<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by James Renner on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by James Renner on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jamesrenner?source=rss-8221d6e709bf------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 21:07:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jamesrenner/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Obsessed Pest]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesrenner.medium.com/obsessed-pest-1d1682fe7808?source=rss-8221d6e709bf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1d1682fe7808</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James Renner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Oct 2023 21:09:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-12-04T16:09:16.466Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Employees claim toxic behavior inside Obsessed Network.</p><p>By James Renner</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/784/1*sLXOfLBWbCHN9hfWbSqaMA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In public, Patrick Hinds is the life of the party. As cohost of the popular podcast, <em>True Crime Obsessed</em>, Hinds has gained a reputation as a gregarious, charming, and funny man and he holds court in the ballrooms of true crime conventions like CrimeCon and Obsessed Fest. There are countless photographs online with his fans, in which his mouth is open, as if in mid-laugh at something they’ve just said. His rise to fame from Broadway raconteur to the nice guy of true crime was inspiring to many. And much of that journey is told in his new book, <em>Failure Is Not Not an Option</em>, which is promoted as the story of a chubby, poor gay son of a lesbian who succeeded in spite of it all.</p><p>But last month, whispers of bad behavior circulated on Reddit following the departure of Obsessed Network’s popular podcast, <em>I Think Not</em> (once called <em>Obsessed with Disappeared)</em>, which is hosted by Broadway actress Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto. Taranto replaced Hinds as cohost on that podcast in 2022. <em>I Think Not</em> is no longer a part of the company and the scuttlebutt is that Hinds was jealous of the success of his long-time friend Ellyn’s podcast and petty in-fighting had led to the split and the last straw had something to do with the unapproved use of a sound clip from the movie <em>The Bling Ring </em>of all things. But that all seemed too ridiculous to believe.</p><p>Several people claiming insider knowledge have since posted steamy tidbits on the ObsessedNetwork subreddit. In September, this post appeared: “Someone linked me to this group because I work with the Obsessed Network and can prove it if that were ever needed. I guess people are worried that the claims being posted here by ‘insiders’ could just be rumors but they’re not. Just know that it’s not made up.”</p><p>For this article, I spoke with seven current and former employees of Obsessed Network and each of them said that the person Patrick Hinds appears to be in public is an act and behind the scenes he’s threatening and insufferable. The most common response when reached by phone was, “I was waiting for this shoe to drop.”</p><p>Most requested to speak on background due to signed NDAs or the fear of repercussions by their boss. Here’s what they say is happening inside Obsessed Network.</p><p>In Hinds’ favor, everyone agrees he’s a hard worker. He puts in long hours. He shows up and gets the podcasts done. But everything at Obsessed Network must be done to his specific liking, which is often based on his current mood, they say, or employees will find themselves in his crosshairs.</p><p>“He’s very scary,” says one current employee. “He goes from 0 to 60 immediately.” If Hinds is upset about something external, they explain, he’ll take it out on the first person he sees. For instance, the day Ashley Flowers was featured in the <em>New York Times</em>, he called a producer and berated them for letting their host do too much research for a show.</p><p>One time, Hinds threatened to fire a podcast host because they were late for a meeting, even though he was late for their meeting the week before. “I have to get off the phone with you or this is going to end with you being off the podcast,” he told them.</p><p>A host was once reprimanded for not having a smile on her face during a company meeting. According to office workers, women seem to receive the brunt of his anger. He is allegedly much softer with men.</p><p>As far as the split with <em>I Think Not</em>, employees say that things began to fall apart when Joey Taranto stood up for Ellyn Marsh during a company meeting. He objected to the way Hinds treated Marsh, which reportedly involved much “screaming and yelling.” Hinds didn’t like being confronted.</p><p>Taranto’s not the only one who took offense to the way Hinds spoke to Marsh. Julia Rhea was an independent contractor who worked for <em>True Crime Obsessed</em> in 2019. “I witnessed the abuse with Ellyn firsthand,” she says. “He threatened her repeatedly. He threatened to fire her several times. It was unfair and abusive treatment.”</p><p>Hinds ostracized Marsh in the office, says Rhea. He would scream at her in front of other people. She remembers hearing him say to Marsh, “I wouldn’t care if your child was threatened, I’d never take your side!”</p><p>It’s a shame because the friendship between Hinds and Marsh goes back years, back to when Hinds was mostly known for a podcast about Broadway shows. They had their disagreements before and were able to work through it. Every so often, Hinds would get mad at Marsh and things would go quiet for a while before he apologized. Several people witnessed Hinds get on his knees in a room full of people at Obsessed Fest last year, begging Marsh to forgive him again.</p><p>After that, emotions balanced on a razor’s edge for a while and eventually ended for good in a bizarre incident that finally severed their friendship — the infamous TikTok debacle.</p><p>Earlier this year, Marsh and Taranto used an audio clip from the film, <em>The Bling Ring </em>in a TikTok video that garnered a lot of attention. After the clip was posted, the hosts received an email from Steve Tipton, Hinds’ husband and business partner, telling them that Hinds was planning to use that audio for a TikTok post featuring himself and Gillian Pensavalle, for their podcast, <em>True Crime Obsessed</em>. When they explained to Tipton that deleting a video could impact the app’s algorithm, Steve responded that this was not a request.</p><p>But Hinds’ fury is not limited to Marsh by any means. It seems to be the style of management at Obsessed Network. Case in point, Hinds’ treatment of Olivia Gunderson, an office assistant. “Patrick made it clear she would be fired because he just didn’t like her,” says Rhea. “It had nothing to do with her performance or work ethic, he just didn’t like her so he would scream at her. Ellyn really loved Olivia. I think that had a lot to do with it in hindsight. He took it out on her.”</p><p>“The turnover here is incredible,” says one employee. “Many don’t last long unless they’re stuck in contracts.”</p><p>Obsessed Network produces a wide variety of podcasts centered on crime and the paranormal, shows like <em>Murder in Alliance</em>, hosted by journalist Maggie Freleng, <em>Strange and Unexplained</em>, hosted by Daisy Eagan, and <em>Crimes of the Centuries</em>, with Amber Hunt.</p><p>One common complaint from employees is Hinds’ flippant remarks about his own hosts and podcast topics that they believe were at times sexist and racist.</p><p>When one host pitched a new show based on a story from South Africa, Hinds’ allegedly responded, “I’m just not interested in that, sorry, I don’t know why. Is it because they’re black?”</p><p>On more than one occasion, Hinds is reported to have said “lesbians want to fuck all of our hosts” in front of staff. During the taping of one podcast, Hinds was recorded saying that a fan was “lesbian for Maggie,” suggesting that a straight fan would make an exception for Maggie Freleng if given the opportunity. In reaction to this quip, Obsessed Network executive producer Becca DeGregorio expressed her concerns in a group message on Slack that was seen by employees as well as Hinds and Tipton. DeGregorio said she was cutting the audio from the episode.</p><p>Hinds appeared more concerned about how her feedback made him look to others than he did about the concern itself. An employee seated near Hinds and Tipton when the message came through said simply, “They lost their shit.”</p><p>Patrick responded to DeGregorio in a terse message: “Your feedback is really appreciated, however I don’t think it was the right thing to put it in the general channel. It would have been more appropriate to bring it to Steve and me as your supervisors and let us discuss with the talent.”</p><p>To which Becca replied: “You and Steve are not a safe space for me to bring this feedback to because it also concerns you. And I think it is pretty clear, that the entanglement of drama between yourselves, the hosts and others at the company leaves employees like me confused as to how to communicate feedback without having it weaponized.”</p><p>It appears most of the staff of Obsessed Network as well as the hosts eventually became awkwardly entangled with Hinds. Shortly after hiring a young man named Gil Torres, as an administrative and touring associate, they came out of a bar and Hinds was heard saying to him, “Well, you’re hot.”</p><p>One thing that would help these situations is an HR department. But at the time of these incidents, Obsessed Network had no HR department where an employee could wage a workplace complaint. Instead, they were sent to Steve. They have reportedly since contracted with a human resources app that employees can contact.</p><p>Beyond Human Resources, there’s a lot of concern internally about how the business is set up. The most profitable podcast owned by Hinds, <em>True Crime Obsessed</em>, is its own separate entity and there are questions about how revenue generated by the podcasts under the umbrella of the Obsessed Network may contribute to social media campaigns used to promote <em>TCO</em>. According to current hosts, there has been little transparency regarding the number of downloads and ad revenue earnings. One host whose contract stated that they would earn a percentage of ad revenue never saw a statement and never received any funds directly from the ads. She was told the show was not popular enough for her to earn money from it and her contract was soon changed so that ad revenue was no longer a part of it at all. Growth did not increase her pay.</p><p>Workplace diversity is also problematic. At the time a new producer was hired, there was not a single person of color working in the office. When they raised this issue with Hinds, he replied that it wasn’t a real problem because he was a gay man and knew well what it was like to be a member of a minority group.</p><p>It’s the petty things, too, that torment the employees of Obsessed Network. Hinds likes the studio to be a certain temperature when recording. The A/C is supposed to be turned on at 10 a.m. when he has a 4 p.m. recording. When Gil forgot to turn on the A/C until noon one day, he was chastised by a very angry Hinds.</p><p>One employee saw their Uber ratings tank after booking several trips for Hinds. They learned that Hinds would berate the drivers when they didn’t go the way he wanted them to. On at least one occasion Hinds threatened to call the police on the driver.</p><p>There was also the constant flouting of wealth in front of his employees — whenever Hinds wanted to go home, he would say he wanted “to go to the Hit Factory,” the expensive apartment building where he lives with Tipton. On tours, Hinds would stay at luxury hotels while his staff was set up at the local Hilton Inn &amp; Suites.</p><p>The tours were a nightmare for staff. Getting Hinds onto a plane was like bringing a child to the airport, they said. He had to be herded to the gate, often sending high-level employees on errands for water and snacks.</p><p>In the office, the micromanaging by Hinds and Tipton also became an issue. One staffer was reprimanded for using the abbreviation “ASAP” in an email. Tipton said it set a bad tone. Not long after that, the employee was told to send all future emails through Tipton before sending out. That employee found their job posted on LinkedIn a short time later.</p><p>Turnover remains an issue at the company to this day. And on the way out, employees typically sign an NDA that is part of their severance package that prohibits them from saying anything bad about their experience or to even acknowledge its existence. However, just last February, the Nation Labor Relations Board ruled that it is “generally illegal for companies to offer severance agreements that prohibit workers from making potentially disparaging statements about the employer or from disclosing details of the agreement,” according to the <em>New York Times.</em></p><p>One host who did speak on the record was Amber Hunt, host of <em>Crimes of the Centuries</em>. “As a journalist, I’m a big believer that truth is a disinfectant and I am not okay with ever feeling as though I can’t speak freely about a situation,” she says. “That said, I can only speak to my experiences. I have heard unpleasant stories from other people. I have seen some documentation corroborating those stories and I have no reason to believe anyone’s making up a tale — but those stories aren’t mine to share.”</p><p>Hunt says she is proud of the work she’s done on her podcast for Obsessed Network and grateful that Hinds and Tipton brought her on. “I will say, though, that when I pitched the show to them, they verbally told me that if our little experiment failed and we couldn’t agree to terms on a second season, I could have the show back. After we began talking about a second season, it became clear that wasn’t actually possible. I was disappointed in that. Basically, I was told that they own the IP and if I wanted the show I created, I’d have to get lawyers involved.” To be fair, she says, she has worked for other companies that wanted to maintain the IP of her shows. The difference here is that verbal commitment that was not honored.</p><p>At the moment, Obsessed Network employees are preparing for their annual Obsessed Fest, which will be held in Dallas on October 20–22, featuring Hinds on center stage along with network podcasters like Maggie Freleng, Amber Hunt, Daisy Eagan, as well as independent true crime podcasters like Rebecca Lavoie, Payne Lindsey, and the hosts from Generation Why. Fans on Reddit questioned the location, though, as Texas is one of the most unfriendly states when it comes to LGBTQ rights. The Lone Star state recently passed laws banning gender-affirming care for minors and are considering an adult ban as well.</p><p>One guest that won’t be attending Obsessed Fest this year is Alaina Urquhart, the cohost of the very popular crime and paranormal podcast, <em>Morbid</em>. She was scheduled to appear in person at last year’s fest but at the last minute she had to attend to a family emergency. Hinds allegedly contacted her at the hospital to tell her she was “ruining Obsessed Fest” by not being there in person.</p><p>Julia Hager, who volunteered in talent services at the fest, was in a waiting room that day and could hear the shouting from the Obsessed Network green room next door when they got the news that Alaina would not be coming.</p><p>Hager was a longtime fan of <em>True Crime Obsessed</em>, frequenting the Facebook groups and listening to each new podcast. She lives in Ohio and when the fest came to Columbus that year, she jumped on the chance to meet her heroes. But you know the old saying.</p><p>“The Obsessed Network staff was incredibly, incredibly rude to the convention staff and volunteers,” says Hager. She says that behind closed doors, the event was disorganized and nobody knew who was in charge. The biggest challenge was the schedule. It eventually fell to the volunteers to figure out where podcast hosts had to be at certain times and they were made to slip into mixers or waiting rooms to tap the guest on the shoulder and bring them to their next appearance. But Hinds was on his own schedule, apparently.</p><p>Hager remembers Hinds flying off the handle a number of times that weekend, shouting things like, “I never agreed to that timeline. Nobody tells me anything.”</p><p>Natalie Grillo, an employee of Obsessed Network, was often the one who had to intervene. “Calm down,” she would say. “No, you calm down!” he’d reply. And around and around it went.</p><p>When Hager went into the green room to collect Gillian Pensavalle, Hinds asked her, “Who are you, what are you doing?” Even though he had already met her ten times by then. And Pensavalle was cold and uninterested. “I’m not on Obsessed time right now,” she told her. “I’m on my down time.”</p><p>“It felt like I was being grilled,” says Hager. “First off, I’m a volunteer. You’re welcome.”</p><p>Later, when staff had to ask Hinds about accessibility for disabled patrons, Hinds waved them off. “Why do I have to deal with this?” he asked them. “Why are you asking me these questions?”</p><p>“Patrick seems so genuine when you listen to him. He’s loved dearly on those Facebook groups. And now he’s yelling at these people. He’d just go from 0–100 and into meltdown mode. It was a shocking lack of professionalism.”</p><p>When asked if she was going to attend this year’s festival in Dallas, Hager says simply, “Never again.”</p><p>“Patrick is a scary person,” says Rhea. “And he may react negatively to this article. But I’m prepared for that now. What’s important is that I stand up and use my voice for the people who can’t speak for themselves because they still work there or are too afraid to talk. I hope this is a wakeup call. I hope he gets the help he needs and works to repair these relationships.”</p><p>Hinds and Tipton did not respond to requests for comment.</p><p>UPDATE: On December 4, Patrick and Steve released an apology video that also provides their version and perception of events discussed in this article. Both Patrick and Steve were given a list of questions and the opportunity to comment/correct the record prior to publication. The list included questions concerning the allegations in this story as well as more serious allegations that have not yet been reported. They chose not to comment.</p><p>Regarding the Morbid situation, whether Patrick called, texted, emailed, or spoke to Alaina’s representative, his displeasure was explicit and relayed to her while she was in the hospital with a sick kid. We can argue semantics of how that message was relayed, but neither Alaina nor Patrick have requested a correction to this piece.</p><p>To his other points and allegations of factual errors, I stand by the women I spoke to with direct knowledge of the situations.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1d1682fe7808" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‘I HAVE NOTHING TO HIDE’]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesrenner.medium.com/i-have-nothing-to-hide-fc5df6d993ba?source=rss-8221d6e709bf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc5df6d993ba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[kevin-coughlin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[james-renner]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ohio-house-13]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James Renner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 20 Sep 2023 20:28:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-10-01T15:11:47.172Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>After 12 years in the legislature, Kevin Coughlin faces a criminal probe and allegations of extra-marital affairs.</p><p>By James Renner</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/454/0*ZAEQThzOpug6Af2r.png" /></figure><p>State Senator Kevin Coughlin is the father of two adorable girls whom he showcases on his campaign website and literature. He sits on the board of directors at a camp for seriously ill children, and is a past “Advocate of the Year” for the American Cancer Society. He looks like a Scoutmaster, with his thick hair and ready smile, the type of guy you trust innately. This is the Kevin Coughlin many voters know, a handsome young conservative. This image has served him well through more than 12 years in public office — he’s never lost a race — and last month he announced his intention to run for governor in 2010.</p><p>But some paint a much different picture of Coughlin — that of a behind-the-scenes schemer and hypocrite.</p><p>Last month two detectives visited the Summit County Board of Elections as part of an investigation into Coughlin. At issue is whether Coughlin illegally altered petitions that were circulated when his faction of the county Republican party tried to orchestrate a coup against longtime boss Alex Arshinkoff. Coughlin’s vague denials at a board hearing in January failed to put the matter to rest, and criminal charges are not out of the question.</p><p>Another accusation, not involving allegations of criminal behavior but potentially more damaging to his reputation, involves an extramarital affair. Sources say that during the summer of 2004, perhaps longer, he carried on a relationship with a younger woman. At the time she was a 24-year-old employee of the University of Akron, an attractive brunette who had worked on Coughlin’s campaign for State Senate. He was the 34-year-old, married, handsome rising star of the Summit County GOP — smart and ambitious, but also prone to blowing off campaign appointments to spend time with his girlfriend.</p><p>Five years later, as he attempts to lead a faction of “New Republicans” away from the pack, this affair is coming back to haunt him. Coughlin claims that anonymous tips that <em>Scene</em> has investigated have come from Arshinkoff’s camp. It’s true that there is no love lost between the two; Coughlin even told <em>Scene</em> that Arshinkoff once hit on him, an accusation that Arshinkoff vehemently denies. Otherwise, however, Arshinkoff declined to comment about his rival.</p><p>Coughlin’s political career began in 1996 when, as a first-time candidate at the age 26, he won a four-way Republican primary for the Cuyahoga Falls’ state representative seat being vacated by long-time incumbent Democrat Wayne Jones. Though he had little more than a masters in Public Administration under his belt, Coughlin had timing on his side; nationally, Republicans were ascendant, thanks to Newt Gingrich, and Coughlin’s name was recognized in Summit County, thanks to Stow Mayor Donald Coughlin (who’s actually not related and pronounces it differently). Defying the odds, Coughlin won.</p><p>In Columbus, one of his first moves was to close loopholes that had helped some men avoid domestic violence charges, which won him immediate bipartisan support from constituents. But before long he would become known for more predictably conservative positions, a hard-nosed political style and a penchant for secrecy.</p><p>When he fought to maintain the Republican hold on the 46th District seat in 1998, Coughlin refused to sign an ethics pledge that others had embraced; he disagreed with requests to provide campaign finance statements on the Internet. In 1999, he joined 50-some other members of the House in voting to exempt themselves from a new public records law that required all candidates for state office to submit campaign finance reports electronically.</p><p>That same year he sponsored House Bill 305, which would have allowed patients to be treated by physical therapists without first getting a prescription. When reporters learned that his wife was a practicing physical therapist, he attacked the media for making a big deal out of the appearance of impropriety.</p><p>He was elected to the State Senate in 2001. In ’03, a <em>Plain Dealer </em>editorial scolded him for chairing a Senate committee that met in secret to discuss plans to bring slot machines to Ohio.</p><p>Over time, Coughlin showed a greater willingness to brandish his status as an elected official to get his way. In 2005, he wrote a letter to Time Warner Cable suggesting the company send money to a campaign that was fighting an elections-reform effort. At the time, Coughlin also sat on the Senate committee that wrote regulatory policy for Time Warner Cable.</p><p>When school officials kicked his campaigners out of a Cuyahoga Falls high school football game in 2006, Coughlin shot off an obliquely threatening e-mail to the school board: “As a matter of policy, it is unwise to target a member of the legislature for such an action,” he warned. “I take little offense to it, but a legislator of lesser temperament may have carried that with him when considering policies impacting the Falls schools.”</p><p>He used the legislature as a weapon against Cuyahoga Falls Mayor Don Robart, too. After Robart supported Alex Arshinkoff during Coughlin’s very public battle to unseat the GOP boss in 2007, Coughlin tried to pass a bill that would make it impossible for Robart to create a mayor’s court in his town.</p><p>There are two Kevin Coughlins, some say: The ambitious, idealistic reformer who went to Columbus and the jaded, selfish man who came back.</p><p>“At first, he was good, he was fun to hang out with,” says one former staffer. “But then he changed.”</p><p>“Kevin and I have had a long relationship,” says former state representative Jim Trakas. “He’s hardworking. Motivated. He tries hard to be a good, effective legislator, but … Kevin is a complex guy. He’s burned a lot of bridges over the years. He’ll have a tough time getting the support he needs now, to run for governor.”</p><p>In 2004, Coughlin voted for a same-sex marriage ban that also prohibited domestic partners from receiving state benefits through their lover’s employer. But allegations about his own behavior call into question his commitment to the sanctity of matrimony.</p><p>In October, <em>Scene</em> received an anonymous e-mail claiming Coughlin had an affair with a campaign worker. “This individual consistently portrays himself in the public as the arbiter of family values,” the e-mailer wrote. The tipster stopped short of naming the alleged mistress, but identified her former roommate and the roommate’s parents.</p><p>The roommate confirms the affair. The roommate says that Coughlin and the young woman (we’ll call her Paramour, a term borrowed from Coughlin’s lawyer) met when she was an undergraduate student at the University of Akron and Coughlin was her instructor.