<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jacob Young on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jacob Young on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jacobyoung84?source=rss-e5b8533d9732------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 08:41:55 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jacobyoung84/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A malaise of pastoral sadness]]></title>
            <link>https://jacobyoung84.medium.com/a-malaise-of-pastoral-sadness-6053bbf9d0f?source=rss-e5b8533d9732------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6053bbf9d0f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sovereign-grace-churches]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[depression]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jesus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pastoral-ministry]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jacob Young]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 Jul 2021 17:49:10 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-01T11:49:40.192Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BmpMGtzIIzFjubWSysWTtg.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://unsplash.com/@pueblovista">https://unsplash.com/@pueblovista</a></figcaption></figure><p>A friend of mine, another pastor in our city, asked me recently: So, how’s your mental health?</p><p>His question came in the middle of reading an article about the dynamics of Simon Biles’ recent decision to step out of a couple events at the Olympics. We share office space together, and so we’ll frequently have conversations about whatever is in the news. I was struck by his question because as a pastor, I hardly ever get asked about my own mental health. I am asked to care for others amidst their struggles with mental health, but rarely (if ever) am I asked a pointed question about the inner health of my mind.</p><p>And within that question lies a great deal of sadness.</p><p>In the last couple years, I have lost a significant number of friendships. After <a href="https://link.medium.com/regobn4Ykib">growing concerns</a> about how Sovereign Grace Churches’ leadership was handling (and spinning) the narrative around how their pastors handle reports of abuse, we were simultaneously invited to leave the denomination by senior leadership and then levied with a significant financial charge for our departure on the way out. In the wake of those events from 2 years ago, it’s become bitterly clear that 12 years of relationships were destroyed. The machine of a narcissistic organization cannot tolerate diversity, but it also cannot imagine meaningful relationships built on something other than its own collective ego. Friendships will never survive in these organizations because “partnership” only thrives where conditional loyalty reigns. But that’s a story for another day.</p><p>Then there was a church situation where I had good reason to worry that any morning I could find an individual waiting for me on the doorsteps of my apartment for about 6 months. An individual with extensive time in jail, who was also homeless. This sense of personal safety in our apartment wasn’t helped when two different men attempted to break in our back door (and nearly succeeded) in the last year we were there.</p><p>Then during the COVID-19 lockdowns, one of my best friends moved away (which was a very good decision for them), and the man who was the co-planter of our church with me <a href="https://jacobyoung84.medium.com/remembering-bill-ca05ecc5fcf1">suddenly died from a heart event</a>. Along the way there have been other small things that have felt like betrayals and slights, but who really cares? And there is, of course, the regular “normal” sorrows and sufferings people invite me into as their pastor.</p><p>Recently I’ve been listening through <a href="https://open.spotify.com/show/5rJtwcRM7WNYs0LNTrlP5N?si=MMiTZb3QSEK2y_NkzXzbAw&amp;dl_branch=1">The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill from Christianity Today</a>. In listening through the podcast, numerous points have felt extraordinarily similar to what we experienced in Sovereign Grace. The inside culture, the in/out dynamics of perceived loyalty to “gifted leaders”, the patronizing tone of interactions, the subtle bullying by those in power, with narcissistic leadership at the center. With this latest episode on “<a href="https://open.spotify.com/episode/6K50lADkObEjBLQIee8SQE?si=080e1a05679d47ac">The Things We Do to Women</a>”, I was yet again reminded of numerous situations in SGC where the same types of counsel and demeaning theology about women were said or played off as jokes.</p><p>And so the sadness. Through the account of these things, I hardly think any of it was overtly intentional — except the denominational stuff. People are people. “Vain is the salvation of man” (Psalm 60:11).</p><p>As a pastor, my role is often to be the first to hear bad news, and the last to hear good news. That is the pastor’s life. In the last week I’ve been the first to hear about people’s deaths by suicide (or attempted deaths), and then been the sort of “first responder” to the chaos people find themselves in. Multiple people, at once, without any knowledge of each other.</p><p>The sadness feels more like an emotional malaise of different types of suffering. Some suffering is at the betraying hands of friends. Some suffering is at the hands of unstable men who stalk my house. Some suffering has been brought about by the great mystery of God’s providence. And, lest I forget dear reader, there is the daily suffering and pain I bring upon myself through my own sin and weakness. I too am just a man, in whom no salvation resides except Jesus Christ himself.</p><p>The latest episode of The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill hit on one area of suffering I’ve been slowly pondering lately. This past fall I read <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Jesus-John-Wayne-Evangelicals-Corrupted/dp/163149905X">Jesus and John Wayne by Dr. Kristin Kobes Du Mez</a>. Amidst the many shocking dynamics of the history she recounts, I was deeply disturbed at her account of how Evangelical men have been discipled to think about and treat women. Dr. Du Mez recounts specific realities I lived through in our time in SGC, which were very similar to what was touched on in latest episode of The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill. Which leads to another under current of pain I’ve been working through: In what ways have I been a voice or means of oppression and domination against my own wife, who’s walked through all of these things with me? Moreover, has there been any ways I’ve lived out those toxic dynamics in my own pastoral ministry? I am inclined to say I have not, but who can truly wash his own hands clean of his own guilt?</p><p>And thus this sadness. The suffering inflicted by others. The suffering of weaknesses. The unintentional sufferings. The sufferings of being a Self in broken world. The pastor stands at the junction of all of these, with Jesus, and lives amidst these many tensions. Pastoral ministry, in my experience, is a prolonged bleeding out of whatever life is in your soul. Certainly it is for the good of others. But behind this statement is the presumption of being intentional motion <em>towards</em> people. Often, the reality is otherwise. It is being on the receiving end of many large and small decisions that hurt other people, and then figuring out how to respond. Hopefully, in step with The Suffering Shepherd.</p><p>(Also, I think I will stop listening to the Rise and Fall podcast for now. It is, to use the language of trauma counseling, too triggering for the time being. And who needs to willingly heap more upon themselves for the sake of the zeitgeist? If you find yourself in a similar position, I’d encourage you to do likewise.)</p><p>As it stands, maybe Ms. Biles is onto something — something screed as weakness and failure by some. But it seems to me that this is the life of the Christian. We are not what we should be, we can only be what we are. And as this is the life of the Christian, it is even more the life of the pastor, who can only ever be what they are: a Christian among Christians confessing together, “We are not the Christ.”</p><p>Maybe more Christians, and especially more pastors, should be asking each other, for the sake of our collective health in Christ: So, how’s your mental health?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6053bbf9d0f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Hope of Bodily Resurrection for Survivors of Trauma]]></title>
            <link>https://jacobyoung84.medium.com/the-hope-of-bodily-resurrection-for-survivors-of-trauma-fbafeeb2e52a?source=rss-e5b8533d9732------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fbafeeb2e52a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[resurrection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healing-from-trauma]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jacob Young]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Mar 2021 15:34:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-12T15:34:03.081Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*6qoFgxKa6AsfxjKLKxB39A.png" /><figcaption><a href="https://unsplash.com/@understandinggrace">https://unsplash.com/@understandinggrace</a></figcaption></figure><p>The resurrection, the renewal of the body in the return of Christ, offers a uniquely better word of hope to survivors of trauma than any vague message of “going to a better place after death” that our culture offers.</p><p>Recent research has shown that trauma of all kinds creates physiological changes in the human body. Dr. Bassel A. van der Kolk, in <em>The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma,</em> present his finds from decades of research with his patients. Commonly, traumatic events are believed to be primarily mental health problems to be solved. It is not that they aren’t physical, but they are primarily wrapped up in our internal life — how we think about things. Thus, treatments for traumatic events are often perceived as simply requiring talk-therapy solutions. These solutions are required, but we must account for other aspects of how trauma lives in the body: the consequences of life’s events changing the physiology of the body itself, not just our intellectual perceptions of the world around us.