<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jen Kiaba on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jen Kiaba on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jenkiaba?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 09:20:47 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jenkiaba/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Toxic Workplaces and the Cult Survivor]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/toxic-workplaces-and-the-cult-survivor-453e8506436a?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/453e8506436a</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[workplace-culture]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-recovery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healing-from-trauma]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 16 Jul 2021 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-19T20:16:41.294Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*f6nYm8-RqsVkDWrL" /></figure><p>In my last year in the Unification Church, I worked for a non-profit called The International Interreligious Federation for World Peace (IIFWP), one of the Church’s many front groups. The core work involved putting on conferences and related events that surreptitiously forwarded the mission and ethos of the Unification Church, and my job had me traveling all across the world as support staff. The rest of the staff was also made up of membership of the Unification Church, which meant that we worked long hours in conditions that did not meet labor standard, without sufficient breaks, and with very little pay.</p><p>Sometimes, to save money, leadership would call on other members to volunteer and swell the staff ranks so that we could pull off the events that Rev. Moon demanded. Often I could at least fight for the volunteers that worked under me to receive an honorarium and have their accommodations covered. Usually it meant that we slept packed like sardines in a hotel room, the ground completely covered with sleeping bags. But we were used to it. That’s how it always was when you worked for the Church.</p><p>Then during the first day of a conference in New York City, my boss came into my makeshift office in the New Yorker Hotel. I had been tasked with heading up ground transportation, and my team was deployed at the city airports greeting guests and dignitaries. I turned away from the wall plastered with maps of the city and marked with routes to the local airports to greet my boss. He cleared his throat and wouldn’t meet my eyes as the voices of my team crackled from the walkie talkie I had holstered at my hip.</p><p>“Is everything ok?” As a woman, I knew I shouldn’t speak first. It wasn’t a hard and fast rule; still, it marked me as aggressive. But I just couldn’t help myself.</p><p>“Ah,” my boss coughed slightly, like he was stalling for time.</p><p>I pressed my lips together, fighting the urge to demand an answer. That would <em>definitely</em> mark me as aggressive, not at all an admirable quality for a woman in the Church.</p><p>He took a deep breath. “Dr. Yang has decided that your volunteers can’t stay in the hotel. We don’t have enough room and need all of the spaces for guest.” Dr. Yang was the continental leader for the United States; his word was practically as sacrosanct as Rev. Moon’s.</p><p>It took me a moment to process the information before I bit off a reply. “Excuse me? What do you mean we don’t have enough room?”</p><p>My boss shrugged. “Dr. Yang says that the volunteers should be grateful that they’re working for True Parents and the Providence, and that they shouldn’t expect accommodations.”</p><p>I fought the urge to growl my answer and instead articulated every work as slowly and precisely as possible. “We have always taken care of accommodations. Of course they should expect them.” I paused and looked at my boss as he changed color from pale to pink and back to pale again. Women definitely weren’t supposed to speak so forcefully.</p><p>He started to speak, to invoke Dr. Yang’s name again, but I shook my head.</p><p>“The Church owns this hotel, and there is literally an entire floor of the hotel that’s unoccupied.”</p><p>My boss rolled his eyes at my suggestion. “That’s because it’s being renovated for dorm rooms. There are no beds or anything in them.”</p><p>I turned towards my desk, grabbed a sheaf of papers that detailed the guests’ arrivals and brandished it towards my boss. “We’ll be lucky if we finish before midnight! I’d rather people sleep on the floor than have to find their way home from fucking LaGuardia in the middle of the night, and be back here at 5am!”</p><p>My boss blanched again; whether it was from my use of profanity or my defiance, I didn’t know.</p><p>“I’m not making anyone go home,” I said through my teeth, suddenly not caring if I got fired. “I won’t let anyone treat my team like this.”</p><p>My boss glared at me before turning to leave. “I’ll see what I can do.”</p><p>I waited for the door to click shut behind him before collapsing in my chair and burying my head on my desk. The discussion had exhausted me, and I still had hours to go. My day wouldn’t end until at least 2am, and I wasn’t sure how I would make it. But at least I was sitting; unlike my team members who were running from terminal to terminal to greet guests. I’d done that work for years, and wanted to do everything in my power to make their jobs easier. And if a spot to sleep on the floor was the best I could do, then I was going to fight to make it happen.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*KA4kWxzv2GOD3gFKlH0atg.jpeg" /><figcaption>A rare moment of rest during my church job</figcaption></figure><p>Anyone who has worked for an abusive or cultic organization can probably relate to that story. In fact, that I ever got paid at all for my work is probably an anomaly in the cult world. Cults thrive on the unpaid labor of their members, and the conditions that those members toil under are exploitative. Of course, while one is in a group like this, that’s not how you are trained to look at it. You’re indoctrinated to believe that you’re volunteering for a cause, or doing providential work — and it’s an honor to be involved.</p><p>In his post <a href="https://matthewremski.medium.com/the-goodness-of-a-cult-comes-from-those-it-abuses-e7ade183688c">The Goodness of a Cult Comes from Those it Abuses</a>, investigative journalist and <a href="http://conspirituality.net/">Conspirituality podcast </a>cohost Matthew Remski writes:</p><blockquote><em>“survivors were stripped of time, security, money, earning potential, educational opportunities, social status, family bonds, bodily autonomy and inner dignity. I hear stories of endless hours of unpaid labour, undertaken with the promise of salvation. […]These details constitute the cultic crime scene. An organization has exploited its members, and left human wreckage. Their stories can be told, corroborated, fact-checked, and published. […] The invisibility of the survivor’s work is a feature in many other cases of institutional abuse.”</em></blockquote><p>Remski’s thesis is that beauty that survivors and members remember from a group often comes from the organization’s encouragement and exploitation of the skills of those it abused. And I really want to hone in on the latter part of the sentence: the fact that people who are involved in these groups are exploited, and experienced institutionalized abuse.</p><p>Cult survivors make great little worker bees (and I say this with a lot of love, respect, and a huge dose of sarcasm), at least in the minds of bosses; especially second and multi-generational survivors. But this is because we spent years working in an exploitative and abusive system that formed the basis for our work ethics. And the stakes were always high: if we didn’t run ourselves ragged, we weren’t contributing to the salvation of humanity! And if we weren’t working as hard as everyone else, we were lazy or selfish (or inviting Satan in). Often it was hard for us to even recognize those systems as problematic, because they were so normalized within the cult framework.</p><p>It becomes even more difficult as we transition into the larger “outside” culture, because we can carry old black and white thinking with us. After all, if an environment isn’t the cult, it should be healthy, right? Obviously, most of us know that the answer is “wrong.” But a cult specialist once told me that second generation survivors often over-estimate the world, and thus we don’t expect to be faced with similarly toxic dynamics as those we left behind when we broke free of our groups — again, if we are even able to recognize them as toxic.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*z-6OYL-PVuU3rZNWT5j4DA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Many cult survivors don’t expect to be faced with similarly toxic dynamics as those they left behind when they broke free of their abusive groups.</figcaption></figure><p>For example, years ago I was only a few months into a new job and my company wanted to send my team to a conference. But, to save money they wanted to put us up in a cheap hotel at the outskirts of the city and have me share a room with my male colleague. Despite the fact that I had moments of being outspoken in my cult days, I <em>needed</em> this new job to survive, and was afraid to say that rooming with a male near-stranger wasn’t something that I was comfortable with. Even when my colleague noticed my discomfort he kept saying things like, “come on, it’s not a big deal.”</p><p>Luckily my boss decided that it probably wasn’t good policy to have the lone female new-hire bunking with a male teammate, but that experience set a precedent for me. It taught me that my company did not value me, my comfort or safety, and that saving a few hundred dollars was more important. And this set the stage for the years to come. Despite being one of the hardest working employees, I struggled to set appropriate boundaries and took on roles way beyond my job description while being paid significantly less than my white male counterparts. (Most women and BIPOC workers can probably relate!)</p><p>There were also consequences for speaking up at this job. Once a VP pulled me into a back room and screamed at me for asking a question in a meeting. This same leader also screamed at me over the phone after I asked a question during a performance review. But leaders were just modeling the behavior of the owners, who often screamed at employees behind closed doors.</p><p>And unfortunately I didn’t know any better. Even though my gut told me that this was all wrong, I’d had several “outside” jobs where management behaved similarly. So I just kept my head down, working as hard as I could, hoping to simultaneously avoid being screamed at while hoping to be noticed for my good work. I’m not the only survivor who has experienced toxic workplace culture.</p><h3>The Impact of Cult Membership on Career Development</h3><p>While I think that many bosses probably do admire the work ethic of their survivor employees (and they usually are not made aware of the employee’s survivor status, because we often keep it hidden for fear of stigma), I think that there is little recognition of how the culture of the American workplace taps into and triggers the old wiring of survivors. So I polled my online community of mostly second generation survivors and asked if transitioning into the American workforce had triggered the toxic work ethic they had been raised with. Here’s what some of them had to say:</p><ul><li>There is a constant fear of being stuck in a system which tries to control me. So I change jobs a lot. It made me extremely sensitive to narcissistic behavior of superiors.</li><li>I’ve had to work with my therapist to establish boundaries in the workplace.</li><li>Habits ingrained by the Unification Church have crippled my work abilities. These scars run deep.</li><li>I stayed and endured an abusive relationship with a boss for over a year. I think a lot of it stems from my learned ability to endure toxic systems/environments.</li><li>I was lucky to get into tech but took a low offer and struggled to learn to advocate for myself.</li><li>As an ER nurse I’m hyper responsive and it annoys my coworkers.</li><li>I still have a fear of leadership and put the company needs over my own (worked when sick, etc.). Also a feeling of disconnect from other employees.</li></ul><p>In her dissertation <a href="https://etd.ohiolink.edu/apexprod/rws_etd/send_file/send?accession=ohiou1242395946&amp;disposition=inline"><em>The Impact of Cult Membership on Career Development and Employment</em></a>Alissa A. Leisure Whitlatch, Ph.D. cites Dr. Margaret Singer and Dr. Janja Lalich’s book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Cults-Our-Midst-Continuing-Against/dp/0787967416"><em>Cults in Our Midst: The Continuing Fight Against Their Hidden Menace</em></a><em>, </em>where they say that the central goals of cults are recruiting new members and raising money for the benefit of the leader. Several of the books included in Whitlatch’s research indicate that, in many cases, a cult strips its members of their identities and leaves them debilitated on many levels: financially, vocationally, spiritually, physically, sexually, and emotionally.</p><p>According to Whitlatch, little attention has been given to the benefits of vocational rehabilitation or career counseling in facilitating a former cult member’s recovery and reintegration into society. And yet, in my personal experience, it was both a fundamental and incredibly difficult aspect of both my survival and integration processes (because as a second generation adult I was not <strong>re</strong>-integrating).</p><p>Whitlatch says that in addition to the economic aspects of work, (a nice way of saying the fundamental survival aspect of it: roof over our head, food on the table), authors Edwin Herr and Stanley Cramer noted in their book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Guidance-Counseling-Lifespan-Systematic-Approaches/dp/B0028KR2SS/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&amp;keywords=Career%20guidance%20and%20counseling%20through%20the%20lifespan%3A%20Systematic%20approaches&amp;qid=1626388279&amp;s=books&amp;sr=1-2"><em>Career guidance and counseling through the lifespan: Systematic approaches</em></a>that meaningful employment is associated with many positive psychological traits. These include self-esteem, personal identity, feelings of dependability and reliability and a sense of competency. However, Whitlatch says, these positive psychological traits are undermined by the cult experience.</p><p>She goes on to say that membership in a cult weakens an individual’s self-concept as this view of self is replaced by the beliefs and practices of the group. Therefore, she says that an important part of the recovery process for former cult members involves a restoration of the self-concept. Again this writing is very much first generation joiner-specific and does not address the second and multi generational experience, where one’s <strong><em>entire</em></strong>self concept is defined by the group, so there is no restoration of self-concept. Rather it is a complete disintegration of self-concept and a building from a kind of ground-zero.</p><p>There are many complications for people leaving cults, and some struggle with psychological difficulties in their integration/reintegration processes. In their book <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/taking-back-your-life-recovering-from-cults-and-abusive-relationships/9780972002158"><em>Take Back Your Life: Recovering from Cults and Abusive Relationships</em></a>, authors Dr. Janja Lalich and Madeline Tobais say that some of the possible psychological difficulties include: trouble sleeping, restlessness, memory loss, depression, lack of direction, panic attacks and ongoing experiences of varying emotions such as guilt, shame, enragement, confusion, betrayal, paranoia and feelings of being lost and in a fog. In <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Cults-Our-Midst-Continuing-Against/dp/0787967416"><em>Cults in Our Midst</em></a><em>,</em> Dr. Margaret Singer and Dr. Janja Lalich identified several effects resulting from cult participation: depression and a sense of alienation, loneliness, low self-esteem and low self-confidence, phobic-like effects around people, fear of joining groups or making a commitment, distrust of professional services, doubt about their ability to make good decisions and problems establishing the values they will live by.</p><p>Whitlatch also references <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Trauma-Recovery-Aftermath-Violence-Political/dp/0465061710"><em>Trauma and Recovery: The Aftermath of Violence — From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror</em></a>by Judith Herman, who explains that trauma shatters the construction of the self and affects systems of attachment and meaning that link people and the community together. Herman also says that trauma destroys a person’s assumptions about the safety of the world, positive self-viewpoints, and the meaningful order of the universe. Therefore, she says, traumatized people feel alone, disconnected, and alienated and thus need support in rebuilding a positive sense of self and in restoring personal worth. In her book <a href="https://www.amazon.com/s?i=stripbooks&amp;ref=dp_byline_sr_book_1&amp;rh=p_27%3AJudith%20Lewis%20Herman&amp;s=relevancerank&amp;text=Judith%20Lewis%20Herman"><em>Complex PTSD: A syndrome in survivors of prolonged and repeated trauma</em></a>, Herman states that Complex PTSD can occur with prolonged and repeated trauma, such as conditions where an individual is held in captivity under the control of a perpetrator and is unable to flee. She also says that Complex PTSD may occur in some religious cults, prisons and concentration camps.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*diTnaONoSeGaFq8DqpNqDw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Domestic abuse survivors and cult survivors have similarities in terms of the coercive control they experienced.</figcaption></figure><p>Unfortunately there is a the lack of research to date examining the relationship between work, career development and vocational rehabilitation services with cults members. So for her dissertation, Whitlatch examined these issues through the lens of other populations who are victims of coercive relationships and experience similar psychosocial traumas to those of cult members. One group that meets these criteria, she says, consists of victims of domestic violence including “battered women.” She posits that the insights gained from — again unfortunately limited — research that examines the importance of work and vocational rehabilitation for victims of abusive domestic relationships can be applied to cult survivor victims when appropriate.</p><p>She says that based on the emotional turmoil that battered women and cult survivors endured throughout their time in the cult and in recovery, an emotional disability or emotional impairment could develop that would qualify survivors for public vocational rehabilitation services. Both populations, she says, have to address dependence upon their abuser or cult leader, a sense of isolation, low self-esteem and a loss of independence. In addition, they both have to re-establish their identities and gain the necessary skills to reintegrate themselves back into society. And, of course, many battered women come away from their experiences with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder.</p><p>Unfortunately, as with everything else, there is also a lack of research on vocational issues among former cult members who have PTSD, so Whitlatch pulled in research on other populations that struggle with PTSD. For example, she cites a study called <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4231273/"><em>Posttraumatic stress disability after motor vehicle accidents: Impact on productivity and employment</em></a>, wherein the research suggested that PTSD is a general risk factor for underemployment and reduced economic functioning.</p><p>Another study she references, <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9426857/"><em>Independent living skills and posttraumatic stress disorder in women who are homeless: implications for future practice</em></a> investigated PTSD in women without homes and the role of occupational therapy in assisting in the development of independent living skills. The study found that symptoms of PTSD may interfere with the ability to perform activities of daily living such as avoidance and numbing symptoms, which are related to withdrawal from social networks and from participation in activities.</p><p>Whitlatch also cites several authors who state that many symptoms of PTSD could interfere with successful employment and vocational behavior including difficulty concentrating, anger outbursts, sleep disturbances, efforts to avoid things associated with the event, feeling detached, restricted affect, intrusive memories, flashbacks, distress when exposed to similar cues, foreshortened sense of the future, and heightened startle response. She says that if these symptoms are exhibited in certain vocational situations, the outcomes could be detrimental to successfully maintaining employment. Additionally, it could be particularly challenging if the work environment did not accommodate the individual to address these issues.</p><p>In her research for her dissertation, she did a search of professional counseling literature, and found that there appears to minimal information on actual accommodations in the work force of individuals with PTSD. But, she says, individuals with psychiatric disabilities can have productive and meaningful employment with the implementation of effective job accommodations. Examples of reasonable accommodations, she says, include modifications to the physical environment, schedule modifications, work procedure modifications, job restructuring, and changes in interpersonal communication. In addition, she emphasizes that it is important to be able to recognize traumatic triggers in the workplace to aid in coming up with solutions before problems occur.</p><p>Public vocational rehabilitation agencies exist in all states in the US, and provide services to individuals who have severe mental, physical and developmental disabilities that hinder their career development and employment. Whitlatch posits that these resources may be important throughout the cult recovery process and could play an important role in restoring the individual’s vocational and personal identities.</p><p>According to Whitlatch, policy makers’ failing to address the impact that cult involvement had on a person’s career development and vocational functioning may contribute to a poor quality of life as a result of chronic unemployment, underemployment and increased reliance on public support systems. However, I think it is also important to note that, according to Dr. Janja Lalich, in an interview with Stephen Mather on the <a href="https://www.evilsheep.co.uk/whatshouldithinkabout">What Should I Think About</a> podcast, there are very few social services available to second and multigenerational cult survivors. In part, I think this is because there is such a dearth of research available on these segments of the population; we will need both research and advocacy in order to understand and then create the services necessary, as well as to advocate for the implementation of proper workplace aid.</p><p>Unfortunately, until workplace management and policy makers are convinced of the importance of implementing those kinds of supports and services, survivors have to learn to advocate for themselves and navigate these often toxic environments. So let’s take a dive into the culture of the American workplace, look at why it can toxic, how that toxicity can often parallel the survivor’s experience within a cultic environment, and what we can do to protect ourselves.</p><h3>Toxic Productivity Dogma in America</h3><p>In Amanda Montell’s book <a href="https://www.oblongbooks.com/book/9780062993151"><em>Cultish: The Language of Fanaticism</em></a><em>,</em> she refers to what she calls toxic productivity dogma in American culture when she writes:</p><blockquote><em>The Protestant ethic remains very much a part of professional culture as a whole in the United States, and we all grow up internalizing its rhetoric- work hard, play hard; another day, another dollar. My partner and I have an extensive collection of coffee mugs embellished with little sayings, and the other day I looked up and noticed for the first time that they all just shameless evangelize toxic productivity dogma: One mug says “Sleep is for the weak”; another reads “A yawn is just a silent scream for coffee.” A silent scream? Are we all so conditioned to believe it’s romantic to be overworked and exhausted, so terrified of leisure and “laziness,” that we print cute jokes about it on drinkware? In twenty-first-century America, apparently so.</em></blockquote><p>The former cult kid in me shudders, especially at the “sleep is for the weak,” because it’s something I so internalized growing up. But the messages don’t even have to be that blatantly culty. I have a shirt that I got for free at a marketing conference I attended years back that simply has the word “Hustle” emblazoned on the front. Without going into an analysis of late-stage Capitalism, I think we all recognize the ethos that that single word has come to represent.</p><p>In a 2019 Forbes article entitled, <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/bryanrobinson/2019/10/21/the-turbulent-and-toxic-state-of-the-nations-work-culture-what-you-absolutely-must-know-and-do/?sh=11b7627e4564"><em>The Turbulent And Toxic State Of The Nation’s Work Culture: What You Absolutely Must Know And Do</em></a>, psychotherapist <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/bryanrobinson/">Bryan Robinson, Ph.D.</a> writes</p><blockquote><em>The global work culture’s language reflects the pervasive acceleration, turbulence, sickness and burnout in today’s job environments: </em>dead<em>lines instead of </em>life<em>lines; </em>sick<em> days instead of </em>mental health <em>days; </em>rise and grind <em>instead of </em>rise and shine; work load<em> instead of </em>work schedule; side hustle (<em>“hustle” is defined as </em>“<em>force someone to move hurriedly”</em>)<em> instead of </em>part-time work<em> and </em>job burnout <em>instead of </em>job engagement.</blockquote><p>He goes on to cite a survey of 1,016 American workers that found a majority of the workforce has job burnout, widespread reliance on side jobs and declining confidence in their job security. Key findings of the study are:</p><ul><li>38% of American workers cite a lack of time for their personal lives</li><li>40% say they work between eight and 12 hours a day</li><li>23% report a negative workplace culture</li><li>26% lack an opportunity for advancement</li><li>1/3 have a side hustle</li><li>21% cite unclear job expectations</li><li>14% report bad relationships with the boss</li></ul><p>The report <a href="https://pages.shrm.org/2019culturereport?_ga=2.242510337.2005368058.1569443261-1126118054.1500058103"><em>The High Cost of a Toxic Workplace Culture</em></a> by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) explored the impact of workplace culture on the well-being of workers and the bottom line of businesses and found a toxic workplace culture costs companies a fortune in turnover and absenteeism. Findings of the survey included:</p><ul><li>49% of American workers have thought about leaving their current organization, while nearly one in five have left a job due to a toxic workplace culture in the past five years.</li><li>76% of American workers said their manager sets the culture, yet 36% said their manager did not know how to lead a team.</li><li>26% of American workers said they dreaded going into work.</li></ul><p><a href="https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/hr-topics/employee-relations/pages/toxic-workplace-culture-report.aspx">SHRM defines toxic workplaces</a> as “where employees dread going to work, don’t feel they can be honest with their manager, and may witness or experience sexual harassment or age discrimination.” According to SHRM, toxic workplaces are a primary reason workers quit their jobs and they often hold their managers responsible for creating the toxicity.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20210330-why-toxic-workplace-cultures-follow-you-home">Aditya Jain, an associate professor in human resource management at Nottingham University Business School, who has studied stress, wellbeing and mental health in the workplace, told the BBC that</a> “a toxic work culture is one where workers are exposed to psychosocial hazards. They may have little or no organizational support, poor interpersonal relationships, high workload, lack of autonomy, poor rewards and a lack of job security.”</p><p>Jain says that the consequences of such work cultures are wide-ranging, and may include individual physical health impacts, like heart disease or musculoskeletal disorders, poor mental health and burnout, as well as organizational fallout, like reduced attendance, engagement, productivity and innovation.</p><p>According to the article, toxic work cultures originate with poor management, whose bad habits can be contagious. “Destructive behaviors at the top trickle down,” says Manuela Priesemuth, an associate professor in the management and operations department at Villanova University, who has researched <a href="https://hbr.org/2020/06/times-up-for-toxic-workplaces">abusive managers and toxic workplaces</a>. “If executives engage in toxic behavior, people in the organization assume this behavior is accepted and they engage in it, too. Soon enough, a toxic climate is formed, where everybody thinks, ‘This is just how we act around here’.”</p><p>Interestingly, it seems, American management hasn’t gotten that memo. After I left the abusive, non-cult job I shared about, I went on a round of interviews. One CEO said to me, “It sounds like you left your last three jobs because of toxic workplaces?” Even though I hadn’t said as much, I had cited circumstances that did point to toxic behavior in management, so I nodded. “And yet,” he drew the words out and did that condescending templed finger motion before continuing. “The common denominator is you.”</p><p>Needless to say I was not offered that job, nor would I have taken it. (Bullet dodged I think.) But this story does highlight the unfortunate tendency of management to deflect blame around culture issues back on employees. And there are several things about this behavior that feel just a little bit culty to me. No wonder more than a quarter of Americans dread going to work!</p><p>With the previously discussed statistical findings in mind, psychotherapist Bryan Robinson asks the question “why does productivity come at the expense of health and well-being? They’re not mutually exclusive, and there’s no reason today’s work world can’t have both. Still statistics show a rise in employees who are reluctant to take off days when they’re sick for fear of reprisal from management.” He also cites a Gallup poll that says 70% of American workers hate their jobs. (And of course all of this data pre-dates COVID, where trepidation around working conditions increased and the work-life balance practically disappeared for many who were lucky enough to work remotely.)</p><p>Overall Robinson’s article is directed more towards company leadership, telling them that it’s in the company’s best interest to address worker’s complaints. He puts it into purely capitalist terms when he says, “If allowed to continue, the toxicity and dissatisfaction will hurt the company’s bottom line. Workplace performance will drop, and the organization’s integrity will be compromised.”</p><p>In the job that I shared about earlier, when workplace performance dropped and the company’s bottom line suffered, leadership decided to track performance even more closely. They held long meetings, presenting to us about our Key Performance Indicators and even went into each person’s client portfolio on a monthly basis, tracking what upsells we had and hadn’t made. Even though selling wasn’t technically our job, we were ridiculed in front of over employees if we didn’t sell our clients on a new service every few months. (Is anyone’s else thinking about Lifton’s cultic criteria, “The Cult of Confession” that I discussed in my previous post <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/were-you-brainwashed-cults"><em>Were you brainwashed?</em></a>)</p><p>Unfortunately, leadership didn’t know how to address the toxic culture, so they minimized it and retaliated against employees. But, according to Robinson, all this does is makes a company a “revolving door for workers,” and he says “it will be more difficult to attract and retain talented employees who can always find a mentally healthier and more attractive work environment.” And he’s right. Every single toxic workplace that I’ve ever experienced also had mass exoduses of employees.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*HIJc7tL4jfb9-9WlrEG87A.jpeg" /><figcaption>A ass exodus can occur in companies with toxic cultures.</figcaption></figure><p>Robinson says that, “workers fare well when management communicates praise and encouragement, fosters clarity about workplace expectations and provides tools an employee needs along with the opportunity to feel challenged.” He cites Tony Schwartz-whose organization, The Energy Project, studied the invisible phenomena that stand in the way of organizational transformation and sustainable high workplace performance, who said, “Burnout will only get worse so long as organizations fail to challenge the ‘more, bigger, faster is better’ mindset.”</p><p><strong>Toxic Workplace Warning Signs</strong></p><p>In the wake of allegations of toxic workplace culture at the Ellen show, <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2020/09/23/3-toxic-workplace-warning-signs-to-look-out-for.html">CNBC published an article with three warning signs to look out for</a>.