<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by James A. Coffman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by James A. Coffman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 10:30:58 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A 50-year Quest Motivated by a Question]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/a-50-year-quest-motivated-by-a-question-356c61b37ba2?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/356c61b37ba2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 02 May 2026 01:48:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-05T19:49:49.415Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Keynote lecture given at the </em><a href="https://mdibl.org/conference/53rd-mbmss/"><em>53rd annual Maine Biological and Medical Sciences Symposium</em></a><em>, held April 24–25, 2026, at the </em><a href="https://mdibl.org/"><em>MDI Biological Laboratory </em></a><em>in Bar Harbor, Maine.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F__4pbA5sy7uk74CY48hwQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The expansion of the universe at/after Big Bang. From <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:CMB_Timeline300_no_WMAP.jpg">Wikimedia Commons</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>The first lesson I have for my students is that <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/science-what-it-is-and-how-it-works-10fe1c9d3d1c">science</a> <em>always</em> starts with a question. Therefore, when communicating findings of scientific research, one should always begin by clearly stating the question motivating the research (it’s remarkable how many scientists and would-be scientists fail to do this). For a scientist, the best questions are those that excite you enough to get you out of bed in the morning and keep you going through all the frustrations and setbacks that inevitably come with scientific research. When I was a kid, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/why-things-are-the-way-they-are-and-how-they-came-to-be-a1ff30043f68">the questions</a> that got me out of bed and excited me more than anything concerned dinosaurs (prehistoric time), and space (the final frontier!). Learning about both prompted me to ask: <em>how did the world as we know it come to be</em>? And part-and-parcel with the same question: <em>why are things the way they are</em> (and not something different)?</p><p>Science has provided some incomplete answers to these questions (note that answers provided by science are <a href="https://global.oup.com/academic/product/ignorance-9780199828074?cc=us&amp;lang=en&amp;#"><em>always</em> incomplete</a>, because they invariably produce more, and ever-more refined, questions). At the largest scale, the answer is cosmological: the 4-dimensional structure of universe describes how we arrived here in our solar system within the Milky Way galaxy via the development, through ~14 billion years of spacetime, of matter and energy from its inception in the Big Bang. After earth precipitated from the debris disk of the primordial solar system, the cooling of its internal fires fueled <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3685457/">an engine that autocatalytically generated life from prebiotic geochemistry</a>. The development of life on earth (note that I purposefully use the word “development”, rather than “evolution”, for reasons that should become clear by the end of this lecture) was a process that proceeded through a series of distinct stages over the 4.5 billion years of earth’s history. Following the emergence of the cell that was the <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-024-02474-w">Last Universal Common Ancestor (LUCA) ~4.2 billion years ago</a> (Ga), it took another billion years for cellular life to develop the ability to harness the sun’s energy through photosynthesis. That, likely in combination with plate tectonics, led to the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event">Great Oxygenation Event</a> ~2.5 Ga, which was followed by the emergence of eukaryotic cells via <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endosymbiont">endosymbiosis</a>. A second “Neoproterozoic” oxygenation event ~1 Ga was followed by drastic cooling that froze the entire planet (“<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowball_Earth">snowball earth</a>”) about 700 million years ago. But this was followed by massive CO2 release through volcanism (raising atmospheric CO2 levels to ~20 times their current levels), which thawed the snowball via the resulting greenhouse effect. This was followed by the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambrian_explosion">Cambrian Explosion</a>: the emergence ~0.5 Ga of complex multicellular life in the form of plants and animals. Thus, complex life and the biosphere as we know it did not emerge until quite recently in earth’s 4.5-billion-year history, following a 4-billion-year period that included several distinct stages involving dramatic and often cataclysmic changes in the planet’s surface, oceans, climate, and atmosphere that allowed only a relatively simple form of life compared to what exists now.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/766/1*Xmkx7GHD1thl2uC-NN99Hg.png" /><figcaption>Proposed presence of oxygen in our atmosphere over Earth’s Geological timescale. From <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Timeline_showing_the_Boring_Billion.png">Wikimedia Commons</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>The Cambrian Explosion produced our entire animal family tree, which includes all animal species alive today, as well as all those that are now extinct. One of the major branches of that tree is the deuterostomes (animals that form an anus before forming a mouth during their early development, in contrast to protostomes, which form the mouth first), which include us (humans and all other vertebrates), as well as echinoderms (e.g., sea stars, sea lilies, and sea urchins). The topology of the family tree, which is based on various converging lines of evidence, indicates that we are more closely related to sea urchins than we are to other, non-deuterostome invertebrates. In other words, our common ancestor with sea urchins is more recent than that which we share with flies and worms. When I worked with sea urchins as a research model (as I will describe shortly) this phylogenetic relationship was one of the attributes that made them a good model for biomedical research.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/678/1*kXfq2zWjwBBT1SD5bgnnQA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Phylogenetic tree showing the relationship between humans and sea urchins. This figure was part of the <a href="https://www.genome.gov/Pages/Research/Sequencing/SeqProposals/SeaUrchin_Genome.pdf">white paper</a> that was submitted to the NIH to justify sequencing of the sea urchin (S. purpuratus) genome in 2005. From <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Urchin_Phylogeny.jpg">Wikimedia Commons</a>.</figcaption></figure><p>Considering this knowledge, the central question that I have been asking since I was a kid (how did our world come to be?) can be refined to the more focused question of how does evolution of life on earth work? What we know (thanks to Darwin, Wallace and their successors) is this: organismal species are naturally selected products of the evolutionary tree of life that emerged from pre-biotic geochemistry and is inherently and continuously regenerative. We are here because all our ancestors, going back 4.2 Ga to the LUCA, had the good fortune of surviving long enough to reproduce. Furthermore, each of us exists by virtue of development that is both <em>genetically informed</em> and <em>environmentally responsive</em> (i.e., <em>plastic</em>). This raises the question: how do genes direct ontogeny and constrain plasticity? What we know is that genes are parts of genetic and cellular regulatory networks and circuits that cybernetically control developmental processes and adaptive/physiological plasticity/responsivity. Finally, we might ask: given the fact that development is plastic and that life itself is inherently regenerative, why can’t we humans regenerate lost or damaged body parts like many other animals can? Relatedly, why don’t we enjoy <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negligible_senescence">negligible senescence</a> like some other animal species do?</p><p>I have been pursuing these questions in a 50-year quest that began in earnest in high school. In 1976 I learned (in high school AP Biology) about the newly emergent field of molecular biology and DNA cloning (and, in a <a href="https://www.jstor.org/stable/24949774"><em>Scientific American</em> article by Robert Bakker</a>, that birds are dinosaurs!). Still motivated by my big existential question, I decided then and there to address the question scientifically, by pursuing a career in biology (or paleontology). In 1981 I graduated from college with a B.A. in biology and an abiding interest in evolution but had no success in applying to graduate school and no clear plan for how to move forward with that. (So, I decided to instead indulge my other lifelong passion, music, and play professionally, which lasted two years before I learned that depending on music for a living took much of the fun out of it). In 1983, after visiting the journal stacks in academic libraries and reading scientific literature (stemming from my reading in college of Stephen J. Gould’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontogeny_and_Phylogeny"><em>Ontogeny and Phylogeny</em></a>), and then writing letters to various evolutionary biologists whose work inspired me, I successfully applied to graduate school with a more focused question: how do changes in (the genes that control) development result in organismal macroevolution?</p><p>In 1984 I started graduate school and, quite fortuitously, was selected to receive an NIH training grant fellowship in cell and molecular biology, just as the discovery of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeobox">homeobox </a>jumpstarted the new field of “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolutionary_developmental_biology">Evo-Devo</a>” (evolutionary developmental biology). In 1985 I refocused my attention entirely on developmental biology (something I had not previously thought much about except as a black box in evolution) after working for a semester in <a href="https://medschool.duke.edu/profile/david-r-mcclay">David McClay</a>’s lab and falling in love with sea urchin embryos. That same year I discovered the work of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_H._Davidson">Eric Davidson</a>, which “removed the scales from my eyes” for how best to answer my big motivating question. So, in 1990, after completing my Ph.D., I loaded up my VW van and drove cross-country to Pasadena, to begin postdoctoral training with Eric Davidson at Caltech.</p><p>In 1995, while perusing the library stacks at Caltech I came across the book <a href="https://direct.mit.edu/books/monograph/4353/Development-and-EvolutionComplexity-and-Change-in"><em>Development and Evolution</em></a> by <a href="https://www.nbi.dk/~natphil/salthe/">Stanley Salthe</a>. I checked it out and read it, and it blew my mind. I wrote a short synopsis that related the ideas developed in the book to my own questions and work, which I sent to Salthe with a letter; he replied with a generous letter that began a correspondence that continued for the next 30 years, until his death in 2024. That same year I completed my postdoctoral training and joined the <a href="https://www.stowers.org/history-mission">Stowers Institute for Medical Research</a> as a Senior Research Associate of Eric Davidson at Caltech. Then, in 2000, I started my own sea urchin molecular embryology lab at the new Stowers Institute in Kansas City. In 2005 I got my first NIH research grant (R01) and moved my lab to the <a href="https://mdibl.org/">Mount Desert Island Biological Laboratory</a>, where I continued to work on molecular embryology of sea urchins. Finally, in 2014, I retooled my lab to work with zebrafish as a model organism to study stress-induced <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Developmental_origins_of_health_and_disease">developmental programming</a> in vertebrates. What had started out as a quest motivated by a big question evolved into a scientific career that addressed the many narrower (but ultimately related) questions that inevitably popped up along the way, leading to numerous discoveries and publications.</p><p>When I was a graduate student, the paper that provided a key to addressing my big question was ‘<a href="https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.165.3891.349">Gene Regulation in Higher Eukaryotes: A Theory</a>’, by Roy Britten and Eric Davidson (published in <em>Science</em> in 1969). That paper proposed that genes control organismal development and physiology by regulating the activity of other genes, via what we now refer to as gene regulatory networks. When I joined Eric Davidson’s lab as a postdoctoral fellow in 1990, I was tasked with identifying the regulators of a gene (“<em>CyIIIa</em>”, encoding a cytoskeletal actin protein) that is developmentally activated in only one part of the sea urchin embryo (the dorsal ectoderm). <em>CyIIIa</em> thus served as a model system for studying spatiotemporal gene regulation during animal development. Our approach was biochemical, which took advantage of the fact that a single sea urchin female produces millions of eggs that, when fertilized (externally, as when they spawn in the wild), all develop synchronously as embryos. Purple sea urchins (<em>Strongylocentrotus purpuratus</em>) are very common and readily available by the thousands on the California coast and thus provided the large amount of raw material needed to purify the relatively low abundance proteins (“transcription factors”) that regulate gene activity.</p><p>Our approach then was to collect and spawn thousands of sea urchins to obtain sperm and eggs (done by teams of Davidson lab students and postdocs at Caltech’s <a href="https://kml.caltech.edu/">Kerckhoff Marine Lab</a>), fertilize the eggs with the sperm, then culture the resulting embryos overnight in large culture vessels constructed in house from hardware and 20-gallon garbage cans. The embryos were developed to blastula stage, a stage of development when we knew that the transcription factors we were interested in were present and active. Previous studies in the Davidson lab, using sophisticated molecular biology techniques combined with microscopy to monitor gene activity within developing embryos, had identified DNA sequences within the <em>CyIIIa</em> gene that were bound by different proteins, which controlled the transcription of the gene’s protein-coding DNA into RNA, either positively (transcriptional activation) or negatively (transcriptional repression). My task was to purify those proteins so that they, and the genes that encoded them, could be identified. To that end, I worked with a computer programmer (the late James G. Moore) to repurpose a commercially available Gilson robot to carry out <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/1308810/">tandem affinity chromatography</a>, a technique whereby proteins extracted from the cultured sea urchin embryos were passed through a tandem series of up to 12 cartridges, each containing a matrix bearing a short DNA sequence (oligonucleotide) corresponding to a segment of the <em>CyIIIa</em> gene known to be bound by a specific transcription factor. Thus, as the extracted proteins passed through one cartridge and on to the next, the protein with a high affinity for the specific DNA sequence in one cartridge would bind the DNA and remain in the cartridge, and the rest would pass through on to the next cartridge, and so on down the line. Each cartridge could then be “eluted” using a salt gradient that disrupted the binding of protein to DNA, freeing each bound and now purified protein for collection. In that way we were able to simultaneously purify eight of the 10 transcription factors that combinatorially regulate <em>CyIIIa</em> activity. The purified proteins were then subjected to protein sequencing, and the protein sequences were used to reverse design oligonucleotide probes for screening libraries of cloned DNA to isolate clones of the genes that encoded the proteins. Obtaining the sequence of the cloned DNA then identified the cognate regulatory genes.</p><p>That work in the 1990s resulted in my co-authoring <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=coffman+ja+%5Bau%5D+davidson+%5Bau%5D+%28SpGCF1+or+SpOct+or+SpRunt-1+or+SpMyb%29+%28development+%5Bjo%5D+or+developmental+biology+%5Bjo%5D%29&amp;sort=pubdate">several peer-reviewed research publications</a>, each one of which described a single transcription factor that had been purified and cloned, along with its function as an activator or repressor of <em>CyIIIa</em> activity (elucidated in parallel work of collaborators). Towards the end of that period (1997) Eric Davidson used all that information, along with many other studies reported in the literature at that time, to update his gene regulatory network model, in a paper entitled “<a href="https://journals.biologists.com/dev/article-abstract/124/10/1851/39223/The-hardwiring-of-development-organization-and">The Hardwiring of Development</a>” that he wrote with Ina Arnone (another postdoctoral fellow in his lab, <a href="https://www.szn.it/index.php/en/staff/list-of-personnel/219-arnone-maria-i/503-arnone-maria-i">now at the Stazione Zoologica Anton Dohrn</a> in Naples, Italy) and published in the journal <em>Development</em>. That paper provided a conceptual model of how gene regulatory networks consisting of interacting genes that, through activation and repression that progressively determines when and where (in what cells) proteins (including transcription factors) are active, control animal development to produce a complex multicellular organism like a sea urchin, a fly, a mouse, or a human being. The paper was a general conceptual model for understanding the holy grail of developmental biology: the genetic program of development that maps “genotype” to “phenotype”.</p><p>A lot of work in the three decades since that paper was published have borne and fleshed out the conceptual model with actual developmental gene regulatory networks, demonstrating that development is indeed “hardwired” in the way envisioned by Davidson and colleagues. But development is also plastic, which means that it responds to environmental factors that impact the developing organism via direct effects on its anatomy, physiology, and metabolism. An example from my own research <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=coffman+ja+%5Bau%5D+developmental+biology+%5Bjo%5D+%22Oral-aboral+axis+specification%22&amp;sort=pubdate">is development of the dorsal-ventral axis of the sea urchin embryo</a>. Much of the “hardwired” <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2677136/">gene regulatory network</a> (GRN) that controls that development has been worked out, and under normal environmental circumstances encountered by developing embryos it suffices to predictably (via the combinatory logic of activation and repression encoded in the network circuitry) produce a bilaterally symmetric pluteus larva with dorsal-ventral polarity. However, under some environmental conditions — for example, low oxygen (hypoxia) — the embryo develops differently, becoming radially rather than bilaterally symmetric due to failure to develop a dorsal-ventral axis. The reason for that is that activity of a gene (“<em>nodal</em>”) that is instrumental in activating the GRN directing development of the dorsal-ventral axis is sensitive to metabolic signals involving oxygen. While under conditions of normal oxygen <em>nodal</em> activity is confined to one side of the embryo (the side thus destined to become the ventral pole of the larva), <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0012160613006970?via%3Dihub">under hypoxia that confinement fails</a>, and instead <em>nodal</em> is expressed circumferentially, leading to altered activity of the entire <em>nodal</em>-dependent GRN, and consequently “ventralization” of the ectoderm. Development of a dorsal-ventral axis is thus not only hardwired, but also plastic, responsive to environmental signals like oxygen.</p><p>The “hardwired” aspect of development is the information that we often refer to as genetic or “nature”, while the plastic aspect is what we refer to as epigenetic (literally, on top of genetics) or “nurture”. The term ‘epigenetic’ was coined by developmental biologist <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C._H._Waddington">Conrad Waddington</a>, who in the mid-20th century showed in experiments with fruit flies that wing development in genetically identical flies could be altered by environmental stressors. Furthermore, Waddington demonstrated that, by selectively breeding flies with environmentally induced wing aberrations, he could eventually produce flies that developed the same aberrations in the absence of those stressors, a phenomenon that he referred to as “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetic_assimilation">genetic assimilation</a> of acquired characteristics”. Waddington’s findings were quite controversial when he published them, as they ran afoul of the neo-Darwinian dogma of the time, with its rigid “anti-<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamarckism">Lamarckian</a>” stance against the idea that developmentally acquired characters can play any role in evolution (a stance that we now know was wrong, by virtue of much research in evolutionary developmental biology and epigenetics over the past 50 years).</p><p>What links developmental hardwiring and plasticity are genes, like the <em>nodal</em> gene discussed above, that play key roles in development and are also responsive to environmental signals. Among animals, sea urchins are remarkable for their developmental plasticity, which is one among the many attributes that lend them to research in developmental biology. Most sea urchin species undergo an indirect form of development, wherein the embryo produces a planktonic, feeding larva called a pluteus, which then serves as an incubator for nested development of the sea urchin itself, which emerges via a dramatic <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oJ9N1s5e0R_hohhnwdMY4w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Metamorphosis transforms a pluteus (left, photomicrograph taken by the author) into a sea urchin (right, original image by Ratha Grimes, obtained from <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Urchin.jpg">Wikimedia Commons</a>; licensed under the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/en:Creative_Commons">Creative Commons</a> <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/deed.en">Attribution 2.0 Generic</a> license; cropped by the author). The images are not to scale; the pluteus is a fraction of a millimeter in length whereas the sea urchin is several centimeters in diameter. The adult sea urchin is entirely derived from the small disc-like rudiment on the side of the gut in the body cavity of the pluteus, as indicated by the arrow.</figcaption></figure><p>Development of larvae toward metamorphosis is plastic, depending among other things on availability of food (the pluteus subsists on a diet of phytoplankton). When food is plentiful, the pluteus rapidly develops to, and then undergoes, metamorphosis into a sea urchin. However, when food is scarce, the pluteus remains a pluteus, and instead grows (lengthens) its ciliated arms to better collect food. <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4706744/">Research in my lab</a> investigated this to identify genes that are activated in response to low food availability, identifying transcription factors (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CREB">Creb</a> and <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ELK1">Elk</a>) that are known from other studies to be involved in response to low-nutrient stress, as well as a transcription factor (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FOXJ1">FoxJ1</a>) that controls development of cilia. We also found that development of the pluteus toward metamorphosis can be inhibited by <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sirolimus">rapamycin</a>, a drug that inhibits a well-studied nutrient sensing regulatory enzyme called <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MTOR">TOR</a> (“target of rapamycin”). Thus, the food-responsive developmental plasticity of sea urchin larvae is controlled by highly conserved nutrient sensing regulators present throughout the animal kingdom. Interestingly, TOR also turns out to be a critical regulator of mammalian (including human) aging, as rapamycin and other TOR inhibitors have been found to significantly extend lifespan (please note that it is inadvisable to take rapamycin, because it is also an immunosuppressant).</p><p>Adult sea urchins are also developmentally plastic, to the extent that they are able to regenerate lost body parts such as tube feet and spines. Moreover, some species of sea urchins have a remarkably long lifespan (up to or possibly more than 200 years), while others are relatively short-lived (5 years in the wild). The last research project I did with sea urchins (in collaboration with my colleague <a href="https://www.gmgi.org/about/team/leadership/andrea-bodnar-phd/">Andrea Bodnar</a>) addressed the question of whether the difference in lifespan between the short-lived and long-lived species could be attributed to loss of plasticity (regenerative potential) with age (senescence) in the former but not the latter. <a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/acel.12487">What we found</a> was that the oldest specimens of the short-lived species regenerated their spines and tube feet just as effectively as those of the longer-lived species, indicating that, unlike in humans, aging in sea urchins is not accompanied by loss of regenerative capacity. We still don’t know why the lifespans of short-lived sea urchins are short, which remains a question for more research. It could be that they age in ways we failed to detect because we did not examine every system (e.g., we did not look at the immune system). But for the anatomical features that we examined, both short-lived and long-lived sea urchins appear to have negligible senescence.</p><p>A central question motivating research at the MDI Biological Laboratory is why do mammals (including humans) lack the regenerative developmental plasticity of most non-amniote species (amniotes are reptiles, birds, and mammals)? <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/chapter/edited-volume/abs/pii/B978012814879200008X">I have argued</a> that to answer that question we need to take into consideration not only the molecular and cellular mechanisms of development and regeneration, but also how those mechanisms have changed and been constrained through animal evolution, within the context of the environments that animals (including our ancestors) have evolved. That is, we need to take an “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecological_evolutionary_developmental_biology">eco-evo-devo</a>” approach to the question. If you survey animal phylogeny, two things stand out. First, most animal species across the phylogenetic tree are capable of some form of somatic (i.e., body) regeneration; those (like us) that are incapable of regeneration are a minority of species at the tips of a few branches, suggesting that the ancestral evolution along those branches entailed loss of regenerative capacity. Second, there is an inverse correlation between somatic regenerative capacity and organismal complexity (measured for example by number of cell types) and metabolic rate.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iRgkNzuPw2NF4bkB8vB-GQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>The inverse relationship between regenerative abilities and complexity in animals. Figure is the author’s own work, modified from <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B978012814879200008X">Regenerative potential across species: an eco-evo-devo perspective</a>. Coffman, J.A. (2019).</figcaption></figure><p>The general processes involved in somatic regeneration can be generally grouped into three phases: emergency repair and defense (wound healing), remodeling, and patterned growth and development. Where regeneration fails in non-regenerative species is during the critical remodeling phase, indicating that lack of regenerative potential is due to lack of developmental plasticity. Interestingly, examination of just the vertebrate branch of the animal tree reveals that the lack of somatic regenerative potential is mostly confined to amniotes (reptiles, birds, and mammals) and is most pronounced in birds and mammals (warm blooded amniotes). This suggests that loss of somatic regenerative capacity in vertebrate evolution was associated with the evolution of completely terrestrial life cycle, and subsequently, the evolution of endothermy (metabolic production of body heat).</p><p>We should thus ask: what constraints and tradeoffs accompanied evolution of amniotes? What we know is that a fully terrestrial life cycle required the evolution of eggs with hard shells, which has no obvious bearing on regenerative potential (although it may nonetheless be somehow relevant). In addition, terrestrial environments have higher oxygen concentration than aquatic environments, which means that metabolism will produce higher levels of mutagenic reactive oxygen species (ROS). Acquisition of endothermy entailed a further increase in oxygen utilization (to generate heat via mitochondria), and hence further increase in mutagenic ROS production. In addition, the basal metabolic rate of endotherms is higher than in ectotherms (“cold blooded” animals), which means that everything happens faster, requiring greater precision. Given that ROS-induced DNA mutation is one of the ways that cells can become cancerous, all of this suggests that the evolution of amniotes, and especially endothermic amniotes, entailed increased selection pressure for tumor suppression. Tumor suppression is achieved via specific regulatory genes that activate cellular processes that kill or neutralize rogue cells, and via the immune system, which surveils for, kills, and removes cancerous cells. Available evidence indicates that both types of mechanism limit somatic regenerative potential in mammals.</p><p>We might thus hypothesize that somatic regenerative capacity in endothermic amniotes (birds, mammals) was traded to accommodate the increased need for tumor suppression that came with evolution of terrestriality and endothermy. The implication is that, to answer the question “why do we lack the regenerative potential of salamanders?” we should investigate tumor suppressive systems, including the immune system, and compare them between regenerative and non-regenerative animals. This is indeed a hot topic of cutting-edge research in regenerative biology. The increased need for tumor suppression in endothermic amniotes is also relevant to the related question of why we mammals are not the beneficiaries of negligible senescence: <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cellular_senescence">cellular senescence</a> is a mechanism for tumor suppression.