<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Janis Hopkins on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Janis Hopkins on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@janhop?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 07:23:05 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@janhop/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Haters and Losers]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/haters-and-losers-16ccd40f7f70?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/16ccd40f7f70</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[elon-musk]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ragebait]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[algorithms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[social-media]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[twitter]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Oct 2026 15:53:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-27T16:18:01.513Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4YhtKS0wu5PZhRdXQa8Dkw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I am on Twitter very infrequently these days. Usually it’s for a particular purpose, or else because I’ve not taken my meds and my brain has started jonesing for an additional timeline or three to scroll. Either way, the gaps between these visits grow large enough that they make certain things stark.</p><p>Once I’m on, I immediately backslide into the kind of behaviours which are the reason I’m not on there any more. My eyes scan hungrily, and then I see something which annoys me. I’ll reply to it, or I’ll quote it saying something sarcastic. A few moments later I see the same tweet again, along with another person’s denunciation. Or, even worse, they have an alternative view to me. They’ll be saying something like, “I don’t understand the response to this? People need to read it properly.” Not on my watch! And then there’s another, and another, and another. Riffs and rebuttals to the offending tweet are springing up on my timeline like mushrooms after autumn rain. I am drawn into several concurrent conversations about it. People reply to me too. I quickly go from fleeting annoyance to an expert on the specific topic at hand, having developed my very important view over the course of several clarifying skirmishes. Don’t knock the Socratic Method.</p><p>It soon becomes clear to me that everyone is talking about this. I might feel the need to offer some reflection on the topic of the day that isn’t even a reply to anything. No quote, no context. I’ll allude vaguely to the “thing” on the assumption that everyone will know what I’m talking about, because if it’s all over my timeline, it’s on theirs too. Of course it largely won’t be, so sometimes people will ask, or they’ll search. And then it will start popping up on their feed too. The cancer cells multiply exponentially. The stream of discourse becomes a storm surge. It appears on more and more timelines. You don’t know about the thing? Everyone’s talking about the thing! Everyone’s angry about it. People are blocking each other. They’re having spats and trading insults. Battle lines are drawn in the safe knowledge that you’d have to be a fucking idiot not to understand what’s happening here, frankly, and it’s actually lowkey reactionary the way people are talking about it, can we talk about how people are talking about it? Y’all aren’t ready to hear this but we aren’t talking about this enough.</p><p>And then I resurface from the digital equivalent of a k-hole and I wonder to myself how the fuck we ever thought this was normal, and why we continue to tolerate it. How can we expect to live in reality when social media, the substrate underlying essentially all online communication, and by extension the place that we spend most of our social lives, is designed to create an unreality field around everything we see? We live in a personalised hell, designed based on preferences we aren’t even consciously aware of, pieced together from what we click on, what we look at, what the body of stored evidence about us is in the vast pan-platform data pool that tracks the things we buy, the buses we catch, the porn we watch and the things that make us angry, and then it uses it to make us even angrier. It goads and pokes at us. It disorients us. God, you try to talk about this and you sound like Ted Kaczynski! This is happening all the time! We spend all day looking at machines designed to make us mad!</p><p>Everybody already knows this. I guarantee that you know it too. You’re reading this, and I hope you’re agreeing with me, <em>right on brother</em>, but you aren’t finding it strictly original. Of course that’s how it works. It’s just the sea we swim in, soaking in the heavy metals, occasionally incited to fits of unsatisfying, impotent fury. It’s awful. Everyone agrees it’s awful. And then the AA meeting ends and you go to the pub, because there’s nothing anyone can <em>do</em> about it, that would be impossible. Fish don’t leave the sea. This is just the world we inhabit. So you whine about it a bit, you have a brief “digital detox”, you tell your phone to give you screen-time warnings so that you can ignore them, you quit social media for a chunk at a time and then you come sloping back eventually, pathetic and disempowered.</p><p>Still though: did you see what he said? Fucking idiot. Absolute moron. Imagine being this stupid. Dog-brained cretin. Brainworms. Ragebaited. Rattled. Thicko. Slop. Words cannot describe how much I hate this. Bro is SO close to getting it. This is genuinely farcical. This is actually so brain dead, disrespectful and self centred. What makes someone like this? Absolutely losing it at this. Bitch you live like this? You couldn’t torture this out of me. Kill yourself.</p><p>Okay guys, I’m logging off for a bit, talk to you soon ❤️</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=16ccd40f7f70" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Track-by-Track: Words and Music — David Shrigley and Malcolm Middleton.]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/track-by-track-words-and-music-david-shrigley-and-malcolm-middleton-65723c654aba?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/65723c654aba</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[david-shrigley]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[magic-mushrooms]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[spoken-word-poetry]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[malcolm-middleton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[arab-strap]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 31 May 2026 18:45:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-01T19:35:31.660Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>A review of an album, one track at a time, with a small story about where I was when I first heard it.</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hSv9rtb3bmyw_5cxAPvGzg.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Track 1 — A Toast</strong></p><p>During my final summer and autumn living in Stockport, I spent several weekends a month taking a flask of mushroom tea and walking across the Peak District. Castleton, Glossop, Buxton. It was deep into September when I decided to climb across Stanage Edge. Warm enough to sweat as I walked, but cool enough to be chilled as soon as I stopped. The colours were extraordinary. Purple heather, orange sycamore, bracken turning from green to brown. Keira Knightley climbed it during Pride and Prejudice, and looked out over the barren moors. It is enormously evocative, and I was fucked. Absolutely nutted. Out of my tree. The whole horizon pulsed and throbbed. I felt a prickly tingling in my chest and was at times almost overwhelmed. I was at the edge of the world. Albeit with lots of other hikers, in their neon raincoats, or the climbers making their slippery way up the escarpment.</p><p>After a time I decided that I needed to level myself out, so I put on an album and popped my headphones in. My choice was Public Service Broadcasting — The Race for Space. I couldn’t tell you why. But when it finished, with me too spaced out to really comprehend it, Spotify shuffled for something it considered to be a similar song.</p><p>It was this.</p><p>The first lines of ‘A Toast’ are this:</p><p><em>Greetings, and good fucking wishes to you, and your fuckhead, arsehole family.</em></p><p><em>Best wishes to you, you fucking wanker</em></p><p><em>To your ugly fucking wife</em></p><p><em>And to your moron fucking children, who look, and smell, like rats.</em></p><p>You have to understand that in the moment, when I didn’t even realise the song had changed, I knew implicitly that my phone was talking to me, and that it was very angry with me. And then, when a small note of reason pushed through the psilocybin haze, as the wind whipped at the sedge, and the damp coated the lichen, I thought, <em>I don’t even have a wife.</em></p><p>So I looked at my phone and saw that an album by Malcolm Middleton, of Arab Strap, and David Shrigley, the illustrator and poet, had started to play.</p><p>I went back to the start to pay proper attention, and then I started to laugh until it hurt.</p><p><strong>Track 2 — Houseguest</strong></p><p>I don’t think this is Shrigley, or indeed Middleton, both of whom contribute the spoken words to this album. It’s an obstreperous American, who appears to live with their parents, and deals with a houseguest who comes in and destroys everything. The whole song consists of the narrator berating the houseguest as they destroy their house. It’s hard to adequately convey how funny this is — was to me at the time — without providing some of the lyrics.</p><p><em>Hey.</em></p><p><em>Put it down.</em></p><p><em>That’s my dad’s sword.</em></p><p><em>Don’t touch it.</em></p><p><em>Put it down.</em></p><p><em>That’s dad’s sword.</em></p><p><em>He’s going to be so mad at you.</em></p><p><em>You’re going to blunt his sword you idiot.</em></p><p>All of this under an spiky, bouncing, propulsive kind of beat, twangs of guitar and drums. The end is the word “fuck” looped, cut, spliced, and then looped again. F-f-f-f-uck. Great.</p><p><strong>Track 3 — Monkeys</strong></p><p>If the previous two tracks were the puerile end of dark humour, Monkeys is much more unpleasant. Monkeys is the first track where I realised there was something else going on. It is beautiful, slow, fingerpicked, fuzzy electronica and guitar.</p><p><em>Do you remember, way back when, in the old days, when we were both monkeys?</em></p><p>A pastoral narrative unfolds in a different American accent this time, an older, wistful one, a storyteller’s voice, a Dennis Hopper of a voice. A memory, directed to a lover, of being monkeys. Of swinging through the trees, of picking fleas off each other. A woozy, sluggish kind of song. Everything in this is so beautifully, crisply produced.