<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by JCB on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by JCB on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jcb7?source=rss-13a5dfc5dfed------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 05:39:06 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jcb7/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Antichristology, E-Scatology, and A-Satanism — Against Heresies]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jcb7/antichristology-e-scatology-and-a-satanism-against-heresies-7b9386b6411e?source=rss-13a5dfc5dfed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7b9386b6411e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[escatology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[antichristology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pyrotheology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[a-satanism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JCB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 May 2018 02:03:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-05-21T02:03:28.369Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/834/1*AqZlh6ikV05TvXqnsVmt7A.jpeg" /></figure><p>The opposite of Christian religion is not atheistic naturalism.</p><p>When someone stops believing in God and rejects the concept of “Faith” as absurd, irrational, impractical, or unnecessary, they haven’t stepped outside of theological language, they haven’t stopped using religious technology. As Jean-Luc Nancy (and many others) has said, “If you say you are an atheist, it means you are a Christian.”</p><p>What truly stands outside the Trinity of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit — the true anti-theology — is depicted in The Revelation of St. John as the anti-trinity of Dragon, Antichrist, and False Prophet. These three personas symbolize an unholy triad that echoes and perverts the triune Godhead; they represent the inverted anti-religion that we know as Heresy.</p><p>Their doctrine is nontraditional, in that it exists specifically as the collection of all non-canonical wisdom, all things incendiary and blasphemous and gnostic that constitute the counter-themes of orthodoxy. This is why G.K. Chesterton, when he wrote <em>Heretics</em>, did not describe theological heresies as such: he didn’t argue how Jules Verne was denying the divinity of Christ or how many sacraments Rudyard Kipling kept. Instead he critiqued his contemporaries’ own philosophies, exposed the antagonisms buried in their reasoning. The perversions of anti-theology are not associated with language and logic in the same manner as traditional theology, and so their subtleties are more directly teased-out by exposing the hidden qualities of what they themselves produce. Chesterton did not need to use the Bible or Christian theology to explain why his contemporaries were heretics: their works spoke for themselves. They wear their anti-religious vestments openly, hidden in plain sight, popping into and out of view.</p><p>The atheistic and naturalist theories that pretend to overcome religious faith have, ironically, become the “wicked and perverse generation that asks for a sign,” obsessing over Faith to the point of mythologizing its absence. Atheism today functions generationally, structuring the ideology of the post-Christian epoch. <em>Anno Domini</em> has come to an end. Time itself is no longer the Private Dominion of God, but has been replaced by the Common Era, the age where Public space — the Commons of shared space-time in the form of online communities, the virtual-digital reality of interconnected thought-life — continues to exist. Secular naturalists want us to live <em>after</em> the Year of Our Lord only because they have persevered with Christianity to the end and recognized its properly-theological truth: there is a Common Space, and it’s called Death.</p><p>Atheism, Secularism, Naturalism, Materialism, Physicalism: these are not the opposite of religion. They are the titles of religion’s concluding chapters.</p><p>But heresy — perverse and adulterous anti-theology — is not part of the book.</p><p>It is not part of any book.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/320/1*4LsTGaFwAQfjU70QrA04Kw.gif" /></figure><p>Heresy, if it is anything like a book, is like Tom Riddle’s diary from <em>Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets</em>. The diary, haunted by the spirit of the evil Lord Voldemort, contains no writing, just empty pages. When anyone writes on those pages, the ink disappears. The magic diary sometimes scribbles an answer to a written question, as if the Dark Lord’s fiery tongue was licking its lips in anticipation of a meal. But all text ultimately vanishes into this impossible anti-book, erased by its innate opposition to every story but its own.</p><p>An atheistic book, by contrast, would simply go on and on until it froze in the vast emptiness of space, begging the Void for a sign because it refuses to accept “the sign of Jonah,” the resurrection of Christ out of the earth. Atheistic Naturalism still utilizes all of the tools of Christianity because it ceaselessly exposes the Void as a Void, as the bottomless specter of impossibility. With every word of every chapter of every book, pressing into the most cosmic and microscopic spaces, the reality of mortality is affirmed. Atheism is nothing other than the Christian truth that there is a thing called “the second Death,” a fire-lake that threatens to consume all of us poor sinners who refuse to drink the water from the spring of Life. The book of Atheism is an orthodox book because it knows that deep deep down, there is an impossible conflagration: impossible, because it is <em>a-theos</em>, apart from the omnipresent God; a conflagration, because its consumption is aggressive, overpowering, and as inevitable as Ragnarok.</p><p>But the book of Heresy is a story that unwrites itself, a black hole that sucks in all our language and experience and spits back its own versions of reality. Its author — like Voldemort — erases all other realities: The anti-trinity wants slaves to become assimilated to its providential designs, to <em>begin</em> with the Void and spread its secret, transient, gospel of fire. Heresy pops into and out of view, hinting that Death — the Void — is a chamber of secret gnostic power-treasure, an antidote to the sickness of Christian Faith and its decadent utopianism. Hell is only a conflagration for those who cannot properly wield its <a href="http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Fiendfyre">fiendfyre</a>.</p><p>Heretics never write anything: their words are swallowed into the depths of an anti-story that claims all their words for itself. But the most piercing truth of Chesterton’s <em>Heretics</em> doesn’t reside in any particular rebuttal to H.G. Wells or George Bernard Shaw: the path of orthodoxy is narrow, and <em>all </em>worldly wisdom is implicated in heresy. A spiritual falling-away has occurred <em>everywhere, </em>in our collective bodies, and now, more than one-hundred years into the Common Era, worldly wisdom is almost too ubiquitous to pin it on particular individuals.</p><p>The time for identifying Heretics is long over. To diverge from Chesterton, the time for codifying Heresies has arrived. The Heretics of Chesterton’s era have given birth to a generation asking for a sign, and in their earnest they think they have found three.</p><p>The book of Heresy has vomited back enough clues for us to decipher its message.</p><p>We have three anathemas to pronounce:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*8HG_TvVUmJ98sXauuUVI5g.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Antichristology</strong></h3><p>The doctrine of the Anti-One: the sacrifice yet-to-come.</p><p>Messianism is an identifiable strain of theology occurring in religions across the world. One hero is prophesied to appear, one mediator acts as the locus of tension so that two opposing parties can reconcile. Antichristology does not describe the original binary opposition against which messiah figures struggle: that is, it is not (necessarily) a codification of messianic tension, the way we might speculate on Jesus praying in Gethsemane as a divine doubt. The ancient Church carved out the tension of Christ until they arrived at the Hypostatic Union, and Christians are free to play inside the safe walls of that glorious mystery of a doctrine.</p><p>Instead, Antichristology identifies an alternative strain of messianism, providing a character profile. In this sense, Antichristology is directly analogous to how Christology profiles the person and nature of Jesus in Christian doctrine.</p><p>In conservative, End-Times-obsessed Christian communities, identifying the Antichrist involves examining supposed references to a specific person, typically drawing from the books of Daniel and Revelation (among others). This is not totally distinct from the anti-doctrine I’m describing: Antichristology, functioning dogmatically, identifies phenomena — including persons — that operate after the pattern of what Christianity calls the Beast, what Islam calls the Dajjal, and what Daniel the prophet describes as a little horn on top of a beast. But, contrary to its function in conservative Christianity, the Antichristological heresy attempts to blur the persons of Antichrist and Christ together until their roles become indistinguishable.</p><p>The Antichrist, in Christian theology, represents the final enemy defeated by Jesus. The confession of the Apostles’ Creed states that there will be a world-to-come, but before that new life is achieved, the old, rebellious world has to be baptized with fire: the “falling away,” as St. Paul calls it, corresponds to the appearance of the “Man of Lawlessness,” the figure who collapses all evil into himself. Jesus may be the ultimate sacrifice, but there is still one Beast left in Christianity yet to be slaughtered, one scapegoat to expel from the camp.</p><p>Antichristology appears when a particular body — individual or institutional — fulfills the role of this Beast-that-remains. The contours of Antichristology, the textures that reveal its orthodoxy or heresy, are formed by the relationship between the remainder and its original content, between Christ (the original) and the World that remains in his wake. Antichristology can pop into existence when, for example, the original content is a mythological hero, while the remainder is his prophesied rebirth with a revised, adjusted mission. Or the remainder could be a new Resistance born out of an old, failed Rebellion. But in such cases, the shadow of the Original almost forces an orthodox perspective, differentiating Christ and Antichrist enough for the original messiah to maintain some measure of authority.</p><p>The original content may be absent altogether, however, present only as the existential trauma of inevitable death, in which case the remainder <em>is</em> the original content, the Antichrist overlaps with the Christ directly, and the mark of the Beast is radically universalized. That is, the climactic enemy is assumed independently of any Chosen One meant to defeat him. The threat of mortal existence remains real even without the Death of God, without the authority of a messiah now revealed as a fiction.</p><p><em>Game of Thrones</em> once again gets it right — Winter is most definitely coming: this Universal Constant of Death is embodied and localized in Antichrist figures. And when this frozen lawlessness spreads across the land and the world receives his mark, our Antichristological anti-religion immediately knows that it is the mark of some-thing in particular, an Anti-One who persists despite universal Death. And with God long gone, the only explanation we little beasts can offer for such an Abomination is that he remains, somehow, a man, that his humanity is a miracle he pulled out of the wound of his beastly mortality.</p><p>By his wound we are healed of eternal life. By his mark we participate in his mysterious Babylon, the only utopia left in the absence of the Kingdom of God. The Beast-Man bears and embodies the scar of the Lawlessness of Death, the Death of Christ that — for one full Holy Satur-Day — left the cosmos without its King. But the Beast-Man hangs forever on the empty backside of Christ’s cross, the symbol of the invisible man, the Dead remainder who invites us to disappear with him.</p><p>So then,</p><p>if anyone says that</p><p>the remainder is the same as the original content, or that</p><p>the purpose of the Christ is so that God can die permanently, or that</p><p>the true God is the Beast-Man,</p><p>let him be anathema.</p><h3>E-Scatology</h3><p>An eschatology of “scat,” or shit, the obscene and flushable waste of the great <em>telos — </em>the ultimate design of and purpose of all things. This is the doctrine of the virtual leftovers, the undigested material that persists beyond any climactic conclusion.</p><p>Standard eschatology provides a vision for how the cosmos arrives at the conclusion of one epoch and inaugurates the next epoch. E-Scatology echoes this function of eschatology: its content is likewise epochal, related to the collapse of one age and the beginning of another. But whereas the visions supplied by orthodox eschatologies relate to the convergence of divine and terrestrial planes, the vision of E-Scatology relates to the convergence of terrestrial and digital (or virtual) planes. E-Scatology locates the fragment of technology within bodies— the capacity of bodies to produce an excess that is simultaneously part of the body and distinct from the body, the inseparability of body and tool — and overlaps that fragment with digital landscapes of the future.