<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Isabel Rose on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Isabel Rose on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@isabelroseadvocate?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 01:26:42 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@isabelroseadvocate/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[CAN LYME PASS FROM MOTHER TO FETUS IN UTERO? SCIENCE SAYS YES, PUBLIC OFFICIALS SAY…NOTHING]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/can-lyme-pass-from-mother-to-fetus-in-utero-science-says-yes-public-officials-say-nothing-9246d61b9a64?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9246d61b9a64</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[womens-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chronic-illness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pregnancy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[maternal-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lyme-disease]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 May 2023 16:48:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-05-28T16:51:05.343Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/760/1*GWKDyfwpReliWc8jKTBM0g.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong><em>Lyme disease can pass from mother to baby in utero whether you know you’re infected or not.</em></strong></p><p><strong>May is Lyme Awareness month.</strong> Perhaps this is why country singer Brad Paisley’s delightful tune “<a href="https://youtu.be/3tiPndMqxLQ">Ticks</a>” played over my car radio the other day. The song tracks the thoughts of a man staring at a beautiful woman at a bar. He wonders what it would be like to walk her through a field of wildflowers before checking her body for ticks.</p><p><strong>I wonder what would happen to their resulting baby should he miss one.</strong></p><p>A wry song like Paisley’s — both sexy and funny, light and serious — can do more to normalize the importance of full body tick checks and to raise awareness of the dangers of tick-borne diseases than any government messaging. But what’s missing from all of the messaging we do receive, and from the general medical knowledge base itself, is that <strong>Lyme, if not treated immediately and aggressively, can not only become a chronic, systemic nightmare for the person bitten by the tick,</strong> <strong>it can also be passed, in utero, from mother to child.</strong></p><p>What, you didn’t know that? Neither did I. But I am a Lyme-infected mother — finally diagnosed at 48, after being infected from a tick bite when I was 8 — who passed on Lyme to her children. In other words, I infected both my children unknowingly, even though I had clear Lyme symptoms prior to, and during those pregnancies that went unacknowledged by dozens of doctors. I should add that one of those doctors, my GP, is an infectious disease specialist.</p><p>Today, to keep this from happening to others, we need to get the word out to other Lyme-infected mothers-to-be and to women of childbearing age who have mysterious, systemic health issues with no clear cause. We also need to reach the government officials who’ve been dragging their feet on this issue, and we need to reach primary care physicians, OB/Gyns, and pediatricians, who are the first line of defense. Researchers also need more funds to study our bodies and those of our children.</p><p>An estimated 500,000 new cases of Lyme disease are reported annually by the CDC, a number that probably grossly underestimates the actual figure as it only includes those who’ve tested positive.</p><p>Why do so many cases of Lyme disease go undetected or misdiagnosed? Simple. Current CDC-approved blood tests are frequently inaccurate, resulting in countless numbers of missed cases. Moreover, because Lyme remains a clinical diagnosis at this time, noted only at first (and rarely, at that) by a bullseye rash and flu-like symptoms, doctors and civilians alike are often ignorant of its complex symptom profile. It is often misdiagnosed as any number of other ailments, including arthritis, fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue, and clinical depression.</p><p>As for the babies of those infected by Lyme, there are currently no clinical guidelines to diagnose, treat, or follow a child who may have been infected with Lyme disease in utero. Nor is there comprehensive, clear guidance regarding treatment of a person who may have been infected with Lyme disease either during pregnancy or prior to it. The sole guidance the CDC offer for someone infected with Lyme who wants to get pregnant is to take antibiotics. But how much or which ones are left up to the person with the uterus and their practitioner.</p><p>“Further research is needed,” the CDC write on their website, leaving a giant question mark as to the safety of getting pregnant after a Lyme infection. Moreover, they posit that congenital transmission between a mother infected with Lyme and their fetus is “possible but rare.”</p><p><strong>Anecdotal data suggests otherwise</strong>. In 2021, a full 36% of the LivLyme Foundation’s 974 grant applicants seeking financial support for treatment reported having transmitted Lyme disease to their children in utero. LymeLight Foundation, which also offers treatment grants, reported that 45% of their applicants transmitted Lyme disease to their children in utero. Mothers Against Lyme, which runs support groups for families affected by Lyme disease, finds that 69% of their participants have passed Lyme Disease onto their children in utero.</p><p><strong>These statistics do not suggest that transmission in utero is rare. They suggest we have a massive issue we’re neither talking about, treating, nor spending research dollars to investigate.</strong></p><p>The consequences of congenital Lyme can be profound, both on pregnancy and its outcome. The first case report was published in 1985. It concluded that Lyme disease during pregnancy had resulted in the premature death of the fetus. In 1989, President George HW Bush issued a proclamation noting, “Lyme disease in pregnancy can result in miscarriages, stillbirth, and birth defects.”</p><p>Should the Lyme-infected baby survive, its path forward can be difficult.</p><p>The late pediatric Lyme specialist Dr. Charles Ray Jones, <a href="https://www.lymedisease.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/Image21-Gestational-Lyme-Studies.pdf">in his study of 102 live births</a> to mothers with confirmed cases of Lyme disease, reported that 80% of the children in his study had cognitive problems, learning disabilities, and mood swings; 72% had fatigue and lack of stamina; 9% had autism. Both of my children are on the autism spectrum, as are many of the children of the women in my Lyme disease support groups.</p><p>Federal agencies warn of the dangers of passing Zika and West Nile viruses onto a fetus and provide guidelines to those seeking pregnancy who’ve been infected with them. Why not Lyme, a far more common vector borne infection?</p><p>So, Brad Paisley, if you’re listening, here’s what we need: a new hit song we mothers with Lyme who have Lyme-infected children can sing in the halls of Congress, begging our public officials to take action. We need to fund more studies of congenital Lyme. We need proper messaging to warn mothers and their doctors of the dangers of passing on Lyme in utero. We need better diagnostics, and we need to normalize testing pregnant mothers and their babies for Lyme disease in the same way “Ticks” has normalized the importance of full body tick checks. Something like “Mammas, Don’t Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be Dismissed, Discounted, Sick, and Unstudied,” but, you know, catchier.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9246d61b9a64" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Our Own Private Kristallnacht, or a Harbinger of Things to Come?]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/our-own-private-kristallnacht-or-a-harbinger-of-things-to-come-762659e3b185?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/762659e3b185</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[second-civil-war]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[taking-responsibility]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[safety]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[current-events]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motherhood]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Aug 2022 21:22:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-12T04:13:02.116Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>How to explain burglary to your teen</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*jksYsR9Xwjy1rpp3aOfUaw.jpeg" /></figure><p>News of the break-in came two days after setting off on a road trip from LA to Colorado to visit my older daughter for her 21st birthday. Immersed in our audio book, <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Breadwinner-Deborah-Ellis/dp/1554987652"><em>The Breadwinner</em></a> — summer required reading for our younger daughter— the call came while we were driving on a windy road near the continental divide. The book paused automatically as a woman’s hysterical voice came through our car speakers. It was our housekeeper, whom we had asked to check on the house a few days a week in our absence.</p><p>The connection was tenuous; we only caught words and phrases: <em>Ladder to your bedroom … Broken glass everywhere… Ransacked… Went around the security cameras… Knew the house… Stole the entire safe…</em></p><p>My own phone vibrated. Two photos came through: one of the now-shattered, picture window to our bedroom; the other of our decimated bedroom closet. Glass was, indeed, everywhere — huge, jagged chunks; small, jewel-like ovals and everything in between that a camera could pick up in a hurried photo, which turns out to be quite a lot.</p><p>“Have you called the police?” I asked our housekeeper, but it was too late. We had entered a dead-zone on the highway.</p><p>Once we accepted that we weren’t going to reestablish contact any time soon, we began to talk.</p><p>“I guess we were robbed,” I said, stating the obvious because I couldn’t state anything else just yet. All of my valuables were in that safe. It wasn’t attached to the wall. We were waiting for a closet renovation to do that; a renovation planned for the fall. I felt immediately devastated and completely culpable.</p><p>More composed than me, our thirteen-year-old asked, “Why do you think it happened?”</p><p>The perpetrators obviously knew the exact position and layout of our room, not to mention the exact location of our safe, way up high on a shelf in our closet, reachable only by ladder, removable only by two people. It was someone we knew, even if only as a home owner might know a one-time-only worker like the filter cleaner on the air conditioner, or a plumber who fixes a broken drain, once. Or else it was someone closer to us; someone who was intimate with our security system. Someone who knew we weren’t all that secure, after all; someone who knew we were careless because we had a false sense of security way on top of the mountain where we live.</p><p>I had a quick flashback.