<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by the infamous Brad on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by the infamous Brad on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 06:42:34 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Miasma (A Hellenic Religious Rant)]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/miasma-a-hellenic-religious-rant-1aa2406e189f?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1aa2406e189f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[paganism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Apr 2020 12:26:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-29T12:26:22.122Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I woke up early this morning in the rare mood to write a religious rant. Something I don’t do all that often. For one thing, I’m really not all that religious. For another, I don’t think jeremiads ever do much more than make jeremiahs feel better about themselves. And most of all, it’s not like more than a tiny fraction of one percent of the country are Hellenic reconstructionist pagans like me, so why should anybody care about my religious opinions.</p><p>Screw it. Today, I’m going to rant anyway. If nothing else, consider it a description of how I’m feeling, what I’m thinking, today. Set some time aside if you’re going to read this; it’s going to be long.</p><p>- — — — -</p><p>The pre-Socratic Greeks had their own version of what it meant for a place — a town, a state, a country, a whole people — to “lose the mandate of Heaven.” And that thinking was wrapped up in the question: what does it mean when you can look at a place and see, with your own eyes, that it’s a place whose luck has run out? What does it mean when all of a sudden, nobody gets a lucky break?</p><p>Well, here are a few things the pre-Socratic Greeks knew (or thought that they knew, if you want to be picky) about their gods. The gods are not, really, nice people. Nor are they terribly virtuous. They don’t need to be: as indestructible, immortal beings they’re almost completely immune to any consequences for their actions beyond fleeting embarrassment. But the gods know that blood, not ichor, runs in our veins, and that we dine on food and drink, not ambrosia and nectar: if we neglect virtue and engage in vice, we don’t escape permanent consequence.</p><p>And the Greeks knew (or we would say “knew”), as a matter of historical fact, that after the collapse of the Bronze Age civilizations, there were a couple of generations where these strange immortal beings, who looked like us but who had powers far beyond that of mortal humans, walked among us. Sometimes invisibly, appearing suddenly. Sometimes in disguise. Sometimes openly, showing their consistent, recognizable faces.</p><p>And during that 100 or so years around 1000 BCE, the gods did two things. For one, they sired the progenitors of most of the ruling families of the Peloponnese, from Athens to the Balkans and all along the Aegean coast. Supposedly, anyway. Take that with however many grains of salt you wish. But more importantly, they did one other thing, and that’s just randomly tossed around minor miracles or handed out lost knowledge, to reward virtue if they happened to see any or, more rarely, to punish vice.</p><p>(You know, much like they say about the devas. Or the angels. Or the fae folk. Perhaps not a coincidence.)</p><p>The rewards for virtue and the punishments for vice are in this life, but they’re random … no amount of virtue entitles you to a reward, no level of vice guarantees punishment. But if a god happens to notice, reward and punishment may be forthcoming — not something that any but the most superstitious were eager to have occur, frankly. (The Greek word for “superstition” is “theophobia,” a crippling fear of offending some god.)</p><p>But, the philosophers said that the gods told us, this is where all luck comes from. Hard work is its own reward, virtue is its own reward, but sometimes despite all your virtue and hard work, it’s just not enough, bad stuff is going to rain down on you. But if a god who noticed your hard work and virtue sees that despite that, bad things are about to happen to you, they can and sometimes do nudge things in your favor. They can enable you to perform far above your ordinary level, temporarily, they can give you good ideas that come into your head out of nowhere, they can cause a plague or a storm or an earthquake to just barely miss your home. They don’t have to! But if they like you, if you impressed them, sometimes they do.</p><p>So what does it mean when this stops happening over a large area, when a place’s luck runs out, when the only rewards they get are the ones that they work for, and they lose those rewards to every unlucky break that comes along? Miasma. It means they have miasma.</p><p>Miasma’s a funny word because it’s been repurposed, at least twice, to mean other things. We use it to describe a lingering unpleasant odor. In the European Renaissance, they used it to describe endemic plagues. But in the original Greek, it doesn’t mean either of those things. It means, for lack of a better word, sin. But only a very specific kind of sin. Or maybe crime is a better word.</p><p>You see, the gods told the Greeks that when people commit crimes, and (importantly) get away with it, they emit a substance that lingers in the air, invisible to any human sense organ — miasma. And when the criminal is caught, convicted, and punished, it sucks miasma out of the air. And the gods cannot, physically cannot, help anyone in a place where the miasma level reaches a certain concentration.</p><p>Some philosophers remembered it as that the gods can’t see through it, that it’s like an opaque cloud between us and them. Smarter ones, I think, said that oh, no, the gods can still see through it. The few, rare crimes that can get you sentenced to an eternity of suffering in the pits of Tartarus are still seen and punished in the afterlife. It’s that once the miasma level gets to a certain concentration, the gods cannot help — and the people in that place then find out just how much pitiless bad luck the gods were protecting them from.</p><p>But here’s an important thing to know about miasma. Not all crimes emit the same amount of miasma. Just as the Catholics have mortal vs venal sins, the pre-Socratic Greeks believed in greater vs lesser miasma. Where did they draw the line?</p><p>The rich and the powerful emit far, far greater amounts of miasma when their crimes go undetected or unpunished.</p><p>When a poor person, or a paid laborer, or a small farmer, or a small business owner commits a crime and it goes undetected or unpunished, it creates, for the gods, something akin to a small, localized unpleasant smell. When someone of hereditary nobility (and therefore allegedly divine ancestry), or possessing great wealth, or in a position of political power commits a crime, however minor, and it goes undetected or unpunished, it pollutes the whole ecosystem; when enough such crimes go unpunished, then no luck is possible anywhere within the reach of their influence.</p><p>- — — — -</p><p>And on my rare darkest and most pious days, I think that one entirely plausible explanation for the back to back to back disasters of the last 20 years is that America is choking in miasma. That 40 years of Reaganomics and our two-tier justice system, 40 years of impunity for the wealthy, have made us a nation whose luck has run out. That we are a nation that will get no lucky breaks until the crimes of the wealthy and powerful are detected, and justice delivered, as reliably as the crimes of the rest of us.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1aa2406e189f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Maybe the best tabletop roleplaying game ever written?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/maybe-the-best-tabletop-roleplaying-game-ever-written-f7f19cb16a2?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f7f19cb16a2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[world-of-darkness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[changeling-the-dreaming]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[rpg]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fantasy]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 May 2017 04:18:58 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-28T07:18:46.276Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>A review of Onyx Path’s <em>Changeling: The Dreaming 20th Anniversary Edition</em></p><p>For those of you who slept through the late ’80s and early ’90s (or weren’t around yet), a tiny little company called White Wolf wrote a series of very punk-themed horror-rip-off tabletop roleplaying games (like Dungeons &amp; Dragons, only more so) in a shared setting called “The World of Darkness:” Vampire: The Masquerade, Werewolf: The Apocalypse, Mage: The Ascension, Wraith: The Oblivion, Changeling: The Dreaming, and Hunters Hunted. It was a series of stories with a heavily-foreshadowed, designed-in end date: on July 4th, 1999, at the end of the Week of Nightmares, all of the player characters in all of their games lost the game, and the human soul was permanently destroyed, giving birth to a world without hope, art, happiness, or any more than a semblance of free will.</p><p>A few years ago, an even smaller company called Onyx Path, including some of the original White Wolf team, bought the rights to issue a limited set of sequels and updates to the first five games, to be called World of Darkness 20th Anniversary Edition. These rewrites basically offer a choice of two basic campaign settings: the disaster at the end of the ’90s never happened, or it did happen, but only wiped out that generation of supernaturals; a new generation since then has revived the story. And the fifth and final core rulebook, <em>Changeling: The Dreaming 20th Anniversary Edition,</em> is about to come out. (As a Kickstarter backer, I have an early review copy; this review is based on that edition. I don’t expect any substantial changes.)</p><p>Interestingly, this may be the most relentlessly <em>playable</em> game that White Wolf’s “World of Darkness” setting has ever seen. If you were around for the hot mess that was <em>Changeling: The Dreaming 1st Edition,</em> this probably sounds completely unbelievable, but stick with me.</p><h4>Where Changeling Originally Fit into the World of Darkness</h4><p>One of the most fascinating things about the game, to me, was that there were two almost completely non-overlapping plots going on, with so little overlap between them that even though there was an attempt to make cross-over play possible, it was almost impossible to make the two stories fit together.</p><p>Over on the one side was Vampire, Wraith, and Hunters: three games that started out as a straight-up Anne Rice ripoff, and never wandered far from gothic novel horror tropes: the vampires are immortals, cursed by the Judeo-Christian god and hoping to ultimately escape his wrath or achieve redemption; the wraiths are dead souls in Purgatory trying to reach across to the living world to avenge their deaths or protect their loved ones; the hunters are a mixture of religious exorcists and hereditary psychics trying to hunt (mostly) ghosts and vampires.</p><p>But on the other side was a genuinely weird meta-plot that I fell helplessly, hopelessly in love with, and so did many others. In this alternate history, there was a time when priests of any religion could reliably call on their gods for miracles, when sorcerers and their spells openly supported or opposed human kingdoms, and when monsters and fairy tale creatures roamed the woods. And the reason that none of us remember that is that all of the evidence has been hidden, edited from history, by a rogue group of sorcerers who successfully altered the fabric of reality, rendering faith <em>and </em>magic almost completely useless, a world where only science and engineering still work.</p><p>That conspiracy now calls itself The Technocracy, and what they didn’t know, what they still didn’t know, is that this would have two horrible effects on the world. One is that if they ever succeed in convincing enough of the human population that magic and religion aren’t real, the human soul will die; without at least some belief in magic and/or religion, neither love, nor art, nor kindness, nor happiness are possible. Without at least some magic or faith in the world, even free will dies, for the rulers as much as the ruled, both carrying out their roles for so long as our species survives without deriving even an ounce of pleasure from any reward. And two, science and engineering alone, deprived of magic and faith, aren’t enough to hold back the personified forces of entropy and decay, both physical and moral.</p><p>Now, I don’t believe any of these things, but I think they make a great “what if,” a great fictional universe to explore, and a great way to confront real-world parallels and ask “no, really, what would I do?” A world where everything that “everybody knows” is wrong, a world where the people who go along to get along are, unknowingly, the very people who are going to get us all killed, is a great setting for telling tales of moral heroism versus moral cowardice.</p><p><strong>Mage: The Ascension: </strong>Back in the day, my all-time favorite of the games was <em>Mage: The Ascension.</em> If Mage had had a more marketable, more traditional name, it would have been “Sorcerers and Cyberpunks.” On the bad guy side: the forces of global capitalist imperialism, their cyborg agents, and various genetically engineered freaks; on the other side, a rag-tag band of losers who still believe in faith, magic, or discredited scientific theories, and can still make those things “work” by breaking the consensus laws of physics, albeit at high personal risk.</p><p>Gameplay sessions typically involved spying on the forces of global capitalist imperialism, trying to strike at weak spots to undermine the public’s faith in science as their savior, alternating with desperate defensive retreats when the government agencies and corporations unleash super-science horrors on the players in retaliation.</p><p>It was fun! But not just anybody could run it, and not that many more players could play it well, because it was <em>so weird.</em> It required a broad depth of reading and incredible imagination just to picture the setting, your characters, and what was going on.