<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 01:39:08 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Took Many Detours Before I Slowly Learned to Live in a Way That Suits Me]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/i-took-many-detours-before-i-slowly-learned-to-live-in-a-way-that-suits-me-f38de9ccd6dd?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f38de9ccd6dd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-acceptance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mental-wellbeing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-discovery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 22:55:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-19T22:55:51.190Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b5fIhMDh61HMmFn-i4OX7Q.png" /></figure><h4>For years, I pushed myself to be more social, more capable, and more like everyone else. But the harder I tried to change, the more exhausted I became. What if the problem wasn’t that I hadn’t tried hard enough?</h4><p>Jane Sonnenschein · April 15, 2026</p><p>When we’re young, we often believe that many of life’s problems can be solved if we just try a little harder.</p><p>Not disciplined enough? Push yourself more.</p><p>Not good enough with people? Work on your social skills.</p><p>Having trouble fitting into your environment? Learn to put up with more.</p><p>Not as capable as the people who seem to be doing well? Keep learning from them.</p><p>It’s as though, with enough effort, we can eventually turn ourselves into better, more capable people who fit more comfortably into the world.</p><p>I used to think that way, too.</p><p>For many years, I lived as though I were constantly trying to fix myself.</p><p>I always felt there was something wrong with me.</p><p>I wasn’t good enough at building relationships, socializing, promoting myself, or sticking with things. I struggled to stay steady when my efforts brought no immediate response. I wasn’t like those people who seemed to know exactly how to get things done and navigate the world around them.</p><p>I kept thinking I simply wasn’t good enough yet.</p><p>That I needed to change a little more, work on myself a little more, and push myself a little harder.</p><p>But over time, I began to understand that some things can’t be fixed just by trying harder. They aren’t superficial habits. They’re connected to something much deeper in the way a person is made.</p><p>It’s only in the last few years that I’ve really begun to understand what I mean by that underlying structure.</p><p>I didn’t used to believe in it.</p><p>I thought that as long as someone understood their problems, worked hard, and was willing to change, almost anything about them could be different.</p><p>Now, I’m increasingly convinced that it doesn’t work that way.</p><p>The way a person is made includes so many things.</p><p>Your temperament. How you respond to the world. How sensitive you are in relationships. How you handle pressure. Whether you feel energized by crowds or more comfortable in quiet surroundings. Whether you thrive by reaching outward or by turning inward and reflecting. Whether setbacks make you more determined to push through or more likely to doubt yourself.</p><p>These things aren’t completely fixed.</p><p>But they can’t be entirely rewritten by a few pieces of advice, a handful of courses, or some clever methods either.</p><p>And one of the biggest mistakes I made in life was refusing to acknowledge that.</p><p>I always thought I should become a different kind of person.</p><p>Someone better at building connections.</p><p>Someone less afraid to ask others for help.</p><p>Someone who could handle silence or a lack of response without taking it personally.</p><p>Someone better at promoting herself.</p><p>Someone more suited to running a business.</p><p>Someone who could move easily through busy social circles and make everything look effortless.</p><p>So I kept pushing myself in that direction.</p><p>Everything felt exhausting, and I was exhausted inside, too.</p><p>Much of that pain didn’t come simply from the difficulties of real life. It came from the constant effort of trying to force myself into becoming someone else.</p><p>Eventually, I realized how damaging that way of living could be.</p><p>On the surface, it looks like hard work. But very often, you’re actually fighting against your own nature.</p><p>And sometimes, what drains a person most isn’t how difficult the work itself is. It’s having to do that work while constantly rejecting who they are.</p><p>That’s exactly how I used to live.</p><p>When I was doing <em>daigou</em>¹, I would see other people managing their WeChat Moments (the personal updates feed within WeChat, somewhat like a Facebook feed) so actively, and I’d wonder whether I should be doing the same.</p><p>Later, when I was involved in <em>weishang</em>², I saw how good other people were at finding customers, building sales networks, and turning personal relationships into business opportunities. Once again, I wondered whether I was too quiet, too slow, and simply not good enough at dealing with people.</p><p>Then I started writing articles.</p><p>I noticed that online platforms tended to favor content that was smoother, more accessible, and easier to share widely. And again, I wondered whether I should change the way I wrote to fit what those platforms wanted.</p><p>There was nothing inherently wrong with those thoughts.</p><p>The problem was that I almost always assumed the standards outside me were right. If I couldn’t meet them, I must be the problem.</p><p>As a result, so much of my effort carried this deep feeling that I was constantly trying to repair myself.</p><p>I wasn’t growing in a way that felt natural to me. I was always trying to polish away parts of myself so that I would cause less trouble and fit more easily into the world.</p><p>After going around in circles, making mistakes, and running into one obstacle after another, I finally began to see something.</p><p>Many of the roads I’d taken had been so painful not simply because I hadn’t worked hard enough, but because I’d kept trying to live according to someone else’s way of being.</p><p>It took me a very long time to understand that.</p><p>Living according to someone else’s way can seem motivating at first. You have something to compare yourself with. You know what success is supposed to look like, what it means to be good with people, how capable people are supposed to behave, and which approaches seem to bring results more quickly.</p><p>But when that way of living doesn’t really suit you, the harder you try, the more uncomfortable you become inside.</p><p>You might be able to learn certain behaviors for a while. But it’s difficult to keep drawing genuine energy from them over the long term.</p><p>Some people naturally thrive in busy social environments. The more people around them, the more energized they become. Complicated relationships excite them, and the more opportunities they have to put themselves forward, the more they seem to shine.</p><p>But I’m not like that.</p><p>I can learn some of those skills.</p><p>Yet if I have to live that way all the time, I become more and more tired, increasingly uncomfortable, and less and less like myself.</p><p>By contrast, I tend to feel most alive under very different circumstances.</p><p>When life is a little quieter.</p><p>When I have clearer boundaries.</p><p>When I don’t have to promote myself all the time, constantly ask people for favors, or keep proving myself to the outside world.</p><p>When I allow myself to move a little more slowly, to be less polished, and to spend more time thinking things through.</p><p>When I can gradually build something through my own work, through time, and through a small number of genuine connections.</p><p>Of course, this isn’t necessarily the kind of life that looks like winning.</p><p>It isn’t particularly exciting or fast-moving. It doesn’t create that impressive early momentum that makes other people think you’re going places.</p><p>But it’s much closer to a way of living I can actually sustain.</p><p>And being able to sustain my life matters a great deal to me.</p><p>I don’t mean simply staying alive. I mean not living in a way that gradually leaves me feeling smaller, emptier, and completely drained.</p><p>When I say that I took many detours before slowly learning to live in a way that suits me, it’s because I’ve finally begun to accept something.</p><p>Not everything worth working for is worth pursuing in the way that exhausts you most.</p><p>I didn’t understand that before.</p><p>I used to ask myself only one question: if other people can do it, why can’t I?</p><p>Later, I began asking a different one: is the way they do it actually right for me?</p><p>The two questions may sound similar, but they’re very different.</p><p>The first pushes me to admit that I’m somehow less capable than other people.</p><p>The second asks whether I’ve been using the wrong methods, putting myself in the wrong situations, or trying to live in a way that simply doesn’t fit me.</p><p>These days, I increasingly believe that becoming more mature doesn’t mean finally training yourself to be capable of everything.</p><p>It means beginning to understand the conditions under which you can thrive, and those that slowly wear you down.</p><p>What kind of pace suits you, and what kind of demands leave you exhausted.</p><p>What helps you build strength, and what gradually makes you lose yourself.</p><p>This is what I mean by living in a way that suits how I’m made.</p><p>It isn’t about giving myself permission to do whatever I want.</p><p>It isn’t about saying, “This is just who I am, so take it or leave it.”</p><p>And it certainly doesn’t mean refusing to learn, grow, or make adjustments.</p><p>It feels more like finally learning to work with myself instead of against myself.</p><p>I began to spend less time thinking about how to fix myself so I could become like other people.</p><p>Instead, I slowly started asking: if this is the kind of person I am, how should I arrange my life, my work, the way I express myself, and the effort I put into things so that I stop causing myself so much pain?</p><p>Once I started asking that question, a lot of things began to change.</p><p>Take writing, for example.</p><p>I used to feel constantly pulled in two directions. On one side were the platforms; on the other was myself. On one side were results; on the other was the need to express what I genuinely thought.</p><p>One part of me would say, “Everyone writes this way because it’s more likely to go viral.”</p><p>Another part would answer, “But I don’t want to lose myself in the process.”</p><p>Eventually, I stopped seeing it as an all-or-nothing choice.</p><p>I began to accept that I could learn how platforms work, improve the way I introduce my articles, and make my writing easier to approach.</p><p>But at the same time, I had to acknowledge that I’m not suited to a style of writing where everything is polished until it’s perfectly smooth, effortless, and designed to appeal to everyone.</p><p>Accepting that doesn’t mean giving up.</p><p>Quite the opposite. It’s a more realistic way of moving forward.</p><p>Because only when you recognize your limits can you work out how to adjust, instead of repeatedly pushing yourself into a corner.</p><p>The same is true of everyday life.</p><p>I used to think that maintaining a stable daily routine should be simple.</p><p>Go to bed on time, get up on time, work on schedule, and get things done when you’re supposed to.</p><p>Why could other people manage it while I kept struggling?</p><p>Over time, I began to understand that, for someone like me, the question isn’t simply whether I’m lazy.</p><p>I’m easily affected by emotions, by the responses I receive from others, by my own thoughts, and by everything that’s constantly going on inside my head.</p><p>So if I want a more stable life, I can’t just keep scolding myself for being so irregular.</p><p>I have to acknowledge that I need structure.</p><p>I need a rhythm that comes from outside myself. I need a little more order and clearer boundaries to help keep me steady.</p><p>I need to break my goals into smaller pieces and be more careful about how I use my energy.</p><p>And I need to learn how to recover first, rather than constantly demanding that I suddenly return to full strength.</p><p>This, too, is part of living in a way that suits me.</p><p>It doesn’t mean saying, “Well, that’s just how I am, so there’s nothing I can do.”</p><p>It means saying, “Because I know I tend to struggle with these things, I need to find a way of dealing with them that works better for me.”</p><p>The same applies to relationships, socializing, work, and expressing myself.</p><p>So many things I once saw as evidence that something was wrong with me have gradually begun to look different.</p><p>It’s not that I don’t know how to connect with people.</p><p>I simply take longer to build those connections.</p><p>It’s not that I can’t be noticed.</p><p>I just need more time.</p><p>It’s not that I don’t want results.</p><p>I simply can’t keep exhausting myself in pursuit of them.</p><p>It’s not that I can’t work with other people.</p><p>I just can’t give up everything that matters to me in order to fit in.</p><p>It’s not that I’m completely unsuited to this world.</p><p>I just can’t spend my whole life trying to live like someone else.</p><p>None of these realizations may sound particularly extraordinary.</p><p>But for me, they came slowly, after taking countless detours and stumbling again and again.</p><p>It’s only now that I’ve finally begun to look at myself with a little more kindness.</p><p>Not because I’ve suddenly become more capable.</p><p>And not because all my problems have been solved.</p><p>But because I’m beginning to understand that all those years of inner conflict, pain, changing direction, anxiety, and questioning my whole life weren’t necessarily signs that there was something fundamentally wrong with me.</p><p>Often, I simply hadn’t found a way of living that suited the person I actually was.</p><p>That doesn’t mean blaming fate or refusing responsibility.</p><p>Quite the opposite.</p><p>To me, it’s a more genuine way of taking responsibility.</p><p>Because once you begin to understand what kind of person you are, you can also begin making more responsible decisions about how to arrange your life.</p><p>Instead of blindly envying other people or constantly trying to fix yourself, you slowly learn to put your effort into things in a way that suits you, build something at your own pace, and live in a way that feels true to who you are.</p><p>Maybe a little more slowly.</p><p>Maybe a little less skillfully.</p><p>Maybe you’ll never look quite as capable or socially confident as some other people.</p><p>But at least it will be a path that doesn’t make you dislike yourself more and more the further you go.</p><p>I think this is one of the few things I’ve finally learned after taking so many detours.</p><p>Not how to win.</p><p>But how to stop being at war with myself.</p><h3>Notes</h3><p><strong>1. Daigou (代购)</strong> — Literally “buying on behalf of someone.” In contemporary Chinese usage, it commonly refers to buying products, often from overseas, for customers in China. Sellers may purchase goods directly and resell or arrange delivery through personal contacts and online networks. The business often relies heavily on trust, recommendations, and social media relationships.</p><p><strong>2. Weishang (微商)</strong> — A form of social-commerce business that became especially popular in China through WeChat. It involves promoting and selling products through personal social networks, private messages, WeChat Moments, and sometimes networks of sellers or distributors. Unlike a conventional online store, <em>weishang</em> often depends on maintaining personal connections and regularly promoting products within one’s social circle.</p><h4>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f38de9ccd6dd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[If a Child Can Study, Why Doesn’t She Know How to Review?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/if-a-child-can-study-why-doesnt-she-know-how-to-review-4ae98189014d?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4ae98189014d</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[machine-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[child-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Nov 2026 23:03:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-15T23:03:20.495Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HkD3SU2dbW36Ky7UXqLLyQ.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>My daughter reads German novels with ease, yet struggles to prepare for a writing test. Our disagreements made me question something I had always taken for granted: how do children actually learn how to learn?</em></strong></p><p>Jane Sonnenschein · October 11, 2026</p><p>A child being able to finish her homework does not necessarily mean she has learned how to study. It was only after my daughter reached fourth grade that I began to see this difference more and more clearly.</p><p>Lately, because of Alicia’s German studies, we have had several unpleasant arguments.</p><p>The reason was actually very simple. She had a German writing test coming up, and one part of it was route description: explaining in German how to get from one place to another, when to turn left, when to turn right, which buildings you pass, or how to cross the street.</p><p>I felt that this kind of writing included quite a few fixed expressions worth collecting, so I found her a sample text. My idea was that she should first memorize it, then try writing it out without looking, and finally recombine the sentences and use them in different route descriptions.</p><p>I didn’t expect her to resist it so strongly.</p><p>She couldn’t understand why she had to memorize those sentences if she wouldn’t be allowed to copy the original text in the test anyway. Later, although she was able to recite it aloud, she ran into difficulties again when I asked her to write it down.</p><p>It was already very late that day — well past her usual bedtime. I had worked all day, then come home and still had to cook, so I was exhausted too. She cried and said my voice was too loud. I grew angrier and angrier because she simply refused to cooperate.</p><p>Looking back, that argument was partly about her reluctance to practice, and partly about me being too impatient and managing the timing badly. But what confused me most was something else: Alicia seemed not to know at all how to prepare for a test.</p><p>She was already in fourth grade. She could read one German novel after another, and her spoken English was also quite good. Her teachers had praised her reading ability, and her English teacher had even invited her to help out in class.</p><p>But as soon as it came to written expression, her problems became obvious. Spelling, punctuation, sentence structure — sometimes even basic capitalization was unstable. What she wrote often needed a good deal of editing afterward.</p><p>What truly frustrated me was not that she misspelled a few words. It was that she seemed never to have formed this awareness: What exactly did I get wrong today, and how can I avoid making the same mistake tomorrow?</p><p>Once, she misspelled a German verb meaning “to cross the street.” I asked her to copy it ten times, hoping repeated writing would help her remember the spelling. Her face immediately fell, and she started writing very unwillingly.</p><p>At that moment, I was honestly very angry.</p><p>To me, if you misspell a word, you copy it a few times and then test yourself again. That seemed completely ordinary. If she wanted good grades, why was she unwilling even to do that much practice?</p><p>But later, as I kept thinking about it, I began to feel that the real issue might not be whether she was willing to copy a word ten times.</p><p>Because the way I was taught as a child was very clear and systematic.</p><p>From first grade on, we copied new characters and words, combined them into phrases, and used them in sentences. Something we learned today might be dictated the next day. The teacher would check it, we had to correct our mistakes, and then review it again after some time.</p><p>When I was little, I didn’t enjoy all of those tasks either. Writing a diary was especially painful. Sometimes I had to write dozens of entries over summer vacation. I often felt I had nothing to say, but I still had to sit there and figure something out.</p><p>But in that process, we gradually formed a very clear understanding: having seen something is not the same as having learned it; being able to understand it is not the same as being able to write it; finishing an exercise is not the same as truly mastering it.</p><p>Later on, we began to know which parts we were not familiar with, which areas needed extra practice, and even slowly discovered which study methods worked for us.</p><p>I myself have always been someone who remembers things by writing them down.</p><p>When I was preparing for graduation exams, I once copied and memorized dozens of pages of material over and over again. At the time, I would listen to music while studying. Some German vocabulary I did not even fully understand, and yet I could still recite it accurately.</p><p>That method worked very well for me.</p><p>But I don’t think everyone should use the same study method. Some people do better reading silently. Some learn better reading aloud. Some need to write things down. Others remember more firmly by organizing structure and understanding logic.</p><p>What I truly want Alicia to learn is how to gradually discover which methods work for <em>her</em>.