<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Irony of A on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Irony of A on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ironyofa?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 10:09:55 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ironyofa/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Henry Scattergood: Son of the Meeting]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/henry-scattergood-son-of-the-meeting-d4c132e4ea78?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d4c132e4ea78</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Apr 2022 17:59:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-28T12:49:54.460Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Students had to wear ties and jackets when Henry Scattergood became principal. When he left in 1970, they wore jeans and had long hair. A rapidly changing nation meant the school needed to reassess its philosophy and future. Should it stay in Germantown and remain with the Meeting? Or, take advantage of free property in Fort Washington? How could it combat racism and segregation? Should it add new buildings to lessen the serious overcrowding? Scattergood, a GFS alum, teacher, and administrator; member of the Meeting; and Germantown resident has to shepherd the school through this wrenching era.</em></p><p><strong><em>(</em></strong><a href="https://medium.com/p/840551fc7e98/"><strong><em>Introduction to this series</em></strong></a><strong><em>)</em></strong></p><p><strong>Henry Scattergood was a hot candidate to head a Quaker school</strong> — and small wonder. He was a birth-right Friend. He had long experience as a student, teacher, and administrator in Friends’ schools. He was physically attractive: tall, powerfully built and athletic, and that mattered to a school that Henry himself described as “a little sissy.” He was affable, easy to talk to, a good listener, and an articulate spokesman for the values of Quaker education. His wife, Sarah (Sally), a charming and quick-witted lady with impressive educational credentials of her own, was another attraction to a board of trustees. Sally was a Bryn Mawr alumna and had taught at Miquon, Springside, and Plymouth Meeting Friends School. They had five children.</p><p>Henry had graduated <em>cum laude </em>from GFS in 1923 and then gone on to Haverford College where he won letters in varsity sports, was elected head of the student association, and graduated with a Phi Beta Kappa key. After Haverford he taught at the Shady Hill School, Sidwell Friends, and GFS. During the war he had served in administrative posts for the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Friends_Service_Committee#History">American Friends Service Committee</a> working with displaced refugees in Lisbon and Casablanca. He had earned a Master’s degree in education from Harvard. In 1952 he was principal of GFS’s Junior High, chair of its Advanced Placement program, and shared all the college advising duties with Burton Fowler. He was also president of the Philadelphia Private School Teachers Association.</p><p>GFS had looked at him in 1940, when he was still too young by his own estimation, and other schools had courted him since. Sidwell Friends, for example, wanted him to be a candidate for principal in 1942, but Scattergood spurned the overture. Sidwell Friends would come after him again in 1964 following the abrupt ouster of headmaster John Colbaugh.¹</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d4PJUzNq3q8tCAD99GZ19A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Henry Scattergood</figcaption></figure><p>In 1952, Scattergood received an offer to become Principal of Friends’ Central, and this offer he considered seriously. He wanted to stay at GFS. “I knew it better than any other school, and I loved it,” but family responsibilities made the much higher salary Friends’ Central proposed very attractive.</p><p>In March he went first to Burton Fowler and then to Edward Evans, the School Committee clerk and his neighbor in Awbury, to tell them about Friends’ Central and to ask about his future prospects at GFS. Evans promised to bring the question to the School Committee.</p><p>The Committee promised him little. Despite their expressed admiration for his qualities, he was told only that he would “be among those considered” after Fowler retired. They meant to form a search committee and there would be no guarantee that he would be the choice. Scattergood’s negotiations with Friends’ Central became more serious.</p><p>Edward Evans could not stand the thought that Scattergood might leave. Henry was a child of Germantown Meeting. Evans had known him all his life, and knew, too, that the School Committee had long anticipated that Scattergood would be the first alumnus to become principal. Evans decided to offer him the job without consulting the Committee. As Scattergood remembered later, it was during a walk in the woods at Awbury that Evans “asked if I would like to become principal of Germantown Friends.” It was highly irregular.</p><p>At the May meeting, Evans told the School Committee what he had done, and that the executive committee backed him. The school could not afford to lose Henry Scattergood. He asked the Committee to validate his offer, to reverse its earlier decision and dispense with a search, and to send Scattergood an official letter appointing him Principal “after Burton Fowler retires in August 1955.” Faced with what amounted to a <em>fait accompli </em>and agreeing that Henry couldn’t be spared, the Committee agreed.</p><p>Henry Scattergood knew nothing about Evans’s maneuver. In response to Evans’s question in the woods, he had answered “if the School Committee thinks I can handle the job, I’d like to give it a try.”</p><p><strong>Scattergood’s appointment was kept secret</strong>, perhaps in fear that an announced successor would undermine Fowler’s authority. Publicly Scattergood was called “Assistant Principal,” but the Committee minutes described him as “Co-Principal.”</p><p>Fowler did not complete his three-year contract. In February 1954 he asked the Committee to let him out of his last year. He wanted to retire in June. He said that at the age of sixty-seven, “the wear and tear of such an active job” was becoming too much, and since Scattergood stood ready to take over, he was certain the Committee would let him go. It did so, and the announcements of Fowler’s retirement and Scattergood’s appointment were made simultaneously.</p><p>Since Scattergood needed no introduction, and certainly no long letter explaining the reasons for his appointment, all attention turned to saying a proper goodbye to Fowler. On June 7, according to an account by David Mallery ‘41, one of Fowler’s young faculty appointees, “over one thousand parents, alumni, students, teachers, and friends” gathered at the school for dinner and a celebration. Fowler’s accomplishments were listed by several speakers, most impressively by Edward Evans who had earlier announced his own decision to retire as clerk. “School democracy” was mentioned, of course, and community service, non-discriminatory admissions, Annual Giving, the Adult School, student government, and “innovation.” Evans spoke of Fowler’s “bright vision of freedom,” and concluded that “we here, under Henry Scattergood, [will] confidently carry on from where he has left us.”²</p><p>The evening’s celebration caught the tone of the transition. It would be seamless, the School would “confidently carry on.” Fowler would be missed, but in Henry Scattergood the school had an outstanding successor: “The fine promise of his young manhood has been more than fulfilled.” Scattergood said in his own speech that evening that there were two things to remember about footsteps: their size and the direction they headed. He hoped he could fill Fowler’s footsteps, but he knew he would follow in the same direction. More than one speaker looked at Irvin Poley sitting next to Scattergood and reflected “with heart warming assurance” that the School’s “anchor” would be at hand for a few more years.³</p><p>Fowler read a letter he had received from a third grader:</p><blockquote>Dear Mr. Fowler,<br>I am sorry you are leaving. I am very glad my Daddy is going to be principal...<br>Love, from Ellie Scattergood.</blockquote><p>Fowler left to become a consultant on educational programs for the Ford Foundation and the Educational Records Bureau.</p><p>In the fall, Bob Boynton, a new teacher, wrote a poem about his first impressions of the School: “GFS Scene Through Four Frames.” Frame number one can stand as an epitaph to the Fowler years.</p><blockquote>An unblurted legacy of quiet sanity, <br>A turn of mind which<br>Has builded a more stately mansion <br>Resplendent in dust-grained mortar:<br>A simple conviction that all are godly <br>And all are human;<br>The unspeaking affirmation that <br>The whole truth is worth courting <br>And can be won.<em>⁴</em></blockquote><p>Henry Scattergood entered the Pilot House that summer without missing a beat. “I don’t recall any difficult adjustment period,” he recalled. “All my former teachers were very loyal to me and supportive. They were very helpful. I mean they didn’t snipe at me or treat me as if I were a kid.”</p><p>It helped, too, that Scattergood knew everyone on the School Committee, and they felt warmly toward him. Steve Cary ’33, was the new clerk succeeding Evans, ’98. Both the School and its governing board were now headed by much younger men. “Steve Cary, Sam Fessenden, some others, my contemporaries, were now my bosses on the School Committee. We spoke the same language; we understood each other. So on the whole I moved into the situation fairly easily and painlessly. We didn’t have any great crises to deal with in the middle fifties. By the time the sixties came along, well, things got tougher.”⁵</p><p><strong>The early years were a happy time for Scattergood.</strong> He got on well with the Committee, parents, and faculty, and he knew the name of almost every student. He continued to teach a class (“to keep in touch with what really went on”), and the door to his office was almost always open.</p><p>He was a man who was more interested in people than programs and would make fewer changes in the curriculum than had Fowler. He was basically satisfied with the program that had been created. Asked by an interviewer to list the strengths and weaknesses of the curriculum in these years, he said, “I don’t think there were any great weaknesses. We were basically in pretty good shape. We had problems finding good people to teach the Junior High, I remember that.” Strengths? “Clara Dewsnap had a very fine Lower School” and in the Upper School “the English Department was the best.” He singled out English teachers Ed Gordon (“outstanding teacher”) and David Mallery (“he made students feel like a million dollars”). The measure of a school, he believed, “was the kind of lives its graduates live,” and by that measure GFS was doing well. He saw GFS graduates as “people who have given a lot of their lives to a profession or have done something useful often way beyond the call of duty. I like to think the school had an influence in their lives.”</p><p>He had an example he cited frequently. “When I looked and saw that the chairman of the Board of Bryn Mawr, Ned Spaeth, and the chairman of the board of the University of Pennsylvania, Bill Day, and the chairman of the board of Haverford College, Jonathan Rhoads, and the chairman of the board of Swarthmore, Bob Browning, were all GFS graduates, that said something to me.”</p><p>The early years continued in familiar rhythms and patterns. Teachers from the Yarnall era continued to retire, and their replacements usually measured up. Burgess had finally managed to save enough money to buy a place in the Fairview Nursing Home in Chestnut Hill and retired in 1960. He had taught for fifty-one years, the longest tenure in the school’s history. Scattergood visited him at Fairview. “He was an old man, he was pretty feeble. But he knew me, and we would talk about old times.” In his later years Burgess loved martinis, but he could not afford them at Fairview, “So Irvin Poley endowed him with a martini fund. We would be sitting there for a while and he would look at his watch and say ‘Nurse, I think it’s time for my first martini.’ Irvin, who never drank a drop in his life, was a sensitive and loving and caring man.’’</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/332/1*YoyEpcqI8A7uMfHSrH3CvA.png" /><figcaption>Poley’s Speaking of Teaching</figcaption></figure><p>Poley retired in 1958, the fiftieth anniversary of his graduation from GFS. To mark the occasion the School published a collection of his articles as a book, <em>Speaking of Teaching</em>. Haverford College awarded him an honorary degree. In 1968 the school would honor him again by naming the assembling room the Poley Auditorium.</p><p>The last chapter of <em>Speaking of Teaching </em>was addressed to GFS Alumni and was Poley’s reminiscence of the last quarter century at the school — “Our School Then and Now.” He more than anyone, more even than Stanley Yarnall, had made possible the differences he described.</p><blockquote>As I look back a quarter of a century, I feel there is improvement in many areas of school life. The school meeting for worship, for example, seems distinctly better suited now to the needs of young people than it was. We no longer have talking down — ’messages for the dear children.’ Boys and girls now seem to be part of the meeting as a whole. In such matters it is easy to be fooled, but my belief is that meeting is now honestly valued by many of the boys and girls…</blockquote><blockquote>There is less emphasis than there was on marks and prizes; there is no class ranking now, no honor roll. There is more emphasis, I truly believe, on ideas, on group achievement, on maturity, on self-respect, on learning for the sake of finding out something interesting or valuable…</blockquote><blockquote>Instead of the old-fashioned separation from the community — an education “guarded/ in the Quaker phrase, from contact with the world — our older students may go to urban minority Close Ups, to the Schools Community Council, to conferences, to seminars, to settlements, to work camps. They tend to work with people rather than for them.</blockquote><blockquote>Students and teachers are much concerned now about the emotional and social life of boys and girls; in my early days, little faculty conferring was done on pupils without academic difficulties. Now both students and teachers are actively concerned for the new student, the shy student, the unaccepted student. The school has had a student advisory committee since 1950 which tries to help the youngsters who show their maladjustment in abnormal self-centeredness, in snobbery, in cruelty, in minor dishonesties.</blockquote><blockquote>In addition to their major place in the physical education program, athletics play a big part in meeting these emotional and social needs. A bigger student body has enabled us to have more teachers and to offer a more varied program…</blockquote><blockquote>The success of the athletic departments in giving more widespread opportunities for all demands a great deal of student leadership and cooperation. It seems to me that in these twenty-five years such student responsibility and the practice of self-discipline have greatly increased in many areas of school life. Our Wednesday and Friday assemblies are usually presided over by students and planned by both faculty and students. The Seniors are now getting good practice in self- government by studying in the library with only their classmates supervision…</blockquote><blockquote>Twenty-five years ago the value of the arts for the realization of personality was beginning to be appreciated. Nowadays drama is studied as a part of English, recognized for the important form of literature that it is. In recent years Bach is sung or played oftener than Gershwin or Sullivan, and every piece taught is likely to be good of its kind. There has been growth in the graphic arts, too…</blockquote><blockquote>Years ago the student body had great ranges of academic ability — perhaps more evident than now, because we knew nothing of remedial reading, because we knew little of individual differences and their recognition in the course of study. Some boys who could not read adequately were attempting both Latin and French. Now we know that foreign languages confuse rather than help the youngster who needs first to get straightened out in reading and spelling, that many children — some of them very able — have reading difficulties, that there is no one perfect curriculum for college preparation. If the student body was more varied then in its abilities to profit from a completely book-centered program, it was much less varied racially and religiously. In addition to every known variety of Protestant, there are now in our school Catholics and Jews of all shades of orthodoxy. There are Negroes now, very much a part of the whole; there is likely to be an Oriental or two and several guests from Europe.</blockquote><blockquote>The teachers are more nearly professional now… [and] there are relatively more men. . .</blockquote><blockquote>Some of these changes are not peculiar to G.F.S.; education in general has moved ahead. In an age when it is easy to be depressed, it is important to see clearly those areas in which progress is evident, and education is one of these. For its day, our school twenty five years ago was good; for this day I am convinced it is better than that. But then I don’t claim to be unbiased.<em>⁶</em></blockquote><p>The 1950s rolled on smoothly. Enrollment continued to edge up — it passed 700 in 1956 — and the waiting list for places grew longer (305 in 1957). Dorothy Platt’s admission reports were invariably optimistic, even chatty. The hardest part of her job was turning so many good people away.</p><p>She liked to give a picture of the kind of parents who chose GFS. Her 1955 report is characteristic. “We usually enroll more doctors’ children than those of any other profession, but this year teachers and manufacturers are in the majority. As usual, our new parents come from every walk of life. We have a psychiatrist, a minister, a pediatrician, chief of the Serum Exchange of the Children’s Hospital, a geophysicist who formerly worked with Einstein, now director of the Geophysical Laboratory of Carnegie Institute; engineers, chemists, a lawyer, an executive of Sears Roebuck, one of Kresge’s 5 &amp; 10; a shipping clerk, teachers, the vice president of a steel company; a musician; a Chinese importer; a secretary, a research psychologist at the Franklin Institute; a professor of city planning; a judge of the Municipal Court; a diplomat; a banker; a social worker; the head of the counselling of the Philadelphia Public Schools; a control clerk; an insurance man; a food broker.” There were 137 Friends’ children, 123 alumni children, and nineteen African Americans.</p><p><strong>The surface of school life may have seemed steady and placid</strong> in these years, and the school attractive to a diverse population, the future bright, but a critical moment was at hand. In 1957, the school faced the most important decision in its entire history.</p><p>“Out of the blue,” Steve Cary remembers, the school was offered land in the suburb of Fort Washington by the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philadelphia_Bulletin#1895_to_1975">McLean family, publishers of the <em>Philadelphia Bulletin</em></a>. The McLeans had no prior connection to the school. “McLean decided he wanted a school on that property, and he just picked us out.” Cary remembered visiting the estate. “It was a beautiful property,” and the offer was extraordinarily generous: The land was to be given freely and with no strings attached.</p><p>A move could solve the pressing space issues on the urban campus. The school had struggled to find adequate space for new programs, growing enrollment, and athletic fields over the previous decades. There was little available land near the campus. Germantown, too, was changing. The post-war shift of well-paying manufacturing jobs to the south or to sites with better highway access meant that there were fewer employment opportunities for local residents. The post-war growth of automobile-centric suburbs drew middle-class Germantowners to places like Plymouth Meeting and Jenkintown. With these changes, Germantown businesses suffered or closed. These neighborhood changes foreshadowed the efforts of the 1960s and seventies to revive inner-city neighborhoods through “urban renewal.”</p><p>The School Committee had a difficult decision to make. A special Development Committee weighed the school’s options. The tract in Fort Washington was attractive but would require a huge investment in new construction for the school; it would also drastically change the “center of gravity” of the school community.</p><p>In May 1957, the Development Committee reported that “after much discussion of the problems involved, especially the financial ones, the School Committee decided that the reasons for staying at the present site outweighed those for moving.”⁷ The decision to reject the McLean’s offer was, in the first place, a moral one. Good neighbors don’t betray their neighborhood. There was an additional moral dimension. When people in the fifties used the term “changing,” they meant racially. The number of African Americans in Germantown was increasing, and “white flight” had begun. To many in the school community, a move to Fort Washington would be to join in “white flight,” it would be shameful, immoral, cowardly — a betrayal of Quaker principles.</p><p>There were other considerations, too. No one wanted to move Germantown Meeting. It served a still-large Quaker population in the northwest part of the city. A move would threaten that relationship between the school and the Meeting. It might also lessen the Quaker character of the school, and Scattergood and School Committee members were absolutely opposed to that. Jack Childs remembered doing a survey of GFS families at that time — where they lived and how they came to school, by private car or public transportation (PTC buses or trolleys, the Reading or Pennsylvania railroad), and concluded that a move to Fort Washington would be a move away from the school’s supporters. How would students already enrolled get to a new campus? Childs’ survey is the probable source for the statement in the Committee minutes that GFS should remain where it was because “the center of gravity to the school’s population is at Stenton and Gowen Avenues.” GFS might find new families in the suburbs, but it would be a very different school if it did, and nobody wanted that either.</p><p>As Henry Scattergood noted, “the school was the child of the Meeting,” and it would be unwise to sever that bond. Ultimately, GFS was a city school and its directors were determined to remain in the city. McLean then offered his land to Germantown Academy, which accepted and prepared to leave the city. The decision to remain in Germantown would have enormous consequences. Fred Calder described it as the kind of decision an institution makes once in a lifetime, a “make or break” decision. The decision did not seem so fateful to those who made it. Eric Johnson, who had returned to the school as head of the Junior High, later called himself “an innocent” in those days. In an interview shortly before his death, Johnson defended the decision as the right one, but admitted that the costs incurred were higher than he had ever imagined. Jack Childs, then a member of the Meeting’s Property Committee, later had second thoughts about his own part in the decision.</p><p>Today it is easy to see that the mid-fifties were just the beginning of the long and serious decline of Germantown. It was not so obvious then. The decline was not unique to Germantown, or even Philadelphia, of course. It was part of a long-term transformation of the manufacturing cities of the rust belt Northeast to a post-industrial economy. Industrial historian Philip Scranton suggests that because Philadelphia had a non-diversified and specialized manufacturing sector, and fewer huge enterprises, its decline was less visible than elsewhere. In contrast to Pittsburgh or Detroit, “Philadelphia’s decay, like its advance, was spread across half a century, a pattern that robbed it of sudden drama and made it difficult to perceive or reverse.”⁸ Scranton dates Philadelphia’s industrial peak as “workshop of the world” to the mid-1920s, and notes that “in the half century after 1925 the city lost two thirds of its industrial jobs and virtually all of its greatest firms. Of the 25 largest in 1925, only the Budd Company remains [in 1990] a major player in its sector.”⁹</p><p>World War II had disguised this pattern and given new life to struggling companies in Germantown, Nicetown, East Falls, and Manayunk, the neighborhoods surrounding GFS. But by the 1950s, the decay had resumed.</p><p>Part of this pattern was clear to the men and women of Germantown Meeting in 1957, but not all of it. Germantown was in a period of transition. The textile mills, knitting mills, and carpet mills south and east of the school were already shutting down or moving South, taking jobs from workers in the neighboring row homes. But much remained: the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budd_Company">Budd</a> plant, for example, and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midvale_Steel">Midvale Steel</a> and <a href="https://www.workshopoftheworld.com/nicetown/nice.html">Nice Ball Bearing</a>, all cutting back, but still alive. The central Germantown business district was still anchored by two upscale department stores: <a href="https://philadelphiaencyclopedia.org/archive/department-stores/deptstore-germantown/">Rowell’s</a> at Germantown and Chelten, and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allen%27s_department_store">Allen’s</a> one block away. People still came from all over the city to shop in Germantown, and people who lived there didn’t need a car to shop for anything they needed. There was still Sears, Penney’s, two Woolworths, and two car dealers.</p><p>Immediately around the school, businesses still flourished. James S. Jones and daughters occupied three of the four corners of Germantown and Coulter and, like Rowell’s and Allen’s, catered to affluent customers. The fourth corner, however, was a worry. The Coulter Inn had become a shabby, low-rent apartment building. Jack Childs described it as the kind of place where the tenants, eighty or so mostly old men, handed over their social security checks to the landlord in return for a cheap room and meals.</p><p>Germantown was showing signs of decay; in places it was even a little seedy. Businessmen complained about a drop off in trade. All this the school and Meeting knew. Could GFS in conscience add to the problems of Germantown by escaping to the suburbs? Or could the school by remaining help arrest the downward slide?</p><p><strong>But remaining in Germantown also raised difficult issues. </strong>The school would remain where it was, but could it continue as it was? The underlying financial problems had to be addressed.</p><p>In 1956 the School Committee had responded to familiar complaints from Scattergood and Dewsnap about losing good teachers because of poor pay (Dewsnap mentioned Hall Cushman, in particular, who left for a public-school job) by adopting yet another salary scheme. This one had a starting wage of $3,000 and a maximum after ten years of $5,600. Moreover, the new scheme was to apply equally to all—there was to be no more pay discrimination between men and women or between Lower and Upper School teachers. The intention was good, but the results (as we shall see) fell short. To pay for this new scale, tuition was increased 10%, the latest in a series of increases that worried the Committee considerably.</p><p>Salaries could not be raised by admitting more students because, as usual, the school was overcrowded. But now the crowding, especially in the Lower School, had become desperate. In the last Pennsylvania Association of Private Academic Schools (P.A.P.A.S.) evaluation, the Lower School’s physical facilities had been found to be “inadequate” and the evaluators had warned darkly of GFS failing the next accreditation unless there was improvement. Too many students were stuffed into too few square feet, and there was severe criticism of poor lighting and inadequate ventilation. The Main Building was in sad shape, too, and Scattergood worried that it might not pass fire and safety inspections. Except for the Alumni Building, there had been no new buildings added to the campus since 1925, and enrollment was 35<strong>% </strong>higher.</p><p>To make matters worse, there was no space on the campus to add more buildings even if the Meeting, always jealous of its space, gave permission and the school could raise the money. Burton Fowler’s warning of a few years earlier that the city was crowding in on the school had proved true.</p><p>The School Committee wrestled with all these issues in 1956 and 1957. The Development Committee, already in place to review the McLean’s offer now looked at options to relocate somewhere else in the city. The Development Committee studied possible sites in the city’s northwest. They wanted at least twenty-five acres, and the Strawbridge-Hayman property on School House Lane received the closest scrutiny. A second possibility was an undeveloped tract near McCallum and Mermaid Lane belonging to the Woodward-Houston estate, although this was judged to be too far from the Meeting. Either site would be costly. The Development Committee, headed by Robert Yarnall ‘40, guessed it would cost $2.2 million to develop either property.</p><p>A second option, and the one chosen, bore a lower price tag—about $750,000. The school would remain where it was but upgrade the existing buildings, construct a new Lower School, and attempt to acquire more land in the immediate neighborhood. The historic decision was made by the School Committee on May 21, 1957.</p><p><strong>The decision at first seemed not only prudent, but wise.</strong> Property was available for development around the school. In July a neighbor, Mary C. Emlen, offered to sell the school her house and land on School House Lane for only $20,000 provided she could remain as tenant. The Committee jumped at the chance. Then, in September, another neighbor, Dr. Mary T. Mason, died and her large property adjoining the athletic fields came on the market. The school purchased the six-acre Mason tract for $120,000 and made plans to develop it for additional playing fields. Over the next few years quietly, even secretively, the school acquired others parcels in and around Germantown and Coulter. Eventually GFS would find itself at odds with community groups who would accuse the school of acting like a slum lord.</p><p>To pay for the upgrade of facilities, the Committee announced plans for a new capital fund drive in November of 1958. The drive was chaired by Samuel Fessenden ’28, and had a target of $600,000. This campaign had a more professional air to it than earlier drives. The firm of John F. Rich, Inc. was hired “to ascertain an accurate picture of our fund raising potential.” It was the Rich firm that recommended the target figure; the Development Committee had hoped for much more. A Buildings Committee, chaired by F. Joseph Stokes ’31, was formed “to guide the planning of physical alterations and new buildings,” and the architectural firm of Chappelle and Crothers, already retained to work on the Mason property, was asked to draw up designs for a new lower school and a campus plan for the school “and of the block surrounding them.”¹⁰ Another committee was charged with designing “a program in which the School can stimulate (with other groups) a regeneration of the Germantown Community.”</p><p>Henry Scattergood was content to leave issues of money and real estate largely in the hands of others. “I was never much of a builder,” he said later. “Bricks and mortar didn’t much interest me.”</p><p>Scattergood was too modest. Bricks and mortar may not have interested him, but education did— and his school and his vision of education required some new bricks and mortar. Two major buildings were constructed during Scattergood’s administration: the Lower School and the science building (Sharpless). Scattergood would always play down his own role in this construction process.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*n4RjB6m92CzArQjiDOy79A.jpeg" /><figcaption>The new Lower School building under construction in January 1961</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Henry Scattergood was—first and foremost—a school man.</strong> His reports to the School Committee showed his delight in the small, but important, triumphs that made up daily school life: the appointment of the first African American faculty member, Jamesena Faulk, as school librarian; the successes of GFS students in <a href="https://www.afsc.org/content/archive-highlights-us-and-international-work-camps">European work camps</a>; the 1955 soccer team, the first to win an lnter-Ac title since 1938.</p><p>Meanwhile, he was putting together his own team. Clara Dewsnap resigned as Primary principal in 1953 to accept a position at Wellesley College, and Ed Gordon, head of the Upper School, left the same year to head the M.A.T. program at Yale. To replace them, Scattergood brought back Hall Cushman, who had taught at GFS from 1952 to 1955, from the Upper Darby public schools to succeed Dewsnap, and he promoted history department chairman Robert Boynton as Gordon’s successor.</p><p>Scattergood was proud of his faculty appointments, too. One of the first was Allen Clayton in 1954. “I hired Al to teach music, but had in mind, too, that he had been an all-American soccer player at Haverford.” Clayton taught instrumental music in the Junior High and High Schools, and he became varsity soccer coach in 1960. Scattergood hired Pat Reifsnyder away from Friends’ Central in 1961. Both Clayton and Reifsnyder were Quakers—an important consideration for Scattergood—and both were extraordinary teachers who became legends in the school.</p><p>Like many American cities, Philadelphia had begun to feel the effects of the demographic changes of the post-war era. So-called “urban renewal” had become a priority of city government, and Germantown was one of the areas of focus. In 1963, the Redevelopment Authority’s draft plan for Germantown raised alarms for the school and Meeting. One of the primary concerns for redevelopment was to find a way to smooth the flow of traffic from the northwest neighborhoods and the growing suburbs beyond into Center City Philadelphia. A key feature of this plan was a recommendation that Coulter Street be widened into a five-to- seven lane road. Clearly, this would be significant for GFS. The widened road would require the taking of the open space in front of the Main Building and Meetinghouse, the properties on the opposite side of Coulter (including the Alumni Building), or both. The minutes of the School Committee’s Planning Committee indicate that the school was blindsided by this development. The bisecting of the campus by a new major traffic artery made use of any properties on the south side of Coulter problematic; this would include Alumni Building (if it survived) and the Boys’ Club fields, which GFS used for physical education classes and sporting events. The minutes also note that “the City is paying G.A. a highly inflated sum for its property, which prohibits its resale to an educational institution. It is ironic that G.A. should be rewarded for moving out of Germantown while G.F.S., which has raised and spent more than $700,000 improving its properties here, has been cut into two parts by the Plan.”¹¹ At a public meeting on June 18, 1963, Cary reminded the several hundred community members in attendance that the school owned and used properties on the south side of Coulter, and had plans for acquiring other properties there. With the widening of Coulter, the school’s “hopes of developing something on that side of Coulter St. are damaged.”¹² The Meeting also reacted with alarm to the proposed widening of Coulter St., noting in an “URGENT” letter to members and attenders that the traffic survey for the plan anticipated that the average number of vehicles using Coulter Street each day would go from 6,200 to 20,400 by 1980.¹³ While this part of the Plan for Germantown would soon be abandoned, it would not be the last time that the School and Meeting would be presented with challenges raised by the economic and demographic changes that the city and neighborhood faced.</p><p><strong>The composition of the student body was another matter.</strong> GFS had begun the process of integrating its enrollment and faculty in the 1940s, but the efforts fell far short in the eyes of many. The September 15, 1963, bombing of the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama, which killed four young girls and injured twenty-two parishioners, would prove a catalyst for one of the school’s most successful initiatives. In the bombing’s aftermath, the GFS community wanted to know what they could do to support the congregation. After discussions led by Ted Wolf ’47 and Eric Johnson ’36, the community realized that while segregation and racism were a serious problem in the American South, the community around the school also suffered from those biases. The GFS Community Scholarship Program arose from these discussions. The CSP fundraising prospectus stated that an increase in minority children at GFS would allow all students to be “healthily exposed to similarities and differences as they pursued their education” and that GFS should “relate itself more closely to its immediate community.” Ted Wolf said that the bombing “reinforced the school’s earlier decision to remain in Germantown.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/636/1*IyJ9_Oas5jpt20GtXZPhkg.png" /><figcaption>First advertisement for the Community Scholarship program</figcaption></figure><p>A September 1965 editorial introducing the program in the <em>Germantown Courier </em>noted that “Central Germantown is a thickly populated area in many respects with inadequate education…. [GFS believes that it can be of] service to the youth of the area by enrolling as members of its regular student body boys and girls attending public schools. Most of these will require full scholarships.”¹⁴ In the first year, six Community Scholarship students joined the seventh-grade class. The GFS <em>Bulletin </em>in 1965 said that the “community scholarships can be a first-hand contribution toward integration, both racial and economic; it can broaden the living educational experience of our students, who should learn to know more people of all economic and social levels.”¹⁵ Initially, funding from foundations supported nine six-year scholarships. By the late 1960s additional scholarships were funded by individuals; the Class of 1969 stepped forward and funded a thirteen-year scholarship for their class gift and current parents donated towards the program, covering the tuition for several neighborhood children for the 1968- 1969 school year. In a letter to Scattergood, U. S. District Judge A. Leon Higginbotham, Jr. (also a GFS parent) wrote of his “growing conviction about the importance of the program.”</p><blockquote>In a society where high-sounding words so often seem to be a conscience-solving substitute for deeds, it is refreshing to me to be involved, even in a small way, with specific accomplishments. You know that I see your Community Scholarships Program as important far beyond the amount of money that goes into it, the small number of people involved, and the physical boundaries of the community it arises from.</blockquote><p>Later in the letter, he noted</p><blockquote>Henry, I see GFS as much more than a very good private school. Somewhere in your literature you say you want to make it “as public a private school as possible.” That is exactly it! GFS is extraordinary in the same sense that are some of the best privately controlled colleges and universities — extraordinary because it has decided as a matter of policy to put its power and facilities to work as much as possible for the community rather than for the granting of more privileges to the already privileged. I agree with the School that excellence in isolation is not enough. It may even be harmful. But excellence with involvement is socially useful and more excellent because it is more relevant to the pressing issues of today.