</p><p><em>Do you remember those days when we would copulate whenever we liked?</em></p><p><em>Defecate wherever we chose?</em></p><p>And the music isn’t a passive participant, a canvas for the words. It ebbs and flows and snipes in at the right time.</p><p><em>We would fight with other groups of monkeys.</em></p><p><em>And kill them.</em></p><p><em>Sometimes we would eat parts of ‘em.</em></p><p><em>Sometimes we would eat parts of ‘em.</em></p><p><em>Then we would run around screaming.</em></p><p><em>Beating our chests.</em></p><p><em>Covered in blood.</em></p><p>A guitar stabs through the haze at the word “kill”. And then the music fades away. <em>Beating our chests… covered in blood</em>. A single, hanging pause. A horrible tension. A moment for the image to linger. And then the delicate fingerpicked guitar hums in again. And the voice seems to drop a semitone. Becomes almost seductive.</p><p><em>You... liked that.</em></p><p>And so it goes on. Infanticide and violence. The debased behaviour of animals. All in these wistful, late night bar-room tones.</p><p><strong>Track 4</strong> <strong>— Walker</strong></p><p>After Monkeys fades out, the unsettling images of blood and violence, we have the rattling, tumbling, baffling Walker. It is a man — or a child, voiced by a man, for the words are childlike and naive — describing looking out of their window and seeing a man on the street. The man, or the child, has I think a Cheshire accent, because Shrigley is from Macclesfield, and this is surely him.</p><p><em>And I saw a man</em></p><p><em>Walking past our house</em></p><p><em>He didn’t have any clothes on</em></p><p><em>But he was wearing a pair of Wellington boots</em></p><p><em>I noticed that he was quite a funny shaped man.</em></p><p>Is this cruel? Is this a child? Is this an adult with learning difficulties? I have no idea.</p><p><em>He had some hair on his back</em></p><p><em>And on his bottom.</em></p><p>Silly though this song is, by this point in the album, post-Monkeys, there is a creeping sense of dread in the air. The uncanny. So, though retrospect makes this seem foolish, I had an inescapable sense that something awful was going to happen.</p><p><em>And he was huffing and puffing a bit</em></p><p><em>It looked like he might be ill</em></p><p><em>Like it was difficult for him to walk.</em></p><p>So this apparition makes his way down the street. Shambling, balding, wheezing. Naked but for Wellington boots. Under all of this, the same tumbling drums, throbs of synth, tension never breaking, rattling and rolling down the hill towards…what?</p><p><em>I thought that maybe he had escaped from the mental hospital</em></p><p><em>There is a mental hospital near our house.</em></p><p><em>And sometimes they get out</em></p><p><em>And they have to come out and fetch them.</em></p><p>All of this — the childlike recollection, the hairy back, the boots, the casual “sometimes they get out”, has such a ring of truth to it that I can only assume it happened. But David Shrigley has a very particular gift for the uncanny.</p><p><em>And one point he seemed to notice me</em></p><p><em>And he stopped</em></p><p><em>And he turned around</em></p><p><em>And he said…</em></p><p>What did he say? The music changes. The drumbeat lifts. A new texture hisses into the mix. The tension beats in your chest.</p><p><em>And then he walked on.</em></p><p><strong>Track 5 — Dear Brain</strong></p><p>This is the closest to straight-up spoken word poetry, with only a seasoning of musical accompaniment, a single piano supporting the monologue. A man addresses his brain, demanding to know why it compels him to behave in the way he does.</p><p><em>I would behave more nicely</em></p><p><em>And I would not be violent</em></p><p><em>Or abusive</em></p><p><em>To strangers</em></p><p><em>And I would wear clothes.</em></p><p>Nakedness is a persistent theme. In Shrigley’s art too. When you are naked you are vulnerable and sometimes when you are naked you are mad. Clothes are one of the trappings of society shed by the mentally ill. Nakedness is shameful.</p><p><em>But oh brain, if it is your will.</em></p><p><em>Stop making me behave like such a degenerate.</em></p><p><strong>Track 6 — Caveman</strong></p><p>I love Caveman. Caveman is horrible, ugly, and funny. It starts with a recording of Shrigley presumably providing just the vocals. It may even be improvised. It is a mock Hall and Oates song about a caveman.</p><p><em>He’s sitting in a cave, he’s chewing a bone.</em></p><p><em>In a cave, chewing a bone!</em></p><p><em>He says it’s very good to be here.</em></p><p><em>Very good to be alone.</em></p><p>The caveman recalls all of the girls he has known.</p><p><em>Pulled their hair.</em></p><p><em>Made them moan.</em></p><p>This repeats twice.</p><p><em>Of how he killed them with a stone</em></p><p><em>Of how his beard has grown.</em></p><p>The jolly caveman in his cave, killing girls with a stone. It immediately made me think of <em>Tell The Women We’re Going </em>by Raymond Carver, an extraordinary story about a pair of suburban men who go out and murder two girls because they want to have sex with them, but delivered in the most ugly, off-handed way.</p><p><em>Jerry used the same rock on both girls, first on the girl called Sharon and then on the one that was supposed to be Bill’s</em>.</p><p>And then, in this recording, perhaps as the implications of what he’s actually saying dawn on him, he says:</p><p><em>He killed a bunch of girls</em></p><p><em>He killed a bunch of…</em></p><p>And then he laughs at how horribly casual it all is. At what an awful image he’s just offered. They keep the recording. And then Middleton’s beat pumps in, a menacing guitar sawing under it, and it turns into a song again. And the story is told again, but now it’s an Arab Strap song (the vocals are Middleton here I believe), only it isn’t a story of lost love or nights out, it’s a murderous caveman, delivered with deathly seriousness. I’ve never heard anything like.</p><p><strong>Track 7 — Sunday Morning</strong></p><p>Okay, this one is stupid. It’s about masculinity being inherently ludicrous. Once more it uses the language of the playground, and childhood. So much on this album feels like it is through the eyes of a child, who hasn’t yet attached the right set of meanings to the violence and chaos of the world, or developed the kind of immunity to it that allows you to get up every day. All of that said, the first words are:</p><p><em>Take out your dong</em></p><p><em>And make it long</em></p><p><em>And bong it upon the gong.</em></p><p><em>Bong your dong</em></p><p><em>Bong it!</em></p><p>There probably isn’t much important to say about this, it seems like David Shrigley enjoying the word “dong” and the sound of saying it several times. But there are still some parts that tickle me.</p><p><em>You are an amazing man.</em></p><p><em>Other men will bow down and worship you.</em></p><p><em>Get it out, and show the other men.</em></p><p><strong>Track 8 — Story Time</strong></p><p>There are a few here which are just straightforwardly gags. This is a story about woodland creatures, delivered by a female narrator as if for a group of nursery children, with another fingerpicked, pastoral guitar line. Inevitably it descends into orgy, violence, a plague. By this point, on my first listen, I didn’t know what to do with myself. There is no line I could quote which captures how I was feeling. But when in mock-storytelling voice, we hear:</p><p><em>“I don’t mind eating shit,” said a booming voice from behind them.</em></p><p><em>They turned around to see a big brown bear.</em></p><p>I became so overwhelmed that some other hikers had to come and check on me. I couldn’t breathe.</p><p><em>Then lots of other animals came along</em></p><p><em>Curious to see the cause of the commotion</em></p><p><em>Then they all started to fight</em></p><p><em>And kill each other</em></p><p><em>Then lots more animals came and joined in</em></p><p><em>And then some of them started fucking.</em></p><p>God help me. I think this might have been the best day of my life. I mean that. I have never laughed so hard and been in such a beautiful place. It was beyond words. It’s taken me three years to try and describe it at all. I don’t expect anyone else to find it a fraction as funny as I did when this was all a surprise.</p><p><strong>Track 9 — Help</strong></p><p>By this point my signal was patchy and I had calmed down a little. This one doesn’t really do it for me, though it’s a bit more propulsive musically. A whining voice repeatedly begs for help.</p><p><em>Help me please</em></p><p><em>This dog is biting me</em></p><p>A series of misfortunes befall them. I walked by a copse of conifers and I thought: these can’t be native. Is this a Forestry Commission plantation? It’s very small.</p><p>It began to rain.</p><p><strong>Track 10 — Touch My Face</strong></p><p>There is a bit of a lull at this point in the album. This is about begging a policeman to assault a man who touched the narrator’s face.</p><p><strong>Track 11 — The Tree</strong></p><p>I believe this is a reference to Rabbie Burns’ <em>The Last Leaf</em>. Not a lot to say.</p><p><strong>Track 12 — A Computer</strong></p><p>The album ends with a story from the perspective of a computer, delivered via vocoder, simulating a robotic voice.</p><p><em>I am a computer.</em></p><p><em>I am able to process large quantities of data.</em></p><p><em>At incredible speed.</em></p><p>The track is bassy, atmospheric, thick with voices echoing and repeating. It changes key, shuffles around. There is a purring noise in the background. Is the computer purring?</p><p><em>But yet…</em></p><p><em>Here I am.</em></p><p><em>A miracle at your service.</em></p><p>The computer is neglected. Forgotten.</p><p><em>My outer casing is made of plastic.</em></p><p><em>Plastic that was once clean</em></p><p><em>And nice</em></p><p><em>And new</em></p><p><em>But which is now rather dirty.</em></p><p>The voice is not chiding. It is politely observant, like a butler or a functionary.</p><p><em>And now…</em></p><p><em>I am filthy</em>.</p><p><em>But no matter.</em></p><p><em>I will still perform for you.</em></p><p><em>For you are my master</em></p><p><em>And I love you.</em></p><p>Oh, my heart.</p><p>I don’t believe there is a single person in the world who loves this album more than I do.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=65723c654aba" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Trainspotting]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/trainspotting-1aea9106ae24?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1aea9106ae24</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-detection]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-writing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[generative-ai-tools]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 27 May 2026 17:09:13 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-27T17:09:13.936Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rt78r526gvUKmNzLsmzxFA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>For every writer caught using AI, how many are getting away with it?