<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Isabel Behncke I on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Isabel Behncke I on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@isabelbehncke?source=rss-451371eb1278------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 13:04:59 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@isabelbehncke/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Fear of contagion — of infection- is one of our most atavistic fears”.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@isabelbehncke/fear-of-contagion-of-infection-is-one-of-our-most-atavistic-fears-4b0c58c965cd?source=rss-451371eb1278------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4b0c58c965cd</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Behncke I]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 19 Apr 2020 19:52:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-21T02:14:15.913Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>“Fear of contagion — of infection- is one of our most atavistic fears”.</strong></p><p><em>“There’s deep irony in this virus forcing us to go against our essence in order to protect ourselves from it. One can’t help calling it a brilliant virus.”</em></p><p>Chilean primatologist Isabel Behncke, known for her research on the social behavior of bonobos in the Congo, asserts that evolutionary biology can help us understand both the causes of the pandemic and our reaction to it. Behncke, who holds a doctorate from Oxford and is currently a member of the Center for Research on Social Complexity (CICS, at Universidad del Desarrollo in Santiago, Chile) suggests we face the crisis with “an ecologist’s eyes”: it could help us think more clearly -without morals getting in the way- about the sacrifices we must make in order to relieve suffering.</p><p>[This interview was done by Daniel Hopenhayn and published originally in Chilean newspaper La Tercera on Sunday 29th March 2020.</p><p>Original Spanish version can be read here. <a href="https://www.latercera.com/la-tercera-domingo/noticia/isabel-behncke-el-panico-al-contagio-a-lo-infeccioso-es-uno-de-nuestros-miedos-mas-atavicos/CR5VVF4IKZG5DKGK5CD4OXJBNM/">https://www.latercera.com/la-tercera-domingo/noticia/isabel-behncke-el-panico-al-contagio-a-lo-infeccioso-es-uno-de-nuestros-miedos-mas atavicos/CR5VVF4IKZG5DKGK5CD4OXJBNM/</a></p><p>Translation from Spanish to English was done by Dr Claudia Hopenhayn, epidemiologist and translator]</p><p><strong>You’ve been reflecting for decades on social phenomena based on their relationship with the biosphere. There we were, imagining robots, when along came a virus that brought the world to a halt. This must fit your narrative.</strong></p><p>Definitely. It has brought to my mind all these studies and conversations from 20 years ago: We were discussing precisely this! The ongoing discussions on zoonosis -diseases jumping from animals to humans-, and whether the virus came from a bat or a pangolin in addition to the need of stopping wild-animal trading markets such as in Wuhan; these concerns that have been around for a while now regarding biodiversity depletion and ecosystems health. If we continue to destroy natural habitats, we’ll increase the animal candidates for future zoonoses. This pandemic is far from the last one.</p><p><strong>But scientists in your field have been dismissed over to those that herald a more anthropocentric future. Terms such as “ways of living” are considered too new age for some palates.</strong></p><p>I actually started out studying ecology, but went on to study primates instead, partly from realizing with frustration that we were far too disconnected from the heart of the matter. By the late 90s, people like Robert Constanza raised the alarm that we were failing to understand the service rendered by healthy ecosystems. In a renowned article published in <em>Science,</em> they estimated the economic value of these services, the logic being: “Since everybody speaks the language of economists, lets present nature as a business which provides essential services, and hopefully people will value it”. Anybody understands they need water and electricity, and that they come at a cost, right? So they quantified the services provided by a healthy ecosystem such as a forest: purified water, CO2 absorption, etc. All of which are so much more valuable than gorilla meat or lumber from the trees. To appreciate the ‘services’ that healthy ecosystems provide isn’t the complete picture but a first step in the right direction.</p><p><strong>And now several articles are warning that many habitats are in themselves barriers protecting us from thousands of diseases.