</p><p>The last decade of my research program has been focused on the role of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Developmental_origins_of_health_and_disease">developmental plasticity in health and disease</a>. The plasticity of early development means that environmental exposures at that stage can alter the trajectory of development in ways that impact later life health and disease risk. Human epidemiology as well as studies in animal research models have shown that early life stress and/or toxic exposures increase risk of mental disorders and chronic age-related metabolic/inflammatory diseases in adulthood. The question we are asking in our research is how? Our working hypothesis is that during the plastic stages of immaturity, adaptation to chronically elevated levels of stress signals such as the steroid hormone cortisol establishes persistent physiological set points (e.g., for basal cortisol levels) that compromise neuroendocrine/immune system responsivity, which decreases adaptive plasticity (including regenerative capacity) in maturity. This raises the questions: (1) does exposure to chronically elevated cortisol during early development decrease regenerative capacity in adulthood? And (2) if so, what are the regulatory genes, cells, and mechanisms that mediate that effect?</p><p>To address those questions, <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=coffman+ja+%5Bau%5D+zebrafish+%28stress+or+cortisol+or+klf9%29+NOT+atrogin&amp;sort=pubdate">we turned to using zebrafish as a model organism</a>, because like us, zebrafish are vertebrates that use cortisol as a stress hormone (reflecting the fact that we evolved from fish). Unlike us, zebrafish are highly regenerative and can regenerate lost or damaged body parts like fins, or even hearts. Finally, unlike us, zebrafish develop externally, making it easy to observe and manipulate their development. We therefore set out to address our research questions by treating zebrafish embryos chronically over the first 5 days of their development (up to the end of larval development when they begin feeding on their own) with cortisol. The first thing we found was that the treated fish gave rise to adults (5 months later, long after the treatment) that maintained elevated cortisol levels, indicating that the treatment had indeed raised the setpoint for basal cortisol levels, as predicted by our hypothesis. We also found that following surgical removal, the tailfins of the treated fish did not regenerate as effectively as those of their untreated siblings, showing higher frequency of abnormalities. To understand why that might be, we analyzed gene expression during tailfin regeneration and found that many genes associated with the immune system and inflammation showed aberrant activity dynamics during tailfin regeneration in the fish derived from cortisol-treated embryos. This likely reflects the fact that cortisol decreases the responsivity of immune cells, which normally infiltrate wounds to kickstart regeneration. Thus, the differences in gene activity observed in the cortisol-treated fish are probably due to a more sluggish inflammatory response to the wound, a possibility that is borne out by our microscopic studies of immune cell dynamics in the cortisol-treated fish. The extent to which the negative impact of the early life cortisol treatment on regeneration is caused by the impact on immune cell dynamics remains an open question for research.</p><p>The other question we have addressed is what genes are mediating the effects of the cortisol treatment? We know that cortisol exerts its effects through a transcription factor, the glucocorticoid receptor (GR), which is present in all cells. But the question then becomes: what genes are regulated by the GR, and which of these further regulates the response to cortisol? One such gene is <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FKBP5"><em>fkbp5</em></a>, which encodes a protein that inhibits the activity of the GR. Thus, by activating <em>fkbp5</em>, the GR activates an intracellular negative feedback loop that increases resistance to the cortisol. <em>Fkbp5</em> is a particularly interesting gene because in humans it has been shown to <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/npp2015235">mediate adverse health effects of stress</a>, by increasing glucocorticoid resistance and thus diminishing the ability of cortisol to dampen inflammation. Another gene that is activated by the GR in response to cortisol is <em>klf9</em>, which encodes a transcription factor that very often acts as a repressor. In fact, some of the genes repressed by Klf9 are other genes activated by the GR. <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/cell-and-developmental-biology/articles/10.3389/fcell.2021.727037/full">Our work</a> suggests that these include <em>fkbp5</em>. The GR and Klf9 are therefore engaged in “incoherent feedforward regulation”, wherein an activator not only activates a response, but also the brakes that subsequently inactivate that response. Interestingly, both negative feedback (as mediated by <em>fkbp5</em>) and incoherent feedforward regulation (as mediated by <em>klf9</em>) are ubiquitous circuits used in nature to enforce transient, pulsed responses to stimuli. While negative feedback regulation of GR activity by Fkbp5 is well known and studied, the extent and role of incoherent feedforward regulation of GR-responses by Klf9 (including the response of <em>fkbp5</em>) is far less studied and remains an important topic for research. It is likely to be important for immune system regulation, and indeed, Klf9 has <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-45477-8">recently been shown</a> to be a critical regulator of mammalian macrophages (an immune cell type at the front lines of defense and repair that plays a key role in regeneration, among other things).</p><p>I would like to finish up by zooming way back out to make the case that development (broadly defined) is what makes evolution (and everything else, for that matter) intelligible. This is an insight that I obtained in 1995 from the book <a href="https://direct.mit.edu/books/monograph/4353/Development-and-EvolutionComplexity-and-Change-in"><em>Development and Evolution: Complexity and Change in Biology</em></a>, by <a href="https://evodevouniverse.com/wiki/Stanley_N._Salthe">Stanley Salthe</a> (1993, MIT Press), which as I mentioned earlier was a seminal, highly influential read for me. Stan (1930–2024) was a zoologist (who, coincidentally, worked as a student at MDI Bio Lab for a summer in the early 1960s!), evolutionary biologist, and natural philosopher who developed a formal theory of hierarchy, and who melded far-from-equilibrium thermodynamics and information theory (“infodynamics”). I have written extensively about his influence on my thinking (see, e.g., <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">Everything that Exists Came to Be Through a Process of Systemic Development</a>), so won’t elaborate on that here. In addition to being a major influence via his book and many published papers, through our correspondence Stan turned me on to the work of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Ulanowicz">Robert Ulanowicz</a>, a theoretical ecologist and complexity theorist. In a letter to me in 1995 Stan wrote (paraphrasing) that I should read Ulanowicz’s 1987 book <a href="https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-1-4612-4916-0"><em>Growth and Development: Ecosystems Phenomenology</em></a>, then mentally shrink myself down to the size of a sea urchin embryo and imagine how the phenomenology described in that book plays out at the cellular and molecular levels during sea urchin development. So, I did.</p><p>The central idea from which Ulanowicz’s work proceeds is that growth and development of ecosystems is driven by autocatalytic loops. If A, B, C, and D represent processes (e.g. species in an ecosystem), they are engaged in an autocatalytic loop if they interact in a positive feedback cycle, e.g., as in A→B→C→D→A. Autocatalytic loops have two attributes that drive growth and development: they are self-amplifying (positive feedback drives growth), and self-organizing (they exert selection pressure for increased efficiency that drives development). Ulanowicz’s key insight was that the growth-inducing and self-organizing attributes of autocatalytic loops can be measured and described mathematically using <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_theory">information theory</a> (a branch of mathematics developed by Claude Shannon and others). Aspects of ecosystems that are measured in this treatment are total system throughput (<em>TST</em>, how much matter and energy flows through the system over time), average mutual information (<em>AMI</em>, how much information on average can be gleaned about the system from measurements of flow through each of its components, i.e., how organized the system is), and informational entropy (<em>H,</em> how much uncertainty there is in the organization of the system). These measures (each of which is obtained by measuring and summing flux through each of the nodes of a network) can in turn be used to derive three additional quantities: Ascendency (<em>A</em> = <em>TST</em> multiplied by <em>AMI</em>), Development Capacity (<em>C</em> = <em>TST</em> multiplied by <em>H</em>), and Reserve (<em>R</em> = <em>C</em> minus <em>A</em>). In a growing system, <em>TST</em> increases, and in development, <em>A</em> increases toward the limit of <em>C</em>, with a concomitant reduction of <em>R</em>. In the limit of maximal <em>A</em> where <em>R</em> becomes zero (maximal efficiency with no reserve), the system is extremely fragile, as removal of any one component would result in its complete collapse.</p><p>Following Stan Salthe’s advice, and after reading and being inspired by Ulanowicz’s 1997 book <a href="https://people.clas.ufl.edu/ulan/publications/ecosystems/ecolasc/"><em>Ecology: The Ascendent Perspective</em></a>, I generalized these concepts to organismal ontogeny and the gene regulatory networks that control it, which resulted in a paper, ‘<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/233834867_Developmental_Ascendency_From_Bottom-up_to_Top-down_Control">Developmental Ascendency: From Bottom-up to Top-down Control</a>’, published in 2006 in <em>Biological Theory</em>. The paper developed a general conceptual framework for understanding <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2078-2489/2/1/102">the relationship between development and information</a>, which remains fertile ground for research. Bob Ulanowicz and colleagues have continued to use this framework to understand the development of ecosystems and human economies, showing that a narrow “<a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0964569114002038">window of vitality</a>” exists within a 2-dimensional organizational spectrum defined by ascendency along one axis and robustness/sustainability along the second axis, within which systems can either become more efficient at the cost of losing resilience (plasticity), or more resilient (plastic) at the cost of lower efficiency.</p><p>In applying these ideas to trying to understand the regenerative capacity of organisms, I was struck by the relationship between the “macrostate” of cellular phenotype and the “microstate” of its underlying molecular configurations — essentially, the flow network of the molecular ecosystem within a cell. For a cell to become specialized for a specific task (as occurs in organismal development, e.g., as cells differentiate into specialized cells such as skin, nerve, blood, muscle, and gland cells), it must increase its ascendency, which reduces its remaining capacity for development. That explains why regeneration typically requires a reservoir of stem and/or progenitor cells that have much lower ascendency (and concomitantly higher informational entropy) than their differentiated descendants. For a differentiated cell to “transdifferentiate” into a different kind of differentiated cell, it must first dedifferentiate to cross a potential barrier of entropy imposed between the different cell types (analogous to the potential barrier of “activation energy” in a chemical reaction). In contrast, stem cells are maintained in a high entropy (low ascendency) state that poises them atop that potential barrier.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/242/1*jHZduclpLwgCcuC0RAPnGA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The potential barrier of entropy between the phenotypes of differentiated cells (author’s own work).</figcaption></figure><p>This fits with Waddington’s well-known conceptualization of development as a canalized epigenetic landscape, wherein cell differentiation (or organismal development) is imagined to be analogous to a ball rolling downhill through a branching array of valleys or canals. The ball that begins at the top is an undifferentiated stem cell (or egg), and the balls that have arrived at the bottom in different valleys are differentiated cell types (or different organismal phenotypes). The ridges separating the valleys are the potential barriers imposed between cellular or organismal phenotypes, which represent constraints on plasticity.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*VqWCWVP8qtl9hhyUO9ssqA.jpeg" /><figcaption>(A) A Waddington-inspired schematic of the epigenetic landscape. Culture conditions will promote the self-renewal of a pluripotent cell, maintaining it in a shallow well at the top of a cellular potential hill. When allowed to differentiate, this cell will “roll” down the hill into one of many terminally-differentiated fates at lower potential. (B) A closer look at the path a pluripotent cell might take as it differentiates into a neuron, passing through a number of intermediate progenitor states of varying stability on the way. The line in (B) represents a slice through the surface shown in (A). (C) The process of direct reprogramming, like chemical catalyst, implicates a restructuring of the epigenetic landscape. From Rodolfa, K.T., Inducing pluripotency (September 30, 2008), StemBook, ed. The Stem Cell Research Community, StemBook, doi/10.3824/stembook.1.22.1, <a href="http://www.stembook.org/">http://www.stembook.org</a>, via <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:The_epigenetic_landscape_and_its_implications_for_direct_reprogramming..jpg">Wikimedia Commons</a>, licensed under the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/en:Creative_Commons">Creative Commons</a> <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.en">Attribution 3.0 Unported</a> license.</figcaption></figure><p>Computational biologist <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Teschendorff">Andrew Teschendorff</a> has <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms15599">applied the information entropy concept to single cell datasets</a> to show that a loss of network entropy (a measure developed by Teschendorff that is mathematically similar to the informational entropy that Ulanowicz described for the trophic networks of ecosystems, which decreases with increasing ascendency) correlates with loss of developmental potency of during differentiation of stem and progenitor cells into different specialized cell types. Using this conceptual framework to understand how the somatic regenerative capacity of organisms is constrained by development (including evolutionary development through phylogeny) is a promising avenue for research in regenerative biology, as it provides a quantitative means of assessing how different genetic and environmental conditions (or stressors) impact the developmental reserve needed for adaptive plasticity.</p><p>I will end with three take home messages that I take to be axiomatic. First, molecular and cellular mechanisms do not suffice to explain biology, which also involves ecology, history, and complex system development (context is everything!). No biological phenomenon can be adequately understood without accounting for ecological, environmental, historical, and developmental context (“Eco-Evo-Devo”). Thus, for any given system (or species), we should ask how much development (including evolutionary development) went into producing that system (what stage is it along the trajectory immature-mature-senescent)? Mechanistic reductionism, to the extent that it occludes (consideration of) context, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/bubbles-within-bubbles-global-insanity-2025-2bb14e1b4f9f">is problematic</a>. In asking about the causes of any phenomenon, we need to consider all four of Aristotle’s causal categories: <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/causation-is-the-interplay-between-freedom-and-developed-constraint-3e5e66e6d380">Material, Efficient, Formal, and Final</a>. Second, the cell is the fundamental unit of life — cell differentiation/specialization/ efficiency trades on developmental potency (i.e., plasticity). Some processes required for cell reproduction (mitosis/division) preclude or impede those required for cell specialization/differentiation, and vice versa (see Leo Buss, <a href="https://press.princeton.edu/books/hardcover/9780691632858/the-evolution-of-individuality"><em>The Evolution of Individuality</em></a>). Third and finally, developmental plasticity is the basis of adaptive change and hence evolvability — to understand how living systems (can) change (and persist without collapsing completely), we need to elucidate what affords them developmental plasticity.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=356c61b37ba2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Emergence from Emergency]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/emergence-from-emergency-1d0d916e3364?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1d0d916e3364</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[civilization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[united-states]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[future]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 May 2025 14:10:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-15T14:10:32.106Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Our global existential crisis affords an opportunity for civilizational metamorphosis</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*SUfrp4Dn56y3Woqo8-OnVQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Emergence, Pacific Spirit Park, Vancouver, BC (Los Paseos from Earth, CC BY-SA 2.0 &lt;<a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0">https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0</a>&gt;, via Wikimedia Commons)</figcaption></figure><p>A term that refers to the creation or (often relatively sudden) appearance of something new and qualitatively different from its precursors is “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergence">emergence</a>”. Emergence is <a href="https://www.bing.com/search?q=define+emergence&amp;FORM=DCTSRC">defined</a> as the process of (1) coming into view or becoming exposed after being concealed, or (2) coming into being, or of becoming important or prominent. As I have written previously, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">anything that exists came to be via development</a>; thus, emergence occurs via development. Development is a progressive trajectory of system-level change that works to increase certainty and predictability in the service of some specific form of work. It occurs in distinct stages: immaturity, maturity, and senescence. Immature systems are still developing and thus have not fully emerged. An immature system is plastic, such that the character of what is emerging can be derailed or steered to alternative fates via perturbation. Mature systems have fully emerged, but their continued development beyond their developmental capacity brings them into senescence, a rigid, information-bound (“saturated”) state that lacks the plasticity needed to adapt to change and is thus poised for collapse when perturbed. The collapse of a senescent system sets its constituent parts up for recycling, which often occurs via the developmental emergence of a new system from the remains of the old one. Since a senescent system is fragile, it enters a state of <em>emergency</em> when perturbed beyond its limited capacity to adapt. This state of emergency thus signals (the possibility of) imminent emergence. If the newly emergent system is substantially different from the dying parent system from which it emerged, the emergency-cum-emergence constitutes a <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis</a>.</p><p><strong><em>Emergence is unpredictable</em></strong></p><p>Emergence is a system-level phenomenon: “emergent properties” refer to a whole that is greater than, i.e., inexplicable as, the sum of its parts. The emergent difference between the whole and the sum of the parts is made up by immaterial relations, i.e., <em>organization</em>. Organization is what develops and can be quantified as an increase in mutual information inhering within a system, i.e., the extent to which knowledge of one part informs you of what to expect from another, based on their functional relationship and interactions. The mutual information developed within a system’s organization affords a measure of certainty and predictability to any entity that can recognize and process (correctly interpret) that information. Because the information that affords predictability depends on emergent organization, prior to the emergence of a new system, the precursor parts of the incipient system (which in the case of human systems are individual humans) generally lack the information needed to predict the specifics of what is coming.</p><p>The emergence of a new system can be thought of as a phase transition, as happens in precipitation. The precipitation of rain drops out of water vapor is a sudden emergence of liquid from gas, brought on by an increase in humidity beyond saturation (owing, e.g., to a drop in temperature). From the imagined perspective of a sentient water molecule with no knowledge of meteorology, its transition from being part of a gas entering the “emergency” of saturation to being part of an emergent raindrop is not predictable. I think it safe to say that we civilized humans lack sufficient knowledge to predict what will emerge from our ongoing civilizational emergency, although we can make guesses informed by knowledge of history and the science of complex systems, as I will do at the end of this post.</p><p>History and prehistory are replete with examples of emergence from emergencies. The European <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renaissance">Renaissance</a> constituted an emergence of a new socioeconomic system (and attendant revolution of art and science) from the emergency of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Death">Black Death</a>. The rise of Cenozoic ecosystems dominated by mammalian megafauna constituted an emergence from the end-Mesozoic emergency of mass dinosaurian death precipitated by the Chicxulub bolide impact. From this perspective, one can see that the resolution of a biological emergency via emergence often involves mass death that opens opportunities for the emergence. This certainly holds for animal <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis </a>(e.g., butterfly from caterpillar), which typically involves widespread programmed cell death prior to the emergence of a new creature from the remains of its larval precursor.</p><p><strong><em>Our ongoing emergency: the end of the world as we know it</em></strong></p><p>Our senescent extractive civilization, along with the ecological infrastructure on which it depends, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/predictably-our-senescent-civilization-is-now-collapsing-a5bffce3898a">is collapsing</a>. Despite the widespread denial, this is a complex, multifaceted global emergency involving the correlated collapse of ecosystems, climate stability, public health, liberal democracy, and the post-WWII international order that imposed constraints limiting genocide and global conflict.</p><p>One thing that should be clear for those experiencing and/or paying attention to our unfolding emergency is that context is everything. The mutual information developed within a mature civilization is context that affords certainty and predictability, which means you can plan your life around expectations that you take for granted: that if you work hard in school and study for a profession, there will be jobs available that allow you to survive and thrive by focusing on and excelling at your chosen profession. Outside of work you can spend your time and money on leisure activities that take advantage of predictable public and private infrastructure, tacit social agreements about what constitutes acceptable behavior in given circumstances, and the rule of law. <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9">In a collapsing civilization</a>, none of those contextual certainties can be taken for granted, and many are lost. For those who come of age in a functioning civilization, the loss of that stable context is very disorienting. The inclination under such circumstances is to keep one’s head down, nose to the grindstone, hoping that things will return to normal. But that does nothing to address, much less reverse, the unfolding emergency. The resolution of the emergency thus depends entirely on the actions of those who recognize it for what it is, and act accordingly, with <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/change-foresight-adaptability-dune-and-parable-of-the-sower-9b46fd804074">foresight</a>.</p><p>Right now, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-united-states-of-america-bf9bfe0b8770">the United States of America</a>, under the authoritarian, kleptocratic regime of Donald Trump, is spearheading our civilizational emergency. While it is a safe bet that Donald Trump himself is completely oblivious to that fact, it is just a safe a bet that many of the oligarchs that he has empowered (including Elon Musk) are not only aware of it, but are counting on it and working to make it happen in order to steer its resolution toward the emergence of a new system that they (and they alone) control for their own benefit, at the great expense of everyone else. That leaves it to the rest of us who are aware of what is happening (a small minority, like the oligarchs, but with far less wealth and political power) to work on steering our emergency toward whatever better (more desirable for us) emergent alternatives realistically exist.</p><p><strong><em>What might emerge from our current global emergency?</em></strong></p><p>Given that the uberwealthy techno-oligarchs (Elon Musk, Peter Thiel, et al.) and their theocratic allies in the Republican Party and US Supreme Court have a head start (and have likely been planning this for long time) and control the lion’s share of wealth and political power, the most likely socioeconomic system to emerge from our current emergency is a global techno-feudal dystopia in which billionaire overlords own and monopolize everything, and everyone else is left to fight for survival in a rapidly degenerating and increasingly toxic world, with food, water, shelter, and protection only available for those who can afford to purchase it (with either money or slave labor, along with complicity) from the overlords and their theocratic allies. Part of the plan undoubtedly involves <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics">eugenics</a> — allowing the old, sick, and socioeconomically disenfranchised to die by neglect and genocide. This would be another brutal dark age, a feudal world in some respects like that which emerged in Europe following the fall of Rome, but augmented and enforced by high-tech weapons, surveillance information technology, unrestrained dissemination of propaganda via corporate and social media, and suppression of fact-based journalism and information that undermines the totalitarian narrative, all vastly empowered by artificial intelligence. The scenario has been imagined in speculative fiction by many authors: <em>1984</em> by George Orwell, <em>Brave New World</em> by Aldous Huxley, <em>The Handmaid’s Tale</em> by Margaret Atwood, <em>Parable of the Sower</em> by Octavia Butler, and <em>The Hunger Games</em> by Suzanne Collins.</p><p>It is not clear that those working toward the emergence of such a system will succeed, and even if they do, whether the emergent system that they create will have any staying power. Such a system would rapidly develop from immaturity to senescence. Its wealthy beneficiaries will still have to contend with the disruptive effects of accelerating climate chaos, ecocide, toxic pollution, and civil unrest, as well as the increasingly acute threat of nuclear annihilation. Thus, it is possible that the emergent dystopia will be a short-lived prelude to extinction, and/or perhaps a hellscape like that imagined in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Road"><em>The Road</em></a> by Cormac McCarthy. It may be that the billionaires and their allies in the military-industrial complex have prepared for such possibilities by constructing underground or underwater bunkers and escape havens, as has also been imagined in speculative fiction, e.g., the TV series <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradise_(2025_TV_series)"><em>Paradise</em></a>, and the book-cum-TV series <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silo_(TV_series)"><em>Silo</em></a>.</p><p>Another possibility, which seems more far-fetched given current power structures and widespread denial and ignorance, is that our emergency will resolve with a renaissance, possibly following a brief or extended dystopic dark age. I can imagine two scenarios that are not mutually exclusive, either from each other, or from the dystopic scenario described above.</p><p>First, it seems that a socioeconomic renaissance might involve the emergence of localized, community-level cooperative networks that manage most trade and politics. Precursors for this exist in places like the New England states that have a strong tradition of local democracy. As the global economy collapses and national governments work to funnel all wealth to a small cadre of lawless oligarchs, thus losing the ability to provide for citizens, local communities will be incentivized to wean themselves from consuming corporate products and turn to each other for goods, services, and support. The development of strong community cooperatives providing the necessities for survival will work to disempower multinational corporations and the military industrial complex. Of course, that will not occur without an attempt by the beneficiaries of the corporatist/fascist regime to prevent and suppress localization, likely via totalitarian police-state violence. But that will become increasingly difficult in a chaotic, dying world, and local communities will organize for self-defense, possibly involving militias. In the USA, it is difficult to imagine that this scenario could play out without civil war that results in significant casualties, and possibly transformation of cities into death traps akin to the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warsaw_Ghetto">Warsaw Ghetto</a> or the ongoing situation in Gaza.</p><p>Second, as technology continues developing toward the “singularity” of artificial intelligence, it seems likely that it will open new disruptive opportunities that not only benefit the techno-feudalists, but potentially anyone else with access to and knowledge of the technology. Thus, it is possible that enough people with sufficient empathy and technological savvy will succeed in developing systems for directing the AI revolution toward the betterment of humanity, using technology to augment and preserve the Commons that is needed for everyone to have an equal right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. That Commons has both actual and virtual components. The actual components are clean air, water, and land set aside with sufficient regulation to allow for regenerative agriculture, aquaculture, and wilderness. The virtual components are media and computer platforms and repositories for disseminating uncorrupted information that is freely available and accessible, such as Wikipedia and the Internet Archive, as well as community and public radio and television.