</p><p>By the summer of 2004, Coughlin was spending a lot of time at Paramour’s apartment at the Village Green complex in Akron, says the roommate. Sometimes, Coughlin and Paramour disappeared into a bedroom; the roommate could hear them having sex. Paramour also allegedly shared hotel rooms with Coughlin on trips to Columbus, too. Other times, he sprung for a room at the Cuyahoga Falls Sheraton.</p><p>At least two neighbors at Village Green noticed Coughlin’s SUV, with personalized plates, parked in the apartment’s lot for hours at a time. Some recognized him.</p><p>“He was clearly out of his element,” says Nate Longstreth, who lived with his girlfriend in the apartment that faced Paramour’s. “I saw him walk in one time wearing this pastel polo shirt and khakis. He came alone. [Paramour] let him in. Later, I asked [the roommate] what was going on and she told me, ‘Yeah, that’s Kevin Coughlin. He’s banging my roommate.’ I told the roommate to go public with it, but she didn’t want to hurt her friend.”</p><p>When Coughlin learned of <em>Scene</em>’s investigation in October 2008, he immediately threatened to sue. “This is based, I presume, on the same rumors that Alex Arshinkoff has spread down here for four years,” he said in a voice mail for <em>Scene</em> publisher Matt Fabyan. “He’s been peddling this story ever since he hit on me.” He also sent this reporter an e-mail from his private account, pleading his case: “In the immortal words of Paul Newman, why would I go out for hamburger, when I have filet mignon at home?”</p><p>The next day, <em>Scene</em> received an e-mail from Ron Kopp of the Akron law firm Roetzel &amp; Andress. “The allegation is false and would be defamatory if published,” the letter stated. “If you have contacted any alleged paramour, the Senator is confident that that person would deny any unseemly relationship — since none existed.”</p><p>On the eve of Barack Obama’s inauguration, Coughlin’s “New Republicans” met at a hotel in Fairlawn to discuss their agenda for the future of Summit County politics. It was there that <em>Scene</em> got the opportunity to speak directly to Coughlin about the affair.</p><p>“I don’t have any extra-marital affair going on,” Coughlin said, using the present tense to address a question about 2004. “I have no idea what you’re talking about. This is bizarre.”</p><p>Coughlin admitted to speaking with Paramour’s roommate, though, after she had talked to <em>Scene</em>. He wouldn’t say what the conversation had been about.</p><p>When asked why his SUV may have been parked outside the apartment at odd hours, Coughlin said, “If you’re talking about the apartments over on West Market, I’ve had a staffer that lived there before and I’ve done drop-offs and pick-ups for the Bush campaign back in ’04. That’s the only time I’ve ever been there.” Some of the drop-offs may have been quite late at night, he added. “Well, during the campaign, I might have dropped someone off there at 1 a.m. but generally, no, I’ve never gone in there.</p><p>“You can poke around all you want,” he said finally. “There’s no paramour out there, there’s nothing tawdry. I have nothing to hide. I have a good strong marriage and that’s not going to change.”</p><p>At the end of the meeting, several Republicans took this reporter’s card. The next day, someone sent more information about Paramour, via Facebook. She lives in an apartment complex in Brimfield.</p><p>On January 23, she answered her door in a white bathrobe, her hair dry, her face made-up. She was instantly recognizable from the picture the University of Akron had published in an in-house publication, but when asked, she denied being herself: “No, I’m sorry, I don’t know when she’ll be back.” When I said I knew who she was, she said, “Now is not a good time for me.”</p><p>Asked about the affair, she would only say, “There’s nothing to talk about. There’s nothing to discuss.” When asked if Coughlin was inside, she shut the door.</p><p>I then parked on the street and waited. About 10 minutes later, she drove out of the complex, talking animatedly on her cell phone. I followed, and she drove to the Brimfield Police Department.</p><p>The report she filed verified her identity. The report states that she told the police chief that she had felt “threatened” because the reporter was “asking her personal questions that she did not feel comfortable answering.”</p><p>After she left, I entered the police station to give my version. Chief David Blough told me that no laws had been broken, but asked that I not follow the woman back to the apartment. I didn’t, and have not been back since.</p><p>Another letter from Coughlin’s attorney arrived shortly after this. Coughlin’s version of events, which could only have been relayed by Paramour, gives a more salacious account of the episode in Brimfield: “The police held the reporter and told him not to set foot in her condo community or follow her again or he would be arrested.” Not true.</p><p>The lawyer warned that a lawsuit was probably going to be filed even if <em>Scene</em> did not publish a story, adding, “Prompt cessation of the harassing conduct may cause us to reassess.”</p><p>Coughlin’s campaign finance reports show that Paramour was paid for consulting work on his Senate campaign, in 2002. Even though he had two other full-time staffers, Mike Chadsey and Jeff Lehner, she was the only one paid directly by his campaign — $6,000.</p><p>Chadsey sometimes met Paramour and Coughlin at the Cuyahoga Falls Sheraton on days that Ohio State’s football team played at home. They each drove separately to the hotel but then traveled together to Columbus and back to the Sheraton. Records show that Coughlin paid for Ohio State football season tickets with money from his campaign fund. When Paramour damaged her car, Coughlin paid for the repairs with campaign money, too — a legitimate expense, he says, claiming the damage occurred while she was dropping of campaign literature. But he refused to provide receipts.</p><p>At the same time, Coughlin was expensing hotel rooms at the Sheraton for “staff accommodations.” A staffer who worked on his campaign says all staff was local and nobody needed a room. “I’ve been afraid of getting a call like this,” he said. “I think it’s slimy, what he did. I think it’s crazy a married adult man would be so open around town with a young woman.”</p><p>There were times when their relationship impacted his ability to campaign, the staffer said. During a day set aside to campaign in Copley, Coughlin instead spent the afternoon at Wolfcreek Winery with Paramour. When asked where he’d been, he told a fellow political candidate that he’d been “canoodling” with Paramour.</p><p>“Where there’s smoke, there’s fire,” says one former state representative. “And with Kevin, there’s so much smoke, there must be a towering inferno somewhere inside.”</p><p>Paramour may not have been the only one. Former Coughlin staffers say that he let a legislative aide go after his wife became jealous. Coughlin denies this. According to two fellow state representatives who spoke on background, Coughlin once got into a public shouting match with Representative Ray Miller outside a committee room at the statehouse over their mutual attraction for a Democratic Caucus staffer.</p><p><em>Scene</em> obtained Coughlin’s phone records through the State Senate. The documents show that in 2004, he frequently called both his wife and Paramour’s cell phone before leaving the office at the end of the work day. For example, on December 8, 2004, at 4:57 p.m., Coughlin called home twice, then Paramour’s cell phone five times, then home again for seven minutes, then four more calls to Paramour’s cell.</p><p>After she was first contacted by <em>Scene</em>, the roommate informed Coughlin that she had been interviewed and what she had said. She would not elaborate on what they’d discussed, but noted, “I’m afraid of what might happen to me if you write about this.” She explained that in late 2004 or early ’05, she and Paramour bumped into Coughlin and a friend of his at Brubakers in Montrose. The roommate says she joked openly about the affair. Coughlin called her later, she says, and told her she had “a big mouth” and that his friend had warned him that “the only way to shut her up is a bullet in the head.”</p><p>Coughlin’s friend confirmed to <em>Scene</em> that the chance meeting occurred, but denied saying anything threatening about the roommate.</p><p>Coughlin’s harassment of possible sources continued into March. Last week, he sent an e-mail from his private account to a source that said: “The tabloid <em>Scene</em> has been trying to put together a hatchet job story on me for several weeks…” He also issues a thinly veiled threat to those who might talk to the paper: “Anticipating legal action, [my attorney] has repeatedly reminded <em>Scene</em> magazine of it’s [<em>sic</em>] obligations to save all records that will help lead us back to the source of the defamatory comments and allegations.”</p><p>Paramour got a job working as the executive assistant for Republican Summit County Engineer Greg Bachman in December 2004, but Bachman insists she was not hired as a favor to Coughlin. However, he admits that Coughlin personally called him to recommend her for the $38,000 a year job. “She was very good at administrative things like Excel and managing databases,” he says.</p><p>Oddly, her first performance review, in 2005, specifically notes, “Needs to take Excel classes; needs basic understanding of personnel access database.”</p><p>By the time she was let go in January, after Bachman lost his bid for re-election, Paramour had become an able liaison of the engineer’s office at City Counsel meetings and in the media. “Whatever I do next, if I can hire anyone, I’ll hire her,” says Bachman.</p><p>But allegations of infidelity and cronyism aren’t the most serious threats to Coughlin’s political future. In January, the Summit County Board of Elections sent information to the county sheriff and the county prosecutor suggesting that Coughlin committed a felony when he altered elections petitions in 2007.</p><p>When Coughlin made a play to unseat Arshinkoff as chairman of the Summit County GOP that year, a number of his supporters worked as “circulators” to gather signatures for New Republican allies so that they could run for positions on the Republican Central Committee and vote in their own chairman. It was a poorly organized coup against a man many in Akron call “Godfather.” Even before it had failed, Arshinkoff’s supporters were carefully double-checking the legitimacy of the petitions. Coughlin should have anticipated this. But it appears he hurriedly altered some petitions in an effort to keep the documents from being ruled invalid by the Board of Elections, possibly in violation of state law. And he would have gotten away with it, too, if his former roommate hadn’t been the guy whose job it was to review the documents.</p><p>Bryan C. Williams, Deputy Director of the Summit County BOE, noticed that someone had used a different pen to fill in portions of the petitions such as “number of signatures,” “party affiliation” and “precinct.” He recognized the handwriting as Coughlin’s — they had shared a hotel room in Columbus from 1997 through 2003, when Williams was working in the legislature (however, Coughlin often made excuses to stay extra nights at the hotel, alone.)</p><p>At issue is whether Coughlin’s circulators were present when he altered the petitions. If they were not, what he did was illegal.</p><p>In order to get to the bottom of this, the BOE held hearings on January 13, at which Coughlin’s circulators were ordered to appear by subpoena. Two of his circulators were suddenly stricken with bad memory and could not recall specifics. Another pleaded the Fifth (an odd choice, considering that there is no scenario in which they, themselves, broke any law; or perhaps not so odd, considering that this particular circulator was represented by Coughlin’s attorney). Two others said that they did not witness the alterations.</p><p>Coughlin was very careful to not admit to altering the petitions circulated by Jones and Davenport.</p><p>Republican BOE chairman Jack Morrison Jr.: “Well, did you fill out the word ‘Republican’ on that circulator statement?”</p><p>Coughlin: “I can’t say that I did.”</p><p>Morrison: “You don’t recognize that as your handwriting?”</p><p>Coughlin: “It may be, but I’m not going to stand here under oath and tell you that I did.”</p><p>Republican BOE member Brian K. Daley doesn’t believe much, if any, of Coughlin’s testimony. “Look, if the circulators were present, why didn’t he just have them fill it out?”</p><p>“I believe what he did was illegal,” says Williams. “Those petitions are akin to affidavits. To change any information on the documents without their prior knowledge or consent, I believe, is illegal.” A similar case that Williams recently investigated led to a felony indictment that was eventually pled down to a misdemeanor.</p><p>He will say this, though, “In the eight years we roomed together, I never saw any indication he was having an affair.”</p><p>That may prove to be small consolation if the prosecutor chooses to present the case to a Grand Jury.</p><p>What impact this probe — and his alleged affairs — may have on his bid for governor remain to be seen. But if Summit County politics is an indication, Coughlin is quickly running out of allies. The Rubber City, like state politics, is full of bridges, and Coughlin has done a good job of burning most of them.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc5df6d993ba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[FBI used Maura Murray case to link child pornography to Scott Wahl.]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesrenner.medium.com/fbi-used-maura-murray-case-to-link-child-pornography-to-scott-wahl-e2e632e9bc22?source=rss-8221d6e709bf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e2e632e9bc22</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James Renner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Jan 2023 18:37:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-12T18:40:49.968Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>FBI used Maura Murray case to link child pornography to Scott Wahl. Wahl acquitted after destroying computer.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/1*s6sd6TY9JUIeZPgKxf-5ZQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Wahl appeared on a popular DC podcast to discuss his work on the Maura Murray case.</figcaption></figure><p>*originally published February 14, 2021</p><p>At 5:30 a.m., the morning of September 6, 2012, nineteen federal agents arrived at the home of Scott Wahl, in Virginia, to seize computers and hard drives they believed were used to download and view child pornography. At the time, Wahl was well known to the family of Maura Murray but had yet to take on a more public role (that came later). Wahl had helped Helena Murray (a distant relative of Maura’s family, and spokesperson for the case) set up a computer to become more active online. He was also the admin for a Facebook page dedicated to the missing woman.</p><p>The Government’s Proposed Findings of Fact lays out what prompted the raid on Wahl’s home that morning.</p><p>According to court documents, on three occasions in May, June, and July 2012, law enforcement observed a computer that was using the Gnutella peer-to-peer to share a large collection of suspected child porn files over the Internet. That specific computer was associated with two IP addresses. Both IP addresses were assigned by Verizon to Scott Wahl.</p><p>FBI agent Steve Miller downloaded several suspected child porn files from the computer. The files were submitted to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, which confirmed that several of the files depicted sexual abuse against known children.</p><p>During the three-hours long raid, FBI agents seized “a number of items containing suspected or known child pornography, including a Dell laptop, Buffalo USB drive, and Fantom USB drive.” Both USB drives were taken from a locked safe that Wahl had to open for the agents. “Agent Miller submitted files from this computer equipment to NCMEC, which confirmed that several of the files on the Buffalo USB drive depicted sexual abuse against known and identified children.”</p><p>While the agents were surveying his computer equipment, Wahl said he thought his wireless Internet access was open, suggesting someone else may have used it to access the child pornography. He told them he’d only closed it up in the last few days. Agent Miller knew this to be untrue, as he’d checked the wireless network on multiple occasions and found it to be “locked down.” Wahl would have known better, too, as he worked on advanced computer and surveillance systems as part of his job.</p><p>As the agents removed evidence from his house, Wahl did not mention that his primary work laptop was not among the items seized. He’d accidentally left it at a house in Florida during a recent job and it was currently in transit, on a UPS truck.</p><p>When the FBI analyzed the evidence they did take, they found more suspicious activity, according to court documents. On the Dell laptop, they found search term histories that included the terms “Lolita” and “13y.” The Internet Explorer history confirmed that someone using the computer had visited websites that contained child pornography and viewed temporary Internet files of child porn. “Child pornography files were also found in unallocated clusters of the Dell laptop, which is where files go once they are ‘permanently’ deleted by the user but not yet overwritten by new files or programs.”</p><p>Wahl claimed the person who viewed the child pornography was his juvenile son and not him. And here’s when <a href="https://mauramurraymystery.com/">Maura Murray comes into this mess.</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/250/1*sez7IAak25mQqtLerG0msA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Maura Murray, missing since 2004.</figcaption></figure><p>The person using the computer was “undoubtedly” Wahl, the government said, because the person was also accessing information about and photographs of Maura Murray at the same time. “The Defendant is interested in the unsolved disappearance of Maura Murray, a young woman who had a car accident on a New Hampshire highway in February, 2004, and was never seen again. The Defendant claims to have spent time at the accident site in New Hampshire on multiple occasions, recorded a video retracing the route of Ms. Murray’s last drive, and posted the video to YouTube under the moniker ‘Human1666.’ The Defendant also claims to have met with Ms. Murray’s family members in Boston, and has had at least one long telephone call with one of those relatives.”</p><p>Forensic analysis of Wahl’s computer showed that on the anniversary of Maura’s disappearance, in 2012, whoever was using the computer had viewed a news report of Maura’s disappearance, then viewed a photo of Maura he had saved in a folder titled “Maura Murray/Pictures of Maura,” then viewed an adult porn file. After viewing the adult pornography, the user clicked on a folder marked “Needs to be sorted” which was on an external hard drive, then viewed a file titled, gangbang of a 13-year-old child. “Forensic analysis indicated that the child pornography was accessed through an external Western Digital My Passport hard drive,” which matched the type of drive that was seized from Wahl’s locked safe. After viewing the child porn, the user then visited this writer’s blog about Maura’s disappearance — MauraMurray.Blogspot.Com, which is no longer active. The current site is <a href="https://mauramurraymystery.com/">MauraMurrayMystery.com</a>.</p><p>The Buffalo USB drive was full of “methodically categorized” pornography, arranged in folders by content, such as “scat” and “shemale.” Forensics found child pornography in the root drive and the recycle bin. The child porn files on the root drive were all placed there between October and April, 2007, which made the excuse that it was his kid unbelievable to the agents, since his son would have been seven years old when those files were used.</p><p>More child porn was found on the Fantom USB drive, according to the prosecution, in a folder named “Downloads from Limewire.”</p><p>The child pornography found on the drives was especially abhorrent, including images of “two prepubescent girls being penetrated digitally and with objects” and “engaging in oral sex.”</p><p>And then came the big mistake in the case. The agents left that day with a trove of computers, hard drives, and evidence. But they didn’t follow up on the business laptop that was being mailed to Wahl from Florida — the computer he used most often.</p><p>As soon as the agents left, Wahl was on the phone with his friend in Florida who had sent the computer in the mail, asking for tracking numbers. The package arrived a couple hours after the FBI had left. When they asked for it some time later, Wahl turned over what remained, little more than a shell. From their report: “The Defendant methodically disassembled the computer, removed, and disposed of all items of interest to the FBI: the hard drive, which contained files, programs, GUID, and information about Internet searches and browsing; and the RAM, which also contained data and activity information for the device. The Defendant did not stop there, however: he went on to alter the wiring connected to the power supply (and dispose of the existing power supply) to prevent law enforcement from attempting to obtain information from the machine by installing new RAM, a new hard drive, and a new power supply.”</p><p>In May of 2013, a Grand Jury issued an indictment and Wahl was charged with receipt and possession of child pornography, both felonies. He was arraigned on July 7, where he entered a plea of not guilty. He was released on a $25,000 bond.</p><p>As a condition of his release, Wahl was asked to forfeit all firearms. He was allowed to continue working with computers as a business but he couldn’t have remote access to anyone else’s computer and had to tell them of the charges before entering their homes.</p><p>The government then announced its intention to use a US Attorney investigator named John Marsh to testify about the child porn files recovered from Wahl’s computers and hard drives. Marsh had been called to testify at many trials and was considered an expert in his field.</p><p>In August that year, Wahl was again indicted. This time they charged him with Obstruction of Justice for destroying his laptop before it could be analyzed.</p><p>In November of that year, as the trial approached, Wahl waived his right for a jury trial, preferring to have the judge, Anthony Trenga, decide his fate. Trenga is probably best known for re-incarcerating Chelsea Manning.</p><p>On December 4, Judge Trenga dismissed the receipt of child pornography charge following testimony of the FBI’s expert, Marsh. The following day, Wahl was acquitted of the remaining charges. At issue was not whether or not child pornography was present on the USB drives in Wahl’s private, locked safe — but who put them there. To this day, prosecutors on the case maintain Wahl was the one who accessed and downloaded the porn — pointing to the way Maura Murray’s case was mixed in with the actions — but due to Wahl destroying evidence, the chain of custody was always suspect.</p><p>“I was 100% exonerated of all charges,” Wahl writes in a public statement. “And as the verdict clearly demonstrates, the prosecution was unable to back up the claims.”</p><p>He goes on to write, “The charging papers clearly try to create the impression that I was attempting to conceal the equipment in my safe for sinister reasons. The truth is that the reason the equipment was in the safe was because my wife and I had caught out thirteen-year-old son illegally downloading music and viewing pornography in his room.”</p><p>He writes that the testimony of forensic analyst John Marsh was “inaccurate” and most of his testimony was stricken from the record “in a motion that the prosecution did not even bother to object to.” He writes that he was able to demonstrate that he was not within 500 miles of where the government claimed he was when the child porn was accessed on at least one occasion. He writes that he damaged his personal laptop in an attempt to fix it after he started experiencing “blue-screening” before the Florida job (though when investigators questioned the friends in Florida, they said he was on it all the time and didn’t complain about it not working).</p><p>Wahl goes on to suggest that one of the detective’s involved in his case may have been targeting his son for sex. He writes that David Abbott, a member of the Washington D.C. Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force, provided testimony that allowed the feds to obtain the search warrant for his home. <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/manassas-city-police-detective-in-teen-sexting-case-commits-suicide/2015/12/15/de88f7c4-a356-11e5-9c4e-be37f66848bb_story.html">In 2015, Abbott, who taught youth hockey in Prince William County, committed suicide after he got caught sexting with an underage boy.</a></p><p>“I feel physically ill when I consider the possibility that this entire ordeal may have been the result of my son, who was thirteen at the time, having been the target of an alleged child predator.”</p><p>Since Wahl’s battle in court, he has taken on a larger role with the family of Maura Murray and has represented them at CrimeCon, appeared as a guest host of Erinn Larkin’s podcast, and still helps run the Maura Murray Public Figure Facebook Page. His latest post went up on February 9, the anniversary of Maura’s disappearance.</p><p>Julie Murray, Maura’s sister, was made aware of the child pornography charges prior to allowing Wahl t<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IEtHdiNogtQ">o represent the case at CrimeCon in 2019</a>. When the information became known to people in the “community” that surrounds the case, in late 2019, Julie told others that she was “distancing” herself from Wahl. He was removed from his admin role on a Murray family Facebook page at that time. But the family allows him to continue involvement on a separate Facebook page, where people sometimes submit tips about the cold case.</p><p>The pornography case was not the first time that Wahl found himself in trouble with the law. In 2000, he was charged with carrying a concealed weapon, following an incident involving the mother of his child, but charges were dropped under the condition that he surrender the weapon to the state. He was also charged with assault and battery in a domestic case but was acquitted.