<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jonah Andrist on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jonah Andrist on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jandrist?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 23:17:58 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jandrist/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[You Can’t Go Home Again]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/you-cant-go-home-again-f01773064d60?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f01773064d60</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[travel]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-improvement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nostalgia]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 14 Aug 2026 21:46:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-26T17:14:19.608Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>And Yet It Seems as if Some Never Leave</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*BuuFE8qQYaFCzu4N" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@bluerug?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Bluerug</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>It is hard to capture the feeling of returning to one’s hometown and the strange disconnection which often drifts through one’s mind. Like a mix between wooziness and revelation, with a dash of nostalgia. Like the taste of a gas station hot dog, the bun gluing to the roof of your mouth.</p><p>The last time I felt it I was home for a few days and, not coincidentally, standing outside a gas station in the shade of its overhang. It was a gas station many in my high school class used to come to for off-campus ‘lunch’ in my senior year. It was merely coincidence, my being outside this gas station — but as I watched the cars pull in and out of parking spots I had that dissociative parenthetical feeling of not belonging where I was. A place I’d been numerous times and yet I felt as if in a foreign country. I have a theory about why my feeling was specifically related to cars, but first you must watch this video of a young bird.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F0nu-AqPuWvQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fshorts%2F0nu-AqPuWvQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F0nu-AqPuWvQ%2Fhq2.jpg&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3b280aaa55e06a1b012dcd7c2afd4048/href">https://medium.com/media/3b280aaa55e06a1b012dcd7c2afd4048/href</a></iframe><p>Just for the sake of not demanding that you <em>have to watch </em>— the video shows a young bird hopping next to a grub with its mouth open. The speculation is — since this is how the bird was fed when it was in the nest by its parents — the bird keeps thinking the grub will leap willingly into its open beak.</p><p>I am going to term this <em>magical</em> <em>thinking</em> and I think we can extrapolate that all of us begin with magical impressions of how the world works. As humans we are even more inept as babies (compared to others in the animal kingdom) and the sheer quantity and diversity of things and actions which can become quasi magical to us is both luxury and chain. It is not terribly uncommon to hear someone in a city presume that, “Walmart will never run out of food.” Most of us having no real input or influence on the true supply chain.</p><p>To return to the cars and my feeling observing them, their magic — I was transported to my youth in this both bitter cold and muggy hot plains where cars were taken for granted as the essential and only means of travel. I had much magical thinking about the CAR. I never really even thought of them as machines — that’s how fundamental to life they seemed. Back home, with my magical thinking gone, it felt strange watching the tires turn in their wheel wells, seeing raggedy looking hub caps and rusty struts and now knowing how much expense it takes for something which felt as necessary as breathing.</p><p>For the past decade I have largely given up daily driving, which probably contributes to the feeling I specifically had watching the cars. But this is only an example, one of many times I’ve felt the inability to be comfortable at home. The times I’ve been reminded that my <em>magical</em> <em>thinking</em> can never return.</p><p>I want to emphasize about magical thinking its connection with nostalgia. Every time I feel this disassociation it is coupled with a light breeze of longing to be able to see the world as I once had. This nostalgia is far from rational but one has to admit, really — how amazing would it be if the grub jumped willingly into our mouths!?</p><p>I had a friend who would often talk forlornly of his inability to sit down to draw and capture the same thrill of creation he had as a child. To say ‘you can’t go home again’ is a lament of deep melancholy, even if one <em>has</em> <em>to</em> know better. To live perpetually in the state of magical thinking would not be as rewarding as the nostalgia suggests. (Starvation is largely regarded as a bad thing.)</p><p>But here I have been talking about a specific type of person like myself. One who felt the demand to move away from home and explore the wider world. What of those who stayed? Who don’t feel nostalgia for the magical thinking but seem to be actively living inside it. Open mouthed.</p><p>Jonah, are you suggesting that these stayers live perpetually in a world of magical thinking? Because that sounds dangerous. It might, even, explain all the ills of society. It would also make you sound like a pretentious asshole.</p><p>While I am ‘sort of’ suggesting that … I think magical thinking is quite a bit more complicated.</p><p>I’m not even sure it’s true that only travelers disabuse themselves of magical thinking and only stayers retain their magical thinking. (Some privileged travelers keep more magical thinking than anyone.) One can have magical thinking on many different fronts. Economically, spiritually, emotionally. I have chosen these three categories arbitrarily, there will be more subsets of these broader categories or even other different broad categories. But for metaphorical simplicity, working with this triad, it strikes me that those who never leave have often retained a level of magical thinking on one of these fronts. Economically, spiritually or emotionally. Which is also to say that about the other two they (probably) <em>have</em> <em>lost</em> their magical thinking.</p><p>I do not suspect that this retention of magical thinking is due to some supreme idiocy, quite the opposite. My guess is the retention of magical thinking in one aspect of our lives is due to a <em>premature</em> hyper development of intelligence in one of the other categories. Losing magical thinking before the brain was ready to understand why. And this hyper development necessitates an ignoring or blase attitude towards the other categories of self. Letting them stay magical out of <em>convenience</em>.</p><p>The most common example, for those who stay, is to become hyper aware economically. Most of us who have the ability to leave were not poor poor. The demands of the psyche to pay attention to their economic environment while young are immediate. Those who lose their magical thinking about keeping their belly full are like the opposite of that young bird. Even while still in the nest they are snapping their beaks closed to be the first to grab the grub.</p><p>I think I was of a slightly rarer type, gaining full sentience of economics much later, and still being of the type who thinks anti-romantically of machines and industrial process (see above my feelings on cars … but also, seriously, how great would it be if the grubs jumped willingly into our mouths!?)</p><p>The trickiest of all these categories is spirituality because the division of retaining and rejecting magical thinking is the opposite of what most people’s intuition suggests.</p><p>Spirituality is what those who lost their magical thinking about economics still retain magical thoughts about. Primarily, that they don’t think about it at all. They treat the spiritual side of themselves like it is unworthy of attention.</p><p><em>To tangle with spirituality is to acknowledge one’s own personal relationship with the unknown.</em></p><p>To retain magical thinking, in this regard, is to presume one never really needs to think about such things. It will all either be revealed in death or nothing will, which amounts to the same thing.</p><p>It has gotten easier and easier to assume that everything needed to know has already been found. Which, to return to the nostalgia aspect of feeling the old presence of magical thinking, is wistful in recalling one’s ignorance. When <em>so</em> <em>much</em> still seemed beautifully unnecessary to know.</p><p>The more you know the less you know, and that’s when you can truly never go home again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f01773064d60" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Non-Psychological Approach to Identity Formation— The Novelist’s Quest]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/a-non-psychological-approach-to-identity-the-novelists-quest-5e341a9ff8ca?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e341a9ff8ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[patrick-melrose]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[novelists]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Jun 2026 19:47:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-08-28T17:06:32.505Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>On Edward St. Aubyn’s <strong>Patrick Melrose</strong> Quintet</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*7D91F3D5WRb9DRPqbCBJ2A.jpeg" /></figure><p>Some writers seem to believe that attracting people to the written word gets more and more hopeless every year. <a href="https://x.com/wself/status/2057911404041302391">Like in this recent article from Will Self</a>, the content of which strikes me as an article which is written every three months by some mediocre thinker trying to gain readership through fear mongering. Self seems to believe everything in the world is vying equally for our attention. His statement could be simplified into: how could books ever compete for the attention of young people compared to the sex and entrancing violence of video games?</p><p>While I must concede that there is a kernel of truth in this statement (I find video games very compelling and addictive), the idea that everything is competing equally for your attention is a misconception formed out of the manufactured financial necessity that the writer should be supported — through sheer popularity — by the masses. A serious novelist is no more competing for the attention of a young person excited about the new video game as <strong>The Symposium</strong> is competing for the same attention of an old person in a nursing home watching reruns of Lawrence Welk. There are obviously going to be people who were never going to be interested in the first place. Video games are not going to steal away the attention of a student who <em>seriously</em> wants to understand the principles of their electrical engineering textbook.</p><p>The burden of explaining to the public why they <em>should</em> <em>be</em> interested is on <em>us,</em> novelists and writers — to tell clearly to the student of physics or biology or computer science what there is to gain from reading fiction. As such, here is my introductory attempt.</p><p>What if the universe is just inside your head? You may say, well, that question is ridiculous. It serves no utilitarian purpose to keep examining it. And yet, since one is haunted by death and the end of consciousness, it is impossible to know for sure one’s knowledge of ultimate truths. It’s Freshman dorm room stuff to sit around with a friend and ponder, “I wonder if you see the same colors I see” but if one bothered to continue to ruminate on said problem — and scientific research has proven that people see less or more of different colors or different shades of the same color — that this problem of <em>perspective</em> runs as deep as human history entire.</p><p>Tolstoy explains, in the introduction to <strong>War and Peace</strong>, that he was developing a new way to tell history. One which, I would argue, tries to account for this tricky notion of perspective. Literature is the battleground where one tries to examine what was being fought for or against in each human heart — to attempt understanding of all perspectives simultaneously, even if we can <em>only</em> fail.</p><p>&lt;&gt;&lt;&gt;&lt;&gt;</p><p>One might even argue in an essay like this — that history is nothing more or less than a parade of identities.</p><p>Although a minor and essentially comic character in the scope of St. Aubyn’s quintet of Patrick Melrose novels, the reader is introduced in the first book <strong>Never</strong> <strong>Mind</strong> to the philosopher Victor Eisen — who I believe sets the fundamental framework for the questions St. Aubyn is exploring. Questions about his own history, family lineage and generational wealth — what such things mean in forming one’s identity.</p><p>Victor is sitting down to write a philosophical work titled, A Non-Psychological Approach to Identity. Later, at a dinner party in the Melrose house in Saint-Nazaire, Victor tries to explain in conversation,</p><blockquote>“I’m not attempting psychoanalysis, an activity, incidentally, which will seem as quaint as medieval map-making when we have an accurate picture of how the brain works.”</blockquote><blockquote>“.. if we are controlled by forces we do not understand, the term for that state of affairs is ignorance. What I object to is that we turn ignorance into an inner landscape and pretend that this allegorical enterprise, which might be harmless or even charming, if it weren’t so expensive and influential, amounts to a science.”</blockquote><p>What is so important about forming a non-psychological framework for identity? Victor’s essential complaint is that the psychological framework doesn’t work. But the novel itself has an even deeper, esoteric challenge for the psychologist (“Pistols at dawn, Mr. Freud!”). How one goes about the business of forming identity is far from clear cut, but the best clues come to us through novels and the challenge of perspective.</p><p>The quote which gives the best clue to <em>his</em> process, and the identity question being explored by St. Aubyn comes in book three <strong>Some Hope</strong>, at the beginning of Chapter 7,</p><blockquote>“Perhaps identity was not a building for which one had to find foundations, but rather a series of impersonations held together by a central intelligence ..”</blockquote><p>This <em>perhaps</em>, this <em>question</em> deserves your rumination. As an aside, as you think about this for one moment, I want to include an anecdote about a child I heard the other day. She was playing pretend influencer. Five years old and flouncing about her yard, playing pretend that the world should like and subscribe. I suggested to her mother, after hearing this anecdote, that she should lean into this impulse and support the child in trying to be an influencer. That way, by the time she was actually a teen, she might roll her eyes at the notion and dismiss it as, ‘something she was doing when she was five.’ But it is likely that no such intervention is necessary. All of us take on such <em>impressions</em> in youth which are later given up. (Or are they? Maybe the unconscious is a series of half forgotten impersonations.)</p><p>We start the journey of identity formation in <strong>Never</strong> <strong>Mind</strong> from the perspective of five year old Patrick. Suffice it to say, Patrick is very seriously abused. And so begins the fragmentation of his perspective, his identity. Or I should say — the modern reader is invited to take his abuse seriously while also witnessing the gross justifications from the perspective of his abuser. After rubbing his erection between Patrick’s buttocks, his father David sits with a bottle of wine and wonders if he, “hadn’t taken his disdain for middle class morality a bit too far.”</p><p>While David is certainly a creep, he is also a stand in for the cultural disintegration/disruption the class consciousness encountered at the start of the 20th Century. David has a scientific mind removed from moral consideration (not unlike what scientists were doing in the discovery of chemical warfare in World War I). And yet David did not invent Mustard Gas — do these <em>relatively</em> small injustices against a little boy compare to the oodles of death and destruction in war? My favorite glimpse by St. Aubyn into his psyche is when David reflects on waiting to maliciously corner one of his dinner guests with an unwanted question,</p><blockquote>“In the pursuit of knowledge, there was no point in killing the rabbit before one found out whether its eyes were allergic to shampoo, or its skin inflamed by mascara. It was ridiculous to ‘break a butterfly upon a wheel’. The proper instrument for a butterfly was a pin.”</blockquote><p>Which is all to say that St. Aubyn represents a full picture of the fractured identity. One whom, from the perspective of the writer, <em>understands</em> the abuser. In book two, <strong>Bad News</strong>, we get the dirty, reckless glimpse of the suicidal splintering which was attempted to deal with this abusive power dynamic. Patrick, now in his early 20’s, is a world class abuser of drugs — the entirety of the novel follows his thoughts while trying to score. Far and away the most intoxicating section of the novel (some readers describe hating it, like intoxication, side effects are included) features Patrick using a needle to shoot cocaine and a cacophony of characters invade his mind. The characters are both pleasure and torture device. Although having gotten sober by the third novel, <strong>Some</strong> <strong>Hope</strong>, Patrick still looks back not unkindly on his “cast of characters” which accompanied the “more dramatic disintegrations.” It is Patrick’s reflection which here I will again repeat with added context.</p><blockquote>“How could he find any firm ground when his identity seemed to begin with disintegration and go on to disintegrate further? .. Perhaps identity was not a building for which one had to find foundations, but rather a series of impersonations held together by a central intelligence, an intelligence that knew the history of the impersonations and eliminated the distinction between action and acting.”</blockquote><p>Later, in book four, <strong>Mother’s</strong> <strong>Milk</strong>, Patrick ponders, “Was there any activity which didn’t freeze into a role?” After all these years, now in his mid 40’s, he still looks more favorably on disintegration than the solid nonsense which might form other’s identities (like his mother’s, for example).</p><p>Now, if one has a more average childhood the drama of disintegration need not be as reckless as Patrick’s — but I think the novel form, in its re-contextualization of perspective, does suggest that examining and dissolving, co-mixing one’s concepts of identity are crucial for self knowledge. Or, if nothing else, the process of reading expands one’s knowledge of the potential impressions and unburdens loneliness at having chosen an identity for unclear reasons. <strong>For having a whole history of identities descend upon us.</strong></p><p>Mostly, I am not a fan of descriptions of clothing in books. But there are undeniable moments, even in one’s own writing, where these descriptions feel absolutely necessary. They explain the pose, the impression the character has of themselves. Likewise, in St. Aubyn’s clear personal experience, the importance of lineage and inheritance dramatically affect the pose people take in the world. I lump these three words together; clothing, lineage and inheritance (although they all might just be a part of the same thing) as clear pieces of the identity puzzle which are <em>non</em>-<em>psychological</em>.</p><p>I want to make the distinction of what aiming for a non-psychological approach <em>means</em>. The novelist is very obviously having a serious conversation with psychology. Patrick’s best friend through his whole life, Johnny Hall — also an ex addict — becomes a child psychologist and the conversations these two have together are among the most thoughtful and sincere reflections on identity one can read anywhere. (One of their conversations over dinner features an all time great line, “what is evil if not sickness celebrating itself?”)</p><p>Which is to say — unlike Victor who sees the failure of psychology to explain the mind in mechanistic terms “(psychology) will look as quaint as medieval map-making” — the novelist is ‘non-psychological’ simply because they are taking a completely different tack. I feel I have over explained, like one of those cryptic modern French philosophers. The novel is non-psychological because it is a novel. It is not the place of the novelist to lob accusations or even theory, but one can hide in plain sight with a character like Victor Eisen who is both right and wrong.</p><p>At this juncture it will be helpful to explain the ‘complete’ approach of identity formation for which Victor was probably aiming. Although it is not technically a new idea, the neuroscientist Robert Sapolsky with his recent book, <strong>Determined</strong>, gives compelling access to the mechanistic argument.</p><p>I encourage you to research his point yourself, but the easiest entry into his argument goes thusly: In the case of people with traumatic brain injuries we allow that the injury is affecting processes of cognition of which the injured has no control. Why should this same logic not apply to the ‘healthy’ mind? Is this exception (traumatic brain injuries) not just a manifestation of the limits of said processes? The malfunction proves the rule. Your frontal lobe and impulse control is formed in childhood almost completely before the age of five. Everything about every decision you make can be traced back to biological programming. The illusion of free will exists simply because these processes are too complex and numerous to observe and categorize completely. Our knowledge of the brain is still like medieval map making, but beginning from this place of humility, perhaps one day we will sketch a more accurate picture.</p><p>I think the novelist can accept all of these claims except for the general conclusion. Certainly there are mechanical aspects to consciousness and free will is, probably, an illusion caused by the immediacy of feeling. However, through observing characters in a novel the reader can note; Patrick <em>mostly</em> feels very un-free, but by acknowledging the constraints of his identity formation — which were sordid and painful — he has the resource of other minds. The difference between a novel and a detailed electron magnetic graph of a brain is like the difference between a map and the territory. Is a map mostly correct? <em>Yes</em>. Even medieval maps were good for the 50 square miles some monks knew intimately. But the territory of mind is more than one mind. Just like a map doesn’t account for vegetation and the feeling of being in a place. Your identity is a series of impersonations. The territory of your free will is how much you are willing to engage with other minds.</p><p>In <strong>Mother’s</strong> <strong>Milk</strong> we are introduced to Patrick’s sons and multiple chapters are written from his eldest Robert’s perspective. Robert thinks to himself, “In the end, it was unfair on everyone being who they were without being able to be anyone else.” It is fitting this note on unfairness coming from the mind of a child. Most notably, because it’s <em>not</em> <em>true.</em> Any adult can notate the variations of themselves through the years. We may not get to be others for long stretches — the disintegration of the ego into pure empathy is a frightening and, thankfully, unlikely circumstance — but for little glimmers one does get to move outside of themselves. What is St. Aubyn doing if not playing with each identity to give a clearer picture of the territory of mind? The framework of the novel allows for the identity to examine itself from a safe distance. (Which is also why the territory is never mapped and requires so much concentration to appreciate. Focusing on details with either a microscope or binoculars.)</p><p>Writing and then reading the last couple sentences of the previous paragraph, I feel as if I have only stated the obvious. Of course this only <em>feels</em> obvious <em>to</em> <em>me</em> after years of reading and reflection — and this point is not <em>obviously</em> why most people read. However, I feel I may have under-examined how difficult it is to achieve this effect in prose and the important place of irony as used by St. Aubyn to highlight this effect of correlated identity examination.</p><p>David Foster Wallace was my generation’s general in a war on irony. And yet it always felt to me that his ‘hyper intentionality’ fell short of clarity. David may have been right to suggest in his criticism of irony that; irony vacated a space — the text — of meaning which it was then <em>incapable</em> of replacing (a concept he borrowed from Kierkegaard). But to empty something of its meaning is a <em>requirement</em> to observe what the meaning meant. Tests are conducted in vacuums. Human beings are addicted to meaning. One might equally find an addiction to irony to counteract the randomness of meaning attachment. Or, to take a ‘non-psychological’ stab at deconstructing who they are and where they are from and what that means.</p><blockquote>“It’s the hardest addiction of all,’ said Patrick. ‘Forget Heroin. Just try giving up irony, that deep down need to mean two things at once, to be in two places at once, not to be there for the catastrophe of a fixed meaning.”</blockquote><p>Both positions (DFW and St. Aubyn) find fault with irony, but it is through Patrick where I finally found my reckoning. Both try to come to terms with addiction (I don’t think any reader of Infinite Jest would find much fault in my suggestion that it is a book haunted by addiction) but there is something about the amorality, the ‘non-psychological’ features of St. Aubyn’s storytelling which destabilize the ego. In pitch perfect mockery of the upper class (“that’s what charm is, bad mouthing everyone else so the person you’re conversing with glows with the feeling of exceptionalism”) we are invited to the absurdities of ego construction through <em>things</em>.</p><p>Not only with characters like his aunt Nancy who is a veritable kleptomaniac and constantly either commenting aloud or thinking mournfully about all the things she might’ve owned, how much generational wealth had been stolen from her. There are philosophical reflections from Patrick. Commenting on his rich uncle Henry’s politics he notes, “Politics are an exciting game but money is sacred.”</p><p>It is through irony where one gets framing to observe the absurdities of the sacred. Self identity being the most sacred deity of all. The novelist invites a reader to speculate on the hidden sacred slowly revealed through character circumstance and decision. How circumstance (like wealth) will effect a person’s attention. Psychology proposes a near limitless set of possible interpretations for explaining how a person came to be. Materialism denies this interpretation entirely, stating every bit of biological code is already written. But science and literature need speculation. There is a need to see another’s thought, to play off said thought. To observe how another person’s being effects one’s own state (the territory of mind).</p><p>The problem with psychology is exposed by St. Aubyn with this line, “The difficulty of being an infant is distinguishing incompetence from malice.” It is only much later into life where one learns the opposite, of ‘not attributing to malice which can be explained by incompetence’. By having a malevolent and malicious father Patrick is able to understand this confusion very viscerally. In psychotherapy one might find many many explanations for internal justification of feeling, but it is only through deconstruction of his parents identities in prose where one feels both incompetence and malice and regret, disillusionment etc etc … all of it simultaneously (or as close as we can get to simultaneous. Obviously if it was truly simultaneous this would explode a nervous system). We get the entire history of humanity which took certain feelings and labeled them as their identities.</p><p>In the final book of the Patrick Melrose series, <strong>At</strong> <strong>Last</strong>, Patrick recounts to his eldest son Robert the feeling of terror being thrown into a pool by his father at three years old without knowing how to swim. Robert responds very sympathetically, knowing how terrible the feeling would be fighting for breath and life. Patrick is touched by his sons empathy for what he assumed to be an insignificant anecdote and even after 800 pages he knows there is still a deep reckoning needed to become free of the (his) history of identities.</p><p>I am inclined to quote too heavily from this last chapter of <strong>At</strong> <strong>Last</strong>, so to overcompensate I will quote sparingly and invite you to read the series for yourself — seeing as here, in my companion piece, I cannot expect to recreate the quiet reckoning of passing through the territory of Patrick’s mind.</p><p>After his mother’s funeral Patrick retreats to his bedsit and has a long think now that both of his parents are dead. He thinks on how much they came to define him and how reactive he became as a person. Working through these thoughts he wonders, “Maybe he could only respond to everything if he experienced it as a question.”</p><p>To live in such a way is no small feat, since asking themselves too many questions is what most people avoid. It is the definition of anxiety in many respects. But worse yet is being stuck in such anxieties — having to live up to some pre-determined definition of who one is and what they’re supposed to be. Trying to not fuck up so much, or, failing to live up to the history of the identities come before. The way out is down into the crevasse. In the words of Patrick’s youngest son which close out the series, “In fact you should change your mind, cause that’s what it’s for.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e341a9ff8ca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Real Problem with the Ultra Wealthy]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/the-real-problem-with-the-ultra-wealthy-80d607587346?