<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Dr. Jaime Hough on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Dr. Jaime Hough on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jaime-8502?source=rss-b8555247baa------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 20:27:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jaime-8502/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Retention: I Don’t Think It Means What You Think It Means]]></title>
            <link>https://jaime-8502.medium.com/retention-i-dont-think-it-means-what-you-think-it-means-bcaf6a1d7df1?source=rss-b8555247baa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bcaf6a1d7df1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[retention-strategies]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[retention]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-ed]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr. Jaime Hough]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 14 Jul 2022 14:47:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-07-14T14:47:37.417Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Not so long ago, at a university that shall remain anonymous, I was working for a program that allowed qualifying high school students to take college classes. Different universities were able to set different standards for what “qualifying” meant both for admission to and continuance in the program. At the university I worked for, a requirement for continuing admission was a cumulative GPA over 2.5. Below this level, the university judged, we were doing more harm than good to students by taking them away from their high school courses.</p><p>In this particular year, we had achieved a banner enrollment of 200 students which was the maximum we could take based on our faculty and course size commitments. Out of that 200 there were 15 students who had joined the program for the first time but had been unable to adjust to university courses and had GPAs below 2.5. Thus, 7.5% of our total students were sent back to their high schools so as not to jeopardize their education or graduation.</p><p>My boss’s boss was furious and demanded explanations that didn’t exist:</p><p><em>Did you reach out to the student to offer support?</em></p><p><em>Did the instructor reach out to offer support?</em></p><p><em>Did you contact the student and their advisor after mid-terms?</em></p><p><em>Why did this happen?</em></p><p>The answers were:</p><p>Yes, yes, yes, and because not everyone who is academically ready is also ready to manage their time independently and I cannot do their work for them.</p><p>This was framed as a retention crisis.</p><p>But a retention crisis for who?</p><p>Overwhelmingly, the students themselves, their parents, and their high school counselors were all happy to have the students return to the high school environment where they could excel rather than continue to struggle and do long term damage to their GPAs and future educational prospects.</p><p><strong>After many long meetings and emails in which no one could quite bring themselves to state the obvious the Vice Chancellor finally put it in writing: fifteen students leaving this program halfway through the year represented an unplanned budget shortfall. And there we have it: retention conflated with short term profit rather than long-term success.</strong></p><p>Although the above example has to do with a hyper-specific example of high school students, I have seen the same underlying principle at work with graduate students time and time again. I bet you have too.</p><p>After I left the job described above I ran my own business as an academic productivity coach specializing in all things graduate school from application to defense.</p><p>Now, I work for the Graduate College at the University of Oklahoma under the title “Director for Graduate Student and PostDoc Retention and Support.”</p><p>Given my job title, retention is something that is often on my mind. One of the core duties of my role is to provide coaching to graduate students who are struggling.</p><p>Since January of 2022, I have worked with three PhD students who have made the decision to leave their programs. While each of these students had different situations, the core of their story was the same: the goals they had come to graduate school with had changed, as goals often do, in response to time and experience.</p><p>The core mission of the Graduate College at OU is to help our students finish well. We interpret that to mean that our role is to help students meet their goals especially as those goals evolve throughout their time with us. We do not define or set goals for our students. They are more than capable of doing that. They are, after all, some of the most accomplished young professionals around. For some students that will be a PhD, for some it will be an MA, for others, it will be taking some enriching coursework to a new career.</p><p>When we say we want them to finish “well” we mean that we want them to do high-quality work without sacrificing their personal wellness.</p><p>But what does all of this have to do with retention?</p><p>Very simply, students will leave. For many reasons. Retention and support means we help them leave well.</p><p>Short-term retention thinking says that we want to keep graduate students and have them finish their degrees at all costs. After all, we’ve invested about 100K per year in the average graduate student through tuition waivers, stipend, access to resources and so on. Second, attrition numbers factor into our rankings and rankings factor into recruitment and donors and so on.</p><p>Short-term retention thinking says that we keep graduate students limping along in programs that are not a fit to maximize our investment in them.</p><p>Short-term retention thinking is the anti-thesis of a student-centered approach.</p><p>At OU, and in my office, we focus on long-term retention.</p><p>The core of long-term retention is acknowledging that students will leave at some point because they graduate or because their goals have changed.</p><p><strong>Long-term retention isn’t focused on when students leave but on how.</strong></p><p>When they talk about their time with us will they say, “Yes, I got my PhD there but I hated every minute of it. I only finished because I felt trapped and I wouldn’t recommend anyone go there.”</p><p>Or will they say, “I choose to leave the program but they showed me how to market the skills I’d gained. They cared about my success and I loved my time there. I’d recommend it to anyone.”</p><p><strong>Given the choice, I would rather students leave and think well of how we supported them than stay and feel that we failed them. This is not a pie-in-the-sky vision for graduate school. This is a vision core to our mission as research universities.</strong></p><p>The bulk of higher education in the United States takes place at land-grant universities whose purpose is to provide a benefit to the populace of that state. At OU our goal is simple, “We change lives.” We have a responsibility to the state of Oklahoma, broadly, and to our students, individually, to make sure that change is for the better.</p><p>From the moment they enter our classrooms, in-person or virtually, our graduate students are learning. They are learning the norms of their discipline. They are learning how much we value research or teaching. They are learning whether or not graduate school is good training for their goals.</p><p>For some students, the answer to that last question will become “no” but that does not negate either our mission or our responsibility to ensure that their experience is valuable and their skills beneficial.</p><p>Let us return, to my opening example, of those 15 high school students who were dismissed from the concurrent enrollment program. Of those 15 students, all of them graduated high school. Some of them, chose to enroll in a different concurrent program wisely noting that different institutional cultures can better support different styles of learners. Still others worked hard to improve their GPA to the required 3.5 for re-admission, and successfully completed the program at a later date.</p><p>Again, we can trace some parallels between this population and graduate students. Of those who choose to leave their program some will move on to other things, some will join another program, and some will come back when they are better equipped for success.</p><p>Retention is not short-term profit or keeping students on the rolls while their ABD.</p><p>Retention is about personal growth. Retention is generational. Retention is a long-game.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bcaf6a1d7df1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Modest Proposal for Contemporary America Relating to Reproductive Rights]]></title>
