<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jenny Lynn on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jenny Lynn on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jennylynn?source=rss-1b999abdbfe3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 10:20:18 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jennylynn/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Utopia Defined: : Margaret Cavendish’s “The Blazing World”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jennylynn/utopia-defined-margaret-cavendishs-the-blazing-world-2511f197dd07?source=rss-1b999abdbfe3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2511f197dd07</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[authors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[utopia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny Lynn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 25 Oct 2022 21:04:14 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-10-25T21:04:53.133Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Utopia Defined: Margaret Cavendish’s “The Blazing World”</h3><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/274/1*uX8t32kEZh2TBlUxZ1tLww.jpeg" /></figure><blockquote>“Margaret too might have been a poet; in our day all that activity would have turned a wheel of some sort. As it was, what could bind, tame, or civilize for human use that wild, generous, untutored intelligence? It poured itself out, higgledy-piggledy, in torrents of rhyme and prose, poetry and philosophy which stand congealed in quartos and folios that nobody ever reads. She should have had a microscope put in her hand. She should have been taught to look at the stars and reason scientifically. Her wits were turned with solitude and freedom. No one checked her. No one taught her. The professors fawned on her. At Court they jeered at her.”</blockquote><blockquote>“What a vision of loneliness and riot the thought of Margaret Cavendish brings to mind! as if some giant cucumber had spread itself over all the roses and carnations in the garden and choked them to death. What a waste that the woman who wrote ‘the best bred women are those whose minds are civilest’ should have frittered her time away scribbling nonsense and plunging ever deeper into obscurity and folly till the people crowded round her coach when she issued out.”</blockquote><p>These quotes, both taken from Virginia Woolf’s <em>A Room of One’s Own, </em>may be the best summation of Margaret Cavendish and her works.</p><p>For <em>The Blazing World </em>is a bizarre book. Coming after Plato’s <em>Republic </em>with its brutal, cold logic, it feels like a whiplash, a fever dream of a story. Written in 1666, it has been called by Dale Spender and other feminist critics “the first science-fiction novel.”</p><p><strong>Background</strong></p><p>The year is 1666.</p><p>The major event of this year is the Great London fire, which destroyed much of central London. The city is also recovering from an outbreak of the bubonic plague, an event referred to as the Great Plague of London. Despite all this, the poet, John Dryden, labeled this year “Annus Mirabilis” or “year of miracles” in his 1667 poem of the same name.</p><p>Margaret Cavendish, the Duchess of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, is forty-three years old and married to William Cavendish, 1st Duke of Newcastle upon Tyne, a man thirty years her senior. Despite the age gap, it is, by all accounts, a happy marriage. William’s noble status enabled Margaret to associate with some of the great thinkers of the day, including René Descartes, Thomas Hobbes, Henry More, Walter Charleton, and Joseph Glanvill. With the help of her husband’s wealth, Margaret Cavendish was able to do the 17th century equivalent of self-publishing, publishing volumes upon volumes of poetry and prose, plays and philosophy, and everything in between.</p><p>Cavendish, like the first Woolf quote stated, had little formal instruction, her education being the standard for women of the time, consisting of reading, writing, singing, and dancing. She took advantage of the opportunities afforded to her by her wealth to educate herself, writing about philosophy and science during an era when the few female writers around, wrote primarily about religion and education.</p><p>As a woman willing to converse with men on natural philosophy and possessing a fondness for eccentric dress, Margaret acquired the nickname “Mad Madge.” She was the first woman invited to join the Royal Society, becoming inducted in 1667 as its first female member.</p><p>Margaret Cavendish died in 1673 and was interred in Westminster Abbey.</p><p><strong>The Work</strong></p><p><em>The Blazing World, </em>while it is often classified as utopian lit, the reality is that this book is less a description of a utopian society and more a philosophical tract, though that still makes the book sound more straightforward than it actually is.</p><p>There’s something akin to <em>Alice in Wonderland </em>with this story and its dream logic. Both share a similar, rough outline: the protagonist falls down a hole into a mythical land full of strange creatures. Yet Lewis Carroll did not intend for the world Alice discovers to be considered a utopia.</p><p>While most utopias begin with the discovery, <em>The Blazing World </em>chooses to go a darker route, with the heroine’s journey being one taken against her will.</p><blockquote>A merchant travelling into a foreign country, fell extremely in love with a young Lady; but being a stranger in that nation, and beneath her both in birth and wealth, he could have but little hopes of obtaining his desire; however his love growing more and more vehement upon him, even to the slighting of all difficulties, he resolved at last to steal her away</blockquote><p>This is a curious storytelling choice to make, choosing to have the heroine set forth on her journey against her will.</p><p>Unfortunately for the merchant, the ship drifts into arctic waters, killing all the men aboard. Our heroine is saved by her beauty which keeps her warm. The beast-men take her to their underground world where she meets the Emperor and immediately becomes Empress.</p><p>Despite being billed as Utopian lit, there is very little description of this underground world or the ideas that govern it. In fact, <em>The Blazing World </em>is more a treatise on the philosophy of vitalism.</p><p>Vitalism is a long discredited scientific theory that holds that living organisms contain some kind of force akin to a soul that governs and directs its being. This theory is a long-lived one being attributed to Galen and Aristotle, as well as René Descartes.</p><p>The Empress spends about ninety percent of the book debating and expositing on various aspects of vitalism with her bug-men and beast-men subjects.</p><p>Though the Empress is already an author self-insert, Cavendish inserts herself even more into the story, by having the Duchess of Newcastle show up and befriend the Empress.</p><p>The lectures come to an end when the noble kingdom of ESFI faces an invasion. Naturally, the Empress cannot let this stand and goes to provide aid.</p><blockquote>Great, heroic, and famous monarchs: I came hither to assist the King of ESFI against his enemies, he being unjustly assaulted by many several nations, which would Jain take away his hereditary rights and prerogatives of the narrow seas; at which unjustice Heaven was much displeased; and for the injuries he received from his enemies, rewarded him with an absolute power, so that now he is become the head-monarch of all this world; which power, though you may envy, yet you can no ways hinder him; for all those that endeavour to resist his power, shall only get loss for their labour, and no victory for their profit. Wherefore my advice to you all is, to pay him tribute justly and truly, that you may live peaceably and happily, and be rewarded with the blessings of Heaven, which I wish you from my soul.</blockquote><p>ESFI is believed to be an acronym for England, Spain, France, and Ireland, because Cavendish is fundamentally English, so naturally her vision of a better world involves England dominating and making an amalgam of all its enemies.</p><p>With the aid of the Empress, the King of ESFI vanquishes his enemies.</p><p>The story ends with a post-script that is infinitely more interesting than anything that came before it, where Cavendish explains the reasoning behind her creation and advocates for others to follow her example and create their own worlds.