</p><p>The problem is that she may never really have gone through that kind of training before.</p><p>We live in Germany, and the teaching style here is very different from what I experienced as a child. At least in Alicia’s past learning experience, she has rarely needed to do what we often did growing up: systematically copy new words every day, recite texts from memory, correct mistakes repeatedly, and then test memory again through the next dictation.</p><p>At home, too, we had previously put a lot of energy into Chinese, English, and cultivating a love of reading. We did not establish a fixed habit of written German practice very early on.</p><p>So although she can read fluently, that does not necessarily mean she has equally mature writing and review methods.</p><p>I used to think that once a child finished her homework, she should naturally know which parts she still didn’t understand. But now I’m beginning to realize that this ability to check oneself is itself something that has to be learned.</p><p>For example, I might assign Alicia a task: read a few pages of a novel, write a short summary in German, or complete a worksheet.</p><p>Once she finishes, she believes the task for the day is over, and she can go do crafts, read, or move on to something else she likes.</p><p>From her point of view, that doesn’t seem wrong. If I asked her to complete two things and she completed them, then naturally she feels she has fulfilled her responsibility.</p><p>But what I expect is something different.</p><p>I hope that after finishing, she can pause and think: Which words in this summary do I actually not know how to spell? Which sentences need revision? Which knowledge points on this worksheet have I still not mastered? If I meet the same problem next time, do I have a way to solve it on my own?</p><p>In other words, I hope she will not only complete tasks, but also learn to manage her own learning.</p><p>This made me think of AI.</p><p>AI is developing so quickly now that even someone who doesn’t know programming can ask it to generate code. But if that person has no relevant knowledge at all, then it is very hard to judge whether the code is correct, whether it is safe, whether there is unnecessary content in it, or whether it can actually be put into use.</p><p>A tool can help us complete a task, but it does not automatically give us the ability to judge the result.</p><p>Learning is the same.</p><p>Alicia can write an essay as instructed, and she can copy a word ten times. But if she does not know how to check whether she has truly mastered the knowledge, then the next time she meets the same problem, she will still need someone else to tell her what to do.</p><p>And what I want her to gradually develop is exactly this ability to judge for herself.</p><p>At the same time, I’ve also recently noticed that Alicia is not completely lacking in self-directed learning.</p><p>She loves drawing and crafts, and lately she has even learned crochet by watching videos. She made a small basket with a lid. She thinks about color combinations, notices what didn’t turn out well, and adjusts it the next time.</p><p>No one needs to supervise her in any of that.</p><p>She wants to do it, so she finds tutorials herself, and when she runs into a problem, she tries to solve it. The whole process is almost a complete example of self-directed learning.</p><p>And that leaves me with a puzzling question: why can the same child be so proactive when it comes to things she enjoys, but need constant reminders when it comes to schoolwork?</p><p>I think one possible reason is that she has not yet learned how to transfer the ways she learns in familiar, enjoyable areas to things that are less interesting.</p><p>When she is doing crafts, she has a clear goal: <em>I want to make this object.</em> If something is not right, she can see it herself.</p><p>But when she is learning German spelling, why a word has to be memorized repeatedly, or what use it will have later, may not feel nearly as concrete as a finished handmade object.</p><p>Especially when practice becomes a task assigned by her mother, it becomes easier for her to focus on how to finish it as quickly as possible, rather than on what she has actually learned.</p><p>Of course, learning cannot depend entirely on interest. Many abilities require long-term repetition, and sometimes rather boring training. A person cannot avoid these necessary things forever just because they are not enjoyable.</p><p>Still, I am slowly coming to feel that what really needs to remain firm is the goal of mastering the knowledge — not necessarily one fixed form of practice.</p><p>If a word is written wrong, a child can copy it, cover the original and write it from memory, break it into parts to remember it, or practice it inside a sentence. As long as she can eventually write it independently and still remember it a few days later when checked again, then the method has at least done its job.</p><p>And if she has not remembered it, then the method needs to be adjusted.</p><p>More than seeing her mechanically complete a required number of repetitions, I want her to gradually understand <em>why</em> this kind of practice is necessary.</p><p>The reason we are so anxious is also tied to this particular stage of German elementary school: fourth grade.</p><p>Alicia hopes to go on to <em>Gymnasium</em> — the academic secondary school that often leads toward university — and we hope she can keep as many future educational and career options open as possible.</p><p>Chris and I have told her many times that we are not demanding that she attend some famous university one day, or take up some profession that looks prestigious.</p><p>Even if she eventually wants to work as a cashier in a supermarket, as long as that is a choice she makes after understanding her other possibilities, we would have nothing against it.</p><p>What matters to us is that she has a choice — not that she ends up with only one road left because of a lack of ability.</p><p>Ordinary life is not easy. How much knowledge, skill, and judgment a person builds when young really can affect how many choices they have as an adult.</p><p>But nine-year-old Alicia may not understand that.</p><p>She knows that she wants to attend <em>Gymnasium</em>, but she may not be able to connect that wish with needing to remember a single German word tonight.</p><p>And the more clearly I see the pressure of the future, the more anxious I become about her hesitation in the present.</p><p>These recent arguments have forced me to examine my own methods as well.</p><p>I was not wrong to want her to study seriously. But perhaps I was wrong to assume that once I explained why learning matters, a child should naturally know how to go about it.</p><p>In fact, she still doesn’t know.</p><p>And learning how to learn probably cannot come through lectures alone, nor can it suddenly be made up in a single evening.</p><p>It has to begin with very concrete things: noticing a mistake, finding a method, practicing again, and then checking whether the material has truly been mastered.</p><p>Only when that process has been repeated enough times can she gradually understand that learning is not simply “the teacher assigns something and I complete it.” It is also “I can discover a problem, and I can figure out how to solve it.”</p><p>In the end, what I hope Alicia becomes is not a child who always needs her parents to supervise her, and who relies on endlessly finishing exercises in order to get good grades.</p><p>I hope that one day, when she comes across something she doesn’t know, she will be able to stop and ask herself: What exactly is it that I don’t understand? And what method can I use to figure it out?</p><p>And before she truly learns how to do that, I will probably have to accept one fact myself: just because I understood how to study fairly early on does not mean a child should naturally understand it too.</p><h4>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4ae98189014d" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Are Chinese People More Willing to Think Long-Term?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/why-are-chinese-people-more-willing-to-think-long-term-ec167e15cfff?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ec167e15cfff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[long-term-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chinese-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[chinese-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cultural-perspective]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Nov 2026 21:14:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-13T21:14:05.011Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jDW7A5HseLwvmZKAfouHUg.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>From high-speed railways to desert restoration, how China’s long history has shaped a way of thinking that looks beyond immediate results and even beyond a single generation.</em></strong></p><p>By Jane Sonnenschein · April 23, 2026</p><p>Over the years, I’ve become increasingly aware of a particular quality among Chinese people, one that often goes unnoticed: a willingness to do things that may bring no visible benefits in the short term, or may not even produce results within a single generation.</p><p>And I’m not talking about anything abstract.</p><p>On a large scale, this means building roads, high-speed railways, dams and canals, reclaiming deserts, and planting trees. On a smaller scale, it means improving local governance, gradually changing people’s attitudes, and taking on difficult, slow, demanding work that someone still has to be willing to do.</p><p>If we judge these efforts by their immediate returns, many of them don’t seem particularly worthwhile. Some may bring almost no benefit at all in the short term.</p><p>Building a road costs a great deal of money. A high-speed railway requires an even greater investment. Some projects may not look financially worthwhile after ten or even several decades.</p><p>Desert restoration is another example. You plant trees, but you may see little change this year or next year. It might take decades before the landscape truly begins to look different. Yet people in China are still willing to plan, invest, and carry on the work from one generation to the next.</p><p>I never used to think very deeply about why this kind of thinking comes so naturally to us. But looking back, I’ve gradually come to believe that it may have a great deal to do with how Chinese people learn history from childhood.</p><p>When we study history in China, we’re not simply learning what happened in a particular year or which famous figures lived during a certain dynasty.</p><p>We’re also learning something else: to look further ahead, and then further still, rather than focusing only on what’s immediately in front of us.</p><p>So many historical stories, the rise and fall of dynasties, and lessons drawn from past successes and failures keep returning to the same idea: the things that truly change a country’s future rarely happen overnight. They take years, sometimes generations, of steady work.</p><p>Chinese history is full of examples.</p><p>Building canals and irrigation systems, constructing flood defenses, reclaiming farmland, governing frontier regions, planting forests, and controlling desertification were often enormously demanding undertakings. They cost money, labor, and sometimes lives.</p><p>Many of the people involved never lived to see the full results. Yet when later generations look back, they can see how these efforts transformed a town, a region, or even the country itself.</p><p>Perhaps because our history contains so many such examples, long-term thinking is more than just an idea we talk about.</p><p>We didn’t suddenly learn to think long-term because it became a fashionable expression. Throughout our history, we’ve repeatedly seen that some things which seem least worthwhile at the time can turn out to be the most valuable in the long run.</p><p>So why are Chinese people often more comfortable with Five-Year Plans or Ten-Year Plans? Why does the idea of getting something started, even without any immediate return, make sense to us?</p><p>I think this goes beyond political or institutional arrangements. It also reflects a way of understanding time, shaped again and again by history.</p><p>We’re familiar with the idea of planting something today so that future generations can enjoy the harvest. In our historical experience, many of the things that matter most were never meant to deliver immediate results.</p><p>This way of thinking runs against a mindset that seems increasingly common in modern life.</p><p>Today, people often begin by asking: What’s the immediate benefit? How long will it take to recover the investment? If I do something today, will I see results tomorrow?</p><p>And if the answer is no, many instinctively wonder whether it’s worth doing at all.</p><p>But much of China’s experience has taught us something different.</p><p>We know that some things are worth doing today not because they make life easier right now, but because they may prevent problems ten years from now, remove obstacles twenty years down the road, or make life a little easier for the next generation.</p><p>That applies to roads, high-speed railways, desert restoration, institution-building, and many forms of long-term governance.</p><p>Perhaps this is why the Chinese saying <em>qián rén zāi shù, hòu rén chéng liáng</em>¹ carries such deep meaning for us.</p><p>It’s not simply a moral slogan. It reflects something many Chinese people genuinely believe, based on both everyday life and their understanding of the country’s history.</p><p>We know that some things are painful, slow, and difficult when they first begin. They may even be misunderstood by many people. But if the direction is right, someone has to take the first step. Otherwise, nothing will ever change.</p><p>I’ve come to think that what history education gives Chinese people goes beyond patriotism or an awareness of past dangers.</p><p>It also gives us a much longer sense of time.</p><p>It teaches us that not everything worth doing must bring an immediate reward. Not every investment that looks unprofitable today will turn out to be a waste. And not every important achievement has to be completed within our own generation.</p><p>I think this also has something to do with how a people understand their own place in history.</p><p>A people without such a long historical memory, or much experience of sustained investment and governance over generations, may naturally find it easier to trust what they can see in the present.</p><p>But China’s experience is different.</p><p>Chinese civilization has existed for so long that many things have never been completed within a single generation. They have taken shape gradually, through the efforts of several generations, sometimes more than a dozen.</p><p>And perhaps this long history has made Chinese people particularly sensitive to changes that happen slowly, almost invisibly.</p><p>We understand that something which seems insignificant today may look completely different fifty years from now.</p><p>That’s why I’ve increasingly come to believe that Chinese people’s willingness to think long-term isn’t simply about being more patient or more accustomed to hardship.</p><p>It’s because our history has reminded us, again and again, that some truly important things cannot be rushed, and that doing them properly takes real investment.</p><p>Avoiding the work today might save some effort in the short term, but the price we pay later could be much greater.</p><p>Perhaps this also explains why many Chinese people approach things that seem to have “no immediate use” with an almost stubborn seriousness.</p><p>Our history offers so many examples of projects that eventually benefited the country precisely because people kept working on them, even when others didn’t understand their purpose and the results were nowhere in sight.</p><p>In the end, long-term thinking has never been just a nice idea. It’s a difficult ability to develop.</p><p>What makes it difficult is that you know perfectly well you may see no results today. You may not even live long enough to see them. Yet you still choose to invest your time and effort, to keep going, and to move things forward, even if only a little.</p><p>And perhaps Chinese people are often willing to accept this way of thinking because, when we study history, we’re not just learning what happened in the past.</p><p>We’re also learning that many things worth doing were never meant to be for today alone. They were meant for the future.</p><p>Maybe this is one of the deepest ways history shapes us. It teaches us not only to live in the present, but also to wonder, almost instinctively, what the work of our generation will leave behind fifty years from now.</p><h3>Cultural Note</h3><p>¹ <strong>Qián rén zāi shù, hòu rén chéng liáng (前人栽树，后人乘凉)</strong></p><p>Literally, “Earlier generations plant trees; later generations enjoy their shade.”</p><p>This traditional Chinese saying expresses the idea that one generation’s efforts can benefit those who come after it, even when the people doing the work may never enjoy the results themselves.</p><p>It is often used to recognize the contributions and sacrifices of earlier generations and to encourage people to think beyond their own immediate interests. In the context of this essay, it represents a belief that meaningful progress often depends on work carried out across generations.</p><h4>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ec167e15cfff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A 13-Year-Old Girl Disappears on Her Way to School in Berlin: How Do We Balance Children’s Safety…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/a-13-year-old-girl-disappears-on-her-way-to-school-in-berlin-how-do-we-balance-childrens-safety-28069ec8dcae?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/28069ec8dcae</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[public-safety]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[society]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[child-safety]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 10 Nov 2026 22:45:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-10T22:45:38.003Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>A 13-Year-Old Girl Disappears on Her Way to School in Berlin: How Do We Balance Children’s Safety and Privacy?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tvWFkcAjF7uAFGO6MBm6JQ.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>A 13-year-old girl’s disappearance in Berlin raises difficult questions about public surveillance, privacy, and what parents can do to keep their children safe.</em></strong></p><p>By Jane Sonnenschein November 8, 2026</p><p>Over the past few days, I have kept coming across the same missing-person notice on social media.</p><p>A 13-year-old girl disappeared in Berlin on her way to school. On the morning of November 3, she left home as usual, planning to take public transport to school. But she never arrived. Several days have passed, and she still has not been found.</p><p>Her name is Lisa Tạ. According to a statement released by Berlin police on November 7, a large number of officers have been involved in the search, and criminal investigators are looking into the possibility of a serious crime. Police believe she probably did not leave her family voluntarily, but what actually happened remains unclear.</p><p>I am also a mother with a daughter. News like this is difficult to read without feeling deeply unsettled.</p><p>Today, I came across another social media post, reportedly from the girl’s mother, asking people to share the missing-person notice and even print copies so that more people might recognize her daughter and help find her.</p><p>Even through a screen, that sense of fear and helplessness was painful to see.</p><p>I cannot verify the full origin of the post, but I can understand how a mother might feel in such a situation.</p><p>Children going to and from school is one of the most ordinary parts of everyday life. When parents watch their child leave home with a schoolbag in the morning, they are usually thinking about what to make for lunch, what time the child will be back, or whether there will be homework to finish that evening.</p><p>Who could imagine that a morning no different from any other might change a family’s life forever?</p><p>To everyone else, it is a news story, a police announcement, a missing-person photograph being shared again and again.</p><p>But to the child’s parents, it is their entire world.</p><h3>1. When a Child Goes Missing, Not Knowing What Happened May Be the Most Painful Part</h3><p>This case reminded me of another girl who disappeared in Berlin in 2019: Rebecca Reusch.</p><p>She was only 15 at the time. Many years have passed, and the case has still not been definitively resolved. Her family has never received a clear answer.</p><p>I have also watched Chinese films about children who went missing or were abducted and trafficked, and about parents who spent years searching for them.</p><p>Some parents search for more than a decade, sometimes even several decades. They cannot truly begin a new chapter of their lives because one question remains unanswered: Where is my child?</p><p>I sometimes think that this kind of uncertainty can be even more painful than receiving terrible news that is at least certain.</p><p>Of course, a missing child has not necessarily been abducted, and it certainly does not mean the child has been killed. The police need to investigate, and the public needs to wait for evidence.