<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by James F. Boyle on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by James F. Boyle on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jamesfboyle?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 18:03:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jamesfboyle/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Completing the Republic of Conscience]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/completing-the-republic-of-conscience-f9a7103c572c?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f9a7103c572c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 12 Oct 2025 18:26:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-13T19:17:47.773Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>How Aquinas Fulfills Cicero and Mazzini Fulfills Paine</p><p>By James F. Boyle, Concord, Massachusetts, October 12</p><p>This essay follows yesterday’s “The Love of Duty Before the Logic of Rights”.</p><p>It turns from the broader argument for duty’s primacy to the lineage that built that moral grammar — showing how Aquinas completes Cicero and how Mazzini completes Paine. And finds full, practical, expression in Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy.</p><p>Each pair represents a fusion of intellect and spirit: Cicero’s civic reason fulfilled by Aquinas’s theology of meaning; Paine’s revolutionary conscience fulfilled by Mazzini’s vocation of service. Together they form the living architecture of moral democracy — a republic not of power, but of conscience.</p><p>I. Cicero’s Civic Reason — and Why It Needed Completion</p><p>Cicero (106 — 43 BCE) distilled the best of Greek philosophy into the Roman soul. In On Duties and The Commonwealth, he wrote that justice is the foundation of the republic and duty (officium) the bond of citizenship.</p><p>“We are not born for ourselves alone,” he reminded a society already drifting toward empire.</p><p>Cicero offered the logic of the moral state: that human beings, rational and social, are bound by nature to one another, and that no government can stand without justice. Yet logic alone could not nourish the heart of a people. His reasoning framed the aqueduct of duty; history still awaited the spring that would fill it.</p><p>II. Aquinas’s Completion: When Reason Drinks from Love</p><p>Twelve centuries after Cicero, Thomas Aquinas (1225 — 1274) completed the synthesis that made Western moral reason durable.</p><p>He joined Aristotle’s ethics of rational order with Christ’s revelation of love, showing that truth is not divided between faith and reason but harmonized within a transcendent ordering.</p><p>Three moves define his completion of Cicero:</p><p>1.	From abstract right to intelligible good.</p><p>Every “ought” arises from the good that reason naturally knows. Law is not an external compulsion but the interior recognition of purpose.</p><p>2.	From rule to revelation.</p><p>For Aquinas to understand what one “ought to do”, is to glimpse a a part of the mind of G-d; to do it, is to be most fully human.</p><p>Obligation becomes illumination — the moment when intellect and conscience meet and, in meeting, reflect the map of ultimate meaning.</p><p>3.	From civic virtue to caritas.</p><p>Justice is sustained by love (caritas), which perfects law through mercy. The common good ceases to be the arithmetic of interests and becomes the ecology of shared flourishing in a transcendent ordering.</p><p>In Aquinas, the aqueduct of duty runs full. Cicero’s moral geometry is irrigated by living water — reason is completed by love.</p><p>III. Paine’s Revolutionary Conscience — and Why It Needed Completion</p><p>Across centuries, Thomas Paine (1737 — 1809) gave voice to the democratic awakening. In Common Sense and Rights of Man, he declared that the individual conscience is the seat of legitimate power: “My country is the world, and my religion is to do good.” He universalized the moral law and unchained ordinary men and women from hereditary subjection.</p><p>Paine’s triumph of rights, however, came with a vulnerability. Without a sustaining sense of duty, liberty curdled into license. A politics that begins and ends with claims will, over time, exhaust its moral capital. Like Cicero, Paine built the scaffolding of justice; like Cicero, he left open the question of how love would inhabit it.</p><p>IV. Mazzini’s Completion: From Rights to a Republic of Duties</p><p>Giuseppe Mazzini (1805 — 1872) supplied the completion Paine’s vision required. Exiled for his republican ideals, Mazzini became the moral architect of Italian unification. While Cavour negotiated and Garibaldi fought, Mazzini made Italy think itself into being — teaching that a nation is born only when its people accept moral responsibility for one another. In The Duties of Man (1844 — 1858), he addressed workers directly:</p><p>“The eighteenth century proclaimed the rights of man; the nineteenth must proclaim the duties of man.”</p><p>For Mazzini, life itself was a mission. Every person and every nation had a divinely appointed vocation: to advance the progress of humanity. He envisioned the nation not as a fortress of power but as a workshop of moral progress — a school of service where rights become real only through sacrifice.</p><p>Where Paine announced the rights of the individual, Mazzini organized the duty of the citizen. He transformed the revolutionary’s cry into the reformer’s labor. The logic of rights found its completion in the love of duty.</p><p>V. The Convergence in MLK and RFK: Love in Public, Duty at Scale</p><p>In the twentieth century, Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy carried this lineage into action.</p><p>•	King embodied Aquinas’s completion. His nonviolence was not strategy but theology in motion — justice as love correcting everything that stands against love. He grounded civil rights in natural law and moral duty, holding that the aim of protest was reconciliation, not triumph.</p><p>In him, reason and love became public courage.</p><p>•	RFK embodied Mazzini’s completion. He translated conscience into policy and compassion into governance. He spoke of a “common bond of common humanity” and insisted that privilege must answer to purpose. His politics was Paine’s humanity married to Mazzini’s mission.</p><p>Together, King and Kennedy showed how the synthesis of reason and love, rights and duty, could still govern a democratic people — not by fear or ideology but by conscience made credible through action.</p><p>VI. Answering the Present Nihilism</p><p>Today we face a subtler tyranny: nihilistic selfishness — the belief that authenticity is appetite and that the moral law is a relic of naïve ages. It borrows the language of rights while erasing the story that makes rights coherent.</p><p>Our inheritance offers the antidote:</p><p>1.	Recenter the intelligible good.</p><p>Aquinas reminds us: duty is not repression but participation in ordering that transcends us. To search for what we ought to do is to reawaken meaning.</p><p>2.	Rebuild duty-bearing institutions.</p><p>Mazzini teaches that nations are moral workshops. Renewal begins where we stand — schools, congregations, businesses, neighborhoods.</p><p>3.	Reunite courage and compassion.</p><p>King and Kennedy prove that public love is disciplined strength. A republic of conscience requires citizens who are gentle in manner and resolute in purpose.</p><p>This is the work of recovery, not nostalgia. It is how a free people remember what freedom is for.</p><p>VII. The Practical Grammar of Leadership</p><p>For those building enterprises or communities, the lineage yields a practical grammar:</p><p>•	Name the good (Cicero): clarify the common purpose that calls us beyond self.</p><p>•	Illuminate the meaning (Aquinas): show how duty enables us to see and live the truth of a shared, life transcending, order.</p><p>•	Secure the dignity (Paine): protect each person’s freedom to answer that calling.</p><p>•	Organize the vocation (Mazzini): weave structures of service that keep love alive in public life.</p><p>This is the moral cycle of sustainable freedom: clarity, illumination, protection, and service.</p><p>VIII. The Cosmopolitan Horizon</p><p>The aim is not retreat into sectarian certainty but the completion of modern liberty — to carry its defense of the person through to the fellowship it implies. That is why I write “G-d”: to affirm the divine mystery of meaning that transcends every creed yet animates all who enact love.</p><p>Aquinas does not cancel Cicero; he crowns him. Mazzini does not cancel Paine; he grounds him. And in King and Kennedy we see that crown and ground joined — love governing through duty.</p><p>IX. The Republic of Conscience</p><p>We do not lack for rights.</p><p>We lack the love of duty that makes rights humane and durable.</p><p>Our task is to live and lead as if meaning were not an ornament but an operating principle — as if freedom were not a possession but a responsibility.</p><p>Take Cicero’s civic reason and Aquinas’s intelligible love.</p><p>Take Paine’s radical dignity and Mazzini’s republican service.</p><p>Walk with King in disciplined compassion and with Kennedy in actionable hope.</p><p>Do this, and the spell of selfishness breaks.</p><p>Do this, and freedom remembers its heartbeat.</p><p>Do this, and the Republic of Conscience is elected to govern.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f9a7103c572c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Love of Duty Before the Reason of Rights]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/the-love-of-duty-before-the-logic-of-rights-38068f3e3c91?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/38068f3e3c91</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-health]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[relationships]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Oct 2025 19:41:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-13T18:34:01.441Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By James F. Boyle</p><p>We live in an age that prizes rights but forgets what makes them sacred.</p><p>We speak fluently of freedom, yet haltingly of responsibility.</p><p>We honor the language of choice, but mistrust the discipline of duty.</p><p>And so, again and again, liberty loses its roots. Every sustainable community knows that duty must precede rights. Duty is not the enemy of freedom; it is its heartbeat.</p><p>It is the love that gives liberty form — the self-discipline that turns possibility into meaning.</p><p>I. From the Order of Reason to the Order of Love</p><p>The lineage of duty begins not with revelation but with reason.</p><p>In the fourth century BCE, Aristotle sought the highest good for humankind — eudaimonia, the flourishing of the soul through virtue. In his Ethics and Politics, he recognized that the good life is a life lived in community, governed by reason and ordered toward the common good. The citizen was not defined by what he could claim, but by what he contributed.</p><p>Cicero, three centuries later, carried Aristotle’s philosophy into the civic language of Rome. In On Duties and The Commonwealth, he taught that justice is the foundation of the republic and that duty (officium) is the sacred bond among citizens.</p><p>He wrote: “We are not born for ourselves alone.”</p><p>For Cicero, freedom meant participation in the moral life of the commonwealth — a harmony of reason, service, and law.</p><p>Yet even as Cicero wrote, the republic was dying. The logic of rights, detached from the love of duty, was already hardening into the logic of power. What the ancients could not yet see is that reason alone, however noble, could not sustain a civilization of the heart.</p><p>Something larger — and softer — had to arrive.</p><p>II. The Christian Revolution: From Caesar’s Order to the Order of Love</p><p>When Jesus of Nazareth entered the story of humankind roughly forty years after Cicero’s death, He brought the moral imagination of a new age. He did not speak to the Senate, but to fishermen and outcasts. His law was not written in Latin or Greek, but in the language of mercy.</p><p>“Love one another as I have loved you.”</p><p>It was His only command, and with those words He turned the world inside out.</p><p>The order of Caesar was built on hierarchy, honor, and conquest. The order of Christ was built on humility, service, and self-sacrifice. Love became the new logic of creation — maternal, creative, boundless.</p><p>This revolution did not reject the reason of Aristotle or Cicero; it fulfilled it. Where the ancients sought virtue through reason, Christ revealed virtue as love made active.</p><p>Duty was no longer a civic requirement but a sacred vocation. The command to love became the law of life itself.</p><p>III. Augustine and Aquinas: The Mind of G-d and the Love of Duty</p><p>Augustine, writing in the early fifth century CE (City of G-d, c. 413 — 426 CE), witnessed the fall of Rome and understood that civilizations collapse when they mistake power for purpose.</p><p>He taught that two cities coexist within every heart — one built on the love of self, the other on the love of G-d. To choose duty, for Augustine, was to choose the latter: the eternal city of compassion and truth.</p><p>Thomas Aquinas, eight centuries later, joined Aristotle’s reason to Christ’s revelation. In him, the intellect of the ancients met the heart of faith. He taught that natural reason and divine grace are not opposites but partners — that to understand what one ought to do is to glimpse the mind of G-d, and that to do it is to be most fully human.</p><p>For Aquinas, duty is love in motion, reason illuminated by faith. This was not theology alone; it was anthropology. He saw that humanity is most itself when it acts not from entitlement but from purpose — not from the logic of rights, but from the love of duty.</p><p>IV. The Modern Awakening: From Mazzini to Paine to King and Kennedy</p><p>When the modern age rose out of the Enlightenment, it rediscovered freedom — but often at the cost of meaning. It celebrated individual rights but forgot their source. And yet within that secular dawn, new prophets of moral democracy appeared.</p><p>Giuseppe Mazzini, born in Genoa in 1805, became the moral and intellectual architect of Italy’s unification. Exiled for his republican ideals, he spent most of his life abroad, organizing secret societies and writing letters, manifestos, and books that awakened an entire generation to the idea of a united, free Italy. But Mazzini’s genius was moral before it was political.</p><p>In The Duties of Man, addressed to the workers of Italy, he declared that the eighteenth century’s obsession with rights had liberated men’s bodies but neglected their souls. “The eighteenth century proclaimed the rights of man,” he wrote. “The nineteenth must proclaim the duties of man.” He called each person to see life as a mission — to labor for one’s country and for humanity as one labors for G-d’s unfolding purpose.</p><p>Mazzini replaced the old nationalism of pride with a new nationalism of service. He imagined the nation not as a fortress of power but as a workshop of moral progress — an instrument of divine unity in a divided world.</p><p>Thomas Paine, the radical voice of the American and French revolutions, echoed that conviction: “My country is the world, and my religion is to do good.” Though Paine spoke in the idiom of rights, his heart burned with duty — a duty to humanity itself.</p><p>In the twentieth century, Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy together embodied this moral inheritance. King translated the love of Christ into the practice of public courage. He taught that nonviolence is not passivity but the strength to suffer for love rather than inflict suffering for pride.</p><p>RFK, walking the same path, gave political expression to that compassion — speaking to rich and poor, Black and white, young and old, as members of one moral community. Where King invoked the Beloved Community, Kennedy invoked our common bond of common humanity.</p><p>Both men lived — and died — by the same creed: that duty is the language of love made public.</p><p>V. The Cosmopolitan Horizon: From Faith to Fellowship</p><p>I write as a Christian American, the proud grandson of uneducated immigrants who believed that dignity was not a right to be claimed but a duty to be lived. They did not study Aristotle or Aquinas, Mazzini or Paine, King or Kennedy.</p><p>But they lived the truth all of them taught: that freedom is sacred only when used in the service of others.</p><p>Today, we inherit that unfinished task. We must move beyond the tribalism of creed or nation toward the cosmopolitan fellowship of the human family. Which our American family of every race and religion calls us to. This does not mean dissolving faith; it means deepening it. The love of G-d is not confined by boundaries — it is magnified by them.</p><p>Each culture, each conscience, each act of service becomes a window through which the light of meaning shines.</p><p>The moral arc of our history — from Aristotle’s reason to Cicero’s justice, from Christ’s compassion to Aquinas’s synthesis, from Mazzini’s duty to Paine’s rights, from King’s dream to Kennedy’s call — bends toward a global ethic of dignity.</p><p>It asks of us not that we abandon faith, but that we embody it. Not that we claim rights alone, but that we fulfill them through duty. And not that we speak of G-d as a mystery apart from us, but that we live as instruments of that mystery — the divine meaning seeking expression through human care.</p><p>VI. The Love of Duty</p><p>The love of duty is the mature form of freedom. It turns sentiment into service, belief into action, faith into fellowship.</p><p>It begins with reverence — for G-d, for truth, for one another — and it ends in responsibility.