<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jasmine Wu on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jasmine Wu on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jasminethedreamcatcher?source=rss-5562c17352e3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sun, 22 Nov 2026 00:09:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jasminethedreamcatcher/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why the Extreme Rain will Soften Us Collectively]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jasminethedreamcatcher/why-the-extreme-rain-will-soften-us-collectively-14f9ab317bfd?source=rss-5562c17352e3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/14f9ab317bfd</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[water]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[entanglement]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[extreme-weather]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jasmine Wu]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Jun 2026 07:44:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-06-26T07:44:24.256Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HZAn41IzhLGrx4wtgK34LQ.png" /></figure><p>Big rain always brings me vivid dreams.</p><p>I was in my vivid dreams this morning, seamlessly awaken to the pouring sound of the rain.</p><p>That’s why the water is such a mystical source to me.</p><p>Perhaps it is the making of the “stream” of collective consciousness circulating around us, for our ancestors’ and more-than-human kins that have passed, ascended and descended continuously in cycles of water. Returning again and again in different forms.</p><p>And now, as climate heats, they seem to descend to us in a more violent way.</p><p>People who know water understands that water is source, not resource.</p><p>It is the source of all life,</p><p>and maybe the source of our relief and anxiety becoming more and more extreme.</p><p>Relief from yesterday’s extreme heat .</p><p>But anxiety to what’s coming next after this extreme relief.</p><p>I wonder when in the future, will the sound of rain become less like a lullaby for me to continue sleeping in the dawn of day with my half-opened eye.</p><p>Because this year, it has really begun to bring me more nightmares with that violent sound, like bodies slamming themselves to the ground.</p><p>It’s a warning.</p><p>Tension &amp; Release, release and tension. My jazz teacher once told me that this is what makes music music so rich, colorful and alive. Especially jazz. The blue notes and dissonance chords create tension, and then the music opens into release.</p><p>And we are living through a more prominent melody nowadays.</p><p>When we live in these extreme tensions and releases of drought, heat, flood, and storms more and more, it’s giving birth to us the practicing of facing uncertainty, ambiguity. <strong>Into the realization that the world we assumed was stable and “normal” was always being held together by a tight grip of control</strong> (and never normal behind the veil, in somewhere you can’t see or easily turn a blind eye to). <strong>The extremes interrupt routines. They expose the fragility beneath what we called normality.</strong></p><p>And what I know is that, through this disruption, collectively, we will be <em>forced</em> to soften.</p><p>The grip we hold on one another loosens. With a softened smile &amp; care.</p><p>The grip we hold over nature loosens. With more sense of sacredness and reverence.</p><p>The grip we hold over our own animal bodies loosens into honoring the miracle of communities working within us, and the cycles of it.</p><p>The loosening of the grip isn’t by our own will alone, but by something ancestral moving through us. The same current that moves rainclouds and rivers, roots and mycelium, oceans and bloodstreams. A wisdom carried in our bodies of water, in our ancestors, and in the living world itself. by the entangled web of life moving through us that naturally leans back toward ways of being that allow life to thrive. that life is not controlled but to dance with. not possessed but to belong to and participate in. Our loosening grip of hand, our bodies eventually will remember what our minds forgot.</p><p>And it is that process of letting go that we begin to see control was just only a story. A story forced upon by colonialism or inherited by some ancestors’ way of survival , stacking into the building blocks of modernity.</p><p>The story that says “life can be controlled.” the story that says “mastery and dominion over life could save us” as if it is the only story that could get us through these intense period of time. It’s not working anymore.</p><p><strong>We are letting go of that. Because by experiencing the intense consequences of control, the more we realize that life has never been controllable.</strong></p><p>It is inherently uncertain, inherently non-linear, inherently dynamic, complicated and entangled. Just too alive to be reduced to numbers, formulas, or rigid frameworks of management.</p><p>Loosening the grip is always hard and uncomfortable and insecure, like an itchy feeling, but we might find a strange sense of liberation. Not liberation from uncertainty, but liberation into it. Liberation from an outdated story that doesn’t serve us all &amp; more-than-human-world anymore.</p><p>As uncertain as times are, a collective maturity may be emerging through these descending waters.</p><p>Perhaps this is what our ancestors, moving through the bodies of water, are resonating with in our own bodies of water. The source of life reminding us of what life is.</p><p>Inviting us to remember that we are not separate from its cycles.</p><p>And asking us to <strong><em>observe the dreams more to bring our awareness to what’s really aligning and not aligning.</em></strong></p><p>They’re dropping new possibilities upon us, and new &amp; ancestral stories of how to re-member in an entangled world and the cycles of life in ways that bring us back into alignment to our own nature.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=14f9ab317bfd" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rethinking Climate Advocacy: From Carbon-Centric Solutions to Relational & Collective Healing]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jasminethedreamcatcher/rethinking-climate-advocacy-from-carbon-centric-solutions-to-relational-collective-healing-90caaa5fbd89?source=rss-5562c17352e3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/90caaa5fbd89</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[healing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-action]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[collective-healing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitalism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[climate-change]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jasmine Wu]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Aug 2025 08:10:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-09-04T08:54:21.630Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This paper was adapted from my last and final essay before graduating from bachelor degree. I feel that this is my most important university essay that sums up my accumulated activism experience in my 4 years of uni. Deep gratitude to Green Dreamer Podcast by Kamea Chayne which is podcast that inspires me a lot on my essay.</em></p><p><em>Here, I aim to explore “the intangible revolution” that is often neglected in the current mainstream environmental / climate activism.</em></p><h3><strong>Chapter 1: Introduction and Research Question</strong></h3><p>Current global climate frameworks and the actions mostly reflect what Charles Eisenstein critiques as “Climate Fundamentalism” , which is hyper fixated on carbon emissions reductions, techno solutions, urgency and control, that oftentimes marginalized the importance of the intangible work — relational, embodied, and place-based ways of collective healing and transformation, aka “the slow work”.</p><p>Underlying climate fundamentalism is the same framework that created the crisis, which stems from disconnection and separation of ourselves, the land and each other by turning the functions of forests and oceans into numbers and metrics as if it could be quantified and the notion that climate change is often looked separately from biodiversity in activism. However, the ecological crisis and climate change has many folds of factors that influence each other.</p><p>The consequences of overly focused on carbon and urgency not only doesn’t address the other interconnected ecological crisis, but also as activists and communities alike experience rising burnout, alienation, and disempowerment. In contrast, fields like collective healing, embodiment, post-activism offer important ways of seeing the world to reweave human and more-than-human relations in the face of ecological collapse.</p><p>By reframing ecological crisis as a relational crisis.</p><p>What are some frameworks and practices that could enrich place-based relationships and restore biocultural diversity as a foundation for planetary healing in Taiwan? How might collective healing, embodied knowledge, and place-based relationships offer root-level solutions to ecological and cultural disconnection?</p><p>Through this lens, climate change is no longer just a problem to solve but a symptom of a deeper call to transform how we relate to ourselves, each other and the land.</p><h3>Literature Review</h3><p><strong><em>Limits of Carbon-Centric Climate Governance</em></strong></p><p>At the heart of current mainstream global climate conversations lies a fixation in cutting carbon. For decades, with the support of policy institutions, climate scientists have gained legitimacy in emphasizing that greenhouse gases, particularly CO₂ and methane, as key drivers of anthropogenic climate change. This has led to urgent calls for transitioning from “gray economies” reliant on fossil fuels toward lower emissions. Due to this, mainstream responses from policymakers to corporate pledges, which overwhelmingly focused its climate action largely in terms of carbon reduction, advancing technocratic, market-driven solutions, making us speak of climate change in “carbonese.” This is a term that a Brazilian researcher and activist Dr. Camila Moreno uses to describe the carbon-focused, reductive, technical language that dominates global climate discourse.</p><p>Author and activist Charles Eisenstein calls this “Climate Fundamentalism”: a belief that climate change can be solved simply by treating the complex causes into a single-variable quantifiable equation, and legitimizing mitigating it through any means necessary. Eisenstein warns that this fundamentalism mindset mirrors the very forces that caused the ecological crisis in the first place, which is extracting value, pursuing efficiency, and ignoring the local context.</p><p><strong><em>Quantification and Commodification: Reducing Life to Numbers</em></strong></p><p>The obsession with emission metrics reflects an<strong> ingrained worldview that objectifies the living world.</strong> The moment we begin to assign monetary value to carbon and nature, turning forests into carbon offsets, we reveal <strong>how narrowly we’ve framed the crisis</strong>. We’ve reduced carbon to the culprit and treated it as something that must be measured, priced, and controlled. In doing so, we fragment the living world into isolated “things” that can be quantified, rather than honoring them as part of a sacred, interconnected whole. Eisenstein writes,</p><blockquote>“By focusing on a measurable quantity, we devalue that which we cannot measure… sacredness of land, water, and relationships.” This quantification bias not only oversimplifies ecological relationships, but also sidelines critical but intangible values like reciprocity, kinship, and place-based knowledge.