<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Janice Rottenberg on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Janice Rottenberg on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@janicero?source=rss-fa2590de1565------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 02:54:04 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@janicero/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Here’s what a Voter Contact Program Director Is, and Why You Should Hire One]]></title>
            <link>https://janicero.medium.com/heres-what-a-voter-contact-program-director-is-and-why-you-should-hire-one-5a744b3bb187?source=rss-fa2590de1565------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5a744b3bb187</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[campaigning]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[organization-design]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democrats]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Janice Rottenberg]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 18 Feb 2021 02:34:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-18T16:20:43.998Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Hello, people of the small corner of the internet who geek out about Democratic campaign structure as much as I do! I’m Janice Rottenberg, and I’ve been mostly on campaigns since 2012.</p><p>In 2019, I hired my first ever Voter Contact Program Director (VCPD) while running Elizabeth Warren’s Iowa Caucus campaign. It was a new role, with a job description I wrote myself — and since then, it’s made its way to a few different campaigns. I’m proud and excited, because I think it’s an important role on a large team. <strong>Many of you may be thinking about your own 2021 or 2022 campaign organizations, and I want you to have every advantage possible to make serious investments and win elections.</strong> I think a VCPD can add huge value to your team, if it’s done in a way that meets your needs.</p><p>So <strong>before you hire your own VCPD, </strong>I want to give you context on the origins of the role, what worked, and what didn’t — so you can make the best decisions possible for your own team.</p><h3><strong>The Origin Story: Inventing a Job</strong></h3><p>In 2018, I moved back to Iowa to be the state Coordinated Campaign Director. I loved my job, and it was an exciting time to be doing the work — Iowa runs a large midterm Vote By Mail (VBM) program, traditionally anchored by significant canvassing and mail operations — but this was the first cycle where we were incorporating peer-to-peer text, relational organizing, and digital ads to promote VBM.</p><p>I was thrilled the program was being expanded to new platforms — but I’ll be honest, I was also overwhelmed. I love thinking strategically about voter contact — timing, methods, and efficiency — but as a Coordinated Director, I had so much else to do. I didn’t get to dedicate as much time as I’d have liked to our VBM program — especially given that it was the core reason our campaign existed.</p><p>After 2018 I wrote a Google Doc called “if I did this again,” hoping my reflections might help me or someone else doing that job in the future. As part of the exercise, I wrote out a list of all the decision making and program strategy I had been responsible for. My diagram looked like this:</p><figure><img alt="this is a chart detailing the two main sets of responsibilities i had on the campaign. the left column are political and management tasks; the right is direct voter contact." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/482/1*ytylX0crjCO7nm-1JGzSsQ.png" /></figure><p>Looking at those two buckets in retrospect, I decided if I did this job again, I’d hire someone else to prioritize Bucket Two. I felt like I had spent years letting those tasks get done on autopilot (I wrote all our door scripts as Field Director in 2014! In 2016, our Data Director and I used to “plan and brainstorm” from 11 PM — 3 AM every night so we could spend the daytime hours managing our teams!), when in fact, they were critical decisions that were impacting our efficacy as a campaign. They deserved someone’s full focus, and there weren’t enough hours in the day for me to do both well.</p><h3><strong>The Job I Invented: Voter Contact Program Director</strong></h3><p>So in 2019, I hired a Voter Contact Program Director (VCPD). In the simplest terms, <strong>a VCPD coordinates:</strong></p><ol><li><strong>which voters to talk to,</strong></li><li><strong>on what channel (i.e. doors, texting, etc)</strong></li><li><strong>when,</strong></li><li><strong>and with what message.</strong></li></ol><p>On a large campaign, they’ll spend most of their time convening and coordinating Data, Digital/Mobilization, and Organizing leadership. In an ideal world, they’re tied into any team that’s talking to voters — like Paid Canvass programming, working with your Finance team on how to maximize participation from your list, or working with your Comms Director to produce messaging materials. They organize the phases and arcs of your voter contact program and give structure to the overall campaign. They help make sure all your voter-facing departments are on the same page, and when they’re not, the VCPD resolves it. <strong>Put simply, they’re a doer, a mediator and they get paid to stay many steps ahead of the rest of your team.