<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by James austin on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by James austin on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 20:05:48 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Keeping the Faith]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/keeping-the-faith-c6b3f423b498?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c6b3f423b498</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 May 2025 20:23:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-05-31T20:23:42.344Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Renewal journal has relaunched — and they put out a </em><a href="https://renewal.org.uk/blog/renewal-editors-reflect-on-the-meaning-of-social-democracy/"><em>very interesting set of essays on the meaning of social democracy</em></a><em>. And, as you’d expect from Renewal, it’s a pretty intellectual and thought provoking (if occasionally a little unfocused) takes on the question. And a few people who used to as a chance to moan. Its social democracy. It’s what we do.</em></p><p><em>But the most interesting take was Morgan Jones’ to me which, I think, touched on the heart of what social democracy atually *is* for many people; as opposed to some thesis. So I thought I’d write on what it is to me. Starting with my Grandpa who, alongside lankyness, moderate athleticism and a terrible sense of humour also cursed me with socialism.</em></p><p><em>This is entirely unedited and was thrown together while eating pasta. So… my apologies.</em></p><p>My Grandpa was a man of great faith. He had three religions: Quakerism, socialism and Nottingham Forest. On Saturday’s we’d go to Church. We’d attend the Temple, the City Ground, take communion (a Blue Ribald passed through the crowd at half time) and say the Lord prayer: <em>Oh, the mist blowing in over Trent, my desire is always to be here…</em></p><p>And then, on Sundays, he’d practice his other religion. Sitting quietly in a hall somewhere. Reading. Musing on humanity. Sharing quite thoughts on God. And through the week the drum beat of the good work; branch meetings, organising, leaflets…</p><p>Linking each of these was an optimism. About football. About humanity. About god. No matter how bad it got the sun was always around the corner. This season would be better than the next. The world would get better; the great evils would be slain and the arc of history would bend ever towards progress or, at least, the playoffs. And, no matter what happen, we would all be Saved in the end.</p><p>It is de-rigur in left wing circles to dismiss religion. It is seen as irrational, a holdover from the old days that has been supplanted by an understanding of class dynamics and dialectic materialism. But social democracy, in the UK at least, has always been more linked to Methodism and non-conformism than Marx. And, I suspect for many, even now, a religious analysis of their values and beliefs would offer rather more insight than an intellectual breakdown<a href="http://do.my/">.</a> My wife is not Political, but she is the child of a vicar, and she immediately recognised the faith in my socialism.</p><p>At its core Social Democracy is a religion of pragmatic optimism. It is a religion that believes we can build heaven where we are, that another future is not only possible, but within our grasp. Whereas other creeds are either grounded in a deep cynicism about human nature or believe that utopia is only attainable following cataclysm and conflict Social Democrats believe that, while we live in a flawed world, it is one that we through dint of our perspiration and human genius can make better.</p><p>Morgan mentions, in her essay, that the only good reason to become a Catholic is because you can’t escape the conviction it is true. The same applies to Social Democracy. We believe this because it is true.</p><p>My Grandpa believed it because he had seen it. He was the last of nine children, the son of a windower who sent his older brothers to work at 14 and pawned his father’s suit each month to feed her children. He saw his own Grandchildren go on to become professors and doctors. None of us have ever had to pawn anything. A better future was not only possible; but it had been built.</p><p>This was, of course, an imperfect future. We all know that. It is one that forces compromise and constant disappointment. The nature of being a Social Democrat, and particularly a Labour social democrat, is to be both constantly hopeful and constantly disappointed. We are the puppy awaiting the punch. It is an irrational enterprise: countless hours spent organising, and knocking, and serving on councils and committees to be met with compromise and removed from position due to a fiscal event taken hundreds of miles away.</p><p>We sit in draughty community halls and comfort each other, saying the old words. Yes, I don’t like the rhetoric either but have you seen the land use framework? I know, the cuts but there was a fiscal black hole? We did invade that country, but my school has a new roof.</p><p>Keep the faith. Keep working. Keep striving. Keep saying the old words, doing the old rituals, printing your WARP sheets, getting angry at Lib Dem bar charts, being a digital campaigner, putting up your garden stake, singing the red flag, getting the meeting done with to have pints, things can only get better at your wedding. Keep the faith. As your parents did before you and their grandparents before them.</p><p>We do this because it’s true. Because over 3000 years of human civilisation the best we have managed to do is social democracy: I can do stats or arguments or citations. I think I can prove this. But that isn’t the point of this essay, and nor to an extent is it the point of social democracy.</p><p>I often speak to friends on the left who despair with Labour and social democracy. What is the point of a government which speaks in such terms about immigration, or cuts some forms of benefits? Is it worth such compromises for such petty gains; for the new school roof, of a small rise in the minimum wage?</p><p>And the answer is: of course it bloody is. Because this is how we build a better future. Not through grand sweeping revolution or holding out for the ideal solution. But through compromises and sweat and sheer bloody pragmatic optimism. It’s through making sure children are warmer and safer at school. It’s through putting a few extra quid in someone’s pocket so they can go to the pub on a Friday. Lowering waiting lists, building wind farms, arguing about finance mechanisms.</p><p>This is, to me, social democracy. It is the socialism of pragmatism, of small acts and little platoons. It is a faith in humanity and cooperation and community and a brighter tomorrow. Whereas Conservatism seeks to preserve, in its truest form, we seek to change and improve. To build a better and more equal society brick by bloody brick.</p><p>Some would argue, as I’ve nodded to in the previous paragraph, this is merely a form of conservatism. It is not. While there are some surface level links, social democracy is driven by an optimistic belief in humanity and its drivers. It values universalism and equality, a enpowering notion of Freedom, mutual obligation, cooperation, democracy, redistrbution, a enabling state, and at the heart of it all: fairness. Conservatism has few of these; its theory is entirely different.</p><p>But I am straying dangerously close to theory again. Each of those drives outlined above are not grounded in textbooks or classrooms, but in hearts and values and beliefs. It is instinct and faith as much as thesis and theory. A outlook.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c6b3f423b498" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Final call]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/final-call-729aaa698258?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/729aaa698258</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 30 Jun 2024 17:45:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-30T17:47:38.059Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A few weeks ago I wrote about what I thought would happen during this general election campaign. I was bored and on a train. I’m now bored and on a train again so…. lets have another go at that.</p><p>I predicted<a href="https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/so-what-happens-next-fce5accdd593"> 4 broad things:</a></p><ul><li>The campaign wouldn’t change much</li><li>Polling would bounce about but the overall prediction wouldn’t change</li><li>Selections would cause issues</li><li>Parties wouldn’t fight the ‘real’ battleground</li></ul><p><a href="https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/so-what-happens-next-fce5accdd593">And made this prediction:</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/533/1*dqMAPMdVhg92Lj1Mu-SxIQ.png" /></figure><p>This election has been a deeply weird one: both low key and with the most consequential campaign since 2017. Lacking in excitement and full of storylines. Containing a huge amount of polling noise and yet with a clear, unambiguous signal. That signal is, in case you missed it, this: the Tories are fucked.</p><p><strong>The Polls</strong></p><p>In general campaigns don’t change much polling wise. <a href="https://x.com/patrickjfl/status/1793312567642796115">The average swing in-campaign during elections is…. 1.7%.</a> I expected a change of about this magnitude, Labour’s lead moving from 20% to 18%. I was, thus far, wrong.</p><p>On a surface level the polls haven’t changed much. When I wrote at the start of the GE the lead in the Guardians poll of polls stood at 21.4%, it now stands at 20.3% — a closure of just 1.1%. So was I right? Yes, in that I didn’t see the polls closing hugely. But no from every other perspective. That basic figure hides a huge amount of churn:</p><ul><li>Labour’s share has dropped by 3.3%</li><li>The Tories share has dropped 2.2%</li><li>The Lib Dem share has increased by 1.2%</li><li>Reform share improved by 4.4%</li><li>Green share… has remained basically identical. Well done Greens.</li></ul><p>Much of Labour’s share changing can be explained by <a href="https://samf.substack.com/p/the-story-of-the-polls-so-far">tactical sorting with the Lib Dems — essentially people choosing to vote tactically and changing their VI accordingly — and methodology change with changes to YouGov/MiC methodology dragging them down by a point or two.</a> This was an effect we also saw in 1997 and was broadly predictable.</p><p>This doesn’t apply to the fall in the Tory share, which has done the exact opposite to what I expected, dropping by 2.2% rather than rising by 5% as I expected. Rishi’s campaign has been a sustained exercise in how not to do it, a true monkey’s paw campaign where everything they’ve tried has gone wrong, and has show that if you really try a campaign <strong>can</strong> have a impact on the polls.