<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jessy Skaria on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jessy Skaria on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jessyskaria?source=rss-41bcf97dda06------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 01:19:04 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Guillain-Barre Syndrome Outbreak of 2025: Does the Threat of Rare Disease Outbreaks Stalk…]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/the-guillain-barre-syndrome-outbreak-of-2025-does-the-threat-of-rare-disease-outbreaks-stalk-608f488ed2a6?source=rss-41bcf97dda06------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/608f488ed2a6</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jessy Skaria]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 31 Jan 2025 22:16:27 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-04-28T15:47:09.651Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>The Guillain-Barre Syndrome Outbreak of 2025: Does the Threat of Rare Disease Outbreaks Stalk Indian Festivals?</strong></h3><p>I wrote the Medium article <a href="https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/does-the-threat-of-mucormycosis-stalk-indian-festivals-3de0a672b3d1"><em>“Does the Threat of Mucormycosis Stalk Indian festivals?</em>”</a> in the aftermath of the Covid Associated Mucormycosis (CAM) / “Black Fungus” epidemic that ravaged India in 2021. It was written even as I was awaiting the publishing of our peer-reviewed hypothesis <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">“<em>Are Unique Regional Factors the Missing Link in India’s Covid-19 Associated Mucormycosis (CAM) Crisis?</em>”</a> which discussed the potentially prime roles played by cattle dung, smoke from burning animal dung, stubble burning and polluted river waters in India’s outbreak of the rare mucormycosis.</p><p>For the last four years, I have been following the reported <a href="https://www.ahmedabadmirror.com/mucormycosis--the-black-fungus--continues-to-haunt-patients/81865304.html/">uptick of mucormycosis in India following religious festivals incorporating dung burning and mass river bathing</a> and also after <a href="https://medicalbuyer.co.in/aiims-bathinda-witnesses-surge-in-black-fungus-cases/">stubble burning</a>. I was, as it happens, in the process of working on my next article on how I expect 2025 — with the clustered events of the Maha Kumbh Mela from January 13-February 26, (bringing extraordinarily high numbers of devotees to the holy rivers), followed just two weeks later (March 13) by the cow dung burning Holika Dahan — to be particularly bad, and potentially a minor version of the 2021 ‘black fungus epidemic’ (sans Covid). That prediction still stands, and I strongly warn Indians to take adequate precautions including wearing masks whenever the air is thick with smoke.</p><p>However, my attention has now been drawn away by a surprising and urgent new development: we are currently facing an entirely new public health disaster, in the form of a rare outbreak of<strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/guillain-barre-syndrome/symptoms-causes/syc-20362793"><strong><em>Guillain-Barre syndrome (GBS)</em></strong></a><strong><em>! </em></strong>The condition, a rare auto-immune reaction that presents as an acute inflammatory polyneuropathy that can progress to potentially life-threatening muscle weakness and paralysis, is usually triggered by a preceding bacterial or viral infection, typically gastrointestinal or respiratory in nature. <em>Campylobacter jejuni</em>, <em>Mycoplasma and cytomegalovirus</em> are some of the commonly associated infectious organisms.</p><p>Initially reported as a cluster of cases from <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/pune-73-cases-of-guillain-barre-syndrome-reported-in-a-week-14-on-ventilator/articleshow/117543113.cms?from=mdr"><strong>Pune</strong></a><strong> </strong>in the second half of January, this rare disease has quickly surged within days and now stands at <a href="https://www.news18.com/india/guillain-barre-syndrome-gbs-virus-maharashtra-death-toll-pune-cases-pimpri-chinchwad-9209243.html">130 cases in the state of Maharashtra</a>, with four deaths and <a href="https://www.freepressjournal.in/pune/guillain-barr-syndrome-in-pune-state-on-high-alert-as-gbs-cases-reach-130-20-on-ventilators-3-dead">20 patients on the ventilator</a>!</p><p>The majority of these patients gave a history of diarrhea in the preceding weeks, and <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/pune-guillain-barre-syndrome-outbreak-niv-finds-norovirus-and-campylobacter-bacteria-in-patient-samples/articleshow/117498341.cms"><em>Campylobacter jejuni (C.jejuni) and Norovirus</em> have been isolated from some of the patients’ stool samples</a>. While <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/campylobacter/signs-symptoms/guillain-barre-syndrome.html">Campylobacter infection is one of the most common </a>triggers for GBS, <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3448342/">norovirus is a relatively less known</a> trigger.</p><p>Since most of the cases have been reported from Pune and surrounding regions, the health authorities are concentrating almost exclusively at finding <a href="https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/pune/contaminated-water-source-near-khadakwasla-likely-cause-for-guillain-barre-syndrome-says-health-minister-9802626/">local sources of contaminated water</a> that could have caused the triggering gastrointestinal infections.</p><p>But here is the catch.</p><p>While the reported surge in Pune does seem to be the most dramatic, many cases of GBS are now being reported from widely diverse, geographically discrete regions within the state of Maharashtra and from different parts of India:</p><p><strong>Three deaths</strong> have been reported from <a href="https://www.firstpost.com/health/guillain-barre-syndrome-west-bengal-kolkata-maharashtra-pune-death-13857695.html"><strong><em>Kolkata, West Bengal</em></strong></a> with <strong>four</strong> more children diagnosed with GBS.</p><p><strong>Four cases</strong> have been confirmed in <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/jaipur/four-cases-of-guillain-barre-syndrome-confirmed-in-raj/articleshow/117752837.cms?fbclid=IwY2xjawIJAAZleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHculh1ZTUC5NGukEnrBYivYQXQY7jQJAHy-Ttj2FbMVmstOCmc3QD8ytjw_aem_EafrA4SibMgowUSrp8fgMA"><strong><em>Rajasthan</em></strong></a><strong><em>.</em></strong></p><p><strong>One</strong> has been reported from<strong><em> </em></strong><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ranchi/jkhands-1st-gbs-case-detected-in-5-yr-old-city-girl-stable/articleshow/117752373.cms?fbclid=IwY2xjawIJAG1leHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHculh1ZTUC5NGukEnrBYivYQXQY7jQJAHy-Ttj2FbMVmstOCmc3QD8ytjw_aem_EafrA4SibMgowUSrp8fgMA"><strong><em>Jharkhand</em></strong></a>.</p><p>And another <strong>one</strong> from <a href="https://www.siasat.com/first-case-of-guillain-barre-syndrome-reported-in-hyderabad-3173168/"><strong><em>Hyderabad</em></strong></a>.</p><p>There are apparently <strong>100 plus</strong> cases in <a href="https://www.downtoearth.org.in/health/guillain-barr%C3%A9-outbreak-in-pune-human-made-epidemic-more-than-5000-cases-expected-experts?fbclid=IwY2xjawIJAfRleHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHaenval0Ppf_ZyLJdVwVA6owQwnfnEiWAWhJr_xTFEGvc2osjG7o4gs8IA_aem_u_TPH-RwcLpuNT2IvlIp6A"><strong><em>Delhi</em></strong></a>; as Dr. Sanjay Pandey, head of the neurology department at Amrita Hospital in Faridabad told DTE, “if the number of GBS cases in every hospital in Delhi were combined, the total could exceed 100”.</p><p>In <strong><em>Maharashtra, apart from Pune</em></strong>, there have been <em>5 cases in </em><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/city-gbs-cases-within-annual-range-5-reported-in-akola-one-on-ventilator/articleshow/117754565.cms"><em>Akola</em></a>, with one patient on ventilator, <em>12 cases in </em><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/12-gbs-hit-hospitalised-in-nagpur-only-2-kids-are-local-no-pune-clustering-here/articleshow/117702574.cms"><em>Nagpur</em></a>, <em>4 cases in</em><a href="https://www.etvbharat.com/en/!state/after-pune-guillain-barre-syndrome-gbs-spreads-tentacles-in-maharashtras-satara-enn25013101121"><em> Satara</em></a> and <em>8 suspected cases in</em><a href="https://www.thebridgechronicle.com/news/guillain-barre-syndrome-spreads-beyond-pune-8-suspected-cases-in-kolhapur-and-sangli"><em> Kolhapur and Sangli</em></a>. Maharashtra being the third largest state in India, please know that these affected focal areas are separated from each other by good distances.</p><p>In short, looking at the bigger picture, it becomes clear that <strong><em>currently multiple parts of India are concurrently in the throes of an extremely unusual outbreak of a very rare syndrome</em></strong>. Bearing in mind the rarity of the condition and the geographically widespread pattern of involvement, it makes sense to look for a <strong>single source of infection at a potentially large site of confluence of people from different parts of India</strong>. This epidemiological pattern is more likely than having this rare disease appearing simultaneously at multiple random parts of the country. This hence behoves our public health departments to be urgently, actively looking for a common source that could have infected all or most of these patients from across the country with the GBS triggering pathogens like C.jejuni, in such a short time span: that is, as mentioned above, an infectious source at a discrete, narrow location, where large numbers of people from different parts of the country happen to have gathered.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NCnFgdncQc7UZP3aXyNzfA.jpeg" /></figure><p><em>And such an investigation could potentially lead us to the holy rivers of Ganga and Yamuna at the Triveni sangam where the </em><a href="https://www.newsday.com/news/nation/india-maha-kumbh-hinduism-h32927"><strong><em>biggest religious gathering on earth is currently taking place, during the Maha Kumbh Mela</em></strong></a><em>, with an estimated 450 million devotees expected over the 45 days of festivities</em>! If this one large source of water, intimately in contact with millions of humans every day, is contaminated by C. jejuni and other dangerous triggering microbes for GBS, it could potentially account for the incredibly huge number of infections that is prerequisite to manifest as the rare outbreak of the uncommon GBS! Please know that <em>it usually takes </em><a href="https://academic.oup.com/jid/article/176/Supplement_2/S125/841642"><em>more than a thousand C.jejuni infections to trigger one GBS case!</em></a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/782/1*O6nkd96PfrJ2XZMqTHj9JA.jpeg" /></figure><p>It is interesting to note that in one of the rare reports of a <a href="https://www.bmj.com/content/bmj/1/6115/751.full.pdf">GBS outbreak following water contamination in Jordan in 1978</a>, of the 30,000 people exposed to polluted water, 5000 developed diarrhea and this triggered an outbreak of just 16 cases of GBS! <strong><em>Hence, it stands to reason that tens of lakhs of Indians must have been exposed to the polluted source of water, for lakhs to be infected, and for us to now witness this outbreak of nearly 160 reported cases across India</em>;</strong> and that again points to the huge gathering of people at the holy waters for the Maha Kumbha Mela.</p><p>It did make sense for our health authorities to first conduct local tests in Pune, which currently has the biggest cluster of cases. And local water contamination could be an added reason why Pune is seeing such a concentrated surge in specific locations. But we certainly should not stop there. Especially since t<em>he tests of the </em><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/inconclusive-water-tests-deepen-gbs-mystery-pune-tally-rises-to-130/articleshow/117758161.cms"><em>local water sources in Pune have not yet produced any conclusive findings, and have, in fact tested negative for C. jejuni,</em></a> which was isolated from the stools of the affected patients.</p><p>While concentrating on Pune, it is also important to note that there was a particularly large <a href="https://www.freepressjournal.in/pune/pune-witnesses-surge-in-travel-demand-for-maha-kumbh-mela-in-prayagraj">influx of devotees from Pune to the Kumbh Mela.</a></p><p>While the NIV (National Institute of Virology) scientists are now rightly contemplating detailed studies of <em>the strain of C.jejuni</em>, please let us not overlook the glaring possibility that at this particular time period, the very rare outbreak of a rare disease that could potentially have originated at a contaminated water source large enough to infect millions of people, need us to take a clear-eyed and scientifically curious look at the vast waters of the rivers Ganga and Yamuna during the ongoing Maha Kumbh Mela.</p><p>Apart from the current urgency, preventative testing of the waters at the Maha Kumbh Mela for fecal contamination and pathological microbes like C.jejuni should anyway be mandatory, considering the <a href="https://www.downtoearth.org.in/water/mahakumbh-2025-unaware-of-water-quality-at-prayagraj-25-million-devotees-took-holy-dip-in-ganga"><strong><em>very high risk</em></strong></a> posed to the millions of devotees coming in contact with those waters. It is good to know that the authorities are already doing <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/allahabad/maha-kumbh-2025-daily-water-testing-removal-of-pooja-waste-among-measures-to-keep-ganga-dip-safe/articleshow/117516138.cms">daily water cleaning and testing</a> during the Mela.</p><p>Though, even with the most valiant efforts of the authorities, is it logistically possible to expect <a href="https://www.weforum.org/stories/2019/08/these-are-the-challenges-facing-india-s-most-sacred-river/">the waters of Ganga</a> and Yamuna to be safe for humans while catering to the needs of additional millions of attendees at festivals like the Maha Kumbh Mela? Statistics suggest otherwise: “However, sewage management still remains a major challenge (during Maha Kumbh Mela). Statistics suggest that if the government does not convert its promises into action, over <strong>50 MLD (50 Million Liters per Day)</strong> of <strong>untreated sewage</strong> will flow into the Ganga daily, <a href="https://www.downtoearth.org.in/governance/with-45-million-devotees-seeking-holy-bath-at-maha-kumbh-heres-how-administration-seeks-to-ensure-that-ganga-is-dip-safe"><strong><em>forcing devotees to take a dip in contaminated water</em></strong>.”</a></p><p>More importantly, even if the waters might be ‘dip-safe’, is it <strong><em>‘sip-safe’</em></strong>? It is a matter of concern <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/varanasi/ganga-water-declared-drinkable-thanks-to-pm-modis-namami-gange-project-yogi-adityanath/articleshow/115342183.cms">that political leaders have assured Indians that the water of Ganga is now </a>safe for drinking, even while <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/varanasi/ngt-advises-varanasi-dm-to-declare-ganga-water-unsafe-for-bathing-and-drinking/articleshow/115442821.cms"><strong><em>the National Green Tribunal (NGT) was in favour of the water being declared unsafe for bathing and drinking</em></strong></a>. It is certainly very concerning that, with political and <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=esPRe3ESgGA">religious leaders vehemently extolling the nurturing virtues of the waters of Ganga</a>, most devotees consider it pure and holy and drink it joyfully without question. Devotees are even known to <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OyGWN-8XoOo">collect water from the sangam site</a> and take it back home for future use and for family and friends who cannot make the pilgrimage.</p><p>All these factors together make it<strong><em> absolutely necessary to prioritize testing the waters at Maha Kumbh Mela as the potential site of origin of water contamination in this current outbreak of GBS</em></strong>, before we move to consider other sources! The waters should be tested for fecal/sewage contamination and specifically for C. jejuni, norovirus and other microbes that could trigger GBS.</p><p>Along with the testing of the water, collecting detailed clinical history from the patients might help us to conclusively crack the mystery of this rare GBS outbreak. The data collected should include:</p><p>1. The patient’s travel history for the past two months. Places visited; suspect food and water consumed; whether they have been in contact with any river waters, and specifically if they have been to the Maha Kumbh Mela or taken bath in the holy rivers, Ganga or Yamuna? Please know that even relatively unpolluted <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6881791/">rivers can have high loads of <strong><em>C.jejuni from the excreta of wildlife, especially wild birds.</em></strong></a></p><p>2. Has the patient consumed water collected from the holy rivers anytime in the past 2 months? Do they have ganga water stored in their homes? This is very important to know since even devotees who cannot travel to attend festivals like the Maha Kumbh Mela are known to get water collected from the holy rivers and brought back to their homes. And it is also common practice among Indians to order home holy <a href="https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/news/now-have-holy-water-of-maha-kumbh-delivered-at-your-doorstep/article69076277.ece">ganga jal(water) through online sites</a>.</p><p>It is also very important to understand that while GBS itself is neither infectious or contagious (meaning it won’t spread from the patient to another person), the infections that trigger GBS, like C.jejuni or Norovirus gastroenteritis, certainly are. Hence, a pertinent point to be considered while taking history from patients is this highly contagious nature of the infections like <a href="https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/15251-campylobacter-infection"><em>C.jejuni</em></a> &amp; <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/norovirus/prevention/outdoor-camping.html"><em>norovirus</em></a>. They can easily spread from person to person by fecal-oral (from patient’s stools to another person) route or contact with contaminated surfaces, especially in crowded places and public toilets. This poses significant public threat if the affected person doesn’t maintain strict hygiene, like washing hands thoroughly after using bathrooms, and especially so if they are involved in public service, or handles food or water for others. Hence, it needs to be stressed that the patient who had the unfortunate autoimmune reaction to the infection that triggered GBS in them might not have any direct connection with Maha Kumbh Mela or gangajal, yet, the question still needs to be asked if they are aware of anyone in their contact group who had been to the Kumbh, and especially if any such contact had a history of gastroenteritis.</p><p>If the water tests at multiple river and camp sites of the Maha Kumbh Mela are negative for fecal coliforms, C. jejuni, enteric viruses and other GBS triggering pathological microbes, and if the clinical history from all the GBS affected patients conclusively prove that none of them had any contact with the holy waters or people returning from Kumbh in the preceding weeks, (<a href="https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/conditions-and-diseases/guillainbarr-syndrome"><strong><em>GBS symptoms can appear from 3 days to 6 weeks after the triggering infection</em></strong></a><strong>)</strong>, then we can certainly divert our resources to look for other/local sources of water or food contamination.</p><p>But, first, please let us not commit the egregious mistake of not even considering the waters at Maha Kumbh Mela as the potential source of contamination in this GBS outbreak. It will be tantamount to wilful and wanton negligence. And Indian doctors and scientists should be better than that.</p><p>I hope our public health personnel and institutions make note of this alert and take the necessary steps to keep our people safe from more cases of GBS, and other dangerous water-borne diseases like typhoid, during this festival season.</p><p>May our festivals and pilgrimages bring us peace, joy and health.</p><p><strong>Updates:</strong></p><p><strong><em>February 1</em></strong>:</p><p>One death in Guwahati, <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/girl-dies-in-guwahati-first-suspected-gbs-death-in-assam/articleshow/117830412.cms?from=mdr"><strong>Assam</strong></a><strong>.</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.livemint.com/science/health/28-people-on-ventilator-in-maharashtra-as-guillain-barre-syndrome-cases-increase-to-149-death-toll-at-5-11738417592858.html?fbclid=IwY2xjawILPxJleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHdOlE697KoAUhGVRliXlGhEDEgN7Bz1SwEtGjyUqRw14oZVzMieJCsKY6Q_aem_2N1fBMLdz8CKd04K5jOyoQ"><strong>Five deaths in Maharashtra</strong></a>, with 28 people on ventilator, and 149 cases.</p><p><strong><em>February 3</em></strong>:</p><p>Second case in <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/guwahati/2nd-guillain-barre-syndrome-case-reported-in-assam-teen-critical/articleshow/117865888.cms"><strong>Assam</strong></a>- 17 year old critical</p><p>Child <a href="https://lalluram.com/guillain-barre-syndrome-death-10-people-died-in-4-states-of-india-5-in-maharashtra-and-3-in-west-bengal/">died of GBS in Jaipur, <strong>Rajasthan</strong></a> on January 28.</p><p>Second case in <a href="https://www.dailypioneer.com/2025/state-editions/another-suspected-case-of-gbs-found-in-state.html"><strong>Jharkhand</strong></a>.</p><p>Cases reported in <a href="https://www.facebook.com/reel/1214483276768866">Ahilya nagar</a>, Maharashtra.</p><p>Cases in <a href="https://www.news18.com/india/guillain-barre-syndrome-five-cases-detected-tally-rises-to-163-9213531.html">Pune rise to 163</a>.</p><p><strong><em>February 5</em></strong>:</p><p>10 year old child dies in Tiruvallur District of <a href="https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/chennai/10-year-old-boy-diagnosed-with-gbs-dies-health-officials-allay-fears/article69184329.ece"><strong>Tamil Nadu</strong></a>.</p><p>Another case in <a href="https://x.com/airnews_kolkata/status/1887149871372570871">Kolkata</a>, <strong>West Bengal</strong>.</p><p>More cases in <strong>Maharashtra, beyond Pune</strong>. Two children diagnosed in <a href="https://marathi.abplive.com/news/nandurbar/guillain-barre-syndrome-two-children-in-nandurbar-infected-with-gbs-after-pune-solapur-one-in-critical-condition-maharashtra-marathi-news-1342660">Nandurbar, Khandesh</a>.</p><p><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/jaipur/7-cases-of-gbs-identified-in-sikars-ringus-area-in-10-days/articleshow/117958723.cms">7 cases identified in Sikar, <strong>Rajasthan</strong></a> in last 10 days.</p><p>3 cases in Gurugram, <a href="https://www.business-standard.com/health/2-suspected-gbs-cases-from-delhi-ncr-region-admitted-in-jaipur-125020501642_1.html"><strong>Delhi NCR</strong></a>.</p><p>Third case in <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ranchi/garhwa-health-dept-on-alert-for-gbs/articleshow/117958624.cms"><strong>Jharkhand</strong></a>.</p><p>Maharashtra caseload rise to 173 with one more patient dead, taking the total count of <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/maharashtra-gbs-cases-total-cases-update-deaths-discharged-patients-ventilator-support-2675873-2025-02-06">fatalities in Maharashtra alone to 6</a>.</p><p><strong><em>February 9</em></strong>:</p><p><a href="https://www.facebook.com/amitava.banerjee/posts/pfbid02JG6QbqkNuViZNBm9Y2KupbN2VP4KZoPf6ChQyZiQQvcX6pEH42NLm6LD6Ycvg7nil?comment_id=595281060136886&amp;reply_comment_id=2063165307465647&amp;notif_id=1738901105602327&amp;notif_t=comment_mention&amp;ref=notif">7 cases diagnosed in Cooch Behar, <strong>West Bengal</strong></a>!</p><p>Maharashtra cases rise to <a href="https://www.indiatvnews.com/maharashtra/gbs-outbreak-total-tally-in-maharashtra-rises-above-180-several-patients-on-ventilator-pune-mumbai-2025-02-09-975468">184 with</a> one case in <strong>Mumbai.</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.etvbharat.com/en/!state/25-yr-old-woman-dies-of-suspected-gbs-in-siddipet-first-case-in-telangana-enn25020903338">25 year old mother dies in<strong> Telangana</strong></a>. First fatality of GBS in Telangana State.</p><p><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/docs-see-unusually-high-cases-of-diarrhoea-in-affected-areas/articleshow/117993585.cms">Pune doctors report unusually high numbers of diarrhea</a> cases in GBS affected areas.</p><p><strong><em>February 11</em></strong>:</p><p>Pune caseload rises to <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/pune-adds-five-more-guillain-barr-syndrome-cases-patient-count-now-at-197-more-than-100-people-discharged/articleshow/118155811.cms">197</a>, with another death taking fatalities here to 7.</p><p><a href="https://www.siasat.com/what-is-gbs-that-caused-a-death-in-hyderabad-doctors-explain-3176321/">Three cases</a> in <strong>Telangana</strong>.</p><p>25 year old in hospital at <a href="https://x.com/i_am_mr_right_/status/1889364708643447123?t=9yGuGGHKhiV23GAAGTOTzg&amp;s=08">Raipur, <strong>Chhattisgarh</strong></a>.</p><p>“If we look at the accepted prevalence data (the numbers of people we think get GBS each year), the number who would need to be impacted in order to see this level of GBS cases is around <a href="https://gaincharity.org.uk/gbs-mass-occurrence-in-pune/">16,000,000.” GAIN charity article</a> stating the incredible number of impacted people needed to create an outbreak of 160 cases- 16 Million! Another pointer to the huge crowds at the contaminated waters of Maha Kumbh Mela 2025.</p><p><a href="https://thenewzradar.com/health-lifestyle/himachal-sees-rise-in-viral-infection-cases-as-maha-kumbh-devotees-return-home-hospitals-feel-pressure-too-2/?fbclid=IwY2xjawIbBZNleHRuA2FlbQIxMQABHfyhYrQ98JBXjcjVCChWFEP_RzQyQAcAMrvrnq0fhiTEXtCUIWuGfwzXDA_aem_LUOdr2oK_-fgHGZXVHv8Cg"><strong>Himachal Pradesh</strong> sees rise in viral infections </a>as Kumbh Mela devotees return home.</p><p><strong><em>February 12</em></strong>:</p><p>Caseload rise to <a href="https://www.etvbharat.com/en/!state/59-year-old-gbs-patient-dies-in-pune-death-toll-rises-enn25021206275"><strong>203 </strong>in Maharashtra. One more death in Pune</a> taking fatalities there to 8.</p><p>At least <a href="https://www.mumbailive.com/en/health/13-year-old-girl-infected-with-gbs-in-mumbai-87713">3 cases in <strong>Mumbai</strong>, Maharashtra. First fatality in Mumbai</a>, taking total reported deaths from GBS in Maharashtra to 9.</p><p>First reported<a href="https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/india/guillain-barr-syndrome-outbreak-andhra-pradesh-reports-first-death-state-on-high-alert-12939424.html"> death in the state of <strong>Andhra Pradesh</strong></a>. 10 year old boy</p><p>Patient in <a href="https://www.facebook.com/jessy.skaria.2006/posts/pfbid0FnUzFKXoh7Gm9vkS9n7JR96FtHtEYFvj2Y6xzpvZQVbUm9Ghun4h3xXGsRbfkcBjl">Kolkata, <strong>West Bengal</strong></a>.</p><p><strong><em>February 14:</em></strong></p><p><a href="https://www.etvbharat.com/en/!state/kolhapur-reports-first-guillain-barre-syndrome-death-amid-rising-cases-in-maharashtra-enn25021403254">One fatality and 8 cases in one hospital in<strong> Kohlapur,</strong></a><strong> Maharashtra</strong>. Death toll in Maharashtra alone now stands at 10. Total reported caseload in Maharashtra stands at 205.