<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jay Priyadarshan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jay Priyadarshan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jayp900?source=rss-7c17065de2c7------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 18:22:44 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jayp900/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Saraswati Singh सरस्वती सिंह (née Iyer) Obituary]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jayp900/saraswati-singh-%E0%A4%B8%E0%A4%B0%E0%A4%B8%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%B5%E0%A4%A4%E0%A5%80-%E0%A4%B8%E0%A4%BF%E0%A4%82%E0%A4%B9-n%C3%A9e-iyer-obituary-d156a13cccf6?source=rss-7c17065de2c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d156a13cccf6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jay Priyadarshan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 11 May 2022 17:50:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-11T17:51:30.841Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>November 14th 1933 — May 9th 2022</p><figure><img alt="Ajji" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*S2SDa8bHsgmtwl_u" /></figure><p>Mrs. Singh was born in Karachi (<em>Karanchi</em>), which was still part of India (<em>Bhārat Gaṇarājya</em>) at the time, to Govindam and Kamala Iyer. She had two older brothers, two older sisters, and one younger brother. She was born into the Brahmin (ब्राह्मण) caste, the priest caste. Her father worked as a customs official at the then critical British Empire port of Karachi. Her mother was a homemaker.</p><p>As a child in Karachi, she excelled as a student and had a happy and comfortable life. In the early 1940s, her father sensed that trouble was coming; he moved their family to Mysore in South India, just one year before the partition in 1947, which divided British India into the independent nations of India and Pakistan. Mysore (<em>Mahishūru</em>) is in southern India, quite far from Karachi.<em> </em>They settled in Vontikoppal, one of the busiest suburbs of Mysore. Suddenly, here, the family was very much without money. Luckily, during the partition, she was not forced to see much violence.</p><p>Still, as a teenager, her family was still without money. At about 18 or 19, she broke with tradition and arranged her own marriage to Bharath Raj Singh, who was both her professor and not a Brahmin. Due to breaking with tradition to have a love marriage, she was viewed in a scandalous light by some. She was “bold.” She was a “force of nature.” Saraswati and her husband went on to have a blissful and devoted marriage of 34 years, teaching and mentoring thousands of students at Mount Carmel and Bangalore University. Their household was filled with music, laughter, dogs, kids, and books.</p><p>She and her husband moved to Bangalore (<em>Bengalūru</em>) some time after. Mrs. Singh was very much a modern woman. She worked as a tutor to gain income and studied at Mount Carmel College for Girls, which is still open today. There, she was an English teacher as well.</p><p>In 1979, she decided to do something unexpected again. Her guru Sathya Sai Baba told her to go to America. She saw this as a chance for a better life for her children, Eswar and Ashok Priyadarshan. Incidentally, Saraswati and her husband created a new surname <em>Priyadarshan</em> for their kids in order to drop their caste associations. They were making a bold statement at the time about shedding caste and regional affiliations in traditional India.</p><p>She succeeded on the GRE to start a new career at Boston University. At BU, she taught freshman English. To make money, she worked jobs at Hahnemann Hospital (now St. Elizabeth’s), Woolworth’s, and Brookline Savings Bank. During this time, she spent a lot of her time in the Greater Boston area. She brought over her husband and two sons, who received full scholarships to BU. Here, her sons would not have to deal with being treated differently (due to their parents’ marriage). They could pursue their dreams.</p><p>In the 80s, Eswar pursued Computer Science at BU. Ashok studied Hotel Management and Computer Science. Ashok married Deepa Ganguly. Eswar met and married Kathleen Downing. During this time, Mrs. Singh worked at BU and lived at St. Mary’s Street.</p><p>In the late 80s and 90s, her grandchildren were born. To Ashok and Deepa, Manisha, Vishal and Divya Priyadarshan. To Eswar, Sunjay Priyadarshan with his first wife Kathleen, (stepson) William Corbett and Sarah Priyadarshan with his second wife Jill Eskenazi. Mrs. Singh relished becoming a grandmother (Ajji). She showed them the value of boldness and intelligence. She was deeply loving. She eventually moved back to India in 1986. Sadly, her husband passed away in 1993.