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/870/1*LUTLp5VbwZn831N-VgKO8Q.png" /><figcaption>The Guardian’s poll tracker shows the situation quite well.</figcaption></figure><p>Worse for the Tories is this deterioration would look worse if it wasn’t for a few in-campaign methodology changes which have been propping them up. If you remove reweighing pollsters from the average (who have had quite aggressive turnout models that boost the govt) then you have a Tory party on roughly 20% and a lead of 22%— wipeout territory.</p><p>And then we have the MRP’s. These have come thick and fast — with 7 conducted in campaign (I think). They’ve varied in final results but all have the same basic message: the Tories will go down to a record defeat. The big question is whether or they can get 100 seats.</p><p>As I’ve mentioned previously the polls have significantly moved this campaign — which gives a real challenge for MRP’s to deal with as they have long fieldwork dates. It’s very notable that those with the most recent fieldwork are the worst for the Tories — despite all MRPs tending to have a slightly smaller Labour shares/leads than conventional VI. (See the list of MRP’s below)</p><p>This is expected — because the Tories general VI position has got worse over time and MRP’s, with their longer fieldwork and development rates, lag the general electoral position. Despite this we are seeing them slowly get more bearish on Tory fortunes — the last few by fieldwork showing the Tories on 76/110/53 seats and a 20% lead, compared to the 140/115 seats from the first YouGov/IPSOS MRP’s (I’m discounting FindOutNow/Electoral Calculus here because it doesn’t really pass the smell test.)</p><p>There has been much controversy around the MRP’s and their seemingly divergent results. Personally I think this is overblown; the polls have, as reflected earlier, moved this campaign and the MRP’s partly reflect that. The nature of FPTP and the extreme swing we are seeing means that small changes in vote shares leads to large seat impacts: broadly they are all telling the same story, one of a huge swing and, as such, many tight and hard to call seats leading to divergent outcomes on small vote share changes. All of the recent ones provide similar lead/polling numbers: Lab on 40–42% and Con 20–22%. The question is not the result but just how deep it goes.</p><p>Their fundamental picture is backed up by our wider data sources: <a href="https://x.com/JamesDAustin/status/1803414813566964088">by constituency polling</a>, <a href="https://x.com/joelwilliams74/status/1805892757250035881">random sample polls</a> and the<a href="https://x.com/AnnaSophieGross/status/1806601211635785743"> behaviour (and anecdotes) of the parties themselves</a>. This suggests a major polling miss (large enough to fundamentally change the result) is unlikely: I don’t think we’ll see a ’97 or ’92 style error. <a href="https://x.com/JLPartnersPolls/status/1807350010855424287">Just today we have yet another polling method unveiled (SRP</a>) which shows…. basically the same outcome as all the others.</p><p>Instead the big question is one of margin or, to be more accurate, whether the traditional VI polls or re-weighing polls are correct. Over the past few months <a href="https://x.com/Beyond_Topline/status/1803085271929401352/photo/1">a significant difference</a> between those pollsters who use ‘Nowcast’ methods of judging voter intention, and others who use models to reweigh voters and to try and judge the election result more accurately.</p><p>We had expected the difference between these approaches to narrow as the election approached, but this has (largely) not happened, resulting in a roughly 4% gap between ‘nowcast’ and ‘reweighing’ approaches — largely explained by them predicting different turnout patterns. The ‘nowcast’ approaches are generally predicting around a 22% lead, while the ‘reweighing’ ones are between 16–20%.</p><p>There are decent arguments for both models — but, the difference between the two is significant: it’s the difference between a 1997 style landslide or a sub 100 seat wipeout.</p><p>This close to a election, my personal view is that the ‘nowcast’ models are more likely to be correct. They have fewer points of failure due to the simpler method (which is vital if you have been relatively accurate in the recent past (particularly Survation) and seem to fit better with the wider data we have from constituency polling, MRP’s and random sample.</p><p>This means I broadly expect the Labour lead to be between 20–24% — probably a: the lower end. And, at this, my mind rebels. So a prediction.</p><p><strong>Prediction:</strong></p><p>It is clear the polls haven’t closed as I initially expected — and at this point I don’t expect any significant change: the election is being well and truly drowned out by sport, Glastonbury and boredom, it’s hard to se what would drive significant change. We may see a percent or two rise in the Tory share but I don’t expect more than that.</p><p>So, in terms of shares I expect broadly this:</p><p>Con: 21%<br>Lab: 41%<br>Reform: 14%<br>Lib: 12%</p><p>A 20% Labour lead. Converting this into seats is harder: if I went with Electoral Calculus’ model, which I don’t really trust, it’d give the Tories 60 seats. But when I actually look at the sort of seats this would require to fall, and the sheer swings, I just struggle to see it as actually possible: Are Labour really going to take seats like Bexley? Or Richmond? Is the Weald of Kent going red? Is the Labour vote really *that* efficient?</p><p>And so my seat prediction:</p><p>Lab 424<br>Con 105<br>Lib 70<br>Green 4<br>Ref 3<br>SNP 22<br>Plaid: 3</p><p>When I put this on twitter yesterday(I wanted to quickly re-read this piece before publishing last night) plenty of people pointed out the predicted shares don’t line up with the seats. They’re right. They don’t on the MRP’s and models we have.</p><p>Having tried to be data led throughout the election I’ll admit I’ve slightly abandoned it with this projection: I don’t really have a good data argument for Labour not having more seats and the Tories less. It’s a gut feeling. In my defense I think this applies to a number of analysts who are predicting a slightly higher Tory seats than the polling suggests. Ultimately this is a very weird election and challenges all of our pre-conceptions of Britisih politics.</p><p>Ultimately we’ll find out on Thursday!</p><p>— — — — — — — — — —</p><p>List of MRPs by final fieldwork (up to Thurs 27/06)</p><ul><li>FindOutNow/Electoral Calculus 2: Con 60: Lab 40/Con 20/ Ref 18/ Lib 11 Fieldwork: 14/06–24/06</li><li>WeThink/Economist: Con 76 seats: Lab 42/Con 22/ Ref: 14/ Lib 11 Fieldwork 30/05–21/06</li><li>Focaldata: Con 110 seats: Lab 41.4/Con 23/Ref 15.5/Lib: 11.3 Fieldwork: 03/06–20/06</li><li>Savanta/Electoral Calculus/Telegraph: Con 53: Lab 44%/ Con 23%/ Ref 13%/ Lib 12% Fieldwork: 07/06–18/06</li><li>Yougov 2: Con 108: Lab 39/ Con 22/ Ref 15/ Lib 12 Fieldwork 11/06–18/06</li><li>More in Common: Con 155: Lab 44/ Con 24/ Ref 8/ Lib 11: Fieldwork 22/05–17/06</li><li>Survation: Con 72: Lab 40/ Con 23/Ref 12/Lib 11 Fieldwork 31/05–13/06</li><li>IPSOS: Con 115 seats: Lab 43/ Con 25/Ref 12. Lib 10% Fieldwork: 7/06–12/06</li><li>YouGov 1: Con 140: Lab 43/ Con: 25/ Ref: 10/ Lib 11: Fieldwork 24/05–01/06</li><li>FindOutNow/Electoral Calculus 1: Con 66: Lab 46/ Con 19/ Ref 12/ Lib 10 Fieldwork: 20/05–27/05</li></ul><p>Putting aside focal data</p><p><strong>A prediction:</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=729aaa698258" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Not calling an early election could be one the most calamitous decisions ever made for the modern…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/not-calling-an-early-election-could-be-one-the-most-calamitous-decisions-ever-made-for-the-modern-170e7a6c4048?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/170e7a6c4048</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 04 Jun 2024 06:41:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-06-04T06:41:15.984Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Not calling an early election could be one the most calamitous decisions ever made for the modern Conservative Party.</h3><p>James Johnson is wrong.</p><p>This may not be a particularly new observation. It could refer to, say, his shot at <a href="https://x.com/jamesjohnson252/status/1794478714895688057">snarky tweets</a> who said said that the National Insurance policy would be a disaster. <a href="https://x.com/jamesjohnson252/status/1797698602740949408">Which he found</a>. Or his <a href="https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/01/04/why-president-rishi-strategy-gives-tories-chance-turn-things/">advocating for something along the lines of Rishi’s five pledges</a> (despite them being impossible to achieve.) <a href="https://x.com/jamesjohnson252/status/1772987710136836584">Which he also found was a disaster.</a> Great pollster, terrible strategist.</p><p>But in this case I’m referring to this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/604/1*w5ZmD57Jdk8oEt0YieDtQQ.png" /></figure><p>It’s not just James making this argument of course, but people across the Tory party. If only Rishi had waited, things could have been better, going early was a dreadful mistake.</p><p>First off, lets be clear: This isn’t an early election. We’re 4 1/2 years into the Parliament. A snap/early election is one maybe 3 years in, rather than one where the sand had begun to run out of the govt some time ago. It’s a election exactly when you’d expect a election to be; which is why both the Lib Dems and Labour have been so well prepared for it.</p><p>You have to call a election at some point; you can’t simply postpone until things are better. It was now or, roughly, within 6 months. The key question is whether it was better to go now compared to, say, October.</p><p>And when making that decision I’d invite you to consider this graph:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/600/1*nq6I_Rm0t2JZyUQcBROFjg.png" /></figure><p>The Tory support has been reducing, roughly, at a surprisingly linear rate throughout Parliament, give or take a few dips with no sign of this progress stopping in 2024. They lost roughly 2% between January and May in 2024. Given that do you want to take a bet that the Tories would have been in better shape had they gone for an election in October than May?</p><p>Polls tend to be causal; they don’t operate by natural laws (despite the beliefs of some — which seem to have been pretty comprehensively debunked by this election) but instead respond to stimuli. And what stimuli would we have seen between May and October that could have helped the Tories?</p><p>The key argument for waiting was the economy; the UK has come out of recession, inflation has fallen and, potentially, we may have seen a rate cut before October. In addition to this, had they gone for October, it is likely Farage would have been busy in America rather than standing in the UK.