<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Ivan Spasov on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Ivan Spasov on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov?source=rss-977506e56c1b------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 20:15:19 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Does “The Big Bang” Disprove a God?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/does-the-big-bang-disprove-a-god-4fc0273566dc?source=rss-977506e56c1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4fc0273566dc</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ivan Spasov]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Nov 2026 13:31:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-10T13:31:43.338Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Can The Big Bang in itself be used as an argument against a God? Any God? We’ll seek to argue that singularly, in itself, it cannot.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gbFW6l3LXfmD5YhA4zb9eA.png" /></figure><h3>1. Introduction</h3><p>The Big Bang is one of the most important scientific discoveries in human history. It has been pivotal in showing us glimpses into the evolution of our universe, and while it is a truly remarkable theory, this essay will argue that it doesn’t give an answer to the ultimate question. The one of God and creation. Many atheists use The Big Bang to disprove a theological beginning to the universe. Many physicalists use it to disprove alternative metaphysics. However, we’ll make the point that such a line of argumentation is inherently faulty.</p><p>The statement of this essay is that The Big Bang in essence is a scientific theory and in principle cannot disprove either theological or metaphysical propositions. Additionally, we’ll make a point that many religious texts can be read in a way that accounts for the theory, while some alternative metaphysics can exist perfectly within it.</p><p>Now, let’s start our investigation at the most appropriate place — the very beginning.</p><h3>2. The Big Bang, God and Metaphysics</h3><p>For us to get a firm grip on what The Big Bang is and how it affects theological and metaphysical questions, we must establish several things at the start. Firstly, is the formulation of the theory itself in a single sentence:</p><p><em>The Big Bang theory proposes that the Universe began roughly 13.8 billion years ago as extremely hot and dense, rapidly expanding and has been cooling down and spreading out ever since. [1][2]</em></p><p>Now, let’s establish what we mean by God, since this might be the most contentious terms within the essay. By “God” we’ll refer to an omnipresent entity that can be seen as the grounds of reality and its sole propagator.</p><p>We will refrain from using a specific God, or an interpretation of divine creation, due to the loaded connotations of these terms which can argue for the existence of one God or another purely by scripture, without even evoking The Big Bang.</p><p>In the next chapters of the essay, we’ll investigate how The Big Bang came to be. Then, we’ll move on to the nature of the scientific endeavor and its relation to the discovery of metaphysical or theological truths.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YwlqPY355n0JObs1rn3TVA.png" /></figure><h3>2.1. The Discovery of The Big Bang</h3><p>The history of The Big Bang is a major part of early 20th century physics and cosmology [1][2]. Firstly, Alexander Friedman solved Einstein’s equations of General Relativity which paved the way for Georges Lemaître and Edwin Hubble, who formed the core of what we know today as The Big Bang [3][4]. For this essay we’ll put our focus on Lemaître — a Catholic priest, mathematician, physicist and astronomer, he can be rightfully considered the father of The Big Bang theory.</p><p>He initially presents his theory as “The Primeval Atom”, where he proposes that physics does not describe an explosion in space but rather an expansion of spacetime from an initial highly compressed state. In that regard, he had a back and forth the great Albert Einstein. Initially, Einstein praised Lemaître’s mathematics but heavily critiqued his physics. However, in a surprising twist, in 1931 Einstein would admit that Lemaître was correct and accept his work. [1][2][3]</p><p>A very interesting point about Lemaître is his stance on science, religion and metaphysics. Namely, that science answers different questions then theology or philosophy in general. He made a sharp distinction between physics and religion, stating plainly that they’re non-overlapping domains. In his famous words:</p><blockquote>“The beginning is so simple, so physical. The creation is quite a different issue.”[2]</blockquote><p>Additionally, when Pope Pius XII tried to use The Big Bang as evidence for divine creation, Lemaître remained firm in his stance, defending the independence of science from religion.</p><p>There is a point to be made here. Namely, that science cannot give answers to fundamental questions like God or creation. Such lines of questioning are answered in the fields of metaphysics and theology. In the next chapter we’ll investigate why that is the case.</p><h3>2.2. Scientific Theories and The Big Bang</h3><p>We’ve established The Big Bang as a scientific theory and we have stated that as such it cannot, in principle, give us any resolution to the questions of God or creation. We’ll need to provide evidence for this statement. Firstly, we’ll need to lay out what science truly is. There is the prevailing myth that it is a vehicle for understanding ultimate or final truths — a very false claim, contradicting the very nature of scientific endeavor.</p><p>Science is the essence of studying reality through observation, hypothesis, experimentation and testing. The scientific method is self-correcting by its nature — claims need to be falsifiable, evidence based and open to revision. In turn, science as a discipline is not a provider of absolute truths but rather a predictor of the behavior of the world, whose aim is to make better and more accurate predictions. [5]</p><p>To enforce this line of thinking further, let’s examine the thoughts of some of the world’s greatest thinkers. We’ll begin with a quote by Werner Heisenberg:</p><blockquote>“The hope that new experiments will lead to a complete objective description of the world seems unrealizable.” [6]</blockquote><p>We can further examine a very strong statement from Niels Bohr:</p><blockquote>“It is wrong to think that the task of physics is to find out how nature is. Physics concerns what we can say about nature.” [7]</blockquote><p>Additionally, let’s present a final quote from Alfred North Whitehead:</p><blockquote>“Science is concerned with the discovery of patterns, and it ignores the qualitative character of individual occasions.” [8]</blockquote><p>There is another layer that we should investigate. What science does is to model the behavior of nature. In that sense, modeling anything is an abstraction, a description or an approximation of how we assume a certain phenomenon can be translated into a framework with which we can work. [5][8][11] Let’s explore the thoughts of Karl Popper:</p><blockquote>“Science may be described as the art of systematic oversimplification.”</blockquote><p>Going further, The Big Bang as a theory has a major problem with causality in general. It does not provide a primordial cause that explains why it occurred in the first place. [4][5] This is usually at the threshold of the biggest question of philosophy — namely, how do we get something out of nothing. A question that is metaphysical in nature. Proponents of The Big Bang would state that “what comes before” doesn’t make sense, since it is the starting point of space, time and the causal chain. However, this is a philosophical statement and not a scientific one. It makes a metaphysical claim, while also providing the breakdown of abstract equations as proof. There are no actual empirical evidence of time and space beginning at The Big Bang and there are alternative cosmology theories that propose a cyclical nature to the phenomena. Here we may also refer to the wisdom of David Hume:</p><blockquote>“The utmost effort of human reason is to reduce the principles, productive of natural phenomena, to a greater simplicity, and to resolve the many particular effects into a few general causes… But we can never discover ultimate causes.”</blockquote><p>With what we’ve seen thus far, we can honestly make a statement that science tells a story. A story about how the world behaves and how we can predict its future behavior. In the words of Paul Feyerabend [13]:</p><blockquote>“Science is much closer to myth than a scientific philosophy is prepared to admit.”</blockquote><p>The Big Bang indeed fits — an approximation, framed as the beginning of our reality but not revealing either cause or an actual genesis. In the next chapter we’ll examine theological and metaphysical propositions that may account for The Big Bang in their own context.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nq-KkXrzL6uqmu_L1wC4eg.png" /></figure><h3>3. God, Theology and Metaphysics</h3><p>Since we began this investigation with the question of God and creation in mind, it only makes sense that at the start of this chapter we tackle theology. We’ve already had a glimpse of it when we discussed Pope Pius XII and his interpretation of Lemaître’s discovery. And despite Lemaître’s well founded objections, a theologian can easily find very good examples in foundational religious texts that can support a Big Bang. We’ll investigate such texts to see possible theological interpretations. Firstly, we’ll start with some fundamental texts in Christianity:</p><blockquote>“In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth. And God said, Let there be light: and there was light.” — Genesis 1:1–3 [14]</blockquote><blockquote>“In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. In him was life; and the life was the light of men. And the light shineth in darkness; and the darkness comprehended it not.” — John 1:1–5 [14]</blockquote><p>As we examine these excerpts, we can clearly see the phenomenon of creation as it unfolds. The image of infinite darkness and nothingness being broken by brightness, a spark or an explosion. Many religions have such an image. Another example can be found in Judaism:</p><blockquote>“A spark of impenetrable darkness flashed within the concealed of the concealed, from the head of Infinity… It was in this spark that all hidden things were concealed and from it issued all worlds”- Zohar I:15a-b [15]</blockquote><p>While the Abrahamic religions provide some very compelling texts, it is the description of creation of the Eastern teachings that we’ll focus on more in the following paragraphs. Firstly, let’s examine the Rig Veda 10.129 [16]:</p><blockquote>“There was neither non-existence nor existence then… Darkness was hidden by darkness in the beginning… All this was water, without distinction. Then that One breathed, windless, by its own impulse. From heat was born the One.”</blockquote><p>There is an even more fitting quote from Bhagavata Purana 3.26.3–4 [17]:</p><blockquote>“The Supreme created the cosmic egg, which lay in the waters for a thousand ages. From this egg the universe came into being, expanding under His glance, and from the subtle the gross was generated, one after another.”</blockquote><p>The egg shape almost completely coincides with Lemaître’s “Primeval Atom”, while the process of its unfolding feels like it could easily be the description of the expansion of the universe, as well as the cosmic radiation background.</p><p>With all of this in mind, we still need to remember that such similarities are not actual evidence of a process found through scientific means. What we should acknowledge is that when it comes to proving or disproving God, The Big Bang can quite easily be used on both sides of the argument.</p><p>Moving out of theology and into metaphysics, we can see many examples of a Big Bang phenomena rooted in the construction of an ontological approach. For our investigation here we will not tackle classical thinkers like Plotinus or Empedocles but rather modern day thinkers, who take the actual theory into account. To do so, we’ll focus on the work of philosopher Bernardo Kastrup and physicist Thomas Campbell.</p><p>Bernardo Kastrup proposes his own form of idealism, where the ground of reality is Universal Consciousness — a field of subjectivity in potentiality, pure awareness. It gives rise to Mind-at-Large, which is what we experience as reality, and we in turn are disassociated altars of Mind-at-Large. In his framework, Kastrup accounts for The Big Bang as follows:</p><blockquote>“The Big Bang marked not the beginning of existence itself, but the beginning of a particular configuration of existence: the onset of a dissociative process in universal consciousness that we call the universe.”</blockquote><blockquote>“The universe did not arise out of nothing; it arose out of the dynamics of consciousness. What we call the Big Bang is simply the first moment of a specific mental process, not the absolute beginning of being.”</blockquote><p>Kastrup doesn’t label Universal Consciousness or Mind-at-Large as God, however both fit our definition of it within this essay.</p><p>Another such thinker is Tom Campbell. While not strictly a philosopher, his work can fit the metaphysical idealism category. He uses a lot of simulation metaphors, although he is clear that it is just jargon. Much like Kastrup, Campbell proposes that at the root of our reality stands what he calls the Larger Consciousness System and that each of us is an Individuated Unit of Consciousness within LCS. Let’s examine how he sees The Big Bang:</p><blockquote>“Our physical universe began with the Big Bang because that was the point at which our virtual reality was started up. The Big Bang is simply the beginning of our rule-set and our evolving simulation; it is not the beginning of the Larger Consciousness System.”</blockquote><p>Within Campbell’s work, as with Kastrup, LCS is not explicitly labeled as God but unlike Kastrup’s Mind-at-Large, Tom is much more open to the term. Additionally, LCS has much more God-like attributes as compared to Kastrup’s ontology.</p><p>There is an additional point to be made for both thinkers. Namely how they address causality. For both of them it is merely an appearance. Each would give his own reasoning but the commonality is that causality is an inner property and appearance of their respective ontological primitives.</p><p>With all that in mind, it’s time to look back at everything discussed and reach the conclusions of our investigation.</p><h3>4. Conclusion</h3><p>We began our journey with a statement. Namely, that The Big Bang does not disprove the existence of a God. We also pointed out that it doesn’t necessarily prove it either.</p><p>Throughout the essay, we discussed how this very point appears at the genesis of the theory with Lemaître himself. Further, we investigated the scope and purpose of the scientific method and how it does not deal with the meaning and essence of reality but rather its behavior and predictability.</p><p>From there we made a leap into theology and religion, investigating a different viewpoint. Then we took a dive into modern alternative metaphysics and found that contemporary idealists, who propose an omnipresent entity as the ontological grounds of reality, can easily account for The Big Bang in their own frameworks, without being logically inconsistent.</p><p>When all is said and done, all stops along the way showed us one thing — that The Big Bang does not disprove the existence of God.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>1. Roveli, Carlo. <em>Seven Brief Lessons on Physics</em>. Translated by Simon Carnell and Erica Segre. New York: Riverhead Books, 2016.</p><p>2. Kragh, Helge. <em>George Lemaître: The Priest Who Invented the Big Bang</em>. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016.</p><p>3. Lemaître, Georges. “<em>The Beginning of the World from the Point of View of Quantum Theory</em>”. Nature 127, no. 3210 (1931): 706. <a href="https://physics.umd.edu/grt/taj/675e/Luminet_on_Lemaitre_The_Beginning.pdf">https://physics.umd.edu/grt/taj/675e/Luminet_on_Lemaitre_The_Beginning.pdf</a></p><p>4. Maudlin, Tim. <em>Philosophy of Physics: Space and Time</em>. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2012.</p><p>5. Maudlin, Tim. <em>The Metaphysics within Physics</em>. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007.</p><p>6. Heisenberg, Werner. <em>“Physics and Philosophy: The Revolution in Modern Science”</em>. London: George Allen &amp; Unwin, 1958, p. 29.</p><p>7. Bohr, Niels. “The Unity of Human Knowledge”. Atomic Physics and Human Knowledge. New York: Wiley, 1958, p. 18.</p><p>8. Whitehead, Alfred. <em>Process and Reality: An Essay in Cosmology, corrected edition</em>. David Ray Griffin &amp; Donald W. Sherburne. New York: The Free Press, 1978.</p><p>9. Popper, Karl. <em>The Open Universe: An Argument for Indeterminism</em>. London: Hutchinson, 1982, Reissued: Routledge.</p><p>10. Popper, Karl. <em>Conjectures and Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge</em>. London: Routledge &amp; Kegan Paul, 1963.</p><p>11. Hume, David. <em>An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding</em>. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999</p><p>12. Хюм, Дейвид. <em>Изследване на Човешкия Разсъдък</em>. Превод: Вера Любенова. Издателство „Изток-Запад“ 2016, София.</p><p>13. Feyerabend, Paul. <em>Against Method: Outline of an Anarchistic Theory of Knowledge</em>. London: New Left Books, 1975</p><p>14. The Holy Bible: King James Version. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1769</p><p>15. Scholem, Gershom (ed.). The Zohar: Pritzker Edition, Vol. 1. Stanford University Press, 2003</p><p>16. The Rig Veda, translated by Wendy Doniger. Penguin Classics, 1981</p><p>17. Bhagavata Purana (Srimad Bhagavatam), translated by Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada. Bhaktivedanta Book Trust, 1972</p><p>18. Kastrup, Bernardo. <em>The Idea of the World: A Multi-Disciplinary Argument for the Mental Nature of Reality</em>. Winchester: Iff Books, 2019</p><p>19. Kastrup, Bernardo. <em>Why Materialism Is Baloney: How True Skeptics Know There Is No Death and Fathom Answers to Life</em>. Winchester: Iff Books, 2014.</p><p>20. Campbell, Thomas. <em>My Big TOE: Awakening (Book 1).</em> Huntsville, AL: Lightning Strike Books, 2003.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4fc0273566dc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Does Metaphysics Answer The Question of Being?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/does-metaphysics-answer-the-question-of-being-8d60db038329?source=rss-977506e56c1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8d60db038329</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aristotle]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[being]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heidegger]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ivan Spasov]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Oct 2025 05:44:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-21T05:44:09.361Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The foundation of what we understand today as metaphysics lies in the question of being. But is it ever answered?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rFN_PV20w04obf4IlKkgnQ.png" /></figure><h3>1. Introduction</h3><p>Metaphysics is a very important part of philosophy and remains one of its most explored topics. It is crucial to understand the nature of metaphysics to properly engage with it.</p><p>In its original meaning, metaphysics is the science of being qua being — being as such, the study of what it means for anything to be.</p><blockquote><em>Being qua being originates from Aristotle’s Metaphysics [1][2] and translates literally to “being insofar as it is being” from the original Greek text τὸ ὂν ᾗ ὂν.</em></blockquote><p>However, we will argue that while it is indeed the subject of metaphysics, being is not really explained in essence. This is also a core thesis of Martin Heidegger, who opens a deep critique in that regard:</p><blockquote>“Metaphysics never gives an answer to the question of Being. Metaphysics has even forgotten that such a question needs to be asked.”</blockquote><p>With that critique in place, surely Heidegger himself would have a proposition on tackling this question? A deeper investigation is in order.</p><p>We will explore the origin of metaphysics with Aristotle, while also exploring Heidegger’s body of work. We will go on a journey from the inception of metaphysics all the way to reopening one of the most difficult questions of philosophy — the question of being. As we move along these deep waters, we’ll assess the possible answers to the question or even if attaining an answer is possible. Our first stop on this journey is at its beginning with Aristotle himself.</p><h3>2. Aristotle and Metaphysical Thinking</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*JXWgJm6iosqHpMVX.png" /></figure><p>Early Greek philosophers search for the archē— water, air, fire or the apeiron. However, it is Parmenides who places being itself as the center of thought by denying the possibility of non-being. Plato carries this insight forward into his doctrine of perfect Forms.</p><blockquote><em>Archē refers to the first principle or originating source that underlies all of reality. [11][12] For a deeper look into the topic, I have another essay on the matter — </em><a href="https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/anaximander-and-the-dawn-of-philosophy-and-science-960341d92e5f"><em>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/anaximander-and-the-dawn-of-philosophy-and-science-960341d92e5f</em></a></blockquote><p>Yet it is with Aristotle that being becomes its own science in the form of metaphysics. [11][12]</p><h3>Defining Metaphysics</h3><p>Developing his system, Aristotle compartmentalizes different philosophical and scientific subjects and now, being becomes a subject of its own study. Questions like “What does it mean to be?”, “What is being itself?” and “What causes and principles explain being” can be explored. Aristotle frames this as first philosophy, placing great importance on it.</p><blockquote>“And this science is not concerned with any one class of things, but with being as being — this is common to all things.” (Aristotle, Metaphysics VI.1, 1025b3–4 [1][2])</blockquote><blockquote>“There is a science which investigates being as being, and the attributes which belong to this in virtue of its own nature.” (Aristotle, Metaphysics IV.1, 1003a21)</blockquote><p>Interestingly, the term “metaphysics” is never used by Aristotle himself. It’s used by Andronicus of Rhodes<a href="#_ftn3">[3]</a> to refer to the set of writings by Aristotle, devoted to the topics we’ve discussed in previous paragraphs. The term itself is derived from its literal meaning — after physics, as that is where Andronicus placed these writings within his hierarchy of Aristotle’s work, after <em>Physics</em>.</p><blockquote><em>Andronicus of Rhodes (1st c. BCE) is a philosopher and editor, who organized Aristotle’s works, or at least the ones available at the time, centuries after his death. [10]</em></blockquote><p>It seems clear that since its onset metaphysics deals with being. But as we’ve seen with Heidegger’s critique, it takes a turn away from the question of being’s essence. We will argue that issue takes root with Aristotle himself. Let’s investigate.</p><h3>Metaphysics and The Four Causes</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*nT_58b6-fgkrt31P.jpg" /></figure><p>It is at the very beginning of <em>Metaphysics</em> [1][2] Aristotle critiques earlier philosophers for recognizing only singular or material causes. To him, the question of being must be sought through universal principles and higher causes. In this case — his Four Causes:</p><p>· Material cause — what substance underlies being?</p><p>· Formal cause — what essence defines being?</p><p>· Efficient cause — what originates being?</p><p>· Final cause — what is the ultimate purpose of being?</p><blockquote>“Most of the first philosophers thought the principles of things were in the form of matter… yet they did not say why it is one and why it is just this and not something else, or what its first principle of change is.<em>” (Aristotle, Metaphysics I.3, 983b6)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“There are several senses in which a thing may be said to ‘have being,’ but all refer to one starting-point; some to what a thing is, some to quality, some to quantity, some to relation, and others in other such ways. But all are spoken of with reference to one central point, one definite kind of thing, and not equivocally. It is for this reason that we say ‘being’ is said in many ways but always with reference to one principle.” <em>(Aristotle, Metaphysics IV.2, 1003a33)</em></blockquote><p>We notice that the Material cause asks, “What substance underlies being?” and this is where things start to crack. Substance itself implies it has a being — it must be an existing thing. We must ask further — what is the being of the substance? Dealing with the question is pivotal, as it informs the being of that which underlies being itself.</p><p>Here Aristotle would go to his concept of substance/matter as potentiality. In his own words:</p><blockquote>“Matter exists potentially, because it may attain to form; but when it exists actually, then it is in actuality, and this is its form.” <em>(Aristotle, Metaphysics IX.8, 1049a18)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“Substance is the cause of being in all other things; for while they are not substances, it is by reference to substance that all the other things are spoken of.