<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jeff Harr on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jeff Harr on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jeffharr?source=rss-326f64b4301------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 23:20:49 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jeffharr/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Good Citizen’s Manifesto for 2017]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jeffharr/a-good-citizens-manifesto-for-2017-117562f8b9cf?source=rss-326f64b4301------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/117562f8b9cf</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politicians]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[goodness]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[values]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[citizenship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Harr]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 31 Aug 2017 22:48:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-08-31T22:48:06.422Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P4N8VRjy2oh6vypkkCc0Pg.jpeg" /><figcaption>From <a href="http://pixshark.com/good-citizenship-for-kids.htm">Pixshark</a></figcaption></figure><p>In today’s America, the cause of good citizenship is under attack from all sides — the ghosts of our long-defeated enemies have been resurrected, and logic, science, and evidential reasoning are smeared every day. As our partially apathetic and partially complicit citizenry go about their lives, the vast majority are not engaged with the political process at all; many of them can’t name their elected officials, explain the government’s checks and balances system we all learn in 4th grade civics class, or think critically about problem solving.</p><p>This climate makes every simple problem into a partisan reality TV drama with binary sides — those who control the media on both sides control the narratives. Each side becomes more isolated and vocal as the television channels they watch rake in the cash from their fear and anxiety. We lose the ability to come together as a community to hash out our problems — it’s much easier to sit at home in our recliners and yell into the echo chamber of our favorite talk show host, without the ability or insight to separate the truth from the vision that the massive international conglomerates that own our media want to push.</p><p>Families are destroyed as we lose the basic ability to communicate with one another — somehow distilling even our loved ones into caricatures of evil and deceit, or by contrast completely ignoring the issues we all face and through our inaction allowing the gap to widen. As we fight with each other in our homes and on our social media platforms, we feed into both the profits and the drama of those who have the reach to project their perspectives and magnify them with money or power. America in 2017 is a country of cliques: the concerned but lazy “pop-politics” left, the terrified/reactionary/anti-intellectual right, the extremist/racist/violent heavily armed alt-right, the contrarian groupthink libertarians, the cowards who “aren’t into politics”, the downtrodden populists, the antifascists, etcetera, etcetera. The way forward — for all of us — is to step back away from our identity politics and start again from a baseline we should all share: good citizenship.</p><p>When I typed “how to be a good citizen” into google, the first result that came up (for me) is a link to <a href="http://sanchezclass.com/goodcitizen.htm">Ms. Sanchez’s 4th grade class website</a>. From what I can tell, Ms. Sanchez is an elementary school teacher from Miami, Florida who authors a blog and maintains a website to use as teaching aids in the classroom. I don’t know Ms. Sanchez, but I didn’t look any further for search results. I think her page on citizenship is a great place to start when trying to answer the question of how we can all be good citizens outside of the trap of identity politics. Here are her ten points:</p><ol><li>Volunteer to be active in your community.</li><li>Be honest and trustworthy.</li><li>Follow rules and laws.</li><li>Respect the rights of others.</li><li>Be informed about the world around you.</li><li>Respect the property of others.</li><li>Be compassionate.</li><li>Take responsibility for your actions.</li><li>Be a good neighbor.</li><li>Protect the environment.</li></ol><p>You’ll notice that very few if any of these straddle partisan lines (I suppose not many 4th graders are partisan, but that’s beside the point). This makes sense: we all have some idea of what being a good person is about, these ideas just don’t often make it into our political positions and the actions we take. Let’s go point by point, and look at the world we’re in today.</p><ol><li><strong>Volunteer to be active in your community</strong></li></ol><p>There are lots of ways to contribute to the community you live in that are apolitical — volunteering, going to community events, picking up litter, attending city/town meetings. The vast majority of Americans today (myself included to some degree) don’t participate in their local areas and it’s a shame that we’ve lost the ability to connect with our neighbors. Last century this function was filled by churches, civil defense organizations, rotary/lions/veterans clubs, historical societies, elderly care organizations, and other groups that have not survived, been drastically reduced in size and influence, or have been replaced by some sort of internet-based interaction in the 21st century. With this transition we lost something — occasions to meet, get to know, and humanize those around us with whom we coexist on a daily basis. I interpret this first item not just strictly as volunteering for a cause, though that certainly is a great help to society and effective at putting your neighbors in context, but also as any act of participation in your neighbors and colleagues’ lives. Let’s rephrase this one to <strong>“Participate in, strive to understand, and engage with the community where you live and work.”</strong></p><p>2. <strong>Be honest and trustworthy.