</p><p>The issue with this analysis is that growth is at a relatively low level compared to, say, 1997 which ddn’t save them and there is no guarantee that rates would have been cut. Inflation didn’t fall by as much as hoped. And there is some evidence the economy has a lagging impact on the polls.</p><p>As for Farage — certainly that may have made for a easier campaign but equally… the Tories were already 22% down in the polls before he chose the stand yesterday and the Reform vote seems to be proving extremely difficult to squeeze.</p><p>What is the flip side of going for October? Aside from the apparently linear losses in the polls you almost certainly would have seen public services further collapse over the intervening 6 months. The Rwanda policy would have been shown to have failed and you’d have had a summer of high small boats arrivals. Prision capacity becomes a bigger issue. Any afterglow from tax cuts were long gone, you’d have had a extremely fractious conference and you increase the chance of a black swan event which causes damage to the government (uni collapse? RAAC issues? Further conflict? Who knows)</p><p>Ultimately it seems very unlikely that things would have got better if the Tories had waited 6 months and they may well have got worse. Rishi was right on this one. And the basic issues that are hitting the Tories campaign, like Rishi being awful at politics, would have happened anyway.</p><p>Instead the great error as not going early. The best time for a election was May. Or April. Or October 2023. Or, ideally, March 2023 at the height of the Rishi bounce. At that point you had stronger polling, less people were impacted by mortgage rate rises and Rishi’s flaws hadn’t been exposed. Your issue and leader ratings were stronger.</p><p>Would you have won? Maybe not. But equally there was almost no likelihood of us singing ‘Oh, Canada’ on election night as compared to the chances now.</p><p>I suspect the dominant narrative will remain that Rishi took a reckless gamble in going for July, but the true, catastrophic gamble was waiting so long on the hope it would get better.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=170e7a6c4048" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[So, what happens next]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/so-what-happens-next-fce5accdd593?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fce5accdd593</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 May 2024 08:10:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-05-23T08:10:17.645Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*DHjt9EJcA_qZPMPv" /></figure><p>Well, that was unexpected.</p><p>It seems odd for an election being called after 4 1/2 years to be ‘unexpected’ but this certainly was. After months of speculation about potential dates most of us had started to relax and think about our summer holidays; after all, why now?</p><p>Because all the other options are worse, seems to be the answer. There is no good time to call an election when you’re 20% down in the polls, but doing it with some decent economic news (if not as good as they’d like) and nothing actively collapsing right now is probably as good as any. Choose your poison, this one finishes you off a bit quicker.</p><p>So, what happens now? What should we be looking out for? Some thoughts:</p><p><strong>The Campaign Won’t Change Much</strong></p><p>The great secret of UK election campaigns is that… for all the sound, fury and money they don’t really change much. As <a href="https://x.com/patrickjfl/status/1793312567642796115">Patrick Flynn</a> notes the average change in govt poll margin between the start of a campaign and its end is 0.14%. This increases to 5.1% but that would, roughly, only reduce the Labour lead (on the poll of polls) to… 16%</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/598/1*MZBSIqGk_UoFUMmZc9GiDQ.png" /></figure><p>It’s worth noting that the ‘when the govt is behind’ stat is based on a relatively small sample size — we simply don’t often see the govt behind in the polls going into an election. And certainly not by this much — the last time was 1997 when the lead shrank by about 6% (Notably much of this was the opposition vote redistributing more effective — from Labour to Lib Dem)</p><p>This from <a href="https://x.com/Dylan_Difford">Dylan Difford</a> underlines the point:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*e-_zEkdg78jo26NJ" /></figure><p>The Lab/Con swing across all these polls is just 1.7% — enough to reduce the Labour lead to… 18% and put the Tories below 100 seats. Even 2017, a famously impactful campaign, saw a swing of just 3.8%</p><p>All the data tells us that our base expectations should be that the polls are broadly right and the challenge for the Tories is to generate enough of a swing to get to 150 seats and avoid wipeout, rather than to win.</p><p><strong>Some Polls Will Change — don’t get overexcited</strong></p><p>In general modern UK polls can be divided into two types: Snapshot polls, which attempt to show a picture of the electorate now, and predictive polls, which attempt to model a general election by redistributing voters (normally ‘Don’t Know’ voters) in various ways.</p><p>Presently you can see a clear divide between these polls as <a href="https://x.com/drjennings">Will Jennings</a> very useful summary shows:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/598/1*o4lAqON_7XDQ9zk77_Y09Q.png" /></figure><p>To this we can add JL Partners showing a 15% lead and MiC showing 16%. You can see two broad groups: JL/Opinium/Savanta/MiC all are ‘predictive’ pollsters, trying to predict voter behaviour in a GE. YouGov, PeoplePolling (lol), Techne etc. all are ‘snapshot’ pollsters who don’t.</p><p>If the theory predictive pollsters follow is correct we should now see the snapshot pollsters move towards them as Don’t Knows reallocate themselves with the election on. This has been expected for a while and one of the interesting polling subplots for the past 6 months has been… why hasn’t it happened?</p><p>We should now expect it to happen quite quickly — so if you see the lead plunge with YouGov/Techne etc over the next week don’t overreact or get too pessimistic (if you’re Labour). It’s an expected impact of the election being called. The predictive polls should remain fairly stable.</p><p><strong>A mad rush of selections will cause issues</strong></p><p>For an election that has been predicted for months this is surprisingly snap and none of the parties are entirely prepared for it — though all will have procedures in place to quickly accelerate candidate selection.</p><p>This particularly, and remarkably given they control election timing, applies to the Tories who have a twin issue: they’ve been both slow to select candidates in ‘open seats’ *and* have a lot of seats suddenly becoming open as sitting MP’s choose to stand down. Their candidates list and CCHQ will be very stretched to react and fill all of these over the next few days.</p><p>Reform are also in big trouble — with only a few hundred candidates identified and in place. Their vetting is also clearly sub-optimal, given their experience in the local elections, and they will struggle to find enough suitable candidates to fill all 650 seats. One to watch.</p><p>That vetting issue applies to all parties — and will be accentuated by the need to select quickly and without due diligence over the next few days. Expect to see multiple ‘X’s candidate is a racist/hates the seat/wants to sell slaves’ over the next few days. Normally those sorts of candidates aren’t significant because they’re tucked away in no hope seats — but they may be more significant this year because…</p><p><strong>Where is the real battleground?</strong></p><p>There is a traditional set of seats which form the battlegrounds of a GE. Some of them, if you’re a sad political geek like me, roll off the tongue unprompted: Swindon, Nuneaton, Basildon, Amber Valley. The battleground shifts slightly each time as coalitions change but the basic idea is the same: these are the group of 40 or so seats which each party needs to win a majority.</p><p>This year, however, it’s a little different. Labour’s lead is such that the seats it needs to win to get a majority (like Swindon North or Filton and Bradley Stoke) should be well in the rear view mirror: electoral calculus presently predicts a Labour 13.3% majority in Swindon North, for example.</p><p>Instead, if the polls are correct, the real battlegrounds are seats like Skipton and Ripon, the Isle of Wight or Somerset North East and Hanham. These are seats with colossal, 17k+ majorities which the polling has Labour picking up.</p><p>An interesting question is whether the parties adjust to this — and adopt their strategies. Will we be seeing Starmer on a hovercraft, visiting the Isle? Or Sunak stumping in Woking? If so, its a sign that both sides data reflects the polling and they’ve given up on the traditional marginals.</p><p>Alternatively, the parties may just ignore the polls and do as they have always done. Thus far this is what Labour have done — twinning safe seats with very traditional target marginals (my own CLP with Swindon North) In which case we may get some surprises on election night.</p><p><strong>A prediction</strong></p><p>Only a idiot would predict the election now. But I am, it’s fair to say, a idiot so here is my very early prediction with some insanely huge caveats:</p><p>Tories: 120 (28%) <br>Labour: 436 (43%) <br>Lib: 58 (11%) <br>SNP: 15</p><p>This envisages a few things — and as you may not is slightly contradictory with my ‘campaigns don’t change anything’ line. It sees, for one thing, the Tory share increasing substantially (by 5%) from the polling we have presently — including the predictive polling. I think this will be from Reform failing to fire + DK’s returning home.</p><p>I also think we’ll get quite efficient opposition voting despite this — as was indicated at the local elections. This is why we still see a very strong Lib/Lab performance in spite of some increase in Tory share. I would say I have a significant variation on these numbers — I could see both the Labour and Tory seat numbers being different by 40 odd seats either way.</p><p>The first two weeks polling will tell us a lot. If we don’t see significant closure in the snapshot polls I reserve the right to revise this at any point.</p><p>Good luck to everyone involved in the campaign from whatever side. Elections are always nasty and exhausting — but it takes real bravery to put yourself out there are stand for what you believe in. See you on the other side.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fce5accdd593" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bullshit politics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/bullshit-politics-a4d6f5547ef7?