<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jamie Bautista on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jamie Bautista on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jamiebautista?source=rss-7561bcf0826------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 12:25:39 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jamiebautista/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How the Feel-Good Carole King Musical Made Me Feel Bad]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamiebautista/how-the-feel-good-carole-king-musical-made-me-feel-bad-3cb28a87215d?source=rss-7561bcf0826------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3cb28a87215d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sara-bareilles]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[beautiful]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[carole-king]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theater]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[broadway]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jamie Bautista]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 24 Jun 2020 15:01:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-24T15:52:10.355Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*dBFBQ4xj0dULeb0Ul4sVYQ.jpeg" /></figure><h4>And how my friend cast in it made me want to be better</h4><p>In early 2019, a personal project I had been working on for a couple of months that meant a great deal to me had fallen apart. It was my own fault that it had gone wrong. It felt like the start of a recurring theme for 2019 where things I had been geeking over for years were all coming to an end, forcing me to say good-bye. Iron Man died in Avengers Infinity War, ending all cinematic appearances by my favorite character of all time. Many of my favorite series ended or announced their ends, like Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, Game of Thrones, The Good Place, My Little Pony (yes, I’m a brony). Three friends also passed away suddenly in that year, with me not being able to say good-bye to any of them. All that may all seem so trivial in hindsight with the gigantic changes and losses people have had to endure now in crisis and pandemic-stricken 2020, but I think personally I’ve been able to navigate 2020’s major upheavals a lot better because of my own smaller and more personal trials I went through the year before. 2020 actually felt like the outside world had caught up to how I had been feeling inside for the last few months. But by that time, I had a better handle on things. I felt better equipped to ride things out. And I think a lot of it had to do with me watching Beautiful: The Carole King Musical when Atlantis Productions staged in in June of 2019.</p><p>I had heard about Beautiful being performed in Manila because one of my actress friends had been cast in it. And I was honestly super excited to see it because it sounded like a musical that was tailor made for me. I’m an old soul who loves music from the 60s and 70s, so the songs and story of Carole King were stuff I was very familiar with. So when that personal project I was working on collapsed, all the more I wanted to see the play to get my spirits up with a healthy dose of comforting nostalgia. But instead, the play I saw forced me to confront uncomfortable truths about myself and made me look long and hard at the mistakes I had made in my artistic life, especially with that specific personal project. But at the same time, instead of letting me escape my troubles by looking back at a simpler time, it challenged me to look ahead to my future and ask myself just what kind of artist I wanted to be. So yeah, not exactly the easy-going fun time at the theater that I was expecting.</p><p>I won’t go into the specifics of the personal project I was working on, but it was a creative endeavor that involved creating online content. It also involved performances and so I had a collaborator on it who was a performer I had long admired and had worked with on another project before. The reason why this project not working out hit me so hard was because it was my first personally funded and initiated creative project in a long time. It was my first passion project after years of doing graphic design and writing for clients, of publishing and doing the business side of things for other artists. I set aside time and money, I turned down projects, all just to get this going, in the hopes that it would become something big, but if not, at the very least it would be self-sustaining so I could just keep doing it. And for most of the few months I was working on it, it was one of the happiest times I’ve ever had working on a project. It is, to this day, one of the most fun and fulfilling projects I’ve ever worked on. It all started to go south when I started to get anxious about whether it would succeed, about the money, about the public reception of it. It all came to a head when all those anxieties caused me to passive aggressively lash out at my collaborator when she asked if she could miss a scheduled session we had due to health concerns. I took it personally and thought she was just making an excuse to slowly work up to saying she didn’t want to continue with the project.</p><p>(to be continued…)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3cb28a87215d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“The Kundiman Party” was Mean to My Actor Friend]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamiebautista/thekundimanpartyantoinette-fbc67676b8ef?source=rss-7561bcf0826------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fbc67676b8ef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[singing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[acting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[performance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[musical-theater]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[drama]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jamie Bautista]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 26 Oct 2019 11:04:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-10-26T11:04:46.846Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ziVH6F_Bd-os8dn-5ZHpVQ.png" /><figcaption>Teetin Villanueva as Antoinette. Art by the author.</figcaption></figure><p>The script of The Kundiman Party is pretty mean to whoever plays Antoinette, a role my friend Teetin Villanueva played during several shows of the play’s original 2018 run at the University of the Philippines by <em>Dulaang</em> <em>Unibersidad ng Pilipinas</em>.</p><p>For those who haven’t seen the play, it’s about a millennial social media expert named Bobby who convinces his girlfriend, her singing teacher Maestra Adela (a retired opera and kundiman maestra) and the teacher’s friends to create an online video series about the beauty of kundiman that also indirectly protests against the current Philippine government and its use of EJK (extra-judicial killings) and violence. Thus is born what the group calls “The Kundiman Party”.</p><p>While Bobby’s cause is just and admirable, his zeal in fighting against the government (who most likely represents his estranged senator father) starts to becomes almost exploitive. He diminishes and sacrifices the integrity of the art form he is using to simply further his rebellion. He choses buzzwords over artistic subtlety, shock value of a death over decency, and angry rhetoric over artistic meticulousness. Soon, he is willing to sacrifice the safety of the others for his cause. He unwittingly becomes the thing he claims to be fighting against when he tells the maestra that sometimes lives need to be sacrificed for a greater cause. He tries to fight fire with fire, anger with anger, and leaves when he felt kundiman may just be a novelty, that it can’t be used to fight as strongly as he wants to. By the end of the play, I wanted to punch the character of Bobby in the face and wanted to yell at him just how wrong he was going about things.