<em>¹⁶</em></blockquote><p>As the school worked at opening its doors to a wider number of neighborhood children, it also eyed possibilities for physical expansion within Germantown. With Germantown Academy’s acceptance of the McLean offer of the Fort Washington property, their large campus across Greene Street was an obvious solution to GFS’s space needs. Colonial Germantown, Inc., a group started in the 1950s to preserve Germantown’s Market Square had, by 1962, broadened its focus to include the revitalization of the wider neighborhood. Working with the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority, Colonial Germantown became the <em>de facto </em>broker for the Germantown Academy property. GFS discussed the property with them over the course of several years. Steve Cary noted, however, that Colonial Germantown never made a “formal, identified, face-to-face approach to GFS” to negotiate an agreement beyond their initial, non-negotiable one-million-dollar price tag.¹⁷</p><p>By late 1964, GA’s Fort Washington campus was almost ready, and the candidates for buying their School House Lane property had come down to two: GFS and the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod, which planned to open a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germantown_Lutheran_Academy">Lutheran high school in Germantown</a>.¹⁸ The two groups presented their plans to the Redevelopment Authority and awaited their decision. In January 1965, the RDA voted 3–1 to sell the property to the Lutherans. In his communication to the GFS community in the Winter 1965 <em>Bulletin</em>, Cary (who noted that his “report cannot be objective; it will, I hope, be candid.”) noted that Colonial Germantown considered that they had made “repeated offers” to GFS that were met with “repeated rejections.” In the school’s view, though, Colonial Germantown’s refusal to negotiate meant that no formal offer had ever been made. As the RDA’s local consultants, Colonial Germantown recommended acceptance of the Lutherans’ offer over GFS in part, at least, because of the school’s prior refusals of their offers. Cary also noted the political reality was that Colonial Germantown had gone so far down the road in negotiating with the Lutherans that backing out at that stage would endanger “the city’s future ability to attract new industry and institutions” by “violating a commitment, regardless of its context or legality.”¹⁹ Cary told the school community that the school’s options included pressing the school’s claim with City Council (which would need to pass legislation authorizing the RDA’s sale of the GA property) or moving on and looking for other expansion options, in particular properties across Coulter Street owned by the Boys’ Club.²⁰</p><p>By the spring, the School Committee had decided “that it is in the best interests of both the School and the Germantown community” that they end their bid for the GA property and instead accept the RDA’s “offer to relocate the Germantown Boys’ club on an adjacent block and make substantially all of the so-called Penn Street block available to” GFS.²¹ Writing in the <em>Bulletin</em>, Stephen Cary told the school community that the idea of the school and the Boys’ Club “sharing space and facilities on this block is absolutely unacceptable.” He continued, noting</p><blockquote>The club has generously indicated a willingness to explore moving, but this will take time, and would have to be on terms acceptable to the club, since we are unwilling to put any pressure on a fine, neighboring institution to move unless it will be to its advantage to do so.</blockquote><blockquote>These matters are currently being explored, and until answers are found, our future course will remain in doubt.<em>²²</em></blockquote><p>Negotiations between the Boys’ Club, the school, the community, and the city over the next several years would not yield a plan acceptable to all parties, and GFS would begin to look elsewhere for space to accommodate the growing school.</p><p>Just as the economic and demographic changes of the 1960s were reshaping GFS and its relationship with the community, the social changes of the 1960s were also affecting what was going on inside the school.</p><p>On the playing fields, while soccer and cross country were “flourishing,” interest in the traditional fall high school sport, football, was waning. In 1968, Ed Thode wrote in the <em>Bulletin</em>:</p><blockquote>Probably the most traumatic event we’ve lived through recently is the dropping of varsity football. This has been a difficult experience for all concerned. For several years now, we have had trouble fielding a squad of sufficient numbers to compete at the varsity level. This year, after a few weeks of preliminary practice, during which time efforts were made to solicit more players from the student body, the squad had shrunk to an all-time low. The administration of the school made the decision to drop the sport. To that small, loyal group of students who were on the team, this was a sad moment.</blockquote><p>The football equipment was put in storage, awaiting the day when or if “a groundswell of interest in the sport appears among our boys.”²³</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*aTggRWTZJPM5qgR5ugleng.png" /><figcaption>The 1967 GFS football team</figcaption></figure><p><strong>One of Scattergood’s first challenges as principal</strong> was to emphasize the school’s dress code. A note to the <em>Parents Bulletin </em>in September 1954 reminded parents that “‘reasonable neatness’ in dress contributes to orderly, controlled behavior.” That “reasonable neatness” included ninth- through twelfth-grade boys wearing jacket and tie to school every day, and seventh and eighth graders wearing a jacket or sweater with tie on Thursdays for Meeting for Worship. Students were asked “not to wear blue jeans to school except for work-days, special trips, or on Saturdays.”²⁴ In 1956, the Parents Auxiliary felt it necessary to propose to Scattergood and to the Student Council a set of guidelines for school attire, especially for girls. “Numerous parents” expressed the opinion that GFS’s girls (especially those in the Junior High grades) had made clothing an area of unhealthy competition, noting that there were:</p><blockquote>Too many and too “fancy articles of clothing, especially in reference to blouses, skirts, and petticoats. One young lady is reported to have worn 12 petticoats! Another, so many bracelets that the whole classroom jingled. Overly-conspicuous earrings and shoes were also reported as distractions.</blockquote><blockquote>Those who cannot keep up with the increasing spiral of “What am I going to wear today?” are made unhappy about it, and have their attention drawn away from their school work.<em>²⁵</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4I7dO5SwCztf0lG_UgdJiw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Studying in the library, 1965</figcaption></figure><p>By the late 1960s, though, it was the students who had strong concerns about the school’s dress code. A committee of faculty and students, meeting in late 1968, decided that the school’s dress code should be reduced to: “No specific rules, but sensitivity to the situation and considerateness towards other people should apply at all times.” Scattergood noted in a memo to the school community that “What we are doing is turning over to students the responsibility to develop and practice good taste and good judgement in matters of dress.” He concluded the memo adding that “the faculty was in agreement that they were glad to turn this responsibility over to students, because they do have confidence that students at this school can be trusted to handle matters in a mature and considerate way.”²⁶ In addition to new freedom in dress, the students asked for a voice in making school policies. This led to more unstructured free time for Upper School students, including signing out to leave campus, fewer athletic requirements, and most significantly, two seats for student representatives on the School Committee.</p><p>Eric Johnson had spent the 1968–69 school year teaching in the Virgin Islands. In an article written on his return for <em>Covenant </em>(an inter-school newspaper), he noted that while he was away, “the tides of change rose and swept through the school.” Friends had written to him that the school’s “standards had been abandoned, and the old place was no longer the old place.” While Johnson was startled by the wardrobe changes — he expected “that along with the weird get-ups would go sloppy attitudes, inconsiderate behavior, and general irresponsibility” — he was pleasantly surprised by the changes and the seriousness of the students. He felt that “by giving up our rules about the non-essentials we seem to have converted energy into wrestling with the essentials: intellectual development, community responsibility, and the search for meaning.”²⁷</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dRD6DUifMI3HPhzpiMJo_Q.png" /><figcaption>GFS Upper School students in Market Square, 1969</figcaption></figure><p>The students were not concerned solely with their life on Coulter Street. As in the rest of American society, the war in Vietnam was a focus of activism. On October 15, 1969, GFS students, faculty, and parents participated in the day-long <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moratorium_to_End_the_War_in_Vietnam">Moratorium to End the War in Vietnam</a>. In a letter to parents, Scattergood noted that</p><blockquote>As a Friends school, we expect to devote a part of the morning to learning something of the history and culture of Vietnam, the background of our involvement in the war, and to discussing our response to this both as individuals and as a nation. We will hold a Meeting for Worship that will include a large part of the pupil population, Upper and Lower School, in different Meeting Rooms.</blockquote><p>This would be followed by a silent vigil on the edges of campus, as well as workshops in sign-painting, role-playing for leafletting, and writing letters to Congressmen. Students who did not wish to participate could leave after the morning activities; parents of Upper School students were asked to sign a permission slip for their children to participate in the afternoon activities.²⁸ John Harkins, principal of the Lower School, wrote to parents that there would be age-appropriate programming for the younger students, including “a walk within school grounds to observe the vigil, but not participate in it.” He encouraged parents who wished to join their children to participate more actively in the vigil in order “to express themselves as a family.”²⁹</p><p>By the late 1960s, GFS was both the same school that it had been when Scattergood took the helm in 1954, as well as a product of the social forces that had reshaped American life in the previous 15 years. Van Kalbach, an Episcopal Academy student who arranged to visit GFS for several days in the spring of 1969 gave an outsider’s view of the school in an essay he wrote after the visit:</p><blockquote>At GFS, there is an atmosphere of hard work by and knowledgeable concern of students, leading to awareness. Having coeducation and people of various backgrounds (e.g., six Germantown Community scholars in every class) and a free dress code has made the school loose but not lax. One doesn’t have the impression one is beginning an eight-hour work day when he begins classes at 8:30; I have felt this way often at Episcopal. The students feel more the value of the school for their lives, and they live there while they are in school, not just exist and work there. This does not seem to cut them off from events outside the school, because GFS is the first to admit outside experience is necessary for a rounded upbringing. Whenever possible, it tries to encourage students to get involved outside school. I don’t think GFS is breeding a generation of fakes, either… While I felt it difficult to break into the students’ world, I didn’t feel they treated each other exclusively — I did hear it’s hard to be a conservative, at least openly, there, but probably not as hard as being liberal at [Monsignor] Bonner [High School]. I don’t think the students are mostly potential anarchists. They know the value of a close relationship with others, of concern, and cooperation. They are sometimes disgusted, sometimes superficial in their condemnations. Is this not better than hollow support of another generation’s way of doing things?<em>³⁰</em></blockquote><p>By the beginning of the following school year, Scattergood had decided that he no longer had it in him to lead GFS in this new era. Chris Nicholson, a member of Germantown Meeting who would join the School Committee in 1971, recalled that Scattergood was tired of conflict and of being an administrator.³¹ A young faculty member at the time, Carl Tannenbaum believed that the 1960s clearly overwhelmed Scattergood, and that things had gotten too “loosy-goosy” for his liking.³² Ellie Elkinton, then a teacher at GFS (and who had lived with the Scattergoods at Awbury during the 1968–69 school year), feels that the world got ahead of him; while he loved being in the classroom, he was beleaguered by the youth culture, the marches, the dress code battles, and evening calls from faculty complaining about something.³³ Whatever his reasons, Scattergood tendered his resignation, effective at the end of the 1969–70 school year.</p><p>In his final column in the <em>Bulletin</em>, Scattergood reflected on his time at GFS. He recalled that when he entered the school in 1916 there were 460 students; at his retirement, the enrollment had topped 800. These types of changes were easy to see, he noted, but others were more important. In his time as a student, he felt that “my teachers seemed more concerned with their teaching and the covering of subject matter than with my learning.” The curriculum “encouraged mastering of facts, consistent application, steady work habits and promptness in meeting daily tasks” but that it did not encourage students “to raise questions or range independently over a field of knowledge.”</p><p>In 1970, though, Scattergood saw the value in</p><blockquote>trying to meet the student where he is and in consulting his interests and preferences. Some educators long for the good old days when school life was simpler and more orderly, but despite the problems that accompany greater flexibility and freedom, I think the present climate produces better educated, more mature students.<em>³⁴</em></blockquote><p>While Scattergood realized that the new climate produced better students, he also realized that he was not well-suited to manage that change.³⁵</p><p><strong>Previously: </strong><a href="https://ironyofa.medium.com/the-future-is-yours-rather-than-mine-b7390a547b34">The Future Is Yours Rather Than Mine</a></p><p><strong><em>Notes</em></strong></p><p>1 William R. MacKaye and Mary Anne MacKaye, Mr. Sidwell’s School, A Centennial History 1883–1983, pp. 199–200<br>2 David Mallery’s account is in Alumni Record, June 1954. The School Committee minutes for April 1954 include Evans’s tribute and list of Fowler’s accomplishments.<br>3 The words are David Mallery’s. <br>4 Pastorian, December 1954.<br>5 Henry Scattergood, interview with Bill Koons.<br>6 Irvin C. Poley, Speaking of Teaching, GFS Archives.<br>7 While the report of the Development Committee is noted in contemporaneous records, there is no copy at GFS or in the School Committee records at Haverford College’s Quaker Archives. Queries to various School Committee members, faculty, and administrators has not yielded a copy either. A summary document prepared by Barbara Brecht (Coordinator of Community Projects) in 1971 summarizes the report.<br>8 Philip D. Scranton, “Philadelphia’s Industrial History: Context and Overview,” in Workshop of the World, The Oliver Evans Press, 1390. p . i i<br>9 ibid, p. i i — 8<br>10 Alumni Record, November 1958<br>11 GFS Planning Committee Minutes, June 17, 1963.<br>12 Germantown Courier, Thursday May 6, 1965, p. 1.<br>13 Letter to Members and Attenders of Germantown Monthly Meeting, Seventh month 2, 1963.<br>14 “Our Brother’s Keeper,” editorial in Germantown Courier, September 30, 1965. <br>15 GFS Bulletin, 1965.<br>16 A. Leon Higginbotham, Jr., letter to Henry Scattergood, June 6, 1967, GFS Archives. <br>17 Germantown Friends School Bulletin for Alumni and Parents, Winter 1965.<br>18 GA’s Fort Washington campus would open in September 1965. <a href="https://www.germantownacademy.net/about/history-traditions">https://www.germantownacademy.net/about/history-traditions</a><br>19 Bulletin, Winter 1965<br>20 Bulletin, Winter 1965<br>21 Letter to GFS Community, April 23, 1965, reprinted in the Germantown Courier, May 6, 1965<br>22 Bulletin, Winter 1965.<br>23 Bulletin, Fall 1968.<br>24 Henry Scattergood, typed note for Parents Bulletin, September 27, 1954, GFS Archives.<br>25 “To the Student Council” memo from Parents Auxiliary, November 12, 1956, GFS Archives. <br>26 Memo from Henry Scattergood, January 23, 1969, GFS Archives.<br>27 Eric Johnson “Back to GFS After a Year of Change: Co-Educational trousers, Long Hair and What Else?”, Covenant, November 1969, typed version in GFS Archives.<br>28 Letter to parents, October 9, 1969, GFS Archives.<br>29 Letter to Lower School parents, October 10, 1969,GFS Archives.<br>30 “Germantown Friends School — Summary”, an essay by Van Kalbach, an Episcopal Academy senior who spent several days at GFS in the spring of 1969; GFS Archives.<br>31 Chris Nicholson, interview with Kate Stover &amp; Tim Wood, September 2014, GFS Archives 32 Carl Tannenbaum, interview with Kate Stover, August 2014, GFS Archives<br>33 Ellie Elkinton, interview with Kate Stover, August 2014, GFS Archives<br>34 “From Mr. Scattergood’s Desk”, GFS Bulletin, Spring 1970<br>35 After his retirement from GFS, Scattergood taught history at Penn Charter.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d4c132e4ea78" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Future Is Yours Rather Than Mine]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/the-future-is-yours-rather-than-mine-b7390a547b34?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b7390a547b34</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Apr 2022 17:58:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-04-22T18:00:16.757Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The School Committee is handed a bombshell announcement: the search committee has selected a non-Quaker to be head of the school. Three months into Burton Fowler’s new term, the Japanese bomb Pearl Harbor and the Quaker school plunges into the midst of war. Treading a path that tries to be both patriotic and pacifistic, GFS families welcome European refugee students, both Christian and Jewish, into their homes, and two Japanese-Americans from an internment camp become the first students of color. Shortages of fuel and food challenge the school’s operations.</em></p><p><strong><em>(</em></strong><a href="https://medium.com/p/840551fc7e98/"><strong><em>Introduction to this series</em></strong></a><strong><em>)</em></strong></p><p><strong>The Search Committee would take almost two years</strong> (twenty-two months) before it produced a new head. Meanwhile Stanley Yarnall was still principal. His announced retirement seemed to give him new energy. In a flurry, he bombarded the School Committee, parents, alumni and faculty with special reports, suggestions, surveys, and recommendations. He was determined to set his own record of accomplishment clear, and to give his eventual successor information about not only the school’s philosophy, but its nitty-gritty details: governance, constituency, geographic reach, and so on.</p><p>It might have been easy for Yarnall to decline gently into this twilight, but he did not. His prose was more vigorous and his stance on issues more determined than they had been for several years. If, at times, he seemed defensive or too much protesting, who can blame him? Forty-three years he had given to the school and would give still more.</p><p>Three themes are evident in Yarnall’s writings from 1939 through 1940. The first was his evident pride in the faculty and staff he had assembled. He had kept them together during the hard times of Depression, and he and they had worked together a long time. In 1939, Yarnall hosted a party to celebrate his thirty-year teachers (Burgess and Domincovich) and twenty-five-year teachers: Margaret Alcorn (Primary music), Katherine Dobson (fifth grade), Irvin Poley, Alfred Smith, and Iro Trueblood (who would retire the next year).¹ Even the staff he hired served long tenures. Secretary and later bursar, Georgeanna Dean retired in 1943 after twenty-five years, and Gladys Barkman, whom Yarnall hired in 1924, served as executive secretary until 1963. Chief caretaker George Shelton (hired in 1921) and caretaker Benjamin Boxley (1925) worked for the school for thirty-nine and thirty-eight years respectively.</p><p>It was not just the senior faculty and staff who gave the school many years of service. Many of the younger teachers Yarnall hired would stay long past Master Stanley’s time. Joe Cadbury would retire in 1975; and PE teachers Vera Miller (hired in 1935) and Elizabeth Cadbury (1936) would both retire in 1966. High on a list of Stanley Yarnall’s contributions to GFS is the continuity and stability that came with such committed, long-term teachers and staff members.</p><p>A feature of Yarnall’s hiring practices was the special pleasure he got from appointing GFS alumni to the staff. He never failed to mention this in his annual reports to the Committee, and in 1940 he noted proudly that seven full- time teachers were school graduates.²</p><p>Perhaps because he had been stung by Thomas Shipley’s criticism, Yarnall repeatedly stressed how hard his teachers and staff worked. In 1940, he asked Jane Reilly, the Lower School secretary, to keep track of her activities for a single day, January 11, and presented it to the School Committee without comment.</p><blockquote>“Arrived at school at 8:10a.m. Unlocked closets, Miss Hardy’s desk and regulated heat in the halls. Made out lunch tickets. Received and attended to calls, two, about sick teachers not coming in, and also several calls regarding children who were sick and would not be in.</blockquote><blockquote>A parent came in to explain about a child in first grade who had been absent with a sprained ankle and was not to go to gym nor to recess.</blockquote><blockquote>Rang the bells at 8:40 and 8:45. Miss Comfort [Anna Comfort, Kindergarten teacher 1918 to 1942] too called in regard to a parent’s changing the date and time of conference. Two teachers came in to see Miss Hardy.</blockquote><blockquote>Collected the mail from the front office and saw Mr. Yarnall about being released from a summons to do jury duty. A parent came in to inquire about fourth-grade recess and the best way to get an extra pair of ski pants to a child without disturbing the class. A parent called and wanted information about entering a child in school. Another parent called and asked to have a message delivered about her children going home in the afternoon.</blockquote><blockquote>It was necessary to quiet the children going to and from recess in the halls. Three children came in at various times during the recess period and asked to have minor cuts and skinned knees fixed up.</blockquote><blockquote>Mr. James [Alvin James, PE teacher] to ask for several copies to be done of a list of activities accomplished in boys’ gym work [it should be recalled that this was the era before Xerox machines]. Mr. Burgess came in with a note from Mrs. Maxwell [Genevieve Maxwell, third-grade teacher] which had to be delivered. Helped put up the cots for the second-grade rest period. Got waylaid by a salesman of office equipment whom the front office had asked to come over and see me. Miss Comfort called about another change in a conference date and time.</blockquote><blockquote>Out for lunch 1:00 o’clock until 1:30.</blockquote><blockquote>Back from lunch to deliver two or three messages to children about going home after school. Wrote two letters and took some dictation from Miss Hardy. Two parents came in and changed time and date of their conferences. Went over conference schedule and checked on the times and wrote teachers notes to explain the changes. Wrote Miss Hardy’s letter.</blockquote><blockquote>Miss Porter from Temple called and asked several questions, among them two that had to be relayed to two teachers and answers gotten from them so that I could give the answers to Miss Porter when she called again the following day. Spent the better part of the afternoon cleaning out files, putting away some reports and making up some blue books for the coming parent-teacher conferences. Fixed the homework slips for the absent children and typed and sealed the envelopes to send them home.</blockquote><blockquote>Locked up for the night at 4:30.”</blockquote><p>Regrettably, Stanley Yarnall never wrote a memoir about his years as principal. He was not much of a writer, in fact, although he and Joe Price together wrote a short biography of William Penn, of which Yarnall was very proud. But in 1939 and 1940, Yarnall’s pen was busy setting his record down. He knew he would be remembered for his buildings. He wanted to be remembered for more than that. A second theme in his reports is the extraordinary growth in academic and intellectual standards in the school curriculum and the need to maintain a balance between progressive reforms and a classical education.</p><p>In April 20, 1939, “the largest gathering of Alumni in the history of the School” paid tribute to Yarnall. In his speech, Yarnall developed his theme. “During the depression years,” he said, “while many schools have gone backward, our policy has been one of expansion rather than curtailment. We have steadily enriched our program in administration, particularly in guidance of individual pupils in re-organizing and re-vitalizing our kindergarten, in adding more teachers in departmental fields, in providing extra courses in social studies, geology, paleontology, physical education, public speaking, dramatics and music…All this has not been done without a great deal of thought, planning and a considerable expenditure.” Once again, he singled out the faculty for praise. “The School has never had so strong or experienced a faculty.”</p><p><strong>“What of the future?”</strong> he asked. “The future is yours rather than mine. Naturally you have come to think too much of the man who has been here continuously for a long time. But the man is only a small part of the great whole.” This gesture at modesty out of the way, Yarnall got down to business. He was still a builder at heart. “We must be prepared to reach out to most new educational movements, to provide for new physical needs, to face new problems realistically and to solve them by spiritual forces and practical idealism.” This will require money, some for bricks and mortar, but more for improvements in program. “Many fields are ripe for the harvest had we only greater resources… For instance, we are now on the threshold of marked developments in music and we can visualize a really significant department, well-housed and strongly based.”³</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GlD821R25jJRmCMLmI6n1g.jpeg" /><figcaption>The first student Gilbert &amp; Sullivan production, Trial by Jury, 1932</figcaption></figure><p>It is interesting that Yarnall should single out music in his remarks. He had never been enthusiastic about music in the school. In a December 1932 report to the School Committee he suggested that “the Quaker background of many of our families seems to be a barrier to individual musical efforts.” He had in mind instrumental music, because vocal music was growing quickly under the liberating influence of the Eight-Year Study. The Girls’ Glee Club had become co-educational, and in 1932 Margaret Eaton Shane, with assistance from Poley, staged the first student Gilbert and Sullivan production, <em>Trial by Jury</em>. It was followed in 1933 by <em>Pinafore </em>and so began a long-running G&amp;S tradition. In 1938, Yarnall met with a group of parents who wanted music to be made a major subject in the curriculum. One of those parents, Barbara Rex, later wrote an article, “Music and the School Board,” for <em>The Atlantic Monthly</em>. She recalled the meeting: “We put our case. We talked statistics, schedules, money. I remember we talked our feelings, too — children and music…boys and girls playing together, singing together, carrying all through their lives this music you give them.”⁴ Yarnall raised two objections. Once again he cited “the absence of student musical ability” and worried, too, about finding “time to accomplish real results” on a scale that would suit those parents’ demands. Nevertheless the next year he hired a third music teacher, Joseph Baroni, an instrumental specialist, to join Shane and lower school music teacher Margaret Alcorn.</p><p>Barbara Rex’s <em>Atlantic </em>article appeared in October 1940 just when Yarnall was busiest setting his record down. In it she described how a group of determined and energetic parents could overcome the resistance of even the most conservative educators. Stung, Yarnall fired back. His rebuttal article, “Music in School,” appeared in <em>The Friend </em>in December 1940, and Yarnall had it reprinted in Pamphlet form and distributed widely.</p><p>Politely describing the Rex article as “delightful,” and Rex herself as “an enthusiastic and co-operative parent, who is making a valued contribution to our thinking,” he nonetheless made it clear he thought she was wrong. “It is fair to say that committee Friends and Principal were not as reluctant as imagined. The Quaker caution and canniness was based in this instance, not so much on lack of conviction as to the values involved, as on finding time, without displacing other essential elements in a rounded education and on meeting the requirements of the conservative and exacting colleges to which most of our graduates go…in retrospect the progress through slow and in a way incredible, seems in reality natural and inevitable, as should be characteristic of the procedure of Friends if we really follow true guidance.” It is a little wordy and defensive, but the record supports Yarnall. His report to the School Committee following the 1938 meeting records his sympathy with the music-minded parents and his hope that “the way would open to work out constructive plans.”</p><p>Yarnall listed the strengths of the music program in 1940. Three full-time teachers, “a highly trained intern,” a second, part-time instrumental teacher [Alfred Mann, from Curtis, whose $500 salary was paid for by the parents’ music committee], seven pianos “scattered through the buildings, not to mention those for practice and instruction in the two houses on Coulter Street across from our school,” practice rooms, the Junior Glee Club, the Senior Mixed Chorus, an instrumental club (“which some prefer to dignify with the name of school orchestra”). He placed great emphasis on the “Carnegie Music Set,” a collection of 1,000 “Victrola records” and a 1938 gift from the Carnegie Foundation, which “all of our boys and girls have access to…and use not only in music courses, but in all classrooms of the Lower School and in the history, art, and French classes of the High School.”</p><p>He credited these changes partly to parents’ interests, but mainly to the Eight-Year Study. “All these steps were possible only because of the greater flexibility of student schedules made possible by the Thirty-School Experimental Study… along with the more liberal attitude in the colleges toward the study of the arts in the schools…”</p><p>All this was true, although Yarnall did not mention that the music classes were music history and music Appreciation, not theory or composition, and met only once or twice a week. Nor did he mention that credit earned in music courses did not apply toward a diploma. His own attitude toward the changes remained ambiguous. He approved the growth of music as a major and integral part of the curriculum, but, in a nostalgic aside, he missed the simplicity of earlier days. “Forty-two years ago when I came to Germantown, Jane Raley was singing her gracious, happy way into the hearts and lives of her Kindergarten children, but without a piano. ‘Follow, follow, follow, follow me. I will follow, follow, follow, follow, follow, thee.’ How the simple lines echo in memory.”⁵</p><p><strong>The 1939 Alumni Testimonial Dinner was a grand affair.</strong> Four hundred guests applauded when the president of the Alumni Association presented Master Stanley with a silver pitcher and tray. More gratifying to Yarnall must have been the remarks of the principal speaker that evening, Leonard Carmichael ’17, then the president of Tufts University. Carmichael caught exactly the sentiment Yarnall had expressed time and time again. “In his work in this School, Mr. Yarnall helped his associates on the faculty to accept the best in the new progressive education, but he did this in a way which never sacrificed the essential values of the older classical school attitude and curriculum…The result has been a wise middle course.” In 1939 and 1940, Yarnall was driving that point home to the School Committee. Don’t get carried away with progressive changes, he stated again and again. In describing the changes under the Eight-Year Study, he told the Committee “these advantages have been gained without the loss of true educational values, and without losing our soul.” His reports grew longer the closer retirement loomed, and he sprinkled them with comments from alumni and visitors who backed “a middle course.” He wrote letters to all the recent graduates asking for their reactions to the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight-Year_Study">Eight-Year Study</a> and shared the answers he received with the committee. Here is a typical one in 1939: “Two of our girls from Wellesley said we must not get any more progressive because while they were quite equal to their work and found it stimulating, some students from progressive schools were having great trouble.” Another example, from an unnamed 1936 graduate: “one thing I am thankful for is that we were given homework every night and lots of it.” He distributed to the Committee a letter from a state education official: “I have never been to a school that I liked better. It seems to me to be a conservatively progressive school which is so much better than being radically progressive.”</p><p>These snippets are so frequent and regular that one wonders if Yarnall had got wind of what the Search Committee was up to. Did he know they were focusing their attention on one of the most prominent progressive educators in the country?</p><p>Yarnall had a third theme he emphasized in 1939 and 1940: the necessity for GFS to remain, emphatically, a Friends school. This was not a new theme, of course; Stanley Yarnall had always been a serious and weighty Friend. In this history he has been portrayed only as an educator, but he was also active in larger Quaker affairs. He had been a founding member of the <a href="https://www.friendscouncil.org/">Friends Council on Education</a> and for many years served as a clerk of the Yearly Meeting’s Peace Committee. He had always viewed the school as an essential part of Quaker witness. But there was an additional urgency in his reports and speeches in these years stressing the centrality of spiritual values and religious experience in school life. Most of his testimonial dinner speech, for example, was devoted to this theme, and he ended it with a favorite scriptural citation: “Unless the Lord build the house, they labor in vain who build it. Unless the Lord keep the city, the watchman waketh but in vain.”</p><p>Evidently Yarnall was worried that the school might lose its Quaker character sometime in the future. In his monthly reports to the Committee Yarnall provides hints of such concern. In February 1940 he presented the Committee with the results of a survey he had done of student religious affiliations. It is a revealing document.⁶ Most striking from a present perspective is that only two of the 563 students who responded had no church affiliation. They were overwhelmingly Protestant (there were twenty-nine Jewish students and four Catholics), and, what may have worried Yarnall, there were twice as many Episcopalians (181) as Quakers (90). Presbyterians, too, outnumbered Friends (113). Quaker enrollment was only 6.47% of the student body.</p><p>At the same February meeting, Yarnall presented a second survey listing the residential areas students came from. It demonstrated, as the Committee noted in its annual report to the Monthly Meeting, “we are fast becoming a city school, drawing its client from a widely scattered suburban community.”⁷ In short, the school’s population base in Germantown, and especially in Germantown Meeting, was changing.</p><p>Yarnall had a second worry that he expressed more directly. His senior faculty were largely Friends. As they retired, replacing them with young Friends was proving difficult. In 1940, for example, four teachers retired and one died. All were Quakers, and Yarnall was able to hire only three Friends to replace them.⁸</p><p>As his long tenure drew finally to a close, Master Stanley bombarded the Committee with suggestions and advice.</p><ul><li>They should plan for a new capital campaign.</li><li>The school should increase its contribution to the library.</li><li>Plans should be made to start a bus service.</li><li>The school should purchase the property on the corner of Germantown and Coulter now available “at a low price.” [The property consisted of Staton’s store, a drugstore, and the Coulter Inn; it is now the site of the Sharpless Building]</li></ul><p>It was an impressive performance from an aging man who, a few years earlier, had seemed tired and drained. Yarnall’s energy and vision revived near the end of his principalship, and the school would continue to draw on him in future years.</p><p>On November 25, 1940, at a special meeting of the School Committee, the Search Committee gave its recommendation and report. It was a bombshell.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SgFOmLX6XD_ZG6sZMG8Mkw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Burton Fowler</figcaption></figure><p>The Search Committee consisted of eight members of the School Committee, so, of course, all were Friends. There were no representatives from alumni, parents, or the faculty.⁹ In a progress report sent to the School Committee in February, search chair Margaret Cary had written: “We are unanimous that any person filling this position must be first and foremost a convinced member of the Society of Friends and that the reason for the existence of the school is because it is a Friends’ School rather than as an excellent private school.” Now the Search Committee announced its choice: Burton P. Fowler — a Presbyterian.</p><p><strong>There must have been many astonished faces</strong> in the Committee room that evening. There must have been many who were disappointed and probably upset that, for the first time in its history, GFS would have a principal who was not a Quaker. “Must have been” rather than “was” because the official minute of the meeting was, as usual, brief and veiled. It read, “Although many expressed sincere regret that there was not at present a member of the Society of Friends who could satisfactorily fill the position, the Committee, with but one exception, approved the recommendation and requested that he be invited to take the position at the beginning of the school year 1941–1942.” He was offered a three-year contract and a salary of $12,000.</p><p>The controversy, if such it was, surrounding Fowler’s appointment had a happy result for the historian. The Committee asked Margaret Cary to prepare two reports explaining her Search Committee’s recommendation. The first would be kept private, for the eyes of the School Committee only; the second, and less candid, report would be published. Together the Cary reports give insight into the search process and serve as an introduction of Burton Fowler.