</p><p><strong>Werewolf: The Apocalypse: </strong>Its predecessor game was probably my least favorite. The setting was much simpler. Lycanthropy isn’t an infectious disease, it’s a hereditary condition (that sometimes skips generations) in both certain sub-species of wolves and certain families of humans. Although they don’t really understand The Technocracy, the werewolves are all too aware that the rise of science tipped the balance of reality against them, leading to their species’ almost complete extinction, surviving (barely, if at all, and in small numbers) on native reservations and in protected wilderness areas.</p><p>Gameplay sessions could best be described, I think, as a heavy-metal album-cover version of <em>Captain Planet.</em> Packs of werewolves would attack any industrial capitalist incursion into wild places or on native lands, but especially the ones infected by entropy demons that hardly anybody else in the World of Darkness were noticing, the forces of The Wyrm, for whom pollution wasn’t just a byproduct of scientific advance but a way to deliberately spread sickness, both physical and psychological; a conspiracy within a conspiracy to infect all living things with cancer and to destroy every bit of vestigial conscience so that the warped, twisted survivors would rob and kill each other without hesitation.</p><p>I feel like it’s due for a come-back, but back in the late ’80s, early ’90s, it was almost completely unplayable, and hardly ever played. In my experience, the main obstacle was that so much of the story was set in deep wilderness or on native reservations: two settings that your average tabletop gamer knows little or nothing about. It may literally be easier to ask your average gamer to imagine an ultra-tech space station full of cyborgs and genetically engineered monsters than to get them to visualize a babbling brook, far from any road or trail, halfway up the side of a mountain in the Ozark National Forest. Also, I think it’s safe to say that how ever much retro-licious fun it sounds like now, the audience for “heavy metal Captain Planet” is still pretty tiny, and was even tinier back then. And that leaves only …</p><p><strong>Changeling: The Dreaming:</strong> Although they don’t know it by name, fairy tale creatures certainly felt it when the Technocracy conquered the world. Over the course of the 13th and 14th centuries, they were hunted to extinction on Earth. Many escaped back into fairyland, into a distant city in the land of dreams called Arcadia. A few tried to survive on Earth by inventing a new kind of changeling: a fairy tale creature would possess an infant human’s body, instead of replacing them wholly, in hopes of peeking out from time to time. But over the centuries, nearly all of them were exterminated. But the back to back exuberance and “anything is possible” energy of Woodstock and the moon landing blew open the gates to fairyland just enough for a new wave of explorers and outcasts from fairyland to sneak into our world again, to become a new generation of changelings. Only to be crushed out of existence, not even so much by Technocracy killing machines as by the sheer crushing boredom and loss of hope of the late ’70s, the ’80s, and the ‘90s.</p><p>Your character starts as a child, probably somewhere around 6–10 years old, who still believes in fairies, and that’s why your fairy-tale soul can suddenly break free long enough to give you the look of a fairy-tale creature — that only other fairies can see, everybody else just sees a weird human kid. And it unleashes your fairy-tale magic: one or two simple mostly-useless tricks. Plus a free-form magic system — but the skill costs to learn it are so high that your character will <em>literally</em> die of boredom before you get enough XP to do anything interesting with it. And if you stave that off, the magical energy (“glamour”) costs are so high, and glamour recharge is so time consuming, that you’ve got a spell-casting budget of maybe 2–3 spells a month. Without your magic, all you have to fall back on are the resources and strengths of … a slightly above-average 8 year old.</p><p>Oh, and also, anybody trying to design a campaign for Changeling ran into another hard-to-bridge problem. There are monsters that hunt Changelings. You don’t stand a chance against them. So there really isn’t anything for your characters to <em>do</em> (when you’re not running and hiding) except play childish pranks on each other like the weird dysfunctional human kids you mostly are. I don’t know very many people who thought that was much fun.</p><p>There are people who think that Changeling didn’t belong in the World of Darkness because it was too childish and cheerful. Those people obviously didn’t read any of the rules. Changeling was <em>punishing.</em> So much so that I know lots of people who read it, who loved having read it, who use it as metaphors for so much of their real lives, but I don’t know of a single campaign that lasted longer than 4 sessions.</p><p>But <em>Changeling: The Dreaming 20th Anniversary Edition</em> is in final editing right now. Those of us who participated in the Kickstarter already have the final-draft copy PDFs in our hands; it should be available to the general public in at most a couple of months. And it fixes so much of what’s wrong with the old Changeling that it may have turned it into the best actual game, the most playable and entertaining game, in World of Darkness history.</p><h4>What Did Changeling 20th Anniversary Fix?</h4><p>Well, let’s start with the simplest change first. The “protect childhood innocence from adult boredom” theme was adorable but, in practice, whiffed of everything wrong with using child soldiers. They got rid of that. Your human host discovers his or her new powers around the same time as other World of Darkness supernaturals, typically in their late teens or 20’s, sometimes even later. So even when you don’t have magic to fall back on, your characters aren’t helpless.</p><p>They also made some substantial changes to the magic system. They made sure that every character class has at least one actually useful spell that they can cast as many times as they want with no glamour cost. Better yet, they made the rest of the magic system a lot more useful at low levels by introducing a new system called “unleashing.” If you have even one level in a category of spells, you can cast any spell in that category. All you have to do is surrender control: tell the game master roughly what you want to achieve, spend the glamour, and roll the dice, at an even lower difficulty and with at least one more dice than you would normally have. But if you succeed <em>too</em> well, you lose control of the spell, and while it succeeds, it does so in a way that will complicate your life later. So as you level up, you can split your points between learning new categories of spells and learning better control.</p><p>When I first read the rules, it looked to me like they’d kept the brutally punishing energy-recharge rules. Your glamour pool typically trickle-charges at one point a night (if nothing goes wrong), enough that you might be able to average as many as two spells a week (if nothing goes wrong). You can recharge your whole glamour pool at once … but for a starting character, it takes at least 2 weeks and might take up to 4 months of doing nothing but that, so it’s nothing you can count on. Which disappointed me … until I finally understood the newly clarified rules about your alternate magically energy pool, called dross.</p><p>You see, they simplified and clarified the rules for your party to leave the mundane world and enter the dreaming world. There, your spells cost a lot less glamour. And of course, you can use your non-spell skills, your ordinary combat skills, to hunt monsters, too. And if you take the time to search the corpse of every monster you kill in the dream lands, each character can harvest enough little bits of magical fur, or feathers, or claws, or teeth, or coins, or gems, or candies, or other little bits of dream-stuff to power 2–3 more spells instead of drawing on your own glamour pool.</p><p>They also finally made it clear what the dream lands are <em>like,</em> and that does more than all of the above to make the game more playable. The Near Dreaming, the easiest part to reach, is the parts of the dream lands that are parallel to the mundane Earth, and can be divided into cities versus rural areas. The cities are … well, frankly, they’re the movie Cool World. They don’t say so, but read the description, then pop your Cool World DVD in and watch it (and show it to your players). The rural areas are … wait for it … a generic D&amp;D medieval fantasy setting! So what your characters basically do is play any other tabletop roleplaying game setting (except that some of it is in Cool World instead of medieval world), going on quests and hunting monsters, and harvesting materials from them that you can take back to the real world to make magic even easier there.</p><p>Why would you go back to the real world? Ah, they also clarified a system called Nightmare, also called Bedlam. You see, about every 10 or so spells you cast, you gain a point of Nightmare, and one of your temporary willpower pool points becomes “poisoned” as it were; if you use that temp willpower point, you go insane. But how many times do you spend your last temp willpower point? I don’t remember anybody ever doing so in any campaign, people hoarded them for emergencies. So 10 or so spells later you poison another one. Still no big deal, but you’re having to watch your willpower spending a little carefully. Keep piling up nightmare until you have as many Nightmare points as the size of your Glamour pool? And you enter Bedlam, go permanently insane, flee permanently into the dreaming, and become a non-player character monster.</p><p>So how do you draw down Nightmare and prevent Bedlam? By returning to the real world and doing one very specific thing. Remember that system I mentioned for recharging your glamour pool all at once, even if it takes weeks or months? It works by using your mundane skills, and whatever magic you can afford, to make life better for any Dreamer, any human being who’s still trying to use their imagination to make the world a better, happier place. (They’ve broadened the range of dreamers, and ways you and they can improve the world, a lot since the earliest edition, too — now you’re not restricted to inspiring artists.) But you can choose, instead of using that moment of relief and inspiration for your subject to refill your glamour pool all at once, to use it to draw down one full Nightmare level.</p><p>And that combination makes it the easiest campaign to design and run. Powerful versions of fairy-tale creatures run amok in the Near Dreaming, “murder-hobo’ing” their way through the monsters that prey on dream-creatures and human dreams and rifling their corpses for stray magic; when that starts to take its toll on them, they escape into our world and look for human “dreamers” to spend all that saved-up magic on, to make our world a better place. When that saved-up magic gets low and mundane boredom starts to take its toll? Back to the fantasy realm!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f7f19cb16a2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Thanksgiving in (alternate universe) Kabul]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/thanksgiving-in-alternate-universe-kabul-a422ba7d720f?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a422ba7d720f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[refugees]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alternate-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[matt-ruff]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-mirage]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[syria]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 13 Mar 2017 18:42:23 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-03-13T18:51:21.987Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>(A <em>The Mirage</em> dream …)</p><p>It doesn’t happen often, but every so often I have yet another dream based on Matt Ruff’s book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/B005HF9CCU"><em>The Mirage</em></a><em>,</em> and they’re often the most vivid dreams. Like this morning’s.</p><p>In my dream, I’m an elderly computer tech, on early retirement for psych disability, living in the declining midwestern industrial city of Kabul, and the new President (former Senator) bin Laden has frozen all refugee applications from several predominantly-Christian countries in war-torn North America. That’s causing a lot of distress in Kabul, because my neighborhood in Kabul revived its economy, over the last couple of decades, by taking in refugees from war-torn countries all over the world, from America, Europe, Africa, and Asia, in various waves.</p><p>And I was playing on my computer while listening to a podcast, where they were interviewing three experts because of an idea that had come up, on the left, that maybe everybody in the UAS, or at least all liberals, should celebrate Thanksgiving this coming November, in solidarity with oppressed Christian refugees.</p><p>The first person interviewed was a pro-refugee activist, part of the Thanksgiving Campaign. She argued that there’s nothing explicitly Christian about Thanksgiving. All People of the Book worship the same God, Allah, and arguably the Americans have invented something wonderful: a day when all of the People of the Book should get together with their families to be thankful for Allah’s blessings, without any sectarian historical baggage. Don’t we all have things to be thankful to Allah for?</p><p>The second person interviewed was a civil libertarian who disputed the first person’s argument that Thanksgiving is non-sectarian. He pointed out that it is an explicitly Christian holiday, but then went on to remind the interviewers that ever since the ratification of the Constitution, the United Arab States has guaranteed freedom of religion to <em>all</em> People of the Book. When asked if Muslims (or, for that matter, Jews) should celebrate Thanksgiving or merely tolerate it, he pointed out that Muslims don’t really share the American experience, that the holiday doesn’t mean the same thing to us that it does to them. He also raised the issue of cultural appropriation: Muslims should leave Thanksgiving to the Christians, not mock them (however unintentionally) by reducing their culture to turkey dinner and Puritan costumes.