</strong></p><p>This person will need to be a good project manager, an excellent learner, and bluntly, not a jerk. They’ll be in a lot of situations in which they are not an expert, but will need to be able to ask smart questions and sometimes defuse disagreement between leaders. They’ll be tasked with translating between teams who have different expertise and deciding who makes the final call — but importantly, they do not need to be a subject-matter expert in all of them to succeed.</p><p>Because the role requires constant collaboration, you should fill this role with someone who complements and supplements the rest of your specific team — whether that’s bringing in an experience set, creativity, stability, etc. I debated whether this role would be lateral or managerial to the Data, Organizing, and Digital/Mobilization Directors, and settled on a lateral structure, but you could do either. Some factors I’d consider as you design your org chart:</p><p><strong>A lateral VCPD will work like a Project Manager. </strong>If you’ve hired a GOTV Director before, think of their relationship to other department directors.</p><figure><img alt="this is an org chart detailing where a Lateral VCPD would fit on a chart and what keys to their success would be." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/479/1*TIp-5fI2E1XxkqrF_-xmzA.png" /><figcaption>Org chart for a Lateral VCPD</figcaption></figure><p><strong>A managerial VCPD should manage your Data, Organizing, and Digital/Mobilization Directors.</strong> They’ll report to campaign leadership and could be treated like a deputy.</p><figure><img alt="this is an org chart detailing where a Managerial VCPD would fit on a chart and what keys to their success would be." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/473/1*U8eesmRvjTPko-GHDEq3UQ.png" /><figcaption>Org chart for a Managerial VCPD</figcaption></figure><p>Many of you may be reading this and thinking, “my campaign or organization is just not big enough to support adding another senior-level position.” <strong>We think it’s possible to capture the goals of the VCPD without a full-time role by ensuring the following three functions are listed as part of someone’s job description:</strong></p><ul><li>Phase planning</li><li>Voter contact analysis</li><li>Cross department project management</li></ul><p>We found these were the most critical functions of a VCPD and the three most likely to be neglected without that one. If you can’t hire a VCPD, make sure someone else on the senior leadership team has these functions at the center of their job.</p><h3><strong>The Case for a VCPD: Five Compelling Reasons for Hiring Your Own</strong></h3><blockquote>If you’ve run a program before, you can probably name a dozen projects like scripts — things you know are important, but end up bumping to the next day’s list for weeks. <strong>A VCPD owns, prioritizes, and improves those projects.</strong></blockquote><ol><li><strong>Hiring a VCPD will improve your Organizing, Data, and Digital shops’ ability to be creative and innovative. </strong>A VCPD takes something off of everyone’s plate, and leaves them with more time and energy to focus on proactive projects. For an Organizing Director, maybe it’s less time spent writing scripts and more time 1:1 with their Regionals. For a Data Director, it’s less time tracking universes and more investigating a trend they’ve noticed. For a Digital Director, it’s less time negotiating with an OD about organizers’ tools and more time exploring an online community where volunteers can congregate. We ask our leadership to do so much, and bringing on a VCPD allows them a little more breathing room to thrive.</li><li><strong>The VCPD can give attention to decisions that are important and not urgent.</strong> These are the types of decisions that are routinely neglected — the example I’ll use is writing scripts for voter contact. In years past, a field director would write the script, get a few folks on the team to review it, maybe get it approved by leadership — then print it. But what if you had a VCPD? They have time to look into the most up-to-date research for effective messaging, talk to the Comms team, ask about polling, make sure scripts for different types of voter contact match, and even design an A/B test to see what works best. And after they’re done, they could make sure the next order of literature is redesigned to work well with the new script. They could even ensure that that same script, messaging and strategy is shared with campaign leadership and stakeholders. If you’ve run a program before, you can probably name a dozen projects like scripts — things you know are important, but end up bumping to the next day’s list for weeks. A VCPD owns, prioritizes, and improves those projects.