</p><p>The character of his girlfriend, Antoinette, on the other hand, was the character I sympathized with the most. While most of the other characters talked and strongly expressed their points of view, Antoinette was often quiet, the one listening. She was balance. While Bobby stopped college to pursue his passion and join rallies, Antoinette graduated and got a good job as a management trainee while still also finding a way to pursue her love of singing at the same time. She joined Bobby in his fight, while trying to still keep him grounded and mediating when he would go too far in dealing with the others. All she wanted to do was to sing and learn to sing well. The conflict between them came when Bobby showed he didn’t really care about Antoinette’s singing, about actual kundiman, and only for the effect the maestra had on people when she talked about kundiman. And when his father slyly convinced him that using kundiman was not truly fighting right before a live meetup with viewers of their videos, Bobby leaves the group and Antoinette (either to give up and join his father or to go to the mountains where the “real fighting” is). And while Antoinette is heartbroken and the person who started this whole thing is gone, she still sings for the people who come, no matter how few they may be. She doesn’t do it to fight for the sake of fighting. She does it because she loves the art of kundiman. And what I took away from the ending was that kundiman, that art, with its power to draw out emotion, to make people want to love, would in the long run turn the public against the belief that violence and killing is necessary to gain peace and prosperity. Her belief that sticking to something higher: higher values, higher standards, would win out even if it does not spread as fast as anger.</p><p>This may be my interpretation of the play and the characters, but it’s something that inspires and drives me to this day, informing how and why I create art. To say I found this play to be influential would be an understatement.</p><p>The play celebrates the art of kundiman, to make people understand what really good can do when done really well. The script has Antoinette doing most of the singing. And kundiman, from a technical standpoint, is to singing what ballet is to dance. It’s demanding, challenging, and a spectacle for a layperson to behold. It’s doesn’t resonate because it makes you want to sing along. It leaves you in awe because it’s a feat that you know you cannot do, like watching a graceful acrobat do a mid-air flip. And yet kundiman is also meant to be deeply emotional, as its purpose is often to spark strong emotional responses in those who listen to it. It’s why kundiman is often used when a suitor needs to stir feelings in his beloved strong enough to make her have no choice but to act on these feelings.</p><p>And the reason I know this about kundiman is the very same reason the script is <em>mean</em> to whoever plays Antoinette. The masterful script by Floy Quintos has Maestra Adela, (masterfully played by Shamaine Centenera-Buencamino) explain kundiman in eloquent and convincing detail to her pupil Antoinette, gushing about it the way Salieri did about Mozart’s music in the film Amadeus. Not only does she explain kundiman, but Adela describes to Antoinette, and by extension to the audience, what a listener’s reaction to this level of kundiman should be. Adela talks about the audience being made to feel pity by kundiman done right, made to feel yearning and desire, to make them stop in their tracks or even be pulled in towards the singer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BRCdZkO3clO537Q70xmVsQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Teetin Villanueva as Antoinette, Shamaine Centenera-Buencamino as Maestra Adela, with Farley Asuncion on piano as Ludwig. Photo by Vlad Gonzales</figcaption></figure><p>And that’s why the script puts so much pressure on the actress playing Antoinette. Her singing has to accomplish exactly what Maestra Adela has just described. She has to make the audience feel exactly what Adela has said they should feel when they hear Antoinette sing, otherwise it would undermine the point the story is trying to make. It’s the equivalent of a baseball batter or a pool player calling out their shot before making it. Most other scripts do this when the artform being described is either an already completed masterpiece, like Mozart’s music in Amadeus, or when they won’t show the audience what is being described as it couldn’t possibly live up to the build-up, like the painting that drives the story of the film “Ang Larawan”. But The Kundiman Party doesn’t back down from this challenge, nor does it allow whoever plays Antoinette to. And the actress for Antoinette needs to do this <em>live</em>, with no edits, redos, or lip syncing.</p><p>Also, the play isn’t a musical where characters sing out dialogue that would be perceived as spoken in the story’s world. The music is diagetic, meaning all the singing done by the characters happen in the world of the play, are heard by the characters as music, and are organic parts of the story. So the singing has to be authentic. Two other characters also sing, but their songs are there for comic relief. Antoinette does most of the singing in this play and her songs don’t have comedy as a crutch or safety net. The songs are meant to work in-story with the actual character singing, yet also work on a deeper level. Kundiman is essential to the theme of the story; how it uses emotion and beauty to stir the soul in contrast to the anger utilized by both sides of the political spectrum. And the theme only works if the singing of these kundiman songs are done exceptionally well.</p><p>It’s an ambitious and ballsy move by the script to really make audiences fall in love with kundiman, but it lays an seemingly unfair amount of pressure on whoever plays Antoinette. It’s a tough role and I have huge respect for all those who have played it.</p><p>When my wife Iyay and I watched Teetin play Antoinette, I have to admit I felt a bit nervous for Teetin at first. A few days before I got to watch the show, Teetin had mentioned to me that she was doubting herself because of how different singing kundiman was compared to her usual style or singing. And I’ll confess when she told me that, I didn’t quite understand why kundiman would be so difficult to do. But when that starting scene played out with her and Ma’am Shamaine, I realized how high the stakes of this role was. It was a bit like breathlessly watching a tightrope walker walk fifty feet in the air, hoping she could hit all those impossibly high notes that couldn’t simply be belted out while also hitting those emotional targets Shamaine’s superb elocution was laying out within the audience.</p><p>I didn’t need to worry at all.</p><p>Teetin’s very versatile and has done all kinds of different roles which is one reason why I’m always eager to see what she performs in next. I’ve heard her sing before in all types of shows, like a cabaret where she sang as an unlucky-in-love velociraptor and a cartoon troll, a Filipino superhero musical ballet (Ballet Philippines’ “Manhid”), a broadway hit where she sings in a British accent (Atlantis Theatrical’s run of “Matilda”), and a Filipino children’s play (PETA’s “Tagu-Taguan, Nasaan ang Buwan”, where, strangely enough, her character also had a British accent). I know she sings really well and I was expecting her to sing really well here. And even given that, I was still not prepared for how amazing she was at singing kundiman.</p><p>Her singing is what opens the show, the lights first coming on to reveal her already singing a kundiman song, and right off the bat I was stunned by how beautiful kundiman sounded and how skillfully Teetin was pulling it off, singing high notes with a restrained vibratto that made it both exhilarating yet tender. You know P.T. Barnum’s stunned expression when he hears Jenny Lind sing for the first time in the film The Greatest Showman? That was pretty much my expression.</p><p>Then Shamiane, as Adela, interrupts and says that while her singing was technically clear, the emotion wasn’t clear yet. Shamaine then builds up kundiman and its intended effect as I mentioned earlier. So this first song was not even supposed to be kundiman at its highest level yet! Teetin, as Antionette, sings again, and this time the emotional goals have been set, Adela has called for a home run over the west bleachers. And Teetin hits it out of the park. I’m not quite sure what it was exactly, but some subtle yet powerful touches she put in her second rendition made quite a difference. Maybe it was little things like how she would pull back her voice just a teensy bit during some notes as if to hint at a sigh. Or how she would change how soft or how slowly she would sing certain words, to give some more weight than others. Perhaps it was little added physical ticks like how her fingers trembled a bit more when she gestured this second time, or how her eyes would squint a bit tighter as she hit the more emotional beats of the song. Unlike a typical Filipino pop song or dramatic performance where more emotion means louder belting or shouting or bigger crying, this was an understated yet stirring performance. There was a restrained and controlled power, as if immense feelings were being held back and just seeping out, barely being contained. Her singing’s subdued beauty perfectly brings out the emotions kundiman is suited for: yearning, desire, empathy. After all, one does not yell or belt out a declaration of love to the object of their affection, at least not if they hope to get the reaction they are hoping for.