</p><p><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/vijayawada/gbs-outbreak-andhra-pradesh-reports-5-cases-of-guillain-barr-syndrome-2-critical/articleshow/118238744.cms"><strong>Andhra Pradesh</strong> reports 5 cases</a>.</p><p><strong><em>February 19:</em></strong></p><p><a href="https://x.com/WebduniaMarathi/status/1890729936324825137">Two deaths in <strong>Nagpur</strong></a><strong>, Maharashtra</strong>.</p><p><a href="https://belgaum.pro/two-from-belagavi-district-suspected-to-have-died-from-guillain-barre-syndrome-in-maharashtra/">Two deaths of people from <strong>Belagavi, Karnataka</strong>.</a></p><p>Rising cases in Maharashtra <a href="https://newskarnataka.com/health/guillain-barre-syndrome-cases-surge-in-maharashtra-two-from-belagavi-succumb/19022025/">outside of Pune. <strong>Sangli</strong> has 16 cases and two deaths. <strong>Kolhapur </strong>has 21 cases and 3 deaths.</a></p><p><strong>Important Update</strong>:</p><p>From my collected data on GBS cases and fatalities all over India (given above), to date, there are likely <strong>148 cases and 10 deaths in India, in states other than Maharashtra</strong>. This is over and above the reported <strong>211 cases and 11 deaths recorded in Maharashtra.</strong></p><p>Hence, if our Health department was vigilant enough to make GBS a nationally notifiable disease when the spike was first noticed in the second half of January, this outbreak would now have recorded <strong>at least 359 cases and 21 deaths!</strong></p><p><strong><em>I fear the unreported cases and fatalities may outnumber this data by the hundreds!</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Very Important Update Feb 24: Fecal contamination of Kumbh Waters proven by CPCB testing! My hypothesis now has solid, data-driven proof.</em></strong></p><p>I consider the February 19th <strong>National Green Tribunal, </strong><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/high-levels-of-fecal-bacteria-in-sangam-waters-at-maha-kumbh-report/articleshow/118369524.cms"><strong>NGT</strong>, report of <strong><em>high fecal contamination of Kumbh waters</em></strong></a><strong><em> with human and animal excreta</em></strong> as clear proof that my hypothesis connecting this unusual GBS outbreak in India to the Maha Kumbh Mela, where crores of Indians have been dipping and sipping fecal contaminated waters, is entirely correct!</p><p>Since this report, by the highest environmental tribunal of India, is based on <a href="http://103.7.181.103:4000/"><strong><em>DATA submitted by an Indian government agency, The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB)</em></strong></a> I was naïve enough to think that Indians and Indian authorities would also consider this as an <strong>urgent public health threat, </strong>issue urgent alerts to the imminently at-risk populace, and <em>hence my work is done</em>.</p><p>Alas! Based on my experience with mucormycosis research, I should have been prepared for the unbelievable obfuscations from government entities, so-called scientists, shame-on-their profession doctors, and blind Indian believers!</p><p><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/sangam-water-fit-for-drinking-bid-to-defame-kumbh-yogi-adityanath/articleshow/118398066.cms">The Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh, the key organizer of Kumbh Mela, blindly trashed the report and reiterated his authoritative assertion that Ganga water is good enough to drink</a>!</p><p>A <a href="https://www.etvbharat.com/en/!bharat/amid-maha-kumbh-padma-shri-scientist-dr-ajay-sonkar-defends-gangajal-purity-for-drinking-with-daring-experiment-enn25022401892"><em>Padma Shri awardee scientist, Dr. Ajay Sonkar led the charge</em></a>, and came out with his lab findings on the amazing capabilities of bacteriophages in Ganga that kill all harmful bacteria in its water, and apparently even drank the Ganga water to prove his point. Not to anyone’s surprise, his claims were given so much publicity that every Indian now probably know of it.</p><p>Not to be left out of favor, <a href="https://www.etvbharat.com/en/!bharat/amid-prayagraj-maha-kumbh-cpcb-report-questions-gangajal-purity-experts-rubbish-claims-enn25022202182">multiple scientists from top-tier universities of India </a>came out to stress the Kumbh waters are perfectly safe for the devotees.</p><p>Even <a href="https://www.msn.com/en-xl/news/other/water-of-river-ganga-forms-phage-kills-faecal-coliform-bhu-professor-after-pollution-board-raises-concern-in-ongoing-mahakumbh/ar-AA1zysKV">Indian doctors, including neurology professors</a> of prominent standing, as Prof. Vijay Nath Mishra, HOD of Neurology, BHU, came out swinging to defend the waters of Ganga!</p><p>Though, some <a href="https://thehindustangazette.com/national/uttar-pradesh/doctors-warn-of-fecal-bacteria-in-ganga-water-at-mahakumbh-mela-33707">good doctors and social media handles have also issued warnings of increased risk of water borne infections in Kumbh devotees,</a> it is drowned deep in the propaganda urging devotees it is perfectly safe to dip and sip in the waters.</p><p>And the<a href="https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/lucknow/a-week-left-a-sudden-surge-in-footfall-at-kumbh-9845522/"> crowds, fully restored in faith that no diseases can spread from the holy waters of Kumbh, keep surging</a> for the last days of the Maha Kumbh!</p><p>What more can I say in the face of so much academic, political and faith-based resistance?</p><p>But, giving up is not an option for me, since the majority of Indians suffering the ill-consequences are not the wealthy, educated Indians, who are the torchbearers of this propaganda, but the poorest of poor, their only information coming from mass propaganda, and whose lives are totally destroyed by an unexpected medical emergency like Guillain-Barre syndrome! There should be someone on their side too, trying to disseminate facts for no charge. And so I will; and wait - for the day when truth finally trickles down to the ground level.</p><p>Meanwhile the cases and deaths are piling up.</p><p>As of today, according to <a href="https://x.com/SanjayJog7/status/1894063085754720449">Public health data from <strong>Pune</strong>/Maharashtra alone</a>, the <strong>cases stand at 217</strong>, with <strong>11 fatalities.</strong> While there is no other official data for the state of Maharashtra, or other Indian States, <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/2-more-gbs-deaths-take-pune-toll-to-11-india-count-hits-23/articleshow/118397668.cms">the <strong>Maharashtra death count is supposed to be 19</strong>, and the <strong>Indian toll is supposed to be 23</strong>, as on Feb 20.</a></p><p>This, in all probability, is still a<strong> massive undercount.</strong></p><p>Since no other states have come out with any kind of daily surveillance, I still depend on random print and online reports to collect my data.</p><p><strong>Andhra Pradesh</strong> had <a href="https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/other/andhra-government-takes-steps-to-stock-up-on-immunoglobulin/ar-AA1zfY0C?apiversion=v2&amp;noservercache=1&amp;domshim=1&amp;renderwebcomponents=1&amp;wcseo=1&amp;batchservertelemetry=1&amp;noservertelemetry=1"><strong>43 cases in January</strong></a>, and apparently has <a href="https://suryaa.com/ap-english-7564-andhra-pradesh-reports-fifth-death-due-to-guillain-barre-syndrome-health-dept-on-high-alert.html">17–18 cases now, with <strong>5 deaths</strong> reported.</a> This is likely very conservative reporting since just <a href="https://www.etvbharat.com/en/!bharat/tirupati-hospital-registers-12-gbs-cases-enn25022402047">one hospital in <strong>Tirupati alone has reported 17 cases</strong> in February, with 12</a> currently under treatment.</p><p><a href="https://www.newsbytesapp.com/news/india/fourth-suspected-gbs-death-in-bengal-this-year/story"><strong>West Bengal has reported one more death</strong></a>, but has given no case status, except saying there are ‘stray cases’ throughout the year! A scary attitude to take during a suspected outbreak from a public health point of view!</p><p><a href="https://www.msn.com/en-in/health/other/karnataka-on-alert-for-guillain-barr%C3%A9-syndrome-gbs-after-rise-in-diarrhoeal-cases/ar-AA1z7t8S?apiversion=v2&amp;noservercache=1&amp;domshim=1&amp;renderwebcomponents=1&amp;wcseo=1&amp;batchservertelemetry=1&amp;noservertelemetry=1"><strong>Karnataka health minister ‘acknowledged a few cases</strong></a>’, but assured ‘there is no outbreak’!! This while they admit <em>30–35 cases were reported in January!</em></p><p><strong><em>Update Feb 28</em></strong>:</p><p>Outbreak reported in <a href="https://x.com/SANewsRajasthan/status/1895177826481119405"><strong>Jodhpur, Rajasthan</strong></a> by multiple local media! <a href="https://x.com/JessySkaria/status/1895507742309413122">Total silence from mainstream media!</a></p><p>According to local sources, <a href="https://earlydaynews.com/gbs-virus-ke-jodhpur-me-case-badhe/?amp=1"><strong><em>3–5 new cases are being reported dail</em></strong></a><strong><em>y</em></strong>! And <a href="https://www.patrika.com/en/special-news/rajasthan-virus-outbreak-breathing-difficulties-reported-in-half-of-patients-19429857"><strong><em>over 50 cases</em></strong> have been reported in just this <strong>one city in Rajasthan</strong> over the past <strong><em>15–20 days</em></strong>!</a> This is so reminiscent of the notorious “Pune Outbreak” which is still ongoing! But since the enthusiastic supporters of “Pune GBS outbreak traced to contamination of local water sources in Pune, and not due to Maha Kumbh waters” will find it difficult to attribute this Jodhpur outbreak to Pune waters situated 1098 kilometers away, I think their absolute silence is understandable! A travesty on honest journalism and public health surveillance!</p><p>Meanwhile <a href="https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/2025/Feb/28/kerala-reports-second-guillain-barr%C3%A9-syndrome-death-in-a-week?fbclid=IwY2xjawIu2zFleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHWrZYCh0zm9-_CxRzLH5aBq5v5snS8kOUAKIkfKl-ZItEvwUHKHQIr19vg_aem_2IRj0g7PHgtSOYNxu9Wg4g"><strong><em>Kerala has reported two deaths f</em></strong>rom GBS.</a> Both cases have been admitted in hospital for weeks. I am surprised even Kerala didn’t report these cases while the Pune outbreak captured the headlines. And they haven’t yet provided any update on how many GBS cases are currently under treatment in hospitals, except for vague reports like, “there has been <a href="https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/2025/Mar/01/two-deaths-in-four-days-raise-concerns-of-guillain-barr%C3%A9-syndrome-outbreak"><strong>a noticeable increase in the number of cases reported in the state</strong></a>, with patients seeking treatment at both government and private hospitals”!</p><p><strong><em>Update March 1:</em></strong></p><p><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/2-more-gbs-cases-take-patient-tally-reaches-221-in-pune-30-still-in-icus/articleshow/118636459.cms"><strong>Pune/Maharashtra alone has 221 cases and 11 deaths</strong></a>. Even from the data collected by me, this is an undercount, especially for the cases reported from ‘<strong>other districts</strong>’! (My data given above, from Sangli, Kolhapur, Nagpur, Satara, Ahilya Nagar, Mumbai, Jalgaon and Nandurbar will come to<strong><em> 67 cases and 8 deaths in the ‘other districts</em></strong>’, much higher than the officially reported 14 cases and 1 death in Mumbai!) But, since Maharashtra is the only state that has been providing government data, for official purposes, I will continue using that.</p><p>Accounting for only the <strong><em>reported data across India </em></strong>(meaning <strong><em>not including</em></strong> the intangible ‘few’, ‘sporadic’, ‘usual’ ‘noticeable increase’ mantras of doctors and media eager to establish ‘all’s well’ and the excess in Maharashtra’s ‘other districts!) , this<strong> GBS outbreak now stands at 510 cases and 31 deaths!</strong></p><p>Since crowds have, in all likelihood, continued contracting triggering infections till the Maha Kumbh Mela concluded on February 26, <strong><em>India can expect to see spikes of </em></strong><a href="https://www.neurology.org/doi/10.1212/WNL.0000000000011342"><strong><em>new cases at least till end of March, with a declining trend into the first half of April </em></strong></a>, because GBS is known to present anytime between <a href="https://www.hopkinsmedicine.org/health/conditions-and-diseases/guillainbarr-syndrome"><strong><em>3 days to 6 weeks after the triggering infection.</em></strong></a></p><p><strong>A tragic and unpardonable failure of public health!</strong></p><p><strong><em>March 7</em></strong>: In <a href="https://www.punekarnews.in/gbs-138-water-sources-in-pune-found-contaminated-amid-guillain-barre-syndrome-outbreak/">Pune, out of 7195 water samples tested, 138 have been found to be contaminated with E.coli and other coliforms</a>, thus increasing the chances of water borne infections locally too. Safe drinking water should be made a priority for all citizens of Pune, and India, to prevent water-borne infections at all times.</p><p><strong><em>Update March 9</em></strong>: Direct connection of a <a href="https://www.inextlive.com/uttar-pradesh/allahabad/children-affected-by-deadly-gbs-two-serious-1741459424"><strong>GBS case to Maha Kumbh reported in media.</strong></a></p><p>Till now, I had only <a href="https://x.com/Aazameins/status/1891843336572383343"><em>social media posts connecting Kumbh returnees and GBS cases</em></a>. For the first time, now a media has reported on a child in <strong><em>Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh,</em></strong> suffering from GBS after going to the Maha Kumbh Mela. This strengthens my hypothesis further.</p><p>Now that Maha Kumbh Mela is over, more evidence of GBS surges in January, February and March are coming to the fore, being reported by doctors and media in states other than Maharashtra.</p><p><strong>March 9</strong>: A case in <a href="https://www.tv9hindi.com/india/after-maharashtra-a-case-of-guillain-barre-syndrome-found-in-noida-government-on-alert-3162717.html"><strong><em>Noida, Uttar Pradesh</em></strong></a>.</p><p><strong>March 10</strong>: <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/jaipur/surge-in-guillain-barr-syndrome-cases-at-sms-hospital/articleshow/118825231.cms"><strong><em>Surge in GBS cases reported in SMS hospital, </em>Jaipur, Rajasthan<em>! 29 cases with 2 fatalities in the past two months!! </em></strong></a>In one hospital in a large state like Rajasthan! Remember, <a href="https://x.com/1stIndiaNewsRaj/status/1896796754840064181"><strong><em>Jodhpur, another city in Rajasthan</em></strong></a> has also reported this surge, by February 28!</p><p><strong>March 11</strong>: <em>For the past one month GBS cases are coming continuously to the leading doctors of the city.</em> <a href="https://www.bhaskar.com/local/mp/sagar/news/this-is-the-situation-after-5-years-134629573.html"><strong><em>Report from Sagar, Madhya Pradesh</em></strong></a>! Doctors seeing <strong>four times increase in GBS patients</strong>!</p><p><strong>March 18:</strong> <a href="https://www.bhaskar.com/local/rajasthan/bikaner/news/the-number-of-patients-with-guillain-barre-syndrome-has-increased-134668498.html"><strong><em>Bikaner, Rajasthan</em></strong></a> — more than one patient every day in one hospital! More than 30 cases per month! Meaning <em>more than 100 patients in this time of 2025 alone!</em></p><p><strong>March 21</strong>: A 14 year old boy <strong>died</strong> in Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar (Aurangabad), and that brought forward <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/aurangabad/14-year-old-boy-dies-of-gbs-in-sambhajinagar/articleshow/119270291.cms"><strong><em>stats that district alone had 28 cases of GBS in 2025</em></strong>.</a></p><p>Remember, Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar is one of the “other districts”, other than Pune, in Maharashtra official stats on GBS cases during this outbreak. And that <a href="https://x.com/SanjayJog7/status/1900524977545412658"><strong><em>Maharashtra official stats on March 14, the final one available, show that there are only 15 cases reported from all the “other districts”, other than Pune</em></strong>!</a> Imagine the burden of unreported GBS cases in India during this outbreak period!</p><p><strong>April 17</strong>: <a href="https://hindi.news18.com/news/rajasthan/jodhpur-this-virus-attacking-neuro-system-patient-risk-of-paralytic-attack-gbs-syndrome-rang-local18-ws-kl-9183326.html"><strong><em>More than 200 cases of GBS in Jodhpur alone in the first 3 months of 2025!</em></strong></a> One city in Rajasthan reporting more than 200 cases! Remember, during this same time period, <a href="https://x.com/SanjayJog7/status/1900524977545412658"><em>“the Pune Outbreak”, which captured world attention has only reported 215 cases from that city!</em></a></p><p><strong>I reiterate</strong>: If GBS was made <strong><em>a nationally notifiable disease</em></strong> when the surge was first noted in Pune, and a Rapid Response Team was formed in Pune on January 21, 2025, India, by now, would in all likelihood be reporting <strong>the biggest GBS outbreak ever documented in world history - with cases in the thousands,</strong> not hundreds!</p><p><strong>A massive failure of public health surveillance</strong>, not just by India, but by international health organizations like the<a href="https://www.who.int/india/news/feature-stories/detail/who-assists-response-to-guillain-barr--syndrome-in-pune"><strong><em> WHO, which was involved with the Pune GBS outbreak from the beginning</em></strong></a>!</p><p>If there is an honest will to understand the scale and epidemiology of this “GBS Epidemic”, the Indian government and international health organizations can still obtain, retrospectively, official data of all the GBS cases admitted in all the hospitals in India in the first quarter of 2025. But, the looming question is: <strong><em>Is there an honest will</em></strong>?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=608f488ed2a6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[“COVID-19, mucormycosis, and the Cow: Damned Lies!” — My rebuttal]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/covid-19-mucormycosis-and-the-cow-damned-lies-my-rebuttal-eda8203bcece?source=rss-41bcf97dda06------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/eda8203bcece</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jessy Skaria]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Sep 2023 18:16:50 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-10-06T17:51:35.800Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>“COVID-19, mucormycosis, and the Cow: Damned Lies!” — My rebuttal</h3><p><em>Holy Cow! Let’s indeed bust the Damned Lies!</em></p><p>“COVID-19, mucormycosis, and the cow: Damned lies!” is a <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0255085723000981">Guest Editorial</a> (hereinafter referred to as <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10208110/#:~:text=The%20rearing%20of%20cows%2C%20the,pandemic%20without%20any%20supporting%20data.">Damned Lies Editorial or DLE</a>) authored by three Indian researchers; one of them — Professor Arunaloke Chakrabarti — is widely considered the foremost mycologist of India. I read it with mounting sadness and horror. These are without doubt eminent physician scientists who have made significant contributions in their respective fields of practice. And yet, they felt compelled to pen this appalling, tabloid-level hit piece, and to pass it off as medical literature: <em>as an Editorial - no less! </em>I am convinced this was done in an attempt to muddy the reader’s mind — and to sully anyone attempting research into a topic (namely the potential bovine connection with mucormycosis) they would like wiped clean from all discussions on mucormycosis/‘black fungus’ or Covid Associated Mucormycosis (CAM) in the Indian context! All this in a likely desperate bid to serve a narrow political agenda!</p><p>As a co-author of the <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">published hypothesis on cow excreta and mucormycosis</a> (cited in the DLE as Reference 35), and the sole author of<a href="https://americankahani.com/perspectives/poor-health-neglected-dung-diseases-in-india-urgently-need-crucial-expert-attention/"> the article directly targeted</a> in the editorial as ‘based on personal biases and prejudices’ (DLE Reference 16), I responded with a <a href="https://authors.elsevier.com/a/1hh2Qv--5w2Eq">Letter to Editor (LTE)</a> of the medical journal that published this DLE — Elsevier’s Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology (IJMM). While my LTE attempted to refute the claims made in the Editorial and to challenge the attacks on my credibility, I could barely scratch the surface of the matter there, due to the the journal’s strict ‘300-word limit’ allowed for an LTE. Hence this piece: an attempt at systematically analyzing and rebutting every inaccuracy and falsehood published in the editorial. <strong>Where I make the case that it is <em>the Editorial</em> that is rife with “Damned Lies”</strong>.</p><p>It is long, <em>very long</em>, since their lies are interminable. But, I promise, it makes for interesting reading, and is well worth the time — for the medical expert and the lay person alike. For anyone interested in knowing the truth behind India’s mucormycosis crisis and the nightmarish Indian “Black Fungus”/CAM epidemic of 2021. Please bear with me.</p><p>And please, do read <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0255085723000981">the Damned Lies Editorial (DLE)</a> first.</p><p>A bit of background:</p><p>In the summer of 2021, at the height of the second Covid wave, India suffered a unique and unprecedented epidemic of mucormycosis (considered a rare invasive fungal infection), with <strong><em>official</em></strong> statistics clocking <a href="https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/51-775-cases-of-mucormycosis-black-fungus-reported-in-india-till-november-29-health-minister-2635865">51775 cases in the six months from May to November.</a> (The country stopped collecting and publishing these official numbers after November. <em>The reason? Your guess is as good as mine!</em>) Experts attributed this dreadful outbreak to a <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8222941/">combination of different factors</a>, the main ones being Covid, Diabetes, abuse of Steroids in the treatment of Covid, and the Environment. It is important to note that, in the entire duration of the Covid pandemic, no country (with the exception, perhaps, of <a href="https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/news/general/2008919/jewish-member-of-iranian-parliament-500-cases-of-black-fungus-in-iran.html">Iran</a>, which also had an outbreak of hundreds of cases of CAM) suffered to the degree that India did. In fact, <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2309-608X/7/8/641">India has always had (even pre-Covid) a highly disproportionate share (70–80%!)</a> of the global burden of mucormycosis. The obvious question that springs to mind is: <em>are there any India-specific factors that could account for this massively asymmetric concentration of mucormycosis in India?</em> The sudden, unique ‘black fungus’ surge in India during a viral pandemic further validated the likelihood of underlying, unexplored India-specific causative factors: aspects unique to the Indian way of life, the role of which increased even further during Covid time, resulting in the Indian epidemic of CAM. Prompted by the <a href="https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/india-news-cow-dung-therapy-cant-beat-covid-may-actually-trigger-black-fungus-warn-doctors/382652">warnings of a few sensible Indian doctors</a>, I was drawn to consider the role of cow excreta as the key differential factor for India — the prime “India-specific factor” responsible for its perennially skewed global share of mucormycosis. I based this on two well-known facts:</p><ul><li>Mucorales, the fungi causing Mucormycosis, are <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2309-608X/6/1/4"><strong><em>coprophilous or dung- loving</em></strong></a><em>,</em> and are abundantly present in herbivore dung.</li><li>No country uses herbivore dung, especially cow dung, as routinely, closely and intimately as <a href="https://www.cnbc.com/2015/12/28/cow-dung-patties-selling-like-hot-cakes-online-in-india.html">India</a>. (Iran, which also suffered a CAM outbreak, as mentioned earlier, shares a similar cultural and religious affinity to another herbivore excreta: <a href="https://a-z-animals.com/blog/donkey-poop-everything-youve-ever-wanted-to-know/">donkey dung</a>!)</li></ul><p>Close observations quickly helped me form multiple damning epidemiological correlations to potentially substantiate such an association. I kept posting about these exciting new observations on social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook, and <a href="https://countercurrents.org/2021/06/how-unique-regional-factors-collided-to-create-the-black-fungus-crisis-in-india-a-hypothesis/">they were also published in Countercurrents on June 13, 2021</a>. <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1410642514370084869?s=20">By July, 2021</a>, the aggregate interpretation of multiple observed facts led me to hypothesize that in addition to the physical use of cow excreta, <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1418067456707465219?s=20">the <strong>smoke from burning dung</strong></a> could also be responsible for India’s CAM epidemic. This was an <strong><em>entirely original hypothesis</em></strong>. Never before was smoke from burning animal dung ever considered as a vehicle for an infectious agent. I provided this novel hypothesis as much publicity as I could through social media, emails and <a href="https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/how-unique-regional-factors-collided-to-create-the-mucormycosis-crisis-in-india-a-hypothesis-5e95f8248e29">a Medium publication</a>, in order to try and spread the message. These efforts were also intended to engage experts and government/health organizations on the matter — and to hopefully get them to issue public advisories regarding the safe use of dung. Sadly, such efforts were ignored by most. Later, with the help of eminent co-authors, <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">these observations were published as a peer-reviewed hypothesis</a> in the reputed journal, <strong><em>mBio,</em></strong> from the American Society for Microbiology (ASM), on March 31, 2022. Many Indian media outlets subsequently provided extensive coverage for this published hypothesis.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HRlBgOVlp3kcU-rr.jpg" /><figcaption>Credit: <a href="https://scroll.in/article/1021265/cow-dung-was-likely-behind-the-black-fungus-epidemic-that-maimed-thousands-in-india-in-2021">scroll.in</a></figcaption></figure><p>From the time I first started exposing these compelling facts on social media, most <a href="https://twitter.com/raghurajs_hegde/status/1440275139887656974?s=20">Indian doctors</a> and many of their <a href="https://www.idsociety.org/multimedia/podcasts/Mucormycosis-The-Highly-Fatal-Fungal-Disease-Affecting-COVID-19-Patients-in-India/">international colleagues have pushed back hard</a> against this hypothesis. While academic narcissism and ego possibly had a role in this disdainful dismissal of the warnings from a female, non-practicing, Indian physician — a scientific nobody — commenting on a current Indian medical crisis from faraway USA, the core message was more sinister, and crystal clear: <em>fact or fiction, do not mess with the holy Indian cow!