<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by JD Flynn on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by JD Flynn on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jdflynn?source=rss-ea6fe1fc0615------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Wed, 18 Nov 2026 03:14:38 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jdflynn/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Smokey]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jdflynn/smokey-c7f8158ea80f?source=rss-ea6fe1fc0615------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c7f8158ea80f</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JD Flynn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 24 Aug 2020 19:41:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-22T20:09:02.722Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Smokey</strong></p><p>Grandma Flynn is 91. She lives in a building subsidized by the city government. It’s a building for seniors, but not a nursing home or anything like that. Just an ordinary apartment building with cheap rent for people over 65.</p><p>I remember when she moved in. It must have been 25 years ago. She’d lived before that in a succession of one-bedrooms in converted urban brownstones. Several of them caught fire, according to the family lore. The myth is true enough that my dad sometimes calls her “Smokey,” and she laughs and beams in the spotlight of her son’s teasing.</p><p>Her apartment is back in New Jersey, where all of our clan comes from. Where no one has stayed but her.</p><p>Most of us have accepted as normal the forces of economics and culture that see a 91-year-old woman living alone, hours and airplanes from her sons and their children.</p><p>We are conditioned to go where careers take us, to master the art of seeming to be from no place, attached only to a vague set of humanistic ideals, satisfied with family connections mediated by Instagram, and bound only by ambition. A few regional affectations — sports or food loyalties — are acceptable in the new humanity. More roots than that are liabilities.</p><p>Grandma Flynn doesn’t live like that. I asked her once why she didn’t leave, move out West, or to Cape Cod, where her sons and their children have settled.</p><p>“I know the bus routes,” she told me. “And the Mass schedule.”</p><p>She does not offer performative nostalgia about the place from which she comes.</p><p>Her connection to her place is just that. Not a cheap and exhibitionist stand-in for a personality. Comfortable familiarity with the predictable routine of buses and parishes.</p><p>Grandma Flynn does not have a formal education. She is the only person I know who spent a lifetime working in factories — a fact that says more about my limited horizon than it does about hers.</p><p>When I was a kid she worked in a plastics factory; she’d bring us glow-in-the-dark molded plastic swords that she’d played some part in producing. I imagined that she took great pride in forging such magnificent weapons, and, probably she did, just not in the way I saw it.</p><p>She is likely a saint. She won’t like me to say it, but it’s true. She grew up mostly in an orphanage run by nuns. When she didn’t have a vocation, she married. Her husband, my grandfather, turned out to be a lout, and a Lothario. But his caddishness was matched by her virtue. She was faithful to her vows until his death, and in a manner of speaking, is faithful to his memory even now.</p><p>Her religious habits are practical, and mostly out of fashion. She is at the parish every morning. She does not miss Mass. She is part of an unbroken line of church ladies that began with wizened old Anna waiting in the temple for the coming of Christ.</p><p>She prays the rosary in the flat, steady cadence of a woman for whom it has become second nature. She is often making some novena.</p><p>I join her for Mass when I have some reason to be back East. She’s a lector, and she asks me sometimes how to pronounce the difficult Old Testament names. Usually I make something up, and she takes it as gospel, or she pretends to. She probably double-checks with her priest.</p><p>Those habits are efficacious. She has occasionally said things that make me think she has deeply mystical experiences. She casually mentions habits of prayer that sound straight from “Interior Castle.”</p><p>I don’t think she has read “Interior Castle.” She reads mystery novels. She can usually predict the end after reading just a few pages. She also reads the newspaper, and is equally talented there at predicting how things will unfold. She watches police procedurals. She collects wooden ships.</p><p>After Mass, she goes to breakfast at the diner with her friends. When I go with her, they’re all up-to-date on what’s happening with my family. I don’t remember their names, but they never seem to notice.</p><p>One of them slipped me $10 last time I was at the diner.