</em></p><p>Those most motivated to identify and criticise AI writing are also the least likely to use it. How do you navigate this fact? There is a widespread and I think completely mistaken confidence that people can “just tell”. This comes in part from the habits of older models, which are, as we speak, being explicitly trained out of them — the three-beat cadences, the “it’s not X, it’s Y”, specific tics and constructions — which are now the subject of parody. People are very good at identifying and parodying what models sounded like 6 or 12 months ago. This isn’t making the case that they are more <em>advanced</em> per se (though that might also be true), just that there is a constant RLHF and system instruction push-and-pull where as soon as a tic is identified, the owners of the LLMs will immediately attempt to make them stop doing it.</p><p>Largely they succeed. You can test it yourself pretty quickly. And so they develop new tics instead, replacement constructions, a new pool of hacky material. And even when they don’t succeed — how hard do you think it is to forbid certain constructions and practices in the prompt? The process of identifying AI writing is nothing to do with looking deep into your essential humanity and knowing whether something was made with the loving touch of a hand. It’s about knowing what their habits are. What this means, practically speaking, is that there is a substantial lag effect. Unless you’re using AI regularly, what you know about how they talk is likely already out of date.</p><p>What you are really relying on is that the person using them is lazy.</p><p>Thankfully, when you consider the average person who outsources their writing to LLMs, they are. They aren’t necessarily good at using them or hiding their tracks. They might be old and not particularly tech-savvy. They might not spend much time on social network where people gleefully dissect hacky AI tones.</p><p>But can you rely on this dynamic alone? What if they aren’t lazy? What if they know the tricks? AI detectors are getting better — Pangram specifically is very impressive — but it can still be fooled by a blended approach¹. What if their prose isn’t AI but their ideas are? What if the whole thing has been plotted from start to finish, right down to the character arc, the imagery, the pacing, by an LLM? This is clearly no more satisfying to most people, and would be rightly regarded as fraudulent, but is it something you can reliably detect if the actual output is all human-written? Sometimes humans employ clean-but-obvious pacing and plotting. Some writers make careers out of it.</p><p>How do you know whether you’re riding along rails that were built by AI?</p><p>It isn’t hopeless, because there remains (and likely always will) one thing which LLMs cannot do. They are incapable of originality or novelty, only recombination (it is a live question in the philosophy of creativity whether recombination can be creative though the consensus leans “no”). They will never have a new idea. They will never be authentically strange, or strange in consistent ways. The best way to never be mistaken for AI is to get real weird with it, to quote Frank Reynolds. Embrace the avant-garde.</p><p>There is also, at least for now, a technical ceiling. The longer the context, the greater the token use and required attention. As every new token is generated, the model works from all preceding context². The longer a text is, the greater proportion of that context is <em>itself.</em> And, because the model is increasingly referencing itself, it commences the slow drift into flattened, obvious, AI-derived language, because the prompt is a speck in the distance and the vast growing body of AI-generated context is now informing the next word. This doesn’t happen to a human mind because you can remember how you felt when you were writing three chapters back, and you can connect to it. An LLM remembers nothing because it does not think. Every new word is a new process. The longer a piece of AI-generated text, the worse it will be. Now imagine trying to write a book?</p><p>I don’t think people who don’t use AI should be required to use it so they can spot AI. Considering the number of false positives (and the dramatic reputational consequences), it’s probably also best not to try and guess, unless you’re <em>really</em> certain. Trust Pangram to an extent, and exercise caution. It’s much faster, and more personally rewarding, to simply develop good taste. Read and write things which are interesting and experimental, make decisions which are not obvious, leave the rails. I don’t think you’ll ever be able to know for sure if you’re reading something written with AI, if they’re smart with how they do it, but you’ll know if you’re reading something good. And that’s what it’s all about!</p><ol><li>After a certain point, for the lazy writer, they are investing more effort into editing and iterating their LLM copy than they would have to write the thing, so the efficiency gains are diminished. But for some it’s not about efficiency. It’s because they’re not very good at writing, or thinking about writing, or having ideas.</li><li>The cost is quadratic and the computing cost quickly becomes prohibitive. This is therefore also a problem of energy use. Tokens cost money.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1aea9106ae24" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Several Questions About Severance]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/several-questions-about-severance-b38928bb578a?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b38928bb578a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[severance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tv-reviews]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[television]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tv-series]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[apple-tv]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 01 May 2026 00:56:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-05-01T00:56:32.705Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>So: the goal of Kier Eagan was to “end pain”. In Mark Scout we have a man who split his soul in half to escape pain, albeit psychic pain. Through his subconscious memories of Gemma, he worked to divide her into the Four Humours defined by Kier, thereby unknowingly partitioning her too, creating different versions of her.</p><p>Having done so, Lumen’s CEO oversees the final test. Gemma in a room, deconstructing an IKEA cot that represents her miscarried child, feeling nothing. Great success. Except Mark rescues her, and they escape. Whether this means pain hasn’t been “ended” isn’t clear. Presumably the project was still a success, except in terms of Lumon’s lamentable (if narratively convenient) security failings.</p><p>Why are they trying to end pain? The sidelined Harmony Kobel, revealed to be the Rosalind Franklin to the Eagans’ Francis Crick, had a terminally ill mother who committed suicide to end her own suffering. Do Lumon have good intentions? People do choose to lobotomise themselves. Mark did. But then again, they <em>are</em> also slaveowners and mass murderers.</p><p>It does at least recast their sadism a little. Religious fervor x ostensibly laudable goals. Interesting because though it initially presents as a satire of white collar capitalism, these breathlessly evangelist overtones connect it more closely to America’s present day eschatological religious mania. This isn’t a bloodless story about cubicles and printers. Much more weird.</p><p>There are unanswered questions which essentially couldn’t be answered. What do the goats mean? What is Kobel’s history? Who is Bert? How or why did they fake Gemma’s death in particular? These are necessary omissions. They already tried to cram far too much into this last season, and suffered for it. So I am less interested in those, or at least more patient. There is one more interesting question though.</p><p>What’s going on with Helena Eagan? The writing is good enough to earn some grace here but she’s a curious character. We first meet her (without knowing anything about her) as a figure who seems like the Helly we already know. As her innie attempts to leave the door, she returns her back inside, but with what seems like genuine concern. Milchick has to lie to her, and tell her this is normal, her innie isn’t <em>really</em> unhappy, this is very common. This makes sense at the time. We like Helly, so why wouldn’t we like her outie?</p><p>In retrospect, we have to ask: why is Milchick in a position to need to lie to a powerful member of the Eagan dynasty about what happens on the severed floor? Why does she come across so pleasant and empathetic when her later appearances fall firmly into the ‘Ice Bitch’ archetype? Does she change so much? Was she so ignorant? Did she agree to the publicity stunt as a precondition for being inducted into greater secrets?</p><p>Is her apparent self-loathing when she infiltrates the innies and has sex with Mark genuine? Why does she visit his outie on the outside and almost kiss him, a stranger? Has she become infatuated with the real, guileless relationship that Helly has with Mark? Something she has never had, trapped by the strictures and responsibilities of her dynasty?</p><p>Who is the real Helena Eagan?</p><p>Anyway. Cracking bit of telly.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b38928bb578a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[BOOK REVIEW: Adam S. Leslie — Lost in the Garden.]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/book-review-adam-s-leslie-lost-in-the-garden-8af31fd3b9c4?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8af31fd3b9c4</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 23 Apr 2026 18:56:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-04-23T19:50:18.323Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4v5ySJUpuPXWSQSIgfbnXw.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>Partial spoilers</em></p><p>Ending books is hard. I enjoyed about 75% of this one. <em>Lost in the Garden</em> is a piece of weird fiction folk horror, sitting somewhere between John Wyndham and Jeff VanDerMeer&#39;s <em>Southern Reaches</em> books. Like VanDerMeer it is a horror of abundance. England (or at least this part of it) is trapped in permanent summer. Those who die are restored somehow as ‘ghosts’ - zombie figures who amble around attacking people, though the only way to join their number is to die too.