            <link>https://jaime-8502.medium.com/a-modest-proposal-for-contemporary-america-relating-to-reproductive-rights-6cb2f988b291?source=rss-b8555247baa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6cb2f988b291</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[second-amendment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reproductive-justice]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reproductive-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abortion]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr. Jaime Hough]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 May 2022 02:10:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-17T02:10:50.726Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qqDN3ezmgEm83iCJAOf7jw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Close up of U.S. flag</figcaption></figure><p><a href="https://www.gutenberg.org/files/1080/1080-h/1080-h.htm">A Modest Proposal</a> for Contemporary America Relating to Reproductive Rights</p><p>A recently leaked draft decision from the Supreme Court of the United States shows a <a href="https://www.politico.com/news/2022/05/02/supreme-court-abortion-draft-opinion-00029473">detailed plan</a> for overturning the landmark 1973 case Roe vs. Wade. Many of us viewed this moment as inevitable as revoking the right to a safe and legal abortion has been the stated goal of the Republican Party since the <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Broken-Words-Science-American-Politics-ebook/dp/B004J4WN6C/ref=sr_1_7?crid=31TXZITN11RCP&amp;keywords=broken+words+book&amp;qid=1652751842&amp;sprefix=broken+words+book%2Caps%2C182&amp;sr=8-7">1980’s</a>. With the aid of Republicans in Congress, the past president was able to appoint <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/01/13/how-trump-compares-with-other-recent-presidents-in-appointing-federal-judges/">three conservative judges</a> at least two of which had records which made their aims plain even if it <a href="https://www.npr.org/2022/05/03/1096108319/roe-v-wade-alito-conservative-justices-confirmation-hearings">contradicted</a> their testimony.</p><p>Many thinkers and organizers greater than myself have thought through the question of what a <a href="https://www.sevenstories.com/blogs/227-free-ebook-the-new-handbook-for-a-post-roe-america">post-Roe</a> United States would look like. Some states are poised to become <a href="https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2022/may/03/they-will-be-welcome-inslee-washington-democrats-o/">sanctuary states</a>, providing abortions to the privileged women of their region, while networks of on-ground activists are already dispensing instructions on how best to care for women who cannot travel for service.</p><p>Here I would like to propose what I believe will be the most equitable solution, applying alike to women from all socioeconomic statuses and races, and to which no red-blooded American could oppose.</p><p>With the advent of <a href="https://www.plannedparenthoodaction.org/issues/abortion/types-attacks/trap-laws">TRAP</a> laws, and state-level abortion prohibitions, even before this leaked draft several areas of the country, especially those in <a href="https://www.cms.gov/About-CMS/Agency-Information/OMH/equity-initiatives/rural-health/09032019-Maternal-Health-Care-in-Rural-Communities.pdf">rural</a>, agricultural, heartland communities, have had decreasing access to reproductive health care from sex education through child care. Reproductive health care that is available is often priced out of the range of the most vulnerable among us, whether it be the cost of birth control not covered by insurance or the travel costs of visiting a facility with staff explicitly trained in reproductive care.</p><p>These same communities have abundant access to the simplest solution possible. In fact, in my own grandparents’ house, I had access to at least five instruments of solution: guns.</p><p>Women who wish to abort and are no longer able to after the overturning of Roe, would be well-served by shooting themselves in the womb. In most cases, this would abort the fetus with several beneficial consequences besides. First, when a grown woman goes to a hospital to be treated for any concern, she is first asked to confirm that she is not pregnant. In many cases, if there is a possibility that she may be pregnant, a pregnancy test is administered before a course of treatment is enacted. In this case, the fetus can safely be presumed to be dead so the woman can receive treatment for her gunshot wound right away.</p><p>I do not mean to imply that a gunshot wound to the abdominal area is a small injury, but more doctors are trained in healing gunshot wounds than in recognizing the difficulties of pregnancy. For the past several years, the United States has been the only developed nation to have an increasing maternal <a href="https://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/issue-briefs/2020/nov/maternal-mortality-maternity-care-us-compared-10-countries">mortality rate</a>. The reasons for this are many, but, pregnancy and its after effects are increasingly a form of medical roulette in the U.S. when compared to the soon-to-be-outlawed and <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4554338/">overwhelmingly safe</a> procedure of abortion. Knowing this, a gunshot wound is merely a risk of a different kind and one <a href="https://everytownresearch.org/report/guns-and-violence-against-women-americas-uniquely-lethal-intimate-partner-violence-problem/">too many women</a> already face.</p><p>Second, many women seek abortions because they are not financially able to support the child. The cost for emergency care after a <a href="https://www.thetrace.org/2017/10/gun-violence-healthcare-cost-research-hospital/">gunshot</a> is significantly less than all the costs of a healthy <a href="https://www.whattoexpect.com/pregnancy/pregnancy-costs/">pregnancy</a> from hospital bill to regular prenatal appointments and would be more financially feasible. In addition, women who need financial assistance to care for their children receive <a href="https://www.fns.usda.gov/wic">WIC</a> funds from the taxpayer but women recovering from gunshot wounds receive no extra aid from the state. Therefore, the American taxpayer would save money on this proposal as well.</p><p>Similarly, for women who seek abortions because they are unable to guarantee the health of the child due to substance abuse or poor living conditions, this solution would also serve.</p><p>Opponents may argue that, even in this solution, the states or the federal government could seek to criminalize women who shoot themselves to end a pregnancy. I have two answers to this. First, this would not be a vast change as women have already been jailed for naturally occurring <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-59214544">miscarriages</a> so the punishment would be no worse. However, this is highly unlikely to happen because <a href="https://everytownresearch.org/report/guns-and-violence-against-women-americas-uniquely-lethal-intimate-partner-violence-problem/">women are shot</a> at an <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/intimatepartnerviolence/fastfact.html">enormous rate</a> by their intimate partners and those partners often face no enforceable, long-term consequences either in jail time or restricting them from <a href="https://www.everytown.org/what-is-the-boyfriend-loophole/">gun ownership</a>. Surely, a country that has not objected to men shooting women, <a href="https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/ohio-incel-charged-hate-crime-plotting-sorority-mass-shooting-officials-n1274673">often</a> <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Isla_Vista_killings">en masse</a>, cannot object to a woman’s right to shoot herself? To do so would mean enacting sweeping gun reform limiting where guns could be bought and who could own them which is not something the United States is capable of doing.</p><p>Those who believe that the fetus is a child may be tempted to argue that a woman shooting herself while carrying a child is attempted murder of said child but that woman would be doing nothing that <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_school_shootings_in_the_United_States_by_death_toll">dozens</a> of school shooters have not already done. Indeed, if we allow women to terminate their pregnancies by shooting themselves we may finally be able to feel for women who don’t want to carry a pregnancy to term the same swell of compassion we feel for young white men who shoot others.</p><p>Finally, many will object that, despite the better availability of care throughout the United States for victims of gun violence, there is no guarantee of life. This is inarguable, but it must also be put in context. At least in death a woman would be afforded the full bodily autonomy of a corpse. Abortion activists have long pointed out that we cannot take tissue or organs from a corpse to save a person’s life and that living women ought to have the same autonomy. It is clear, then, that a woman who shoots herself to terminate a pregnancy would be advancing in death to a full bodily autonomy no living women in the United States is guaranteed.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6cb2f988b291" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Get Out. Right Now. End Your PhD.]]></title>
