<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jeff Alworth on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jeff Alworth on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jeffalworth?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 18:11:30 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jeffalworth/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Heckuva Party]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/heckuva-party-d71ee0892b39?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d71ee0892b39</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[governance]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gop]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[republican-party]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 13 Aug 2021 15:53:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-13T18:05:17.317Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*pWoKoRPT4TV_bo6SLJtOMQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>We end this week with the specter of governors from the two largest red states waging war with schoolteachers who are trying to prevent students from being sickened during a global pandemic. Each day, 125,000 people are being infected with Covid-19, and in state after state, the GOP has moved to prevent officials from responding.</p><p>For anyone who has endured politics in the 21st century, though, it <em>sort of</em> makes sense. The Republican Party, once a sanctimonious force of white men who lectured about patriotism and the sanctity of life, have become an anti-science death cult devoted to upending democratic elections. And they’re <em>still</em> sanctimonious.</p><p>As cartoonishly evil as the Republican Party is now, it’s not a recent thing. In fact, Republicans kicked off the century by bending norms and the law to install a president who received a minority of the votes. That was considered anomalous at the time, not a fallen norm that would lead to efforts to undermine elections themselves. Within a few years, the US was lying itself into wars and arguing for torture. Over my morning coffee, I sat down to think of just the actions the GOP has taken — not the bad faith rhetoric it routinely offers voters and the press, but the things they were willing to fight for and implement. It is … quite a picture:</p><ul><li><strong>2000</strong>: Seized the White House in a dubious claim to the election.</li><li><strong>2001</strong>: Cut taxes on the rich.</li><li><strong>2001</strong>: Ignored warnings of a terrorist attack.</li><li><strong>2001–2008</strong>: Methodically filled the federal and supreme courts with activist conservative judges.</li><li><strong>2002</strong>: Passed bipartisan No Child Left Behind act.</li><li><strong>2002–2003</strong>: Started ill-conceived wars, the second sold to the public with lies.</li><li><strong>2003</strong>: Cut taxes on the rich!</li><li><strong>2004</strong>: Defended secret torture of war prisoners.</li><li><strong>2008</strong>: Crashed the US economy.</li><li><strong>2009–2017</strong>: Tried to prevent Democrats from providing health care to uninsured Americans.</li><li><strong>2016</strong>: Backed a racist demagogue who bragged about his sexual assault.</li><li><strong>2017–2020</strong>: Continued stuffing the courts with active conservatives, many undistinguished, including unprecedented shenanigans to score two new Supreme Court justices.</li><li><strong>2017</strong>: Tax cuts on the rich!</li><li><strong>2018</strong>: Amid anti-immigrant hysteria, separated children from parents at the US-Mexico border and housed them in pens.</li><li><strong>2020</strong>: Grossly mishandled an international pandemic.</li><li><strong>2021</strong>: Sparked (and later excused/defended) a coup to overturn a legal election.</li><li><strong>2021</strong>: Embarked on a series of measures to prevent Democrats (i.e. candidates backed by majorities of voters) from winning elections.</li><li><strong>2021</strong>: Opposed all efforts to address global pandemic, including discouraging vaccinations and preventing schools and businesses from requiring masks.</li></ul><p>During the Bush years, the Republican Party actually tried to do real stuff. Mostly malignant, harmful stuff, but real stuff. Since 2016, their entire raison d’être is to thwart democratic elections, pack courts, attack immigrants, and cut taxes on the rich. There’s nothing else left to the Party beyond trolling people committed to democracy and actual governance.</p><p>Anyway, happy Friday.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d71ee0892b39" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[History Suggests Big Change is Coming]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/history-suggests-big-change-is-coming-f7ae6225b853?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f7ae6225b853</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[republicans]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[political-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[us-politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democrats]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 19 Mar 2021 15:18:51 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-19T15:27:25.632Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>When anyone analyzes American politics in 2021, a pervasive assumption nearly always colors their thinking: that gridlock and polarization have cemented the parties into a stalemate from which neither can escape. This is a structural problem with no easy solutions. But what if that isn’t true?</p><p>There’s another way to look at this moment— one that suggests Donald Trump presided over an ideological era that has run its course. If this seems farfetched based politics as they happen moment by moment, and especially following the near-existential events surrounding the election of 2020, it seems less so if we look at the past 90 years of American history. That span was marked by two epochs, one liberal and one conservative. In perfect symmetry, the liberal era dawned in 1932 marked by new ideas and large scale change that eventually lost steam, only to be replaced by a conservative era that followed the same pattern, starting in 1980. The contours of each mirror the other, and suggest at least the possibility that we have entered a new era.</p><p>Both rose from the ashes of exhausted and defeated eras in which policy prescriptions had run out or become ineffective. They were replaced by ideas that had been popular among the opposition party for decades but considered fringe, but which, in a short time, became new orthodoxies that endured throughout the period. They followed predictable patterns marked by initial ideological vigor and optimism that culminated mid-era in large policy wins, followed by a slow decline. And, even when the opposition party won the presidency, the available policies did not deviate far from the era’s philosophical center (a view characterized by the metaphor of the “Overton window,” discussed below).</p><p>The details of course differ. The fear of communism and the Soviet Union that marked the liberal era had no analogue in the conservative. The focus on socio-religious issues that marked the conservative era had no analogue in the liberal. Yet the larger patterns were remarkably similar. In the table below, the liberal era is shaded blue, the conservative red; the ruling and opposition trends chart the ways the parties behaved if they were in or out of power.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*W_rvtVNeBBZrNVlisZeD3A.png" /></figure><h3><strong>Contours of the Eras</strong></h3><p>Following the free market excesses of the Roaring 20s, FDR inherited a country ready for large-scale government intervention. Throughout his and Truman’s administrations, the New Deal remade American society, and the values of equality prevailed over individual liberty. This continued into the 1960s, when JFK and LBJ not only made gains in civil rights, but solidified government-sponsored safety net programs begun under FDR. Once the left had achieved these sweeping changes, they began pushing for programs that were unpopular, and Nixon, which governing within the liberal orthodoxy, began to plant seeds for the future conservative era. Carter’s administration actually began rolling them back.</p><p>Meanwhile, when the liberal era began, Republicans fell into chaos and couldn’t decide whether to proceed by trying to co-opt some of Roosevelt’s messages or by opposing him at every turn. (Not that it mattered much; by 1934 Democrats had a supermajority in both chambers of Congress.) The opposition began to gain strength by the 1960s and the GOP developed a contested blueprint for the future in the failed Goldwater campaign. Nixon governed largely within the liberal consensus, but conservatives continued to gain power, normalizing Goldwater’s seemingly extreme positions. Reagan picked those up and nearly won in ’76 and rode them to victory four years later.</p><p>The conservative era followed similar contours. Reagan unleashed an anti-union, pro-market, low-tax era that upended thinking of the liberal era. It reversed the focus on equality and emphasized personal liberty. This thinking dominated American politics through the 2000s. Clinton, like Eisenhower during the progressive era, “triangulated” throughout his administration, adopting conservative positions on welfare, crime, the environment, and big business, solidifying them as legitimate. Much as LBJ completed his era’s biggest goals in the ’60s, George W. Bush managed to finally achieve the deregulation and low taxes Reagan initiated. Finally, Trump, whose approval never reached 50%, presided over the least-popular government in the polling era.</p><p>Like Republicans in the liberal era, Democrats fell into chaos following Reagan’s election. A new faction tried to find wiggle room within the values of conservatism, one that courted business and ignored labor while retreating its defense of the poor, marginalized, and politically disenfranchised. This approach delivered some victories in the era, but always on conservative terms. However, during the Bush administration, a more vocal liberalism emerged that looked to government to ensure greater protections for racial, gender, and sexual minorities as well as safety net programs like health care, affordable college, child care, and so on. Still, the conservative consensus prevailed through the Obama administration. Although he managed to achieve many victories in his tenure, they were still framed within the accepted orthodoxy of the conservative era. ObamaCare, as one example, wasn’t a government program; it was a market-based kludge.