<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by ICCD Newletter on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by ICCD Newletter on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 18:39:49 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Community Member Spotlight: Vrom]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/community-member-spotlight-vrom-8ba3c66e0d73?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8ba3c66e0d73</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Mar 2023 15:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-21T15:00:00.868Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[Interview by <a href="https://twitter.com/IotaPoet">IotaPoet</a>]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*9sGRnhdqtnPrVnHTqV6YEw.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://twitter.com/Vrom14286662">Vrom</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>IotaPoet</strong>: <strong>So tell us - how did your IOTA journey start?</strong></p><p>Vrom: My journey started in 2017, when a friend explained Bitcoin and Ethereum to me and why we need a global currency that is censorship resistant, programmable and can be sent around the world with almost no costs. After a while, he also mentioned IOTA, so I did my own research and joined the IOTA slack channels. I had never heard about slack, so I was quite impressed by the possibilities to work together worldwide on a 24/7 basis on the same goals. So for me, it felt right, that the IOTA project was managed in that way, and it was also great to be able to directly speak to the founders, who back then had a much more casual conversation style. So, it was always funny and entertaining to hang around in slack and engage with them and the community.</p><p>From an investment point of view, I was especially convinced after I listened to the rooftop interview with Dom Schiener (this can still be found on YouTube), where he explained the shortcomings of the blockchain technology and why IOTA could be a solution. He also had a clear vision for the internet of money, especially for a machine-to-machine economy and IOTA seemed to fit perfectly.</p><p>So, that was the time when I decided to buy my first MIOTAs, but unfortunately, I had to wait almost 5 days for my bank transfer to finally appear on Coinbase. That was the first time I realized how ancient our actual financial system felt. I was especially frustrated because the price of IOTA was constantly rising at that time.</p><p>Later I had to transfer Bitcoin to Bitfinex, so I had to make my first blockchain transaction. It took these BTCs almost half an hour to finally appear on my Bitfinex wallet and during that time I was constantly in panic, because it felt like I might have done something wrong. I was afraid that the funds would be lost forever. This was the time when I realized that waiting 6 blocks to finally see my money on another wallet was not the user experience I was expecting from the “internet of money”. Further, with Bitcoin I would never receive the same amount of money that I sent. It drove me crazy because I was used to normal bank transfers, where it felt like I never lost money while sending money (at least inside the EU and I forgot all the other maintenance costs for a bank account…). Back then the IOTA light wallet was not the best experience, but still I was able to receive my coins in my wallet and I was impressed by the speed of this IOTA transaction. That was the time when my IOTA journey started.</p><p><strong>IP: With nearly 12k organic followers, you are one of the biggest IOTA accounts on Twitter, what motivates you to be so active on there?</strong></p><p>Vrom: I was never really active on Twitter, but when I joined the crypto space it was clear that all the latest information was shared on Twitter. So, I decided to create a special IOTA-related account. At the beginning I was just a lurker in the dark, but as I already had a private crypto-related whatsapp group, where I always shared the latest IOTA news, it was just a small step to also publish this information on Twitter. I thought that this could be my way to help the community to grow, as the founders constantly wrote that everyone could do something to help the community. Back then I was also impressed by Limo’s weekly Sunday Banter, where he explained all the latest IOTA-related news to the German community and I also wanted to help him a bit to find more content.</p><p>With almost no coding background I thought that this was my way to contribute to the community and I got a lot of positive, but sometimes also negative, feedback. Especially for my screenshots from discord and telegram discussions, where I normally just posted the screenshots without any comments. However, some people became angry, normally because of the drama that appeared after certain sentences made by the founders. I had the feeling that everyone should be unbiased and informed about all the important topics that happened around IOTA. I found it unfair that some information was only shared in certain telegram or discord channels, where not everyone had access. So for me, Twitter was always the most accessible way for crypto-related content and I thought it was a good way to inform the community about all things related to IOTA.</p><p>Coming back to your question; on the one hand, Twitter is a great platform to reach other people with similar interests, and on the other hand it is also possible to reach people outside of our bubble. For example, if you tag some famous account and get enough likes, even Elon Musk might be interested in your tweets. That’s why I guess Twitter is the fastest way to spread all kind of news and once IOTA can finally announce Coordicide you can be sure that I still want to be there and spread it with my followers!</p><p><strong>IP: What’s your most liked tweet in relation to IOTA?</strong></p><p>Vrom: At the end of every year I normally make a thread about all of my monthly most-liked tweets, so if you want to find them for 2022 and 2021 you can just use these links:</p><h3>IOTA Vrom.iota 🦋✨️💪➡️🐙☠️🤖🛸 soon on Twitter: &quot;[1/13] Last year I made this annual review of my best Tweets in 2021Today I will do the same for 2022 🧵🔽 https://t.co/34ueURW2cl / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>1/13] Last year I made this annual review of my best Tweets in 2021Today I will do the same for 2022 🧵🔽 https://t.co/34ueURW2cl</p><h3>IOTA Vrom.iota 🦋✨️💪➡️🐙☠️🤖🛸 soon on Twitter: &quot;Here is my anual review for 2021:[1/12] My best tweet in january 2021:https://t.co/dkqInSNYOF / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>Here is my anual review for 2021:[1/12] My best tweet in january 2021:https://t.co/dkqInSNYOF</p><p>For 2020 it is a bit more complicated, because I didn’t order them in one thread. So, you have to enter: “(from:vrom14286662) until:2021–01–01 since:2020–12–31” into the “advanced search” of Twitter.</p><p><strong>IP: Who are your favourite IOTA and other crypto accounts to follow on Twitter?</strong></p><p>Vrom: Right now it is ID.iota (<a href="https://twitter.com/id_iota">@id_iota</a>), who informs us about the latest GitHub activities and the progress of the Coordicide MVP, but I can certainly also recommend following the IOTA Foundation (<a href="https://twitter.com/iota">@iota</a>), Shimmer (<a href="https://twitter.com/shimmernet">@shimmernet</a>), Hans Moog (<a href="https://twitter.com/hus_qy">@hus_qy</a>) and Dom Schiener (<a href="https://twitter.com/DomSchiener">@DomSchiener</a>) to always stay up to date…</p><p>And people should also follow all the content producers like <a href="https://twitter.com/MoonacoPodcast">@MoonacoPodcast</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/IotaPoet">@IotaPoet</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/shortaktien">@shortaktion</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/TangleVerseWeb">@TangleVerseWeb</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/IOTAcontentDAO">@IOTAcontentDAO</a> and I am sure I forgot some.</p><p>In the near future it will be very interesting to follow all the emerging IOTA projects that will start with the ShimmerEVM. So have a look at <a href="https://shimmer.network/ecosystem">https://shimmer.network/ecosystem</a> or <a href="https://tangleverse.io/">https://tangleverse.io/</a> to know what&#39;s coming, and always keep an eye open to the newcomers that might not have not been public yet. In web3 it’s always beneficial to be an early adopter. But no financial advice! 😉</p><p>Right now I would also highlight the accounts of <a href="https://twitter.com/soon_labs">@soon_labs</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/ShimmerSeaDEX">@ShimmerSeaDEX</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/TangleSwapE">@TangleSwapE</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/iotabee">@iotabee</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/DeeprFinance">@DeeprFinance</a>, <a href="https://twitter.com/iotapes">@iotapes</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/LendeXeFinance">@LendeXeFinance</a>. These are some of the outstanding projects that are already public and did an amazing job during the last year.</p><p><strong>IP: You are involved in the IOTA Stammtisch, can you give us a brief overview of this and your role?</strong></p><p>Vrom: I don’t know if you remember, but in 2017 there was a very active community member called Tobias (RonQ) who started the very first IOTA Stammtisch in Munich. It was a quite a regular sit together with some of the IOTA enthusiasts from Munich and even Hans Moog (not at the IF at that time) joined from time to time. But as these meetups had become less often because Tobi was more and more distracted by his studies and the crypto startup he started, it was Albert and me who took over and decided to do the IOTA Stammtisch Munich more regularly.</p><p>Since then it happened once a month, but when Covid-19 hit us, we were not allowed anymore to go to a restaurant for quite some time.</p><p>That’s why I had the idea to do an online regular IOTA Stammtisch where everyone can join, no matter where they live. At that time I was quite an active member in the einfachIOTA team, so it was the easiest way to directly start in their discord and we also wanted to be independent of the IOTA Foundation.</p><p>The IOTA online Stammtisch was started with only around 10 people, but week after week there were more and more people joining our conversations and after a few months we sometimes had more than 400 people in there. After the initial hype, I would say in the last 1.5 years we always have around 150 to 300 people who participate in our regular meetings.</p><p>As the people are most interested in what the MVPs like Hans Moog, Holger Köther, Max Hase (muXxer) or Dom Schiener have to say, we created the golden rule, “Wenn der Kuchen redet, haben die Krümel Pause!”, that you can compare with the sentence “When big daddy talks, kids listen!” But I have to admit that most of the time we don’t really follow these rules, and as we drink alcohol during these meetings the conversations could easily end up in endless discussions about German taxpayers, Tesla advantages/disadvantages or political discussions. Strictly speaking these are not allowed to talk about (one rule is: no religion and no politics!)</p><p>Concerning my role at the IOTA Stammtisch: I had no plan to get a special role in these meetings, but after a while it turned out that we need some kind of moderator who keeps the conversations going if we get stuck at some point or if we stay too long at certain discussions. That’s why I started to create a list of all the important IOTA news that happened during the weeks, so that everyone could easily pick up a new topic to talk about. But it turned out that most of the time it was me who used the list. So, you could call me some kind of “Coordinator of the soon-to-be more decentralized IOTA Stammtisch”. 😉</p><p>By the way: I guess we already had more than 150 of these IOTA Stammtisch sessions and I made more than 100 weekly summaries (a lot of PoW 😉) that you can find in link below:</p><p><a href="https://iota-community.github.io/community-events/stammtisch/2023-03-13/index.html">IOTA Stammtisch Themen</a></p><p><strong>IP: Which Shimmer project are you looking forward to the most once the ShimmerEVM drops?</strong></p><p>Vrom: First of all, I am not only looking forward to the ShimmerEVM, but also to all the innovative features that the ISCP will enable. There is a lot more cool stuff going on than just the ShimmerEVM in terms of smart contracts. This will add value to the already existing Stardust features, and we will be able to run many smart contract chains (not only EVM chains) in parallel and interact frictionlessly through the Tangle.</p><p>From the project point of view, I am very interested in what the ShimmerSea and the team of TangleSwap are going to show us once the beast is released and how the ApeDAO is going to profit from it. I am also curious about all the additional features that we can expect from the Soonaverse once the ShimmerEVM is live and I want to see that the DEX of Iotabee is finally completely decentralized.</p><p>On the gaming side of view, I am looking forward to Iotabots, Darkmythos, IotaHeros and Daobee, and I guess we can expect a lot more games from the Asia community where we have seen a lot of attention lately with the promotion of Shimmer.</p><p><strong>IP: What’s a point you think a lot of people are overlooking in relation to IOTA/Shimmer?</strong></p><p>Vrom: As I already mentioned, one point is the scalability of all the parallel and interoperable smart contract chains, that will be able to directly and bridgelessly communicate through the Tangle. Another point is the native assets and the NFTs that can live on the layer 1 or the layer 2 and can be minted for free by everyone and also transferred for free on the main layer, all with just an initial deposit fee.</p><p>Some more interesting features are the digital identities and the feature that NFTs could hold other NFTs or multiple native assets. I think that it will be an eye-opener for many developers once they realize what IOTA/Shimmer has to offer and people will only understand all of it once they can use these features in their dApps.</p><p>I guess we will see a lot of adaption in the metaverse and in many other web3 environments.</p><p><strong>IP: Which guest would you love to hear on the Moonaco Podcast?</strong></p><p>Vrom: Mat Yager, Hans Moog, Max Hase (muXxer), Jonas Theis or Christoph Strnadl.</p><p><strong>IP: What are your long term aims for your Twitter account?</strong></p><p>Vrom: I’ve<strong> </strong>never thought about that, but my goal should be to never become a played account, like so many others who became famous.</p><p><strong>IP</strong>: <strong>Do you think Shimmer will be a success?</strong></p><p>Vrom: Yes!! Especially because the IOTA Foundation is proceeding very carefully when it comes to updating their IOTA mainnet. That’s why Shimmer will always be many months ahead and as the crypto space has no time to waste, they will most likely always jump on the Shimmer network first. I am not sure if they always want to migrate to IOTA once it is possible. And you should also not forget, that the Coordicide will first appear on Shimmer and the crypto space is irrational and crazy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8ba3c66e0d73" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[AMA with Adam and Austin from IOTA’s business development team]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/ama-with-adam-and-austin-from-iotas-business-development-team-6eb554b785ad?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6eb554b785ad</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Mar 2023 14:59:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-21T14:59:35.599Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[ — by Mart]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/545/1*W260sNFQNxCU58WG5tmkig.jpeg" /><figcaption>Adam Hardaker and Austin Bandalof</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Narrative is extremely important for all crypto projects (along with most things in life). What is IOTA’s unique narrative that will help it stand among giants like Bitcoin and Ethereum’s compelling narratives?</strong></p><p><strong>Austin:</strong> IOTA’s narrative is unique, it’s about creating sound money, a closely linked environment where people can experience DeFi and NFTs. We need to figure out a way to go back to fundamental problems, banking the unbanked, bringing it to third world countries. IOTA can do differently than just focusing on price action and serve people that come to this space to better the world.</p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Crypto’s vision went stagnant for a long time. Bitcoin is an inflation hedge, Ethereum is programmable money for example. IOTA offers a real alternative to this. It’s the only crypto that can offer an alternative vision, not relying on miners or validators, so no gatekeepers. Crypto means no middleman and IOTA does something that comes closer to that vision.