</p><p>When our family moved to Los Angeles from NYC in 2019, we were in the middle of deep, quarantine, Covid, Trump era. We kept our distance from our neighbors and pulled our masks up snug around our faces feeling safer that way, not only from infection, but from the stressful political currents zapping around us.</p><p>Despite our best efforts to stay to ourselves, in the lead-up to the 2020 election, my then twelve-year-old and I got caught in a MAGA rally one day while taking our daily walk on a tree-lined pathway along Santa Monica boulevard in Beverly Hills. Fighting through a sudden throng of ralliers, many unmasked, we made our way back to our car and climbed the long, steep hill back up to our house.</p><p>Half an hour had passed since we got caught in the wrong place at the wrong time, but our hearts were still pounding, both of us in a prolonged state of shock from the clamor of honking horns, menacing shouts, the sheer quantity of pick-up trucks and American flags waving at the ends of scary-looking rods.</p><p>“That’s why we chose <em>this</em> place,” my husband reminded us as we settled down on our terrace. He waved his hand at the expanse around the bluestone — the Eucalyptus where the hawk rests; the other where the owl hoots; the mountains beyond in all their purple-hued majesty. “We’re safe up here,” my husband reiterated. “No one is going to come this far up the hill looking for trouble.”</p><p>How soundly we slept in our far-from-the-madding-crowd beds!</p><p>Flashback completed with the kind of clarity we always have in hindsight, I didn’t want to admit our stupidity and naivety to our daughter, so, I simply said, “We’re living in uneasy times.”</p><p>My husband joined in with a brief overview of income inequality and class tension.</p><p>“But why us?”<em> </em>our daughter persisted.<em> </em>“Why not the neighbors?”</p><p>“Why<em> not </em>us<em>?” </em>I tried. Then I realized I had something much better to draw upon. <em>The Breadwinner</em> is about a ten-year-old girl in Afghanistan who survives the brutality of the Taliban. The narrative centers around two important themes: how quickly life can change; and how resilient people can be, even in the face of the most crushing brutality.</p><p>“Think of <em>The Breadwinner,</em>” I pointed out to our daughter. “The protagonist had plenty of reasons to feel like life was against her, but she had an amazing survival-spirit and overcame all kinds of odds. Compared to what she and her family endured, our burglary is nothing. We just lost <em>things</em>. That girl and her family lost people; body parts; their freedom.”</p><p>“The ability to listen to, or play music!” my daughter added, getting into the spirit of things.</p><p>“We experienced a violation to be sure, but we have plenty of options, which is lucky!” I fist-pumped the air. “And no one was injured. That’s really what matters.”</p><p>“That doesn’t answer why <em>we</em> were robbed, though,” our daughter said soberly.</p><p>“Well,” I began uneasily. “I guess someone who knows us a little bit felt like life is unfair. In that person’s eyes, we have things to spare that they felt they needed. We weren’t around, and maybe our neighbors were, so they helped themselves to <em>our</em> things.”</p><p>“But <em>why</em>?” she pressed.</p><p>Goddamn it. I had no choice. I had to say it.</p><p>“Because mommy and daddy were stupid. And because not everyone is nice.”</p><p>I could hear our daughter’s gears turning. My husband and I place great emphasis on our daughter reciprocating behavior. She has to be taught this because she’s on the autism spectrum and doesn’t understand everything about behavior inherently, the way other, more neurotypical kids might. If she wants people to be nice to her, we’ve said time and again, she needs to be nice to them. As for being smart, how many times have we told her that being a science savant means nothing if she can’t apply her intelligence to real-world situations?</p><p>While our daughter took the time to process my statement (and, no doubt, figure out how to use it to her advantage in the future), I realized that we were insured for everything that was in the safe. There was some comfort in this thought, but you can’t replace your great-aunt’s strand of pearls or the one-of-a-kind vintage ring you bought yourself when you sold your first novel or the pin your parents gave you for your fiftieth birthday.</p><p>In the lull of my private recollections, our daughter asked, “Is it because I’m part of the LGBTQ+ community? Is that why us and not the neighbors?”</p><p>“God, no!” my husband and I said in passionate unison.</p><p>“How would anyone even know that outside our tiny little circle?” I reminded her.</p><p>“Is it because the next civil war has started?” she persisted. “Is that why?”</p><p>We’d been discussing civil war in regard to <em>The Breadwinner</em>, wondering if we are currently living in pre-Taliban/ pre-Second Civil War America. Is it time to leave, we’ve been wondering aloud as a family, or remain, like the family in <em>The Breadwinner</em>, patriots in the land we love, until either the end of our own lives or the end of oppressive rule?</p><p>Neither my husband nor I leapt to say “no” to our daughter’s question about civil war. Though our break-in could have happened at any time, it didn’t.</p><p>It happened at a time in America when Elon Musk has built his own space ship with some of the spare change he isn’t using to either buy, or not buy, Twitter, while our gardener, who’s day starts at 4:30 am, is also working as a night-time security guard but still can’t afford to live anywhere even near Los Angeles proper.</p><p>It happened at a time when when main-stream media, and the educated — including scientists — are being demonized, including liberal, white homeowners like (hum de dum) <em>us</em>.</p><p>It happened while the January 6th hearings are proving, without a doubt, that the Trump government was full of corruption, bullying, and lawlessness without any consequence for bad behavior and half our nation doesn’t care AT ALL; in fact, baby-Trumps are obtaining positions of power and influence in communities all across this country from the smallest county seat all the way up to the Supreme Court.</p><p>It happened at a time when America seems to have become irreparably unmoored from its democratic roots; at a time when neighbor seems more pitted than ever against neighbor.</p><p>From that point of view, it’s tempting to imagine our robbery as somehow connected to a civil war that may have begun on January 6th, 2021, if not earlier.</p><p>Then again, burglaries are not new business. They’ve been around since the dawn of time. My family was robbed at gunpoint in our apartment in NYC during the 1980’s at the height of the crack epidemic. We hadn’t locked the front door. The robber had walked right in.</p><p>“If you’re dumb enough to leave yourself vulnerable to thieves, you deserve to be robbed,” my great-uncle had said. He grew up on the lower east side and knew a thing or two that would have been better passed down to me than his wife’s now-stolen pearls.</p><p>Would that same great-uncle tell us that our burglary was a mere result of our stupidity, or, having known many people lost during the Holocaust, warn us that the event was a warning; the little violation that happens right before the big one? The one in which we, and others like us — meaning, people who have what others want — are killed? (See Wikipedia entries for <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Revolution">Russian Revolution</a>; <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Revolution">French Revolution</a>; <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_Revolution">Cultural Revolution</a>).</p><p>Was the break-in <em>our</em> break-in for a new world order in which we need to live in a fortress-like setting simply to ensure our day-to-day survival?</p><p><em>Is</em> it time to arm ourselves? To leave the country for a safer place (like—where?)? Or can we decide that this was just our daughter’s turn to learn that not everyone is wishing us well and chalk it up to our poor security arrangement?</p><p>As I wrestled through each potential question and answer, my daughter asked how we would know if a civil war had started.</p><p>Former teacher that he was, my husband jumped in with another question. “What do you think civil war might look like today?” he asked her.</p><p>“Like break ins?” our daughter suggested.</p><p>“Nah,” my husband said. “That’s just lawlessness and desperation. We don’t know who the robbers vote for or even if they can vote.” His eyes glued to the curves on the road, he nevertheless explained himself in straight tones. “We’re living in a perfect storm. The progressive left has promoted soft-on-crime policies, while the hard right is embracing a “no-consequences-for-bad-behavior” worldview. Add to this a sputtering economy, inflation, and a whole lot of people who are bummed out about going back to the workplace after getting paid to stay home for more than a year — “</p><p>“So, no civil war?” our daughter asked.</p><p>“No civil war,” I said. “And I’m sure everything can be fixed easily.” This I added more emphatically. “We’ll fix the broken window, get a new safe that’s built into the wall. Honestly, having fewer things of value around the house is better in general. Less to worry about it. It was a break-in this time but it could be a fire or an earthquake next time. Living in LA, we need to learn to handle adversity.”</p><p>Despite my own fear and anxiety, I tried to sound cheerful. A mother’s job, I decided, is to reassure. Not blindly, but within reason, especially in the case of doubt.</p><p>The very next moment, <em>The Breadwinners</em> came back over our speakers and we began to descend into a better-connected zone. Part of me wished we could turn back around and stay safely in the out-of-contact range, but if this robbery will teach me anything, it’s that there isn’t any out-of-range any more. We are all susceptible to peoples’ basest instincts, no matter where we are, no matter where we go. The best we can do is teach our children that bad people exist, urge our children to lock their doors better than we locked our own, and encourage them to stay ever-aware of those who might not be rooting for you, even as you continue to root for them.</p><p>August 2022</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=762659e3b185" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Questions and Conversation]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/questions-and-conversation-ceff6f4ebcc7?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ceff6f4ebcc7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Jul 2022 15:44:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-22T19:19:32.955Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Processing the morning’s newsfeed when your children ask questions and you don’t have the answers.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*yEqKhfpqROC7cVBPiGdSqg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Trump is going to run again. The TV squawkers this morning are saying, <em>it’s not if, but when</em>.</p><p>After the commercial break, this: <em>a Trump rally in Oklahoma will be taking place</em> with <em>female Trump-acolyte and gubernatorial candidate, Kari Lake.