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/80d607587346</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[wealth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[money]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Mar 2026 20:33:04 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-19T04:28:40.915Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ycl6NHNBU4zf98pX" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@brooksieg?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Geoff Brooks</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>As <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LxJW7hl8oqM">David Graeber concisely pointed out in terms of thinking about the national debt</a>; the more the government takes on debt, the more money there is in the public sector. Similarly, if there is going to be wealth there will always be some version of the heights of wealth.</p><p>Sometimes, I think about $MONEY$ like how it was used by the Native American peoples on the West Coast thousands of years ago, as shells. It’s far easier to imagine a life where one wasn’t obsessed with collecting shells. But the complexity of things which can now be bought with money has gotten transcendentally more compelling and the appeal of being rich along with it.</p><p>Still, one can put no price tag on love or friendship or pleasure or joy. Daniel Tosh once joked, “Money might not be able to buy happiness, but I’ve never seen anyone frown on a jet-ski.” An accurate observation. But there’s compelling evidence that a walk on the beach is just as good.</p><p>Call those first few paragraphs ‘treating my canvas’, because I want to tell a story. To do that I will have to give a few biographical details about myself.</p><p>My dad grew up in a town of about a thousand in rural North Dakota. We lived in the Metropolis of North Dakota, Fargo, my entire young life. But because of my dad’s upbringing he wanted me and my sister to experience school in a similar way to how he did — small classroom sizes, the ability to be on any sport or extracurricular team we wanted regardless of talent.</p><p>This is how I wound up going to private school.</p><p>Since it is Fargo, and there were only 3 private schools in the area, at that private school I ended up befriending the grandson of one of the richest men in North Dakota (I just looked him up, he’s half a billionaire). I remember having a special sleepover at the grandfather’s house and the house was (and still is) the only house I’ve ever been in where one was capable of getting lost.</p><p>I kept being friends with this other boy because, why not? Though by the time we were in college the drift of interest had already happened where I knew my life was not going to be spent as a business major in pursuit of profit.</p><p>Still, there must have been some residual good feeling or else all his other friends had different plans, because kind of out of the blue my old friend invited me on a skiing vacation where we’d fly to the resort by private plane. I was already on my descent to go stare into the void but still a little too young and stupid to pass up the opportunity.</p><p>I say young and stupid because if I’d known myself better, I would’ve declined the invitation. It was a trip with his father and brother and sister and one of their friends and I was battling serious depressive symptoms. But I’d hid my true feelings from most everyone so I wasn’t concerned, it was just stupid to think I’d have a good time.</p><p>I say all that to not let myself off the hook, to color in the feeling which comes next. I also want to say that this friend’s dad was/is a piece of shit. One day after skiing he drank at least 3 double jack and cokes and with heavy snow falling on curvy mountain roads he barreled the SUV down the mountain cackling like an immortal demon. Cackling with the confidence that even if he crashed it was going to be everyone else’s problem. Although this was influential on my journey to understanding that famous phrase from Jesus Christ, “It is easier for a camel to get through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to get to heaven”, this behavior really made me question their mindset in a much more banal setting.</p><p>The group of us went out for pizza at a little whole in the wall. A quaint spot very common in tourist towns. During dinner a small band set up in the corner and began playing some inoffensive bluegrass music. Although the dad started it, the rest of the table followed his lead, making fun of these local musicians.</p><p>And that was the proverbial straw which broke the camel’s back in my psyche. What were they even doing? Making fun of a local band just trying to play a little music, make a couple people happy? They might not have been the most talented band in the country — and they certainly had very reasonable expectations for their ambitions — but laughing at them and making fun of what they were doing made me realize, despite not being a musician and having no pretenses to it, I was 100x more spiritually inclined towards what those musicians were doing than these entitled kids (including the dad) making fun of them.</p><p>It doesn’t sound that profound, typed out like this. It’s taken me nearly 20 years to learn how to put into words the feeling I had that night — drifting away from the associations which might’ve made my life more profitable but certainly not more <em>rich</em>.</p><p>The real problem with the ultra wealthy (and their associates), is they bring to the conversation a <em>deeply cynical sense of reality</em>.*</p><p>What bothered me most was that I could see things from the wealth perspective. From the point of view of that table in the restaurant — making fun of that little band was <em>correct</em>. These musicians were wasting their time. Playing this music was never going to make them lots of money. It would be hard to even say if anyone in the restaurant appreciated what they were doing.</p><p>I also carry inside me cynical traits, but there is nothing more cynical than wealth which claims the end goal of everything in itself.</p><p>Making fun of those musicians they were implying stupidity, but what would look more stupid than a man sitting on a tremendous pile of seashells claiming to have conquered reality.</p><p>Ultra wealth to most people looks absurd. The people who own yachts and pay a full-time staff to use the boat two weeks a year. Private jets burning fossil fuels for weekend getaways.</p><p>And yet the cynicism of wealth still holds the high ground.</p><p>Whatever can be bought and sold, whatever you can convince people to buy is the only reality.</p><p>I also want to insist that for many of the ultra-wealthy this cynicism is hard won. At every juncture where they succeed and others fail and their prowess keeps reaping dividends because the bottom slop of society just wants conveniences which you find better ways to sell them — at every juncture this cynicism is reinforced.</p><p>It would be impossible for it to be any other way, psychologically. Which is to say; I don’t think having some cynical personalities in the world is inherently a bad thing. The truly pernicious side effect is that the cynic, using the cynical superpowers they have acquired, begins being unable to see the world any other way. And then, because they are salesmen, they <em>sell </em>this viewpoint to society.</p><p><em>The way the rich stay rich is by convincing you the only way to have fun is on a jet-ski</em>. (Italicized to indicate metaphor.)</p><p>So much of what is now pitched as reality is done so through this cynical lens.</p><p>It is now my intent to get fairly rigorous about cynicism because I want to re-assert that this mindset is only a natural outgrowth of the possible psychologies. That isn’t the issue. The issue is the prevalence.</p><p>If any individual psychology (philosophy) took over the entire culture there would be imbalance. One of my <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x4ggu69RPes">favorite philosophy podcasters just did a piece on Pyrrho</a>, the first Greek skeptic, which comes immediately to mind. Skepticism, in its simplest terms, is the removal of all judgment. Even to the point, in this exaggerated case of Pyrrho: Pyrrho was walking by a pond where his mentor was struggling to swim. Pyrrho walked by with complete indifference making no judgment of the situation. He treated his mentor like he would a wild coyote or someone he’d never met. Skepticism removes all claims to reality. Judgment is suspended essentially to the point of indifference.</p><p>And you can easily see how if such a philosophy took over the culture at large there would be consequences.</p><p>The cynicism of the ultra-wealthy in our culture is equally unbalanced and yet we are far more tolerant of it. This is largely due to our (structure’s) dependence on hierarchy and the cynics ability to use their cynicism to claim authority.</p><p>My first order problem with the cynic is that they presume <em>most people are stupid</em>. Even if they are right, which I don’t think they are, the <em>presumption </em>itself is misguided. Just like it would be equally misguided to presume that most people are geniuses.</p><p>That cynical presumption, which is at its grossest and most obvious form in mockery (like I witnessed in the restaurant), is more often hidden under layers of competence demands which have no real claim to necessity. The wealthy just want workers to be better so they can make more money (and not compensate accordingly). That’s it. That’s the whole thing. And increasingly this looks like treating people from the get-go like they’re dummies.</p><h3>AI as the Ultimate Instantiation of Cynicism</h3><p>What could be more cynical than a system which cuts humans out of the process entirely? Which suggests, through the nature of its processes, humans are too stupid to figure out how to fix their own problems. (Which are so often created by them in the first place.)</p><p>People talk and write a lot about AI these days, so I really don’t want to belabor this point. I mostly have this new section bold and big as a signpost that we’re already in the end times of how deeply cynicism has pervaded the culture. (Of course there are more interesting and complex takes on capitalism and AI. Like Nick Land’s notion that as soon as capital came into being it had its own drives to transcend humanity. At least in such a take we’re all the dummies, including the billionaires.)</p><p>I could expand on this point with AI and relate my own skeptical attitude, but it is not my goal here to prove that AI or cynicism is ineffective. Wealth is very <em>effective</em>. <em>Too effective</em>.</p><p>Wealth can make simple pleasures; simpler ways of life look <em>worthy </em>of mockery. Or unworthy of aspiration.</p><p>It’s strange for me to look back and realize what a formative experience that small trip was for me. I went back to my little room and full on into books and novels and understanding the life of the mind. The pleasures of an artistic life. I dropped out of school to pursue this even more seriously.</p><p>And even if I never make another dime from my writing I know I get to spend my life not as a cynic. Which is its own reward.</p><p>*For anyone paying close attention it should be clear from the tone of the article I am using the word cynicism in its colloquial sense. Not so much in realtion to the classic Greek philosopher Diogenes who was cynical about all things human … though, there is still crossover.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=80d607587346" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What a (Literary)Agent Wants]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/what-a-literary-agent-wants-4c3128d36064?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4c3128d36064</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[publishing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Feb 2026 06:54:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-27T18:56:02.494Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*f9YKYiFrf1iespEy" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@dakhmedd?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Diana Akhmedova</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>If you will please harken your imagination back to the early iterations of internet blogs and imagine music auto-playing as you open up this link.</p><p>The song — What a Girl Wants, Christina Aguilera.</p><p>I don’t want to actually link to the music, I just wanted to create a vibe. A tone for this blog entry. This is nothing more or less than a bitch sesh.</p><p>My aunt recently ‘beat’ a very serious cancer diagnosis. This immunotherapy stuff is getting really good. If I should link anything it should be to the immunologist <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_P._Allison">James P. Allison</a> talking in conversation with Sean Carroll — an interesting talk which I absorbed .5% of. Anyway ..</p><p>I am staying in my little sister’s basement after bumbling my way through finding a way to live a writing life and failing continuously. Today is my 37th birthday and for the last two years I have made no income as I spent my time diligently writing a novel with plot for ‘commercial’ consumption.</p><p>As a celebration for feeling better my aunt flew out to the west coast to hang with my sister as they are quite close. I should say, as background now — my aunt spent her adult life as a children’s entertainer. She wrote eight albums of original music. She made most of her money traveling by van, regionally, (the upper midwest) and putting on small performances.</p><p>I’m no expert, but in terms of children’s music, it’s hard to imagine there’s anything much better on the market than what my aunt made. I’d often asked her if she regretted not doing more to expand her reach. Like, for example, reaching out to agents or managers. I even have her response in writing,</p><blockquote>“The music…I never understood why making 200 kids happy wasn’t as good as making 2000 happy. When it comes down to it, it never was a goal of mine to make lots of money. I was good with “enough”. My addiction of choice was the joy children and I created together. A place where no one had to feel less-than — the grown up equivalent of that fear of not measuring up to someone else’s standards. Just let it go, blissful, no thinking, no judgement, just being in the moment. Forty five minutes at a time. There were a lot of 45 minute therapy sessions over 30 years — is it even possible to have regret after that?”</blockquote><p>Still, over dinner and drinks one night while she was here, she asked how my own process with reaching out (querying) was going and I responded the only way one would. Awful. Horrible. And she nodded and laughed. And then I asked, in return, how much she had tried.</p><p>“Oh, not much, really.” She said, looking towards the table and rubbing the back of her neck. Which I took to mean she had barely ever, like a handful of times … but maybe it was more times than she was proud of, since she did seem to ultimately find all of the TRUE pleasure available in the activity and the weak moments where she’d wanted MORE seemed slightly embarrassing, now.</p><p>But there is one more reading of this exchange, and it is how I feel while doing it. Querying agents makes me feel bad.