</strong></p><p>This is another item that clearly should be apolitical — but is less universally accepted than one would expect in 2017. We have managed to elect a president whom a vast majority of Americans regardless of politics will concede is explicitly untrustworthy, and the consequences for our elected officials, business leaders, and celebrities lying to our faces are non-existent or worse. We cannot assume in this day and age that the people we choose to lead us are acting in good faith when CEOs of companies that defraud and fail the American people are slapped on the wrist and given huge golden parachutes, or when white collar criminals do a few months in resort jail, or when even the most universally reviled among us are pardoned or defended in the media.</p><blockquote><strong>Good faith</strong> (<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Latin_language">Latin</a>: <em>bona fides</em>), in human interactions, is a sincere intention to be fair, open, and honest, regardless of the outcome of the interaction. — Wikipedia</blockquote><p>It should be obvious to us that in our personal lives lying, cheating, theft, and subterfuge risk our livelihoods and that any gains from those acts come from taking advantage of those who are more trustworthy — I think this is true for society as well. Let’s rephrase this one as <strong>“Always act in good faith, whether at home or in society — and expect your leaders to do the same.”</strong></p><p>3. <strong>Follow rules and laws.</strong></p><p>We’re a nation of laws — just by reading the history of the American Revolution and our founding documents one can tell that the very kernel of our foundation comes from a desire for fair treatment, representation, and taxation under an (ideally) equal code of law. However, in 2017, certain among us have decided to disregard the law and rules en masse — whether through partisanship, ignorance, or malicious intent. Though there are plenty of good reasons to oppose a law that isn’t implemented as a mutually agreed upon societal contract between the people and the legislature, we’re dealing with a more fundamental problem in this point. Rampant hypocrisy flows through our nation — with some claiming it’s okay to break a law/rule as long as you’re a member of the right party, while vilifying those who break the very same law who are members of the opposition. The same goes for race, sexual orientation, gender — there’s a huge amount of disregard for laws when politically expedient or when serving the cause of identity politics.</p><p>One of the major issues with this situation is that when all the sides start ignoring the rules, there’s no exchange of ideas, no give and take, no incentive to change and it becomes easy to tar an entire group with the epithet of “liars” as a way to avoid confronting the root cause of problems. The outbreak of “fake news” and “lugenpresse” as a rallying cry has become so common as to be meaningless for both the people yelling it and those it is being yelled at — everyone assumes only their own sources of information are true and it becomes easier to write off uncomfortable observations as fake than to actually do the mental and emotional work of confronting them and growing from the experience. We’re in a world where the president can lie, on television, directly to the faces of the citizenry and a huge section of the population accepts that as normal, either granting him slavish acceptance of anything he says or writing off his lies as “what politicans do.”</p><p>Ideally, a nation of rules and laws should have consequences for breaking them and that’s certainly how our founders envisioned it, in order to prevent the worst tendencies of authoritarianism from taking root. We should all be able to agree that lying, cheating, and theft should have consequences — especially for those in power. There of course are scenarios in which laws are passed not in good faith, or they are applied unfairly, and I don’t mean for this point to be a referendum on laws per se. However, when our leaders flaunt the very restrictions put on them by the people’s will in order to consolidate power, it clearly contravenes the spirit of those controls — and though it only takes one person to break the law, it takes a whole system and society in agreement to respond. Let’s rephrase this point to <strong>“Value the truth in yourself and others, fight and prosecute dishonesty, and combat breaches of the social contract.”</strong></p><p>4. <strong>Respect the rights of others.</strong></p><p>Yet another point that I hope would be obvious — but we seem to be in the middle of a war of rights, where groups inside our country champion all kinds of opinions about the rights of other groups. This, I believe, would confound the founding fathers who envisioned this country as a place where the people of the world could come to live without persecution, in peace and prosperity. Somehow in 2017 race, gender, sexuality, religion, culture, citizenship, and creed have all become identifiers which are socially acceptable for some to base their opposition of rights upon. Entire movements and groups exist for the sole purpose of reducing, stripping, and combating the rights of other human beings who identify differently — this is a sad state of affairs. America is supposed to be a place where we can all raise ourselves up together, with the sacred knowledge that no matter how much we may disagree, we all have our rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. In 2017, that’s no longer the case — the most extreme among us have their voices multiplied and empowered (sometimes by foreign actors who would love to see our country fail) and it has become largely acceptable in our society to denigrate, devalue, and oppose the rights of others out of fear, ignorance, prejudice, or cowardice. This isn’t the way it should be — let’s rephrase this bullet to <strong>“Respect and defend the freedom of those who are different, both to peacefully exist and to pursue happiness.”</strong></p><p>5. <strong>Be informed about the world around you.