</em></p><p>The <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0255085723000981#bib22">Guest Editorial</a> — the DLE — by Drs. Valliappan Muthu, Ritesh Agarwal and Arunaloke Chakrabarti, filled with lies, misrepresentations and cover-ups, is the latest strike in an ongoing series of attempts to discredit <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">our hypothesis</a>.</p><p>And this is my answer to them: a point-by-point rebuttal of their arguments — countering their lies, damned lies and statistical lies.</p><p><strong>Their Case Against our hypothesis:</strong></p><p>In the <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0255085723000981#bib22">Damned Lies Editorial (DLE)</a>, this can be summarized into <strong>four principal Damned Lies</strong> the authors try to propagate, in addition to innumerable subsidiary fabrications employed to substantiate those main lies.</p><p>The four principal damned lies in the DLE are:</p><p>1. India did <strong><em>not</em></strong><em> </em>have a unique Covid-Associated Mucormycosis (CAM) epidemic. It was a worldwide phenomenon. And hence looking for ‘India-specific factors’ is not warranted.</p><p>2. Host factors, like Diabetes, Steroids and Covid are the critical causative factors in CAM and need to be focused on doggedly, while environmental factors can be ignored, especially since the Mucorales fungi are considered ubiquitous.</p><p>3. The hypothesis on the role of cow and its excreta in India’s CAM epidemic is a damned lie. Hence any research into it is a waste of time, resources and efforts.</p><p>4. All the debate on the role of cow excreta in India’s CAM epidemic started with a viral morphed article, and hence all such ‘misinformation’ is Damned Lies.</p><p><strong>My rebuttal of each of the above lies propounded in the Damned Lies Editorial (DLE) follows:</strong></p><p><strong><em>Principal DLE Lie #1</em></strong>: <em>India did not have a unique Covid-Associated Mucormycosis (CAM) epidemic. It was a worldwide phenomenon. And hence looking for ‘India-specific factors’ is not warranted.</em></p><p><strong><em>My rebuttal:</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Is India’s CAM epidemic comparable to that of other countries?</em></strong></p><p>The answer is an emphatic No.</p><p>I do not understand why this is even a subject of debate. It was out there — for all the world to see. When the Indian CAM epidemic was underway, the horrors of the Covid pandemic had paled in comparison to <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/20/world/asia/india-covid-black-fungus.html">the grim ‘black fungus’ epidemic in India</a>. It made global headlines, and was a nightmare the other countries wished to be spared, and mostly were!</p><p>But here we have ‘experts’ dangling statistics in an ugly attempt at revising history and to show that the CAM <strong>epidemic</strong> was a <em>worldwide phenomenon (hence also affecting India) </em>that occurred during the global COVID pandemic. Therefore, according to them, what warrants maximum focused research is the role of Covid in the CAM epidemic, and not any India-specific factors as suggested in our hypothesis.</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>While an uncommon invasive infection, an </em><strong><em>epidemic</em></strong><em> of mucormycosis occurred following the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic worldwide, especially in India [2,3]”</em></p><p>By definition, “an epidemic is the rapid spread of a disease to a large number of hosts in a given population within a short period of time”.</p><p>Agreed that CAM cases were reported worldwide. But, an epidemic of mucormycosis<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10168193/">, with 51775 officially reported cases in 6 months, happened only in India</a>! There was certainly no worldwide epidemic of mucormycosis following Covid pandemic, as the DLE states. That is a damned lie! The one other country that mimicked India’s crisis, but still to a much smaller scale, was <a href="https://irannewswire.org/iran-has-run-out-of-black-fungus-medication/">Iran, which also unofficially reported hundreds</a> of CAM cases in a similar short span of time. And these are the two countries focused on in <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">our hypothesis</a> as affected by excessive cultural/medicinal use of herbivore dung and its fumes (Cow dung in India and Female Donkey dung — <a href="https://brieflands.com/articles/jjnpp-66668.html">anbarnesa</a> — in Iran)<em> </em>during Covid time: when their populations were extremely vulnerable to Invasive Fungal Infections (IFIs) due to Covid and its attendant treatment with steroids.</p><p>It is this unprecedented Indian CAM epidemic that alerted physicians globally to the possibility of increased mucormycosis cases associated with Covid in their own countries. This observation is noted in almost all academic papers on CAM, as in <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8662289/">this study</a> from Germany, referenced (54) in the DLE: “<em>Early on during the pandemic, the awareness for COVID‐19‐associated aspergillosis was high due to the already known association of aspergillosis and severe influenza. COVID‐19‐associated mucormycosis (CAM) gained worldwide attention in early 2021, during the second wave of the COVID‐19 pandemic in India, where high number of COVID‐19 cases, overuse of corticosteroids for treatment even of mild COVID‐19, high incidence of diabetes without glycaemic control, and an overall high count of Mucorales spores indoors and outdoors have been proposed to be main drivers. The unprecedented surge of cases with CAM became a major healthcare issue with strongly increased prevalence over months. </em><strong><em>Of course, this also put infectious diseases physicians in other regions on alert</em>.”</strong></p><p>It is this seismic Indian CAM epidemic that the DLE wants equated with the modest uptick in CAM in other countries, so that no one goes looking for inconvenient “India-specific factors” like cow dung!</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>The widespread perception of CAM as an exclusively Indian problem was fuelled by misleading articles and news items, which led to the proposal of several ‘</em><a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22"><em>India-specific’ risk factors [35]</em></a><em>. Unfortunately, it is a myth that CAM occurred only in India</em>.”</p><p>(Please note the use of ‘<em>CAM’</em> instead of ‘<em>CAM epidemic’</em> by the authors in this quote, unlike the previous one. Throughout the DLE, there are multiple instances of similar literary gymnastics where the DLE authors try to stay technically correct in their wording, while in reality, their damned lies are meant to create the wrong impression in the reader’s mind. <strong><em>The truth hidden in the above two DLE quotes is that while CAM cases were indeed worldwide, it was the brutal CAM epidemic that was exclusively Indian.)</em></strong></p><p>Let’s analyze each reference cited in the DLE to create this false sense of equivalence between India and other countries that reported CAM. A deep dive into each reference convinced me that the DLE authors hoped the average reader would not attempt the same, and would take them at their word! Be prepared to be shocked, to understand how science, even statistics, in published, peer reviewed medical literature, can be misused and manipulated by expert conmen in academia, to create their desired perception in readers and thus serve their heinous agendas.</p><p><em>For there are indeed “three kinds of lies: Lies, Damned Lies, and Statistics”!</em></p><p><strong>a) Germany:</strong></p><p><strong><em>Grandiose DLE statement</em></strong>: “<em>In a nationwide survey from Germany, a few of their intensive care units reported nearly a 100-fold increase in mucormycosis following COVID-19 than before </em><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8662289/"><em>[54]”</em></a></p><p>And the reader would likely go: Wow! Nearly a 100-Fold Increase in CAM in Germany!</p><p><strong><em>Reality:</em></strong> <em>13 cases!</em></p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8662289/">The referenced study identified 13 CAM cases</a> from six tertiary referral hospitals, diagnosed between March 2020 and June 2021.</p><p>Stats in the reference: “<em>Two centres reported higher prevalence of CAM amongst hospitalised COVID‐19 patients (0.67%, 4/596 and 0.58%, 4/691, P = 1.0) between January 2020 and June 2021 compared to prevalence of mucormycosis not associated with COVID‐19 (0.0047%, 2/42,518 and 0.001%, 1/89,048, P = .51) overall. For ICU patients also similar prevalence was reported in both centres for CAM (1.47%, 4/273 and 1.78%, 3/169, P = .80) and for mucormycosis not associated with COVID‐19 (0.015%, 1/6,454 and 0.005%, 1/19,636, P = .99). In both centres CAM prevalence was higher overall and in ICU COVID‐19 patients compared to mucormycosis prevalence overall and in ICU non‐COVID‐19 patients (P &lt; .001 for all comparisons). In a third hospital, prevalence of CAM in ICU COVID‐19 patients was slightly lower (0.15%, 1/647).”</em></p><p>“<em>Nearly a 100-fold increase</em>” is a technically correct interpretation. If you consider a jump from 0.015% to 1.47%, it is indeed nearly a 100-fold increase. But using this grandiose, “nearly a 100-fold increase” to compare the German CAM cases with those of the Indian CAM epidemic, is meant to muddle the truth: because, the eye-grabbing “100-fold increase” in Germany, in reality, is only a jump from 1–2 patients to 3–4 patients!!</p><p>How does this ‘nearly a 100-fold increase’ in Germany compare to reports from India, when we even adjust for population?</p><p><strong><em>Germany (Population — 83 million; Number of cases over a period of one year - 13</em></strong>): The referenced <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8662289/">German study</a> says: “We identified <strong><em>13 CAM cases</em></strong> from six tertiary referral hospitals diagnosed between March 2020 and June 2021. Twelve patients had severe or critical COVID‐19, eleven were mechanically ventilated for a median of 8 days (range 1‐27 days) before diagnosis of CAM.”</p><p><strong><em>From just one city in India, Delhi (Population- 33 million; Number of cases at one point in time, July, 2021 - 952</em></strong>): ‘<a href="https://www.livemint.com/news/india/delhi-has-more-infections-of-black-fungus-than-active-covid-19-cases-govt-data-11626227610032.html">Delhi has more black fungus infections than active Covid-19 cases: Government Data’</a>! At the height of the Covid second wave in July, India’s national capital, Delhi, had more cases of mucormycosis than active Covid cases<em>! </em><strong><em>952 CAM cases</em></strong><em> </em>vs 833 Covid!! The article also says: “The national capital had recorded over 1,650 cases of mucormycosis or black fungus till 6 July, the official government data shows.”</p><p>The <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8662289/">German authors</a>, incidentally, acknowledge there is no comparison between their scenario and the Indian CAM epidemic: “COVID‐19‐associated mucormycosis is <strong><em>rare</em></strong> in Germany, mostly reported in <strong><em>patients with comorbidities and impaired immune system and severe COVID‐19</em></strong> <strong><em>treated in the ICU</em></strong> with high mortality compared to mainly <strong><em>rhino‐orbito‐cerebral CAM in patients with mild COVID‐19 in India</em></strong>”.</p><p>Comparing <strong>13 CAM cases in Germany</strong>, that too among <strong>critically ill, hospitalised, </strong>Covid patients, to India’s nightmarish CAM epidemic of tens of thousands among the <strong>general population</strong> with mild Covid, takes a gargantuan stretch of wicked imagination and manipulated statistical interpretation indeed!</p><p><strong>b) France:</strong></p><p><strong><em>Grandiose DLE statement</em></strong>: “<em>Another multisite ICU study from France reported 1% of mucormycosis in COVID-19 patients, </em><strong><em>an incidence rate like India</em></strong><em> </em><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8626095/"><em>[55]”</em></a></p><p>And the average reader would likely go: Wow! India and France had the same incidence rates of CAM! And they would continue reading the editorial for more gems from these great Indian doctors who are renowned for their vast and specialized expertise on CAM.</p><p>Unless you take the trouble to read <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8626095/">Reference 55</a> thoroughly!</p><p><strong><em>Reality</em></strong>: <em>6 cases in mechanically ventilated patients!</em></p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8626095/">This is a study</a> “aimed to identify the prevalence, risk factors, and mortality associated with Invasive Fungal Infections (IFIs) in mechanically ventilated patients with COVID-19 under intensive care.”</p><p>Again, <strong><em>not in the general population, but in critically ill, mechanically ventilated, Intensive Care Unit (ICU) inpatients</em></strong>!</p><p>Here are their statistics: “<em>Between Feb 29 and July 9, 2020, we enrolled 565 mechanically ventilated patients with COVID-19. 509 patients with at least three screening samples were analysed. 128 (25%) patients had 138 episodes of pr/pb or possible IFIs. 76 (15%) patients fulfilled the criteria for pr/pb CAPA. 38 (7%) patients had one or more other pr/pb IFIs: 32 (6%) had candidaemia, six (1%) had invasive mucormycosis, and one (&lt;1%) had invasive fusariosis</em>.”</p><p>The unbelievable damned lie!</p><p>By equating a 1% finding from this very focused study of IFIs among a narrow, very specific, incredibly vulnerable group of patients (i.e., mechanically ventilated Covid patients in the ICU) — <strong>a grand total of 6 patients </strong>— to the CAM incidence rate in India, the DLE is attempting a slick con job on its readers! And hugely underestimating their intelligence in the process. <em>The absolute horror!</em></p><p>As mentioned earlier, the DLE, authored by three prolifically published researchers, exhibits extraordinary skills at hoodwinking the reader, the reviewer and by extension — the research watchbodies — in their write-up. An example is the sly addition of the seemingly innocuous phrase <em>‘ICU study’</em> in the grandiose DLE statement above. Easily overlooked by the reader, but put in place as a defence for their misleading statement, if questioned. Though how they would explain equating that ICU incidence in the French study to “an incidence rate like India” is beyond comprehension! The willful nature of this data manipulation becomes more obvious by how they use this same study later to emphasize that France, a country that does not use cow dung, also had ‘<em>such high proportions of CAM</em>’! Note again how they make their lie technically correct by adding the phrase ‘critically ill’ in the statement below, and hope the reader misses this glaring anomaly in the analysis that compares apples to oranges!</p><p><strong><em>DLE Quote</em></strong>: “<em>The occurrence of CAM in such high proportions (up to 1% of critically ill COVID-19 cases in France) in countries where cow dung is not used, points towards the need for a better explanation for CAM rather than India-specific factors [55,59].”</em></p><p>The above is a statement that also exposes the fact that the authors are very much aware of the nature of the cohort studied in France (critically ill, mechanically ventilated patients in ICU). Clearly, it can only be a deliberate attempt at duping the readers when these experienced researchers make the false equivalence between 6 cases of mucormycosis in such a cohort in France to the outsize CAM incidence rate among the general population in India!</p><p>This falsification of facts become even more glaring if the reader takes the trouble to understand that the other <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9540166/">reference (Ref 59), cited in the above DLE quote, is a study from Iran</a>, the one other country that had a noticeable CAM outbreak with Rhino-orbital Mucormycosis/ Rhino-Orbito-Cerebral Mucormycosis (ROM/ROCM), like India, and which was mentioned in our hypothesis in relation to the country’s excessive use of <strong>donkey dung or Anbarnesa</strong>.</p><p><strong><em>Note that Iran and donkey dung are cunningly not mentioned in the text, while France and its lack of cow dung usage is significantly highlighted!</em></strong></p><p><em>Oh, the tangled web of lies we weave….</em></p><p>c) <strong>Chile</strong></p><p><strong><em>DLE Quote:</em></strong> <em>“The reported prevalence of COVID-19-associated pulmonary mucormycosis was similar in Chile and India [34,56]”</em></p><p><strong><em>Reality</em></strong>: <em>3 cases</em></p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8084475/">Reference 56</a> is a retrospective study of adults admitted to one hospital ICU in Chile, during May 18–July 18, 2020, for COVID-19–Associated Invasive Mold Infection (CAIMI). “Of the 856 COVID-19 patients admitted, 146 (17.1%) were hospitalized in the ICU and 16 (11%) received a diagnosis of CAIMI. Considering the 16 CAIMI cases, we observed an incidence of 11% in patients with severe COVID-19 (6.8% aspergillosis, 0.7% mucormycosis (1 patient*), 0.7% aspergillosis/mucormycosis (1 patient*), and 0.7% scedosporiosis (1 patient*).”</p><p>* <em>Actual number of patients obtained from </em><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8084475/bin/20-4412-Techapp-s1.pdf"><em>Appendix</em></a><em> to the paper.</em></p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8979562/">Reference 34</a>: A study that includes The Damned Lies authors on Covid Associated Pulmonary Mucormycosis (CAPM) states: “<em>The burden of CAPM following the second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in India and other countries remains largely unknown</em>.” “<em>In a systematic review, CAPM accounted for 26 (9·5%) of 275 patients with CAM from across the world. 17(7·3%) of 233 reported CAM cases from India and nine (21·4%) of 42 reported CAM cases from the rest of the world were due to CAPM</em>.” “<em>The experts estimated that the number of patients with CAPM in the recent CAM epidemic should have been around 4000. However, no more than 40 incidents of CAPM have been published globally. Thus, there is a possibility of gross under-reporting of the number of patients with CAPM</em>.”</p><p>No comments! Experts can surely read both the references and try to comprehend the sorcery that would magic the math in them to add up, and present similar prevalence in India and Chile! <em>Good Luck!</em></p><p>By glibly lying that France had similar <strong><em>incidence</em></strong> rate of CAM as India, and Chile had similar <strong><em>prevalence</em></strong> of CAPM as India, statistical terms that inspire quiet confidence among the academia, the DLE authors are underscoring the disturbing reality that statistics is the ultimate refuge of the slickest ‘learned’ damned liars!</p><p>d<strong><em>) DLE Quote</em></strong>: “<em>The other countries that reported CAM</em>”</p><p><strong><em>Reality:</em></strong> From each of the cited references in the DLE is as follows:</p><p>. France, again — <em>17 cases</em>!</p><p>(<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8773954/">Reference 57</a>): “<em>In this study, we reported </em><strong><em>17 cases of CAM in France</em>, <em>the largest series from 1 country outside India.”</em></strong></p><p><em>“Emerging reports, mainly from India, recently described COVID-19-associated mucormycosis (CAM). In this country, more than 28000 cases have already been reported and mucormycosis is now a notifiable disease. </em><strong><em>Outside India, only a few case reports have been published</em></strong><em>.”</em></p><p><em>“From March 2020 to June 10, 2021, </em><strong><em>17 </em></strong><em>patients from 11 centers developed CAM.” “During the same period, </em><strong><em>473353</em></strong><em> patients have been hospitalized for COVID-19 in France.”</em></p><p>Please, do not forget the DLE quote earlier with reference to France having “<em>an incidence rate like India</em>”!</p><p>. Egypt — <em>5 cases</em>!</p><p>(<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10111294/">Reference 58):</a> In a prospective cohort study including 253 <strong><em>critically ill</em></strong><em> COVID-19 patients</em> in the ICU of one hospital over 4 months, five cases (1.97%) of mucormycosis were detected.</p><p>. Russia- <em>60 cases</em>. (<a href="https://pesquisa.bvsalud.org/global-literature-on-novel-coronavirus-2019-ncov/resource/pt/covidwho-2266294">Reference 60</a>)</p><p>. Romania — <em>1 case report!</em> (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9168568/">Reference 63</a>)</p><p>“<em>The largest experience comes from India, which has dealt with a challenging epidemic of COVID-19-associated mucormycosis (CAM). </em><strong><em>To our knowledge, no previous studies have reported CAM in Romania</em></strong><em>. We therefore present a case</em>…”</p><p>. Latin America — <em>16 cases</em>. <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8386102/">(Reference 64</a>): Peru — 4, Brazil- 3, Mexico- 2, Chile- 3</p><p>. Honduras -<em>17 cases of mucormycosis; 11 CAM</em>. (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8675660/">Reference 61</a>)</p><p>“<em>Seventeen persons received a diagnosis of mucormycosis during May 5–September 6, 2021; these included 11 persons with COVID-19–associated cases</em>.”</p><p>. Pakistan — <em>43 cases of mucormycosis; 22 CAM</em>. (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9896361/">Reference 62</a>): From three tertiary care centers in one city, Lahore: “<em>Out of the total 43 reported patients of mucormycosis in the set time frame (May to July 2021) only 22 cases had a history of Covid‐19.”</em></p><p>. Iran — <em>94 cases of mucormycosis; 52 CAM</em>. (<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9540166/">Reference 59</a>): “<em>Between February 2020 and September 2021, 94 patients with mucormycosis have been identified in our center. Forty-two (44.7%) of them did not report having any history of COVID-19 during the last 6 months, and had negative results with our diagnostic tools, including both qPCR and CT scan at the time of presentation. As a result, they had been excluded from our study. For the other 52 patients with mucormycosis (55.3%), all were adults who had a history of symptomatic COVID-19, within the last few months of mucormycosis, consequently, they were categorized as CAM group.”</em></p><p>As can be seen from the above statistics provided as references by the DLE, while CAM cases have been reported from some countries, none of them come close to the unprecedented CAM epidemic that happened in India — <em>not just in absolute numbers, but also in relative per capita frequency</em>.</p><p>As mentioned earlier, most developed countries conducted dedicated <strong><em>retrospective studies only after the Indian epidemic hit global headlines</em></strong>, to determine whether they had an uptick in CAM cases as well. Some did find an increase, especially in pulmonary mucormycosis among critically ill Covid patients in ICUs and on ventilators. Rhino-orbital Mucormycosis/ Rhino-Orbito-Cerebral Mucormycosis (ROM/ROCM), which constituted the bulk of reported Indian CAM cases still remains very rare in such countries. Comparing this sophisticated, uncommon diagnosis of predominantly Covid Associated Pulmonary Mucormycosis (CAPM) in severely ill Covid patients in well-equipped Western hospitals, to the nightmarish CAM epidemic (predominantly ROM/ROCM) among the general population in India, — where <a href="https://www.indiatvnews.com/news/india/fearing-covid-19-black-fungus-couple-commits-suicide-in-karnataka-727149">terrified Indians committed suicide rather than risk getting Covid and ‘Black Fungus’</a> — is specious indeed! And a glaring example of flagrant and egregious statistical manipulation with the clear intent to deflect from any focus on “India-specific factors”!</p><p>While on the topic of global CAM, it is pertinent to note that there are clear differences in the presentation of CAM in the Low- and Middle-Income Countries (LMICs), as compared to that in developed countries.</p><p>While a noticeable uptick in ROM/ROCM associated with milder COVID cases in the general population was the most common presentation in the LMICs, the more difficult to diagnose pulmonary mucormycosis was the predominant entity in developed countries, and that too, mostly in severely ill/ICU/ventilated Covid patients.</p><p><a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1579833617727258624?s=20">I have hypothesized that this could be dependent on the nature of acquisition of the Mucorales spores.</a> In LMICs, they are more likely to be community-acquired, from the heavier spore loads in the ambient air, mostly embedded in larger airborne biomass particles like smoke, dung, soil, mud, compost. These hefty spore-loads and larger particles are more likely to settle in the upper airways leading to ROM/ROCM in the vulnerable.</p><p><strong>This community acquired infection in <em>LMICs</em>, due to its <em>higher individual exposure to fungal spores</em>,</strong> can even affect relatively healthier, younger, immunocompetent individuals (as seen <a href="https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/india-news-covid-three-kids-with-black-fungus-get-eye-removed-in-maharashtra/385433">in India, even among children</a>).</p><p>On the other hand, exposure to the ubiquitous, smaller doses of fungal spores found universally, even in <strong><em>developed countries</em></strong> and settings like hospital ICUs, would more likely result in the spores reaching the lower airways, leading to pulmonary or disseminated mucormycosis, and that too <strong>only in the most vulnerable, critically ill and immunocompromised, due to the <em>lower individual spore exposure </em></strong>in such scenarios.</p><p>Pulmonary mucormycosis is also very likely massively underdiagnosed in LMICs like India. ROM being so vividly distinguishable externally makes it difficult to be clinically misdiagnosed and undercounted.</p><p>Also, in LMICs, many cases of mucormycosis diagnosed during the Covid era did not have a history of preceding or concomitant Covid infection, and hence were excluded from being counted as CAM, as seen in the above references for Honduras, Iran and Pakistan — <a href="https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/27/9/21-0934_article">and in India</a>. This again points to the possibility that the epidemiology and pathogenesis for mucormycosis varies depending on one’s country of residence — which determines the vastly different proportionate fungal spore loads in their ambient air — even though Mucorales are generally considered globally ubiquitous and present <em>‘in every breath we take’</em>.