</p><p>I think this might come down to my people pleasing tendencies. Many (if not <em>every)</em> agents now list pretty specific desires they have for a book they would like to try and sell. Reading through their preferences one might wonder if the only way to truly please would be to find an agent’s preferences and write a book to their desired specifications.</p><p>But working that way would not result in good literature. It would be like using AI to crank out hundreds of procedurally generated works hoping there’s enough material to fit every niche of interest. This is already being done, as far as I understand. (At least one woman I’ve heard about uses a variety of AI models to compose hundreds of romance novels and made 6 figures doing so.)</p><p>By the by, I don’t even think this is necessarily a bad way to go about the process of selection. I can almost understand the inclination. The most prolific readers dig through mountains of genre for the feelings and characters they want. To titillate their plot orgasm reflex. I have done the same with pornography. If a pornographer suddenly decided they were an artist, I, like everyone, would roll my eyes.</p><p>Am I not my own niche? I’ve written this before but I’ll write it again. I have never met anyone (and never will meet anyone) who precisely shares my interests in books. Where and how do publishers and agents get the confidence that their interests coincide with public interest?</p><p>The only way is to get pop generic, like Christina Aguilera (or whatever old white guy really wrote the lyrics to What a Girl Wants). A girl wants love and presents and a cute dinner (I’m not actually going to listen to the song, it’s thematic, this is close enough).</p><p>These are not the only things a girl wants. Most of us don’t know what the hell we want. I remember reading some years ago the collected letters of Willa Cather where she repeats what has always seemed like the truth.</p><p>In order for your book to be good, or more importantly, interesting, people can’t know that they wanted it.</p><p>Surprise is one of the principal pleasures. This seems so obvious to me I cannot understand how this one factor is so frequently overlooked.</p><p>Not only overlooked, considered (essentially) irrelevant. Again, I mostly understand, because the competence of direction made necessary by the mind to qualify a judgement as a skill doesn’t account for what — to somebody else — might be a pleasant surprise. It is more honest for an agent to say exactly what they like, so a submitting author sees precisely for whom they can pleasantly surprise through competent A to B precision. (I have no doubts one difficulty of my own is how quickly my mind goes lateral. A to D, without showing my work.)</p><p>But for me, a reader might be anybody or nobody. I can’t imagine any of my favorite authors knowing precisely who their books would be for — other than taking for granted a certain level of education and curiosity.</p><p>Are we so deep into capitalistic specialization there’s too much stuff which exists in the category of knowing you will like it? Or, is it capitalism’s <em>ultimate unrealistic ideal </em>to make you keep wanting some version of perfect story you’re never going to get?</p><p>In any case I regret making you have to read the above last couple paragraphs because what I should really be doing is using my <strong>I </strong>statements.</p><p>I have realized that being a writer means being a feeler. I am a professional feeler. Not like a therapist who categorizes feeling. A pure feeler who thinks about their feelings, all the time.</p><p>This is a bit of a departure from what I thought, at the beginning, the little pleasures and demands of being a writer would be. Namely, having control of my own little world. I had to learn how to sit down and feel so someone else might feel something while reading.</p><p>Thoughts are not so different from feelings. They are different words primarily for semantic purpose. Every feeling might not be a thought, but every thought is also a feeling. Nietzsche claimed he never trusted a thought he had when he wasn’t walking. That, to me, sounds like a pretty clear cut condition of feeling. In his case, freedom. The free range of thought.</p><p>It’s not so easy to think about your feelings all the time, to examine each and every thought. Especially when you open yourself up to rejection. You’re going to be feeling rejection, a lot.</p><p>Which brings me back to my aunt and the desire to not try. Reminds me of the words on Bukowski’s grave, Don’t Try. I get why. The world that wants you to try is like an Incan God King who demands sacrifice.</p><p>I am a secularist. My aunt had the benefit of local performance. Even still I will go one step further than she did above, on the point of difference between making 200 kids happy or 2000 … There’s no difference to me between making zero people happy and 2000. When I really look at it, emotionally.</p><p>My ideal reader would walk up and say, “Man I really liked this one part of your book which made me think about this ..” and go off on their own completely separate tangent.</p><p>The ideal I <em>feel</em>, as a reader, is the amount of curiosity a text can bring out in me.</p><p><em>And how can you have curiosity if you already know what you want?</em></p><p>I have the impression about life that most people are interesting but have sacrificed being as such in favor of being agreeable. And most of those who <em>try </em>to be interesting (instead of not trying, as suggested by Bukowski) really aren’t, and have only known what it is to pretend.</p><p>But this is not another Salingerian screed about the fakers and phonies. I think there is value in pretense. Pretense is the first step in being freed of the burden of being agreeable. Where this fails is when the pretense demands validation. I think this is the step for which the agent is the gatekeeper. But gatekeepers, more than many many other roles, can get too focused on their capacities of discernment. Now, one is the best gatekeeper for this kind of person, the other for another … and I must insist I don’t think they’re wrong, but I think it’s easy to lose the concept for why the gate existed in the first place. Taking a step back to acknowledge that it’s all a pretense. Any gate is pretense that the place behind is somehow inherently more magical.</p><p>Both writers and agents are culpable to this system. It’s hard to remember what one originally wanted, standing in line. Waiting for the gatekeeper.</p><p>I turn to the words of Mary Oliver,</p><p>“And this is what I learned: that the world’s otherness is antidote to confusion, that standing within this otherness — the beauty and the mystery of the world, out in the fields or deep inside books — can re-dignify the worst-stung heart.</p><p>Sometimes the desire to be lost again, as long ago, comes over me like a vapor.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4c3128d36064" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Disappointed by This Is Where The Serpent Lives]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/disappointed-by-this-is-where-the-serpent-lives-168fe5029b3e?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/168fe5029b3e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[book-review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Jan 2026 19:04:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-01-21T19:04:48.472Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3HSuOi8FBgkPQokDvi81oQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>Expectation truly is a thief of joy.</p><p>Despite knowing this, distinctly, I had pre-ordered Daniyal Mueenuddin’s (DM) first novel with excitement. Excitement based solely on the strength of his book of short stories <strong>In Other Rooms, Other Wonders</strong>. He had released no fiction since this work in 2009 which received much acclaim, rightfully so.</p><p><a href="https://podbay.fm/p/the-new-yorker-fiction/e/1554134400">If you are unfamiliar here is a reading of the first story <strong>Nawabdin Electrician </strong>from the New Yorker Fiction Podcast</a>.</p><p><strong>In Other Rooms </strong>was a series of stories which felt (to me) like the author had something to say. This looks glib, written as a sentence, because so many <em>feel </em>like they have something to say and humans are endlessly talking and of those talking each really does have their own story — but it is the writer who captures stories which are not their own and still renders them with deep empathy and beauty which usually marks out an intelligence which <em>really does have something to say</em> about the world or reality writ large.</p><p>Mueenuddin’s second story, <strong>Saleema, </strong>particularly gave me that impression. It will do enough to explain that it is about a young, essentially indentured servant girl. About as far removed an experience as one can get from a privileged land holding young man from Pakistan who graduated from Yale Law, as Mueenuddin did.</p><p>Although, with hindsight being 20/20, one might’ve suspected weak points in style for the transfer of talent in short story writing to the novel format. By far the weakest story in <strong>In Other Rooms</strong> is when DM turns prose on his own experience. As many words as a novel needs, one is going to have to use their own experience. And unfortunately for <strong>This Is Where The Serpent Lives</strong>, much of the story revolves around characters of this privileged, landholding type.</p><p>The novel is unwilling to take any risks whatsoever and it made me wonder if the success achieved by the short stories was the perfection of the illusion taught by MFA programs. Short, to the point sentences. Which help build momentum in short format because information must be expressed concisely. These sentences in longer works seem to lack any poetry, any passion. And the local, sociological and temporal concerns, when stretched out — feel rather meandering and pointless.</p><p>No one is paying me, I have no obligations for professionalism so I’ll admit I DNF’d TIWTSL. There was nothing to keep me involved. This is a cheap shot without explanations so I will expand.</p><p>The moment I stopped completely is where DM turns his attention to a young Pakistani’s discovery of masturbation. I had flashbacks to the awful slog that was Joshua Cohen’s <strong>Book of Numbers</strong>. It’s not that such masturbatory material would be impossible to make compelling, but damn near and you better have good reason for its thematic importance.</p><p>At best it made me think of Kumail Nanjiani’s first stand up special where he talks about getting a porn tape stuck in the family VCR during a power outage and embarrassingly having to take the now broken tape player to a repair man after desperately trying to remove the tape. But that story had a punch line — it happened so often the repair man looks at him with weary eyes and tells the young boy to bring it to him first, next time.</p><p>Which is to say this is heavily traveled ground and without a punch line feels closer to rambling.</p><p>I might venture to include quotes from TIWTSL but nothing quotable stood out.</p><p>The peak of my engagement was a story within the larger story (whatever that is, I quit before any clarity on that point). A story about two brothers who go out on a camping trip with a girlfriend and the girlfriend kisses the other brother. Again I found my mind wandering. I started thinking about stories within stories and 1001 Nights.</p><p>One might think that even with high expectations there would be enough words and space in a novel where glimmers of brilliance would <em>have to </em>shine through. Perhaps that is a naive view for why people write, especially at a certain level of success — and I have to admit my expectations were aligned with what other great writers of the past have done. In a nearly twenty-year break between published works (longer than Joyce took to write his moonshot,<strong> Finnegan’s Wake</strong>), knowing the publisher will release whatever you write regardless — take a big swing. Bleed, as Hemingway framed writing, melodramatically.</p><p>But DM is a Yale graduate, it was naive to not presume he would play it safe against the weight of other’s expectations.</p><p>The true crime of colonialism is how firmly it has rooted the idea of possession in the human soul. Despite many pushes to the contrary hierarchies are taken as a given. <strong>This Is Where The Serpent Lives </strong>feels like it has as much curiosity or insight into such things as your average romance novel.</p><p>When (mostly) not writing DM manages a large farm in Pakistan. It is good he has such work to return to. But instead of continuing to try and land liver shots against a man who I’m sure is a very kind employer and person — perhaps the reader will indulge some speculation about disappointment, more generally.</p><p>The older I get the more remarkable it seems to me that any artist ever makes it through. Every motion of life wants to sum up and simplify. Encourages “genrefication”. My personal favorite summation of art comes from James Baldwin, “Art finds the questions which have been buried by answers.”</p><p>Another quotation which I pulled from an early 90’s New Yorker magazine article goes, “The arts are the field on which we place our own dreams, thoughts and desires alongside those of others so that solitudes can meet. To their joy sometimes, or to their surprise, and sometimes to their disgust.”</p><p>In this case, my ultimate disappointment is to feel none of these, not even disgust. TIWTSL is a book which never asks a question. Perhaps certain kinds of readers who want answers and only answers will find the book a pleasant stroll through the countryside of Pakistan. But I thought my traveling companion was going to be a much better conversationalist than he turned out to be.</p><p>Shame on me?</p><p>(As a final note it is a <em>remarkable </em>achievement to produce even one great book in one’s life. <strong>In Other Rooms</strong> is such a book.)</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=168fe5029b3e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Truly Drunken Night]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/a-truly-drunken-night-4cd86c484163?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4cd86c484163</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[drinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 06 Jan 2026 21:28:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-28T17:09:13.234Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*kSzoO-PAJkS5mCg-" /><figcaption>Roughly how many beers were drunk.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Part 1 — </strong><a href="https://medium.com/@jandrist/notes-on-a-devils-threesome-085d05adf688">Notes on a Devil’s Threesome</a></p><p>I don’t think it’s true there are only a couple individuals one might love in their entire life. What I do think is true; there are only a few situations in life where, through circumstance and necessity, the <em>situation</em> produces the alchemy of love. A natural flow wherein one gets to be completely themselves and then gets to wonder, yet further, who the other person really is and find out.</p><p>The same is true of friendships. And as an adult I had (have?) trouble differentiating the intensity of such a friendship from love. I do not want to be a celebrity but I understand the impulse on one front — I’d be okay with a lot of people loving me. To feel a thousand different situations, metaphorically.