</p><p>Eventually, she came to live near Eswar &amp; Jill in California. She remained strong and sharp through her later years and survived COVID-19 twice. She passed away peacefully on the night of May 9th, 2022. She is survived by her sons, their families, and countless friends. Her memory lives on with them.</p><p>She described her life as repeatedly “jumping over water” to get where she wanted to go. While she frequently adorned Saris and was a devout Hindu, she was not a traditional woman. Telling her “No” was not an option. As stated, she was a force of nature who paved the way for future generations to blaze their own trails.</p><ul><li><em>Authored by Eswar Priyadarshan, Jill Eskenazi, Sarah Priyadarshan, Sunjay Priyadarshan, and William Corbett.</em></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d156a13cccf6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[It’s a Wonderful Life]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jayp900/its-a-wonderful-life-7b3d1b639ccb?source=rss-7c17065de2c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b3d1b639ccb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christmas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[butterfly-effect]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[its-a-wonderful-life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[life]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[meaning-of-life]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jay Priyadarshan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 28 Dec 2021 21:31:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-28T21:32:51.646Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When a flower blooms, it joins an ecosystem in which all living things are interconnected. Flowers are often small. You might have to get up close to see them. You may get even closer to smell them. Flowers show us every color we could imagine. We must pause to fully see them. And we can never fully know them. They are beautiful. They stop time if only for a moment.</p><p>Flowers are alive, and part of their beauty is their fragility. They can break. They, like all living things, die. It’s easy to break them. Sometimes we do it by simple accident. Sometimes on purpose, as we ponder our fate. But we don’t usually want to harm them. When someone destroys a garden, it is out of primal rage that they soon regret acting upon. When Jem destroyed Mrs. Dubose’s garden, he apologized and became a better person. He also kept the flower she gave him.</p><p>When you are a child, a flower can be your whole world for a time. It is a treasure from the ground. It is all the wonder you can contain. You don’t want it to die. When you pull it from the ground, you don’t realize that could kill it. You are taking it because you love it and you want to continue to share in its beauty. Maybe you feel yourself in the innocence of the petals. You want to freeze it in time, maybe like you’d like to do yourself.</p><p>If the petals on your flower fall off, it could be a horror. A catastrophe. You are young. Something so small can consume you.</p><p>—</p><p>A man stands all alone on a bridge as snowflakes dance down around. He is lonely and cold. He is lost. He no longer knows how to go on. He feels his life has no worth. Unbeknownst to him, he is not alone. In fact, far from it.</p><p>His name is George Bailey, and he is the main character of Frank Capra’s 1946 <em>It’s a Wonderful Life</em>, perhaps the greatest film of all time.</p><p>I have to assume you know the story.</p><p>George was a young boy in Bedford Falls, NY, dreaming of seeing the world. He was a brave and good child. He saved his brother’s life. He stopped a grieving druggist from making an irreversible mistake. He knew early what mattered most.</p><p>When his father dies, he has to put his plans on hold to run his father’s Building and Loan so that the corrupt Mr. Potter will not take it over.</p><p>He stays in Bedford Falls while his brother goes off to college. He hopes to travel when his brother returns, but his brother returns with a job offer and a wife. George realizes he may never leave. Right before his honeymoon with his new wife Mary, there is a run on the bank. They forgo their honeymoon to save the Building and Loan. He knows he will never <em>see the world</em>.</p><p>His life is permanently here now. He uses the Building and Loan to help people get affordable homes. He raises a lovely family in a renovated house. He refuses to cave to Mr. Potter. He rebuffs corruption.</p><p>Perhaps he sees the world in a different way than he ever meant.</p><p>When his buffoonish Uncle Billy loses $8,000, George turns to Potter for help, offering up his life insurance. He knows he could be in legal trouble and has nowhere else to turn. Ever the snake, Mr. Potter calls the police on him.</p><p>He yells at his family. He gets drunk. He prays. He drives to the bridge, out of options.