</p><h3><strong>Change Comes Fast</strong></h3><p>This is the big lesson of the two eras: when things changed, they changed fast and, but the standards of a year or two earlier, radically. It’s as if what an electorate “knows” has suddenly changed. What is considered fringe and unacceptable one year becomes wholly mainstream the next — and what was mainstream the previous year now seems dangerous and extreme. There are a host of examples, but few are as stark as tax rates. In 1931, the highest income tax rate was 25%. In one year it jumped to 63% — a number inconceivable by modern standards. Yet it went higher, jumping to over 90% in the mid-40s. It remained high until the 1960s, when it came back down to around 70%, which is where it was when Reagan began slashing, bringing it all the way back down to 28%.</p><p>What is politically possible, what voters see as “reasonable” ideas, exist within what political scientists call the <a href="https://www.mackinac.org/OvertonWindow"><strong>Overton window</strong></a>. During the past forty years, proposing a top marginal tax of 75% would have seemed laughable, inconceivable — even though under a different era it had been that high for decades. And while that window can appear to be nearly immovable, with only the smallest incremental changes coming after years of trench warfare, circumstances that have been building for decades can shift it far to the right or left in a matter of months. Opposition parties work for decades to popularize ideas, slowly dripping them into society’s bloodstream until they seem less alien. Meanwhile, ruling parties eventually achieve their popular goals and then begin to pursue more extreme goals that unnerve voters. These currents create the conditions for quick, radical change.</p><p>It’s hard to describe what’s happening without seeing this dynamic at play. Joe Biden was no one’s avatar of progressive revolution. His half-century of politics has been marked by placing himself in the dead center of the Party’s wings. In his long years serving in the conservative era, that meant having taken a number of positions that now seem retrograde. The man who opposed busing to desegregate schools in 1974 now heads the party of Black Lives Matter. That the early months of his administration have been so markedly liberal is evidence that the rules have changed. Joe isn’t a revolutionary leading the party left, he’s the same old politician who finds the middle ground between a Joe Manchin and Bernie Sanders. It’s just that the middle has shifted almost unrecognizably in the past year. Given that he is passing more overtly leftist legislation than any Democrat since LBJ, and especially given that it has so far been <a href="https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/despite-gop-opposition-polls-show-bidens-covid-relief-plan-retains-broad-popularity-151557608.html"><strong>wildly popular</strong></a>, that suggests the real possibility that something monumental is happening.</p><p>The popularity of the relief bill could be an outlier. The Covid-19 pandemic is a once-in-a-century crisis. When Democrats push to pass a $15 minimum wage, or a sweeping voting rights act, or to undo the filibuster, perhaps voters will regard these acts as unacceptable overreach. Yet if history is a guide, there’s a very good chance they’ll be popular. In that case, Biden could be the unlikely leader of a new age of liberal politics, a popular leader who will lead the US out of its current period of polarization and calcification. Time will tell, but it’s no more outlandish than the dramatic shifts that happened in 1932 or 1980.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f7ae6225b853" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The GOP’s Rightward Ratchet]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/the-gops-rightward-ratchet-fbef392b1dae?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fbef392b1dae</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[gop]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[republican-party]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 05 Feb 2021 17:26:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-05T17:26:09.788Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*89brNnUnssZs2gD4dyA8_g.png" /></figure><p>For forty-odd years, from the moment my mom tried to explain the bizarre development of a peanut farmer romping through the Democractic primary in the mid-70s, I’ve been magnetized by politics. There’s something irresistible about a massive human project with so many contradictory, layered, and interdisciplinary impulses, all crashing against each other to produce unexpected outcomes. Or it was, until 2016. That’s when I developed a sense of helplessness about politics, which no longer seemed dynamic nor unexpected — and worse, which now seem to be headed on an inexorable path toward a constitutional crisis..</p><p>My helplessness stems from the way the Republican Party is has become inaccessible to the normal forces of politics. Like any party, the GOP has always had rival factions that forced self-correction following elective disasters. Representing monied interests — necessarily a minority faction — the party has long flirted with authoritarianism. The John Birch Society and Joe McCarthy in the 40s and 50s were early examples. But it has also had tempering influences — those same elites need stability and order for markets to thrive. If authoritarianism was a sickness, the GOP had antibodies in the form of sensible, democracy-championing leaders like Dwight Eisenhower to heal the Party. For every Goldwater, there was a Rockefeller.</p><p>Neither major party was ideologically or regionally homogeneous, and that helped preserve a healthy balance. Unfortunately, the realignment of the parties following the Civil Rights era damaged the GOP’s directional gyroscope. Southern White reactionaries streamed out of the Democratic Party, infusing the GOP with a whole new dimension of racial resentment and religious fervor. (The Dems, a coalitional party, remained riven by competing factions and experienced the opposite trend — one driving their Party toward moderation.)</p><p>Realignment introduced two new toxins into the GOP. The first, from the unyielding religious right, was a moral certainty that snubbed cooperation. You can’t horse-trade with godless baby-killers. The second, an eschatological mindset dredged up by the “lost cause” of the civil war — the idea that good, honest people can’t win and will always be painted as villains — infused the party, at least at the grassroots, with nihilism. That the parties had by that time become homogeneous meant Republicans lost members who held socially or racially liberal views. No one remained to challenge moral certainty or the sense of cultural loss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1IaSCC0pcqJhcMb_du6B2A.png" /></figure><p>We don’t need to go through the full history, which starts with Nixon’s southern strategy and picks up speed with Reagan’s libertarianism and Gingrich’s zero-sum politics before blossoming in the mass media world of Fox News and the internet. What’s important in the development is that Republicans began to see a winning strategy that defied normal politics.</p><p>They realized that if they never broke ranks, every loss became emblematic of their worldview of lost causes, grievance, moral certainty, and existential threat. They could use loss as a boomerang to future success. And so, first in fits and starts but later with precision clockwork, the pattern became clear: always escalate the fire-breathing to shore up emotional engagement of the base, adopt a scorched-earth policy toward negotiation, and further demonize Democrats. Gingrich was the evil genius who saw the unerring wisdom in this course. The GOP became a rightward, authoritarian ratchet, always turning in one direction.</p><p>What it means is that after ever election, win or lose, the GOP gets more extreme. If they win, as in 2016, it is evidence the cause is true. If they lose, its because someone has betrayed the cause. Either way, the answer is the same: get more extreme, move further right, and burn the heretics. Moderates — those politicians who would actually negotiate with Democrats — were mostly run out of the party by the mid-aughts. Now a moderate is anyone who has been in office long enough to have come of political age before recent ratchets to the right. Heroes of the party from one decade become betrayers the next. Even the Paul Ryans eventually become squishes.</p><p>(The rest of us played some role in this, allowing whatever latest extreme actions the GOP committed to become normalized. We held the parties to different standards and wearily accepted that one party was in the business of destroying its rivals while the other, to retain legitimacy, had to woo theirs. It was the dysfunctional relationship of the abused to the abuser, and I say that not to diminish even a tiny bit people abused by parent or spouses, but to emphasize just how dysfunctional our politics have become. As one party gets ever more extreme, everyone must accommodate themselves to the changes.)</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3YsELwNNkYhb6bYuNNS6jg.png" /></figure><p>So, it was of course inevitable that Republicans would begin to openly embrace violent sedition and treason. It was inevitable they would abandon even the pretense of supporting democratic elections. It raised eyebrows to learn of a plot to kidnap and kill a Democratic governor, but it didn’t surprise. The assault on the Capitol was more startling but hardly, knowing everything else we have leaned about the party, unexpected. And the latest revelations that a sitting Congresswoman called for politicians to be killed (GA’s Marjorie Taylor Greene) were just more of the same.