</p><p>To place the love of duty before the reason of rights is not to reject modern liberty, but to complete it. It is to remember that the purpose of freedom is not self-assertion but self-transcendence — not isolation, but belonging. We are heirs to a sacred sequence:</p><p>Aristotle’s reason, Cicero’s justice, Christ’s compassion, Augustine’s insight, Aquinas’s harmony, Mazzini’s service, Paine’s humanity, King’s dream, and Kennedy’s courage.</p><p>Together they call us toward a cosmopolitan order of love — not an empire, but a fellowship of conscience.</p><p>If we would preserve our freedom, we must love it enough to serve it.</p><p>And if we would serve it rightly, we must love one another first — not as subjects of a nation only, but as citizens of meaning itself.</p><p>That is the love of duty before the reason of rights. And it is the work already begun.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=38068f3e3c91" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Dignity Must Come First]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/why-dignity-must-come-first-321c53e2e1c9?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/321c53e2e1c9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Sep 2025 23:02:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-22T11:32:15.848Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Excavating the Conservative Intellectual Roots of “Sustainable Leadership” — Cicero, Natural Law, and Kenotic Service — Now Converging with Modern Science to Shape the Future of Enterprise Sustainability</p><p><strong>The Compass We Forgot</strong></p><p>In a world increasingly on fire, Directors of Sustainability and other enterprise leaders face a paradox. On one hand, they have more tools, data, and frameworks than ever before: ESG metrics, scenario planning, TCFD disclosures, and supply-chain mapping software. On the other, the deeper moral grammar of leadership has thinned. We measure, but do we know how to judge? We optimize, but do we remember what we are optimizing for?</p><p>The categories of contemporary politics — progressive vs. conservative, radical vs. reactionary — offer little help. But if we return to Cicero, the Roman statesman who first translated Greek philosophy into civic duty, we find a compass. His vision of natural law, dignity, and duty — later deepened by Augustine, Aquinas, Erasmus, Schiller, and refracted in modern servant leadership — converges with the latest insights of neuroscience, evolutionary psychology, and behavioral economics.</p><p>This essay excavates that lineage. Not to canonize Cicero, Augustine, or Aquinas, but to show how their insights resonate with today’s experimental and theoretical science. The result is what I call <em>Dignity First Leadership</em>: a cosmopolitan, collaborative approach to triple-bottom-line value creation — people, planet, profit — across the immediate, mid, and long term.</p><p><strong>Cicero: Natural Law and the Duties of Leadership</strong></p><p>In <em>De Officiis</em> (On Duties), written in 44 BC for his son, Cicero framed leadership not as power but as service to law rooted in nature.</p><p><em>“True law is right reason in agreement with nature, universal, unchanging, everlasting.”</em></p><p>Here lies the foundation of the Western tradition of human dignity. Cicero’s natural law is not the decree of emperors but the participation of human reason in the moral order of nature itself. This was radical conservatism: it conserved what was universal and unchangeable against the whims of the powerful.</p><p>Cicero set out four cardinal virtues — prudence, justice, courage, temperance — and organized them into duties (officia). Among them:</p><p>•<em>	Do no harm</em> unless compelled by justice.</p><p>•	<em>Keep faith</em> (fides) in contracts and promises.</p><p>•	<em>Act with decorum</em>, fitting one’s role and circumstances.</p><p>•	<em>Subordinate glory</em> (dignitas and gloria) to the honestum (the truly honorable).</p><p>For Cicero, leadership meant managing thymos — the spirited desire for honor and recognition — so it served justice rather than domination. The republic depended on it.</p><p><strong>Augustine: From Duties to Ordered Love</strong></p><p>Augustine admired Cicero; he credits reading his lost <em>Hortensius</em> with awakening his love of philosophy. Yet he judged Rome’s republic to have collapsed because its loves were disordered. In <em>The City of God</em>, Augustine diagnosed the libido dominandi — the lust to dominate — as the ruin of empires.</p><p>Civic life, he argued, could only endure when grounded in rightly ordered love (ordo amoris). Laws and duties still mattered, but they were fragile without inward transformation. Leaders must love justice more than glory, peace more than conquest, service more than domination.</p><p>For modern Directors of Sustainability, Augustine’s insight is painfully relevant. Enterprises collapse in trust when they love short-term earnings more than long-term resilience, market share more than ecological integrity. Leadership fails when its loves are disordered.</p><p><strong>Aquinas: Natural Law and Kenotic Magnanimity</strong></p><p>Aquinas, writing in the 13th century, reasserted Cicero’s natural law:</p><p><em>“Law is an ordinance of reason for the common good, promulgated by the one who has care of the community.</em>”</p><p>But Aquinas deepened it. Where Cicero prized magnanimity (magnitudo animi), Aquinas fused it with humility: true greatness aims at great things, but only for the common good, not for self-exaltation.</p><p>At the center of Aquinas’s theology of leadership lies the kenotic hymn of Philippians 2:</p><p><em>“Though he was in the form of G-d… he emptied himself, taking the form of a servant.”</em></p><p>Kenosis — self-emptying service — became the Christian grammar of authority. It was picked up in the Catholic magisterium and echoed in Anglican moral theology. Leadership was not domination but service ordered to the flourishing of others.</p><p><strong>Erasmus and Schiller: Educating Rulers and Citizens</strong></p><p>The Renaissance humanist Erasmus, in <em>The Education of a Christian Prince</em> (1516), explicitly drew on Cicero. He argued that rulers must be educated in humility, justice, and the arts, so that power would serve peace. If Cicero trained the citizen, Erasmus trained the prince.</p><p>Schiller, writing after the French Revolution, extended this to the people. In his <em>Letters on the Aesthetic Education of Man</em> (1795), he insisted that political freedom would collapse unless citizens’ sensibilities were cultivated by beauty. Art and culture harmonized sense and reason, forming free individuals capable of self-government.</p><p>Both echoed Cicero’s conviction: law alone is not enough. Leaders and citizens alike must be formed — educated in taste, virtue, and dignity — to sustain freedom.</p><p><strong>From Kenosis to Servant Leadership</strong></p><p>Fast-forward to the 20th century. Robert Greenleaf, reflecting on organizational crises, articulated Servant Leadership:</p><p><em>“The servant-leader is servant first… It begins with the natural feeling that one wants to serve, to serve first.”</em></p><p>This was not corporate altruism but a secular retrieval of kenotic leadership. Authority legitimized by empowering others; leadership measured by the flourishing of those served.</p><p>Servant Leadership echoes Cicero’s natural law, Augustine’s ordered love, and Aquinas’s humility-magnanimity synthesis. It provided modern enterprises with a grammar of leadership aligned with dignity.</p><p><strong>Cross-Cultural Parallels: A Cosmopolitan Convergence</strong></p><p>To stress: this inheritance is not exclusively Western, nor is Dignity First Leadership a book of Christian business leadership. Dignity-centered leadership is a cosmopolitan reality:</p><p>•	<em>Confucianism: ren</em> (benevolence) and li (ritual propriety) ground dignity in harmonious social relationships.</p><p>•	<em>Islam:</em> the Qur’an declares, “We have honored the children of Adam” (karamah), grounding dignity in creation itself.</p><p>•	<em>Vedic</em> thought: dharma and ṛta align leadership with cosmic and social order, sustaining both society and individual flourishing.</p><p>All converge on the same principle: leadership is just when it honors human dignity, aligns with a larger moral order, and cultivates service.</p><p><strong>Modern Science: Confirming Ancient Insight</strong></p><p>What is most striking is how experimental and theoretical science is now converging on these classical insights.</p><p>•	<em>Neuroscience</em> shows our brains are wired for empathy, fairness, and connection.</p><p>•	<em>Evolutionary psychology</em> confirms that cooperation, not competition alone, ensured human survival.</p><p>•<em>	Behavioral economics</em> (Kahneman, Thaler) reveals that fairness and trust outweigh narrow utility in decision-making.</p><p>•	<em>Social psychology</em> demonstrates that meaning and recognition drive performance more than material incentives.</p><p>•<em>	Systems theory</em> insists enterprises are not machines but communities nested within ecological and social networks.</p><p>Science validates what Cicero, Augustine, Aquinas, Erasmus, and Schiller intuited: humans are not merely rational calculators of gain, but irreducibly social, meaning-making, and dignity-seeking beings.</p><p><strong>Triple-Bottom-Line Leadership in a Complex Age</strong></p><p>Cicero’s duties map surprisingly well onto the triple bottom line:</p><p>•	<em>Justice → People</em>. Protect workers, communities, and supply chains; honor human dignity.</p><p>•	<em>Prudence → Planet</em>. Govern with foresight; align enterprise strategy with ecological limits.</p><p>•<em>	Beneficence and Temperance → Profit</em>. Generate value with discipline, avoiding the excesses that hollow long-term viability.</p><p>For Directors of Sustainability, the lesson is clear: strategy must be built not only for immediate compliance, but for mid-term adaptation and long-term regeneration.</p><p>Enterprises cannot thrive if they treat dignity as negotiable, people as expendable, or communities as disposable.</p><p><strong>Why Dignity Must Come First</strong></p><p>Cicero teaches us that leadership is always a moral choice. Augustine warns that without ordered love, enterprises collapse. Aquinas harmonizes humility with magnanimity in kenotic service. Erasmus and Schiller remind us that both rulers and citizens must be formed in virtue and taste. Greenleaf reframes this as Servant Leadership. Modern science confirms it all.</p><p>The conclusion is not sectarian but cosmopolitan, not nostalgic but experimental: in a world of cascading complexity, dignity must be the first principle of leadership.</p><p>That is the intellectual background for<em> “Dignity First Leadership; Developing &amp; Driving A World-Class Sustainability Strategy”. </em>The book itself offers the tested practices — drawn from over fifteen years of advising more than 100 global enterprises — that allow leaders to operationalize dignity in strategy, supply chains, and governance.</p><p>The ancient compass of natural law and dignity is converging with modern science. The task before us is not to choose between conservative or progressive, radical or reactionary. The task is to recover the wisdom that human beings are irreducibly social, meaning-making creatures who flourish most when dignity comes first.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=321c53e2e1c9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Recovering Dignity: Classical Wisdom, Modern Science, and the New Leadership Paradigm]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/recovering-dignity-classical-wisdom-modern-science-and-the-new-leadership-paradigm-d71377b3cf75?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d71377b3cf75</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 21 Sep 2025 16:49:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-21T17:31:40.348Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong><em>Why Leadership Needs a Deeper Compass</em></strong></p><p>In a world increasingly on fire — ecologically, politically, socially — there is a temptation to believe that leadership must be either hard-nosed realism or utopian dreaming. We are told that leaders must choose: be “progressive” or “conservative,” “radical” or “reactionary.” But what if that framing itself is broken? What if the categories that dominate our public discourse obscure a deeper truth about who we are, and what leadership requires in this century of cascading crises?</p><p>My forthcoming book<strong>, Dignity First Leadership; <em>Developing &amp; Driving a World-class Sustainability Strategy</em> (“DFL”)</strong>, builds on more than fifteen years of advising over one hundred Fortune 500 and global growth companies on their sustainability strategies. It is a practical handbook for enterprise leaders, especially Directors of Sustainability, who need actionable best practices to accelerate decarbonization and embed sustainability into core business strategy. But beneath those best practices lies an intellectual background that is rarely articulated: a recovery of ancient philosophical insights into human purpose and dignity, now confirmed and amplified by modern science.</p><p>This essay sketches some of that background. It shows how DFL is neither left nor right, progressive nor conservative, but rooted in an interdisciplinary convergence: the rediscovery, across philosophy and science, that human beings are not simply rational calculators of self-interest but irreducibly social, purpose-driven, and meaning-making creatures. Recognizing this is not nostalgia. It is a reframing of leadership paradigms — of thought, speech, and action — in light of both ancient wisdom and contemporary science.</p><p><strong>Classical Foundations: Telos, Dignity, and Leadership</strong></p><p>The idea that humans are more than consumers or laborers is not new. It has been central to philosophy for more than two millennia.</p><p>•	<strong><em>Aristotle</em></strong> argued that everything in nature has a telos — an end or purpose. For humans, that purpose is eudaimonia, flourishing. Leadership exists to orient communities toward the conditions of human flourishing: justice, courage, friendship, and a shared pursuit of the good life.</p><p>•	<strong><em>Cicero</em></strong> extended this into Roman thought, insisting that true law is “right reason in agreement with nature” and that the role of governance is to serve justice and the commonwealth, not the personal gain of rulers. Dignity (dignitas) meant the worth of every citizen to participate in the life of the republic.</p><p>•	<strong><em>The Stoics</em></strong>, from Epictetus to Marcus Aurelius, pushed this further, declaring that dignity inheres in all humans by virtue of reason and moral capacity, regardless of status or power. This was a revolutionary claim: a slave, no less than an emperor, possesses dignity.</p><p>In the East, similar insights emerged: <strong>Confucian</strong> philosophy grounded leadership in ren (benevolence) and li (ritual propriety), emphasizing that dignity and purpose are cultivated through social harmony and virtuous example. <strong>Buddhism</strong> taught that liberation requires not mere self-satisfaction but compassion and detachment from greed.</p><p>Across traditions, the message is clear: leadership is not the pursuit of domination or profit, but the cultivation of dignity and flourishing within community.</p><p><strong>Modern Betrayals: The Rise of Economism</strong></p><p>Modernity has often forgotten this inheritance. Since the Enlightenment, a strain of thought — sharpened by Bentham’s utilitarianism and encoded in mainstream economics — has reduced humans to utility-maximizers, driven only by the calculus of pleasure and pain. This economism has come to function as a de facto global moral philosophy.</p><p>It is powerful precisely because it is simple: individuals seek to maximize their utility, and society is just an aggregate of individual utilities. This assumption undergirds markets, policies, and corporate practices. But it is also false. It denies our lived experience as beings who sacrifice, who cooperate, who search for meaning and belonging. It erases dignity and reduces leadership to management of incentives.</p><p>The results are plain: alienation in the workplace, overconsumption of resources, social fragmentation, and ecological breakdown. Economism promised liberation through growth; instead, it has left us hollow, anxious, and precarious.</p><p><strong>The Scientific Turn: Rediscovering Our Nature</strong></p><p>What is remarkable — and what grounds the DFL thesis — is that a generation of experimental and theoretical science has now begun to demonstrate empirically what the ancients intuited: that humans are fundamentally social, cooperative, and purpose-driven.</p><p>•	<strong>Neuroscience</strong> shows that our brains are wired for empathy, trust, and social connection. Mirror neurons, oxytocin responses, and brain imaging confirm that we are not isolated utility-maximizers but relational beings.</p><p>•	<strong>Cognitive</strong> and social psychology demonstrates that meaning-making, fairness, and belonging are not luxuries but necessities. Experiments consistently show that people will sacrifice material gain for fairness, recognition, or solidarity.</p><p>•	<strong>Evolutionary psychology</strong> argues that our species survived and thrived because of cooperation, shared norms, and collective problem-solving, not because of atomized competition alone.