</p><p><strong>Austin:</strong> Most projects stay kind of centralized, IOTA though not decentralized yet, wants to get as decentralized as possible and secure for everyone. It’s pretty clear that there’s a centralized entity behind a lot of projects. We want to create an environment for people that’s as decentralized as possible.</p><p><strong>Polygon is praised across the industry for their business development team getting major partnerships with Meta, Reddit, Ticketmaster, etc. for NFT initiatives. Are there any similar plans to work with popular Web2 companies to gain traction for NFTs (or other Web3 capabilities) on IOTA?</strong></p><p><strong>Austin:</strong> We had conversations with larger companies in web2. Polygon has more funding; it’s easier to dish out capital for partnerships. For us, it’s not the largest priority right now, there are different ways to onboard new users. For instance, reaching out to gamify products to onboard web2 users instead of onboarding companies as a whole. NFTs are a way to onboard these more traditional users.</p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Payoffs are not as obvious as one might believe. It depends on how much money you’re willing to pay for such an integration. Starbucks for example, if they had NFTs on your chain, the demand for your chain goes up and at the end of the day you’re essentially selling block space. But block space as a resource isn’t scarce, so people / companies building on these projects doesn’t necessarily drive the price up.</p><p><strong>Austin:</strong> Polygon has different priorities than IOTA. Polygon is focused on getting attention, but the UX (User experience) is not good. It’s not really usable relative to other networks. So, for IOTA, it’s less important to focus on partnerships, but better focus on projects that offer accessibility to new users, learning and a seamless experience. A Starbucks customer isn’t jumping on crypto because Starbucks issued NFTs on Polygon.</p><p><strong>Buddhini question: Which other DLTs do you see as the biggest threat / competitor to IOTA?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Bitcoin, ETH, Cardano and Monero. Competitors might also be other projects in the same market share range. But I like to keep it open and it’s completely situational. It also depends on how we expand our vision. If we look purely at TVL for example, it might be a different competitor to what users see as competitors: Azero, Hedera. IOTA should shoot higher and make up for the shortcomings of ETH and its L2s.</p><p><strong>How is “Developer Experience” factored into IOTA’s growth strategy? What efforts are there to attract more developer talent to the ecosystem outside our bubble?</strong></p><p><strong>Austin:</strong> Many ecosystems don’t have developer support. You can get a grant from Polygon or Aave for example, but beyond that there’s no follow up, no help. IOTAs offers the ability to connect projects, share experiences, tackle roadblocks and help each other out. Ecosystems should be built together. Take Arbitrum as an example: there’s a core group of devs that have a closed circle. Touchpoint should open this up and connect better, giving people the opportunity to see a problem that others have also faced and work together to overcome it. The ability to matchmake is enormously powerful for developers.</p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Something not touched yet is DevX (Developer experience). How good is the wiki and how to deploy a smart contract? We need to challenge ourselves to keep everything up to date, because everything is moving forward. As IOTA 2.0 progresses, the library and tooling gets a lot more attention. The DevX team and dr. electron really focused on that. But we need to wait until the core protocol is more in stone.</p><p><strong>Austin:</strong> Developers build where they see an opportunity, where money is available, where there’s a potential to attract users. IOTA has a massive community, it’s definitely attractive. Many projects are going multichain to attract more users.</p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> And that’s not just theoretical, that’s the feedback from people already in Touchpoint. It helps that many feel like there’s a community, which is not always the case for other chains. It’s overlooked how important that circumstance can be.</p><p><strong>What major markets or geographies do you see as an opportunity for IOTA in the near term? What efforts are being taken to grow our presence in them?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> There are little pockets of communities in Buenos Aires and Taiwan. The challenge is how to access these communities in the best possible way. If IOTA enters these markets, how would it look? Ambassador programs for example? What types of events are going on, how does the IF handle it, how do the people on the ground do it? Hopefully we are getting mini-entities there at some point in the future. Generally, we need to be more present, hold more events, etc., but it needs to be timed once the protocol gets new features to draw the biggest attention. How do we leverage the communities there to help pull new people? I think that spreading the word might be the best way do it.</p><p><strong>Austin:</strong> Conferences are one of the best ways to create new partnerships. Crypto is worldwide but sometimes it’s hard to interact with people. I like to get in front of people and present the ideas. Convincing people to launch on IOTA might be difficult sometimes because there are so many chains. The goal is to be different than some of these other projects. We need to influence people. Less focus on speculation, more focus on adding value. Take the US for example: alot of DeFi activities come from there but you need exchanges for that. So we are trying to create connections to larger onboarding mechanisms, including exchanges. <br>Another example is RobinHood: It’s new to crypto but has an amazing UX. Many meme stock rallies occurred because RobinHood gave people access to easy investing. So, getting on the big exchanges important.</p><p><strong>Adam, you talked about a push into Asian markets back in December and Dom is currently in Dubai. Can you tell us more about your strategy and goals in Asia?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Absolutely, it’s the one place where we have a regional advisor and it’s an important area of interest. There were discussions about which place makes the most sense to be physically and also about any trade-offs there. What is it like to be in Taiwan vs. Singapore vs. Hong Kong vs. Tokyo, these are decisions that haven’t been made yet. Once ShimmerEVM is out, it makes sense to get loud. IOTA’s name goes far in Asia, a non-profit foundation based in Berlin is received well.</p><p><strong>Digital ID has been an area IOTA has promoted as a unique value add of our ecosystem vs others. Is this still the case? If so, what business development initiatives are being worked on particular for DID adoption?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> That’s not directly a business development question. Many projects are racing to have a breakthrough with DID, it’s one of the original use cases of crypto. The short answer is groups like Walt.id are doing that stuff, they’re more or less doing it because they like IOTA.</p><p><strong>What’s the current state with fiat on-ramps? Did the on-chain solution that doesn’t rely on CEXs materialize? What will the fees look like?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Fees depend on what group you go with. Technically an on-ramp already exists with TanglePay, the fees are approximately between 3 and 8% . We (the IF) have a preferred partner we want to work with, but it’s basically held off until ShimmerEVM is there, they need a beta to see what they’re working with. We chose them because Charlie and I wanted the fees to be as low as possible, lower than other alternatives. Integrating is not a problem though, they can integrate in a week or two. So that’s the answer about the short term, I hope to be able to say more in two months or so.</p><p><strong>Austin:</strong> It’s always a battle to find the best on-ramp with the lowest fees. Different CEXs are offering these services, but they want the (EVM) beta to be launched. They need certain milestones to get IOTA on the list. But there are also regulatory issues and many projects on the list to get integrated, so it might take time. But there are options, we searched for years for the right ones to use and things are in the works. Fiat on- and off-ramps are one of the biggest priorities.</p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> One group in Touchpoint is doing their own fiat on-ramp. It’s not announced yet, but one group wants to do their own on-ramp, they’re essentially IOTA fans.</p><p><strong>Without necessarily sharing current progress, how big a role does Business Development play in exchange listings? Are exchange listings a priority for IOTA’s business development efforts, or are there other priorities that you see being more impactful?</strong></p><p><strong>Austin: </strong>Exchange listings are important, but cheap fiat on- and off-ramps are more important. It’s the best to promote DEXs over CEXs, the years have shown that many CEXs are less trustworthy than doing things on chain.</p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Different approach: people should have access to the token and be able to use the ecosystem. To capture the most people, you need on-ramps, exchanges and bridges. <br>Integrating a L1 is more complex than integrating another EVM where you can just add the chain ID and you basically can start trading. The challenge is: many see IOTA / Shimmer as untested because it’s something new. You’re not paying the default price, the prices are $200.000 and upwards. So, paying more money to get on more exchanges is not the solution. But finding the right partners, that not only want to list the token, but are also open to list ecosystem project tokens, is important. Coinbase and Binance are potentially going to wait until Shimmer proves itself, but that’s just my personal take. ShimmerEVM needs to show it has organic projects, not just copy-pasted ones, but I think Shimmer has quite some organic projects. But there’s also an extra layer of complexity: Market makers and exchanges need to work together and not every market maker works with every exchange.</p><p><strong>Do you think Shimmer might be a door opener for some of the exchanges, or is it still tedious and too many bridges were burned in the past?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Sometimes it might be the opposite way, if IOTA is already listed, it might be easier to list Shimmer. But it can definitely be the case if Shimmer goes up, if the narrative gets spun that it’s the place where new things happen and then it could open the door for IOTA. It depends on the exchange, some think that Shimmer seems fresh in a good way, others (in Taiwan for example) want proof, that Shimmer is not just for degen stuff but actually smart-city type stuff, which sounds more like an IOTA thing.</p><p><strong>Often times the devil is in the details on exciting new technology. What seemingly small details about IOTA help the protocol live up to Crypto’s “Decentralization” mission?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam</strong>: The most important one is the builders experience. IOTA is not the first dual-token project, but Mana can also be a thing. Some people might want to hold IOTA just for Mana. We want the Tangle to be a huge trust layer, where many different chains exist and are able to talk to each other seamlessly. EBSI, DeFi, whatever. I am bullish on IOTA because of the ability to seamlessly work and talk together.</p><p><strong>Austin</strong>: We are trying to build a connector between networks. L2s are going multichain, and we have the ability to learn from the past, from the successes and failures of different ecosystems. We can build on what they created, build on the ideas that made them become important players (like Cosmos). Look at it this way: each network is an island and if IOTA can connect all of these islands, it can stand out.</p><p><strong>We’ve seen an unprecedented attack on the industry via bad actors and ill-intended regulators this past year. How is IOTA positioning itself favorably to stand above other L1s in a post-regulation, likely more controlled, world?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam</strong>: There are two ways to go: how close you get to the regulators and how much you make yourself immune to them. The former: We are doing our due diligence, we have internal discussions how to make sure to not get classified as security, how to make Mana not another token, possibly not a taxable event for using mana. But the fear of regulation shouldn’t hinder a project. Connections to German Bundesbank or EBSI type things should count for something as well.</p><p><strong>Austin</strong>: It’s most important to find the fine line and not push too far. Take it slow and steady and adapt to the changing landscape. Many seem to do it for price action, but everyone is affected by the failures. Learning from the mistakes and shortfalls of others can be an opportunity, to continuously learn what works and what doesn’t. Bottom line: slow and steady always wins this race.</p><p><strong>Do you still plan to create an IOTA Ambassador program?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam: </strong>Yes, this is something I’ve been working on with Cory and Antonio and we are talking to our advisors in Asia. How would it work there vs. how would it work globally? It might be that people hold an event on how to deploy Smart Contracts on Shimmer and we reimburse them for the meal cost, that’s like the minimum level. But it could also be that you’re an ambassador and we want you to represent us at events. You talk to potential partners, take them as far as you can and then you redirect them to us. There are different ways that this could work, and they all involve a mix of meetups, hackathons, developer workshops, etc.</p><p><strong>Buddhini question: Are there any plans/discussions about privacy (like stealth addresses, “hidden” txs with zk tech, etc.)?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Not sure if we had any plans about it, but discussions definitely. Most developers are short-term focused, like a research team researching L1 Smart Contracts, or the GoShimmer team for example.</p><p><strong>Austin: </strong>I definitely want to push the IF and our team, it’s important to at least have the option of doing this sort of thing. We talked to some projects that are focused on this, for example Railgun. We have a solid relationship with them and there’s a potential to work together in the future.</p><p><strong>What do you see as the most promising opportunities for IOTA adoption (as it relates to business development) in the Short, Medium, and Long Term?</strong></p><p><strong>Adam:</strong> Touchpoint is going to be the most impactful thing. Once EVM is live, the focus should shift from the IF to different ecosystem projects, and they take the front stage. Reaching adoption is finding the best people and helping to propel them outside of the IOTA ecosystem. Short term, that is the biggest focus. Medium term: IOTA 2.0 and get projects to utilize it, potentially also enterprises.</p><p><strong>Austin:</strong> From my perspective the one thing is focusing on outreach. I think that NFT finance is a huge thing that’s coming up. There are different aspects that work in crypto and we want to create an environment where we kind of support our core projects but also have the ability to onboard what we know has worked in the past. A lot of these teams are going multichain and we want them to share that we have this massive amount of liquidity and a large community that is ready to learn and participate in DeFi. Since I’ve joined Touchpoint, I’ve seen projects building amazing stuff, and the next step would be to bring in projects that are well established on other chains that are looking to find other markets to expand to themselves.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6eb554b785ad" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Token Swaps — DEX vs. CEX]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/token-swaps-dex-vs-cex-e31b0c81a96f?