</em></p><p>And all this happening parallel to the revelations of the January 6th hearings in which it has been proven successfully — proven undeniably — that Donald Trump is a dangerous actor; a focused, wanna-be-and-almost-recently-was oligarch; a being (I can’t call him a man) who does not care <em>at all</em> that people were crushed to death defending the capitol; defending democracy ; defending the world against Trump himself.</p><p>As usual, my daughter is on her ipad in the next room while I prepare breakfast. When I call her into the kitchen for eggs, she asks, “If Trump wins again, does it mean we’ll have to leave America?”</p><p>Our children are listening. They have questions.</p><p>I may have once answered her like my father answers my own questions these days. “Don’t be so dramatic,” I might say. But I don’t. Instead, I ask her if she wants more salt (she doesn’t). Then, I tell my husband we need to walk the dogs, which is code for: <em>we need to talk privately</em>.</p><p>While our enormous hounds sniff every blade of grass on our street, my husband and I have the same conversation we’ve been having for a while now, only its conclusions are getting closer and closer to reality.</p><p>It’s the, “what if” conversation, where we try to imagine every scenario the next few years might bring so we don’t get caught unprepared.</p><p>These conversations have taken the place of older conversations in which I felt so certain of my opinions. I’m not certain of anything, these days. So, I talk it out with my husband, with friends, with relatives, with strangers. I flounder for answers and listen for solutions to difficult questions.</p><p>Some examples:</p><p><strong>Q: What if Trump wins and the state takes over the internet and we lose our privacy? How will communicate with other like-minded people?</strong></p><p><strong>Conversation:</strong> Is there another internet where Trump and his like went after they were banned from Twitter? Can we use it now? Or make our own? What did dissidents do in Russia (pick any era of oppression)? What did they do in China during the Cultural Revolution? In Cambodia during the Khmer Rouge? In… there are no shortage of examples from history.</p><p><strong>Q: Should we buy property in Portugal? (Several famous people and other not-famous people we’ve heard of have already bought property in this almost mythical liberal Valhalla).</strong></p><p><strong>Conversation:</strong> Neither of us speaks Portuguese. Is there an American school where our daughter could go, or would we home-school her? Could we find support for her learning issues? Her physical issues? Her various medical needs, which are considerable? How would we communicate with the vet?</p><p>Which crosses Portugal off the list. How would we even get to Portugal with two huge dogs, especially if it suddenly becomes hard to leave the country because no one can get gas anymore because Russia has cut us all off? Which leads us to Canada. Even though it’s cold there, at least they speak English. It’s just a drive. We can put the dogs into the car. Which leads to,</p><p><strong>Q: What <em>if </em>the war goes on in Ukraine and no one can get their hands on gas? What if we get stranded here?</strong></p><p><strong>Conversation:</strong> Would that be so bad?</p><p>(We play out all scenarios and realize we might be just fine. We can use a friend’s new restaurant as a headquarters for our underground liberal lifestyle. We’ll secretly support our gay, trans and ethnically diverse friends, figuring out how in nightly meetings in this restaurant’s courtyard. We’ll use phrases like, “More calamari over here!” to mean, “We need more estrogen pills for our trans teen!” or maybe that phrase will mean, “We have room in our house to hide another activist.” I don’t know. I can only imagine.)</p><p><strong>Q: Is my imagination fertile enough?</strong></p><p><strong>Conversation: </strong>My father thinks it’s much too fertile. He thinks I’ve gone off the deep end. Yet, I ask this: If we aren’t in the deep end right now, here in the still-but-barely United States (or should we just call them what they are, the Un-united States?), where, exactly, are we?</p><p>In my estimation, we are in the place in a pool where you are on your tip toes, chin raised to keep from being submerged. One more step and you won’t be able to breathe without being actually swimming; or without floaties; or without knowing how to tread water. Without the right skill set, you might drown.</p><p>All right. You get the idea. I can’t include every thread of conversation we’ve had since the day Trump announced his run for President (the first time).</p><p>What informs these conversations?</p><p>Everything.</p><p>Plus, books like “Night,” by Elie Wiesel, “The Painted Bird,” by Jerzy Kozinski.</p><p>Movies like “The Garden of the Finzi-Continis,” “Schindler’s List,” “Life is Beautiful,” “Jojo Rabbit.”</p><p>Plays like Caryl Churchill’s, <em>Far Away</em>, and William Golding’s, <em>Lord of the Flies </em>and Kazuo Ishiguro’s, <em>Remains of the Day.</em></p><p>Paintings like Bosch’s <em>Garden of Earthly Delights</em>, Goya’s, <em>The Third of May 1808,</em> Picasso’s <em>Guernica.</em></p><p>I search and search, scouring my personal index of survival stories, considering everything so I’m prepared for the darkest of what we already know one human can do to another, even at a time in history when we have a choice of oat milk, almond milk or soy. I don’t want to be caught off-guard; unprepared; naïve when the writing is in bold marker like grafitti on all the walls of our society: “We are in trouble!”</p><p>When I get back to the house from our morning <em>what-if</em> walk, our daughter is up in her room getting dressed for the day.</p><p><strong>Question</strong>: What will I tell her when she asks again?</p><p><strong>Possible Conversation</strong>: <em>We don’t plan to leave, right now, sugar, but we’re monitoring things; considering options. Keeping our eyes open.</em></p><p><strong>Question: </strong>Is this wrong approach? Do I say, <em>These news reporters like to make people like us anxious. The truth is, all is fine.</em></p><p><strong>Question:</strong> What is truth today?</p><p><strong>Question:</strong> What do you say to <em>your</em> children? What is it time for? Do we have a to-go bag ready in the hallway, or serve our kids a plate of eggs like it’s any other day?</p><p><strong>Question:</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ceff6f4ebcc7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Roar]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/roar-743d0ff0e5d5?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/743d0ff0e5d5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[advocacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[women-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motherhood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[roe-v-wade]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abortion-rights]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 15 Jul 2022 11:13:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-16T03:42:56.201Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Sharing your abortion story is a way of legitimizing the dire need for the return, ASAP, of safely-conducted, legal abortion for everyone, everywhere.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/612/1*jksYsR9Xwjy1rpp3aOfUaw.jpeg" /></figure><p>My third pregnancy didn’t work out. It’s as simple as that. At some point between my first OB visit— when I listened to my future baby’s heartbeat with joy, trepidation and excitement — and the second visit — when we could no longer detect a heartbeat — the baby died.</p><p>I wasn’t very far along. How many weeks I can’t say exactly because no one was thinking in terms of weeks back then. But, for the sake of visualizing things, let’s call it thirteen weeks.</p><p>So, there you go: I lost a baby after the current legal cut-off to qualify for an abortion in many states today. But this wasn’t today. It was a number of years ago.</p><p>My OB was calm and compassionate, reminding me that miscarriages and early fetal demise are common, especially for people like me who are over forty, with a history of cervical dysplasia and a previous pregnancy that was complicated.</p><p>“What happens now?” I asked.</p><p>“We schedule an abortion,” my OB said plainly.</p><p>It took me a moment to process this statement. Never mind how to manage the sense of loss; all the fantasies I had already had about being a mother of three; how we would cope with our new addition; how soon I’d need to wear maternity clothes; what car we’d need to drive to fit our brood of three kids. I simply hadn’t imagined needing an abortion. Even hearing the OB say that the baby was already dead, my instant thought was that it would simply be reabsorbed because it was so small. Or maybe — I don’t know — fall out? Yes, I think I thought that this dead baby might fall out of my body like my blood does every month when I get my period.</p><p>Alas, that isn’t how dead babies work. I needed an abortion. My OB mentioned something about being too far along already. Or maybe it had more to do with my risk factor for heavy bleeding. I had almost died from a hemorrhage after my second child’s birth. I was fragile.</p><p>Whatever the reason, I needed to abort my baby. My OB was old and wise. I knew he woudn’t recommend an unecessary surgery. So I scheduled one.</p><p>On the morning of the procedure, I took the subway uptown. At the clinic entrance, I was greeted by an armed guard who stood outside the building looking slightly menacing. I wondered what he was protecting—me? the building? the doctors inside?—but I didn’t wonder for long because the elevator opened and the armed guard motioned for me to step in. Then I went downstairs to the basement.</p><p>I checked in at an unremarkable check-in desk and waited in an unremarkable waiting room where folding chairs were set up in rows, many already occupied by girls and women of varying ages and ethnicities though it wasn’t yet 8 am. After a brief wait, I was called into an unremarkable procedure room. A doctor showed up. I was sedated briefly, got my abortion and came to. Then, I went to a shared recovery room where I was offered either <em>Fig Newton’s </em>or possibly a packet of <em>Chips A’hoy</em>.</p><p>While I waited to be cleared to leave, I chatted with two other women. One was an early twenty-something who got drunk at a party and didn’t even remember having sex. She was shocked when she discovered she was pregnant. She grew up in Ohio and was Catholic. Just beginning her life in New York City at a job in finance, she knew she wasn’t remotely ready to become a mother. The second woman had decided to terminate her pregnancy when she learned her child had a rare disorder she knew she couldn’t afford to support.</p><p>We all agreed it was a good thing abortion was an option.</p><p>Compared to the two other ladies surrounding me, my abortion felt unremarkable. I wasn’t overly grateful that I got one. I simply needed one because if I didn’t get one, I’d be at risk of, well, <em>death</em>. My abortion felt obvious. Choice over whether or not to terminate life wasn’t involved, which is the more traumatic scenario. For me, I simply had a medical necessity.