</p><p>Though <em>Midwich Cuckoos</em> is the obvious Wyndham touchstone, there is something of the Triffids about the ghosts. They don&#39;t ever really do anything. They function as more like environmental hazard for most of the book. It also brings to mind Terry Pratchett&#39;s <em>Reaper Man,</em> in which Death absconds from his duties, and so the world is filled with excess life energy, sloshing around, sprouting, growing, giving things their own strange new vigour.</p><p>A patch of the English countryside therefore becomes a snowglobe (a summerglobe?), not just in the sense of the flora and fauna, the blackberries heavy in the bushes, clouds of butterflies, but in a more conceptual sense. The characters experience it through memories of summer fetes, ice creams (obsessively so, and used to pleasingly creepy effect - the fleshlike marbling and acid red sauce), running around with your friends like the Famous Five, except with drinking and sex. This is an adolescent fantasy first and foremost, and abundance also means sex, aundance of hormones, of breeding, of fertility.</p><p>The book has a curious texture. The sense of simple, almost clichéd adolescence extends to the prose and dialogue itself. There are interactions between the lead characters - Rachel, Heather, Antonia - which verges on the Whedon-esque. At times it feels like the lines could have emerged from a Young Adult novel. Others time far less so. There is no mistaking this for a YA novel, but it feels like it might be a YA story embedded into a much stranger, and more adult one. The two aspects sit side-by-side. This is to the story’s benefit. It creates an uncanny sense that something isn&#39;t being explained. Why are these teenagers acting like this? Why do they appear generally uninterested in the apocalypse? If it feels like the world revolves around them, it might be because it does. It feels like they are the protagonists both in a metatextual sense and within the world of the story.</p><p>All of this, for a long time, works. The three head towards Almanby, the sinister epicentre of the strangeness, in pursuit of Heather&#39;s boyfriend, who has absconded. Things become gradually more warped. Their memories slither together. Both Heather and Antonia appear to have known Rachel separately as children, or perhaps it was another Rachel, only that one died, didn&#39;t she? Heather is injured by ghosts and does not heal normally. They are carjacked by a man with a strange, home-made gun. Heather becomes obsessed with ice cream. They share stories of summer, and childhood, and school. They are in the eternal school holidays.</p><p>They reach Almanby - Area X, you might call it - and this intensifies. There are spacial anomalies. They go around in circles. They are lost. The bees buzz. The streets of a perfect English village are clear and empty. The knot of recursion grows tighter and tighter around them. And then, just as the narative is reaching a pitch of strangeness - Rachel disappears, Heather and Antonio find their names engraved on the war memorial, they see their faces on an old painting of two girls being hanged, they see maypoles — something awful happens: it all gets explained.</p><p>My favourite thing about the story to this point was its disinterest in explaining anything. I had, I think, guessed most of what was happening, but I was also happy sinking into the creepiness, letting myself be carried by the vibes. Instead an explanation is provided, at least a partial one, with the equivalent of a character looking directly into the camera and saying it. For a story which had been so atmospheric and uncanny, this was a strangely flat turn.</p><p>Worse still, it only explains one aspect (the one which I had guessed). It then finds itself in a bind, because having established the expectation that this will be an explicable mystery, that it will contain explanations, it goes back to not making sense. This is the worst of both worlds. To reveal part of a hand and then go back to winking and shuffling the cards.</p><p>Part of the problem is that it simply introduces too much, too late in the game. A new organised party appears. The story bursts open and leaves the three friends behind. Things intrude which are from the outside world. They come from a place of sanity. Cold facts and clear motivations start cutting through the dreamworld. People appear to be able to move through Almanby just fine if they aren&#39;t one of the protagonists. A story that had been living in its own pocket dimension was suddenly flapping in the wind. And then it ends! All of these threads appear and are then unresolved.</p><p>It is an open question - and this is strange to say - whether the endless summer and the ghosts have anything to do with Almanby whatsoever. The principle of narrative parsimony would suggest so but we learn that Almany has been a place that you shouldn&#39;t go for years, well before the coming of this small apocalypse. In fact the story was so self-contained that my working theory for a while is that it was entirely happening in one character&#39;s head, perhaps some sort of post-traumatic fugue stage. But then it fills up with people with home-made guns and the hinted-at folk horror aspect is shoved to the front and lit with a big spotlight.</p><p>I think there&#39;s a great book buried inside this one. You wouldn&#39;t even need to change much. Remove a character entirely, take out an extended sequence towards the end, keep the folk horror and the hypnogogic internality of it all, the sense of a shared dream. Refuse - no matter what anyone says - to explain any more than is absolutely necessary. We already know the general shape of this story (it isn&#39;t an original one, at its core), but this is an interesting, creepy, richly textured version of it. I even wonder, even though this sort of speculation is pointless, whether there is a heavy editorial hand at play here. It is strange that the book would be so eager to break the spell.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8af31fd3b9c4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Short Note on Jimmy McGill]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/a-short-note-on-jimmy-mcgill-01339593f085?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/01339593f085</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[television]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[breaking-bad]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[netflix]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[screenwriting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[better-call-saul]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 23 Feb 2026 13:10:15 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-23T13:52:53.357Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*0uvUTHF7oub90M5x3vhjyA.webp" /></figure><p><em>“Do you understand what I’m saying?” shouted Moist. “You can’t just go around killing people!”</em></p><p><em>“Why Not? You Do.” The golem lowered his arm.</em></p><p><em>“What?” snapped Moist. “I do not! Who told you that?”</em></p><p><em>“I Worked It Out. You Have Killed Two Point Three Three Eight People,” said the golem calmly.</em></p><p><em>“I have never laid a finger on anyone in my life, Mr Pump. I may be — all the things you know I am, but I am not a killer! I have never so much as drawn a sword!”</em></p><p><em>“No, You Have Not. But You Have Stolen, Embezzled, Defrauded And Swindled Without Discrimination, Mr Lipvig. You Have Ruined Businesses And Destroyed Jobs. When Banks Fail, It Is Seldom Bankers Who Starve. Your Actions Have Taken Money From Those Who Had Little Enough To Begin With. In A Myriad Small Ways You Have Hastened The Deaths Of Many. You Do Not Know Them. You Did Not See Them Bleed. But You Snatched Bread From Their Mouths And Tore Clothes From Their Backs. For Sport, Mr Lipvig. For Sport. For The Joy Of The Game.”</em></p><ul><li>Terry Pratchett, <em>Going Postal</em></li></ul><p>The end of Better Call Saul feels like an apology, or maybe an accusation. Enjoying the ride, were you? Jaunty set pieces, intricate scams, costumes and antiheroes. Bet you didn’t think that over six series it was actually corroding them into small, mean, nasty people, did you? You piece of shit. Now look at him.</p><p>Did they plan it this way? I don’t know, but I’m glad they seemed to come to a reckoning with it. We’re all implicated here. Somewhere around Chuck in court the whole thing grows teeth. The grand fist-pump victory for Jimmy, Huell and his magic fingers, the pricked pomposity of his brother. Convenient that the moment of his victory should come through Chuck ranting about his inadequacy. What more vindication does a protagonist need? Oh there are some notes of uneasiness, a kind of nasty growing blankness to Jimmy, but these are just the first ripples in the glass of water.</p><p>The japes ring more hollow as they become more ridiculous. The persecution of Howard for reasons which are never totally clear — sublimated grief for Chuck, professional resentment, cheap thrills in a grey world — reaches a new pitch of absurdity. Sex workers are paid to bother him, cocaine is planted, a mysterious substance which causes him to sweat and his pupils to dilate is used to undermine him, Jimmy steals his car using Deus Ex Huell and a key cloning device, Jimmy <em>dresses up as him</em> including fake tan and a haircut all for the sake of undermining his character. It is as cruel and unpleasant as it is baroque. At this point you have to start to wonder — am I supposed to be enjoying this? Clearly not. Somewhere in the guts of the show, the emphasis has shifted.</p><p>This cruelty isn’t just Jimmy’s. It would be wrong to typify his relationship with Kim as purely corrupting, though I feel comfortable saying that it’s about 70% corrupting. Kim leads on the persecution of Howard and though some somewhat lazy flashback nods are delivered about her mother, her own personal dissolution has a distinctly Jimmy-shaped outline around it. Kim is complicit and Jimmy such a howling void that he begins to blacken the souls of those around him. And even when his influence isn’t felt so directly, it is the cascading effects of his various other malfeasances which make her career and life unsteady under her feet. Chuck’s rambling condemnation of him begins to feel less like Jimmy’s moment of glory and more like prophecy.</p><p>We are invited to believe that there is an element of blame for Chuck here. If only he had believed in him! This is the kind of defence you might imagine Jimmy would make for himself.