</p><p>The third person interviewed was, of course, a spokeswoman for the bin Laden administration. She was particularly angry that this argument for a pan-sectarian Thanksgiving was coming up now, and called it a pro-Crusader attack on the President by people who were trying to bring Canon Law to the United Arab States. The first Thanksgiving was, after all, she pointed out, a celebration of a victory by Christians over the Native Americans, and the current Thanksgiving was war-time propaganda during the American Civil War, an appeal for Christian unity. She said that anybody who thinks that Muslims should celebrate Thanksgiving is siding with Dick Cheney against their own people at a time when Dick Cheney’s “crusader” terrorists from places like Texas were disguising themselves as Confederate refugees in order to create sleeper cells for more crusader terrorist attacks. She accused the left of forgetting the November 9th, 2001 terror attack on the World Trade Center in Baghdad.</p><p>I came away from it with the familiar thought that as a secularist Afghani, if Christians aren’t safe in bin Laden’s UAS, neither am I, and all too aware that refugees were the backbone of my community. I was thinking that you’d have to be an idiot not to realize that the refugees weren’t crusaders, they were the crusaders’ victims, fleeing from war — refugees are the most peaceful people, the most anti-war people, you’ve ever met, because they’ve seen the horrors of war up close. Some of them were even translators for our soldiers in Virginia, whose lives are at risk if we send them back to the Confederacy!</p><p>So I decided that maybe I should celebrate Thanksgiving this year, in my own secular, low-key way. No silly Puritan costumes, but maybe find an American-refugee restaurant that’s open that weekend and get some American food. Maybe with some friends. Maybe even try to find something to be thankful for, even if bin Laden is President.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a422ba7d720f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What I Decided to Do If It Happens]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/what-i-decided-to-do-if-it-happens-9ba27f0c13d6?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9ba27f0c13d6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[muslim-ban]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 30 Jan 2017 21:11:57 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-01-30T21:58:35.529Z</atom:updated>
            <cc:license>https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/</cc:license>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>If it happens, I won’t freeze up, because I rehearsed.</em></p><p>Before I get to the main subject of this essay, let me tell you a little bit about myself, in order to provide some context for my remarks. Ask anyone who’s seen me anywhere near the scene of a crisis or an alarm, and they’ll tell you that I don’t freeze up. Other people freeze up; in what seems to them like a tiny fraction of a second, I take action.</p><p>It wasn’t until I read a lot of Phillip Zimbardo that I realized why that is: other people don’t rehearse. I rehearse. I learned, as a tiny little child and victim of non-stop violent bullying, that I had to rehearse, because if I waited to start planning until the violence began, I wasn’t going to make it.</p><p>Then I lucked into a giant pile of Cold War era nuclear war preparedness pamphlets, which I loved just as science fiction, but they changed something subtle in me. I didn’t have to be encouraged to take part in tornado drills or fire drills, not any more, even as early as 3rd grade or so. I knew, from the bottom of my heart, that there are many things that can go wrong. They probably won’t go wrong. But if you don’t prepare for them, and they do go wrong, you’ll screw them up.</p><p>Tornadoes have become my go-to example, because I live on one corner of the map marked Tornado Alley. Lots of people that I know ignore tornado alarms, because, they’ve learned from long experience, they’re “always” false alarms. In this town, someone who hears a tornado siren and says, “there probably isn’t a tornado and even if there is, it’s probably not going to hit me” is almost certainly right. Even when there is a tornado, only at most a few dozen of the city’s tens of thousands of homes will be hit. The odds are way in their favor.</p><p><em>But if you wait until the tornado is touching down a few houses away, it’s too late for you to take shelter.</em> We actually had a really vivid example of this a few years ago, when a tornado ripped through a broad swath downwind from the airport, wrecking dozens of houses. One guy who was out driving in it nearly died when a building got blown over onto his car. He saw that the tornado was heading for his neighborhood, so he called his girlfriend and yelled at her to get into the basement, right now. When she came to, she had broken legs and a concussion — she’d waited too long, and as she was halfway down the basement stairs, the house fell on her. And because wreckage and downed power lines had closed off her neighborhood to even ambulance traffic, she had to crawl to the nearest hospital. In an interview with the local paper, she counted herself among the lucky ones, and she’s right. She counted on nothing bad happening. And suffered for it. And nearly died.</p><p>I don’t assume that every building I’m in will be hit by a tornado. I will probably never be hit by a tornado. But every building I spend more than a few minutes in, I look for and memorize the route to a basement or a sheltered inner room. I don’t assume that my kitchen or my furnace will catch fire. They probably won’t. But in every place I’ve lived for the last twenty five years or more, I’ve had a fire extinguisher bolted to the wall in the kitchen, and I’ve memorized at least two routes out of every room. I also always have at least a pair of slippers near me no matter where I am, no matter what I’m doing. And speaking of that last one, I didn’t assume, during the Ferguson riot aftermath, that police would chase protesters into my neighborhood and tear gas the whole block. But when they got within a mile of here, I had a bag hanging on the doorknob with my essential medicines and I kept my comfortable walking shoes on at all time.</p><p>If you wait until the tornado is about to hit to plan your safety route, you won’t make it. If you wait until the fire breaks out to buy a fire extinguisher, the house will burn down; if you also waited until then to plan your escape route, you’ll burn with it. If you wait until the riot over-runs your neighborhood to pack your bug-out bag, you won’t self-evacuate in time. Those things will probably never happen to you. <em>But if you’re prepared and if you rehearse, you can stop worrying about “what if they do?”</em></p><h4>So Let’s Talk about Trump’s Immigration Order</h4><p>I had a <em>rough</em> weekend, mentally and emotionally. There are two businesses on my block that I know with great confidence are owned by Muslim refugee families. There’s another one that I suspect of being Muslim-refugee-owned on my corner. If I’m right, I can see three of them from my usual bus stop. There are another two within half a mile. So is the Islamic Center of St. Louis.</p><p>The order banning travel back into the United States by green-card holders, the actual forced deportation of green-card holders who happened to be at airports when the order came down, shocked me to my core. These are legal permanent residents, the most vetted of the vetted. Most of them fled here because they were <em>victims </em>of terrorism; not a few of them were let in because they were our <em>allies</em> against terrorism. Barring them from traveling to the United States is, as multiple courts have reminded the administration over the weekend, flat-out illegal. Not only was that illegal order followed, at least some customs officials are <em>still</em> obeying that illegal order, even in the face of federal court orders to the contrary.</p><p>But because I’m the kind who prepares, because I’m the kind who rehearses, this didn’t just shock my conscience. It left me feeling shockingly unprepared. If lawful permanent residence doesn’t mean anything to Trump’s enforcers, then I could, any time I’m at the bus stop, see Immigration and Customs Enforcement trucks sweep down on one or more of the businesses within half a block of that bus stop and start rounding up families.</p><p>And as the god is my witness, I hadn’t rehearsed for that. I had no idea what I was going to do. And having read Zimbardo’s <em>The Lucifer Effect,</em> specifically the chapter on how humans decide what to do when surprised, I knew what that meant. If I didn’t make up my mind what to do and rehearse it, I would freeze up. Then I would look around to see what other people were doing, and other people would be, like me, frozen up. So I would try to remember when I’ve been in this situation and do what got me rewarded in the past or do the opposite of what got me punished, but I’ve never been in this exact situation before. If I were normal, what I would do next is “what I’m told” by anybody who looks like an authority figure. (Fortunately, as the Man of Concrete’s son, I’m inoculated against that. My dad would actually beat you if you used the “I was following orders” excuse and somebody could have been hurt.) Failing that, I’d try to remember some story of someone who looked like me who was in a similar situation and was the hero and do what they did in the story — but by that time, it’d be too late already. So forget about the next step, actually try to think through the situation and plan a rational response; by that time the ICE trucks with their illegally seized victims would be gone.</p><p>It probably isn’t going to happen. If it does happen, it’s not statistically likely to happen in front of me, I don’t spend that much time standing in front of Muslim refugee-owned places. (Maybe I should.) But if it did happen, I was going to screw it up.</p><h4>What Are the Options, and What Did I Decide?</h4><p>As someone who has no real dependents, and who long-ago checked off every item on his bucket list, and who is a white middle class old guy, I have a lot of freedom of action and only a couple of constraints: I do not want to do anything that makes it worse for the victims. And I want the people who come after me to be proud of whatever I did. Those principles guided me through the AIDS crisis. They guided me through the Satanic Panic. They’ll guide me now.</p><p><strong>I could do nothing.</strong> I could look away, I could walk away. I’m white, I’m not a Muslim, I’m an old man, I have that privilege.</p><p>When I brought up the question in the neighborhood Facebook group, “what are we as a neighborhood going to do,” I got 70+ expressions of solidarity and no concrete plans other than “I’m trying to stop it from happening.” But we have two people who keep repeating the same administration propaganda line: it’s not going to happen, and it’s okay that it’s going to happen because they might deserve it. Except for the very rare occasional bigot, Tower Grove South loves its refugee neighbors. Looking away, walking away, doing nothing, is siding with the bigots. I can’t be proud of that. So I won’t do it.</p><p><strong>I could try to use force to rescue the family that the feds are attacking.</strong> But no matter how I game that out in my head, no matter how my mental rehearsal goes, there is no way that this ends well. Even if I were to inspire enough other people on the street to join me, there’s no way the family being rounded up could escape, nowhere for them to hide that the feds wouldn’t find them.</p><p>And it would probably go worse than that. If I assault federal officers who are, in their deluded or self-preserving minds, engaged in a counter-terrorism sweep, the guns are definitely coming out. I could get shot. Which is no big deal; if that could result in that family’s escape, I’d pay that price. But once the guns start going off, the victims could get shot. Kids could get shot. That’s a risk I can’t take. It’s too likely to end in a slaughter. I won’t have any part of that on my conscience. I can’t be proud of that. So that’s not an option.</p><p><strong>I could non-violently resist.</strong> And that’s a tempting option. If I started carrying handcuffs when I go out, I could be ready to handcuff myself to the vehicle, so they’d have to cut me loose before they could drive off. If enough of us blocked the vehicles, we might buy time for reporters or lawyers to show up and shame the feds out of seizing this family. It might work. It probably wouldn’t get anybody killed. I’m still thinking about it. But … it’s a lonely corner, most of the time, no more than half a dozen people waiting for a bus, usually fewer. Even if they all rushed in with me, even they were all willing to endure “pain compliance techniques” to buy time for the Muslim family, I just don’t see it being enough time. If I think it’ll work, I’m ready to do it. But I just don’t see it working.</p><p><strong>I can witness.</strong> And dear god, that doesn’t seem like enough, but it has helped others. I have a camera phone. I never use Facebook Live; if I were to go FB Live, it would catch at least some attention. When the cops forcibly take my phone away (and the odds are that they will), if I don’t smash it, they’ll use it to delete the video — but we’ve seen, in the last year, that when the cops illegally delete FB Live video, Facebook can restore it from backup. I can’t shame the feds into refusing an order to expel or incarcerate the innocent Muslims in front of me, at least, I probably can’t. But with the video I produce before I get beat up and my phone seized or smashed, maybe you can shame them into not seizing the next family.</p><p>So I’m practicing and rehearsing that. I probably won’t need to, just as I probably won’t have to dig myself out from under tornado rubble or fight a kitchen fire or flee from a riot on a moment’s notice. But if it does happen, I’m ready. So now, after a weekend of fear and fret, I can stop worrying.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9ba27f0c13d6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[So, Who Would You REALLY Have Voted for in Germany in 1930?