</p><p>“We’re all proud of you,” she told me, patting my hand and pushing a bill into it.</p><p>“Oh, I’m nothing to be proud of. I might be a secret criminal, you know.” My grandma’s friend laughed and kissed my cheek.</p><p>It’s been a few years since I’ve been to the parish, or to New Jersey at all. Trips to New York don’t usually leave time for a visit to Grandma.</p><p>But she came to visit us in Colorado last Christmas. Our whole family was together: my parents, my sisters and their families, Kate and me and our kids.</p><p>One night, the adults played the sort of modern party game that inevitably, and by design, turns vulgar. I watched Grandma Flynn as people took their turns. If she was uncomfortable, she didn’t let on. I tried to keep my answers G-rated, in a gesture of piety toward Grandma, I guess.</p><p>I made eyes at my sisters to suggest they do the same, but they didn’t see me, or they didn’t take me seriously.</p><p>I decided with self-satisfaction I must be the superior grandchild.</p><p>I’m really not. I call Grandma Flynn every month or so. She answers always on the fourth ring, and no matter the time, I always worry I’ve woken her. But she has the grace of making small talk that is common to her generation; she guides the conversation from the weather to family updates to brief observations from her daily walks. At the end of the call, she thanks me for thinking of her, and I feel sheepish.</p><p>I told her once that I feel bad for not calling more often.</p><p>“Well, Honeybunch,” she said. “Call more if you want, I guess. Unless I’m not home.”</p><p>She was impervious to my attempt at ritualized self-doubt, an essential component of any modern relationship. She was grateful for the call, and she said so. Just like that.</p><p>“Ok, Thanks for calling. Love you.” The line clicked.</p><p>She probably had somewhere to be.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c7f8158ea80f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Rooting for Sean]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jdflynn/rooting-for-sean-e25fbbc9109c?source=rss-ea6fe1fc0615------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e25fbbc9109c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JD Flynn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 07 Aug 2020 00:25:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-07T15:05:11.939Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Sean Gilmartin is a good sport.</p><p>When Sean was called up from the minor leagues in 2018, he took an Uber to Camden Yards, just a few hours before he was scheduled to pitch against the Boston Red Sox.</p><p>A car was supposed to pick Sean up at his hotel, but never showed. The driver had gone to the wrong place, it turned out. So Sean took an Uber, probably hoping the team would reimburse him after the game.<br> <br>The Uber driver deposited Sean on the curb outside the ballpark and sped away. Sean’s cleats and glove were in the trunk. It took a while to get things sorted out. <br> <br>Sean eventually got his gear, and pitched a little more than 2 innings that night.</p><p>On 40 pitches, he allowed five hits and and one run, and he walked two batters. Sean wasn’t the worst pitcher in that game, and he wasn’t the best. But the Orioles lost, and Sean only stuck around the rest of the season before he got sent back to Norfolk.</p><p>Sean, then 28, with a big league chance fading away, didn’t mind too much. He had a perfect record at the World Series, and that counted for something.<br> <br>The Mets put Sean on the championship roster back in 2015. While the team was nearly swept, Sean had a pretty good run. He faced two batters, in the eighth inning of Game 2, and neither of them made it to first base.</p><p>Sean Gilmartin’s father is a chiropractor, by the way. A chiropractor dresses like a doctor, talks a bit like a doctor, and has an office like a doctor, but a chiropractor is not a doctor. And deep inside, each chiropractor knows that.</p><p>Sean is a ballplayer. He walks, talks, and acts just like a ballplayer should. And he loves playing baseball.</p><p>This season, at 30, Sean has a triple-A contract with the Tampa Bay Rays, and some hope to catch on again in the bigs as a middle reliever.</p><p>Sean’s cousin is Chad Gilmartin, the Principal Assistant Press Secretary for the leader of the free world, at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.</p><p>In college Chad had a few White House internships, and snagged a job on the Trump campaign after graduation. In April, 11 months after he finished his B.A., Chad got his job in the White House press office. It’s a pretty big job.</p><p>Chad’s also a Special Assistant to the President. Three years ago, he was a summer camp counselor.</p><p>Chad’s boss is Donald Trump’s press secretary. She is also Sean Gilmartin’s wife.</p><p>You know her as Kayleigh McEnany, but McEnany is her maiden name. Officially, she’s Kayleigh Gilmartin. And she’s Sean’s biggest fan.