</p><p>In conjunction with curated preservation of the Commons, a renaissance-like emergence will require transformations in art, science, and academia. There are precursors already beginning to take shape, led by venerable (and well-endowed) academic institutions like Harvard. A renaissance in academia will require “a new social contract between higher education and the [public] that simultaneously calls for a firm commitment to academic freedom and what [Harvard professor Danielle Allen] calls a “horizontal” relationship between universities and the public — one that is based on mutual respect and reciprocity” (<a href="https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.ady7672"><em>Science</em> vol. 388, pp. 564–565</a>). A renaissance in science will require public understanding of <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/science-what-it-is-and-how-it-works-10fe1c9d3d1c">what science is and how it works</a>, which will in turn require a transformation of public education. A renaissance in art will require the uncoupling of support for artists from exploitative commodification of their art. In the USA, with its federal government collapsing into fascism, all of this is now more easily achieved at the level of local communities and would benefit from the support of such efforts and public institutions by wealthy benefactors who are motivated to work toward human betterment.</p><p>While local community-directed, bottom-up socioeconomic development is necessary for a renaissance-like emergence of a new civilization, it is insufficient, allowing at best reversion to low tech agrarian or subsistence economies (something that would require massive depopulation, and even then, will be difficult in a toxic world with a chaotic climate). To tackle our existential emergency, top-down control will also be required, ideally involving global governance that leverages science, information technology and AI to map out and manage fair, equitable solutions to the challenges associated with environmental, ecological, and climate disruption. Evolutionary biologist and complex systems theorist Peter Corning prescribes such governance (which would of necessity involve some combination of “progressive capitalism” and democratic socialism, favoring cooperation over competition) in his book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Superorganism-Contract-Endangered-Elements-Evolutionary-ebook/dp/B0C94NQNBM"><em>Superorganism: Toward a New Social Contract for Our Endangered Species</em></a><em> </em>(Cambridge University Press, 2023).</p><p>We are entering a dark and uncertain age. The uncertainty comes from the collapse of the American-led, developed-to-senescence global socioeconomic system that has granted us much of the certainty that we have benefitted from over the past 80 years since World War II. The silver lining of the new uncertainty is that it opens an opportunity for transformative change that was virtually impossible under the rigid, near insurmountable constraints of our mature civilization. But taking advantage of that opportunity to steer our emergency toward the emergence of a beneficent civilization (a new Renaissance) will require strategic and tactical foresight and concerted action. That, in turn, will require that enough smart, empathetic people squarely face the dire reality of our emergency and provide leadership, prioritizing and committing to the hard work of organizing and winning over enough hearts and minds to counter the already advanced efforts of the sociopathic overlords who have taken control of the United States government, and who are working diligently to expand that control to the rest of the world in order to bring about the emergence of a techno-feudal dystopia. The duration of the coming dark age, the extent of human suffering, and the likelihood of human extinction all depend on which of those competing efforts prevail over the next few years, if not months.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1d0d916e3364" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bubbles within Bubbles: Global Insanity, 2025]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/bubbles-within-bubbles-global-insanity-2025-2bb14e1b4f9f?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2bb14e1b4f9f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civilization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 24 Apr 2025 12:42:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-29T21:13:49.869Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M7AP5t0O5ny-fPCDRgMUJw.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Bubbles_over_a_leafy_green_background.jpg">Bubbles over a leafy green background</a> (Balise42, CC BY-SA 4.0 &lt;<a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0">https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0</a>&gt;, via Wikimedia Commons)</figcaption></figure><p>When I was in the 8th grade (1972–73), I wrote a long, free form poem, in bold black marker, on a meters-long sheet cut from a large roll of unperforated printer paper that my dad had brought home from work. I wrote (furiously as I recall) on the kitchen table, during a live televised speech by President Richard Nixon coming through our family’s black and white portable TV on the kitchen counter. I can’t remember what the speech was about, or the words of my poem or what inspired me to write then and there. All I remember is that the poem was an extended metaphor about being trapped in a bubble from which I could not break free, as hard as I might try. It wasn’t a class assignment, but I brought it to school the next day, and my teacher was impressed enough that she hung it on the wall.</p><p>Although my memory of it is hazy, I think my poem was about how, by virtue of mental walls built and reinforced by society and civilization, most of us are alienated from nature and ourselves. It’s a feeling that I’ve had for as long as I can remember.</p><p>Forty years later, I wrote a book, co-authored with the late Donald Mikulecky, entitled <em>Global Insanity: How Homo sapiens Lost Touch with Reality while Transforming the World </em>(<a href="https://emergentpublications.com/global-insanity-how-homo-sapiens-lost-touch-with-reality-while-transforming-the-world/">Emergent Publications, 2012</a>). The book argues that our civilized alienation and collective insanity (broadly defined as an unhealthy mental condition detached from reality) is a product of the reductionist mindset that developed in concert with Western science and technology, and came to dominate our outlook on, and approach to understanding, the world. Reductionism oversimplifies reality by focusing (scientific) explanations of causation on <em>mechanisms</em> that can be manipulated (typically for short-term gain), without carefully considering the systemic context (including environment and historical contingency) and its role in shaping reality. Ironically, I have since come to view that thesis itself as an oversimplification, although I remain a staunch critic of reductionism and view it as a major impediment to dealing effectively with our <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/emergence-from-emergency-1d0d916e3364">existential emergency</a>.</p><p>On Amazon, our book has <a href="https://www.amazon.com/product-reviews/1938158040/ref=cm_cr_dp_d_show_all_btm?ie=UTF8&amp;reviewerType=all_reviews">6 reviews</a>: four 5-star, one 4-star, and one 1-star (ouch!). As much as I hate getting a 1-star review, it makes a point worth considering:</p><blockquote>I agree with the author’s ‘inescapable conclusion’ that barring a cultural metamorphosis that breaks free of deeply entrenched mental frames that made us what we are, continued development of the Global Economy will lead inexorably to the collapse of civilisation.”</blockquote><blockquote>In other words we all seem to agree we need a profound paradigm shift. But it is the nature of this which we all seem to be wrangling with.</blockquote><blockquote>The real problem on this planet is the human condition-ie our troubled collective psychosis or global insanity if you like.</blockquote><blockquote>May I suggest that the first agreement we all need to make for the sake of collective understanding, is to use this term widely and with the same meaning. From Plato’s Republic to E O Wilson’s latest book ‘The social Conquest of the Earth’, writers have used the term The Human Condition to unevasively pinpoint the real issue; IE our fallen, corrupted, at odds with nature, alienated state. It intrigues me that two seemingly intelligent, caring men (no disrespect intended) can write a whole book on ‘global insanity’ without even mentioning the real problem!</blockquote><p>While in defense I might argue that the whole point of the book was to <em>explain</em> “our fallen, corrupted, at odds with nature, alienated state” as a highly developed product of reductionist thinking (motivated, ultimately, by our cognizance and fear of death), apparently, we didn’t do a convincing job, at least for that reader. On reflection, I can see that our analysis and critique was opaquely technical and perhaps danced around “the human condition” without tackling it head on. Which makes me wonder if maybe I did a better job in my 8th grade poem than I did in my book. Sadly, that poem is long gone, so we’ll never know.</p><p>To briefly recap the argument articulated through the 7 chapters of<em> Global Insanity</em>: (1) planet earth in the Anthropocene is an evolved complex system, of which we humans are part and parcel, that cannot be adequately explained by reducing its phenomenology and current predicament to conceptually simple, focused and hence disconnected problems; (2) the predominant explanatory framework used by 21st century humans is a reductionist <a href="http://klempner.freeshell.org/newsletter/issue170.html">mythology of mechanisms</a> developed linguistically over the past few millennia via metaphor, metaphysics, and math; (3) life itself is a complex relational phenomenon that is not explainable or adequately explained by this mechanistic mythology, as proved formally by the work of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Rosen_(biologist)">Robert Rosen</a>; (4) <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">evolutionary change occurs via and is constrained by systemic development</a>, which has a logic (and is thus coarsely predictable) based on information production and thermodynamics that entails distinct developmental stages of immaturity, maturity, and senescence; (4) the global economy upon which civilization now depends is a living system that developed to its current stage, which is arguably one of senescence; (5) as such, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/predictably-our-senescent-civilization-is-now-collapsing-a5bffce3898a">our civilization is unsustainable and destined for collapse</a>; and therefore (6) we should be thinking about how to survive in order to create a new system from the remains of the old one, i.e., produce a civilizational <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis</a>.</p><p>The human condition can be described metaphorically as bubbles within bubbles. Each of us is a bubble of subjective experience, living within and entrained by a sociocultural bubble existing withing the larger bubble civilization. The bubble of contemporary civilization, now stretched to bursting, was blown up by the activities of the dominant sociocultural-economic bubble of the 20th century United States of America, which is now collapsing. Over many generations of bubbles within bubbles, we have become progressively detached and alienated from reality. Now the bubbles are bursting all around us, and things are getting real.</p><p><strong><em>The big bubble of global civilization</em></strong></p><p>Human civilization is a complex living system that has developed around the fundamental biological imperative of <em>homeostasis</em>, i.e., internal constancy (and hence increased certainty and predictability) in the face of environmental fluctuations. Human beings are social creatures that work to maintain homeostasis by forming cooperative communities, societies, economies, etc. that build protective structures and controlled environments. Via agriculture and technology, what began prehistorically as small clans, tribes, and communities developed into the larger hierarchically stratified socioeconomic systems that we refer to as civilizations. Through history, civilizations have come and gone, developing to senescence before collapsing, typically because of environmental degradation and ecological overshoot. In that, ours is no different, and the <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9">collapse of our global civilization is well underway</a>. However, because of high-energy technology and industry, our civilization and its collapse are affecting Earth on an unprecedented scale: for the first time in human history, civilization is overpowering non-human nature on a global scale, decimating the stable climate and ecological relationships upon which civilization depends. Owing to nuclear weapons, the collapse has the potential to destroy the entire biosphere, causing an extinction event that rivals if not exceeds previous mass extinctions such as the Great Dying at the end of the Permian, and the dinosaur demise at the end of the Cretaceous. Even absent nuclear Armageddon, the sixth mass extinction is already well underway, precipitated by civilized human industry.</p><p>Global human civilization in the year 2025 is the big bubble encompassing smaller civilized bubbles, all the way down to each of us as civilized individuals. Like any bubble, civilization is ephemeral, held together by the threads of shared understanding obtained through language, mythology, and enculturation. As should be obvious to anyone paying attention, that shared fabric is now unraveling owing to separate, adversarial bubbles of understanding that have developed in response to factors such as extreme wealth inequality, information technology that empowers and spreads mis- and disinformation, the amalgamation of religion and political power, and the psycho-physiological dominance, under stress, of the limbic system (which motivates emotion and fight-or-flight responses) over the neocortex (which motivates reasoning). While adversarial sociocultural bubbles (tribal up through nation state) have always existed (typically resulting in war), the ongoing, accelerating <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9">collapse of global civilization </a>is being driven by the collapse of one of the biggest bubbles within that overarching bubble: <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-united-states-of-america-bf9bfe0b8770">the United States of America.</a></p><p><strong><em>A bubble within the bubble: the American techno-plutocratic empire</em></strong></p><p>After its revolutionary birth in 1776 and early development that struggled with the cognitive dissonance of slavery in a nation founded on the self-evident truth that “all men are created equal” (culminating in the Civil War of 1861–1865), the U.S.A. came into its own during the 20th century, which has thus been referred to as the “American Century”. The ascent of the U.S.A. from an upstart nation to global superpower that indulged imperial ambitions was in no small part enabled by its participation and triumph in the two world wars, especially the second (1940–45), which jumpstarted the American economy along with science, technology, and industry. Due to the progressive policies of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, which strengthened the labor movement and were maintained and strengthened by his successors up through Jimmy Carter, the American economic boom benefitted many working-class Americans, lifting them up into a large and relatively prosperous “middle class”. This was accompanied by the “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mid-20th_century_baby_boom">baby boom</a>” of 1946–1964. Many of that generation, the so-called baby-boomers, were raised and came of age in a bubble of unprecedented economic prosperity and the freedom that it bought.</p><p>That all began to change in 1980 with the election of President Ronald Reagan, who implemented policies of aggressive deregulation, regressive taxation, deficit spending, and divisive politics that preyed on and stoked racist, sexist, Christian fundamenatalist, and nativist fear. At the same time, Reagan Republicans began a long game of stacking the courts, including the Supreme Court, with like-minded idealogues. This “Reagan Revolution” rested on and reinforced the myth that wealth was built on the hard work of individuals, and its corollary that poverty was the result of individual laziness and failure. The result of all this was that the middle class ceased to benefit from economic growth, which thenceforth mainly lined the pockets of the wealthy. By the 2020s, the wealth that had once belonged to a large middle class had been siphoned to a small number of ultra-wealthy, self-serving individuals and their corporations who, by virtue of favorable decrees by the Supreme Court, also held an inordinate amount of political power, essentially owning most of the politicians. Meanwhile, the mythology of rugged individualism morphed into a libertarian ideology of ‘live and let die’ that rationalized the vast disparities of health, well-being, liberty, and justice brought about by extreme wealth disparity as the price of “freedom”. This mythology was aided and abetted by the explosion of information technology and social media from 1990–2025, giving rise to the brutal authoritarian techno-plutocracy that now has taken over the American government.</p><p>The American bubble that emerged in the 20th century produced a global empire that was enforced by the sacrifice of American lives and treasure in a protracted series of foreign wars, from Korea, through Viet Nam, and later in Afghanistan and Iraq. In addition, more clandestine American foreign interventions overturned socialist democracies and propped up ruthless authoritarian regimes that benefitted the American economy during the decades long “Cold War” with the Soviet Union. Many Americans who celebrated the collapse of the USSR in 1991 believed that that vindicated American policy, economics, and “exceptionalism” under Ronald Reagan. Many of those same Americans, or their ideological descendants, helped elect Donald Trump to the US presidency in 2016, then again in 2024, quite ironically, with a good deal of help of Vladimir Putin’s Russia, which had (and still has) ambitions of reclaiming the imperial power lost when the USSR collapsed. The ongoing collapse of the American empire thus seems karmic. But the collapse was inevitable: it was always a bubble, and through the deregulation and regressive policies of the past 45 years, the bubble was stretched to the breaking point.</p><p><strong><em>Each of us is a psychological bubble within a cultural bubble</em></strong></p><p>Each of us is a unique psychological bubble formed developmentally through a combination of genetics and enculturation, i.e., nature and nurture. Human psychology is perhaps the most important yet least respected science. There are many reasons for the lack of respect, but a big one may simply be insecurity, the fear of objectively confronting one’s inner workings and the extent to which they confute the curated image we have of ourselves, an image that we each develop in our formative years and wear as a mask throughout much of our lives. As a result, most people lack psychological awareness and insight (especially into their own psychology), and are afraid to go there. Psychological defense mechanisms such as denial, rationalization, and projection are the norm rather than the exception.</p><p>A factor that plays a major role in developing and enforcing the psychological bubbles that entrap each of us is metaphorical language. Psychologist <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_Jaynes">Julian Jaynes</a> argued (persuasively, in my opinion) that human consciousness emerged relatively recently (~5,000 years ago) in concert with the use of metaphor as a linguistic instrument for understanding and relating to ourselves and the world. A metaphor is the use of a word that literally means one thing to describe something else entirely: time “flies” (not literally), we “picture” ourselves in our “mind’s eye” (there is no literal picture, and no literal eye within the mind). We are so prone to metaphor that even the word “literally” is now widely used figuratively for emphasis. Dependence on metaphorical language, to the extent that it explains human consciousness and exceptionalism, helps explain the human condition — our alienation from ourselves and nature. As I have written previously, <a href="https://medium.com/p/cc682de51ec6">the price we pay for human consciousness is an exceptional proclivity for self-deception</a>. Reliance on metaphors to relate to the world and each other makes us easy marks for savvy salesmen, politicians, and conmen. This has been explored extensively by <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Lakoff">George Lakoff</a>.</p><p>Through our upbringing, language, and socialization, the bubble of psychology internalizes the larger bubbles of culture and civilization. That internalization involves the interpretation of information. Since interpretation only happens via an interpretive framework (an explanatory model, typically framed with metaphor), different cultures find meaning in different kinds of information. We all are prone to confirmation bias, the easy acceptance of information that confirms one’s opinions and prejudices. Without education and training (as obtained by engaging honestly in <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/science-what-it-is-and-how-it-works-10fe1c9d3d1c">science</a>) most people default to culture-specific confirmation bias in evaluating information.</p><p>The explosion of information technology that began in the late 1980s (in concert with the “Reagan Revolution”) brought with it an explosion of misinformation and disinformation, which have been exploited, along with the human proclivity of self-deception through confirmation bias, by oligarchs and religious fanatics who wish to amass and monopolize power. As a result, in 2020s America, citizens live in alternative “realties” whose shared understandings of the world and what constitute facts are mutually exclusive. The shared “reality” of the MAGA cult in the U.S.A. is largely a bubble of lies and propaganda disseminated through corporate and social media. But it is also true that the shared “reality” of non-MAGA Americans, while being more receptive to facts and science, is nonetheless a bubble constructed of human-centric cultural myths (including the myth of “American Exceptionalism”, and the myth of national borders and identities) that are not based on anything in the actual world. In any case, the national unity that characterized the expanding American bubble following the second world war has collapsed, and the United States of America now consists of different, antagonistic sociocultural bubbles whose mutual animosity is helping drive the collapse of the republic, which is no longer United. Left unchecked, that collapse will also bring about the collapse of both the larger bubble of global civilization, and the smaller sociocultural bubbles within it, all the way down to individual psychologies. Global insanity is real. Insanity can be maintained via illusion, until it can’t, at which point reality takes over. The reality that civilized humans will increasingly confront is that they (we, at least most of us) are ill-equipped to survive in the real (i.e., wild, uncivilized) world.</p><p><strong><em>Bursting bubbles through empathy, education, travel, and psychedelics</em></strong></p><p>Given the mutually reinforcing nature of the bubbles within bubbles that comprise human civilization, is there a human quality that can be nurtured and used to break free of the mutually antagonistic bubbles that are tearing civilization apart? Of course there is, and it is perhaps the most cherished of human qualities, the very thing that makes humans <em>humane</em>: empathy.</p><p>Empathy entails feeling and perceiving the world from the perspective of someone outside our personal bubble. In <em>To Kill a Mockingbird</em>, Atticus Finch tells his daughter Scout: “You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view…until you climb into his skin and walk around in it.” Human empathy can be extended not only to other humans, but also to all other creatures. Civilization is bound to collapse unless empathy is part and parcel with the socioeconomic system upon which it is built. The only path to an empathic, healthy civilization is through <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/a-biomedical-argument-for-democratic-socialism-and-wealth-redistribution-93ad9e551947">wealth redistribution and Democratic Socialism</a>.</p><p>An empathy-building activity in my own life has been travel, especially international travel. In 1974, only a year or two after writing my poem, I moved to Switzerland for two years, after having lived form most of my formative years in Kentucky. Living in a new country, with a different language and customs, was mind-expanding, to say the least. That experience liberated me from the bubble of my life up until then.</p><p>Another thing that has enabled me to transcend my personal bubble is a liberal arts education, which, like travel, alerted me to many alternative perspectives and built my capacity for critical thinking. I can honestly say that, without the strong liberal arts education that I have had, my mind would be confined to a much smaller bubble.</p><p>Finally, as noted above, personal psychological bubbles (<a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">like anything else</a>) come to exist developmentally, and breaking free of them requires developmental plasticity, which is naturally lost as development progresses unchecked along a specific trajectory. We are now learning (and I can attest through personal experience) that psychedelics like psilocybin or LSD have therapeutic benefits by increasing the plasticity of the brain, allowing it to break free of hardened habits of mental activity (confining bubbles) within which it had become trapped. A case might thus be made for the judicious use of psychedelics to catalyze the civilizational <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis</a> that we need to avoid a global, hell-on-earth dystopia and possible human extinction. I’ll leave that for another article.</p><p><strong><em>Further Reading</em></strong></p><p>Coffman, J.A., and Mikulecky, D.C. <a href="https://emergentpublications.com/global-insanity-how-homo-sapiens-lost-touch-with-reality-while-transforming-the-world/"><em>Global Insanity: How Homo sapiens Lost Touch with Reality While Transforming the World</em></a>. Emergent Publications, 2012.</p><p>Coffman, J.A. and Mikulecky, D.C. <a href="https://cosmosandhistory.org/index.php/journal/article/view/467">Global Insanity redux</a>. <em>Cosmos &amp; History</em>, 11: 1–14, 2015.</p><p>Jaynes, J. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Origin-Consciousness-Breakdown-Bicameral-Mind/dp/0395329329/ref=tmm_hrd_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&amp;qid=&amp;sr="><em>The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind</em></a>. Houghton Mifflin, 1976.</p><p>Lakoff, G., and Johnson, M. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Metaphors-We-Live-George-Lakoff-ebook/dp/B009KA3Y6I/ref=sr_1_1?crid=X818M99MO69T&amp;keywords=George+lakoff+metaphor&amp;qid=1641931366&amp;s=digital-text&amp;sprefix=george+lakoff+metaphor%2Cdigital-text%2C126&amp;sr=1-1"><em>Metaphors We Live By</em></a>. University of Chicago Press, 1980.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2bb14e1b4f9f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Disturbingly Plausible Explanation for the Fermi Paradox]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/a-disturbingly-plausible-explanation-for-the-fermi-paradox-5c6f719a75e4?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5c6f719a75e4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[aliens]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civilization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[universe]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[galaxy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 15 Mar 2025 02:36:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-30T19:42:41.164Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/759/1*NpVYRVHC_RRwbv4UYCthSA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Nuclear weapon test Romeo (yield 11 Mt) on Bikini atoll, March 27, 1954. United States Department of Energy, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons</figcaption></figure><p>The universe is so immense that it is almost certainly rife with life. Our Milky Way alone, just one of as many as 2 trillion galaxies in the observable universe, was recently estimated to harbor <a href="https://www.seti.org/press-release/how-many-habitable-planets-are-out-there">~300 million habitable planets</a>. If life evolves to produce technologically advanced civilizations whenever and wherever conditions allow, it is unlikely that our civilization is the only one in our galaxy. Moreover, since the galaxy is far older than our solar system, it likely includes civilization-conducive planets that have had sufficient time to produce technologies advanced enough to send out radio signals, enable interstellar travel, and maybe even allow galactic colonization. But there has not been a confirmed encounter with such aliens. This led physicist Enrico Fermi to ask, “where is everybody?” The lack of confirmed alien contact, despite the seeming likelihood that life is not uncommon in our galaxy, is known as the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox">Fermi paradox</a>.</p><p>Several explanations have been proposed for the Fermi paradox, one of which is explored here. But first it is important to reiterate a key assumption on which the paradox rests: that life itself is commonplace in the galaxy. At one time this assumption was tenuous, given that the emergence of biological life from prebiotic geochemistry (“abiogenesis”) seemed, based on the knowledge and conventional wisdom of the time, to be highly improbable. But science has since shown that terrestrial abiogenesis was not so improbable under conditions found on the primordial earth. This leaves open the question: what fraction of all earthlike planets in the galaxy are <em>sufficiently</em> earthlike (e.g., with critical factors such as plate tectonics) to have been similarly conducive to abiogenesis? We don’t yet know the answer to that, because we don’t yet know enough about the geophysics and geochemistry of planets outside our solar system. But given the size of our galaxy, it is not hard to imagine that it harbors many other living planets. If this assumption is correct, the question becomes: on a living planet, what is the likelihood that life will evolve to produce technological civilization? And if that likelihood is high, what then is the likelihood that technological civilization will develop capacity for interstellar travel?</p><p><strong><em>Hard steps</em></strong></p><p>Abiogenesis is the first of several conceivable “hard steps” that need to be taken for evolution to produce a technological civilization. The hard-steps model stems from <a href="https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/abs/10.1098/rsta.1983.0096">a 1983 paper by physicist Brandon Carter</a>, who reasoned, based on the limited knowledge of the time, that given the <em>a priori</em> improbability of each of the hard steps, the likelihood of a civilization like ours evolving on earth is exceedingly low — in other words, that our existence is an anomalous fluke of nature — an extraordinarily lucky draw in the lottery of life. A similar argument was made over a decade earlier by molecular biologist Jacques Monod in his essay <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chance_and_Necessity"><em>Chance and Necessity</em></a>. If that is true, then we might not expect to find any other civilizations in our galaxy.