</p><p>Dr. Bassel A. van der Kolk illustrates this experience for us:</p><blockquote>“Traumatized people chronically feel unsafe inside their bodies: The past is alive in the form of gnawing interior discomfort. Their bodies are constantly bombarded by visceral warning signs, and, in an attempt to control these processes, they often become expert at ignoring their gut feelings and in numbing awareness of what is played out inside. They learn to hide from their selves.” [1]</blockquote><p>We do not need to do a full treatment of his work here to observe a few things: For survivors of trauma, their very humanity has been warped in a way that merely “thinking right thoughts” will not change. Their humanity has been assaulted. They cannot help much of their experience of “being human” and continue to live a tortured existence in their humanity.</p><p>If we offer any sense of “going to a better place” in death as the ultimate resolution to their human experience, we do a disservice to the glory of their humanity. To be human is a complex experience of body and soul. Where are lines for both? I’m hard pressed to offer a solution here. But for people who have experienced trauma, their humanity has been violated in some deep way that results in a soul-level torture to find relief. A future beyond death that is merely some type of ghostly experience without a body actually insults the horror of their traumatic experience(s). If humanity’s resolution in life after death is to merely lack a body, what value is there to the body that has been the source of such great trauma and assault to the their soul?</p><p>It is here that the good news of Christ’s “first fruits” resurrection meets the confusion of their trauma as a better word. This Jesus, who has been “made perfect through suffering” (Hebrews 2:10, 7:28), was raised in a glorious body — a body that endured significant trauma upon the cross — to a wholeness imbued with the Spirit, and is now united to us in such a way that our humanity will also “put on immortality” like he has (1 Cor. 15:53). He will appear, and “the Lord Jesus Christ… will transform our lowly body to be like his glorious body, by the power that enables him even to subject all things to himself” (Phil. 3:20–21). We have a scarred, glorified Savior (Luke 24:39).</p><p>Certainly there are many aspects of the risen and reigning Christ that offer specific comfort and hope for the traumatized (his priestly care for them, his justice, etc.). But to the point at hand, let us draw out a few specific observations based solely on the objective fact of his resurrection and thereby, the resurrection unto glory for the believer.</p><p>Jesus Christ experienced the fullness of trauma — the soul crushing, physiological changing effects of trauma. Certainly his Passion, from Gethsemane to his dying breath can be so identified. These experiences were not immaterial to glorifying God. So critical were they to showing the value of humanity and God’s glory that he is permanently scarred in his glorification. Which is to show that those things that are the deepest wounds to our humanity are finally, fully filled by the Spirit’s glorifying work in our humanity that they remain as markers of God’s glory and presence with us. They are not shameful marks to be erased. That which shows the fulness of human suffering evidences the power of Christ’s loving descent into our experience, followed his redemption of those experiences.</p><p>Additionally, some of the most painful aspects of traumatic experiences are the “collateral damage” of life that seems to have been stolen away. Whether it’s the inability to have intimate relationships without some type of “triggering” moment, or some permanent physical effect, trauma can often feel like some aspect of our humanity, of our ability to easily engage the world, has been stolen. The traumatized thus feel like they were not merely victims of uncontrollable events, but re-traumatized by being excluded from some type of human experience. To this, the glorified, resurrected body of Christ evidences this simple reality: Your humanity will be so renewed and restored in such a way that there is only more joy to be experienced. To the traumatized especially, from those who weep uncontrollably at night to those who feel irrevocably numb, he says promises to touch their renewed humanity with pure hands, to “wipe away every tear from their eyes” so that “death shall be no more” (Revelation 21:4), which is to say, every mark or effect of death upon the whole of our humanity — all of that which feels most uncontrollable in our lives, will be done away with.</p><p>Thus, we see the frailty and insult of any view of the afterlife that does not center on the resurrection of the body. Survivors of trauma know this intuitively. Their humanity has been violated in some deep way, and nothing less than the fully renewed, glorified humanity offered them in Christ will heal their wounds.</p><p>[1] Van der Kolk, Bessel A. 2015. <em>The Body Keeps the Score: Mind, Brain and Body in the Transformation of Trauma</em>. Harlow, England: Penguin Books. Page 97.</p><p><em>This is a class assignment from my seminary work. I’ve posted it without any changes, simply hoping that the concepts themselves are helpful and that any clunkiness in phrasing or grammar are forgiven.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fbafeeb2e52a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Remembering Bill]]></title>
            <link>https://jacobyoung84.medium.com/remembering-bill-ca05ecc5fcf1?source=rss-e5b8533d9732------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ca05ecc5fcf1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[friendship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[church-planting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eulogy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jacob Young]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 23 Jun 2020 19:12:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-09T18:17:53.493Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7FmoRl1tkZv-NSJa1p3dkA.jpeg" /><figcaption>August 2018</figcaption></figure><p>Two weeks ago Bill O’Grady died. On May 11, he was rushed to the Hospital with chest pains. Upon medical attention, it was discovered he’d had an aortic dissection. He was rushed into emergency open heart surgery, and never woke up. He passed away on June 10, just three days after his 63rd birthday.</p><p>As I write these facts out, I keep expecting to get a call from Bill to wake me up to reality. He would call me during his “screen time” (aka, while driving), to catch up and talk. I have this nagging sense that somehow, this is all just a big misunderstanding, and he’ll be calling me any minute.</p><p>But it’s not. I performed his graveside last week. I saw his dead body at the wake. He’s had a solid 40+ days (isn’t that a Biblical thing?), and he’s still not awake. He has died, and this is the reality I must adjust to.</p><p>I’ve been trying to think of an analogy to describe what this feels like. Not just for anybody to lose a close friend, but for me to lose Bill. The best way I can describe it is this:</p><p>One day, a friend calls you and invites you to go to a Red Sox game with him. He has decent tickets. The adventure of taking the Green Line into Boston is always fun. You both arrive at the game, and just before first pitch, an usher comes over and says, “Hey guys, you want seats on the Green Monster?” You look at each other, “YEAH!” You watch the first 3 innings on the Monster. Then, the same usher comes over and asks, “Hey guys, we’ve got seats behind home plate. You want them?” Yeah! I forgot to mention that this is the ALCS, and its Sox v. Yankees, game 4, the Sox with a tight lead. During the Seventh Inning stretch, the same usher comes over one last time, and says, “Hey guys, sorry to keep moving you around, but we’ve got tickets behind the Sox dugout. You in?” Just as you’re getting up to go to these new seats, your friend says, “Hey, I’m going to get some hot dogs and a couple beers. I’ll meet you there.” You sit in your seats, and wait. The 8th inning starts up, and your friend doesn’t show. Maybe the line was long. Bottom of the 8th, and it looks like extra innings if things don’t get figured out. 9th inning, and still your friend is gone. You’re left waiting for someone who’s never coming back, at the height of the biggest games of your lives and the joy of an impending Sox victory can’t lift the sinking weight of sadness and confusion in your friend’s absence.</p><p>That is what it feels like for my friend Bill to be dead.</p><p>And, just to fill it out and do it justice, come to find out he ran into John Henry, owner of the Red Sox on his way to concessions, and got personally invited up to the Owner’s Box (in this analogy, aka Heaven). Great for him, dumpy for me.</p><p>Bill and I started King’s Cross Church together. This simple line holds a thousand stories behind it. Bill had been a life-long worship leader since his conversion, and lead worship at major churches in the area. He’d ultimately decided that he wanted to be a part of planting a new Gospel-centered church in Manchester, and in God’s providence, that ended up being me who lead it. From day one, it was me and Bill trying to figure out what God was doing in Manchester, and how we fit into His mission. For a long while, it was just Bill’s family and mine gathering on a Tuesday night to study the Bible together. Slowly more people joined, and we split the group, and added a Saturday night worship time. Bill was always eager for the next step, but always reminded me, “Never despise the day of small beginnings.” We spent over 2 years on Saturday nights, worshiping and having a meal together. Bill shared my frustration with finding a suitable place for us in the city for Sunday morning worship, but we knew something would show up. Ultimately, we found a spot in our neighborhood at a recovery center. Bill joined the board of that recovery center, and we watched amazed as God continued to meet broken, weary people in need of Jesus. The church, to put it simply, has been a refuge for the broken and weary, and has been used by God to serve our city.</p><p>That’s where things were when Bill went into the hospital. It’s where things are, even after Bill’s passing. But it feels like I’ve lost the wind in my sails.</p><p>Through every step of the way in planting, Bill was an encouragement. When we couldn’t get funding early on and I was working another job, Bill made sure we were taken care of. When we had a guy go sideways and slander me in the church, Bill helped me process — AND — when he met that guy in town, told him he was praying for him and eager to see him get healthy. When we walked through hard and messy denominational politics last year, Bill was there eagerly encouraging me, “Let’s get this stuff behind us, there’s a lot of mission still to do here in Manchester. More people need the love of Christ.” Whenever I had a major decision to make, I’d talk it through with Bill — always with an aim on helping people have a heart-transforming experience of Jesus Christ himself, in the Gospel.