</p><p>So here we are and this is why I am so enervated by politics. We have passed the point where the politics common to democracy still function. There is no legal or political solution to stop the GOP, no self-correcting mechanism to snap them out of this nihilistic vortex. If I could look back into the history post-Gingrich and find a single case where the party bucked this habit, it might give me a little hope. There isn’t one. The opposite is true: when any Republican politician has tried to buck this trend, they soon become ex-politicians.</p><p>No one knows what this means. We’re way off the grid in terms of normal democratic politics. In past eras I understood the rules and would have delighted in the gamesmanship of the two parties as they maneuvered for popularity and power. Now I watch in horror as one party quickly escalates its assault on those rules, seeing them as the ultimate barrier to their ends — along with, of course, those who want to to preserve them. It is an extremely bad time in America and I lack the imagination to see an easy way out.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fbef392b1dae" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Bursting the Shadow Bubble]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/bursting-the-shadow-bubble-251a9b12c6c6?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/251a9b12c6c6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[impeachment]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[capitol-riot]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 13 Jan 2021 17:27:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-13T17:27:08.491Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/1*hJUC-77Lhw7NpqKF5BM-vA.jpeg" /><figcaption><a href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/blinkofanaye/50811610361/"><strong>Blink O’Fanaye/Flickr</strong></a></figcaption></figure><p>Governments have faced hundreds of insurrections over the centuries, but none have been as well-documented as last Wednesday’s MAGA mob. This is only partly because past rioters haven’t owned smart phones: one of the weirdest — and most revealing — quirks of the Capitol insurrection was how readily rioters were to document their crimes. Through their smiles and triumphal IG posts about “patriots,” we observe a body of people so trapped in a false narrative they literally can’t imagine an alternative one. These were evangelists of the “big lie” that Trump actually won the election, a belief that would only thrive in an enclosed bubble of fake news.</p><p>This bubble has been ably documented over the past five years, and periodic explorers to its inner depths have fed a steady stream of news about the outlandish beliefs held inside. We knew it existed, even if we didn’t understand its population or precise theology. Most of us didn’t understand how angry its members were, or how ready to commit violence, or how intent on overturning a democratic election. The mob was an abject demonstration of all of the above, but also a window into the guileless self-satisfaction that came from living in a reality where they were actually upholding rather than destroying the will of the people. In this bubble their beliefs were pure and unstained by doubt.</p><p>When blood and urine spilled on the Capitol floors, we began to understand more clearly how depraved those beliefs were. Perhaps equally as jarring, however, was the way in which the insurrection revealed a second bubble of reality that had grown as a protective shield against the first. In that reality, Republicans were just fighting the good fight, but still believed in American values of equality, democracy, and liberty for all. This second, shadow bubble is inhabited by most people not living in the first, hanging onto the increasingly crazy hope that the GOP was still a sane and normal party of good faith, if one willing to play hardball. A <em>huge</em> amount of effort went into maintaining this hope, because the alternative was too painful to consider.</p><p>Thus you had big portions of the media absurdly making excuses for racist, anti-democratic statements by the GOP, arguing they hadn’t really said what they’d just said. Or that those who said it were a crackpot fringe who didn’t understand when to use their inside voice instead of spouting Q-anon nonsense. It was a feint the GOP ruthlessly exploited, first breaking norms and then winking at sensible people as if it were all just normal political theater.</p><p>And so many Americans — and crucially Democrats and reporters — chose their own false reality because the alternative was to acknowledge that a powerful, frankly racist wing of American society was committed to end democracy. For many, that was literally unthinkable. They couldn’t imagine such a party existing — or more to the point, they could reconcile their own image of a moral America in which such a faction could thrive and win converts. The shadow bubble was one in which MLK wins and the Confederacy loses, where the sane judgment of upright citizens ultimately defeats demagogues like Joe McCarthy and fringe figures like Barry Goldwater. America, an ultimately moral place, was inconsistent with a party like that. So they didn’t believe such a party existed.</p><p>The shadow bubble actually enabled the primary bubble. It fostered inattention and inaction. It laundered every new transgression back into normalcy, so that no matter how extreme the GOP got, members of the second bubble forgave and recontextualized the acts of those in the first bubble. For radicals in the Republican Party, this was an excellent situation.</p><p>Last Wednesday’s mob was shocking in part because of the series of unlikely events it took to expose it. The GOP has been on this track a long time — twenty years at least. And yet it took a uniquely incompetent and mentally unwell president, an election close in a few key states but a near landslide in actual votes, and a two-month campaign to overturn a plainly fair and conclusive election to set the stage for that mob to form. Had Trump prevailed, had he not been so insane and begrudgingly admitted he lost (or allowed he wouldn’t be inaugurated in January), had <em>a few</em> GOP members of Congress acknowledged he won — any of these would have broken the chain of events leading to the riot. All these antecedents would still be present, and the actions of folks like Cruz and Hawley would be wholly unchanged, but the shadow bubble would have been working heroically to keep them concealed. We’re able to consider the danger to democracy not because it’s a new thing, but because an incredibly unlikely event forced us to accept it.</p><p>As the House begins its second (!) impeachment of Donald Trump, I am deeply uneasy. Republicans are instinctively trying to put the shadow bubble back together. The very members who last week were trying to subvert an election were this week calling for “healing,” understanding just what a powerful inducement that is for denizens of the shadow bubble. Americans of goodwill <em>do</em> want healing. We want back into that reality where democracy magically dispels all corruption, racism, and malice. That instinct is profound, and the GOP knows how to manipulate it.</p><p>No figure has been more adept at exploiting the shadow bubble than Mitch McConnell, whose political genius resides in breathtaking cynicism. Yesterday he publicly toyed with a vote to convict Trump in the Senate, despite spending the past two months refusing to acknowledge Trump’s loss. Having spent four years as his servile wingman, McConnell is happy to betray Trump at the moment it serves his purposes, understanding that he represents the perfect fall guy. If Trump can be sufficiently demonized, all the GOP’s public sins can die with him — even as McConnell will return to the very acts that subvert the democracy.</p><p>This is a dangerous moment in history, but also an opportunity. The insurrection that never should have happened did, in a context in which the instigators were unambiguous. There is a lot of hard, painful work ahead. Those of us who want live in a world in which lightness overcomes the dark,must now press for legal consequences. We must demand that anyone not committed to democracy be named and opposed, that illegal acts are punished. We have to shore up laws and fix the broken parts of our democracy that allow a majority to govern. It’s going to take a long time and the GOP will fight every step of the way. As bad as it will be, though, the alternative, which until a week ago I thought was inevitable, is so much worse. Real healing is often painful.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=251a9b12c6c6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[2020 Considered: Part 1, the Results]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/2020-considered-part-1-the-results-14e97b0a26?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/14e97b0a26</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[polling]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-2020]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2020-presidential-race]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 02 Dec 2020 19:51:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-12-07T16:28:18.323Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*QjGr2L0dvWh4fhB70dlNZQ.png" /></figure><p>In the first of three posts on the fallout of the 2020 election, I consider the results themselves.</p><h4>Magnitude of the Win</h4><p>The final results are <em>still</em> not quite in (New York again sets the standard for failure to tally ballots), but we know Biden won 306 electoral votes, will have won more than 81 million votes overall, and achieved a margin that will end up somewhere between 4.5–5% . That’s a good win but no landslide and as a result, partisans on both sides have been trying to characterize it as more or less than it was. Let’s look at it in historical perspective. Taking elections from 1968 forward (14 in all, the modern era of elections), here’s where Biden’s performance places him.