¹⁰ In her published report, Cary described how the search team did its homework. They surveyed the needs of the school from top to bottom (“its problems, its opportunities, its future,” particularly the school’s “shifting population centre”), consulted closely with Yarnall, Hardy, and Burgess (Poley, of course, was a candidate), and interviewed twenty-three faculty and all members of the School Committee. “We took careful notes at all these interviews which often lasted whole afternoons.” Evidently no parents or alumni were interviewed. The committee then developed a profile of the man they wanted (and only men were considered). He should be a Quaker, a “first class educator, a man recognized as a leader in Secondary Education,” someone the Committee could work with (“a man fully and deeply convinced of the value of decisions reached after careful group thinking”). Most of all, “he must be a man’s man.”</p><p>Privately Cary told the School Committee that they had found three men who fit the profile, two of them Quakers. The first was president of a junior college, well regarded in educational circles, and very attractive. But investigation discovered he was not an active Friend. That reason, even more than his lack of secondary school experience, disqualified him. The second finalist, described as a “distinctly coming person,” was Henry Scattergood. Interviewed sixty years later, Scattergood was astonished. He had no memory of even being interviewed for the job (although he was) and could scarcely credit that he had been a finalist in the search. He had just completed his M.A. at Harvard and was teaching at the Shady Hill School in Cambridge, Massachusetts when the committee approached him. “He made a strong and virile appeal to the Committee,” Cary wrote, but they finally decided he was a shade too young. It would appear, however, that the committee had decided on Fowler’s successor before they had decided on Fowler.</p><p>The Search Committee focused on Fowler early in the process. He was fifty- three years old and the headmaster of the Tower Hill School in Wilmington. Several committee members had met him during the Eight-Year Study when, as president of the Progressive Education Association, he had visited, spoken, and consulted at GFS on several occasions. Several faculty members knew him as well. Burgess and Domincovich, for example, had both served on P.E.A. committees with him. Fowler had another connection to the school. Yarnall had just hired Fowler’s daughter, Mary, as assistant teacher in the four-year- old Kindergarten.</p><p><strong>It is not hard to see why Fowler interested the committee.</strong> He was a distinguished and experienced administrator. Born in South Butler, New York in 1887, he had earned degrees from Syracuse (A.B.) and Columbia (A.M.) and had been awarded an honorary doctorate by Syracuse in 1929. He had been principal of several public high schools in New York and had moved to Tower Hill in 1923 after five years as principal of Central High School in Cleveland, Ohio. Except for the fact he was not a Quaker, he fit the Search Committee profile perfectly. He had a national reputation. In addition to two terms as P.E.A. president, he was an official of the National Council on Education, a frequent speaker at national and international conferences (“in Locarno, Geneva, and Elsinor” Cary noted), and was a trustee of Sarah Lawrence College. He was also, Cary assured the Committee, “a deeply religious man of the highest ideals,” an elder in his church allied “with the finest and most progressive thinking it stands for”, and “deeply sympathetic” to Friends. The Search Committee had evidently solicited a letter on the point from Fowler, and Cary excerpted it in both the public and private reports. Fowler wrote: “The ideals of Friends attract me greatly. It seems to me that during the critical years ahead they give America and the individual citizen something to steer by… The chief challenge to living now is for me the chance to work with congenial spirits in the task of creating a better democracy. And I know of no group that cares so much for this as Friends.” He was even reading several books on Quakerism, Cary reported privately. Finally, the published report addressed the questions directly and tried to shift responsibility for keeping up the Quaker character of GFS. “Our determination to have the school remain a truly Quaker School is even more sincere than when we started our long quest over two years ago. That we are appointing a non-Quaker makes all the more clear to us as it must to you that by your own sincerely Friendly way of life we must help and uphold Burton Fowler’s hands. We are convinced that if the School becomes less of a Friends’ School than it is today, it will be so because those of us on the Committee and Faculty and among our parents and students have failed to demonstrate this way of life to Burton Fowler.”</p><p>Fowler was well-aware of the controversy. In a revealing letter to School Committee clerk Thomas Shipley he confessed to only one misgiving about accepting the job: “The fact that I am not a Friend.” He told Shipley he was concerned by “the possible and wholly understandable lack of faith of your community in me as an outsider.”¹¹</p><p>If it is easy to see Fowler’s attraction to the Search Committee (gaining a man of his reputation would be a coup.) It is less easy to understand why the job attracted Fowler. Tower Hill was a prominent, respected, and well-endowed school with a progressive reputation. DuPont money had helped build a beautiful campus on the edge of Wilmington. Why leave such a place to come to a crowded block in Germantown to a school with no endowment at all? Cary hinted in the private report that he felt frustrated at Tower Hill. “He believes that if he came to GFS he would have greater opportunity to develop in parents and pupils a carryover of his ideals than he can in the wealthier and more homogeneous group at Tower Hill.”</p><p>After he arrived at GFS, Fowler said all the expected things to parent groups and alumni about his attraction to the school: the Quaker tradition, supportive parents, devoted alum, etc. To Thomas Shipley he had been a little more candid. He wanted to head an urban school of moderate size, with a good reputation for excellence and stability, and he wanted to make that school a force for social change. Irving Poley later recalled him as a man of tremendous energy always bursting with plans and ideas, “maybe four or five a month” of which perhaps two would get done.¹² Fowler did not outline his ideas specifically in the Shipley letter, writing only vaguely about “service” and “democracy,” but it is clear he had an agenda in mind and that the Search Committee knew it. Events would prove that at least one item on the agenda was racial integration.</p><p>Fowler also made it clear to the Committee clerk that he was of independent mind. After assuring Shipley that he would not embarrass the Committee and would “faithfully support” Quaker beliefs, he pointedly noted that he did not share them all. He specifically cited his conviction about war as an example of disagreement. He concluded his letter by describing his management style: “While my whole policy of school management is one of democratic-sharing based on full discussion with all concerned, the Committee, the Faculty, the parents, and the students, nevertheless it would be my prerogative to make final decisions regarding administrative problems, and that any such problems that may be brought to the attention of individual members of the Committee should first be referred to me before any plan of action is discussed.” If Stanley Yarnall ever read this letter, and he almost certainly did, he would at least have agreed with this last statement.</p><p>The School opened with its new principal on September 17, 1941. Eighty- two days later the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor and the United States entered World War II.</p><p>The storm clouds had been building for years, of course, and GFS people, like all Americans, had looked on anxiously as the world went mad. Students wrote worried essays in <em>The Pastorian </em>about events in China; Lucinda Iliff and Joseph Price added the study of contemporary affairs to their history courses. The parochialism, even innocence that characterized the school on the eve of earlier wars was notably absent in the late thirties.</p><p><strong>More important, the school had taken action.</strong> In March 1939, the school agreed to a request from international refugee agencies to take in Jewish children fleeing the Nazi Holocaust. The first to arrive was “a boy named Weigl from Vienna” [John W. Weigl ’43] and by the end of the year there were four refugee children in the school. Each year thereafter more refugee children arrived. In October 1940, Yarnall reported that the numbers had grown to fifteen. They came from England, Scotland, South Africa, Czechoslovakia, Belgium, Sweden, and Austria. Many were Quakers, but Christian and non- Christian faiths were represented. Some had family in the United States and means to pay tuition fees, but half did not. GFS families opened their homes to them, and Yarnall looked for scholarships to help to pay for the others. For most, the school absorbed the expenses. Marjorie Hardy reported on the progress of one Kindergartener: “The latest newcomer is a French-speaking four-year-old boy who is rapidly learning English, and, we hope, forgetting the eight weeks of fleeing with his parents from France through Norway; often hiding in ditches to avoid bombs as they fled.”</p><p>Another action the school took before Pearl Harbor was to join with other Germantown institutions to form a civil defense team. Fire drills were stepped up and evacuation plans perfected. The Parents’ Auxiliary sponsored classes in first aid and home nursing for students, parents, and faculty. By the time Burton Fowler arrived at Coulter Street, the school had scheduled frequent air-raid drills, created a student Air Raid Precaution Committee, and stored buckets of sand at every level and corner of the school for emergency use.</p><p>The contrast with the GFS reaction to World War I is striking. There were no disputes about displaying the flag or buying war bonds, fewer debates about how displays of patriotism compromised Friends’ principles. The school engaged the issues of World War II forthrightly. In February 1942, the school issued a statement for parents and alumni titled “Germantown Friends School and the Present National Emergency,” written by Committee member Edward Evans and signed by Fowler. It reiterated the Quaker commitment against war and pledged anew the Friends belief in nonviolence. But it also recognized the Quaker commitment to help those victimized by war and pledged the school would do its part in helping the afflicted. Evans and Fowler promised GFS would give its full energy supporting non-violent actions to defeat militarism and fascism.</p><p>After Pearl Harbor, the school turned to non-violent service with fervor.</p><p>Students volunteered in local hospitals (“the only way you can wear a uniform,” said <em>The Pastorian</em>), raised money for relief agencies, planted a <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victory_garden">Victory Garden</a>, wrote letters to soldiers overseas, hosted alumni in the service when they returned to school for a visit (“What about it girls? Didn’t Jimmy Kidder look too, too divine in those navy blues,” <em>The Pastorian</em>, 1943), and worried about their futures. The draft took boys into the service at age eighteen. The school set up a special committee to advise students on the technicalities of the draft and conscientious objection. Some male students took summer school courses in order to graduate early. A few were eager to fight. In 1945, for example, six senior boys graduated early to join the war.</p><p>Most of the faculty were too old to enlist, and most were, in any case, conscientious objectors, but four did. The three men who enlisted or were drafted were Alfred Mann (music teacher), Alvin James (PE), and William Goodell, the forge-builder. Susan Erwin, a French teacher, joined in the WAVES (“This isn’t meant to be a fashion revue, but who could help but notice how studding Lieutenant Erwin looked in her uniform; that silver star looked awfully nice, too,” <em>The Pastorian</em>, 1943).</p><p><strong>For Burton Fowler, the war presented his first challenge</strong>, and he seems to have relished it. He was faced with a dozen problems every day. There were fuel shortages, gasoline and tire shortages (“over 600 of us manage to ride, walk, or pedal our way every morning”), food shortages, and salary freezes. The alarms didn’t work; the school buildings needed repair; and, always, there was a conflict between children and adults that is at the heart of any school any day.</p><p>Most of his energies were spent on day-to-day activities (the coal bins outside Mr. Breininger’s room overflowed today), but sometimes he reflected more generally on the war’s effect. In January 1943 he wrote:</p><blockquote>Not school as usual, but school at its best has been our announced policy for the year. The faculty and students together are undertaking to find out in this world-shattering year of 1942 what that means.</blockquote><blockquote>General Summerall recently announced that ‘Every classroom should become a citadel — that all non-war objectives should be stripped from education.” I believe this is a mistake… is education to be one of the most tragic casualties of this war? If this war is to be worth winning, we must have at its conclusion more than a generation trained to fight.<em>¹³</em></blockquote><p>The Victory Garden was a favorite Fowler topic. In the backyard at historic <a href="https://www.philalandmarks.org/grumblethorpe">Grumblethorpe</a>, younger GFS students planted and harvested spinach, corn, beans, beets, turnips, onions, and potatoes for the school lunchroom. “Since rationing has cut sharply into our usual food supplies, possibly as much as one- third, the school garden is no mere gesture but an essential industry.”¹⁴</p><p>Fowler talked a lot about “democracy” in schools in his first years at GFS, and at first no one really knew what he meant by that. They got a hint in the following:</p><ul><li>February 1944. The Student Council says that it wants to put a plaque in the front hall honoring war veterans.</li><li>March 1944. The School Committee objects to the plaque. It will “conflict with the pacifist attitude of a Quaker school.</li></ul><p>Fowler convened a meeting of School Committee members and students to work out a compromise. Edward Evans, for the Committee, and student leader John Fernberger finally hashed out a compromise. There would be no plaque. Instead, students would send a greeting to all GFS veterans of the War, and an inscribed copy of that letter would be displayed in the Front Hall.</p><p>This was a typical GFS tempest. But it is revealing of Burton Fowler’s style of leadership, as well as a more accommodating position by Quakers. Dialogue was established, grounds for compromise laid clear, and resolution managed peacefully and civilly. It would not always be possible to achieve resolution so neatly.</p><p><strong>Fowler was a complicated man.</strong> He was an educational radical and a Republican. He wore double-breasted suits, smoked cigars, and looked and acted like the embodiment of the establishment, but he had a genuinely progressive vision of education. He wanted to give students the power to shape their own lives, but he also demanded that they take responsibility for their actions.</p><p>He was always a presence in the front hall, his double-breasted suit usually open and flapping, button–holing students and faculty alike to discuss something urgent. “He was a hands-on headmaster,” Betty Cary recalled. He was not a pacifist, and he did not oppose war on principle, but he took a careful stance on World War II, as fitted the non-Quaker head of a Friends School. Still it brought him into a conflict with his Quaker overseers.</p><p>In the spring of 1942, for example, Fowler permitted a Navy Lt. Commander to address the student body about the advantages of college officer training courses (NROTC). The School Committee objected but, after consideration, a compromise was worked out. The Committee agreed “that both sides of the question of pacifism should be put before them” [i.e. students], and that the Society of Friends “should not appear to be propagandizing for pacifism.” The Committee even stated as policy that “attendance at any talks on pacifism should be purely voluntary…”</p><p>Fowler did not take advantage of that concession. Not long after Lt. Commander Hartenstein’s speech, Steve Cary ’33 was invited to speak to students about his experience in <a href="https://civilianpublicservice.org/">Civilian Public Service</a> camps. Thereafter, and throughout the war, students heard a balanced set of speakers — although, it must be said, the balance favored the Quaker view.</p><p>GFS continued to welcome refugees from the war. In 1942, President Roosevelt’s Executive Order 9066 created a new set of refugees: Japanese Americans who, solely because of their ethnic origin, were judged to be dangerous to American security. They were summarily sent to relocation centers, which critics labeled concentration camps.</p><p>Friends were outraged and worked hard to reverse the government policy. Unable to overcome the racism, paranoia, and opportunism that created the policy, Quakers took advantage of a provision in the law that allowed respectable people outside the declared “Pacific war zone” to sponsor the release of some Japanese Americans interned in the camps.</p><p>In December 1943, GFS accepted and gave full scholarships to two Japanese American teenagers from the <a href="https://encyclopedia.densho.org/Jerome/">Relocation Center in Jerome, Arkansas</a>. They entered the eleventh grade. It was an historic moment. John Masai and Richard Hagashi were the first students in GFS history who were not white. They both lived with GFS families, Masai with the Willets and Hagashi with the Henry Evans family, and took regular courses in the school. Like several of their new classmates, Masai and Higashi were on special accelerated programs designed to allow them to graduate early and enter national service.¹⁵ Reflecting on their experiences for their Commencement Papers, Higashi wrote “Relocation Camp” and Masai wrote “Japanese- Americans Adrift.” As GFS’s first graduates of color, they should be counted among the school’s significant alumni.¹⁶ Higashi, in particular, left a record at the school. Fowler declared him the school’s “best violinist,” and <em>The Pastorian </em>blamed the baseball team’s mediocre record in 1944 on the fact that “Dick” had left school to join the military. Their presence and success added considerably to a growing demand that the school drop the color line in its admissions.</p><p>Germantown Friends had become uncomfortable with racial exclusiveness even before the war. While the school had no stated policy excluding people of color, “everyone understood” that was the policy. On rare occasions, a student would write an article for <em>The Pastorian </em>mildly questioning the school’s position, but there had been no serious challenge to the color line until 1938. That year an African American girl (perfectly qualified otherwise, the Admissions Committee reported) applied and was turned down. The School Committee anguished long and hard over the decision. The girl was qualified; the Society of Friends professed belief in racial equity; and Friends had always worked for social tolerance — all that was admitted by the Admissions Committee (all Friends from the School Committee). But, the admissions Friends said, we have an obligation to stewardship. We cannot in conscience take a stand that might jeopardize the school. The admission of African Americans could, and we think will, lead to withdrawals and a drop in applicants. We cannot risk the future of the school, they concluded, until “the way opens” for greater racial understanding.</p><p>It was not a brave moment for the School Committee. They accepted the rejection. They had held the school together through the Depression and were cautious about any action that might jeopardize their labor. War was looming, too, and who know what that might portend? But there was real unease in confirming the color line.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*cfJoz9j3A2ael2CHmpWiLw.png" /><figcaption>Margaret Cary</figcaption></figure><p>Margaret Cary asked to have a letter entered into the minutes, such was her anguish. While reluctantly agreeing with the decision (“We have no moral right to jeopardize the financial and therefore the educational set up of the school”), she was clearly tortured. “If we are Quakers, we must, however, believe that ‘There is that of God in every man.’ This is a bed-rock Quaker principle. I believe we can neither honestly nor logically discriminate against any race or color. As members of the Meeting…[and faculty, staff, and student body]… I believe that we must slowly educate ourselves so that we may reach a place where we will be willing to embark on an educational experiment in racial understanding…”</p><p>Cary, it should be recalled, was clerk of the Search Committee that recommended Burton Fowler, and Fowler was deeply committed to racial integration. John Masai and Richard Higashi were a great help to Fowler and others who wanted to erase the color line.</p><p>Finally, in 1947 the school announced in the <em>Alumni Record</em> that there would be a “broadening” of the school’s “admissions policy, to admit a few highly qualified applicants of minority groups not now represented” and noted that GFS would be the seventh private school in Philadelphia to do so. One Black student, a four-year-old boy, was admitted to the four-year Kindergarten that fall. At least one Black student was admitted each year in subsequent classes. In 1949, the first Black student teacher worked at GFS.</p><p><strong>“I’m going to graduate today.</strong> Funny, it doesn’t seem like twelve years, it’s all gone so terribly quickly, all the little things that made up my school life,” Connie Wiltberger ’42 wrote in the May 1942 issue of <em>The Pastorian. </em>Her essay is a reminder to us that the shadow of war did not eclipse all the joy of school life. There was still laughter and fun at GFS during the war years. Students larked about, joked, made fun of teachers, and were silly. She made only one oblique reference to the war and that was about volunteer nursing (“in the unbecoming pink outfits from Jones’s for $2.25). Otherwise her delightful essay recalls the happy inconsequential of school life.</p><ul><li>Like always having to dash to get in before the first bell rang in the morning.</li><li>And standing in line eons of time for one hamburger with relish. The lunchroom was always a center of activity, all the different grades from gangly children in stiff pigtails to lanky seniors in glamour bobs.</li><li>Cliques of us draped artistically over the front steps, soaking up the sun and conjugating Latin verbs or reciting French idioms.</li><li>Our class meetings where everybody had an opinion and voiced it at length.</li><li>The bedlam that was the front hall table and daily despair of the office force.</li></ul><p>Connie Wiltberger’s reminiscence should strike true for generations of alumni. The names would change as years passed, but not the sentiments. “Oh, the fun in all the classes. Boners that people have pulled, amusing things that teachers have said. Mr. Price philosophizing on life and conditions… Mr. Domi reading the drunken porter scene in <em>Macbeth </em>or ‘Is this a dagger I see before me?’ Class discussions in English about current affairs always ending in a quarrel.”</p><p>Students and faculty were enlisting in the armed forces or choosing non- violent service; the school was on short rations for food, coal, and gasoline; and news from the war front was very bad in May of 1942, but Wiltberger stressed the normal, the ordinary. Life at GFS would go on day by day until “Commencement” (the title of her essay). “The boys in white flannels and blue coats, the girls in misty white armfuls of flowers. Two by two, up the aisle flanked by familiar faces and suppressed murmuring. We’re graduating — the class of ’42.”¹⁷</p><p>For teachers, the creation of the normal and ordinary school life was more difficult. The war distracted students from their work, excited their emotions, and threatened to disrupt the whole tenor of life in school dedicated to peace and non-violence. The faculty, like Fowler and the School Committee, had to wrestle hard with the conflict between Quaker principles and the widely held belief that World War II was a good war.</p><p>The experience of a Lower School teacher serves as a good example of faculty efforts to contain the war’s impact in the classroom. Caroline Narvel was a second-grade teacher at GFS during the war, and in December 1943 wrote a report to Marjorie Hardy about her class.¹⁸ “At the beginning of the term,” she reported the eighteen second graders “were so enthusiastic over war planes that the room was literally swamped with them. Pictures were brought in and all our conversations centered about planes seen this summer guarding the coastline or about relatives flying in war zones. It seemed that our entire year was to be spent in imagining a serial combat.”</p><p>Determined to resist this emphasis on militarism but recognizing that “it is impossible to obliterate any intense interest just by ignoring the situation,” Narvel despaired. “The problem is to turn the enthusiasm into worthwhile channels,” she wrote. The solution she devised was to turn students’ interests to aviation in general. She read a book (<em>Timmy Rides the China Clipper</em>) about a young boy flying alone to Hong Kong. “We all envied Timmy and wished we, too, could take such a trip,” she reported. A class project was launched. Maps were drawn, books about airplanes were consulted in the library, TWA air schedules were studied, and a time and route planned. “For days no one had mentioned the war or combat planes. We were too involved in the intricacies of aerial travel.”</p><p>Teachers writing reports almost always belabor the obvious, and Narvel was no exception. She listed at great lengths the skills learned by students from this study: research skills, geography, money management, and arithmetic involving miles and time zones. She concluded, “Since ours is a Democracy, the greatest value of all is that we are learning to plan and work happily together towards a common goal.”</p><p>A contemporary educator might question the wisdom of much of this. Should students be diverted from a study of a serious, and deeply felt, problem to one less troublesome? Is Narvel’s notion of democracy correct? But such questions are irrelevant here. Narvel’s experience illustrates well the way GFS tried to deal with war in the classroom, and of course, she was teaching second graders.</p><p><strong>As the war dragged on, students intensified their community services.</strong> By 1944, thirty girls were serving in area hospitals; other students were raising money for the Community Chest and the Red Cross, collecting toys for the Friends Neighborhood Guild, or working at the Germantown Settlement- sponsored Tot Lot. Friends’ weekend work camps, helping the poor and unfortunate in Philadelphia neighborhoods, were strongly attended. So busy were students that, in 1943, the infamous Information Tests were omitted for the first time since 1907. No room in the schedule for the Information Test? It was incredible! Not even the cheap, paperback version of the annual Blue and White yearbook that year could be better witness of the war’s impact.</p><p>In 1944, the tide of war shifted. Allied forces eventually crushed Nazi Germany, and Burton Fowler faced a dilemma. For his civic contributions, he had been invited to participate in a <a href="https://digital.library.temple.edu/digital/collection/p15037coll3/id/49593/rec/6">VE day celebration at City Hall.</a> Would the School Committee permit it? It would indeed.</p><p>The decision was an endorsement of Fowler’s leadership during the war. He had directed a school which professed pacifism and gave full voice to its witness, but at the same time did not preach it exclusively. Fowler’s leadership produced a school that worked hard at providing public service opportunities for its students. The tone of the school seemed, to the School Committee, consistent with the broad beliefs of peace and brotherhood that underlay a faithful Friends School. The non-Friend who had replaced the legendary Master Stanley had succeeded masterfully in just three years.</p><p>Master Stanley had not yet disappeared and still had a role to play. “The future is yours, rather than mine” he had said, and he meant it. He never interfered or publicly voiced disagreement with Burton Fowler, although he must have disagreed with many of Fowler’s actions. He was a frequent, but benign, presence at the school after his retirement. Walking slowly to Fifth Day Meeting, his cane tapping along the walk, and then sitting on the facing bench in repose, a dignified, grave Quaker presence — he probably terrified the next generation of GFS students.</p><p>Yarnall had proposed in his last list of suggestions that the school launch a new, big, important capital campaign. In 1944, the school acted on his suggestion.</p><p><strong>It was an extraordinary decision.</strong> The war was not over; there had been no survey of the school’s potential resources; and there was not even a plan in place to show where the school would use the money. But after VE Day, GFS, along with the rest of the nation, took new hope and could look to the future.</p><p>Edward Evans was now clerk of the Advisory Committee, and in October 1944 he sent to the Monthly Meeting a proposal to raise $100,000 to $150,000 for expansion of the school. The proposal was short on details, and the Meeting reacted coolly, but provisionally approved. They wanted no new buildings on their grounds, however.</p><p>The campaign would coincide with the Centennial Celebration described earlier. That weekend celebration would prove to be a great success, but the capital campaign was not. On the day alumni, faculty, and students mingled in celebration of one hundred years of school history and to view the tableaux in the gym, visit classes, hear music and watch spectacles, less than half the proposed campaign goal had been reached. And the weekend celebration did not prompt many of the guests to open their wallets.</p><p>There were at least three reasons. First, and most important, GFS had never had great benefactors. There had been Alfred Cope long ago, but no one since. Irvin Poley was generous, but his fortune was modest, and there was no one else in the alumni, school, or Meeting capable or willing to give the large sums that give a capital campaign impetus. It is a continuing refrain through the school history. GFS has done much with very little financial backing.</p><p>The other problems were more specific. This fund drive had no focus. As Evans framed it, the money raised was for “expansion and endowment” and givers were not moved by such vague goals. Then there was the problem of leadership. Dale Purves ’19 was the campaign director, but his business interest took him away frequently, and he had to resign his directorship.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ywnqCKU2jXQ5lyAfD8iI_Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Square Club, which would become the Alumni Building after its purchase by the school</figcaption></figure><p>Fowler pointed the way to a solution. The Square Club, across Coulter Street, was once again for sale. During the war it had been used by employees of the Bendix Corporation as a recreation center, an improvement, from the School’s viewpoint from its earlier incarnations as German social club and Democratic Party headquarters. There was a four-lane bowling alley in the basement and a basketball court on the second floor. The building could be purchased for about $30,000, and its purchase became the target of the campaign. Now styled the “Alumni Building” (because alumni contributed most to the Centennial campaign), it is still an integral part of the campus and home to the history and Classics departments.</p><p>The question then was who should direct the final drive aimed at acquiring the Alumni Building?</p><p>The school asked Stanley Yarnall, and he agreed. It was a beautiful, even symmetrical choice. It would round out Yarnall’s long service to the school. Master Stanley, the builder, would close his association with GFS on yet another building. He would complete a capital drive he had proposed in his last years, and he would help acquire a building he had coveted and recommended for purchase.</p><p>Stanley Yarnall had passed the torch to new leaders with grace and dignity. Worn down though he was, he must have felt regret when he retired. He had created a fine school, and it was “his school.” His successor was brilliant, popular, acclaimed — but, when disaster threatened, it was Master Stanley the school turned to for help. For Stanley Yarnall, the last fund drive must have been eminently satisfying.</p><p><strong>Next: </strong><a href="https://ironyofa.medium.com/henry-scattergood-son-of-the-meeting-d4c132e4ea78">Henry Scattergood: A Son of the Meeting</a><strong><br>Previously:</strong> <a href="https://ironyofa.medium.com/irvin-corson-poley-master-teacher-bfe0573fda90">Irvin Corson Poley: Master Teacher</a></p><p><strong><em>Notes</em></strong></p><p>1 For some reason, Emma Roberts (1903–1940) was left out.</p><p>2 Yarnall did not list the names of the seven alumni, but he must have meant Poley ’08; Margaret Shane ’18; Lucinda Iliff ’20; Elizabeth Cadbury ’24; Elizabeth Stetson ’25; William Goodell ’26; and Allen Stokes ’32; who replaced Iro Trueblood in 1940.</p><p>3 <em>Alumni Record</em>, June 1, 1939, pp. 1 and 4.</p><p>4 <em>The Atlantic Monthly</em>, October 1940.</p><p>5 <em>The Friend</em>, Twelfth Month, 12, 1940.</p><p>6 The survey’s figures, as recorded in the Committee minutes, are: Episcopal 181, Presbyterian 113, Friends 90, Lutheran 35, Jewish 29, Unitarian 25, Methodist 23, Baptist 6, Roman Catholic, Congregational 3, Christian Science 2, Reformed 2, Protestant 2, New Thought 1, Universalist 1, none 1, not given 1.</p><p>7 The survey of residence: Queen Lane to Mt. Airy Avenue, 334; Mt. Airy Avenue through Chestnut Hill, 113; North of Chestnut Hill, 39; West of Germantown and Chestnut Hill, 16; East of Germantown and Chestnut Hill, 42; Queen Lane to Wayne Junction 22; Olney and Frankford 5; “Town”, 12. Total: 583. School Committee Minutes, February 1, 1940. The quotation is from Annual Report to Monthly Meeting, October 4, 1940, filed with Monthly Meeting minutes in Haverford College Quaker Collection.</p><p>8 The retirees (and the year they started at GFS) were Emma Roberts (1903), Iro Trueblood (1914), Esther Arnold (1918) and Evelyn Wood (1922). Primary teacher Anne Maxfield died in 1940. The Friends appointed to replace them were Allen Stokes (1940–1945), Kathryn Kerlin (1940–1943), and Mary Ritter (1940–1942).</p><p>9 Search Committee members included the weightiest Friends on the School Committee: Margaret M. Cary, long clerk of the Advisory Committee, was clerk. The others were School Committee clerk Thomas E. Shipley; Bernard Waring, treasurer and clerk of the Finance Committee; Morris E. Leeds, former clerk of the Committee; Hadassah M. Leeds; Gertrude M. Woodruff; William E. Cadbury; and John A. Silver, who would replace Waring as treasurer in 1941. <em>Alumni Record</em>, April 15, 1942, p.1.</p><p>10 Margaret Cary’s report to the School Committee is filed with the Committee minutes, between pages 146 and 147 in volume N 4 19.3 in the Haverford Quaker Collection. The published version, which is substantially different, appeared in the <em>Alumni Record</em>, April 15, 1941.</p><p>11 The letter is dated December 23, 1940. In School Committee minutes.</p><p>12 Poley’s remarks are quoted by Eric Johnson the <em>GFS Bulletin</em>, Spring 1972, GFS Archives.</p><p>13 <em>Alumni Record</em>, January 26, 1943, GFS Archives.</p><p>14 <em>Alumni Record</em>, April 15, 1943, GFS Archives.</p><p>15 In the class of 1945’s graduation photo, Higashi, Masai, and eight of their classmates are represented by individual portrait photographs attached across the top of the traditional photo of the graduating class on the front steps of Main Building.</p><p>16 In the Class of 1945’s June Commencement program, it is noted that Higashi (along with several others) received his diploma in January, and both he and Masai are listed in the class roll. Interestingly, neither Higashi nor Masai are listed in GFS alumni directories published in 1982, 1989, 1994, and 2000; they appear as alumni in 2012 edition, however.</p><p>17 <em>The Pastorian</em>, May 1942 and Alumni <em>Record</em>, April 15, 1943.</p><p>18 Narvel was on the staff only three years, from 1942 to 1945.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b7390a547b34" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Service, Reflection, and Joy]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/service-reflection-and-joy-89e0f61cdd89?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/89e0f61cdd89</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[k-12-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[services]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[schools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 26 Jan 2022 23:40:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-26T23:40:02.748Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Mia Adams, Grade 10 at Germantown Friends School, shares reflections from her school’s Martin Luther King Day of Service</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Wo0GaisYHIxzuPJBK-2WeQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Art with Teacher Lili</figcaption></figure><p>For 26 years, GFS has celebrated and honored the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. with an annual Day of Service. Held virtually for the second year in a row, this important day gave students, faculty, and staff the opportunity to collaborate with organizations and community members in Germantown, and throughout the city of Philadelphia. GFS Director of Community Engagement Dr. Zarah Adams’ goal was to provide a space to increase community projects in art, sustainability, and education, by co-leading initiatives with universities and neighborhood associations. We saw that goal come to fruition earlier this month.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*k6Hd3uyrvMQCh0lh9STqFw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Dr. Zarah Adams, Director of Community Engagement, sharing donations with community partners.</figcaption></figure><p>This year’s Day of Service theme, “Combatting Racism and Building Community,” presented several opportunities for students and families. Individuals created snack bags and toiletry kits for the Face to Face mission in Germantown. GFS even surpassed its goal of 200 bags with the help of local organization AmeriHealth Caritas and several boy scout troops. Students Ethan Young ’23 and Oscar Schwartz ’23, leaders of the Upper School Community Engagement Club, facilitated a virtual session for the kit assembly. Families also donated gently-used children’s clothing to Cradles to Crayons; and new hats, gloves, and socks to Covenant House in Germantown.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/720/1*44GwbsCCRWx3w9_LI5UViw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Charles Ellison, WURD Radio</figcaption></figure><p>Reflection was the primary goal of the day, which began with keynote speaker Charles D. Ellison of <em>WURD</em> radio. The award-winning journalist, host, and executive producer of “Reality Check,” spoke about the strategies used by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. to create change. Ellison noted, “[MLK Day of Service] is a day to reflect on the fight before us…to reclaim the power that King, and many others like him, fought and died for.” He encouraged students to follow Dr. King’s legacy by getting involved in local politics and standing against social injustices observed in their neighborhoods.