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/so-who-would-you-have-really-voted-for-in-germany-in-1930-de674375029a?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/de674375029a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[donald-trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 02 Mar 2016 05:10:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2016-03-03T05:04:49.896Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>It might not be who you think you would have voted for.</em></p><p>It’s another election year in the United States, another year of people arguing about whose candidate is the most like Hitler, another year where almost none of them actually know anything about pre-WWII Germany.</p><p>The question is meaningful, if only barely so. Political issues, and political party alignments, haven’t changed all that much since the 1800s. Roughly the same positions and issues are called “left” versus “right” in 2016 as they were in 1930s Germany, or 1920s Spain, or for that matter 1800s France when the whole “left versus right” terminology was coined. So you can map issues onto parties.</p><p>But because Hitler is our go-to trope for “irredeemable monster evil” the political terms, the words we use to describe various parties and various positions, have been so politicized that, if you want a meaningful comparison, you can’t say that party X was “liberal” or some issue or party Y was “socialist” on some issue or party Z was “conservative” on some issue.</p><p>So let’s look at who was on the left in the election that brought Hitler into the government, and who was on the right, not in terms of labels, but in terms of what they stood for. Compare their issues to your own issues, their stances to your own stances, and then ask yourself honestly, if you believed then what you believe now <em>and as someone who didn’t know what was going to happen next,</em> who you really would have voted for.</p><p>And before I get started, let me point out something about massively multi-party governments like the German government during the period between World War I and World War II. <em>In such a system, the word “party” doesn’t mean what it means in 21st century America. It means what we mean by “caucus.”</em> After each election, when it came time to appoint someone to run the country and to appoint many people to various government offices, the parties voted more-or-less in lockstep: all the left-wing parties voted for the Social Democrat candidate and all the right-wing parties voted for the Center candidate; whichever one won (almost always the Social Democrat) handed out cabinet positions and such among the various parties (think “caucuses”) in his coalition (think “party”).</p><h4>On the Left: the Social Democrats and Their Allies</h4><p>When Germany first became a democracy by the Kaiser’s last decree on his way out of the country after World War I, the Social Democrats were practically the whole legislature, because “there should be a legislature” was their original defining issue: they were the pro-democracy party. But it didn’t take long for more parties to form, because once there was a legislature, everybody has to take actual sides on issues. But in almost every election until 1930, the Social Democrats were able to parlay their incumbency and popularity into a leadership position. Then came the world-wide Great Depression, and just like voters in a lot of countries, they took the blame.</p><p>But the <strong>Social Democrats</strong> had a pretty consistent set of positions:</p><ul><li>They supported a market economy, but …</li><li>They also supported a tax system that mostly taxed rich people and very-profitable corporations, and …</li><li>They supported the right of unions to bargain collectively and to strike.</li><li>They encouraged investment in Berlin and other major cities, in order to promote the already-strong industrial export economy, and encouraged farmers and their children to move to the cities if they needed work.</li><li>They supported a strong national defense in order to protect against revolutionary movements within and to deter invasion by France or Russia, but …</li><li>They supported compliance with the Treaty of Versailles until or unless a peaceful exit from it could be diplomatically negotiated. And finally …</li><li>They supported strong separation between church and state, in order to prevent any resurgence of violence between Protestants and Catholics, and to discourage violence by either of the above versus Jews.</li></ul><p>The <strong>Independent Social Democrats</strong> were a splinter party that broke away from the Social Democrats over the issue of national defense. They agreed with every single plank of the Social Democratic platform but one: they opposed nearly all military spending, believing that Germany would be safer without a strong national army, safer pursuing a peaceful policy of neutrality (like Switzerland), that Germany couldn’t afford an army strong enough to stand up to Germany’s many enemies. Unsurprisingly, they preferred that money be diverted from soldiers and defense contractors to schools, clinics, and hospitals.</p><p>And finally there was the <strong>Communist Party of Germany</strong>. They were a pro-Soviet reform party, which means that they renounced Communist revolution as a tactic, but supported constitutional amendments that would replace the existing government with one in which nobody who had employees or who earned the majority of their income from rents or investments could vote. In practice, they voted in lock-step with the Independent Social Democrats.</p><p>If you would have voted for any of the above parties, congratulations: you would have voted against Hitler.</p><h4>On the Right: the Center Party and its Allies</h4><p>For most of the time between 1918 and 1930, the <strong>Center Party</strong> was the leader of the opposition groups; after World War II, it absorbed most of the rest of the non-Nazi right-wing parties and became the Christian Democratic Union party that runs Germany now. Originally, the Center Party stood for opposition to everything that the Social Democrats stood for, including democracy itself — the party ran, in part, on a platform of bringing back the absolute monarchy and making the elected government merely advisory, as it had been under the Kaiser. But once that was a moot point, they carved out a niche for themselves as Germany’s rural conservative party, running on two issues:</p><ul><li>They stood for direct government funding of Catholic education (and not for schools run by any other religion) and for taxpayer-funded pensions for Catholic priests and nuns (and not any other clergy). They insisted that this was necessary to preserve German culture and virtues against Protestant and Jewish “tolerance” for deviance, what they were the first to call the Culture War. And …</li><li>They proposed reducing government support for big-city industries in favor of more subsidies and price-supports for struggling German farmers, both to promote rural virtues and to free Germany from dependence on imported food.</li></ul><p>On almost every other issue, they deferred to their coalition partner, the <strong>German National Party</strong>. In practice, the German National Party supported the Center Party’s religious policies, but they did so knowing that if the Center Party was in power, they would vote against it the same way that the Independent Social Democrats voted against every defense budget. (And, in fact, it was mostly by reaching out to the National Party that the Social Democrats were able to pass military funding bills.) The National Party agreed with the Social Democrats on some issues:</p><ul><li>They supported a market economy.</li><li>They supported a strong national defense, for the same reasons as the Social Democrats, and subject to the same restriction:</li><li>They supported obedience to the Treaty of Versailles and only diplomatic efforts to seek relief from it.</li></ul><p>But on business and the economy, they were in opposition:</p><ul><li>They supported lower taxes on investors and on business, believing that this would stimulate more investment and a stronger economy.</li><li>They wanted union strikes made illegal again; they wanted the government to intervene on behalf of companies against workers.</li></ul><p>And finally, there were the <strong>National Socialists</strong>, or, as they came to be called, the Nazis. In practice, they voted in lock-step with the National and Center parties. They did not run for office on a platform of “here is how we think government should work” as much as on a list of complaints about the government, both Social Democrat and Center, that they felt were not being addressed:</p><ul><li>They wanted Germany out of the Treaty of Versailles, by force if necessary. They blamed the Social Democrats in the World War I era advisory legislature for the loss (the “stab in the back” theory). They insisted that if Germany threatened to go on the attack if the treaty’s sanctions weren’t lifted, then the weak, soft, peace-loving British and French and Americans would surrender and lift the sanctions.</li><li>They demanded stronger action against the Communists, who they felt had gotten off easy after a failed communist revolution in 1918; that the Communist Party of Germany voted in lock-step with the Social Democrats “proved” that the Social Democrats were traitorous stooges of Moscow. And, …</li><li>They blamed all of the above on the Jews, and promised an unspecified “final solution” — usually interpreted by the press as meaning “mass deportations.” They accused the Jews of subverting Germany’s traditional Christian religious values, of plotting with Germany’s enemies, of planning a campaign of pro-communist terrorism. They told the public that the other parties were naive: the next World War had already begun, and Germany was losing.</li></ul><p>If you would have voted for any of the above parties? <em>You would have voted for Hitler.</em> Because when the votes were counted here was the choice the parties faced:</p><ul><li>The Social Democrats won the election. But they didn’t get enough votes to form a government, even with the support of the Independent Social Democrats and the Communists. The only way they could form a government would be if the Center Party and the National Party agreed to a centrist coalition.</li><li>The Center Party and the National Party could not form a government by themselves. The only way that they could have a center-right government would be if Hitler and his Nazis would agree to form a coalition with them, and that was unthinkable: a vote for Hitler was a vote for a war that they knew Germany would lose. And besides, the man’s race-baiting was intolerably ignorant.</li></ul><p>And so Hitler himself cut the knot. Even though his party came in 2nd in the elections, even though it was the largest right wing party, he didn’t insist on forming a Nazi government. He offered to hand the government to the Center Party in exchange for one purely symbolic position, the chancellorship: a job that mostly consisted of going to state funerals and cutting ribbons, except during national emergencies, when it incorporated the job that we would call FEMA director.</p><p>Then came the Reichstag Fire, which Hitler insisted was the first terrorist act of a pro-Moscow communist uprising to come. Then came the declaration of national emergency. The next election was held with Nazi death squads in the streets, murdering anybody they suspected would vote for any center-left or left-wing party. The next election after that was never held until we held it for them, after millions of people had died.</p><h4>So If Today’s American Candidates had Run in 1930 Germany</h4><p>If you compare our remaining American 2016 presidential candidates to the positions of the various parties in the 1930 German national elections, I think it’s pretty clear:</p><ul><li>Hillary Clinton would be the Social Democrat.</li><li>Bernie Sanders would be the Independent Social Democrat.</li><li>Jill Stein would be the Communist.</li><li>Ted Cruz would be the Center Party candidate.</li><li>Marco Rubio would be the Nationalist.</li><li>Donald Trump would be the Nazi.</li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=de674375029a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Muslim Panic, Satanic Panic?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/muslim-panic-satanic-panic-1ab30f9952e0?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1ab30f9952e0</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Feb 2015 19:01:37 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-03-07T09:48:51.534Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Are New Atheist authors and leaders trying to pull the same awful crime that Neopagan authors and leaders tried back in the late 1980s?</em></p><p>Despite <a href="http://www.thebaffler.com/blog/nuances-nonbelief/">what Stuart Whatley wrote for <em>The Baffler</em> today</a>, I don’t think that it’s at all coincidental that the latest anti-Muslim hate crime was by someone who self-identified, online, as a Dawkins-style “New Atheist.” Whatley is complaining about <a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/local/wp/2015/02/11/chapel-hill-killings-shine-light-on-particular-tensions-between-islam-and-atheism/">a <em>Washington Post</em> article</a> that said that the Chapel Hill murders were emblematic of the ongoing fight between the New Atheists and Muslims. Whatley’s annoyance at this, and his attempted refutation, can (I think) be entirely fairly summed up as “<a href="https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/no-true-scotsman">no true Scotsman</a>” crossed with “#NotAllAtheists”.</p><p>To that end, all I can say is the same thing that so many of us were taught last year in the brilliant feminist response to the #NotAllMen twitterstorm: #YesAllWomen. Not all atheists are bigoted anti-Arab, ant-Islam wannabe hate killers, but yes all Muslims have to fear New Atheists. After the New Atheist communities’ most prominent authors have spent the last half dozen years or so beating this drum, I don’t see how anybody can call the New Atheists anything <em>but</em> an anti-Muslim hate group. These are people who can’t be distracted from their message of anti-Muslim hate by oppression or violence from any other religious community, whether it’s the veto on public policy the Ultra Orthodox hold in Israel or the anti-gay secessionist rhetoric of Alabama’s fundamentalist Chief Justice or terrorist acts by Christian Identity groups or anti-abortion groups or anti-Islam terrorism by Buddhists in Sri Lanka. Nope. Try to bring any of that up, and they change the subject back to, “the Muslims are coming to kill us all!”