</p><p><strong>Electoral College</strong> (538 total)<br>270–300: 3<br>301–350: 4 ← Biden<br>351–400: 3<br>401–450: 1<br>451–500: 1<br>500–538: 2</p><p><strong>Popular Vote Margin<br></strong>-2.1 to 0%: <strong>2</strong><br>.1 to 2%:<strong> 2</strong><br>2.1 to 4%: <strong>2</strong><br>4.1 to 6%: <strong>2 </strong>← Biden<br>6.1 to 8%: <strong>2</strong><br>8.1 to 10%: <strong>2</strong><br>10% and over: <strong>2</strong></p><p>A couple other notable facts. Both candidates won 25 states exactly, yet the popular vote margin, with a million votes outstanding, is around 7 million. Much has been made of the widening gap between rural and urban voters, and this is a further example. Nevertheless, had 44,000 people voted differently in Wisconsin, Arizona, and Georgia, the result would have been an electoral vote tie, 269–269. Finally, the GOP has been remarkably consistent in the six elections this century. In five of those, they received between 45.7 and 47.9% of the vote. Only once did they exceed that window, in 2004, when an incumbent president was running during wartime. (The Dems, for their part, have never won fewer than 48% of the vote in any election this century.)</p><p>Finally, despite the incredible loyalty some Trump voters exhibit, he did underperform relative to other Republicans. He will end up losing to Biden by around 4.5%. House Republicans, by contrast, received just 3% fewer votes collectively than Dems. It’s not a huge disparity, but Trump being Trump hurt his candidacy. (Romney got a larger percent of the vote than Trump did in either of his elections.)</p><h4>Analysis, extremely Briefly</h4><p>As final results emerge, we’re getting a more granular sense of how the 2020 election differed from 2016. The upshot: not very much. Educated, particularly suburban whites shifted a bit toward Biden, the gender gap widened, and some Latino and Black men voted Trump this time. Some of these patterns may reveal minor truths about the electorate. (I’m particularly interested to see how toxic masculinity may have helped Trump.)</p><p>But 2020 isn’t about White suburban trends in the exurbs or the fracturing of the Latino vote. Rather, the election revealed a major truth about voters in the United States. An incumbent president who grossly mishandled a raging pandemic, who was impeached for uncontested abuse of power, who lied at a staggering rate while shattering norms of governance and behavior, who didn’t bother to hide his visible corruption, and who shared his scheme to steal a national election months in advance managed to get more votes than any other candidate except Joe Biden in an American election. In the end, 75 million Americans voted for Donald Trump <em>because</em> he was a White ethno-nationalist authoritarian. Trying to parse the meaning of the election in any terms that fail to reckon with this disturbing reality mean little.</p><h4>Mean Reversion and State Leans</h4><p>2020 did reveal how states continue to change — or not. Some states, like Florida and Ohio, seem to be swing states yet turn out, in the recent realignment, not to be. Others, like Georgia and Arizona, have really moved. Still others — Pennsylvania and Wisconsin — may have become true swing states. Have a look at the results in 2000, 2012, and 2020:</p><ul><li><strong>Georgia.</strong> 2000: R +11.7%, 2012: R +6.2%, 2020: D +.2%</li><li><strong>Florida</strong>: R +.1%, D +2.8%, R +3.3%</li><li><strong>Wisconsin</strong>: D +.2%, D +14.1%, D +.7%</li><li><strong>Arizona</strong>: R +6.3%, R +9%, D +.3%</li><li><strong>Pennsylvania</strong>: D +4.2%, D +6.4%, D+1.2%</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*hutjUfLzp7LqJLpU7v-z6Q.png" /></figure><p>Obama muddies the water in these trends a bit because his wins were substantial, big enough to push him to a win in FL (which has only voted D when he was on the ticket), and run up the score in WI and PA. No idea what was happening in Arizona in 2012, honestly. But following that election there was a lot of talk of abandoning it by Dems — which goes to show how these things are hard. Instead, Arizona moved left in 2016 and again in 2020, following Nevada’s pattern of turning blue. Georgia, similarly, moved steadily blue throughout the century. Pennsylvania and Wisconsin seem to be center-left but up for grabs. North Carolina, incidentally, seems to fall somewhere between Georgia and Florida — moving left, but very slowly.</p><p>Since states tend to follow national results, we would expect to see some swing in elections where the winner had a big majority versus toss-up elections. A state that typically votes +3 for the GOP might balloon up to +6 in a wave election for a GOP candidate, or be a toss-up in a wave election won by a Dem. In non-wave years, we would expect mean-reversion (that is, such a state returning to +3 GOP). The states like GA and AZ that continually move in one direction illustrate real change. (Worth noting than in a national election in which Biden won by only +2, we’d expect him to lose GA and AZ).</p><p>There’s some of this in terms of voting blocs as well. Dems have been winning enormous percentages of Black and Latino voters. That Biden won “only” 88% of Black voters and 70% of Latinos may just represent mean-reversion. In 2016, Trump only won 18% of Latinos — a number without historic precedent — so his 27% in 2020 isn’t so surprising. It’s exactly what Romney won in 2012.</p><h4>Polling Errors, Trump Voters</h4><p>Pollsters had yet another bad cycle, and it looked a lot like 2016. The error varied, and in some states polling was quite accurate. But again, the error was all in one direction, underestimating Trump’s strength. In order to account for the disparities here, we can’t look at structural problems with polls like voter access. If those were the culprits, we’d see similar errors across the board. The starkest examples of the weirdness were the outcomes in Minnesota and Wisconsin.</p><ul><li><strong>Minnesota</strong>. Polls showed Biden up 9.2%. He won by 7.1%.</li><li><strong>Wisconsin</strong>. Polls had Biden up 8.4%. He won by just .7%, an even larger error than in 2016.</li></ul><p>These two states are very similar in nearly every way. Minnesota is the more educated of the two, but Wisconsin’s voters are more educated than voters nationally. It’s hard to see how that accounts for the differences. So what gives?</p><p>The 2020 vote was gigantic — the largest in a hundred years. Two things appeared to happen. Biden managed to flip a lot more Trump voters than vice-versa. However, Trump again won a majority of the late-deciders and seemed to get a lot of non-voters to cast ballots. If so, two factors contributed to the error. First, pollsters’ likely-voter screen missed Trump voters. Second, pollsters’ weighting failed to account for Trump voters.</p><p>In two elections, Trump has reversed a long-standing dynamic that once favored Democrats in which low-propensity voters are induced to cast a ballot in big elections. Those same voters didn’t show up in 2018 when Trump wasn’t on the ballot, and polls then were a lot more accurate.</p><p>A final, plausible explanation is that GOP voters, whom Trump fed a consistent message that polls are fake, disproportionately refused to participate in them.</p><h4>The Weirdest, Trumpiest Election</h4><p>Despite Trump’s incredibly transgressive, unprecedented term, his approval never escaped a narrow window. Neither events nor other actors affected his approval at all. Americans knew who Trump was and either liked him or didn’t. No amount of chaos or accomplishment was going to change that. It doesn’t seem possible that something as profoundly destabilizing as a pandemic would have no affect on the election, but it didn’t — or not much. Given how close the election was, small changes might have altered the outcome. Had Trump handled the pandemic better, he might have pulled out a repeat of 2016. It barely mattered who the Dem was, though it’s possible to imagine one tipping the scales to Trump just enough. But effectively, nothing Trump could do would lose him the support of about 46% of the electorate. After it was all done, he got 46.1% against Clinton, and he’ll end up getting 46% and change against Biden.</p><p>This is the Trump age in the smallest of nutshells: the American people knew exactly who Donald J. Trump was, and 46.5% liked what they saw.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=14e97b0a26" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What To Look For on Election Day]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/what-to-look-for-on-election-day-2eeb6370a6ca?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2eeb6370a6ca</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-2020]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-day]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2020-presidential-race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[2020-senate-elections]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 03 Nov 2020 01:48:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-03T02:50:03.671Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UVs-8tIAnn9XSv6YxGi9sA.png" /></figure><p>Forecasts made a day or two before an election are almost always composed for the benefit of forecasters who are attempting to talk themselves into a favored outcome. I am resisting that temptation and instead trying to focus my mind on those factors that will actually matter tomorrow.</p><h4>Every Election is a Simple Proposition</h4><p>I’ve been poring over individual states, looking at early-voting data, sussing out voting demographics, assessing who controls the voting apparatus, and trying to predict the likelihood of a Biden win in each case. At one point I was listening to a podcast in which a statistician was pointing out the possible salience of White Catholic voters in the upper Midwest who might be breaking for Biden when I realized I had gone too far. Given the massive early vote and the unpredictable effect of Covid on voting patterns, the microscopic view is absurd. These tiny shifts may help explain the election once we know the results, but they’re useless to consider now given the massive unknowns. So let’s simplify.