</p><p>•	<strong>Behavioral economics</strong>, from Kahneman and Tversky to Thaler and Sunstein, has revealed the limits of rational-choice models and the deep role of heuristics, biases, and social norms. More importantly, it shows that dignity, fairness, and trust are not “irrational” but central to decision-making.</p><p>These findings converge on the same insight: the part of nature we have most misunderstood is human nature itself. We are not best described by economism but by a richer anthropology that reclaims our dignity as social and meaning-driven beings.</p><p><strong>Leadership at the Crossroads</strong></p><p>This convergence of ancient philosophy and modern science presents both a challenge and an opportunity. The challenge is stark: our inherited paradigms of leadership, grounded in economism and short-termism, are inadequate for a world of cascading crises. Climate breakdown, geopolitical instability, and technological disruption expose the bankruptcy of leadership models that treat humans as inputs or markets as the sole arbiters of value.</p><p>The opportunity is equally stark: by recovering dignity as the first principle of leadership, we can reframe decision-making in both governance and business.</p><p>•	In <strong>governance</strong>, dignity requires leaders to see citizens not as voters to be manipulated or consumers of public goods, but as participants in a shared moral project.</p><p>•	In <strong>business</strong>, dignity requires leaders to see employees, customers, and communities not as means to profit, but as ends in themselves, worthy of trust, fairness, and solidarity.</p><p>For Directors of Sustainability — those who must persuade, guide, and sometimes cajole their enterprises toward decarbonization and resilience — this reframing is not optional. It is strategic. A sustainability strategy that treats people as compliance obligations will fail. A strategy that recognizes and elevates dignity can align business with life and win enduring trust.</p><p><strong>Why Dignity First Leadership Matters</strong></p><p>DFL arises from this convergence. It is not progressive or conservative, radical or reactionary. It is deeply studied, pragmatically tested, and cross-partisan in resonance. Its core claim is simple but transformative:</p><p>•	Dignity is our evolved and differentiating need and capacity for constructive social meaning.</p><p>•	Leadership that begins with dignity can reframe how enterprises think, speak, and act.</p><p>•	This reframing is not utopian: it is grounded in both ancient philosophy and contemporary science, and it is tested in practice through more than fifteen years of advising over one hundred global enterprises.</p><p>The book offers actionable best practices: how to build world-class sustainability strategies, how to persuade boards and executives, how to embed purpose into operations, and how to accelerate decarbonization at scale. But beneath those practices lies the intellectual background sketched here: a reclamation of dignity as the first principle of leadership.</p><p><strong>Our Need Is For Leaders Not Management</strong></p><p>As discussed in DFL, management is the science of doing something right but leadership is the art of successfully prioritize right. In a world of growing uncertainty and complexity, we need is not so much for “management’” as it is for authentic and effective leaders.</p><p>The ancients remind us that leaders are shaped by moral choice. Modern science confirms that dignity, fairness, and solidarity are not optional extras but central to who we are. Our contemporary crises demand that we take these insights seriously.</p><p>What is at stake is more than sustainability strategy. It is the recovery of our joy in simply being — together, as irreducibly social, purpose-driven, and meaning-making creatures.</p><p>In a world increasingly on fire, the leaders who will matter are not those who calculate management efficiencies, but those who cultivate dignity first.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d71377b3cf75" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Universal Dignity as the Coherence Beacon]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/universal-dignity-as-the-coherence-beacon-4a484d50dda9?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4a484d50dda9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[machine-learning]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 20 Jul 2025 17:14:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-20T17:14:42.229Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By James F. Boyle, Concord, MA, July 19, 2025</p><p>A proposal for anchoring sustainable systems leadership in the timeless and now truly inclusive demand for human worth</p><p>In response to today’s escalating global risks — climate instability, governance breakdown, AI disruption, social polarization — a growing body of systems thinkers, complexity scientists, and leadership theorists are calling for what some now describe as a “Third Attractor”: a viable civilizational path forward that avoids both fragmentation and authoritarian control.</p><p>This emerging conversation — powered in part by the meteoric rise of AI-related thought leadership — recognizes that our traditional ways of organizing power, value, and knowledge are insufficient to meet the moment. At its heart lies a profound question:</p><p>What shared principle can guide our expanding systems of intelligence, coordination, and governance — across borders, sectors, and cultures?</p><p>Some theorists refer to this evolving intelligence network as the “Interbrain”: the distributed, digital, human-centered architecture that is already shaping how we think, collaborate, and decide together on a planetary scale.</p><p>But without a clear moral and epistemic signal — a coherence beacon — this system risks being co-opted, fragmented, or corrupted by short-term incentives, misinformation, and power asymmetries.</p><p>I propose that this Coherence Beacon must be: Universal Dignity.</p><p>🔥 Dignity and the Soul’s Forgotten Center</p><p>In The Republic, Plato describes the tripartite soul (psyche) as composed of:</p><p>1.	Appetite — the pursuit of freedom and pleasure,</p><p>2.	Reason — the search for order and understanding,</p><p>3.	Thymos — the spirited hunger for recognition, justice, and moral standing.</p><p>This third element — thymos — was long recognized, from Plato to Hegel, as the driver of political change and historical development. As Francis Fukuyama explains in Identity: The Demand for Dignity and the Politics of Resentment (2018), thymos is the third dimension of the soul, and its demand for dignity — not wealth or reason alone — has moved nations and defined revolutions.</p><p>But thymos was sidelined by the rise of 19th-century economics, which reduced human motivation to utility maximization — a dismal calculus of pleasure and pain. The rich moral architecture of the soul was displaced by consumption metrics.</p><p>And yet, the hunger for dignity has only grown.</p><p>🧭 Universal Dignity as the Organizing Principle</p><p>Universal Dignity is not merely an ideal. It is a practical organizing principle capable of anchoring:</p><p>•	Governance design,</p><p>•	Corporate leadership,</p><p>•	AI ethics,</p><p>•	And sustainable development.</p><p>It resonates because it is:</p><p>•	Philosophically grounded in the deepest traditions of Western and global thought,</p><p>•	Culturally affirmed across continents (Ubuntu, Ren, Karama, Imago Dei, Buddha-nature),</p><p>•	Theologically rooted in the Christian tradition that declared all people bear God’s image,</p><p>•	Politically enshrined in the American and French Revolutions, which secularized dignity — expanding it from kings and clerics to every citizen,</p><p>•	Universally claimed in our time by a generation born in the 21st century, who demand recognition across identity, class, and geography,</p><p>•	And scientifically validated by breakthroughs in behavioral economics, motivational psychology, and leadership theory.</p><p>This is no longer a partisan or religious claim. It is a civilizational foundation — and it is ready to be built upon.</p><p>🌍 From Incompleteness to Moral Coherence</p><p>Modern systems built solely on freedom (appetite) and control (logic) are incomplete and unstable. They drift toward incoherence, extraction, or oppression.</p><p>To center Universal Dignity is to reintroduce a stabilizing moral gravity — moving us from chronic disruption to regenerative coherence.</p><p>It is not a utopian vision. It is a necessary foundation for any system — corporate, governmental, or technological — that aspires to be resilient, just, and trusted.</p><p>🕊️ From Exclusive Privilege to Universal Worth</p><p>The evolution of dignity has been long and hard-won:</p><p>•	From class-bound privilege in ancient Greece and Rome,</p><p>•	To Christian expansion of moral worth across all souls,</p><p>•	To the democratic revolutions that secularized dignity for all citizens,</p><p>•	And now, to a truly universal understanding — recognized by those whose only revolution is their birth into a time that knows all people matter.</p><p>We are now, finally, of one equal temperament of heroic hearts — and the institutions we lead must reflect this moral truth.</p><p>🤝 Dignity as the Coherence Beacon of Sustainability Leadership</p><p>As leaders committed to building just, low-carbon, and regenerative economies, we must ask:</p><p>What value is sacred enough to shape our systems — but shared enough to scale them?</p><p>Universal Dignity is that value. We should ask:</p><p>Can it guide how we lead?</p><p>Can it shape how we build?</p><p>Can it anchor how we govern?</p><p>Can it be the Coherence Beacon that moves our world from fragmentation to flourishing?</p><p>#UniversalDignity #SustainabilityLeadership #ThirdAttractor #CorporateSustainability #PoliticalPhilosophy #BusinessEthics #Fukuyama #Thymos #Leadership #SystemicChange #AIandEthics #Interbrain #DanielSchmachtenberger #BehavioralScience #MoralImagination #HumanFlourishing</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4a484d50dda9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Universal Dignity: Recovering Who We Really Are]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/universal-dignity-recovering-who-we-really-are-6fcfface38a0?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6fcfface38a0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 18 Jul 2025 20:25:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-07-18T20:25:04.056Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By James F. Boyle, Concord, MA</p><p>CEO &amp; Founder, Sustainability Roundtable Inc. Author of “Dignity First Leadership”</p><p>www.sustainround.com</p><p>I. A Call to Recover Ourselves</p><p>We are living in a time of deepening civilizational uncertainty. The promise of freedom through markets and of order through governance, has left too many either alienated by chaos or crushed by control. The world is increasingly “on fire” — climatically, culturally, and cognitively — and yet the fundamental question we face is not technical, but moral:</p><p>What holds us together when neither freedom nor order alone is enough?</p><p>The answer begins with dignity. Not as sentiment. Not as policy. But as the deep moral grammar of who we are — as individuals, as cultures, and as a shared species inhabiting one fragile biosphere.</p><p>This manifesto is a call to recover universal dignity as the core organizing principle of our global age — what systems theorists have begun to call a Third Attractor and what collective intelligence architects describe as a new Interbrain — a moral signal of coherence capable of guiding us beyond the binary wreckage of late-stage modernity.</p><p>II. The Forgotten Third: Thymos as the Heart of the Human Soul</p><p>In The Republic, Plato divides the human soul into three parts:</p><p>1.	Epithymia — Our appetites: the love of freedom, pleasure, gain.</p><p>2.	Logos — Our rational mind: the love of order, reason, clarity.</p><p>3.	Thymos — Our spirit: the hunger for dignity, recognition, and moral standing.</p><p>For centuries, the Western liberal project has empowered the appetites and served the logos — but neglected the thymos. And with that neglect, our public life has grown both hollow and combustible.</p><p>Francis Fukuyama, in his brief but luminous 2018 book “Identity: The Demand for Dignity and the Politics of Resentment,” recovered this Platonic insight for the modern age. He writes of the “third dimension of the soul” — thymos — as the engine of political resentment, spiritual longing, and the search for meaning in a world that too often treats people as inputs, outputs, or data points.</p><p>“Human beings do not just want material things or legal recognition; they crave respect, moral standing, and to be seen.” — Francis Fukuyama</p><p>This craving is not a pathology — it is a universal and ineradicable feature of our moral architecture. It is thymos. And it is time we recognized it as such.</p><p>III. The Interbrain and the Third Attractor: Beyond Markets and States</p><p>The collapse of trust in institutions, the fracturing of sensemaking, and the rise of algorithmic manipulation have led a new wave of thinkers — Daniel Schmachtenberger, Nora Bateson, Jim Rutt, Benjamin Bratton — to explore what comes after the liberal order.</p><p>They call it the Third Attractor.</p><p>•	The First Attractor: Market Capitalism — free but fragmented, driven by appetite.</p><p>•	The Second Attractor: Centralized Statism — ordered but brittle, driven by logic.</p><p>•	The Third Attractor: An emerging paradigm seeking coherence, dignity, and planetary stewardship.</p><p>And the intelligence system that could make this possible? They call it the Interbrain: a globally-distributed, technologically-mediated, socially-evolving network of shared meaning-making. Not AI as dominator. Not bureaucracy as monitor. But humanity thinking together.</p><p>Yet this Interbrain — like any cognitive system — requires a signal of coherence. It needs a beacon, a principle of orientation and integrity. That signal must be dignity.</p><p>IV. Universal Dignity as the Coherence Beacon of the Interbrain</p><p>Dignity — our thymotic drive for moral recognition — is the universal, inalienable signal that:</p><p>•	Transcends culture yet honors it.</p><p>•	Resists humiliation but invites humility.</p><p>•	Grounds individual sovereignty while enabling mutual accountability.</p><p>As I explore in Dignity First Leadership, dignity is not an abstraction. It is the anchor of trust in the boardroom, the basis of justice in the economy, and the moral grammar of credible leadership.</p><p>In the Interbrain of the global noosphere, dignity is not simply a value — it is the coherence beacon that tells us:</p><p>•	What is true (vs. propaganda),</p><p>•	What is just (vs. efficient only),</p><p>•	What is flourishing (vs. profitable alone).</p><p>This is not utopian speculation. It is the minimum viable ethics for a world that wants to survive itself.</p><p>V. Cross-Cultural Resonance: Dignity Across Civilizations</p><p>This is not just a Western thesis. The moral architecture of dignity resonates across traditions:</p><p>•	Ubuntu (Southern Africa): “I am because we are.”</p><p>•	Ren (Confucianism): Humaneness, the mutual obligation to affirm.</p><p>•	Karamah (Islam): Innate human nobility, endowed by God.</p><p>•	Imago Dei (Christianity): Human beings as bearers of divine image.</p><p>•	Buddha-Nature (Mahayana Buddhism): The dignity of inherent awakening.</p><p>Each tradition, in its own way, affirms that we are not just consumers or citizens — we are beings worthy of reverence.</p><p>VI. A Renaissance of Dignity: Leading from Our Center</p><p>Leadership today must do more than manage risk or optimize returns. It must redeem a shared culture by reclaiming what is most human in us: our evolved, differentiating and unyielding demand for moral recognition.</p><p>In Dignity First Leadership, I argue that:</p><p>•	Executives must lead by affirming dignity in decision-making.</p><p>•	Enterprises must design around human worth, not just market worth.</p><p>•	Economies must serve life — not the other way around.</p><p>This is not a rejection of freedom or order. It is their reconciliation through the third dimension of the soul — thymos, the seat of our dignity.</p><p>The Third Attractor is not a destination. It is a moral commitment to build a civilization where:</p><p>•	The free are honored.</p><p>•	The just are upheld.</p><p>•	And all are seen.</p><p>VII. Conclusion: The Interbrain Will Reflect Who We Choose to Be</p><p>As the Interbrain grows — through sensors, platforms, narratives, and policies — it will reflect the signal it is given. If that signal is appetite, we will devour ourselves. If it is logic alone, we will freeze into technocracy.</p><p>But if that signal is dignity, then our collective intelligence will become not just coherent, but conscious.</p><p>Dignity is not an option. It is our birthright, our beacon, and our best hope.</p><p>Let us recover it. Let us lead with it. Let us build the Third Attractor together — from the center of who we really are.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6fcfface38a0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dignity First Leadership; Developing & Driving a World-class Sustainability Strategy]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/dignity-first-leadership-developing-driving-a-world-class-sustainability-strategy-ea2aa904019c?