</p><p><strong>1. A lack of respect</strong></p><p>Linda Seabrook, general counsel and director at <a href="https://www.futureswithoutviolence.org/">Futures Without Violence</a>, told CNBC that “a toxic workplace is one in which employees don’t feel safe or respected,” and said that while many workers know if they’re not being respected, there are also specific warning signs to look out for.</p><p>“For example, if you feel the weight of intense hierarchical structures, that is not a good sign. Like, <em>Do I have to let my supervisor know if I’m going to the bathroom?</em> Or if workers don’t feel that they have the ability to voice their concerns without fear of retaliation,” she says. “It comes down to whether you feel heard and valued and respected.”</p><p><strong>2. Retaliation for raising concerns</strong></p><p>Another telltale sign of a toxic workplace is an inability to raise concerns, says Ana Avendano, an adjunct law professor at the City University of New York School of Law and the co-founder of<a href="https://survivorsknow.org/about/"> Survivors Know</a>, a nonprofit that aims to combat sexual harassment in the workplace. In a toxic workplace, workers “are not really allowed to complain,” she says. “If they do, complaints are either ignored, or you’re punished for it.”</p><p><strong>3. Power imbalance</strong></p><p>In their article, CNBC Make It said that many of the experts they spoke with said that when an imbalance of power is used to take advantage of others, it is a telltale sign of a toxic workplace. Stephen Boardman, communications director for the Service Employees International Union, says “My definition of a toxic workplace would be a place where employers use their power and leverage to take advantage of and abuse their workers.”</p><h3>How Toxic Work Culture Can Become Cult-ish</h3><p>So now that we know that nearly 20% of Americans have left toxic work environments, let’s talk about what happens when work culture goes from toxic to cultic. In the Harvard Business Review article <a href="https://hbr.org/2019/05/is-your-corporate-culture-cultish"><em>Is Your Corporate Culture Cultish?</em></a> executive coach, psychoanalyst, and management scholar<a href="https://hbr.org/search?term=manfred%20f.%20r.%20kets%20de%20vries&amp;search_type=search-all"> Manfred F. R. Kets de Vries</a> says that “healthy corporate cultures can easily turn into corporate cults, whether leaders intend for it to happen or not.”</p><p>In fact, he says that a number of companies that our culture celebrates already tread the <a href="http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/careers/career-advice/life-at-work/corporate-culture-or-corporate-cult/article4482643/">fine line</a>; he says that Apple, Tesla, <a href="https://nypost.com/2017/02/20/zappos-ceo-didnt-just-want-a-company-he-wanted-a-cult/">Zappos</a>, Southwest Airlines, Nordstrom, and Harley Davidson are a few examples. Not only do they have what he calls a “cult-like following” among customers, but management encourages <a href="https://theweek.com/articles/474359/5-signs-that-apple-cult">cultish behaviors in their workforces</a> as well.</p><p>Like a religious cult, Kets de Vries says that the degree to which management controls employee’s thinking and behavior is what characterizes a company as cultic. Like we explored in my post <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/love-bombing"><em>What is lovebombing?</em></a> the process begins in the recruitment stage. He says that employees are screened for their “fit.” Even in my old job, that was a criteria during the interview stage. Once we had interviewed someone, we were always asked if the person was a good “cultural fit.” While that certainly doesn’t indicate a cultic environment on it’s own, management’s looking for a specific type of personality can ensure that workers are less likely to rock the boat.</p><p>Then, Kets de Vries says, once an employee is hired, management then sees “that on-boarding processes and incentive systems tend to reinforce the need for alignment. This drives the way people communicate, make decisions, evaluate each other, as well as hiring, promotion and termination decisions. In such a climate, individualism is discouraged, and group-think prevails.”</p><p>He says that some cult-like companies even go so far as to position the workplace as a replacement for family and community. Whether intentionally or not, this serves to isolate the employees from support networks that can provide an important counterpoint to the workplace culture. In these companies, he says, leaders encourage people to center their lives around their jobs, which leaves little time for leisure, entertainment, or vacations.</p><p>There are two ways, he says, to tell if a company is or is becoming cult-like: language and ritual. Cultic environments use the loading of the language (read more in my post <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/were-you-brainwashed-cults"><em>Were you brainwashed?</em></a>) which creates their own terminology. This reinforces the sense of belonging within the group, and creates an us-and-them divide with outsiders who don’t understand this specialized language.</p><p>And while ritual is <a href="https://hbr.org/2013/02/how-ritual-delivers-performanc">not always problematic</a>, it can be a sign of larger issues. The language within ritual is also important because, according to author Amanda Montell, ritualistic language can be used to abuse power. In her book “Cultish,” she talks about the power of religious language, and says to keep it ethical and healthy it must be confined to “ritual time.” She says that often there is a symbolic action to both enter into and end that ritual time (lighting a candle, singing a song, etc.) but that oppressive groups never let you leave ritual time because the language is all consuming. And if a company strives to keep its employees in “ritual time” that can also be a sign of problematic culture.</p><p>Kets de Vries says that three ways to determine if workplace culture trends towards the culty is to ask the following questions:</p><ul><li>Do employees believe in the company’s vision because they understand and agree with it or because that’s what they’re supposed to do?</li><li>Does the company encourage them to have personal lives?</li><li>Most importantly, does it encourage the individuality and non-conformism that drive breakthroughs?</li></ul><p>If the answer to any of these is no, there is a problem.</p><h3>Some Solutions for Dealing with a Toxic Work Environment</h3><p>If we look back to that BBC article, both Jain and Priesemuth say that getting rid of toxic work culture involves companies identifying and addressing the root causes of the dysfunction, which, again, is often bad management. But, they say, that doesn’t mean employees have to wait around in the hopes that things will get better. They say that educating yourself on your rights, whether via your company’s employment policies or local laws, can be an empowering first step — and I think this is an incredibly important one for cult survivors who may have been indoctrinated into believing that they somehow deserve poor treatment.</p><p>Jain says that not only will understanding employers legal obligations help workers hold them accountable, but also “having this awareness can also help in pushing back on managers whose expectations have become unreasonable or unfair since the transition to remote work.”</p><p>Priesemuth says that “gathering evidence of hostility can be a useful tool to substantiate any claims that might be raised through HR or senior management.” So if someone is behaving in an unprofessional manner, saving emails or chats, or writing down what was said on a call can be helpful. “Also, it’s beneficial to try to find allies — perhaps colleagues who have similar experiences or witnessed any transgressions — who can serve as a support system or help address the problem,” says Priesemuth.</p><p>In one of my old jobs, the company was too small to have any HR department or a meaningful system to address grievances. But having colleagues who had similar experiences was incredibly helpful in the face of management’s behaviors. It helped me verify my reality (something really important after the gaslighting many cult survivors have experienced) and understand that my feelings and reactions were valid.</p><p>If changing jobs isn’t feasible at the moment, Priesemuth recommends taking measures to make yourself less vulnerable to toxic behaviors. “Setting stronger boundaries between work and your outside life has been useful for employees,” says Priesemuth. “Research has shown that it can reduce job-related stress and increase employee wellbeing.” Some of these boundaries might include turning your phone off after a certain hour of the evening, signing out of email and simply making yourself unavailable.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*g9T5tpU7G78o29hATEOl4A.jpeg" /><figcaption>Take steps to protect yourself. Set boundaries, whenever you can, to insulate yourself from toxic behaviors and environments.</figcaption></figure><p>To go back to psychotherapist <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/bryanrobinson/">Bryan Robinson, Ph.D.</a> ‘s Forbes article that I referenced earlier, he has seven suggestions for actions you can take to protect yourself:</p><ol><li><strong>The first step is to arm yourself with consistent self-care.</strong> This is a really hard one for cult survivors, because we often don’t even know what self care looks like. But Robinson says to make sure you realize that you’ve hit a breaking point before stress-warning signs set in. So basically, try not to let your body breaking down or regular panic attacks be the sign that something needs to change. He also suggests consciously building rest time into your day by building cushion time between meetings, not agreeing to unrealistic deadlines and unplugging at the end of the day. <br>Of course, I can think of a number of companies that simply don’t allow for this kind of behavior, to the point of being exploitative. In my opinion, no human being should ever be exploited in order to put food on their table or a roof over their head. And if you’re a cult survivor, this kind of environment is probably incredibly re-traumatizing, and it would be wise to do everything you can to find different employment.</li><li><strong>Don’t compromise your physical or mental health for your job. </strong>Robinson says that instead of waiting for the company to decide what’s best for you, be assertive. He says that you should decide how far you’re willing to go to meet company demands and to be prepared to put your foot down when you believe your employer oversteps those bounds.<br>This is a <strong>really</strong> hard one for cult survivors because most of us were taught not to have boundaries in the first place. So to a) set them and b) defend them is probably incredibly stressful. But, this is a really good skill for us to learn. Because even in a non-toxic work environment, a lack of boundaries or permeable boundaries can turn what might otherwise be a decent job for “normal” people into an overwhelming and, again, re-traumatizing one for cult survivors.</li><li><strong>Pinpoint your discontent.</strong> Robinson also recommends defining what exactly what is it about the job that makes you dissatisfied? Is it the boss from hell? Boredom with tedious work? Not enough money? Long hours? Heavy workload? Unreasonable company expectations? Performance pressures? Once you can isolate exactly what the factors are, then decide if you can correct them.<br>Again, this can be a little bit more murky for the cult survivor because many of us have issues with authority, so a fair boss can still trigger us. A rote job that is secure and a little tedious might feel meaningless because it’s not based in a greater “mission” — after all many of us were tasked with saving the world. This is where I find it helpful to talk to either a cult-aware therapist or other survivors who can help us connect the dots between our experiences, expectations and discontent.</li><li><strong>If your concerns are intolerable and unfixable, enlist your employer as a resource if possible.</strong> With this recommendation, Robinson says to take a perspective of problem solving and trying to help the company achieve its goals without simply venting. This can put you and management on the same team to solve issues around workload, work life balance and deadlines.</li><li><strong>Think things through carefully. </strong>Robinson admits that everyone has a breaking point, but that no one can tell you to quit your job without knowing the intimate details of both your work and personal life. He says that it’s important to weigh the financial consequences in light of your job’s negative aspects, plus the other factors in your life such as the people who are dependent on you, amount of debt, and so on.</li><li><strong>Practice mindfulness.</strong> I’m actually going to share this one with a big caveat, in that <a href="https://www.browndailyherald.com/2021/07/08/brown-neuroscience-lab-devises-novel-guidelines-measure-study-negative-effects-mindfulness-based-meditation/">Brown neuroscience lab has found that over 50% of participants to have experienced adverse effects from clinical mindfulness-based programs.</a> In an article on <a href="https://www.thescienceofpsychotherapy.com/is-mindfulness-safe-for-trauma-survivors/">The Science of Psychotherapy, David A. Treleaven, PhD</a>, writes, “For people who’ve experienced trauma, mindfulness meditation can actually end up exacerbating symptoms of traumatic stress. When asked to pay focused, sustained attention to their internal experience, trauma survivors can find themselves overwhelmed by flashbacks and heightened emotional arousal.”<br>However, Robinson suggests that for this, to find one aspect of your job that is enjoyable or meaningful while you wait it out. He says it won’t fix the problem, but it can get you through until you make the decision about whether to stay or leave.</li><li><strong>If you’ve tried everything to sustain your current position and things are going nowhere, it might be time to move on. </strong>He says to pay special attention to this if your misery starts to manifest physically. Watch for symptoms such as insomnia, anxiety or depression, panic attacks or gastrointestinal problems. Hopefully, he says, if you’ve tried all other above actions and things haven’t improved, hopefully you have figured out your exit strategy.</li><li>I do want to make the connection that a lot of the symptoms that he describes are similar to the general symptoms that cult survivors experience in their post-cult life. So finding a support system, such as other survivors or a helping professional, in reducing or managing these symptoms could be beneficial in both our work and personal lives.</li></ol><p>The good news is in all of this, according to Robinson, is that more companies are starting to realize that job stress and burnout is a major health and safety issue and that it is to their advantage to have healthy employees. In fact in 2019, the World Health Organization declared job burnout as a bonafide medical diagnosis. Robinson says that happy employees are productive employees, and major corporations are starting to develop unique ways to support employees and humanize work environments.</p><p>So hopefully this will eventually extend towards creating a more humanized work environment for trauma survivors as well. The more we recognize the commonalities across the various segments of survivors, I think the more we can create safe spaces for us to live, work and thrive.</p><p>If you have been in ANY high control group or religion, share your story with the hashtag #igotout. Share on your own platform OR if you need to be anonymous and / or would like support, there are resources at the <a href="https://igotout.org/">I Got Out</a> website.</p><p>When you see a survivor share their story, let them know they have been heard. This is such a meaningful part of the movement. We all need to know we’re not alone.</p><p>If you know someone who has been harmed by a high demand group, share #igotout posts you think would help them.</p><p>Together we can bring awareness to how many of us have been harmed by high control organizations and end the shame or stigma we might feel about our experiences.</p><p><em>Tell your story.</em> <em>Impact lives.</em> <em>Change the world.</em></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/toxic-workplaces-cult-survior"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on July 16, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=453e8506436a" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Were you brainwashed?]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/were-you-brainwashed-18b7df953b15?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/18b7df953b15</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[thought-reform]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[survivorship]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brainwashing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 17 Jun 2021 14:28:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-17T14:28:01.502Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/1*VpAUlhxvyA1c4MydVfmZ9g.png" /></figure><p>Back in May, <a href="https://www.lisakohnwrites.com/">writer and fellow second generation ex-Moonie Lisa Kohn</a>, and I were interviewed by Fen Alankus for the “Follow the Woo” podcast. We were comparing and contrasting our experiences growing up in the Unification Church in different decades, and in different “castes.” While I was born in, Lisa’s mother joined when Lisa was just 10. In Church theology, much is made about the level of purity of the children born into the group. We were called “Blessed Children,” while the kids whose parents brought them in at a young age were called a “Jacob’s Child,” although that term wasn’t commonly used when Lisa was growing up in the Church.</p><p>(Fun fact: Fen was almost a Jacob’s Child too, but her mother left the Church in time! As soon as the episode is live I’ll link to the episode so you can hear more.)</p><p>One of the things that Lisa and I are both passionate about is helping others like us by sharing our stories of survival and resilience, often with an educational underpinning. So during the course of the podcast interview, Lisa shared that while she was on tour to promote her memoir <a href="https://www.mainpointbooks.com/lisa-kohn"><em>To the Moon and Back: A Childhood Under the Influence</em></a><em>, </em>she had the opportunity to be interviewed for a popular daytime talk show. (The following is paraphrased from my memory of the conversation.)</p><p>“Before I went on stage the producer was doing a pre-interview and asked me, point blank, ‘were you brainwashed?’” she said.</p><p>There was a long pause where both Fen and I stared into our webcams, mouths hanging open.</p><p>“Are you fucking kidding me?” I finally managed.</p><p>“Nope.” Lisa shook her head and put her hand over her heart. “Swear to God.”</p><p>I must have audibly growled before muttering, “What a horrible question. That is such a fundamental misunderstanding of what thought reform is.” I might have also slammed my fist on my desk. “And what a horrible, shaming thing to say to a survivor!”</p><p>Frankly, at that point I was tempted to completely derail the conversation and delve into a treatise on what thought reform is, and why asking a survivor if they were brainwashed is a stigmatizing question — at best. But I refrained. After all, that’s what this blog is for!</p><h3>The briefest history of the word “brainwashing”</h3><p>So, first, let’s talk about the word “brainwashing.<em>” </em>It was coined by American journalist and intelligence agent Edward Hunter in the 1950s. According to Dr. Janja Lalich and Madeleine Tobias, authors of the book <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/taking-back-your-life-recovering-from-cults-and-abusive-relationships/9780972002158"><em>Take Back Your Life: Recovering from Cults and Abusive Relationships</em></a>, the term “brainwashing” is a poor translation of Chinese characters for “thought struggle” or “thought remodeling,” and they refer to Chairman Mao Zedong’s political campaigns of the 1920s to 1960s. They say that when discussing cult dynamics, psychologists and sociologists prefer the term “thought reform,” because “brainwashing” is misunderstood and often associated with Communism or torture. But, they say, that the sophisticated and subtle systems of influence found in cults today hardly require a prison cell or a torture chamber.</p><p>Still, the word “brainwashing” prevails in both popular imagination and writing on the topic of cults. Some, like Rebecca Moore, <strong>Professor of Religious Studies</strong> at San Diego State University and sister of women who helped plan the 1978 Jonestown massacre, have gone as far to say that <a href="https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/brainwashing-myth-truth-jonestown-massacre-rebecca-moore-us-a8454136.html">brainwashing is a pseudoscience</a> because, she says the word “ignores research based explanations for human behaviour and dehumanises people by denying their free will.”</p><p>Others, like Dick Anthony, a research and forensic psychologist, who wrote <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A%3A1022081411463"><em>Pseudoscience and Minority Religions: An Evaluation of the Brainwashing Theories of Jean-Marie Abgrall</em></a> for <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023%2FA%3A1022081411463"><em>Social Justice Research</em></a><em> </em>cite the failed <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_MKUltra">CIA MKUltra experiments</a>, where the aim was to develop mind-controlling drugs for use against the Soviet bloc in response to alleged Soviet, Chinese, and North Korean use of mind control techniques on U.S. prisoners of war during the Korean War. Anthony states that the “CIA theory has been evaluated scientifically in research in several contexts […] and it has been shown to be ineffective in coercively changing worldviews.”<em> </em>After retiring, Sidney Gottlieb, the head of the CIA’s MKUltra programs, dismissed the entire effort as “useless.”</p><p><strong>So, is brainwashing <em>A Thing</em>?</strong></p><p>Some, like anthropologist Geri-Ann Galanti, Ph.D. and sociology professor emeritus Eileen Barker have written about their experiences with the Unification Church and echoed the sentiment that “brainwashing” techniques either did not exist or were ineffective. Galanti, who spent a week at Camp K, wrote in a paper <a href="https://www.icsahome.com/articles/brainwashing-and-the-moonies-galanti-csj-1-1-1984"><em>Brainwashing and the Moonies</em> </a>for a 1984 issue of <em>Cultic Studies Journal</em>, wrote that she expected she would encounter “brainwashing” techniques, but that expectation was not met. However, she wrote that she was “struck by the subtle, yet powerful, socialization techniques through which the UC members were able to influence her.”</p><p>Barker, on the other hand, spent nearly seven years studying Unification Church members. Not only did she attend numerous workshops and visit communal facilities, but she interviewed members, ex-members, “non-joiners,” and control groups of uninvolved individuals from similar backgrounds, as well as parents, spouses, and friends of members. Her thesis was that she rejects the “brainwashing” theory as an explanation for conversion to the Unification Church, because, she said it explained neither the many people who attended a Unification Church recruitment meetings and did not become members, nor the voluntary disaffiliation of members.</p><p>Disclosure: I have not finished reading all of <em>Making of a Moonie,</em> Barker’s book which goes into these interviews and sums up her rejection of the “brainwashing” theory. But as somebody who has read a significant amount of first-generation memoirs, I feel like this thesis does not acknowledge that many of the people who did join were in that vulnerable state that I talk about in a lot of my other posts. Also to call it the “disaffiliation” of members — it’s not like people just woke up one day and said, “you know what, I’m done with this.” That moment, if and when it comes, occurs after years of abuse. And I think that the words “voluntary disaffiliation” cover up and ignore the incredible fight for a lot of us to get out.</p><p>Many have criticized Barker as being a cult apologist. She is the chairperson and founder of the Information Network Focus on Religious Movements {<a href="https://inform.ac/">INFORM</a>}. <a href="https://freedomofmind.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Hausherr-Cult-Apologists-introvigne.pdf">Dr. Steve Hassan’s website also cautions that Barker is on the referral list of the now Scientology-run Cult Awareness Network.</a> So those are things that I want to posit as we’re looking at the “two sides” of this brainwashing question.</p><p>On the other side of the argument, in 2004, neuroscientist and physiologist <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kathleen_Taylor_(biologist)">Kathleen Taylor</a> published a book called <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/brainwashing-the-science-of-thought-control/9780198798330"><em>Brainwashing: The Science of Thought Control</em></a>, in which she explores the neurological basis for reasoning and cognition in the brain, and proposes that the self is changeable, while describing the physiology of neurological pathways. In a 2005 article for <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2005/oct/08/terrorism.booksonhealth"><em>The Guardian</em></a> she writes,</p><blockquote><em>“Say the word ‘brainwashing,’ and chances are we think of the Manchurian Candidate, of some mysterious process that installs malevolent new beliefs in people’s minds — as if ideologies were just like versions of Windows. This horror-movie view of brainwashing is alarming, but also comforting. It scares us with one of the most frightening visions we can contemplate: the utter loss of free will as our minds are “turned” or “poisoned”, our core identity subjugated to some evil-minded fanatic.”</em></blockquote><p>And she goes on to say that the reason that this is comforting is because it removes us from the process. It makes the “monster,” as she calls it the, responsible party. She was referring to Osama Bin Laden and our thinking of, “Oh, he’s the evil one,” because when we think of brainwashing, we think of a person that’s able to just put new ideas into our brains and it removes our responsibility.</p><p>But, she cautions, brains are not computers, and there is no button that someone can press to turn a man from good to evil. Instead, she says, we need to think of brainwashing realistically: not as black magic but in secular, scientific terms, as a set of techniques that can act on a human brain to produce a change in beliefs — sometimes drastically and over short periods of time.</p><p>She says that these techniques include:</p><ul><li>isolating the individual and controlling their access to information,</li><li>challenging their belief structure and creating doubt,</li><li>and repeating messages in a pressurized environment, which help change someone’s old beliefs and introduce their brain to new ones.</li></ul><figure><img alt="A woman stands in a dark room in a red dress and red head covering wears a mask with white fabric billowing out of the eye hole." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*SIxJkeGOJIab6-Cn" /><figcaption>Isolating individuals is a technique used in thought reform.</figcaption></figure><p>But for the transplant to take, she says, emotion is required. A person needs to have positive feelings when they talk about the new beliefs, and negative ones whenever they think of old ideas. This uses a human brain’s own power of association to manipulate it.</p><h3>The Eight Criteria for Thought Reform</h3><p>As mentioned, most cult-aware psychologists and sociologists prefer the term “thought reform” over “brainwashing” because the former circumvents the associations with the latter noted by Kathleen Taylor. Personally I also believe that “thought reform” as a preferred term helps to create clarity in the issues brought up by Galanti and Barker. One may not be able to flip a switch and turn someone into a “mindless robot” (or “brainwashed zombie”, as the popular media of the 70’s and 80’s referred to Unification Church members as), but I believe that people can be coerced by what <a href="https://www.icsahome.com/articles/deception--dependency--and-dread-langone">Michael D. Langone, PhD refer to as “Deception, Dependency, and Dread”</a> to facilitate the conversion experience. (Dr. Alexandra Stein builds on this her book “<a href="https://www.routledge.com/Terror-Love-and-Brainwashing-Attachment-in-Cults-and-Totalitarian-Systems/Stein/p/book/9781138677975">Terror, Love and Brainwashing: Attachment in Cults and Totalitarian Systems,”</a> to describe how people are converted and why they stay.)</p><p>Like “brainwashing,” we get the term “thought reform” from the Cold War era, specifically from campaigns of the Communist Party of China to reform the thinking of Chinese citizens into accepting Marxism-Leninism and Mao Zedong Thought. American psychiatrist Dr. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Jay_Lifton">Robert Jay Lifton</a>, popularized the term in his book <a href="https://archive.org/details/ThoughtReformAndThePsychologyOfTotalism"><em>Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism: A Study of “Brainwashing” in China</em></a>.</p><p>According to the publisher,<strong> </strong>Lifton’s research for the book began in 1953 with a series of interviews with American servicemen who had been held captive during the Korean War. In addition to interviews with 25 Americans, Lifton also interviewed 15 Chinese who had fled their homeland after having been subjected to indoctrination in Chinese universities. From these interviews, which in some cases occurred regularly for over a year, Lifton identified the tactics used by Chinese communists to cause drastic shifts in one’s opinions and personality and “brainwash” American soldiers into making demonstrably false assertions.</p><p>The word “brainwashing,” Lifton says, was originally used to describe Chinese indoctrination techniques from this period, although it would also later be applied to Russian and Eastern European techniques as well. He goes on to say that the term has been applied to everything from American advertising to corporate training programs and even private prep schools. These applications, he says, are not always without basis, and suggests there is a continuum on which the method exists but that this liberal usage also contributes to confusion. As mentioned before, many of us imagine brainwashing as this all-powerful, irresistible, or magical method of achieving total control over an individual, but according to Lifton, it is none of those things.</p><p><a href="https://www.wnyc.org/story/symposium-on-communist-brainwashing/">In 1957 there was a symposium panel of experts at the New York Academy of Medicine to discuss the topic of mind control. During this panel, Lifton stated</a> that thought reform consists of four stages: the emotional assault, followed by leniency, then confession, and finally re-education<em> </em>The latter, in Cold War era China meant remaking of a person in the Communist image. In the summary of the symposium Lifton is paraphrased, discussing an example of the process which aligns with the techniques that Taylor wrote about:</p><blockquote><em>The prisoner is brought in and confronted with his crimes. Then he’s asked to detail his entire life and experience in China, which, for missionaries, might be a period of 30 or 40 years. After the interrogation, the prisoner endures “the struggle” in his cell: “he sits in the middle of the cell, and the other prisoners, his cellmates, form a circle around him and begin to shoot invectives at him denouncing him as an arch criminal, a stubborn imperialist who refuses to recognize his crimes.” These are prisoners working towards their own release.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>After months of this treatment, there is leniency. Lifton quotes a priest, who describes the kindness of a judge — a judge who encourages him to confess and get it over with. The theme of confession is then repeated over and over.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>When he eventually confesses, he is made to denounce his colleagues… and then undergoes a reeducation process, and the end of which there is “the development of a new identity, the recoding of reality, the conversion, if you will, in which the prisoner begins to look at the world through Communist eyes and if the process is successful, is reborn.”</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="A woman in a nude leotard sits on the floor with her face wrapped in bandages, a red curtain draped over her head like a shroud." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/0*nwGT2Yf3mrSDpsMa" /><figcaption>Cultic thought reform is aimed at both social control and individual change.</figcaption></figure><p>In his book, Lifton says that these elements of thought reform are closely related and overlapping because they bring into play a series of pressures and appeals, on an intellectual, emotional and physical level, that are aimed at both social control and individual change. Again, he and Taylor are in alignment on this, and these elements also resonate with Dr. Janja Lalich’s Bounded Choice framework, which I discuss in my post “<a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/illusion-choice">The Illusion of Choice</a>.”</p><p>At the end of <a href="https://archive.org/details/ThoughtReformAndThePsychologyOfTotalism"><em>Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism</em></a><em>, </em>Lifton writes, “Where totalism exists, a religion, political movement, or even a scientific organization becomes little more than [a] cult.” He goes on to identify eight psychological themes that he uses as criteria for evaluating if a situation meets the standard of a “totalist environment,” or a cult.