</p><p>In July, 2004, Wahl was charged after he followed someone too closely in his vehicle. There is no information on victim’s sex or age. He was also charged for not having his license plates displayed in what may be a separate incident around that time. He was found guilty on both counts when he didn’t show up for the hearing, according to court documents.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FIhljiOcDbBs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DIhljiOcDbBs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FIhljiOcDbBs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/eed35365cbb865f7c61827fdcaa5e5fc/href">https://medium.com/media/eed35365cbb865f7c61827fdcaa5e5fc/href</a></iframe><p>Since then, Wahl has become a public figure, not just in the Maura Murray online community and podcasts, but also as a guest on Spicer &amp; Co, where he appeared on Sean Spicer’s show to discuss the rise in gun sales during COVID (Wahl works as a manager at a gun store in Virginia). On the April 21 broadcast, Spicer interviewed Wahl, who said, “Most Republicans in our area already kind of have their stockpiles… or not stockpiles, but have their firearms.” He was talking about how Democrats were coming into the store, unfamiliar with background checks, and suggested they were “mislead by the media” about the law. He said sales were five-times higher at the start of COVID, a boom to business, better even than after Newtown and Las Vegas.</p><p>He seems to pop up in every facet of Maura Murray’s case. A couple summers ago he turned up unexpectedly at a bar where Erinn Larkin was having drinks with the girlfriend of Bill Rausch (who was Maura Murray’s boyfriend at the time of her disappearance). The girlfriend thought that Wahl was “creepy” and tried to keep her distance. <a href="https://mauramurraymystery.com/in-his-victims-words/">That woman would go on to file a protection order against Rausch after years of abuse. </a>She believes Larkin was filming her without her permission at the bar, in some sort of reconnaissance mission for Rausch.</p><p>Behind the scenes, Wahl tries to maintain an iron grip on the narrative of Maura Murray’s case and many people find his direct messages to be threatening in nature, when someone disagrees with him. Others have claimed he uses fake aliases to comment on and to like his own posts, though he has denied these allegations.</p><p>When Maura Murray Missing host Tim Pilleri posted on Twitter about Wahl’s history, Wahl sent a text threatening legal action. He’s done the same to journalist Maggie Freleng, going so far as to have a lawyer issue a warning to her in December, 2019, after she mentioned his charges on Reddit.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*rRTKN4polGLm_jcmYOyV0Q.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/822/1*4zP5uvZz6RCmFndzzCjbew.png" /></figure><p>And over the years, he has threatened this writer, too, saying that he was ready “to go to war” if need be.</p><p>He also said that Erinn Larkin planned to file a frivolous lawsuit against this writer, because “even if she doesn’t win, she understands you will lose tens of thousands of dollars defending yourself.” Here’s a small sample of texts he’s sent to my personal number:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/848/1*T5wg-Kd18FWEq4jHheDKkQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/864/1*iZmYFoVp3bLjy8IuzLpwWA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/840/1*dZOqqXiO8aTTB5E-hfCS7A.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/844/1*ErXqJM604Cmc6LAxMqe7dQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/838/1*WzkR-toifPIaRn9SbDqO0w.png" /></figure><p>A law enforcement official who worked on Wahl’s case, but who wishes to remain anonymous, had this to say, “I think about Scott Wahl every day. I wake up in the morning and turn on the news to see if he’s on there after having done something terrible.”</p><p>Documents:</p><p><a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1I_zrTalP5T2fpsPRVJZfjNBmM0ByBO6q/view?usp=sharing">Findings of Fact</a></p><p><a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1vF0gSWdVknE4bYrP9CKq5iW26U7TrB19/view?usp=sharing">Seized Evidence</a></p><p><a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gYyELz76wHysQZLd47hx8fmWY-eWneNV/view?usp=sharing">Wahl’s Statement</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e2e632e9bc22" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Little Liars Everywhere]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesrenner.medium.com/little-liars-everywhere-42f285c36cf0?source=rss-8221d6e709bf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/42f285c36cf0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[lisa-pruett]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[shaker-heights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[true-crime]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[james-renner]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-soke]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James Renner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Aug 2021 11:01:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-23T11:01:06.233Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Four murders, two false confessions, one meddling cop. And some Shaker Heights kids in the middle of it all.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Vjt6Qkn3Givam2jhCWkdrw.png" /><figcaption>Residence of Philip and Dorothy Porter</figcaption></figure><p>JAMES ARNOS WAS ONLY NINETEEN when he found his grandfather’s dead body. It was Sunday, May 19, 1985 and James’s mother, Joly, had become concerned that she had not heard from her mother in several days. So she sent her son, James, to check in. Her mother was Dorothy Porter, a renowned artist, who lived with her husband Philip Porter in a large house in Shaker Heights, on Lee Road near Shaker Boulevard. Philip was executive editor of the <em>Plain Dealer</em> in the 60s. The couple were practically Cleveland royalty.</p><p>When James arrived, the day’s paper — a Sunday <em>Plain Dealer</em> — was still sitting in the driveway — a bad omen to discover at the home of a career journalist. All the doors were locked but the lights were on inside. When he knocked, nobody came to the door. So James went home and told his mother. Then the two of them returned to the house and Joly used a spare key to open the kitchen door.</p><p>“Mother?” she called. But nobody answered. Joly could sense something was very wrong. She told James to go next door and get help. James returned quickly with the neighbor and the two of them went upstairs while Joly remained by the door. James found Philip in bed. He’d been stabbed twice in the back. His body lay face-down, dressed in pajamas, his fingers still grasping a pair of eyeglasses. A thermos of milk and a plate of crackers rested on the nightstand. They found Dorothy in the basement. She’d been stabbed, once, and strangled to death with the cord from her iron.</p><p>Peter Gray was chief of police in Shaker Heights back then. Chief Gray told the media that the Porters’ murders appeared to be a burglary gone wrong but they had no leads. Philip and Dorothy were last seen alive on May 17, a Friday night, when they’d hosted a cocktail party at their house. Their guests left around seven o’clock. It appeared the break-in had happened between 7 and 9 p.m., an odd time for such a brazen home invasion — it would have still been light outside. The point of entry was a kitchen window. Someone had cut through the screen and climbed inside.</p><p>“Nothing appeared to be disturbed,” Chief Gray told the <em>Plain Dealer</em>. “It doesn’t appear to be a regular burglary, with things shuffled around. There was none of that. There wasn’t even a real sign of a struggle. If it weren’t for the two dead bodies, you wouldn’t know something had happened.”</p><p>Dorothy’s purse and wallet were out in the open when police arrived. The working theory was that the burglar had come in as the Porters were preparing for bed and Dorothy had come down and interrupted the crime.</p><p>This was in the days before police really used DNA. Long before the magic of genetic genealogy. Their only suspect was an unidentifiable black man that a fifteen-year-old neighborhood kid named David Branagan had seen running away from the house that night. The case went cold for several years.</p><p>Then, in 1990, Shaker Heights detectives caught a break. A young con named Donny Soke (pronounced Soh-key), confessed to the crime. He said he and his father broke into the house that night, looking to rob the Porters. But then things got out of hand and his old man had to kill them. Donny was convicted and remains in prison to this day. His father, Ted, died in prison in 2008.</p><p>So what’s the mystery? It’s a closed case. Off the books. The murderer is dead, his accomplice is in prison. Justice was done.</p><p>Except, Donny Soke recanted his confession during his trial and again this year. He says a rogue Eastlake cop helped him invent the story with the promise of favors in prison. All we know for sure is that there is no physical evidence linking Donny or his father to the scene of the crime. And a new review of the murders suggests a much better suspect — the teen who claimed to see a black man running from the Porters’ house that night — David Branagan, who would later become a suspect in that other Shaker Heights tragedy — the unsolved murder of Lisa Pruett.</p><p>And if Soke is telling the truth, the Shaker Heights police may have let a killer slip through their fingers twice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*qzK5usPnkpO3rGjjNOJGUA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The Soke Family</figcaption></figure><p>WHAT WOULD CAUSE DONNY SOKE to confess to murders he never committed? To understand how that happened, it’s important to first understand where Donny Soke came from.</p><p>Debbie Holley is Donny’s older sister. Today, she works as a hairstylist and is a single mother to three grown children on the west side. Fifty years ago, she was Donny’s protector, holding his hand on the long walks to school in the country. Their father, Ted, was in prison for burglary and she and Donny and their younger brother, Dean, were living with their grandparents. Their mother had abandoned them.</p><p>It was better for her and Donny when their father was in prison. Ted ran with the Hells Angels and had a violent temper. “I remember Ted beating Donny as a kid,” says Holley. “I remember hearing Donny scream bloody murder one day and I ran outside to see my dad had pushed Donny’s face into the gravel driveway and was pounding on him. I told him, ‘Stop, you’re going to kill him!’”</p><p>Violence in the Soke family had been passed down like a bad gene. When her father was a child, says Holley, her grandparents would tie him up in the basement and make him lean his knees into corn kernels until he behaved.</p><p>When she turned thirteen, Holley was invited back to live with their mother and her brothers ended up as wards of the state. That’s when Donny, who she remembers as a sweet boy, started getting into serious trouble.</p><p>“Looking back, I think Donny had undiagnosed ADD,” says Holley. “I think he was just a kid who couldn’t settle his mind and his environment was chaos. How are you supposed to act when your parents give you up? He went into a boy’s home and found more abuse there.”</p><p>Then, their mother got cancer. Donny was eighteen and serving a three-to-fifteen stretch at Pickaway on a burglary charge. Even though his mother had abandoned him, Donny desperately wanted to see her before she died. And that’s when he came up with a really stupid plan — to make up information about a crime to exchange for early release.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LjEVXsyix4WY-um4PjhBzA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Donald Soke</figcaption></figure><p>IT TAKES ABOUT AN HOUR to gain entry into the visitor’s room at the Toledo Correctional Institution, today. It’s a maximum-security prison operating during a pandemic and security is paramount. Visitation only occurs on certain days and a visitor must schedule in advance. Once there, you must submit to a rapid COVID test and then return to your car for twenty minutes until someone calls with the results. If it comes back negative, you can then proceed to check-in. There’s paperwork to fill out and you’re given a visitor’s badge which you then must carry to the next building, where they scan your drivers’ license. After that, you are let through a man trap and a set of double-doors and into the prison, itself. You’re taken to Visitation, then, a room the size of an elementary school gym, where you take a seat at a long table with a plexiglass partition that keeps any germs to one side. Then the prisoner is paged and led from their cell to the room. As a prize for making it all this way, chips and water are provided.</p><p>I chose Doritos when I met with Donny Soke. The first thing I noticed, other than the spiderweb tattoo that covers his entire face, was that Soke was missing a finger. A pinky. “I’m in Toledo for my protection,” he explains. “The Aryan brotherhood nearly killed me. Took my finger. So they brought me here.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/790/1*kawtVGG6_UcyzoRV8YCCaw.png" /><figcaption>Donnie Soke, today</figcaption></figure><p>This was the first time I’d met Donny Soke in person but we had spoken on the phone at least once a week for six months. I knew his story, already, but we went over it all again.</p><p>The first link in the chain of terrible circumstances that leads to Donny being in Toledo Correctional, minus a finger, is a deep-for-trouble man named Daniel Ott. Ask any law enforcement official who’s served in Cleveland in the last fifty years and they’re likely to have a story or two about Dan Ott. His rap sheet goes back to 1960 and includes at least fourteen counts of auto theft. He was just sent back to prison in 2019, at the age of <em>seventy-eight</em>, for stealing a trailer owned by a drug task force. In 2006, an unfortunate man who shared his name was murdered by hitmen who were too stupid to verify their target. In 1989, Ott was a police informant, feeding detectives information he picked up from the rumor mill in prison, rolling on badder guys to reduce his own sentence.</p><p>Ott told police that he knew of a guy in prison named Soke who had something to do with the murder of a schoolteacher’s wife. An Eastlake detective named Tom Doyle heard about this and figured he meant Karen LaSpina, the wife a popular high school teacher out that way.</p><p>Karen LaSpina’s bloodied body had been found inside her Eastlake home, on October 10 1985, just five months after the Porters murders. She’d been stabbed fifty-five times and bled out on her kitchen floor.</p><p>Soon, Doyle was visiting Donny in prison. At first, Donny told him that he and his buddy “Kirby” had gone out drinking and to hustle pool the day of the murder. But they weren’t as good at pool as they thought and they decided it would be easier to just rob someone. They drove around, looking for empty houses to ransack, and ended up at the LaSpina home. Soke and his cohort broke in, thinking the place was empty, and Karen surprised him, so Kirby killed her. That was his initial story.</p><p>But police were able to confirm that Kirby was elsewhere at the time of the murder. Detective Doyle had a hunch that the murder had actually been committed by Soke’s father, Ted, who had a history of violent behavior. He thought it likely that Donny was trying to cover for his old man by implicating someone else. Eventually, Donny gave him the story he was looking for. Yes, he said, it was his father who’d really done the killing.</p><p>Donny, then just twenty-years-old, told Doyle that he would testify against his father on two conditions: one, that he’d get a reduced prison sentence for the burglary; and two, that Doyle would take him to see his mother, who was dying of cancer and was not expected to live long enough to see his release.</p><p>So for weeks, Doyle would pick Soke up from prison, take him to see his mom, maybe get him a pizza or a burger, and then drive him back. Each time, Soke divulged a little more information about his father’s role in the LaSpina homicide, like some hillbilly Scheherazade. There is no honor among thieves, even in the best of circumstances, and Donny’s father was a violent prick. Why not give the Ted some of that trouble? Looking back on it, Doyle’s sister believes he did it simply to get attention from their father.</p><p>After Donny agreed to testify. Ted was indicted on the LaSpina murder. But charges were dropped after Donny had a change of heart and admitted he’d made the whole thing up. None of it was true. But it was too late to unring the bell. Because of his confession, Donny was convicted of the LaSpina murder. And now he was in the slammer for life.</p><p>What did Donny do, then? Like any gambling addict, he went double-or-nothing on another deal. He told Doyle that he had information on a murder involving a newspaperman. Doyle figured that Donny meant Philip Porter and his wife, Dorothy, who were murdered a day before Donny’s eighteenth birthday. Donny said that he, his father, and another man named Danny Crawford, broke into the Porter house and killed them.</p><p><a href="https://casetext.com/case/state-v-soke-1">According to later statements by an appeals panel</a>, Detective Doyle gave Donny confidential police reports from the Porter homicides with all the information he needed to concoct his new story.</p><p>“The fact that Donald Soke had in his possession an initial crime scene investigation is nothing short of astounding,” the judges wrote in their decision. “Not one member of this distinguished panel can ever recall a report of this nature being produced at trial, let alone given into the possession of a witness. The reason is obvious, and it is to prevent a situation just as the one we have here now. One of the few credible things about the testimony of Donald Soke was his knowledge of information that, quote, only the murderer could know. And that is now given a new dimension.”</p><p>Donny and Crawford were given special deals to roll on Ted Soke — Crawford would only be charged with burglary, out in a couple months. Donny was given a promise that if he testified against his father, the prosecutor would not seek the death penalty. Now, Donny hated his father and wanted him in prison, but he also didn’t want to send his father to the chair. Donny took the deal and Ted was convicted by a panel of three judges. But the prosecutor reneged on his promise to Donny and Ted was sentenced to death. So, again, Donny recanted his testimony, admitting he’d made it all up. And Ted had to be retried. A jury found Ted guilty in that trial, too, and he was re-sentenced to seven-to-life.</p><p>There is not a single piece of physical evidence that links any of these men to the homicides of Karen LaSpina or Philip and Dorothy Porter. And the testimony of the getaway driver, Danny Crawford, does not hold salt if you’ve ever been to Shaker.</p><p>“We drove around a few neighborhoods,” Crawford said in his official statement to police. “And came across a couple houses that looked like they might be good prospects but we decided on the Porter house. We parked right next door to the house out in the street.”</p><p>The Porters lived on Lee Road. There is no parking on Lee Road to this day. A shifty-eyed guy sitting in a ragged car in front of a mansion at 8 p.m. on Lee Road in May is likely to be spotted by neighbors or police within minutes. But Crawford said he sat there for nearly a half hour, unseen.</p><p>The only thing that convicted the Sokes was Donny’s testimony and testimony from other jailhouse snitches, who cut their own deals with police. And each of them dealt with one officer, in particular — Detective Tom Doyle.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Atk52VGEVUnRxT02n1O8xQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Soke’s sister, Debbie Holley</figcaption></figure><p>TOM DOYLE WAS THE SPOKESMAN for the Eastlake police for a number of years and cultivated close relationships with journalists in Cleveland. He still plays poker with some of them to this day. He has a gregarious nature and can tell one hell of story — whether it’s about going to war with the Hells Angels or how he was on the force when Eastlake formed their first detective bureau after a body washed up on the beach one day. Soon enough, he was investigating other high crimes. Doyle discovered early on that he was skilled at turning cons into confidential informants. And his informants helped solve his cases. And that was how a good detective proved his worth.</p><p>“When you’re a detective, you get holidays, weekends, nights because you’re good at solving cases,” he explained. “You start not solving cases, you’ll be back to dog complaints and druggies puking on you.”</p><p>The night of the Karen LaSpina’s murder, Doyle was attending another cop’s retirement party. Almost everyone in the department was there. The beer and booze were flowing and in the midst of their celebration, everyone’s pagers went off at once. That’s how they learned about the homicide. Just about everyone there knew Karen’s husband, Tony. Tony was a popular math teacher at Eastlake North. According to Doyle, Tony was also the guy who picked up their sports betting slips and drove them out to Dino’s bar, where some other guy took them to the Italians in Collinwood and brought back their winnings. Tony had just gone into business with an Eastlake cop, Leon Hodkey, buying up houses to remodel and flip. Tony was also a part-time dispatcher for the department.</p><p>Earlier that day, Tony had called Hodkey and asked him to come look at a new house. The cop came over and then Tony, Karen, and their three kids drove around with him for a bit. But they couldn’t find the house, so they returned home. “When they get home, Tony says to Karen, ‘I’m going to the store to pick up a Sweetest Day present. You go on inside and I’ll take the kids and we’ll be right back.”</p><p>Tony said that he found Karen’s body on the floor, inside, when they returned.</p><p>“By Monday, we knew that Tony had a girlfriend,” said Doyle. “Tony gets an attorney, refuses a polygraph.” Tony married his girlfriend six months later.</p><p>The detectives took carpet samples from the scene. They found blood that didn’t come from Karen. The lab told them that the blood contained “esterase D type 2,” a rare gene that only one in a hundred people have. So Doyle and the other detectives put together “vampire kits,” little packets that included a note card, a lancet, a piece of gauze, and a band-aid. Whenever they arrested someone for a violent crime they asked them nicely for a blood sample to see if they had esterase D type 2.</p><p>“August 15, 1989, I get a call,” said Doyle. “It’s Buddy Kovacic, the nephew of the police chief in Cleveland. He says, I got this informant.” That was Dan Ott, who suggested that Donny Soke might have something to do with the crime.</p><p>Doyle sent an officer down to collect a blood sample from Donny Soke. “When the officer asked for the blood, Soke said, ‘This is about the schoolteacher’s wife.’ Later, when I talked to him, I told him you should never play hearts, Donny. So he told us what happened. Funny thing is, he didn’t even have ESD-2 in his blood. But his father did.”</p><p>It was around this time that Doyle learned about Danny Crawford, Soke’s friend and sometime partner in crime. Doyle had a hunch that Crawford knew something about it all. So Doyle picked Crawford up from jail on a warrant to convey him to Lake County jail. “I put him in the back and I say, ‘My warrant says I’m to take you to Lake County, but it doesn’t say how. You can relax, you can smoke, you can drink coffee. But you cause any problems, I’ll put you in the trunk.’”</p><p>For a while all Crawford did was look out at the world through the back window. Eventually Doyle asked him what the fuck he was looking at. “I haven’t seen a tree in nine months,” Crawford said.</p><p>During their ride, Crawford told Doyle that, sure, Ted and Donny did the LaSpina murder. He agreed to testify against them.</p><p>Meanwhile, other jailhouse snitches were suggesting that Donny Soke and Danny Crawford were involved in even more crimes. Everyone wanted a deal from Doyle. One inmate said that when he shared a cell with Crawford, Crawford got drunk and said, “They didn’t have to kill the old man. He couldn’t even get out of bed. But they killed him and then drank his milk and ate his cookies.”</p><p>‘“Now, I hear this,” said Doyle, “and I’m thinking this inbred fucking hillbilly shit doesn’t read the paper. So how would he know about the milk and cookies [at the Porters]? He couldn’t.”</p><p>Doyle presented the information to detectives in Shaker Heights. At first they gave him the cold shoulder. And Doyle took it personally. He believed that the police in Shaker Heights looked at Eastlake as a “hick department.” It wasn’t a particularly good time for Doyle. At home, his marriage was falling apart. She wanted a divorce. And she wanted him to stop chasing the Porter case. But he couldn’t leave it alone.</p><p>Finally, two Shaker Heights detectives met with Doyle to hear him out. They came to Eastlake and Doyle introduced them to Crawford’s girlfriend. That’s when the girlfriend told them about how she’d sent newspaper clippings to Danny Crawford when he was in prison. Crawford really was a hick who read the news and he’d had all the details he needed to fabricate his story.</p><p>The detectives were furious. One thought Doyle was wasting their time. “He called me an asshole and then he left,” said Doyle.</p><p>When Doyle returned home that night, he found a half-eaten pizza in a box for supper. On the box was a note from his wife — she’d left and taken the kids.</p><p>The detective sat and ate the pizza and mused on his life. “What is wrong with you, Tom?” he wondered. “How can I see something nobody else sees?”</p><p>At 9 a.m. the following morning, Shaker Heights Detective Gerald Jankowski called. He thought there might be something to Doyle’s theory after all. So Jankowski and Doyle hit the prisons again, fishing for informants that could link the Sokes to Philip and Dorothy Porter.