</p><p>One of the wonderful things about <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/science-what-it-is-and-how-it-works-10fe1c9d3d1c">science</a> is that the knowledge it produces progressively refines our understanding of probabilities. Thus, through science we have learned that many things that used to seem improbable (or even impossible) — for example, human flight — are, under conducive conditions, deterministically predictable. Thus, as noted above, abiogenesis no longer seems improbable given current scientific knowledge. What about the other hard steps to evolution of technological civilization? These include, sequentially, the evolution of photosynthesis (required to produce atmospheric oxygen), eukaryotic cells (required for complex multicellularity), animals (required for human-like consciousness), and finally, complex civilization itself. Each of these hard steps seems on its face to be highly improbable, presenting difficult challenges that appear virtually insurmountable by chance alone. But, as with the first step of abiogenesis, <a href="https://www.science.org/doi/full/10.1126/sciadv.ads5698">science has given us reason to believe that each subsequent step is not so hard</a>, but rather is enabled by, and a somewhat predictable outcome of, the constraining conditions and opportunities created by the previous step. From this perspective our emergence on earth is not so much a lucky accident, but rather a somewhat predictable outcome of earth’s <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">development</a>. Reality of course exists somewhere between these two extremes: given the critical evolutionary role of chance events (such as the asteroid impact that decimated the dinosaurs and enabled evolutionary ascendence of mammals, and hence humans), the probability of human-like civilization evolving within the available window of opportunity on an earth-like planet remains an open question.</p><p><strong><em>The Great Filter</em></strong></p><p>An idea closely related to the hard-steps model is the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter">Great Filter</a>, which posits the existence of an evolutionary hard step interposed between technological civilization and interstellar travel. Considering what we know about biology and <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9">our civilization’s increasingly dire predicament</a>, the Great Filter is a reasonable hypothesis.</p><p>The evolutionary emergence of human civilization in some ways echoes previous evolutionary emergenc(i)es that precipitated catastrophic changes in the biosphere: for example, the emergence of photosynthesis resulted in the “great oxygenation event” that caused mass extinction of most of the relatively simple, single cell life forms existing on earth at that time, due to the toxicity of oxygen. Life eventually adapted to oxygen, which, by creating a surfeit of free energy, launched the emergence of more complex lifeforms — indeed, it was a prerequisite to our own evolution. The cyanobacteria that developed photosynthesis were an “invasive species” that took over the planet. An <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasive_species">invasive species</a> can be broadly defined as one that, either via newly evolved traits or due to ecosystem disruption, overcomes all ecological constraints on its reproductive success, allowing it to run rampant throughout its environment, decimating resources and other species. Human beings, by virtue of our <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-price-we-pay-for-human-consciousness-is-an-exceptional-proclivity-for-self-deception-cc682de51ec6">exceptional intelligence</a> and social cooperation, are an invasive species. In fact, the advanced technological civilization that we have developed via science, mechanical engineering, and high energy industry has granted us unprecedented power that overcomes all ecological constraints — we are the ultimate invasive species.</p><p>Unfortunately, technological civilization, as it currently exists, is incompatible with biological sustainability: biology has evolved no defense against the entropic destruction caused by fossil- or nuclear-fueled technology. And yet, human beings are apes, and our basic behavior does not deviate far from that of our ape cousins, the chimpanzees: like them, we are largely ruled by emotions tied to tribalism, testosterone-driven aggression and alpha-male dominance, and territoriality. Abetted by technology, territorial disputes that for chimpanzee clans are limited to local (albeit often murderous) skirmishes manifest for humans as the horrific world wars of the 20th century and the many ongoing conflicts and “ethnic cleansings” of the 21st century. We appear unable to evolve past our deeply rooted simian proclivity for tribalism and war. This signals that humanity may lack the capacity to deal effectively with the existential predicament that development of technological civilization has precipitated. Indeed, <a href="https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rstb.2022.0259?utm_source=substack&amp;utm_medium=email">it was recently proposed</a> that the very trait that made us so successful as the ultimate invasive species — cooperation abetted by shared culture — is now an impediment to the global cooperation needed to effectively deal with the environmental crisis that we have created, given that cultural differences trigger an “us vs. them” mentality. Cultural traits (e.g., religion) and other “<a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00368504241272491">inherited behavior patterns</a>” (genetically and culturally encoded models) that gave our ancestors a leg up and made us a successful invasive species are now significant impediments to effectively dealing with the problems that civilization has created. In general, inherited behavior patterns are significant constraints on evolution that are not easily overcome, which is why extinction is the fate of most species.</p><p>Before <em>Homo sapiens</em> can have any chance of achieving interstellar travel, it must survive the catastrophic consequences of <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecological_overshoot">ecological overshoot</a> caused by human civilization. The prospects of that do not look good, as human extinction — possibly near instantaneous via nuclear annihilation — is becoming an increasingly probable possibility. The basic problem is that high energy technology significantly accelerates <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-nature-of-change-cf707bfbdf77">change</a> (both intended and unintended), to rates orders of magnitude faster than the rates of biological and cultural change that allow <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/change-foresight-adaptability-dune-and-parable-of-the-sower-9b46fd804074">adaptation</a>. Consider how much the world has changed during the lifetimes of our “elders” (including those in power) and think of how well they have managed to adapt by changing their minds and attitudes. As biological beings with relatively long lifespans, humans are simply not equipped to adapt to the accelerated change wrought by our clever technology. The inherited behavior patterns that made us so successful may be insurmountable impediments to taking the hard step of global scale cooperation needed for technological civilization to survive. This may be universally true for all biological life, anywhere it emerges and evolves.</p><p>Thus, the incapacity of biological life to adapt to the exponentially accelerating change wrought by technology is a highly plausible Great Filter that accounts for the Fermi Paradox. High-tech civilization may be an evolutionary dead end destined to self-destruct, a glorious flower that develops explosively at the end of an evolutionary branch before falling into nothingness.</p><p><strong><em>Further Reading</em></strong></p><p>Monod, J. <a href="https://monoskop.org/images/9/99/Monod_Jacques_Chance_and_Necessity.pdf"><em>Chance and Necessity: An Essay on the Natural Philosophy of Modern Biology</em></a><em>. </em>Vintage; New York, 1971.</p><p>Coffman, J. A. <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4392722/">On the meaning of chance in biology</a>. <em>Biosemiotics</em> 7 (3): 377–388, 2014.</p><p>Coffman, J. A. <a href="https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-030-00075-2_13">Why functional genomics is the central concern of biology and the hard problem of abiogenesis</a>.<em> Springer Proceedings in Complexity</em>. 2019.</p><p>Carroll, S. B. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Fortunate-Events-Chance-Making-Planet-ebook/dp/B086YHXHPL/"><em>A Series of Fortunate Events: Chance and the Making of the Planet, Life, and You</em></a>. Princeton University Press, 2020.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5c6f719a75e4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Science: What it Is, and How it Works]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/science-what-it-is-and-how-it-works-10fe1c9d3d1c?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/10fe1c9d3d1c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[knowledge]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[funding]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[research]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 08 Mar 2025 02:04:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-08T17:31:43.937Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/799/1*tnrQhHn9stT2S0UBhLoseg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Apollo 11 moon landing, July 21, 1969: Buzz Aldrin removing the passive seismometer from a compartment in the SEQ bay of the Lunar Lander. Photo by Neil Armstrong, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons</figcaption></figure><p>It’s been over six decades since U.S. President John F. Kennedy launched a massive public investment in science and technology with his aspirational “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/We_choose_to_go_to_the_Moon">we choose to go to the moon</a>” speech. Since then, Americans not only travelled to the moon and back (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_program">9 times</a>, including 6 in which astronauts landed and walked on the moon), but, via persistent public investment, pushed the envelope of scientific knowledge further into the unknown than was dreamed possible. Because of that investment we now enjoy technological wonders like computers, the internet, cell phones, and medicines that extend human lifespan by preventing, treating, or curing diseases that routinely ravaged our ancestors. But now continued investment, and indeed, Americans’ respect for science itself, is collapsing. It is astounding that in 2025, a substantial number of Americans believe that the moon landings were faked; that life on earth did not evolve; that vaccination does not defend against viral disease; that climate change is a hoax; and even that the earth is flat.</p><p>As astonishing as it may seem, this delusion is not surprising from a psychological perspective. As I wrote previously, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-price-we-pay-for-human-consciousness-is-an-exceptional-proclivity-for-self-deception-cc682de51ec6">the price we pay for human consciousness is an exceptional proclivity for self-deception</a>. I also wrote that <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/science-is-the-best-defense-we-have-against-self-deception-b234efe91763">science is the best defense we have against self-deception</a> (mental “vaccination”, as it were, against delusion). The collapse of public trust in (and now government support for) science in the U.S.A. is a testament to public ignorance of what science is and how it works. In the spirit of scientific inquiry, it is reasonable to ask what caused the collapse, and if the scientific enterprise itself played any role.</p><p>I have been a professional scientist for 40+ years now and thus have an insider’s knowledge of what science is and how it works. For what it is worth, this is what I have learned.</p><p><strong><em>What it is, ideally</em></strong></p><p>As I tell my students, science always starts with a question. There are only five fundamental questions: <em>what</em>, <em>when</em>, <em>where</em>, <em>how</em>, and <em>why</em>. Through science we ask those questions to obtain answers that grant us insight into nature. This endeavor used to be called “natural philosophy”. Classical scientists like Isaac Newton did not refer to themselves as scientists, but rather as natural philosophers. But their motivation was the same; they were curious to know what the world is made of, how it works, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/why-things-are-the-way-they-are-and-how-they-came-to-be-a1ff30043f68">why things are the way they are, and how they came to be</a>. They also were committed to the idea that human intellect has the capacity to figure out <em>true</em> answers to those questions by direct interrogation of nature, without recourse to mythological “just so” stories. A central goal of natural philosophy — now referred to as science — is to better understand <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/causation-is-the-interplay-between-freedom-and-developed-constraint-3e5e66e6d380">causality</a>, ideally in a way that empowers us to predict the course of events and manipulate them to our advantage.</p><p>Like any other philosophy, science is built on a foundation of assumptions or ideological “commitments”. For starters, it assumes that what we observe in the world exists independently of our individual selves and minds, a philosophy referred to as “realism”. The opposing perspective, “idealism” holds that nothing exists outside of our mind. The 18th century idealist philosopher <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Berkeley">George Berkeley</a> famously opined that if a tree falls in the forest but no one is there to perceive it, then it didn’t fall. While that may seem like nonsense, attempts to interpret the modern science of quantum mechanics have led scientists to pose scenarios that seem equally nonsensical, like <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schr%C3%B6dinger%27s_cat">Schrödinger’s Cat</a>. Realism and idealism are opposing poles in an age-old dialectic that has guided human thought. Although they provide useful heuristics guiding inquiry, they are ideologies that in and of themselves fail to capture reality. By virtue of natural philosophy <em>cum</em> science, we have come to learn that neither realism nor idealism adequately depicts the actual world, which is far more interesting, existing both independently of, and as a creation of, the mind, as I hope becomes clearer in what follows. Nevertheless, the prevailing ideal anchoring science is realism: the assumption that our senses, combined with logic, provide us with a realistic understanding of the world as it exists outside and independent of us.</p><p>In line with its commitment to philosophical realism, the goal of science is to understand the world “objectively”, that is, as it really is, rather than as we would like it to be. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francis_Bacon">Francis Bacon</a>, one of the philosophical founders of contemporary Western science, worked to devise a method of interrogating nature that eliminated (or at least minimized) the subjective biases of the interrogator — what is now commonly referred to as the “scientific method”. The ideal of objectivity sought by Bacon is approached through a combination of rigorous logic (mathematics) and observational verification. Ideally, what this means is that the veracity of any explanation for an observed phenomenon can be <em>tested</em> by constructing, based on the logic of the explanation, defined circumstances that reliably (re)produce the phenomenon, i.e., an experiment. An underlying assumption implicit in this scientific ideal is that the act of observing an experiment does not influence its outcome; that is, the experimenter is excluded from the conditions considered relevant to the experimental results. While on its face this seems reasonable, it breaks down when we look at things closely enough. In reality it is impossible to observe something without interacting with it and thus affecting it in some way. Pure objectivity is thus an ideal that we strive to but can never fully achieve.</p><p>In summary, science ideally is a means of obtaining accurate, reliable knowledge about the world, providing answers to our questions. Some answers are definitive while others are tentative but amenable to testing via observation and experiment. From this idealized perspective, one might suppose that there is a finite body of knowledge that, through concerted application of the scientific method, we will eventually come to discover in its entirety. But this supposition is completely wrong.</p><p><strong><em>What it is, really</em></strong></p><p>Science starts with a question: most if not all scientists do what they do (or at least, start out doing what they do) because they are curious to know about the world (“nature”). In essence, science is a refined approach to doing what we all do from birth through (at least) early childhood. Every child who pesters their parents with the question “why”, or who, after being told not to touch a hot stove, does so anyway to test the warning, is engaging in rudimentary science. Indeed, as I have written <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-price-we-pay-for-human-consciousness-is-an-exceptional-proclivity-for-self-deception-cc682de51ec6">previously</a>, all animals (and for that matter, all living organisms) engage in the <a href="https://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol18/iss3/art1/figure1.html">modeling relation</a>, which informs them of their world and through which they learn to anticipate change before it becomes an existential emergency. Science is merely a highly developed human expression of that defining characteristic of life itself.</p><p>Science is often contrasted with art, but in reality, science <em>is</em> art, of a specific form. Like all artforms, science requires well-trained, artistically creative expression, at every stage, from posing a hypothesis and designing an experiment to test it, to displaying the results and telling a story about what those results mean. What distinguishes science from other forms of art is that science tests its creative expressions against reality using rigorous logic (mathematics), observation, and measurement. If the creative expressions of science fail those tests, they are discarded as unrealistic fantasy unworthy of further consideration. Thus, while art in general can be said to be a creative endeavor to explore our subjective experience of the world, science is art that goes one step further to ascertain whether what is found in that exploration is logically and empirically verifiable — and thus “objectively” true. It is not a coincidence that the greatest scientists were the most creative (Einstein being the quintessential example).</p><p>If science is not, as is often idealized, a project that builds a body of knowledge that has finite limits and is thus possible to complete, what is it really? According to neurobiologist <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuart_Firestein">Stuart Firestein</a>, science works to progressively <em>refine</em> our infinite ignorance. From my experience, this perspective captures the reality of science: our ignorance is what motivates us to ask questions, answers to which help allay our ignorance. But (as any working scientist knows) every answer raises new questions that probe deeper into the workings of the world. Thus, we always remain “ignorant” (in that there will always be things that don’t know), but the knowledge obtained through science refines that ignorance by empowering us to ask better (more precise) questions that take us further down the rabbit hole into understanding the world’s boundless complexity. As we progress down that hole, we learn more and more about the world as what was previously unknown becomes known. But there is no end to what we can learn. Science exemplifies the aphorism: it is not about the destination, but the journey.</p><p>When seen from this perspective, it is easy to imagine that the rabbit hole of science has many anastomosing branches, and indeed it does: physics, chemistry, biology, geology, anthropology, sociology, psychology, etc., each with their many subbranches (e.g., for biology: ecology, physiology, cell biology, etc.). While each branch connects to the others, each also extends into a divergent, unique set of questions. This raises the question: given that the progressive refining of ignorance via science raises an ever-increasing, ever-branching variety of questions, who decides which of those questions to pursue? Ideally, one might think that it is the scientists themselves. But considering that pursuit of the questions requires resources (i.e., funding, energy, infrastructure, and technology) that are finite, reality is more complicated: the questions pursued by science are those for which the resources are available to support their pursuit.</p><p>Historically, funding for science was provided by wealthy benefactors, such as royalty or the Church, in pursuit of the benefactor’s idiosyncratic agenda. Much of the knowledge derived from classical science was obtained by “gentleman scientists” — independently wealthy people (typically men) who were afforded sufficient leisure to engage in scientific investigations. Those fortunate few pursued whatever questions they found of interest. For anyone lacking personal wealth, the questions pursued tend to be those of interest to a benefactor (although there have always been a few generous benefactors who recognize genius and are happy to support it just to see where it leads).</p><p>In the modern era (mainly post-World War II) the major benefactor for science in the U.S.A. has been the federal government, which funds scientific research using money provided by taxpayers. The government itself provides some guidance as to what questions are prioritized, e.g., as with Kennedy’s goal of landing a man on the moon, which raised many questions stemming from the central question of how to accomplish that, which required a good deal of scientific research to answer. But the government has mostly relied on scientists themselves to prioritize questions, e.g., via “peer review” of grants that fund the research. So, the questions that science pursues are generally those that have been prioritized by funders using the expert advice of working scientists. As you can imagine, this means that, far from the ideal of being a pure, unbiased pursuit of knowledge, science is heavily biased by the interests that have developed both within the culture of working scientists, and in the wider culture in which science is embedded. Since most science depends on public funding, it depends on public trust, which depends on public understanding and appreciation of science.</p><p>As noted above, there are many branches of science, each with their own knowledge bases and technical languages. The explosion of scientific knowledge has favored the evolution of specialists within each field focused on specific lines of questioning. As the knowledge continues exploding, scientific specialists in different fields are finding it increasingly difficult to keep up with their own field, much less engage in discourse across fields, and indeed, to even understand the questions being addressed in other fields. The result is that science has grown into a ‘Tower of Babel’. While the ideal of science is that knowledge must be amenable to scientific verification, very few people outside of the highly specialized silos of different fields of science have the expertise or even the language needed to ask, much less answer, the questions needed to test the veracity of scientific information that passes for knowledge. The only recourse is to trust that the specialists in each field are asking the right questions and have sufficient scientific expertise not only to answer them, but to verify that the answers being provided by their specialized peers are correct. For publicly funded science, that becomes an acute problem when the public loses its trust in science.</p><p>So, although the ideal of science is that it is something that anyone with curiosity, an ability to ask probing questions amenable to scientific testing, and <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/science-is-the-best-defense-we-have-against-self-deception-b234efe91763">healthy skepticism</a> can pursue, the current reality is that it is something that is mainly pursued by a small minority of highly trained, highly focused specialists who talk mainly to each other about their esoteric work. Trusting the veracity of scientific knowledge requires either that you become technically proficient in a specific field or place your faith in those who do. When you consider that our existential predicaments — ecological overshoot and collapse, accumulating toxic pollution, climate change, and the specter of nuclear annihilation — are all fruits of science and technology, it is understandable why the public might be wary of placing their faith in scientists.</p><p><strong><em>How it works, ideally</em></strong></p><p>The “scientific method” for answering the questions motivating science is to formulate a hypothesis, which is a tentative, best guess answer, based on logic and what is currently known. To be scientific, a hypothesis must be testable, that is “falsifiable” by empirical observation and/or logic. To test a hypothesis, empirical observations and measurements must be made, often via experiment in controlled laboratory conditions, that either prove the hypothesis to be false by contradicting its predictions, or not. Ideally, experiments will be designed in such a way that any result that does <em>not</em> disprove the hypothesis can be taken as support for its veracity, rather than a chance coincidence. However, since it is difficult if not impossible to know enough about anything to rule out all alternative explanations for any given observation (including pure chance), science is not in the business of “proving” hypotheses, which always remain somewhat provisional explanations subject to further testing. Over time, hypotheses that withstand the scrutiny of rigorous testing can be elaborated into scientific theories, which not only provide explanations of observed phenomena, but also explanations and predictions of many disparate phenomena that are observed under a variety of circumstances. The main difference between a hypothesis and a theory is that the latter has explanatory power that is generalizable across phenomena and has been tested more thoroughly. Nonetheless, scientific hypotheses and theories are both provisional explanations subject to falsification by contradictory facts, and revision by new knowledge.</p><p>Ideally, science constructs hypotheses and theories via two kinds of reasoning: deductive and inductive. The former begins with a small number of assumptions (axioms or “first principles”) that appear self-evident (e.g., “a line is the shortest distance between two points”), and then uses logic or mathematical modeling to deduce conclusions about causality that can then be empirically tested via observation. Inductive reasoning begins with a variety of observations that appear to form correlated patterns suggestive of causality, providing a hypothesis that can then be tested via mathematical modeling and through further observations and measurement. While science uses both types of reasoning in service of the “scientific method”, as you might by now expect, this idealization fails to adequately capture how it really works.</p><p><strong><em>How it works, really</em></strong></p><p>Science is the art of asking questions that have answers which can be determined to be true or false. While the “scientific method” as well as deductive and inductive reasoning play a role in that inquiry, in practice it depends entirely on the creative intuition of scientists. As I wrote <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/why-things-are-the-way-they-are-and-how-they-came-to-be-a1ff30043f68">previously</a>, chance is the font of all creativity, and this is as true for science as it is for any other art form. Isaac Asimov said that “The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds the most discoveries, is not “Eureka!” but ‘That’s funny…”. He was referring to the fact that most groundbreaking discoveries — those that expand the envelope of understanding — are initially surprising. They are often serendipitous, like Alexander Fleming’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discovery_of_penicillin">initial discovery of penicillin</a> following accidental contamination of a bacterial culture with mold. As Louis Pasteur famously said, “in the fields of observation, chance favors only the prepared mind”. So, the most groundbreaking scientists are those who have prepared themselves to be vigilant for surprising observations and follow them where they lead. In practice then, science works to advance understanding (refine ignorance) not only by focused application of the scientific method to solving a specific problem, but just as importantly, by scientists playfully indulging their curiosity and intuition, and following where it leads.</p><p>But science depends on funding, and funders are typically not motivated to merely indulge the curiosity of scientists. They are more often interested in solving problems (roadblocks to progress in a defined project, such as putting a man on the moon) that require scientific knowledge. So, science, in practice, is the art of asking questions that have answers that can be determined to be true or false AND that are of interest to those who can provide the resources needed to do the work. As a result, science is subject to fashion and the whims of those with the means to support it. Although public funding ostensibly gets around this by having scientists themselves determine, via peer review, what gets funded, it doesn’t really, because scientists are people with whims and opinions entrained by the fashions of culture, and like all people, are vulnerable to peer pressure. Peer review thus acts as a filter biasing what science gets done. While scientific breakthroughs that push the envelope generally depend on surprising results that by nature are not predictable, peer review depends on the opinions of scientists whose expertise developed around pre-existing knowledge. Getting creative, groundbreaking science funded therefore requires that a scientist have sufficient rhetorical talent to thread the needle of assuaging reviewer skepticism about “out-of-the-box” thinking.</p><p>A mental box that constrains contemporary science is “reductionism”, the scientific approach to understanding phenomena by breaking them apart to identify the underlying mechanisms that produce them. As an approach, reductionism has been very successful. For example, in my own field of developmental biology we now know quite a bit about the molecular and cellular mechanisms that direct development of a single cell zygote into a multicellular embryo and then into a mature organism. Reductionism has been instrumental in the development of most modern medicines, including effective treatments for diseases that were previously considered untreatable. The amazing success of reductionism has encouraged widespread belief among scientists that it is the best if not the only legitimate scientific approach to understanding phenomena. Many journals won’t publish research papers that describe observations but do not elucidate the underlying molecular mechanisms that account for the observations, and similarly, grant proposals that do not attempt to elucidate mechanisms are seldom funded.