</p><p>—</p><p>Before we move on, we must look closely at the beauty of this film. There are many angles from which we could approach this.</p><p>For one, it is visually lovely and oddly soothing. It is black and white with blankets of snow. It is tidy outfits and lived-in homes. It looks <em>real</em>.</p><p>The music is also wonderful and ties in well with the moods of the film. “Buffalo Gals” sung under the moon by George and Mary is a particularly transcendent moment. It creates <em>love in the air</em> almost literally.</p><p>Speaking of, the characters in this film again feel very real. It looks like we are seeing parts of their real lives. The romance between George and Mary is very compelling. Their fierce embraces are cathartic (and I am usually bored by heterosexual romance). One of the best scenes of the film is the “honeymoon” staged by friends in an abandoned home they would come to live in. Since they could not travel to somewhere far off and tropic, George and Mary’s friends attempt to recreate a bit of this locale in a dining room. It conveys a sense of community and compassion that might be the climax of another film. Instead, it is just one of the many heartbeats of this movie.</p><p>On the other side of things, Potter is a legitimate villain. He is truly loathsome. He is not the kind of villain you want to see fail. He’s the kind you want to see die. And of course, there is Clarence. We’ll get to that.</p><p>At the center, George is a very good person. He is selfless and loving. He takes care of his family and his community. He gives up his dreams because he knows what is right. He resists the temptation of corruption. In a key scene, he comes home to his sick daughter, Zuzu. She has a flower with her, but some of the petals fall. She hopes he can fix it. He slyly pretends to “fix” it, while actually just pocketing some of the petals that have fallen off. He returns it to her, healed. Here, a parent knows just what small trick play to make their child feel safe and loved in a world that is often unsafe and unloving. He knows what it means for his child to be able to sit and stare at her flower. He knows what it means to a child for a flower to break.</p><p>—</p><p>On the bridge, as George stares down into the abyss of the running water, Clarence appears. The opening scene of the film sets us up for this scene. We know Clarence is an angel sent to help George at his most trying moment, as all in Bedford Falls pray for him. We know that a successful mission means Clarence receives his wings. What we don’t know is how he will do it.</p><p>Clarence, of course, jumps in first, forcing George to briefly break out of his despair and save him. Recovering in the bridge operator’s office, Clarence reveals who he is to George. His <em>Guardian Angel</em>. It is a pivotal scene. The physical comedy of the bridge operator as he reacts to what Clarence says is riotous. George humors Clarence, but clearly does not really believe him. George, talking to Clarence, does realize he does not want to die. Rather, he wishes he’d never been born. He believes he has ruined the lives of everyone in his life.</p><p>Clarence realizes this is his Ace. He grants the wish. What follows is the pair returning to Bedford Falls and George slowly realizing that Clarence actually made that wish come true. At first, he can’t believe it and just assumes something is wrong with other people as they fail to recognize him. More haunting are the changes to Bedford Falls without him having ever been born.</p><p>Without him, his brother Harry falls in the ice and dies. The soldiers he saves in WWII die. Mr. Gower becomes a social pariah. Martini never opens his bar. Mary is alone. His mother runs a boarding house. Uncle Billy is institutionalized. Violet is caught up in illicit activities. Bedford Falls is Pottersville, which now resembles Las Vegas more than a charming small town. No one in his town has the life they would have had. In the ecosystem if Bedford Falls, it turns out, George Bailey was critical to the well-being of others. Without him, life is, well, not wonderful.</p><p>—</p><p>In 1952, the visionary Ray Bradbury helped coin the term “butterfly effect” with his short story “A Sound of Thunder,” in which a small change (accidentally killing a butterfly) is made in a time travel journey that significantly alters the present. When the butterfly effect is at the center of a discourse, explicitly or implicitly, we typically focus on the origins of major events and major changes. We like to think about the potential for one person to change the world.</p><p>It’s a cool, trippy way of thinking that invites deep historical and sociological exploration. It is a way to zoom in and zoom out on the passage of time. It can be inspiring, but also very dark. It is heavy and heady.