</strong></p><p>That is so important. The enormous bill we are footing is partly the price of not understanding how those barriers work. Perhaps we ceased to feel part of the living network we share with other beings. To quote the title of Harari’s book, we envisioned ourselves graduating from animals to gods. Our eyes were set on Mars, we were on our way out. We somehow lost respect for our home. And there’s poetry in the fact that a simple virus can throw us back into nature in a couple of weeks. We spent trillions of dollars on defense systems and a strand of RNA brings us down on our knees. A slap in the face: You are flesh and blood, lest you forget! Or in Greeks terms: “Hold on there, you are not God — you’re a Demi-god at best. Listen, we’ve achieve incredible feats as a species, let’s not sell ourselves cheap. But we continue to be animals, and to get here we had to co-evolve with other entities, including viruses. Viruses and humans intertwine in a very ancient dance ritual! And it’s interesting how evolutionary biology sheds light not only on this phenomenon, but also on the social behaviors that are emerging in response to the pandemic.</p><p><strong>Such as?</strong></p><p>Take isolation at a time of crisis: it’s so hard for us as a species. We are social beings who’s survival depends, first and foremost, on the group. Face-to-face contact and social touch are an essential part of human health and wellbeing, and depriving us from them will be difficult.</p><p><strong>That’s why it’s so baffling that the only way for us to come together is through isolation.</strong></p><p>That’s where the deep irony lies: the virus forces us to go against our essence in order to protect ourselves from it. One can’t help calling it a brilliant virus. I happened to be in the Congo during the Ebola outbreak, a much more lethal outbreak but not as contagious, due to its transmission method. Covid-19, because it kills fewer and further between, profits enormously from our social behavior. One can almost hear it thinking: “I know these animals are incapable of withholding interaction amongst themselves for 14 days, they are born to interact, so I am just going to lay low and let humans be humans so I can hitch a ride from one to another.”. This virus is at the very least a formidable strategist. Another aspect that evolutionary biology can help understand is contagion through social networks. Not only the biological contagion, but also the propagation of ideas and emotions. Such as panic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hrdghYKvOj4niSkw_yGRzQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Would you say that the competition between reason and panic puts us to the test on how sapiens we are in these circumstances?</strong></p><p>The dichotomy between emotion and reason has not been very useful, because being <em>Sapiens</em> involves having emotions, you cannot separate the two. And while we need to emphasize that hey, let’s not get panicky because it causes us to shut down cognitively with grievous consequences; it is useful to recognize the role fear plays in our history for understanding what’s happening to us. Fear exists because it serves a purpose. And the dread of contagion, of infection, is one our most atavistic fears. We are alive, in part, because our ancestors at some point saw someone very ill and said: “Oh, gross”, and kept their distance. In other words, it’s only natural that coronavirus scares us irrationally. Because if we were really <em>Sapiens</em>, we’d have a mental Excel spreadsheet telling us that we are much more likely to die of cardiovascular diseases, making us terrified of hamburgers. But since we carry atavistic fears, our fears aren’t well calibrated. We are more scared of planes than cars, which is statistically absurd. Blood, spiders, snakes, scare us more than cars. So it’s kind of inevitable to feel this panic of contagion. But we have to be conscious of it and regulate it, rather than let it run loose, which can be dangerous.</p><p><strong>The best and the worst</strong></p><p><strong>Optimists assure the lock-down is going to stimulate an attitude of cooperation. Pessimists believe that when push comes to shove, selfishness will prevail. What do you think?</strong></p><p>Experience shows that in times of disaster, both the best and the worst of human nature emerge. I find the dichotomy between cooperation and conflict tends to be slightly deceitful. Societies work at different levels of organization -person, family, neighborhood, company, nation, global society, etc. Ecologists would argue that the key to observing phenomena in nature is to understand how, at all those levels, cooperation and conflict coexist. Each of us is an ecosystem -our body hosts more bacteria than human cells- within which there are many conflicts. Now, what tend to happen in the face of serious threats is that cooperation among the highest levels increases, the big teams join efforts. We’ve seen emerge, in the past few weeks, some interesting examples of full-scale cooperation, of collective coordination. When was the last time humanity united under a single purpose, keeping us all in the loop? But conflicts of interest haven’t been long in appearing. And of course, political polarization. I think it would serve us well, in order to have a friendlier conversation, to observe what is happening from an ecologist’s viewpoint, observing complex systems in action.