<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jeff Witt on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jeff Witt on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jeffwitt?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Mon, 16 Nov 2026 06:39:41 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jeffwitt/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Warpath offers Insights into why Lilith is Killing it!]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/warpath-offers-insights-into-why-lilith-is-killing-it-a114f1190cb1?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a114f1190cb1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 02 Apr 2021 16:47:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-02T16:47:16.574Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>One of the hardest things for game developers to do when analyzing a hit game is to figure out what works well for the hit game and what doesn’t. Game companies will typically be tight-lipped on the secret sauce to their game’s success, so game designers like myself will need to resort to educated guesses at best as to why a game succeeds.</p><p>So when a Hit-Making Game Developer launches a game that takes influences from their previous games, it creates a golden opportunity to get insight into what the Developer believes has and has not worked in their previous games. Enter Warpath. At first glance, Warpath looks like a clone of Rise of Kingdoms but with a modern warfare setting. But pretty early in the game you will begin to see designs heavily influenced by AFK Arena. Warpath would not be the first 4x game to incorporate RPG Systems (look at Lords Mobile). However, it is the first game that I can recall that has utilized designs from the Developer’s previous games but in a whole different genre. Because of this, Warpath shows us what Lilith believes to be working from both Rise of Kingdoms and AFK Arena.</p><p>In this Article i’ll go over some designs in Warpath that were taken from AFK Arena. In the future I’ll do the same for Warpath and Rise of Kingdoms.</p><h3>Upgrading a Unit’s Level</h3><p>Upgrading Army Units is not a new thing in 4x Games. What is particularly interesting in Warpath though is both the number of Levels, number of currencies, and leveling structure used in leveling Army Units.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/915/0*D5qlB-uLy9f-7xWH" /></figure><p>Hero Leveling in AFK Arena uses Hero XP and soft currency to Level up Heroes normally. But at certain level thresholds (20, 40, 60, etc.), the game requires Hero Essence in addition to Hero XP and soft currency to level up. Now Hero XP is pretty common in AFK Arena, but Hero Essence is much harder to come by. Thus, when players hit those thresholds, they are tempted to spend to buy the Hero Essence necessary to continue leveling the Hero.</p><p>Warpath follows a very similar leveling structure. They require only Unit XP (very common) to level a Unit except for when the Unit is at a level that is a multiple of 10 (10, 20, 30). At those levels, the Unit needs both Unit XP and a much rarer Bullet Currency to level up to 11. After that, leveling will continue to only need Unit XP until the next multiple of 10. The design is too close to AFK Arena to not be deliberate. The fact that Lilith not only used the same design, but also compressed the level thresholds to every 10 levels (instead of 20 levels in AFK Arena) suggests that this leveling structure works very well for their monetization. Their decision to also require research for certain thresholds suggests that requiring players to engage with research to upgrade their units further should also work.</p><h3>Unit Assembly</h3><p>The Research Center in Warpath doubles as a building used for “assembling” units. When the Player selects an Army Unit to be assembled, they must also select Fodder Army units to be crafted into the selected Unit. After the assembly is complete, the selected Army Unit has increased their star rating by part of a star and their stats jump quite a bit.</p><p>The funny thing about this is that some Assemblies require <strong>the exact same Army Unit</strong> as the selected Army Unit, while other Assemblies require <strong>two Army Units of the same tier and type</strong> as the selected Army Unit. Sound familiar?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/984/0*T0oecau-XFcxQNv4" /></figure><p>The Army Unit Assembly system sounds just like the Ascension system in AFK Arena. There are some minor differences — whereas AFK Arena relies on Rarity as the upgradable system through Ascension, Warpath upgrades Tier (star). The fact that Warpath breaks stars into multiple pieces for the purposes of expanding the depth of Army Unit Assemblies shows that adding this depth is just as important in Warpath as it was in AFK Arena.</p><p>Hero Ascension is the crux of AFK Arena’s Hero Depth. So having that depth (even in star form) shows that Lilith highly values Hero depth and wanted to make sure that Warpath had it in a way where Rise of Kingdom’s Hero depth was lacking. It also ties into Warpath’s decision to make Army Units more like Heroes than Troops.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/773/0*4DbvquVnkqPFDjET" /></figure><p>Players control 5 Army Units in combat, similar to the 5 Heroes Players use in AFK Arena. Going with Heroes versus the traditional Troop Model from Rise of Kingdoms suggests that Lilith thinks they can make up for any lost Monetization from Troops with Hero systems and depth.</p><h3>Idle Rewards</h3><p>In Rise of Kingdoms, Lilith had daily rewards that the Player could collect that were based on how far along the Player was in the campaign. They also had a store that allowed you to purchase things with currency earned through the daily campaign rewards. AFK Arena had none of that, just the idle rewards that helped define that type of RPG.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/925/0*sfNLmaT6OlYJEcrS" /></figure><p>Warpath combines AFK Arena’s Idle Rewards with Rise of Kingdom’s Campaign Store. Again, reading the tea leaves you can see that both the Idle Rewards of AFK Arena and the Campaign Store of Rise of Kingdoms were important to Lilith when making Warpath. If Idle Rewards weren’t important but the Campaign Store was, Lilith would have just used the Rise of Kingdoms Daily Rewards. If Idle Rewards were important but the Campaign store didn’t move the needle, Lilith would have just used the Idle Rewards. The deliberate changing of Daily rewards to Idle Rewards while keeping the Campaign store is informative of how Lilith viewed the importance of those designs.</p><p>Idle Rewards generally are better than a Daily Reward system in that they reward Players who come back multiple times a day. As we generally want players to engage with the game over multiple sessions a day, having a large chunk of Army Unit XP to come back to so that you can make your Army Units stronger before fighting again is the better design.</p><h3>Is there More?</h3><p>I’m still fairly early in the Warpath experience so there may be more influences from AFK Arena that I haven’t found. But I am honestly very excited by what I see so far. AFK Arena’s designs solved a lot of problems that other F2P RPGs faced, from Hero depth to session length. Seeing that Lilith incorporated some of the Hero Depth features into a 4x game is fascinating. At the same time, AFK Arena struggled with Elder game, guild-based events. Rise of Kingdoms excels in their alliance-based activity, which definitely has been retained in Warpath. Warpath just went live a few weeks ago, but I expect stellar performance from it at the minimum, and I will look forward to what else they put into the game.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a114f1190cb1" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/warpath-offers-insights-into-why-lilith-is-killing-it-a114f1190cb1">Warpath offers Insights into why Lilith is Killing it!</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What Makes a Feature a Monetization Feature?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/what-makes-a-feature-a-monetization-feature-5e78d295f0d9?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e78d295f0d9</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Mar 2021 19:07:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-04T19:07:59.115Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*GIFiNBZLSQvF41Bs" /></figure><p>One of the biggest misconceptions about the Battle Pass as a feature is that it is a monetization feature. While the Battle Pass does monetize, it is not designed to monetize on a per player basis, and will only result in large revenues through High-DAU games. Small developers who look to these larger audience games for inspiration will be dismayed when they fail to generate enough revenue for their studios.</p><p>But this begs the question: What is a Monetization Feature? In this article I will go over some simple signs to look for when assessing the monetizable impact of a game feature. Some of these will be more clear-cut than others.</p><h3>#1: Content Sold Directly to the Player</h3><p>This is pretty easy to detect. In general, any new content added to the store or sales is meant to boost Monetization. Just examine whether the Developer populated sales or the Store with the new content.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ISjbkDLF5CSL5Utl" /></figure><p>For example, when Summoners War added Gemstones and Grindstones, they began putting them in select sales. Players who now need this new content will be incentivized to purchase those sames. Clearly Gemstones and Grindstones were something that was meant to boost Monetization.</p><h3>#2: Content Includes New Ways to Spend</h3><p>Content or Features that include a new way for Players to spend are generally designed to boost Monetization. The reasoning is that if the Content was designed for Retention, the Developer wouldn’t put barriers such as currency or item costs in the way of Players engaging in the content.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*CwLlZwPCwGRpvyUk" /></figure><p>The Forge in RAID: Shadow Legends is a good example of a Feature being meant for monetization. Needing materials and soft currency to use a Feature are hallmarks of something designed to monetize. The more gating the input costs are, the more likely the Feature or Content was designed for spend.</p><p>Unlike #1, there are a few caveats here:</p><ol><li><strong>Preventing Players from Running out of Content</strong>: Content added to prevent Players from having nothing to do is generally not done for Monetization. Running out of content can cause a collapse in player monetization. So even if there are ways for new content to monetize (think energy required to do battles in an RPG, for example), the Developer is not focusing on Monetization when adding that content.</li><li><strong>Aggressiveness in costing Matters: </strong>If Content or a Feature require a nominal cost for Players to engage, then it probably isn’t about Monetization. While there is no hard and fast rule as to how aggressive a feature should be with costs in order to be considered a Monetization feature, I would expect Players to really feel the pinch if they are being pushed to spend more.</li></ol><h3>#3: Content Forces Players to engage in existing Monetization Content</h3><p>This aspect of Monetization is a little more nuanced than the other two. In general, we should assume that a Player won’t spend unless they feel like they have to. This means that a Player must objectively feel pushed or compelled to spend by content in order for that content to affect monetization. If a Player does not feel objectively compelled or pushed to spend by content or a feature, then that implicitly means the content is not made to push monetization.</p><p>Here are three examples of this principle in effect:</p><ol><li><strong>Summoners War adds Levels 11 and 12 for Dungeon Bosses</strong></li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XUBLQ24MjVXF-15e" /></figure><p>When Summoners War first launched, it launched with 10 Levels of Bosses. At some point they added Levels 11 and 12. These new boss levels didn’t drop anything new, but rather just had higher drop rates for higher rarity and star runes.</p><p>While spending would help a player with getting to Giant Boss Level 12, the only thing they would get was increased efficiency in farming Runes. Efficiency is a great motivator for some things like Events, but for core game farming, efficiency doesn’t really motivate Players to spend, especially if the cost to farm is low.</p><p>So were Giant Boss Levels 11 and 12 added to boost Monetization? Probably not. They were added to boost engagement and get high end players something to work towards.</p><p><strong>2. Empire &amp; Puzzles has element-focused Titans</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/220/0*evaOSkqUxg9dSG4k" /></figure><p>Somewhat more effective is content that strongly encourages players to use specific things. Anything that gives bonuses for using specific Heroes of Equipment can be said to be ‘nudging” the player towards spending. Players who really want to do well with the content might spend to do so, but that requires that the player 1) need to spend to succeed; and 2) care enough to want to succeed with the content.</p><p>Are Titans in Empire &amp; Puzzles more effective than Giant Boss Levels 11 and 12 in Summoners War at improving Monetization? Yes. But the effectiveness is limited by whether the player feels like they <strong>need</strong> to spend to succeed.</p><p><strong>3. Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes and the Yoda Event</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*epdq1qXZhG_loYD4" /></figure><p>When I think about content that forces Players to monetize, the first thing that comes to mind is the Yoda Event in Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes. The idea is pretty simple: you have 7 Battles, each with their own restrictions:</p><p>Battle 1: Use 5 Jedis of 1 Star or Higher</p><p>Battle 2: Use 5 Jedis of 2 Stars or Higher</p><p>Battle 3: Use 5 Jedis of 3 Stars or Higher</p><p>Battle 4: Use 5 Jedis of 4 Star or Higher</p><p>Battle 5: Use 5 Jedis of 5 Star or Higher</p><p>Battle 6: Use 5 Jedis of 6 Star or Higher</p><p>Battle 7: Use 5 Jedis of 7 Star</p><p>Each time a Player wins one of the Battles, they get Yoda Shards. At some point, unless the Player has 5 Jedies of 5–7 Stars, they cannot proceed. They have to either farm for Jedi Hero Shards or buy them outright. The Player is stuck unless they spend. This is the clearest example of something that was meant to push monetization — the Player feels the need to monetize because they have no other choice or option.