</blockquote><p>What doesn’t get measured or monetized simply gets ignored or underfunded. By making carbon reduction as main priority, it might leave us pushing aside seemingly separate but actually interwoven issues such as water cycle, biodiversity collapse, toxic pollution, land grabbing, cultural erasure, social injustice, and “biocultural diversity.” These cannot be fully captured in numeric models or profit metrics.</p><p>Biocultural diversity, a concept developed by anthropologist Luisa Maffi describing the inextricable links between biodiversity, cultural diversity, and linguistic heritage. When climate governance focuses solely on emissions, it ignores the relational worldviews of Indigenous and local communities, whose knowledge systems arise from deep cultural ecological intimacy. Luisa Maffi further explains the inherent interconnectedness of nature and culture,</p><blockquote>“it is no coincidence that language loss, cultural loss, and biodiversity loss are happening together. They are symptoms of the same disconnection.”</blockquote><p>Meanwhile, Traditional Ecological Knowledge (TEK), rooted in centuries of land stewardship from indigenous communities, rarely fits into climate finance frameworks or large-scale techno-fixes. Yet these communities offer some of the most resilient, regenerative models for living in reciprocity with the Earth. When community-led movements or their worldview and knowledge are disregarded because their “impact” cannot be reduced to carbon metrics or monetized in offset markets, we risk the neglecting important solutions to the problem. Dr. Camila Moreno argues in her paper that being blindfolded by numbers and carbon units from other diversity, nature, culture and lifestyle as “epistemicide.”</p><p>Paul Hawken critiques this turn in climate strategy as a dangerous “monetization of life,” where nature is commodified to gain legitimacy in policy circles. Carbon dioxide markets, he argues, echo past exploitations, like the commodification of enslaved people and ivory tusks.</p><p>Nowadays, turning ecosystem services, biodiversity and elements of nature into credits in marketplaces are emerging rapidly. Environmental activists are often forced to speak the language of markets: how much carbon a tree stores, how much a whale is “worth,” how much “natural capital” a mangrove generates.</p><p>But at what cost?</p><p>Take for example a team of economists at the International Monetary Fund (IMF) estimated that a single blue whale is worth $2 million over its lifetime.5 This figure attempts to translate the whale’s ecosystem services, which includes carbon capture and ecotourism, into a total monetary value, so that policymakers who prioritize economic metrics might finally recognize the “worth” of these beings.</p><p>This logic extends into the rise of nature-based solutions, which often centers on calculating how much carbon can an ecosystem service absorb, like forests, mangroves, or wetlands. These carbon sinks are then assigned a price tag, turned into carbon credits, and sold to corporations, allowing them to continue polluting while claiming to reach “net zero.”</p><p>This strategy of financialization is understandable: it’s a way to have a seat at the table, to speak in the only language power seems to understand. As important as it is to navigate the power games to be heard in majoritarian politics, there ought to have a deeper reflection: <strong>what does it say about our systems when we must translate what is fundamentally important to life into financial language just to justify protecting it?</strong></p><p><em>Some strategies might be more effective, but how might it influence our worldview and how we view in relation to other beings?</em></p><p><em>What do we lose when we link whales, forests, rivers, and entire ways of life to carbon metrics, just to make them legible to the system?</em></p><p>We can keep on attempting to link all these issues, the value of these important living beings with climate change or carbon mitigation, but it set us up for a dangerous zone where we risk disregarding or suppressing other intangible, hard-to-measure reasons to protect what’s important to the local people or the ecosystem as a whole. This carbon-centric policies reflected that the mainstream climate discourse prioritizes the global over local, measurable over qualitative. Eisenstein critiques in his book “Climate: A New Story” that it reflects a mentality which sacrifices what is sacred and precious for a distant goal, and that we can identify a cause by dissecting reality into isolating variables. Referring again to Paul Hawken, he warns that we’re using the mindset that causes the problem, which is objectifying the living world including the people in it.</p><p>In order to break free from this way of thinking, it requires a fundamental, body to mind shift that is beyond mitigation towards reimagining our relationship with the world. Next, we’ll dive into the literature reviews of the concepts and emergence of prefigurative ontologies that challenge this dominant paradigm.</p><h3><strong>Introducing Alternative Frameworks of Healing</strong></h3><p><strong><em>Ecopsychology and Embodiment</em></strong></p><p>Why do we need to tune into our bodies to change the world fundamentally?</p><p>Our industrial, capitalist society has long favored numbers, metrics, and rationality over emotion, intuition, and relationality. Rene Descartes wrote “Cogito, ergo sum (I think therefore I am)”, placing the bodies below the mind, influencing the development of separation between mind and body, setting foot for later philosophers to viewing human as part from the nature world.</p><p>The carbon-focused, market-driven, capitalist, science approach to climate governance is a symptom of a deeper disconnection that made us define human worth by productivity. In this worldview, we are conditioned to treat ourselves like machines to do more, work faster, and maximize efficiency. Slowing down, resting, feeling, or simply being is often seen as laziness or inadequacy. We become anxious when we are not “doing,” as if our value disappears when we do less. This phenomenon, known as “internalized capitalism,” describes the ingrained belief that our self-worth is dependent on our output, even without the actual work to be done, and rises the guilt of not doing. It reflects a socio-technical world built upon capitalism that prioritizes extractive doing over regenerative being, shaping not only our economies, but our nervous systems.</p><p>Ecopsychology and embodiment offer alternative approaches to relate and respond to the ecological crisis of return. These fields invites us to tune into our ancestral bodily wisdom and relational way of viewing planetary healing.</p><ol><li><strong>Ecopsychology: Bridging relation between Nature, Psyche and Society</strong></li></ol><p>In the field of ecopsychology, the connection between the inner and outer landscape is bridged. Psychology focus on the logos, studying the meaning, order or speech of the psyche or soul. While “eco” came from the Greek “oikos”, meaning home.</p><p>Elan Shapiro puts it beautifully of how ecopsychology is in relation to life:</p><blockquote>“Ecopsychology approach the psyche in relation to its earthly, natural home and explore the shift in our patterns of identity and relationship that occur when we include our connection to the web of life around us as essential to human well-being.”</blockquote><p>Ecopsychologist Andy Fisher defines ecopsychology as “a project to overcome the fracturing of reality into the separate regions of Psyche, Nature, and Society.” He further argues that the divisions is inherent part of the “modern capitalist civilization” which maintains its continuation through processes of colonization and disconnection. And here decolonization refers both lifeworld decolonization. He organized 4 general tasks that Ecopsychology is engaged in resolving to the corresponding historical need. One of the tasks is the practical task to develop therapeutic and recollective practices towards an ecological society.</p><p>However, Ecopsychologists like Fisher asked us to keep in mind of this field as the product of Western / modern mind because those indigenous peoples way of living is inherently dedicated to the reciprocal relations of nature and culture that has no need for ecopsychology.</p><p>In the practical task of Ecopsychology, therapeutic practices emerged to provide to support people in finding their footings in life in the face of changing environment and create a life-centered society, such as like ecotherapy, inner work for social change, somatics / embodiment practices.</p><p><strong>2. Somatic Embodiment: Bodily Awareness in Times of Crisis</strong></p><p>In the 70s, Thomas Hanna used the Greek word soma into the growing field related to consciously embodying the movement. He used soma as “the body experienced from within “. Somatics, originates from the Greek word “soma” meaning body or “of the whole body”, compared to anatomy which comes from Latin meaning of “cut into pieces”, somatics is a field that focuses on the whole and internal perception. Both embodiment and somatic works focuses on centering body, values sensation and drawing up polyvagal theory. The practices of somatic embodiment are used in of psychotherapy, body training, movement or spiritual practices. This discipline that we call embodiment or somatic movement can be rooted back to philosophers like Aristotle and eastern Yoga, Martial Arts practices.</p><p>Embodiment is the mind becoming aware of bodily “sensations, feelings and gestures it holds”. While consciousness is the embodied basis of mind.</p><p>The founder of Body-Mind Centering, Bonnie Bainbridge Cohen, described a 3 stages of path towards full embodiment. The first step is “Visualization”. It’s the initial step to anchor the mind and create mental imagery to hold the presence of body’s physical structure, “search to become aware of that part of the body.” Second step is “Somaticisation”, which is to witness the inner sensations through visualization process. Last is the “Embodiment” which is sourced in the presence of “cellular awareness and leads to complete knowing”, a unity of body and thought, dropping the sensory information into the subconscious that is fully integrated into our way of being and moving.</p><p>Somatic educator and author of “Returning Home to Our Bodies” Abigail Rose Clarke states “it is a practice of being fully present in the whole body, which means we must also be present in our place in the whole world. It’s a practice of wholeness.” (p.24)</p><p>In her book “Embodied Spirit, Conscious Earth“, Linda Hartley wonderfully puts it “when we are deeply connected to our own embodied being, we naturally come into deepened re-connection with Earth-body out of which we have evolved and upon which we are totally dependent for life. Embodiment practitioners like her view the awareness that returns into our inner landscape which invokes reflection of relationships with the parts that composed of us brings forth a wider lens of seeing how our cells are sacredly important to the flesh and bones as our own role and behavior to the Earth. Through practicing the awareness and tuning into the sensations of what composed of the human body, it shifts the way we are present in our body and the way we move. This conscious awareness inspires to see the relationship within us and around us, as interconnected in a world of reciprocal relationship.