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a4d6f5547ef7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 07 Mar 2024 10:02:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-07T10:02:04.476Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*exvVXrzLO1Oxv9il.jpg" /></figure><p>The fundamental deal of democratic politics is this: the political class deal with the policy detail and, on the basis of reality, put forward visions for the country from which voters choose.</p><p>Our role, and I include myself here, as a political class is to amalgamate the incoherence of public opinion and policy options into a coherent programme. That involves making hard choices, grounded the reality. And, once we’ve done that we present these separate visions to the country who chooses.</p><p>This means that those with better things to do don’t have to engage with policy detail but still, fundamentally, control our trajectory of the country. They delegate their role in scrutinising that detail to us, a key responsibility of the press and political class. It’s never been a perfect system but, broadly, it has worked. Until now.</p><p>Because fundamentally the political class have abdicated that responsibility. We are no longer engaging with reality or even trying to provide coherent programmes. We pretend we can cut taxes against imaginary headroom, move the dates of spending plans back for electoral expedinacy, and deliberately salt the ground for our opponents in the hope of electoral advantage.</p><p>More than that this sort of behaviour is actively incentivised by our system. The political class consists for 3 broad, interrelated pillars; the politicians themselves, the press and commentariat and the policy wonks. In general the politicians decide, the press hold to account and the wonks provide the ideas.</p><p>Right now the only bit interested in reality is the wonks, who are sending up every flare they can find about the state of the UK. The press has no interest at all in holding to account; their engagement is entirely surface-level; see how the budget was solely discussed in its political terms rather than focusing on what it meant for public sector finances. The trumpeting of the aim to cut NIC altogether, despite that being totally unworked and pie in the sky.</p><p>In an environment when the govt and the press, those who set the terms of the debate, have no interest in engaging with reality there is no incentive for anyone else to do so. In fact the opposite exists: the opposition engaging with reality would lead you to be jumped on, your plans pulled apart and compared to a totally unrealistic set of govt proposals. So you don’t bother; you lean into the unreality and deal with it later.</p><p>Which leads us to the absurd situation we’re in now: Both parties committed to spending plans which are self-evidently unaffordable. A spending review delayed because it would reveal how brutal those cuts would be pre-election. A commitment to tax cuts made affordable by fantasy numbers and projections which are absurd. And a debate which pretends that the above is somehow real but the big issue is whether Angela Rayner had 2 houses 15 years ago or summit.</p><p>Its a bit passe to blame this on Brexit, but the lurch into unreality from British politics does seem to have started then and escalated since. The challenges and trade offs presented by Brexit were so great that the governing party, to slice the Gordian knot in 2019, just ignored them. And since then they’ve continued to do so as the issues mounted, having found that there was no political cost to doing so.</p><p>And the issues are mounting. The choices facing the govt are stark. Whether it be Brexit, climate change, public spending, tax there are few good options out there — partly because we’ve spent almost a decade ignoring reality and putting off those choices.</p><p>This is on all of us. Everyone who writes, tweets, analyses or takes part in politics. We have a privileged position and our system works because the British people delegates their trust to us that we’ll, to the best of our ability, try and govern the country well and realistically.</p><p>And we’re not doing so. We have all failed to greater and lesser extents. Even those of us who have been calling out the unreality have done so.</p><p>This is, fundimentally, about culture. A political culture we have allowed to develop with avoids hard choices, refuses to engage with reality and prefers fantasy solutions to hard work. Our norms have collapsed and bullshit has filled the holes.</p><p>I’m not convinced any of the traditional cure alls for British politics; enforcing norms legally, electoral and constitutional reform etc. solve this. Because they’re little more than firebreaks. Instead we need to rebuild our political culture and incentives, make sure that we’re calling out and punishing those who don’t engage with reality. We need to create incentives to engage with realistic policy.</p><p>I don’t believe this will be possible prior to GE 2024/5 but it does feel its all coming to a head. Maybe, just maybe, this is the apotheosis of the bullshit cycle and after a cleansing, we can reset and insist on realistic politics.</p><p>And maybe then we can take up our responsibilities once more and actually serve the British people.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a4d6f5547ef7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The case for May]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/the-case-for-may-309fe5ca49f2?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/309fe5ca49f2</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 04 Mar 2024 11:14:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-03-04T11:14:20.522Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*LYlZTRGtj1X3nis9.gif" /><figcaption>Rishi Sunak, contemplating a May election. He’s on the left.</figcaption></figure><p>I’m going to start this one by telling you why, in effect, it’s totally irrelevant. I don’t believe the Tories will call a May election. To do so they’d need to dissolve Parliament within the next few weeks and they show no signs of being prepared to do so. I continue to think that the most likely election date is around the end of October or the end of November, with a non-trivial chance that the Tories inertia themselves into January.</p><p>But in choosing to go even longer the Tories are making, yet another, huge error. They should be calling an election as soon as possible: with early May as the best date. Not doing so risks turning an already bad situation into a… well, we’ve done the Canada 93 meme to death but yeah, that.</p><p>In normal times calling an election when you’re 20% down in the polls would be suicide. So why should Rishi do it?</p><p><strong>The big mo</strong></p><p>Well, it is suicide. The Tories are not going to win this election. The question, at the moment, is how bad it will get: the best case scenario right now is a 1997 style thrashing. The worst case… <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1993_Canadian_federal_election">we’ll we’ve covered that already.</a></p><p>The Tories are now over 20% down in the poll of polls with their support shrinking. Even without tactical voting this would reduce them to &lt;100 seats and give Labour a 300 seat majority.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/0*8qPaSgHmaTuJf_7D" /><figcaption>Seat projection on the present poll of polls, sans tactical voting. With tactical voting it’s even more brutal</figcaption></figure><p>On a quick glance this bolsters the delay case; why go to the polls when this is what they’re showing? The answer is momentum: right now the lead is growing, not shrinking. The poll closure isn’t happening. You’re going backwards and the narrative is getting worse.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/945/1*ertvckz7GeYlEZVk3Tum4w.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/952/1*VXV9j4qLlMX4F-0bzlRXJA.png" /></figure><p>Since Christmas the average lead in the poll of polls has grown from about 17/18% to 20%. The Tory vote share has dropped from 26%&gt; 24%. Despite a few attempts to present outlying polls as evidence of a fightback the trend is clear; the Tories are going backwards. Their vote is shrinking, not growing. The underlying ratings are doing the same; any hopes of a president Rishi campaign have been pretty much sunk by his recent set of approval ratings. The issues polling remains equally dire.</p><p>These polls have been confirmed by by-election results — putting aside the clusterfuck that was Rochdale both Kingswood and Wellingborough were exactly the results you’d expect for a 20% lead.</p><p>So, despite the last few weeks momentum remains with Labour and slowly but surely the idea that the polling might not close is starting to seep into the commentariat. This will continue to grow over the coming months: Starmer will be treated more and more like the PM in waiting, Sunak will become an ever lamer duck and the narrative will focus ever more on the scale of the coming defeat.</p><p>This will work against any attempts to change the narrative or relaunch. You can do a million Downing Street statements but the more relaunches or big moments take place, the less impact they have. Activists will become disheartened. You’ll look like a squatter. The press becomes more interested in the future regime. With each day that passes you lose ammo, energy and momentum. The only solution is to get to the polls as soon as possible.</p><p><strong>Nothing good will crop up</strong></p><p>The argument in favour of going long is, essentially, that something will prop up. In particular the government seems to be hoping that inflation will continue to fall and the economy will come around. This will lead voters to come back to the Tories. Plus, maybe Keir Starmer will punch someone or something.</p><p>This is, frankly, delusional. For one thing inflation remains high by recent historical standards and will remain so; it being slightly lower than before doesn’t mean its low. Similarly we may move out of recession but growth will remain anemic: predicted at 0.5% across the year.</p><p>In 1997 2 years of strong growth and low inflation wasn’t enough to save the Tories from a crushing defeat. Why would a quarter of slightly better stagnation help? Not to mention there is some evidence that economic growth takes time to be felt and feed through to the polls and, frankly, you don’t have time. You might be helping Starmer to get the credit for a growing economy in 2025 tho, so thanks.</p><p><strong>Unexploded bombs</strong></p><p>Far more likely than something cropping up is something else going wrong. The British political landscape is littered with semi-exploded and unexploded bombs which policy people are aware of but the wider public may not be. The consequence of 14 years of failed government.