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e31b0c81a96f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Mar 2023 14:58:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-21T14:58:54.038Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Token Swaps — DEX vs. CEX</h3><p>[ — by <a href="https://twitter.com/DigitalSoulx">@DigitalSoulx</a>]</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FzOlgxlAbY40%3Fstart%3D4%26feature%3Doembed%26start%3D4&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DzOlgxlAbY40&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FzOlgxlAbY40%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6adfe404347c293739e5592a073b864a/href">https://medium.com/media/6adfe404347c293739e5592a073b864a/href</a></iframe><h4>Session #2: Token Swaps — DEX vs. CEX</h4><h4>Presented by 0xHunter [15 September 2022]</h4><h4>Summary, organization and additional detail by DigitalSoul.x</h4><p>Welcome to the second Shimmer DeFi Education session of seven. In the first session, we explored the different types of cryptocurrency wallets and how to use them. This session deals with cryptocurrency exchanges: Centralized Exchanges (CEX) and Decentralized Exchanges (DEX). Both of these types of exchanges are online marketplaces for buying and selling cryptocurrencies. However, their modes of operation are very different and this session will consider the pros and cons of each.</p><h4>Centralized Exchanges (CEX)</h4><p>A centralized exchange is run by a corporation: <a href="https://www.coinbase.com/">Coinbase</a> or <a href="https://www.binance.com/en">Binance</a> for example. They generally have features that appeal to new crypto investors such as convenient fiat on-ramps and off-ramps, polished user interfaces, customer service reps, etc. Because they have the backing of corporations, they have the appearance of being trustworthy and it’s true that they must conform to local regulations. But, since they are corporations they must also generate a profit and answer to their shareholders. Additionally, these CEX platforms act as a third party between traders and their coins. Many of them take custody of your coins while you are using the platform, and some of them might not even purchase the coins at all. They might simply generate an in-house ledger entry to account for your purchase without actually buying the coins in the first place.</p><p>For trading, most CEX use the <strong>order book model</strong>. This is just a two-sided ledger of bids and asks (buys and sells). The difference between the bid and ask price is known as the <strong>spread</strong>. Trading on a CEX is generally through one of two methods: <strong>market orders</strong> and <strong>limit orders</strong>. When you place a market order, you are saying that you are willing to transact at whatever price your counterparty asks. If there is low liquidity for a particular coin, you may have to clear several orders to complete your transaction, and this will have an affect on the price. The advantage is that your order is filled immediately. Alternatively, when you place a limit order, you specify the price at which you wish to transact. Your order will remain open until there is a counterparty who agrees to transact at your price and then the trade happens automatically. While this gives you confidence in the price you will pay, there is a chance that it could take a long time for your order to get filled, if at all.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*zdrY0rIsN5Wg789B.png" /></figure><h4>Strengths of CEX</h4><ul><li><strong>Deep Liquidity: </strong>Typically there are plenty of buyers and seller for assets on a CEX, so most orders can be completed quickly.</li><li><strong>Relationships with Established Market Players: </strong>CEXs may run promotions with established market players and in this case they might offer special perks to users.</li><li><strong>Strong Compliance with Local Regulations: </strong>As a corporation, a CEX must comply with local regulations in their area. This may help users to feel safe and comfortable since local regulations change often and can be difficult to keep up with.</li><li><strong>Enables Over-the-Counter Trading: </strong>You can structure deals in a very customized way using a CEX. Using a trusted intermediary offers some advantages when dealing with others or when placing orders for large amounts of cryptocurrency.</li><li><strong>Trading can be High Frequency: </strong>In many CEXs you can connect to APIs. This allows users to transact at a speed that is only limited by network latency, enabling actions that aren’t possible on a decentralized exchange.</li></ul><h4>Weaknesses of CEX</h4><ul><li><strong>Centralized: </strong>When an exchange is centralized, the leadership is generally localized in a certain area as well. They’re not only beholden to the local government, but to the CEO / shareholders of the company. They have an obligation to make a profit, and that profit usually comes from the fees that are passed on to their users. Also, their infrastructure is hosted on web2 platforms which are single points of failure.</li><li><strong>Custodial: </strong>Generally you don’t actually own your crypto assets when you deposit in an exchange. Instead, you own a legal IOU which is supported by the jurisdiction of the exchange. Because of this, you’re missing out on the core value proposition of blockchains: the ability to self-custody your own assets.</li><li><strong>Permissioned: </strong>Although it varies from one jurisdiction to the next, generally you will have to have to KYC to open a CEX account. You’re also at the mercy of their terms of service, and they can revoke your access at any time.</li><li><strong>Opaque Execution: </strong>While<strong> </strong>some exchanges do provide execution data about recent trades, at it’s core it’s still a web2 platform. At the end of the day you’re trusting the data that they host on their servers, and if you want to transact on their platform you must have faith that this information is accurate.</li></ul><h4>Decentralized Exchanges (DEX)</h4><p>A decentralized exchange is also an online marketplace for buying and selling cryptocurrencies, but it is <strong>non-custodial</strong>. This means there is no need for a middleman and instead these peer-to-peer platforms are facilitated via <strong>smart contracts</strong>: code stored on a blockchain that perform certain functions when preset conditions are met. This allows for full transparency when trading.</p><p>Since there is no middleman, there is no entity in a DEX that can match buyers and sellers. This is in stark contrast to the order book model that a CEX uses. Instead, DEXs use a new facilitator called the <strong>liquidity provider</strong>. These participants ensure that there are tokens to be traded at all times by offering the different tokens in each aggregated <strong>liquidity pool</strong>: a group of two (or more) crypto assets managed by a smart contract. The simplest pools have balanced amounts of two different assets. If a liquidity provider wanted to enter a balanced pool of Ethereum and USDC for example, they would need to deposit 1 ETH (currently ~$1600) and 1600 USDC. By offering tokens to this pool, a liquidity provider is signaling that they’re always willing to trade ETH for USDC and vise versa. If the demand for ETH rises more quickly than that of USDC, the liquidity provider would then have less ETH in their position and more USDC. However, the total percentage of the pool represented by the liquidity provider’s position would remain unchanged.<br>In return for offering this service, liquidity providers receive rewards. One of the primary benefits of being a liquidity provider is that they collect a proportional amount of the fees of the trades made in the pool. When a token is first offered on a DEX there is generally a lot of volume. During this time it’s a great opportunity to provide liquidity and capture the fees, especially if relatively little liquidity has already been added to the pool. These fees can be added to your liquidity position, either automatically or manually depending on the protocol, adding to your position like compound interest. The fees may be offered in the form of one of the assets in the pool, or in the form of another token altogether known as a <strong>Liquidity Provider (LP) token</strong>. These LP tokens are platform-specific, but generally composable as well. In some cases you can deposit them with the protocol and receive a yield on them, a practice known as <strong>yield farming</strong>. You may also be able to borrow against them by using them as collateral. Different protocols have devised creative ways of adding value to these LP tokens.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*KUEi7RfPjcp6xwt6.png" /></figure><p>The bottom line is that liquidity providers allow the DEX market to function by offering their tokens to traders. If there are very few liquidity providers, this will have a negative affect on a DEX. In this case, token holders that want to buy or sell won’t be able to without moving the price significantly during the course of the trade. Low liquidity increases volatility and doesn’t allow traders to get the maximum value for their tokens. Even after tokens are available for trading through the liquidity providing mechanism, there must still be a way to determine the price for each asset based on supply and demand. Enter the Automated Market Maker (AMM).</p><h4>Automated Market Maker (AMM)</h4><p>The Automated Market Maker (AMM) is simply a mathematical curve that determines the price of each asset in a pool based on the amount of each token in the pool:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/679/0*QikyUi2AaXx26L4l.jpeg" /></figure><p>Constant Product Automated Market Maker</p><p>The red curve illustrated above illustrates how the price of an asset reacts to changes in the amount of assets in a pool. Specifically, the prices of asset A and asset B are calculated via the formula x*y = k where ‘x’ is the amount of asset ‘A’, ‘y’ is the amount of asset ‘B’ and ‘k’ is a constant. For this reason, this type of AMM is called <strong>constant product</strong>. By way of example, let’s assume that a pool is balanced and the same amount of assets are available on each side. If a trader then comes in and continuously sells the same asset, the price asymptotically approaches zero but it never actually reaches zero. This ensures that there is always a price for each asset in the pool and tokens will be available for trading. Although liquidity is available at all times, it will decrease as the chart moves farther away from zero. Having assets available to trade as well as a price for each asset is extremely important to the operation of a DEX.</p><p>Small orders generally won’t result in a significant change in price if there is sufficient liquidity. However, larger orders can cause a significant change on the red line illustrated above. <strong>Slippage</strong> refers to the amount the price of an asset in a liquidity pool will deviate due to your trade. The higher the liquidity in a given pool, the less the slippage. Similarly, the lower the liquidity, the more the slippage. If you make a large trade, the price actually changes over the course of your trade. While this occurs in CEX order books as well, it’s a defined equation in a DEX. If there is not much liquidity and you wish to purchase a large amount of a given token, the slippage will be high and you will be paying more and more per token as your order gets filled.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*CJAqE9dWr9lfyVmy.png" /></figure><p>To combat the effects of slippage, decentralized exchanges generally allow you to set a parameter called the <strong>slippage tolerance</strong>. This number represents the percentage price movement you’re willing to tolerate to execute the order. If you set the slippage tolerance to 1% for example, your order will only execute if the price moves less than or equal to one percent while executing your order. If your order would cause the price to move more than that, the DEX won’t be able to execute your order. This is important because it’s frequently difficult to know exactly how much the price will change as a result of your order since other traders can submit transactions to the same block. Most DEXs will inform traders of the expected slippage prior to executing an order.</p><h4>Strengths of DEX</h4><ul><li><strong>Trustless: </strong>There’s no counterparty risk as you’re only interacting with smart contracts.</li><li><strong>Transparent: </strong>You can see all of the orders on the blockchain and you can verify the code executing the order if you like. The entire process is verifiable.</li><li><strong>Permissionless: </strong>There are no gatekeepers preventing access, enforcing terms of service or requiring KYC. Anyone in the world can participate.</li><li><strong>Composable: </strong>The DEX framework is modular and allows others to build on top of the foundations that exchanges have developed. In many cases this can even be done without the permission of the exchange. This allows for improved network effects in building different ecosystems.</li></ul><h4>Weaknesses of DEX</h4><ul><li><strong>Exploit Risk: </strong>The smart contract code could have a bug or an exploit leading to loss of funds. To minimize this risk, make sure that the smart contracts have been audited. For even more peace of mind, verify the audit at the website of the auditing company.</li><li><strong>Technical Complexity: </strong>Interacting with DEXs is fundamentally different and more complicated than interacting with CEXs. There is a learning curve involved and without a firm understanding of the basics, it can be easy to lose money. Some of the more subtle, advanced considerations will be explored in the next section.</li></ul><p>Despite the exploit risk noted above, this can be mitigated by the <strong>Lindy Effect</strong>. This describes the belief that the longer a smart contract has been in use without being exploited, the more trustworthy it is. The amount of funds locked in these smart contracts tends to increase over time, making them more and more enticing to hackers. The more time has passed without exploit since the contract was put in use, the less the likelihood an exploit will be found. However, this is no guarantee, just a rule of thumb!</p><h4>Advanced DEX Considerations</h4><h4>Impermanent Loss</h4><p>Impermanent loss describes the opportunity cost of being a liquidity provider compared to simply holding the two initial assets instead. It is a temporary loss of value that occurs as a result of changes in the price of the assets in the pool. Liquidity providers are always selling rising assets and buying falling assets by nature. In this way they are always on the wrong side of the profitable trade, but this doesn’t necessarily mean the trades are bad. There could be situations where an investor always wants their portfolio to be half ETH and half USDC. In that case, providing liquidity is essentially auto-rebalancing their portfolio. However, if their goal is to just make as much money as possible then it might have been more profitable to simply hold the assets without entering the pool.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*VEX3IDbRd8oSsZS2.png" /></figure><p>The easiest way to illustrate impermanent loss is through example. First, assume that a liquidity provider has 1 ETH and 1000 USDT that are deposited into a liquidity pool on a DEX. At the time of the deposit, the price of ETH is $1000 and the price of USDT is $1. This means that the value of the deposit is $2000: $1000 for the ETH and $1000 for the USDT. Let’s also assume that this position represents 10% of the total constant product liquidity pool size. This tells us that the product ‘k’ for this pool is 100,000: 10 ETH * 10000 USDT.</p><p>Now, consider that the price of ETH goes up by a factor of 4 to $4000 while USDT remains the same. In the scenario, traders will use the pool to swap USDT for ETH until the ratio indicates the current price. Since the constant ‘k’ of 100,000 must be maintained in the pool, there would now be 5 ETH and 20000 USDT in the pool.</p><p>The liquidity provider is still entitled to their 10% of the pool. If they withdraw their assets from the pool at this point, they would receive 0.5 ETH and 2000 USDT. While their total value of assets has increased from $2000 to $4000 ($2000 in ETH plus $2000 in USDT), the value of the USDT portion of the deposit has decreased, resulting in an impermanent loss.</p><p>Note that if the liquidity provider had simply held the initial assets, the initial deposit of 1 ETH and 1000 USDT would now be worth $5000: $4000 for the ETH and $1000 for the USDT. The loss is called “impermanent” because it will only occur if the price of the assets in the pool changes while the liquidity provider has funds in the pool. If the prices of the assets return to their original values, or if the liquidity provider withdraws the funds before any significant price changes occur, they won’t experience any impermanent loss. Even so, the effects of impermanent loss can be offset by the trading fees. If there is sufficient volume in a certain price range over a long enough period of time, the fees generated by the protocol that are split among the liquidity providers can be more profitable than simply holding the initial assets.