<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jacopo Pelanda on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jacopo Pelanda on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jacopopelanda?source=rss-8453a1c00081------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 21:54:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jacopopelanda/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Class Matters?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacopopelanda/class-matters-current-standards-and-future-developments-in-cabin-design-c6417d811477?source=rss-8453a1c00081------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c6417d811477</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[airplanes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[airlines]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[innovation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jacopo Pelanda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Jan 2018 16:10:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-10T21:18:30.395Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Current standards and future developments in cabin design.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*RvS-xvGCu7rSu8d3WcL24w.jpeg" /></figure><h3>1 Introduction</h3><p>In the early days of commercial air transport, the sole fact of being able to travel by plane was the actual luxury, rather than a fancy seat or a cutting-­edge entertainment system. But with time, airlines started to offer different fares for different tickets and eventually also different classes. On long haul flights the cabin is becoming more and more of a service-­oriented and luxury topic. With Qatar Airways’ Introduction of a Business Class that surpasses many First Class seats of other airlines, the new QSuite, Swiss upgrading their Business Class, and Lufthansa removing the First Class from their A350 Model entirely, it is safe to say that there must be some kind of shift in the way airline cabin design is perceived. First Class is declining, but at the same time Business Class is evolving. With the introduction of the Premium Economy Class or even private Apartments, some airlines now operate up to four classes. It is important to bear in mind that airlines always try to maximize their profits, like any other company. Therefore, the changes in cabin design are a very important aspect to observe how airlines try to interpret customer needs. In the future, we might not have any classes at all anymore, but rather a very modular experience. Some industries, even aviation itself, have evolved business models that are very user-­centric and customers only want to pay for what they actually consume.</p><p>In this paper, we would like to outline the evolution of cabin design and its implications for the future. The goal is to make predictions for the near future and try to elaborate assumptions of how the cabin could change in the far future. After outlining the research question, a brief introduction to the methodology is made. Followed by that, First, Business, Premium Economy and Economy classes are outlined and compared. It is especially important to highlight how these classes have changed over time in quality and quantity. The next part is focusing on the future of cabin design. Based on the previous analysis of the classes and literature review, predictions are made in which direction the cabin design is moving in the near future. In a more open-­minded last part, we want to elaborate how the cabin design in the far future might change entirely.</p><h4><strong>2 Research question and thesis</strong></h4><p>This seminar paper aims to find answers concerning the question: What are the key drivers of cabin design configuration changes and how does the future of cabin design look like? As airlines are exposed to an increasing competitive market environment, revenue and cost management are critical. The seminar paper will therefore analyze the developments of the aviation industry in this specific dimension.</p><p>The following theses are made for the paper:</p><p>• First class is declining in profitability due to a constantly improving business class</p><p>• Increased competition forces airlines to innovate their cabin design</p><p>• Future cabin configurations are driven by profitability calculations and satisfy more individual demands</p><p>To address the papers’ theses the authors will elaborate the historical development of cabin configurations, discuss the economies of current cabin designs and make a prediction about future cabin design.</p><h4><strong>3 Methodology</strong></h4><p>Qualitative methods are suited to gain a first insight into a subject where research gaps exist and not much is known. After gaining an initial understanding, the subject can be further analyzed by quantitative methods when required (Lewis, Saunders &amp; Thornhill, 2009). Nobody knows how the future looks like, only assumptions can be made based on past experiences and available present information. Therefore, a quantitative approach is not really feasible for making trend predictions at this stage. In a qualitative approach the inquirer makes knowledge claims based on individual experiences and observations with the intent of developing a theory or pattern (Creswell, 2003). One of the core strengths of qualitative research is the ability to describe the behavior of a research subject, single out factors that influence a certain development or status, better understand contextual and systemic influences and study similarities and differences between research subjects (Mason, 2002). Qualitative description can play an important role of suggesting possible relationships, causes, effects, and dynamics. In the context, the qualitative research about the future cabin design of aircrafts is adequate, because there are few concepts in previous literature and it’s a highly speculative topic.</p><p><strong>4 The evolution of cabin design</strong></p><p>After elaborating the underlying idea, methodology and research question of this paper in the previous chapters, we would now like to highlight the historical development of the different classes and the evolution of customer needs.</p><p><strong><em>4.1 Historical context</em></strong></p><p>Initially, passengers were not the main source for revenues, but the early airlines were created mainly to fly mail around a country. When airplane size and capacity grew, they began to focus on passengers in order to make sense out of their new capabilities. Therefore, one of the fundamental concepts today’s airlines are based on emerged: to make the possibility of traveling available to a greater amount of people. Technological innovations such as a pressurized cabin and supercharged engines allowed the airlines not just to compete on travel duration but also on services and comfort with trains and passenger liners. The customer experience improved significantly over time, although there was still a single class of service. During World War 2 the US army ordered enormous numbers of airplanes which were later no longer needed. Thus, new and existing airlines were equipped with large fleets and needed to attract more passengers, which they tried to do so by reducing the cost of air travel. Like today, travel routes with more stops were cheaper than a nonstop flight, but the concept of offering different fares was a revolutionary idea for that time. Additional differentiation was not possible as the International Air Transport Association (IATA) acted as a supervisory authority to approve fares and establish industry-­wide standards. The appearance of larger airplanes like the Boeing 707 was another reason that air travel started becoming something that not only upper class but also middle class could afford. These airplanes could carry much more passengers due to a new way of laying out the cabin. Fortunately enough, these types of new planes offered exactly that possibility to test out new cabin layouts. The airlines then recognized that there were possibilities to add more different service levels, which then resulted in the introduction of Business Class. Another development was the introduction of loyalty services such as frequent flyer programs. This gave airlines the ability to classify their most valuable customers and had influence on seating configuration and equipping of airplanes (Rowell, 2016).