</p><p>From the correct interpretation of the above statistics and the actual ground reality, it is amply clear that the <strong>CAM epidemic</strong> in India was unique and unprecedented, and cannot be considered on an equal footing with the reported <strong>CAM cases</strong> from other countries. And even among the countries that reported CAM, there is a difference in the epidemiology and pathogenesis of CAM between developed and developing countries. A difference that points to likely environmental factors in LMICs that could have crucial roles. And more pertinently, to ‘India-specific factors’ that make Indians so disproportionately vulnerable to mucormycosis at all times, and were likely at the root of the horrific ‘black fungus’/CAM epidemic of 2021. The ‘India-specific factors’ that are so charged and controversial that this DLE had to unleash unethical, unacceptable manipulations of data from peer-reviewed medical publications to hoodwink the scientific world into accepting (despite the self-evident truth) that CAM epidemic was a worldwide phenomenon, and not specific to India.</p><p><em>Why?</em></p><p>Because it is very important for the DLE authors to establish that it is the universal host factors — Diabetes, Steroids and Covid — the common denominators in all these countries during the Covid pandemic — and the ubiquitous nature of the Mucorales, that caused the “worldwide CAM epidemic”, and not any specific environmental factor critically increasing individual spore exposure in India. It is absolutely crucial for them that India is not singled out for added scrutiny of ‘India-specific factors’. Especially no peeking at India’s environment and the secrets it holds. Sacred secrets that have the potential to uproot empires…</p><p>And that brings us to the second big question: <strong><em>Did the environment play a critical role in India’s CAM epidemic?</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Principal DLE Lie #2: </em></strong><em>Host factors, like Diabetes, Steroids and Covid are the critical factors in CAM and need to be focused on doggedly, while environmental factors can be ignored, especially since the Mucorales fungi are considered ubiquitous.</em></p><p><strong><em>My rebuttal:</em></strong></p><p>The environment played a critical role in India’s CAM epidemic, and need to be a crucial focus of further research into understanding India’s ‘black fungus’ epidemic and its perpetually skewed high case load of mucormycosis!</p><p>A look at published reports on <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11046-019-00403-1">all past outbreaks of mucormycosis</a> would show that they invariably and consistently point to disparate added environmental sources as the critical factor for the outbreak — be they medical devices, hospital linen, contaminated air, construction activities, tornadoes, or even volcanic lava.</p><p>But, in the context of the largest outbreak of mucormycosis ever, the CAM epidemic of India, these ‘experts’ regress to the lazy “Mucorales fungi are ubiquitous” argument to dismiss the critical role of environment, and want to concentrate only on the host factors — which in this case, has conveniently provided Covid as the extra/added factor! <strong><em>Ignoring the self-evident truth that Covid was global, a pandemic, while the CAM epidemic was glaringly Indian! </em></strong>Now that the pathetic statistical gymnastics and skullduggery employed by the DLE authors to show the CAM epidemic was also a global phenomenon have been exposed, let us concentrate on their attempts to downplay the role of the environment.</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>The ubiquitous presence of fungal spores is insufficient to result in disease and compromised host immunity or an altered net state of immunosuppression, which is probably the most critical factor underlying invasive mucormycosis</em>.”</p><p><em>Oh, yeah!</em> Throughout the paper, the DLE keeps echoing this prayer to the global medical community — dismiss the role of the ubiquitous fungal spores in India’s CAM epidemic; concentrate on the compromised host immunity or an altered net state of immunosuppression, due to Covid and steroids and diabetes. That is enough. That should be enough!</p><p><em>Pathetic!</em></p><p>But, with so much published evidence on the role of increased environmental fungal loads in past outbreaks, the DLE is also forced to acknowledge some role of the environment, and comes up with a curious new rule — added environmental sources are important in India only in hospital scenarios!</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>While the ubiquitous presence of Mucoralean spore in rural, indoor, and outdoor environments has been highlighted in India [[43], [44], [45], [46]], hospital reports are more alarming [47,48]. Healthcare-associated mucormycosis is a well-known entity described from several transplant centers catering to immunocompromised individuals [49]. Hospital linens have been shown to cause outbreaks of cutaneous mucormycosis [50]. In a study from a network of transplant centers in the United States, even freshly laundered linens were contaminated with Mucorales in 47% of hospitals [51]. </em><strong><em>Thus, Mucorales from various hospital sources in a general hospital in India could have contributed to mucormycosis in immunocompromised individuals, especially ongoing construction activity during COVID-19</em></strong><em> [52]. Notably, a study from France observed a cluster of CAM cases in relation to hospital renovation near the ICU catering to critically ill COVID-19 subjects [53].”</em></p><p>Whoa! What are these ‘experts’ saying? That an increase in environmental Mucorales spores in hospital environments in India, from hospital sources, could cause mucormycosis outbreaks, but if there is an increase in environmental Mucorales spores in the ambient environment of the general Indian community — which by their own admission is teeming with undiagnosed and poorly controlled diabetics (<strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>India can be considered the ‘diabetes capital’ of the world, and uncontrolled diabetes mellitus is the most common predisposing factor associated with mucormycosis in India.”</em>) — the only critical factor in acquiring CAM in the community is host susceptibility, with the high environmental spore load having nothing to do with it? Are they missing something? <em>No. I don’t think so.</em> This is willful contortion of facts, with the authors banking on their reputation as ‘experts’ to try and afford such twisted facts scientific credibility.</p><p>Let me clarify:</p><p>At the beginning of the CAM epidemic in India, Prof. Chakrabarti, one of the authors of the DLE, had written an article, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8222941/">‘the recent mucormycosis storm over Indian sky’</a> and had emphasized on the “<strong><em>four major issues</em></strong> to be highlighted: <strong><em>diabetes, steroid, COVID-19, and environment</em></strong>!” That made eminent sense. And was reflected in the <a href="https://publichealth.jhu.edu/2021/covid-19-and-fungi-a-nightmare-in-the-making">opinion of global experts, some of whom openly wondered “what is in the air in India”.</a></p><p>And here is this same Prof. Chakrabarti now doing a 180, and directing everyone to focus only on the first three — the host factors — and to ignore the fourth, the environment!</p><p><em>Holy Cow!</em> What happened between then and now? I think dung finally hit the fan, and the only way the ‘experts’ could hope to clean up the mess was by trying to bottle the dung genie that emerged from the Indian environment during the CAM epidemic. And in a desperate bid to contain this pervasive, rampaging genie, they are likely feeling the pressure to erase the whole environmental factor! <em>What a dilemma!</em></p><p>To see an expert trying his best to discredit the role of the high environmental Mucorales spores in India, which he himself has studied in the past, is disturbing, to say the least. As an example, one multi-centre Indian study, done at the peak of India’s CAM epidemic, isolated <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0195670122000317">environmental Mucorales spores in 51.8% of outdoor air</a> samples collected from near hospitals! Another study (Ref. 41) isolated Mucorales from <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9478190/">88% of outdoor samples near the residences of CAM patients</a> in North India! ‘Ubiquitous’ certainly has a new meaning in the Indian context!</p><p>Please also note the fact that most Indian CAM cases were diagnosed in patients who were never hospitalized for Covid, but were in home isolation for mild Covid. As stated in <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9478190/">this study co-authored by Prof. Chakrabarti and cited in the DLE (Reference 41</a>): “<strong><em>A considerable number of CAM patients were never admitted to a hospital before the development of the disease</em></strong>.”</p><p>And yet, we are now challenged by the DLE authors to prove that environment played a critical role in India’s CAM epidemic! Picking up that gauntlet, I am pleased to direct their attention to the Indian study that came out since the Covid pandemic, that does prove the role of the environment in India’s CAM epidemic. This study, ‘<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/myc.13578">Multimodal analysis of the COVID-19-associated mucormycosis outbreak in Delhi, India indicates the convergence of clinical and environmental risk factors</a>’, does show that “<em>the CAM incidence peak was preceded by an uptick in environmental spore concentrations in the preceding 3–4 weeks that correlated with increasing temperature, high evaporation and decreasing relative humidity</em>.” And they conclude unambiguously: “<em>An intersection of host and environmental factors contributed to the emergence of CAM</em>.”</p><p>To understand the absurdness of dismissing the role of environment in a mucormycosis outbreak, however small the cluster , let me share quotes from a study referenced in the DLE, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8948870/">Ref. 53,</a> that can bust many self-evident lies in the Damned Lies Editorial.</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>Notably, a study from France observed a cluster of CAM cases in relation to hospital renovation near the ICU catering to critically ill COVID-19 subjects</em> <em>[53].”</em></p><p><strong><em>This is a pertinent </em></strong><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8948870/"><strong><em>study on a clustered series of Mucorales detection in a month at an ICU in France</em></strong></a>. The following are quotes from the study:</p><p>a) “While COVID-19-associated pulmonary aspergillosis is now well described in developed countries, COVID-19-associated mucormycosis <strong>(CAM) has seemed to remain quite rare in Europe</strong>.”</p><p>b) “In a retrospective study performed between March 2020 to September 2021 among COVID-19 adult patients in the intensive care unit (ICU) at Toulouse Hospital (Southern France), ten patients (7.1%) had a positive Mucorales PCR over the same period.”</p><p>c) “Surprisingly, 9/10 had a positive Mucor/Rhizopus PCR in August-September 2021, during the fourth Delta SARS-CoV-2 variant wave. <strong>Epidemic investigations have identified a probable environmental cause linked to construction works in the vicinity of the ICU (high levels of airborne spores</strong> due to the mistaken interruption of preventive humidification and summer temperature).”</p><p>d) “Even if CAM are apparently rare in Europe, <strong>a cluster can also develop in industrialised countries when environmental conditions (especially during construction work) are associated with a high number of COVID-19 patients in the ICU.”</strong></p><p>e) “Diabetes, a common risk factor for mucormycosis, was reported for 20% (2/10) of the patients. Most of the patients were treated for COVID-19 infection with dexamethasone (9/10; 90%) and tocilizumab (7/10; 70%). Surprisingly, the incidence of Mucorales-positive cases was very different in the successive waves of the COVID-19 pandemic and according to the SARS-CoV-2 variant prevalence. During the first 17 months (March 2020 to July 2021), only one patient had a positive PCR (0.9%; 1/117), while 9/24 patients (B-J) (37.5%) had a positive Mucor/Rhizopus PCR in August–September 2021 (fourth wave). Interestingly, among patients B–J, 100% of those tested were positive for the Delta SARS-CoV-2 variant (7/7) and 77.8% (7/9) had a dexamethasone/tocilizumab combination therapy.”</p><p>f) “This alarmingly high number of positive fungal PCRs during the August–September period led us to <strong>investigate this “fungal epidemic</strong>”. The nine patients (patients B–J) were hospitalised on both ICU sites (six and three at Rangueil and Purpan, respectively). In August 2021, construction and renovation works were taking place on both sites within 200 m of the ICU in a context of summer weather with a mean temperature in Toulouse of about 23 °C. <strong>Environmental tests</strong> (air and surface sampling) at the Rangueil ICU were positive for numerous filamentous fungi including Rhizopus oryzae in 6/38 samples (16%) and Aspergillus sp. in 6/38 samples (16%). At the time of the outbreak, preventive humidification of excavation work in the vicinity of the Rangueil ICU (&lt;10 m) had been mistakenly interrupted.”</p><p>g) “The Infection Prevention and Control team successfully implemented the following corrective measures: (i) resumption of sprinkling of the excavation, (ii) replacement of the ICU air handling unit inlet filters, (iii) countermanding the institutional COVID-driven recommendation to open the windows of tertiary rooms that were ill-adapted to the ICU controlled environmental zone, (iv) inactivation of the low pressure setting of COVID patients’ cubicles, thereafter maintained in isopression; and (v) intensification of bio-cleaning in cubicles and tertiary areas and storage rooms.”</p><p>h) “<strong>The risk of acquiring IMI (Invasive Mold Infection) varies according to the level of individual exposure to fungal spores</strong>.”</p><p>i) “Construction and renovation <strong>activities can increase airborne fungal spore load and have been reported to be an independent risk factor for invasive fungal infections</strong>.”</p><p>j) “In our centre, excavation and building activities occurred within the proximity of the ICU and the hypothesis of fungal dissemination via this activity cannot be excluded. <strong>The simultaneous massive increase in Mucorales and Aspergillus detection in August–September 2021</strong>, as well as the unusual proportion of non-fumigati Aspergillus species compared to the norm, could constitute an argument in favour of this hypothesis.”</p><p>k) “<strong>Even if an association between environmental conditions (construction work, temperature) and the increased fungal detection seems likely, it remains very difficult to demonstrate a direct causal link</strong>.”</p><p>l) “<strong>When environmental conditions (high levels of airborne spores due to construction work, local climatic conditions, such as summer temperatures) are associated with a high number of COVID-19 patients in the ICU, a CAM cluster can also develop in European countries</strong>.”</p><p>This case series reports on the detection of a Mucorales cluster (<em>please note that the study is describing positive detection of Mucorales from respiratory samples — and not overt mucormycosis</em>) in nine Covid patients in a hospital ICU in France, within a short period of time — one month. In my opinion, this study could be used as an example of how the CAM epidemic in India (and Iran) could have been approached — on a larger scale.</p><p>The study describes an unusual cluster for which the usual culprits, the host factors — Covid, steroids, diabetes and sick patients in ICU — could have sufficed as causative factors accounting for the cluster. Yet, the authors looked beyond that, to the environment, because “<strong><em>the risk of acquiring IMI varies according to the level of individual exposure to fungal spores</em></strong>.” Meaning, when a mucormycosis outbreak occurs, it makes eminent sense to know <strong><em>what activity or environmental factor led to the cluster being exposed to a higher spore-load at the same time</em></strong> (since activities that <em>increase airborne fungal spore load have been reported to be an independent risk factor for invasive fungal infections</em>), irrespective of the immune status of the individuals in the cluster. The French authors considered this likelihood of increased environmental spore load, as a key differentiating factor in causing this unusual cluster — <strong>looked for it and found it</strong>: construction and renovation activities in the proximity of the ICU which could have increased the airborne fungal spore load in the area. And here is the crucial, honest statement<strong><em>: “Even if an association between environmental conditions (construction work, temperature) and the increased fungal detection seems likely, it remains very difficult to demonstrate a direct causal link</em></strong>.”</p><p>(Incidentally, similar observations are made by global health organizations with regard to the role of environment in Histoplasmosis, another dreaded fungal infection. As stated in this CDC website: <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/histoplasmosis/environment.html">Histoplasma in the Environment. </a>“Detecting <em>Histoplasma </em>in environmental samples can be challenging.” “In outbreak settings with a very clear exposure, environmental testing may not be necessary, particularly if the results would not change public health recommendations to prevent future cases. Also, an environmental sample that tests negative for <em>Histoplasma</em> does not necessarily mean that the fungus is not present or was not present at the time the exposure occurred.”)</p><p>In direct contradiction to all the above observations in the French study, here is the DLE referencing that study to label our hypothesis of potentially increased environmental/airborne spread of Mucorales from fresh, dried and burning dung (thus increasing the individual spore exposure of vulnerable, Covid-ravaged Indians) likely being the key differential factor in India’s CAM epidemic, as a Damned Lie!</p><p><em>Why!?</em></p><p>Because, according to them, for this particular Indian CAM epidemic “<em>the ubiquitous presence of fungal spores is insufficient to result in disease</em>” and hence there is no need to look further for environmental factors that could determine any increase in individual exposure to fungal spores! And anyway, “<em>the unevaluated and most crucial factor is likely coronavirus”</em>! (Hint: The corona virus caused a global viral pandemic but was also specifically designed to cause a fungal epidemic in India! Fodder for conspiracy theorists, indeed!!) Moreover, the DLE authors are adamant that this new hypothesis is a ‘damned lie’ because experts are yet to prove a direct causal link to high environmental or cattle dung exposure! <em>What can I say?!</em></p><p>Allow me to conclude this saga of busting the DLE’s damned lie #2 that attempts to negate the role of the environment in India’s CAM epidemic by quoting the same DLE authors.</p><p>First, a sentence from a <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/">2022 paper co-authored by our own DLE authors</a> (interestingly, the cattle dung burning study — described later — used to refute our hypothesis!) : “<em>A high environmental burden of Mucorales in India is well recognised. It possibly explains that the country accounted for &gt;80% of the global burden of mucormycosis </em><strong><em>before and after</em></strong><em> the COVID‐19 pandemic.”</em></p><p>Wow!! So, these DLE experts, at times, elsewhere, do acknowledge the crucial impact of the high environmental burden of Mucorales in India. But it is still very conditional: It had an impact only “<em>before and after the COVID‐19 pandemic</em>” and not during CAM! And if it made any impact during CAM, it was only in the hospital setting, and not in the general community, as now they state in the DLE!! Sure!</p><p>Well, no. Not so quick. This is the apt time for a friendly reminder of the DLE author, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8222941/">Prof. Chakrabarti’s own words</a> at the beginning of India’s CAM epidemic, in June, 2021: <em>“The fourth factor is environmental prevalence for Mucorales in India. Mucorales spores had been detected at 0.68–1.12 ​cfu/cubic meter in indoor and 0.73–8.60 ​cfu/cubic meter in outdoor air of India with predominance of main pathogenic species Rhizopus arrhizus. </em><strong><em>These high spore count in air allows the entry of spore in the respiratory tract of vulnerable patients causing mucormycosis</em></strong><em>.</em>”</p><p><em>Irony just died taking a headlong leap into a dung heap!</em></p><p><strong><em>Principal DLE Lie #3: </em></strong><em>The hypothesis on the role of cow and its excreta in India’s CAM epidemic is a damned lie. Hence any research into it is a waste of time, resources and efforts.</em></p><p><strong><em>My rebuttal:</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>The key question: Is the hypothesis on the role of cow excreta in India’s CAM epidemic a Damned Lie or a Daring Truth?</em></strong></p><p>With all the scientific evidence already available at the time of the CAM epidemic, in conjunction with the corroborating findings from research studies that have emerged since then, and my own observations and experiments from the past two years, <strong><em>I am willing to bet that The Hypothesis is a Daring Truth</em></strong>. So daring that ‘experts’ — presumably kowtowing to the majoritarian regime currently at the helm in India — are scrambling to dismiss it as ‘damned lies’, rather than face the unimaginable fallout when the inconvenient truth regarding the Indian Cow Excreta spills out amongst the Indian public.</p><p>Please refer <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">to our published, peer-reviewed hypothesis</a>, if you are not already familiar with it, to understand how we arrived at such a conclusion even while the CAM epidemic was raging in India. And below is a summary of the evidence to support our hypothesis including more recent relevant studies and observations.</p><p>The key supporting facts are:</p><p>1. Mucorales are <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2309-608X/6/1/4">coprophilous or dung loving</a>, especially as regards herbivore dung, such as cattle dung. That is a long-standing, evidence-based fact. Additionally, with the isolation of Mucorales <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/">from 75% of fresh and 50% of dry Indian cow dung samples, in a study</a> performed after the publication of our hypothesis, (conducted by the DLE authors <em>et al</em>), there is now proof of this coprophilous nature of Mucorales in Indian (“<em>Desi</em>”) cow dung as well!</p><p>2. Mucorales spores are <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7151165/">small and easily aerosolized</a>.</p><p>3. Fungal spores are known to travel long distances in the smoke of biomass fires, as shown in<a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1352231003009142"> this pioneering study</a>. And recent <a href="https://www.sciencenews.org/article/wildfire-smoke-microbes-air-health-risk-bacteria-fungi">Pyroaerobiology studies</a> are reaffirming this previously unexplored threat of the spread of microbial pathogens in wild fires.</p><p>4. India has the largest cattle inventory in the world, with <a href="https://beef2live.com/story-world-cattle-inventory-ranking-countries-0-106905">more than 300 million cattle</a>! This huge cattle population produces around <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2589014X21000529">3 million tons of dung per day in India</a>!</p><p>5. Indians, mainly those who practice the majority religion of Hinduism, do not consider cow dung as a waste product to be kept at a distance from human habitation, but <a href="https://swadeshivip.com/blog/throwing-light-on-the-benefits-of-cow-dung-and-its-importance/">as holy and beneficial and with health benefits, </a>when used intimately by humans. This results in a large proportion of the cow excreta being left out in the open, with dried dung dust likely getting dispersed in the air (much like the <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7845282/">bat guano dust implicated in invasive fungal infections like Histoplasmosis</a>). <a href="https://bharatvarshnaturefarms.com/indian-holy-cow-dung-cakes-and-its-uses/">Dried dung is also burnt</a> in Indian homes, especially in rural communities, as fuel for cooking and warming, as an insect repellant, and in religious rituals. A large proportion of Indians, thus, come in regular contact with cow dung, its air-borne particles, cow urine and the <a href="https://en.gaonconnection.com/cooking-gas-lpg-firewood-ujjwala-scheme-rural-india-women-health-risks-air-pollution/">smoke of burning dung</a>, consciously and unconsciously. This is an irrefutable fact.</p><p>A fact that compels even the <strong>DLE</strong> to admit that “<em>the rearing of cows, the use of cow-dung cakes as fuels, and several other cultural practices have been present in India for several centuries”, </em>even while they blithely try to gloss over this crucial, unique Indian risk factor with counter statements like<em>, “some media reports from India found a few individuals from a population of 1.4 billion who suggested using cow dung or cow urine to prevent COVID-19.”</em></p><p>In a densely populated country like India, with the highest cattle population in the world, where cows and their dung and urine are considered holy and medicinal, it’s never a ‘few individuals’; it’s always a huge proportion of Indians who are, consciously or unconsciously, in contact with the cow and its excreta. <em>Fact. Not a Damned Lie.</em></p><p>The traditional reverence of the cow has inevitably been taken advantage of by market forces, and has resulted in the increasing <a href="https://openthemagazine.com/cover-stories/cow-dung-capitalism-milking-the-holy-cow/">commodification of the animal and</a> its products in 21st century India. The cow is now marketed in the country as a miraculous source of wellbeing — an infinite source of wealth generation.</p><p>And a <a href="https://www.economist.com/christmas-specials/2022/12/20/indias-movement-to-protect-cows-is-rooted-in-politics-not-religion">political weapon</a>.</p><p>Since the advent of the nationalist, majoritarian BJP government in 2014, there have been active <a href="https://www.outlookindia.com/national/cow-products-from-an-exalted-position-in-indian-psyche-to-all-over-the-marketplace-magazine-256890">governmental efforts to promote the benefits of the holy cow and cow products</a> among Indians and even globally. While this unbridled promotion has received some <a href="https://www.science.org/content/article/indian-scientists-decry-infuriating-scheme-study-benefits-cow-dung-urine-and-milk">pushback from Indian scientists</a> , it remains the unfortunate truth that the average Indian remains in the thrall of the cow.</p><p>This promotion of medicinal benefits of cow dung and cow urine increased manifold, as the killer Covid virus wreaked havoc in its second coming. Even <a href="https://www.deccanherald.com/india/panchagavya-havan-can-check-coronavirus-bjp-mp-815543.html">elected Members of Parliament</a>, on the floor of the Lok sabha (the Indian Parliament), advocated for the use of “<a href="https://ajpsonline.com/HTMLPaper.aspx?Journal=Asian%20Journal%20of%20Research%20in%20Pharmaceutical%20Sciences;PID=2015-5-2-9">Panchagavya havan”, (purifying fires by smoldering five products of the cow — dung, urine, milk, curd and ghee)</a> to counter the Corona virus! And terrified Indians — in the face of a horrifying viral pandemic and unaided by an overburdened, broken health care system, with little access to doctors and hospitals — turned to this well known, most trusted, age-old ‘remedy’ to stay safe, especially by <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/coronavirus-outbreak/story/fumes-fill-belgaum-streets-karnataka-bjp-mla-abhay-patil-carries-out-havan-ward-off-covid-19-watch-1807061-2021-05-26">‘sanitizing the air with smoke from cow dung havans to drive away the Corona’</a>.