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ea2aa904019c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[business]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 04 Jul 2025 01:27:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-08-24T22:15:13.213Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h2>(To be published December 5th, 2025)</h2><h2>Preface</h2><p>July 3rd 2025</p><p>I. Born in Revolution</p><p>July 4 marks the 249th anniversary of the American Declaration of Independence — a radical proclamation that dignity, not domination, is the foundation of legitimacy. Though written within the contradictions of a slaveholding society, its moral core remains enduring: that human beings possess rights not because of their station, tribe, or wealth, but by virtue of their humanity alone.</p><p>That claim now demands a new defense.</p><p>Today, we face a different but no less urgent crisis of legitimacy. Across the world, we are witnessing a resurgence of authoritarian nationalism masquerading as strength: movements from Ankara to Delhi, Manila to Moscow, that reject the very premise of universal dignity in favor of hierarchy, supremacy, or market absolutism. These movements offer no consistent ideology — only the same ancient lie: that human beings are defined by submission, not sovereignty; by received identity, not self-chosen integrity.</p><p>The proper response to this is not silence, cynicism, or technocratic refinement. The proper response is leadership — not the exhausted leadership of metrics and margins, nor the procedural leadership of ESG compliance. What is needed now is something deeper: a leadership grounded in moral clarity, informed by science, shaped by empathy, and directed toward shared human flourishing.</p><p>Call that leadership Dignity First.</p><p>II. A New Framework for a New Era</p><p>Dignity First Leadership is a response to a failure. Not merely of governance or policy, but of paradigm and perception. Our world is not lacking intelligence, capital, or innovation. What it lacks is the kind of leadership capable of aligning those capacities with our highest shared values — leadership that can frame, think, speak, and act with moral coherence in the face of global ecological, social, and institutional breakdown.</p><p>This is a failure visible at every level of leadership — in states, firms, universities, and communities. We have spent decades refining our technical tools while leaving our moral frameworks hollow. The result is a leadership class adept at optimization but adrift in meaning, competent in analysis but paralyzed in action.</p><p>What has been lost — perhaps most consequentially — is our sense of dignity. As the materialist assumptions of modern economics became our de facto global moral philosophy, we traded moral imagination for models, and meaning for utility. In so doing, we replaced the soul with the stomach, reducing people to self-maximizing individuals. This shift did not just distort our institutions — it disfigured our inner lives, fueling pathological overconsumption, loneliness, and a cultural epidemic of alienation.</p><p>We need a new foundation. That foundation is not theoretical. It is already being laid — quietly, creatively — by a new generation of leaders committed to restoring dignity as the center of legitimate action. This book does not invent their work. It names it, defines it, and promotes it.</p><p>Call this paradigm Dignity First Leadership.</p><p>III. A Career in Service of Alignment</p><p>This book is also the culmination of decades of professional and moral inquiry. It reflects my experiences as the principal co-founder of the Alliance for Business Leadership in Massachusetts, and then. as the Founder, CEO &amp; Chairman od Sustainability Roundtable Inc. (SR Inc) — a Public Benefit Corporation and Certified B Corp as well as the non-profit SR Inc supports: the Sustainable Leadership Foundation. Through each of these roles, I have worked with hundreds of company executives, public officials, and civic innovators seeking to align economic activity with enduring human values.</p><p>Through SR Inc, our team has advised over 100 Fortune 500 and global growth companies over multiple year in how to develop and drive world-class sustainability strategies. Our purpose, shared by every service and product we offer, is simple and unfinished: to help align business with life. It is a purpose that everyone I have ever asked supports. And yet, most all acknowledge it has not been remotely achieved and is not even regularly pursued.</p><p>This book is written to accelerate that alignment.</p><p>IV. Dignity Defined</p><p>At the heart of this work is a concept older than any firm and deeper than any strategy: dignity.</p><p>This book defines dignity, consistent with the Oxford English Dictionary and emerging behavioral science, as our evolved and differentiating need and capacity for constructive social meaning. Dignity is not a mere feeling, nor a formal status. It is the cornerstone of our shared humanity — the source of our moral claims, the foundation of our rebellion against injustice, and the psychological engine of trust and belonging.</p><p>When dignity is denied, legitimacy collapses. When it is honored, systems cohere.</p><p>Leadership, in this frame, is not simply the exercise of influence or the management of throughput. It is the stewardship of meaning — the capacity to recognize and elevate the dignity of those affected by enterprise action.</p><p>V. Human Nature Reconsidered</p><p>Science, too, is now catching up to what philosophy and theology long insisted: that human beings are irreducibly social. Where 20th-century economic models imagined us as isolated utility-maximizers, contemporary research is revealing that we are, above all, meaning-seeking, morally attuned, socially bonded beings.</p><p>It turns out that the part of nature we have most painfully misunderstood is human nature. In our haste to model the external world, we neglected the internal realities of motivation, identity, and trust. But this is changing. Work like that of Nicholas Christakis’s Human Nature Lab at Yale — spanning sociology, network theory, evolutionary biology, and public health — is reconstructing a picture of human beings as cooperative, emotionally intelligent, and profoundly relational. His lab’s research points to one of the most needed recognitions in our time: that the structures we build are only as strong as the social meaning they support.</p><p>Leadership that reflects this fuller human truth — this three-dimensional soul — is not only more just, but more effective. It moves faster, builds deeper trust, and generates more durable value. Whether in executive decision-making, enterprise operations, or economic design, dignity-centered leadership aligns institutional behavior with human design.</p><p>VI. A Paradigm Already in Motion</p><p>What makes the Dignity First framework powerful is not only its moral clarity, but its empirical grounding. It is not an abstract philosophy awaiting application — it is a lived reality already emerging across multiple domains of leadership. Though it has often lacked a unifying name, it has gained coherence through practice, through scholarship, and through its results.</p><p>In the sphere of Executive Leadership, Donna Hicks has shown that dignity is not an ornamental value, but a fundamental requirement for trust, cohesion, and legitimacy. Her work reveals how leaders who understand and safeguard dignity foster loyalty, resilience, and creativity. Michael Pirson, through the Humanistic Management movement, has advanced a vision of management as a moral profession — one that prioritizes flourishing over control and meaning over compliance.</p><p>In Enterprise Strategy, Rebecca Henderson has powerfully argued that the future of capitalism depends on its ability to reconnect with moral purpose. Her work shows that firms succeed not in spite of purpose, but because of it — when they treat people and ecosystems not as resources to be extracted but as partners in shared value. Andrew Winston builds on this by urging business leaders to be bold, courageous, and anchored in long-term stewardship, especially in the face of climate breakdown and social fragmentation.</p><p>In Economic Leadership, Gene Sperling reframes prosperity not in terms of output, but of human freedom — the ability to care for one’s family, contribute to community, and live with dignity. Kate Raworth has given us a new model — Doughnut Economics — that binds economic activity to social foundations and ecological ceilings, challenging growth as the sole measure of success. Mariana Mazzucato has redefined the role of public investment, demonstrating that states and markets must co-create missions oriented toward justice, resilience, and shared well-being.</p><p>Though these thinkers and practitioners vary in emphasis, they converge around a single principle: that dignity is not only ethically foundational but structurally consequential. Systems that ignore it decay. Institutions that center it endure.</p><p>VII. What the Book Offers</p><p>This book distills, synthesizes, and extends this emerging leadership paradigm. It is structured in four parts, each corresponding to a key sphere in which the dignity-centered framework must be understood and applied.</p><p>The first section, Reframing Leadership in the Anthropocene, introduces the systems logic that undergirds the book’s thesis. Drawing on Donella Meadows’ theory of leverage points, it shows that paradigm — the shared mental model of purpose and value — is the deepest place to intervene in a failing system. In an age defined by climate disruption, institutional distrust, and moral confusion, we do not need better models within the same frame. We need a new frame — one grounded in dignity as a human and ecological necessity.</p><p>The second section, Executive Leadership: The Human Core, focuses on how top leaders — CEOs, CFOs, board chairs, and senior executives — can practice dignity-first leadership in their language, strategy, and governance. It examines how trust is built through moral clarity, how decision-making can be guided by stakeholder recognition, and how courage can be institutionalized in teams.</p><p>The third section, Enterprise Leadership: Strategy with Soul, explores how dignity is translated into operations, procurement, reporting, supply chain management, and stakeholder engagement. It connects the ethical imperatives of human rights, climate justice, and inclusion with the tactical tools already familiar to Directors of Sustainability, from science-based targets to ESG frameworks. But it does so with a reframing: not as compliance, but as a form of moral leadership in action.</p><p>The fourth and final section, Economic Leadership: Legitimacy Beyond Growth, zooms out to examine the moral architecture of the economic system itself. It interrogates growth, redefines prosperity, and proposes how investors, institutions, and public-private partnerships can co-create economies centered on dignity, ecological balance, and inclusive value creation.</p><p>Each chapter offers conceptual clarity, real-world examples, and practical strategies to support implementation — because this is not merely a theoretical book. It is a guide for action.</p><p>VIII. Toward a Movement</p><p>Dignity First Leadership is not the final word in this emerging paradigm. But it is a name for it. A structure for its advancement. And a resource for the women and men already practicing it — often without permission, sometimes without recognition, but always with resolve.</p><p>The Alliance for Business Leadership, Sustainability Roundtable Inc., and this book are all part of a single moral and strategic project: to align business with life. Every person I’ve asked agrees that this is what we should be doing. It is what business was always meant to serve. It is what our laws, our models, and our institutions must now be realigned to support.</p><p>The world does not lack intelligence or capital. It lacks legitimacy. That cannot be manufactured. But it can be rebuilt — by leaders committed to truth, courage, and solidarity. This book is written for them.</p><p>Let us lead not merely with intelligence, but with integrity.</p><p>Not for image, but for impact.</p><p>Not for domination, but in defense of dignity.</p><p>Let us lead — with Dignity First.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ea2aa904019c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Absolute Immunity is Absolutely Anti-American]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/absolute-immunity-is-absolutely-anti-american-05a107bbe29f?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/05a107bbe29f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[culture]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Jul 2024 16:28:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-04T16:48:13.336Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The Supreme Court’s decision in <strong>Trump v. U.S.</strong>, which granted the President absolute immunity when engaged in official conduct, is grossly antithetical to the very purpose of the American Revolution that we celebrate on July 4th. This ruling undermines the core principles of accountability and the rule of law that the Revolution sought to establish, reducing American citizens to subjects under a leader who is explicitly placed above the law.</p><p>Justice Sotomayor’s dissent in this case eloquently articulates the dangers of absolute immunity. She draws on historical precedents and the Federalist Papers, specifically <strong>Hamilton’s Federalist No. 69,</strong> to underscore that the framers of the Constitution intentionally rejected monarchic immunity. Hamilton contrasted the limited, accountable executive power of the American President with the extensive, unaccountable power of the British monarch. Hamilton stated:</p><p><strong><em>“The President of the United States would be liable to be impeached, tried, and upon conviction … would be liable to prosecution and punishment in the ordinary course of law.”</em></strong></p><p>This passage highlights that the President, unlike a king, was intended to be subject to the law. Sotomayor points out that this intent was mirrored in the early state constitutions of Delaware, Maryland, and New York, which explicitly restricted executive immunity to ensure accountability. These states’ experiences with executive overreach under colonial rule informed their insistence on limiting the powers of their governors.</p><p>Moreover, Thomas Paine’s writings, particularly in <strong>“Common Sense</strong>,”vividly describe the tyranny of absolute authority. Paine condemned the notion of a king’s divine right and the resulting subjugation of citizens, arguing for a system where individuals were treated as citizens, not subjects. He wrote:</p><p><strong><em>“… of more worth is one honest man to society, and in the sight of God, than all the crowned ruffians that ever lived.”</em></strong></p><p>Paine’s critique of absolute monarchy underscores the inherent dignity and sovereignty of the individual, which absolute immunity for a President erodes. Granting such immunity effectively reintroduces a form of monarchical power, contrary to the Revolution’s aim of establishing a government of laws, not men.</p><p>This ruling is an insult to American citizens, as it effectively transforms them from free citizens into subjects of a man who is explicitly above their law. This notion was eloquently addressed by President John F. Kennedy in his inaugural address, where he recognized that the rights of man:</p><p><strong><em>“… come not from the generosity of the state but from the hand of God.”</em></strong></p><p>Kennedy’s statement reflects the belief that no man, including the President, should be above the law that emanates from a higher moral order and is shared equally among all citizens. The Supreme Court should remember Lord Acton’s dictum:</p><p><strong><em>“Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.”</em></strong></p><p>By granting absolute immunity to the President, the Court has placed one man above the shared law that rightly governs all Americans, contradicting the essence of the American Revolution and the enduring principles of equality and accountability.</p><p>The aptly named <strong>“Trump v. U.S.” </strong>decision, by endorsing absolute immunity for the President, grossly contradicts the vision of the founders and the hard-won principles of the American Revolution. It places the President above the law, echoing the very tyranny the Revolution sought to escape. Justice Sotomayor’s dissent, grounded in historical context and constitutional principles, warns of the profound dangers this ruling poses to American democracy. Her dissent should now be read every July 4th until this abomination is corrected and the office of American citizen restored as the highest office — in its legal dignity and protections — in our republic.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=05a107bbe29f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Democratic Autonomy vs. Nativist Servility]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/democratic-autonomy-vs-nativist-servility-48c9d89b984e?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/48c9d89b984e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 27 May 2024 16:40:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-07-13T15:45:07.313Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>On this Memorial Day, it is altogether right to reflect on ideals which millions of Americans have championed and which so many have sacrificed for — publicly and privately.</p><p>Ursula K. Le Guin’s profound insight into the role of women in efforts to build a more practical and effective nation for all resonates deeply with those who cherish the essence of democracy:</p><p>“We are volcanoes. When we women offer our experience as our truth, as human truth, all the maps change. There are new mountains. That’s what I want — to hear you erupting. You who have been told to button your lips, to sit down, and to be nice. For us to be the light, all the great forces must work to draw us back into the dark — but we are the light.”