</p><p>Teetin would then have to sing kundiman in various other emotional contexts throughout the story. At one point, she has to fake not hitting a note. Another part has her barely able to sing, with immense sadness overwhelming the technical necessities of kundiman. One pivotal scene has Antoinette singing to her soon-to-be boyfriend Bobby, causing him to finally ask her to be his girlfriend. Each song had a different balance of emotional and technical clarity. And I found myself reacting strongly and unconsciously each time she sang. When Antoinette had Bobby pulled in with her song, I found myself unintentionally leaning forward as well as I listened and watched. When she sang after Adela gave her impassioned speech about the death of one of the side characters, I found myself gripping my wife’s arm a bit tighter, as if the song was reminding me to hold on to the one I love while I could. And I remember distinctly that when Teetin would finish a song, the reaction wasn’t immediate applause like when the hilarious comedic songs were done by Jenny Jamora and Rica Nepomuceno. Whenever Teetin would finish a kundiman song, I would find myself frozen, still silently staring and leaning in to listen, not quite ready for the song to finish and not yet quite fully believing that I had heard something so mesmerizing. The rest of the audience also appeared silently stunned. It takes a few seconds for my brain, and the rest of the audiences’ I imagine, to register that the song is over and only then after a few seconds does loud and deserved applause suddenly erupt. To me, that was the figurative eight ball in the corner pocket Adela had called earlier for the song to sink.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*72btf5qHTB2bdrx1AKERAw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Teetin as Antoinette. Photo by Vlad Gonzales.</figcaption></figure><p>The role of Antoinette doesn’t have as many lines or big speeches as the other characters, as she is meant to be the point-of-view character for the audience. She is the one the other characters say their speeches to and whose soul they are fighting over with their philosophies. So Antoinette is there to react and listen mostly. But yet there is an eagerness to please, a sincerity behind the lines she does have and her expressions that frames how we as an audience are supposed to take in all these ideas thrown at us. And when Antoinette sings, the audience then becomes aware of her as a separate character and that is where she processes all the things given to her by the others.</p><p>Yes, the role of Antoinette is tough and that’s why I have to give Teetin and the other two actresses who have also played the role my highest admiration. Considering I saw the play three times, the perceived “meanness” of the script towards that role was apparently the right move, as it elevated the story since the performers were all up to the challenge.</p><p>Teetin captures that eagerness and that vulnerability so well when she acts and it frames her song numbers perfectly, giving the right emotional context that makes her songs all the more powerful. When her heart breaks on stage, your heart breaks for her as you see real tears drip down her cheeks. When she declares her love for singing, you believe it. You can see it all comes from somewhere real. Teetin is someone, like Antoinette, who also made hard decisions moving away from a “safe” major (medicine) and instead shifted to her passion for theater. She also experienced heartbreak and hasn’t shied away from using her art for socially aware causes, even when it was difficult for her to do. It was almost as if she was born to play this role.</p><p>Other actors who have played Antoinette have done a great job as well. I saw another performance of the play in 2019 with another actress playing the role. But I have to say after watching that run, it made me realize that no one will ever be The Kundiman Party’s Antoinette to me other than Teetin.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*l0GPLmRTbKI5iw99gnVMQw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Antoinette and Adela. Photo by Vlad Gonzales.</figcaption></figure><p>The Kundiman Party <em>told</em> me why I had to fall in love with kundiman. But Teetin’s performance is what <em>actually</em> made me fall in love with it.</p><p>I do hope that won’t be the last time she gets to perform that role.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fbc67676b8ef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[CHAROT! Ambitiously Shows Why Discussing Politics Should Be A Laughing Matter]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamiebautista/charot-ambitiously-shows-why-discussing-politics-should-be-a-laughing-matter-ded9fbf2055d?source=rss-7561bcf0826------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ded9fbf2055d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[theater]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[federalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philippines]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jamie Bautista]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 05 Mar 2019 11:13:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2019-03-12T03:59:34.384Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/540/1*bjPPVYNbQCXgUJPGtsCmEw@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Philippine Educational Theater Association’s (PETA) politically-themed musical comedy CHAROT! is the most ambitious play I’ve seen in a long time. I’m not joking. And in a political atmosphere that feels so angry with people yelling at each other and nobody listening, we need this kind of ambition.</p><p>This production is so ambitious because it wants to balance seemingly opposing goals that are difficult enough to achieve on their own.</p><p>It’s a play that aims to tackle complex serious issues by using accessible and broad comedy. It’s a play that wants to be objective by presenting both sides of an issue as impartially as possible (to the point of letting the audience decide the ending), while simultaneously taking a strong stand and having a clear perspective. It’s a play that tries to be as clear and concise as possible in teaching something to make sure it doesn’t go over the audience’s heads, while at the same time being subtle and layered in a way that rewards viewers who put in the extra effort to dig deeper into the story. It’s a play that introduces new songs and music to expound on its themes and story to engage its audience without relying on nostalgia or the familiar. It’s a play that doesn’t just try to use digital technology and social media, it allows them to shape its story. Most importantly to me, it’s a play that attempts to speak to all sides of the political spectrum without insulting or disrespecting them.</p><p>Does it achieve <strong>all</strong> these ambitious goals it sets for itself? Not quite, and that is to be expected from any ambitious endeavor (anything that succeeds at all its goals with its first try was probably setting the bar too low). But most what is lacking in the play are more untapped potential and missed opportunities than actual flaws. And the goals it does hit, it hits them so hard I swear I could feel the foundations of activist and political theater rumble.</p><blockquote><strong>It’s a play that attempts to speak to all sides of the political spectrum without insulting or disrespecting them.</strong></blockquote><p>CHAROT! (a Filipino expression that means “Just kidding!”) tells the story of a group of people from different walks of life and political leanings, stranded in traffic (and an electrified flood) all trying to get to a polling station before the end of the voting period on election day set in the near future of 2020 in the alternate universe version of our country called P.I. They are to vote whether or not to implement the CHARter Of Togetherness (or CHAROT).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rODTQL45FW_X3XONKgQTBA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>I’ll admit that I’m often wary of productions that tackle political or social issues. It’s because usually they are so explicit and one-sided and I can’t imagine anyone from the other side of the debate or even people who are undecided ever having their minds changed by these stories. They tend to preach to the converted. Even PETA’s brilliant Game of Trolls made me feel this way, even if I enjoyed the heck out of it when I saw it in 2017. So I was prepared to simply enjoy the comedy of CHAROT! and not think too much about its political goals. Sure, it promoted itself as offering a fair and objective view on the topic of Federalism, just in time for the elections in May 2019. But I was doubtful they could achieve it. After all, how can one make a compelling story without taking a stance? It would most likely either seem biased for taking a stance or appear weak for not having a voice. But the more I think back to the story of CHAROT! the more I appreciate it and that impresses me.