</p><p>But there’s something in the WaPo/Baffler argument that makes me wonder if I know what that’s all about, something even more awful than ordinary bigotry or the lazy intellectual sin of falling for your own country’s war propaganda. Because I may have been through this before.</p><p>Remember the Satanic Panic, the great “Satanic ritual sex abuse” conspiracy theory, the claim that occultists were raping tens of thousands of children per year, and making those children murder tens of thousands of babies per year, with cover-up help from all levels of government, in order to create an army of brainwashed assassins for the anti-Christ? Remember the resulting police and media panic, of the mid ‘80s through the early ‘90s? I certainly do; I was one of the lesser victims of it.</p><p>Well, during the Satanic Panic I was directly or indirectly contacted by five different NeoPagan leaders, all of them much more prominent than me: Ar nDraiocht Fein’s Isaac Bonewits, Aquarian Tabernacle Church’s Pete Pathfinder, Circle Sanctuary’s Selena Fox, and Church of All Worlds’ Otter &amp; Morning Glory Zell, all of them demanding that I stop publicly questioning the evidence in the Satanic Panic scare and that I get on board with it, or they would do whatever they could to ruin me. Bonewits and Pathfinder were very explicit about why, too. They said that they didn’t care if the Satanists were guilty or not. They both said that they saw this as their opportunity to convince Christian America that we weren’t their enemy, by piling on a common enemy.</p><p>I told each and every one of them off, over the phone or in person or in writing. I told them that I was going to keep standing publicly with, and using my prestige as a board member of the Alliance for Magical and Earth Religions and as the founder of MagickNet along side of, the few Neopagan groups that were standing up for truth and justice, like Covenant of the Goddess and the Wiccan/Pagan Press Alliance. (I know I’m forgetting one, I always do.) For one thing, truth matters; seeking to get innocent people jailed (or worse) to protect your own skin is morally despicable behavior. Almost as importantly, the fact that so few of the persecuted victims of the Satanic Panic were even Satanists, or any kind of occultist, that so much of it was based on coerced testimony framing them for being Satanists, showed the folly of this idea: if they hate us, they’re not going to accept us as their allies, period; any Satanic Panic you feed will just eventually be used against you when they get around to destroying you.</p><p>So now it occurs to me to wonder. Because atheists are, in America, the single most hated belief group, with approval ratings on par with or maybe even below religious extremist terrorist groups. (Which, I have to say, strikes me as nothing less than deranged, but that’s not the point.) And atheists live in America, and Britain, two countries that have had thirteen and a half years of anti-Muslim war propaganda on almost every TV channel and radio station. How much of Dawkins’ and Hitchens’ and the rest of the New Atheists’ anti-Muslim hate is real and how much is opportunistic?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1ab30f9952e0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Notes from “The Inequality Inefficiency”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/notes-from-the-inequality-efficiency-a6549091280e?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a6549091280e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Sep 2014 08:48:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-09-01T12:15:12.411Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The odds are good, but the goods are odd? Men’s vs women’s experience in polyamory.</em></p><p>(Author’s note: Yes, this is a wall of text. There is a “too long, didn’t read” summary at the end.)</p><p>I should say, up front, that it normally is harder than pulling teeth to get me to go to a workshop on polyamory. I’ve known I was polyamorous longer than I’ve known the word; it took a science fiction author to explain to me, even in part, what jealousy was. Workshops are for people who have problems. Whenever people ask me to host a workshop, or to come to a workshop, I remind them of Dean Martin’s old joke, “I’m not an alcoholic, I’m a drunk. Alcoholics go to meetings.”</p><p>But St. Louis’s increasingly-famous sex-positive coffee house, <a href="http://shamelessgrounds.com/">Shameless Grounds</a>, hosted a two hour workshop with a family therapist who handles a way-disproportionate number of poly families, because she’s one of the only therapists in the region who isn’t judgmental towards polyamory, who doesn’t assume, when a poly family comes in, that the first thing that they need to do is give up polyamory. And her announced topic sounded interesting to me, and like one I have some strong opinions about: inequality of opportunity, for men, in polyamory.</p><p>The attendance was light; it was on a Sunday afternoon during Labor Day weekend, and it had been rescheduled on short enough notice that I know at least one person who couldn’t switch their schedule and there were probably more. Interestingly, even it was advertised as primarily for men and to address men’s problems with inequality in polyamory (but with women welcome as long as they understood that it wasn’t going to be primarily about them), there were slightly more women than men in attendance. And it had one more problem, an interesting one:</p><p>It was clear from the beginning that we, the audience, were frustrating the presenter. And pretty soon, it was clear why: the men in this particular audience had inequality problems that we wanted to discuss, including ones that affect both genders in negative ways. But she kept trying to quickly address points and move the conversation on, it was clear that there was one particular problem that she came ready to address, and determined to address, and it was clearly frustrating her that it wasn’t these men’s problem. Funnier yet: when she did bring it up, only two people in the audience said that they had that problem, and one of them was a woman. In fact, it seems to me that when she finally did come out and actually say what it was she wanted to talk with us about (an hour into a two hour workshop), it seemed to me (and still does) that she was conflating two somewhat unrelated problems, but she insisted that they are the same problem.</p><p>But because she was trying to be a good therapist and ask us what our problems were instead of telling us what our problems were, because she was being subtle and somewhat non-directive, when she opened the discussion, she opened it with what seemed to her to be a truism: obviously it is easier for women to find dates than men. I do not think that she was even vaguely prepared for the amount of push-back she got on this assertion.</p><p>The first piece of push-back she got was from me, and from two other members of the audience, who challenged her stats in one minor but important way: if you eliminate from the list of “people seeking partners” the people who are looking for one-time hook-up casual sex, suddenly the inequality of opportunity looks a lot less extreme. Pushed on that, she did back down a little, while still insisting that it was a problem, for reasons she wouldn’t explain at all until way later in the discussion.</p><h3>Breaking News: Attractive Men and Women Get More Dates</h3><p>Next, one of the triads in the audience had a member who did bring up exactly exactly the problem she wanted to talk about, one partner who was getting jealous, and depressed, over how many more dating opportunities her other two partners got. It was, in fact, a m/f/f triad. It wasn’t the guy who was complaining of being unable to find a date. It was, however, the member who was most overweight. Before I’d even heard from her, though, I had brought up at least three guys that I know, in the local poly community, who get at least as many offers as the women in their lives do—and what they all three have in common is that they’re both sensitive people who are also slender and conventionally attractive.</p><p>That turned into a surprisingly sensitive and unheated discussion of what attractiveness even is. It was made less contentious pretty rapidly when it turned out that we all had a pretty congruous definition of attractiveness: the combination of physical appearance and emotional intelligence. The physical appearance angle seemed to make people uncomfortable (or at least that was my impression, maybe I’m being unfair). So it got hand-waved pretty quickly, leaving me regretting that I didn’t get to bring up one famous poly advice columnist’s interesting observation that she almost never ran into complaints about being unable to get a date from anyone who flosses daily.</p><p>But at least some of us (admittedly, myself included) did get to bring up, and get some validation on the fact, that it’s not all that surprising that in most couples, it’s the partner who puts more hours of work into fitness, diet, personal style, and other appearance issues who gets more offers, and nobody disputed the observation that pressure to do personal-appearance work is still pretty gendered.</p><p>But no, what most people in the audience wanted to talk about at the most length, under the subject of attractiveness, was emotional intelligence: in particular, there was way more agreement than I was expecting that by comparison to most women, most men suck at emotional intelligence, defined (for this purpose) as sensitivity to the other person’s non-verbal and other emotional signals, skill at expressing emotion, and willingness to engage in emotional communication. For all that people wanted to talk about it, though, we spent a lot of time agreeing with each other on the basic parts of emotional intelligence that men in general most need to work on. We need to check our privilege and not try to steer conversations to what we want to talk about. We need to spend less time talking and more time deliberately eliciting comment from women who entirely fairly assume that most men don’t want to hear from them; women are conditioned from an early age to seek permission to speak, and men are conditioned from an early age to speak over them. And we need to get over or push through our conditioning that says that expressing emotion is efeminate, and will therefore cause us to be perceived as unmanly.</p><h3>Apparently, Compersion is Pretty Rare</h3><p>Once we had beaten that dead horse into the ground, at length, we all sat for a while and looked at the presenter, and she looked back at us. There was clearly some problem that she wanted to talk about, and she kept asking us open-ended questions trying to get someone to admit to having whatever problem that was. Finally, she got frustrated enough with her audience to do what she maybe should have done an hour earlier: tell us what the vague topic description on the coffeehouse calendar page meant to her, what it was that she came prepared to discuss.</p><p>As I said earlier, the presenter is a family therapist. She finally exasperatedly said that in her practice, as the therapist who sees most of the polyamorous couples and families in the St. Louis area who are seeking therapy or counseling, one problem makes up over half of her practice:</p><ul><li>Previously-monogamous heterosexual couple opens up their relationship.</li><li>Woman gets a lot more offers for casual sex than the man gets.</li><li>Man feels inadequate and unattractive by comparison.</li><li>Man wishes there was some polite way to ask woman to have fewer partners until he catches up.</li></ul><p>And she pushed us, and I mean that I feel like she pushed us <em>hard,</em> to admit that this was the problem we all came there to talk about.</p><p>Because she pushed us hard to admit any problem that even vaguely resembled this, she did get one man to admit that yes, his wife gets way more offers for casual sex than he does. Since she’s not looking for casual sex, this is no big deal to either of them. But, he continued, she has had one or two more romantic, emotional relationships than he has since they opened up the relationship, and, put on the spot, he admitted that he occasionally wondered if that meant that he was less attractive than his wife.</p><p>But then he pushed back, saying that <em>on the other hand,</em> he had done the math, and that she was also a lot more available for romantic relationships than he was, that because of the way his life was going (and he didn’t go into detail) that the extra romantic relationships were happening because she had more time for them, and more energy for them, and most importantly to them they weren’t actually interfering with much if any of the time he would have been spending with her, or the attention he was getting from her, irrespective of whether she was in another relationship or not. So he was pretty determined not to let it bother him.</p><p>The therapist really didn’t like that answer. She refused to accept that he really meant that, gave us a long rant about how the polyamory community pressures us to pretend to be more enlightened than we are, that nobody is really okay with a situation like that. But as she went around the room, trying to elicit more men’s confessions that we supposedly feel threatened by women dating other men when we don’t have a date lined up, the audience mostly just wasn’t having it. (I mentioned this to a friend afterwards who suggested that maybe families who end up in couples therapy or family therapy have different problems than people who don’t.)</p><p>But the closest the therapist got to agreement with her was that she did eventually get one man, and the woman who had started early in the workshop complaining about the fact that both her male partner and her female partner got more dates than her, to admit that what they seek from dating is an ill-defined feeling of “validation,” and that they did wish that they were getting as much of that as their partners were. In the half an hour, more or less, that the therapist was pushing us all on this, the conversation between these two, and the therapist, about what “validation” meant to them finally gave me the first hook on which to hang the beginnings of an understanding of a problem I’ve never had.