</p><p>Instead of looking at individual states, it’s valuable to consider the election like a wager: with an electoral college win set at 270, which candidate is more likely to get there? Let’s assume the polling, which has been incredibly, unprecedentedly stable, has <em>some</em> validity. Biden leads Wisconsin and Michigan by 8%. (I’m using <a href="https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/2020-election-forecast/"><strong>538</strong></a> for all the numbers here.) If we consider states polling at 8% or more for a candidate our safe zone, nine states and one district are polling within a narrower range, and they account for 154 electoral votes: <strong>Arizona</strong> (Biden +2.6%) , <strong>Florida</strong> (Biden +2.5%), <strong>Georgia</strong> (Biden +.8%),<strong> Iowa</strong> (Trump +1.6%), <strong>Nebraska 02 </strong>(Biden +3.7)<strong>, Ohio</strong> (Trump +.4%), <strong>Pennsylvania</strong> (Biden +4.9%), <strong>North Carolina</strong> (Biden +1.9%), and <strong>Texas </strong>(Trump +1.3%). Montana also figures into that window, with Trump at +7.1%, but let’s just assume he hangs onto Big Sky Country.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*1IdGaGEyN8pKeTy6J6hEMg.jpeg" /></figure><p>Biden starts with an incredibly strong advantage here, leading 259 to 125. If you examine any individual state, it’s easy to find reasons to doubt the polling. For Biden fans, that means that even in any of the six states he leads, it’s easy to talk yourself into scenarios where he loses. But all of them?That seems a lot less plausible. <strong>Biden can win the election if he carries just one of seven of these states, whereas</strong> <strong>Trump has to win at least seven of the eight states to reach 270</strong>. The President could afford to lose Nebraska’s second district (1 EV) and Iowa (6 EV), but every other state on the board has eleven or more electors. He needs them all. So, again, if you had to take one candidate to get the over, which one would it be? Biden is the clear favorite.</p><h4>The Senate</h4><p>The Presidency isn’t the only prize, and in many ways it will be impossible to govern without picking up the Senate as well. Given our weird Constitution, the Senate becomes a veto point for the President in terms of cabinet and judicial appointments. The GOP currently holds a three-seat advantage in the Senate, and Democrats are defending a seat in Alabama that will almost certainly flip Republican. That means Democrats need to win a net four seats to reach 50 if they also win the Presidency (the Vice President breaks ties in the Senate). Here things look like a toss-up. In order to take control of the Senate, Democrats would need to win four of these nine races:</p><ul><li><strong>Colorado</strong>. John Hickenlooper (D) leads Cory Gardner (R) by 7.1%.</li><li><strong>Arizona</strong>. Mark Kelly (D) leads Martha McSally (R) by 5.2%.</li><li><strong>North Carolina</strong>. Cal Cunningham (D) leads Thom Tillis by 3.1%</li><li><strong>Maine</strong>. Sara Gideon (D) leads Susan Collins (R) by 1.4%.</li><li><strong>Georgia</strong>. In a wild open primary in which appointed candidate Kelly Loeffler is running in a field of four, Democrats are leading in polls.</li><li><strong>Georgia</strong>. David Purdue (R) leads Jon Ossoff by .5%.</li><li><strong>Iowa</strong>. Joni Ernst (R) leads Theresa Greenfield (D) by 1.5%</li><li><strong>Montana</strong>. Steve Daines (R) leads Steve Bullock (D) by 3%.</li><li><strong>South Carolina</strong>. Lindsay Graham (R) leads Jaime Harrison (D) by 5.5%.</li></ul><p>Senate races are somewhat independent of presidential outcomes, but correlated with them. If Biden is easily beating Trump, more of these races will be in play — especially if states like Iowa, Georgia, and North Carolina are trending Biden. However, if Trump holds those states, the Senate races will be harder to pick up. It’s certainly possible for Trump to lose while the GOP hangs onto the Senate.</p><h4>Stray Factors to Watch</h4><p>If you’re curious about the early vote, this university professor has <a href="https://electproject.github.io/Early-Vote-2020G/index.html"><strong>a fantastic, comprehensive site</strong></a> with all you need to know. We have all been trained to remain cool as the results start trickling in with the knowledge that it will take days to count the votes in most states. We shouldn’t expect to know who won on election day. That’s true. However, it’s possible to over-learn that lesson. Tomorrow’s results will present a lot of clues about where the election is headed. Florida and North Carolina have already started counting their ballots and we’ll get a tally of a lot of the results there immediately. If Trump shows strong support in those states, that means we’ll be looking at the Midwest for pivotal outcomes. Regions are correlated, so favorable results in NC and FL will tell us a lot about Georgia.</p><p>Similarly, Wisconsin will start releasing decent results early, and these may hint at what to expect in MI, OH, and IA. Biden should win Wisconsin, so the question is whether he’s doing better or worse than the polls, which suggest an eight-point Biden lead. Arizona will also have early results — though they’ll come an hour after the East Coast. If one of the candidates is doing especially well there, that may hint at what to expect in Texas. If Biden is getting crushed in Arizona, it’s time to look at Nevada, a state just on the bubble for Trump to snatch.</p><p>Finally, the GOP has already telegraphed its plan to challenge votes in competitive states, and hardcore partisans have threatened voter intimidation on election day. All of that is unprecedented, so just be aware of the possibilities. At the same time, also note that election day always features wild rumors and fast-spreading misinformation. That happens even during sedate elections like 2004 and 2012 where an incumbent sailed to re-election. Tomorrow is going to be one long cavalcade of outlandish claims, so beware.</p><p>That’s it. Be well, try to get some sleep, and hope for the best.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2eeb6370a6ca" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Election One Week Out]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/the-election-one-week-out-5569f69667c2?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5569f69667c2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[poll]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[election-2020]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 27 Oct 2020 22:20:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-27T22:20:50.059Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*t1X4Enk5bTYND6r5STsLJg.jpeg" /></figure><p>This is an unprecedented election. To date, ~66 million votes have already been cast, and that number could top 100m by Election Day. Election experts expect a huge turnout, most pegging the number at 150–160m — far more than the 137m who turned out in 2016.</p><p>The really shocking development is that one party, through state suppression and judicial decree, is actively trying to disqualify enough of the vote so the incumbent can cling to power. No one believes Trump can actually win a majority of votes. “Winning” for the GOP amounts to something between narrowly legal technical victory and a soft coup. There’s no way to predict how that will play out, though Democrats are trying to run up the score to make it impossible for the GOP to disqualify enough ballots. Our democracy is nearing DefCon, and I suspect most of us are just hoping for a miracle here.</p><p>But anyway, we do have polls. These suggest what the actual vote may look like, and that’s important. In 2016, Clinton was sitting on a 3.5% lead in the 538 aggregate — and it was collapsing quickly. Biden had a stable lead of 9% this morning. His margin through debates, Presidential viruses, and Supreme Court battles hasn’t wobbled outside the 7.5 to 10.5% range.</p><p>More important, of course, are state margins. Below are the current averages in battleground states according to 538. I’ve included all the states Biden and Trump hope to flip. It seems a bit absurd to include South Carolina in the averages, but it represents the same level of reach for Biden (-7.9%) as Minnesota is for Trump. (Biden winning AK and SC is, according to polling, slightly <em>more</em> likely than Trump winning NV and MN.)</p><p>Barring some kind of super bizarre, not-in-modern-polling error, Biden will win Wisconsin and Michigan. The critical state is Pennsylvania. If Biden wins it (beyond efforts to disqualify votes), he’ll win the election. Everything else will be gravy. The Senate and statehouses are also a huge deal this census-year election, but you can go read 538 if you want more on them.</p><p><strong>Biden Targets</strong> [2016 EV: 232]</p><ul><li><strong>Michigan</strong>: +8.3% (16/248)</li><li><strong>Wisconsin</strong>: +7.1% (10/258)</li><li><strong>Pennsylvania</strong>: + 5.3% (20/278)</li><li><strong>Arizona</strong>: +2.8% (11/289)</li><li><strong>Florida</strong>: +2.4% (29/318)</li><li><strong>North Carolina</strong>: +2.4% (15/333)</li><li><strong>Maine District 2</strong>: +2.1% (1/334)</li><li><strong>Georgia</strong>: +1.2% (16/350)</li><li><strong>Iowa</strong>: +1.2% (6/356)</li><li><strong>Texas</strong>: -1.3% (38/394)</li><li><strong>Ohio</strong>: -1.6% (18/412)</li><li><strong>Alaska</strong>: -6.4% (3/415)</li><li><strong>South Carolina</strong>: -7.9% (9/423)</li></ul><p><strong>Trump Targets</strong> [2016: 306 EV]</p><ul><li><strong>Nevada</strong>: -7.1% (6/312)</li><li><strong>Minnesota</strong>: -7.9% (10/322)</li></ul><p>Hang in there, folks, just one 27-month long week to go!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5569f69667c2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Why the Supreme Court Needs 15 Justices]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/why-the-supreme-court-needs-15-justices-f6cd5d2a1f90?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f6cd5d2a1f90</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[supreme-court]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[government]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[constitution]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 13 Oct 2020 18:06:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-13T18:09:30.059Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*iLQ5hhj1MOWoUEd3s6DgJw.jpeg" /></figure><p>As the baroque, late-empire spectacle of the Supreme Court battle unfolds during this election year, let’s talk about one easy fix that would substantially reduce some of the nation’s dysfunction. The founders, in all their wisdom, decided to put <a href="https://ecommons.udayton.