually-working-fight-climate-change</a></p><p>Resolution #8: Agriculture and climate change. (2024, February 8)</p><p>Rutgers University Climate Change Resource Center. (2020, May) Farming, food, and climate change in New Jersey. <a href="https://njclimateresourcecenter.rutgers.edu/climate_change_101/farming-food-and-climate-change-in-new-jersey/">https://njclimateresourcecenter.rutgers.edu/climate_change_101/farming-food-and-climate-change-in-new-jersey/</a></p><p>Schaver, D. &amp; Avanzini, S. (2023, January 10) Why agricultural subsidies must be reformed to enable a regenerative food system. <em>World Economic Forum. </em><a href="https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2023/01/reforming-agricultural-subsidies-to-enable-a-regenerative-food-system/">https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2023/01/reforming-agricultural-subsidies-to-enable-a-regenerative-food-system/</a></p><p>Schonbeck, M. &amp; Zoebisch, C. (2020, December 18) Why we need a broader perspective to help farmers meet the climate crisis. <em>AgriPulse.</em> <a href="https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/15041-opinion-why-we-need-a-broader-perspective-to-help-farmers-meet-the-climate-crisis">https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/15041-opinion-why-we-need-a-broader-perspective-to-help-farmers-meet-the-climate-crisis</a></p><p>Spanberger, A. (2022, December 2022) President signs into law Spanberger’s ‘Growing Climate Solutions Act,’ Greenlights making carbon markets more accessible to American agriculture. <a href="https://spanberger.house.gov/posts/president-signs-into-law-spanbergers-growing-climate-solutions-act-greenlights-making-carbon-markets-more-accessible-to-american-agriculture">https://spanberger.house.gov/posts/president-signs-into-law-spanbergers-growing-climate-solutions-act-greenlights-making-carbon-markets-more-accessible-to-american-agriculture</a></p><p>U.S. Department of Agriculture NRCS (n.d.) Climate-Smart agriculture and forestry (CSAF) mitigation activities list for FY2024. <a href="https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/sites/default/files/2023-10/NRCS-CSAF-Mitigation-Activities-List.pdf">https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/sites/default/files/2023-10/NRCS-CSAF-Mitigation-Activities-List.pdf</a></p><p>Valentine, M. (2019, March 7) PG#28: “When you can’t name a problem, you can’t solve it.” <em>Paper Giant.</em> <a href="https://www.papergiant.net/news/pg-28-when-you-cant-name-a-problem-you-cant-solve-it">https://www.papergiant.net/news/pg-28-when-you-cant-name-a-problem-you-cant-solve-it</a></p><p>Von Braun, J. &amp; Birner, R. (2017) Designing global governance for agricultural development and food and nutrition security. <em>Review of Development Economics. </em>21(2), 265–284. DOI:10.1111/rode.12261</p><p>Vos, R., Martin, W., &amp; Resnick, D. (2024) Repurposing agricultural support: Creating food systems incentives to address climate change. Chapter 2. <em>Global Food Policy Report.</em> IFPRI. <a href="https://gfpr.ifpri.info/2022/05/11/repurposing-agricultural-support-creating-incentives-for-sustainable-food-systems/">https://gfpr.ifpri.info/2022/05/11/repurposing-agricultural-support-creating-incentives-for-sustainable-food-systems/</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=147e629e88c6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Can We Say “Climate Change” to Deal with Climate Change?:]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/when-can-we-say-climate-change-to-deal-with-climate-change-cf6f9e46ea37?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cf6f9e46ea37</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 27 Jul 2024 11:33:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-27T11:58:33.769Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>When Can We Say “Climate Change” to Deal with Climate Change?: The Early Years of Carbon-Smart Agriculture in New Jersey: Part One</h3><p>July 27, 2024</p><p>“When You Can’t Name a Problem, You Can’t Solve It“ — McKinley Valentine, Self-described Neurodivergent Writer, “The Whippet,’ A Newsletter for the Terminally Curious”</p><p>SUCCESS STORY</p><p><strong>Minnesota’s Lakes are Cleaner This Summer Thanks to Farmers’ Conservation Efforts</strong></p><p>By Jacob Gustin</p><p>June 20, 2024</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*LLlIIfsbf-CBfkpObd0goA.png" /></figure><p>In a parallel to farmers helping to address climate change, a precedent when it comes to lake water quality.</p><p>Source: <a href="https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/conservation-basics/conservation-by-state/minnesota/news/minnesotas-lakes-are-cleaner-this-summer">https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/conservation-basics/conservation-by-state/minnesota/news/minnesotas-lakes-are-cleaner-this-summer</a></p><p><strong>What’s At Stake</strong></p><p>New Jersey is more vulnerable to climate change than other states in the northeast. It is warming more quickly. Its sea-levels are rising, too, with an even chance of 1.4 feet or more by 2050. Rain is anticipated to increase by up to 11%. (NJDEP, 2020A) The farming sector is <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZTDn7igl0U">not immune</a> to negative impacts. (Eisemen, D., 2023) New Jersey’s big picture policy direction on climate change was set by the Global Warming Response Act during the Governor Corzine Administration. It called for an 80% reduction in carbon emissions by 2050. (New Jersey, 2007) This was, and still is, very ambitious. Since then, strategies have been set by the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (NJDEP) to meet this goal (NJDEP, 2020B), but it is unlikely that all will work according to plan. However, it is quite possible that due to the worsening of climate change, the pursuit of this Goal will have to be accelerated. Some are seeking help in addressing climate change from agriculture, including from within this sector itself. Von Braun and Birner say that agriculture has not been a focus of (international) climate change policy, and “call for a more prominent integral positioning of agriculture in …climate policies…” (2017, pgs. 276–277) Climate-Smart, both a federal and state program, is one major way for agriculture to make a contribution, such as through extensive use of cover crops. However, state-wide and regionally, it has not been positioned that way.</p><p><strong>Status</strong></p><p>New Jersey has, thus far, been able to meet its interim carbon reduction targets. But it will only get harder, especially in the out-years.</p><p>The New Jersey Department of Agriculture (NJDA) supports Climate-Smart. It presents webinars about it, offers programs with technical and financial cost-sharing support for farmers, and is seeking grants to do more. (DeFlumeri, 2024) But it does not emphasize climate change. Neither climate change or Climate-Smart are on its website. The operating mindset is that Climate-Smart measures must be in the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ib24sfx3NrM">financial interests</a> of the farmer for them to adopt them. (DeFlumeri, 2024)</p><p>It is not just the NJDA. The non-profit, North Jersey RC&amp;D (NJRC&amp;D), which works extensively with farmers, does not emphasize climate change, either. Climate-Smart is discussed on its website through their “Grazing Initiative.” (Personal Communication Tessiero. L., 2024, June 25) Their services include offering as much as $60K for cost sharing per farmer for Climate-Smart measures, up to $30K for help with marketing, and they provide technical assistance. (NJRC&amp;D, n.d.)</p><p>The Foodshed Alliance, a hybrid environmental-farmer non-profit, has a section on climate change on their website. It has also presented a couple of webinars on Climate-Smart. It recently unveiled a new program, “The Grains Initiative.” But although the latter is integrally tied to climate change through, among other ways, increased carbon-holding capacity in soil from growing grains, it said nothing explicit about climate change during a Field Day event, except for briefly noting the warming climate. (Gee-Burney, 2024) It did not even mention the funding now available for farmers for complementary measures through the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) (Until I brought it up.)</p><p>It is certainly possible to promote ways to reduce carbon and sequester it without saying the apparently politically risky term, “climate change.” But is this avoidance approach going to be sufficient?</p><p><strong>Introduction: Background, Context, Methodology</strong></p><p>This was originally written mostly for the NJDA as a Policy Brief for a graduate course I was taking in Prescott College’s PhD Program in Sustainability Education: “Food and Agriculture Policy.” It could be helpful for NJDA’s current work on the Natural and Working Lands Strategy Report for sequestration in agriculture. (NJDA has not responded to the Brief.) The Brief has been adjusted and expanded for a larger audience.</p><p>Even then, while narrowly about NJDA’s Climate-Smart Program, it was really about asking them to re-conceive how agriculture in New Jersey could play a greater part in combatting climate change. It applied beyond NJDA to other agencies and organizations involved in the agriculture-environment nexus, as they think about the Agency’s and farmers’ role going into the future.</p><p>While that was my first extended look at NJDA and climate change, I have written to other state agencies in the past on the latter, including the NJDEP, the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities (NJBPU), the New Jersey Office of Climate Action &amp; The Green Economy, the Governor’s Office, and the New Jersey Economic Development Administration (NJEDA).</p><p>See the Endnote<a href="#_edn1">[i]</a> for more of my relevant climate change and agriculture experience.</p><p>The methodology, as reflected in the “References” section in Part 2, included reviewing State reports on climate change, viewing three NJDEP and Foodshed Alliance videos on climate change and Climate-Smart, and discussions with farmers.</p><p><strong>Obstacles: Current Mindsets and Others</strong></p><p>As a subset of obstacles, I focus on mindsets and how they can limit our thinking. (The subject of my PhD research). But there are also other obstacles.</p><p>Note only is Climate-Smart relatively new, but there is a widespread perception that farmers do not accept or even want to hear about “Climate Change.” This term is avoided in most discussions. Instead, the way to approach farmers is seen nearly exclusively to promote the business case for certain measures like cover crops and no- or low-till farming. This is considered sufficient, with no necessity or value in linking to, or addressing, the larger context. That is, the urgency of the problem, and therefore the need for nearly everyone to step up and do their share. It is feared that doing this risks losing farmers’ interest.</p><p>This is not without some foundation. At one Climate-Smart webinar, the speaker twice asked the audience of mostly farmers what impacts of climate change they have been seeing. There were a couple of uncomfortable silences. (Eisemen, D. 2023)</p><p>While Cornell Extension Service presents webinars on Climate-Smart Agriculture (Eisemen, 2023) and offers tools for it (Cornell, n.d.), Rutgers Extension Service in Warren County, New Jersey has no brochures about it, or currently an Agent on staff to talk to farmers. (Personal Communication to Rutgers Extension Service, Warren County, 2024, June 26).</p><p>What Climate-Smart is can be confusing, as: (a) it is a rather loose label, not totally independent from other good management practices on farms, including those not directly related to climate; (b) it is hard to distinguish it from the increasingly heard “regenerative agriculture;” (Rutgers University, 2020) © the categories included in it is not always consistent. Soil Health and Grazing are, but not always Agro-Forestry, Organic Agriculture, Energy Efficiency, or Renewable Energy — although others may see it differently. There are at least 40 specific types of activities that can qualify for support. (USDA, n.d.); (d) it is not the only step farmers can take to address climate change; and (e) it strongly overlaps with carbon sequestration (and thereby links with NJDEP’s and NJDA’s Natural Working Lands Strategy work), but is not synonymous with it.