</p><p><em>It’s a Wonderful Life</em>, released just a few years before the aforementioned short story, is a masterpiece, in part, because it does not really engage in said discourse. It does not a draw an unfathomable and untenable line between one person and the course of history. The trouble with butterfly effect narratives that do engage in such lines of thought is that they are purely speculative. They are stories that exist basically to make you think, “Wow, this is pretty nuts” — and not much else. You can’t prove them so you can’t disprove them. They are spectacle. You can’t even call them a thought experiment since, well, what is the hypothesis? <em>If this thing happened then this other thing might happen a long time later? Okay?</em> You just have to imagine it, I guess. It’s cool, but it’s not really transcendent. There’s not much you can do with it. It’s just trippy to look at.</p><p><em>It’s a Wonderful Life</em>, on the other hand, looks at a much smaller scale. It does not tell George, “Hey! If you weren’t born, the global supply chain would collapse! The world would be run by fascists!” It doesn’t try to shock him (or us) with geopolitical nightmares and dystopias. It points to specific moments and specific people and says, “Look at how you touched them. It seemed small, but it meant everything.” It says: “This person is happier with you than they would be without you.” “This man can support his family because of you.” “Your hometown is better because of you.”</p><p>It shows us how we matter to each other. How we make each other’s lives wonderful by being us. You don’t have to travel everywhere, do everything, make headlines to make an impact. Wealth is measured in ways it cannot be measured, since wealth is how you have graced another person’s life, which can’t be quantified. It can only be.</p><p>—</p><p>In a small room, in a small town, with one other person, you can make a world of difference for someone, even if just for a short time. You know, your daughter can only have a flower to happily gaze upon if you are born in the first place.</p><p>—</p><p>I give <em>It’s a Wonderful Life</em> five stars.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b3d1b639ccb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jayp900/rudolph-the-red-nosed-reindeer-58f4b0e5af0?source=rss-7c17065de2c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/58f4b0e5af0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christmas]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[queer-coded]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rudolph]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jay Priyadarshan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Dec 2021 17:20:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-21T17:20:59.227Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The stop-motion origin story of our dear Rudolph is a centerpiece of the Christmas season. It is practically nonsensical to imagine someone who celebrates Christmas not watching every December. I am sure even many non-Christmas celebrators watch it. It is sowed into out culture and provides magic and nostalgia. Santa, Rudolph, and the Grinch are basically the trinity of Christmastime pop culture figures.</p><p>Unlike some other fixtures of the season that we seemingly engage with because it feels required, this is actually a solid film outside of it being tethered to us by tradition.</p><p>First of all, it is very funny. Burl Ives provides humor right off the bat with jokes that hold up remarkably well. He points us towards “the first castle on the left…as a matter of fact the only castle on the left.” He also invites us to “pull up an ice block and lend an ear” before beginning his narration. Ives sets a tone of light-heartedness balanced with true meaning. Some Christmas movies are too “funny” (but not funny). Some are too sentimental. This one finds the middle quite nicely.</p><p>Throughout we also have the lovely dynamic between Yukon Cornelius and The Abominable Snowman. Yukon is an absolute masterpiece of a supporting character. His fake-out death scene is a legitimate gut-punch. For some reason not explained, he refers to the Abominable as a “Bumble.” We are thus treated with some wonderful lines from Yukon about our Bumble. When the Abominable’s teeth are removed (after Hermey pretends to be a pig by <em>oinking</em> to get his attention), Yukon tells us we now have a “mighty humble Bumble!” When he brings the new, toothless Abominable to the Castle, he tells the others it is safe — he is a “reformed Bumble.” And, of course, when asked how he survived the fall with the Abominable, Yukon tells us, “Bumbles bounce!” It’s the kind of characterization and writing that is both divine and human at the same time. You can’t imagine a world without it.