</p><p>Again, just because content pushes a player to monetize, how aggressive that push is determines whether the content is monetization-based or not.</p><h3>Low DAU Games Need Monetization Features</h3><p>As a Game Developer, looking for ways to push players to monetize isn’t always fun. You build a game for people to enjoy, and monetization in most cases ends up trying to limit the player experience in some way in order to get them to spend. If you are lucky enough to produce a viral hit, getting millions of DAU in the process, then you don’t have to rely on Monetization features to succeed (or at least you don’t need to be as aggressive with them). But most developers won’t be able to get there. When in doubt, create features for Monetization and then relax them if you find that keeping players is more important than monetizing them.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e78d295f0d9" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/what-makes-a-feature-a-monetization-feature-5e78d295f0d9">What Makes a Feature a Monetization Feature?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Tale of Two Games: How Clash Royale and AFK Arena handled their Monetization Differently]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/a-tale-of-two-games-how-clash-royale-and-afk-arena-handled-their-monetization-differently-8f58a05d9985?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8f58a05d9985</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 25 Feb 2021 23:26:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-25T23:52:56.881Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There has been a lot of discussion lately about the declining performance of Supercell generally and Clash Royale in particular. While there may be many factors that are contributing to Clash Royale’s decline, most agree that Monetization is one of those factors. And yet Clash Royale has done very little to try and increase the amount of things they can monetize off of over the years, even in the face of declining revenue.</p><p>There has also been some talk about the odd choice of features that AFK Arena has recently introduced (Match-3 in an Idle RPG?). While it is hard to be absolutely sure as to why AFK Arena chose to implement this, I believe the decision to add a Match-3 in AFK Arena relates to Clash Royale’s decision not to add new monetizable content. Both Games are focusing on retaining players and increasing engagement. This article takes a look at their different approaches to this and why there is such a large difference in performance from the same approach.</p><h4>Clash Royale Started Out from a Position of Strength</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/810/0*5SVgHtZJ0NZhf8tr" /></figure><p>When Clash Royale first hit the scene, it was an instant hit. Millions of Players flocked to the game, and Clash Royale’s rather shallow Metasystems earned Supercell a lot of money. During the first two years, Supercell mainly focused on releasing new Cards, new Arenas, and new Gameplay Systems. None of it was aimed at increasing monetization, but given that their massive player base was monetizing at an adequate rate, Supercell decided that focusing on things that would keep the player base engaged and retained was the right strategy. And indeed it was for the first few years.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*RCitS2DaDGnUrLpt" /></figure><p>For Clash Royale, releasing New Cards was an effective way for them to sustain their monetization. New cards made the drop rates of cards the Players wanted lower. Thus, releasing new cards required players to open more chests overall. They weren’t meant for Monetization, as Players weren’t pushed or forced to acquire the new cards. But extending the amount of chests Players had to open to optimize their decks means that Players would continue to monetize at their current rate. Therefore, Supercell mainly focused on new gameplay modes and systems to keep their players engaged.</p><p>Why this strategy? Wasn’t Supercell leaving money on the table by not more aggressively pushing monetization? The truth of the matter is that once a company makes a certain amount of money, it becomes more imperative to sustain that monetization rather than try to increase it even further. In Supercell’s case, keeping players in the game and spending as they had been would continue to sustain Clash Royale’s initial success. The alternative would be to try and introduce new systems meant for monetization, and that might turn off the player base.</p><h4>Supercell Took the Wrong Actions when Monetization Started to Decline</h4><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/903/0*aGAxuFUqFH8SFVDl" /></figure><p>Yet, slowly over time as Clash Royale’s monetization began to weaken, Supercell began deprecating the content through certain monetization tools such as Legendary Chests or Fortune Chests.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7VAj-jIwvAXjAZle" /></figure><p>Deprecating Content creates new monetization opportunities for lesser spenders, and so employing these more effective monetization tools let Clash Royale sustain their Monetization for longer than they should have. The downside is that these effective tools let spenders blow through content faster. Between better monetization tools and fewer new card releases, Clash Royale quickly began to run out of content that monetized. Their disastrous implementation of an overly-lucrative Battle Pass didn’t help.</p><p>The fact is that focusing on Retention on a Live Game works when your Monetization is good. But when it is not, focusing on Retention not only will fail to solve the problem of declining revenues, it will also squander opportunities to add more monetizable content to the game.</p><h4>AFK Arena spent Time Solidifying their Monetization Strategy</h4><p>In many ways, AFK Arena had the opposite strategy as Clash Royale. Launching to decent revenue, AFK Arena focused early new features on extensions of monetizable content (like Mythic Equipment Tiers), Gameplay Systems that pushed players to optimize Heroes (like Peaks of Time and Voyage of Wonder), and more subscriptions (found in the Noble Society).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*F5--j_KRAWr1s1Fu" /></figure><h4>Then AFK Arena Shifted Focus to Retention/Engagement</h4><p>Once they hit their stride, AFK Arena shifted to retaining their players. They knew that as long as Players continued to play and kept getting met with stat checks, they would continue their spending patterns. Here are some examples of odd content that has little or nothing to do with Player progression or spend:</p><p><strong>War of Wits:</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/898/0*ptgDIEpJrE_brY8n" /></figure><p>This is basically a draft-style PvP competition where each player takes turns picking from a pool of cards. After all the turns to pick cards are finished, the players each play their best parties and the player who wins gets points for the leaderboard for that gameplay mode.</p><p><strong>Forest Mania:</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/897/0*EOA_YrMWq5t-dZSW" /></figure><p>Basically a match-3 built into AFK Arena with no costs. Seems like a way for some players to kill time and get some rewards?</p><p>This is not to say that AFK Arena isn’t pushing monetization at all. But even looking at content they add that can boost Monetization, it is implemented in a non-aggressive way:</p><p><strong>Trial of the Gods</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/898/0*JLLAk3V1-1Anf12N" /></figure><p>Trial of the Gods is a gameplay mode where players can choose debuffs to build up their point score. If they complete the adventure with all the debuffs they selected, they’ll get a reward. Rewards are based for the amount of debuff points they select. While this does give players constant stat checks, there is no pressure for the Player to complete it now. They can occasionally come back to the Gameplay and make progress as they get stronger at their own pacing.</p><p><strong>Hero Growth Bundles</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*a1Lt98tPdfKHz45a" /></figure><p>Even clear monetization features like Hero Growth Bundles, where Players unlock both free rewards and sales by Tiering up a specific Hero aren’t aggressively utilized in AFK Arena. The Bundle is buried deep within the Merchants UI (Merchants &gt; Heroic Ship). A feature like this would have definitely been more aggressively pushed in other RPGs like RAID: Shadow Legends. But because AFK Arena is in a good place with Monetization, they don’t feel the need to aggressively utilize all their Monetization Tools. They’d rather keep players happy, and let spenders of different strengths spend in ways that suits their play-style.</p><h3>Monetization and Retention are Two Sides of the Same Coin</h3><p>In F2P Games, it is a fallacy to completely divorce Monetization from Retention. If Monetization improves and Retention holds steady, the Game Developer is making more money. If Monetization stays the same but Retention goes up, the Game Developer is making more money. While Developers would ideally like to focus on both Monetization and Retention, in reality they can only focus on one. The trick is to figure out at what point can you stop focusing on one or the other.</p><p>Clash Royale began by focusing on Retention/Engagement. They could afford to do this because they were happy with the current levels of spend by their player base. The moment that the spend levels began to drop, whether it was because Spenders ran out of content, or left the game, Clash Royale should have immediately turned it’s focus back to Monetization. One might argue that they did with the advancements in the Store and in Gacha that they made. However, those would ultimately speed up the consumption of content. It wasn’t a fix to the long-term problem. If a developer is monetizing off of content and is running out of that content, either they need to make more of that content (i.e. release more cards) or they need to add new content that monetizes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/900/0*RPtsmc2NBbS0RoyX" /></figure><p>AFK Arena started out by focusing strongly on Monetization. They added many metasystems to make Heroes more powerful combined with many Gameplay modes that would offer various types of stat checks so that Players would have to optimize a wide variety of Party combinations to succeed. Most importantly, they added a semi-evergreen Metasystem in the form of Max Hero Level being based on the number of Heroes at Ascended Tier. Right now there are 77 Ascended Heroes in AFK Arena. The Max Level is 240+5*77 = 625. Every Ascended Hero AFK Arena adds will further extend that Metasystem. So AFK Arena is not at risk of running out of content for spenders anytime soon.</p><p>Given all this, AFK Arena made the conscious decision to pivot towards retention/engagement. Make the players happy and they will continue to engage in the content of that game. And if that content causes them to continue spending, then AFK Arena is in a very good place right now. Should spending from the player base begin to decline, I would fully expect AFK Arena to shift back to monetization, as any other game company should.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8f58a05d9985" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/a-tale-of-two-games-how-clash-royale-and-afk-arena-handled-their-monetization-differently-8f58a05d9985">A Tale of Two Games: How Clash Royale and AFK Arena handled their Monetization Differently</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[4 Design Tips you NEED in 2021]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/4-design-tips-you-need-in-2021-b5def0bfb055?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/b5def0bfb055</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 08 Jan 2021 21:25:05 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-08T21:25:05.276Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Tip 1: Take Clash Royale Gameplay, Ditch the Metasystems</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/450/0*Kqr0hQeVjZ9FKiLk" /></figure><p>There is a lot to admire about Clash Royale. It’s smooth hand-movement controls make deploying spells and units feel very natural. It’s chest system creates an organic method of session control that doesn’t rely on artificial limitations. It’s growing number of cards introduce new strategies each update. And it builds upon the successful Clash of Clans brand as well. With it’s natural gameplay and superb polish, it’s not surprising that a lot of competitors use Clash Royale as an inspiration for their own games.</p><p>There is one problem with this strategy of adopting Clash Royale Gameplay though: Developers are also adopting the Metasystems of Clash Royale. Clash Royale suffers from a woefully shallow Card Level System that has knee-capped it’s elder game monetization, as seen by their revenue slide over the last 1–2 years. This is mainly because of how few levels cards have, and how much the card costs scale:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/506/0*xn9kotndhdV36vuA" /></figure><p>Once your spenders max out the cards that they want to use, it becomes very hard to expand the metasystem to sustain spend. Thus, monetization in the elder game will likely begin sliding. And if your Game’s DAU is only a fraction of Clash Royale’s, there are few levers you can utilize to increase early game monetization lest you shorten the lifespan of the card content. Games that adopt both Clash Royale gameplay and metasystems will find their revenue nowhere near as much as Clash Royale unless they can manage to get a very large DAU.</p><p>For 2021, I encourage Developers to not be afraid of going semi-deep with their metasystems. Instead of 10–12 Card Levels, why not 25 or 50 with a smoother cost curve? Why not have a simple research system that requires items earned in chests, through the store and as event rewards? If you are worried about too many stats, don’t be. Clash Royale has shown that Card stats don’t really make Clash Royale matches seem brutally unfair, and players seem to accept them. In the end, you will be happy that you have a variety of different metasystems to leverage to ensure your game monetizes.