</p><p>So it can be hard to get a handle on it.</p><p>Despite the passing of the federal Growing Climate Solutions Act in 2022, which will facilitate carbon sequestration, the potential of the Act is still scientifically unsettled and likely depends on a range of factors. It works, in part, through Carbon Markets (also called “Carbon Farming.”) So while sequestration should play a role among many other carbon reduction efforts, it is currently difficult to say how big a contribution it could make. There is a fear that estimates of it will be overstated. Still, the potential of the Act is significant, offsetting 5% of U.S. carbon emissions, (The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine, 2018 as cited in Popkin, 2020). There are an increasing number of tools being developed to <a href="https://www.greenbiz.com/article/carbon-sequestration-farms-actually-working-fight-climate-change">measure it</a>. (Popkin, 2020) Warren County-based non-profit NJRC&amp;D is starting a research project, working with 20 farmers, over four years, to measure both soil sequestration and on-farm carbon. They will then input the data into models. (Personal Communication, Tessiero. L., 2024, June 25) There is progress in trying to overcome the difficult problem of how much sequestration can help.</p><p>The carbon markets area should be actively monitored, with some early, cautious participation.</p><p>New Jersey has draft soft targets for sequestration for a number of Climate-Smart strategies, such as rotational grazing, both for 2030 and 2050, but without numbers. Instead, they are called <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsQo5VzmhQc">“Practical Recommendations”</a> as not enough is known at this time about what could be expected from them. (DeFlumeri, 2023)</p><p>Overall, the State is seeking to reduce its total carbon emissions from 98.5 MMT in 1990 to <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DsQo5VzmhQc">24.2 MMT</a> by 2050 (Pho, 2023). This is transformational and will not be reached just by business-as-usual practices. More will be necessary. NJDEP has said that: “New Jersey needs carbon sequestration…to meet the State’s 2050 Goals.” (Pho, 2023)</p><p>The overall goal for sequestration (including but beyond Climate-Smart), though, is modest: to “maintain, and if possible, increase, the amount of carbon sequestered in its natural sinks,” from “8.1 MMT CO2e in 2021, or [offsetting] 8% of total State emissions,” to equal to or more than 8.1 MMT CO2e by 2050. (NJDEP, 2024, p. 2)</p><p>These mindset and other obstacles must be overcome. I think it is doable.</p><p><strong>Opponents</strong></p><p>There are no obvious “opponents,” as farm groups seem supportive of Climate-Smart, such as the New Jersey Farm Bureau. (New Jersey Farm Bureau, 2024) But the perception remains that telling the whole story regarding what it is about is too risky. That view may limit its potential.</p><p>However, on another front, there is a political problem that has apparently not yet surfaced at the state or national levels. But at the international level, the term has become caught up in dueling visions of the future of the overall food system. Those who favor a more agroecological perspective, as opposed to industrial farming, have issues with Climate-Smart. The former emphasize local farms and food sovereignty. They see Climate-Smart as having no standards. It avoids political aspects of the food system and issues of relative power that critics see as necessary to face. It “does not address the root causes of the problem,” (Action Aid, n.d., p. 6) and is prime for agribusiness greenwashing. (Lilliston, 2015)</p><p>The implication for New Jersey is that this “political” perspective may emerge at some point. One way to minimize some of the opposition is to ensure that environmental improvements through Climate-Smart are real.</p><p><strong>Taking Advantage of Opportunities</strong></p><p>At some point, it will become harder for most denialists and skeptics to avoid accepting the term “climate change.” (Although I hope it is not too late by then.) Anecdotal evidence (discussions with a few farmers and those who work with them) show that this may be happening. The delegates to the last State Agricultural Convention are fine with it. (Resolution #8, 2024) The same for the New Jersey <a href="https://njfb.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/NJFB-2024-Policies.pdf">Farm Bureau</a>. (New Jersey Farm Bureau, 2024)</p><p>The USDA and NRCS at the federal level explicitly discuss “climate change,” and put Climate-Smart in that context. (Mitchell, 2023) USDA’s NRCS states: “With support from NRCS, farmers….can contribute to climate solutions.” (NRCS, n.d., p. 4)</p><p>Lutz &amp; Welsh state “a more holistic set of agriculture policies will help maximize greenhouse gas emissions reductions and ensure that all U.S. farmers are able to benefit from contributing to national climate change goals.” (Lutz &amp; Welsh, 2021, p. 6)</p><p>The IRA will put $19.5B into Climate-Smart. (Mitchell, 2023) NRCS, the lead federal agency on it, is gearing up, including dedicating funding for, and linking it to, its other conservation programs (Personal Communication, Jiorle, R. 2024, June 24). The USDA has a new Climate-Smart Commodities program that will put over $3B into 141 projects. The Growing Climate Solutions Act, mentioned earlier, supports Carbon Markets and requires USDA to set up a registration program, with third-party verifiers, to make it easier for farmers to participate (Spanberger, 2022).</p><p>There are untapped opportunities that arise with decreased resistance. There is more support now to be able to discuss the climate change big picture, a fuller role of agriculture in addressing it, and to putting Climate-Smart in that context.</p><p>This, in turn, could provide increased motivation for concerned farmers to embrace Climate-Smart and related activities, channel their creativity and efforts towards addressing climate change, and perhaps even for going beyond “the business case.” (Godelnik, 2021)</p><p>It is time to re-visit that mindset.</p><p>Part 2 of this short series will focus on recommendations, both for NJDA and others at the environment-agriculture nexus, including from outside of New Jersey, and will also include References for both articles.</p><p><a href="#_ednref1">[i]</a> Here are more of my relevant New Jersey climate change and agriculture experience.</p><p>My last article before this one, written for NJDEP, was: “Where New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection and Stakeholders Could Take Their Climate Change Efforts: <a href="https://innovator3.medium.com/where-new-jersey-department-of-environmental-protection-and-stakeholders-could-take-their-climate-5e6c55b3d502">30 Suggestions</a> for Continual State Leadership.” It has Iinks to many other articles I wrote or co-wrote over the years about New Jersey and climate change.</p><p>In the late 1990s, I co-catalyzed NJDEP’s first involvement with climate change. In the early 2000s I led the Interagency Sustainability Work Group, which had active participation from NJDA. The Final Report, “<a href="https://dspace.njstatelib.org/items/f74c4c2f-819f-4a23-a618-9fbe44ec7a99">Governing</a> With The Future in Mind,” had a recommendation about agriculture. A then-new Administration subsequently threw out this Report.</p><p>There’s something about agriculture that speaks and gets to even a former stickball player from Brooklyn. I felt it moving to rural northwest New Jersey 13 years ago, and gave it more attention, both mentally and physically.</p><p>I managed a farmer’s market one summer and physically worked on 20 farms, mostly as a volunteer gleaner. Often I found myself working next to the farmer who had invited my group. We often talked either about farming, in general, or the environment-agriculture connection. An example, I sometimes tell my students, of learning with your fingers.</p><p>I was once accused during a discussion at a party by someone with very different political views of being “an academic.” I did not interpret this as a compliment. I responded by showing him my farm-earned band-aids. He had no response.</p><p>This anecdote may have helped spark my writing an eight-part series on “Speaking to the <a href="https://medium.com/@innovator3/forget-trump-for-a-day-but-is-it-past-time-for-trump-loathers-and-trump-voters-to-talk-part-1-ffb647c16401">Trump Voter</a>.” I ended that story in Part 1 with “I also won’t forget that multiple band-aids can do more than protect cuts.” (Polsky, 2017)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cf6f9e46ea37" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Where New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection and Stakeholders Could Take Their Climate…]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/where-new-jersey-department-of-environmental-protection-and-stakeholders-could-take-their-climate-5e6c55b3d502?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e6c55b3d502</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change-innovation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[njdep-climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change-policy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[new-jersey-climate-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change-solutions]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 30 Nov 2023 21:48:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-30T21:48:17.916Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Where New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection and Stakeholders Could Take Their Climate Change Efforts: 30 Suggestions for Continual State Leadership</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HW78BjWTXQKQxwiQm7eM7A.jpeg" /><figcaption>A Global Report Card, the economist</figcaption></figure><p>The State of New Jersey and the New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection (NJDEP) have come a very long way on climate change from the late 1980’s when a colleague and I, eventually the Sustainability Team Leader inside the Department, had to instigate to create any interest at all in it, as hard to believe as that might sound. And then stoke the embers to keep things moving forward after fallbacks of government interest.</p><p>The response we got to our earliest effort, from an Assistant Commissioner, was “Not our issue.” NJDEP was not the only non-interested State Agency. Counting on pressure from the outside, which internal change-makers sometimes do, was also, perhaps surprisingly, almost non-existent, as even environmental groups weren’t interested at that time.</p><p>But things have changed with the current Administration pursuing progressive goals and policies, including prioritizing this issue. They “get” the threat but are still hampered by a somewhat similar lack of reflection about “What do we not know about what we don’t know?” And “What assumptions are holding us back?”</p><p>Now the Department is asking for input about their August, 2023 <a href="https://dep.nj.gov/wp-content/uploads/climatechange/new-jersey-final-cprg-workplan.pdf">Climate</a> Pollution Reduction Grant Work Plan to guide their climate change efforts going forward. This seems like a good opportunity to tell them, and their stakeholders, about some possibilities, even if what is offered goes beyond the objectives for public input that NJDEP seeks at this time on the Work Plan.</p><p>We’re going to have to increase our tool kit, level of ambition, and creativity, even more if the carbon reduction goals need to be sped up, which I suspect is likely.