</p><p>I write today to help illuminate the contrasting paths of Democratic Autonomy and Nativist Servility, two distinct experiences reflecting the consequence of the choice a citizen makes when she or he determines how committed they are to protecting and promoting systems of universal adult elections and the impartial rule of law. Democratic Autonomy, is the lived experience of a functioning democracy, and is founded on collective self-government in the service of greater individual self-government. In contrast, Nativist Servility is the lived experience of authoritarian tyranny, where ethnic or cultural dominance overshadows the principles of freedom and equality.</p><p>At its best, the global and historic purpose of America, politically, socially and I submit even commercially, is to promote three foundational principles that make a democratic society possible. These three principles are: the freedom of conscience, the equal dignity of all, and the rule of law.</p><p>The current global landscape reveals a tragic trend veering away from these vitally important principles. Whereas political discourse globally used to be shaped by broadcast media that was structured to emphasize broad system efficiency, it is now shaped by social media, which is structurally focused on the individual participant’s relative social status and dignity. There has also been a shift to nearly zero marginal cost political communications and these shifts, together, have created an opportunity for unabashedly bigoted nativist authoritarians in various nations, to peddle a dead-end nostalgia for a bygone era of their ethno religious group’s dominance.</p><p>Unfortunately, the rise of a nativist authoritarianism is not confined to distant lands. Within the USA, the MAGA White Nationalist movement’s celebration of the January 6th deadly assault on our government and its rejection of our system of elections and our rule of law that is manifest in scores of city, state, and federal courts rulings MAGA White Nationalists categorically reject, represents a threat not seen since the slave states declared war on the USA.</p><p>This all recalls the ominous warning of Italian political theorist Antonio Gramsci who proved all too prescient when in 1934 he wrote from one of Mussolini’s prisons: “The old world is dying, and the new world struggles to be born: now is the time of monsters.” We must acknowledge, however, that as much as we pray and work to avoid it, when the time of monsters approaches so too does the time of heroes.</p><p>The cultural authority of the post-World War II rules-based order, developed and led by the United States, is under public and continuous assault from both foreign rivals led by China and Russia and domestic opponents, most notably the MAGA White Nationalist movement which rejects the merit and legitimacy of the U.S. led post WWII rules based world order. The post WWII order centered and celebrated the universalism of the Enlightenment as it built a system of universal human rights designed to transcend static received identities of race, religion, and geography. This anchored domestic and international respect for a rules based order in universal Enlightenment principles of empiricism and human dignity; which can be used to explode the tyranny of racial and religious majorities. Regrettably, these foundational principles of the Enlightenment are now regularly attacked domestically and internationally.</p><p>We find ourselves at a critical juncture where the consequences of a citizen’s political commitments will result in either living with Democratic Autonomy or in a profoundly insulting Nativist Servility. Because both domestically and internationally, nativist authoritarians are actively renouncing the legitimacy of free elections and the rule of law, institutions that are vital to the democratic societies that make possible the full expression of our human dignity.</p><p><strong>Democratic Autonomy</strong></p><p>Democratic Autonomy is the lived experience of a fully functioning democracy, which can be defined as collective self-government in the service of greater individual self-government. At its core, Democratic Autonomy rests on the three great principles: first, the freedom of conscience, second, the equal dignity of all, and, third, the rule of law. Each of these principles is interdependent, forming the bedrock and soil of a democratic society rightly committed to ever greater individual and collective self-government.</p><p><strong><em>The Freedom of Conscience</em></strong> ensures that individuals have the liberty to think, believe, and express their thoughts without fear of persecution. It is the foundation of all other freedoms, enabling a pluralistic society where diverse viewpoints, coexist to test and ennoble each other.</p><p><strong><em>The Equal Dignity of All</em></strong> insist on an unequivocal, organizing, commitment to the need and capacity of every individual to contribute to constructive social meaning, regardless of race, religion, gender, or any other characteristic. It requires that all people are treated as empowered choice making ends in themselves; never simply as means to another end. Consistent with this, JFK in his brilliant inaugural defined the belief animating the American Revolution that was “still at issue around the world,” as: “the belief the rights of man come not from the generosity of the state but from the hand of G/d.”</p><p><strong><em>The Rule of Law</em></strong> is the principle that laws govern the land, not the arbitrary whims of any man or group of men. A commitment to it is a commitment to ensuring that justice appears, and in every practical way is, impartial with everyone held accountable to the same legal standards.</p><p>Together, these principles interact to breath vitality into a society where individuals can fully participate in their governance, ensuring their voices are heard and their dignifying right to self-government fully expressed.</p><p><strong>Nativist Servility</strong></p><p>Nativist Servility, the parallel to Democratic Autonomy, is the lived experience of nativist authoritarianism empowered. It reflects the deadening dominance of a particular ethnic or cultural group over others, at the expense of minority rights and democratic principles. Leaders like Viktor Orbán in Hungary, who extol “illiberal democracy,” Recep Tayyip Erdoğan in Turkey, who proudly has protesters pummelled, Vladimir Putin in Russia, Xi Jinping in China, and Narendra Modi in India, who increasingly flatters Hindu chauvinism, exemplify a worldwide movement towards the sulfurous hate that charges nativist authoritarianism with its energy.</p><p>These leaders proudly curtail freedom of conscience, reject an unequivocal commitment to the equal dignity of all and reject an organizing commitment to the rule of impartial law enforced by independent courts. This trend attacks the basis of a democratic society and leads to power being concentrated in the hands of a few who thrill at the mantra “might is right.” Which it never is for human beings because we are endowed with souls (in Greek, “psyche”) of profound depth through which we experience life and which makes possible society shaping human connections across even continents and centuries.</p><p><strong>The Intersection of Principles</strong></p><p>It can be persuasively argued that one insight Homo Sapiens have earned over the last many centuries, is how important it is to individual and collective flourishing to center and celebrate the freedom of conscience, the equal dignity of all, and the rule of law. Which are deeply interconnected and mutually supporting. Without the freedom of conscience the equal dignity of all and the rule of law cannot be safeguarded in world of always changing thought and expression. Without a centering of the equal dignity of all, the rule of law becomes skewed, favoring some over others. And without the rule of law, a society becomes subject to the ancient brutish lie of the mob: “might is right.”</p><p>In the U.S. and Europe a generation of self-referential academic progressive intellectuals did not help by failing to appreciate that the contest of ideas that most counted extended well beyond their ivied campuses. To areas where universal principles were needed, first and foremost, to protect minority identities from majorities all too motivated by ill will to believe they shared nothing with minorities but contempt. They rightly illuminated where colonial powers had fallen grotesquely short of their own universal ideals but discrediting those ideals instead of those who failed them is not constructive.</p><p>To uphold Democratic Autonomy, we must ensure that the universalist principles of the Enlightenment are recovered, centered and celebrated. Because this enables the vital functioning of truly democratic society: one where individuals share a deep and organizing commitment to respecting others freedom of conscience, to recognizing and magnifying the dignity of all others and to respecting the rule of no one man or group of men but the rule of impartial law.</p><p><strong>Conclusion</strong></p><p>Against the backdrop of rising nativist authoritarianism and the erosion of democratic norms, it is incumbent upon us all to reaffirm our commitment to these organizing and enduring principles. Stepping towards Democratic Autonomy requires safeguarding individual liberties, participatory governance committed to universal human dignity and the rule of law, while rejecting a surrender to Nativist Authoritarianism, which undermines the vigor and essence of democracy and our lives.</p><p>In these challenging times, we can commit to a courageous, continuous and creative collaboration that lifts a lamp that illuminates the path to a future built on our conscience unbound, the equal dignity of all and the rule of law. On this Memorial Day, let us honor the sacrifices made for these principles by committing ourselves in immediate, practical and enduring ways to the ceaseless but creative fight for freedom, dignity, and the rule of law.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=48c9d89b984e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Leading with Dignity in 2021]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesfboyle.medium.com/leading-with-dignity-in-2021-2be1fb8bac42?source=rss-947b7603b447------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2be1fb8bac42</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sustainability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[corporate-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[systems-change]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[policy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James F. Boyle]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 26 Jan 2021 22:56:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-07T19:38:11.320Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>“<em>The crises we face are not a science problem, they are a human problem.” </em></strong><em>— </em>Doug McMillon, CEO, announcing Walmart will become a “Regenerative Company”</p><p><strong>Introduction:</strong></p><p>Doug McMillon is right. As we confront the triple, mutually reinforcing, challenges of: an uncontrolled pandemic, wrenching social inequity and the mounting threat of irreversible environmental breakdown, we must acknowledge that these are driven by human beings and are, therefore, “a human problem.” In part because these crises can be informatively understood as arising out of an “industrial age paradigm” of public and private leadership and policy that is premised on what science is increasingly revealing to be a misunderstanding of human nature. The same misunderstanding that has distorted micro and macroeconomic theory and policy for generations. Fortunately, a new leadership paradigm is being developed for broader society and those businesses willing to acknowledge they are rightly understood to be dependent on, and embedded within, societies. Dr. Donna Hicks’ <strong>Leading with Dignity; <em>How to Create a Culture That Brings Out the Best in People”</em></strong> (2017) provides a resonate central motif and approach supported by Michael Pirson’s academically rigorous “<strong>Humanistic Management; <em>Protecting Dignity and Promoting Well-Being”</em></strong> (2017) and the International Humanistic Management Association, Inc. Pirson leads. Their work supports an emerging, relatively simple, human, not market centered paradigm premised on a generation of scientific learning across disciplines that validates ancient thought traditions about human nature. It also could prepare enterprises and, ultimately, economies to address the immense challenge a generation of global science has revealed we face in human caused environmental breakdown. It is a new paradigm of leadership that seems well designed to resonate with the souls (i.e., in Greek: “psyche”) of those women and men inclined to work together in a creative and purposed solidarity to transform our “human problem” into a demanding but brilliant flourishing. Wherein complex and even chaotic systems including large enterprises, markets and economies are organized by well reasoned and passionately lived commitments to make them serve the demands of the universal, inviolable and inalienable dignity of all the individuals involved and the natural environment that sustains us all. Those that embrace this approach should enjoy a flourishing that will be first their own but — as science suggest is necessary — expressly for the benefit others. Which can be realized through lived commitments and attitudes that reflect their reverence for the complexity and beauty of life which they can be humble before as servant leaders enlivened by their shared and urgent mission.</p><p>What follows is an informal survey of the leading thinkers, recent books and even choice quotes that help support this new paradigm of leadership. First in enterprise strategy, then in economic theory and then in economic policy. To promote an approach in an increasingly complex and chaotic time that puts the needs of people and the natural environment that sustains us, first.</p><p><strong>From Optimizing Markets For “Efficiency” to Human Centered Leadership to Vindicate “Dignity”</strong></p><p>Fifteen years ago, Walmart’s public commitment to “Corporate Sustainability” helped build what was then a small and esoteric field. On the 15th anniversary of Walmart’s commitment to Corporate Sustainability, CEO Doug McMillon committed Walmart (which is now the world’s largest private employer operating in 28 countries) to becoming a “<em>Regenerative Company, one dedicated to placing nature and humanity at the center of our business</em>” to help transform the world’s supply chains to be regenerative and help reverse nature loss. This commitment was made through a remarkable <a href="https://corporate.walmart.com/newsroom/videos/2020-regeneration-doug-mcmillon-speech">14 minute video</a> through which McMillon pledged that Walmart would move beyond achieving its goals of 100% renewable energy, zero waste to landfill and its success in increasing its minimum wage more than 50%. Because “more must be done urgently” to grapple with the public health crisis, wrenching economic and racial inequity in the U.S. and abroad and also, in particular, because we face a “climate crisis” that threatens to become irreversible.</p><p>Walmart’s CEO recognized “<em>that this is a watershed moment in history, where all of humanity is coming together, whether we realize it or not</em>” and that “<em>we have created an astonishing moment of truth</em>” wherein we must confront the threat of human caused, irreversible and self-accelerating climate breakdown. McMillon went further and recognized “<em>the crises we face are not a science problem, they are a human problem</em>” and that although “<em>technologies are important . . . the ultimate power to change the world does not rely on them alone, it relies first and foremost on reverence, respect and compassion for ourselves, all people and the natural environment that sustains us all</em>. <em>This is regeneration.</em>”</p><p>In the stark, necessary, challenges it identifies and in its soaring optimism that those challenges can be met with the approach he details, McMillon’s speech is a study in leadership communications. It contrasts sharply with a mushrooming industry of academics and writers who don’t seek to lead as much as report the very real horrors of climate and ecological breakdown and who, therefore, regularly only offer wistful and qualified hope we will meet these existential challenges. One such writer is Jed Purdy who was raised in rural West Virginia and recently joined the faculty of Columbia Law School. His analysis and eloquence focuses on the intersection of the global environmental crisis American politics, law and culture. His new book “<strong>This Land is Our Land; <em>The Struggle for a New Commonwealth</em></strong>” (2019) is aligned with McMillon’s speech in that it recognizes that we face an urgent existential challenge in potentially irreversible environmental breakdown and that it is a “human problem.” But he is far less confident we have any real prospects for success and in the last chapter observes that “<em>we are suffering not from ignorance or innocence but from a lack of faith that understanding can help us.”