<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jialai Chen on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jialai Chen on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 01:02:11 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jchen153/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[There Are a Ton of Ways My Thesis Could Sustain Itself. Here Are 5 of Them. ]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153/there-are-a-ton-of-ways-my-thesis-could-sustain-itself-here-are-5-of-them-6a7d4b037712?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6a7d4b037712</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[design-theses]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jialai Chen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 15 Nov 2026 22:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-15T22:00:00.384Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>This week, my thesis got a new name, a clearer direction, and five potential business models. Apparently, having one identity crisis wasn’t enough, so I decided to give my project five different futures to worry about.</blockquote><blockquote>But before getting into the business models, I should probably explain what has changed.</blockquote><h3>✨From Toyforce to Junk Drawr 🗃️</h3><p>When I first started developing my brand, I called it <strong>Toyforce</strong>. The idea was to encourage adults to bring more play into everyday life through clothing, objects, and experiences.</p><p>But as my research progressed, I began questioning whether I was defining play too narrowly. I spent so much time explaining why adults should play that I hadn’t fully considered what kind of brand could actually make playfulness part of contemporary culture.</p><p>I also realized that adults are already playing, just in different ways. Some collect toys, some skateboard, some spend their weekends playing tabletop games or watching obscure films. These interests might look completely unrelated, but they share something important: curiosity, personal expression, and the freedom to do something simply because you enjoy it.</p><p>Rather than inventing another activity for adults, I became more interested in how a brand could bring these existing cultures together.</p><p>That’s where <strong>Junk Drawr 怪物抽屉</strong> comes in.</p><p>Inspired by the familiar junk drawer, the name represents a place for things that don’t quite fit anywhere else. Strange objects, forgotten treasures, unnecessary possessions, and things we keep simply because we like them. I love the contradiction: adulthood encourages us to organize everything, while some of the most interesting parts of our personalities resist categorization.</p><p>Compared to Toyforce, Junk Drawr gives the brand a broader identity. It doesn’t define play as a particular activity or aesthetic. Instead, it creates space for different interests, attitudes, and forms of expression to coexist.</p><p>At its core, I envision Junk Drawr as an independent lifestyle brand creating original clothing, objects, and home goods with a distinctive sense of humor and visual identity. These products are not just merchandise supporting a larger mission. They’re the brand’s creative foundation, translating a playful mindset into things people can wear, use, and live with.</p><p>But I don’t want the brand to stop at products.</p><p>Through cultural events, festivals, and collaborations, Junk Drawr could also become a platform connecting different play communities. I imagine a festival where independent film, skateboarding, collectible design, tabletop gaming, and other subcultures exist side by side. Not because they need to become one community, but because bringing different worlds together might create unexpected connections and new forms of participation.</p><p>My research into Brain Dead helped me see how a lifestyle brand can become a cultural meeting point without abandoning its identity as a product-driven business. What interests me most is how products, cultural programming, and creative collaborations can reinforce one another.</p><p><strong>I want Junk Drawr to create its own things while making room for other people’s worlds.</strong></p><p>The products establish what the brand stands for. The cultural platform allows that attitude to travel beyond the products themselves, connecting people who might otherwise never cross paths.</p><p>And perhaps that’s the biggest shift from Toyforce to Junk Drawr. I’m no longer trying to convince adults that they should play more. I’m exploring how design can give different forms of adult play greater visibility, cultural relevance, and a place in everyday life.</p><p>Of course, building a brand with this ambition also raises a practical question: How could it sustain itself without losing the creative freedom that makes it interesting in the first place?</p><p>That brings me to this week’s exploration of five different business models.</p><h3>01. Commercial Product — Selling Things Nobody Asked For (But Might Actually Want)</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*EZcOz8n5Tf3CWs0oSmDh7Q.png" /></figure><p>This is the closest to my long-term vision for Junk Drawr: an independent lifestyle brand developing and selling its own clothing, objects, and everyday goods.</p><p>The business model is relatively straightforward. Design original products, manufacture them, and sell them directly to consumers. The difficult part, of course, is everything between those three steps.</p><p>Throughout my thesis, I’ve been interested in how ordinary objects can become opportunities for play. A product doesn’t necessarily need a completely new function to change how someone interacts with it. Sometimes, changing its appearance, context, or expected behavior can be enough to create a moment of surprise.</p><p>One of my recent experiments, <strong>EGGCIDDENT</strong>, explores exactly that.</p><p>EGGCIDDENT is a collection of six handmade egg-shaped scented candles packaged in an egg carton. They resemble familiar breakfast eggs, but they’re designed to be burned rather than eaten. The packaging plays with this contradiction through lines like <em>“6 Eggs. Zero Protein.”</em> and <em>“Burn, Don’t Fry.”</em></p><p>The idea is intentionally ridiculous. Nobody needs an egg-shaped candle. But making one involved much more than simply coming up with a joke. I had to experiment with wax mixtures, temperatures, molds, scents, packaging dimensions, and repeated attempts to get the candles to hold their shape.</p><p>Some attempts collapsed. Some needed repairing. Apparently, even fake eggs are difficult to make.</p><p>What interested me was how a familiar household object could become something unexpected through a simple change in material and purpose. The humor is immediate, but the design process behind it is serious.</p><p>EGGCIDDENT helped me understand the kind of products I want Junk Drawr to create. They shouldn’t be weird simply for the sake of being weird. The strongest ideas should combine an unexpected concept with thoughtful design, material quality, and a certain visual intelligence.</p><p>This also revealed the biggest challenge of the Commercial Product model: <strong>How do you turn a moment of amusement into lasting value?</strong></p><p>Something can make people laugh for five seconds without making them want to buy it, use it, or keep it. Novelty alone isn’t enough to sustain a lifestyle brand.</p><p>I think the answer lies in developing a consistent design perspective rather than relying on individual jokes. A strange candle, an unconventional jacket, and a sculptural tray might serve completely different purposes, but they should all communicate the same attitude.</p><p>The goal isn’t to create a collection of random funny objects. It’s to build a recognizable design world where the products feel connected by their imagination, humor, and aesthetic.</p><p>In this model, the products become the most direct expression of the thesis. People wouldn’t need to understand my research on adult play before buying something. They could experience the idea simply by encountering or using it.</p><p>That feels important to me. <strong>The design should do some of the explaining.</strong></p><h3>02. Membership &amp; Community — Making Friends Without Calling It Networking</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cqgd7mR78N6j_azmfLXDOw.png" /></figure><p>The second model takes Junk Drawr in a completely different direction.</p><p>Instead of selling physical products, what if the brand primarily offered access to a cultural club?</p><p>Members could participate in independent film screenings, tabletop game sessions, creative workshops, unusual hobby gatherings, and other events built around shared interests.</p><p>This direction connects strongly to my earlier research. In several of my observations and interviews, play emerged as something that creates connections between people, not just an individual activity.</p><p>During my visit to Boyar Gifts, for example, I noticed how frequently people experienced the store together. They pointed things out to each other, laughed at unexpected objects, and shared their discoveries. The products were interesting, but much of the enjoyment came from the interaction happening around them.</p><p>That observation made me think about the social possibilities of Junk Drawr.</p><p>Adults often have interests that don’t fit neatly into their professional or social circles. Someone might love model building, vintage toys, experimental films, or tabletop games without knowing anyone nearby who shares that enthusiasm.</p><p>A cultural club could create opportunities for these interests to become social experiences.</p><p>The membership model could generate recurring revenue through subscriptions, offering access to curated programming, special events, and members-only experiences.</p><p>But the more I thought about it, the more complicated it became.</p><p><strong>You can sell access to an event. Can you really sell a sense of belonging?</strong></p><p>A membership doesn’t automatically create community. People might join for an event and never return. Others might love the idea of a club but not have the time to participate regularly. And running a good community requires continuous programming, coordination, and attention to the people involved.</p><p>The value can’t simply be a calendar full of activities. It has to come from the quality of the experiences and relationships that develop over time.</p><p>This model also raised an important question about the identity of Junk Drawr. If the club becomes the main offering, does the brand gradually become an event organizer rather than a product-driven lifestyle label?</p><p>I still find the cultural club idea exciting, but I now see it more clearly as a potential extension of the brand rather than its foundation.</p><p>I want people to first become interested in the world Junk Drawr creates, and then have opportunities to participate in that world together.</p><p>A community should grow from something people genuinely care about, not exist simply because a brand has decided it needs one.</p><h3>03. Marketplace &amp; Platform — Curating Other People’s Weirdness</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*cozTgl2s84LDtpC2Px1yIA.png" /></figure><p>For the third model, I imagined Junk Drawr as a curated marketplace bringing together unusual products from independent designers and makers.</p><p>Instead of producing everything internally, the platform would connect creators with customers, generating revenue through commissions on sales.</p><p>At first, this seemed like an attractive way to expand the brand’s offerings without taking on the full responsibility of manufacturing every product.</p><p>There are so many independent designers creating interesting things, and many of them struggle to reach audiences beyond their existing circles. Junk Drawr could potentially become a destination where people discover unconventional design through a shared cultural perspective.</p><p>But this model made me think more seriously about <strong>curation as a form of authorship</strong>.</p><p>A marketplace isn’t valuable simply because it offers a lot of things. If that were the case, the largest online retailers would also be the most interesting.</p><p>What makes a curated platform distinctive is its judgment: what it chooses to include, what it leaves out, and how it creates meaning between seemingly unrelated products.</p><p>That connects surprisingly well with the name Junk Drawr. A real junk drawer might contain all kinds of unrelated objects, but every item has ended up there for a reason. The collection reflects the person who owns it.</p><p>I imagine Junk Drawr Market working in a similar way. It could feature completely different creators and objects while maintaining a recognizable editorial perspective.</p><p>However, this direction also exposes a tension in my project.</p><p>If Junk Drawr becomes known primarily for selecting other people’s work, how much room is left for its own creative identity?</p><p>I don’t want the brand to become a store that depends entirely on the creativity of others. At the same time, I like the idea of Junk Drawr eventually supporting an ecosystem of independent designers whose work shares a similar experimental attitude.</p><p>Perhaps curation could become part of its cultural programming or future retail experience, rather than replacing original product development.</p><p>This exploration taught me that a brand’s identity isn’t determined only by what it makes. It can also be expressed through what it chooses to associate itself with.</p><p>Still, for Junk Drawr, I want creation to come before curation.</p><h3>04. Licensing &amp; Intellectual Property — What If the Ideas Are the Products?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*YDcRNu7y4R0WMHzLJucfjg.png" /></figure><p>The fourth model was particularly interesting to me as a graphic designer.</p><p>Instead of focusing on manufacturing products, Junk Drawr could develop original characters, graphic systems, and imaginative visual worlds that other companies could license and apply to their own products.</p><p>A single original character might appear on clothing, collectibles, packaging, furniture, or even within a physical installation. Revenue could come from licensing agreements and royalties rather than direct product sales.</p><p>This direction made me reconsider the relationship between a brand’s visual identity and its commercial value.</p><p>As designers, we often think of visual identity as something that communicates what a brand already does. But what if that identity could become a creative asset capable of generating new products and experiences?</p><p>In that case, Junk Drawr wouldn’t simply have a recognizable aesthetic. It could own a growing collection of original creative properties that other brands want to collaborate with.</p><p>However, I also realized that creating something visually distinctive doesn’t automatically make it valuable intellectual property.</p><p>A strange-looking character is still just a strange-looking character unless it has enough personality, recognition, and flexibility to exist beyond its original context.</p><p>The challenge would be developing ideas that are not only visually appealing but also capable of evolving across different applications without losing what makes them recognizable.</p><p>This is also where the relationship between creativity and business becomes particularly interesting. Licensing could allow a small independent brand to reach audiences and product categories beyond its own manufacturing capabilities. But relying too heavily on external partners could also reduce control over how its ideas are used.</p><p>For Junk Drawr, I think the most promising aspect of this model is the possibility of building a distinctive creative universe around its original products.</p><p>Rather than inventing characters simply to license them, I would prefer to let recurring graphics, objects, and visual ideas emerge naturally from the brand’s design practice.</p><p>If those ideas eventually become recognizable enough to exist independently, licensing could offer another way to expand the brand.</p><p>In other words, I want Junk Drawr to develop intellectual property because its ideas are worth extending, not because it needs more things to put a logo on.</p><h3>05. Experimental Venture — Making Things Before Knowing If Anyone Wants Them</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*IpUH-9XemWqIMpiNQu0Ang.png" /></figure><p>The final model might be the most relevant to my current stage of development.</p><p>I imagined Junk Drawr as an experimental product lab, where unusual ideas are developed into prototypes, tested with potential audiences, and refined before being considered for production.</p><p>Unlike the Commercial Product model, this version wouldn’t begin with a finished collection ready to sell. Instead, it would focus on discovering which ideas are worth developing into real products.</p><p>This approach makes sense because many of my current experiments are still somewhere between ridiculous concepts and functional objects.</p><p>EGGCIDDENT is one example, but I’ve also been developing ideas such as a tray where jewelry and accessories become facial features, a miniature trophy celebrating completely insignificant achievements, and clothing that incorporates hidden playful compartments.</p><p>Each idea explores a different relationship between play and everyday life.</p><p>Some encourage unexpected interactions. Others transform ordinary objects through visual humor. A few might turn out to be terrible ideas.</p><p>And that’s exactly what makes this model interesting.</p><p>During the process of making EGGCIDDENT, I learned much more from physically testing the idea than I could have learned from imagining the finished result. Material limitations, production mistakes, and packaging problems all changed my understanding of the product.</p><p>But there’s another kind of testing I haven’t explored enough yet: finding out what other people actually think.</p><p>Just because I enjoy an idea doesn’t mean anyone else wants to own it.</p><p>An experimental venture could create opportunities to involve potential customers earlier in the design process. People could react to concepts, compare prototypes, suggest improvements, or express interest in future releases.</p><p>The goal wouldn’t be to let public opinion make every creative decision. That could easily result in designing the safest possible products, which would defeat much of the purpose of Junk Drawr.</p><p>Instead, feedback could help me understand the difference between an idea that’s surprising, one that’s genuinely engaging, and one that people would actually want in their lives.</p><p>This model also challenges the traditional relationship between a brand and its audience. Rather than presenting everything as a polished finished product, Junk Drawr could reveal some of the uncertainty, experimentation, and occasional failure behind its work.</p><p>I like the possibility of making the process itself part of the experience.</p><p>Of course, being experimental doesn’t pay the bills either. At some point, the venture would need to turn promising ideas into products people are willing to support financially.</p><p>But perhaps that’s the point. This model isn’t a permanent excuse to keep making prototypes. It’s a way to learn what deserves to become a business in the first place.</p><h3>So, What Am I Actually Building? 🔨</h3><p>After exploring these five models, I realized that the most important decision isn’t simply how Junk Drawr could make money.</p><p>It’s <strong>what kind of value I want the brand to create, and what I want people to recognize it for.