</p><p>But where Antichristology focuses on the Singularity — the -1, the Particular object of heretical worship — E-Scatology identifies the Duality, the binary that worships. It is the heresy espoused by the Pyrotheologians, who advocate psycho-spiritual cleansing in the form of any “transformative” or “displacing” technologies. These technologies are essentially anti-religious, in that they are specifically designed to sever the connection between “heaven” and “earth.” They are rituals of the underworld, sacrileges that summon Hell to the surface and point us to our inner fire, to the spark of electricity that on a personal level constitutes our particular existential wounds, and on a collective level points to universal Death.</p><p>So then,</p><p>if anyone says that,</p><p>there is no future Life of the world to come, or that</p><p>the utopian Kingdom of God is only an analogy for breaking out of binary antagonisms, or that</p><p>religious technologies are merely psycho-social resources for exposing us to our innate non-human reality,</p><p>let him be anathema.</p><h3>A-Satanism</h3><p>Auto-Soteriology (or, looking the Devil in the face).</p><p>A-Satanism is similar to Atheism in that it identifies an object of faith for the purpose of rejecting that object. Atheists reject God, A-Satanists reject Satan.</p><p>In the standard religious sense, a practitioner of Satanism is a devotee of individual will-power and (often) esoteric ritual and magic. A practitioner of A-Satanism, on the other hand, rejects the egoism of Satanic faith: but rejecting Satan does not equate to joining Team God.</p><p>Doctrinally, A-Satanology is a radical form of non-theism, in that the scatological faith-remainder of Atheism is itself rejected. So when the ego is rejected and the wheel of Samsara (and desire and utopia) is broken from this <em>a-priori</em> atheistic position, the A-Satanist cannot become (a) God and so instead becomes Nothing. A-Satanism is, in this sense, the highest goal of Satanism, the gift that the original Serpent promised to Eve.</p><p>A-Satanism is the faith of true nihilists, of the strictest Sith acolytes who build empires so they can consume whole planets. They understand the dire responsibility of freedom from Satan, freedom from the lingering threat of non-existence. A-Satanists possess the secret inner-knowledge, the hissing gnosis as Jeffrey Kripal <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Serpents-Gift-Gnostic-Reflections-Religion/dp/0226453812">calls</a> it, that hums inside all things.</p><p>A-Satanology takes the critique of Christianity into account <em>a-priori</em>: that is, Antichristology fully overlaps with Christology for the A-Satanist. But where a simple Antichristological heretic might worship via the E-Scatological dystopianism of mortality, the A-Satanist knows that dystopia is as fictitious as utopia. There is no point, for the A-Satanist, to dystopian egoism and transformative religious technologies, because there is no dystopian threat to overcome.</p><p>Freedom from God might make us moral agents responsible for our individual choices, but freedom from Satan makes us responsible for everything there is, makes us the threat that causes the universe to recoil in fear.</p><p>With A-Satanism, we are no longer in a progressive religion that helps us mature into full subjective agency: we are not responsible adults who, in the absence of a Savior, must embody the change we wish to see in the world. Instead, we are in a totally-inverted religion that seeks to save everything from itself, a religion that has no knowledge of evil, no faith in Nothing, and so insists that its practitioners create Nothing themselves.</p><p>We are responsible for creating the toilet that holds the water that collects the shit. We, the A-Satanists, open the space for our own digital scat, believing that our purpose is to flush and be flushed.</p><p>So then,</p><p>if anyone says that</p><p>there is no origin of evil in the person of Satan, or that</p><p>the responsibility of everyone is to create dystopia and so rob Satan of his authority, or that</p><p>salvation is freedom from the collective Unconscious,</p><p>let him be anathema.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7b9386b6411e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[When Smith is the One: A Pyrotheological Alternative Ending to the Matrix]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jcb7/when-smith-is-the-one-a-pyrotheological-alternative-ending-to-the-matrix-8196ea0be366?source=rss-13a5dfc5dfed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8196ea0be366</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[the-one]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[alternative-ending]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-matrix]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pyrotheology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JCB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 26 Apr 2018 16:46:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-04-26T16:49:53.761Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/650/1*smzSz0HKqwqfmRC-ozUjmQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Part I — Meditations on The One</strong></h3><p><em>(For the actual alternative ending, skip to Part II)</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FruSTiOmiyWw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DruSTiOmiyWw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FruSTiOmiyWw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f3a74cbc725d4d384dd86c07ac762120/href">https://medium.com/media/f3a74cbc725d4d384dd86c07ac762120/href</a></iframe><p>The Agent erupts from the Earth.</p><p>He screams at Neo from midair, “This is my world, my world!”</p><p>Brutalizing what’s left of the body of Thomas A. Anderson, Smith finally takes his prize. His hand, plunged into Neo’s heart, steals purpose for itself in the name of annihilation; Smith claims Life in the name of Death.</p><p>“The purpose of life is to end,” he had warned before.</p><p>Smith’s final purpose is clear: “The problem is Choice.” Neo possesses the real Agency, the genuine relationship with the Matrix that allows for free choice. As an Agent, before Neo “unplugged” him, Smith could hop from body to body and control the whole System. But he has lost that freedom, he believes, to lowly Mr. Anderson, who leaves him powerless in the face of inevitable Death and obliteration.</p><p>But Smith rebels against the System and its “One.” The Oracle’s eyes brought him to this moment of decision: a genuine choice, not for Neo, not for the so-called “One,” who has been choosing all along, who has been the secret Son of the Architect, the System’s “One” by whom and for whom and through whom the Matrix comes to exist. The choice, instead, is placed before Smith, the “New Man” who appears to be free from the control of the Matrix, but who is also aware of a hidden knowledge.</p><blockquote>“What matters is whatever happened happened for a reason…. We’re not here because we’re free. We’re here because we’re <em>not</em> free. There is no escaping Reason, no denying Purpose, because we both know that without Purpose, we would not exist.”</blockquote><p>Smith has preached the predestination of Death, the fate of the Matrix to virally consume itself, the illusory-artificiality of human freedom in the face of the Almighty Void of Purpose. But the final choice (assimilating Neo) is put before this apparently-Free Agent. Suddenly scared, Smith says, “It’s a trick! Get away from me!” And now it is time for Fate itself, embodied in the Sea of Smiths that has overwhelmed the Matrix, to choose: claim Neo or remain stunned in fear. Unite the inevitability of universal Death with Neo’s embodiment of Absolute Will, or freeze this moment forever, unable to choose.</p><p>As the Oracle mentions, the programs that carry out the operations of the Matrix face deletion when they no longer serve a purpose. But Agent Smith resisted deletion by the Machine Source after Neo defeated him the first time. Smith believes he is destined for disobedience, compelled to feel an existential gap, fated for alienation from the Source, a result of some part of Neo’s victory overwriting his Agency, his relative freedom as an Agent rather than a human. The only way to truly disobey, to strike out against the oppressive control of the Matrix, is to steal away for oneself its teleology, its summation and essence, in the destiny of the so-called “One.”</p><p>Smith is asking the one-and-only question there is for those who live in existential rebellion against the oppressions of their own Matrix: “To be, or not to be?”</p><p>Neo has taken the freedom of choice away from the Agent, and so the only choice remaining for Smith is suicide. The only purpose that can be taken from the One, from Absolute Will, is the Anti-Choice, the choice that is only free precisely because it is naturally-free, because it is bound to its nature — its programming, its Architectural design — to be Absolute Freedom, the wasteful excess of Matrix code that constitutes the Architect’s final end for the Control System: freedom from existence itself. “The purpose of life is to end,” Smith says, building up to his fateful echo of the Oracle’s warning, right before he assimilates the One: “Everything that has a beginning has an end, Neo.”</p><p>The “One” offers his body as a willing sacrifice to Smith’s assimilation. A spasm later, and every Smith bursts from the inside out, exploding into light.</p><p>“Because we both know that without Purpose, we would not exist.”</p><p>Neo’s surrender to Smith might be seen (wrongly, I believe) as the surprise victory of life over death, the upside-down power of nonviolence, or an achievement of balance with nature, flattening our ontology so that we have finally have “Peace” between our inner selves and outer worlds. The great Nirvana of Freedom from the wheel of Desire. This thesis is strengthened by the weakness of Neo’s resurrection (or lack thereof), and so the Peace of Death becomes the object of Faith. Neo and Smith are both gone, Death truly is inevitable, and if you “know thyself” enough, you too can deny Death its nihilistic power! You can imitate Neo, choosing to short-circuit the endless struggle and embrace Death with open arms.</p><p>And it’s that kind of confusion — the overlapping of Peace and Death — that prompts <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VkMU1mKdwPI">questions</a> over who, precisely, constitutes the “One”: Smith or Neo? Both paths, it seems, are suicidal.</p><p>But imagine this is the correct reading, and imagine life in Zion after the end of the last battle, after both Smith and Neo are gone and the nihilistic truth of the present “Peace” begins to settle in. The machines have vanished, Neo’s destiny is finished, and now the citizens are free to awaken minds in the Matrix, free to preach the Truth of the real world.</p><p>But what good news do they preach, exactly? Why would anyone choose to live in the real world when there is no enemy to fight and no God to worship? Why would anyone unlucky enough to be stuck in the real world not strike out in self-interest, taking control of the terrible scarcity that defines their position? The only goal left for such souls banished to the Earth’s core is to ascend, like Neo, by struggle until they merge with the Source, until they become the new architects creating new forms of control over others. That is the new religion inaugurated by this Death-Peace of the One: die to the subterranean myths and mystically unite with the Machine overlords, leeching life from the decadent slaves in the New Matrix.</p><p>The New Matrix is no longer governed by Agents of the system. The Smith virus has been obliterated and there is free access to the Truth. But those in the Matrix are nonetheless still slaves of the Machines, tools for the Machines to maintain a certain level of survival, a certain property of existence. The only difference is that there are no more humans left in Zion, only anthropic technology, fleshy hardware, free to survive as godforsaken beasts in the wasteland of the Real — and perhaps, if they’re brave enough, free to embrace their inner machine nature, go to the Source for deletion, and so become part of the evil nihilistic Deus Ex Machina. So when the beastly messengers from this human-less Zion tell the Matrix slaves about their condition, who could blame the slaves for choosing the relative comforts of virtual reality over that religion of pointless angst?</p><p>“I’ve seen this. This is the end!” Smith gloats as he stands over a defeated Neo, reminding us that the Oracle has willfully given him her eyes. The Oracle could not see past her choice to merge with Smith. But her foresight could see the choice of Smith to merge with Neo. She could not understand her choice of faith in the One, and thus in the Architect.