</p><p>It should be clear that providing liquidity is more complicated than most people believe. While there are services that attempt to aggregate and manage liquidity, it helps immensely to develop a strategy first. Providing liquidity should not be done passively unless the prices of the assets in the pool are tightly bound. Instead, liquidity providers should be more active to ensure that the asset prices don’t diverge too much. They should monitor their position to be able to remove liquidity when the assets prices reach the same ration that existed when the liquidity was first provided. Also, in some cases impermanent loss can be offset by yield farming: the practice of providing liquidity in order to earn rewards in the form of additional tokens or fees. Yield farming typically involves staking or locking up assets in a smart contract in exchange for the rewards, but can help to mitigate impermanent loss. However, these LP tokens can be highly volatile, so they are not without inherent risk themselves.</p><h4>Miner Extractable Value (MEV)</h4><p>MEV refers to value that can be extracted by actors based on the way a blockchain orders their transactions. On the Ethereum network, for example, there is an auction to order transactions. There’s even an ‘MEV Searcher’ community that bids to get certain transactions included in each block to extract the value. This is considered a negative example of MEV, since miners can essentially choose the transactions with the highest extractable value to include in a given block. By contrast, the Shimmer network has unordered transactions so some of the MEV opportunities are mitigated.</p><p>Another example of MEV is <strong>arbitrage</strong>:<strong> </strong>buying an underpriced asset from one exchange and selling it for more on another. This is generally considered positive because it equalizes prices across markets. It also limits fragmented liquidity and promotes healthy markets. On the Ethereum network this generally happens in the same block. Even on platforms where the transactions are not orderable, arbitrage still exists. Instead, it’s just in sequential blocks. When transactions can be ordered, traders will want to submit theirs as quickly as possible to front-run other traders. This happens in real-time, leading to virtually zero lag time between price equalization on decentralized exchanges. In this way arbitrage is generally viewed as positive for DeFi.</p><p>The last example of MEV to discuss is related to the slippage tolerance we discussed earlier. If a trader notices there is an order waiting to be filled and that person will tolerate one percent slippage, the trader can go in and buy the asset up to the maximum price that the other will tolerate. Then, immediately after the other person buys it for the one percent higher price that they set, the trader will sell the asset for the profit. This is generally considered predatory and doesn’t add value, but it’s also not profitable to do this to very small trades due to gas fees. It’s also only a problem on Ethereum and other blockchains where you can order transactions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/468/0*kdispiuwZtgQKmGz.png" /></figure><h4>Alternate AMM Models</h4><p>In the example we viewed above, we considered the simple constant product AMM popularized by <a href="https://uniswap.org/">Uniswap</a>. However, instead of using the x*y=k curve, a protocol could implement any curve they want. In fact, many protocols are still experimenting with different curves for different models. Stated otherwise: “The curve <em>is</em> the protocol.”</p><p>Also, we considered pools that were balanced 50%-50% but this can be adjusted as well. Perhaps one pool is 95% ETH and 5% USDC. One of the consequences of changing the weight of the pool is that the liquidity providers are less exposed to impermanent loss. Also, if a token is newly launching but the project doesn’t have matching value in another token to start the pool, they could provide 80% of the position in their token and 20% in a stablecoin, for instance. The trade-off is that there’s more slippage and potentially higher fees for traders due to the imbalanced liquidity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*-0sYwCaBWIsvYHD2.png" /></figure><p>Also in the initial AMM model we discussed, there were only two assets in the pool. Actually there could be many more assets in a given pool. Offering exposure to several different assets can provide interesting opportunities to liquidity providers. <a href="https://curve.fi/">Curve</a> is one protocol that is well-known for multi-asset pools. For instance, there might be a pool that is comprised of three different stablecoins. As a liquidity provider, you’ll get the volume for all three of those stablecoins trading against each other. Also, the prices of each of these coins are more tightly bound together because they’re priced in terms of one another. If there is sufficient liquidity, one of the tokens can always be traded for another. However, if one of the stablecoins is risky compared to the others and that one depegs, then your liquidity position is in jeopardy. In this case, traders will quickly come in to arbitrage and buy the two good stablecoins. In the end, these multi-asset pools expose each asset to the others, making these pools more risky.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*SjynshKBhFxIf2qb.png" /></figure><p>It gets really interesting if you combine several of these factors. For example, maybe there is a weighted, multi-asset pool similar to one offered by <a href="https://balancer.fi/">Balancer</a>. This could be a liquidity position tailored to a specific portfolio. In this case, you can be sure that the asset allocation you desire for the portfolio is maintained while you are collecting the fees generated by trading in the pool.</p><p>In conclusion, while DEXs are much more complicated than CEXs, the benefits far outweigh the drawbacks and allow for privacy and self-custody — key features of cryptocurrencies. At the same time, CEXs do have their place and can provide peace of mind regarding regulations as well as convenient fiat on- and off-ramps.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*NA4Nqp8Zv5iDybw-.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e31b0c81a96f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Tl;dr Moonaco Podcast Episode 61 with EnergieKnip]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/tl-dr-moonaco-podcast-episode-61-with-energieknip-28104d88e073?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/28104d88e073</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Feb 2023 17:07:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-08T17:07:05.783Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[ — by <a href="https://twitter.com/irieness195">Ness</a>]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*83_-NO5X2861H-B9I0OHoA.jpeg" /></figure><p>EnergieKnip has built a local green currency on IOTA to drive energy efficiency in homes. The non-profit organization BlockchainLab Drenthe started with spreading knowledge about blockchains, giving guest lectures at university and building several blockchain applications.</p><p>When the city of Emmen reached out to them to find a solution to grant people subsidies for saving energy, EnergieKnip was born. They designed an app that the city can use to give out the subsidies, and the people can only spend it on energy saving measures. Since crypto is tightly regulated in the Netherlands, they first had to go into talks with the National Bank to ask if they were allowed to launch a local currency in the municipality of Emmen. The National Bank agreed, and EnergieKnip launched their own currency based on IOTA.</p><p>They designed an app with two purposes:</p><p>1. <strong>Collect information</strong> anonymously.</p><p>2. <strong>Reward people</strong> for sharing that information by giving them subsidies they can spend in local hardware stores.</p><p>To comply with the GDPR rules, EnergieKnip did a physical air drop. They gave a letter with a QR code to 50,000 households, that they randomly distributed. By doing this, no one knows which QR code belongs to which household. On January 11th, 2022, the first letters with a QR code were distributed.</p><p>By scanning the QR code, people can download the app and install the wallet on their phone. After that, they are asked to answer 27 questions about their behavior, their house and their energy saving measures. The answers are then sent to the municipality of Emmen through the IOTA tangle. As a reward for answering the questions, the people receive an equivalent of 50 euros on their wallet in the local cryptocurrency. They can use this subsidy to buy energy saving measures in ten different hardware stores in Emmen.</p><p>The shop owner of the participating stores also received a QR code and a wallet. When somebody paid with the local currency, they send the coins back to the municipality and receive the euros directly to their bank account.</p><p><strong>But why did they choose IOTA to build EnergieKnip?</strong> Basically, there are four reasons for that:</p><p>1. Feeless</p><p>2. Enough capacity</p><p>3. Fast enough</p><p>4. And most importantly: it uses very little energy!</p><p>After introducing EnergieKnip the participation went crazy. Prior to this, when the city of Emmen gave out paper vouchers as subsidy, only 16% were claimed. With EnergieKnip 100% of the money was claimed within 13 days. So, the city decided to double the money, and again it took only 11 days until all the subsidies were claimed. A huge success and a win-win-win-win situation for the municipality of Emmen, the people living in Emmen, the retailers and the environment.</p><p>EnergieKnip in Emmen was such a big success, that two other cities in the Netherlands contacted them and the first two spin-offs were created. The first spin-off, VitalityKnip, rewards 1,000 employees by giving them 50 euros per quarter in a stable coin. The second spin-off in the city of Heerlen uses the system to distribute money to people who can’t pay their energy bills. The city gave the purpose-bound money to 20,000 families who were in financial trouble. In total, they gave out five million euros.</p><p><strong>What’s next to come?</strong></p><p>There are already three successful projects in the Netherlands, but this is just the beginning. Adri sees a lot of potential in their system and presents some other areas where it could be used.</p><p>- <strong>Tourism:</strong> Giving tourists the opportunity to answer questions regarding their stay by providing QR codes in hotels. They are then rewarded with coins they can spend at local stores or museums.</p><p>- <strong>Battle heat stress in city centers:</strong> People who are living in the city center could receive a QR code and a subsidy. They could use this money to buy plants for their garden that offer shadow.</p><p>- <strong>Promote health</strong> and enable people to visit a fitness center.</p><p>- <strong>Weapons buyback program in the US: </strong>The police buys back guns at market price, but instead of USD people would receive a local crypto currency that they can then use in local retail.</p><p>- <strong>Opportunities for children:</strong> Especially children of poor families don’t always have the opportunity to participate in a local sports team. Municipalities as well as organizations could use the system to offer subsidies to low-income families.</p><p>- <strong>Arts and culture:</strong> In Germany teenagers who turn 18 receive 200 euros to spend on local arts and culture. This could also be done via a crypto wallet with a purpose-bound coin.</p><p>Those are only a few ideas of what is possible with the EnergieKnip system, and in the future they also want to work with projects outside the Netherlands. Even the German Bundesbank already contacted them to talk about regional currencies.</p><p>As a next step, BlockchainLab Denthre is working on a MultiKnip where people can have several coins for several purposes.</p><p><strong>And to give you some hopium:</strong> “IOTA is one of the best projects at the moment.” But Adri gives one advice for other projects: Just start building instead of waiting for what’s coming next. IOTA is developing so fast that there will always be something better to come, but you can’t wait forever to finally start putting your idea to action.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=28104d88e073" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Community Member Spotlight: ID.iota (@id_iota)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/community-member-spotlight-id-iota-id-iota-175122827a27?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/175122827a27</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Feb 2023 17:06:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-08T17:06:40.528Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[Interview by <a href="https://twitter.com/IotaPoet">IotaPoet</a>]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/400/1*YWw6kKTz7pgMqOQwS3YHmA.jpeg" /><figcaption>ID.iota</figcaption></figure><p><strong>IotaPoet: Which coin do you think will be worth more on 21 August 2024- IOTA or Shimmer?</strong></p><p>ID.iota: Great Question! I really love how those discussions come up and how everyone got surprised with the Shimmer Marketcap suddenly being at above 200 Million USD. We are still above 100 Million USD at the time of writing (2nd February), which puts us at 15% of IOTAs Marketcap. To compare the numbers, Kusama, the staging network of Polkadot, is at 5% of Polkadots Marketcap.</p><p>So basically, the market saw more in Shimmer than just a staging network and as we can see even the IOTA Foundation is pivoting. Shimmer isn’t any longer just the “little crazy Cousin” from Iota. Shimmer is advertised as “feeless, parallelized DAG ledger to secure and create fully customizable smart contract chains”. And if you listen to what the IF is communicating in Discord lately you see that they are eager to bring things to success with Shimmer.</p><p>So that’s how the IF and the market understands Shimmer, but we also see quite different tokenomics for Shimmer and IOTA till today. We have token locks through the storage deposit, and we will see $SMR as the token necessary to pay fees whenever using ShimmerEVM.</p><p>I think at the end it depends, if the market thinks that strong Shimmer leads to strong IOTA, or if the market doesn’t see any price adaption from Shimmer to IOTA. My guess is 21st of August 2024 is too early in either case. If Shimmer becomes the go-to place for Web3 and IOTA becomes the go-to place in real world adoption, then we will see a Shimmer close to IOTA in 2025 and IOTA above Shimmer in 2029.</p><p><strong>IP: So tell us- how did your IOTA journey start?</strong></p><p>II: It all started sometime in 2017. I earned my first money and was smart enough to invest in ETFs and laughed about Bitcoin pumping. The time people at my workplace started talking about the Bitcoin I knew this bubble is going to burst. Then, a little later my brother called me, and we talked about IOTA. I researched, got hooked and invested my first money into it. I think we paid 2 US-Dollar per MIOTA at that time.</p><p>It took till the next bull market until I really became part of the ecosystem and inhaled everything about IOTA. So, if you are annoyed about my threads, blame it on my brother!</p><p><strong>IP: What’s an aspect of IOTA/ Shimmer technology you are most interested in?</strong></p><p>II: I think people underestimate the brilliance of the Iota Smart Contracts design. It really is an evolution to what we got in crypto up to now, and might be the foundation on which IOTA can build for years from now. It is super flexible and will support Solidity and WASM for DApps. Developers will be able to build whatever they want wherever they want on IOTA. With the integration of Move in the L1, we will even see L1 smart contracts. I think people haven’t really grasped, that with this ISC framework ShimmerEVM is just the beginning.</p><p>The IOTA 2.0 technology might be a game changer, but we don’t know the details yet. ISC is here and it&#39;s great!</p><p><strong>IP: What’s a point you think a lot of people are overlooking in relation to IOTA/Shimmer?</strong></p><p>II: During the last bull run we got the impression that several protocols solved the trilemma. Avalanche, Solana and BNB all claim, that they are decentralized, secure and scalable. However, they really just increased the necessary efforts to run a chain validator, to a level that no one was able to participate in the validation anymore. Thus, no decentralization.</p><p>Even Protocols like Aleph_Zero are currently running on 14 validators, 10 of those 14 validators are currently run by the Aleph_Zero foundation themselves. All those protocols are great. None of them has solved real decentralization.</p><p>But hasn’t the space agreed that decentralization isn’t that important anymore? Well, we develop in another direction now. Scalability is achievable through rollups. This is however only useful if the Layer 1 you anchor in is super secure and really decentralized.