</p><p>Which is it going to be? A RAAC school or hospital which has been missed collapsing? Someone who hasn’t been jailed because we have no more prison spaces doing something awful? Another set of councils going Section 114 or making huge cuts which will be felt as the year goes on? A military escalation that exposes just how reduced our armed forces are? One of the 20k asylum seekers you’ve lost ending up in the public eye? The list is, almost literally, endless.</p><p>Any of these could cause a major damage to the government who is directly accountable for their causes. At best they further reduce any reputation for competence you have, at worst they may be resignation offenses. Either way they will ensure a constant stream of negative stories from a press who no longer have much interest to protect the govt. The longer that you stay in office the worse this gets.</p><p><strong>Your voters are literally dying</strong></p><p>The most remarkable stat I discover this week was this by <a href="https://twitter.com/Dylan_Difford/status/1761746258673168413">Dylan Difford</a>:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/618/1*AEUOrNRI37QgoTv0cxYjOw.png" /></figure><p>Yes, to put it simply, due to demographics the Tory vote is literally dying off at the rate of around 23k net per month. This isn&#39;t a huge number, but over time it adds up — if you delay by 5 months from May to October it’ll account for about 0.5% of the present Tory vote share. Not huge, given the lead is 20%, but still significant. This is also quite a crude measure; it doesn’t include voters who, for example, may become unable to vote for other reasons (need a proxy now but don&#39;t get one, in care homes etc etc) which will also have a impact.</p><p>In short the Tories need to be making some progress just to stay still in the polls.</p><p><strong>Local Elections and infighting</strong></p><p>On the 2nd of May the local elections will take place. In some ways the Tories are lucky with which seats are up for grabs: while these were last fought at the high watermark of the vaccine bounce they were already relatively unkind for the Tories geographically and so they don’t hold enough seats for us to see the 1000+ losses that we saw last year.</p><p>And, while many mayoral seats are up for grabs only 2 are held by the Tories (though they are biggies). So by comparison they are fairly small beer — but will still be brutal for the Tories, with a good chance they’ll loose 300+ seats and both Ben Houchen and, worse of all, Andy Street — one of their few assets in a battleground region.</p><p>These losses will almost certainly lead to a renewed bout of infighting. While the anticipated grid of shit hasn’t really dropped post-by elections, Rishi’s internal opponents haven’t disappeared and will be prepared to jump on the next real world sign of electoral gloom. My feeling is that the impact of any convulsions may be minor; but it’ll add to the perception of a divided party and panic in the Tory ranks.</p><p><strong>The US election</strong></p><p>You may have heard: the US is having an election this year.</p><p>While US elections are always a big deal and dominate the narrative here, it seems likely that, given the stakes, this one will be even bigger and more dominant than usual. We can expect October and November to be overtaken by the build up the the US and, whatever the outcome, the fallout from it.</p><p>It will be very difficult for either party to keep their message separate from events and narratives bleeding over from the US during a autumn election. For Labour this is a frustration but doesn’t present a huge issue; Starmer will need to be diplomatic on who he wants to win but the party’s alignment to the democrats and unity around this is clear.</p><p>For the Tories, however, it presents a bigger issue. They naturally align to the GOP but given where that party has gone this presents a increasingly difficult issue; Most British people strongly dislike Trump, US culture war positions on, say, vaccines have little basis in the UK and it’d struggle to avoid getting on the wrong side of issue.</p><p>This would present a particular challenge as a number of Tory MP’s will openly support Trump, including the former Prime Minister and professional millstone Liz Truss, and the Tory campaign will be constantly dogged by questions of whether they support Trumps positions.</p><p>This seems to be the reason the Tories have already dismissed the first 2 weeks of November as potential election dates; but it won’t be limited to this period. It’ll be a running sore through any autumn campaign.</p><p><strong>The weather / differential turnout</strong></p><p>As any political activist knows; shit weather makes it hard to get your voters are. And the further we go into the year from May the worse the weather is likely to get.</p><p>For all parties this presents an issue. A strong ground campaign can, to a extent, address it; turning out voters via strong voter ID and GOTV work on the day, pushing postal votes and reminding people to get there&#39;s in. Anecdotally weather presents a particular issue for older voters who struggle to get to the polls, and those who may not be particularly motivated to attend.</p><p>All of these factors, of course, appear to apply to the present Tory coalition. The Tory vote now, essentially, consists of pensioners. Their enthusiasm levels seem to be low. And the Tory ground campaign, as seen in recent by-elections, is close to non-existent.</p><p>The longer into the year you go, the less likely you are to get good weather that encourages your voters to turnout. The more you need a strong ground campaign and message to get them to make the effort. And I’m going to guess that ‘Get the Tories out!’ is a stronger message than ‘The Country is fucked, vote for us.</p><p>— — — — — — — -</p><p>The truth is that there aren’t really that many good arguments for May. There are never good arguments for a party to go to the polls when 20% down, but you can’t forestall an election forever and the prospects for a Autumn or Winter election are even worse. It’s frying pan or fire.</p><p>Rishi may value hope or the prospect of another summer in Downing Street over a few more Tory seats. Or he may not. But from a strategic perspective hanging on till autumn or beyond looks even more disasterous.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=309fe5ca49f2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[They think it’s all over (it probably is)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/youre-38-0-down-and-it-s-not-even-half-time-f6fa49d16ce7?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6fa49d16ce7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Jan 2024 17:33:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-18T19:52:06.144Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*pO9imcRJZSYnFj3Z" /><figcaption>A Tory politician giving a team talk having conceded a few tries. Apparently.</figcaption></figure><p>You’re 38–0 down and it’s not even half time. Your fly half has just thrown yet another interception to the opposition outside centre who has had the gall to goose-step your fullback on his way to scoring under the posts. ‘He was in Tigers academy’ someone whispers as you trudge back to under the posts, ready for the pre-talk from your captain.</p><p>“We can still win this” he insists “tackle hard, keep the ball safe and we can force our way back into the game. Remember the game a few seasons back when we came back? Ultimately, they’re not that good, it’s been our mistakes that are costing us. We beat them last year” Aye, you think, but we were only 14 points down a few seasons ago. And they’re better than last year… and have that bloody no.13.</p><p>You can pick your sport or metaphor. The opposition are 4–0 up in a cup game and their striker has just scored via a rabona. Your opposition has 20 overs to go, need just 3.0 run/per over to win and have just switch-hit your spinner for six.</p><p>Whatever metaphor you choose this is basically the situation the Conservative party now finds itself in. Yes, technically within the rules of the game you can still win. But it’s deeply unlikely and in reality what you’re doing is damage limitation.</p><p>A few months ago I wrote about why people <a href="https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/all-this-has-happened-before-0e4ee53c9608">were underestimating the prospects of a Tory wipeout.</a> At the time my base case was that we’d see the Tories get between 180–220 seats at an election, with a small but underestimated chance that we’d see a wipeout. I now think that the upper end of this prediction is the best case scenario for the Tories and that they’re more likely to get between 150–180 seats. And that the chances of a sub 100 seat ‘wipeout’ are up to about 25%.</p><p>So why am I getting more bearish on the Tories chances? I apologise for the volume of graphs about to follow.</p><p>The first factor is time: The Tories are running out of it. <a href="https://twitter.com/drjennings/status/1721284200723108325">I covered this in more detail here</a> but, in essence, the 2 1/2 months since I wrote on the chances of wipeout constitute about 1/5 of the time left for the Tories. And they’ve made little progress. We know that, <a href="https://twitter.com/drjennings/status/1721284200723108325">as we get closer to the election</a>, polls become more predictive and we’d be expecting to start to see real closure at this point.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/OwenWntr/media">Owen Winter’s work</a> is useful at showing this — Labour are well ahead of where you’d expect a winning opposition to be at this point *and* closing in on similar polling to 1997.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*-ULVvw87kOt4fcf8" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*PbCdAVbotG8JB7xA" /></figure><p>More than that, far from closing up the polls are actually widening. Polls since Christmas have all, aside from Savanta, shown falls in the Tory vote share and increases in the Labour lead. We have leads of 27%, 19%, 16%, 17%, 22%, 14%, 20%, 15%, 22% in the latest polls from reputable pollsters. <a href="https://news.sky.com/story/sky-news-poll-tracker-how-are-political-parties-performing-as-an-election-looms-12903488">The SkyNews tracker</a> has crept up to a 19% average lead and<a href="https://www.politico.eu/europe-poll-of-polls/united-kingdom/"> the Politico one</a> is on the way to that:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/716/1*OPIZ5Cab2N_bO6WwLt8teQ.png" /><figcaption>Poll closure when?</figcaption></figure><p>Worse still for the Tories are the underlying ratings and data which may actually be getting worse. Rather than things appearing to close and Labours position deteriorating we’re actually getting signs that the Tory vote is getting weaker. For example, <a href="https://twitter.com/Beyond_Topline/status/1747943722342347155">as Beyond_Topline points out </a>on the most recent YouGov poll a majority of Tory 2019 voters with intention are no longer voting for the party. Worse, <a href="https://twitter.com/Beyond_Topline/status/1747945431743545851">36% of them</a> have switched to another party… and we know switchers are harder to get back in the fold.