</p><p>It was never “a few individuals”! <em>No, sir!</em></p><p>If our hypothesis is correct, <strong>cow dung havans during Covid</strong> must have exposed innumerable Indians (regardless of whether or not they personally attended these rituals — since the smoke from the burning dung can be dispersed to great distances!) to huge air-borne spore loads of Mucorales. In both rural and urban communities. Faced with this massive spore burden, vulnerable Indians, (especially the diabetic, immunocompromised and those treated with steroids), their immunity already challenged by the vicious Delta strain of Covid, could potentially have easily succumbed to mucormycosis. Reminding again: “<strong><em>The risk of acquiring Invasive Mold Infections (IMI) varies according to the level of individual exposure to fungal spores</em></strong>.”</p><p>Please check out <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">our hypothesis references 25–28 and 35–39</a> where we draw likely causal associations between burning of cow dung in different Indian communities to subsequent clusters of CAM in the same areas.</p><p>Add to this the fact that <a href="https://news.abplive.com/photo-gallery/news/in-pics-people-across-india-perform-holika-dahan-amid-covid-19-restrictions-1450576"><strong>Holika Dahan </strong>— involving huge bonfires, most with cow dung patties included among the combustibles — was celebrated across India</a>, even in cities like Mumbai, on <strong>March 28, 2021, just weeks before the peaking of India’s CAM epidemic</strong>. (I have hypothesized on the likely crucial role of Indian festivals burning cow dung on India’s long-standing tryst with mucormycosis in this <a href="https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/does-the-threat-of-mucormycosis-stalk-indian-festivals-3de0a672b3d1">Medium article published December, 2021</a>.)</p><p><a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/delhi/2-delhi-civic-bodies-approve-use-of-cow-dung-for-cremation-of-bodies-amid-surge-in-covid-deaths/articleshow/82373755.cms">Crematoriums in many parts, including Delhi, used cow dung</a> along with wood, to keep up with the mounting Covid deaths.</p><p>If the smoke from all this burning cow dung did carry fungal spores, as we hypothesize, then gauge the enormity of the damned lie in trying to dismiss this hypothesis on the role of cow dung and its fumes with petulant whines in the DLE, like ‘<em>a few individuals from a population of 1.4 billion’</em> or ‘<em>mucormycosis was highly prevalent in the urban areas where cow dung was not used’</em>!!</p><p>International readers and academicians not familiar with India’s intimate cultural association with cows and its excreta, can turn to so-called ‘<a href="https://www.informaticsjournals.com/index.php/jnr/article/view/26653/20405">science journals’ of alternative medicines</a> to get in depth and ‘peer-reviewed’ knowledge on this connection. This one with statements like “<em>Henceforth, cow was confirmed to be the mammal whose urine and dung are pure, without toxins</em>,” and “<em>Cow dung contains anti-fungal compound. It inhibits the growth of Corophilous fungi</em>” (<em>sic)</em> makes for interesting and very disturbing reading.</p><p>6. <strong>The Corroborating Studies that have been published since the CAM epidemic</strong>:</p><p>1 Another country that had a smaller but similarly terrifying CAM outbreak, was Iran, and I had, <a href="https://x.com/JessySkaria/status/1439484740831223818?s=20">at the time, hypothesized on the role of <strong><em>anbarnesa</em></strong></a><strong><em> (female donkey dung and its fumes)</em></strong>, which has similar cultural importance in Iran as cow dung and its smoke in India, as a probable key factor there.</p><p><a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8837871/">Iranian doctors have since published a study</a> on this connection!</p><p>They have cultured Mucorales from a sample of Anbarnesa used by a CAM patient and concludes: “<em>I</em><strong><em>n addition to the experimental data, our clinical experiences showed that many patients with CAM used Anbarnesa in the course of SARS-COV2 infection.”</em></strong></p><p>Now, this study also exposes the ignorance or another damned lie of the DLE authors when they state: “<em>To our knowledge, no case of mucormycosis (neither in published literature nor news articles) has ever been associated with the burning of animal dung.”</em></p><p>2 It is interesting to note how the DLE authors keep citing their own studies as proof that environmental factors and cow dung had no role in India’s CAM epidemic, while completely ignoring a major retrospective <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36790120/">study from Delhi that indicated the convergence of clinical and environmental factors in India’s CAM epidemic!</a></p><p><strong><em>As mentioned earlier, this study demonstrated that “the environmental fungal spore count in the Delhi NCR region was at its highest in the 3–4 weeks preceding the peak of CAM cases in their hospital”, (starting on March 29th, 2021). This coincides with the same 3–4 weeks after Holika Dahan (on March 28) when heaps of cow dung were burnt in the same region! This, in my opinion, is a huge validation of our hypothesis</em></strong>, though, predictably, that study too avoids any mention of cow dung or its fumes or Holika Dahan, and gives full credit for the increased environmental spore load to “<em>increasing temperature, high evaporation and decreasing relative humidity</em>”! Thankfully, dealing with India-rubber men (and women) has also afforded me the advantage of understanding their compulsions to be convoluted<em>.</em></p><p>3 This brilliant paper, “<a href="https://academic.oup.com/gbe/article/15/4/evad046/7079964">Divergent Evolution of Early Terrestrial Fungi Reveals the Evolution of Mucormycosis Pathogenicity Factors</a>” has opened up new avenues of possible research into the pathogenesis of mucormycosis, and I feel, it indirectly supports our hypothesis with its path-breaking findings<strong><em>: the most relevant being the discovery of the CotH domain, the mucormycosis pathogenicity factor, in the anaerobic gut fungi, Neocallimastigomycota. Which, of course, are found in large numbers in cattle dung!</em></strong></p><p>“Interestingly, the CotH domain (PF08757), a potential invasin factor of Mucormycosis, was found in Mortierellomycotina, Basidiobolus, and Neocallimastigomycota genomes, but had previously only been described in the Mucoromycotina.”</p><p>“The CotH was suggested to be directly involved in interactions between Mucorales pathogens and human endothelial cells.”</p><p>“The results are informative to guide clinical practice as Mucormycosis may arise from many previously less documented situations, including the injuries during natural disasters, <strong><em>unconscious contact</em></strong>, and triggered by other diseases like Novel Coronavirus Pneumonia (caused by COVID-19).”</p><p>“On the other hand, Neocallimastigomycota members produce surprisingly high numbers of CotH domains with the largest duplication event. It is not clear why anaerobic gut fungi maintain so many CotH copies since they serve as primary plant polysaccharide degraders and do not pose any identifiable harm to their mammal hosts.”</p><p><strong><em>If even anaerobic gut fungi like Neocallimastigomycota, abundant in herbivore dung, have the capability to cause mucormycosis, is it any wonder that two countries that culturally use herbivore dung and its smoke excessively (through conscious and unconscious contact), India and Iran, are also the two countries that exploded with CAM?</em></strong></p><p>Our hypothesis is not a damned lie, nor a waste of time and resources, when it can tie up with pathbreaking research studies like these, and will one day, hopefully, be proven as the crucial medical observation that would help in mass prevention of Invasive Fungal Infections. In fact, I believe that in an ideal world, <a href="https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/one-dung-to-bind-them-all-410ee7d86a0c">Neglected Dung Diseases (NDD), affecting the most underprivileged of the world,</a> warrants immediate attention from global health organizations like the WHO. But since this world is neither ideal nor much interested in the health of the underprivileged, I have little hope of anyone acting proactively. And hence, for what it is worth, I will keep pushing, irrespective of the blatant stonewalling by academia. Unsavory labels like <em>Crazy</em> or <em>Damned Lies</em> will only help further motivate me. Because I totally believe that the truth will emerge triumphant someday.</p><p>Now let us analyze <strong>the two studies cited by and performed by the DLE authors that purportedly ‘do not prove the role of cow dung or its burning in CAM’.</strong></p><p><strong>A.</strong> The first study, “<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/">Could cattle dung burning have contributed to the epidemic of COVID‐19‐associated mucormycosis in India</a>?” was done by the DLE authors <em>et al </em>in March-April 2022.</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “To investigate this novel hypothesis, we <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/">conducted an aero-mycological study to evaluate the role of cattle dung burning in mucormycosis</a>” <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/">[Ref. 44].</a></p><p>This was a sound pilot study — <em>I will give them that.</em></p><p>Though the conclusion is par for the course for DLE interpretation: “<em>We found no significant increase in the proportion of air samples growing Mucorales during or after burning cattle dung cake than that before.</em> <em>It seems unlikely that cattle dung burning contributes to the occurrence of mucormycosis</em>.”</p><p>Thus, prima facie, it discredits our hypothesis. But interestingly, this study does corroborate our hypothesis — in many ways.</p><p>Let me try to explain:</p><p>1· The study proves the richness of Mucorales in Indian cow dung — with <strong><em>isolation of Mucorales from 75% of fresh and 50% of dry Indian cattle dung samples tested</em></strong>! Remember, a damned lie spread among the 1.4 billion Indians is that <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/22/world/asia/india-cow-exam-curriculum.html">Indian or <em>Desi </em>cows are holy and that their dung and urine are pure and without pathogens, even though foreign cows might be different</a>. So, this study, the first academic isolation of Mucorales from Indian cow dung, (<a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1488710701560606722?s=20">I have also privately arrived at the same conclusion</a> from Indian cow dung patties bought through Amazon, and analysed in an academic lab in the USA), should itself have been the beginning of scientific, fact-based pushback against such terrible myths, and should have activated a cascade of research into the likely role of cattle dung in India’s mucormycosis woes, as we have hypothesized. Evidently, that didn’t happen!</p><p>2· The study demonstrated Mucorales are present in the air of homes that regularly burn cow dung as cooking fuel — as proved by <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/table/myc13487-tbl-0001/?report=objectonly">their presence before, during and after burning the dung</a> for the study.</p><p>3· The study demonstrated that the <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/table/myc13487-tbl-0002/?report=objectonly">average spore counts in homes with cattle are much more (almost 100 fold more) than those in homes without cattle.</a></p><p>4· The study is truly a testament to the ubiquitous nature of cattle dung in rural India: “<em>We randomly selected 22 houses from three villages of Haryana, India (rural), where cattle rearing and related activities, including dried cattle dung cake preparation, storage and use, are routinely practiced</em>.” The images provided in the study are also visual proof of the same.</p><p>In all, this is a pilot study that begs for urgent bigger, better, pan-Indian and international studies on this likely cause of the spread of Mucorales and other fungal spores from a substrate used extensively in India: dung and the smoke from burning dung.</p><p>Especially considering the wanton and promoted use of cow dung, particularly for fuel and rituals and festivals at all times in India, and not just during Covid, and the likely high risk it poses to the large cohort of immunocompromised and diabetic Indians.</p><p>Especially knowing that “<em>India can be considered the ‘diabetes capital’ of the world, and uncontrolled diabetes mellitus is the most common predisposing factor associated with mucormycosis in India</em>”- and all these vulnerable diabetic and pre-diabetic Indians are being unsuspectingly exposed to Mucorales rich cow dung and its fumes, on a regular, day-to-day basis! Especially knowing that, in total ignorance of the danger lurking in the dung and its fumes, in complete faith that it is good for them, these vulnerable, diabetic and pre-diabetic (and immunocompromised) Indians might actively expose themselves to dung and plumes of its smoke!</p><p>Especially knowing that India regularly contributes 70–80% of the global case burden of mucormycosis, and here, in this rich, abundant source, cow dung, we might have an answer to, <em>“Why? Why is it so disproportionately high in India?”</em></p><p>But what do these ‘experts’ do? They and their Western co-conspirators <a href="https://twitter.com/seidel_dani/status/1572878857908391936?t=biQGQrOt-8JcmzJ5FCO78g&amp;s=19">shout from the podiums of international mycological conferences</a>: The Indian experts have done The Study <em>(in 22 households! In a population of 1.4 billion, as they keep reminding in the DLE!</em>). And we now know conclusively that cow dung and its smoke had nothing to do with India’s CAM epidemic! Let’s have a huge round of applause for ‘disproving’ this unpalatable hypothesis!</p><p><em>Damned, damned lies and Desperate Cover-up!</em></p><p>The explanations given by these ‘experts’ on how this lone aero-mycological study sufficed to conclusively dismiss our hypothesis are:</p><p>a) <em>Mucorales were present in the air even before burning dung!</em></p><p>Remember- most of these houses regularly burn cow dung cakes for cooking! And normally have plenty of cow dung drying in the house, on the walls or in the yard! But these experts count the Mucorales present in such air, before they did the experimental burning of the dung, as having nothing to do with dung!!</p><p>b) <em>The most common Mucorales isolated from soil and dung samples was L. corymbifera, while R. arrhizus was the most common species isolated from indoor air samples. In contrast, Lichtheimia was the predominant species in air samples after and during the combustion of cattle dung cakes. Infection by Lichtheimia corymbifera was not encountered excessively during the CAM outbreak in India. Rather, Rhizopus arrhizus was the most commonly isolated agent (&gt;60%) like that seen before the COVID-19 pandemic, and Lichtheimia infection remains rare. Hence, we consider the proposed role of cow dung and its burning in mucormycosis a ‘damned lie’!</em></p><p>Err…respectfully… <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/table/myc13487-tbl-0003/?report=objectonly">the dung and soil did have Rhizopus arrhizus</a>, along with Lichtheimia, right? The dung was not a R. arrhizus repellant, was it? And where do you reckon the Rhizopus in the tested air came from? You do accept that all Mucorales are soil fungi that release spores into the air, right? So, yes, the R. arrhizus you isolated in the air of these homes too, did come from the soil — and components that make up the soil, like dung, compost, decaying vegetation… and the presence of even one R. arrhizus in the dung samples you tested should have alerted you on its possible role as a critical source for mucormycosis in India, considering our profound cultural and intimate use of dung, shouldn’t it? Especially when you know the amount of dung produced daily by the cows in India- around three million tons!</p><p>And why this step motherly attitude to poor Lichtheimia? Just because R. arrhizus has been most frequently isolated from Indian environment — probably because it is more easily aerosolized than Lichtheimia (yet<em> another exciting topic for potential new research!)</em> — does it take away all credit from Lichtheimia as a causative agent of mucormycosis in India? Even after being more thermotolerant than Rhizopus, doesn’t Lichtheimia deserve a chance to infect Indians? Or are you saying that like the harmful foreign cows and holy <em>desi </em>cows, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10056009/">foreign Lichtheimia can cause mucormycosis</a>, (“<em>In Europe and USA, Lichtheimia are the second and third most common causal fungus of mucormycosis, respectively”)</em> but <em>desi</em> Lichtheimia, by association with the <em>desi</em> holy cow dung, refuses to cause mucormycosis in Indians?!</p><p>And out of curiosity, how many cases of CAM in India had definitive species identification? When we couldn’t even provide the poor patients with enough Liposomal Amphotericin for the treatment of mucormycosis, do you expect the world to believe the damned lie that we can confidently dismiss Lichtheimia as a causative agent in India’s CAM epidemic, because our diagnostic skills at species identification even during an epidemic that broke our health care system are that superior and accurate? Have you not read international peer-reviewed papers that carry statements like, “<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8662289/">For Indian cases, species identification is rarely reported</a>”? <em>Please, have some perspective!</em></p><p>c) <em>The DLE experts magnanimously allow that these pesky Lichtheimia and Rhizopus in the dung and soil could have caused cutaneous mucormycosis, but since that was not encountered ‘excessively’ during CAM, it’s again proof that cow dung had no role in India’s CAM epidemic.</em></p><p>Let’s analyze their argument here: Spores of Mucorales, a soil fungus, are considered ubiquitous in the air/environment, and the primary mode of infection is considered inhalation. Why? Because we know these fungal spores are easily aerosolized into the atmosphere. But here, we have experts arguing that what happens in the Indian cow dung remains in the dung. Somehow, the Mucorales in the Indian cow dung never aerosolize or contribute to environmental spores that can cause the common Rhino-orbital/Rhino-orbito-cerebral mucormycosis (ROM/ROCM) or pulmonary mucormycosis among Indians. They stay quietly in the dung, to live and die in the dung, causing trouble only if an immunocompromised Indian with a cut on the skin spreads it on their skin, to cause cutaneous mucormycosis, and only that! <em>Wow! What well behaved ‘Desi’ Mucorales!!</em></p><p>This desperation to cover-up the likely aerosolization of Mucorales from dung, especially from the dried dung and dung dust ubiquitous in rural India, can also be seen in their selective mention of only the isolation of Mucorales from undried dung, and not from 50% of the dried dung samples they tested: “<em>Undried cattle dung grew Mucorales in six of the eight samples tested, and 83% of these cultures showed Lichtheimia corymbifera.” </em>Cunningly also avoiding mention of isolation of R. arrhizus from the remaining 17%, and that too from both fresh and dried dung! And <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1579476148140273665?s=20">as I have shown in this video, dried dung is friable and spreads easily as dung dust with wind</a>. So, if the authors were really interested in understanding the role (or the lack of it), of cow dung in India’s disproportionate mucormycosis woes, even if they ‘cannot prove’ the spread of Mucorales through burning of dung, they should have certainly used the findings in this pilot study to research more into the likely spread of Mucorales from the millions of tons of fresh and dried dung in India, and certainly strived to make it common knowledge among Indians that ‘<em>Desi</em> cow dung’ from <a href="https://www.krishnayangauraksha.org/holy-cows-lets-save-the-hinduisms-blessed-bovines.html">the holy Indian cows</a> also harbors dangerous pathogens like the fungi causing ‘black fungus’! That would have been a daring truth. But, instead, they are solely focused on dismissing and discouraging any further research into the role of cow dung in India’s mucormycosis crisis by labeling it “Damned Lies” and “a waste of time, efforts and resources”! This is an unpardonable crime against the Indian masses, the hapless victims of a preventable disease, and that too a most horrific one like mucormycosis!</p><p>The fact that they are mad at the CDC for mentioning animal dung on its <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/fungal/diseases/mucormycosis/causes.html">website</a>, even after their own study has proven the richness of Mucorales in cow dung, is testament to their depth of deception!</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>Several authors and news articles mention cow dung as the primary source of mucormycosis by misquoting the information available on the CDC website, which lists animal dung as one of the several possible environmental sources of Mucorales. The more common sources include decaying organic matter in the soil, such as dried leaves and compost piles [</em><a href="https://www.cdc.gov/fungal/diseases/mucormycosis/causes.html"><em>42</em></a><em>].</em></p><p>Err…, how do you know that “<em>the more common sources include decaying organic matter in the soil, such as dried leaves and compost piles</em>”? Even more than the Mucorales isolated from 75% fresh and 50% dry cow dung samples you have tested yourself? Is there a comparative study? May I see that? Sorry? Not available? Another Damned Lie? Or should I just take your word because you are the experts?</p><p>d): <em>“Rather, Rhizopus arrhizus was the most commonly isolated agent (&gt;60%) like that seen before the COVID-19 pandemic, and Lichtheimia infection remains rare.”</em></p><p>Pathetic nitpicking on the basis of species isolation in a small study on cow dung!</p><p>Let’s consider their own study: From a few one-gram samples of cow dung, the authors isolated Mucorales in 75% of the fresh and 50% of the dried samples tested. Taking only the dried samples, (the easily aerosolized ones), even ignoring their unloved Lichtheimia, the rate of isolation of the favorite R. arrhizus is 1/6 or approximately 16%. We know that <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1198743X14607205">typically one sporangium may contain up to 100000 spores</a>. Now consider just 16% of the three million tons of cow dung produced each day in India, and imagine the number of R. arrhizus spores aerosolized into the Indian air!</p><p>Before you voice that <em>‘But, cows are everywhere’ </em>argument, please bear in mind again that unlike the rest of the world, most Indians, especially those in rural communities, do not consider cow dung as waste or harmful, but as holy and beneficial, and <a href="http://conniegoestoindia.blogspot.com/2015/04/about-india-cow-dung-cakes.html">leave them openly in close proximity to human habitation</a>! By factually considering the R. arrhizus spores freely aerosolizing from 16% of these three million tons of dung left out in the open in India, each day, every day, we can estimate the truth of the impact of cow dung in increasing India’s environmental R. arrhizus spore load. And when we consider that in total, Mucorales can be isolated from 75% and 50% of fresh and dried Indian cow dung respectively, the stats become mindboggling. Add to this the dung from all other livestock in India! <em>Holy Shit!</em> It is this potentially enormous source of Mucorales (including R. arrhizus) that these experts want ignored — completely — as ‘Damned Lies’, because the isolation of R. arrhizus was less than Lichtheimia in their samples from a few grams of cow dung in a study of 22 households!</p><p>I consider this unpardonable medical neglect!</p><p>Even as Indians suffer so disproportionately from this terrible disease. Not just during Covid. But always!</p><p>And that brings us to the next cover-up in the DLE: the phrase — <strong><em>“like that seen before the Covid-19 Pandemic”.</em></strong></p><p>“<em>Rather, Rhizopus arrhizus was the most commonly isolated agent (&gt;60%) </em>like that seen before the COVID-19 pandemic<em>, and Lichtheimia infection remains rare.”</em></p><p><em>Yes, sir! </em>Couldn’t it be because the excessive and intimate use of cow dung was always a problem in India, and almost certainly the biggest contributor of environmental Mucorales, including Rhizopus arrhizus, in India, not just during Covid, but before Covid too?! And because of the cowardice of ‘experts’ who dare not speak the truth, continuing unabated even after Covid?!</p><p>Again, as the DLE itself accidentally concedes: “<em>The rearing of cows, the use of cow-dung cakes as fuels, and several other cultural practices have been present in India for several centuries</em>”!</p><p>Yes indeed, <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6462913/">India has always had an ongoing mucormycosis crisis, before Covid</a> —during Covid and after Covid — <strong><em>due to an environment excessively loaded with Mucorales spores, most likely a direct consequence of India’s centuries old cultural practices of excessive usage of cow dung and its fumes.</em></strong></p><p>And that is <strong>The</strong> <strong>Daring Truth.</strong></p><p>The problem is politics and religion and economic interests — not science, definitely not science — demanding that the truth be labelled the Damned Lie.</p><p>e) “<em>There was no statistically significant difference between the proportion of indoor air samples growing Mucorales from houses with and without cattle</em>.”</p><p>Points to be noted here:</p><p>1. The study is said to be done between March 1 and April 30, 2022. Holika Dahan, 2022, was on March 17. Hence, if the sampling was done after Holika Dahan, when cow dung bonfires would have been burnt everywhere in the study region, even in urban areas, it is not surprising that there was no statistically significant difference between the houses with and without cattle.</p><p>2. Please note that the above numbers are comparing the <strong><em>culture (growth on laboratory media) </em></strong>of Mucorales fungi from air samples in the houses with and without cattle (16.7% vs 14.3%) — <a href="https://theconversation.com/better-diagnostics-for-fungal-infections-are-badly-needed-heres-why-80162">a notoriously difficult process</a>. However, while pointing out the above statistics on similar isolation of Mucorales, why is the study hesitant in noting <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/table/myc13487-tbl-0002/?report=objectonly">their own finding of almost 100-fold increase in <strong><em>average spore count in the air samples</em></strong> from the homes with cattle?