            <link>https://jaime-8502.medium.com/get-out-right-now-end-your-phd-86e4189688d4?source=rss-b8555247baa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/86e4189688d4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[graduate-school]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[phd]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[phd-student]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dissertation]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr. Jaime Hough]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Mar 2021 20:38:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-19T20:38:33.535Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2tw6qEa8ckyO35CcHOTgTw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Drinking coffee during an abd2phd webinar.</figcaption></figure><p>As a dissertation coach I follow a number of groups for graduate students on social media and whatever the ostensible purpose of the group is — from career coaching, kvetching, or seeking support from people like you — one of the most popular questions is a version of: I don’t like getting my PhD — is it worth it to stay?</p><p>No. In case you were wondering, the answer, nine times out of ten, is a resounding “no.”</p><p>I became a dissertation coach to help other people avoid the mistakes I made and provide the support I needed during my PhD journey. I work with people who want to finish their PhDs but have been failed by the system. They come to me for the support they should be getting from their institutions.</p><p>I have never advised a client to quit their PhD because I have never had a client that I believe, in all honesty, <em>should</em> quit their PhD.</p><p>That said, as someone who has spent over half of my adult life in some version of university, and spent almost a decade getting my graduate degrees — I can tell you with absolute confidence that most of the people getting a PhD really, really shouldn’t.</p><p>I am continually amazed how, in candid conversations with graduate students and faculty, many of them reveal that they hate most of their job.</p><p>A traditional professorial job as tenure-track faculty has three main components: research, writing, teaching.</p><p>Most of the academics I know viscerally hate two of these things, if not all three.</p><p>Some folks have compared academia to a cult, and it’s easy to see why when people are paying a huge opportunity cost, as well as a steep personal cost, to pursue a job that they don’t even like.</p><p>I honestly can’t tell you what it is about the idea of a tenure-track professor that causes this behavior, but I can tell you this: life is so, so short.</p><p>It is too damn short to spend seven years (the average time it takes to get a PhD) doing things you don’t like just to get a job that involves doing . . . more of those things you don’t like.</p><p>Although I have met academics who hate every major component of their job it is much more common to meet people who really love one aspect of academic jobs and hate the other two.</p><p>It’s not enough.</p><p>If you love research there are many, many jobs out there that will pay you to do research without the stuff that you dislike. They will often pay you more than academia and, given the changes to tenure we’ve seen in the past decade, you have just about as much job security.</p><p>I know someone whose whole job is to research everything possible about a subject assigned to him by consulting clients. He loves doing deep dives into subjects and he loves the variety of things he learns about. I know someone else whose job is to research emerging policies around reproductive justice. Even I, who mostly runs a one-woman-show of a business, periodically hires freelance researchers to help me with large projects.</p><p>Similarly, if what you really love is writing there are a million opportunities for you. I know one woman who makes six figures a year selling erotic short stories on Amazon and I know another woman in cybersecurity who says her English BA is her most important skill because she writes papers all day, every day. It turns out that writers, like researchers, are needed in almost every industry. If you love writing, academia is far from the only place you can do it.</p><p>Opportunities are always expanding for people who genuinely like teaching. I have friends who are very well paid to teach AP classes at bougie high schools but I also have friends who make bank using their course design skills to create corporate trainings. Resources like <a href="https://www.teacherspayteachers.com/">teacherspayteachers</a>, online course platforms, and offering specialty workshops for interested groups are all good ways to make money for folks who love teaching but couldn’t give a fig about writing or research.</p><p>There are many dissertation coaches out there. My clients come to me, specifically, because they want the holistic approach I provide. Your dissertation does not exist in isolation. It is one of many parts of your life. When I meet with my clients, we talk about every aspect of their life, so that we can fit dissertation progress in among every thing else they are doing. Pretending that the only thing they have to do is dissertate leads to unrealistic plans which leads to missed deadlines and frustration.</p><p>An important part of holistic coaching is the simplest question: are you happy?</p><p>Part of why I insist on asking my clients whether or not they are happy is because two people very close to me died during my PhD. Death, of course, raises big questions about life and what we’re doing with it. It is an invitation to think over the lives of those who have passed as well as our own and the one thing I can tell you is that life is too short to hate your job.</p><p>If you are thinking of getting a PhD because you were always a good student then you should get an MA instead. PhD work is about producing knowledge while most BA and MA work is about consuming knowledge. They are two totally different processes and liking, or being good at, one does not ensure you will feel that way about the other.</p><p>If you are currently in a PhD program because you like the flexibility of the schedule or helping people from your own communities succeed, well, it turns out there are lots of ways to do that. For instance, I currently set my own schedule helping academics who are predominately women with adhd — like me. Before that, I advised primarily working-class students at a satellite campus of a state university. In other words, I helped students from my community and had a damn good time doing it AND made a salary that let me support causes I care about.</p><p>If you are currently in a PhD program and realizing that you don’t like researching, writing, and teaching then it’s probably time to get out.</p><p>If, like an alarming number of my professors, you are currently in a PhD program because you didn’t know what else to do after college then it’s probably time to get out.</p><p>If you are currently in a PhD program because somehow your whole identity got wrapped up in being “the smart one” (like mind did) then it’s probably time to get out.</p><p>There are lots of jobs that will let you learn, lots of ways to be smart, and we are all finding our way one misstep at a time.</p><p>Let me end by saying this: although I originally started my PhD because I had gotten my self-worth all tangled up in being “smart” I finished it because I found that I loved the work.</p><p>I did not always love the working conditions but on a solid 80% of my days in a PhD program I went to bed feeling blessed to do the work I love — researching, writing, and teaching.</p><p>I have never advised a client to leave their PhD program because the clients who come to me need help to do something they love.</p><p>This is not to say that love of the job should make you willing to put up with low wages, bad contracts, or faculty bullies. When getting a PhD love of what you are doing is necessary but not sufficient.</p><p>With all of that said, if you don’t love two out of the three major components of your job, then it’s time to get out.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=86e4189688d4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I think about that phrase a lot.]]></title>