</p><p>How does it cleverly manage to somehow be objective while taking a strong stance? It does so by being objective on the subject of federalism, while taking a strong stance on other issues: those of voter responsibility and on charter change. As advertised, the play explains federalism fairly and gives pros and cons for both sides of the argument about it. Yet the play takes a firm stance on voter responsibility. Its message isn’t really about federalism, but that as a voter you owe it to your country and to future generations to educate yourself on topics like federalism and not vote simply based on your political affiliations. The play doesn’t say federalism is good or bad, but instead demonstrates how immoral politicians can sway you when you give up your ability to think critically or gain knowledge about an issue. That is the brilliant approach this play has taken, by using an issue that should be politically neutral and using it as an example to make a strong statement for educated voting. When I teach writing, I tell people there is a difference between a subject and a theme. A subject is simply a topic. A theme requires you to make a value judgement about a subject. And a good story needs to have a theme. What CHAROT! has done is use federalism as a subject to explore its theme of telling people to use critical thinking when voting. The subject of federalism allows for the objective exploration and discussion. But the theme provides the throughline that focuses all the narrative threads needed to make a compelling story. It’s simply a well-conceived structure.</p><blockquote>A theme requires you to make a value judgement about a subject. And a good story needs to have a theme. What CHAROT! has done is use federalism as a subject to explore its theme of telling people to use critical thinking when voting.</blockquote><p>Of course, the story could still end up seeming one-sided and still only preach to the choir if it ended up making fun or demonizing one side of the political spectrum. The danger of having a theme is that making a value judgement risks offending those who don’t share that judgement. And honestly I felt the videos showed before the actual play started framed the play as if it was going to make fun of supporters of the current administration, since it showed parody versions of their candidates as well as the president. It’s a shame if any potential audience members were turned off by that because the play itself was very fair in treating all political views. In fact, some of the most endearing and relatable characters were those who were supporters of the analog of President Duterte and who remained supporters even at the end of the story. None of the main characters were vilified or shown to be misguided due to their political stance. This was a play that came the closest I to what I have always wanted to see: a play that treated people of different political views with respect in order to open them up to conversing with each other to consider new ideas.</p><p>Yet even if the play is only seen by one side of the political spectrum (and hopefully it will not be limited that way) I would not consider it preaching to the converted. The play’s message of not voting simply by political leanings but by critical thinking is an important one to tell even to those who share the same political beliefs.</p><p>In short, its theme isn’t “federalism good” or “federalism bad”. Its theme is “voting should mean critical thinking”.</p><blockquote>This was a play that came the closest I to what I have always wanted to see: a play that treated people of different political views with respect in order to open them up to conversing with each other to consider new ideas.</blockquote><p>The play breaks into two main acts. At the start of the second act, the characters are split into two groups, with each one having a proponent who is for or against “CHAROT” (the analog for charter change) trying to convince the group on how to vote. The characters read out the pros and cons and voice various concerns people might (or should) have. The backdrop shows fun yet informative animations that illustrate the points being made. A valid criticism that could be made on this part is that the play ends up being more “tell” than “show”, opting to simply feed the audience facts rather than dramatize them. This portion of the play honestly feels more like an episode of Schoolhouse Rock or Sineskwela. But I think the show can be forgiven this since after all, this is a production by the Philippine <strong>EDUCATIONAL</strong> Theater Association, so I can hardly blame them for coming off a bit like a teacher in some segments. Art is often a balancing act between clarity and persuasion, with too clear messages possibly being boring to watch and persuasive and artistic executions being too subtle or vague to understand for most audiences. Since the goal of the story is to have the audience know as much as they can about federalism both for the play (since we could vote on CHAROT too via a web app they can access on their phones that will affect the ending of the play) and for real life voting, opting for clarity while sacrificing some artistry is understandable. Fliers with facts about federalism were even handed out to the audience members to help them retain these facts even after the show. So here, PETA managed to fulfill the “educational” part of their name and their promise to present an objective view of federalism.</p><p>And yet, this decision to go for clarity at the start of the second act did not mean the play itself was had no artistry in the way it talked about federalism. Far from it. In fact, the play was already showing the pros, cons, and issues regarding federalism from the very first act in the crazy and hilarious interactions of all the main characters. For some, it may have looked like the first act was pure comedy meant to entertain and act as a warm-up for the more serious discussion on federalism later. But really, the antics of the characters as they fought, argued, made friends, and tried to get out of the crazy situation they were in was a clever artistic representation of the issue of federalism.</p><p>For one, the play is a true ensemble piece with a very strong cast. Even other PETA shows with large casts like Rak of Aegis or Game of Trolls had clear main protagonists. In CHAROT!, every character had equal focus in the story, each with their own character arcs. While many may think each character represented a sector of society if you take the play as allegory, looking deeper, the different characters actually symbolize the different regions and communities in the Philippines. It isn’t a one-to-one symbolism like one would do in an allegory. It’s more of applicability, where we can apply an idea to these characters and plots. The story works on many levels.</p><p>All the characters have different personalities, different quirks, different levels of wealth, different political leanings, and different motivations. They’re a lot like the different regions in the Philippines that are all so different, vary greatly in wealth, and lean different ways politically. The way the characters interact with each other, the dynamics between them, are not only the heart of the show and what give it so much life, they also perfectly encapsulate the different issues regarding federalism. There is a scene where only one character has secretly has stashed a little food while every one else is starving from being stranded for hours. She offer to share it secretly with another character from a similar social standing, but when they are discovered, arguments break out and hijinks ensues. You then have characters exclaiming that they are leaving others out, some declaring they deserve things, others complaining about taking advantage of the generosity of others. This hilarious scene where people are fighting about snacks though to me symbolize the inequality of resources and wealth among the regions. It shows why federalism is being considered at all. Later on, the different characters are forced to compete with each other in a beauty pageant-like talent competition to fight for a right to be rescued in a vehicle with limited space. Again, this could be a dramatization of the competition the different regions would have to go through by themselves to attract foreign or corporate investments if the country goes federal. There is a part where one character manages to buy all snacks from another, showing what could happen if federalism happens and one region simply has more resources, connections, and infrastructure than the others. You have a character who keeps trying to give ideas, but is often ignored. This could show why some regions want independence since they feel ignored by the rest of the country.