</p><p>You see, I pretty visibly checked out of this part of the conversation about 10 or 15 minutes into that half an hour. And after everybody else had said their piece, the therapist came back around to me and challenged me to admit that I had these feelings, too. And I said to her that I had checked out of the conversation because the last 20 minutes or more of the conversation was in Urdu, completely incomprehensible to me. There has never been a day in my life that I wanted someone to be less happy than they were because it bothered me that they were happier than I was; if you’re happier than I am, my reaction is consistently, “thank god one of us is.” If you have more opportunities to get what you want out of life, good, go for it; I would hate myself if I asked you to turn down opportunities to be happy because it’s unfair to me that I don’t have as many opportunities. (Left unsaid: if, in fact, it is even unfair, and given my limitations, it probably isn’t.)</p><p>I was completely surprised and completely taken aback as to how hard she flipped out on me. In a loud, angry, and perhaps even insincere tone of voice she said, “<em>Congratulations.</em> I’ve heard that there are natural poly’s out there. You’re the first one I’ve ever met. So let’s go back to talking about problems that everybody else has.”</p><h3>“What Are You Trying to Get Validated?”</h3><p>And so they did, including yet more encouragement to the two people who’d both used the term “validation” to describe what it was that they were missing from their lives, who had both used the term “validation” to describe what it was that their partners got more of. The therapist kept asking, and not getting an especially coherent answer to, the question, “But what is it that you are trying to get validated?” And the way in which they talked about it may have finally given me my first understanding of the source of a lot of dysfunction I’ve seen in both monogamous and polyamorous relationships: a lot of jealousy, and a lot of anger, and a lot of dishonesty crops up when one partner feels a lot less attractive than the other.</p><p>It’s not necessarily the time or the attention or the intimacy that they’re reacting to, it’s the fear that if they’re less attractive than their partner, then someone more attractive will come along (if they haven’t already) and then they won’t be able to compete, at all, for attention, won’t be able to keep any part of the relationship. But more than that, and this is what was finally clear to me, no matter how much they laugh off the unwanted sexual advances that their partners get, no matter how reassured they are that they’re not going to be abandoned, they can’t get over feeling insulted.</p><p>Me? I don’t get insulted by comparisons. You tell me that someone else is more attractive than me, I’m going to say one of two things, “Yeah, I see what you mean,” or “well, I don’t see what you mean, but that’s a matter of taste.” Some people call that low self esteem. (Given that I equally often get accused of arrogance, I call it a nuanced appreciation of what I have to offer, both positive and negative. Feel free to disagree with me, everybody does. And you’re all wrong.)</p><p>The therapist then gave people in the room what she seems to be her standard advice to couples in such a situation: if one of your partners is feeling insecure or unattractive because you get more dates, maybe you need to accommodate that and go on fewer dates until they catch up. (<em>This</em> is poly-friendly relationship advice? I was stunned. And appalled.)</p><h3>The Men Hate OKCupid and Craigslist. The Women Don’t Get It.</h3><p>The therapist took the end of that conversation as an opportunity to segue back to a topic that she, and other women in the audience, wanted to engage us men on: her feeling that men could solve their problem with feeling unattractive and get more dates if they just got better at using Craigslist and, even more importantly, got better at using OKCupid, “Because face it, OK Cupid is where people go to meet dates now.”</p><p>What followed was the same pretty-generic advice that everybody who shills for OKCupid gives:</p><ul><li>Include better photos, and more of them. Take off your sunglasses and face the camera, women want to see your full facial expression.</li><li>Fill out a lot more of the questionnaire and include more details in your profile. Women want to know who you are.</li><li>Ask specific questions that show that you read the woman’s profile, don’t ever ask generic small-talk questions like “how are you” or “what’s up.”</li><li>Follow her train of conversation, don’t try to steer it to other subjects.</li></ul><p>After about 15 or so minutes of this, another man in the audience finally said what I was wanting to say. And he said it so much better than I could that by the end of his rant, I wanted to stand on my chair, whistle, holler, applaud, throw frisbees around, and wave a cigarette lighter. I can’t do it word for word, so I apologize for the paraphrase, but:</p><p>When it comes to trying to meet people that you’re going to have any kind of personal connection with, websites are a really good way to do it. He said that he’s met lots of women, including all but one of his current partners, online. Via Facebook, Instagram, and Flickr, not OKCupid. <em>OKCupid sucks.</em></p><p>What people put on their OKCupid profile is a carefully curated (and, I added when he was done, more often than not dishonest) artificial “first impression” that tells you none of what he, or I, or any other man in the audience wants to know before deciding if a woman is interesting. What do you do other than go out dating, and how often do you do it, and with what kinds of crowds, and how long have you been doing it? OKCupid <em>at most</em> tells you who else <em>on OKCupid</em> they are friends with or in relationships with, a tiny percentage of their actual social circle, which (he forcefully pointed out) is completely useless if he wonders what friends you and he have in common. OKCupid shows a couple of pictures of you, ones that you chose because you think they make you attractive; on other social media sites, women post pictures of themselves in a lot more contexts, many of them a lot less artificial and made-up and posed.</p><p>Or, as I summed it up to a friend on Facebook (also female, also pushing back against my attack on OKCupid): nobody looks as good as they do in their OKCupid profile, nobody dresses as well as they do in the picture they chose for their OKCupid profile, and nobody is as happy as they portray themselves to be in their OKCupid profile, and nobody’s job, finances, health, family, or work-life balance is as happy as they portray it on their OKCupid profile.</p><p>But the therapist who was leading the discussion group really did want to leave it there and drop it: if men got better at emotional intelligence and learned to use OKCupid, they would stop asking their wives to go out on fewer dates, and that would solve the inequality inefficiency.</p><h3>I Still Say …</h3><p>By this point in the workshop, all the topics that the presenter came prepared for had been covered, and most everybody in the audience had had their issues addressed in a (mostly) respectful and helpful way, and, well, honestly, people were exhausted. The conversation petred out with about twenty minutes to kill. The therapist asked, repeatedly, with long pauses in between, if anybody had another issues to raise about male inequality in the kink, sex-positive, or polyamory communities? Anybody?</p><p>After a long pause, I finally said (and I’m sure I sounded as tired as I was), “Okay. Let’s say that men, myself included, got better at emotional intelligence and learned to more confidently introduce ourselves. Let’s say that single men got better at using OKCupid. Two problems remain, and you haven’t addressed either of them. ‘<a href="http://goodmenproject.com/sex-relationships/hunting-the-elusive-unicorn/">Unicorn hunters</a>’ and harem collectors are still going to exist, the movement still tolerates them, and those men make single men feel about as welcome as a leper on fire. And so do most event organizers.”</p><p>Aggravatingly, like <em>almost literally every other activist in the poly community</em> other than Franklin Veaux, she refused to engage at all on the patriarchy issue and couple privilege. But there was one person in the room who organizes clothing-optional sex-positive events, and she threw the organizers versus single men question to him.</p><p>He gave the same answer he’s given every time he’s been questioned about the subject—and, to my ear, he sounded tired of answering it. His experience is that they <em>have</em> to close early invites to nearly all single men. Single men sign up for these events a lot sooner, which gives a skewed impression of what the final gender balance will be, which throws off women. That leaves an event with only men at it, which doesn’t make anybody happy, least of all the single men who clamored to be let in. He said that, in particular, before women who are single or looking are willing to sign up for an event, it takes them time to recruit female friends who’ll come with them—and then he finished that sentence with exactly what I was looking for, “So they’ll feel comfortable or something.”</p><p>“Or something” indeed. Here’s something I’ve noticed about the clothing optional, sex positive, polyamorous, and kink-friendly communities of today compared to 15 years ago, when I <em>was </em>one of the organizers of such events, and who knew a lot of the previous generation of organizers in this town and some of the current generation: in a lot of contexts, we’re moving <em>backwards</em> on consent issues, we’re moving <em>backwards</em> on making women feel safe at events. Some of it is the aging off of old activists. Some of it is the gradual, perceptible (and to my mind, unwanted) replacement of the previous generations’ female leaders with more and more male leaders. I still think that the biggest difference is that, with broader social acceptance, all of those movements have been flooded by people who come from the broader, patriarchal, rape-tolerant culture who haven’t yet had their behaviors and assumptions challenged forcefully enough.</p><p>The infamous “Brad Parties” were small potatoes compared to bigger events like Czarkon and St. Louis Leather and Lace, but even I know two things. The lesser of the two important things is that if you want women to feel safe enough, and to have enough of a good time, that they come back, you really have to be highly pro-active about intoxication management; nothing scares off women faster than badly-managed out of control drunks. (And for good reason!) But that’s a smaller part of a broader issue. Women who go to poly, kinky, nudist, or even just plain social events know that they’re going to be propositioned, however bluntly, by men they would rather not be. If it happens a lot, if men who proposition every woman there aren’t educated or gently mocked out of it or overtly expelled, they’re not coming back. And they for damned sure aren’t coming back if they have any fear that a “no thank you” will be met by wheedling, argument, anger, blame, or gods-forbid force.</p><p>I had an emotionally competent and confident all-girl ninja squad of enforcers backed up by a one-man brute squad skilled at using education before persuasion and persuasion before intimidation and intimidation before force (me). I also had literally non-stop messaging, interspersed with enough other visuals to attract the eye, on the subjects of safety and consent, and in almost literally every room and literally for the whole duration of each and every event. That I also had no shortage of happy women attending my clothing-optional and/or leather events is not coincidental.</p><p>I’m not saying you have to turn every polyamorous, kinky, or clothing optional event into a feminism seminar. I am saying, however, that it takes proactive steps and ongoing management to teach consent culture to people raised in rape culture, and doubly so if intoxicants are served. (And I didn’t even get to address the issue of <a href="http://ask.metafilter.com/55153/Whats-the-middle-ground-between-FU-and-Welcome#830421">“ask” versus “guess” culture</a>.)</p><h3>My (Maybe-Unfair?) Summary:</h3><ol><li>There was a strong consensus that, unsurprisingly, a lot of people, most of them men, who complain about not getting dates are unattractive people: some of them people who don’t maintain their appearance, more of them people who treat other people badly.</li><li>Less-attractive people feel insecure, and act out in bad ways, when they end up in relationships with more-attractive people; she seems to think that more-attractive people should accommodate that.</li><li>Less-attractive people would (supposedly) have fewer problems if they all got on OKCupid and learned to use it well.</li><li><em>Still</em> nobody wants to talk about patriarchy. Let alone do anything like call people on patriarchal attitudes or actions. Even <em>though</em> patriarchy hurts men too, <em>especially </em>in alternative sexuality communities.</li></ol><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a6549091280e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Need Feminism Because …]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/i-need-feminism-because-2a2380117f15?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2a2380117f15</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 Aug 2014 20:44:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-08-06T20:44:27.261Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Half the problems of my polyamorous life have a common cause.</em></p><p>I’ve been invited to participate in this group workshop, about a week and a half from now, at my favorite coffee-house:</p><blockquote><a href="https://www.google.com/calendar/render?eid=XzYwc2ppZDFoNzRzM2liOWo4a3FqZ2I5azc1MWplYjlwOGNzMzBiOW42OHI0NGQxbzZsMWs2Y2k2Nmsgc2hhbWVsZXNzZ3JvdW5kc0Bt&amp;ctz&amp;sf=true&amp;output=xml"><strong>The Inequality Inefficiency</strong></a><strong>:</strong><br>Sat, August 23, 1pm – 3pm<br><a href="http://shamelessgrounds.com/">Shameless Grounds</a></blockquote><blockquote>Amy Luechtefeld, M.A., NCC, LPC will be leading a FREE discussion. The group will be addressing the problem of the perceived lack of opportunity of partners in poly relationships; most typically, that of male partners. She will be exploring several stereotypes of males attending events alone, factors inhibiting successful partnering, and strategies for reframing and creating a more active dating and sex life.