</p><p>The criteria are as follows, with examples taken from psychotherapist Rosanne Henry’s website, <a href="https://www.cultrecover.com/">https://www.cultrecover.com/</a> and <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/taking-back-your-life-recovering-from-cults-and-abusive-relationships/9780972002158"><em>Take Back Your Life</em></a><em>:</em></p><p><strong>Milieu control:</strong></p><ul><li>This is control, or attempted control, over all a person sees, hears, reads, writes. This can be isolation from other people, psychological pressure, geographical distance or unavailable transportation, and sometimes physical pressure.</li><li>This can also be related to the control of a sequence of events, such as seminars, lectures, group encounters, which become increasingly intense and increasingly isolated, making it extremely difficult, both physically and psychologically, for one to leave.</li></ul><p><strong>Mystical manipulation:</strong></p><ul><li>This is extensive personal manipulation which seeks to promote specific patterns of behavior and emotion in such a way that it appears to have arisen spontaneously from within the environment, while it actually has been orchestrated.</li><li>People mistakenly attribute their experiences to spiritual causes when, in fact, they are concocted by human beings.</li><li>Jesse S. Miller, Ph. D. wrote a paper for a 1986 issue of the<em> Cultic Studies Journal</em>, titled <em>The Utilization of Hypnotic Techniques in Religious Conversion, </em>where he describes what he calls<em> the “masterful use” </em>of hypnotic techniques used by totalist groups, but admits that alone they do not explain the phenomenon of the conversion experience.</li><li><strong>Alice Greczyn recently gave a talk at the Conference on Religious Trauma called “</strong><a href="https://pheedloop.com/CORT/site/sessions/?id=SESERFJ3ERHU1BOGA"><strong>Drunk, High, and Hypnotized: The Neurotheology of Mystical Experiences</strong></a><strong>,” (</strong><a href="https://www.recoveringfromreligion.org/fall-excursion-2021"><strong>she will be giving a similar talk at Recovering From Religions’s Fall 2021 Excursion)</strong></a><strong> and </strong><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?t=2163s&amp;v=5EXFh8Db2-w"><strong>she touches on some of that these things in the Evangelical Christian movement on the Graceful Atheist podcast here</strong></a><strong>.</strong></li></ul><p><strong>Demand for purity:</strong></p><ul><li>This is a black and white worldview, where the world becomes sharply divided into the pure and the impure, the absolutely good (the group/ideology) and the absolutely evil (everything outside the group). In the Unification Church we used the terms “Fallen World” and “Outside World” interchangeably to refer to people not in the group.</li><li>The leader is the ultimate arbiter of what and who is good or bad.</li><li>One must continually change or conform to the group “norm.”</li><li>Tendencies towards guilt and shame are used as emotional levers for the group’s controlling and manipulative influences.</li><li>This ties in with the process of confession — one must confess when one is not conforming.</li></ul><p><strong>Confession:</strong></p><ul><li>Confession is carried beyond its ordinary religious, legal and therapeutic expressions to the point of becoming a cult in itself.</li><li>The follower is now “owned” by the group.</li><li>Makes it virtually impossible to attain a reasonable balance between worth and humility, and they experience a loss of boundaries between what is secret and what the group knows.</li></ul><p><strong>Aura of sacred science:</strong></p><ul><li>The group’s doctrine or ideology is held up as the ultimate moral vision for the ordering of human existence. The group demands reverence for the ideology, its originator and those who presently bear it.</li><li>Questioning or criticizing those basic assumptions is prohibited.</li><li>This inhibits individual thought, creative expression and personal development.</li><li>It offers considerable security to young people because it greatly simplifies the world and answers a contemporary need to combine a sacred set of dogmatic principles with a claim to a science embodying the truth about human behavior and human psychology.</li></ul><p><strong>Loading the language (special vocabulary):</strong></p><ul><li>The language is characterized by the thought-terminating cliche (thought-stoppers). You can read more about this in my post <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/toxic-positivity-thought-terminating-cliche"><strong>Toxic positivity and the thought-terminating cliché</strong></a><strong>.</strong></li><li>Words are given new meanings — the outside world does not use the words or phrases in the same way — it becomes a “group” word or phrase.</li><li><a href="https://play.acast.com/s/5b3d2846-6f01-5f3e-84e8-70addf1ed190/60bbca08f36633001a142ce3?seek=4682">Several example of this are discussed in Season 2 Episode 1 of Falling Out</a>; there is one where Donna describes hearing the word “indemnity” in an insurance context, whereas in the Unification Church we used it to describe a kind of “pay-it-forward” concept of suffering now for future blessings.</li></ul><p><strong>Doctrine over person:</strong></p><ul><li>This is the denial of the self, and any perception other than the one dictated by the group.</li><li>If one questions the beliefs of the group or the leaders of the group, one is made to feel that there is something inherently wrong with them to even question — it is always “turned around” on them and the questioner/criticizer is questioned rather than the questions answered directly.</li><li>In the Unification Church this manifested in telling members that they were being “invaded by evil Spirit World,” or “forming a common base with Satan” when they questioned. I talk about this more in my post <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/toxic-positivity-thought-terminating-cliche"><strong>Toxic positivity and the thought-terminating cliché</strong></a> as well.</li></ul><p><strong>Dispensing of existence:</strong></p><ul><li>Similar to the demand for purity, this is when the group has an absolute or totalist vision of truth, those who are not in the group are evil/ not enlightened/ not saved, and therefore do not have the right to exist.</li><li>When I was growing up my mom used to quote Genesis 6:1–4, “the <strong>s</strong>ons of God saw the daughters of men that they were fair; and they took them wives of all which they chose.” Her interpretation of this verse was that when the sons of God married the daughters of men, it meant that people with souls (the sons of God) intermarried with people who had no souls (daughters of men). Therefore, to her, essentially all of humanity was wandering around in a no-soul or diluted-soul state, and it was only by receiving the marriage Blessing from Rev. Moon that people could be engrafted back onto the lineage of God and have souls. I don’t know if this came from Unification Church ideology, but it illustrates the point in a pretty stark manner.</li><li>If the non-people cannot be recruited, then they can be punished or even killed.</li><li>Similarly, this breeds a fear into followers who learn that their life can literally depend on this willingness to obey the group or the group leader.</li></ul><h3>Thought reform in action</h3><p>Similarly to Lifton, Dr. Margaret Singer discussed conditions that lend themselves to psychological manipulation. Like Lifton, she investigated and testified about techniques used by North Koreans against American soldiers in wartime. (In later years she also repeatedly testified against the Unification Church.)</p><p>Those conditions, adapted from <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/taking-back-your-life-recovering-from-cults-and-abusive-relationships/9780972002158"><em>Take Back Your Life</em></a><em>, </em>are:</p><ul><li>Keeping a person unaware of what is going on and how they are being changed one step at a time.</li><li>Controlling the persona’s social and/or physical environment, especially the person’s time.</li><li>Systematically creating a sense of powerlessness, covert fear, guilt, and dependency.</li><li>Manipulating a system of rewards, punishments, and experiences in order to inhibit behavior that reflects the person’s former identity, attitudes, and/or beliefs.</li><li>Manipulating a system of rewards, punishments, and experiences in order to promote the group’s ideology, belief systems, and group-approved behaviors.</li><li>Putting forth a closed system of logic and an authoritarian structure that permits no feedback and cannot be modified except by leadership approval or executive order.</li></ul><p>In the short term, these techniques might not produce lasting changes. But over the long term, they can create what Dr. Lalich and Madeline Tobais refer to as the formation of the cult identity. In <em>Take Back Your Life, </em>they<em> </em>reference<em> </em>American psychiatrist, Louis J. West, and Dr. Singer’s piece “Cults, Quacks, and Nonprofessional Therapies,” from the <em>Comprehensive Textbook of Psychiatry/III,</em> in which West and Singer describe practices and behaviors that contribute to the control and potential exploitation of an individual:</p><ol><li>Isolation of recruits and manipulation of their environment.</li><li>Control over channels of communication and information.</li><li>Debilitation through inadequate diet and fatigue.</li><li>Degradation or diminution of the self.</li><li>Induction of insecurity, fear, and confusion, with joy and certainty through surrender to the group as the goal.</li><li>Peer pressure, often applied through ritualized “struggle sessions” generating guilt and requiring open confessions.</li><li>Insistence by seemingly all-powerful hosts that the recruits’ survival — physical or spiritual — depends on identifying with the group.</li><li>Assignment of monotonous tasks or activities, such as chanting or copying written materials or mind-numbing repetitious lessons in so-called classes.</li><li>Acts of symbolic betrayal or renunciation of self, family, and previously held values, designed to increase the psychological distance between recruits and their previous way of life.</li></ol><p>(They also have very strong words for cult apologists saying, “Many apologists — individuals and organizations — contribute to the cults’ veneer of respectability behind which ugly and harmful things are happening. […] If the apologists are church officials, physicians, or behavioral scientists, the grateful cults have been known to reward them with grants, awards, published praise, and even ‘research’ opportunities.</p><p>This makes me think of the honorary degrees that were given to the Moons, the awards that were handed out or <a href="https://www.salon.com/2004/06/21/moon_7/">the crowning of Reverend Moon in one of the Senate buildings at the U.S. Capitol.</a> Josh Gordenfeld’s book, <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Bad-Moon-Rising-Washington-Religious/dp/0979482232"><em>“Bad Moon Rising,”</em></a> opens with a scene about this crowning. All of these people, who, for whatever reason, are involved in contributing to this veneer of respectability are, in many ways, denying the abuse that people suffer and are contributing to the facade that these groups are respectable and are not engaging in human rights violations.)</p><p>Langone says that <a href="https://www.cultnews101.com/2012/12/cults-questions-and-answers.html">“after converts commit themselves to a cult, the cult’s way of thinking, feeling, and acting become second nature, while important aspects of their pre-cult personalities are suppressed or, in a sense, decay through disuse.”</a></p><figure><img alt="A woman in a pink dress sits on top of a trunk with an arm hanging out from the opening." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*PeE1L07uEqR6Xjd1" /><figcaption>The pre-cult identity can “decay” through disuse.</figcaption></figure><p>So I’m curious to know if any other second gen survivors of the Unification Church or, even those from other groups, have ever experienced a moments where they see, what they think might be, their parents pre-cult identities coming through. I used to see it all the time with my mother. She was, what she called, a “fundamentalist Moonie.”</p><p>But at the same time, there were occasions where her raunchy sense of humor or her adventurous nature would come through, I’d feel like I’d see the person that she used to be. She had this very strict, upright “Moonie personality,” (again, the fundamentalist Moonie that she called herself), but I don’t think that’s who she really was. And so it is alarming when, you think of Langone’s statement, to wonder with both our parents and others who were coerced into joining these groups, how often is that original personality fighting to get through?</p><p>To point back to Lifton’s criteria for thought reform, in the Unification Church, we would have been taught that the old personality was your “fallen nature” trying to fight through, and that the cult personality was your “original mind.” And so as the original personality is trying to assert itself, one would thought reform oneself into the cult’s way of thinking to suppress that old self</p><h3>Thought reform in the Unification Church conversion experience</h3><p>Now that we understand what thought reform is, I want to illustrate it via the process used by the Unification Church. After I escaped the Church, I spent years reading first generation memoirs, trying to understand what had happened to my parents to make them “join” the Church. Few helped me understand what had been so compelling about the Church. My own parents’ testimonies about “meeting the Church,” were always vague and misty eyed, but they never offered details of their indoctrination.</p><p>It was only in the book <a href="https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/moonwebs-journey-into-the-mind-of-a-cult_josh-freed/771400/?resultid=dd2d5fd3-f124-426a-912a-1a828944dac2#isbn=0920528279&amp;edition=726372"><em>Moonwebs: Journey into the Mind of a Cult</em></a><em>, </em>where<em> </em>author and journalist Josh Freed describes the process by which the Unification Church utilized thought reform in the Boonville camp that I understood what had been done to my parents and so many others. Taking the criteria of thought reform described above, we can see how someone who is in a vulnerable state might be susceptible to a cult’s indoctrination.</p><p>It’s an intense read, and I highly recommend it for anyone who might be on a similar journey of trying to piece together their past. Caveat: just because I understand that my parents were victims does not mean I absolve them of the abuse they perpetuated. I know this is a big trigger point for my fellow ex-second generation, and so I wanted to state that very clearly. Speaking of triggers, the following details the psychological horrors that totalist environments can inflict upon a person. So feel free to skip if reading about it would upset you.</p><p>Some of the passages that I found particularly illuminating from <em>Moonwebs </em>are in Chapter 10 where Freed writes,</p><blockquote><em>Boonville’s assault rips apart their complacency and finds the “seeker” inside them. For some, the vulnerable spot is a lack of fulfillment in their work or personal lives; for others, the guilt of being modern “consumers” who have compromised their past ideals. Their own unused potential is used as a weapon to push them into extreme introspection…and further. […]</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Then, poised at the abyss of nervous collapse, the recruit is offered only one avenue of escape, which he takes in sheer desperation: he fastens onto the group to escape his pain. It is not said, but it is implicit: as long as he remains in Boonville and continues his inner exploration, he will be accepted, loved — even respected, for the courage to face his problems and try to change.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The recruit did not need such support when he arrived at Boonville, but now, with his sense of identity collapsing, he needs it desperately; he clings to the group like a raft in a storm, carried along on a wave with no idea of where it will break, knowing only that for the time being it will keep him sane and alive. […]</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Yet for all their power, these changes do not signify the “creation” of a Moonie. The resulting loss of self may be sufficient to create a new charismatic, or a Billy Graham convert, but it is not enough to send the recruit out flower selling and proselytizing for Moon; in fact, he usually does not yet even know that Moon exists.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>If the recruit were to return to the world and his old “connections” at this point, says Dr. Clark, he would likely fall back into his old life, with little remaining but a sense of wonder at a remarkable experience (and a possible willingness to make regular contributions to the group that “saved” him). But just as evangelist John Wesley discovered 100 years earlier that he required regular “study groups” if his members were not to “slide back into misery”, Moon too requires continuing — though far greater supervision of the “convert”.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The new recruit is weak and frightened; he has lost his sense of identity and is desperately in need of something to restore or replace it, but he is not a “Moonie”. He is only the raw material with which the making of a Moonie will begin.</em></blockquote><p>And in Chapter 14 where he writes,</p><blockquote><em>Boonville creates an intense emotional environment that pushes the “patient” into the recesses of his own mind. In fact, Boonville is far more intense than any recognized therapy, since the recruit is totally isolated from the real world for days on end — food and sleep are cut back; the routine is bizarre and unsettling; and throughout, the recruit does not even know he is undergoing a “therapy” experience.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>As a result, many recruits break down quickly, coming to a volatile and vulnerable state that is sometimes the object of intense therapies. However, at this point, it is as if the “therapist” has gone mad: rather than pulling back to help the patient find answers in himself, the Moonies close in, deliberately using the recruit’s growing vulnerability to drive him to the very brink of a nervous breakdown. Then, as he teeters in terror on the fringes of sanity, he is offered only one refuge to avoid going insane: abandoning his own identity entirely and fastening onto the “benevolent therapist” to lead him to safety […] once this has been achieved, the group then systematically turns this awesome power back upon the weakened recruit to dismember and obliterate all remnants of his former identity.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>In the weeks ahead, the recruit is convinced that he has lived a hopelessly selfish existence: the only way out of his horrifying plight is to annihilate his old personality and rebuild it from scratch at the “therapist’s” directions. This is never stated explicitly, but it is understood: from this point onwards, the recruit may trust only the group’s standards — rigorous and strange as they may seem — and not his own ego-centered perspective. Whatever experience, knowledge and emotions that previously guided his behavior are worth nothing in the days ahead. They are “old concepts” that he must be strong enough to subdue.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>This is the crucial juncture in becoming a Moonie; it is at this point that whatever makes up the person’s identity is totally invalidated, blotted out of any role in determining his future path. The recruit has been so terrified that he has lost all confidence in his own thoughts and feelings to guide his actions. To be accepted, he is ready to </em>disbelieve<em> everything he thinks and feels and obey anything the group tells him: a state of such utter submission that, like Benji, recruits can be steered not just off the path — but in the very opposite direction to that in which they had intended to go.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>[…] This total annihilation of self-worth and utter willingness to obey is the very essence of the Unification Church’s control over its members.</em></blockquote><p>If you would like to read the entire book and cannot find a physical copy for sale, the website <a href="https://tragedyofthesixmarys.com/moonwebs-by-josh-freed-1-of-3/">The Tragedy of the Six Marys</a><strong> </strong>does have the full text available.</p><p>Similarly, if you’re interested in how <a href="https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~dst/NXIVM/esp11.html">Lifton’s Eight Criteria for Thought Reform applies to NXIVM’s Executive Success Programs, check out this piece by Paul Martin, Ph.D.</a>, the former Director of Wellspring Retreat and Resource Center near Albany, an internationally known residential treatment facility for persons abused by cults and dysfunctional relationships.</p><h3>Why this matters for cult survivors</h3><p>According to Lifton, “with greater knowledge about [cults], people are less susceptible to deception.”</p><p>I would also argue that the more people understand the true psychological abuse that thought reform entails, the less they will say stupid and harmful things to cult survivors or ask them hurtful, demeaning questions.</p><p>Here’s an example in action: the other day I was working on a different blog post, and digging through my cult books (I jokingly call them my “cult library”) looking for information to support my thesis. In my perusing of the shelf, I came across the book “<em>Brainwash: The Secret History of Mind Control</em>” by Dominic Streatfeild. I’d purchased the book at the end of 2019, but with the events of 2020 I couldn’t bring myself to sit down and read it. However, as I was flipping through it, I remembered why I’d been interested in the book in the first place: it claimed to have an entire chapter dedicated to examining “brainwashing‘ in the Unification Church. So, I decided to finally sit down and read.</p><p>While I was at it, I decided read the whole chapter for the camera (inspired by<a href="https://youtu.be/EZxSEpbgFPQ"> Faith Yen’s YouTube Live readings</a> of the novel <a href="https://www.thriftbooks.com/w/heavenly-deception_maggie-brooks/2460966/?resultid=0113a5dd-4fdc-4eaa-acd8-60f5d2cc7a54#isbn=0525245162">“<em>Heavenly Deception</em>” by Maggie Brooks</a>, which also examines the indoctrination process in the Unification Church), and posted it in six episodes on IGTV:</p><blockquote><a href="https://www.instagram.com/tv/CPYowYrA_41/?utm_source=ig_embed&amp;utm_campaign=loading"><em>A post shared by Jen Kiaba (</em></a><a href="https://medium.com/u/c26d34bd0520"><em>Jen Kiaba</em></a><em>)</em></blockquote><p>I had been hopeful for the book, because it examined the way that the Unification Church used fraud and deception to recruit and indoctrinate, and how the deprogramming that was practiced to extract young people out of the Church was problematic as well. But by the end of the chapter (episodes 5 &amp; 6) I felt like I was stopping every few sentences to discuss how the language that the author was using seemed to be a fundamental misunderstanding of indoctrination and that high demand groups use a cycle of abuse to keep their members within the group.</p><p>Essentially the author spends nearly 30 pages talking about how the techniques practiced by the Church are similar to the abuses committed against prisoners of war, but then pivots to judge the members for committing to the Matching &amp; Blessing ceremonies in the Church. He even goes so far as to ask one of his interview subjects if she was brainwashed, at which point I seriously wanted to throw the book.</p><p>(Another thing that I noted as I read the chapter was that Streightfeild began by utilizing the word <em>cult</em> when referring to the Unification Church, but by the last third of the chapter was either referring to it as a <em>new religious movement</em> or was using “cult” in quotations. So it made me wonder if Streightfeild might fall more into the “cult-apologist” camp.)</p><p>By the end of the chapter, I was quite disappointed in the author because I felt like he does a huge disservice to the survivor. Not just if a survivor reads the book; I think that could be problematic in and of itself. But if somebody else comes to this book to get an education about what happened to people to bring them to join or to stay, the writing shames those survivors and contributes to that overall thought that cult survivors are weak, stupid, etc.</p><p>In his paper, <a href="https://www.cultrecover.com/sites/default/files/The%20Relational%20System%20of%20the%20Traumatizing%20Narcissist.pdf"><em>The Relational System of the Traumatizing Narcissist</em></a>, psychoanalyst Daniel Shaw says</p><blockquote><em>One of the reasons of many of the people who leave cultic groups choose not to identify their own experience as abusive is because to do so would mean acknowledging an extraordinary degree of grief over the loss of a deeply cherished idealized attachment, connected to their most cherished hopes about themselves and about life.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Along with the unleashing of an extraordinary degree of shame about their own self deception and gullibility and shame and rage about the amount of abuse they were willing to endure for the sake of maintaining their tie to the leader. Eventually the realization that their devotion and labor within the group led to no real personal growth and to no significant contribution to society will also become a source of deep shame and regret.</em></blockquote><p>Now, I don’t know if that differs between first generation, second and multi-generational members. Maybe there is a good deal of nuance, depending on how much of one’s adult life is spent in a cult, especially for people who were born in. But, I want to add to that, I feel that a lot of us don’t identify our experiences as abusive because, when we share about our experiences, the shame and regret is reflected back at us by an uneducated populace.</p><p>I think it’s important to remove stigma for cult survivors, because the less shame we feel around our experiences, the more we can heal from them. Questions like, “were you brainwashed” are both shame-inducing because of the associations with the word, and indicate a voyeuristic pleasure in the survivor’s experience, where the questioner is looking to hear about bizarre rituals that confirm the “otherness” of the survivor. It also expresses doubt about the real harm inflicted on survivors. In essence to me, it’s nearly as bad as the question, “<a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/why-didnt-you-just-leave">Why Didn’t You Just Leave?</a>”</p><p>But when we understand what thought reform techniques are, and that they are a form of coercive control and psychological abuse, we should realize that the real question ought to be, “Are you comfortable sharing how you were harmed?” This question invites the survivor to set a boundary, to choose whether or not they are comfortable sharing their story, and indicates that they are believed. As I’ve written about in <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/memory-loss-dissociation-euphoric-recall"><strong>Memory Loss, Dissociation and Euphoric Recall in Cults</strong></a><strong>,</strong> survivors are so conditioned not to believe their own experiences, that someone inherently saying, “I believe you” can make all the difference in our healing processes.</p><p>So not only do I want to help educate and empower fellow survivors, but I want to help inform others as well. If you are a survivors, and somebody asks, “were you brainwashed?” you can shut that question down. You don’t have to answer. Again, the question in and of itself indicates a lack of empathy and a lack of understanding.</p><p>If somebody came to me and said, “were you thought reformed”?”</p><p>I would say, “Yeah, I was psychologically abused. And the fact that you can acknowledge it by that use of this term is really helpful.”</p><p>So again, if somebody asks, “were you brainwashed,” not only do you not have to answer, but you can send them this post to help explain what happened to you. If you so choose, you can start to share your experiences in the context of those eight criteria. Maybe those eight criteria for thought reform will help you understand your own experience better. But at the end of the day, what I want to happen for all of us is for us to alleviate that sense of shame for our experiences. Because again, the less we acknowledge our experiences as abuse, the harder it is for us to process them.</p><p>If you have been in ANY high control group or religion, share your story with the hashtag #igotout. Share on your own platform OR if you need to be anonymous and / or would like support, there are resources at the <a href="https://igotout.org/">I Got Out</a> website.</p><p>When you see a survivor share their story, let them know they have been heard. This is such a meaningful part of the movement. We all need to know we’re not alone.</p><p>If you know someone who has been harmed by a high demand group, share #igotout posts you think would help them.</p><p>Together we can bring awareness to how many of us have been harmed by high control organizations and end the shame or stigma we might feel about our experiences.</p><p><em>Tell your story.</em></p><p><em>Impact lives.</em></p><p><em>Change the world.</em></p><h3><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Don’t Miss a Post!</a></h3><h4><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Sign up to get new posts in your inbox.</a></h4><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/were-you-brainwashed-cults"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on June 15, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=18b7df953b15" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Toxic positivity and the thought-terminating cliché]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/toxic-positivity-and-the-thought-terminating-clich%C3%A9-50e6d96b7db0?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/50e6d96b7db0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abuse-survivors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[gaslighting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[brainwashing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[toxic-positivity]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 29 May 2021 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-06-08T15:08:48.779Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*a6-LNt1N5-BBPLC9" /></figure><blockquote><strong><em>“A life of faith involves putting ourselves in the position of an offering. Only by dividing good from evil in ourselves can we become living offerings pleasing to God. We should constantly separate good from evil within ourselves, according to the standard of God’s Will. If we neglect to do this, a condition is set up for Satan to invade</em>.” </strong><a href="http://familyfed.org/scriptures-old/section-2-chapter-1-the-providence-to-lay-the-foundation-for-restoration/"><strong><em>Sung Myung Moon</em>; The Divine Principle, Chapter 1, Section 2</strong></a></blockquote><p>I awoke to the harsh, tinny sound of a lifeguard’s whistle. In between long blasts a voice shouted, “Brothers and sisters, time to get up!”</p><p>My eyes peeled open and I looked around in the thin dawn light. I was laying on the floor of a crowded cabin, tangled in a sleeping bag that was only half on a thin plastic sleeping mat. The noise of the whistle made it difficult to get my bearings, and I mashed my pillow over my ears as I tried to remember how I had gotten here.</p><p>Mom had put me on a bus yesterday morning. It had driven all day, and after dark had begun winding its way up a mountain. Someone had helped me off the bus and brought me to the cabin by flashlight.</p><p>The whistle outside of the cabin died down, and I could finally think. <em>I’m at Camp Sunrise. This is a Divine Principle workshop.</em></p><p>Later that morning, after a long, punishing round of group exercises, I followed my fellow campers to a lecture hall at the top of the hill. Inside were rows of tables. Brothers sat on the right, sisters on the left. At the front of the room was a large photo of True Parents and a chalkboard.</p><p>A second generation leader named Chikashi [name changed] approached the board and wrote <em>Divine Principle: Chapter One </em>before turning to us. He scanned the room, arms behind his back, bouncing up and down on his toes. “What is the purpose of life?”</p><p>Several hands shot up. A brother shouted, “happiness!”</p><p>A squint of his eyes said Chikashi didn’t approve of speaking out of turn. “And how do we find happiness?” He spoke this a little more slowly, a hint of a threat in his voice.</p><p>Less hands this time. Someone was called on. “By having our desires fulfilled.”</p><p>“Exactly. But what about evil desires?” Chikashi’s eyes swept over us, as though scanning for evil.</p><p>No one spoke.</p><p>“Do any of you ever have evil desires?”</p><p>I shifted in my seat, wondered if wanting breakfast counted.</p><p>“How many of you would rather eat instead of getting spiritual food from lectures?”</p><p><em>Oops.</em></p><p>“Ah, so our original minds are in conflict with our bodies. This is why we must achieve mind-body unity, to overcome sinful desires and live in harmony with God! True Father says, the first way to achieve unity of mind and body is to knock down the body. Strike the body. Deny everything that the body desires.”</p><p>I rubbed my hand across my stomach, dragging my nails across my shirt, trying to tell my hunger to quiet down.</p><p>“To what degree do we have to deny the body?” Chikashi looked at us, waiting for someone to answer. When no one did he said, “True Father says we must deny it completely, even to the point of death!”</p><p>Chikashi drew scientific-looking diagrams on the board, explaining each. The yin and yang for the dual characteristics of God; man as subject, woman as object. I’d seen them before but wasn’t sure how they fed me.</p><h3>The thought terminating cliché</h3><blockquote><strong><em>“I am your brain.”