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1049&amp;context=pol_fac_pub"><strong>more veto points in our government</strong></a> than any other modern democracy. The Supreme Court is the final way for leaders to stop laws from taking place (or, as may be case in less than a year, trashing duly-passed legal legislation like ObamaCare), and as such has become one of the most contentious and polarizing institutions in the country.</p><p>Much of what the founders created isn’t easy to fix. The US Senate was intentionally designed to reward small states with outsized influence. The Electoral College was, too — and the subtext in both was to over-represent the voice of slave states. Neither one can be fixed easily. The Supreme Court is another matter, however, and the President and Senate may decide how many members it contains. Indeed, it hasn’t always comprised nine justices. It started out with six and slowly grew with the country to ten in 1863. The numbers settled at nine three years later. At the time, America’s population was just 38 million.</p><p>The two parties didn’t always view the Supreme Court as such a pivotal actor. The parties weren’t ideologically consistent, and the President and Senate didn’t subject nominees to ideological purity tests in the way they do today. Often justices ended up departing significantly in ideological terms from the men who nominated them. The Senate would also typically approve qualified nominees out of deference to the President. The GOP makes much hay about how Senate Democrats rejected Justice Robert Bork in 1987 precisely <em>because</em> it was so rare. (By contrast, a GOP Senate didn’t just reject Merrick Garland in 2016 — they refused to even hold hearings.)</p><p>Change came in the past three decades as the parties became ideologically coherent and the Court became critical in preserving or overturning key laws — the right to abortion central among them. Getting a justice on the Court has become increasingly important to governance, and justices hang on as long as possible, exacerbating the sense that each nomination is a life-or-death matter.</p><p>Things have reached a point of permanent dysfunction — one that worsens the country’s pathologies. It’s now clear no president will ever be able to place a justice unless their party also holds the Senate. We could easily find ourselves in a situation where years go by with eight or fewer justices sitting on the bench. (In 2016, facing a situation in which they lost the presidency but held the Senate, GOP Senators <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/04/11/republicans-are-now-saying-8-justices-on-the-supreme-court-is-just-fine-it-might-work/"><strong>argued for precisely that</strong></a>.) With stakes so high, no opposing Senate will ever give a lifetime appointment to a 40-something ideologue. Or even a 60-something moderate like Garland.</p><p>Adding justices would lower the stakes. A larger Court would reflect greater diversity and life experience. Presidents would be able to place more of them, and as such they wouldn’t represent an existential crisis. It would also reduce the power of any single justice — another important benefit of a body with the final say on the law. A larger, more diverse Supreme Court would gain more legitimacy, especially important in a time when voters hold politicians in such low regard.</p><p><strong>A Modest Proposal<br></strong>Over the past fifty years, presidents have placed 19 justices on the court (assuming Amy Coney Barrett is confirmed this year). That’s an average of 1.5 each four years or three every eight. Expanding the court would give presidents more selections. Any number would be arbitrary, but 15 would represent a substantial increase yet remain a functional number. With fifteen, churn would jump to roughly five justices in any eight-year term. Every year or two one justice would depart and a new justice would join the court. It would become more routine and no single appointment would carry the searing importance a vacancy like Ruth Bader Ginsberg’s has created.</p><p>Of course, getting to fifteen would be politically risky and could itself become a political crisis. Were Democrats to jam 2–6 justices through without Republican support, the public would be outraged. Republicans, of course, would retaliate as long as there is constitutional recourse. The solution could easily become the source of a much bigger problem.</p><p>So consider this suggestion: raise the number to 15, but appoint four Democratic choices and give the GOP two slots. (According to the constitution, the president would have to nominate them, but would select Mitch McConnell’s two favored candidates). This kind of horse-trading used to be common on the court: the President would negotiate with the opposition’s leader to find a choice that would sail through approval.</p><p>Democrats would take an immediate hit because this arrangement would leave the GOP a 8–7 majority. In the long run, it would benefit Democrats, and in the short run it would avoid a legitimacy crisis on the court and prevent the radical rulings we can expect with the probable 6–3 GOP majority of the current court. Indeed, with fifteen justices, it would be far harder to ever create majority who would reliably make radical rulings. Justices are never purely ideological. Most have idiosyncrasies that cause them to rule against their normal allies— we saw it with Scalia, Kennedy, Roberts, and even Gorsuch. (Liberals cross lines even more often.) With fifteen justices, the likelihood of any case collecting eight votes on purely ideological grounds drops substantially.</p><p>It would be in the Democrats short- and especially long-term interests to move to fifteen with a one-seat minority. They should begin coordination and develop a messaging plan for why this is the sensible constitutional solution — and one that will ultimately save the court.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f6cd5d2a1f90" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Election Notes, Labor Day Edition]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/election-notes-labor-day-edition-4f4bd0279dc0?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4f4bd0279dc0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[presidential-election]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[biden]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 07 Sep 2020 15:43:45 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-09-07T15:43:45.330Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/984/1*k52H2137avf_dYUkKJdW0A.png" /><figcaption>Real Clear Politics poll tracker, Biden v Trump</figcaption></figure><p>The election that would never end is suddenly speeding toward its conclusion. For so many months, all our speculation was purely theoretical — and all commentary ended with disclaimers about how much things might change. Once Labor Day comes, however, the presidential picture begins to firm up. Over the last 15 cycles, no candidate with a polling lead at Labor Day has ever lost the popular vote. Two have lost the presidency — including Hillary Clinton in 2016 — but polls are no longer meaningless. So as we enter the home stretch, let’s consider where the election stands and what to expect.</p><h4>What the Polls Say</h4><p>While not without caveats, Joe Biden enjoys a large lead in national polls, and a comfortable advantage in state polls. According to 538 (more about that site below), Biden currently holds a <a href="https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/president-general/national/"><strong>7% lead</strong></a> in national polling averages (50.4% to 43%). That’s a substantial lead. Polling errors happen, but rarely at that scale — particularly in races that are as stable as this one, with two very well-known candidates. Keep in mind that errors happen in both directions, so if an 8% error is possible in Trump’s favor, it’s also possible in Biden’s. Finally, Biden has consistently been polling above 50%, an important benchmark. If accurate, that means voters who have already decided to vote for Biden would have to switch to Trump. There just aren’t many gettable voters for Trump to pick up.</p><p>Of course, the electoral college changes the picture, so here’s <a href="https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/"><strong>where we are</strong></a> at the state level. Biden leads state polling averages in six Trump 2016 states. Trump trails in all three Clinton-won states he has targeted to flip.</p><p><strong>Trump-won states</strong></p><p>Wisconsin (Biden +7.4%), Michigan (+6.7%), Arizona (+4.7%), Pennsylvania (4.5%), Florida (2.8%), North Carolina (1.8%)</p><p><strong>Clinton-won states</strong></p><p>Minnesota (Trump -6.3%), Nevada (6.5%), New Hampshire (-8.2%), Maine (-9.9%)</p><p>These show a closer race, but Biden holds a clear advantage. One way to think about them is imagining different polling errors. Even if state polls are off by 4% in Trump’s favor, Biden will win the electoral college 289–249. If the polls are accurate, he’ll win 333–205. If there’s a two-point polling error in <em>Biden’s</em> favor, Biden will win 411–127 (picking up GA, IA, OH, and TX). In other words, as polls stand now in a very stable race, Biden is doing very well.</p><p>Now, about those caveats.</p><h4>National Elections are State Elections</h4><p>Trump “won” the 2016 election by garnering three million fewer votes than Clinton. He doesn’t need to beat Biden to win the election, he needs to beat him in the right states. Here Dems are rightly concerned that Trump will steal the election via voter suppression, mail-ballot shenanigans, and other efforts. And he is certainly trying. Yet elections in the US are overseen at the state rather than federal level, and so these efforts must happen piecemeal, with participation by state elections officials.