</p><p>That’s what drew people to “love Jesus together” at King’s Cross. Bill’s authenticity of experiencing Jesus was the dominant feature of his worship leading. He was an extremely skilled musician, and sang in an octave a little too high for me (that was one of the last things I’d wanted to talk to Bill about — his last set of songs were a bit too high… What a dumb thing to want to talk about in retrospect). But people were regularly affected by his joy in singing about the love of Christ, the presence of Christ in trials, the power of Christ in the preached word, the move of the Spirit through spiritual gifts, the posture of the church to care for the broken.</p><p>Bill’s worship leading was marked by his love for the Gospel, and his, uh… “gift of gab”. He and I would laugh about this one time his call to worship consisted of 3 points. By the time he was done calling us to worship (aka, giving a sermon), we’d all been standing there for 15 minutes! We’d laugh about that time, and Bill would just laugh at himself, “I couldn’t get out of it, so I just kept going!” From that time on, when we’d review before the service, Bill would say, “I’ve got X for my call to worship”. All I’d say was simply, “Is it short?!”</p><p>In Bill’s worship leading, he was genuinely transparent — talking about his past week, things that he struggled with, pointing to Scripture, and calling us to enjoy this overflowing, twice what we could imagine grace in Jesus Christ. Bill was fond of throwing out 2 Corinthians 5:21 during the middle of worship, “For our sake he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.” He would pray between songs, “Jesus was made into our sin for us, so we are made the righteousness of God!” The double substitution of the Gospel is what fueled Bill’s grace-filled imagination in leading worship.</p><p>I once heard that the Protestant Reformation should really be known as the Singing Reformation. Some think of councils and books, but for the people at the time, it was the renewed singing of hymns, filled with the power of Christ’s love, that fueled the Reformation. That has been the reality for King’s Cross. The songs have been filled with the power of Christ’s love for the broken and weary, because Bill was filled with the same.</p><p>Our singing will continue to be filled with the power of Christ’s love, just maybe in a minor key from time to time.</p><p>Our worship and mission at King’s Cross will have a bit of a limp going forward. It’s these difficult realities, the claws of death that swipe at us, that wound our joy for a time. Personally, I’ve struggled with the truth of the <a href="https://www.the1689confession.com/1689/chapter-31">Resurrection</a> in the wake of Bill’s death. Dead people coming alive again, better than before? I’ve preached it, but do I love it now? In the shock of this type of claim, I can begin to relate with some of the Sadducees who balked at Jesus’ teaching. “The same day Sadducees came to him, who say that there is no resurrection, and they asked him a question… But Jesus answered them, ‘As for the resurrection of the dead, have you not read what was said to you by God: ‘I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob’? He is not God of the dead, but of the living’” (Matthew 22:23, 31–32).</p><p>I find the simplicity of Jesus alluring and frustrating. You mean to tell me, simply because “God is the God of the living”, all this pain in the sudden loss of my friend, all the numbness that marks my days since he passed away, will come untrue? If God is the God of the living, how come death feels so natural, so final? Could it be that these truths in the Bible make a functional, factual, real claim about my skin and bones, not to mention the world around me?</p><p>It’s these gritty, dusty realities that makes Christianity so strikingly adventurous. The Bible points to the dead, moldering remains of Bill O’Grady and claims, “Those will be made whole some day. They must. They will be changed. For this perishable body must put on the imperishable, and this mortal body must put on immortality”. This is the striking gap, the lead, so to speak, that Christianity has over the whole of world religions. We do not merely need the furniture of our minds and souls shuffled around to live right lives. No, the whole house has to be remade, and it’s on the other side of death. Christianity makes a claim on death, so as to make that which is our most feared enemy the slave of Christ in our lives. I, for one, struggle to hold onto that right now because it means, maybe I’ll be able to watch the Sox win another world series with my friend.</p><p>I finish this like I have been for the last couple weeks: Sitting in my office, staring at the ceiling. I’ve talked with Bill a thousand times in here, and now I have no idea what the rest of the year looks like without him. But I know what Bill would say to me: “Look, you’ve got good people with you, ready to go with the mission of Jesus. This stuff has been hard, but let’s get back at it. There’s a lot of people who still need the love of Christ.” Amen brother Bill. Even in his death, Bill’s leading us in worship.</p><p><em>Anno Domini, June 23, 2020.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ca05ecc5fcf1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Shepherding Movement: A Summary]]></title>
            <link>https://jacobyoung84.medium.com/the-shepherding-movement-a-summary-5883c3d27e9f?source=rss-e5b8533d9732------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5883c3d27e9f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spiritual-abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[charismatic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[shepherding-movement]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jacob Young]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 30 Nov 2019 18:12:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-01-01T16:33:28.995Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*bx_X8e-7Pe5KTnOcNYfMog.jpeg" /></figure><p>How do we commit to each other’s growth in Christ? For all believers, this is a critical question to the functional life of a Christian. It is not easily solved, and often fraught with mistakes and blunders along the way. Such is the plaguing problem of discipleship. At times, there can be fad solutions to these issues, which come with some benefits, and while well intended are often marked by lopsided application of Biblical truths to the life believers helping believers be growing disciples.</p><p>In<em> The Shepherding Movement: Controversy and Charismatic Ecclesiology, </em>S. David Moore recounts a critical moment within the Charismatic Restoration world of the late 1970’s and early 1980’s. This movement offers critical insights into how Charismatics at the time we’re thinking through discipleship, pastoral care, leadership, and spiritual authority, perennial issues to any Christian, regardless of being a charismatic or not.</p><p>This article presents a summary of the Shepherding movement, from the academic work of S. David Moore’s work is provided largely, if not exclusively in quotations from his book. I have not recounted much of the historical dynamics of the controversies that arose, but only those elements which point towards defining and illuminating the theological teachings of the movement, their leadership and cultural philosophy, and interesting nuggets along the way. Obviously, this is a subjective report, so if you want more, <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Shepherding-Movement-Pentecostal-Theology-Supplement/dp/0826471609/?tag=planrepl-20">buy the book</a>.</p><p>In no way do I intend to undermine the sales of Moore’s book. However, given that when I purchased it for $7, and that it’s now selling second hand for $50 with no mention of another printing in the works, I thought its material could be helpful for some. It is for that sole purpose that I quote so extensively.</p><h3>The History of the Shepherding Movement</h3><p>For the sake of time and space, the Shepherding Movement refers to a discipleship structure and network, based around a few central ideas, lead by five teachers, in the late 1970’s and early 1980’s. The need for this discipleship structure and network was in large part a response to the dynamics of the Charismatic movement of the time. Charismatics were largely dispersed among churches, and were generally seen as a truly transdenominational work of the Spirit. They saw themselves as a part of God’s renewing work among his people by engaging believers with a fresh outpouring of the Spirit, spread through multiple Protestant churches, as well as Roman Catholic communities. Therefore, they were, in effect, “a people spread among a people” who needed attending, support and care. Therefore, the Shepherding Movement (SM) arose at a time when Charismatics were loosely associated, largely independent, and in need of discipleship and organization to help them grow in Christ and join the Spirit’s work. The reason the term “movement” is used, is that despite ultimately looking and talking like a denomination (which is what ultimately caused some of their biggest controversies), Charismatics at the time were largely allergic to the idea of becoming an institution.</p><p>To quote <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shepherding_Movement">Wikipedia</a> for brevity:</p><blockquote><em>It began when four well-known Charismatic teachers, Bob Mumford, Derek Prince, Charles Simpson, and Don Basham, along with Ern Baxter and John Poole, “formed the organization that would be ‘the center of one of the most violent controversies (i.e., the Discipleship/Shepherding controversy) in Protestant charismatic history,’ Christian Growth Ministries (CGM), headquartered in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida.”</em></blockquote><p>It focuses around the teaching ministries of Charles Simpson, Bob Mumford, Derek Prince, Don Basham and Ern Baxter, who were drawn together and mutually submitted to each other for the sake of their own discipleship and ministries. They were known as the “Ft. Lauderdale Five”. What Moore’s book does is describe how they came together, what their theological distinctives were, and how eventual controversy lead them to go their separate ways. The SM was not some small collection of churches, but was in effect, the largest influencer in the Charismatic Renewal in the 70’s and 80&#39;s.