</a> (0.013 × 10⁴ vs 0.001 × 10³)</p><p>3. Unlike what is claimed by the authors, it is not just ownership of cattle that equates to proximity to cattle (and its excreta and smoke from burning dung), especially in rural India, since the cattle usually roam wherever they please, and cow dung is used by most, irrespective of cattle ownership.</p><p>f) “<em>While the soil obtained from the cattle shed did not grow Mucorales, almost all the other soil samples from rural or urban areas grew Mucorales</em>.”</p><p>Why have the authors stated this damned lie in that paper? Their own <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/table/myc13487-tbl-0003/?report=objectonly">Table 3</a> shows that one sample out of the six soil samples tested from the cattle shed (16.7%) <strong><em>did grow</em></strong> Mucorales, which was identified as Lichtheimia corymbifera. Also, the average spore count in the cattle shed is high. So, why the lie in the discussion? Is it because these ‘experts’ know that, as with references in the DLE, tables and figures and statistics are also likely less rigorously evaluated by the average medical reader, who usually just believes the interpretation by the researchers? A willful attempt at a Damned Lie even in that study? Not surprising at all, considering their focused aim since India’s CAM epidemic is to somehow convince readers that mucormycosis has nothing to do with cows or anything remotely bovine!</p><p>In view of the extreme bias of the DLE authors who have now openly stated that our hypothesis is a ‘<em>waste of time, resources and efforts’</em>, I really feel all their studies/papers on this issue should be reevaluated by global experts with a healthy dose of skepticism, rather than as the last word coined to dismiss our hypothesis!</p><p><strong>B.</strong> A study aimed to know <a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/myc.13604">if Cattle Dung Exposure (CDE) was associated with Pulmonary Mucormycosis (PM) in subjects with Diabetes Mellitus</a> (DM). (<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/myc.13604">Reference: 40</a>)</p><p>Rather than the conclusions drawn by the study authors, (“<em>Cattle dung exposure was not associated with PM in subjects with DM. Instead, male sex, poor glycaemic control, COVID-19 and the type of housing were associated with pulmonary mucormycosis</em>.”) which again, <strong>includes our DLE authors</strong>, what I would like to focus in this study is the percentage of cases and controls exposed to cattle dung, the primary exposure they were supposed to be studying<strong><em>. A staggering 87.2% of the cases and 83.3 % of the controls had cattle dung exposure!</em></strong></p><p>Now, first, if this doesn’t bust the damned lie of the DLE authors that the cow dung hypothesis is wrong because only <em>‘a few individuals from a population of 1.4 billion’</em> were exposed to cow dung during CAM epidemic, what would? In India, unlike in most other countries, the population who are consciously and unconsciously in intimate contact with cows/cattle and their excreta and dung fumes is astronomical. As demonstrated in this study by the same authors! 83–87% of their study population was exposed to cattle dung! And that is why cow dung, a rich source of Mucorales, attains crucial importance in the Indian context! Which, unfortunately, also has huge political, economic and religious relevance, and hence most ‘experts’ are keener to make the world look away from dung, rather than upset this delicate Indian socio-religious and economic ‘dung’cart!</p><p>And how, after 87.2% of cases had <strong>Cattle Dung Exposure (CDE),</strong> did these ‘experts’ come to the conclusion that CDE is not statistically significant? Because 83.3% of the controls also had CDE! The mind boggles!!</p><p>Remind me again. What is the total number of confirmed Indian Covid patients? Around <a href="https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/india/">44 million</a>? Of these, how many got CAM? Around <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9212773/">50,000</a>? <strong><em>0.11% !</em></strong> But hey, we have Indian &amp; global experts stressing on the ‘immune dysregulation’ caused during Covid increasing the susceptibility of Covid patients (magically, mainly, only Indian Covid patients), to mucormycosis! Don’t get me wrong. I also agree Covid was a contributing factor, and its role needs to be studied in detail. <em>But the damned hypocrisy!</em> 99.89% of Indians with COVID (with or without diabetes), per official numbers, did not contract CAM. And yet, <strong>the DLE</strong> states: “<em>While several environmental or host factors were proposed and discussed during the CAM outbreak in India, </em><strong><em>the unevaluated and most crucial factor is likely coronavirus</em></strong><em>.</em>” Turning around then, and declaring the hypothesis on Cattle Dung Exposure (CDE) as a factor in CAM a damned lie, since many Indians with diabetes exposed to cattle dung did not contract pulmonary mucormycosis, is simply beyond any kind of common sense or medical sense!</p><p>In a similar vein<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9540166/">, the Iranian study provided as Reference 59 by the DLE</a>, shows how a comparable proportion of the cases of CAM and controls without CAM received dexamethasone: 86.9% vs 88.5%. “<em>Also, 113 (86.9%) and 46 (88.5%) patients had received dexamethasone, at the constant dose of 6–8 mg/d for five days in CAM and control groups, respectively; which did not show any significant difference (P-value = 0.778).”</em> Yet, steroids too are considered a key factor in CAM by experts and not dismissed as “Damned Lie”! (Again, I agree that steroids did play a crucial role in CAM, and their role needs to be highlighted, not dismissed as Damned Lie, just because everyone who received steroids for Covid didn’t end up with CAM!)</p><p>But somehow, cow dung is different! <strong><em>Cow dung is the only factor that gets dismissed as “Damned Lie” because it can be argued by shameless experts as either ‘only a few Indians used it’ or ‘a lot of Indians</em></strong><em>, </em><strong><em>with and without CAM were exposed to it</em>”!</strong> Oh, yeah! That is the privilege of being an ‘expert’. Heads I win, tails you lose! <em>Humbug!</em></p><p>In the same study they say living in <em>Kutcha </em>houses is associated with Pulmonary mucormycosis. What the DLE does not say is that in India, especially in rural India, <a href="https://gosmartbricks.com/why-indians-put-cow-dung-on-the-walls-of-their-home/"><em>kutcha</em> houses are more likely to have cow dung</a> in significant proximity, even used as building materials on the walls or floors of most homes!</p><p>And I love the concluding statement of this study, echoing the DLE sentiment: “<em>Notably, more research on the host factors and the immune mechanisms underlying invasive mucormycosis is required rather than focusing on environmental sources.”</em> A desperate <em>move-along-nothing-to-see-here</em> attempt at concealing the truth!</p><p>At this point, it’s extremely interesting to track the <strong><em>rapid pro to anti environment evolution </em></strong>of the DLE authors, especially of Prof. Arunaloke Chakrabarti, in the short time span of 2 years, from 2021 to 2023:</p><p><strong><em>Stage 1. Full Pro!</em></strong></p><p>Published Jun 24, 2021: “<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8222941/">The recent mucormycosis storm over Indian sky”</a>. <strong>Quote</strong>: “<em>The four major issues may be highlighted to explain the present situation (CAM): diabetes, steroid, COVID-19, and environment.” “The fourth factor is environmental prevalence for Mucorales in India. Mucorales spores had been detected at 0.68–1.12 ​cfu/cubic meter in indoor and 0.73–8.60 ​cfu/cubic meter in outdoor air of India with predominance of main pathogenic species Rhizopus arrhizus. </em><strong><em>These high spore count in air allows the entry of spore in the respiratory tract of vulnerable patients causing mucormycosis</em></strong><em>.</em>”</p><p><strong><em>Stage 2. Partly Pro!</em></strong> Not during CAM, but before and after CAM!</p><p>Published Jul 7, 2022: “<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9350001/">Could Cattle Dung Burning have contributed to CAM in India: An aeromycological study</a>.”</p><p><strong>Quote</strong>: “<em>A high environmental burden of Mucorales in India is well recognised. It possibly explains that the country accounted for &gt;80% of the global burden of mucormycosis </em><strong><em>before and after</em></strong><em> the COVID‐19 pandemic.”</em></p><p><strong><em>Stage 3. Anti!</em></strong></p><p>Published May 16, 2023: “<a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/myc.13604">Risk factors for pulmonary mucormycosis in subjects with diabetes mellitus — A case-control study.</a>” The Cattle Dung Exposure study discussed above.</p><p><strong>Quote</strong>: “<em>Notably, more research on the host factors and the immune mechanisms underlying invasive mucormycosis is required rather than focusing on environmental sources.”</em></p><p><strong><em>Stage 4. Very Anti!</em></strong></p><p><strong>Damned Lies Editorial </strong>published on May 24, 2023!</p><p><strong>Quote</strong>: “<em>The ubiquitous presence of fungal spores is insufficient to result in disease and compromised host immunity or an altered net state of immunosuppression, which is probably the most critical factor underlying invasive mucormycosis.</em>”</p><p>Sad regression, and of course, ‘<em>No man has a good enough memory to be a successful liar</em>’!</p><p>Since the appearance of the dung genie in India’s CAM environment, this has become the standard whining plea of the Indian experts to the international mycology community: Ignore the environment. Don’t look at it. We have nice juicy Covid, Diabetes, Steroids. Take your pick. Repeat the mantra: ‘CAM epidemic in India was due to host factors, and host factors alone, with Covid and its treatment with steroids among a huge diabetic population, playing the pivotal role in compromising host immunity and providing favorable hyperglycemia for the fungi to thrive. Mucorales are ubiquitous, they are everywhere and had no additional role in India. Hence, considering environmental factors is a waste of time and efforts. And considering cow dung is a damned lie!’ Believe! Don’t question!</p><p>And for those with an iota of common sense, who suspect something in India must be responsible for its disproportionate caseload of mucormycosis, apart from the well-known host factors, the Indian experts are ready to throw in anything and everything that could stick, (for the record: I am all for more research into any suspected factor, however unlikely — since mucormycosis is a disease that should be prevented at all costs): from <a href="https://www.cnbctv18.com/healthcare/doctors-suspect-overuse-of-zinc-and-iron-increases-risk-of-black-fungus-infection-9440491.htm">Zinc</a> to <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8805480/">dirty masks</a> to <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/coronavirus-outbreak/story/black-fungus-cases-industrial-oxygen-cylinders-humidifiers-covid-19-1807099-2021-05-26">humidifiers</a> to <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8810519/">A/C vents</a> to <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0255085723000981#bib22">genetic factors</a> to <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">unproven therapies during Covid</a>. And if you are mulish and insist there must be something unique in the air in India, then <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/not-cow-dung-or-medical-oxygen-but-filthy-environment-behind-mucor-spread-expert/articleshow/96745378.cms">blame India’s filthy environment</a> (<em>to hell with nationalism</em>)! But, please, please don’t ask what makes India’s environment filthy and loaded with Mucorales. And never, ever think of the cow or its dung!</p><p><em>Cut the bullshit, please!</em></p><p>At this point it is worthwhile analyzing two factors featured in the DLE, as added reasons for India’s CAM epidemic:</p><p>i) Systemic Predisposition:</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>Contrarily, the case mix of invasive mucormycosis in India remained like that before the COVID-19 pandemic, indicating a systemic predisposition to mucormycosis than a local factor.”</em></p><p>As if systemic predisposition factors are present only in India! In <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22#:~:text=Specifically%2C%20we%20hypothesize%20that%20Mucorales,role%20in%20India&#39;s%20CAM%20epidemic.">our hypothesis</a>, we have already busted this false claim. In the case of Diabetes Mellitus (DM), while India certainly has a large number of diabetics and prediabetics, statistically, that ratio, 8–10% of global diabetics, is nowhere as calamitous as the 70–80% of global mucormycosis burden that we bear! While diabetics globally were more prone to severity and complications from Covid, only the diabetics in India were so disproportionately affected by CAM. <em>Why?</em></p><p>The cunning DLE is ready for that question:</p><p>ii) Genetic Factors:</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>Unknown genetic factors might be responsible for the high burden of mucormycosis in India</em>”!</p><p>Hmm… These are ‘experts’ exasperated at our hypothesis wasting their ‘valuable time and resources’! But they are seriously considering researching into ‘unknown genetic factors among Indians’! <em>By all means, please carry on</em>. Seriously. As said before, I am of the opinion that any research into likely or unlikely causes of mucormycosis is more welcome than dismissing them as “Damned Lies”.</p><p>Though, I will leave the reader to gauge the enormity of this diversionary tactic, by pointing out the fact that <a href="https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/countries-with-the-most-emigrants-living-abroad.html">Indians form the biggest group of global emigrants</a>. We are everywhere, all over the world. But the disproportionate tendency for mucormycosis remains stubbornly with the Indians still living in India. Strange, don’t you think, these genetic factors disappearing as we cross the borders?! (And if you do see an international Indian patient with mucormycosis, I think that Indian is more likely to have visited India in the near past or bought cow dung through Amazon; or might be occupationally/recreationally exposed to soil, compost, manure or livestock; or more likely to have the well-known universal host risk factors for invasive fungal diseases like diabetes or immunocompromise, rather than any unknown genetic susceptibility to mucormycosis! <em>But, hey, I am no expert!</em>)</p><p>Another interesting fact: Our hypothesis has also noted the regional differences in the mucormycosis burden within India, based on the regional differences in the use of cow excreta. A clear example is Kerala- <a href="https://cadiresearch.org/topic/diabetes-indians/diabetes-keralal">the Diabetic capital of India</a>, which had <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-58054124">very high numbers of Covid cases</a>, and yet, had <a href="https://twitter.com/Lalitha_Ranjani/status/1421786773076643840?s=20">minimal cases of Covid-associated mucormycosis</a>. The reason — we propose, is <a href="https://www.outlookindia.com/national/where-the-divisive-politics-of-holy-cow-has-no-place-magazine-256804">because Keralites rightly consider cow as just another animal</a> and cow dung as a waste product, more in line with the rest of the world. And it is almost never burnt as a cooking fuel or in rituals or festivals in Kerala. (Disclaimer…I am a proud Keralite.) But it was noted that many Keralites who were living in different parts of India, <a href="https://www.newindianexpress.com/cities/kochi/2022/mar/07/kochi-woman-beats-black-fungusreturns-home-in-good-health-2427139.html">outside Kerala, did contract mucormycosis</a>. Err….those Keralites probably inherited the “Indian mucormycosis genetic factors” from the air as they crossed the Kerala border, I guess!</p><p>It bears repeating, how <strong><em>in a strange Freudian twist, the DLE itself gives the reason why India had the unique CAM epidemic, and how it is a direct extension of a long-standing problem in India:</em></strong></p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong><em>: “The rearing of cows, the use of cow-dung cakes as fuels, and several other cultural practices have been present in India for several centuries, and it is imprudent to proclaim that these practices led to an outbreak of nearly 50,000 cases over four months following the COVID-19 pandemic without any supporting data</em>.”</p><p><em>Dear oh dear….</em> how could Prof. Chakrabarti forget incriminating statistics about India’s mucormycosis caseload from his own earlier papers when making such sweeping statements about India’s unique and long-standing cultural association with cows and cow dung? One of his papers from 2019 (before COVID) gives <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6462913/">an estimate of India’s annual prevalence of mucormycosis as 900,000 cases</a>, which translates as 300,000 cases over four months!! (6 times more than the CAM cases in four months!) It is also well known that India contributes 70–80% of the global burden of mucormycosis regularly, even pre-Covid. <strong>And here we have experts who have proven the presence of Mucorales in the Indian cow dung, who have shown that India has a high environmental load of Mucorales, who admit that India has a centuries-old bond with cows and use of cow dung, and yet, vehemently deny that cow and cow dung (and indeed all of the environment!) have any role in India’s CAM epidemic!!</strong></p><p><em>Credible experts indeed!!</em></p><p>P.S: Speaking of experts and hypocrisy, whenever experts jump through hoops to declare that cow dung has nothing to do with India’s mucormycosis crisis or CAM epidemic, because we are “yet to prove a direct causal link” with this proposed environmental factor, I marvel at their shameless hypocrisy. These same experts and premier health organizations have no hesitation in warning (<em>rightly so!</em>) about <strong>the role of bird and bat guano in Histoplasmosis</strong> — even though, after decades of research, they are yet to conclusively prove a direct causal link. The warnings continue to be based more on epidemiological connections. As seen in this helpful <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/histoplasmosis/environment.html">CDC warning</a>: <strong><em>For any accumulations of bird or bat droppings</em></strong><em>, soil, or other environmental material suspected to be contaminated with Histoplasma, </em><strong><em>the safest approach is to assume the material is contaminated, take exposure precautions, and remediate it accordingly</em></strong>.</p><p>Followed by an explanation on how difficult it is to establish a direct causal link: “<em>Detecting Histoplasma in environmental samples can be challenging. Routine environmental sampling for Histoplasma is not recommended, although research is needed to evaluate potential targeted testing strategies. Focused polymerase chain reaction (PCR) or culture testing can help confirm a suspected environmental source during a histoplasmosis outbreak. In outbreak settings without a clear exposure, large-scale environmental testing is unlikely to be useful. </em><strong><em>In outbreak settings with a very clear exposure, environmental testing may not be necessary, particularly if the results would not change public health recommendations to prevent future cases</em>.</strong> <strong><em>Also, an environmental sample that tests negative for Histoplasma does not necessarily mean that the fungus is not present or was not present at the time the exposure occurred.”</em></strong></p><p>And here we have India’s ongoing mucormycosis crisis and India’s disproportionate use of a <strong><em>proven </em></strong>Mucorales-rich substrate — cow dung. <strong><em>And the setting of an outbreak (CAM) with very clear exposure to cow dung and its fumes. And yet, there is </em>not one public advisory <em>from experts or health organizations that the safest approach to prevent mucormycosis is to assume animal dung is contaminated, and take exposure precautions accordingly.</em></strong></p><p><em>Why?</em></p><p>What makes mucormycosis and its patient profile not worthy of the same safety precautions advanced to histoplasmosis and its patient profile? “<em>East is East, and West is West, and never the twain shall meet….”</em></p><p>What makes bird and bat guano easily acceptable as likely causative agents for Histoplasma while there is so much resistance to looking into animal/cow dung as likely agents for mucormycosis? “<em>Faith: not wanting to know what is true</em>.”</p><p>An excellent example of what happens when market-driven and socio-religious agendas turn evidence-based medicine into evidence-suppressed medicine? “<em>Science, money and politics, all manipulate one another</em>.”</p><p>This cruel apathy among the global medical community is simply unacceptable!</p><p><strong><em>Principal DLE Lie #4: </em></strong><em>All the debate on the role of cow excreta in India’s CAM epidemic started with a viral morphed article, and hence all such ‘misinformation’ is Damned Lies.</em></p><p><strong><em>My rebuttal:</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>Did a viral morphed article start the misinformation extravaganza about cows and mucormycosis?</em></strong></p><p>Not at all.</p><p>This seemingly small, but crucial DLE lie needs to be busted, to expose the enormity of diligent fraudulence perpetrated in this Editorial.</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>How did the misinformation begin? Mucormycosis, now widely addressed by the general public as ‘black fungus,’ was mentioned in a viral social media post claiming ‘Indian scientists link cow urine to 9000 cases of mucormycosis.’ </em><a href="https://www.altnews.in/morphed-bbc-article-links-black-fungus-with-cow-urine/"><em>[24</em></a><em>]. Replete with grammatical and factual errors [24], the morphed article led to a widespread debate on the topic and marked the beginning of the misinformation extravaganza {23, 25, 26].”</em></p><p>As far as I can ascertain, this viral social media post (<em>not a morphed article in actual fact, but a </em><a href="https://twitter.com/Nabinawaz_/status/1397259043685629952?s=20"><em>morphed screenshot</em></a>), highlighted by the DLE, started doing the rounds on May 25, 2021 (<a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-57217246">the original BBC article</a> from which this fake was morphed was only published on 23rd May, 2021) and was <a href="https://www.thequint.com/news/webqoof/morphed-bbc-article-used-to-link-black-fungus-cases-to-cow-urine#read-more">quickly debunked by fact checkers,</a> the author of the original article, and the BBC itself, by the very next day, May 26, 2021. While fake news can spread despite debunking, the DLE’s desperate attempt to show this morphed screenshot as “the beginning of the misinformation extravaganza” is a willful attempt to subvert history and create new narratives, as is the intent of this entire Damned Lies Editorial!</p><p>As conceded later on in the DLE, and in references <a href="https://www.news18.com/news/india/cow-dung-therapy-cant-beat-covid-may-actually-trigger-black-fungus-warn-doctors-3732482.html">17</a>, <a href="https://theprint.in/health/doctors-hint-at-cow-dung-black-fungus-link-as-people-turn-to-gobar-for-covid-cure/657781/">28</a> and <a href="https://news.sky.com/story/covid-19-indias-doctors-warn-against-using-cow-dung-to-ward-off-coronavirus-amid-rise-in-deadly-black-fungus-12303329">29</a>, these DLE authors are aware that expert warnings from eminent Indian doctors on the dangers of using cow dung and urine to ‘cure’ COVID, and its likely role in secondary infections including mucormycosis were loud and clear from the beginning of May, much before this viral morphed post came into being on May 25. The first major publication of this concern by Indian clinicians appeared on <a href="https://www.reuters.com/world/india/indian-doctors-warn-against-cow-dung-covid-cure-2021-05-11/">Reuters on May 10</a>, including a quote from the national president of the Indian Medical Association (IMA), Dr. J A Jayalal. On <a href="https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/india-news-cow-dung-therapy-cant-beat-covid-may-actually-trigger-black-fungus-warn-doctors/382652">13th May, Outlook directly linked cow dung therapy with ‘black fungus’</a> after interviewing prominent doctors like Dr. Mona Desai, the chairperson of the women’s wing of the IMA. The <a href="https://theprint.in/health/doctors-hint-at-cow-dung-black-fungus-link-as-people-turn-to-gobar-for-covid-cure/657781/">May 13th tweet by the Infectious Diseases expert, Dr. Faheem Younus (Ref 28)</a>, had also led to much social media discussion on the subject. Now, all these expert opinions and articles together mark the beginning of the information (not misinformation, as the authors slyly claim) on the likely connection between cow excreta used excessively by Indians during Covid, and India’s disproportionate caseload of mucormycosis at the height of the Covid second wave. <strong><em>These sensible opinions- and the shutting down of these voices soon afterwards- was exactly what piqued my interest in researching more on this likely connection</em></strong>. As evidenced by this <a href="https://www.facebook.com/jessy.skaria.2006/posts/pfbid0oh84WRAV39GArsVsLxLkyPqTHRJ68zdAku3yXuuheCxkmwzBjoc8FnrJSTf5omKl">desperate appeal I made on social media about this issue, on May 21,</a> days before the morphed post appeared.</p><p>Attributing fraudulently a critical role to a morphed social media post, that was firmly debunked in a day, and which at best might have influenced some lay people, as the beginning of the ‘widespread debate’ on the role of cow excreta in India’s CAM epidemic is a very carefully and deliberately crafted ‘damned lie’!</p><p>In an effort to establish the principal lie, the subsidiary lies continue- <a href="https://science.thewire.in/health/burning-cow-dung-india-black-fungus-epidemic-2021/">Reference 23</a>, provided as purportedly the ‘beginning of the misinformation extravaganza’ is a media article on our published hypothesis in April, 2022 — one year after the CAM epidemic!</p><p>The addition of <a href="https://despardes.com/doctors-hint-at-cow-dung-and-black-fungus-link-as-people-turn-to-gobar-as-wonder-drug-in-covid-hit-india/">Reference 25</a> is a good representation of the underhandedness of this DLE. That article was published by an online media portal after the appearance of the morphed screenshot on May 25, and hence includes that fake news. But the main body of the article, which is about eminent doctors denouncing cow dung therapy, is sourced from another mainstream media article published by <a href="https://theprint.in/health/doctors-hint-at-cow-dung-black-fungus-link-as-people-turn-to-gobar-for-covid-cure/657781/">The Print on May 14</a>, much before the morphed post came into existence. The DLE authors, to justify their lie about the timeline on ‘misinformation extravaganza beginning with the viral morphed article’, used this web copy from a later date, with the inclusion of the viral morphed post in it, as the reference in the DLE, to <strong><em>confuse readers into thinking that Indian doctors started warning on dangers of cow excreta only</em></strong> <strong><em>after</em></strong> <strong><em>the morphed post generated public interest;</em></strong> <strong><em>while the reality is the opposite</em></strong>. The amount of sly thought that must have gone into building this fake narrative is almost unbelievable! Perhaps these strenuous mental efforts confused even the diligent architects of the DLE, since they subsequently make <strong><em>the fatal flaw of exposing their awareness of the original May 14 article</em></strong>, which is used later in the DLE as <a href="https://theprint.in/health/doctors-hint-at-cow-dung-black-fungus-link-as-people-turn-to-gobar-for-covid-cure/657781/">Reference 28</a>!