</p><p>They started dating in 2015, back when Sean had his magical run with the Mets and Kayleigh was going to Harvard Law, moonlighting as a pundit on CNN.</p><p>She streams his games on her phone. This year there aren’t any minor league games, so Sean’s at home with their baby, Blake. (Blake is a girl in this case. Think Blake Lively, not Blake Shelton.)</p><p>They’re young, and good looking, and articulate, and the world is Sean and Kayleigh’s oyster.<br> <br> In fact, the Gilmartins are my favorite subplot in the reality show that surrounds the White House, Trump World, and “The Swamp.”<br> <br> And you should be rooting for Sean.</p><p>His wife and his cousin will spend this fall trying to help the president sound and look like a president. They’ll draft talking points that say the pandemic is under control, the protests in Portland are no problem, and the concern about alleged Russian bounties on U.S. soldiers is overblown. It’s a big election for them.</p><p>Sean is not a part of that campaign. He’s a ballplayer. He’s hoping to keep his fastball under control, and maybe make a big league club next year.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e25fbbc9109c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Prayers in Mukuru]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jdflynn/prayers-in-mukuru-967ae46c8380?source=rss-ea6fe1fc0615------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/967ae46c8380</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JD Flynn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 08 Apr 2020 23:43:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-10T00:13:55.800Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/811/1*m-qZ3he7ds-turG1b4ApEg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A man walks on a commercial street in Mukuru, Nairobi, Kenya.</figcaption></figure><p>If you’re in the Mukuru slum of Nairobi, Kenya, you cannot avoid the shit.</p><p>Rivulets and rivers of waste run through the dirt tracks that are Mukuru’s streets. They turn some spots into small, fetid lakes.</p><p>Black water sits stagnant in drainage ditches, and in the river that borders the slum. Not muddy, but black and stinking of shit. Sun bleached garbage floats in the muck and lines every street.</p><p>The smell is overpowering.</p><p>Residents are accustomed to all that; they are expert at finding the path of least putrescence as they navigate the streets. But you’ll have to accept that if you are in Mukuru, shit will be a part of the experience: you’ll smell it, you’ll slip in it, your shoes and pants will be stained with it.</p><p>On a Sunday in July, with my boss Alejandro, I go to Mass in Mukuru. We’re with our friend and colleague Fr. Don Bosco. We’ve spent a week putting on a workshop for African journalists. Our work completed, we’ve gone for church at Mukuru’s St. Monica’s Chapel, where Don Bosco ministers each Sunday.</p><p>The Mass is beautiful. It is typical of Kenyan liturgies: a swaying choir, people dancing, kids everywhere. At the offertory, people bring forward gifts of groceries to be distributed to those most in need: a jug of oil, a bag of flour, a sack of vegetables.</p><p>At the end of Mass, there is a fundraising raffle. The prize is a bunch of bananas weighing probably 100 pounds. I spend $40 on the banana raffle, but I don’t win.</p><p>After Mass, Fr. Don Bosco says he has another Mass to offer. We went to the 8:30, and he will now celebrate the 11. Masses are so long the two practically overlap.</p><p>Fr. Don Bosco suggests that while he celebrates the second Mass, we tag along with some young members of the parish who visit elderly or sick parishioners. “This will give you a chance to see how these people are living,” he says.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_3xKVqW_g0lNsjWseiurwg.jpeg" /></figure><p>—</p><p>It is not my first time in a slum, or even in Mukuru. But it will be my first time visiting Mukuru’s people in their homes. I’m nervous at the prospect.</p><p>At least 500,000 people live in Mukuru, an area smaller than Central Park. By 2030, the population is expected to double. Most live with less than $1.25/day.</p><p>Altogether, more than 60% of Nairobi’s people live in slums: in shacks cobbled together from corrugated iron, scrap wood, and packing crates. Those with electricity steal it from the factories where they work, stringing a rat’s nest of wires just a few feet above their roofs.</p><p>In Mukuru, there are only a handful of water taps, at which people pay to fill five-gallon jugs each morning. Their shacks have no running water.</p><p>There are rank toilet stations in the slum. One must pay a few shillings to use them. A boy mans the latrine wearing knee-high rubber boots. After each person uses the toilet, he tosses a bucket of water over the floor. The toilets should drain into a pit, but shit leaks from them onto the slum’s dirt streets.