</p><p>The reflection of witnessing our bodily sensations and responses to social change is crucial.</p><p>As multisensory beings, humans are biologically and psychologically wired to adapt to change. However, the scale and complexity of current planetary crises often trigger nervous system, making individuals into fight-or-flight survival responses.</p><p>The “flight” response may manifest as apathy, numbness, or a refusal to engage with collective pain, which is a psychological mechanisms that shield individuals from overwhelming emotional stimuli. (Joanna Macy “Coming Back to Life) On the other hand, the “fight” response often fuels activism, generating a sense of urgency to act now. Philosopher and post-activist thinker Bayo Akomolafe critiques this orientation toward urgency. As he explains, “slowing down is not a function of speed, it is a function of deepening awareness, noticing the others in the room.” For him, urgency can hinder alternative pathways and perpetuate dominant patterns of control, productivity, and extraction even within activist spaces. “We rush through into the same patterns we are used to,” he reminded, which reproducing the very conditions we seek to transform.</p><p>Echoing this idea, Abbey Reyes, a leader in driving community climate solutions , describes how her community incorporates embodied practices to resist the “allure of urgency.” She emphasizes the importance of cultivating a “deeper sourced, a deeper current” of resilience, one that is not reactive, but regenerative. This approach suggests that systemic change is not only about what we do, but how we do it. If the reactivity is unexamined, it can lead to burnout and division, hindering long-term movement’s sustainability.</p><p>Both Akomolafe and Reyes highlights a critical dimension of transformative work: the interdependence of inner and outer systems. As Akomolafe puts it, “the inner work and the outer work, the inner structures and the outer structures, are fractals of each other.” Activists cannot manifest a world rooted in justice, relationality, and care if their daily practices are embedded in hierarchies, separations, or cycles of exhaustion. The transformation we want to see in the world must be mirrored in our ways of being, sensing, and relating.</p><p><strong><em>Relational Ontology &amp; Collective Care</em></strong></p><p>Turning to communities and seeing its significance in shifting towards a new narrative from the old paradigms of business-as-usual is gaining more discourse. Scholars argue that climate change is not only an environmental crisis but also a crisis of relationship, between humans and nature, and among ourselves.</p><p>As Culture Hacks Lab explains in their report, “narrative communities” are groups of actors engaged in ongoing, shared conversations, using similar narratives over time. These communities experiment with new ways of understanding and knowing, new ontologies and epistemologies, to create alternatives that embody new ways of thinking, being, acting and relating to the world. In doing so, they fundamentally challenge the assumptions and logic that drives the current system.</p><p>Approaches like cooperatives, mutual aid networks, and asset-based community development (ABCD) are increasingly seen as forms of decentralized, relational governance. The active choice of organizing ways to turn towards one another embody a bottom-up form of climate governance centers in care for one another and interdependence.</p><p><strong><em>Indigenous Epistemologies &amp; Place-Based Knowledge</em></strong></p><p>While community-based approaches offer ways to empower local agency and local governance, indigenous knowledge systems, or indigenous way of knowing is a crucial mirror that contrasts the linearity and fragmentation of dominant climate governance driven in Western empirical science knowledge system. In order to set the difference of being a set of coherent, dynamic practices, values and worldview over list of doctrine knowledge, indigenous scholars prefer the term “the way of knowing” over “knowledge system” to describe how their knowing is rooted in culturally specific ethical principles that respect the reciprocal relations to more-than-human-life.</p><p>“Kincentric ecology”, a term developed by ethnobotanist Enrique Salmón, wonderfully describe how indigenous cultural mode, drawing examples of Rarámuri example of iwígara understand the natural environment through relationships and stewardship, seeing themselves and nature as part of “an extended ecological family that shares ancestry and origins”, which is why it’s kin or relative. Their collective identity to be responsible for the wellbeing of whole, which includes the natural world that they inhabit in, precedented over the individual’s desire, because they understand that individual couldn’t flourish from an unhealthy community or environment. This sense of interbeingness is foundation to humans, though many of us have lost touch with it in the quest to individualism. Their variety way of knowing embedded in local ecosystems are encoded into not only their identity but also language8, which I will further show in my case studies.</p><p>Indigenous ways of knowing are inherently place-based, experiential, and reciprocal, emphasizing that land is not a resource to be managed but a relative to be in the right relationship with.</p><p>Rather than viewing the environment as external and passive, Indigenous frameworks position humans as part of a web of responsibilities within a living system which not only is an inherent cultural way of building climate resilience because it is a dynamic, intergenerational way of knowing passing down from ancestors that’s changing and adapting to the surroundings.</p><h3>My Personal Experience</h3><p><strong>Case Study 1: Healing Relationship with Ourselves — Re-membering Our Bodies</strong></p><p>Over the past five years, I have been involved in environmental and animal rights activism, beginning with high school campaigns for plant-based diets and molding into broader climate and sustainability work during university. Like many young activists driven by a sense of urgency, I felt that every moment not spent organizing was a moment lost in the face of ecological collapse. Effectiveness was equated with constant movement like planning, managing team communication, or staying up late to make sure everything is perfect. Within the sustainability club and broader youth climate networks, we celebrated efficiency, normalize extended late night meetings, and feeling incomplete if we don’t tracking our progress with KPIs and impact reports.</p><p>This culture of constant action eventually led me into a cycle of burnout. In the days leading up to a vegan and plastic-free fair I organized with a team, I was overwhelmed by logistical stress and emotional disconnection. When the event concluded, I had no space to reflect, only pressure to show up for the next advocacy event. Even though moments of exhaustion, I brushed off the fatigue, internalizing the expectation that activism required personal sacrifice. This phenomenon, besides from individual aspect of lack of self-knowledge or time management, it reflects a deeper societal influence as previously discussed that mirrored dominant social values that prioritize output over wellbeing.</p><p>A turning point came during the participation in 28th Conference of the Parties (COP) under United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) , where I attended as a delegate with the Taiwan Youth Climate Coalition. The conference was intense with hours-long negotiations, daily strategic meetings, and side events happening one after another. A fellow climate youth activist from Spain told us, half-jokingly, “It’s normal not to sleep during COP,” as he and another activist from Poland stayed up late for many nights to strategize for a youth intervention in the negotiation rooms in order to voice our demands from governments. I wasn’t surprised by the workload, and I understand this is the once / twice in a year chance to put all yourself in, but by how normalized this self-sacrifice had become. Youth delegates, despite advocating for a livable and just future, were themselves operating under extractive patterns of labor, burning themselves for a burning world.</p><p>It was here that I began to feel a deep discomfort. The very movements trying to resist burnout at the planetary level were replicating burnout within the people driving them. Like we’ve crossed the Earth’s planetary boundaries in pursuit of more, we often cross our own emotional and physical limits. While we campaigned for systems that value life over profit, we accepted conditions that devalued our own lives and bodies in the name of progress. As explored earlier, this normalization of self-neglect resonates to broader patterns of internalized capitalism where our nervous systems are tuned to overperform in a culture that rewards a busy, restless life.</p><p>After cycles of burnout and shock experienced in COP28, I began to question the model of activism I had embraced. I slowly integrated new rhythms into my practice by allowing space for grief, setting boundaries around meeting times, rest without guilt, and engaging in somatic exercises like body scans and breathwork. These practices helped me reconnect with the simple, radical idea that the body is not a machine, and that slowing down can also be a form of resistance. By also recognizing myself as part of nature, and the flesh and bones that consists of me, which should be honored with care , I understand more deeply that like the Earth, we have limits. And like the Earth, when those limits are ignored, we begin to deplete.</p><p>Rather than retreating from activism, this shift has allowed me to show up with more presence, less burnout and resentment, and greater alignment with the future I’m hoping to create. And even though I’m still sometimes dropping back to the old mode of constant doing and sometimes having too much on the plate, I can now name what forces conditioned us in a systemic level and chose again and again to more embodied resistance.</p><p><strong>Case Study 2: Healing Relationship with Community — Re-membering with Each Other</strong></p><p>During the semester, I participated in a facilitator training hosted by the Post Growth Institute on the Offers and Needs Market (OANM). It is a community process designed to enhance the spirit of mutual aid and deepen human connection in the times of separation and disconnection by modernity. Developed by Donnie Maclurcan, OANM is described as “a facilitated process of mutual aid used to identify and exchange knowledge, skills, resources, opportunities, and needs.” 