</p><p>Eventually, Doyle was able to get Donny to testify against his father to close the Porters homicides.</p><p>Doyle visited Donny shortly after the verdict. “Donny was exuberant,” Doyle recalls. “He thinks he’s getting out of prison because he made a deal to testify. But he pleaded guilty to a first-degree felony in the process. I tell him, ‘I don’t know why God takes angels and makes them babies and gives them to people like Ted Soke, but He did. And that man ruined your life. You’re fucked. You’re never getting out.’”</p><p>Donny started to cry. “But I felt good,” said Doyle. “I felt unburdened.’</p><p>The next day, Doyle accepted an award for being the top investigator in the entire state of Ohio. This moment was clearly the height of Doyle’s career.</p><p>On the way back to his empty house after accepting the award, the big, clunky car phone in Doyle’s vehicle rang. It was not good news. A judge had just vacated Ted’s conviction in the Porters case. Donny had contacted the court and said he’d lied on the stand because the police had offered him deals. Donny claimed that every word he’d said on the stand was untrue. Now, the Cuyahoga County prosecutor wanted Doyle’s head.</p><p>To this day, Doyle believes the Sokes killed Philip and Dorothy Porter. And it wasn’t a simple interrupted burglary, he says, but a targeted assassination — his working theory now is that Ted was a member of the Hells Angels and Philip had written some unsavory things about the motorcycle gang as a journalist two decades before and so he had to be gotten rid of.</p><p>Doyle is retired now but his last years on the force were fraught with controversy. On March 9, 2006, Doyle and another police officer were driving down U.S. 6, after having a few drinks. Doyle stopped the car in the middle of the westbound lane and got out to take a piss. A twenty-one-year-old in a Nissan came up behind him, swerved to avoid the car, and hit Doyle instead, sending the policeman flying. Doyle broke his shoulder and leg in the accident. The young man who hit him was actually cited for failure to control. After a twelve-week investigation, Doyle was charged with driving under the influence and improper parking.</p><p>Danny Crawford has kept close with Doyle over the years. Some time ago, according to Doyle, Crawford called him to ask for a ride back to town from prison. Since then, Doyle has spent around a thousand dollars of his own money to help Crawford acclimate to life outside. “Not because I feel guilty by any means,” Doyle wanted me to know. “The system fucked him.”</p><p>Doyle believes he always did what he had to do. And even if Doyle is retired, he’s still a cop at heart — he’s put two of his own sons in jail for heroin possession. “I’m a firm believer in doing the right thing,” he said.</p><p>According to Doyle, Donny is a serial killer and guilty of to two additional homicides. One of them, he says, is the murder of Nadine Madger of Willoughby, who was killed in 1980. Donny would have been thirteen at the time. For his part, Donny says he keeps admitting to crimes because Doyle keeps putting money on his commissary account. Prison is hell but some money for snacks and coffee makes it just a little more comfortable.</p><p>If Donny made it all up, then who killed Philip and Dorothy Porter? There were other suspects for a time. Before Donny confessed, the only leads the police had came from three neighborhood kids, David Branagan and his two friends. Let’s call them John and Bill. Bill was thirteen, John was fourteen, and David was fifteen at the time of the murders.</p><p>The boys told an intriguing story — on the night of the murders, Bill’s parents were hosting a preview party for an upcoming auction (they were moving out of town, soon, and selling some things before they left). When the adults weren’t looking, the boys stole some beers and snuck through Branagan’s backyard to the abandoned house beside the Porters’ residence, where they broke into a garage and let off some fireworks. They told detectives that as they were leaving they saw a black man in the Porters’ back yard.</p><p>“The boys observed the suspect looking through the rear windows,” the report reads. “The suspect apparently did not see the boys at first, as he was slightly crouched down, walking slowly by the rear windows and still looking inside.”</p><p>The boys didn’t tell their parents about any of this until the police came knocking at their door while canvassing the area. Bill and John sat with sketch artists who came up with two different drawings of a generic black man.</p><p>Five years after the Porters were murdered, Branagan inserted himself into another homicide investigation — the murder of Lisa Pruett. Branagan went to the police station the day after Lisa’s murder to tell them a familiar story — he’d run into a black man at a bus stop and he believed the man was responsible for Lisa’s murder as well as the murder of the Porters.</p><p>Branagan was twenty years old when Lisa was murdered, and was still living in his uncle’s house on Sedgewick Road, which runs parallel to Lee Road. Branagan’s home was just behind the Porters’ house, diagonally to the south, separated by some trees and bushes.</p><p>When Branagan spoke to police the day after Lisa’s murder, he told them he’d walked by the scene of Lisa’s murder that night, returning home from dropping off his girlfriend, Holly Robinson. He accurately described the police and the canine unit that had searched the corner of Lee and South Woodland. He said he’d been stopped by a detective but let go and that his aunt was awake when he got home. He said he spoke to her and then took a shower.</p><p>But when detectives brought Branagan in for a second interview, he admitted that he’d lied to them. He’d never spoken to police that night. He had quietly observed them without being seen. When the detective asked why he’d lied, Branagan said, “To build drama. And to pique people’s interest in me.” He also admitted that his aunt was asleep when he returned home. No one had seen him before he showered and went to bed.</p><p>Holly Anderson claims Branagan told her that he was breaking into homes the night of Lisa’s murder — several of Branagan’s former friends and ex-girlfriends also say he admitted to breaking into homes on Lee and Sedgewick for years. Branagan would use a knife to cut into screens and open windows and doors. A week prior to Lisa’s murder, someone cut into the screen on Joel Rathbone’s house, which was just behind the backyard where the girl’s body was found. The same person apparently tried to break into the house across the street from Rathbone’s too. And the night of the murder, Mrs. Bush, the owner of the property where Lisa was murdered, reported that she heard what sounded like someone breaking into a rental car in her driveway about twenty minutes before she heard the girl’s scream.</p><p>During the course of their investigation into Lisa’s murder, Shaker Heights police came to believe that whoever killed her had learned that she was sneaking out of her house to meet up with her boyfriend, Dan Dreifort that night. They knew that Kevin Young (who would later be tried and acquitted of the crime) had learned of Lisa’s plans from a friend of Dan’s named Tex Workman, while talking at Arabica on Shaker Square. The only other customers at the time when Tex and Kevin were talking about Lisa were David Branagan and Holly Robinson.</p><p>Just before Kevin’s very public trial, Holly Robinson met with Cuyahoga County prosecutors and told them that she believed Branagan could have murdered Lisa Pruett. He’d left her house with plenty of time to intersect Lisa on her way to her boyfriend’s. And Branagan, she knew, had a collection of skinning knives and he always kept one on him for protection. She says prosecutors were not interested in hearing her out.</p><p>“They said Branagan had an alibi,” says Robinson. “But I was his alibi. And so I didn’t think that was true.”</p><p>David Branagan died in 2017. Cause of death was “hypertensive arteriosclerotic cardiovascular disease” and “cirrhosis of the liver.” Before he died, he fathered a child with a woman named Tracy Warner. Shortly before his death, Branagan began stockpiling weapons in their Twinsburg apartment, she says. When I asked Tracy whether she thought Branagan could be involved in Lisa’s murder she said, “Let me tell you a story he shared with me. When he was in preschool, a boy picked on him. He waited until lunchtime and then he put Comet cleaner in the boy’s sandwich. Do I think he did it? Sure. I wouldn’t be surprised.”</p><p>The stories about Branagan’s dark predilections continue to come in as news travels the grapevine of Shaker Heights. Just last month, this reporter was contacted by a former girlfriend of his from high school, a woman named Kim Forward. She started dating Branagan when she was just a freshman and he was a junior. She wasn’t allowed to be at his house if his adoptive parents weren’t home but he’d sneak her over, anyway, using a footpath only neighborhood kids knew about, a thin path that winds through backyards between Lee and Sedgewich from South Woodland all the way to where the Porters once lived. There was a spare bedroom over Branagan’s garage and he would take her there for sex. Sometimes he would bring out the knives he collected and use them during foreplay.</p><p>Kim knows firsthand how skilled Branagan was at breaking into homes. He would sneak into her house at night, quietly enough that her father, who was a Vietnam vet, didn’t hear him. Once inside, he would coerce her into doing things she didn’t want to do. “If you don’t, I’ll make a lot of noise and wake up your dad,” he’d tell her.</p><p>“Looking back, he had episodes of darkness,” she says, today. “Depressive episodes. Do I think he’s capable of having killed Lisa? Yes, I do. But we had it in our minds back then that it was Kevin Young.”</p><p>Branagan’s friend, John, lives in Florida these days. He still remembers the night the Porters died in great detail — how they broke into the property beside the Porters that night and saw an unidentified Black man in the back yard. “I watched this guy going around the house, trying to get in,” he says. “We bolted. Hopped the fence behind us and ran back to Sedgewick. Dave said the guy chased us but I didn’t see that.”</p><p>John says that Branagan grew more reckless as he got older. He stole wine from John’s parents and broke into the Millers’ house down the street and stole a shotgun. “When people mention David Branagan, I get nervous,” he said. “He always wanted to be bigger and better than you. He wanted the limelight.”</p><p>Bill’s story is a little different, today. He says he saw the black man come out of the back door of the Porters’ house. “I heard the screen door slam shut,” he says. “Then I bee-lined straight to the fence.” The detail about the door is odd, given that the house was locked from the inside when James Arnos arrived two days later.</p><p>After running home, Bill realized he’d his jacket behind. It had his name in it, he says, and he was afraid the police might find it. So he and Branagan went back and discovered it stuck in the fence.</p><p>Bill said that a couple detectives stopped by his house after Philip and Dorothy Porter’s bodies were discovered that Sunday. They took the boys’ statements. Later, one of the detectives came back to speak with Bill’s mother. He told her he thought her son was lying.</p><p>Not too long after that, Soke confessed to the murders and he never saw the detective again.</p><p>“I’m sure it was Danny Crawford I saw coming out of that house that night,” he says.</p><p>I had to point out to him that Danny Crawford is white.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3p2j0Ya-P6IKW02FkZr_Fw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Ted Soke</figcaption></figure><p>THERE IS ONE WAY to know for sure who killed Philip and Dorothy Porter. The evidence could be tested. Somewhere in storage is that iron that was used to strangle Dorothy. The killer would have needed a firm grip on the cord.</p><p>James Arnos thinks it’s time for a definitive answer. “My family would like the evidence in the case to be tested for DNA so that we may know for sure and in the hope that it will bring some final clarity to this horrific event,” he says.</p><p>But for the moment, Shaker Heights police consider the Porters murders solved and the Lisa Pruett case has been deemed “inactive.”</p><p>Civil right attorney, Terry Gilbert, is currently reviewing Soke’s case “The misconduct of Detective Doyle is breathtaking,” he says,“a text book primer on how to corrupt the criminal justice system, by manipulating snitches and engineering false confessions to create the illusion of solving crimes. After 30 years of forensic DNA progress, we now know how these nefarious tactics are a leading cause of wrongful convictions, where vulnerable victims like Donny Soke languish in prison while Doyle walks away with bragging rights and no accountability.”</p><p>Final note: During the reporting of this story, Donny Soke changed his story once again. He now maintains he was involved in all of these murders. His letter was notarized and came, not from the prison where all his other letters went sent from, but from the home of retired detective Tom Doyle.</p><p><em>James Renner is a former Scene staff writer and founder of the nonprofit The Porchlight Project, which raises funding for new DNA testing for Ohio cold cases. porchlightonline.org. His next book, about the unsolved murder of Lisa Pruett, is set to be published next year.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=42f285c36cf0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Beyond the Jungle of Bad]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesrenner.medium.com/beyond-the-jungle-of-bad-9840660087f6?source=rss-8221d6e709bf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9840660087f6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[true-crime]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mystery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[crime]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[journalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[dna]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James Renner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 03 Oct 2018 16:12:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-10-03T16:12:56.923Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>The True Story of Two Women from California Who Are Solving All the Mysteries.</h4><p>By James Renner</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*sJnRqI66W7MJ3s4d" /><figcaption>“person holding gray skull illustration” by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@yipleonardo?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Leonardo Yip</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Case Study: Joseph Newton Chandler</strong></p><p>They called the dead man Joseph Newton Chandler but that wasn’t his name. He lived alone in an efficiency in a nondescript apartment complex in Eastlake, Ohio, a workaday suburb of Cleveland. He rarely ventured far from home and the closest thing he had to a friend was a former coworker at a chemical factory he once listed as an emergency contact on his employment forms.</p><p>One day in July, 2002, Chandler purchased a handgun — a .38 caliber Charter Arms revolver. The old man returned home. He locked his door and windows, turned off the AC. Then he stepped into to his bathroom, faced the mirror, and put the barrel of the gun in his mouth. The last thing to enter his mind, other than that bullet, may have been the dark secret he was leaving behind.</p><p>By the time anyone noticed he was missing, Chandler’s body had decomposed in the summer heat and maggots had got at it. It was impossible to lift fingerprints. Police reviewed the paperwork this dead man had provided to the rental office, searching for next of kin. He’d listed a sister, Mary Wilson, who lived at 1823 Center Street, in Columbus. But the address led to an empty lot. It was important they find some relative — he’d left $82,000 in the bank.</p><p>The court appointed his coworker as the executor of his estate and enlisted a private investigator — Mike Lewis — to track down Chandler’s family. Lewis used Chandler’s birth certificate to identify his parents and then cross-checked birth records in Buffalo, where Chandler was born, and in that way located a sister. She was rather surprised to hear the news because her brother, Joseph Newton Chandler, had died in a tragic car accident at age eight along with their parents, four days before Christmas, in 1945. The dead guy in Eastlake was not the real Joseph Newton Chandler.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/316/1*nTPx1DThpEABxwafqeY-Zw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Whoever he was, he’d carefully assumed the dead boy’s identity over several years — first, by obtaining a copy of Chandler’s birth certificate in Buffalo and then by using that document to get a social security number in Rapid City, in 1978, before moving to Ohio. He got a job as a draftsman for the Lubrizol chemical company and earned a reputation there as a quiet eccentric — he liked to listen to the sound of static while he worked.</p><p>The Eastlake police ran down every lead they had but the case went cold. U.S. Marshal Pete Elliott heard about the mystery in 2014 while looking for some men who had escaped Alcatraz. Perhaps Chandler was actually one of these fugitives, he thought. Certainly, the man was running from something — why else would he take his true name to the grave? Why would he look at himself while he ate a bullet? To a trained investigator, that suggested guilt and shame.</p><p>Elliott located hospital records for the old man. One detailed a trip to the E.R. in 1989, when the man had been treated for lacerations on his penis which he claimed were caused by having sex with a vacuum cleaner. Not long before he committed suicide, the erstwhile Joseph Newton Chandler was diagnosed with cancer and the hospital collected a tissue sample. They still had it. Elliott sent it to the lab. Unfortunately, the DNA was too degraded to be of much use to law enforcement. It seemed like the old man’s true identity would never be found.</p><p>Then, on June 21, 2018, Pete Elliott called a press conference in the jury assembly room at the United States Court House in Cleveland.</p><p>In the news footage, there’s an amused smile on Pete Elliott’s lips as he steps to the podium to address reporters. He has a whopper of a story for them — the true identity of the man known as Joseph Newton Chandler has been discovered. But not by any cop.</p><p>“Now it is my honor to introduce the ladies from California,” he says. “Dr. Colleen Fitzpatrick and Dr. Margaret Press not only put us in the ballpark with Joseph Newton Chandler, they told us the exact seat he was sitting in and then told us who paid for the ticket and the person who paid for that ticket was Mr. Robert Nichols. It’s my honor to introduce the two doctors.”</p><p>Elliott steps away and Dr. Colleen Fitzpatrick comes forward. She can hardly be seen behind the podium. “I want to thank the Marshals for trusting us to work on this case,” she says, her face all smile, her glasses perched on top her short, wavy hair. She doesn’t open with an anecdote or charming story. Colleen dives head-long into a partical explanation of Y-chromosomes and proprietary software used to make sense of all of it and much of this was left out of subsequent newspaper articles but one thing was clear — Colleen and her partner had come up with a new way to catch bad guys.</p><p><a href="https://youtu.be/nHozsKuIHsU">https://youtu.be/nHozsKuIHsU</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*jwi8LMjfcbxdW9jj" /><figcaption>“plasma ball digital wallpaper” by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@joshriemer?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Josh Riemer</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Case Study: Colleen Fitzpatrick</strong></p><p>Colleen Fitzpatrick has a vest with forty-two pockets and before she explains how she changed forensic science forever, she wants to explain what each pocket is used for. We’re at her favorite Persian restaurant — Darya, in Costa Mesa. She’s just come off a plane from Cleveland a day after Elliott’s press conference, and the vest made traveling easier.</p><p>“It’s a SCOTTeVEST,” she says in rapid-fire, staccato sentences. “It was on Shark Tank, the TV show? It will change your life. Look, you can fit an iPad in this pocket and here’s a pocket you can store your credit cards because it blocks RFID signals so nobody can scan for your information, people do that now, and this pocket is for your glasses and here, the piece de resistance…” She opens a pocket to reveal a card-sized piece of cloth with diagrams sketched on it. It takes me a second. “It’s a map to all your pockets so you can know where everything goes and where everything is.” Before the meal arrives she has sold me on the SCOTTeVEST.</p><p>Colleen grew up in Lakeview, that upper-middle class section of New Orleans that drowned in Katrina. She was the oldest of four and her memories of the Big Easy from the 50s and 60s conjures a world that doesn’t exist anymore. A safe, cozy place in a time before Mardi Gras became a bacchanal. Her family had the only pool in the neighborhood and her mother let the Red Cross train kids to swim there. Her father sold silk flowers, wholesale and retail, in a large shop and designed and hung Christmas decorations for businesses in the winter.</p><p>From an early age, Colleen exhibited savant-like behavior. She was proficient in French by the time she was four. She skipped eighth grade. And she was always working on some fantastical project.</p><p>“Colleen would hold little fairs at our house,” recalls her sister, Bebe. “Like county fairs, you know? With booths and games for kids. One year, she made a spook-house in the garage. You sat in a wagon and she pulled you through.”</p><p>The entire family enjoyed thought-provoking games. There were long matches of Clue with the extended family and her grandmother was the reigning champion for many years. Her father taught them to play hearts.</p><p>The Fitzpatrick kids liked to collect Mardi Gras beads in the French Quarter and along Bourbon Street and it was always a challenge to see who could procure the most without being indecent. One year Colleen returned with great piles of beads.</p><p>“She came up with such a great idea,” says Bebe. “She made this giant clown face, with a big open mouth for a target. She stood on the sidewalk and as the parade came by, she challenged everyone to throw their beads in its mouth.”</p><p>Though nobody gave a name to it, it was clear Colleen was different. She thought differently, saw the world differently. She assessed the world in a series of win/loss challenges, looking for any advantage.</p><p>“Have you ever seen The Big Bang theory?” says her brother, Tim. “I tell her she’s our Sheldon.”</p><p>“People expected her to do something fabulous when she left,” says Bebe.</p><p>When it came time for college, though, funds were tight. Much of her father’s income was going to care for her dying grandmother. Colleen had her mind set on the physics program at Rice University but she knew she’d probably end up at Loyola. As the enrollment deadline approached, Colleen focused on her science fair project — she was conducting experiments with a Benham disk. An illusion first discovered by an English toymaker, a Benham disk is a circle with a specific black-and-white pattern of curved lines that, when spun, appears to create bands of color. Different people see different colors and to this day nobody really understands how it works. Young Colleen set out to discover what was going on. She ran a number of tests and constructed variations of the Benham disk to see if it had any impact on the colors produced.</p><p>The day her enrollment paperwork for Loyola was due, a telegram arrived at the Colleen’s house. Her science fair project was one of ten in the country selected for an award by Tomorrow’s Scientists and Engineers, a program sponsored by Humble Oil. The prize was $6,000 toward the college of her choice.</p><p>“My life is a series of events like this,” says Colleen. “I’m a scientist but science can’t describe everything. We cannot describe ourselves scientifically. How do I describe why we are here? I believe in intuition, in being directed down a certain path because of events like this. Is there a master puppeteer directing our path through life? Or do we engineer it all ourselves? I don’t know.”</p><p>In college Colleen studied physics at Rice and earned her PhD from Duke University. Along the way, she became fascinated with an illusion of a different sort — holograms. She taught herself holography, the method of creating a three-dimension image on a two-dimension surface of glass. It was art, it was science. And it required great patience and focus, the glass had to remain completely still during the process. If it wavered even a billionth of a meter the image would not develop. She built a holography lab in her garage and it took her five years to get it right.</p><p>Colleen lectured at Sam Houston State University for a couple years but found she didn’t care for teaching. She left for a job with Rockwell International, a defense contractor out of Seal Beach. There, Colleen worked on the laser radar system used in Ronald Reagan’s Star Wars initiative. Later, at Spectron Laser Systems, she was the principle investigator on the LITE Laser for the space shuttle, an experiment that used lasers to identify chemicals and pollution in the atmosphere. In 1989, she founded her own company, Rice Systems, Inc. She continued her work on the use of lasers for high-resolution measurements and bid on contacts with NASA, the National Science Foundation, and DARPA. She was working on the next spacecraft to Jupiter when funding was redirected to a return voyage to the Moon by the Bush administration, in 2005. As a kind of release, Colleen then began writing a book about her other passion — genealogy. Colleen knew there was a way to apply science to genealogy in a way that had not really been done before. Hers was the very first book on the subject, according to <em>Forensic Magazine</em>.