</em></p><p>For me that evokes a poem W.B. Yeats wrote a hundred years ago communicating a similar lack of faith among the educated about the future social importance of integrity and truth. Yeats published “<strong>The Second Coming</strong>” in 1920 and it reflected the disillusionment the slaughter of the first world war inspired as well as elite foreboding about the even greater horrors to that seemed to be gathering in an always more unsettled world. Then as now many of the most extensively educated agreed with Yeats that: <em>“The ceremony of innocence is drowned, the best lack all conviction while the worst are full of passionate intensity.”</em> Which in its unnerving despair reminds those that would lead: although academics and poets are essential to facing the “human problem” we must solve to restore a widely felt sense of hope about the future, we also need many different type of leaders. Which in this age of globally ascendent businesses and faltering nation states, necessarily includes business leaders and their particular insights, style, creativity and courage in change.</p><p><strong>Do Business Leaders Need To Focus On This “Human Problem”?</strong></p><p>Many business leaders will assert that speaking about what Walmart’s CEO describes as an “astonishing moment of truth” wherein “the entire world is coming together whether we realize it or not” and the “human problem” that is driving its threatening dimensions, is beyond what most any business leader can meaningfully address — except maybe for the CEO of the world’s largest employer. But the argument business leaders should focus tightly on the practical productivity of those they are charged with managing, may well be part and parcel of the “human problem” Walmart’s CEO suggested was at the heart of health, social and ecological crises we face.</p><p>As Stephen Covey — author of the hugely popular “<strong>7 Habits of Highly Effectively People</strong>” (1990) — recognized in “<strong>The 8th Habit; <em>From Effectiveness to Greatness</em></strong>” (2004) the fundamental “problem” of the “post-industrial knowledge economy” is that most managers continue to embrace an “industrial age paradigm” that seeks to control, extract and exchange “things” — including people. As opposed to respecting people as creative, choice making ends in themselves, who seek their own voice and purpose. Covey quoted Henry David Thoreau in saying <em>“there are thousands hacking at the branches of evil to one that is striking at the root.” </em>And in identifying what Covey conceptualized as the “industrial age paradigm” — which can be described as a model (as opposed to individual human being) focused ethics that seeks efficiency through control, extraction and exchange of “things” — Covey seems to have been striking at the root of what Walmart’s CEO recognized as our current “human problem.” Which may explain why Doug McMillon felt it was all together appropriate for the world’s largest employer to make a deliberate, public, values defining commitment to its practical opposite in: “<em>reverence, respect and compassion for ourselves, all other people and the natural world that sustains us all.”</em></p><p><strong>Can Leaders Transcend Assumptions &amp; Drive Fundamental Change?</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/580/0*mi5FqVnsz_VssSc9.png" /></figure><p><em>Donella Meadows’ Concept of 12 Leverage Points to Change Complex Systems</em></p><p>Steven Covey is as mainstream and successful a business expert as exists. But in his “<strong>The 8th Habit; <em>From Effectiveness to Greatness</em></strong>” he was demonstrating the power of Donella Meadows’ work. Meadows was an Environmental Scientist at Dartmouth focused on Systems Change to avert environmental collapse who died too young in 2001 but seems only more important in 2021. Meadows published a seminal essay in 1999 entitled: “<strong>Leverage Points; <em>Places to Intervene in a System</em></strong>.” Therein she detailed twelve leverage points through which one could work to change large and complex systems such as a large corporation, an economy or even our relationship to the natural world. Meadows identified “transcendence” and “paradigm change” as the first and second most highly leveraged ways to effect change in complex systems. By the first she meant the ability to emotionally internalize that every system is premised on certain paradigms or fundamental “mental models” such that someone could transcend their own most ingrained or assumed frameworks of perception. In regard to the second, “paradigm change”, Meadows was borrowing a concept from Thomas Kuhn’s well noted 1962 book “<strong>The Structure of Scientific Revolutions</strong>” which held that once a “paradigm” or fundamental framework is changed (e.g., the idea in early medicine that sickness was in the blood and that, therefore, bloodletting would help), the entire related field would change. Meadows applied the concept to deliberate societal change and used the example of Ronald Reagan’s persistent and ultimately successful assertion of a new fundamental framing of American politics when he pushed beyond discourse about the proper role of government to assert that the government, itself, “was the problem.”</p><p>This concept that both Covey and Meadows promoted that regularly unconscious or only partial conscious fundamental frameworks or “paradigms” (from the Greek “paradeigmata” or exemplar mythic story) out of which complex systems can arise — aligns with both ancient wisdom and emerging science. Plato recognized how stories can shape character, culture and behavior and in the dialogues within “<strong>The Republic</strong>,” the argument that “<em>our first business is to supervise the production of stories and choose only those suitable and reject the rest</em>” was well presented and proposed to apply to the most cherished stories from the nursery to affairs of state and religion. Similarly, as contemporary economics was taking shape following World War II, MIT’s Paul Samuelson observed, “<em>I don’t care who writes the nation’s laws or advanced treatises, if I can write its economics textbook</em>.”</p><p>More recently, Israeli intellectual historian Yuval Noah Harari’s wildly well received “<strong>Sapiens” (2011)</strong>, “<strong>Homo Deus” (2015) </strong>and “<strong>21 Lessons for the 21st Century” (2018) </strong>each review the growing evidence in evolutionary psychology, social psychology and cognitive science that Homo sapiens evolutionary adaptation includes a defining ability to develop and share stories and meanings about subjects without any physical existence; which facilitates sapiens unmatched ability to cooperate to overcome adversity and reproduce. So social psychologist John Haidt only had it half right in “<strong>The Righteous Mind; <em>Why Good People Are Divided By Politics &amp; Religion</em></strong><em>”</em> published in 2013 that Sapiens are “<em>90% chimp and 10% bee</em>,” since we are also believers in shared meanings, from conceptions of divinity to national histories, to currencies and “human rights” which is an evolved capacity that has helped sapiens cooperate across continents, centuries and wars to reproduce into the billions.</p><p>So, if we agree with Meadows that leaders can transcend their received traditions and that largely unconscious paradigmatic frameworks of perception can be identified and deliberately changed through concerted effort to effect great practical change system-wide — can we agree that the paradigm that needs to change is the one identified by Stephen Covey as “the problem” in his second chapter by that name in “<strong>The 8th Habit</strong>”? Covey defined “the problem” causing so much unhappiness in the modern workplace as the “industrial age paradigm” which treated people as “things,” which defies Immanuel Kant’s famous definition of “human dignity” as a quality that requires that humans ‘must never be treated as just means to an end, but as an ends in themselves.’</p><p>As 2021 begins, can we also recognize the error of the “industrial age paradigm” includes it’s unthinking instrumentalization of parts of living co-dependent ecological systems as “things”? In 2009, the philosopher and ethicist Robert Audi of Notre Dame recognized in “<strong>Business Ethics &amp; Ethical Business</strong>” the environment is rightly understood as “<em>an end not just a means</em>” and that the “<em>principle of intergenerational justice</em>” obligated businesses to act responsibly even in the absence of legal requirements. In 2015, Pope Francis went further in his epic encyclical on Integral Ecology, “<strong>Laudato Si; <em>Praise Be Our Common Home</em></strong>” to propose an evolution of consciousness. There the pope (who was a working chemist before his eleven years of intellectual and spiritual training to become a Jesuit) argued human beings of every religious persuasion and those without religion, could recognize we are “<em>part of the single garment of creation</em>” and what we perceive as the rest of creation is not ours to assume we can “utilize” and we could, instead, respond to what we perceive as the “rest of reality” with praise.</p><p><strong>Evolving from a Model Wherein Individuals “Extract Value” to “Shared Purpose”</strong></p><p>To the extent Covey’s “industrial age paradigm” model of behavior focused on controlling, extracting and exchanging “things” is a degrading instrumentalization of the natural world, then it is exactly the type of paradigm Meadows would hope leaders could transcend and change. To advance that, Meadows counseled both a systematic and dramatic highlighting of the faults of the incumbent paradigm and a relentless assertion of the supplanting paradigm’s advantages. Often through a network of colleagues who share a commitment to the superior fundamental framework. Consequently, to follow Meadows’ lead, it is necessary to move beyond a critique of the faltering “industrial age paradigm” and to examine the advantages of a proposed, superior, paradigm.</p><p>Steven Covey’s proposed new “knowledge economy paradigm” in “<strong>The 8th Habit</strong>” was one that invited the managers to find their “voice” and “purpose” and inspire those they lead to do the same. This approach to managing is likely to resonate better with today’s knowledge workers over the “industrial age paradigm” on several levels. First, it proposes a system centered on the human beings involved instead of on the optimization of the system. Second, it recognizes the manager needs to become more self-aware of her own “voice” and “purpose”; and third, it recognizes managers must seek to “inspire” and facilitate the “voice” and “purpose” of her teammates. Unfortunately, writing in 2004 before the depth, breadth and urgency of the threat of irreversible environmental breakdown was widely understood in business, Covey does not emphasis the need for a new relationship with our environment in his description of the required new leadership paradigm (although he does delineate a need to pay systematic attention to “conscience” through which this concern would now manifest).</p><p>Almost a generation after Covey published “<strong>The 8th Habit,</strong>” an ever-growing number of knowledge workers have come to understand that climate science warns of the mounting threat of irreversible, self-accelerating, environmental collapse as the ultimate price of production costs that are “externalized” from current economic value creation models. Consequently, as 2021 begins, it seems appropriate and even necessary to include a fundamentally changed relationship with the world at large as part of new paradigm of leadership that is capable of meeting today’s challenges. Supporting this type of audacity is a growing chorus of top business and thought leaders now extolling the need to think bigger and even “reimagine capitalism”. In-part because prevailing economic patterns are obviously unsustainable.</p><p>A leader among these leaders is Rebecca Henderson who recently published “<strong>Reimaging Capitalism; <em>In a World on Fire</em></strong>” (2020). The first two words of that title is the name of what is reportedly the most popular class at Harvard Business School, which Henderson has led in teaching for ten years. Henderson’s book was reviewed on this <a href="http://sustainround.com/2020/08/07/reimagined-capitalism/">Sustainable Leadership blog</a>) and provides dozens of case studies of impressive twenty first century enterprise leadership highlighting leaders who embrace a shared purpose driven, multi-stakeholder, approach to long-term value creation. Henderson even quickly mentions business leader’s engagement with economic development at large. Specifically, she sites Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson’s who partnered to write “<strong>Why Nations Fail</strong>” in 2015 and “<strong>The Narrow Corridor; States Societies, and the Fate of Liberty</strong>” in 2019, to encourage business leaders to move beyond the blinkered framing of “government versus markets” and, instead recognize the superiority of the “inclusive versus extractive” framing that is broadly accepted among development economists.</p><p>Henderson’s focus, however, is on next generation enterprise strategy; and she makes an important contribution to that through her persuasive arguments and case studies encouraging business leaders to move beyond a prioritization of short-term shareholder interest to a shared purpose driven, multi-stakeholder, long-term value creation and she recognizes that now must occur in a changed context that is shaped by a world that is actually and increasingly “on fire.” Consistent with Harvard Business School’s practical focus on case studies, she does this through dozens of compelling, detailed, examples of aligned leadership. Henderson does not focus on delineating the new paradigm for leadership itself.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/0*opNCE82j43UZ17AS.jpg" /><figcaption>Leading With Dignity, Dr. Donna Hicks, Yale University Press (2017)</figcaption></figure><p>Fortunately, that is something a scholar focused on excellence in leadership has recently done just across the Charles River from Rebecca Henderson at the JFK School of Government. Dr. Donna Hicks is a psychologist who gained global notice through her efforts to help advance the peace process in Northern Ireland and between Palestine and Isreal. In her 2017 “<strong>Leading with Dignity; <em>How to Create a Culture that Brings Out the Best in People</em></strong>” Dr. Hicks has proposed a new paradigm for leadership that is premised on a scientific understanding of human nature and centered on a leader’s relationship with herself, other people and the world at large. Since she emerged as a leader in international dispute resolution and teaches at a leading school in public administration, Dr. Hicks ground-breaking work on the role of “dignity” in organizational leadership has not been as widely discussed as it deserves in the popular and academic discourse on responsible business leadership. Ken Frazier, Chairman &amp; CEO of Merck &amp; Co., Inc. has, however, recognized that: “<em>Donna Hicks articulates for business leaders not only a grand concept but also a practical framework for strengthening corporate culture by recognizing and promoting the inherent value of each employee</em>.”</p><p>Since Dr. Hicks’ new paradigm for organizational leadership was developed outside of any business school and as a model for leadership in societies throughout the world, it is not surprising that it is well aligned with the markedly expanded social and environmental expectations and demands facing today’s business leaders. Coming from beyond the walls of a business school or consultancy, it is also not surprising that Dr. Hicks’ 2011 book “<strong>Dignity; <em>Its Essential Role in Resolving Conflict</em></strong>” and her 2017 “<strong>Leading with Dignity<em>” </em></strong>both reflect a sophisticated understanding of the emerging cross-discipline re-evaluation of the human nature that has occurred over the last generation. Which she explores to help explain the success she has had centering “dignity” in international dispute resolution and in teaching and advising on enterprise leadership strategy.</p><p><strong>A New Paradigm for Leadership in a Challenged &amp; Purpose Driven Age</strong></p><p>What Dr. Hicks proposes is relatively simple and aligned with Stephen Covey’s guidance from “<strong>The 8th Habit” </strong>in that it focuses on personal excellence and relationships as opposed to system or model optimization. But unlike Covey, Dr. Hicks expressly focuses on the quality of relationships including an important relationship with the broader world. Dr. Hicks guides leaders to focus — first, foremost and regularly — on three connections: a connection to self, a connection to others and a connection to the broader world. In each instance, Hicks guides the leader to address — in what might well be described as a reverential manner — our own pricelessness and vulnerability as a human being, the same in those we serve as leaders as well as the pricelessness and frailty something greater than us such as the broader world. Failing to observe this three-pronged discipline causes inefficiencies since it is premised on our needs as irreducibly social, purpose seeking, beings with a developed and vulnerable sense of our own fundamental, inalienable, worth — or “dignity” — and hunger for greater, more fairly earned, “respect.