</p><p>All of this is to say that Rudolph is a <em>mostly</em> wonderful and very grounded film. It has some knock-out humor and moments of real transcendence.</p><p>At the heart of the movie is a story about difference and the acceptance and possibility of embracing of difference. Rudolph is shamed and banished for his red nose. At the same time, Hermey the elf is humiliated and marginalized for his desire to be a dentist rather than be a toy-maker. This story is also very queer. Rudolph is too bright and shiny to fit in. Hermey has stylish blond hair, a different appearance from the rest of the mostly identical elves, and would just <em>love</em> to be a “dentist.” I have to wonder if the film’s creators were aware of this in 1964.</p><p>While the story is about Rudolph, the Hermey character is arguably more compelling and central to the plot’s movement. While Rudolph’s difference is framed as an unacceptable birth defect that <em>could</em> be hidden, Hermey’s entire character goes against the grain and expectations of society. You get the sense that Rudolph would fit in if he could; however, Hermey would not.</p><p>After they have both been banished from their respective sections of North Pole society (and left somewhat willingly, realizing their lack of belonging), they find each other. In a lovely scene, they sing about being misfits and not fitting in. They question their station in society, but also embrace each other and their status as misfits. They are able to create a space in which they can celebrate being different (Hello! Gay!).</p><p>They two journey away from the North Pole, eventually being partially on the run from the Abominable. They join Yukon along the way as well. Among the three, we even have a rough layout of some sort of queer male spectrum. Hermey is decidedly <em>femme</em>; Yukon is much more <em>masc</em>. Rudolph is somewhere in the middle (which is fine, but makes him a less entertaining character since the film does not explore this tension). Together, they are able to successfully navigate their way back home (including a scene where they all share a bed!).</p><p>On the way, they come across the Island of Misfit Toys. There is a lot to unpack with this one. It is inhabited by toys that are “incorrect” in some critical way (there is no explanation of how such glaring manufacturing errors were made). My favorite is the Charlie-in-the-Box since his “mistake” is not even physically built into him — they just gave him the wrong name (??). These toys long to be discovered by Santa so they can be delivered to children and make them happy, their apparent sole purpose in life.</p><p>Once again, I have to ask, were these toys made in Santa’s workshop and then discarded? Were they made somewhere else? How did this happen?</p><p>The island is ruled by a flying lion named “King Moonracer” (Hello! Gay!). This creature is kind but stern and does not allow out trio to move in there. As a result, they feel themselves misfits even among misfits. Nonetheless, Moonracer is benevolent and wants to find a way to help the misfit toys and wants to help the trio.</p><p>The IOMT is a queer and safe (ish) space, but the toys do not want to stay there. They want integrate into mainstream society, BUT (!) they do not want to change themselves. They want to be loved and seen as capable of providing love to children. I know we are talking about toys here, but that is a pretty powerful message to send. The scenes in this setting are truly some of the most powerful.</p><p>As I said, the trio finally come home to complete their journey, realizing they can’t hide forever.</p><p>Unfortunately, their re-acceptance into society is hard to see as a total win. They do receive apologies from all guilty parties and are allowed to be themselves. But their key moments are when their differences are framed as <em>useful</em>. Hermey uses his dentist skills to defang the Abominable. Rudolph’s bright nose saves Christmas because he can light the way through the blizzard (side-bar: They have magic in the North Pole but have <em>zero</em> ability to create <em>something</em> that can do what Rudolph’s nose can do? Santa was <em>really</em> just gonna <em>cancel</em> Christmas?).</p><p>So our heroes are accepted despite their differences (Yay!). Their differences are even embraced (Yay!!). But, part of what makes them accepted is that they have a use in society (Erm…). Hermey has a role in the military industrial complex (fighting snow monsters) and the healthcare system (fixing elf cavities). Rudolph has a role in globalized capitalism (ensuring the supply chain can continue in hazardous conditions). I know I’m kind of exaggerating, but am I wrong? I mean, is this actual queer acceptance? Why can’t we just be loved without fulfilling any societal role? And why do the other characters get to just get away with banishing Rudolph and Hermey? That was pretty brutal. Santa at least deserved to be dragged on Twitter for his behavior (#SantaIsOverParty).