</strong></p><p>The five models offer very different answers. Commercial Product creates value through original goods. Membership creates value through experiences and belonging. Marketplace creates value through curation and access. Licensing creates value through intellectual property. Experimental Venture creates value through developing and testing new possibilities.</p><p>Each model could support some aspect of my thesis, but each also demands different resources, skills, relationships, and responsibilities.</p><p>And while it’s tempting to imagine Junk Drawr becoming a clothing brand, cultural club, creative studio, marketplace, and experimental laboratory all at once, I suspect that would be an excellent way to accomplish absolutely nothing.</p><p><strong>The clearest direction for me is still to build an independent, product-driven lifestyle brand.</strong></p><p>I want its original products to establish a distinctive visual and cultural identity. An experimental lab could provide a way to develop and test those products, while collaborations, events, and communities could gradually expand the world around them.</p><p>What matters is the order.</p><p>I don’t want to start by building a massive cultural ecosystem and then figure out what the brand actually makes. I want the products themselves to give people a reason to become interested in Junk Drawr, and let the cultural possibilities grow from there.</p><p>This also changes how I think about sustainability.</p><p>A sustainable creative business isn’t necessarily the one with the most revenue streams. It’s one where the different parts of the business reinforce each other without losing the original idea.</p><p>If the products are distinctive, they can attract people who share the brand’s attitude. Those people might become interested in its events, collaborations, or creative experiments. Their participation could, in turn, inspire new products and directions.</p><p>That feels like a much more meaningful relationship between commerce and culture than simply attaching a community to an online store.</p><p>There’s also something I want to be careful about as the project develops.</p><p><strong>Playfulness shouldn’t become another requirement that consumers have to perform.</strong></p><p>My thesis started with the observation that adulthood often comes with pressure to behave in certain ways. It would be ironic to respond by creating a brand that tells people they need to be more spontaneous, more expressive, or more fun.</p><p>Instead, I want Junk Drawr to offer possibilities rather than instructions.</p><p>Someone might buy a product simply because they like its shape, appreciate its humor, or find it aesthetically interesting. They don’t have to identify as a playful person or participate in a community. And that’s fine.</p><p>If the object makes them smile, sparks a conversation, or changes how they experience something familiar, then perhaps the idea is already working.</p><h3>What’s Next? 😼</h3><p>This week helped me move from thinking about what Junk Drawr <em>could be</em> toward understanding what it would actually take to exist.</p><p>The next challenge is to translate that clarity into a recognizable brand identity and a more coherent collection of original products. I’ll start by developing <strong>50 logo explorations</strong> and experimenting with different directions for the brand’s visual system. I’m particularly interested in how typography, graphic elements, and visual composition can communicate Junk Drawr’s humor and unconventional attitude without relying on obvious symbols of play.</p><p>Beyond the logo, I want to explore how the visual system can be both distinctive and flexible. Junk Drawr needs a recognizable identity of its own, but it also needs enough room to accommodate different products, creative collaborations, and cultural events without everything looking the same. Finding that balance between consistency and unpredictability will be an interesting design challenge.</p><p>I also want to continue making physical prototypes and testing them with real people. Because a convincing homepage is one thing. Having something worth putting on that homepage is another.</p><p>Ultimately, I don’t want Junk Drawr to become a brand that merely talks about the importance of play.</p><p>I want it to create things that make room for it.</p><p>And if I can turn a collection of questionable ideas into a sustainable business, that might be the most ridiculous achievement of all.</p><p><strong>Not bad for a junk drawr.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6a7d4b037712" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Here’s My Thesis, Down On Paper]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153/heres-my-thesis-down-on-paper-bd0a48ff5c83?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bd0a48ff5c83</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[design-theses]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jialai Chen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Nov 2026 23:25:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-09T22:06:16.238Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>There is something mildly ridiculous about spending months researching play, only to end up writing a sixteen-page document explaining exactly what it is, why it matters, who it matters to, and what I intend to do about it.</blockquote><blockquote>Very playful of me.</blockquote><blockquote>But this week, that was exactly the assignment: put my thesis down on paper. Not another moodboard, prototype, or collection of interesting references. An actual statement of what I’m investigating, what I’ve learned, what I believe, and what still needs to be figured out.</blockquote><blockquote>Looking back, my thesis has changed quite a bit. What started as an interest in toys for adults has gradually become a much broader investigation into how play might exist within adulthood itself. Along the way, I’ve read about the philosophy and psychology of play, interviewed researchers and practitioners, observed people interacting with objects in stores, and attempted to make a few ridiculous things myself.</blockquote><blockquote>Some of those experiments worked. Some involved repeatedly pouring melted wax into an egg-shaped mold and questioning my life choices.</blockquote><blockquote>The result is <em>Play for Grown-Ups</em>, a design thesis exploring play as a mindset, attitude, and aesthetic that can exist in ordinary adult life.</blockquote><blockquote>My Thesis Affirmation Document is divided into seven main parts. Rather than repeating everything written in it, I wanted to revisit each section and reflect on what it reveals about where the project stands today.</blockquote><blockquote>And perhaps, more importantly, where it still needs to go.</blockquote><h3>01. The Vitals: What Am I Actually Trying to Change?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Ov0IKZSHg1wJDmjfFp7sRg.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*l32OKG66hUnzU0tt4qhJVQ.png" /></figure><p>One of the hardest questions in this section was also one of the most basic: Why does this thesis need to exist?</p><p>When I first became interested in adult play, I was thinking about how growing up often comes with an invisible set of behavioral expectations. Be responsible. Be practical. Take things seriously. Do things properly.</p><p>None of those expectations is necessarily bad. In fact, being responsible is pretty useful when you have rent to pay.</p><p>What interests me is how easily these expectations become a definition of maturity itself. Somewhere along the way, we begin treating seriousness as evidence of adulthood, while curiosity, silliness, and doing things for no particular reason are assigned to childhood.</p><p>But my research has made me question whether that division actually reflects how adults behave.</p><p>Adults already play. They collect strange things, exchange ridiculous jokes, develop oddly specific hobbies, decorate their homes with unexpected objects, and find enjoyment in activities that accomplish absolutely nothing. Play hasn’t disappeared. It has simply become less recognizable under the conventional image of adulthood.</p><p>This shifted my thinking considerably. My project doesn’t need to convince adults to start playing, as though they have forgotten how. It needs to explore why certain expressions of playfulness are welcomed in adult life while others seem out of place.</p><p>It also made me reconsider my own assumptions about maturity. I don’t want to argue that adults should become more childlike. Children are not simply miniature versions of adults with better imaginations, and adult play doesn’t need to imitate childhood.</p><p>Adults bring experience, knowledge, irony, taste, and cultural understanding into how they play. Those qualities can make play more layered, not less authentic.</p><p>So perhaps the question isn’t how to make adulthood less adult.</p><p>It’s why adulthood has to look so serious in the first place.</p><h3>02. The Research: More Reading, Fewer Easy Answers</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*mDKe-gHzStxAOR9bCYKYPw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lTlQHYSmlo9nozSxr1LBJQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*t5T1-k5m1DfG_Iwg9EAHig.png" /></figure><p>At some point, my research folder started looking like I was preparing to open a small university dedicated entirely to playing.</p><p>Philosophy, psychology, sociology, game studies, design, neuroscience, retail, cultural criticism. Apparently, everybody has something to say about play.</p><p>What surprised me wasn’t how much research existed, but how differently people understood the same word.</p><p>Miguel Sicart’s <em>Play Matters</em> helped me distinguish between play as a particular activity and playfulness as a way of engaging with the world. Brian Sutton-Smith’s work complicated the idea that play must always be positive or beneficial. Bernard Suits introduced the fascinating idea of voluntarily accepting unnecessary obstacles, which feels almost offensive to a designer trained to make everything easier.</p><p>These perspectives challenged my initial tendency to think of play as something cheerful, spontaneous, and immediately enjoyable.</p><p>Play can involve uncertainty, resistance, rules, experimentation, and even frustration. It doesn’t necessarily have to look fun from the outside.</p><p>My conversations with play researchers and practitioners made these ideas more tangible. Speaking with Renee Bryant, Ann Charlotte Thorsted, and Rachael Renae helped me think more carefully about curiosity, intrinsic motivation, and the importance of leaving room for uncertainty.</p><p>One insight that has stayed with me is that play shouldn’t arrive with a predetermined answer.</p><p>That sounds simple, but it becomes surprisingly difficult when you’re a designer. We are constantly asked to define objectives, anticipate behavior, and create successful outcomes. We want people to understand our intentions, preferably within the first three seconds.</p><p>Play doesn’t always cooperate with that process.</p><p>Meanwhile, my visits to Boyar Gifts and Big Night showed me something that academic reading alone couldn’t. At Boyar Gifts, I watched people discover unexpected objects, show them to friends, laugh, and start conversations. At Big Night, the arrangement of colorful tableware, storytelling, and spatial atmosphere made browsing feel like an experience in itself.</p><p>Nobody needed to announce that a playful activity was about to begin.</p><p>These observations led me toward an important realization: play can be something we do, but playfulness can also be something we encounter, express, and experience through our surroundings.</p><p>That possibility feels particularly relevant to my work as a designer.</p><h3>03. The Stakeholders &amp; Theory of Change: You Can’t Force Someone to Have Fun</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*ZgXHiLZBVdVYFk_dBXDYPw.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Itl3xdLK6Df5VKVsg0LAUQ.png" /></figure><p>This section forced me to confront a slightly uncomfortable possibility: what if the designer isn’t supposed to be in charge?</p><p>After looking at the perspectives of adults, play researchers, and designers or retailers, I began to see a tension between what these groups need.</p><p>Adults already have enough responsibilities. They probably don’t need another person telling them to schedule fifteen minutes of creativity between their morning coffee and their next meeting.</p><p>Researchers emphasize freedom, curiosity, and self-directed engagement. Designers and brands, meanwhile, have to create something tangible, understandable, and worth people’s attention.</p><p>My job is somewhere in the middle.</p><p>Earlier in the project, I often described my goal as encouraging adults to play more. Now that phrase feels a little too directive. It assumes I know what play should look like for someone else, and that their participation would demonstrate my success.</p><p>But what if someone encounters an object I’ve designed and uses it in a way I never anticipated? What if they find it beautiful rather than funny? What if they simply ignore its playful possibilities?</p><p>I am starting to understand that these are not necessarily failures.</p><p>The more useful design question is how to create something that offers possibilities without demanding a particular response.</p><p>A familiar object might have an unexpected second function. A piece of clothing might contain a detail that changes how someone interacts with it. A retail environment might invite exploration without turning the visit into a structured game.</p><p>The designer can establish the conditions, but the experience ultimately belongs to the person encountering it.</p><p>Of course, there’s a certain irony in writing a theory of change about something that resists being controlled.</p><p>I suppose that’s part of the challenge.</p><h3>04. The Lexicon: Twenty Words for Something We All Apparently Know How to Do</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1O-ReCebwWjlmArfQGs1aQ.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LERqzRfFBuWKXt-gCCv9wA.png" /></figure><p>Before beginning this thesis, I probably could have explained play in one sentence.</p><p>Now I need twenty terms.</p><p>Progress?</p><p>Actually, yes.</p><p>Building this lexicon made me realize how many concepts I had been treating as interchangeable. Play, playfulness, humor, novelty, open-endedness, and interaction may overlap, but they describe different things.</p><p>This distinction matters when those ideas start becoming physical designs.</p><p>For example, something can be humorous without being particularly playable. An object can look playful while offering very little room for exploration. A surprising product might create an immediate reaction but become completely uninteresting once its joke is understood.</p><p>I find that last distinction especially important.</p><p>Novelty is easy to mistake for playfulness because both can generate an immediate response. But novelty often depends on the first encounter. Once the surprise disappears, what remains?</p><p>That question has become one of my most useful design filters.</p><p>Another concept I keep returning to is <em>friction</em>. Designers generally treat friction as something to eliminate. Fewer steps, smoother interactions, faster results.</p><p>But if an unnecessary obstacle is voluntarily accepted, it can become part of the pleasure of an experience.</p><p>I don’t think this means making things inconvenient for no reason. It means recognizing that efficiency isn’t the only possible measure of a good interaction.</p><p>Sometimes an unexpected detour is more interesting than the shortest route.</p><p>The lexicon has also helped me recognize something about my visual approach: there isn’t one correct aesthetic for adult play. It can be absurd or understated, colorful or restrained, loud or completely deadpan.</p><p>A playful object doesn’t necessarily need to announce itself with a smiley face.</p><p>Which is good news, because I would really prefer not to put a smiley face on everything.</p><h3>05. The Outputs: From Big Ideas to Actual Things</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4ncjiiblAj9kMDs3uBy9uA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CURXs1dLIHpTTpeaSOgsfA.png" /></figure><p>This might be the section where my thesis becomes the most exciting, and also the most dangerous for my bank account.</p><p>The primary design direction is TOYFORCE, a research-led lifestyle brand exploring how playfulness might become part of what adults live with, use, wear, carry, and experience.</p><p>Rather than creating a traditional toy brand, I’m interested in building a coherent world where ordinary adult categories can behave a little unexpectedly.</p><p>The brand is a vehicle for testing the thesis, not the thesis itself.</p><p>That distinction is important because it gives me room to question the products rather than simply trying to make everything fit a predetermined brand identity.</p><p>My recent object experiments have been an early opportunity to test this approach.</p><p>One of them is EGGCIDDENT, a collection of scented candles disguised as eggs. The concept plays with the familiarity of grocery packaging and the absurdity of treating an everyday food item as a decorative candle.</p><p>Six eggs. Zero protein.</p><p>Making them, however, introduced a considerably less glamorous side of design. Wax ratios, pouring temperatures, collapsing surfaces, difficult demolding, and an impressive amount of time spent trying to make something look like an egg.</p><p>Beyond learning how to make candles, the process raised a more important question: Is the idea itself enough?</p><p>A candle shaped like an egg might be funny. But would someone actually want to display it? Would the packaging create a memorable experience? Would the object remain interesting after its initial surprise?</p><p>The same questions apply to my other concepts, including the Face Tray, Nothing Serious Trophy, Off-Duty Suit, and Bad Ideas Book.</p><p>Each offers a different way to challenge expectations around familiar objects or behaviors. But not all of them will necessarily become final products.</p><p>I want these prototypes to help me discover which ideas can develop beyond their initial concept.</p><p>The wider TOYFORCE world could eventually include campaigns, retail experiences, digital storytelling, and opportunities for people to participate. What matters is that these elements share a coherent point of view rather than becoming five unrelated school assignments.</p><p>At this stage, I am less interested in producing the largest possible collection than in making a smaller number of things that convincingly demonstrate what the thesis is trying to explore.</p><p>Preferably without requiring a paragraph of explanation beside every object.</p><h3>06. The Complications: Selling Play Without Selling Out</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*s8aqrwDq_-MxatN0hk1fDA.png" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KkTRIIpUtIdrA2BYtM-B5w.png" /></figure><p>Here comes the awkward part.</p><p>I’m proposing a lifestyle brand that explores play as something intrinsically motivated, open-ended, and not necessarily productive.</p><p>And then I’m going to design products, package them, advertise them, and potentially sell them.</p><p>There is a contradiction here that I can’t simply resolve with a clever slogan.</p><p>If play doesn’t need a practical purpose, what happens when it becomes a product with a price tag? Does a brand genuinely expand opportunities for play, or does it simply turn playfulness into another aesthetic people can purchase?</p><p>I don’t think commercialization automatically invalidates the project. Clothing, furniture, and household objects already help us express our personalities and construct our everyday environments.