            <link>https://jaime-8502.medium.com/i-think-about-that-phrase-a-lot-e0ee5eedfd2?source=rss-b8555247baa------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e0ee5eedfd2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[phd-student]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[academic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[higher-ed]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dissertation-help]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[phd]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Dr. Jaime Hough]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Dec 2020 00:02:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-09T00:02:28.505Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_LQkL9hQp69YtJ-OSpPL4g.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote><strong>Who Defines Harm? Real Talk About Abusive Advisors and an Abusive System</strong></blockquote><p>I think about that phrase a lot. It’s part of the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hippocrates">foundation</a> of Western medicine. It’s part of the foundation of the Western <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Academy">academy</a>.</p><p>I wonder, though, who gets to determine what constitutes harm?</p><p>For instance, J. Marion Sims, considered the “<a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/04/j-marion-sims/558248/">father of modern gynecology</a>” practiced the techniques for which he became famous on slaves without anesthesia under the belief that black people could not feel pain.</p><p>Take a moment and imagine, if you will, the mental barriers one has to erect to vivisect a live human being and convince yourself that they are not in pain. Imagine then, if you were the man who had successfully barricaded your mind against seeing clear evidence of harm, or even humanity, in your subjects how you would record your practice for others. You would not note, for instance, their screams of pain. You would, perhaps, write that the subjects you worked with are strangely reluctant to undergo medical procedures that directly benefit them. To be fair to Sims, we need to position him within the history of women’s health more broadly. For thousands of years what passed as official medical knowledge was the idea that women might not be fully human, with wandering organs that made them do crazy things. Medical practices known to benefit women by decreasing their death in childbirth were ignored for decades because male doctors didn’t think it was important. In other words, they didn’t see a harm there.</p><p>Defenders of Sims’ legacy have argued that, “To implicate him . . . is to implicate medicine in mid-19th century America.”</p><p>If you’ve stuck with me this far you may rightly be wondering, what does any of this have to do with getting a PhD or dissertation advisors?</p><p>To answer that question, let’s look at some of the similarities between the modern medical field and academia.</p><p>Both an MD/DO and PhD are terminal degrees. Trainees in each field are required to pay a huge opportunity cost through extended, expensive years in schooling while often paying a personal cost such as less time with family, chronic stress, or decreased health. The training for both professions (at least the Western incarnation of both professions) is rooted in an exclusive practice where male actors have, historically, gotten most of the credit and acclaim while the contributions of women and people of color have been overlooked. In both professions, you practice as a professional for years before being recognized by your community as a such. The human cost of pursuing each degree is often written into a narrative of rigor where the harsh conditions of the program theoretically weed out trainees who can’t “hack it.” After years of training and harsh conditions trainees finally earn the right to the title and, hopefully, a place in the profession.</p><p>Looking at both of these professions side-by-side, I would argue that what passes as “normal professionalization” in each field contains quite a bit of harm that participants at every level are trained to see as something other than what it clearly is.</p><p>All of this is not just a rambling diatribe (I mean, it is that, too), but a necessary prelude to understanding abusive advisors.</p><p>Abusive advisors are supposed to exist as a small minority in distinction to the vast majority of advisors who occupy a range between fine and great.</p><p>It’s hard to overestimate how important advisors are to whether or not a graduate student successfully makes the journey from consumer of knowledge to producer of knowledge, from student to doctor, from temporary employment to permanent employment. In my MA program it was common practice to refer to your academic “family.” You advisor occupied the role of parent. The other students being overseen by your advisor were your academic siblings while your advisor’s advisor was your academic grandparent.</p><p>I shy away from analogies that construct graduate students as children because those analogies are, of themselves, part of the toxic culture of graduate school in which the contributions of accomplished professionals are minimized until and unless they finish the degree. However, in terms of raw power, I don’t know if anything conveys the actual and perceived power that academic advisors have over their students better than this analogy. Like a parent, your academic advisor has the power to make you part of a lineage or to exclude you from it. Like a family, your academic advisor and your fellow advisees shape a large part of who you become both professionally and personally. There is one other way in which this troublesome analogy may be of use.</p><p>The law recognizes that parents can abuse their children through neglect. In fact, we have laws on the books that protect children, the elderly, and the disabled from abuse via neglect. We even have a legal standard, “duty of care,” that applies to corporations (a.k.a did the corporation take reasonable steps to protect a consumer from harm).</p><p>In other words, we, as a society, have enshrined in law the common-sense notion that there are cases where neglect, in and of itself, constitutes harm. In most of these cases, neglect constitutes harm because one party (the caregiver or the corporation) has significant power over the life and safety of the person they are serving.</p><p>Your academic advisor does not actually have control over your life and, at least in the humanities, they rarely have control over your physical safety. However, they can have a great deal of influence over your mental health and your income — and all that is <a href="https://health.usnews.com/health-news/patient-advice/articles/2016-04-20/the-countless-ways-poverty-affects-peoples-health">correlated with it</a>.</p><p>Therefore, before we talk about abusive advisors we need to talk about the perpetuation of harm by well-intentioned actors.</p><p>I’ve come to believe that most advisors are harmful advisors.</p><p>This isn’t to say that most advisors are bad people. Just like the grad students they so consistently fail to serve, they are people caught in a bad system being asked to do ever more with less.</p><p>While there are, undoubtedly, bad actors who are malicious and harmful, the far larger problem comes back to who gets to define what counts as harm.</p><p>Even the best of advisors are torn between their own research, teaching, service-work, family life, and personal needs. Advisees have to find a space in the middle of all of that meaning that each individual advisee is often left with a sliver of their advisor’s time. This fictional advisor isn’t a bad person. This is a bad system in which there is almost no option for your average academic advisor to give the necessary attention but given the power differential between a dissertation advisor and a PhD student this sort of necessary neglect constitutes a real harm to the graduate student. It is not the harm of an outright abusive advisor, nor is it necessarily the harm of missed deadlines or poor feedback.