</p><p>There is nothing obvious about getting an abortion today. In fact, I wonder what would happen if the same scenario befell me now?</p><p>Discussing this fraught questions with a girlfriend, she pointed out that nothing would be different if I needed an abortion today because I split most of my time between two states where abortion is still acceptable—New York and California.</p><p>“It isn’t your problem,” she said as we strolled down Madison Avenue, enjoying a lovely July afternoon.</p><p>Isn’t it, though? Isn’t abortion everyones problem? A woman’s life affects all those around her. If something happens to a mother, her whole tribe suffers.</p><p>Obviously, I speak from personal experience when I say that anyone choosing to have an abortion is doing so because it is imperative.</p><p>Anyone choosing abortion is doing so because by continuing that pregnancy, their life (and ostensibly the life they are terminating) will not go well if the pregnancy continues.</p><p>Pro-lifers think women who have had abortions don’t care about life. On the contrary, we are choosing abortion precisely because we <em>do</em> care, passionately. We care about our <em>own</em> lives, prizing it over the un-lived life of the fetus we think will be better off not coming into the world, or the fetus, like mine, that can’t because it has failed to thrive in utero.</p><p>When we choose an abortion, we are choosing <em>not</em> to ruin a life; we are choosing to save one: our own. What’s wrong with that? Why is advocating for your own life now a crime?</p><p>If a state is going to insist that women have babies, that same state better insist that all women who give birth get the financial, medical and psychological assistance required to raise that baby <em>no matter what</em>. Because that’s what it’s come down to. It’s come down to <em>no matter what</em>.</p><p><em>FYI, no matter what </em>covers a whole lot of ground. I, for example, am the mother of a transgender teenage daughter on the Autism Spectrum. I chose neither of those circumstances; they simply happened. They are facts of my life, not choices. My complicated child really needs me alive these days as we navigate her uncertain future.</p><p>If I did get pregnant again, what would my options be today? Even though my girlfriend thinks abortion isn’t my problem, let’s play out a hypothetical. If I had to move to a red state — for whatever reason — and a baby died inside me and had to come out; and if — for whatever reasons — I could no longer afford to travel to a state where abortion is allowed, what benefit would there be in denying me an abortion?</p><p>What if I got an illegal abortion and died from complications? What if I didn’t get an illegal abortion but that dead baby killed me for reasons my OB didn’t feel like discussing back when he simply told me I had to have one?</p><p>What if I died? Right in the middle of my life? Because abortion wasn’t legal anymore?</p><p>People die all the time at inconvenient, unimagined times. Women get terminal cancer with young children. Or they have a car accident. Or they get caught in the cross hairs of destiny in some unimaginable way. <em>Stray bullet. A piece of construction debris collides with their head while waiting at a stoplight. A balcony has a loose railing. An elevator malfunctions and they fall fifty feet to the basement floor.</em>(You can fill in with stories from your own collection of terrible-things-that-happen-to-other-people.)</p><p>Tragedies happen every single day. But these deaths are cruel acts of fate, whereas a woman dying because she was unable to obtain a legal abortion in her state is a chosen act of legal punishment.</p><p>How has this come to be? And why are so many pro-lifers other women? (Read my next essay).</p><p>In the meantime, while we wait for the Supreme court to blow up, or for democracy to die or not die, or for the forest near us to burn, or the pond to go dry, or for our next Frappuccino to arrive, or for one of the Kardashians to bend at the waist, <em>what on earth can we do?</em></p><p>If you are a powerful person, do what is within your power to do. If you have money to spare, donate to organizations that support women’s rights and democratic values.</p><p>If you are a man who cares, help us by voting for the politicians who will ensure our rights; don’t be afraid of the topic just because abortion doesn’t happen to you directly.</p><p>If you are like me— meaning <em>just a regular ‘ol</em> <em>person</em> — no one in particular — just Jane Doe — here’s what I think you can do: <strong>you can</strong> <strong>tell your story, too,or share this one or another one. </strong>Let’s validate our shared experiences in this one, still-here option: freedom of speech.</p><p>Let’s voice our collective stories and our collective outrage and, in so doing, build circles around ourselves of like-minded people.</p><p>In sharing our stories and reaching out to each other, we can create micro communities that feel safe; where we feel understood, seen and heard. From these small, safe places we can potentially move outward, to other small communities in other places, creating a kind of digital underground railroad of sympathy around what it means to be a woman today and, in that way, help each other survive. And maybe more.</p><p>What can’t we do? Give up; think it isn’t our problem; shrug and keep strolling.</p><p>Don’t we still live in a democratic society where we all make decisions together by voting? Yes, we have a Supreme court. Even so, laws are only binding based on mutually agreed upon actions. They are <em>ideas</em>. If enough of us disagree with an idea, it can’t bind us.</p><p>We cannot despair; instead, we must share. It is our only option. We must raise our voices however we can.</p><p>We are woman. Let’s <em>roar</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=743d0ff0e5d5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Politics of Motherhood]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/the-politics-of-motherhood-62d08703dbdb?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/62d08703dbdb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[protection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motherhood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mothers]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 Jun 2022 00:57:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-30T12:48:40.924Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/1*yEqKhfpqROC7cVBPiGdSqg.jpeg" /></figure><h3>Mothers are always worried; it comes with the territory. But today’s mothers have even more to worry about than ever: politics.</h3><p><em>Author’s Note: I wrote this piece right after mother’s day. By the time I was ready to post it, Uvalde happened and no one was thinking about anything but guns. This weekend’s tumultuous news, however, makes me feel the time is ripe to talk about the role mothers are playing now in society. After all, mother’s day doesn’t happen once a year: it happens every single day.</em></p><p>A few days before Mother’s Day, I was making breakfast for my younger daughter when we heard the news together from the television in the kitchen:</p><p><em>Texas was investigating families who offer medical support to their transgender children, recommending removal of the child from the home. Legal action was proposed against the parents and medical provider; teachers and neighbors were being asked to turn in suspects. My daughter looked up from her iPad.</em></p><p>“Can I still go to my appointment?” she asked.</p><p>Her thirteen-and-a-half-year-old face was awash with concern too big for her years to carry, though I don’t think it was for kids like her in Texas, or because Texas was moving to adopt KGB and Nazi era tactics of snitching on colleagues.</p><p>No, my daughter’s concerns were more personal. She had already waited eight months to see our new gender doctor in Los Angeles. Having relocated in the middle of Covid from New York City, so she could attend a school for girls like her, who have a specific type of autism spectrum disorder commonly called “Asperger’s,” we had to rebuild our entire infrastructure. This included finding a new gender doctor for her.</p><p>I knew how much the upcoming appointment meant to her. Eager to discuss the timing of her hormone therapy, she wants to know when the puberty blocker that’s been in her arm for the last two years will be companioned with estrogen. Girls in her class are getting breasts, having periods. She wants to know when it will be her turn.</p><p>“<em>Of course</em> we’re going to your appointment,” I said. Then I told her not to worry about Texas. I didn’t mention Arkansas, where it’s already illegal to offer transition care to minors. Fourteen other states are currently considering bans or restrictions on affirmative care for transgender youth, but I didn’t mention any of that to her, either.</p><p>“California is one of the <em>good</em> states,” I said, flipping her pancake, my ease at the skillet belying the worry in my mind. The breakfast was delivered just as my phone pinged — an early morning text from my older daughter.</p><p><em>Keep having breakthrough bleeding on my birth control pills. I think it’s the new Lyme meds. What if I get pregnant?</em></p><p>A college junior, my older daughter suffers from complex consequences of chronic Lyme Disease, a condition currently unrecognized or misunderstood by many doctors. At least she’s been getting treatment lately, or should I say treatments? They come and go, some effective for a time, others creating worse problems, like the break-through bleeding.</p><p><em>Use a condom</em>, I typed back.</p><p>As I wiped the counter and put the eggs and milk back in the refrigerator, I tried to remember where Colorado stands on the matter of abortion rights. Of course, if worse comes to worse, she can always come to California —</p><p>Until she can’t.</p><p>How long can I count on my new home states? Forever? For another two years?</p><p>I always thought my former home state of New York would be blue in perpetuity, but I know plenty of New Yorkers who voted for Trump, and plenty more who are dissatisfied with the fractured democratic party. Tired of the radical left, they all plan to vote red in ’24. Manhattan may always remain a bastion of liberalism, but it’s no longer clear to me whether the rest of the state will follow suit. Which means California — home of Ronald Reagan — might not, either.</p><p>“Time to get dressed,” I reminded my younger daughter as I simultaneously consoled myself with the thought that my older daughter will be graduating soon and can live in a good state, unless a job or graduate program necessitates moving to one of the bad ones.</p><p>I grew up singing songs like, “Three Cheers for the Red, White and Blue,” and “It’s a Grand Old Flag.” We were a patriotic household, with a long list of members who proudly served in various military branches and fought in various wars. How we loved America! Today, I can only say, “How I love <em>some</em> of America,” which doesn’t feel very patriotic at all.</p><p>Finally, in the car and on the way to school, my younger daughter broke a long silence to ask if it’s true that some people don’t believe a kid can be transgender. Since her first full sentence to me, uttered at the age of 2, was, “I’m a girl,” she can’t wrap her own mind around the negation of her actual being.