</p><p>Between 1969 -­ 1978 three important milestones occurred for the development of premium cabin classes. First, the Introduction of the Boeing 747, which lead to space for luxury cabins. Second, the Invention of the Concorde, which stood for First Class travel. Third, the Deregulation started in 1978 in the U.S, which gave airlines full control over ticket prices. As competition increased and the oil crisis hit the industry, airlines had to be more innovative, so they started to implement a multi cabin configuration with different classes and increased service offers (Wittmer, Bieger &amp; Müller, 2011). From a historical perspective, the second thesis can be confirmed that increased competition has led to significant cabin design innovations.</p><p><strong><em>4.2 Customer categorization</em></strong></p><p>After deregulation, airlines started different service offerings and segmented their customers (Wittmer, Bieger &amp; Müller, 2011). The demand for air transportation can be seen as the driving force for the development of the whole aviation system, because it is the final demand in the aviation value chain. Of course, demand is also influenced by the supply side, for example by innovation in services or types of aircraft (Wittmer, Bieger &amp; Müller, 2011). Like with every consumer product, customer preferences vary between different market segments, which then are in itself homogeneous. That means that in a certain segment, customer preferences, buying behavior or goals are actually mutual in some way (Kotler, 1991). Airlines take advantage of this concept by trying to cater to the needs of different customer personae. If the product is designed according to the needs of the consumer it will drive their willingness to pay, which is exactly what carriers are doing. In order to make more sense out of consumer needs and to bundle them in homogeneous groups, so-­called personae are created. This concept makes it much more hands-­on and intuitively understandable for cabin design development. Edelmann and Becker (2007) have therefore developed such a persona concept which is displayed in Table 1. Different attributes like age, sex or travel purpose imply characteristic needs, which then influences an individual’s choice of cabin class (Wittmer, Bieger &amp; Müller, 2011). For example, a very budget-­oriented customer prefers Economy Class, whereas a pragmatic business traveler might choose Premium Economy Class and a very service-­oriented person would probably choose the higher classes.</p><h4>Customer Categorization</h4><p><strong>Bargain Hunter</strong></p><p>Functionals / Cheap Chic</p><p>Age Profile: 20–45</p><p>Business Travel: marginal flyer</p><p>Leisure Travel: occasional flyer</p><p>Segment Size: Major</p><p><strong>Traditionals</strong></p><p>Conservatives / Habituals</p><p>Age Profile: 55+</p><p>Business Travel: marginal flyer</p><p>Leisure Travel: occasional flyer</p><p>Segment Size: Major</p><p><strong>Established Seniority</strong></p><p>Corporate Seniors</p><p>Age Profile: 45–70</p><p>Business Travel: frequent flyer</p><p>Leisure Travel: frequent flyer</p><p>Segment Size: Medium</p><p><strong>Modern Mainstream</strong></p><p>High Streets Shopper / Travel Experiencers</p><p>Age Profile: 25–45</p><p>Business Travel: occasional flyer</p><p>Leisure Travel: occasional flyer</p><p>Segment Size: Major</p><p><strong>Trendsetters</strong></p><p>Cosmopolitans / Discoverers / Globetrotter Age Profile: 18–40</p><p>Business Travel: frequent flyer</p><p>Leisure Travel: frequent flyer</p><p>Segment Size: Medium</p><p><strong>High Society</strong></p><p>Company Leaders / VIPs / Celebrities Age Profile: 20–99</p><p>Business Travel: high frequent flyer</p><p>Leisure Travel: frequent flyer</p><p>Segment Size: Niche</p><p><em>Source: Edelmann and Becker 2007 from Wittmer, Bieger and Müller 20111</em></p><h4><strong>5 The economies of cabin configuration</strong></h4><p>One key thesis of the paper is that cabin design is driven by profitability calculations and has to be innovated under increasing competition. Therefore, we analyze today’s cabin classes and put them into an economical perspective. This will enable us to highlight current challenges and give indications for future potentials.</p><p>In this section, the seminar paper analyzes the reasons for the ongoing rise of the Business Class, which is the class with which airlines made the most profit up until recently (Hugon-­ Duprat &amp; O’Connell, 2015).</p><h4><strong><em>5.1 Development of First Class compared to Business Class</em></strong></h4><p>The number of airlines offering a First Class cabin has declined considerably, the number fell from 46 in 1998 to 29 in 2012 (Hugon-­Duprat &amp; O’Connell, 2015). In certain markets, First Class has been replaced by Business Class. Today the Business Classes often come very close to the average First Class cabins. Flat-­bed seats in long-­haul Business Class are expected as the norm. Combined with multi-­course meals, sophisticated inflight entertainment systems and personalized service, today’s Business Class is encroaching into the First Class territory of yesteryear (Huang, 2016). Airlines who offer a very good Business Class have to do even more regarding their First Class, but have to take the limited space of an aircraft into consideration. Many airlines respond to this challenge by providing two-­class cabins on many routes (Garcia, 2014).</p><p>Airlines nowadays also put more weight on preflight services to differentiate their First Class from Business Class. In the cabin design, a “private suite” concept has been established in the industry, to promote privacy and exclusivity. Some carriers also believe that they can maintain the differentiation to Business Class and First Class with an even more luxurious Super First Class. Etihad for example established a class above First Class called “The Residence”. The next chapter will analyze the First Class of some players, which market themselves as “premium carriers” (Garcia, 2014).</p><h4><strong><em>5.2 Comparison between different carriers’ First Classes</em></strong></h4><p>In this section, we compare three of the most luxurious First Class experiences. Then in a first step the preflight services are compared and in a second the in-­flight specialties.