</p><p>The harm, I argue, consists in the opportunity cost these graduate students pay, the deep grief in losing a part of their identity when they unwillingly leave academia, the toll on their health from near-poverty level stipends, and the gap on their resume that they may struggle to explain to employers.</p><p>Even in the best cases, I have seen harried professors often give incomplete or contradictory advice to their equally harried grad students. These harms don’t even begin to touch on the missed opportunities for the mentorship and sponsorship that we all go into graduate school hoping for.</p><p>“First, do no harm,” is an inadequate injunction for care. Our advisors, even all the good ones, are doing harm because they are trapped in a bad system that creates a monumental power difference and then necessitates neglect of the dependents all in the name of cheap labor and the life of the mind.</p><p>What we need, when we think about advisors, especially abusive advisors, is to recognize the ways in which the current incarnation of the system itself is abusive.</p><p>If you came to this post because you feel like you are being abused but you feel conflicted because your advisor is a genuinely kind, caring person who just doesn’t have enough time then don’t let anybody gaslight you.</p><p>Even if your advisor isn’t abusive the system is.</p><p>There are a lot of proposals on how to fix the system and I’ll let you Google them when you can’t sleep because graduate school gave you anxiety which gave you insomnia. However, if you are ABD right now and you want to get those other three letters one of the best things you can do for yourself is be honest about the system you’re in.</p><p>Let me be very clear: I’m not writing this piece to indict dissertation advisors. They are almost as trapped as their students, if not more so. (I mean, sure, they have a salary but they also have many more years invested in the system and a longer resume gap to explain if they want to leave.)</p><p>If critiquing dissertation advisors as dangerously neglectful of their PhD students means indicting the whole system then let’s burn this mother down.</p><p>First, though, let’s try and get everyone out of the building. To that end, the rest of this post is dedicated to helping PhD students identify whether or not their advisor is actively abusive and, if they are, giving you tips on how to work with or around them.</p><p>Talking about abusive advisors is hard for a lot of reasons. In researching for this post I spent a lot of time googling variations of “signs of an abusive relationship.” The overwhelming majority of my results were signs of an abusive romantic relationship.</p><p>When we, in the US, talk about abusive relationships, we tend to default to romantic relationships. Even when we talk about abuse of power in workplace settings it often has to do with leveraging differences in power to take advantage of a subordinate sexually.</p><p>I sometimes fear that our concept of abuse is so rooted in a conception of romantic/sexual abuse that it leaves graduate students who are experiencing other types of abuse from their advisors without a vocabulary to articulate what is happening.</p><p>Another reason why talking about abusive advisors is so difficult is because when trying to discern whether or not a romantic partner is abusive there is an expected set of standards of normal behavior and there is abuse. For instances, all couples fight but it’s definitely abusive if one partner hits another.</p><p>With PhD advisors it’s different. The very job definition of a PhD advisor is to critique your work. Everybody’s advisor is critiquing them. If your advisor’s critique makes you feel terrible for days you are more likely to wonder if that’s a problem with you. If you tentatively ask faculty you trust whether or not your advisor’s feedback should make you feel this way you’re likely to be told that you need to toughen up</p><p>In the rest of this piece I’ve adapted 15 <a href="https://www.huffpost.com/entry/early-signs-of-an-abusive-relationship_b_588e6c63e4b06364bb1e2730?guccounter=1">early signs of an abusive relationship</a> from a romantic context to an academic context along with realistic advice about what you can and can’t do if you find yourself stuck with an abusive advisor. You can also check out the excellent list compiled by Dr. Chanda Prescod-Weinstein here on Medium.</p><p>Without further ado~</p><p><strong>1. Love Bombing.</strong> Love bombing is where an abuser showers their intended victim with praise and attention. The HuffPo article above states, “They will tell you you’re unlike anyone else they’ve ever met.” While a graduate advisor may not love bomb you in a romantic sense — wooing you with flowers, dinners, and comments on your physical appearance — they may love bomb you with the things academics value — promises of publications and prestigious introductions. They may tell you that you are the most brilliant grad student they’ve ever had and that you’ll go far together. Love bombing is, by its very nature, incredibly seductive. So, how do you tell if you really are the most brilliant grad student your advisor has worked with in a decade or whether or not they are love-bombing you? Look to how other graduate students in your program relate to them. The clearest instance of love-bombing I’ve ever encountered is when an abusive advisor was taking on first-year PhD students while her senior grad student was still in the program. In her case, love bombing took the form of telling her new graduate students not to listen to her veteran student because they were special and much more qualified than he was. They wouldn’t have the problems he had with her because they were special, unlike him.</p><p><strong>2. Monitoring.</strong> In a romantic relationship this often takes the form of wanting to know who you are hanging out with and where you are and what you’re doing. In an academic relationship this can be an advisor who wants to know what courses you’re taking, what conferences you’re going to, and who you’re talking to at those conferences. Again, part of the problem with recognizing abusive advisors is that the behavior of an abusive advisor is not fundamentally different from the behavior of a good advisor. A good advisor will probably want to know what classes you are taking (some programs will make your advisor sign off on your classes or research hours). A good advisor will want to know what conferences you’re going to and may recommend panels to attend or people to seek out at those conferences. The difference really comes in intention and tone which can be incredibly hard both for victims and observers to pick up on. A good advisor will listen to your reasons for attending X conference. They may make recommendations such as “don’t go to any conferences in the final year of your dissertation — just focus on finishing” but they will treat you as an intelligent person making decisions about your future career. In contrast, an abusive advisor will always approach you from the perspective that (a) you are an idiot who could not survive without them and (b) your behavior reflects on them. An example would be a PhD student I know who went to his field’s major conference. As an aspiring academic professional should do he went to the book room and chatted to several publishers. He happened to talk to the publisher that had published his advisor’s book. Although he did not seek to drop her name it organically came up in conversation with the publishing representative. The publishing rep said they would be very interested in publishing the grad student’s dissertation when he was done writing it. For any rational grad student and advisor this would be a huge win and the next steps would be talking about how to stay in touch with the publisher and how to think about restructuring the dissertation for a book proposal. Instead, when the publishing rep told the advisor that he’d ran into her talented student she angrily emailed the student and told him not to talk to people she knew without her permission and that he had horribly embarrassed her. The grad student agonized for weeks about what he had done or said wrong to the publishing rep. In reality, he hadn’t done anything wrong. He had done exactly what a grad student should do but his abusive advisor saw his actions as a reflection on her professional reputation and wanted to both monitor and control who he talked to and how. This also relates to the next abuse tactic.