</p><p>David Barrett’s <em>World Christian Encyclopedia </em>estimates around 100,000 people being associated with the movement. The SM’s magazine, <em>New Wine, </em>distributed to “over 110,000 in 1976, and at its peak was distributed in 140 nations… What makes this even more significant is that more than 50 percent of <em>New Wine’s</em> readership were [church] leaders. In addition, the five teachers distributed their own newsletters, tapes, and books over the years of their association. Statistics for the five-year period from 1979–1984 show a distribution of 4,500,000 magazines, 1,000,000 newsletters, 600,000 cassette tapes, and 250,000 books… [At the] 1977 Kanssas City Conference on Charismatic Renewal in the Christian churches [the Shepherding Movement had] over 12,000 in attendance” (Moore, 6–7).</p><p>The structure of the SM was, in effect, a pyramid scheme for discipleship. A Christian submitted themselves to a shepherd, who took on responsibility for their whole-life discipleship. Additionally, a disciple would tithe to their shepherd directly. A shepherd would generally have no more than 5–10 men (or family units) under his care. This shepherd was under the care of his own shepherd — so on as so forth, with the top 5 leaders of the SM at the top, who “mutually submitted to each other”. While not intended (it was modeled after the picture of Jesus with his 12), it was clearly a pyramid scheme focused on discipleship.</p><p>While I do not intend to recount the history, I will note events that illustrate points, but will primarily focus on their theology and teaching. To quote Moore, “The history of the Shepherding controversy illustrates how difficult it is to appropriately confront other leaders and how challenging it is for other leaders to hear and respond to critics’ charges” (Moore, 5).</p><ul><li>“Troubled by the cultural revolution they were observing all around, many began to look for a return to a biblical certainty characteristic of conservative Christianity, believing the moral absolutes of the Bible provided meaning an order for their lives. A more biblically conservative view gave them a framework to interpret and make sense of the difficult times” (Moore, 19).</li><li>“By 1973, one-third of all North Americans were consciously feeling an intense need for mutuality and community, and by 1980 nearly one-half of North Americans felt that way. The Shepherding movement’s emphasis on house church and cell groups tapped into this social trend… the Shepherding movement would become the ‘the most extensive expression of the house church movement in the United States’. This growth was not in consequence of a passing fad, but because the movement created ecclesiastical structures that were ‘a direct response to problems inherent in a complex mass society’” (Moore, 20–21).</li><li>“The distinctive teachings of the Shepherding movement were shaped more by Charles Simpson than by any of the other teachers. It was Simpson who practiced them before the others — though without the same terminology — and continues leading the movement today (2003). As the movement matured and developed, Simpson became the <em>de facto</em> leader of the other four teachers. These five very different men were drawn together because they were like-minded in their concern for the spiritual maturity of the Charismatic believers. They had respected one another’s ministries…” (Moore, 41).</li></ul><h3>Key concepts to Shepherding Movement</h3><ul><li>“They believed ‘that submission to spiritual authority provides the greatest spiritual protection anywhere available for Christian ministers and teachers’” (Moore, 42).</li><li>“The teachers of the Shepherding movement were deeply troubled by other weaknesses they saw. They believed that there had been male abdication of spiritual leadership in the home and a general dissolution of the biblical modeled family unit. They were concerned over the lack of discernment regarding the exercise of spiritual gifts and a disregard for the need of personal character. In the Charismatic movement, there was a kind of ‘charismania’, in which believers were caught up in an experienced-based mentality’ regarding their faith” (Moore, 42).</li><li>“Significantly, many of the young people and leaders that first attached themselves to the Shepherding movement were in some manner a part of the Jesus movement” (Moore, 43).</li><li><strong>One of the more critical quotes: </strong>“Their analysis of the condition of the Charismatic Renewal and broader Christianity is especially important to understanding the Shepherding movement’s self-concept. They saw themselves seeking to be ‘men of Issachar, who understood the times and knew what Israel should do’ (1 Chron. 12.30 NIV). They felt they were perceiving the issues facing the church and giving leadership in response to prophetic insight. Bob Mumford often referred to what he called a ‘now word’ or a ‘preceding word’. His idea was that God was speaking contemporaneously to his people to give them guidance by emphasizing certain essential truths or teachings. The teachings that were to become their trademark on authority, submission, discipleship, Shepherding care, and the kingdom of God were seen as ‘living-edge truths’ to confront and guide their generation. This perception began more and more to drive their association as they sought more effectively to teach Charismatics how to mature their relationship with Christ. They sought to use conferences, video, audiotapes, television, books, and <em>New Wine Magazine</em> to bring healthy teaching to Charismatics” (Moore, 44).</li><li>“Concepts on discipleship, authority, and submission seemed to address directly the ‘individualism and lack of spiritual discipline’ among the segment of the renewal they ‘were ministering to most often’. These teachings on authority and submission were new for the four and to independent Charismatics, since they all, according to Simpson, ‘were skeptical of authority because we associated [authority] with dead churches and abuse’” (Moore, 47).</li><li>“Recognizing a need for guidelines to help mediate future disputes within the renewal, a ‘code of ethics’ was drawn up at the 1971 Seattle meeting. The ‘document, entitled “Ethics for Christian Leaders”, was drafted and solemnly agreed upon, although there was no formal signing of the document’. The document called for criticisms and complaints against any fellow leader or his ministry to be handled according to the Matthew 18 guidelines, by first going privately to the person ‘to establish the true facts’…” (Moore, 49).</li><li>For Simpson, covering was “protection provided by submitting oneself to God’s delegated authority in the home, church, and civil government” (Moore, 55).</li><li>Prince “emphasized the roles of apostles and prophets as present-day ministries” (Moore, 55).</li><li>Mumford taught a series of messages entitled “Sheep and Shepherds” wherein he said, “You need to find a shepherd… You make a commitment to him, he makes a commitment to you… If you don’t have someone to whom you can go and say brother I want you to shepherd me… you better find one in God and find him soon.” For Mumford and Simpson, the key to making pastoral care work was the formation of a definite, one-to-one, personal relationship between each person and a shepherd leader” (Moore, 55–56).</li><li>“To be involved in church meant to have a vital relationship, first with a shepherd, and then with other believers” (Moore, 57).</li><li>“They believed covenant relationships were one more answer to the problem of independence among Charismatics. It was not a biblical option to walk alone; believers were to be vitally connected to shepherds and fellow Christians and to learn to demonstrate commitment, loyalty, and accountability and service within the community life” (Moore, 57).</li><li>Prince “stated that he did not recommend that people go to seminary, but instead advocated a mentoring model for ministry training… He taught that the elders of the local church are ultimately the final authority in local church affairs and that apostolic ministry must be invited in by the local presbytery of elders” (Moore, 63).</li></ul><h3>Distinctive Teaching of the Shepherding Movement</h3><ul><li>“The movement’s ecclesiology was driving by what the leaders thought was a God-directed response to the times and, consequently, was not systematic” (Moore, 68).</li></ul><h4>The Kingdom of God</h4><ul><li>Mumford: “When we speak of authority, we mean simply God’s order, not authoritarianism. Submission, authority, and discipleship, as I understand and teach them, are the uncomplicated an basic ingredients necessary for the practical outworking of the Lordship of Christ in the life of every believer” (Moore, 71).</li><li>The delegated authorities in the church serve to mediate God’s rule through their exercise of spiritual authority. By submitting to delegated authority, believers were submitting to Christ” (Moore, 71).</li></ul><h4>Ecclesiology</h4><ul><li>“[T]hey acknowledged the invisible, universal Church, but stressed the visible and local nature of the church as its essential character” (Moore, 71).</li></ul><h4>Discipleship</h4><ul><li>Mumford believed discipleship “was a very fundamental and vital ongoing relationship which brings maturity to the believer in every phase of his life. The Christian life is not simply knowledge to be learned, classes to be attended, etc., but rather a life-style which is primarily imparted and passed on by sharing closely with others who know the Way. This is the relationship that the ‘youngest brother’ Timothy had with Paul. We believe the Lord is leading us to ‘grow up’ or mature some disciples so that they will be capable of discipling and bringing others to a similar degree of maturity. As the older Christian teaches the younger, he is able to watch over his live, and often to prescribe what is needed for his continued growth and maturity. These prescriptions may come in the form of books to read, tapes to listen to, teaches to sit under, and various other input into one’s life. It also involved feedback, oversight concerning his life-style, where he goes and what he does. It is my conviction that discipleship should be an ongoing part of every Christian’s experience. The circumstances may vary, but what we want to transmit is not information or procedures, but a way of life. The life of Christ flowing between two persons is a manifestation of discipleship” (Moore, 73).</li></ul><h4>Shepherding</h4><ul><li>“Every believer was to have a personal, definite, and committed relationship with a shepherd” (Moore, 73–4).</li><li>“Contrary to charges of critics, the shepherd-sheep relationship never carried any soteriological dimension. The movement’s leaders never questioned that salvation and entry into the universal, invisible church was through anything but faith in Christ, who alone was ‘the Door’. They did believe that participation in [a] local church necessitated a personal commitment to a shepherd who served as ‘a door’, caring for the sheep on Jesus’ behalf” (Moore, 74).