</p><p><strong>How would that help?</strong></p><p>Because it would help us understand that diagnoses that lead to good solutions aren’t those which oppose absolute values. “What matters here is A (e.g. health)”, or “What matters is B (e.g. the economy)”. To emerge as best as possible from this crisis we’ll need to consider the different levels at which society is organized, and that will force us to ponder amongst different values, amongst different kinds of sacrifices.</p><p><strong>And amongst different types of suffering, right? We’ve seen a conflict of sorts between ER physicians, who’re asking for more radical measures, because life comes first, and epidemiologists, more used to assessing the social impact of these radical measures.</strong></p><p>That’s a huge topic. Many people are arguing over this, perceiving the trade-off as a moral fault. But nature is full of trade-offs: how much energy an individual spends on different objectives, how much it grows, when and how much to breed, how much to invest in each offspring, when and which risks to take… All these are “decisions” that are made weighing goals that often conflict between each other. We humans try to apply a set of moral values, but we are inevitably tied to the concrete limits of nature and its trade-offs. If we recognize this, perhaps there would be less cross-fire between people who believe the other to be morally inferior.</p><p><strong>Not an easy one.</strong></p><p>Oh, no. In fact, Jonathan Haidt, a social psychologist I recommend following, believes that we will now cooperate more because disasters bring out the best in people, but he also says that these situations increase moral disgust. Similar to atavistic fears, the emotion of disgust is part of our evolutionary repertoire. There’s physical disgust when faced with things we perceive as dirty, like feces, but we’re also capable of moral disgust, and that’s what’s surfacing in many of these discussions. There’s people saying “you’re disgusting, you want to save the economy and you don’t care about lives”, or the reverse, “you think about the sick but you don’t care about the amount of people that will be deprived of their livelihood, how abhorrent”. This feeling of moral repulsion is very human.</p><p><strong>But it doesn’t help much to discuss how we want to administer the different costs of the pandemic.</strong></p><p>That is at the heart of the matter, because the virus forces us to crystalize these questions. Also, the world will continue to be hyper-connected after this crisis, and to deal with this complexity -and its inherent uncertainty- it’s essential to learn to balance costs and benefits among different axes of society.</p><p>In this case we have, on one hand, the axis of health: how many people get sick and how many people die. The economy constitutes another axis: how many people will see their quality of life worsen, to what extent of poverty and for how long.</p><p>A third axis consists on the possible mental health problems, which is another very powerful source of human suffering.</p><p>So, to illustrate this with extreme cases: would we be willing to have 1 billion people suffer for 10 years, in order to save the lives of 10 people? Probably, not. And would some of us be willing to be slightly uncomfortable for a couple of weeks to save 100 million lives? Yes. But since the real scenario with COVID is neither of these extremes, we are forced to choose how we will calibrate ourselves, what sacrifices we are going to asume. It’s very difficult to predict which decisions will cause the least possible suffering, but we have to try to home in on the answer. And this requires changing the paradigm of discussion in which each participant’s focus is entrenched in their area of expertise.</p><p><strong>Competing for who sees the “realer” reality.</strong></p><p>Right, it’s like standing in the forest and saying: “<em>I’m</em> observing birds migrations”, “Well <em>I’m</em> observing Carbon transfer” “yes, but <em>I’m</em> observing trees species”. Well who’s watching the forest? I would love to see interdisciplinary meetings where epidemiologists and physicians sit down with economists, sociologists, psychologists. And politicians, obviously. I may be optimist, but I think those conversations would help us to think better and to feel less suspicious of each other.</p><p><strong>It can’t help that the virus caught us with rock-bottom levels of trust, a topic you’ve been discussing for a while.</strong></p><p>Yes, I was just recalling that four years ago I spoke at the Congress of the Future about the trust crisis in Chile. I mean, it was an issue of concern back then. Add the polarizing effect of social media, followed by the social crisis in the country, and now coronavirus. It’s a complex scenario, since trust is the basis of social relationships. The tricky bit is that the trust crisis isn’t stopping at institutions and politicians, it’s affecting empiricism as a way of thinking. It’s become fashionable to mistrust “experts”, either on account of conspiracy theories or through a deeper skepticism along the lines of: what authority do “experts” have and when do we give them our attention. But now we need to place all our trust on public health experts, science and empiricism as a thought structure. This means dialing the hostility down and de-glamorizing the skepticism.