</p><p>But buying something playful and actually experiencing play are not the same thing.</p><p>An object might communicate humor or personal identity without ever producing a playful interaction. That doesn’t necessarily make it worthless, but I need to be precise about what kind of value I’m creating.</p><p>This also raises questions about the people I’m designing for.</p><p>It’s tempting to imagine a particular type of adult who appreciates strange objects, clever humor, and good design. Perhaps someone who looks suspiciously like a person I would enjoy shopping with.</p><p>But adult play isn’t a personality category, and my personal taste shouldn’t determine its boundaries.</p><p>Someone might express playfulness through a carefully arranged home, while another finds it through practical jokes, collecting, improvisation, or making things with their hands. What appeals to one person might be embarrassing or completely meaningless to another.</p><p>I need to keep testing these differences rather than assuming a polished brand world can speak for everyone.</p><p>The third complication is perhaps the most practical: the work has to survive outside a presentation.</p><p>A beautiful mockup can make almost any concept appear convincing. Real objects have material limitations, production costs, physical behaviors, and users who may not respond as expected.</p><p>If my thesis can only be understood when I stand beside it explaining my research, then something is missing.</p><p>In that sense, the success of TOYFORCE depends on more than having a strong identity. It depends on whether the things I design can earn a meaningful place in someone’s everyday life.</p><p>I don’t have complete answers to these contradictions yet.</p><p>But I would rather make them visible now than discover them after designing an entire collection of very attractive, very expensive jokes.</p><h3>07. The Bottom Line: Six More Months of Playing Seriously</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*N_hA9FOKid_CTkwF1r6TlA.png" /></figure><p>The final section asked me to explain why this thesis is worth another six months of my life.</p><p>A reasonable question, especially when those six months will probably involve an unreasonable number of prototypes.</p><p>Writing the answer made me think about how much my understanding of the project has changed since the beginning.</p><p>I started with a fairly personal frustration about the expectations attached to growing up. Over time, that frustration became a research question, then a collection of conversations and observations, and eventually a design direction with its own opportunities and contradictions.</p><p>What gives me confidence isn’t that the thesis has remained consistent. It’s that I’ve been willing to change it.</p><p>I no longer think the goal is to make adults buy toys, or to prove that playing makes people healthier, happier, or more productive.</p><p>There is already plenty of research discussing the benefits of play. I don’t need to turn every enjoyable experience into another argument for self-improvement.</p><p>My contribution is more specific to design.</p><p>I want to investigate what happens when familiar adult objects, environments, and visual systems are given another possible interpretation. How much can a small shift in form, function, context, or expectation change someone’s relationship with something ordinary?</p><p>And can those shifts become part of a believable lifestyle rather than remaining isolated moments of amusement?</p><p>There is still a lot to figure out, particularly how to test these ideas with people whose relationships to play are different from mine.</p><p>But I finally have a clearer sense of what I’m trying to build, and why.</p><h3>So, What’s Next?</h3><p>After sixteen pages of explaining play, I think it’s finally time to do something with it.</p><p>What excites me most about the next stage is the opportunity to translate all this research into a visual and physical world. As a designer, I’ve always been interested in how branding can shape more than the appearance of something. It can create a personality, establish an attitude, and influence how people experience even the most ordinary things.</p><p>With TOYFORCE, I want to push that possibility further.</p><p>I’m curious about how typography, color, imagery, objects, packaging, and unexpected details can work together to make playfulness feel like a natural part of adult life. Not necessarily loud, colorful, or obviously funny, but something with its own visual intelligence, humor, and personality. Something people would genuinely want to wear, use, collect, or surround themselves with.</p><p>More importantly, I want TOYFORCE to feel like a brand that actually believes in what it stands for. If play is a mindset, that attitude should influence how the brand communicates, behaves, and interacts with people. If play is an aesthetic, it should be recognizable through the entire experience, not just a few playful graphics.</p><p>I don’t know exactly what the final world will look like yet, and that’s probably a good thing. There should still be room for surprises, experiments, and a few bad ideas that turn out to be surprisingly good.</p><p>For now, I’m looking forward to making a lot more things, testing them in the real world, and seeing how far this idea can go.</p><p>After all, a thesis about play should leave some room for playing.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bd0a48ff5c83" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Exactly is a Provotype? Here are Mine.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153/what-exactly-is-a-provotype-here-are-mine-eb356bc1ae1c?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eb356bc1ae1c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[provotype]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[designthesis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jialai Chen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 01 Nov 2026 22:44:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-11-01T22:49:00.707Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>I usually think of prototypes as optimistic objects. You have an idea, you make a version of it, and you test whether it deserves to become more real. A prototype helps expose practical problems, but it still assumes that the thing might eventually work.</blockquote><blockquote>A provotype felt different. Instead of improving an idea, I had to take a tension inside my thesis and exaggerate it until the logic became uncomfortable.</blockquote><blockquote>That was surprisingly useful for TOYFORCE.</blockquote><blockquote>For the past several months, I have been researching adult play, but my thesis has gradually moved away from the simple idea of designing toys for adults. I am more interested in play as a mindset, an aesthetic, and an attitude that can live inside ordinary adult life. It can appear in what we wear, carry, collect, display, or choose to live with.</blockquote><blockquote>At the same time, play becomes difficult to talk about the moment someone tries too hard to organize it. A playful experience can be invited, but not completely prescribed. Curiosity can be encouraged, but not guaranteed. And although I have often described my thesis as creating more “permission” for adults to play, even that word started to feel suspicious once I pushed it far enough.</blockquote><blockquote>So instead of designing two things that would help adults play, I decided to design two systems that would make adult play significantly worse.</blockquote><blockquote>The first tells you whether you are playing well enough.</blockquote><blockquote>The second tells you whether you are allowed to play at all.</blockquote><blockquote>That became my introduction to provotyping.</blockquote><h3>Making a Problem More Visible Instead of Solving It</h3><p>What I began to understand through this assignment is that a provotype does not need to propose a desirable future. It can take something that already exists quietly and make it loud enough to examine.</p><p>That distinction mattered because I did not need another project telling me that play is valuable. I already believe that. What I needed was a way to challenge the language I had been using around the thesis.</p><p>I have often said that adults need more room for play. But what does “more” mean? Does it eventually become something measurable?</p><p>I have also said that design can create permission for play. But if permission is taken literally, who gets to grant it?</p><p>Those questions became the starting point for two intentionally bad ideas.</p><h3>Provotype 01: PLAY SCORE™</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CxDEMd58oc4QTDdKYWnAyA.jpeg" /></figure><p>PLAY SCORE™ began with something completely ordinary: the amount of adult life that is now measured.</p><p>Sleep, steps, screen time, exercise, productivity, spending, focus, recovery, and habits can all be converted into data. This is not necessarily a criticism of those tools. A lot of measurement is useful. What interested me was the logic underneath them: once something is considered important, it becomes tempting to track it, improve it, and compare it against a target.</p><p>Play seemed like a particularly bad thing to put through that process.</p><p>A recurring idea in my research is that play can be intrinsic and open-ended. It does not always need to arrive at a correct result. Sometimes its value comes from curiosity, experimentation, humor, or doing something simply because it feels interesting in that moment.</p><p>If I turn that into a measurable goal, something changes.</p><p>So I created PLAY SCORE™, a fictional self-tracking app that measures how successfully an adult is playing throughout the day.</p><p>The main screen gives the user a daily score. Mine became <strong>37/100</strong>, followed by the warning:</p><p><strong>YOUR DAY IS CURRENTLY 68% TOO SERIOUS.</strong></p><p>The app then breaks play into measurable categories such as curiosity, spontaneity, pointless activity, social play, and decorative absurdity.</p><p>The categories are ridiculous, but I wanted the interface to take them completely seriously.</p><p>Visually, I kept the app restrained and Swiss-inspired, using strong grids, oversized numbers, neutral typography, large areas of white and gray, and one bright pink accent. I did not want it to look like a playful game. It needed to resemble the kinds of wellness and productivity products we already trust.</p><p>The joke works better if the interface never admits that it is joking.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PmnT2kyZcG361u6mKUrxew.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY SCORE™ / DAILY SCORE DASHBOARD</strong></figcaption></figure><p>I then designed a Live Play Monitor that interprets ordinary behavior throughout the day.</p><p>Walking directly to a destination lowers the score. Opening a spreadsheet voluntarily lowers it even more. Spinning once in an office chair earns a few points. Making an unnecessary joke during lunch earns more.</p><p>At first I thought these would simply be funny pieces of microcopy. But while designing them, I noticed a more interesting problem.</p><p>The app has to decide what counts as play.</p><p>That means an open-ended behavior suddenly needs a definition. The system needs criteria, categories, and a correct way to succeed. Something that might originally happen without a purpose now has one: earning points.</p><p>Even the category “Pointless Activity” becomes useful because it improves the score.</p><p>That contradiction became the real provocation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*L7IKPRjklNsAv0HXlNWBfw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY SCORE™ / LIVE PLAY MONITOR &amp; RECOMMENDED PLAY</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The Recommended Play section then pushed the contradiction further. When the user performs badly, the app gives instructions.</p><p>It might tell someone to move an object somewhere it does not belong, say something unnecessary to a friend, use a chair incorrectly, or do nothing productive for four minutes.</p><p>Any of those actions could genuinely become playful. But when they arrive as assignments, they start to feel like tasks.</p><p>My favorite moment in the interface came from the <strong>Improve My Score</strong> button. After pressing it, the app responds:</p><p><strong>SCHEDULING SPONTANEITY…</strong></p><p><strong>Spontaneous activity scheduled for 3:40 PM.</strong></p><p>That sentence was probably the clearest expression of the whole project. The system wants to help so badly that it destroys the thing it is trying to support.</p><p>I extended PLAY SCORE™ into advertising with the line:</p><p><strong>WARNING: YOUR PLAY SCORE IS TOO LOW.</strong></p><p>At that point, the app stopped feeling like a random joke and started to feel slightly uncomfortable.</p><p>The warning creates a new form of failure. The user is no longer only expected to work well, sleep well, exercise enough, and manage time properly. Now they can also fail at having fun.</p><p>That made me think differently about TOYFORCE.</p><p>My thesis argues for making more room for play in adult life, but there is a huge difference between saying that play deserves space and telling people that they are not playful enough. The first opens a possibility. The second creates another expectation.</p><p>PLAY SCORE™ gave me a very clear version of something I do not want TOYFORCE to become: another system of self-improvement disguised as freedom.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*nPhh-CuIrxiIRh1h2BKqKA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY SCORE™ / WEEKLY SCORE/ ADVERTISEMENT</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3OTVV7A_4abbOTkidEJT_Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY SCORE™ / ADVERTISEMENT</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vj5o4hEPKjLEJsWmcMH1KQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY SCORE™ / ADVERTISEMENT</strong></figcaption></figure><h3>Provotype 02: PLAY PERMIT™</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*AI6GFiCiwc3Prp1SAtLI1A.jpeg" /></figure><p>PLAY PERMIT™ came from a different tension.</p><p>While researching adult play, I kept noticing that the desire to play is not always the main problem. Adults often seem perfectly capable of enjoying humor, surprise, absurd objects, and spontaneous interactions. What changes is whether a situation makes those behaviors feel acceptable.</p><p>Adults become extremely skilled at reading social environments. We quickly understand whether a room feels serious, whether something is meant to be touched, whether a behavior might look inappropriate, or whether we should wait for someone else to go first.</p><p>A lot of that awareness is necessary. But it can also make playful behavior disappear before it starts.</p><p>This was visible in some of my field research. At Boyar Gifts, adults across different ages laughed at objects, showed discoveries to friends, and reacted to things together. The playful energy was not coming from a formal activity. The environment and the presence of other people made those reactions feel normal.</p><p>At Big Night, the situation was different but related. Play existed in the aesthetic of the store itself: colorful tableware, strange objects, small stories, and an environment that treated playful taste as something adults could comfortably live with.</p><p>These experiences led me to think a lot about <strong>permission</strong>.</p><p>But the more I used that word, the more I wanted to test it.</p><p>If adults need permission to play, what happens if that permission becomes official?</p><p>That question became PLAY PERMIT™.</p><p>PLAY PERMIT™ imagines a fictional bureaucracy in which adults must apply for authorization before behaving playfully.</p><p>The visual language comes from government identification, municipal forms, public signage, licensing offices, and administrative systems. Like PLAY SCORE™, it uses a Swiss-inspired structure and the same limited palette, but here the design feels more institutional than digital.</p><p>The permit itself includes clearance levels.</p><p>A basic license might allow <strong>LOW-RISK CURIOSITY</strong>, while higher levels authorize <strong>PUBLIC PLAY</strong> or eventually <strong>UNSUPERVISED ABSURDITY</strong>.</p><p>The wording is intentionally ridiculous, but the design treats every category as official.</p><p>The card includes issue dates, expiration dates, identification numbers, restrictions, and approved behaviors. Small warnings explain that unauthorized unseriousness may result in review.</p><p>The more convincing the document looks, the better the project works.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*U9YsRPm__pwiAu_F1UHg_w.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY PERMIT™ / PERMIT CARD</strong></figcaption></figure><p>I then created an <strong>Application for Temporary Play Authorization</strong>.</p><p>The form asks the applicant to explain the purpose of the activity, its duration, the expected productivity loss, whether other adults will be present, and whether the behavior could be interpreted as childish.</p><p>One question became especially important:</p><p><strong>Is this activity necessary?</strong></p><p>That is where the bureaucracy clashes directly with play.</p><p>A lot of adult systems are built around justification. We explain why something is useful, efficient, appropriate, or worth the time. But play often resists that logic. An activity can matter without being necessary.</p><p>The form therefore creates an impossible task: the applicant has to justify purposeless behavior without destroying its purposelessness.</p><p>I also designed a rejected version of the application. The refusal can cite reasons such as insufficient justification, excessive social visibility, or the risk of undermining professional seriousness.</p><p>The point was not that any real institution is literally stopping adults from playing. It was to make invisible self-regulation visible by giving it paperwork.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wWer6ld5j05Z8hAPJig09Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY PERMIT™ / APPLICATION FORM</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*KT4K2MRSiVsLh7tt4_qL5Q.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY PERMIT™ / APPLICATION COUNTER</strong></figcaption></figure><p>The project became more interesting once I moved beyond graphic documents and imagined the physical environment around them.</p><p>Using AI image generation, I created a Play Permit Office that looks somewhere between a DMV and a city licensing department. Adults sit in a waiting area holding forms while a number system determines when they can approach the counter. Signs announce <strong>NO UNAUTHORIZED PLAY</strong> and estimate an approval time of four to six business days.</p><p>I deliberately kept the space boring.</p><p>If the world looked futuristic or aggressively dystopian, it would become too easy to dismiss. I wanted the absurdity to sit inside an environment that felt ordinary and procedural.</p><p>Nobody in the scene is shocked that play requires paperwork.</p><p>That normality is what makes it strange.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f4ZLGoFMg6sIGZN09BInOA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY PERMIT™ / PLAY PERMIT OFFICE</strong></figcaption></figure><p>From there, I imagined the same system operating in everyday environments.</p><p>An adult behaves slightly too playfully in an office and a compliance officer checks their permit. A home with unusual furniture requires a domestic play license. A public space contains a marked area where only authorized play is allowed.