</p><p>We’d had a threesome and the only thing left to know was if there was anything just between us.</p><p>I didn’t understand the night in this way at the time, but there’s no other way to describe it. After a couple years seeing each other on a near daily basis we were to have our first date. The final test if he was gonna get something more out of me and if I was gonna get something more out of him.</p><p>I want to include a picture of us to lead off this story, it’s easy to post such things on the internet, but no picture exists. Neither of us had smartphones or cameras and in any case were not spiritually inclined.</p><p>Indigenous superstition about photographs is essentially correct. They might not steal a person’s soul but they definitely steal the soul of a moment. On this we were aligned.</p><p>For some reason he was staying in a hotel in a town 40 minutes away. He was bad with money so he’d given me a chunk to watch over and we were gonna make a night of it. Tie one on. Why we were both drunks was different, but we had both absorbed the romantic recklessness of the drunken writers who went plowing through their psyches, looking hubris in the face and tying it around their necks like Hemingway’s kerchief. This, to me, is the definition of tying one on.</p><p>Since there is no picture perhaps I should sketch us both. It is not in my instinct to do so, I have resisted mirrors for most of my life and I am bad at describing myself. Looking, now, I have large kind of misshapen ears, a rounded knob in my neck from leaning over a keyboard, glasses (stylish) and an unkempt beard. He is mostly clean shaven, nothing much more than stubble. He is tall and thin, at least before the next couple years where the beer gut finally catches up with him. But then we are still young. He is not even 30 and realistically handsome. Almost like a movie star but too average. I am not yet 33 (I know this because my Jesus year was very strange indeed).</p><p>We met at a hotel bar. Not his hotel the one next door. It’s a strip of hotels next to the small river with five foot falls, just enough in this barren stretch of country to name the town. The hotels are primarily used as a pit stop for foreign bus travelers on their way to bump elbows in the now crowded Yellowstone Park. But this time of year the large bar is mostly empty and the hotel lobby seems cavernous for no good reason. From here we can walk into downtown and through the whole thing in half an hour. But for the moment we have our first couple beers in this hotel bar with big windows that look out to the walkway along the river.</p><p>There is an ugly guy setting up for sad karaoke and he talks to my friend about how he sells molly or he’s a deputy sheriff and just arrested somebody for selling it or both.</p><p>I am not quite paying attention. I don’t know what we’re doing here. Often I feel this way around my friend, I get anxious at the chaos he invites and then finally he convinces me to let everything go and I have a good time. I do let everything go and his chaos becomes my ballast.</p><p>But that moment has not yet come. That will take a few more drinks.</p><p>It is boring to describe a series of bars, so I will skip to our drunken dinner, hours later. The Indian restaurant nearing close and it now very much feels like a date. He is ordering drunkenly and like a suspicious girlfriend I am questioning his appetites. I am also trying to keep him quiet and decent to the waiter but at every turn of annoyance I’m also laughing. He is my favorite kind of humor. Willfully stupid. With little moments of brilliance. We have a running joke about how when we first met I thought, of the things he said, 10% were brilliant and that percentage keeps lowering and lowering. By this point he’s down to about 2 ½% but it doesn’t really matter it never did because it’s the laughter which brings me back, not the brilliance.</p><p>He has a bright, high, reckless laugh. And he’s happy when he makes me laugh. He had a strange relationship with his mother. His dad was always traveling for work and she was sick in bed and it was his job to keep her spirits up. I wont be the first or last to point out how comedians are often damaged people, clawing for their own sanity by keeping others amused and I wont let myself off the hook by saying I didn’t, in some sense, take advantage of that tendency. But our connection was also stranger. Growing up in sparsely populated, cold northern states. We’d traveled to common places and met in nowhere Idaho by complete chance. The alchemy, like I was talking about at the beginning.</p><p>You ever look at a dog sitting next to you on the couch and they’ve got soft gentle eyes, but then you’ll take them out on a walk and their eyes look crazed and nervous? He bounced between those energies and I was his rock. The thing between himself and a hard place he kept bouncing between.</p><p>Looking back to Greek society, it’s strange how homosexuality became related to degeneracy (blame the Christians, obviously). It has been good that in my lifetime gay marriage has been legalized and my saying it’s good is very far from brave. However, the truth of the matter, for me is; homosexuality <em>is</em> degeneracy. Which is to say, interesting. My basic sexual inclinations are prosaic. The sexual act in its most literal form is my favorite, by default. But it is everything else which attracts my intellectual curiosity.</p><p>By way of example — this very story. How many times did I get drunk and have sex with my girlfriend of that time? It would be impossible to count. And yet I am not writing those stories. They seem not interesting enough to write about. It is the truly drunken abandon of this night which still lingers with my curiosity.</p><p>The first real feeling of the eternal feminine waking inside me. The side of love which is entirely about personalities. Most women do not like to hear the following point — that male objectification of their bodies is biologically <em>useful</em>. I completely understand. For lack of a better word it’s … neanderthal. But I have to say, if men were as picky about personality as women — nobody would be fucking nobody. A woman has a cycle, if a man had the same type of cycle how often would pure desire overlap? Don’t take this point too seriously I just wanted to say I finally felt how the attraction to personality might <em>overcome</em> every other obstacle. The primary obstacle being I am not, by default, attracted to men.</p><p>Maybe there is some other thing which is awoken by drunkenness. A floundering and bombastic need for connection. The only way to know if someone truly likes the depths of your psyche is if they put their mouth on your genitals.</p><p>After dinner we went to the towns only bikini dancing bar. My friend is more interested in regaling the bartender with stories than the dancers. The place is the size of a postage stamp. One of the dancers comes off the stage and starts talking with me. I am the guardian of our nights monies and my friend asks for cash for more beer which I hand over and the dancer with sharp mean eyes drags me to a different table. She interrogates me about why I will give my friend money but not give her any. A strange confrontational question. But I peel out five bucks of singles which she snaps away like she had already done me a great favor and I walk away feeling confused about all transactions (and what women really want from me, more generally). It’s time to move our drinking elsewhere.</p><p>A couple more bars and at least one very large boot of beer later and we’re finishing the drinking hours at the classiest bar downtown. It is still full. There has been some kind of political meeting. I have that strange “last call” sobriety where everything in the universe seems completely clear. Unrememberable clarity, trivialities are in detail because you don’t have to be on guard of the sky. My friend is talking with a drunk but clean cut guy in a suit among these other suited men and ladies in tight but not too tight skirts. This guy is looking at my friend, hungry. The curious eyes of someone who has a beautiful plate of food put in front of them but they’re not quite sure what the meal is made of. Perhaps it all begins here — a type of jealousy or pride that he’s all mine.</p><p>We walk back to the hotel joking about this guy, wondering if he’s gay or what.</p><p>Back in the hotel we’re menaces to sleeping society. On the main floor there’s a pool table and we’re playing and joking and then out of nowhere the same guy from the bar is there. He calls us wild and his curious and hungry eyes keep lingering*. Finally we tease or ignore him enough where he leaves and we go up to the double bedroom.</p><p>I wonder how we still had so much energy. If I had been alone I would’ve turned on the TV and passed out immediately. But we lie on our separate beds and it feels wrong. This buildup of intimacy and then this separation. I am the one to make the first move. From my bed to his. His flaccid cock is 3 times the size of my flaccid cock. I have had women hold my member in their hands just to hold it. Literally stating they are not trying to start anything. And it is this same impulse I feel. To hold a power totem. Perhaps absorb some of the power, or perhaps it’s a gentler feeling, to hold a man in your hand. There’s no such thing as power, feel how soft and fragile it all is.</p><p>He is resistant to my advance because he is a romantic and my goal is esoteric. I remember next we’re standing maybe dancing to music. He says to me, “You’re a fucking faggot you know that?”</p><p>And then kisses me on the mouth and we kiss for a moment even though kissing doesn’t do much for me and then he shoves me backwards and I fall onto the bed and laugh with glee. The power is there but it’s not trying to hurt me. Maybe even loves me.</p><p>Oscar Wilde once noted, “Everything in the world is about sex, except for sex. Which is about power.” It is not a quote meant to be understood as categorically true. It is a poetic rediscovery of the word <em>power</em>. A human being knows nothing of raw energy. It is impossible for the nerve endings to sense even a fraction of the heat from the sun. It is our own power about which the word refers. To make someone fall into your grasp and then hold them, gently. The power of love is to give in, too. Thinking about love suddenly the world is unpredictable again. That’s why lovers need the power, power means predictability and predictability is comfortable.</p><p>The love is ruined the next morning with a catastrophic hangover and my cruelty. It is noon and some man is banging on the door. My friend says it’s fine just put the bolt on the door but I slink to the parking lot to go feel woozy in my car. Finally my friend comes out and we get drive through food and even a french fry makes me want to vomit. I claim maybe I got some of his gonorrhea in my stomach — as a joke to acknowledge the strangeness of the evening but I can tell he is hurt. My head is pounding too much to be kind. I feel nothing about my cruelty, the other consequences are too distracting.</p><p>We barely discuss this night. We stay in regular contact for a few more years but write off the moment. Just a truly drunken night.</p><p>*We will later discover his picture in the paper, the man at the bar and back at the hotel with hungry eyes. He was a State Senator. Now ousted and disgraced for a sexual impropriety with a young female intern. Seeing this neither of us is surprised. What’s surprising is how he hid those hungry eyes at all.</p><p>This feels a tonally strange place to end this piece since I doubt any reader scrolled to the end to read this further detail at the point it is noted and are only seeing it now. Which makes me question why it was an important detail at all.</p><p>It is in reference to the situation. Can I say with any clarity no sexual thing would’ve happened between me and my Cassidy without this interaction? No, I cannot. But these situational influences have much more sway on life than is classically given. I would like to stress that point. Especially to those believers in true love. Not to strip them of the illusion out of meanness — perhaps I am replacing that illusion with another wherein situations have <em>too much </em>importance.</p><p>I believe in personalities. Every girlfriend I’ve had has had an ex-boyfriend who was a heroin addict, so … I know that says something about me.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4cd86c484163" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Death of Immortality]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/the-death-of-immortality-82c95ec8769b?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/82c95ec8769b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[equality]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 02 Sep 2025 18:27:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-12-05T22:15:04.879Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Passages from Milan Kundera’s Novel: <strong>Immortality and The Most Prescient Question for the 21st Century’s Literary Landscape</strong></h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*bp6FDe_a_XQH2m2CKrZUxA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I think there’s a distinction between books which are, “Do yourself a favor and read this” and “I like this”.</p><p>The books that are in the “do yourself a favor” camp are miracles. Which is to say; the miracles only exist in the mind of the person who witnessed them and are not easily transferable to anyone else.</p><p>Which is also to say; then what books deserve to be read? How does one know which books will do them the most good? Most eschew this difficult question entirely and focus on popularity. Popular things must be popular for a reason (a sentiment, to its credit, which is sometimes true). The formula for most writers (who would like to perform miracles) then becomes to turn out a book people like or gains enough popularity to sustain some kind of career and “hope” that; in there, somewhere, are the ingredients for a miracle.</p><p>What I have described above is not the thought process when one starts writing. The impulse is simpler. To take away the onus of bad bosses and physical labor in favor of pursuing their imagination and creativity. Freedom through art. There’s also the ego’s appeal to greatness. What springs to mind is a conversation I once had with a postal worker who really wanted to publish his fantasy book because he wanted a book signing. Many of us are smart enough to hide these fantasies under demure or intellectualized rationale, but he told me straight out. What he wanted from publishing a book was to sit behind a table and smile as others approached him and smiled and told him how great he was. Who could blame him, it sounds nice.</p><p>What I am trying to get at is: there’s a lot of reasons to want to do art. As such, there’s a lot of people who try. Like, a lot a lot. Publishers are inundated with queries. Since I’ve been writing I’ve never submitted a story to a magazine which, when I’ve seen the stats, has had less than a thousand other submissions. Examining those numbers critically, I couldn’t be upset about being or not being published. In the froth, who could even differentiate? Pick one that is easy to read and make it popular. Marketing is the more understandable course of action.