</p><blockquote>By this poetical description, you may perceive, that my ambition is not only to be Empress, but Authoress of a whole world; and that the worlds I have made, both the Blazing and the other Philosophical World, mentioned in the first part of this description, are framed and composed of the most pure, that is, the rational parts of matter, which are the parts of my mind; which creation was more easily and suddenly effected, than the conquests of the two famous monarchs of the world, Alexander and Caesar</blockquote><blockquote>and if any should like the world I have made, and be willing to be my subjects, they may imagine themselves such, and they are such, I mean, in their minds, fancies or imaginations; but if they cannot endure to be subjects, they may create worlds of their own, and govern themselves as they please:</blockquote><p>It is hard to discern what we might learn from <em>The Blazing World. </em>Granted not every story has to be as didactic as an Aesop fable.</p><p>Virginia Woolf’s assessment of Margaret Cavendish seems to be the most adequate summation of her works. Cavendish was in many ways, lucky when compared with most women of her time. She had what Woolf says that every woman writer has to have to pursue a career: money and a room of one’s own. Though Cavendish also had another element which was key for many aspiring woman writers of the past, including Woolf: a supportive husband willing to let his wife follow her passions. Who knows how many great writers we missed out on, due to recalcitrant husbands and being drowned under the burden of kinder, küche, kirche.</p><p>Rather than trying to extract some moral from <em>The Blazing World</em>, we should appreciate it more for what it is: a bizarre fever dream, another oddball entry in a genre that often seems to be made up of oddball entries.</p><p>Next time, we’ll pay a visit to Francis Bacon’s <em>New Atlantis.</em></p><p>Bibliography</p><p>“An Introduction to Margaret Cavendish, or ‘Why You Should Include Margaret Cavendish in Your Early Modern Course and Buy the Book.’” <em>The Mod Squad</em>, 17 Mar. 2014, philosophymodsquad.wordpress.com/2014/03/16/an-introduction-to-margaret-cavendish-or-why-you-should-include-margaret-cavendish-in-your-early-modern-course-and-buy-the-book.</p><p>Cavendish, Margaret, et al. <em>The Blazing World and Other Writings</em>. Zaltbommel, Netherlands, Van Haren Publishing, 1994.</p><p>Johnson, Lily. “Why You Should Know About Margaret Cavendish.” <em>History Hit</em>, <a href="http://www.historyhit.com/why-you-should-know-about-margaret-cavendish.">www.historyhit.com/why-you-should-know-about-margaret-cavendish.</a> Accessed 24 Oct. 2022.</p><p><em>Margaret Lucas Cavendish (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)</em>. 29 May 2017, plato.stanford.edu/entries/margaret-cavendish.</p><p>Shaw, Will. “Cavendish (1623–1673).” <em>Project Vox</em>, projectvox.org/cavendish-1623–1673. Accessed 24 Oct. 2022.</p><p>Utopianfiction.com. 2022. <em>Utopian Literature — Discussion and examples of utopias, dystopias, ecotopias and other speculative fiction</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;https://www.utopianfiction.com/&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>Utopiaanddystopia.com. 2022. <em>Utopian Literature List — Descriptions of Famous Utopian Works</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;http://www.utopiaanddystopia.com/utopian-fiction/utopian-literature-list/&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>Wikipedia contributors. “The Blazing World.” <em>Wikipedia</em>, 17 Aug. 2022, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Blazing_World.</p><p>Wikipedia contributors. “Margaret Cavendish, Duchess of Newcastle-upon-Tyne.” <em>Wikipedia</em>, 21 Oct. 2022, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margaret_Cavendish,_Duchess_of_Newcastle-upon-Tyne.</p><p>Woolf, Virginia. <em>A Room of One’s Own</em>. New Edition, Publishers Group Canada, 2017.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2511f197dd07" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Utopia Defined: Plato’s Republic]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jennylynn/utopia-defined-platos-republic-264becc09511?source=rss-1b999abdbfe3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/264becc09511</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[plato]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[philosophy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[utopia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[analysis]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny Lynn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Aug 2022 21:26:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-08-11T21:26:08.986Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/475/1*JOfBhtcEngUgY6Y0dTxGQw.jpeg" /></figure><p>So far, this has been the hardest material I’ve taken on for this project. Maybe somewhere down the line, I’ll be hit with something harder, but right now, <em>Republic </em>is in the lead. I had to really dive into supplemental materials to understand what the book is about.</p><p>Still let’s see what it has to teach us.</p><p><strong>Background</strong></p><p>Plato’s <em>Republic </em>was written sometime around 375 BC. Plato would have been in his mid fifties at the time.</p><p>Not much is known about Plato’s early years. Our best guess as to what year he was born is “somewhere between the years 429 and 423 BC.” We know that he was born into an aristocratic family. His father traced his lineage back to Codrus, the king of Athens, and Melanthus, the king of Messenia. His mother boasted of a relationship to Solon, the poet and law-giver.</p><p>As a young man, Plato became a student of Socrates, and it is impossible to talk about Plato without discussing Socrates. It’s from Plato we get most of the biographical details of Socrates’s life, and Socrates plays the central role in many of his dialogues.</p><p>Socrates never wrote down his teachings, so all we know about his beliefs, comes from his followers. Socrates spent his days wandering the streets of Athens, teaching philosophy. He attracted great interest from the youth of Athens and that, unfortunately, would lead to his early death, when he was accused of corrupting the youth of Athens and put on trial.</p><p>Socrates’s trial took place in a tense climate, not long after Athens had finally been reclaimed from Sparta following what was effectively a military occupation. The official charges, laid against him by the poet Meletus, were 1) corrupting youth; (2) worshipping false gods; and (3) not worshipping the state religion. The trial took place over the course of a day, and Socrates tried to defend himself, but his efforts were ultimately unsuccessful. Socrates was found guilty and was ordered to commit suicide by drinking hemlock.</p><p>Of course, there’s the obvious problem that comes with only knowing a subject through secondhand sources. To what extent we can trust Plato’s depiction of Socrates will always be up for a debate, barring the invention of time travel. The common theory is that while Plato did, in some parts, try to accurately portray Socrates’s beliefs, he also wasn’t above placing some of his own views in Socrates’s mouth.</p><p>Plato outlived his mentor by nearly fifty years, dying in the year 348 BC or 347 BC. Unlike most of his contemporaries, his canon has remained mostly intact for over 2,400 years, and has been discussed and commented on for nearly as long, making it very difficult to say something new. But we shall try.</p><p><strong>The Work</strong></p><p>Of <em>The Republic, </em>the part that has made the greatest impact when it comes to the general public is the Allegory of the Cave. It has been explored over and over again, most notably being its use in the film <em>The Matrix.</em></p><p><em>The Republic </em>is divided into ten books told in the form of dialogues. The central protagonist is Plato’s idol, Socrates, who will proceed to lead several long, meandering discussions on the nature of justice.</p><p>The first book, as well as much of the second, consist of Socrates and his companions discussing and trying to define justice.</p><p>It is towards the end of the second book that Socrates proposes discussing justice by using the model of the ideal city, reasoning that after all, no man survives on his own, completely apart from others.