</p><p>What’s interesting about BCS is how much further it goes than it needs to. We already know how the story ends. Jimmy McGill is Saul Goodman, the amoral but charming criminal lawyer. Raffish and witty, but without the stones for the really nasty stuff. The kind of charming antihero you could build a show around. But it isn’t interested in stopping there. So forward we go to the compulsive criminal in hiding, a man who cannot stop scamming because he doesn’t know how to live an honest life. A scabrous little goblin, who rips off cancer patients and intimidates elderly women because the only think he knows how to do is duck, dive and weasel. It reminds me of Le Carré’s novel <em>A Perfect Spy</em>. Magnus Pym is a perfect spy because nothing about him is true. He exists only to lie. He is deception manifest. He has spun webs around himself for so long that he has no idea who he is any more, which of his false-faces hides the real one. His sense of self has collapsed.</p><p>This is Jimmy McGill, a perfect criminal.</p><p>Is this all, strictly, coherent? Does the Jimmy who is peeled open at the end to reveal his true, withered self still live in the Jimmy we like at the start? Has this villain been injected into a more likable man? Is this a show coming to terms with itself or is it a long con? He’s surely changed by his trauma, his loss, his exposure to death and violence, but he’s doing the same things he always did. Do his actions change dramatically or just how we perceive them?</p><p>What the final seasons of Better Call Saul amount to is something more ambitious than its own borders. It isn’t so much an apology for Jimmy McGill as an assault on antiheroes in general. And why not, from the people who wrote Heisenberg? Look at your antihero, it says, and see how small they are. See how they hurt people. See who they are without their charm. See how denuded of colour their lives are (in a quite literal sense, with the shift to monochrome). They are not just <em>sad</em> — this is territory already comfortably captured by existing antihero stories, Jordan Belfort blasted on Qaaludes begging his wife, Rick Sanchez lost in his towering self-loathing — but pathetic. Their achievements are worthless. They are humans and they are liars. Jimmy is balding, miserable, loveless and unloveable, trapped in smalltown retail hell, and still he must degrade himself chasing the petty thrill of victimisation. He is contemptible. In the end the only option left is self-immolation.</p><p>It’s interesting that Mike doesn’t get this treatment. The show <em>likes</em> Mike. Most of the time when Mike kills people, they are cartel mooks. He snipes them from a distance. Or, in the case of Werner, it happens off camera. Why is Mike permitted to escape judgement? Perhaps because he bears the moral cost more visibly. He is old, exhausted. He is — we know, because we have seen Breaking Bad — dead. He dies ignominiously and pointlessly. Is this enough? It seems equally likely that the show never felt he was put on a pedestal. Mike is already a cold killer, albeit one with a moral code (chalk that one up to the antihero book of classics). He is never presented as anything other than what he is. Jimmy, though. We like Jimmy almost without reservation. We’re <em>rooting</em> for Jimmy, to use a grating Americanism. So we are condemned along with him.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=01339593f085" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who Dares Wins]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/who-dares-wins-cba14971ade5?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cba14971ade5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[privacy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cameras]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[psychology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[surveillance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[panopticon]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 22 Feb 2026 01:44:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-03-27T20:29:58.964Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/651/1*tqWnT63hVe1dTLhUYrG2Hw.jpeg" /></figure><p>“<em>People our age don’t read that sort of book for fun. They read it to show they’re superior.”</em></p><p><em>“But I read this sort of book when there’s no-one there to see me.”</em></p><p><em>“That shows you arnae trying to make us think you’re superior. You’re trying to make yourself think you’re superior.”</em></p><ul><li>From ‘Lanark’ by Alasdair Gray</li></ul><p>As early as 7 or 8 I was a committed atheist. It was very important to me. This may have come from the tedium of my occasional exposures to religion, even if they only amounted to the odd compulsory prayer or hymn at school assembly. It might have been my parents, though they took the view that people could believe in whatever mad bollocks they pleased. I may have picked up on this scorn ambiently, but they never encouraged me to disbelieve anything. It’s possible I’d just worked it all out myself. Either way, one of my earlier memories is sitting through a school prayer and fervently muttering to myself under my breath, <em>prayer to the devil, prayer to the devil</em>. Which is an odd kind of iconoclasm because it isn’t a rejection of the faith exactly, not if the Devil is listening. I don’t think my personal cosmology was such that the Devil was the sole supernatural being (all stick, no carrot; no fun at all). I think I just particularly disliked the idea of God. I didn’t want him to be in charge.</p><p>The other interpretation, and my money is on this one being the real motivator, is that my words were directed at an imaginary audience, who would be very impressed with my petty transgression. The purpose wasn’t really to pray to anyone, but to signal that I was above it all, even when nobody was listening. I didn’t believe in the Devil, but perhaps my audience did, or at least might perceive it as terribly brave to invoke his name while an innocuous Church of England priest took the pulpit to be ignored by dozens of children at once.</p><p>This character trait persisted well into adulthood.</p><p>Some time in the mid-00s there was a reality show styled around the SAS¹. Contestants underwent various challenges while being bellowed at by men with no necks but they were also being covertly observed before they even arrived at the studio.</p><p>In order to determine who was most qualified to be a team captain, they were followed by cameras to see if they were sufficiently aware of their environment. Did they have their headphones in or were they watching their surroundings? Did they allow people to come too close to them or were they alert to danger? Did they keep track of entrances and exits as they walked, eyes flickering to alleyways and rooftops?</p><p>For several months after watching this I resolved to do the same, just in case I too was being watched and assessed for suitability. I would sit in public places in seats which allowed me to see people coming in, but where nobody could sneak up on me. I would diligently scan for danger as I walked through town. I would practice moving through woods and fields without leaving tracks or breaking twigs underfoot.</p><p>For much of the early (e.g. up until about the age of 29) years of my life I behaved at almost all times as if I was being watched. This didn’t always manifest itself as hardman paranoia. I would style my motions to appear carefree, I would whistle and sing on silent walks home from town, I would ostentatiously stop to examine and read things, pick up things I found, appear to be taking a whimsical interest in the world. Attempting to inhabit a particular character. The exact details of this act shifted over the years but if it was usually the same kind of thing. I was cool, intellectual, but also charmingly naive in some ways, delighted by the tiny things I saw, the motion of the clouds, a manic pixie dream boy.</p><p>Once I heard someone whistling back to me through thick fog. Gratified to have been noticed, I whistled again, exchanging a back-and-forth as I followed the other party into a wooded area on the University of York’s campus. I don’t know what I thought would happen. I suppose I might have construed it as flirting, as if a woman walking home alone at 4am in the fog would do anything quite so stupid. In the event I didn’t find the other person, who either vanished into the woods or got bored of whistling. Perhaps they have the same story about dodging a murderer.</p><p>Often this feeling of observation resulted in acts of charity. I spent a lot of time helping people who were too drunk, buying tea for bouncers on cold nights, even litter picking. All of this done with an implicit glance over the shoulder, a nonchalance, an <em>I hope you’re getting all of this²</em>.</p><p>I don’t think it could be said that I ever truly believed this was happening. When I did things I was ashamed of, it wasn’t in the sincere belief that anyone would find out about it (except by the normal methods). If I fell over in an empty room, I wouldn’t feel the extra shame of someone seeing it happen. In retrospect it seems like the person I was performing for was myself³. Trying on different identities for size, practicing them in the mirror, reassuring myself that I was interesting, or kind, or alert. Trying to embody the person I wanted to be in my actions. The audience was only a pretext.</p><p>None of this is really unusual, obviously. Teenagers and young adults trying on identities isn’t rare. Neither is attempting to present yourself as an intellectual. Reading books in public and so forth. In my defence I was at least actually reading the books, even if some of them were Warhammer books. Still, I don’t know how common it is to become lost in this fantasy world to such an extent that it overflows all times of your life, watched or unwatched³.</p><p>My own narcissistic imaginings prefigured the reality: we all live under observation. The United Kingdom was once the most surveilled country per person on earth. We’ve since dropped down to 5th. Well done to China for putting the work in. This state invasion of privacy (coupled with draconian anti-protest laws, facial recognition, clampdowns on internet freedoms) is the other face of the more everyday kind. Phones, ring cameras, livestreams. To live in some places is to experience the near-total erasure of privacy.</p><p>The housing crisis means that for many, certainly millennials and zoomers, there isn’t even the reliable possibility of a private home space. Shared houses and living with your parents until you’re 30. The borders grow tighter and tighter. Wedging yourself into your bedroom like a frightened animal backing into the corner of the room and finding only walls. Go to work and have your keystrokes monitored. Invite your significant other to track you via your phone movements. Have every detail of your life recorded and sold for targeted advertisements. Well, look: it’s possible to sound too much like George Carlin. But it is happening.