</p><p>This isn’t an isolated finding either — <a href="https://conservativehome.com/2024/01/18/lord-ashcroft-what-the-first-of-my-new-monthly-polls-tells-us-about-the-shape-of-the-next-general-election/">Lord Ashcroft also finds </a>something similar (tho not the same) with just under 50% of 2019 Tories saying they’re definitely likely to vote for the party. He also finds that Lib Dem/Green voting is relatively soft (and Labour voters quite open to voting Lib Dem) which shows a high chance of tactical voting.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/851/0*BtzwWNPw3oS6SiK0" /></figure><p>Looking away from VI to the background ratings the Tories are in arguably the worst state we’ve ever seen a major party in. They lead on just <a href="https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/trackers/defence-and-security">one major policy area, defence,</a> and even then Labour came within a 1% lead here in December. <a href="https://twitter.com/Dylan_Difford/status/1746135029392998417/photo/1">Dylan Difford</a> has shown just how much worse the Tory position is than 1997 when they at least led on 3 major policy questions ahead of the election.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*L3bEvPawrApknFMy" /></figure><p>It’s worth noting that Dylan’s numbers are from October and the Tory position may have got worse since then. For example,<a href="https://www.ipsos.com/en-uk/uk-opinion-polls"> IPSOS now have Starmer with a 17% lead on net approva</a>l and <a href="https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/trackers/which-political-party-would-be-the-best-at-handling-the-economy">YouGov with a solid lead on the economy</a> (this is different polling from that which Dylan uses — I can’t find any more recent issues polling from IPSOS.) To underline the point YouGov’s recent <a href="https://www.ipsos.com/en-uk/uk-opinion-polls">MRP found that Starmer has a 9% lead on best PM,</a> with more people answering ‘Don’t know’ than selecting Sunak.</p><p>Traditionally the Tory’s strategic strengths where the economy, defense, law and order and immigration. You can see this in 97. To now be in a place where all but defense are losing issues is remarkable. This is why Labour feel comfortable devoting 3/4 PMQ’s to immigration: because it is now a winning issue for them.</p><p>As a Labour supporter its like being in bizarro world. The issue we always avoided and struggled with is… now something we want to talk about?!?</p><p>It’s because of this weakness that its very hard to see what option to Tories have to try and recover, or where that recovery is going to come from. You want to fight on issues where you are a) stronger than your opponent and b) which have high salience. And these just… don’t exist for them. As such they should go for the least worst option: probably fighting on the economy and leadership, where their disadvantage is slightly smaller.</p><p>Not that they’re doing that of course. Their approach seems strategically muddled, leading to a lack of clarity in messaging and repeated relaunches.</p><p>There isn’t a clear route to winning in the VI either. For example, just winning back Tory switches to Don’t Know isn’t enough to significantly close the gap; In the unlikely event they win back every 2019 Conservative who has gone ‘Don’t Know’ *and* every Reform voter… Labour probably maintain a 8% lead. And if you think that will happen I have a bridge to sell you.</p><p>So the Tories are in the business now of damage limitation. Forcing a hung parliament or minority govt seems their best chance. But Yougovs MRP showed just how hard this will be: it showed how, even in a relatively good scenario (where the Tories lose by 13.5% — a closure of 5.5% from the poll of polls) you’d still get a 97 style thrashing with the Tories just holding onto 169 seats.</p><p>And this was with 46 of the seat they did held being by margins of under 5%. Given that YouGov’s adjustment for tactical voting seemed relatively weak (and some add % shares) it’s hard to see how they would hold those — <a href="https://twitter.com/Dylan_Difford/status/1746890360884724075">which leads to things like this</a> in a slightly more realistic scenario with tactical voting + Reform being squeezed.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/613/1*68OSkTbDfOBwRqRsnQ8azQ.png" /></figure><p>And again this is on base data that is relatively kind to the Tories, with a decent sized closure. <a href="https://swingometer.substack.com/p/what-would-a-really-big-labour-win">Rob Ford has shown another scenario</a> where a relatively good, % wise, scenario could end up badly for the Tories. This is with a 13.5% lead. Now imagine one with say, a 17% lead (still closure from now) and tactical voting would be…</p><p>Okay, so that the polling which offers very little hope for the Tories. But what about the politics? Can we look forward to events helping them out?</p><p>The honest answer is… no. Tory hopes are very much resting on the idea that the economy will improve and this will spur people back to the Conservatives but predictions are for interest rates to remain relatively high and the economy to, at best, stagnate. <a href="https://kpmg.com/uk/en/home/insights/2018/09/uk-economic-outlook.html">KPMG, for example, antipate growth of 0.5% across the year with core inflation remaining relatively high.</a> While we may see some real wage growth, people&#39;s living standards will still have fallen across the Parliament. By comparison in 1997 we saw strong economic growth for 2 years in the run up to the election and real wage growth across the Parliament — and it wasn’t enough to save them.</p><p>Politics wise it looks like that the first 3 months of the year will be dominated by the budget and Rwanda. Rwanda will continue to be a flashpoint and eat up headlines and Parliamentary time. I fully expect it to be defeated in the Lords and to then ping pong back and forth until Parliament dissolves. Quite why the Tories are choosing to waste half their available time, and suffer repeated splits and defeats, on a policy that just <a href="https://twitter.com/sundersays/status/1748008091222765590/photo/1">34% of people think they should continue with</a> is a mystery to me.</p><p>The budget offers better prospects. There is some headroom for tax cuts (though voters, <a href="https://conservativehome.com/2024/01/18/lord-ashcroft-what-the-first-of-my-new-monthly-polls-tells-us-about-the-shape-of-the-next-general-election/">even Tory voters</a>, would prefer this to be used on investment) and a chance to try and reset the narrative around the economy. There is less than there would have been, however, given the splurge on tax cuts in the Autumn which have had zero impact. If I was the Tories I’d be trying to think about why this might be and not just waste another £20bn on tax cuts.</p><p>Then we have some space before the local elections. These are likely to be a bloodbath for the Tories; the seats were last contested in 2021 at the height of the vaccine bounce. It seems likely the Tories will lose over 400 seats and the mayoral races in Tees Valley and West Midlands will be very tight. Losing both would be a huge blow.</p><p>Other issues will come up, of course — but its hard to see how they favour the government. The most foreseeable ones, from the continued closure of the Red Sea to the collapse of a major uni or more councils, all seem harmful. I could write a whole article on this <a href="https://www.joxleywrites.jmoxley.co.uk/p/do-you-smell-what-the-raac-is-cooking">(and John Oxley has)</a> but events seem unlikely to deliver a boost.</p><p>I note I haven’t spoken much about the opposition here. This is partly because this was intended to be a short blog summarising how bad the situation has become for the govt and partly because, unless they shit the bed (see Labour 2010–2019), I don’t think oppositions have much of a impact of election outcomes.</p><p>But to put it simply: Starmer is very unlikely to shit the bed, <a href="https://labourlist.org/2024/01/labour-general-election-manifesto-policies-plan-campaign/">Labour are clearly getting their messages and fighting positions in order</a> and have amassed <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/sep/07/labour-boosts-election-war-chest-with-record-quarter-for-donations">a significant war chest</a>. We’re as disciplined as I’ve ever seen us and seem data led. A clear strategy seems to be being executed and any weaknesses are being ruthlessly killed off. The difference with the govt couldn’t be greater. The big danger for Labour is that they’re over-cautious or box themselves in for government. But that’s for another blog.</p><p>Given the case I’ve made above it’sfair to ask why I’m not even more bullish on the chances of a wipeout. After all, there are plenty of reasons not to expect poll closure and relatively few to expect it.</p><p>The answer to this is fivefold:</p><p>a) There is a very strong historic pattern of polling closure which I’m not willing to just dismiss. Others have outlined this in various ways — <a href="https://theweekinpolls.substack.com/p/how-much-will-the-polls-close-by">Mark Pack has a good summary.</a></p><p>b) FPTP gives very strong protection to establishment parties, both in terms of brand and seats. That is hard to overcome.</p><p>c) There are good numbers of DK voters out there who lean Tory — I still expect them to return home and boost the Tory % by 3 or 4 points. That, combined with a classic squeeze of reform votes, should close the gap from ‘wipeout’ to ‘landslide’.</p><p>d) I’m not convinced that Reform exist in anywhere near the numbers polls are showing and think some of their vote should be redistributed Tory*</p><p>e) I’m a coward and am probably herding</p><p>But you can’t get away from the fact that all of the data points towards a huge Tory defeat — and that those factors aren’t getting better over time. We should be seeing closure. We’re not. And I see little political prospect of the Tories making significant political moves that might rescue the situation — I’m not even convinced those moves exist any more. Should this continue for, say, another 3 months then I think the odds of wipeout may creep to a 50%+ position for me.</p><p>In the meantime the Tory party will continue to trudge back to the posts, wondering why their fly-half forgot which colour shirt he was wearing.</p><ul><li>this only applies if Farage doesn’t return</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f6fa49d16ce7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Joy of Dot Watching]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/the-joy-of-dot-watching-8788d26c18eb?