</p><p>The behaviors themselves are intentionally small. Nobody needs to be doing anything outrageous. The more harmless the act, the more ridiculous the regulation becomes.</p><p>That helped me understand something I had been missing when I used the word permission in my thesis.</p><p>I had often imagined design as something that could <strong>give</strong> adults permission to play. After making PLAY PERMIT™, I am less interested in giving permission and more interested in making permission feel unnecessary.</p><p>There is an important difference.</p><p>A sign saying “You are allowed to touch this” still reminds someone that touching normally requires approval.</p><p>An object that naturally invites interaction can make the question disappear.</p><p>A campaign saying “Adults are allowed to have fun” still positions play as an exception to normal adult behavior.</p><p>A visual world where seriousness and absurdity already coexist treats play as part of adulthood rather than a temporary escape from it.</p><p>That shift feels much closer to where I want TOYFORCE to go.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XIofQPqV712aCCdWQHDoXw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY PERMIT™ / AUTHORIZED PLAY ZONE</strong></figcaption></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_4CkPCXFrC_-dnjnfMgBoA.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>PLAY PERMIT™ / HOME</strong></figcaption></figure><h3>What the Two Provotypes Changed</h3><p>The two projects ended up testing different weaknesses in my thesis.</p><p>PLAY SCORE™ showed me what happens when encouraging play becomes a demand for self-improvement.</p><p>PLAY PERMIT™ showed me what happens when creating social permission becomes an authority system.</p><p>Neither problem is purely fictional.</p><p>They both come from ways adult life is already structured. We are accustomed to measuring ourselves, and we are accustomed to adjusting our behavior according to context. The provotypes simply pushed those habits until they became impossible to ignore.</p><p>That is why I found this assignment more useful than making two speculative “solutions.”</p><p>It forced me to look at the negative version of my own argument.</p><p>TOYFORCE is still a lifestyle brand built around adult play, but I now feel more careful about what the brand should actually do.</p><p>I do not want it to tell people how often they should play. I do not want it to define a correct version of play. I do not want someone to buy a TOYFORCE object and feel that purchasing it proves they are a playful person.</p><p>At the same time, I do want the brand to create objects, images, spaces, and experiences that make curiosity and absurdity feel natural inside adult life.</p><p>That is a subtler role.</p><p>The brand can create invitations without becoming an instructor.</p><p>It can create a strong visual world without turning that world into a rulebook.</p><p>It can make playful behavior feel culturally legitimate without positioning itself as the authority that grants legitimacy.</p><p>This assignment made that boundary much clearer.</p><h3>The Most Useful Part Was Designing Something I Disagreed With</h3><p>Before this assignment, I assumed a provotype was mainly supposed to provoke other people.</p><p>Now I think it can also provoke the designer.</p><p>Both projects began with ideas I partly agree with. I believe adults can benefit from having more room for play, and I believe social conditions influence whether people feel comfortable acting playfully.</p><p>What I had not examined carefully enough was what happens when those beliefs become systems.</p><p>PLAY SCORE™ and PLAY PERMIT™ gave me two exaggerated answers.</p><p>One turns play into achievement.</p><p>The other turns it into compliance.</p><p>Neither is a future I want, but both helped me understand the kind of future I am actually trying to build.</p><p>I am not trying to design a system that makes adults play correctly.</p><p>I am trying to build a world where being an adult can include curiosity, humor, softness, absurdity, and purposeless enjoyment without those qualities needing to be justified first.</p><p>Maybe that is what I understand a provotype to be now.</p><p>It is not simply a strange prototype or an intentionally bad idea.</p><p>It is a way of taking a belief, exaggerating the logic around it, and seeing where that logic breaks.</p><p>For me, the most useful provotypes were not the ones that gave me a new answer.</p><p>They were the ones that made me more suspicious of the answers I already had.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eb356bc1ae1c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[‍I Did Some Speculative Futuring, and Here’s What I’m Taking Away From It.]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153/i-did-some-speculative-futuring-and-heres-what-i-m-taking-away-from-it-27d843e56d47?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/27d843e56d47</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ai-workflow]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-theses]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jialai Chen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Oct 2026 00:32:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-27T00:32:51.766Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>This week, I basically let my thesis run away from me on purpose.</blockquote><blockquote>I took most of what I have been researching around TOYFORCE — my readings on adult play, interviews, field research, cultural questions, existing object experiments, and the contradictions I still have not resolved — and put them into a speculative workflow. I wanted to see what would happen if I stopped protecting the thesis and allowed it to become something much bigger, stranger, or even wrong.</blockquote><blockquote>I thought the exercise would help me choose a future for TOYFORCE.</blockquote><blockquote>Instead, it made me watch the project become several different things and decide, sometimes very strongly, what I did and did not want it to become.</blockquote><blockquote>At different points this week, TOYFORCE became a cultural brand, a public play platform, a commercial phenomenon, an open-source participation system, and eventually something that looked suspiciously like an industrial-design thesis. Some of these versions were exciting. Some made complete sense on paper but felt wrong almost immediately. Looking back, those wrong turns were probably where I learned the most.</blockquote><blockquote>Before doing this exercise, I already knew that I did not want TOYFORCE to simply be an “adult toy brand.” My research over the last few months has moved me further and further away from understanding play only as an activity. I have become much more interested in play as a way of approaching everyday life: curiosity, humor, openness, experimentation, and the willingness to do something without needing to know exactly what it is for.</blockquote><blockquote>That is why I have started thinking about play as a <strong>mindset, an aesthetic, and an attitude</strong>.</blockquote><blockquote>This distinction matters because it changes the design question. If play is only an activity, then my job would be to design things adults can play with. But if play can also be a mindset or an aesthetic, then the territory becomes much larger. It can live in a chair, a jacket, a candle, a bag, a book, a room, or even in the way something is displayed. The object does not always need to announce itself as a toy. Sometimes it simply needs to make an ordinary moment feel slightly less fixed.</blockquote><blockquote>This is also connected to something I have been thinking about in relation to the word <em>childish</em>. I do not think adult play is about becoming a child again. Adults are playing on top of adult knowledge, experience, self-consciousness, taste, and responsibility. We know the rules we are breaking. Sometimes that is exactly where the humor comes from.</blockquote><blockquote>So when I began the speculative futuring workflow, TOYFORCE was still, in my mind, a lifestyle brand. The question was what kind of lifestyle it was actually proposing.</blockquote><h3>Future A: What If TOYFORCE Really Becomes a Cultural Brand?</h3><p>The first future was the easiest for me to recognize.</p><p>TOYFORCE grows into a larger lifestyle and cultural brand. There are objects, furniture, clothing, collaborations, spaces, campaigns, and a community around it. Play becomes something that adults can wear, carry, collect, display, and live with.</p><p>This future was exciting because it allowed me to stop thinking about my existing projects as isolated objects. EGGCIDENT is one experiment. The Nothing Serious Trophy is another. The Off-Duty Suit explores a different relationship between adulthood, professional identity, and play. But once they are placed in the same world, the question becomes less about whether each individual thing is “playful enough” and more about whether there is a recognizable attitude connecting them.</p><p>That brought me back to my field research.</p><p>At BOYAR GIFTS, I noticed how quickly ordinary objects could become social triggers. People pointed things out to each other, laughed, picked things up, and started conversations. The exact humor was very personal, but surprise seemed to work much more broadly. A familiar object would behave slightly differently from what someone expected, and that tiny disruption was enough to change the interaction around it.</p><p>That was where I wrote down: <strong>Humor is personal, but surprise is universal.</strong></p><p>Big Night gave me another kind of evidence. There, the store itself became part of the playful experience. It was not asking people to play a game. The playfulness existed in the colors, tableware, object descriptions, themed displays, and atmosphere. Even learning what an object was and why someone had chosen it became part of the experience.</p><p>That was when I started thinking that <strong>play can be an aesthetic</strong>.</p><p>Future A made that idea much larger. If play can exist aesthetically, then TOYFORCE can enter the home in ways that are not necessarily interactive. A lamp can be playful. A side table can be playful. A mirror, tray, chair, or shelf can have a strange personality without becoming a toy.</p><p>The home has actually become one of the most interesting spaces in the thesis for me. Adults put a lot of effort into surrounding themselves with objects that communicate taste, maturity, control, sophistication, status, or calm. I started wondering why play could not also be part of that vocabulary.</p><p>What would a playful home for an adult actually look like if it did not look like a children’s room?</p><p>That question now feels much more important than simply designing more toys.</p><p>Future A showed me how TOYFORCE could become a complete world. But because it was so close to what I already wanted, it was also the easiest future to accept without questioning. So I needed the workflow to push somewhere less comfortable.</p><h3>Future B: What Happens When Looking Playful Is Not Enough?</h3><p>Future B moved TOYFORCE away from lifestyle products and toward public play.</p><p>The project started appearing in streets, workplaces, parks, transit spaces, and waiting areas. Instead of asking what adults might want to own, it started asking what would make them actually participate.</p><p>This is where the question of <strong>permission</strong> became much more important.</p><p>One of the things I have gradually realized through my research is that adults may not lose the desire to play as much as they learn to regulate it. We become very good at reading situations. We know when we are supposed to be professional, when we might look embarrassing, when we are being watched, and whether anyone else is doing the same thing.</p><p>A child may approach an unfamiliar object without much concern about how that action is being interpreted. An adult can have the exact same curiosity and still decide not to touch it.</p><p>So Future B forced me to ask a much more precise question: what makes someone feel allowed to begin?</p><p>That connected strongly with another idea from my research: play should not arrive with a predetermined answer. The more a designer explains exactly what someone should do, what they should feel, and what the expected outcome is, the more the experience starts to behave like another assignment.</p><p>I began thinking about the difference between designing play and designing an invitation.</p><p>I do not think I can actually design play itself. I can create a condition, a cue, a strange object, an atmosphere, or a moment of uncertainty. But the person still decides whether to enter.</p><p>That was a valuable realization.</p><p>The problem was that the speculative future kept developing. TOYFORCE gradually became a public-play system. There were facilitators, protocols, governance rules, participation structures, and public interventions. Eventually the project became intellectually coherent but emotionally unfamiliar to me.</p><p>It was a perfectly reasonable thesis.</p><p>It was just not mine.</p><p>This was one of the first moments this week when I understood what speculative futuring could actually do for me. It was not only helping me imagine where the thesis might go. It was helping me find the point where I wanted to say <strong>no</strong>.</p><p>I did not want TOYFORCE to become a public-service platform. But I did want to keep what Future B had taught me.</p><p>A lifestyle brand can look playful without actually making someone feel any more open, curious, or willing to behave differently. A product can be visually funny and still function only as decoration. A store can be colorful and still feel completely controlled.</p><p>So the lesson from Future B was not that TOYFORCE should become public play.</p><p>It was that the brand needs to understand <strong>permission</strong>.</p><p>A package can invite someone to behave differently. A retail environment can make touching feel acceptable. A piece of furniture can suggest another posture. An object can leave enough ambiguity that the user starts inventing their own relationship with it.</p><p>Future B became less of a destination and more of a test for Future A.</p><h3>Future C: What If TOYFORCE Becomes Too Successful?</h3><p>The third future was the one that made me the most uncomfortable because, on the surface, nothing was going wrong.</p><p>TOYFORCE became successful.</p><p>There were collaborations, limited editions, collectors, resale culture, social media communities, branded spaces, and products that communicated taste and identity. In other words, it started behaving exactly like a successful lifestyle brand.</p><p>That is where the thesis began to turn against itself.</p><p>If TOYFORCE is trying to make play a more natural part of adult life, what happens when “being playful” becomes another identity that can be purchased?</p><p>This question feels especially relevant to the cultural contradiction that first drew me toward the topic. In many of the social and family contexts I have been thinking about, adulthood is still strongly associated with responsibility, stability, seriousness, and achievement. At the same time, adult collectibles, designer toys, blind boxes, character goods, and other forms of “kidult” consumption have become increasingly visible.</p><p>So there is an interesting gap.</p><p>Adults may now have much more permission to <strong>buy playful things</strong>, but that does not automatically mean they have more permission to <strong>behave playfully</strong>.</p><p>That gap is important because TOYFORCE is intentionally a commercial brand. I am not interested in pretending that commerce is the enemy. I like objects. I like brands. I am interested in why people become attached to things and how products become part of identity.</p><p>The problem is that a product can support a playful way of living, but it can also simply sell the image of one.</p><p>Future C pushed this question until it became impossible to avoid:</p><p><strong>When does TOYFORCE encourage a playful life, and when does it simply sell “playful person” as another consumer identity?</strong></p><p>I do not think this contradiction needs to disappear. In fact, I think it may be one of the more important tensions inside the thesis.</p><p>The worst possible outcome would be for TOYFORCE to become a brand where people feel they need to purchase the right objects in order to perform playfulness correctly. A thesis that began by questioning rigid adulthood would have created a new kind of rigidity.</p><p>That is almost funny enough to become a TOYFORCE product itself.</p><h3>The Workflow Started Arguing With Me</h3><p>The part I did not expect was that the AI workflow itself started becoming part of the research.</p><p>I built the speculative futures in Hunch as a branching system. I did not want to ask one question and receive one polished answer. Each future developed through different branches: positive reactions, criticism, media interpretation, fan culture, backlash, success, failure, and different cultural contexts. Then those branches were brought back together into synthesis nodes.</p><p>That structure was useful because it prevented the workflow from treating one outcome as inevitable. The same feature could look valuable in one branch and become the exact source of criticism in another.</p><p>But after I finished the three futures and started combining them, something interesting happened.</p><p>Future B slowly began to take over.</p><p>The synthesis became increasingly focused on public participation, social permission, behavior, and intervention. The more developed those ideas became, the more the system treated them as the logical next direction.</p><p>For a moment, TOYFORCE stopped being a lifestyle brand.</p><p>That was when I created a <strong>Thesis Anchor</strong> inside the workflow.</p><p>The anchor was simple: TOYFORCE remains a lifestyle brand. The three futures are not competing replacements for the thesis. They are stress tests.</p><p>Once I made that explicit, the three futures became much easier to understand.</p><p>Future A showed me what TOYFORCE <strong>could become</strong>.</p><p>Future B showed me what TOYFORCE <strong>needs to understand</strong>.</p><p>Future C showed me what TOYFORCE <strong>needs to be careful not to become</strong>.</p><p>This small intervention in the workflow ended up teaching me something about working with AI as well. A model can continue a line of reasoning extremely well, but it does not automatically know which parts of a project are non-negotiable. If one branch becomes more detailed, the system can begin treating detail as importance.</p><p>That means I cannot only give AI more context. I also need to tell it where the boundaries are.</p><h3>From Hunch to Claude: Turning “What If?” Into “What Now?”</h3><p>After Hunch, I moved the results into Claude.</p><p>The relationship between the two tools became much clearer than I expected.</p><p>Hunch was good at expansion. It helped me stretch the thesis into alternate worlds, create contradictions, and explore what might happen if an idea became extremely successful or failed in a particular way.</p><p>Claude had a different job.</p><p>I gave it the synthesis and asked for a rollout plan.</p><p>In other words, Hunch kept asking <strong>“What if?”</strong></p><p>Claude asked <strong>“Okay, then what are you actually going to do?”</strong></p><p>That sounds like a natural next step, but it exposed another problem.</p><p>The first rollout plan Claude generated was highly detailed and very organized. It included public interventions, stewards, protocols, governance systems, open-source objects, and participation structures.</p><p>Again, it made sense.</p><p>And again, TOYFORCE had disappeared.