</p><p>The decades-long back-&amp;-forth provides perspective for future efforts, from a Governor Kean-era Executive Order for state agencies — only, to look at their carbon emissions; a Governor Florio-era receipt of a U.S. Environmental Protection Agency grant to inventory the State’s carbon emissions; Governor Whitman-era Internal and External Work Groups to develop sector-based voluntary agreements to reduce carbon emissions by the then-revolutionary goal of 3½% below 1990 levels, and move the State towards sustainability, including a pioneering Office of Sustainable Business, later killed by Governor DiFrancesco; the Governor Corzine-era Global Warming Response Act, which for the first time brought vision to the State’s thinking on carbon reduction (i.e. 80% by 2050); and a forgetting of the latter during the Governor Christie Administration, which removed New Jersey from the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI).</p><p>There are numerous positive things in the Work Plan, including some of which I wasn’t aware. Still, there are a large range of ideas I would like to offer.</p><p>At times, I take the long view, not just in the sense of looking backwards, including missed yet possibly still-available opportunities; but also looking forward, sometimes a long way, to what will likely be necessary, even if currently some ideas may be considered wildly impractical. For the latter, the best that probably can be done are baby steps, but connected to a vision of where something needs to go.</p><p>Some of my ideas are informed by earlier efforts within the Department, including what the obstacles were, at the time and later; and since then, from my continuing to following different fields, and ways of looking at the issue.</p><p>There is some overlap in the 30 wide-ranging suggestions.</p><p>At times sources are provided. Where not, it is possible they could be suggested.</p><p>Here some suggestions, both for NJDEP or anyone else interested in this perspective.</p><p>1. Communications, Stakeholder Input, and Responsiveness. The first two are about the best I’ve seen from NJDEP, especially the idea of “Deeper Engagement.” This is far from the typical two-three-minute limit imposed on those giving comments at Public Hearings, usually with no feedback from the government staff at the front of the room. Such a protocol limits real communications, making it at times close to token.</p><p>To utilize deep engagement effectively, though, NJDEP needs to respond do people whose input is not taken so that they don’t think they have wasted their time, and were not heard. That includes both specific ideas mentioned during these sessions, and reports/articles/letters sent to NJDEP.</p><p>NJDEP and the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities (NJBPU) sometimes do the latter, but inconsistently. NJDEP staff have given me generous time to speak with them about product labeling, carbon sequestration, and cost: benefit analysis. But sometimes they have not. Still, that is better than The Office of Climate Action &amp; Green Economy (OCAGE), The Governor’s Office, and the New Jersey Economic Development Authority (NJEDA) that literally never have. That is bad government practice, inconsiderate, and, to the degree some ideas might be valuable, bad policy-making. And unnecessarily so. Providers of input probably are not expecting total agreement with their ideas. See “Not Meeting New Jersey State Government’s Basic Responsibility to <a href="https://greeneconomynj.org/2020/10/22/not-meeting-new-jersey-state-governments-basic-responsibility-to-respond-to-constituents-suggestions-frustrating-and-a-barrier-to-innovation/">Respond </a>to Constituents’ Suggestions: Frustrating and a Barrier to Innovation.” Whereas, this later one was better. “Can a Public Meeting Catalyze a <a href="https://greeneconomynj.org/2020/02/28/can-a-public-meeting-catalyze-a-tipping-point-for-both-accelerated-conventional-and-creative-efforts-to-address-climate-change/">Tipping Point</a> for Both Accelerated Conventional and Creative Efforts to Address Climate Change?“</p><p>2. All-of-Government Approach. This is fine and appropriate, but a method to do this was in a 2002 Report based on what an Interagency Sustainability Working Group found. See <a href="https://dspace.njstatelib.org/handle/10929/70056">Governing</a> With The Future in Mind. Beyond this, relevant non-NJDEP agencies should acknowledge their connection. At recent forums I’ve attended, neither the NJBPU or The Highlands Council even mentioned NJDEP. Even while focused on things closer to their mission, other agencies should mention this, at least in passing</p><p>3. Keep a further eye on California (which NJDEP is probably already doing). This includes California’s <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/23/climate/gavin-newsom-california-climate-action.html#:~:text=In%20China%20this%20week%2C%20Mr,California&#39;s%20climate%20policies%20and%20technologies">global</a> work, having large companies report on their carbon emissions, and incentives for those with <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/11/16/business/energy-environment/los-angeles-energy-inequality.html?searchResultPosition=9">low</a> income.</p><p>But certainly not just California when other states do innovative things, too. The Work Plan does hint this</p><p>4. Be careful with Metrics. As the one-time lead on NJDEP’s and State Government’s Indicators efforts, I suspected some problems with them at the time, which later led to writing 22 articles exploring these and how to overcome them. See “Putting the Cart Before the Horse: Five Anecdotes About Sustainable Business Metrics,“ the most relevant of the 22 to <a href="https://sustainablebrands.com/read/new-metrics/putting-the-cart-before-the-horse-five-anecdotes-about-sustainable-business-metrics">NJDEP</a></p><p>5. Product Labeling. This initiative isn’t mentioned in the Work Plan. I gave comments to NJDEP staff on product labeling based on a Policy Paper I did over 30 years ago. (It may be available at the NJDEP or State Library.) Among other things, labeling can go beyond just ensuring accuracy of a claim. It can promote better-performing products and thereby be an element supporting a green economy</p><p>6. Cost: Benefit Analysis/Social Cost of Capital. This isn’t mentioned in the Work Plan, either. I also gave comments about this to NJDEP staff based on a Work Group Guidebook written during the Whitman Administration</p><p>7. Sequestration. This is mentioned in the Work Plan. I was impressed earlier with the scope of ideas during a conversation with NJDEP staff. To critics who argue that it is a diversion from the emphasis on reducing carbon emissions, NJDEP might respond: (a) it might (and probably will be) necessary, (b) it is possible to do both mitigation and sequestration, and (c)if I remember right, they’re focusing on natural solutions. This is not to say investing in some research and development (R&amp;D) or following others’ work on other ways to sequester carbon shouldn’t be done (such as putting it in concrete). It depends on the relative risks, whether those risks can be managed, and, in the end, how desperate we may one day be.</p><p>However, regarding natural sequestration, as I learned during Senator Bob Smith’s <a href="https://www.sierraclub.org/sites/www.sierraclub.org/files/2023-03/NJ_Forest_Stewardship_Task_Force_Report.pdf">Forests</a> Task Force earlier this year, there isn’t a full consensus on what “Healthy Forests” means. The best that NJDEP can do is catch up on this work (if it hasn’t already), follow the recommendations that achieved consensus, and see if anyone can help bridge the gaps between stakeholders when they don’t agree on such difficult issues as when, if ever, trees should be cut, the deer management issue, and apparent conflicts between the goals of addressing climate change and biodiversity.</p><p>Some key areas did not receive enough attention by the Task Force, such as whether “Sustainability” has been misused but doesn’t have to be, why there seems to be a binary choice between protecting old growth and planting new trees, whether there are at least some green jobs prospects in this area, and whether there’s ever a place for non-native species.</p><p>However, I also found the consensus-attempting process that the Task Force leaders used was excellent, even apart from the results, including bringing in leading outside scientists to inform us on some of the above. It would be a good model for trying to address other tough issues</p><p>8. Keep the biodiversity connection in mind. See “10 Ways the Climate Crisis and Nature Loss are <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/nov/29/10-ways-in-which-climate-crisis-and-nature-are-linked-aoe?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other">Linked</a>.” This regards both joint opportunities, as more of the one not focused on might be possible; and when there might be trade-offs, meaning that helping with one hurts the other. How can these trade-offs be avoided or at least minimized? In comparison to concern about climate change which is now at least partially mainstreamed, our society has not yet woken up to how serious the biodiversity crisis is. See “Number of Species at Risk of <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/nov/08/species-at-risk-extinction-doubles-to-2-million-aoe?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other">Extinction</a> Doubles to 2 Million, Says Study“</p><p>9. Consider the potential upsides of the Biomass/Bioenergy Economy, as the downsides are already known. While the ethanol experience, one form of bioenergy, might at best be considered a learning experience, we’re likely to need bioenergy to transform sectors that cannot easily convert to green electricity. Plus, by working with the New Jersey Department of Agriculture and NJEDA, there may be the opportunity to displace oil-based products with much more benign farm products. I’m aware of only one report in this area, written by the Rutgers <a href="https://ecocomplex.rutgers.edu/documents/BIOMASS_ASSESSMENT_2.0_2015.pdf">Eco-Complex</a>, which I believe was ignored. Sustainability, not just a technical approach, needs to guide this, too</p><p>10.Sustainability. Don’t just use “Sustainability” as a throw-away adjective placed before a noun, like “Architecture,” “Buildings,” or “Business.” That adds little meaning to them. Instead, take the tenets, insights, and ideas of the field seriously, including the stretching of current thinking.</p><p>I once facilitated a rare story directly on sustainability in the New York Times by a columnist but first had to explain to him, in a conversation, that sustainability is not synonymous with climate change, yet adds value to understanding it. See “It’s the End of California as We Know It: The Fires and The Blackouts are Connected to a Larger Problem in this State: A Failure to Live <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/30/opinion/sunday/california-fires.html">Sustainably</a>.”</p><p>If we start to see conflicts between environmental justice and other goals, go deeper into sustainability to try to resolve them. Or if businesses claim they are sustainable, because they are doing a few good things. But, while they won’t say this, they’re doing nothing to conserve biodiversity. So point them to specific businesses that are. See this organization, The Wildlife <a href="https://www.wildlifehc.org/">Habitat</a> Council that works with businesses on biodiversity projects, including those that simultaneously help with climate change. Or see this book by their Executive Director, a former New Jersey environmentalist: Strategic Corporate <a href="https://islandpress.org/author/margaret-ogorman">Conservation</a> Planning: A Guide to Meaningful Engagement</p><p>11.Carbon Tax. While probably the most politically infeasible strategy NJDEP or the New Jersey Department of Treasury could do, one day we may need a major one to reach our current goals, and even more so if we have to accelerate those goals. Which is quite likely. Imagine if we had one now. It could be very helpful with multiple issues like funding New Jersey Transit or environmental equity projects. If the day comes when we’re prepared to consider a carbon tax, and if a rebate feature is a part of it to restore equity, try to keep a portion of the revenues for such purposes as R&amp;D, careful subsidization of high potential green technologies, or adaptation.