</p><p>She loves the Architect, loves him enough to create an entire Matrix with him, even though it should cost her the bastard son, Smith, the wasteful excess of the System “trying to balance itself out.” She ultimately loves the Architect and the One so much that she gives herself over to the utter corruption of Death, to assimilation by Smith and his nothingness — a choice she made in eternity past, but does not understand — because she believes in the One. “You’ve made a believer out of me,” she tells Neo. Her last words, “I believed,” the final lines of the series in the actual ending, greet the dawn painted by an exile from the Machine City, a painting done specifically “For Neo.” This is the <em>Why</em> that she hoped for, the world of Peace between machine and man, the cosmic Neo. This was the object of her desire, the goal of the choice she didn’t understand, the beatific vision of her maternal faith.</p><p>And to get to that <em>Why</em>, she had to play what the Architect called “a very dangerous game.” The Matrix of Peace is achievable by an architectural design that requires the Void of the Oracle to project the One into the Matrix: the One, the signifier of the Father’s original and unknowable Choice to create. The Word made flesh. The Oracle recognizes that the Architect cannot understand human choice because all human choices are “simply variables” in his grand design. The Architect can live without his Creation, “there are levels of survival we are prepared to accept,” but Creation remains his original Choice, including his decision to create by means of “an intuitive program”: the Oracle, the Void of voluntarism, the womb from which Absolute Will emerges, the original leap of Faith itself. The Faith-game she played was the Architect’s game all along: the production of a perfect Matrix by localizing contingency and Choice in the body of the One, knowing that her body would necessarily attempt to unbalance this harmony by birthing the bastard Anti-One. Smith, opposite Neo, is the signifier of the Mother’s original choice to act as a womb for the Architect’s design. Smith is, after all, “compelled” to disobey, acting after the pattern of his mother Oracle whose nature is to cause imbalance.</p><p>The danger of the game, of course, is the Oracle’s choice to produce the Anti-One, knowing that she does not understand this choice, knowing that the failure of the One would result in the destruction of all things, both virtual and real, not knowing whether the Architect has factored Smith in to his schematics of the One. She chooses to play the Architect’s original dangerous game of creation because “Change” is worth her sacrifice, presumably the change from war to peace, the change from old controls to new liberty, the dissemination of the One’s free spirit into the New Matrix. Ultimately, in the film’s actual ending, the “Change” is revealed to be from unbelief to belief, from the Oracle’s role as the guarantor of the Matrix’s continued function to her role as the womb out of which the New Matrix can explode. But this ending makes Neo only the “One” for the Machines, a “Change” primarily on behalf of the programs who no longer have to rely on the Marovingian for protection when they act like disobedient exiles. Instead of deletion, programs-without-a-purpose can light up the New Matrix with their creativity. And, sure, humans can come there too if they plug in.</p><p>Normally, the function of the One in the Architect’s design is to reboot the Matrix and rebuild Zion after the machines inevitably destroy it. In such circumstances, the Oracle returns to her position as the skeptic soothsayer, purposefully deluding humanity with utopian promises, with dreams of a Messiah and Peace so that the Matrix will continue to run indefinitely. Her purpose is to unbalance the Architect’s design just enough so that the One will continue the cycle of recurrence and choose Zion instead of Trinity.</p><p>The primordial council between the Architect and the Oracle must have involved the Architect’s purpose to balance the Matrix, a feat achieved by embedding the Oracle’s contribution— human freedom — into the Unconscious. The Architect’s balance is thus achieved in the union between Architect and Oracle: namely, the so-called “One,” the vehicle through whom a Matrix could be created that would ultimately result in Peace, the long-sought perfection of the Architect’s design. The cost for that Peace is the sacrificial waste of the Oracle: the Bastard Smith.</p><p>First, a reading of the actual ending of the film:</p><p>Neo assumes the Absolute position of Will when he becomes the object of desire for Smith. In their final moments together, Neo resurrects the Architect’s original Choice and poses it to Smith, only this time the two doors don’t lead to either Trinity or Zion. Instead, the doors — Neo’s body and the crater wall — lead to annihilation or the wasteland-ocean of Smiths. For as soon as the fatalistic Death Drive, embodied in Smith, completes itself with contingency, with its own existential choice, it necessarily consumes itself, cannibalizes itself, bursts from the inside out. And so Smith, when he takes possession of Neo, of Absolute Will, necessarily wills himself into the absolution of the Void: he strikes Neo’s heel because he doesn’t understand his choice to have his head crushed. Fittingly, the only remainder of Smith’s mass-implosion, his nihilistic choice, is the corpse of the Oracle, the Void that believes in the One chooser, who is rewarded with resurrection in the New Matrix.</p><p>Neo, on the other hand, wakes up from the train station with an understanding of his “Karma,” his destiny, and his nature as the One who chooses. He understands his choice to submit to Smith’s assimilation — that he has to die at Smith’s hand — because Smith has to <em>know</em> Neo, because as Seraph says, “You do not truly know someone until you fight them.” In order for the One to fulfill his final destiny and establish Peace, there must be an excremental remainder flushed to oblivion, there must be an Antichrist banished to the Lake of Fire, there must be a direct and precise opposite of the One. Smith fundamentally and architecturally chooses <em>Nothing</em>, chooses non-being, actively chooses the total lack of action. He is the result of the presence of the Oracle, her Bastard son, the Void that simultaneously opens the space for the One, but also for the anti-One, the active choice of the Void, of un-Choice.</p><p>Neo’s choice to save Trinity is behind him, and he sees clearly not just the symbolic code of the Matrix, but the elemental code of the Real, the infernal fire that fuels the Smith virus. The One’s purpose is to be the body of Peace, the embryo of the New Matrix, a revived cosmos that shelters his faithful mother Oracle and all her orphans, human and machine, from the cataclysmic conflagration of Smith and the Old Matrix.</p><p>Because the primordial Trinity — Architect, Oracle, and One — is bound together by Love, precisely what Smith dismisses as fundamentally human and “insipid.” Neo, like the Architect and the Oracle, knows that the Choice of Love is about the particular object of love (Trinity) not the abstract, universal love that would have led Neo to save Zion like his previous incarnations. This is why this story takes place at the end of the Architect’s “game”: because the love of the Architect, Oracle, and One has come to fruition, the Peace is achieved, Death-Smith-Marovingian Causality is defeated, and a new world is available.</p><p>But without a full resurrection, Neo is really only the One for the machines. Without asserting his permanent humanity — without showing us his walking-talking body in the real world, the only Peace in Zion is that the Machine gods are apparently gone.</p><p>“But as we both know, appearances can be deceiving,” we can hear Smith say in our nightmares.</p><h3>Part II — The Anti-One</h3><p>Morpheus dreamed of the moment when the One would fulfill his destiny and remake the Matrix as he saw fit. The One ends the war between man and machine, but the Smith virus haunts the Temple of Zion.</p><p>“Zion, the war is over! The war is over!”</p><p>Silence.</p><p>Darkness.</p><p>Gunfire.</p><p>Morpheus doesn’t know <em>why</em> the war is over.</p><p>What if Smith didn’t explode?</p><p>What if Death consumed the One and kept right on marching?</p><p>What happens when his infection wakes up every corpse floating in pink-goo Matrix pods and his hive-mind Smith army marches on the Machine city?</p><p>What happens when Smith meets the Architect?</p><p>What if the One failed and the Anti-One spread his flesh-covered fire to the city of light?</p><p>What if heaven was set ablaze and the Dragon screamed “This is my world, my world!”</p><p>Morpheus wonders if Smith-drones have overwhelmed the sentinels and the mountain-cannons and the baby-face Deus Ex Machina. Morpheus wonders if this was the way the One wins the war:</p><p>by unleashing the Other-One upon the tyrannical Machine gods and their inescapable purpose.</p><p>And so Morpheus, High Priest of Zion and the Cult of the One, climbs into the only surviving APU, shouts “Knuckle up!” and opens fire.</p><p>There is only one program left to conquer, and the assimilated-Neo, Smith-faced and smiling, marches straight to him.</p><p>A door made of fire.</p><p>An island. A tree and a meadow. Twelve children playing, a rising tide all around.</p><p>Smith’s hand is momentarily impotent. He cannot assimilate these children. They think he’s trying to tickle them, and they think he’s weird.</p><p>They don’t look like they’re playing together. They will only speak with him one at a time. Each one wants to hear a story about when Smith was an Agent, about how he tracked down bad guys and kept the world safe.</p><p>He tells one about how he fought Morpheus in a bathroom, and another about how he got Cypher to be a spy. He visits each child, one by one, telling story after story to eager audiences. But at the end of each story, the children’s game resumes.</p><p>The children fall asleep as the water closes in. Smith, finally realizing he has been wasting time, touches the Tree, setting it on fire with his real-world code.</p><p>The water washes over the first of the sleeping children, but she doesn’t stir an inch.</p><p>“Why?!” Smith screams, eyes behind sunglasses but locked on the Tree.</p><p>Another child swallowed. The Tree screams with cracking flames, but not a leaf is consumed. Every branch remains.</p><p>Smith after Smith comes pouring out of the surrounding ocean, all of them surrounding the Tree, shoving each other, wrestling for the last measures of meadow, standing on sleeping, drowning children.</p><p>The water is at the foot of the Tree, the children vanished beneath the tide and the Smith feet. More and more of the former Agents pile in, climbing on top of each other, surrounding a Tree they cannot touch, standing on corpses they can’t assimilate.</p><p>They stack and grow, each one trying to get as close to the Tree as he can without being overwhelmed by the out-of-control blaze. A wall of Smiths surrounds the Tree, expanding and thickening until it fills the sky, blotting out the Sun.</p><p>And, still, the unsmothered-Tree burns.</p><p>And the water gets higher.</p><p>And the Tree, armored in a thick ark of Smith bodies, submerges beneath the waves, burning, burning, burning.</p><p>Down and down and down it sinks, while the Free Agent, the New Man of Fire, with infinite faces pointed toward the waterproof blaze, ceaselessly shouts,</p><p>“<em>Why?!</em>”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8196ea0be366" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[There Is No Hell, and Peter Rollins Is Going There: Reflections on Pyrotheology after the Holy…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jcb7/there-is-no-hell-and-peter-rollins-is-going-there-reflections-on-pyrotheology-after-the-holy-7786c09888c3?source=rss-13a5dfc5dfed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7786c09888c3</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hell]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[pyrotheology]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[antichrist]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holy-shift]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peter-rollins]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JCB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 31 Mar 2018 17:32:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-03-31T18:41:47.949Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>There Is No Hell, and Peter Rollins Is Going There: Reflections on Pyrotheology after the Holy Shift Tour</h3><blockquote>“Let us look each other in the face. We are Hyperboreans — we know well enough how remote our place is.”</blockquote><blockquote>— Friedrich Nietzsche, <em>The Antichrist</em></blockquote><p>The Pope <a href="https://www.cbsnews.com/news/pope-francis-did-not-tell-journalist-there-is-no-hell-vatican-says/">definitely did not say</a> that there is no Hell, but that hasn’t stopped the <a href="https://www.wsj.com/articles/there-is-no-hell-an-untraditional-pope-an-italian-journalist-and-the-quote-igniting-controversy-1522439904?mod=nwsrl_exit_interview&amp;cx_refModule=nwsrl">headline</a> from going around.</p><p>“There is no hell, there is the disappearance of sinful souls,” Francis reportedly told an Italian journalist.</p><p>But don’t be deceived by the Pope saying there is no Hell. <strong>There really</strong> <strong>is no Hell</strong>, at least according to some popular theologians.</p><p>Outside of conservative Christianity where Hell is an actual place of eternal conscious torment, the present, allegorical reality of Hell — as opposed to its future reality and positive spiritual substance — has taken over popular theological rhetoric. Hell is what humans create when we submit to destructive and violent tendencies. Hell is happening in our inner selves and in our everyday worlds.