</p><h3>Tip 2: Embrace System Deprecation</h3><p>It’s 2021. Out with the old and in with the new! This applies to games too. Because mobile games can survive for several years (Clash of Clans is 8?), it can become difficult for Developers to continue to add onto a system without game inflation making the costs of the new content meaningless or the costs inflate to an absurd degree. In these instances, ending an existing system and starting a new system on top of that can really help the game. This is called System Deprecation.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6zc51yLiTsvUUMAf" /></figure><p>Look at Summoners War. Their Monster Awakening System gave players something to grind for. Yet after several years, where Players have already awakened most of their Heroes, using those Awakening Materials for a Second Awakening would be too cheap for Players who have tons of Awakening Materials already. Once the Monster has earned enough Awakened Experience, they can be Awakened a second time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2JazD0xe52Xys_9B" /></figure><p>The Second Awakening requires the Player to use the Monster in special stages to earn Awakened XP for that Monster. These special stages require a new form of energy: Dimensional Energy. Dimensional Energy recovers very slowly, and only 30 Dimensional Energy can be purchased each week for 375 Gems. It’ll force Players to spend a lot of time grinding Awakened XP, and the developers have complete control of the Player experience because they aren’t tied to the old Awakening Materials.</p><p>As you are managing your games economy, take a hint from Summoners War and deprecate systems whose lifespan has come to an end, and add a new system with new economic levers that you have full control of.</p><h3>Tip 3: Collections can go in nearly every Game</h3><p>Having trouble thinking of a system to add to your game? Are you searching for more short-term goals for your Players? Do you want a system that is easily expandable? Collections may be just for you!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*-Vj7bC9cWcpsrhqB" /></figure><p>The concept is pretty simple: complete a collection and get a prize. But this simple system carries with it many benefits that can significantly help a Game’s KPIs. First and foremost, Collections create a deep itemization in the game that is easily expandable by the Developer. Think of new collections for updates and holidays and events. This in turn allows Developers to give out Collection items as loot, quest rewards and event rewards, both in the core game content and in event content. Similarly Developers can sell Collection items in the store and in sales.</p><p>With proper prizes, Collections can also serve as a short-term goal for players. If Players need a break from the Core Loop, they can focus on completing collections currently in progress. Collections are also great accompaniments to Events and limited time content. If your game has Heroes, create collections around specific Heroes that will give Players invested in that Hero short-term goals to focus on.</p><p>Collections can come in different forms, from card sets, to sets of artifacts or relics, to sets of skins. Whichever form of Collection you choose, you won’t be sorry for adding it to your game!</p><h3>Tip 4: Develop Multiple Opportunities to be Whales, not just Combat</h3><p>One universal fact about games is that not every player likes to PvP. Yet, for many 4x games and other genres, PvPing is the main avenue for a player to become a Whale. If your players spend a lot of money to become very powerful, chances are they will end up PvPing. Knowing that not all players enjoy PvPing, its surprising that more Developers haven’t found ways to create other vectors of gameplay that isn’t PvP where Players/Guild Members can shine.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*tHnqZW8yxzxyptWn" /></figure><p>Where it’s resource farming and distribution, PvE, defense, research, crafting, or anything else that may make a Player stand out to their Guild, I encourage Developers to design gameplay and event systems in ways where non-combat Players can spend to feel like superstars.</p><p>How does one go about this? In 4x Games, create parts of a larger Guild Wars event where Guilds need to gather, craft, research, or build things. Then, players who don’t want to PvP can instead invest more in research, gear, and heroes that will help them excel in those other activities. If you make those activities meaningful enough, you could get players in top Guilds to spend to excel in those events.</p><p>2021 is shaping up to be an exciting year! Hopefully these tips will help you design the next big hit! Until next time!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=b5def0bfb055" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/4-design-tips-you-need-in-2021-b5def0bfb055">4 Design Tips you NEED in 2021</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Understanding Content Inflation: How to avoid it and when to Use it]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/understanding-content-inflation-how-to-avoid-it-and-when-to-use-it-3526beb37d77?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3526beb37d77</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2020 03:24:53 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-19T03:24:53.008Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Content Inflation is one of the largest banes of any game developer. Entire monetization and development strategies revolve around how to leverage content for monetization and how to sustain that level of monetization. This balancing act is what separates long-lasting games from those which decline over time. Luckily it does not have to be this way. A key lesson to Free to Play (F2P) Games is that the value of something fluctuates over time. Managing content inflation means managing the value of game content throughout the lifetime of the game.</p><p>By content inflation, I mean the process of content that initially was more scarce or reserved, that becomes generally more available to players over time, thereby reducing it’s value. Monetization that relies on specific content will decline as that content becomes inflated. Understanding content inflation requires you to understand the Content Deprecation Cycle (CDC).</p><h3>The Content Deprecation Cycle</h3><p>Every F2P game has a content deprecation cycle (CDC). The idea behind a CDC is that content’s value is tied to how expensive the source of that content is. The more expensive the source of content is, the more valuable that content will be. As the same content is given out in less expensive sources, it’s value declines. New content released in more expensive sources will have a higher value.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*krH8ZQasJ4QE5o6i" /></figure><p>The CDC looks different in different game genres. Casual games will have very light CDCs, mainly just the devaluation of cosmetics. Hardcore games, on the other hand, live and die by their CDCs. Proper planning of the CDC is necessary in order to maximize the value of content at different parts of the CDC and leverage that value for monetization.</p><h3>How does the CDC affect Content Inflation?</h3><p>Cannibalization occurs within a game when content that is lower on the CDC is objectively as valuable or more valuable that content higher on the CDC. While it can be hard to objectively assess the value of virtual goods, it can be done, especially in certain game genres.</p><p>In Genshin Impact, 4-Star Weapons can be found through Gacha (Wishes) or through forging.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/918/0*737c9_XumXX-YOnJ" /></figure><p>But suppose 4-Star Weapons dropped from Bosses in Abyssal Domains. Direct Loot Farming is generally less expensive than purchasing Gacha, so players would accordingly begin to farm Abyssal Domains more until they have enough 4-Star Weapons to fill their roster. This would lead to a cannibalization of revenue from Gacha, as fewer players would pay for Gacha when they can directly farm the weapons from Abyssal Domains.</p><p>This doesn’t mean that players won’t eventually spend on Gacha. 5-Star Weapons still maintain their high value. But Gacha monetization is likely to be delayed and reduced if Genshin Impact were to start dropping 4-Star weapons in Abyssal Domaines.</p><p>Assessing objective value in virtual goods is easy to do with stat-based items. The higher the stats, the more valuable it is. Other types of virtual goods are more tricky. The trick is to try to assess how often a Player would choose one virtual good over another. With stats, nearly all players would choose a 4-Star, 39 Attack Sword over a 2-Star, 33 Attack Sword. That’s easy enough in RPGs, but what about other Genres?</p><p><strong>Resources and Speedups in Strategy Games like Rise of Kingdoms</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uEL_T616gtMu2bIn" /></figure><p>Like stats in RPGs, it’s pretty easy to assess the objective value of resources and speed-ups. Basically, more is better. Resources and speed-ups given throughout the CDC will only cannibalize resource and speed-up sales if the quantities of resources/speed-ups earned through grinding or low-cost activities rivals quantities earned through purchases.</p><p><strong>Boosters in Match-3 Games like Gardenscapes</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/0*bKcvyOGz-02LW-5I" /></figure><p>In Match-3 Games, Boosters that clear more of the board are objectively more valuable than Boosters that clear less of the board. The Dynamite Booster has a higher value than a single bomb. Cannibalization occurs in Match-3 Games when the better boosters are given out too freely, or when lesser boosters are given out too frequently so that Players don’t feel compelled to spend on the better boosters.</p><p><strong>Cards and Gacha in RTS Games like Clash Royale</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*U4ulzU5oAbUmmLjA" /></figure><p>Cards, and by proxy Gacha, are the bread and butter of Clash Royale. Any effort to sell cards directly (like the Store does) or to give out Gacha more frequently, results in lower monetization from Gacha. This explains why the Pass Royale (Clash Royale’s version of the Battle Pass) hurt retention so much. The free chests and auto-chest queuing that the Pass Royale gave, along with other rewards, hurt existing monetization of Gacha.</p><p><strong>Boosters in Farm and other Sim Games like Hay Day</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/638/0*cSmncNk_Gz95tCin" /></figure><p>Whereas Boosters in Match-3 games are evaluated more on interplay with the board, we can assess the value of Boosters in Sim games more easily by looking at 1) what does the Booster apply to, 2) how big is the bonus of the Booster, and 3) how long the Booster lasts. Again, more is better is generally the rule when trying to assess the value of a Booster. Content inflation occurs if more powerful Boosters are distributed too frequently or if enough lesser Boosters are available to let the players achieve what they want to.</p><p>We can see that properly managing a CDC within a game can help a Game Developer preserve their game’s monetization. However, when content inflation does occur, what should developers do to fix it?</p><h3>The Payoffs and Perils of Inflated New Content</h3><p>Game Developers who may have cannibalized future monetization for the sake of meeting this month’s revenue targets do have one powerful tool for partially healing or mitigating the future effects of their content inflation: <strong>New Content</strong>. Because content inflation occurs when a lower-cost action provides similar value to a higher-cost action, adding more value to the higher-cost action will partially solve the problem. If revenue from the +50 Attack Sword in Gacha is being cannibalized by the +40 Attack Sword dropping from the dungeon Boss, try having the Gacha drop a +70 Attack Sword! Easy Peasy, right?</p><p>Not exactly. Yes, swapping out the +50 Attack Sword with a +70 Attack Sword will better differentiate the Gacha from Boss drops, and push players to purchase more Gacha, thereby remedying the content inflation in the short run. The problem is that once you inflate one source — Gacha in this case — you need to inflate the content that players purchase Gacha to get through or overcome. If the difficulty of enemies are the same after the Gacha inflation as before, players will mow through content faster, which will result in <strong>lower monetization across the board</strong>.</p><p>Inflated new content is one of the strongest tools for changing player incentives and influencing player behavior, but it must be handled very carefully. Game Developers opting to use inflated new content to solve short-term content inflation problems without doing the leg work of setting up additional content to absorb that inflation might find themselves no better off in the long run, even if they see short-term gain from inflating the Gacha.</p><p>In the above example, a better way to handle inflation the Gacha content would be to release the inflated Gacha with a new tier of enemies, so as to have players who purchase the Gacha make progress, but still have challenging content later on that they will have to rely on Gacha to overcome.</p><p>Are there ways to combat content inflation besides inflated new content?</p><h3>Sometimes getting a new Treadmill is better than repairing the old one</h3><p>The steady treadmill of new content that uses the pushes and pulls of inflation alongside a disciplined Content Deprecation Cycle (CDC) keeps a game’s monetization healthy. Over time though, that treadmill becomes harder to maintain. The gap between average players and spenders typically will increase as the game gets older. This gap makes it very difficult for Game Developers to figure out who to design and balance content for. It could get to the point where either you are focusing solely on your spenders and your non-spenders drop off, or you cater too much to free players and your monetization suffers.</p><p>When this happens, it is sometimes easier to cease creating content for an existing system and instead create a new system to transition your spenders to. Doing so frees you from considering both ends of your player base, and instead design around your spenders. In the meantime, the CDC will funnel the old system’s content to free players over time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/793/0*v_is7lVu5o4tngOl" /></figure><p>One of the clearest examples of this happening is in Clash of Clans. The second “builder” base was introduced with a separate new economy, alongside new PvP modes and other updates. Progress from the first Base didn’t really affect a lot of what was happening in the second base. Because of that, the builder base allowed Supercell to control the content experience for spenders and non-spenders alike.