</p><p><strong>Lufthansa </strong>(Frankfurt departure):</p><p>Preflight: Valet parking service for private or rental cars. Personal assistant at the airport, who offers any kind of support and guides the passenger through the terminal. Exclusive First Class terminal with à la carte dining and a cigar lounge. Limousine service to the airplane.</p><p>Inflight (Airbus A380–800): 8 First Class seats which can be transformed to a 2m bed, shown</p><p>Seat details: Pitch — 81 / Width 31. Flexible à la carte dining.</p><p><strong>Etihad</strong>: (Abu Dhabi departure):</p><p>Preflight: Etihad provides a limousine service to the airport. Besides preferred check-­in there is a premium lounge with a 5-­star restaurant and a spa.</p><p>Inflight (Airbus A380 -­ 800): Etihad offers nine First Class suites and the exclusive “Residence” on the A380–800, the latter one pictured below. The nine First Class apartments offer a leather seat and an additional 2m bed. Seat details: Pitch — 80 / Width 29.5. First Class passengers are entitled to use the shower on board. There is also a lobby room. Etihad has a head cook on board to fulfill individual requests of passengers.</p><p><strong>Singapore airlines: </strong>(Singapore departure):</p><p>Preflight: Concierge style check-­in. “Private room” First Class lounge access with à la carte dining.</p><p>Inflight A380 -­ 800: There are 12 First Class Suites, with two double Suites, shown in figure 3.</p><p>Seat details: Pitch — 81 / Width 35. A la carte meals, or pre-­ordered specialties.</p><p>Huang (2016) confirms the second thesis of the paper with pointing out that an increasing competition about premium cabin configurations has put pressure on airlines to also adopt to increasing sophisticated standards in Business and First Class. The result of this round of competitive innovation in seating standard is that airlines defend market shares but they have also adopted significantly higher unit costs (The Economist, 2016).</p><h4><strong><em>5.3 Economics of First Class vs Business Class</em></strong></h4><p>Just a quarter of First Class fliers on overseas flights pay full fare for their seats, according to a survey by market research firm Atmosphere Research Group;; the rate is closer to 15% on flights within the U.S.</p><p>Statistics show that only around 0.7% of all passengers fly First Class and 31.4% fly Business Class (Claussen &amp; O’Higgins, 2010). Floor space is limited on an aircraft and it is important that airlines optimize it with maximal efficiency. A First Class seat takes three times more space than an Economy Class seat, whereas the costs associated are nine times higher (Kollmuss &amp; Lane, 2008).</p><p>In their research Hugon-­Duprat and O’Connell (2015) calculated that an airline with a 14-­seat configuration in First Class would need around a 60% load factor to make the class profitable. This is hard to achieve because of high fares and a high Business Class product. A lot of First Class passengers pay fixed corporate rates or upgrade with loyalty miles which don’t pay the full price. This brought First Class to slowly disappear from U.S airlines, and in the last twenty years it has been replaced by Business Class.</p><p>The catering cost of one First Class passenger is estimated at $155 to $185 (Business at $40 to $75) (Hugon-­Duprat &amp; O’Connell, 2015). This is due to the convenience that the entire range of meals has to be available to all First Class passengers. Proportionally the cabin crew costs are higher in the premium classes, normally there are two crew members taking care of First Class.</p><p>O’Connell (2011) found that the yield measured in US cents per RPK (revenue passenger kilometer) for First and Business Classes was 24 cents and 19.6 cents respectively. Real revenue would amount on an average B747 to 1942 USD per passenger compared to 1251 USD per passenger. However real cost per passenger for First Class is around 2056 USD compared to 766 USD for Business. It can be concluded that often the real revenue in First Class falls short of the cost of its production due to its high specification and space absorbing product offering. The final cost to revenue ratio for First Class is 1 to 0,94 and 1 to 1,6 for Business.</p><h4><strong><em>5.4 Why some airlines stick to First Class</em></strong></h4><p>Even though First Class might not be profitable for some airlines, it would be difficult to drop it due to their image and marketing strategy (Garcia, 2014). The First Class helps these airlines to market themselves as “premium carriers”, which also helps to market the other cabin classes.</p><p>There are still customers who want to stand out of the crowd. Some cultures need First Class, as they appreciate exclusivity (Garcia, 2014). In some markets, there are plenty of customers willing to pay for full private cabins (Middle East and Asia) (Garcia, 2014). For airlines, it makes sense to offer a First Class Product on specific regional routes. In the Middle East, First Class suites are a big success due to a large number of super-­wealthy businessmen, politicians and royalty who regularly connect through the region and the active “luxury” branding of Emirates, Etihad and Qatar (Huang, 2016).</p><h4><strong>6 The rise of Premium Economy</strong></h4><p>In an almost class-­warfare like environment between Business and First Class one class seems relatively stagnant: Economy. Experts agree that the disparity between Economy and the very luxury-­oriented classes needs to be addressed as aircraft interior design evolves. In fact, some experts even question whether in today’s and tomorrow’s travel experience, there is even a place for the concept of class (Garcia, 2014). But that is just a side note regarding the broader future of cabin design. In the context of this paper it is necessary to take a closer look at all classes available for long-­haul flights, in order to be able to make a complete assessment regarding the status-­quo of airline cabin design.</p><p>In this section, we would like to establish an overview over the fairly new and emerging Premium Economy Class, its attributes, make a comparison to the more traditional Economy Class and try to see if it’s even possible that Premium Economy might tackle the higher classes. In a study, Hugon-­Duprat and O’Connell (2015) found out that a Premium Economy seat, while 1.6 times more expensive to produce, generates revenues that are 2.3 times higher than its cost of production, as can be seen in Table</p><p>2. This is quite remarkable and seems to explain partially why so many commercial airlines invest heavily in this segment.</p><h4><strong><em>6.1 What is Premium Economy and who is it designed for</em></strong></h4><p>Even though the concept might seem fairly new, the class was introduced in the early 90’s. It is situated between the Business and Economy Class offers (financially and logistically). Premium Economy guests enjoy a broad variety of different benefits which may or may not include increased seat pitch, enhanced seat width, more seat recline, additional frequent flyer points, more baggage allowance, enhanced In-­Flight Entertainment with wider screens, dedicated check-­in counters, priority boarding, laptop power ports, wider variety of meals, dedicated toilets and amenity kits (Hugon-­ Duprat &amp; O’Connell, 2015). In figures 3-­6 you can find a range of different Premium Economy products.