</p><p>Part of genealogy involves the examination of old photographs in order to identify subjects and time periods. At the time, most investigators were focused on the details of the clothing worn by the subjects in the pictures, trying to identify the manufacturer and time period a blouse or pair of pants was produced. But that method was very imprecise — people could keep the same pair of pants for years. So instead, Colleen studied the thickness of the cardboard the photographs were printed on. She researched the history of cardboard and learned how the thickness increased over time. She also researched the aspect ratios of the photos, which reveals the size of the negatives the photographer used, which in turn identifies the particular brand of camera that took the photo. She built a website — ForensicGenealogy.info — and blogged about her findings.</p><p>In 2006, Colleen was contracted by Hebron Investments, an international business that located people whose homes had fallen into escrow due to unpaid taxes in various parts of the world. She worked seventy-five cases, locating people in thirty countries, sometimes using Google translate to communicate. She found them all but two.</p><p>After that, Colleen spent some years identifying holocaust survivors who had been taken from their families during the war. She helped expose fraudulent authors who claimed to be survivors of the Holocaust. And she got really good at identifying people using archival records and DNA. The techniques she was using to find these people would soon be used to locate a serial killer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*qKNM3pL3CRi8NWh1" /><figcaption>“bridge near concrete road” by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@miker87?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Mike Rasching</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Case Study: The Canal Murders</strong></p><p>On the morning of November 9, 1992, a young woman’s nude, headless body was discovered near a bike path along the Arizona Canal in Phoenix. Police were quick to connect this body to the report of a missing woman that had come in the night before — twenty-two-year-old Angela Brosso had gone for a bike ride along the canal path and never returned home. It was Angela’s birthday. Her bike was never located. Her head was found eleven days later in a canal grate.</p><p>Ten months later, seventeen-year-old Melanie Bernas went for a bike ride along the Arizona Canal and never returned. Her body was found in the water the day after she disappeared. She’d been stabbed to death. Her bike was also gone. A serial killer had come to Phoenix.</p><p>And for twenty-two years, the man remained unidentified.</p><p>In 2014, the 25th International Symposium on Human Identification was held at the Biltmore in downtown Phoenix and several local detectives attended the event to learn about new techniques that could be used in forensic identification. Colleen Fitzpatrick was there, speaking about her attempts to identify the extended family of Abraham Lincoln’s mother.</p><p>Colleen offered to meet with the police to explain a new way they might use DNA to find Angela and Melanie’s killer. An officer picked her up and brought her to station. If there was any chance this woman had a new trick up her sleeve, the detectives were interested.</p><p>“These murders brought the city to its knees,” says Detective Dominic Roestenberg. “We hadn’t seen anything that violent. By the time we heard about Colleen, we had exhausted all investigative leads. And what she did… it was miraculous.”</p><p>What Colleen did was find a needle in a factory of haystacks. The state lab had tested the suspect’s DNA and isolated his Y-DNA profile. Y-DNA is very important to genealogists. Every person has 23 pairs of chromosomes, a mix of genetic information from their mother and father. The 23rd pair, however, is either two X-shaped chromosomes for a girl or an X and a Y-shaped chromosome for a boy. The Y-shaped chromosome is passed from father to son — like a surname. If a person’s Y-DNA profile can be sequenced and compared to other profiles in a large enough database, it’s possible to figure out what that person’s last name likely is.</p><p>There are a number of websites with large, public databases of Y-DNA profiles, which are used by genealogists to trace lineage, huge websites like YSearch.org, but also smaller, individual sites that focus on specific surnames — there’s the Smith Project and the Jones Project and the Fitzpatrick Project. In fact, Colleen knew there were over 200,000 publicly available Y-DNA profiles and she had the software to mine them.</p><p>When she compared the canal murderer’s Y-DNA to these publicly available profiles, she got eight matches, all with the same last name.</p><p>“She gave us a last name, Miller,” says Roestenberg. “We did a follow-up and found his name in our files. We found a suspect with that name who we had contacted years earlier.” Detectives had talked to Bryan Patrick Miller twenty years earlier, when he was nineteen. At the time, he denied involvement and was dismissed. Now he became their number one suspect.</p><p>Of course, they needed to confirm that they had the right man. So the detectives surreptitiously collected Miller’s DNA (since the criminal case is still pending, he won’t say how exactly they did this) and sent the sample to the lab so that the genetic material could be compared to the DNA left at the crime scene.</p><p>Days later, as the detectives gathered for a weekly meeting, an analyst from the lab called. Could they come over? Like right now?</p><p>“They literally walked over,” says Roestenberg. “That never happens. The lab employees never just walk over to the police department to personally deliver information. And they came in and said, ‘We got him.’”</p><p>Roestenberg was so shocked all he could say was, “Are you sure?’” To which the lab technician replied the chances they were wrong was one in several quintillion. “Yeah, it’s definitely him. I do believe I shed a tear.”</p><p>It was eight p.m. and Fitzpatrick was at dinner with a friend when the detective called. “He said, ‘You were right, you were right! His name’s Miller!’”</p><p>The next day a SWAT team arrested Miller, now forty-three-years-old, for the murders of Angela Brosso and Melanie Bernas. He goes to trial soon and police say he is a suspect in several additional cold case murders, perhaps dozens.</p><p>“Without Colleen getting involved, I feel strongly that this case would never have been solved,” says Roestenberg. “I don’t know if you ever get closure, but, yes, it was good for the family.”</p><p>Thanks to Colleen, police had been given a new tool to crack cold cases. And there was one dark mystery from the Pacific Northwest that called for Colleen’s particular set of skills.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/300/1*_tNhvjSeOAglweXAIS9QQg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Case Study: Lori Erica Ruff</strong></p><p>The day before Christmas, 2010, the body of Lori Erica Ruff was discovered inside her car. She’d parked in her in-law’s driveway before she shot herself. Near her body were two suicides notes, one addressed to her “wonderful husband,” the other addressed to their young daughter, to be opened on her eighteenth birthday. At the time, Lori was separated from her husband, Blake Ruff, and Blake had moved back into his parent’s place. The suicide notes offered no explanation for the suicide — they were described as the disparate ramblings of a disturbed mind.</p><p>Lori met Blake in a bible-study class in 2003. This was in East Texas, where Blake’s extended family were from. When his parents inquired about Lori’s own family, she gave only vague replies — she was from Arizona, she said, and her parents were dead.</p><p>After Lori’s funeral, Blake’s brother-in-law, Miles Darby, drove out to Lori’s house in nearby Leonard. He searched the place for some clue, something to explain why she killed herself. The house was a mess. Hidden in a closet they found a lock box. Miles pried it open with a screwdriver. Inside was the birth certificate of a girl named Becky Sue Turner, a two-year-old who had died in a house fire in 1971, in Fife, Washington.</p><p>Investigators learned that someone had requested this birth certificate from the records office in Bakersfield, California, in 1988. Later that year, Turner’s birth certificate was used to obtain a state ID in Idaho. Three weeks after that, a woman calling herself Becky Turner appeared before a judge in Dallas and legally changed her name to “Lori Erica Kennedy,” further distancing herself from her true identity, whatever it had been.</p><p>Try as they might, the police could not figure out who Lori really was prior to 1988 or why she took her real name to the grave.</p><p>Colleen read an article about Lori’s mystery in the <em>Seattle Times</em> and immediately reached out to lead investigator Joe Velling, whose job it was to track down the fraudulent use of social security numbers for the SSA. She explained, as best she could, how her team could find Lori’s real family if they had access to her DNA. But nobody had Lori’s DNA. No problem, said Colleen. They had the next best thing — Lori’s daughter.</p><p>Lori had wanted a child more than anything and she had tried repeatedly to have one with Blake but the pregnancies ended in miscarriage. Finally, after fertility treatments, she gave birth to a girl, in 2008. By the time Colleen got involved, Blake had already submited his DNA, and the DNA of his daughter, to 23andMe, a genealogy website. 23andMe has a tool that looks for common markers and removes them. With a couple clicks, Colleen was able to filter out the part of the girl’s genetic code that had come from her father and isolate the part that had come from her mother. A search was then run on the DNA that remained which produced several hits with a man named Michael Cassidy at the top. The website said he was probably the dead woman’s first cousin. Colleen tried to email Cassidy, but he never replied. But soon, another close match was made and Colleen was able to connect this new profile to Michael Cassidy as well. Knowing both of their names, she was able to triangulate the right Michael Cassidy. His family was from Philadelphia.</p><p>Velling flew to Philly and dropped in on a member of the family while she was at work. He tried to explain how Colleen had isolated the DNA of a dead woman from her daughter’s spit and then out of frustration just showed her photographs of Lori. “My God, that’s Kimberly!” she said. Kimberly McLean was her cousin-in-law and she had disappeared in 1986. The day she turned eighteen, she left a note on her pillow asking her mother not to look for her.</p><p>We may never really know what drove Kimberly McLean to change her name not once, but twice. Every family has its secrets. Every person has their own demons. And sometimes people just want a change. But our parents’ DNA will always a part of us.</p><p>A quirky, socially-awkward civilian had become law enforcement’s new secret weapon. Without meaning to, Colleen Fitzpatrick had become a post-modern Sherlock Holmes. And every Holmes needs a Watson.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*mmBqlgPpgHXHdRb2" /><figcaption>“person opening notebook on brown wooden table” by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@diskander?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">David Iskander</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Case Study: Margaret Press</strong></p><p>Before she found genealogy, Margaret Press fell in love with linguistics. This was at Berkeley, in the late sixties — where the culture was evolving day by day. Margaret’s mother was an activist in Pasadena and she’d taken Margaret to political protests as a girl, where she had witnessed the power of words in the signs and chants used to fight racism and McCarthyism. By the time she got to Berkeley, revolution was the word of the day. Not just in the streets but within the study of linguistics as well. A young rockstar of a linguist, Noam Chomsky, was challenging long-held beliefs about the origins of language. Chomsky proposed that the capacity for language was innate in humans — that we are born with an understanding of the structure of language that is not learned, as unlikely a thing as a child who never played chess knowing where each piece goes at the beginning of his first game.</p><p>“Suddenly the planets were going around the sun, not the earth,” says Margaret, recalling the excitement she felt reading Chomsky’s theories for the first time. “This universal structure of language has to be hard-wired inside us. And it is. Like our DNA. If you work backward from any language you will see where it diverges from a common, shared language hundreds of years ago.” Margaret explains how in most IndoEuropean languages, the word for “father” begins with either a “p” or an “f.” Like a mutation on the Y-chromosome, you can figure out which languages are related to each other based on which letter they use today.</p><p>For her dissertation, Margaret compiled a descriptive grammar of Chemehuevi, a nearly-extinct Native American language. After grad school, she found work writing in the language of computers and worked in software development until she retired two years ago. The software work was always meant to supplement her other passion — writing murder mysteries. Margaret is the author of several fiction and nonfiction books based in Salem, Massachusetts. In 1996, she published <em>Counterpoint</em>, which detailed her research into the real-life murder of Martha Brailsford.</p><p>It was another mystery writer, though, who inspired Margaret to test the boundaries of forensic science.</p><p>In 2000, the novelist Sue Grafton learned about a cold case from Santa Barbara as she was casting about for a mystery she could use for the next book in her Alphabet series. In 1969, a young woman’s body was found by hunters in a quarry, her murder never solved, her identity never recovered. There were scant clues — she’d buck teeth and new fillings. She wore bell-bottoms and horseshoe earrings. Grafton became enamored of the case and used it for the basic plot of <em>Q is for Quarry</em>.</p><p>In 2001, Grafton paid to have the woman’s body exhumed. DNA was collected. A facial-reconstruction was done. But none of the leads panned out.</p><p>Margaret read about the case and wondered if she might be able to help. She knew that adoptees in the United States were having luck tracking down their parents by having their DNA sequenced by companies such as Ancestry and 23andMe. Why couldn’t that same technology be used to identify the Santa Barbara Jane Doe? So she contacted the Sheriff’s Office. “They wouldn’t return my calls,” she says. “They thought I was a crank, like the psychics who call and say they know who the murderer is. A genealogist calls and says I can solve your case? Okay, right.”</p><p>What she needed was credibility. Colleen had street cred. She was already working with law enforcement on similar cases. So Margaret reached out to Colleen on Facebook and laid out her plan — she wanted to get the dead woman’s genetic profile from the detectives in Santa Barbara and upload it into the 23andMe database. It would surely kick up a relative match, a second cousin in Boise or something.</p><p>But Colleen and others said such a thing would be impossible. Ancestry and 23andMe do not allow users to upload their own genetic profiles. They test the samples sent in by subscribers themselves and then use proprietary software to find specific markers known as single nucleotide polymorphisms, which you’ll see written as “SNPs”, commonly called “snips.” These markers are then compared to other profiles in their database. They brainstormed ideas — perhaps they could attend a symposium where executives from the genetic companies would be present and convince them that they should allow these uploads.</p><p>And then a hobbyist figured out a workaround. It was a member of their Facebook genealogy group — he’d submitted a DNA sample of his dead father (gathered from a tissue sample collected during a hospital stay) and had its entire genome sequenced — not just the Y-DNA that many genealogists relied on to trace lineage, but also the DNA from the other twenty-two chromosome pairs inherited from both parents — what’s called autosomal DNA. And while the private ancestry companies don’t allow uploads, they do allow users to download a text file that contains coded information about specific markers that were identified in their DNA. That text file can then be uploaded to a public repository of autosomal DNA on the web, called GEDmatch. The GEDmatch software then looks for matches between all their user’s data sets. Using a program to isolate these same snips from the whole genome data a file could be created and uploaded. It worked! The man succeeded in created a 23andMe file for his father on his own. GEDmatch located the man’s relatives and Colleen and Margaret found their solution. The same strategy could be used to identify any John or Jane Doe.</p><p>“It was the right moment, the perfect storm,” says Margaret. “The public databases were getting bigger, and the genetic testing was getting cheaper. Suddenly, entire-genome testing was affordable.” Margaret still holds out hope that one day the private companies will see the benefit of working with them, too. “We’d have access to another 15 million profiles if Ancestry and 23andMe allowed clients to upload data. We could solve these cases lickety split.”</p><p>Grafton died last December. The Santa Barbara Jane Doe has yet to be identified. But Margaret hopes for an answer soon. “I would have loved to tell her we’re going to do this case.”</p><p>From that moment on, Colleen and Margaret have spoken nearly every day. Colleen contacts law enforcement and Margaret manages a volunteer army of genealogists that gather to discuss leads in their private Facebook group.</p><p>“She’s the nuts and bolts,” says Colleen. “I’m more of the marketing end. I’m more the one with the contacts, who knows the agencies, knows how to speak to them. Our personalities are very compatible.”</p><p>Together, Colleen and Margaret founded the DNA Doe Project, a nonprofit organization that uses autosomal DNA to identify John and Jane Does. The project also helps raise funds for agencies that want to use their services but who can’t afford it. What they needed now was proof of concept.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/151/1*ymwqlnZKZwWnDtpf1Nz7aQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Case Study: Lyle Stevik</strong></p><p>This mystery began on September 14, 2001, three days after the towers came down. A young man checked into the Quinault Inn, a motel in Amanda Park, Washington, under the name “Lyle Stevik.” He had no luggage. No I.D. Only the clothes on his back, some cash, and a toothbrush. Three days later, he was found hanging from a belt tied around a clothes rod in the closet of his room. His name was fictitious, a character from a Joyce Carol Oates’ novel, and the address he gave to the clerk led to a hotel in Idaho.</p><p>Armchair sleuths wondered if the man was part of the terror cell that had orchestrated the September 11 attacks — did he kill himself before the feds could catch him?</p><p>Police collected his DNA, sent it to the lab, and then entered his profile into the F.B.I.’s Combined DNA Index System — known as CODIS — the government’s private database of felon DNA. No match. But that only meant he’d never been to prison.</p><p>Colleen read about the case and reached out to the local coroner, Lane Youmans. It was the perfect mystery for the DNA Doe Project to solve. Youmans was game but there was a problem — the county didn’t have the money for testing. So Colleen and Margaret organized their first “DoeFundMe” campaign to raise funds for a new, autosomal DNA test. Redditors and members of their Facebook group opened their wallets. They raised the $1,500 needed for the testing within twelve hours.</p><p>Youmans sent Lyle’s DNA to the lab, where it was sequenced and then converted to electronic data and saved on a hard drive. Colleen then had a bioinformatics expert extract specific snips from this data that are also used by GEDMatch. The markers from Lyle’s profile were then compared to the markers from other people’s profiles on the website (the software does this — nobody can ever see or directly access someone else’s DNA profile). Markers found in Lyle’s DNA matched to probable distant cousins in Northern New Mexico and the greater Four-Corners area. But it was hard to narrow it down from there. The problem was endogamy.</p><p>Endogamy occurs in isolated community groups — most notably Appalachia, where cousins intermarry and people are sometimes related to each other in five different ways. In the Lyle Stevik case, the results brought Colleen and Margaret to a region of the United States that originally settled by Spanish conquistadors who took Native Americans as wives. Their descendants had been isolated from the greater world and there had been a lot of intermarriage. The team felt they were close but it was going to be difficult to hone in on the man’s identity because of the intertwined branches of his family tree.</p><p>GEDmatch has lots of nifty tools. One of them is a program called “Are my parents related?” Colleen clicked on it, expecting to find that Lyle’s parents were related like everyone around them, but they were not. Colleen knew that this must mean one of Lyle’s parents were not from the same region. Another researcher in their group noticed a particular snip on Lyle’s Y-chromosome that matched to a man from south America — which suggested his father likely came from there, too. And that meant his mother must be the parent who was native to the Four Corners area.</p><p>The team spent hundreds of hours building out family trees for the matches. One lucky volunteer contacted a family member from this region to help them make better sense of the family tree. That family member mentioned that she had heard that a young man, distantly related to her, had gone missing some years ago. They had stumbled onto their answer sooner than expected.</p><p>“These cases are like trying to figure out a giant Sudoku puzzle,” says Margaret. “And this solution fit the puzzle.”</p><p>Case closed. Sure. But the state of Washington does not release the names of suicides. And the family of the deceased did not come forward, publicly.</p><p>“In many cultures there’s shame associated with suicide,” Margaret explains. “My brother committed suicide. It was never in the papers. The publicity would have added to the pain. I can think of no reason this family would want to make it public.”</p><p>That made some Redditors who had donated money very angry. “They’re saying, ‘We have a right to this knowledge. We’re entitled to know who he is,’” says Margaret.</p><p>It was an unexpected reaction but Colleen and Margaret were not discouraged. Lyle’s case and the others they were working on proved that the DNA Doe Project worked. “This was unprecedented,” says Colleen. But there was a growing concern that others in the genealogical community would view what they were doing as an invasion of privacy. Each time they solved a new case, it brought more attention. Eventually, GEDMatch would have to decide what was permissible. And what would happen to their efforts to identify their John and Jane Does if the database they relied on suddenly changed its terms of service? What if it simply shut down? “If GEDmatch rolled up the sidewalk, we were toast.”</p><p>Margaret sighs. “And then the Golden State Killer happened.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*bxfwRJgfNOwKn_hkqZUWFw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Case Study: The Baby-Dick Killer</strong></p><p>It seems callous to reduce the evil of this man to a paragraph. But there’s simply too much to give every last horror its due.</p><p>His crimes began with burglaries (about a hundred), which advanced to rapes (at least fifty), and then to murder (at least thirteen). His killing fields were the suburbs of Sacramento, Modesto, Visalia. The serial killer’s reign lasted from 1974 to 1986, and then he went silent. Some suspected he had died. The police have given him many names over the years — The East Area Rapist, the Original Night Stalker, the Golden State Killer. Redditors preferred another moniker, though. Online, he was known as the Baby-Dick Killer, so named because his victims claimed their attacker had a micro-penis. DNA linked all of these crimes together but the perpetrator remained unknown — police found no match in CODIS.</p><p>Paul Holes, a retired investigator for the Contra Costa DA’s officer, consulted with his own forensic genealogist, a woman named Barbara Rae-Venter, a retired intellectual property attorney. They compared the Golden State Killer’s DNA with the profiles on GEDmatch, and identified possible relatives. From there they narrowed the list down to a couple possible candidates, which pointed them to Joseph DeAngelo, a former police officer from Citrus Heights.</p><p>80-year-old Curtis Rogers was in bed the morning of April 25, reading the news on his computer as is his routine. That’s when he saw the breaking news — the Golden State Killer was caught — and the police had used his website to do it.</p><p>“I could feel my hair turn gray,” says Rogers. In another life he worked in international business, servicing clients like Quaker Oats and Mennen. He’s retired, now. But not less busy. GEDmatch was his idea. But he’d never envisioned where it would lead him. “I think I sat there and just tried to absorb the meaning of what was happening. I looked outside. There were antennas. There were reporters at my door.”</p><p>Rogers was faced with a dilemma — what was to be done about GEDmatch, what responsibility did he have? “I was very concerned,” he says. “Were we violating the privacy of our users, allowing these forensic genealogists to compare a suspect’s DNA to their profile? At the same time, here was this killer that made Jack the Ripper look like a choir boy. I did a lot of thinking. The ethics are very bothersome.”</p><p>Rogers is not a crime fighter by choice. He was a member of the Rogers surname project, and claims to be the third cousin, three times removed, of Winston Churchill. Rogers had become frustrated by having to make so many calls to members of other surname projects in order to trace back his family tree. So out of necessity came a simple idea — what if he were to build a website that could serve as a central clearinghouse for autosomal DNA data?