</p><p>“The Intelligent Troglodyte’s Guide to Plato’s Republic” explains it this way:</p><blockquote>So how is one to identify this particular virtue of the soul, justice? By studying cities. Cities are made up of souls — of individual persons, skilled in various ways, working together, to some extent, for the common good. The conflicts, deliberations, and decisions relevant to the nature of justice are more out in the open. So Socrates proposes to devise an imaginary just city and then to study it. His hope is that justice will be easier to identify in the city, and that, having defined it there, they will be able to define it in the soul.</blockquote><p>Socrates defines a city as consisting of a minimum of four people, but it doesn’t take long for this hypothetical ideal to swell in numbers.</p><blockquote>Then we must enlarge our borders; for the original healthy State is no longer sufficient. Now will the city have to fill and swell with a multitude of callings which are not required by any natural want; such as the whole tribe of hunters and actors, of whom one large class have to do with forms and colours; another will be the votaries of music — poets and their attendant train of rhapsodists, players, dancers, contractors; also makers of divers kinds of articles, including women’s dresses. And we shall want more servants. Will not tutors be also in request, and nurses wet and dry, tirewomen and barbers, as well as confectioners and cooks; and swineherds, too, who were not needed and therefore had no place in the former edition of our State, but are needed now?They must not be forgotten: and there will be animals of many other kinds, if people eat them.</blockquote><p>And much as Sir Thomas More couldn’t envision an ideal society without a subjugated underclass to provide slave labor, Plato can envision no way for his city to exist without territorial disputes.</p><blockquote>And the country which was enough to support the original inhabitants will be too small now, and not enough?</blockquote><blockquote>Quite true.</blockquote><blockquote>Then a slice of our neighbours’ land will be wanted by us for pasture and tillage, and they will want a slice of ours, if, like ourselves, they exceed the limit of necessity, and give themselves up to the unlimited accumulation of wealth?</blockquote><p>This conflict, of course, winds up necessitating a standing army at the ready.</p><blockquote>And so we shall go to war, Glaucon. Shall we not?</blockquote><blockquote>Most certainly, he replied.</blockquote><blockquote>Then without determining as yet whether war does good or harm, thus much we may affirm, that now we have discovered war to be derived from causes which are also the causes of almost all the evils in States, private as well as public.</blockquote><blockquote>Undoubtedly.</blockquote><blockquote>And our State must once more enlarge; and this time the will be nothing short of a whole army, which will have to go out and fight with the invaders for all that we have, as well as for the things and persons whom we were describing above.</blockquote><p>It is unknown as to why Plato didn’t simply set his perfect society on some undiscovered land. The simplest and probably the best answer is that writers’ imaginations tend to have concrete limits. A good example of this phenomenon can be seen in <em>Bruce Almighty </em>where the titular character gets the power of God, which he proceeds to use to impress his girlfriend and get his anchoring job back. Or the pallid so-called heaven of Tim LaHaye and Jerry Jenkins’s <em>Kingdom Come </em>where, when called upon to write about paradise, can’t come up with anything outside of the 9 to 5 grind.</p><p>In fairness, most humans are sadly forced to operate within concrete realities, so it’s hard to shed them when it comes to fiction. There’s also the hazard in going too far into the realm of the impossible. Galt’s Gulch’s existence, Ayn Rand’s utopian community as depicted in <em>Atlas Shrugged, </em>hinges on the existence of a magic motor which can create energy out of nothing, a device which would upend several laws of physics if it existed.</p><p>Maybe if Rand had set her story in the sci-fi or speculative fiction genres, she could get away with such fantastical elements, but Rand makes it clear that she feels her story is set in our reality and serves as a realistic portrait of its failings. In other words, she is depicting Galt’s Gulch not as a utopic ideal, but something that can be manifested in our reality through willpower and hard work. But the motor is such an out-there fantastical element that it only serves to reveal more and more the impossibility of Rand’s vision.</p><p>Socrates, of course, continues to paint war as an inevitability. Though thousands of years separate Plato and Stephen King, he probably would have nodded in agreement with this quote from <em>The Stand:</em></p><blockquote>What Christ should have said was “Yea, verily, whenever two or three of you are gathered together, some other guy is going to get the living shit knocked out of him.” Shall I tell you what sociology teaches us about the human race? I’ll give it to you in a nutshell. Show me a man or woman alone and I’ll show you a saint. Give me two and they’ll fall in love. Give me three and they’ll invent the charming thing we call “society.” Give me four and they’ll build a pyramid. Give me five and they’ll make one an outcast. Give me six and they’ll reinvent prejudice. Give me seven and in seven years they’ll reinvent warfare. Man may have been made in the image of God, but human society was made in the image of His opposite number, and is always trying to get back home.</blockquote><p>Plato’s <em>Republic </em>is ruled by a council of guardians, who are called upon to live an austere lifestyle akin to that of the citizens of <em>Utopia. </em>This is different from the lifestyle of the average citizens of his republic which is actually fairly luxurious; its citizens enjoy fish, sweets, prostitutes, and perfume.</p><p>According to Socrates, the Guardians should have neither possessions nor property and as for sex, it is to consist of couplings that are strictly clinical in nature. They are to be raised only to associate with the good and to be entirely ignorant of bad things; this also includes representations of bad things as seen in plays and literature.</p><p>The flaws in such a worldview are rather obvious. If the ruling elite are raised in way that they cannot understand emotions like cowardice, greed, and jealousy, how are they supposed to rule on issues related to those feelings?</p><p>Plato is well aware of how luxury and possessions corrupt would-be governments, so it makes sense that he would try to solve the problem by ripping these things out of the equation entirely.</p><p>Plato’s <em>Republic </em>is generally a grim read. Unlike many other utopian literature, where there’s presented the possibility of the utopian society becoming a reality, Plato seems to recognize the impossibility of his society, how it could never be. Though he may wax poetic about his perfect society ruled by enlightened philosopher-kings, he firmly believes that eventually this society would degenerate, going through four stages: timocracy, oligarchy, democracy, ending in tyranny.</p><p>Timocracy means that property-owners run the government. This is actually the form of government advocated by the Founding Fathers. Despite them being hailed for creating a democracy, the truth is that they took a generally dim view of democracy, believing as Plato does that it results in the rule of the angry, ignorant mob. They felt the vote should only go to men like them: rich property-owning males. The reason poor people, women, and minorities have the vote is in spite of the Founding Fathers, rather than because of them.</p><p>Plato believes that his philosopher-king society degenerates into a timocracy when the next generation of guardians includes people of an inferior nature, people of iron and brass, rather than silver and gold. For timocrats will make their fortunes via pernicious ways and will be spendthrifts and hedonists.</p><p>Basically, throughout <em>Republic</em>, Plato uses the metaphors of silver, gold, iron, and brass to classify people. Gold is the highest class from which the philosopher-kings descend. Silver contains their auxillaries. Those of brass and iron are meant to be husbandmen and craftsmen. While admitting that most children will be the echo of their parents, Plato demonstrates a surprisingly progressive outlook:</p><blockquote>But as all are of the same original stock, a golden parent will sometimes have a silver son, or a silver parent a golden son. And God proclaims as a first principle to the rulers, and above all else, that there is nothing which should so anxiously guard, or of which they are to be such good guardians, as of the purity of the race. They should observe what elements mingle in their off spring; for if the son of a golden or silver parent has an admixture of brass and iron, then nature orders a transposition of ranks, and the eye of the ruler must not be pitiful towards the child because he has to descend in the scale and become a husbandman or artisan, just as there may be sons of artisans who having an admixture of gold or silver in them are raised to honour, and become guardians or auxiliaries.