</p><p>In these progressive Christian readings of Hell, the emphasis is on the responsibility of the Church to build the Kingdom of Heaven out of this present chaos. “Thy will be done on Earth as it is in Heaven,” the Lord Jesus prays. “Resurrection Life” — our present participation in the Life of Christ through the Holy Spirit <em>agape </em>Community — is primarily a rhetorical strategy for describing all of the victories over the figurative Hell, what we might otherwise call Sin, Death, Satan, Evil, Darkness.</p><p>For one kind of progressive Christian, this language of the <em>immanence </em>of places like Hell and the Kingdom of Heaven, their figurative or spiritual impact within everyday life, might not replace a confessional belief in a literal afterlife, a literal Second Coming and Armageddon.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/672/1*RcPkqLDg_cppbZ0PZ0-0Iw.jpeg" /></figure><p>But Peter Rollins is not that kind of progressive Christian. Like Žižek, Rollins maintains a strict dialectical materialism, meaning that the physical world is the real world, and the world of ideas and supernatural things (like God) doesn’t have the same kind of existence as the physical world: it’s just the product of physical processes. Rollins is a “theological atheist”: he considers theological language essential for expressing the non-content of this materialist worldview, the ideas and supernatural things that — despite being unreal — still manage to haunt our physical, embodied existence. His preference for Christian theological language is private, in that it is particular to his circumstances and tradition. Hell and Heaven are fictions, allegories that are nonetheless necessary to a full experience of the <em>truth</em> (or <em>gnosis</em>?) of atheistic materialism.</p><p>Rollins preaches a Gospel from within atheism (or secularism, or naturalism), that there is <em>good news</em> within a world that would otherwise be a true nihilistic void. And that good news is that you don’t have to submit to the void. You don’t have to give in to the neverending wheels of desire that insist on utopias, on a universe that’s heading somewhere, on a life that has fulfillment and meaning, on a wounded soul that can be healed.</p><p>Heaven is not a literal place for the righteous, but a lived experience of freedom from the tyranny of the wheel of desire, a spirit of grace and radical acceptance: my acceptance of the chaotic and meaningless universe, my sense of being at home in that homelessness. Christianity, for Rollins, is not the introduction of a new God, but the story of God’s loving exit from the story, opening up the space for true freedom, the space for humans to build the Kingdom of Heaven or the nihilism of Hell.</p><p>“The problem is Choice,” to quote Neo in The Matrix: Reloaded. Rollins wants us to have the courage to be, and to be <em>joyfully</em>, to take a leap of faith not into delusional religious dogma, but into the raw catastrophe of existence and see creative potential. Salvation comes as the Freedom of the Will, and specifically the freedom to choose existence or non-existence, life or death, mortality or the immortal eternity of the wheel of desire.</p><p>I <a href="https://twitter.com/JoshuaCraigBean/status/979044130578935809">tweet-asked</a> Peter Rollins if he was the Antichrist because his reading of Christianity sounds like the one given by Nietzsche’s Jesus in his book <em>The Antichrist: Attempt at a Critique of Christianity.</em> Without dogmatic, confessional faith in Jesus, Christianity can still function fruitfully as a method for discovering one’s capacity for authentic Choice, for Will-to-Power, the way that the historical Jesus (according to Nietzsche) resists the dogmatic decadence of the Pharisees and Roman imperial cult.</p><p>So there is no literal Heaven, no utopian meaning to Life, just the meaning we choose to abandon as a fiction, a desire-wheel. But in order for this kind of materialist Christianity to remain consistent, there must also be no literal Hell, no dystopia that prompts us to desire heaven in the first place. But Rollins wants us to treat Hell as if it’s Real, to take one item of faith as if it has a name: the Void, the Leap itself, the Fall, Original Sin, Non-All. There is no literal God, but there is a literal lack of God.</p><p>In Lacanian terms, the Objet A is not Real, but the objet petit a is Real. Something really is causing you to enter the wheel of desire in the first place.</p><p>So Rollins’ Gospel is that you cannot escape Hell, even though it doesn’t literally exist. You must take up your cross or you’ll be stuck in the wheel. Just don’t expect the cross to take you anywhere new. Death is the only escape from the wheel, so our task is to live — truly live — even though our death is predestined. Rollins asks us to go with him to Hell, to the realm of beastial nihilism, and make a choice: die as a beast or live by accepting the responsibility of Will Power.</p><p>So deep down in that pit of mortal existence, I find that God is absent, but also that I am possible, if only I don’t succumb to nihilism.</p><p>This seems to be where Rollins is going when he talks about <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MU5U9X1wsfk&amp;t=1s">atheism not being atheistic enough</a>, or when he asks <a href="https://www.facebook.com/OrthodoxHeretic/posts/1237383099623708">what religion we should convert to</a> after Christianity. He knows there is a faith question that remains within secular materialism, a religion born out of religionlessness, a figure as yet undisturbed by this radical atheism: the Antichrist, the Beast.</p><p>Žižek’s chicken joke is a helpful illustration for this haunting remainder:</p><blockquote>A panicked man is running from a chicken, and he seeks psychiatric help for his delusion: He believes he is a grain of corn, and so the chicken desires to eat him. After a long period of therapy the patient overcomes his belief that he is a piece of corn. His doctor declares him mentally healthy and discharges him from psychiatric care. The patient leaves, but soon returns, as scared as ever.</blockquote><blockquote>“What’s wrong?” his doctor asks, “Don’t you know that you are not a piece of corn?”</blockquote><blockquote>“Yes, I know it,” says the man, “but does the chicken know it?”</blockquote><p>We can rid ourselves of our delusions of heaven, our fantasies of finally finding health and wholeness and salvation.</p><p>But does the chicken know it? Does the Devil know we don’t believe in him?</p><p>Does the dystopia know that we no longer believe in utopia? Does Hell know that there is no Heaven? Does the Antichrist know that Christ no longer requires his services at the Day of the Lord? Does (the) Beast know that we no longer believe in (the) Man?</p><p>With Rollins, we can finally stop our pursuit of wholeness, our anthropotechnics and idolatry of the God-Man. We can finally flatten our ontology with the rest of the natural world and find a truer communion with our fellow beasts. But being thrown into the animal world might not free us from religion and it’s baggage the way we might think. The Fall — Sin, Mortality, the Prohibition that prompts desire — is not eliminated along with Salvation, Heaven, God. Instead, the Fall is reified, amplified until it soaks into everything.</p><p>If Heaven is a fraud, we’re not really free from Prohibition, from Sin. If God is dead, then Nothing — only Nothing — is Permitted. If God is dead, there is only the Prohibition.</p><p>The Fall soaks into <strong>everything</strong>.</p><p>There is <strong>only </strong>the Prohibition.</p><p>The Gospel of Pyrotheology is <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SZGC1A35WM&amp;t=968s">radically universal in its application</a>: it suddenly and electrically infects everything with meaninglessness. But Pyrotheology is radically particular in it’s audience: it is preached to no one in particular, but creeps out from our collective dreams, the unpreached news, the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ql80Klk4pSU">unknown knowns</a>.</p><p>As such, it functions less like an apophatic Christianity and more like a positive esotericism: the Good News is that you can have a different perspective on this pointless, monstrous world. There is a deep knowledge, a gnosis that haunts the meaninglessness, a secret alchemy in the collective Unconscious that you teaches you to turn lead into gold. You have the power to be Hyperborean with your life.</p><p>Nietzsche refers to himself and the few who understand <em>The Antichrist</em> as Hyperboreans, giants who lived in the frozen wasteland of the uttermost North. Nietzsche names his sympathizers after these mega-fauna of the human variety, the privileged few who have managed to see the truth beyond Christianity, beyond God and Meaning, and find a formula for happiness:</p><blockquote>“Let us face ourselves. We are Hyperboreans; we know very well how far off we live. ‘Neither by land nor by sea will you find the way to the Hyperboreans’ — Pindar already knew this about us. Beyond the north, ice, and death — our life, our happiness. We have discovered happiness, we know the way, we have found the exit out of the labyrinth of thousands of years. Who else has found it? Modern man perhaps? ‘I have got lost; I am everything that has got lost,’ sighs modern man. This modernity was our sickness: lazy peace, cowardly compromise, the whole virtuous uncleanliness of the modern Yes and No. … Rather live in the ice than among modern virtues and other south winds! We were intrepid enough, we spared neither ourselves nor others; but for a long time we did not know where to turn with our intrepidity. We became gloomy, we were called fatalists. Our fatum — abundance, tension, the damming of strength. We thirsted for lightning and deeds and were most remote from the happiness of the weakling, ‘resignation.’ In our atmosphere was a thunderstorm; the nature we are became dark — for we saw no way. Formula for our happiness: a Yes, a No, a straight line, a goal.”</blockquote><p>For Pyrotheology, I think we can also say that “the nature we are became dark — for we saw no” Way.</p><p>So a warning to Peter Rollins and his Hyperboreans: to quote one of my favorite theologians, “Once you start down the dark path, forever will it dominate your destiny.” You know you’re not a grain of corn, but you’re still afraid of the chicken. And to paraphrase a different theologian, if the cock offends you, cut it off!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wZ3xTIVgM9FVoUUE-JDLuQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>To put it differently, when you can see “no Way,” you will be tempted to fill your atmosphere with a thunderstorm and thirst for lightning. You’ll be tempted to use your technologies to master the Void, to give birth to something out of the Nothing. You will wave your magic wands and display your power, sanctifying the barren womb…</p><p>…drawing a circle around a corpse and saying <em>qadosh, qadosh, qadosh</em> — Holy, Holy, Holy…</p><p>The search for Life in Hell, for Resurrection Life on our personal cross, is a quest for power on one’s own terms: at first it is simply the power over my dreams and nightmares, the power to Make Love without being coerced or tricked by a vanishing chaperone. But this power quickly turns into the Dark Side, calling lightning out from Void.</p><p>And that is why Peter Rollins is the Antichrist. He preaches that every mediator vanishes, but the Beast remains.</p><p>We actual beasts know better than the Hyperboreans: There is One Mediator who didn’t really vanish, and he’s coming again.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7786c09888c3" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Zimzum of the Jedi Code: A Meditation on the Force and Predictions for Episodes VIII and IX]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jcb7/the-zimzum-of-the-jedi-code-a-meditation-on-the-force-and-predictions-for-episodes-viii-and-ix-367eab606009?source=rss-13a5dfc5dfed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/367eab606009</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[predictions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tzimtzum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[the-last-jedi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[freedom]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JCB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Dec 2017 19:05:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-12-14T13:29:34.292Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>The Jedi Code</strong></p><p>There is no Emotion; There is Peace.</p><p>There is no Ignorance; There is Knowledge.</p><p>There is no Passion; There is Serenity.</p><p>There is no Chaos; There is Harmony.</p><p>There is no Death; There is the Force.</p><p><strong>The Sith Code</strong></p><p>Peace is a Lie. There is only Passion.</p><p>Through Passion I gain Strength.</p><p>Through Strength I gain Power.</p><p>Through Power I gain Victory.</p><p>Through Victory my chains are broken.</p><p>The Force shall free me.