</p><p>Still, there are those pesky miracles. Do we really need them anymore? Can’t we just make stuff people like and call it a day? There’s more than enough of us out here. The works of the old masters are still there for instruction. Maybe it’s time we did away with the superstition. It was always just mortality; the miracles were illusions. Like we killed God, maybe it’s also time to kill the idea of the immortal artist.</p><p>The first work I encountered which seemed to tackle this nagging thought problem I had was Milan Kundera’s 1991 novel <strong>Immortality</strong>. And more specifically, the closing section, <em>The Celebration (</em>a spiritual precursor to his final novel with his best title <strong>The Festival of Insignificance</strong>). I have a quote from this last section memorized and would often repeat it to try and start conversation on this topic which obsessed me. I was always met with blank stares. I’m finally taking this article as an opportunity to explain more in depth through context in the novel why I think Kundera’s insight is perhaps the most prescient question for the 21st Century’s literary landscape. I need to include two pages, the quote I repeat will be (anti)italicized. The “I” speaking is Kundera as narrator.</p><blockquote>We started to talk about all sorts of things. Avenarius referred a few more times to my novels, which he had not read, and so provoked Paul to make a remark whose rudeness astonished me: “I don’t read novels. Memoirs are much more amusing and instructive for me. Or biographies. Recently I’ve been reading books about Salinger, Rodin, and the loves of Franz Kafka. And a marvelous biography of Hemingway. What a fraud. What a liar. What a megalomaniac.” Paul laughed happily. “What an impotent. What a sadist. What a macho. What an erotomaniac. What a misogynist.”</blockquote><blockquote>“If you’re ready, as a lawyer, to defend even murderers why don’t you come to the defense of writers who have committed no wrong except for writing books?” I asked.</blockquote><blockquote>“Because they get on my nerves,” Paul retorted cheerfully.</blockquote><blockquote>“My wife adores Mahler, (Paul) continued. “She told me that two weeks before the premiere of his Seventh Symphony he locked himself up in a noisy hotel room and spent the whole night rewriting the orchestration ..</blockquote><blockquote>“I visualize him sitting in the hotel room, surrounded by manuscript papers .. he was convinced that his whole work would be ruined if the melody were played by a clarinet instead of an oboe during the second movement.”</blockquote><blockquote>“That’s precisely so,” I said, thinking of my novel.</blockquote><blockquote>Paul continued, “I wish that someday this symphony could be played before an audience consisting of the best musical experts, first with the corrections made in those last two weeks, and then without the corrections. I guarantee that nobody would be able to tell one version from the other. Don’t get me wrong: it is certainly remarkable that the motif played in the second movement by the violin is picked up in the last movement by the flute. Everything is worked through, thought through, felt through, nothing has been left to chance, but that enormous perfection overwhelms us, it surpasses the capacity of our memory, our ability to concentrate, so that even the most fanatically attentive listener will grasp no more than one-hundreth of the symphony, and certainly it will be this one-hundreth that Mahler cared about least.”</blockquote><blockquote>His idea, so obviously correct, cheered him up, wheareas I was becoming sadder and sadder: if a reader skips a single sentence of my novel he won’t be able to understand it, and yet where in the world will you find a reader who never skips a line? Am I not myself the greatest skipper of lines and pages?</blockquote><blockquote>“I don’t deny those symphonies their perfection,” continued Paul. “I only deny the importance of that perfection. Those super sublime symphonies are nothing but cathedrals of the useless. They are inaccessible to man. They are inhuman. We exaggerate their significance. They made us feel inferior. <em>Europe reduced Europe to fifty work of genius that it never understood. Just think of this outrageous inequality: millions of Europeans signify nothing, against fifty names signifying everything! Class inequality is but an insignificant shortcoming compared to this insulting metaphysical inequality, which turns some into grains of sand while endowing others with the meaning of being!”</em></blockquote><blockquote>The bottle was empty. I called the waiter to bring us another. This caused Paul to lose the thread.</blockquote><blockquote>“You spoke about biographies,” I prompted him.</blockquote><blockquote>“Ah … yes,” he recalled.</blockquote><blockquote>“You were happy that you can at last read the intimate correspondence of the dead.”</blockquote><blockquote>“I know, I know,” said Paul, as if he wanted to counter in advance any objections from the other side. “I assure you that rifling through someone’s intimate correspondence, interrogating his former mistresses .. that’s rotten. Author’s of biographies are riffraff, and I would never sit at the same table with them as I do with you. Robespierre, too, would never have sat down with the riffraff that had collective orgasms at the spectacle of public executions. But he knew that he couldn’t do without them. The riffraff is an instrument of just revolutionary hatred.”</blockquote><blockquote>“What is revolutionary about hatred for Hemingway?”</blockquote><blockquote>“I’m not talking about hatred for Hemingway! I’m talking about his <em>work</em>! I’m talking about <em>their</em> work! It was necessary to say out loud at last that reading about Hemingway is a thousand times more amusing and instructive than reading Hemingway. It was necessary to show that Hemingway’s work is just but a coded form of Hemingway’s life and that his life was just as poor and meaningless as all our lives. It was necessary to cut Mahler’s symphony into little pieces and use it as background music for toilet-paper ads. It was necessary at last to end the terror of the immortals. To overthrow the arrogant power of the Ninth Symphonies and the <em>Fausts</em>!”</blockquote><p>When Kundera uses Paul to speak about class inequality being an insignificant shortcoming it’s not to suggest class inequality doesn’t exist. Many people spend entire lives and careers obsessed with class inequality. Yet if you walk around a city you will see thousands and thousands of houses for people who have relatively the same station. Class inequality is a big issue but if one treated the “metaphysical inequality” problem with the same seriousness and attention it’s quickly apparent how much more drastic the difference is. Having 100’s of thousands of books being of equal importance is to suggest a re-conception of motives and human interest far more complicated than everyone having a similar amount of money. Class inequality, in comparison, is easily solvable. I’ll repeat; no matter how difficult and intrenched the class inequality problem might seem, it is far easier solved than the metaphysical inequality problem. Trying to understand class inequality is like trying to understand gravity. Trying to understand metaphysical inequality is like trying to understand dark matter.</p><p>Likewise, the concept of “50 works of genius they never understood” is not to suggest no understanding <em>at all </em>but the issue raised a few paragraphs earlier with Mahler and the overwhelming nature of perfection. I think of Joyce’s <strong>Finnegan’s Wake </strong>and how he proclaimed it should take the reader ten years to read it the same way it took him ten years to write it. But it is not uncommon for a book to take ten years to compose — especially if one took into consideration all the bad writing one has to churn out at the beginning stages of finding one’s voice.</p><p>It is impossible to understand <strong>Finnegan’s Wake</strong> without giving it a large amount of time to dissect, but does it deserve to be given 10 years of a readers life considering all the other personalities and different views of existence one could draw from? This is what is being suggested about not being understood. What makes particular individuals so worthy of this deep consideration?</p><p>The question Paul’s character raises is; is the differentiation of genius from everyone else justified? And his short answer is NO, “just as poor and meaningless as all our lives.” (It should also be noted in Kundera’s chapter Paul is described as having been drinking since morning.)</p><p>I tend to agree with Paul. That difference is not justified.</p><p>If we look at the state of most modern literary published works, it’s hard for many of us readers (who also write) to distinguish what makes the books exceptional (this is not at all to suggest that they are bad, but that due to the abundance many readers are looking for even the tiniest of excuses to not read said work). To ask, like I did at the beginning, which books deserve to be read? Implies the question; which books deserve to be published? I cannot help but think these questions are tied up in a growing awareness of the <em>problem</em> of metaphysical inequality.</p><p>Now, is it a <em>problem</em> with a <em>solution</em>? That may depend on how you understand the word solution. But before that I will further define the “problem”.</p><p>I’ve met many types of writers. The schizophrenic poet, the aforementioned mailman with a high fantasy series, the creative writing teacher with polished short stories for academic journals — the Italian meta fiction impresario that she was dating. Writers of sketches, screenplays, memoirs. I wouldn’t be surprised if every reader of literary fiction also fancied themselves a writer, having a novel published one day. I never quite knew what to do with that information about this bounty of writers. I should say; I still don’t know. Because on some level their striving is identical to my own. But on another level, it isn’t. I get the feeling they haven’t done the full immortality equations, they just have a feeling that they’d like the validation. And is that such a hard thing to give? Could we solve the metaphysical inequality problem with one big pat on the back? Another option is the reduction of the term genius, which will end up being a casualty in the great push for equality. (The battle to retain meaning in the word genius would be one of the strangest battles to ever exist, because anyone who needed the term that bad would be an obvious fraud.)</p><h4>The Tribe of the Published</h4><p>The other day I had a question for myself. How come so much of my default thinking comes out in my internal monologue as the form of advice? I broadened this out into; how come there’s such a penchant for advice giving in humans in general?</p><p>I asked my sister, who’s a therapist, and her first instinct was the word control. We discussed it for a few minutes and the answer became obvious. We give advice so others see things our way and thusly we have recruited into our tribe. It’s a protective mechanism. Most people would prefer good advice but it certainly doesn’t have to be good. If you make people feel like they’re part of a tribe that’s 90% of the workload.</p><p>The intellectual proclaims to have escaped this tribalistic trap. Claims to be as objective as they can be. This <em>theoretical</em> tribe is the tribe I always wanted to be part of. Like all tribes there are upsides and downsides. The upside is you can pretend to be of a class which are the real movers and shakers of human destiny. You’re not just thinking how to make money, you’re thinking about humanity’s long term future. Including concepts like Nietzsche’s Last Man where; how much adjustment of humanity can one make before one invites a uniformity without the chaos modifier which seems to have been the great randomizer of progress? The downside is; you’ll probably go your whole life without meeting another person of your tribe. And even if you do meet one, you’ll be skeptical if they’re really in it for the right reasons, like you are. The downside is one willingly invites loneliness.</p><p>But most writers don’t have such high minded ambitions. Perhaps for many <strong><em>it’s as simple as being in the tribe of the published</em></strong>.</p><p>When I dropped out of college I had a nagging problem with the education system. I liked learning and knew I would continue to do it throughout the rest of my life. I didn’t understand why I needed a piece of paper that said I had completed such and such number of courses. I literally didn’t get it. It wasn’t until some years later where I went to visit my friend who’d had the worst grades in our class but had powered through and was now a high school history teacher. I must’ve brought up my confusion because he told me a story which felt like a slap over the back of the head.</p><p>His economics professor had told him; “You get a degree so nobody can take it away from you.”</p><p>Of course! How naive I was about the world to think that my curiosity would be worth something in and of itself.</p><p>Here we have an example about pinning down the metaphysics of an individual. “Being published” could be viewed similarly to getting a degree or certification. It’s a certificate for one’s striving to be included with the immortals. And the actual practical effect might be similar to a college degree these days. That is; very little effect (especially in the humanities).</p><h4>Immortality</h4><p>Rereading Kundera’s novel for probably the 11th time in preparation for finally putting down these thoughts I think I’ve come to the conclusion that there is a proposed solution in his novel. Maybe it was so obvious I kept overlooking it.</p><p>Firstly, a couple more pieces of context from the novel. This is Kundera’s definition of immortality.</p><blockquote>Everyone can achieve immortality to a smaller or greater degree, of shorter or longer duration, and this idea already starts occupying people’s minds in early youth. They used to say about the mayor of a certain Moravian village that he had an open coffin at home and that in happy moments when he felt well satisfied with himself, he would lie down in it and visualize his funeral. These were the most beautiful moments of his life, those reveries in the coffin: he dwelt on his immortality.</blockquote><blockquote>Naturally, when it comes to immortality people are not equal. We have to distinguish between so-called <em>minor</em> <em>immortality</em>, the memory of a person in the minds of those who knew him (the kind of immortality the village mayor longed for), and <em>great</em> <em>immortality</em>, which means the memory of a person in the minds of people who never knew them personally.</blockquote><p>The more fascinating problem is that of <em>great</em> immortality. Minor immortality doesn’t offer many complications. Being a profoundly good person or a profoundly shitty one will earn a person the same amount of minor immortality. This is probably why minor immortality is easily overlooked and not particularly enjoyed, except for those rare individuals like the mayor of that Moravian village.</p><p>Great immortality is involved in the thrust of history.