</p><p>Claude had taken the strongest conclusions from Future B and treated them as the thesis direction.</p><p>So I corrected the input and made the lifestyle-brand position explicit.</p><p>The next version moved closer, but then Claude swung in another direction. It invented a set of engineered hero products and began planning mechanical tests, durability tests, user trials, and product specifications.</p><p>TOYFORCE had now become something closer to an industrial-design thesis.</p><p>That was another useful misunderstanding.</p><p>It forced me to articulate something I had not stated clearly enough before: <strong>the products are not the thesis.</strong></p><p>Products are one language through which I can imagine the thesis.</p><p>I do want real objects. EGGCIDENT matters more because it exists physically. Packaging, smell, scale, weight, and the fact that it actually burns are part of the joke. Some things need to exist in the world to be understood.</p><p>But I do not need to manufacture an entire lifestyle company.</p><p>A lot of TOYFORCE can and probably should remain speculative: furniture, interiors, clothing, accessories, retail environments, campaign images, domestic scenes, and other objects that help build a believable world. AI allows me to imagine the scale of a lifestyle brand without pretending I have the budget or production capacity of an actual company.</p><p>Once I fed Claude more of the research — not just the final conclusion — the rollout changed again. It began to understand the importance of BOYAR GIFTS and Big Night, the distinction between play and childishness, the role of permission, the commercial contradiction, the existing object experiments, and especially the importance of the home.</p><p>The final version now separates TOYFORCE into a larger speculative lifestyle world and a much smaller number of physical proofs.</p><p>That feels right.</p><p>The goal is no longer to prove that I can engineer ten perfect products.</p><p>The goal is to make the world believable enough that someone can understand what a play-first adult lifestyle might actually feel like.</p><h3>What I Am Taking Away</h3><p>The most useful thing speculative futuring gave me was not a prediction.</p><p>It gave me boundaries.</p><p>Before this week, I could say that TOYFORCE was a lifestyle brand for adult play, but that description was still broad enough to hide a lot of unresolved questions. By pushing the project into different futures, I had to decide what kind of lifestyle brand I actually meant.</p><p>I now think the thesis needs to operate across different levels of adult life. Some things can be used. Some can be worn or carried. Some can simply be lived with. Some can shape a room. Some can create a social invitation. Some might never create obvious “play behavior” at all, but still change how an ordinary moment feels.</p><p>That last point has also changed the way I think about evidence.</p><p>Earlier, I felt like I needed to prove that an object had successfully made someone play. But that starts to become a very narrow definition very quickly.</p><p>If someone keeps an object on their shelf because it makes them smile, does that count?</p><p>If they show it to every friend who visits?</p><p>If a piece of furniture makes a room feel less serious?</p><p>If someone misuses an object in a way I never predicted?</p><p>If it becomes part of a ritual?</p><p>If it makes someone remember something?</p><p>If it simply becomes something they want to live with?</p><p>For this thesis, I think those reactions matter.</p><p>The project is not trying to produce a “play score.” I am more interested in curiosity, surprise, attachment, reinterpretation, conversation, humor, and the strange moment when a familiar thing stops behaving exactly as expected.</p><p>That is also why the home now feels so important. I want TOYFORCE to exist not only in a temporary event or a campaign image, but in the ordinary background of adulthood. A chair, lamp, tray, candle, book, bag, jacket, or object on a shelf can become part of how someone constructs a life.</p><p>Not everything needs to scream that it is playful.</p><p>Actually, I think I am becoming more interested in the opposite.</p><p>What if play is simply already there?</p><p>I started this thesis thinking about how adulthood often asks us to put certain things away: curiosity, softness, imagination, humor, and purposeless enjoyment.</p><p>After this week, I am less interested in “bringing those things back.”</p><p>That phrasing assumes they disappeared.</p><p>Maybe the more interesting possibility is that they never needed to leave.</p><p>TOYFORCE is still a lifestyle brand. But now I understand it less as a collection of playful products and more as a proposal for what adulthood could feel like if play were allowed to remain inside it.</p><p>Not an escape from adulthood.</p><p>Not a return to childhood.</p><p>Not constant fun.</p><p>Just a life with more room for curiosity, absurdity, softness, surprise, and things that do not always need to justify themselves.</p><p>The speculative futures did not give me a final answer.</p><p>They made the original idea harder to say casually.</p><p>And I think that is probably the point.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=27d843e56d47" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Digging In: What Does the Literature Have to Say About My Thesis Territory?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153/digging-in-what-does-the-literature-have-to-say-about-my-thesis-territory-56d48cf7e417?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/56d48cf7e417</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[just-play]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[design-theses]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jialai Chen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 19 Oct 2026 20:41:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-19T20:41:51.806Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<blockquote>Last week, I was trying to figure out who was shaping my thesis territory.</blockquote><blockquote>This week, I became more interested in the arguments underneath it.</blockquote><blockquote>The literature on play is surprisingly messy. Researchers do not even fully agree on what play is, where it begins, what it is for, or whether asking “what is it for?” is already the wrong question.</blockquote><blockquote>That mess is becoming useful to me.</blockquote><blockquote>The more I read, the less I want a clean formula for adult play. I am more interested in a few tensions that keep showing up: usefulness versus uselessness, freedom versus rules, reality versus imagination, seriousness versus nonsense, and play as entertainment versus play as a way of questioning the world.</blockquote><h3>Play Is Bad at Staying in One Box 🗃️</h3><p>Brian Sutton-Smith’s <em>The Ambiguity of Play</em> gave me a much better reason for why defining play has been so frustrating.</p><p>He organizes major theories of play into seven “rhetorics”: progress, fate, power, identity, the imaginary, the self, and frivolity. Play can be explained as learning and development. It can also be competition, luck, fantasy, community, personal experience, or nonsense. Sutton-Smith is less interested in choosing the winner than in showing that each explanation comes with its own values and assumptions.</p><p>That is a pretty important warning.</p><p>If I only describe play as something that builds creativity, I am already choosing one story about it. If I describe it as stress relief, I am choosing another. If I focus only on toys, I am shrinking it again.</p><p>René Proyer’s research on adult playfulness makes the problem even more specific. His OLIW model separates adult playfulness into four dimensions: <strong>Other-directed, Lighthearted, Intellectual, and Whimsical</strong>. Someone might play through social interaction. Someone else might play with ideas, complexity, words, or strange connections. Another person might simply notice absurd things in everyday life.</p><p>I like this because it breaks one assumption I have been carrying into the visual side of my thesis:</p><p><strong>playful does not have one look.</strong></p><p>It does not automatically mean bright colors, toys, rounded shapes, jokes, or childish graphics.</p><p>Someone solving a weird conceptual problem can be playful. Someone rearranging objects for no reason can be playful. Someone making a dry joke in a meeting can be playful.</p><p>This gives TOYFORCE more room visually. Maybe some things can scream. Other things can barely wink.</p><h3>“Useless” Is Starting to Sound Useful 🤚</h3><p>A second thread in the literature is much stranger.</p><p>Play often involves choosing to do something in a way that is less efficient than necessary.</p><p>Roger Caillois describes play, rather wonderfully, as an occasion of <strong>“pure waste.”</strong> Time, effort, skill, money — gone. Yet he still considers play an important part of social and cultural life. He describes it as voluntary, uncertain, and separated in some way from ordinary necessity.</p><p>Bernard Suits takes the inefficiency even further in <em>The Grasshopper</em>. His famous definition of playing a game is a <strong>“voluntary attempt to overcome unnecessary obstacles.”</strong></p><p>That sentence is almost ridiculous when you think about it.</p><p>Golf would be much easier if I could pick up the ball and drop it in the hole.</p><p>A maze would be more efficient if it were a straight hallway.</p><p>A puzzle would be solved faster if somebody printed the answer on the box.</p><p>But then there would be no game.</p><p>This feels especially interesting now because so much contemporary design is built around removing friction. Faster checkout. Fewer clicks. Smarter recommendations. Automated decisions. AI finishing the sentence before I do.</p><p>Play often does the opposite.</p><p>It puts the friction back in.</p><p>Not because friction is always good, but because sometimes the unnecessary part <strong>is the experience</strong>.</p><p>This gives me a different way to think about my objects. A TOYFORCE object does not always need to make life easier. Maybe it can make a tiny part of life slightly more complicated, strange, or roundabout.</p><p>The “Nothing Serious Trophy” is a good example. A trophy normally compresses achievement into a clear hierarchy: you did something measurable, therefore you get the object. Giving someone a trophy for being the <strong>World’s Biggest Fried Egg Fan</strong> keeps the ritual but destroys the useful achievement underneath it.</p><p>Nothing was accomplished.</p><p>Excellent.</p><h3>Rick Rubin Made Me Suspicious of My Own Productivity Language 🧐</h3><p>Rick Rubin’s <em>The Creative Act: A Way of Being</em> is not play research, so I do not want to use it as scientific evidence.</p><p>But it sits surprisingly well next to this literature.</p><p>Rubin says he originally intended to write a book about making great art, but it became a book about <strong>“how to be.”</strong> His larger point is that creativity is not only the production of creative objects. It depends on attention, openness, noticing, experimentation, and a particular relationship with the world.</p><p>That feels close to play without being identical to it.</p><p>It also made me notice something uncomfortable in my own writing.</p><p>Every time I say adults should play because it improves creativity, resilience, innovation, or productivity, I make play defend itself using the language of work.</p><p>Basically:</p><blockquote><em>Please let us waste time. It will make us more efficient later.</em></blockquote><p>That is a terrible deal.</p><p>Sutton-Smith’s rhetoric of progress makes this problem very clear. A lot of modern thinking values play because of what it develops later. Children play, therefore they learn. Adults play, therefore they innovate. Play receives permission because it eventually reports back to something serious.</p><p>I do not want to throw those benefits away. There is real research behind many of them.</p><p>But I also do not want TOYFORCE to become productivity culture wearing a funny hat.</p><p>Rubin gives me a more useful connection: creativity — and maybe play — can be understood as a relationship to experience before it becomes an output.</p><p>That difference matters.</p><h3>Play Needs Reality, but Not Too Much Reality 🧏🏻‍♀️</h3><p>D. W. Winnicott’s <em>Playing and Reality</em> opened another direction for me.</p><p>Winnicott writes about an intermediate area between someone’s inner reality and the external world. His work begins with transitional objects in childhood, but extends toward playing, creativity, and cultural experience more broadly. This “in-between” area is neither completely imaginary nor simply objective reality.</p><p>This is useful for me because it gives objects a more interesting role.</p><p>A playful object does not need to become a fantasy prop that removes somebody from ordinary life.</p><p>It can stay ordinary.</p><p>But it can also hold another reading.</p><p>A tray is still a tray. Put glasses on it and suddenly it has a face.</p><p>A suit is still a suit. Open something unexpected inside it and the meaning changes.</p><p>A trophy is still recognizable as a trophy. The category printed on it can completely ruin its seriousness.</p><p>The real object stays there. The imaginary layer sits on top of it.</p><p>That seems much closer to the kind of adult play I am interested in than simply reproducing traditional toys.</p><p>It also gives me a useful design test:</p><p><strong>Does the object end after I understand what it is?</strong></p><p>If the answer is yes, maybe there is not much room left.</p><p>I want objects where the first reading is not necessarily the last one.</p><h3>Rules Do Not Kill Play. Boring Rules Might. 🙀</h3><p>I used to think open-endedness meant giving people as few rules as possible.</p><p>The literature keeps complicating that.</p><p>Caillois describes a spectrum between spontaneous improvisation and highly rule-bound forms of play. Even very structured games can still contain uncertainty and freedom inside the structure.</p><p>Suits makes the same point from another angle. The obstacle is unnecessary, but players willingly accept it. The limitation is what gives the action meaning.</p><p>A more recent book, Jaakko Stenros and Markus Montola’s <em>The Rule Book</em> (2024), argues that rules do more than restrict players. They create a limited possibility space and give actions meaning. Without the rules of chess, a queen is just a small object sitting on a board.</p><p>This makes me rethink what a playful design system should do.</p><p>Maybe the goal is not infinite possibility.</p><p>Infinite possibility can be exhausting.</p><p>“Do anything you want” is technically freedom, but it is also the design equivalent of handing someone a blank sheet of paper and walking away.</p><p>A strange rule can be much better.</p><p>Use this object incorrectly.</p><p>Make something in three minutes.</p><p>Give yourself a trophy for something nobody cares about.</p><p>Wear something where it obviously does not belong.</p><p>Suddenly there is somewhere to start.</p><p>This also connects back to the research on children without requiring me to pretend adults are children. Bodrova, Germeroth, and Leong’s discussion of Vygotskian play argues that mature make-believe play involves roles and rules rather than total behavioral freedom. Their work is about childhood development, so I would not use it as evidence for adult behavior. But it gives me another theoretical example of play and structure existing together rather than cancelling each other out.</p><p>Maybe good play design is not rule-free.</p><p>Maybe it just has rules worth breaking.</p><h3>Play Can Also Be a Little Rude 👅</h3><p>A lot of popular writing about play makes it sound incredibly wholesome.</p><p>Play connects us.</p><p>Play heals us.</p><p>Play makes us creative.</p><p>All good.</p><p>But Sutton-Smith’s categories include <strong>power</strong> and <strong>frivolity</strong>, not only development and happiness. Play can contain competition, parody, mockery, trickery, excess, absurdity, and inversion.</p><p>Mary Flanagan pushes this much further in <em>Critical Play: Radical Game Design</em>. She studies games and playful practices used for aesthetic, political, and social critique. Her examples include artists and designers who take familiar forms of play and twist them in order to question the assumptions underneath them.</p><p>This gave me a much sharper way of thinking about humor in TOYFORCE.</p><p>Humor does not need to be decoration.</p><p>Play can poke holes in things that normally feel fixed.</p><p>A fake trophy can make achievement culture look slightly ridiculous.</p><p>An “Off-Duty Suit” can mess with what professional clothing is supposed to communicate.</p><p>A “Bad Ideas Book” can temporarily reverse the normal demand that ideas should be smart, useful, presentable, and preferably monetizable.</p><p>These objects can still be funny.</p><p>But the joke can actually have teeth.</p><p>That feels more interesting than designing cheerful objects whose only job is to make someone smile.</p><h3>Adult Playfulness Is Not a Personality Type Called “Fun Person” 🥸</h3><p>Proyer’s OLIW research also gave me another useful correction.</p><p>I sometimes unconsciously imagine the target audience for this thesis as a particular kind of person: expressive, curious, visually adventurous, maybe already comfortable looking a little weird.</p><p>But the four dimensions in the OLIW model suggest that adult playfulness can show up very differently. <strong>Other-directed</strong> playfulness happens socially. <strong>Lighthearted</strong> playfulness involves improvisation and a less rigid approach to consequences. <strong>Intellectual</strong> playfulness appears in ideas and complexity. <strong>Whimsical</strong> playfulness involves noticing oddity in ordinary life.</p><p>That makes the audience much more interesting.</p><p>Someone does not need to wear a ridiculous hat to be playful.</p><p>They might love wordplay.</p><p>They might rearrange systems.</p><p>They might improvise dinner from whatever is left in the fridge.</p><p>They might send stupid photos to one specific friend and behave completely seriously everywhere else.</p><p>They might quietly enjoy objects that make no sense.</p><p>For the design, this means I should be careful not to turn <strong>playfulness into an aesthetic stereotype</strong>.</p><p>There can be loud play.</p><p>There can also be extremely deadpan play.</p><p>Honestly, I am becoming much more interested in the second one.</p><h3>What Happens When Play Escapes the Playground? 🛝</h3><p>Another theme across these sources is that play often gets separated from “normal life” in theory.</p><p>Caillois describes play as occurring within a protected space distinct from ordinary necessity. Winnicott gives us an intermediate space between inner and external reality. Games create their own rules and temporary meanings.</p><p>But my thesis is trying to do something slightly awkward with that.</p><p>I do not really want to build a separate playground.</p><p>I want play to leak.</p><p>Into the apartment.</p><p>Into clothing.</p><p>Onto the desk.</p><p>Into the kitchen.</p><p>Into the store.</p><p>Into the things someone already touches every day.</p><p>That creates a design question I had not articulated clearly before:</p><p><strong>How much ordinary life does an object need in order for its playful second reading to feel surprising?</strong></p><p>If everything in a space is screaming “FUN!!!,” nothing is surprising anymore.</p><p>Maybe the playful part needs something serious to push against.</p><p>That would explain why I am increasingly attracted to familiar adult objects rather than obvious toys: suits, trophies, trays, books, furniture, household objects.