</p><p>I couldn’t answer her immediately, as I may have even a few years ago. What is truth now? Back in the 1970s, when I was in grade school, we were taught to think of truth the same way we were taught to think about fact. Truths, like facts, were incontrovertible. They were the pillars upon which entire societies stood. The phrase “alternative facts” would have earned a student an instant F. Luckily, it wasn’t hard to ascertain what was true or false. We learned from our parents and our teachers, our clergy, doctors, judges and journalists. We learned fro our role models, like the President. Collectively, these people could be counted on to teach us right from wrong, fact from fiction, and in return, we believed them.</p><p>Today, however, “news,” “truth,” and “fact,” are all open to interpretation and reporters are hired specifically for their bias, the more exaggerated the better for a network or paper’s rating. Judges, too, are picked from pools of bias and packed into courts by politicians eager to promote their own points of view. In fact, in this day and age, truth must be qualified, so I told my daughter that it was true to some very uninformed people but not to me or her dad or all the people we know.</p><p>I was engulfed in worry as Mother’s Day approached, but what better present could I have gotten? My older daughter showed up, having driven to Los Angeles in one mad, fifteen-hour shot because the unseasonable heatwave scorching Utah and Nevada made it impossible for her spend more than a few minutes out of her air-conditioned car during the drive west. At least she’s majoring in atmospheric science so she can be part of the global warming solution rather than a contributor to it. That is, as long as we have a political body that supports the idea of global warming.</p><p>And then it was Mother’s Day, that most non-partisan of holidays. Surrounded by my two girls, I should have been basking in a sense of accomplishment and pride. But I wasn’t. Instead, I was marinating in a sense of deep maternal angst.</p><p>Mothers want to protect their young, even if their young are old enough to become mothers themselves. How can I protect these two girls I love so dearly? How can I keep the good states from getting bad, and the bad states from getting worse? If I can’t always make my kids get along, how can I make our political parties? Don’t the women who support opposing political views from me love their children with equal measure? How can we both feel like we’re protecting our offspring and yet have such wildly opposing ideas of how this might be accomplished?</p><p>Mother’s Day ultimately unfolded as it always does. We went for brunch; I sent flower emojis back to all my friends who wished me a lovely day and texted Happy Mother’s Day to as many friends as I could including those who are mothers to pets, nieces and nephews. By nightfall, I was mildly numb from all the focus and slightly guilt ridden because I was too tired, by then, to help wash my younger-daughter’s hair, which I still do because she can’t — and may not ever be able to — coordinate this effort on her own.</p><p>If, for any number of reasons, I am no longer able to care for my younger daughter because she is removed from our house, who will wash her hair for her? Will her foster parent make her cut it all off and call her by a new male name? Will my daughter try to kill herself because her true identity is unrecognized? Will her death make the laws against supporting trans youth worthwhile? Exactly who do those laws support? People who are afraid of what they don’t understand? Why do they require laws to protect them? Don’t our children need the law on their side?</p><p>And what about my older daughter? If she accidentally gets pregnant and dies getting an illegal abortion because her home state refuses to give her one legally, who will benefit? What if my daughter gets pregnant when she chooses and discovers that the fetus is suffering from something unspeakable? Something that will make her own life impossibly hard to continue? What if she has one healthy child already and dies aborting this next child because her home state won’t conduct a safe, legal abortion? Who will benefit? <em>Who?</em></p><p>As long as we’re asking ourselves questions, let’s ask ourselves this: what woman — either in the throes of sex or at her OB’s office having a fertilized egg implanted — imagines her future child saying, “I’m <em>not</em> a boy, mommy, I’m a girl!’” or visa versa.</p><p>What woman — either in the throes of sex or at her OB’s office having a fertilized egg implanted — imagines her future child being raped by her uncle and impregnated when she’s fourteen and too ashamed to admit it— or possibly even understand what’s happened— until she’s already showing? Does anyone want a fourteen-year-old to become a mother? How can someone who isn’t yet in high school successfully raise a baby? I have a college degree and an MFA and barely have the hang of it after twenty years in the business.</p><p>So, just who does imagine these scenarios?</p><p>No one, that’s who. But they can happen, and if they happen to you and your child, you are going to want to protect him, her or them just as surely as you want to protect yourself.</p><p>And so I went to bed on mother’s day with one thought in my mind: if every mother in this country agreed that it is in everyone’s best interest to pass laws that support <em>all </em>of our children, our angst would decrease and this land would truly be one nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.</p><p>Until then, there has never been more pressure on us mothers to instill values into our children of compassion and imagination. Without that, I fear the future of this nation truly will be continuously compromised and mothers’ day will be yet another example of the partisan divide that is hurting us all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=62d08703dbdb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Battle Over Gender Therapy: a supportive mom’s P.O.V.]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/the-battle-over-gender-therapy-a-supportive-moms-p-o-v-168729162843?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/168729162843</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gender-identity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civil-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hormone-therapy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Jun 2022 23:38:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-30T21:23:33.923Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/620/1*ManCkMGwFnrljkMOWQmC6A.jpeg" /></figure><p>After the 6th friend sent me a link to the article in last Sunday’s New York Times magazine entitled, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/15/magazine/gender-therapy.html"><em>The Battle Over Gender Therapy</em></a>, I decided it was time to take a careful read.</p><p>While I am grateful to reporter Emily Bazelon for her excellent reporting, I nevertheless feel that one group got less attention than is warranted: the parents. Well, that’s not entirely true. Bazelon does discuss parents who fail to support their transgender children, but she doesn’t give nearly enough consideration to parents, like me and my husband, who do support their kids. And this is a pretty grave omission, because when push comes to shove, this issue is all about parents.</p><p>We are the ones making the doctor appointments; researching options; gnashing our teeth; wondering if there is such a thing as a right choice. We are the ones who are holding our children close as they voice their radical depression over what is, ultimately, your fault, especially as a mother. “Why did you make me like this in the first place?” is a phrase I have heard more than once.</p><h4>A tip for those of you who think the gender therapy issue is easy for the supportive parent— it isn’t.</h4><p>Any parent who is supporting their transgender teen through puberty via blockers or hormones, and in some cases, surgery, is doing so only after the greatest amount of focused conversation, deep research, deeper self-scrutiny and the deepest scrutiny of their child.</p><p>My husband and I are parents to a thirteen-year-old transgender girl. We first affirmed her, socially when she was six after several years of persistent, consistant and insistant declarations by our child that “he” was in fact “she.”</p><p>The process of switching genders at a young age, while emotionally fraught, was relatively easy: new name; new hairstyle; new outfit, and we all got on with our lives. That is, until precocious puberty hit at eleven.</p><p>Gone was the joy we felt in purchasing a pair of pink leggings, or watching our ecstatic daughter donning a purple bow. Panic set in. Our child returned to the near-suicidal state that compelled us to begin our gender journey in the first place.</p><h4>My husband and I were incredibly relieved when we found a way to press the pause button.</h4><p>By having a puberty blocker implanted into our daughter’s arm, our doctor reasured us that we could buy ourselves time to think things through in a calmer state since panic isn’t the best jumping off point for major decision-making.</p><p>We weren’t sure what to make of the blocker. Would it stunt our child’s growth? Would her development in other areas be hindered? Our fear over our daughter’s upset at the onset of secondary male characteristics outweighted our fear of the unknown. We went ahead with it.</p><p>To our tremendous relief, once the blocker was implanted, our daughter’s voice stopped deepening, her nascent facial hair diminished and her penis stopped growing. We relaxed. For a while. But time marches on.</p><p>It is two years later and a new (very difficult) decision is being decided. We may choose to remove it, despite the risks that action may incur. We are concerned, having weighed Dr. Marci Bowers’ observations, as quoted in Emily Bazelon’s article: “Trans girls who don’t go through male puberty may find it difficult to have an orgasm after they have genital surgery as adults. They also could have less penile tissue with which to create a vagina, which could lead to more complication after surgery.” Dr. Bowers goes on to say, “Talk about it.”</p><p>And herein lies the tremendous pressure that every parent of a transgender child must bear, particularly the parents of transgender girls. We are forced to decide whether or not our child — still a minor (if 18 counts as an age when one can make good decisions, which, in and of itself is questionable) — should be able to reproduce using their own genetic material.</p><p>Perhaps of even greater significance, we must choose whether or not our child will be able to feel pleasure one day during the same act many of us used to make our transgender child in the first place, and most certainly during our own private moments of self-pleasure.</p><p><em>Talk about it?</em></p><h4>Discussing masturbation, orgasm, a micro-penis that might lead to a vagina made from parts of your child’s colon or intestines—not to mention the complexity of raising children of their own sometime in the very far off future— are not easy chats to have with a young teen.