</p><p>It began in 2010 and he named it GEDmatch, after GEDCOM (Genealogical Data Communication), a data format used for comparing DNA profiles that was developed by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. Genealogy is a big part of the Mormon faith because of their belief in baptism-by-proxy. If they can specifically identify a person who died, no matter how long ago it happened, they can be saved if a member of the church is baptized in their place. Their mission is to save us all.</p><p>GEDmatch was built so genealogists could analyze their DNA, not to catch criminals. But in the end, the ends justified the means. “The dam was broken with the Golden State Killer,” says Rogers. “There’s no going back. What we need to do is educate our users.”</p><p>GEDmatch will remain up and open, he says, and can be used to track serial killers and rapists. It’s a new era for DNA.</p><p>“The police were used to things that were easy,” says Rogers. “Black and white. Fingerprints are either a match or not. DNA matched a suspect or it didn’t. Now, DNA is no longer black and white, no longer yes or no. It’s more complicated now. The police have to use people like Colleen. Experts at finding people. Law enforcement can’t do it alone right now because they simply don’t know how but maybe in the future they’ll train their own experts.”</p><p>Currently, there is nothing regulating this new field of investigation and genealogists are very concerned that Congress will tackle the issue.</p><p>For now anyway, the new frontier of forensic genealogy is wide open. Colleen has begun accepting criminal cases through her private company, Identifinders International. The DNA Doe project remains dedicated to giving names to John and Jane Does.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*TvXjgkWMN-G5inFs" /><figcaption>“closeup photo of incandescent bulb” by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@martinadams?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Martin Adams</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>Case Study: Joseph Newton Chandler, Revisited</strong></p><p>In retrospect, it was long, twisted chain of events that brought the Joseph Newton Chandler case to a close. If Colleen had not won that science fair, if a retired businessman had not had an idea to create an open database of DNA profiles, if the case had not landed on U.S. Marshall’s Pete Elliott’s desk… it’s hard to look back and not see some cosmic design to it all.</p><p>Elliott heard about Colleen after she solved the Lori Erica Ruff case and asked if she could help him. The lab had already isolated the man’s Y-DNA profile. In that profile were segments of DNA where the nucleotides (the A-G-T-C bases you learned about in grade school) repeated. Everyone’s DNA has these small, repeating bits of genetic code, in different places — what’s called a “short tandem repeat,” or STR. Colleen compared the STR profile generated on the case to hundreds of thousands of Y-DNA profiles stored online at places like YSearch.org. Out of all of those available profiles, only one matched all seventeen markers. That person’s last name was Nicholas.</p><p>This line of Nicholases descended from a colonial immigrant, George Nicholas. George’s son was the first treasurer of the colony of Virginia. It was a prominent family with old ties going back centuries. There were literally thousands of descendants.</p><p>So Elliott, at Colleen and Margaret’s request, resubmitted the DNA to the lab for full genome sequencing. When the data came back, Colleen uploaded the file to GEDmatch, where the new information was compared to the other autosomal DNA files in its database. This identified hundreds of distant relatives.</p><p>“We were working with fumes here,” says Colleen. So they requested that the lab test the DNA extract one more time — a risky gamble, since this would destroy the remaining DNA the lab had for this man. Once it was gone, there could be no more tests. The lab came back with a slightly different data set this time. That’s when Margaret suggested they combined two files. “I explain it like having two photographs where the resolution is not great and then overlaying them to fill in the face in the picture,” says Margaret. This time GEDmatch identified several relatives they’d never seen before. And one new match led them to a woman named Schreiber who had four sons with a man whose last name was Nichols.</p><p>Three of the boys had a date of death. The fourth — Robert Ivan Nichols — did not. The DNA Doe volunteers scoured social media for more information about this family. They searched public records and phone numbers. And one very smart sleuth noticed an odd coincidence — she’d found that the Nichols family home was 1823 Center Street in New Albany, Indiana — when Chandler had filled out his rental agreement, he’d listed 1823 Center Street, Columbus as an address.</p><p>“It wasn’t a coincidence,” says Elliott. “Liars always lie close to home.”</p><p>Soon, Elliott stood on the doorstep of man named Phil Nichols, who he now believed was the mystery man’s son. “I drove down with another Marshal and knocked on his door. When he opened the door, it was like Joseph Newton Chandler was standing there. They looked so much alike. I knew we had our guy.”</p><p>Of course, that was only half the mystery. Elliott knows the man’s real name, now, but he still doesn’t know what Nichols was running from. What he’s been able to gather from family stories and scarce public records is that Nichols served on the USS Aaron Ward, which was bombed by the Japanese during World War II. He suffered wounds in battle and burned his uniform when he returned home. In 1965, before he became Joseph Newton Chandler, Nichols lived in Napa County, California — a time and location familiar to those who have hunted the Zodiac Killer. Authorities are searching for a connection but Colleen believes the answer will be mundane and personal, like Lori Erica Ruff.</p><p>“I think it’s more likely we’re dealing with a man who suffered from PTSD from the war, which caused paranoia,” she says.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/319/1*0Fzv5rXjU-mV4wUwxqRgiw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Final Case Study: The Somerton Man</strong></p><p>Mountain climbers have their Everest. Arm chair sleuths have the Somerton Man.</p><p>It begins with a body found on Somerton beach, just south of Adelaide, Australia, in 1948. There was no discernable cause of death and to this day investigators are unsure if the man was murdered or if he committed suicide, or if he died of natural causes. He had no I.D. The tags had been cut off his clothes. There was comb in his pocket from America and some Juicy Fruit gum. Oh, and hidden in a fob pocket was a piece of paper torn out of a book, a single line of text, “Tamam Shud” — Persian for “It is ended.” The very book from which the page was ripped — a collection of poetry called <em>The Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam </em>— was eventually located. Someone had tossed it into the back seat of a parked car and the owner of the vehicle came forward after hearing the details of the case in the news. Inside the book were two additional clues — a message written in code and the phone number of a local nurse. The nurse claimed to know nothing. She said she didn’t recognize the dead man on the beach. To this day, his identity remains unknown.</p><p>And here we have another simple twist of fate — a biomedical engineering professor from Adelaide named Derek Abbott, found himself sitting in a laundromat, in 1995. Bored, he flipped through a stack of old magazines. One had a write-up on Australia’s most notorious unsolved mysteries. He was transfixed by the tale of the Somerton Man. He never forgot it and when a newspaper published the secret code, in 2007, he thought it would be a fun puzzle to share with his students. They used statistical analysis in an attempt to identify the cypher. But the solution proved elusive.</p><p>“When you have a good math problem, it fights back at you,” he says. “If we’ve got ourselves a good problem, it isn’t a slam dunk. You need tenacity to see the problem through. This is no different.”</p><p>Abbott came to believe the strange message was not a substitution code at all. Perhaps each letter represents an entire word, combining to make a sentence that had special meaning to two people or maybe it represents a passage or poem from another book. But the cypher wasn’t the only way to identify the Somerton Man. What he really needed was DNA.</p><p>Abbott pushed the authorities to have the body exhumed, to no avail. Luckily, the local police museum had kept a plaster cast of the man’s upper body and some of his hairs had stuck to the plaster. Abbott obtained a hair sample from the museum and sent it to a lab, which was able to recover the full mitochondrial DNA profile of the mystery man. It was just enough to identify him as being of European descent, which they already knew from pictures of his body.</p><p>Abbott had another thought — what if the Somerton Man really did know that nurse, the one whose number appeared in the book with the secret code? Through his contacts with the police, Abbott discovered her real name, which had never been published — Jo Thomson. He tracked her down only to discover she’d died a couple years before. However, she left behind a son, born around the time the Somerton Man was found, a child who had a peculiar dental deformity — he had no lateral incisors — which made it look like his pointy teeth were closer to the front, giving him a vampire-like smile. The Somerton Man had this same, rare deformity. There was a good chance Thomson’s child was the dead man’s illegitimate son.</p><p>When Abbott sought out the son, he learned the man had died just a few months prior and his body cremated.</p><p>“But we do have somebody else,” he says with a smile. “We have my wife’s DNA.”</p><p>See, when Abbott went searching for Thomson’s son, he’d met the man’s daughter. They fell in love. They got married. They now have three kids of their own — children who may be the great-grandchildren of the man Abbott has been trying to identity for over twenty years.</p><p>Abbott met Colleen when she came to Adelaide on a book tour. They’ve been working the case together ever since. Early results have led them to Virginia, where Abbott believes the Somerton Man’s relatives may live to this day.</p><p>However, Colleen cautions not to be too excited for the answer. She doesn’t believe he was a spy or anything so cool. “I think he’s going to be just some guy who died on the beach.”</p><p>Now that police know what a forensic genealogist can do, Colleen’s phone rings incessantly. She still does most of her work sitting at a small table in the kitchen of the same townhouse she’s lived in for decades. “I’m getting calls and emails every day. I’m working on a dozen cases.”</p><p>Her house is not large, a couple rooms and bedrooms upstairs. She sublets one of her rooms to a friend. For her dream job to survive, the DNA Doe Project will need funding.</p><p>Her siblings are not so worried, though. They remember the girl from Lakeview who found a way to get all the beads she ever needed. “She loves a challenge,” says her sister, Bebe. “Maybe it’s in her DNA.”</p><p>Colleen’s brother, Tim, is a part-time deputy back home, runs search and rescue boats when he’s not designing Christmas decorations for fancy businesses in four states. “I’m really proud of her,” he says. “It puts a smile on her face which she hasn’t had in a long time. I’m enjoying watching her. It’s tremendous.”</p><p>No matter what happens, Colleen and Margaret have each other’s back. “When you work these cases, you feel that insipient gloom and it can affect you,” says Margaret. “We rely on each other and our team and we focus on the excitement of being the ones to solve a case. And we are. We’re solving them doe by doe by doe. It’s a jungle of bad out there but we’re chopping through it.”</p><p>There’s a picture of the Dalai Lama hanging on Colleen’s wall. It’s signed. “I don’t know what the reason is I find myself here, now,” she muses, thinking on the events that stretch back to New Orleans and a simpler time. “Was it to bring closure to these cases? It could be. I might have fulfilled my purpose ten years ago. How do I know? You just gotta do what you can.”</p><p><a href="http://jamesrenner.com/">James Renner is the author of True Crime Addict. Recently, he filmed a virtual reality docu-series about the Delphi Murders.</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9840660087f6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Gordie and Skoot Kill a Bear]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesrenner.medium.com/gordie-and-skoot-kill-a-bear-c6561729b731?source=rss-8221d6e709bf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c6561729b731</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[iraq]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[renner]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[horror]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James Renner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 May 2017 14:05:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-01T14:05:04.406Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8zIbv5axfZQdAygs3Ln4KQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Author’s note: The following story serves as a short bridge between my 2015 novel, <em>The Great Forgetting</em>, and an upcoming tale of Gothic horror.</p><h3>1</h3><p>The TouchTunes machine was playing Zeppelin when Skoot walked into the Driftwood looking for Gordie. The bar hadn’t changed but Skoot had. The bar was still two rooms of dusty chestnut and pine, pool table in back, a couple pleather booths beside a window lousy with neon beer totems. The girl with the scar behind the counter. Yes, the bar was the same. But Skoot was different.</p><p>His face was thinner. His eyes, still that dreamy deep blue, peered out now from dark craters. That blond straw hair the townie girls once loved had receded on the low tide of age. Thirty-one, but he wore his life… <em>older</em>.</p><p>Skoot took a seat on a thin-cushioned creaky stool. Behind him an older couple sipped on bottles of Dortmunder and didn’t speak to each other. The bartender placed a tall Yuengling Black &amp; Tan on a cardboard coaster in front of him. He sipped it and then licked the suds off his stubble.</p><p>“Ain’t you livin’ down Marietta?” The bartender asked him. An old scar snaked under her left eye in a way that was strangely beautiful.</p><p>Skoot nodded.</p><p>“Whya come all the way back to Franklin Mills? You slummin’?”</p><p>Skoot laughed. “Can’t slum if you are the slum, Shelly. I came back for Gordie.”</p><p>“Gordie?”</p><p>“Yeah. Gordie. Figured he might be here.”</p><p>“Gordie don’t drink no more.”</p><p>Skoot sighed. “Gordie drinks. Gordie can’t stop drinkin.”</p><p>“Well he’s still over by the BFI. Seen him out there slappin sheet on his roof last week.”</p><p>“BFI?”</p><p>“The dump. Over Deerfield?”</p><p>“Right.”</p><p>“Whachu want with Gordie?”</p><p>Skoot looked back at the old couple just to see if they were watching. They were not. He reached into the pocket of his ruddy brown leather jacket and pulled out a creased photograph which he handed to the bartender. She unfolded it and then stared for a moment, her eyebrows creasing together.</p><p>“It’s a bear,” said Shelly.</p><p>“Lookit the way it’s tilting its head.”</p><p>She saw it then and laughed.</p><p>“Damn this bear looks just like Gordie. That’s exactly the way he tilts his head when he’s lookin’ cross the room at you. Like he’s saying something at you but you can’t hear him, something only you and him know.”</p><p>Skoot took the picture back and placed it in his jacket pocket again.</p><p>“You come all the way up to Franklin Mills to show Gordie a picture of a bear that looks like him?”</p><p>“No, Shell. I didn’t come all the way up to Franklin Mills just to show Gordie a picture of a bear that looks like him. I came all the way up to Franklin Mills to show Gordie a picture of the bear that stole his goddamn soul.”</p><h3>2</h3><p>The trailer listed.</p><p>It was perched on stacks of cement block but the lee side had sunk into the ground over the course of some years, casting it down on that end. It was one of those sheet-shingled box trailers, not even a double-wide, yellow once but bleached white now. He was using blankets for curtains. Old kids blankets he got from who knows where because he didn’t have no kids anyway. Skoot climbed the rusted wrought-iron steps and knocked on the plywood door.</p><p>“Gordie?”</p><p>No one answered, and after a time Skoot nudged the door with his fist and found that it was not locked. He pushed it open and stepped inside.</p><p>Living room was dark but not unclean. A space heater clicked in the corner and gave everything a kind of red sickly color. Old couch with a large knitted blanket. Coffee table where some McDonalds’ and a mostly-empty bottle of Wild Turkey sat. No TV. Hot in here even though it was not so cool outside.</p><p>“Gordie? It’s Skoot.”</p><p>“Humma nah!” came a voice somewhere down the dark hall.</p><p>“That’s ooh-rah, staff sergeant.”</p><p>From the darkness came the sounds of much clatter, like an animal rolling off a counter into a box of tools. Gordie cleared his throat and spit — into a wastbasket or sink, hopefully. The trailer shifted a bit as he walked out to meet his visitor.</p><p>When he appeared from the shadows of the hallway, Skoot recoiled a little even though he had prepared himself for this moment all the way up from Marietta. They’d traded letters, emails, Facebook posts. But the last time he’d seen Gordie was on the tarmac beneath the C-9 after they landed at Camp Pendleton. He remembered a limber Marine, twenty-two and a hundred fifty pounds, gaunt from the war, those intense brown eyes. That was eight years ago.</p><p>Gordie had a gut. A big pregnant-man gut. It peeked out from under a Lords of Acid tee as if it were ashamed to introduce itself. His dark hair was too long and had grayed at his temples, except for in that one place where he’d gotten the scar above his right ear, where it was just a strip of hairless skin the shape and size of an unsharpened pencil. The man’s face was bloated. Even from where he stood, and in the red-dark of the trailer, Skoot could see a burst capillary on the bridge of Gordie’s nose. His jeans were caked with whitewash paint. But he didn’t smell bad. Gordie always smelled like just a little Old Spice.</p><p>“Take it all in, Skoot,” he said. “Tell me I’m still sexy.”</p><p>Skoot stepped to Gordie and pulled him in. He hugged him tightly even though Gordie’s arms just kind of dangled there. Before he pulled away, he kissed Gordie on his stubbly cheek and that made the man laugh. But the laughter was ironic and didn’t mean much.</p><p>“You stopped answerin’ my letters,” said Skoot.</p><p>“Writing’s a chore.”</p><p>“Knew you was something bad. But man.”</p><p>“Yeah.”</p><p>“When’s the last time you showered?”</p><p>“Saturday.”</p><p>“Today is Saturday.”</p><p>“So a week, then. You come all the way up here to tell me to wash my hair?”</p><p>Skoot pulled the photograph from his jacket and handed it to his friend.</p><h3>3</h3><p>While Gordie soaked in a steaming tub and smoked a thin joint made of remainders, Skoot sat on the shitter and told him all about the bear and the Indian named Chief Running Feather. Gordie listened, his head tilted back against the lip of the tub so he could blow the blue smoke out a screenless window that gave the room a modicum of circulation.</p><p>Skoot had been forced into some action when his old lady left him in 2007, after a particular nasty fight when both of them said some things there was no coming back from. Also, he hit her. Just once, but it was enough. She left him, took William and the cat. Let him keep the arthritic Weiner dog and the truck. The hell of it was, before Iraq, the two of them had been one of those overly-happy couples, the kind you see sitting on the same side of the booth at Applebees or Olive Garden sometimes. To end like that, in anger, in rage, well, it busted their marriage and broke his heart and he came to the conclusion that either he should kill himself or figure out what was making him so mad.</p><p>First thing he did was drive out to the trestle off Highway 7 in Mingo Junction. He stopped at the Circle K along the way, bought a bottle of Thunderbird and a fifth of Jack. Finished the bird and was halfway through the whiskey, daring himself to fall asleep on the tracks over the bridge where even if the conductor seen him he wouldn’t be able to stop in time, before he finally passed out. He awoke in the middle of the tracks the next afternoon and took it for a miracle. For five days anyway. Then he learned that the Norfolk and Southern that used to come by there on its way to Marietta had been decommissioned while he was away at war. By the time he realized his mistake he’d already checked into the VA and was taking a first step toward recovery.</p><p>Shell shock. PTSD they called it now. Lot of meds at the beginning and that didn’t help much. Sure, the anger was gone. But so was everything else. Worst of all, his pecker quit working. “Got so bad I had to apologize to the strippers and so I quit them, too,” Skoot explained. And then one day in group an old timer from Korea come back from vacation with a big smile, and a big smile in PTSD group is a big fucking thing. Nobody smiles at those things. It’s how you know you belong. Anyway this gray beard come back with this smile and told everyone about this place called Whispering Pines and this man called Chief Running Feather and four weeks later Skoot found himself in a sweat lodge in the middle of Fuck Nowhere, Pennsylvania.</p><p>“Somewhere over by the Susquehanna,” said Skoot, when Gordie lifted an eyebrow. “They bused us in from Columbus. Dropped us off on the side of a mountain. You have to trek in. Twenty miles to the main cabin with all your gear on your back. Like that fucking hump we did back in S.O.I. It was rough on some of them. Specially the older ones.”</p><p>Chief Running Feather was waiting for them when they arrived. It was impossible to tell how old he was. Something about Indians, Skoot had never been able to really tell how old they were. They were either young or really old. And this one was older than most, but not so old he stooped when he walked. Wrinkly skin. Gray shoulder-length hair. He wore a navy-blue sweatsuit and converse all stars. Chief Running Feather was part Cherokee, part Canadian Cree, he told them. And he didn’t believe in Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.</p><p>What Chief Running Feather believed in were the stories passed down to him by his father and his father’s father on the res. And here, Skoot took on the voice of Chief Running Feather the best he could, closing his left eye partially, as if the man he was imitating had some kind of simple palsy.</p><p>“ ‘Our soul is a song in our body,’ he said. ‘And it yearns for harmony,’ or something like that. ‘Sometimes a young warrior returned from battle missing his song. The song that makes him who he is. His <em>soul</em>. He has witnessed something so terrible that, in his anguish, his soul fled his body to seek harmony elsewhere.’</p><p>“That’s what happened to <em>you</em>, Gordie. That’s what happened to us.”</p><p>Chief Running Feather told them they had to return to the place their soul escaped from their bodies because there they would find their soul searching for them.</p><p>Skoot spent five days in the Pennsylvania mountains with Chief Running Feather and the other men from the Brecksville V.A. In the mornings they did yoga in a field of clover overlooking the river valley. They ate Spartan lunches and after a short time forgot they were hungry anymore. They smoked a lot. Tobacco. Refer. Every night they stripped down naked and climbed through a tiny hole in a burlap teepee and sat around glowing coals which were doused off and on with water so that the steam would fill up the empty spaces between their bodies. When they climbed out, they were covered in soot. “Soot in my bellybutton, my eyes, my asshole, man,” said Skoot. They washed in a gravity shower beside the sweat lodge and then returned to the main cabin for more smokes and barbeque.</p><p>“And then I went back, man.”</p><p>“Back where?” Gordie asked, stepping out of the bath and toweling his balls dry.</p><p>“Where do you think? Nasiriyah.”</p><p>“Wait. Wait, what?”</p><p>“I went back to An Nasiriyah. Dhi Qar. I found my soul right where I left it. In that damned bathroom at the Tallil airport.”</p><h3>4</h3><p>He never told Shayna, his old lady, exactly what had gone down in that tiny airport bathroom that first week of Operation Iraqi Freedom, but she’d pieced together enough to know never to ask him about it. All Skoot knew after he returned home was that he felt numb. Like nothing made him happy or sad anymore, even his kid. He’s a for-instance: Before the war he’d been a neat-freak — he kept his clothes pressed and he detailed his Mustang every Sunday afternoon. But now, he didn’t even notice the garbage that piled up in the back of his car until Shayna yelled at him for it one day after she found half a candy bar ground into the carpeting. Before the war he’d been pretty laid back to tell the truth. Took a lot to get his goat. But after he came home the littlest thing could set him off. Once he’d screamed at Shayna for leaving her hair clip on the sink. His emotions, when they finally got going, were a cascading river. Unstoppable. When he was twelve his old man had taken him hiking up in the White Mountains of New Hampshire right before mud season. He remembered watching the ice break up on the Ammonoosuc, how all the ice that had stacked up during the long winter months just suddenly broke apart and a wall of water plowed down the valley toward the old mills on the Connecticut. It was like that. And eventually they figured out it was because of what he’d seen in the bathroom at Tallil Air Base.</p><p>“You can’t go back,” she told him, and this was after she’d already left so it was nice that she’d met him at McDonald’s and listened to him talk while William played on the jungle gym. “You can’t really think that’s a good idea.”</p><p>“I’m out of other ideas,” was all Skoot said in his defense.</p><p>There was problem, though. A flight to Basra would set him back. Skoot only collected $2500 a month on VA disability. He’d tried to supplement by cooking pizza at Pittera’s in Steubenville under the table but one day some old coot’s F-100 backfired in the parking lot and he just froze while a large pepperoni burned to death in the oven. Sometimes his father, who was a contractor across the Ohio, down Claysville, paid him to cart block down to basements but Skoot didn’t like to do that either. When he got up a sweat he started to smell like he’d smelled in the damned desert under his flak jacket and then he didn’t feel like working anymore that day.