</p><p>However, the wider the geographic scope of a carbon tax, the better. That is, multi-state is better than just New Jersey implementing it. The national scale is even better. See “New Jersey Now ‘Gets’ Climate Change. What We Are Still Missing: Focus State Support for a <a href="https://greeneconomynj.org/2019/01/20/new-jersey-now-gets-climate-change-what-we-are-still-missing-focus-state-support-for-a-carbon-tax-at-the-federal-level-part-5/">Carbon Tax</a> at the Federal Level: Part 5”</p><p>12.Research &amp; Development. Contrary to the message sometimes sent that “We know how to (fully) address climate change,” we’re going to need new technologies. During the Kean Administration, New Jersey had a focus on funding advanced and even speculative technologies. Return to this and carefully pick and seed high potential, but less-than-certain technologies. If successful, these technologies could be passed to the marketplace and make a big difference, with taxpayers getting a fair return. However, don’t overlook less technical, more socially-oriented ideas, or quality public input to and acceptance of choices. Try to avoid unintended consequences. Again, use a deep sustainability perspective</p><p>13.Don’t just focus on Rutgers University as the State’s exclusive higher education partner. Rutgers nearly always is the only university mentioned, as there seems to be a mistaken assumption that it is the only place to go for help. I have taught and/or been a Fellow at five other New Jersey colleges, attended conferences at many other colleges, and was a long-time member of the New Jersey Higher Education Partnership for Sustainability (NJHEPS). Other colleges, professors, and students at them can help, too.</p><p>This is not to take anything from Rutgers, as it too has come a long way, with their climate change work prominent in the field. But even they could do more. See “<a href="https://dailytargum.com/article/2020/02/rutgers-climate-task-force-has-work-to-do">COMMENTARY</a>: Rutgers’ Climate Task Force Has Work To Do.”</p><p>14.Social Science. We don’t usually think about climate change this way, as usually technology or policy frame our thinking, but we’re facing a massive challenge to change human (and organizational) behavior. Focusing just on science and technology is not going to be enough. There’s increasing thought, coming from multiple fields, that we need to reach people in other ways besides presenting facts and data. We’re going to have to better understand how to do that. We also need to do better at anticipating the negative consequences of technical choices we’re considering, before they’re introduced and lead to unpleasant surprises. If we did, we may be better able to ameliorate them, with more public acceptance. We can’t just leave out the human element, both through social science and the <a href="https://uci.edu/brilliant/human-experience/humanities/science-needs-the-humanities-to-solve-climate-change.php">humanities</a></p><p>15.Problems with how we sometimes think, the assumptions we make, and our mindsets, including by those actively trying to address climate change. This has been my focus in recent years. See this <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9m3MhwsbHfA">talk</a> I gave, in part on my NJDEP experience, entitled “What’s Holding Us Back on Climate Change.” Or this article, “New Jersey Now ‘Gets’ Climate Change. What We Are Still Missing: Why We’re <a href="http://greeneconomynj.org/2019/01/03/new-jersey-now-gets-climate-change-what-we-are-still-missing-why-were-not-talking-about-what-were-not-talking-about-part-4/">Not Talking About</a> What We’re Not Talking About: Part 4.” Some of the other suggestions reflect this</p><p>16.NJDEP needs to realize that it has a culture. It’s not only because it’s a government agency as, likely, all other sectors have cultures, too. It’s also not necessarily a bad thing. But cultures can be limiting, by narrowing what they see, how they think and communicate, and — what they don’t see. NJDEP should try to be sensitive to this, including occasionally asking internally: “What are missing?” And not take the first quick “Nothing” as the answer. See “New Jersey Now ‘Gets’ Climate Change. What We Are Still Missing: Starting with <a href="https://greeneconomynj.org/2018/10/22/new-jersey-now-gets-climate-change-what-we-are-still-missing-starting-with-organizational-culture-part-2/">Organizational Culture</a>: Part 2”</p><p>17.Innovation Ecosystem. This is a term used in the Work Plan. Go beyond the mindset that innovation is only seen with advanced technologies. There is also social innovation/entrepreneurship (related to the green economy), policy innovation, and organizational innovation.</p><p>Another mindset blockage is that innovation can only look like what people are expecting. Something very different might not even make it in the door. That’s the opposite of innovation</p><p>18.The Governor’s Environmental Excellence Awards. The criteria for this are heavily numbers-oriented, focusing on, for example, how many pounds of pollution are reduced by the applicant’s initiative/project. While this certainly has its place, for example, the whole area of ideas, catalyzing initiatives, and getting people to raise their sense of what’s possible is ruled out. Again, not innovative. The criteria for this Award need to be re-thought to better reflect the State’s direction and what it will take to achieve its (possibly speeded up) goals</p><p>19.Education. The State is rightly proud of being the first, and maybe still the only, State to have a K-12 climate change curriculum. But New Jersey shouldn’t rest on its laurels. Future iterations could get into various themes: emphasizing that there are still unknowns in how to address aspects of climate change, thereby alerting and maybe motivating students to be the ones to figure things out; adding some of the themes of these comments; preparing the facilitators we’re going to need with the skills and resources to try to bring people together to resolve difficult issues, both those that are here and may be coming; and how to merge science-based facts and process with stories/narratives, spiritual beliefs, and other ways of knowing. I suspect that education may eventually be seen as even more necessary to address climate change, and not just in the conventional sense, and not just for K-12 or even college students.</p><p>See “<a href="https://enveurope.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s12302-021-00525-8">Non-conventional</a> Learning on Sustainable Development: Achieving the SDGs,” “It’s OK, We Disagree’: as Campuses Boil Over With Rage, Some Seek <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/nov/25/us-students-colleges-universities-israel-hamas-gaza">Elusive Path</a> to Dialogue,” or “From 45 Years as a Sustainability Change-Agent: 40 Ideas and Lessons to Pass on to Students and <a href="https://innovator3.medium.com/from-45-years-as-a-sustainability-change-agent-40-ideas-and-lessons-to-pass-on-to-students-and-c704bf487a9e">Perpetual Students</a>: The Biggies: Part 1“</p><p>20.Green Economy/Green Jobs. Current thinking about this topic properly considers now-conventional ideas like jobs in the solar and wind sectors, other renewables, sometimes efficiency, sometimes buildings. But it overlooks many other possibilities. This includes both other sectors and ideas.</p><p>Regarding other sectors, why not think of the possibilities of almost any sector greening, including, but way beyond, renewables and the jobs associated with them? That type of greening is associated with the sustainable business revolution, with which the NJDEP has historically dabbled, but has not taken even close to full advantage.</p><p>For instance, some companies have accepted the need to address climate change, have announced ambitious net carbon zero goals, and supported climate change public policy. Some are even working, on the environmental side, to enhance biodiversity, and, on the social side, to support democracy, Black Lives Matter, and LGBTQ issues. See “On 40 Years Watching the <a href="http://www.sustainablebrands.com/news_and_views/organizational_change/matt_polsky/40_years_watching_sustainable_business_field">Sustainable Business</a> Field: Part II of Using Sustainability to Recharge America’s Problem-Solving” for some of the possibilities.</p><p>There also are interrelated ideas that facilitate a green economy like green design (see “America’s Broken Systems: A Case for <a href="http://www.sustainablebrands.com/news_and_views/organizational_change/matt_polsky/america%E2%80%99s_broken_systems_case_sustainable_design">Sustainable Design</a>?: Part I of Using Sustainability to Recharge America’s Problem-Solving”), biomimicry, life cycle assessment, industrial ecology, the circular economy, “B Corps,” green industrial policy, and impact investment.</p><p>These ideas are not new, but have been underutilized. Why not consider a goal to be the leading state in expanding the now almost conventional idea of a green economy, and bring in potentially all of these ideas? There could be gains in most areas of sustainability, including the economy, environment, and even social areas.</p><p>A report, co-written by my students at Ramapo College in 2018, has many ideas on this, but has been ignored by this Administration. See “A <a href="https://www.ramapo.edu/mass/wp-content/uploads/sites/129/2018/06/PolskyA_Green_Economy_for_NJ.pdf">Green Economy</a> for New Jersey: A Proposal to the New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy,’ &amp; ‘Postscript: Going Wider and Deeper with the Green Economy.” It includes several Appendices, including a summary of most of the earlier State reports on a green economy, and ideas on how to take further advantage of agriculture.</p><p>It would prove useful if the State, and particularly the OCAGE, decide to go deeper into, and even aim to mainstream, the green economy.</p><p>(If this article is ever reviewed at the federal level, here’s a version for them by another Ramapo College class, “Defending the <a href="http://greeneconomynj.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/DefendingtheGNDJun2019.pdf">Green New Deal</a>: Recommendations To Build On What’s Actually In It While Reaching Out To Others”.)</p><p>21.Efficiency. The following are comments I sent to the NJBPU in September, 2023, after a webinar it sponsored on energy efficiency.</p><p>It reinforces some of the same concepts mentioned above, and a few others. It: highlights the vital importance of efficiency (which often gets overlooked in discussions about energy supply options) and keeping the public posted on how the State is doing on it, the overlooked importance of implementation, keeping up with the state of the art, use of terms in communication, and the value of social science.</p><p>“(I) Read/browsed the PPT and listened to most of the Presentation. Many good points (e.g. the link with solar and now water, suggestions on how to go beyond the Audit findings, the enthusiasm of the speakers), but didn’t see some things, or other issues:</p><p>· At times, too jargony. If you don’t know the field, you’ll miss some of the terms. I didn’t see the customer’s perspective, particularly the very new customer unfamiliar with the lay of the land and knowing who’s who (including the differences between the roles of BPU, TRC, and the utility). Suggest take the view of a new applicant. Follow them through the process, seeing where they might get stuck</p><p>· What I call “People” issues continue to be missed. These include (a) why does the LGEA application my Synagogue submitted several months ago just sit, without period notifications of status? I heard it takes an average of 7 months once everything is complete. I’m pretty sure my synagogue’s complete application has taken longer. It makes it difficult to maintain committee interest from the customer end (which can be hard enough); (b) No social science on how to influence peoples’ behavior to be interested/receptive to energy efficiency. Do we know what percentage of people show initial interest and then don’t go further; and why? What is social science discovering about this field?</p><p>· No big picture on the importance of the State’s energy efficiency goal and how we’re doing in achieving it</p><p>· No showing of technical innovations and thought on how to ramp up energy efficiency to potentially new stretch goals. For instance, see this article in yesterday’s Times. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2023/09/19/realestate/sustainable-home-renovation-brooklyn.html">https://www.nytimes.com/2023/09/19/realestate/sustainable-home-renovation-brooklyn.html</a>. Does BPU follow this field?</p><p>· No link to DEP’s Product Labeling and Sustainable Business Initiatives, the very new Social Cost of Carbon announcement for all State Agencies (<a href="https://na01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Furldefense.com%2Fv3%2F__https%3A%2Fwww.njspotlightnews.org%2F2023%2F09%2Fnj-murphy-administration-wont-back-down-clean-energy-goals%2F__%3B!!J30X0ZrnC1oQtbA!KRGDgJInIy_HGlG8BGHs9y_oNrNw-RM5xZlT9I8LCJ2x1rT6mRvpmrnOzBFnBN2TnheT6GRfKuS4TYyULFzR4EE7csswRw%24&amp;data=05%7C01%7C%7Cbf2724cc75cc4669a5b708dbd01ab551%7C84df9e7fe9f640afb435aaaaaaaaaaaa%7C1%7C0%7C638332585378122421%7CUnknown%7CTWFpbGZsb3d8eyJWIjoiMC4wLjAwMDAiLCJQIjoiV2luMzIiLCJBTiI6Ik1haWwiLCJXVCI6Mn0%3D%7C3000%7C%7C%7C&amp;sdata=RarQ%2F39YG4INAeQU17OgW54t%2BAjxFkhaCm9QgdrKgw8%3D&amp;reserved=0">https://www.njspotlightnews.org/2023/09/nj-murphy-administration-wont-back-down-clean-energy-goals/</a>), or Sustainable Jersey</p><p>· Did the State ever see my last formal comments to the BPU from 2019? <a href="https://na01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Furldefense.com%2Fv3%2F__http%3A%2Fgreeneconomynj.org%2F2019%2F09%2F17%2Fcomments-to-the-new-jersey-board-of-public-utilities-njbpu-on-their-2019-draft-energy-master-plan-emp%2F__%3B!!J30X0ZrnC1oQtbA!KRGDgJInIy_HGlG8BGHs9y_oNrNw-RM5xZlT9I8LCJ2x1rT6mRvpmrnOzBFnBN2TnheT6GRfKuS4TYyULFzR4EFyQcQErw%24&amp;data=05%7C01%7C%7Cbf2724cc75cc4669a5b708dbd01ab551%7C84df9e7fe9f640afb435aaaaaaaaaaaa%7C1%7C0%7C638332585378278660%7CUnknown%7CTWFpbGZsb3d8eyJWIjoiMC4wLjAwMDAiLCJQIjoiV2luMzIiLCJBTiI6Ik1haWwiLCJXVCI6Mn0%3D%7C3000%7C%7C%7C&amp;sdata=LJKBe8mKwLE9xsgFkRRXpmYj1bmhWzp5rBfpl18iTCc%3D&amp;reserved=0">http://greeneconomynj.org/2019/09/17/comments-to-the-new-jersey-board-of-public-utilities-njbpu-on-their-2019-draft-energy-master-plan-emp/</a>. I stopped doing these, after three or four iterations over the years, because I saw no evidence that they ever went anywhere”</p><p>22.Speaking to Conservatives. In some circles, conservatives are presumed to be unreachable on climate change. This is unfortunate, as I can’t see how the State can achieve its ambitious goals without them.</p><p>We’ve already seen problems with the constructed controversy of windfarms at the shore (though not all opponents are conservative), parts of the state (yes, even New Jersey) where you can’t say “climate change” (or you can advocate for it, but can’t call it by its name).</p><p>Yet, there have been some successes. See either “Seven Projects with <a href="https://innovator3.medium.com/seven-projects-with-potential-to-talk-to-the-trump-voter-part-4-e172ee80f4c">Potential</a> to Talk to the Trump Voter: Part 4,“ for ideas, or “Climate Change, A <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/climate-change-divided-america-need-sustainability-policy-ira-feldman">Divided</a> America, and The Need For Sustainability Policy.”</p><p>23.Transformation. New Jersey is way behind Europe in the field of Sustainable Transformation or large societal changes. This field tries to understand how to make big changes in society, including what is blocking them, and how to overcome obstacles, such as through the use of pilots or demos of cutting edge ideas which can be difficult to imagine. Some of the thinking in this field has changed from these things should be kept away from government, as government, by its nature, is too bureaucratic and resistant to change. To now, that is not necessarily true, and that government must be part of it. There are people in government who are comfortable with more rapid change, but, as in the earlier comment on culture, assumptions have to be identified and no-longer relevant ones changed.</p><p>Transformation is in at least implicit contrast to a common theory of how to make societal change: “One building block at a time.” This assumption about slow change can be effective, and certainly much easier, including politically and what it is asking from the government and the public. But may not be sufficient if, again, the goals have to be accelerated</p><p>See “Sustainability <a href="https://petrakuenkel.com/article/sustainability-transformations/">Transformations</a>” and “New Jersey Now ‘Gets’ Climate Change. What We Are Still Missing: “From Government and <a href="http://greeneconomynj.org/2018/10/28/new-jersey-now-gets-climate-change-what-we-are-still-missing-from-government-and-really-helping-part-3/">Really Helping</a>: Part 3.”</p><p>For more on speeding up change, as well as unappreciated mindset barriers that make it harder, see “Leverage Points Meets Sustainable Transformation: <a href="https://oidaijsd.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/12-12-2-130.pdf">Speeding Up</a> Sustainability Progress and 101 Mindset Barriers to It”</p><p>24.Phase Out Fossil Fuels. This has been a hard step for the State to take although, it can be argued, this is the trend line. Still, it’s not clear to everyone what the writing on the wall says. Not all pipeline projects have been killed, and there is political opposition to some clean energy measures, like encouraging electric stoves.</p><p>Yet, while, as above, providing some support to and keeping an eye on sequestration, there is no way to protect our planet without phasing them out. Perhaps international climate change negotiators at the U.N. Conference of The Parties 28 (COP28), resuming their work today, will get there some day.</p><p>New Jersey could beat them to it by announcing a phase-out schedule for fossil fuels, giving these sectors and their customers plenty of notice of what’s coming, and time to prepare. It would not be the first time the state led global action.</p><p>New Jersey has to bite this bullet</p><p>25. Much more and better biking. The occasional calls for more biking, while important, are framed by a limited sense of what’s possible. Check out some European cities; e.g., Copenhagen, Munster, Rotterdam, Amsterdam; and see things at an entirely different scale. This could be our long-term vision, even if we can only work on specific projects on a more limited basis. “See Transport Matters: Strengthening the <a href="https://www.itdp.org/2022/03/02/strengthening-the-human-infrastructure-of-cycling/">Human Infrastructure</a> of Cycling”</p><p>26.County and Municipal Scales. The Plan is vague about what these are. Existing ones, other than Sustainable Jersey, may not be well known. Initiatives at these scales have their own possibilities.</p><p>See “12 Ideas for <a href="http://greeneconomynj.org/2019/09/12/12-ideas-for-sustainable-jerseys-next-10-years/">Sustainable Jersey</a>’s ‘Next 10 Years” for the local scale, and “New Jersey Now ‘Gets’ Climate Change. What We Are Still Missing: A Climate Vision for Montgomery County, Maryland: Should We Be Doing This in New Jersey?: Part 6“ for the county scale</p><p>27.Speaking of scales, expand the international presence. This includes both learning from other parts of the world, and showing what we are doing in New Jersey. See “The New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection’s <a href="https://ciaotest.cc.columbia.edu/olj/shjdir/v3n2/shjdir_v3n2f.pdf">Non-Traditional</a> Role in Promoting Sustainable Development Internationally,” or “A Personal Learning Bridge: How New Jersey and the World, Including Europe and Germany, Might <a href="https://cues.rutgers.edu/climate-bridge-conference/posters/Matthew-Polsky.html">Learn From</a> Each Other”</p><p>28.Pick up on the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UNSDGs). These <a href="https://sdgs.un.org/goals">17 Goals</a> represent the urgent direction that must be pursued to achieve a sustainable planet. Unfortunately, few in the U.S. are even aware of them though they are not new. While climate change is only one of them, all 17 are interrelated. And while they are not intended for the state level, there is no reason New Jersey cannot pick up on them, adjusted as appropriate, and do its share towards meeting them. That would send quite a message, about direction, the understanding of urgency, the interrelatedness of policies and actions (and not just in government), and that New Jersey “gets” the big picture that we really are “All in this together.” It could even spur non-New Jerseyans to pick up the pace in their pieces of the planet, helping them and, in an interconnected world, indirectly, us too</p><p>29.Not Just NJDEP. Having worked with or within other sectors in New Jersey (see below) over the decades, in the years ahead it is not just NJDEP that needs to consider transformational possibilities, and what they might be missing. NJDEP does not operate in a vacuum. It’s also (a) other state agencies; (b) the Legislature; (c) as above, other levels of government; (d) business (as above, all sectors); (d) higher education; (e) environmental groups; and (f) journalism (see “Where is Sustainability in The <a href="https://www.greenbiz.com/article/where-sustainability-new-york-times">New York Times</a>”). Even social welfare groups must consider their climate change connections and how they can help</p><p>30.Recruit Ex-NJDEPers. Take advantage of interested NJDEP alumni to see if they can lend, in some cases, hard-earned advice to help current staffers think about how to implement some of these ideas and actions.</p><p>Conclusion</p><p>I want to return to four themes involving interrelationships that don’t usually come up: the time dimension, the limits of what NJDEP can do, the need for creativity, and between geographic scales.</p><p>I hope some of these ideas will be considered, both in the short run and in the years ahead. The short- and long-runs are related. The latter should inform and guide the former. And the latter shows climate change is one of the greatest threats we in New Jersey face. As the surprises show up, and limits of current policies become apparent, we and those who come after us are likely to need to strongly consider currently unimagined responses. That’s worth keeping in mind when an idea for a strategy is written off as “infeasible,” particularly politically, or because the specific behavioral change seems too much, too soon.</p><p>These comments ask a lot from NJDEP, but they can’t do this alone. They will need a significant amount of help from others interested in this issue, as well as, through each’s efforts and influence, those who do not yet appreciate the urgency of the situation; working directly with the Agency, or in parallel with their separate efforts.</p><p>Both within and outside NJDEP, this help can come in a variety of forms, such as by showing creativity, which includes pulling together ideas from multiple places and fields, perhaps in ways that have never been done. This includes fields where creativity is understood as essential, such as fashion, but even those where it is not necessarily associated, such as engineering. Certainly, the inertia from a business-as-usual mindset cannot be our guide.</p><p>The photo at the beginning of these Comments shows a mediocre global response to the threats from climate change. While I don’t think the specific grades The Economist assigns are directly applicable to New Jersey, since this Administration has done much better, still, it is relevant in at least two ways.</p><p>The tagline, “Some Progress, Must Try Harder” still applies.</p><p>And while we focus on New Jersey, the global dimension still applies. One of the main messages, apparently forgotten, from the late 1960’s Environmental Revolution is: “We’re all connected” (or “interconnected”).</p><p>What happens in New Jersey both effects the rest of the world and is affected by it, in many usually hidden ways, both negatively and positively. Two positive ways the State and its citizens can affect the world are by staying aware of global developments and by setting examples of what is possible.</p><p>In some cases, we’re already doing this but not realizing it. See “The <a href="https://www.truevaluemetrics.org/DBpdfs/Ideas/MattPolsky/The-Local-Global-Connection.pdf">Local-Global</a> Connection: Forging Inter-scale Sustainability Action.”</p><p>That’s worth remembering as COP28 begins today, with so much at stake. Hopefully it will be surprisingly successful. But, if not, we’re all going to have to step up even more.