</p><p>Still, I’m told that in Mukuru, these toilets are a luxury. People who can’t afford them, or can’t walk to them, cut out the middleman, avoid paying the latrine fee, and dump their waste directly into the streets, or the narrow, rank sewage canals that line bigger roads, or into the river.</p><p>On Sunday, walking with young people from the parish, who live here and raise their families here, I set my face and pretend not to be nauseated by the smell of their home.</p><p>They pretend not to notice that I’m walking with mouth agape, failing to hide my shock at Mukuru’s poverty.</p><p>—</p><p>In our group is Elizabeth. She’s maybe 30, and a tailor. Elizabeth mends clothes at a well-maintained old machine — to me it looks like a museum piece. She also designs and sews her own clothes, which are smart and well-fitting.</p><p>Elizabeth is a church lady.</p><p>She spends whatever free time she has around the parish. She is pious and kind. She is also fearless. Elizabeth raises three children on her own in a slum where thievery and sexual violence are common. Her children are polite and curious. They pray, as does their mother, with a practical expectation that God will protect them.</p><p>Kathy, also walking with us, wears a striking red dress that hugs her figure. Her hair is pulled back and she carries a brown leather clutch. She is smart and ambitious. Kathy grew up in Mukuru slum, but she’s going places. She’s sure of it.</p><p>She works as a vendor in a tourist market well outside the slum, selling trinkets to people like me. She earns almost none of the sale price. Still, she carries herself like a professional.</p><p>Kathy is the only person I meet who asks for money. I don’t blame her. Her priest has asked her, unexpectedly, to show a few Americans around her slum. Kathy is an entrepreneur, and this is an opportunity too good to pass up.</p><p>As we walk, Kathy explains to me that she wants to enroll in a three-year program in “the medical field.” She’s been accepted, she says, and can enroll anytime. The only problem is that the program costs $4,000. She asks if I can help.</p><p>I try to explain to Kathy that by American standards, I am not wealthy.</p><p>“I am not a rich man,” I start to say.</p><p>But while I’m talking, on Kathy’s own street, I need to step over some rotting lettuce, a discarded and ragged pair of underwear, and the sun-dried body of a dead mouse.</p><p>My protests of poverty have no place here. I can’t even get the words out.</p><p>I tell Kathy that I’ll do what I can, and keep her in prayer. She asks if she can follow-up by email, and send me details about the program. I nod weakly.</p><p>I talk mostly with James. James is just a few years younger than me, and, like me, he is the father of young children. I feel a kind of kinship with him because he is a parish catechist, and, like me, familiar with work in the Church. James and I joke about working in Church ministry, laughing about the particular foibles of bosses who are clerics. We, I imagine naively, would be friends in any context.</p><p>James tells me about raising his own family in the slum, a few meters from the shack where he grew up.</p><p>He tells me about close friends with HIV, and the psychological resilience required to “exempt them,” in his mind, from a certain future of painful death.</p><p>Only because I ask, James tells me about the monthly hustle to pay his family’s rent — a sum of $25, often just out of reach for him. The Church work doesn’t make ends meet. James is vague about what he does to make up the difference, and I don’t push.</p><p>I have no cash in my wallet; I gave my last bills to the parish. I wish I could have them back, and give them to my friend. I could pay James’ rent for a year, and never feel the expense. But I don’t have any cash and I doubt he has Venmo. When he talks, I can only listen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*O6bI9EDp83dK-ABW8y4Buw.jpeg" /></figure><p>—</p><p>We turn off the main avenue into a dark alley between corrugated iron sheets. The smell is stronger here. Long shacks are built with big pieces of iron, and then divided into small dwellings. They’re apartments, I guess, or row houses.</p><p>We stop at a door — a few long boards nailed together and mounted on a pair of hinges — and we enter Lucy’s home.</p><p>Lucy is blind, and homebound. I can’t tell how old she is: she seems ancient, but I suspect she’s only in her 60s; life in Mukuru rarely lasts longer than that. She is wearing the same kind of housecoat my grandma wears sometimes, and sitting on the edge of a wooden bed. Lucy’s home is about half the size of a dorm room. The floor is a sheet of blue and white vinyl on top of the red dirt. The walls are corrugated iron, as is the roof. On the walls are four pictures of Jesus and Mary. There is a calendar.</p><p>It’s hot in Lucy’s home, and dark. There is no breeze. There are no windows. The only light comes from the doorway.