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*i-TGVbUgoKo91Zyl_BhszA@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>The audience votes on the fates of Millennial Boy (CJ Navato) and Millennial Girl (Teetin Villanueva)</figcaption></figure><p>The endings of the two acts also show both sides of the argument on federalism. The first act has the cast split apart, which allows them to achieve their goal of reaching the precinct. This feels like making a case for federalism. The second act, however, has them working together as one group and achieving the goals of voting and helping one of their members. And this feels like an argument towards staying unitary. The list of scenes that could be symbolic could go on and on. Again, it’s like the pros and cons and the possible outcomes are shown through the actions of the characters. The story is not allegory so it does not give easy answers. It presents ideas that make you think and try to make your own connections.</p><p>This technique truly works because of the stellar performances of the cast. Because it is such an ensemble piece each actor must be able to have their character stand out and not be drowned out by the others, or the metaphor of the cast representing the diverse country breaks down. And every one of the actors does so. Each one is given their chance to shine and all of them take full advantage of it. The audience ends up laughing with and then caring for each of these characters. We care about what happens to them because the performers bring these characters to vivid life.</p><p>Then act two comes and they present us with the hard facts about federalism and voting. Then the audience should put two-and-two together and think to themselves, “Oh! That thing about state independence is like that scene between those characters” or “Ah! What they mentioned about foreign ownership could be related to that scene I laughed at in act one!”. The clarity of the facts in act two give the audience the opportunity to unlock the meaning behind the artistry and persuasive storytelling of act one, and it all clicks together. The structure of the play is very ambitious.</p><p>Even the interactive part of the play shows how the play is structured. The first decision the audience is asked to make is one about the characters. The second one is about the issue of CHAROT/Charter Change. By giving the audience full control of the ending and to make their own statement about federalism and charter change, it underlines the fact that the story’s relevance and theme isn’t about those things. Its true theme is that the audience needs to think, to look at all the facts, to make intelligent connections between these facts and the real people they see around them. The true theme of the play is that you are being given the chance to affect characters you’ve come to care about. Don’t mess it up by not thinking it through.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YvX9Rd8j6Nz2GokFFSNdiA@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Voting happening live for the final decision on whether to pass CHAROT!</figcaption></figure><p>This is how you use comedy to teach about federalism in an intelligent way, and not (definitely not) by using cheap “pepe and dede” jokes.</p><p>Even the use of catchy original music with lyrics serving the story fits in with the theme. Unlike many of the more famous local musicals where nostalgia and the comfort of familiarity is used to attract the audience, CHAROT! invites the audience to listen to something new, to consider the idea brought about by lyrics that serve the story rather than a story crafted to fit familiar lyrics. Critical thinking means opening yourself up to new ideas and experiences and part of the ambition of CHAROT! is daring to invite and entice people to add to their musical tastes and not simply go for songs they already know they like. Fortunately, the cast’s amazing vocals paired with the memorable music is up to the task (“Aabot din ‘yan!”)</p><p>Activist and political theater is brave because it dares to yell out truth in the face of power. I find that CHAROT! is even more brave because it dares to spread truth via positivity and laughter when everyone is trying to gain power through anger and outrage. Just as the country is trying to figure out whether we should split up into different states or stick together as one unitary country, this play itself is exploring if we can make change come about more by pushing hard for one side of an issue, or trying to find ways to get people of different mindsets to come together. That’s ambition. And that’s the kind of ambition I hope to see in more works of art. I hope more productions take notes from what CHAROT! is attempting here.</p><blockquote>Activist and political theater is brave because it dares to yell out truth in the face of power. I find that CHAROT! is even more brave because it dares to spread truth via positivity and laughter when everyone is trying to gain power through anger and outrage.</blockquote><p>I have been wary about being involved in political discussions or activities in the past few years, mainly because it always seemed so toxic, so angry. I have a relative who claimed he had to take on a rather “asshole-like” and combative persona online because that was the only way to further his political cause. So I wondered if there was a way to discuss important political and social issues without resorting to being angry, without disrespecting people you disagree with. Is there a way to use positivity, empathy, and maybe even laughter to bring about change? It’s something I try to explore now in my own art as I slowly try to dip into social issues again. And CHAROT! is a refreshing and inspiring sign that discussing politics can still be fun, affirming, yet also effective and intellectually challenging at the same time. It gives me hope.</p><p>Are you going into this play only expecting a fun time, as I initially did, where you just leave your brain at the door? Well, I have one thing to say to you: CHAROT! :-)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*_MfYmYyRmkp0QbAfiScFsA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ded9fbf2055d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Desaparesidos” Proves Theater is the Most Visceral Way to Relive the Horrors of Martial Law]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jamiebautista/desaparesidos-proves-theater-is-the-most-visceral-way-to-relive-the-horrors-of-martial-law-fc12a40a6e7f?source=rss-7561bcf0826------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fc12a40a6e7f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[theatre-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[human-rights]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philippines]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[martial-law]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theatre]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jamie Bautista]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Aug 2018 17:15:52 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-05T16:30:18.352Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kfeHlTfEi6Dm2kq4YFaD_Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>THE MARTIAL LAW BABY</p><p>I’m a Martial Law Baby. I’m part of the generation that was old enough to be alive when Martial Law was still in place, yet too young to truly understand what it was all about. If you were to ask many middle to upper class members of my generation, many of them would say the reason they hated Marcos back in the day was because he got rid of Voltes V. I would bet many of the people saying they remember the times of the dictator as “not being that bad” are from my generation, children whose parents did their best to shield them from the horrors and harsh realities of the time. You’d think that I would be different, considering my family was inescapably tied to the politics of the day. But I’ll admit that while my parents told me about the dictatorship, explained why they had to go to these rallies that were too dangerous for my sister and I to join, my memories of the mid-80s were really those of a child. I remember my mom handing me a Masters of the Universe Wind Raider toy, telling me it was from my Ninang Ballsy who just arrived from Boston after living there for years. At the time, I didn’t know the story of why she and her mom, my Lola Cory, had returned to the Philippines, or that her dad Ninoy had just been shot days earlier. All my 8-year-old self knew was He-Man had a new vehicle thanks to a ninang from the U.S. I remember learning to sing “Tie A Yellow Ribbon” since my parents kept playing the cassette, and then being made to sing the song at what I thought was some type of program, which later on turned out to be a small rally. And before the rallies, and helping in the campaign, and being at EDSA for Lola Cory’s presidential inauguration at Club Filipino, I honestly don’t remember my parents ever talking to me about Martial Law or how dangerous times were back then. Even though the government took away my grandfather’s company, even though my mom introduced my dad to Ninoy while the latter was still in prison, these were stories I would only learn about when I was much older. And even now, I know I was sheltered and it’s honestly hard for me, even with my family background, to fully appreciate what Martial Law was like. So while there is a fight to bring awareness of these times to Millennials who only know of them as history, I believe there must be a bigger effort to get many from my generation who see those years as their youth to look past their own memories and experiences and realize there were horrible thing going on in the country.