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/680/1*hJCgy6Qv22f1I9GODUFMGw.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e6c55b3d502" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From 45 Years as a Sustainability Change-Agent: 40 Ideas and Lessons to Pass on to Students and…]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/from-45-years-as-a-sustainability-change-agent-40-ideas-and-lessons-to-pass-on-to-students-and-a5d5246306fa?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a5d5246306fa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability-education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Jan 2023 14:06:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-06T14:06:46.927Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>From 45 Years as a Sustainability Change-Agent: 40 Ideas and Lessons to Pass on to Students and Perpetual Students: What Hasn’t Been Working as Well: Part 3 of 3</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qkCU7uhHh8-hxi9Ji0VKqw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Another False Duality</figcaption></figure><p>In Parts <a href="https://innovator3.medium.com/from-45-years-as-a-sustainability-change-agent-40-ideas-and-lessons-to-pass-on-to-students-and-c704bf487a9e">1</a> &amp; <a href="https://innovator3.medium.com/from-45-years-as-a-sustainability-change-agent-40-ideas-and-lessons-to-pass-on-to-students-and-adb378412440">2</a>, I discussed sustainability ideas I don’t find common, even in others’ sustainability classes and lectures, to students in my two classes this past semester. I also added to them, making 25 in all. Here are my final 15, partially focusing on the teaching process and environment, themselves.</p><p>Whereas Part 2 tended to focus on what was working; Part 3 does the opposite.</p><p>26) While it can be effective to use humor in the classroom, both to humanize things and to make points in other, unexpected ways, the students’ sense of humor and the professor’s may not always be in sync. I showed an old Abbott &amp; Costello skit to try to make the contrarian point that numbers aren’t always as <a href="https://sustainablebrands.com/read/new-metrics/how-superficial-interpretations-of-sustainable-business-metrics-can-be-totally-off-base-part3">straight-forward</a> as their reputation would have it. While they liked the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oN2_NarcM8c">physical humor</a> (although their apparent unfamiliarity with this duo made someone feel old), and showing of long banned educational methods (i.e. hitting someone for taking too long, or calling them “Stupid” when they don’t get it), the point wasn’t accepted to dig deeper about, and question, what numbers are actually telling you</p><p>27) Alternate ways of presenting, including animation, also failed in two ways I tried to make points about mindsets, including as they underlie many of our views, and are a potential source of resistance to societal change. I showed an excerpt from a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9m3MhwsbHfA">video lecture</a> I had given on mindsets, and the trailer from the movie, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C8oiwnNlyE4">Flatland</a>. While they were meaningful to me, from the dazed looks one didn’t have to look for a deeper mindset. Next time I will try the “<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9I5YvLm5KXI">Iceberg Model</a>” of Systems Change, possibly working up to Cloud’s version, or something from Rimanoczy’s <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Sustainability-Mindset-Principles-Developing-Responsible/dp/0367559005/ref=asc_df_0367559005/?tag=hyprod-20&amp;linkCode=df0&amp;hvadid=509245866633&amp;hvpos=&amp;hvnetw=g&amp;hvrand=5049946504794565025&amp;hvpone=&amp;hvptwo=&amp;hvqmt=&amp;hvdev=c&amp;hvdvcmdl=&amp;hvlocint=&amp;hvlocphy=9003739&amp;hvtargid=pla-991325035827&amp;psc=1">Sustainability Mindset</a> work. It’s a concept undergraduates should know, one that took me years to recognize and appreciate</p><p>28) For reasons I don’t understand, students are not at their best with impromptu “field trips” to Tabling events on campus, held by fellow students on the social side of sustainability issues. (I discovered these while walking to class and having a quick preparatory chat with the students there.) My students did not engage well with the students behind the Table, not even on the subject of disabilities, although I know from having been officially told that a few of them have them, and I anticipated more back-and-forth (Still, it was probably a valuable experience for the students, who were not mine, doing the Tabling.)</p><p>29) Conversely, while I would never push it, some students with disabilities (or have siblings who do) can sometimes surprise you with what they are willing to reveal about themselves in class, and how valuable to discussions it is when they do</p><p>30) Students don’t seem as engaged with criticisms of sustainability from the political left or right as I would have thought, or what can be learned and possibly taken from them, and how to respond to them. Or perhaps, I just haven’t figured out yet how to communicate why this subject is important</p><p>31) A few students still don’t understand or remember when I tell them on the first day of class that the definition of plagiarism is more expansive than they realize, and that I would be using Turnitin to screen their final papers. I still got a Paper one had written for a previous class, which is very easy to detect. Unfortunate for them (and me, as it’s painful when it happens), but their action constituted plagiarism, according to the University’s definition. All they had to do was to ask their prior professor and me if they could use their previous paper, but build on it for my class. We probably would have agreed.</p><p>32) Group work, recommended to me by a colleague, and also requested by a student, is a good idea, as it encourages other aspects of the learning experience. But it does not manage itself. There are going to be challenges with Group work as the members’ grades are at least partially linked. There were unexpected issues with meeting deadlines, including an understandable reluctance to present their work when team members had been absent, either during planning sessions, hampering their progress, or on the anticipated date of the presentation. More absences than usual this past semester, possibly for COVID or for other reasons, did not help. The idea of mixing students with different majors together during Group formation did not appear to offer interdisciplinary benefits, but there still may have been some</p><p>33) Students are very familiar with the addictive, time/focus-stealing properties of smart phones, but they still find it very hard to stop. (To be fair, that is true for more than just students.) Clearly being informed is not enough (A meta-lesson in that it is applicable to other societal issues involving behavioral change. That is, contrary to some models of behavioral or societal change, more is required than just providing information.)</p><p>34) Not just for sustainability classes, but it is not clear why students who need them don’t use grammar-checkers, or even spell-checkers. On the other hand, their presentations generally tend to be quite good, with even those who doubted themselves doing better than they thought they could</p><p>35) It is also strange that some students continue to ask questions that are answered in the Syllabus, despite the attention paid to it on the first day</p><p>36) I internally cringe when hearing well-meaning and common calls for “More Education,” although it usually offers a soft and safe approach that is not unwelcome in the sometimes controversial world of sustainability. Education is deeply profound, rich, and even more important than it is already given credit for. Almost casual use (e.g. “We need to recycle more,” “Use more mass transit”) can easily conceal the existence of its potential larger value.</p><p>Superficiality can hide that, at its (badly needed) best, Education:</p><p>1. Offers practice with critical thinking, perhaps the single biggest theme of this Series</p><p>2. Clarifies the difference between superficial and deep sustainability. A colleague once called the former “Sustainability Lite,” and includes when “Sustainability” is cited without much understanding of what it really means, or even knowing that it means anything special</p><p>3. As hinted in Part 1, can be both Practical and offer Ideas. Or put in other ways, offer both skills and thought; be both for theorists/academics and practitioners</p><p>4. Is not just cognitive/intellectual. There are different ways to look at what could, or even needs to be, parts of education.</p><p>Education should:</p><p>· Include instruction about, and modeling of, soft skills, such as empathy-building and active/deep listening</p><p>· Involve alternative models like co-learning between students and professors, experiential learning, <a href="https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED462550">somatic learning</a>, <a href="https://www.wgu.edu/blog/what-transformative-learning-theory2007.html#close">transformational learning</a></p><p>· Be open to meta-lessons, including asking if there is a deeper message to recurrent or related points, or an easily-missed larger picture</p><p>· Of course, include the arts</p><p>· More heavily utilize the social sciences for understanding and trying to address attitudinal, value, and behavioral changes</p><p>· Value the idea of potentially putting (almost) anything “under the microscope,” including if the professor is properly modeling sustainability, even the field of sustainability or the education process themselves</p><p>· Take systems thinking and adaptation to learning styles, seriously</p><p>· Prepare students for lifelong learning, including “Learning how to learn,” and understanding and accommodating how the brain changes with age</p><p>· Seek to renew values and qualities such as awe, wonder, curiosity, imagination, and humility</p><p>· At some points include and merge philosophy, ethics, ecology, and spirituality into other subjects</p><p>· Include occasional experimentation by the professor, including what hasn’t been tried before, or a second or third attempt to re-try, in a different way, something important that did not work well the first time</p><p>· At least briefly mention the “giants” in a particular area, including the late ones, so that students may get a sense of legacy and realize that, if they decide to become involved, are part of something bigger</p><p>· Not avoid controversial and risky subjects (of course, done carefully), and working with sustainability skeptics and cynics</p><p>· Reflect on how to (finally) make sustainability mainstream.</p><p>With both the need and all the possibilities, it would be tragic to keep Education at the superficial level.