</p><p>This film sends a pretty clear message that marginalizing people is wrong and dangerous to them. Their differences should be accepted. But it shoots itself in the foot with its added layer of different people’s acceptance being partially contingent on them fulfilling a societal function.</p><p>A truly and radically queer-accepting space would mean loving queer people simply because they exist.</p><p>I give <em>Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer</em> three-and-a-half stars.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=58f4b0e5af0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“Do They Know It’s Christmas?”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jayp900/do-they-know-its-christmas-71e67f98fd40?source=rss-7c17065de2c7------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/71e67f98fd40</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[john-green]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christmas]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jay Priyadarshan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 04 Dec 2021 23:07:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-12-05T20:55:01.950Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I’ve been having trouble getting into the Christmas spirit this year. It’s probably because it’s been a fucked up year (and continues to be) for many obvious reasons. It’s kind of a bummer since I usually get really into the Christmas spirit. So I decided I am going to take another approach to getting into the season. Inspired by John Green’s <em>The Anthropocene Reviewed,</em> a book in which he rates (out of five stars) and reviews a variety of seemingly unrelated things from modern society (such as Canada geese, air-conditioning, and hot-dog eating contests), I have decided to review some of the common and popular ephemera of the Christmas season.</p><p>I am starting with the well known charity single “Do They Know It’s Christmas?,” released in 1984 by the Band Aid supergroup to raise money for the famine in Ethiopia.</p><p>A lot of people who were alive then really love this song. It is a Christmas staple for many Baby Boomers I know. It was obviously very financially successful, raising 8 million pounds. It’s a nice idea, I guess; and I hope that money actually was used to provide relief and sustainable supports for those in need. But we need to look at these lyrics.</p><p>It starts off relatively innocuously, touching on how Christmastime can be a hard time for some people even if it’s great for you and me.</p><p>Then, one of the guys from Duran Duran says, “<a href="https://genius.com/4405599/Band-aid-do-they-know-its-christmas/Theres-a-world-outside-your-window-and-its-a-world-of-dread-and-fear">There’s a world outside your window / And it’s a world of dread and fear</a>.” Okay. Hm. So this British guy is now claiming that Africa (they never reference Ethiopia, only “Africa”) is full of “dread and fear.” Our first stereotype is invoked and it’s a doozy to unpack. The songwriting (by an award-winning and commercially successful white guy) frames Africa as The Other, completely separated from the Anglo world. And not only that, he characterizes it as a hopeless and fearful place. Portraying The Other as the opposite of the ostensibly cheerful and Christmas light-adorned West is not new, but it’s still not okay because it is insulting to the real humans who live on the massive and diverse continent living full and complete lives. It frames “Africa” in the Western imagination as so desolate that all you can do to “help” is buy a CD single of a pop song. It in fact absolves Western audiences of feeling any need to actually engage in the societal structures that are creating and maintaining a variety of issues in Africa (that are not in reality delinked from issues in the West).</p><p>Was that too much of me? Oh well. Next line.</p><p>Following Duran Duran’s unnuanced characterization, Sting says plainly, “<a href="https://genius.com/4610428/Band-aid-do-they-know-its-christmas/Where-the-only-water-flowing">Where the only water flowing</a> / <a href="https://genius.com/2490701/Band-aid-do-they-know-its-christmas/Is-the-bitter-sting-of-tears">Is the bitter sting of tears</a>.” It is true that many regions in Africa are dealing with water insecurity and that millions of humans lack consistent access to water. But that is true elsewhere. And water insecurity is not an issue inherent to it being Africa. Infrastructure issues, corruption, and climate change all contribute to water issues around the world. However, the language in the song suggests Africa is just some sort of cursed fantastical place that is completely devoid of water. In