</p><p>We must not allow our fear to write the ending of a missing child’s story before the search is over.</p><p>Every year, many minors are reported missing in Germany, but the vast majority of these cases are eventually resolved. That matters too, because it reminds us that not every missing-person report should be understood as a serious violent crime.</p><p>But for families who still have no answers, even a very high overall recovery rate does nothing to ease what they are going through.</p><h3>2. These Stories Have Made Me Rethink How China and Germany Approach Public Safety</h3><p>I grew up in China and have now lived in Germany for more than twenty years.</p><p>The two countries have some very noticeable differences in how they understand safety, privacy, and the management of public spaces.</p><p>Chinese society has changed enormously over the past few decades. My parents’ generation lived through years of material shortages. Life back then was almost another world compared with today.</p><p>Many Chinese cities have since undergone remarkable changes in everyday convenience and public facilities.</p><p>One particularly noticeable change is how common surveillance cameras have become in public places.</p><p>I have a relative who works in the public security system in Zhejiang Province. We once talked about missing children. He told me that, within the area of local work he was familiar with, he had not encountered a similar case in recent years.</p><p>Of course, that was only an observation based on his personal work experience. It does not represent all of Zhejiang, and it certainly does not mean that child disappearances or trafficking no longer occur in China.</p><p>But that conversation made me think about something.</p><p>If a child really disappears in a public place, could video recordings from along the route give the police more time to find out what happened?</p><p>Where was the child last seen? At what time did the child leave a particular intersection? Did the child get into a vehicle? Was anyone else there?</p><p>Information like this could be extremely important during an investigation.</p><p>I do not believe surveillance cameras can prevent every crime. Crimes can also happen in places cameras cannot reach.</p><p>But if necessary recordings are available from certain important locations, investigators may at least have more leads to follow afterwards.</p><h3>3. Germany Takes Privacy Seriously, but Must We Really Choose Between Safety and Privacy?</h3><p>After living in Germany for so many years, I am very familiar with the country’s strict data protection rules.</p><p>Some situations that might seem easy to solve by installing a camera, at least from the perspective of everyday life in China, can become much more complicated in Germany.</p><p>Questions arise about privacy rights, data storage, the purpose of recording, and who is legally allowed to access the footage.</p><p>In the past, I have sometimes found myself puzzled by how these rules work in everyday situations.</p><p>For example, when something goes missing at a school, everyone wants to find out what happened, but there may be no video recording available to help establish the facts.</p><p>Of course, schools are places where minors spend much of their time. Privacy needs are not the same in classrooms, corridors, and other areas. Cameras cannot simply be installed wherever someone wants them.</p><p>I understand those concerns.</p><p>But I still want to ask a question: Is it possible to protect personal privacy while making more sensible use of surveillance technology to improve public safety?</p><p>Today, people generate enormous amounts of personal data through their phones, shopping apps, and social media.</p><p>Many willingly upload photographs of their daily lives and even share images of their children publicly.</p><p>Of course, that is not exactly the same as surveillance in public places.</p><p>There are important differences between choosing to share information ourselves and having the state or another institution continuously record people’s activities. The balance of power is different, as are people’s freedom to choose and the risks of how that information might be used.</p><p>But this also shows that we cannot simply assume our personal data is adequately protected as long as we reject cameras in public places.</p><p>Perhaps the more important question is how to establish clear boundaries.</p><p>Where is surveillance genuinely necessary? Who should be allowed to use the recordings? How long should they be kept? Under what circumstances should they be accessed? And how can we prevent that information from being misused?</p><p>Germany’s approach to privacy has its own historical and legal background. Surveillance itself can also create new risks.</p><p>That is why I am not arguing for cameras to be installed everywhere, on every street or in every school, without conditions.</p><p>I simply believe that when security needs and technology change, our discussion of surveillance should become more specific, rather than remaining divided between two extremes: being for it or against it.</p><p>If a particular technology could help prevent crime in certain places or make investigations more effective, shouldn’t we at least consider whether it could be used more appropriately under strict oversight?</p><p>I think that is a question worth discussing openly.</p><h3>4. Could Economic Pressure Make Society Less Safe?</h3><p>Germany has faced considerable economic difficulties in recent years, and many families have felt the pressure of rising living costs.</p><p>I sometimes worry that as life becomes harder for people, certain social problems might also become more serious.</p><p>Looking back at China’s development, I often think about the periods when economic progress was very uneven and there were enormous differences in living standards between regions.</p><p>Crimes such as human trafficking have complicated social causes, including networks of illegal financial interests, gaps in regulation, and risks faced by vulnerable groups.</p><p>But I also know that we cannot simply say a weak economy will inevitably lead to more crime.</p><p>And we certainly should not treat poverty itself as a criminal motive.</p><p>Likewise, seeing several stories about missing children on social media in a short period does not prove that child disappearances in Germany are rapidly increasing.</p><p>We would need long-term data to establish that, not just a few shocking videos.</p><p>Still, as a mother, seeing these stories appear repeatedly has made me reconsider how safe I once assumed my surroundings were.</p><p>In the past, I generally felt that Germany was a relatively safe place to live. When I took my daughter to the supermarket or other public places, I was not always particularly worried.</p><p>Now I find myself thinking that there is nothing wrong with keeping that relaxed attitude, but perhaps we should also be more deliberate about teaching children how to recognize risks.</p><p>We do not need to imagine that danger is waiting everywhere.</p><p>But neither should we assume that because nothing has happened before, certain things could never happen.</p><h3>5. Besides Hoping for a Safer Society, What Can Parents Do Themselves?</h3><p>Over the past few days, as I have followed the news about the missing girl, I have also been asking myself what ordinary parents can do for their children.</p><p>Beyond following the investigation and helping share reliable missing-person information from the police, what can we actually do?</p><p>Several years ago, we introduced our daughter to Krav Maga, the Israeli self-defense system.</p><p>Chris had previously trained in different forms of martial arts. What he values in this kind of training is its usefulness in real situations, rather than simply whether the movements look impressive.</p><p>But I do not believe that learning martial arts means a child can defend herself against an adult.</p><p>And I certainly do not want a child to think that she must fight someone whenever she faces danger.</p><p>What I hope my daughter gains from the training is, first of all, better physical coordination, greater awareness of her surroundings, and some mental preparation so that she does not completely panic when something unexpected happens.</p><p>Perhaps even more important are the very simple things we teach children in everyday life.</p><p>For example, if an unfamiliar adult asks a child for directions, the child can answer politely, but has no obligation to go anywhere with that person.</p><p>If someone asks a child to get into a car or claims that the child’s parents have sent them to pick her up, she must check with her parents first.</p><p>If something feels wrong, she can say no, leave, or shout for help. She does not need to worry about whether that might seem impolite.</p><p>Children should also know which shops, medical practices, or other public places along their route between school and home might be safe places to ask for help.</p><p>Parents should agree with their children in advance on how to contact one another if the usual route or pickup arrangements change.</p><p>In the past, I have watched online videos showing how strangers might trick children into going with them. Some even included scenes in which a child supposedly lost consciousness shortly after touching a particular object.</p><p>Such videos can be frightening and leave a strong impression.</p><p>But whether the events are real, and whether the methods shown are even credible, needs to be carefully checked.</p><p>We should not assume that something really happened just because a video looks convincing.</p><p>Rather than repeatedly showing children terrifying videos about abduction, I think it is more useful to establish clear, simple safety rules with them and practice those rules regularly.</p><p>There is also something that may matter even more than all these techniques.</p><p><strong>Children need to feel able to tell their parents when something strange or worrying happens.</strong></p><p>If a child is afraid of being scolded for making a mistake or believing something a stranger said, she may hesitate to tell her family about a dangerous experience.</p><p>Helping a child understand that, whatever happens, she can always come to her parents straight away is itself a form of protection.</p><p>That trust matters.</p><h3>6. What We Need Is Awareness, Not Panic</h3><p>As I write this, I am still thinking about that 13-year-old girl in Berlin.</p><p>Her parents must be desperately hoping that someone can provide a genuinely useful lead.</p><p>Perhaps someone saw something along the road. Perhaps a passing vehicle or some small, easily overlooked detail could help the investigation.</p><p>We cannot carry the pain this family is experiencing for them. Nor can we decide what happened based on speculation.</p><p>What we can do is pay attention to reliable information released by the police and help share missing-person notices once their sources have been confirmed.</p><p>And if we actually know something, we should contact the police promptly rather than fill comment sections with unsupported theories.</p><p>This case has also made me think again about what safety really means.</p><p>It is not just about whether there are cameras on the streets, or how strictly privacy is protected by law.</p><p>It also depends on whether society has systems that can respond quickly when people are in danger, and whether parents can help children develop the skills they need to protect themselves.</p><p>There may always be boundaries between public safety and individual freedom that need to be reconsidered and adjusted.</p><p>I do not believe any country has found a perfect answer.</p><p>But I hope that as technology develops and society changes, we can continue discussing these questions rather than rejecting other possibilities simply because we have become accustomed to one way of doing things.</p><p>For most people, a missing child is a story that occasionally appears in the news.</p><p>But for the family waiting for that child to come home, every day must feel unbearably long.</p><p>I hope Lisa comes home safely.</p><p>And I hope that every child who leaves home with a schoolbag in the morning can return safely, just as they always have.</p><h3>Afterword | November 9, 2026</h3><p>I wrote this essay on November 8. At that time, I was still hoping that the 13-year-old girl would return home safely.</p><p>But shortly after I finished writing, I saw the news I had been dreading most.</p><p>On November 8, police discovered a body inside an unoccupied house in Brandenburg. On November 9, Berlin prosecutors confirmed that the person who had died was Lisa, the girl who had been missing for several days.</p><p>A man was under suspicion, but the precise cause of her death and the circumstances of the case were still being investigated.</p><p>When I saw the news, I did not know what to say for a long time.</p><p>Only a few days earlier, she had been a 13-year-old girl leaving home with her schoolbag, on her way to school.</p><p>Now, for her family, the waiting had become a loss that could never be undone.</p><p>Over the past few days, I have also been watching how people have responded on social media.</p><p>On one hand, missing-person information can reach thousands upon thousands of people in a very short time. More people can keep an eye out, share the information, and perhaps even provide useful leads.</p><p>That is one of the genuinely valuable things social media can do.</p><p>Perhaps the widespread attention this case received has also prompted more parents to think seriously about child safety issues they might otherwise overlook.</p><p>But there is another side to it.</p><p>After the tragedy became known, the stream of posts about the girl did not stop.</p><p>Unverified claims, speculation, and highly emotional content continued to appear.</p><p>Some people were expressing sincere grief. Others were trying to find answers. And inevitably, some were using the tragedy to attract attention.</p><p>I am writing about this case myself, so I cannot pretend to be completely outside that problem.</p><p>It has made me turn the question back on myself.</p><p>Are we genuinely concerned about what happened to a child? Or are we, without even realizing it, turning another family’s suffering into something that can be shared and discussed over and over again?</p><p>Perhaps the difference is not whether we talk about the case, but why we talk about it, what evidence we rely on, and whether we know when to hold back while the facts remain unclear.</p><p>Social media can make the disappearance of a child we have never met matter deeply to countless people.</p><p>But it can also amplify fear, spread speculation, and bring further unwanted attention to a family that has already suffered an unimaginable loss.</p><p><strong>Paying attention should not mean turning someone’s suffering into content. And grief does not need to be proved through endless sharing.</strong></p><p>As for what public safety problems this case may reveal, we still need to wait for more findings from the investigation.</p><p>We cannot treat unconfirmed speculation as an answer simply because the outcome is heartbreaking.</p><p>Nor can we assume that any single technological measure would necessarily have prevented this tragedy.</p><p>But at the very least, what happened to this girl has reminded me that child safety should not become a concern only when a missing-person notice is being shared widely.</p><p>I hope that this attention lasts longer and eventually leads to more practical safety education, more effective public protection, and greater respect for victims and their families.</p><p>As for Lisa, I do not think her death needs to be explained away with any further argument.</p><p>She was only 13.</p><p>She should have had so much more life ahead of her.</p><p>May she rest in peace, and may her family be given the peace and privacy they deserve in their grief.</p><h4>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=28069ec8dcae" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[She Can Spend All Day Making a Cash Register, but Won’t Spend Ten Minutes Tidying Her Room]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/she-can-spend-all-day-making-a-cash-register-but-wont-spend-ten-minutes-tidying-her-room-8642aa3d151c?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8642aa3d151c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[child-development]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[familylife]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[parenting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[motherhood]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 07 Nov 2026 18:06:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-07T18:06:32.660Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*fvPDA5T9SXHHBIIdStmbLA.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>My daughter can build a working cardboard cash register on her own, yet still needs reminders to tidy her room. Why does growing up happen so unevenly?</em></strong></p><p>By Jane Sonnenschein October 18, 2026</p><p>Over the past month or two, I’ve become increasingly aware of some changes in my nine-year-old daughter, Alicia.</p><p>Sometimes she does things that genuinely surprise me. I even find myself wondering whether I’ve been underestimating her abilities all along. But at other times, she can make me so frustrated over the simplest everyday things that I hardly know what to say.</p><p>Take tonight, for example. Before going to bed, I looked into her room and found it in a complete mess again.</p><p>Just a few days ago, she had spent an entire morning rearranging her bed, desk, and bookshelf. Her bed used to be on the left side of the room, with her desk on the other side. But she came up with a new layout herself and moved several pieces of furniture into different positions.</p><p>When I heard what she’d done, I was genuinely astonished.</p><p>I couldn’t even imagine how she had managed to move that bed on her own. Chris told me she’d done everything herself. And when I went into her room to have a look, I had to admit that her new arrangement really did make the space feel much bigger.</p><p>I praised her at the time. I hadn’t expected her not only to be capable of organizing things, but also to have her own ideas about how an entire room should be arranged.</p><p>And this wasn’t the first time she’d surprised me.</p><p>Not long before that, she had taken our terribly messy refrigerator and organized it beautifully. Then she turned her attention to the kitchen shelves, where we kept food in all kinds of awkwardly shaped packages.</p><p>Two boxes had been crammed full of things: dried seaweed, soy milk, red dates, pickled mustard greens, and packets of seasoning, all mixed together. I’d tried sorting them out myself and eventually found the whole thing rather overwhelming.</p><p>In the end, Alicia took everything out and arranged it all neatly again.</p><p>Because her own room had been messy for so long, I’d come to think of her as a child who simply didn’t have much sense of order.</p><p>But after seeing her do these things one after another, I realized that she wasn’t just capable of tidying up. She actually had some very good ideas about arranging spaces and organizing objects into categories.</p><p>And yet, when I looked at her room again tonight, I couldn’t help sighing.</p><p>She’s been doing a lot of arts and crafts lately, and the materials are everywhere. There are scraps of paper and little objects scattered across her desk, the floor, and the area around her bed.</p><p>The room she’d worked so hard to rearrange only a few days earlier had already returned to its usual messy state.</p><p>Then there’s her wardrobe.</p><p>I’d folded her clean clothes and left them in the living room. Several times, I’d reminded her that she had time during the autumn school holidays to take them back to her room and put them away.</p><p>She agreed each time, but she was clearly reluctant.</p><p>Today she said to me again, “Mum, I don’t want to do it. Could you do it with me tomorrow?”</p><p>I really didn’t know what to say.</p><p>I’ve already helped her organize that wardrobe countless times. Sometimes we’ve spent almost an entire day doing it.</p><p>Everything looks lovely when we’re finished. But afterwards, she starts stuffing clothes into it again without much thought. Eventually, it gets so full and messy that clothes sometimes fall out when we open the door.</p><p>I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve reminded her about these things.</p><p>When you’ve finished making something, put the materials away. Throw away the scraps of paper you’ve cut off. When your clothes have been folded, put them back in the wardrobe.</p><p>None of these tasks is particularly difficult on its own.</p><p>But she simply doesn’t want to do them without being reminded.</p><p>And yet, just a few days ago, she made something that amazed me all over again.</p><p>Her friend Lina, who lives downstairs, has a toy cash register. Alicia really liked it and wanted to borrow it for a while, but Lina didn’t want to lend it to her.</p><p>So Alicia thought, if she couldn’t borrow one, why not make one herself?</p><p>And that’s exactly what she did.</p><p>She built a cash register out of cardboard.</p><p>It wasn’t simply a matter of finding an empty box and drawing a few buttons on it.</p><p>First, she worked out how she wanted it to be constructed. She drew plans on cardboard, decided on the measurements, and then cut, folded, and glued the pieces together to turn flat sheets into a three-dimensional structure.