</h4><p>Now, add into the mix the fact that our child, like a percentage of all transgender kids, is on the autism spectrum and struggles with a processing disorder, and the discussions become even more difficult. Even if you’re a super-open parent, like me. Which is why we turned to a gender specialist to act as a moderator.</p><p>This helped, but it was still hard, not only for us as parents, but also for our child. She broke down in tears of mortification when forced to admit that she wants to be able to ejaculate when she masturbates with a penis she hates. Those tears switched in nature to ones of unfairness and loss when we discussed certain infertility if she continues to repress male puberty. She went dry eyed with horror at the thought of not being able to have an orgasm one day with her future, impossible-to-imagine-right-now vagina.</p><p><em>I’ll take, “Subjects not taught in school for $100, Alex.”</em></p><p>Of course, even the seemingly simplest decisions in the teen gender space are met with unexpected conflict. Having arrived at the conclusion that we need to gather more information, I booked another appointment with our gender doctor. Easy, right? Wrong. Our specialist is so besieged with patients, her next opening is six months away.</p><p>Should we find another doctor with a more flexible schedule? Perhaps, but we can’t seem to find a gender doctor with a shorter wait list.</p><p>Why are the waits so interminable? The reality is, there are a lot of transgender kids out there who need care and they’re all racing for an appointment because they are following politics and writhing in fear.</p><p>These teens are asking themselves: <em>Could I be removed from my home if my parents support my desire for hormone intervention? Will I be put into foster care and forced to live in my former “dead” identity? </em>Many of these kids have legally changed their names on their birth certificates and passports; their former self no longer exists. <em>Who will they become</em>? they wonder. <em>What will happen?</em></p><h4>What these terrified kids and their families need — just like our kid and our family needs — are options, not draconian laws.</h4><p>They need frank discussion, and if they can’t have those frank discussions without prompting from a trained moderator, they need to find one. If these moderators are busy fighting fines, or are worried about going to jail or losing their license to practice medicine, these conversations won’t be happening. And without the conversation, the consequences will be, well—</p><p>Some of these kids will harm themselves from fear, alone, of lack of options. And if they live in a state where they truly have no options, some will turn to self-mutilation. Others may choose suicide, or will become one of the transgender teen runaways who make up scary statistics.</p><p>Bazelon points out in her article that <em>all 70 participants in the initial hormone experiments in Amsterdam benefited positively from treatment</em>. She also points out that <em>a second study of 55 patients showed positive outcome with hormone intervention during puberty</em>.</p><p>This is significant data. And we need to keep collecting it to better understand this developing field. How can we continue learning if our clinics and clinicians are obliterated? How can we make informed decisions when the participants in the studies, themselves, are obliterated?</p><p>I speak from the gender trenches, with mud under my nails and the threat of potential tear gas coming my way soon, forcing me to keep a metaphorical gas mask in my cupboard <em>just in case</em>. Parents need support, not punishment, because our children need support, not punishment. How can we pivot without options? How can we offer hope without even the potential for opportunity?</p><h4>None of us is choosing hormone intervention on a whim. None of us thinks it’s like buying our kid a new pair of Air Jordans.</h4><p>Child abuse, the haters say? When did the agonizing decision process of figuring out how to keep our children alive become abuse?</p><p>Would it be better for us to have no choice at all? To answer that, I look back at that all-important statistic, so well-known to all parents of trans kids: “40 percent of trans people will attempt suicide.” <em>And one of those could be our kid, </em>each one of us parents has thought next.</p><p>Let’s keep our children and teens from becoming the wrong statistic. Let’s let them become positive statistics instead. Let’s keep the options on the table. Let’s choose the safety of making hard choices in a climate that isn’t so fraught. Let’s choose choice.</p><p>Isabel Rose</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=168729162843" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Long-Haulers: Covid vs. The Rest of Us Suffering with Chronic Conditions]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/long-haulers-covid-vs-the-rest-of-us-suffering-with-chronic-conditions-1d399d1f2fdc?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1d399d1f2fdc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[chronic-lyme-disease]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[autoimmune-disease]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[belief]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healthcare-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[long-hauler]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 Jan 2021 18:20:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-28T21:55:18.383Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Long-Haulers: Covid Sufferers…and The Rest of Us Suffering with Chronic Conditions</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*rxN-KWTXClZSpJIng1IqUw.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote><em>Yesterday, the New York Times published yet another story chronicling the tragedy of lives still derailed many months after being treated for Covid. The article mentioned that a center for these “Long Haulers” has opened up at Mt. Sinai, and that researchers are studying these unfortunate souls in hopes of gaining better understanding and, hopefully, some cures.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>My heart goes out to everyone still suffering. It goes out with deep and authentic sympathy since my own life has been completely derailed by a misunderstood chronic health nightmare. So, I do, truly, understand what it feels like to be less-than-you-once-were; caught, unaware, by a virus that science doesn’t yet grasp.</em></blockquote><p>Here is the difference between me, and the Covid Long Haulers. I’ve been suffering for more than forty years. FORTY YEARS. I didn’t even have a proper diagnosis until relatively recently: an explanation for all those years spent shuffling from one doctor or physical therapist to the next, some treatments in centers of excellence, others in back alleys reminiscent of something out of a Dickens novel.</p><p>How wonderful for the Long Haulers to be believed. How wondrous to be recognized. My particular condition—Chronic Lyme—isn’t even recognized by the powers that be. I have something people squint their eyes at frequently. I’ve even been to doctors who say, “Don’t even <em>start</em> with the whole Lyme thing. It’s just… not believable to anyone of true science.”</p><blockquote><em>I’m not bitter that Covid Long Haulers have been believed and embraced, offered instant acceptance and community within the established medical world while I spent decades being labeled “a hypochondriac,” “a woman,” “a mother” a “New Yorker,” “a drama queen,” and “someone needing attention.” I’m not angry, even though I was tested for early on-set dementia in my forties while I simultaneously tried to manage one child with ocular issues, anxiety and asthma, and another with Autism Spectrum Disorder and gender dysphoria.</em></blockquote><p>Truthfully, I rejoice at this development. The embrace and studies surrounding Long Haulers can only help those of us with similar stories of chronic suffering. And that is no small achievement. I am sorry that it has taken a global pandemic to shed light on the reality of post-treatment lingering symptoms, but if this harkens a new era of research for us, I say, “Amen.”</p><p>Hopefully now, journalists who write for respected outlets will defer from publishing articles doubting the validity of maladies like Chronic Lyme disease, as it has done in the past. Trust me: those of us who have been sidelined from life’s pleasures don’t need any more negativity cast our way.</p><p>Here’s the thing that does bother me: why have Covid Long Haulers been supported, while Chronic Lyme sufferers been shunned? And I do mean, shunned. Shunned to the point that celebrity sufferers like Yolanda Hadid have written memoirs with pleading titles like, <em>Believe Me. </em>What does it reveal about our medical establishments—from training centers, to hospitals, private practices and government institutions?</p><p>One thing it tells us is that when people complain of something that a blood test can’t find, or the eye can’t see, our culture has a reflex to discount the messenger, rather than to keep searching for the culprit. Clearly, it’s easier and won’t result in a law suit.</p><p>It also tells us that when enough people die, the world is capable of both sympathy and immediate action.</p><p>Few people drop dead from Chronic Lyme disease; it’s a much slower death for sure, frequently one of the soul first before the body and mind get there. There are those who do die from syndromes related to Chronic Lyme disease, but few people associate themselves with the victims.</p><p>Covid has grabbed our attention because the world stopped. Must that be the case for every misunderstood chronic disease or syndrome?</p><p>Like the changes required to truly tackle something really hard—say, global warming—a complete change of ideology is needed; a change that Covid Long Haulers are hastening even as I write these words. Their bodies are being looked at in entirety, not one joint or organ at a time. Their stories of brain fog and exhaustion are being believed, not smirked at while a clinician suggests more cardio or an afternoon cup of coffee.</p><p>If this is the moment of greatest darkness that leads to a brighter day in medicine, and the industries surrounding it like insurance and big Pharma, I welcome it.</p><p>With both fingers and toes crossed, I hope this global nightmare challenges our researchers to strive ever harder on behalf of all chronic disease sufferers. I hope it encourages patent holders to keep their greed at bay. I hope it allows everyone in the health field to unite, as our new President has urged: unite for long-term healing for everyone.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1d399d1f2fdc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Congenital Lyme disease]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/congenital-lyme-disease-19e5e6a0319d?