</p><p><strong>3. Isolating.</strong> Abusers always seek to isolate their victims because abuse only functions in an environment of deep shame. If you have a strong support network they’ll remind you that you don’t need your abuser’s shit and help you figure out ways to get out of the situation. This is why one of the first things any abuser does is isolate you. In romantic relationships this often takes the form of explosive jealousy when you spend time with other people, picking fights with your friends, encouraging you to quit your job or move away from your family. I think this is one of the abuse tactics that looks the most different in an academic setting. For starters, the structure of grad school is isolating in and of itself. You’ve often moved far away from your established support network and you may be financially dependent on the institution and, therefore, on maintaining your advisor’s favor.</p><p>Moreover, the process of academic specialization is, in and of itself, isolating. By the time you’re ABD the world of relevant experts for the academic field you’re in is astonishingly small. This can mean that, if you realize you have an abusive advisor, your options to switch are small and, in some cases, nonexistent. Apart from the isolating structure of graduate school, though, individual abusers may try and isolate you but it won’t be by picking fights with your friends. Instead, they may refuse to work with certain other faculty as part of your committee. It never ceases to amaze me how many academic professionals are willing and eager to be sycophants. I know of more than one case where an abusive advisor would refuse to allow anyone on the committee who wasn’t part of their cult of personality. This, of course, defeats the very purpose of having a committee in the first place. The role of a committee is to ensure that you are earning your PhD and not receiving, or being denied it, unfairly. When an abusive advisor fills a committee with people devoted to them it further isolates the student by ensuring that your success is dependent on keeping your advisor happy (and it usually results in some group gaslighting or backlash if the student dares to mention their concerns to someone on the committee). Abusers also seek to isolate by taking control of the narrative. For instance, they may mention, or may hint that they’ve mentioned, to other professor’s in the department that you are a difficult student. This sense that your advisor has poisoned the well can keep students from looking for alternatives. One old chestnut that carries over in all abusive situations is the abusers contention that no one else would put up with you except the abuser. Abusive adviors will contend that no other professor would put up with your procrastination/writing/email salutation/teaching load/family situation/insert random normal thing here.</p><p><strong>4. Shoulding.</strong> The <a href="https://www.huffpost.com/entry/early-signs-of-an-abusive-relationship_b_588e6c63e4b06364bb1e2730">HuffPo </a>article I’m pulling from for this list says, “Comments about how you should or shouldn’t cut your hair, whom you should see, what job you should take, how you should speak, etc. are an indication that your partner believes he knows more than you do about yourself and your life.” Uh, so, this dynamic is pretty much the premise of all PhD advising.</p><p>So, what’s the difference between when this behavior is normal and when it’s abusive? A good advisor will see you as a young professional in your own right — someone who knows what they’re doing but may need a little guidance from time to time. They’ll give you advice to make your life easier or better. For instance, there were a lot of times that my advisor asked me questions I absolutely hated. However, as I wrestled with them I realized that they made my thinking clearer and my argument better. It wasn’t exactly pleasant but it was both well-intentioned and based on the premise that I was an adult who could deal with complicated questions. In contrast, an abusive advisor will talk to you and treat you like you are an idiot child who could not survive without their beneficent help. An abusive advisor uses “should” like a weapon saying things like, “Congratulations on your book review but you really <em>should</em> be working on an article” or “Instead of wasting your time on conferences you <em>should</em> be writing.” The point of this abusive shoulding isn’t to help you but to make you feel like everything you think and do is always-already wrong. This is an important part of instilling the shame that’s critical to an abusive relationship. A good tell of an abusive dynamic is if your advisor is shaming you for normal behavior. However, to know what “normal” is for graduate students you need to be in regular contact with your peers which can be difficult if your abusive advisor has isolated you from the department.</p><p><strong>5. Permission.</strong> Abuse isn’t logical. For abusers there is absolutely no conflict in telling you that you should do something and then getting mad at you for not asking permission before doing that thing. Forcing you to ask for permission by explicitly telling you that you have to or by getting mad when you don’t is a method of isolation. Remember the grad student I mentioned earlier whose advisor wanted him to ask permission for who he could talk to at conferences? That’s a perfect example of this type of control. There are other advisors who will tell you not to approach other faculty about being on your committee until they say you’re ready or not to send your article into a journal until they approve it. This is, of course, a trap. They will either (a) never give you permission (b) force you to do the thing without permission and then get mad at you or © only give you permission when they feel they can control the results or the narrative.</p><p>You, my dear readers, are all very smart people and so I’m sure you’ve already noticed that the common them of all five of these examples is control. These are all strategies to control your behavior in one way or another and, through controlling your behavior, to isolate you. The next set of abusive behaviors we’ll look at are also about power and control but focus, instead, on controlling how you think about the situation you’re in.</p><p><strong>6. Us against Them.</strong> Control and manipulation are hallmarks of abuse. “Us against them” is a little different. In an “us against them” dynamic the abuser preys on the sympathy of the graduate student. It’s important to note that the results of the “us against them” dynamic are the same as other types of abuse. An advisor who positions themselves as the victim — of departmental politics, of jealous colleagues, of vindictive journal editors, of disciplinary guidelines — is not a good advisor. Even if they aren’t abusive they probably aren’t the kind of person who can give you the skills you need to navigate the academic workplace. So, how can you tell if your advisor is just inept or abusive? There are a couple of tells here.</p><p>First, do you find yourself being isolated as a result? Does this “us against them” rhetoric cut you off from other people in your department or field before you’ve had a chance to judge them for yourself? Second, does your advisor seem displeased when you try and meet new people? Third, does it seem like they low-key want to be in feuds with everyone? That is, when you tentatively propose solutions or work arounds do they discount them or even become hostile? The thing about the “us against them” tactic is that, eventually, you will see through it and once you do the person using this rhetoric will discard you. In the case of a PhD advisor that doesn’t necessarily mean cutting off the relationship entirely but it might mean ignoring your emails, not responding to your drafts, and never having time for you. Don’t be surprised, once you’ve seen the light, if you find out that you have moved from the “us” to the “them” in your advisor’s world view and become one of the many people s/he counts as an adversary.</p><p><strong>7. Hot/Cold.</strong> This is just what it sounds like. The abuser will turn cold and distant when you don’t do the right thing before running hot, perhaps even <a href="http://abd2phd.com/2019/06/06/5-signs-of-an-abusive-advisor/">love bombing</a> you, when you’ve done the “right” thing. Part of what’s so insidious about this tactic is that it acts as random reinforcement which can be incredibly <a href="http://psychopathsandlove.com/intermittent-reinforcement/">addictive</a> (think gambling). I’ve seen this play out in a couple of ways among PhD candidates and their advisors.