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*GKgarzQ2hJp2-IZuLQPI1Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>My sister Camille and I in the presence of two future presidents.</strong></figcaption></figure><p>This is why it is so important and it is so encouraging that so many artists in various fields are discussing the era of Martial Law, exploring the themes of using fear and violence to enforce power, and trying to prevent history from being wrongly revised. Just in the first two weeks of August 2018, I saw a film and two plays that dealt with the Martial Law era, and they weren’t the only ones showing at the time either. Each production covered a different aspect of the era, using different perspectives and they have helped to create a multi-faceted view of the Martial Law era in my mind. But of all the movies and theatrical shows I’ve seen so far, I’ve found one to have left the most visceral impact on me, that really made me feel as if I was one of the survivors of those dark times, and not the ignorantly blissful child I actually was back then. That show was the 2018 production of Desaparesidos.</p><p>THE POWER OF WHAT IS ABSENT</p><p>Produced by Renante Bustamante, Jenny Jamora, and Kalil Almonte, directed and adapted by Guelan Luarca from the novel by Lualhati Bautista, Desaparesidos is a Filipino play that tells the story of rebels during the time of Martial Law and what happened to them and the people connected to them decades after. I’ll admit that I had never read the original novel (having only read Bautista’s Dekada ’70 in college) so I didn’t quite know what to expect. Scratch that, I actually did have some idea of what to expect, since it was the third Martial Law themed production I was seeing that month. Of course we would be shown people being chased, arrested, tortured, and killed by government forces. In the lobby outside, a few helpful sheets of paper mounted on a pole warn the audience that there would be loud but safe gunshot sounds during the show. So I expected there to be depictions of violence meant to drive home the point that the time of Martial Law was not a safe time and one that should not be forgotten. But what I did not expect was how hard these depictions would hit me. After all, I had recently watched a fantastic film that also showed the true story of rebels during Martial Law, shot on actual locations and fully realized sets with effects and makeup. How could a stage play match that? And Desaparesidos was not even a big scale production like the Martial Law set muscial I had also seen that month which had fancy sets and props. Desaparesidos was being staged at the Doreen Black Box in Arete in Ateneo where the stage was just a simple raised box at the center of the theater. Save for news clippings and charts hanging in the upper walls behind the audience, there was no set or backdrop save for darkness. The actors did not even have a backstage to retreat to between scenes, they only had misdirection and dark aisles between the audience seats. And yet, that bare minimalism is precisely what helped Desaparesidos deliver the most visceral and effective representation of how awful it was to have been a victim of Martial Law atrocities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ql-NCsn1HqUEfrqhIYFE-Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>The stage inside the Doreen Black Box</strong></figcaption></figure><p>I’m a comic book writer, and I was amazed by how many of the principles and techniques we use in our medium were brilliantly utilized by director Guelan Luarca in his production. Author Scott McCloud in his book “Understanding Comics” calls comics “the invisible art” because he believes in comics what isn’t shown is more important than what is. He calls this concept “closure”, where the audience is shown a part of something, and their minds simply fill in the gaps to imagine the whole. Aside from efficiency, the added benefit is that the audience becomes a participant in the art, contributing more to it with their imagination. And this concept of closure is exactly what Desaparesidos executes masterfully. By not having any sets and only one or two carefully selected props to provide a visual hint of the setting, the audience are the ones who build the environment of the scene with their imagination. And the settings they create in their minds are more realistic and detailed than any backdrop the best set designer can build, and are more personally resonant and familiar than any place even the best location scout can find.</p><blockquote>“By not having any sets and only one or two carefully selected props to provide a visual hint of the setting, the audience are the ones who build the environment of the scene with their imagination.”</blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*7Wq-967LKj6t3mwgqXE7Fw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Ana and Karla.</strong> Photo by Irvin Arenas</figcaption></figure><p>I think back to the play and I can still see very vividly in my mind the peaceful village where the rebel Ana left her baby in the care of the young expectant mother Karla. I can clearly see every stone, every house, looking like small provincial towns I’ve been to myself in the past. But the actual scene in the play had nothing behind the actors except audience members across the room and the black wall behind them. I can see the dingy cells where Ana and another rebel, Roy, were held, having imagined them to look like prisons I’ve visited before, with the textures of the walls and bars sharp in my memory, even though during the play there was nothing on the stage other than a spotlight and a hanging hose that doubled as an electrical torture wire.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*aF8g0Noi0W7NLWteOxCBcQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Roy being tortured. </strong>Photo by Irvin Arenas</figcaption></figure><p>Aside from the sets, some of the actual horrific acts of the story are not even shown on stage. Talking to Renante after the show, I learned that a lot of the more graphic content of the play was toned down to allow it to be shown to young audiences and students. So many potentially disturbing scenes were done in artistic ways that merely implied how horrific they were. The clearest example of this is the scene where Ana aka Ka Leila, played with convincing intensity by Chic San Agustin-De Guzman, is raped by prison guards.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*01tXmjc7qS9b9nClcL3i5w.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Ana / Ka Leila.</strong> Photo by Irvin Arenas</figcaption></figure><p>In the story, Ana is led out of her cell by a guard, so for this scene Chic is lead out to the theater itself and into the lobby, with the door left open. The audience then hears her unbearable cries of pain and anguish from outside the theater, while on stage articles of clothing that are identical to what Chic was wearing are tossed on stage one after the other. Finally, the scene mercifully ends with Ana/Chic, now wearing nothing but her underwear, crawling painfully back up on stage to get dressed, tears flowing down her eyes. I later learned that earlier versions of the play actually showed the rape on stage, but I would argue that not showing it actually made the scene more powerful and more disturbing. The same goes for others scenes of characters being killed, or the village that sheltered the rebels being raided, with only scared voices, angry yells from soldiers, and sounds of gunshots guiding the audience’s imaginations. What makes those scenes more effective even if they are less graphic than they could have been is that the audience is given the responsibility to fill in the details. So a character that is killed or raped off-stage in a way goes through that horrifying experience hundreds of times; one for each member of the audience watching that imagines the details differently. And I’ll bet what each person imagined was tailor-fit to their own fears and thus more horrifying to them than anything any director or performer could show on stage. The audience, in a way, is made complicit in the what happens in those scenes. The audience cannot help but have a strong reaction to the production since they are participants in its creation and not simply viewers.