</li><li>“The movement taught that submission to a shepherd provided spiritual ‘covering’ by being in right relationship to God’s delegated authority in the church. The shepherd assumed responsibility for the well-being of his sheep. This responsibility included not just their spiritual well-being, but for their full development emotionally, educationally, financially, vocationally, and socially. Submitting to a shepherd necessarily involved a thoughtful recognition of ‘those whom God has placed over us and required a deeper level of transparency and openness’ than many in the Charismatic Renewal were accustomed to” (Moore, 74).</li><li>Mumford: “Submission means that we intend to share our lives and decisions as openly as possible. This means that major decisions, such as occupational changes, large financial expenditures, schedule changes, and other matters that affect us personally, as well as the group to which we are related, will be open to the group before they are finalized… Categorically, let me say: The group or the shepherd does not make any ultimate determination as to whether the individual can or cannot make the decision, but they give feedback, guidance, and counsel which is expected to be seriously considered before action is taken… [There] is a need to embrace true biblical and balanced authority if the Lordship of Christ is to become practical and applicable in this critical hour of world history” (Moore, 75).</li><li>“Many of the movement’s early followers were young people who wanted and needed the discipline the shepherding relationship brought with its concept of authority and submission. Shepherds were to lead their sheep and provide practical guidance on etiquette, personal dress, management, budgeting, and basic home, yard, and automobile care. Moreover, shepherds were to assist ‘people in their financial difficulties, family complications, or similar intricate personal problems. To do so effectively requires an adequate degree of biblical authority’, Mumford wrote” (Moore, 75).</li><li>“Functionally, for a person to be a committed part of one of their churches required this definite commitment to a shepherd. Consequently, one was either ‘in or out’, based on one’s willingness to be pastored personally” (Moore, 75).</li></ul><h4>Covenant relationship</h4><ul><li>“They saw covenant relationship as the solid ground for permanent and stability within a disintegrating culture. A believer’s relationship to God was firmly rooted in God’s covenant love, demonstrated by Christ’s sacrificial death. Consequently, believes were to commit themselves with the same king of self-sacrificial love and loyalty to their leaders and fellow believers. Covenant was the ‘cohesive substance of kingdom life as given by Jesus Christ’. Christ and his relationship with the Twelve, Mumford wrote, was an example for today’s church: ‘It was this foundational of a covenant relationship between Christ and His disciples which was a foundation poured for the whole new society. It is the nature of covenant and our loyalty to that covenant that gives Christ’s work permanency in a fluctuating and impermanent world. Thus I began to understand that the covenant and the covenantal relationship is the ark of safety in our degenerate society” (Moore, 76).</li><li>“Practically, covenant mean ‘abandoning the option to quit’ in relationships. It meant one assumed ‘unlimited liability’ in relationships by helping a brother or sister at one’s own expense if necessary” (Moore, 77).</li><li>“The Shepherding movement saw itself as developing a king of spiritual army. It emphasized the need for discipline, rank, and commitment. It used the term ‘spiritual fatherhood’ to stress the goal of establishing nurturing relationships that carried true spiritual authority. A believer was encouraged to find fatherhood in his or her shepherd. It taught that other lateral relationships with fellow believers in the house church or cell group resulted from the relationship a disciple made with the shepherd or spiritual father. In other words, the primary connection with the group was first to the shepherd, and spiritual family was a by-product. Jesus had called together a diverse group of disciples who had then to learn to love each other, and so it was for the sheep who submitted to a shepherd” (Moore, 78).</li><li>“The Shepherding movement stressed the importance of serving one’s shepherd as foundational to developing for ministry. Believers were to prove faithful in serving another man’s ministry before receiving their own” (Moore, 78).</li></ul><h4>Other distinctives</h4><ul><li>Emphasis on male leadership</li><li>Family relationships</li><li>Submission for all spiritual leaders (v. lone rangers)</li><li>Translocal spiritual authority</li></ul><blockquote>“The five teachers believed ecclesiastical authority was all too often external and without spiritual reality, where true spiritual authority was relational and life-changing” (Moore, 80).</blockquote><ul><li>Personal tithing to your shepherd</li><li>Evangelism (Note: Very little emphasis here.)</li></ul><h3>Observations from their crisis and separation</h3><ul><li>“Nevertheless, the movement’s leaders did not believe they were a denominational organization. It is noteworthy that the movement never formally organized itself like a legal corporation of churches. It was always a voluntary association of churches that never kept or maintained a formal roster of affiliated churches. Each associated church or cluster of churches incorporated independently. The leaders were correct in saying that the movement was held together by a network of personal relationships” (Moore, 84).</li><li>“While the five men never referred to themselves as apostles, many of their constituents saw them as such” (Moore, 85).</li><li>“Bob Mumford wrote to Kahlman in October and expressed his dismay about her treatment of him” (Moore, 111).</li><li>“Hayford criticized the hasty judgement of some toward the five teachers, but also expressed concerns over the movement’s failure, in his view, to thoroughly answer critics’ charges ‘regardless of how groundless’ they may be. Hayford said, ‘A self-righteously indignant stance which refuses to dignify the charges with a reply only serves to fortify the stance of the accusers’” (Moore, 112).</li><li>“Mumford wanted to go further in the statement and acknowledge more fully their own mistakes and extremes, but Simpson disagreed. Simpson felt that, while there had indeed been problems resulting from their teachings, the five men had a responsibility to their committed followers who had paid a high price to be associated with them. Simpson did not want to appease the movement’s antagonists and thereby shake their follower’s confidence” (Moore, 118).</li><li>“The Shepherding leaders believed their attackers were acting unscripturally by airing unsubstantiated rumors and allegations and refusing to engage in meaningful dialogue. The movement’s teachers were angered, since they felt they were making substantial efforts at healing the first… This all contributed to a perception among the movement’s leaders that they were being persecuted for their God-directed teachings. They also believed that, because these teachings were a part of God’s restoration of New Testament Christianity, Satan was resisting them through the controversy. These perceptions in the fact of controversy only reinforced their commitment to the teachings of Shepherding, discipleship, and covenant relationship. In many ways, the conduct of their critics, which they perceived as being unethical, may have contributed to an unwillingness to listen to the legitimate concerns of their opponents” (Moore, 124).</li><li>“For Simpson and his leaders, the Covenant Life Conference in Mobile over the 4 July 1979 weekend was very significant” (Moore, 144).</li><li>“In 1981, a broader national and international leadership council was created that included the five teachers and several leadership, all of whom came form the regional councils. In the end, their attempt to decentralize seemed only to lead to more centralized government” (Moore, 146).</li><li>“The Shepherding movement placed a strong emphasis on music and worship” (Moore, 146).</li><li>“Mumford acknowledged a deficiency in evangelistic activity among their churches. They discussed the impression outsiders had, that anyone not doing what the movement taught was missing God” (Moore, 148).</li><li>“The very things they taught created a propensity toward an abuse of spiritual authority, especially among young immature leaders, or leaders who lacked character and integrity” (Moore, 149).</li><li>“A Covenant Community: A community of God’s redeemed people: bound together in covenant love, submitted to compassionate authority and rulership, manifesting peace, holiness, and family fidelity expressed through revered fatherhood, cherished woman and motherhood with secure and obedient children. A community where loving correction and instruction produce healthy growth and maturity; where dedication to excellence produces the finest results in arts, crafts, trades and commerce, providing prosperity and abundance for all its members. A community of faith, worship, praise and selfless ministry, manifesting individually and corporately the fits and fruit of the Holy Spirit. A community where all life is inspired and directed by the Spirit of Jesus Christ and is lived to his glory as a witness and testimony to the world” (Moore, 150).</li><li>“The Shepherding movement identified with the Anabatist emphasis on the visible, believing community, comprised of those whose conduct is distinctly different from the world. Moreover, they identified with the Radical Reformers’ rejection and persecution as heretics for truths they deemed faithful to the New Testament” (Moore, 153).</li><li>“In a December 1976 meeting in Naples, Florida, Mumford and the others actually decided to split up. They gathered again a month later in Naples, and Simpson appealed for a continuing association, feeling that disbanding would hurt too many people who were committed to their leadership. Simpson agreed to be the leader within the group of five at the request of the others” (Moore, 161).</li><li>“Unofficial alliances were formed with Bob Weiner’s Maranatha Campus Ministries and Larry Tomczak’s People of Destiny. Also a loose alliance had been established with Christian reconstructionist R.J. Rushdooney” (Moore 164).</li><li>“Surprisingly, Prince’s exit was hardly mentioned publicly within the movement” (Moore, 166).