</blockquote><p>Given Plato’s rather grim view of human nature, and the times in which he lived, it’s rather enlightened of him to admit the possibility of talent arising anywhere, of heritage not being destiny. He is also ahead of his time by advocating for the equal rights and education of women.</p><blockquote>Then, if women are to have the same duties as men, they must have the same nurture and education?</blockquote><blockquote>Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>The education which was assigned to the men was music and gymnastic. Yes.</blockquote><blockquote>Then women must be taught music and gymnastic and also the art of war, which they must practise like the men?</blockquote><p>But it must never be forgotten that Plato takes an overall grim view of human nature.</p><p>After a timocracy, the government becomes an oligarchy. Under this government, the rich will rule and care for nothing except lining their own pockets.</p><p>On the surface, this doesn’t sound too appreciably different from a timocracy, but under an oligarchy, there ceases to be any pretense of virtue or higher calling in government, and the gap between the rich and poor will grow and grow until the oligarchy collapses.</p><p>The oligarchy collapses when the poor rise up in rebellion against their rich overseers. Under a democracy, we have the rule of the mob. Rules and laws cease to mean anything and eventually, law and order will cease to be.</p><p>Plato has long been infamous for his dim view of democracy. The philosopher, Karl Popper, of the Paradox of Tolerance fame, in his book, <em>The Open Society and Its Enemies, </em>lays into Plato, calling him a proto-fascist and accusing him of betraying Socrates’s views:</p><blockquote>Plato’s description of democracy is a vivid but intensely hostile and unjust parody of the political life of Athens, and of the democratic creed which Pericles had formulated in a manner which has never been surpassed, about three years before Plato was born. Plato’s description is a brilliant piece of political propaganda, and we can appreciate what harm it must have done if we consider, for instance, that a man like Adam, an excellent scholar and editor of the Republic, is unable to resist the rhetoric of Plato’s denunciation of his native city. ‘Plato’s description of the genesis of the democratic man’, Adam writes, ‘is one of the most royal and magnificent pieces of writing in the whole range of literature, whether ancient or modern.’ And when the same writer continues: ‘the description of the democratic man as the chameleon of the human society paints him for all time’, then we see that Plato has succeeded at least in turning this thinker against democracy, and we may wonder how much damage his poisonous writing has done when presented, unopposed, to lesser minds …</blockquote><p>But to properly tear down bad ideas, we must strive to understand them first. Because for Plato, democracy isn’t everyone going to the polls and pulling the lever for their favorite candidate. Democracy is the baying of the angry mob out for blood. For Plato, it was mob rule that killed his mentor, Socrates. Socrates’s fate was decided by a jury of citizens chosen by lots that may have consisted of 501 men, as that was the common size of juries back then.</p><p>Eventually, in a democracy, a demogogue will rise up and attract enough of a following to be voted into power, resulting in a tyranny. Plato’s vision of a tyranny is pretty much what you envisioned: the worst possible person attracts enough votes to legitimately get into power and once in power, proceeds to dismantle what’s left of the democracy and set themselves up as a tyrant, unaccountable to practically no one.</p><blockquote>At first, in the early days of his power, he is full of smiles, and he salutes every one whom he meets; — he to be called a tyrant, who is making promises in public and also in private! liberating debtors, and distributing land to the people and his followers, and wanting to be so kind and good to every one!</blockquote><blockquote>Of course, he said.</blockquote><blockquote>But when he has disposed of foreign enemies by conquest or treaty, and there is nothing to fear from them, then he is always stirring up some war or other, in order that the people may require a leader.</blockquote><blockquote>To be sure.</blockquote><blockquote>Has he not also another object, which is that they may be impoverished by payment of taxes, and thus compelled to devote themselves to their daily wants and therefore less likely to conspire against him? Clearly.</blockquote><blockquote>And if any of them are suspected by him of having notions of freedom, and of resistance to his authority, he will have a good pretext for destroying them by placing them at the mercy of the enemy; and for all these reasons the tyrant must be always getting up a war.</blockquote><p>Unlike most utopian lit, <em>Republic </em>is an entirely grim and gloomy take on the matter as while it lays out its vision of a perfect society, it admits that this society is unlikely to endure. Simon Blackburn’s biography of Plato’s <em>Republic </em>has a passage which seems to serve as a summation of the contradictions and limitations of the book:</p><blockquote>We should bear this in mind when we contemplate the ‘utopian’ character of the republic that Plato is about to sketch. There is no doubt that he himself is often taken to be the grandfather of utopian writings in general, the ancestor of endless visionary books about Arcadia, the Golden Age, the Land of Cockaigne, the Garden of Eden, or the Islands of the Blest. There are some plums in this pudding such as Thomas More’s Utopia of 1515, or Samuel Butler’s Erewhon of 1872, but in general utopian writings have a bad image nowadays. They often sound weird, impractical, visionary, if not outright mad.</blockquote><p>That’s a fair summation of some of the limits of the utopian genre — weird, impractical, visionary, if not outright mad — but in a way, it serves as its strength. In our world where Capitalist Realism rules the day and is effectively destroying the planet, we might benefit from expanding our visions into the realm of the mad for just a little.</p><p>Our next journey into Utopia will take us to Margaret Cavendish’s <em>The Blazing World.</em></p><p>Bibliography</p><p>Blackburn, Simon. <em>Plato’s “Republic”: A Biography</em>. Manjul Publishing House Pvt Ltd, 2009.</p><p>En.wikipedia.org. 2022. <em>List of utopian literature — Wikipedia</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_utopian_literature&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>Open Textbook Library. “The Intelligent Troglodyteâs Guide to Platoâs Republic.” <em>Open Textbook Library</em>, open.umn.edu/opentextbooks/textbooks/266. Accessed 11 Aug. 2022.</p><p>“Plato | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.” <em>Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy</em>, iep.utm.edu/plato. Accessed 11 Aug. 2022.</p><p>“Plato.” <em>Wikipedia</em>, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plato. Accessed 10 Aug. 2022.</p><p>Wikipedia contributors. “Plato’s Five Regimes.” <em>Wikipedia</em>, 29 July 2022, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plato%27s_five_regimes.</p><p>Rafe, et al. “Thoughts on Freedom: Condensed OSE Chapter 4.” <em>Sabhlok City</em>, sabhlokcity.blogspot.com/2006/07/condensed-ose-chapter-4.html. Accessed 11 Aug. 2022.</p><p>Wikipedia contributors. “Republic (Plato).” <em>Wikipedia</em>, 10 Aug. 2022, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_(Plato).</p><p>Sharpe, Matthew. “Guide to the Classics: Plato’s Republic.” <em>The Conversation</em>, 16 Dec. 2019, theconversation.com/guide-to-the-classics-platos-republic-127724.</p><p>“Socrates | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.” <em>Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy</em>, iep.utm.edu/socrates. Accessed 11 Aug. 2022.</p><p>— -. “Socrates.” <em>Wikipedia</em>, 15 July 2022, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socrates.