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/19e5e6a0319d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[congenital-disease]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lyme-disease]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pregnancy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[advocacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[maternal-health]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 11 Dec 2020 17:44:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-11T23:39:29.360Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Opening remarks at the NIH/NICHD</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/299/1*hzUIIHCIJDE2eDTqQWUqiw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Lyme disease can impact your developing baby</figcaption></figure><p><em>As Chairman of the Board of Mothers Against Lyme—an advocacy group concerned with the impact of Lyme disease, and it’s co-infections, on pregnancy— I met with the NIH and NICHD on December 7, 2020. Joined by several board members, my job was to set up their personal testimonies in regard to the terrible impact of Lyme disease on their lives, and the lives of their children. My words are applicable to other diseases. Perhaps they can be of use to some of you in your own advocacy. www.MothersAgainstLyme.org</em></p><p><strong>ISABEL ROSE REMARKS</strong></p><p>One incorrect statement from an influential source can ruin lives.</p><p>The Infectious Diseases Society of America recently published such a statement.</p><p>“To date,” they claim in their newest guidelines, “Lyme disease in pregnancy has not been found to result in congenital infection or syndrome of abnormalities, and no additional treatment or monitoring of the mother or infant is recommended beyond the standard of care.”</p><p>I repeat: <em>one incorrect statement from an influential source can ruin lives. </em>In fact, that one sentence left me feeling temporarily paralyzed. I even wondered if Mothers Against Lyme should continue our work, such was the degree of my personal morale collapse.</p><p>But as my emotion mellowed, I realized the wonderful opportunity we were given: the opportunity to share some data the IDSA may have missed.</p><p>So, I’m here; here as a representative.</p><p>Here because I know, like many women, I will never forget the moment at my 36-week sonogram when the technician said, “There’s a problem.”</p><p>I’m here because, like many women, I will never forget the day I heard, “There are many early interventions for children with developmental delays.”</p><p>I’m here because I will never forget the sound of my four-year-old daughter’s screams as a nurse poked her with a fresh I.V so my little one could get the antibiotics she needed for the Lyme disease our pediatrician swore would be completely cured after two weeks; a daughter who, at 19, is still struggling with chronic Lyme disease and it’s longterm consequences.</p><p>I’m here because I never saw a bullseye rash: not on myself; not on either of my children.</p><p>And I’m here because so many people — including doctors, and mothers, and women who are hoping to become mothers — still incorrectly think that if their Lyme test, or their child’s Lyme test, comes back negative, they don’t have Lyme.</p><p>I’m here because, until we get a reliable Lyme diagnostic, I want every OB to know what Lyme symptoms look like, so they can offer appropriate and available treatment to their patients who may be at risk, not just of passing their infections on to their offspring in utero, like I did, but at risk of having those infections damage their developing child in utero, like my infections did.</p><p>And I am here because, after suffering countless misdiagnosed physical and neurological assaults for 48 years, it was not until four years ago that I was finally properly diagnosed, and then successfully treated, for Lyme disease, as were both of my children shortly thereafter, and my 78-year-old mother — a woman who has spent much of her life suffering from what her doctors call Rheumatoid Arthritis but which I now call Lyme.</p><p>I know that correlation does not equal causation. But I also know that research is inspired by stories from the trenches, where I am, and where so many other women are, our sleeves rolled up, our hands dirty, our nails shredded or bitten to stumps. Maybe hearing some of our abbreviated stories will help convince you that further studies are critically needed.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=19e5e6a0319d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[In Support Of All Transgender Children]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/in-support-of-all-transgender-children-and-their-brave-parents-e216db70a192?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e216db70a192</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[equality]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[children]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 09 May 2017 15:30:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-06-26T03:58:31.672Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>In Support Of <em>All </em>Transgender Children</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*NNQ0ZMKAPF-W0Dm2smgMSA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Addressing a crowd at the Family Equality Council benefit at Pier 60, NYC</figcaption></figure><p><em>(Note: I was asked to speak recently at the annual benefit in support of the Family Equality Council. Many of the attendants asked if I could publish my words. So, here they are.)</em></p><p>My 8 year old daughter is obsessed with science. And I mean <em>obsessed</em>. This kid knows how every system in the body works: the endocrine system, the reproductive system… how a sperm fertilizes an egg…how a fetus grows in utero… how newborns instinctively know how to suckle from a mother’s nipple…</p><p>Incidentally, she calls female nipples “useful nipples,” as opposed to male nipples, which she says are “purely decorative.”</p><p>I might also mention that she is incensed to have such hateful things attached to her own body as “purely decorative nipples.” She’s equally infuriated that she doesn’t have a uterus, because she plans to grow a baby herself one day and she wants to know <em>where</em> and <em>how</em>.</p><p>Oh, yes, my little scientist, knows that she isn’t like the other girls in her second grade classroom — those lucky cis-gender girls who take their anatomy for granted.</p><p><strong>HER CHILDHOOD</strong></p><p>The early years of my daughter’s life were a challenge, which I’m sure you can imagine since we mistook her for a boy; since we thought she was <em>going through a phase </em>every time she donned a tutu; since we thought she was <em>trying to get attention</em> by throwing tantrums when we made her wear a suit<em>. </em>Back in those days, she refused to look in the mirror, or smile for a photo. She was four when she told us she wanted to burn her own face off because it wasn’t surrounded by long beautiful hair.</p><p>Our lives changed on <strong>December 19, 2014</strong>, on a Christmas vacation to Mexico. It was on that day that the chrysalis imprisoning our child split open and a true butterfly burst forth, soaring on the wings provided by a simple cotton sundress. It was on that day that my husband and I fully understood the crucial mission every parent has to listen to their child; to respect the inner wisdom every child is born with; to recognize that our <em>children</em> tell us who they are — not their parents, or their teachers, or their pastors, or the President.</p><p><strong>POLITICS</strong></p><p>Less than a year ago, I thought we had this equality thing down. The gains made under the Obama administration were profound, and seemingly a sign of great cultural progress. And yet, with the simple stroke of his pen this past february, President Trump rescinded protections that guarantee transgender students the right to use the bathrooms of their choice, thereby launching an all-out, unprovoked<em>,</em> discriminatory human rights violation aimed directly at transgender youth and their families.</p><p>On a mission for answers, I traveled to D.C. at the end of March to meet with Education Secretary Betsy DeVos. I asked her to consider the sheer <em>courage</em> transgender and gender expansive students summon when they enter the bathroom of their choice. I said, “Secretary DeVos, transgender children <em>are</em> who they <em>are</em>. They aren’t girls pretending to be boys, or boys pretending to be girls.” I added, “At a time when bullying is a federally sanctioned form of conflict resolution, these kids need more protection than ever. Acceptance is protection and protection is a requirement.”</p><p>Secretary Devos was gracious; I sincerely thank her for that. She nodded politely, reconfirmed her belief in the voucher system, and (glaringly) made no commitment whatsoever to become an ally to non-gender conforming students.</p><p><strong>FIELD REPORT FROM OUTSIDE THE LIBERAL BUBBLE</strong></p><p>So where does this leave us?</p><p>By the sheer luck of our status — because we live in NYC with easy access to transgender support groups, therapists, and doctors; because our daughter attends a public school that considers themselves part of our team — we’re probably going to be alright — for <em>now</em>.</p><p>But there are families who are not alright. <em>Right now</em>.</p><p>I want to tell you about my friend, Sally.</p><p>Sally was born and bred in a small town in Arkansas: a tight community of devout Christians who (as Sally puts it) “are all up in each others business.” When Sally’s five year old son, Daniel, persistently proclaimed himself a girl, Sally took him to the church elders, who proceeded to “help” the child by trying to beat the demon seed out of him.</p><p>When Daniel begged to go to “Daddy Jesus” as Sally watched her child’s blood soak through the wood floorboards of the church where she, herself, was baptized, she had an epiphany. She understood that God makes no mistakes; she realized that ashes to ashes, dust to dust <em>we are all one and the same; </em>that her child’s anatomy was window dressing; and that her baby did not deserve to be punished for simply being her true self.</p><p>So Sally picked up her battered child and moved, with her six other kids, to a new town — away from her family and friends; away from her once beloved church, and from her job. And how was Sally rewarded for her bravery? Her husband left her; Daniela’s local public school refuses to let her use the girls bathroom; child services has begun an investigation into whether Sally is guilty of child abuse and suffering from Munchausen by Proxy; and Daniela may be moved to foster care where she will be forced to live once again as a miserable boy named Daniel.</p><p><strong>DISCRIMINATION AFFECTS US ALL</strong></p><p>When Sally told me all this recently, I felt terribly for her in the way that people who think of themselves as “safe” tend to offer poor, sad <em>others — </em>until I realized, with a shock of ice cold recognition, that privilege of my New York status can only protect <em>my</em> family so far. Just like long-established, civically minded and philanthropic German Jews who were hauled off to concentration camps even as they proclaimed, “There must be some mistake! I’m a German!” — if the mob comes for us, our daughter is as vulnerable as Daniela, and <em>I</em> am as powerless to protect my child as Sally.</p><p>Sally and I have something else in common. We’ve both been criticized for outing or children by daring to tell our family stories. And yet I ask: if not us, then who?</p><p>If that mob ever comes, I guess they’ll know how to find me. And when they do, they’ll hear me proclaim again and again: “I support, and unconditionally love, my transgender daughter. Here I stand.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e216db70a192" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Transgender Children 101]]></title>