</p><p>For games that have utilized inflated new content a lot to fix content inflation, it might be a good idea for the Developers to start planning for a replacement to systems that are getting harder and hard to maintain or balance.</p><h3>Content Inflation isn’t all Bad</h3><p>While this article has focused on the pitfalls of content inflation, it is possible to use content inflation to squeeze out additional revenue from content that is headed towards obsolescence.</p><p>The trick is to spot content whose value is at 0 or near-zero, and pair it with content that still has healthy value <strong>in a way that increases the sales of the healthy content.</strong> For example, suppose a +50 Atk Sword normally costs $10 in the store, and sells approximately 100 units a day, for total revenue of $1000 a day. The store also sells:</p><ul><li>+40 Atk Swords for $5 in the store, and sells 150 units a day, for a total revenue of $750 a day.</li><li>+30 Atk Swords for $2 in the store, and sells 125 Units a day for a total revenue of $250 a day</li><li>+20 Atk Swords for $1 in the store, and sells 50 Units a day for a total Revenue of $50.</li></ul><p>When creating a bundle from this content, a common mistake Game Developers will make is for selling the Bundle for less than the cost of the healthiest item (the +50 Atk Sword).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/811/0*1ic9wdK2vdovBGz8" /></figure><p>A bundle like this above, while increasing sales, has the potential to cannibalize future sales of the +50 Atk Sword. At a value of $15 sold for $8, it’s definitely possible that the increase in sales will outweigh the cannibalization. But it’s possible that it won’t. Instead, if you bundle enough low-value items with the healthiest items, and sell at a price above the healthiest item, you reduce the risk of cannibalization. For example:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/795/0*NTZxs1234TXmQ-tW" /></figure><p>In this case, a $26 value bundle is sold for $12. The value to cost ratio is similar to the first bundle. The difference is that the content that is cannibalized in this second bundle is the lesser-performing +30 Atk and +20 Atk Swords. Once the bundle ends, the value of the +50 Sword will still be $9.99. The value of the +30 Atk and especially the +20 Atk Swords will probably have reduced. But they only accounted for $300 a day vs. $1000 a day for the +50 Sword. The cannibalization of the lower-performing items is less likely to impact the long-term health of the game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/580/0*N13lOb4Gcd6bGJnn" /></figure><p>One Game Developer that whole-heartedly embraced this mentality when it came to bundling items is Machine Zone. In Game of War, many bundles would have a ton of crafting content in them that was much less valuable when compared with what they were currently selling. Yet, adding this near-0 value content to a bundle made the bundle appear much better. Basically, when you know content’s value is low to the point of obsolescence, don’t be afraid to try and squeeze more money out of that content by bundling it with other healthy content.</p><h3>Content Inflation is Unavoidable, but Game Developers can mitigate it’s Damage</h3><p>It is natural for content to be inflated over time.. This article is not meant to suggest otherwise. However, diligent game developers can reduce the instances of content inflation and prevent it from largely harming the game’s monetization. Organizing and running a thoughtful Content Deprecation System, carefully planning new content into the game that replaces the inflated content, and taking advantage of monetization opportunities that deprecating content offers will help make your game’s monetization last over time.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3526beb37d77" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/understanding-content-inflation-how-to-avoid-it-and-when-to-use-it-3526beb37d77">Understanding Content Inflation: How to avoid it and when to Use it</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Genshin Impact has the Problems of a Major AAA Game AND a Major F2P Game]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/genshin-impact-has-the-problems-of-a-major-aaa-game-and-a-major-f2p-game-cc6a12d295cb?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/cc6a12d295cb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2020 01:29:24 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-11-04T01:29:24.894Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*mMj96RUAfCEoaFu6" /><figcaption>F2P or AAA?</figcaption></figure><p>In 1993’s smash hit <em>Jurassic Park</em>, the character Ray Arnold (played by Samuel L Jackson) said of the Dinosaur Park: “We have all the problems of a major theme park and a major zoo and the computer’s not even on its feet yet.” The idea was that running a major Theme Park or Zoo, by itself, was a major hurdle that not all companies can pull off. Combining both into one just compounded the problem.</p><p><strong>Genshin Impact</strong>, the <em>Breath of the Wild</em> clone that rocked the F2P world when it was released over a month ago, suffers from the same problem posed in <em>Jurassic Park</em>. Its stunning graphics and AAA gameplay will create the expectation of new content over time that even the Titans of AAA have a hard time meeting, while at the same time feeling the pressure of revenue goals that bedevils all F2P Developers. This is not to say that the team of hundreds at MiYoHo aren’t up to the challenge. But how they handle the dual treadmills will determine the long-term success of Genshin Impact and serve as an example for other F2P Developers. Let’s dive into the challenges Genshin Impact faces:</p><h3>Normal F2P Events don’t Translate well to AAA Gameplay. Will Players be satisfied with a F2P Live-Ops cadence?</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*PWLudlcAz-QC6pO-" /><figcaption>World Bosses reset on a weekly basis</figcaption></figure><p>Genshin Impact has a myriad of elder game content that runs on a daily/weekly/monthly basis. This includes:</p><p>Daily:</p><ul><li>Layline Outcrop Spawns</li><li>Daily Commissions</li></ul><p>Weekly:</p><ul><li>World Bosses</li><li>Layline Outcrop Quests</li></ul><p>Bi-Weekly:</p><ul><li>Abyssal Moon Spire Reset</li></ul><p>Players familiar with F2P RPGs will recognize this regular cadence of Live-Ops activity. To avoid the expensive content treadmill, many games let players do specific content only a certain amount of times over a specific period of time. It’s a tactic utilized by nearly every major F2P Game, and Genshin Impact has followed this tactic to the letter.</p><p>Doing this regular content will earn players Resources used to upgrade the various meta systems in the game. What is lacking though are the BIG rewards that F2P Games have typically used to lure Players to complete their events. Things like new Heroes, special Equipment/Artifacts, and other things seem to be lacking from the regular Live-Ops content available to players. By itself, this is not necessarily an issue. Lots of F2P and AAA Games save the best stuff for this newest content or events, and since Genshin Impact Live-Ops so far is focused on having players engage with existing content, it makes sense why they don’t give out specific Heroes or Equipment/Artifacts as rewards. But eventually there will be that expectation of new Heroes/Equipment coming from new content.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*gCfJnGFQ9P5UfSlE" /><figcaption>Best Stuff dropping from Hardest Content is expected In AAA Titles…not Gacha</figcaption></figure><p>In World of Warcraft, Players expect new equipment to drop with new Raids. It’s one of the most positive experiences after overcoming difficult content, and it something players of AAA Games look forward to when new content is dropped. This begs the question of how often will new content drop in Genshin Impact?</p><h3>New Content is Expensive! How often will it drop?</h3><p>World of Warcraft drops a new content expansion every 4–6 months. I wouldn’t be surprised if players expect the same content release cadence for Genshin Impact. Because of the visual nature of the gameplay and the complexity of the combat, new content is expensive, <strong>especially if the new content isn’t a reskin.</strong></p><p>For those not familiar with the term, a “reskin” is when a developer uses the same art asset that is modified to a certain extent so that it appears as new art. The extent that a reskin looks visually different depends on the developer. AAA Developers will likely put more effort into distinguishing the reskin than a lot of F2P developers who are dealing with lower budgets.</p><p>Fans of Genshin Impact should be alarmed at the amount of reskins that Genshin Impact relies on. For one thing, there are only 6 families of enemies in the game:</p><ul><li>Hilichurls</li><li>Slimes</li><li>Ruin Machina</li><li>Abyss Order</li><li>Treasure Hoarders</li><li>Fatui</li></ul><p>Each of these enemy types has a few reskins. One wonders what new enemies in the game will look like over time? Will they continue to rely on more reskins of existing enemies? Or will they create new enemy types with different combat mechanics? Even though Breath of the Wild had a few DLC patches, they never introduced new content over time in a way that a top F2P Game does. And given that Genshin Impact has copied a good chunk of Breath of the Wild’s design, what will their approach to new content be? I kind of doubt they will release content on the cadence of a World of Warcraft. The question is whether they will even try to do that?</p><p>Assuming that the Genshin Impact developers figure out an adequate Live-Ops and new content cadence that will keep their players satisfied, one final question remains:</p><h3>How does Live-Ops handle Inflation?</h3><p>This may be the thorniest issue that Genshin Impact will come to terms with — how do you inflate content over time? Eventually Genshin Impact will have to add new Equipment (if not both Heroes and Equipment). Otherwise, spenders in Genshin Impact may run out of content.</p><p>There is room for inflation in AAA Games. World of Warcraft has inflated their content so much that they have had to implement MULTIPLE stat squishes. Genshin Impact, by comparison, has kept their stat ranges very manageable. Indeed one could argue that Genshin Impact can afford to have WIDER stat ranges and still keep from coming off as Pay to Win.</p><p>The issue here is that Genshin Impact has so far relied too much on Gacha for the distribution of Heroes and Equipment. This presents two challenges for Genshin Impact depending on how they intend to distribute new Equipment or Heroes:</p><ol><li><strong>New Content distributed outside of Gacha:</strong> How do you introduce new Inflated Equipment/Heroes outside of Gacha without disrupting your Gacha Monetization; and</li><li><strong>New Content distributed inside of Gacha: </strong>If Inflated Content is placed in Gacha, how do you push players to do the newest and most challenging content without inflating Primogems given out</li></ol><p>For #1, if Genshin Impact started to award equipment outside of Gacha, that would potentially cannibalize future Gacha purchases from Players. Once spenders got strong enough to overcome challenges of new content, they would start getting better equipment from the new content, and not through Gacha purchases. Thus, you would begin to see spending on Gacha begin to decline. While Players would need to spend Mora and other inputs to level up/upgrade the new content, the dip in Gacha spending would be felt in loss of revenue over time. In order to maintain the value of Gacha over time, new inflated equipment and heroes should be distributed through Gacha.</p><p>This is very much in line with AFK Arena’s Gacha Economy.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/587/0*PN0qCTbnT9UfLH1w" /><figcaption>New Heroes In Gacha keeps Gacha Value up!</figcaption></figure><p>New Heroes introduced to the game are generally added straight to Hero Scrolls. Doing this preserves the incentive for Players to purchase Hero Scrolls. Given the reliance on Gacha in Genshin Impact, going the AFK route makes sense, except for Challenge #2: If Inflated Content is placed in Gacha, how do you push players to do the newest and most challenging content without inflating Primogems given out?</p><p>In World of Warcraft, Players must continually run the toughest content in order to gear up for the next toughest content. But if Gacha is the main way new Heroes and Equipment is given out, Players should focus not on running the most difficult content, but rather the content that allows them to farm Primogems most efficiently. If players can farm for primogems without doing the most difficult content, that could cannibalize monetization as well. Genshin Impact could increase the distribution of Primogems to incentivize Players to run the most challenging content, but that would also reduce monetization from Gacha.</p><p>There is no easy answer here. Personally, I would use crafting to introduce new Equipment into the game, and have new content drop materials for the new equipment. New Heroes can continue to come from Gacha, and so Gacha will maintain at least some relevancy over the lifespan of the game (though probably not as much as the first 3–6 Months). But divorcing the best equipment from Gacha is definitely the way to go in the long run, as you can dangle new equipment materials as loot from the newest challenging content.</p><h3>And the Elder Game’s Not Even on Its Feet Yet…</h3><p>It is still very early to determine how the Elder Game of Genshin Impact will shape out. The dynamic mix of AAA Gameplay and F2P Metasystems has certainly got the industry buzzing. The big question is what will the Genshin Impact audiences expect as an Elder Game Live-Ops and New Content cadence, and whether MiYoHo can satisfy audiences without ruining the game’s economy. The failure of them to do so will result in a significant revenue decline over time…</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=cc6a12d295cb" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/genshin-impact-has-the-problems-of-a-major-aaa-game-and-a-major-f2p-game-cc6a12d295cb">Genshin Impact has the Problems of a Major AAA Game AND a Major F2P Game</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Genshin Impact is Changing F2P as we know It]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/how-genshin-impact-is-changing-f2p-as-we-know-it-d77153357e32?