9Inspired by Asset-Based Community Development (ABCD) and the spirit of pre-industrial markets, this process reimagines economic and social life through turning to each other for cooperation rather than competition. What stood out to me most was how OANM invites participants to begin from abundance, which stems from asset-based approach. It is to first recognize what the members have to offer, rather than what they lack. By starting from each individual’s gifts, whether tangible resources, lived experiences, or time, the process gently retrains our modern, scarcity-oriented brains to notice capacity before deficiency. In a capitalist system that often convinces 3 things organized by Donnie: (1) we are not enough, (2) we don’t have enough, and (3) there isn’t enough, OANM becomes a softer act of resistance by remembering each other’s wholeness and gifts. OANM focuses on relationality instead of transactional, which often strips community’s spirit. The “market” becomes a place not only for exchange, but for vulnerability, reflection, and belonging. The process has two main parts, allowing space for people to name both their gifts and their needs, which might seem as a radical move in a culture that often views needing help as weakness. In this way, the practice challenges both capitalist and patriarchal values that reward self-sufficiency and isolate individuals from the collective. One participant shared, “In solidarity economies, relationships are our greatest currency.” The design of the process and facilitator is focused on weaving the slowness, inclusivity, and care into the exchange. For example, before any sharing begins, facilitators ask participants to pause, breathe, and check in with themselves, which connects with embodiment concepts of tuning into ourselves. During the process, the facilitators guide the participants with care in detailed difference of language like “would anyone like more time?” instead of “is everyone ready to move on?”. Care in process like these hold space for those with introverted tendencies, decolonizing the often rushed, extrovert-centric pace of mainstream group facilitation. Participants are encouraged to speak from personal experience, and to give feedback not by naming what went wrong, but by sharing what would help them feel more supported.</p><p>OANM might be seem as a form of exchange, but it’s inherently a community healing process that reminds us our value isn’t based on productivity or expertise, but in the small, meaningful ways we can support one another. Offerings from participants spans from language teaching, being an accountability buddy, giving away unused kitchen tools, or simply holding space. The needs named are just as important as the offers shared. Expressing the needs openly inspires a new kind of cultural permission for interdependence. Inherently, the OANM is an inspiring example of what relational healing might look like in practice within modern communities. It sees people not as economic actors, but as fractals in a web of reciprocity.10 It re-members community by inviting people to show up not just as consumers or labors which capitalistic society sees us, but as whole humans made up of flesh and bones with stories, needs, and gifts. Through this practice, we begin to heal the alienation entrenched in modern capitalist life, and move toward a culture where mutual care is a collective norm.</p><p><strong>Case Study 3: Healing Relationship with the Land — Re-membering Earth</strong></p><p>As part of my internship with a climate advocacy organization, I had the opportunity to participate in a four-day fieldwork camp in Cayamavana Village (茶山部落), a southern Cou (鄒族) indigenous peoples community located in the mountainous region of southern Taiwan. Cou indigenous people is mainly separated into the north and southern village. The villages are separated by the terrains of the mountains which has their own local cultures. The Cou people I refer here is only referring to Cayamavana Village from the southern village. My role was a student mentor, accompanying youth participants who were assigned with exploring culturally significant vocabulary in the Cou language. This immersive experience allowed me to learn alongside, exploring how embodied practices of place-based knowledge manifested in language. A particularly transformative moment happened while walking in the mountains with Basuya, a Cou hunter, whose guidance offered us urban humans how worldview, particularly kincentric worldview shapes their ethical and spiritual relationship with the environment. It became clear that the Cou way of relating to land, animals, insects and seeds is a relational ontology, that contrasts with carbon-centric climate governance approaches which turn ecosystems into data points or carbon offsets.</p><p><em>Kincentric Ecology in Language and Relating</em></p><p>Guiding students in the process of “seeing behind the vocabularies” was one of the most transformational learning experiences for me during the trip. In Cou worldview, naming is not a taxonomic act, but a relational, storied process. Unlike urban, western scientific paradigms where land and lifeforms are categorized through universal naming, the Cou peoples name only those places, beings, or features that hold story, memory, or emotional significance. For example, what we might call a mountain goat is instead referred to simply as “the thing on the cliff”. Rather than labeling every being, the forest is treated as home, and just like in one’s own house, not every corner is named, only the places marked by experience, ritual, or ancestral memory. Basuya jokingly said, “if you fall down here, this spot will be named as ‘the corner where Jasmine fell.’” This shows how deeply they are in intimacy with place and a worldview in which land is not an object of study or ownership, but a living relative.</p><p>This extends to ethics of the use of nature manifested through its language. The practice of hunting was never described using the word “hunt.” Instead, Cou tribe spoke of “taking a walk in the mountains”, showing a deep humility before the land god. Indigenous hunter Basuya explained that it’s a taboo to predict or expect the amounts of animals that you take away, because animals aren’t seen as exploitable resources, but as sacred gifts judged and offered by the land spirit. To express a desire to hunt for specific amount or type of animals is like placing an order from the menu of land spirit, which is a huge disrespect.</p><p>Hornets and bees are Cou peoples’ favorite, Basuya told us. The honey holds a special place in their food culture and ecological knowledge. However, their approach to harvesting shows a relational ethic rather than an extractive. When gathering honey, they never take the entire hive. Rather, they leave enough for the bees and hornets to regenerate. They even assist in creating or maintaining suitable nesting spaces for pollinators, sometimes using abandoned pangolin dens or creating nests to support wild bees in building their hive. This shows their culture deeply rooted in reciprocity, respect and care towards more-than-human life by understanding that if the bees thrive, the community thrives too. This stands in sharp contrasts to the destructive legacy of modern infrastructure we encountered while walking in the mountains with Basuya. Along the riverbeds were abandoned sediment-trapping dams of past development projects now rusting in between rocks and leaves. It was forgotten by their builders, but not by the land. These steel structures, once built to control erosion or sediment flow, now sit like dead giants, blocking waterways, almost injuring those of us who pass by, and damaging ecosystems that once flourished. Basuya told us they used to raft along these rivers, now these debris became a danger to those who raft here. “Do whatever you can to stop these dams from being built,” Basuya plead us. “They are killers of life here.” And here the life means the biocultural diversity of life. It is deeply disheartening to witness how modern development often leaves without considering consequences, and assumes the permanence of establishment where there should be humility.</p><p><em>Climate Resilience and Adaptation</em></p><p>Even Cou tribe’s way of seed conservation challenges modern scientific paradigms. Nowadays, in order to preserve seeds, labs preserve them through refrigeration (removing them from life cycles). In contrast, Cou families continue to plant native millet varieties each year, ensuring the seed “remembers” and adapts to climate changes that’s different each in generations. As one elder shared, “Only through planting can we tell the seed what the outside world is like.” This is not only agricultural knowledge, it is a deeply kincentric ecological cultural way of resistance to challenges from communities that stands in the front lines of colonial and existential threat.</p><p>This witness of a completely different way of relating to nature shocked me and leaves me wondering: if we re-member ourselves as part of nature, starting from also reconnecting to where our ancestry came from, who our ancestors are, where are we situated, as the Cou people relate so intimately to their environments, might we begin to heal the divide between humans and the Earth, and rediscover the sacredness that sustains us all?</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>By looking critically in the eyes of mainstream carbon-centric climate governance, this paper argues that the crisis isn’t in the amount of carbon emissions, but of our ontological relation with ourselves, each other and land. Through engaging in embodiment practices, community-based intentional processes like Offers and Needs Market, or seeing how indigenous ways of relating to land as case study of Cou tribe, this paper has explored how alternative frameworks of relationality, embodiment, and place-based knowledge offer significant insights for transforming climate governance and activism from the inside out.</p><p>Instead of seeing the self as separate from Earth and to control its changing climate, each case study shows how collective healing begins with re-membering, literally mending fractured relationships modernity, capitalism, colonialism has torn apart. No matter if it’s slowing down to feel our bodies in the urgent of crisis, turning toward one another in economies of mutual aid, or intimacy with land seen through indigenous languages, these show that the way we relate is the change itself.</p><p>In contrast to carbon-centric, market-driven solutions, this research suggests that ontological shifts in how we relate may be more foundational and long-lasting.</p><p>It invites climate activists, researchers, and policymakers to go beyond metrics and emissions, to include the unseen actors of stories, bodies, memories, and sacred relationships.</p><p>Last but not least, this paper argues that the Anthropocene is not only an era of ecological loss, but <strong>a threshold for re-membering who we are, where we come from, and what it means to live well together on a shared Earth.</strong></p><h3><strong>Reference</strong></h3><ul><li>Abram, David, and Andy Fisher. Radical Ecopsychology: Psychology in the Service of Life. Albany: SUNY Press, 2012.</li><li>Eisenstein, Charles. Climate: A New Story. Berkeley: North Atlantic Books, 2018.</li><li>Hawken, Paul. Carbon: The Book of Life. New York: Viking, 2025.</li><li>Moreno, Camila, Daniel Speich Chassé, and Lili Fuhr. Carbon Metrics: Global Abstractions and Epistemological Epistemicide. Publication Series Ecology 42. Berlin: Heinrich Böll Stiftung, 2015.</li><li>Miller, Clark A. “Climate Science and the Making of a Global Political Order.” In States of Knowledge: The Co-Production of Science and the Social Order, edited by Sheila Jasanoff, 46–66. New York: Routledge, 2004.</li><li>Orlove, Ben, Pasang Sherpa, Neil Dawson, Ibidun Adelekan, Wilfredo Alangui, Rosario Carmona, Deborah Coen, et al. “Placing Diverse Knowledge Systems at the Core of Transformative Climate Research.” Ambio 52, no. 9 (2023): 1431–47. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-023-01857-w.">https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-023-01857-w.</a></li><li>Salmón, Enrique. “Kincentric Ecology: Indigenous Perceptions of the Human-Nature Relationship.” Ecological Applications 10, no. 5 (2000): 1327–32. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/2641288.">https://doi.org/10.2307/2641288.</a></li><li>brown, adrienne maree. “Fractals: The Relationship Between Small and Large.” Earthling Opinion, March 1, 2019. <a href="https://earthlingopinion.wordpress.com/2019/03/01/fractals-the-relationship-between-small-and-l">https://earthlingopinion.wordpress.com/2019/03/01/fractals-the-relationship-between-small-and-l</a> arge/.