<em>” (Aristotle, Metaphysics VII.1, 1028a10)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“It is impossible that anything should come to be out of that which is not<em>.</em>” <em>(Aristotle, Physics I.8, 191b1)</em></blockquote><p>So, in a sense we can say that matter is in a state of being when it attains form. But that’s hardly a satisfying answer if we’re to take Heideggerian critique seriously. Namely that being and non-being cannot reference each other. Referencing non-being is an oxymoron. By virtue of the reference, something with a being points to a thing, which always has a being. If it doesn’t, it is no-thing and there is nothing to reference. Thus, the question of being regarding substance/matter remains unanswered.</p><p>At this point, we should circle back to the thesis that Aristotle doesn’t really tackle the question of being as such. Let’s investigate how he thinks of being.</p><h3>Aristotle’s Views on Being</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*WQL9NdlPnaHDGfWr.png" /></figure><p>Aristotle promises that metaphysics as first principles will tackle the gargantuan question of being as such. But does he really engage with it? Let’s see:</p><blockquote>“Being is spoken of in many ways, but always with reference to one principle and one nature.” <em>(Aristotle, Metaphysics IV.2, 1003a33)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“The being of each thing is what we say it is in virtue of itself; for example, the being of a man is to be a man, the being of a horse is to be a horse.” <em>(Aristotle, Metaphysics VII.4, 1029b13)</em></blockquote><p>If we analyze Aristotle’s own thoughts carefully, we can see one thing plainly — he does not make a statement of what being in itself is at any point. In the first quote, he points to its reference to one principle and one nature. That nature is not defined beyond the thought processes outlined in our investigation on substance/matter. And here is where the circularity unfolds with the second quote. The position is rather blunt — the being of man is to be a man. But what does it mean for anything to “be”? There is no direct explanation. Heidegger expresses a deep concern:</p><blockquote>“The ancient ontology, whose greatest figure is Aristotle, has exhibited the horizon of being primarily in the ‘definition’ of beings as such. But it has failed to discuss the meaning of that Being in which beings have their mode of being.” <em>(Heidegger, Being and Time, p. 23 [5][6])</em></blockquote><blockquote>“Aristotle’s ontology already shows the decisive turning away from the original Greek experience of Being. He interprets Being primarily as actuality (energeia), and with that the fate of Western metaphysics is set: Being is determined as presence.” <em>(Heidegger Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics, p. 149 [8][9])</em></blockquote><p>Now, with that in mind, let’s expand on Heidegger’s critique.</p><h3>1. Heidegger — Metaphysics and Being</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/0*dCbSq0ywd1Hd-G6-.jpeg" /></figure><p>Martin Heidegger (1889–1976) is one of the greatest philosophers of our time. As we’ve already seen throughout the essay, a pillar of his work is metaphysics and the question of being. He starts off his master work <em>Being and Time</em> [5][6] by critiquing metaphysics and restating the question of “What does it mean to be?”</p><p>He would dedicate other works on the topic as well. His lectures on <em>Introduction to</em> <em>Metaphysics</em> [7] mark their own path forward in pushing the question further. Another work of his, which we’ll examine is <em>Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics</em> [8][9].</p><p>At the core of Heidegger’s critique sits the huge importance placed on being. He is quite explicit that it is the most important question in philosophy:</p><blockquote>“Why are there beings at all, and why not rather nothing? … Clearly it is no ordinary question … This is obviously the first of all questions.” <em>(Heidegger, Introduction to Metaphysics, p. 1)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“The question of Being is the most fundamental and the most concrete of questions. Its fundamental nature lies in the fact that it concerns every being as being.” <em>(Heidegger, Introduction to Metaphysics, p. 7)</em></blockquote><p>For Heidegger, being as such is what enables anything else in existence. Without being, there is no inquiry, no seeking, no science, no philosophy and most of all — no reality. That is why he is so adamant that we must get to the core of what being is.</p><blockquote>“The question of Being aims at ascertaining the a priori conditions not only for the possibility of the sciences which examine beings as beings of such and such a type, but also for the possibility of those ontologies themselves which are prior to the ontical sciences and which provide their foundations.” <em>(Heidegger, Being and Time, p. 33)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“Every questioning is a seeking. Every seeking takes its direction beforehand from what is sought. In this way, every questioning is a seeking of Being.” <em>(Heidegger, Introduction to Metaphysics, p. 25)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“In raising the question of Being we stand in the most radical confrontation with the whole of philosophy.” <em>(Heidegger, Introduction to Metaphysics, p. 14)</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uj0MkJKzY7P9s55o" /></figure><p>Now we can more extensively uncover Heidegger’s critique. At the core of it is the promise that this truly important question is to be the focus of metaphysics. And as we’ve already seen, Aristotle has made that promise explicit. But Heidegger argues that not only has that promise not been delivered on, but it is in fact completely forgotten:</p><blockquote>“From the very beginning, metaphysics has spoken of beings and their being. But it has not asked about the meaning of Being itself, nor about the truth of Being.” <em>(Heidegger, Introduction to Metaphysics, p. 152)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“Metaphysics never asks about the truth of Being itself. Metaphysics does not ask this question, because it cannot.” <em>(Heidegger, Introduction to Metaphysics, p. 38)</em></blockquote><p>We have analyzed how Aristotle circles around the question of being and doesn’t really address it.</p><p>But Heidegger’s critique is not exhausted with him. There are many philosophers he discusses in that regard, with more memorable statements and analysis on Descartes, Kant and Hegel, to name a few.</p><blockquote>“The ontology of Descartes begins with the interpretation of the Being of beings as constant presence-at-hand. Being means, for him, being objectively present.” <em>(Heidegger, Being and Time, p. 128)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“For Kant, Being signifies the position of an object within experience. Thus Being becomes reduced to the mode of objectivity; it is no longer questioned in itself.” <em>(Heidegger, Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics, p. 157)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“In Hegel’s Logic, Being is grasped as the pure indeterminate immediate. But in this way it becomes emptied out and deprived of its essential content.” <em>(Heidegger, Being and Time, p. 45)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“Since Descartes, philosophy has thought of Being primarily as the objectivity of the object, as what is available to representation.” <em>(Heidegger, Introduction to Metaphysics, p.152)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“The essence of modern metaphysics is its subjectivism. Here Being is interpreted through the subjectivity of the subject. The consequence is that Being is no longer experienced as such, but only as object for a subject.” <em>(Heidegger, Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics, p. 206)</em></blockquote><p>To summarize, Heidegger raises an objection that being is reduced to an object and its own essence is never really investigated properly. But this is where irony sets in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/975/1*Sz5qtrs-He1Nm2KoU2m4bQ.png" /></figure><p>Although Heidegger strongly critiques other philosophers and the entire field of metaphysics for not living up to their promise of answering the question of being, he himself doesn’t answer it either. He states that being cannot be defined and the only way to understand it is to study our own, as we are not only a being but in possession of being itself.</p><blockquote>“Being cannot indeed be defined. But we can at least say that the term ‘Being’ does not stand for some thing that ‘is’.” <em>(Heidegger, Being and Time, p. 23)</em></blockquote><blockquote>“We cannot define Being by appealing to something still higher. Being is the ground of all grounds, and so the abyss that can never be grounded.” <em>(Heidegger, Introduction to Metaphysics, )</em></blockquote><blockquote>“In the analysis of Dasein, the horizon for the most primordial kind of Being — that of Being itself — will be laid bare.” <em>(Heidegger, Being and Time, p. 37)</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Dasein [5][6] is a Heideggerian term, meaning the human being as the entity that relates to its own existence. The being for whom being itself is the issue.</em></blockquote><blockquote>“Being cannot be represented directly. It reveals itself only in the transcendence of Dasein, and in this way must be interrogated indirectly.” <em>(Heidegger, Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics, p. 203)</em></blockquote><p>Now as we look at this, where do we stand on the question of being? We do not have a definitive answer, yet we have moved a step forward. Aristotle has given us the field of exploration of being in metaphysics, while Heidegger has pointed out that we must not lose focus in the essence of being.</p><h3>4. Conclusion</h3><p>In this essay, we’ve discussed the unfolding of metaphysics as it relates to being. We’ve reached as far back to the very beginning with Aristotle and have gone all the way to the 20th century with Heidegger. All with one idea in mind — to see if we would see the question of being unfold into a singular answer. However, it appears we may have come up short in that regard, as we follow some of the world’s greatest thinkers. From Aristotle to Heidegger, they both put being in the spotlight and try to develop the proper grounding needed for it. And from our inquiry, we can say metaphysics indeed deals with being, but neither Aristotle nor Heidegger are able to define being itself. So, we must ask — is it a question that can really be answered? Sadly, we cannot say, but we must try regardless. It is in our inquisitive nature. It is what defines us as human — the will to attain knowledge, even in the face of an unanswerable question. And in a sense, this specific question is quite special, as we are beings and being is what we are.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>1. Aristotle, <em>The Works of Aristotle, Vol. VIII, Metaphysics</em>, Translated by W. D. Ross, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1924</p><p>2. Аристотел, <em>Метафизика,</em> Превод от Николай Гочев, София: Университетско Издателство „Св. Климент Охридски“, 2023</p><p>3. Aristotle, <em>The Works of Aristotle, Vol. II, Physics</em>, Translated by R. P. Hardie &amp; R. K. Gaye, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1930</p><p>4. Аристотел, <em>Съчинения в Шест Тома, Том II, Част I, Физика</em>, Превод от проф. Цочо Бояджиев, София: Издателство „Захарий Стоянов“, 2012</p><p>5. Martin Heidegger, <em>Being and Time,</em> Translated by John Macquarrie &amp; Edward Robinson, Oxford: Blackwell, 1962</p><p>6. Мартин Хайдегер, <em>Битие и Време</em>, Превод от проф. Цочо Бояджиев, Издателство „Изток-Запад“, 2020</p><p>7. Martin Heidegger, <em>Introduction to Metaphysics</em>, Translated by Gregory Fried &amp; Richard Polt, New Haven: Yale University Press, 2000</p><p>8. Martin Heidegger, <em>Kant and the Problem of Metaphysics</em>, Translated by Richard Taft, Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1997</p><p>9. Мартин Хайдегер, <em>Кант и Проблемът за Метафизиката</em>, Превод от Любомир Милчев; София: Издателство „ОТВОРЕНО ОБЩЕСТВО“, Издателство „Анубис“, 1997</p><p>10. Дарин Тенев, <em>Три Лекции върху Хайдегер: Модалност и Индексичност в Битие и Време</em>, София: Издателство „Изток-Запад“, 2023</p><p>11. Bertrand Russell, <em>History of Western Philosophy</em>, Routledge, 1945</p><p>12. Бертранд Ръсел, <em>История на Западната Философия, Том 1</em>, Издателска къща „Христо Ботев“, 1994</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8d60db038329" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Our Own Existence — The Only Absolute Certainty]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/our-own-existence-the-only-absolute-certainty-1225908e0d8e?source=rss-977506e56c1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1225908e0d8e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philospophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[consciousness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[knowledge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[awareness]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ivan Spasov]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Sep 2025 07:35:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-15T07:38:05.478Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Our Own Existence — The Only Absolute Certainty</h3><p>What is it that we really know and can we be certain of it? Is there anything certain at all, even our own existence?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lii4Fx5fmygnXdoFTIuMMQ.png" /></figure><h3>Introduction</h3><p>The question of knowledge and its truthfulness has been at the forefront of human thought since time immemorial. This essay will make the claim that there is only one thing that we can be certain of and that is our existence. Gaining any sort of knowledge and certainty is only possible through awareness, which facilitates the truth of our existence.</p><p>With that in mind, we’ll need to define a couple of terms that will be used throughout the essay:</p><p>· <strong>First-Person Awareness</strong> — It is the immediate, irreducible fact that there is awareness from a first-person perspective. Simply being aware of anything. It can even be without thought, inference, deduction, a self or any cognitive faculty — simply to perceive anything that could arise in experience.</p><blockquote>Similar to the terms used in philosophy of mind — “core subjectivity”, “pure awareness”, “reflexive awareness” and “I AM”-ness.</blockquote><p>· <strong>Absolute Certainty</strong> — This term will refer to a condition of knowledge in which a proposition or a fact cannot be doubted, revised, invalidated or put to any reasonable scrutiny within any framework — epistemic or even metaphysical.</p><p>· <strong>Operational Certainty</strong> — This term will refer to a condition of knowledge in which a proposition or a fact carries a high probability of truth, has utility when invoked and is generally accepted as truthful by consensus. However, it can be an object of doubt, be revised or invalidated at any point in time, given sufficient evidence.</p><p>As we previously outlined, the focus of this essay will be to prove that the only Absolute Certainty we have is of our own existence by virtue of First-Person Awareness, giving us the very ability to know anything. Another point will be to investigate major forms of knowledge — empirical, rational and spiritual, and why they can be known only with Operational Certainty and not an absolute such. But firstly, we must expand on First-Person Awareness.</p><h3>First-Person Awareness — The Only Certainty</h3><p>If there is one thing we can say with certainty it is that our ability to be aware of anything exists. Our window into the world, First-Person Awareness. Without it — there is no knowledge, no ability to examine, no rational thought, no empiricism.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*GYBrhbT8pe3chaJ1uA3uwQ.png" /></figure><p>An outstanding scientific study, done by Zoran Josipovic and Vladimir Miskovic in 2020 [1], shines a light on awareness and what can be considered its contents. In the paper, they outline NDA and MPE respectively.</p><blockquote>NDA or Nondual Awareness — a non-conceptual, non-propositional, non-representational, and arousal independent type of self-knowing awareness. Often associated with a felt sensation of presence, being, bliss, luminosity.</blockquote><blockquote>MPE or Minimal Phenomenal Experience — experiences that carry very little or no phenomenal content, an experience of nothingness but still an experience. Found in deep sleep, anesthesia, as well as in some very specific meditation practices.</blockquote><p>In their work, they make the claim that awareness is the definitive ground of reality of the observer. The immortal words of one of history’s greatest thinkers Rene Descartes echo strongly — “<em>Cogito ergo sum</em>”. [2][3] However, when talking about First-Person Awareness we are not referring to thought. The core thesis isn’t that the ability to think is what defines us as existing in certainty. While brilliant, the step Descartes makes is conflating a very important distinction — the one between the contents of awareness and awareness itself. As seen in Josipovic and Miskovic’s work [1], and as already established in eastern philosophy, thoughts are a part of the contents of awareness but not awareness itself. Thoughts are what awareness is aware of. But we must make another statement. First-Person Awareness is not to be conflated with the concept of the Cartesian Theater.</p><blockquote>Daniel Dennett proposes a very poignant and sharp critique to Descartes’ “Cogito ergo sum” in that its implication is that of a homunculus, a self that watches experience unfold on mental stage.</blockquote><p>First-Person Awareness, similarly to NDA and MPE, points not to an observer-self but to the very ability to have any experience at all. If we have to look at the bigger picture, there is no view of reality without First-Person Awareness and is thus the only thing that holds Absolute Certainty. With that in mind, we must examine why any other object of knowledge can hold only Operational certainty. Since we’ve started with a scientific study, let’s investigate the limitations of empirical knowledge.</p><h3>Limitations of Empirical Knowledge</h3><p>Empirical knowledge is one of the most direct ways we get to grips with reality. We gain it from observation, sense perception and experience. In this chapter we will explore why it cannot bring us Absolute Certainty but rather just operational such.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iaKV_55Nvv9NpX18-B2k1Q.png" /></figure><p>The act of observing is an experiential one and is derived from sense perception. Science tells us that our senses are not tuned in to recognize reality in its purest form.</p><blockquote>In his book The Case Against Reality, Donald Hoffman makes a very substantiated claim that our senses were shaped for survivability and not for perceiving the world as it is. His biggest point is that, as observed in other species as well, evolution by natural selection favors certain types of simplifications and even sometimes illusions that would increase the chances of survival.[12]</blockquote><p>As far back as humanity goes, phenomena have been observed that were later unequivocally proven to be false. The classical examples being hallucinations, mirages and deliriums. But there are bigger ones — a good example would be the illusion of the Earth being flat when observed from an open field.</p><p>Experiences are subjective and while science has given us the ability to remove a certain amount of subjectivity from the act of gathering data, the meaning of the data is another matter altogether.</p><p>We should investigate two of history’s greatest thinkers — David Hume and Thomas Kuhn.</p><p>David Hume is one of the greatest empiricists in the history of philosophy. However, he was not blind to the problems of empirical knowledge. In his landmark work “An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding” [4][5] he unfolds the problem with induction.</p><blockquote>The Problem of Induction, although not explicitly named as such, is outlined in Section IV and V. [4][5]</blockquote><p>He would frame the core issue as such, that our presumptions that the future will resemble the past and patterns once observed will repeat themselves, are not logically guaranteed and inductive reasoning is itself circular in that regard. [4][5] Surely, the sun will rise tomorrow but there is nothing that guarantees it — merely our observation that it’s constantly happening in a cycle. A contemporary sidebar here is the flow of time and its simultaneity.</p><blockquote>Prof. Tim Maudlin outlines the process of how Einstein’s Special and General relativity decisively overturn Newtonian physics.[13]</blockquote><p>With such a sidebar it is only natural that we proceed to Thomas Kuhn. In his groundbreaking work, “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions” [6][7], he makes a very strong point of how paradigm shifts in science occur. Kuhn’s description of what a paradigm is, namely a shared framework of assumptions, theories, and methods of data interpretation, is at the core of what we’ll investigate. Even though raw data is present, the very nature of the paradigm itself comes with assumptions that may be faulty. Paradigm shifts occur when enough anomalies are accumulated, and the assumptions no longer have a sufficient bearing. But there is a more interesting point Kuhn makes — such shifts do not necessarily occur when a model is considered “closer to truth” but rather, when the new model being proposed is more coherent or useful. Further, he states that this cycle makes raw empirical observations context dependent, thus what is considered a fact under the current paradigm often falls and is dismissed under the next.</p><p>With everything outlined in this chapter, we can safely state that we cannot get Absolute Certainty through empirical knowledge. We’ve also noticed a pattern. Even in our most rigorous empirical findings, we cannot abstract and isolate the observations and the data, and we must rationalize it. So, with that in mind, it is time to investigate how far rational knowledge can get us.</p><h3>Limitations of Rational Knowledge</h3><p>Rational knowledge has been the bedrock of Western Philosophy since its inception. It is derived through logical reasoning and deduction, while being independent of sensory experience. But as with empirical knowledge, it is impossible without First-Person Awareness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YOf7UIgzee0R_ytrAX4iBA.png" /></figure><p>One of rational knowledge’s biggest problems is the fact that it often contradicts empirical evidence. A very stark example can be found in Parmenides’ thinking. Pushing rationality and logic to its absolute breaking point, he concluded that nothing truly changes and that all change is illusory. Time, action, agency and everything that we observe to be in flux is a mere illusion.</p><p>That conclusion is in drastic conflict with what is empirically observable. The very act of thinking about this unchanging reality is a change in states of mind, which conflicts with Parmenides’ stance that it is only through the mind that we can glimpse into the actual unchanging reality.</p><p>We will not stake the Absolute Certainty on Parmenides alone though. Let’s investigate the arguable peak of rational knowledge in the face of mathematics.</p><p>Given the category of synthetic a priori knowledge by Immanuel Kant, mathematics and mathematical models have been the benchmark for bootstrapping any scientific theory.</p><blockquote>Kant introduces synthetic a priori as a type of knowledge that is both known without experience (a priori) and still adds new information, meaning the predicate is not analytically contained in the subject. [8][9]</blockquote><p>Building on abstractions and watching their predictions unfold into reality certainly gives us the sense that this way of attaining knowledge can have Absolute Certainty. But if we make that assumption, we’d be mistaken. It would be best if we investigate one of the brightest minds in that field — Kurt Gödel.</p><p>Through his Incompleteness Theorems, Gödel puts on display some of the biggest issues regarding formal systems and Absolute Certainty. He frames his findings in terms of rational systems and proposes that true statements cannot be proven from within the system. Furthermore, he states that a rational system cannot be both complete and consistent, it would also always have truths outside of its reach. Thus, going from rational knowledge, into mathematics, and going back to logically rigorous frameworks, Gödel clearly states that they’re epistemically incomplete.</p><p>With this chapter about to conclude, we can’t help but notice one thing — until now we’ve framed every type of knowledge as something that is observed by virtue of First-Person Awareness. With that in mind, we’ll tackle another type of knowledge which seems almost intertwined with that phenomenology, namely spiritual knowledge.