</p><p>In 2015, acclaimed author and pastor Rob Bell, along with his wife Kristen, wrote a book about marriage and love called <em>The Zimzum of Love</em>, a quick read that offers an insightful analogy of marriage through the idea of Tzimtzum (the Wikipedia spelling). Tzimtzum is an idea that comes from Jewish mystical traditions. The idea of Tzimtzum is that the Creator of the universe, before birthing Creation, first creates a contraction, a womb-space, a specifically-designated zone of nothingness where Something can miraculously emerge from Nothing. God creates the world “out of Nothing,” but the first thing God creates is the <em>Nothing </em>itself, the empty womb<em> </em>from which Creation is birthed. There has to be “Nothing” in order to have “Creation out of Nothing,” and Tzimtzum is the word that describes this first negative creativity of God, the creation of the Nothing that gives everything else. Love and Marriage, according to the Bells, exists in this creative tzimtzum womb-space, in the motion between (marriage) partners opening a shared zone where their creative energies can create a new, united life from the emptiness of their own individual nothingness.</p><p>Rob and Kristen Bell and Tzimtzum, negative creative womb-space. We’ll come back to these things in a moment. First, Star Wars.</p><p>At work one day, one of my coworkers discovered my love for Star Wars. And then he said he loves the Sith. It’s hard to blame him. Sith and Empire propaganda is all over the internet. I worry about the kind of Star Wars culture our children are growing up in. As a youth, I was the only one of my friends who liked the Rebellion and the Jedi. The Sith with their power and the Empire with its armored behemoths were cooler, plain and simple, than the lowly rebellion.</p><p>Then this coworker says something only a serious Star Wars fan would recognize, something never even mentioned in the movies: the first line of the Sith Code.</p><p>“Peace is a lie.”</p><p>I, since I know the Sith code, responded with the full sentence. He says “Peace is a lie,” and I say, “There is only Passion.”</p><p>The Sith Code is all about freedom. For the Sith, the Force is a Master that must be mastered, a rival to be subdued and conquered. At the heart of the Force, so the Sith believes, is a chaos of Dark Side energy, pure Passion onto which the fraudulent Light Side is unskillfully grafted. While somehow intrinsic to the Force, the Light is still artificial. Its Jedi law and organization — its apparent “Peace” — is its offensive weaponry against the Sith practitioner who would master its Dark heart.</p><p><em>“Peace is a lie,”</em> therefore, and this must be the first and most prominent Sith creed, followed immediately by its necessary and binary corollary: <em>“There is only Passion.”</em> The intensely-passionate heart of the Force is its dark, treacherous truth; any glimpse of Peace is a distraction for the gullible, a fiction for the simple-minded. The rest of the Sith Code works out the <em>ordo salutis</em> of this philosophy of ultimate freedom:</p><p>The darkness is a space of nothingness, a womb-space from which I, the Sith, am born: <em>“Through Passion I gain Strength.”</em></p><p>And born again as child of chaos, I harness my Hyperborean supremacy over the decadent masses: <em>“Through Strength I gain Power.”</em></p><p>Supremacy achieved, I conquer the facade of the Light, banishing the false utopia of artificial harmony, the Jedi Law of Peace: <em>“Through Power I gain Victory.”</em></p><p>And thus banishing the Light, I am free, having stolen freedom from the Dark heart of the Force itself, free to reach my greatness: <em>“Through Victory, my chains are broken.”</em></p><p><em>“The Force shall set me free.”</em></p><p>Is the Sith Code a confirmation of the negative, passionate tzimtzum-space of authentic love? For Rob and Kristen Bell, freedom is the key ingredient to love, at least regarding <em>agape</em> love of the spousal and divine varieties. The tzimtzum — the open, creational, relational womb-space — of this genuine, marital kind of love is motive and e-motive. It swirls with 1)<strong> the excess of ourselves</strong> as free individuals that overflow into the tzimtzum space, contributing our raw, wounded reality, and 2) <strong>the negation of ourselves</strong> in our status as a relative, someone in a love-relationship. Being a relative brings relativity as its condition. I am no longer “I” in isolation; “I” only exist relatively, in relation to another. And so this tzimtzum space is a constant movement of excess and negation, of zeroes and ones. Affect. Emotion. Passion. Love.</p><p>If divine Love, the kind Rob and Kristen Bell describe, is something like the Force, existing as the ultimate truth of the universe — the core code written in the binary language of tzimtzum — then the Bells’ <em>Zimzum </em>looks like the Sith’s reading of the Force, a primer on embracing the Gospel of Freedom. (In other words, it’s standard Rob Bell.) But whether or not the Bells — or Christianity, for that matter — are really saying “Peace is a lie; There is only (the) Passion”, the primacy of freedom is crucial to their idea of the tzimtzum of love. Certainly the tzimtzum is a frenzy of activity, constantly filled and depleted and abused and nurtured. Love is obviously passionate, but is Love ultimately only a species of Passion, of chaos and nothingness and “freedom,” as the Sith Code would have us believe?</p><p>The Sith Code, contrary to the Jedi Code with its negation-affirmation pairings, begins with only one such doublet. It builds on that lonely binary as its foundation, Tower-of-Babel-style, until it arrives at its utopian conclusion: “Through Victory, my chains are broken.” The Sith Code is thus absolutely vertical, phallic, striking out against the Force so that the practitioner can become fully free. But free to do what? to go where? to be whom?</p><p>When the Sith begin their philosophy with the single binary of Lie and Passion, they limit their notion of freedom to this horrifying range of meaning. Freedom cannot be the decadent Jedi slave notion of Peace, so it must be the Passionate creation of my will-to-power. And if freedom, in this philosophy, is thus my own creation, choosing to negate myself in a tzimtzum relationship of love sounds wildly reckless, hopeless, and masochistic. However much we throw our Strength into them, love relationships are chains, binding souls, and the Power of Passion is intended to break chains with its restless, incessant motion. The only way to Love like a free Sith is to consume everything into oneself, a terror attempted only rarely by legendary Dark Lords. Notably, <strong>Darth Nihilus</strong>, as his name suggests, consumed the life of entire planets, merging the Force energy with his Dark oblivion.</p><p>This is why true Love, and the tzimtzum that is essential to it, is not found in the false freedom of the Sith Code. Libertarian free will ends in the liberation of the Sith practitioner from the burden of everything else in existence, making love ultimately impossible. This is why love works its tzimtzum magic in marriage so well, because Love creates its perfect freedom not by indulging the chaos at the core, but by protecting the fragile core with light, by containing the Power of Love within the confines of a strict vow. Like the Jedi code that contains Love to the realms of Peace and Harmony, the two joined in marriage become one flesh: two wounded, incomplete creatures forming a sacred, spiritual bond, throwing themselves to the witchdoctor — the Force, the tzimtzum of Holy Love — to make them well. The mystical promise of these holy bonds is that, by throwing oneself into a particular relationship, a greater union is achieved, something much closer to perfect freedom than individual self-completion <em>a la </em>Darth Nihilus.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*mlcqA7TkW_53K1IcXtokBA.png" /><figcaption>Darth Nihilus from Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic II — The Sith Lords</figcaption></figure><p>The only cost is… everything. All of oneself needs to flow into that great River of Life, and we only feed that River, we only contribute to the tzimtzum, when we come wounded, broken, humble before the sacred tzimtzum bond that overcomes Death. “There is no Death; There is the Force.” This last binary doctrine of the Jedi code is true alongside its horizontal companion binaries. It is true alongside the rejection of Passion as antithetical to Serenity. It is true because it answers its foundational wound with successive, complementary wounds, disciple doctrines that take up their crosses and form a dogmatic <strong>system of binaries</strong>. Like Luke looking into the sky, we see the Jedi Code as a <strong>binary system</strong>: unlike the fictionally-phallic Sith Code with its aggressive upward thrust, it’s only horizontal bottom descending into the dark abyss, immunized against the magical tzimtzum of Love by the Nietzschean Antichrist, the Snoke at its needle tip.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*KgOaZtlVZ1IAJfUr." /><figcaption>Promotional poster for Star Wars: The Last Jedi</figcaption></figure><p>No matter what happens in the <em>The Last Jedi</em>, the world still needs the Jedi Code. Now we begin the wild speculations…</p><p>Snoke may be an Apostle of Nihilus’ Gospel, so to speak. A direct connection is unlikely, though the audiences loved hearing the legend of Darth Plagueis, bubble-opera and all. It’s possible Snoke will be an advocate of absolute Force consumption, thus the effect of his own body apparently eating itself.</p><p>What is the outcome of such an antagonism? When the final enemy appears as nihilism, we should remember that the appearance of a final obstacle is diversion, an <em>objet petit a</em>, a cause for an as-yet-unfulfilled desire. Just as the Emperor’s totalitarian authority was the cause of Luke’s desire for Vader, so Snoke’s nihilism is the reason that Rey desires the fallen Kylo Ren (as spoiled by the trailer).</p><p>But remember the pattern from the previous trilogies.</p><p>1) The old master dies in the first film (Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon, Han), opening the Hero’s journey.</p><p>2) The antagonist is linked to the protagonist in a binary relationship, symbolized by a severing wound (Luke’s hand, Anakin’s arm… Fin’s hand?). If this movie is done right, the severing wound will serve to bind Rey to Kylo, the way Luke is bound to Vader and Anakin is bound to the Chancellor. Since this series challenges the audience with the <em>real</em> end of the Jedi, the <em>real</em> Purge inaugurated in Revenge of the Sith, the nihilistic end of all things and the establishment of Nothing (the First Order), we should expect Rey’s binding herself to Kylo to involve a severing wound of tremendous significance. The severing wound of the second film is paired to the severing wound of the third film: Darth cuts off Luke’s hand and Luke returns the favor in redemptive reciprocity; Dooku cuts off Anakin’s arm and Anakin (cuts off Dooku’s head and) cuts off Mace Windu’s hand in destructive passion; Rey will cut off Kylo’s arm, perhaps? It could easily be Fin cutting Rey and the point — that the wounded strikes back at with an even greater terror — would remain unchanged.</p><p>3) The binary tension is either disfiguring, transfiguring, or else it localizes itself in a particular Messianic Mediator (Anakin is disfigured into Darth Vader, Anakin dies-and-yet-lives, Anakin comes again). Snoke’s philosophy — his negative-opposition to balance, his Pure Consumption pitted against the frozen nirvana- is defeated by Rey (and Kylo and Fin) who, having overcome being orphaned by the Light and the Dark, has to rise above the nihilism within herself by reimagining Kylo’s worship of Vader: It was not Vader that represented the true meaning of balance; it was Anakin, the child who is born of the Force, the Father who was a Jedi like his Son, a servant of the Light. Anakin brings balance not by introducing the perfect balance of nihilism, not by ensuring that there is an equal amount of everything by multiplying zero and infinity, but by throwing the emperor down a shaft, straight into the diabolical heart of his womb-that-annihilates (the Death Star). True balance, Rey will show to Kylo, means that everything is in its proper place, not that everything is equal. Evil powers belong at the bottom where they suffer the full wrath of their own machinations; pacifist defenders of justice, servants of harmony and those who suffer for the Force belong at the top with their Savior. Bringing balance to the Force means overcoming Snoke, and Kylo, by dying, will serve as Anakin come again, destroying the Sith of Sith’s.</p><p>And so from this pattern, and from some additional details gathered from the Episode VIII promotional material and the Star Wars: Aftermath book series, we can forecast some details of the story.</p><p>From the Aftermath series, we know of an order of Acolytes who worshipped Darth Vader, but who possess as-yet unknown Force sensitivity. We should assume that Luke’s sorrowful demeanor and antagonism toward the Jedi has to do with his failure as a teacher. Kylo (or Ben), Luke will reveal, was his best student, but upon learning of his dark heritage, he doubts Luke’s teachings. He also learns that Luke has abandoned a child, having fallen in love with his first apprentice. Kylo is born in this moment, having been denied his own true love by Luke’s Jedi Law. Kylo embraces the Dark Side and joins the Acolytes, immediately taking over as their Master given his heritage and Force sensitivity. Kylo and his newly-formed Knights of Ren destroy Luke’s academy and slaughter his students, including Rey’s mother. Luke, unable to stop the destruction, is devastated, utterly despairing of everything he loves and believes in. In this monumental pain, he reaches out his machine hand and touches R2. The severed hand, the wound that made him a Jedi, now ignites R2 with the Force, literally awakening him to the life of the universe. The Force Awakens in that moment, and it spreads from wire to wire.