</p><p>The category gives me the setup.</p><p>Play gives me the wrong answer.</p><h3>The Literature Is Also Making My Thesis Less Nice 🥴</h3><p>I mean that in a good way.</p><p>Earlier in this thesis, I was using words like joy, curiosity, softness, and openness a lot.</p><p>I still believe in them.</p><p>But the literature is showing me that play is bigger and messier than a collection of positive feelings.</p><p>It can waste time.</p><p>It can create obstacles.</p><p>It can involve power.</p><p>It can distort reality.</p><p>It can mock rules.</p><p>It can produce nothing.</p><p>It can be intensely structured.</p><p>It can be absurd.</p><p>It can even be annoying.</p><p>That makes the territory much richer.</p><p>And it makes the thesis less like a campaign saying:</p><p><strong>ADULTS SHOULD PLAY MORE :)</strong></p><p>I am much more interested in asking what happens when adulthood is allowed to become slightly less optimized, slightly less literal, and slightly less single-use.</p><h3>Where I Am Now 🤲</h3><p>The biggest change this week is that I no longer see play as one thing that I need to insert into adult life.</p><p>The literature makes that almost impossible anyway.</p><p>Sutton-Smith shows me that play carries multiple, sometimes conflicting meanings. Caillois and Suits show that inefficiency and unnecessary difficulty can be part of its pleasure. Winnicott gives me an in-between space where reality and imagination can overlap. Proyer shows that adult playfulness has different forms. Flanagan shows that play can question culture instead of simply decorating it. Rubin, from outside academic play research, gives me a useful parallel: maybe the deeper shift is not a new activity but another way of meeting the world.</p><p>Together, they are pushing TOYFORCE somewhere more specific.</p><p>I am less interested in designing things that <strong>look playful</strong>.</p><p>I want to design things that refuse to have only one correct reading.</p><p>An object can work and still contain a joke.</p><p>A rule can exist and still invite misuse.</p><p>Something can be beautifully made and completely unnecessary.</p><p>A serious object can have an unserious second life.</p><p>Maybe that is the territory I am actually digging into now:</p><p><strong>How can design make adult life a little less single-use?</strong></p><p>That question feels much bigger than toys.</p><p>And much more fun.</p><h3>Research Referenced</h3><p>Brian Sutton-Smith, <em>The Ambiguity of Play</em> (1997) — competing rhetorics of play, ambiguity, progress, power, identity, imagination, self, and frivolity.</p><p>Roger Caillois, <em>Man, Play and Games</em> — voluntary play, uncertainty, rules, improvisation, and play as “pure waste.”</p><p>Bernard Suits, <em>The Grasshopper: Games, Life and Utopia</em> — games as voluntarily overcoming unnecessary obstacles.</p><p>D. W. Winnicott, <em>Playing and Reality</em> — transitional objects, potential/intermediate space, creativity, and cultural experience.</p><p>René T. Proyer, “A New Structural Model for the Study of Adult Playfulness” — Other-directed, Lighthearted, Intellectual, and Whimsical adult playfulness.</p><p>Mary Flanagan, <em>Critical Play: Radical Game Design</em> — play as aesthetic, political, and social critique.</p><p>Rick Rubin, <em>The Creative Act: A Way of Being</em> — creativity as a relationship to the world rather than only the production of an artifact.</p><p>Jaakko Stenros and Markus Montola, <em>The Rule Book</em> — rules as constraints that create possibility and meaning.</p><p>Elena Bodrova, Carrie Germeroth, and Deborah J. Leong, “Play and Self-Regulation: Lessons from Vygotsky” — the relationship between roles, rules, and mature pretend play.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=56d48cf7e417" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Who Are the Leaders in My Thesis Territory?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153/who-are-the-leaders-in-my-thesis-territory-9105683a9aef?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9105683a9aef</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[design-theses]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[adult-play]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jialai Chen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 12 Oct 2026 22:53:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-12T22:59:50.274Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Who Are the Leaders in My Thesis Territory? Or: Apparently, “Just Play More” Is Not Very Useful Advice</h3><blockquote>I started this thesis with an idea that still feels true to me: <strong>play should have a bigger place in adult life!</strong></blockquote><blockquote>Not necessarily a scheduled “play hour.” Not a giant ball pit in every office. And definitely not the idea that, in order to play, adults need to somehow become eight years old again.</blockquote><blockquote>What I am interested in is a <strong>play-first way of living</strong> — one where curiosity, humor, softness, imagination, and doing things simply because we enjoy them can coexist with responsibility, intelligence, taste, work, bills, and everything else that comes with being grown-up.</blockquote><blockquote>TOYFORCE is one possible world for that idea. It could include toys, but also clothing, furniture, objects, spaces, events, publications, or things I have not thought of yet.</blockquote><blockquote>So my research question slowly became less about <strong>what playful things I could make</strong> and more about:</blockquote><blockquote><strong>What actually allows an adult to play?</strong></blockquote><blockquote>And, maybe more importantly:</blockquote><blockquote><strong>What makes us stop ourselves?</strong></blockquote><blockquote>The people I have been reading, watching, listening to, and interviewing do not all define play in exactly the same way. But several ideas keep showing up again and again.</blockquote><h3>🌟 1. P<strong>layfulness</strong> Is Bigger Than “Playing”</h3><p>One of the first people who helped me understand this was philosopher <strong>Miguel Sicart</strong>.</p><p>In <a href="https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262534512/play-matters/"><em>Play Matters</em></a>, Sicart makes an important distinction between <strong>play</strong> and <strong>playfulness</strong>. Play can be something I do. Playfulness is more like an attitude I bring into a situation.</p><p>That difference opened the project up for me.</p><p>If playfulness can exist while I am cooking, dressing, walking, making something, rearranging my desk, talking to somebody, or interacting with an ordinary object, then my thesis does not need to create a separate little zone called:</p><p><strong>ADULT PLAY — PLEASE ENTER HERE.</strong></p><p>A 2023 study by <strong>Kathy Lubbers and her collaborators</strong>, <a href="https://doi.org/10.5920/jpa.1258">“Adult Play and Playfulness: A Qualitative Exploration of Its Meanings and Importance,”</a> reinforced this. When adults were asked what playfulness meant to them, they did not only describe games or activities. They talked about humor, relationships, positive emotions, and ways of experiencing everyday life.</p><p>That distinction also appears in <strong>Katina Bajaj’s</strong> TED Talk, <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/katina_bajaj_how_play_boosts_your_creativity_and_resilience">“How Play Boosts Your Creativity and Resilience.”</a></p><p>One line stayed with me:</p><blockquote><em>“Play wasn’t some list of actions we could add to our calendar. It was an approach.”</em></blockquote><p>I like this because the last thing I want to do is turn play into another thing adults are supposed to optimize.</p><p><strong>Wake up. Meditate. Drink water. Answer emails. Play for twenty minutes. Return to being serious.</strong></p><p>That would kind of defeat the point.</p><p>For me, this research shifted play from being an <strong>activity category</strong> to something closer to a <strong>way of moving through life</strong>. How exciting!</p><h3>🫧 2. Maybe Adults Don’t Outgrow Play. Maybe We Get Better at Editing Ourselves.</h3><p>This has probably been the biggest realization in my research so far.</p><p>The more I read about adults and play, the less convinced I am that people simply “grow out of it.”</p><p>Instead, we become very good at asking questions like:</p><p><strong>Is this useful?</strong></p><p><strong>Am I good at it?</strong></p><p><strong>Is this embarrassing?</strong></p><p><strong>Is somebody watching me?</strong></p><p><strong>Am I too old for this?</strong></p><p>And once those questions get loud enough, the playful impulse can disappear before anything actually happens.</p><p>Designer <strong>Cas Holman (</strong>One of my favorite artists in this planet) has been especially important here. Her book <a href="https://casholman.com/book"><em>Playful: How Play Shifts Our Thinking, Inspires Connection, and Sparks Creativity</em></a> describes the tension between what she calls the <strong>Play Voice</strong> and the <strong>Adult Voice</strong>.b</p><p>The Play Voice notices possibility.</p><p>The Adult Voice is more likely to ask whether the possibility is productive, appropriate, impressive, or stupid.</p><p>Holman’s framework — <strong>embrace possibility, release judgment, reframe success</strong> — has started to feel almost like a checklist for my thesis.</p><p>In her conversation with <a href="https://www.goodlifeproject.com/podcast/adult-play-free-play-playful-learning-cas-holman/"><em>Good Life Project</em></a>, she talks about how easily adults abandon things once we realize we are not particularly good at them or cannot turn them into achievement.</p><p>And in <a href="https://www.eliseloehnen.com/p/remembering-how-to-playeven-when"><em>Pulling the Thread</em></a>, she makes a deceptively simple point:</p><blockquote><em>“Adults do play.”</em></blockquote><p>The problem is often accessing it.</p><p><strong>Beth Kelley</strong> pushes this question into the social world. In the <em>Playful Nature</em> episode <a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/51-beth-kelley-who-decided-adults-should-stop-playing/id1779475925?i=1000788036370">“Who Decided Adults Should Stop Playing?”, </a>the conversation moves through “cringe,” public embarrassment, adult social norms, and why telling someone to “just go play” is not particularly helpful.</p><p>This showed up very clearly in the Reddit discussions I looked at too.</p><p>In one thread, a woman described continuing to play imaginatively with Barbie and Polly Pocket well into adulthood — but hiding it because she had learned that other people might see it as childish.</p><p>In another, people asked why playgrounds are designed so clearly around one message:</p><p><strong>Children belong here. Adults do not.</strong></p><p>These stories are anecdotal, not scientific evidence, but they made something very visible to me:</p><p><strong>The desire to play can still be there long after the permission disappears.</strong></p><p>And permission is not only something inside our heads.</p><p>A room can give permission.</p><p>A group of people can give permission.</p><p>An object can give permission.</p><p>A brand can give permission.</p><p>Or all of those things can quietly tell you:</p><p><strong>Don’t.</strong></p><h3>😌 3. Unfortunately for Me as a Designer, You Cannot Force Someone to Play</h3><p>This became much clearer through my SME interviews.</p><p>I spoke with <strong>Renee Bryant</strong>, founder of <a href="https://www.theplayrxcure.com/">The Play Rx</a>, who works specifically with adults and play.</p><p>Very early in our conversation, she told me:</p><blockquote><em>“Play is not an activity. The question should be, are you in a state of play? Because play is an attitude.”</em></blockquote><p>And then:</p><blockquote><em>“I can’t tell anyone to play.”</em></blockquote><p>This is both extremely useful and slightly annoying when my thesis is about designing for play.</p><blockquote>Because if I cannot tell someone to play, then I also cannot completely design what their play is supposed to look like.</blockquote><p>Renee described her role instead as creating an <strong>arena</strong> where play might happen.</p><p>She also gave me one of my favorite lines from the research:</p><blockquote><em>“You have to shrink the search space, but not so much that you suffocate.”</em></blockquote><p>That sentence has stayed in my head while I design.</p><p>Too much freedom can feel like standing in front of a blank page.</p><p>Too much instruction turns the experience into another task.</p><p>The interesting territory is somewhere between them.</p><p>Give me enough structure that I want to enter.</p><p>But leave enough uncertainty that something can still become mine.</p><p>Cas Holman reaches a similar conclusion in <em>Playful</em>, especially in the chapter titled <strong>“Making Play, Not Toys.”</strong></p><p>That title has become very useful for me.</p><p>It does not mean “don’t make toys.”</p><p>It means the object itself is not the final goal.</p><p>The more useful question is:</p><p><strong>What kind of behavior, interpretation, curiosity, interaction, or possibility does the thing leave behind?</strong></p><p>That changes how I look at my own objects.</p><p>A strange trophy is not interesting just because it has a funny sentence on it.</p><p>A face-shaped tray is not playful simply because it looks unusual.</p><p>The question becomes:</p><p><strong>Does the person get to continue the idea?</strong></p><p>Can they rearrange it?</p><p>Misuse it?</p><p>Interpret it differently?</p><p>Make their own joke?</p><p>Discover something I did not prescribe?</p><p>That is much closer to the kind of design I want to make.</p><h3>🍀 4. Adult Play Does Not Mean Becoming a Child Again</h3><p>This is probably the position I feel strongest about now.</p><p>The phrase <strong>“play like a child again”</strong> appears everywhere.</p><p>I understand why.</p><p>Children are easy shorthand for curiosity, imagination, spontaneity, and freedom.</p><p>But the more I research, the less interested I am in asking adults to somehow undo adulthood.</p><p>Renee challenged this directly in our conversation.</p><p>At one point she said:</p><blockquote><em>“We infantilize children.”</em></blockquote><p>And later:</p><blockquote><em>“You have to play at the top of your intelligence. You don’t regress to play. You progress.”</em></blockquote><p>That sentence helped me articulate something I had been feeling but did not yet have words for.</p><p>Adult play does not have to happen by removing adult knowledge.</p><p>It can happen <strong>on top of it</strong>.</p><p>An adult brings taste, references, humor, cultural awareness, relationships, skills, contradictions, and twenty or fifty or eighty years of experience into play.</p><p>Why would I want to erase all of that?</p><p>My conversation with Danish play researcher <strong>Ann Charlotte Thorsted</strong> reinforced this.</p><p>Thorsted has studied play in adult and organizational contexts, including work connected to LEGO. Her research can be found through <a href="https://www.anncharlottethorsted.dk/publikationer">her publications</a> and in work such as <a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/21594937.2016.1147292">“Communities of Play — a Collective Unfolding.”</a></p><p>She told me:</p><blockquote><em>“Adults are not the same when we are playing. It’s not the same as when children are playing.”</em></blockquote><p>That feels obvious once somebody says it.</p><p>But culturally, we still often talk about play as if childhood owns the copyright.</p><p>Thorsted also talked to me about <strong>wonder</strong>.</p><p>When I described making absurd objects, she was interested in the moment when somebody looks at something and thinks:</p><blockquote><em>“What is going on here? I don’t understand that.”</em></blockquote><p>I love that as a design condition.</p><p>Not confusion for the sake of confusion.</p><p>Just enough interruption to break certainty.</p><p>A moment where the object stops being obvious and a question begins.</p><p>That, to me, feels much more interesting than trying to recreate childhood.</p><h3>🧸 5. Toys Are Part of My Territory. But “Toy” Is Not the Territory.</h3><p>Researching adult toy culture has also been useful because it shows just how much the category of adulthood is already changing.</p><p><strong>Katriina Heljakka’s</strong> article <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2673-8392/5/3/127">“Adult Play with Character Toys”</a> looks at adults collecting, photographing, customizing, displaying, traveling with, storytelling around, and forming emotional relationships with toys.</p><p>Her research is helpful because it complicates the assumption that an adult with a toy is simply nostalgic or regressing.</p><p>Adults can use toys for identity, storytelling, community, creativity, photography, humor, and world-building.</p><p>At the same time, adult toy consumption is now a major commercial category.</p><p>Diego Lasarte’s <em>New Yorker</em> article <a href="https://www.newyorker.com/culture/the-lede/why-adults-are-playing-with-toys">“Why Adults Are Playing with Toys”</a> looks at the rise of “kidult” culture, collecting, nostalgia, fandom, and the growing economic importance of adult toy consumers.</p><p><a href="https://newsdig.tbs.co.jp/articles/-/2910179">TBS NEWS DIG</a> has documented a similar phenomenon in Japan.</p><p>This is definitely relevant to TOYFORCE.</p><p>But TOYFORCE is not trying to become another “toys for adults” label.</p><p>A toy can belong in the world.</p><p>So can a jacket.</p><p>A chair.</p><p>A trophy.</p><p>A book.</p><p>A weird incense burner.</p><p>A store.</p><p>A party.</p><p>A piece of packaging.</p><p>A public intervention.</p><p>The category is not what connects them.</p><p><strong>The attitude is.</strong></p><p>TOYFORCE is ultimately more interesting to me as a lifestyle proposition:</p><p><strong>What if play were allowed to show up in what we wear, collect, display, live with, and do every day?</strong></p><h3>🪁 6. So What Am I Actually Learning as a Designer?</h3><p>A few things now feel much clearer.</p><p>First:</p><p><strong>Play does not need to be justified only because it makes us more productive.</strong></p><p>Yes, research connects play to creativity, resilience, learning, adaptability, and social connection.</p><p>Stuart Brown discusses lifelong play and its developmental importance in <em>Play</em> and his TED Talk <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/stuart_brown_play_is_more_than_just_fun">“Play Is More Than Just Fun.”</a></p><p>His article <a href="https://www.fa-sett.no/filer/Consequences_of_Play_Deprivation-Stuart_Brown_MD.pdf">“Consequences of Play Deprivation” </a>also examines what may happen when play becomes absent from life.</p><p><strong>Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi’s</strong> work on intrinsic rewards and flow is useful for understanding experiences that are rewarding in themselves.</p><p><strong>Andrew Huberman’s</strong> episode <a href="https://www.hubermanlab.com/episode/using-play-to-rewire-and-improve-your-brain">“Using Play to Rewire &amp; Improve Your Brain”</a> talks about play as low-stakes exploration and contingency testing.</p><p><strong>David Elkind</strong>, <strong>Julia Cameron</strong>, and <strong>Rick Rubin</strong> have also helped me think about self-directed exploration, creativity, process, curiosity, and the damage done by premature judgment.</p><p>But I am becoming careful about making an argument that sounds like:</p><p><strong>Play is important because it will make you work better.</strong></p><p>That would make play answer to productivity again.</p><p>Sometimes the value of doing something is simply:</p><p><strong>I wanted to.</strong></p><p>Second:</p><p><strong>Play needs uncertainty.