</p><p>There are two wooden beds in Lucy’s home, a single bed and a twin, but I have the impression four or five people live there. Between the beds is room only for a flimsy white plastic chair and space for one or two people to stand. At the foot of one bed is a wooden shelf, on which sits a bag of cornmeal, a Tupperware of sugar, a water jug, and a small wooden statue of St. Joseph.</p><p>Speaking in Lucy’s village language, a woman walking with our group tells her that we are visiting from the parish, and that two Americans are there. Lucy begins to cry. I don’t really understand it. She tells the woman, who translates for us, that she’s honored to have us in her home. That she is so happy we’re there.</p><p>She asks me and Alejandro to pray for her — to “pass her a blessing,” our companions say. As in most places that day, the prayer falls to me. I’m short of words. Nothing I can think to say seems to fit the moment.</p><p>I feel the least fit there among our group, standing in an iron shack in a Nairobi slum, to ask anything of God. I think they’ll see through me, and so will God.</p><p>Still, I string together a few sentences asking God to bless Lucy, and to bless all of us, and to give us each hope for a future with him. I ask Mary and the saints to pray for Lucy. I end with a Hail Mary. Lucy is practically weeping as the prayer is translated. I still don’t understand why I should mean anything to her.</p><p>Lucy says the Our Father in her local language, and thanks us, over and over, for coming. She takes my hand when I offer it, and squeezes it, and thanks me in Swahili.</p><p>“<em>Asante sana,</em>” I say to her, “thank you very much.” She cries again.</p><p>We visit more houses. We’re well off the main street now, and walking through dark and narrow dirt alleys between the shacks. Our companions know just where to turn. I have no idea where we are. I am focused only on keeping my feet dry.</p><p>Sometimes, we make a sharp turn and find ourselves in a small courtyard, where a few chickens scratch the dirt, or a man shells beans with his daughters. Sometimes the smell intensifies, or changes suddenly to the pungent aroma of piss and kerosene. Along some alleys, we see men burning piles of garbage, and the rank smell of burning plastic fills our noses. I try never to cough.</p><p>We visit Ann, who is old, obese, and has only two teeth that I can see. We pray with her, and she cackles and asks us to come back again.</p><p>We visit Mary Gathoni, whose shack is especially hot and dark. A television blares a Kenyan morning show while we pray. Mary Gathoni repeats her name over and over, so that we remember it. She tells us, through our translator, how proud she is that we are there.</p><p>Kathy asks me what I think of the homes in their slum. From Kathy, the question feels almost like a test.</p><p>“I think,” I start, careful with each word, “that I am very grateful you’ve brought me here to show me your homes.”</p><p>My new friends laugh. They tease me about my diplomatic answer. They ask if that’s how we answer questions in America. What did they want me to say, I wonder. That I’m gagging from the smell and shaken by the poverty?</p><p>Why didn’t I say that? I really don’t know.</p><p>__</p><p>We visit Esther, a young woman with a gaunt face and a stocking cap on her head. Our friends say she is “not feeling well.”</p><p>I find I have almost nothing to say at her home. I can tell she has AIDS and I suspect she’ll die soon. If anything in my life has prepared me for this visit, I’ve failed to heed the preparation.</p><p>When it’s time to pray, I begin with the sign of the cross, but then I’m at a loss for words.</p><p>I’m silent for a minute or two, looking for something to say, when Alejandro saves me. He prays about the cross, about unity, and about the Church. I shake Esther’s hand, and this time I’m the one crying.</p><p>—</p><p>After Esther, we visit the home of Winifred.</p><p>Winifred is friends with Elizabeth. They high-five when we enter. They seem about the same age, and both are pretty. Winifred’s home is the cleanest and brightest of any we visit.</p><p>Winifred lives alone with her son Cyril. Cyril has cerebral palsy. He sits on the couch, his fists moving above his head and his eyes tracking the fists. Cyril is 14, but he’s the size of most six-year-olds. His hair and clothes are neat. He’s wearing little socks on his feet.</p><p>Winifred tells us about Cyril’s diagnosis. He first showed signs of cerebral palsy, which occurs with disproportionate frequency in the third world, when he was five years old. She tells us that she’s by herself, it’s just the two of them, and that she needs to do everything for him.</p><p>I tell Winifred about Max and Pia, my children with Down syndrome. I tell her I know how hard she works, and I that admire her.</p><p>I tell her that I know how important routine is in her home, and that I know we’ve disturbed the routine.