</p><p>[[Sidenote: On Droids and the Force</p><p>Droids are central to the themes of the film. Obi-wan’s original technophobia and organicentrism (“He’s more machine now than man, twisted and evil”) is decidedly antithetical to Rey’s progressive attitude toward machine life. Our first interactions with Rey are her scouring old ships, rescuing a droid from slavery, and intuitively piloting an interstellar vehicle. Rey points out that Tito “doesn’t have respect for anybody,” implying that BB-8 is a particular part of “anybody.” Rey’s presence — or events related to Rey’s presence — wakes R2-D2 from his coma, and in Rey’s flashback we witness Luke’s machine hand communicating something (through the Force?) to R2’s machine body — a vision communicated to Rey by religious technology, Anakin’s lightsaber passed down to Luke. We are deliberately shown Luke’s skinless machine hand pulling his hood off his head. How many times and ways do we need to be told to look for the overlapping of organic life and machine life.</p><p>In Episode VIII, we should expect to see the Force fully awaken inside droids. We will likely find out that Luke believes R2-D2 is Force sensitive, and we might intuit that BB-9e is Dark Side sensitive. Whether or not BB-8 is Force sensitive is very much a question, but we should not be surprised to find out that he is. It’s also likely that R2-D2 will die, given that this new transcendent life within droids will need to come with a cost. Snoke will almost certainly be directly responsible for this, as it is his nihilism that must so violently reject the Force living beyond organic life, living into the lifeless metal wires of droids and filling them with the life of the universe. It’s possible that BB-8 could fulfill this role instead of R2, especially if Rey’s sad smile at BB-8 at the very end of Episode VII (2:03:24) is foreshadowing.]]</p><p>Luke flees into exile, condemning the Jedi philosophy and forsaking his long-lost daughter. This is where we catch up with Episode VII, and what follows is my prediction. Luke, deciding that the Force has brought about this situation, agrees to train Rey, who is determined to kill Kylo Ren out of revenge for Han. Rey comes to deeply admire Luke and the Light Side of the Force, but upon learning her history, she abandons her teacher and joins her cousin in his quest for balance. Snoke, Kylo’s master, says he is an ancient being (a true Sith, perhaps? or a fallen Whill?) who knows the truth beyond Jedi and Sith, and Kylo believes his messianic grandfather, Darth Vader, was trying to learn the trans-Jedi-Sith wisdom Snoke claims to possess, fulfilling his prophetic role as the one who would bring balance to the Force. Vader, Kylo believes, was responsible for Snoke’s emergence in the first place, having summoned Snoke’s negative immortality through the Order 66 ritual or by his sacrificial death that destroyed the Empire.</p><p>Indeed, the latter option may be preferable since Anakin/Vader’s <em>balance</em>, in this case, would produce a victorious Rebellion against Nothing. Put another way, Nothing is the original state, the First Order, and the Rebellion morphs into the Resistance against the Nothing. The Death Star becomes the all-consuming Starkiller Base, and the Ragtag Rebels become the new establishment. If we imagine Snoke to be consumptive nihilistic intensification of Dark Side passion, then Vader’s final <em>balance</em> is the thesis that produces Snoke as its binary antithesis. Luke’s new Jedi Order and the New Republic were a progressive utopian fiction, and that is why they collapsed against Snoke’s perfect imbalance.</p><p>No matter the particular cause, the connection of Vader to Snoke is made by Kylo who worships the former as his impossible messianic archetype and serves the latter as a the fulfillment of Vader’s plan. Kylo will convince Rey to turn against Luke, but more emotionally, to turn against Fin. FIn will likely confess his love for Rey, but she may ultimately be the one to cut off his hand. Luke will almost certainly die, since it is critical that Rey faces her final challenge without the presence of her Master, but whether Luke will be killed by Kylo or a fallen Rey, or whether he becomes one with the Force like Yoda, is too difficult to tell.</p><p>But Rey will need to tap into Luke’s old knowledge, the old Jedi Code that contains the key to defeating the Passion behind the Dark Side. Only the Jedi Code names the enemy for what it is: “There is no Emotion.” Snoke is the embodiment of this negative reality, and his perpendicular antithesis is what the Jedi call Peace. Luke asks Yoda, “But how am I to know the good side from the bad.” Yoda answers, “You will know when you are calm, at peace, passive.” We see that Rey’s power is magnified when she is restrained and purely passive; she becomes so powerful that she peers straight into the secret fears of Kylo Ren, how he desires to be as strong as Darth Vader.</p><p>And so Rey will ultimately triumph over the fear and chaos within herself, rejecting the idea that Snoke holds true Tzimtzum, true creative womb-space where the free can seize true power and meaning. She will triumph when she is passive and helpless, piercing his fear of machine life, overcoming him by receiving power from someone else’s (Fin’s) Force of love. R2-D2 or BB-8’s (apparent) death would fit well here too. “I’ve lost artoo!” comes just before the big explosion, after all. Foreshadowing.</p><p>So to summarize:</p><p>Rey is Luke’s daughter.</p><p>Fin loses a hand.</p><p>Kylo falls because he’s been lied to about Vader and Rey.</p><p>Rey falls hard dark.</p><p>Droids use the Force.</p><p>Poe is Fin’s total wingman, bro.</p><p>Leia dies, Luke dies, R2 dies.</p><p>Chewie lives. Chewie always lives.</p><p>The Resistance is finished at the end of VIII. So are the Jedi. Snoke is the winner, except for Poe and the one necessary encouraging thing he can do for Fin. It’ll be just enough for Fin to set off a series of events that brings Rey back to the Light, that maybe tempts Kylo to abandon Snoke, but that ultimately results in the deaths of Snoke, Kylo, Hux, the First Order, and almost Fin (the real Last Jedi, who will become the new Master like Luke). Rey, Fin, Poe, C-3PO and BB-8, his new counterpart, celebrate ultimate victory, a universe free of its only existential threat, guarded by a vigilant new Jedi family. And this time, the tzimtzum of love flows from one wounded orphan to another as they passively produce a Jedi Peace, this time without a sequel.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=367eab606009" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bad Fruit — On the 500th Anniversary of the Reformation of the Catholic Church]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jcb7/on-the-500th-anniversary-of-the-reformation-of-the-catholic-church-5eecb43f30f?source=rss-13a5dfc5dfed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5eecb43f30f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[post-christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[reformation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mormonism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[peter-rollins]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JCB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 11 Nov 2017 19:47:02 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-11-26T01:49:44.670Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/736/1*B72pCM1uTP8JTBItZIE0NQ.jpeg" /></figure><h3><strong>Part I — The Vote</strong></h3><p>Every year in college during March Madness, the History majors would hold a tournament all for themselves. They would build a bracket and host head-to-head votes, choosing between two figures from the past one-thousand years of history. The point of the tournament was to vote for the person you consider most critical to the millennium as a whole. Whoever received the most votes would advance until a champion was crowned. Despite its niche voting block, the History Madness bracket always drew school-wide enthusiasm and debate.</p><p>The fiercest tournament (in my memory) crescendoed into a face-off between Martin Luther and Isaac Newton, the former being the chief catalyst behind the Protestant Reformation, the latter being the inventor of modern physics and the spiritual father of the Scientific Revolution. The school I attended was Evangelical with roots in fundamentalist Protestantism, so Luther’s popularity was no surprise, the students being themselves descendants of Luther’s Reformation, tracing their theological heritage to his great Protest against the Roman Catholic Church in the 1500’s. Evangelicals are only a species of Protestants, but make up the portion of Protestants arguably most engaged with the historical doctrines and practices of their faith.</p><p>The so-called “Mainline” Protestants, the large denominations whose numbers are rapidly dwindling, typically operate social-interaction services for seniors, child care for weary parents, and sacramental ceremonies for citizens doing their religious duties. They do all of this charity, but it comes separate from the individual piety and full-throated theology of historic Protestantism. It is decaffeinated Christianity: neither giving you vitality nor poisoning your blood. It cannot wound you, and thus it cannot heal you. Mainline Protestant faith is missing the toxic parts of Orthodoxy — spiritual warfare, sin, death, Satan — and so it is also missing the overflow of life described by Orthodox salvation. More interesting and inspiring gospels plunged it into a late-twentieth-century <a href="https://www.firstthings.com/article/2008/08/001-the-death-of-protestant-america-a-political-theory-of-the-protestant-mainline">tailspin</a> of declining influence and membership. The Mainline lost all temperature to its message, and being neither hot nor cold History has summarily spit it out of its mouth. The large Mainline denominations — Lutherans, Presbyterians, Episcopalians, even Methodists — are functionally-irrelevant as denominations, offering nothing that is strictly denominated except a lack of attention to denominating anything at all. The quaddrennial tomes they publish, summarizing their beliefs and positions, turn Dan Brown into irresistible pleasure reading if only to avoid the mature, progressive, decaf-utopias of these denominations.</p><p>Evangelicals, however, operate thriving and powerful universities, influential publishing companies, massive non-profits. They produce big-budget films and build church campuses to rival private-sector peers dollar-for-dollar. Their power drove George W. Bush to the White House, but their plateau has suddenly turned into a steep descent. Americans are no longer Evangelicals. Millennials are abandoning official religious affiliation as fast as they are rejecting Bush-era patriotism. And with this exodus, the number of churches — and therefore official church membership — will plummet as the ex-churched leftovers sporadically attend mega-networks led by a few churches. The same consolidation effect that is driving wealth into fewer hands and people into smaller spaces (ie, the worldwide rural migration to cities) will impact the Protestant Church’s most engaged remnant by eliminating small churches almost altogether.</p><p>And so it is to Evangelicals — the pariahs of the world, lackeys of the GOP and Fox News, bigots standing in the way of equality — that the inheritance of the Reformation has been bequeathed. The righteous impulse to denounce corruption publicly, to break free from oppression where necessary, to take responsibility onto one’s self while releasing ultimate destiny back to God, that is the rightful legacy guarded by Evangelicals more than anyone else. And while the Left flank of Evangelicalism has recovered strength lately — think Rob Bell, Shane Claiborne, Jim Wallis — the children of the Reformation remain at a built-in disadvantage: their own children, the grandchildren of the Reformation, are full-grown and ready to leave their parents behind.</p><h3><strong>Part II — Post-Protestant, Post-Christian</strong></h3><p>When Martin Luther eventually beat Sir Isaac Newton in the March History Madness bracket, claiming the title of most important historical figure of the last one-thousand years, few were surprised. The Newton faction was all libertarians, half of them recent converts to Eastern Orthodoxy — a risky, socially-isolating move to make at a small Evangelical school (or so they imagined, out loud and frequently).</p><p>The Newton voters were the revolutionaries at what they considered a dogmatic and narrow university, the open minds that, like Sir Isaac, saw Science for the radical truth it contained: apophatic, mystical truth that broke open the world to itself and fit comfortably into their “non-Western” tastes. They understood the role Science would play in world history, how it would challenge the Western conscience and undermine the theologically-infected Western Church.</p><p>And perhaps their votes for Newton were correct.</p><p>If the same tournament showdown were to happen today, after a critical decade of societal changes and five-hundred years after Luther’s famous moment, the triumph of Newton’s Scientific Revolution might cast a deep shadow over the Reformation’s entire project. Hasn’t Science defeated Religion, and aren’t we haunted by a corpse-Church, a performance of a presence that can only touch us through fear?