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d77153357e32</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 15 Oct 2020 04:31:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-10-15T04:31:29.993Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OmQbacs0IA6sDkpj" /></figure><p>Genshin Impact crashed onto the scene two weeks ago, hitting Microsoft Windows, PlayStation 4, and Mobile. With revenues expected to potentially hit $100 Million on mobile alone within its first month, it’s easy to see why Genshin Impact has garnered a lot of attention. Having played and studied the game, and also played it’s clear inspiration — The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild — I think that Genshin Impact will stand out as an important turning point in the evolution of Free to Play games. Below are 3 ways that Genshin Impact will shape F2P Designs for future games.</p><h3>#1: Not only is F2P compatible with AAA Gameplay, it can actually improve on some AAA Designs</h3><p>For all the absolutely breathtaking visuals that The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild gave us, the game actually had a lot of design flaws that were frustrating for a lot of players.</p><p>A big flaw was the lack of direction in the game. As Great as the sense of Exploration was in the game, the lack of direction and knowing where to go was a consistent pain-point in the Player Experience. While Players had a few long-term Goals to work towards, there was virtually nothing guiding the Player over the course of the Game.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/970/0*K0FlbDRQSjSYuTgH" /></figure><p>Genshin Impact improves upon this through strong Story-Telling, guiding the Player to specific locations, enabling the use of multiple Heroes, and providing specific tasks.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9efE06H4n0PD6kEl" /></figure><p>Daily Tasks, in particular, are a staple of F2P Mobile RPGs. All the major F2P RPGs on Mobile utilize Daily Quests to get Players to dabble in all the major core systems each day. Genshin Impact utilizes that same philosophy by having the following daily activities:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*nIjgY0hEu1djtqfb" /></figure><ol><li>Daily Commissions</li><li>Daily Mining Expeditions</li><li>Battle Pass Daily Challenges</li><li>And more!</li></ol><p>The use of Daily Tasks and a strong Story-Backed Quest Chain gives Players a lot of direction as to what they should be doing. As a result, the Player is more likely to feel like they have accomplished something at the end of the Play Session. Compare this to Breath of the Wild, where an hour’s worth of exploring can sometimes end with little to no progress, a bunch of random ingredients, and some broken weapons.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/980/0*Ssueo5eyXfc7M9Ep" /></figure><p>Speaking of Broken Weapons, one of the biggest flaws of Breath of the Wild is the horrible Weapon Durability system. The frequency of Weapons breaking, and the need to always grind for new Weapons, is a terrible Design decision. Forcing Players to manage the Weapon Economy took a lot of fun out of the game session, as Player’s decisions while exploring the World were partly influenced by what was happening with their Weapons. In Genshin Impact, Weapon Upgrades <strong>solves this problem</strong>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*BrOlDI9oRsrqncKB" /></figure><p>In Genshin Impact, Players can increase Weapon Level by fusing other weapons and Materials into the Weapon to give it experience. Once the Weapon has enough experience, it increases in Level and gains stats. This means that players spend time grinding for low level weapons and materials, eventually leveling up their Weapons over time.</p><p>This system is vastly superior to the Weapon Durability system in Breath of the Wild. While both systems require a certain amount of grinding, Genshin Impact’s F2P Weapon Enhancement System creates a better player experience. Players are free to use the Weapons that they want without worrying about their Weapon Management. At the same time, Players must eventually grind for Weapons and Materials in order to improve the Weapons their Heroes currently use.</p><p>And it’s not like Breath of the Wild didn’t rely on stats to a certain extent. Weapon Damage in the later Weapons could be as much as 10x damage versus the beginning weapons. Genshin Impact, by comparison, doesn’t have a wide range in damage in the base stats:</p><p>5 Star Weapon:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*NhMpPwV_2MyzHdor" /></figure><p>1 Star Weapon:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SfS67Th_nSr6D427" /></figure><p>This power discrepancy is mild by F2P standards. But that’s because Genshin Impact recognizes that <strong>you don’t need a ton of stat inflation to make stats meaningful in a skill-based game</strong>. A few stats go a long way when your control of the Hero largely determines whether you hit or miss, or take damage or avoid the attack.</p><p>In the end, both systems tackle the same problem: how to slow down Weapon Stat Growth for the Player. But the tried and true F2P Weapon Enhancement System is the one that creates a better Player Experience.</p><h3>#2: Action RPGs don’t have to be a Single-Hero Experience</h3><p>Action RPGs are a nice alternative to the standard F2P RPGs like AFK Arena or Marvel Strike Force for Players who want skill to matter. While stats can be extremely important in Action RPGs, Player Skill is definitely a big part of success too. And Action RPGs are generally receptive to the same types of F2P Metasystems as Party-Based RPGs. Look at Archero:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/536/0*HrHZZsbqjuTT5-Xc" /></figure><p>The big difference in potential between Action RPGs and Party-Based RPGs is typically on the monetization front. Party-Based RPGs monetize better because <strong>Players need to optimize more Heroes in a Party-Based RPG than in an Action RPG.</strong> Fewer Heroes means less depth, and less depth means less monetization.</p><p>Action RPGs typically only utilize one Hero, drastically cutting down the aggregate depth of the Metasystem Economy. Some Action RPGs have tried to expand the number and complexity of systems for a single Hero to make up for the loss of depth. Take the Monster Codex system from Lineage II: Revolutions.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*6d7aFzFKVfRHvBRl" /></figure><p>Yet these systems are typically complex for the average audience, and the more systems a Hero has can detract on the importance of any <strong>one</strong> system, making monetization of a particular system a little more difficult.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YB9nJuSyOdDG6jG4" /></figure><p>Enter Genshin Impact, which has developed a fairly smooth means of switching Heroes. Players can bring 4 Heroes at a time, and can switch between them by tapping them. This allows Genshin Impact to require Players to optimize more than one Hero. Combined with challenges based on Element, and suddenly Players will need to manage and upgrade enough Heroes to support a couple different party compositions. Will it ever reach 30+ Heroes that are required in the End Game for more traditional F2P RPGs? Time will tell. But requiring Players to collect, optimize and use multiple Heroes is a strong start in getting Action RPGs up to Par.</p><h3>#3: Cross-Platform Opens up Design Opportunities for F2P Developers</h3><p>Perhaps Genshin Impact’s largest influence on the F2P Industry is to unchain Game Designers from designing around the mobile play session. For over a decade now, F2P Game Designers have trained ourselves to try and squeeze in meaningful progression into a 3–5 minute play session for Players on the Go. The consequence of this is that a lot of F2P Mobile Gameplay designs fall short of what is fun or exciting to Players.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*ksYeYwLnfW0khNwY" /></figure><p>Genshin Impact doesn’t care about Mobile Session length. Just like 5 minutes of playing Breath of the Wild would be virtually pointless, so too would playing Genshin Impact for just a few minutes at a time. This is because <strong>Genshin Impact is meant to be played more like a Console/PC game than like a mobile game. </strong>Players sitting down for 30–60 minutes at a time will surely make more meaningful progress than Players who play 10–15 minutes on Mobile here and there.</p><p>This doesn’t mean that Mobile is completely irrelevant to Genshin Impact. With a strong crafting economy and a lot of daily tasks, Players can try and accomplish something in a 10–15 minute play session. But playing on Mobile isn’t mandatory. Players can play primarily on any of the other Platforms, while still being able to make some progress on Mobile when they are away from the main Platform.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bI6G91VzgDstvG69" /></figure><p>This strategy is very similar to Fortnite, where serious Battle Royale Players probably didn’t rely on Mobile Controls to compete, but Players looking to complete Battle Pass challenges could hop on Mobile and make some progress in their downtime here and there.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*Un7iSJq5U9agMf7p" /></figure><p>This does not mean that Genshin Impact lets Players play as much as they want to. They clearly don’t want Players to make <strong>too much</strong> progress in a day.</p><p>Thus, they’ve implemented Resin, a sort of energy system that Players spend in order to receive rewards from certain activities like running Dungeons, fighting Elite Bosses, etc. If a Player wants rewards from those activities, they have to have enough Resin. Doing the activities without Resin will result in the Player being able to do the activity, but they won’t be rewarded for it. It’s similar to doing a match in Clash Royale when all your chest slots are full.</p><p>Resin recharges slowly over time, but Players can spend to refill Resin. It is standard F2P, but shows that Genshin Impact is aware of the potential of Players to burn through their Metasystem content too quickly if unchecked.</p><p>What does this mean for Mobile F2P? For one thing, Game Designers have more choices on how to shape Gameplay that is more more compelling to their Player Base. Going Cross-Platform means that at least some Gameplay Systems need not follow the strict session rules that Mobile has forced Developers to adhere to. And Developers should not be afraid to pick and choose between mobile-centric designs for some gameplay systems and cross-platform design for others. If you intend for your Audience to start out as mainly Mobile, have your core gameplay be mobile-friendly. But then you should explore if cross-platform would give your Elder Players a better experience in the Elder Game. More choices will spark more innovation, which is great for the industry.</p><h3>What’s Next?</h3><p>Genshin Impact is still very fresh and we will have to see how the game tracks over the next few months. But I hope it’s initial success is sparking discussions across all developers about how they might best develop compelling gameplay while still incorporating strong F2P Mechanics. Next week, I’ll explore 3 Potential Pitfalls that Genshin Impact might fall into as Players transition to the Elder Game.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d77153357e32" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/how-genshin-impact-is-changing-f2p-as-we-know-it-d77153357e32">How Genshin Impact is Changing F2P as we know It</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Auto-Battling your Way to Victory is not a Good Design]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/auto-battling-your-way-to-victory-is-not-a-good-design-109937a1f236?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/109937a1f236</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 10 Aug 2020 20:54:46 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-08-10T20:54:46.125Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Auto-Battle has been a mainstay of many RPG and Strategy Mobile F2P Games for over half a decade. It was a Quality of Life boon to Players who enjoyed the game but didn’t want to spend time manually grinding for Exp, Items, Currency, and more. But what happens when a game takes Auto-Battle and bakes it into its core design so that Players essentially are able to Auto-Battle their way to victory? Enter Battle Legion, a new PvP “Mass Battler” that hit the App Stores a few weeks ago.</p><p>Battle Legion allows Players to Auto-Battle their way to success, whether its completing the Season Pass or advancing through the Arena Tiers. And while this formula succeeds in simplifying the Player experience, it leaves players with precious little to focus on or care about outside of its Auto-Battle Game Play.</p><h3>In this Article, we’ll cover:</h3><ol><li>How other games have used Auto-Battle in the past and how Battle Legion implemented it;</li><li>How Battle Legion’s implementation of Auto-Battle made winning and losing much less significant than other Strategy Games</li><li>How few Strategic Choices and little Loss-aversion killed the Strategy part of Battle Legion.</li></ol><h3>A Brief Auto-Battle Explainer</h3><p>Auto-Battle became popular in RPGs such as Summoners War and derivative RPGs like Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes, Marvel Strike Force, etc.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*MEUoqkkXeVGPQnXT" /><figcaption>Auto-Battle is great for grinding!</figcaption></figure><p>All of these RPGs gate content behind a pretty steep grind, requiring players to replay PvE Stages they already completed an insufferable amount of times in order to get the inputs they need to optimize their Heroes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cAwEHCDaUFvTKjeS" /><figcaption>Why require Players to pay attention to Battles they have won before?</figcaption></figure><p>Since Players have already completed the PvE Content, there is no game reason to require players to manually play through the content again. Thus, Players are given an option to turn Auto-Battle “on” and have the battle play out to its conclusion. All the Player needs to do is initiate the battle. Auto-Battle is often a toggleable button, so Players can turn it off and on as they wish.</p><p>Note that this form of Auto-Battle is used when grinding requires no strategic choice, but rather is just a side-product of requiring energy. The real grind in RPGs like Summoners War/SWGOH is that energy = inputs.