</p><p>“Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.” <em>Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy</em>, plato.stanford.edu. Accessed 11 Aug. 2022.</p><p>— -. <em>The Republic (Penguin Classics)</em>. New, Penguin Classics, 2007.</p><p>— -. “Timocracy.” <em>Wikipedia</em>, 20 July 2022, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timocracy.</p><p>— -. “Trial of Socrates.” <em>Wikipedia</em>, 1 Aug. 2022, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_of_Socrates.</p><p>Utopianfiction.com. 2022. <em>Utopian Literature — Discussion and examples of utopias, dystopias, ecotopias and other speculative fiction</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;https://www.utopianfiction.com/&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>Utopiaanddystopia.com. 2022. <em>Utopian Literature List — Descriptions of Famous Utopian Works</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;http://www.utopiaanddystopia.com/utopian-fiction/utopian-literature-list/&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>Walton, Jo. <em>The Just City</em>. Corsair, 2015.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=264becc09511" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Utopia Defined: Sir Thomas More’s “Utopia”]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jennylynn/utopia-defined-sir-thomas-mores-utopia-86e7ec19bce?source=rss-1b999abdbfe3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/86e7ec19bce</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[thomas-more]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[utopia]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[literature-review]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny Lynn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 24 May 2022 20:43:56 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-05-24T20:43:56.292Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/700/1*-4RKXaJQOaO03sAMYpHJDg.jpeg" /></figure><p>We can argue about whether Sir Thomas More’s book really qualifies as the first Utopian fiction, but since it served as the trope namer, it seemed like a good place to start. For this post, I read the above edition of this work, due in part to the promised essays by Ursula K. Le Guin. Le Guin will only be mentioned sparingly in this post, but trust me when I say she’ll come up more in later posts.</p><p>Before we leap into the book itself, we need to talk about the time and place where it was written as well as the guy who wrote it.</p><p><strong>Background</strong></p><p>The year is 1516. Sir Thomas More is currently employed as one of the two under-sheriffs of London. It would be another year before he would become an advisor to King Henry VIII. Henry VIII was currently married to wife number one, Catherine of Aragon, and in 1516, Henry VIII welcomed the birth of his first child, the future Queen Mary I.</p><p>The Protestant Reformation wouldn’t officially take off until 1517, but that didn’t mean that the Church wasn’t already churning with controversy. Numerous reformers like John Wycliffe, Jan Hus, and John Calvin had taken on the effort of reforming the church, criticizing such problems as the sale of indulgences.</p><p>England was undergoing its own version of the Italian Renaissance with an overflowing in the production of literature, especially when it came to plays. Like the rest of Europe, England was developing its own colonies in the New World, and it’s the exploration of the New World which serves to provide the backdrop for <em>Utopia.</em></p><p>Christopher Columbus first landed in the New World in 1492. What followed was slavery and wholesale slaughter as Columbus along with the rest of Europe, sought to extract as much wealth from their colonies as they could. For good or for ill, Columbus’s arrival so rocked the New World that the history of the Americas would be divided into Columbian and Pre-Columbian eras. But the discovery of the Americas also rocked Europe.</p><p>A simple example of this can be seen in our diets. Corn and potatoes weren’t a part of the European diet until they were brought back from the Americas. But the New World also brought with it deeper questions.</p><p>Before the New World, the common knowledge stated that all people and all animals descended from Noah and his ark. So when the Europeans crossed an entire ocean and discovered new lands full of strange new peoples and animals never seen before, it forever shook this common knowledge. Scholars and other esteemed men were forced to grapple with the question of “How did these people and animals get across an entire ocean?”</p><p>The existence of the Indians of the New World also raised trickier, deeper theological questions. For the Indians couldn’t simply be dismissed as damned infidels like the Jews or Muslims, people who had heard the word of Christ and rejected it; these people simply hadn’t heard of Christ. So what was their status within the confines of the Christian religion?</p><p>It’s questions like these that may have played no small part in what would be called the Protestant Reformation, which took place in 1517, twenty-five years after Columbus’s first voyage.</p><p>More remained a devout Catholic, eventually being named a saint, after being executed by Henry VIII for refusing to acknowledge his annulment to Catherine of Aragon and his creation of the Church of England.</p><p>With that background in mind, let’s talk about the book.</p><p><strong>The Work</strong></p><p>The format of the book takes the form of written correspondence between More, Peter Gilles, the town clerk of Antwerp, and Hieronymus van Busleyden, counselor to Charles V, later involving conversations with a fictional character named Raphael Hythlodaeus.</p><p>To the extent that <em>Utopia </em>has made any dent in the pop culture landscape, people remember its usage in <em>Ever After </em>where the main character cites this passage:</p><blockquote>For if you suffer your people to be ill-educated, and their manners to be corrupted from their infancy, and then punish them for those crimes to which their first education disposed them, what else is to be concluded from this but that you first make thieves and then punish them?</blockquote><p>This comes from the beginning which is set at a dinner party. The host is bragging about the number of thieves he had hanged.</p><p>Thomas More’s character, Raphael Hythlodaeus, takes the host to task for this.</p><blockquote>There was no reason to wonder at the matter, since this way of punishing thieves was neither just in itself nor good for the public; for, as the severity was too great, so the remedy was not effectual; simple theft not being so great a crime that it ought to cost a man his life; no punishment, how severe soever, being able to restrain those from robbing who can find out no other way of livelihood.</blockquote><p>The dinner party serves as a discussion of the enclosure movement. Enclosure technically began in the 12th century, but it was in the 16th century when it really took off.</p><p>The Enclosure Movement led to peasants losing the strips of land which they had farmed for centuries, which were snatched up by wealthy landowners, who proceeded to fence it off and strictly control access to. These strips of land had served to grant peasants a degree of independence from their feudal lords, but once these lands were taken away, these peasant farmers lost this independence.</p><p>Many leftist theorists mark this as the beginning of what would become known as Capitalism with its bourgeoisie and proletariat classes. Once separated from their land, these formerly semi-independent farmers became mere workers, forced to sell their labor to whoever would hire them.</p><p>In Tudor England, the main driver of the Enclosure movement was increased demand for wool. Landowners snatched up land long used by the peasantry and converted into sheep pastures. With so many peasants turned out from their land, the crime rate rises.</p><p>The issue of dispossessed workers remained one struggled with throughout the Tudor era and beyond. More, naturally, is on the side of the workers.