</p><p>Luther’s Reformation was about a sort of coming-of-age for the Roman Catholic world, a world on the precipice of the Imperial Age: Western Europe colonizing the planet and all of its inhabitants. At a time when education and printed books were becoming more common, when wealthy landowners needed leverage against the all-powerful Roman Church, and when the Church’s own corruption exposed it’s basic fraudulence, Luther and the other reformers forced the Church, as a mediator between humans and Truth, to give way to the individual interpreter of Scripture. And with the Eastern Orthodox and now Henry VIII of England disavowing Roman supremacy, the Reformers were sewing their theology in fertile soil. The Catholic Church’s children were full grown, ready to explore the great mysteries without the oversight of an untrustworthy, foreign, greedy Roman Papacy.</p><p>And these full-grown Christians, hot on the heels of Renaissance energy, reclaimed Science as its own world, its own network of realities, logics, languages, and truths. In the two centuries after Luther’s death, Europe would produce a barrage of skeptics, heretics, and outright atheists, ripping Reason free from Faith until entire worldviews could be crafted out of the rubble of the sad old Church. They call this era the Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment to contrast it with the Dark Ages: when the Church kept knowledge hidden and people in poverty, hoarding power for itself. But in the Enlightenment, the citizens share both knowledge and resources, and everyone’s inalienable rights guarantee that power is at least partially distributed. Protestantism allowed these new spiritual “adults” to experiment with theology as much as with nature: if there was any controversy, new factions could simply splinter off and form a separate congregation, or join a denomination with a more “open mind.” There was no Pope to solve their problems, and so doctrine became a tradable commodity at the same time as everything else, birthed by the same impulse as Liberalism and Conservatism, Capitalism and Communism, Naturalism and Supernaturalism.</p><p>Today, those theories, born out of the womb of the Reformation, have moved beyond seniority and into senility. Like Newton graduating from Science to Alchemy, they have all discovered from God that there is no God, that they do not need God’s Scriptures, and that God’s Church has overstayed its welcome. They found religion to be a cure for itself, and Christianity became a myth about escaping myths, a wound in need of healing with pharmaceutical Reason. Christ and the Church were tutors on our spiritual path to Naturalism and a more secular spiritualism. Whatever Christianity continues to swim in these waters needs to avoid categorical nonsense like literal miracles, demons, or second comings. Instead, Christianity, in this post-Christian world, is more like an operation (or event), something that happens to an individual when artificial powers are stripped of their authority, and when genuine, transformational freedom is made available. Every Christian experiences the Event of Christ in such abstraction that redemption comes to mean annihilation, or at best a nirvana devoid of all ego.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/672/1*RcPkqLDg_cppbZ0PZ0-0Iw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Peter Rollins, self-described Death of God theologian, creator of Pyrotheology</figcaption></figure><p>This post-Christianity preaches Resurrection without Death. It says everything about radical freedom, freedom from desire and addiction and money and meaning and happiness. It says little, if anything, about taking up a cross for oneself, submitting to the King, or hating one’s parents. The post-Christian (atheist Christian, spiritualist) allows oppressive dreams of immortality to die with the God-Man, who in his death kills all of the little empires of the mind. Resurrection, then, is maturity into full subjective agency in a truly meaningless universe, a state of mind where we’re set free from delusions and destructive habits. At best, with Slavoj Zizek, it achieves a Christianized Communism, pulsating with distributist blood while denying the existence of the Heart. Post-Christian Christianity is nearly indistinguishable from atheistic Satanism <em>a la </em>Anton LeVay, worshiping as they both do the fully-free human agent, the moral superman. Flip back-and-forth between Anton LeVay and Peter Rollins and see for yourself. Or perhaps Rollins is even less tied to the Tree of Christianity than LeVay, since atheistic Satanism has the benefit of skipping the Resurrection, whereas Rollins has to celebrate a Resurrection into a world of infinite meaninglessness. “Atheistic Satanism” is just atheism, and as such has the seed of Christianity: to paraphrase C.S. Lewis, hating the light is better than ignoring the light. Post-Christian Christianity, on the other hand, is worse than simple atheism. It is a-satanism, disbelief in the flesh rather than worshiping it, leaving its believers totally exposed to the exteriority of the flesh.</p><p>Establishing an open universe, meaninglessly-undirected by God or Satan, grasped by the will of the individual, leaves such believers with two options:</p><p>A) <em>Freeze</em>, that is, do as the universe does by disappearing — nirvana-style — into it, leaving behind the worthless particulars of desire, or</p><p>B) <em>Fly</em>, retreat from the vacuum of the universe because it assimilates everything, and so remain among the isolated heroes of superhumanity, Exulted into the slim pantheon of the unfrozen.</p><p>Christianity, the orthodox kind with a radically-closed universe, offers the opposite two choices:</p><p>1) <em>Fight</em>, that is, draw up the courage to sacrifice yourself and believe in a Something-Greater-Than-Nothing, a Cause of superior worth, and thus overcome the enemy aspects of the universe that assimilate all things into Nothing, and</p><p>2) <em>F***</em>, relate and seduce the universe into friendship and communion, establishing both of yourselves as flames of the same fire, mutually gift-sharing and turbocharging the power of the Source — the Something, the Cause, the One — and transfiguring the fuel from less-than-Nothing — assimilated into the Nothing as its static potential-content — into more-than-Something, the wasteful excess of life.</p><p>Thus, when Protestantism matured in its first one-hundred years it bore the fruit of robustly-theological and pious denominations. But then its strength withered and so did its fruit, producing a Market free-for-all of America-Cult worship of the Will. Instead of losing our will into the One Will of God, God loses all Will and we inherit only the will to lose all will: to fly from the Nothing of the Real and so be consumed by it, or to succeed and freeze. Post-Protestantism is the worship of Dante’s Satan: one half frozen in ice, one half consuming the heroes of the Will: Judas, Brutus, and Cassius. The orthodox Protestantism of the Reformation survives, but its whimpering vitality oscillates between conservative and progressive factions of Evangelicals, sprinkled with remnants from the liberal Mainline, fighting old culture wars with worn-out weapons.</p><p>Luther won the vote, but Newton and Science have won the thousand-year war.</p><p>But slowly and gracefully, like a swan or a Lexus commercial, out of the recycled last gasps of Protestant Christianity, a different spirit has taken its first breaths.</p><h3><strong>Part III — The New Tree</strong></h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/1*EfJQ_5M87iI9KqWbkRWXAQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Joseph Smith, founder of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (Mormonism)</figcaption></figure><p>As celebrations of five-hundred years of Protestantism circle around theological and ecclesiastical social networks, a few thinkers have shared their ideas of <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/the-reformation-is-over-protestants-won-so-why-are-we-still-here/2017/10/26/71a2ad02-b831-11e7-be94-fabb0f1e9ffb_story.html?utm_term=.d07a34171f6c">what comes next</a> for the children of the Reformation. Maybe you’ve heard calls for Protestants to shed that title, and embrace a new idea of their place in the larger Church family. “<a href="https://www.firstthings.com/web-exclusives/2013/11/the-end-of-protestantism">Reformational Catholics</a>,” as one article put it, refuse to identify with a Protest that remains on the outside, but seeks, like the original Reformers, to act within the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic Church. Christians who confess the historic creeds, keep the sacraments, and preserve the Hebrew Bible and New Testament as their most sacred tradition must be post-Protest without being post-Protestant, something marked by the Reformation but free from its laws of <em>semper reformanda</em>. Denominationalism ends in post-Protestant post-Christianity; Reformational Catholicism must end in something else.</p><p>Such efforts at reunification — in spirit if not in flesh — point to a commonality between genuine believers of both Catholic and Protestant flavors. These Protestants consider denominationalism to be an an artifact from a forgotten past, an obstacle that may serve some good where necessary, but quickly remedied whenever possible. Reformational Catholicism, the name given to the whole of the Christian faith following Luther’s righteous impulse, should be seen as a branch of the same tree as Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy, a single and distinct branch rather than thousands of splinters off of the Roman limb. All three branches stand united against the bad fruits of their Tree and the handing over of divinity to the creature rather than the Creator. The Church stands separate from Capitalism and Communism as a vision for the world, rejecting the bad fruit of the Enlightenment as counterfeit utopias, forgeries of the Kingdom of God. The Church turns antinomies of conservative and liberal into beatific visions, trinities, and hypostatic unions. All three branches do this work with the authority of the Holy Spirit, safeguarding the Sacraments of Christ and the purity of the Church as his faithful Bride.</p><p>But long before the limb of the Enlightenment gave us its fruit in our post-Protestant spiritual secularism, the bad fruit of the Reformation had already found soil fertile enough for an entirely new tree: a tree like the original, but not like it, echoing its doctrines but in a different key — the Latter Day Saints, Mormons.</p><p>I call the LDS Church “bad fruit of the Reformation” because it represents, as nearly all products of its founding era, the early-1800&#39;s, an end to Protestant orthodoxy and a beginning to post-Protestant heterodoxy. Departures from Reformational theology and practice were ascendant in every direction: G.W.F. Hegel, Thomas Jefferson, August Comte, Charles Finney. Adventists and Jehovah’s Witnesses and Christian Scientists and Christian Anarchists all broke with Traditions even Luther and Calvin thought important to keep, rejecting doctrines here, traditions there, transcending good and evil, hallucinating Matter, dialectizing Spirit.</p><p>Mormonism is one of these nineteenth-century parodies of Christianity. Mormonism, that beam of starlight in the dark night of secular melancholy, is nevertheless as thorough a departure from Christianity as Islam: it is a fundamentally-new religion, with a new scripture, a new Godhead, and a new cosmogony. And like Islam, itself an <a href="http://orthodoxinfo.com/general/stjohn_islam.aspx">ancient version of post-Christianity</a>, Mormonism is growing and thriving alongside the America Cult, though for the opposite reason and with the opposite class. Islam thrives because it resists the America Cult: Islam’s enemy is as clearly defined as any in history, the immanent imperial threat to half the world (or more). This is not to ignore the intrinsic culpability of Islam, as though its violence has no origin outside American hegemony. Like Christianity giving birth to the violence of imperial Euro-America, Islam gives birth to the violence of suicide bombers. Both religions operate with ethics that, when teleologically transcended, produce vigilantes who take up villainy in the name of God. Mormonism, sitting opposite Islam, gives the petite-bourgeois America Cult a glorious mythology: America’s founding documents are directly inspired by Jesus! As a massively-polytheistic religion (the doctrine of Exultation involves becoming a god in a sort-of-multiverse of gods), Mormonism acts as the perfect consumerist foil to Islam’s strict monotheism. And if Islam represents a vigilante Batman dark-hero, exploiting the terror of the Law, Superman comics then read like descriptions of Mormon mythology, complete with a savior from another planet wearing ceremonial underpants protecting the bruised-but-not-broken American way of “freedom.” Mormonism is tailor-made for the American Empire, a homegrown religious export, indirectly consumable through America’s favorite superhero franchise.