</p><p>So if “Education” is too easy, or does not risk potentially, but not frivolously, rocking a few boats, we may not be doing or even seeing it right. See <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214629620302991">this</a> for a very extended vision of the role of education</p><p>37) (37–40 could apply to more than just sustainability professors and courses.) Universities should do better in providing A.V. systems in classrooms that dependably and easily work (for us non-techies), and in providing dry erase markers that aren’t so dry they don’t have ink left in them. Students shouldn’t have to witness professors stumbling around, talking to the machine, writing blanks, distracting from what’s more important. It should not be necessary to prepare for class with a “Plan B” in case the technology doesn’t work</p><p>38) Relatedly, having now taught at five colleges, while super-busy Department Heads try, administrations need to be more sensitive to adjunct professors’ relative lack of knowledge about campus practices and situation, and not just in the better-known ways (like last minute cancellation of courses after work has already been invested preparing them)</p><p>Not being around as much, adjuncts are not as likely to know about some necessary matters, and therefore need to take scarce time to find out, thereby detracting from more important time working on the substance of the course:</p><p>· When key support Offices move to different locations, or Information Services breaks their functions into different departments that address different types of problems</p><p>· How professors and students can access The New York Times, because of its paywall, which can be so tricky to overcome that I had even a librarian (whom I value as knowing how to find anything) actually suggest it would be easier to find an alternative source on a subject I wanted to cover. The same with accessing articles from The Washington Post on the same day as class</p><p>· How to learn use now-pervasive course management software, including all the things that can go wrong no one tells you about. There’s also the time necessary to do so, especially when the adjunct has been gone from the campus for a while (I’ve also found there can be differences in how different colleges use the same system)</p><p>· How to work around the absence of support during very high stress periods such as the final day of class, which is the last opportunity for students to give high point value presentations, if the A.V. system doesn’t work, and Media Services went home. Or the day before final grades are due, after emailed warnings of consequences to missing the deadline, the school’s website goes down, and again, no one is staffing Information Services (not that their phone message tells you that)</p><p>· When a detour to a main access street to the campus occurs, along with ways around them, so you know to allow more time to get to class</p><p>Adjuncts might not even see key emails on the college system outside of their contract period.</p><p>Measures to help adjuncts feel part of the University and Department are welcome, such as inviting them to staff luncheons, while understanding it will be difficult to attend most of them.</p><p>If the University reserves Guest dorm rooms for visitors, it would be nice to make them available, without a bureaucratic process, and at a discount to adjuncts who face a long trip back home, late at night, and while very tired and barely functional after an intense three-hour class. That also opens up the possibility for the adjunct to be on campus the next morning, and make it easier to do such things as meet with students</p><p>39) While adjunct work is thought of as transactional, by nature, with pros and cons, there seems to be a combined bureaucratic/creative blockage to considering how to make better use of them, even if they’re only going to be around for a limited time during the week and not for the full year.</p><p>If the big overall goal of the University still is to serve students by contributing to their education, there is an opportunity cost to not finding ways to make more use of adjuncts (e.g. to advise students not in one’s class or college clubs, present at campus conferences, advise an Independent Study student, or provide a different voice about a University initiative). This includes seeing to the Administrative arrangements to facilitate this</p><p>40) Regarding colleges themselves, as a student, I once heard the Dean of my school say: Colleges are where “The life of the mind resides”</p><p>Yet, I’m not sure many believe this anymore. If not, they need to get back to it. Universities and what happens in the classroom (at least at their best) are unique and important. That includes being the intellectual hub for the creation of non-technical knowledge; trying to solve difficult societal problems that no other sector has the same ability to do; fostering curiosity and humility; and creating the best conditions possible for students and professors to experience “A ha!” moments (As well as the community, too, when they work on common initiatives.)</p><p>Therefore, unnecessary bureaucracy within the university should be screened for and eliminated when it gets in the way.</p><p>Hopefully, many, or at least some students, will make it a priority in their future lives to help address urgent societal problems, no matter what profession they find themselves in. Maybe a few will even make it a major priority. Such a mission won’t be easy. But it would be worthwhile.</p><p>If this does happen, while it is unlikely the professor will ever know — even just imagining it helps one at least temporarily forget the “grindier” parts of teaching, and keep saying “Yes” to opportunities to teach it again!</p><p>Yes, it is beyond trite to say that “Students are our future.” But as this is one conventional wisdom that has it right, the rest of us need to do everything we can to help them get ready!</p><p>Acknowledgements</p><p>At the conclusion of this Series, I would like to thank my wife, Sandy, for the editing; guest speakers for the two courses: Larry Furman; Allison McLeod, New Jersey League of Conservation Voters; Dr. Prabhakar Shrestha, NJIT’s Assistant Director of Sustainability; student guest speakers from Ramapo College’s Enactus Club: Leah Carratura, Liam Thornbury, and Naydelin Reyes Rodriguez; and my Department Heads, Dr. Maurie Cohen of NJIT’s Department of Humanities and Social Science, and Dr. Ashwani Vasishth of Ramapo College’s School of Social Science and Human Services.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a5d5246306fa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From 45 Years as a Sustainability Change-Agent: 40 Ideas and Lessons to Pass on to Students and…]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/from-45-years-as-a-sustainability-change-agent-40-ideas-and-lessons-to-pass-on-to-students-and-adb378412440?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/adb378412440</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability-thought]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Jan 2023 19:04:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-03T19:04:02.313Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>From 45 Years as a Sustainability Change-Agent: 40 Ideas and Lessons to Pass on to Students and Perpetual Students: What’s Been Working: Part Two of Three</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*OCIo6VxOhZVL2A48UlGEyQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Unless you’re going to be a firefighter, not very vocational</figcaption></figure><p>In <a href="https://innovator3.medium.com/from-45-years-as-a-sustainability-change-agent-40-ideas-and-lessons-to-pass-on-to-students-and-c704bf487a9e">Part 1</a>, I discussed eight key points of two recently-completed fall semester courses, World Sustainability and Science, Technology, &amp; Society (STS), on their respective last days of class. In Part 2 I provide an expanded list 17 more, including some anecdotes.</p><p>9) Becoming better at having difficult conversations, particularly with those with whom you <a href="https://medium.com/@innovator3/forget-trump-for-a-day-but-is-it-past-time-for-trump-loathers-and-trump-voters-to-talk-part-1-ffb647c16401">disagree</a>, may be another means to work through and find better answers on hard issues. Even if that goal is not immediate, it is possible to achieve civility — we do it all the time in class, despite what we see in the larger society. And that is its own accomplishment</p><p>10) Just because some ideas for potentially better answers to difficult societal issues may exist within sustainability doesn’t mean they are widely known in society, or even in the environmental or sustainability communities. Don’t assume what we talk about in class is easily replicated outside of it (not that they shouldn’t frequently try.) Further, all audiences they face may not hold the same assumptions (See Number 9 above.)</p><p>11) In the STS class where sustainability is not necessarily explicit, students do not mind the introduction of it into classroom discussions, and tend to be responsive to it. However, familiarity with the idea of curriculum, as in “How do we change curriculum in courses university-wide to be more consistent with sustainability?” is not meaningful. They tend to come back with “More recycling bins,” which isn’t necessarily course-relevant (not that it couldn’t be), but is far from what is intended or needed</p><p>12) Engineers and technically trained people (which describes the STS class) may have latent power to address societal problems with their future employers because of the importance of their skills — even if they don’t believe their professor about this</p><p>13) It is vital that society does better in assessing and minimizing the dangers from new product technologies before they are introduced. We can’t keep making the same mistakes, such as with cryptocurrency recently. Some means to do this exist</p><p>14) We seem to have turned a corner on the subject of businesses acting sustainably. In the past, when I brought up this topic, the reaction was an automatic and confident statement that “It’s all greenwash.” When I brought up Interface, the visionary carpet company that was aiming for zero pollution — and then going “beyond zero,” they would listen, but couldn’t see the larger possibilities, such as more companies seriously pursuing sustainability. But for the first time in the 30th course I taught, after I brought up an example of a company that has strongly innovated sustainability practices (i.e. Patagonia), later in the course students researched and discussed others, such as Coca Cola, Ikea, and Nike</p><p>15) After the students read an article about the high protein content of insects, which suggested eating more of them, I brought in a package of dried insects for them to try. (Consistent with a suggestion a professor of mine once made to try to utilize more of the senses in teaching). Only a few took me up on it. Even with their faces covered by masks, their expressions were quite funny. I’m sure they were thinking: “Professor Polsky might bring them to class, but I’m still not going to eat bugs.”</p><p>We did work out conditions that would lead a few to try: as a hidden ingredient and if they didn’t know about it (So much for transparency!)</p><p>16) The analysis or treatment of every issue does not have to be strictly global, even in a global course, although it may be indirectly present. However, be mindful of opportunities to influence the scope of any future sustainability activities, such as within a town, to this larger scale</p><p>17) Advice I received from a fellow professor to bring in the Carbon Footprint concept, “They relate to it,” proved true, even with the additional element I added of putting the concept, itself, under the microscope. I asked whether, in any way, the concept is limited. (Later, in a final paper, a student picked up on this.) By completing a questionnaire, developed by students at another college, they were able to assess their own carbon footprints. In a couple of their later assignments, a number mentioned that they were surprised and disappointed by their poor scores, it had gotten to them, and made them think of what they could do to improve (That was true, too, for their professor.)