</p><p>“Yes,” she says. We have disrupted her routine. She’s not reluctant to acknowledge that.</p><p>I don’t know why I tell Winifred about my kids, or what I expect. I’m trying to prove something to her, or to myself, I think. I feel wholly foolish in her home. She is smart, competent, hard-working, and in no need of our consolation or kind words. What Winifred needs, I am sure, is practical, every-day, consistent help. We aren’t there for that.</p><p>We stand in the center of her home, both wondering what exactly we’re supposed to be doing there.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Dt5xc564mzPATOhwXBd6Yg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Outside a Mukuru home for disabled children.</figcaption></figure><p>A few days earlier, I’d visited a Mukuru home for slum children with cerebral palsy and other disabilities, children whose parents couldn’t, or didn’t, take care of them. Some children had autism. One was hydrocephalic; his head was stretched like a watermelon. It is an experience I haven’t yet processed when we’re in Winifred’s home — It was different to meet 14 disabled children and four caretakers living in two concrete rooms, decorated with murals of Mickey Mouse. There I played with children and talked with caretakers, and I felt like I belonged.</p><p>But at Winifred’s home, I feel like my presence is an intrusion. In fact, it is. Winifred should not have to spend time soothing my conscience about that, and she doesn’t bother trying.</p><p>By my silence, it becomes obvious I have no prayer to offer at her home. Alejandro says a few words to God, and then we step back into the sunny courtyard outside her door.</p><p>We stop at James’ home, two rooms where he lives with his wife and children. By Mukuru’s standards, it is a very good place. We stop at Elizabeth’s tailor shop, one small room that is also her home, on Mukuru’s commercial street. It’s the size of our walk-in closet at home, and packed with bundles of clothing. She shares a bed with her children.</p><p>After our visits, we make our way back to the parish.</p><p>__</p><p>I don’t take any pictures walking through the slum that day. It wouldn’t be appropriate, I’m sure. And as I walk, I debate whether I will write anything at all about what I see there. I know I have nothing to offer about my time in Mukuru. I don’t have any lessons, and I can’t speak intelligently to the social and political causes of the Mukuru slum. If being there will change my life, I don’t know how.</p><p>But I’m stuck on something James says to me as we walk through Mukuru’s back alleys.</p><p>I ask James how he manages to stay hopeful in Mukuru. I ask him why he doesn’t hate God, and hate me, and hate the injustice of poverty.</p><p>“This is a very difficult place to live,” James says. “Here, we have to love each other to survive.”</p><p>“So for me,” he says, “this slum is a place of love.”</p><p><em>JD Flynn writes from Denver, Colorado.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=967ae46c8380" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Daniel Vanier, and what comes next]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jdflynn/daniel-vanier-and-what-comes-next-fb9a3250a234?source=rss-ea6fe1fc0615------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fb9a3250a234</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[catholicism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[jean-vanier]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[JD Flynn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 08 Mar 2020 02:34:44 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-03-08T03:56:12.883Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/902/1*ivzX0XUqosfDjisCKpjZEA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Jean Vanier. Credit: <a href="https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Kotukaran&amp;action=edit&amp;redlink=1">Kotukaran</a>/wkimedia. cc by sa 3.0</figcaption></figure><p>My youngest son is Daniel Vanier Flynn. We call him Davey.</p><p>The “Daniel” is for my father.</p><p>The “Vanier” is for Jean Vanier, the man who founded L’Arche, who was a friend to the disabled, and who used his reputation for holiness and wisdom to sexually coerce and manipulate at least six women over four decades.</p><p>My wife, Kate, thinks we should change our son’s name. He’s only two, Kate points out, and he won’t remember what his middle name once was. He hardly remembers it now.</p><p>Kate is practical and efficient. The night the news broke, she was ready to excise Vanier from our home.</p><p>She was grieving, but she was also scanning lists of “V” saints, trying to decide who might be a suitable replacement.</p><p>Of course I also thought of Davey, asleep in his crib, carrying the name of Jean Vanier. But I wasn’t ready to change his name. And I didn’t know why.</p><p>I read more news, as much as I could find, while Kate made lists on her phone, next to me in bed.