</p><p>However, in Michigan, Pennsylvania, Arizona, and Wisconsin, the Secretaries of State overseeing elections <a href="https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-09-05/democrats-hold-secret-edge-if-election-is-too-close-to-call"><strong>are Democrats</strong></a>. This is important. Tactics that suppress votes require active efforts by states: limiting polling locations (always, of course, in BIPOC neighborhoods), limiting early voting, dumping people from voting rolls, and, in 2020, limiting mail voting. It’s a lot harder to rig elections in states where officials prioritize ballot access, as Democratic states will do this year. (And it’s worth noting that not every Republican is so committed to a Trump win they’re willing to help him cheat. Just last week, Oregon Secretary of State Bev Clarno, a Republican, ruled against the state GOP on an issue involving the explanatory pamphlet mailed to all registered voters).</p><p>I don’t want to sound Pollyanna-ish. Many states with Republican leadership will do these things, and their efforts will earn Trump an additional few points. It’s why wins in Georgia and Texas are much less likely than polls suggest. Florida, which historically runs some of the most corrupt elections, will be an interesting test case. The polls there show Biden with a lead of about 3% — a deficit local Republicans might be able to bridge by suppressive efforts. Winning there would be a strong sign of strength.</p><p>Biden may yet win a landslide, but he’ll need to widen the gap in Republican-led states that will attempt to suppress his voters.</p><h4>Whom to Trust</h4><p>Election seasons feature a lot of very hot takes. Typically the biggest news story of the year, news orgs trumpet an avalanche of breathless reporting and opinion. One of the biggest criticisms is that their relentless focus on the horse race leads to baroque “theater criticism” — style and form over facts and substance. That’s all valid and true, but what it misses is just how <em>bad</em> the coverage is. Incentives are misaligned; pundits are focused on attracting eyeballs, not getting things right. After an election, the worst analysts suffer zero consequences and, if they drove traffic, are rewarded by leading the charge four years later.</p><p>A small group are held accountable: data analysts like Nate Silver at 538. Because they quantify their punditry, they are crucified for even small misses. In 2008 and 2012, Princeton neuroscientist Sam Wang moonlighted as a Nate Silver alternate. He was so confident Hillary would win, he promised to eat a bug if Trump prevailed. That ended his career as a polling data guy, and he turned his attention to gerrymandering.</p><p>Nate Silver isn’t the only one standing, but no one has an identity so exclusively tied to elections. He is under incredible pressure to get this right. As a result, he spent weeks fine-tuning the model that got 2016 right, and obsessed over ever factor that might throw it off. Although he’s a lefty, he isn’t even slightly motivated to shade his prediction to Biden; getting the election wrong would be far more damaging to his career.</p><p>His analysis, revealed most fully on Twitter, is incredibly subtle. If you want to understand the election, <a href="https://mobile.twitter.com/NateSilver538"><strong>read his feed</strong></a>. It will give you a deep sense of the factors that decide elections (and ones, like the hoary old “fundamentals” pundits cite, that don’t), and what to watch. Silver also understands probabilities in a way no reporter does, and that will inform your thinking the next time a pundit starts babbling about “key factors.”</p><h4>Is the Cake Already Baked?</h4><p>Looking forward, everyone worries about events that might scramble the race. Debates, October surprises, economic changes, the pandemic — might these not rewrite the election and allow Trump to rally like he did in 2016?</p><p>No one would be fool enough to rule it out, but it’s remarkable how stable the race is and how little has changed it. In <a href="https://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/2020/president/us/general_election_trump_vs_biden-6247.html"><strong>head-to-head polls</strong></a> dating back nearly a year, Trump has never fallen below 40% against Biden, and never risen higher than 45%. Biden has ranged from 47 to 53%. During that time, Trump was impeached, 190,000 people died from a pandemic, and 30 million people lost their jobs. No matter — nothing pushed Trump below 40% nor Biden above 53%. It’s <em>possible</em> Biden’s floor is lower, yet his voters tell pollsters <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2020/08/13/the-2020-trump-biden-matchup/"><strong>there’s almost no chance</strong></a> (5%, similar to Trump’s) they’ll switch their vote. In 2016, undecided voters broke 2–1 for Trump at election day, but this year there are very few to break.</p><p>Labor Day is always an important milestone because it signals the moment casual voters start tuning into the election. It’s why the numbers become less volatile. There’s every reason to think that’s especially true this year, with a 48-year political veteran and former Vice President running against an incumbent. It’s hard to imagine a surprise large enough to change anything substantially. Perhaps Biden will become so lost during a debate voters will fear profound senility, but beyond that?</p><p>There’s little doubt Trump will become more desperate and more chaotic in the final weeks of the campaign. It’s hard to imagine him conceding defeat or admitting loss. Much about 2020 will create a sense of doubt about the election — on both sides. Those are matters for a different post. The basic contours of the election, however, are coming into focus, and they favor Biden.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4f4bd0279dc0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What if Trump Wins?]]></title>
            <link>https://jeffalworth.medium.com/what-if-trump-wins-fb5a0549dd96?source=rss-bdfb8411ac7c------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fb5a0549dd96</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[2020-presidential-race]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trump]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Alworth]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Aug 2020 17:47:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-31T17:47:01.067Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*K8TB47Tgl7u4H2BQZIUWgA.jpeg" /><figcaption>(Getty Images)</figcaption></figure><p>Until last week’s disturbing Republican Convention, I was able to place the specter of a second Trump term in the back of my mind. In the midst of a pandemic and open conflict over racial justice, it was literally unthinkable. And, thanks to those crises, it’s been easy to imagine a Biden presidency. The polls have been soothing. As it stands now, Biden holds an <a href="https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/polls/president-general/national/"><strong>8–9% lead</strong></a> in national polls, with leads from 5–8% in Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Florida, and Arizona. Trump has bled support in nearly every category of voter, including, thanks to his fine work on the pandemic, elders. Unemployment is over 11% and tens of millions are out of work; by election day, 200,000 people will be dead from the Coronavirus. While the election is still nine weeks off, those are tough headwinds for any candidate to overcome, especially one who hasn’t polled near 50% since he took office.</p><p>And yet. Trump filled out an inside straight to win in 2016, and with a few good breaks, such a repeat is plausible — indeed, Nate Silver gives him a <a href="https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/2020-election-forecast/"><strong>one-in-three</strong></a> chance of doing so. We all have protective membranes in our minds that filter out emotionally painful content, and I’ve been hiding behind mine, trying to take solace in those positive poll numbers. The Republican convention,offered a sneak preview of a second term, however, and it’s one filled with an even more aggressive assault on all the president’s enemies — and democracy itself. In the convention’s wake, it has been useful for me to think the unthinkable and prepare for this dark possibility.</p><h3>The Past as Prologue</h3><p>One of the weirdest features of the Trump era is the surprise people register when Trump does exactly what he said he’ll do and what he has always done. He is a man with abundant mental health issues revolving around his own narcissism and lack of empathy. He uses power, lies, and publicity to achieve his own narrow goals, always at the expense of others. He sees the world as zero-sum and feels victorious only at the failure, humiliation, or diminishment of others. He is cunning but not smart, unable to comprehend complex issues, think strategically, or plan for multiple outcomes. He uses the techniques of a bully, particularly bigotry and sexism, to divide and polarize.</p><p>He has displayed all of these propensities, floridly, for four years. He has demonstrated how he’ll govern both temperamentally and in terms of public policy. It is fairly easy to anticipate his future term because it will merely continue the pathologies, corruption, incompetence, and narcissism of the first term. They will all just continue to evolve and, thanks to a servile Republican Party unwilling to check him in the legislative or judicial branches they control, worsen. Below I look at these categorically, and although they seem very grim, I ask you to also note how they do form a continuation of current practices and are the most plausible assumptions.</p><h3>Domestic Policy</h3><p>The consequences will be profound in terms of policy. Trump has begun to move away from Congress as the vehicle for new laws and what he can’t jam through a (likely Democratic) House, he’ll enact through executive orders. Where executive orders won’t work, he’ll use other measures to destroy programs he doesn’t like. As the head of the federal government, he has great latitude to damage agencies. A list of possible actions could be very long, but here are a few that seem likely to certain:</p><ul><li>He’ll fatally cripple Obamacare, scale back the postal service, effectively eliminate the IRS, and end all government oversight.