</p><blockquote>“So a character that is killed or raped off-stage in a way goes through that horrifying experience hundreds of times; one for each member of the audience watching that imagines the details differently.”</blockquote><p>Another principle used by comics that this play also adopted is that of focus via minimalism. Scott McCloud suggests that many indie comics print in single color partly due to economic reasons, but also because it makes the stories and the characters stand out more, and seem more bold due to the stark contrast in the black and white artwork. There are no fancy coloring effects for the artwork to hide behind. Similarly, the lack of sets, the sparing use of props, and the very simple costume designs put all the focus on the actors and their performances. Surrounded by negative space, there is nothing to diffuse the attention on the performers, their nuanced actions, and their emotional delivery of dialogue from one of the country’s best writers. And the stellar cast of this production, with many of them playing multiple roles, deliver in spades. Desaparesidos is all about how those who are missing, who are not there, ironically are the ones who occupy every waking thought of their loved ones. It’s only fitting that the play embodies that by using techniques of absence to highlight this theme of people going missing.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*hmaiGBdOLrd9x-tmi9zotQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Photo by Irivn Arenas</figcaption></figure><p>THE POWER OF WHAT IS RIGHT IN FRONT OF YOU</p><p>Desaparesidos’ success in recreating the horrors of the human rights abuses of the past do not only rely on what it leaves out. It also uses theater’s unique qualities of being live and intimate to produce an experience other media such as film or prose simply cannot. Having the performers and thus the characters right in front of us, in the flesh, their emotions laid bare before us, knowing the exact gestures, actions, and line deliveries may never be exactly replicated again, that makes our connection with these people and what they go through more real than any other medium. This is especially true in the Doreen Black Box, a relatively small theater where even in the last row, the faces of every actor is clear as can be.</p><p>Even the sound effects of this production takes the intimacy of theater to the next level. Most of the sound effects are not pre-recorded or delivered via speaker. There is a full foley stage (like the ones used by old style radio stations with all types of sound props and instruments) behind the audience creating everything from the rumbling of thunder to the ear piercing gunshots. The sounds feel real. Some coming from the foley artists in the back, others from the actors themselves who aren’t in a particular scene but are instead seated in the aisles among the audience, creating sound effects right beside them. Perhaps the most unsettling use of this technique is when soldiers are taunting the prisoners Roy and Lito. Instead of actors yelling from backstage, the actors playing the soldiers yell from seats within the audience. The effect is not only that of voices that sound right beside you, but it almost feels like it’s the audience itself taunting the victims. It feels like by simply watching, by doing nothing but observe, we are again made complicit and are almost as bad as these guards reveling in the suffering of another person.</p><p>During some of the more tense scenes, I found myself often putting my fingers into my ears as I anticipated gunshots or acts of violence. That’s how I deal with suspense in movies and I don’t remember ever having that type of reaction from a play before. Yet compared to the times when I would do that while watching suspenseful movies, this time I felt like there was no escape. <br> Blocking out the sound seemed less effective in shielding me from my anxiety as I could physically feel the actors running around in a panic in the darkened stage before me, my mind racing as it uncontrollably generated gory details of each self-muted scene.</p><p>But what really drove home the reality of the experiences being depicted here was not something that was part of the play itself. After the show I watched concluded, there was a feedback session (a new trend in theater abroad that aims to let the audience participate in the development and evolution of plays in this new world of digital connectedness) where the audience was asked to give their comments on the play or to ask questions. What made this feedback session special was that the speakers brought on stage were not the actors or the director or writer of the play. Instead, they brought on Ms. Edith Burgos, wife of the founder of the Malaya newspaper and whose son Jonas was abducted by military forces in 2007 for helping farmers (and who has not been seen since). They also brought up from the audience National Artist for Literature Bienvenido Lumbera, who was himself arrested during Martial Law.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*b4eoFYBwZ1FKesTOTCSyxA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Bienvenido Lumbera and Edith Burgos. That’s me in the audience behind Mrs. Burgos. </strong>Photo by Kalil Almonte</figcaption></figure><p>As these two speakers recounted their experiences, their real life losses, and then answered questions from the audience, the play grounded itself firmly in reality and history. Watching the play was no longer simply a recreation or representation of history. It brought before the audience a chance to personally interact live with those who were actually part of that history and to listen to their stories first-hand.</p><p>So this dance between the absent and the present, between the audience and the play, it creates an emotional gut punch that other productions covering Martial Law simply cannot match. And the first act of Desaparesidos, set during the Martial Law years, takes full advantage of all the conceptual strengths of the play to make Martial Law babies like me have no choice but to face the harsh realities we were mercifully sheltered from.</p><p>THE AFTERMATH AND THE FEAR</p><p>Most of the intensity of Desaparesidos occurs in the first act, the one set in the Martial Law years. The second act is set many years later and focuses on the toll fighting the so-called good fight has taken on the now retired rebels and on the next generation. It is here where the play’s direction to place focus on the performances of the actors really intensifies the emotional impact of the story. The second act for me was all the more unsettling and emotionally taxing because after feeling like you went through hell with the characters in act one, act two constantly nags you with the question “Was going through all that worth it?” The new characters introduced here, most of them children of the characters from act one, represent the different ways my generation and perhaps the current generation view the struggles of the baby boomers. One of them resents what her parents went through as it has only caused them to be broken and overly protective of her. One of them is curious about it, her own identity and past having huge holes in them due to those days robbing her of a parent. Another is inspired, and wants to reignite the passion of those days and to continue the fight. The play does offer some closure to some of these characters, but it never gives easy answers or moralizes about which perception is the right way to react. But maybe that isn’t what the story is trying to say. There is no right way to react. All we know is that we, that people, are affected by a society that embraces violence, even if that violence seems to be in the past. And it is here where the powerful performances that were occurring live right in front of me, framed by nothing but darkness and a few spotlights, sparked in me powerful feelings of sympathy and empathy.</p><p>But of all the characters in act two, the one I identified with the most was Karla, played by Teetin Villanueva (this being the second play I’ve seen her in this year where <a href="https://medium.com/@jamiebautista/thekundimanpartyantoinette-fbc67676b8ef">she wrecks my heart in a good way with her performance</a>).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*8QhPfmYtozIVFEiaJMMCJA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Karla.