</p><p>The first way is pretty straightforward. The advisor runs hot and cold for no discernible reason to anyone outside of the abuser’s mind. It keeps their advisee disoriented and trying to guess at what behavior incurred their advisor’s wrath and what generated their blessings. It also keeps the student from getting fed up with constant negative feedback and running away. The second way I’ve seen this play out is with narcissistic advisors who could care less about a given grad student as long as they are average (e.g. teaching, researching, doing the thing) but are right there to shower the grad student with praise and be part of all their photos when they win an award or get published.</p><p><strong>8. Manufacturing Jealousy.</strong> This technique is what you would get if you mashed the previous two together. Some advisors will pick a student or two who can do no wrong and will spare no effort or expense on their behalf. In contrast, the rest of their students get the cold shoulder and the bare minimum of effort (often after having to beg for it). This is more than just some advisors get on better with certain students. That’s just human. In the cases I’m talking about the advisor uses blatant favoritism as a weapon both to ensure that they always have a few students who will defend them against allegations of bad advising and to use as an offer of reward to the rest of their students. The implicit offer is that if you could just do “something” like the golden students you too could be part of the chosen. It’s a powerful motivator and a good way to get a lot of hard work out of people. Some advisors aren’t this consistent, though, and their “golden student” will rotate based on who won the last award, turned in the latest draft, or some other arbitrary criteria in their head. The results are pretty much the same. You get a bunch of grad students who don’t trust each other enough to band together and ask for better treatment and you get students motivated by the need to get that inconsistent reward so they work ever harder.</p><p><strong>9. Constant Togetherness.</strong> Okay, this is a rare one because of the nature of academia. It would be incredibly noticeable and weird for you to live with your advisor and spend all your time with them. However, there are a few signs that your advisor might be demanding too much of your time. For instance, do they seem to get offended if you don’t take or TA for their class? Do they constantly want to present at conferences together? Do they not want you to take on commitments they can’t be part of (like being an officer in your program’s graduate student organization)? Do they refuse to let you send your drafts to other people or hint that they wouldn’t like it if you did? Do they disparage publishing opportunities in which they don’t co-author?</p><p>A good advisor will certainly try and professionalize you by recommending conferences in your field or having you TA for their class. The hallmark of when this becomes harmful is if it seems like it’s less about professionalization and more about controlling you. Students who experience this type of demand for their constant time and energy may find out later that their advisor was taking credit for their work. It shouldn’t happen, but it does, and making sure that the two of you are seen together as often as possible can help blur the lines between who came up with what idea in the broader discipline. After all, if you both presented at the same 5 conferences together and published 2 papers then who really came up with that idea, you know? The grad student or the professor? Hint: The professor always wins this game.</p><p><strong>10. “Starting Over” together.</strong> This one is also very different in academic settings compared to romantic ones. In academia your research is your life. Asking you to start a new life is less about moving to a new place and more about asking you to start a new topic at a time when doing so would be not just difficult but harmful. For instance, after you are ABD. If your advisor is asking you to significantly change your topic post-prospectus then talk to other grad students and faculty you trust (possibly those at other institutions) before committing to any big changes. I’ve seen advisor’s string PhD students along for years by letting them make significant progress and then suggesting changes that are just big enough to not seem outrageous but add an extra year or two to the project. Nobody needs that shit. You know your project and where it needs to go. Trust. This might be a sign that it’s time to get a new advisor who will support the project you have.</p><p><strong>11. Picking Fights.</strong> One of the most important things to know about abusers is that all abusers are bullies and all bullies are cowards.</p><p>Read that again.</p><p><em>All abusers are bullies and all bullies are cowards.</em></p><p>Bullies never, ever pick on someone they think might be able to fight back in any way. This is why <a href="http://abd2phd.com/2019/06/13/5-more-signs-of-an-abusive-advisor/">isolation</a> and <a href="http://abd2phd.com/2019/06/06/5-signs-of-an-abusive-advisor/">shame</a> are so critical to the cycle of abuse. If you aren’t isolated and/or ashamed then you might have the ability to stand up for yourself or have someone else stand up for you.</p><p>One of the ways that abusers find their victims is by picking fights. They start small. For instance, let’s say you miss a deadline you set with your advisor to turn in a chapter draft. A normal advisor will respond to this, even if they’re annoyed by it, with something like, “Thanks for your draft. Since it’s a little late I may be delayed in getting you revisions. I’ll aim to have revisions to you by [DATE].” Another normal response might be along the lines of, “I’ve noticed your last few drafts have been a little late. Would it be helpful to push out our future deadlines by a week or two to give you more time?” Or, “Would it be helpful to meet and talk about writing process?”</p><p>An abusive response is along the lines of, “If you can’t meet the deadlines you set for your chapters you should really think about whether or not you belong in this profession.” An abusive response is, “I don’t know if I can work with someone who can’t meet their deadlines.”</p><p>In the normal response your advisor notices that you are struggling with deadlines and offers to find a way to help. This is part of the professionalization process. In contrast, the abusive advisor belittles you in ways that threaten your livelihood (by raising the specter of you being kicked out of graduate school or losing funding or their precious recommendation) and focuses on punishing you rather than helping you.</p><p>The point of these fights, from the abuser’s point of view, is to see how much you will take. The tests themselves don’t make sense. In the example above, the abusive response is not only out of line in terms of normal boss-employee relationship but particularly out of line in an academic context. Academics are late all the time. We tend to be terrible with deadlines. Academic deadlines are commonly understood by academic professionals to be aspirational. There are, of course, exceptions to this rule, but, generally, if you miss a deadline with your advisor there’s a strong chance they will be so busy missing their own deadlines with publishers, editors, etcetera, that they won’t even notice.</p><p>The only way to deal with this behavior from your advisor is to stand up for yourself. For instance, let’s say you get one of the abusive responses above. An appropriate response would be something like, “I understand your frustration and apologize for my tardiness with this draft. I look forward to your feedback when you have time.” Keep it short. Keep it simple. Keep it saved.</p><p>If you think your advisor might be showing some early signs of abusive behavior try and get as much info as you can in writing and Save. Everything. Save it in your email, save it on a flash drive, save it on your hard drive. Just save it.</p><p><strong>12. Violence of any kind.</strong> This one is, in my observation, more rare in academic circles, but the advice is pretty simple. If your advisor is violent in any way — if they physically intimidate you, throw things during your meetings, rip up drafts, or do anything that makes you feel physically unsafe you need to leave as soon and as quickly as possible.</p><p><strong>13. Criticism.</strong> From the Huffington Post article cited above, “Abusers tend to be messy perfectionists. They want the world and everyone around them to be perfect, but their own minds are a mess . . . They want to talk about what everyone else is doing wrong.”