</p><p>GFS health teacher Maryanne Rawlings facilitated a discussion on “Mindfulness and Just Relationships,” which revolved around the “universality of emotions”; Upper School Students Beier Nelson ’22 and Neil Bennet ’22 discussed how communities responded to the pandemic; and Dr. Molefi K. Asante, author and professor of African Studies at Temple University, facilitated a session on “Serving Humanity.”</p><p>We also found joy! Herb Scott, chef and owner of Herb Scott Catering in Germantown, led a virtual cooking class, which could compete with any show broadcast on the Cooking Channel. Herb cooked grilled vegetables, buttermilk fried chicken, and macaroni and cheese, and shared cooking tips learned from his father.</p><p>Lower School art teacher and Germantown Monthly Meeting member, Lili Sharpless, led an art lesson for young students, who traced their hands and created colorful words in reflection of Dr. King.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*j-ye_Og5j9qjrPT4Q-HjfQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Christopher Li ’22 and Zoe Schaedle ’22 discussed music and artists from the civil rights movement. Participants learned about the stories behind songs written and performed by artists like Nina Simone.</p><p>GFS Director of Library Services Kate Garrity, and several volunteers, read stories about Dr. King and the civil rights movement, namely <em>The Year we Learned to Fly </em>by Jacqueline Woodson. For those unable to attend her session, Kate created an electronic library for the community to access throughout the day.</p><p>Unfortunately, forecasted winter weather postponed the environmental stewardship event with Philly Goat Project at Awbury Arboretum, but once a new date is determined, students and families hope to spread wood chips on trails, remove vines from trees, move donated Christmas trees, and clean the barn; and of course, volunteers look forward to visiting with the goats.</p><p>In the manner of Friends, the day ended with a worship sharing, which allowed the community to come together and reflect on lessons learned, and projects that support the joy needed to sustain the ongoing goals and mission of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.</p><p>Learn more about the GFS Martin Luther King Jr. Day of Service <a href="http://www.germantownfriends.org/mlk">here</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xVpAyseFPRen6ZkCy1P1Rg.png" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=89e0f61cdd89" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Connecting the Community through Basketball]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/connecting-the-community-through-basketball-474e243760dd?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/474e243760dd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[food-insecurity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[basketball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sports]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[services]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philadelphia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Jan 2022 02:30:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-20T01:07:54.599Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7Ge0tuoZMovRaLdCWunBRQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jane Ellis, Dr. Zarah Adams, and Lynard Stewart</figcaption></figure><p>The annual Germantown Community Basketball Tournament, hosted by Germantown Friends School (GFS) last weekend and now in its 31st year, brings together students and neighbors through a shared love of basketball and athletics. But instead of treating spectators to a traditional halftime show between championship games, the break in competition is used to honor local leaders and inspiring community members who have made an impact on the community. This year, GFS recognized Lynard Stewart, youth anti-violence advocate and Head Coach at Simon Gratz High School, and Jane Ellis, founder of Germantown Community Fridge, for their commitment to Germantown and Philadelphia.</p><p>Bookmarking the awards ceremony, spirited basketball filled the Henry Scattergood Gym at GFS. While championship titles were secured by St. Hubert Catholic High School for Girls and the GFS Varsity Boys team, games also included talented players from Parkway Northwest, Paul Robeson High School for Human Services, Simon Gratz High School, and William W. Bodine High School for International Affairs.</p><p>Stewart has been a game changer on and off the court. At Simon Gratz, he serves as the head basketball coach and dean of students. He also created the Backboard program, focused on empowering his players to connect with and improve their neighborhoods. Stewart is an Assistant Recreation Leader for the City of Philadelphia, a Behavioral Health Specialist at the Philadelphia Mental Health Center, and the co-founder of B-AllPhilly, which provides guidance and instruction to inner city youth. In response to the 2020 murder of former Simon Gratz basketball player Ross Carter, Stewart organized the “Stop the Violence” rally and secured key organizations to address trauma and resources available to the community.</p><blockquote>“I’ve been blessed in my lifetime to be able to receive various awards, but the ones that stand out to me are the ones that involve giving back.”</blockquote><p>“I’ve been blessed in my lifetime to be able to receive various awards, but the ones that stand out to me are the ones that involve giving back. It’s everyone’s responsibility to reach back and make sure things are going the right way, said Stewart. “GFS is a school within a community that I’m very familiar with. To be recognized by such an institution that has become such a pillar in the community means so much to me.”</p><p>Ellis, a teacher at Greene Street Friends, started the Germantown Community Fridge in 2020 to provide perishable and non-perishable food to community residents in need, free of charge. The impetus for the Fridge was Ellis’ desire to connect her students and the community when virtual teaching began, due to COVID-19. The Germantown Community Fridges are located at 20. W Armat Street and at 19 E. High Street. Many community groups, families, and schools — including GFS’ Upper School Community Engagement Club — support maintaining and filling the fridge.</p><p>Ellis shared, “Our two fridges wouldn’t be standing today without the support of our neighbors, dedicated fridge team, the volunteers, and the organizations that donate everyday. It is an honor to have it recognized and shines light on our commitment to battle food insecurity and food excess in the Germantown community.”</p><p>“While the Germantown Community Basketball Tournament has been a staple for over three decades, this year’s event is particularly important. With COVID-19 challenging the physical and mental health of youth all over the city, we are thrilled to bring people together for healthy and joyful competition and camaraderie,” said Katie Bergstrom Mark, Director of Athletics at GFS. “It is phenomenal to showcase two inspiring leaders, who are examples for our students of how to use their voices to create real change through action in our community. Both Lynard and Jane are making a difference for young people every day!”</p><p>You can also view an article by The Philadelphia Tribune Writer OJ Spivey <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1yIzJuxyHmsprgCcS0WT3YstrBjpFI8Hd/view?usp=sharing">here</a> and below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*byo13x22_tUHE7VLIlzo0g.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=474e243760dd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Five Ways to Encourage and Celebrate Diversity with Early Learners]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/five-ways-to-encourage-and-celebrate-diversity-with-early-learners-7269d032ba6a?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7269d032ba6a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[preschool]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[racism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[schools]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diversity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 15 Sep 2021 03:11:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-15T03:11:03.506Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By Lindsay Roberts, Early Childhood teacher and member of the Early Childhood Diversity Committee at Germantown Friends School</p><p><em>Published by NBC’s Parent Toolkit in December 2019</em></p><p>At school or at home, adults can provide a framework for young children to embrace different perspectives and diverse cultures, reducing bias and fostering empathy.</p><p>Multiple studies, including research at the <a href="https://phys.org/news/2017-04-infants-racial-bias-members.html">Ontario Institute for Studies in Education (OISE) at the University of Toronto</a>, have documented that children as early as six months old notice and react to race and show signs of racial bias.</p><p>With this developmental process in mind, families and teachers can help turn the concept of differences into something to celebrate. As our children grow up, we want them to feel accepted and respected for the singular individual that they are and also truly appreciate others. With hate and bullying inundating our news and entering the homes, schools, and communities across the globe, it is particularly important that we incorporate inclusive lessons, habits, and vocabulary into the everyday living and learning of our young people.</p><p>In the classroom, as an early childhood teacher at Germantown Friends School, and at home, as the mother of a toddler and an infant, I have identified best practices to make the celebration of diversity and inclusion a meaningful, lasting part of this important work.</p><p><strong>1. Pages and Pages of Understanding<br></strong>Books. Books. Books. I can’t say enough about the power of this traditional medium. Today, we are fortunate to have a robust library of stories available for children that address important lessons, educate about race, diverse traditions, and cultures, or simply have characters that represent the diverse identities of our country, and the world.</p><p>There are stories about significant changemakers in history, including those of color; characters of different races and ethnicities; and books featuring a variety of family structures. There are children’s books that highlight different religions, beliefs, and traditions. We see characters living in rural areas and busy cities. And we hear true accounts of resilience and fictional tales of children and communities.</p><p><strong>Online, at the library, or in a bookstore, you can surely find these books, but it is important that you do just that</strong>. While kids may gravitate towards known characters or brands, it is important to make an effort to include these diverse stories in your own library, evening bedtime routine, or trips to the library. Read the stories together, read them as a family, and let your little one flip the pages and explore on their own, taking in the images, colors, symbols, and expressions.</p><p>A few favorites:</p><ul><li><em>It’s Ok to Be Different </em>by Todd Parr</li><li><em>Let’s Talk About Race</em> by Julius Lester</li><li><em>The Colors of Us</em> by Karen Katz</li><li><em>Strictly No Elephants</em> by Lisa Mantchev</li><li><em>Whoever You Are</em> by Mem Fox</li></ul><p><strong>2. Show and Tell<br></strong>In addition to exposing children to the richness of people and culture through stories and pictures, you can add depth to these efforts through real-life experiences and memories.</p><p>With young children, it can be helpful to start with themselves. Discuss what they enjoy, and what makes them happy. Talk about what they look like, including hair and eye color, and skin tone. Who makes up their family? What are their favorite traditions and foods? As parents, you can also point out what makes you individual and unique. Maybe you have freckles or glasses, or perhaps you grew up with a grandparent in the house or had a best friend who celebrated a different religious tradition. <strong>As adults, we serve as examples for our children in so many ways. If we describe our own experiences, children listen, take note, and follow our lead.</strong></p><p>Include discussions about friends and family. Maybe your child’s classmate has long braids and her cousin has big curls. Or perhaps Grandma speaks a different language and has an accent, and an Auntie who wears a bindi. Identifying unique physical and personality traits and cultural preferences, and allowing kids to ask questions, will foster a culture in which differences are positive and celebrated.</p><p>Finally, get out of the house! Depending on where you live, you may be able to visit neighborhoods that have become cultural communities, or various places of worship, restaurants, schools, and museums that feature diverse people and traditions. You can visit towns where the homes and buildings look different from your own. Along with your child, highlight the joyful parts of these visits — bakeries or shops, special smells, music, art, noises, and people. Discuss what about the neighborhood looks familiar to you and what looks unfamiliar.</p><p>At our school, early childhood students of all ages explore identity beginning with themselves, drawing self-portraits, mixing their own skin color in paint, and creating other art projects that allow a child to highlight special parts of their appearance or personality. We incorporate family shares in which family members or friends come to class and talk about a special tradition that may be religious, cultural, or completely secular. Kids can see various family structures and learn that no two households are exactly the same. Our pre-kindergarten-aged children visit with and interview members of the community, asking questions about their lives, work, and families.</p><p>By exposing children to people who experience lives different from theirs, and visiting places outside of their norm, you can bring about awareness and appreciation — and even more, you can do it as a family.</p><ul><li>Encourage young children to self-reflect and share what they feel makes them special.</li><li>Have children draw pictures or describe similarities and differences to their parents, family, and peers.</li><li>Take walks, visit other neighborhoods, talk to people, and ask questions.</li><li>Attend events and festivals.</li></ul><p><strong>3. Let Feelings Speak<br></strong>Young children often openly share their feelings about an event or situation, but you can also encourage this expression and create an environment where they feel safe voicing what is on their mind. It helps for an adult to also share emotions, using words that are age-appropriate for children. This openness can lend itself to important dialogue about differences and similarities, fair and unfair, and exclusion.</p><p>At GFS, talking about feelings is a central part of our daily classroom life, an important practice as we begin to approach race and exclusion in our curriculum. Explore what your child is feeling and share your own reactions and emotions.</p><p>“How did it make you feel when you were left out of the game?”</p><p>“It made me feel sad when kids said I couldn’t play with them.”</p><p>“It made me feel sad, too.”</p><p>This acknowledgment of feelings and unfair treatment will help children understand bigger inequalities and approach life with concern and care for other’s well-being.</p><p><strong>4. Don’t be afraid of questions.<br></strong>As an adult, this can be a tough one. You may not know all of the answers. In fact, you will definitely not know all of the answers. It is important to remember, though, that our reactions, behaviors, and words matter — a lot. Race, gender, family, and religion: these are complex topics and conversations that an adult must face themselves when children ask questions. Embrace questions. Answer them simply or find the answers. Do not overcomplicate your response.</p><p>Young children under the age of five do not need or want extensive details. They want to know, Why does that child have darker or lighter skin color or What is that covering the woman’s head and chest? Explain that everyone has a unique skin color. Compare the colors of skin in your own family; you will likely see many shades. Share that some people express different beliefs and traditions through clothing or jewelry, like a cross, Star of David, or hijab. Religion and race can be hard to explain, but introducing new words can create a familiarization beyond what they see within their own families and communities.</p><p>If you do not know the answer, tell your child that you will research it together. Inquiry and understanding are key in building tolerant, empathetic people and there is no better time than toddlerhood to get started on this.</p><p>It is also important for adults to eliminate the taboo of talking about these important topics. Remove the “shhhs” and whispers around topics related to race, gender, religion, or family structure. If something is said that seems embarrassing, correct it, share facts, and ask questions. If you demonstrate that you are comfortable (even if inside you may not be), your children are more likely to be as well.</p><p>Along this journey, there will be unkind words said and unfair situations that will arise. Use these experiences as teachable moments and explain why your child’s actions or reactions could be improved. Embrace questions and teachable moments with courage. And remember, your actions serve as models.</p><p><strong>5. Remind children that they have the power to create change.<br></strong>Embracing diversity and inclusion extends to standing up for what is right. <strong>Help young children understand that their words and actions can have a significant impact on their friends and community. Even though they are little, they have “word power.”</strong></p><p>Even at a young age,<strong><em> </em></strong>children can be allies. They can speak up, write letters (parents can take dictation), make posters, ask questions, share, and participate. And remember, you can lead by example, modeling these behaviors and actions. Exhibit empathy when someone is not treated kindly. Donate clothing and toys with your child. Include neighbors who may be home alone.</p><p>I have enjoyed taking my three-year-old to marches and to vote, showing her that everyone’s voice matters and that we can all make a difference. Find something to do together that is meaningful to your family or of interest to your child, from supporting shelter dogs to serving lunch to seniors at the local community center. Your actions will give children the courage to do the same. On the flip side, the act of modeling for your children can also strengthen your own bravery.</p><p>As you consider the best ways to integrate lessons of diversity and inclusion into your home life, think about your comfort and biases. Be brave about your own shortcomings or blindspots. Become informed. Read, ask questions, research. You do not need to be an expert and you are not alone. In addition to books, toys, articles, and online resources, your child’s teachers can be great sources of information.</p><p>As adults, we can help forge a path for our children to be comfortable with embracing differences, recognizing that the world is beautiful because we all contribute something special. Young children can shine their light in their own way, using their unique gifts and talents to make change and build a world filled with acceptance and understanding.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/421/1*8cboALUaObakHuDVNwI5gA.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Lindsay Roberts</strong> graduated from Sarah Lawrence College with a concentration in Early Childhood Education and has been working in the field for 17 years. As a graduate of a Quaker elementary school herself, she appreciates the Quaker values and philosophy on education and has found they have had a positive impact on her education, growth, and development. Lindsay joined Germantown Friends School in 2011, where she has been working with the three-and four-year-olds. Her goal is to create and maintain an inviting, stimulating, and caring learning environment that will contribute to the development of the whole child.</p><p>In addition, Lindsay is a trained leader in Seeking Educational Equity and Diversity (S.E.E.D.), where she teaches about multicultural pedagogy, curriculum, and institutional change in independent schools. In her free time, Lindsay enjoys traveling, entertaining friends and family in her home, new culinary experiences, and enjoying life with her husband Ben and their two children, Simone and Ziggy.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7269d032ba6a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Irvin Corson Poley: Master Teacher]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/irvin-corson-poley-master-teacher-bfe0573fda90?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bfe0573fda90</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Aug 2021 15:25:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-24T15:25:49.752Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Nationally recognized, GFS is now on the cutting-edge of progressive education in the early 1930s with an array of Upper School electives to in-depth, year-long studies in the lower grades. Theater productions are found throughout the school, including a wooden, two-story, student-built Trojan Horse. When the Depression hits, the school struggles to keep tuition affordable, enacting multiple budget cuts and large faculty lay-offs.</em></p><p><strong><em>(</em></strong><a href="https://medium.com/p/840551fc7e98/"><strong><em>Introduction to this series</em></strong></a><strong><em>)</em></strong></p><p><strong>Irvin Poley always credited his Quaker ancestors for his interest in the theater.</strong> There were two stories about them he loved to tell.</p><p>“My great-grandfather, a very plain Friend, was informed by a conscientious talebearer in the Meeting that a fellow member had been to the theater. She added, self-righteously, ‘I myself have never been within the doors of a playhouse.’ Alan Corson replied, ‘Neither have I, Hannah, but many better people have; so let’s say nothing about it.’</p><p>“His son, my grandfather [Elias Hicks Corson] didn’t let a lame horse prevent his hearing Dickens do his famous dramatic readings. He stopped his farm work a little early, walked the twelve miles to the city from Plymouth Meeting, heard Dickens and got home in early morning. He had no time to sleep, but he lingered over breakfast long enough to delight my mother and his other children with his imitations of how Dickens acted out his characters.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/405/1*3dCWCCcamq5ZbUnFpeeu-w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Joe Jefferson as Rip Van Winkle, 1896</figcaption></figure><p>Poley told these tales in a little memoir he titled <em>The Play is Now the Thing, </em>and in it he traced his love for the theater to his boyhood. “In my parents’ home, my mother always managed to find money for one good play a year for the family. I saw <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Jefferson">Joe Jefferson</a> in ‘Rip Van Winkle’ when I was ten, Irving and Terry in ‘The Merchant of Venice’ when I was eleven, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Mansfield">Richard Mansfield</a> in ‘Julius Caesar’ when I was twelve. A life-long interest was set then and there… I still paste in scrap-books the programs and reviews and pictures of every play I see.” Poley’s theater books are in the collection of the Friends Free Library.¹ Irvin Poley was born in Philadelphia in 1891. His father, Warren H. Poley, owned a drugstore on Germantown Avenue near Walnut Lane where young Irvin worked, he remembered, for twenty cents a day. Warren Poley eventually made a fortune investing in pharmaceutical stocks, and, when his father died, Irvin and his brother and sister inherited a great deal of money. “They were millionaires,” is Henry Scattergood’s memory. But there was not much money in the early, formative years, and Irvin Poley never forgot. “Irvin told me,” Henry remembers, “he said, I am very fortunate now to have money I didn’t have when I was young…and I want the pleasure of giving it away while I am still living… He was a very generous man.”</p><p>Poley always gave anonymously. He was a benefactor of the Friends Free Library, and he gave a good deal of money for scholarships. Much of his philanthropy was individual. “He made his way into a lot of people’s hearts,” Scattergood says. Perhaps remembering a personal experience, Henry recounted that “A young faculty member, who was obviously struggling with a low salary, Irvin would present them enough money so they could go to dinner and the theater. He did a lot of little, kind things — what the poet called those ‘little unremembered acts of kindness.’ His life was full of that. He was really a lovely man.”²</p><p>After graduating from GFS, Poley went to Haverford intending a life in the theater, perhaps as an actor or a playwright. In the summer of his sophomore year, however, he got a job as a counselor at Flying Moose Lodge, a summer camp in Maine owned by Henry Domincovich. Mr. Domi persuaded Poley that his real gift was as a teacher.</p><p>He graduated from Haverford in 1912 and accepted a teaching position at the Cedarcroft School, a boarding school in Chester County. He hated it. The school was too conservative for him, and it was also too remote from the theater he loved. The workload was also incredible. As was usual with Poley, he later turned the painful first year experience into a good story.</p><p>“In my first year of teaching, an experienced colleague entered my room late in the evening and found me desperate for sleep; in the fumbling, exhausting, beginning-swimmer way of a green teacher in boarding school, I had less than fifteen minutes of relaxation since seven that morning, what with teaching six classes, coaching a football team, presiding over two study hours, three meals and a dormitory.</p><p>“But there were papers still to be done. Before I realized what was happening, the young man picked them up, tore them through, put them in the scrap-basket, and said, ‘You need sleep more than the boys need the papers.’ Like a baby, a teacher seems to learn more his first year than any time later. Another teacher that same winter — a woman — used to tell me with grim satisfaction how late her papers had kept her the night before. ‘And they never look at them,’ Mr. Poley! One glance at the grade, and they throw them in the scrap-basket!’ “‘Why do you stay up to one o’clock to finish, then? I asked. ‘Something in here, Mr. Poley,’ she answered with a dramatic tap on her bosom, ample enough, I am sure, to hold an inflated conscience. Her heart may not have been bigger than her head, but her conscience was. Whereupon I resolved that whatever time I spent reading papers — and I have spent a reasonable amount — would be profitable to my students.”³</p><p>Stanley Yarnall invited Poley to come to GFS in 1913; he jumped at the chance and loved it from the start. The Poleys kept a “family diary,” a slim journal in which each family member made periodic notations. Irvin’s entries in these years are consistently joyful. He admired Yarnall, he respected his new colleagues at the school, and he plunged into his work with zest. Within two months of his arrival at GFS, and with help from Helen White and Katherine Dobson, he produced a play by students in the Intermediate English class. It would be the first of countless productions. That first year he was even able to persuade Teacher Emma Roberts to accompany him to the theater — something she had never done. It became an annual event for them.</p><p>The Poley family diary shows young Irvin embracing a whirl of happy and innocent Quaker life before World War I. There were countless parties, picnics, ice cream socials, afternoon teas, family holidays, wedding receptions, and trips to New York and Broadway and to the Poconos.</p><p>He fell in love with Frances Ross, and they were married in 1917. Tragically, she died in the influenza epidemic of 1918. Henry Scattergood remembers “that just about killed him. He said, ‘I had to force myself to laugh again.’” He was slow to recover, but eventually married Ruth Verlenden, a Hicksite Friend and graduate of Swarthmore, in 1922, and their marriage lasted over half a century.⁴</p><p><strong>Poley’s influence in the school grew steadily throughout the 1920s.</strong> He had been hired to take charge of the Intermediate School because Yarnall wanted a disciplinarian. Poley could be one, although that is not how he is generally remembered. “He was not soft, he was not easy. I can remember him walking down the hall in the morning and he would greet a student, ‘good morning,’ and if the student didn’t answer he would grab him by the back of the neck and say ‘when I greet you, I expect you to have the courtesy to answer me back.’ People know he meant business.”⁵</p><p>Yarnall soon put him in charge of the scheduling, then asked him to oversee the revisions in the Primary curriculum. In 1927 he was appointed vice-principal, and, by 1930, he was the obvious choice to run the school during Yarnall’s sabbatical leave.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gBsBh9aaQJeJaOeeBRX20g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Irvin Poley in his classroom c 1935</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Irvin Poley was a great teacher and a great teacher of teachers.</strong> In the 1930s he also managed two important developments in the history of the school: He created the Malvern Festival, and he directed GFS’ participation in the Eight-Year Study.</p><p>“He knew a lot about teaching,” Scattergood says. “He knew the tricks of the trade — but he didn’t rely on just tricks. He was genuinely good.”</p><p>What really happened in a Poley classroom? What made Poley a “genuinely good teacher?”</p><p>The important history of Germantown Friends School, or of any other school, really takes place in a classroom where only a teacher and students are present. It is almost impossible for the historian to reconstruct in any depth that special chemistry or to recount in detail the particular dynamic that distinguishes good from mediocre teaching.</p><p>Poley himself realized that. In his first report to the School Committee, as acting principal in 1930, he said “The most important phase of school life, what actually goes on in the classroom, is hard to report,” and he didn’t try. Students, interviewed years later, remembered odd moments, bits of humor, evidence of teacher eccentricity, sometimes their own pleasures, and often their pains, in a class. But they almost never recall any details about the way the course developed, or the class discussions or the subtle details of presentation. They can, however, offer brief glimpses of personality and style. David Mallery ’41, was a Poley student in the 1930s, and a colleague later.</p><p>In what he called “mini-flashes,” Mallery described moments in a Poley classroom when he was a student.</p><blockquote>“Ninth-grade English: Irvin has just played Brutus to my Cassius for three whole pages, and then another Cassius takes over. Why do I feel more interesting in his class than other classes?</blockquote><blockquote>“ — Public Speaking period: he has just finished reading sample school announcements in the heaviest possible Philadelphia accent. The classes crack up. None of us will ever say ‘dai-oan tai-oan’ and ‘poark the coar’ again without checking ourselves for a second just after — or even before….</blockquote><blockquote>“ — He is reading aloud from Act Three of “Our Town.” There is a fervor in his voice, caring and love. ‘Does anyone realize life while they live it? Every, every minute? ‘No, Saints and poets, mebbe.’”⁶</blockquote><p>One of Poley’s “tricks” or techniques in teaching was always to have an assignment or questions written on the blackboard when students entered the room. “He meant business” and the whole period was to be used. Students should consider the blackboard as they settled down. They should write the questions down in their notebooks.</p><p>Here is part of a typical Poley week with students reading Sinclair Lewis’s <em>Arrowsmith</em>. Poley described this in an essay titled “The Spiral Approach to Composition.”</p><p>When students enter the room on Monday, on the blackboard is written:</p><blockquote>For Tuesday:</blockquote><blockquote>1. Read as much of <em>Arrowsmith </em>as you have time for.</blockquote><blockquote>2. Start thinking about what you’ll write about for Friday,</blockquote><blockquote>3. Study “The Value of the Specific” to see which version you like better and why.</blockquote><blockquote>“On a Monday, say four or five days before a theme is due, I mention to the class that I shall soon be expecting something good in written expression of their own ideas. I ask if an of them have trouble finding a subject to write about; nearly all do, of course. We then discuss ways of getting material — chance bits of conversation, items in a newspaper, a face in the hotel lobby. I may mention Eugene O’Neill’s building The Emperor Jones from the silver bullet and the continuous tom-tom….” Half of the class time on Monday is spend on items 1 and 2; the remainder of the period is spent introducing the novel. Poley raises questions: “What is meant by the scientific method?” “Does Arrowsmith seem to think research more important than reducing suffering? “Do you feel that Sinclair Lewis sympathizes with Arrowsmith in this opinion?”</blockquote><blockquote>Item 3 on the blackboard, <em>The Value of the Specific</em>, is an exercise devised by Poley and, in this instance, compares a passage written by Charles Dickens with a passage written by Poley. Its assignment to be read as homework and discussed the next day. Here is an abbreviated version:</blockquote><blockquote>Dickens: “Such a bustle ensued that you might have thought a goose the rarest of all birds… Mrs. Cratchit made the gravy (rather beforehand in a little saucepan) hissing hot…”</blockquote><blockquote>Poley: “Such a movement ensued that you might have thought the food were to have the rarest in the world. The mother busied herself finishing something to serve with the main dish…”</blockquote><blockquote>Most of Tuesday is spent on the exercise <em>The Value of the Specific</em>. “Needless to say,” Poley wrote, “there will be a universal preference for Dickens over Poley. Why? Because Dickens is more specific; that is easy. But, to learn from the exercise what there is to learn, most youngsters will need to hear corresponding phrases read aloud” and Poley introduces lessons in reading, interpretation, grammar, and punctuation based on the passages of the exercise.</blockquote><p>What impresses the modern reader when following Poley’s lesson plans day after day is the thorough and thoughtful way he weaves language and literature together. Written on the blackboard on Wednesday, for example, are three sentences:</p><blockquote>1. Something alive went up something green.</blockquote><blockquote>2. An insect climbed a grass-blade.</blockquote><blockquote>3. A brown-spotted ladybug climbed the dizzying height of a grass-blade.</blockquote><p>Which is the best sentence? The class chooses the third, “because it is more specific.” Poley challenges their assumptions: The best for what purpose? Is “being specific” overdone? Is “specific” really the issue at all? He goes back to Dickens: Why were “bustling” and “hissing hot” more effective than the Poley paraphrases? Is it just a matter of specifics?</p><p>Then it was back to <em>Arrowsmith</em>. He wrote on the board “They pictured what poverty would mean — a small house on a side street, with the housework done by slatternly servants,” and invited discussions about class, luxury, conflicting values, and points of view.</p><p>On the board for Thursday was:</p><blockquote>1. If your rough draft isn’t already written, write it.</blockquote><blockquote>2. Re-read aloud what you have written at least twice to the ear; make what revision becomes necessary.</blockquote><blockquote>3. Symposium on <em>Arrowsmith </em>a week from today. Better have book finished by Tuesday next.⁷</blockquote><p>Poley had a favorite phrase to describe his method of teaching: “Teach obliquely, test directly.” He compared his teaching method to the Chekhov play. “In <em>The Cherry Orchard</em>, for example, the complexity of the characters and the multiplicity of minor plots — no ‘well-made play’ here — are stimulating, fascinating, yet a little confusing until the final curtain. The final tableau of the forgotten servant with the noise of the cherry trees offstage unifies the great play magnificently. We have a new understanding of people everywhere, especially of pre-Soviet Russian aristocrats; we see freshly why such people — lovable as they often were — foreshadow violent revolution. For Chekhov’s genius substitute the intelligent preparation, the hard work, his interest in technique characteristic of good English teachers. We shall have, then, I think day by day more variety — boys and girls thrive on variety, though they need routine, too — and more real interest, the kind that incites to self-motivated study. And at the end of the unit or of the semester we may have something of the same sense of enlarged understanding of the whole that Chekhov gives.”⁸</p><p>In a Poley classroom, there were no lists of vocabulary or spelling words, or grammar rules. They came up each day “obliquely.” To each proper use of commas, for example, he would take sentences from student themes. “Theodore Roosevelt because he filled out McKinley’s term was considered ineligible for re-election.” This sentence might lead to vocabulary. What is “ineligible”? What is eligible? What is an antonym?</p><p><strong>Poley did have a lot of tricks.</strong> Henry Scattergood has never forgotten “Neither (or either) leisurely foreigner seized their weird heights,” which contains every important exception to the “i before e” spelling rule. He favored spelling bees where scores were kept for the right answers and no one sat down after a mistake. “Why should only the best spellers have the dizzy glory of repeated opportunities to spell?” He liked students to keep “inventories” of new things they learned, books read, words mastered. “It calls for a stock-taking of English learned in and out of class. It motivates note-taking, mental and physical, a difficult thing to do, especially with junior high youngsters.” He believed in asking questions first, and then calling on a student to answer. “If you reverse the procedure, most youngsters will relax and stop listening when they hear a name other than their own.”</p><p>Poley devoted a good deal of attention to oral reading and appreciation even in a regular English class. He described his oblique technique and a trick — “the one world location test” — in an article he wrote for an English teachers’ journal. “Let’s take for a moment a play that most of us have taught, <em>Macbeth</em>. Suppose you have introduced the tragedy by reading aloud about half the first act, trying to follow the happy mean of explaining enough and not too much, of explaining the essential word but always trying to let the lines speak for themselves. For homework I might ask students to re-read aloud with full expression what I had read to them and then to finish the act, rather daring them to see if they can get the main points of the first seven scenes. The next day I might begin class with a one-word test with ten questions.” Here is a sample:</p><blockquote>My noble partner</blockquote><blockquote>You agree with present grace and great prediction That he seems rapt withal: to me you speak not: If you can look into the seeds of time,</blockquote><blockquote>And say which grain will grow and which will not Speak then to me…</blockquote><blockquote>1. Who says this?