</strong> Photo by Irvin Arenas</figcaption></figure><p>Karla as a character is someone who sides with the cause the other main characters, Roy and Ana, are fighting for, but one gets the feeling she doesn’t have it as the driving force of her life. Yes, she agrees with the fight her husband Jinky is a part of and she does what she can to support the group, especially by taking care of Ana’s baby while Ana goes off to fight. But Karla really wants to put her family first. She herself is pregnant and when trouble starts brewing, the first thing she worries about is how her husband will find her. And so later on, it makes sense that she chooses to flee the country when the tides turn against them.</p><p>I don’t know if that’s the right reading of the character, but maybe I see her that way because I’m just projecting myself onto her. With my family, when they talk politics and get involved in national matters, I feel like Karla. Yes, I side with them and agree with them and do what I can to support them, but in my heart I know that if push came to shove, I think I would put my family, my wife, my kids before any abstract idea of country or freedom. I tell people it’s why I would never try to work in government as I would end up making all the wrong decisions under pressure. I see many of my relatives go to serve the country by working in government or protesting wrongs in government. And I have seen the cost it has on them, on their families. It makes me feel ashamed to know I probably wouldn’t have the strength to sacrifice what they have, all the more what true rebels like the characters in Desaparesidos sacrificed. Like Karla did, I thought to myself “Was it all worth it? Haven’t we all paid enough? Can’t we just sit this out now and live a normal life?”</p><p>THE POWER OF EMPATHY…TO FIGHT POWER</p><p>But in the end, I did not only relate to Karla, I was inspired by her. Despite her weaknesses, her understandably human desire to survive and have those close to her survive, when the time came to face the harsh truths, she stepped up. She forgave and understood the person who caused the death of her husband. She risked unravelling the family she had created for herself to bring a truth to light and to make good on a promise kept years earlier. And it turns out she had to make an impossible decision, she made a choice that was for the good of another person, another family, not her own. And I would like to think that if I were put in similar situations as Karla, in the end I would deal with them the way she did.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*Unt-W7Z8RrXXFmLE2rqdAQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Karla’s choice.</strong> Photo by Irvin Arenas</figcaption></figure><p>One of the questions asked of Edith Burgos during the feedback session was what specific things the youth of today could do to continue the fight of past generations, to prevent the sins of the past. She gave one very specific answer. She said that her son was abducted by military men at a restaurant in front of several other people. If only one person had gone to help, to try to stop the military men or called for help, she felt her son may not have disappeared. She then told all of us in the audience that the best thing we can do is to simply help if we see someone needs help.</p><p>That is why this is an important play. That is why we need to experience the theme of this play in such a visceral manner… why I needed to. It may be set in the times of Martial Law and using that historical context, but this play isn’t just about Martial Law. It isn’t political or taking any sides. One of the charts hanging above the row where I was sitting, one of the very few pieces of set decor in the theater, showed the number of reported desaparesidos for each administration.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/213/1*slkQPn76PvvLhfsKRFqswQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>To my surprise, the highest number was during the time of Lola Cory with over 800 cases (though Mrs. Burgos wanted to clarify that the chart only showed reported cases, and the Marcos era actually had over 30,000 victims with most not making any claims or reports). I won’t shield myself from the fact that there were people who continued to practice that even after the dictator was removed, even during the times of Lola Cory and Uncle Noy. Edith Burgos lost her son during President Arroyo’s time, not during Martial Law. The play isn’t asking us to fight against a specific administration or certain people or parties. No, it’s asking us to fight against a culture that allows violence to enforce power. It is human nature to be corrupted by power, to want to keep it when you have it. But it is also human nature to empathize and connect with other people. That is why people who use violence justify it with abstract concepts like security, stability, or progress, while reducing the people affected by violence also into similarly abstract ideas, dehumanizing them. And that is why we need an experience like Desaparesidos to make us connect with the victims of such violence, to not only be told but to be made to feel what they went through until it makes us sick to our stomach and we tell ourselves there is no way we can allow this to happen to another human being. Because only when faced with another real person can we make the hard but correct decision to help them, to save them, no matter the cost to us… as Karla did.</p><blockquote>“The play isn’t asking us to fight against a specific administration or certain people or parties. No, it’s asking us to fight against a culture that allows violence to enforce power.”</blockquote><p>So what should Martial Law Babies like me and millennials do now? Do we fight the same way our parents and grandparents did, especially seeing the toll it took on them? Personally, what I took from watching Desaparesidos is that we need to know and understand what the generations before us went through and why they fought so hard, but then find our own way to fight. Fighting today doesn’t mean going into the mountains with guns to fight against a government or protest against certain people. Instead, I believe we should continue to fight against the culture of violence for power. For one, we must challenge ourselves to sacrifice for others, to care for others. Like Mrs. Burgos asked us, we should help when we see someone needs help. The Philippines is no longer worth killing for, but the Filipino is still worth dying for. And as scared as I may be, I pray when the time comes, I will be up to the task.</p><p>Also, we need to encourage others to care for their fellow Filipinos, to push back against those who would try to sacrifice other people’s dignity or lives for any reason. We need to fight to create a culture that values life and uses empathy. That is why we need people like the team who created Desaparesidos; artists who sacrifice their energy and time and potential earnings to use their talents to constantly create art that promotes this culture of empathy and life. For example, Teetin and producers Jenny and Kalil were all part of the play The Kundiman Party that explored similar themes. Renenate was an actor in Liway, an indie film that also explored the era of Martial Law by looking at the lives of political prisoners. I feel these are people who are revisiting these themes in their choice of work for a reason. This is why I am so glad there are so many artists now that are producing so much art that fills in various roles in creating a new culture of empathy that abhors violence. The three productions I mentioned I watched this August 2018 all played different roles in this. Liway was a film based on a true story that provided visual and historical accuracy. The play Eto Na! Musikal nAPO made the themes more palatable by mixing these themes with nostalgia. But the role of Desaparesidos I feel is important because it is meant to stir the strongest reactions and create empathy powerful enough to overcome apathy, selfishness, and fear. With all these artists and all these works coming at the problem from many angles, I feel hopeful that we will one day create a country, or even a world, where using violence against a person is almost unimaginable and totally unacceptable.</p><blockquote>“The Philippines is no longer worth killing for, but the Filipino is still worth dying for.”</blockquote><p>This is why we need works like Desaparesidos and we need to see more works like it. Maybe then, just as we used our imaginations to create sets to fill in the blank and dark stage around the actors we were connecting with, we will be moved to use our minds and hearts to create the ideal world around the people we see around us.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*6wddNDyYXmdHsyCcpz9Vow.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Malaya, symbolizing a new generation seeking answers.</strong> Photo by Irvin Arenas</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fc12a40a6e7f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>