</li><li>“Simpson also sought to adjust problems in the movement’s pastoral structures. He admitted that, while never intended, they had created a kind of pyramidal structure that locked people into relationships. Their long standing teaching that to be a part of the church one had to be joined personally to a pastor had created a significant problem. If the one-on-one pastoral relationship broke down, then so did the person’s relationship to the church. Moreover, if a translocal relationship broke down, a whole church was often cut off from the movement. Simpson was not sure it was biblical for entire groups of people to be dependent on individual relationships. They began to moderate their approach, by encouraging commitment not only to a pastor but also to the church as a whole” (Moore, 176).</li><li>“Simpson’s network and a few other groups are what remains of the influential and highly visible expression of the Charismatic Renewal. Those groups that have taken up the movement’s mantle continue to wrestle with the tension between an organic relational emphasis and the need for structure and organization” (Moore, 184).</li><li>“Though they were still active in some ecumenical activities, they felt persecuted by many Charismatic leaders and took a ‘we work with our own’ attitude” (Moore, 185).</li></ul><h3>Moore’s final reflections</h3><h4>Historical reasons for the rise and fall of the Shepherding Movement</h4><ol><li>The Shepherding movement was a renewal that was driven by a theologically informed, restorationist idealism.</li><li>Despite its deep roots in the ecumenical soil of Charismatic Renewal, the Shepherding movement became a local church-centered movement.</li><li>The Shepherding movement was a house church movement.</li><li>The Shepherding movement was a pastoral care movement.</li><li>The Shepherding movement emphasized non-professional leadership and non-traditional leadership training.</li><li>The Shepherding movement’s exercise of authority was hierarchical. “Followers were not encouraged to an unquestioning, blind obedience to their shepherd but to an informal trusting obedience that was an outflow of a close caring relationship. The exercise of spiritual authority was well intentioned and seen as a means to bring health and maturity to people. Still, the emphasis on hierarchically oriented submission to God’s delegated authorities led to many cases of improper control and abusive authority throughout the movement” (Moore, 182).</li><li>The Shepherding movement emphasized the relational organic nature of the church.</li></ol><h4>Why did the Shepherding movement fail?</h4><ol><li>The movement simply grew too fast and exceeded its ability to produce trained and qualified leaders for the task.</li><li>The movement’s leaders failed to recognize the downside of an authoritarian approach.</li><li>The movement’s ideology forced the five teachers into apostolic and pastoral roles for which they were not called or prepared.</li><li>Their view of covenant limited the options of the five teachers. “They believed covenant meant abandoning the option to quit… Their emphasis on loyalty also caused them to tolerate problems in key leaders” (Moore, 187).</li><li>The enormous pressures of the controversy exacerbates internal and personal struggles.</li><li>The movement did not develop an adequate church polity to deal with their Charismatic and institutional tensions.</li><li>The movement’s emphasis on authority, submission, and servanthood had a way of silencing dissent.</li><li>Finally, it simply was impossible to keep five strong, independently successful leaders together.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/266/1*KSEw5LrVYiNFpu05y5iAAA.jpeg" /><figcaption>At barely 200 pages, it’s worth the read.</figcaption></figure><p>What I’ve put together here is largely a quotation summary of Moore’s work, focusing more on the teachings and practices of the Shepherding Movement. I did not get into the details of the controversies surrounding them. If those dynamics interest you — and they are interesting (e.g. Pat Robertson is a key player…) — then I would highly recommend you <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Shepherding-Movement-Pentecostal-Theology-Supplement/dp/0826471609/?tag=planrepl-20">buy the book</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5883c3d27e9f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Deep Fakes, FaceApp and Child Pornography]]></title>
            <link>https://jacobyoung84.medium.com/deep-fakes-faceapp-and-child-pornography-63ee23e56f30?source=rss-e5b8533d9732------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/63ee23e56f30</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pedophilia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jacob Young]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 10 Oct 2019 03:37:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-05T17:04:57.604Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*9XJWIp-uSvFTKGfjuTc6WQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>I do not intend to be alarmist in the slightest, but when drawing together concerning developments in our culture, I imagine it’s inevitable. Rather than writing an essay with a concrete ending, what I’m going to do is simply lay out a number of observations, hopefully in a logical sequence. The difference is simply to allow for the observations to be evaluated on their own, rather than everything leading to a singular point.</p><ol><li><strong>Deepfakes are not just about pornography. </strong>The term “deepfakes” refers to “a technique for human image synthesis based on artificial intelligence. It is used to combine and superimpose existing images and videos onto source images or videos using a machine learning technique known as generative adversarial network” (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deepfake">Wiki</a>). Which is to say, it is a program that blends real pictures to each other. It gained notoriety in 2017 when celebrities had their faces superimposed onto pornographic actors. But it’s not just about realizing the depraved imagination of one’s favorite celebrity anymore. Deepfakes are increasingly being used to produce convincingly produced videos for other outlets. For example, a video of Mark Zuckerberg making a sinister statement was recently released (<a href="https://www.instagram.com/p/ByaVigGFP2U/">here</a>). You can read more about it <a href="https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/pajvq9/mark-zuckerberg-deepfake-facebook-misinformation-moderation-satire">at Vice</a>. Or another <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bPhUhypV27w&amp;amp=&amp;app=desktop">recent example</a> of Bill Hader’s impersonation of Arnold Schwarzenegger being “deepfaked” with the face of The Terminator himself.</li><li><strong>Deepfake tech is beginning to be easily accessible.</strong> <a href="https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/qv7agw/deepnude-app-that-undresses-photos-of-women-takes-it-offline">Vice recently wrote</a> about an app called Deep Nude, “an app that takes an image of a clothed woman, and with one click and a few seconds, turns that image into a nude by algorithmically superimposing realistic-looking breasts and vulva onto her body.” The app was created for user’s entertainment and ultimately was taken down because, “The world is not yet ready for DeepNude.” Because this is a list of points rather than an article, I’ll leave those realities to sit in your mind: An app that generated convincing but fake nude pictures of <em>any</em> woman was created for entertainment, and removed because the world isn’t ready for it yet.</li><li><strong>Pedophilia is being presented as a hardwired, unchangeable sexual preference in need of social accommodation. </strong>Two points to pull together here, <strong>1:</strong> This was presented a year or so ago at a TEDx talk by Mirjam Heine in her talk, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNr3yhjQPI8&amp;t=8s">Pedophilia Is A Natural Sexual Orientation</a>. (Please note, TED Talk’s <a href="https://blog.ted.com/tedx-talk-under-review/">statement</a>.) <strong>2:</strong> A connecting point here, and if it doesn’t follow, please forgive me: While some have forgotten his name, Michel Foucault famously lobbied to demolish the age of consent laws in France in the 1980’s (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_petition_against_age_of_consent_laws">wiki</a>). His line of thinking was that children have the capacity to express their sexuality in their own terms and should not be legally barred from exercising their sexuality, even if it involves a child engaging in sex acts with an adult, so long as there is no violence or abuse involved. His argument is that children have the capacity for sexuality, and therefore, it is oppressive, condescending and abusive to tell them they cannot engage the world sexually, even if someone under the age of consent (e.g. 18 years old) engages with an adult sexually. He argues “to suppose that a child is incapable of explaining what happened [sexually] and incapable of giving his consent are two abuses that are intolerable, quite unacceptable.” He goes on to say that “an age barrier laid down by law does not make much sense” (<em>Politics, Philosophy, Culture: Interviews and Other Writings 1977–1984</em> by Michel Foucault, p. 284). The point of these two aspects is simply this: There are substantial arguments being made about sexuality and children. Foucault’s argument is that children should be allowed to express their sexuality with an adult so long as there isn’t violence or abuse involved, and Mirjam Heine’s argument is that sexual attraction to children is unchangeably hardwired. Consider who wins (pedophiles) and looses (children) in their version of reality.</li><li><strong>The FaceApp shows that augmented reality will be allowed, but can be used both ways. </strong>I know I’m poking many of my friends in the eye here (I cantankerously said to my friends that the original FaceApp was called “parents”). FaceApp took a picture of your face and “aged” it. Apart from the security concerns about how this data will be used, it shows that augmented “fake” pictures of our “aged” self are ok. Now, I am not trying to be an alarmist, but the same tech that adds wrinkles and gray to your face, could easily be used to remove wrinkles and hair from your body. Which is to say, a picture that can be aged, can be “youthed”. To put this more pointedly, a picture of any person can be made to look younger, <em>much</em> younger.</li></ol><p>A few closing questions or thoughts:</p><ol><li>With apps like DeepNude being taken down, not because they’re morally deplorable, but because “the world isn’t ready yet” how long until an app is created to “youth” a picture of you or me into child pornography?</li><li>An app like DeepNude means that any picture of a child <strong>could</strong> be used to generate fake child pornography of that child. If you’re a parent, let that read: of <em>your</em> child. Remember, with Facebook and Instagram, we are voluntarily putting hundreds and thousands of pictures online of our children.</li><li>Will deepfake child pornography be illegal? No one was physically harmed or coerced into the production of said content. In fact, no child was physically harmed in the production of the deepfake picture/video. If the reasons for child pornography being wrong are <em>only</em> that children are harmed in its production, and that they should not be denied expressing their sexuality, I fear we are not far away from legally allowing it. To be clear, child pornography is morally repugnant and vile. The question is whether the law of the land will see deepfake’d or FaceApp’d child pornography differently.</li><li>As a parent, I ask: Should I continue to put pictures of my children online?</li><li>As a citizen, I wonder: How do I live in a digital world?</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=63ee23e56f30" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A patient gentleness requires courage and strength.]]></title>