</p><h3>Limitations of Spiritual Knowledge</h3><p>Out of all the types of knowledge we’ve discussed up until now, spiritual knowledge has the strongest phenomenological footprint yet is the hardest to report and assess. People have changed their lives completely because of spiritual experiences. Yet as profound as they are, they are also deeply personal. They cannot be expressed to another person, at least not to full capacity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZsEZ5acy89TQRx6viQivOQ.png" /></figure><p>When talking about spiritual knowledge, we will not refer to a specific religion or scripture. The reason — religions in their canonical and literal interpretation contradict each other, as well as empirical observation and a lot of times even rational thinking. So, with that in mind, we’ll consider spiritual knowledge to be a deep personal belief that arises by virtue of profound experience.</p><p>The first major problem that we run into is already outlined — spiritual knowledge is deeply personal and thus, deeply subjective. No third party has any way to verify the subjectivity of the experiencer. As William James outlines in The Varieties of Religious Experience, they are transient, ineffable, noetic and passive — they happen to the subject and as an object are indescribable if absolute truths is what we want to extrapolate out of them. [10]</p><p>The attainment of spiritual knowledge is vivid in the moment it happens, but after it has passed, it becomes the subject of reportability, even to one’s own self. A memory, a reconstruction, which we know to be faulty. And this is the point to make — spiritual knowledge arises within First-Person Awareness and can be the contents of it. And while the transcendental experience itself could be questioned, having the experience cannot.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>And so it is that we’ve come full circle. The only thing we can know with Absolute Certainty is that we exist, insofar as we treat that existence as a First-Person Awareness which can observe anything.</p><p>As we’ve seen, any knowledge outside of our own existence can be faulty in terms of absolute truth. In empiricism, our senses can lie to us, while our interpretation of raw data can lead us astray. With rational knowledge we run into contradictions and paradoxes when we step out of the mind and into perceived reality. While with spiritual knowledge, stepping anywhere outside of our most intimate self is impossible. And as immersed as we are in that spiritual experience, it may clash with what is observable or rational.</p><p>The only thing we can be certain of is that awareness contains all of it. And while there is awareness, there is existence. And if there is existence, there is a need and possibility for knowledge.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>1. Zoran Josipovic and Vladimir Miskovic; “Nondual Awareness and Minimal Phenomenal Experience”; Frontiers in Psychology 11 (2020): 2087; <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.02087/full">https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.02087/full</a></p><p>2. Rene Descartes; “Meditations on First Philosophy”; Translated by John Cottingham; Cambridge University Press, 1996</p><p>3. Рене Декарт; „Размишления Върху Първата Философия“; Превод от Лиляна Мичева; Издателство „Наука и Изкуство“, 1980</p><p>4. David Hume; “An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding”; Oxford University Press, 2000</p><p>5. Дейвид Хюм; „Изследване на Човешкия Разсъдък“; Издателство „Изток-Запад“, 2016</p><p>6. Thomas S. Kuhn; “The Structure of Scientific Revolution”; University of Chicago Press, 1970</p><p>7. Томас С. Кун, „Структурата на Научните Революции“; Издателство „Изток-Запад“, 2016</p><p>8. Immanuel Kant; “Critique of Pure Reason”; Translated by Paul Guyer and Allen W. Wood; Cambridge University Press,1998</p><p>9. Имануел Кант; „Критика на Чистия Разум“; Превод от проф. Цеко Торбов; Акад. Издателство „Проф. Марин Дринов“, 2013</p><p>10. William James; “Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human Nature”; New York: Longmans, Green, and Co., 1902; (physical book not present, read through Archive.org at link <a href="https://archive.org/details/varietiesofrelig00jameuoft/page/380/mode/2up">https://archive.org/details/varietiesofrelig00jameuoft/page/380/mode/2up</a> )</p><p>11. Michael Levin; “Platonic Space: Where Cognitive and Morphological Pattens Come From”; ThoughtFrom.Life, 2025; <a href="https://thoughtforms.life/platonic-space-where-cognitive-and-morphological-patterns-come-from-besides-genetics-and-environment/">https://thoughtforms.life/platonic-space-where-cognitive-and-morphological-patterns-come-from-besides-genetics-and-environment/</a></p><p>12. Donald Hoffman; “A Case Against Reality: Why Evolution Hid the Truth from Our Eyes”; New York: W. W. Norton &amp; Company 2019</p><p>13. Tim Maudlin; “Philosophy of Physics”; Princeton University Press, 2012</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1225908e0d8e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Brief Overview of Aristotle’s Organon]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/a-brief-overview-of-aristotles-organon-17ff43c09a2f?source=rss-977506e56c1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17ff43c09a2f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[logic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[overview]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[aristotle]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ancient-greece]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ivan Spasov]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Aug 2025 12:26:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-29T12:28:23.542Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In this brief essay, we’ll do an overview of the central themes and importance of The Organon — the masterwork of Aristotle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/0*VCgAl7MojLjbEW9P.jpg" /></figure><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Aristotle (384 BCE — 322 BCE) is one of the most important and influential thinkers the world has ever known. A true polymath, his work is instrumental in laying down the foundations of western philosophy and science. A very prolific writer, Aristotle has written on topics that go across the board of human knowledge — from formalizing logic to physics, metaphysics and beyond. In this essay, we’ll focus on his most foundational work — The Organon. It contains six treatises, all of which form the grounds of his way of thinking. The essay itself will be an overview of this monumental feat of philosophical thought. A bite-sized summary of the topics Aristotle would tackle.</p><p>This essay follows the classical sequence of the treatises:</p><p>1. <strong>Categories </strong>(<em>Categoriae</em>)</p><p>2. <strong>On Interpretation</strong> (<em>De Interpretatione</em>)</p><p>3. <strong>Prior Analytics</strong> (<em>Analytica Priora</em>)</p><p>4. <strong>Posterior Analytics</strong> (<em>Analytica Posteriora</em>)</p><p>5. <strong>Topics</strong> (<em>Topica</em>)</p><p>6. S<strong>ophistical Refutations</strong> (<em>De Sophisticsis Elenchis</em>)</p><p>The classical sequence of treaties within The Organon is organized by Andronicus of Rhodes (1st Century BCE) and later used as the Aristotelian canon by future great thinkers like Averroes and Thomas Aquinas. The modern sequence, as used in The Complete Works of Aristotle [3] published by Princeton University Press, would be 1) Topics; 2) Sophistical Refutations; 3) Categories; 4) On Interpretation; 5) Prior Analytics; 6) Posterior Analytics. The reason for the reorganization is mostly for clarity, however for our purposes we’ll stick to the classical order.</p><p>Another thing to note — why am I even writing this essay? Why does it need to exist? Isn’t this an overview of a widely recognized work of philosophy?</p><p>And my answer would be — yes, it is, however I find it very helpful to read online summaries of such works and then compare them with each other. To also look at the bibliography, maybe see literature that I’m not necessarily familiar with. Additionally, I recently wrote a very similar essay for my undergrad in Philosophy and I would have really appreciated a digest of The Organon that can lead my thought process.</p><p>With that in mind, we can start our investigation into one of philosophy’s greatest works.</p><h3>The Organon — A Summary</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*LmjY0Tl0_tXgrk4W.jpg" /></figure><p>A monumental feat of philosophical and scientific thought, The Organon is a big collection of six treatises. Each builds upon the others and expands into an entire, self-sufficient system. While philosophers prior to Aristotle were known to utilize similar methodologies, more notably Pythagoras, Socrates and Plato among others, The Organon is the first of its kind in being a formalized, systematically developed framework. Interestingly, it is commentaries by Averroes and Thomas Aquinas that have elevated these treatises even further, while keeping true to the original.</p><blockquote>Averroes (Ibn Rushd, 1126–1198) — one of the greatest Muslim thinkers, has rooted a lot of his work in Aristotelian canon. Opposed to Neoplatonism, he would see Aristotle as a beacon of rationality. Averroes has extensive commentaries on The Organon, layered in three levels — short, middle and long; made for beginner, intermediate and advanced scholars respectively. Averroes would also support including Rhetoric and Poetics in The Organon — a common view in Arabic tradition at the time. [8]</blockquote><blockquote>Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) — Easily one of the most influential Christian scholars, he references Aristotle regularly in his theological works, going as far as to develop an integration of Aristotle’s syllogism into Christian theology as a way to investigate and validate rational deduction and metaphysics. He has extensive commentaries on On Interpretation, Posterior Analytics as well as Topics. [9]</blockquote><p>It is truly remarkable how Aristotle’s work has influenced our culture throughout the ages. But there is a good reason why. Let’s look at each treatise within The Organon and gain a better understanding of them.</p><h3>Categories</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8F_6IJiEGalte4FL.jpg" /></figure><p>This is the first treatise of the six and tackles the subject of how we speak about things and what kinds of things there are. It traces the roots of “things” in general, developing their ontological history, while also forming grammatical rules on how we can refer to “things”. It also makes a sharp distinction between substance and accidents, meaning it defines substance as that which exists in itself, while accidents as properties that exist in something else. [1][3] Substance is the underlying entity that has an independent existence. Accident is a property of a substance that does not define what the substance is, while also not having a standalone existence without the substance.</p><p>Additionally, Aristotle defines ten categories. Let’s look at them through Aristotle’s own words:</p><p>1. <strong>Substance</strong></p><blockquote>“Substance, in the truest and primary and most definite sense of the term, is that which is neither predicable of a subject nor present in a subject — for example, a particular man or a particular horse.” 2a11</blockquote><p>2. <strong>Quantity</strong></p><blockquote>“Examples of quantity are: two cubits long, three cubits long, a length of five feet.” Categories, 4b20</blockquote><p>3. <strong>Quality</strong></p><blockquote>“Examples of quality are: white, grammatical. Quality is a term used with reference to character or disposition.” 8b25</blockquote><p>4. <strong>Relation</strong></p><blockquote>“Examples of things said relatively are: double, greater, master, knowledge.” 6a36</blockquote><p>5. <strong>Place</strong></p><blockquote>“Examples of the category of where: in the Lyceum, in the marketplace.” 5a25</blockquote><p>6. <strong>Time</strong></p><blockquote>“Examples of the category of when: yesterday, last year.” 5a25</blockquote><p>7. <strong>Position</strong></p><blockquote>“Examples of the category of being in a position: is lying, is sitting.” 5a25</blockquote><p>8. <strong>State</strong></p><blockquote>“Examples of the category of having: has shoes on, has armor on.” 5a25</blockquote><p>9. <strong>Action</strong></p><blockquote>“Examples of the category of acting: cutting, burning.” 5a25</blockquote><p>10. <strong>Being acted on</strong> — “Examples of the category of being-acted-upon: being cut, being burned.” 5a25</p><p>These categories would be the qualifiers of what would be the subject of his logic. But the next leap in that direction would come in the next treatise we’ll investigate — On Interpretation.</p><h3>On Interpretation</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EjoCauQQxu0mvXhE.jpg" /></figure><p>On Interpretation is the second treatise we’ll dive into. It describes propositions, affirmation and negation, as well as the conditions for truth and falsity in language. Logical syntax and semantics are introduced and the relationships between affirmatives, negatives, universals and particulars are tackled. [1][3] To get a better understanding of the treatise, we should look at Aristotle’s own words:</p><blockquote>“First we must define the noun and the verb, then the negation, the sentence, and the affirmation” 16a3</blockquote><blockquote>“A sentence is a significant portion of speech, some of which possess truth or falsity.” 16b26</blockquote><blockquote>“Every sentence must be either true or false, but not every sentence expresses a judgment.” 17a25</blockquote><blockquote>“The affirmation is the assertion of something of something, the negation the denial of something of something.” 18a28</blockquote><blockquote>“It is impossible that the same attribute should at the same time belong and not belong to the same subject in the same respect.” 19a23</blockquote><p>Interestingly, these formalizations while intuitive still would need to be put into a system in order to ensure logical consistency and that becomes quite apparent in the next treaties.</p><h3>Prior Analytics</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/1*unmxDTxpaavxddDUnkZJzw.png" /></figure><p>Prior Analytics is the foundational treatise of formal logic as it develops Aristotle’s concept of syllogism — deductive arguments made of two premises and a conclusion. This is the first known attempt at making a system for deductive reasoning. [1][3]</p><p>Let’s dive into it and break it down by looking at actual quotes:</p><blockquote>“A syllogism is a discourse in which, certain things being stated, something other than what is stated follows of necessity from their being so.” 24b18</blockquote><p>This is the definition Aristotle gives to syllogism — a necessary inference from stated premises.</p><blockquote>“Terms are those into which the proposition is divided, that is, the subject and the predicate of a statement.” 25b32</blockquote><p>Aristotle explicitly identifies subject and predicate, and formalizes his definition of terms, which would become foundational to his logical operations.</p><blockquote>“In every syllogism there are three terms. One of them is the middle term, which must be in both premises and not in the conclusion.” 26a10;</blockquote><blockquote>“The middle term must be the same in both premises, for otherwise there will be no syllogism.“ 27a10</blockquote><p>These last sentences give an emphasis on the middle term as the anchor of consistency in syllogism. As we’ve seen, Aristotle defines syllogism as the process of finding a necessary inference from a set of stated premises, where propositions are divided into terms — the subject and the predicate, with the middle term being the same for both premises.</p><p>Today, we use a formalization of these constructs, which is largely lifted by medieval Latin scholastic logic, heavily reliant on Aristotle. The symbols used in that formalization are S, P and M respectively:</p><p>· <strong>S</strong> = minor term (subject of the conclusion)</p><p>· <strong>P</strong> = major term (predicate of the conclusion)</p><p>· <strong>M </strong>= middle term (appears in both premises, not in the conclusion)</p><p>Interestingly, they have gained popularity in one shape or another through Peter of Spain [5], William of Sherwood, Thomas Aquinas and others.</p><p>Let’s observe an example — “All men are mortal. All Greeks are men. Thus — all Greeks are mortal.” If we were to map out the example, it would look something like this: M-P, S-M -&gt; S-P. [7]</p><p>With this mapping in mind, we can proceed to the next big topic– the four categorical proposition types A, E, I and O:</p><p>· <strong>A</strong> — Universal Affirmative, where “All S are P”. An example would be — “All men are mortal”.</p><p>· <strong>E</strong> — Universal Negative, where “No S are P”. An example would be — “No reptiles are warm-blooded”.</p><p>· <strong>I</strong> — Particular Affirmative, where “Some S are P”. An example would be “Some birds are flightless.”</p><p>· <strong>O</strong> — Particular Negative, where “Some S are not P”. An example would be “Some animals are not mammals.”</p><p>Coming from Categories, moving through On Interpretation and going into Prior Analytics, we can see Aristotle building the very formidable structure of his canon. Next up — Posterior Analytics.</p><h3>Posterior Analytics</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/638/1*sWabjXKdv0Xxk_2u5F-qTw.png" /></figure><p>In this treatise, Aristotle outlines the requirements for true knowledge — grounded in first principles, necessary, demonstrable. He also lays the groundwork for what we could consider scientific knowledge, expanding into induction, definition and structuring explanatory reasoning. Let’s investigate Aristotle’s thought process through his own words [2][3]:</p><blockquote>“All instruction given or received by way of argument proceeds from pre-existent knowledge.” 71a1</blockquote><p>In previous treatises we’ve seen the formation of Aristotelian logic but now, the subject that needs to be tackled is the pre-existent knowledge upon which we base our stance on truth.</p><blockquote>“We think we understand a thing when we know its primary causes.” 71b9</blockquote><blockquote>“Science is a demonstrative state… a state apt to demonstrate.” 78b22</blockquote><p>This is the first critical shift in going from a purely logical structure, where merely valid reasoning was sufficient, to concerns about explanation and demonstrability. In that sense, Aristotle would make the claim that to truly know something, one must extrapolate it from premises that are true; accounted for prior to the conclusion; causally explanatory; better understood in nature.</p><blockquote>“The knowledge of the fact differs from the knowledge of the reasoned fact.” 76a37.</blockquote><blockquote>“A definition is a formula which signifies the essence of a thing.” 73a21</blockquote><p>An important thing to mark here is that Aristotle distinguishes between knowing a fact and knowing a reasoned fact. Knowing a fact is empirical, while knowing a reasoned fact is explanatory and requires a causal structure. To assess beyond the empirical, Aristotle places a high value on the essence of a thing. It’s formal identity and not just characteristics or relations. In that regard, scientific knowledge hinges on grasping essence as much as it does on grasping behavior.</p><blockquote>“It is by induction that we acquire universals.” 100b5</blockquote><p>To take this train of thought further, we can see Aristotle developing his account of induction and intuitive reasoning. Realizing that not all knowledge can be demonstrated, Aristotle would state that it can be extrapolated directly by first principles, by abstraction of repeated experiences. This leads nicely into the next big point within The Organon.</p><h3>Topics</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*qedNYaAXpkoxkPDEgYa5RA.png" /></figure><p>In Topics, Aristotle outlines principles of reasoning based on accepted opinions and consensus facts. This develops his form of dialectical reasoning, which is foundational for a proper philosophical argument. He outlines argument forms, fallacies as well as rhetorical strategies, which build up the ability of a philosopher to express a better argumentation. [2][3] To get a better understanding of what this treatise is all about, we should investigate Aristotle’s own words:</p><blockquote>“The object of our inquiry is to find a method whereby we shall be able to reason from opinions that are generally accepted.” 100a18</blockquote><blockquote>“The dialectical argument is reasoning from opinions that are generally accepted.” 101a36</blockquote><blockquote>“We must distinguish between the classes of things we are investigating.” 104a1</blockquote><blockquote>“The most productive principles of reasoning are definitions and divisions.” 107a5</blockquote><blockquote>“It is useful to have examined the number of senses a term may have.” 112a15</blockquote><p>Topics also introduces some of the fallacies, further developed in Sophistical Refutations. Within the current treatise Aristotle develops a broader view of Equivocation, Begging the Question, False Cause and implies many others. We see the groundwork for Aristotelian dialectical unfolding and philosophical dialogue, much of which will be expanded upon in the next section.</p><h3>Sophistical Refutations</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/636/1*h6oAdx1qtYRgIjT06mE17Q.png" /></figure><p>In Sophistical Refutations, Aristotle develops a systematized way to analyze, detect and refute sophistical reasoning. [2][3] Let’s look at his thought process with some quotes:</p><blockquote>“There are fallacies not dependent on language, and those that are.” 165b25</blockquote><blockquote>“Some fallacies depend on the form of expression, others on the matter.” 168b35</blockquote><blockquote>“It is more difficult to detect a fallacy than to solve a syllogism.” 177b10</blockquote><p>From his words above, we can already see that Aristotle distinguishes roughly two categories of fallacies — ones in language and ones that pertain to reasoning. It is important that we look at both categories.</p><p>Fallacies in language arise due to ambiguities or misuse of language:</p><p>· <strong>Equivocation </strong>— Using a word in more than one sense.</p><p>· <strong>Amphiboly </strong>— Ambiguity due to sentence structure or syntax.</p><p>· <strong>Combination </strong>— False inference due to grouping words together improperly.</p><p>· <strong>Division </strong>— Opposite of combination — inferring improperly by separating what should be grouped.</p><p>· <strong>Accent </strong>— A fallacy arising from a misplaced stress or intonation in speech. Mostly a spoken language issue.</p><p>· <strong>Form of Expression </strong>— Mistaking metaphor or idiom for literal meaning.</p><p>Non-linguistic fallacies on the other hand deal with logical or substantive errors in reasoning:</p><p>· <strong>Accident </strong>— Confusing what is accidentally true with what is necessarily true.</p><p>· <strong>Contextual relativity and absolute claims</strong> — Confusing what is true in a specific context with what is absolutely true.</p><p>· <strong>Missing the point </strong>— Giving an argument that proves something, just not what was at issue.</p><p>· <strong>Begging the Question</strong> — Assuming what you are trying to prove.</p><p>· <strong>False Cause</strong> — Mistaking something that is not the actual cause for the actual cause.</p><p>· <strong>Converse Error</strong> — Affirming the consequence.</p><p>· <strong>Many Questions </strong>— Posing a question that presupposes something controversial.</p><p>With the development of such a framework we can honestly say that Sophistical Refutations closes out the first complete logical system to ever be formally developed — a colossal achievement for Aristotelian thought.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Aristotle is undoubtedly one of the most important thinkers in humanity’s history. As we’ve seen throughout the essay, he is foundational to philosophy, science, linguistics and many more fields that would develop and use his system as a building block. And out of all his works, The Organon is one of the most important ones, as it is the foundation on what most others would later rely on. And while his work on physics, metaphysics and ethics is groundbreaking and very closely associated with the respective disciplines they develop, The Organon is what everyone seeking to understand them must first stand on — a work of philosophical thought that would forever be solidified in human history.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>1. Аристотел; Съчинения: Том I. Органон, Част I; „Захари Стоянов“, София 2008</p><p>2. Аристотел; Съчинения: Том I. Органон, Част II; „Захари Стоянов“, София 2008</p><p>3. Aristotle; The Complete Works of Aristotle: The Revised Oxford Translation, Volume I; Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1984</p><p>4. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Aristotle; <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/aristotle/">https://iep.utm.edu/aristotle/</a></p><p>5. Peter of Spain; Tractatus, Summulae Logicales; Edited by L. M. de Rijk. Assen: Van Gorcum, 1972.