</p><p>While reductionism as an approach is well and good, it tends to entrain a problematic but highly prevalent mindset. In focusing on mechanisms, reductionism ignores relational context (e.g., the role of environmental conditions and evolutionary history), inviting the assumption that molecular mechanisms are determinative and causally sufficient to explain a given phenomenon. One symptom of this in biomedical science is the prevalence of overgeneralization: when a mechanism underlying an observed phenomenon is elucidated in a specific model system under highly controlled laboratory conditions, it is often assumed that the mechanism is sufficient to explain the phenomenon whenever it is observed in any system under any condition. While science itself has proven this to be a dangerous and often mistaken assumption, the temptation to overgeneralize from an experimentally elucidated mechanism remains, because findings that are <em>generally </em>true are more interesting, and far more likely to attract funding, than findings that are highly dependent on specific experimental conditions. Reductionism makes it easy to give in to this temptation by removing the causal influence of context from consideration.</p><p>The other major problem emanating from reductionism is that ignoring context invites failure to anticipate or even attend to the unintended consequences of engineering based on reductionist science. Focus on mechanisms enables engineering of technological wonders that make our lives easier or more comfortable, like automobiles, smart phones, and Cheetos, while creating (but ignoring) new and increasingly serious environmental problems like climate change, toxic pollution, ecocide, and deteriorating public health.</p><p>Finally, the reality of contemporary science is that it is both enabled by and highly dependent on “cutting edge” technologies — advanced telescopes, microscopes, DNA sequencers, particle accelerators, supercomputers, servers, etc., etc. — that are energy and resource intensive and expensive. As I have written <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">previously</a>, development of anything is driven by positive feedback loops, and the scientific enterprise is no exception. Science produces knowledge that enables engineers to develop technologies that enable scientists to dig deeper for knowledge that further enables engineering of technology that scientists use to probe even deeper, in a positive feedback loop (“virtuous cycle”). As the scientific enterprise has developed, science itself has evolved: whereas only a few years ago most effort was directed at <em>obtaining</em> data, the explosion of data enabled by technology and computers has now shifted the effort bottleneck to the <em>interpretation </em>of a massive and still growing body of existing data. The work of professional science has concomitantly evolved, such that most progress is now made by collaborating teams of scientists from multiple disciplines, rather than by individual scientists working alone.</p><p><strong><em>We need science</em></strong></p><p>Despite its shortcomings as currently practiced, we <em>need </em>science, because at this point, we can’t solve our problems or understand our <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/predictably-our-senescent-civilization-is-now-collapsing-a5bffce3898a">predicament </a>without it. Any society that abandons science is certain to fail and <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9">collapse</a>. Moreover, the roots of science are part and parcel with being alive and sentient: as I have discussed here and elsewhere, science is a highly developed, human expression of the modeling relation that is the essence of life itself. The question for society is thus not whether we need science. Rather, the questions we should be asking are what kind of science we want to do, and why; how we want to go about doing it; who we want to empower to do it; and how much we value it as something worth investing in.</p><p><strong><em>Further Reading</em></strong></p><p>Firestein, S. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Ignorance-Drives-Science-Stuart-Firestein-ebook-dp-B007M7HXMC/dp/B007M7HXMC/ref=mt_other?_encoding=UTF8&amp;me=&amp;qid="><em>Ignorance: How it Drives Science</em></a>. Oxford University Press, 2012.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=10fe1c9d3d1c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Rise and Fall of the United States of America]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-united-states-of-america-bf9bfe0b8770?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bf9bfe0b8770</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[usa]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 17 Feb 2025 23:39:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-06T14:30:54.607Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>An excerpt from Chapter X: The Final Days (2024–2026)</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*BE0AX3kRs-6P5gOPoV5gFA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Constitutional Convention of 1887 (Junius Brutus Stearns, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons)</figcaption></figure><p>As discussed in the previous chapters, the U.S.A. was built on an unstable foundation cobbled together from the opposing forces of democracy and slavery-based capitalist oligarchy. After the early republic settled into a two-party system, that tension created a political pendulum that swung wildly back and forth from one pole to the other, culminating in the first Civil War (1861–1865). While that conflagration ended with the outlawing of chattel slavery, it failed to resolve the pendulous tension between democracy and oligarchy. The tension did not resolve until the final collapse of the republic into a techno-feudalist state, in which a tiny, self-serving group of ultrawealthy overlords owned everything, including the vast population of former citizens who, for want of food, water, shelter, and protection, willingly submitted to slavery.</p><p>The dynamic tension between democracy and oligarchy that was baked into the foundations of the republic came to a head during last half century of the American empire, beginning in 1980 with Ronald Reagan’s deregulation of industry and demonization of government. That, abetted by Reagan’s appeal to widespread racist, Christian fundamentalist, and nativist fears, led the nation’s lower and middle classes to increasingly polarize and turn on one another as their wealth was inexorably redistributed (ironically, via the mechanisms of government) to the highest echelons of the upper class. The final nail in the coffin of American democracy was the explosive development, beginning in the 1990s, of information technology, which was exploited by Russian political technologists and their oligarchic allies in the U.S. to undermine both public discourse and trust in U.S. institutions. So, the collapse of the republic did not happen overnight. But it seemed that way to most U.S. citizens, who (with a few notable exceptions among academic scholars) lacked the objectifying perspective that we now enjoy as the beneficiaries of a half century of intervening time.</p><p>Many historians have remarked on the parallels between the fall of the U.S.A. in 2025 and the fall of the German Weimar Republic 92 years earlier. Indeed, as noted in the last chapter, many Americans repeatedly sounded the alarm while it was happening, even prior to the first election of Donald Trump in 2016. Despite the obvious parallels, it is worth asking how it could have happened, given the substantial differences between the political and socioeconomic circumstances of the late Weimar Republic and the late U.S. Republic. The citizens of Germany in the early 1930s suffered from hyper-inflation that rendered their currency almost worthless, massive unemployment, and the psychological trauma of losing the first World War. They also lacked a deep historical tradition of democracy. In contrast, American citizens of the early 2020s were the beneficiaries of over 240 years of a constitutional democracy, with its attendant freedoms and rights encoded in law. Under the presidency of Joe Biden, they also enjoyed a remarkable economic recovery from the devastation wrought by the COVID-19 pandemic. Indeed, that recovery produced the strongest economy in the world and the lowest U.S. unemployment in decades, which eased inflation and launched projects that began to renew crumbling infrastructure. Moreover, Trump’s failure during his first presidency to respond adequately to the pandemic that killed over a million Americans, followed by his violent coup attempt of January 6, 2021 (which was widely televised and led to his second impeachment) and then by the public dissemination of the Project 2025 plan to overthrow American democracy upon re-election of Trump, provided Americans with all the information they needed to hear the echoes of Nazi Germany and understand the existential danger of a second Trump presidency. Given all that, why did Americans re-elect Trump in November 2024?</p><p>While there is no simple answer to that question, we can identify at least three key factors. The first was the rise of information technology, which as noted above was used strategically by the opponents of democracy to misinform the public and destroy trust in both academic expertise and government institutions. Following his electoral defeat in 2020, Donald Trump and his anti-democratic accomplices exploited that mistrust by mounting a massive, sustained disinformation campaign (not unlike the “Big Lie” propaganda used by the Nazis), which was amplified by Russian political technology on social network platforms and via far-right corporate media, as well as by Trump’s allies in Congress. This disinformation campaign was not effectively countered by “centrist” mainstream media, which instead provided an additional platform for disseminating the propaganda by presenting it as normal politics. It is important to remember that at that time, the predominant economic model was the commodification of attention, which resulted in a nationwide attention deficit disorder in a populace that was poorly educated (and hence gullible), politically disengaged, and complacent. Americans thus found it easy to put the horrors of the first Trump presidency out of mind, even the horror of his first coup attempt, and to eventually accept the lies as a reasonable alternative account of what had happened. As unbelievable as it may sound to us now, by November 2024 many Americans were naïvely unsuspicious of Trump’s intentions, preferring to take him at his word when he claimed to have their best interests at heart.</p><p>Second, for reasons that are still not entirely clear, but undoubtedly owing to the substantial political power Trump retained through his uncanny hold over his large charismatic cult, following his 2020 electoral loss the Republican Party purged itself of members who weren’t deemed sufficiently loyal to Trump. That purge extended to many state legislatures, which then mounted concerted and highly strategic campaigns to disenfranchise anti-Trump voters. Those campaigns included gerrymandering to permanently lock in far-right Republican supermajorities, purging voter rolls of registered Democrats, eliminating polling locations in largely Democratic districts, passing laws that enabled discounting of legitimate votes, and generally making it difficult for Democratic-leaning voters to cast their ballots. These activities strongly “stacked the deck” in favor of a Trump electoral victory.</p><p>The third, and perhaps most decisive factor that enabled Trump’s reelection was the financial and technological aid he received from the world’s wealthiest man, Elon Musk. Musk, like Trump, was an oligarch born into familial wealth accumulated through exploitation. Unlike Trump, Musk was technologically savvy and built both his reputation and his historically unprecedented wealth by buying and running forward-looking tech-based companies, including the electric automaker Tesla and the private rocket manufacturer SpaceX, both of which benefitted greatly from government contracts and subsidies. During the first Trump presidency, Musk was still mostly known only for his spectacular, futuristic technological endeavors, for which he was widely admired. But Musk was also outspoken in his “libertarian” sociopolitical views, which he frequently expressed on the popular social network Twitter. He eventually became frustrated with that platform’s system for checking the factuality of what users posted, and for blocking posts that were deemed misleading, irresponsible, or incendiary. When Twitter’s finances became tenuous, Musk seized the opportunity for a hostile buyout of the company, which he then quickly transformed into an outlet for far-right propaganda. After restructuring via massive layoffs, the company imploded, with substantial losses in both value and users. Even then, most Americans continued to view Musk more as a technological savant than as an oligarch with authoritarian proclivities. As noted above, most Americans by that time were distracted and gullible, and thus easily misled.</p><p>So, as it happened, despite alarms having been sounded warning of Musk’s exceptionally inordinate influence and power during the leadup to the 2024 election, the scope and depth of that influence took most people completely by surprise during the successful technological coup d’etat that he mounted immediately after Trump took office in January 2025. Musk’s coup, carried out by a small, handpicked group of hackers, hijacked the nation’s computer systems, compromising most of the financial and technological levers of government. This occurred while most of the nation was distracted by Trump’s onslaught of outrageous executive orders and performative politics. While the coup took barely three weeks to accomplish, several months later many Americans continued to believe that they still lived in a functioning republic and went about their daily business, as if nothing had really changed. That public perception did not change until the economic collapse of 2026, and by then it was too late.</p><p>Many of us living now find it astounding that in November 2024 most Americans failed to even consider that, in addition to the outsize influence that Musk exerted through his propaganda dissemination network and his financing of Trump’s political campaign, he had sufficient technological savvy and resources to exploit cyber-vulnerabilities and hack into critical computer systems that tallied votes, and thereby swing the election for Trump, without anyone being the wiser. It is likely that he had planned his coup for a long time and saw the election of Trump as a means to that end. It is therefore implausible that he would <em>not </em>have stolen the election given the opportunity; and given the aforementioned vulnerabilities, the opportunity almost certainly existed. Remarkably, after losing the election Democrats failed to even mount an investigation into that all-too-plausible possibility. This was in stark contrast to the Republican response to Trump’s loss in 2020, with its many recounts of votes and investigations of “voter fraud” (all of which failed to produce any evidence that put the legitimacy of Joe Biden’s victory in question).</p><p>The Musk-Trump coup of 2025 marks the end of the constitutional republic of the United States of America, a 248-year experiment in democracy launched by the Declaration of Independence in 1776, and, following the victory of the colonies in their war of independence from British rule, codified by the Constitutional Convention of 1787. The Constitution formalized the rule of law that would be the republic’s guiding light. After the Musk-Trump coup, that rule of law vanished, and the nation fell into the age-old ‘law of the rulers’ that had been the norm for most of human history, and against which the American colonists had fought in their revolutionary war. Ironically, as noted at the beginning of this chapter and explored throughout this book, the foundations of the republic contained the seeds of its demise, written into the Constitution by the wealthy oligarchs (many of whom owned slaves) who were widely revered as the nation’s “founding fathers”. Like all oligarchs, the founders desired to preserve their wealth and power against the democratic forces that might work to redistribute it more equitably and so took care to defend against that by writing protective measures (such as the Senate, which was instrumental in paving the way for a second Trump presidency) into the Constitution.</p><p>Some may object to the assertion that the U.S.A. ended with Musk’s coup, preferring the commonly held view that the fall did not come until the end of the second American Civil War. That conflict, part of the overall global war precipitated by the Trump regime’s 2026 military assault on Iran, did not begin until after the economic collapse that precipitated the Second Great Depression, which fully transformed the U.S.A. into a techno-feudal slave state. When the civil war finally erupted Donald Trump was still president of what was nominally the United States of America, a designation that did not end until the conquest and surrender of the U.S. capitol that established our current geographic principalities. But by February 2025 Trump’s U.S.A. was a republic in name only. Musk’s successful coup robbed it of all the essential qualities that had made it both the venerated “land of opportunity” for its largely immigrant populace, and the model of democracy that much of the world aspired to emulate. Given that Donald Trump’s trademarked slogan was “make America great again”, it is indeed ironic that his re-election destroyed the very essence of what had made America great in the first place.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bf9bfe0b8770" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Nature of Change]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-nature-of-change-cf707bfbdf77?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cf707bfbdf77</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[time]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[thermodynamics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 03 Feb 2025 22:31:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-23T13:56:26.706Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On the what, why, where, when, and how of perpetual change.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*phL4rHkaheA_-vYUJnPY_g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Infrared image of the Helix Nebula (from <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Comets_Kick_up_Dust_in_Helix_Nebula_(PIA09178).jpg">Wikimedia Commons</a>)</figcaption></figure><blockquote>And there you are,</blockquote><blockquote>Saying we have the moon, so now the stars,</blockquote><blockquote>When all you see</blockquote><blockquote>Is near disaster gazing down on you and me.</blockquote><blockquote>And there you’re standing,</blockquote><blockquote>Saying we have the whole world in our hands,</blockquote><blockquote>When all you see,</blockquote><blockquote>Deep inside the world’s controlling you and me.</blockquote><blockquote>Who’ll see perpetual change?</blockquote><blockquote>You’ll see perpetual change.</blockquote><ul><li>Jon Anderson (from the Yes song <a href="https://youtu.be/gMP-ogxdZdA?si=2vg19s2kc0PyV8Uf"><em>Perpetual Change</em></a>)</li></ul><p>The irony of existence is that the only constant is change. This universe and everything in it are constantly changing, even when they appear not to be. To me, that is a beautiful thing. I am a <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/why-things-are-the-way-they-are-and-how-they-came-to-be-a1ff30043f68">lifelong student of change</a>, motivated by a fascination that began early in childhood when I became aware of deep time (via dinosaurs) on the one hand, and deep space (via astronomy) on the other. I learned through some excellent illustrated books that, eons before anatomically modern humans appeared on earth a mere 300,000 years ago, dinosaurs dominated the planet for 186 million years, before becoming suddenly extinct 66 million years ago (or mostly extinct — all except for the dinosaur ancestors of modern birds), a sudden change that we now know was caused by a cataclysmic collision of an asteroid with earth. I also learned that our sun is but one star among billions of others in our galaxy, which is but one of trillions of galaxies in the universe. In junior high school I learned of Einstein’s theory of relativity, which holds that time passes at a rate that is objectively relative to velocity: time slows as velocity increases, up to the limit set by the speed of light, at which speed time stands still. These thoughts have occupied my mind most of my life, and they still blow my mind, in a way that I find quite comforting.</p><p>Change is both an objective fact and a subjective experience. We all experience change as we go through life — not only in what we observe happening in the world and our environment, but also in ourselves. In adulthood I became increasingly interested in the subjective aspect, i.e., psychological change: the process of learning and how it occurs episodically, in “fits and starts” rather than as a smooth progression, and the difficulty of changing bad habits and addictions. As I get older, I am acutely aware of the subjective relativity of time, how the perception of its passage depends one’s age: at 65, time flies by so much faster, marked by far less personal change, than it did when I was 6.</p><p>Finally, change is something that is central to everything I work on in my profession as a biologist. It is manifest not only in the evolution of life on earth, but also in the fact that we creatures all come to exist via development, a dramatic process of change that transforms a single cell into a complex multicellular organism, often involving <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis</a>, change that radically transforms an organism’s way of being. Developmental change constrains and thus guides evolutionary change. In the face of all this change, a defining characteristic of being alive is <em>homeostasis</em> — the maintenance, via physiology and behavior, of relative constancy in one’s various attributes (appearance, weight, body temperature, etc.). Homeostasis is the illusion of stasis — to achieve it, organisms work to dynamically control their physiology, anatomy, and behavior, in a way that allows them to proactively change (typically in subtle ways that are not obvious to the eye) as needed and to the extent possible to adapt to their ever-changing circumstances, while still maintaining their characteristic attributes. Moreover, while in maturity we may <em>appear</em> not to change for long periods of time, the molecules and cells in our bodies are changing constantly, coming and going in a process of continuous regeneration such that materially, the physical body you have now is almost completely different than the one you had a few years ago.</p><p>At this point of human history, our species confronts a world undergoing unprecedented, cataclysmic change wrought by human technology and industry. If we want to deal with that change effectively (i.e., if we want to avoid extinction, the fate of all species unable to <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/change-foresight-adaptability-dune-and-parable-of-the-sower-9b46fd804074">adapt to change</a>), it behooves us to understand the nature of change — what it is, and why, where, when, and how it happens. I believe that my lifelong study has given me insight into those questions.</p><p><strong><em>What it is</em></strong></p><p>Change is the production of <em>difference</em>, which entails movement. In other words, change is that which manifests the passage of time. Change in location — movement from point ‘a’ to point ‘b’ — takes time. Minimally, this requires that points ‘a’ and ‘b’ are in distinct locations. But it also implies that ‘a’ differs from ‘b’: If ‘a’ and ‘b’ and all points between are identical in <em>every</em> way, there would be no change. Change is thus difference that makes a difference, which, not coincidentally, is also one of the definitions of information.</p><p>The classical (Newtonian) laws of motion mathematically formalize various aspects of change that can be described and analyzed geometrically: change in position, change in velocity (forced acceleration), change in momentum, etc. The remarkable predictive power of calculus invites the deterministic fantasy that all change is predictable. Of course it is not, because the complexity of the actual world is such that acquiring sufficient knowledge to render it fully predictable is impossible, not only due to physical limits imposed by the second law of thermodynamics, deterministic chaos, and quantum indeterminacy, but because it is impossible to develop a formal model of the actual world that is complete. Every change produces new causal relations that were not accounted for in the model. The world is fundamentally unpredictable because everything depends on everything else: variables cannot be realistically separated in the way that is needed to solve the deterministic equations. The universe of possibility thus includes all manner of unpredictable change (that which we attribute to <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4392722/"><em>chance</em></a>), which is the most interesting kind: the creation of something fundamentally new — i.e., something that is not only different, but surprising.</p><p>Change is caused by <em>energy </em>differentials: the energy difference between a system and its surroundings, or free energy, is what compels change. Energy takes two basic forms: kinetic (movement) and potential (stored in some stationary configuration). Potential energy can be converted into kinetic energy, and <em>vice versa</em>. Energy dissipation involves its conversion from one form to another, which is the subject of thermodynamics (the science of how energy or heat — ‘thermo’ — moves — ‘dynamics’).</p><p>Energy is intimately related to the Newtonian concept of force, which, given inertia, is what is required to change an object’s motion. Any forced change in motion (acceleration) dissipates energy. The increasing kinetic energy of an accelerating object implies that potential energy is being dissipated into kinetic energy. That is exactly what happens when you push on the accelerator of your car — the potential energy in the gasoline is dissipated, via combustion, into the kinetic energy of your acceleration. When <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/why-things-are-the-way-they-are-and-how-they-came-to-be-a1ff30043f68">Humpty Dumpty fell from the wall</a>, the potential energy of the gravitational attraction between him and the earth was dissipated into the kinetic energy of his acceleration to the ground, which was then dissipated into the kinetic energy of his messy shattering.</p><p><em>Change, then, is transformational movement, or the flow of matter and energy as they are converted, via dissipation, from one form to another</em>.</p><p>As alluded to above, change manifests time. What is time? According to Einstein, it is merely the fourth dimension of our universe, which together with the first three dimensions comprises spacetime. Recall that time (again, according to Einstein) is something that passes only for things moving at less than the speed of light. For anything traveling at the speed of light, time stands still. This implies that a deep connection exists between time and light.</p><p>Light, which is carried by waves, is composed of quantum particles called photons (an insight for which we can yet again thank Einstein!), which are the smallest irreducible packets of energy. The energy of light is measured as its frequency (wavelength), which is the basis of color: higher frequencies (toward the ultraviolet end of the spectrum) carry more energy than lower frequencies (toward the infrared end of the spectrum). For a single photon, the frequency is the period of its oscillation. Frequency is the inverse of time (f = 1/t), and <em>vice versa</em>. The energy of a photon (E = <em>h</em>f, where <em>h</em> is Planck’s constant) is thus also the inverse of time. This relationship has led biophysicist <a href="https://www.mv.helsinki.fi/home/aannila/arto/">Arto Annila</a> to reason (controversially, albeit compellingly, as I have yet to see a substantive counterargument) that time — as well as everything else in the universe including the vacuum — is composed of photons, a modernization of an ancient atomistic idea. According to Annila, subatomic matter (electrons, protons, neutrons) consists of bound photons adopting closed configurations that impart the properties of each subatomic particle, whereas light is free single photons, and the vacuum is paired photons of opposite polarity, which renders them invisible. In Annila’s accounting, the photonic vacuum, which envelops and interacts with everything within it (i.e., everything in the universe), is the medium that carries the waves of electromagnetic fields, analogous to how the water is the medium for the waves of the ocean, or air is the medium for soundwaves.</p><p>So, back to the question of what change is, and its relationship to time: time passes when things change, and conversely, change marks the passage of time. But time only <em>passes</em> for things that are moving more slowly than the speed of light. Things that are moving at the speed of light — photons — physically embody time: a photon is a single, irreducible unit of time, held within the photon’s period. Since change is a transformational flow that converts energy from one form to another and takes time, we can surmise that change occurs via the flow of photons, which take the least-time path in any given circumstance.</p><p>Although everything is constantly changing, some things appear to change more than others, and (from our perspective) some things appear to not change at all. That is because the energy flow that mediates change is configuration-dependent and channeled via impediments to flow that establish defined conduits. The conduits mediating the flow that brings about change are what we refer to as information. Like everything else, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">they came to exist through a process of development</a>. The information that makes change in our universe intelligible — the laws of physics, the rules of chemistry, the genetic codes of biology — came to be via development of the universe since its explosive inception.</p><p>Life is a conduit mediating the energy flow that brings about change. Through the conduit of life, change does not occur willy nilly — it happens in ways that are intelligible, and in the service of life. Life exists as a dynamic tension: it requires stability in the face of change, and thus seeks homeostasis, which it achieves by using genetic and epigenetic information to control flow toward its own self-maintenance and self-perpetuation.</p><p>But life entails death, and death signals impermanence, which is a fundamental aspect of change. Change is thus a dance of life and death, regeneration and degeneration. Subjectively, things can change for the better or for the worse, via construction and destruction: change manifests as both progress and as regress. Some aspects of change are cyclical, others are not.</p><p>Change is a yin-yang phenomenon.</p><p>Whatever its manifestation, change happens because of the flow of energy. That is what it is. But <em>why</em> does it happen?</p><p>To answer that we need to consider that the universe is far from equilibrium — a complex, dynamic system composed of entities and subsystems that are out of balance with their surroundings — and that, given the opportunity, imbalanced configurations naturally move toward balance.