</strong></p><p>I could write much more than a few paragraphs on this topic alone — this point strikes at the very heart of anti-intellectualism and the American tradition of distrusting and oppressing educators, scientists, and researchers as “eggheads” and “nerds”. There’s a Pulitzer prize winning book I recommend we all read called “Anti-Intellectualism in American Life”, written by Richard Hofstedter in the 1960s. In it, he explains how our culture is wrapped up in the fabric of opposing the perceived elitism and superiority complex of the British as we gained our independence — unfortunately we never lost the tinge of that from our shared consciousness. It’s what causes some groups among us to dispute the scientific method, evidential reasoning, and logic itself. It’s what causes some to politicize education and claim that just by acquiring knowledge someone has taken a position. It’s what makes the uneducated among us simultaneously envious of the opportunities more educated people have had to learn while also disputing that very education as somehow elitist or “book smart but not street smart.” To me, a lack of education on the way the world works is one of the biggest root causes of the conflicts we see playing out today — most Americans can’t name their elected officials, explain how our political system works, explain our country’s history, point out most foreign countries on a map, tell the difference between major religions, or accurately compare fascism to communism. We almost celebrate our ignorance — all you have to do is watch a few hours of “All-American” pop entertainment to hear intelligence both vilified and devalued. The problems with this should be obvious — we have created a world in which we are largely led and influenced by those who are explicitly anti-intelligence. “Facts” have become something to dispute, not accept — and when opposition to science happens, it doesn’t obey the same rules that science does. People just “feel” like the facts are wrong, and their anecdotal experiences reign supreme over any kind of repeatable, testable, position that one could consider a true opposition. Until our citizenry understands how productive debate, counter arguments, and logical problem solving work we won’t be able to reach outcomes that are effective and sustainable, so let’s rephrase this one to: <strong>“Understand how the world works, value the pursuit of knowledge, and only take positions you can logically defend.”</strong></p><p>6. <strong>Respect the property of others</strong></p><p>I think we can all agree vandalism, looting, and property destruction don’t advance any of our causes and contribute to the rift between us. What this bullet might include is a respect for those with less property than you and a duty to understand your own privileges and luck that have gotten you to where you are in life. Not to discount hard work, of course, but all societies struggle with systemic advantages and disadvantages — for example, the businessman who attributes his success solely to his own efforts and fails to appreciate the millions of dollars in loans their successful father gave them when they were starting out, while castigating a less successful person for “not working hard enough”, without any of the context it would require to come to that conclusion. If we respected each other’s property and work, we’d have a better understanding of how our society is arrayed to let some benefit more easily than others. Let’s rephrase this one as well: <strong>“Respect property, as well as recognizing the advantages you may have had over others.”</strong></p><p>7. <strong>Be compassionate.</strong></p><p>This nation’s history is littered with examples of American compassion — the first responders and the city residents of New York after September 11th, but also sheltering disaster victims, our large volume of charitable contributions, our hospitality to visitors, the list could go on. It’s an essential part of our culture to be warm, welcoming, and supportive to those who rely on us for help. We also traditionally oppose the discompassionate regimes of foreign powers — combating genocide, slaughter, religious persecution and other forms of hate when possible. Why is it then, in 2017, so little compassion is directed at our fellow citizens? On all sides there are advocates for seeing other groups of Americans as the enemy, and taking away even that fundamental promise of compassion from them en masse. Somewhere along the way we forgot what made this country the land of opportunity and freedom — today we have to deal with government officials disputing the words engraved on the Statue of Liberty. At what point does the citizenry realize that we’ve lost the thread of American compassion? Even in simple discussions on policy, we’ve degenerated into insult-throwing dehumanizing attacks instead of working together to empathize and compromise and move the country forward. It’s such a simple concept, and I think it’s captured well by the existing language, but I’ll add a bit: <strong>“Be compassionate, helpful, and empathetic to all human beings.”</strong></p><p>8. <strong>Take responsibility for your actions.</strong></p><p>This item is a key pillar of adulthood, let alone citizenship. Those of us who have spouses, children, jobs, bills — we all have to be responsible for the actions we take in life. The current threat to our ability to be responsible comes in many forms, but one of the most damaging is “whataboutism” — or the tendency to respond to an accusation not with a defense of your actions, but with a “what about” directed at the perceived other side. By way of an example, a common current response to the negative actions of one party’s candidate or politician is “what about what their opponent did?” This serves only to distract from the negative action — not to address it. When you refocus the conversation on the other side, you’re shirking your responsibility to process, contemplate, and properly react to your own actions (or those of your party). When we continually refocus the problem on the “other side” we don’t make any progress holding each other to the standards the country deserves, we just slowly spiral down into a lower and lower bar of success and acceptability. Part of being a responsible adult is to understand the consequences of your actions — not justifying them by pointing out that other people might do those actions too. Let’s call this one <strong>“Take ownership of the consequences of your action or inaction, and be responsible for holding yourself to acceptable standards before criticizing others.”