</p><p>The whole development of IOTA 2.0 has decentralization at its core. If the IF is able to deliver on its vision and we are able to reach 3, 4 or even 5 figure throughput and the L1 DAG, with medium and low requirements on the nodes, this protocol is able to change everything we have ever seen in this space before.</p><p><strong>IP: What motivates you to post such detailed threads about IOTA/Shimmer even during the bear market?</strong></p><p>II: To be honest, I don’t care too much about the market. I am happy if we are pumping. I am sad if we are down. I lost significant amounts of money in IOTA but I believe in my investment. I think IOTA could really change things in the crypto space.</p><p>I wrote my first thread after the Twitter Space from @CryptoMiners_Co with Jonas Theis (one of the research developers of IOTA 2.0). The interview was pretty bad. Jonas was there to talk about IOTA 2.0 but was only asked about JLR, Project Alvarium, Trademark Africa and some other things he basically knew nothing about, because they just aren’t part of his work.</p><p>So afterwards I thought, we really need to put everything Jonas said into easy words, so everyone can understand the depth of the whole IOTA 2.0 design. Therefore, I wrote first my thread. It got incredible attention and here I am.</p><p>I keep going, because I really think IOTA is a gem, but no one wants to explain its tech in simple words. We need easy to understand explanations that aren’t expecting a lot of background knowledge. I feel like, that might become my part in the ecosystem.</p><p><strong>IP: Which Shimmer project are you looking forward to the most once the ShimmerEVM drops?</strong></p><p>II: Oh, they are all great! I am super happy about our DEX-Landscape, with TangleSwap having more of an Asian Community, TangleSea with more of a European community and Iotabee with their Soonaverse partnership.</p><p>I can’t wait for what Nakama is building with Deepr and Accumulator and obviously the whole Soonaverse Ecosystem…</p><p>But most excited I am about TangleHub and IotaOrigin. I don’t fully grasp yet what they are doing and can’t wait to see how they will build their vision on ShimmerEVM.</p><p><strong>IP: Which guest would you love to hear on the Moonaco Podcast?</strong></p><p>II: Wen ID_IOTA on Moonaco Podcast?</p><p>The EnergieKnip episode was so great! Adri is such a rolemodel for a real builder. I also really liked the episode with Kutkraft. It was so nice to hear those fine man have a talk about their life and IOTA.</p><p>I think Thomas should have a talk with the people behind iotaheroes. They are really building stuff and do use the capabilities the IOTA technology provides them. I am really interested in their ShimmerEVM release.</p><p>Furthermore, trading card games like SpeakNFT or Dark Mythos are looking really promising and haven’t been part of the podcast as well. Would really love to hear from them!</p><p><strong>IP: Are you following any other projects/protocols?</strong></p><p>II: I do follow a little bit of the tech development of DAGs in our space. Especially Aleph ZERO and Constellation. Furthermore I am trying to read a lot about zero knowledge proofs and how this tech can change the crypto space. I will try to invest more time in the future though.</p><p><strong>IP: Do you think IOTA can compete with more established DeFi protocols such as Ethereum?</strong></p><p>II: This is dependent on IOTA 2.0 and if the Iota Foundation will deliver. If we see the minimum viable product (MVP) of IOTA 2.0 until June this year, I think we absolutely could become a top 20 coin again (next to Cosmos, Avalanche, Fantom and Aptos).</p><p>Up until that time I think there is a reasonable argument that IOTA is still centralized and shouldn’t be valued as more decentralized protocols like Cosmos or Ethereum.</p><p>However, everyone in the IOTA community should know that DeFi Protocols are often valued by their TVL (Total Value Locked). So, it&#39;s everyone’s duty to bring Shimmer to success by using the DAPPs that come with it. It is a joint effort from community and builders.</p><p><strong>IP: What do you have planned for your Twitter account going forward?</strong></p><p>II: I would really love to get consistent with my output. A weekly thread, that explains one part of the tech. One weekly look into the ecosystem and maybe a weekly update on what’s happening on GitHub. That would be where I imagine my content in the future.</p><p>Now I really need to finish things in my private life. My master thesis needs to be written until March and afterwards I must move for a new job… So let’s hope for bigger things in the second half 2023, hopefully just in time with a working IOTA 2.0 MVP and ShimmerEVM Release.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=175122827a27" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Battle of the Layer1s: The Zero-Sum Struggle]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/battle-of-the-layer1s-the-zero-sum-struggle-e19ffdce089b?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e19ffdce089b</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Feb 2023 17:06:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-08T17:06:15.723Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[ — by MolochNess]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mb3d6qJKNLQEyNZgEHuP5Q.png" /></figure><p>Welcome back, time to delve into the finer details of these ecosystems:</p><h3><strong>User/Developer experience</strong></h3><p>Despite periodic surges in adoption, crypto still has a long way to come with regards to user and developer experience.</p><p>One of the largest points of friction for normal users: L1s and L2s force user to pay fees in a ‘core token’: $ETH, $ADA, $MATIC, etc. A handful of dapps also require users to use special tokens: Brave, Chainlink, Arweave, The Graph. Even if most of those are business-facing, how many B2B companies charge their clients in speculative and volatile assets? Web3 games use special currencies, ($MANA, $SAND, etc), but at least gamers are accustomed to that.</p><p>The status quo works well-enough when most users are crypto die-hards and speculators who would use/hold $ETH regardless. However, average people are unlikely to learn about $ETH and keep re-purchasing it forever simply to pay fees. Users routinely get ‘stuck’ with a wallet full of USDC/NFTs/etc, but not enough $ETH to cover the cost of a transfer or swap, forcing them to embark on a grueling trip to and from Binance. The only way to avoid this is to buy core tokens in excess of what they really need, but that exposes users to volatilty, and most people just don’t want to.</p><p>For global adoption to occur, L1s and L2s must enable fees in more mainstream assets (eg: USD stablecoins), or wallets will have to abstract the complexity away from users, swapping assets their users have for the respective core token.<br> <br>There are various other points of friction, eg: wallet security, or having to sign numerous transactions to accomplish simple tasks, but these are less platform-specific.</p><h4><strong>Ethereum</strong></h4><p>The Ethereum user experience varies a lot depending on the layer you interact with.</p><p>For Ethereum L1 and EVM L2s/Sidechains, users must hold ETH or MATIC to pay for gas fees. Transaction cost /speed is determined by real-time network demand: popular NFT mints can drive up fees significantly and cause a backlog. App-specific L2s like ImmutableX and dYdX offer fast and gasless transactions, instead charging a % fee on user trades.</p><p>As for developers, Solidity and the EVM make it simple for to launch tokens, NFTs, and get into smart contract development. However, despite having a low barrier to entry, it is notoriously difficult to create bulletproof Ethereum contracts. Many $billions have been lost so far to DeFi, NFT, and bridge hacks (1), although not all of that can be attributed to the smart contract model.<br> Notable EVM contract hacks include:</p><ul><li>October 2021, Cream Finance lost over $130 million, its third hack to date (2).</li><li>April 2022, Beanstalk Finance was hacked for $182 million via a DeFi exploit, when a hacker used a ‘flash loan’ to give themselves majority control over the procotol, and vote to transfer themselves the assets (3).</li><li>April 2022, Aku Dreams NFT project ‘Akutars’ accidentally locked $34 million in their minting contract, rendering it permanently inaccessible (4).</li><li>April 2022, Fei Protocol lost $80 million due to a liquidity pool exploit</li><li>October 2022, Team Finance lost $12 million to an exploit.</li><li>December 2022, the Raydium DEX lost $2 million due to a liquidity pool exploit.</li><li>February 2023, Orion Protocol lost $3 million due to a re-entrancy bug.</li><li>February 2023, BonqDAO and AllianceBlock lost $110 million when a hacker exploited an oracle price feed, minting BEUR to sell on Uniswap (5).</li></ul><h4><strong>Cardano</strong></h4><p>The user experience depends mostly on your priorities. Unlike Ethereum, and most EVM chains, Cardano lacks a dynamic fee market that responds to network utilization. This results in lower fees for users, at the cost of not knowing how long transaction confirmation will take. This is better for relaxed payments and trading, but problematic for time-sensitive NFT mints or certain DeFi apps, which might require users to quickly deposit extra collateral to avoid liquidation. There are plans to implement a tiered fee market, where some users pay a ‘base’ fee, while others can pay priority fees to guarantee faster transaction inclusion (6).</p><p>One huge upside of the EUTXO model, is deterministic pricing. Users and wallets know the exact cost prior to submitting, which also means transactions can’t randomly fail due to requiring more gas than expected (7).</p><p>Babel Fees is a proposed upgrade to Cardano, which would allow users to pay for transaction fees in other assets besides $ADA (8). Essentially, Stake Pools opt-into accepting non-$ADA assets for fees, and cover the protocol-level cost (denominated in $ADA) on behalf of users. This would be a massive UX improvement, people could start to use crypto without even realizing it, using familiar currencies (USD, EUR, INR, BRL, etc) to send payments, use DeFi, buy NFTs, and more.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/893/1*Qd5Jy-HdQqmJJPl5kosXFQ.png" /><figcaption>Credit: IOHK</figcaption></figure><p>For developers: while it’s easy to create simple tokens and NFTs on Cardano, developing full (L1) dapps remains difficult for average developers, due to the choice of language and ledger model: Plutus (based on Haskell) and the EUTXO model. For some, this is strictly a positive thing: if Solidity/EVM development weren’t so deceptively easy, perhaps $billions in hacks could have been prevented. Beyond Plutus, Marlowe is a domain-specific language (DSL) for financial smart contracts, designed for non-functional developers, or even people with little-to-no coding experience. However, given the relative immaturity of Cardano’s DeFi ecosystem, it remains to be seen how effective Plutus/Marlowe/EUTXO are in preventing smart contract hacks over the long term.</p><p>There has also been recent progress in expanding language support on Cardano L1 (9):</p><ul><li>Eopsin, based on Python</li><li>Aiken, based on Rust</li><li>HeliosLang, based on Javascript</li><li>Plu-TS, based on Typescript</li><li>Scalus, based on Scala</li></ul><p>Each language compiles down to PlutusCore, the low-level code executed on Cardano L1.</p><p>Sidechains and L2s will allow the use of other execution environments (such as EVM, WASM, SVM), allowing developers to pick from a number of options while staying inside the Cardano economy.</p><h4><strong>IOTA</strong></h4><p>Like Cardano, IOTA L1 uses the UTXO ledger model. Unlike most blockchains however, there are no elected ‘leaders’ to demand transaction fees from users (‘leaderless consensus’). Instead, access is regulated by ‘Mana’, a resource generated by staking $MIOTA and participating in consensus. Throughput remains scarce though, so many users won’t have enough Mana to cover their needs, so must buy access from 3rd parties or use services that cover the cost for them.</p><p>Given the trajectory of Mana research over recent months, it seems like time to put the “feeless” narrative to bed. Earlier Mana designs would allow users to submit transactions at <strong>zero</strong> cost until a certain threshold of congestion was reached, but this design would leave the network vulnerable to whales, spamming free transactions to create congestion, artificially increasing demand for $MIOTA/Mana. Recent designs allocate a fixed amount of bandwidth, or have a baseline Mana ‘cost’ per transaction. Still, Mana is strictly an upgrade over (superset of) the normal fee model, allowing holders to seamlessly ‘attach’ transactions to the network, while still letting users to buy access from 3rd parties if they don’t wish to hold much $MIOTA. To some this may seem questionable: how is Mana better than staking ETH/ADA and spending rewards on transaction fees, or including your own transactions for free when you get elected to produce a block? Two reasons:</p><p>1. In traditional blockchains, unless you rank among the top 100 stakers, you have a miniscule chance of being elected to publish a block at the same time you need to send transactions.<br>2. Even for users who opt to pay fees, they will get more competitive prices on average, because there isn’t a singular ‘leader’ with a monopoly over transaction inclusion, but tens or hundreds of Mana providers willing to sell access, driving costs down.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-Xa-es1cBr_7aKctyLuiuA.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Notable Adoption, PoCs and Deployments</strong></h3><h4><strong>Ethereum</strong></h4><p>The largest dapp and developer ecosystem in crypto, even if you exclude L2s/Sidechains.</p><ul><li>USDT and USDC, each with ~60k daily active users/addresses</li><li>OpenSea: the largest NFT marketplace, with ~80k daily active users/addresses</li><li>Uniswap — the largest decentralized exchange (DEX), with ~50k daily active users/addresses</li><li>Visa has been actively exploring blockchain-based payments on StarkNet, utilizing Account Abstraction to facilitate recurring payments (10).</li><li>Reddit launched ‘Digital Collectibles’ NFTs on Polygon in July 2022, having amassed a userbase of over 6.4 million wallets holding 9.3 million avatars. (11)</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SSRVBrImvVdAr6UedTS9_w.jpeg" /></figure><ul><li>Starbucks has launched ‘Starbucks Odyssey’, an extension to their popular loyalty program, rewarding users with NFTs. At time of writing, there has been $72k of secondary trading volume. (12)</li><li>Meta: Facebook and Instagram have integrated NFTs, via Ethereum, Polygon, Flow, and Solana (13).</li><li>Ernst &amp; Young (EY) have partnered with Polygon to deploy ‘Polygon Nightfall’, an ‘Optimistic-ZK Rollup’ which facilitates private transactions and business logic.</li><li>Nike acquired RTFKT, a crypto-native brand with one of the largest NFT communities. They are also developing a Polygon-based NFT marketplace.</li></ul><p>Many projects are in the experimentation phase, awaiting future scalability upgrades to support user traffic of a full roll-out.</p><h4><strong>Cardano</strong></h4><p>The 4th largest NFT ecosystem by daily volume, an up-and-coming DeFi ecosystem, with a strong focus on ‘boots-on-the-ground’ adoption.</p><ul><li>The Ethiopian Ministry of Education and IOG are collaborating to deploy the self-sovereign identity (SSI) service ‘ATALA Prism’ to over 5 million students, 750k teachers, and 3.5k schools in Ethiopia. As of December 2022, development of the project is complete, and onboarding of students and teachers has commenced. (14)</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ghZh8onk_hF21Z2IVNp2Dw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credit: Twitter/Cardanians_io</figcaption></figure><ul><li>World Mobile, a mesh ISP operating in Tanzania with 20k daily active users. Now that the free trials are ending, customers are beginning to pay for their World Mobile connections, at half the cost of legacy ISPs. (15)</li><li>Empowa is a ‘RealFi’ project, financing affordable housing. After financing the homes of 30 families, Empowa signed an agreement with the Municipality of Beira, Mozambique to finance an additional 25,000 climate-smart homes. (16)</li><li>JpgStore: the largest NFT marketplace on Cardano, with ~15k daily active users/addresses and a total of 437 million ADA in trading volume (17).</li><li>Minswap: the largest DEX on Cardano, with ~6k daily active users/addresses, and a total of 48 billion ADA in trading volume (18).</li></ul><p><strong>IOTA</strong> <br> <br>One of the largest and oldest L1 communities in crypto, with a focus on infrastructural and governmental programs.</p><ul><li>European Blockchain Services Infrastructure (EBSI) — The IOTA Foundation has been working with EBSI since 2021, originally one of 7 accepted applicants in the first phase. At time of writing EBSI has narrowed it down to just IOTA and 2 other applicants (19).