</p><blockquote>“The increase of pasture”, said I, “by which your sheep, which are naturally mild, and easily kept in order, may be said now to devour men and unpeople, not only villages, but towns; for wherever it is found that the sheep of any soil yield a softer and richer wool than ordinary, there the nobility and gentry, and even those holy men — the abbots! — not contented with the old rents which their farms yielded, nor thinking it enough that they, living at their ease, do no good to the public, resolve to do it hurt instead of good. They stop the course of agriculture, destroying houses and towns, reserving only the churches, and enclose grounds that they may lodge their sheep in them. As if forests and parks had swallowed up too little of the land, those worthy countrymen turn the best inhabited places into solitudes; for when an insatiable wretch, who is a plague to his country, resolves to enclose many thousand acres of ground, the owners, as well as tenants, are turned out of their possessions by trick or by main force, or, being wearied out by ill usage, they are forced to sell them; by which means those miserable people, both men and women, married and unmarried, old and young, with their poor but numerous families (since country business requires many hands), are all forced to change their seats, not knowing whither to go; and they must sell, almost for nothing, their household stuff, which could not bring them much money, even though they might stay for a buyer. When that little money is at an end (for it will be soon spent), what is left for them to do but either to steal, and so to be hanged (God knows how justly!), or to go about and beg?</blockquote><p>As it was true then, it is true now: crime, in general, is born of poverty and desperation. Dispatching the criminals without addressing the circumstances which led them down the path, is slapping a bandage on a massive gaping wound.</p><p>The book moves away from the dinner party and eventually, we get to the meat of the book as Raphael Hythlodaeus talks about the land of Utopia. He starts with some talk about the geography of Utopia:</p><blockquote>‘The island of Utopia is in the middle two hundred miles broad, and holds almost at the same breadth over a great part of it, but it grows narrower towards both ends. Its figure is not unlike a crescent. Between its horns the sea comes in eleven miles broad, and spreads itself into a great bay, which is environed with land to the compass of about five hundred miles, and is well secured from winds.</blockquote><p>The traditional picture of a utopian society will invariably take place on an island. But More provides something of a wrinkle on the subject. Originally, the island was a peninsula.</p><blockquote>But they report (and there remains good marks of it to make it credible) that this was no island at first, but a part of the continent. Utopus, that conquered it (whose name it still carries, for Abraxa was its first name), brought the rude and uncivilized inhabitants into such a good government, and to that measure of politeness, that they now far excel all the rest of mankind. Having soon subdued them, he designed to separate them from the continent, and to bring the sea quite round them. To accomplish this he ordered a deep channel to be dug, fifteen miles long; and that the natives might not think he treated them like slaves, he not only forced the inhabitants, but also his own soldiers, to labour in carrying it on.</blockquote><p>In this passage, we see one of the first major traits of Utopia, one of many that shows how More’s <em>Utopia </em>is very much a creation of the Renaissance/Age of Exploration.</p><p>For as the above passage illustrates, Utopia is the product of conquest with its native population overtaken by the enlightened army of General Utopus. This, of course, is paralleled by the real world conquests going on at the time of the book’s publication.</p><p>As China Mieville points out in his introduction:</p><blockquote>We know the history of such encounters, too; that every brutalised, genocided and enslaved people in history have, like the Abraxans, been ‘rude and uncivilised’ in the tracts of their invaders. A start for any habitable utopia must be to overturn the ideological bullshit of empire, and, unsentimentally but respectfully, to revisit the traduced and defamed cultures on the bones of which some conqueror’s utopian dreams were piled up. ‘Utopia’ is to the political imaginary of betterness as ‘Rhodesia’ is to Zimbabwe, ‘Gold Coast’ to Ghana. How, then, might we set out for New Abraxa?</blockquote><p>Little detail is given in More’s work as to the Abraxans. They receive about a one line mention where they immediately ally themselves with Utopus and cease to exist as a people. This is a rather strange decision to make. More could have easily just used the common trope where his character stumbles onto a strange island following a storm at sea or something like, and the story would still unfold more or less the same.</p><p>The decision to include an indigenous population is an interesting worldbuilding choice to make, and we can only speculate why. Utopias are ultimately a reflection of the writer’s views as well as the times in which they were created. In light of the conquest of the New World, maybe it makes sense that when called upon to create a paradisal society, More can’t envision this occurring through any means besides subjugating any entire class of people.</p><p>Of course, we get no description of how the Abraxans were made into Utopians. The only reasoning given is that the society created by Utopus is so great that everyone just naturally wants to join, and so they do, abandoning whatever culture or traditions they may have had without a thought.</p><p>Though this kind of passive mention of indigenous peoples has long been something of a tradition when it comes to discussions of history. Christopher Columbus’s brutal enslavement of the natives of Hispaniola has only recently started to gain more widespread knowledge.</p><p>Columbus instituted a brutal system of tribute where all Indians fourteen years of age or older had to collect either a large bell of gold or twenty-five pounds of cotton. When an Indian delivered the tribute, they were given a brass or copper token to wear about their neck as proof of their payment. Any Indian without a token was punished. With a fresh token, an Indian was safe from punishment for three months during which they were to collect more cotton or gold. If their tokens expired, the Spaniards cut off their hands.</p><p>This is a sharp contrast to traditional depictions of Christopher Columbus taught in history classes, which are practically hagiographies depicting the brave explorer setting forth into the unknown and discovering a new world. Careful narrative sleight of hand obscures the strange paradox of how the indigenous peoples managed to inhabit their lands for centuries without ever having discovered them. A ruling in 1823 by Chief Justice John Marshall illustrates this phenomenon where he says that the Cherokee had rights to their land by occupancy, but whites had greater rights due to their discovery.</p><p>In Utopia, the cities are all laid out in pretty much the same gridlike fashion, though the only one described at length is its capitol, Amaurot, which is, not too surprisingly, strikingly similar to London in it layout. According to Hythlodaeus, the Utopians regularly switch between the countryside and the city so that everyone gets the opportunity to live both kinds of lifestyles.</p><p>Here’s the description of the average workday length of a Utopian citizen.</p><blockquote>they, dividing the day and night into twenty-four hours, appoint six of these for work, three of which are before dinner and three after; they then sup, and at eight o’clock, counting from noon, go to bed and sleep eight hours: the rest of their time, besides that taken up in work, eating, and sleeping, is left to every man’s discretion</blockquote><p>Far cry from the workday of the average American which begins at 9 and ends at 5, thus, giving us an average of eight hours, give or take however long their lunch break is.</p><p>The average adult worked 1980 hours of a work year that consisted of 180 days, which divides into an average of 11 hours per day, but these hours aren’t completely accurate.</p><p>We’ve long viewed the average medieval peasant of this time as a poor, overworked, uneducated soul toiling from sunrise to sunset on their little patch of land. But that is a grave misconception. The medieval calendar contained so many holidays, not just the big ones like Christmas, Easter, and midsummer, but also numerous saints’ and rest days. And the average workday was intermittent, broken up by meals, along with frequent stoppages during the heat of the day.</p><p>The bulk of the work was carried out over six months of the year, allowing the remaining six to be taken up with leisure. There was still work down during these months much in the way someone still has to eat and clean while on vacation, but it was hardly the brutal drudgery that has long stereotyped the era. Basically once the numbers are crunched, the peasant of this era enjoyed more leisure time than the average modern-day office worker.