</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><a href="http://www.tparents.org/moon-talks/sunmyungmoon73/SM730517.htm"><strong>Sung Myung Moon; Master Speaks; May 17, 1973</strong></a></blockquote><p>By the time I was eight years old, I had already sat through a number of Divine Principle lectures, although that summer at Camp Sunrise is the first that I remember with clarity. It was through those early and repetitive indoctrinations that my parents and leaders taught me that my doubts and questions about the Unification Church and its leader Rev. Moon were how evil spirit world and Satan invaded me.</p><p>They taught us that we should read 20–30 pages of the Divine Principle everyday because, according to the Church, a spiritual channel opens when we read. Leaders said that this allowed God to educate both our own mind and the spiritual world, including our ancestors (who might also attack us if we strayed). One leader said, “<a href="http://www.tparents.org/Library/Unification/Talks2/Marianov/Marianov-160216.pdf">To open your original mind don’t stop reading when you have a question. Read the whole book in the shortest time and the next time you read you’ll find the answer.”</a></p><p>Church leaders also advised members we should <a href="https://www.tparents.org/Library/Unification/Talks2/Marianov/Marianov-160118.pdf">read the Divine Principle a minimum of 20 times in order to be protected from Satan (or 100 times if we were a in a position of leadership).</a></p><p>Another leader even said, <a href="http://www.tparents.org/Library/Unification/Publications/TodaysWorld/TodaysWorld-93/TodaysWorld-9311.pdf">“I want you to read Divine Principle so much that your book is nearly broken. That is your minimum condition!”</a> Others said that we had to “liberate our spiritual minds,” and in order to do that you had to <a href="http://quantum-unification.blogspot.com/2017/03/free-your-spiritual-mind-real-meaning.html">stop thinking with your brain</a> (physical mind) which then enables one to <a href="http://www.tparents.org/Library/Unification/Talks2/Marianov/Marianov-101126.htm">relax and liberate yourself from […] external problems</a>.</p><p>If all of this sounds alarming, there’s a good reason. This training teaches individuals to use thought terminating clichés, like when someone is experiencing doubt, it is “evil spirit world invading,” so they stop engaging in critical thinking. These thought stopping techniques, also called a semantic stop-sign,<strong> </strong>are a mind control technique wherein loaded language is used to quell the cognitive dissonance that one experiences when encountering contradictory information or thoughts. It allows a person to remove the stress of the cognitive dissonance by avoiding all further consideration of a matter.</p><p>The concept was popularized by <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Jay_Lifton">Robert Jay Lifton</a> in his book <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thought_Reform_and_the_Psychology_of_Totalism"><em>Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism</em></a><em>,</em> where he also referred to this technique as the as “The language of Non-thought.” It’s also explored in <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Orwell">George Orwell</a>’s book <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nineteen_Eighty-Four"><em>Nineteen Eighty-Four</em></a>, in the use of Newspeak, which sought to eliminate shades of meaning, ambiguity and nuance available to people in Oldspeak (standard English).</p><p>According to Lifton, the way “thought-terminating cliché [s] operate is that the most far-reaching and complex of human problems are compressed into brief, highly reductive, definitive-sounding phrases, easily memorized and easily expressed. These become the start and finish of any ideological analysis.”</p><p>In the book <a href="https://epdf.pub/alcoholics-anonymous-cult-or-cure.html"><em>Alcoholics Anonymous: Cult or Cure?</em></a> author Charles Bufe says, “thought-stopping phrases include any use of language, especially repeated phrases, to ward off forbidden thoughts. One common example of this is the admonition given to Catholic schoolchildren to recite the Hail Mary or rosary to ward off “impure thoughts.” The use of repetitive chanting by the Hare Krishnas serves the same thought-stopping purpose.”</p><p>In the book <a href="https://recoveringagency.com/"><em>Recovering Agency: Lifting the Veil of Mormon Mind Control</em></a><em>,</em> the authors quote<em> </em>cult expert Dr. Steve Hassan as saying, “In the Moonies, I was told thought stopping would help me grow spiritually, and allow me to remain centered and focused on God. I didn’t know it was a mind control technique. I had been indoctrinated to believe that thinking negative thoughts would allow ‘evil spirits’ to invade me… Frequently, in many Bible-based cults, the ‘devil’ or ‘Satan’ is the source of the member’s doubts. Reciting scripture, speaking in tongues, and humming can be used to stop critical thinking.”</p><p><a href="https://www.marketwatch.com/story/wake-up-former-moonie-says-the-cult-of-trump-needs-deprogramming-2019-11-25">Dr. Steve Hassan has also said that “emotionally driven, loaded words, thought-stopping, and thought-terminating-type clichés, like ‘fake news,’ ‘build the wall,’ ‘make America great again,’” function similarly.</a></p><p><a href="http://www.mikerindersblog.org/the-horrors-of-wordclearing/">Mike Rinder’s blog on “Word Clearing” in Scientology offers an example of loading the language for thought-stopping</a>.</p><blockquote><strong><em>“You think too much! Just be faithful.”</em></strong></blockquote><blockquote><a href="http://www.unification.net/truelove/tl1-08c.html"><em>Sun Myung Moon; </em>True Love; Volume One, The Restoration of True Love</a></blockquote><p>It’s not just cults that use the thought terminating cliché. Perhaps some of the following are familiar:</p><ul><li>“God never gives you more suffering than you can bear.”</li><li>“Only God can judge.”</li><li>“God has a plan.”</li><li>“The Lord works in mysterious ways.”</li></ul><p>Or on a completely secular level:</p><ul><li>“Everything happens for a reason.”</li><li>“To each his own.”</li><li>“We will have to agree to disagree.”</li><li>“We all have to do things we don’t like.”</li><li>“You are not being a ‘team player’.”</li></ul><p>My favorite: “It’s all in your head.” That’s one I heard constantly growing up in the Church. Whether I was voicing concerns about abuse or dealing with debilitating illnesses, the message from my parents and the Church leaders was the same.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*_3fgqxKUGUM7RJmXvapXZg.jpeg" /><figcaption>Negative emotions, the Unification Church teaches, are caused by Satan and evil spirit world.</figcaption></figure><h3>Thought stopping with positive thoughts</h3><p>Now, on the other hand, sometimes thought stopping techniques can be used for good. Some people use them to help ward off panic attacks caused by negative thoughts and rely on clapping their hands, snapping their fingers, or snapping a rubber band on their wrist, and then replacing the negative thought with the more rational, positive one.</p><p>Growing up, my mom taught me to say <a href="https://www.jackcanfield.com/blog/negative-self-talk/">“Cancel, cancel,” every time I engaged in what she considered to be negative self-talk. It was a technique she learned from reading books by Jack Canfield</a>, founder of the <a href="https://www.express.co.uk/expressyourself/250226/Chicken-soup-millionaire">billion-dollar Chicken Soup for the Soul™ publishing empire</a> and author of books like <em>The Aladdin Factor. </em>And while that sounds like a nice, empowering way to help a kid, thought stopping to eliminate negative emotions, and only focusing on the positive, is the essence of toxic positivity.</p><p>As a kid I struggled with undiagnosed depression. Many days I had a hard time getting out of bed to go to school, and would curl right up under the covers when I got home.</p><p>My mom couldn’t understand it, especially because I was a straight A student, and participated in sports and extra curricular activities at school. She tried everything that she knew how, within the scope of the Church’s approval, to help me. She’d take me on long drives so we could have the one on one time that I desperately craved (as the eldest of five kids it was a rare commodity), started doing evening tea talks to cheer me up, and even bribed me with the occasional Dunkin’ Donuts outing. But when she was short on time or money, sometimes her favorite go-to was a funny little frenetic soft shoe as she sang,</p><p><em>”You’ve got to accentuate the positive <br>Eliminate the negative <br>Latch on to the affirmative <br>Don’t mess with Mister In Between…”</em></p><p>It almost never failed to get me to laugh. Even now I can’t help but smile as I think of the memory. But one thing I never learned to do was to sit with my difficult emotions to understand them or process them. That’s because in the Church they weren’t allowed.</p><p>Remember: negative emotions and thoughts were considered to be the realm of Satan. When you were negative, people said that you were being invaded by Satanic or evil spirit world. There were really only ever a few solutions that I saw presented when someone was struggling with emotions that were considered to be on the negative end of the spectrum: shame them out of someone, pressure the person to read more of Moon’s words, and if all of that failed, ship them off to a workshop — especially to the Cheong Pyung Training center in Korea where they would have to participate in ansu sessions that the Church believed would rid them of the evil spirits that were supposedly the cause of all negative emotions, as well as mental and physical maladies.</p><p>Somehow I managed to never get sent to Cheong Pyung. I suspect that mostly had to do with the prohibitive cost of the travel and subsequent workshops. But I did experience years of people telling me that my struggles were all in my head, that my negative emotions were just me “Caining Out” (a thought stopping phrase used to reference the Biblical brother Cain who killed Abel in a rage), or my “forming a common base with Satan.”</p><p>In essence, the words of the Bing Crosby song that my mom used to sing to me were the exact formula that the Church required in order for me and my behavior to meet with approval. At their core, all of the shaming and indoctrination was to enforce an environment of toxic positivity, so that one would never stop to question the beliefs or activities of the Church.</p><p><a href="https://www.healthline.com/health/mental-health/toxic-positivity-during-the-pandemic#So,-how-do-you-deal-with-toxic-positivity?">According to an article on Healthline.com “With toxic positivity, negative emotions are seen as inherently bad. Instead, positivity and happiness are compulsively pushed, and authentic human emotional experiences are denied, minimized, or invalidated.”</a></p><h3>What is Toxic Positivity?</h3><p><a href="https://thepsychologygroup.com/dr-jamie-long/">Dr. Jamie Long</a>, a Licensed Clinical Psychologist and co-owner of <a href="https://thepsychologygroup.com/">The Psychology Group Fort Lauderdale</a>, and <a href="https://thepsychologygroup.com/samara-quintero-lmft-cht/">Samara Quintero, LMFT, CHT</a> a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist, define toxic positivity as,</p><blockquote><em>the excessive and ineffective overgeneralization of a happy, optimistic state across all situations. The process of toxic positivity results in the denial, minimization, and invalidation of the authentic human emotional experience.</em></blockquote><p>They say that, just like anything done in excess, when positivity is used to cover up or silence the human experience, it becomes toxic. They warn that by disallowing the existence of certain feelings, we fall into a state of denial and repressed emotions, and deny the validity of a genuine human experience.</p><p>Some examples that they use of toxic positivity, and reframing into accepting statements are:</p><p><strong>Toxic Positivity:</strong></p><ul><li>“Don’t think about it, stay positive!”</li><li>“Everything happens for a reason.”</li><li>“Everything will work out in the end.”</li></ul><p><strong>Affirming Reframe:</strong></p><ul><li>“Describe what you’re feeling, I’m listening.”</li><li>“Sometimes we can draw the short straw in life. How can I support you during this hard time?”</li><li>“This is really hard, I’m thinking of you.”</li></ul><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xO7xcDwjqHydYef6I3eEAQ.png" /></figure><p>Isn’t it interesting how closely the toxic positivity resonates with the thought terminating clichés that we explored before?</p><p><a href="https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/toxic-positivity">According to Medical News Today, other examples of toxic positivity are:</a></p><ul><li>telling a parent whose child has died to be happy that at least they can have children</li><li>urging someone to focus on the positive aspects of a devastating loss</li><li>telling someone to get over their grief or suffering and focus on the good things in their life</li><li>labeling people who always appear positive or do not share their emotions as being stronger or more likable than others</li></ul><h3>Why is toxic positivity dangerous?</h3><p>Again, according to Medical News Today, “a positive outlook is not harmful. However, a person who believes that they must only be positive may ignore serious problems or not address underlying mental health issues.</p><p>Similarly, people who demand positivity from others may offer insufficient support or make loved ones feel stigmatized and judged.”</p><p>They list the risks of toxic positivity as including:</p><ul><li><strong>Ignoring real harm:</strong> A <a href="https://repository.uel.ac.uk/item/8842y">2020 narrative review</a> of 29 studies of domestic violence found that a positive bias might cause people experiencing abuse to underestimate its severity and remain in abusive relationships. Optimism, hope, and forgiveness increased the risk of people staying with their abusers and being subject to escalating abuse.</li><li><strong>Demeaning a loss:</strong> Grief and sadness are normal in the face of loss. A person who repeatedly hears messages to move on or be happy might feel as though others do not care about their loss. A parent who has lost a child, for example, might feel that their child was unimportant to others, compounding their grief.</li><li><strong>Isolation and stigma:</strong> People who feel pressure to smile in the face of adversity may be less likely to seek support. They may feel isolated or ashamed of their feelings, deterring them from seeking help. According to the <a href="https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/stigma-and-discrimination">American Psychiatric Association</a>, stigma can deter a person from seeking mental health treatment.</li><li><strong>Communication issues:</strong> Every relationship has challenges. Toxic positivity encourages people to ignore these challenges and focus on the positive. This approach can destroy communication and the ability to solve relationship problems.</li><li><strong>Low self-esteem:</strong> Everyone experiences negative emotions sometimes. Toxic positivity encourages people to ignore their negative emotions, even though stifling them can make them feel even more powerful. When a person is unable to feel positive, they may feel as though they are failing.</li></ul><h3>So is it ok to be negative?</h3><p>Unlike what a cultic group will tell you, it’s ok to have negative emotions and feelings. According to psychologist Mark Travers Ph.D., there is a powerful rule in psychology known as the “negativity bias,” which refers to the idea that humans are more attuned to negative cues in our environment, such as threats or challenges, than we are to positive cues such as rewards and successes. From an evolutionary standpoint, this had a survival function and kept us alive in dangerous environments.</p><p><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/social-instincts/202102/why-toxic-positivity-is-dangerous-idea">His article on Psychology Today actually argues <em>for </em>positivity and that the entire idea of “toxic positivity” is harmful, but I disagree. </a>While I will grant that having a generally positive mindset can be helpful for our sense of wellbeing, I want to posit that a negativity bias can also be helpful when assessing whether a person or a group might be harmful.</p><p>Again, according to Medical News Today, humans feel a wide range of emotions, each of which is an important part of well-being. They say that anxiety, for example, may alert a person to a dangerous situation or a moral qualm, while anger is a normal response to injustice or mistreatment. Sadness may signal the intensity of a loss.</p><p>Their stance is that not acknowledging these emotions means ignoring the action they can inspire, which again, I think puts us into a dangerous position when we are assessing potentially abusive or manipulative people or groups. They also say that failing to talk about our negative thoughts and emotions doesn’t make them go away. In fact, sometimes just vocalizing our negative emotions helps to reduce the power that they have over us, and can help us feel less trapped by them.</p><p>The same article on Medical New Today also states there is research showing that talking about our emotions, including negative emotions, can even help the brain better process feelings. An <a href="https://www.scn.ucla.edu/pdf/AL(2007).pdf">older study</a> found that labeling and talking about emotions reduced the strength of certain brain pathways associated with those emotions. This finding suggests that talking about feelings may make them feel less overwhelming.</p><p><a href="https://time.com/5163576/ignoring-your-emotions-bad-for-your-health/">According to psychotherapist and author of <em>It’s Not Always Depression</em>, Hilary Jacobs Hendel,<strong><em> </em></strong></a>teaching people that emotions are not under conscious control would help them tremendously. Basic biology and anatomy explain that we cannot stop our emotions from being triggered, as they originate from the middle section of our brain that is not under conscious control.</p><p><a href="https://www.healthline.com/health/mental-health/toxic-positivity-during-the-pandemic#What-is-toxic-positivity?">In an article on Heathline.com</a>, <a href="https://www.drjaimezuckerman.com/">Dr. Jaime Zuckerman</a>, a clinical psychologist in Pennsylvania who specializes in anxiety disorders and self-esteem, says,</p><blockquote><em>“Avoidance or suppression of emotional discomfort leads to increased anxiety, depression, and overall worsening of mental health. Failure to effectively process emotions in a timely manner can lead to a myriad of psychological difficulties, including disrupted sleep, increased substance abuse, risk of an acute stress response, prolonged grief, or even PTSD.”</em></blockquote><p>In that same article, <a href="http://www.karollcounseling.com/">Carolyn Karoll</a>, a psychotherapist in Baltimore, Maryland, says that toxic positivity can “give the impression that you are defective when you feel distress, which can be internalized in a core belief that you are inadequate or weak.”</p><p>She cautions that, “judging yourself for feeling pain, sadness, jealousy — which are part of the human experience and are transient emotions — leads to what are referred to as secondary emotions, such as shame, that are much more intense and maladaptive.” This is a really important point for understanding cultic abuse. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpqW_LTi-vg">According to Dan Shaw, LCSW, in his talk with the International Cultic Studies Association, shame is both a cult recruitment and indoctrination tool.</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*99NQHqu0KCsY2-w2zwVmGw.jpeg" /><figcaption>Shame, caused by toxic positivity, can be used as both a cult recruitment and indoctrination tool.</figcaption></figure><p>In an interview with licensed marriage and family therapist <a href="https://www.theccc.miami/whitneygoodman">Whitney Hawkins Goodman</a>, <a href="https://drleaf.com/blogs/news/the-dangers-of-toxic-positivity-signs-of-gaslighting-tips-on-what-not-to-say-to-someone-who-is-grieving-with-therapist-whitney-hawkins-goodman">Dr. Caroline Leaf discusses the relationship between toxic positivity and gaslighting</a>, saying that trying to be positive is not always a bad thing. It can, however, become toxic when we shame ourselves for having normal human emotions. This kind of toxic positivity, they say, can be a form of gaslighting, which is a manipulation tactic (intentional or otherwise) used to make someone question their own reality and deny their own thoughts, feelings and experiences.</p><p>At the cultic extreme, toxic positivity is both a thought stopping technique and a form of gaslighting. The abusive leader does it to their membership, members do it to each other, and members also learn to inflict this abuse on themselves. At the end of the day, cultic control hinges on the members’ belief in the positive power of the cult leader as a key part of the cult experience. This power could be anything from believing that the cultic beliefs are true, to believing that their leaders are heroes, are all-powerful, and are all-knowing. It could also be believing that their leadership is somehow the only path to spiritual salvation.</p><p>In either event, the more followers cultic leaders have, the more power they enjoy. The more followers the leaders manage to gain, the less likely they are to be challenged. And the less likely someone is to challenge them, the better the cult leaders can maintain their control over the cult members. If everybody is just gaslighting themselves and others with toxic positivity about their experience in the group or with the leader, they’ll never be able to break free from that false reality.</p><p>With that in mind, it is vital for us to give ourselves and others permission to experience and validate our painful emotions. Sometimes we have to sit with our bad feelings, without judging them. After all, emotions are information, which can help us grow and learn. And, in some cases, a little bit of that negative bias can go a long way towards helping protect ourselves and others.</p><p>If you have been in ANY high control group or religion, share your story with the hashtag #igotout. Share on your own platform OR if you need to be anonymous and / or would like support, there are resources at the <a href="https://igotout.org/">I Got Out</a> website.</p><p>When you see a survivor share their story, let them know they have been heard. This is such a meaningful part of the movement. We all need to know we’re not alone.</p><p>If you know someone who has been harmed by a high demand group, share #igotout posts you think would help them.</p><p>Together we can bring awareness to how many of us have been harmed by high control organizations and end the shame or stigma we might feel about our experiences.</p><p><em>Tell your story.</em> <em>Impact lives.</em> <em>Change the world.</em></p><p><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Get Blog Posts In Your Inbox!</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/toxic-positivity-thought-terminating-cliche"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on May 29, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=50e6d96b7db0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Trauma of First Love in a Cult]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/the-trauma-of-first-love-in-a-cult-47aa51931803?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/47aa51931803</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[healing-from-trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[narcissistic-abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coercive-control]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 22 May 2021 15:16:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-22T15:16:34.167Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/1*L64r69-7yPwkIjNMy1LPKg.png" /></figure><blockquote><strong><em>“First love is something that is strongest, greatest. Until your death, you will never forget about your first love.” Sung Myung Moon,</em></strong><em> </em><a href="http://www.tparents.org/moon-talks/sunmyungmoon73/SM730118.htm"><em>Change Of Blood Lineage 1–18–1973</em></a></blockquote><p>Sweat trickled from my scalp into the waistband of my shorts as we boarded the buses, smeared with mud after a service project. It was August in Miami. My mother had sent me away, across the country, for two weeks to join the Pure Love Alliance tour. It was a front group of the Unification Church where leaders bussed youth around the United States, promoting a purity culture-based abstinence-only curriculum that the Church was trying to get implemented in public schools. That afternoon we had been digging trenches for a new sprinkler system at North Miami Senior High School through sporadic Florida downpours that still never managed to break the muggy heat.</p><p>A boy caught my eye as he neared my seat. The late afternoon sun sparkled on raindrops that clung to his deeply golden-brown arms. Light glinted off wet spikes of his obsidian hair. As he blinked, droplets danced from his long lashes in a spray that looked like a celebration of his beauty.</p><p>Something in my stomach thumped pleasantly. I cut my eyes away and tried to tuck stray strands of damp hair behind my ears. My every sense was alert to him, shivering as he neared. Or maybe it was the AC blasting on my wet clothes.</p><p>The line to the back of the bus bottlenecked. He was nearly parallel with me. I risked an upward glance. Our eyes locked. Another shiver traveled down my spine and pulsated at the soles of my feet.</p><p>The line moved forward. His eyebrows quirked up. A small smile flashed like lightning across his face. I touched my cheek, hoping there were no remaining traces of mud.</p><p>He broke the connection and walked on. My entire body went slack, the soft cloth of my seat cradling my sodden form. Who was he?</p><p>Of course, I couldn’t ask. But for the next few days I kept him in my line of sight, the awareness of him lighting my nerve endings on fire. It was wrong, but I wanted to be near this new magnificent creature, and to make him aware of me.</p><p>Over the years that boy on the bus became my best friend, my confidant and the eye of the hurricane in a time when my family was tearing itself apart. Eventually he also became my first love. There was a time that I thought we might grow old together, if only we could find a way to convince our parents and Church leaders to allow us.</p><h3>Forbidden Love in a Cult</h3><blockquote><em>“If your conscience was really alive, you could not say to me, “I don’t have a good fiancée; he is not the kind I wanted.” Your original mind should be saying, “Father, because I am so impure, I don’t really deserve any person as my spouse. But since I have received this spouse as a gift from God, I will serve him/her for the rest of my life. I want to deserve this great blessing with all my heart and soul.” Those who do not have the privilege of giving your first to your spouse must be repentful and at the same time most appreciative to God and willing to compensate. In this way you can restore your love and reach the same degree of Heaven.”</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Sung Myung Moon; </em><a href="https://history.familyfed.org/restoration-of-true-love/chapter-5-the-matching"><em>Blessed Family 6–20–82</em></a></blockquote><p>We weren’t given a choice about who we would marry growing up in the Unification Church. Instead, Rev. Moon gave himself the task of choosing everyone’s spouses, and he taught us that we ought to be able to love anyone. (There was a short time he allowed parents to choose for their children, until he realized that gave members too much control and wrested the power back until his death.) But there were several years in my teens where that boy and I fought for our own choice, both covertly and overtly. It was a fight that pitted us against our faith, our families and community. It was one we would ultimately lose, and in that process we lost each other as well.</p><p>Those of us who had the audacity to fight for our own choices were shamed, abused, and sometimes expelled from the Church. We were taught that unless our first love was someone that was chosen for us, it was something from Satan.</p><p>In fact, according to Moon,</p><p><strong>“If you marry whomever you want to, it is hell; but if you marry not according to your own will, then it is like the Kingdom of Heaven.” </strong>Sung Myung Moon; <a href="http://www.tparents.org/Moon-Books/twtc/Twtc-4-4.htm">The Way for a True Child</a></p><p>So to find oneself with feelings for someone when the relationship was not sanctioned could be an incredibly traumatizing experience. We were supposed to somehow cut ourselves off from our own natural feelings and sexual development until the moment that Moon (now parents &amp; leaders) decided that we were ready to be married.</p><p>When speaking about the matching and marriage of his own daughter, Un Jin, Rev. Moon said,</p><blockquote><em>“She had no idea that she would be participating in this matching until eleven o’clock in the evening three days ago. She did not have any particular person in mind. She received the direction to come and prepare for the Blessing at eleven o’clock that night. There was no process of approval or agreement. We do not need this kind of approval or agreement.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>We do this work quickly to make things crystal clear. It is not supposed to include thoughts from a third person. Whatever the decision, it must be done by True Parents, not by any third person. This should be done centering on True Parents. So I don’t take your parents advice into account at all.” Sung Myung Moon; </em><a href="http://www.tparents.org/Moon-Books/twtc/Twtc-4-4.htm"><em>The Way for a True Child</em></a></blockquote><figure><img alt="A red headed woman in a white dress with a blindfold pulls at her hair that is tangled in a bird cage while holding rusty scissors. Image copyright Jen Kiaba." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*EtQ3ubdn5_u8NX3o" /><figcaption>Lack of informed consent permeated many of the matchings conducted by Rev. Moon in the Unification Church.</figcaption></figure><p><em>Note: “the Blessing” refers to the mass weddings in the Unification Church. “The Matching” refers to events where Moon would gather his followers and match them, often without them ever having met before.</em></p><p>This lack of informed consent underscored my own marriage experience, being married to a stranger with no notice. But the point that I want to make here is that we were raised to be so utterly un-formed from a romantic relationship standpoint, that we were expected to be ok with being married to a complete stranger with next-to-no notice and to be happy about it. And liking our marriage partner wasn’t even a criteria. In fact, Moon said:</p><p><strong>“I may not give you a handsome husband, or a person with whom life is easy, but I give you the gift of true love.” </strong>Sung Myung Moon;<strong> </strong><a href="https://history.familyfed.org/restoration-of-true-love/chapter-5-the-matching">Restoration of True-love; Chapter 5, The Matching</a></p><p>Now members of the second generation ex-Unification Church community are beginning to speak out about their experiences, going so far as to coin the phrase “first love trauma” in online conversations. It wasn’t a phrase I’d heard before, even as I’ve studied the intersections of purity culture and religious trauma. But boy could I relate to it.</p><p>So it made me wonder if there was any research on second generation adults who have left cults, and their first experiences with romantic love. It’s a pretty niche topic, and as I’ve mentioned before, there isn’t much research on second and multigenerational survivors to begin with. Therefore I didn’t find anything so specific as it related to first love trauma.</p><p>Instead I went broader, and decided to look a little more deeply at the psychology of first love, and see if I could make some connections to what I’ve learned about the psychology of and abuses within cults.</p><p>Please note that most of the research that I have found, especially that on Purity Culture, does not specifically address the painful ways that cultic teachings and purity culture have affected the LGBTQ+ community. In part this is because religious purity culture is often exclusively heterosexual. LGBTQ+ orientation and nonbinary gender identification were either condemned or ignored in the religious teachings that I grew up with, and I personally repressed much of my own identity at that time. Therefore I am not the appropriate person to speak to those experiences within that framework.</p><p>However, I will continue to seek out those voices and will link to research when I find it. In the meantime, <a href="https://growingupmoonie.com/episode-7-hideo">in the final episode of the podcast Growing Up Moonie, Hideo Higashibab speaks beautifully to his experience as a queer transgender man growing up in the Unification Church</a>.</p><h3>The Psychology Behind First Love</h3><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5378292/">Multiple studies</a> have given us data about what our brains experience when we’re in love. The research suggests that romantic love can be literally addictive. According to an article published in the <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5378292/">academic journal Philosophy, Psychiatry, &amp; Psychology</a>, scientists have draw parallels between the biochemical reactions in the brain associated with human love and the artificial stimulation that occurs from alcohol, heroin, or cocaine use.</p><p>Additionally, if we experience our first love during adolescence, which is generally a of period intense emotions, then the memories that we retain of it can be as intense. <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/soloish/wp/2016/02/12/why-we-never-really-get-over-that-first-love/">Jefferson Singer</a>, a Connecticut College psychologist whose research focuses on autobiographical memory, is quoted in the Washington Post saying that most people have something he calls a “memory bump” between age 15 and 26. <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33924660/">Data in another study indicates that our working memory peaks around 18.