</p><p>Smells were the worst trigger.</p><p>There was the sweat. But also certain meats. Like spiced meat, the kind you might smell coming out of the kitchen at Mariachi Loco’s or some cheap Mexican restaurant by the mall. That smell reminded him of a certain open-air grill outside An Nasiriyah where a man named Hakim and his two sons sold Kubba’t Mosul, a minced-meat pastry sandwich, for 250 dinar — what amounted to about twenty-five cents, American. And forget public restrooms. Skoot hated public restrooms. All that ammonia and bleach sent his mind right back to that bathroom at Tallil Air Base.</p><p>In the end it was Shayna’s father who fronted the money for the trip. An old soldier turned trucker who’d done a tour in ‘Nam and probably understood better than anyone the future Skoot was facing if he didn’t settle his fears. He sent the check in an envelope to his apartment. No note. Just the check and in the memo line where most people wrote stuff like “groceries,” the old man had written: “one soul.”</p><h3>5</h3><p>Four hours later after leaving Gordie’s trailer, Skoot parked his tan Regal in a turn-off gravel lot somewhere east of Sunbury. He usually left it unlocked. Who’d steal a Regal, anyway? Especially one that smelled of snus and had a bumper sticker that read, Semper Fi?</p><p>“How far?” asked Gordie.</p><p>“Twenty miles,” said Skoot.</p><p>“Well, goddamn it, let’s go if we’re going.”</p><p>They got out and put their canvass backpacks on over their leather jackets. Skoot had thought ahead and had bought two liters of water for both of them and some provisions for the trek up the mountain — granola, jerky, nuts, a couple old MRE’s even. Five minutes and they were on the hard-packed clay-and-pebble trail that wound through oak and alders that were only just beginning to turn color.</p><p>Gordie grunted as he walked. He was out of shape. All you had to do was look at the way his gut hung over his jeans to know he probably hadn’t run in six years. Had certainly given up the hard weights. “Sometimes,” said Gordie, “sometimes I think about the stuff they gave us, that Doxycycline, you know? For the malaria and shit.”</p><p>“And what?”</p><p>“And well whether it had anything to do with how we turned out.”</p><p>“It’s not the Doxy.”</p><p>“It was the Doxy that wrecked my intestines. It’s so good at killin’ stuff it killed all the good bacteria in my guts. Had to eat so much yogurt. Goddamn I hate yogurt. Can’t even look at the stuff now. And that was the Doxy.”</p><p>“Wasn’t the medicine they gave us that made us crazy,” said Skoot. “You know what it was that made us crazy.”</p><p>“Yeah. I guess I do.”</p><p>“Not just us, neither. Everyone who was there in that bathroom. All that made it back, anyway.”</p><p>“Even Robinstein?”</p><p>“Are you kidding?”</p><p>“What?”</p><p>“Robinstein ran his old lady over with his Renault. She lived but she lost a leg over it. He’s in Grafton, now. Five to ten.”</p><p>“Shit.”</p><p>A young couple in running gear jogged past going the other way and gave the two Marines a wide berth. Most people tended to give them extra room without being aware they were doing it. Ever since they come home it was like they gave off a bad vibe. As if it was ten thousand years ago and they had brought down a Mammoth and come back to camp and everyone could smell the monster’s blood on them.</p><p>They stopped at a feeder creek to have a little supper. This was just after five and the sun still had a ways to go before it had to consider the tops of the rolling mountains. The sound of the water was nice and the bologna and cheese sandwiches Skoot had prepared for them was the first real meal Gordie had eaten in several days. Soon he was feeling so good he allowed himself a smile, the first in a long long time.</p><h3>6</h3><p>Skoot came west to An Nasiriyah from Basra International Airport instead of north from Kuwait City with M16s and a Humvee like before. He sat in the back of a taxi driven by a thin man in a taqiyah, one of those hats that looked like upside-down bowls made of hemp. The city had changed but not much. There were several pre-paid cell phone kiosks along Ambush Alley, now. Some of the dirt streets had been widened and paved. But it was still mostly mud brick shanties on the skirts with taller concrete buildings downtown. Not much vegetation except date palms. The city was a box of dust when the high winds came. He remembered how the sand and grit had turned to a talcum powder after the first week of the Push when the tanks and Humvees had pulverized the sand roads. The sand powder would part in front of their caravan like a cloud. Sometime in the years since he’d left, the sand had turned to sand again.</p><p>Skoot had not missed the heat. It came at you like a demon, the kind that sucks the lifeforce right out of you. It sat on your chest and pulled the air from your lungs, every last ounce of sweat from a million pores. There was nothing like it in the states. Even the imbedded reporters had no vocabulary to properly describe it to the people back home. It was a heat that made you sad. It was the kind of heat that killed air conditioners; this car’s had perished long ago. All they could do with the Humvees was take off the doors. When they were dressed in full mop gear the heat was so bad you’d risk sniper fire than sit behind closed doors.</p><p>“Tallil,” the cabbie said but Skoot already knew where they were. He was amazed at how much Arabic he’d retained — enough to read the street signs, enough even to understand half of what the lady was singing about on the radio.</p><p>The air base appeared around a corner, a short brick tower beside a long concrete runway surrounded by several hangers. It was called Camp Adder now, and mostly served as a support Army base. The old sheet metal box shelters near the front were called Yugos, remnants of the Iraqi military airport that had been built by Yugoslavian contractors in the 80’s. But there had been a lot of new construction since Skoot had left. There were dozens of modular offices and a barracks in back. A mobile commissary advertised Pizza Hut and Taco Bell. Looming over everything inside the walled-in compound was that creepy step pyramid, the ancient ziggurat of Ur, the supposed birthplace of Abraham.</p><p>They pulled up a ways from the front gate where a couple sentries were posted. “I wait here, okay?”</p><p>“Yes, wait,” said Skoot, pushing 50,000 dinars under the glass divider.</p><p>It was just as hot outside as it had been in the car and Skoot wiped the back of his neck with an already damp handkerchief. Slowly, his hands empty and at his sides, he approached the two armed men at the North gate. A third sat in a wooden pagoda just inside — Skoot had helped build that thing in 2003. They were bearded, skinny, dressed in the gray camouflage of Iraqi police. Looked like Shias. Good. Sunnis were harder to deal with, in his experience.</p><p>“Salam,” said one.</p><p>“American,” said Skoot. “Marines.”</p><p>“Wait,” said the other man. He spoke Arabic into the mobile attached to his epaulette. Skoot smiled at the men and waited.</p><p>“Khod!” one of them, the taller one to the left, said. He held out a pack of cigarettes.</p><p>Skoot nodded and pulled a cigarette from the package with one hand while he dug into his pants pocket with the other. One of the things you learn quick in country is the need to keep your pockets full of little gifts. He handed a sheet of four pills to the man. Candy was good. Over-the-counter medicine was better.</p><p>“Ooo,” said the tall man. “Tylenol Cold and Flu.” He put the meds in his jacket, then lit Skoot’s cigarette with a grimy dime store lighter.</p><p>“Why do you all return here?” asked the shorter man. “What brings you back?”</p><p>“You seen other Marines come back?”</p><p>The man nodded. “You come back like you forgot something. Like you left something…important…behind.”</p><p>“I did.”</p><p>“Whatever you left is long gone man.”</p><p>Skoot didn’t reply, but he hoped that was not true.</p><p>After a minute a wide-hipped white man in tan fatigues came out of the doors of a large re-habbed Yugo and walked briskly to them. He was Guard, obviously, but Skoot snapped a salute anyway.</p><p>“Sergeant John Scutener, First Battalion, Second Marine Division,” said Skoot.</p><p>The man in the tan fatigues shook his hand through the gate. “Captain Benjamin Rausch. What can I do for you, Scutener?”</p><p>“Wanted to take a look. Take some pictures. Make some prayers. That sort of thing.”</p><p>“You’ve been here before.”</p><p>“My unit took this base. March, 2003.”</p><p>The captain nodded to his sentry who pushed a button. The gates pulled back on metal tracks. Skoot ground his cigarette into the earth with the heel of his boot and stepped inside. The Iraqi guards shook his hand as he entered. One even patted him on the back. Skoot followed Rausch toward a low brick building near the new radio tower. They watched as a Galaxy, that unreliable favorite of cargo transports, landed loudly on the main strip.</p><p>“You in the program?”</p><p>“Like A.A.?” asked Skoot. “No. Different program: C.O.M. Cranky Old Marine. Thought coming back here might make me tolerable.”</p><p>“You want company?”</p><p>“I’d prefer to go it alone, if you don’t mind.”</p><p>“I don’t,” said Rausch, holding the door for him. Just inside were two more Iraqi policemen beside an outdated metal detector. Probably gave off radiation like nobody’s business. Skoot placed his cell phone and change in a dish and then walked through and the light stayed green.</p><p>“We catch a Marine in country without a ka-bar?” asked Rausch.</p><p>“It’s a new Iraq, right? Thought I’d just trust you guys this time.”</p><p>Truth was Skoot had pawned his knife and his sidearm was at the bottom of Claytor Lake, the abandoned swimming hole in Franklin Mills, along with his dog tags. He never wanted to fire a weapon again, never wanted to feel the weight of that steel in his hands.</p><p>Rausch left him alone after that and Skoot didn’t waste time. He walked down the yellow clay-tiled hallway toward the bathroom. That grimy yellow tile. The decades-old Pepsi machine by the weird third-world pay phone that looked like something out of a science fiction movie. The flickering flourescents. All the same. Even the smell; a tangy bleach-and-mildew stank that never quite covered the aroma of old piss.</p><p>Without allowing himself pause, Skoot entered the bathroom.</p><p>More than just a commode. It was a shower, too. White and black tile. Toilets without stalls, lined up against a wall. A communal trough for pissing, a green garden hose snaked out of the wall, one end lying inside it to provide a flush when needed. Stainless steel mirrors above ceramic sinks.</p><p>Skoot looked at the corner, between the piss trough and a sink, where a drain was set in the floor. The blood had cleaned up quick. Like it had never been there. Robinstein had cleaned it up with a bottle of bleach and a mop and some gloves. Should have been him. Or Gordie. Or any of the others. Robinstein didn’t have much to do with what happened in here.</p><p>After a minute Skoot walked over to the drain and knelt down. His heart was beating weird. He could hear it, a pulsing in his ears like he was hearing it underwater. He wasn’t going to pass out though.</p><p><em>I’m a monster,</em> he thought. <em>We are all monsters.</em></p><p>“You deserve as much grace as you give to others,” Chief Running Feather had said. And that was true, wasn’t it? He could get behind that. If he could forgive Gordie and Robinstein and Glendenning and Biscuit, he could forgive himself.</p><p>We were boys. Only boys. What did anyone expect?</p><p>The pulsing in his ears grew louder and now something else… Like a kind of calmness entering his body, the way it feels to push the red button in the hospital to get the morphine, the way it runs through your body like cool steel that quickly moldens in warm blood.</p><p>There was something white in the drain. Like a piece of the tile floor but Skoot knew it wasn’t a piece of the tile floor. He reached down and picked up the drain cover. He set it aside and reached in. He brought it out and held it to the light in front of his face.</p><p>About the size of a dime, rounded and smooth and white. A piece of skull. The rest of the body was in an unmarked grave behind the ziggurat.</p><p>It felt oddly heavy in his grip. He’d seen a special on the Discovery Channel some time ago; a BBC special about neutron stars and how a spoonful of neutron star stuff weighed as much as Mount Everest. This bit of skull bone was kind of like that. It was something more than just bone.</p><p><em>This is where my soul went.</em></p><p>Skoot looked back to the bathroom door. It was still closed.</p><p>He put the skull bone on his tongue like they taught him to do with those wafers at St. Joe’s. Then he swallowed it whole. It was gone before he could be revolted enough to stop.</p><p>After that, he’d felt better.</p><h3>7</h3><p>Whispering Pines had been condemned and Chief Running Feather was MIA. All the cabin doors were boarded shut with sheets of plywood. Tacked to the outside of the mess hall was a laminated notice from the Northumberland County tax assessor. “Foreclosed,” it said. A red label on the window warned that the building was “unfit for habitation.”</p><p>“Well shit,” said Gordie. “What now?”</p><p>The walk up the mountain had been hard on Skoot’s old friend. It had taken them an extra hour to make the climb due to the considerable weight Gordie had added to his frame in the years they’d been apart. Every mile they had to stop so he could catch his breath and dab his sweat away with a ragged towel.</p><p>“Don’t matter,” said Skoot, nodding over to a trail at the edge of the clearing that led into a nest of red spruce. “They won’t have condemned the sweat lodge and that’s all we really need anyway.”</p><p>“What about Chief Running Feather?”</p><p>“He taught me what he knows. I can manage.”</p><p>Skoot was right — the sweat lodge was still there, though one side of the canvass igloo had collapsed. It only took a few minutes to get it settled again and to clear out the daddy long-legs that had nested inside.</p><p>Likely they were alone at the summit for the night but they built the fire a hundred feet into the spruce just in case, digging away the brush and lining the pit with rock. If a ranger came by to check on the old cabins in the dark, he wouldn’t be able to see the fire or smoke without coming down the trail. They’d hear him long before then. You can’t untrain a Marine.</p><p>The sun set before the fire got cooking. The twigs snapped loudly and shot off fireflies but they managed to keep it contained. Around eleven o’clock there was a bed of red coals, what Skoot’s father had called a dragon’s bed. They placed a couple fist-sized chunks of granite and sandstone on top and waited for them to warm.</p><p>Gordie reclined on his open jacket and looked through the treetops at the expanse of the Milky Way. A frozen river in the sky. It had looked the same in An Nasiriyah though pretty much everything else was different.</p><p>“You know what I kept thinking when we were over there?” said Gordie.</p><p>“No,” said Skoot. He kept watching Gordie. He didn’t like the tone of his voice. Especially not out here in the middle of nowhere and far from it all.</p><p>“I kept thinking that here were streets that Jesus walked on. That those cities we fought in were so old that maybe Jesus or at least Peter or Paul or someone, maybe they walked on the same road. His feet where my feet were. Thought it every day. Couldn’t get it out of my head. That zigger thing, ziggurat, didn’t help. It was so big and it was always there. I got some books from the library when we got back. You know nobody knows how old it is? One guy, an anthropologist, said it had to be at least four thousand years old but that the base of it was even older, maybe ten thousand years, even. That it was built by these people called Sumerians so that they could worship a God called Sin. Can you believe that? A God called <em>Sin</em>.”</p><p>“Why were you thinking about all that?”</p><p>“I don’t know, man.”</p><p>Skoot looked to the dragon’s bed where the rocks were warming. They didn’t look hot enough yet. Soon.</p><p>“Here’s another thing I can’t get out of my head,” said Gordie.</p><p>“Okay.”</p><p>“Like have you thought yet about why anyone goes to war in the first place?”</p><p>“What do you mean?”</p><p>“Well think about it. I mean, seriously. Why did we go to war? And I’m not talking about just Iraq. I mean every war. What’s your answer when you think about it?”</p><p>Skoot was quiet for a minute. He didn’t like this conversation much. But he’d brought Gordie all the way up here and talking was a part of what they had to do.</p><p>“For liberty,” he said. “For peace.”</p><p>“That’s right. Exactly right,” said Gordie. “But what about the other side?”</p><p>“Which other side?”</p><p>“Saddam’s people. The Ba’aths. The terrorists. Afghanies, too. Why were they fighting?”</p><p>“Because they hate America.”</p><p>Gordie craned his neck to look at him. “You really believe that anymore?”</p><p>Skoot shrugged and pushed at a rock with a dry branch he’d found at his side.</p><p>“You know what I think? I think they were fighting for peace, too. I think that’s all anyone ever really fights for. Crazy, right? All the wars when you get down to it were fought for peace. That’s like drinking to get sober. Except, here’s the shitty part: we all have a different idea of what peace means and we hate every one else’s way of seeing it.”</p><p>“I don’t understand,” said Skoot.</p><p>“Doesn’t matter,” said Gordie, looking back at the fire. “I guess my point is, we’re only heroes depending on what side you’re looking from. And on the other side, we’re just monsters. And maybe that’s what happened to us, because I sure as hell feel black inside. I’ll tell you something else. I think the Iraqis who came at us, especially that one, the one in the bathroom. I think they felt that blackness too.”</p><p>“So we’re all monsters? Is that it?”</p><p>“Nah, man. Not that easy. We’re all both. Heroes and monsters. Each of us and all of us. All the time. And not just men who go to war. Everybody. You and I and Glendenning and Robinstein and Biscuit, we just were forced to see it too early. Most everyone else can ignore it awhile. Until we’re old and facing our own death. We had to face it before we were ready. And that’s what’s making us batshit.”</p><p>Skoot put on his fire retardant glove and began tossing the rocks into the metal bucket from the sweat lodge. Gordie broke off a thick branch from a spruce and ran it under the bucket’s handle. They each took an end and hiked the hot rock back to the canvass shelter. At the entrance they stripped off their clothes and then got on their hands and knees and crawled into the sweat lodge. The low door was a part of it, too, Chief Running Feather had explained. It was about humility.</p><h3>8</h3><p>Gordie’s soul was not in the bathroom. Skoot was sure of it; he’d searched for half an hour. He thought he felt a little Robinstein by the door because that’s where he’d been most of the time but he wasn’t sure. The others’ souls, if they’d escaped their bodies here, they hadn’t stayed behind. After a while Skoot returned to the cab and handed the driver some folded bills and told him he didn’t need him after all.</p><p>It wasn’t so safe to walk around An Nasiriyah even so many years later. Not for an American, not even a Marine. It wasn’t the Saddam loyalists or anything like that. It was the opportunists, the kidnappers he had to watch out for. Especially being unarmed as he was. Someone might take a look at his shoes or his jeans and start having covetous thoughts. Or worse, someone might peg him for a spook, a CIA operative or something and think maybe he was worth a ransom. He’d learned long ago to override his fear, though. Hell, that was half of what being a Marine was all about. And so he actually managed a swagger as he walked down the road toward town, through the oldest section known as Mahatt Ur.</p><p>This part of Nasiriyah was spooky and had always reminded Skoot of that Star Wars where they were in the desert, the one where they went through that mud hut town and found the alien bar with the funny music. He’d always wondered if they’d filmed that movie somewhere around here but thought maybe much of the Middle East looked about the same. Even the music coming out of the old boom boxes in the screenless windows of the metal-hooded huts sounded kind of like that bar. So maybe if they didn’t film the movie here the guy that wrote it had thought about this place when he did.</p><p>A guy in a taqiyah, sitting on a stool outside another one of those prepaid cell phone shops, waved at him. “Salam,” he said. “Rahimaka Allah!”</p><p>Skoot just shook his head and kept walking.</p><p>Round the next turn was the zoo and he smelled it before he saw it, a rank stank like a wall of flavor. A little zoo, a few pens and a couple yards fenced in by wooden planks salvaged from some American Quonset hut or something. There was even a sign out front that said, “Zoo,” in English and he thought maybe that had been stolen, too. From where he stood he could see a kangaroo rubbing up against the side of a metal shed. Its hide was splotched and it looked awful itchy.</p><p>Skoot was about to move on when he smelled Gordie. It wasn’t the stink of the animals. Gordie didn’t stink. He always smelled the same; Old Spice, the kind that comes in that red genie-lookin bottle. Only guy in their company had bothered with cologne. And there it was, on the warm current drifting down this alley. Nobody round here would likely treat themselves to Old Spice cologne. Or maybe they did now they were liberated. Hell maybe the Old Spice was in every corner stand. Maybe they gave a bottle away with every prepaid cell phone. But he thought it unlikely. It was a sign. He walked to the entrance of the zoo where the smell seemed to be coming from.</p><p>A skinny boy in a pale galabiyya sat at a booth by the front door, the old cotton dress hanging over his feet. The signs here were all in Arabic but Skoot could read enough to see that admission was 5,000 dinar for adults and 2,000 for kids older than four. He handed the boy eight dollars and told him to keep the change.</p><p>“Shokran,” the boy said.</p><p>“You’re welcome,” said Skoot.</p><p>First thing inside was a dark room with blue lights. A wide aquarium was built into the far wall. It was kind of dirty, this aquarium, and full of skinny mangar and a couple soft-shell turtles, which he’d seen already anyhow. He hurried on. Being in a dark room in Iraq was never a good thing unless there was a hooka in the middle surrounded by olive-skinned prostitutes.</p><p>Beyond the aquarium was a narrow passage that ran between two cages fronted with potted ferns and palms. Inside one was a skinny leopard, the black kind he’d been scared of since watching Amityville Horror on the Late Night Movie in Franklin Mills when he was eight. It sneered at him from a corner and he gave it the finger. In the other was some kind of cat called an ocelot but he could tell Gordie’s soul wasn’t anywhere near this particular cage so he moved on.</p><p>A door at the end of the hall opened onto the outside paddock he’d eyed from the street. Here was the mangy kangaroo, still rubbing against the wall like it was all it ever did. The enclosure was divided into a few more pens, triangulating out from a center observation area, like segments of a grapefruit. After the kangaroo was an island of capuchin monkeys hollering and fighting and sexing with each other. Beyond monkey island was the bear and as soon as Skoot seen him he knew Gordie, or a part of Gordie, was somewhere inside it.</p><p>It wasn’t just the way the bear tilted its head like Gordie did. It was also the way it was looking right at him, its claws on the bars of the cage, like it had been waiting for him for a while. And it had a scarred right ear, a white hairless patch, just like Gordie had, from what happened in that damned bathroom. As Skoot walked toward the animal, that Old Spice smell grew so strong he could almost hear it in his head.</p><p>A little hand-drawn sign posted on a stand a few feet from the cage gave the story of the creature but Skoot could only make out enough to see that the bear’s name was Master Bruin and that it had come from Russia.</p><p>Was it possible, if you lost your soul, for it to migrate into the body of an animal? Chief Running Feather had never been specific about that part. But if his soul had been hiding inside the fractured remains of a human skull he figured just about anything was possible.</p><p>“Gordie?” he asked.</p><p>The bear only tilted its head.</p><p>“If you’re in there, man, give me a sign.”</p><p>The bear roared, a deep, guttural shout. And then it took a dump.</p><p>If any part of Gordie ever got itself trapped inside a bear, Skoot figured that’s just about what he would have done.</p><h3>9</h3><p>Three days after the sweat lodge, where Skoot had done his best Chief Running Feather impression while they sat in the stingy smoke, he preceded Gordie onto a 747 bound for Iraq.</p><p>“I ain’t got the money to fly back to Iraq, dummy,” Gordie said when Skoot told him about the flight that was already long planned before he came home to Franklin Mills. After Skoot had come home from that visit to the zoo in Nasiriyah, he’d gotten a job detailing cars for a dealership outside Marietta. The manager paid him on the sly and it was enough, on top of his disability, to sock something away. Took three months before he had enough to pay back his old lady’s old man, but he wouldn’t have nothing to do with it.</p><p>“I bought something with that,” he told the Marine.</p><p>So Skoot had set it aside to for Gordie and he didn’t have a choice in the matter, now. Gordie was going. And that was that. Besides, it would work. Skoot was sure. And when it did, maybe Skoot could pay for some other dumbass to go back to Iraq to get his soul. Not Robinstein. But, someone else. Maybe Biscuit.</p><p>“Don’t know that I deserve any of this,” Gordie had said as they were coming off the mountain.</p><p>“None of us do.”</p><p>And so now it was on Skoot’s own dime they returned to Iraq. And the heat greeted them at the door to the jet like an old friend who doesn’t know he’s over-stayed his welcome.