</p><p><strong><em>Why it happens</em></strong></p><p>The question “why” is equivalent to “to what end”? When we ask someone why they did what they did, we seek their motivations, which include their goal-directed intentions. This makes sense, because life directs change intentionally, working via energy dissipation to achieve its own ends of survival and reproduction, which in turn serve the universal drive for greater balance. But what about more generally? Why does change happen in purely physical systems that lack intentions?</p><p>Consider an ice cube in a drink: over time, the cube melts, and the molecules that were frozen within it freely mix with those in the drink. If left standing long enough, the mixture will become homogeneous, owing to the spontaneous movement of its molecules. That spontaneous, unintentional change happens because concentration differences even out in the process of attaining balance. The energy mediating the change flows down a gradient of increasing probability, from an unbalanced, less likely configuration (i.e., one that is more constrained, with fewer degrees of freedom) to a balanced, more likely one (less constrained, with more degrees of freedom): molecular movement proceeds spontaneously in the direction of least resistance (most freedom). This is the second law of thermodynamics: energy flows down gradients of potential. Given the opportunity, any energetic configuration of high potential will dissipate spontaneously (via kinetic energy) into a configuration of lower potential. Thus, change entails some loss of potential, as a system achieves balance with its surroundings. We can therefore say that, in general, <em>change happens because an energy differential affords potential (free energy) for it to happen</em>. Free energy, the force that compels change, is provided by the imbalanced configuration of the universe, a vast reservoir of potential energy that is undergoing dissipation into kinetic energy over time.</p><p>A common objection to this formulation is that locally we can readily observe changes that have the opposite effect of creating configurations of high potential from configurations of lower potential, in seeming violation of the second law. Life itself is widely offered as the prime example. But one might also wonder why water freezes if ice is a lower probability (more ordered) configuration than liquid water. The illusion that the second law is violated in these cases is created by failure to consider the larger context. In the case of life, the creation of configurations of high potential energy from ones with lower potential energy (e.g., synthesis of ATP from ADP and phosphate) is made possible and driven by the far larger down-gradient flow of photons from the sun, which is spontaneously equilibrating with the surrounding vacuum. In the case of freezing water, whenever that occurs, a temperature gradient exists between the water and its surroundings, equilibration of which (via down-gradient flow of heat out of the water into the surroundings) freezes the water. These and innumerable other examples make clear that change occurs because configurations that are out of balance with their surroundings are unstable (or metastable) reservoirs of potential energy, which dissipates into movement (kinetic energy) that brings about a more stable, balanced configuration. The answer to the question ‘<em>to what end does change occur</em>?’ is ‘<em>to achieve balance’</em>.</p><p>So, change happens because energy flows spontaneously to achieve balance in an imbalanced universe. Said another way: change happens because the universe moves spontaneously to erase differences — which is paradoxical, given that change is the creation of difference! But that paradox merely signals the complexity of the universe, and its relative youth. The universal movement toward balance that over time erases differences in potential fuels the creation of new differences that we experience as change. Dissipative equilibration is the universal font of change.</p><p>While change happens because the universe is out of balance, and movement toward balance is spontaneous, here on earth a good deal of change happens because someone intended it to happen (including someone who is not human — all creatures are intentional), and some of that intentional change involves work that builds up rather than erases potential. Whenever that occurs, it is because a larger gradient of potential is available to be tapped. Any work carried out to bring about intentional change invariably has some unintended consequences. Some of the potential energy that is dissipated to achieve the work is irrecoverably lost as waste.</p><p>So: change happens because potential energy dissipates as the universe moves spontaneously toward greater balance, and some of the kinetic energy that is thus made available can be harnessed intentionally for work, which has both intended and unintended consequences that manifest as change. In economics (the science of human work), intended consequences are typically viewed and quantified as economic growth and development, whereas unintended consequences are viewed as “externalities” that are typically ignored in accounting. Human economic growth, development, and externalities all contribute to the anthropogenic change (including in the climate) that is transforming our world, for which there are no externalities.</p><p><strong><em>Where it happens</em></strong></p><p>The answer to <em>why</em> change happens leads directly to the answer to <em>where</em> it happens: change happens wherever the universe is out of equilibrium — that is, everywhere.</p><p>Here it is useful to distinguish the two kinds of energy flow mediating change: spontaneous flow, and work, for which <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incomplete_Nature">Terrence Deacon</a> coined the respective terms “orthograde” (with the grade) and “contragrade” (against the grade). Orthograde flow is simply energy flow down a potential gradient, such as occurs when an ice cube melts in a drink, or when warm water freezes when the surrounding temperature drops below 0 degrees C. It therefore occurs wherever there is an unconstrained gradient of potential. Contragrade flow — that which involves work — occurs wherever orthograde flow can be tapped to build up potential to support work locally. Life on earth mediates contragrade flow that taps the orthograde flow of photons from the sun. The 21st century human economy is contragrade flow that taps the orthograde flow of energy released by combustion of fossil fuels, which are the potential built up by the work of prehistoric life.</p><p>Given this, we can conclude that change — whether it be spontaneous (orthograde) or achieved via work (contragrade) — happens wherever there is a source of potential energy; that is, wherever the universe holds a reservoir of energy by virtue of an imbalanced configuration. At this stage in the universe’s development that is everywhere. In some places (like planet earth) conditions are such that the rate of change is much faster than elsewhere (e.g., on Mars). Equilibration produces change, some of which involves work fueled by the equilibration. But when does it occur?</p><p><strong><em>When it happens</em></strong></p><p>Change happens <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/causation-is-the-interplay-between-freedom-and-developed-constraint-3e5e66e6d380">whenever a constraint is removed</a> that had previously impeded energy flow in a specific direction, due to a chance event, or when prior changes produce a new mechanism that facilitates the flow. Identifying the constraints, and the course of events that lead to their removal, is the subject of history and the job of historians (including historical scientists such as geologists and paleontologists).</p><p>The history (including the prehistory) of earth includes many cataclysmic changes that were triggered by <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/why-things-are-the-way-they-are-and-how-they-came-to-be-a1ff30043f68">chance events</a> such as the asteroid impact that decimated the dinosaurs. The immediate change precipitated by the explosive kinetic energy of that impact was the death of most life on earth. But that mass death removed a constraint that had previously prevented the evolution of large mammals: namely, the dinosaurs themselves, which had dominated the macrofauna for hundreds of millions of years, suppressing evolutionary radiation of mammals into those ecological niches. In human history, there are many examples of sociocultural change that occurred only when constraints were removed that had previously prevented opportunities. One example is the European Renaissance, marked by explosive change in economics, art, and science on the heels of the Bubonic plague, which removed constraints (by removing people) imposed by the feudal system during the prior Middle Ages.</p><p>Constraints can also be technical in nature. The explosive anthropogenic change that has marked the past two centuries occurred only after Enlightenment science removed the constraints of ignorance that had impeded progress in human engineering. The industrial revolution, and all the subsequent change it catalyzed, was made possible by removal of mental constraints via the sciences of physics, chemistry, and geology. Those mental constraints had previously been developed and enforced by organized religion working in cahoots with socioeconomic-political power, which benefited (and still benefits) from ignorance.</p><p>As noted above, the trajectory of change — movement of energy — is channeled by conduits of possibility and probability, established by prior systemic development. The conduits are formed by constraining barriers to potential that direct flow, much like the contours of a river or canal direct the flow of water. Change happens when those constraining barriers are either removed or overcome by the flow of energy mediating change. Thus, one of the jobs of historians is to identify “tipping points” — historical moments when events and circumstances have, for whatever reason, overcome a barrier (e.g., the knowledge barrier of ignorance, or the economic barrier of inequality) that previously had occluded access to a well of potential.</p><p>At this moment of history, we have an interesting case in point. The United States government recently had a change in administration that is intentionally implementing a dizzying array of disruptive changes in governance, many of which are illegal and unconstitutional. The law and Constitution are constraints that heretofore have sufficed to prevent such change from happening. But as future historians (if there are any) are likely to point out, those constraints have depended on two conditions: (1) agreement of those elected to the highest office of the land to uphold their oath to the Constitution and abide by the rule of law and other social norms; and (2) enforcement of the law, no matter who breaks it. Right now, neither of those conditions is being met, so the constraints that have historically maintained the United States of America as a constitutional republic no longer exist. As a result, the republic is very rapidly degenerating into a fascist oligarchy led by a dictator, aided and abetted by the wealthiest man in the world (i.e., someone who has inordinate amount of control over economic energy flow), who was not elected, but who has little reason to fear repercussions, and hence no qualms about breaking the law, violating the Constitution, and causing massive harm and suffering.</p><p>In general, then, we can say that change happens whenever circumstances remove or overcome constraints that otherwise impede energy flow in a new direction. I would venture to say that in general, destructive events (like the asteroid impact or Bubonic plague) enable new patterns of orthograde flow that over time develop into systems of contragrade flow that erect new constraints while removing others. One obvious major constraint on contragrade flow is availability of an energy gradient that can drive the work that such flow entails. Contemporary human civilization is contragrade flow enabled by burning of fossil fuels. Although energy alternatives exist, it has yet to be demonstrated that they suffice to enable civilization as we know it. When the energy source enabling the contragrade flow of civilization disappears (as it inevitably will), the entire system that depends on that flow for its existence <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9">collapses</a>, bringing about catastrophic change, i.e., collapse of the system.</p><p>Collapse of a system always <em>appears </em>to happen suddenly. While sometimes the change is sudden, due to a chance event such as an asteroid impact, other times it is due to internal changes that have gradually and progressively built up over time, straining the system to the breaking point. For example, the current crisis in the United States seems like a sudden collapse of the constitutional system, but the stresses that precipitated that collapse — massive economic and political inequality — have been building up as a result of the neoliberal economic policies and divisive politics of the past 45 years. Whether a catastrophic collapse is brought on suddenly by a chance external event or gradually by the buildup of internal pressures to a breaking point, it is change caused by removal of constraints.</p><p>If change happens when constraints are removed that previously had prevented the change from happening, what is the nature of those constraints, and how do they arise? That brings us to the final question, how change happens.</p><p><strong><em>How it happens</em></strong></p><p>The constraints that channel the energy flow mediating change are information. <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2078-2489/2/1/102">Information comes to exist via development</a>, which is self-organizing, “autocatalytic” change within a system, and indeed, that brings any system into existence. The universe developed into what it is now following the big bang. The living earth developed into what it is now following its birth as a fiery ball of molten rock. You developed into what you are now following your conception as a single cell zygote within your mother. Each of those developments progressively over time produced the information that defines the respective systems: the “fabric” of spacetime and “laws” of physics, the chemical elements, the geo-biochemistry of earth, and the cellular, anatomical, physiological, and psychological attributes that make you who you are. Within a developing system (the universe, earth, you), evolution occurs, which combines the increasingly constrained (and hence predictable), self-organizing change of development with chance occurrences happening in the larger system containing the developing system. The answer to how change happens, then, is via systemic development and contingent evolution.</p><p>As I have written <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">elsewhere</a>, systemic development follows a characteristic sequence of stages, from immaturity through maturity into senescence. Energy flow in immature systems fuels their growth, and as informational constraints are still undergoing development, immature systems are less predictable — less constrained — than mature systems. They also tend to be less effective and efficient at doing specific jobs. Maturity brings effectiveness and efficiency, but often at the cost of variety, as behaviors become more constrained by specialization for the narrow set of tasks needed for a specific form of work. Senescent systems, having developed beyond the capacity of the system for a specific trajectory of development, are maximally constrained, informationally overburdened, and thus least able to change their way of being. Change nevertheless happens within — or to — senescent systems, in the form of degeneration, regression, and eventually collapse (death, extinction, or metamorphosis) and recycling. From this perspective, development can be viewed as both a means of achieving a specific end, and as a trap that reduces the plasticity that affords capacity for change.</p><p>One reason that it is important to understand the role of development and its stages in constraining the direction of and potential for change is that it illuminates aspects of change that are otherwise unintelligible. For example, impediments to psychological change such as addiction are best understood as well-developed constraints that need to be deconstructed before the change can occur. Our collective inability to confront and solve the wicked problems confronting our civilization is another example. On the one hand, technological change, which overcame many prior constraints on anthropogenic change, continues accelerating at an exponential rate, toward the “singularity” in which humanity becomes merged with (or subsumed by) generalized artificial intelligence as envisioned by Ray Kurzweil. On the other hand, human culture is mired in inflexible, maladaptive mindsets and consumerist addictions that have roots in our simian biology, and which developed past maturity into senescence over the past few hundred years and millennia. Political power is monopolized by people who matured a half century or more ago, whose motivations and actions are thus based on obsolete models that do not engage with current realities, abetted by obscenely wealthy oligarchs who use that monopolization to further their own greed-based agendas. Sociocultural development in our civilization has clearly entered senescence (not coincidentally related to the senescence of the elderly politicians), which is impeding needed change. Meanwhile, technology develops apace, with AI still in an immature (and hence unpredictable) stage, and disruptive environmental change also continues accelerating. The developmentalist perspective on change shows us that the collapse of a senescent system is typically a result of inflexibility that prevents adaptation to external challenges that perturb the system. Our civilization is a senescent sociocultural-economic-political system challenged by the disruptive perturbations of accelerating technological and environmental change. From this perspective, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/predictably-our-senescent-civilization-is-now-collapsing-a5bffce3898a">its collapse appears inevitable</a>. And indeed, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9">it has already begun</a> and is well underway and accelerating.</p><p><strong><em>Implications</em></strong></p><p>Understanding the nature of change is a prerequisite for dealing with and adapting to perpetual change. Unfortunately, the reductionist mindset that dominates contemporary science is a constraint that occludes insight into change, which is a serious problem given that we are confronted with unprecedented change that is now an existential crisis. Reductionism is the attempt to understand the world by breaking it down into idealized, unconnected problems that can be modeled mechanistically while ignoring context. This reductionism is unrealistic and lacks the capacity to adequately explain the nature of change, because the complexity of the world cannot be reduced to decontextualized mechanisms; in reality, everything depends on everything else. While reproducibility and objectivity in science are a noble and necessary quest, they are an idealized myth — no two events or outcomes are ever identical in every way, and nothing can be analyzed without interacting with it and thus changing it. Generalizations are useful but are simplified idealizations that do not capture all the information needed for <em>fully </em>understanding the what, why, where, when, and how of perpetual change. Our mechanistic models are powerful, but a world of trouble arises if we <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-price-we-pay-for-human-consciousness-is-an-exceptional-proclivity-for-self-deception-cc682de51ec6">deceive ourselves</a> into believing that they are complete and adequate depictions of reality.</p><p><strong><em>Further reading</em></strong></p><p>Annila, A. <a href="https://www.mv.helsinki.fi/home/aannila/arto/9789529433650.pdf"><em>Back to Reality: A Revision of the Scientific Worldview</em></a>. Privus Press, 2020.</p><p>Coffman, J.A. and Mikulecky, D.C. <a href="https://emergentpublications.com/global-insanity-how-homo-sapiens-lost-touch-with-reality-while-transforming-the-world/"><em>Global Insanity: How Homo sapiens Lost Touch with Reality While Transforming the World</em></a>. Emergent Publications, 2012.</p><p>Salthe, S.N., <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Development-Evolution-Complexity-Change-Biology-dp-0262513838/dp/0262513838/ref=mt_other?_encoding=UTF8&amp;me=&amp;qid=1644080347"><em>Development and Evolution: Complexity and Change in Biology</em></a>. MIT Press, 1993.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cf707bfbdf77" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Change, Foresight, Adaptability: Dune and Parable of the Sower]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/change-foresight-adaptability-dune-and-parable-of-the-sower-9b46fd804074?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9b46fd804074</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science-fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[evolution]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civilization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Dec 2024 22:23:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-22T19:44:16.197Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*D-FylVnQ2eImTlo6PzCY4g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Frank Herbert and Octavia Butler (Images from Wikimedia Commons: Frank Herbert photo by unknown photographer, in Public Domain; Octavia Butler photo By Nikolas Coukouma — File:Butler_signing.jpg, CC BY 2.5, <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=37868711">https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=37868711</a>)</figcaption></figure><p>On a recent road trip, my partner and I listened to two “sci-fi” audiobooks: Frank Herbert’s <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Dune-Frank-Herbert-audiobook/dp/B000R34YKC"><em>Dune</em></a>, and Octavia E. Butler’s <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Parable-of-Sower-Octavia-E-Butler-audiobook/dp/B002DN9ID2/ref=sr_1_1"><em>Parable of the Sower</em></a>. Both novels deal with <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/predictably-our-senescent-civilization-is-now-collapsing-a5bffce3898a">civilizational senescence</a>, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9">collapse</a>, and <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">rebirth</a>, and more generally, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">development</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/why-things-are-the-way-they-are-and-how-they-came-to-be-a1ff30043f68">evolution</a> — themes I have written about at length. I am a big fan of speculative (“science”) fiction, and at one time I aspired to be a sci-fi writer (an aspiration that produced some unpublished stories but never developed to fruition). In important ways, fiction can better convey deep insights than nonfiction: we humans are geared to storytelling, and good fiction simultaneously engages our emotions and intellect. <em>Dune</em>, which I first read a half century ago in high school, is one of my all-time favorite novels, and listening to it as an adult I picked up on things that I missed in adolescence. I had not previously read <em>Parable of the Sower</em> and was blown away — the story strongly resonates with my worldview and is one I might have written were I a brilliant novelist like Butler. Published in 1993 but set in 2024–2027, it is disconcertingly prophetic. And very dark.</p><p>My intent here is not to review the books or recap their plots (I recommend that you read or listen to readings of them), but rather to explore how they intersect with my thinking about development and evolution. The exploration is parsed into three broad themes: <em>change</em>, <em>foresight</em>, and <em>adaptability</em>.</p><p><strong><em>Change</em></strong></p><p>The ancient Greek philosopher <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heraclitus">Heraclitus</a> famously said that “everything changes, and nothing stands still”, noting that the only constant is change: “you cannot step into the same river twice”. <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-nature-of-change-cf707bfbdf77">Change </a>is the central story of our lives: it happens to us (as we grow up and grow old and suffer the “slings and arrows of outrageous fortune”), with or without us, whether we like it or not. Due to energy-intensive human industry, technological and environmental change is now happening at an accelerating rate that is unprecedented in human history. If you zoom your mind’s eye out to view the ~5-billion-year evolutionary history of earth, the terrestrial change over the past century appears as an explosion, an instantaneous flash like when a star goes supernova. While we have no idea what will come after the flash, we do know that it is already precipitating a <a href="https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/environment/a43680664/sixth-mass-extinction-timeline/">mass extinction</a> that may ultimately include <em>Homo sapiens</em>.</p><p>In <em>Parable of the Sower</em>, teenage protagonist Lauren Olamina, daughter of a Baptist preacher father and deceased mother whose drug addiction bequeathed Lauren with extraordinary (albeit crippling) empathy, develops a personal religion, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earthseed">Earthseed</a>, based on her conviction that God is Change. Lauren is a writer (her journal forms the text of the novel) and writes out the tenets of Earthseed as verses in <a href="https://godischange.org/the-book-of-the-living/"><em>The Books of the Living</em></a><em>.</em> A key tenet is that God can be <em>shaped</em>. On the other hand, God, being change, simply <em>is</em>, and is indifferent to us. As noted by Lauren’s friend Harry, this formulation of God sounds a lot like the <a href="https://discover.hubpages.com/education/Maximum-Entropy-Production">2nd Law of Thermodynamics</a> or entropy. But Lauren counters that the 2nd Law is only one aspect, and that we can work to shape God — in other words, we can direct change. While that may seem trite, for Lauren, it is a bold, even heroic, stance. Due to catastrophic climate change, her world is rapidly disintegrating into a violent, chaotic dystopia in which the United States is no longer united; cities are “company towns” owned by predatory multinational corporations that use slave labor; hunger, homelessness, addiction, desperation, violence, sadism, and suffering are the norm; and mere survival is extremely challenging. In that world, things (usually bad) happen <em>to</em> people, irrespective of their intentions and desires. In the first part of the story, Lauren observes this from the relative safety of her financially modest but walled, gated and armed community enclave in Southern California, but foresees that things will only go from bad to worse. Unsurprisingly, her friends and family don’t want to listen to her, preferring to live in the fantasy that everything will work itself out and be okay — that eventually, the “good times” will return. But of course, they won’t and don’t, and Lauren’s foresight proves accurate. But through it all — and Lauren’s journey is increasingly harrowing (eventually recalling <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Road">Cormac McCarthy’s <em>The Road</em></a>, which <em>Parable of the Sower</em> predated and may in part have inspired) — she keeps the faith that, so long as she survives, she has agency to shape God. So, she resolves to do whatever it takes to survive, and to work to make her Earthseed religion, with its ultimate aspiration of dispersing humanity to the stars, come to fruition.</p><p>In <em>Dune</em>, humanity has dispersed to the stars, and the galactic civilization is organized as a feudal empire. The story takes place in the far future, millennia after an existential war between human beings and “thinking machines” (i.e., artificial intelligence) ended with humans destroying and outlawing the machines (alluded to but not described in the book). Interstellar travel is mediated by developmentally specialized humanoids, members of the Guild, who use exceptional mental powers enhanced by the drug “spice” to navigate ships through warped space. Spice is obtained from the desert planet Arrakis — a.k.a. Dune — which, being the sole source of the vital drug, is key to the galactic economy and civilization. The protagonist of <em>Dune</em>, teenager Paul Atreides, is the product of a long-term breeding program carried out by the Bene Gesserit, an all-female quasi-religious order with highly developed mental and physical prowess. Paul’s mother Jessica, a Bene Gesserit who is concubine to Paul’s unmarried father, Duke Leto Atreides, bore Paul in defiance of the Bene Gesserit directive that they only produce daughters. At the outset of the story Paul and his family relocate from their oceanic home world of Caladan to Arrakis, where Leto has been assigned by the galactic Emperor to oversee the spice mining, following removal of the previous overseer, Baron Vladimir Harkonnen. Many generations of bad blood exist between the Atreides and Harkonnen families, and the plot of <em>Dune</em> revolves around that feud, the spice economy and brutal desert ecology of Arrakis, and the convoluted conspiracies, machinations, and intrigue involving the Emperor, Baron Harkonnen and his nephews, the Bene Gesserit, and the Guild. When the Harkonnens, assisted by elite imperial troops, invade Arrakis and assassinate Duke Leto, Paul is swept into the melee and narrowly escapes with Jessica into the desert. There they come across and are adopted by the indigenous desert people known as Fremen. Paul “goes native”, adopting the Fremen name Muad’Dib, and gradually comes to see his destiny as being the prophesied Fremen messiah and agent of change who will direct the course of events that usher Arrakis, and ultimately the imperial galactic civilization, through a <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis</a>.</p><p>As I have written previously, change manifests in both <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/why-things-are-the-way-they-are-and-how-they-came-to-be-a1ff30043f68">evolution</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">development</a>, the latter being a progressive system-level trajectory of maturational change that simultaneously creates and constrains the opportunity space for (thus “shaping”) evolution. In <em>Parable of the Sower</em>, Lauren’s contention that God (i.e., change) can be shaped should thus be viewed from a that perspective, by asking the question: what is the developmental context of the system in which change is taking place? Recall that development is a trajectory of change that transforms an incipient, at first immature system into a mature system that, absent effective regulation, continues developing to the end stage of senescence. As I will discuss further below, the opportunities afforded by immature systems are very different than those afforded by mature and senescent systems, in general being less system-specific and system-dependent, favoring generalists over specialists. Senescent systems lack the capacity to adaptively change their way of being and as a result inevitably collapse when conditions become inconducive to their existence. In <em>Parable of the Sower</em>, the context is the maggot-ridden remains (figuratively as well as literally, given the number of corpses) of a senescent terrestrial civilization (ours) that collapsed under the duress of climate change, whereas in <em>Dune</em>, the context is a mature but senescing galactic civilization that, being entirely dependent on a rare resource (spice) that is unique to a single planet, has become fragile and thus poised for collapse.