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8788d26c18eb</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 15 Jan 2024 16:29:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-15T16:34:06.089Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*F4ha2Zpeoegt7NtI4odqsQ.png" /></figure><p>It happens about every minute. One of the tiny dots of my screen jumps a few millimeters over the beige landscape of your standard OS map. A few moments later another dot moves. And then another. Ants crawling over a virtual landscape.</p><p>There are few things which make you sound more mad than trying to explain the joy of dot watching to others. After all, how do you explain the fascination of watching a few pixels move on the screen?</p><p>That’s because the joy of dot watching isn’t in the actual act of doing it; but instead in the imagination. It’s in seeing how those contours turn into land and the dots into people, struggling against fearsome and imagined conditions to do something…. mad, and silly, and frankly glorious.</p><p>Today is the second day of the Spine Race — probably the UK’s premier dot watching event (hell, it’s premier ultra-running event as well but that&#39;s by the by) and an endeavor which can fundamentally be described as ‘fucking insane’ and, even more accurately, absurdly appealing. The runners are attempting to cover all 250 odd miles of the Pennine Way, the king of UK trails, in the depths of winter, battling through snow, hail, wind and the sheer bleakness of the moors to make it as quickly as possible.</p><p>For the lead 5 or 6 runners it’s a race. For the rest it’s a challenge; a test of what you can endure and how far you can go. And so we watch them and will them to continue on, checking in to see if their dots have moved and praying for them to enduring.</p><p>At the moment I’m watching three different parts of the race at once. At the front I’m seeing Damian Hall, the reigning champion, chase down Kim Collison as they head towards Middleton. Damians tracker updates. The gap closes. Kim’s does. The gap widens. Its compelling. In the middle I’m keeping a eye on Claire Bannwarth as she descends off Great Shunner Fell, one of the hills I hate the most, a featureless expanse of pain and fog, holding three mile lead in the womens race.</p><p>But the most fascinating race is at the back, where the black Lantern Rouge cut-off icon slowly but surely chases down the laggards; Alan Cormack and Roger Andrews. They’re a full 40 miles or more behind the leaders, still traversing the gap between Calderdale and the Yorkshire Dales.</p><p>Unlike Damian and Kim they aren’t elite athletes. They’ve paid hundreds of pounds to suffer and survive, to spend well over a hundred hours trudging through bog for no glory or recognition. At some point they may falter; worn down exposure or the sheer relentlessness of their task. But their dots still trudge forward. And I will them on, checking in every hour or so to see them move another mile or two closer to their goal. In many ways their achievement is greater than the leaders and more deserving of recognition for however long they last.</p><p>I’ve never met any of those people, by the way. I only heard of Alan and Roger yesterday. I think I may have passed Damien on a training run once, maybe, as he lives nearby. Or at least a bloke some seriously nice kit with a mohawk went past me. It could have been him. Or, you know, some other randomer who runs far and likes Inov8.</p><p>But it doesn’t matter. Because in my head I can see each of them, picturing them from their smiling photos (or ones where they’re… holding tea bags?) dropping down a scree slope or forcing their way up a rocky incline. Bashed by the wind and soaked by rain, feet cracking the fresh crust of snow… Yes. I’m jealous.</p><p>The emptyness of the map and graphics help. All you have are some contours, a dot, and a photo. In that space you can project; imagining what each line means and what could possibly be happening in the minutes between the dot moving. Have they fallen? Put a spurt of? Hit a particularly nasty steep bit? Stopped for a cup of tea?</p><p>It helps if you know the course. For the Spine I do, having done the Pennine Way once in full and most sections a few times seperately. Even better if you’ve done something similar — though no amount of walking or even running can replicate a 200+ mile winter race — then you can appreciate the suffering and the sensation, think about how they must be feeling as they drag their legs through the bogs of Slightholme Moor or how their minds must lift as they traverse the glorious track along Upper Swaledale to Keld.</p><p>Anyways, they’re almost in Middleton. In the time it’s taken me to write this they’ve covered another two miles of bog. And ahead lies what is, in my view, one of the best twenty mile sections of path in the world; High Force, Low Force, Cauldron Snout and the glorious, unexpected emergence of High Cup Nick. They won’t see that, of course. It’ll be dark when they get there. Maybe Alan and Roger will.</p><p>But in my mind…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8788d26c18eb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Time is running out]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/time-is-running-out-17e6295bbb70?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/17e6295bbb70</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Jan 2024 11:28:17 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-12T11:30:55.758Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/0*vqHcQArd9In7JqVa.jpg" /><figcaption>The Tories, right now.</figcaption></figure><p>Bombastic, inexplicably popular in the mid-10s despite an increasingly poor output and prone to conspiracy theories… this Tory party has a lot in common with Muse. That includes a tendency to warble ‘How did it come to this’ at high volume before shrieking joylessly.</p><p>Unlike the Tories, however, I used to like Muse.</p><p>Anyways, the point more generally is that, as Muse said before they began to create rubbish, the Tories time is running out.</p><p>Anyways, it’s been 2 months since I last wrote about the way in which the chances of a Tory wipeout were being unestimated by the general political commentariat and, in that time, little has changed both in terms of polling and how people are treating the prospect.</p><p>Oh, we’ve had another Rishi relaunch or two (which have achieved little polling movement), some polling noise, and the decision that any election will be delayed until Autumn but the overall picture remains the same: the Tories are on about 25%. Labour have roughly a 18% lead. And nothing is shifting.</p><p>And time is running out.</p><p>This matters. While public sentiment can shift dramatically, as we saw around Liz Truss’ budget, more normally it’s a slow bleed. A point here, a point there and the polling lead closes. The 2 months since I last wrote constitute, roughly, 1/6 of the time remaining for the government to close the gap. <a href="https://twitter.com/drjennings/status/1721284200723108325">And we know that polling becomes more predictive the closer we get to the election.</a> So, with each day that passes without change, the likelihood change won’t happen grows</p><p>The British political calendar is also not in the government&#39;s favour. For all of the political noise and events we fundamentally have a very ritualised political calendar. There are certain periods of inactivity where its very difficult for either party to make headway, as no one is paying attention and set points where you can change the political weather. These are, for the government, essentially, the Budget, Party Conferences, the Kings Speech and the Autumn Statement.</p><p>These are the points where you get significant airtime, which set out your plans in detail, set the terms of debate and, most crucially, affect peoples pockets. Normal people will at least see some of what you do here and some messaging might get through. The Autumn events, in particular, offer the single best chance of relaunching and rebooting your message; done well they should allow you to dominate the narrative, deliver meaningful change quickly and set a clear vision.</p><p>Done well. Done badly well…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P2ZSGH6D-ZwmG8KCm0lIgg.png" /></figure><p>The issue for the Tories is that of those major events they only have one, maybe 2, left to play with: the Budget in March. We’re likely to see some big offers here, made possible via some very punchy assumptions of future spending, but the decision to use the autumn statement to bring in tax cuts has considerably reduce the room for a big offer in March.</p><p>The failure of the Autumn Statement to change the political weather should also act as a warning to the Tories; spending £20bn on tax cuts, undermining your future room to maneuver, for no electoral gain may well show that a similar approach in March will have similar results. Thus far there seems to have been no real analysis on the Tory side as to why the tax cut had no impact; just a demand for more. If in doubt, go harder.</p><p>And, outside the budget what do the Tories have? Jan and Feb will be spent in a bunfight over Rwanda. May will see colossal local election losses and the fallout from that will bleed into June. July and August tend to be political dead months as people go away and then… you’re in September and party conference season. None of this is counting the ‘events’ which will crop up and demand time; from the escalating issues in the middle east to random things like the Post Office scandal or the collapse of Councils.</p><p>Time is always key in politics and there is precious little time and opportunity left. You can relaunch (again) but without something to peg that around it’ll be less impactful that the last ones.</p><p>Charitably speaking the Tories have 7 months left and maybe 2 big events to turn it around. That’s not much time. And it’s not clear what they have in the locker to change things which are both fiscally and politically possible. They’re drowning, asphyxiated, trapped by the spell they’ve created. And, if they can’t do so then wipeout awaits.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=17e6295bbb70" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[All this has happened before.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/all-this-has-happened-before-0e4ee53c9608?source=rss-4e1463f2de58------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/0e4ee53c9608</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James austin]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Nov 2023 12:13:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-11-09T14:42:41.465Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>All this has happened before. That doesn’t mean it’ll happen again (or: Why we need to be thinking about a wipeout)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MeW4mRm11Db9rmCd2yYKxQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Keir Starmer in 2029, colourised</figcaption></figure><p>All this, as Admiral Adama intones in Battlestar Galactica (the greatest modern sci-fi series), has happened before. And all this will happen again.