</p><p>Sooooooooooo . . . That’s kind of the definition of most academics and academic work . . .</p><p>Because really, truly, <a href="http://abd2phd.com/2019/04/17/harm/">the whole damn system is abusive</a>.</p><p>So, how do you know if you’re advisor’s criticism is what passes for normal in the academic system or has crossed a line?</p><p>The first clue is how the criticism makes you feel. If you feel worthless after receiving criticism from your advisor then that may be a sign that their feedback has crossed a line. A lot of academics I know, particularly first-generation PhDs, women, and people of color tend to assume that if the feedback they are receiving makes them feel bad it’s because they need to “toughen up.” It’s some internalized boot-strap shit, of which I am the reigning queen.</p><p>Let me just say this: If you are a woman, a person of color, a first generation PhD, disabled/chronically ill, or some combination of the above your very presence in a PhD program is proof that you are tough as diamonds and strong as titanium. You wouldn’t be here otherwise. You’ve overcome obstacles most people don’t ever even see. You’ve torn yourself in two to fit in with “academic expectations” and your community of origin. You aren’t easily intimidated or overwhelmed so if your advisor makes you feel bad it’s a good sign that they’re trying to.</p><p>If you need more proof that your advisor’s criticism has veered from helpful to hurtful check in with what they’re criticizing. Are they criticizing the argument, the project, or the person? The function of an advisor is to critique your argument. This might mean questioning your sources, your theoretical feedback, your analyses, the organization — anything about the argument itself. The purpose of this critique is supposed to be to challenge you and make your argument better. This is good critique.</p><p>If your advisor is criticizing your project you might have a problem. If you are already ABD and your advisor decides *now* to have a big issue with your project then something is wrong. Being ABD means that you’ve been through your prelims and prospectus. If your advisor had a major criticism of the project itself it should have come up sometime during this process. To be fair to both sides, I know some people who have some bananas projects. I know one person who is working on a dissertation about comic books and their big, controversial claim is that classic US comic characters and story arcs are heavily influenced by the Jewish-immigrant experience. Which, yes? Comic book authors and industry experts have talked about this. It’s not exactly a hot-take. HOWEVER, even though the project might not be the most innovative, this person’s committee signed off on it by passing their prospectus. At this point, any suggested major overhauls of the project are out of bounds because the committee signed off on the project as is. All of that said, criticism of your project at this stage could just mean that your advisor is oblivious rather than malicious.</p><p>The real tell is if your advisor criticizes <em>you</em>. If your advisor ever makes you feel stupid or like you don’t belong in your program then their critique has crossed the line into abuse.</p><p>This is often a death-by-a-thousand-cuts type of situation. A lot of times, we make the mistake of thinking that something has to be big and dramatic, like someone screaming at you that you don’t belong in the program. Often, it’s more subtle than that with comments like, “If you’re not aware of the literature maybe you should think about switching to another program,” in cases where you are demonstrably aware of the literature. Other examples might be things like, “There are a lot of people who want to be in this program and would be happy to meet their deadlines” or “Are you sure you’re cut out for this kind of work?”</p><p><strong>14. Comments About Exes.</strong> Substitute “exes” here with “former advisees.” If your advisor trash talks former advisees to you then something is wrong. Even if they didn’t have the best relationship an advisor should never trash talk a former advisee to current advisees. As instructors and faculty we all complain about our students sometimes to our colleagues. It’s part of what helps us troubleshoot problems and stay sane, but we don’t complain about our students to our other students.</p><p>Hearing an ex use derogatory terms about their former partners is troubling. As the article on intimate partner violence referenced above says, “Assume that whatever he says about her will one day be said about you.” In a romantic relationship this is troubling. In an academic relationship this is a huge red flag. Theoretically, in a romantic relationship both partners are equal. You have, literally, thousands of people to choose to be in a romantic relationship with and there isn’t a huge power difference between you. If a romantic partner talks shit about their exes and describes them in derogatory terms that’s a sign that they might have, at best, a skewed perspective and, at worst, be abusive and trying to control the narrative of their past relationships.</p><p>In an advisor-advisee relationship there are, maybe, <em>maybe</em> a few dozen people you can work with which is just one part of the vast power differences between advisors and advisees. When an ex-romantic partner talks shit about you it can devastate your own self-perception and social group. When an advisor talks shit about you as a former student it can devastate your whole world for a long time. Graduate school is so insular and isolating in its own right. Often your friends and social network are other graduate students. Your future career in academics depends, in large part, on whether or not your advisor is willing to write you a good recommendation. I think this problem is particularly acute for grad students in the humanities because transitioning your career from academics to industry is seen as a less viable option than it is in the sciences or social sciences. This is why, if you see or hear an advisor defaming their former advisee you should be very wary and take whatever steps you can to protect yourself and your reputation.</p><p><strong>15. Superiority. </strong>Okay, this is another one that’s kind of baked into the structure of academia. The whole idea of this medieval apprentice-ship model is that full professors are better than associate professors which are better than assistants which are better than non-tenure track which are better than graduate students. So, yeah. I really can’t say this enough: The whole damn system is abusive.</p><p>In an ideal world, PhD advisors would be people who had more perspective than you because they have been in the profession longer and have had more opportunities to fail and recover. All of my healthiest interactions in academia were with people who had this attitude. In contrast, an advisor who believes they are inherently smarter or better than you because they are tenured or because they just *are* is a huge problem. Unfortunately, academia as it currently exists tends to attract a lot of these people because they see it as a space where they can expand on their own greatness ad nauseum and, too often, they are right. I don’t know if there are any studies to back this up but, based on my personal experience, I believe that academia disproportionately attracts narcissists the same way CEOs are disproportionately made up of people with <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_triad">dark triad</a> traits.</p><p>The best advice I can give you here is to look for someone who wants to use their better position in the structure to help you. Steer clear of people who punch down and steer clear of people who don’t have time for people they don’t deem “impressive” enough.</p><p>It’s true what they say: a PhD is more about persistence than intelligence and in my own PhD journey and my work with clients I can tell you that persistence is about seeing the system clearly. The most jaded PhD candidates I know are those who made the academy into a fairy-tale world in their heads. They were bitterly disappointed by the reality of it and many didn’t finish their degrees. For those that did, I can’t think of a single one who continued to work in academia.</p><p>The best way to get through this system is to clearly acknowledge what it is and where the pitfalls are. I hope that this helps.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e0ee5eedfd2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>