</strong></p><p>9.<strong> Be a good neighbor.</strong></p><p>This point ties into #1 and #4 — if you’re active in your community, and respectful of the rights of others, you’ll have a much better chance of being a good neighbor. What I think this one means in 2017, in a world that is increasingly interconnected via technology and the speed of travel, is that we need to extend the idea of whom we consider to be our neighbors. The reason some states are shaped the way they are is sometimes to protect particular resources or waterways that the state wanted to make sure they had a perpetual claim to — but by now, we all share and use the resources in our country together to achieve shared goals and move society forward. We’ve gone from a highly locally oriented society to a more homogenous and national society where people are constantly in flux, new ones are always arriving, and people are increasingly involved in and affected by issues well outside of their locality. What does it mean to be a good neighbor in an interconnected world? It means treating everyone as if they lived next door to you, with all the compromises and challenges that come with that. When there are wildfires in California, people from all over shelter those who have lost their homes — when blizzards take out electricity in the northeast, citizens everywhere donate for clean water supplies for those affected. The fact is, we’re all neighbors — especially online. The implication of this is that being a good neighbor is both harder and easier in 2017, I think we can sum it up as <strong>“Conduct yourself in a neighborly fashion no matter where someone happens to live — we’re all in this together.”</strong></p><p>10. <strong>Protect the environment.</strong></p><p>Pictures of the smog in Beijing were widely circulated during the Olympics held there a few years ago —we should agree that nobody wants to live in a smog filled polluted city. We’ve also made huge progress on less currently pressing environmental issues — banning CFCs drastically reduced acid rain, and the Adirondack mountains in New York state are a great example of an area that has been able to recover. Part of our American traditions are built around access to public land, preservation of nature, responsible hunting and fishing, and enjoyment of the great outdoors. None of these things are possible without stewardship of the environment — if it wasn’t for our acts of preservation we wouldn’t have any living Buffalo, waterfowl (we used to have guns that could kill hundreds of ducks at a time — eventually banned after pressure from citizen hunters who noticed bird populations diving to near zero), or many other of our nation’s most revered and wonderful locations, which could have been mined in an age when less controls were in place. We have centuries of science behind our understanding of the human role in the macro environment and it’s the consensus of the people we trust to inform us that we have responsibilities to our environment. Let’s say <strong>“Ensure responsible stewardship of our land, water, and air and that the environment has a voice in deliberations that affect it.”</strong></p><p>So now let’s recap our manifesto, as we’ve modified it:</p><ol><li>Participate in, strive to understand, and engage with the community where you live and work.</li><li>Always act in good faith, whether at home or in society — and expect your leaders to do the same.</li><li>Value the truth in yourself and others, fight and prosecute dishonesty, and combat breaches of the social contract.</li><li>Respect and defend the freedom of those who are different, both to peacefully exist and to pursue happiness.</li><li>Understand how the world works, value the pursuit of knowledge, and only take positions you can logically defend.</li><li>Respect property, as well as the recognizing the advantages you may have had over others.</li><li>Be compassionate, helpful, and empathetic to all human beings.</li><li>Take ownership of the consequences of your action or inaction, and be responsible for holding yourself to acceptable standards before criticizing others.</li><li>Conduct yourself in a neighborly fashion no matter where someone happens to live — we’re all in this together.</li><li>Ensure responsible stewardship of our land, water, and air and that the environment has a voice in deliberations that affect it.</li></ol><p>You’d be hard pressed to define any of these values as explicitly partisan — it’s also my feeling that they encapsulate a large portion of what it means to be a good citizen, a good American, and a good human being. Very little of our current political discourse adheres to these simple values, which our children learn at a young age in school, which echo those of most religions, and which are timeless in their appropriateness. So then, if we’ve done a good job defining them, how does this affect our politics and our society today? What would adherence look like, or change about the world? How many of our leaders, whether governmental, business, religious, or cultural can you name that would pass these basic tests of conduct? And what does it say about the state of things in 2017 that there are so few?</p><p>Can we hold ourselves to a higher standard? Can we be good citizens? I can’t answer that for you, but this list is a good place to start. Applying this manifesto to your judgment of your elected officials, your votes, your action in society will help change the status quo, the complicit laziness of accepting things the way they are, and the tendency of those in power to be corrupted and seek to maintain power by driving our public discourse away from these simple values.</p><p>I recommend vigilance in defense of these ten themes: don’t settle for less. If we can’t agree on what it means to be a good citizen, then maybe we’re truly lost and this country can’t recover. I don’t believe that’s the case, and I have the utmost faith and confidence that if we try, we can overcome the war in the minds, hearts, and streets of these United States we all love.</p><p>Thanks to <a href="http://www.sanchezclass.com/home.htm">Ms. Sanchez</a> for her unwitting contribution!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=117562f8b9cf" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>