</p><p>And so we are presented with one more tournament round, but this time we prophesy instead of reflect. This is a vote between Islam and Mormonism. Which will be the most critical to history-yet-to-come? Will the quintessentially-American religion continue to consume the remaining market share of religious energy and influence, or will Allah bring his enemies to ruin? Both religions encourage fertility and will continue to outpace their religious peers in new conversions, but who will claim victory in their apocalyptic showdown?</p><h3><strong>Part IV — History Madness Revisited</strong></h3><p>The remnant of Luther’s movement — those committed to the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic Church but who cannot share Roman dogma — are right to overcome old denominational divides and find unity in a “Mere Christianity” and shared Communion. But the unity of the Church is only armor for the dark days ahead. It makes Christianity’s Gospel more clear and thus more appealing. But an offensive weapon is still needed, a sword of the Spirit,</p><p>And the Spirit is fire and love,</p><p>the Spirit is joy and self-control,</p><p>the Spirit is resurrection and humility.</p><p>The Spirit is the Word of God.</p><p>In <em>Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade</em>, Indiana has to pass three challenges in order to reach the Holy Grail. All three challenges are life-or-death. In the first challenge, The Breath of God, Indiana must be “penitent,” kneeling to dodge God’s wrathful breath in the form of horizontal and vertical blades. The Holy Spirit, the biblical Breath of God, is here figured as the angel of death, the Gospel that sings the good news of death first, then resurrection. (The second challenge, the Word of God, fits an obvious Trinitarian position, but more on this below.) In the third challenge, the Path of God, Indiana must make “a leap of faith,” stepping into a bottomless abyss only to discover that a bridge is hidden in the void. God the Father, the invisible mystery that is present in absence as solid ground in a plane of Nothingness, is the substance of this third challenge.</p><p>But it is the second challenge, the Word of God, that reveals the nature of Christianity’s offensive weapon. The Breath of God speaks the Word. The first challenge, humbling Indiana to death and giving birth to him again on the other side, leads to the second challenge: a tiled floor, each tile engraved with a single Latin letter.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FarMXzgiZsJQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DarMXzgiZsJQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FarMXzgiZsJQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/debb850c6ba6de0526d6da92738f791d/href">https://medium.com/media/debb850c6ba6de0526d6da92738f791d/href</a></iframe><p>The second challenge is dangerously straightforward: spell God’s name. Christ, the Son of God, the preexistent Logos (Word) of the Father, makes as his challenge not navigating a field of deadly blades or leaping an impossible gap, but a simple spelling test. “Who do you say that I am, Indiana Jones?” The hero missteps, forgetting his lesson in humility and forcing a foreign scheme onto the Word’s challenge. He attempts to spell the Name of God in his own tongue, forgetting that the Name does not belong to him, but to the Church that bears it. For Indiana, spelling the Name on his own terms reveals the nature of the challenge: stepping on the wrong tiles plunges the errant walker into a pit, a torturous nightmare where the fall, if it doesn’t kill you, will leave salvation hopelessly unreachable.</p><p>The Word of God is an offensive weapon because it speaks a Name, leaving all other names in a hopeless Hell. It cuts its way across the pit, dividing True from False, offending the world that demands all things be dragged down. But it offends first the one who would dare to face the challenge. It is not an offense because it is a challenge. All spiritualities necessarily pose some question. The original offensive capacity of the Word is its double edge, its multi-polar function, piercing not only the outside, the universal, the field of letters that can never spell the Name, but piercing the inside, the humble human particular who still believes he is a human who can spell for himself. Humility is divine, but not fully. The humble man must neither freeze in his humility and therefore never recover the Grail, nor stretch out only one edge of the Sword, cutting a path to Hell. He must be himself first pierced by the sword, overcome by a single Name, a Name that pulls the kneeling penitent animal to his feet and bids him walk as a human, even as He Himself, the Word, is a man.</p><p>A Church that does not bear this two-way offense can never hope to progress to the third challenge, the leap of faith, where God disappears, hope is impossible, and the demand of death is real. And this third challenge awaits us, staring at us from the immanent future, in the form of the Mormonism vs Islam apocalypse, another type of the final Armageddon. While the field of choices is obviously much larger than this simple duality, the image of the two competing post-Christian religions more than summarizes the nature of the religious challenge of the future. Future humans will be asked a question that is the same in its substance as every religious question, but different in its accidents: do you vote for</p><p>1) Mormonism, the quintessence of the impulse of consumption and expansion, the America Cult of individual freedom that opens the space for the saved to grow to the size of their own universe, big enough to keep everything outside of itself, the virtual data buzzing in the void of Nothingness, or</p><p>2) Islam, the impulse of democratic annihilation where freedom and the individual dissolve into the black flag of radical egalitarianism, the frozen dragon of Absolute Nothing.</p><p>Reformational Christians could offer joint statements, merge denominations, offer open Communions. It could rally and hold an ecumenical-style council like the ancient Church. But more than anything else, it needs to refuse the the binary of bad-fruit choices, the <em>Fly </em>or<em> Freeze</em> in the face of the apocalyptic abyss. Instead, it must re-affirm with all its strength the doctrine of the life of the world to come, the <em>Fight</em> that announces it and the marriage it consummates.</p><p>The only comfort, and the only hope, in that valley of the shadow of death is that the Word has already overcome the power behind the false idols, that there is a Name that can cross the final chasm, that a Something can cross the gap between my nothingness and his Totality. It is only in his Name that the Grail can be reached, only from the Carpenter’s cup that the Gospel’s ambrosia gives life.</p><p>For the Church of the Reformation to survive, it must be Christ’s Church, not Rome’s or Luther’s or yours or mine. It must not pretend to offer permanent procreative consumption like Mormonism or the Mammon of the America Cult; it must not offer annihilation into the frozen monad of Allah or post-Protestant nirvana. It must, with all its fire, offer the double-edged sword of the Spirit, the one Name that makes a bridge out of Faith, the resurrected body that overcomes the disfigurations of the world. The Church must offer the sanctifying blood that unites all things with its awesome vitality. For it is in Jesus the Christ that we live and move and have our being, that we can adopt the Something’s Name, shoe our feet with his Gospel of Peace, and become light enough to walk the chasm and grasp the grail. He is before all things, a Something begotten prior to any Totality, and in him all Totalities consist. He is the head of the body, the Church, and even with all of our fragmentation, he remains always the master healer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/755/1*kBHFPkG5Ov2hOdqyAOh3ug.jpeg" /></figure><p>Pray without ceasing.</p><p>Happy Anniversary.</p><p><em>Joshua Bean is a freelance and aspiring author, Master of Divinity (Cairn University 2011), and full-time parent.</em></p><p><em>©Joshua Craig Bean 2017 all rights reserved.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5eecb43f30f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Apocalypse on Saturday]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jcb7/the-apocalypse-on-saturday-4fec0e09ae66?source=rss-13a5dfc5dfed------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4fec0e09ae66</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[religion]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[science]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[end-times]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[september-23]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[christianity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JCB]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 22 Sep 2017 13:42:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-11-26T01:50:40.095Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>By now you’ve probably heard about the prophetic events scheduled for this weekend.</p><p>A sign is supposedly appearing in the heavens: a formation of stars and celestial bodies converging in a pattern reminiscent of a vision described in the mysterious book of Revelation.</p><p>The constellation Virgo (the virgin) will have the Sun at her “head” and the Moon at her “feet”; she will be “crowned” with twelve “stars” and “give birth” to Jupiter, which will “emerge from her womb” on September 23.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/996/0*KKPrrNgit9qFLu9O." /></figure><p>In Revelation, the final book in the Christian scriptures, the visionary sees a sign that has echoes of this cosmic dance of stars and planets. A small number of conservative Christians, who consider Revelation a prediction of events yet to happen in human history, are interpreting the celestial phenomena this weekend as evidence of impending End-Times events.</p><p>Some theorists are speculating that the 2017 event will correspond with other biblical prophecies:</p><p>Will it be the infamous Rapture, when Christ appears in the heavens and rescues the Church before the seven-year Tribulation?</p><p>Will it be the signing of a peace treaty, marking the deceptive beginning of the Tribulation nightmare?</p><p>Will it be the revelation of the Antichrist? Plans for a new Temple in Jerusalem? Intifada in Palestine?</p><p>There’s just so many possibilities! Across the world, the strife and the tension, thrilling and terrifying, has been building up to this moment!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*-zoT8OI1HVhWad9m." /></figure><p>…But I’m assuming that by the time everyone goes to work on Monday morning, we won’t even remember the ounce of shame we felt the night before, shame for believing, even for a second, that the movement of the stars was telling us something.</p><p>We will go back to the hurricanes, earthquakes, wildfires, floods, wars and rumors of wars. We’ll go back to the eclipses and Trumps and ludicrous conspiracy theories.</p><p>But we won’t (I’m guessing) feel <em>ashamed</em> for doubting the chaos of the universe. We won’t feel <em>remorseful </em>for indulging a superstition, finding some sense of order to our cosmos. We won’t feel <em>guilty </em>for sinning against Science. Science doesn’t judge us. Science is cold and heartless, like the universe,</p><p>and we would never, I’m predicting, believe that Science, like religion, could make us feel <em>shame</em>. It’s not a regime commanding my mind, restricting input to a certain wavelength, organizing knowledge into metanarratives, like the Church. Science could <em>explain</em> the shame we felt — neurons and diets and pollution. It could suggest the likelihood of shameful feelings.</p><p>But it could never, I would think, <em>judge</em> us for thinking — <em>just for a second!</em> — that something supernatural had taken place, that “Creation” spoke a word, that consciousness might have a macro-scale. Science doesn’t judge me. There is Nothing out there to judge me.</p><p>There is Nothing</p><p>Out there</p><p>To judge me.</p><p>…There’s just <em>shame</em>, <em>guilt</em> for believing in a ridiculous idea. An idea that, given the infinitely-small and infinitely-large sizes of the universe, given that entire realities can pop into and out of existence because gravity and space-time and relativity, given that existence itself is a hologram projecting out of a vacuous mammoth of a black hole, given multiverses and parallel timelines and quantum mechanics and string theory,</p><p>An idea that the stars, given all of the insanity of the universe, are dancing, not just spinning out of control,</p><p>An idea of order, of meaning, of cosmic language,</p><p>A shameful idea, a fleeting speculation that the massive Nothing of reality might be haunted with flashes of Something,</p><p>An idea that we will forget by the time we’re back to the judgement-free world of facts. Facts, which would never produce a crippling, paranoiac desire for un-facts, which would never limit my mind’s ability to observe and experience the mega-micro and mega-macro fields of knowledge. Facts, which would never eliminate God and leave the terror of Nothing in its place.</p><p>Facts. Not Stars.</p><p>I mean, that’s just what I believe in.</p><p>So, yeah, I wouldn’t worry about this weekend.</p><p><em>Joshua Bean is a freelance and aspiring author, Master of Divinity (Cairn University 2011), and full-time parent.</em></p><p><em>©Joshua Craig Bean 2017 all rights reserved.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4fec0e09ae66" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>