</li><li><strong>Online and virtual voter contact is a large part of today’s campaigns — and it needs to be wholly unified with offline voter contact. </strong>Mobilization or Digital Organizing teams are managing increasingly large P2P/SMS, relational, and email operations and innovating onto new platforms quickly. Organizers need to be equipped with Digital capabilities, and Digital teams need to be fully ingrained within Organizing priorities. To truly integrate these online and offline organizing requires treating them as one holistic Voter Contact Program, with a VCPD quarterbacking that collaboration. Functionally a lot of this will come down to ensuring that data is moving correctly to and from the right sources and that program heads understand what is <em>both </em>needed <em>and </em>possible. Whether it’s figuring out what the definition of a “supporter” is when a campaign is ingesting both online and offline data, or balancing priorities to ensure that reports serve the right stakeholders, a VCPD can be an extremely helpful translator and traffic cop for integrating online and offline programming.</li><li><strong>A VCPD allows your campaign to meaningfully sequence individual contacts into what will feel like an authentic, ongoing conversation with a voter. </strong>We have more ability than ever to precisely determine what and when a voter will hear from us. Widespread API integrations in the political tech space started to expand in 2016, and only recently did the VAN API call cap get lifted, meaning that the past 4 years in campaign innovation have seen a <em>dramatic </em>shift in the speed at which we can access data and how much data we can get our hands on. Prior to those innovations, things were just slower and information about voters was spread all over the place. There’s a trove of voter-level data that is continuously better informing us and allowing us to do smarter work. Your VCPD can and should make sure your campaign has the best plan to reach the voters you need to talk to to win.</li><li><strong>Having one person in all types of voter contact meetings will make your program more consistent and effective. </strong>Every campaign wants to maximize efficiency and ensure everyone’s work fits together — but too often, there’s no one in the room to spot inconsistencies or keep everyone on the same page. A VCPD is tasked with just that, eliminating cross-incentives, making sure everyone’s outputs help each other, and getting the most out of every member of the team. And a bonus: if you’re part of a national campaign or committee, the VCPD can make sure your in-state or -district voter contact syncs up with what National HQ is planning.</li></ol><h3><strong>What happened when we tried it, by the role’s originator, Dan Bram:</strong></h3><figure><img alt="this is a picture of Dan Bram, the first VCPD, dressed in a cardboard calculator costume." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KSRAz5je83UPa7Qche3J0g.jpeg" /><figcaption>Meet Dan Bram! When not dressed like a human calculator, he actually did a lot of calculations.</figcaption></figure><p>I had a really fun opportunity to work as a VCPD on the 2020 Iowa Caucus. In my past lives before 2019 I had (in no particular order): been an organizer, worked in political tech, managed organizing staff and programs, nerded out on campaign &amp; related private sector outreach research, spent some time on the IE side, ran a Packetland, and dabbled in different definitions of digital. I didn’t really know what I wanted to do in 2020, but I did know that I genuinely loved trying new things and seeing how solving a problem in one department could translate over to solving a completely unrelated problem in another department. While a lot of my time was, much to the enjoyment of my high school math teachers, spent getting uncomfortably familiar with the joys of caucus math (including the creation of an unofficial mascot for the satellite caucuses — a zombified squirrel acquired from a Michael’s during a Halloween sale), I got to put a lot of these ideas that Janice talked about above into practice. We didn’t always get it right, but I learned a <em>ton </em>and our program benefited from the role.</p><p><strong>I spent a lot of time working on tasks that were vitally important to the outcome of our work, but aren’t traditionally prioritized as urgent in the hectic day to day of campaigning.</strong> Here’s what that entailed:</p><ol><li><strong>Phase planning: </strong>During the summer we mapped out everything that needed to happen through the end of the election, so that as we were planning each phase of the campaign, we could make smart decisions on which program pieces should be in each phase. This included how the universe parameters for each channel (i.e. phones, doors) would change during each phase. This long term planning meant we had ample<em> </em>lead time to train volunteers in a way that we knew would translate well to GOTV, develop universe parameters that would give us information on voters that we knew we would need later on, and set benchmark check ins that allowed us to be responsive to how the program was going and make changes as needed, instead of making knee jerk reactions to weekly goals. Having this process live with me as the VCPD helped completely align digital, data, and organizing goals into one cohesive plan.