</li><li>Project Alvarium — a collaboration between the Linux Foundation, Intel, Dell, and the IOTA Foundation to create a ‘Data Confidence Fabric’ for use in IoT. Recently, Project Alvarium announced its intention to work with Hedera Hashgraph, another L1 platform.<br> While IOTA and Hedera serve different markets: the former decentralized and permissionless, the latter centralized and permissioned, it may indicate that Alvarium is looking for more agile partners.</li><li>Zebra: a multi-national supply chain hardware and services company, incorporating IOTA into supply chain provenance (20).</li><li>EnergieKnip: an app that incentivizes consumers to share data about their energy usage. With 30,000 active wallets, it is the largest government blockchain project in the Netherlands.</li><li>Trademark East Africa: an initiative to streamline international trade, automating processes and cutting down on paperwork. Testing is live in Kenya, with plans to roll-out in neighbouring countries (21).</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/952/1*ktXjGSGLJhx7tL97wf_VBQ.png" /><figcaption>Credit: IOTA Foundation</figcaption></figure><ul><li>KupKrush: a project that aims to align incentives along the recycling supply chain, specifically for used coffee cups.</li><li>Soonaverse: an NFT-focused sidechain, with plans to eventually settle onto IOTA L1</li></ul><p>Many of these projects are awaiting Coordicide and L1/L2 smart contract functionality, so they can finally deploy on a scalable, decentralized, and functional platform.</p><h3><strong>Obstacles, Risks to be Aware of, and Road to Mass Adoption</strong></h3><h4><strong>Ethereum</strong></h4><p>The Merge has greatly de-risked Ethereum, but much of their roadmap remains unfinished.</p><ul><li>Staked-ETH withdrawals are set to activate in March, in the ‘Shanghai’ hardfork.</li><li>EIP-4844, aka ‘Proto-Danksharding’ is an upgrade to Ethereum’s ‘Data Availability’ (storage) that L2s utilize to securely settle on Ethereum L1. This is expected to arrive by Q3/Q4 of 2023.</li><li>Stake centralization and censorship: Six centralized staking providers control 11/16 million (68%) of staked ETH: Lido, Coinbase, Kraken, Binance, Stakefish, Figment, and Bitcoin Suisse, with the first 4 controlling 55% of stake (22). Not only does this threaten Ethereum’s credible neutrality, it puts the platform at risk of regulatory crackdown, given all the regulated companies running the network. 65% of Ethereum blocks over the last 30 days complied with the OFAC sanctioned addresses list, enforcing passive censorship(23).</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/701/1*8vGQj_SAnC2YHdef-TlG0g.png" /><figcaption>Credit: nansen</figcaption></figure><ul><li>Inclusion Lists (or CRLists) are a proposed way to enforce censorship-resistance on Ethereum, by tracking the mempool and forcing ‘block builders’ to include transactions within a certain period. However, this still relies on an honest majority of ‘block proposers’, so it’s unclear how this will work if ETH stake centralization continues.</li><li>DankSharding is a longer-term scalability upgrade that will build on the scaffolding of EIP-4844. Most likely to arrive in 2–3 years, given the complexity.</li></ul><p>Long-term, the largest risk I see for Ethereum is an exodus of the biggest L2s onto their own settlement layers, secured by their respective tokens. User activity is likely to concentrate in a handful of L2s (eg: Polygon, Starkware, zkSync)</p><p>Many Ethereans would argue that L1 Data Sharding + L2s solve the Trilemma. I believe this is incorrect. While L2s <strong>do</strong> support more users, inheriting L1’s security and decentralization, if L2s are a platform’s only means to scale (as is true on Ethereum’s current roadmap), that leaves L1 vulnerable to long term economic atrophy. As L2s capture the vast majority of users, transaction activity, fee revenue, TVL, and only pay a tiny fraction to L1, Ethereum’s economic security will likely dwindle.</p><p>Sure, in a few years Ethereum could try to force L2s to pay higher settlement fees, but with what leverage? When L2 tokens capture &gt;10x more value than $ETH, they can launch their own L1s with superior settlement guarantees, and discard Ethereum.</p><p>Of course this is highly speculative, and could turn out very differently, but in my eyes the economic incentives seem to align against Ethereum.</p><h4><strong>Cardano</strong></h4><p>With Proof of Stake (Shelley), and Smart Contracts (Goguen) live, the two pieces left for Cardano to deliver are Scalability (Basho) and Governance (Voltaire). Both of these ‘eras’ are underway, being developed in parallel, but scalability — arguably the most important — is an elusive one.<br> <br>Hydra, Pipelining, Input Endorsers, Sidechains, Rollups, and L1 optimizations are Cardano’s main pathways to scalability.</p><p>A conservative version of Pipelining was delivered in the Vasil upgrade, with headroom to increase network capacity further.</p><ul><li>Hydra ‘heads’ (L2) are live, but other subprotocols (‘inter-head’ and ‘head-to-tail’) are necessary to support more complex use-cases (24). Development is ongoing.</li><li>Rollups are still a while away from being viable on Cardano, primarily because it lacks sufficient Data Availability to support them.</li><li>Input Endorsers promise to deliver on the long-awaited parallelization benefits of the (E)UTXO model, but require a significant re-design of Cardano L1. Design and specification seems likely to take another 1–2 years at the current pace.</li><li>Cardano’s low fee revenue — a consequence of static fees and low demand — puts it in a precarious position. Ethereum L1 proves there thousands of people willing to pay higher fees for maximally-secure settlement, which flows into ETH’s economic security. Cardano must scale and fill that capacity with a large quantity of transactions to pay for long-term security.</li></ul><h4><strong>IOTA</strong></h4><p>Stardust: an upgrade to tokenization, already launched on Shimmer, IOTA’s staging network (25)</p><p>This acts as the precursor to full L1 smart contract functionality.</p><ul><li>IOTA 2.0/Coordicide: the longest-awaited upgrade to decentralize the IOTA platform. Despite delays and setbacks, visible progress is being made. Optimistically, we might see IOTA 2.0 on Shimmer by the end of this year, with full Coordicide launching on IOTA by Q1/Q2 2024.</li><li>Sidechain and L2 smart contracts are much lower-risk, there is extensive precedent to draw from in other ecosystems, it’s a matter of engineering it to fit nicely on IOTA L1.</li><li>L1 smart contracts are more tricky, there are limited examples of UTXO-based smart contracts, and none that use leaderless consensus as IOTA does. Prototype development has begun, with an unclear timeline of delivery (26).</li><li>The largest risk IOTA currently faces is the dwindling funds of the IOTA Foundation, who have projected 18–24 months of runway left (27). Additional funding must be found, either through investors, token price appreciation, or a second round of community donations.</li></ul><p>Without its community and ecosystem of (prospective) builders, these factors would surely spell death for IOTA, but when there’s a will there’s a way. The Ethereum Foundation was nearly-bankrupt in 2016 (28), but through sheer force of will made it through to the finish line, and now sits on a balance sheet of multiple $billions.</p><p>In conclusion, Ethereum remains in the lead, but the same design choices that allowed it to surge ahead now hold it back from secure and scalable adoption. Cardano, IOTA, and several other platforms intend to claim the throne, each with a unique set of tradeoffs to consider.<br>Only time will reveal the winners of this war.</p><p><strong>Sources:</strong><br> (1) <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2021/11/19/over-10-billion-lost-to-defi-scams-and-thefts-in-2021.html">https://www.cnbc.com/2021/11/19/over-10-billion-lost-to-defi-scams-and-thefts-in-2021.html</a><br> (2) <a href="https://decrypt.co/84590/cream-finance-suffers-third-hack-losing-over-130-million">https://decrypt.co/84590/cream-finance-suffers-third-hack-losing-over-130-million</a><br> (3) <a href="https://www.theverge.com/2022/4/18/23030754/beanstalk-cryptocurrency-hack-182-million-dao-voting">https://www.theverge.com/2022/4/18/23030754/beanstalk-cryptocurrency-hack-182-million-dao-voting</a><br> (4) <a href="https://decrypt.co/98530/aku-ethereum-nft-launch-ends-with-34m-locked-in-flawed-smart-contract">https://decrypt.co/98530/aku-ethereum-nft-launch-ends-with-34m-locked-in-flawed-smart-contract</a></p><p>(5) <a href="https://cointelegraph.com/news/bonqdao-protocol-suffers-120m-loss-after-oracle-hack">https://cointelegraph.com/news/bonqdao-protocol-suffers-120m-loss-after-oracle-hack</a><br> (6) <a href="https://forum.cardano.org/t/further-improvement-on-tiered-fees/106232">https://forum.cardano.org/t/further-improvement-on-tiered-fees/106232</a><br> (7) <a href="https://docs.cardano.org/learn/eutxo-explainer">https://docs.cardano.org/learn/eutxo-explainer</a><br> (8) <a href="https://iohk.io/en/blog/posts/2021/02/25/babel-fees/">https://iohk.io/en/blog/posts/2021/02/25/babel-fees/</a><br> (9) <a href="https://twitter.com/PapaGooseCrypto/status/1613973196004528128">https://twitter.com/PapaGooseCrypto/status/1613973196004528128</a> (Cardano L1 Languages)<br> (10) <a href="https://usa.visa.com/solutions/crypto/auto-payments-for-self-custodial-wallets.html">https://usa.visa.com/solutions/crypto/auto-payments-for-self-custodial-wallets.html</a></p><p>(11) <a href="https://dune.com/polygon_analytics/reddit-collectible-avatars">https://dune.com/polygon_analytics/reddit-collectible-avatars</a></p><p>(12) <a href="https://odysseymarket.niftygateway.com/marketplace/publisher/starbucks-odyssey">https://odysseymarket.niftygateway.com/marketplace/publisher/starbucks-odyssey</a></p><p>(13) <a href="https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/05/08/metas-instagram-to-support-nfts-from-ethereum-polygon-solana-flow/">https://www.coindesk.com/business/2022/05/08/metas-instagram-to-support-nfts-from-ethereum-polygon-solana-flow/</a></p><p>(14) <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tHC80NFj4lo">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tHC80NFj4lo</a> (Cardano in Africa)</p><p>(15) <a href="https://wmtscan.com/">https://wmtscan.com/</a></p><p>(16) <a href="https://empowa-io.medium.com/empowa-announces-25-00-housing-project-in-mozambique-1428e356ff1c">https://empowa-io.medium.com/empowa-announces-25-00-housing-project-in-mozambique-1428e356ff1c</a><br> (17) <a href="https://www.jpg.store/">https://www.jpg.store/</a><br> (18) <a href="https://dappsoncardano.com/">https://dappsoncardano.com/</a><br> (19) <a href="https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/news/european-blockchain-pre-commercial-procurement">https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/news/european-blockchain-pre-commercial-procurement</a><br> (20) <a href="https://developer.zebra.com/blog/getting-started-identity-enabler-zebra-iota-edge-sdk">https://developer.zebra.com/blog/getting-started-identity-enabler-zebra-iota-edge-sdk</a><br> (21) <a href="https://blog.iota.org/trademark-east-africa-and-iota-paperless-trade-with-the-tangle-aims-to-become-a-standard-in-2022/">https://blog.iota.org/trademark-east-africa-and-iota-paperless-trade-with-the-tangle-aims-to-become-a-standard-in-2022/</a><br> (22) <a href="https://pro.nansen.ai/eth2-deposit-contract">https://pro.nansen.ai/eth2-deposit-contract</a><br> (23) <a href="https://www.mevwatch.info/">https://www.mevwatch.info/</a><br> (24) <a href="https://iohk.io/en/blog/posts/2020/03/26/enter-the-hydra-scaling-distributed-ledgers-the-evidence-based-way/">https://iohk.io/en/blog/posts/2020/03/26/enter-the-hydra-scaling-distributed-ledgers-the-evidence-based-way/</a><br> (25) <a href="https://blog.shimmer.network/a-deep-dive-into-stardust/">https://blog.shimmer.network/a-deep-dive-into-stardust/</a><br> (26) <a href="https://discord.com/channels/397872799483428865/397872799483428867/1072859970879619102">https://discord.com/channels/397872799483428865/397872799483428867/1072859970879619102</a> (IOTA L1 SC)<br> (27) <a href="https://discord.com/channels/397872799483428865/397872799483428867/1051834777147277332">https://discord.com/channels/397872799483428865/397872799483428867/1051834777147277332</a> (Dom Treasury)<br> (28) <a href="https://twitter.com/peter_szilagyi/status/1334138760565559297">https://twitter.com/peter_szilagyi/status/1334138760565559297</a> (EF Almost Bankrupt)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e19ffdce089b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Tangleverse Times interviews David De Troch]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/the-tangleverse-times-interviews-david-de-troch-61cb886a967f?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/61cb886a967f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Feb 2023 17:05:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-08T17:05:52.540Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CVqxc3zRpNQnNBSx77Hsqg.jpeg" /><figcaption>David De Troch</figcaption></figure><p><em>David is working as a software engineer for the IOTA foundation. Currently, he is in the Firefly team.</em></p><p><strong>Tangleverse Times: What separates Firefly from other wallets out there?</strong></p><p>David De Troch: Three things make Firefly stand out from other wallets. The first one is our dedication to a superb experience for our users. We have the opportunity to work with amazing designers and ping-pong between what is technically feasible and what is optimal for the user. Whenever we think about a new feature, we start with regular design discussions to find a solution that looks and feels good. The back and forth continues throughout the whole development phase which results in a well-designed UI/UX.</p><p>The second differentiator is the unique features that come with the IOTA protocol. At Firefly, we believe you can have the best network, but without a good wallet, there won’t be any real-world adoption. And what is the point of developing all these cool features if nobody uses them?</p><p>The last part is our commitment to usable security. Critics of the crypto industry often point out that it is cumbersome to interact with digital ledgers due to the technical knowledge required to keep everything secure. We aim to provide a digital wallet that doesn’t compromise on its security but still allows its user to take advantage of these new technologies in a frictionless manner.</p><p><strong>TT:</strong> <strong>Do you see yourself as a competitor to Metamask and other wallets in the long run, or do you think Firefly will have its own niche?</strong></p><p>DDT: Not exactly. Metamask is a tool for very basic things, namely signing transactions that trigger asset transfers or interact with smart contracts. It isn’t good at interpreting the data itself, and we are not a big fan of its security model. The main issue is that phishing websites can trick people into giving up their private keys since they are stored in browser storage. Firefly lives in a sandboxed application which enhances its security.</p><p>In my eyes, our competitors would be more like Ledger Live or Exodus, which provide a comprehensive way of interpreting the data and a lot of functionality for the different networks. Firefly is exploring options to both connect with dApps in the browser as well as integrating dApps directly in the wallet, but of course, these need to be done in a secure manner. Part of the solution could be to develop a browser extension that communicates with Firefly but provides a similar in-browser experience to MetaMask.</p><p><strong>TT: Do you plan to support more cryptos than the ones from the Iota Shimmer Assembly ecosystem in the future?</strong></p><p>DDT: Firefly is an IOTA/Shimmer wallet first and foremost. There are very few wallets in the IOTA ecosystem, and the barrier to entry is high due to the unique technology of IOTA. It would of course be amazing to extend the UI/UX we carefully designed and implement other chains and it would be a great way to attract users from other ecosystems, but it is not a priority at the moment.</p><p><strong>TT: What are some features that need to be added to Firefly in your opinion?</strong></p><p>DDT: I am very excited about the new opportunities that will present themselves for Firefly once the protocol removes the Coordinator. In the long term, I think that most digital wallets at the moment underestimate the potential digital identities offer. There are a myriad of use cases (digital identities, IAM services, password managers, …) that make a lot of sense to have in Firefly. The fact that most people carry their identities in their physical wallets supports this intuition.