</p><blockquote>There are certain paths in life that from the very beginning place a person face to face with such great immortality, uncertain, it is true, even improbable, yet undeniably possible: they are the paths of artists and statesmen.</blockquote><p>These days I think you could also include scientists … but I include the <em>great</em> scientists as artists in their own right.</p><p>Kundera includes many different examples in the novel but the highest amount of attention is given to Goethe. And specifically about 30 pages to a retrieval of the history between Goethe and Bettina Brentano. Who framed herself as one of Goethe’s great loves to secure her place in immortality. He uses Goethe and the immortal narrative of his loves because, by Kundera’s conception, Goethe is at the middle point of European history.</p><blockquote>As a young man Goethe studied alchemy, and later became one of the first modern scientists .. he lived during that brief span of history when the level of technology already gave life a certain measure of comfort by when an educated person could still understand all the devices he used.</blockquote><blockquote>Beethoven’s work begins where Goethe’s center ends. It is located in the moment when the world starts gradually losing its transparency, darkens, becomes more and more incomprehensible, rushes into the unknown, while man, betrayed by the world, escapes into his self, into his nostalgia, his dreams, his revolt, and lets himself be deafened by the voices inside him so that he no longer hears the voices outside.</blockquote><p>This is part of a larger anecdote about Goethe removing his hat and bowing to the Empress on the street and Beethoven instead pulling his cap yet further down and striding forward. An anecdote about how Europeans viewed progress at the time.</p><p>One cannot talk about immortality without talking about history. But is history continually being made or is the sense of history itself closer to a concept? Formed by ideologies. (I ask truly as a question but I’ll admit it’s very close to being rhetorical. Any thinker has to acknowledge the conceptual pieces of history are at least as important as literal facts. Go read <a href="https://medium.com/@jandrist/humans-at-play-in-the-dawn-of-everything-c95dd0e7c25b">David Graeber and David Wengrow’s The Dawn of Everything </a>and try to have a conversation with anyone about where the real power of kings comes from.)</p><blockquote>Ideology was like a set of enormous wheels at the back of the stage, turning and setting in motion wars, revolutions, reforms.</blockquote><p>Kundera suggests we have progressed into an age where ideologies no longer hold any value. Or at the very least; all ideologies have been bested by a term he has coined <em>imagology</em>.</p><blockquote>Some one hundred years ago in Russia, persecuted Marxists began to gather secretly in small circles in order to study Marx’s manifesto; they simplified the contents of this simple ideology in order to disseminate it to other circles, whose members simplify(ed) further and further .. so that when Marxism became known and powerful on the whole planet, all that was left of it was a collection of six or seven slogans so poorly linked that it can hardly be called an ideology. And precisely because the remnants of Marx no longer form any logical system of ideas, but only a series of suggestive images and slogans .. we can rightly talk of a gradual, general, planetary transformation of ideology into imagology.</blockquote><blockquote>All ideologies have been defeated: in the end their dogmas were unmasked as illusions and people stopped taking them seriously. .. Reality was stronger than ideology. And it is in this sense that imagology surpassed it: imagology is stronger than reality, which has anyway long ceased to be what it was for my grandmother .. who still knew everything through her own experience.</blockquote><p>Kundera goes on to compare and contrast village life with his Paris neighbor. But the most important feature, to my reading, is;</p><blockquote>The wheels of imagology turn without having any effect upon history. Ideologies fought one another, and each of them was capable of filling a whole epoch with its thinking. Imagology organizes peaceful alternations of its systems in lively seasonal rhythms .. Ideology belonged to history, while the reign of imagology begins where history ends.</blockquote><p>There has been at least some postmodern contemplation of this <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_End_of_History_and_the_Last_Man">End of History</a> and its consequences. It’s hard to argue with the benefits of peace and “lively seasonal rhythms” over World Wars and gulags.</p><p>Kundera, in 1990, was yet to see the new manifestation of nonsense ideology which can be hyper complex and <em>also</em> ignore reality, using the bag of tricks spread down through imagology.</p><p>But now that I’ve established more of his ideas lets return to the metaphysical inequality and immortality problem. Namely, Kundera’s obvious solution.</p><p><strong>There will be no more <em>great</em> immortals. The immortals were tied to history.</strong></p><p>And history will never again be what it was, unless we revert into ideology.</p><p>If you were raised in the age where imagology gained its victory over ideology (anyone born after 1970, say) the only real option available to you is <em>minor</em> immortality (your 15 minutes of fame). Or perhaps we should have a new term for it, mixed minor — since how many people does one <em>even know</em> personally?</p><p>But do not worry, this is no great tragedy. It’s a good thing to lose great immortality, and not only because it helps even out the metaphysical inequality problem.</p><p>Anyone who’s been on the path of great immortality has realized what a burden it becomes. It means eternal trial.</p><p>Some of the more charming recurrent scenes in <strong>Immortality</strong> has Kundera imagining Goethe and Hemingway chatting in the afterlife.</p><blockquote>You ask me what was the point of bringing the two together. After all, they don’t belong together at all, they have nothing in common! So what? With whom do you think Goethe would like to pass his time in the other world?</blockquote><blockquote>It was only out of my most sincere love for him that I dreamed up someone at his side who interested him very much (in case you have forgotten, let me remind you that Goethe was fascinated by America throughout his life!), someone who wasn’t like the band of pale-faced Romantics that come to dominate Germany toward the end of his life.</blockquote><p>..</p><blockquote>“You know, Johann,” said Hemingway, “they keep bringing up accusations against me, too. Instead of reading my books, they’re writing books about me ..</blockquote><blockquote>“That’s immortality,” said Goethe. “Immortality means eternal trial.”</blockquote><blockquote>“If it’s eternal trial, there ought to be a decent judge. Not a narrow-minded schoolteacher with a rod in her hand.”</blockquote><blockquote>“A rod in the hand of a narrow-minded teacher, that’s what eternal trial is about. What else did you expect, Ernest?”</blockquote><blockquote>“I didn’t expect anything. I had hoped that after death I would at last be able to live in peace.”</blockquote><blockquote>“You did everything you could to become immortal.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Nonsense. I wrote books. That’s all.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Yes, precisely!” laughed Goethe.</blockquote><blockquote>“I have no objection to my books being immortal. I wrote them in such a way that nobody could delete a single word. To resist every kind of adversity. But I myself, as a human being, as Ernest Hemingway, I don’t give a damn about immortality!”</blockquote><blockquote>“I understand you very well, Ernest. But you should have been more careful when you were still alive. Now it’s too late.”</blockquote><blockquote>“More careful? Are you referring to my boastfulness? I admit that when I was young I loved to blow my own trumpet .. But believe me, I wasn’t such a monster as to do it on account of immortality! When I realized one day that this was the point of it all, I panicked. From that time on I must have told people a thousand times to leave my life alone. But the more I pleaded the worse it got. I moved to Cuba to get out of their sight. When I won the Nobel Prize I refused to go to Stockholm .. when I realized one day that (immortality) was holding me in its clutches, it terrified me more than death itself. A man can take his own life. But he cannot take his own immortality. As soon as immortality has you aboard you can’t get off, and even if you shoot yourself you’ll stay on deck along with your suicide, and that’s horrible, Johann, that’s horrible.</blockquote><p>I like this picture of Hemingway’s motivations towards the end of his life. Not only cause it fits the metaphor of the book Kundera wrote but it feels more explanatory than what the real cause probably was. Some version of paranoia induced by traumatic brain injury.</p><p>Kundera then, being the brilliant ally of his own gravediggers, takes a position alongside the imagologues. Immortality was just the daydream of ideas and ideology.</p><blockquote>“Haven’t you realized yet, Ernest, that the figures they talk about have nothing to do with us?”</blockquote><blockquote>“Don’t tell me, Johann, that you bear no relation to the Goethe about whom everybody writes and talks. I admit that the image that remained behind you is not entirely identical to you. I admit that it distorts you quite a bit. Still, you are present in it.”</blockquote><blockquote>“No, I’m not,” Goethe said very firmly. “And I’ll tell you something else. I am not even present in my books. He who doesn’t exist cannot be present.”</blockquote><blockquote>“That’s too philosophical for me.”</blockquote><blockquote>“Forget for a moment that you’re an American and exercise your brain: he who doesn’t exist cannot be present. Is that so complicated? The instant I died I vanished from everywhere, totally. I even vanished from my books. Those books exist in the world without me. Nobody will ever find me in them. Because you cannot find someone who does not exist.”</blockquote><blockquote>“I’d like to agree with you,” said Hemingway, “but explain this to me: if the image you’ve left behind has nothing to do with you, why did you lavish so much care on it while you were still alive? Why did you start writing Poetry and Truth?”</blockquote><blockquote>“Ernest, resign yourself to the idea that I was as foolish as you. That obsession with one’s own image, that’s man’s fatal immaturity. It is so difficult to be indifferent to one’s image. Such indifference is beyond human strength. One becomes capable of it only after death. And even then it doesn’t happen at once, but only a long time after death.”</blockquote><p>And as such we return to the Tribe of the Published, and the image of that. To be protected from death’s idea by having a relationship with that tribe. In the tribe there are no trials. Because there’s no failures and no successes (this idealized version of the tribe). The imagologues might pick you, in tune with some lively seasonal rhythm, and you should enjoy it, this dance around the maypole. But remember, too, everybody else deserves a turn. Like your Kindergarten teacher told you.</p><p>And this idea, so obviously correct, is perhaps the melancholy Kundera coined; the unbearable lightness of being.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/proxy/1*7Fuug_pRM3-54ynAofIrPg.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=82c95ec8769b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Mountainhead — A Review of the Film]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/mountainhead-a-review-of-the-film-9d833a48d31b?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9d833a48d31b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[billionaires]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[theater]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Jun 2025 22:51:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-06-06T22:51:06.323Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Mountainhead — A Review of the Film</h3><h4>(and a pitch for a different version of it)</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*kyM7jJVt6dc4DmmhtJICeg.png" /></figure><p>The new movie from writer/director Jesse Armstrong is a story which would not seem out of place in Greek theater. With a single location, and four main characters it could easily be transferred to the stage. It is satire. But smart satire, for those of a certain class. Maybe, even, it would’ve gotten the biggest laughs performed at one of the homes of a Greek aristocrat — servants handing around plates of olives and decanters of wine and the servants laughing along, half heartedly (though even fake laughter does lead to real laughs), at their masters’ mirth.</p><p>It would be one group of friends making fun of another group of friends but all in good fun, because what was really going to challenge them anyway? To be great one must have the guts to not crumple at mere words.</p><p><strong>Mountainhead </strong>feels like a film whose ideal audience is billionaires. I don’t mean “ideal” in simple terms of who will enjoy it — I mean also; who would get the most out of watching the film, spiritually.</p><p>The eternal problem with satire is, when done well, it’s difficult to distinguish from endorsement. I don’t think most viewers are envious of our extraordinarily wealthy men in <strong>Mountainhead </strong>on a ‘personal’ level. But there is not enough objective criticism in the film for the material to be flirting with at least a little wish fulfillment. The characters are masters of their universe, after all. The president calls one of them to have a conversation. (Much like, in the Greek theater example, the audience would’ve included prestigious Senators.)</p><p>This is not to say that <strong>Mountainhead </strong>is a pretentious film, though satire always plays with pretense. I mean that for satire of this nature to change any behavior whatsoever the audience appreciating the subtle ribbing should be able to take the criticism seriously.</p><p>As a non billionaire (hell, as a non thousand-aire at this particular stage in my life) I cannot.</p><p>Which is not to say I disliked the film. I like fast paced dialogue with characters saying educated things. Everything I have to say about <strong>Mountainhead </strong>is not criticism — except I have to suggest that it is, like most of Greek satire and according to Greek philosopher&#39;s estimations on the nature of satire — a minor work.</p><p>As the plot kicks into full gear there is a scene where one character is leaning over a banister in the mansion. From observing the establishing shot of the sprawling mansion of this meeting of minds on top of a mountain, the home they were at did not seem particularly <em>tall</em>. Large in width, surely, but too much height on top of a mountain means needing incredible amounts of substructure. Most mansions of that type are wide, not tall. Yet in this scene the house appears to be four, five stories tall. There’s a reason for this, in the plot, of course. And I don’t bring up this point just to be pedantic. I bring it up as the emotional point in the film where I sensed the excuses the writer was using to include farce. The moment at the top of this stairwell is intended to be comedic.