</a> This can cause our memories formed at this time to be some of our most impactful.</p><p>There are a number of articles that go so far as to say that first love leaves an “imprint” on the sensory areas of our brains. But <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/contributors/nancy-kalish-phd">Nancy Kalish Ph.D.</a> cautions that strong emotional memories are not imprints. She says that <em>imprinting</em> is a term used to describe bonds that form biologically, for all members of a species, such as how baby duckling imprint on whatever they see within a few hours of their hatching. <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/sticky-bonds/201007/first-love-lost-love-is-it-imprinting">She says that our first love does not prevent later bonds from occurring that are just as strong or stronger.</a></p><p>So to be safe, we can substitute the word “imprint” for “impression,” and we can conclude that based on the chemistry of our brains and our peak memory processing in young adulthood, first love leaves an incredibly deep impression on us.</p><figure><img alt="A woman in a white blindfold and red dress has a birdcage tied to her back as she hikes through a misty forest while leaning on a walking stick. Image copyright Jen Kiaba." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*ULJ-mfPqMv4Gh4kE" /><figcaption>First love leave a deep impression upon us in young adulthood due to peak brain processing &amp; the chemistry of our brains.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>The primacy effect of first love</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/articles/201001/heartbreak-and-home-runs-the-power-first-experiences?collection=100364">According to Dan McAdams,</a> a psychologist at Northwestern and author of <em>The Redemptive Self: Stories Americans Live By</em>, in our late teens and early 20s, we begin to solidify our identities by developing and internalizing an autobiographical narratives about our lives: who we were, are, and might be in the future. “These experiences give us natural ways to divide up the stories of our lives — episodic markers that help us make sense of how our life has developed over time,” he says.</p><p>This makes me question what happens to our psyches when we are told we are evil for our sexual development, sexuality and feelings of first love if not condoned within the cultic context. If we were forced to marry that person, because our Church community was afraid that we would “fall,” then we likely carried the burdens of that shame and pain into the relationship.</p><p>In an article on Psychology Today, science writer Jay Dixit says that it is the “primacy effect” of the firsts that help them stay as vivid and clear in our memories. This is another reason why our first love leaves such a strong impression on us. Some articles on first love posit that our first love is important in this regard, because it becomes the foundation for our future relationships.</p><p><a href="https://www.elitedaily.com/dating/are-first-loves-really-deepest/1055283">According to Dr. Niloo Dardashti</a>, a couples therapist based in New York, the feelings we experience with our first love do become a blueprint for how we approach future relationships.</p><p>Susan Andersen, a psychologist at NYU, says, “Powerful first relationships can stamp a template in your mind that gets activated in later interactions.” Therefore, our first love can become a lens through which we see future relationships.</p><p>But the loss of our first love, Dixit writes, differs from later losses, because it makes us face the cold reality that we are in constant danger of losing people that we love.</p><p>According to Robert Neimeyer, a psychologist at the University of Memphis who studies how people draw meaning from loss and grief, “We’re wired for attachment in a world of impermanence. How we negotiate that tension shapes who we become.”</p><p>Jeffery Singer, the Connecticut College psychologist, says that early loss can poison one’s ability to trust or feel safe, or give oneself over fully in subsequent relationships. Dixit writes that while many people find that they emerge more resilient from surviving a painful loss, there is also a strong link between early loss and depression, and early loss is also associated with diminished ability to form later attachments.</p><p>So for those of us who grew up in a cult, if we had a first love and were not allowed to be with that person, what does that do to our future attachments and future relationships?</p><p>Dr<em> </em><a href="https://www.theguardian.com/profile/luisadillner">Luisa Dillner</a>, who<strong> </strong>writes the popular “Love by Numbers” column for London’s <em>Guardian, </em>wrote</p><blockquote><em>“There probably should be a post-traumatic love syndrome. It would be a much lesser condition than post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), but it might share symptoms, among them reliving the moment, avoidance and emotional numbing, and being hyper-vigilant in case it happens again. In layman’s terms, you’ll be less open, more irritable and anxious.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Being traumatized after any event is linked to not being in control — a University of Colorado study of 144 people found that those who didn’t initiate the split were likely to suffer more afterwards.”</em></blockquote><p>So again, if we weren’t allowed to be with the person that we first fell in love with in the cult, then according to Dillner, we probably have experienced something along the lines of PTSD.</p><p><strong>What if our first love was a trauma bond?</strong></p><p>Because I wasn’t allowed to be with the young man I was in love with in my teens, most of our relationship was carried out online via AOL’s Instant Messenger. Yes, I know I just dated myself there. I remember logging on in secret, hoping no one in my family — or later at the Church boarding school — would find out who I was talking to. And as I waited for his screen name to appear, my palms were sweaty and I shook in fear.</p><p>Yes, I was afraid of being caught. But my physical reaction was coming from something deeper. I knew that every time we spoke, we fought. It had started even before we were in a relationship; we would send Moon’s quotes to one another, trying to prove how the other was out of line. Over the years it escalated to verbal and emotional abuse, to the point where many days it felt like psychological warfare.</p><p>But this was also love. At least it was to me. This was how my parents and my faith community showed me love. I didn’t realize it then, but we were using the same tactics to control one another’s behavior that the group used to control us. Now I look back and can honestly say that beyond love, I believe that we were trauma bonded.</p><p>According to licensed psychologist <a href="http://sexpositivepsych.com/about-me/">Liz Powell, PsyD</a>, a trauma bonding relationship is reflective of an attachment created by repeated physical or emotional trauma with intermittent positive reinforcement. Dr. Powell says that trauma bonding can happen in relationships, as well as dynamics that include fraternity hazing, military training, kidnapping, child abuse, political torture, cults, prisoners of war, or concentration camps.</p><p>As I’ve written about before, Dr. Alexandra Stein’s research posits that the closed, fearful world within a cult is designed to promote a relationship of disorganized attachment to the leader or group. It is the combination of terror and ‘love’ that emotionally traps and cognitively disables followers.</p><p>Michael Samsel, who has a master’s degree in Child, Couple, and Family Therapy at Antioch University, runs the site <a href="https://www.abuseandrelationships.org/,">https://www.abuseandrelationships.org/,</a> and on it he writes about something called <a href="https://www.abuseandrelationships.org/Content/NonIPV/communal_abuse.html"><strong>communal abuse</strong></a>. He says,</p><blockquote><em>“</em><strong><em>Communal abuse is a type of abuse that is exerted, in part, by victims (</em></strong><a href="https://www.abuseandrelationships.org/Content/Basics/survivor.html"><strong><em>survivors</em></strong></a><strong><em>) upon each other in the course of aspiring for something good within a intentional community”</em></strong></blockquote><p>He identifies it as a kind of cultic abuse, and says that the abusive proclivity itself comes largely from the psychopathic qualities of the leader, which pre-date and usually explain the formation of the group. The cult then perpetuates what he terms <em>survivor-on-survivor</em> abuse. However when he uses the term <em>survivor</em> he is referring to victims who are stuck in the abusive system.</p><p>This not only explains the behaviors that young man and I engaged in during our relationship, but much of the interpersonal dynamics within the group itself.</p><figure><img alt="A woman in a red hood stands wrapped in red bandages and a red skirt. Image copyright Jen Kiaba." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*BOoIdRIrvHjVLVWN" /><figcaption>Communal abuse explains much of the interpersonal dynamics within the group, even in love relationships.</figcaption></figure><h3>“The Blessing is forever. It is eternal.”</h3><p>In Jin Moon spoke those words on November 20, 2011. The timing is ironic, because she was then pregnant with the illegitimate child of another Church member, which ended his marriage. (If you want to read a well-written summary of the Game of Thrones -esque saga that is the Unification Church, check out this <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/115512/unification-church-profile-fall-house-moon">article by The New Republic from 2012</a>. Hopefully someone will update it someday with the newest “episodes” that have come from this cult-family feud.)</p><p>Despite her personal affairs, the phrase echoed the Church’s stance on the marriage ceremonies. Not only did you have to forgo all personal preferences (unless you were a Moon, I guess?) in the Matching and Blessing, but then you have to continue to accept that other person. Forever.</p><p>Most of the Church families that I saw growing up were unhappy. My own parents were deeply unhappy and incredibly abusive towards one another, although I didn’t realize that their behavior qualified as abuse. I simply normalized it for many years. I also heard stories of violent husbands who sent their battered wives to the hospital with broken bones, only to have those wives return again and again. First generation would cluck and shake their heads, but what were they to do? After all, the Blessing is forever.</p><p>Some of these abused partners were even told that it was their fault that their partner was harming them. Somehow they weren’t loving their partners enough, they weren’t setting the right conditions with spirit world. It was their job to heal and raise up their spouse. The line we were given was that God would never give us something that we couldn’t handle.</p><p>It wasn’t until I left the group and started talking to other survivors that I realized the depth of the abuse. I read <a href="https://howwelldoyouknowyourmoon.tumblr.com/post/176459382983/nansook-hong-in-the-shadow-of-the-moons-book"><em>In the Shadow of the Moons</em></a><em> </em>by Nansook Han, and realized that the Moons empowered their abusive son to beat his wife. This behavior likely empowered other abusers to harm their own partners in the Church.</p><h3>Purity Culture as a Form of Sexual Abuse</h3><p>Ok, but what if someone got Matched and Blessed and was lucky enough to end up with a nice spouse? What if they were lucky enough to have never loved someone before meeting their spouse. Is their first love a traumatic one? Maybe.</p><p>The Unification Church co-opted evangelical purity culture when it came into the American national consciousness in the 1990s. (Although I think it’s safe to say that the UC had it’s own brand of purity culture long before they started co-opting language and ideas.) My mother tried to get me to read the book <em>I Kissed Dating Goodbye</em>, by Joshua Harris, which popularized the concept of “courting” as an alternative to mainstream dating and as a foundation for a happy marriage.</p><p>For many, this book was a lynch pin in the purity culture messaging they received as teens, which has contributed to deep emotional traumas that they have around sex and sexuality. The book itself was criticized for being an example of belief in ‘<a href="http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download;jsessionid=B9C3010A1FD062056A58C6E66416DBD3?doi=10.1.1.685.5489&amp;rep=rep1&amp;type=pdf">benevolent sexism’ and ‘women as property’</a>, as promoting <a href="https://www.readcube.com/articles/10.1007/s12119-016-9390-x">‘rape supportive messaging’</a> and ‘<a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/298910311_Producing_High_Priests_and_Princesses_The_Father-Daughter_Relationship_in_the_Christian_Sexual_Purity_Movement">sexual purity teachings’ that emphasize a ‘hierarchical father-daughter relationship’ and reduces the agency of adolescent girls</a>.</p><p>(Harris has since divorced his wife, reconsidered his views on dating, apologized to those whose lives were negatively impacted by the book and directed the book’s publisher to discontinue its publication.)</p><p>Alice Greczyn, founder of <a href="https://www.daretodoubt.org/">Dare to Doubt</a> and author of <a href="https://smile.amazon.com/Wayward-Memoir-Spiritual-Warfare-Sexual-ebook/dp/B08V39YNP5/ref=sr_1_2?dchild=1&amp;keywords=wayward&amp;qid=1620947318&amp;sr=8-2"><em>Wayward: A Memoir of Spiritual Warfare and Sexual Purity,</em></a> wrote an article <a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1LF3JmJg9exal4Kw3JlZKjxldXvl0P8ng/view">Is Purity Culture a Form of Sexual Abuse? for I<em>CSA Today</em>, the International Cultic Studies Association magazine</a>. In it she says,</p><blockquote><em>Purity culture taught me that my love life would unfold in three ways: (a) I would remain a virgin until my wedding night, and I wouldn’t so much as hold hands with a guy until I was engaged to him; (b) As a girl, I would dress modestly and be faithful to my husband all the days of my life, including before I knew him; and c)I would never date, but I would know who my future husband was because God would confirm it through my spiritual elders, and especially through my dad.</em></blockquote><p>She goes on to define purity culture as being based on the belief that the acts of sex should only occur within a heterosexual marriage, and that all lustful thoughts before marriage are sinful. In the Christian churches she grew up in, not only was having a crush on somebody a sin, but it was also a betrayal of her future spouse. In that sense, her experience with purity culture was exactly the same as mine within the Unification Church.</p><p>One of Greczyn’s youth pastor told girls that they were like white porcelain dishes, and when we gave ourselves away, we let people spit all over our dish. What man would ever want to marry us and eat off a dirty dish? Growing up I heard variations on that metaphor. I was chewed up gum, crumpled and torn paper, a cup that had been spit in.</p><p>Like me, Greczyn was also taught that men’s lustful thoughts about her were her fault. In purity culture, women were cautioned not to be “stumbling blocks” for their brothers in Christ. In the Unification Church we had different language for the same concepts. The shame of that experience left her with long-lasting scars, Greczyn says, and instilled her with a fear of her own womanhood.</p><p>This tracks with the data. According to <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/women-who-stray/201708/overcoming-religious-sexual-shame">David J. Ley Ph.D., in a 2017 article <em>Overcoming Religious Sexual Shame</em></a><em> </em>on Psychology Today, “across the country, therapists are now seeing a tide of young people, feeling immense shame and pain about their sexual urges, desires and behaviors” because of the programming of purity culture.</p><p>One of the first therapists to notice this epidemic was Dr. Tina Schermer Sellers. Author Linda Kay Klein interviewed her for the book <a href="https://lindakayklein.com/pure/"><em>Pure: Inside the Evangelical Movement That Shamed a Generation of Young Women and How I Broke Free.</em></a><em> </em>In it Schermer Sellers told Klein that the symptoms she was seeing were exactly the same symptoms she might see in someone who had been sexually abused. However, many of these young people claimed that they had never been sexually abused.</p><p>According to Greczyn,</p><blockquote><em>The timing of this surge of people seeking help for sexual trauma, sometimes with no sexual experience at all, pointed Dr. Tina to the boom of purity culture in the mid to late ’90s. This was the era of promise rings and purity retreats, of abstinence-only sex ed, and books such as Joshua Harris’s </em>I Kissed Dating Goodbye<em>. This was the era of my youth. Klein describes in </em>Pure…<em> how my generation was bombarded at home, at church, and at school with the message that sex was wrong and our bodies were sinful.</em></blockquote><p>She says that some of these repercussions resemble post-traumatic stress disorder: Panic attacks. Paranoia. Nightmares. Dissociative states. Depression. Eating disorders. Self-harm. These symptoms may remain dormant until they’re triggered, by sometimes something as harmless as kissing, or even just talking about sex.</p><p>For women, one of more devastating effects of purity culture that Greczyn describes is a condition called <em>vaginismus</em>, which causes an involuntary tightening of the muscles around the vagina, making sex extremely painful and often impossible. Sometimes vaginismus is a symptom of sexual assault. Other times it’s a symptom of purity culture.</p><p>She goes on to describe the story of one virgin bride who discovered she had vaginismus. This bride was actually looking forward to having sex with her husband, but every time they tried, her body shut down in pain, blocking him from entering her. According to Greczyn, this bride had unwittingly trained her body to shut down this way through years of shutting down any sexual thoughts or sensation, and that sex was so painful that she ended up having to have surgery. Author <a href="https://abcnews.go.com/Health/hasidic-jew-runs-orthodox-roots-arranged-marriage-child/story?id=15540395">Deborah Feldman describes a similarly painful and humiliating experience with vaginismus</a> in her book <a href="https://bookshop.org/books/unorthodox-the-scandalous-rejection-of-my-hasidic-roots/9781439187012"><em>Unorthodox: The Scandalous Rejection of My Hasidic Roots.</em></a></p><p>So taking all of this into account, my guess is that even if one’s first love is supported by the cultic structure, it is still traumatic. Because how can one be raised with strict beliefs about one’s sexuality and sexual development as being evil, and then simply shed those beliefs once in a condoned relationship?</p><p>Getting accurate data on Blessed couples who are in the Unification Church would be difficult, if not impossible. But in the anecdotal conversations that I have had with people who have left the Church with their Blessing partners, I’ve heard that despite loving their partner and choosing to stay with them, there is deep trauma that needs to be healed within their relationship.</p><figure><img alt="A woman in a green cloak kneels in a cave looking up at light coming in through a crack. Image copyright Jen Kiaba." src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*XiSIRZr7qZMM8g9O" /><figcaption>Don’t go it alone. Finding community can make all the difference in your healing journey.</figcaption></figure><h3>Healing from Purity Culture and First Love Trauma</h3><p>As there has been an uptick in reports of sexual trauma within a religious context, there is also an increased number of therapists who are informed on this subject. You can now search sites like <a href="https://www.inclusivetherapists.com/">https://www.inclusivetherapists.com/</a> with keywords such as “purity culture” and find therapists near you who can help with this kind of trauma.</p><p>Therapists who have experience with evangelical Christianity and religious trauma may also be able to help with cult-specific abuse. International Cultic Studies Association also keeps a list of cult-informed therapists here: <a href="https://www.icsahome.com/support/counseling-resources">https://www.icsahome.com/support/counseling-resources.</a> They also run support workshops for those born or raised in high demand groups or religions.</p><p><a href="https://www.reclamationcollective.com/support-groups">There are also resources like the Reclamation Collective, which hold recovery support groups</a>. The support groups are designed to be need-specific, and therefore they have deconstruction and spiritual abuse support groups for men, women, immigrants, the queer community, and the BIPOC community.</p><p>There is also a strong community online of people who are recovering from purity culture. For example, if you follow <a href="https://www.instagram.com/explore/tags/purityculture/">#purityculture</a> on Instagram, you’ll immediately be connected with many accounts run by people who are on their own healing journey or are assisting others in their healing. Instagram is where I found the <a href="https://www.ericasmitheac.com/">sexuality educator Erica Smith</a>. She runs the <a href="https://www.ericasmitheac.com/the-purity-culture-dropout-program">Purity Culture Dropout program</a>, an eight week intensive sexuality education and coaching program for folks who were raised in purity culture and who are seeking queer inclusive, shame free, trauma informed, medically accurate, and comprehensive sex education. She also runs <a href="https://www.ericasmitheac.com/pcd-queer-support-group">Purity Culture Dropout Queer Support Groups</a>.</p><p>All this to say, if you’re suffering from the trauma of love in a cult the damage from purity culture, you’re not alone and you don’t have to go on your healing journey alone. There are many of us here, ready to walk beside you.</p><p><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Get Blog Posts In Your Inbox!</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/trauma-first-love-cult"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on May 14, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=47aa51931803" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Memory Loss, Dissociation and Euphoric Recall in Cults]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/memory-loss-dissociation-and-euphoric-recall-in-cults-d69c2091602b?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d69c2091602b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healing-from-trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[memories]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 11 May 2021 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-12T16:30:15.237Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*qe-OmNsb56bgmwOL" /></figure><p>Several months ago I was listening to an episode of <a href="https://www.fallingoutpod.com/">the Falling Out Podcast</a>, in which the host, Elgen Strait, interviews people who grew up in and left the Unification Church. In this particular episode he was talking to Donna, who had gone to the same church boarding school I did, but had been kicked out the year before I arrived. At one point, Donna says that she had to do research on the school and look back at records and announcements to make sure that her bad memories weren’t some sort of fever dream.</p><p>Her words stopped me in my tracks.</p><h3>Memory Loss and Dissociation</h3><p>Sometimes I, too, struggle to recall things from my childhood in the cult. There are long blanks in my memory. When I do excavate memories, I have to sit with them for a long time and ask, “did I hallucinate that experience?”</p><p>These days, I’ve been talking to a lot of survivors, many of whom are actively sharing their stories online. But the theme of doubting our experiences is something that seems to come up again and again. I began to wonder why that is.</p><p>Could it be that many of us blocked out memories simply to survive?</p><p>When I refer back to <a href="https://coercivecontrolcollective.org/news/2018/6/26/people-to-know-dr-alexandra-stein">Dr. Alexandra Stein’s</a> writing about attachment models in cults, that seems to make sense. <a href="http://www.dailymail.co.uk/home/you/article-5835661/From-high-flyer-sex-slave-Cults-prey-successful-women.html">In a 2018 interview with the Daily Mail she said,</a></p><blockquote><em>“The aim [of cults] is to isolate you and trap you in that isolation. They create chronic stress, which causes trauma. Trauma leads to dissociation, a state in which you cannot think about your own feelings. In that gap, the cult can insert its ideology and tell you what you are feeling.”</em></blockquote><p>Dissociation <a href="https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/dissociative-disorders/what-are-dissociative-disorders">is defined by the American Psychiatric Association</a> as an experience of mental detachment, or disconnection between the mind and body, an unconscious coping mechanism that typically develops in response to trauma. When it’s at its most severe, the person dissociating could experience amnesia, loss of identity, and an inability to recognize themselves or their surroundings.</p><p><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-mind-body-connection/201407/cults-and-the-mind-body-connection">Sharon K. Farber Ph.D., writes in a Psychology Today article </a>that:</p><blockquote><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/love-bombing"><em>Cults start seducing people with love-bombing</em></a><em>, paying a great deal of attention to and being very affectionate with potential recruits, a very effective way of connecting with someone who is feeling lonely and isolated. Then they assault and overwhelm their senses by using various techniques to induce a dissociated state, an altered state of consciousness, a trance state, in which mind and body are disconnected from each other.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>These techniques include sleep and food deprivation, drumming, chanting, lecturing on and on for hours, flashing lights, spinning around in circles, all of which assault the senses and break down a person’s ability to think. The cult uses mind control to fill the dissociated mind with their beliefs and </em><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/magical-thinking"><em>magical thinking</em></a><em>. A moment comes when the mind shuts down and seems to snap from this assault to the nervous system.</em></blockquote><p><a href="https://depts.washington.edu/uwhatc/PDF/TF-%20CBT/pages/7%20Trauma%20Focused%20CBT/Dissociation-Information.pdf">According to the University of Washington’s Harborview Abuse and Trauma Center</a>, everyone occasionally has times of daydreaming or mind wandering, which is normal. But sometimes dissociation is used as a coping mechanism either during trauma, or later on when thinking about or being reminded of the trauma. They say it manifests as:</p><p>What’s interesting to me is that the Unification Church definitely practiced techniques to get people into that dissociative state, and yet we were actively discouraged from “spacing out.” Now, growing up I had no idea what dissociation was, but looking back I now think that many of us in the Church used it as a coping mechanism. Stein and Farber discuss <em>induced dissociation</em> as a cult technique to insert cult ideology, whereas the University of Washington discusses it as a coping mechanism.</p><p>So I have to wonder if the kind of dissociation that <strong>was</strong> encouraged in the Church was the kind that was induced during chanting/singing, lectures, group exercises, punishments, etc. where they could then posit more ideology, versus the kind that might have been used as that protective coping mechanism.</p><p>Then when you layer in how cults train members in thought-stopping techniques to keep doubts from entering their consciousness (in the Unification Church we sometimes chanted phrases like “out Satan,” or “absolute love, absolute faith, absolute obedience”), it’s no wonder that so many of our memories are buried, or feel surreal when we recall them.</p><h3>Abuse Amnesia</h3><p>On the other side of the coin are people who feel as though the only memories that they have access to are positive ones. I’ve heard accounts of this both from people who are still in the Unification Church, as well as those who have left. It’s the latter group that really interest me, because many of them recognize that there are abusive practices in the Church, while still struggling to grapple with their own memories.</p><p><a href="https://www.instagram.com/renrobot.art/">Ren, an activist in the ex-Unification Church second generation community,</a> told me that, up until recently, she had thought that being a part of the Oceania Leadership Team had been an amazing opportunity to travel the world. (OLT is <a href="https://www.summerofcheesecake.com/2015/08/sex-death-human-trafficking-unification-church.html">an outgrowth of the Special Task Force labor trafficking program in the Unification Church, which you can read a little bit more about on my old blog <em>Summer of Cheesecake</em></a><em>.</em>) This, despite the fact that she had been living in a van, fundraising upwards of 16 hours a day, seven days a week, and sometimes had to beg for money for meals. She said, “Up until a few years ago I thought I was so blessed to have all of those experiences. Like, don’t complain, you travelled the world.”</p><p>Another ex-second generation told me, “[I have memory loss] from workshops I attended. Sometimes it’s hard to fully realize that the UC is abusive because we have a non-violent image.”</p><p>Someone else wrote to say, “I couldn’t understand that neglect is abuse; I thought I’d had a lovely childhood.”</p><p><a href="https://www.instagram.com/mightybrecca/">Becca, who is also an activist in the ex-Unification Church second generation </a>community said, “I repressed a lot of bad stuff. Even while I was doing therapy, I had a hard time describing what the problem was. Even now I’m remembering bad encounters and terrible things while or after I listen to an episode of an ex-Moonie podcast or read a post on Instagram. I wonder if I buried those memories deep in my unconscious because I knew they still hurt me.”</p><p>I especially relate to the last person’s experience. Just as I experienced while listening to Donna’s episode on Falling Out, the more I hear or read other ex-second generation’s stories, the more either my own memories resurface, or I am reminded that my memories were not just hallucinations. Growing up we were taught to doubt ourselves, our realities and our perspectives so that the Church could posit its own. But the more we hear each other’s stories, the more it seems that we verify and validate each other’s experiences.</p><p><a href="https://www.goodtherapy.org/therapists/profile/sharon-stines-20160924">Sharie Stines, PsyD</a>, posited in a post on Goodtherapy.com that <a href="https://www.goodtherapy.org/blog/abuse-amnesia-why-we-stay-with-our-abusive-partners-1003175">victims of ongoing abuse can suffer from <strong>abuse amnesia</strong></a><strong>. </strong>She says, “It occurs when a person has been abused-physically, verbally, sexually, or emotionally-and in a matter of minutes, hours, or days, it’s as if the occurrence of abuse never happened. The victim and the perpetrator carry on as if the incident never happened.”</p><p>She describes the changes in brain chemistry during the abuse cycle, saying that during the abuse, stress hormones cortisol and adrenaline are released. During the abandonment phase, the brain releases dopamine which motivates the person to search for relief in the object of desire-the abuser. This syncs perfectly with Dr. Alexandra Stein’s writings on attachment theory in cults, and how running to the abuser or the cult creates a trauma bond. (I explore some of her writing more in depth in the posts, “ <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/why-didnt-you-just-leave">Why Didn’t You Just Leave?</a>” and “ <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/whats-bad-growing-up-cult">What’s So Bad About Growing Up in a Cult?</a> “) Then, according to Sharie Stines, homeostasis sets in and the abusive relationship has become a system, with abuse amnesia as an essential component of this balance.</p><p>She goes on to say that,</p><blockquote><em>“Once the abusive partner comes back and stops actively abusing, the brain releases oxytocin and opioids, which have a calming effect. The stress hormones are diminished and the feelings of relief caused by the positive chemicals reinforce the victim’s ability to forget the bad and hold on to the good.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>The pattern continues-minimize the bad, focus on the good. Forget the pain. Remember the positive.”</em></blockquote><h3>Euphoric Recall</h3><p>Then, the other day, I was being interviewed by someone who asked me to talk about good memories in my family of origin and in the cult. It was an honest and seemingly harmless question on the surface. And I certainly have some safe memories that I was happy to share. But the question also alarmed me for several reasons.</p><p>The first is that, as I’ve shared before, experiencing cultic abuse is similar to experiencing domestic abuse/intimate partner violence. <a href="https://youtu.be/lAXAZzeg8WA?t=716">Dr. Janja Lalich said, in an interview on Change The Narrative with JD Fuller,that </a>“I believe abusive relationships have so many of the same characteristics [as cults] and people coming out of them have very similar issues to to deal with in recovery.” This, she said, is because abusers in relationships and cult leaders use a narcissistic strategy, and interlocking mechanisms of influence and control to continue manipulating the victim or keep one in the group. (I explore more of her model of these interlocking mechanisms in the post “ <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/illusion-choice">The Illusion of Choice.