</p><p>It is noted on purpose that these benefits may or may not be included because the offerings in Premium Economy vary very distinctly between different carriers. The innovation of Premium Economy seating is the beginning of the blurring of definitions in premium offerings in the aircraft cabin. It is the first section where a differentiation is made which is rather dependent on the airlines marketing strategy, than on uniform product definitions in the industry (Garcia, 2014). While First Class is gradually being phased out, Premium Economy is increasingly being installed in order to enhance differentiation between Business and Economy Class. Premium Economy aims at more cost-­oriented business passengers or leisure travellers who are unwilling to pay for Business Class, but prepared to pay an additional charge to upgrade to Premium Economy. Those leisure travellers are usually retirees, or people whose children have moved out of home thus creating more disposable income, or young professionals who are flying for special occasions and aspire superior comfort. Business travel is highly sensitive to the economy while leisure travellers are more resilient. Premium Economy lets the airlines spread the risk by including a middle cabin which then lessens the financial impact when airlines are exposed to downturn (Hugon-­Duprat &amp; O’Connell, 2015).</p><h4><strong><em>6.2 Economics of Premium Economy</em></strong></h4><p>The fares for the service are usually between 30 and 50 percent higher than the regular Economy Class fare, whereas the Business seat can be up to 65 percent higher than Premium Economy (Hugon-­Duprat &amp; O’Connel, 2015). O’Connell (2011) found that the yield measured in US cents per RPK for First Class, Business Class and Economy Class was 24 cents, 19.6 cents and 5.8 cents. Whereas Claussen and O’Higgins (2011) found that the proportion of passengers in each class was 0.7%, 31.4% and 67.9%. So clearly there is a large yield gap between Business and Economy. The yield per RPK for Premium Economy is estimated to be in the range of 8.5 and 9.5 cents (Hugon-­ Duprat &amp; O’Connell, 2015). The ratio of seat costs in economy is usually indexed at 100, which allows an easy way to establish the costs for other classes. In British Airways’ four cabins those ratios are 1.0 for economy, 1.64 for Premium Economy, 3.5 for business and 9.4 for first (Hugon-­Duprat &amp; O’Connell, 2015). This means that Premium Economy is 1.64 times more expensive to accommodate, however in comparison to business still very affordable.</p><h4><strong>Economy</strong></h4><h4><strong><em>6.3 Economy vs. Premium Economy</em></strong></h4><p>According to Hugon-­Duprat and O’Connell (2015) long haul Economy Class passengers attach greatest importance to legroom, followed by food/drink, choice of seat (aisle or window), baggage allowance, entertainment and wider seats. Overall passengers in Economy Class on long haul flights value additional seat pitch above all other attributes. That being said, with Premium Economy offering significantly more legroom there might be a strong case for the class. Premium Economy is a niche market with great potential. IHS (2013) estimates that the amount of Premium Economy seats will grow from 14000 in 2012 to 70000 in ten years. That’s a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 17.1%. For comparison: The amount of First Class seats is predicted to grow at a rate of just 1.6%, Business Class is set to grow by 9.3% and Economy Class seating is expected to grow at 6.1%. This suggests that Premium Economy will be a much bigger player in the future than it already is today. Aircraft manufacturers have already recognized the trend and are reengineering the cabin floors as they also foresee the development of the Premium Economy Class products. Boeings 787 is innovatively designed in order to enable airlines to rearrange cabin configurations with less physical and financial impact (Boeing, 2013). Airbus even places all the premium classes on the upper floor in future A380 models, which points to the fact that Premium Economy is closer positioned to business than to economy (Flightglobal, 2013). If booked in advance, Premium Economy is about 85% more expensive than economy and if booked closer to departure about 35% but can be as low as 10% more (Seatguru, 2017).</p><h4>7 The Future of Cabin Design</h4><h4><strong><em>7.1 Current</em></strong></h4><p>Regarding the aircraft interiors, a lot has changed in the last few years. Whereas Economy Class got more cramped year by year with airlines trying to squeeze as much seats into a plane as possible, the Premium Cabins experienced quite the contrary. With Business Class at 8-­across a row (e.g. United 777-­200, shown in figure 7) to Lufthansa’s 6-­across a row (almost all planes) to the new standard with 4-­across a row and aisle access from every seat (e.g. Singapore Airlines, American Airlines, Finnair etc.), passengers have become accustomed to the new luxury and ask at least for that.</p><p>At the same time, product designs are getting more innovative in terms of space utilization and maximization, with the new United Polaris Business Class, manufactured by Zodiac, being the leader in this category. While their old Business Class has the above mentioned 8 seats per row in a 2-­4-­2 layout, the new design allows for nearly two rows of 1-­2-­1 layout in the same space, with direct aisle access, due to a very dense configuration, which is shown below (Skift, 2016a).</p><p>So, while the seat count remains actually the same (with removal of First Class it even increases), that should result in higher revenues due to having a superior product.</p><p>The same goes for First Class, starting with El Al’s frightening 2-­2 layout (Boeing 777-­200ER, shown in figure 9), to the all hyped Lufthansa, Etihad and Air France First Classes which all offer only the best, with Air France’s new La Première in figure 10</p><p>Singapore airlines just held a media conference this week in Singapore presenting their newest A380 Suite Class product, shown below in comparison to the old Suite, which will start operating daily from 18 December on the route to Sydney.</p><p>Together with Emirates, who will present their newest 777-­300ER First Class product at the Dubai Airshow in November, they will presumably set a new standard for travel up front.</p><h4><strong><em>7.2 Near Future</em></strong></h4><p>With this kind of enhancement in mind one may ask how the future of air travel inside the cabin looks like, and there is no lack of studies and ideas regarding this.</p><p>According to a study from Airbus, the configuration of the seat could be adapted to the number of passengers on the plane by installing foldable seats, providing “adjustable comfort” (Telegraph, 2017).</p><p>This could be especially useful for intra-­Europe flights, as the current “Business Class” consists merely of a free middle seat with the same configuration as Economy Class, which, compared to other short-­haul Business-­ and First Class products, isn’t a competitive product by any means. In this case, the seats for Business Class could be adjusted with at least a little more legroom compared to the back of the plane, and non-­used seats are just folded up where the space is needed.