reality, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_of_Africa#/media/File:Africa_Precipitation_Map.svg">it does rain in Africa</a>, and many African countries border the ocean or contain large bodies of water. Now, I know pop music doesn’t consistently deal in reality and frequently relies on extremes and hyperboles to make a point. However, this is flat out misinformation that once again suggests “Africa” can only be saved by Western water saviors. Again, the real solution is global action against climate change and sustainable and locally-engaged infrastructure that can provide water access. The lyrics also suggest “Africans” sit around all day crying, which ignores actual non-profits and NGOs and human beings working in the real world to find solutions.</p><p>I am not a geopolitics expert, so it is hard for me to assess the best ways to solve the ills that Africa (and many other parts of the world) face. I can say many of these issues are due in part to the disasters of Western colonialism. So does the West have a responsibility to help? Perhaps. But it seems likely that the people of the variety of regions of Africa need to be (and already are) involved and leading the charge in fixing issues such as water insecurity. An attempt by the West to completely fund and control this will not provide any sort of independence or agency. Band Aid completely misses the concept that, for a geographic region to thrive, the people living there need to be the ones making decisions since they know it best. Western involvement solely via throwing money may not help.</p><p>Next is a line about “chimes of doom” that is too patronizing to even engage with. Literally shut the fuck up.</p><p>Next we get to Bono’s brutal and dark sarcasm that is meant to … guilt us into donating? He quips, “<a href="https://genius.com/4610424/Band-aid-do-they-know-its-christmas/Well-tonight-thank-god-its-them-instead-of-you">Well tonight thank God it’s them / Instead of you</a>.” Here we have Paul Hewson of Ireland perched on his goddamn ivory tower that he’s built smack in the middle of “Africa,” rolling his eyes at Europe and America, middle finger up and tongue out. What is the goal of a line like this? Why are these incredibly wealthy white Europeans pointing their fingers at Western consumers with one hand and holding out their other hand waiting to accept donations? The previous lines attempted something like sympathy — but here we have pure cynicism. It’s ruthless and ugly. Hewson sounds more interested in stroking his own self-righteous boner that actually helping people.</p><p>This all leads us to the astonishingly delusional, vicious, and racist chorus. Here it is:</p><p><a href="https://genius.com/4665414/Band-aid-do-they-know-its-christmas/And-there-wont-be-snow-in-africa-this-christmas-time-the-greatest-gift-theyll-get-this-year-is-life-oooh-where-nothing-ever-grows-no-rain-or-rivers-flow">“And there won’t be snow in Africa this Christmas time<br>The greatest gift they’ll get this year is life (Oooh)<br>Where nothing ever grows, no rain or rivers flow</a><br><a href="https://genius.com/4665479/Band-aid-do-they-know-its-christmas/Do-they-know-its-christmas-time-at-all">Do they know it’s Christmas time at all?</a>”</p><p>Let’s start with the facts. It <a href="https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/does-it-snow-in-africa.html">does in fact snow</a> in Africa. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/sep/11/giraffes-in-the-snow-south-africa-karoo-desert">Here</a> are some giraffes in snow. Next, let’s talk about “nothing ever [growing].” While it’s true that there is a lot of land in Africa that is hard to grow plants in, things do in fact grown in Africa. According to Brittanica,</p><p>“Agriculture is by far the single most important economic activity in Africa. It provides employment for about two-thirds of the <a href="https://www.britannica.com/science/continent">continent’s</a> working population and for each country contributes an average of 30 to 60 percent of <a href="https://www.britannica.com/topic/gross-domestic-product">gross domestic product</a> and about 30 percent of the value of exports.”</p><p>Things do grow there! <a href="https://i.guim.co.uk/img/media/64070cec6ff281d3621a92a261b164e99af907f1/0_87_3600_2160/master/3600.jpg?width=1020&amp;quality=85&amp;auto=format&amp;fit=max&amp;s=e44e509e18bab975abe56f40acb7b9dd">Here</a> is a farmer in Niger, for example.</p><p>We already talked about rainfall actually happening. Do I need to prove rivers exist in Africa? Literally one of the longest and most famous rivers on Earth is in Africa. AND, it is partially IN Ethiopia! (I am talking about the Nile River, duh). So far, every single thing said in the chorus is wrong.