</strong></p><p>Michael Kleiss’s TED Talk <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/michael_kleiss_toys_are_for_grown_ups">“Toys Are for Grown-Ups”</a> helped me think about toys as tools for testing, building, rearranging, failing, and thinking through the hands.</p><p><strong>Fabian Hemmert’s</strong> talk <a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/fabian_hemmert_learn_grow_and_thrive_the_transformative_power_of_play">“Learn, Grow, and Thrive: The Transformative Power of Play”</a> similarly shows how play can be used to enter complicated subjects and speculative futures.</p><p>Their work reinforces something that has come up everywhere else:</p><p>A playful object does not need to scream:</p><p><strong>PLAY WITH ME!</strong></p><p>Sometimes it just needs to create a small crack in certainty.</p><p><strong>What else could this be?</strong></p><p><strong>What happens if I do this?</strong></p><p><strong>Am I allowed to use it wrong?</strong></p><p><strong>Is there even a wrong way?</strong></p><p>And third:</p><p><strong>My role is not to design the answer.</strong></p><p>It is to design enough of an invitation that somebody wants to find their own.</p><h3>Where I Am Now</h3><p>I started this thesis wanting to build a <strong>play-first lifestyle for adults</strong>.</p><p>That part has not changed.</p><p>What has changed is that I now understand more clearly what that ambition requires.</p><p>It is not enough to make things colorful, weird, funny, cute, collectible, or “playful-looking.”</p><p>For play to become part of adult life, there also needs to be:</p><p><strong>possibility.</strong></p><p><strong>intrinsic motivation.</strong></p><p><strong>uncertainty.</strong></p><p><strong>room for interpretation.</strong></p><p><strong>freedom from immediate judgment.</strong></p><p><strong>social permission.</strong></p><p>And enough structure to help someone begin without deciding where they have to end.</p><p>Most importantly, I no longer think adulthood and play need to negotiate with each other.</p><p>One does not have to disappear for the other to exist.</p><p>Maybe maturity can include responsibility <strong>and</strong> ridiculousness.</p><p>Taste <strong>and</strong> curiosity.</p><p>Competence <strong>and</strong> experimentation.</p><p>Knowing a lot <strong>and</strong> still asking “what if?”</p><p>That is becoming the territory I care about most.</p><p>TOYFORCE is not asking adults to go backward.</p><p>It is proposing that maybe there was never a good reason for play to be left behind in the first place.</p><h3>Research Referenced in This Post ;)</h3><ul><li><a href="https://mitpress.mit.edu/9780262534512/play-matters/">Miguel Sicart, <em>Play Matters</em></a></li><li><a href="https://doi.org/10.5920/jpa.1258">Kathy Lubbers et al., “Adult Play and Playfulness”</a></li><li><a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/stuart_brown_play_is_more_than_just_fun">Stuart Brown, “Play Is More Than Just Fun”</a></li><li><a href="https://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Consequences_of_Play_Deprivation">Stuart Brown, “Consequences of Play Deprivation”</a></li><li><a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/katina_bajaj_how_play_boosts_your_creativity_and_resilience">Katina Bajaj, “How Play Boosts Your Creativity and Resilience”</a></li><li><a href="https://casholman.com/book">Cas Holman, <em>Playful</em></a></li><li><a href="https://www.goodlifeproject.com/podcast/adult-play-free-play-playful-learning-cas-holman/">Cas Holman on <em>Good Life Project</em></a></li><li><a href="https://www.eliseloehnen.com/p/remembering-how-to-playeven-when">Cas Holman on <em>Pulling the Thread</em></a></li><li><a href="https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/playful-nature-podcast-by-wildstrong/id1745575490">Beth Kelley on <em>Playful Nature</em></a></li><li><a href="https://www.theplayrxcure.com/">Renee Bryant / The Play Rx</a></li><li><a href="https://www.anncharlottethorsted.dk/publikationer">Ann Charlotte Thorsted</a></li><li><a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/21594937.2016.1147292">“Communities of Play — a Collective Unfolding”</a></li><li><a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2673-8392/5/3/127">Katriina Heljakka, “Adult Play with Character Toys”</a></li><li><a href="https://www.newyorker.com/culture/the-lede/why-adults-are-playing-with-toys">Diego Lasarte, “Why Adults Are Playing with Toys”</a></li><li><a href="https://newsdig.tbs.co.jp/articles/-/2910179">TBS NEWS DIG on Japan’s “kidult” toy market</a></li><li><a href="https://www.hubermanlab.com/episode/using-play-to-rewire-and-improve-your-brain">Andrew Huberman, “Using Play to Rewire &amp; Improve Your Brain”</a></li><li><a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/michael_kleiss_toys_are_for_grown_ups">Michael Kleiss, “Toys Are for Grown-Ups”</a></li><li><a href="https://www.ted.com/talks/fabian_hemmert_learn_grow_and_thrive_the_transformative_power_of_play">Fabian Hemmert, “The Transformative Power of Play”</a></li></ul><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9105683a9aef" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Challenged Myself to “Finish My Thesis’ in 1 Week. Here’s What Happened]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153/i-challenged-myself-to-finish-my-thesis-in-1-week-here-s-what-happened-d8ba832f85b7?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d8ba832f85b7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[one-week-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jialai Chen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 01 Oct 2026 20:14:07 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-10-01T20:14:07.575Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Stop Thinking Too Much. Start Making</h4><blockquote>Trying to “finish” a thesis in one week sounds a little ridiculous — especially when the thesis itself is about play. But that was exactly what made the exercise useful.</blockquote><blockquote>For one week, I stopped treating my thesis as a distant idea and tried to build it as if it already existed. I gave it a name, a visual identity, products, campaigns, and a world of its own.</blockquote><blockquote>More importantly, I stopped asking whether this was the “right” thesis and started asking what I actually wanted to make. This week confirmed something I had already been feeling: <strong>this is the direction I want to keep exploring.</strong></blockquote><blockquote>TOYFORCE began with a simple question: why does growing up so often mean becoming more serious? As we take on more roles and responsibilities, curiosity, softness, humor, and purposeless joy can start to feel like things we are expected to leave behind.</blockquote><blockquote>I wanted to imagine another possibility.</blockquote><h4>First, I had to figure out what TOYFORCE actually makes.</h4><p>This sounds obvious, but it was probably the most important step.<br>If TOYFORCE was going to be more than a logo and a manifesto, I needed to understand what existed inside its world. So I started with a lot of brainstorming, and I gave myself permission to come up with ideas before asking whether they were practical.</p><p>That led to things like soap shaped like a block of matcha, an egg-shaped chair, matching outfits inspired by tangled telephone cords, strange toys, collectible objects, accessories, and home goods. Some ideas were useful. Some were barely useful at all. That was kind of the point!</p><p>I became interested in taking familiar objects — things we wear, use, collect, or keep around the house — and shifting them just enough to make them surprising again. A chair could behave a little more like a toy. A household object could become something collectible. Clothing could carry the logic of a game or an inside joke. Instead of asking, “What kind of toy should I design?” I started asking: What happens when play gets into everything?<br>That question opened the project up immediately. TOYFORCE could make things to play with, things to wear, things to sit on, things to collect, and things that simply make someone stop for a second and smile.</p><h4>Then I had to figure out what the brand itself should feel like.</h4><p>At that point, I stopped thinking about TOYFORCE as a brand with fixed boundaries. I started to see it as a space for endless possibilities — something that could keep shifting, surprising, and showing up in ways people might not expect. That idea became the foundation of the visual identity. I chose a star as the main symbol of the brand. To me, it represents energy, possibility, and the feeling that something unexpected could happen at any moment. It also gave TOYFORCE a simple visual device that could keep changing across different applications without losing its identity.</p><p>The goal was not to make the brand look “playful” in an obvious way, but to make it feel open-ended, slightly unpredictable, and always ready for the next idea.</p><h4><strong>One week was obviously not enough.</strong></h4><p>But that was useful too.</p><p>The point of the exercise was not really to finish the thesis. It was to find out what would happen if I stopped treating it like an abstract future project and started treating it like something real.</p><p>And what happened was that the project kept expanding.</p><p>Every product suggested another product. A toy led to a home object. A home object suggested a campaign image. A campaign image suggested a physical space. That led to ideas for a website, a product catalog, limited editions, artist collaborations, cultural research, and eventually an entire world around the brand.</p><p>I also began finding books, artists, designers, and toy traditions from different cultures that could become part of the research. That was when I started to see that the project had more depth than simply “making fun things.”</p><p>Toys and playful objects can carry memory, culture, ritual, identity, comfort, and humor. The forms may change from place to place, but the impulse to spin something, collect something, dress something, stack something, or simply keep an object because it makes us happy seems to appear again and again.</p><p>There is a huge amount here that I have barely touched.</p><h4>The biggest surprise was how good the project felt to work on.</h4><p>That sounds like a small thing, but I do not think it is.</p><p>During this week, I was constantly looking for weird references, strange objects, materials, toys, furniture, packaging, fashion, and cultural artifacts. Research itself started to feel playful. I was not approaching every reference with the pressure of asking, “How does this prove my thesis?” I was following curiosity and seeing where it led.</p><p>That mindset was genuinely refreshing.</p><p>The project gives me permission to work across product design, branding, photography, motion, spatial design, fashion, publishing, and cultural research without feeling like those things need to be separated from one another. It also gives me room to be a little unreasonable.</p><p>For a designer, that feels incredibly valuable.</p><p>The people around me who saw the work during the week told me that the brand already felt convincing and, more importantly, fun. Considering how quickly everything was made, that made me think this might be something worth spending the next several months developing properly.</p><p>Not because I think the project is finished.</p><p>Almost the opposite.</p><p>I can now see how unfinished it is.</p><h4>So what is TOYFORCE really trying to do?</h4><p>I do not think the goal is simply to convince adults to buy toys.<br>It is also not about pretending adulthood does not exist.</p><p>TOYFORCE — for now; I reserve the right to have a naming crisis later — is interested in building a play-first way of living: one where play is not limited to a particular age, activity, or moment of free time. It can live in the clothes we wear, the objects we keep, the furniture in our homes, the things we collect, and the small rituals of everyday life.</p><p>The project is about making room for the parts of ourselves that adulthood often asks us to put away: curiosity, softness, imagination, humor, and the ability to enjoy something simply because we like it.<br>Maybe that is what I learned most clearly from this one-week experiment.<br>I do not want to make a thesis that only explains why play matters. I want to build a world where you can actually feel it.</p><p>And ideally, one that makes someone laugh along the way.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d8ba832f85b7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[✒️First Principles: Testing 4 Thesis Directions with AI]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153/first-principles-testing-4-thesis-directions-with-ai-1dbca776c743?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1dbca776c743</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[mfad]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jialai Chen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Sep 2026 14:51:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-21T16:37:08.088Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>I needed a way to look at my thesis ideas with more distance than simply asking, <strong>“Do I like this?”</strong> So I built a <strong>Thesis Testing Machine</strong> that puts every direction through the same sequence of checks.</h4><p>I borrowed the idea of <strong>first-principles thinking</strong> to separate what I actually knew from what I was only assuming. Before thinking about what I wanted to design, the machine asked what each thesis was fundamentally about, what forces were shaping the problem, what already existed around it, and what still needed to be tested.</p><p>From there, each direction went through the same structure: first principles, research territory, leading thinkers and precedents, possible design outcomes, practical constraints, personal fit, risks, and eventually a reframed thesis question.</p><p>For each direction, I also developed a separate <strong>Thesis Briefing Document</strong> containing research references, assumptions, prior work, contradictions, traps, possible outcomes, and a “Why Me?” section. The sections below pull out some of the findings that felt most useful or surprising to me, followed by my own response to each one.</p><p>Whichever direction I eventually choose will stay with me for roughly a year. I will be researching it, testing it, questioning it, and probably getting annoyed with it at some point too. So instead of only looking for the idea that sounds most exciting right now, I wanted to see what happens when all four are pushed through the same structure!</p><h3><strong>Elastic Identity</strong></h3><p>Briefing Document: <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ba6fjwNt8V1teZBUUln9mzRjKyOLEgFB/view?usp=drive_link">https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ba6fjwNt8V1teZBUUln9mzRjKyOLEgFB/view?usp=drive_link</a></p><h4>What the AI Brief Surfaced</h4><p>I originally approached <strong>Elastic Identity</strong> as a branding project about whether one identity could take on very different visual expressions across cultures, audiences, and contexts.</p><p>The AI test quickly made that question more specific:</p><blockquote><strong><em>How much can a brand change before it stops feeling like the same brand?</em></strong></blockquote><p>One of the strongest findings was that brand identity may depend less on visual sameness than on a smaller set of stable underlying principles. That shifted the research away from asking, “How many styles can one brand have?” toward a more useful question:</p><blockquote><strong><em>What should remain invariant when a brand moves between cultures and contexts?</em></strong></blockquote><p>The research territory around this question includes flexible identity systems, dynamic identities, adaptive branding, global-versus-local branding, and cross-cultural communication.</p><p>The references also helped make the problem more concrete. Martin Lorenz’s <em>Flexible Visual Systems</em> offers one way to think about rule-based variation rather than random stylistic change. Kenya Hara and MUJI raise a different question: how can a strong philosophy remain recognizable even when its campaigns, photography, products, spaces, and local expressions change?</p><p>The brief suggested studying brands such as <strong>MUJI, MTV, TikTok, and Penguin Random House</strong>, not as visual inspiration, but by asking the same questions of each one:</p><p>What remains stable?<br> What is allowed to change?<br> And which changes actually threaten recognition?</p><p>From that came one possible framework: dividing brand elements into <strong>Invariant, Adaptive, and Open</strong>.</p><p>The project could then pressure-test that framework. Typography, imagery, motion, language, material, and spatial identity might all change under different cultural conditions, while a smaller set of principles or signals remains fixed.</p><p>That made <strong>System + Experiment</strong> much more convincing to me than simply creating multiple versions of the same brand.</p><h4>My Response</h4><p>This direction connects very directly to the kind of work I want to do professionally. I am interested in branding, cultural context, and moving between different visual languages rather than applying one recognizable personal style to everything.</p><p>But the machine also exposed the project’s biggest weakness.</p><p>Because I already enjoy working across different styles, the thesis could very easily become:</p><p><strong>“Look, I can design the same brand in five different ways.”</strong></p><p>That might make a good portfolio project, but it would not necessarily give me enough to investigate for a full year.</p><p>The important shift for me is from:</p><p><strong>“I can design in different styles.”</strong></p><p>to:</p><p><strong>“I can explain why, when, and how a visual language should change.”</strong></p><p>If I continued with this thesis, I would probably narrow <strong>culture</strong> as the main variable rather than trying to study culture, media, audience, and collaboration at the same time. I would also begin with an <strong>Invariant Audit</strong> of existing global brands before designing my own system.</p><p>That would force me to build the project from evidence instead of immediately jumping into visual experimentation.</p><h3><strong>Who Owns the Wall?</strong></h3><p>Briefing Document: <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1A7m4BfLj1nAJsG5zg5LbVy6L4XWZMHLO/view?usp=sharing">https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ba6fjwNt8V1teZBUUln9mzRjKyOLEgFB/view?usp=drive_link</a></p><h4>What the AI Brief Surfaced</h4><p>My starting point for <strong>Who Owns the Wall?</strong> was much more observational: graffiti, stickers, posters, advertisements, and other unofficial marks across New York City.</p><p>At first, I was interested in the contrast between authorized and unauthorized visual communication.</p><p>But the AI test suggested that a simple <strong>legal versus illegal</strong> or <strong>advertising versus graffiti</strong> framework was probably too narrow.</p><p>The stronger question became:</p><blockquote><strong><em>How is the right to be visible negotiated on New York City surfaces?</em></strong></blockquote><p>One of the findings I found most interesting was that <strong>permission may actually be more important than ownership</strong>.</p><p>A privately owned wall can face the public.<br> A legal advertisement is still regulated.<br> An unofficial sticker may disappear almost immediately.<br> A message can be publicly visible without the surface itself being public.</p><p>That reframed the wall from a visual backdrop into a system involving <strong>permission, placement, maintenance, regulation, removal, and replacement</strong>.