</li><li><strong>Getting very, very in the weeds on universe parameters: </strong>While every campaign spends time on universe parameters, this role gave us added capacity to look at how universes needed to adapt over time, based on geography, channel, and person level criteria. For example, this led us to look at which voters responded best to which channels (doors, text, in state calls, distributed calls, mail, etc)in which areas of the state, and create universe parameters that were specific to each county. For door universes specifically, we built the universe sizes from the precinct level up to match projected turnout and support needed, and were able to get so granular as to incorporate projected county level delegates needed per precinct. Functionally, this meant that the universe size and makeup matched the local organizing capacity and necessary support, so we were giving volunteers the most efficient voters possible. This kind of deep level data and organizing strategy is often out of reach for campaigns that are stretched for time and staff attention. The VCPD role made nimble and data driven decisions, on a truly minute scale, possible.</li><li><strong>Running in-cycle experiments: </strong>While caucuses are unique campaign environments for… a lot of reasons, we had the time and capacity to be thoughtful about 1) what voter contact experiments we wanted to run, and 2) how to incorporate those experiments into our existing program, so that the results could still benefit us down the road if successful. The VCPD structure allowed for us to test mail/door chase programs, pre-canvass text outreach, and how quickly we could feasibly follow up with online leads. As VCPD, I was the natural project manager, and each department pitched in. We could test out different messaging on calls and texts for different universes before making the jump to add that new messaging into door scripts, which allowed us to use already tested messaging on the doors. Some things worked, some didn’t, but we struck a good balance between trying new things and executing on the basics. Our data and digital teams collaborated on several experiments to increase P2P SMS reply rates, including one that we now lovingly refer to as a “U Up?” script — essentially asking the voter, “hey, is this [name]?” to confirm with whom we were talking, before continuing the conversation. We tested this language out across varying use cases and universes, and saw overwhelmingly positive results across the board — not only in reply rates, but in ensuring that the IDs we collected through P2P SMS were actually matched to the voters we thought they belonged to. These scripts and strategy eventually made its way to widespread use in general election battleground programs across the country, which is pretty neat!</li></ol><h3><em>What Worked Well</em></h3><p>Having a VCPD on our team offered three key advantages — outlined below.</p><p><strong>Aligned in-person and online voter contact goals, metrics, and incentives: </strong>We set up an incentive structure between the organizing and digital voter contact programs that allowed both teams to aim towards the same goals, while figuring out what their respective lanes were. The VCPD structure gave us the ability to communicate between teams and figure out, for example, what organizing challenges could be solved with additional capacity, or how the digital program could be bolstered by changes in the organizing program. One of the key goals of our in-state digital program was generating as many quality leads as possible for the local organizers to follow up with. We were able to look at where more paid digital acquisition would be more effective, where additional distributed texts into the depths of the voter file might yield more leads, or where recruiting more volunteers in our relational program could better help us reach those goals. Come GOTV, we were able to make honest assessments of when additional door capacity would help and where, and instead of expending resources where we didn’t need them, we could push distributed call and text capacity to hit our goals because of the program we had built throughout the year.</p><p><strong>Integrated data across programs and teams: </strong>There have been huge leaps in campaign tech in the couple of years in the realm of connecting tools and the underlying data behind them. Together, we built a helpful notification system originally designed to tell organizers (every 6 hours) when they had new online sign ups, and what action person had signed up.This notification system eventually evolved to include any trigger we wanted, including new supporters from the distributed program, new relational contacts from outside their turf, people who had looked up their caucus location, inactive email subscribers, offline &amp; online donors, people who signed a digital “commit to caucus card” and more. Typically these kinds of flows can take hours to days before they’re put in front of an organizer — going from a BSD form to a data warehouse to VAN to a VAN target is a Tolkienian journey — but by guaranteeing that a sign up gets put in front of an organizer within 6 hours of actually signing up <em>drastically </em>increased conversion rates, bought organizers into the process, and increased overall lead penetration. We could also make smarter decisions about channel-level resource allocation, where some voters were prioritized for texting if they had a cell phone, email if they had an email address, or mail if they had no phone number or email at all — ensuring we were making the most out of every possible contact available.