</p><p><strong>Another way out of the confidence crisis is through a demand for more empathy, a ability you have studied in depth in your work with bonobos.</strong></p><p>Yes, but I think we are using the wrong word there.</p><p><strong>How so?</strong></p><p>Because we are expecting empathy to solve the enormous tension created by an hyper-connected world. But empathy is a quality that developed in the context of face-to-face interactions, between individuals that know each other and can mirror behavior and eventually emotions. It’s very different to expect empathy from humans that don’t know each other. We are capable of it to a certain extent, because we have the ability to think of ourselves as a species, but empathy is ultimately an insufficient resource in this respect. Because if I ask for your empathy, I am asking you to understand what it is like to live and feel in my shoes. And if the goal is to create frameworks of coexistence to integrate a variety of lifestyles and needs, the question we must pose is “lets understand each other as a society” rather than “you step into my individual shoes”. This discourse on “emotional revolution” with the premise that “if my feelings are stronger than yours I’m more entitled and I have more authority” isn’t going to solve the difficulties of understanding each other in societies as complex as nowadays.</p><p><strong>It has also been said that the pandemic caught us at a moment of very low tolerance to danger, to what’s beyond our control. That many new behaviors -from certain nutritional fads to the proliferation of “safe spaces”- were oriented towards blocking any disturbance that could make us feel vulnerable.</strong></p><p>That, or anything that could offend us. In this regard we’ve been brought down a notch or two by nature. It’s always amused me, this desire for control, for eliminating all potential risks from your life. It makes me wonder, particularly, what made us believe it was possible. It’s just too omnipotent to think you can control nature and other human beings like that. I’m not saying “Look, you have to befriend fear, experience danger”. It’s been a while since I was 18-year-old. The generational rarity still surprises me though: the ode to safety, perhaps for the first time in history, came from the younger generations rather than their elders. Today we have no alternative but to make amends with the fact that life is uncertain, intrinsically risky. Although we have been able to reduce many dangers and causes of death, I think this encounter with our fragility is rather sobering. The perception of death reorganizes priorities. Besides, the virus has shown us something else: that we like living, that life is certainly worth living, despite the pain it entails and the bickering. It will be hard, but it will proove how resilient and capable we are of cooperating at many different levels.</p><p><strong>When the urgency and fear pass, will we re-think our relationship with the planet and the way we inhabiting it? Or we will go back to business as usual?</strong></p><p>Honestly, and by definition, I have no idea, because this is just beginning, and there’s a long way to go. For several several weeks ahead of us tomorrow will be worse than today. But once the wave washes away, <em>if</em>we manage to reflect critically on what happened, based on evidence and not on fake news or bipartisanship, we should try to recalibrate our way of inhabiting the planet as a global society. At the end of the day it’s not about making new decisions, but understanding that we are already making them. When we decide how much we invest in health, in social connectivity, in culture, in preserving nature, we are revealing which well-being we care most about, for ourselves and for others. And which sources of suffering we understand and which ones we don’t.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BdNu0guQUBtV6HDRD-66dQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — <br>Isabel Behncke Izquierdo<br>MSc (Lon), MPhil (Cantab), PhD (Oxon)<br>Evolution &amp; Behavioural Science</p><p>Email: isabel.beagle at me.com</p><p>Instagram, Facebook and Twitter: isabelbehncke</p><p>Senior Fellow, Gruter Institute</p><p>TED Fellow <a href="http://on.ted.com/f09bh">http://on.ted.com/f09bh</a><br><br>Visiting Researcher, Social and Evolutionary Neuroscience Research Group (SENRG)<br>University of Oxford, United Kingdom</p><p>Associate Professor, Social Complexity Research Centre (CICS) <br>Gobierno UDD, Santiago de Chile</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4b0c58c965cd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>