            <link>https://jacobyoung84.medium.com/a-patient-gentleness-requires-courage-and-strength-b41c7d895c44?source=rss-e5b8533d9732------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b41c7d895c44</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gentleness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[patience]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[church-leadership]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[church]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jacob Young]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Sep 2019 15:22:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-09-10T15:22:54.054Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PB90r16tCCshEnr5zNTzew.jpeg" /></figure><p>I have lately been reading Zack Eswine’s <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Imperfect-Pastor-Discovering-Limitations-Apprenticeship/dp/1433549336/?tag=planrepl-20"><em>The Imperfect Pastor</em></a><em>. </em>The following was a selection from this book that I have found helpful for my soul. When misrepresented and mischaracterized by others — whether in our own church, or in our denomination — we must, I <em>must</em>, be patient with them all.</p><blockquote>“We urge you, brothers, admonish the idle, encourage the fainthearted, help the weak, <em>be patient with them all.</em> See that no one repays anyone evil for evil, but always seek to do good to one another and to everyone. (1 Thess. 5:14–15).</blockquote><p>“Make sure it is the idle and not the fainthearted whom you admonish. Be clear it is the fainthearted and not the idle whom you are encouraging,” Paul says. And then Paul reveals what this congregational work of discernment and care will require. “Whether a person is idle, fainthearted, or in need of help, whether you are admonishing someone or encouraging her, be certain of this,” Paul said. “Be patient with them all.”</p><p>But how do we show patience in the midst of mean accusations or mischaracterizations? Paul answered. Even when someone does them evil, he exhorts them to wait out their legitimate emotions rather than spew them. They are to bear with their deep wound.</p><p>In our day, that would equate to waiting two or three days before responding to the email and holding back the fury in an immediate voice mail. They (and we) are to find perspective and healing from a source other than the temporary gratification from rushing to repay evil done to them. They are to wait out their racing thoughts and emotions until they choose good, even for an enemy. Then this wrestling toward praise, prayer, and gratitude without ceasing for every circumstance they face, and seeking in it what is from God’s Spirit (and letting for of what is not) — this reveals the pathway patience takes (1 Thess. 5:16–22).</p><blockquote>“The Lord’s servant must not be quarrelsome but kind to everyone, able to teach, <em>patiently enduring evil</em>, correcting his opponents with gentleness.” (2 Tim. 2:24–25)</blockquote><p>Resisting the illusory desire for immediate defense, immediate remedy, and immediate relief is not easy pastorally. A patient gentleness requires courage and strength.</p><p>Source: <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Imperfect-Pastor-Discovering-Limitations-Apprenticeship/dp/1433549336/?tag=planrepl-20">Zack Eswine, <em>The Imperfect Pastor, </em>p. 125–126.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b41c7d895c44" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[King’s Cross Statement on a Third-Party Investigation of Sovereign Grace Churches]]></title>
            <link>https://jacobyoung84.medium.com/kings-cross-statement-on-a-third-party-investigation-of-sovereign-grace-churches-f27dbd4cd610?source=rss-e5b8533d9732------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f27dbd4cd610</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sovereign-grace-churches]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mission]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-assault]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[sexual-abuse]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jacob Young]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 Jun 2019 16:00:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-12T19:48:52.572Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jd9g0eqyQTVeG0dElWK0Ww.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jesus said, “Let the little children come to me and do not hinder them, for to such belongs the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 19:14)</figcaption></figure><p><em>Please Note: Since publishing this statement, King’s Cross Church has left Sovereign Grace Churches. In a Special Council of Elders meeting in August 2019, the elders of SGC voted 64 to 6 to approve the motion, “We move that the council of elders vote to approve the Leadership Team’s April 12 recommendation”. Given our conviction that this was in error, and other ongoing issues related to our partnership with SGC, we formally separated from the denomination on November 6, 2019.</em></p><p>From the Elders and Members of King’s Cross Church:</p><p>In recent months, Sovereign Grace Churches’ Leadership Team has made two public statements about the allegations of pastoral malpractice with regard to child abuse in our past. After five years or more of public outcry about these allegations, the Leadership Team published on the SGC website a <a href="https://www.sovereigngrace.com/s/FAQ-Concerning-Allegations-Made-Against-Sovereign-Grace-Churches-Final-2-Revised-520.pdf">question-and-answer page</a> and their <a href="https://www.sovereigngrace.com/s/thoughts-on-the-call-for-an-independent-investigation-of-sovereign-grace-churches-8bmp.pdf">rationale</a> for recommending that SGC not launch an independent third-party investigation.</p><p>The issues SGC has faced nationally have not majorly affected us as a local church. We have benefited from SGC’s recommended policies and resources and have eagerly supported our <a href="https://www.sovereigngrace.com/s/Approved-Revised-SG-Statement-on-Child-Sexual-Abuse-191105.pdf">denominational statements on sexual abuse</a> and amendments to the Book of Church Order (section 12.4).</p><p>Nonetheless, the national dialogue about this issue and how SGC should respond has affected us for two reasons: First, we believe it is important that our history not be murky, that we must address allegations with honesty and transparency for the sake of our own integrity and for the reputation of the Gospel. Second, we care about what matters to our neighbors — and they care deeply about these issues. A lack of clarity about our past could deter many for whom a local history of clerical abuse is still an open wound.</p><p>In the wake of the <em>Boston Globe</em>’s 2002 Spotlight investigations into child abuse within the Roman Catholic church, Manchester, NH, was one of the cities <a href="http://archive.boston.com/globe/spotlight/abuse/stories4/012603_folo.htm">found</a> to have a bishop who enabled abusive priests: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_abuse_scandal_in_Manchester_diocese#14_priests_named_for_abuse">Fourteen</a> sexual predators continued to hold positions of power and authority in the church despite the church’s awareness of their sins against God, their flocks, and the state. The institutional cover-up (not to mention the crimes themselves) devastated the reputation of the Catholic church — and, for some, Christianity itself — in one of the most heavily Catholic parts of the country. The Catholic church’s response communicated disregard for the abuse of children, lacking humility, introspection, and repentance.</p><p>With this local history recent and personal, our neighbors care about institutional accountability on the issue of child sexual abuse. They want to see courageous and determined systems to ensure current and future accountability for child safety <em>and</em> a humble, transparent accountability for the past. This is a matter of justice that our neighbors feel through common grace, and they have not experienced a church that pursues introspection and care on this issue. While those betrayed by a religious organization are looking for Jesus, we must show them that Jesus’ people will walk with them in their pain and recovery. This includes being honest about potential past mistakes, failures, and malpractice.</p><p>The Leadership Team asks, “Does an entire denomination have to prove its innocence, based upon a presumption of guilt, for every accusation made online, whether it has been substantiated or not?” No, and indeed we agree that both the church and its elders have the right to presumption of innocence, and that they are not legally or morally obligated to clear their names. Insofar as we believe that a pastor innocent of the charges laid against him has the right to assert his innocence, we agree with the Leadership Team’s statements. But we also recognize that at times exercise of some rights can hinder Gospel witness.</p><p>Take the Apostle Paul’s example: “We have not made use of this right [to pastoral compensation], but <em>we endure anything rather than put an obstacle in the way of the gospel of Christ</em>” (1 Corinthians 9:12). His aim is the advance the Gospel, a reward greater than the payment he deserved, a reward apparently obtained through his sacrifice of a legitimate right. “What then is my reward? That in my preaching I may present the gospel free of charge, so as not to make full use of my right in the gospel” (1 Corinthians 9:18). Paul saw fit to surrender a right so that he might identify more deeply with, learn from, and witness to those to whom faithful Gospel witness is due. “To the weak I became weak, that I might win the weak. I have become all things to all people, that by all means I might save some. I do it all for the sake of the gospel, that I may share with them in its blessings” (1 Corinthians 9:22–23).