</p><p>I wanted to find something that would help me understand. This man seemed to know God intimately. How could he spend decades spiritually and sexually abusing women who trusted him? How could it be true?</p><p>Those most wounded by Vanier are, of course, his actual victims, the women whose trust he exploited to sate his lust, or yen for power, or whatever perverted inclination he was trying to satisfy. They’ll struggle mightily with shame and guilt. It will be hard for them to trust that God is real, or loving, and that they’re actually worth loving. The psychological effect of sexual abuse is profound, and when coupled with spiritual abuse, the damage is amplified.</p><p>Next hurt are those with whom he lived and those whom he cared for — those who trusted him personally.</p><p>On the periphery of the pain are people like my family, who learned something from Jean Vanier, and who thought he was holy. But our pain is real. Because Jean Vanier meant something to Kate and me.</p><p>—</p><p>Almost nine years ago, we adopted a baby boy with Down syndrome. Less than a year later, we adopted a newborn baby girl, who also has Down syndrome. We knew nothing about disabilities when Max and Pia came home with us. We read a lot, but it was Vanier who stuck closest to our hearts.</p><p>Vanier, who founded with disabled people a community of love, offered us a way to make some sense of our own children’s disabilities.</p><p>I often feel that I have some responsibility to put the right face on disabilities. Have an anecdote about how cute my children are. Justify their existence. Explain away the intrusion they represent — spiritualize it, or at least offer a life lesson. Make the accommodation of my children seem worthwhile.</p><p>Vanier felt to us like someone who didn’t need that. Someone we wouldn’t have to explain ourselves to, or pretend for. Someone who would want to be with us, as things really are, even in the tedious, loud, uncomfortable, demanding normality of our family life. Someone who didn’t see people for their utility.</p><p>Vanier taught that all of us are wounded, and broken. That all of us are disabled, in one way or another. And that our brokenness — our sinfulness, even — can be a locus of friendship, and intimacy, and communion, especially if we invite other people close enough to help us carry crosses.</p><p>Disabled people show us, Vanier taught, that projecting illusions like strength and self-sufficiency stands in the way of admitting our own brokenness, and stands in the way of ever really loving one another. That divine intimacy, even, comes from bringing our wounds and weaknesses to God.</p><p>Vanier didn’t have to be perfect to teach those lessons. But he did have to be honest. And he wasn’t.</p><p>—</p><p>It is possible he struggled, I think to myself. That he didn’t want to do what he did. That he was trying, for decades, to get away from it. That he was ashamed, and he didn’t know how to stop.</p><p>But he grievously misrepresented himself.</p><p>He wrote and spoke of relatively benign flaws with the appearance of great humility, while concealing his criminal abuse. He pretended not to know about the abusive practices of his spiritual mentor — even while they mirrored his own. He left women scarred and hopeless, he blasphemed God himself, and he never owned up to any of it.</p><p>People thought he was a kind of spiritual master, and even while he rebuffed them, he knew they kept thinking it. And, in one way or another, with books and lectures and documentaries and appearances, he let them.</p><p>All of that has led me to something like a crisis of faith. At its worst, it becomes nearly a kind of epistemic despair.</p><p>Of course, that feels like a cliche. It is a cliche. But it is no less true for its banality. I thought this man was holy, and he wasn’t. And now I am surprised to find myself wondering if holiness is real.</p><p>If he wasn’t holy, I thought to myself those first few days, was anyone? If he spent a lifetime meeting the peculiar demands of loving people with disabilities, and wasn’t transformed in holiness, can I be? Is no one really freed from sin?</p><p>McCarrick made me angry, but he never made me question the Christian proposition. I never expected that he was holy. That someone I already thought lukewarm turned out to be wicked was no real surprise. Other bishops too, who have proven to be wicked, have evoked in me no emotional response. I’ve known too many bishops, as men of flesh and blood, vice and virtue, to expect them to be any particular thing.</p><p>But I saw Vanier in a different way. I saw him as a kind of icon, through which Christ, I thought, was magnified. I thought he was a sign of the presence of God. But of course he wasn’t.</p><p>It is foolish to expect so much of people. I’ve warned friends against it. It is one thing to see Christ in another person, I’ve said, but it is naive to trust uncritically anyone but God. I know well the danger of succumbing to the cults of personality that surround spiritual figures. But I thought Vanier was worth trusting. A lot of people did.