</a>”)</p><p>So, with that in mind, it makes me concerned that asking a cult survivor to share happy memories of their time in a cult, or within a cultic family, can be like asking a domestic violence survivor to share happy memories of times with their abuser.</p><p>It’s not that these happy times don’t exist. In fact, they are part of the cycle of abuse that keeps the victim stuck. <a href="https://youtu.be/06QEn0oTkMQ?t=325">According to Dr. Ramani Durvasula, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist</a>, “it’s very common for people in relationships with narcissists to get really lost in the love-bombing memories.” She goes on to say that in those relationships, it’s very common for love bombing to fuel something called <strong><em>euphoric recall. </em></strong>Durvasula says euphoric recall is “exactly what it sounds like; it’s remembering the good stuff, remembering the euphoric stuff.”</p><p>Like the psychological term “ <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/social-instincts/202101/no-you-were-not-happier-way-back-when-heres-why">rosy retrospection</a>,” euphoric recall is the tendency of people to remember past experiences in a positive light, while overlooking negative experiences. It is generally discussed in dependency and substance abuse terms, and if you Google it, most of the results will be for addiction treatment programs.</p><p>According to Durvasula, as far as narcissistic relationships go, “euphoric recall is your enemy. It makes the rumination worse and make you doubt yourself; and at this point now you’re gaslighting yourself.” The process keeps the victim trapped in a dangerous environment because they tend to doubt their own reality or downplay the abuse.</p><p>So is asking a cult survivor about their happy memories essentially asking them to engage in potential euphoric recall? I think so, and worry that it can potentially trigger them back into the state of doubting their own intuition around an abusive experience. Whether we realize it or not, when we ask the victim to share their happy memories we are potentially asking them to share stories of the cycle of their abuse and gaslighting.</p><p>Does this mean that there were no good experiences growing up in a cult? No. But I think that we need to be careful asking survivors to engage in rosy retrospection, or euphoric recall, because it can be potentially detrimental in the healing process, or trigger them back into the state of doubting their own intuition around an abusive experience.</p><p><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Get Blog Posts In Your Inbox!</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/memory-loss-dissociation-euphoric-recall"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on May 11, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d69c2091602b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What is love bombing?]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/what-is-love-bombing-jen-kiaba-9ea75054d599?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9ea75054d599</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[love-bombing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[narcissistic-abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[domestic-violence]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Apr 2021 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-12T16:26:50.834Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*mEG_xzA4a2XzSzCg" /></figure><p>The term “love bombing” seems to have come into the cultural consciousness in a big way in the past several years, perhaps because of the prevalence of toxic behavior in arenas like online dating. Culturally we’re at a point where the term gets tossed around quite casually. A quick Google search on the term brings up cautionary articles from sources as varied as Cosmopolitan to Business Insider and Psychology Today.</p><p>Many articles highlight the fact that love bombing is a control tactic, and go as far to say that it’s generally used by people on the narcissistic personality disorder spectrum, especially in dating. They point to signs like constant compliments, showers of gifts and things moving quickly in relationships as being potential red flags. But many of these articles seem to miss the mark in terms of diving into how sinister love bombing really is. They talk about how in online dating contexts, someone might ghost after love bombing someone, but they don’t get into the psychology of what happens if a love bomber is able to use the tactic to manipulate someone. Because the reality is that being ghosted is probably the best case scenario if you ever find yourself on the receiving end of love bombing.</p><p>So I want to explore exactly what this tactic is, the kinds of people who use it, why it is abusive, and how to identify the signs of love bombing so that we can protect ourselves from it.</p><p>According to the support group <a href="https://www.btr.org/uncover-3-disturbing-tactics-emotional-abusers-use/">Betrayal Trauma Recovery</a>,<strong> “</strong>Love Bombing is a distinct phase in the <a href="https://www.btr.org/what-is-narcissistic-abuse/">cycle of narcissistic abuse</a>, and is present in every abusive relationship. It is also known as the ‘honeymoon phase’.”</p><p><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/lifetime-connections/201804/love-bombing-narcissists-secret-weapon">Suzanne Degges-White Ph.D., describes love bombing as the practice of overwhelming someone with signs of adoration and attraction.</a> She discusses it in the context of a romantic partner as acts like flattering comments, tokens of affection, or love notes placed everywhere. Other signs she says to watch out for are text messages that increase in frequency and romantic fervor, which can escalate into surprise appearances designed to manipulate you into spending more time with the love-bomber, less time with others, or on your own.</p><p><a href="https://bestlifeonline.com/dating-red-flag/">Marriage and Family Therapist Shirin Peykar, LMFT says that the motivation behind love bombing is often “to win over your trust and affection so that [the abuser] can meet a goal of theirs”</a>, such as control, the feeling of power or superiority, or the boosting of the abuser’s ego.</p><p><a href="https://www.domesticshelters.org/articles/identifying-abuse/it-s-not-love-it-s-love-bombing">Domesticshelters.org, a searchable directory of domestic violence programs and shelters in the U.S. and Canada, says that love bombing is particularly sinister</a> because “abusers thrive off of building up your self-esteem before gradually tearing it down. By getting you to trust them and open yourself up, they end up learning your weaknesses and using them as bait to make you stay. It’s common for survivors to easily get gaslighted and feel controlled, even without noticing.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*g8XXlDrGZuwG5NOawQxJZA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Abusers rely on long-term “love bombing” tactics to build up a sense of dependency in their victim</figcaption></figure><h3>Where did the term “love bombing” come from?</h3><p>While, love-bombing doesn’t always take place within a romantic context, the intended outcome is always the same: to isolate and control the victim. That’s because it’s a technique that exists on the coercive control spectrum, and it’s used to seduce the victim and to get them to lower their defenses.</p><p>According to a number of psychiatrists, love bombing is a psychological weapon used to manipulate a victim in order to gain and then maintain power and control in a relationship. The relationship could be romantic, a friendship, or a business connection. Gang leaders and pimps use it as a a way of controlling their victims as outlined in the 2009 book <em>Gangs and Girls: Understanding Juvenile Prostitution</em> by Michel Dorais and Patrice Corriveau.</p><p>And, of course, cult leaders use love bombing to recruit followers.</p><p><strong>The cultic origins of the term “love bombing”</strong></p><p>According to Ronald N. Loomis, a cult awareness educator and the Director of Education for the American Family Foundation, the term “love bombing” originated with the Unification Church. <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20040818214228/http://religiousmovements.lib.virginia.edu/cultsect/mdtaskforce/loomis_testimony.htm">He testified before the Maryland Cult Task Force in 1999</a> and said that love bombing was a technique that the Unification Church used in their recruitment on college campuses. He testified that love bombing is,</p><blockquote><em>“a recruiter approaching the student and doing everything that the recruiter can to make the student feel special and unique. They’re quickly trying to convey the message that ‘I am your new best friend.’ And they will fake mutual interests in order to give the impression that they share many things in common.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>And this process is done through typically several visits without it ever being identified that there is an agenda, that, in fact, the person is a recruiter, that they are representing a group, and that their real purpose is to get that student into the group.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>And they usually try to find a student who shows the outward signs of being vulnerable, of being alone, of maybe looking like they’re kind of sad.”</em></blockquote><p>In fact, Loomis went on to say that some cults like the Unification Church went so far as to recruit outside of the student counseling offices. He said,</p><blockquote><em>“This group trained its members to stand outside the doors of your [counseling] center and study the faces of students that are leaving who are probably coming from an appointment. If they’re crying, if they’re avoiding eye contact, if they’re looking down and sad, then you walk along side that person and you strike up a conversation about the weather, about what’s going on campus, check out the books that they’re carrying and quickly pretend that you are also taking the same course or took it.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Do anything to make a connection because that person is going to respond to you more typically than a student who you might find sitting with six other people in the student union snack bar laughing and having a good time.”</em></blockquote><p>Psychology professor, Dr. <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Singer">Margaret Singer</a>, one of the leading researchers on thought reform, originally brought awareness to this concept through her writings on cult behaviors. In her 1996 book, <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cults_in_Our_Midst"><em>Cults in Our Midst</em></a>, she writes,</p><blockquote><em>As soon as any interest is shown by the recruits, they may be love bombed by the recruiter or other cult members. This process of feigning friendship and interest in the recruit was originally associated with one of the early youth cults, but soon it was taken up by a number of groups as part of their program for luring people in.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Love bombing is a coordinated effort, usually under the direction of leadership, that involves long-term members’ flooding recruits and newer members with flattery, verbal seduction, affectionate but usually nonsexual touching, and lots of attention to their every remark. Love bombing — or the offer of instant companionship — is a deceptive ploy accounting for many successful recruitment drives.</em></blockquote><p>In her 1977 article “Therapy with ex-cultists,” which appeared in the <em>National Association of Private Psychiatric Hospitals Journal</em>, Singer also said that while love bombing might initially be interpreted as kindness, or a manifestation that the devotees has access to a spiritual truth enabling them to radiate love and win others to their truth, love bombing is actually interpreted as a sinister ‘coercive’ technique.</p><p>The idea behind love bombing is to get the potential victim to lower their defenses. Dennis Tourish, wrote an article <em>Charismatic leadership and corporate cultism at Enron: The elimination of dissent, the promotion of conformity and organizational collapse </em>for a 2005 issue of the journal <em>Leadership, </em>and in it he calls love bombing an recruitment strategy that is aimed at emotionally draining the victim and positively attaching them to the recruiter.</p><p>Now, growing up in the Unification Church, I didn’t necessarily experience the love bombing that a recruit would have. However, those techniques were still occasionally used on the second generation if leadership felt that someone needed to be coerced back into proper behavior. For example, being introverted or isolated in the Church was considered to be dangerous, because you would be “forming a common base with Satan.” But really, when someone is left to their own thoughts, divergent thinking can occur. So, if at a workshop, someone was having difficulty getting into the spirit of things, they might have been love bombed by other second generation. People of the same gender would have followed them around, constantly hugged or touched them, and invaded their physical and emotional space to get them to participate. If that didn’t work, then more shaming or abusive measures would have been used.</p><p>As a counselor for an outside camp when I was 18, I even used love bombing on a young camper when we were playing kickball, although I wasn’t aware that what it was at the time. This camper had slid into home base, and had gotten a scrape along her thigh in the process. Her immediate reaction was to cry from the pain, but I encouraged everyone around her to start cheering her on for having made it to home base. Before she had shed many tears, her eyes lit up and she was cheering as well.</p><p>And for a long time I thought I had done the right thing, redirecting her focus to the positive. But at the same time, she was six years old, likely in pain, and deserved someone to acknowledge her and make sure she got appropriate care. What I did was manipulate her emotions and redirected her focus, and while it might have been a small instance of love bombing, and didn’t include manipulative escalation, it was still toxic.</p><p><a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/reading-between-the-headlines/201703/the-manipulative-partners-most-devious-tactic">In an article for <em>Psychology Today,</em> psychiatrist Dr. Dale Archer</a> says that love bombing works because”humans have a natural need to feel good about who we are, and often we can’t fill this need on our own.” He says that there are times of high susceptibility to being love bombed, such as after losing a job or going through a divorce. If we think back to my article “ <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/we-are-vulnerable">We are all vulnerable</a>,” the susceptibilities that Archer highlights resonate perfectly with what other experts say are the times in our lives are when we are most at risk for cult recruitment.</p><p>However, Archer points out that no matter how, why or where one’s susceptibility has arisen, love bombers”are experts at detecting low self-esteem, and exploiting it.” This underscores exactly what Loomis said in his testimony to the Maryland Cult Task Force, and what Dr. Singer herself describes as a “coordinated effort.”</p><p>In fact, the Unification Church so indoctrinated their members to love bomb potential recruits that <a href="https://history.familyfed.org/tf-sermons/we-who-have-been-called-to-do-gods-work">Rev. Moon, the leader of the church, told members in 1978 that they had to keep up the facade of happiness at all times</a>:</p><blockquote><em>Here the walls are tired of seeing your sullen faces. They are waiting for the time when they will see that Unification Church members are smiling all of the time, even at four in the morning. The man who is full of love must live that way. When you go out witnessing you can caress the wall and say that it can expect you to witness well and be smiling when you return. What face could better represent love than a smiling face? This is why we talk about love bomb; Moonies have that kind of happy problem. We are called by God to perfect ourselves in this love.</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7Xo1mexRVmQUrovwSUf6Lg.png" /></figure><p>In the Unification Church, the importance of love bombing was reinforced with other thought control techniques like group chanting. In the memoir <em>Crazy for God — The nightmare of cult life</em> ex-Moon disciple Christopher Edwards describes how even something as seemingly innocuous as a game of ball was used to reinforce love bombing as a control technique:</p><blockquote>Each group divided up into one of two teams. Each team was appointed a captain who suggested a cheer and team chant. During the entire game our team chanted loudly, “Bomb with Love,” “Blast with Love,” as the soft, round balls volleyed back and forth. Again I felt lost and confused, angry, remote and helpless, for the game had started without an explanation of the rules. The guests were being moved around the field like robots on roller skates.<em> </em>“Listen, Chris,” Jacob called from the sidelines. “If you don’t understand the rules, just chant or cheer as loudly as possible. The important thing is to do whatever a Family member tells you. Remember, unity is everything here.”</blockquote><p>The movie <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ticket_to_Heaven">Ticket to Heaven</a>, which is based on the book <a href="https://www.abebooks.com/9780888930200/Moonwebs-Journey-mind-cult-Freed-0888930208/plp"><em>Moonwebs: Journey Into the Mind of a Cult</em></a> by journalist Josh Freed, has similar scenes at 0:25:00 and at 1:03:30, where members playing a kind of dodgeball chant, “bomb with love! bomb with love! bomb with love!”</p><h3>Protecting Yourself from Love Bombing</h3><p><a href="https://www.cosmopolitan.com/sex-love/a26988344/love-bombing-signs-definition/">Psychotherapist Ami Kaplan, LCSW, says that “anyone is capable of love bombing, but it’s most often a symptom of narcissistic personality disorder.”</a> When referring to interpersonal relationship, and not cultic/gang/trafficking recruitment, she claims that love bombing is largely an unconscious behavior.</p><p><a href="https://www.laurarichards.co.uk/deep-diving-coercive-control/">Victim advocate Laura Richards cautions that love bombing “will not feel like bombardment, although it is. It will feel flattering.”</a></p><p>But once the abuser feels secure in the relationship, Kaplan says they typically switch and become very difficult, abusive, or manipulative and switch to devaluing their victim.</p><p>The support group Betrayal Trauma Recovery says that love bombing typically presents as:</p><ul><li>Putting the victim on a pedestal</li><li>Constant communication (texting, phone calls, letters, dates, over-nights, trips together)</li><li>Early, strong commitment (getting engaged, entering into a relationship, getting married, sleeping together soon after meeting or having reunited)</li><li>Putting down previous partners (“my other girlfriends were never as beautiful as you,” “my ex-wife was psycho,” etc)</li><li>Buying expensive gifts</li><li>Entrusting victim with intimate knowledge and secrets</li><li>Entrusting victim with personal belongings (car, apartment, credit card, etc)</li><li>Constant, “ultimate” praise (“hottest in the world,” “perfect,” “best,” etc)</li><li>Intense, passionate, and frequent sexual encounters</li></ul><p>When removing the sexual or romantic connotations, many of these signs can be used for other relational dynamics as well.</p><p>For example, years ago I once had a former work colleague attempt to get close to me by telling me inappropriate levels of detail about his life and then express dismay when I wasn’t comfortable reciprocating. He would say things like I was undermining his sense of worth and self esteem because I was putting up inappropriate boundaries. Eventually he even tried to send me sexually inappropriate photos before I cut him out of my life.</p><p>In the same workplace, there was also a consultant that would call me on the evenings on weekends praising me by saying that I was the “only person in the company with executive leadership skills.” Then he eventually told me that he wanted to get the job of CEO in the company, and wanted to use me and my skill as leverage. When I pushed back on his overall behavior, he screamed at me in a conference room. His behavior, and the company’s overall support of his tactics, led me to resign.</p><p>Dr. Dale Archer suggests the following as a litmus test for judging a potential love bomber:</p><blockquote><em>“Think of your best friend, how much you have in common, and how often the two of you agree (or disagree). Now consider how long it took to build that bond. Is it likely someone you’ve just met knows you as well as your best friend? If you find yourself saying, ‘Yes, they do!’ warning bells should be ringing.”</em></blockquote><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rKgc6QUPjLCASKz1V3FpkA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Love bombers typically switch and become very difficult, abusive, or manipulative of their victim.</figcaption></figure><p>Archer also says to beware of those who:</p><ul><li>constantly seek to stroke your ego</li><li>push a relationship to levels you’re not ready for</li><li>are quick to show warmth and affection, but then lose their temper or find other ways to “punish” you when they don’t get their way</li></ul><p>Remember, you have a right to set boundaries. If anyone is trying to get to move faster than you’re comfortable with, make a choice quickly, or tries to punish you for not going along with them, those are red flags. It’s better to give yourself time and space away from that relationship to get a clear head and make rational decisions. And if you’re afraid that you’re already involved in an unhealthy group, situation, or relationship, it’s ok to reach out to friends, family or professionals to get help.</p><p><a href="https://narcissistabusesupport.com/resources/">Narcissistabusesupport.com has a list of resources, from therapists to local support groups as well as links to free legal assistance and housing.</a></p><p>And the International Cultic Studies Association (ICSA) provides <a href="https://www.spiritualabuseresources.com/get-help/recovery-from-spiritual-abuse">SpiritualAbuseResources.com as a service to help people recover from coercive control in spiritual contexts</a>. ICSA also has <a href="https://www.icsahome.com/support/counseling-resources">an extensive list of counseling resources here</a> if you or a loved one is looking for a cult-aware therapist.</p><p><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Get Blog Posts In Your Inbox!</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/love-bombing"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on April 30, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9ea75054d599" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[What’s so bad about growing up in a cult?]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/whats-so-bad-about-growing-up-in-a-cult-7a4ce8b29c14?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7a4ce8b29c14</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[childhood-trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abuse-survivors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma-recovery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Apr 2021 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-03T15:36:38.002Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*OUa8-nyvg99kABiK" /></figure><p>A few years ago someone commented on one of my social media posts, asking me to explain why I felt that growing up in a cult was such a bad thing. It was such a diminishing question that I felt my brain completely freeze up. The question mirrored much of the gaslighting that the Unification Church and other high demand groups &amp; cults inflict upon their membership, telling them that things aren’t that bad, or that they should be grateful for their suffering.<br> <br>Other cults employ similar gaslighting techniques, such as the below shared by the Instagram account “ <a href="https://www.instagram.com/letstalkcults/">Let’s Talk Cults</a>.”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/868/1*S5y3Q5HRJkwKVtWDUKCTUQ.png" /></figure><p>Essentially many of these phrases mean the same thing as “what was so bad about growing up in a cult.” And trauma survivors across the spectrum have probably heard variations on the phrase. So when confronted by a stranger on the internet with that question, the only response I could give in my triggered state was, “I suggest you educate yourself on cultic abuses before asking a question like that.”</p><p>Now that several years have passed, I wanted to take the time to answer the question more fully. And to be clear, I don’t think that it should be the survivor’s job to take on the emotional labor of educating the public about childhood trauma in cults. But this is an area that I’ve been diving into a lot lately, and so I wanted to write a post that other survivors could direct the curious public to, in case faced with a similarly impertinent question.</p><p>Let’s start by saying that to ask any survivor of a cult (whether first generation, second generation or multigenerational) what was so bad about their experience is akin to asking a domestic abuse survivor what was so bad about their relationship. As I’ve covered before, coercive control manifests similarly in cultic environments, trafficking environments, and in intimate partner violence. So if the thought of asking a battered woman what was so bad about her relationship makes you recoil, just know that the question resonates similarly to survivors of other coercive environments.</p><h3>Terror tactics used in cultic systems</h3><p>According to Alexandra Stein, author of <a href="https://www.routledge.com/Terror-Love-and-Brainwashing-Attachment-in-Cults-and-Totalitarian-Systems/Stein/p/book/9781138677975">“Terror Love and Brainwashing: Attachment in Cults and Totalitarian Systems,”</a> the grooming process to lure someone into a cultic group is also very similar to the grooming process seen with domestic violence. The victim may be subjected to “love bombing,” a process of inundating a person with adoration and attention, which can trick them into thinking they have found a safe space. But then the switch occurs, where the abuser begins to isolate the victim from their friends and family, and a person is then engulfed in a new, abusive system. Now, when someone is born into this abusive system, they are born within that isolation.</p><p>According to Stein that isolation within the abusive system paves the way for “terror” tactics to be utilized. This can range from the abuser threatening the victim, teaching them to fear the outside world, instilling the fear of an apocalyptic event, or causing the victim to walk on eggshells in fear of being criticized by the leader or the group.</p><p>Stein says, “I believe <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/attachment">attachment</a> theory provides a good theoretical approach for understanding brainwashing, and it holds that people run to a safe haven when they are afraid. If the group has been successful, the recruit, now having had fear instilled by the group, runs to the only safe haven available-the group itself.”</p><p>With children in the cultic system, I believe that there is another layer to this. Oftentimes parents are in the position of abuser, or allow for others within the cult abuse the children. In my case other adults and second generation members acted as abusers when my parents weren’t present. When children have been programmed with “terror” tactics from a young age, it means that they are that much more likely to run to the “safe haven” of the abusive parents/members and the cultic system.</p><h3>The effects of terror</h3><p>According to Stein, there are two major effects of running to the group for safety. The first is that it creates a trauma bond with the abusive parents and/or group. Stein classifies this as a disorganized attachment bond, and emphasizes that it is a difficult bond to break when a person is isolated from alternative havens of safety. This underscores many of the points I made in a previous post, “ <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leavingwhy-didnt-you-just-leave">Why didn’t you just leave?”</a></p><p>Another important point that Stein makes is that isolation doesn’t necessarily have to be physical. Even a cult that doesn’t keep its members on a secluded compound can still be considered isolationist, because they are secluding their members on an emotional and cognitive level. This is usually achieved by controlling personal relationships between cult members as well as limiting access to family members outside of the group, and by controlling access to information about the group. For example, growing up I was taught that my family members who were not in the Unification Church were evil, and that if I read material that criticized the Church I would be possessed by evil spirits.</p><p>Stein states that the second effect of running to the source of fear for safety is dissociation, because this technique doesn’t provide an actual escape from the threat. It instead causes a person to go into a kind of “freeze” mode. According to Stein:</p><blockquote><em>“This explains why perfectly intelligent people can find themselves unable to rationally view a cult they are involved with. It is literally too frightening and disorganizing to do so. The lack of alternate information and true havens undermine a follower’s cognitive processes on matters regarding the group. The cult can now do the thinking for them-the essence of brainwashing.”</em></blockquote><p>Now, again, most of Stein’s work focuses on the cult recruit. And, unfortunately, there is a dearth of information on the developmental consequences of being born or raised in this kind of terrorizing system.</p><p>As I discuss in my post <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/healing-through-art-research">Healing Through Art — Part Two: The Research</a>, Leona Furnari, LSW, wrote a paper which outlines a number of issues that children raised in cults can suffer from. They include, but are not limited to:</p><p>These, however are development considerations. They do not cover the ongoing issues that cult life can have on second and multi generational adults.</p><p>However Cyndi H. Matthews published a study, <a href="https://www.icsahome.com/articles/second-generation-religious-cult-survivors-implications-for-counselors-docx"><em>Second-Generation Religious Cult Survivors: Implications for Counselors</em></a><em>,</em> in the International Journal of Cultic Studies. In it she found that while first- and second-generation cult survivors both experienced psychological challenges in leaving a cult and reintegrating into society, second generation adult cult survivors face additional challenges. Similar to Furnari’s paper, some of these challenges include the effects of a lifetime of abuse and neglect, attachment disorders, a lack of education, but Matthews also goes further to explore family-relationship challenges, and a lack of external-world support.</p><p>The following is excerpted from her study, the full text of which can be found in the link above.</p><h3>Challenges childhood cult survivors face</h3><p>In her study Matthews identifies 12 themes in participants’ experiences of growing up in a cult, deciding to leave, leaving, and living outside the cult:</p><p><strong>1: Patriarchy and Gender Roles</strong> — many participants describe the subjugation of women and domination by men in their religious cults. In the Unification Church, we referred to man as “subject” and woman as “object.” This was illustrated in the theological text, <em>The Divine Principle,</em> as the “Four Position Foundation”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/532/1*B-89tmFiJiRb-FLbLJXJEw.png" /><figcaption>An example of a graph showing man in the “subject” position and women in the “object” position in Divine Principle teachings.</figcaption></figure><p>According to Matthews’ study, after leaving, however, almost all participants experienced marriage or relationship difficulties in terms of superior/subordinate relationships. They found they needed to redefine their roles in marriage, and most considered the possibility of ending marriages that were created in the cult. She further states that these and other subjugation and manipulation techniques may contribute to former members’ feelings of low self-esteem, powerlessness, and worthlessness.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*eJX1Nz7gzZVm7ksbWkphGg.jpeg" /><figcaption>“The Penitent Ones” by Jen Kiaba</figcaption></figure><p><strong>2: Obedience to Authority </strong>— Throughout their time in the cult, participants were forced to unquestioningly submit to authority. Those who did question authority were subjected to humiliation, shaming, and possible abuse, such as being yelled at, shamed in public or private, called out from the pulpit, and even spanked in public. When leaving a cultic group, that training can stick with a second generation adult, making it difficult for them to stand up to authority figures or question them.</p><p><strong>3: Decision Making</strong> — Similar to the demand of obedience to authority, all participants in the study discuss how decisions were made by the cult leaders, or in some cases, fathers in the community. Many participants mention that physical, emotional, or psychological abuse would follow if decisions made by the leader were not followed. Upon leaving their respective groups, survivors discuss having difficulties with with black and white or polarized thinking, magical thinking, and trying to find the one right answer to a problem or question. This can make it difficult to function independently and make decisions on their own once leaving the cult.