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/331/0*cJ-2WGZ5Bj0wOQhW.jpg" /><figcaption>Humanistic Management, Michael Pirson, Cambridge University Press (2017)</figcaption></figure><p>In “<strong>Leading with Dignity</strong>” Hicks praised Michael Pirson’s 2017 Book “<strong>Humanistic Management; <em>Protecting Dignity and Promoting Well-Bein</em>g”</strong> and the International Humanistic Management Network Pirson leads. Pirson’s book provides an academically rigorous explication of the management science supporting Hicks approach to leadership in “<strong>Leading with Dignity</strong>.” In that book Hicks cites leading evolutionary psychologists and social psychologists and, specifically, the work of neuroscientist Bruce Perry and his co-author Maia Szalavitz who claim we are “<em>born for love</em>” in a 2010 book by that name. Which is all consistent with Harvard University’s great biologist E.O Wilson “<strong>The Social Conquest of the Earth”</strong> in 2015 which helped established the “eusocial” (i.e., hyper social) nature of Homo sapiens. Wilson observed in that memorable book: “<em>morality, conformity, religious fervor and fighting ability combined with imagination and memory produced Homo sapiens as a winner in terms of survival.”</em> Hicks’ approach is also aligned with the work of Nicholas A. Christakis, a physician and sociologist who directs the Human Nature Lab at Yale (inspired by the cross-discipline re-evaluation of human nature) who two years after <strong>Leading with Dignity</strong> published: “<strong>Blueprint; <em>The Evolutionary Origins of a Good Society” </em></strong>in 2019 which further summarized relevant theoretical and experimental based science.</p><p>The new paradigm for leadership offered by Dr. Donna Hicks in “<strong>Leading with Dignity</strong>” is, therefore, premised on current science about our irreducibly social needs (which is important to contrast with the endless “wants” assumed by contemporary economics) as human beings and provides a path to highlight and address the important change in context that science is revealing to all the stakeholders of an enterprise about the existential threat of human caused environmental breakdown. Consequently, Dr. Hicks’ leadership paradigm is an excellent approach for women and men who want to address the “human problem” Walmart’s CEO acknowledged. In part through acknowledging that the part of nature we have most painfully misunderstood is human nature and its needs; which we must address to improve our relationship with ourselves, others and with the boarder world. Three relationships influenced by the context science is revealing about the threat of irreversible environmental breakdown.</p><p>Furthermore, Dr. Hicks’ proposed paradigm for leadership is also aligned with, first, the emerging consensus in micro-economic theory and practice from “shareholder first” approaches to purpose driven multi-stakeholder value creation; and, second, the distinct, aligned evolution of macro-economic theory and analysis that also seeks to take into current science about human nature as well as complexity theory and the mounting existential threat of human caused environmental breakdown.</p><p><strong>Leading With Dignity Into a New Micro and Macro-economics</strong></p><p>The emerging consensus at the enterprise or micro-economic level is more than academic. As noted earlier on this Sustainable Leadership blog, 181 CEOs of America’s largest corporations who participate in the Business Roundtable committed in August of 2019 through a full page Wall Street Journal ad to a new “<a href="https://www.businessroundtable.org/business-roundtable-redefines-the-purpose-of-a-corporation-to-promote-an-economy-that-serves-all-americans">Statement on the Purpose of the Corporation</a>” which committed them to a purpose driven, multi-stakeholder approach to long-term value creation. In the statement they specifically recognized that corporations exist to benefit stakeholders such as customers, employees, suppliers and host communities as much as shareholders. This represented a specific reversal of a Business Roundtable publicly declared definition of the purpose of the corporations in 1997 that: “<em>The paramount duty of management and of boards of directors is to the corporation’s stockholders</em>. <em>The interests of the other stakeholders are relevant as a derivative of the duty to the stockholders.” </em>This high-profile reversal has helped catapult the “multi-stakeholder capitalism” advocated for more than a generation by the World Economic Forum which meets annually in Davos and is reflected in “<a href="https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/12/davos-manifesto-2020-the-universal-purpose-of-a-company-in-the-fourth-industrial-revolution/">Davos Manifesto 2020</a>” into mainstream business strategy in the U.S. and globally.</p><p>The change to a more science based, ecologically sophisticated, macroeconomics has also been developing for a generation if not the forty plus years that a multi-stakeholder approach to enterprise value has been. A new economics in the broad sense began to gestate when Paul Hawken published in 1993 (a decade before he began advising Walmart) “<strong>Ecology of Commerce; <em>A Declaration of Sustainability</em></strong>”. And took meaningful form in Hawken’s magnum opus in 1999 with Hunter &amp; Amory Lovins’ “<strong>Natural Capitalism; <em>Creating the Next Industrial Revolution</em></strong>,” which helped create a generation of sustainability activists as it made clear contemporary economics was woefully unacceptable in accounting for and preserving our vitally important environment. As the authors noted in “<strong>Natural Capital”</strong>, contemporary economics: “<em>neglects to assign any value to the largest stocks of capital it employs — the natural resources and living systems, as well as the social and cultural systems that are the basis of human capital</em>.”</p><p>More recently Thomas Piketty, an Associate Chair of the Paris School of Economics, has written what may prove to be an era shaping critique of contemporary economics — on its own terms. It has helped devastate the brand of “Neo-liberal Economics,” encouraging the conversion of that term into an insult; despite the fact it describes much of U.S. and global macro-economic thinking. Piketty did this through his massive “<strong>Capital in the Twenty First Century</strong>” in 2014 and his equally ambitious “<strong>Capital &amp; Ideology</strong>” in 2020, which has succeeded in making more economists conclude publicly economics must change. In “<strong>Capital in the Twenty-First Century”</strong> Piketty provides a rigorous quantitative analysis of global economic history, by country, concluding: capital concentrates inefficiently; and in “<strong>Capital &amp; Ideology”</strong> Piketty examined the interplay of ideology and capitol to conclude: inequality is largely unnatural and economically counter-productive and it shapes the ideology and institutions (Piketty’s “the regime of inequality”) that evolve to justify it. Consequently, macro-economics appears as prepared as micro-economics for a new approach informed by current science on human nature and what we have done to the natural world that sustains us.</p><p><strong>Enterprises Are Embedded In Economies That Must Vindicate Dignity</strong></p><p>As noted on this <a href="http://sustainround.com/2020/05/20/covid-19s-five-lessons/">Sustainable Leadership blog</a>, the Covid-19 crisis has reminded business leaders of Five Lessons about the relationship between businesses, states and nature. As Kate Raworth, an Oxford development economist who helped guide the creation of the UN Sustainable Development Goals, has long argued: economies are embedded in societies and societies are embedded within our natural world and it is only natural for human beings to seek shared meaning and value quite distinct from the utility maximization expected by classic economic theory.</p><p>In Kate Raworth’s 2017 book “<strong>Doughnut Economics; <em>7 Ways to Think Like a 21st Century Economist</em></strong><em>”</em> the former long-time economist for Oxfam is especially cogent when arguing against a macro-economics that assumes perfect information, rationalism and the absence of politics. Only more persuasively than dozens of prominent thinkers before her, Raworth lampoons the development of a reductionist economics that assumes those participating in an economy are not committed citizens, parents, children and faith and community participants before they are perfectly informed, utility maximizing, consumers. And which assumes economies should be optimized to increase Gross Domestic Product; even if “GDP” does, as Robert Kennedy once observed, “<em>measure everything but what makes life worth living</em>.” And fails to measure all sorts of value — like that of parenting — as well as all sorts if costs, like the world threatening cost of carbon pollution. So, Raworth proposes a well-being — or dignity first — centered “Donut Economics” that acknowledges it is necessary to meet real human needs to enable personal and societal development and avoid citizens falling into a proverbial hole of only growing need; while also setting limits on consumption required by environmental limits. This is an approach that has won an enthusiastic following within several smaller economies including those of New Zealand, Scotland, Wales, Iceland and the Amsterdam metropolitan area which have officially adopted the “well-being” based economics Kate Raworth promotes. They have also established the Well-being Economies Working Group within the Organization for Economic Co-Operation &amp; Development.</p><p>This argument for a more sustainable macroeconomics is complimented and expanded by Mariana Mazzucato, Professor of Economics of Innovation and Public Value at the University College of London and her 2018 book “<strong>The Value of Everything; <em>Making and Taking in the Global Economy</em></strong><em>”</em>. Wherein Mazzucato argues that we can do better than Oscar Wilde’s cynic who: “<em>knows the price of everything but the value of nothing</em>.” If we return to the center of economics, the examination of the nature of “value” which needs to be expressly tied to how an item or process within complex systems advances human purposes. Which is, in turn, advanced by a theory of micro-economic value creation within a given enterprise that dignifies multiple stakeholders including supplier, labor, manager, consumer and citizen of an enterprise’s host community who all help create and evaluate an enterprise’s value.</p><p>It is the conventional, reductionist economics, however, that unquestionably dominates economics and has long influenced other social sciences. Consequently, the assumptions inherent in conventional economics have become both a contributing part, and component of, the “industrial age paradigm” Covey recognized as “the problem.” It is possible, however, to imagine how the explication of a richer, scientifically based, understanding of human nature as part of a new “Sustainable Leadership Paradigm” could helpfully support both emerging multi-stakeholder micro-economic value creation strategies and increasingly understood and respected “well-being” focused macro-economics it reinforces. Especially if this new, science based, understanding of human nature and challenging natural context was described and promoted in a manner designed to resonate across current intellectual and political cleavages.</p><p><strong>Dignity as the Third Dimension of Our Souls</strong></p><p>A thought leader who may be able to help is Francis Fukuyama. He was promoted as a global star by leaders of the “neo-conservative” political movement after the viral popularity of his 1989 essay “<strong>The End of History and the Last Man</strong>”. That helped him grow the essay into a 1992 book by the same name which many have pointed out was incorrect to assert any part of history ended with the triumph of liberal democracies over the Soviet Union. He became more welcome in progressive circles after his books on social trust and biotechnology and his ascension to Director of the Center for Democracy and the Rule of Law at Stanford. He was as welcomed by progressives as he will ever be after he completed his two volume master work: “<strong>The Origins of Political Order and Political Decay</strong>” (2011 &amp; 2014). Which was a magisterial survey of human political history from the cave to the Arab Spring. It included a wise re-appraisal of the great Enlightenment thinkers who failed to understand human beings evolved as social beings and a cogent political history of Africa, the Middle East, Asia, Europe and the Americas to conclude: the lawful, relatively autonomous and meritocratic administrative state was the key to building the social trust needed for societal flourishing.</p><p>After the rise of nationalist politics globally and the political success of Donald Trump who seemed to personify the patrimonialism Fukuyma warned in 2014 regularly ends flourishing societies, he published “<strong>Identity; <em>The Demand for Dignity and the Politics of Resentment”</em> </strong>in 2018. In that luminous but flawed book, Fukuyama (whose grandparents suffered in the Japanese Internment during WWII and was not taught Japanese growing up), examines the intellectual and political enthusiasm for racial, ethnic and sexual identity in the U.S. and the violent, authoritarian, white nationalist reaction. It is a thin book and the best part of it is the first half on the second chapter entitled: “The Third Part of the Soul.”</p><p>In that chapter, Fukuyama recognizes economic theories are built on theories of human behavior which are, in turn, built on theories of human nature. Fukuyama summarizes the case against modern economics based on the more social understanding of human nature contemporary science has revealed. He then reaches back to one of the first recorded discussions of the human soul in a fascinating attempt to help develop a vocabulary of story and words to discuss the more social nature of human motivations science now supports.</p><p>In just a few sentences Fukuyama cites psychologist, economist and Nobel Laureate, Daniel Kahneman, author of the 2015 best seller “<strong>Thinking Fast and Slow</strong>” and his collaborator the mathematical psychologist and cognitive scientist Amos Tversky’s critique of modern economics and their work helping to establish Behavioral Economics. Fukuyama then explains that contemporary economics is premised on the theory that humans are “rational utility maximizers.” A theory that rests on multiple assumptions including that the correct unit of account is the individual (not a company, family or community) and that individuals cooperate to advance their individual self-interest. Wherein an individual’s preferences — “for a car, for sexual gratification, for a pleasant vacation” — make up what economist call a person’s “utility function.” Thus, a hedge fund manager betting for another billion and a Marine jumping on a grenade to save his team are both said to be “maximizing their preferences.”</p><p>What is needed, Fukuyama asserts, is a theory to explain why some pursue money and security and while others sacrifice money and time or even die for causes greater than themselves. Which, although Fukuyama does not mention it, is a question that organizational science has explored going back at least to Douglas McGregor’s classic work of organizational theory “<strong>The Human Side of Enterprise” </strong>(1960) which is known for its contrasting assertion of a “Theory X” (that employees were largely only concerned with their immediate self-interest) and “Theory Y” that employees are naturally self-motivated to advance enterprise goals and also creative but require leaders who recognized that and facilitate their more independent contributions. In 2021, it is safe to say Theory Y has been validated by both social psychology and generations of successful management strategies driven by prominent leaders, including those who report success with Steven Covey’s earlier mentioned “<strong>The 8th Habit.”</strong></p><p><strong>Have We Evolved To Be Self-Sacrificing Guardians?</strong></p><p>Perhaps because evidence of predictably self-sacrificing, pro-social, human proclivities is established elsewhere, Fukuyama does not examine experimental social psychology or cognitive science. He instead turns to the cultural authority of Plato and examines one of the foundational texts in western philosophy. Fukuyama does so to recover how Plato categorized what for centuries was viewed as a central well spring of human motivation. One long ago obscured by the rise of utilitarian and materialistic philosophies and contemporary economics and its reductionist interest in “material utility.”</p><p>Fukuyama turns to Book IV of <strong>The Republic</strong> to recount how Plato imagines Socrates leading two aristocratic students through a dialogue to examine different parts of the human soul (in Greek: “psyche”). The dialogue explores hypothetical situations to tease out how a given “psyche” must have different dimensions to it to enable a single person to desire things like water but know not to pursue it due to any credible concern for poison; or to be committed to the highest standards but furious with themselves if they submit to baser desires. Then Socrates and students are imagined to quickly agree the soul has an <em>epithymetikon</em> (from <em>epithymia</em>) or aspect providing bodily appetites located in the stomach. As well as a hopefully governing “logistikon” (from <em>logos</em>) or calculating aspect located in the head. Socrates prompts this student to go further and consider a story of a respected aristocrat who reproached himself angrily for his failure to suppress his interest in looking an especially morbid scene. Through dialogue they concluded this was evidence <em>thumitikon</em> (from <em>thymos</em>), a third dimension of the soul that is often translated as “spiritedness” located in the chest that may be best described as a passionate hunger for recognized social worth or dignity.