</p><p>Watching the new HBO series <a href="https://www.hbo.com/dune-prophecy"><em>Dune: Prophecy</em></a>, I was struck by the fact that even though its storyline takes place 10,000 years before that of <em>Dune</em>, the technology and sociocultural context were much the same, as if little changed during that 10,000-year interval. While at first that rubbed me the wrong way, on reflection it makes sense, if you consider that the galactic imperial civilization was mature, having already developed advanced technology and having abandoned and outlawed artificial intelligence by the time the Bene Gesserit began their long-term breeding project. Mature and early-senescing systems are marked by an apparent stasis — change occurs but is relatively subtle: it doesn’t alter the overt nature of the system. Think of how little human beings change in adulthood, between say the age of 30 and 50, compared to childhood when the body is still growing and maturing, or late in senescence when degeneration is accelerating. Or think of the peak of the Roman civilization, which lasted a millennium. In the Dune universe, there is the added complexity of civilization being galaxy-wide, and it is difficult to imagine how time measured in earth years translates to rate of technological and sociocultural change at a galactic level. In any case, the fact that there isn’t much overt change in the 10,000 years between <em>Dune: Prophecy</em> and <em>Dune</em> is illustrative of the static “locked in” way of being that comes with maturation into senescence. In senescing systems, most change is subtle, even imperceptible, until the system is perturbed and collapses under its own weight, at which point all hell breaks loose. If change is a river, then senescence is a slowly crumbling dam in that river. In our current civilization, this can be seen by considering that although technology has changed (and continues to change) explosively, proportionally little has changed socio-culturally. From that perspective, technological change can be viewed as the swollen and still swelling river, and the sociocultural context of our civilization as the crumbling dam.</p><p>In short, because change occurs in systems that undergo development from immaturity into senescence, evolutionary change is episodic — a series of bursts or “<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punctuated_equilibrium">punctuated equilibria</a>” (as documented by paleontologists Niles Eldridge and Stephen Jay Gould in their analysis of the fossil record) — rather than gradual and continuous. Rapid, dramatic change is confined to early development (i.e., in immaturity) and during late senescence and collapse (and, if it occurs, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis</a>). Systems that are mature and/or entering senescence are relatively stable, so change is more subtle and gradual, appearing as equilibrium.</p><p>In human history, sociocultural context has largely been shaped by religion, and religion is central to both <em>Dune</em> and <em>Parable of the Sower</em> (which indeed takes its title from the biblical story, quoted at the end of the book). In both books, an old, established religion — Bene Gesserit in <em>Dune</em>, Christianity in <em>Parable of the Sower</em> — is part and parcel with the senescing/collapsing civilization, metamorphosis of which into a renewed stage of immaturity is accompanied, and even driven, by development of a community and cult around a new religion that is the brainchild of each story’s protagonist — Muad’Dib’s messianic cult in <em>Dune</em>, Lauren’s Earthseed in <em>Parable of the Sower</em>.</p><p><strong><em>Foresight</em></strong></p><p>Foresight is a central theme of both <em>Dune</em> and <em>Parable of the Sower</em>, and the protagonists of both stories are exceptionally gifted with it. In <em>Dune</em>, Paul, aided by spice, develops a superhuman prescience by which he foresees and mentally models multiple possible future timelines — much like a chess master. These abilities are the product of Bene Gesserit breeding, which also involved foresight (planning) that further manifested as religious prophecy. In <em>Parable of the Sower</em>, Lauren sees the writing on the wall, which her peers refuse to acknowledge, and prepares accordingly. As I have written <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-price-we-pay-for-human-consciousness-is-an-exceptional-proclivity-for-self-deception-cc682de51ec6">previously</a>, living systems are by nature anticipatory. Organisms do not merely react to change in their environment, they survive and thrive because they encode models of their world that <em>anticipate</em> the change, models that are decoded into adaptive preparations needed to deal with the change before it becomes an existential emergency. For example, deciduous trees lose their leaves and birds fly south in the fall in preparation for winter. When confronted with stressful or dangerous situations, our physiology prepares for “fight or flight” via metabolic adjustments elicited by adrenaline and cortisol that, among other things, provide us with a burst of anticipatory energy. Organisms that fail to anticipate do not survive and go extinct. Humans are therefore not exceptional in being anticipatory, all creatures are anticipatory systems — it is part and parcel with life itself. What makes humans exceptional is our unique ability to develop <em>language-based </em>mental models that are anticipatory, via <a href="http://klempner.freeshell.org/newsletter/issue170.html">metaphor and mathematics</a>. But if you look around, that facility appears to be failing us, in part because it bequeaths us with <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-price-we-pay-for-human-consciousness-is-an-exceptional-proclivity-for-self-deception-cc682de51ec6">an exceptional proclivity for self-deception</a>. In addition, the <a href="https://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol18/iss3/art1/figure1.html">modeling relation</a> that underpins anticipation requires a rate differential between the internal entailments of the anticipatory model (fast) and the external causation driving the change (slow), a rate differential that is rapidly being erased as the internal entailments encoded in the model embodied by our civilization become bogged down by mis/disinformation while technological and environmental change accelerates.</p><p>The motto of the Boy Scouts of America is “be prepared”. The heroes of <em>Dune</em> and <em>Parable of the Sower</em> take that to heart, and as a result, survive to become agents of change — shaping God, as it were. Given our civilization’s failure to make anticipatory preparations for the change that’s coming — despite the writing having been on the wall for all to see now for many decades — it is a motto that appears to be lost on most Americans.</p><p><strong><em>Adaptability</em></strong></p><p>Darwin’s theory of evolution by means of natural selection is often paraphrased as “survival of the fittest”. But what does “fittest” mean? “Fitness” is a technical term referring to how well an organism “fits” its environment and ecological niche — in other words, how well <em>adapted</em> it is to its circumstances, allowing it to survive and thrive. “Survival of the fittest” might thus be restated as “survival of the most adaptable”. From the foregoing we might surmise that accurate anticipation (foresight) is key to adaptability. And as foresight is a key theme in both <em>Dune</em> and <em>Parable of the Sower</em>, so too is adaptability. In <em>Dune</em>, this theme is central to life on Arrakis: the Fremen have adapted to that harsh desert ecology by developing a culture that values water above all, and technology (e.g., “stillsuits”), social norms, and behavior that enable them to survive and thrive in the desert. Paul, an alien to Arrakis, learns the Fremen way, and as a result survives and thrives, falling in love and partnering with a Fremen mate (Chani) with whom he has children. In <em>Parable of the Sower</em>, Lauren teaches herself the skills she will need to survive in a brutal, post-civilization world: where to find and process food and potable water, how to handle a gun, how to discern who can be trusted and who cannot. By learning how to adapt to her circumstances, she manages to survive, and as much as possible in her dystopic world, to eventually thrive by falling in love with a fellow traveler and nucleating and leading an incipient synergistic community that will help her realize her Earthseed dream.</p><p>Adaptability is a concept that only makes sense in light of ecology, and ecology is the central science in <em>Dune</em> (arguably, it is the most scientific aspect of this “science fiction” story, given that the interstellar space travel and mental prescience aspects are still purely fictive, and as far as we know from a perspective informed by current scientific knowledge, possibly — practically, if not physically — impossible). Given the centrality of ecology, it is instructive to reflect on the fact that change in ecosystems, like in everything else, has both developmental and evolutionary aspects. Ecosystems develop from immaturity to maturity, and sometimes (when balance is lost) into senescence. With this in mind, we can ask: how does the developmental stage of an ecosystem (and analogously, an economy or civilization) affect adaptability of an ecosystem’s constituent organisms, including humans?</p><p>As an ecosystem develops, it becomes increasingly <em>informed </em>— that is, relationships mediating energy flow through the system become increasingly established and well-defined, and thus more efficient and predictable. As a result, traits that impart adaptability in immature ecosystems differ from those that impart adaptability in mature ecosystems. Immature ecosystems favor generalists, whereas mature ecosystems favor specialists. A generalist is an organism (or person) that can make use of a variety of resources, whatever is available — a jack of all trades, master of none, as it were. Example animal generalists include coyotes, crows, and humans, which can survive and thrive in a wide variety of environments. The American frontier up until the 20th century favored pioneers and homesteaders who were generalists, as the economy had not yet matured. In contrast, a mature or senescent ecosystem (or economy) favors specialist organisms (including people) who adapt by becoming highly skilled at using a specific resource base and taking advantage of opportunities that exist only by virtue of the high level of organization developed within the ecosystem. In nature, an example is the giant Panda, which depends entirely on bamboo for subsistence. Most people in our contemporary, globally capitalized and industrialized civilization are specialists, obtaining subsistence from specialized work and opportunities that <em>only </em>exist by virtue of civilization. In other words, most of us are highly and specifically adapted to civilization. <em>Parable of the Sower</em> depicts what happens to us when that civilization disintegrates. Lauren, being an extremely intelligent woman who grew up in those circumstances, realizes that her survival requires that she become a generalist. Most of her friends, family, and acquaintances do not fare so well, their mindsets still entrained by and locked into the senescence of their late civilization. <em>Dune</em> also explores the generalist-specialist spectrum, with members of the Guild being extreme specialists who depend entirely on spice (and hence Arrakis) for their way of being, whereas Paul, who also has superhuman mental powers, is more of a generalist able to adapt to changing conditions.</p><p>In the face of rapid change such as that characteristic of both early development (immaturity) and terminal system collapse, generalists are more adaptable than specialists. This is because generalists are more developmentally <em>plastic</em>, able to read their circumstances and pivot their way of life and doing what is necessary when circumstances change. This comes at a cost however, as it requires wider attentional focus, which is <a href="https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/418539">energetically costly</a>. That is in fact the reason that mature ecosystems favor evolution of specialists, who succeed, survive, and thrive to the extent that they focus their attention and energy to become exceptionally well adapted to a specific resource niche via one (or a few) specific skill(s). Thus, development of ecosystems and economies is accompanied by developmental differentiation of the organisms/people that constitute those systems. As the systems mature, the organisms/people become increasingly specialized and decreasingly plastic (the same is true <em>within </em>organisms, whose ontogenetic development is accompanied by developmental differentiation of cells, with attendant loss of cellular plasticity). In other words, development is generally accompanied by loss of plasticity (both in the system as a whole, and within most of its constituents) owing to the focusing of attention favored by maturation of the system and the increasingly specific/specialized opportunity niches that it affords. As an ecosystem matures, adaptability is increasingly conferred by attention and skills that are more and more narrowly focused, at the expense of the plasticity needed to adapt to change that occurs beyond the normal range found withing that narrow context. Mature ecosystems (and economies, and organisms) are largely composed of specialists, with a few scrappy generalists eking out an existence within the remaining interstices.</p><p>Paul Atreides and Lauren Olamina can survive and thrive in their adverse, rapidly changing circumstances because they have enough plasticity to adapt to that change. In Lauren’s case, the plasticity is imparted by her exceptional intelligence, her loving upbringing and training from her father, and from being forced to adapt to the often-crippling effects of her empathic affliction, which keeps her ever alert to everything happening around her. In Paul’s case, the plasticity comes from his Bene Gesserit pedigree and training from his mother, and from spice. The role of spice in plasticity is an intriguing subject, as spice is essentially a hallucinogen (purportedly inspired by Herbert’s experiments with hallucinogenic mushrooms), and hallucinogens appear to work by increasing brain plasticity. In recent years research has shown that hallucinogens have therapeutic benefits (as Timothy Leary discovered and advocated in the 1960s), which come from their ability to “rewire” the brain — essentially promoting mental de-development into a more plastic, immature state that is better poised to change adaptively by accessing a new developmental trajectory. In other words, hallucinogens catalyze mental metamorphosis. That is a very interesting subject that I won’t expound further on here, leaving it for a future article.</p><p><strong><em>Further Reading</em></strong></p><p>Butler, O.E. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Parable-Sower-powerful-dystopian-future/dp/1472263669"><em>Parable of the Sower</em></a>. Four Walls Eight Windows, 1993.</p><p>Herbert, F. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/DUNE-HERBERT-FRANK/dp/0340960191"><em>Dune</em></a>. Chilton Books, 1965.</p><p>Rosen, R. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Life-Itself-Comprehensive-Fabrication-Complexity/dp/0231075650"><em>Life Itself: A Comprehensive Inquiry into the Nature, Origin, and Fabrication of Life</em></a>. Columbia University Press, 1991.</p><p>Salthe, S.N., <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Development-Evolution-Complexity-Change-Biology-dp-0262513838/dp/0262513838/ref=mt_other?_encoding=UTF8&amp;me=&amp;qid=1644080347"><em>Development and Evolution: Complexity and Change in Biology</em></a>. MIT Press, 1993.</p><p>Ulanowicz, R.E. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Ecology-Ascendent-Perspective-Robert-Ulanowicz-dp-023110829X/dp/023110829X/ref=mt_other?_encoding=UTF8&amp;me=&amp;qid="><em>Ecology, The Ascendent Perspective</em></a>. Columbia University Press, 1997.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9b46fd804074" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Metamorphosis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a17684104ac8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[metamorphosis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[earth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collapse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civilization]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Nov 2024 22:48:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-11-21T13:56:58.120Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*oJ9N1s5e0R_hohhnwdMY4w.jpeg" /><figcaption>Metamorphosis transforms a pluteus (left, photomicrograph taken by the author) into a sea urchin (right, original image by Ratha Grimes, obtained from <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Urchin.jpg">Wikimedia Commons</a>; licensed under the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/en:Creative_Commons">Creative Commons</a> <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/deed.en">Attribution 2.0 Generic</a> license; cropped by the author). The images are not to scale; the pluteus is a fraction of a millimeter in length whereas the sea urchin is several centimeters in diameter. The adult sea urchin is entirely derived from the small disc-like rudiment on the side of the gut in the body cavity of the pluteus, as indicated by the arrow.</figcaption></figure><p><strong><em>Preface</em></strong></p><p>This is a piece that I began writing in 2022 but set aside and have been sitting on now for the past two years. I have two excuses for procrastinating. One, I have been focusing on my professional career as a scientist running a biomedical research lab, pretending that if I keep my nose to the grindstone, carrying out business-as-usual writing technical research papers and grant proposals to support my fascinating albeit excessively reductionist research program, all would be well and work itself out. It’s a form of denial, but denial defends against emotions like angst and depression. And as everyone in the “civilized” world knows, the only way to survive if not thrive in this capitalist economy is to stay on the hamster wheel. Two, I am an expert procrastinator, easily drawn to distractions like the daily news and various forms of entertainment (some healthy, others not so much), a form of avoidance that functions similarly to denial. But circumstances in our world have become so bleak and heartbreaking that now the only way for me to process them is to write, hoping that in that process I might find some hope. Those circumstances include the unimaginable human suffering happening in Gaza (actually, it is all too imaginable: I can easily imagine how the ongoing death, destruction, and horrendous suffering in Gaza — as well as in many other places like Syria, Sudan, Ukraine, etc., etc. — will, in the not distant future, come to visit much of the “first” world, including the U.S.A., particularly in cities). Closer to home, we recently experienced another mass shooting by a mentally disturbed individual who took advantage of the fact that the weapon of choice for mass murderers (AR-style rifle) is easily accessible to just about anyone in the U.S.A. Meanwhile, the national political situation appears hopeless, with half the electorate in the U.S.A. living in a false fever dream fueled by the pathological narcissism and lies of a former (and now re-elected) president and convicted felon, by the financial support of oligarchs and religious zealots who see the opportunity that this affords them for consolidating their political power, and by their slick professional propagandists in the media and religious establishments, who seek to transform the nation into a white-supremacist Christo-fascist dictatorship ripe for unmitigated pillaging of what wealth can still be violently eked out of the human and natural world. None of this is surprising, it all fits the expected regressive pattern of civilizational collapse.</p><p>While I am happy to admit that I might be wrong, I see only two possible fates for <em>humanity</em> (our species and all that makes us human, including our capacity to act <em>humanely</em>) at this juncture in history: it will either vanish completely as civilization collapses into violent conflagrations (with high likelihood of terminating in nuclear annihilation, considering that the only thing that is holding the vast stockpiles of nukes in check <em>is</em> civilization); or, it will undergo a metamorphosis, a rebirth in which survivors of the collapse create a new and possibly radically different kind of civilization. Unfortunately, neither path forward will be without death, destruction, and suffering (which, as noted above, are already happening at heartbreaking levels). But at least with metamorphosis there is hope that humanity will survive and continue evolving, perhaps (but not necessarily) into a more enlightened and <em>humane</em> species of ape.</p><p>Thus, I firmly believe that whatever hope there is for the future of humanity lies in civilizational metamorphosis. What might that entail?</p><p><strong><em>Synopsis</em></strong></p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9"><em>Everything that exists came to be through a process of systemic development</em></a><em> in our evolving universe. Development of a system toward some specific end, absent regulation, invariably leads to the system’s senescence, a precarious developmental end-stage in which the system, having developed to the limit of its capacity for that specific trajectory of development, is no longer able to adapt to disruptive change and is thus poised for collapse. As a result of unregulated development, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/predictably-our-senescent-civilization-is-now-collapsing-a5bffce3898a"><em>our global civilization has entered senescence and has begun collapsing</em></a><em>. Collapse of a senescing system can either be terminal — as in death or extinction — or transitional, heralding the birth of a new, incipient (undeveloped or immature) system — i.e., metamorphosis. From the internal perspective of a mature or senescent system (i.e., the prevailing perspective held by constituents of the system), metamorphosis is inherently unpredictable (given that there is no precedent encoded in the system’s models), and in many ways indistinguishable from destruction, so at best we in the civilized world can only hope that collapse of our civilization will lead to its metamorphosis and not a complete obliteration of humanity. Despite this unpredictability, we can examine known examples in a variety of systems to gain insight into what metamorphosis generally entails and ask how often it occurs in the natural world. We might then use this information to ask whether our civilization holds any potential for metamorphosis — and what, if anything, we can do to help make it happen. My thesis here is that metamorphosis is quite common across all scales in the natural world and generally entails (and requires) extensive de(con)struction of the developed state that allows for reorganization, and thence emergence of a new system from what remains of the old. I will defend my thesis using disparate examples of metamorphosis in nature as well as in human-engineered systems.</em></p><p><strong><em>Metamorphosis is the transformation of a mature system into a newly emergent, immature system that is radically different from its precursor</em></strong></p><p>The word “development” generally refers to a progressive, increasingly predictable trajectory of systemic change directed to achieve some specific or specialized end. This is because development of a system — be it a weather system, an organism, an ecosystem, a parcel of land, an economy, a culture, a society, a technology, a skillset, or an artform (to name just a few examples) — is characterized by accumulation of information within the system, which channels or controls activities within the system and increases the certainty that any observer of (or participant in) the system has or can acquire through learning about systemic relationships, and hence predictability of outcomes mediated by those relationships. Development of a system progresses through canonical stages of <em>immaturity</em> (low information content/high uncertainty), <em>maturity</em> (moderate information content/maximal certainty), and finally <em>senescence</em> (maximal information content/declining certainty due to a fully mature system’s limited capacity to develop and process the additional information needed to effectively adapt to or control the trajectory of change). The declining certainty in senescence is paradoxically coupled with the near certainty that the senescent system is not long for the world.</p><p>I have argued that our westernized, hyper-capitalized, militarized, fossil-fueled industrial civilization, which ostensibly developed to maturity to achieve the end goal of freeing (at least some of) us from the caprices of nature, has entered senescence, and thus, predictably, is now collapsing. Here I want to explore how the collapse of a mature, senescing system can bring about transformation that produces a new system, i.e., metamorphosis. My intent is that by exploring the concept of metamorphosis in abstract terms as well as through examples across the spectrum of life and in relation to human systems, I might provide some hope that civilizational collapse is not necessarily the end of the world, just the end of the world as we know it and possibly the harbinger of rebirth. Given the circumstances, the only realistic alternative is unimaginable death, destruction, and sociocultural regression to an uncivilized condition, accompanied by untold suffering, and possibly human extinction.</p><p>Metamorphosis can generally be defined as <em>relatively rapid, transformational change</em> that <em>creates a new system from the seedbed of an older mature or senescing system</em>. In metamorphosis, a new, immature system fuels its own self-organizing growth and development using free energy provided by the “parent” system. The new system then undergoes its own trajectory of growth and development, eventually becoming a mature system that emerged from the detritus of the old system. Many familiar examples exist in the animal kingdom: a butterfly emerges from a chrysalis built by a collapsing caterpillar; a tailless, four-legged, air-breathing frog emerges from a collapsing fish-like tadpole; a sea urchin emerges from a collapsing pluteus.</p><p>The case of sea urchins (and similarly, sea stars) is particularly illustrative: the familiar body plan of the adult sea urchin is completely different from that of the pluteus larva from which it emerged, with a body axis (mouth/head to anus/tail) that is orthogonal to that of the pluteus (see images at the top of this article). They are essentially completely different animals (with different diets, ecological niches, and ways of living) that came from the same fertilized egg and genome. During metamorphosis, most of the cells that composed the body of the pluteus commit suicide (“apoptosis”) and are turned into fuel for the baby sea urchin, which emerges rather violently from the body cavity of the pluteus that incubated it. As an erstwhile sea urchin embryologist, I observed this process, which to my mind recalled the scene in the movie <em>Alien</em> when the baby alien bursts out of officer Kane’s chest.</p><p>A phenomenon related to metamorphosis is <em>metagenesis</em> — a life cycle characterized by alternating phases of sexual and asexual reproduction. Familiar animal examples include cnidarians (e.g., jellyfish), in which asexual polyps bud off sexual medusae, which produce single cell haploid gametes that join to produce diploid zygotes that develop into new polyps. The transformations through which a polyp gives rise (via budding) to a medusa arguably constitute a type of metamorphosis, although unlike in the more extreme cases described above, they don’t typically result in the destruction of most of the pre-metamorphic parent organism (the polyp), only the terminal part that transforms into a medusa. Even more dramatically, while medusae of most species senesce and die after achieving sexual maturity (as is true for most animal species), medusae of the “immortal jellyfish” <em>Turritopsis sp</em>. have the remarkable ability to de-develop, Benjamin Button-like, from senescence into a new polyp, which also constitutes a type of metamorphosis. Finally, it should be noted that in the plant and fungal kingdoms, metagenesis is widespread as a mode of life history, in which the life cycle consists of alternating generations of asexually reproducing haploid <em>gametophytes</em> and sexually reproducing diploid <em>sporophytes</em>, each alternating generation being a strikingly different organismal system informed by the same genetic lineage.</p><p>Sexual reproduction itself can be thought of as a form of metamorphosis affording an escape from senescence. In individual animals, senescence is a developmental end stage that is entered following sexual maturation. In a sexually mature animal, gametogenesis (the production of a haploid gamete via meiosis from a diploid progenitor derived from an epithelial cell in the gonad) is a radical <em>cellular</em> transformation that sets the stage for the subsequent developmental transformation of the diploid zygote (formed from the union of two gametes) into a fully formed, genetically distinct organism, the primary function of which (with respect to the continuance of the species) is to produce more gametes that produce new zygotes that develop to adulthood to repeat the cycle. To the extent that a mature adult organism can successfully produce gametes and mate, it has fulfilled its biological function (i.e., the function that has been naturally selected), after which it becomes dispensable, entering the terminal stage of senescence. Species that can <em>only</em> reproduce sexually (which constitutes most of the “higher” branches of the animal evolutionary tree, including mammals and birds) will rapidly become extinct if they lose the capacity to either produce viable gametes or engage in mating. Thus, the series of cellular and developmental transformation that accompany sexual reproduction — whereby the union of two parents gives rise to a similar, but in many important respects different, individual harboring new, possibly advantageous characteristics lacking in the parents — can be thought of as a kind of metamorphosis responsible for the transformational change (and hope for the future) embodied by each new generation.</p><p>Finally, I would note that although the term metamorphosis is normally applied only to dramatic ontogenetic transformations such as the ones described above (chrysalis to butterfly, tadpole to frog, pluteus to sea urchin), I would argue that the concept is more widely applicable in organismal life cycles, most if not all of which can be viewed as having multiple stages of maturation that would each be terminal were it not for transformation of the system via significant re-organization. Gastrulation (the transformation of a blastula, a hollow ball of cells, into a more complex multilayered embryo with a gut) is one such transformation. Adolescence is another, in which a child is dramatically (sometimes traumatically) transformed into an adult. In psychology, breakthroughs (or psychotic breaks) often occur rapidly to produce radically new perspectives or personality characteristics. Anyone who has developed a skill, such as proficiency with a musical instrument, or athletic training, will note that progress is not gradual, but comes through extended periods of apparent stasis punctuated by sudden “breakthroughs” in proficiency. While many would object to using the terms “maturity” or “senescence” to refer to the precursor state to such metamorphoses, I would argue that the terms are applicable to the extent that in each case the work of prior development had taken the system as far as it could go along a specific self-organizing trajectory, requiring significant deconstruction and re-organization (e.g., within the cellular milieu of the blastula for gastrulation, or within the brain for psychological development) to enable further development of a new (kind of) system that transcends its precursor. Thus, one can see the ontogeny of any organism as being not a continuous developmental trajectory from immaturity to maturity, but rather a concatenated series of developmental maturations, each of which sets the stage for metamorphosis into the next.