</p><p>The research territory also became much wider than graffiti history. It could include public-space studies, urban regulation, activist graphics, visual anthropology, ephemera, urban memory, and the right to the city.</p><p>The brief pointed me toward research including Sabina Andron’s work on urban surfaces, Joe Austin’s <em>Taking the Train</em>, Martha Cooper and Henry Chalfant’s <em>Subway Art</em>, and <em>Style Wars</em>. Together, these references would help me understand the wall not just as an image, but as a social, legal, historical, and material space.</p><p>The most useful proposed method was something called a <strong>Surface Biography</strong>.</p><p>Instead of walking around New York collecting hundreds of unrelated photographs, I could choose a small number of surfaces and return to them repeatedly.</p><p>I could document:</p><p>appearance,<br> overlap,<br> covering,<br> removal,<br> repair,<br> residue,<br> and return.</p><p>Alongside that, a <strong>Visibility Atlas</strong> could classify each mark according to things such as surface type, permission status, lifespan, scale, author type, removal method, and its relationship to nearby commercial or official messages.</p><p>That would make <strong>time itself part of the evidence</strong>.</p><h4>My Response</h4><p>I like this direction partly because it asks me to work in almost the opposite way from my normal practice.</p><p>Instead of creating a controlled design system, I would be observing a system that already exists and is constantly being rewritten by many different people.</p><p>Visually, there is already so much material inside the subject: layering, erasure, residue, repetition, obstruction, scale, damage, and disappearance.</p><p>I would not need to invent a visual language from nothing.</p><p>But that creates an ethical problem too.</p><p>If I am not careful, graffiti writers, activists, advertisers, anonymous sticker-makers, and official signage could all become the same “cool street texture” inside my design. The brief specifically made me think about context and attribution rather than aestheticizing everything I photograph.</p><p>There is also a very practical problem: <strong>New York gives me almost too much material.</strong></p><p>I could spend months photographing walls and still have no natural ending.</p><p>The AI brief therefore proposed a very strict field method: choose around <strong>three fixed sites</strong>, photograph them repeatedly using the same framing and classification system, and observe them for roughly <strong>six to eight weeks</strong>.</p><p>I think that constraint makes the project much more credible.</p><p>But even with that structure, I am less convinced that this should become my main thesis.</p><p>The natural outcomes still lean toward photography, archives, mapping, publications, and exhibitions. Those could make a strong research project, but they connect less directly to the commercial and brand-oriented body of work I want to build.</p><p>So right now I see this as a project I would genuinely enjoy investigating, but I am not sure I want to spend an entire thesis year inside it.</p><h3><strong>The Designer After Making</strong></h3><p>Briefing Document: <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/13q0rxS41rMPc08_4B8Q3JfWey4KEdCpn/view?usp=drive_link">https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ba6fjwNt8V1teZBUUln9mzRjKyOLEgFB/view?usp=drive_link</a></p><h4>What the AI Brief Surfaced</h4><p>Of all four directions, <strong>The Designer After Making</strong> produced the clearest academic structure.</p><p>My original position was already quite positive toward AI. I use it in my own design process, and I was interested in showing that AI does not necessarily replace designers — it can also expand what designers are able to make.</p><p>The AI test immediately identified a problem with that starting point:</p><p><strong>I had already decided what I wanted the research to prove.</strong></p><p>So the thesis question changed.</p><p>Instead of:</p><p><strong>“Can AI be a useful creative tool?”</strong></p><p>it became:</p><blockquote><strong><em>Where does design authorship reside when generative AI participates in visual production?</em></strong></blockquote><p>The first principle behind the reframing was that authorship may not simply belong to whoever manually produces the final form.</p><p>It may exist across a chain of consequential decisions:</p><p><strong>frame → prompt → generate → select → reject → edit → combine → contextualize → finalize</strong></p><p>That distinction made the project much more interesting to me.</p><p>Generating something is not necessarily the same thing as designing it.</p><p>At the same time, selecting something is not automatically authorship either.</p><p>So the research would need to ask which decisions actually change the direction of the work, which decisions can be delegated, and whether <strong>authorship, control, craft, ownership, and responsibility</strong> are even the same thing.</p><p>The research gap also became clearer. A lot of discussion around AI design focuses on speed, quality, productivity, attitudes toward AI, or the larger question of whether AI will replace designers.</p><p>This project could instead make authorship <strong>observable</strong>.</p><p>The same visual communication brief could be developed in three conditions:</p><p><strong>Human-led</strong><br> <strong>AI-led</strong><br> <strong>Human–AI collaborative</strong></p><p>Then I could compare not only the final outputs, but how each workflow actually arrived there.</p><p>Several precedents made this idea feel less abstract.</p><p>The <strong>PORTO ROCHA x Google DeepMind YOYOYO</strong> project is useful because its process includes prompting, iteration, selection, type refinement, physical prototyping, and a large human team behind the final result.</p><p><strong>Sougwen Chung</strong> offers a very different model of human-machine collaboration, where authorship happens through gesture, feedback, memory, and adaptation rather than simply prompting an image generator.</p><p>And <strong>Anna Ridler</strong> makes dataset construction, annotation, selection, and curation visible as creative labor — things that are often hidden when people only look at a final AI image.</p><p>These examples made me think that authorship could be scattered across a workflow rather than located at one obvious moment.</p><p>The strongest proposed outcome became an <strong>Authorship Trace</strong> or <strong>Decision Ledger</strong>.</p><p>For every experiment, I could record the meaningful decisions: prompts, rejected directions, manual edits, timestamps, references, revisions, selection sets, and moments when the project changed direction.</p><p>The workflow itself would become the visual material.</p><h3>My Response</h3><p>Methodologically, I think this might be the strongest of the four.</p><p>It has a clear research question, a repeatable experiment, and a way of turning something abstract — authorship — into visible evidence.</p><p>But that only works if the experiment is controlled.</p><p>If the human-led version gets three hours while the AI version gets twenty minutes, or if each workflow starts from a different brief or different references, then the comparison does not really tell me anything.</p><p>The AI brief therefore proposed using <strong>two or three fixed briefs, the same time budget, three workflow conditions, and one repeatable decision taxonomy</strong>.</p><p>That rigor is probably what makes the project academically interesting.</p><p>At the same time, it is also part of why I hesitate.</p><p>I already have a fairly strong opinion about AI. I believe it can be useful, and I use it regularly.</p><p>So the experiment has to be capable of producing a result I do <strong>not</strong> want.</p><p>If I enter the project assuming that human judgment will always turn out to be the most important thing, then I am not really researching anything.</p><p>I am illustrating an argument I already believe.</p><p>The other concern is time.</p><p>AI tools change incredibly quickly. If the thesis becomes too attached to a specific model or current capability, parts of it could feel outdated before I even finish the project.</p><p>The more durable question would therefore need to be about <strong>judgment, agency, responsibility, and decision-making</strong>, with AI functioning as the current condition through which those questions are being tested.</p><p>I still think this is a very strong Academic Pursuit.</p><p>But I am less sure that it gives me the kind of emotional, material, and world-building space that I personally want from a thesis I will be living with for a year.</p><h3>Play for Grown-Ups</h3><p>Briefing Document: <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1a9a9UuuvqpKQDOD7BwO7TOu0TwO722zS/view?usp=drive_link">https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ba6fjwNt8V1teZBUUln9mzRjKyOLEgFB/view?usp=drive_link</a></p><h4>What the AI brief surfaced</h4><p>This was probably the direction that changed most through the testing process.</p><p>I began with a fairly straightforward idea:</p><p><strong>a premium toy and lifestyle brand for adults.</strong></p><p>Toys, collectibles, fashion accessories, home objects, artist collaborations, limited editions — essentially a larger brand world built around play.</p><p>But once the machine stripped away the products, it arrived at a different question:</p><blockquote><strong><em>How can design give adults permission to play without asking them to perform childhood?</em></strong></blockquote><p>That word — <strong>permission</strong> — changed the project for me.</p><p>The thesis may not actually be about toys.</p><p>It may be about why certain behaviors, emotions, and objects become harder to claim as we grow older.</p><p>Why does curiosity become childish?</p><p>Why does uselessness make us uncomfortable?</p><p>Why can softness, silliness, or purposeless joy begin to feel embarrassing?</p><p>And why do adults sometimes need a culturally acceptable reason — collecting, design, nostalgia, luxury, fashion — to interact with things that are playful?</p><p>The research territory therefore expanded into play theory, adulthood and childhood as cultural categories, emotional objects, collecting, object design, lifestyle branding, and consumer culture.</p><p>Thinkers including <strong>Johan Huizinga, Brian Sutton-Smith, D. W. Winnicott, and Stuart Brown</strong> offer different ways of understanding play as something larger than children’s entertainment.</p><p>Meanwhile, designers such as <strong>Bruno Munari, Cas Holman, Isamu Noguchi, and Enzo Mari</strong> show how play can become a way of thinking, interacting, experimenting, and making.</p><p>The AI brief also suggested that the strongest project would not be just a brand launch.</p><p>It would combine three things:</p><p><strong>an object family + a brand world + a discursive layer</strong></p><p>The objects make the argument tangible.</p><p>The brand gives those objects a cultural and social context.</p><p>And the research asks what adulthood has taught us to feel about play in the first place.</p><h4>My Response</h4><p>This is still the direction I feel most drawn to.</p><p>Part of that is visual.</p><p>It gives me room to work across toys, collectibles, fashion accessories, home objects, packaging, photography, motion, campaigns, pop-ups, collaborations, and physical experiences.</p><p>But the reason I keep coming back to it is more personal than that.</p><p>Growing up, I often heard versions of:</p><p><strong>“You’re grown up now. You can’t be like that anymore.”</strong></p><p>Maturity often seemed to mean becoming more serious, controlled, practical, and useful.</p><p>And I became interested in the things that quietly get pushed aside in that process — curiosity, softness, silliness, imagination, play, or doing something simply because it feels good.</p><p>I do not want the project to argue that adults should become children again.</p><p>That is not what interests me.</p><p>I am more interested in asking whether those qualities can coexist with maturity.</p><p>Can responsibility and play exist together?</p><p>Can softness and strength exist together?</p><p>Can something be sophisticated without becoming emotionally cold?</p><p>I also want <strong>Play for Grown-Ups</strong> to become more than a toy brand.</p><p>My ambition is to build a lifestyle that people genuinely want to identify with.</p><p>I want the products to be things people are proud to collect, carry, wear, display, and bring into everyday life — not secretly because they are nostalgic for childhood, but because the brand represents a way of seeing adulthood.</p><p>In that sense, I am interested in how brands like fashion or streetwear labels can turn an object into a cultural signal.</p><p>The interesting question for me is whether <strong>playfulness itself could become something aspirational</strong>.</p><p>Could curiosity, softness, humor, and play become part of how someone expresses their identity?</p><p>But this ambition creates a contradiction that I think could make the thesis stronger:</p><blockquote><strong><em>If I make play premium, desirable, and culturally aspirational, am I freeing play — or simply turning it into another form of status and consumption?</em></strong></blockquote><p>I do not know the answer yet.</p><p>And I think that is a good sign.</p><p>The biggest risk with this direction is that I could very easily skip the difficult questions and start designing a cool brand.</p><p>The visual world comes naturally to me, which is exactly why I should not begin there.</p><p>Before building it, I need to investigate why adults feel they need permission to play, what makes one playful object feel childish while another feels sophisticated, and how those judgments change across different cultural environments — especially within Asian family and social contexts.</p><p>That could mean interviews, object audits, toy history, cultural research, and prototypes where I deliberately change things such as material, packaging, price, context, language, or display.</p><p>I want to see whether design can actually change how the same playful behavior is perceived.</p><p>If the brand grows out of that research, then it could become more than a collection of products.</p><p>It could become a world with an actual point of view.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1dbca776c743" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[✨Four Possible Ways to Look at My Thesis do✨]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jchen153/four-possible-ways-to-look-at-my-thesis-do-a4303ba86e14?source=rss-cbe0b3b76a19------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a4303ba86e14</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jialai Chen]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 13 Sep 2026 18:56:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2026-09-20T23:51:35.362Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Blogpost 1</h4><p><strong>Thesis Exploration 1「 A. Career Tactical 」</strong></p><h3>Elastic Identity</h3><blockquote>Designing Brand Systems That Shift Across Culture, Media, and Context.</blockquote><p><strong>One Principle, Many Expressions</strong> looks at how one brand can use very different visual styles and still feel like the same brand. I am interested in brands that can change across cultures, audiences, collaborations, and media without losing their core identity. MUJI is a good example: it can feel simple and quiet in one project, more emotional in another, or more local in a cultural collaboration, but it still feels like MUJI. I want this thesis to show that a good brand designer should not use the same style for every project, but should understand what kind of visual language fits each context.</p><p>I imagine creating one main brand or cultural platform and showing how it changes across different situations. The typography, image style, motion, materials, and tone can all shift, while a few core ideas stay the same. The goal is to show that I can work with different cultures and visual styles, and still keep the brand clear, connected, and recognizable.</p><p><strong>Thesis Exploration 2「 B. Exactly the Opposite 」</strong></p><h3><strong>Who Owns the Wall?</strong></h3><blockquote>A study of how graffiti, stickers, posters, and other unofficial marks reveal who gets to claim visibility and space in New York City.</blockquote><p>I want to study how people unofficially claim public space in New York through graffiti, stickers, posters, and other marks. These small actions may look random, but they raise a larger question: <strong>who is allowed to be visible in the city?</strong> Commercial ads can legally occupy huge public surfaces, while personal marks are often treated as vandalism. I want to use this contrast to think about ownership, permission, and power in public space.</p><p>For this project, I would document how these marks appear, overlap, disappear, and return over time. The goal is not just to collect street graphics, but to show how ordinary people leave their presence on a city that is heavily controlled by governments, businesses, and property owners. Instead of designing a controlled visual system, I want to study one that is constantly being changed by many people.</p><p><strong>Thesis Exploration 3「 C. Academic Pursuit 」</strong></p><h3>The Designer After Making</h3><blockquote>When making becomes shared with machines, where does design authorship actually reside?</blockquote><p>The Designer After Making looks at how generative AI is changing the way designers make, judge, and take authorship of their work. As AI becomes better at producing images, layouts, and visual styles, I want to ask: where does design actually happen when humans and machines are creating together? I am especially interested in the human decisions behind the process — setting direction, choosing, rejecting, editing, and deciding when something feels right. These choices may be just as important as physically making the final image.</p><p>Through a series of visual experiments, I want to compare human-led, AI-led, and human–AI collaborative workflows. I will look at both the final results and the decisions behind them to understand how human judgment shapes AI-generated work. Rather than seeing AI as something designers should reject, <strong>I want to show how it can become a creative tool that opens up new ways to experiment, develop ideas, and make things that might not be possible alone.</strong></p><p><strong>🩵 Thesis Exploration 4「 D. Personal Pursuit 」🩵</strong></p><h3>Play for Grown-Ups</h3><blockquote>A fictional premium toy brand that brings play, curiosity, and a sense of freedom back into adult life.</blockquote><p>Growing up, I often heard that becoming an adult meant being more serious, responsible, and mature. Over time, we are expected to leave behind things that feel childish — play, curiosity, softness, imagination, and doing something just because it is fun. I am interested in questioning that idea. I do not think growing up should mean losing these parts of ourselves.</p><p>I want to create a fictional premium toy brand mainly for adults. It could include toys, collectibles, fashion accessories, home objects, artist collaborations, and limited editions. The goal is to create things that adults want to play with, collect, wear, or keep around simply because they bring joy. I see this as a <strong>Personal Pursuit</strong> because one of my biggest goals as a designer is to make work that feels fun and alive. The project is not about refusing to grow up, but about showing that <strong>being mature does not mean giving up play.</strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a4303ba86e14" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>