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*A-ecUW71ic_VNHvC" /><figcaption>A lot of Auto-Battle is gated by Energy or another Limiting Mechanic</figcaption></figure><p>The game is primarily concerned that Players spend energy to get the inputs they need. The higher stage a Player is able to complete, the more efficient the input/energy ratio is. Having players play through the actual PvE Stage is just a byproduct of sinking energy. This is why many RPGs later upgraded Auto-Battle to Auto-Complete, making the grind experience for players even easier.</p><p>With Auto-Battle making the RPG grind tolerable, Players can then focus on Gameplay that requires attention and strategy, including:</p><ol><li>PvP</li><li>PvE Stages they have not completed</li><li>Events</li><li>Other forms of Gameplay that require strategy and stats to succeed.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/459/0*p_4hFwpAkSNWVxup" /><figcaption>AFK Arena is all Auto-Battle, but still showcases a lot of strategic decision opportunities</figcaption></figure><p>While many forms of gameplay may still be automated (such as combat in AFK Arena), Players still have strategic choice in choosing which Heroes to use and where they are placed in the formation.</p><h3>Battle Legion’s Auto-Spin kills the Strategy of the Game</h3><p>Battle Legion’s biggest issue is that grinding and core gameplay content are more or less the same, and that allowing Players to make progress on both fronts with the Auto-Battle system waters down the core gameplay a ton.</p><h3>Battle Legion’s Auto-Spin Function</h3><p>Battle Legion’s version of Auto-Battle is the Auto-Spin option found in the lower right corner. Tapping on it allows players to play multiple matches in a row without the Player needing to initiate a match.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ak9n6BCtHXOwr_z9" /><figcaption>That’s a lot of Auto-Spins…</figcaption></figure><p>Battle Legion requires Auto-Spin tokens to do matches automatically one right after another. These tokens accumulate over time, with a cap of 50 tokens that can be generated and 200 that can be held by the player at any given time.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/147/0*K88cWk8qn32DDpro" /></figure><p>When the toggle is highlighted, the Player will go into another match immediately, regardless of whether they win or lose.</p><p>This all seems very harmless, right? The problem is not with how the Auto-Spin operates itself, but rather how it interacts with other parts of the game.</p><h3>There are no Limitations on Gameplay in Battle Legion</h3><p>The Games that use Auto-Battle to ease the burden of grinds all have energy requirements. AFK Arena, which has Auto-Battle but doesn’t have an energy requirement, doesn’t require grind activity (choosing instead to wrap it up in an idle mechanic). A Limiting Mechanic (like Energy) is necessary to ensure that Auto-Battle doesn’t let players earn too much too quickly. Otherwise Players will consume content too quickly and the Game’s monetization will suffer.</p><p>Battle Legion doesn’t have any sort of Limiting Mechanic. Even if a Player runs out of Auto-Spin Tokens, they can still manually begin a match. Instead of a Limiting Mechanic, Battle Legion attempts to use Match Inefficiency as a means of curbing the Player session. This is similar to Clash Royale:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iRlot1Hat1i_LQ-j" /></figure><p>Winning a match in Clash Royale gives Players progress along a couple different vectors: A New Timed Chest, Advancement in Arena Trophies, progress to the Season Pass and the Crown Chest.</p><p>Likewise, in Battle Legion, a Match win goes towards progress in 3 systems:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ugsDEAwGwf41YIid" /></figure><p>Wagons are the equivalent of Clash Royale’s Timed Chests. Rank Progress is similar to Arena Progress (though more lenient), and the Season Pass is similar as well.</p><p>It is absolutely true that using Match Inefficiency to curb the Player session works in Clash Royale.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/768/0*j36aAoW_poRbBIhg" /><figcaption>Clash Royale has a clear point where playing additional matches is not longer valuable to most Players.</figcaption></figure><p>Given that winning a match requires a lot of concentration and effort, and that losing not only will set a Player back Arena Trophies, but might be considered a waste of time, not earning a Chest sharply curbs my incentive to continue playing. Yes, Crown Chests and the Pass Royale could push me to still grind for Crowns when my Chest Slots are full. But a good player will generally try to overlap filling all the chest slots with completing the Crown Chests and Pass Royale Tiers as much as possible.</p><p>But Match Inefficiency becomes compelling <strong>only when the risk of losing is great enough to deter the Player from playing a match with reduced incentives</strong>. And unfortunately, losing a match in Battle Legion doesn’t really matter…</p><h3>Losing doesn’t matter in Battle Legion</h3><p>There are two “costs” for losing in Battle Legion: Rank Points and Auto-Spin Tokens. I use quotation marks for costs since I believe them to be almost nominal in nature. Given the high capacity of Auto-Spin Tokens the Player can hold, it is quite difficult to use all your Auto-Spin Tokens as it is.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*gsTgdQXpikoCDaCu" /><figcaption>Auto-Spins are too cheap!</figcaption></figure><p>Add to that the low cost of purchasing new spin tokens and it is hard to imagine that “wasting” an Auto-Spin Token will deter players at all.</p><p>As for Rank Score, losing is significant only in that it gets you farther away from your Rank Tier Rewards.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7C5SMJHcGV34hWiL" /><figcaption>Reaching a new Tier is super valuable because it means I cannot go below that Tier Minimum</figcaption></figure><p>Unlike Clash Royale, you cannot backtrack to a lower tier. So once you hit a Tier, you are guaranteed to continue receiving those Tier Wagons. And whereas a match in Clash Royale takes 1–3 Minutes of active concentration and interaction, a match in Battle Legion takes less than 30 seconds and you don’t have to do anything. So does it really matter if I lose a few times in a row? I can just keep playing and use my 30%, 40%, 50% win rates to still get through the Season Pass and make slow and steady progress up the Rank Tiers.</p><p>And that is the crux of the problem with Battle Legion…how often I win or lose is almost irrelevant.</p><h3>Where is the Strategy?</h3><p>Battle Legion gives the Player no strategic choice of how a specific match is going to turn out. The opponent is completely random aside from general Trophy proximity (as far as we can see).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9lNFFym2DgVeqaj0" /><figcaption>Where is the Strategy if I can’t make any decisions before or during battle?</figcaption></figure><p>The player has no option as to which opponent they play, and the player has no way to configure their army to battle the opponent once they are matched. There is no way for a Player to affect the Battle outcome during the battle. Clash Royale’s matching is completely random as well, but the Player has so much room to affect the battle during the match.</p><p>So where is the strategy? Yes there will be army formats and compositions that are superior to others. But if there is no opposing factor to change up those formats and compositions, is that really strategic? Would 15 minutes of reading Battle Legion Guides make me a good enough player to get my win rate up to 70%+? Does that even matter?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1015/1*3f6G5wPhiTTwVv2JFPvx9w.png" /><figcaption>Given that Win Rates just determines how many Auto-Battles I’ll need to play, why should I spend to boost my win rate from 40% to 50% to 60% to 70%?</figcaption></figure><p>And what is the point of spending in the game? Does having a 60% or 70% win rate make that much difference over so many matches compared with a 50% win rate?</p><p>Arguably the Season Pass is a good deal because its so easy to complete! It is the first Battle Pass I’ve been able to complete 100% through Auto-Battle (an Industry First!?). But if I stop caring about getting stronger, am I going to continue investing in future Season Passes?</p><p>The Battle Legion gameplay on its own is fine. Unfortunately efforts to simplify strategy gameplay for Players seem to have accomplished killing the strategy of the game. Hopefully the Game Developers add more engaging systems to the Game so I can finally take the game off Auto-Battle and play for real.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=109937a1f236" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/auto-battling-your-way-to-victory-is-not-a-good-design-109937a1f236">Auto-Battling your Way to Victory is not a Good Design</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Can Riot make TFT a Billion Dollar Game?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/can-riot-make-tft-a-billion-dollar-game-7c7f158d459?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7c7f158d459</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 17 Jul 2020 01:27:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-07-17T16:42:34.825Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>It is always great to have a super popular game that millions of players play regularly. It is even better when Player Trust in the Game Developer behind the popular game is very high. Riot has succeeded in building a brand that players trust to be fun without a lot of Free to Play (F2P) gimmicks or Pay to Win (P2W) systems. Yet their dedication to a cosmetics-only approach to monetization is a serious limiting factor on their long-term ability to monetize. TFT is an example of this limitation.</p><p>TFT currently shows $.43 Revenue per Download. This is a much smaller amount compared to many other RPGs and Strategy games out there.</p><p>Needless to say, TFT doesn’t look so hot on the Revenue front. But given Riot’s reputation for fair play and rejecting anything looking like P2W, what are some things that can be added to TFT to help the game monetize more without compromising Riot’s standards?</p><p>The challenge here is to design features that won’t alienate the hardline no-P2W Riot Players. These Players love Riot because of Riot’s Anti-P2W philosophy — the belief that Players should feel good when spending and when deciding not to spend. Before I suggest a few designs, let’s establish a few principles that we want to maintain that will prevent the new monetization leading to P2W:</p><ol><li><strong>Engagement &gt; Stats</strong>: Benefits of Monetization should be tied to Engagement and Skill more so than just the addition of new Stats.</li><li><strong>Focus on Skill:</strong> Embrace the Skill-Based nature of the Game.</li><li><strong>Don’t Sacrifice Game Play:</strong> Monetization won’t matter if the Player just isn’t good at the Game</li></ol><p>With these guidelines, let’s explore possible system additions to TFT that could help with their monetization.</p><h3>Origins and Classes are Built for Metasystems</h3><p>TFT has a wide array of Classes and Origins, with all Champions in the game having a combination of the two.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*VoUpoffNKKVroAWm" /></figure><p>This type of classification of Champions is very typical of many RPGs you find on mobile. Just check out the five classifications of Star Wars: Galaxy of Heroes:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Tvojk46uU6KsMEkA" /></figure><p>In RPGs, Classifications are a good way to organize content for the purposes of sales, bonuses, event restrictions, and other things you can monetize off of. Indeed, TFT already utilizes their Champion Classification with their set bonuses.</p><p>Here is an example of set bonuses by the Blademaster Class in TFT:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ltNhdjQt9iwQLSGO" /></figure><p>And here is an example of the set bonuses by the Chrono Origin in TFT:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*735ECwS3EJtQnv44" /></figure><p>The Core Strategy of TFT is how to balance Class and Origin set bonuses while managing EXP Levels, Individual Champion Star Levels and Item Equips. This balance opens the game up to several strategies as to how to play the game. Some include:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*54L7VAnseCFqZ8Ue" /></figure><p><strong>It is this balance of Set Bonuses, EXP Levels, Champion Star Levels and Item Equips that will allow TFT to add a stat system that it can monetize off of without making the game P2W or undermining Player Skill.</strong></p><h3>Randomness and Skill undermine Stats</h3><p>It is a universal truth in F2P Games that Randomness and Skill generally undermine the value of Stats in RPG and Strategy games. The less valuable stats are, the harder it is to monetize off of stats. And TFT sets up a lot of things to ensure that individual Champion Stats don’t dictate who wins:</p><ol><li><strong>Set Bonuses:</strong> The Set Bonuses for Origins and Classes in TFT are staggering. If you look at the set bonuses posted above for the Blademaster Class and Chrono Origin, the top set bonuses dwarf the lower set bonuses, and can completely change how a group of Champions can perform in battle. Compare that to the relatively mild equipment set bonuses in World of Warcraft:</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/470/0*kc5uhxQqnZojJcCT" /></figure><p>Don’t get me wrong, these set bonuses were significant at the time in Classic World of Warcraft. But that was because WoW’s Stat Economy overwhelmingly relied on Stats for performance. The more a game relies on stats, the more valuable each stat is. And thus, smaller set bonuses like this were more impactful. The massive set bonuses in TFT are bound to undermine the individual stats of Champions.</p><p><strong>2. Random Store Offerings: </strong>Even if a Player goes into a match with a solid game plan, their strategy may be disrupted by unlucky store rolls.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OhHE3g7QIQgZu83t" /></figure><p>The fact that Players cannot rely on getting the Champions they want in the Store undermines a statistical advantage a player may have. Add to that the balance between paying to Refresh the Store and the need to buy XP, and it would be near-impossible for a Player to rely on stats alone to muscle their way through to a top rank in a match.</p><p><strong>3. Other Systems also Undermine Stats: </strong>Champion Counters, Item equips, Champion Placement on the Map, EXP Investment and more are all factors that undermine stats.