            <link>https://isabelroseadvocate.medium.com/trans-trolls-welcome-here-f5424237ccb0?source=rss-8cffc256b0ed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f5424237ccb0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[lgbtq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motherhood]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[transgender]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Isabel Rose]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 03 Mar 2017 12:05:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-15T20:22:10.480Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>The mother of a transgender child clarifies some misconceptions</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yxmfYHLSwe9t9XVFfMaEOw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Happiness is contagious; transgendor dysphoria is not.</figcaption></figure><p>Shortly after I published my <strong>Open Letter to Ivanka Trump</strong>, in which I asked her to consider the plight of parents and their transgender children, I heard back from a reader with the following advice: “Prepare for hate mail. Ignore it.”</p><p>Sure enough, the emails started pouring in, and while most were supportive, a clear contingent were rough. At first I ignored the vitriol but soon found myself searching for the hateful missives, drawn to the ugliness like rubbernecking at the scene of an accident.</p><p><em>What happened</em>, I always wonder, when I see a car crushed like an accordion on the side of the highway, shattered glass on the asphalt, an ambulance pulling away, sirens blaring. Could something have been done to rescue the victims from such an awful fate?</p><p>Just as our road safety specialists exhort us to learn the rules of the road before we get behind the wheel, as I read (and then reread) the various accusations leveled at me, I felt an increasing desire to respond to my detractors in an effort to avoid any further catastrophes that could have been circumvented with a little more understanding.</p><p>Below are some of the emails I received, followed by my responses.</p><p><strong><em>“There’s no way your son could have know he was transgender at the age of 8. Obviously either you, or your equally deranged husband, brain-washed the poor kid.”</em></strong></p><p>Actually, our child knew there was an incongruity between the way he felt, and the way he was being dressed, long before he knew the words to explain himself. As soon as he could gesture, he pointed to girl dolls, dresses and mermaids. And once our child discovered language, he put together sentences like, “I’m a girl kitty,” or “I’m a girl bunny.” He was three years old. And recently, when asked at what age did she realized she wasn’t a boy, our daughter answered, “I don’t understand the question. I’ve <em>always</em> been a girl.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/707/1*4-WI8CuaXe66q_xmZ0m5jQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Not every transgender child has this level of awareness at such a young age, but many transgender children do, or perhaps more parents are listening and responding to their transgender children, which in turn is bringing the number of cases we know of to light.</p><p>Exactly why some children are transgender and others aren’t, isn’t fully understood, though recent studies point to differences in the brain composition of transgender people, which supports my belief that people who are transgender do not make that choice, but simply <em>are</em> transgender. It’s been my observation that you can’t make someone, or prevent someone, from being transgender. A person either is, or isn’t.</p><p>As far as brain-washing goes, aside from the fact that in our case we already had a daughter and didn’t need to brainwash our son to become another one, this comment begs the question: Why would we wish our child to have an identity that is so often attacked and disrespected by others? While my husband and I completely embrace our daughter for who she is, it is clear, from comments like the one above, that others in our world do not afford transgender children the same dignity.</p><p><strong>“There is no way your child could understand sexuality at the age of 8, let alone 5.”</strong></p><p>You are right! When someone is transgender it doesn’t mean they’re gay, straight or bisexual. In fact, it has nothing to do with sexuality. Being transgender has to do with identity — who you are — not who you love.</p><p><strong>“It’s sad to know that there are evil parents in this world who turn their children into perverts.”</strong></p><p>Being transgender is not a perversion; just life in all its glorious diversity.</p><p>“<strong>Your child has an illness and needs medical attention immediately!”</strong></p><p>As a parent who was confronted by her four year-old’s severe depression, I can assure you that my husband and I did, indeed, seek medical attention from a trained and experienced professional. We did not, however, seek the kind of medical treatment one would obtain if their child had a disease.</p><p>Being transgender is not the same as having a viral or bacterial illness, nor is it a psychiatric affliction. Others can’t catch it, or be treated for it with rounds of drugs, electroshock therapy or through reconditioning.</p><p>Luckily, what <em>can</em> be treated with medication is depression and anxiety. Pediatric specialists can prescribe a variety of medications that can relieve the worst symptoms. If a child is so distracted by their gender dysphoria that they can’t get through the day, I strongly recommend looking into this option. Happier children will make stronger adults. We need to get over any stigma we may attach to meds and, instead, focus on their benefits. It might not be the choice you make, but at least you should know it’s an option.</p><p>If your child, like ours, meets the criteria for gender dysphoria (insistent, persistent and consistent in their gender identification regardless of their anatomy) the specialist you see can assist both you and your child in coming up with solutions that will improve all of your lives and minimize emotional discomfort.</p><p><strong>“You should beat the sh-t out of your kid and tell him to deal with the fact that he has a penis. You can’t get everything you want in life and your little brat better learn that right now!”</strong></p><p>I don’t believe in corporeal punishment (and I pray to god you don’t either!). In fact, I’m pretty sure most states now consider it physical abuse or assault when you beat your kids. That said, we do seem to share at least some common ground. Like you, I whole-heartedly agree that children need to learn that disappointment is part of life and that you can’t get everything you want. Nevertheless, if your child is suffering from gender dysphoria, like mine was, that child needs compassion, reassurance, advice on how to best manage his or her distress, and access to a community that shows them it’s ok to be who they are.</p><p>Family acceptance, rather than family violence, is clearly the best form of protection we can give our children. My gender counselor, Jean Malpas, told an audience at a recent gender rally that an accepted child is eight times less likely to attempt suicide later in life. You tell me: what’s better — a dead child, or a transgender one?</p><p><strong>“The fact that you forced your child to cross-dress just goes to show how mentally ill you are.”</strong></p><p>Not every transgender child insists on changing all gender markers — like their name, hairstyle and fashion — but many do. As a parent, you have to follow your child’s lead. We never insisted that our son become our daughter. We always let her show us the way. Our only motivation was, and continues to be, having a happy child. In our case, we had a seriously distressed son who sobbed when we put him in a suit for formal family gatherings. We allowed him to dress like a girl… <em>et viola!</em> We had happy child. The end.</p><p><strong>“You should be jailed for mutilating your child!”</strong></p><p>There is definitely no mutilation going on with transgender children. Wipe that idea right out of your mind.</p><p>When the parent of a transgender child says their child has “transitioned,” or is “an affirmed transgender boy/girl” this means that the child is now being recognized by the pronouns that correspond with his, her or their preferred gender. It does not mean they have undergone gender confirmation surgery. Actually, until children hit puberty, and often well beyond that, nothing medical or irreversible is done beyond fashion and grammar.</p><p><strong>“You need help.”</strong></p><p>I agree! Any parent who is raising a transgender child should get help! There are gender specialists everywhere. Contact the Gender &amp; Family Project at The Ackerman Institute, or The Trans Youth Equality Foundation. Join a transgender family community either in person or on line. Educate yourselves (and your friends) by watching and promoting Katie Couric’s brilliant new documentary made with National Geographic called <em>Gender Revolution</em>. We are, indeed, stronger together.</p><p><strong>Are you being funded by George Soros?</strong></p><p>No.</p><p><strong>“What kind of pussy parent are you? If your kid has a penis, they should pee in the men’s room. If your kid has a vagina, she should pee in the girl’s room. Don’t force the rest of us to have to witness your depravity.”</strong></p><p>To that one, I will simply say: Maybe the person who is upset by the sight of the unexpected in their bathroom needs to examine their response to diversity. When we encounter difference, which is inevitable given the plurality of our nation, we have a choice in regards to our response to it. We can make it go away, or we can welcome it and realize that beneath our skin, hair and clothes, past our breasts, vaginas and penises, we all have beating hearts, rushing blood, lungs breathing in and out. In short, we are all the same.</p><p>I hope this brief show-and-tell has offered some insight into the level of misunderstanding that’s out there.</p><p>Wouldn’t it be wonderful if we could all come to terms with the huge spectrum of gender that makes our world such an interesting place? Wouldn’t it be refreshing to focus on the beauty of that diversity rather than fear it, accuse it of something it isn’t, shame it or, worse, run it off the road and send it careening into a ditch?</p><p>We each have the opportunity every single day of our lives to look at those things we fear and either turn away and pretend they aren’t there, or ask ourselves why we fear them.</p><p>And now that I’ve addressed some of that detritus on the shoulder of life’s highway, I want those naysayers and pundits to know that my little happy family won’t be looking back in the rearview mirror anymore. We’re gunning it all the way to a horizon of joy and acceptance. Lucky for you, we’re very open-minded, so if you change your tune, you’re welcome to join us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f5424237ccb0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>