<br>This talk is NOT limited to men only, and is open to everyone, but will be focused primarily on partnered individuals who feel the deck is stacked against them.</blockquote><p>This is a subject that I have a lot of experience with, that I’ve thought about at length—oh, heck, I’ll just say it out-right: if I let myself, I could rant for that whole two hours. Which, in addition to being rude and uninvited, would be really unproductive. So I’ve got a week and a half to drain the vitriol and boil it down to simple statements, and I’ll start here.</p><p>What do the following things have in common?</p><ol><li><strong>Unicorn-hunting:</strong> A really useful phrase coined (as far as I know) by <a href="http://www.xeromag.com/franklin.html">Franklin Veaux</a> (LiveJournal’s “<a href="http://tacit.livejournal.com/">tacit</a>”) to describe the most annoying and increasingly unwanted behavior of newcomers to polyamory: a heterosexual husband and his presumed-to-be bisexual wife looking for a young, attractive, single bisexual woman to move in with them and have sex with both of them. (And, all too often, to clean their house and cook their dishes and care for the couple’s children.)</li><li><strong>One-Penis Policies:</strong> The less-controversial assumption that, for at least some people, the only or best way to “do” polyamory is for one man to share many women, who can have sex with all the women they want, but only with one man, him.</li><li><strong>Anti-Male Event Policies:</strong> The also not-especially controversial assumption, within the polyamory community that because of rape culture, the motives of unaccompanied men who show up at polyamory or sex-positive events can and should be questioned, that they should be treated as suspicious until they prove otherwise. This is often justified by the entirely false belief that men are the only covert monogamists who show up at polyamory events hoping to take advantage of a couple’s openness to steal a wife or a girlfriend.</li><li><strong>Abuse of Secondaries:</strong> The most common form of polyamory, one that privileges a couple’s relationship over either partner’s relationship(s) with others, is facing serious push-back because of horror story after horror story about how this has lead to some really abusive, manipulative, and/or exploitative treatment of secondaries—as one friend of mine has taken to saying, “treating secondaries like disposable Kleenex.”</li></ol><p>What do I think that these things have in common?</p><h3>Patriarchy</h3><p>Polyamory, as I’ve seen it practiced since the early ‘90s (but not so much before that, I insist), thoroughly privileges any man’s fear that another man will steal his wife or girlfriend, while dismissing any woman’s fear that another woman will steal her husband or boy-friend. Why is this? Because men’s fears are always more important than women’s fears: good old fashioned sexism.</p><p>Despite the last decade of political advances, men fear (even more than I remember from the ‘70s and ‘80s) being seen as bisexual or gay way more than women fear being seen as bisexual. Why? Because if a man is in a relationship where he is exposed to another man’s genitalia, even by sight let alone brief or fleeting touch, he might be accused of liking it. And that would make him “gay,” and therefore effeminate, and therefore no longer entitled to male privilege.</p><p>Note, also, that this leads directly to, and is (I insist) the main reason for, “unicorn hunting:” the one unquestioned form of so-called polyamory, the right of any man to have sex with as many women as he wants, as long as they only have sex with him—or with each other, but only as long as they are attractive to him and he gets to watch.</p><p>And a culture that declines to strongly challenge the patriarchal, harem-seeking behavior of only “opening up” a monogamous couple to three-somes with disposable “hot bi babes” is one that is full of couples that have no use for men, whether or not the wives in question find them romantically or physically attractive. So, unsurprisingly, the price of admission for men into the polyamory movement is, increasingly, that they must bring a hot bi babe. Unsurprisingly, “patriarchy hurts men too.”</p><h3>Completely Backwards</h3><p>What makes this incredibly galling to me, above and beyond the obvious sexism and anti-feminism of a supposedly (and self-congratulatingly) “open” and “forward thinking” and “sensitive” community, is that from any kind of biological basis, it is, if anything, entirely backwards.</p><p>If you read Ryan &amp; Jetha’s <em>Sex at Dawn,</em> one thing that should jump out at you and that is the sheer amount of evidence that humans naturally evolved in, and are most biologically and socially suited to, an environment where receptive women mate with multiple men. It is not a coincidence that this is the norm in all known pre-agricultural societies, to the point where at least one well-documented conteporary pre-agricultural society was surprised to find out that it was actually possible for a woman to get pregnant by one man. It is not a coincidence that among all primate species, the loudness of involuntary female vocalization during sex correlates linearly with the number of males the female typically has sex with during estrus—and that human women have the second-loudest involuntary organsmic vocalizations of any primate species. If nothing else, I shouldn’t have to point out to anybody what everybody over the age of about 12 knows: it takes longer for the average woman to climax than the average man can last, before ejaculation and loss of erection.</p><p>And yet so many people in Anglo-American culture accept as unquestioned “the feminine mystique:” the form of psycho-sexual illness, brought on by oppression and near-solitary-confinement isolation in the single-career suburban “nuclear” family of the ‘50s and ‘60s, that women have lower sex drives than men, that it’s natural for a man to want a lot of sex and natural for women to prefer to not have sex. If you read at all extensively, this idea is hilarious: every other culture in human history has known the opposite. Every post-agricultural society, determined to protect male inheritance rights, has fretted over the fact that women want multiple partners even more than men do. The central goal of all patriarchal morality systems, the central “problem” they have all attempted to confront, is how to keep a woman’s sex drive in check.</p><p>So excuse me if, after the last couple of decades I’ve lived through, my frustration boils over at the level of acceptance within the polyamory community for the idea that men have a natural right to channel women’s sexual appetites.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2a2380117f15" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Journalists, Alive, from the Scene]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/journalists-alive-from-the-scene-62d2b139405?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/62d2b139405</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 29 Jul 2014 10:14:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-09-01T10:17:47.876Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Sometimes “objective, neutral” journalism is impossible. Some of those times, “objective, neutral” journalism would be irresponsible.</em></p><p>A couple of days ago, David Carr of the <em>New York Times</em> wrote an editorial called, “<a href="http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/28/business/media/at-front-lines-bearing-witness-in-real-time.html">At Front Lines, Bearing Witness in Real Time</a>.” He reminds us that combat journalism has accelerated from telegraph and post speed, during the American Civil War, to Twitter speed now. And in so doing, he says, combat journalism has lost several things. Coming from victims as easily as from trained journalists, it’s lost objectivity; bypassing editors, it’s lost proportionality; bypassing aggregators, it’s lost attachment to historical context. Mind you, his argument loses force when you remember that I’m linking you to a <em>New York Times</em> editorial that lots of people are reading and forwarding (including, yes, Tweeting links to). We didn’t lose those things. We gained other things to supplement them.</p><p>I think the recurring comments about the emotional impact of a Twitter feed soaked in gore (as Bruce Sterling neatly summed it up when he linked to this editorial) demonstrate what really motivates his objection. I started nodding when he pointed to an example that professional journalists are still ambivalent about almost a decade later, one that’s been on my mind. Recent events in Gaza that specifically relate to journalists, what happened to them, what they saw, and how the world reacted to their reactions, reminded me of the same thing.</p><h3>We Have Seen this Reaction Before</h3><p>In 2005, US armed forces were used to keep aid convoys and, yes, journalists out of the flooded city of New Orleans, because of Roy Nagin’s and George Bush’s flatly ignorant and racist belief that unlike past disaster zones, New Orleans first needed to be militarily pacified; Red Cross disaster relief and in-person journalism had to wait for the <em>three and a half days</em> that it took to fly the 101st Airborne back from the war zone in Afghanistan and deploy them against thirsty, hungry, dying Americans. When the reporters were finally allowed in, they went about their business as they are trained to do: calm but just a little forceful, carefully neutral in tone, as close to unemotional as they could be.</p><p>But then something happened that was almost unprecedented in American real-time broadcast journalism, something that didn’t even happen in London during the Blitz, or in New York City during 9/11: one by one, the journalists each lost their minds, and lost their tempers, on the air. There was one sight amidst the drowning city that so shocked their consciences that the most carefully trained and auditioned news-describing automatons couldn’t check the emergence of their humanity: an entire several-thousand-person overflow storm shelter, the New Orleans Convention Center, that hadn’t been stocked before people were sent there, that wasn’t manned while people were there, and that had been forgotten in the aftermath because the only person who knew that people had been sent there had, after giving the order, self-evacuated from the town.</p><p>After three and a half days of neglect waiting for the 101st Airborne to “pacify” a patiently waiting town, then seeing the Army air-drop a single pallet of bottled water and fly off because they were afraid of the about-to-die refugees, first Anderson Cooper, and then one by one every other stand-up journalist broadcasting from New Orleans after the levies failed, <em>lost their minds</em> on the air, screaming in impotent rage that this had been allowed to happen and that it was still happening.</p><p>And although there was some low-key grumbling and hand-wringing from the professional journalism outlets and trade organizations? Nobody lost their career over it. Nobody was even censured. We’ve had a vague sense that that one time, it was appropriate, although we can’t entirely say why.</p><p>So let’s talk about the journalists in and around occupied Gaza during the latest Israeli military incursion, a couple of whom have also lost their minds. And let’s talk about the fact that, this time, audiences outside the war zone, even ones who would previously have politically identified with Israel’s US-allied democracy, and would have stood united against the people who cheered the deaths on 9/11 and then voted for a sometimes overtly genocidal Islamist political party? Even that audience? Is gobbling up with two spoons angry and agonizing cries from journalists who, professionally, ought to know better, journalists whose editors promptly removed them from the war zone for letting themselves express sadness or anger in public and in real time. That same audience is siding with, and demanding the return to the war zone of, those journalists. That same audience is filling up their lists of followed feeds on Twitter with live reports from the war zone that are even angrier, and even sadder, and even gorier, than what got those journalists fired. (And the previously famously media-savy Israeli Defense Force is, as at least one news analyst observed recently, being caught completely unprepared by this.)</p><p>Time time, it seems appropriate, even to people who would side against the victims politically. But nobody is quite sure why. I have an idea, though.</p><h3>We Know: We Have Always Needed This</h3><p>Herodotus, reporting long after the fact from the Persian Wars. Matthew Brady, distributing wire service photographs of the casualties of Antietam. Edward R. Murrow, broadcasting live from the Blitz. CBS news embeds, reporting from US fire bases in Vietnam. The immediacy continues to improve, but the message doesn’t: we all know that if we’re going to militarily defend ourselves (or, unforgivably, attack others), if we know that we’re going to be held accountable to history for what is done in our names, we really need to know if what is being done is just. And being human beings, whose sympathies are so frequently visceral rather than intellectual, we need some way to receive the same sense impressions that we would have received if we had been there for it, because that’s how human beings make moral decisions: by looking both sides in the face while they’re doing what they’re doing, and deciding who we identify with, whose agony and anger seems more viscerally real to us.</p><p>And do not, by any means, get me wrong and think that I am criticizing 2500 years of war correspondents and war reporters and war journalists going all the way back to Herodotus for what they have done so far in trying to meet that need. Written language is an awesome tool. Written language is my personal favorite tool! But …</p><p>When post-Civil War journalists, and then historians, passed along the lament of victorious general Sherman that, “It is only those who have neither fired a shot nor heard the shrieks and groans of the wounded who cry aloud for blood, more vengeance, more desolation. War is hell,” we all read that, and we nodded, and we felt like we’d learned something we needed to know. But we didn’t really know.