</p><p>18) We can learn from anyone, including from other students, including those not in our class when they come to give a guest lecture</p><p>19) Bringing in popular culture, if not over-done, can be a useful way to understand big picture issues. Student tend to be more familiar with what’s going on in popular culture than I am, more comfortable bringing it up and talking about it, making it easier to see the relevance to larger points. For instance, the specific celebrities that have disproportionately high carbon footprints due to their frequent private flying</p><p>20) Also in contrast with the past, they can come in with a bit of familiarity with advanced concepts like <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sf4oW8OtaPY&amp;list=RDQMcJnApwOuxi8&amp;start_radio=1">biomimicry</a>, <a href="https://thesystemsthinker.com/systems-thinking-what-why-when-where-and-how/">systems thinking</a> and <a href="https://www.verywellmind.com/definition-of-social-construct-1448922">social construction</a>. They tend to be fine with some level of challenge to the motherhood-and-apple pie Scientific Method they learned in high school, taught as without flaw, and the need for it and how it’s used to evolve to better address sustainability. But not if taken too far into <a href="https://i2insights.org/2021/10/19/guide-to-post-normal-science/">post-normal</a> science or <a href="https://www.britannica.com/topic/postmodernism-philosophy">post-modernism</a></p><p>21) Even on the first day of class during routine student introductions, there were opportunities in something just about what everyone said to immediately model the intense discussion/conversation-oriented nature of what was to come throughout the entire course</p><p>22) I was surprised and delighted that not only did a high school student find his way to my class, but that on some assignments he had the highest grade. Also, he was more familiar with the environmental classics than anyone in the class, something that doesn’t always come up in a sustainability course. His high school had prepared him well</p><p>23) Some students are shocked to learn of the degree of poverty, hunger, and lack of clean water in some developing countries. It influenced their choice of topics for their final papers. In addition, sometimes using the U.N.’s 17 <a href="https://unsdg.un.org/">Sustainable Development Goals</a>, which I had introduced early in the course, they made interconnections between issue-areas. One student reacted to another student’s presentation of the immense flooding in Pakistan by asking “Why didn’t I know that?,” facilitating a connection to, and discussion of, the issue of media coverage, or lack of it, of sustainability.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a></p><p>24) In keeping with a promise I made early in semester that even though we talk about very serious subjects, I’m not against having some fun, I bought a therapy dog to class and let him roam the classroom. (I asked permission for the latter, with students reacting as if that was the dumbest question I had asked all semester.) Not sure there was a larger sustainability point, there, but there was a lot of hugging going on</p><p>25) Students taught me: in a discussion about a circular economy, the stigma against wearing used clothing is gone (thanks, in part, very surprisingly, to Tiktok). Who knew?</p><p>In Part 3, we will discuss several remaining “Ideas and Lessons.” Many will be more directly linked to what happens in the college classroom, including when things don’t work that well, such as when key sustainability points are not well grasped by students.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> A major problem for sustainability — even now — 35 years after the <a href="http://www.un-documents.net/our-common-future.pdf">Brundtland Commission</a> put sustainability on the map. And what does that tell us?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=adb378412440" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[From 45 Years as a Sustainability Change-Agent: 40 Ideas and Lessons to Pass on to Students and…]]></title>
            <link>https://innovator3.medium.com/from-45-years-as-a-sustainability-change-agent-40-ideas-and-lessons-to-pass-on-to-students-and-c704bf487a9e?source=rss-9a2ce080fbb9------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c704bf487a9e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability-in-society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[matt polsky]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Jan 2023 10:27:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-02T10:27:41.908Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>From 45 Years as a Sustainability Change-Agent: 40 Ideas and Lessons to Pass on to Students and Perpetual Students: The Biggies: Part One of Three</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AmUnVlSI7Zb5Xe6GQ6dTQg.jpeg" /><figcaption>So do we still believe this?</figcaption></figure><p>Over the decades, as both an Adjunct Professor for 31 courses, in several other sectors, with multiple identities, I’ve become aware my approach to sustainability differs from others, both in the classroom and when trying to make change outside of it.</p><p>That is:</p><p>· While obviously heavily overlapping with the environment, sustainability is not the same thing. It increasingly seeks to bring in the economic and social spheres. And not in a token way. While we’ve seen progress doing this for environmental justice, and certainly there are a number of fields now built around environmental economics, we are far from finished. (At a couple of public hearings I attended last summer on environmental justice, economics was treated by nearly everyone who testified as the enemy. While understandable, it doesn’t have to be.)</p><p>· If you’re going to say “Interdisciplinary” (or its variants), you have to practice them. For instance, you can’t just rule out politics as irrelevant or divisive. You have to include and search for ways to make it work. (See this <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/climate-change-divided-america-need-sustainability-policy-ira-feldman">co-written</a> with Ira Feldman.)</p><p>· The same is true for other aspects we used to say during the brief heyday of sustainability in the late 1990’s when the field almost made it to the societal/political mainstream: “Sustainability ties to all other problems” (even if those working on these problems don’t seem to know that); and “Sustainability offers a framework and tools for understanding and addressing problems.” That is, it’s not just what you see in the media from time to time, an adjective to occasionally add to a field, such as “Sustainable” in front of architecture or business</p><p>· While sustainability somehow missed that moment (again, see the above- reference), the possibility of reaching the everyday mainstream still exists. And we still need it to. So it’s important to keep prodding and being opportunistic to make it so</p><p>· In the educational sphere, it is not just about doing projects, although they have their place (and I’ve started including them in courses). Same for skill-building — as obviously important as that is, particularly these days. In my telling, it’s mostly about a way of thinking. But, again, taken seriously</p><p>· Further on classroom education (which I pick up again on in Part 3), professors’ messages can be too basic, when students might be capable of understanding more complex ideas. While it’s impossible to target perfectly, from time to time treat freshman and sophomores as upper-classmen and see how it goes. If the ideas overwhelm them, then return to a more basic level. You only have them once, and you don’t know if they’ll ever be exposed to important ideas you exclude</p><p>· Making change is about both pursuing small, incremental improvements (AKA, actions or steps) and seeking big, what’s now being called Transformational Societal Change.<a href="#_ftn1">[1]</a></p><p>I recently finished teaching two fall courses: World Sustainability at Ramapo College; and Science, Technology, &amp; Society (STS) at New Jersey Institute of Technology (NJIT). They’re not the same thing, but not too far apart, and recently been somewhat converging. So the majority of what follows applies to both of them, as well as to other sustainability courses, or courses in other fields incorporating sustainability.</p><p>As it’s been almost two years since I’ve written in Medium, I thought I would share a much expanded, revised version of the main points given on the last day of class of each course with a larger audience, both within Education and beyond, as my view of “Education” includes the wider society. They could be useful even outside of pure educational contexts for government, business, non-profits because, as I’ve said elsewhere: “We’re going to have to learn our way to sustainability.” (Or at times, “through climate change.”) And that includes those who’ve thought they were long done with school.</p><p>I don’t believe most of these are that obvious or necessarily covered, or as emphasized, elsewhere.</p><p>I start here with the biggies, and then in two further Parts, offer further “Ideas and Lessons” I hope will helpful for students and educators in higher education, as well as informal educators/perpetual students in any other sector.</p><p>Towards the end of the Series, I offer suggestions for teaching sustainability in college courses, including where current efforts (at least mine) fall short.</p><p>Here are a few to get things started:</p><p>1) We have urgent problems in society, and we’re not close to making sufficient progress in resolving them. Therefore, we need to think differently about them than we’re currently doing. But we can’t just say it; we have to practice it</p><p>2) We don’t always have full answers to urgent problems — even if few are saying this, or it seems people speaking or writing about solutions give that impression. Even textbooks don’t always get it right. (It can be useful, and an important meta-lesson, to actually show this, especially when sustainability-deaf statements are made on Page 1 of a text.) Actually getting to solutions can be murky, with no formulas for finding answers that I’ve ever discovered. Hence why we must think them through</p><p>3) Regarding that “Urgency,” while that shouldn’t always have to be in everyone’s face, as that has its own drawbacks, the baseline of urgency needs to be established. Challenging the perhaps unaware or unquestioned assumption that we have forever to solve our problems makes too much difference, to too many other things</p><p>4) Therefore, for those who want to try, it is important to become better critical thinkers. You won’t often hear that as a typical “Skill for Success.” (Note “Thinking” is not exclusively just cognitive/intellectual. That’s explained in Part 3, Idea 36.)</p><p>5) It may be necessary at times for students to challenge themselves in something they don’t want to do or have private doubts about, such as speaking in class, being able to constructively weigh in during classroom conversations. Even if something they say turns out to be wrong (which rarely happens. Much more often they’re part right), or they don’t say it perfectly, it is still valued, even appreciated, and that most likely they will improve with practice</p><p>6) Or even in their written work, it is not uncommon for students to do much better during the course of a semester once they better understand the expectations. Sometimes it does take the mini-shock of receiving a lower grade than they might have expected, along with coaching-oriented comments, on the first assignment</p><p>7) Sometimes, conventional wisdom and assumptions need to be challenged. (OK. In my world, more than “Sometimes.”) Upon reflection, it/they might hold us back. Examples occur in just about every class. (For example, we re-looked at the potential value of Ignorance, and found a potentially synergistic relationship with further knowledge.)</p><p>8) If faced with deeply unpleasant choices on issues, you don’t have to simply accept them. The way they are framed may be overly limiting. Consider other, perhaps broader ways to describe them. Try to invent one or two new options. Hence the under-emphasized importance of creativity outside of the Arts context; and why “Innovation,” often cited by many fields, cannot be allowed to be superficial. (I’ve said elsewhere: “We need to innovate how we innovate.”) As a tip, try to convert “Either”/”Or’s” into “Both”/”Ands.” That is, challenge apparent binaries, “It has to be This or That’s.” These are common, but might not be real. (For instance, “We can only learn with our heads, hearts, or hands-on.” It has to be one or the other. But why does it have to be that way?) Someone’s proposed ideas may be unrealistic/unreasonable/undoable. So what? Even poor ideas, if put forward in the right environment, can generate good ones.</p><p>Now that I’ve hopefully established that this is not about “Business-as-usual” Sustainability or Education, we pick up on more “Ideas and Lessons” in Part 2.</p><p><a href="#_ftnref1">[1]</a> There’s one more, but it involves role reversal with the author as a PhD student. The PhD is, in part, a pursuit of truth. The technical definition of a PhD as a Doctor of Philosophy takes the latter seriously. It is not just the narrow pursuit of a credential.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c704bf487a9e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>