</li><li>chayne, kaméa. “Relearning the Languages of Land, Plants, and Place, ft. Martín Prechtel.” Uprooted (Substack), February 15, 2025. <a href="https://kamea.substack.com/p/green-dreamer-martin-prechtel.">https://kamea.substack.com/p/green-dreamer-martin-prechtel.</a></li><li>Stone, Madeleine. “How Much Is a Whale Worth?” National Geographic, September 24, 2019. <a href="https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/how-much-is-a-whale-worth.">https://www.nationalgeographic.com/environment/article/how-much-is-a-whale-worth.</a></li><li>“The Offers and Needs Market.” Accessed June 5, 2025. <a href="https://offersandneeds.com/#.">https://offersandneeds.com/#.</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=90caaa5fbd89" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Taiwan Youth at COP28: Experiences and Perspectives on How Taiwan’s Legal Status Influences UN…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jasminethedreamcatcher/taiwan-youth-at-cop28-experiences-and-perspectives-on-how-taiwans-legal-status-influences-un-cbccd1c7f5ec?source=rss-5562c17352e3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cbccd1c7f5ec</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[taiwan]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[observation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[un]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[youth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cop-28]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jasmine Wu]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 25 Feb 2025 04:18:26 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-02-27T05:18:42.301Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Taiwan Youth at COP28: Experiences and Perspectives on How Taiwan’s Legal Status Influences UN Participation</h3><blockquote>This is my final report for a course in university called &quot;Gaiapolitics and War Ecology”, and I’m grateful to Professor Paul Jobins for encouraging me to share it.</blockquote><h3><strong>Taiwan’s Status under the UN</strong></h3><p>After World War II, the need for a more robust international organization to maintain peace pushed nations to establish United Nations(UN), guided by the UN charter. In the preamble of the UN charter, it wrote: “we the peoples of the United Nations … reaffirm faith in fundamental human rights, in the dignity and worth of the human person, in the equal rights of men and women and of nations large and small.”</p><p>UN membership, the highest form of participation in international community, is closely tied to the issue of sovereignty. However, in order to be granted as official member state of United Nations, it has to be passed through decision of General Assembly and agreed by two-thirds majority by the five “great powers” of Security Council who could wield veto power that can single-handedly block the decision. During the Cold War, this admission criteria became a battleground between the West and Soviet Union, blocking nations under the ideological confrontation, losing its significance under the power politics.</p><p>Following the Republic of China (ROC) government’s withdrawal to Taiwan in 1947 and the establishment of the People’s Republic of China (PRC) in Beijing in 1949, both claimed to be the rightful international representative of China. The United States supported the ROC’s claim for over two decades in the UN and the UN Security Council. Despite efforts to broker a dual representation or a two China solution, geopolitical shifts in the early 1970s, combined with increasing global recognition of Beijing, led to the inevitable end of ROC representation in the UN in 1971 under Chiang Kai-shek’s regime. Resolution 2758¹, adopted swiftly by a simple majority and no longer requiring a two-thirds majority or a Security Council recommendation, admitted the PRC to the United Nations, leaving Taiwan isolated and excluded from numerous international organizations, particularly the UN. Although ROC lost its membership in the UN, during 1993~2000, there were several attempts of UN bids or approaches to ask for the right to represent or full membership. Two referendums were even taken place in 2008 by the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) and Kuomintang (KMT) to ask the people in Taiwan whether the government should apply for membership². Taiwan’s attempt to join the UN has never made it to UN General Assembly’s agenda, due to China’s concern that Taiwan’s involvement in the UN would significantly advance the island’s path toward independence, it rejects Taiwan’s pragmatic approaches and membership bids. Only a few countries with diplomatic ties to Taiwan challenged China, while the majority followed China’s lead, either quietly or openly. During the 2000s, Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) opened a window for Taiwan and World Health Organization (WHO), inviting Taiwan to be the observer in World Health Assembly (WHA). Ever since, Taiwan resorted to issue-oriented approach with involvement in low-profile manner, like participating in side events and public meetings in International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO). The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) is also one of Taiwan’s effort for its presence in the UN.</p><h3><strong>COP: Conference of the Parties</strong></h3><h4>Background</h4><p>With the aim of tackling climate change and its global consequences, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) was adopted and signed by nations in the UN in the 1990s. Signatory nations are referred to as “Parties,” and to date, there are 198 Parties that have signed the UNFCCC. The Conference of the Parties (COP), is one of the climate summit that serves as the highest decision-making body within the UNFCCC which gathers member countries annually to negotiate on whether they’re on track to deal with climate change.</p><p>The UNFCCC’s COP forums serve as a crucial platform for global dialogue on climate change, fostering discussions, negotiations, and actions to mitigate its impacts, promote sustainable development worldwide, as well as a stage for nations to highlight their climate actions and ambitions. Each COP results in agreements or treaties, with significant outcomes including the Kyoto Protocol in 1997 and the Paris Agreement in 2015³.</p><p>In COP’s venue, it is divided into the<strong> Blue Zone </strong>and the <strong>Green Zone</strong>. The Blue Zone, exclusive to accredited parties and observers, has more participatory restrictions than the Green Zone, which is open to the public. Blue Zone serves as the venue for formal negotiations, the World Climate Action Summit, national pavilions, presidency events, and hold numerous side events such as panel discussions, round tables, and cultural events from different countries.</p><h4>Participants &amp; Permissions</h4><p>Blue Zone participants can be divided into 3 categories:</p><p>(1) Party: representatives of Parties to the Convention and Observer States,</p><p>(2) Press: Members of the press and media,</p><p>(3) Observer Organization: Representatives of observer organizations.</p><p>The Observer Organizations can be further categorized into 3 types: (1) UN system &amp; special agencies (Secretary), (2) Intergovernmental Organizations (IGOs), and (3) Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs). In the venue, participants’ badges indicate their role, with different badges granting different permissions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/539/1*V-hE1F9-XO4LLYL489Y7VQ.png" /><figcaption>Different badges indicating different roles. (Source: <a href="https://climate.arabyouthcenter.org/en/download?fl=D4fql7PnPk1YnnzkAbrZGqoR6IwkggODUkqMboRZ.pdf">Arab Youth Council for Climate Change</a>. 2023.“Empowering Youth for Climate Action: Navigating COP and COY in the UAE”. )</figcaption></figure><p>For instance, certain high-level meetings only allow entry for those who have Party Badge, restricting access for other participants. Among the Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs), they formed into 9 groups of stakeholders with similar interests called the “constituencies”, each with their focal points to interact with the secretariat including: Business and industry NGOs (BINGO), Indigenous peoples organizations (IPO), Children and Youth NGOs (YOUNGO), etc.</p><p>It’s not mandatory to be part of a constituency, however, belonging to a constituency can offer benefits. Such as: access to the Plenary floor for interventions (a chance to speak at the negotiation table), allocation of secondary badges in case of site access limits, receiving informal advance information from the secretariat, timely updates through constituency meetings, occasional invitations to Ministerial receptions, access to bilateral meetings with officials, and limited invitations to secretariat organized workshops between sessional periods.</p><p>In the case of<strong> Taiwan Youth Climate Coalition (TWYCC)</strong>, we joined the YOUNGO constituency and seized the benefits of having first-timer-COP guides and resources made by YOUNGO volunteers, meeting other youth activists, and speaking in the negotiation tables for youth.</p><h4><strong>Taiwan &amp; Climate Change</strong></h4><p>With the impact of climate change, increased frequency of high temperatures, flood and drought and proportion of severe typhoons in irregular seasons can be seen in Taiwan⁴. Not only is Taiwan a victim, but also the contributor to climate change. In 2020, Taiwan’s production-based CO₂ emissions per capita were reported at around 11 tons, ranking 8th among countries with populations exceeding 10 million⁵.</p><p>The National Inventory Report (NIR) from Taiwan’s Environmental Protection Administration provides undeniable evidence that Taiwan’s emissions cannot be overlooked globally. Notably, the industrial sector plays a crucial role, contributing 49% — surpassing the global average of 33% — and accounting for over 65% of the country’s total energy demand, securing its place as the fourth-highest globally. In 2019, 40% of total greenhouse gas emissions in Taiwan originated from the top 10 companies, with four belonging to the Formosa Plastics Group, highlighting a “carbon oligopoly” phenomenon in Taiwan’s emission⁶.</p><h4><strong>Taiwan’s Official Participation in COP28</strong></h4><p>The 28th Conference of the Parties (COP28), held in Dubai from Nov. 30 to Dec. 13, had the largest registered attendees in history of COP, which also contains the largest ever amount of Taiwanese delegations.