</blockquote><blockquote>2. Who is the noble partner referred to?</blockquote><p>The test and correction — by other students — would take half the period, and the rest would be spent with Poley reading lines with one student after another. The night’s homework would be reading aloud the second act and writing a one-word test like the one Poley had constructed. “The third day the students would read aloud their passages and he class would spot them orally. This device gives three day switch an emphasis on oral reading that should bear fruit in appreciation.”</p><p>Near the end of his teaching career, Poley asked a student intern, Ada Hoell, to follow him around and take notes as he taught a six-week drama class to ninth graders. He wanted to leave a record of “what really happens in my classroom.” The class was studying <em>Julius Caesar </em>and Maxwell Anderson’s <em>Elizabeth the Queen</em>. Here are parts of Hoell’s notes:</p><blockquote>1. Explanation of figurative language brought up in its relation to lying. The class saw it was possible to act a lie; Mr. Poley spoke of Arnold Bennett’s phrase, “looking with the steadiness of glance peculiar to liars who read novels.” The class saw the figurative language may help to vivify the truth and that lying (intended to deceive) may be done with literal language…</blockquote><blockquote>2. As an illustration of a paradox, Mr. Poley quoted Alfred Noyes’s lines,</blockquote><blockquote>They are jammed and crammed in buses But they’re each of them alone</blockquote><blockquote>In the land where the dead dreams go.</blockquote><blockquote>The possibilities of loneliness in a crowd were grasped by some. Mr. Poley asked if the rich and powerful were every lonely. Someone referred to Elizabeth’s saying, “I am encompassed by lies,” and, “If there were only the sound of one honest voice!” Someone else brought up Elizabeth’s remark to Essex,</blockquote><blockquote>But you’d have to say that, because you wouldn’t hurt me, And because I’m your queen.</blockquote><blockquote>The class discussed the reasons why people who are rich and powerful learn to distrust compliments.</blockquote><blockquote>3. The class came to this argument between Elizabeth and Essex:</blockquote><blockquote>Elizabeth:<br>…You believe yourself <br>Fitter to be king than to be queen! You believe you’d rule England better Because you’re a man!</blockquote><blockquote>Essex:<br>…(I) see that why you fail<br>When you do is merely because a woman cannot Act and think like a man</blockquote><blockquote>Elizabeth:<br>…a woman’s thinking’s wiser.</blockquote><blockquote>There came up the question of the differences in achievement between men and women. Supremacy in letters and in government was granted to man. Is it a difference in mental ability or in education? Mr. Poley mentioned George Eliot’s picture in <em>The Mill and the Floss </em>of a bright girl who was not allowed to study Greek and her slow-minded brother was forced to….</blockquote><blockquote>4. Was Elizabeth bad? Was Essex? Was Antony? Was Cassius? Was Brutus wholly good? The class contributed characteristics. Elizabeth was vain, capricious, deceitful, hot- tempered, brilliant, vigorous, sensible, and peace-loving. Essex was greedy for power, proud, generous, honest, a war-bringer and a trouble-maker for England. Antony was deceitful, but he really loved Caesar. Cassius faced facts in a realistic way. Brutus was a rationalizer when he wouldn’t take money from the peasants for his armies, but was angry at Cassius for not getting money for him by the same means. The class saw that these characters were human partly because they were neither white nor black, but gray.</blockquote><p>Germantown Friends School has had many teachers in its century and a half, but few have left records that allow the historian to enter their classrooms. With Irvin Poley, even if we can’t enter, we can peer through the window, and the scene is always lively. Catherine Hineline, who retired from GFS in 2007 after teaching in the Lower School for thirty-eight years, once had the opportunity as a young teacher at Sidwell Friends School to literally peer through a window to watch Poley. In 1968 Poley was invited to teach Shakespeare to a class of sixth graders at Sidwell Friends. “I know that class well, having taught them before,” Katie remembers, “and I know that it was just impossible to teach them Shakespeare.” Katy and other Sidwell teachers watched him through a one-way window. “He started by reading a bit from the play, I think it was <em>Macbeth</em>, and then distributed scenes and had the students read — act. From the moment he opened his mouth, he had them. He asked questions that drew the students into the play and helped them see parallels to their own lives. He was very old then, thin and hunched over, and the students loved him. It was magic.”</p><p><strong>Poley was also a teacher of teachers.</strong> “He was marvelous, the best in the school, at helping young teachers,” Henry Scattergood, who was briefly a young teacher in the school in the 1930s, says. But Poley’s reputation was wider than GFS.</p><p>Starting in 1928, Poley taught a demonstration class for English teachers at Harvard every summer. For an hour, he would teach drama and literature to ninth graders who were enrolled in an “enrichment” course, while teachers who were working on advanced degrees observed the class. In a second hour, Poley would lead a seminar with the teachers on what he had done in class and why. He taught this demonstration class for more than twenty years and his name, and GFS, became widely known in progressive education circles.</p><p>In 1945 he was asked to write an article for <em>The Clearing House</em>, an education journal, about “What Every Young Teacher Ought to Know.” His advice is practical, humorous, wise, and explains a lot about why Poley was so well regarded by fellow teachers. Here is some of his advice:</p><blockquote>1. Don’t expect the impossible of yourself. “You can’t be all things to all pupils…”</blockquote><blockquote>2. Expect the possible. “There is almost no skill or talent that can’t be put to use in a school…”</blockquote><blockquote>3. Keep as well as you can. “There is no profession whose members take such fanatical pride in being at their posts, no matter how unfit for duty. I don’t know why teachers tend to be stubborn about never giving into ills of the flesh; perhaps being a good example year after year breaks down a sense of proportion.” His advice: go to bed.</blockquote><blockquote>4. Your mental health is as important as your physical. “As an aid to good mental health, read samplings of drill exercises and discuss answers in class and stagger that part of your paper-load which has to be read carefully; don’t assign more than have time to do calmly, with a reasonable amount of interest.”</blockquote><blockquote>5. Be a person in our own right. “Have outside interest… The day is over when a teacher is expected to be of a third sex, uninterested in normal social life…”</blockquote><blockquote>6. Try to enjoy something in each student. “It does not really matter how much you are liked in return;…But it matters enormously to young people to be liked and respected”</blockquote><blockquote>7. Boys and girls really are different. “It is even more important with girls than boys to watch your manners, because girls care more about your good opinion”</blockquote><blockquote>8. Trust your pupils, but don’t tempt them. “Don’t make it easy for children to lie or to cheat. If you are testing your pupils’ memory of work assigned, assume that everyone will want to sit as far apart as possible. And don’t forget that honesty is not the only virtue worth being concerned about…we teachers are likely to be too much impressed by conformity, politeness, and truth-telling. Like Pitti Sing’s, our taste exact for flawless fact amounts to a disease. We may be too little impressed by such virtues as initiative, courage, independence of judgment, the higher forms of truthfulness. Dr. Ralph Sockman once said, ‘It is one thing to be moral enough to tell the truth as one sees it; it is a better thing to try and find the truth before one tells it.’ Let’s not overlook the bigger virtues.”</blockquote><blockquote>9. Include routine as well as variety in our plans. “Boys and girls need routine. Have routine jobs well routinized — the arrangement and the collecting of papers, for example, and preparation of blackboards. You may want to have homework written on the board several days ahead…[it] has a steadying effect… Routine, then, is important in our planning, but so is variety. Don’t always stand in the front of the room; don’t always wear the same necktie with the same suit. Change the youngsters’ position as well as your own; the younger they are the more they need legitimate excuse for physical activity — opening a window, closing a door, going to the blackboard.”</blockquote><blockquote>10. If you must punish, give yourself time to do it wisely. “Don’t scold; don’t be lead into a prolonged search for absolute justice.”</blockquote><blockquote>11. Don’t try to use influence until you have it. “Don’t take it as a compliment if told you seem just like one of the boys; you wouldn’t be getting a salary if you were.”</blockquote><blockquote>12. Don’t expect our advisees to jump directly from the usual self-absorption of youth to altruism; self-respect must come first. The rest of Poley’s advice to young teachers is about getting along with principals and colleagues, and it boils down to “if you can’t be happy… get out.”</blockquote><p>It was advice that Poley himself would need to weigh in 1941.</p><p>Poley is best remembered for the “Malvern Festival.” These were a series of plays, or usually excerpts from plays, that were performed in assemblies during the spring. They were named after a famous English drama festival that every summer produced a series of six plays given “in chronological order, so that in one week of nightly theatre-going one could painlessly acquire a vivid sense of the historical development of English drama.”⁹ Poley’s version was quite different from the original.</p><p>The festival originated in the spring of 1933 when two junior boys, Harold Robinson and Maurice Webster, asked Poley to teach a course in public speaking for their senior year. With approval from Yarnall, Poley offered the course for the first time in 1934–35 and twelve students (six boys and six girls) signed up. For the first half of the year, they studied the rudiments of public speaking. “We began… with practicing simple announcements pleasantly audible in the rear of the assembly room [now the Poley auditorium]. We were interested… in private speech as well as public. We learned that we speak with our bodies (posture, gesture, pantomime) in addition to our vocal apparatus.” Every person interviewed for this history remembers Poley standing in the back of the Auditorium listening to every speaker, on every occasion, and often making suggestions. “He thought you should hear a person when they got up,” one student remembers. “He insisted on it.”</p><p>The second half of the year students performed plays. “Almost by accident we drifted into doing very simply a unified series of short or shortened plays in assembly — a series which we called the Malvern Festival.”</p><p>The first year (1935) the public speaking class presented “A Feast of English Comedy,” five assembly programs a week apart with ten- to thirty- minute bits from <em>You Never Can Tell, The Importance of Being Earnest</em>, W.S Gilbert’s <em>Engaged, The School for Scandal</em>, and <em>A Comedy of Errors</em>. For the next quarter century, the Malvern Festival flourished.</p><p>It was always done with few props and little costuming. Poley thought this was one of the great values of the Malvern approach. It focused attention on the text, the interpretation, and the actors. He believed that elaborate production hindered rather than helped the audience’s imagination.</p><p>He never apologized for cutting plays, sometimes quite ruthlessly, to fit the time constraints of an assembly. “For school purposes… many plays gain by the cutting… to my taste, <em>The Comedy of Errors </em>for a whole evening is a bore. It proved hilarious, cut to forty minutes… <em>The Madwoman of Chaillot</em>, full length, would, I suspect, be unbearable with youthful amateurs… but our school audience was enchanted with a half-hour from the last act…”</p><p>Poley wrote many articles for education journals about the Malvern Festival, and he always made the same points: It is the student experience that matters, not the production’s polish; broad exposure to all kinds of drama is preferable to the masterful presentation of one play; drama should be made to fit into the school schedule, and should be seen as a normal, natural part of education. He had taken advantage of special celebrations (like the Shakespeare Tercentenary) to promote drama, but he didn’t really approve of this. Drama, indeed all the arts, should be central to the curriculum, and woven into it. “Our ideal [is] taking performances in our stride, of rehearsing only in study periods or in regular public speaking periods, of students going to their regular classes up to a few moments before going on the stage. We believe in the Malvern Festival idea of a unified series of plays cut to a manageable size and all the emphasis on making the interpretation of character as honestly and effectively projected as possible.”</p><p>More students gained more positive experiences doing the Malvern approach, he argued, than any other. Perfect performances, by the very few, after many nights of rehearsal, with elaborate staging, lighting, and costuming missed the point. The theatre became separate from student lives when viewed that way, he thought. “They” performed for “us.” Poley’s approach was to try to eliminate the distinction between pronouns.</p><p>Poley also used the Malvern Festival to give students a chance for growth and attention. “He brought people out who had never been brought out before… students, girls for example, who had never much been noticed became bella donnas — they had a place they had never had before. They came into their own, and he worked very hard at that…”¹⁰</p><p>Poley had a soft spot for outsiders, misfits, and disaffected and lonely adolescents, and he saw the Malvern Festival as a way of drawing them into the mainstream. He knew that most educators in the 1930s regarded the arts as a refuge for weak students, and he resented that. But he came to realize that the arts represented a chance for those students to show their worth. “Good acting takes, fortunately, ability of a different sort from that measured by scholastic aptitude tests — a mixture, perhaps, of imaginative understanding of others and freedom from self-consciousness.”</p><p>The Malvern Festival continued from 1935 to Poley’s retirement in 1958. There were a few Malvern Festivals after that, but they really only retained the name. The beliefs and spirit that directed the Malvern Festival retired with Poley.</p><p>The Festivals were always organized around a theme, although the theme seems often to have been stretched and lightly regarded. History connected “It Began in Greece” (1939) to “History Takes the Stage” (1946), but it is hard to find any other connection between the balcony scene from <em>Romeo and Juliet </em>(1939) and a reading from Benet’s <em>The Devil and Daniel Webster </em>(1946). The theme for 1938 illustrates the point. It was “They All Wrote English” and was a way to group Irish playwrights (J.M. Synge, <em>Riders to the Sea</em>) with American writers (Marc Connelly and George Kaufman, <em>Dulcy</em>). Poley always maintained that the Malvern Festival themes were serious, and discussed by students in class at great length, but it surely looks like Irvin selected plays he liked and thought would work with students — and figured a theme later.</p><p><strong>Poley also took charge of the Eight-Year Study, </strong>the most important development in the Intermediate and High School during the 1930s. The <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight-Year_Study">Eight-Year Study</a> was a joint project of the Progressive Education Association and the Carnegie Foundation and aimed at loosening up the high school curriculum.</p><p>The Carnegie Foundation for many years had worried that college admissions standards, and the natural desire of college preparatory schools to meet those standards, had produced a fixed curriculum that forced every student, whatever his or her individual talents and interests, into the same college preparatory mold. There was too much emphasis on language and literature, for example, and too little on science and history. The arts were neglected. The Foundation believed that high schools were teaching to test standards. Did Bryn Mawr require Horace on its entrance exam? Schools taught Horace. Would Haverford test on Burke’s <em>Speech on Conciliation</em>? Students looking to Haverford read it.</p><p>In a series of publications, Dr. W.S. Learned of the Carnegie Foundation attached this formula for college admissions. Students were being taught that education was the accumulation of course credits, he argued. They “passed off” examinations in every subject in order to gain college admission, but they never put it all together. Education was becoming mastery of “credits” and not mastery of material or integration of knowledge.</p><p>The Carnegie Foundation, with help from Progressive Education Association (P.E.A.) formed a committee to enlist “a limited number of strong, outstanding secondary schools of proved excellence” in an experiment to show that a broader curriculum, with more choices and electives, and with individualized programs for different students, could be as successful for college preparation as the usual approach. After several years of study, the experiment was launched in 1933, and thirty schools from around the country were selected to participate. GFS was one of them.</p><p>In the Eight-Year Study, participating colleges (and these included most that GFS students attended) suspended their usual examinations for applicants and accepted students from the thirty experimental schools on the basis on recommendations and a liberal reading of their school transcripts.</p><p>There were no hard and fast rules. The colleges were not obliged to accept every recommended student, but they were obliged to judge students on the basis of “well-defined serious interests and purpose” and “demonstrated ability to work successfully in one or more fields of study.” In practice this meant, for example, that a GFS graduate who excelled in math and science was admitted to Bryn Mawr in 1939 despite the fact she had not taken Latin.</p><p>GFS was selected as one of these thirty elite “progressive” schools in part because of Stanley Yarnall’s early participation in the Carnegie planning process. As early as 1928, Yarnall had joined a committee of private school heads to consider Leonard’s ideas. In succeeding years, he encouraged Harry Domincovich and Laurence Burgess to take part in the sub-committees working out parts of the proposed experiment.</p><p>GFS may also have been selected because of a well-publicized “progressive” pageant staged in 1931 to celebrate Virgil’s 2,000th birthday. The entire Intermediate and Upper School stopped all ordinary business on May 6 to participate in a three-hour celebration of classical culture in fourteen dramatic tableaux with song and dance. The pageant was given prominent coverage by every Philadelphia newspaper. <em>The Inquirer</em>, for example, headlined its story “Virgil Relives in School Pageant—450 Pupils Take Part.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*92FKpolvEx8izJyZ5IMtFw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The 1931 Virgil Pageant, written, performed, and staged by GFS students</figcaption></figure><p>The inspiration for this pageant was, of course, the Shakespeare Tercentenary of 1916, which Harry Domincovich, the Virgil Pageant’s chief organizer and moving force, had also helped stage. But Virgil’s pageant was bigger and better than Shakespeare’s, and what would have most impressed the Progressive Education Association was that the text of the pageant was written by two senior girls, Elizabeth E. Simon and Lidie B. Saul.</p><p>GFS made the most of this pageant. The text was published in a very nice paper edition; Domi, Poley, and Yarnall mined it for articles in education journals; there was even a movie made of the pageant which was advertised in educational journals (a copy of this movie is in the GFS Archives). Years later Yarnall was still reporting to the School Committee letters of praise he had received about the Virgil Pageant.</p><p><em>The Pastorian </em>printed a lengthy description of the pageant in the June 1931 issue which began “Wednesday May Sixth! One day in our lives we shall never forget… Promptly at two-thirty the bugle blew and people began moving onto the stage [at Wister Brown Field]. Joe Stokes, the emperor, appeared with his friends, lictors, and court ladies, and the School sang Horace’s ‘Carmen Saeculare.’ Then the crowd dispersed and left Augustus with his court and the Roman Provinces to celebrate the closing of the gates of the Temple of Janus as a symbol of peace throughout the empire. The fifth class [seventh grade] girls did a very interesting Italian Peasant dance as Roman provinces, saluted the emperor, and went out followed by Augustus and his party, who left Virgil [C. West Churchman] alone on the stage. In his solitary reflection, he felt the urge to write an epic which would remind the Romans of their past and bring back the old patriotism and religion. His thoughts of former times were portrayed by the ensuing scenes.” There was even a Trojan horse built by sophomore boys.</p><p>In his report to the School Committee, Irvin Poley (Yarnall was in the hospital with a bad knee and missed the pageant) described it as “one of the biggest weeks in the school’s life” and “a triumphant outcome of weeks of work.”</p><p>The importance of the Virgil Festival was not so much the event as its timing. Few schools were willing to devote so much time and energy to a singular event. Few schools were willing to let a talented teacher like Domincovich run with his enthusiasm, engage students in his dream, and recruit colleagues to lend their time and talent. Fewer schools would risk such a grand fantasy in the midst of the Depression. GFS was willing to do all that— and attracted attention from the Carnegie and PEA people when they looked for their thirty experimental schools.</p><p>Yarnall first proposed joining the Eight-Year Study in 1932. After gaining approval from the School Committee, he appointed a faculty committee, chaired by Domincovich, to draw up a proposal. The report (undated, but certainly 1933) concluded that “we are not satisfied with our present secondary curriculum.” Committee member D.L. Burgess was scathing. The High School, he said, “had a long way to go to catch up” with Marjorie Hardy’s Primary curriculum.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UbSO6utyCx8xGo0PNizE_Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>GFS’s announcement of changes in curriculum for the Eight Year Study</figcaption></figure><p>In general, the faculty agreed that there needed to be more history, science, art, and music in the upper grades. This would be achieved by reducing the required courses for tenth through twelfth grades to only four: English, history, Bible, and PE elective. Courses in math, historical geology, art, music, economics, public speaking, and drama would be offered initially with the possibility of more electives later. The language teachers opposed the change. In the language of the report (clearly written by Poley), “After stoutly arguing the indispensability of Latin (or French) for each class, the embattled linguists… whose ox was gored… accepted grudgingly.”</p><p>GFS was formally announced as a participant in the experiment in 1933. Most of the thirty schools were independent ones, but a few public schools participated as well. In the Philadelphia area, the other participating schools were Baldwin School, George School, and Tower Hill School in Wilmington, whose headmaster, Burton Fowler, became a frequent visitor to GFS.</p><p>Faculty from the schools in the Eight-Year Study met regularly in conferences and workshops to compare ideas and note what changes worked well. Some schools launched wholesale reforms, such as abandoning traditional academic departments in favor of interdisciplinary courses. GFS was comparatively moderate in its approach. Take music as an example. A new required course in singing was added to the intermediate grades in 1934 (but only two periods a week); choral music was offered as an elective in grades ten through twelve (but only three times a week—there was still no music or art major); in 1937 a minor elective in musical appreciation was started.</p><p>Yarnall was happy with this. He told the School Committee in 1933 that GFS “was decidedly on the conservative wing of the movement, and rather well satisfied, if the truth must be told, that such is the case… I do not believe that any of our Committee need fear that we are going off on wild tangents.”</p><p>The Eight-Year Study followed students after graduation through their college careers. Eric Johnson ’36, remembered being interviewed twice a year while at Harvard “and the study seemed to show that students from the experimental schools did a little better academically” than the other schools. “The changes we made were, indeed, not radical ones. The older boys and girls still know when they are studying English and when they are studying history. The intergradation we work for is that achieved by the individual for himself with the help of as much wise guidance as we can muster… Correlation between subjects we make when it seems wise, but never correlation for the sake of correlation…”</p><p>The specific changes Poley emphasized were (1) a three-year course in world history for grades ten through twelve; (2) greater opportunity for advanced study in science; (3) more art and music; and (4) greater individual choice. He gave as an example: “One boy, very able in science and mathematics but almost incapable of learning French or Latin, was allowed to spend most of his time—what was left after required English and social science—in the fields he was good in—astronomy, physical geography, chemistry, physics, biology, mathematics—and is now doing well in a college of excellent standing.” There were trade-offs. Fewer students took French and Latin, but those who did were more committed and enthusiastic. “We believe in at least one foreign language for all but the very few,” Poley assured the alumni, but in general “fewer people take fewer languages further,” and he thought that wise. The most important contribution of the Eight-Year Study, Poley thought, was that it helped students become self-determined. “Guidance interviews were once filled with such expressions as, ‘Oh, I don’t suppose I have much choice. I might want to go to Williams, so I’d better keep my Latin,’ and ‘I don’t care. Which will give me more credits?’ Much more frequently than not we hear now, ‘Couldn’t I possibly do more than five majors? I want both Math and Latin, and I must have some analytical chemistry.’ The boys and girls are now taking an active part in planning their own schooling. That doesn’t mean they can elect anything they want and drop it as soon as it’s hard. More than half of them want to attempt too much rather than too little. But we have been too to some extent successful in eliminating a faith in drudgery for the sake of drudgery; we don’t hold to the theory that, since life won’t be easy after school, boys and girls should necessarily pursue the subjects they like least for the sake of their character.”</p><p>One happy result not mentioned by Poley was that the old system of naming classes (Fifth Class for seventh grade, Fourth Class for eighth grade, and so on) was replaced in 1933 by the more usual K through twelve nomenclature.</p><p>Stanley Yarnall more and more turned over educational questions to Poley and Hardy during the 1930s. He still kept the school reins firmly in his hands, but he let them run their divisions week to week and encouraged them to initiate and battle for changes in curriculum and scheduling. Master Stanley had enough to do keeping the school afloat during the Depression.</p><p>Marjorie Hardy was busy making the GFS Primary a model for progressive schools around the county. In her first report to the School Committee in 1930, she “found the school strong in many respects and weak in others…” The weakness included a lack of student order and discipline, faculty professionalism, and lack of play space. She worked hard at correcting all three.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*29eh3ClLKyE17lWIoL6Plg.png" /><figcaption>Marjorie Hardy with student in Friends Free Library</figcaption></figure><p>Even though a renowned “progressive educator,” Marjorie Hardy fit right in to Yarnall’s “conservative progressive” philosophy. She was liberal about curriculum, but strict about good order. She announced right away some new rules: Students would walk in the halls on the right side; there would be no yelling; students in class would listen attentively and never interrupt; students would speak “in no voice louder than the natural speaking voice.” She told the governing board, “I am interested in providing conditions to develop good emotional balance, character, clear thinking, and good study habits along with intellectual achievement. Many factors contribute to such development, and better order is one necessary factor.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*2mVLZYgkcKJDx3khvSvoJg.png" /><figcaption>Students using typewriters as part of the “typewriter experiment”</figcaption></figure><p>Teachers who did not go along with her program were fired. Esther Arnold, for example, had taught penmanship in the Primary since 1918. Hardy disliked Arnold’s “drill-oriented approach” and thought penmanship was outdated. Arnold refused to change and so Hardy fired her. In her place, Hardy introduced “the typewriter experiment.” All GFS students would learn how to use the new machine. The Smith-Corona company, eager to expand its market, lent the school enough typewriters so that every Primary student could use one. The experiment was supposed to produce neater work, better spelling, and more clearly ordered written work. It had mixed results, but it is a good illustration of Hardy’s eagerness to embrace new technology and new ideas. When the experiment ended, in 1932, the school purchased sixty-two typewriters for student use.</p><p>Central to Hardy’s ideas of progressive change was making social studies the core of the curriculum. She despised the “old idea of memorization of isolated facts in history, geography, and civics” and wanted to develop a “unified” curriculum revolving around a central theme. In 1932, Hardy announced the result of a year-long curriculum study. The Kindergarten would introduce the theme of community and look at how the local community interacted with the family. First graders looked at the intersections of different kinds of regional communities, rural and urban, with particular attention to issues of transportation and communication. Second graders focused on pre- industrial communities, specifically North American Indians. The third grade looked at navigation, boats, and world exploration as local, regional, industrial and pre-industrial communities merged into a global economy. It is a stunningly modern social studies curriculum, and it is far in advance of most educational thought in the 1930s. Hardy made it the core of the Primary.</p><p>She also pioneered other changes that have become permanent parts of the school. Graded report cards were dropped in favor of written teacher reports; there were parent-teacher conferences twice each year; every Primary grade had a parent committee to plan activities, supervise special events, and host parties. The Parents’ Auxiliary, later the Parents’ Association, grew out of Hardy’s efforts.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*-eH5mjU47cw3tElSb5AHtA.png" /><figcaption>Joseph Cadbury and students feeding a goat</figcaption></figure><p>Inspired by the Eight-Year Study, Hardy enlarged the science curriculum in the Primary. For years, the only special science class in the Primary grades had been School Committee member Margaret Cary’s “Nature Studies.” According to her daughter-in-law, Betty Cary, Margaret Cary’s course, at least for the higher Primary, was really sex education. In 1933, at Hardy’s urging, the school bolstered the Primary science curriculum by hiring Joseph Cadbury part-time to teach science to all Lower School classes. Cadbury would eventually become a full-time teacher, and over the years, a legend. He was really a naturalist, not a scientist, but he stirred student interest in the natural world for two generations.</p><p>Hardy also fought for full-time teachers for the Primary in PE and music, and won both battles. She was even able to gain play space for the Primary when she convinced the School Committee to give the Primary one of the three girls’ tennis courts on Greene Street for a playground. Her victory was short- term, however. In 1935 part of that play space was used to build the four-year Kindergarten building.</p><p><strong>Stanley Yarnall’s last decade was not a happy one. </strong>“He stayed too long,” Henry Scattergood says, and the written records bear that out. The Depression weighed on him heavily. While Germantown Friends School seems to have managed the Depression better than most institutions, there was sacrifice— and the burden was laid on the faculty, to Yarnall’s sorrow.</p><p>The GFS “family” in the thirties was overwhelmingly middle to upper middle class. The parents who sent their children to the school were professionals, managers, and civil servants. Many of these families could look back to generations of wealth, which had been conservatively invested with the intention that it would see them through hard times. The great Depression, which destroyed the lives of great numbers of working Americans, did not touch this central core of GFS families and directors.</p><p>The students reflected their parents’ values, of course, and were conservative on the great political and social issues of the time. In mock elections, Republicans swept the GFS field. In 1932, for example, Hoover defeated Roosevelt in a student poll by a landslide, and students voted Republican all through the Depression years.</p><p>Student essays in <em>The Pastorian</em>, which became essentially a literary magazine in the thirties, were distinctly conservative. Insofar as student essays dealt with contemporary affairs, and they seldom did, they deplored the failures of ordinary people to take advantage of opportunities or deplored the ordinary person’s lack of faith in free enterprise. <em>The Pastorian </em>usually featured high-minded calls for “a better world” short on analysis or detail. The closest a student publication came to dealing with the Depression was a <em>Pastorian </em>interview in 1932 with Morris Leeds, clerk of the School Committee and president of Leeds and Northrup. “Is there really a Depression, Mr. Leeds?,” was the <em>Pastorian </em>question. “Yes,” Leeds answered, “but these ups and downs should be expected.”</p><p>While students, parents, and School Committee members found the Depression a distant problem, GFS faculty had their salaries cut. In October 1932, without prior warning, the teachers were told that their salaries for the rest of the year would be cut by ten percent. The 1933-34 budget cut their salaries an additional ten percent.</p><p>Other independent schools were also cutting faculty salaries, as the school was quick to report. GFS was right in the middle-range of salary reductions, and, moreover, GFS had not yet fired faculty to reduce costs—a statement the School Committee made official in its 1933 report. But later in 1933, GFS started firing full-time employees.</p><p>Tuition remained constant from 1927 to 1937 at $350 per year maximum. The School Committee took pride in that fact. They meant for GFS to be more affordable than other Independent Schools, and $350 put it in the lower third among Philadelphia private schools. To maintain that low tuition meant lowering teachers’ wages, and the School Committee decided to do that.</p><p>Enrollment dropped from 637 in 1930 (near capacity) to 575 in 1935. That would be a serious drop for any school, but for one without much endowment it was very serious. In the financial reports for the 1930s, tuition amounted to over 90% of operating costs, and so the enrollment decline was more important for GFS than for other schools.</p><p>Yarnall and the School Committee cut costs where they could. Maintenance costs were deferred. The School stopped its contributions to the faculty retirement fund, and salaries were cut again by 10% in 1935, although a quarter of that cut was restored at the end of the year.</p><p><strong>Yarnall fought hard for his faculty.</strong> By 1938 the enrollment decline had been slowed and turned around. Yarnall reported 590 students that year and announced that there would be no more salary cuts.</p><p>Finances continued to be a worry, however. In May 1939, Thomas Shipley, clerk of the Finance Committee, warned that “the situation was still critical” and wondered if the school was operating “in a business like way.” Yarnall could not have been pleased by that remark nor by Shipley’s subsequent claim that the school was overstaffed.</p><p>The struggle was hard on Yarnall. He walked more slowly now, often with a cane. He had turned sixty-five in 1935 and had warned the School Committee that he could not go on forever. He suggested that the Committee begin to look for his successor, but the Committee took no action.</p><p>He was becoming more irascible. Henry Scattergood ’29, who was hired in 1933 (after teaching at Sidwell Friends for two years following his graduation from Haverford; he would leave GFS in 1937 to study for his Masters degree at Harvard) remembers Yarnall losing his temper with faculty members.</p><p>The surviving records of the Parents’ Auxiliary and the Alumni Association both hint at difficulties with Yarnall. The Alumni, for example, twice sent special emissaries to Yarnall in 1939 to work out differences about issues never specified exactly in their minutes. The school was becoming uneasy with Yarnall’s leadership and he, understandably after almost a half-century, was impatient with criticism.</p><p>Late in 1938 Yarnall made it clear to the School Committee that he meant to retire as soon as they could find a new principal. This time they responded. On January 5, 1939, the Committee appointed a Search Committee from its members to find a new principal. This was a first in GFS history.</p><p><strong>Irvin Poley desperately wanted to be principal.</strong> He felt he deserved it. He had served the school long and well, had brought it distinction, was acclaimed far and wide as the symbol of GFS teaching excellence.</p><p>He had just taken on a new administrative responsibility. In 1939 GFS abolished the Intermediate School, absorbing the fifth and sixth grades into Marjorie Hardy’s Lower School and moving the seventh into an Upper School. This new arrangement would last more than fifty years, and Poley was its architect. He was named the new head of the Upper School.</p><p>Poley was experienced, dedicated, and committed to a progressive course of education, and he had administrative experience at every level in the school. He was especially encouraged when, as he later recounted to friends, one (and sometimes he said more than one) of the members of the Search Committee assured him he was their choice. “Of course we want thee to be principal, Irvin; there can be no other choice,” is how he remembered the words of one Committee person.</p><p>It was not to be, and it was the greatest disappointment of his life.