</p><p>An understanding of the targeted attack of the doctors who first voiced their concerns about the dangers of cow dung/urine therapies will shed light on the core purpose of this DLE, and its targeted attack on <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">our cow dung hypothesis</a> and <a href="https://americankahani.com/perspectives/poor-health-neglected-dung-diseases-in-india-urgently-need-crucial-expert-attention/">my article</a>.</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong> “<em>A hypothesis should be generated based on astute observation and interpretation of facts rather than on </em><strong><em>personal biases and prejudices</em></strong><em> [16].”</em></p><p>DLE <a href="https://americankahani.com/perspectives/poor-health-neglected-dung-diseases-in-india-urgently-need-crucial-expert-attention/">Reference 16</a> is my article, published by an online media outlet on the likely <a href="https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/one-dung-to-bind-them-all-410ee7d86a0c">role of animal dung in many less understood human diseases</a>. An extension of my research into the CAM epidemic in India, that prompted me to look into the likely harmful effects of various animal dungs and their fumes on human health, especially among the poorer and neglected people of the world. <strong><em>It is not confined to the cow. Or to India</em></strong>. And yet, this DLE labels it as based on <em>‘personal biases and prejudices’</em>. Why? Because these ‘scientists’ cannot see beyond my name, a Christian name, and in the current political scenario in India, that makes me anti-Indian, biased toward Indian/Hindu culture; my hypothesis on herbivore/cow dung hence rooted in my prejudice against the Holy Cow of Hinduism!</p><p>Nothing demonstrates <strong>this terrible anti-science slide of contemporary India </strong>as the fate of the afore-mentioned Dr. JA Jayalal, the then President of IMA: the manner in which he was viciously ‘exposed’ as a <a href="https://www.opindia.com/2021/05/dr-jayalal-modi-hate-ayurveda-ima-chief/">Christian proselytizer, his expanded Christian name, Dr. Johnrose Austin Jayalal, brought suddenly into national focus</a>, and how he was embroiled in a <a href="https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/delhi/ima-president-moves-hc-not-guilty-of-using-ima-to-propagate-christianity-7358893/">legal battle to prove his integrity</a> as a doctor and an Indian, days after he publicly denounced the use of cow dung and urine during Covid (<a href="https://www.reuters.com/world/india/indian-doctors-warn-against-cow-dung-covid-cure-2021-05-11/">quoted in Reuters</a>)!</p><p>Or how <a href="https://www.opindia.com/2021/05/public-health-experts-covid-19-cow-dung-mucormycosis-faheem-younus/">Dr. Faheem Younus was trolled so badly</a> as a fraud and a Muslim trying to belittle Hindus, after he tweeted about this same likely connection between cow dung and ‘black fungus’, that <a href="https://twitter.com/BefittingFacts/status/1395342864599576581?lang=en">he later deleted his tweet!</a></p><p>Swift retributions that ensured that no doctors in India or abroad dared speak out any more about the dangers of ‘cow dung and urine therapy’ during Covid! <strong><em>Retributions that worked so well that after mid-May, 2021, you hardly hear a whisper about such a likely connection. Except from a buzzing, irritating gadfly — yours truly!</em></strong></p><p>My status as a ‘scientific nobody’ spared me, and I could voice my hypothesis on social media. The oft-repeated, standard responses of “ubiquitous Mucorales” “host factors” “steroids”, “diabetes” and “Delta strain” stated with the narcissistic arrogance of academic standing, combined with the vicious bashing of the ‘cow dung hypothesis’ by the various <a href="https://twitter.com/raghurajs_hegde/status/1440275146665705487?s=20">‘experts’ on #MedTwitter</a>, were enough to make me sound like a repetitive, grating, broken record nobody wanted to listen to. I could be ignored easily and totally. But, getting the help of eminent co-authors, and publishing the observations as a <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">peer-reviewed hypothesis</a> in a reputed medical journal, was simply not meant to happen. Nor was it supposed to grab eyeballs as one of The Scientist’s <a href="https://www.the-scientist.com/speaking-of-science/notable-science-quotes-70065">notable science quotes of the year</a>! And still more irritating was the continuing buzzing of the gadfly on social media, even after the publication, and ‘studies’ by the DLE authors that ‘disproved the hypothesis’! The response to such shocking overarching insubordination has now taken the form of this desperate DLE, full of lies and twisted facts to try and discredit my opinions and our hypothesis, once and for all!</p><p><strong>DLE Quote</strong>: “<em>Instead, there are observational and experimental data against this hypothesis, and continuing such misinformation is unwarranted.</em>”</p><p>It is a thinly veiled warning for me: STOP!</p><p>Once the true nature of this DLE is revealed — a political and religious propaganda piece under a scientific cover — the bigotry of the authors become even more clear in disturbing sentences like the following:</p><p><strong>DLE quote</strong>: “<em>Interestingly, camel urine use for COVID-19 was discussed in some West Asian countries and received support from a few Indians for its purported medicinal value [</em><a href="https://en.radiofarda.com/a/drink-camel-urine-to-cure-coronavirus-prophetic-medicine-man-says/30565663.html"><em>30</em></a><em>,</em><a href="https://www.opindia.com/2021/05/islamic-preacher-zakir-naik-explains-the-benefits-of-drinking-camel-urine/"><em>31</em></a><em>]. While camel and cow urine remain unproven regarding their medicinal effects, cow dung was widely discussed, to the extent of being labeled as rampant [32]. Indeed, news on camels would not have been as sensational in India as an article on cows</em>.”</p><p>Unbelievable bias and bigotry for a science editorial!</p><p>a) While firmly against any hint at cow urine or dung as a likely source of mucormycosis, this DLE is whining at the low ‘sensationalism’ given to the similar likely role of camel urine!</p><p>Note, while our hypothesis stresses on the role of cow excreta used excessively in India as the critical factor in India’s excessive mucormycosis load and the CAM epidemic, its basic exploration is on the role of animal, especially, herbivore excreta (which includes camel dung and urine too) as a source of mucormycosis in humans who come in close contact with it. This is made amply clear by our reference to Iran’s use of Anbarnesa and its noticeable CAM outbreak, and in our closing sentence: “<em>Further research in these directions would hopefully establish the role of herbivore dung in the causation of CAM and lay the foundation for initiating measures to reduce the incidence of the disease.”</em></p><p>b) The above sentences and the references given in the DLE — with the worrisome religious motifs of cow and camel to represent Hinduism and Islam- bring in, <strong><em>probably a first of its kind, dog whistle into mainstream medical literature: a Hindu-Muslim divide in a scientific editorial!</em></strong> <strong><em>This bigotry deserves firm condemnation, and not publication in a medical journal!</em></strong> I hope the international research watchbodies take note of this travesty.</p><p>c) The cover-up in talking about ‘camel urine’ specifically, but not daring to mention a word about Anbarnesa, or female donkey dung and its fumes, points to the crooked agenda of these ‘experts’! As mentioned earlier, <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1439484740831223818?s=20">I had connected Anbarnesa with Iran’s CAM outbreak by August- September 2021</a>, and had tried to raise awareness of the issue through social media. This likely connection was also published in <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">our hypothesis</a>, and in a <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8837871/">published study on CAM from Iran</a>!</p><p>The main intent of this ‘editorial’ is to discredit our hypothesis and divert all attention from the role of cow dung and its fumes in mucormycosis. Clearly, any probing of herbivore dung or its fumes as a realistic risk factor for mucormycosis, that can pique further academic interest, is a perceived danger to their cause. Hence the pointed lack of mention of Anbarnesa, a West Asian tradition already explored in our hypothesis as the likely key factor for Iran’s CAM outbreak, anywhere in this DLE! However, their unbridled xenophobia and bigotry couldn’t help but ensure a dishonorable targeting of camel urine! <em>Shockingly disturbing! And a very dangerous trend!</em></p><p>Finally, the <strong>DLE</strong> wants to focus all attention on “<em>The elephant in the room: SARS-CoV-2 as a risk factor for CAM.”</em></p><p>Sure! Why not? But, just to clarify: Isn’t the role of Covid already in focus? Unlike the old saying, isn’t the elephant in the room, SARS-CoV-2, given full attention by the global scientific community? Academicians generally agree that the immune dysregulation and the tendency to exacerbate hyperglycemia by SARS-CoV-2 did play a crucial role in CAM. And that the mismanagement of Covid with steroids also played a pivotal role. Hell, the damn condition is called <strong><em>CAM — COVID Associated Mucormycosis, and not COW Associated Mucormycosis!</em></strong></p><p>Evidently, Covid already has an elephantine role in CAM! It is rather the elephant dung (or cow/animal dung), fuming and stinking up the room, that is being deliberately ignored by the scientific world. But, hey, one good thing about dung is that the more you ignore it, the more stink it will raise. <em>Cheers!</em></p><p>In short, by denying the obvious truths about coprophilous Mucorales and the very plausible role of cow dung and its smoke in India’s unique CAM epidemic,<strong><em> this Damned Lies Editorial propagates </em></strong>the terrible <strong>damned lies</strong> fed religiously to an unsuspecting population of 1.4 billion Indians that put them at a disproportionately high risk of invasive infections like mucormycosis. The <strong>damned lies</strong> that cow dung and urine are holy and of medicinal value! The <strong>damned lies</strong> that ‘<em>Desi</em>’ cow excreta do not contain harmful germs, even if ‘foreign’ cow dung might harbor such dangers! The <strong>damned lies</strong> that the smoke from burning cow dung purifies the air and has health benefits!</p><p><strong>Centuries old damned lies that need busting by scientists who seek facts, not favor!</strong></p><p>There was a time when arrogant doctors refused a simple, self-evident proposal to wash hands to reduce unnecessary patient deaths. I consider this DLE and similar attacks against our hypothesis as another instance when bigoted, arrogant, selfish, cowardly physician-scientists dismiss <strong><em>a simple, self-evident proposal: to take precautions while dealing with animal excreta and its fumes to reduce unnecessary, avoidable, dangerous invasive infections in unsuspecting patients.</em></strong> History repeats itself, because egotistic invertebrates never learn from the past. <a href="https://www.amusingplanet.com/2023/07/the-tragedy-of-ignaz-semmelweis-doctor.html">Dr. Ignaz Semmelweis</a> called such doctors, “irresponsible murderers and ignoramuses”.</p><p>I concur. Completely. They were that. As are the present ones. Damned Liars too, I should add!</p><p>And that concludes my response to this disgusting Damned Lies Editorial. <em>For now.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=eda8203bcece" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[One Dung to Bind them All]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/one-dung-to-bind-them-all-410ee7d86a0c?source=rss-41bcf97dda06------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/410ee7d86a0c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jessy Skaria]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 31 Oct 2022 00:17:16 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2025-03-27T04:44:52.577Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Having been a bit of a gadfly on the mucormycosis crisis in India, I started appreciating — while flitting around cows and dung — the unexplored pathogenic possibilities of human-animal dung interactions. Particularly so, in the ‘neglected world’, where dung and droppings are not just a part of daily life — they are often embraced, revered and sought after. These possibilities, in my view, are so enormous that they raise the potential for the development of an entirely new branch of medicine: “Neglected Dung Diseases” (NDD).</p><p>At the very outset, I must state: This is a hypothesis, which may well end up refuted following further study . I am no expert on any of the diseases I interrogate below as potentially connected with the dung of domesticated animals. I only hope this would serve as a pointer to experts in these respective fields to look closer at dung and droppings as potential causative agents — that they would study in detail how this ubiquitous source of pathogens could be at the root of many ailments in communities closely associating with it. If shown to be true, prevention, to a large extent, could be achieved for many of them, by something as simple and inexpensive as cautionary public advisories and behavioral modifications. Just as they did for <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/fungal/features/histoplasmosis.html">Histoplasmosis</a> vis-à-vis bat/bird droppings, and for <a href="https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/archive/nation/india-declared-free-of-neonatal-tetanus-yaws-266162">neonatal tetanus</a> and cow dung . Innumerable lives could be saved, at not a lot of additional cost.</p><p>The following are some of the entities, that in my view, would most benefit from this research:</p><p><strong><em>Mucormycosis:</em></strong> The role of herbivore dung in mucormycosis is something I am quite confident of, having been researching it intensely since the terrible Indian epidemic of COVID Associated Mucormycosis (CAM) in 2021. I have written about it in detail in two articles on Medium (<a href="https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/how-unique-regional-factors-collided-to-create-the-mucormycosis-crisis-in-india-a-hypothesis-5e95f8248e29">here</a> and <a href="https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/does-the-threat-of-mucormycosis-stalk-indian-festivals-3de0a672b3d1">here</a> ), two in the Indian print media (<a href="https://countercurrents.org/2021/06/how-unique-regional-factors-collided-to-create-the-black-fungus-crisis-in-india-a-hypothesis/">here</a> and <a href="https://www.freepressjournal.in/health/covid-19-the-dreaded-question-will-black-fungus-make-a-comeback-amid-the-third-wave">here</a>) and also had it published, with the help of eminent co-authors, as a peer reviewed hypothesis in <a href="https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/mbio.00473-22">mBio</a>. The hypothesis hinges on the potentially related facts that India contributes a disproportionately large share of the global mucormycosis burden, and that there is disproportionately high, frequent and intimate contact with cow dung- a rich source of the causative Mucorales fungi- amongst a large proportion of the Indian population.</p><p>In addition to the already known association of Mucorales with herbivore dung (<a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2309-608X/6/1/4/htm">coprophilous fungi</a>), a recent <a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/myc.13487">study</a> in India has demonstrated cow dung to be rich in the specific species of the fungus that have been isolated from mucormycosis patients in the country — this, I believe, further strengthens the hypothesis on source association.</p><p>The fact that India has a higher percentage of patients with rhino-orbito-cerebral mucormycosis (ROCM) could also be a pointer to the potential mode of infection: inhaled dung particles. Spores embedded within dung particles (dried dung or smoke of burning dung) are likely to be larger in size and are hence <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0048969721017204">more likely to settle down</a> in the upper respiratory passages like the nose and paranasal sinuses, leading to ROCM in vulnerable patients.</p><p>Toxins and spores from dung could also reach the distal, smaller air passages causing pulmonary mucormycosis, which may be massively underdiagnosed in India, due to well acknowledged logistic <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11046-022-00638-5">diagnostic difficulties</a> with fungal infections.</p><p>Researchers in Iran have also connected CAM in that country with the dung of another domesticated herbivore — the donkey — through the traditional use of <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8837871/">anbarnesa</a> among many Iranians.</p><p>Clearly, a lot more research and investigative analysis is needed to better understand these potential connections, which in my view, cannot be ignored any more.</p><p>Once the potential connection between cow dung and the Indian CAM epidemic dawned on me, I started exploring whether similar associations might exist in other countries and cultures that live in close contact with animal dung. It was very disturbing to see how almost all such populations are known to have a higher than average caseload of Invasive Fungal Diseases (IFDs), especially of the sinuses and orbits. Foremost among these countries are Iran and Sudan. While Iran had a well-documented CAM surge, Sudan has been chronically suffering from various fungal diseases ranging from <a href="https://www.austinpublishinggroup.com/otolaryngology/fulltext/ajo-v3-id1085.php">Chronic Invasive Fungal Sinusitis</a> to Aspergilloma and mycetoma. With cattle being an integral part of the Sudanese life style, I again feel it is quite possible that dung and its smoke play a crucial role in the causation of these fungal infections in the country. The same could also apply to other developing countries with close human-domesticated animal interactions, such as Pakistan, Egypt, Kenya, Peru, Bolivia, Brazil and Honduras.</p><p><strong><em>Aspergillosis/ Aspergilloma</em></strong><em>:</em> Different species of Aspergillus are commonly <a href="http://www.ijat-aatsea.com/pdf/Nov_v4_n2_08/9%20IJAT2008-12-R.pdf">isolated</a> from dung and droppings. In India and many other places, <a href="https://www.scienceopen.com/document_file/b2489aaf-0f9b-4856-81fd-ee05094bd344/PubMedCentral/b2489aaf-0f9b-4856-81fd-ee05094bd344.pdf">mixed fungal species</a> like Mucorales and Aspergillus have been isolated in many infections including ROCM during COVID. Dung, a rich organic source of mixed pathogens, could very well be the source of such infections .</p><p><strong><em>Mycetoma:</em></strong> This dreadful disease — common in poorer populations who walk barefoot in soil and dung, such as in Sudan and India — is usually seen following penetrating injuries, and hence could potentially be due to the deposition of the causative fungi deep into the tissues from a dung source, resulting in granulomatous inflammation. Interestingly, <em>Madurella mycetomatis</em>, the first recognized causative fungus for the condition, was discovered in Madura (in the Indian state of Tamil Nadu), which was also a hot-spot for CAM. Experts in the field like those from the <a href="https://www.mycetoma.edu.sd/">Mycetoma Research Centre</a> in Sudan have already performed <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3656121/">studies</a> on this likely dung connection, although they have so far not been able to prove it conclusively.</p><p>It is my strong belief that continued research in this direction will firmly establish the dung-mycetoma connection sooner rather than later.</p><p><strong><em>Tuberculosis:</em></strong> While the disease is mainly caused by the bacillus <em>Mycobacterium tuberculosis</em>, the secondary contribution of <em>Mycobacterium bovis — </em>the organism causing bovine TB — to the overall disease burden is also known. It’s highly likely that apart from the already known <a href="https://www.cdc.gov/tb/publications/factsheets/general/mbovis.pdf">modes</a> of spread from infected cattle to humans, the dispersal of the bacilli from <a href="https://tbhub.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/AR-factsheet-faeces-and-slurry-120118-1.pdf"><strong><em>dung slurries</em></strong></a> into the environment could be another source of spread of bovine TB to humans and other animals.</p><p>More research is certainly needed in this context, especially since tuberculosis is now mainly a disease of the developing world where such dung-human interactions are more common.</p><p><strong><em>Kashin Beck Disease (KBD) and Keshan Disease (KD):</em></strong> These are two rare, seriously debilitating illnesses of debatable, possibly multifactorial etiology. They are endemic to a few specific regions, most importantly along a selenium-deficient belt extending from the northeast to the southwest of China, with <a href="https://clinlabint.com/several-common-differentially-expressed-genes-between-kashin-beck-disease-and-keshan-disease/">overlapping demographics</a> for both conditions among the affected population.</p><p>KBD is a chronic osteoarthrosis that can cripple the sufferer for life. KD is a highly lethal cardiomyopathy that can present as acute, subacute, chronic or latent forms.</p><p>I have to confess that I was completely unaware of KBD and KD, prior to my research on populations of the world that commonly use dung as fuel. And these endemic diseases in the cold regions of China, Tibet, Mongolia and Siberia caught my attention. I realized that what is common to these areas is that they are populated largely by poor, traditional, peasant communities that rely heavily on yak and other cattle dung as fuel for heating and cooking. That people in these parts of the world spend an inordinate time indoors in poorly ventilated spaces during the harsh winters, breathing in such dung fumes.</p><p>From what is available on these conditions in the published literature, I learned enough to know that researchers continue to be baffled about the etiology of both <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-019-39792-0">KBD </a>and <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7985175/#:~:text=Keshan%20disease%20(KD)%20as%20an,heart%20failure%2C%20and%20cardiac%20arrhythmia">KD</a>.</p><p>Multiple causative factors are being considered, including, nutritional deficiencies (most commonly selenium, but also other trace elements, iodine and vitamins), polluted water (with organic matter, fulvic acid), viral and fungal infections, and mycotoxins (from contaminated grains of barley, maize and corn).</p><p>It needs to be emphasized that to date, no one factor has been definitively proven to have a pivotal causative role in these enigmatic conditions, though selenium deficiency is considered a prime factor, since long term replacement of selenium has helped control the diseases to some extent. However, the simple addition of the deficient minerals and changes in diet (avoiding contaminated grains) have <a href="https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s002640000179.pdf">not produced consistent</a> improvement, prevention or cure. And, it has been noticed that people who moved away from endemic regions have been spared KBD, while those, even older than 25, who moved into endemic regions developed the disease. That many other places in the world with selenium deficiency do not have cases of KBD or KD. Many areas of mainland China where KBD used to be endemic are no longer so. What changed in such areas was upward socioeconomic mobility resulting in improved living standards, including a better and varied diet. Significantly, the changes also resulted in the population transitioning from the use of biomass fuels such as animal dung to natural gas or electricity . But regions of Tibet and rural China, where these diseases are still endemic, continue to depend a lot on the traditional use of <a href="https://www.tibettravel.org/news/201403242227.html">yak dung</a> as fuel for household heating and cooking . Put together, these factors, in my opinion, raise the possibility that mycotoxins, other microbial pathogens or pollutants released during the use (including burning) of dung in the homes of these patients could be a major causative agent of KBD and KD. Since the pathogenesis of KBD is considered to be oxidative damage to bone cells (potentially due to mycotoxins) in the presence of deficient antioxidant defence (Selenium deficiency), I propose that the dung and its fumes could be acting in tandem with the other suspected etiologies, or may even be the core causative differential among these vulnerable patients.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/850/1*WaJL3Jrfh0lagGgMI6PgcA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Credit: <a href="https://phys.org/news/2015-01-yak-dung-pollutes-indoor-air.html">Phys.org</a></figcaption></figure><p>While <a href="https://ourworldindata.org/indoor-air-pollution#:~:text=Indoor%20air%20pollution%20results%20from%20the%20burning%20of%20solid%20fuels,risk%2C%20particularly%20for%20respiratory%20diseases">indoor air pollution</a> by burning biomass fuels, including dung, is studied widely, the release and spread of microbial pathogens and toxins in the smoke of burning biomass, is as yet unexplored. As such, it is indeed encouraging that the study of<a href="https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ecs2.2507"> pyroaerobiology</a> is gaining momentum in the USA. Hopefully, such studies would soon unlock the mysteries to the etiology of diseases like KBD and KD.</p><p>In this context, a recent<a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33462434/"> study</a> that mucormycosis can also be related to a mycotoxin named mucoricin, is extremely interesting.</p><p>In short, regardless of whether this hypothesis is proven or refuted, there is absolutely no doubt that much research is needed into the role played by animal dung and bird droppings in human health, especially in populations that live in close proximity to them.</p><p>Along with what we already <a href="http://publichealth.lacounty.gov/vet/docs/Educ/AnimalFecesandDisease.pdf">know</a> of dung-related <a href="https://water.unl.edu/article/animal-manure-management/pathogens-and-organic-matter">zoonotic infections </a>, further detailed research is needed to understand the impact of all kinds of human-dung interactions and their potentially unimaginable cost in terms of human health, lives and medical expenses.</p><p>The health of the poor matters, as much as that of the wealthy. Deliberate neglect of diseases of the underprivileged is a crime against humanity. It is my fervent hope that advances in science help all equally, and not just the privileged.