</p><p><strong>4: Group and Relationship Support </strong>— When a first generation member leaves a cult, they have the option to reunite with old friends and family. There is a “pre-cult identity” to return to. But according to Matthews, second generation survivors do not have those options. They are dealing with complete loss of friends, family and identity. They also often struggle with building new relationships and friendships in an outside world where they feel “judged” and “weird.” Because most cult survivors have not experienced healthy relationships, they also tend either not to trust at all or to trust too much in relationships, which can lead to additional negative experiences.</p><p><strong>5: Relationship With Parents</strong> — In most cases, parents have full authority over their children in a cultic environment. Participants in the study discuss that fathers used anger and punishment to control, and mothers used guilt and shame to control their children. Overall, parents put children’s needs second to the cult. <br>Upon leaving, for parents who continued to communicate with their parents, conversations were generally guarded because the cult continued to come up in conversation and the participants would be invited back to church.</p><p>In many of the stories that I have heard coming out of the Unification Church, children’s needs were often categorized as “selfish” or “satanic,” leading to parents neglecting their children and teaching them that it wasn’t safe to express their needs. When I left, my mother often asked me to come to “forgiveness ceremonies” where for a large sum of money I could be reinstated back into good standing in the Church. She would also tell me that all of my struggles in assimilating to the outside world were because I had left, and that I “needed God in my life.”</p><p><strong>6: Religiosity and Spirituality</strong> — study participants note that to be “spiritual” meant to be “religious” and obey all cult rules and regulations. The cult, after all, was posited as the only path into heaven or to achieve enlightenment. Yet oftentimes participants observe that the behavior of the leader was not in tandem with the doctrine, or the doctrine itself didn’t make sense to them.</p><p>Matthews notes that, today, most participants consider religiosity and spirituality as completely different entities, with spirituality meaning “connection with a higher power or nature”, and religiosity meaning “dedication to a specific religious denomination.” She said that most participants considered themselves to be spiritual but express a lack of trust toward any church organization.</p><p><strong>7: Abuse</strong> — according to Matthews all discuss psychological/emotional, physical, spiritual, and sexual abuse they suffered in their respective cults. She states that all forms of abuse in a cult could be classified as spiritual abuse, because it was done in the name of a higher power or religious organization. Physical abuse took the form of hitting, spanking, isolation, and food and sleep deprivation. Emotional abuse was the most common form of abuse reported, such as calling people out, public or private rebuke, public humiliation, intimidation, and threats.</p><p>She also notes that some participants even talk about how they were manipulated into and participated in the abuse of disobedient or defiant members. They discuss the guilt and shame they experienced because of the abuse, and how they left because they could not tolerate inflicting abuse upon others. In the Unification Church we were expected to “report” on other’s behavior, and to either shame someone into better behavior or, essentially, shun them.</p><p>Upon leaving, almost all participants also experienced shunning and threats from their families and other cult members.</p><p><strong>8: Outside Influences</strong> — Because these former cult members were separated from the outside world while in the cult, they saw outside influences such as work, school, and counseling as evil and to be avoided. When they left their respective groups, almost all participants report that they felt behind in education, finances, and employment. Because all their time had been spent working in the cult, they had not had the opportunity to advance their own skills and abilities. Many also report that they didn’t know how to spend their free time.</p><p><strong>These final four themes are perhaps the most important in my view, and Matthews states that they were also interwoven into the prior eight themes.</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*WQeg4U58VSdPj9KZF2mPVA.jpeg" /><figcaption>“Let Me Look At You” by Jen Kiaba</figcaption></figure><p><strong>9: Sense of Identity </strong>— While in the cult, members were taught how to be and act. Most participants report that they had two identities, one that was constructed in the cult and one secret self that was not known to the cult. Participants felt torn between their two identities. Once they left, many participants report feeling lost, confused, different, behind, and even somewhat childlike or naïve in relationship to others around them. Participants report that discovering their true personality was difficult but rewarding.</p><p><strong>10: Emotional Consequences of Life in the Cult</strong> — While they were in the cult, participants report feeling judged by others, guilty about their decisions and thoughts, and angry as a result of manipulation, abuse, and control. Some individuals left because of their anger toward parents or leaders or both. They all experienced a wide variety of strong emotions, especially guilt and anger, while they were leaving. After leaving, participants report that they continue to deal with guilt, anger, shame, and depression.</p><p>To compound the difficulties, after leaving, second generation survivors have difficulties learning to trust and interact with “outside people,” after having been taught to distrust them their entire lives.</p><p><strong>11: Fear and Courage</strong> — Cult leaders manipulated and controlled the group’s members by inducing fear in them through threats, shunning, humiliation, and abuse. These feelings of fear led to dread, hopelessness, and helplessness that continued to reappear for participants during and after leaving. In spite of their fear, all participants found the courage to leave.</p><p><strong>12: Long Process of Change</strong> — For all participants, leaving took a lot of thought and reflection. All participants mention that they felt forever affected and damaged because of their cult experiences. [Previous studies] found that the effects of living in a cult last long beyond when one leaves. Participants in this study reiterate that change and healing were a lifetime process.</p><h3>In their own words</h3><p>With the above themes in mind, I wanted to hear from other second generation Unification Church survivors, and asked them to share their responses to the question: “What was so bad about growing up in a cult.” Here’s what some of them had to say:</p><ul><li>Toxic altruism</li><li>You are not taught to think independently.</li><li>Secret identities and double lives.</li><li>You grow up never trusting yourself, then when you leave you don’t trust anyone else either.</li><li>Definitely a lot of shame a guilt</li><li>Feeling incapable of expressing oneself/connecting with others.</li><li>The biggest challenge has been trusting my ability to make sound decisions.</li><li>It taught me to hate myself because I couldn’t be the version of myself they wanted.</li><li>You turn into a program in that it robs you of your humanity (you turn into the walking dead).</li><li>It doesn’t allow people to be different, express themselves honestly and openly as unique individuals with unique experiences and ideas.</li><li>Cults instill the idea that if you don’t follow their teachings (that are the only and chosen way to live) there is consequences of pain, shame, eternal torture, they make people rely on the organization to feel a sense of value and purpose which is why it is hard to leave.</li><li>I lived in fear of myself, that my own needs would be against the church. I lived in heightened fear of negative emotions, experiences, ideas and people that didn’t understand the cults vision.</li><li>There was pressure to conform, follow and support and live to a standard. For those, and for myself, that were different in a variety of ways, it created a sense of self hate, self abandonment, disgust, confusion, frustration, anger, leading to self destructive behaviors, because I couldn’t bridge the gap between the expectations and who I was.</li></ul><p>As we can see, many of the responses that I received fit into the themes covered in the study done by Matthews. But the ones that stuck out to me the most were the ones that talked about self-hatred. That’s something that resonated deeply with me, and along with the lack of self trust, is perhaps the thing that I find the most tragic. When you’re taught not to love or trust yourself, it allows space for any kind of abuser to step in and define your worth for you. I’m of the opinion that these things make the childhood cult survivor that much more susceptible to future abuses when they leave the group.</p><h3>Hope for the future</h3><p>Even with all of the difficulties stated above, there is hope for those of us who grew up in cults. According to Leona Furnari, MSW, LCSW and Rosanne Henry, MS, LPC, in their ISCA Today article <em>Lessons Learned from [Second Generation Adults] about Recovery and Resiliency</em>:</p><blockquote><em>As yet, resiliency research specifically for [second generation cult survivors] has not been carried out. Resiliency research that has been done with children who face many risk factors similar to the factors children in cultic groups may face shows hopeful results. This resiliency research indicates that 70% to 75% of children who have experienced significant risk factors are able to survive and create positive lives for themselves. In addition, research in recent years on the plasticity of the human brain and its ability to generate new cells and neuro-networks with new learning and new experiences provides much hopefulness for the capacity to overcome developmental trauma.</em></blockquote><p><strong>Now, what does resiliency look like to you?</strong></p><p>According to Funari and Henry, most of us who who were raised in high demand groups do not see ourselves as resilient. And yet the participants in their workshops had jobs; many were married; some were raising children; a few were in school. Still, because of how they were raised, many participants did not seem to recognize just how powerful they were. After all, that power was demonstrated in their ability to survive, walk away from everything they had ever known, and create a new life. Still, many participants understated both their survival and success.</p><p>Perhaps you too are prone to diminishing your success and resiliency.</p><p>In their workshop, Fenori and Henry asked participants to define their own resiliency on a continuum from vulnerability (less resiliency) to adaptability (more resiliency), with a discussion of what impacts the ones’ ability to be resilient. Participants came up with four categories of overlapping strengths that they used to define resiliency: 1) Social Competence, 2) Problem Solving, 3) Autonomy, and 4) Sense of Purpose.</p><p>Below is a table of the list of the strengths that participants used to define their resilience.:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*XyQlZBRPdHJ1_XZloHNcqw.png" /></figure><p>Perhaps reviewing these qualities can help you see yourself in a new light: as stronger, more capable, and much more resilient than you ever thought. At least, I certainly hope it does.</p><p><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Get Blog Posts In Your Inbox!</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/whats-bad-growing-up-cult"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on April 22, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7a4ce8b29c14" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Healing Through Art — Part Two: The Research]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/healing-through-art-part-two-the-research-3619d7d52e81?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3619d7d52e81</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abuse-survivors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healing-from-trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[art-therapy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[religious-trauma]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 14 Apr 2021 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-19T14:51:24.276Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Healing Through Art — Part Two: The Research</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*ve-BIckno0H4or58" /></figure><p>In focusing on art as a healing tool, I want to hone in specifically on religious trauma because that area of focus is where my personal experience is rooted. However, I believe that many of the resources shared in this post apply to other areas of trauma as well.</p><p>Let’s start by defining religious trauma. According to <a href="https://mywellbeing.com/ask-a-therapist/everything-you-need-to-know-about-religious-trauma">therapist Sheri Heller, </a>who specializes in treating complex trauma, addictive disorders, survivors of narcissistic abuse in addition to religious and spiritual trauma,</p><blockquote><em>“Religious or spiritual trauma is a form of psychological abuse and brainwashing that inculcates the shameful message that we are sinful and must live in a constant state of penance and atonement to escape the ravages of hell and God’s punishment. This kind of fall-redemption theology uses fear to ensure dominance and control. Essentially it sets up Stockholm syndrome with the spiritual/religious leader and with one’s idea of God.”</em></blockquote><p>Psychologist Marlene Winell coined the term <a href="https://journeyfree.org/rts/">“Religious Trauma Syndrome” (RTS) </a>in a<a href="https://www.babcp.com/Review/RTS-Its-Time-to-Recognize-it.aspx"> 2011 article she wrote for the British Association for Cognitive and Behavioural Psychotherapies </a>. She describes RTS as:</p><blockquote><em>“the condition experienced by people who are struggling with leaving an authoritarian, dogmatic religion and coping with the damage of indoctrination. They may be going through the shattering of a personally meaningful faith and/or breaking away from a controlling community and lifestyle. RTS is a function of both the chronic abuses of harmful religion and the impact of severing one’s connection with one’s faith. It can be compared to a combination of PTSD and Complex PTSD (C-PTSD).”</em></blockquote><p>I wanted to highlight Winell’s definition specifically because she uses the phrase “ <strong>authoritarian, dogmatic religion</strong>.”</p><p>Despite the growing body of research on Religious Trauma Syndrome, is a relatively new term and field of study. <a href="https://www.restorationcounselingseattle.com/religious-trauma-transitions">According to Mackenzi Kingdon (LMS) </a>, a licensed mental health counselor in Washington State, “Religious Trauma Syndrome is not an official diagnosis in the DSM-5. [But] it is a common experience shared among many who have escaped cults, fundamentalist religious groups, abusive religious settings, or other painful experiences with religion.”</p><p>Therefore, I will rely on research done on cults to help fill in some gaps. Please keep in mind that not all churches and religions are cults. However, some exist on the cultic spectrum. So if my use of the word “cult” feels alienating, please substitute the words “religion” or “church” in your mind as needed.</p><h3>The damage that cults &amp; high demand religions do to children</h3><p>Many of us who are dealing with the fallout of religious trauma were raised in these authoritarian groups, and therefore I want to hone in on the developmental damage that is done to children. In her paper “ <a href="https://www.spiritualabuseresources.com/articles/born-or-raised-in-closed-high-demand-groups-developmental-considerations">Born or Raised in Closed, High Demand Groups: Developmental Considerations</a>,” Leona Furnari, LSW, references Arnold Markowitz, C.S.W. and David A. Halperin, M.D.’s 1984 paper “ <a href="https://www.icsahome.com/articles/cults-and-children-the-abuse-csj-1-2">Cults and Children The Abuse of the Young</a> “ which appeared in the Cultic Studies Journal, when she writes:</p><blockquote><em>A child’s parent, who is in a dependent, regressive state due to being under the influence of the group’s leader(s), “is prone toward abusive practices” (Markowitz, A., &amp; Halperin, D.) and power over children is often the only power this parent may have. Most adults in CHDGs live in a state of unpredictability, in that one never knows when the “axe will fall” and the member will be disciplined (shunned, put in the “hot seat”, lose privileges, etc.).</em></blockquote><p>She goes on to say that children who grow up in such environments are at-risk for many significant issues, including but not limited to:</p><ul><li>lack of an appropriate, consistent caretaker;</li><li>lack of healthy attachment to appropriate caretaker;</li><li>lack of adequate medical care;</li><li>physical abuse;</li><li>physical neglect;</li><li>sexual abuse;</li><li>educational neglect;</li><li>lack of intellectual stimuli;</li><li>unrealistic expectations that children participate in adult activities, such as meditation, fasting, sexual activity; and</li><li>suppression of developmental tasks.</li></ul><p>Fenori highlights that parents of children in closed, high demand groups are often thought-reformed to believe that normal human feelings for their children, such as love, concern, and attachment, are not “spiritual” or that these feelings dilute the group’s higher or special purpose. She says that children, who are naturally striving to accomplish normal developmental tasks such as identity, safety and independence, are labeled “possessed,” crazy, or bad. The parents’ confusion, the negative labels, and the overt and covert negative messages children receive about their worth and safety are all factors that contribute to traumatic experiences for them.</p><h3>Development and Trauma</h3><p>In his book <a href="https://www.brightsidebookshop.com/book/9780826156419">Therapy for adults molested as children: Beyond survival </a>, Dr. John Briere states that there are three primary self-capacities that develop in normal early childhood. These are:</p><ol><li>Identity-which provides a consistent sense of personal existence and enables the individual to respond from an internal sense of security. Unstable identity may cause an individual to become easily overwhelmed.</li><li>Boundary-awareness of separation between self and others. Those with poor boundaries tend to allow others to intrude upon them, or they intrude upon others. This can lead to a lack of awareness of personal rights to safety and/or difficulty with interpersonal relations.</li><li>Affect regulation-which includes: (a) affect modulation (self-soothing techniques to reduce or change painful emotion) and (b) affect tolerance (ability to experience negative affect without resorting to external destructive or self-destructive behaviors or “acting out”).</li></ol><p>Fenori uses Briere’s outlines to contrast with Paul Martin’s stages of recovery following cultic experiences discussed in the chapter Post-cult recovery: Assessment and rehabilitation of <a href="https://www.abebooks.com/9780393313215/Recovery-Cults-Help-Victims-Psychological-0393313212/plp">Recovery from cults: Help for victims of psychological and spiritual abuse </a>. She posits that Martin’s stages are similar, but with a unique twist for those born or raised in closed, high demand groups because there is no pre-cult identity to go back to:</p><ul><li>Evaluation of the experiences — often in tandem with finding a support network, including any former members and/or extended family who have been on the outside; education on cults/mind control; therapy; reading; journaling</li><li>Reconciliation/Adaptation, Conciliation — moving slowly, taking small steps; explore redefining of terms; set small goals, tend to personal health; discover personal strengths</li><li>Integration — occurs over time</li></ul><p>I believe that art, when used to explore our experiences with religious trauma, is incredibly important for all stages. However, for me personally, it is the most integral in the first stage. As I mentioned in part one of this post, when I first left the group I had been raised in, I had no language to process my experience.</p><p>I’ve heard similar stories from others who grew up in the Unification Church. Renee, another artist who grew up in the Unification Church, discussed her art with Ares of the <a href="https://anchor.fm/ares-meyer">Ares Meyer Podcast </a>:</p><blockquote><em>“I filled up my sketchbooks with my turmoil. I couldn’t [speak] my feelings because they were so outrageous, no one in the church could accept them. I couldn’t use words. I would show anyone my sketchbook. I would pass my books around so people knew how I felt. It was my only way of communicating, I felt like a mute.”</em></blockquote><p>This is likely consistent with the experiences of others who grew up in traumatic circumstances. According to the <a href="https://www.pasadenavilla.com/2017/11/16/benefits-of-art-therapy/">Pasadena Villa Psychiatric Treatment Network </a>, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3181584/">research using neuroimaging scans </a>suggests that the part of the left side of the brain, associated with speech and language, can shut down when a person tries to remember a traumatic event.</p><p>So not only do many of us lack the formal language to discuss the developmental roots of our trauma, but our brains will literally shut down the areas responsible for language processing when remembering trauma. And the likelihood is that for many who grew up in authoritarian religions and high demand groups, the trauma is not isolated to a single event, but was a pattern of abuse used to regulate both thinking and behaviors.</p><h3>Research on the healing power of art</h3><p>Most of us understand that art helps us express experiences that are too difficult to put to words. But now we know <em>why</em> we struggle with language processing around trauma. In fact, according to the <a href="https://www.pasadenavilla.com/2017/11/16/benefits-of-art-therapy/">Pasadena Villa Psychiatric Treatment Network </a>, traumatic memories activate the part of the right side of the brain which controls autonomic and emotional arousal. Therefore, art practices, and more formal art therapies bypass the left side of the brain. Instead, the art practice stimulates the traumatic memory on the right side. As you create your art, the speech area of the brain reactivates and reintegration of the right and left sides of the brain can occur.</p><p>In a 2007 issue of <em>The Arts in Psychotherapy</em> Frances Reynolds and Kee Hean Lim published “Contribution of visual art-making to the subjective well-being of women living with cancer: A qualitative study.” They found that engaging in different types of visual art (textiles, card making, collage, pottery, watercolor, acrylics) helped these women in 4 major ways:</p><ul><li>First, it helped them focus on positive life experiences, relieving their ongoing preoccupation with cancer.</li><li>Second, it enhanced their self-worth and identity by providing them with opportunities to demonstrate continuity, challenge, and achievement.</li><li>Third, it enabled them to maintain a social identity that resisted being defined by cancer.</li><li>Finally, it allowed them to express their feelings in a symbolic manner, especially during chemotherapy.</li></ul><p>I believe that the effects of engaging in the arts can be similarly beneficial for people healing from cultic abuse. For many of us who have escaped closed, high demand groups, the lasting effects of religious trauma can manifest in a preoccupation with the abuse inflicted upon us in the group, much as the women in the above study may have struggled with a preoccupation with their diagnosis. This preoccupation can often leave many of us feeling “stuck.”</p><p>Therefore, engaging in an art practice can either help us with the rehabilitation process discussed by Martin, or it can give us a much needed relief from the overwhelm that we feel in post-cult life. Similarly, I believe that engaging in an art practice can also help us with our self worth, help redefine our identities outside of the confines of the cult-identity and gives us an outlet to express our feelings in the healing process.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/830/1*LBR85xQzl02DePdgmAO_WQ.png" /><figcaption>The Therapeutic Value Of Art by <a href="https://the-art-of-autism.com/the-therapeutic-value-of-art/">The Art of Autism</a></figcaption></figure><p>The organization <a href="https://www.rtor.org/2018/07/10/benefits-of-art-therapy/">Resources to Recover</a>, states that one does not necessarily need to see a licensed art therapist in order to receive the therapeutic benefits of an art practice. In fact, they recommend activities such as art journaling, sketching, making collages, sculpting with clay, etc. However, they do state that working with a licensed therapist also has its advantages because a professional can tailor each activity to your needs.</p><h3>A cult survivor explains the benefits of art therapy</h3><p>Mental health professionals and experts agree that art therapy has many benefits, from boosting your <a href="https://www.rtor.org/2018/04/24/love-yourself/">self-esteem</a>, and providing you a safe outlet to relieve your emotions, to giving you a sense of control over your life and helping you to get to know and understand yourself better. Studies have also shown that <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4041074/">creating art stimulates the release of dopamine</a>.</p><p><a href="https://norimuster.com/writing/handbook.html">In Cult Survivors Handbook: Seven Paths to an Authentic Life, Nori Muster,</a> researcher, artist and author of the memoir <a href="https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00I14ZP16/ref=dbs_a_def_rwt_hsch_vapi_tkin_p1_i0">Betrayal of the Spirit: My Life behind the Headlines of the Hare Krishna Movement</a> says, “art therapy gives the client a holistic medium of communication. Instead of struggling to put feelings into a linear format of one word after another, clients can spill out all their feelings simultaneously without worrying about grammar, syntax, or logic.”</p><p>She states that art has no time element and works much more closely to how the mind itself works. By engaging in a therapeutic art practice, one is left with a tangible product that not only becomes a visible record of the therapy, but it can also create a bridge to get in touch with one’s inner self. This, she says, is a process called “objectification.” It takes one’s feelings and externalizes them into a drawing, collage, etc., and helps one to recognize and integrate their feelings more easily.</p><h3>ART THERAPY ACTIVITIES</h3><p>Muster suggests the following activities to get started with a therapeutic art practice on your own:</p><ul><li><strong>Make a life map</strong>. Using pencils, pens, pastels, or paint, draw a timeline and mark the major events and turning points in your life leading up to where you are now. You may make it look like a road, a clock, or just a straight line. Another way to do it is with collage. Cut out pictures that symbolize the important events and add them to the timeline. Another variation with collage is to make a map of your life that also uses headlines and words.</li><li><strong>Make another timeline</strong>, limited to one aspect of your life, such as your history with your family, with sex, with religion, or another major issue. Do another life map, but instead of a line, make it a house, a landscape, or abstract design. Do another life map, but only of what your future will be like. Do a life map that freezes one moment in time. Draw a cartoon to represent your life and draw bubbles to write in what the characters in the drawing might say.</li><li><strong>More visual art projects:</strong> draw a picture to show your good side and shadow side, or your past, present, and future. Make a pamphlet about yourself, including all the details you want other people to know about you. Make a mask to show your inner self, or some aspect of yourself that you want to integrate. Put it on and let it talk. Draw a picture to represent a problem you are working on. Draw a picture to reflect your present mood. Date it and start a journal of “present mood” drawings.</li></ul><h3>Rediscovering the self through art</h3><p><a href="https://www.sararoizen.com/">Artist and art therapist Sara Roizen</a> has her clients create 3 different self-portraits on 3 separate pieces of paper.</p><ul><li>how you see yourself</li><li>how you think others see you</li><li>how you would like to be seen</li></ul><p>When I first exited the cult that I was raised in, I would have struggled to even complete the first task. I felt invisible, even to myself, growing up. I think that many of us, especially those who experienced formative years in high demand religions, feel the same.</p><p>As we now know, according to Dr. John Briere, identity is one of the three primary self-capacities that develop in normal early childhood, and trauma can lead to unstable identity. But, even if these activities are a struggle, I want to posit that engaging in them can be a transformative experience that can help us reclaim our stories and rewrite our narratives.</p><p>Does your healing art have to be a self portrait?</p><p>No.</p><p>However, what if we looked at all art as a self portrait?</p><p>American Artist <a href="https://www.azquotes.com/author/56888-Richard_Schmid">Richard Schmid</a> says, “In a sense, every work you do is a self-portrait because your paintings always reveal more about you than about your subject. Your experience of something, not the something itself, is the true underlying subject of every work you do.”</p><p>If working in self portraiture feels too painful in the beginning, I recommend working with something called a surrogate. In her class <a href="https://www.catherinejust.com/offerings#/selfportraitureselfpaced/"><em>Self Portraiture as Medicine</em>,</a><a href="https://www.catherinejust.com/"> artist Catherine Just</a> encourages her students to try a surrogate as a self portrait. She says that this can be something else that stands in for yourself. She encourages her students to find an object that feels representative or holds meaning for them. She often uses a white slip as a surrogate in self portraits.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*2G8ePq_xS93ic-XJiUJNzw.jpeg" /><figcaption>White slip by Catherine Just</figcaption></figure><p>Just says, “The white slip has been used in my work for years and when it’s alone in an image it’s standing in for me. This particular slip is seeped in secrets and so am I.”</p><p>In <a href="https://www.npg.org.uk/business/publications/self-portrait-renaissance-to-contemporary.php"><em>Self Portrait. Renaissance to Contemporary</em></a><em>, </em>Anthony Bond states that, through his gaze, symbol of his creative power, the self-portraitist acquires a triple role: he is, at once, the author, subject and spectator of himself. Each of these three roles makes a statement; the subject says “Yes I am — and I am ok as I am”; the author says, “I am creating, I am the creator”, and the spectator is saying “I am looking at myself, I can see myself.”</p><p>I believe that there is immense healing power in all three statements for those who are healing from the religious trauma inflicted by cults and authoritarian faith groups. Whether we were born in, or joined, the groups strip us of our identity and ability to see ourselves. By engaging in an art practice, we are creating self portraits of our essence.</p><p>Each act of creation is both a rebellion against our authoritarian pasts and a reclamation of our identities going forward. With each creation we can then rewrite both our narratives and our futures, and that is one of the most healing activities we can engage in.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VxK4jYLYI73FYOzWi9siQQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>If you’re interested in joining me at the <a href="https://pheedloop.com/CORT/site/home/">Conference on Religious Trauma</a> , you can sign up at <a href="https://pheedloop.com/CORT/site/">https://pheedloop.com/CORT/site/</a>. Use the code <strong>MAIL15</strong> for a $15 discount!</p><blockquote>If you have been in ANY high control group or religion, share your story with the hashtag #igotout. Share on your own platform OR if you need to be anonymous and / or would like support, there are resources at the I Got Out website.</blockquote><blockquote>When you see a survivor share their story, let them know they have been heard. This is such a meaningful part of the movement. We all need to know we’re not alone.</blockquote><blockquote>If you know someone who has been harmed by a high demand group, share #igotout posts you think would help them.</blockquote><blockquote>Together we can bring awareness to how many of us have been harmed by high control organizations and end the shame or stigma we might feel about our experiences.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Tell your story.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Impact lives.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Change the world.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Find out more at <a href="http://igotout.org/">igotout.org</a></blockquote><p><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Get Blog Posts In Your Inbox!</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/healing-through-art-research"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on April 14, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3619d7d52e81" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Healing Through Art — Part One: My Story]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/healing-through-art-part-one-my-story-ddda4176cc62?