</p><p>There was even a drawer underneath that could be pulled out, with paper money she’d made herself inside.</p><p>She also made a handheld scanner and decorated the cash register with her favorite cartoon designs.</p><p>When I saw it, I casually suggested, “Why don’t you make a receipt too?”</p><p>She thought about that for a moment and started working out where the receipt should come from.</p><p>Eventually, she designed a small paper dispenser on the side of the cash register, so it could imitate the way a real machine prints a receipt after a card payment.</p><p>She even made her own bank card, complete with a drawing of a chip and a contactless payment symbol.</p><p>There were a few misspelled English words on the cash register. But that wasn’t what caught my attention.</p><p>What amazed me was that she’d done almost everything herself, from the initial idea to the finished product.</p><p>The body of the cash register and its drawer were particularly interesting. She’d used cardboard and paper of different thicknesses, and the measurements had to fit together.</p><p>She needed to think ahead about how the materials would look once folded and how the different parts could be assembled.</p><p>Even just looking at the finished cash register, I could see how much thinking must have gone into it.</p><p>And she was willing to spend most of a day, perhaps even an entire day, working with those pieces of cardboard, making adjustments until she had created exactly what she wanted.</p><p>When she finished, she told me she wanted to give the cash register to me.</p><p>And that wasn’t all.</p><p>A few days earlier, she’d also crocheted a little three-dimensional doll, complete with a head, body, arms, legs, and a hat.</p><p>When I was a child, I watched my mother knit sweaters, and I learned a little basic knitting myself.</p><p>As an adult, I once knitted a scarf for Chris, which remains one of the very few things I’ve made.</p><p>But crocheting a three-dimensional doll like that? I have absolutely no idea how to do it.</p><p>Alicia, however, was able to watch videos on her own, study the stitches and shapes, and eventually make a complete doll.</p><p>So I’ve increasingly come to feel that she has a genuine interest in making things with her hands, along with some abilities that deserve to be developed further.</p><p>And she certainly isn’t a child who lacks patience.</p><p>Quite the opposite.</p><p>When she really wants to do something, she can concentrate on it for hours. She looks for solutions herself, makes adjustments when something doesn’t work, and keeps going without anyone having to remind her.</p><p>So why does she seem to become a completely different person when it comes to putting clothes away, cleaning up her craft materials, or reviewing what she’s learned at school?</p><p>That’s the question I’ve been struggling with lately.</p><p>Not long ago, Alicia and I had several disagreements over her German studies.</p><p>She’s already in fourth grade. Her German reading isn’t a major problem, and her English is very good. But her written expression, spelling, and punctuation still need quite a bit of practice.</p><p>I want her to gradually learn how to review her own work.</p><p>She needs to understand which words she can spell correctly, which things she hasn’t yet mastered, and how to correct mistakes once she’s made them.</p><p>But she still seems very used to simply completing whatever tasks someone else gives her.</p><p>If Mum tells her to do a worksheet, she does the worksheet. If she’s asked to read a few pages of a novel and write a short summary, she completes those tasks.</p><p>But once she’s finished, she rarely stops to consider what she still doesn’t understand or which mistakes she needs to practice again.</p><p>Sometimes, when she spells a word incorrectly and I ask her to practice it a few more times, she becomes very reluctant.</p><p>I find that especially difficult to understand.</p><p>How can she spend an entire day designing and making a toy she likes, yet be unwilling to spend a few minutes practicing a word she doesn’t know how to spell?</p><p>Gradually, though, I began to realize that there might be an important difference here.</p><p>She’s capable of taking the initiative when she’s doing something she has chosen for herself.</p><p>But she hasn’t yet learned how to take the same initiative with things she hasn’t chosen, even when they’re necessary parts of everyday life.</p><p>When she was making the cash register, she had a clear goal.</p><p>She wanted that particular toy, and she wanted to make it herself.</p><p>She knew what she was trying to achieve, and she could keep changing and improving things until the finished product matched what she had imagined.</p><p>Putting clothes away is different.</p><p>You tidy your clothes today, but a few days later you have to do it again. You put away your craft supplies, only to take them out again tomorrow.</p><p>There isn’t much novelty in these tasks, and they don’t leave you with a finished creation you can admire for days afterwards.</p><p>Some of the repetitive exercises involved in schoolwork are much the same.</p><p>You learn how to spell a word today, but you may need to review it again two days later. You solve a maths problem correctly, but next time you still need to be able to solve it independently.</p><p>For a child, these things may not provide the same immediate sense of satisfaction as finishing a handmade creation.</p><p>But the problem is that life can’t consist entirely of things we enjoy doing.</p><p>Someone can be wonderfully creative and still need to learn to put their clothes back in the wardrobe, throw away rubbish, and complete the schoolwork they’re responsible for.</p><p>So I’ve come to think that what Alicia really needs to develop may not be an interest in everything she’s expected to do.</p><p>Instead, she needs to gradually learn that even when something isn’t particularly interesting, she can still find a way of doing it that works for her, get it done, and keep doing it over time.</p><p>Of course, that’s much easier to say than to put into practice.</p><p>And lately, I’ve also been noticing changes in Alicia in another part of her life.</p><p>Since I started working in September, our family’s daily arrangements have changed quite a bit.</p><p>In the past, I used to take Alicia to her martial arts school every Friday.</p><p>But after I became busier with work, I wanted Chris to take over. Unfortunately, he often had headaches or wasn’t feeling well enough to take her.</p><p>So we decided to try letting Alicia travel there by tram on her own.</p><p>The route isn’t particularly complicated. It’s only three stops, and she knows the way.</p><p>But the first time we suggested that she go by herself, she was very hesitant. She kept saying she couldn’t do it and was worried about going alone.</p><p>Eventually, she agreed to give it a try.</p><p>She arrived at the school without any problems and came home on time.</p><p>What surprised me was that after that first trip, she simply started going to her martial arts school by herself.</p><p>We no longer needed to take her there every Friday.</p><p>There have been other changes too.</p><p>Previously, whenever she wanted to ride her bicycle, I had to help her carry it up from the basement.</p><p>Now she can carry it up those steps herself and then head off on her bike.</p><p>A little while ago, a thirteen-year-old friend came over to visit.</p><p>That evening, her friend needed to take public transport to the railway station to meet her mother. Alicia suggested accompanying her and then coming home by herself.</p><p>I asked, “Are you sure you can go there with her and then take the tram back on your own?”</p><p>She answered confidently that she could.</p><p>So the two girls travelled to the railway station together. Her friend and the friend’s mother saw Alicia onto the tram for the return journey.</p><p>I stayed in contact with her by phone throughout the trip, and she eventually arrived home safely.</p><p>Only when she got downstairs did she tell me that she’d actually felt a little frightened.</p><p>It had already become dark, and the streetlights near our building weren’t particularly bright.</p><p>I told her, “You were very brave.”</p><p>Because to me, a child managing to do something independently doesn’t mean that she never felt afraid along the way.</p><p>She may still hesitate or feel nervous. But she’s beginning to realize that even when she’s a little frightened, she is capable of getting things done on her own.</p><p>Recently, she also told me about something that had happened while she was travelling to her martial arts class.</p><p>She noticed that a manhole cover seemed to be loose and nearly stepped on it.</p><p>She recognized the danger, tried to move the cover, and placed a stone on top of it.</p><p>Of course, something like that is better left to adults, so she doesn’t risk hurting herself.</p><p>But even from this small incident, I could see that she’s beginning to observe her surroundings, recognize potential problems, and respond to situations independently when she’s outside.</p><p>None of these changes happened because we suddenly came up with some special parenting plan and started training her to do things one by one.</p><p>Much of it happened simply because I started working and could no longer arrange every little detail of her life as I had before.</p><p>Places where Mum used to take her are now places she goes by herself.</p><p>The bicycle Mum used to carry upstairs is now something she can carry on her own.</p><p>And the room she once needed Mum to help organize is becoming a space she’s learning to arrange according to her own ideas.</p><p>It suddenly occurred to me that a child’s independence doesn’t necessarily begin only when the parents believe the child is ready.</p><p>Sometimes life gives a child an opportunity first.</p><p>And only after trying something for the first time does the child discover that she was capable of doing it all along.</p><p>Recently, we also bought Alicia a small suitcase.</p><p>After the autumn holidays, her school is organizing a three-day class trip for the fourth graders. The children will spend several days away from home with their teachers and classmates.</p><p>While we were buying the suitcase, I suddenly had a strange feeling.</p><p>She’s really getting close to finishing primary school.</p><p>I’d always felt that children grew so slowly.</p><p>For a while, I even wanted to measure her height every few days. But no matter how often I measured, there hardly seemed to be any change.</p><p>Then I stopped measuring for a month or two.</p><p>When I checked again, she’d grown by at least 2.5 centimetres.</p><p>Perhaps that’s simply how children grow.</p><p>When you live with them every day, it’s surprisingly difficult to notice all those small changes.</p><p>Then one day, you look back and realize how many things they can now do that once required your help.</p><p>And the funny thing is that even while I’m amazed by all these changes, Alicia can still drive me up the wall by refusing to tidy her wardrobe.</p><p>She can spend an entire morning rearranging the furniture in her room, but won’t spend a little time putting her clothes away.</p><p>She can design complicated craft projects herself, yet won’t clean up the scraps of paper scattered across the floor.</p><p>She can take the tram to martial arts classes on her own, but still needs me to remind her to complete some of her regular schoolwork.</p><p>I used to find all of this terribly contradictory.</p><p>But the more I think about it, the more I wonder whether our understanding of growing up is simply too focused on everything developing together, neatly and at the same pace.</p><p>It’s almost as though we expect a child, once she’s growing up, to become responsible, independent, and self-disciplined all at once.</p><p>She should be able to take care of herself, study seriously, and keep her life organized.</p><p>But real growth doesn’t seem to work that way.</p><p>A child may have come a long way in certain areas while still needing repeated reminders in others.</p><p>Alicia can build a cardboard cash register that I wouldn’t even know how to make, yet she still hasn’t developed the habit of putting her clothes away.</p><p>That doesn’t mean her abilities in the first area aren’t real.</p><p>And it doesn’t mean the problems in the second area should be ignored.</p><p><strong>Both are real.</strong></p><p>As parents, we shouldn’t stop expecting our children to develop basic habits simply because they’re doing well in certain areas.</p><p>But neither should we overlook the progress they’ve already made just because they continue to struggle with other things.</p><p>All this has made me think about something we often say we want our children to develop: initiative.</p><p>But how does initiative actually develop?</p><p>If a child can already think independently, look for solutions, and take action when doing something she enjoys, perhaps what she needs isn’t another long lecture about responsibility.</p><p>Perhaps she needs to gradually learn how to apply the abilities she already has to those everyday tasks that don’t interest her quite as much.</p><p>But it’s not as simple as saying to her, “If you can make a cash register, why can’t you put your clothes away?”</p><p>Because completing a creative project you’re excited about and consistently doing something repetitive and boring are not exactly the same ability.</p><p>The first requires interest, imagination, and a willingness to solve problems.</p><p>The second also requires habits, a sense of responsibility, and the willingness to act even when there isn’t much enjoyment involved.</p><p>Perhaps that’s what makes raising and educating children so difficult.</p><p>We can’t teach our children to do only the things they enjoy.</p><p>But at the same time, we shouldn’t overlook the interests and abilities that are already growing naturally within them simply because they struggle with certain repetitive tasks.</p><p>And I’m still trying to find the right balance myself.</p><p>When I saw Alicia’s messy room tonight, I was still angry.</p><p>Understanding more about her personality and abilities hasn’t suddenly made me perfectly calm about finding craft supplies scattered everywhere and clothes that haven’t been put away.</p><p>Especially now that I’m tired from work myself, I simply don’t have the energy to spend an entire day tidying her room for her, as I sometimes did in the past.</p><p>I want her to take responsibility for her own things.</p><p>That expectation hasn’t changed.</p><p>But at the same time, I can see more clearly than before that she’s genuinely growing.</p><p>It’s just that the direction and pace of that growth don’t always match what I expect.</p><p>She can now go out on her own, help her friends, design and make her own creations, and begin organizing her living space according to her own ideas.</p><p>All these changes have happened within just the past month or two.</p><p>And perhaps the reason I’ve been able to connect them is that I’ve started taking writing seriously this year.</p><p>In the past, many things happened in everyday life and were soon forgotten.</p><p>If Alicia tidied the kitchen, I’d praise her.</p><p>If she took the tram by herself, I’d be happy about it.</p><p>If she made a toy, I’d think it was interesting.</p><p>Then a few days would pass, and I’d forget about it.</p><p>But now, because I keep recording and looking back on these experiences, I’m gradually beginning to see that all those little moments, which once seemed unrelated, are actually becoming part of the story of a child growing up.</p><p>We often feel that everyday life is much the same.</p><p>We work, cook, go to school, go to bed, and repeat the same things the next day.</p><p>But when we look back at our children, we suddenly realize how much time has quietly changed.</p><p>The child who once needed someone to hold her hand and accompany her can now take the tram by herself.</p><p>The child who didn’t know how to organize her room is beginning to design the space according to her own ideas.</p><p>The child who once simply played with toys can now draw plans, cut cardboard, and make a toy that actually works.</p><p>And yet, that same child, who is slowly growing up, will still leave her room in a complete mess.</p><p>She’ll even say to her mother, quite confidently, “Could you do it with me tomorrow?”</p><p>When I think about it, sometimes I find it funny. Other times, I feel rather helpless.</p><p>Perhaps this is simply what growing up looks like.</p><p>She becomes more and more capable while still having plenty of things left to learn.</p><p>And as parents, we can only keep appreciating the abilities she’s already developed while continuing to teach her how to take responsibility for the things she hasn’t yet learned to manage.</p><p>As for why she’s willing to spend an entire day making a cash register but won’t spend ten minutes tidying her room, I still haven’t found an answer that explains everything.</p><p>But I’m increasingly beginning to feel that instead of repeatedly asking why she doesn’t want to do something, perhaps there are more useful questions to explore.</p><p>How can we help a child gradually learn to take action even when she isn’t interested in the task?</p><p>And how can we teach responsibility without wearing away the enthusiasm and creativity that are already so naturally part of who she is?</p><p>I think these are things I’ll need to keep observing and learning about.</p><h4>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8642aa3d151c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[As Knowledge Becomes Easier to Access, Judgment May Be What’s Truly Scarce]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/as-knowledge-becomes-easier-to-access-judgment-may-be-whats-truly-scarce-848cf1bcd074?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/848cf1bcd074</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[future-of-education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-thinking]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[technology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[artificial-intelligence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 22:47:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-04T22:47:05.963Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*veXo2sl6QTuIhhvDAk9eeA.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>AI makes it easier than ever to learn and create, but how do we know which answers to trust, when to question them, and what we’re truly capable of?</em></strong></p><p>By Jane Sonnenschein September 16, 2026</p><p>Some time ago, a friend of Chris’s was working on a piece of software that could run locally on a computer. More precisely, he was developing a local workflow for managing a company’s internal documents.</p><p>The idea was actually quite easy to understand. Many companies have large amounts of internal information, including business data, contracts, customer records, and other documents that shouldn’t simply be uploaded to external platforms.</p><p>If those files could be kept locally and organized through a piece of software, a company owner who wanted to know something about the business would no longer have to search through dozens of documents. They could simply ask a question, and the system would look for the answer in the company’s own files.</p><p>It sounded convenient, and it also seemed to address a growing concern among businesses: data security.</p><p>The interesting part was that the person developing this software wasn’t a programmer. He knew almost nothing about coding.</p><p>In the past, that would probably have been the end of the story. Even with an excellent idea, someone who couldn’t program would have found it very difficult to turn that idea into a working product on their own.</p><p>But now there is AI.</p><p>He could describe what he wanted to build, ask AI to generate the code, and gradually put the whole program together.</p><p>And something quite interesting happened. A field that once required considerable professional knowledge to enter had become accessible to someone without any formal training. He could actually build a product that worked.</p><p>After listening to his friend explain the project, Chris asked several questions about security.</p><p>How exactly did the software handle company documents? Did the data really stay on the local computer? Which third-party components did the program use, and were those components secure? Could the AI-generated code contain vulnerabilities? And if companies eventually started using the software, what would happen when something went wrong?</p><p>His friend couldn’t really answer those questions.</p><p>I don’t think he was necessarily trying to avoid them. He might simply not have known how to answer.</p><p>After all, when someone doesn’t understand programming, AI can help them write code. But it cannot also install into their mind all the professional judgment that an experienced programmer has developed over many years.</p><p>That conversation left me thinking about something:</p><p><strong>AI can lower the barrier to doing something, but it cannot take responsibility for you when you do it wrong.</strong></p><p>A program that runs is not necessarily a program that is secure. A product that looks useful is not necessarily ready to be used by a company.</p><p>This becomes especially important when the software involves internal business data, access permissions, privacy, security vulnerabilities, copyright, or software licensing.