</p><p>Thomas Shipley had become clerk of the School Committee and Shipley wanted a principal with business principles. Poley was a visionary, just a teacher, impractical. He was also — although this is never stated in the record — not “manly” enough for the businessmen who dominated the governing board. Could Poley balance a budget? Was he hard enough to fire faculty? The businessmen who dominated the Committee knew that times were still tough, and they judged Irvin Poley, who had demonstrated his determination in other, less recognizable ways, not tough enough for the job.</p><p><strong>Next: </strong>The Future Is Yours Rather Than Mine<strong><br>Previously: </strong><a href="https://ironyofa.medium.com/a-vision-realized-65d1990ce622">A Vision Realized</a></p><p><strong><em>Notes</em></strong></p><p>1 “The Play is Now the Thing” was published in the <em>Alumni Record</em>, February 1957, and as Chapter 21 of <em>Speaking of Teaching</em>.</p><p>2 Henry Scattergood, interview with Bill Koons, July 1990.</p><p>3 From “What Every Young Teacher Ought to Know,” <em>The Clearing House</em>, Vol. 19, №5, January, 1945.</p><p>4 Henry Scattergood, interview with Bill Koons, July 1990.</p><p>5 Henry Scattergood, interview with Bill Koons, July 1990.</p><p>6 David Mallery, “Irvin C. Poley and GFS: An Unforgettable Legacy,” <em>Alumni Record</em>, Fall 1974.</p><p>7 “The Spiral Approach to Composition,” from which these excerpts come, in Chapter 5 of <em>Speaking of Teaching.</em></p><p>8 “Teaching Obliquely and Testing Directly,” Chapter 7 in <em>Speaking of Teaching</em>.</p><p>9 “The Play is Now the Thing,” <em>Alumni Record</em>, February 1957.</p><p>10 Henry Scattergood, interview with Bill Koons, July 1990.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bfe0573fda90" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Vision Realized]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/a-vision-realized-65d1990ce622?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/65d1990ce622</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 Aug 2021 15:23:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-24T15:31:47.627Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>It’s the 1920s, and athletics continue to expand, with GFS dominating the soccer season. Tensions with the Meeting grow as the school plans to enlarge both its student body and its campus footprint. New pricing means that tuition for seniors is now $300 and Kindergartners $100 — but they get their own newly-built stand-alone building. And, for the first time, teachers receive pensions.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0otlXOdVucxHRDFjvYvMtQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The 1925 expansion of Main Building, in progress</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>(</em></strong><a href="https://medium.com/p/840551fc7e98/"><strong><em>Introduction to this series</em></strong></a><strong><em>)</em></strong></p><p><strong>Stanley Yarnall was still dreaming</strong> of expansion and new buildings. In 1919 he asked his teachers to divide into sub-committees to prepare a comprehensive plan “for the school’s physical needs.” It was quite a want list. The plan called for a new gymnasium, larger classrooms for the High School, a new science laboratory, more space in the Primary, a Kindergarten building, a larger collection room, a larger cafeteria, and higher salaries. He presented the list to the School Committee in May 1919. They turned it down.¹</p><p>The Committee’s reluctance is understandable. They had spent over $100,000 on construction in the preceding decade. They were worried about rising tuition costs, and, in addition, at the same time Yarnall was badgering them about purchasing the Wistar Brown field. The Committee “was united” in saying no.</p><p>Yarnall was irritated. “In the history of the school, as I have observed it, there are appropriate times to accomplish certain things and if these opportunities are embraced their effect is reflected in the teaching force and the student body. Dangers, objections and possible improvements can be brought up in connection with any scheme for building or other growth or extension in any school or business undertaking, and I trust this Committee can take counsel of its hopes rather than of its fears.”²</p><p>One Committee member who agreed with Yarnall was the prominent business leader Morris L. Leeds. In 1920, Leeds became clerk of the Committee and together, he and Yarnall would launch the greatest expansion in the school’s history.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/484/1*hwWiqrL6IDfntxJvoEBxjQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>GFS faculty in 1918. Stanley Yarnall is standing at far left.</figcaption></figure><p>GFS was a prosperous place in 1920. Enrollment was 557 and growing, and while this created crowded conditions, it also created annual surpluses of about $10,000 which had paid down the accumulated debt. Budget figures show that income had increased from $44,582 in 1911 to $146,384 ten years later. In 1923 the treasurer, Thomas Potts, reported a surplus of over $16,000. The assessed value of the school property was $507,500. Tuition, contrary to Committee fears, was low and in the bottom quartile of Philadelphia independent schools. In 1920 tuition ranged from $100 for Kindergarten to $300 for seniors. A full twelve-year education would cost a family in 1920 only $2,360. The school’s academic reputation was excellent; its playing fields were the finest in the city; there was a long waiting list for admission. Prospects were good.</p><p>There were compelling reasons to expand besides the crowded school rooms. Teacher salaries, especially for women, were low. The highest paid woman teacher in 1920, Edith Knight, earned $1,500, and the average was $1,000 (men still earned twice that). Expansion and higher enrollment ought to afford general salary increases for both men and women, Leeds and Yarnall argued. Yarnall himself was paid $4,500 in 1920. The situation for women teachers had been eased somewhat in 1919 when friends of the school, principally Arthur Leeds, purchased <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivy_Lodge">Ivy Lodge</a>, the old mansion on East Penn Street, and converted it into low-rent apartments for ten women teachers. In 1920 its owners deeded Ivy Lodge to the School Committee.</p><p>The School Committee was rapidly coming around to Leeds’s and Yarnall’s point of view. An important figure on the Committee was Margaret Cary, the clerk of the Advisory Committee. In a large School Committee of twenty-five, the small Advisory Committee had become a kind of inner circle or executive board which set the agenda for the larger group. Cary supported a plan for expansion.</p><p>In 1921 Yarnall resubmitted his comprehensive plan of 1919. He had two points to make. First, the school had to grow; it could not shrink and remain competitive with other private schools in the area. Second, the time to expand was now because overcrowding interfered with education. The gym and lunchroom were both too small, “totally inadequate.” Classes in the Main and Primary Buildings “are always crowded and frequently pupils are obliged to sit on the window sills. At our daily assemblies the older girls have to sit on chairs in a ratio of three to two, and thirty boys either have to stand or sit on the window sills.” He quoted from a report by science teacher Iro Trublood: “The room where Nature Study is now taught has no place where plants will grow, no place for as much as a bowl of goldfish…and about four pupils in a Botany class can get proper light to work if they are using microscopes or making drawings. There is no place where children doing elementary science can try experiments or carry out their own projects.”</p><p>He added a personal note. “We cannot, without a real loss to the school, go on more than another year as we are now doing. 1923-1924 will be my twenty- fifth year of service to the school. Perhaps it is only personal ambition, but I think it is a laudable one, to desire earnestly that in that year the Germantown Friends School may perfect plans to enable our teachers to do their work with sufficient space and adequate facilities.” The School Committee was convinced and approved “in principle” the plan.</p><p>The Advisory Committee recommended, and the full Committee agreed, to a two-part program. Two smaller projects would come first—the construction of a separate Kindergarten behind the Meetinghouse and a locker room at Wistar Brown Field. Both would be financed by using a surplus of funds in the treasury as collateral, and both new buildings were completed and opened for use in 1923. The second, and grander, part of the program was a capital campaign to solve all of the school’s other physical needs in one stroke. They would build a large T-shaped addition to the front of the Main Building and a new, large, up-to-date gymnasium. The gymnasium construction would necessitate the purchase of a back portion of the property belonging to the Pennsbury Home and the destruction of the horse sheds behind the Meetinghouse. All this would not only end the crowding, but permit even greater numbers to enroll. The Committee thought 630 about right.</p><p>The Committee began immediately to make plans to raise the estimated $200,000 needed for all the improvements. It would be the first capital drive for the school since Alfred Cope’s in 1869, and the theme would be the celebration of Master Stanley’s twenty-five years. Yarnall must have been pleased, and probably surprised, by the sweep of the plans. After years of persuasion, argument, and pleading he finally had a School Committee that thought the way he did.</p><p>Almost, it would appear, as an afterthought, the Committee notified the Monthly Meeting of its plans and asked its approval. Unexpectedly, Monthly Meeting said no.</p><p>Monthly Meeting was growing wary of the school. It was already bigger than the Meeting, with a bigger budget, more buildings, more people. Already it had taken over much of the space at Germantown and Coulter and torn up grass and cut down ancient trees. Now it proposed to enlarge again? Many Meeting members were not pleased by the idea. Was this not a classic case of the tail wagging the dog? The Meeting told the School Committee to stop its plans. The Meeting would have to study this.</p><p><strong>The School Committee was shocked.</strong> They had, presumably, expected the same kind of approval they had been given in 1915—do what thee thinks is right. The Committee braced itself for an argument. Stanley Yarnall must have been stunned. To come so close to his dream, and then be blocked by an unexpected obstacle, was a blow. Had he pushed too hard, too fast? Did some members of the Meeting regard this plan as evidence of personal ambition? He never admitted to either of these thoughts. For the record, all he expressed was his “deep concern” with the Meeting’s “problem.”</p><p>A special committee (Quakers love committees) of the Monthly Meeting was formed to study the proposed expansion. Chaired by Alfred Scattergood, it met once a week for nine weeks in the winter of 1923-24 trying to find consensus “of more or less divergent views.” In its report, some of the Meeting’s worries were spelled out.</p><p>“The School has now become so large an enterprise and involves such heavy financial and administrative responsibilities that it raises the serious question whether it may at some time overtax the material and spiritual resources of the Meeting.”</p><p>“The erection of further buildings on the Meeting’s grounds is not welcomed by this committee nor probably by anyone…”</p><p>“Another objection that has been raised is that we are not justified in spending as much as $200,000 or more on our own school, which already has many advantages, when there are so many urgent needs calling for our help in the country and abroad.”</p><p>In January 1924, Edward Evans, for the special committee, sent the School Committee a series of Queries to answer. The first Query reveals another, and more important, objection. Why should the Meeting spend money to enlarge the school when only 25% of the students are Friends? It is a question that would come up again, later, in GFS history.</p><p>The School Committee’s answer to this and the other queries is one of the finest testaments in GFS history. It was passionate, eloquent, and, at times, angry.</p><p>Why should the Meeting fund a school where only 25% [actually 21%] of the students were Quakers? Because Quaker children should experience eco- education; because Quaker children should know diverse views; and co- education and diverse views require a larger school.</p><p>Yarnall had no obvious hand in the Committee’s responses. Evidently, and wisely, he chose to lie low. He must have been proud of the School Committee’s answers, however. It was the doctrine he had been preaching for years. In this, not in buildings, lies his greatest triumph. “The pupils who pass through our school become familiar with the view and spirit of the Society of Friends and towards the end of their course are harmonious and sympathetic in their attitudes toward Quakerism. We are not, therefore, throughout our school dealing with aliens or strangers to our views. Some members of the Meeting may feel that the children who are not Friends are a dangerous and antagonistic element with whom our children are thrown and who have to be guarded against. This is not the belief of the committee. We feel rather that the Meeting has a great opportunity in providing a school so developed that our children receive a rounded education, physical, intellectual, and spiritual… where at the same time a large number of earnest children of our community, their families and their friends, come under the same influence, and learn to value, respect, and often love, the fundamental things for which Quakerism stands for.</p><p>“Interruption at this time with the plan which the School Committee has so carefully considered, and believe to be right, will inevitably mar and thwart this great work. If such action is taken, the burden and proof rests not on the School Committee, but on the Meeting. Can the Meeting provide a substitute that will be as influential or far reaching in building Quakerism in our children or in extending the message of Quakerism beyond our borders?”</p><p>Some of the answers to the queries had a decided edge. Query: Are there not more important things to spend our money on? “Is the Meeting so busy sending workers and money to the great populations of Germany, Russia, and France that it minimizes the opportunity of intensive work among its immediate neighbors?” Query: Cannot the school continue as it is? “It is unworthy of our Meeting to tolerate inferior standards and low ideals of educational service, even if there are present indications that we can ‘get by with it’ financially.” In a specific reference to the “only 25% Friends” argument, the Committee noted “there are those who fear that the letting down of bars along lines of dancing, movies, theaters, etc. on the part of some parents of Friends children has been brought about by the pressures of the world ideals of the 75%.” The Committee thought that theory was nonsense.</p><p>Reluctantly, and with reservations, the Monthly Meeting finally approved the expansion plans in April. “Still, the school is excellent and deserves our support. Should we not all feel that something vital and inspiring had passed out of the life of the Meeting” if the school disappeared?</p><p><strong>It had been a titanic struggle</strong>, however civilized the record appears. The forces in favor of a guarded education had been defeated, finally and forever. The Class of 1924, Tyson Stokes’s class, back from their frolic at Exton, had commissioned artist <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violet_Oakley">Violet Oakley</a> to design a new school seal with the lines from Ecclesiastes “Behold, I set before Thee an Open Door.” It was exquisite timing, and if in 1924 the school still wasn’t open, expansion made possible greater diversity in the next decade.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/225/1*2Fw9HsesxWupxdBKBmxNrA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Violet Oakley’s seal for GFS, commissioned by the Class of 1924</figcaption></figure><p>The Meeting demanded several assurances before approving the capital drive. They wanted an end to the “creeping enrollment increases” that had characterized all of Yarnall’s years and an absolute cap on enrollment of 630. The plans called for solicitation of non-Friends, and this bothered Edward Evans, in particular. He demanded that it be made clear that while Friends welcomed their money, non-Friends should not think they would have any influence in running the school. Additionally, there should be no construction begun until all the money had been raised or pledged. There must be absolutely no more debt incurred.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G4ACcmu7tDzsP1uyfbSzGw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Architect’s rendering of the Main Building extension. The Meeting objected to the un-Quakerly style and demanded that it be simplified.</figcaption></figure><p>Finally, the Meeting’s approval was contingent on changes in the architect’s design for the new T-shaped addition. The proposed front appeared to some members as pretentious and un-Quakerly. They demanded it be changed to fit with the style of the Meetinghouse.</p><p>Because of the delay in gaining Meeting approval, Yarnall missed celebrating his twenty-fifth anniversary in the new buildings. Not until November 1924 was enough money on hand to let a construction contract, and the Main addition and gymnasium were not completed until 1925. Members of the Meeting contributed over half of the funds raised.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/483/1*v7I7mwbINEWws_yiYTgOww.png" /><figcaption>Main Building shortly after the 1925 expansion</figcaption></figure><p>The new buildings in 1925 completed the creation of the modern school. There would be much rearrangement of walls and partitions over the coming years, but the GFS almost every alumnus/a who reads this remembers was essentially in place from that year. The Main Building was now fifty-five feet closer to Coulter Street than it had been. The elegant, rounded, pillared portico was replaced by the current, and more severe, two-story porch. The collection room (renamed “assembly room” in 1927 and today’s Poley Auditorium) was complete; the front hall was almost the same as today, including the front hall table that has been the exclusive domain of seniors in recent years. The 1925 gymnasium (today’s A.A. Smith Gym) is almost entirely unchanged.</p><p>Yarnall reported the teachers well satisfied with the new buildings. Not only was there now enough space to work in, the quality of the school life seemed improved. There was less “rush and hurry” in the school day. Yarnall, too, was satisfied. This marked the end of his building epoch; in the remaining sixteen years he served as principal, there would be no new major construction.</p><p>While the twenties brought great changes in the physical appearance of the school, the schooling itself changed little. Every year, every eighth grader studied <em>A Midsummer Night’s Dream</em>, American history and civics, and the life of Christ, and he or she know, inevitably, that the next year would bring <em>Julius Caesar</em>, “English Constitutional History,” and “The beginnings of Christianity, based on The Acts, with especial reference to the life of Paul.” A child in third grade know that he or she would be reading <a href="https://www.google.com/books/edition/An_American_History/kHEAAAAAYAAJ?hl=en">Muzzey’s <em>An American History</em></a><em> </em>textbook as a senior. Course descriptions in the school catalogues are the same, virtually word for word, from 1920–1929.³</p><p>The same situation was true for the Primary. The curriculum was frozen, and much of the classwork was based on memorization and repetition. Students sat at their desks and recited. To cite just one example, in third grade students used the <a href="https://www.google.com/books/edition/The_Horace_Mann_Readers/keAOAQAAMAAJ?hl=en"><em>Horace Mann Readers: Book III</em></a>, a spelling workbook, a grammar workbook, a geography workbook, and an arithmetic textbook (multiplication and long division). Progressive educators like Irvin Poley were unhappy with this curriculum. He considered much of it “dry as dust drudgery.” Poley had been director of the Intermediate School and was now vice principal. He thought the Primary could do a great deal more to prepare students for the upper grades by exciting and enlivening the curriculum. “There is truth as well as beauty in Masefield’s line, <a href="https://www.theotherpages.org/poems/gp1_11.html">‘The days that make us happy make us wise.’</a>” He later wrote that “most of us do drudgery — and we are the better for doing some of it — only when it is necessary for success in reaching a goal. In a modern school…surely competence, let alone distinction, depends on more than bored, unhappy, but doggedly persistent study.”⁴ In the Primary as well as the upper grades, students received marks of A, B, C, etc. There were no comments on their strengths or weaknesses. There were no parent conferences, no individual student projects, and almost no art; there was only one period of music a week, and no special science class. There was just <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sloyd#:~:text=Sloyd%20(Swedish%20Sl%C3%B6jd)%2C%20also,until%20the%20early%2020th%20Century.">Sloyd</a> for boys and sewing for girls.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/484/1*wXmf9oBPJ94Nhmc-FkFkCw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A Lower School classroom in 1927</figcaption></figure><p>In 1927 Poley was granted a leave of absence to study the “newest and most progressive educational ideas” at the University of Chicago. His return in 1928 sparked the first changes in the curriculum and were directed at the Primary School.</p><p>The principal of the Primary was Elizabeth T. Roberts, who had been at GFS since 1900 and principal since 1914. Poley and Yarnall were convinced she was not going to change. “While she understands some of the aims and ideals of the newer education, she has not been able to put those ideals into action.” They persuaded the School Committee to force her retirement after one more year. In the meanwhile, Poley would experiment with curriculum changes and report the strengths and weaknesses of the Primary program.</p><p><strong>Poley’s impact is immediately evident.</strong> In a 1928 report, one Primary class “is assembling properties and costumes to dramatize Hansel and Gretel;” and others are reported as building a Mexican village and visiting the zoo. The next year the first grade built a small town. “Thought, observation and planning, and cooperation are needed on the part of the workers to turn cartons into houses, garages, schools, yellow American stores, etc.” In another classroom there were “pictures of engines, paper trains, wooden trains, sentences on the board about trains. A visit to Broad Street Station, and an unexpected tour through the new green train which had just brought the Cubs from Chicago to play baseball was one of the thrills of this study.”</p><p>Elizabeth Roberts’s retirement raised a serious issue for the school, and not for the first time. There was no pension plan for retired teachers, and Miss Roberts had no money. As a stop-gap measure, a part-time job as Primary School librarian was created for her. Earlier teachers who had retired without means and had received special grants of charity from the School Committee. Roberts’s predecessor as Primary principal, Elizabeth Forsythe, for example, had been the object of a charitable appeal (“she is going blind, her brother is already blind”), and the funds had been raised for a small private annuity. The same thing had been done for “Teacher Jennie” (Jane S. Jones) and Jane Raley. Roberts’s forced retirement, along with that of Edith Knight (to be described below), forced the school to face reality. A case-by-case charity system was just not adequate, not to mention demeaning to the teachers. After years of study and delay, GFS finally joined the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teachers_Insurance_and_Annuity_Association_of_America#History">TIAA</a> pension annuity program in 1930.</p><p>The Primary school was headed in a progressive direction after 1928. That was assured, and the pace of change would accelerate, with the appointment of Marjorie Hardy as the new Primary principal in April 1930. A graduate of the University of Chicago, with eleven years of experience in the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_Chicago_Laboratory_Schools#History">laboratory school</a> there, Hardy was a nationally known progressive educator. She was the <a href="http://worldcat.org/identities/lccn-no2007076144/">author of numerous journal articles and the <em>Child’s Own Way </em>series</a> of elementary readers. Her acceptance of the GFS post is evidence of the school’s growing reputation.</p><p>The Intermediate and High School curricula changed little in the twenties, in part because GFS had become a mainly college prep school, and college admissions required a conservative approach. Each year Yarnall reported a higher number of graduates and a higher percentage of them going to college. He admitted to the School Committee in 1923 that “Our work in High School must more and more be determined by college entrance requirements.”</p><p>There were some progressive teachers in the upper grades. There was Poley, of course. His classroom techniques will be described in chapter five. Iro Trueblood was a progressive. “Our children too much get the idea that they can only learn through books, that they cannot really get first-hand knowledge from things. Most of the situations they must deal with later in life have nothing to do with books. I should like to do much of my teaching by having children deal more with the environment and less with books.”</p><p>But most of the High School teachers were traditionalists. Domincovich and Burgess taught by lecture and by line explication of texts. Bennett and Herman Breininger appointed in 1920, in science and math were also educational conservatives. It is worth noting, however, that GFS students scored their highest marks on standardized tests and college boards in the conservative departments of English, science, and math. Even Irvin Poley admitted that progressive education was not the only approach to learning.</p><p>Henry Scattergood recalled that the classes he took in the twenties were very conservative. “They were recitations, not discussions. The teacher would ask a question and you would answer it. Then the teacher would ask another question. There was definite homework every night—so many lines to translate, factual questions to answer…” Students had no free time. “You were either in class or in study hall. We were scheduled. We didn’t know how to use free time because we weren’t given any,” Scattergood remembers. He believes this was the greatest weakness in the education he received at GFS. “We didn’t learn how to use free time.”⁵</p><p>The curriculum in the upper grades was “lock step,” Scattergood remembers. If, for example, you wanted to take Latin and French, you couldn’t take biology or European history. Choices were determined by the schedule.</p><p>The weakest GFS departments in the 1920s, judged by the scores on college boards, were history and French. “Uncle Joe” Price, head of the history department, was a “character” fondly remembered by alumni and indulged by Yarnall. The principal repeatedly explained students’ low scores in history as “not Mr. Price’s fault.” Howard Platt, like Price, a long-term teacher, was added to the history faculty to teach social studies in 1926.</p><p>French was another matter. Edith Knight, the head of the language department, was sixty-two years old and in poor health. She had been a faculty member since 1907, and she did not want to retire. Yarnall and Advisory Committee chair Margaret Cary forced her out anyway. Cary described it as “one of the most unhappy months your Principal and I have had in either of our lives” and hoped “that time will heal the wounds.” The Knight case painfully pointed out the need for a pension plan.⁶ Lucille Hiatt was given charge of the French department.</p><p>The most important change in the Intermediate and High School program was the slow but steady advance of music and drama. Yarnall remained hesitant about music. He wrote in 1923 “I am not sure we want to launch into an elaborate program of musical education in the Germantown Friends School, but doubtless we do want to make some improvement within conservative limits.”</p><p>Pressure from parents had forced him to permit a Girls’ Glee Club in the High School beginning in 1920. He later recalled that “A few parents musically inclined insisted. Long and incredulous deliberations. Reluctant consent. Judicious purchase of a piano and the mischief was done and the camel’s nose was under the tent flap.”⁷</p><p>Alumni who remember the Gilbert and Sullivan productions of the 1930s or the explosion of music that followed the arrival of the incredible Mary Brewer in 1942 would not be impressed with the music program of the twenties — but it was an important transition period.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/484/1*uwjIZKUavtbaTnLefDSU8A.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Glee Club, 1923</figcaption></figure><p>The Glee Club gave one concert a year under the direction of Elizabeth McCloskey. There were no music classes in the higher grades, and McCloskey’s part-time teaching was confined to the Primary one hour a week. The Glee Club was a voluntary, after-school activity, and, judging from Yarnall’s reports, its annual program was not of very high quality. Evidently frustrated by her part-time status, and none too popular with students anyway (“that name McCloskey strikes a feeling of terror in memory,” Eric Johnson recalled), she resigned in 1926.⁸</p><p>A GFS graduate, Margaret Eaton (“Peg”) Shane ’18, who had been teaching music at Baldwin, was hired as the first full-time music teacher in 1927. Upper School music really started with her appointment.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qiD7ks-7VXcEZWp5Sg0UvA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Mandolin Orchestra, 1918–19</figcaption></figure><p>The only music for boys prior to Shane’s appointment was a mandolin club organized in 1917–1917 by Richard Janney ’18. It, too, gave an annual concert that Yarnall found painful — and who could blame him. The club was usually about twenty boys, eighteen mandolins, one saxophone, and a piano. They hired their own director, and played “light airs.” Shane changed all this. It was at her urging that the school hired a part-time instrumental teacher “to wean the boys to different stringed instruments and higher standards.” In 1927 a boys’ orchestra was begun, directed by a young Swarthmore graduate named Isaac Battin. It would be many years, and many part-time directors later, before the orchestra was on a solid footing, however.</p><p>Additional music became available after 1926 when two teachers from the Curtis Institute primary school, which had closed, were given permission to give private lessons to GFS students in a house on Coulter Street opposite the Meetinghouse. In return, Lotta Greenup (violin) and Marjorie Paddock (piano) gave recitals once or twice a year in morning assemblies.</p><p><strong>Music became more regularly interwoven into school life.</strong> A grand piano was purchased for the assembly room. Shane organized a Junior Glee Club for Intermediate girls, and music became a regular feature of holiday celebrations and school festivals. Often individual students performed in morning assemblies, and there were sometimes guest artists. For example, in 1929 the promising young violinist Emanuele Santi gave a morning concert that prompted Yarnall to write “The fact that we are now able to have such programs with real satisfaction to our student body indicates a growing sense of appreciation for music among us. A few years ago we would have hesitated to arrange such a program, fearing that the boys and girls would not be attentive and that the occasion would let us down as a school. We can now safely predict good order on the part of practically all and true appreciation on the part of nearly all whenever we have a musical program.”</p><p>Shane also brought boys and girls together in singing ensembles, another GFS first. One student from the twenties, Deborah Smith Lutman, remembered that achievement in particular. “Peggy Shane — sharp-tongued and iron-willed had the boys as well as the girls sing in a Christmas assembly… and tears still rush to my eyes remembering that moment. Who were the boys, Rhoads Murphy, Harrie Price — what a surge of beauty she opened to us, and to the music that was followed from her visionary beginnings.” In 1929 for the first time the Glee Club and Orchestra gave a joint concert; and in 1930 a boys chorus was added to the Glee Club.⁹</p><p>Drama, too, continued a steady growth in all divisions of the school.</p><p>Primary classes frequently performed plays based on Bible stories and folk tales. Poley continued to direct scenes from plays such as <em>Twelfth Night </em>and <em>Julius Caesar </em>and <em>She Stoops to Conquer </em>as part of the seventh- and eighth- grade English course. There continued to be dramatic pageants that echoed the Shakespeare Tercentenary. For example, in 1926, to celebrate the nation’s sesquicentennial, the Primary classes presented “Early Days in Pennsylvania,” which featured music, dance, and dramatic scenes in “Indian Life,” “William Penn’s Arrival,” “Francis Daniel Pastorius,” etc.</p><p>A Poley innovation of the twenties was “Intermediate Day,” a festival usually held in Awbury Arboretum. In 1926 it was especially elaborate. To produce “Old Philadelphia Days,” Intermediate School students researched history, wrote dialogue, and borrowed costumes from old Quaker families to present six historical scenes, among them “Social Life: A Minuet at <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peggy_Shippen">Peggy Shippen</a>’s Home, July 4, 1776,“ and “Home Life: Anti-Slavery Society Holds a Quilting Bee at the Mott’s Race Street Home.” Yarnall decided this was a bit too much. He told the School Committee that the celebrations had been worthwhile, but took too much time and energy, and promised there would be nothing so elaborate staged “for some years to come.”</p><p>Better evidence of the growing importance of drama in school life was the formation of two student groups who produced their own plays. The “T.O.C.” (Thirty-One Club) was composed of seventeen girls from the Class of 1931. Coached by Ruth Poley (and rehearsing at the Poley home), they produced three short plays in 1929: <a href="https://archive.org/details/makerofdreamsfan00down"><em>The Maker of Dreams</em></a><em> </em>by Oliphant Dawn, <a href="https://www.google.com/books/edition/A_Treasury_of_Plays_for_Women/qxw6AQAAMAAJ?hl=en&amp;gbpv=1&amp;dq=Rehearsal+by+Christopher+Morley&amp;pg=PA335&amp;printsec=frontcover"><em>Rehearsal</em></a><em> </em>by Christopher Morley, and <a href="https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=iau.31858022913804&amp;view=1up&amp;seq=7"><em>Neighbors</em></a><em> </em>by Zoar Gale. Not to be outdone, boys from the Class of 1933 organized “The Salamander Club,” and performed a play written by classmate Joseph Roland based on Twain’s <em>Connecticut Yankee</em>, also in 1929. The Salamander Club invited girls to join in 1931 when it staged <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Admirable_Crichton"><em>The Admirable Crichton</em></a><em>.</em>¹⁰</p><p>The decade of the twenties was transitional, as has been stated. What Stanley Yarnall later called “the unfortunate older days of inhibitions and limitations” in the arts slowly gave way to an appreciation of the central role culture could play in Quaker education. Despite some misgiving of his own, Yarnall backed the changes.</p><p><strong>This decade was the coming of age for GFS sports,</strong> in large measure because of the successes of Alfred A. Smith. In his first half dozen years, Smith coached all the boys’ varsity teams. “I coached so much,” he said, “that I didn’t have time to sweat.” In 1920, Herman Breininger was hired to teach math and to coach football and baseball, leaving Smith with soccer, basketball, and track. It was as a soccer coach that Smith became a legend. GFS had joined the “old” Inter-Academic league (sometimes called the Private School League) in 1916. Competing against Penn Charter, Haverford School, Friends Select, and Wilmington Friends, Smith’s teams captured the League title seven straight years from 1917 to 1924. That streak included five undefeated seasons, forty- seven victories in a row, 108 goals scored, and only fifteen goals given up. It was the longest win streak of any GFS team in any sport ever, and included matches with public schools and club teams.¹¹</p><p>Smith is remembered as much for his sportsmanship as for his coaching success. “He was a sweetheart,” is how one alumna recalls him. He would not tolerate rough play, bad language, or unsportsmanlike behavior. “If any of his players tried anything like that, he would just yank them off the field.”¹²</p><p>In 1928, GFS reluctantly joined the modern Inter-Academic League. Doing so was “a necessary evil,” in Yarnall’s opinion. Friends Select and Friends’ Central were planning to join, and Smith was worried about scheduling games if GFS were shut out of the new league. He and Yarnall recognized that GFS would be weak competitors against larger, all boys schools like Germantown Academy and Episcopal, and that proved to be the case. GFS and the new Inter-Ac were never happy together.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/483/1*j_0jZaxFlJGLRBxsRAqQXw.png" /><figcaption>The 1932 City Champion soccer team</figcaption></figure><p>Smith’s soccer teams continued to win, however. In the next decade, the “Smithmen,” as one alumnus called them, won league titles in 1931, 1932, 1934, 1936, and 1940. The 1932 team may have been Smith’s greatest. It won the City Championship by defeating Public League champion Northeast High School. A half-century later, Eric Johnson remembered the moment: “There were just two or three minutes left and Bill Doak, who was playing outside left — he was the greatest dribbler in the world — got the ball away back near our goal line, and he dribbled it all the way down the field on the left side — imagine going right by everybody with the crowd cheering like mad — and single handed — didn’t pass to a soul — shot it in and we won the championship.”¹³</p><p>GFS was never a power in football, but it did produce one memorable football season in the twenties. Coached by Herman Breininger, a “plain- spoken, peppery Pennsylvania Dutchman,” the team was undefeated and “its goal line never crossed.” “I was in the seventh grade, that was then called the Fifth class,” Henry Scattergood recollected, “and it was a remarkable season. They were my heroes, of course, Tommy Atherton and Jimmy Nicholas and some others” in the class of 1922. The team tied its first game against Germantown Academy 0–0 (the year before GA had won 34–0) and went on to defeat schools like Friends’ Central 60–0 and Chestnut Hill Academy 39–0. There would never be another season like it. A plaque forever preserving this year is in the school archives.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tasVcR38JDc1WD1aD4faIQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The 1920 field hockey team</figcaption></figure><p>Girls fielded interscholastic teams in hockey and basketball, and the hockey team, in particular, had great success in the twenties. Coached by Elizabeth Maris, hockey won the Inter-School League (Springside, Irwin, Stevens, Friends Select, and Westtown) five times in ten years. The hockey players even attended the summer camp run by Constance “The Apple” Applebee, the grand dame who brought the game to the United States. A stellar player in these years was Elizabeth Cadbury ’24, who would return to teach and coach at GFS for many years.</p><p>There were other sports teams in the twenties that did well, and even some new sports were introduced. Girls’ lacrosse, for example, was begun in 1928 and lasted through the thirties before it died out — not to be revived until the 1960s. There was even, briefly, a boys’ fencing team.