</p><p>Fukuyama contends that Thymos has been a central part of the philosophical, religious and political discussion of human nature for centuries. Hegel recognized it as a central driver of human affairs and even the progress of history itself. But outside of Fukuyama and a few other Hegel scholars like the Russian émigré to France Alexandre Kojeve whom Fukuyama has referenced as an inspiration, the notion of Thymos was eclipsed in the modern era. First by the rise utilitarian and then economic thinking (Neo-classical, Marxist and Keynesian) which came to assume desire for material benefit drove human choices, societies and history. But it seems to be appropriate to revive a discussion of Thymos since rigorous science and real-world business successes both suggest that there is a sound basis for the ancient assumption that either all or at least a meaningful portion of human beings regularly have a passionate hunger for a more than material recognition of their dignity.</p><p>In “<strong>Identity; <em>The Demands for Dignity and the Politics of Resentment”</em></strong> Fukuyama explores how it can be helpful to distinguish an “isothymia” that seeks a recognition of universal dignity from a “meglothymia” that seeks special, exclusionary, honors. He asserts that what was discussed in “<strong>The Republic”</strong> was, by these definitions, the megalogthymia of ancient Greece’s aristocratic order and specifically a description of Plato’s idealized Guardians. Who are brought up from childhood to be “<em>courageous, moderate, holy and free.” </em>Book III, Sec. 395. Fukuyama suggests that much of the rise of democratic societies in history could be understood as the evolution from a “megalothymatic” ordering into an “isothymatic” ordering as what began as an aristocratic demand for exclusive honors grew into a demand for universal dignity. Unfortunately, Fukuyama does not consider how society committed to universal dignity might be complimented by an aligned system enabling greater self-chosen commitments for exclusive honors.</p><p>Even in his ill-considered assertion that an identity conscious politics as practiced in the U.S. is, necessarily, about a demand for exclusionary, as opposed to universal dignity, Fukuyama provides an example of how recovering the discussion of Thymos can help us better address our current challenges. Including the daunting challenge of an anti-rational, ethnic nativism that is rising globally and making it difficult to address challenges in social equity and environmental breakdown. Because discussions of a need for dignity moves beyond the tired framing of our “baser” interest in the material advantage of one’s perceived group (think of the Epithymia of the Greek stomach) versus the enlightened self-interest of the shared and greater good (think of the Logos of the Greek head). This is something that was well understood by leaders before economic thinking conquered all. Napoleon appears to have appreciated the vital role of the hunger, or need, for dignity when he famously observed: “<em>you call these metals and ribbons baubles; well, it is with such baubles men are led . . . do you think you would be able to make men fight by reasoning? Never, that is only good for the scholar in his study.”</em></p><p>Since he wrote “<strong>The End of History and the Last Man” </strong>in 1992, Fukuyama has argued that the liberal democratic order is challenged by the difficulty it has satisfying the demands of Thymos. Indeed, the “Last Man” in the title of that book is a reference Nietzsche’s “Last Man” in his 1883 book “<strong>Thus Spoke Zarathustra.”</strong> Therein the “Last Man” was opposite of a triumph of history. Neitzsche saw the “Last Man” as the goal of secular and egalitarian modernity which would arrive at the end of history as a “masterless slave” to rational consumption devoid of any Meglothymic hunger — or high passion for great status. He would be as C.S. Lewis speculated, a man with desire and reason but “without a chest.” He was the opposite of the Neitzsche’s Ubermensch or “Superman” (a term adopted by Hitler and his National Socialists) who had the super human strength to hunger for life even in its most terrifying and historically consequential dimensions beyond constructed moral systems.</p><p>Fukuyama has no enthusiasm of Nietzsche’s Superman but he does express concern for a dullness of people at the “end of history.” In this Fukuyama is working in the anti-egalitarian tradition of Hegel who thought Christianity an ideology for slaves and many noted thinkers including seminal German thinker Martin Heidegger (once a member of the Nazi party) who saw mass democratic society as incompatible with fully expressed individuality and creativity. Which was a concern of several mid-century American thinkers like Sloan Wilson who wrote “<strong>The Man in the Grey Flannel Suit</strong>” (1956) and Herbert Marcuse who wrote “<strong>The One Dimensional Man</strong>” (1964), and that seems a misplaced concern in the 2020s.</p><p>Fukuyama benefits in surprising ways from paying attention to the nearly lost tradition of assuming a central role for Thymos as a hunger for more than logic and more than greater material benefit, something closer to what David Hume described as “the passions” when Hume famously observed: “Reason, is, and ought only be the slave of the passions.” “<strong>A Treatise of Human Nature”</strong>, Book III, Part III, Sect. III (1739). This unusual focus has helped Fukuyama become a rare public intellectual in the U.S. and rarer still, one with readers across party and ideological lines. It also seems to have helped Fukuyama prove prescient in several specific ways. Back in the 1990s Fukuyama hypothesized that if unable to lead society forward to something better than liberal democracy, Megalothymotic leaders around the world might seek to lead societies backwards to theocracy. Fukuyama even specifically mentions Donald Trump in 1992 as the type of Megalothymotic striver that might — if he wasn’t distracted by ambitions in the marketplace — work to dramatically overturn liberal democracy’s table of rational consumption. All to feed his passion for greater social status for himself through hollow promises to feed others need for social status.</p><p>What Fukuyama only mentions in the passing when writing on Isothymia and Megalothymia is that they could be made complimentary if a society provides a meaningful sense of universal and inalienable dignity to all citizens that satisfies Isothymotic hunger and enables citizens to both socially accept and consider pursuing for themselves, higher, exclusive, honors to satisfy any Megalothymotic hunger. Fukuyama acknowledges this is possible but fails to observe that arrangement seems to have occurred (with egregious exceptions for racial minorities and the traditionally marginalized) in the U.S. following its success in World War II when national pride swelled and a robust legal system and strong labor rights and wages provided many a feeling of universal dignity and some of the most fortunate strove for special, socially reinforcing, honors through philanthropy (e.g., the Rockefellers) or progressive politics (e.g., the Kennedys).</p><p><strong>Science Continues to Reveal Nature &amp; Advance History</strong></p><p>Fukuyama is wrong; history in the grand sense is not over. Democratic capitalism as organized in the 1990s is not, fundamentally, the best we can do; nor is it even sufficient to meet the challenges we face. And the changes required are not superficial. Fukuyama believes that scientific innovation combined with human’s thymotic hunger propels history forward. And on the 25th anniversary of “<strong>The End of History and the Last Man” </strong>he even conceded biotechnology had advanced to make the possibility of transhumanism foreseeable and that if that occurred it would require more meaningful historical change. But what he misses is that science is working unceasingly to: (a) reveal a richer, more social, understanding of human nature than was broadly understood a generation ago, (b) digitally integrate the world socially and economically; and, © make clear that that natural environment that sustains us all is increasingly being undermined by human caused climate and ecologic breakdown.</p><p>This has all come together to help cause what Walmart’s CEO called an “astonishing moment of truth where all the world is coming together whether we realize it our not.” Fortunately, the emerging scientific understanding of human nature provides a strong basis for reasoned faith in human beings to be true to our exceptional ability to create shared meanings and a shared sense of purpose and mission. And the remarkable communication and transparency made possible by the ever increasing digitalization of the global economy, is making it possible to imagine the success of a dignity first, commitment led approach to multi-stakeholder value creation at both the level of the firm and at the level of the society the firm operates in and rightly serves. What is unfortunate, is the proliferating opportunity for the sort of sustained heroic commitments required to build a genuinely new society that is as distinct from the liberal democratic capitalism of the 1990s that Fukuyama argued was the “End of History” as that ordering was distinct from the monarchical agrarian ordering that proceeded it. But it means that the last thing our current moment lacks are opportunities for those who hunger to offer great leadership.</p><p>Many are already committed to exemplifying a new model of leadership in scaling global enterprises like those purpose driven multi-stakeholder value creators in Rebecca Henderson’s cases studies. Others are are committed to building new models of leadership and relationships including Dr. Donna Hicks approach of leading with dignity. Still others are committed to advancing a new, more ecological, model of economics wherein the entire broader system is explicitly intended to serve the human needs of citizens as in those countries and leading global urban centers who have adopted Kate Raworth’s Donut Economics which is organized by commitments to meeting human needs and purposed for a human flourishing.</p><p>Consistent with all this, Gene Sperling, former Chief Economic Advisor to Presidents Clinton and Obama published a book in 2020 entitled “<strong>Economic Dignity</strong>” bringing this approach to economic policy making. Although he did not mention mention Dr. Hicks or Kate Raworth, in his book Sperling proposes an organizing and multi-faceted commitment to meeting the minimum needs required to enable every person’s flourishing as a recognition of — and investment in — their human dignity. In doing so, Sperling recognizes the inadequacy of former approaches he helped lead that sought to optimize a massive and complex U.S. economy but failed too many citizens it was supposed to serve. So, he proposes to now begin with meeting minimum needs first. Which is itself consistent with the hard-won wisdom of Germany’s post World War II 1949 Basic Law (i.e., Constitution) which begins: “Human dignity shall be inviolable. To protect and respect it is the duty of all state authority.” Hopefully, in 2021 global businesses will begin to see how this foundational principle for public authorities should be applied to the private enterprises that public authorities’ charter.</p><p><strong>Towards “Reverence, Respect &amp; Compassion for Ourselves, All People &amp; the Natural Environment”</strong></p><p>Science is helping our human community, at every level, turn from watching and reacting to shadows of unreason, to reveal a richer and more accurate understanding of human beings, human purposes and human needs in complex societies. It is also revealing that our challenge is immense and urgent. But our challenge is not best understood as a problem of technology, policy or someone else’s baser appetites versus deracinated reasoning. It is a human problem and it’s ours. We can decide if science supports a richer understanding of human beings as profoundly social and breathtakingly talented at innovative collaboration across cultures, continents and centuries and as motivated by a thymotic passion for dignity at least as much as by reason or base appetite. If we conclude it does, then we can embrace what a young Calvin Coolidge argued back in 1914: <em>“Don’t hesitate to be as revolutionary as science. Don’t hesitate to be as reactionary as a multiplication table.”</em> But it will be necessary to remember that art and politics are far older than science and it is only lately that science is discovering how our human hearts respond to each other. So it will be necessary to work with and through art, politics and tradition.</p><p>Those interested in a new paradigm for leadership will benefit greatly from Dr. Donna Hicks’ “<strong>Leading with Dignity”</strong> and Michael Pirson’s “<strong>Humanistic Management</strong>.” They need to explore, perhaps with Mariana Mazzucato, author of the coming book “<strong>The Mission Economy; <em>A Moon Shot Approach to the Economy</em></strong><em>,”</em> how fundamental commitments can shape what is considered rational and valuable. This will help determine how leaders can move beyond market-based models seeking “efficiency” to human centered models committed to vindicating (from the Latin: “to avenge”) “dignity.” And, specifically, when, where and how a trinity of commitment: to our best selves, to enabling our colleagues’ and customers’ best selves and to a natural, regenerative, relationship with the environment that sustains us all — can be our shared purpose. At every level of leadership: in family, community, companies, nations and the world. For those interested — as individuals, as leaders in enterprises and as citizens in societies which each flourish more impressively to the extent each level of commitment is made to meet the needs of every citizen’s inviolable and inalienable dignity.</p><p>Science is revealing the daunting breadth, depth and urgency of the existential challenge we face in human caused environmental breakdown that is undermining the order of life on earth in our time, for all time. But is also increasingly connecting us as never before on multiple levels and it has begun to reveal to us what ancient art and wisdom have long known: we have a passionate need — and talent — for connection and building dignity. So, we have every reason to have faith in the success we increasingly understand that we must together create. Which helps us understand how and why we can grow from always looking to “utilize” and become, to having a deep sense of gratitude for what we are and what we can be, both for others and for our natural world.</p><p>This is a new, centered and calm, attitude of reverence won through recognizing the beauty, complexity and vulnerability of life. It is an attitude more of “being” than “becoming” and more about “caring” than “having”; which is beyond and apart from any given religion as described in John Ehrenfeld of MIT and his former student and now professor at University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business, Andrew Hoffman’s <strong>“Flourishing; <em>A Frank Conversation About Sustainability” </em>(2013).<em> </em></strong>But it can be experienced joyously in a religious context as Pope Francis suggests in <strong>Laudato Si</strong>, quoting the presumably Shinto influenced Bishops of Japan when he observed: “<em>to sense each creature signing the hymn of its existence, is to live joyously in G-d’s love and hope</em>.” It is an attitude that inclines us to reject the isolating, utility maximizing, conceit of economists and embrace what Albert Camus — who was a national level soccer player then a Nazi fighting commando before winning the Nobel Prize for Literature — described as the “insane generosity” of solidarity. We can do this by joining with Camus in turning a too cerebral Descartes on his head and asserting:</p><p><strong>“<em>I rebel, therefore we are</em>.”</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/104/0*hezppKeXmO9zkufg.jpg" /></figure><p>Jim Boyle is the CEO &amp; Founder of Sustainability Roundtable, Inc. For more than a dozen years, Jim has led full-time teams of diverse experts to assist nearly 100 Fortune 500 and growth companies in their move to more sustainable high-performance. Specifically, SR Inc has helped world-leading corporations, real estate owners, and federal agencies to set goals, drive progress, and report results in their move to greater Corporate Sustainability. Mr. Boyle led in the creation of SR Inc’s Renewable Energy Procurement Services (REPS), which advises and represents Fortune 500 and fast growth companies across the U.S. and internationally in the development of renewable energy strategies and the procurement of both on and off-site advanced energy solutions. Before founding SR Inc, Mr. Boyle co-led Trammell Crow Company Corporate Advisory Services in San Francisco and returned to his native Boston and Trammell Crow Company’s market leading team in Greater Boston where he received the Commercial Brokers Association’s Platinum Award for the highest level of commercial real estate transactions. Earlier, he advised companies on real estate and environmental matters as an attorney at a large law firm based in Boston. Jim is a graduate of Middlebury College, where he co-captained the football team, and Boston College Law School. Early in his career, he served as a federal law clerk, an aide to John F. Kerry in the U. S. Senate, and on Vice President Al Gore’s campaign for President. Jim lives in Concord, MA with his wife and kids a half mile across the street from Emerson’s house and museum on the route to Walden Pond.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2be1fb8bac42" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>