</p><p>And yet no real comedy is to be had. (I laughed once at a character quoting Kant but that was just because it was funny for me to imagine a techbro quoting Kant). Maybe some millionaires are laughing, “Ha! That’s just like so and so!” But despite all its literacy it fails to be art.</p><p>Art like Fellini’s <strong>Satyricon </strong>which takes on the whole genre.</p><p>Here’s my pitch for what would make <strong>Mountainhead </strong>art. And as soon as I say it you’ll know exactly why I’m not a thousand-aire. Or why you hate Lars von Trier movies (the only person who I could imagine doing something this bold).</p><p>Epstein Island. Full stop. You can write it yourself if you want.</p><p>Personally, I’d start with a Bill Gates like figure. Somehow still naive (or is he?). Flying into the island. He begins to sense glimpses of the traps laid for him. Others arrive. Many powerful beyond measure. The audience has to confront these characters knowing what they’re doing but finding ways to displace blame.</p><p>Anyway perhaps you see my point. If you see/have seen <strong>Mountainhead </strong>you’ll know the scandal is forgivable. There’s no <em>challenge </em>to the average viewer. To encounter some dark side of themselves and human nature or the characters, really. They make a goofy decision but it never feels despicable, it feels goofy.</p><p>Like teasing your friend, when they pass out at a party and you write something in permanent marker on their face.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9d833a48d31b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Was Past Lives (2023) a Good Movie?]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/was-past-lives-2023-a-good-movie-c81cc8603100?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c81cc8603100</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[film]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 20 Mar 2025 21:31:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-28T20:04:13.683Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Or — a Eulogy for negative criticism.</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/474/1*-ugSive_I6U5_4VFUXNGHg.jpeg" /><figcaption>“This Romantic masterpiece deserves Oscars.”</figcaption></figure><p>A retroactive note,</p><p>When I finished typing this piece I knew my sentiment was quite raw, probably flawed. I couldn’t stop thinking about what I’d written for many days — which is usually a good sign that there are thoughts which have been expressed messily. I also realized, during this period, that the eulogy I am implying was mostly for the business of my own mourning; the end of an era where I was going to let art that didn’t do anything for me, make me feel lonely. I am a believer in art, I really want everything to move me. So I suppose when many people say something moved them, and it does nothing for me, I turn on the inner skeptic and (like a Hercule Poirot or Columbo) start looking for the tricks, the deceptions, the fakery that I picked up on subconsciously but other less rigorous viewers missed. <em>Obviously </em>that is a wackadoo emotional position. But it doesn’t necessarily mean that the skepticism I have spent so many years cultivating is wrong. In this case, and the case of art more generally and the niche feelings of experience curated for particular viewers — you will probably consider all of the following words a weirdo, missing the point.</p><p>At least many people on the internet told me as such when I posted this to a film subreddit. At the end I will address their comments in lieu of changing the article as it first existed.</p><p>Before we get into the conception of “good”, which I have a metric for, I want to talk about the current state of criticism.</p><p>Recently I took to the internet to express my frustration at the second season of the TV show Severance, only to be met with disdain and a very valid response of, “well if you don’t like it, don’t watch it then.” A response so reasonable it’s almost equally frustrating. At core, it suggests that there’s so much media to “consume” one can find their own little niches of choice and never expect to have a shared experience of that thing with another person. I’m not saying this is inherently a bad thing — it has just, basically, eliminated a need for a secondary voice who expresses a different reaction other than enjoyment and appreciation.</p><p>And, to be fair, the best side of criticism has come from a positive place. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w6iZMC05cwE&amp;ab_channel=TulipBulbs">Pauline Kael going on The Dick Cavett Show to rep for McCabe and Mrs Miller</a>. Bringing buried works from out of the shadows to a larger audience. But with the amount of media these days this is largely the only critical voice at play. Sure, there are some “pans” but these are for movies which are so egregiously bad basically every critic has to acknowledge the movie’s flaws. These movies are also generally big budget and tone deaf, having lost some of the humanity they were trying to convey through the meat grinder of people making sure they made money.</p><p>But my personal favorite or most memorable piece of criticism was from Film Crit Hulk in his examination of the movie Birdman (a piece lost in defunct internet webpages, a 30 minute look for it and I couldn’t find a link). A movie largely enjoyed by most people but which left me very cold and annoyed. I didn’t know what to make of my feelings, and it was months later, after Birdman won multiple Oscars, where I finally found his piece and felt deeply comforted reading a negative critique. I wasn’t alone.</p><p>Which is to say I think there’s still a place for negative criticism. Oh god … I can’t help it … here come my thoughts about Severance.</p><p>Take Severance season 2 for example. Even setting aside that the pleasures of the show seem to only come from the audiences expectation of a big reveal (But could that end goal ever be satisfying? Shouldn’t you be able to enjoy each episode individually? Not waiting on tender hooks for little reveals hoping it all eventually pays off?) What is the idea in Severance which I’m supposed to have a conversation with somebody about? It’s a show that frustrates me because it gets close to saying something, but trying to examine what it’s trying to say becomes oblique.</p><p>Okay, out of my system though I could honestly spend hours on what Severance gets wrong (but people like it, let it go). So instead I’ve decided to focus on the much more nuanced feelings I had for the film Past Lives. A seemingly universally adored film (95% positive on Rotten Tomatoes) which I don’t think could be denied is being shown love specifically by this new type of critic who need to be positive to help a movie get exposure.</p><p>Would a commercial plumber in Fargo, North Dakota like the film Past Lives? This film about an ambitious Korean immigrant writer in a slow burn love story? I’m thinking they would not (in fact I’m specifically thinking about a batch of old co-workers who <em>I know</em> wouldn’t like it). Which brings me to the conception of what makes good (a completely imperfect metric maker).</p><p>Good meaning over 50% of people would like a movie pulled from a truly random pool of every kind of individual. I bring up this metric not because it helps answer the question of whether Past Lives is good, I bring it up because it doesn’t. I don’t know what the answer would be. If of those individuals you disproportionately got people from New York and LA it would probably tip the scales but other than that I just don’t know.</p><p>I can say that on a personal level I didn’t think it was much of anything. Maybe if it was the first movie of that style which I’d ever seen I’d think it a gorgeous rumination on the melancholy of lost loves and the different paths one might have taken. As the 20th movie of its tone that I’ve seen — I’m much less impressed. There’s more melancholy and, frankly, ideas, in a single episode of Six Feet Under (just watched Season 3 Ep 1 again, thinking of that specifically). There’s more ideas in five minutes of Rick and Morty than the entire 1 hour 45 minute runtime of Past Lives.</p><p>On multiple occasions watching Past Lives I got up and left the room completely certain I wouldn’t miss anything worth pausing. I saw a movie from The Philippines a few years ago which featured a ten minute segment of a young man simply washing his vegetables and making dinner which seemed a deeper meditation and coming from a place of curiosity than Past Lives (though I’m sure that such a movie would fare worse than PL on the “good” scale).</p><p>I have roughly the same problem with Past Lives as I had with Elif Batuman’s highly praised 2018 novel The Idiot. If you accused either of being boring the response would be, “but life is boring, this is an emotional response to real life”. And I’d have to hide a scowl and agree.</p><p>Arguably, I am probably being unfair. There’s something in the ambition of our main protagonist writer character which I see in myself and have often found distasteful. For example: she is very concerned with winning awards. But unlike myself she is actually on that path with a career. She’s a vaguely unlikable character whom only good things seem to happen for. There’s no risk in her story. In the end she might’ve had a different life but she has this one which is pretty good anyway. I hate to be this guy … but that’s not a story. It’s not anything … other than a brief history lesson about this Korean term, In Yeon, which is about fate and how even brushing clothes with someone is a fated act. This is the only idea in the whole film.</p><p>Like I tried to establish at the beginning — it makes sense that negative criticism of this kind is a dying, a potentially pointless activity. But like that Film Crit Hulk Birdman review maybe there’s a couple of you out there who were also confused about the boundless praise and maybe feel less lonely knowing you weren’t the only one unimpressed.</p><p>And now for the comments ..</p><p>“Frankly, there’s no reason to suspect that a plumber in Fargo would necessarily like a good movie. That’s not really what it means to be a <em>good</em> movie. That’s just what it means to be “a movie that a plumber in Fargo likes.””</p><p>Right, I’m not suggesting that’s what it means to be a good movie, what I’m suggesting is a good movie <em>might </em>have a plumber as a fan. Like the movie Suzhou River or Solaris or Tampopo, or hell, Barbie.</p><p>Really what I’m suggesting is that if the entirety of your movie hinges on one specific emotional experience, which is inaccessible to a high percentage of your potential audience you should also include some ideas or really any other part of human experience, jokes, maybe. Something for a different type of viewer to find worthwhile.</p><p>But ultimately, I suppose, my frustration was at the idea that apropos its high valuation in terms of ratings there’s no way Past Lives would actually appeal to 95% of a general audience. A ridiculous frustration, wanting the representation of life to look exactly like life. I suppose I’m vaguely concerned that platforming mid-level artists is going to result in a lot of middling art but, again, I know that’s just a crazy personal thought. But it’s a thought that happens, which if anyone got to the point of bothering to read all of this might feel slightly comforted to know they weren’t the only one. I’m still willfully jumping into the pit, right now, even though I know better.</p><p>“This criticism is so up its own ass that it’s miraculous that you can simultaneously say negative criticism is dead lol. You say there’s more “ideas” in an episode of Rick and Morty than this movie but what does that mean? Are they thoroughly thought out? Are the explored with nuance? What’s your point? What are you getting at? Why do you think you failed to connect with it? Interrogate that instead of doing bizarre diatribes about plumbing in the dakotas.”</p><p>It’s funny to note what people fixate on in a piece of writing. Like the plumber thing. I always thought if you were going to do critique you should also engage with the art form and make personal choices, but don’t expect to not be punished for doing as such.</p><p>“Disregarding your own clearly evident flaws, it’s a movie about a very specific experience that most maybe can’t relate to. I do agree it’s overrated, but your criticism of it is somehow overwrought and shallow at the same time.”</p><p>But this is also part of my point! In the face of specific experience what criticism could ever be considered valid? It’s almost like encouraging artists to make less choices because you’ll be less open to criticism. But, it seems to me, this also means closing off the possibility of truly representing the breadth of experience and cracking open a new crevasse to the unknown.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c81cc8603100" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Art — The Process of Learning]]></title>
            <link>https://jandrist.medium.com/art-the-process-of-learning-2fb31a43ffb7?source=rss-3d29b60ed43a------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2fb31a43ffb7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonah Andrist]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 06 Feb 2025 18:48:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-06T18:48:40.399Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Art — The Process of Learning</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*yXy03eZs04APzK1w" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@rozetsky?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Ant Rozetsky</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p>Last summer I heard a quote from Elizabeth Gilbert which was, speaking on art and writing, “One is entitled to the labor. One is not entitled to the fruits of that labor.”</p><p>At the time I was hanging out, almost every day, with a writer friend and we were making notes on a discussion about failure. As it was on topic I told him this quote I heard. Immediately he responded, “I hate that.”</p><p>And I understood what he meant. After so many years of labor one doesn’t want to give in and accept this rejection from the universe. If work doesn’t yield fruits what even is work? If labor doesn’t entitle you to anything, then that fundamentally alters what the term <em>labor </em>even is.</p><p>More accurately, I think now, the problem with Gilbert’s quotation is that even though art can feel laborious and hard, it is not <em>work</em>.</p><p>Art is the process of learning. And to dedicate oneself to art is to be a lifelong student.</p><p>Think; just because one is their class valedictorian it does not entitle them to the best life. That would be an equally bizarre and unfair version of reality (not to mention that being able to pass tests and please teachers doesn’t necessarily equate interest in learning).</p><p>I originally read of art as the process of learning in a book about alchemy. It was used simply to describe what learning was — art. They used the term like that’s how it might be used in the dictionary.</p><p>As such I pass that ancient wisdom on to you.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2fb31a43ffb7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>