</p><p>Based on this, we can refine our definition of metamorphosis as being a deconstructive reorganization that transforms a mature and/or senescing system into a new and substantially different, newly immature system with potential for further development (e.g., a tadpole into a froglet, a blastula into a gastrula, an epithelial cell into a gamete, an addict into a recovering addict). Metamorphosis is a process whereby a system can evade or escape, and thence develop past, terminal senescence.</p><p><strong><em>Earth’s evolutionary development occurred via a series of metamorphoses</em></strong></p><p>You are probably wondering what any of this has to do with our collapsing civilization and its potential for metamorphosis. Before I go there, let’s zoom way out, consider how the evolutionary development of life on earth has played out via a series of metamorphoses, each of which was radically transformational for life on earth. Those transformations are preserved and catalogued in earth’s geology.</p><p>The earth was born naked, a fiery ball of molten rock without atmosphere or sea. We still don’t know exactly how abiogenesis — the emergence of biology (genetically-informed life) from prebiotic geochemistry — occurred, although there are plenty of plausible, testable hypotheses that are fueling active, and quite fascinating, research. But we do know that life <em>as we know it today</em> was not possible on the early earth, which lacked oxygen and whose earliest atmosphere would be toxic to most modern life. Nonetheless, life of a sort became possible under those harsh conditions; we know that because they are replicated to some extent on earth today, in hydrothermal vents on the ocean floor, which harbor primitive forms of life that cannot exist anywhere else. Conditions changed dramatically however, several hundred million years after earth was born, with the emergence of the first cells capable of photosynthesis. That, possibly combined with the advent of subduction in the earth’s crust, led to a progressive transformation of the atmosphere known as the “Great Oxygenation Event”, which destroyed most life constituting the mature biosphere at that time, for which oxygen was poison. At the same time, by providing a surfeit of free energy it opened new opportunities for those living systems that by chance were equipped to exploit it. Life did so, in part, by forming endosymbiotic cooperatives — cells within cells that were the ancestors of what we now know as eukaryotes, i.e., cells with nuclei containing the genetic material, along with other intracellular organelles such as mitochondria derived from free living bacterial ancestors. For some two billion years the living earth consisted of relatively simple eukaryotes and prokaryotes (cells without nuclei), and multicellular life as we know it today did not exist. <em>Complex</em> multicellularity — as it now exists in plants and animals — did not evolve until relatively recently in earth’s history, a half a billion years ago, in a geological event known as the Cambrian Explosion that occurred in conjunction with further increases in atmospheric oxygen. Before that, around a billion years ago, the earth had become almost completely frozen — “snowball earth” — and seemingly lifeless. The thawing of snowball earth and subsequent Cambrian Explosion was a metamorphosis that radically changed the earth system, producing the roots of complex life as we now know it.</p><p>The point I am trying to make in this brief review of the earth’s development is that it progressed through a series of distinct epochal stages, each of which was arguably a developmental trajectory that matured and began senescing (developmentally locked into a specific way of being) before undergoing metamorphoses triggered by environmental crises. Each metamorphosis birthed a radically new, immature system that then underwent its own developmental maturation. The pattern continued over the past half billion years following the Cambrian metamorphosis, with a series of geological eras characterized by ecological and taxonomic developmental trajectories that were terminated by mass extinctions (e.g., the “Great Dying” at the end of the Paleozoic, and the apocalypse following the Chicxulub bolide impact that wiped out the non-avian dinosaurs at the end of the Mesozoic). Like the transformations demarcating the Precambrian eras that were constituted by simpler life forms, the ecological and taxonomic transformations precipitated by each of the mass extinctions over the past half billion years of earth’s life can be thought of as planetary metamorphoses, each of which produced new ecosystems populated by, and whose developmental maturation drove the evolution of, new life forms and ecosystems derived from precursors present in the old system.</p><p><strong><em>Metamorphosis as a recurrent feature in the rise and fall of human civilizations</em></strong></p><p>Let’s zoom back in, to the here and now, to ask how all of this pertains to the human-engineered system of civilization.</p><p>Like the history of life on earth, the history of human civilization, although much shorter (an instant in comparison), is marked by stages that can be viewed as developmental trajectories punctuated by dramatic and often cataclysmic changes resulting in civilizational metamorphosis. Throughout history, and in different parts of the world, civilizations have developed and matured before declining and falling. But new civilizations have often arisen from the seedbeds left by the fallen ones. Perhaps the best-known example here in the West is what happened after the rise and fall of the Greco-Roman civilization. Our current Westernized global civilization can be thought of as having been produced by metamorphosis of that precursor. What remained of Roman civilization after the fall of Rome (preserved by the Roman Catholic church) developed over a few centuries into the medieval feudal civilization in Europe, which matured and entrained human activity until came the decimation of the Plague. The Renaissance (arguably a response to the business opportunities opened by the high mortality of the Plague) was another metamorphosis, in which classical art and philosophy, combined with the advanced science and mathematics developed in the middle Eastern Muslim world and brought to Europe via the Crusades, was (re)discovered and developed into Enlightenment science, which produced the Industrial Revolution, a metamorphosis that in turn led, in the late 20th century, to the latest metamorphosis, the Information Technology Revolution. Although civilization didn’t collapse completely between the fall of Rome and now, it was wracked with multiple cataclysms (plagues, famines, wars) that brought about transformational reorganization, including the world wars in the 20th century, which arguably were instrumental in potentiating the development of contemporary technological civilization.</p><p>An illustrative example is the city of Berlin, which I visited in 2022 (around the time I began writing this piece). What struck me about Berlin was the juxtaposition of the old and classical with the new and ultramodern. And everywhere there were signs of the catastrophic destruction of the city at the end of WWII, including bullet marks on old walls, and old foundations of collapsed buildings that no longer exist. On top of and interwoven with that are modern steel and glass buildings. Berlin is also remarkable for its exceptionally progressive culture, so different from the regressive culture enforced by the Nazis. I couldn’t help but think of its transformation as being a metamorphosis. And it occurred to me that one thing that all metamorphoses have in common — be they organismal, planetary, or civilizational — is collapse, typically cataclysmic, of an existing mature system that has maxed out its developmental potential, out of which emerges a new system full of new as yet unrealized developmental potential.</p><p><strong><em>What might metamorphosis of our civilization entail?</em></strong></p><p>While it’s difficult to imagine how metamorphosis of our civilization might be achieved, there is no doubt that <em>if</em> it does happen, it will be massively disruptive to what is currently considered “<a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9">business as usual</a>”. I can imagine three possible scenarios, all of which have been explored in speculative fiction.</p><p>The first is complete collapse with loss of technology and industry combined with massive global mortality due to a cataclysm such as a pandemic or nuclear war. In this scenario whatever remains of humanity will need to rebuild civilization from the ground up, from dispersed and largely disconnected local communities that are reduced to pre-industrial modes of subsistence. This kind of metamorphosis was explored in Walter M. Miller Jr.’s novel <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Canticle_for_Leibowitz"><em>A Canticle for Leibowitz</em></a>, and David Brin’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Postman"><em>The Postman</em></a> (which was made into the movie by the same name starring Kevin Costner).</p><p>The second scenario is collapse with lower (but likely still significant) mortality, but retention of technology and some industry through which the ultra-wealthy consolidate power in authoritarian nation states (or possibly an authoritarian world government) that enforce the monopolization of power and hierarchical stratification of society through a combination of distracting entertainment, police-state brutality, and near complete control of media. In this dystopic scenario, which appears to be increasing in likelihood, the power of the rulers may be augmented by artificial intelligence and robotics. This kind of metamorphosis was explored in Aldous Huxley’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brave_New_World"><em>Brave New World</em></a>, George Orwell’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nineteen_Eighty-Four"><em>1984</em></a>, and Suzanne Collins’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hunger_Games"><em>The Hunger Games</em></a> series. Depending on how advanced the intelligent machines become, I can imagine them taking over completely and either enslaving or eliminating most of humanity, as was explored in the movie <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Terminator"><em>The Terminator</em></a> and its spinoffs.</p><p>The third and most desirable (least dystopic) of the three scenarios involves working through the ongoing collapse (with its attendant mortality and depopulation brought about by a combination of lower birth rates, disease, famine, and war) in a way that retains and manages technology and industry to the benefit of everyone. This metamorphosis would ideally entail emergence of a self-organizing, synergistically cooperative socioeconomic system (“<a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/elements/abs/superorganism/7B1993DC8F50B53744E23EB09A15BA5D">Superorganism</a>”). One way that this may occur is plutocratically, through top-down implementation and management of a new system that facilitates “<a href="https://www.evolutionarymanifesto.com/SelfOrganizeGoodPrePrint.pdf">comprehensive consequence capture</a>”. Another possibility is that enough people will finally recognize the indispensable value of the natural systems that we all depend on (the “Commons”) that they will <a href="https://4thgenerationcivilization.substack.com/p/a-global-history-of-societal-regulation">self-organize, via “cosmo-localization”, a means of “inflating”, preserving and protecting the Commons</a> for future generations, which would necessarily entail disempowerment of multinational corporations and the oligarchs who control them. Whichever way it may happen, in my mind this still appears as the least likely of the three scenarios, as it is difficult for me to imagine that people will overcome their deeply entrenched animal instincts and tribal sensibilities enough to come together to form the necessary cooperatives. But just because I can’t imagine it doesn’t at all mean it’s not possible. Here it is important to reiterate that world-changing transformations that can be characterized as metamorphoses are inherently unpredictable before the fact. While it is harder to find speculative fiction for this scenario, the one example that comes to mind is Frank Herbert’s <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dune_(novel)"><em>Dune</em></a> series. (It is interesting to note that the civilizational metamorphosis imagined in that series was accompanied by the organismal metamorphosis of Paul Atreides’s son Leto II into a sand worm with superhuman consciousness.)</p><p>Whatever scenario plays out (and there are undoubtedly others than those I’ve sketched here), I think it’s safe to say that if humanity is to survive and thrive beyond the next few years, civilization needs to undergo a metamorphosis into a very different socioeconomic system than what we have now, one that is better equipped to anticipate and proactively negotiate the accelerating change in the biosphere and technology and take advantage of whatever new opportunities that change provides. If it’s going to happen, it will (need to) happen soon, as climate change and planetary ecocide have become an existential emergency, and the collapse of civilization is well under way. The question then is: assuming that a metamorphosis will occur, how can we work toward ensuring that it doesn’t produce a dystopia?</p><p>The state of our world makes it hard to be hopeful. But keep in mind that the darkest hour comes just before dawn.</p><p><strong><em>Further Reading</em></strong></p><p>Corning, P.A. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Superorganism-Contract-Endangered-Elements-Evolutionary-ebook/dp/B0C94NQNBM"><em>Superorganism: Toward a New Social Contract for Our Endangered Species</em></a>. Cambridge University Press, 2023.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a17684104ac8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Energy, Information, and the Collapse of Civilization]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacoffman/energy-information-and-the-collapse-of-civilization-c903e63d5fe9?source=rss-608435c6f985------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c903e63d5fe9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[energy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[civilization]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collapse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[information]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James A. Coffman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Nov 2024 18:56:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-05T21:55:10.365Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Why carrying on business as usual as though everything is going to be okay is part and parcel with civilizational collapse</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*dRayNdOOLRElxykD28MKeQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Destruction, from The Course of Empire by Thomas Cole (1836) (from Wikimedia Commons)</figcaption></figure><p>I have been enjoying the recent television adaptation of Isaac Asimov’s <em>Foundation and Empire</em>, a classic science fiction trilogy that I read over 50 years ago in high school. While the story calls to mind the fall of the Roman empire, it’s obviously relevant to what’s happening in the world right now. In the story, Hari Seldon is an academic who predicts, based on the science of psychohistory (which melds psychology, history, and the mathematics of probability and statistics), the imminent collapse of the galactic empire, and that the only way to avoid an interminable dark age is to create a “Foundation” on a remote galactic outpost that preserves the knowledge built by civilization. I am not a psychohistorian, but I am an academic, with a PhD in zoology (the science of animal biology) and expertise in developmental biology (the science of how a single cell zygote gives rise to a complex multicellular organism), a strong liberal arts education, and a life of observation and study that has provided me with <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/why-things-are-the-way-they-are-and-how-they-came-to-be-a1ff30043f68">some insight</a>, or at least intuition, into what’s happening, and how it will play out. My insight and intuition come from my lifelong habit of trying to imagine things from a zoomed-out vantage point of deep time and space (within which, all human history is but an instantaneous, and possibly in the end, insignificant, blip) as well as by zooming in on what is happening at any given moment, all the way down to the molecular and cellular levels, and trying to put it all together into a coherent, scientifically sound story.</p><p>In pondering <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-united-states-of-america-bf9bfe0b8770">the collapse of the United States of America</a> into a fascist state (which despite appearances, did not happen overnight), it helps to take a step back and realize that anything and everything that happens in this universe, including the grand sweep of geobiological evolution and human history, down to your mundane daily activities at any given moment and the molecular and cellular processes underlying those activities, can be understood as <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/causation-is-the-interplay-between-freedom-and-developed-constraint-3e5e66e6d380">energy flow channeled by information</a>. For contemporary human civilization, currency (money) is a proxy for energy flow, and information is conveyed through written, spoken, and body language, as well as printed and electronic media.</p><p>It also helps to realize that civilization is a complex system that, like any complex system, <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/everything-that-exists-came-to-be-through-a-process-of-systemic-development-412bc66977c9">developed into existence</a> by working (marshaling energy flows to achieve some specific end result) in increasingly informed ways. A casual survey of developing systems of any kind (weather systems, ecosystems, organisms, social systems, economies, etc.) should convince you that, in general, development is a process that transforms an immature, relatively undetermined (incipient) and powerless system into a mature, more fully determined and powerful system equipped to carry out specific kinds of work. Absent regulation that impedes further development, a mature system will continue developing via activities that in maturity become increasingly habitual, which leads to senescence. Senescence is the end stage of development in which a mature system, lacking capacity for further development due to lack of external resources and/or internal constraints erected by prior development, nonetheless continues by force of habit doing the same things that it did to develop to maturity, but now with diminishing returns, which poises the system for collapse, either into nothingness (death or extinction), or into a less complex system that forms the seedbed of a new system (<a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis</a>). As I explained at length <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/predictably-our-senescent-civilization-is-now-collapsing-a5bffce3898a">previously</a>, this process is intelligible from the combined theoretical perspectives of thermodynamics (the dynamics of energy flow) and information theory — a.k.a. “infodynamics”. To make it less abstract and hence more relatable, it helps to reflect on how the general concepts apply to the particulars of our everyday lives.</p><p>First, consider that we human beings are animals, and like all animals, we need to eat to live. Eating — taking in food (plants and/or other animals) through a mouth, then passing it through a digestive tube that extracts the energy and other nutrients before discarding the residual fecal waste out an anus — is how we animals channel the energy flow that sustains life. It is the definitive characteristic of being an animal. To keep the life-sustaining energy flowing, we animals sense our environment using nervous systems, which provide us with the information we use to locate (and with our musculoskeletal systems, move toward and ingest) food, as well as avoid threats and find mates. As animals, everything we do revolves around and is “geared” towards those primordial needs. For many animal species, especially those that aren’t particularly social, that’s basically it. Different species have solved the same problem in myriad different ways, but if you’re an animal, the fundamental problem is that you must eat to live. That contrasts with our more distant cousins the plants, which just need to soak up the sun’s rays.</p><p>But humans, in addition to having extraordinarily large brains and opposable thumbs, are highly social animals — it is our superpower — so, in developing societies and eventually civilizations, we have built systems and structures that significantly augment our primal animal abilities to fulfill our basic needs. Over millennia, via cooperative agriculture and industry, the work enabled by energy flowing from the food that our ancestors ate was used to develop social networks into complex systems of trade and monetary currency, and the information that channels energy flow through those systems developed via written language and media. That led to the societal-level development of the scientifically informed technology that enabled us over the past few hundred years to tap into the vast deposits of high-grade energy provided by fossil fuel. The ensuing development — the fruit of the “industrial revolution” — produced the technological infrastructure that frees most of us from the day-to-day concerns of our wild animal cousins, as well as the legal systems and law enforcement that protect most of us from predation by rogue humans. So, we are freed to work in a variety of jobs that were created to satisfy emergent goals of the social system, including art, science, law, medicine, and entertainment, which in turn rewards us with money that we can use to buy food and other necessities, as well as a vast array of luxuries that distract us from the harsh realities of life in “the wild”. If you work for a living in a paying job, as long as the civilizational <em>system </em>is working to fill the grocery stores with affordable food, you don’t have to worry or think much about having your basic animal needs filled. All our individual activities are for the most part channeled by civilization-specific information (that is, information that is irrelevant outside the context of civilization) that we learn and internalize growing up, which most people take for granted and never bother to think about.</p><p>The problem though is that in a mature civilization, most people are entirely dependent on the information and benefits specifically conferred by civilization, unable to live without them. In that way the development of civilization traps its inhabitants in a <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/bubbles-within-bubbles-global-insanity-2025-2bb14e1b4f9f">bubble </a>that is largely disconnected from the real (i.e. wild) world. At the same time, a mature civilization, although habit-bound by the routines of its inhabitants, does not stand still, but rather continues developing in a largely unregulated fashion (as is happening now with energy-intensive technologies such as artificial intelligence), taking the system past the finite developmental capacity imposed by the physical limitations of the earth eco-system (i.e., the limited natural resources and waste detoxifying capacities of the biosphere), and hence into senescence. A senescent civilization is a bubble stretched to the limit but still stretching and about to burst.</p><p>In a senescent civilization business-as-usual drives the system inexorably toward collapse, because business-as-usual is geared toward modes of growth and development (e.g., fossil fueled building of infrastructure required by the multi-national corporations that produce and sell fossil fuel-derived products, including much of our food) that worked well in the context of immaturity to develop the system to maturity, but which in the context of maturity work more and more to undermine system viability. That is because the energy flows and associated information used to develop the system to maturity produce waste and other side effects (“externalities”) that accumulate in the environment and become increasingly toxic, such that virtuous cycles in early development become vicious cycles in late development. As mounting toxicity drives a civilization to senescence and thence to collapse, the benefits conferred by civilization become harder to access by anyone who isn’t wealthy. This causes people to become angry and turn on one another, because very few of us want to give up the privileges we have taken for granted, and it’s all too easy to imagine that someone else is coming for them. This is particularly true for the more historically privileged members of society (“freedom is just another word for nothing left to lose”). The uber-wealthy who have the lion’s share of power exploit this by using the media that they control to keep poorer peoples’ attention and anger focused on each other.</p><p>But it’s still all about energy and information. In senescence the information that channels energy flow is entrenched in self-interested business models and habitual behaviors that emerged in the context of early development, so much so that the system is impeded from using energy to adapt to increasingly precarious and rapidly deteriorating circumstances. In a highly developed, senescent civilization, most people still depend on money that they obtain from jobs that in turn depend on economic growth, and most people still get their information from media that emerged with, supported, and is geared to that growth, and as a result most people lack time, energy, and sufficient awareness to significantly change their way of being as required to adapt. It’s a catch-22: even if you see the problem and want to change the system, in order to feed yourself and your family you still must focus most of your energy on going to work to make money. And since most available jobs (and the information provided you by the media) are devoted to well-developed (i.e., highly informed) but increasingly toxic modes of economic growth, your daily activities serving <em>business as usual</em> drive development of the system further into senescence and thence collapse.</p><p>As the system collapses, energy flow (currency) becomes harder to access for most people (e.g., due to the extreme wealth inequality that invariably develops following financial deregulation and imposition of regressive taxation) as power becomes concentrated in the hands of a few who work to limit what choices people have, including for leadership. At the same time, information becomes increasingly unreliable (e.g., due to technologically augmented spread of politically motivated misinformation, propaganda, and lies). As a result, democracy is undermined and becomes all but impossible. Increasing scarcity, accelerating disruptive environmental change and degradation, mass migration, and failing infrastructure increase conflict, making fascism and other types of autocratic or totalitarian systems more attractive, maybe inevitable, as a strongman leader and tribalism (finding identity in a cult) intuitively appeals (and is sold) to the base (i.e., primate animal) instincts of people as a means to hold on to what they have. But that is an illusion — fascism doesn’t solve the problems driving the collapse, it only makes them worse, accelerating the collapse. Fascism cannot fix the system that produced it. It is merely symptomatic of the developmentally entrenched patterns of information and energy that bring about senescence and collapse in a late-stage, hyper-capitalist, corporatist oligarchy. It is a last-ditch attempt of the dominant beneficiaries of the system to extract the resources they need to continue their doomed energy-intensive way of life.</p><p>The potential silver lining of America’s descent into fascism, if there is one, is that it will help accelerate the inevitable collapse of our unsustainable way of being in this world. It may thus provide us with greater impetus, and possibly even freedom, to get on with the project of transforming whatever remains after the collapse into a new healthier socioeconomic system sooner rather than later. We have no way of knowing whether the collapse will lead to nothingness or <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis</a>, although with the Damocles sword of nuclear weapons, it is safe to say that nothingness is an all too real possibility. But if we want to work toward metamorphosis that produces a civilization that is not dystopic, I’m guessing that can only be done from the ground up, through the building of strong local communities.</p><p>So, if I have any recommendations at this darkening end time, it is to get to know and engage with your neighbors, work on being kind to yourself and one another and on forming strong communities, and resist the efforts of faraway powers (who, if you think about it, are people you don’t really know) to incite you to violence. Remember that violence tends to beget violence and increase suffering and is at best a last resort option for self-defense. One way to nonviolently resist the fascist state is to disengage from mass media and as much as possible divest yourself from the global economy while investing in your local economy. Prepare for cash becoming scarce or worthless, by learning skills and creating things of value to barter. When it all falls, if there is to be any kind of <a href="https://medium.com/@jacoffman/metamorphosis-a17684104ac8">metamorphosis </a>of human civilization into something new and improved, it will be up to small scale economies and local politics based on interpersonal relationships, networks, and communities to rebuild and transform the system, and hopefully preserve the art and knowledge developed by prior civilizations. The Foundation will be built by our local communities. In my opinion, if there is any hope at this late stage, that’s where it lies. Good luck — we will all need it.</p><p><strong><em>Further Reading</em></strong></p><p>Coffman, J.A., and Mikulecky, D.C. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Global-Insanity-sapiens-Reality-Transforming/dp/1938158040/ref=sr_1_4?crid=2KEMX1U94IRSF&amp;keywords=Global+Insanity&amp;qid=1641930992&amp;s=books&amp;sprefix=global+insanity%2Cstripbooks%2C162&amp;sr=1-4"><em>Global Insanity: How Homo sapiens Lost Touch with Reality While Transforming the World</em></a>. Emergent Publications, 2012.</p><p>Coffman, J.A. and Mikulecky, D.C. <a href="https://cosmosandhistory.org/index.php/journal/article/view/467/774">Global Insanity redux</a>. <em>Cosmos &amp; History</em>, 11: 1–14, 2015.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c903e63d5fe9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>