</p><h4><strong><em>7.3 Far Future</em></strong></h4><p>Another study from Airbus goes even further, eliminating the traditional separation from First-­, Business-­ and Economy Class, as there are plans for transforming seats out of materials which can morph into a different shape (The Economist, 2015). You then literally get what you pay for, meaning, that the more you pay, the more comfort and space you will get. In the same study, envisioned in figure 15there is a concept for a “biopolymer membrane”, which allows to turn opaque or transparent on command, making regular windows unnecessary. At the same time these new structures, both of the seat and the fuselage, are much lighter and therefore more fuel efficient when it comes to economic aspects (The Economist, 2015).</p><p>A third study, again from Airbus, but this time a little more hand on, with the promising name “Transpose”, is being realized by A3 (pronounced A cubed) in Silicon Valley (CNN Money, 2016). The idea behind this concept is, to change the fact that airlines are currently bound to their interiors for seven+ years, once installed. Highly promoted features like the bar, shower or stores inside a cabin are seldom installed (except for the Middle Eastern Carriers and Korean Airlines), due to the reason that it is not profitable for an airline (Skift, 2016b). With the modules from “Transpose”, the engineering team around Jason Chua wants to target that problem. The modules can be equipped with all different kind of interior, be it a shower, a restaurant, a play area for kids or additional seats and sleeping pods, shown in figure 16 (Airbus XO, 2017). For the lack of windows, A3 has installed a “windowless technology”, which are OLED screens in the walls of each module (CNN Money, 2016).</p><p>The idea is to change modules according to the destination or demand, and this in less than an hour. To achieve this, a mockup version of a modified A330 freighter has been set up, together with nine high-­fidelity modules. The units then get into the plane by some kind of crane (currently pushed by hand, shown in figure 17 (Airbus XO, 2017)).</p><p>While the transparent structure of an airplane currently has more similarity with Science Fiction, “Transpose” seems more realistic. The main factor for airlines to decide if acquiring such an aircraft for their fleet or not is the revenue. Now that non-­profitable modules can just be swapped in minutes instead of grounding the whole airplane for weeks or months, this concept doesn’t seem too unrealistic to be realized. A former airline CFO even estimated, that this concept could increase profits by 5-­7%, which is a huge number when talking of airlines. Normally, no windows would also mean less weight and even less costs, but since this is a freighter, it doesn’t apply in this case. Nevertheless, according to Chua, the project was already discussed with regulators, brands, and leaders in the aerospace and the airline industry, about how to make modular cabins a reality (Airbus XO, 2017).</p><h4>8 Conclusion</h4><p>At the end, we are able to draw several conclusions out of this seminar paper. Firstly, although First Class often isn’t even break even and Premium Economy-­ and Business Classes are the main revenue drivers for airlines, there will most likely still be a First Class around, at least in the near future and that will remain so as long as classes still exist, even if on much less routes. The First Class product will however be of great exclusivity to certain carriers. This is mainly due to the prestige with which First Class is associated, and premium carriers like Lufthansa or Emirates still rely quite heavily on that, at least for marketing purposes. Secondly, while First Class is diminishing more and more, the new player in the market seems to be Premium Economy, being the most profitable out of all classes currently. This is primarily due to the worse Economy Products and the still affordable prices for Premium Economy compared to Business-­ and First Classes. Lastly, there are two promising future concepts from Airbus. One of them wants to eliminate classes with the help of transforming seats while at the same time having a special structure, which aims for massive weight reduction and therefore much more revenue for airlines. The other one wants to solve the problem of non-­profitable elements like showers or bars in aircrafts by just swapping out the modular cabin-­parts in less than an hour, currently being tested in Silicon Valley. Funnily enough there weren’t any similar projects to be found by Boeing.</p><p>It will for sure be exciting what the future keeps at hand regarding the design, layout, material and revenues of aircraft cabins. You never know, but while reading this paper in a couple years’ time, you might find yourself in a co-­working space of a modular Airbus A300-­Series.</p><h4>9 References</h4><p>Airbus XO. (2017). Transpose takes off. Article from website: http://airbus-­ xo.com/transpose-­takes-­off/, 02.11.2017</p><p>Andystravelblog. (2017). Singapore Airlines unveils incredible new A380 Suites Class.</p><p>http://andystravelblog.boardingarea.com/2017/11/01/singapore-­airlines-­</p><p>unveils-­incredible-­new-­a380-­suites-­class/#jp-­carousel-­6789, 02.11.2017</p><p>Boeing Aero. (2013). Estimating Maintenance Reserves. <em>Aero Magazine</em> 4. Article</p><p>from website:</p><p><a href="http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/2013_">http://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/2013_</a></p><p>q4/pdf/AERO_2013q4.pdf, 30.10.2017</p><p>from website: https://www.businesstraveller.com/tried-­and-­tested/air-­france-­la-­ premiere-­first-­class-­b777-­300er/, 02.11.2017</p><p>Claussen, J., O’Higgins, E. (2010). Competing on value: perspectives on</p><p>Business Class aviation. <em>Journal of Air Transport Management</em> 16 (4), 202-­ 208.</p><p>CNN Money. (2016). Airbus ponders a future with a flying Starbucks and no view.</p><p>Article from website:</p><p>http://money.cnn.com/2016/12/22/news/companies/planes-­without-­</p><p>windows/index.html, 02.11.2017</p><p>Creswell, J. (2003). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative and mixed mehtods</p><p>approaches. London: Sage publications, 18</p><p>Flightglobal. (2013). Airbus to Offer A380 Reconfiguration. Article from website:</p><p>http://pro.flightglobal.com/news/articles/airbus-­to-­offer-­a380-­reconfiguration-­ 385774/, 30.10.2017</p><p>Garcia, M. (2014). The Future of the Aircraft Cabin -­ Tracking Trends and Debunking Myths. <em>Skift Report #23</em>: 16-­28</p><p>Huang, C. (2016). The future of first class. Aviation, S. 46-­49</p><p>Hugon-­Duprat, C., O’Connell, J. F. (2015). The rationale for implementing a premium</p><p>Economy Class in the long haul markets — Evidence from the transatlantic market. <em>Journal of Air Transport Management </em>47, 11-­19</p><p>HIS. (2013). Are you Sitting Comfortably? Commercial Airlines Adopt More Cost-­</p><p>conscious Approach to Seating Classes as Installed Base Passes 3 Million Seats. Article from website: http://press.ihs.com/press-­release/design-­supply-­ chain/are-­you-­sitting-­comfortably-­commercial-­airlines-­adopt-­more-­cost-­co, 30.10.2017</p><p>Kollmuss, A., Lane, J. (2008). Carbon Offsetting &amp; Air Travel: Part 1: CO2-­Emissions Calculations.</p><p>Kotler, P. H. (1991). Marketing management: Analysis, planning, and control (8th ed.).</p><p>Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall.</p><p>Lewis, P., Thornhill, A., Saunders, M. (2009). Research methods for business students. Pearson education, 489</p><p>Luxuo. (2017). Picture from website: http://www.luxuo.com/wp-­ content/uploads/2010/08/a380-­suite-­singapore-­airlines.jpg, 02.11.2017</p><p>Mason, J. (2002). Qualitative researching. London: Sage Publications, 1-­3</p><p>O’Connell, J.F. (2011). An inherently turbulent industry. <em>Air Transport in the 21st</em> <em>Century</em>, 59-­ 96</p><p>Rowell David. (2016). The History of Airline Classes and Cabins. Article from website:</p><p>http://blog.thetravelinsider.info/2016/09/history-­airline-­classes-­cabins.html, 31.10.2017</p><p>SeatGuru. (2017). Premium Economy Class Comparison Chart. Chart from</p><p>website: <a href="http://www.seatguru.com/charts/premium_economy.php,">www.seatguru.com/charts/premium_economy.php,</a> 21.10.2017</p><p>Sfgate. (2012). Picture from website:</p><p><a href="http://blog.sfgate.com/cmcginnis/files/2012/01/IMG_4668.jpg,">http://blog.sfgate.com/cmcginnis/files/2012/01/IMG_4668.jpg,</a> 31.10.2017</p><p>Singapore Airlines. (2017). Picture from website:</p><p>https://www.singaporeair.com/saar5/images/flying-­withus/suites/individual-­ cabins.jpg, 02.11.2017</p><p>Skift. (2016a). The Unexpected Micro-­Revolution Behind United Airlines’ New Business</p><p>Class Seat. Article from website: https://skift.com/2016/06/22/the-­unexpected-­ micro-­revolution-­behind-­united-­airlines-­new-­business-­class-­seat/, 02.11.2017</p><p>Skift. (2016b). Airbus Wants Airlines to Radically Rethink the Passenger Experience.</p><p>Article from website: https://skift.com/2016/12/13/airbus-­wants-­airlines-­to-­ radically-­rethink-­the-­passenger-­experience/, 02.11.2017</p><p>The Economist. (2015). Flying into the future. Article from website:</p><p>https://www.economist.com/news/technology-­quarterly/21651920-­how-­</p><p>technology-­changing-­passenger-­cabin-­whatever-­class-­you-­fly-­flying, 30.10.2017</p><p>The Economist. (2016). Carriers are ditching first-­class cabins as business class</p><p>becomes plusher. Article from website: https://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2016/06/changes-­front-­and-­centre, 31.10.2017</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c6417d811477" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Examining China ’ s Great Leap Forward from a Development Perspective]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jacopopelanda/examining-china-s-great-leap-forward-from-a-development-perspective-a6934fc80963?source=rss-8453a1c00081------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a6934fc80963</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[china]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economic-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jacopo Pelanda]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 08 Jan 2018 15:39:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-08T16:15:25.500Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ST1I8MLvzT4lz_z4oRJZXw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Introduction</strong></p><p>In the 1950s and 1960s, development thinking was centred mainly around the growth-oriented view based on Harrod-Domar’s Growth Theory (von Kimakowitz, 2010). The model explains the associations between income, savings, investments, and output needed to achieve full employment and stable growth found in developed economies (Oman &amp; Wignaraja, 1991). The model has largely resulted in policy prescriptions that utilise conditions based on abundant labour and scarce capital. Additionally, this type of growth-oriented development flourished due to the emergence of international organisations such as the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund in the post-war period. Of these prescriptions, there were three major concepts that encouraged growth as development, the “Big Push”, “Balanced Growth”, and W. W. Rostow’s “Take-off Theory”.</p><p>This paper examines the case of China’s economic development through the lens of Rostow’s “Take-off Theory” as well as the later expanded “Stages of Economic Growth” from 1949 to the early 2000’s with special focus its social and economic policy, the Great Leap Forward (1958 to 1962). The Great Leap Forward was widely seen as a major economic disaster and many deaths as well as the Great Chinese Famine from 1958 to 1961 were attributed to it. There is a usefulness in examining the Great Leap Forward through a development perspective rather than ordinarily through a political lens as this gives us insight into the policy failure from an economic development standpoint, and provides a comparison with the alternative steps that the country has taken to achieve its success today. Additionally, the case highlights some limitations of Rostow’s development theories in explaining the development of countries through a unilineal view.</p><p><strong>Theoretical Foundation</strong></p><p>Rostow’s “Take-off Theory” stands out from the three as the only empirically derived growth model (Rostow, 1956), which explains that countries could “take-off” into a self-sustained stage of growth by raising their savings investment to a percentage above their Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Rostow later hypothesizes that an economy prepares for the “take-off” within two or three decades to transform itself into a self-sustained state. Rostow’s later work, the “Stages of Economic Growth”, expands on the idea of “take-off”, identifying a unilineal development pattern involving five stages of an economy’s economic progress (Rostow, 1990). Rostow introduces the five stages of a society’s economic development as (1) the traditional society, (2) pre-conditions for take-off, (3) take-off, (4) drive to maturity, and (5) the age of high mass-consumption.</p><p><strong>Traditional Society</strong></p><p>Traditional society as described by Rostow, is the most basic form of society, characterised by a majority primary sector economy consisting of subsistence farming as well as hunting and gathering (Rostow, 1990). The overall economy experiences low labour productivity and low surplus output for markets, alongside a low capital stock. Additionally, economic growth is limited due to the absence of modern technologies and individual economic mobility. Often there is no powerful central government, and feudalistic structures alongside clan and family dynamics play an important role. The social structure generally consists of a strong hierarchy, with little potential for class mobility, while Rostow also believed that the society assumes economic progress is not possible for them or their descendants.</p><p><strong>Pre-conditions for Take-off</strong></p><p>Rostow classifies this period as taking up to a century or more, due to the deep structural changes required before take-off. This stage requires fundamental changes, such as a society’s attitudes towards science, risk-taking, and profit-making (Rostow, 1990). Institutions like central government, financial markets, and education have to be developed, while infrastructure needs including railways, ports, and electricity have to be built — Rostow describes this as a form of building up social overhead capital. Additionally, the labour force needs to develop in its adaptability in order to meet the changing demands of the economy, while enough food needs to be produced for a fast-growing population. Agriculture plays an important role in this stage, providing surplus food, increasing incomes and savings, and stimulating industrial investment (Rostow, 1990, pp. 17–18); another condition for achieving take-off.