</p><p>The important point is that sport had become accepted as a major part of school life in this decade. Intramural contests between classes, or between “Blues and Whites,” continued, as did gymnastics demonstrations and Field Days. But competitive team sports were the future. Sport became part of the rhythm of the school, an accepted, natural part of the day. Afternoons devoted to sport at Clark and Wistar Brown fields became accepted, normal, and, eventually, required.</p><p><strong>By 1930 Stanley Yarnall had reached the peak of his professional career.</strong> His school was becoming known at least regionally; and he had become something of a national figure in education. He was an advisor to the Carnegie Foundation; an officer of the Progressive Education Association; and, in 1930, he was elected president of the exclusive, and prestigious, Headmasters’ Association.</p><p>That same year he asked the School Committee for a sabbatical year. He was tired and needed a chance for renewal. The Committee readily complied and he was granted a leave of absence at full salary plus expenses. The Committee also sent him a special “minute” of praise. “The vision of many years has now been realized in our great school, with its double classes full from Kindergarten to Senior — its building equipment sufficient, if not ample, in classrooms and laboratories — its two gymnasiums and fine playing fields. This is an impressive monument to thy foresight, unremitting care, and good management.”</p><p>In Yarnall’s absence, Irvin Poley would act as principal.</p><p><strong>Next:</strong> <a href="https://ironyofa.medium.com/irvin-corson-poley-master-teacher-bfe0573fda90">Irvin Corson Poley: Master Teacher</a><br><strong>Previously:</strong> <a href="https://ironyofa.medium.com/master-stanley-517ba596b978">Master Stanley</a></p><p><strong>Notes</strong></p><p>1 School Committee minutes, May 29, 1919.</p><p>2 The comprehensive plan, entitled “A Forward Look for the Germantown Friends School,” GFS Archives.</p><p>3 These examples, and those that follow, are in the GFS Archives.</p><p>4 Poley, <em>Speaking of Teaching</em>, pp. 100–102.</p><p>5 Henry Scattergood, interview with Bill Koons, July 1990, GFS Archives.</p><p>6 Edith Knight was given a parting gift of a Ford runabout “complete with rumble seat” and a special grant of half-salary by the School Committee “for the rest of her life.” She died in 1933.</p><p>7 Stanley Yarnall, “Music in School,” pamphlet published in 1940, in GFS Archives</p><p>8 Johnson’s remark is from the transcript of the 1980 Calder roundtable discussion. It follows a reminiscence by Henry Scattergood. “There was no music for boys — oh yes — there was a mandolin project. I guess if you had a mandolin you got to play. And there was a girls’ choir or chorus, and we had a lady named Mrs. McCloskey who taught music — and if we were very good, which was very hard for most of us, she would bang out the Parade of the Wooden Soldiers on the piano for the last three or four minutes of the period. That was our reward for behaving.” GFS Archives.</p><p>9 Student Handbook for 1930, GFS Archives.</p><p>10 Student Handbook, 1931–1932, GFS Archives.</p><p>11 Smith’s record has been pieced together from scores published in <em>The Pastorian </em>for these years. Other sources used here include Takyi Morgan, “History of Soccer at Germantown Friends School” in GFS Archives, Folder 93; and the <em>Alumni Record</em>, February 15, 1940, GFS Archives.</p><p>12 Henry Scattergood, interview with Bill Koons, June 1994, GFS Archives. “Sweetheart” is the word used by Virginia Childs when interviewed by Bill Koons, June 1994, GFS Archives.</p><p>13 Calder Roundtable transcript, 1980.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=65d1990ce622" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Writing for Thinking Notebooks: Continuing Revelation in the Pandemic English Classroom]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/writing-for-thinking-notebooks-continuing-revelation-in-the-pandemic-english-classroom-7d5b1481bb43?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7d5b1481bb43</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[covid19]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[teaching]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Jun 2021 14:02:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-11T14:18:24.787Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>by Rachel Reynolds, Middle School English Teacher, Germantown Friends School</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*I67O2JTu3P2YYm8v" /></figure><p>If adolescence is marked by a quality of unknowing — of curiosity and uncertainty, a sense that anything might be possible — then to be an adolescent during the COVID-19 pandemic has been to experience this sensation writ large. Thrown into an ephemeral landscape of blue-lit boxes, straddling the world of home and school without preparation or prior experience to rely on, middle schoolers (like the rest of us) suddenly found themselves everywhere and nowhere at once in spring of 2020, meeting people who otherwise would never have set foot inside their houses within the confines of their bedrooms and sharing meals in their kitchens with people they couldn’t touch. While as an adult, I still exercised some control over my days — I had lessons to prepare, meals to cook for my child, reading up to do on the latest in virus information — I was struck by how haunted students seemed by the sudden disappearance of school as a physical site and community. If school opened and closed with their computers, then was it even really happening? With the floor dropped out below them, the task for me as their teacher became to answer that question in the affirmative, and then to prove it.</p><p>Once the initial whirlwind of shifting to remote instruction subsided, we had the opportunity at my school to hunker down with our teaching teams (shout-out to Chelsea Koehler and Sara Primo) and to work with a mentor from <a href="https://globalonlineacademy.org/">Global Online Academy (GOA)</a>. As my colleagues and I considered what questions we wanted to bring to our mentor, we kept going back to paper, to proof: We wanted our students to come out of their eighth grade year with evidence that it had really happened; we wanted them to hold their own accumulation, to offer a counterbalance to so much existing in the elusive space of the internet. And we wanted to continue to keep our school’s Quaker roots at the forefront. We decided we needed a notebook.</p><p>I brought this nascent notebook idea to our GOA coach, who helped develop it into sections: prompts, cool words, and questions. From there, we added another section — writing territories — and embraced the idea that we could use these notebooks to center the idea that you don’t have to know what you have to say in order to write. Instead, you can write to think, writing can be a tool to process and move towards clarity. In a time riddled with uncertainty, and standing on the already shaky ground of early teenage-dom, it felt like a balm we could offer our students was a fierce embrace of unknowing and a commitment to introspection and a steady practice of curiosity. With that, Writing for Thinking notebooks were born.</p><blockquote>“WFT notebooks are one of my favorite parts of 8th grade English. It gives you a place to dump your thoughts and ideas in whatever (hopefully a bit organized) way you want. It is nice to have a space that is purely your mind without much interruption. My personal favorite section was the Writing Territories section. I loved seeing all the lists of responses to the prompts and to look back on what was on my mind. Also I loved decorating mine and making it my own.” — R.C. (8th grade student)</blockquote><h3>Prompts</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*7qGuMQv85nYZYJwz" /></figure><p>On one hand, the prompts section of our Writing for Thinking notebooks — or, WFT notebooks, as we’ve come to affectionately call them — is a space to prepare for the class to come. It’s a sneak peek of where we’re headed and an invitation to get your head into that space. While the above prompts were part of a unit on the personal essay and generated material that was thinned and narrowed into the world of one piece, what exists in student notebooks is also a record of themselves in this moment. If they open to that page, what they’ll find is a reflection of their interior as it existed on a certain morning this past fall. The lists they’d write today would overlap, but they wouldn’t mirror the original exactly; and in this way, the list becomes a pin on the map of their journey through this year.</p><h3>Cool Words</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*hbhzvwZ7Bga-siX8" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*U8QEbMjrJ8-d3H0H" /></figure><p>As English teachers, we are convinced that words are cool. They are one of the most useful tools we have for communicating, after all, and one of the building blocks we turn to for making sense of the world. Middle schoolers, however, are ready skeptics. Words are something to be quizzed on, corrected about, to struggle to find. With the Cool Words section of WFT notebooks, we wanted students to take language into their own hands, to feel themselves in the driver’s seat of making meaning. If they felt limited by the world, we wanted them to recognize language as a site of expansion, of agency and curation, of connection and even delight. With the top entry, we aimed to combine a love of language with love for the self, to affirm language as worthy of adoring and, in finding this language within their own writing, to have students affirm themselves in the process. With the entry that follows, we asked students to examine their relationship to making meaning, inviting their attention towards their own process and, in doing so, nudging them to consider their orientation to authority and authorship. While some students went to the dictionary, others crafted idiosyncratic definitions for their names that spoke to who they are and/or how they hope to be seen in the world. Always, in our notebooks, we are practicing noticing, pulling out small threads of ourselves to turn them over in the light.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*AdX4RH04n5LRfNN6" /></figure><h3>Writing Territories + Daily Diaries</h3><p>Inspired by educator Nancie Atwell, we wanted to periodically invite students to pause and reflect on the stories closest to their hearts. What stories are they uniquely poised to tell? What are the stories they keep going back to, the ones that hold keys to something essential and their own. As the days blurred together, we wanted students to pause and notice themselves, to find depth by turning inward when so much on the outside was out of reach. Writing Territories held space for this process.</p><p>Our approach went something like this: We would offer a category — pets, then and now; itches; costumes — and students would put pen to page and write, crafting a list in response. The rules were loose; the aim was for kids to see where these tiny categorical prompts took them if they just kept writing. At the end, we’d share. The array of responses that emerged was breathtaking: how unique we all are, how much we have in common.</p><p>When we reached our poetry unit, we borrowed an idea from author Lynda Barry and tasked students with daily diary entries. They were to use their notebooks on a daily basis, breaking the page into quadrants. In the top left, they were to note 7–10 things they’d done that day, while in the top right they noted 7–10 things they saw. For each of these quadrants, students were challenged to spend two minutes a piece, challenging themselves to identify things for their list that were unique to their day or their lives. In the bottom left corner, students had 30 seconds to jot down something they’d overheard in their day; in the bottom right quadrant, they had another 30 seconds to draw a quick picture of something they’d seen.</p><p>On one hand, daily diaries were a way to practice specificity with writing, honing students’ attention to images and details and helping them tease out those things that capture the essence of an experience. On a more pressing level, though, the diaries were an invitation to look beyond their screens, to disrupt the sameness of life in quarantine by insisting on differentiation across their days and tasking them with practicing noticing it. We wanted to help kids round out their lives, to see how much was happening and to step into their power as authors of the story of their days.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*Yw4eVlnpyWjTUNV9" /></figure><h3>Questions</h3><p>If WFT Notebooks are a space for embracing uncertainty, then the elevation of questions seems like an essential facet. The last section in our notebooks, students wrote questions from the last page inward, slowly bringing their wonder toward the center.</p><p>Sometimes we gave students prompts, as in the above example, which we used in our poetry unit. More often, though, we began class with a question dump, dedicating a few minutes for students to empty their brains to the page with every question, big and small, milling about their minds. Anything was fair game: <em>What’s for dinner? Why did I pick that fight with my sibling? Can we save the planet from global warming?</em> The goal was to help them get things out, to find a bit of peace by putting the nagging bits on the page where they can look at them. It was also to help them see themselves. We each have our own haunts, our own curiosities, and setting them before us is a way of deepening our understanding of who and how we are in the world. As much as we are guided by what we feel we know, uncertainty also informs our path — we hoped through this practice students would start to see theirs more clearly. With regards to more formal writing, our questions also offered points of entry as students were empowered to identify questions they felt inspired to follow more deeply.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*1DSsSwNzqS4ak2mG" /></figure><blockquote>“I liked how my WFT notebook was a safe place where I could process and collect my thoughts. When people shared their ideas, it helped me think more deeply about the prompt.” — M. G-Y (8th grade student)</blockquote><h3>Site of Possibility</h3><p>As the pandemic tossed everything we thought we knew about school into the air, we were forced to prioritize and to articulate what mattered most in our classrooms. As we made peace with the fact that we would not be able to do everything we’d done in the past, my colleagues and I found ourselves recognizing a site of possibility: What did this mean we could do instead? While the landscape of remote and hybrid teaching continued to fluctuate, we knew we needed an anchor, something concrete to return to time and again, no matter what form our classes took. We also knew that we were uniquely poised to help students document their experience of this unusual year, thanks to our curricular investment in writing. From here, Writing for Thinking notebooks were born. This pandemic landscape isn’t where they end, though; instead what crystalized for us along the way is that WFT notebooks are a tool that speaks to the needs of our students and that helps us teach holistically, centering the entanglement of the self with our texts and curriculum and guiding students to embrace their unique generative capacities in the process. No matter what is happening in the world, 8th grade is a time of transition, a moment when students step starkly into themselves as they settle into being teenagers and begin envisioning themselves as high school students and beyond. WFT notebooks hold space for them to pause in this process, to reflect and move forward intentionally, all while supporting their connection to class material. The challenge for us as teachers is to deepen their use in our classrooms. After navigating a pandemic, that is a most welcome exploration.</p><p><strong>About Rachel Reynolds</strong></p><p>Rachel Reynolds is a Middle School English teacher at <a href="https://www.germantownfriends.org/">Germantown Friends School</a>. Rachel is also an experienced writer and editor, for both print and online forums and feels strongly about encouraging and inspiring students to use any kind of writing to express themselves or discover their voices.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7d5b1481bb43" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Connection Between Coding and Caring]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/the-connection-between-coding-and-caring-b9e4944ae4bf?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b9e4944ae4bf</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 May 2021 16:06:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-07T16:09:46.589Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>GFS Fourth Grade Students Create iPhone App to Address Real-World Problems with VineyardAppCamp</em></p><p><strong>Isabel Schmidt ’16, Assistant Director of Summer Day Camp Programs</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LIMFbXIdT-GA2DrP_RywNQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>When we think of mobile applications, we often think of utility and functionality — we aren’t usually brought to tears. However, dry eyes were not an option for Ola Boswell, Executive Director of Deep Roots, a homeless shelter in Earleville, Maryland. Ola had just been shown the app that GFS fourth grade students had designed and built for her organization through the Coding and Entrepreneurship after school club, taught by Steffen Cornwell, Amy Yeung, and Andri Hail of VineyardAppCamp (VAC). Their app made it possible for Deep Roots’s clients to shop for free items through the organization’s thrift shop and food pantry. “We can’t thank you enough for giving families another way to access these support services,” said Boswell.</p><p>VineyardApp is a tech and entrepreneurship program that teaches students coding fundamentals, and in the words of co-founder Jordan Taylor helps novices “form deep, life-long connections, with the complex processes of design, innovation, and technology.” With the support of highly-trained instructors, students learn to code, draft a business plan, and ultimately design and build iPhone apps for nonprofit organizations. Exploration, collaboration, and fun are at the heart of the program’s mission.</p><p>To build their app, GFS students met once a week, for an hour, over the course of a year. They initially learned basic coding languages like Javascript and HTMl through small group activities like creating their own websites. Once students had mastered the essential skills, they began working on real apps for nonprofits. They created and viewed the app that they were generating using VineyardApp’s online AppBuilding tool, and went on to test what they were building on their phones with the help of an instructor. Many GFS students found a new passion through VAC’s programming, like Jaden, who continued with the course “because it’s fun, and you actually get to create your own app, which is very interesting.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CQNPLvP24cfTzKhrHFk8QA.png" /></figure><p>GFS partnered with VineyardApp co-founder Jordan Taylor for this year’s ASPire after-school club. “The creativity and community-mindedness of GFS students stands out,” he says. “During one of our first classes, students asked if they could build an app to help freshmen learn how to navigate [high school]. They’d had trouble getting around their school when they were new and wanted to help others. I thought that that was very telling and really special.”</p><p>Jordan, a native of the tri-state area, is committed to helping students acquire technical and entrepreneurial knowledge. As a result of his vision, VineyardApp’s curriculum is “hands-on, results-oriented, and built around creating a transformational experience that extends beyond camp,” he says. “If you challenge a student and respect them, they grow in new and impressive ways.”</p><p>VineyardApp also runs camps during the summer. Germantown Friends School is the only independent school in the Philadelphia area that offers the program’s innovative and exciting curricula, via the school’s enrichment club program and its summer camps.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XHBC8U3b5FkThThQhcKYpQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>While reflecting on the app that GFS students created for Deep Roots, Boswell gave “a very special thanks to VineyardApp for teaching students the connection between coding and caring.” It is this very connection that makes the program so aligned with the Quaker values of the GFS community.</p><p>If your student is interested in a one-of-a-kind summer camp experience, please visit <a href="https://www.germantownfriends.org/student-life/summer-camps">https://www.germantownfriends.org/student-life/summer-camps</a> to sign up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b9e4944ae4bf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Master Stanley]]></title>
            <link>https://ironyofa.medium.com/master-stanley-517ba596b978?source=rss-4b3e4441aaa5------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/517ba596b978</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Irony of A]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 23 Apr 2021 14:45:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-23T15:02:31.306Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Stanley Yarnall, one of the most influential figures in GFS history, takes the lead. The school is now bursting at the seams; a bigger school, Yarnall says, means a greater Quaker influence. In some areas, GFS adheres to Quaker tenets such as girls prohibited from wearing jewelry. But the school also introduces music, theater, and sex education. The “finest gym in the city” is built (the Little Gym!).</em></p><p><strong><em>(</em></strong><a href="https://medium.com/p/840551fc7e98/"><strong><em>Introduction to this series</em></strong></a><strong><em>)</em></strong></p><p><strong>Stanley Yarnall was a handsome man.</strong> A group photograph of GFS students and teachers taken the year he arrived, 1898, shows “Master Stanley” as generations would remember him. He was tall, an inch or two over six feet, and he towered over the diminutive Davis Forsythe. His hair, famously white in later years (“he used bluing, you know”)¹ was still dark, swept back from a prominent forehead, and his face, with a handsome, aristocratic nose, gazes calmly and steadily at the camera.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/202/1*P3rl-0diwgz07bObJjImnA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Stanley Yarnall</figcaption></figure><p>It is his bearing that captures the eye. He was young, only twenty-seven years old and this was his first teaching job, but he projects an air of confidence far beyond his years. He is turned three-quarters to the camera, as if posing for a studio portrait, and he stands straight, shoulders back, head held high. It is a picture of a man of dignity, reserve, composure; a man very well pleased with himself; a man with presence.²</p><p>Stanley R. Yarnall was born in Philadelphia August 29, 1871, the son of Hibberd and Mary (Rhoads) Yarnall, birthright Friends. He had graduated with honors and a Phi Beta Kappa key from Haverford in 1892 and had won a fellowship there in Classics. He took his M.A. at Haverford in 1893. He was working in a book store when he was recommended to Davis Forsythe as a replacement for Charles Brede, a popular Latin teacher. Yarnall would never be a popular teacher, nor did he try to be. Students complained that his “lessons are entirely too long — he is always saying ‘and in addition’ after he has given us enough already. We are killed with work.” One class nicknamed him “Old In-Addition.” Forsythe caught Yarnall’s style exactly in his first assessment of him. “The new teacher of Greek and Latin is exacting and thorough, but judiciously so.”³</p><p>In 1905, Yarnall went to Harvard to complete a master’s degree in education. His thesis was “Some Account of the Friends’ School Germantown, Philadelphia with a Discussion of the Program of Studies.” His own copy of this thesis survives, and it tells us a good deal about the school he had just joined and would make his life’s work. It tells us even more about its author.⁴</p><p>The thesis (ninety-two pages, plus nine tables) is written in Yarnall’s own hand (a distinct, strong, angular style), and proceeds in careful, systematic order to describe the school’s location and grounds, buildings, governance, faculty, and program of studies department by department. It is intelligent and thorough, but not the work of a scholar or intellectual. It is descriptive, not analytical; the product of a good and prudent mind, but not one, on this evidence, highly imaginative. It is also largely uncritical. Yarnall liked the school’s program as it was and largely approved the direction it was taking. Throughout his long career, he would describe himself as a “conservative progressive,” and that pretty well characterizes his ideology in this thesis.</p><p>It is clear that he was not excited about “The Individual System” which the school’s catalog (a Forsythe innovation) was advertising as one of the school’s best features. He never uses the phrase at all, and, in fact, seems to deny its existence. He wrote approvingly that “The Friends’ School is an example of the older order of academics that adhere closely to a fixed program, deviating from it only in the cases of college preparatory students whose work must be planned to meet the requirements of the different institutions they are expecting to enter.” He was more conservative than Forsythe. The latter, for example, had tried unsuccessfully to persuade the Committee to consider a limited elective system for older students. Yarnall’s verdict was that “this is a question that cannot be entered upon now unless there were more time to think over the whole situation… with patience the time will come when the whole question can be taken up for investigation and action. In the present in view of the conservative nature of the older members of the Committee, and indeed of the community, it seems best to make haste slowly…” Yarnall had doubts about the elective system, hence the advice “make haste slowly.” When it came to changes he wanted, however, he would charge full-steam ahead. With haste.</p><p>Yarnall’s thesis gives a rare, in-depth portrait of the early twentieth-century school, and it is worth examining. It is a lovely portrait, too. He described Germantown as “the largest and most attractive residence quarter” of the city, and Coulter and Greene Streets, the coordinates of the school, were “both quiet residence streets with substantial houses and pleasant lawns.” Bustling, noisy Germantown Avenue, with its prosperous shops and historic house (“the <a href="https://www.nps.gov/inde/learn/historyculture/places-germantownwhitehouse.htm">Morris house… scarcely a stone’s throw distance, the home of Washington during the Plague year when congress met in Germantown</a> and sat in the historic buildings of Germantown Academy two blocks west”), the recently electrified trolleys rumbling up and down the avenue “and making connections to all parts of the city,” did not disturb the tranquil scene. The school, he assured Harvard, was set in park-like grounds, set back from the avenue “by a lane, so long as to insure privacy, and almost rural silence.” The school grounds “are ample and well laid out and contain may fine specimens of sycamore, cypress, and ash trees” including “an ancient sycamore that was standing when Penn had the country surveyed.” The <a href="https://www.loc.gov/item/pa3802/">Meetinghouse</a> (“severely plain in architecture, but with a dignity”) stood behind a graveyard described as giving “the impression of well-kept old lawns enclosed by stone walls and hedges.” If Yarnall hadn’t turned to education, he might have found a career in advertising.</p><p>The school now had three buildings on the campus. In 1898 the school had purchased the Mullen property adjoining it on the north, and where earlier students had peered through knot-holes into the slaughter-yard, a new, modern gymnasium was built in 1902. Equipped with up-to-date gymnastics equipment and even a running track, it was “the finest gymnasium in the city.” In 1914 Yarnall would write of the new gym; “It was like passing from night to day to step from the old shed to the light, cheerful, well-equipped building that has meant so much to all later Germantown Friends School pupils.”⁵ <em>The Pastorian</em> editor who thought a modern gym “visionary” in 1897 would have shared Yarnall’s delight.</p><p>The two school buildings housed all four divisions of the school. The Kindergarten was located on the first floor of the new Primary building. Students stayed there one or two years before moving on to a three-year Primary division. The Kindergarten shared the first floor with the Intermediate and High School chemistry and physics labs, which were located in an addition constructed at the same time as the gymnasium. The woodworking, or Sloyd, room was in the basement.</p><p>The “Primary School” was on the second floor. In the rear addition on the second floor was a lunchroom. The first hot lunches at GFS were served in 1903. Yarnall wrote almost nothing about the Primary curriculum, describing only an emphasis on reading and elementary arithmetic.</p><p>After three years of the Primary, students entered a two-year intermediate division followed by a six-year high school course, both housed in the Main Building. In a unique and perversely complicated nomenclature, the grades were called Kindergarten, First, Second, Third (Primary), Seventh, Sixth (the Intermediate division), Fifth, Fourth, Third, Second, First, and Senior classes. This arrangement, with its peculiar names, would be continued for many years. Enrollment was limited to twenty-five students per grade, and there was a waiting list for admission for every division.</p><p><strong>The faculty in 1905 numbered eighteen for a student body of 262.</strong> Two of these, at least, were only part-time (the drawing teacher and elocution master) and may not have been Quakers, but all the full-time faculty were Friends.⁶ Yarnall disapproved of part-time teachers, but relished a mostly Quaker faculty. “Quaker education” meant to Yarnall the Friends’ values of civility, tolerance, a “family” feeling, simplicity, and concern for others. Who better to teach these values than Friends?</p><p>The Kindergarten had a head teacher (Jane Raley for a quarter century, from 1895 to 1920) and a succession of assistants. The Primary had three teachers, but Elizabeth Forsythe (1887–1914) was the “chief teacher” and supervised two assistants. The Intermediate and High Schools had eight full-time teachers, plus the principal (who taught two courses), organized loosely by departments. Teachers taught across department lines and up and down the grade levels. Yarnall thought this was an advantage: “The lines of the departments are not kept so strictly as in most schools. For instance, the work in English is divided among four teachers…” Because the faculty was so small, the Primary teachers took one Intermediate class a day, and High School teachers taught two or three different subjects to four or five distinct grades each day. Yarnall saw an advantage in this. “In this way teachers come to know the individual boys and girls from the time they leave the primary school, and watch their development as a continuous process while the pupils, for their part, feel no need for a re-adjustment as they pass from grade to grade.” Yarnall was making a virtue out of necessity.</p><p>A modern GFS student, suddenly caught in a time-warp and transported back ninety years, would be astonished by the school Yarnall described. On the one hand, it was much easier. There were no final exams. Homework was minimal — a maximum of two hours a night for Seniors (and none at all for Primary students). Students advanced from grade to grade not by tests, but because of consensus of the teachers approved them. School was dismissed at 1:30 p.m. There was no after-school sports program.</p><p>On the other hand, five years of Latin were required for a diploma, and the only way out of that was to substitute Greek literature in the fifth year. A passing grade for any course was B-, and a C mark was a failure. There were spelling tests every day in every grade, Bible readings every day, and Bible study once a week. A phobia with modern GFS students is geography; they would have foundered in 1905 when geography was studied every year. Even Yarnall thought that a bit much. His description of the curriculum as “the older order of academics” seems appropriate.</p><p>Yarnall listed the books used in every course. There was a heavy emphasis on textbooks and the classics. In English, for example, the Sixth class (today’s fifth grade) read Longfellow’s <a href="https://poets.org/poem/courtship-miles-standish"><em>The Courtship of Miles Standish</em></a>, short stories by Hawthorne, and poems by Whittier, among other works. The next year, sixth graders read <a href="https://www.gutenberg.org/files/20203/20203-h/20203-h.htm">Franklin’s <em>Autobiography</em></a> and stories by Dickens, Browning, and Ruskin. High Schoolers digested great quantities of Walter Scott, Goldsmith, Tennyson, McCauley, and Emerson. Seniors studied rhetoric.</p><p>He was not entirely uncritical. The curriculum in the upper grades he thought needed upgrading. Math, for example, barely got to the binomial theorem. History was weak; the drawing courses too unimaginative. Yarnall taught Classics and the Bible, two subjects he thought were very well presented, but science and modern languages (French and German) could be improved. Forsythe had recently assured the School Committee that GFS would not become a wholly college preparatory school. Yarnall made no bones about it. A college prep school was exactly what he wanted, and more college bound students, too.⁷</p><p>He also proposed some additional courses “to enrich and strengthen the program”: economics, history of art, classical literature, mechanical drawing (for boys), and sewing and domestic science (for girls).</p><p>Nowhere in his thesis did Yarnall describe the school’s financial base, although he was clearly aware that by 1905 money was a potential problem.⁸ The buildings erected in 1896–97 and 1902 had drained the school’s endowment. Instead of raising money through a capital campaign, as Alfred Cope had done, the School Committee had sold the major part of its accumulated stocks and bonds. Higher tuitions and a waiting list of non-Friends willing to pay the price, kept the school in the black every year. In 1905, for example, the school had a surplus of over $4,000 in a budget of $26,000.⁹ But there was no longer a cushion to fall back on.</p><p>Yarnall was careful in his criticisms of the School Committee. He thought it was too large (twenty members), and some older Friends weren’t pulling their weight, but on the whole he thought the Committee able, dedicated, and “in harmony” with the principal. He was evidently unaware for the Committee’s tendency to micro-manage day-to-day affairs. He would soon learn.¹⁰</p><p>When Stanley Yarnall returned to GFS from Harvard in the fall of 1905, he was handed the opportunity to put his thesis proposals to work. In April, Davis Forsythe had become ill and had requested a six-month leave of absence. The Committee granted him leave and named Yarnall acting principal.</p><p>Davis Forsythe never really reclaimed his office. He tried for six months in 1906, but collapsed in July with “nervous prostration.” The Committee granted him a full year’s leave this time (at two-thirds salary), but finally grew impatient. In May 1907, Edward Wistar, the clerk of the Advisory Committee, was dispatched “to suggest the advisability of his resigning.” To soften the blow, and in recognition of his thirty-three years of service, the Committee gave him a parting gift of $1,000.</p><p>From all accounts, Forsythe was a decent and gentle man. Students remembered him with affection, and in 1910, the Alumni Association decided to fund the scholarship in his honor that is still awarded annually. His health eventually improved and he became a teacher at Westtown, clerk of Philadelphia Yearly Meeting (1912–1916), and editor of <em>The Friend </em>from 1911 to his retirement in 1929. He died in 1934.¹¹</p><p><strong>Stanley Yarnall’s elevation was an explosion.</strong> The tone of the monthly “Principal’s Reports” changed dramatically. Forsythe had been deferential, soothing, but Master Stanley was another matter. He was bristling with ideas, plans, suggestions, and proposals. In his very first report in 1905, while still only acting principal, he proposed enlarging the Kindergarten (there was room for thirty), adding two classrooms in the Main Building by shifting walls, and rearranging the structure of classes by adding another grade to the Primary. The next month he told the Committee he had installed bells in the school, reduced passing time between classes, and wanted to close school at 1:30 instead of 1:50. Yarnall’s appointment as principal in 1907 seems to have increased his energy. He wanted an athletic field, electricity, a telephone, an honor roll, a larger office, and more male teachers. The enrollment in 1907 was only 284; he wanted twice that.</p><p>The School Committee was dazzled — or maybe dazed. In December 1908 they demanded he give them an agenda. “In view of the many changes suggested by the Principal from time to time, the Committee feel that it would be of advantage to them if they had knowledge of what general Plan our Principal has in mind for conducting the School so that the Principal and Committee may work in harmony.”¹² Yarnall was more than happy to comply.</p><p>Master Stanley would eventually get all his specific demands. But missing in the tumult and confusion of the official record are two other issues he was raising. They were stated carefully, sometimes indirectly or obliquely, but they are unmistakable.</p><p>The first, and by far the most important to him, was his belief that the school was a ministry. Friends, he stated again and again, had an obligation to spread their Truth — not with an eye for increasing their numbers, but to broadcast the principles. Friends’ schools, he thought, were the best witness to Quaker testimonies. In the “general plan” he produced for Committee, the first point was “To recognize the demand made upon the school by a growing community and to appreciate as a privilege, rather than dread as a danger, this increasing call for social services and religious influences on the part of Germantown Meeting.”¹³ A larger school meant a greater Quaker influence.</p><p>Yarnall’s second issue was to persuade the Committee to confine its attention to policy matters and to leave the management of the school to him. He was careful not to challenge the Committee’s authority, but he wanted to redirect its attention. He stopped bringing forward little items for approval; he announced curriculum changes, but did not seek permission to make them “as they have to do with rather technical questions which you would not understand without elaborate explanation.”¹⁴</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h9ABFly1eYKaTdLdYG-peQ.png" /><figcaption>The school building in 1913</figcaption></figure><p>In time Yarnall would win the Committee to his views, but it would not be easy. The sanitized minutes do not give a clear picture of what happened, but they are full of references to “free and frank discussion.” In May 1908 long-time Committee clerk Jonathan Evans abruptly and curtly resigned (he was later persuaded to resume his post). In June 1909 Advisory Committee clerk Wistar also resigned, and insisted a minute be put in the record stating strongly his opposition to Yarnall. It would be several years before the principal and Committee could truly be said to be in “harmony.”