</li><li>He’ll end immigration except where it can be rigged to allow educated Europeans entry.</li><li>He will crush immigration coming across the Southern border, using visible acts of cruelty to fire up his base.</li><li>He will begin dismantling public education and target universities.</li><li>He will drastically scale back welfare programs.</li><li>He’ll end the few remaining protections for unions.</li><li>He’ll not just end environmental policies, but aggressively promote ones that pollute. He’ll get rid of many national parks, and open public lands to extractive industry.</li><li>He will amp up racist language and coddle local jurisdictions that pass laws targeting BIPOC citizens.</li><li>He’ll get one or two more Supreme Court seats. Many states will outlaw abortion. The courts will gut regulations restraining corporations.</li><li>His recent payroll tax deduction was an ominous sign that he wishes to target social security. No doubt Medicaid is on the list as well.</li><li>He’ll continue to use tariffs and trade laws to benefit favored industries and punish foreign enemies (who in many cases merely hamper his business interests rather than threaten the US).</li><li>Following the examples of the pandemic and Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico, he will mishandle crises, blame others, and use the chaos to target enemies.</li></ul><p>One could go on and on. The really scary thing is that most of these are destructive acts, which are far easier to implement than passing new legislation. In many cases, he can just direct agencies not to spend money — something the Court has already signaled they’re cool with.</p><h3>Destroying Democratic Structures</h3><p>The election happens at a particularly dangerous moment, as the US enters a census and redistricting year. The GOP has already hobbled the census, which will deliver an inaccurate count heavily favoring Republican states. The Supreme Court has actively ruled that political gerrymanders are legal, so Republicans will extract even more house seats from a diminishing minority. Redistricting will certainly marginalize BIPOC voters, but the courts won’t touch it unless the GOP is stupid enough to hold a press conference announcing their racist intentions.</p><p>States will pass creative laws to disenfranchise Democratic voters, many blatant in their intent, and the Court will allow them. The GOP will continue to use the propaganda of “election fraud” to further corrode people’s confidence in elections.</p><p>The Senate will continue to approve incompetent, radical, and partisan justices who will rule in favor of White minorities, Christians, and big business (those favored by the president, anyway).</p><h3>The Economy</h3><p>I wouldn’t be surprised if the economy rebounds from Covid and continues to perform decently. The US economy is incredibly large and strong and won’t collapse the second Trump is re-elected. Instead, Trump’s corruption will lead to a mini version of the post-Soviet land grab, with Trump-favored oligarchs reaping huge government windfalls. Income inequality will worsen, and poverty will return as a major issue, but the economy overall will list rather than capsize. Trump has many tools to support it, particularly if he ignores deficits.</p><h3>Cosplay Generalismo</h3><p>Trump has no real interest in foreign policy, and is antagonistic to diplomacy. Foreign policy is merely an avenue for advancing his own interests. Like everything else, those include a welter of private grievances, domestic policy goals, business interests, and personal affinities.</p><p>A review of his first term reveals these patterns. He befriended foreign despots partly because they’re familiar and friendly to him, partly because he has foreign deals cooking in their countries. He scrapped the Iran deal in a fit of pique against Obama. He is genuinely friendly with men like Putin and Modi.</p><p>He’s too lazy to be interested in war or realpolitik, but he <em>loves</em> military cosplay. Being surrounded by generals and tanks thrills him. The campaign’s current focus on “law and order” has nothing to do with rule-breaking and everything to do with authoritarian displays of state power. I would expect him to continue his ad hoc foreign actions while scaling up the visible elements of his military authority. No one will restrain him from sending parades through Washington or appearing with the head of every police union in the country.</p><p>It’s worth noting that his mere reelection will alienate the US from allies, damage that will take decades to undo. Europe has been waiting cautiously to see what happens in this election, and they will regroup without the US if he wins. They must. American international leadership will be over.</p><h3>Propaganda on Steroids</h3><p>Trump is embarrassingly bad at most things, but in one realm he has a kind of cunning genius. He understands a sucker. Throughout his life, he learned how to manipulate the media to give him exposure, and he’s used it to appeal to the base interests of his target audience (variously customers, media consumers, voters). Most politicians try to appeal to everyone and reflexively avoid alienating chunks of voters. As a grifter, Trump never tried to appeal to everyone — his tactics involved finding and exploiting those willing to buy snake oil. It happens that this also makes him a perfect, instinctive authoritarian.</p><p>His current campaign is a master class in Trump propaganda. Having allowed the country to slip into chaos, he is now running on a law-and-order campaign, arguing that if Biden is elected, the country will … slip into chaos. This argument is not meant to convince everyone or even most people. It is a racist, nationalist appeal to his base (the suckers), one focused on increasing their engagement. It is obvious, crude, and possibly effective.</p><p>He is now beginning to learn the lessons or authoritarianism as well. Before becoming president, he’d run his grifts as long as they were lucrative and then bail, usually amid a cloud of lawsuits. As President, he’s learned that lying and propaganda have several benefits. They undermine the authority of the free media. They create an environment in which facts are political, in which there is no objective authority, and this weakens his opposition. And hislies, particularly the obvious ones, become a demonstration of power because no one can stop him from telling them.</p><p>In a second term, we can expect Trump to undo the protections of speech and who may wield it. He will continue to attack the free press and more fully ignore those who don’t offer Pravda-like coverage. He and the judiciary will weaken media protection, going after individual reporters and media outlets. He will allow increasingly militant supporters to threaten and attack protesters while using “freedom of religion” and other excuses to carve out zones of free speech. It will all be a steady, slow erosion such that political enemies take risks speaking out, while supporters are given bigger and bigger platforms to spread Republican Convention-style lies and propaganda.</p><h3>GOP Servility</h3><p>The Constitution creates a system of checks, and I base all these predictions on the assumption that congressional and judicial Republicans will support Trump. While that is an assumption, it’s extremely difficult to imagine the counterfactual — especially after the display we witnessed at the RNC. Republicans understand that they are not popular. They recognize that they do not hold majority support and are becoming less popular.</p><p>Consider: both the Senate and Electoral College were designed to benefit small (and importantly, pro-slavery) states. That’s how the GOP has managed to “win” two of the past five elections despite receiving fewer votes, and why, despite having received more than 12 million more votes, Senate Democrats remain in the minority. Add the incredible gerrymander following the 2010 election, and the House is disproportionately GOP as well. Those elections mean the judiciary is also skewed; in the past fifty years, Republican presidents have appointed 11 of 15 justices to the Supreme Court. The last time a Democrat appointed a Chief Justice was 1946.</p><p>Trump offers thee GOP a way forward when all other roads lead to doom. Their survival depends on supporting Trump, suppressing the vote, and keeping judges in their pocket. They will take it.</p><h3>The Reaction</h3><p>It’s easy to predict what Trump will do. It’s more difficult to guess what the opposition does. In particular, what do these actors do?</p><ul><li>Blue states in the Northeast and along the West Coast, which are dominated by Dems. Will they begin a soft succession by ignoring Trump? How will the federal government react if they do?</li><li>Citizens, particularly in purple states dominated by Republican legislatures. In cases where a majority are Democrats and are ruled by minority Republicans, will they tolerate state support of Trump’s excesses? Will Americans take to the streets?</li><li>The media. They have been woefully unprepared for Trump, and have been instrumental in normalizing his behavior. Will they continue to do so?</li></ul><p>We have seen a number of cases where fragile democracies have slipped into authoritarian rule under men like Trump. We haven’t seen many cases where citizens managed to stop it, and so far, America’s performance hasn’t inspired confidence.</p><h3>2024</h3><p>Will the US have fair and free elections in 2024? Our status as a true democracy will be tested within four years: it’s that stark. If Trump is re-elected, he will, through instinct and intention, undermine the norms and structures that make democracy possible. In 2024, we’ll have an election. There’s a real question whether it will be like the 209 that have come before it, or something like the “elections” Vladimir Putin allows.</p><p>It seems unthinkable to suggest this, and yet given the players, the actions they’re taking <em>right now</em>, and the stakes, I can’t see how there’s any way to avoid it. If Trump is re-elected in 2020, American democracy will be on the line.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fb5a0549dd96" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>