<strong> </strong>TFT has so many factors that can affect a Player’s performance in a match. The strategic spending of coins and the Player’s skill in choosing a good combination of champions, increasing their army size through EXP, equipping the right items on the right champions, and more are what will determine who places high in a match and who comes in last.</p><p>All these factors should allow for moderate stat-based systems to be in the game without making the game P2W. Here is an example of a system that could create additional monetization opportunities for TFT while keeping the game skill-based:</p><h3>Champion Mastery: Making Champions stronger the more they are used</h3><p>The idea of Champion Mastery is pretty simple: the more a Champion is used, the stronger it gets. Champions would have mastery levels that exist outside of matches. A Mastery Level determines the Champion’s base stats when in a match. Look at Blitzcrank, for example.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/565/0*nhU_C7kkT78Lz9h1" /></figure><p>As Blitzcrank’s Mastery Level increased, some of it’s base stats would grow:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M6Rw8kfyxSyYY1ivQ9IL7g.png" /></figure><p>A few things to note:</p><ol><li>Not all stats need to be increased. Stats that have less inflationary potential like attack speed, crit rate and range would stay static. But other stats that are more open to be inflated would increase.</li><li>The stat increases need not be huge. One of the paradoxes of Strategy games is that as little as stats might matter, the more competitive players will go to great lengths to achieve those small stat gains. We can have Champion give a modest stat boost to only some stats, and have that be effective.</li><li>A Champion is considered Used if it was placed on the Battlefield for 3+ Rounds.</li></ol><p>Players can increase a Champion’s Mastery Level by using it in Matches. At the end of the match, Players would earn Mastery Points for the Champions they used. The amount of points each used Champion earns is dependent on where the Player places in the Match. For example:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/385/1*RQ2G-b0KubotEzI5tKzDZQ.png" /></figure><p>In this example, a Player who places 3rd would have each of their Champions used earn 12 Mastery Points.</p><p>Match Points required to increase a Champion’s Mastery Level increases with each Mastery Level.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/478/1*yMOi8ROHsZIW0_luh5banw.png" /></figure><p>The goal of a system like this is pretty simple:</p><ol><li>The more a player plays, the stronger their Champions will get over time.</li><li>The more skillful a player is, the stronger their Champions will get over time.</li><li>Skill and Engagement both will lead to Champion Mastery Progress.</li></ol><h3>Monetize Mastery by selling Mastery Point Boosts</h3><p>To Monetize off of Champion Mastery, I would sell options for Players to increase the amount of Mastery Points earned through Matches. These would come in the following forms:</p><p><strong>Subscription IAPs that accelerate Mastery Points earned.</strong></p><ol><li>Low cost ($0.99 to $2.99 Subscriptions) would be sold to accelerate the amount of Mastery Points earned by Champions of specific Origins and Classes.</li><li>For example, there would be a $1.99 Blademaster Subscription, and a $2.99 Chrono subscription, etc.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/626/1*gVhWiAWahcbwMC3LpmZG6g.png" /></figure><p>While the Subscription is active, Mastery Points earned per match would increase.</p><p>Note that a lot of the point increases would occur at the lower place finishes. This allows for very skillful players who don’t want to pay to earn nearly the same amount of Mastery Points per Match as a spender, but less skillful players can use the subscriptions to Mastery their Champions faster and try to become more competitive.</p><p>The IAP Subscriptions would basically ensure that the Player makes meaningful mastery progress even if they don’t do well in a given match.</p><p>Auto-Chess Players tend to favor specific Origins and Classes. Selling Subscriptions based on Origins and Classes allows different levels of spenders to choose how much to spend based on how many Origins and Classes they want to try and optimize.</p><p><strong>Daily Mastery Point Minigame</strong></p><p>Given the use of Minigames across several genres, it seems like a Minigame would fit pretty well in TFT. Think about the Wheel Minigame in 8-Ball Pool:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*FsPUNkGuxCe-iNJT" /></figure><p>When the Player first logs in during the day, they will see a circle randomly filled with Champions (similar to the beginning of the match).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*23Y7YNMqSa1WRQp9" /></figure><ol><li>Player taps a button and the Champions will being moving around the circle until one stops in from of the Player.</li><li>The Player will earn 10–100 Mastery Points for the Hero that stops.</li><li>The first “Spin” of the Wheel would be free, but subsequent spins would cost a $0.99 — $2.99 IAP.</li><li>While this is technically paying for immediate progress, the random aspect of it would deter spenders from heavily relying on this as a method of increasing their Champion Mastery levels versus playing actual matches.</li></ol><ul><li><strong>Ad-Based Temporary Boosts in all Mastery Points earned.</strong></li></ul><ol><li>Players who watch Ads will get a 20% Mastery Point Boost for all Classes and Origin Champions for 4 hours. Players can watch multiple Ads to increase that Boost to 48 Hours max.</li><li>These Ads are 100% voluntary. Players would never be forced to watch an Ad if they don’t want to.</li><li>Purchasing an IAP Subscription will make that boost permanent for the Origin or Class aligned with that Subscription while the Subscription is active.</li><li>While Ad-Based Monetization has become big with more casual Idle Games, it has largely been underutilized in RPGs and Strategy Games. This is partly due to the fact that Ads have a negative reputation as things that can cheapen a brand.</li><li>Given TFT’s likely large user base, having a strong Ad-Based Monetization would likely derive a fair amount of revenue.</li><li>It also lets players who don’t want to spend still contribute to Revenue and get some benefits.</li></ol><p>While I am a big advocate for using 100% Voluntary Ads in High-DAU games, the negative reputation they have as part of AAA games makes it unlikely that Riot or other Game Developers with Strong Brands will be adopting Ads anytime soon.</p><p>The value of the subscriptions is to not only allow players to progress faster, but also soften the blow on matches where Players don’t do as well. With a subscription active, Players will feel like they make progress even if they place very low.</p><h3>Events will create Revenue Spikes</h3><p>With Champion Mastery giving something for Players to work towards over time, the other area where TFT can boost it’s monetization comes from Events. Riot has already dabbled in Event Gameplay with League of Legends’ Clash Tournament Events. TFT has the opportunity to take what has already been done in LoL and push it further with more monetization opportunities that don’t undermine the skill-based nature of TFT Gameplay.</p><p>TFT already has a Solid Ranked system that keeps competitive players in the game and potentially boosts long-term retention. But the Rank System does little for monetization. Since the Ranked Season lasts months, there is no immediate need for Players to spend to advance in the Rank System (even if there were things to spend on).</p><p>Effective Events in TFT need the following qualities in order to successfully monetize:</p><ol><li><strong>Time-Limited Urgency: </strong>Players must have a limited amount of time to be successful</li><li><strong>An Artificial Limiting Factor: </strong>Players must not be able to attempt the Event without any limitations</li><li><strong>A Monetization Tool or Currency that relates to the Limiting Factor: </strong>TFT must be able to sell Players something that gets around the Limiting Factor.</li></ol><p>Here are a couple Event designs that could do well with TFT:</p><h3>Tournaments</h3><p>Tournaments challenge Players to Place very high in a small number of Matches in order to advance. The emphasis is on high Match Placement, which in turn mainly emphasizes Player skill, though stats could matter too.</p><p>There are 4 Rounds:</p><ol><li><strong>Qualifying Rounds</strong></li><li><strong>Quarterfinal Rounds</strong></li><li><strong>Semifinal Rounds</strong></li><li><strong>Finals</strong></li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cf0Db8jiQIAvf8w9" /></figure><p>These Rounds would play out over a two-week period:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*LW5Gv6jCV9EiiazcqIvRdQ.png" /><figcaption>Tournaments would occur on a two-week cadence</figcaption></figure><p>Players advance through the Rounds based on their aggregate Match Scores:</p><ol><li><strong>Qualifying Rounds: </strong>We group Players into Leaderboards of 20 Players. The Players play 3 matches to try and get the highest place in each match. Placement in the Matches will give Tournament Points.</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/328/1*mg9yEhosxiJjckOTnttLPQ.png" /></figure><p>Tournament Points from the 3 Matches determines where Players rank in the Qualifying Round Leaderboard. So the highest score in the Qualifying Rounds would be 24 (three 1st Place finishes). A player who gets 2nd Place, 3rd Place, and 5th Place would have a Leaderboard Score of 17.</p><p>At the end of the Qualifying Round, the top 10 Players on the leaderboard advance to the Semifinal Rounds. The remaining Players who don’t advance can try again in the next day’s qualifying Rounds. There are four Qualifying Rounds, so if a Player fails to advance in the first Qualifying Round, they can try again in the next Qualifying Round.</p><p><strong>2. Quarterfinal Rounds: </strong>Quarterfinal Rounds behave the same as Qualifying Rounds, except Players play 4 Matches and the top score is 32.</p><p><strong>3. Semifinal Rounds: </strong>Semifinal Rounds behave the same as Qualifying Rounds except Players play 5 Matches and the top score is 40</p><p><strong>4. The Finals: </strong>The Finals behave differently from the other Rounds. In the Finals, all Players from the Semifinals compete in one leaderboard. Prizes are awarded based on ranking on the Leaderboard. If Players tie, the tie-breaker is the number of matches played overall, with fewer matches beating more matches. Two Players with the same score and same number of matches will each receive the prize for that Rank. The Finals require the Player to play 6 Matches, and have 48 as the top score.</p><h3>Tournaments monetize by selling additional Match chances to Players.</h3><p>Players rank on the Tournament Leader based on their Top 3, 4, 5, or 6 Match Scores. While Players can only count their top 3–6 Scores for the purposes of ranking on the Leaderboard, they are allowed to play more matches if they have Tournament Tokens.</p><p>At the beginning of the Round, the Player receives 3, 4, 5, or 6 free Matches so that they can place on the Leaderboard. After that, the Players pay a Tournament Token to play another match. If the Match Placement Score is greater than the lowest Match Score they received to place on that Tournament, <strong>that new score will replace the lowest score and the player has a higher new score.</strong> So if a Player has a 2nd Place, 3rd Place and 5th Place score in the Qualifying Round Leaderboard (7 + 6 + 4 = 17), and pays a Tournament Token to play another match and places 3rd again, that 3rd Place score (6) will replace the 5th Place score (4) to give the Player a new total leaderboard score (7 + 6 + 6 = 19).</p><p>Players can earn Tournament Tokens through the following:</p><ol><li>Galaxy Pass Rewards</li><li>In the Store for an IAP</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Dl86ILJOpwo6MtIC" /></figure><p>The desire to rank high enough on the Leaderboard to advance to the next Round should cause Players to purchase Tournament Tokens. Having an entry cost as an IAP has proved effective in some other games. In Hearthstone, Players can pay $1.99 or 150 Hard Currency to attempt the Arena.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/675/0*UG-f8-M6yRutsH4A" /><figcaption>IAP Costs for Event Entry aren’t new in this space.</figcaption></figure><p>Purchasing additional Match attempts with Tournament Tokens is not P2W. More skillful Players who regularly get in the top 3 or 4 of a match will likely be able to advance once or twice without paying a Tournament Token. If they purchase the Galaxy Pass, the most skillful players can bank their Tournament Tokens earned from the Galaxy Pass to use to get far into a Tournament. But Players who are unlucky in a Free Match and want to try and replace the bad score can pay a Tournament Token.</p><p>With Tournaments running every two weeks, Players can feel free to skip some tournaments and attempt others. Riot should also feel free to differentiate Tournaments along Origins and Classes, or through different Arenas. As with other types of events, it’s important to make Events feel new or different even if it’s one you ran before. As long as enough Players can engage in the Tournaments, there should be sizable monetization from Tournament Tokens.</p><h3>Tactics Events</h3><p>Given how critical Origins and Classes are to tactics used in Matches, it makes sense to have Events that stress those tactics. Tactics Events are one-day events that operate as normal events, but limit the potential Origins and Classes that can be picked to 4 Origins and 6 Classes. For example:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*5Feo27Ob5oebeZm_GLD8ww.png" /><figcaption>A new combination of Origins and Classes for the Tactics Event each Day will keep Players coming back every day.</figcaption></figure><p>The benefits of this format are:</p><ol><li>Players who already excel with the use of Origins/Classes in this event can do even better.</li><li>Players who aren’t as familiar with the combos will have an easier time learning tactics with fewer possible options to pick from.</li><li>Should the Mastery System be adopted, Players who want to increase the mastery level of specific Origins and Classes will have more success doing it during this Event than in general gameplay.</li></ol><p>Tactics Events require a Tactics Token. Tactics Tokens are given out in the same way as Tournament Tokens — through Galactic Pass Rewards and Store IAPs.</p><p>There are more events that can fit with TFT. It all depends on how much Riot feels comfortable pushing Players to engage with gameplay that is gated by inputs that are sold for money.