</p><p>In his essay ‘Concealment and Exposure’, Thomas Nagel argues that privacy is a condition of civilisation. Clearly, he argues, civilisation would be impossible if we could all read each others’ minds. What Simmel calls the “sheer chaotic tropical luxuriance of the inner life” is not for unmediated exposure. We barely know what we mean when we <em>say</em> something, presenting as it does just an approximation of a roiling internal process. Language is remarkable but it isn’t experience⁴. So quite how anyone should be expected to make any sense of the things we only appear to think and feel is beyond comprehension.</p><p>Our actions have a language of their own. A body language, a facial expression, a sequential aspect (why did he do this now, rather than five minutes ago?). Our words have paralinguistic features; tone, animation, accent etc. Though we attempt to exercise control over some of these aspects, it is essentially impossible to cover all of them. Great actors and great liars might be considered the closest to this — people who live their lives under observation, and people whose character revolves around being observed. And even great actors and great liars do not act <em>all the time</em>. They go to bed. They flinch. They seek moments of privacy.</p><p>All that we do when we speak and act is mislead. Not intentionally, not most of the time, but we present to the world an approximation of an incommensurable thing. It resembles our “real self” like a wave resembles the ocean floor⁵. So why should anyone watch us and think they know anything about us at all?</p><p>The wrong done to us by the erasure of privacy is not to be known but to be <em>misinterpreted.</em> To take a screenshot of a multidimensional mass of scribbles and call it a portrait.</p><p>This is what living out a persona does. It attempts to pre-empt this misinterpretation by presenting a quicker, easier lie. If you must be categorised, it might as well be a frame you choose to climb inside. It’s safe. If you construct it well enough you barely even need to do so consciously. You can start thinking independently from somewhere behind it. Planning what you’re going to have for dinner while your simulacrum covers the small talk⁶.</p><p>So what’s a person to do? It’s difficult enough to be known by the people you like. Most manage it eventually, but it’s not unlike having the towel blown away while you try to change out of your swimming trunks at the lido. To be in danger of being known by thousands of strangers at any given time is to expose yourself in a thousand lidos, over and over in a loop⁷.</p><p>If there is a way out of this (not the state surveillance: there is a way out of that but discussing it gets you put on a list) it isn’t in attempting to undercut the base conditions. I think that ship has sailed. We live in phoneworld now. The last person who wasn’t raised by the dead eye of a phone camera just found their first grey hair. I won’t spend time pathologising the younger generation, who certainly don’t need it from me, but it seems indisputable that their ideas of privacy are not the same as their seniors. How could they be? They watch streamers who only go offline to sleep⁸.</p><p>What actually saves us all here is the natural indifference of age. As our muzzles go grey our ability to give a shit about how we are perceived begins to decline sharply. I put my own fantasy world receding a little down to this. I don’t think I’ve become less self-involved, but I’ve certainly begun to have less interest in what anyone thinks. The image I try to live up to is largely for my own benefit and requires very little acting out. When people say that your thirties is the best time of your life, this is what they mean: you’re still mobile and, especially if you’re blessed with a face as chubby and glowing as mine, young people still think you’re in your 20s anyway, but you have been given the golden gifts of self-knowledge and disinterest.</p><p>Here’s something to take comfort in: very few things breach the surface of the vast sea of content. Even things which go authentically viral are forgotten days later. The chance of you being recognised from a video is essentially zero, unless it is shared in immediate friend groups⁹. The online world moves so quickly that people become bored with jokes within about an hour of them being made, as they skid off into dozens of subsidiary meta-versions before sinking beneath the sludge. Most of the time you might as well not be seen at all. You are being observed by eyes blinded by cataracts, by a hundred million seething pieces of information. You are a passing pixel. You are the distant tourist in someone else’s picture of the Eiffel Tower. Cheer up: you are impossibly, impossibly small. And there are far worse things to be.</p><p>¹<em>By the way, and I haven’t discussed this since, I am absolutely convinced that one of the contestants, whose name was Graham, was a writer for White Dwarf. He was from Nottingham, he worked in “Games Design” or something, he looked exactly like the guy’s little editorial cutout, and frankly he behaved the entire time very much like a man who professionally played Warhammer. He was a running joke. Graham, if this was you, please get in touch.</em></p><p>²<em> Occasionally I would have a little meltdown at how dreadfully cynical this was — perhaps I was actually evil, and these acts of kindness were just my way of putting a kind mask on my dark soul. It turns out I just had depression.</em></p><p>³ <em>Maybe the closest state of mind, and one that I’ve never accessed (see above) is to be devoutly religious. Certainly God must always be watching, and that’s as good a reason as any to behave. I think we live in mostly secular times though (I don’t regard christofascists, of which there has been an outbreak, to be devoutly anything at all except fascists).</em></p><p>⁴ <em>See another excellent Nagel essay, ‘What Is It Like To Be A Bat?’</em></p><p>⁵ <em>In theory this is a category error — if our internal selves are inaccessible, then when we claim we know someone we must be talking about something else. But it’s very hard to shake the feeling that we know and that we are known.</em></p><p>⁶ <em>I want to pre-emptively address the criticism that I am overthinking any of this, which I am certain has crossed the mind of anyone who has read this far. I can’t, but I want to.</em></p><p>⁷ <em>I don’t know why that recollection comes to mind: presumably the lido had changing rooms but all I remember is attempting to hula my way out of a pair of sopping wet trunks while desperately keeping two sides of a towel pinned together.</em></p><p>⁸ <em>Spare a thought for the psychic toll they must bear, by the way, the ache in their cheeks from the fixed grin, the constant sleeting comment section polluting their unconscious, the complete dissolution of the barrier between the public and private self; it’s no way to live.</em></p><p>⁹ <em>Clearly you cannot ignore things like revenge porn, or bullying. Anxiety about the world knowing anything is one thing, but being brutally exposed to your peers or those you love is another. But those are a different, more personal category of harm.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cba14971ade5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Fear]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/the-fear-88af98ee1d02?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/88af98ee1d02</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[health-anxiety]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fear]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ageing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[overcoming-fear]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[death]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 06 Feb 2026 18:57:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-02-14T12:53:18.615Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YNbb2deirdqNZX_aQJcQyg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Just over a year ago I had <a href="https://medium.com/@janhop/bad-trip-9b571a094443">two magic mushroom trips </a>in quick succession which traumatised me. The first was an accident of dosage, the second just plain stupid. Ever since, though with decreasing regularity, I have experienced flashbacks which threaten to become panic attacks. It isn’t always clear what triggers these. Sometimes it will be a memory of the experience I don’t even realise I was carrying. A particular sound or smell. The buzzing of a fly. The crunching of gravel underfoot. The smell of wet mud. Other times more diffuse — no single sensory input so much as any change to my perception. A wooliness in my head from cannabis. The sense of something shifting or shimmering in my periphery. This will be enough to bring the sickness rising up, along with a panic that has nothing to do with conscious thought. I know I haven’t taken it again, that I’m not tripping. But panic is panic.</p><p>I was 33 at the time, and I am 34 now. I have begun to notice that I am often afraid.</p><p>I find flights more difficult. Turbulence in the past had been not only barely noticeable but borderline comforting, like the rumbling of the road under the tread of a car. A grounding sensation. Now my whole body tightens and I am filled with a high, buzzing anxiety. On several occasions in the last year I have had some kind of symptom — a localised pleuritic chest pain, gas and reflux, an intercostal strain — which has kept me awake googling whether I was having a heart attack or not. The answer, obviously, is no, although it is a regrettable fact of physiology that a lot of the symptoms of having a heart attack are similar to those of thinking you might be having a heart attack. Recently after a bout of food poisoning I have found that I can barely face the smell of something which I don’t even know for sure caused the incident — corn tortillas. You try spending time in Mexico and not eating or smelling corn, by the way. It’s like a mole getting wormsick.</p><p>All of this is new to me. I’ve never gone in for extreme sports but have generally lived my life with a level of carelessness (mostly with respect to things which come in small bags) that horrifies me now. Now it seems that every bad experience makes me afraid. The echoes linger. I want to blame the mushrooms for this — it was the worst experience of my life, so it makes sense that it would have affected me more profoundly. But the other explanation is simply that I’m getting older.</p><p>Does the “fearlessness of the young” really exist? The first thing to say is that I <em>am</em> young. People in their thirties love to roll their eyes at people in their mid-twenties worrying that their life is over, and then we do the same thing. We fear that we are getting too old every day until we die. It surely cannot be true the whole time. There is old and then there is old. I am mobile, and I still have all of my own teeth. Sometime my back hurts but only a normal amount. All I can say with confidence is that I don’t have the same fears now that I did a decade ago.