</p><p>6. Аристотел; Топика; прев. Иван Христов; „Захари Стоянов“, София 1998</p><p>7. Бл. Долапчиев, Ив. Чобанов; Из Историята на Механиката: От Аристотел До Нютон; „Наука и Изкуство“; София 1961</p><p>8. Averroes; Middle Commentaries on Aristotle’s Logic; Charles E. Butterworth; St. Augustine’s Press, 2009</p><p>9. Thomas Aquinas; Commentary on Aristotle’s On Interpretation; Jean T. Oesterle; Marquette University Press, 1962</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17ff43c09a2f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Nested Realities: Extending Being Through Video Games]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/nested-realities-extending-being-through-video-games-b8486550403b?source=rss-977506e56c1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b8486550403b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[existentialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[videogames]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ivan Spasov]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 07 Jul 2025 15:47:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-07T15:47:07.692Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cxDTvH62tZxPzzkVvHVWTQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Screenshot from Skyrim. Credit: <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/vmax137/">https://www.flickr.com/photos/vmax137/</a></figcaption></figure><p>In this essay, we’ll explore how games as aesthetic expression impress the mind, develop into existential projections and then even turn into metaphysical structures. We’ll draw from <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hegel/">Hegel</a>, <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/heidegger/">Heidegger</a>, and <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/plotinus/">Plotinus</a>, arguing that games as the highest art form is able to extend experience by being an emanation of the player’s reality.</p><h3>Introduction</h3><p>Video games are like doors to a different dimension. Behind each door lies a carefully crafted world with its own flavor, waiting to be explored. Players can dive deep into these worlds and live through some of the most intense emotions that can be evoked through an art form. From the magical sense of adventure in a fantasy game, through the adrenaline pumping action of a competitive e-sport game, all the way to the sense of accomplishment that simulation games give. The feeling of being home, the feeling of being in danger, the dread of the unknown and the promise of treasure. All these rich experiences and much more can be found in video games.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4E5u3MwwIpuJrkLB03kI9A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Screenshot from Elden Ring. Credits: <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/182150045@N02/51974115042/">https://www.flickr.com/photos/182150045@N02/51974115042/</a></figcaption></figure><p>Games are one of the youngest artistic mediums around, yet among the most complex. They blend many art forms such as visuals, music and design into an interactive world that is more than just entertaining. That world is complex and unparalleled with any other form of expression outside of pure imagination itself. Yet still, we treat video games lightly.</p><p>Some see them as escapism, leisure or just a casual activity. That however is not what the actual players encounter. Video games move people in ways that very few things do. They create powerful emotions, attachments, a sense of belonging, happiness, exaltation and sometimes even nostalgia and grief. Players are not mere observers of a fictional world, as seen from the perspective of a made up character. They are active participants. They start to inhabit the spaces they’re thrust into and to develop a deeper emotional connection towards what’s unfolding in their perception. It’s the player — both in how they play the game but in how they react to the world outside — the everyday world.</p><p>In this essay we’ll make a bold claim — video games are not just escapism from reality but rather an extension of it. They emanate from the player’s own “being”, extending their <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/phenomenology/">phenomenological</a> horizon, offering a richer variety of experience. In a sense, the player-character is an extension of the player, having a valid existence in a game world that feels real, and as this essay will try to prove — in its own way it is.</p><p>To achieve this, we will firstly lay out an argument about the value of art within the framework of G.W.F. Hegel. Next, we’ll ask one of philosophy’s most dreaded questions — the question of “<a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/existence/">being</a>”. Here specifically, in the context of playing a video game. We’ll explore the topic through the lens of Martin Heidegger. Finally, we’ll go into the <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/metaphysics/">metaphysical</a> depths of everything being implied in this essay by turning to Plotinus, the Neoplatonist philosopher of emanation.</p><p>This will be our path — from aesthetics through <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontology">ontology </a>to metaphysics. From Hegel, through Heidegger, to Plotinus. But before we begin our journey, some clarifications are in order.</p><h3>Conceptual Framework</h3><p>A prerequisite for a clear understanding of what’s ahead must be laid out, so that the right idea is conveyed. So, we’ll need to define some terms that are going to be commonplace within the essay. Additionally, we’ll go over some of the core ideas and how they tie the picture together. Firstly, we’ll start by expanding on some definitions.</p><ul><li><strong>Phenomenological horizon</strong> — this term will refer to the scope of experience available to a conscious being at any given time. The possibility space of awareness, so to speak. When talking about expanding the phenomenological horizon, we’ll refer to the growth of that possibility space beyond its current frame.</li><li><strong>Meta-reality</strong> — the constructed reality of the video game, as experienced by the player. Basically, all the constructs within the confines of the video game that in some way, shape or form are observed by the player and become a part of their phenomenological horizon. That would include gameplay, graphics, sound, UI and so on.</li><li><strong>Player-character</strong> — this can refer to several things. While it obviously can point to the avatar that the player is controlling, it can also be seen as any point of view through which the player is able to observe any given meta-reality. It could just as well be a free-roaming camera or a fixed view of a poker table. To put it simply — the player-character refers to the point of view through which the meta-reality of a given game unfolds.</li><li><strong>Emanation</strong> — the ontological process through which multiplicity unfolds from unity, while preserving causal relations to that unity. Emanation is the process through which one becomes the many, while the many are an outpouring of the one, keeping a direct relation to it. The same way in which a vast sea gives rise to a whirlpool, the whirlpool is an emanation of the sea. While the whirlpool is distinct, it’s existence hinges on a causal structure within the sea. At the same time, the very existence of the whirlpool has causal influence on the sea itself.</li><li><strong>Intelligibility</strong> — the capacity for something to become meaningful within a context. This applies predominantly to the mind. We’ll often say in the essay that something can be attained through intelligibility or become intelligible. This will refer to the contextual attainment of meaning within the mind.</li><li><strong>Extension of being</strong> — this phrase indicates the step that follows the broadening of the phenomenological horizon. The very existence of the player is extended into the game world and through the player-character. That way not only is the possibility of experience broadened but also the entire frame of existence for the player.</li></ul><p>As a second conceptual scaffolding, we need to put into frame what philosophical thought we’re going to use within the essay, without going into much detail as each section will expand as necessary.</p><ul><li><strong>Hegelian aesthetics</strong> — they give us the means to recognize video games as a legitimate and superior art form. Additionally, for Hegel the purpose of art is to manifest inner life outward, unfolding the very ground of existence. He gives supremacy to inner life, imagination and intelligibility, making any expression of the conscious mind the true expression of reality. We’ll make the argument that video games center the player’s agency as the driving force of its artistic medium, giving the experiences within meta-reality complete validity.</li><li>Through <strong>Martin Heidegger</strong> we’ll explore what “being” means in our current context — as a player, as the player-character, as well as being within a meta-reality. We’ll start by looking at the player through the Heideggerian lens of Dasein — the being for whom “being” is a contemplation and an issue. The one who’s “being” is the essence of their existence. We’ll use his system to look at one of the most important aspects of “being” — how possibilities make it unfold into reality itself, creating the flow of life. We’ll see how games impact possibilities through Heidegger’s thinking on technology. We’ll see that “being” in the context of a video game is not much different as in everyday reality.</li><li>And finally, through <strong>Plotinus</strong> we’ll look at the broader implications of our previous steps which will inevitably lead us to metaphysical conclusions. Everything we’ll describe through examples, analysis and framing within Hegelian and Heideggerian thought will lead us to the same door — that the ontological truth of video games resides within Neoplatonism and more specifically in Plotinus’ emanation framework. Much like The One emanates into The Nous, The Nous into The World Soul with the individual soul residing between it and Nature (another emanation of the World Soul), so does the player’s state of being reside between the everyday reality and meta-reality. We’ll make the argument that the player emanates into the player-character and the video game world. To put it more simply, we’ll see how Plotinus can help us explain the hierarchy of nested realities that becomes apparent after we’ve seen the player’s state of being when they play.</li></ul><p>There is a great deal of oversimplification within this conceptual framework, however concepts will become clearer as we move from one section to another. Now, we can begin with the first chapter of our essay — the aesthetical validity of video games.</p><h3>Video Games as an Immersive Art Form</h3><p>The status of video games as an art form has been a subject of many interpretations as the medium has progressed throughout the years.</p><p>Here we’ll make the argument that not only are video games their own art form but also the culmination of manifested creative thought. To make this point, we’ll lean on the great German philosopher G.W.F. Hegel and his thoughts on aesthetics, art and how they impact the essence of our very being.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/452/1*K4wwOgDwazZU50y3LIvbAg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A portrait of Hegel, done by Schlesinger in 1831</figcaption></figure><p>Following in the footsteps of Immanuel Kant and moving along with contemporaries like Fichte and Schelling, Hegel gives supremacy to the mind, consciousness and thus — imagination. For him, anything perceived by the mind and then represented in the terms of imagination is supreme in aesthetic qualities to anything nature has to offer.</p><p>What that means is that Hegel places a higher aesthetic value to anything that is born of the inner world — that includes but is not limited to the imaginal representation of what nature is. We can get an even better understanding if we look at some quotes from him:</p><blockquote><em>“The work of art stands higher than any natural product, however excellent, because it is born of the spirit.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>“Imagination is the productive activity of the spirit, and it is only through imagination that the artist gives sensuous expression to spiritual content.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>“Nature is beautiful, but it lacks the freedom of spirit and therefore cannot express the Idea as art can.”</em></blockquote><p>Hegel’s stance is informed primarily by his overall philosophical and metaphysical framework — his dialectical unfolding as well as his overall concept of the Spirit. However, even if we look outside of the specifics of his philosophy, there is a lot of merit to his words. Everyone is unique. We see and express our individual experiences through our own lens. Each moment in time, each expressed emotion is different for everyone and the way one person sees a flower may be completely different from how another sees it.</p><p>We each have our own phenomenological horizons — our own anchor points, our own first-person perspective along which phenomena come in appearance. We place subjectivity over each phenomenon, giving it meaning and intertwine it in our own personal narratives, so it only makes sense that the art we express carries an elevated aesthetic. Something which is truly unique — when we consume art, we get a glimpse of the inner world of another individual.</p><p>It is with this mindset that Hegel grants supremacy to dynamic, imaginative expressions of art. He places a high emphasis on the physical expression of the art form — the further it is from material reality and the more inwards it’s directed, the higher it places on Hegel’s aesthetic hierarchy. Now is a good time to analyze it and video games’ place in it.</p><h3>A Hegelian ranking of the arts</h3><p>In Hegelian terms, video games could be considered the peak form of art, and this designation would be justifiable. To understand why, we need to see how Hegel ranked art in terms of aesthetic hierarchy. At the bottom of his list was architecture, followed by sculpture, then painting, music and at the very top as the pinnacle of aesthetics — poetry. A look into his reasoning is quite appropriate.</p><p><strong>Architecture</strong> — While he ranks it at the bottom, Hegel has a reverence for it. He would make a case that architecture is the most material and external among the arts. However, there is a really strong quote from Hegel’s Aesthetics that puts an emphasis on the transcendent ideas within it.</p><blockquote>“Architecture is the first to open the way for the God… but it leaves Him still in the abstract darkness of the inner chamber.” -Aesthetics, Vol. I, p. 648</blockquote><p><strong>Sculpture</strong> — Next on the ranking is sculpture. While it is an expression of an idea into subjectivity, and can leave a strong imprint on conscious viewers, it remains static and with strong material roots. A reflective quote by Hegel:</p><blockquote>“In sculpture… the spiritual inner life has found its bodily shape, and its bodily shape has become animated by spirit.” — Aesthetics, Vol. I, p. 723</blockquote><p><strong>Painting</strong> — With the introduction of color, light and dynamic expression of shapes and forms that cannot exist within the natural world, painting is the first art form that truly starts to represent inner subjectivity made manifest. It enables the expression of inner states of being — emotions, abstract feelings that cannot be expressed with anything less. A great quote from Hegel on the matter:</p><blockquote>“Painting abandons the solidity of material and the external world… in favor of appearances that suggest the inward.” — Aesthetics, Vol. II, p. 888</blockquote><p><strong>Music</strong> — A higher order of dynamic artistic expression, which has almost no physical manifestation outside of our very ability to perceive it. Music is abstract, yet it brings an immensely rich experiential proposition to the forefront of awareness — it can induce feelings from across the entire spectrum of human emotion, while the canvas of its unfolding is pointed inward. Every emotion felt has an inward trigger, not an external one. Something that only the self recognizes and is unique to it. To quote Hegel:</p><blockquote>“Music is the art which, more than the others, sets aside the objective world and speaks the language of the heart.” — Aesthetics, Vol. II, p. 900</blockquote><p><strong>Poetry</strong> — The very pinnacle of artistic expression according to Hegel. It shares a lot of commonalities with music in that poetry’s innate rhythm resonates inward and speaks directly to the inner self. And much like music, it is dynamic, not physically manifest and it creates an abstract phenomenological canvas that helps the receptive awareness build its own imaginal realms. What really elevates it to the top spot of the artistic hierarchy is its additional expression in language — the tool of thinking. It is through thought that we attain intelligibility. It helps us establish our own inner world. So, when we see another’s inner world expressed through text we bear witness to a representation of their essential being. A quote from Hegel on poetry :</p><blockquote>“Poetry is the universal art of the spirit which has become free in itself and is not tied to finding its realization in external sensuous matter.” — Aesthetics, Vol. II, p. 973</blockquote><p>Hegel would also propose that with the progression of time and the unfolding of the spirit, all of these art forms would subside in favor of the ultimate artistic expression of thought — philosophy. And while philosophy is a strong contender to become king, Hegel couldn’t envision something like the meta-realities of video games during his time. Within them, the player can experience all other arts, including even his predicted future king — philosophy.</p><h3>Video Games as the highest form of aesthetics</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L16_niCcQKLKbxB3nMUiVw.png" /><figcaption>A screenshot from God of War: Ragnarok. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNE1G4tP2kI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNE1G4tP2kI</a></figcaption></figure><p>Modern video games are an interactive medium that thrusts the player in a full experience that is felt through sight, sound, touch and intelligibility. That experience unfolds in a rich world that fully immerses the player. That same unfolding happens before their very eyes, as if they are there, living in that world, that meta-reality. There is a very definite sense of causality and felt experiences can be profound. Each meta-reality is constructed to make sense for the specific game being played. From first person shooters, through roleplaying games, to simulations and beyond, we can state that video games generally have all Hegelian forms of art within them, and that would include his final frontier of philosophy.</p><p>The way art forms intermingle into these coherent meta-realities is as fascinating as within our own reality. They meld together to create a new phenomenological frontier to be experienced, and each art form finds its place, building a complete aesthetic expression.</p><p>Meta-reality unfolds in a constructed world. From the most elaborate RPG to a very basic version of digital poker. In almost any such context there is architecture. Buildings, serving a utilitarian purpose within the confines of the meta-reality they exist in and while they are not brick and mortar, they emulate the aesthetic characteristics of their physical counterparts — even when under a complete stylization. A castle to explore, a house to live in, a city to build or even a room with a table to play poker at. All of these are what architecture looks like within meta-reality. And what makes them solid, aside from what is felt in perception, is the fact that they’re actually built by people — game developers and artists, carefully laying out the elaborate and immersive world through which the player will unfold his own “being”. In the same manner, sculpture and painting find their homes in meta-reality. Video game characters are sculpted and placed as an imaginative expression within the world — the player-character being no exception. From the mightiest of dragons, to the complete realistic portrayals of athletes. Knights and aliens, kings and monsters. All imagined, sculpted, animated and poured into the rich meta-reality the player is about to experience. Paintings and elements are placed all over the game world as well as the user interface, finding their place in perception and acting out the imaginative act of “being” in this world. It essentially feels like a layered reality to which we have access. Something which we’ll see much more of in our metaphysical contemplation with Plotinus.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*egPIOa7eztp07g1zYp7MHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Screenshot from Gravity Rush 2. Credit: <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/182150045@N02/">https://www.flickr.com/photos/182150045@N02/</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h1PyiDqo2mseXyJ61YJrWQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The process of creating Concept art. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3fYcYq4XMg">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3fYcYq4XMg</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OUFhe8olhQkvMKbvSshotA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The process of 3D sculpting. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XW0bqZBmPY">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XW0bqZBmPY</a></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wl6PwBND87UihjaLVmzlIg.jpeg" /><figcaption>The process of Level design. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4wziE0AYCoo">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4wziE0AYCoo</a></figcaption></figure><p>Next, we have music, which Hegel treats as a higher form of art. It stretches from title themes, through ambient sounds to music specifically made to be played by certain characters. But it’s not just the music — it’s the entire concept of sound design. Every sound heard in the game is made by a sound designer. Every cricket in the wild, every footstep, every sound of a button press. All of these express the dynamic qualities of sound.</p><p>And the final Hegelian aesthetic frontier we’re yet to meet in video games is poetry. While we can go down the easy road and say that there is such a thing inside meta-reality in the forms of poems, lore pieces engraved into certain items, dialogue pieces between characters and so on, we would be doing a disservice both to poetry itself and what Hegel thought made it special.</p><p>The reason poetry is at the top of the Hegelian aesthetic ladder is the rhythmic dynamism that drives emotions inside the inner world. The way words convey and propagate subjectivity within the observer in an uncanny fashion. The cycle of emotions drives us on a rollercoaster like no other because it has the largest capacity to induce experience.</p><p>There is a thing within video games, which is their core essence, which does the exact same thing as poetry and can be directly translated into it and that is gameplay. The way the player interacts within meta-reality, the rules around which the player navigates, the layout of text, story, interconnectivity and direct agency expression are exactly what Hegel thinks poetry induces within a person’s mind.</p><p>In that regard, when drawing the line we can see that the entire Hegelian aesthetic hierarchy can be found within video games, while additionally going even deeper into the subjectivity of the player, making them live, feel and in a sense exist in another world, which is in itself an art form.</p><p>These immersive meta-realities build up the inner world of the player, making concepts from them intelligible and extending their phenomenological horizon beyond everyday reality. They contain all the stimuli that induce thought, mind, emotion and expression through core subjectivity — something that Hegel would say is at the core of reality and at the core of “being”.</p><p>In that context, a line of thought is starting to form. How can we understand such a meta-reality? Something that extends to the very top of the aesthetic ladder and even melds with our sense of reality through emotion. A good way would be to maybe understand what our own reality is like — isn’t meta-reality ultimately a fictional representation of it? The answer here is both yes and no.</p><p>Understanding reality is one of philosophy’s hardest problems and greatest tasks to tackle. It is an open-ended question to this day. Too open-ended. That is why German philosopher Martin Heidegger decided the best way to ask questions about our reality and existence isn’t to point them at the root of the universe but rather at ourselves. We are an expression of the larger reality — we are the ones, who’s existence revolves around the question of existence. We’ll investigate Heideggerian thought in the next section, where we’ll try to unpack a very important question from before — what does it mean to “be” within a meta-reality? What does it mean to “be” the player and what does it mean for them to “be” the player-character? In an essence, we’ll tackle the question of “being” in video games.</p><h3>Being, Realities &amp; Meta-Realities</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NKRDfIzBkYkzmzAHWoPdWg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A screenshot from The Matrix Awakens — a video game demo to showcase Unreal Engine 5. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WU0gvPcc3jQ">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WU0gvPcc3jQ</a></figcaption></figure><p>What we really want to explore is how video games truly extend our own “being”, our very existence. We want to grasp the extension of our phenomenological horizon — what does it extend into and how is that manifested into our awareness? Who is the nature of the player-character — are they an emanation of us or do they have a separate “being”? If they do, is it confined solely to the meta-reality they exist in? How much of what we experience within a meta-reality is our most authentic self? Let’s explore.</p><p>We’ve seen the artistic power of video games as the highest aesthetic form in the previous chapter. We’ve also had a glimpse of the immersion and connections players can build with the meta-realities they inhabit through the characters they control. They create vivid mental connections, such as thoughts, feelings and emotions, expanding their awareness and phenomenological horizon.</p><p>To explore the state of “being” of the player, the player-character and the meta-realities of the games being played, we’ll dive into one of the richest philosophical systems — that of Martin Heidegger.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/337/1*shnjJC31-R4ttB6gCCdvMg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A photograph of Martin Heidegger from 1960</figcaption></figure><p>Known for his major work “Being and Time”, Heidegger is a philosopher who has strong opinions on technology as well, thus the perfect storm for our current investigation. We’ll ground our perspective in an order that’s not chronologically relevant to his work. With that in mind, firstly we’ll tackle one of his later works — his essay “The Question Concerning Technology”. A big misconception is that Heidegger takes a stance against technology itself and that cannot be further from the truth. We’ll see shortly that video games can be considered a tool to help us express our authenticity and reveal a much larger context of “being”, which is something Heidegger would have an appreciation for.</p><p>A key feature of video games is the fact that they reveal possibilities to the player. These possibilities are not merely within their own meta-reality but in the player’s everyday world as well. Certain possibilities are revealed to the player through visual or auditory queues that would guide them to something that’s not even remotely related to their current context. Another major revelation of possibilities is the expansion of the phenomenological horizon of the player — the ability to experience things that they couldn’t outside of the meta-reality they’re currently in.</p><p>Both the revealing and the possibilities themselves are a key component, not only of Heidegger’s thought but of the human condition in general. Here we can circle back to Hegelian thought — the dynamic unfolding of the mind is a tool for self-discovery and progression. Now, we’ll directly investigate some Heideggerian concepts that tie strongly into why video game experiences are as valuable to the player as they are.</p><p>For him, possibilities are essential to our very existence. Without going in-depth on his concept of Dasein, we can say with a huge layer of oversimplification, that Dasein describes our existence (and everything it entails) at its core. And here is the interesting part — for Heidegger Dasein is not defined by what it currently is but rather, what it can be. Dasein always exists towards the possibilities in front of it. Since it is the being concerned with “being”, it always looks ahead with the arrow of time — towards potentialities. To quote Heidegger:</p><blockquote>“Dasein is a being which, in its Being, is concerned about its very Being. It is a being that is always ahead of itself, in that it exists as a possibility.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Only because Dasein is as it is, can it in its Being be concerned about its ownmost potentiality-for-Being.”</blockquote><p>There is quite an intuitive notion we can take for ourselves from this. Most of us look at what we perceive could happen to us. We tend to imagine a feeling associated with a certain possibility space and thus, we’re completely turned towards it. What would happen if we could drastically increase that possibility space with a multitude of sandboxes that allow us to extend our being? To broaden our horizons — both in terms of mind and practicality? What if each of these sandboxes is the meta-reality of a game that allows us to explore freely? It is time for an anecdote, who will become much more important later on, when we start to tackle Plotinus.</p><p>A long time ago, a very close and dear friend said something quite impactful — that he had learned the basics of a free market economy from an MMORPG — namely NCSoft’s Lineage II. Within the game’s meta-reality, trading for specific rare items and crafting ingredients at a high level is done primarily in an impromptu market, developed by other players, for other players in the town square of Giran — a major city in the game. In an in-game economy completely dictated by the players, prices would rise and fall accordingly. Monetary relationships would come into certain dynamics. And that same friend had learned them and would exploit the living daylights of them if he could. The really interesting part about all of this is his own statement that learning economy in that way helped him understand sales and business in later life. His time spent in Lineage II’s world had revealed certain possibilities to him — both in meta-reality and in his everyday reality. This is where we’ll circle back to Heidegger, with the topic of video games as technology and his outlook on it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ma57-hVJ_zrMyqVw-CVRhg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A screenshot of Lineage II and Giran’s huge player-driven market. Credits: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J9cCT2h4xuw">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J9cCT2h4xuw</a></figcaption></figure><p>Heidegger would propose that technology is a way of revealing possibilities, with such revelation becoming the tool through which we can truly look at our own horizons and expand them. To look at his words directly:</p><blockquote>“Technology is a way of revealing. Technology comes to presence in the realm where revealing and unconcealment take place, where alētheia, truth, happens.”</blockquote><p>A thing to keep in mind about technology is that we need to make sure it doesn’t become an end in itself. Something in which we completely lose ourselves in and become subservient to it. This is one of Heidegger’s biggest fears and video games certainly carry a risk of such an overflow. “Being” must not become encapsuled into a technological frame, leaving the initial state of it abandoned and forgotten. “Being” must be enhanced through technology, not replaced by it. And it is that vital importance, that is at the core of what we’re looking for here. To understand it however, we need to place being back at the center.</p><h3>Being — The Existence of the Player</h3><p>While it’s not our objective to tackle the general concept of being, we need to have a simplistic overview of it to assess the context of being as it relates to video games. For this essay, we’ll do so again in a Heideggerian frame. We’ve already mentioned the term Dasein in the previous section, now let’s expand and look at what we can extrapolate, although with a great deal of simplification and nuance omission. Also, for simplicity’s sake, we’ll omit Heideggerian terminology and frame things into the relevant context, as opposed to an overall philosophical framework.</p><p>We can say that the being of the player is defined as the human mode of existing, characterized by self-awareness, the ability to relate to the player’s own existence and experience and the ability to question that existence and the reality it unfolds in. The player always exists within reality where they are not defined as a thing among things but rather as a relational part of a much bigger whole. The player is a meaningful relation of significance to all other parts of the bigger whole, while having their own agency — their being is their primary concern. The player has their own emotions, feelings and a rich inner world, looking inward while also expressing themselves outward towards the whole.</p><p>This is how we, the player, are — the essence of our being in the world. It describes our existence as related to our everyday reality. It is also a precursor to a question — what is the “being” of the player within meta-reality? What is then the “being” of the player-character and are they essentially one and the same? Let’s investigate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EvhHtBTjWXSlUCGX8Rmp5Q.png" /><figcaption>A player customizes a player-character in a version of Skyrim’s character creation screen. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GH2mxAcIAfg">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GH2mxAcIAfg</a></figcaption></figure><p>The Heideggerian concept of being that we loosely lifted shows us a lot of points that translate directly — from being within the confines of reality to being within meta-reality. From the being of the player in the world to the being of the player in the game world.</p><p>We’ve seen how immersive and all-encompassing such a world can be for the player. When stepping into such a meta-reality, they keep a lot of what defines their being in the real world. They are still a relational part of the bigger whole and not a thing among things — the video game is the enclosed system, defined by its components and the player-character is just such a component. The character has relational significance to all other entities within the video game. The existence of the video game is defined by its parts — the player, the entities, the gameplay, the assets but also every part is defined by being within the video game.</p><p>While in the metaphorical shoes of their in-game counterpart, the player is able to exercise their agency through gameplay. That agency, as we’ll see further, transcends meta-reality and leaves a strong trace in the real world, however its impact is felt very directly within the video game. All the while — the player is aware of their own existence. They know both that they exist and that their awareness is currently focused within a meta-reality. The player is aware of the unfolding events and can see causal structures play their part within the game. Thus — the player can start to question their choices and the place of the player-character within meta-reality.</p><h3>Being Within Video Games</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rqS91vrLlxJMjL9wSrCCqA.png" /><figcaption>A screenshot of the player-character entering a busy town in Skyrim. Credits: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCsiYNKMSWw">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCsiYNKMSWw</a></figcaption></figure><p>We’ll need to tackle a direct example. In Bethesda’s Skyrim, the player is placed in the shoes of a completely customizable character and set into the vast world of the Elder Scrolls, specifically in the Skyrim region. Their character is thrown into a living ecosystem where Ulfric Stormcloak leads a rebellion against the Empire, with the latter having a strong presence to maintain control. Things quickly get out of hand when everyone are attacked by Alduin — a mighty ancient dragon. This meta-reality is immensely deep. With stories and lore that reaches far back into perceived time, long before the player had even entered. Other in-game characters have names, appear to have their own personalities and agencies, making them feel alive. The player can do a huge assortment of things within the game — become a warrior, sorcerer, thief, buy a house, start a family, listen to bards, eat cheese and drink wine, develop an unlikely brotherhood with a band of werewolf warriors or become a part of the Dark Brotherhood of assassins — and all of that is just barely scratching the surface.</p><p>Within this example, the player is thrown into a meta-reality that feels like it was there before we’ve ever existed and like it would exist for thousands of years after we’re no longer in that world. All the needed ingredients for the player to express and experience their “being” are there. It feels like a representation of our world, from a time long past. A fairytale made manifest into existence. This meta-reality can actually be seen as an emanation of our own. A topic that we’ll tackle with Plotinus.</p><p>The “being” of the player character is interwoven with the being of the meta-reality. The “being” of Skyrim is defined by the relations of the player’s being and that of each inhabitant and their interactions with the player. The world is vast, alive, and full of possibilities. Looking at the art of the game, listening to its music and executing the gameplay with all its preset rules and probabilities leave the players feeling like Skyrim has been their home for the time they’ve experienced it. They feel nostalgic for places and characters they’ve met only in the context of this meta-reality. Yet, there are revealed possibilities which have a real phenomenological impact on the player — thus a truth is revealed. That the player can feel at home in a place that is only in imagination from an ontological perspective.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2vM1fBf0gQI-0P6W91BXtg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Players, who’s were greatly impacted by their time in Skyrim. Expressing strong emotions not only for the meta-reality they inhabited but for their everyday reality during the same period. Credits: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ou1pl0XNR">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9ou1pl0XNR</a></figcaption></figure><p>It’s a callback to our thoughts on Hegelian aesthetics — the strong emphasis that video games put on intelligibility, imagination and integration into the mind, through the immersive artistic form that they are, form a world that feels real. That extends the player’s phenomenological horizon as they experience the meta-reality through the player character, as if it was everyday reality. Now, we should investigate another phenomenon more deeply — the experience of the expression of “being” of that character. To put it simply — the character itself has a significance and a state of “being” within the meta-reality they inhabit. And while the player’s eyes are the ones who see through the eyes of the player-character, it is the character that is the conduit for experience within meta-reality.</p><p>Let’s return to Lineage II, the video game from our anecdote earlier, and develop a thought experiment about player interaction.</p><p>An Orc Tyrant, we’ll call her Cali, wants to buy soul shots (an item from Lineage II) in order to hit stronger while on a raid. Cali goes to Giran Town to purchase the said item from someone. In Giran, she finds a Dwarf, we’ll call him Graystone, sitting on the ground, selling the item. Mind you, both Cali and Graystone are player controlled characters. So, Cali buys the soul shots and leaves, going on to do raids, PvP and all the good things an Orc Tyrant does. Graystone gets his money and all are happy. How does it look from each of their perspectives though?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*j0HxpsTsZQFgsi1Qah3lvw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A player goes shopping in Giran. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0v7U3UYC71E">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0v7U3UYC71E</a></figcaption></figure><p>For Cali, the very avatar that she is, is moved from one location to another — in this case Giran Town. Cali’s phenomenological point of view is that of her player — let’s call the player Ivan. So, it is Ivan’s first person perspective that melds with Cali’s and leads her and by proxy, his conscious self to Giran. It is Ivan’s agency that drives Cali’s actions. Within Giran, Ivan and in turn Cali notice a lot of characters, sitting on the ground and offering everything one could imagine. Ivan, as Cali, needs soul shots in order to satisfy a need — his own, and Cali’s, in the context of that specific meta-reality. Ivan/Cali notices a specific dwarf. His name is Graystone — a player controlled character. All that’s in appearance to Ivan/Cali is Graystone. Ivan/Cali browses Graystone’s goods and buys whatever the need is. Ivan/Cali gets the soul shots, while Graystone gets his money, everyone’s happy.</p><p>On the other end of that exchange is Jenny. Jenny has a dwarf — she’s called him Graystone, after a story she’d heard as a kid. Jenny and by proxy Graystone, need money to better equip Jenny’s other characters that she uses. Graystone is doing his best job — to be an Artisan and a trader through his in-game skills and Jenny’s own agency. Jenny and by proxy Graystone are sitting in Giran, hoping someone will buy the soul shots that Jenny has spent time crafting through Graystone. Jenny/Graystone sits there in Giran, when all of a sudden, a female Orc Tyrant named Cali approaches. A trade is initiated, and Cali buys the soul shots. Everyone is happy — Cali gets her item, Jenny/Graystone — the money.</p><p>And here is where things get interesting — at no point do Jenny and Ivan have a direct contact with one another. Only Cali and Graystone do. That same Cali, whose lore is independently merged with the Orc culture; that same Graystone that is known within that meta-reality as a master Artisan. But not Ivan the person and not Jenny the person. What is in perception is the language, or rather — the “physical manifestation” of the meta-reality.</p><p>What Ivan knows is how the world looks through his eyes, observing Cali. What Jenny knows is how the world looks through her eyes, observing Graystone. Neither one is able to see the reality behind the eyes of the other. What Jenny observes are the actions of Cali, not the actions of Ivan, although Ivan is the conscious agency controlling Cali. The memories Jenny would create would be those with Cali, not Ivan. In a sense, Ivan doesn’t exist in Graystone’s world and by proxy — in Jenny’s.</p><p>Here we can open many questions — who is the observer and who is the observed? Whose life is the one being lived and who’s “being” is the one unfolding in perception? Can we make a point that Cali is an emanation of Ivan, while Graystone of Jenny? The answer might seem simple but it’s not.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/894/1*hCz4ar8cFh0GmpCBEptBfg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A picture depicting an “observer”. Credit: <a href="https://www.deviantart.com/brainbody/art/The-Calm-Observer-957997615">https://www.deviantart.com/brainbody/</a></figcaption></figure><p>Cali and Graystone all have their own “being”, irrespective of the being of the player. However, that being is static and predetermined. They exist when the player is not controlling them. In lore — they have existed before the player took control. But we never see that. We know it, but it is never in perception. Their static “being” shifts into a dynamic one only when the player takes control. They become “alive” only through the player’s agency. It is the player’s eyes that look at the game world through the eyes of the character. Cali starts to want something only if Ivan is contextually immersed enough in Lineage II to want something. However, this isn’t a simple process. Ivan is immersed in a meta-reality only because his being has been melded onto it. Because his phenomenological horizon has extended beyond his own reality and onto that of the game. So, which comes first — the chicken or the egg? Is Cali the one who produces the expansion of Ivan’s phenomenological horizon or is it he who does it through her eyes?</p><p>It’s not really “one or the other”. What is obvious is that the agency is always the player. Even when immersed in the narrative of the character, the agency remains that of the conscious experience behind the player-character. Another thing to note is that the connection between the character and the player can always be severed in only one direction — by the player. It is not a symbiotic relationship, although at times (and especially with video game addictions) can seem like it. We’ve hinted at this already, but we can spell it out a bit more here — in our example, Cali is an emanation of Ivan. An emanation of the essence of the player onto the player-character that leads to the expansion of the phenomenological horizon.</p><p>We need to look at the forest for a bit, as we risk seeing only the trees. If we expand our view, we can see clearly that the “being” of the player and the player-character are intertwined. The same can be said for the entire meta-reality as well. This shows us more than existential extensions. We have a metaphysical claim.</p><p>Since these meta-realities are intertwined with the player and the player-character and their states of “being” have relations which cannot be understated, we are forced to say that video game worlds have an ontological validity. Meta-realities are real in a certain sense. They carry with them the realness that comes from the sheer relationship between them and the player. What they mean to the player and how much significance is placed upon them. They exist as intelligible structures within the player’s mind. And as we shift focus to our metaphysical claims, we can’t help but look back at Hegel, who gives metaphysical and ontological validity to mind above all else.</p><p>This is the point where our investigation is forcing us to make a metaphysical claim. As we’ve hinted at in previous paragraphs, video games are an emanation of reality, the player-character is an emanation of the player and we as the player exist between these worlds. Let’s elaborate by diving into emanations, Plotinus and the significance of such metaphysical claims.</p><h3>Video Games as an Emanation of Reality</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zSnW_L77AUeofvn_UH8B0Q.png" /><figcaption>A screenshot from Elden Ring. Credits: <a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/182150045@N02/">https://www.flickr.com/photos/182150045@N02/</a></figcaption></figure><p>When we say the player-character is an emanation of the player, what do we really mean? What is emanation in this context? This is an important point to drive across. In the beginning of the essay, we defined the term emanation quite clearly and while this definition could serve in the exploration of the relationship between the player and the player-character, it is a bit too broad, so we need to tighten it.</p><p>As we’ve seen in previous examples, this relationship is created primarily on a phenomenological level and can be integrated into the mental world of the player only through intelligibility. Thankfully, there is a metaphysical framework that has emanation as its primary ontological principle, and we can use it to explore our main themes further. That framework belongs to the great Roman thinker Plotinus. We’ll investigate it, and as in previous cases — for clarity’s sake, we will be reductive and will simplify his work to use it for our purposes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/569/1*23wxBqbHM_s3VJmD_sudzA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A sculpture of Plotinus</figcaption></figure><p>Plotinus would state that at the very ground of reality is The One, which is beyond our comprehension. From The One emanates The Nous — a Universal intellect, which is a realm of pure thought. Within that realm are the unchanging universal Forms, as seen by Plato. Then, from The Nous emanates The World Soul. Within it, time and space form and give rise to what we perceive as the Universe. And this is where our analogy really starts to take shape — from The World Soul emanate individual souls as well as Nature as we know it — the material world. Let’s at some of his own words, as written in The Enneads:</p><blockquote>“Multiplicity exists only as an image of unity.” (V.1.8)</blockquote><blockquote>“All things must come from one principle; everything must originate from a single source.” (V.1.6)</blockquote><blockquote>“Even the things furthest removed have their being through the One.” (VI.9.5)</blockquote><blockquote>“Each thing as it comes into being is not cast off by its source, but remains within it.” (V.1.7)</blockquote><p>An important part of Plotinus’ framework is the position of the individual soul as it relates to its emanation hierarchy. A big part of it resides in The World Soul where it is a part of a more primordial reality — the realm of intelligibility and thought. Another part of it resides in Nature — the material world. From a hierarchical standpoint, the material world is an emanation of The World Soul. The individual soul then plugs itself from The World Soul onto Nature and experiences the material world as perceived by us. It gets so immersed in the life it leads within the physical realm, that it becomes a thing of its own, not being in realization that it is a higher order being that also resides in another realm. The only way to actualize knowledge of the full picture of reality is through intelligibility — only the mind can know truth as mind is the source out of which emanation is happening.