</p><p>Due to Taiwan’s legal status under UN, Taiwanese officials couldn’t participate in COP conferences as party delegates, but through seeking “non-governmental organization observer” identity through gaining participation badge under the name of government-funded Industrial Technology Research Institute (ITRI), they’re still able to be active in COP’s Blue Zone within the participation limits of an observer in a low-profile manner. They have been participating in COP via the ITRI since 1995. In COP28, the Taiwanese government delegations was led by Minister of Environment Shieu Fuh-Sheng (薛富盛). Besides government ministries, limited Taiwanese grassroot organizations, corporations, academia were also able to join COP by leveraging observer organization identity in COP28. Taiwanese high position officials who publicly announced their attendance plans to COP might be monitored and denied entry, such as the case of this year, Cynthia Wu (吳欣盈), a vice president candidate from Taiwan People’s Party (TPP) who ignored the advice of keeping low-profile manner and hold a press conference to announce her plan to COP28 was denied entering the Blue Zone. Several government officials, including Shieu, have also been denied access, possibly due to the leaked information of their plan. When I met other Taiwanese attendees who have connections with Taiwanese officials, I’ve inquired who are the officials that will be coming to COP28, they didn’t disclose the names of the officials, as if to maintain secrecy of their plans to COP, avoid being sidelined even under the identity of observer organization. Nevertheless, they still strive to take actions in the Green Zone where it doesn’t require a badge. In COP28, the Taiwanese officials seize the opportunity to hold 46 bilateral meetings with 35 like-minded country government officials to discuss climate policies and “2050 Net-Zero” plan. In order to demonstrate the robust friendship and collaboration with diplomatic allies, Taiwan cooperated with Palau and Saint Christopher &amp; Nevis to hold cooperative events in their pavilion. Official side events, have high threshold to apply due to the huge amount of applicants from around the world in various fields. However, Taiwan still manages to hold 5 joint side events between Taiwan NGOs and diplomatic allies, sharing experiences on just transition, climate finance, adaptation, etc. What’s more, outside the venue, a cruise reception by Taiwanese government for ally nations was organized, featuring the screening of “Melting Greenland” documentary, while the Commercial Office of Taipei in Dubai also had a welcome reception, both intended to express the friendliness and our intention for deeper relationship. Interestingly, to gain onsite publicity, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MOFA) placed electronic advertisement in 53 Dubai metro stations that has “Climate Action with Taiwan!” in English and Arabic words.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/987/1*bSdGJni24K3YwL6V8asLbw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Surprised to see Taiwan’s advertisement in many stations. Some of us think it’s a waste of money spent without clear message or climate actions depicted, others think it has its diplomatic impact.</figcaption></figure><p>To show solidarity for Taiwan to be included, there were 42 parliaments representing 12 diplomatic allies and Formosa Clubs in Europe, Latin America, and the Caribbean sent letters to Simon Stiell, the Executive Secretary of the UNFCCC, to collectively urge the global community to incorporate Taiwan in discussions, processes, and mechanisms associated with both the UNFCCC and the Paris Agreement. One of the highlights of the decision made in COP28 was the operationalization of the “Loss &amp; Damage Fund”, with United Arab Emirates pledging USD $100 million along with other wealthy nations following suit to pledge the financial support for vulnerable countries. A step that Taiwanese government has taken after COP28 to show effort in climate finance is MOFA announced the contribution of US $10 million to the establishment of “Climate Transition Fund” for climate adaptation in four ally countries ── Tuvalu, Nauru (end relation at Jan.15), the Marshall Islands, and Palau. Chia-Wei Chao, a research director of Taiwan Climate Action Network (CAN) think tank who’s also a professor, commented on his X, comparing the scales of countries’ pledges to UN climate fund at COP28 :</p><blockquote>“the scale of the fund is comparable to the commitment from Japan, and Taiwan is a non annex I &amp; non-party of UNFCCC, this kind of the financial commitment should be used as a leverage to urge Singapore or South Korea to do the same thing.”</blockquote><p>Without UN’s recognition and its legal responsibilities, why is Taiwanese government and private sectors still taking voluntary actions to strive to meet the agreements of UNFCCC?</p><p>The “Climate Band-wagoning Concept”, might be an answer to this, in which Taiwanese government primarily aims to expand its international presence rather than the intention to climate mitigation. Adhering to the provisions of UN climate agreement not only “saves the earth”, but is also a key strategy to increase its international recognition⁷ and gaining a sense of “civic nationalism⁸.”</p><p>Furthermore, Taiwan’s export-oriented economy holds significant influence in the global supply chain, therefore Taiwanese industries are actively engaging in “private governance” to address environmental concerns, such as declaring net-zero targets in response to global initiatives. After the returns of Taiwanese officials from COP28, Ministry of Foreign Affairs published the “Report on and Subsequent Responses to COP28” in the Legislative Yuan to answer interpellation and discuss on further actions to align with the negotiation decisions being made in COP28⁹.</p><p>Taiwan being one of the largest per capita emitters, as a non-member of COP, operates without official pressure or monitoring in climate change negotiations, unless it voluntarily participates. While Taiwan has established its own climate initiatives like the “Climate Change Response Act” and “2050 Net Zero Plan¹⁰,” the absence from formal negotiations poses challenges in ensuring that its actions align proportionally with the responsibilities associated with addressing climate change or providing insights in regulations for greening industries which Taiwan has the world largest semiconductor production that should join the conversation instead of passively complying the rules.</p><h3><strong>My Experience in COP28</strong></h3><p><a href="https://www.twycc.org.tw/"><strong>Taiwan Youth Climate Coalition (台灣青年氣候聯盟, TWYCC)</strong></a>, a youth-led, environmental NGO officially created in 2012, has been sending youth delegates every year to COP for more than 10 years. Recognizing the importance of not only raising public awareness but also<strong> empowering the youth in understanding and shaping policies</strong>, TWYCC prioritize both local action and international collaboration. Local actions involve advocating for climate policies to include youth representations, climate education in Taiwan’s curriculum, youth’s perspective in just transition policies, etc.</p><p>One of TWYCC’s division is the<strong> International Affairs Division (國際部)</strong> which aims to train volunteers within this division and select delegates to COP in order to track important climate issues, network with global youth activists to ultimately make youth’s voices be heard. Grateful and blessed, I was chosen as one of the 5 delegates to represent TWYCC in COP28 to take inspirations from the world back to Taiwan and for further advocacies.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/611/1*EU941J90v59Gesve4Ep7TA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>TWYCC’s COP28 Delegate Team</em></figcaption></figure><p>Before heading to Dubai, we’ve attended the “Pre-COP28 Consensus Meeting” which invited all the Taiwanese who are planning to go to COP28. Among the participants are media reporters, researchers, NGOs, a team of high school students, corporations, entrepreneurs, etc. We shared our plans on this meeting and exchange contact details for further collaboration on ground. Despite different goals for COP28, this community allowed us to share resources, emergency accommodations, and news exposure opportunities for the trip.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/413/1*aDSHS9sQ32HusqHjRL_hJQ.png" /><figcaption>My first week observer organization badge. TWYCC isn’t an accredited NGO to join COP, thus we get the badge from other Taiwanese NGOs who are accredited</figcaption></figure><p>I stayed in Dubai for 18 days. First 3 days for the 18th Conference of Youth (COY18) that typically take place few days preceding COP, to network with other youth and attend in skill-building workshops. In COP28, we focused on tracking negotiation meetings related to the topic of “Just Transition”, at the same time holding events to share our advocacy works and network with youth activists for future collaboration opportunities.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/710/1*RTtRxxRo8u0f32w4n6cX3A.png" /><figcaption>TWYCC’s plans to speak in events in COP28 (Image from Jasmine)</figcaption></figure><h4><strong>Seat at the Table</strong></h4><p>Joining YOUNGO’s Just Transition Working Group was a perfect chance to know deeper about how negotiations are taken place and the interests of each member states.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*fSSM5HiXA0-9BInvQ5ZwPQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>YOUNGO Just Transition Working Group Photo</figcaption></figure><p>The leader of the working group provided us opportunities in the negotiation rooms to make necessary “interventions”, a term for delivering demands in negotiation rooms to speak up on behalf of YOUNGO on just transition, defending the YOUNGO Global Youth Statement¹¹ proposals for the Just Transition Work Programme in the negotiations, making sure the negotiation output will be based in human and labor rights, public participation and delivering education and skills for the youth.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/983/1*DXHD91vkYdvNNEIc_syoxQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Hard working youths in Just Transition Working Group discussing on the floor outside the negotiation rooms about strategy for interventions on behalf of youth.</figcaption></figure><p>Yun-Fang (another TWYCC delegate) and I were able to make intervention in a high-level ministerial Round Table on Just Transition and a pre-sessional workshop respectively.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/288/1*K6CCqsmsCs9_upqdcu5CJQ.png" /><figcaption>TWYCC members (Me on the left; Yun-Fang on the right) delivering interventions on behalf of YOUNGO to call for meaningful, equal participatory space for youth in the form of Advisory Board</figcaption></figure><p>Recalling on a prior incident at COP years ago where a TWYCC delegate unintentionally referred to Taiwan as a “country,” causing Chinese youth delegates to leave the room¹², I hesitated to mention “I’m from Taiwan” during my intervention, in fear of whether this would seem political which hinders the Chinese delegate in the room to listen to the demand of youth. Concerned about provoking the Chinese delegates, I sought advice from my TWYCC mentor afterwards, who reassured me that specifying my origin without explicitly mentioning “country” wouldn’t be a significant provocation. However, this fear of unintentional mistepping the political sensitives is still constraining in discussing climate change. Later, Yun-Fang in her interventions in the high-level negotiation did mention Taiwan. Yun-Fang also shared her frustration with me when she had a moment that she cried disappointingly when seeing how youth from around the world are at a session actively sharing strategies of lobbying in COP because the consequences would have direct impact to the law of their countries which are included in the UN, which might not have that much of a binding power to Taiwan compared to other countries.</p><p>As an observer in the negotiation rooms, you could sit in the back, seeing member states raising their placards to give their opinions on the procedures, goals, timeframe on the issues that matter to them. Without the seat at the table, we could only take notes and comply passively to the decisions being made.