</p><p>The plan that Yarnall submitted, initially in February 1908 and again a year later, called for doubling the size of the school. “We think of our school as large. It is really small.” Especially in the upper grades, enrollment was “too small for the best school life. Our most highly trained and highest salaried teachers are obliged to work with handfuls of pupils… to have efficient high school work and to hold good teachers and maintain proper school spirit, we must have larger upper classes.” He proposed gradually adding a second class of twenty-five at each grade level which, in time, would mean a total enrollment of about 600. That would make GFS one of the largest independent schools in Philadelphia.</p><p>This would require more construction “either by adding to our present building or adding new ones.” It would also require the purchase of an athletic field “as the supreme need of the Boys’ side of the school.” He did not provide an estimate for the number of new teachers that would be needed.¹⁵</p><p>The Committee fully realized the implications of Yarnall’s plan. GFS had always been small and intimate, “a family school” is how Yarnall had described it in 1905, and it would now be something very different. “The changes suggested are radical and important,” Jonathan Evans noted, and the Committee debated them for a full year before finally giving approval. Even then they felt the need to secure agreement from the Monthly Meeting. “While we feel that such a large school will bring increased responsibilities and care, we also feel that perhaps we should not shirk from meeting this call, on the part of a growing community by extending the educational advantages…and the social and religious influences of Germantown Meeting.” The language, of course, is Yarnall’s. The Meeting’s response said simply do what you think is right.¹⁶</p><p>The plan adopted in 1909 was the most significant action taken by the School Committee since 1885. Enrollment shot up. In 1901 there were 363 students; in 1915 the figure was 444; in 1920, enrollment was 557 and still climbing. The faculty increased from twenty-three full-time teachers in 1910 to thirty-seven full-time in 1920.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*H3-okpZ_KoWL_axRevh6Tw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The expanded “collection room”</figcaption></figure><p>To accommodate these growing numbers, the school buildings were repeatedly expanded. In the summer of 1909, a third story was constructed on the Main Building and a two-level passage way built over the arch connecting Main with the Primary. In 1915 a third story was added to both Primary buildings; the passage of the arch was expanded, and a third level added to it. A new locker room for boys was built between the gym and the library. There was a new lunchroom in the basement, an expanded “collection room,” a new heating plant, electric lights in the gymnasium (replacing gas chandeliers), a new science laboratory, and a fire tower. These were heady times for GFS and for Master Stanley, but somehow he found time for a personal life. In August 1917 he married his secretary, Susan Roberts.</p><p>There was never enough money to do all the building “Old In-Addition” wanted. Except for a bequest from the estate of benefactor Alfred Cope, most of the money was borrowed. That made some members of the Committee nervous, and there were some testy exchanges with the principal. In 1914, for example, Yarnall was pushing for the third floor addition for the Primary. The Committee told him that if he wanted the addition he would have to find the money. Yarnall’s answer was blunt: “My attention has been called to a Minute adopted at your last meeting stating in substance that I am encouraged to collect at once $25,000 so that plans for building can be carried through. Some weeks ago when I placed the needs of the school on the material side before the Advisory Committee, I told them I felt it was necessary for schools like ours to have more ample financial support from their friends…. I am still fully convinced of the correctness of this view. Such a minute as that adopted at your last meeting does not, however, give me the encouragement or the warrant to go forward with the effort mentioned. If you are really concerned with regard to this matter and are deeply interested in the school, I shall gladly associate myself with a committee that you will appoint for this definite purpose…Until such action is taken, however, I shall feel free from any obligation to raise funds for the school.”¹⁷</p><p>Borrowing for capital construction meant admitting even more students whose tuitions would pay the mortgages. The school found itself continually crowded and cramped despite all these improvements.</p><p>Yarnall also had his eye on acquiring an athletic field for boys. It was necessary, he said, to retain boys in the High School. He had also changed his mind about the desirability of the inter-scholastic sports. In 1905 he had written that such contests were probably not “wholesome” (a favorite word), but the success of teams coached by Walter Cowing had changed his mind. The only playing space available for both boys and girls was still the ground between the school and the Meetinghouse. A colorful account exists of Yarnall and School Committee member Frederick Strawbridge “plotting” and “skulking” around the neighborhood of the school “frequently at night so that no overly-curious soul might discover what was afoot” looking at the property.¹⁸ However it came about, in 1909 Yarnall spotted what he wanted: three acres at Coulter Street and Wissahickon Avenue belonging to the estate of Edward W. Clark. The School Committee was persuaded again to borrow, the land was purchased, and, with financial help from Frederick Strawbridge, a building on the property was converted to a locker room. By 1910, a football field, baseball diamond, and one-fifth mile track had been built. Four years later the Clark family gave an adjoining fifty-foot wide plot to the school, and the whole was officially named Clark Field.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l4MDlzOfzkFiWETYa7e9Ig.jpeg" /><figcaption>Baseball at Clark Field, c1913</figcaption></figure><p>Only boys used Clark Field; in fact, girls could only go there with a chaperone. The girls’ field hockey team would be homeless for another decade. They made do with the tiny space at school, on rented fields at the Germantown Cricket Club, or a playfield on Limekiln Pike. Two tennis courts for the girls were built west of the Meetinghouse fronting Greene Street, but it hardly compensated. In any case, five tennis courts had been built for the boys at Clark Field.</p><p>Yarnall tried repeatedly to interest the School Committee in acquiring more field space for girls, but he failed. The school was mortgaged to the hilt; girls were staying in school through the upper grades anyway: and, in any case, girls and athletics seemed a peculiar and not entirely “wholesome” mix to many. Not until 1920 did GFS girls get an athletic field, and even then it was second best. That year Agnes Brown Leach offered to sell the school six acres west of Wissahickon Avenue, stretching from Midvale to School House Lane, for half its market price. The School Committee jumped at the opportunity, and the T. Wistar Brown Field (named in honor of Agnes Leach’s father) was acquired. The central portion of this is the modern GFS Athletic Field. It was bigger and better than Clark Field and so was developed for boys’ athletics. Girls thereafter used the older, small Clark Field.</p><p>Master Stanley was a great builder, the greatest in the school’s history, and his grandest projects in brick and mortar were still to come. But he also built with people. Probably his greatest accomplishment was recruiting and retaining a faculty who would dedicate thirty to forty years of their lives to GFS.</p><p>Some of these teachers were on the staff when Yarnall moved into the principal’s office. Jane S. Jones, “Teacher Jennie,” taught math to High Schoolers from 1889 to 1926. Elizabeth Roberts taught in the Primary for thirty-six years before becoming the school librarian. She retired in 1940 after forty years of service. “Teacher Emma,” Emma D. Roberts, a Bryn Mawr graduate, taught English from 1903 to 1940. Also from Bryn Mawr was English and Latin teacher Helen Zebley, a GFS graduate, who taught from 1903 to 1930.</p><p>Master Stanley’s favorite among the teachers he inherited was Walter Cowing, the boys’ PE director. He paid him more than twice what the women teachers earned, $2,000 (women were paid $750 to $850), more even that Frank Maxfield, the vice principal and science teacher. He repeatedly praised Cowing for his “clean, manly sports program,” and, when Cowing resigned in 1914 to become Philadelphia Boy Scout director, Yarnall was crushed. “A serious blow to the school,” he told the School Committee, “a great disappointment… it is doubtful if we shall be able to fill his place.” He did, though. He hired a young, inexperienced graduate of Springfield College named Alfred A. Smith.</p><p>Yarnall favored male teachers. “It is not a good thing for a school like ours when the proportion of women teachers becomes too great,” he told the Committee in 1909. That year he hired two men who would become legends. Henry A. Domincovich (“Mr. Domi”), who had an A.B. from Haverford and M.A. from Harvard, had taught at Moses Brown and Phillips Andover. He would spend the rest of his life, thirty-eight years, at GFS. Daniel Lawrence Burgess, also a Haverford graduate, stayed even longer. He retired in 1950.</p><p>Year by year, Master Stanley assembled the faculty that would lead the school to prominence. Irvin C. Poley, ’08, was hired in 1913; the next year brought A.A. Smith, Iro Trueblood, and Katherine Dobson. Each would remain over a quarter-century; in Irvin Poley’s case almost twice that. Glenn Bennett, Anna Comfort, and Joseph Haines Price, all hired in 1917, complete the roster of long-time teachers Master Stanley recruited in his first decade.</p><p>The long years of service by these teachers is a testimony to Yarnall’s leadership. “He was not always an easy man to work for,” Eric Johnson remembered. “His standards were high; he could be stubborn; he was tenacious.” Surviving faculty meeting minutes from these years add other adjectives. He was demanding, sometimes imperious; he could be a nitpicker. But he created an atmosphere where good teachers felt encouraged and supported. He gave them room. He trusted them, and they in turn were loyal to him.</p><p><strong>For students, Yarnall’s early years also brought exciting changes.</strong> The sleepy, little school woke up with a start. Elocution contests, “declamation” contests, debates, gymnastic exhibitions, field days — each year the calendar became busier. <em>The Pastorian</em> gave a snapshot of school life in the 1913 issue: “The recesses of spring are the most heterogeneous and productive of all school activities. The future soccer stars developing in the space by the stone wall; the fair, would-be field hockey players taking their daily training around the Meetinghouse; the hand-ball enthusiasts on the cement walks at the side of the building, with their row of spectators on the fire escape; the baseball fans; and the various groups scattered all over the grounds, engaged in anything from taking a nap to discussing the political conditions, certainly prove that the Germantown Friends is a very busy and prosperous place.”¹⁹</p><p>The longest-lived of all those new activities was the “dreaded” General Information Test. For almost fifty years, beginning in 1911, D.L. Burgess produced the annual test. “What is the capital of Poland?” “Why does the statue of William Penn on the City Hall tower face north-east?” “Give the real name of the author called Mark Twain.”²⁰</p><p>Academic standards were improving rapidly. In fact, Master Stanley worried that they were going up too fast. In 1912 he noted “the unfortunate report is spread about that our school is too severe,” and he while he praised his teachers “for the advance in the school’s intellectual standards” he cautioned them “against the dangers of over strain. A complete education is not given by driving children on to continuous compliance with rigid requirements.”²¹ There was now a monthly honor roll for both Intermediate and High School. By 1915 there was even a Primary honor roll.</p><p>Sport was becoming more important. Most contests were intramural. Twice each year the Intermediate and High School were divided into teams of “Blues and Whites” (“Crickets and Spiders” in the Primary) for “wholesome” competition in gym and field events. Tennis courts were constructed in 1910, both at school (behind the Meetinghouse) for girls and at Clark Field for boys.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K1jbDZSLaBm-epDpR-HuLQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Girls’ tennis courts in 1917. They were built along Greene Street, to the west of the Meetinghouse in 1910; Boys’ courts were built at Clark Field the same year.</figcaption></figure><p>Varsity inter-scholastic competition grew steadily each year. Boys fielded teams in football, soccer, basketball, baseball, and track — all coached by A.A. Smith, who also taught physiology and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sloyd">Sloyd</a>. Girls’ teams did not play a league schedule, but the number of games with other schools increased. In 1910, for example, both field hockey and basketball (two girls’ sports) played only an annual match with Friends Select. By 1920 there was a full schedule with schools like Westtown, “Miss Irwin’s School,” Stevens School, and Springside. The separate Boys and Girls Athletic Councils even printed “approved” school cheers. They were just awful:</p><blockquote>Bommajigger, boomajigger, boomajigger, boom –<br>Riggaragger, riggaragger, riggaragger, room –<br>Cannon ball, cannon ball, sis boom ba’ –<br>Germantown Friends School, rah, rah, rah.<em>²²</em></blockquote><p>Master Stanley approved all this (one hopes he winced at the cheers) in part, it would appear, because GFS teams regularly whomped the daylight out of Penn Charter and Germantown Academy.</p><p>As a result of the school’s improved academic reputation and the success of its sports teams, more boys chose to remain at GFS in the upper grades. In 1913, for example, eighteen seniors graduated, ten girls and eight boys. The class poet, Katherine Cooper, boasted of the numbers:</p><blockquote>The greatest honor won as yet,<br>Our class alone enjoys;<br>I’ll tell you so you won’t forget:<br>We’ve with us here eight boys.<br>Nineteen twelve of four could boast.<br>‘Eleven of but one.<br>We’re proud to have the most,<br>And end as we’d begun.<em>²³</em></blockquote><p>Seven of the eight boys went to college (two each to Haverford and Penn State, and to Penn, M.I.T., and Textile). Four girls from this class were college bound: Bryn Mawr (two), Mt. Holyoke, and Western Reserve.²⁴</p><p>A highlight of the early Yarnall years was the Shakespeare Tercentenary Celebration in 1916. This was a pageant, a festival of song, dance, and drama that signaled how far — and how quickly — Master Stanley’s school had come from the GFS he described in 1905. It is also evidence of the growing influence of young Irvin C. Poley.</p><p>Poley had a passion for the theater and was impatient with the traditional hostility of Friends to drama. As a student at GFS he had been warned repeatedly by teachers to stop his play-going. “They all accepted the contemporary Quaker suspicion of the arts in general and the theater in particular — not just because of the assumed immorality of actors, but because of the pretense of being somebody else, because of the feeling that playing a villain might lead the performer to villainy.”²⁵</p><p><strong>Quaker attitudes were changing, however. </strong>The year Poley returned to teach at GFS, he announced his intention to produce a play about Queen Elizabeth in his Intermediate English class. The School Committee heard of this from Yarnall and immediately appointed a sub-committee “to consider the desirability of the children of the school giving plays.” That group spent five months trying to get “a sense of the meeting” and finally issued a report in October 1914: “The use of plays as an educational factor in schools has become so general that we must take a broad view of the subject. That they have a proper place in school life can scarcely now be questioned.” The School Committee’s policy was hedged in with restrictions. Plays must be “in connection with work in history or literature;” costumes must be simple and subject matter be “in sympathy with the view of Friends;” and Yarnall must be asked for prior approval. But Irvin Poley had won his first battle for drama.</p><p>Music, too, was starting to make a small appearance. In 1915, a part-time teacher of “vocalization,” Elizabeth McCloskey, was hired to teach Primary students a few songs one day per week. A year later she was even provided with a piano. There was no music in the Intermediate and High School.</p><p>The Shakespeare Tercentenary Celebration was a pageant, a spectacle much greater than anything the School Committee had imagined, and they had to be persuaded. A carefully worded petition from the faculty was heard. Because the Shakespeare festival was a watershed event in the history of the school, this petition is worth quoting at length.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-FOL6J5WWiOkz1ujbY-Jow.jpeg" /><figcaption>The 1916 Shakespeare Tercentenary Celebration at Clark Field. The faculty had to convince the School Committee to allow the performance.</figcaption></figure><p>It began with an appeal to duty. “For some years the spring of 1916 had been anticipated as the time for an international festival in honor of Shakespeare’s contributions to English literature and the culture of the world. Present conditions in Europe have forced the abandonment of the program there.” The United States Commissioner of Education “has issued a call to American schools and colleges to make this a special occasion” and the faculty “have felt laid upon them a duty to consider what our School might do as its share.”</p><p>The program was deliberately described as modest. “The representation of several scenes from <em>The Merchant of Venice,</em> <em>A Midsummer Night’s Dream,</em> and<em> Julius Caesar</em>, by boys and girls of the first, third, and fourth classes, set in a framework of Shakespearean songs and Old English folk games and movements, the former by High School pupils, the latter by Intermediate pupils.” It met the restrictions outlined in the Committee’s policy. “The portions of the works of Shakespeare mentioned above come naturally in the respective English classes; the Old English exercises would fit in well with the gymnasium classes…Due consideration would be given to simplifying the matter of costume.”</p><p>Finally the petition argues the “many advantages to be derived.” Increasing a spirit of unity, bringing parents closer to the school, and “it would have some influence in our community on higher ideals of culture.” The elaborateness of the petition, its studied and careful tone, is evidence that Quaker attitudes hadn’t changed that much. The teachers expected opposition.</p><p>The School Committee gave its approval, but reluctantly. “It is felt that this occasion must not be regarded as a precedent for similar occasions in the future.” But of course it became a precedent. Here are the roots of The Virgil Pageant, Poley’s Malvern Festival, and the modern school’s claim to be a place “where the arts flourish.”²⁶</p><p>The tercentenary was a great success. <em>The Pastorian</em> claimed over a thousand spectators at Clark Field watched the Grand Procession, plays, dances, and songs. Although Poley’s later accomplishments with drama would eclipse this one, he recognized its importance in gaining acceptance for his ideas. It also provided him with a favorite story. One of the boys he directed in <em>Midsummer Night’s Dream</em> left GFS the next year for boarding school (which was still happening more frequently than Master Stanley wanted). He wrote Poley that “I miss my English class most; the teacher here has no dramatic ability.” Poley’s rueful comment was “evidently I spent too much time on drama and not enough on spelling.”²⁷</p><p>Master Stanley was willing to accept educational changes and to support good teachers like Poley, but some changes he did not like at all. It pained him to see the <a href="https://quakerspeak.com/video/history-quaker-plain-speech/">plain speech</a> disappear. He and many other teachers continued to use it, but even Quaker children dropped their “thees” and “thous” at school.²⁸ The practice of addressing faculty as “Teacher” and “Master” was also fast disappearing, and he asked his teachers whether efforts should be made, as he thought, to retain those forms. The faculty said no.²⁹ Some trends he adamantly opposed. Any boy caught smoking would be expelled. Girls were not to wear “bracelets, rings, or any unnecessary jewelry.” There would be no dances, no fraternities (although girls had Beta Sigma, a Christian study group). In at least one instance, Master Stanley actually turned back the clock. Davis Forsythe had abolished final examinations in his “Individual Program.” Yarnall brought them back, and, by 1919, students were taking two-hour finals in four major subjects. It all adds up to the description of himself he always preferred — a conservative progressive or a progressive conservative.</p><p><strong>World War I was a testing time for Master Stanley and his school.</strong> As a Friends School, GFS was bound by the Quaker peace witness and could not support the war. Yarnall, himself a firm pacifist, was determined to permit nothing that would even give the appearance of supporting the war, and it brought down on his head substantial criticism from the Germantown community and even from some GFS parents and students.</p><p>Three issues raised the most noise. The first was the presence of German in the modern language program. Students and their parents wanted it dropped, apparently in part because the teacher, “Frau Krickscher” (Pauline H. Krickscher), was German. Enrollment in the course dropped dramatically, and in 1918 Yarnall was forced to let her go (She had been at the school since 1901). That he was forced to do so “by the unfortunate circumstances of the war” is evident by the tribute he paid her in morning collection.³⁰ A second section of French, taught by Irvin Poley, was substituted.</p><p>The second issue concerned a request from the newly formed student council, which started in 1916–1917, “to raise a flag on the school grounds.” So far as can be determined, the school had never flown a flag, and Yarnall decided it wouldn’t do so now. “Its presence might be understood as an approval of our country’s declaration of war.” Many parents and students were outraged. They saw no contradiction between Quaker principles and flying a national symbol. Even the faculty was divided. D.L. Burgess, perhaps influenced by the fact that he had taught four years at the Bootham School in England, wrote Yarnall a letter asking him to reconsider, but the School Committee backed the principal.³¹</p><p>A compromise was eventually worked out. Committee member Agnes Tierney explained it in a letter to the Meeting: “When our country first entered the war it was deemed inconsistent with the Meeting’s attitude toward all war to permit the display of a flag in honors of that event. But when in the Fifth Month it was discovered that the little boys were planning to present a flag to the school your committee believed it wise not to discourage this evidence of loyalty to the school. The condition was made, however, that a letter should go out from the principal stating that to the Society of Friends the flag did not stand for war but for the highest ideals of patriotism, internationalism, and brotherhood.” The compromise seems a little weak-kneed and the whole affair something of a tempest in a teapot. But such turmoil was new and unsettling to Germantown Friends. Tierney called 1918 “the most difficult year in the school’s history.”³²</p><p>The final issue raised by the war brought the school wider, public criticism as unpatriotic. Yarnall refused to cooperate with the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_bond">Liberty Loan</a> campaign, then being pushed by the Wilson administration as a patriotic duty. Most Americans did participate. The Treasury reported that over 20 million people, more than half the adult population of the country, bought the bonds in 1918. Not Master Stanley.³³</p><p>Yarnall was convinced his course was right, and while the criticism hurt, it was bearable.</p><p>Two families withdrew their children from the school in protest, and more were unhappy, but “I believe there is a favorable reaction now among the most sensible people.” Other schools, he thought, had given in to war excitement, but “we have taken the ground that it is our work to keep steady along lines of instruction and wholesome academic life. We are, I think, equally patriotic and wiser to insist that at this time our chief contribution to the country is a group of well-trained boys and girls.”³⁴</p><p>Yarnall was not unpatriotic, and he was aware of the value of good public relations, so he looked for ways “to display patriotism that are consistent with Friends’ principles.” He appointed a joint faculty-student committee (another first) to explore the problem, and soon GFS students were raising money for Armenian refugees and sending boxes of books to soldiers in overseas camps; girls were sewing and knitting for the soldiers; and a few boys were studying auto mechanics at Rinker’s Garage. (Friends could in good conscience serve in the ambulance corps.)</p><p>J. Tyson Stokes ’24 was a student at GFS through most of the early Yarnall years. He remembered them vividly.</p><blockquote>“On reaching the Kindergarten age it was ordained that I should go to Germantown Friends School, then, as now, one of the leading independent schools in the Philadelphia area and located about a mile from our house.” He attended for the full time, twelve years, from 1912 to 1924. “That was a most satisfactory time in which to be educated if one was born on the right side of the tracks and one’s parents could afford the relatively low tuition charges of a private Quaker school [tuition rose from $100 to $300 during Stokes’ years].</blockquote><blockquote>The 19th century didn’t really end until November 11, 1918, the calendar notwithstanding. And so half of my school years were passed in the relaxed atmosphere of a past age, and half in the six years after World War I…</blockquote><blockquote>During my time the late Stanley R. Yarnall was at the height of his powers as principal. Stanley Yarnall looked good like a Headmaster should. Well over six feet tall, with a ruddy complexion and a magnificent head of curly hair prematurely white, and always dressed in a dark three-piece suit and starched white collar, his bearing was sufficient to inspire awe. The nadir for a GFS student was to be sent, very rarely, from the classroom to Mr. Yarnall’s office where, after cooling one’s heels in the anteroom for an appropriate interval for self-analysis, one was invited in to the presence. Since this never happened to me, I don’t know what was said behind the closed doors, but whatever it was, was sufficient to preclude the culprit from repeating the error responsible for the visit. There wasn’t much backslapping camaraderie or togetherness between students and principal in our day, and it never occurred to us that there ought to be.</blockquote><blockquote>In our early years the principal was called ‘Master Stanley,’ in accordance with the early practice of Friends’ schools; and there were a few of the older teachers whom we gave the first name treatment, such as Teacher Emma and Teacher Jenny. By the time we had graduated this practice had been pretty well abandoned…and it now occurs to me with some surprise that none of our many women teachers were married.</blockquote><blockquote>The advent of the Class of 1924 about coincided with that of Irvin C. Poley, a fortunate coincidence for us. My first recollection of Mr. Poley as a teacher was in seventh grade, when he was assigned to teach French to the boys. It is extraordinary to realize that even in a Quaker school the emotions aroused by World War I were sharp enough to eliminate German from the curriculum and Frau Krishka [sic] from the faculty… A classmate, the son of German parents, was regarded with suspicion and rumor had it that his father maintained lights in a tower in his house to guide approaching Zepplins…</blockquote><blockquote>Mr. Poley was saddled with the trying task of picking up the pieces after we had been subjected to a disastrous first year of French with Monsieur W… [Jules Marcel Wilmart, 1918–1919]. He had been selected on the prevalent but dubious assumption that the basics of a foreign language are best taught by one native to the tongue. Monsieur W…, he archetype of French academic, know his French all right but had little conception of how to motivate and control adolescent American boys.</blockquote><blockquote>I should guess now that Irvin Poley would not have maintained at the time that he was perfectly qualified to teach French. My mother, who spoke French well, would be critical of my pronunciation of certain words, but all discussion ended when I said, “Mother, that’s the way Mr. Poley pronounces it”. Guess who won…</blockquote><blockquote>The great Poley contribution to our education, however, was his single-handed relaxation of the Quaker sanctions imposed on fiction, music and drama, still quite evident in our early years at GFS. At that time the only permitted gesture in the direction of the performing arts was the so-called Elocution Contest, when we recited once a year for the benefit of long-suffering but proud parents stirring lines from Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address and lengthy ballads and epic poems of Scott, Tennyson and Browning. Under the Poley aegis, that diet was seasoned by some of Shakespeare’s lighter moments and the works of then-living authors like John Maesfield and Sir James Barrie. Irvin Poley produced, with the limited talent available to him in his English classes, Shakespearean excerpts such as the Pyramus and Thisbe interlude from <em>A Midsummer Night’s Dream</em> on the ‘stage’ of the old Collection room. As the ‘stage’ consisted of a platform about twenty feet long, six feet wide, one foot higher than the Collection Room floor, with no curtain, and as the time available was restricted to about twelve minutes, it is obvious that the limitations on high dramatic achievement were formidable indeed. The Class of 1924 may be said to have sown the seeds of liberation; but we graduated too soon to benefit from the Malvern Festivals…</blockquote><p>Stokes also remembers, but doesn’t credit, the fact that Yarnall was one of the first private school educators to address sex education. In 1918 he sent both his PE directors to a seminar on “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_hygiene_movement">social hygiene</a>.” Thereafter, both A.A. Smith and Elizabeth Jones gave lectures on the subject.</p><blockquote>I remember a School announcement that there would be an afternoon lecture on “Hygiene” which we upper class boys were required to attend and to which our fathers were invited. This was anticipated with a good deal of relish and high hopes; but the speaker, alas, never emerged from behind the veil of birds, bees and flowers.</blockquote><blockquote>Our classes were mixed [co-educational] in the primary grades, separate in the intermediate and mixed again in high school, but the ‘home’ classrooms were always single sex… I remember the moment in senior English when we were studying <em>Macbeth </em>line by line and word by word for the College Boards. A male classmate… asked in a mixed class, ‘What, Mr. Domi, is a soldier’s whore?’ Titter and a moment of electric silence, and then, with obvious embarrassment, ‘A woman of ill repute. Next question.’</blockquote><p>He described a decorous student social life.</p><blockquote>Our contacts were mostly on a group level at class parties or the Dancing Classes attended by some of us and where the dancing consisted of the fox trot, one-step and waltz… There was practically no pairing off or ‘going steady.’ The great class party of the year took place annually at the Francis Strawbridge farm in Exton, the girls spending the weekend and the boys arriving Saturday morning by train and hay wagon. We swam in the Blue Hole, an abandoned quarry, ran hare and hounds…, engaged in mixed three-legged races in a hazardous cow pasture and played softball. A great time was had by all.”<em>³⁵</em></blockquote><p>It adds up to a pretty picture of Master Stanley’s school. What Tyson Stokes did not know was that the year he graduated, 1924, Master Stanley himself was engaged in the biggest battle of his professional life.</p><p><strong>Next:</strong> A Vision Realized<br><strong>Previously:</strong> <a href="https://ironyofa.medium.com/the-old-school-1a76c580a424">The Old School</a></p><p><strong><em>Notes</em></strong></p><p>1 Virginia Childs, interview with Bill Koons, June 1994</p><p>2 The word “presence” is invariably used to describe Stanley Yarnall. Most of the alumni interviewed for this book used the term; it was invoked in testimonial dinners marking his twenty-fifth anniversary at the school and his retirement in 1941. It was literally the last word used to describe him. His obituary notice in <em>Friends’ Journal</em>, volume 10, p. 90 concluded: Friends will miss his counsel and impressive presence.”</p><p>3 Principal’s Report, in School Committee minute book, 11th month, 3rd day, 1898. The anecdote about “Old In-Addition” is from Agnes Tierney in the <em>Alumni Bulletin</em>, 1923, in a memorial marking Yarnall’s 25th anniversary at the school, GFS Archives</p><p>4 Yarnall’s thesis is in GFS Archives.</p><p>5 The purchase of the Mullen property is described in School Committee minutes throughout 1898. The price is noted at $2,500 in the budget figures for 9th month, 28, 1899. The School Committee delayed building the new gymnasium for four years evidently for financial reasons. Not until May 1902 did it authorize construction of the gym and an addition to the rear of the lower school (where the laboratories and lunchroom were located). Yarnall’s “from night to day” comments come from an article he wrote about physical changes in the school for <em>The Pastorian</em>, volume 5, number 6 (May, 1914). In it he describes the old shed: “Twelve years ago the ‘gymnasium’ was a low room between the rear of the library and the present gymnasium. It was dusty and generally forlorn, without locker facilities or showers and with little equipment. One of the most prominent features was a coal stove with a stove-pipe that had a habit of getting in the way of balls and boys in rapid motion with disastrous consequences.”</p><p>6 Yarnall doesn’t mention the faculty’s religious affiliation in his thesis. However, two years later all the full-time faculty were Quakers and the only two teachers in the 1895 roster who left were both Friends (Davis Forsythe and Agnes Tierney). Annual Report of the School Committee to Germantown Monthly Meeting, 1907 in Monthly Meeting minutes. There was no policy forbidding the hiring of non-Friends. In 1891 Davis Forsythe hired Mary Hughes, who was not a Quaker, as a primary assistant teacher. Some members of the School Committee objected, but after consideration the Committee approved her appointment. No stated policy was developed, however. Mary Hughes seems to have been the first non-Friend ever employed as a teacher. She left the school in 1893.</p><p>7 Forsythe’s assurances to the Committee appear, for example, in the Principal’s Report for 1900 and 1903. School Committee Minutes.</p><p>8 His only reference to finance is a vague statement about the school’s endowment — which “had formerly been liberal.”</p><p>9 The tuition for the High School in 1905 was $125.</p><p>10 For an example of “micro-managing”, see the Committee minutes for January 28, 1904: “The Horizontal bar in the Gymnasium having torn loose from its fastenings in the floor and there seeming to be difficulty in making it secure, the Committee on Buildings authorized to have it fixed in such manner as they deem best.”</p><p>11 The Alumni Association was started in 1905. The affectionate memories of his students are found in a tribute to Forsythe delivered at the 31st Alumni Association Meeting and published in the <em>Alumni Record</em>, June 1, 1936. The Forsythe scholarship was approved officially in 1910, the same year as the Susannah Kite scholarship. The Kite scholarship was awarded that same year, but it would not be until 1914 that the first Forsythe scholar was announced.</p><p>12 School Committee Minutes, January 28, 1908</p><p>13 Yarnall’s plan was introduced twice, in 1908 and again 1909. This statement appears in the 1909 version. School Committee Minutes, February 1909.</p><p>14 School Committee Minutes April 29, 1015</p><p>15 The quotations here are from both the 1908 and 1909 versions of the plan which do not materially differ.</p><p>16 Letter to Monthly Meeting from Jonathan Evans dated 4th month, 29, 1909 recorded in both School Committee and Monthly Meeting minute book.</p><p>17 Letter to School Committee included in minutes for May 28, 1914.</p><p>18 From an anonymous account in the <em>Alumni Bulletin</em>, April 1, 1939.</p><p>19 <em>The Pastorian</em>, vol. IV, no. 17 (May 7, 1913) p.3.</p><p>20 Examples from the 1920 test.</p><p>21 Minutes of the Faculty, GFS Archives.</p><p>22 <em>The Pastorian</em>, March 1918, p.77.</p><p>23 <em>The Pastorian</em>, June 10, 1913, p.11.</p><p>24 Principal’s Report, the School Committee minutes, June 1913.</p><p>25 Irvin C. Poley, <em>Speaking of Teaching</em>, privately printed 1957, p. 115, GFS Archives, Poley personnel folder. Confirming Poley’s memory is minute from the faculty in 1909, the year after he graduated. “Monthly Meeting has voiced its deep concern for the spiritual welfare of the School. Feeling that the concern of the Meeting should be shared by the teachers, Stanley Yarnall acquainted the teachers with the feelings of the Meeting and expressed the desire that each individual might deeply appreciate the large responsibility resting upon him to lend his influence in fostering and practicing Christian principles. Various teachers expressed their sympathy and wished that a stronger influence might be exerted opposition to theater going.”</p><p>26 The petition was not attached to the School Committee minutes for an unexplained reason. The Committee’s reluctant approval is recorded in the faculty meeting minutes of March 2, 1916.</p><p>27 The anecdote is from <em>The English Journal</em>, January 1925.</p><p>28 Henry Scattergood, interview with Bill Koons, February 1981.</p><p>29 <em>The Pastorian</em> as early as 1910 reported that Mr. and Miss were replacing Teacher and Master. Yarnall remained Master Stanley at least until the late 1930s, long after the practice was abandoned. The source here is a transcript of a round-table discussion led by Fred Calder with “school veterans” in 1980.</p><p>30 The tribute to Frau Krickscher is not recorded, only referred to in the School Committee minutes. German was not dropped. A few students remained in the class which was taken up by D.L. Burgess.</p><p>31 Burgess letter is in School Committee minutes May 23, 1918. It was most unusual for a teacher to disagree with Yarnall so openly.</p><p>32 Annual Report of the School Committee minutes May 23, 1918.</p><p>33 Mark Sullivan, <em>Our Times</em>, (Scribner’s, 1925) volume 5, p. 652.</p><p>34 Principal’s Report to School Committee, May 2, 1918.</p><p>35 Two versions of Stokes’ memoir exist. They are very similar and I have borrowed from both versions. The earlier is a text of a talk he gave to GFS students in 1974, his fiftieth anniversary of graduation, GFS Archives folder #40. The other is his autobiography <em>No Axe to Grind</em>, Haverford House, Wayne, Pa. 1982.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=517ba596b978" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>