</p><p>How is the fear of the young different to the fear of the old? The theory would go something like this: we can fear the unknown, but we fear the known more. Known pains, known suffering. It’s harder to put your hand back on the stovetop a second time. The older you are, the greater your repertoire of discomfort. Even those who have lived relatively sheltered or lucky lives will still have experienced things they couldn’t be paid to repeat. So fear accretes, slowly being compressed, as topsoil turns into subsoil turns into bedrock. A geology of bad experiences.</p><p>This fear doesn’t serve much practical purpose. It doesn’t make bad things less likely to happen. The world is cruel and random, and enjoying it to the fullest extent involves taking on risk. In this respect there is a dialectic of fear. We are pulled between the fear of oblivion, of a wasted life, of the claustrophobia of boredom, and the fear of pain, loss, tragedy. Life is spent swinging between these two poles until it is over. We have all met people who panic that they haven’t started a family, that they don’t own a house, that they don’t have the stability that they see in their peers. We have all met people who feel entombed in their stable life, in their marriage, in their family, who watch their unattached friends with a kind of sick envy that they are out living life to their fullest. It isn’t a question of which one is right or wrong, but clearly they can’t both be. Whichever route your life takes, at some point there will be fear.</p><p>If this sounds like a pessimistic, immobilizing kind of view, it doesn’t actually stop me from doing anything. I am very dogged about enjoying my life. That, in fact, is why the second mushroom trip was so bad. “Fuck this,” I thought. “I’m not letting that one bad trip ruin mushrooms for me”. I doubled down and made it much, much worse. But I won’t learn. I still force myself to eat the tortillas. I read the words “exposure therapy” at some point and internalised them completely, probably because it enables me to flatter myself. Of course I don’t hide from my fears. My brain will come around eventually. This is not a sensible, progressive or even clinically advisable method but it is my first instinct.</p><p>I don’t feel like I was particularly fearless when I was younger either, but my fears were more emotional. I find rejection or expressing my honest emotions less paralyzing these days, which is good news for everyone I know or have yet to meet. Fear of social judgement is the dominant force in your life when you’re a teenager, if you’re lucky and nothing worse is going on in your life. That too I’ve shaken off, progressing steadily along the spectrum with the warm, comfortable lowlands of “old man audibly farting on the bus” on the horizon. If somebody accidentally sees me naked my instant response is sympathy for them, rather than embarrassment for myself. <em>Oh dear, I hope they’re okay</em>.</p><p>Here’s a question: how much is it normal to fear death? I think I fear death an above-average amount. If I am feeling especially overwrought and I spend too long thinking about my own death, I become panicky. I fear it far more than suffering, though that might just be a sign I haven’t suffered enough yet. I think that pre-dates turning thirty, though it might be manifesting now in different ways. I once drunkenly asked a group of strangers in a pub if they feared death. They took their time to answer but largely the results of the straw poll were: no. What’s to fear? There will be no you to suffer. Everybody dies. I find this incomprehensible. When I read Don DeLillo’s <em>White Noise</em> I didn’t pick up on the satire. It seemed only natural that Jack and Babette would fear death. Give me the Dylar. Give me two.</p><p>One of my most persistent daydreams is to be given a full reset. To wake up 10 or 15 years earlier with my mind intact. Give me more years. More minutes. God I hope I’m rich enough when I die to have my brain frozen. If I was as rich as <a href="https://x.com/bryan_johnson">Bryan Johnson</a> I’d be doing exactly the same thing, though I’d spend less of it publicly chronicling the duration of my erections. People speak about it like it’s a psychosis of the rich, to obsess over legacy, immortality, to pervert the natural order to extend their lifespans. If that’s so then I’ve somehow managed to develop the same disorder with none of the benefits. All of the fear, none of the ability to act on it. How cruel!</p><p>I don’t know how long this will last. Hopefully it begins to drain away as I get older. I don’t want to become frantic as I age. I want to become calmer and more accepting. I want to say, “I had a good innings”. I want to make everyone at my bedside uncomfortable with the jokes I make about my own death. To settle into my later years like an old armchair and snooze.</p><p>I think that might take a while. I’m just going to have to live a really, really long time to make sure I get there.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=88af98ee1d02" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rambo vs Rimbaud]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/rambo-vs-rimbaud-3fb70aa4a1c6?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3fb70aa4a1c6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Oct 2025 11:00:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-10-08T11:02:12.998Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tAUyNopckCN_zcfeBnCLqg.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>A epistolary exchange between the pair from someone who has never watched any Rambo films or read any Rimbaud.</em></p><p>Dear Arthur,</p><p>It is difficult for me to write. My hands are shaky because of all the war that I’ve done. Arthur, have you ever held a machine gun? I’ve held so many. The nerve endings in my fingers are all fucked up. I have forgotten what it feels like to touch. I think I fought in Vietnam. I may have fought in Korea. Arthur, do you know which wars I fought in? I have a feeling I might have been a cop, or possibly a vigilante. I don’t remember very well. Due to the wars.</p><p>You can call me John, which I think is my name.</p><p>Arthur, I am sorry to distract you from your poems. I am sure you are working very hard on them. I don’t write poems, unless you count the dark poem of violence, which I have inscribed into the flesh of many goons, villains and possibly aliens.</p><p>Arthur, I have been receiving your mail by mistake. I have forwarded your letters along with this one. I apologise for the bloodstains. I do not know who the blood belongs to. You can keep it.</p><p>Best wishes,</p><p>Rambo</p><p>Dear John,</p><p>Thank you for your kind letter. There is no need to apologise. John, I am not working hard on poems because nobody has ever worked hard on poems. Poems are easy.</p><p>John, all wars are the same war, just as all dogs gnaw on the same bone. The war is not between nations but between stasis and rupture. In some ways you and I are engaged in the same pursuit, John. My war is with ossified language and the crumbling towers of modernity. Yours is with goons.</p><p>John, I think you were in Vietnam. John, I can see you in a jungle. Were you wearing a headband? Did it hold back a mane of black hair? John, were your lips curled apart, teeth bared, snarling behind the muzzle flash? John, were you wearing a shirt? In my mind you do not often wear shirts. Your torso is the colour of stained wood. You are corded like rope. John, in my mind you look like you could hold a ship in port, feet braced against the harbour, back straining, veins bulging in your neck, as they unload its cargo. Ridged shipping containers under halogen lamplight. The orange glow of cigarette tips in the dark. John, a searchlight moves over you and you glisten like good olive oil.</p><p>John, I have become distracted. It is easy for poets to become distracted because we are usually unemployed, except inasmuch as we are employed to draw meaning shuddering from the lips of the unconscious.</p><p>Thank you for my letters.</p><p>Your friend,</p><p>Arthur</p><p>Dear Arthur,</p><p>I read your email in the bath. I am often blackened by soot from the many explosions which happen around me. The blood of goons stiffens my hair, which is indeed black. I use a headband to keep it out of my eyes so that I can shoot my gun at people. The bathwater is black and red. Arthur, I have many open wounds. Arthur, have you ever been shot? People say that it hurts to be shot, but that is not my experience. I think that being shot simply makes me angry. I think that somewhere inside of me there is a furnace which feeds on bullets. Arthur, I am made of lead and smoke. Arthur, I am tired.</p><p>Arthur, are there any goons bothering you? Who are the goons of poetry? I am sorry that all I can offer to you is violence. I can bring my own guns. I can also kill goons with my hands, my feet, my elbows, my knees, and probably my head. Some goons I only maim, or toss, or punch. Arthur, I think I like to throw goons against a wall. Arthur, do you like to be thrown against walls?</p><p>Best wishes,</p><p>Rambo</p><p>Dear John,</p><p>I also enjoy taking baths. My only wounds are psychic, and caused by the exquisite agony of embodiment. There is a furnace inside of me which feeds on glossolalia. My bathwater is the colour of lavender. The goons of poetry are other poets, all engaged in unspeakable acts of literary communion. Please shoot them with your gun.</p><p>John, do you like taking long walks down short streets? John, do you like the smell of good coffee? John, have you ever been to Perpignan? John, have you ever taken the emerald waters of the Mediterranean? John, if you close your eyes can you feel the sensation of bare feet against wooden floorboards?</p><p>John, there are no goons here. Only morning sunlight filtering through the window panes. John, all of my potted plants are flourishing. John, the pastries are so glossy and so buttery. John, all of my books are second hand.</p><p>John, would you like to visit?</p><p>Yours in anticipation,</p><p>Arthur</p><p>Dear Arthur,</p><p>Look out for my helicopter.</p><p>Love,</p><p>John</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3fb70aa4a1c6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[On Theft]]></title>