</p><p><strong>Take-off</strong></p><p>This is the central stage in Rostow´s model, comprising a relatively brief period of two or three decades where manufacturing takes up a greater role in the economy. During this time, urbanization and industrialization increase, rapidly expanding the secondary sectors over the primary. Rostow argues that at least one manufacturing sector, such as textiles, has to take prominence within the economy for international competitiveness. Rostow also specifies that the proportion of investment to national incomes or Net National Product (NNP) must rise from 5.0% to 10.0% or higher in order to exceed population growth (Rostow, 1990, p. 41). He reasoned that a typical marginal capital-output ratio of an economy during this stage is around 3.5:1 and that population can be expected to grow at a pace of 1.0 to 1.5% per annum. Based on this assumption, an unchanged rate of NNP requires investment (saving) rates need to account for around 3.50 to 5.25% of NNP. However, in order to shift NNP per capita growth rates to 2.0%, it requires investment rates of above 10.0% of NNP. Despite the difficulty in gathering historical investment and NNP ratios, Rostow analysed data of Germany, Great Britain, and Sweden concluding that investment rates significantly rose during take-off periods and varied with various factors, such as social overhead costs per capita.</p><p><strong>The Drive to Maturity: Period of Self-sustained Growth</strong></p><p>At this stage, Rostow describes an economy as having become mature, and thus capable of propelling a self-sustained growth via industry diversification and development throughout the country. With the conditions of investment rates being between 10.0 and 20.0% of national income, economic development becomes automatic. The initial prominent industries that constituted the economy’s comparative advantage would decline in growth as diminishing returns occur. However, the economy’s overall positive growth rates result from newly emerging industries (Rostow, 1990, p. 59). The shift from rural to urban civilization proceeds, while the structure of foreign trade continues to advance. Rostow cites the example that in the 19th century Germany, the dominant growth drivers shifted from coal and iron to industries toward chemicals, electricity and machine tools (Rostow, 1990, pp. 9, 59).</p><p><strong>Age of High Mass-consumption</strong></p><p>In the last stage, the tertiary sector becomes a mainstay as leading sectors shift towards durable consumer goods and services (Rostow, 1990, p. 10). Living standards rise for the masses, while and consumer goods are mass-produced; this growth is sustained by the increase of the middle class of consumers. Typically, consumers have increased disposable income for goods above their basic necessities, and Rostow accordingly regards the prominence of the automobile as an appropriate symbol of this phase (Rostow, 1990, p. 11). According to Rostow, the United States was the first nation to enter into this stage during the 1920s, whereas Germany entered only in the 1950s.</p><p><strong>Policy Formulation</strong></p><p>In 2015, China’s Net National Income reached USD8.31 trillion (World Bank, 2015), five times more than it was in 2005, and a hundredfold compared to that in 1970. Its rapid growth in the last three decades, 1985 to 2015 (Appendix A) is marvelled at by economists around the world. Despite its distinct communist stance and persistent system of government-backed and state-run industry (McNally, 2013, pp. 46–47), the development path taken by China from 1949 onward seems to closely resemble W. W. Rostow’s liberal economic five stages of growth (Appendix B). However, the road to economic success was not as straightforward as the model would suggest, and various economic and social reforms can be observed throughout China’s economic growth over the decades.</p><p>During China’s Mao Era, Chairman Mao Zedong and the incumbent government launched a major social and economic reform titled the Great Leap Forward (GLF) occurring from 1958 to 1961. The policy’s overall objective was to accelerate economic growth via economic centralisation and state planning. The economic side of the GLF involved using a state-monopoly on agriculture to finance rapid industrialisation. Agricultural collectivisation was introduced, involving the sharing of land, tools, and draft animals, while private ownership on land was gradually phased out (Liu, 2016). The GLF thus became a natural experiment in removing private property rights (He &amp; Sun, 2016).</p><p><strong>Project Implementation</strong></p><p>The GLF strongly resembles Rostow’s preconditions for take-off stage in that its main goal was to accelerate food production, thereby raising incomes and funnelling that into rapid industrialisation (Hu, Guangyu, Hui, &amp; Griffith, 2014). With an expected accelerated food production, the state government intended to store surplus food to avoid famine as well as to earn foreign exchange from exports. Additionally, Mao utilised peasant labour to manufacture steel through communal backyard furnaces (Chan, 2009). These policy moves were congruent with Rostow’s emphasis on gaining a comparative advantage in at least one industrial sector, whilst greatly increasing surplus food produced to generate income and induce population growth. Due to prolonged periods of civil war (Wilbur &amp; Young, 2017) as well as World War II, the Chinese economy was hard-pressed during the Mao Era to rapidly industrialise. It could be argued that the GLF failed to achieve the “take-off” stage as it could not generate two the preconditions, built-up social overhead capital, and income from the agricultural sector diverted to manufacturing as described by Rostow.</p><p><strong>Building Social Overhead Capital</strong></p><p>The GLF implemented social policies involving the banning of spiritual and religious freedom, changes to communal working structures, and the removal of private ownership alongside its economic ones, making it all the more difficult to achieve a stable social structure (He &amp; Sun, 2016, pp. 184–185). Its communal working structure and Mao’s focus on the peasant as the backbone of the communist economy also made it difficult to achieve any form of individual social mobility as described by Rostow. Finally, there was little advancement in production nor any focus on improving capital goods. These factors made it difficult to build up social overhead capital. Though granted, there were efforts by Mao’s government to improve the social standing of women and improve rural education (Hu, Guangyu, Hui, &amp; Griffith, 2014), these were only minor increments to the social overhead capital needed.