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G_o02HxiqTYpQ8Prj3hMag.jpeg" /><figcaption>Perspective of an observer in the negotiation meeting room</figcaption></figure><p>However, an opportunity was observed to gain seat at the table through our friendship with a 22 year-old Polish negotiator, Zuzanna Borowska, who’s speaking on behalf of Liberia in negotiations regarding just transition. Given her expertise and experience in this area, the Liberian government entrusted her as the official negotiator. If Taiwanese delegates are eager to assist ally nations by sharing our expertise in specific areas, we could also seize on the opportunity to serve as negotiators for other countries.</p><h4>National Pavilions &amp; Events</h4><p>Besides meeting rooms for negotiations, there were also national pavilions, buildings with individual spaces for member states to hold events and showcase their climate actions. What’s more, 5 thematic pavilions were also in COP28, each having their own sub-pavilions set by civil societies. When global youth asked me where my country’s pavilion is, I told them that we’re not allowed to have a national pavilion due to the status, they were surprised to find out about the status of Taiwan in the UN. To breakthrough the limitation of not permitted to have national pavilion, not only did Taiwanese officials cooperated with Palau to hold events, Taiwan Climate Partnerships (TCP) also applied for a sub-pavilion called “Digital X Green Pavilion” under one of the thematic pavilions, holding more than 30 events¹³. TWYCC has also been able to hold an event about intergenerational equity in this pavilion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LkSEIiKZsbsLlL2PFtBSyA.jpeg" /><figcaption><em>Me being the moderator of TWYCC’s event </em><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OVS_H8Mnl_E&amp;t=3752s"><em>“Generational Equity Through the Lens of Youth and Corporate Responsibility”</em></a><em> in Digital X Green Pavilion, invited by TCP</em></figcaption></figure><p>Just beside Palau’s pavilion lies the State of Palestine’s pavilion. Palestine is not recognized as a member state, but as an observer state, a status that Taiwan wasn’t even able to have. COP28 was the first time for Palestine to set their pavilion, organized by the Minister of Environment from Palestine (Environment Quality Authority, EQA). A few Palestinian officials made a significant effort to attend COP28, highlighting the challenges of pursuing climate mitigation and energy security while living under occupation. By attending their event about energy sector in Palestine and having conversation with their Ministry of Agriculture, I observed that this opportunity gave Palestine a chance to demand their rights to clean water and soil which are violated under the Israeli occupation and exacerbated by climate change. I was surprised to see that there are still Nationally Determined Contributions (NDC) and climate actions taken even under constrains of the siege. The speaker said, “The COP28 chief Sultan claimed that ‘COP isn’t just about negotiating the texts, but also improving the lives of the people.’ But does this apply to the Palestinian people?” It’s admiring to see Palestine’s insistence in the involvement of COP during Gaza’s bombardment, which also serves a way to make a presence for raising awareness to the plight that is happening there. Despite not recognized as a member state, we can still witness global leaders using their COP28 speeches to draw attention to the crisis, and civil societies making “ceasefire” in the center of the biggest COP28 climate protest outside the negotiation room.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*-dwMMbuwUA9mj6fk3FrBRA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Inside State of Palestine’s pavilion</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*h-9FflCQJUuHy0TH7qZRWw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Biggest climate protest was dominated by the call for ceasefire in Gaza because they claimed “there’s no climate justice without human rights”</figcaption></figure><h4>News Coverage</h4><p>During COP28, the experience of being approached by more than 4 Taiwanese news media outlets for interviews evoked a sense of uniqueness among TWYCC members. This distinct attention stands out particularly when compared to the youth from other countries present at the venue. However, beneath the surface of this attention lies a complex emotional layer — a sense of eager to be seen and perhaps a bit of inferiority. This stems from the realization that Taiwan’s limited participation in the UN restricts our ability to engage fully on the international stage. As a result, the stories and perspectives of Taiwanese participation become both scarce and valuable, especially when Taiwanese youth could speak in the negotiation rooms rather than officials. The media’s interest not only shows the importance of youth’s voices, but also highlights Taiwan’s underlying frustration and yearning to be seen and included in the global platform. Perhaps for Taiwan and Palestine, without being able to officially negotiate the decisions, these international climate summit became a quest for visibility and acknowledgment. For me, COP28 not only serves as a motivation for further my future climate advocacies, but also a testimony of Taiwan’s unrecognized but acknowledged presence in the UN. For Taiwan society, rather than emphasizing a collective message for climate justice, the meaning of COP28 participation serves more as another coverage of “inspiration” of Taiwanese being seen internationally — a twisted and disappointing phenomenon when climate dialogue became limited due to geopolitics.</p><h3><strong>Conclusion</strong></h3><p>From my experience in COP28 and observation of Taiwanese officials’ actions, sovereignty became important when participation operates under UN’s criteria. Taiwan’s commitment to maximizing its impact within the limited status at COP28 persists despite being excluded as member state. High-ranking officials face the likelihood of being restricted from entering the Blue Zone, where crucial negotiations unfold. In response, civil societies strive to amplify their influence within constituencies, such as TWYCC’s engagement in YOUNGO, providing an alternative avenue for deep participation in negotiation rooms and the formation of unofficial allies. However, the exclusion remains a barrier to achieving climate justice and effectively addressing the challenges of climate change. Therefore, UN must find alternative ways to include people in certain “controversial” territories, be it Taiwan, Puerto Rico, Palestine, Saharawi Arab Democratic Republic (SADR) or Kosovo in the table, because climate change is a challenge and responsibility that transcends borders, unbound by passports or nationalities. The principle of “leaving no one behind” should extend to nations far and near, irrespective of their status within the UN, ensuring a collective commitment to address it worldwide.</p><p><strong>Other interesting/creative scenes at COP28:</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*t2K8bbd1v0kkGWG2gvLeCA.jpeg" /><figcaption>The only moment I heard waves of laughter echoing through the pavilion — Turns out, it was a Scottish comedian who’s also an environmental economist called Matt Winning, talking about climate change with humor! The creativity and wit drew people in, offering a much-needed laugh in the midst of the intense, serious atmosphere of COP28.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/505/1*ZDACLUUjSQL7tf2mFESP7w.jpeg" /><figcaption>“FOSSIL OF THE DAY Award“ event organized daily by the renowned international organization Climate Action Network (CAN) during the COP conference, where an award ceremony publicly, sarcastically give award to the countries with the poorest performance in terms of climate action, implementation, or negotiations at COP.</figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="A creative card game called “Chatty Changemakers” to share interesting conversations around climate change." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/484/1*Tc27u0sHf-27aLnnur8R_w.jpeg" /><figcaption>A creative card game called “Chatty Changemakers” to share interesting conversations around climate change.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>Potential participation to future COP (will be updated soon!)</strong></p><p><strong>Footnotes:</strong></p><p><em>[1] UN General Assembly Resolution 2758, passed in the 26th session, admitted Beijing to replace Taipei in the United Nations and its Security Council.</em></p><p><em>[2] The referendums failed to exceed the threshold although it has high percentage of affirmative votes. Some said that the referendum failed not only because there were still debates on Taiwan’s sovereignty but also been politicized for domestic political gains.</em></p><p><em>[3] An important non-binding goal was set that countries agreed “keep a global temperature rise this century well below 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels and to pursue efforts to limit the temperature increase even further to 1.5 degrees Celsius.” (United Nations. (2015). “Paris Agreement”. </em><a href="https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/english_paris_agreement.pdf"><em>UNFCCC</em></a><em>, Dec. 12.)</em></p><p><em>[4] Ministry of Science and Technology. (2017). “Climate Change Impact”. </em><a href="https://adapt.moenv.gov.tw/eng/TCCIP-1-A/TCCIP-1-A-5_en.html#:~:text=Surface%20temperature%20in%20Taiwan%20has,to%203.6%C2%B0C%20respectively."><em>Taiwan Adaptation Platform</em></a></p><p><em>[5] Yi Ling Roy Ngerng. (2020</em><a href="https://rsprc.ntu.edu.tw/en/m01-2/climate-change/1514-1209-taiwandoingenough.html"><em>).“Is Taiwan Doing Enough to Address Climate Change in The Hottest Summer Ever?”.</em></a><em> RSPRC, Dec. 09.</em></p><p><em>[6] Liu, John &amp; Chao, Chia-Wei. (2023) “Politics of climate change mitigation in Taiwan: International isolation, developmentalism legacy, and civil society responses”. </em><a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/369423342_Politics_of_climate_change_mitigation_in_Taiwan_International_isolation_developmentalism_legacy_and_civil_society_responses"><em>WIREs Climate Change</em></a><em>, Mar. 21.</em></p><p><em>[7] Chen, Milan. (2020). “Climate Change Politics in Taiwan: Understanding Taiwan’s Voluntary Climate Action”. </em><a href="https://mediatum.ub.tum.de/doc/1555257/1555257.pdf"><em>Technische Universität München</em></a><em>, Sep. 29.</em></p><p><em>[8] Jobin, P. (2021). ”Environmental movements in Taiwan’s anthropocene: A civic eco-nationalism.” </em><a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352283480_Environmental_movements_in_Taiwan&#39;s_anthropocene_a_civic_eco-nationalism"><em>Environmental movements and politics of the Asian Anthropocene.</em></a></p><p><em>[9] 外交部。(2023年12月14日)「第 28 屆聯合國氣候變遷大會（COP28）返國報告與後續因應情形」。</em><a href="https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/SittingAttachment/download/2023120832/29001023201223132002.pdf"><em>立法院 社會福利及衛生環境委員會第 15 次全體委員會議</em></a><em>。</em></p><p><em>[10] Since 2015, Taiwan has been guided by the “Greenhouse Gas Reduction and Management Act,” which mandates a legally binding long-term emission reduction target of 50% below 2005 levels by 2050. In alignment with global efforts, Taiwan announced its Intended Nationally Determined Contribution (INDC) under the Paris Agreement framework in the same year. Under President Tsai Ing-Wen’s administration, initiated in 2016, the government has created a four-pillar energy transition principle: “reduce coal, increase natural gas, promote green energy, achieve nuclear-free.”