</p><p>The hardest part is often no longer getting a particular feature to work. It is knowing whether something is wrong with what you’ve built, and whether anyone will have the ability to identify the problem when something goes wrong.</p><p>In the past, professional barriers also served as a kind of filter.</p><p>Someone who couldn’t write code usually couldn’t build a program at all, so many potential risks never reached the stage where a product could actually be offered to others.</p><p>Now AI has opened that first door. Even without a professional background, someone can quickly gain part of the practical ability that once took years of training to develop.</p><p>That is, of course, an extraordinary change.</p><p>But it also creates another problem.</p><p>When making something becomes increasingly easy, understanding what you’ve actually made becomes even more important.</p><p>A few days ago, I came across another online conversation, this time between a content creator and a man in his forties.</p><p>The man hadn’t received much formal education when he was young, and he had always felt that his limited qualifications had held him back.</p><p>He had spent many years living and working in Beijing, away from his hometown and separated from his wife and child for long periods. He was one of the many people sometimes described in China as <em>běipiāo</em>¹.</p><p>Eventually, because his parents were in poor health and his child was about to enter senior high school, he decided to end those years in Beijing and return to his hometown in Inner Mongolia.</p><p>His work was seasonal, and there wasn’t much for him to do during the winter.</p><p>That made him anxious. Should he find another job?</p><p>Judging by his savings, his family was actually unlikely to face serious financial difficulties for several years. But even so, after just a few months without work, he began to feel insecure, almost as if life would slip out of his control unless he continued earning money.</p><p>Another major source of anxiety was his child.</p><p>The child was in the final year of junior middle school, equivalent to ninth grade, and was already under considerable academic pressure.</p><p>The father hadn’t gone far in school when he was young. Although he later earned a junior college diploma through adult education, he still felt that many career opportunities had remained closed to him because of his educational background.</p><p>Naturally, he didn’t want his child to follow the same path.</p><p>The content creator suggested that education in the future might not always work the way it does today.</p><p>Why did our modern school system take shape during the industrial age?</p><p>To a large extent, it was because a modern society operating on a large scale needed a relatively standardized way to educate large numbers of people.</p><p>Children entered school according to their age, studied broadly similar subjects, took standardized or comparable examinations, and then moved through different stages of selection based on their qualifications.</p><p>The advantages of such a system are obvious. It can operate on a large scale, and it provides a relatively consistent way to judge what kind of training someone has received, even when it is impossible to know every individual personally.</p><p>But if AI continues to develop, could this way of selecting people change?</p><p>The content creator believed that individual differences might become increasingly important in the future.</p><p>What a child genuinely enjoys, what they are good at, and which subjects they are willing to explore deeply over many years might come to matter more than having everyone complete the same training according to the same pattern.</p><p>I don’t know whether academic qualifications will lose their current importance as quickly as he suggested over the next ten years. Nor do I know what schools will actually look like in the future.</p><p>But the conversation reminded me of something more fundamental.</p><p>Knowledge itself is becoming easier and easier to access.</p><p>A few hundred years ago, if an ordinary person wanted to learn a craft, they couldn’t simply open a webpage, find a book, or ask AI a question.</p><p>In many trades, they first had to become an apprentice under a master, a traditional practice known in Chinese as <em>bàishī</em>².</p><p>They would enter the master’s workshop, but that didn’t mean they would immediately begin learning the actual skills.</p><p>At first, they might be expected to do odd jobs, run errands, serve tea, and help with everyday tasks.</p><p>Only after spending a long time together and proving themselves trustworthy would the master gradually begin passing on their knowledge and experience.</p><p>Even then, traditional craftspeople often kept a few tricks of the trade to themselves.</p><p>Their knowledge was what allowed them to make a living.</p><p>Knowing a method that other people didn’t know gave someone a competitive advantage. There was little reason to teach another person absolutely everything without holding anything back.</p><p>In those days, gaining access to knowledge was difficult in itself.</p><p>Once someone entered a particular trade, they might remain in it for the rest of their life. Changing fields meant finding a new way in, becoming an apprentice again, and spending years accumulating experience from the beginning.</p><p>Much of that knowledge wasn’t written down in books, waiting for someone to look it up.</p><p>It existed in certain people’s minds. To gain access to it, you first had to enter their network of relationships.</p><p>The internet has already changed this enormously.</p><p>And AI has taken things a step further.</p><p>In the past, you at least needed to know which keywords to search for, which books might be useful, or which websites to visit.</p><p>Now, even if you have only a very vague idea, you can simply tell AI:</p><p>“I want to make something like this. Tell me how I should begin.”</p><p>This means that an ordinary person can now enter many completely unfamiliar fields at a remarkably low cost.</p><p>Don’t know how to code? AI can help you write the code.</p><p>Don’t know how to build a website? AI can help you create one.</p><p>Can’t translate something? AI can translate it for you.</p><p>Don’t know how to design something? AI can suggest an initial approach.</p><p>Even if someone knows almost nothing about a particular field, through an ongoing conversation with AI, they can quickly develop a basic understanding of its main ideas and problems. In the past, reaching that point might have required reading a great deal of material.</p><p>What has changed here may be more than productivity.</p><p><strong>It is the scarcity of knowledge itself.</strong></p><p>And if we look a little further into the future, what might happen if brain-computer interfaces eventually become advanced enough for people to store large amounts of information directly in their brains, almost as easily as saving files on a computer?</p><p>Imagine that learning a language, which currently takes years, could one day involve directly transferring hundreds of thousands of words, grammar rules, and examples of actual language use into the brain.</p><p>Or imagine that instead of spending years studying a subject, a person could acquire a large amount of its foundational information in a very short time.</p><p>If that ever became possible, the kind of learning that currently requires us to spend enormous amounts of time memorizing information might change fundamentally.</p><p>But that is also where another problem would appear.</p><p>Suppose I suddenly had ten thousand books stored in my brain.</p><p>Would that mean I possessed all the abilities represented by those ten thousand books?</p><p>Not necessarily.</p><p>If someone asked me, “Do you know this book?”</p><p>Of course I would.</p><p>My brain might even be able to retrieve it instantly.</p><p>But when I faced a real problem, would I know which of those books to use?</p><p>And even if I knew which book to look at, would I know which method in it was suitable for the situation in front of me?</p><p>If three theories contradicted one another, which one should I believe?</p><p>If a particular method had worked in the past, but circumstances had since changed, would I recognize that it was no longer suitable?</p><p>And if I faced a completely new problem, something nobody had encountered before, could I bring together knowledge from several very different fields and develop a new solution?</p><p>At that point, the amount of information I possessed would no longer be the deciding factor.</p><p>What would matter is whether I had developed my own way of organizing and making sense of that knowledge.</p><p>This is why I increasingly feel that the most important ability in the age of AI may not be how much information we have in our heads.</p><p>It may be whether we can judge when that information is useful, and whether the answers we receive can actually be trusted.</p><p>Writing is very similar.</p><p>Today, anyone can give AI a title and ask it to produce an article of about two thousand Chinese characters.</p><p>If they wanted to, generating a hundred articles in a single day wouldn’t be particularly difficult.</p><p>But then come the questions.</p><p>Does that article actually say what you wanted to say?</p><p>Do you agree with the opinions it expresses?</p><p>Are the facts it refers to true?</p><p>Has it quietly added a position that you never expressed in the first place?</p><p>If someone has no ideas or judgment of their own, and simply thinks, “Well, that sounds pretty convincing,” before repeatedly copying and publishing AI-generated content, they are not necessarily developing stronger writing skills.</p><p>They are simply accumulating more text produced by a machine.</p><p>As these tools become more powerful, I find it even more important to understand who I am, what I want to express, and what I believe is right.</p><p>Without that understanding, the more powerful our tools become, the easier it may be for us to hand over our own thinking.</p><p>Chris’s friend and his software project are really another example of the same problem.</p><p>His idea was a good one, and AI gave him the ability to turn it into something real for the first time. That is certainly something worth encouraging.</p><p>But if companies were eventually going to place large amounts of internal information into his software, he would also need to face a very different set of questions.</p><p>Is the AI-generated code secure?</p><p>Which third-party components does it use?</p><p>Does the data really remain on the local computer?</p><p>Could someone bypass its access controls?</p><p>Might a software update introduce new vulnerabilities?</p><p>And if something goes wrong, who will be able to understand the code well enough to find the cause?</p><p>These questions don’t simply disappear because the program happens to be running successfully.</p><p>If he doesn’t have the knowledge to make those judgments himself, then he needs to find someone who genuinely understands these issues and can review the software.</p><p>Because AI may be able to write tens of thousands of lines of code for you, but when a serious problem occurs, it cannot step forward and say:</p><p>“I’ll take responsibility.”</p><p>The person who approves the product, launches it, and allows customer data to be placed into it is still a human being.</p><p>So I’ve increasingly come to feel that the biggest change in the future may not be whether people still need to learn.</p><p>It may be what we actually need to learn.</p><p>If knowledge becomes easier and easier to obtain, perhaps education really won’t need to spend so much time on mechanical memorization and repeatedly passing information from one person to another.</p><p>But that doesn’t mean people can afford to have less and less understanding of their own.</p><p>Quite the opposite.</p><p>We may need to learn even more about logic, judgment, verification, asking questions, creating things, solving problems, and understanding ourselves.</p><p>A person needs to know what they are good at.</p><p>They also need to recognize what they don’t understand.</p><p>They need to know when to trust a tool and when to question it.</p><p>They need to recognize that an answer can look beautifully written and still be wrong.</p><p>And when they encounter an unfamiliar problem, they need to know how to find the most relevant knowledge among everything they have learned, then bring different pieces of it together in a useful way.</p><p>If every child really does have a personal AI tutor in the future, the most important question won’t simply be whether AI knows how to teach.</p><p>The child will also need to gradually understand where they learn quickly and where they keep making mistakes.</p><p>They will need to learn how to ask questions, how to check answers, and how to tell their AI tutor what they genuinely understand and what they are struggling with.</p><p>Only then can they use the tool to help create a learning path that better suits them.</p><p>AI may come to understand a person better and better.</p><p>But that person also needs to understand themselves better and better.</p><p>In the past, when knowledge was scarce, one person’s greatest advantage might have been:</p><p>“I know something you don’t.”</p><p>As knowledge becomes cheaper and more accessible, that advantage may gradually diminish.</p><p>Perhaps what will increasingly distinguish one person from another is a different ability.</p><p><strong>Faced with the same information, some people merely possess it, while others know how to use it.</strong></p><p>If the day ever comes when we really can place ten thousand books directly into our brains, I don’t think humanity’s most important question will be:</p><p>“How many books do I have in my head?”</p><p>It will still be this:</p><p>When the real world presents me with a problem I’ve never encountered before, will I know which knowledge to draw from those ten thousand books?</p><p>And will I know when even the answers in those books should no longer be followed without question?</p><h3>Notes</h3><p><strong>1. Běipiāo (北漂)</strong></p><p><em>Běipiāo</em> is a Chinese term commonly used to describe people who move to Beijing from other parts of China in search of work, education, or better opportunities, often without having permanent roots in the city.</p><p>The word combines <em>Běi</em> (北), referring to Beijing, and <em>piāo</em> (漂), meaning to drift or float.</p><p>The expression carries more than the simple meaning of migration. It often suggests the uncertainty of building a life in a large city, the pressure of earning a living, separation from family, and the feeling of not quite belonging. Some people eventually settle in Beijing, while others return to their hometowns after many years.</p><p>In this essay, the term describes the man’s long experience of working in Beijing while living apart from his family.</p><p><strong>2. Bàishī (拜师)</strong></p><p><em>Bàishī</em> refers to the traditional practice of formally becoming a student or apprentice under a master, especially in fields such as craftsmanship, martial arts, traditional medicine, and other skills passed down through personal instruction.</p><p>The expression literally means to acknowledge or pay respect to a master.</p><p>Historically, learning a trade often involved more than receiving technical instruction. An apprentice might spend years helping with everyday work, observing the master, and gradually earning trust before being taught more specialized knowledge.</p><p>The relationship could involve expectations of loyalty, respect, and personal obligation. Masters sometimes chose not to reveal all their techniques, partly because those skills were also the basis of their livelihood.</p><p>In this essay, <em>bàishī</em> illustrates a time when access to specialized knowledge often depended on personal relationships and long periods of apprenticeship, rather than simply being able to find information.</p><p>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=848cf1bcd074" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Many Success Stories Don’t Lie. They Just Leave Out the Conditions That Made Them Possible]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/many-success-stories-dont-lie-they-just-leave-out-the-conditions-that-made-them-possible-4481a4cf7245?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4481a4cf7245</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[self-reflection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-commentary]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[success]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Nov 2026 22:10:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-02T22:10:23.236Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1KLi_oLoZDaVVr82JigkNg.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Why talent and hard work are only part of the story — and how the opportunities we rarely hear about shape success.</em></strong></p><p>By Jane Sonnenschein July 21, 2026</p><p>“Success is never an isolated event. It always happens within a particular environment, with certain resources, and at a particular moment in history.” — Anonymous</p><p>We often come across stories like these.</p><p>A child shows extraordinary talent at a very young age, publishes a book as a teenager, and becomes successful and famous in their twenties. Someone from an ordinary background, with no connections or resources, manages to change their life through hard work alone. An entrepreneur starts a business in a tiny room and eventually builds a huge company. A mother looks after her children while using whatever spare moments she can find to write, and a few years later, she has built a career of her own.</p><p>These stories are not necessarily false.</p><p>The people involved may genuinely be talented, and they may have worked harder than most of us can imagine. They may have experienced failure, poverty, and self-doubt. Some may really have started with very little and gradually worked their way toward success.</p><p>The problem is that a story can be entirely true, sentence by sentence, and still leave people with a completely mistaken impression.</p><p>Because what many success stories do best is not invent things that never happened. It is leave out the conditions that others cannot easily reproduce, while keeping the results that appear to be within everyone’s reach.</p><h3>I</h3><p>Some time ago, while thinking again about <em>Shang Zhongyong</em> (伤仲永)¹, I gradually realized that our understanding of a “genius” comes not only from that person’s actual abilities, but also from the stories society later builds around them.</p><p>If a child can write poetry at an unusually young age, that certainly suggests a level of language ability beyond what most children of the same age possess. But there is a considerable distance between “this child can write poetry” and “this child becomes a famous prodigy known to everyone.” And much of what happens in between has little to do with talent itself.</p><p>First, someone has to notice the child.</p><p>That child needs to be born in a time when written records can be preserved. There must be people nearby who can read and write, someone capable of recognizing that the child’s work is unusual, and someone willing to share the story with others.</p><p>And even after the child has been noticed, someone must believe the story is worth telling.</p><p>An equally intelligent child born into a family without access to books or writing materials might have their abilities mentioned only occasionally by relatives. If the child grows up in an environment that places little value on those abilities, their efforts might even be dismissed as a waste of time.</p><p>The fact that we remember certain child prodigies from history does not necessarily mean they were the most intelligent or creative children of their time. It may simply mean they happened to become part of a social network in which their abilities could be recorded, discussed, and preserved.</p><p>The children whose stories were never recorded did not necessarily lack talent.</p><p>They simply never entered the historical record.</p><h3>II</h3><p>A person’s ability and their influence are not the same thing.</p><p>Ability belongs to the individual, but influence always depends on conditions beyond the individual.</p><p>Someone may be an excellent writer, but without a publisher, a platform for sharing their work, or access to readers who might appreciate it, their writing may never reach a wide audience.</p><p>On the other hand, someone’s work may not necessarily be better than everything produced by their contemporaries. Yet with better publishing opportunities, stronger connections, or a message that happens to capture the mood of the time, that person may quickly become widely known.</p><p>This is not to suggest that successful people have no ability, or that every achievement can be explained by luck and privilege.</p><p>I’ve simply become increasingly convinced that we need to separate several things we often treat as though they were the same.</p><p>Talent helps explain why someone is capable of creating something. Resources help explain why that creation has a chance to reach the wider world. And the circumstances of the time help explain why this particular person, at this particular moment, becomes visible to so many others.</p><p>These three things are connected, but they are not interchangeable.</p><p>Without ability, resources may not be enough to sustain someone’s influence over time. But ability alone, without resources or opportunities, may not be enough to carry their work beyond the boundaries of their private life.