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*DHsFo2UZtG8uyJtYoVMwbA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A symbolic screenshot from Elden Ring. Credits: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bg8i4CvE74M">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bg8i4CvE74M</a></figcaption></figure><p>Looking at Plotinus’ framework, it looks uncanny like our previous examples. It appears as though the individual soul, residing within The World Soul is playing a game within Nature. And whilst in Nature, the individual soul never really comes to know another individual soul but rather it’s temporary corporeal form. While in Nature, the corporeal form that soul takes has a being of its own. This should give us flashbacks to the example from Lineage 2 we’ve analyzed already.</p><p>To reiterate and reframe — Ivan is the soul, Cali is the corporeal form. And while Cali gets to know Graystone, Ivan doesn’t really get to know Jenny. At least not in the confines of that specific meta-reality. Now, analogies aside, we must step back and look at some of Plotinus’ thoughts on the soul and contemplate how it ties into our core thesis:</p><blockquote>“The soul never completely leaves the intelligible world.” (IV.8.8)</blockquote><blockquote>“In the soul’s descent, it brings forth images and shadows of what it once beheld in purity.” (I.1.8)</blockquote><blockquote>“Each soul is a kind of world, and all souls together make up the totality of the intelligible universe.” (IV.3.7)</blockquote><blockquote>“The soul is the author of the life of the body; but it also constructs worlds.” (IV.3.9)</blockquote><p>A very key feature about this line of thinking is that within Plotinus’ ontology, the emanation unfolds in mind. And it is exactly that space of intelligibility and phenomenology that is the center point of the melding between the player and the player-character. As we’ve seen at the very beginning with Hegel, the foundations of truthfulness of our own reality form in the mind. And in a similar fashion in which Nature unfolds through an emanation of the intelligible realm of The World Soul, it is our individual soul that makes the connection between the two. This juxtaposition is interesting — the player occupies the same space that Plotinus’ individual soul does — one in-between two realities, one emanating from the other. The player is between the everyday world and a meta-reality in the same way an individual soul is between The World Soul and Nature. We can expand further and see what that implies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wFhchYHFVdKXoh-nxcyk_A.jpeg" /><figcaption>A simplified diagram of Plotinus’ emanation structure. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vZEUo_sHoBw">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vZEUo_sHoBw</a></figcaption></figure><p>Our everyday reality is akin to The World Soul — an encapsulated universe which is the space of “being” for an entity like us. In our case — the player, in Plotinus’ case, the individual soul. Within that space, emanates another encapsulated frame — a reality within a reality. One that directly overflows from the first, directly caused by it and having continuous causal connections to it. That is — the same way Nature emanates from The World Soul and the same way the meta-reality of a video game emanates from our everyday reality. In both cases, the intermediary is the same — the soul and the player. Their state of “being” is similar — the individual soul takes corporeal form, while the player — an avatar or another player-controlled perspective — what we’ve come to call a player-character. The modes of “being” are also similar — an entity of a higher order descends onto a more simplified, imperfect emanation of their reality to experience an existence that’s unburdened of their own reality frame. The soul gets to live in Nature, in physical form — observing objects that belong to the perfect Forms within The World Soul, while being imperfect instances of them. It gets to forget the eternal unchanging reality of The World Soul and experience a life of change and flux — imperfect but dynamic. Similarly, the player enters a meta-reality, becoming bound to scenarios and possibilities they would not encounter in everyday life. A world in which they can do things they normally cannot, forget their identity, even their corporeal form in favor of a representation within an imaginary realm. To gain some further grounding on these points, we should again refer to Plotinus’ own writing:</p><blockquote>“Imagination is a power of the soul, giving form to the formless and presenting it to thought.” (IV.3.30)</blockquote><blockquote>“In the intelligible world, to see is to be what one sees.” (VI.7.33)</blockquote><blockquote>“To be present to something is to give it reality.” (VI.5.6)</blockquote><blockquote>“The intellect is not a passive mirror but a creator of its objects.” (V.9.8)</blockquote><blockquote>“The higher the soul’s vision, the more it sees not as something else, but as itself.” (I.6.9)</blockquote><blockquote>“Thinking and being are not two; to think truly is to exist.” (V.9.5)</blockquote><p>With everything in place, we can’t help but feel the need to tie things together within an observation of a metaphysical nature.</p><h3>The Metaphysical Conclusion</h3><p>Taking a step back and looking at the picture from a far, it reads like this — the mind is the stage of unfolding for all our experiences. It seeks to know, feel, explore — it seeks to know its own existence through the very experiences that define it. Mind wants to extend beyond what is already available to it — to broaden its phenomenological horizons. That way it can explore itself more, learn more about its own state of being. And with each extension of that horizon, it emanates into another state of being, another reality frame, another perspective to have experiences from. That is the nature of reality and that is the nature of ourselves. That’s why we play video games — they are another emanation through which our mind can experience.</p><p>As we evoke metaphysics, we can’t help but notice a pattern in modern day discourse in philosophy of mind. Let’s elaborate.</p><h3>Reality as a Video Game in Modern Metaphysics</h3><p>While physicalism is still the dominant metaphysical position in mainstream philosophy and is a largely adopted framework as an explanation tool within science, recent years have seen the rise of a lot of alternative propositions. The interesting point here is that a lot of them use video games as an analogy for reality. The validity of these positions is not the subject of the essay — some make better arguments than others. Some adopt a very literal interpretation of the “reality is a video game” metaphor, while others treat it simply for what it is — a metaphor.</p><p>Some thinkers take on a very direct and on-the-nose approach to this. For example, in his book Reality+, the great philosopher of “hard problem of consciousness” fame David Chalmers makes the claim that the reality we experience is an actual computer simulation, running on a piece of hardware at the next-level-up of reality, essentially, making the world we live in a meta-reality to another.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/491/1*a9RoAdd_S2QHL4MIe_vnjA.png" /><figcaption>A thumbnail of David Chalmers. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RH5qjdHhtBk">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RH5qjdHhtBk</a></figcaption></figure><p>Another similar case is prof. Donald Hoffman, a cognitive psychologist, who’s claim is that reality works like a video game, perceived by a virtual headset — modeled by evolution to perceive only what is necessary within that virtual reality. Hoffman often gives Rockstar Games’ Grand Theft Auto series as an example.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/494/1*CbAGycl86mM3FVh9nc990w.png" /><figcaption>A thumbnail of prof. Donald Hoffman. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-5Q8kbsrE9o">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-5Q8kbsrE9o</a></figcaption></figure><p>In a similar manner, in his trilogy My Big ToE (Theory of Everything), physicist Thomas Campbell makes the claim that consciousness is all that exists, and perceived reality is a data stream. Additionally, that physical reality is one of many possible realities, much like one of many video games that can be played.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/494/1*Bq97qvw72T5mAzoQ5JFZtA.png" /><figcaption>A thumbnail of Thomas Campbell. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FkRLKPNscDI">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FkRLKPNscDI</a></figcaption></figure><p>Others take a softer approach in their metaphors but have similar conclusions. The philosopher and former CERN scientist Bernardo Kastrup has a framework which is a modern take on metaphysical idealism, proposing that at its roots, reality is consciousness and that what we perceive are, as he puts it, tools on our dashboard of perception. Similar ways of thinking can be found in physicist and groundbreaking tech entrepreneur Federico Faggin’s work. While developments in physics and more specifically interpretations of quantum mechanics also start to appear, pointing in a similar direction — a participatory universe, QBism and other similar movements.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/494/1*74-pa1oIg02dpzELcHPyQQ.png" /><figcaption>A thumbnail of Bernardo Kastrup. Credit: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P-rXm7Uk9Ys">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P-rXm7Uk9Ys</a></figcaption></figure><p>The rise of panpsychism also helps push this discussion forward, as mind becomes an ontological part of every object within reality.</p><p>Regardless of the metaphysical lens through which we choose to look at reality itself, one thing is certain — video games and the implications of their existence are felt in our daily experience.</p><h3>Final Thoughts — The Validity of Gaming Experiences</h3><p>We walked a long walk, exploring the phenomenological possibilities of video game experiences. We went deep into the artistic merit of video games as a medium, we explored what “being” is like within their confines and we even explored how they are an emanation of the player’s essence. With all that being said, one thing is certain — video games open a new, yet completely valid world of possibilities. One of many realities which can be explored. Experiences to be had. And all of them having a strong impact on the player’s mind.</p><p>We’ve seen that a life lived inside a meta-reality can contribute to our own sense of “being”. A broadening of the phenomenological horizon feeds the mind, and it is in mind that our idea of the world forms and unfolds.</p><p>So, as we create memories within these game worlds, as we experience emotions, as we find new parts of ourselves and further explore those we know about, we can always have the certainty that our authentic emotions contribute to what we consider real. All the time spent in those mystical worlds is a time lived, not wasted. And while we must not substitute everyday reality with a meta-reality, we should always find comfort in knowing that we can retreat to an emanation of our own self, in a mystical world, where the possibilities are endless.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><ul><li>Hegel, G.W.F. Aesthetics: Lectures on Fine Art, Volumes I &amp; II. Translated by T.M. Knox. Oxford University Press, 1975</li><li>Heidegger, Martin. Being and Time. Translated by John Macquarrie and Edward Robinson. Harper &amp; Row, 1962</li><li>Heidegger, Martin. The Question Concerning Technology and Other Essays. Translated by William Lovitt. Harper &amp; Row, 1977</li><li>Plotinus. The Enneads. Translated by Stephen MacKenna, revised by B.S. Page. Penguin Classics, 1991</li><li>McGilchrist, Iain. The Master and His Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World. Yale University Press, 2009</li><li>Chalmers, David J. Reality+: Virtual Worlds and the Problems of Philosophy. W.W. Norton &amp; Company, 2022</li><li>Campbell, Thomas. My Big TOE (Trilogy). Lightning Strike Books, 2007.</li><li>Hoffman, Donald D. The Case Against Reality: Why Evolution Hid the Truth from Our Eyes. W.W. Norton &amp; Company, 2019</li><li>Kastrup, Bernardo. The Idea of the World: A Multi-Disciplinary Argument for the Mental Nature of Reality. Iff Books, 2019</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b8486550403b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Critique on Plato’s Account of the Soul in Phaedo]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/a-critique-on-platos-account-of-the-soul-in-phaedo-fa443a6e2aa7?source=rss-977506e56c1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fa443a6e2aa7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[plato]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[soul]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[epistemology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ivan Spasov]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Apr 2025 06:09:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-29T12:29:57.926Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In this essay we’ll investigate Plato’s concept of The Soul as it unfolds in Phaedo.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hNh9GRBHxETt2WZTUlg0RA.jpeg" /><figcaption>A morning photo with some of the books used in the writing of this essay, a cup of strong coffee and a trusty rosary.</figcaption></figure><h3>1. Introduction</h3><p>Plato’s work is quite possibly one of the most influential intellectual endeavors in the history of humankind. It transformed philosophy forever and became the foundation and benchmark for Western philosophical thought.</p><p>In this essay we will analyze a landmark dialogue of Plato — Phaedo, in which he gives his account of the soul. The main setting is Socrates’ last meeting with his friends and peers shortly before his execution. The topics discussed are of a wide variety, as Plato dives into the nature of philosophy and gives a lot of grounds for metaphysical and epistemological analysis. However, the center piece of the dialogue is the soul and its place within the larger reality.</p><p>Within the essay I’ll provide a personal critique of the account of the soul with some constraints in place. Firstly, <strong>we’ll take the existence of a soul as a given</strong>. In this context — any type of a soul, not specifically as defined by Plato. Its existence is a common historical belief leading up to the 4th Century B.C.E. and most pre-Socratic philosophers have a type of soul within their metaphysical system — thus, debunking it as a general concept would be anachronistic and not tackle the topic at hand.</p><p>Secondly, <strong>we’ll only stay within the confines of Plato’s own metaphysics</strong> — is his account of the soul satisfactory within the framework that he himself has set up. Third, I’ll use primarily Phaedo and allow myself to reference only earlier dialogues and only when necessary. I’ll base the order of the dialogues on Leonard Brandwood’s work[5] which places Phaedo in Plato’s middle period. This would exclude later work, like for example Parmenides or Sophist.</p><blockquote>On a sidenote, English is not my mother language and thus my initial acquaintance with Plato comes from a non-English translation. I’ve read the Dialogues in my native language — Bulgarian and my thought process is based on that specific version.[3] In order to use proper citation, I’ll cross-reference my work with “Plato: Complete Works” by Hackett Publishing [2]. To ensure consistency, I’ll be using the Stephanus numbering system[4], which is present in both books. I’ll reference the appropriate numbering to each excerpt I’ve used in my argumentation accordingly.</blockquote><p>With that in mind, the thesis of the essay would be that Plato’s account of the soul is not satisfactory as key attributes ascribed to it are either unproven or carry contradictions. Namely, the true immortality of the soul as well as the attainment of knowledge.</p><h3>2. Plato’s Account of The Soul in Phaedo</h3><p>The dialogue begins as Echecrates and Phaedo talk about the day of Socrates’ execution. Phaedo recalls Socrates’ final meeting with his saddened peers — Cebes, Simmias, Crito and Apollodorus, who are all present. However, Socrates does not share the gloom over his inevitable demise. In one last conversation with them, he tackles the deepest topic there is — that of death, the afterlife, reincarnation, and the soul.</p><p>He makes the case that a <strong>philosopher should not fear death, as it is merely the separation of the soul from the body with the latter being a hindrance at attaining knowledge and truth</strong>. The body provides distractions through senses, emotions, and desires — leading a life not in tune with ultimate truth or wisdom. (<em>Phaedo 63c — 67b</em>)</p><p>Here we first start to get a sense of the <strong>attributes of the soul</strong>. They unfold throughout the dialogue, and we’ll examine the arguments for them in the upcoming section, however it is important to list them out first. As Plato states through the words of Socrates, <strong>the soul is immortal, eternal and indestructible</strong>(<em>Phaedo 78b — 84b</em>); <strong>a key component in the cycle of rebirth</strong> — a part of the Form of Life (<em>Phaedo 70c — 73b; Phaedo 105c — 107b</em>); <strong>the conduit of knowledge</strong> across all planes of existence. (<em>Phaedo 72e — 77a; 80d — 81a; 107c — 115a</em>)</p><p>We must mention that while Plato describes the attributes/characteristics of the soul, he does not explicitly state what it is. Another thing to note is that each attribute of the soul reinforces and is a part of the argumentations for the other. If one is not satisfactory, then the entire picture starts to lose ground. The ones that the essay will focus on in the next section will be the immortality of the soul and its status as a conduit of knowledge.</p><h3>3. Questioning The Immortality of The Soul and Its Attainment of Knowledge</h3><p>While other great thinkers have challenged Plato’s views on the immortality of the soul and the recollection of knowledge, they have mostly done so from their own metaphysical perspective, using their own definitions. One of the most infamous critiques in that regard comes from the great Aristotle. He challenges his former teacher’s views and lays out a different concept on what the soul is. He argues against the foundation of Plato’s idea and instead propose a soul that is a form of the body and just as mortal. Other great thinkers, more notably Thomas Aquinas, Immanuel Kant and Nietzsche, would also challenge Plato’s vision through their own lens.</p><p>In this essay, <strong>we will be looking at the soul only through what there is in the source material</strong>. We will be analyzing Plato’s own framework and based on it, we need to set an important definition.</p><h3>3.1. A Definition of the Soul</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QU7JfaTEqOFbZ3Twegd1jw.png" /><figcaption>An abstract representation of the soul’s journey into the afterlife</figcaption></figure><blockquote><strong><em>The soul is the individuated awareness of each creature</em></strong><em>. It has a governing role in the creature’s actions and participates in the creature’s metaphysical essence. It transcends the mortal self while remaining its underlying principle.</em></blockquote><p>This is an extrapolated vision of the soul that we can clearly see in Plato’s own work. To quote from Phaedo directly (<em>Phaedo 79a — 80b</em>):</p><blockquote>“Haven’t we also said some time ago that when the soul makes use of the body to investigate something, be it through hearing or seeing or some other sense — for to investigate something through the body is to do it through the senses…”.</blockquote><p>Here we see clearly that the soul is what decides to do an investigation (or any action for that matter) and is what processes it as the witness of the sensory data, with the body being a conduit to digest the information. Moving to another quote:</p><blockquote>“Look at it also this way: when the soul and the body are together, nature orders the one to be subject and to be ruled, and the other to rule and be master.”</blockquote><p>This is a definitive statement in support of the previous quote and the definition laid out in the beginning.</p><p>Now, after setting a definition, let’s proceed with our investigation into the possible internal contradictions nested in the soul’s attributes — its immortality and knowledge. We’ll look at self-sufficient criteria for what would constitute immortality. First would be the impossibility of cessation of awareness and secondly would be the simple inability of the soul to accept death, as Plato himself states :</p><blockquote>“Whatever the soul occupies, it always brings life to it … the soul will never admit the opposite of that which it brings along …”</blockquote><h3>3.2. Does the Soul Possess True Immortality?</h3><p><strong>As we’ve seen in the definition of the soul, it is the metaphysical essence of what a creature is, and awareness is its only way of “being”.</strong></p><blockquote><em>“Being” in the strict sense of existing. With no body and no sensory perception, “being” can be defined by the awareness of the soul’s persistence after bodily death.</em></blockquote><p>This is where we must ask the question —<strong> does Plato prove that there is no definitive cessation of awareness of the soul at any point after the death of the body?</strong> It’s a topic that he doesn’t touch on, although he relies on the awareness of the soul for building its entire disembodied experience.</p><blockquote><strong>Phaedo 80d — 83e</strong> describes the life-death-rebirth cycle, where some phenomenology is outlined, however the strongest points of the descriptions relate to the wondering disembodied ghosts and the fate of the morally eroded.</blockquote><blockquote><strong>Phaedo 107c — 109d</strong> describes a map of the afterlife of a sort and goes into a lot of experiential details and the phenomenology of the soul.</blockquote><p>It is obvious that Plato maintains the awareness of the soul, however there is almost nothing in his words that convinces us that it never ceases.</p><p><strong>Let’s do a thought experiment</strong>:</p><blockquote><em>Ariston lives out his days and dies. After Ariston the person dies, his soul goes to the afterlife. We’ll call that soul X. X proceeds through the soul’s journey and returns to life with its reincarnation into Glaucon, so now X is the soul of Glaucon. The awareness of X is what persists both in Ariston and Glaucon — the details are different, but the core awareness is the same. Glaucon does not recall Ariston, though the awareness that sees through their eyes is the same. Knowing that we have the precedent of Ariston dying and Glaucon not knowing of being Ariston, can we really say that X itself never underwent a death-rebirth process in the afterlife? Something that would look like this — Ariston dies, and X moves on. In the afterlife X dies and is reborn as another soul, Y. At that point Y is what is reborn into Glaucon. In that case, we would have a blankness from X to Y, similarly to how we have it from Ariston to Glaucon. If that is the case, true immortality is void as this would be more akin to the process of recycling.</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0f7nSM62LJXCTammdNIK4w.png" /><figcaption>An abstract representation of a rebirth cycle within the afterlife</figcaption></figure><p>Plato could counter with his statement that <strong>the soul participates in the Form of Life and cannot admit its opposite in death</strong>. He crafts a similar tension point between Cebes and Socrates, as Cebes expresses the concern that the soul may eventually wear out and perish (<em>Phaedo 87a — 88b</em>). The reasoning that Socrates provides however may prove unsatisfactory — both for their own argument and for the points we’ve illustrated in previous paragraphs. Let’s investigate the argumentation here.</p><p>Plato states that the soul is more akin to the Forms and in that way differs from the particulars of our day-to-day experience.</p><blockquote>For the essay, I’ll undertake a terminology of universals = Forms, where I’ll be using Forms in their meaning as it pertains to Plato, while I’ll explicitly name the earthly manifestations of these forms as particulars.</blockquote><p>It participates in the Form of Life and is divine in essence, thus is immortal. To look at Plato’s own words:</p><blockquote>Socrates: ”… Then again, which do you think is like the divine and which like the mortal? … Which does the soul resemble?”;</blockquote><blockquote>Cebes: “Obviously, Socrates, the soul resembles the divine, and the body resembles the mortal.”; (Phaedo 80a — 80b)</blockquote><blockquote>Socrates: ”… the Form of life itself, and anything that is deathless, are never destroyed … then the soul, if it is deathless, would also be indestructible …”; (Phaedo 106d — 106c)</blockquote><p>Something to note — <strong>while we can agree that under Plato’s own metaphysics the Form of Life is deathless and indestructible, its particulars are not.</strong></p><p>Much like any particular, a single such belongs to one or more Forms. So, if we look at one (in the case of a living being), for example Ariston from our thought experiment, he is a particular of the Form of Life in so far as he is alive. However, he can perish. This is a clear-cut example of his life ending and thus a particular belonging to the Form of Life admitting the opposite of its own existence in death. Plato could make a counter argument that, as previously stated, the soul is more akin to the Forms than to a particular. However, that argument is unsatisfactory. It is an individuation — all living beings don’t share the exact same soul. It is not a singular, unchanging entity in the sense of the Forms, as we’ve already seen Plato state many times that the soul undergoes change and development. In that sense it is more of a particular. However, even if we do accept his proposition, contrary to our observation, the soul remains on a spectrum of “Form to particular”. <strong>His placement of the soul within that spectrum is not put up to scrutiny and seems arbitrary considering his own line of reasoning.