</p><p>In the immediate future, I am excited about the Stardust integration of IOTA into Firefly Shimmer. From a technical view, the quickest option to develop Firefly Shimmer was having two apps. Now that Stardust is coming to IOTA, we will start to design the incorporation of two networks into one app.</p><p>Additionally, There are a couple of smaller features that we have pushed down the line for far too long that would enhance the functionality of Firefly. These include an address book, a fiat on-off ramp, and more extensive developer suites. The address book is the easiest to develop, so personally, I hope we might squeeze it in sometime soon.</p><p><strong>TT: According to Charlie the spinoff will be finished early 2023. Are there already plans to expand the team? If so, how much or fast do you plan to expand?</strong></p><p>DDT: There are plans to expand the team. Initially, we want to hire senior developers with expertise in security, quality assurance, and devops, as well as a talented product designer to help design all the new features we have planned. Luckily we are well-equipped for our general software development tasks. A bigger team would also allow us to contribute more to the Rust libraries that the IF is developing.</p><p>However, the team mustn’t grow too fast, since that leads to a high burn rate. It is also necessary to spend sufficient time on the new hires. We need to integrate them into the team and give them enough training/supervision initially so that we are all aligned with our mission.</p><p><strong>TT: NFT support in Firefly is in Alpha. Governance proposal support is an important feature which may follow soon after. What will the team focus on after that?</strong></p><p>DDT: The two big milestones for Q1/Q2 are enabling full EVM support for the Shimmer EVM and the integration of IOTA into Firefly Shimmer. Since the release of Firefly Shimmer, we have been able to work on a couple of features in parallel due to the enhanced modularity of the new application. I expect this to continue throughout this year.</p><p>From a business development perspective, this year will be full of new challenges that come with becoming a separate entity. I expect that some team members will set some time aside to work out the practical things around making Firefly successful as a business.</p><p><strong>TT: Is it possible that multi-signature capabilities could be integrated into Firefly or will this require a separate app, like (formerly Gnosis) Safe?</strong></p><p>DDT: At the moment, there are a lot of roads that lead to multi-signature capabilities. Once we have EVM support, supporting the Gnosis multi-signature smart contract would be straightforward. In my opinion, it’s too early to think about a secure multi-party computation feature since that space is changing very fast, and it’s not clear yet which approach will consolidate. For our target audience, a hardware wallet still provides optimal security.</p><p><strong>TT: Are there any specific things that Firefly can learn from other ecosystems’ wallets?</strong></p><p>DDT: Definitely! I like the way Metamask has structured its code. Ledger Live has a very convenient way of showing the different dApps it supports. Frame has an interesting way of connecting to the browser through a companion, and Exodus has a nice overview of how different chains are supported. I think each project has something valuable, but it’s difficult to keep track of all the progress that’s happening around the whole space. We regularly use alternative wallets to see how they tackle similar UI/UX problems.</p><p><strong>TT: What are some possible real-world use cases for Firefly in your opinion? Is there anything that the community didn’t think of yet?</strong></p><p>DDT: At the moment, most Firefly features target the Web3 space. But Web2 isn’t going to go away anytime soon. So I think it makes sense to revisit some of those original use cases and incorporate Web3 technologies to improve trust assumptions. I would like to see some Web2 use cases such as a `Login with Firefly` on external web pages or signing documents in an unforgeable way with a Firefly identity.</p><p><strong>TT: Let’s finish with our obligatory degen question: Will it be possible for the community to invest into the firefly spinoff?</strong></p><p>DDT: At the moment we are looking for a small number of high-profile investors to help us grow into a full-fledged company. We want to move quickly and this is the best way of doing so. However we would love to be able to support investment in Firefly from the community in the future.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=61cb886a967f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[IOTA & Shimmer: All Machines Welcome Here (Even Virtual Ones)!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/iota-shimmer-all-machines-welcome-here-even-virtual-ones-aaec5c3f60df?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/aaec5c3f60df</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Feb 2023 17:05:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-08T17:05:15.615Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[ — by <a href="https://twitter.com/DigitalSoulx">@DigitalSoulx</a>]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/741/1*WvJjEeHqCeA4lX2oKD1QlA.jpeg" /></figure><p>While the original vision of IOTA was to build a DLT to enable the Internet of Things, the development of the protocol has expanded well beyond that today. The Smart Contract infrastructure that will soon be rolled out on Shimmer will broadly expand the capabilities of the ledgers by enabling a host of new distributed applications (dApps). However, it is clear that the original “no machine left behind” motivation has not been abandoned; it has been expanded to include even the virtual machines of today.</p><p><strong>How can a machine be virtual?</strong></p><p>We are all patiently awaiting the release of the ShimmerEVM: the Shimmer-customized Ethereum Virtual Machine. In simple terms, a Virtual Machine (VM) is a software package that emulates a different Operating System (OS) that is to be run alongside your primary OS. A VM has its own memory, storage space, etc. and can be used to perform standard computer functions like running a program or creating files. However, the ‘machine’ is just a virtual construct. It allows software to be run on a machine that would otherwise not support it. It provides separation between dApp and node, so if there is an attack on the VM nothing else is affected. The rest of this article will introduce several different VMs that may soon be supported on Shimmer (and later IOTA) with their corresponding strengths and weaknesses.</p><p><strong>Introduction to the Shimmer Ethereum Virtual Machine or ShimmerEVM</strong></p><p>Let’s start with the VM that is currently the most popular and will be integrated into Shimmer and IOTA first: the ShimmerEVM. The EVM is a stack-based, Turing-complete VM that is responsible for executing Smart Contracts on the Ethereum network. Since it’s Turing complete, it can execute any computationally-viable program, making it highly flexible. Also, Ethereum has a wide and long-established community. So, there is a wide base of users and resources available to developers writing code in Solidity, the popular yet still somewhat complicated programming language designed for the Ethereum blockchain.</p><p>Despite the advantages, on the Ethereum network the EVM currently faces scalability challenges since all state transitions must be processed one after the other (serially). This can cause delays in processing and higher transaction fees as the network gets congested. Also, gas fees can be unpredictable and quite high at times of peak usage, making it difficult for developers to predict the costs of running their dApps. However, the ShimmerEVM may alleviate some of these drawbacks due to the inherent benefits of the DAG structure of the network.</p><p><strong>The MoveVM: More Flexible and Highly Secure</strong></p><p>Next, let’s take a look at the MoveVM, developed through the Diem project and supported by Meta. The initial plan was develop the Diem blockchain and the Libra stablecoin for integration with the Meta web2 platforms like Facebook and Instagram. When the regulatory environment presented too many challenges to accomplish this, the tech was sold to the Silvergate blockchain bank.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EmmSwlOnLCxCuapmXPZp-Q.png" /></figure><p>The MoveVM utilizes a relatively new programming language called Move, which is more flexible, more secure and easier to use than traditional smart Contract languages like Solidity. The Move language itself is a resource-oriented language developed specifically for the MoveVM, so it is extremely efficient and performant. Move itself includes support for managing the scarce storage and computation resources available on a blockchain.</p><p>The MoveVM has several key security features worth noting: 1) Code must be verified before it can be executed, and this improves the integrity of the dApps that are developed for the VM. 2) Each token can be coded with specific rights and privileges for owners. So, hackers without the proper credentials won’t be able to pull tokens from a smart contract even if they gain access. 3) Due to the design of the VM, smart contract exploits like double spend attacks and reentrancy are very unlikely. Also, MoveVM includes support for transaction-as-script. This provides great flexibility to users of the Move language, since they can execute multiple operations through a single transaction that could simply be a user script. It is a powerful smart contract framework and even the IOTA Foundation sees the potential:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/904/1*tQ9F7V2huX3kZXKKP_EvKA.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://iota-foundation.jobs.personio.com/job/989795?display=en">https://iota-foundation.jobs.personio.com/job/989795?display=en</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>The FuelVM: A Highly Scalable and UTXO-Based VM</strong></p><p>The FuelVM developed by Fuel Labs is also being considered for use on Shimmer and IOTA. The whole idea behind the FuelVM was to make Ethereum more scalable by deploying a Layer 2 rollup that would make better use of existing hardware rather than forcing nodes to upgrade. This is important, because if the resource requirements are too high, less nodes can join the network, making it more centralized. However, the FuelVM should not be viewed only as a rollup since it can also be configured as its own Layer 1 to achieve consensus in a network. Lastly, it’s worth noting that smart contracts in the FuelVM are written in Sway, a language that takes cues from Rust and Solidity while utilizing the best of both languages.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WhPpxI6_of_I9M0CdgaRZw.png" /></figure><p>FuelVM is notable because it can be utilized on just about any blockchain. It was designed to enable fraud proofs so it’s perfect for optimistic rollups, greatly improving the scalability of Ethereum. It matches well with Shimmer and IOTA because it’s UTXO-based, and every transaction must have well-defined rules for any UTXOs it handles. As we are aware with the new output types in Shimmer, transactions can be set to execute only when certain conditions are met (like our time-lock feature), offering novel use-cases. The UTXO model is also cleaner and leads to fewer conflicts while limiting state bloat.</p><p>The FuelVM also allows for native handling of assets which is a stark contrast to EVM. The EVM only natively supports ETH, and other assets can only be handled via smart contracts. Native handling of assets has clear advantages: 1) Gas is cheaper for native transfers when compared to smart contracts. 2) Native assets allow for a much better user experience since there is less complexity involved with configuring the smart contracts.</p><p><strong>Novel Virtual Machines Still Have Weaknesses</strong></p><p>However, the MoveVM and FuelVMs are not without drawbacks. They are still relatively new technologies, so they don’t have the same adoption and support (libraries, tools, etc) of more accepted VMs, like the EVM. Even though the Move language was tailored for the MoveVM, its formal semantics and resource management features make for a steep learning curve for developers. Similarly, the FuelVM has a unique architecture that may make it more difficult for developers to learn. Lastly, the scalability of the VMs has not been fully tested in high-usage environments even though they are expected to be better than EVM.</p><p>Although the EVM has a first-mover advantage and is widely used for smart contracts today, there are number of new virtual machines preparing to challenge EVM’s dominance. These novel environments can build on the features that make EVM so popular while resolving its limitations. And even though the MoveVM and FuelVM show much promise, they are not the only players trying to entice the next generation of smart contract developers. Many blockchains already use their own network-specific VMs. Even Ethereum has a new VM to address the limitations of EVM while utilizing the capabilities of the new Proof of Stake consensus in Eth 2.0: eWASM or Ethereum WebAssembly. In the end however, it seems clear that the future for Shimmer and IOTA will include support for many VMs, allowing developers from many backgrounds and experience levels to feel at home with us, just like the machines.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=aaec5c3f60df" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Battle of the Layer1s: The Fierce Decade]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/battle-of-the-layer1s-the-fierce-decade-1660de195b2e?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1660de195b2e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Jan 2023 13:51:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-14T13:51:23.954Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[ — by MolochNess]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mb3d6qJKNLQEyNZgEHuP5Q.png" /></figure><p>The Layer1 wars rage on. Ethereum is the largest fish in crypto’s tiny pond, but it remains to be seen how these fish compete on the global stage. Ethereum, Polygon, Arbitrum, and Optimism combined have fewer than 2 million daily active addresses, which should illustrate how early we still are.</p><p>However, the stakes are clearly high! Layer1 platforms (L1s) remain the single-biggest category in crypto, with &gt;30% dominance (60% if you include BTC), with the remainder split between stablecoins, DeFi, NFTs, middleware, etc. There is an enormous potential market for L1s, with billions of users left to capture.</p><p>Several burning questions remain:</p><p>• Can Ethereum scale crypto to the masses, or will something stronger take its place?</p><p>• Which competing Layer1s are best-positioned to carve out their own chunk of the market?</p><p>• Should the competition compete on technology or community?<br> • How much value can Layer1s even capture in an L2/L3-centric world?</p><p>The ecosystems I’ll be comparing are Ethereum, Cardano, and IOTA (2.0)</p><p>Others are worth discussing: Solana, Cosmos, Avalanche, Algorand, Polkadot, etc, but time is finite!</p><p>To cover this subject in a fraction of the depth it deserves, this article is split into two.</p><p>For this first part, the points of comparison are:</p><p>• Scalability</p><p>• Decentralization</p><p>• Security</p><h4><strong>Scalability</strong></h4><p>We want more users, but what does “scale” mean in the context of decentralized platforms? For some, it refers only to TPS. The higher the better! For others, it means supporting more users without eroding the qualities that make DLTs special in the first place.</p><p>Given the purpose of our industry, the latter is the one we ought to care most about.</p><p>Imagine a classy restaurant: ‘La Chaina’, that serves 100 people a day. If La Chaina wants to serve 1,000 people a day from one location, some combination of: food quality/presentation, order speed/accuracy, service, atmosphere, etc, will necessarily suffer. If you degrade the quality from fine dining down to fast food to meet demand, have you <strong>actually</strong> scaled La Chaina?</p><p>The same principles apply to DLTs. Increased traffic = more expensive hardware/internet requirements, which excludes many people from participating in consensus or node operation, defeating the purpose of a supposably decentralized and inclusively-accountable network.</p><p><strong>Ethereum</strong> intends to scale entirely with Layer2s: Optimistic and ZK Rollups, Validiums, and others.</p><p>The original plan was to scale Ethereum via Execution Sharding, which meant multiple copies (shards) of the blockchain would run in parallel. Shards would be coordinated by the central Beacon Chain, and each additional shard would increase Ethereum’s total capacity, without making any individual shard too ‘heavy’ for average node operators to process. Eventually it was decided that Execution Sharding was overly complex, and Rollups with Data Sharding would serve as a good alternative.