</p><p>Perhaps this is what the Chinese expression <em>tiānshí, dìlì, rénhé</em>² is getting at: the importance of timing, favorable conditions, and human support.</p><p>Yet when someone’s achievements are later turned into a success story, resources and historical circumstances often gradually disappear from the telling. What remains is individual talent and hard work.</p><p>As a result, the visibility created by resources is reinterpreted as evidence of personal ability. The achievements that follow from that visibility are then used to prove that the person was an unquestionable genius from the very beginning.</p><h3>III</h3><p>Why do we so often leave out these conditions?</p><p>One important reason is that complicated success does not make a very good story.</p><p>If we acknowledge that someone’s achievements are influenced by family resources, educational opportunities, personal connections, historical timing, physical health, geographical location, and unexpected events, the story becomes much harder to turn into a simple lesson.</p><p>Readers can no longer easily conclude, “If I do the same thing, I can succeed too.”</p><p>But a story that spreads widely usually needs to be simple enough for people to understand and remember.</p><p>He succeeded because he worked hard enough.</p><p>She succeeded because she never gave up.</p><p>That child became a genius because the parents valued education from an early age.</p><p>That ordinary person changed their life because they worked two hours longer than everyone else each day.</p><p>All these factors may genuinely have played a role. But they are only parts of a much larger chain of causes.</p><p>Once the other conditions have been removed, success begins to look like a question with one correct answer. Repeat the successful person’s actions, and you should be able to reproduce the same result.</p><p>Stories like these can give people hope and encourage them to take action, so they are not without value.</p><p>The real problem begins when someone puts in the same effort but does not achieve a similar result. The story that once seemed encouraging can suddenly turn around and judge them.</p><p>If someone else managed it, why can’t you?</p><p>Perhaps you haven’t worked hard enough.</p><p>Perhaps you didn’t really stick with it.</p><p>Perhaps you only talk about wanting to change your life, while constantly making excuses for yourself.</p><p>A story originally meant to inspire people ends up becoming a way to prove that those who haven’t succeeded are somehow not good enough.</p><h3>IV</h3><p>We rarely stop to ask what those apparently repeatable paths to success were actually built on.</p><p>We hear that a writer published their first book at twenty, but no one mentions that they grew up in a home filled with books, had parents who knew the publishing industry, and enjoyed enough financial security to spend years writing.</p><p>We hear that an entrepreneur started a company in a garage, but the story leaves out their strong educational background, established social connections, and the fact that they could afford to fail and still have another chance to begin again.</p><p>Or we hear that a nine-year-old child has published a book, and the story is presented as proof that age is never a limitation.</p><p>But for a nine-year-old to publish a book, adults must at least help organize the writing, find a suitable publishing platform, arrange the layout, design the cover, handle copyright matters, and take care of promotion and sales.</p><p>The child’s creativity may be entirely genuine. But the process of bringing that work to market is clearly not something a nine-year-old has completed alone.</p><p>If we tell only the part about publishing a book at nine, while leaving out the family’s investment, the technical tools, and the adults working behind the scenes, the story can easily become another source of pressure.</p><p>Look, another child has already published a book at nine. Why are you still just playing?</p><p>But perhaps the more interesting question is not why this child became successful so early. It is why the child’s ideas were taken seriously in the first place, and why the family was willing to help turn an idea into an actual book.</p><p>Talent explains why the child was able to write. Resources explain why the child was able to publish. And the circumstances of the time help explain why that child came to be presented as a remarkable young creator.</p><p>All these conditions are part of the story, yet usually only the first one remains.</p><h3>V</h3><p>I used to believe these stories quite easily myself.</p><p>I thought that if someone genuinely had ability, and if their work was good enough, sooner or later people would notice.</p><p>It wasn’t until I began writing regularly over a longer period that I gradually understood how many different abilities and circumstances lie between writing something good and having that work seen.</p><p>Writers need to understand how platforms work. They need to learn about titles, cover images, and ways of reaching readers. They need enough time to keep producing work, and they also need to carry on during long periods when little or no feedback arrives.</p><p>Even after a piece of writing becomes visible, whether readers stop to read it depends on many other things: how a platform distributes content, which subjects people are interested in, their reading habits, and sometimes a recommendation that happens by chance.</p><p>Someone may spend years developing a mature and thoughtful writing style, yet reach only a small number of readers because their work never finds a suitable way to circulate.</p><p>Another writer’s work may not necessarily be any more insightful, but because the topic, format, and timing happen to fit together, it may attract enormous attention in a very short time.</p><p>This doesn’t mean the second writer doesn’t deserve to be noticed, nor does it mean the first has necessarily been treated unfairly.</p><p>It simply shows that the value of a piece of work and the attention it receives are not the same thing.</p><p>Yet we live in a time when numbers are constantly used to judge value.</p><p>A high number of views seems to mean an article must be better. Having more followers seems to prove that someone is more capable. Selling more copies appears to confirm that a work has greater artistic value.</p><p>When visibility is repeatedly mistaken for ability, we gradually begin to judge ourselves by the same standards.</p><p>If nobody likes my writing, does that mean it isn’t good enough?</p><p>If nobody follows me, does that mean my ideas have no value?</p><p>If someone else succeeds much faster than I do, does that mean I was never talented in the first place?</p><p>What we forget is that the response someone receives from the wider world tells us only how many people happened to notice them on a particular platform, at a particular moment.</p><p>It cannot fully demonstrate what that person is capable of, and it certainly cannot determine their worth as a human being.</p><h3>VI</h3><p>Does acknowledging the conditions behind success risk becoming a way of making excuses for failure?</p><p>This is often the first concern people raise when they hear words like “resources,” “environment,” and “opportunity.”</p><p>They worry that once we begin emphasizing external circumstances, people will stop taking responsibility for their own lives and blame everything they have failed to achieve on the world around them.</p><p>That concern is not entirely unreasonable. People can indeed use broad explanations about society and its structures to avoid taking action on things they could actually change.</p><p>But recognizing the importance of circumstances does not mean denying the value of effort.</p><p>Quite the opposite. Only when we understand the conditions we are dealing with can we begin to see where our efforts might actually make a difference.</p><p>If the problem is that our work is not yet good enough, then we need to keep practicing and improving it. If the problem is a lack of ways to reach an audience, we need to learn how to make our work more visible. If we don’t have enough time, we may need to rethink how our daily lives are organized.</p><p>And if a particular path requires resources that an ordinary person simply cannot afford, perhaps the sensible thing is to adjust the goal rather than keep punishing ourselves for not having enough willpower.</p><p>Taking responsibility for our lives in a mature way doesn’t mean pretending that everyone starts from the same place. Nor does it mean believing that hard work can remove every objective limitation.</p><p>It means recognizing those limitations and then deciding what we can still do, what we are willing to take responsibility for, and which comparisons we would be better off letting go.</p><p>Effort matters, but effort is not a kind of magic that can erase real differences between people’s circumstances.</p><h3>VII</h3><p>Rethinking the way we tell success stories is not about destroying hope or suggesting that people’s achievements are unworthy of respect.</p><p>We simply need a more honest way of telling these stories.</p><p>Someone may succeed because they genuinely have ability, because they have worked hard over many years, and also because they had access to certain resources, met certain people, and found themselves in the right place at the right moment in history.</p><p>Acknowledging these conditions does not diminish what they have achieved.</p><p>On the contrary, it helps us understand more accurately how a person’s life came to take the shape it did.</p><p>And only when we see this fuller picture can we avoid turning someone else’s results into a judgment against ourselves. We may also stop presenting achievements that only a very small number of people could realistically attain as standards that everyone else is expected to meet.</p><p>Genuine genius is a kind of ability. But being recognized by society as a “genius” is also a story that gets told about someone.</p><p>A person may possess extraordinary ability without ever receiving that recognition. Another may become, through timing, resources, and publicity, a much more dazzling figure in the public imagination than their actual abilities alone would suggest.</p><p>Of course, we can admire successful people and learn from their experiences.</p><p>But before trying to follow the same path, perhaps we should first ask ourselves: Which conditions have been included in this story, and which have quietly been left out?</p><p>Because many success stories don’t lie.</p><p>They simply leave out the conditions that mattered most, and that are often the hardest for anyone else to reproduce.</p><h3>Notes</h3><p><strong>1. Shāng Zhòngyǒng (伤仲永)</strong></p><p><em>Shang Zhongyong</em>, often translated as <em>On Zhongyong</em>, is a classical Chinese prose essay by Wang Anshi (王安石, 1021–1086), a writer and statesman of the Song dynasty.</p><p>The essay tells the story of Fang Zhongyong, a boy from an ordinary family who displayed an extraordinary ability to compose poetry at a very young age, despite having received no formal education. His father began taking him around to impress others rather than ensuring that he received a proper education. As Zhongyong grew older, his remarkable early abilities gradually faded, until he was no longer noticeably different from other people.</p><p>The essay has long been used in Chinese education to discuss the relationship between natural talent, learning, and upbringing. In this article, the reference also raises a related question: why some gifted children become known to history while others remain invisible.</p><p><strong>2. Tiānshí, dìlì, rénhé (天时、地利、人和)</strong></p><p>This traditional Chinese expression refers to three kinds of favorable conditions: <em>tiānshí</em> (天时), the right timing or circumstances; <em>dìlì</em> (地利), advantages provided by one’s location or environment; and <em>rénhé</em> (人和), cooperation, relationships, and support from other people.</p><p>The expression has roots in classical Chinese thought and is commonly used to explain why success often depends on more than individual effort. It suggests that timing, circumstances, and human relationships can work together to make something possible.</p><p>In the context of this essay, it captures the idea that talent and hard work matter, but their results are also shaped by opportunities, resources, and the social conditions in which a person lives.</p><h4>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4481a4cf7245" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Does Today’s Education System Seem to Be Overlooking People with Real Potential?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/why-does-todays-education-system-seem-to-be-overlooking-people-with-real-potential-003ae202d8e8?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/003ae202d8e8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[education]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[machine-learning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[critical-thinking]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 Oct 2026 22:54:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-31T22:54:36.473Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*i3GYyFTYP-U83rCwYZiyQg.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Why good grades and standardized tests don’t always reveal a person’s true potential — and what education might be missing.</em></strong></p><p>By Jane Sonnenschein First written on April 21, 2026 Revised on October 31, 2026</p><p>Some time ago, I came across a news report, or perhaps it was a discussion about how companies recruit people. I can no longer remember exactly which company was involved, but one idea stayed with me.</p><p>Apparently, some large companies in China had begun exploring a different approach to recruitment. Instead of waiting until students graduated from university, they were considering selecting promising young people straight out of high school and helping them develop their abilities through practical work and ongoing training.</p><p>When I first read about it, I wasn’t particularly surprised. My immediate reaction was that it actually seemed quite reasonable. And almost at once, another thought occurred to me: had these companies finally begun to realize that people with genuine potential might not be standing neatly at the end of a standardized educational path, waiting to be chosen when they graduate from university?</p><p>Over the past few years, I’ve increasingly felt that many education systems, especially those built around standardized requirements, examinations, rankings, and repeated selection, are very good at identifying people who fit the system. But they may not be equally good at recognizing people with real potential.</p><p>To me, those are two different things.</p><p>When people talk about educational selection, they often take certain assumptions for granted. A student who gets good grades must be smarter. Someone who fails to enter a desirable school must lack ability. And when a child is eliminated at a particular stage, it is easy to assume that the children who remain are simply more capable.</p><p>But can a person’s abilities and potential really be judged so easily?</p><p>The more I think about it, the less convinced I am.</p><p>In some education systems, children begin being compared and ranked from a very young age. As they move through secondary school, they face further rounds of selection. In China, for example, the <em>zhongkao</em>¹ and <em>gaokao</em>² not only influence which schools students can attend, but also shape the educational opportunities available to them afterward.</p><p>Of course, I understand that any education system responsible for large numbers of students needs some form of standardized assessment. There are many students, high-quality educational resources are limited, and society needs a way to make decisions about who can enter different educational pathways. Unified examinations at least provide a relatively clear set of rules that makes comparison possible.</p><p>From an administrator’s point of view, such a system has obvious advantages. Common teaching standards, schedules, examinations, and marking criteria make schools easier to organize and manage. They also reduce assessment costs and allow large numbers of students to be evaluated.</p><p>The problem is that when a system has to prioritize efficiency, fairness, and practicality, what it can measure is often only one part of a person’s abilities.</p><p><strong>It can tell us who performs well under established rules, but it cannot necessarily tell us who has the greatest potential to grow when facing real problems in the future.</strong></p><p>One reason I care so much about this distinction is my own experience at school.</p><p>As a child, I was never the kind of student who consistently achieved high marks. That doesn’t mean I did particularly badly. Compared with other children in my neighborhood, people might even have considered me a reasonably good student. But I found it difficult to maintain the steady performance expected of someone who was always supposed to do well.</p><p>My grades might be excellent for a while, only to fall again after some time. After being criticized, I would work harder, and my results would improve. But sooner or later, I might become less disciplined, and my performance would fluctuate once more.</p><p>For a long time, I assumed this meant I wasn’t hardworking or self-disciplined enough. Only as I grew older did I begin to realize that the problem might not be so simple. Perhaps I was never the kind of person who could remain motivated over long periods by standardized examinations, rankings, and external evaluations.</p><p>I was especially poor at multiple-choice questions, true-or-false questions, and reading comprehension exercises that required choosing one correct answer from several possibilities.</p><p>For example, I often got multiple-choice questions about classical Chinese poetry wrong. The same happened with reading comprehension. Sometimes I felt I understood a text perfectly well, yet I still couldn’t select the answer the examiner wanted. Strangely enough, when I was allowed to write my own analysis instead, my teachers often said I had done a good job.</p><p>It took me many years to understand what this might mean.</p><p>Perhaps the problem wasn’t that I had failed to understand the text. Perhaps I simply wasn’t very good at reducing my interpretation to a handful of predetermined options and identifying the one that most closely matched the examiner’s thinking.</p><p>Of course, reading comprehension does require standards of judgment, and multiple-choice questions are not necessarily limited to testing memorization. Some are very well designed and can genuinely assess whether students have read carefully, understood a text’s structure, and recognized what its author intended to express.</p><p>Still, I believe that when someone has their own understanding of a piece of writing, and the available options don’t fully reflect that understanding, an examination may fail to capture the full extent of their abilities. This is especially true of literary reading, where interpretation, personal response, and expression can be open to different possibilities, while standardized questions must reduce that complexity to a limited set of answers.</p><p>Why, then, do schools rely so heavily on such questions? I think one very practical reason is that they are easier to mark.</p><p>When large numbers of students are involved, asking everyone to write an open-ended analysis takes considerably more time from teachers. It also creates difficulties with consistent marking, differences in subjective judgment, and disagreements over scores. Multiple-choice and true-or-false questions, by contrast, can be marked quickly, produce clear results, and make it easier to compare students on a large scale.</p><p>So it isn’t necessarily that educators fail to recognize the value of open-ended expression. Rather, when an assessment system must balance efficiency, cost, and comparability, standardized answers are often the most convenient solution.</p><p>These tools certainly serve a purpose, and in many situations they work well. But being useful doesn’t mean they can measure a person completely.</p><p>I’ve gradually come to believe that what needs questioning about many education systems today isn’t that they have no value, but that they still carry a great deal of the thinking that shaped education during the industrial age.</p><p>Industrial societies needed large numbers of workers who could receive relatively uniform training and perform their jobs according to established procedures. Whether they were technicians in factories, office clerks, accountants, or people in many other occupations, workers were expected to acquire a fairly stable set of knowledge and skills and carry out their responsibilities within clearly defined organizations.</p><p>Under those conditions, large-scale standardized education made sense. Common textbooks, teaching schedules, examinations, and the use of qualifications and grades to direct students toward different schools and careers allowed societies to educate large numbers of people with relatively limited resources.</p><p>I don’t think this model was fundamentally wrong. In fact, standardized education has played an important role in making mass basic education and professional training possible.</p><p>But society’s expectations of people’s abilities are changing, and education systems may not always be adapting at the same pace.