</strong> Additionally, even if we ignore this, particulars of the Form of Life have already been proven to be subjects of reincarnation. <strong>The soul itself could also be a subject of such</strong> and there is nothing within the framework presented by Plato that would hinder it, thus we’re back to the thought experiment of Ariston to X, X to Y and Y to Glaucon.</p><p>Even if the arguments of the previous paragraphs could stand against Plato, he would still have another ace up his sleeve — his epistemology. <strong>Even if the soul would lose awareness and continuity, even be completely recycled to a blank slate, it could still come to remembrance through recollecting previous knowledge</strong> — first in the afterlife and then upon rebirth. However, that argument is still not satisfactory within Plato’s own framework. Additionally, another subject of investigation in this essay is his proposition of knowledge through recollection and we’ll move into it next.</p><h3>3.3. What Does the Soul Actually Know and Remember?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FNu4VXk97IU8ezopBTrkvQ.png" /><figcaption>An abstract representation of the knowledge of the soul</figcaption></figure><p>For Plato, the mechanics of knowledge rely closely on the soul and the reincarnation cycle. <strong>A soul exists in the afterlife where it gets to know the Forms, the thing in itself.</strong> Upon rebirth, the now embodied soul forgets what it has attained in the afterlife. From there, all processes of gaining knowledge become a remembrance of what the soul already knows in the first place. Plato really solidifies this argument in Meno (<em>Meno 81a — 86c</em>), however in Phaedo he outlines it. (<em>Phaedo 73a — 77b</em>)</p><p>In that outline he makes the statement that the ability for recollection proves the soul’s existence before the birth of the individual. <strong>That circles back to our initial argument on immortality</strong>. While Plato does make a good case for a pre-existing soul, he does not make a case for it being a part of a previous rebirth cycle. From our thought experiment — X predates Ariston, but we cannot know if it is the same X in Glaucon as well. That is because the soul forgets in each consecutive cycle of rebirth. We can deepen the investigation.</p><p><strong>When the soul is embodied, it experiences particulars</strong>, which belong to certain Forms. It is that encounter that creates the remembrance of what it has already known. But that leaves an epistemological gap — the knowledge of the particulars. The name of Ariston, where he lives, his friends, the tasks that he must attend to — all of which in unison build the personal identity of what the soul perceives when embodied. They are the building blocks of the egoic self which is what the disembodied soul will be judged on upon entering the afterlife.</p><blockquote><strong>Phaedo 107c — 113c</strong> describes the process of judgement of the soul in the afterlife, which includes statements about the virtue and wiseness of the life lived before death.</blockquote><p><strong>That type of knowledge falls outside of the Forms.</strong> What type it is and why its apparent importance is dismissed is something Plato doesn’t clarify within Phaedo. He only states that true knowledge is found in intelligibility and that sensory perception is deceptive.</p><p><strong>That leaves us with a picture of incomplete epistemology</strong> in a metaphysical system where the soul is the conduit of knowledge with its own fate being decided upon what wisdom it carries.</p><h3>4. Conclusion</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*aDLmNBexWKReOZGNgm8Yxw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Statue of Plato by Edgar Serrano</figcaption></figure><p>Plato is without a doubt one of the greatest philosophers to ever live. He is a cornerstone of western philosophy, and his ideas have been relevant since their inception. The aim of the current essay was never to disparage any of Plato’s work but rather to exercise personal critical thinking. To seek questions within what is provided.</p><p>In the beginning, we’ve outlined some restrictions — looking into the account of the soul in Phaedo and analyzing Plato’s own metaphysics. After that we’ve established what he attributes to the soul as its own characteristics. Then we proceeded to define what the soul is. From there we found potential tension points with its immortality and attainment of knowledge. With everything laid out in Plato’s own words and the parameters I’ve set out for myself; I hope that I’ve been convincing enough to convey what I’ve thought and felt to be unanswered questions within Phaedo. Still, that doesn’t diminish the fact that this is one of Plato’s deepest and most influential works, which will remain as one of metaphysics’ historic pillars.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>1. Платон; Диалози — Том 2; Философско Наследство — Наука и Изкуство, 1982.</p><p>2. Plato; Complete Works; Hackett Publishing, 1997, Edited by John M. Cooper &amp; D.S. Hutchinson</p><p>3. Bertrand, Russell; History of Western Philosophy; Routledge, 1945</p><p>4. Бертранд, Ръсел; История на Западната Философия; Издателска къща „Христо Ботев“, 1994, Том 1</p><p>5. Leonard, Brandwood; The Chronology of Plato’s Dialogues; Cambridge University Press, 1990</p><p>6. Аристотел; За Душата; Съчинения в Шест Тома, Том II, Част IV; Издателство „Захари Стоянов“, 2018</p><p>7. Aristotle; On the Soul (De Anima), Green Lion Press 2001, Translated by Joe Sachs.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fa443a6e2aa7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Anaximander and The Dawn of Philosophy and Science]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/anaximander-and-the-dawn-of-philosophy-and-science-960341d92e5f?source=rss-977506e56c1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/960341d92e5f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ancient-philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pre-socratic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[anaximander]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ivan Spasov]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Mar 2025 08:34:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-07T08:49:20.224Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Anaximander - The Dawn of Philosophy and Science</h3><h3>The Milesian School — The First Scientists and Philosophers</h3><p>Throughout the ages, many have contributed to building Western philosophy and science, from Pythagoras, Plato and Aristotle, through Hume, Descartes and Newton, all the way to Einstein, Popper and Kuhn. But before them, there are the first greats — <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/thales/">Thales</a>, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/anaximander/">Anaximander</a>, and <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/anaximenes/">Anaximenes</a>, all of whom belong to the <a href="https://greekreporter.com/2024/05/19/ancient-greece-milesian-school/">Milesian school of thought</a> (6th Century BCE). Miletus is the birthplace of what we’ve come to know as philosophy and science. A vibrant city where different cultures would thrive and exchange ideas. What did it feel like to live there and how did it help usher in a new era of thinking? Let’s investigate.</p><h4>History and Culture of Miletus</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*SluweptzBjn4notZMaAvYg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Original image by Kenneth Fairfax</figcaption></figure><p>Miletus is an ancient Greek city that to this day carries the memory of cultural diversity and free thinking. Located in modern day Turkey, on the western coast of Anatolia, Miletus is the perfect state to cross-pollinate ideas. Being on the trade-crossroads between multiple cultures, including Persian and Lydian, the Greek state had started to develop an identity of its own as an intellectual center. As Herodotus states — “Miletus was a significant power in maritime commerce and established over 80 colonies, primarily along the shores of the Black Sea. Its traders and sailors not only brought wealth but also ideas from diverse cultures.” [<a href="#Bibliography">1</a>]. It is in Miletus that Thales, Anaximander, and Anaximenes would develop the first steps in philosophy and science.</p><h4>From Mythology to Philosophical and Scientific Thought</h4><p>For the ancient man, be it of Greek, Egyptian, Persian or any origin, the world is a mythical place, driven by mystical forces. The cosmos and the sky are the domains of all-powerful Gods using the elements as their tools. Mighty beings of divine origins play chess with the world and bend all of reality to their will. That was all people knew — myths and mythology, handed down from one person to the other. And while poets like Homer give the Gods of Olympus more human-like traits, questioning the all-powerful beings that rule over the world was not something a one could do. That is, until the Milesian school starts to put these fundamental beliefs into doubt, developing the concepts of a natural world instead of a mythological one.</p><p>Starting with Thales but also true for the entirety of Milesian thought, they define the <a href="https://www.rep.routledge.com/articles/thematic/arche/v-1">archē </a>— one natural substance which is the ontological origin of the world. In a sense, they are the first <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/monism/">monists</a>, claiming that all of reality is derived from a single substrate or a concept. For each of the big three thinkers, the substance is different. For Thales it is water, for Anaximander it is the apeiron, which we’ll investigate further in an upcoming chapter and for Anaximenes — air. They derive their ontology through rational inquiry and not through belief or mythology. They think rationally and make speculations based on what they observe in the world. They see patterns and patterns of patterns, all of which help them to build a conviction of a natural world. As the great German idealist <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hegel/">G.W.F. Hegel states</a> :</p><blockquote>“The Milesians were the first to elevate thought from the sensuous into the universal. Thales, Anaximander, and Anaximenes sought to explain the cosmos through principles derived from nature itself, thus breaking away from the mythological interpretations of earlier traditions.”[<a href="#Bibliography">2</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">3</a>]</blockquote><p>Another reaffirming quote can be found in “History of Western Philosophy” by the great <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/russell/">Bertrand Russell</a> :</p><blockquote>“Thales is considered by many as the first philosopher and the founder of Western science because he sought to explain natural occurrences by natural means. His bold hypothesis that ‘everything is water’ reflects an early form of material monism, which would become a central theme in Greek philosophy.” [<a href="#Bibliography">4</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">5</a>]</blockquote><p>This is precisely the spirit of philosophy and science — questioning dogmas, investigating everything, putting established facts into doubt when they don’t seem convincing.</p><h4>Thales, Anaximander and Anaximenes</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/460/1*HYl513KZGijYwpmqiGBMZQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Thales of Miletus (c. 620 — c. 546 BCE)</figcaption></figure><p>Thales of Miletus (c. 620 — c. 546 BCE) [<a href="#Bibliography">6</a>] is the first of this revolutionary way of thinking and the one to make the major step forward from the old ways of mythology. He is the first one to define his archē, his ontological primitive/principal as something naturalistic, namely — water, where everything originates from it. His way of viewing the Earth is quite interesting as he proposes that it is floating in water. He also makes a significant push in geometry by not only introducing principles adopted in Egypt but developing his own theorems, the first stating that “<em>The diameter of a circle always subtends a right angle to any point on the circle” [</em><a href="#Bibliography"><em>7</em></a><em>] and the second being known as the Intercept theorem, providing “the ratios between the line segments created when two parallel lines are intercepted by two intersecting lines</em>.” [<a href="#Bibliography">8</a>] Known for his travels across the many lands and cultures Miletus has access to, one can see how Thales’ world view is shaped. And that world view, along with his own travels, shapes the ideas of another.</p><p>Anaximander of Miletus (c. 610 — c.546 BCE) [<a href="#Bibliography">9</a>] will be the subject of the entire second chapter of this essay but it would only make sense to include him here as well. For Anaximander, the ontological primitive of reality, his archē, is the apeiron. He defines it as boundless and unlimited, something that cannot be experienced. This is a step beyond Thales, as Anaximander states that at their core, even the elements have their genesis through the apeiron.</p><p>Anaximander has many other ideas that could rightfully give him the title as one of the first scientists — from his view on Earth floating freely in space, through his proto-evolutionary biology, all the way to his cosmology and many parts in between. All of that and more will be discussed in the next chapter. But now let us shift focus to the last of the three Milesian greats.</p><p>Anaximenes (? — c.528 BCE) [<a href="#Bibliography">10</a>] is without a doubt one of the greatest thinkers of his time. Much like Thales and Anaximander, he is interested in the origin of reality and his archē, much like Thales’ is one of the elements, but instead of water, he proposes air. Anaximenes sees air as the building block that through change gives us all the other elements, such as fire and water. It is in that same thought pattern that we can look at as the cornerstone of Anaximenes’ philosophy — that of eternal change.</p><p>The pattern of the shift from mythology to philosophy and science is clear in all three but one of them embodies it in ways that can astound even modern day thinkers.</p><h3>Anaximander and Scientific Thinking</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*iYcWyP6a-lEW9XYZRKKBgg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Anaximander as imagined by Pietro Bellotti around 1700, found in this publication — <a href="https://snl.no/Anaximander">https://snl.no/Anaximander</a></figcaption></figure><p>As discussed earlier, Anaximander is a true paragon of the ideas of the Miletus school of thought. His work arguably gives start to the study of metaphysics, proto-evolutionary biology, complex cosmology and ingenuity through empirical discoveries. To better understand this, we must start with Anaximander’s archē, his ontological primitive — the apeiron.</p><h4>The Apeiron — The Boundless, The Unlimited, The Infinite</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qbt_k4rCvE5TTgWSzyU_0A.png" /></figure><p>At the heart of Anaximander’s philosophical and scientific thinking is the apeiron, that of which all comes to be. The one that gives birth to all, the substance through which everything else comes into existence. According to Anaximander, The Apeiron is infinite and boundless, it is eternal and cyclical. It has no origin and no end. It is in eternal motion while itself remains unchanged. A boundless unyielding concept at the heart of cycles of creation and destruction. It is both at the root of and governs all of existence. [<a href="#Bibliography">9</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">12</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">13</a>] One of the most interesting aspects of how it works is in the origin of the balance of opposites, which is at the root of The Apeiron but is also a big part of Anaximander’s entire system of natural laws. The boundless balances opposites, and it is through that balance that worlds and phenomena are created and then destroyed in the infinite cycle that is perpetuated through The Apeiron.</p><p>An interesting thing to note here is that this cyclical opposition also encompasses the elements and their properties and while they are a strong foundation for the Milesian school (Thales’ archē is water, Anaximenes’ is air), Anaximander sees something that pushes the boundary of his scientific thinking. The elements are composites and finite. They are made of other things; they interplay with each other. As <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle/">Aristotle</a> himself notes in his Physics :</p><blockquote>“Anaximander observed that the elements are in opposition to one another, and if one were infinite, it would destroy the others.” [<a href="#Bibliography">11</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">12</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">13</a>]</blockquote><p>Anaximander lays out a view in which The Apeiron is something that cannot be experienced directly by the senses but is seen through the way its laws mold the world. To quote Aristotle further:</p><blockquote>“Some make the infinite the underlying substance, such as Anaximander and his followers, and they hold that the source of existing things is that which embraces all things and steers all.” [<a href="#Bibliography">11</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">12</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">13</a>]</blockquote><p>This is a radical departure from his contemporaries in more ways than one. As the great physicist and thinker Carlo Rovelli points out in his book on Anaximander, he was one of the first to not only challenge the mythological origins of the cosmos but also challenge thinkers who were pivotal for his own way of thinking, in this case — Thales. [<a href="#Bibliography">14</a>] And while Anaximander does not attack his views, this was one of the first times where scholarly critique and critical thinking were pushed to the forefront oh the emerging scenes of philosophy and science. It is with all of this in mind that we must look at another revolutionary trail of though that he had — Anaximander’s cosmology.</p><h4>Cosmology and Astronomy — A New Look</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1019/1*qXJ0p0MgtmJQLpz8f_Zd-w.jpeg" /></figure><p>Before Anaximander, in the days of mythology, the Earth was always seen as something that is supported in space. Even Thales proposes that it is supported by the water it floats on. However, Anaximander makes a big leap with his way of thinking and brings to light one of the most important points to come out of the Milesian school. Namely, that the earth is not supported by something, nor is it surrounded by water — it is floating freely in space with nothing to aid it. It is his brilliant cosmological picture that provides the logic for why this is happening. In it, the Earth has a cylindrical form and is surrounded by the celestial bodies, which orbit around it. Their orbits are concentric circles all of which have fixed (although considered by many to be arbitrary) radial offsets with Earth being the center. Days shifting into nights, seasons shifting into other seasons, all of these are the motions that circulate through these offsets. [<a href="#Bibliography">9</a>] And here is probably the most interesting part — this cosmological picture told Anaximander the important truth, namely that Earth is floating free in space. He would say that due to these concentric circular offsets of the celestial bodies, the planet is in perfect equilibrium so there is no reason for it to be a part of any cosmic motion. It is in a position of indifference. To quote <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle/">Aristotle</a>:</p><blockquote>“Anaximander says that the Earth stays where it is because of its indifference; there is no reason for it to move in one direction rather than another, since it is equally related to all points.” [<a href="#Bibliography">11</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">12</a>]</blockquote><p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlo_Rovelli">Carlo Rovelli</a> points to the significance of Anaximander’s findings, stating that even though his reasoning or empirical evidence are not what we’ve come to know since, this was truly the most difficult leap into cosmology to be made, especially at that time. [<a href="#Bibliography">14</a>] One must question everything they know about reality and put it under the most intense scrutiny to get to where Anaximander got.</p><p>Now, to look at another one of his achievements — developing a conceptual idea of what we could consider proto-evolutionary biology.</p><h4>Proto-Evolutionary Biology</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/728/1*8LO4GPDsCRrLkoq2Lz4QXA.jpeg" /></figure><p>To understand the significance of Anaximander’s thoughts, we need to once again take a step back. In the days of old, the creation of life and more specifically humans, was something attributed to the Gods or at the very least to godly processes. The fish was created a fish, the dog was created a dog, and a human was created a human. This has been so ingrained into the world view at the time that questioning it was unthinkable. This is where Anaximander’s proto-evolutionary theory comes in.</p><p>He describes life as something that originated in a moist environment at an earlier stage of the lifecycle of the Earth. As water and earth started to mix and dry under the influence of the sun, life is born. From there, life evolves into more complex forms. Initially he describes the first living beings as being enclosed in thorny barks and as they move away from moist to dry, they break away from the bark, they survive for a short while. [<a href="#Bibliography">15</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">16</a>] From there he posits the existence of fish and fish-like creatures. It is from them that humans evolved. To quote <a href="https://oxfordre.com/classics/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780199381135.001.0001/acrefore-9780199381135-e-1464?p=emailAEwBXEd8iOuDA&amp;d=/10.1093/acrefore/9780199381135.001.0001/acrefore-9780199381135-e-1464">Censorinus</a>:</p><blockquote>“He declares that humans were originally born from animals of different kinds because other animals quickly manage on their own, but humans alone require lengthy nursing. For this reason, they would not have survived if they had been like this in the beginning.” [<a href="#Bibliography">15</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">16</a>]</blockquote><p>The process of birth of life as well as any evolutionary conditions are an entirely natural process, completely independent of the activity of a deity. As Hippolytus would clarify :</p><blockquote>“He says that originally, when the Earth was moist, the warm elements acted upon the moist, and living creatures were generated.” [<a href="#Bibliography">17</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">18</a>]</blockquote><p>It is truly astounding to see the depth of thought that Anaximander puts into his work and even though we’ve investigated a lot of the bigger concepts, he is known for contributing to other scientific and philosophical discoveries.</p><h4>Further Innovations</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/512/1*P_bti4H9KvxHT-8aQWnHWw.jpeg" /><figcaption>A world map as imagined by Anaximander, Hecateos and Aristagoras. Credit: National Museum of Krakow</figcaption></figure><p>Anaximander is credited by Strabo for creating one of the earliest maps of what was then perceived as the world — “He was the first to draw the outline of land and sea, and he made a map of the entire world that was known to him.” [<a href="#Bibliography">19</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">20</a>] With that he would lay the groundwork for future generations of cartographers that would make even more precise and accurate representations of the world. Another great achievement of Anaximander is the introduction of the gnomon with which time could be measured, solstices and equinoxes determined as well as celestial events. [<a href="#Bibliography">16</a>] Through his overall philosophical and scientific world view, he also offered natural explanations to thunder, lightning, the formation of rain a basic model of the atmosphere and earthquakes. [<a href="#Bibliography">11</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">12</a>]</p><h3>From Ancient to Modern Times</h3><p>After looking at the Milesian school of thought and focusing on Anaximander, we can see a clear pattern of building the base of what we would come to consider philosophy and science. Although in its infancy at the time, the steps Thales, Anaximander, and Anaximenes take are huge and groundbreaking. Their influence is felt throughout the ages — from other early thinkers like Plato, and Aristotle, through historical figures like Isaac Newton and Immanuel Kant, leading into modern day philosophers and scientists like Albert Einstein and Thomas Kuhn. Bertrand Russel acknowledges :</p><blockquote>“Anaximander, a pupil of Thales, was a bold and speculative thinker who introduced the conception of the indefinite or infinite as the origin of all things.” [<a href="#Bibliography">4</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">5</a>]</blockquote><p>Karl Popper would state:</p><blockquote>“With Anaximander, the critical tradition begins; he was perhaps the earliest philosopher to criticize his teacher.” [<a href="#Bibliography">21</a>][<a href="#Bibliography">22</a>]</blockquote><p>With all of this it becomes apparent — the Milesian school has shaped the world as it is today and will be forever remembered for their bold steps into laying out the future that is our present.