</p><p>“Goddamn,” said Gordie. “You can never hide from the sun in the suck.”</p><p>“Not anywhere in the sandbox,” Skoot agreed.</p><p>“I had forgotten how everything looks out of focus,” said Gordie, peering out at the city as they walked to the terminal. It was the sand particles that were too tiny to fall to the ground except for when it rained. The floating grit dulled the sharp corners of the world. It was an optical illusion, making it seem like you could never quite get a lock on anything your eyes told you was there.</p><p>Outside Basra International, they located a cab and asked the man to bring them to An Nasiriyah. It was a two-and-a-half hour drive, but Skoot had prepared for this and showed the cabbie the money.</p><p>Soon they were barreling up Route 8, toward that ancient city that rested in the shadow of the ziggurat.</p><h3>10</h3><p>It had only been a year but the zoo was gone. The kangaroo pen was empty, but some scratches on the side of the compound looked fresh. A man working at the cell phone store next door told them, in broken English, how it had all gone down.</p><p>“Monkeys got sick. Couldn’t stop shitting. Some Americans come in, close it down.”</p><p>“Where’s the bear?” asked Skoot.</p><p>The man blinked at him.</p><p>“Ursa,” said Gordie. He’d heard the word somewhere, high school probably, and knew it had something to do with bears. He rose up on his feet and put his arms out like a grizzly ready to attack.</p><p>The Iraqi nodded. He pointed down the street, where the road dead-ended at the outskirts of Mahatt Ur. A low mud building sat there, its wooden doors open to the heat, dark inside. A sign out front advertised something in Arabic that Skoot couldn’t read. He thought it might be a cantina. They thanked the cell phone man with some Tylenol and then walked toward the building.</p><p>“This doesn’t seem right,” said Gordie.</p><p>“Don’t sweat it,” said Skoot. “We won, remember.”</p><p>Still, Gordie felt naked without his M16, the one he called “Shelly,” positioned in front of his heart, pointed at the alert. Other than his pocketknife, he was weaponless. They’d been taught better than to walk into a dead-end without support.</p><p>It was a restaurant, a wide-roomed dining hall with a noisy kitchen. A transistor radio played a kind of clangy music in which a Santur was surely involved. The radio sat on a ledge where the cooks placed plates for the only server, an older gentleman in a white robe who stooped as he walked. Both tables were occupied by men sitting shoulder-to-shoulder playing some version of dominoes with handmade ceramic tiles. A dust-coated overhead fan kicked the heat around a bit and it was just a couple degrees cooler inside. A couple of the men looked over to them but they didn’t stare long.</p><p>“Look,” said Gordie, pointing to a poster hanging on the back wall.</p><p>It was a hand-drawn bill, two feet by a foot. It showed a shirtless barrel-chested Iraqi man standing in a boxing ring with a big black bear.</p><p>“Well,” said Skoot.</p><p>“Sabah el kheer,” said the older man, who had trudged over to them.</p><p>“Right back at ya,” said Gordie. “Could we see the bear?”</p><p>The older man looked over to the poster then shouted for someone in the kitchen. A large bearded man wearing an apron stained with sweet-smelling Jajeek sauce came out and walked over to them.</p><p>“Hallo,” the man said. “You want to box the bear? Yes? You come to fight Master Bruin?”</p><p>“Can we just see him first?” asked Skoot.</p><p>The man nodded. “I am Muhammad Zald,” he said, shaking their hands. “You pay in dollar or dinar alright? Walk with me.”</p><p>They followed Zald through a passageway curtained with an old blanket at the rear of the restaurant. Beyond was a larger building made of corrugated steel sheeting, dark except for the diffused sunlight that snuck in through a skylight made of plastic. The arena was packed dirt and in the center was a matted boxing ring like the kind Skoot remembered from the Ravenna Big Brother’s Club. A couple rows of seats made from old munitions crates circled the ring.</p><p>Zald walked past all this, toward a shadowed corner where a large dark shape lurked inside an iron cage.</p><p>“Master Bruin!” said Zald, knocking his wedding ring against one of the iron bars.</p><p>The bear turned its head without moving the rest of its body. It was a big black bear, for sure. Old. Its muzzle was graying and splotchy. Its right ear was gone around a long scar that looked like a dog bite. And God did it stink, like a thick-fibered couch where some fat man ate himself to death.</p><p>“You have visitors,” said Zald.</p><p>The Iraqi turned back to them then and waited patiently.</p><p>“Right,” said Skoot. He dug into his jeans and handed the man 10,000 dinar and a whole sheet of Theraflu. Zald smiled. “You sure you not want to box? He won’t fight back.”</p><p>“Maybe later,” said Skoot.</p><p>Zald left them alone.</p><p>“What now?” asked Gordie.</p><p>“You kill it, I think,” said Skoot.</p><p>“With what?”</p><p>“With your old bowie knife.”</p><p>“With my…Skoot! You think I could have gotten through customs with a fucking bowie knife strapped to my leg?”</p><p>“What did you bring then?”</p><p>“Man, this is your rodeo. I didn’t bring nothing ‘cept for my pocket knife and that’s not going to do more than piss it off.”</p><p>“Then I guess you’re gonna have to strangle it, Gordie. Doesn’t look like it would care much if you did.”</p><p>But Gordie just shook his head. “What if I didn’t kill it?”</p><p>Skoot shrugged. “I’m not sure how it works. I don’t know. You feel anything?”</p><p>Gordie looked at the bear. It had gone back to looking at the sheet metal wall. “Hey!” he said to it.</p><p>Master Bruin snorted loudly and whined, deep in its chest.</p><p>“Hey, damn it. Look at me,” said Gordie.</p><p>The bear’s head turned and it licked its lips loudly, perhaps thinking it was time for its lunch. When it saw he wasn’t Zard, it whined some more.</p><p>“Shush, now,” said Gordie. “Lemme get a look at you.”</p><p>Slowly, Master Bruin shifted onto its paws and ambled toward him. It stood on its hind legs for a moment and scratched its belly then lumbered back down.</p><p>“Hey, bear,” said Gordie. “Hey. Are you a bear or what?”</p><p>Master Bruin tilted its head then and appeared to smile.</p><p>“I dunno,” said Gordie, scratching his ear the way he always did when he was figuring something out. “I see a kind of resemblance…”</p><p>The bear scratched its own ear, the one still there.</p><p>Skoot laughed.</p><p>“Well,” said Gordie. “That’s just a…”</p><p>But before he could finish Master Bruin got back on its hind legs, walked quickly to the bars, and held out one paw at Gordie. Its hand, with its filed-down black nails, opened and closed, opened and closed.</p><p>The Marine walked over to the animal and after a second’s hesitation put his hand inside the bear’s own. Gently, Master Bruin pulled Gordie closer to the cage. The animal looked into his eyes. Deeply.</p><p>“Goddamn. I think you’re right. I do feel something.”</p><p>“Not too close, man.”</p><p>The bear stuck its snout out to the man and sniffed his long hair. It sneezed.</p><p>“Hey there,” said Gordie, reaching out and placing his free hand on Master Bruin’s cheek. “Hey bud. You got a piece of my soul in there? Do ya? Is that what happened?”</p><p>The bear began to lick Gordie’s face.</p><p>“Thanks for keeping it safe, fella. Thank you. But can I have it back? Could you just give it back to me?”</p><p>“Dude,” said Skoot. “Back up a bit. I think he likes how you taste.”</p><p>“I need it, Master Bruin.”</p><p>The bear registered its name. It stopped licking at his face. Something about its eyes changed, too.</p><p>“I need my soul, man. Give me my soul.”</p><p>“Gordie,” said Skoot. The bear still had a paw around his friend’s right hand. Its black claws were dulled but still looked dangerous.</p><p>“Give me back my soul you stupid bear!”</p><p>It happened before Skoot could pull him away. Master Bruin released Gordie’s hand and with one quick upward swipe, tore off a hunk of the left side of Gordie’s face. One of the bear’s nails caught the eye and it slid out, soundlessly. For a moment — likely a second but with the adrenaline pouring through his body it felt like a full minute to Skoot — nothing more happened. The bear simply stood there with part of Gordie’s face dangling from its paw. Then Gordie collapsed without so much as a groan. Fainted cold. Blood began to quickly pool around the man’s head, painting the concrete floor a dark purple.</p><p>Then Skoot began to scream.</p><p>Zald came running. “Matha!” he shouted. “Oh! Bala’a il a’air!” Without slowing, he addressed Skoot as he jogged past him to a metal cabinet beside the cage. “What the fuck happened? What the fuck? Is he dead?”</p><p>“I don’t know. It hit him. It just…God!” Skoot ran to his friend. He pulled off his thin cotton shirt, balled it up and pushed it against the wound. When he looked up at Zald again, the Iraqi was standing beside the cage with an antique Russian rifle, a beautiful SKS, aimed at Master Bruin.</p><p>“Aasef,” said Zald. He shot the bear in the temple. The bullet went in through the hole where its right ear used to be. Master Bruin sank to the ground with one last prolonged snort.</p><p>“Ambulance,” yelled Skoot. “He needs a doctor! Ahtaju tabeeban!”</p><h3>11</h3><p>There was frost in the wide ditches and it was plenty cold when Skoot returned to Franklin Mills that March. Gordie had moved out of the trailer by the dump and into a duplex behind the bar. He was living with Shelly and their place was close enough that she could walk to the Driftwood for work. Gordie, himself, didn’t drink anymore. He got a job down the aircraft plant in Ravenna. Second shift. Grunt assembly work but he didn’t mind. Kept him busy. Kept his mind sharp. He was grilling two thin steaks on the Weber out front when Skoot pulled up in his Mustang.</p><p>Not so worse for the wear, either. The bear, Master Bruin, had taken Gordie’s left eye and a section of his cheek but the graft had taken well. Gordie rocked a camouflaged eye patch, now, and the scar tissue on his face was only a little jagged, only a little bit lighter than the surrounding skin. He looked like a bad dude from some daytime soap. He wore it well, that scar. Better than any he’d been given in An Nasiriyah or Kirkut. He smiled at Skoot and waved at him with the spatula.</p><p>That was another thing about Gordie these days, that smile. It was like Skoot remembered from school, the way he’d looked after tackling the quarterback from Crestwood on Homecoming Night. It was one of those things you don’t really notice when it goes missing. Like the Moon. But when Gordie had started smiling again at that Army hospital they’d taken him to in Germany after the incident with the bear, Skoot had noticed right away how long it had been gone.</p><p>“It was back when I woke up,” Gordie said. His face had been all bandaged up at that point. “I woke up and I felt like myself again.”</p><p>They sat on lawn chairs in front of the house and ate their steaks with ketchup and talked about Biscuit and Glendenning and even Robenstein and waited for Shelly to finish up at the Driftwood. When she got home they were going to drive into Kent to see a movie, all three of them.</p><p>“I had this dream the other night,” Gordie said as he washed their plates in the sink. This was after they come inside, about ten minutes before Shelly was due home.</p><p>“What sort of dream?” asked Skoot.</p><p>“Kind of an odd dream. The kind you can never really understand.”</p><p>“What was it?”</p><p>“I’m outside Tallil. In Mahatt Ur. Only I’m driving my old Saturn and not one of the Humvees. Along Highway 7 at that place where the stone bridge goes over that creek that feeds into the Euphrates? It’s during the rainy season and so the river is running over the bridge. Looks like only a foot or so. But probably too high for the Saturn so I stop the car right before the bridge. But I can see across the bridge and there on the other side is that boy. The one from the bathroom. He’s hurt. Don’t know what kind of hurt but it’s bad. And he needs my help. And I have to help him but the water is too high. He’s waving me over. Calling out for help. So I decide to try it. And I move forward in my old Saturn. But when I get halfway across the bridge that fast water carries me away. We both die this time.”</p><p>Skoot didn’t say anything. He just watched his friend finish the dishes. When Gordie was done, he flipped the towel over his shoulder and looked at Skoot and shrugged. He smiled again. Skoot smiled back.</p><p>“That was probably the right thing to do,” Skoot said, finally.</p><p>###</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c6561729b731" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The House Behind the Hedges]]></title>
            <link>https://jamesrenner.medium.com/the-house-behind-the-hedges-914435636de9?source=rss-8221d6e709bf------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/914435636de9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[great-forgetting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[haunted-house]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[short-story]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[james-renner]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[James Renner]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Dec 2016 15:55:47 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-04T21:55:44.013Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G0cWllgoX284wZtm07U-LA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Author’s Note: The following short story, about two young men exploring a haunted house in 1992, takes place in the world of THE GREAT FORGETTING. It appeared as a chapter in an early draft of the novel. I am sharing it, now, to celebrate the Picador paperback release of the book, on January 10, 2017.</em></p><p>The old mansion slumbered in the dark.</p><p>It was a four-story Victorian, lousy with shutters and eaves and lightning rods, windows like eyes, doors like mouths. It sat on a slope of Tallmadge Road, obscured by a row of pine trees. Once, the siding had been yellow, but now it was the color of a cataract. Yew hedges had grown so wide and tall they choked away access to the front door.</p><p>Jack stood next to Tony, his shoes touching the ground on either side of his bike. They stared at the abandoned home and listened. Jack pictured Smaug, the dragon from <em>The Hobbit</em>, sleeping in the basement, waiting. It had been Tony’s idea to break into the Wagner mansion.</p><p>It sounded like a fine idea to Jack. He was game for any excuse to fly through the night on his Huffy, especially on nights like this one. The air was so goddamn hot, so goddamn stagnant, the only breeze had to be manufactured. Local journalists had begun to report on an exponential increase in violent crimes. Murder. Rape. People were going insane from the heat.</p><p>This adventure was a welcome distraction for Jack. He could not stop thinking about Sam. He hadn’t seen her since that frightening night a week ago when her father nearly killed him. Since then, no one had heard from her.</p><p>So Jack had spent the night at Tony’s and they had gone AWOL a little after one in the morning, pedaling their bikes down Tallmadge toward this decrepit mansion, subject of local ghost stories going back decades.</p><p>Old Man Wagner, so they said, had been the richest man in Franklin Mills, a lawyer for Akron’s rubber barons. He built the mansion for his young bride after the Great War and she had five healthy children and then a sixth. The last, a boy, had a skull twice the size of a normal human’s. Melonhead, they called him. Wagner was so horrified by his offspring, he locked the boy away in the rounded spire at the top of the house. The mother constructed the most wonderful bedroom for him and filled it with every toy a boy could desire. And there the child stayed. His world became that room and he never knew to want more. What he could see of the world through the window was an elaborate play, they told him, acted out for his amusement. <em>Miasma, illusion.</em></p><p>Eventually the Wagners died off — the circumstances vary from telling to telling — and Melonhead was left to fend for himself, subsisting on the mice and birds that wandered inside the broken home, the rainwater from the gutters. On a quiet night, you could hear him singing lullabies on the wind.</p><p>Jack and Tony knew it was just a story. But they wanted to suspend disbelief long enough to scare the bejesus out of themselves. It beat sitting in the heat and watching Big Chuck and Lil’ John’s weekend creature-feature on Channel 8.</p><p>“Ready?” said Tony, leaning his bike against a pine.</p><p>“Ready,” said Jack.</p><p>They tried to push through the yew hedges but the brambles were thick and scratched their arms.</p><p>“Lets go around back,” Tony suggested.</p><p>“Does the air seem thicker to you?” asked Jack. “Like it might rain?”</p><p>“It’ll never rain again. Not here.”</p><p>They walked around, climbing over a giant oak that lay upon the remnants of the porch. They walked the length of it and found themselves on the dark side of the house, where a cobblestone patio was obscured beneath a carpet of Russian thistle. A large picture window, miraculously intact, looked into the quiet house. Tony worked a large stone out of the patio, canting it back and forth with his feet until it came free. He lifted it over his head.</p><p>“Wait,” said Jack.</p><p>Too late. The rock punched through the window with a THUNK-SPOOSH! Glass splinters the size of guillotine blades fell in a crash that would have echoed over all of Franklin Mills. But the air was thick enough to buffer it.</p><p>“The melonhead’s awake, now,” Tony said, with a laugh.</p><p>They switched on their flashlights. Tony’s was a heavy Maglite, Jack’s a red plastic five-and-dime type. Minding the shards of glass that stuck out from the bottom of the window frame like broken teeth, the two sixteen-year-old boys stepped inside.</p><p>Thinly focused beams of light picked up dusty motes that hung in the air like suspended raindrops. They were in a sitting room furnished with upholstered hickory chairs and a chaise lounge. The walls were covered in expensive wallpapering, an oddly-shaped damask pattern the color of seaweed. The pattern looked like faces of fat, hairy dragons. The room smelled of rot and plaster and mildew.</p><p>Tony walked to a cherry cabinet set against the westerly wall, covered in a sheet of dust. A crystal decanter of amber liquid sat on top. He set the Maglite down, aiming it up at the ceiling to provide diffuse light and, with some effort, pried the cork stopper off.</p><p>“Scotch,” he said.</p><p>“Don’t.”</p><p>Tony brought the spirits to his lips. He took a tiny swallow, then spit out the rest in a violent spray. “Uck,” he said.</p><p>“What’d it taste like?”</p><p>“Like gasoline.” He took his flashlight and walked into the darkness through an arched doorway. “C’mon.”</p><p>Jack followed. The floorboards protested their intrusion, creaking and snapping like fireworks beneath their feet.</p><p>The next room was the kitchen. The marble countertops were covered in a fine black ash that Jack thought might be some sort of mushroom or mold. Moss hung from the pedals of a ceiling fan. Tony opened the door of a tall cabinet beside a rusted sink. The cupboard was stocked with tins and boxes of brand-named food that no longer existed: Fern Park spinach; Soughtafter tomatoes; Royal Dutch coffee; a beige tin marked, Eintopf. A piece of propaganda art was tacked to the inside of the door. It showed Uncle Sam collecting junk from a line of people that extended over the horizon. Large white letters proclaimed: <em>Remember: Everyone must pitch in to secure a better future! Turn in your chronological artifacts today!</em></p><p>“That’s creepy,” said Tony.</p><p>“What is it?”</p><p>Tony shrugged. “Something from World War II I guess. War bonds or something.”</p><p>Jack shined his light over the room and discovered a narrow set of carpeted stairs leading to a second floor. The carpet had been gold, once, but it was almost brown, now. There were dark splotches baked into the fabric. It could have been mud or Ragu. But Jack was sure it was blood. Tony stepped around him and motioned for him to follow.</p><p>The steps protested, yelping loudly under their feet, worse than the floorboards. Larger men might have fallen through the moldy planks but the boys each weighed less than 140 pounds and so they were granted passage. Jack bit his bottom lip. He was suddenly overwhelmed with a sense of vertigo, as if he were standing outside his body, looking in. His nerves warned him of an unseen danger. Every instinct told him to run. He savored it all and followed his friend upstairs.</p><p>The paper pattern on the walls of the second-floor hallway showed the white reliefs of aspen trees and starlings against a periwinkle sky. The heads of the starlings were tilted as if the birds were listening to the sound of their footsteps.</p><p>Tony opened the door to their immediate right. It made no noise and Jack wondered, distantly, if it had been oiled.</p><p>The room was devoid of furniture. Tony’s flashlight illuminated shelves set into a corner where knicknacks were displayed, ceramic figurines, the sort you’d find in tea tins. A menagerie, as it turned out. Animals, two-by-two. A recreation of the passengers of Noah’s ark, in miniature. Jack was walking toward the far corner where another row of shelves held similar treasures when his shoe stepped in something squishy.</p><p>He shined his light down and recoiled instantly. He let go a meager scream.</p><p>“What?” said Tony.</p><p>“Look!”</p><p>A mound of brownness grew from the floor. A heap of organic muck without smell or, if it smelled, a smell waylaid by the overpowering stank of the house itself, the plaster and time and dust.</p><p>“It’s shit,” Tony whispered.</p><p>“It’s human shit,” Jack corrected.</p><p>And that’s when they heard it: the groan of the stairs as something larger than themselves approached. Instinctively, they shut off their lights and backed against the wall. Jack grabbed at the air and found Tony’s hand. He clenched it tightly.</p><p>The sounds stopped.</p><p>Jack could hear Tony try to quiet his breathing, his fearful panting slowing. He tried to do the same. But he was frightened beyond reason. The best he could do was shut his mouth and breath through his nose.</p><p>Jack listened. With all his will, he listened.</p><p>CREAK!</p><p>Something was in the room with them.</p><p>Tony pulled his hand free and a second later his Maglite clicked on.</p><p>A ghost-man stood before them. Rail-thin, dressed only in a pair of white briefs the color of grime, it’s stomach distended under ribs that stretched its mottled skin. The man was not simply old, but ancient. Hairless. Liver-spotted and cancerous. And his skull twice the size of a normal human’s.</p><p>At first Jack thought it was a demon. He opened his mouth to scream but nothing came out. He couldn’t push air from his lungs. He was so terrified, he couldn’t breathe. The monster grabbed his arm and pulled him forward.</p><p>“My house!” it screamed. It’s breath was noxious, compost gas.</p><p>“Leave him alone… asshead!” Tony yelled. He brought the Maglite down on the ghost-man’s arm. It cried out and let go. “Run, Jack, Run!”</p><p>Jack dove around the melonhead and staggered to the door. When he looked back, he saw the old man silhouetted in the light of Tony’s flashlight.</p><p>“My house! You’re in my house!”</p><p>That was when Jack noticed the object in the man’s right talon. A wide metal mallet, the sort used for tenderizing chickens and busting skulls.</p><p>In a sickening, paralyzing panic, Jack watched, helpless, as the old man brought the hammer up and back, readying an arc that would connect with Tony’s head. Tony seemed transfixed, too, hypnotized by the strangeness of the moment.</p><p>And then the room was filled with a blinding light, a light so white and hot that it hurt Jack’s eyes. His first thought was that a nuclear bomb had detonated over Franklin Mills, this light the harbinger of a shockwave bringing destruction and fire. A shockwave did come, slamming against the house, shaking it back and forth, and with it, thunder.</p><p>The old man dropped the mallet and clutched his ears. Tony ran, pushing Jack forward and down the stairs. They heard the flood begin. Rain hammered on the house like gravel dumped from a truck onto a sheet of metal. They leaped from the hole in the picture window, a shard of glass scraping Jack’s leg, drawing blood. It missed the major artery but he would have a scar the rest of his life.</p><p>It was like stepping under a waterfall with no borders. They were soaked through in a second. Again, Jack found Tony’s hand. He could not make out the shape of Tony’s body, so thick was the falling water. Another bolt of lightning broke the sky, connecting with the ornate rod atop the mansion, which was still occupied by a melonhead or some vagrant, forgotten by the world.</p><p>They located their bikes using sense memory and pushed through the rain, down the road a quarter-mile before giving up and ducking under a row of thick pine trees beside the ditch. They took shelter under the thick boughs and collapsed onto a bed of nettles. The world was ending in a Biblical flood that brought a cool wind from the North. Jack would later listen to Dick Goddard explain how the storm dropped nearly two feet of water on one hour that night. In the valleys, homes and trailers were washed away, into the Cuyahoga, claiming the lives of forty-seven souls.</p><p>Jack was laughing, hysterical laughter, the kind you can’t control even if you try. “Leave him alone, asshead!” he said, between such bursts.</p><p>Tony laughed, too. “I couldn’t think of anything else,” he said. “My mind went blank.”</p><p>They laughed until their sides cramped up and still the rain raged beyond the trees. They had Tony’s Maglite for comfort. Jack had lost his flashlight somewhere in the house.</p><p>For a long time they said nothing more. Then Jack turned to Tony and said, “I’m in love with Sam Brooks.”</p><p>Tony looked up into the dark branches. “My dad’s going crazy and I’m afraid one day he’s going to kill my mom,” he said. “Or me.”</p><p>An hour before dawn, the rain let up. They rode their bikes back to Tony’s family’s apartment over the convenience store and they slept till noon.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=914435636de9" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>