</p><p>This is especially noticeable today, when artificial intelligence is developing rapidly, new tools are constantly appearing, and access to knowledge has become easier than ever. Many tasks that once required years of training are becoming much simpler to perform.</p><p>Being able to complete standardized tasks accurately is still a valuable skill, of course. But it may no longer be enough, on its own, to give someone a lasting advantage in the future.</p><p>I’ve become increasingly interested in a different set of abilities: whether someone can recognize a problem without being prompted, begin working without having every step arranged for them, explore an unfamiliar tool independently, continue learning when their existing knowledge is no longer sufficient, and keep looking for solutions even when there is no ready-made answer.</p><p>These abilities are not mysterious, nor do they necessarily belong only to exceptionally intelligent people. Often, they develop gradually through dealing with real problems, trying different approaches, making mistakes, and having the freedom to adjust.</p><p>Yet these are precisely the qualities that standardized examinations find difficult to measure.</p><p>What worries me even more is that when children spend years following highly uniform learning schedules, becoming accustomed to teachers assigning tasks, textbooks setting the pace, and examination papers defining the correct answers, they may gradually become very good at completing other people’s instructions without becoming equally good at raising questions of their own.</p><p>Of course, I’m not saying that students who get good grades lack initiative, or that standardized teaching inevitably weakens creativity. Many excellent students also have strong independent learning skills. A solid foundation of knowledge and systematic training can also provide essential support for independent thinking.</p><p>What concerns me is that when an entire evaluation system places too much emphasis on measurable results, abilities that are difficult to demonstrate on an examination paper may receive too little attention.</p><p>A child may be excellent at completing clearly defined tasks and know exactly how to achieve high examination scores. But one day, when faced with a situation in which nobody tells them what to do first, and even the problem itself is not fully defined, will they still know how to begin?</p><p>This brings me to an interesting contradiction.</p><p>We hope education will produce capable people who can think independently, take the initiative to learn, and solve complicated problems. But if the main way children gain recognition throughout their school years is by completing predetermined tasks correctly, where are they supposed to find enough opportunities to practice dealing with situations that have no standard answers?</p><p>To me, this is a question education needs to take seriously.</p><p>It also explains why I could understand the reasoning behind companies experimenting with selecting young people directly from high school and training them earlier.</p><p>This doesn’t mean university education has become useless, or that high school graduates are necessarily more capable than university graduates. Universities provide systematic knowledge, research environments, and professional resources, and many careers genuinely require years of rigorous higher education.</p><p>But if what a company really needs is someone willing to learn, able to solve problems independently, and capable of growing through practical experience, perhaps educational qualifications and examination results shouldn’t be the only criteria used to decide whether that person is worth investing in.</p><p>After all, people don’t necessarily develop according to the timetable set by schools.</p><p>Some children stand out from primary school onward. They learn steadily, achieve excellent grades, and seem to know what they want from an early age. Others may need much more time to discover a direction that suits them.</p><p>They might be particularly strong in some subjects and weak in others. They might struggle with standardized examinations or fail to show their strengths within a fixed teaching schedule. Yet in a particular field or a real-life situation, they may demonstrate unexpected understanding and initiative.</p><p>Some people need to develop a genuine interest before they become fully engaged. Others can only connect separate pieces of knowledge when they encounter a concrete problem. Still others may have outstanding abilities in one area, but their overall grades remain low because they struggle in other subjects.</p><p>Of course, these children may also have real gaps in knowledge or skills that need to be addressed. I don’t believe that everyone who performs poorly at school must secretly possess an undiscovered talent.</p><p>But I also don’t believe that someone’s performance at a particular age, in a particular examination, or along a particular educational path is enough to determine how far they may eventually develop.</p><p><strong>An education system can make an assessment of someone’s current performance, but that assessment should not become a premature judgment of their entire potential.</strong></p><p>Many people who are not selected first are not necessarily incapable. They may simply have failed, at a particular stage, to develop in the way the system finds easiest to recognize.</p><p>When I think about it this way, many education systems today remind me of a sieve.</p><p>A sieve certainly serves a purpose. We also need rules to help distribute educational opportunities and resources among different people. But what a sieve keeps and what it lets fall through depends largely on the size and shape of its openings.</p><p>If it has been designed according to one particular standard, anything that doesn’t fit that standard is naturally more likely to fall through.</p><p>Yet not everything that falls through is worthless.</p><p>Some people have perfectly good comprehension skills but struggle with standardized answers. Others have interests and potential that don’t translate into consistently good grades at the expected age. Some are especially talented in one area but are held back by weaker performance elsewhere. And others may not fit the orderly, predictable pattern of development that schools expect, yet may flourish through practical experience in the wider world.</p><p>What I find most regrettable is that these people may lose certain opportunities too early in life, and may even gradually come to believe that they really aren’t capable enough.</p><p>Of course, the real world doesn’t reward only innovation, independent learning, and problem-solving. Many jobs still require a solid foundation of knowledge, rigorous training, and the ability to perform tasks consistently over long periods. Society needs different kinds of people, and no single method can recognize every kind of ability.</p><p>But the more rapidly the world changes, the more important it becomes to acknowledge that people’s abilities take different forms, and that no one evaluation method can suit everyone.</p><p>Especially now that artificial intelligence can handle an increasing number of standardized tasks, shouldn’t we create more room for abilities that are harder to measure through standardized assessments, allowing them to develop and be recognized?</p><p>Looking back at that discussion about companies recruiting and training high school graduates, perhaps the reason I didn’t find the idea particularly surprising was that it raised a question I had already been thinking about.</p><p>If the people companies need cannot always be accurately identified through traditional educational pathways, shouldn’t recruitment methods that rely mainly on qualifications, examinations, and standardized evaluations gradually become more open?</p><p>Of course, a news item whose precise source I can no longer remember is not enough to prove that recruitment practices are changing across the business world. Nor does it justify concluding that education systems have lost their ability to identify capable people. Still, I believe the idea itself is worth discussing.</p><p>Because it reminds us that a person’s abilities do not suddenly become valuable only after they have completed a prescribed educational path.</p><p>Education systems certainly continue to serve important purposes, and they will remain essential for organizing educational resources and developing professional skills for a long time to come. Perhaps what we really need to be careful about is not that these systems have stopped working, but that they continue to operate so efficiently that we may mistake that efficiency for accuracy in identifying talent.</p><p>When a system consistently selects people who meet its standards, it is easy to believe that it has also selected those most worth nurturing.</p><p>But there is always a gap between those two judgments.</p><p>I think the real question today isn’t whether we should have examinations or whether grades should matter. It’s whether we can maintain necessary standards of evaluation while also creating more opportunities for people who develop at different speeds, have different combinations of abilities, or think in different ways to be recognized.</p><p>After all, education should do more than establish which standards a person has reached at a particular moment. It should also help us discover what that person might become.</p><p>If a system grows increasingly good at selecting those who meet its existing standards, while leaving too little space for people who have not yet met them but still have the potential to grow, then what it misses may be more than certain students’ opportunities to continue their education.</p><p>It may also miss abilities that could have developed gradually in a different environment.</p><h3>Notes</h3><p><strong>1. Zhongkao (中考)</strong></p><p>The <em>zhongkao</em> is China’s examination for admission to upper secondary education, usually taken at the end of junior secondary school, around the age of fifteen. Results play an important role in determining which educational pathways students can enter, including academically oriented high schools and vocational education. Admission arrangements and available options vary by region. Unlike a simple end-of-year school examination, the <em>zhongkao</em> can significantly influence a student’s subsequent educational opportunities.</p><p><strong>2. Gaokao (高考)</strong></p><p>The <em>gaokao</em> is China’s national college entrance examination, generally taken at the end of senior secondary school. It is one of the main factors determining admission to universities and different levels of higher education. Because university places and institutional reputations vary considerably, examination results can have a major influence on students’ future educational options. Although admissions policies differ across provinces and institutions, the <em>gaokao</em> remains a central part of China’s university selection system.</p><h4>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=003ae202d8e8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Don’t Write About Sadness Directly.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/i-dont-write-about-sadness-directly-1d56bb2ff165?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1d56bb2ff165</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[storytelling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-reflection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing-process]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[creative-writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:38:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-30T22:38:54.853Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>I Don’t Write About Sadness Directly. I Write About a Clock, a Room, and a Ring Lost in a Rice Field.</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Vtw1P9Lcog5b1dL973tlLQ.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Why a ticking clock, a quiet room, and a childhood memory can express emotions more deeply than words alone.</em></strong></p><p>By Jane Sonnenschein · March 15, 2026</p><p>Tonight, while scrolling through Xiaohongshu (a Chinese lifestyle and social-sharing platform often compared to a mix of Instagram and Pinterest), I came across an interesting post titled <em>“Even AI Thought My Writing Was AI-Generated.”</em></p><p>The person who posted it seemed to be a student. She had written an essay herself, then asked Doubao and DeepSeek, two Chinese AI assistants, to each write another essay imitating her style. She put all three pieces together and asked readers to guess which one was hers and which two had been written by AI.</p><p>It was the kind of question that naturally makes you curious enough to click. What made it even more interesting was that people in the comments kept guessing, and even AI identified the essay she had written herself as AI-generated. She seemed a little confused by the whole thing too.</p><p>At first, I clicked simply because I was curious. But the longer I read, the more seriously I began to think about it. Those three essays touched on something that had already been on my mind for the past couple of days.</p><p>How should we write about emotions?</p><p>Or, to put it more precisely, why do some articles keep telling you how miserable or heartbroken the writer feels, yet leave you feeling very little? And why can another piece of writing draw you in almost immediately, without ever directly mentioning sadness?</p><p>I went back and read the three essays several times.</p><p>The first was fairly simple and easy to read, although some of its metaphors felt a little forced to me. I could barely get through the second one at first. It actually gave me a headache. Later, I made myself go back and finish it, and began to think that perhaps this one was more likely to have been written by a real person. There was something about its repetition and unevenness that felt less controlled.</p><p>I read the third one twice. It flowed more smoothly and felt more coherent, like something written by someone who already knew how to write well.</p><p>But what really made me stop wasn’t the question of which essay sounded like AI.</p><p>It was the sudden realization that, deep down, I had always known what kind of writing I believed in.</p><p>I’ve never been particularly convinced by writing that states emotions too directly.</p><p>That doesn’t mean someone shouldn’t write, “I’m sad,” “I’m hurting,” or “My heart is broken.” Of course they can. But when an entire article keeps telling you just how much the writer is suffering, that suffering can sometimes begin to feel strangely unconvincing.</p><p>Not because the emotion itself is necessarily false, but because once it is reduced to a label, it easily becomes a conclusion. You understand what the writer is telling you, but you haven’t really entered the moment.</p><p>I’ve always believed more in another way of writing.</p><p>I don’t write about sadness directly.</p><p>I write about a room so quiet that I can almost hear my own breathing, with only the clock on the wall ticking away.</p><p>I write about sadness slowly seeping in, like water.</p><p>I write about a child walking to kindergarten, brushing her hand against the fence beside a field, until one day a ring that was far too big for her finger slips off and falls into the rice field.</p><p>I write about a mother who is so frugal that she hardly ever allows herself to eat meat, yet always puts some into my bowl.</p><p>I write about a little toy airplane that could fly in circles from the ceiling, a toy gun that lit up, a plant in the corner of a room, and all those seemingly unimportant things attached to the refrigerator.</p><p>Most of the time, I don’t begin by deciding what a particular scene is supposed to express. These details simply appear as I write.</p><p>Only when I look back at my work later do I gradually understand that this is how I have always written about emotions.</p><p>For a long time, I had never really thought about it.</p><p>People’s comments on my writing were often rather vague. They would say I wrote well, but there was usually something else behind that compliment. Some said my writing was difficult to understand. Others thought it felt a little empty.</p><p>My father used to read things I had written and tell me quite directly, “Your writing has no soul.”</p><p>What he meant was actually quite simple: he couldn’t understand it.</p><p>He felt that I had written a lot, and that the sentences might sound beautiful, but he couldn’t grasp what held everything together. He couldn’t find the central idea or understand what I was really trying to say. To him, that meant the writing had no soul.</p><p>For a long time, I more or less believed that judgment myself.</p><p>I thought perhaps I was good at putting sentences together, using metaphors, and creating an atmosphere, but not necessarily good at writing something meaningful.</p><p>So for years, I tried to turn myself into a different kind of writer.</p><p>I wanted to read more literary classics, learn how to tell stories, and make my work feel more substantial, more like the kind of writing people generally recognize as genuinely good.</p><p>It wasn’t until recently, when I started rereading some of my old work, that I suddenly realized something.</p><p>Perhaps I had never been unable to write. Perhaps I had simply failed to recognize my own way of writing.</p><p>What I’ve always been good at is not stating things directly.</p><p>I don’t naturally begin by telling readers, “I’m terribly sad,” “My father and I have a close relationship,” or “My feelings toward my mother are complicated.”</p><p>Instead, I tend to place emotions inside scenes, actions, and small objects that don’t seem, at first glance, to be expressing any particular feeling.</p><p>Take something I wrote about my father when I was young.</p><p>I didn’t directly say that my father loved me very much, or that there was something complicated about our relationship.</p><p>I wrote about a time when he came home from a business trip and brought me a toy gun and a little airplane that could hang from the ceiling and fly around in circles. He also bought me a ring that was obviously unsuitable for a child. It was the sort of ring an elderly person might wear, and it was much too big for my finger.</p><p>Later, on my way to kindergarten, I would often run my hand along the fence beside the farmland. One day, the ring slipped off and fell into the rice field.</p><p>None of these details explains anything directly.</p><p>Yet when they are placed together, so much is already there: my father’s somewhat awkward way of showing love, the atmosphere at home shaped by my parents’ arguments, a child’s attachment to a gift from her father, and that strange, empty feeling when something precious suddenly disappears.</p><p>Then there is my mother.</p><p>If I write about her, I don’t usually begin by saying that our relationship is both deep and complicated, or that there is a certain helplessness in the love between us.</p><p>Instead, I write about how careful she always was with money. She was reluctant to eat meat herself, but whenever we sat down for a meal, she would put some into my bowl.</p><p>That one small action already carries so much: love, guilt, restraint, tenderness, and the ache of knowing what someone has quietly given up for you.</p><p>Over time, I’ve come to understand why I trust this kind of writing more.</p><p>It isn’t the writing that repeatedly tells me how much someone is suffering, how deeply they love, or how unfairly they’ve been treated. It’s the writing that doesn’t need to name those feelings because I can already sense them in the scene.</p><p>This is something I’ve gradually come to care about more and more: <strong>feeling something matters more than simply reading about it.</strong></p><p>When someone writes, “I’m sad,” the reader receives a piece of information.</p><p>But when someone writes about a room so quiet that all you can hear is the steady ticking of a clock, the reader begins to experience a kind of sadness.</p><p>To me, there’s a real difference between the two.</p><p>One tells you the conclusion. The other lets you enter the moment.</p><p>And I’ve always believed more in the second approach.</p><p>Because what makes an emotion convincing isn’t someone telling me how much they hurt. It’s being able to recognize that hurt in the silence of a room, the ticking of a clock, the sound of someone breathing, or a ring disappearing into a rice field, even though the writer has never directly said how painful it was.</p><p>This is also why I’ve become increasingly uncomfortable with writing-advice posts that rely too heavily on techniques.</p><p>Today, I came across another post with more than three thousand likes. Its title was something along the lines of “An Amazing Technique for Writing Emotions.”</p><p>When I opened it, the format was exactly what I had expected.</p><p>Don’t write “I’m nervous”; describe someone’s Adam’s apple moving as they swallow. Don’t write “I’m sad”; describe some particular physical reaction or detail instead. Then came Technique One, Technique Two, Technique Three, followed by a neat list of practical tips.</p><p>I can see how this might help someone who is just beginning to write. It’s like a PowerPoint presentation or a checklist, a ready-made method that you can immediately apply.</p><p>But that isn’t really how I understand writing.</p><p>To me, writing naturally doesn’t mean deciding in advance that you want to express sadness through scenery, then deliberately inventing a ticking clock, a quiet room, a movement of someone’s throat, or some carefully chosen object.