</p><p>At times it seems that’s the default status of our political commentary. To look back at scarce data points and declare that because this pattern took place in, say, 1997 it must be followed in 2023/4. The only way for Labour to win is to ape Blair. 97 is the worst it can get for the Tories.</p><p>Thus, the insane debate a few months back on whether we’re in the 1992/1997 timeline; can the Tories close the gap like Major? Or is it a Blair style ride to victory for Labour? No other avenue is contemplated. I took on that particular debate in <a href="https://medium.com/@jamesdaustin_82825/why-i-think-the-tories-are-done-11a7109c5141">my blog back in Feb</a>, one whose basic conclusions I think have held up well.</p><p>At that time it was argued that Rishi could close the gap and that the polls would close. That we were in 1992, not 1997. 9 months on and… the Tories are arguably in a worse electoral spot. In February they were 21% behind Labour in Britain Predicts poll of polls. They’re now… 20% behind and the gap has widened since the summer.</p><p>More than this the one positive for the Tories in Feburary, Rishi’s ratings, has collapsed. In Feb he was on -29, not good but not catastrophic by modern political standards. There was the prospect he could drag the Tories&#39; ratings up to meet him. This hasn’t happened; his approval in October hit -40, it&#39;s at -34 this month, and pretty much every one of his polling rating has collapsed. By comparison Starmer is on -14%. Good luck with a presidential contest.</p><p>To underline the point today&#39;s Yougov has Labour with a 24% lead, the Tories hitting 23%, one of a number of polls showing them on below 25%. Put that YouGov poll into electoral calculus and, even without tactical voting, you get this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/744/1*pw9CoaHb8zAMlJThY5JA8w.png" /></figure><p>Stick in tactical voting at a moderate level and the Tories are reduced to 35 seats.</p><p>Obviously this is an extreme example, but equally it&#39;s not a unique one. Put in any present poll and you’ll get a similar result; Electoral Calculus’ own poll of polls has the Tories on 133 seats. The Tories haven’t hit over 30% in any poll since June. Labour’s polling has remained broadly stable with a average 15%+ lead since Trussageddon over a year ago.</p><p>But, all this has happened before, right? In 1997 Labour also chalked up huge leads but were pegged back by the time of the election. In IPSOS/MORI at the same point in the cycle, for example, Labour notched up a 27% lead. Other polls around the same period had their lead between 16% — 34%. A year later Labour won by 12.5%. And if all this has happened before, it must happen again.</p><p>Well… maybe. When we look at 1997 it’s worth considering two key factors; the Tories in 1997 presided over a robust economy, which provided a reason for polling to close. 1997 also saw the polls overestimating Labour’s lead, making those large leads in 1996 look a little less substantial in retrospect.</p><p>The economics seem particularly key. By the time 1997 rolled around the UK had seen three years of strong growth, with falling unemployment, low inflation/interest rates and a smaller deficit. This gave Clarke room for a relatively aggressive budget in 1996, cutting tax and giving the Tories at the very least an electoral case. In addition to this Major, while unpopular, was at the very least a proven politician who had won an election and equally Blair in terms of trustworthiness — the electorate&#39;s verdict was, to quote Kellner, ‘nice man, shame about the party’. In short: There were decent reasons to vote Tory. A argument.</p><p>Today none of those factors apply. The economy is in a poor state, Sunak’s ratings are underwater, as are those of his government and party. The party is deeply split with cabinet ministers freelancing with no attempt to reign them in. And the polling appears far more accurate than in the pre-1997 period, bourne out by repeated by-elections.</p><p>So, while there are some similarities between 1997 and today, there are as many or more differances. All this hasn’t happened before, and there is no reason for the same thing to happen again.</p><p>Our obsession with the past means we view 1997 through the frame that it was a disaster for the Tories, the worst possible result. But what if it wasn’t? What if it was the best-case scenario? After all, it was the largest polling closure in recent history, driven by very strong economic growth driving it. What happens when you remove that?</p><p>All of which is to say this: <strong>People are massively underestimating the chance of a wipeout at the next general election.</strong> Not just a major loss like 1997 but a Canada 93 scenario where the Tories are reduced to &lt;100 seats.</p><p>Our sense of political normality rebels against this. You look at the seats which would need to fall for this to happen and it seems unreal; my home seat of Skipton and Ripon, for example, would go red and the concept of a Labour MP for Kilnsey is just… weird. But at this point it’d be remiss t just dismiss the possibility just because it hasn’t happened before: A Tory MP for Bolsover would have seemed bizarre in 1997, when Labour had a 27k majority, but there we are. The incumbent side always won national referendums until they didn’t. Labour would always hold Scotland. Labour can’t win Tamworth or Mid-Bedfordshire.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/430/0*a1yU8ejo7x7cfSvM" /><figcaption>Yes, the idea of Labour having the MP for here is absurd</figcaption></figure><p>Politics is broadly causal. There aren’t natural laws, but instead voters who respond to the situation they are in, the wider picture and what they see from politicians. So its always good to think about the why and, put simply; Why would the polls close from here?</p><p>The only real arguments I can see are: ‘Don’t know’ voters return home to the Tories as we get closer to the election, and ‘Reform votes’ are squeezed in an election. The former has some issues — <a href="https://twitter.com/Beyond_Topline/status/1651309533283721216">Don’t know voters aren’t exclusively drawn from ex-Tories</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/DamianSurvation/status/1708566250429747284"><em>more would consider Labour than the Tories </em></a><em>— </em>and it’s unclear if those Reform votes exist in real life to be squeezed (and any effect may well be cancelled out by Labour squeezing Green votes and tactical voting).</p><p>Aside from that it’s hard to see what drives poll closure over the next 11 months. The broader strategic picture looks very poor for the Conservatives. Consider:</p><ul><li>The economy is likely to remain flat-lining. There are strong indicators of a recession. Inflation and interest rates will remain high, directly attributed to the Tories; any rise in real wages will be minimal and there is precious little fiscal headroom for any pre-election sweeteners. Rishi’s pledge on inflation is likely to be missed and is misunderstood anyway</li><li>The NHS winter crisis is likely to be more severe that last year, when ambulance services basically stopped, and there is no sign of strike action disappearing. The waiting lists will continue to rise with Rishi’s pledge on them looking like it’s been abandoned. Strike action will continue.</li><li>Public services will continue to deteriorate. Our prisons are overflowing and the criminal justice system is collapsing. Police don’t attend crimes. Schools will continue to struggle with RAAC. The trains are a mess and will continue to get worse.</li><li>Small boats will continue to arrive, though perhaps in smaller numbers. Conflict over the asylum, immigration and wider culture wars escalate.</li><li>The housing crisis will continue to develop, with more mortgage holders, landlords and renters being hit by a mix of rising costs, interest rates and supply squeezes</li></ul><p>These are just a few of the issues that the government will continue struggle with over the next few months — in broad order from most to least important. You could add another half dozen, from foreign policy to parliamentary challenges. For any government, this range of crises would be overwhelming and we’d expect it to impact their polling negatively. To expect the government to make gains in this environment seems… unlikely. And that is without considering any black swan events or crises that are likely to spring up.</p><p>It’s also worth considering the election itself and how it might play out. What exactly is the Conservative line going to be? Given the above, what is its argument for another term, beyond trying to undermine Starmer? They will be led by a deeply unpopular leader (who has another year of his ratings dissolving), face massive and seemingly efficient tactical voting and a well-funded, strategic Labour party with a leader who is tactically leaden-footed but strategically and politically strong.</p><p>None of the above screams poll closure to me. The reasons for the gap to hold or widen seem to outweigh those for a closure. The biggest reason for the polls closing seems to be ‘its what they do;’ it’s happened before, and will again. But as I argued in February this isn’t always the case — we’ve seen gaps go out in the past.</p><p>I’m not saying it’s certain that the Tories will be wiped out in 2024. My personal expectation right now is a 1997 style (or 2019 for Labour) defeat with the Tories reduced to 200 or so seats. The mountain for Labour to climb from 2019 is vast, the electoral geography hard and they won’t be able to spread their resources too thin. Some votes will return to the Tories and I don’t think tactical voting will be as efficient as we’ve seen in by-elections.</p><p>But what we should be doing is taking the prospect of a Tory wipeout seriously and seeing it as a very plausible outcome — far more so than a Tory majority or hung Parliament — rather than dismissing it as a outcome. This should inform our commentary and expectations. And with every day that the polls continue to hold it becomes more likely. Their predictive power increases as we get closer.</p><p>Our present discourse doesn’t reflect this reality at all, but it should. We need to be focusing on what the Tories can do to avoid wipeout, not to win another election. How would Starmer behave with such a huge majority? What would it enable Labour to do? Who would be elected? None of this is being covered or event discussed. We seem to be sleepwalking towards a major (and quite obvious) political change with very little awareness of whats happening.</p><p>But whatever happens it’ll be very different to what has come before. So say we all.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=0e4ee53c9608" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>