</p><p>When poet Wilfred Owen returned from World War I and told us in only that grisly, emotional way that poets do what it was like to march behind the medical wagon that was carrying a friend of your as he died from exposure to poison gas, every horrible sight and sound of it, and wrote to us that if we had been there, we “would not tell with such ardent zest to children ardent for some desperate glory the old lie: <em>dulce et decorem est pro patria mori,”</em> that it is a sweet and appropriate thing to die for your country? We all read it, and we still read it, and we nod, and we feel as if we’ve learned something that we didn’t already know, that we needed to know. But we didn’t really know.</p><p>I could go on and on: Ernie Pile mailing in cartoons from the European theater of World War II and James Michener writing long-form first hand reports from the Pacific theater of the same war and Studs Terkel recording for us many, many first hand reports of that “Good War;” we read them, and we nodded, but we didn’t really know. CBS Evening News broadcast only barely not real-time video from Vietnam, and years later the <em>Toledo Blade</em> won a Pulitzer when the soldiers who fought to find and eliminate Viet Cong snipers in the Free Fire Zone told the truth about what it took, what it was like to be there, and Tim O’Brien wrote for us about <em>The Things They Carried.</em> And we read it. And we nodded, feeling that we now knew some of what we needed to know. But we didn’t know.</p><p>I think this is what we thought that we needed to know, that we just plain lack the imagination to know from a written account no matter how talented the writer, that we can’t learn from neutral-toned, just-the-facts objective stand-ups from television war correspondents no matter how close they stand to the fighting:</p><p>Let’s say that you supported the war. Let’s say that you agreed that the attacking side had a moral and legal justification for what they were doing, that it was legitimate self defense. Let’s say that, knowing that, it had been you instead of a war correspondent who was, during what he thought was a lull in the fighting, playing catch with four little children on a peaceful beach when, as happens in war time, your side’s navy mistook those children for soldiers and blew them up in front of you after you had just spent an hour playing with them, instead of this happening to a professional war correspondent, what if it had been you who this had happened to: looking at what was left of those children’s faces, then looking at the equally scared and angry faces of the naval artillerymen who killed them, what would you feel?</p><p>Let’s say that you supported the war. Let’s say that you agreed that the attacking side had a moral and legal justification for what they were doing, that it was legitimate self defense. And let’s say that instead of a professional journalist that was standing on a hill the night of the biggest battle of the war to date, it was you standing on a hill just outside of and above the battle, watching the tanks and artillery and bombers blow up a crowded neighborhood to get the militants they think are hiding there. Let’s say that, while you’re standing their neutrally and objectively watching, and trying to ignore the cheerleading of bloodthirsty civilians from your own side who are openly bigotedly rooting for lots and lots of civilians down there to die. Let’s say that they saw you there, not participating in their cheering section, and warned you that if you said one wrong word they would destroy your car and hurt you. If it was you, and not a war correspondent, looking from the faces of those war cheerleaders down into the fire and rubble below, and then looking back, what would you feel?</p><p>In the same way that Anderson Cooper knew that it wasn’t enough to tell us what he saw in New Orleans in 2005, wasn’t enough to show us what he was seeing? In the same way that he, and then we, understood that his emotional reaction being on the scene is something we needed to know, that it was a legitimate part of the story? Two journalists, one in Gaza and one just outside Gaza, saw what they saw, and reported what they saw, and knew—I think correctly—that showing us and telling us what they saw wasn’t enough, that we needed to know the emotional impact of those things <em>because</em> we needed help understanding how it felt to be there. Both of them were pulled for making that judgment; only one of them has been returned.</p><p>I think they were right. And the huge hunger on the Internet for other emotional stories from inside the war zone suggests to me that they were right. Lots of us believed, as recently as a week ago, that because of Hamas’s past, and because of its affiliations, and because of the rocket attacks, and because of a kidnapping and murder of some children (that Hamas had nothing to do with, but that’s not what we were told at first), that Israel’s war on Hamas was entirely legally and morally justified.</p><p>I think we know, deep down, that before we are so sure of that, we need to know what it would be like to see that, smell that, hear what Israel is doing in self defense in person. Because, being human, only then can we really know the answer to the question, “If this is what it costs, is it still worth it?” Because we know that, years down the road, even if it only happens after we’re all gone, that question will be asked: if this is what it costs to have a Jewish state centered on the ancient Jewish temple city of Jerusalem in these days, even if we do think that that’s a good thing (a question I’m not even asking here), could we look from the faces of one set of fighters or victims to the faces of the other set of fighters or victims, and then back, and still feel, emotionally, that it was worth it?</p><p>And I don’t think objective, calm, edited journalism can answer that.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=62d2b139405" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[There is a Standard American English Word for “NRE”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jbradhicks/there-is-a-standard-american-english-word-for-nre-4b0137e6441e?source=rss-c851b4107097------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4b0137e6441e</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[the infamous Brad]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 28 Jul 2014 08:41:36 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2014-07-28T08:41:36.420Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Hint: “Erotic” didn&#39;t originally mean “sexy.”</em></p><p>I was looking for <a href="http://www.doctornerdlove.com/2014/02/why-women-dont-approach/">a Dr. Nerdlove column that my roommate mentioned</a>, stumbled across a couple of more looking for another column that it teased … and one word, used at random in a column I wasn’t even looking for, jumped out at me. It’s a useful word! It’s also one that I fear may have fallen out of common usage, and if so, it needs to be brought back. But some prelude, though, first, if I may:</p><p>One of my rants, as a religious Hellenist, is that an awful lot of people are awfully confident of C.S. Lewis’s mis-translation of one of the ancient Greek words for “love.” He makes the valid point in <em>The Four Loves </em>that we use the word “love” to mean several different things, many of them non-overlapping. My pet peeve, though, has to do with the then-common mis-translation of the word <em>eros,</em> a mistake he passed along for generations to follow. And that really annoys me, because (a) I think that understanding the difference between <em>eros</em> and other kinds of love, and its exact nature, is important to staying out of abusive relationships and preserving nurturing ones, and (b) it cuts to the heart of my ex-wife’s accusation that I have never really loved anyone.</p><p>The ancient Greek word <em>eros,</em> in its ancient sense, does not mean “sex.” They had a word for sexual attraction and purely sexual relationships: <em>pornos,</em> not coincidentally meaning, “of and related to, or similar to, what people do with prostitutes.” Wanting to bump uglies with someone because they make you horny is not erotic, it’s pornographic. Not that there’s anything wrong with that!</p><p>There’s an awkward acronym in the polyamory movement, useful enough to have become a common neologism that’s breaking out into the broader American-speaking public: New Relationship Energy, or NRE (pronounced “en-arr-RHEE”). It’s that passionate feeling (that I think I can honestly tell you that I have never felt) of “oh my god, I love that person so much that they must love me back or else I will die; I would do anything, however stupid or suicidal, if that was what it took to get that person to love me.” <em>That</em> feeling is what the word <em>eros</em> means in ancient Greek.</p><p>And here’s the funny thing about <em>eros.</em> The Greeks considered it a form of temporary insanity. They considered it a gift from the gods—specifically, from Aphrodite’s idiot child Cupid, although sometimes from the goddess herself—and, as such, something that was dangerous to ignore, dangerous to repress. To reject a god’s gift was to court the wrath of that god, and gods make dangerous enemies. But they also understood, in a way that (as far as I know) <em>none</em> of our modern cultures seem to be doing a good job of communicating to people as they grow into their first romantic and sexual feelings, something else about <em>eros:</em> it is not something you can, or should, build a permanent relationship on, or ruin a permanent relationship over.</p><p>If Cupid’s arrow strikes you and someone else at the same time, and the two of you absolutely must “fall in love with” (an occasionally useful phrase) each other, well, the ancient Greeks considered that feeling unpleasant and dangerous to ignore. But they understood, and we don’t, that it doesn’t mean that you have any reason to build a life with that person; they understood, and we don’t, that it doesn’t say anything negative about your existing relationship. The Greeks feared offending Cupid or Aphrodite, but they also feared offending Hera, the goddess of the sacred marriage bed, even more, and feared offending Hestia, the even older and more revered goddess of the sacred hearth and home, more than that.</p><p>Smitten by <em>eros?</em> Get it out of your system. Enjoy it while you can. It passes. <em>It always does.</em> But for the love of all holy gods, if not for the love of sanity itself, <em>don’t marry that person,</em> and for the love of life itself, <em>don’t leave your marriage over it.</em> Feeling NRE, feeling <em>eros,</em> does not mean that you no longer love your partner. It sure as all hell doesn’t mean that you have “found your soul-mate,” a phrase that I am far too used to meaning “I have to leave the mother of my children because I’ve feeling passionately in love with a girl my children’s age.” (No, seriously: after all the examples I’ve seen, if you want to convince me that you are a shallow, emotionally immature moron, all you have to do is use the word “soul-mate” unironically in my presence.)</p><p>Nor does losing that feeling of fleeting, intoxicating passion mean that you no longer love your partner. If you’re with the wrong person, you may, in fact, not love them—but that has nothing to do with the presence or absence of a temporary state of intoxication. Indeed, I find nothing in the world so creepy, disturbing, and psychologically unhealthy than the last decade or two’s fad of Christian marriage manuals aimed at keeping <em>eros</em> alive within a marriage, something about as likely as pushing a string uphill. Love simply doesn’t work that way.</p><p>So, yes, I find it tremendously useful that the polyamory community has coined the term “New Relationship Energy.” And I find it extremely helpful that that term, and its acronym NRE, are spreading out among other users of the American dialect of English. It gives me some hope that, somewhere out there, some day, someone will avoid the mistake that (I think it was) Mark Twain mocked when he defined “marriage” as, “Two people in the grip of the most fleeting and insupportable of passions, who rush directly to the altar of God and vow to remain that way forever.”</p><p>But there’s a limit to how much it can catch on, I think. It’s jargon. It’s an awkward acronym from a not especially popular subculture, one that many people find threatening. It’s not even vaguely euphonic.</p><p>And, fortunately, it’s not even vaguely necessary. Because, as <a href="http://www.doctornerdlove.com/2014/02/ask-dr-nerdlove-heal-after-abuse/">an old Dr. Nerdlove letter-reply</a> just reminded me, standard American English already has, or at least had, a word for that. It’s one I haven’t heard used in conversation in years, which makes me think that somewhere in the last couple of decades it got relegated to obsolete English, but at least he remembered the word and knew how to use it in a sentence (emphasis added):</p><blockquote>That burning, driving passion your girlfriend is talking about? That’s not love. That’s <strong>infatuation.</strong> It’s a total rush of passion and sexual desire and novelty that feels almost overpowering at times. It’s like a chemical high — and there’s a lot of chemicals involved, oxytocin, dopamine, and norepinephrine firing off and flying straight to the pleasure centers of your brain. It feels amazing and, if you’re inexperienced, it can feel a lot like love… but it’s not. Infatuation is part of the “honeymoon period” of every relationship, when everything is new and amazing and enthralling… but it’s also temporary. Infatuation fades, usually within six months to a year.</blockquote><p><strong>Infatuation.</strong> It’s a word. Let’s bring it back. And let’s use it whenever somebody, in the grip of the most fleeting and insupportable passions (however wonderful they feel!) even halfway seriously considers doing something permanent and irreversible about those feelings. Let’s remind them that infatuation passes; infatuation is not actually love.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4b0137e6441e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>