</p><h3>What is the Monetization Impact of these Events?</h3><p>I’ve outlined three Systems in this Article. Based on the proposed designs, I would expect the following Monetization improvements:</p><p><strong>1. Champion Mastery</strong></p><p>Champion Master and the IAP Subscriptions, Minigame, and Ad Boosts are all aimed to increase core Monetization each day. As players join TFT on different days and decide to purchase subscriptions on different days, we should see some monetization from the Subscriptions each day. Similarly, Players who enjoy the Minigame and are apt to spend a few dollars will contribute to daily Monetization. Finally, nonspenders will engage with Ad Boosts to increase the Mastery Points earned. Those Ads watched will provide a non-insignificant source of revenue given TFT’s expected audience size.</p><p><strong>2. Tournaments</strong></p><p>Tournaments are designed to create revenue spikes on certain days during the Event. When Tournaments first start, we probably wouldn’t see a lot of spend on Tournament Tokens during the Qualifying Rounds, as Players have multiple attempts to get through the Qualifying Rounds. Beginning with the Quarterfinal Rounds, we should begin to see more spend on Tournament Tokens. Revenue will begin spiking during the Semifinal Rounds, and will reach it’s peak during the Finals. This revenue spike behavior should repeat as Tournaments repeat.</p><p><strong>3. Tactics Events</strong></p><p>Like Champion Mastery, Tactics Events should raise core monetization each day, with small spikes on days when the Origin/Class combination is very compelling to the bulk of Players. Tactics Events also give Riot an opportunity to use Player data when it comes to Origin/Class combos to ensure that the Origin/Class offerings in each day’s Tactics Events will be compelling to at least a good chunk of the Player base.</p><p>F2P Mechanics have proven to be capable of earning a game billions of dollars over the years. Yet not all F2P Mechanics are equal. Some designs absolutely do make a game P2W. But others can not only avoid making a game P2W, but can add long-term direction and goals that will make the player experience more satisfying. We will see what Riot chooses to do with TFT.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7c7f158d459" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/can-riot-make-tft-a-billion-dollar-game-7c7f158d459">Can Riot make TFT a Billion Dollar Game?</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Battle Pass Q&A you didn’t know you Needed]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/ggdigest/the-battle-pass-q-a-you-didnt-know-you-needed-267d24473342?source=rss-3b9857ab4532------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/267d24473342</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[game-design]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jeff Witt]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Jun 2020 00:39:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-06-26T00:39:32.175Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Battle Pass integration in top grossing games has skyrocketed over the past few years. Unfortunately, we’ve seen mixed results in the implementation of Battle Pass in games. During a recent event we discussed how to implement Battle Pass successfully. Here are the answers to some of the top questions. If you have more questions that I didn’t cover here, please send them to us here at ggDigest. Enjoy!</p><h3>How do you price the Battle Pass?</h3><p>This is always a tough question to ask as pricing is really relative to the perceived value you plan to offer based on player expectations in your game. But there are two things you should keep in mind when pricing your Battle Pass:</p><ol><li><strong>The value you give for the price of the Battle Pass should be significantly greater than what a Player can get with a one-time purchase.</strong></li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EqOnVgvCCKLUl0bj" /></figure><p>AFK Arena is a good example of this. For $25 you get a lot more bang for your buck then other similarly-priced one-time sales:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/367/0*tXH79D6wgp1WJJka" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/381/0*s_acqRmFJz3rk3Ep" /></figure><p>Presenting the Player with a lot more perceived value with a Battle Pass than anything they can <strong>immediately </strong>buy is a good way to make Battle Pass more appealing from a spend perspective.</p><p><strong>2. Err on the side of the price being higher so you have room to reduce the cost if needed.</strong></p><p>Higher Prices can be lowered without much backlash from Players. But raising prices can violate Player Expectations and should be avoided if necessary. So start higher for your initial season and then lower it for future seasons if you don’t get enough engagement. You can also run mid-season deals to get more players into the Battle Pass at a discount.</p><h3>How do you determine the duration of a Battle Pass?</h3><p>Ideally you are using your Battle Pass to push your Players to engage in the game in a certain way. While there is no definitive answer to how long a Battle Pass Season should run for, you should make sure that the duration is compatible with everything else happening in the game.</p><p>So if you have a live-ops cycle that Players are accustomed to, it might be good to make your Battle Pass the same length of your live-ops cadence or some multiple thereof. Monthly or Quarterly are easy to use as well. Again, there are no right answers here, but the more synergy Battle Pass Duration has with everything else you are doing in your game, the better.</p><h3>What are the Best Industry Examples of Battle Pass Implementation?</h3><p>As a Game Designer, I am a big fan of using features to solve or mitigate existing problems in your games in addition to improving on what is working. So in my opinion, the best implementation of the Battle Pass are those implementations that did the best to fix a problem or improve a situation in their games.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/0*SK7BEByd9Tl90EoH" /></figure><p>One of the best implementations of Battle Pass is from the OG itself — <strong>Fortnite</strong>. As a Battle Royale Game with no sort of progression system in the game, Fortnite really ran the risk of having Players get tired of it early and churn if they were forced to compete in the Battle Royale over and over again. But the brilliance of their Battle Pass is that suddenly you had a ton of non-Battle Royale things to do that would help you progress as much or more as those that dominate the Battle Royale.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*7KH4BldENqQPgpaJ" /></figure><p>Fortnite utilizes their Battle Pass Challenges to keep their players engaged in ways that aren’t too time-consuming, that are easily done through Mobile or on PC/Console, and that still show off the great vanity items that players earn. In the case of Fortnite, the Battle Pass solves a huge direction/engagement problem the game would have otherwise had without Battle Pass.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*1XJ4FfSbFHJKhtC6" /></figure><p>Another good implementation of the Battle Pass is in <strong>8-Ball Pool</strong>. During the Discussion Panel on Battle Pass, I strongly argued that Battle Pass is mainly an Engagement/Conversion Feature, and not a Monetization Feature. The Pool Pass in 8-Ball Pool is an example of how the Battle Pass can strongly impact monetization. Because 8-Ball Pool requires chips to play Matches, using the Battle Pass to increase engagement will by definition increase the chips sunk to play Matches.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/846/0*5XbSv_EhWlGczAc2" /></figure><p>Combined with incentives to play higher cost Tables to complete Daily Missions and get Pool Points, the Battle Pass has proven to improve 8-Ball Pool’s core monetization.</p><p>There may be other examples of the Battle Pass being implemented in a way that solved core problems or improved existing performance. If you have examples, please shoot them our way at ggDigest!</p><h3>How do you think Battle Passes can add Drive more Value?</h3><p>Like my other answers, the answer to this is kind of relative to what is going on in the game. But at a high level, the Battle Pass will add value if the engagement it drives adds value. If you are working on a Game that has low retention and poor session metrics, it’s possible that adding a Battle Pass can improve that if Players have more direction and more direction creates a better Player experience. Should the Battle Pass improve retention and player session metrics, then it is clear adding it to your game created a ton of Value.</p><p>Similarly, if you mainly monetize off of your events, but find engagement in your events lackluster, implementing a Battle Pass that drives increased engagement in your events will have created Value if the monetization from events increase.</p><p>The Battle Pass is certainly capable of driving Value. The question is whether game companies can implement it in a targeted way that actually solves a problem the game is having, and not just shove it into the Game just because it is popular in Fortnite.</p><h3>If a Battle Pass is too difficult to complete, would it not discourage picking up the Battle Pass?</h3><p>There have been a lot of questions about how much effort or time it should take to complete a Battle Pass. In general, you should leave enough room for Players who don’t want to complete some of the more odious challenges to skip them and still complete the Battle Pass without paying <strong>if they engage in the game enough</strong>. A Battle Pass that allows players to complete it in 70% of the time it is available gives Players room to pick and choose what challenges they want to complete.</p><p>Giving players some breathing room allows you to make the Challenges more difficult and hopefully drive more indirect monetization. For Spenders who don’t spend the same amount of time as free players, the higher difficulty challenges combined with the less time they spend playing may push them to spend to complete the Battle Pass.</p><h3>What do you think Clash Royale should have done to implement a successful Battle Pass?</h3><p>Personally, I would have Players progress through the Battle Pass in Clash Royale by opening Chests rather than earn Crowns. Earning Crowns doesn’t cost Players anything but Time. And given that the Battle Pass was giving away a lot of objective value, it is very possible that Clash Royale’s Battle Pass cannibalized monetization, which is exactly what you don’t want to do when implementing Battle Pass.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*OW21uCw9M_kT_3K-" /></figure><p>Had Supercell instead give out Battle Pass Points every time a Chest is opened (whether through timed chests or purchased chests), then Progress through the Battle Pass is pegged to a time cost that Players can spend Gems to speed up. This almost certainly would monetize better than Clash Royale’s current implementation of the Battle Pass. <strong>Now it’s entirely possible that Players will view this design as too greedy</strong>. But the design directly touches on Monetization in a way that using Crowns to progress doesn’t.</p><h3>How important is the revenue from tier skips in the overall BP model?</h3><p>I don’t have any inside information about how much revenue comes from Tier Skips versus Battle Pass Activation. I strongly suspect that Tier Skips don’t generate a lot of revenue outside of the Battle Pass Activation + Tier Skip bundles.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_sJ88lBjMIlbLWBu" /></figure><p>These more expensive IAPs not only activate the Battle Pass for Players, but also have them skip the first X Tiers. Outside of those Bundles, you probably don’t see much revenue generation until when the Season is nearly over and stragglers pay to complete the Season before time runs out.</p><p>Note that these Tier skips should only be available for Games whose Battle Pass is designed for <strong>engagement only</strong>. Its OK to sell Tier Skips in engagement-oriented Battle Passes because you are more concerned with Players coming back and grinding their way to completing the Battle Pass, so selling Tier Skips is just icing on the cake. But the moment you design your Battle Pass for monetization, <strong>TAKE OUT THE TIER SKIPS</strong>. Tier Skips will undermine any sort of monetization you expect to receive from Players completing challenges.</p><h3>Is it OK to give out enough Premium Currency in a Battle Pass to purchase the next one?</h3><p>Again, this depends on the motivations for adding the Battle Pass into your game in the first place. If the Battle Pass is merely for engagement, then yes it is fine to give enough Premium Currency to purchase the next Battle Pass.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/750/0*pmEUAY0x4yh07n-u" /></figure><p>Because you are deriving benefits by having Players return to your game and engage in your gameplay to complete the Battle Pass, it is perfectly fine to give them enough currency for the next Battle Pass. Best-case scenario, you sink the currency you gave out and the Player must pay for the next Battle Pass anyways. Worse-case scenario, the Player has enough Premium Currency to activate the next Battle Pass and you have that Player retained for another season.</p><p>In general though, I think its better to have Battle Passes activate through IAPs instead of Premium Currency…</p><h3>When is the best moment to introduce your player to the BP?</h3><p>In general there is no right answer to this. I personally wouldn’t introduce it while Players are still learning the ropes of the game — i.e. Not on Day 1. I would also ensure that most of the features the Battle Pass Challenges will utilize are unlocked when a Player first sees the Battle Pass. While theoretically you don’t need the Player to have unlocked everything to start engaging in the Battle Pass, it is a bad player experience to have challenges that they can’t immediately complete or work on.</p><p>That’s it from me. Please send more design questions to us and we’ll answer them here at ggDigest!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=267d24473342" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest/the-battle-pass-q-a-you-didnt-know-you-needed-267d24473342">The Battle Pass Q&amp;A you didn’t know you Needed</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/ggdigest">ggDigest.com</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>