</p><p>Now this not to advocate for anarcho-primitivism or that we smash up all our computers and commit ourselves to the 16th century lifestyle. I bring this up because proponents of technology have generally marketed tech as a tool towards creating a Utopian society by freeing up more time for leisure, but circumstances have yet to bear this out. Instead, the average worker has wound up working harder and producing more for increasingly lower wages.</p><p>More couldn’t have completely foreseen late-stage Capitalism, but the following passage bears some eerie prescience.</p><blockquote>consider how few of those that work are employed in labours that are of real service, for we, who measure all things by money, give rise to many trades that are both vain and superfluous, and serve only to support riot and luxury: for if those who work were employed only in such things as the conveniences of life require, there would be such an abundance of them that the prices of them would so sink that tradesmen could not be maintained by their gains; if all those who labour about useless things were set to more profitable employments, and if all they that languish out their lives in sloth and idleness (every one of whom consumes as much as any two of the men that are at work) were forced to labour, you may easily imagine that a small proportion of time would serve for doing all that is either necessary, profitable, or pleasant to mankind, especially while pleasure is kept within its due bounds.</blockquote><p>This passage seems strikingly similar to David Graeber’s book <em>Bullshit Jobs</em>, which lays out these points:</p><ul><li>Huge swathes of people spend their days performing tasks they secretly believe do not really need to be performed.</li><li>It’s as if someone were out there making up pointless jobs for the sake of keeping us all working.</li><li>The moral and spiritual damage that comes from this situation is profound. It is a scar across our collective soul. Yet virtually no one talks about it.</li><li>How can one even begin to speak of dignity in labor when one secretly feels one’s job should not exist?</li></ul><p>So already More is seeing the bloom of bureaucracies and other inefficiencies. More believes that if everyone was put to work on necessary labor, then there would be a surplus of necessary goods, and no one would have to go without. Maybe that standard was true of his time, but perversely, the opposite is true in our time. We have a surplus of all the basic necessities needed to sustain life: food, shelter, and medicine. Yet these are made artificially scarce by a brutal capitalist system. It costs society more, not just in morale, but in actual money to let people die from a lack of access to these things, but we keep doing it, and it’s worth exploring why. Because tying back to previous comments made about technology, the idea has long been that improved technology would lead to greater access to the necessities of life; clearly, the problem goes beyond that of technology’s abilities.</p><p>In More’s Utopia, when its citizens are not working, eating, or sleeping, they spend their time attending lectures, carrying out discourses of their own, playing music, or playing games similar to that of chess.</p><p>Now for some, this sounds like a pretty dull life, its amenities few and far between. As the old saying goes, “One man’s Utopia is another man’s Dystopia.”</p><p>More’s Utopia sounds similar to the philosopher Epicurus’s model of an ideal society. Despite the reputation Epicurus has acquired, the truth is that while he advocated for a life of pleasure, he divided between higher pleasures and lower ones, higher ones being the pursuit of justice and lower ones being that of wine or Dionysian excess. Epicurus advocated for higher pleasures, believing that lower ones made for a cheap thrill, but they don’t last long.</p><p>Despite the seeming austerities of Utopia, More insists that Utopians are not ascetics.</p><blockquote>But they think it madness for a man to wear out the beauty of his face or the force of his natural strength, to corrupt the sprightliness of his body by sloth and laziness, or to waste it by fasting; that it is madness to weaken the strength of his constitution and reject the other delights of life, unless by renouncing his own satisfaction he can either serve the public or promote the happiness of others, for which he expects a greater recompense from God.</blockquote><p>This is rather strange as More himself regularly practiced fasting and wearing a hair shirt.</p><p>Probably the biggest sign that More’s <em>Utopia </em>is very much an artifact of its time, is its advocacy of slavery. More tries to soften this by saying that Utopia is such a cool place that citizens of neighboring nations regularly sell themselves into slavery just to live there.</p><blockquote>Another sort of slaves are the poor of the neighbouring countries, who offer of their own accord to come and serve them: they treat these better, and use them in all other respects as well as their own countrymen, except their imposing more labour upon them, which is no hard task to those that have been accustomed to it; and if any of these have a mind to go back to their own country, which, indeed, falls out but seldom, as they do not force them to stay, so they do not send them away empty-handed.</blockquote><p>But this is hardly much a comfort. But just as More couldn’t envision his ideal society without the violent subjugation of indigenous peoples, he couldn’t envision a society that didn’t have an enslaved underclass toiling at the lowest possible station.</p><p>He tries to soften this by assuring his readers that the slaves are treated well, probably holding the paternalistic view that many did towards Indian and African slavery that as bad as it was, they were still better off being slaves than godless heathens in their native lands.</p><p>More’s own words betray the more mercenary aspects of slavery.</p><blockquote>For the most part slavery is the punishment even of the greatest crimes, for as that is no less terrible to the criminals themselves than death, so they think the preserving them in a state of servitude is more for the interest of the commonwealth than killing them, since, as their labour is a greater benefit to the public than their death could be, so the sight of their misery is a more lasting terror to other men than that which would be given by their death.</blockquote><p>Not too surprisingly, one of the more interesting sections in light of More’s ultimate fate is the one about religion.</p><p>Initially the Utopians worship a god they called Mithras, but naturally as soon as they are introduced to Christianity, they jump onboard. There are some holdouts, but everyone generally gets along, with only one exception.</p><blockquote>He being newly baptized did, notwithstanding all that we could say to the contrary, dispute publicly concerning the Christian religion, with more zeal than discretion, and with so much heat, that he not only preferred our worship to theirs, but condemned all their rites as profane, and cried out against all that adhered to them as impious and sacrilegious persons, that were to be damned to everlasting burnings. Upon his having frequently preached in this manner he was seized, and after trial he was condemned to banishment, not for having disparaged their religion, but for his inflaming the people to sedition; for this is one of their most ancient laws, that no man ought to be punished for his religion.</blockquote><p>It seems strange that Sir Thomas More would advocate for religious tolerance. When the Protestant Reformation took off a year later, he considered it to be a heresy and saw the Reformation as a threat to society as a whole. Over the course of his career, he would persecute many Protestants.</p><p>His initial actions against Protestantism consisted of preventing Lutheran books from being imported into England, spying on and investigating suspected Protestants, and arresting anyone holding in his possession, transporting, or distributing Tyndale Bibles and other materials of the Protestant Reformation.</p><p>More has been accused of all manner of atrocities against Protestants. The Protestant historian John Foxe claimed in his book <em>Foxe’s Book of Martyrs </em>that More personally tortured heretics. More himself denied these accusations claiming that he only caned two people: a child who was caned in front of his family for heresy regarding the Eucharist, and a “feeble-minded” man who was whipped for disrupting prayers. Still, numerous accounts link him to burnings of heretics.