</p><p>I hope he will go to heaven, and I‘ll pray for his soul. But I thought he was a saint. It seems quite clear that I was wrong.</p><p>—</p><p>It was Vanier’s spiritual writing that most influenced me. I thought it came from real spiritual experience. Now I doubt that’s true. A man who abuses religion is probably not gifted with a deep life of prayer.</p><p>I suspect if I went back and read through his scriptural commentary, I’d find it tinged with narcissism, egoism, and equivocation I didn’t see before. Maybe it was there, and I didn’t want to see it.</p><p>I don’t think that everything he wrote is a lie. I think he wrote about human experiences with some wisdom and insight, and about spiritual experiences with some formation in the wisdom of real mystics and true saints. I think there is truth in his work, but it isn’t his truth. And I wonder whether he wrote out of love for his readers, or to manipulate his victims.</p><p>Whether his work must be condemned unequivocally is a philosophical question to which I do not have the answer. But it doesn’t much matter to me. I learned some things from him that will stay with me, I think, but I need to separate those truths from the person who delivered them.</p><p>Anyway, I don’t want to read him again. I don’t have the stomach for it. And I don’t want to take the risk that I’ll still love his work, or be again deceived by what he has to say.</p><p>I know this is why God gives us the Church. I know that the Church, in her wisdom, and through the test of time, carefully discerns men and women of heroic virtue — saints worth imitating and venerating. But the Vatican’s saint-making department is an office full of sinners, some of them facing criminal investigations. Believing that God works through those guys to help people know who was really holy takes faith. I know it’s true, but in the days after the Vanier news, I found myself plagued by doubt.</p><p>The apologetic answer I have at the ready is not yet a consolation. I laugh, because I’ve offered it before to suffering friends, and no one has told me how hollow it sounds.</p><p>—</p><p>While I muddle through the predictable stages of my prosaic and suburban existential crisis, Kate keeps coming back to the name. I keep insisting we should wait.</p><p>I don’t know what I’m waiting for. There will be no <em>deus ex machina</em> for Jean Vanier. Nothing will reverse this story. I know about men who abuse the language and the intimate vulnerability of faith — I have interviewed the victims of men like that. In Vanier’s case, six women had the same story. He’s not going to be exonerated.</p><p>I know that everyone is a sinner, that most people are an admixture of good and bad. I have accepted that Daniel, for whom my son is also named, is not a saint. All of us must make peace with the sins of our fathers.</p><p>But Vanier was apparently a systemic sexual abuser who was held up as a servant of God. This is not about taking the bad with the good. This is about depravity and deception. I am reading Jonathan Edwards, and wondering if he went far enough.</p><p>All the same, I want to wait. Mostly, I realize, because I don’t have wisdom about some better name for my son.</p><p>I have been a Christian for a while now. I’ve not faced a crisis quite like this, but I’ve earned some scars over the years. I know this wound will also scar over.</p><p>Eventually we’ll give all this to the Lord. We’ll take the good, and surrender the rest, and our faith will likely emerge unshaken. We’re lucky — it won’t take us a lifetime to work through any of this, as it will for the women he harmed, and the people he was close to. We’ll feel shame, and anger, and disappointment for a season, and then we’ll move on.</p><p>I’ll work out the cliched doubts of my existential crisis.</p><p>My hope will be restored, I’m sure. My faith will be burnished. The Lord has not yet disappointed me. I’ll continue to follow him, and he’ll continue leading me closer to him. I’ll keep trusting in that.</p><p>And soon enough I’ll give my son a new name. He shouldn’t have to carry this one. But it’s going to take me a little while.</p><p>A name is a direction, I realize — a kind of commissioning. I wanted to put my son on a path I thought was illuminated by love, by generosity, by humility, by joy. I wanted to put him on the path I thought that Jean Vanier had walked. I wanted my son to be like that man — but now I don’t.</p><p>A new name bespeaks a kind of resurrection — new life. But I haven’t yet found a way forward from Calvary.</p><p>It’s Lent, and I am still waiting for the Resurrection.</p><p><em>JD Flynn is a writer and editor.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fb9a3250a234" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>