</p><p><strong>Diverting Agricultural Income</strong></p><p>The GLF was equally unsuccessful in diverting the necessary agricultural income for stimulating the manufacturing sector as a precondition for take-off. There was little surplus income generated from the agricultural production due to reckless agricultural innovations as well as poorly planned and constructed irrigation systems (Hu, Guangyu, Hui, &amp; Griffith, 2014). These were the result of unreachable output targets and high taxation of the communes’ production by the state-monopoly. Mao also incorrectly focused only on grain and food production, neglecting more productive commercial agriculture and cash crops for export. This minimized any surplus generated from the agricultural communalisation effort. Additionally, the dual focus on steel production via backyard furnaces was extremely counterproductive toward generating income as it diverted labour away from agriculture and ultimately failed to produce any income-generating steel due to a lack of expertise and capital equipment (Shabad, 1959).</p><p><strong>Impact Generation</strong></p><p>Overall, the GLF was a stark failure to achieve economic development in China and resulted in the Great Famine along with an estimated 45 million deaths (Mitter, 2012). The policy was overly ambitious, while poor governance and planning meant that little could be done to correct for it. It is apparent that the take-off was not achieved until 1978 (Appendix B) during the Chinese Economic Reform that ended collective farming (BBC, 2006). Investment rates did not rise to the sufficient levels as described by Rostow, while there was no success in either agricultural of manufacturing sectors. Finally, a stable political, social, and institutional framework only emerged after Mao’s death with the takeover of Deng Xiaoping’s focus on a more a market-based economy and trade policies.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Mao’s China after World War II and the conclusion of its civil war, faced considerable internal problems and remained confined to Soviet influence (Shen &amp; Xia, 2011). Despite the turmoil, Mao believed that the backbone of the future Chinese economy would be rooted in the Chinese peasant, and he envisioned a transition from an agrarian society to an industrialised socialist society through communalisation. However, the results were far from it due to massive instability throughout the country, as well as poor planning and execution. The preconditions for Rostow’s “take-off” could not be generated via the GLF, and only occurred in during the Chinese Economic Reform.</p><p>The case highlights that Rostow’s model does have its limitations, especially with regard to his proposed time periods of the stages, but also with regard to the free-market principles that it is based on. Poor planning or innovative economic reform on the part of state actors can affect the outcome of development regardless of the situation of the economy at the time. Rostow’s development model is based on hermetic free-market principles, ie. the relationship between Savings-Investment and Economic Growth; and Mao’s socialist policies had little place in it. Yet, today’s China has managed to subvert this limitation and ultimately attain the age of high mass-consumption stage as described by Rostow’s liberal capitalistic development model. All this has developed alongside strict financial and capital controls as well as widespread state-ownership of its corporations. China’s “state-run” economic growth continues to prove free-market economists wrong, though that remains to be seen in the long term as China is fast approaching a plateau (Bulloch, 2017).</p><h3>References</h3><p>BBC. (2006, November 3). <em>Quick guide: China’s economic reform</em>. Retrieved November 22, 2017, from BBC News: <a href="http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/5237748.stm">http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/5237748.stm</a></p><p>Bulloch, D. (2017, June 23). <em>On Liberal Reform, China Is At A Crossroads</em>. Retrieved November 22, 2017, from Forbes: <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/douglasbulloch/2017/06/23/if-china-turns-its-back-on-liberal-reforms-what-does-the-future-hold/#b9c9fd212119">https://www.forbes.com/sites/douglasbulloch/2017/06/23/if-china-turns-its-back-on-liberal-reforms-what-does-the-future-hold/#b9c9fd212119</a></p><p>Chan, A. (2009). The Campaign for Agricultural Development in the Great Leap Forward: A Study of Policy-Making and Implementation in Liaoning. <em>The China Quarterly</em>, 129, 52–71.</p><p>He, Q., &amp; Sun, M. (2016). Central Planning Legacies: The Linger Effects of the Great Leap Forward in China. <em>Bulletin of Economic Research 68:2, 2016, 0307–3378</em>, 182–203.</p><p>Hirst, T. (2015, July 30). <em>A brief history of China’s economic growth</em>. Retrieved 11 22, 2017, from World Economic Forum: <a href="https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2015/07/brief-history-of-china-economic-growth/">https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2015/07/brief-history-of-china-economic-growth/</a></p><p>Hu, A., Guangyu, H., Hui, V., &amp; Griffith, G. (2014). <em>The Political and Economic History of China (1949–1976); Volume 2: The Great Leap Forward: 1957–1965.</em> Singapore: Enrich Professional Publishing.</p><p>Liu, E. (2016). <em>Maoism and the Chinese Revolution : A Critical Introduction.</em> Chicago: PM Press.</p><p>McNally, C. A. (2013). Refurbishing State Capitalism: A Policy Analysis of Efforts to Rebalance China’s. <em>Journal of Current Chinese Affairs, 42, 4</em>, 45–71.</p><p>Mitter, R. (2012, December 7). <em>Tombstone: The Untold Story of Mao’s Great Famine by Yang Jisheng — review.</em> Retrieved from The Guardian: <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/books/2012/dec/07/tombstone-mao-great-famine-yeng-jisheng-review">https://www.theguardian.com/books/2012/dec/07/tombstone-mao-great-famine-yeng-jisheng-review</a></p><p>Oman, C. P., &amp; Wignaraja, G. (1991). <em>The Postwar Evolution of Development Thinking.</em> London: Macmillan.</p><p>Rostow, W. W. (1956). The Take-Off Into Self-Sustained Growth. <em>The Economic Journal, Vol. 66, №261</em>, 25–48.</p><p>Rostow, W. W. (1990). <em>The Stages of Economic Growth: A non-Communist Manifesto (3rd Edition ed.).</em> Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.</p><p>Schweinitz, d. K. (1972). Review of The Stages of Economics Growth by W.W. Rostow. <em>Journal of Economic Issues, 6 (2)</em>, 166–7.</p><p>Shabad, T. (1959). China’s “Great Leap Forward”. <em>Far Eastern Survey, Vol. 28, №7</em>, 105–109.</p><p>Shen, Z., &amp; Xia, Y. (2011, September 14). The Great Leap Forward, the People’s Commune and the Sino-Soviet Split. <em>Journal of Contemporary China. Volume 20, 2011 — Issue 72</em>, 861–880.</p><p>von Kimakowitz, E. (2010). The Evolution of and Current Debate in Development Thinking: What Defines Good Development? <em>Humanistic Management Center Working Paper Series</em>.</p><p>Wilbur, C. M., &amp; Young, E. P. (2017, November 3). <em>War between Nationalists and communists</em>. Retrieved November 22, 2017, from Encyclopædia Britannica: <a href="https://www.britannica.com/place/China/War-between-Nationalists-and-communists">https://www.britannica.com/place/China/War-between-Nationalists-and-communists</a></p><p>World Bank. (2015). Retrieved 11 22, 2017, from Adjusted net national income (current US$): <a href="https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.ADJ.NNTY.CD?end=2015&amp;locations=CN&amp;start=1970">https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.ADJ.NNTY.CD?end=2015&amp;locations=CN&amp;start=1970</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a6934fc80963" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>