</p><p>Our neighborhood is weak from the injustice of child sexual abuse. With no concrete evidence against them, our pastors certainly have a right to maintain their innocence of the charges of pastoral malpractice, but what is the reward of claiming this right? What is the alternative? Could we win some of the weak by becoming weak — not falsely claiming guilt where we are innocent, but taking on the burden of proof and submitting to impartial (and therefore more credible) investigators?</p><p>We have an opportunity to humble ourselves and practice Gospel witness, a chance to show our neighbors, weakened by persistent injustice, that the church is a place for weak people. If we, as the Leadership Team has recommended, refuse to surrender our position of strength, we fear we are refusing to “become all things to all people” and, disastrously, hindering those we serve from hearing simply “of Christ and him crucified” (1 Cor 2:2).</p><p>While it is appropriate for SGC elders to assert their innocence, we believe that the church’s right to investigate through a third-party — for the sake of Gospel witness — should also be asserted. Our elders should submit on this matter for the sake of the church’s witness before a watching world. To the best of our knowledge, the allegations of widespread conspiracy to cover up pastoral malpractice within our churches are unfounded. Yet we care about how our witness on this matter is interpreted by our neighbors. We want accountability on this issue and want to know if there are any valid claims about our past concerning pastoral malpractice.</p><p>Are their measures we can go to that could establish evidence or innocence on these charges? Yes. Some type of third-party investigation can be commissioned. While the rationale paper presented by SGC’s Leadership Team implies that there is only one option for how to engage this question — a comprehensive church-by-church private criminal investigation that would disregard biblical teaching and amount to an attack on the accused — that is simply not the case. Rachael Denhollander’s public comments have made clear that there are “multiple independent firms capable of carrying out” an investigation that “did not violate SGC’s ecclesiology,” and simple research into the available entities to investigate these claims proves this true.</p><p>In our perspective, Sovereign Grace Church’s Leadership Team’s public statements have consistently lacked the appropriate humility about these allegations of pastoral malpractice in our history, and have sidestepped the agreed process our churches have approved in our Book of Church Order.</p><p>While we would like to present a case for what a third party investigation could look like, the more critical point to the nature of SGC’s partnership and voice on this matter needs to be addressed. While this may seem like a technicality to some, the reality is that the Leadership Team’s recommendation is only that, a recommendation. It is not binding, nor authoritative for Sovereign Grace Churches. The only body in SGC that can make authoritative, binding decisions and statements for our denomination is the Council of Elders.</p><p>This is why we have long maintained that the only appropriate avenue for engaging these allegations is in the Council of Elders. We may not all agree on solutions, but we must all own the decisions together. That is what we agreed to in our partnership agreement. If the elders of SGC do not convene to deliberate and decide on this issue, then our polity will retreat to our apostolic roots which was the time period of these alleged policies and events. If the elders of SGC do not convene to decide on how we will address these allegations about our past, we will be retreating from the important progress we have made in our ecclesiastical union. We must acknowledge our responsibility as the voice of SGC, address whatever mistakes we can from our past, and in repentance and faith, move forward together.</p><p>What follows is another letter that we wrote in February, 2018. At the time, we set it aside in the spirit of preserving unity and in the hope that the work and events of 2018 that were in motion would lead to SGC satisfactorily addressing the allegations regarding pastoral malpractice. We publish this letter as well because the arguments in it still deserve consideration.</p><p>While we have dissented from the Leadership Team’s position for a while, we have not dissented from our partnership. At this juncture, our eldership feels that we must put forward our thoughts for other elders and members of SGC to consider, along with registering with our broader family in Christ where we stand on this important issue.</p><p>With you in the grace of the Gospel,<br>Pastor Jacob Young,<br>With the elders and members of:<br><a href="http://kingscrossmanchester.com/">King’s Cross Church</a></p><h4>An Appeal to Sovereign Grace Churches (February 2018)</h4><p>From the very beginning of our church plant we have been deeply grateful for our partnership with Sovereign Grace Churches. We exist because of their training and equipping. We have thrived thanks to their care, support and friendship. We are a Sovereign Grace Church, and are grateful to be bound with like-minded men and women around a common confession of faith, order of church government, and mission initiatives.</p><p>In recent years, Sovereign Grace has walked through very difficult and turbulent waters regarding our past. There have been many questions; questions about allegations of improper handling of sexual abuse within our churches, and questions regarding our policies of pastoral practice. These questions are right to ask. These questions address serious ethical issues. Knowing the love of Jesus for the safety and flourishing of children, and concern for the reputation of his churches and his pastors and thereby the reputation of the Gospel to the watching world, these questions must be answered.</p><p><strong>Over the last five years,</strong> SGC has had ample opportunity to publicly address these questions. Answering them publicly would have been both humble and wise, and would have bolstered the reputation of the Gospel through our churches. Despite SGC’s virtual silence on these issues, in God’s good providence these questions still demand answers.</p><p>Last year, Rachael Denhollander raised serious questions about specific points of our history on this topic, and to date SGC has <a href="https://sovereigngrace.com/sovereign-grace-churches-response-to-christianity-today-article/">made</a> <a href="https://sovereigngrace.com/a-response-to-allegations-against-sovereign-grace-churches/">three</a> <a href="https://sovereigngrace.com/sovereign-grace-churches-statement-to-christianity-today/">public</a> responses to her, including an <a href="https://sovereigngrace.com/an-open-letter-to-members-of-sovereign-grace-churches/">initial letter</a> in 2014 about the civil lawsuit dismissal. These responses have been substantively true in judgement but marked with an unnecessarily defensive and combative tone. The Gospel-centered attitude we claim for ourselves should invite critique and acknowledge specific areas of repentance and change. These responses failed to display that attitude, and our posture to point has failed to humbly invite an objective evaluation of our past that give an account to our brothers and sisters in Christ such as Rachel Denhollander.</p><p>During our crisis a few years ago we invited a third party investigation into our leadership culture. The resulting report by the Ambassadors of Reconciliation was very helpful in evaluating the dysfunction and unhealthy dynamics of our leadership — issues that needed repentance, faith, and change. Additionally, on an annual basis we have third party evaluations of our finances. With that in mind, it is contrary to our values and history for SGC to baldly refuse any third party investigation into the questions about past allegations.</p><p><strong>We strongly disagree with this posture.</strong> While we are extremely grateful for the work to improve our churches policies and procedures moving forward, we believe there is still work to be done regarding past allegations. We appeal to SGC to work with a credible third party to investigate these past issues and make a public report. If we truly believe the Gospel says the worst about us but promises unending grace for confession and change, then we have nothing to lose by this investigation, and everything to gain. Further, we have an obligation to our broad family of evangelical brothers and sisters to give an account of these issues because we are bound together in Christ, united by the same Gospel and cause. Our broader family not only looks to us for answers, but also an example of how to respond to these questions in a distinctly Christian manner.</p><blockquote>We strongly disagree with the tone and posture of SGC’s public statements regarding Rachael Denhollander’s questions, and SGC’s refusal of a third party investigation with public findings.</blockquote><p>In our Father’s good providence, we believe that this issue has been pressed upon us for the good and reputation of our pastors and our churches, and for the advance of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, who himself deeply cares about the safety and flourishing of our children. We fear our negligence in answering these questions has resulted in our leaders delegating leadership in this area to our lawyers, rather than leaning whole-bodied into these questions for our own good, and the good of others.</p><p><strong>We must change this.</strong> We appeal to all Sovereign Grace elders that we change our tone and posture on this issue. Our elders must call a Special Counsel of Elders to deliberate this issue for ourselves (see BCO 15.2.2). Let us invite a third party investigation with public findings. Our Father cares about this issue, and we must set an example by expressing his heart with public accountability. We must do this for the reputation of the Gospel, for the reputation of our churches, and for the protection of our children into future generations.</p><p>With you in the Gospel,<br>Pastor Jacob Young,<br>With the elders of:<br><a href="http://kingscrossmanchester.com/">King’s Cross Church</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f27dbd4cd610" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>