</p><p><strong>Freed up time for the experts to be the experts: </strong>One of the key benefits of taking the responsibilities and tasks of a robust Voter Contact Program and putting it all into a specific job is that it frees up a <em>ton </em>of time for other voter contact department directors (in our case the Organizing, Digital, and Data Directors) to dig in deeper with their own teams. Our Organizing Director had more time for staff development and coaching conversations; our data team could spend more time actually executing on reports or tools instead of going back and forth on program requirements; and our Digital team had more access to data &amp; reporting and could spend more internal time planning innovative ways to reach out to voters. And it’s part of the job of a good VCPD to keep the current state of play of other departments in their head at all times, so that, especially in the hectic campaign environment, even if one department was putting out a fire, we had enough information to move forward as a team. Large campaigns tend to have issues where everyone who is tangentially related to a topic is invited to a meeting, and it’s sometimes difficult to get everyone in the same room at the same time. This role can be a huge help in convening those who can meet, getting the easy decisions out of the way, and following up with other stakeholders for input afterwards to keep things moving.</p><h3>What Didn’t Work Well</h3><p>Incorporating a VCPD into the mix isn’t some sort of silver bullet for campaign organizational ills. Not all the parts of how we set this role up, or how I did it, worked. <strong>We learned two main lessons from our mistakes:</strong></p><p><strong>We separated the program from people too much: </strong>One of the things that attracted me to this role was the freedom to focus a lot of my time on program development and analysis. While this theoretically allows an organization to efficiently spend their time, it also made it too easy to detach myself from how humans operate. Having a VCPD to be thoughtful and proactive about voter contact is a huge asset, but you also need to realize that no matter what race or campaign you’re on, some percentage of the staff are doing this work for the first time. I sometimes had to be reminded that it was not a good idea to roll out a new program piece because we were still focusing on getting new staff up to speed on the fundamentals of organizing. A specific tactic or strategy is only as effective as what you can pull off and manage towards, and there were more times than I’d like to admit where my lack of day to day interaction with staff led to sub-optimal planning.</p><p><strong>Campaigns are getting increasingly complex and it’s easy to over-engineer a program. </strong>My day to day involved a lot of writing plans, diving into reports, running meetings, and managing workflows. When you actually do have the time to look at everything that is happening on a campaign when you want to (truly not a common occurrence, despite how much we want to) it’s too easy to fall into the trap of “being too cute by half” — or overly engineering a plan and missing the bigger picture, especially in a caucus environment where everything was at the precinct level (should this type of data to indicate support be weighted at a .7 or .8? A .75?). In retrospect I wish I had been better at taking a step back and thinking about not just what was the “right” answer to a problem, but more importantly what was the answer that would get us most of the way there as simply as possible.</p><h3><strong>In Conclusion: Hiring a VCPD Made Us Better, and We Think It Will Make You Better, Too</strong></h3><p>Campaigns are built on a pile of institutional knowledge, and so little of that knowledge gets written down. We wrote this post in the hope that our experiences might help you — the campaign leadership of tomorrow — build the best possible organization.</p><p>We’re convinced that the structure of campaigns needs to change to keep up with the changes in voter contact methods, and that hiring a Voter Contact Program Director made us better at talking to voters. Coordinated Directors are reaching their max-out point, and <strong>if we want to continue to run winning programs, we need to invest in staff who will coordinate the big arcs and little details of those programs.</strong></p><p>Every campaign is different, and <strong>we hope you’ll design exactly the structure that works for you and your electorate — whether that’s with a VCPD or some totally new role you dream up.</strong></p><p>And if we can ever be of service, don’t hesitate to reach out! We’re at janice [dot] rottenberg [at] gmail [dot] com and dbram10 [at] gmail [dot] com.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iJH511dCqiCqWQHuPJtu0Q.jpeg" /><figcaption>remember the zombiefied squirrel we mentioned? meet Satan!</figcaption></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5a744b3bb187" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>