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ddda4176cc62</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[personal-essay]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healing-from-trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[healing-through-art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[trauma]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 03 Apr 2021 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-05-04T12:57:59.540Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Healing Through Art — Part One: My Story</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*BtaJC2GjgfeBXo6_" /></figure><p>Today I’m working on my presentation on <a href="https://pheedloop.com/CORT/site/schedule/">Healing Through Art for the virtual Conference on Religious Trauma</a> next month, and I wanted to start by sharing my experience of using art as a tool for reclaiming my story and rewriting my narrative.</p><p>If you felt yourself tense up at the idea of creating art, I want to reassure you: many people I’ve met over the years have told me that they’re not creative. Despite their assertion, I believe we are all born creative, or at the very least, with the capacity to be creative. If we’re lucky, we grow up in an environment where the adults around us encourage and foster that creativity.</p><p>In their paper <a href="https://www.icsahome.com/articles/creativity-and-cults-boeri"><strong><em>Creativity and Cults from Sociological and Communication Perspectives: The Processes Involved in the Birth of a Secret Creative Self</em></strong></a><strong><em> </em></strong>Miriam Williams Boeri, Ph.D. and Karen Pressley state that “Creativity […] is partially dependent on recognition of and acceptance by those who assign value to one’s creativity.”</p><p>However, for many people who have experienced high demand religions, groups, or abusive family dynamics, their creativity was diminished, or outright discouraged. This is because creativity is not only inherently an expression of our inner selves, but it is associated with the generation of new, perhaps divergent, ideas. Therefore, if our inner self and creativity are not in alignment with glorifying the abusers who seek to control those in their congregations, groups or families, then it is seen as a threat.</p><h3>How is creativity a threat?</h3><p><a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282332743_Intuition_and_creativity">In his 2015 paper <strong><em>Intuition and Creativity</em>,</strong> Shoaib Ul-Habiq says,</a></p><blockquote><em>Creativity, as an individual level construct, is defined as the production of novel, useful ideas, new products, services, processes or solutions. It refers to both the process of idea generation or problem solving and the actual idea or solution (Amabile, 1983; Shalley, 1995). Johnson (1972) suggested that creative activity may exhibit several dimensions including sensitivity to problems on the part of the creative agent, originality, ingenuity, usefulness, and appropriateness in relation to the creative product, and intellectual leadership on the part of the creative agent.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Others view creativity as a largely unstructured process which is grounded in the intellectual capacity to generate divergent thinking, remote associations, rich imagery and primary process (Guilford, 1967; Mednick, 1962; Rothenberg, 1987; Suler, 1980).</em></blockquote><p>The two points that are most important to highlight in the above are <strong><em>novel, useful ideas</em></strong> and <strong><em>divergent thinking</em></strong>.</p><p>According to a basic dictionary definition, creativity means “the ability to transcend traditional ideas, rules, patterns, relationships, or the like, and to create meaningful new ideas, forms, methods, interpretations, etc.; originality, progressiveness, or imagination” (Dictionary.com)</p><p>In her book <a href="http://www.amazon.com/Bounded-Choice-Believers-Charismatic-Cults/dp/0520240189">Bounded Choice: True Believers and Charismatic Cults</a>, Dr. Janja Lalich states that the cult leaders define what and who is creative. However, you can substitute whatever abusive power dynamic for the following, and it could still be true to many people’s experiences:</p><blockquote><em>The expression of any thought-be it through song, painting, story, or other craft-is generally discouraged, unless that expression enhances thoughts the leaders (the power elite) have already expressed. Original personal thoughts contrary to the cult’s meaning system are forbidden, and the expression of such private thoughts cannot become public. For example, musicians and songwriters are encouraged to compose music for their leaders’ lyrics; writers are required to craft stories that express the world views of those in power. This power dynamic in the cultic milieu supports the cult’s hegemony, and inhibits any questioning of the leader’s naming of creativity.</em></blockquote><p><a href="https://www.icsahome.com/articles/creativity-and-cults-boeri">According to Boeri and Pressley</a>, “If others-usually the leader-do not identify a cult member as creative, the member cannot continue to have a creative self without birthing a secret creative self.”</p><p>Growing up in a cult, my expression of self was a threat to my parents, my faith community and the closed society I was raised in. Now members of the Unification Church might counter and say that creativity is actually very much encouraged. After all, in the 1970’s there were music groups like Sunburst and today they have the band Sonic Cult. The Church also owns the Manhattan Center, where a number of creative projects were attempted over the years. In Korea they founded both the Sunhwa Arts School (originally founded as the Little Angels School) and the Universal Ballet.</p><p>On a more local level we had arts festivals for the Second Generation where we shared our music, visual arts and films. Back in 2005 I even helped create a workshop for young actors. But, again, creativity was only encouraged only if it glorified Rev. Moon, his version of God, and his vision of the “ideal world”. In fact, our mission, when engaging in the arts, was to take them over from the “Fallen World.” If our creativity didn’t have that at its center, it was considered of Satan.</p><p><a href="https://www.icsahome.com/articles/the-last-draw-cults-and-creativity">In 2010, a survey respondent for the Cultic Studies Review described their experience thusly</a>: “Creativity wasn’t suppressed… it was co-opted, harnessed, used, channeled… from an emotional level, I want to use the word ‘raped’….”</p><p>I kept my creative side mostly hidden, and therefore did not experience much of what the respondent did in terms of the abuse of their creativity. However, I do think that their words are important to keep in mind when thinking of the kinds of creative expression allowed in cultic environments.</p><h3>The birth of my secret creative self</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/990/1*QX2xoAVbR1PLxlfJhmdrwA.jpeg" /></figure><p><a href="https://www.icsahome.com/articles/creativity-and-cults-boeri">According to Boeri and Pressley</a> “a cult member might express a [creative] thought or show the symbolic expression of a thought (e.g. a song, story, drawing) only to a trusted cult member or to an outsider who shows appreciation. In these cases, a creative self may have to be nurtured in secret by some cult members who do not want to expose their tangible expressions of creativity to the judgment of cult leaders. This process leads to the birth of a secret creative self.”</p><p>The creation and suppression of my creative self was an incremental process that occurred over many years. My cult identity was supposed to be kept hidden from the outside world, but the true “inner self” was something that I also learned to keep secret.</p><p>Growing up, my mother tried to impress the importance of my identity on me. She said that I was different, that I had a mission, and that I had to be very careful about who knew who I was — otherwise Satan would attack me. It was like being born with a secret identity, where I was constantly under threat by the “outside” and “Satanic” world, which would seek to corrupt me. Therefore my younger siblings, myself, and all of the other Second Generation, whom we called Blessed Children, were brought up believing that we needed to be separate from the evil, outside world.</p><p>In order to achieve this, many members lived together either in communal living spaces or near one another in closely knit communities. Some communities even started their own schools so that their children didn’t have to attend public schools and fraternize with satanic children. My siblings and I didn’t grow up in one of those communities. For many of our formative years, we were two hours away from the closest Church family. This meant that we grew up in a strange liminal space where we had to live within the world but were not allowed to “be of it.”</p><p>This meant I felt a strong sense of otherness, both in and out of the cult, and struggled to form connections with others. I moved through the world in fear of others, initially only allowing myself to be vulnerable and create friendships in the rare sanctioned spaces that my faith and family allowed. I strove to involve myself in every Church activity that I could, because only when I was with other Blessed Children was I supposedly allowed to “be myself.”</p><p>Except that I wasn’t. As I grew older, the more I questioned and began to see cracks in the facade of faith. But, in the Church, to question what we were taught was to invite Satan and the evil Spirit World into your mind; to fend off evil, one must quiet the questions and dive further into the readings and teachings of Rev. Moon, whom we were taught to call <em>True Father. </em>As a reflex, I was ashamed and hated myself for questioning and thought that I must certainly be evil.</p><p>I knew that my art was evil; I had known that from a young age. Anything that the Church saw in me that was not within the realm of acceptability was shamed out of me. As a result, I was less comfortable showing anyone who I <em>really</em> was, Church or no. There were only a few safe people with whom I could share my struggles, and the art that came out of it. It was in those few safe spaces that the “secret creative self” flourished.</p><p>At the time I didn’t have words to describe what I felt. I hadn’t learned the language of trauma or healing; all I knew was the narrowly prescribed language of the Church. And yet, as you can see, some of the images from my high school sketchbook clearly describe everything that I was thinking and feeling about my world:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/500/1*EhkewgL-MI66_fBluoHKFQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>an image from my high school sketchbook</figcaption></figure><h3>Leaving the Church</h3><p>At 19 I found myself on a terrifying personal precipice. I didn’t know if I believed in the Unification Church’s version of “truth”, but with no safety net outside of the Church community, and with a deep fear of the outside world, I didn’t know where to turn.</p><p>Additionally, growing up, the Church had taught me that Rev. Moon would choose my spouse. In the Unification Church, one didn’t date. Everything was separated by gender, and we referred to one another as <em>brother </em>and <em>sister </em>in order to emphasize platonic relations. The Church had a word for sex before marriage: <em>falling. </em>To <em>fall</em> was the greatest sin that could be committed.</p><p>And at 19 I was pressing against my eligibility expiration date. Friends asked me when I was going to join the “ring club,” and others would caution and say, if “you don’t hurry all the good ones will be gone.” That I was still on the market meant that I, apparently, was not <em>one of the good ones.</em></p><p>Then news came: The aging Rev. Moon, who had directed all of the marriages within the faith from before my birth until I was 15, announced shortly before Christmas that after four years of having the parents Match the Blessed Children, he was stepping back in. This, perhaps, for the last time.</p><p>My parents were breathless with agitation. They had tried, without success, to find me a Match and were wondering if things might be hopeless. My mother sat me down and said, “If Jesus came to you and said he had found your perfect match, would you turn him down? Now how much more is <em>True</em> <em>Father?”</em></p><p>How could I say no? I simply hadn’t come to that point in my journey yet.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/426/1*DNGKE_FdPHa2yJ5iTYtIMA.jpeg" /></figure><p>A few days later I found myself married, or Blessed in Church language, to a complete stranger from another country.</p><p>That choice ended up being the final straw in breaking my faith, and the next two years found me struggling to extricate myself from my marriage. As I struggled, the Church community didn’t rally to support me or save my marriage. Rather, the community turned its back on me. After all, I had “broken the Blessing,” an unforgivable sin.</p><p>The Church taught us that to leave the faith was to open ourselves to death. Growing up they had regaled me with stories of lightning strikes and traffic accidents where the unfaithful had met their doom. So there I was, alone, rejected from the tribe that I had dared to question, and afraid of a very real death.</p><p>In the dangerous wilds of the outside world I faced the difficult task of integrating into a world that I had been taught to shun, and to accept the fact that I was no longer a Blessed Child with a secret identity.Who was I really? And how did I connect with the world?</p><h3>Shedding an Identity and a Language</h3><p>After being rejected by the community of my birth, I had a genuine fear of rejection from the outside world as well. I was so afraid of being judged for what had happened to me, that for a long time I tried to pretend that I was normal and didn’t tell anyone who I really was. “No one would understand,” I told myself. “They would think I was weak, stupid, or both.”</p><p>Over the years, as I distanced myself from the Church, I shed both the language and the identity that had been foisted upon me. But it still took much learning and healing before I had the capacity to express and understand my experience in verbal language. In the interim I turned, again, to art.</p><p>Although I tried journaling, painting and poetry, the thing that felt the most radical was picking up a camera and turning the lens on myself. After all, growing up as I did, seeing myself <strong>for myself</strong> had been forbidden. In that environment, who I was, how I felt, what I thought, and who I married was to be interpreted by the cult.</p><p>In the beginning, I felt immense amounts of guilt when I photographed myself. The images always came out looking dark, sad, depressed. “Who was I to be sad?” the voice in my head would say. “After all, I had escaped, gotten a cute apartment, a job that paid my rent. I had even found a nice boyfriend. What did I have to be sad about?”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/640/1*JzV3ic7QQfyuMTPZU7y7hg.jpeg" /><figcaption>An early self portrait</figcaption></figure><p>At the same time, the voice in my head accused me of being vain for photographing myself, of trying to attract the wrong kind of attention. Sometimes it threatened me with the fear of retribution from the cult. I didn’t realize that this was the voice of the religion in my head, still trying to keep me from experiencing myself.</p><p>Despite that old voice, I kept taking pictures. And for a long time I hardly recognized myself in the images. But perhaps it was my way of trying to document my own existence for the first time.</p><p>Even still, for many years I felt as though I was circling around my truth. I didn’t know how to say, “This is what happened to me.” Not verbally, and not in my art. In fact, I didn’t even have the capacity to acknowledge that I had been raised in a cult. That word was something that the Church had taught me to believe was a false accusation levied against the Church by the Satanic “outside world.” I also didn’t know that what I had experienced growing up was considered abuse.</p><p>Then in 2012, Rev. Moon died. Even after five years of being out of the group, his death caused something inside of me to crack open. With his death, I realized that I’d had another unacknowledged fear: that, somehow, Rev. Moon could still hurt me even after my escape.</p><p>But now the man who had controlled so much of mine and my family’s lives could no longer hurt me. For the first time since I’d left, I realized that I was beginning to feel safe. And I needed to tell my story.</p><p>Initially I tried writing, but still didn’t know how to explain what I had experienced. I tried penning essays that detailed my experiences and the reasons why I left the Church. But I still didn’t have the language to describe the trauma, or the education to even truly understand what had happened to me. I didn’t understand what coercive control or thought reform looked like, and had simply normalized them into my upbringing.</p><p>Again, it was only with art that I felt like I could express my experience.</p><p>At first, fear nearly overwhelmed me. “How dare I?” I thought.</p><p>Then I realized that the voice was my old conditioning; I was still silencing myself long after the Church was there to do it for me. But I wondered: if by remaining silent, was I also being complicit? And so I decided to speak in the only way that I then knew how. Thus my Burdens of a White Dress project was born.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*940e45USiTF-YC5ML3iNJg.png" /></figure><p>It’s a series that now comprises over 60 images exploring the feminine experience of growing up in a high-demand group, as well as the intersections of purity culture, coercive control, and the sexual, mental and emotional traumas that occur as a result. Most of the images are self-portraits, and they use red, black and white as both a color scheme and the primary symbolism with which I explore these issues.</p><p>For years, I struggled against shame and the internalized cult voice to make each image. Today I can look back at both this project, and the images that came before it, and see that I wasn’t just ashamed of taking photos of myself. I was ashamed of my entire story. But creating it was an important step in my healing.</p><h3>The beginning of healing</h3><p>By using art, I was able to name the wound that I had no language for. Eventually I delved into the education that would give me the framework and language to understand my experience on an intellectual level. But I believe that many of us understand our experiences on a sensory level that supersedes language.</p><p>Creating the work gave me the tools I needed to begin writing more in depth about my story, and to start speaking about it on social media and at conferences. I’ve also returned to poetry, creating black out poetry with Church literature as a reclamation effort.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*G_NmNTpPUZJ7YblkCUWQaw.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*wojQMTP6dLx9zJ3yR7OpxA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Blackout poetry made from Rev. Moon’s “memoir”</figcaption></figure><p>I wouldn’t have been able to do any of this without having first allowed myself to explore my feelings and experiences through a more visual art medium first.</p><p>But perhaps was the most healing was the connection that I was able to create through sharing my work. The first time, I was so afraid I nearly blacked out in a panic. I was at an artist’s workshop and slid my prints across a table to the woman who was sitting across from me. She looked at the images very quietly for a moment and then up at me with incredible sadness.</p><p>“These photos remind me of me.” Then she told me her story, and a new kind of connection was forged.</p><p>Almost without fail, when I share my work and my story, others share their stories in return. A dialogue opens up. I begin to hear that in seeing my work, others find the strength to break through their fears, own their voice or access the words with which they needed to share their stories.</p><p>Every single one of us here has suffered something that has become a defining part of our stories. And every one of us has also probably been afraid to be vulnerable and share those parts of us. But when we find safe spaces to create the art that expresses our stories and our truths, we can find healing and give others permission to explore their own healing as well.</p><p>In my next post I will talk more about the role that creativity has in healing, as well as the research behind it.</p><p>If you’re interested in joining me at the <a href="https://pheedloop.com/CORT/site/home/">Conference on Religious Trauma</a> , you can sign up at <a href="https://pheedloop.com/CORT/site/">https://pheedloop.com/CORT/site/</a>. Use the code <strong>MAIL15</strong> for a $15 discount!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*VxK4jYLYI73FYOzWi9siQQ.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3z7SLITbTAmKBkOMlgHEeg.png" /></figure><blockquote>If you have been in ANY high control group or religion, share your story with the hashtag #igotout. Share on your own platform OR if you need to be anonymous and /or would like support, there are resources at the I Got Out website.</blockquote><blockquote>When you see a survivor share their story, let them know they have been heard. This is such a meaningful part of the movement. We all need to know we’re not alone.</blockquote><blockquote>If you know someone who has been harmed by a high demand group, share #igotout posts you think would help them.</blockquote><blockquote>Together we can bring awareness to how many of us have been harmed by high control organizations and end the shame or stigma we might feel about our experiences.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Tell your story.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Impact lives.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Change the world.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Find out more at <a href="http://igotout.org/">igotout.org</a></blockquote><p><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Get Blog Posts In Your Inbox!</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/healing-through-art-my-story"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on April 3, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ddda4176cc62" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Illusion of Choice]]></title>
            <link>https://jenkiaba.medium.com/the-illusion-of-choice-20b83d7ca1c7?source=rss-c26d34bd0520------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/20b83d7ca1c7</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[brainwashing]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cult]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[coercive-control]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[domestic-abuse]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[abuse-survivors]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jen Kiaba]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 27 Mar 2021 00:00:00 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-19T14:52:34.713Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/940/0*7npAb1V0Kzj25NbF" /></figure><p>“This has always been your choice, Jenny,” my mother would say. It was a refrain I heard from her many times over the years before I left the Unification Church.</p><p>She would usually wield it when she saw me backing away from a fork in the road that she, and the Church, wanted me to take. Whether I was trying to get out of going on a Church mission that boiled down to living in a van and being labor trafficked as a minor, trying to leave a Church job that paid me $100 a month and had me sleeping in a communal room on a floor, fighting to get out of an arranged engagement with a stranger, or trying to get out of an arranged marriage with a different stranger, the sentiment was always the same: <em>you chose this.</em></p><p>And for many years, I believed that.</p><p>Because the Church community laid the responsibility for a choice at my feet, I felt like I needed to stick it out and prove that I could succeed. In the Church we had language like, “overcoming Fallen Nature,” which was lightly veiled to mean that when you struggled with something you were engaging with Satan. If I failed, I was letting Satan win. If I <em>chose</em> to go against the prescribed path, I was essentially aligning myself with evil — or I <strong>was</strong> evil.</p><p>But did I really have a choice? Or was the choice simply an illusion?</p><h3>Bounded Choice</h3><p>Dr. Janja Lalich developed a theory called “bounded choice”, which she delves into in her book of the same name <a href="http://cultresearch.org/bounded-choice/">Bounded Choice: True Believers and Charismatic Cults</a>, as a tool for examining and analyzing high-demand environments and cults. <a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/The%20essentials%20of%20the%20theory%20comprise%20four%20dimensions">The essentials of the theory comprise four dimensions</a>:</p><ul><li><strong>Charismatic authority:</strong> This is the emotional bond between leader and followers. It lends legitimacy to the leader and grants authority to his or her actions while at the same time justifying and reinforcing followers’ responses to the leader and/or the leader’s ideas and goals. The relational aspect of charisma is the hook that links a devotee to a leader and/or his or her ideas.</li><li><strong>Transcendent belief system:</strong> This is the overarching ideology that binds adherents to the group and keeps them behaving according to the group’s rules and norms. It is transcendent because it offers a total explanation of past, present, and future, including a path to salvation. Most important, the leader/group also specifies the exact methodology (or recipe) for the personal transformation necessary to qualify one to travel on that path.</li><li><strong>Systems of control:</strong> This is the network of acknowledged, or visible, regulatory mechanisms that guide the operation of the group. It includes the overt rules, regulations, and procedures that guide and control members’ behavior.</li><li><strong>Systems of influence: </strong>This is the network of interactions and social influence residing in the group’s social relations. This is the human interaction and group culture from which members learn to adapt their thoughts, attitudes, and behaviors in relation to their new beliefs.</li></ul><p>According to Lalich’s theory, these dimensions form a “self-sealing system,” that is, a social system or society that is closed in on itself and, therefore, sealed off from the outside world.</p><p>In the Unification Church, we used the phases “outside world” and “Fallen world” interchangeably, but the language reflects that the community was a relatively sealed system. As a child, I still had dealings with the outside world, because I attended public schools. However, even then I was to maintain a distance from outside people, and the Church community strenuously discouraged me from forming any meaningful relationships with them. After all, even casual friendship could be a threat to the sealed system.</p><p>This is one example of what Lalich means when she states that, “Living within the bounded reality of the cultic social system, the cult member encounters no meaningful reality checks and becomes more and more enmeshed with and invested in the closed world of the group.”</p><p>The Church indoctrinated us to “cut it off,” meaning to end any relationship that threatened the structure of the group. Whether we were developing friendships with outside kids, or crushes on someone, the directive was the same. We were even cautioned against close friendships within the Church, which leadership labelled as “horizontal relationships.” Leaders, instead, encouraged us to focus on “vertical relationships,” meaning either invest in our emotional relationship with God and the cult leader, Rev. Sung Myung Moon (whom we called True Father), or create deferential relationships with people who were above us in the church hierarchy. My mother even resorted to moving my family across the city of Phoenix, and into a new school district, when I was 14 because she saw I was forming meaningful relationships with people in my high school and determined that they were a threat.</p><h3>The Need to Conform</h3><p>Within a system like this, according to Lalich, “the member’s life and choices are constrained not only by the system but also, and perhaps even more powerfully, by the close-mindedness of the individual him- or herself who is functioning in alliance with that system. [L]ife outside the cult has become impossible to imagine.”</p><p>Not only is life outside of the group near impossible to imagine, but within these groups many of us are taught that leaving the group is tantamount to spiritual death. As a child, my parents and the Church also taught me that physical death awaited if I left.</p><p>When our ancestors were trying to survive in the wild, it was impossible to survive outside of the tribal unit. <a href="https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/conformity">According to Psychology Today, the need to belong is deeply wired into human biology.</a> Today, it manifests in our desire for acceptance, and to fit in. Because a cult taps into that hard-wired universal human need, we can understand how strong self-sealing systems can be.</p><p>Overlaying the bounded choice framework onto the biological need to survive within the human group, we can see that there is only the illusion of choice for people within cultic systems. At every crossroads, where my intuition was screaming for me to not take a prescribed path, my conditioning told me that total abandonment and death awaited down the other path. Even if I was told that I had a choice, did I really?</p><h3>Death or Freedom?</h3><p>In the end, I decided to leap to my spiritual “death” in order to escape. It took me years to understand that my freedom was a choice grounded in bravery and resilience. In fact, for the longest time, I carried a heavy weight of shame with me. After all, I had “failed” to walk the prescribed path and chosen Satan.</p><p>Once I had spent enough time away from the group and educated myself, I threw off the shackles of perceived “failure.” But I still carried the shame.</p><p>Why?</p><p>Because bounded choice is still something that many people don’t understand. Even after studying it, and digesting it on an academic level, I didn’t fully understand how it related to me and my story.</p><p>“After all,” people would say, “no one held a gun to your head. So in a sense you <em>did</em> choose to marry that stranger.”</p><p>It took me a long time, and aligning myself with non profits like <a href="http://www.unchainedatlast.org/">Unchained at Last</a> and the <a href="https://resiliencyfoundation.com/">Resiliency Foundation</a>, which work to end child and forced marriage, that I even started to use the word “forced” to describe my own arranged marriage.</p><p>Two weeks I had the opportunity to watch a screening of <a href="https://www.knotsthefilm.com/">Knots: A Forced Marriage Story</a>, during a virtual parallel event to the <a href="https://www.unwomen.org/en/csw">United Nations Commission on the Status of Women</a>, hosted by <a href="https://ngocsw.org/">NGO CSW/NY</a>. The story follows three women, the coercion they faced that lead their being forced into marriage, and the steps they took in their respective journeys to escape.</p><p>Nina, one subject of the documentary, used the term bounded choice and described it as, “you can either make the choice we want you to make, or you can jump off a cliff and die.” I’m paraphrasing, but her words hit me on a visceral, bone-deep level. They were chillingly familiar.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*M0oasyu3ThpygBhTa2yGng.jpeg" /><figcaption>Nina, one of the subjects of the documentary film Knots: A Forced Marriage Story</figcaption></figure><p>Finally, I understood: bounded choice means no choice at all.</p><p>So many of us carry shame-shaped wounds from our experiences within in a bounded-choice, coercive environment. Those environments can look like toxic relationships, abusive families, high-demand religions, and even workplaces. I believe that shame is a residual control mechanism that was wired into us. And I hope that as we come to understand what bounded choice really means, and that the choices we were given were only illusions, we can rewrite our personal narratives. When we replace shame with a deep appreciation for our bravery and resilience, I’m convinced that a deeper level of healing can occur.</p><blockquote>If you have been in ANY high control group or religion, share your story with the hashtag #igotout. Share on your own platform OR if you need to be anonymous and / or would like support, there are resources at the I Got Out website.</blockquote><blockquote>When you see a survivor share their story, let them know they have been heard. This is such a meaningful part of the movement. We all need to know we’re not alone.</blockquote><blockquote>If you know someone who has been harmed by a high demand group, share #igotout posts you think would help them.</blockquote><blockquote>Together we can bring awareness to how many of us have been harmed by high control organizations and end the shame or stigma we might feel about our experiences.</blockquote><blockquote><em>Tell your story.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Impact lives.</em></blockquote><blockquote><em>Change the world.</em></blockquote><blockquote>Find out more at <a href="http://igotout.org/">igotout.org</a></blockquote><p><a href="https://jenkiaba.ck.page/15533e7435">Get Blog Posts In Your Inbox!</a></p><p><em>Originally published at </em><a href="https://www.jenkiaba.com/lessons-on-leaving/illusion-choice"><em>https://www.jenkiaba.com</em></a><em> on March 27, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=20b83d7ca1c7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>