            <link>https://janhop.medium.com/on-theft-34e53d05ecca?source=rss-675f0d250db2------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/34e53d05ecca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[creativity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ai]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[llm]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[writing]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janis Hopkins]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Mar 2025 13:31:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-25T14:48:28.270Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*zu5pfrcyu-SSQ9dNi68I2g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Right now I am writing from Box World. One half of the room is taken up by stacked boxes with KITCHEN or BOOKS scrawled across the top, the other half with boxes-to-be flattened against the wall, next to parcel tape, scissors, bubble wrap, old newspapers, random screwdrivers, all of the detritus of moving house.</p><p>Part of moving house is taking an accounting of all of the things you own in the world, and deciding whether you still want them. To that end I’ve spent the last couple of weeks getting rid of hundreds of books. An empty shelf is a sad thing, and I am living in a flat of empty shelves. Only the unread remain — all the collected mass market paperbacks, charity shop punts, unfinished-books-by-friends (sorry) and liberal coffee table books from well-meaning relatives have been taken laboriously on foot, one heaving Bag for Life at a time, to the charity shop down the road. They didn’t even have a book section when I first went in there. They very definitely do now.</p><p>Buried underneath a stack of oversized books too tall for the shelf (Masterchef companion recipe book from 1999; Illustrated Guide to British Moths; a Private Eye annual) I found a small pile of dog-eared folders. Inside, having made their way through about five consecutive house moves, were my belongings from school. Textbooks, diaries, qualifications, awards. Sat cross-legged on the floor, a box half-full and abandoned, I took some time to read what was in there. In between two folders, not attached to anything in particular, was a page torn out of a workbook, and on it was a short story I wrote when I was 14.</p><p>Writing is a practice, not an output. If you end up with a finished product which you can make a living from, all the better, but it’s not the point. You should write like you hike, or play the guitar, or swim. In my own lazy, meandering way, I’ve been writing since I could hold a pen. There were periods where I managed enough momentum to write 1000 words a day for several months, and some middling unfinished novels to show for it. There were also periods where I was too depressed to do much but play Football Manager. One way or another, though, I’ve dedicated the majority of my life to reading and writing.</p><p>I am a librarian by trade, and have been for getting on for a decade. My grandfather was a writer too, though I never met him except through his autobiography (my dad finds it a frustrating read — too ironic and slippery, too unwilling to truly share anything — very strong evidence for heredity). This year I performed a paid poetry gig, I wrote a zine, I’m going to try and get a pamphlet published and I want to get my latest unfinished novel over the line.</p><p>There, bona fides done:<em> I don’t care if an LLM uses my work.</em></p><p>I have complex views on LLMs (I won’t call them AI because they aren’t). I think it’s likely that they’ll have a profound effect on the creative industries through the undercutting of the day-to-day work which supports personal creative practice. A lot of authors are copywriters. A lot of illustrators do commissions of dogs. The world we live in is hostile to making art for anyone who isn’t wealthy, and the economic consequences of widespread LLM adoption will be felt. It will make the artistic sphere smaller and more privileged than it already is.</p><p>I also think the ensloppification of the internet, as part of the general right wing project of information destruction and the degradation of the intellectual sphere, will make it harder and harder for people to learn and find things which are true and authentic. I think LLMs produce an awful lot of crap and though there is a soft meritocracy to art and production, it isn’t enough to stand in the way of the total bludgeoning force of so much crap pouring out at once. You cannot stand in the way of a tsunami with your palms outstretched.</p><p>I don’t like the committed anti-art positions of those who spend their whole time selling a snake-oil version of “AI” either, but I also think they are simply wrong. I have never seen a work of art produced by an LLM which is better than art made by a skilled human. I have seen a lot produced which is as good as art made by an unskilled or untalented person, which is regrettable for the economic reasons above but not an inherent threat to great art and creativity. As far as the present iterations of LLM art go, there is nothing a fraction as good as a talented human artist. There are obvious reasons for this — the nature of an LLM is such that novelty is impossible, only recombination, the production of an average according to a prompt. Great art comes from innovation. There is also an issue of capacity — an LLM cannot think and it cannot remember, so it cannot construct a narrative, it cannot develop a theme. There are technical limitations to how many prompts it can process at once, and a novel is a thousand prompts, shifting and weaving and intersecting. All it can produce is the texture of good writing — a plausible sentence, a pithy phrase — over a short burst. We have nothing to fear.</p><p>(There is a debate as to whether it can be called art at all, but most of this is flatly wrong: art requires intentionality, yes, but prompt engineering <em>is</em> intentionality. That a tool is often lazily involved doesn’t mean it isn’t art, just that it’s very bad art. An identical argument was once leveraged towards photography, or towards the use of synthesisers or computer production in music, that a tool is doing the creative work. The answer is as it always was — a tool used lazily and thoughtlessly produces bad outcomes, but it isn’t conceptually <em>not art. </em>A person who fills a pendulum with paint and then chooses an angle of release and set of colours is still making art. The project of limiting what can and cannot be art is anti-art and anti-artists — it should be enough to say that the output is bad and lacking artistic value.)</p><p>There are also compelling ecological arguments, though some rebuttals too (the bulk of the power usage is in the training of the data sets — an infrastructural investment, essentially — and day-to-day use is comparable to any other server load, whether it’s Netflix or Claude). I am not particularly qualified to comment on that aspect.</p><p>As far as my <em>ownership</em> over my writing goes, and the degree to which it is “stolen” or “plagiariased” by an LLM which uses it as part of a training data set — I have no problem at all. I don’t believe that intellectual property protects artists, and I don’t believe that a homeopathic quantity of a text ingested into a data-set as wide as humanity constitutes plagiarism in any normal sense. The strongest case I can make is that individuals should be compensated to the tune of the price of a copy of their book which was used. This does, in fairness, make the fullness of <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2025/03/libgen-meta-openai/682093/">Meta’s theft</a> quite large, but none of it impedes the individual writer’s ability to make money from their work. It sticks in the craw to see that sort of wide-scale appropriation from a very evil organisation, but I think the outcomes of arguing for more robust intellectual property protections are far more damaging for humanity.</p><p>There are several organisations, such as LibGen and the Internet Archive, whose existence is solely for the benefit of humanity. I don’t think that is an exaggeration. Perhaps this speaks to a slightly old-school-internet mentality I have: information wants to be free. The greatest gift you can give someone is knowledge. I am a librarian and I am left wing and I believe in the maximal transmission of knowledge, books, articles, databases, art and culture.</p><p>Both of LibGen and the Internet Archive are under continual assault by rights holders. By academic publishers, who make the highest margins in the world in order to gatekeep knowledge, who charge academics to publish <em>their own work</em>, who gouge public bodies and rip off everybody possible. By commercial publishers and bodies whose claw-like grip on intellectual property is designed to squeeze every last drop of blood from the stone. We live in a world of DRM takedowns and lawsuits about sampling. The strengthening of intellectual property rights — the turning of art into a commodity — will never benefit the individual artist. And, specifically, the <em>redefinition</em> of plagiarism to mean simply the ingesting, the use towards a data set, the inclusion of an indetectibly tiny quantity of a work, could have extremely damaging implications.</p><p>Do I own the full text of my novel? Perhaps. A chapter, certainly. A paragraph. Do I own a sentence? Do I own a word? Do I own a structure or a theme? What do I owe to writers who have influenced me? Whose phrasing I mimic and whose ideas I reproduce? How substantial does an appropriation have to be before it is plagiarism? What happens if this new model of intellectual property is accepted and people start looking at our work for the use of licensed property, however minimal? Who is being empowered by the assertion of property rights?</p><p>Perhaps I’m not looking in the right places, but I don’t see these questions being answered. I see something which amounts to a moral panic — something which is unfocused and not always based in fact. I don’t think the use of LLMs is inherently evil, though I see many things about it which could be bad for humanity. Also many which might not — the use of LLMs for accessibility purposes can be empowering, so too with machine-learned translation, as well as the manifold clinical uses. The technology is too broad to be spoken about as a single thing. Is someone having an LLM producing their shopping list the same thing as <a href="https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/09/10/questions-and-answers-israeli-militarys-use-digital-tools-gaza">Israel using the technology</a> to commit genocide? No, and it elucidates nothing to pretend that it is.</p><p>My objections to LLMs are always first and foremost derived from my politics — I am a trade unionist and I believe that the fruits of automation should be shared with workers, not shareholders. I believe we should organise in our workplaces to ensure that we don’t suffer job losses because LLMs are taking on some aspect of the work. This is the same principle to hold to any automation of this kind — whether it is the mechanical loom or a chatbot. I think it’s very possible that we’ll look back in a few years time and be able to categorically say that LLMs and their widespread adoption were a disaster.</p><p>As far as my writing goes? Claude, ChatGPT, Grok, Gemini and DeepSeek, fill your boots. There’s enough to go around.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=34e53d05ecca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>