</p><p>Rollups move computation off-chain, posting compressed data back to L1 as often as desired.</p><p>• Optimistic Rollups assume all transactions are valid, leaving a 1 week challenge period to prove otherwise via fraud proofs. They are simpler to build with and more cost-effective for complex smart contract interactions.</p><p>• ZK Rollups prove correctness with validity proofs posted to L1. Simple transfers and swaps are cheap, but generalized computation tends to be gas inefficient.</p><p>• Validiums operate similarly to ZK Rollups, but with data held off-chain by a 3rd party, such as a Data Availability Committee (cheaper, but with weaker trust assumptions).<br> There are also Volitions, which allow users to pick between on-chain (ZK Rollup) and off-chain (Validium) data, depending on their cost/security priorities.</p><p>ZK technology has made staggering progress in the years since Ethereum’s pivot away from Execution Sharding, so I expect to see exploration of ZK Execution Sharding to scale L1 economies without surrendering users to 3rd party L2s.</p><p><strong>Cardano</strong> plans to scale with an array of technologies, each catering to different use-cases.</p><p>• Ouroboros Leios (Input Endorsers) aims to supercharge base-layer throughput by utilizing untapped network resources (dead-time) for parallel transaction processing.</p><p>• Ouroboros Hydra. Isomorphic state channels (mini-blockchains) that allow activity to move off-chain and settle final results to Cardano L1 as needed, while inheriting much of its security.</p><p>• Sidechains. While not directly secured by L1, they can be economically aligned and/or share a subset of Cardano’s stake-pools. These allow new users to enter into Cardano’s ecosystem, and facilitate rapid feature experimentation that can be integrated into the core network if desired.</p><p>• Rollups/Validiums. Much the same as on Ethereum, although theoretically more efficient due to Cardano’s EUTXO model. It’s not currently possible to deploy these on Cardano, due to the lack of validity proofs/proper Data Availability, though these are likely to be remedied in future upgrades.</p><p><strong>IOTA</strong> shares a lot in common with Ethereum, Cardano, and Cosmos’s scaling strategies: the shared security model with L2 chains, UTXOs and parallel processing on L1, and the App-Chain thesis, respectively. Mana stands to be an attractive model for L2 chain operators. Instead of being forced to pay non-refundable fees to settle to L1, there’s an added option of buying a share of network throughput, which can be sold whenever desired. Leaderless consensus should enable extreme performance advantages compared to traditional blockchains, and there is also a long-term vision to scale L1 further via ZK-Sharding. However, with so many pieces of the roadmap left to build, these will have to be revisited at a later date.</p><h4><strong>Decentralization</strong></h4><p>The crux of our industry, but how do we measure it?</p><p>Node count/requirements, core/ecosystem developers, and client diversity all matter. However, stake distribution, also known as the Nakamoto Coefficient (NC) or Minimum Attack Vector (MAV), is arguably the single-most important factor for decentralization.</p><p>Put simply: a smaller number (eg: 5) means a network is more vulnerable to attack, as fewer entities need to collude, or be pressured by governments, to harm an ecosystem. If a cartel reaches &gt;50% of stake, they can potentially reverse transactions, censor people based on their identity or the dapps they use, and generally undermine a network. On the flip-side, a large NC/MAV gives users/developers the confidence to explore and build without worry. Also, if stake was verifiably spread evenly across 100,000 unique, globally distributed entities (NC/MAV of 50,001) , the need for non-stakers to run nodes would be greatly diminished. Developer and client diversity remain important for security reasons (redundancy in case one client faces a severe bug), but even if they were all malicious, they cannot force validators to install harmful or censorious software.</p><p>Each platform uses a variant of Proof of Stake, but their implementations have different tradeoffs and count ‘validators’ differently. At time of writing:</p><p><strong>Ethereum</strong> has 497,000 “validators”. Each validator is a virtual entity with 32 ETH at stake. Since the protocol explicitly forces people to split their stake into arbitrary chunks, large ETH-holders must operate multiple “validators” each. This can mislead people who expect a similar ratio of “validators” to unique entities validating the network, implying a much greater level of decentralization than actually exists. Ethereum has an NC/MAV of 4, with 50.4% of ETH stake controlled by Lido, Coinbase, Kraken, and Binance. While Ethereum can still turn this around, it’s not a good look that ETH stake is concentrated in the hands of a few centralized, regulated entities.</p><p><strong>Cardano</strong> has 3,210 ‘stake-pools’, most of which accept stake delegation from passive holders.</p><p>While stake-pool operators (SPOs) can/do run multiple pools, doing so is disincentivized by the protocol unless they reach a much higher stake threshold ($22mil vs ~$42k). Thus, while Cardano has fewer pools than Ethereum has validators, the number gives a much better representation of decentralization. Cardano has an NC/MAV of 23, Binance and EToro with 10.8% and 2.1% respectively, and the remaining 37% controlled by community members and large holders.</p><p>This is a large gain over Ethereum: 5x larger NC/MAV, and reduced dominance of centralized entities, but there’s still a lot of room for improvement.</p><p><strong>IOTA</strong> has yet to remove its infamous ‘Coordinator’, so for now it scores a zero in decentralization.</p><p>However, if ‘Coordicide’ did ever launch, when you take IOTA’s many strengths into consideration:</p><p>• Large and passionate community, going strong from 2015</p><p>• Learnings from others’ mistakes (eg: lack of native stake delegation)</p><p>• Perhaps the fairest L1 token distribution ever</p><p>(100% of $MIOTA sold, vs ~80% of $ETH/$ADA, ~25% of $DOT, ~20% of $AVAX, and ~2% of $SOL)</p><p>There’s a good chance IOTA could quickly reach the top 5 in terms of decentralization.</p><h4><strong>Security</strong></h4><p>If NC/MAV is the focal point of Decentralization, it stands to reason that Economic Security — the cost to buy a controlling share of a network’s stake — should be the focal point of Security.</p><p>Platforms that accrue more value to the core token ($ETH, $ADA, $MIOTA) will have higher market caps over the long term, directly increasing the cost of an economic attack on the network.</p><p>Value accrual can happen in a few ways. Revenue can be paid to token-holders, the supply can shrink via burning mechanisms (eg: EIP-1559), or simply from demand to buy/hold the tokens for the benefits they offer (eg: access). Each one drives demand for the token, boosting price, market cap, and network security.</p><p>‘Staking Ratio’ is another point to consider: the percentage of tokens currently staked.</p><p>Market cap is important, but even if a network was valued at $1 trillion, if just 1% of tokens are staked ($10 billion), it will only cost ~$5.1 billion to acquire a majority stake.</p><p><strong>Ethereum</strong></p><p>After removing Execution Sharding from their roadmap, Ethereum’s long-term economic security is questionable. If L1 doesn’t scale to support more users, and L2s pay orders of magnitude less in fees to settle onto Ethereum, where will the money to provide security come from?</p><p>If we assume an L2 → L1 settlement fee of $0.0001 per transaction, then Ethereum would need 35 billion L2 transactions/day to generate the same revenue L1 earns today (~$3.5 million revenue and ~1 million transactions per day).</p><p>Staking Ratio is 13.8% (15.9 million $ETH)</p><p>Why so low? Three big reasons are:</p><p>• ETH in DeFi. With such a strong on-chain economy, ETH-holders have more choice of where to deploy their capital to earn yield.</p><p>• Lack of native stake delegation. Without this, holders are forced to jump through extra hoops initially, and when switching providers, and potentially accept worse trust assumptions (eg: custody via CEX or smart contract), disincentivizing more people from staking.</p><p>• Slashing. Even though risk of being slashed is low, a perception of risk is enough to deter people. The Shanghai fork enabling staking withdrawals in Q2 2023 should derisk ETH staking further, increase the Staking Ratio over the following months.</p><p><strong>Cardano</strong></p><p>If L1 and L2 scale together, that creates a harmonious environment, where a variety of L2s exist and thrive, but the L1 has a robust economy to fund economic security, and gives it greater leverage against L2s that wish to undermine it.</p><p>Staking Ratio is 71.9% (25.4 billion $ADA).</p><p>The main explanation for this figure, is how ingrained staking is in Cardano’s culture.</p><p>YouTubers, Twitter personalities, even dapps run their own stake-pools and solicit $ADA delegations. It’s a stark contrast compared to Ethereum, where stakers keep most things lowkey, and have no reason to discuss their staking habits. Also, there are presently fewer opportunities to generate $ADA yield on Cardano, so staking is the go-to choice for most holders.</p><p><strong>IOTA</strong></p><p>Similar to Cardano, if IOTA successfully scales L1s and L2s, that bodes much better for long-term economic security. L2 transactions are simply lower profit-margin for L1, so shouldn’t be relied upon to keep an ecosystem alive.</p><p>Staking Ratio won’t be known until Coordicide, but if we speculate: it seems likely $MIOTA will support native stake delegation like Cardano, Avalanche, etc, making a Staking Ratio of 60–90% likely. Especially after the Mana market picks up, many holders will want to sell access on the open market.</p><p>Thus concludes part one! The next post/s will cover the following points:</p><p>• User/Developer experience</p><p>• Notable PoCs and Deployments</p><p>• Obstacles/risks to be aware of</p><p>• Road to mass adoption</p><p>Stay tuned for more!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1660de195b2e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Avoiding the Dangers of Excessive Data Sharing with SSI]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@iotacontentcreators/avoiding-the-dangers-of-excessive-data-sharing-with-ssi-a8fbeb369200?source=rss-fd5e6da36708------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a8fbeb369200</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[ICCD Newletter]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 14 Jan 2023 13:50:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-14T13:50:47.653Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[ — by <a href="https://twitter.com/JelleFm">Jelle Millenaar</a>]</p><p>Tim Berners-Lee, the creator of the World Wide Web, has recently <a href="https://edition.cnn.com/2022/12/16/tech/tim-berners-lee-inrupt-spc-intl">gained attention</a> for his efforts to fix the internet through the SOLID project. This project aims to give people control over their own data and shares many goals and concepts with Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI). Instead of tech giants owning people’s data, individuals will be able to collect and share their own data with only those they choose, becoming the ultimate controllers of their own digital selves. One thing that isn’t talked about a lot with SOLID and SSI is how people will be protected from companies asking for too much data. We will further explore this challenge in this blogpost.</p><p><strong>The Dangers of Self-Sovereign Identity</strong></p><p>Imagine a world where having a rich digital identity is normal. People would be carrying around large amounts of personal information on their phones or computers, and sharing this information would be as easy as making payments with a phone. Parties receiving this information can instantly verify its integrity and source, making it almost trivial to establish trust. One app (a so-called wallet) on a person’s phone contains all sorts of important documents like their passport, licences, degrees, medical history, transportation tickets, concert tickets, and much more. While there are many benefits to this technology, it also presents challenges. For example, if it is this easy to share information, companies might ask for more information than they strictly need. The additional information might be valuable for companies to create customer profiles or and run analytics at the cost of your privacy. Companies might not let you use their services or go to certain places if you don’t agree to share the additional information.</p><p><strong>Corporate Accountability</strong></p><p>Fortunately, modern privacy laws like the EUs General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) protect people from data overcollection by companies. These laws state that companies can only collect and use personal data for specific, explicitly defined purposes and cannot collect or use more data than is necessary. While this corporate accountability is crucial, it can be difficult to enforce, because it is hard to gather evidence of data overcollection as an individual. However, we now have the opportunity to build this accountability into new protocols for data sharing, such as the new OpenId standards, that are at the heart of Self-Sovereign Identity.</p><p>One way to stop companies from collecting too much data is to keep track of data requests. This means storing a list of what data is being asked by whom and for what purposes. This helps make sure that companies are only collecting and using data for the purposes they have defined, and not collecting or using more data than they need. It’s also important to make sure that data requests can be linked to a specific company through their digital identity. This helps ensure that the requests are coming from real companies and not from people trying to do something bad. However, even if we keep a log of data requests, it might be hard to use it as proof if a company denies the log is true.</p><p><strong>Non-Repudiation</strong></p><p>Non-repudiation, or the inability to deny something that has happened, is an interesting solution for this. After a company has been successfully identified, they can use their digital identity to sign data requests. These cryptographic signatures can’t be faked and show clearly who signed the request. Just like with a contract, assuming no forgery, a company can’t deny that they have signed it, because you have undeniable proof with their signature since digital signatures forgery is almost impossible. By using this method to sign data requests, we can add non-repudiation to our log of data requests.</p><p>If at any point a company requests any amount of information, the digital identity wallet will keep track of this information including the signature proof. If the information request is excessive, it would be possible to contact your local data protection agency and not only submit a complaint, but also have non-repudiable proof. Naturally, this requires the data protection agencies to recognize the SSI method of identification and trustworthy corporate digital identities. With these things in place, it would be possible to fully automate the process of submitting a complaint.</p><p><strong>Voluntary Participation</strong></p><p>When this idea has been discussed before, corporations are often hesitant and don’t like the idea of being held accountable. Unfortunately, we can’t force them to work this way, but we can make it voluntary. If it’s completely voluntary and there are no consequences, it probably won’t be used very much. However, there is something we have complete control over.</p><p>When a person interacts with a company through a digital identity wallet, both parties will check each other’s identities and the user will get a request to share data. This request must be shown to the user and they have to agree to it by clicking “Yes” or “No”. The wallet designer has complete control over how this looks. This is where we can add consequences for companies that don’t voluntarily agree to sign data requests. The wallet can simply show a warning that says the data request might not be done in good faith and the user should be careful. This leads to a lack of trust by the user, which may persuade some users to opt for another service that doesn’t do this, creating market pressure to sign data requests fairly.</p><p>Accountability will be cornerstones for a healthy Self-Sovereign Identity ecosystem. It is important to design solutions that protect users and not further weaken their privacy. Impierce Technologies takes this huge responsibility very seriously. We design software that enables modern data sharing possibilities while protecting privacy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a8fbeb369200" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>