</p><p>Natural writing happens when the feeling is already there, and the surrounding details begin to appear alongside it.</p><p>Those objects already belong to your life. They are things you have seen, lived with, or carried in your memory. When you write, they emerge together with the emotion, and that is what gives them their sense of truth.</p><p>If the process works the other way around, with the technique coming first and the emotion being added afterward, the result can easily feel forced.</p><p>The metaphors feel forced, the scenery feels forced, and even the sadness can begin to resemble something arranged for a photograph.</p><p>So by the time I finished reading those three essays tonight, I was no longer particularly interested in deciding which one sounded like AI and which one didn’t.</p><p>What I really wanted to understand was why I react so strongly to certain kinds of writing.</p><p>And perhaps I finally began to see the answer.</p><p>It’s because this is how I’ve always written myself.</p><p>When I write about sadness, I don’t directly describe sadness. When I write about love, I don’t necessarily name love either.</p><p>For the feelings that are most complicated, hardest to explain, and most likely to lose something when they are put too plainly into words, I’ve never relied primarily on conclusions.</p><p>I leave behind scenes, gestures, and a little empty space.</p><p>That empty space matters.</p><p>Because once it is there, readers can enter it themselves. One person may feel sadness, another love. Someone else may sense helplessness or loss.</p><p>Everyone brings their own experiences into what they read, so the feelings they take away won’t necessarily be the same.</p><p>I don’t see that as a problem. On the contrary, I think it’s one of the most valuable things about writing.</p><p>If I simply tell someone, “My father and I had a very close relationship,” they can only understand what that sentence means.</p><p>But if I write about the little airplane hanging from the ceiling, the toy gun that lit up, and the ring that fell into the rice field, readers have room to sense something for themselves.</p><p>They may begin to realize that there is more beneath those details than the words directly explain.</p><p>And that feeling can reach much deeper than a conclusion.</p><p>This is why I increasingly believe that the most important thing when writing about emotions is not to announce the feeling, but to bring the moment itself to life.</p><p>Rather than explaining everything on the reader’s behalf, I want to leave enough space for the reader to find a way in.</p><p>It’s not that I don’t understand those writing techniques.</p><p>I’ve simply become more convinced that what truly moves people isn’t the technique itself, but whether it has grown out of a real emotion.</p><p>Looking back at the Xiaohongshu post I saw tonight, <em>“Even AI Thought My Writing Was AI-Generated,”</em> I realize that the most interesting part, for me, wasn’t the question of which essay sounded like AI.</p><p>It was that the whole experiment made me turn around and look at myself again.</p><p>After all these years, I still believe most strongly in writing that doesn’t rush to define its own feelings. Perhaps I’ve always written this way. Perhaps what I truly wanted to express was never simply the words “I’m hurting.”</p><p>I write about the ticking of a clock, a quiet room, and a ring lost in a rice field.</p><p>And everything I never said directly has been there all along.</p><h4>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1d56bb2ff165" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why Do the Hardest-Working People Eventually Slow Down?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jane.kids.books/why-do-the-hardest-working-people-eventually-slow-down-a0dc38d54021?source=rss-9ca090368fca------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a0dc38d54021</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[life-lessons]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-growth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[self-reflection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[work-life-balance]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jane Sonnenschein | A Chinese Way of Seeing]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 07:39:41 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-29T07:39:41.209Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rvj-cAKFPKLyg7bYIXD4HQ.png" /></figure><p><strong><em>Why the pursuit of success eventually leads some of us to question what we’ve been sacrificing along the way.</em></strong></p><p>By Jane Sonnenschein<br>First written on April 8, 2026 · Revised on October 28, 2026</p><p>Today, while scrolling through the list of WeChat Official Accounts I follow, I came across one I had subscribed to many years ago. WeChat Official Accounts are publishing channels within the Chinese messaging app WeChat, somewhat like a combination of blogs and email newsletters.</p><p>I have to admit that I haven’t spent much time reading articles there over the past two years. If I hadn’t started writing again last year, I probably would have forgotten many of the accounts I used to follow. So the names that are still on my list feel strangely familiar, almost like old friends from a different period of my life.</p><p>This writer was one of them.</p><p>She is a fairly well-known figure in China’s WeChat publishing community. She didn’t become popular overnight because of one or two viral articles. She had been writing and building her audience for years, and her story was often used as an example in writing courses.</p><p>I happened to read one of her recent articles today. What caught my attention wasn’t another writing method or a new lesson about success. It was the fact that she had begun talking about why she wanted to slow down.</p><p>Looking back on her earlier life, she described herself as someone who was always extremely goal-oriented. Take losing weight, for example. She didn’t particularly enjoy the process, nor did she pay much attention to how she felt along the way. Almost all her attention went toward the final result: Had she lost the weight? Had she reached the number she wanted?</p><p>She approached many other things in much the same way. Once she had decided on a goal, she would work hard to remove distractions and direct as much time and energy as possible toward achieving it. Whether the process was enjoyable, or whether other parts of life deserved her attention, seemed less important at the time.</p><p>As I read her reflections, I began to think that she wasn’t describing only herself. She also reminded me of many people who became successful during the early boom of WeChat Official Accounts and China’s wider online content industry.</p><p>These people often seemed to have an extraordinary drive. It wasn’t simply a matter of being hardworking or disciplined. They knew exactly what they wanted, and they were willing to put almost everything else aside to get there.</p><p>If they wanted to make money, gain followers, or build a business to a certain size, they could set aside things that had little to do with that goal and focus on the actions most likely to produce results.</p><p>During the years when online content platforms were growing rapidly, that ability could be especially rewarding.</p><p>Platforms offered many opportunities to people who were willing to keep producing content and act quickly. If you published enough, learned how the platforms worked, and were prepared to explore new ways of earning money, you had a chance of growing your audience and increasing your income.</p><p>Of course, effort and success have never had a guaranteed cause-and-effect relationship. But during that period, the connection often seemed more direct than it does today. It was easier to believe that if you kept working, became more efficient, and pushed yourself a little harder, your next achievement would be greater than your last.</p><p>That was why I found it so interesting to see someone who had once done so well under those rules looking back and wondering whether she had neglected too much of life along the way.</p><p>Her article made me curious enough to revisit some of the success stories that writing courses had promoted for years. I wanted to understand what those people had in common, and whether the qualities that had helped them succeed were still just as effective today.</p><p>The more I looked, the more I noticed something that is easy to overlook.</p><p>Many of these successful writers were not necessarily the most talented or thoughtful people among those learning to write. Nor were they always the ones with the strongest writing skills. But they generally had a very clear idea of why they were writing, and they were prepared to keep taking action toward that goal.</p><p>Over the past couple of days, I came across some remarkable examples. One person wrote four hundred articles in a year. Another kept writing while holding a baby. Someone continued staying up late to write television reviews around the time of her mother-in-law’s funeral. Another completed thirty-five pieces in a single month.</p><p>Some had very little writing experience when they started, but once they decided to pursue writing professionally, they actively looked for opportunities to submit articles, take on paid assignments, and earn money from their work.</p><p>These were exceptional cases, of course, and they shouldn’t be treated as examples everyone ought to follow. When I read about people continuing to work through major family events, I admire their commitment, but I also wonder what such a way of living must have cost them.</p><p>Still, there is something about their abilities that I genuinely admire, partly because it is something I have always struggled with myself.</p><p>When it comes to writing, I often spend a great deal of time thinking about questions that arise before I have even begun.</p><p>Which account would be the right place for this article? Is my account focused enough? Does this writing style feel too formulaic? Is the title too ordinary, or does the way I’m expressing an idea go against what I originally wanted to say?</p><p>Sometimes I take those questions even further. If people follow an account because they enjoy one type of content, will they lose interest when I write about something completely different?</p><p>These are not meaningless concerns. For someone who hopes to write over the long term while keeping a personal voice, questions about positioning, style, and readers’ expectations do deserve attention.</p><p>But I also have to admit that when the same questions appear before every attempt to do something, they can gradually become a source of exhaustion rather than a useful part of making decisions.</p><p>People with very clear goals seem better able to reduce these questions to something practical: Will this help me move closer to what I want?</p><p>If the answer is yes, they are willing to start. If not, they put it aside for the time being.</p><p>So while I might still be wondering how to write something in a way that feels right to me, or how to arrange my content without confusing my audience, someone else may already have written an article, submitted it, taken on a paid assignment, tried a new platform, or earned money from the first attempt.</p><p>Whether the process feels natural, whether every sentence reflects their personal taste, or whether the approach seems too commercial often comes second.</p><p>I used to think these differences were mainly about writing ability or how quickly someone could learn. But looking at those examples again has made me realize that what separates people is sometimes not just their writing skills.</p><p>It may also be their ability to keep working toward a goal over a long period of time, and their willingness to set aside concerns that don’t directly affect the result.</p><p>This has led me back to a question: Why is it that, when people begin writing, some eventually manage to earn money from it while others make very little progress?</p><p>Of course, income depends on many things, including individual ability, available opportunities, and the stage of development a platform has reached. It would be too simple to explain success entirely through personality.</p><p>But judging from these examples, writing ability may not be the only important factor.</p><p>For people whose goals are to earn money and grow an audience, the ability to produce content consistently, look for opportunities, and avoid getting stuck in endless hesitation may be just as important.</p><p>In a way, this realization has also made me reconsider some of the principles I have tried to follow in my own writing.</p><p>I have always felt that writing should come as naturally as possible and reflect what I genuinely think and feel. I don’t want every article to follow the same formula simply because that is what a platform rewards. Nor do I want to keep repeating things I don’t really believe just to attract more attention.</p><p>These preferences are not an attempt to appear superior to anyone else. Writing simply means something different to me. I don’t want it to become entirely a process of producing content in exchange for numbers and results.</p><p>But from another perspective, the choices made by people who approach writing as a business are easy to understand.</p><p>If the goal is to make money, reach more readers, and build a successful account, then studying platform rules, adjusting content, increasing output, and even setting aside some personal preferences are all practical decisions.</p><p>Perhaps the difference between us is not that one side understands writing better than the other. Perhaps writing has simply been serving different purposes in our lives from the beginning.</p><p>What stayed with me most about that writer’s article, though, was not just the difference between people like her and people like me.</p><p>It was why, after so many years, she had begun questioning the way she used to live.</p><p>One possible explanation that came to mind was that the environment itself had changed.</p><p>When content platforms were growing quickly and attracting followers was relatively easy, strong ambition and sustained effort often brought visible rewards. Someone might gain more attention by publishing regularly, improve their results by learning how an algorithm worked, or increase their income by recognizing a new opportunity early.</p><p>When hard work repeatedly leads to measurable progress, it is natural to believe that your approach is working. You become more willing to keep going in the same direction.</p><p>But once a platform matures, competition increases, and more and more content becomes available, the relationship between effort and reward may become less direct.</p><p>Methods that once helped an account grow quickly may no longer work as well. Posting more frequently may no longer bring the attention it once did.</p><p>That doesn’t mean effort has become worthless. It means that the rewards for effort increasingly depend on factors beyond any individual’s control.</p><p>For someone who has grown accustomed to measuring their efforts through results, this can be difficult.</p><p>Even if they maintain the same discipline and work just as hard as before, they may no longer be able to achieve the growth they once enjoyed. The approach that used to work so well begins to reach its limits.</p><p>In the past, setting aside other parts of life in pursuit of a goal may have seemed worthwhile because each achievement made up for what had been sacrificed along the way.</p><p>But when the outcome becomes less certain, a question that could once be postponed becomes harder to avoid:</p><p>If I have already put so much into something, yet still cannot be sure of getting the results I hoped for, what does the process itself mean to me?</p><p>I wonder whether this may be one reason why some people who have spent ten or even fifteen years creating online content are beginning to talk more openly about life, feelings, and their relationship with themselves.</p><p>When they were younger, their strong sense of purpose and remarkable ability to get things done helped them take advantage of the opportunities available at the time. Through years of effort, they built something substantial.</p><p>But as they grow older, gain more life experience, and face changes in the platforms they depend on, things they once felt able to ignore may gradually become important again.</p><p>A person cannot spend an entire lifetime thinking only about the next increase in followers, the next target, or the next achievement. Especially when those results become harder to obtain, experiences that cannot be translated directly into numbers or income may begin to matter more.</p><p>Of course, I don’t know exactly why that writer has changed her perspective now.</p><p>I cannot conclude from a single article that she wants to slow down because the opportunities of an earlier era have faded. Perhaps the change has come naturally with age and experience. Perhaps she has achieved enough to give herself more freedom to decide how she wants to live.</p><p>But her reflections did help me see another side of a life built around goals.</p><p>The advantage of that approach is that it can keep a person moving for a long time and improve their chances of getting results.</p><p>Its limitation is that when someone spends years placing results at the center of life, and becomes accustomed to judging their own worth by whether they have achieved their goals, changes in the outside world can leave them struggling to find a new sense of direction.</p><p>The same may happen when a goal no longer provides the satisfaction it once did.</p><p>As I reached this point in my writing, I realized that the time I had spent looking through those old success stories had not been wasted.</p><p>In the past, I tended to notice how much those people worked and how relentlessly they pursued their goals. Then I would turn the comparison back on myself and wonder why I couldn’t do the same.</p><p>I admired their efficiency, but I was also puzzled by my own habit of hesitating over details that seemed to cause them very little trouble.</p><p>Now I can see their achievements a little more clearly.</p><p>Much of their success came from knowing what they wanted and making consistent, practical choices in pursuit of it. They were not necessarily smarter than everyone else or more capable in every respect. Their way of working simply gave them a particular advantage in the environment they were in.</p><p>At the same time, I have begun to understand that this way of living is not suitable for everyone.</p><p>And just because some people succeeded with it during a particular period does not mean it is the path everyone must follow if they want to achieve something.</p><p>For me, recognizing this doesn’t mean giving up my expectations for what I write or how I express myself. Nor does it mean I should turn myself into someone who cares only about how efficiently writing can be turned into income.</p><p>I still want writing to make room for personal thought and feeling.</p><p>But I also need to acknowledge that my tendency to question everything before taking action has sometimes held me back. Some of the questions I spend so much time worrying about could probably be answered after I have actually started doing the work.</p><p>I can learn from successful writers’ clearer sense of purpose and their ability to act without having to adopt their entire way of living.</p><p>After all, learning a useful skill and accepting a particular lifestyle are two different things.</p><p>And when I think again about the article I read today, what strikes me most is that someone who once placed goals and results at the center of her life has begun taking the experience of living itself more seriously.</p><p>Perhaps she has already spent enough years learning how to work tirelessly toward one goal after another. Now she is trying to learn something that sounds simple but may be surprisingly difficult: how to continue working and pursuing goals while also paying attention to how she feels, without treating every moment of life as merely another step toward a result.</p><p>I suspect this change is not limited to people who create online content.</p><p>It may be something many people who have spent years working hard, competing, and chasing achievements eventually have to face.</p><p>From a young age, many of us become familiar with the idea of working toward a goal. We learn how to become more efficient, how to persevere, and how to overcome difficulties.</p><p>But we may be far less familiar with how to value the life we are living when there is no clear result waiting at the end.</p><p>So what moved me most today was not simply that she had finally decided to slow down.</p><p>It was that she had begun to acknowledge something she had once overlooked: whether or not we reach our goals, the life we experience along the way, and the feelings that come with it, deserve our attention too.</p><p>For many people who have grown used to measuring themselves through hard work and results, perhaps learning this is even harder than learning how to work harder.</p><h4>Originally published on <a href="https://chinesewayofseeing.com/">A Chinese Way of Seeing</a>, a trilingual collection of essays by Jane Sonnenschein about China, family, language, and cultural perspectives.</h4><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a0dc38d54021" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>