</p><p>So More isn’t exactly the paragon of religious tolerance. Ultimately, he would be executed for refusing to renounce his Catholicism, but it’s hard to tell whether he was the type of advocate for religious tolerance that was only concerned about tolerance for their religion.</p><p>More was well aware of the hazards of religious strife, even before becoming a Chancellor. Living in the 16th century, there was no way to not be aware of this. So some of his dictums are remarkably radical for its time.</p><p>Raphael finishes his lecture. More’s self-insert is ambivalent about Utopia, probably reflecting More’s own ambivalence regarding such issues as religious freedom.</p><p>So what can we learn from More’s <em>Utopia</em>? Well, as the trope namer and archetype, it laid out a lot of the conventions that would come to represent the genre. We have the wise, enlightened leader in Utopus, a society where wealth doesn’t matter, and the promise of equality, which would become well-worn tropes in Utopian lit. Like most Utopian literature, it is laced with critiques of the rich and powerful, castigating those who live in opulence despite not contributing much of anything to society.</p><p>Yet there are notes of ambivalence in More’s words. There’s the obvious in that the name Utopia is a pun on Greek words ‘ou-topos’ [no place] and ‘eu-topos’ [good place]). The person who narrates the discussion, Raphael Hythlodaeus, last name means “speaker of nonsense” after all.</p><p>To quote from one of Ursula K. Le Guin’s attached essays “A Non-Euclidean View of California as a Cold Place to Be:”</p><blockquote>In The Shape of Utopia, speaking of our modern distrust of utopia, [Robert C. Elliott] said,</blockquote><blockquote>If the word is to be redeemed, it will have to be by someone who has followed utopia into the abyss which yawns behind the Grand Inquisitor’s vision, and who then has clambered out on the other side.</blockquote><p>There are many flaws to be found in Thomas More’s <em>Utopia</em>, its endorsement of colonialism and slavery being among its most obvious, but we need flawed archetypes to form better ones.</p><p>And that’s Thomas More’s <em>Utopia. </em>Next in the series, we’re going to go back to ancient Greece with Plato’s <em>Republic.</em></p><p>Bibliography</p><p>En.wikipedia.org. 2022. Enclosure — Wikipedia. [online] Available at: &lt;<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure">https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enclosure</a>&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>En.wikipedia.org. 2022. <em>List of utopian literature — Wikipedia</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_utopian_literature&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>En.wikipedia.org. 2022. <em>Thomas More — Wikipedia</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_More&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>En.wikipedia.org. 2022. <em>Utopia (book) — Wikipedia</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utopia_(book)&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>Graeber, David. Bullshit Jobs: A Theory. India, Simon &amp; Schuster, 2019.</p><p>Groups.csail.mit.edu. 2022. <em>Preindustrial workers worked fewer hours than today’s</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;https://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/hours_workweek.html&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>Le Guin, Ursula K., and More, Thomas. Utopia. United Kingdom, Verso Books, 2016.</p><p>Loewen, J. W. (2008). Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong. United Kingdom: New Press.</p><p>Utopianfiction.com. 2022. <em>Utopian Literature — Discussion and examples of utopias, dystopias, ecotopias and other speculative fiction</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;https://www.utopianfiction.com/&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><p>Utopiaanddystopia.com. 2022. <em>Utopian Literature List — Descriptions of Famous Utopian Works</em>. [online] Available at: &lt;http://www.utopiaanddystopia.com/utopian-fiction/utopian-literature-list/&gt; [Accessed 24 May 2022].</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=86e7ec19bce" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Utopia Defined: the Parameters]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jennylynn/utopia-defined-the-parameters-6a12e9024091?source=rss-1b999abdbfe3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/6a12e9024091</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[fiction]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[books]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[medium]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jenny Lynn]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 09 Mar 2022 03:03:49 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-03-09T03:03:49.839Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Utopia Defined: the Parameters</p><p>It has become increasingly clear that we live in an age of constrained futures. Our media is chock full of dystopias and gloom, and even the most optimistic of futures dares not hope for too much, envisioning a world not too different from the one we have now. Even Star Trek, long known for its optimistic future, seems to have turned increasingly grim, choosing to set their most recent series during the time of the Original Series rather than try to create a new vision of the future.</p><p>Both Franco ‘Bifo’ Berardi and Mark Fisher spoke of what they called “a slow cancellation of the future” that came into being in the seventies along with neoliberalism, the political philosophy that has defined the era ever since. The two ideas seem to go hand in hand, ultimately producing the capitalist realism that currently hangs over us. If, as capitalist realism asserts, capitalism is the only viable political reality, then this is the best possible world we can hope for, and dreams of anything better is merely interesting wool-gathering.</p><p>This attitude is generally borne out in any current political discussion where anyone who proposes the prospect of a more just world, will invariably be greeted with choruses of “Be realistic.” Leaders of the past were capable of envisioning using societal forces to reshape society for the better, but the current ones seem to have thrown up their hands and resigned themselves to the current systems of power and control. Dreams of utopias have been effectively constrained to the dustbin of history.</p><p>On some level, this is understandable. Past attempts to create heaven on earth have resulted in appalling misery. But we do a disservice in dismissing the value of utopia entirely. Utopia is ultimately unachievable, but it can serve as a guiding star. To quote Oscar Wilde,</p><blockquote>A map of the world that does not include Utopia is not worth even glancing at, for it leaves out the one country at which Humanity is always landing. And when Humanity lands there, it looks out, and, seeing a better country, sets sail. Progress is the realization of Utopias.</blockquote><p>The Left is often stereotyped as being gloomy, always pointing out problems, offering little by way of a positive future. To a degree, this is true. Though we live in an era of constrained futures, the Right is better able to present a utopian vision of society. It is generally of an Ozzie-and-Harriet halcyon that never really existed, but it is still a vision for their supporters to rally behind.</p><p>The Left on the other hand, suffer from a lack of a coherent vision, which needs to change. If we are to change the world, we need to be able to present a compelling counter-vision as to how we feel it should be; it’s as simple as that.</p><p>That is what this project intends to do. Over the course of this study, I will read and review fictional utopias of the past. By studying the utopias of the past, their grand ideas as well as their failings, the goal is to expand our imaginations a little and in doing so, craft a coherent vision for the modern age.</p><p>First up on this slate, is the classic, Sir Thomas More’s “Utopia.” While not technically the first novel of utopian fiction, it is the one that first named the trope and set the standard by which the genre is studied.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=6a12e9024091" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>