</p><p>Now we get to one of the most disrespectful lines in the history of recorded music. And it’s the song’s fucking title. Let’s talk about it. First of all, almost half of the humans in Africa are Christian. That’s hundreds of millions of people we are talking about. If we want to zoom in on Ethiopia, its most popular religion is Christianity. Next, the literacy rate in Africa is approximately 66%. Now, I know that is not everyone, but it is about 2 out of every 3 people. I don’t have a photograph of anyone in Africa holding a calendar, but I have been to Africa and I was always able to tell what day it was without placing a call to the West to ask. So, I think we can assume humans in Africa have calendars (and the Internet! and television!). And we know a whole lot of them can read and practice Christianity. Christmas is kind of a big deal in Christianity. If you practice Christianity, Christmas is not one of those little holidays you might skip or forget about. So I think we can say with certainty that, yes, to answer your question, they do know it’s Christmas in many, many places in Africa. In fact, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUkmXnvwpXQ">here</a> is video evidence of Christmas being celebrated in Africa.</p><p>So, again, we get Africa being portrayed as a monolithic and distraught place where everyone is basically on their deathbed and unaware of anything. This portrayal relies on racist and xenophobic ideas and removes any ounce of humanity. It ignores how the West played a major role in causing a lot of the issues throughout Africa and suggests Africa is and always has been this sad and dead place with nothing. It completely ignores geopolitics and colonialism. It ignores racism and human right violations. It also ignores the fact that millions of different people lead complete and varied lives throughout the continent of Africa.</p><p>Now, you may reply and say I am being too harsh. It was just a song and they were just trying to raise money. What’s the harm?</p><p>Okay, let’s talk about it. How often do you engage with media of any sort that portrays Africa in any way? How often are the narratives of Africa ones of tragedy and hopelessness? Yes, there are major issues in Africa. But there are major issues everywhere. Presenting Africa with only this narrative suggests it is a failed continent where no one’s life has any meaning. It also completely Otherizes Africa to the point where it may as well be another planet. Africa is actually not that far away. And things that happen there are connected to things that happen here in the US. It’s not right to continue to peddle a disrespectful and simplistic “Africa of the mind” to Western audiences. As I said, it suggests the problems of “Africa” are due to it being Africa — that con-fuddled circular logic ignores real history and ignores the fact that many nation states and bad actors need to be held responsible and accountable for the corruption and social issues that do exist in the CONTINENT of Africa.</p><p>This song was intended as charity and was made by I hope well-meaning white Europeans. I am sure they heard about the famine in Ethiopia and felt compelled to use their vast resources to help. I don’t expect white Western people to live in state of constant self-flagellation and guilt for the horrors of colonialism and racism. People want to help other people and don’t always know how. People are busy with their own lives and their own problems, and paying a small fee in exchange for a catchy pop song is an easy way to feel like you are doing <em>something</em>.</p><p>BUT, is it too much to expect charity to be based in reality, kindness, and factual information? Can’t we expect intelligence of people? Can’t we expect people to learn about the complexities of the world around them? Is that too much to ask? Africa has issues and it has beauty and it has millions and millions of people living lives that are full of meaning. It is harmful to only see it through one lens. We in the West can do more good for people in need by being more fully aware of their reality and seeing them as humans equal to us. Charitable transactions don’t seem prone to creating sustainable solutions. Education, empathy, collaboration, and understanding of difference (and similarity) are much more important.</p><p>The last thing I will say is that I have been to Africa three times in my life. Twice as a tourist and once as a student studying abroad (which is still kinda tourism, but that’s another story). I met a lot of people there. They were not all the same. They were in fact all unique from each other. They were mostly very kind and interested to speak to me. They all had interests and passions and loves. Not a single one of them was sitting in the floor crying into an empty cup.</p><p>I give “Do They Know It’s Christmas?” zero stars.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=71e67f98fd40" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>