</em></p><p><em>[11] </em><a href="https://www.coy18uae.org/global-youth-statement"><em>Global Youth Statement</em></a><em>, a joint youth policy demand by all the working groups under YOUNGO, representing youth from 150+ countries, calling for key policy demands in various climate change topics.</em></p><p><em>[12] This incident occurred within TWYCC during a COP session when a delegate intended to share Taiwan’s climate action, accidentally using the sensitive word to describe “Taiwan is a country…” instead of “Taiwan is an island…” The misstep caused frustration among Chinese youth delegates, prompting them to quickly exit the room.</em></p><p><em>[13] 台灣氣候聯盟。(2023年12月7日)</em><a href="https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E3%80%8Ecop28%E7%9B%B4%E6%93%8A--%E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E7%A7%91%E6%8A%80%E5%B7%A8%E9%A0%AD%E7%B5%84%E9%9A%8A%EF%BC%8C%E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E6%B0%A3%E5%80%99%E8%81%AF%E7%9B%9Fcop28%E8%A8%AD%E9%A4%A8%E3%80%8F-050535463.html"><em>「COP28直擊 | 台灣科技巨頭組隊，台灣氣候聯盟COP28設館」</em></a></p><p><strong>References:</strong></p><p><em>Jobin &amp; Chen. (2023). “Toward an Upgrade of Gaia-politics: A View from the East Asian Critical Zone”. </em><a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/373302930_Toward_an_Upgrade_of_Gaia-politics_A_View_from_the_East_Asian_Critical_Zone"><em>Science Technology &amp; Human Values</em></a><em>, Oct.</em></p><p><em>Jobin, P. (2021). ”Environmental movements in Taiwan’s anthropocene: A civic eco-nationalism”. </em><a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352283480_Environmental_movements_in_Taiwan&#39;s_anthropocene_a_civic_eco-nationalism"><em>Environmental movements and politics of the Asian Anthropocene.</em></a></p><p><em>Huang, Eric. (2003). “Taiwan’s Status in a Changing World: United Nations Representation and Membership for Taiwan”. </em><a href="https://digitalcommons.law.ggu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1072&amp;context=annlsurvey"><em>Annual Survey of International &amp; Comparative Law.</em></a></p><p><em>Liu, John &amp; Chao, Chia-Wei. (2023) “Politics of climate change mitigation in Taiwan: International isolation, developmentalism legacy, and civil society responses”. </em><a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/369423342_Politics_of_climate_change_mitigation_in_Taiwan_International_isolation_developmentalism_legacy_and_civil_society_responses"><em>WIREs Climate Change</em></a><em>, Mar. 21.</em></p><p><em>Chen, Milan. (2020). “Climate Change Politics in Taiwan: Understanding Taiwan’s Voluntary Climate Action”. </em><a href="https://mediatum.ub.tum.de/doc/1555257/1555257.pdf"><em>Technische Universität München</em></a><em>, Sep. 29.</em></p><p><em>MOFA. (2023). “Public, private Taiwanese actors participate in UNFCCC COP28, highlight Taiwan’s contribution to net-zero world”. </em><a href="https://en.mofa.gov.tw/News_Content.aspx?n=1328&amp;sms=273&amp;s=116190"><em>MOFA</em></a><em> Web, Dec. 15.</em></p><p><em>Lee, Chermaine. (2023). “Exclusive: Taiwan Willing to Donate to Disaster Fund, Environment Minister Says”. </em><a href="https://www.voanews.com/a/exclusive-taiwan-willing-to-donate-to-disaster-fund-environment-minister-says-/7393365.html"><em>VOA News</em></a><em>, Dec. 11</em></p><p><em>Winkler, Sigrid. (2012). “Taiwan’s UN Dilemma: To Be or Not To Be”. </em><a href="https://www.brookings.edu/articles/taiwans-un-dilemma-to-be-or-not-to-be/"><em>Brookings</em></a><em>, Jun. 20.</em></p><p><em>Chueh, Sophia. (2023). “Meet Our COP28 Delegates &amp; Taiwan base team”. </em><a href="https://medium.com/taiwan-youth-climate-coalition/meet-our-cop28-delegates-taiwan-base-team-680e9b077a5b"><em>Medium</em></a><em>, Nov. 15.</em></p><p><em>United Nations. (2015). “Paris Agreement”. </em><a href="https://unfccc.int/sites/default/files/english_paris_agreement.pdf"><em>UNFCCC</em></a><em>, Dec. 12</em></p><p><em>Ministry of Science and Technology. (2017). “Climate Change Impact”. </em><a href="https://adapt.moenv.gov.tw/eng/TCCIP-1-A/TCCIP-1-A-5_en.html#:~:text=Surface%20temperature%20in%20Taiwan%20has,to%203.6%C2%B0C%20respectively."><em>Taiwan Adaptation Platform</em></a><em>.</em></p><p><em>Yi Ling Roy Ngerng. (2020).“Is Taiwan Doing Enough to Address Climate Change in The Hottest Summer Ever?”. </em><a href="https://rsprc.ntu.edu.tw/en/m01-2/climate-change/1514-1209-taiwandoingenough.html"><em>RSPRC</em></a><em>, Dec. 09.</em></p><p><em>CNA. (2023). “Taiwan highlights COP28 advances; refutes TPP candidate’s accusation”. </em><a href="https://focustaiwan.tw/politics/202312190008"><em>Focus Taiwan</em></a><em>, Dec. 19.</em></p><p><em>Lee, James K.J. (2016). “Taiwan Should Be Part of Global Fight Against Climate Change”. </em><a href="https://thediplomat.com/2016/11/taiwan-should-be-part-of-global-fight-against-climate-change/"><em>The Diplomat</em></a><em>, Nov. 04.</em></p><p><em>Tsai, June. (2008). “Referendums echo support despite politicization” </em><a href="https://taiwantoday.tw/news.php?unit=10,23,45,10&amp;post=14762"><em>Taiwan Today</em></a><em>, April 04.</em></p><p><em>Gao, Pat. (2023). “Renewing Earth” </em><a href="https://taiwantoday.tw/news.php?post=244099&amp;unit=4,31&amp;unitname=Taiwan-Review&amp;postname=Renewing-Earth"><em>Taiwan Today</em></a><em>, Nov. 01.</em></p><p><em>外交部。(2023年12月14日)「第 28 屆聯合國氣候變遷大會（COP28）返國報告與後續因應情形」。</em><a href="https://ppg.ly.gov.tw/ppg/SittingAttachment/download/2023120832/29001023201223132002.pdf"><em>立法院 社會福利及衛生環境委員會第 15 次全體委員會議</em></a><em>。</em></p><p><em>台灣氣候聯盟。(2023年12月7日)</em><a href="https://tw.news.yahoo.com/%E3%80%8Ecop28%E7%9B%B4%E6%93%8A--%E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E7%A7%91%E6%8A%80%E5%B7%A8%E9%A0%AD%E7%B5%84%E9%9A%8A%EF%BC%8C%E5%8F%B0%E7%81%A3%E6%B0%A3%E5%80%99%E8%81%AF%E7%9B%9Fcop28%E8%A8%AD%E9%A4%A8%E3%80%8F-050535463.html"><em>「COP28直擊 | 台灣科技巨頭組隊，台灣氣候聯盟COP28設館」</em></a></p><p><em>田習如。(2023年12月3日)「COP28台灣青年不缺席 4名代表化焦慮為行動」。</em><a href="https://www.cna.com.tw/news/ahel/202312030010.aspx"><em>中央社</em></a><em>。</em></p><p><em>吳昀芳。(2023年12月06日)。「關於COP28，你不能不知道的4個重點！」。</em><a href="https://gcaa.org.tw/9334/"><em>綠色公民行動聯盟</em></a><em>。</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cbccd1c7f5ec" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2024 政大「去成長」修課心得]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jasminethedreamcatcher/2024-%E6%94%BF%E5%A4%A7-%E5%8E%BB%E6%88%90%E9%95%B7-%E4%BF%AE%E8%AA%B2%E5%BF%83%E5%BE%97-6af3e4bf7411?source=rss-5562c17352e3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6af3e4bf7411</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[修課心得]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[degrowth]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[去成長]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jasmine Wu]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Jan 2025 05:00:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-01-13T05:07:27.761Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>Before</strong></h3><p>2024上半年，政大Green24永續社的讀書會一起讀完了《少即是多: 棄成長如何拯救世界》，開始更全面的思考環境危機、社會議題的共通性，漸漸看見資本主義的本質 — 強調永無止盡的經濟成長，還有將身心、人類&amp;自然切割的二元論，正是當今社會所面臨眾多危機的深層根源。當我得知政大竟然開了一門有關去成長的課程（degrowth，可以翻譯為「棄成長」或「去成長」），我超興奮，竟然在我看完書後就有這門課的出現，簡直像是manifested一樣！</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1016/1*GUCqADNtUVSzCqfzsgLHsA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*odf-Ard2AofOwHT4vZbTVw.png" /><figcaption>2024上半年政大Green24永續社讀書會</figcaption></figure><p>不過，我當初還是猶豫過是否還需要修這門課，因為當下認為我已看完書就對去成長的概念有基本的了解，而且也不缺學分。還好很慶幸的是，我最後還是修了這門課，而過程中讓我發現我需要學習或是忘卻所學（unlearn）的概念遠比我想像的還要多！真是讓我更加謙卑！</p><h3><strong>After</strong></h3><p>以下是我上完課的轉變：</p><ol><li><strong>不斷問「為什麼」</strong></li></ol><p>課程結束後，最大的轉變是在面對生活或選擇時，我會開始不斷反問自己：「這選擇真的是我自己想要的嗎？還是社會期待的或是被迫的呢? 為什麼會如此呢？」在路上看到廣告時，會反思：「為何社會上這麼多廣告？我們真的需要這些廣告嗎？為什麼我們要接受這些廣告的存在？」</p><p>尤其是盧倩儀教授及Jane老師的課，使我們為近視的雙眼戴上了眼鏡，有了意識，開始檢視內在、外在的一切。</p><p><strong><em>擁有更多的意識的方式，就是不斷地對習以為常的事物提出「為什麼」，才可以更認識自己與這世界的脈絡。</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1016/1*Of6t8vxKjOQ_I_9eAWXGTg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jane老師分享Jon Jandai的語錄，說明社會體制如何影響我們，將自己生活變得很煎熬</figcaption></figure><p><strong>2. 更重視合作、連結</strong></p><p>從小到大，我們被教導人的本性是物競天擇、弱肉強食，而資本主義更深化這樣的觀點，強調個人利益與競爭，讓我們很有壓力要勝過他人。</p><p><strong><em>但這堂課讓我們看見競爭並不那麼自然，至少不比合作更自然。</em></strong></p><p>邱奕儒老師介紹，大自然合作的案例比比皆是，像是珊瑚礁與藻類、或是細胞之間的合作，但社會卻聚焦於競爭，來合理化將營利最大化的追求。而這堂課讓我看見在地社群與集體，如何透過互助來滿足共同需求，讓生活更有韌性、更幸福的各種案例（如：團結經濟、合作社、社區貨幣、合作住宅等）。</p><p><strong>3. 看見「雜」的價值</strong></p><blockquote><strong>唐敏老師：「對大自然不熟的人才會說『雜』。雜是件好事！」</strong></blockquote><p>看似是複雜、雜亂、不整齊的事情，其實自有道理與價值，像是看似不整齊的樹叢，其實自有一套蘊含豐富生態的系統。但我們若一貫以自己或是現代標準的眼光評斷所有人、事、物、當地社區，甚至去干預，則會因不理解歷史脈絡而破壞、危害他們的一套運作模式。</p><p>因歷史上歐洲霸權的擴張、殖民與全球化，西方科學成為許多國家科學教育的主流，這不僅讓我們視比較「傳統」的知識體系為較落後或是不值得看重的知識（如：原住民傳統生態知識）。我們透過這堂課「解殖」自己的思想，檢視當前社會主流觀點如何影響我們對於什麼為「進步」、什麼為「落後」的評斷。</p><p><strong><em>世界上沒有一個標準解方，但有符合在地脈絡的方法。而這造就了多元性的價值。</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6WQT_71qo_lxvr9F" /><figcaption>Photo by <a href="https://unsplash.com/@mllewelynb?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Maximus Beaumont</a> on <a href="https://unsplash.com/?utm_source=medium&amp;utm_medium=referral">Unsplash</a></figcaption></figure><p><strong>4. 更柔、更有包容性：把人當人看，把人當自然的一部分</strong></p><p>我們在這一學期看見將自然與人類分離的二元論如何將我們人類視為大自然之外，將人類看作比大自然更優越。同時，我們也看見資本主義如何利用這種觀點，將萬物 — 包括自然、動物、勞力與土地 — 簡化為可被買賣的商品。邱奕儒老師說：「當土地變市場交易的商品，土地的用意就變成買賣土地而非生產。」資本主義不僅剝奪了萬物（人事物、藝術、動物、土地等）原本神聖的本質、獨特性，還讓一切事物因金錢的介入變得同質化。因為一旦某物可以換取金錢，金錢又能購買其他事物，讓萬物只要透過金錢就可以被輕易購買、利用。</p><p>在資本社會，為了企業的營利，人似乎被視為生產工具，無止境地追求效率和生產力的最大化。在這樣的體制下，我們也逐漸內化了資本主義的價值觀，認為只有不斷地做更多、提高效率，才是有價值的；一旦停下來休息或選擇不做，就會感到內疚。這種觀念讓我們以職業和成就來衡量一個人的價值，忽略了人本身的獨特性與生命存在的純粹美好。我們忘記了，作為一個生命體，就已經是一種值得欣賞的奇蹟。</p><p><strong><em>如果我們能更多地意識到自己是有血有肉、充滿週期與變化的生命，我們將更重視當下的狀態、懂得珍惜休息，對自己更加寬容，甚至毫不猶豫地爭取應有的生活品質；</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>如果我們也意識到他人同樣是有血有肉的存在，我們將更加尊重他人身體的需求，寬容他們的過錯，並捍衛他們的權益；</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>如果我們認識到自己與大自然中的萬物同樣擁有生命，並發現自己是大自然的一部分，我們將與萬物建立更深的連結，過上更謙卑、充滿同理心與關懷的生活。而人權迫害、環境危機，或許就會減少。</em></strong></p><p>在這個迫切需要集體力量的時代，我們也很需要珍視多元價值的存在，因為只有融合多樣性與集體行動，才能真正創造更美好的未來。我很好奇，要如何意識到我們彼此共享的人性與作為地球一部分的集體連結，同時尊重、理解每個人因背景差異而展現出的獨特個體性呢？</p><h3><strong>Process</strong></h3><p>這堂課有太多令我感動的部分，尤其是每位老師都注入了他們的全部心力與能量，將他們希望讓我們了解的知識與經驗傳遞給我們。</p><p>在林一善老師的課，我們的座位不再是只有面對老師，而是與同學面對面，聽大家的想法。他提到其實去成長是一個不斷「忘卻所學（unlearning）」的過程，因為舊經驗會干擾新的學習，因此需要將我們現有的思維抽絲剝繭，看到底有多少是社會體制框架了我們，又有哪些是我們自己真正嚮往的生活。</p><p><strong><em>去成長在這堂課並非翻成「棄」成長，其實也與「去」在中文裡的雙重定義：「去除」或是「往、追求」</em>。</strong>不但要去除無益成長的物質與框架，更要去追求心靈上的持續成長，讓我們眼中仍有那道光。當他詢問現場的同學我們未來嚮往的職業／或想做的事是什麼，同學們的答案都讓人感動。當我說出自己未來想要成為更好的領導者時，被大家聽見並肯認的感覺真好，也使自己更有動力。</p><p>另外，我也很喜歡Jane及唐敏老師帶領的題目發想及小組討論的樣式：Open Space及兩腳原則（Law of Two Feet）。強調的是自由、順其自然的互動方式，<strong>一旦有人發現自己處於既不是學習也沒在貢獻的時刻，就可以去更有成效的地方</strong>。在找期末報告的組員時，老師並不是隨機安排或讓我們自己分組，而是讓我們（1）先將自己有興趣的題目寫在紙上 （2）每個人上台分享自己有興趣的題目（3）將紙擺在台前歸類。（4）聚集同主題的同學們，分享想法並做更小的分組。這樣不僅可以看見所有人有興趣的題目，更可以認識每個人~ <em>（如果要做線上分組或主題發想也可推薦使用PadNet，但可能就難以實體認識每個人）</em>我很喜歡這跟其他課程不同的分組方式，比較容易認識原本不熟但又有同興趣的同學們！希望政大其他堂課的老師也能得知這種分組、討論模式～</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ACf1Iupod4pw9mmjtYZ4Tg.png" /><figcaption>唐敏老師解釋Open Space原則</figcaption></figure><h3>Future</h3><p>真的非常幸運，能從這一學期的課程看見環境、社會危機的根源，以及課程中所邀請到的實際實踐者，讓我感受到更多希望與力量！</p><p>我發現，Degrowth的本質是要並不是完全的減法觀點，而是重新導向我們的焦點 — regrow，將我們自我、社會、經濟的成長從經濟成長轉移到更宏觀、循環、再生的成長。</p><p>在這門課過後，我更喜歡與人連結、社區還有集體的互動，並在未來想學習更多去成長相關的知識，尤其是樸門，並研究、實踐更以人為本的領導方式。這門課啟發我參與更多去成長相關的活動，像是在這期間我參與了Post-Growth Institute的Offers and Needs Market (OANM)，未來想要在政大Green24永續社實驗舉辦這樣的互連供給與需求的活動！</p><p>去成長課程讓我意識到現有體制的設計使我處於馬不停蹄的狀態，讓我們消費、活在未來。很感謝這門課程，它讓我決定慢下來，回歸當下，去反思、紀錄與創造來抵制這樣的體制！</p><p><strong>很感謝這堂課啟發我開始了第一篇部落格文章，未來我將持續書寫、紀錄與創作，活出更具反思、深刻的生活 ~</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6af3e4bf7411" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>