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>1. Herodotus, The Histories, Penguin Classics 1996</p><p>2. G.W.F., Hegel, Lectures on the History of Philosophy, University of Nebraska Press, 1995, vol. 1</p><p>3. Г.В.Ф., Хегел, История на Философията, Издателство Българска Комунистическа Партия, 1961, Том 1</p><p>4. Bertrand, Russell, History of Western Philosophy, Routledge, 1945</p><p>5. Бертранд, Ръсел, История на Западната Философия, Издателска къща „Христо Ботев“, 1994, Том 1</p><p>6. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Thales of Miletus, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/thales/">https://iep.utm.edu/thales/</a></p><p>7. Math Open Reference, Thales’ Theorem, <a href="https://www.mathopenref.com/thalestheorem.html">https://www.mathopenref.com/thalestheorem.html</a></p><p>8. Geometry Help, Intercept Theorem, <a href="https://geometryhelp.net/intercept-theorem/">https://geometryhelp.net/intercept-theorem/</a></p><p>9. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Anaximander, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/anaximander/">https://iep.utm.edu/anaximander/</a></p><p>10. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Anaximenes, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/anaximenes/">https://iep.utm.edu/anaximenes/</a></p><p>11. Aristotle, The Complete Works of Aristotle, Princeton University Press, 1984</p><p>12. Аристотел, Съчинения в Шест Тома, Издателство „Захарий Стоянов“, 2012, Том II, Част I, Физика</p><p>13. Аристотел, Метафизика, Университетско Издателство „Св. Климент Охридски“, 2023</p><p>14. Carlo Rovelli, Marion Lignana Rosenberg, Anaximander and The Nature of Science, Penguin, Penguin Audio, 2023, Read by Roy McMillan</p><p>15. K. Freeman, Ancilla to the Pre-Socratic Philosophers, MA: Harvard University Press, 1983</p><p>16. Диоген Лареций, Животът на Философите, Народна Култура София, 1985, Допълнение от Тодор Томов</p><p>17. H. Diels, W. Kranz, Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker 6th Edition, Berlin: Weidmann; 1951.</p><p>18. H. Diels, W. Kranz, Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker 6th Edition, Berlin: Weidmann; 1951, Refutation of All Heresies, Translation by several hands, Internet Archive, archive.org</p><p>19. Strabo, Geographica, The Geography of Strabo, Harvard University Press, 1917</p><p>20. Страбон, География, Поредица Антични Автори Към Изворите за Тракия и Траките, Книги I-V, Книги IX — XI, Рал-Колобър, 2006, Допълнение Валерий Русинов</p><p>21. Karl Popper, Conjectures and Refutations: The Growth of Scientific Knowledge, Routledge, 2002</p><p>22. Карл Попър, Целия Живот е Решаване на Проблеми, Калъс &amp; Космополит София, 2005</p><p>23. Страбон, География, Поредица Антични Автори Към Изворите за Тракия и Траките, Книги I-V, Книги IX — XI, Рал-Колобър, 2006, Допълнение Валерий Русинов</p><p>24. Страбон, География, Поредица Антични Автори Към Изворите за Тракия и Траките, Книги I-V, Книги IX — XI, Рал-Колобър, 2006, Допълнение Валерий Русинов</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=960341d92e5f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Conceptual Monism in Pre-Socratic Philosophy: Heraclitus and Parmenides]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@ivan.ognqnov/conceptual-monism-in-pre-socratic-philosophy-heraclitus-and-parmenides-44968563f80d?source=rss-977506e56c1b------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/44968563f80d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metaphysics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[monism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parmênides]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[heraclitus]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Ivan Spasov]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Mar 2025 06:58:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-07T06:58:36.521Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>How completely opposite ideas of reality lead to similar conclusions of unity in conceptual monism</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*yMUG2cUseJqarSYFtc72ow.png" /></figure><h3>Introduction</h3><p>The development of a <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/monism/">monistic</a> metaphysical framework is one of the biggest undertakings a philosopher can set upon. Starting off with substance monism and the <a href="https://www.encyclopedia.com/humanities/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/arche">arche</a>, the concept evolves with each coming of the tide, each epoch. Moving from <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/thales/">Thales</a> to <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/index.html">Plato</a>, from <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/index.html">Plato</a> to <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/spinoza/">Spinoza</a> and <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/hegel/">Hegel</a>, going as deep as <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/heidegger/">Heidegger</a> and <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/whitehead/">Whitehead</a>, who would propose distinct types of <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/monism/">monism</a> altogether. Contemporary thinkers like <a href="https://www.bernardokastrup.com/">Bernardo Kastrup</a> and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_Goff_(philosopher)">Philip Goff</a> still explore substance monism. For the context of this essay, we will be using a broad definition of monism, as in the position that at the most fundamental level of reality there is a single principle, concept or substance that unifies all of existence [1][2] [8].</p><p>Now, to understand how monism became such a powerful framework in philosophy, we will need to go back in time and look at two of history’s greatest thinkers. <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/heraclit/">Heraclitus</a> and <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/parmenid/">Parmenides</a> — the eternal flux of change and the unbending, never-changing stillness of being. Two radically opposing views, who reach a unity through conceptual monism and forge the base on which future thinkers would stand. Let us look at how history unfolds and what would lead to Heraclitus and Parmenides.</p><h3>Monistic Views in Pre-Socratic Philosophy</h3><p>The monistic way of thinking is as old as western philosophy itself, and it starts as early as the pioneers of pre-Socratic thought with the <a href="https://greekreporter.com/2024/05/19/ancient-greece-milesian-school/">Milesian school</a> (around the sixth century BC) in <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/thales/">Thales</a>, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/anaximander/">Anaximander</a>, and <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/anaximenes/">Anaximenes</a>. They make the first bold leap in going from a mythological explanation of reality into a naturalistic one [1][2][3][4]. They think about the <a href="https://www.encyclopedia.com/humanities/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/arche">arche </a>— an ontological primitive through which reality takes shape. For Thales, the arche is water [5], for Anaximander — the apeiron [6], for Anaximenes — fire [7], a substance that is at the root of reality. This would lay the groundwork for what monism is — a single thing at the ground of being from which all emerges.</p><p>Many great thinkers of the pre-Socratic period would push the boundaries of what we would view as monism. The great <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pythagoras/">Pythagoras</a> would say that reality is underpinned by numerical relationships, stating that the <a href="https://www.britannica.com/topic/ontology-metaphysics">ontological</a> primitive and unifying principle of existence is the abstract, mystical and metaphysical nature of mathematics [3][4][9]. <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anaxagoras/">Anaxagoras</a> would venture even further into the abstract, as for him at the root of reality stands The Nous — a singular, universal, organizing intelligence that governs all of existence. Anaxagoras does not define it as the creator but rather the organizer of what already exists and that is exactly what could classify this metaphysical proposition as monistic [3][4][10]. <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/democritus/">Democritus</a> would uplift and refine <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/leucippus/">Leucippus</a>’ work into one of the most well-known ancient monistic theories with the atomism [3][4][11].</p><p>However, the focus of the current essay will be on two completely opposite metaphysical frameworks. These two radically different world views belong to two of the greatest thinkers to ever live — Heraclitus and Parmenides. Becoming and being, ever-changing and unchanging. We will explore each of their metaphysical propositions individually and look at how their principles lead to a framework of conceptual monism.</p><h3>Heraclitus — A Reality in Flux</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qbt_k4rCvE5TTgWSzyU_0A.png" /></figure><p><a href="https://iep.utm.edu/heraclit/">Heraclitus</a> (sixth century BCE) is one of the most influential pre-Socratic thinkers [12]. At the heart of his philosophy stands the ever-changing, the flux, the flow of opposites. He sees reality in motion and in constant transition from one state into another, which gives way to a unity derived by change. He would say that “<em>All things are one</em>”(DK 22B50 [14]) and would maintain that plurality and multiplicity are just in appearance. They are in that ever-changing state of flux, through which unity is achieved.</p><p>Heraclitus’ own words can help us gain understanding</p><blockquote>“This world-order, the same for all, no god or man has made, but it always was and is and shall be an ever-living fire, kindling in measures and going out in measures.”</blockquote><blockquote>(DK B30 [14])</blockquote><p>An important part of Heraclitus’ ontology is what some might consider his <a href="https://www.britannica.com/topic/ontology-metaphysics">ontological</a> primitive — fire. However, in this context fire should be treated as a metaphor for the flux and the ever-changing nature of reality. In a sense, a metaphorical name for the organizing principle found at his ontological roots. Let’s look at some of Heraclitus’ fragments.</p><blockquote>“All things are an exchange for fire, and fire for all things, as goods for gold and gold for goods.”</blockquote><blockquote>“A man in the night kindles a light for himself when his sight is extinguished; living, he touches the dead in his sleep; waking, he touches the sleeper.”</blockquote><blockquote>(DK B90 [14])</blockquote><p>Almost stating it directly in the first quote, Heraclitus points us even deeper into this line of thought in the second as he points out that the kindling of the light and flame of life is as much a part of the cycle of unity as the extinguishing of the kindling, leading into another layer of the never-ending process of oneness under change.</p><p>As seen in the previous paragraphs, Heraclitus proposes a monism in process, not a substance. The process of eternal becoming, steeped in flame, and recognized by The Logos, leading into oneness. The senses give us the ability to observe reality as it changes, while The Logos governs the organization of change. Our experience is the stage onto which reality is presented, and The Logos sets up what would unfold on that stage.</p><p>Heraclitus could be seen as the one to lead into the development of the philosophies of becoming, relation, and even process philosophy. Future greats like Hegel would go as far as to say [1][2].:</p><blockquote>“There is no proposition of Heraclitus which I have not adopted in my Logic.”</blockquote><p>Alfred North Whitehead would point out the influence of Heraclitus on his work as well, saying [15]:</p><blockquote>“The doctrine of Heraclitus is the best example of an adequate metaphysics. The flux of things is one ultimate generalization around which we must weave our philosophical system.”</blockquote><p>In true form, fitting for Heraclitus, his world view would have an opposite. It is that of his contemporary — the philosophical juggernaut that is Parmenides.</p><h3>Parmenides — Unchanging Being</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*JW08dj15ew_vWuK6_k34cQ.png" /></figure><p><a href="https://iep.utm.edu/parmenid/">Parmenides</a> (sixth century BCE) proposes something very radical, namely that there is only “<em>being</em>” with “<em>becoming</em>” presenting only as an illusion. Within that “being,”, there is no separation and everything is one. It is eternal, unchanging, and whole [3][4][16]. Parmenides comes to these conclusions solely based on reasoning, making him the first philosopher to propose a completely rationalistic system of metaphysics. And as he would state in his work “On Nature”, rationalism is the only way to truly know reality.</p><p>To engage with Parmenides’ ideas, firstly we need to look at the very foundation of his metaphysics, namely — the concept of “being”. In his own words, he would say :</p><blockquote>“It is necessary to say and to think that Being is: for it is possible that Being is, and it is impossible for nothing to be.”(DK 28B6 [14])</blockquote><p>Many philosophers have simplified this argument to “<em>Being Is, and Non-Being Is Not</em>”. “Being” in that sense is all that exists, eternal and unending. If it were to end, then it would become “<em>non-being</em>” and by the definition of his argument, the two opposites cannot co-exist, therefore only “being” exists. But he goes a step further and would argue that reality is also unchanging and eternal. To quote:</p><blockquote>“What is cannot not be; it is complete, immovable, and without end.”(DK 28B8 [14]); “For how could what is thereafter perish? And how could it have come to be? If it came into being, it is not, nor if it is ever about to be.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Never shall this prevail, that things that are not are. Restrain your thought from this way of inquiry.”</blockquote><blockquote>(DK 28B6 [14])</blockquote><p>To Parmenides, concepts such as changing states are incompatible with “being”. Everything is static and unchanging. He makes another argument here that would be a strong pillar of his way of thought — “being” as one whole, as a monistic concept of the ground of reality. To quote Parmenides:</p><blockquote>“Being is undivided, for it is all alike; no part of it is more here or less there.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Nor was it ever, nor will it be, since now it is, all at once, a continuous one.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Being is, and there is nothing beyond it that could prevent it from holding together or breaking apart.”; “It is not dispersed here and there throughout the cosmos, nor is it compounded from many things; but Being is full of itself, indivisible.”</blockquote><blockquote>(DK 28B6 [14])</blockquote><p>All of Parmenides’ words here bare testament that he sees reality as a singular whole, a non-divisible oneness that is all-encompassing. Any parts or boundaries that may be distinguished are only an illusion in perception. This conceptual monism, much like Heraclitus, goes beyond any substance — it is at the core of what it means to “be”.</p><p>To further supplement the point about the illusory nature of change in perception and to elaborate on true knowledge being accessible only through intelligibility, we can again refer to Parmenides’ work directly:</p><blockquote>“The opinions of mortals consist of naming things wrongly, ascribing birth and death to things that cannot truly exist.”(DK 28B19 [14])</blockquote><blockquote>“It is the same thing to think and to be.”(DK 28B3 [14])</blockquote><blockquote>“Do not let habit, born from experience, compel you to travel along this path, to direct your sightless eyes, your echoing ears, and your tongue; rather, judge by reason the challenging proof I have laid before you.”(DK 28B7 [14])</blockquote><p>Parmenides goes as far as to outright state that habit in erroneous thought is born through the reliance on the senses — sight, hearing, taste. His statement is clear — being and thinking are the same and true perception of reality is the one that resides in the rational mind.</p><h3>Monism in Unity — Polar Opposites Converge</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4FKMzL7_JDvyg2DrTeBv5g.png" /></figure><p>An interesting thing to note is that although Heraclitus and Parmenides may have a completely different approach in their systems, they converge in a similar place. A conceptual monism in unity across all of reality. Everything is one, there is no stand-alone existence.</p><p>While the core of their respective philosophies shows immense differences, there are more similarities than one can find at first glance. One such thing is the importance they place on mind. We’ve seen how much emphasis Parmenides puts on this within his thought process but to really grasp where we have a convergence with Heraclitus, we need to look at how Heraclitus himself thinks about The Logos:</p><blockquote>“This Logos is always so, yet men fail to comprehend it, both before they have heard it and once they have heard it. Although all things happen according to this Logos, they are like inexperienced men when they experience words and deeds such as I set forth, distinguishing each thing according to its nature and showing how it is. But other men fail to notice what they do when awake, just as they forget what they do when asleep.”</blockquote><blockquote>(DK 22B1 [14])</blockquote><p>As we can clearly see, human beings cannot reach ultimate truths without knowing The Logos, which as discussed previously is the organizing principle behind reality in Heraclitus’ system. And although he treats the senses as the primary source for knowing our immediate world, The Logos as a form of mind is what organizes reality. It is a structure of thought and intelligence, governing the universe. Parmenides does not have a similar concept; however, he does see thought and rationality within one’s own mind as a shining light onto ultimate reality.</p><p>Another point of convergence for both thinkers is eternity as the horizon onto which their ontology projects. For Heraclitus it is eternal change — opposing states interchange in a never-ending dance, always flowing from one place to the next. For Parmenides it is eternal “being” — nothing ever changes, and there is no time to speak of. There is only the still and unchanging eternity of “being”. While the ontology is admittedly different, in both cases it stretches out into infinitude with eternity being the final frontier.</p><p>We can look at another point of convergence, which answers one of the most profound questions a human can ask — that of death. Both Heraclitus and Parmenides deny the permanence of death as an eternal end, however as with everything else, their methodology is completely different. For Heraclitus, death is not the end but the opposition of life. Death will be superseded by life as all reality is in flux. Then death will set in again, but it will never be final and absolute. For Parmenides, death is simply an illusion — there is only “being”, and where there is “being”, there cannot be death as it is “non-being”.</p><p>All these convergences and the entirety of their systems leads us to the inevitable realization that even though they walk completely opposite paths, Heraclitus and Parmenides reach a similar conclusion — the ontological status of their metaphysical ideas. And for both, that is a monism in conceptual unity.</p><h3>Heraclitus And Parmenides’ Impact on Philosophy</h3><p>The propositions that Heraclitus and Parmenides push forward resonate throughout philosophy even to this day. At the turn of their own philosophical epoch, the stage would be set for one of the greatest thinkers in human history — one that would combine the flux of becoming with monolithic being into the most prolific system philosophy has seen. That man is Plato. He would have a tough time reconciling the two opposite views and he would see validity in their argumentations. In his developed thoughts, Heraclitus’ reality of flux and change finds its place in what would be called “the realm of becoming” which is fluctuating, perceived through the senses and is the every-day world we experience. Parmenides’ work would be incorporated into what would be called “the realm of being” also known as “<a href="https://www.thecollector.com/what-is-plato-theory-of-forms/">the world of Forms</a>” and it is eternal, unchanging and only accessible through intelligibility. He would even have his own dialogue in which Plato discusses primarily the problem of “the one and the many” [17][18].</p><p>Many philosophers would be influenced by Plato and indirectly by Heraclitus and Parmenides, but even more would drink directly from the source and expand on these profound topics as set forth by two of philosophy’s pre-Socratic pillars.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>The pre-Socratic philosophers have paved the way for Plato and Aristotle, who would lay the groundwork for what we would come to understand as Western philosophy. Their search for a naturalistic and rational explanation of reality has given humanity some of the most profound insights imaginable. In that pursuit, seeking metaphysical truth and the ground of all being proves to be the toughest. And among all who have tackled this particularly challenging task, none have been as polarizing yet as compelling as Heraclitus and Parmenides. They would push the boundary of conception and elevate the enlightening conclusion, that at its very root — everything lies in unity, and all can be seen as oneness. They make a case for complex conceptual monism, which yields the greatest gift of all — realizing that we are one with the very fabric of the universe.</p><h3>Bibliography</h3><p>1. G.W.F., Hegel; Lectures on the History of Philosophy; University of Nebraska Press, 1995, vol. 1</p><p>2. Г.В.Ф., Хегел; История на Философията; Издателство Българска Комунистическа Партия, 1961, Том 1</p><p>3. Bertrand, Russell; History of Western Philosophy; Routledge, 1945</p><p>4. Бертранд, Ръсел; История на Западната Философия; Издателска къща „Христо Ботев“, 1994, Том 1</p><p>5. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Thales of Miletus, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/thales/">https://iep.utm.edu/thales/</a></p><p>6. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Anaximander, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/anaximander/">https://iep.utm.edu/anaximander/</a></p><p>7. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Anaximenes, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/anaximenes/">https://iep.utm.edu/anaximenes/</a></p><p>8. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Monism, <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/monism/">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/monism/</a></p><p>9. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Pythagoras, <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pythagoras/">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pythagoras/</a></p><p>10. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Anaxagoras, <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anaxagoras/">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/anaxagoras/</a></p><p>11. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Democritus, <a href="https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/democritus/">https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/democritus/</a></p><p>12. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Heraclitus, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/heraclit/">https://iep.utm.edu/heraclit/</a></p><p>13. The Collector; Heraclitus of Ephesus: The Philosopher of Change, <a href="https://www.thecollector.com/greek-philosopher-heraclitus-ephesus-quotes/">https://www.thecollector.com/greek-philosopher-heraclitus-ephesus-quotes/</a></p><p>14. G.S., Kirk and J E., Raven; The Presocratic Philosophers; Cambridge University Press, 1957;</p><p>15. Alfred North Whitehead; Process and Reality; Free Press, 1978</p><p>16. Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy; Parmenides, <a href="https://iep.utm.edu/parmenid/">https://iep.utm.edu/parmenid/</a></p><p>17. Plato; Complete Works; Hackett Publishing, 1997, Edited by John M. Cooper &amp; D.S. Hutchinson</p><p>Платон; Диалози — Том 4, Философско Наследство — Наука и Изкуство, 1990г.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=44968563f80d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>