</p><p>Neglected Dung Diseases urgently demand crucial expert attention. I appeal to all medical agencies to ensure they do not remain neglected any more.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=410ee7d86a0c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Does the threat of Mucormycosis stalk Indian festivals?]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/does-the-threat-of-mucormycosis-stalk-indian-festivals-3de0a672b3d1?source=rss-41bcf97dda06------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3de0a672b3d1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[black-fungus]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[mucormycosis]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[holi]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cow-dung-fumes]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[diwali]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jessy Skaria]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Dec 2021 02:28:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-12T16:36:59.273Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In 2021, when the world was focused on the COVID pandemic, Indians were caught in the glare of an additional nemesis — the dreaded “Black Fungus”. The condition struck a chill in our hearts. Images in the media of suffering patients with their stories of utter despair sent waves of panic through the country. The infection killed many of its victims, while even the “lucky” survivors faced physical disfiguration, debilitating surgeries and long periods of recovery, made worse by the crippling financial costs of treatment. Black Fungus made even COVID appear benign in comparison. As the country searched frantically for answers, <em>What is Black Fungus?</em> became the <a href="https://www.republicworld.com/technology-news/social-media-news/google-year-in-search-2021-black-fungus-tops-list-in-india-under-what-is-category.html">most recorded Google query</a> among Indians in 2021.</p><p>What <em>is</em> Black Fungus? Why is it so dreaded? Why does it seem such a particularly “Indian affliction’’?</p><p>As most Indians know by now, Black Fungus or mucormycosis (as it is correctly called) is an opportunistic fungal infection, caused by a group of fungi called Mucorales. These fungi are ubiquitous, meaning they are present all over the world. And yet, mucormycosis is a relatively lesser-known disease globally, even among doctors. This is because humans are typically resistant to fungal pathogens; this immunity keeps most of us safe, even if we come in contact with these microbes on a regular basis. The word “opportunistic” indicates that the fungus causes illness (i.e., mucormycosis) in humans only when the human host is weak or prone to infections, as with any kind of immunocompromise or conditions like diabetes. And hence the rarity in our acquaintance with this villainous microbe.</p><p>Mucormycosis and Black Fungus became household names in India when the condition wreaked unimaginable havoc across the country during the second wave of the COVID pandemic. The world watched with dread as well — wondering if the condition would spread globally from India along with the Delta variant of the Coronavirus — and then breathed a sigh of relief when it did not. Except for a few scattered cases worldwide — only <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1444435611742576640?s=20">Iran</a> had a sharp increase with more than hundreds of cases recorded — Black Fungus remained staunchly Indian. <a href="https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/51-775-cases-of-mucormycosis-black-fungus-reported-in-india-till-november-29-health-minister-2635865">Official statistics</a> put the number of Indian cases recorded in the period of six months between May 20, 2021 and November 29, 2021 as 51,775.</p><p>51,775 cases is a huge, unacceptably huge number, by any means. But, if we took a step back and studied the available medical literature closely, we would realise that the truth is more nuanced, that this sudden “surge” during the pandemic is just the tip of a particularly dangerous Indian iceberg.</p><p>In a peer-reviewed article from February 2019 — months before the onset of the COVID pandemic — leading Indian mycologist, Professor Arunaloke Chakrabarti quotes a <a href="https://www.mdpi.com/2309-608X/5/1/26/htm">stunning statistic</a> from the Leading International Fungal Education (LIFE) portal: that India’s estimated annual (pre-COVID) prevalence of mucormycosis is 900,000 cases! Which translates to 450,000 cases in 6 months, and a virtually unthinkable 2500 cases per day!</p><p>And here we are, quaking with dread, googling frantically, when a 6-month officially recorded figure of 51,775 cases bursts in the open during the COVID pandemic- almost 8 times less than what was estimated in pre-COVID 2019!</p><p>Of course, the reported figure of 900,000 was only an estimate. But remember, this estimate was offered by a leading global fungal infections monitoring portal, and quoted by the foremost mycologist in India, in a peer-reviewed paper.</p><p>Time for a reality check.</p><p>India, with her teeming billion plus population, has always had a cavalier, almost laid-back attitude to deaths and diseases in general, and a casual unconcern for routine health statistics. A certain <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfuAN-o6H0Q&amp;ab_channel=YRF">iconic line</a>, although uttered — and immortalized — in a different context, voices this attitude aptly: <em>‘Bade bade deshon mein aaisi choti choti baatein hoti rehti hain’</em>. We simply take thousands of deaths daily in our stride. For example, how many of us know or care that more than 2.6 million Indians contract <a href="https://tbfacts.org/tb-statistics-india/">tuberculosis (TB)</a> every year and over 400,000 succumb to it annually? Which means that, on average, more than 1095 Indians die of TB every day. Routine. Not worth our notice. But we do sit up and take notice when there is an unusual surge. Especially if the surges take place in the affluent urban or suburban areas. If 100 TB patients were to be admitted to a single tertiary hospital in Mumbai at the same time, and 25 of them succumbed to the condition in one day, it would certainly make national headlines. And if this ‘unusual pattern’ trended for a period of time, instead of black fungus, Indians would be online frantically searching answers to “What is TB?” and “How to avoid getting TB?”</p><p>The fact is, for India to tackle the menace of “black fungus” or mucormycosis appropriately, we need to first accept that India has always had a disproportionately huge and long-standing problem with this rare opportunistic fungal infection.</p><p>We’ve always had an invisible epidemic! That’s the truth.</p><p>The reasons for this lack of visibility could be many. Maybe the condition goes largely undiagnosed. Fungal infections are <a href="https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fmicb.2019.00214/full">notoriously underdiagnosed and underestimated</a>, even in developed countries. And <a href="https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/alarming-rise-in-fungal-infection-cases-pgimer-study--43222">India’s lack of such diagnostic facilities</a> has been a matter of concern for mycologists all along. It is also likely to be more prevalent among the poorer and rural populations, such as the farming communities, with infections going untreated and unreported. And again, since the affected individuals are most likely to be in the vulnerable, immunocompromised, diabetic or elderly categories, infections and deaths among such patients may not attract much scrutiny.</p><p>What changed in the second wave was that COVID, with its equal-opportunity affliction of all — the condition did not discriminate between rich or poor, urban or rural — along with its accompanying problems: especially the use of steroids in its treatment further lowering the immunity of the infected patients and worsening the blood sugar levels of diabetics, in conjunction with the very <a href="https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/health-environment/article/3134352/cow-dung-cocktails-why-india-cant-get-enough-quack?module=perpetual_scroll_0&amp;pgtype=article&amp;campaign=3134352">unique Indian ways</a> practiced widely to fend off the virus, caused a surge of mucormycosis among Indians, particularly and very dramatically among the urban, affluent population, and brought this as yet unnoticed problem starkly to our attention.</p><p>It is thus not a new problem, but a chronic, hitherto casually under-recognized one.</p><p>From an Indian perspective, only a holistic, open-minded approach to its management will help us solve this problem.</p><p>The first step in this approach would be to seek answers to the question “Why India specifically?”</p><p>Of all the answers put forward in response, so far, by the experts, let us consider the two most important ones:</p><p>1. Host susceptibility: with India’s high numbers of diabetic patients — many of them undiagnosed or poorly controlled — we do provide the fungi with a large cohort of hosts vulnerable to an opportunistic infection.</p><p>2. High environmental fungal loads: Although only a few studies have been conducted to measure the environmental load of Mucorales spores, it <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0255085721041347?via%3Dihub">has been shown</a> that many parts of India have abnormally high levels of these spores in the outside air.</p><p>Ideally, we should have thoroughly explored both the host <em>and</em> the environmental factors that could be held responsible for our high prevalence of mucormycosis cases. Instead, what we saw during the Covid-associated mucormycosis (CAM) epidemic was an abnormally skewed exploration of only the host factors. All through our “Black fungus Epidemic”, experts have been concentrating almost solely on the clinical profile of patients likely to contract mucormycosis- those with COVID/ treated with STEROIDS/ and those with DIABETES MELLITUS. They have repeatedly and aggressively hammered this information into the Indian minds so much so that many Indians now consider themselves lucky if they contracted COVID or are diabetics, and yet escaped the dreaded ‘black fungus’. With our innate subservient attitude to authority, not many patients or their families have asked the question: “Even given my clinical problems (COVID/steroids and/or diabetes), what are the chances that I would have contracted mucormycosis had I lived outside of India? When so many diabetics around the world are getting COVID and are being treated with steroids, why are Indians so particularly vulnerable to contracting the black fungus?”</p><p>It’s time to ask these unasked questions, which would invariably bring us to another: Why do many parts of India have exceptionally high Mucorales spore loads? What does India do different from the rest of the world that could contribute to this high environmental fungal load?</p><p>At the beginning of the CAM epidemic in April-May 2021, <a href="https://www.outlookindia.com/website/story/india-news-gujarat-doctors-warn-against-cow-dung-therapy-say-it-may-lead-to-mucormycosis/382541/">many Indian doctors pointed out</a> a probable cause for our mucormycosis crisis: Indian traditions involving the excessive use of cow dung and urine. It made perfect sense. Cow dung — in fact, most dung, and especially herbivore dung — is known to harbour Mucorales fungi (which are called <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1517838216309054">coprophilous</a> or dung-loving). And India has always had a special and close relationship with the cow and with bovine products, including dung and urine. Many of these doctors called for restricting the personal use of cow excreta in order to avoid getting infected with mucormycosis. But most of these sensible voices faded by mid- May, possibly from lack of adequate media coverage. Following this, only isolated opinions on this issue were heard, mainly on social media and infrequently on online media portals, <a href="https://countercurrents.org/2021/06/how-unique-regional-factors-collided-to-create-the-black-fungus-crisis-in-india-a-hypothesis/">my article</a> published in the Countercurrents in June being an example of the latter.</p><p>A few of us interested physicians and public health professionals continued our queries along these lines. We followed the mucormycosis epidemic closely, as we attempted to see how it intersected with both the host and environmental factors.</p><p>Soon, it became obvious that there is a pattern. <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/coronavirus-outbreak/story/fumes-fill-belgaum-streets-karnataka-bjp-mla-abhay-patil-carries-out-havan-ward-off-covid-19-watch-1807061-2021-05-26">Areas where community <em>havans</em></a> with burning cow dung were held to ward off Corona subsequently <a href="https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/karnataka/2021/jun/14/no-specialiststo-treat-black-fungus-in-belagavi-district-kin-of-patients-2315843.html">showed major clusters</a> of cases of mucormycosis, whereas regions within India which did not indulge in such activities were relatively spared. Here, then, was the potential basis of understanding the high environmental load of Mucorales in India! The fungal spores present in dung are potentially dispersed widely through smoke, thus exposing everyone who breathes in such air to infection with the Mucorales spores. However, mucormycosis being an opportunistic infection, only the vulnerable, including the diabetics, the immunocompromised, or the COVID infected, actually contracted the condition. Medical literature <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1352231003009142?via%3Dihub">supports</a> such spread of fungal spores in fumes and wind, and experts in the field of <a href="https://www.fs.usda.gov/treesearch/pubs/57391">pyroaerobiology</a> agree that this is plausible.</p><p>Armed with this corroborating information, we have embarked on the long and arduous process of proving a potential causative association between fumes from burning biomass — including herbivore dung and crop stubble — and invasive fungal diseases, including mucormycosis and aspergillosis, in vulnerable populations exposed to such smoke, anywhere in the world. Evidence-based medicine being a necessarily rigorous process, we know that the frustrating wait for academic validation and conclusive proof must be endured patiently. We only wished that in the meantime, there was a way to warn potential patients about avoiding this possibly dangerous exposure. In an attempt at achieving this objective, we have issued <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1439378048009359360?s=20">multiple</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1466828134645440514?s=20">continuous</a> warnings through <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1467553998488145926?s=20">social media posts</a>, trying to engage with as many influential people as possible, to disseminate the message. Even while cognisant of the limitations of our reach, we never stopped trying.</p><p>It was a relief, then, as doctors in India announced a decline in mucormycosis by September, accompanying a fall in COVID cases — welcome news indeed. The relief was, however, short-lived, as another possible startling connection with mucormycosis came to the fore, with the potential for serious imminent danger.</p><p>Indian festivals are colorful, bright occasions, with many of them involving bonfires or ritual fires. And I was aware of the increasingly popular <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/travel/destinations/only-cow-dung-cakes-charged-with-vedic-mantras-used-at-this-3000-year-old-holika-dahan-in-ujjain/as74552307.cms">recent trend</a> to use cow dung, in lieu of the traditional wood, as fuel in the festive fires. With the knowledge garnered about the potential spread of Mucorales spores through dung fumes, I realised the possible high risk involved for the Indians attending such festivities and inhaling the smoke from burning cow dung. October-November is the main festival season in India, with Diwali being the most popular of them. <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/100-crore-diyas-target-for-kamdhenu-deepawali-in-gujarat/articleshow/86772209.cms">Media reports</a> were celebrating the “green” Diwali oil lamps or <em>diyas</em> made of cow dung, with news about millions of them being prepared for sale prior to the festival! If the “cow dung hypothesis” was correct, if the Mucorales spores did indeed spread through smoke from smoldering cow dung, unsuspecting Indians were again in dire danger of getting the dreaded black fungus! With crop-stubble burning also in progress, I was seized with a sense of urgency to try and prevent more suffering, and shot off urgent emails early in October to all responsible leaders I could think of — including the Prime Minister, the Union Health Minister, the Principal Scientific Advisor, the Indian Council for Medical research (ICMR), the World Health Organisation (WHO) and even some well-known media personalities. I never received any responses. The few of us who believed in this hypothesis also made efforts to warn as many Indians as possible through social media platforms. I specifically contacted, <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1451921286452727813?s=20">tweeted</a> at and tagged <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1463558402941100036?s=20">reporters</a> and <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1454177304154943499?s=20">doctors</a>, in an attempt to spread the word. Except for some scattered individual support, the warnings were largely ignored. Diwali was celebrated in many places with cow dung <em>diyas</em>. Our helplessness at not being able to avert the crisis was, however, replaced by scientific curiosity. Now, if the cases did go up post-Diwali, it would certainly be a validation of our hypothesis, and the academicians, doctors, leaders and journalists whom I had warned would have to acknowledge that. It might prompt honest research into our hypothesis, and ultimately help potential future patients. But what followed was a disturbing concerted silence on the topic, an almost deliberate avoidance in the mainstream media. However, by diligently gathering news from different online portals, especially regional media websites and social media, there is now enough <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/pune/3-mucormycosis-patients-found-in-district-lastweek/articleshow/88286014.cms?utm_source=contentofinterest&amp;utm_medium=text&amp;utm_campaign=cppsthttps%25253A%25252F%25252Ftoi.in%25252Fgryaqb12%25252Fa24gk&amp;pcode=461">evidence</a> that there was an additional spike after Diwali ; that mucormycosis cases have gone up quite noticeably in many <a href="https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/lucknow-news/deepotsav-in-lucknow-gomti-s-banks-bedecked-in-brilliance-of-1-lakh-diyas-101635965225453.html">places where cow dung <em>diyas</em> were used extensively</a>. Regional newspapers, such as <a href="https://twitter.com/anujtandon85/status/1470591948578648066">this one</a> from Lucknow, report them with alarming headlines like “Black Fungus Returns”.</p><p>Now here follows the crux of the matter I want to highlight, the reason why I would like this article to be read and understood, as soon as possible, by all Indians and interested mycologists:</p><p>Diwali, as we know, does not follow the Gregorian calendar — the date varies from year to year. This year, it fell on November 4th. Last year, in 2020, it happened to be on November 15th. In 2022, it will fall on October 24th. There is only limited data in the academic literature about the incubation period of mucormycosis: incubation period refers to the time between exposure to a disease-causing organism (bacterium, virus or fungus) to the manifestation of the illness (that is, when symptoms and signs of the illness become apparent). It is also important to understand that the same infection may have different presentations (or forms) and incubation periods, based on the manner of exposure to the pathogen. Percutaneous inoculation of the Mucorales fungus causing cutaneous mucormycosis, for example, is reported to have an incubation period of <a href="https://academic.oup.com/ofid/article/2/suppl_1/461/2634806">1–2 weeks</a> .This means that after being exposed to the Mucorales fungi through a cut or burn in the skin, a vulnerable patient would develop symptoms of mucormycosis in about 1–2 weeks. But there is virtually no data in the medical literature about the incubation period for the rhino-orbito-cerebral mucormycosis (ROCM), which is the most common presentation in India, and the form of mucormycosis most likely to result from inhalation of the fungal spores, such as through smoke. From our research of CAM and based on the assumption that our hypothesis is correct, I am of the impression that the incubation period of ROCM is 2–5 weeks (or roughly 10–40 days). I came to this conclusion mainly based on the time interval between reported cow dung smoke exposure (such as through community <em>havans)</em> and reports of clusters of mucormycosis cases within the same communities. And from the history of cow dung smoke exposure prior to diagnosis in the few patients I could contact directly. And this was why, through social media, I took the bold and risky step of <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1456273781937385475?s=20">predicting</a> a rise in mucormycosis cases after mid-November this year, based on the hypothesis that increased infections would start manifesting by 2–5 weeks following the inhalation of spore-laden fumes from the cow dung <em>diyas </em>lit during Diwali on November 4th.</p><p>Here are some regional media reports (I used Google translate to read in English) that show that the prediction appears to have sadly come true, with multiple instances of patients admitted to different hospitals, and labs diagnosing higher numbers of mucormycosis in and around places where cow dung <em>diyas</em> were lit extensively:</p><p>· <a href="https://www.jagran.com/uttar-pradesh/moradabad-city-black-fungus-symptoms-of-black-fungus-found-in-women-doctors-refer-him-higher-center-22214248.html">November 17, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh (UP)</a></p><p>· <a href="https://news7noida.com/black-fungus-patient-found-after-recovering-from-dengue/">November 19, Noida, UP</a></p><p>· <a href="https://twitter.com/Zee24Kalak/status/1463381524372332546?s=20">November 23, Mehsana, Gujarat</a>.</p><p>· <a href="https://twitter.com/ZeeBiharNews/status/1463409577668407296?s=20">November 24, Delhi</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.divyabhaskar.co.in/local/%20adodar/%20adodara/news/four-new-cases-of-corona-in-last-36-hours-in-vadodara-city-129161049.html">November 28, Vadodara, Gujarat</a></p><p>· <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1465847861434855425?s=20">November 30, Jamnagar, Gujarat</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.jagran.com/haryana/rohtak-black-fungus-continues-to-engulf-even-after-a-year-of-kovid-22263471.html?utm_source=referral&amp;utm_medium=TW&amp;utm_campaign=social_share">December 3, Rohtak, Haryana</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.jagran.com/haryana/hisar-white-fungus-spread-with-dengue-and-corona-in-hisar-two-patients-of-black-fungus-also-found-22261422.html?utm_source=referral&amp;utm_medium=TW&amp;utm_campaign=social_share">Dec 4, Hisar, Haryana</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.bhaskar.com/local/haryana/hisar/news/first-case-of-death-due-to-black-fungus-after-second-wave-of-corona-death-of-student-suffering-from-black-fungus-in-nayauli-khurd-129178536.html?_branch_match_id=917153692499398962&amp;utm_campaign=129178536&amp;utm_medium=sharing&amp;_branch_referrer=H4sIAAAAAAAAA8soKSkottLXT0nMzMvM1k3Sy8zTr3LxKjEu8U31yEkCAJV7NZYfAAAA">Dec 4, Hisar, Haryana</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.naidunia.com/madhya-pradesh/indore-only-11-patients-of-black-fungus-in-myh-indore-7164216">Dec 4, Indore, Madhya Pradesh</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.jagran.com/haryana/hisar-suffering-from-black-fungus-100-people-underwent-surgery-two-or-three-times-in-agroha-medical-still-died-22266709.html?utm_source=referral&amp;utm_medium=TW&amp;utm_campaign=social_share">Dec 5, Hisar, Haryana</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.bhaskar.com/local/haryana/hisar/news/dr-nalwa-patients-are-getting-black-fungus-in-fungal-culture-test-health-department-we-do-not-have-any-information-129186340.html?_branch_match_id=917153692499398962&amp;utm_campaign=129186340&amp;utm_medium=sharing&amp;_branch_referrer=H4sIAAAAAAAAA8soKSkottLXT0nMzMvM1k3Sy8zTLy%2B0CA0LCDTyyUkCAFM3gokfAAAA">Dec 7, Hisar, Haryana</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.amarujala.com/haryana/hisar/black-fungus-50-of-the-patients-got-symptoms-of-tb-hisar-news-hsr618832033">Dec 8, Hisar, Haryana</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/andhra-pradesh/2021/dec/09/foreign-returnee-tests-positive-for-covidin-andhra-pradeshs-krishna-district-2393390.html">Dec 9, Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh</a></p><p>· <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1469348864402640899">Dec 10, Rohtak, Haryana</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.divyabhaskar.co.in/local/gujarat/vadodara/news/after-165-days-in-the-city-12-more-cases-of-corona-the-number-of-active-cases-increased-to-59-6-patients-with-mucormycosis-are-currently-under-treatment-129197515.html">Dec 10, Vadodara, Gujarat</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.amarujala.com/video/haryana/six-new-cases-of-black-fungus-in-hisar">Dec 13, Hisar, Haryana</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.inextlive.com/uttar-pradesh/lucknow/along-with-dengue-black-fungus-is-also-secretly-stinging-1639417471?utm_source=referral&amp;utm_medium=TW&amp;utm_campaign=social_share">Dec 13, Lucknow, UP</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.jagran.com/haryana/hisar-now-cases-of-yellow-fungus-have-been-found-after-black-fungus-in-hisar-these-patients-also-have-symptoms-of-tb-22292626.html?utm_source=referral&amp;utm_medium=TW&amp;utm_campaign=social_share">Dec 14, Hisar, Haryana</a>.</p><p>· <a href="https://www.jagran.com/bihar/patna-city-again-coronavirus-started-to-scare-corona-infection-again-after-black-fungus-death-of-elderly-in-patna-22297190.html?utm_source=referral&amp;utm_medium=TW&amp;utm_campaign=social_share">Dec 15, Patna, Bihar</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.gujaratsamachar.com/news/madhya-gujarat/two-new-cases-of-mucormycosis-were-reported">Dec 22, Vadodara, Gujarat</a></p><p>· <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chandigarh/mucormycosis-back-in-haryana-18-under-treatment-in-rohtak/articleshow/88501813.cms?utm_source=twitter.com&amp;utm_medium=social&amp;utm_campaign=TOIDesktop">Dec 26, Rohtak, Haryana</a></p><p>So, yes, as feared, there certainly was a surge 2–5 weeks post-Diwali this year.</p><p>Next, I decided to check for media reports of similar clusters 2–5 weeks after Diwali last year (2020), which was celebrated on Nov 15th. And there it was! <a href="https://weather.com/en-IN/india/coronavirus/news/2020-12-21-covid-19-aggravating-rare-black-fungus-infection-delhi-hospitals">Multiple reports</a> of clusters during the first three weeks of December from places ranging from Delhi, Ahmedabad, Rajkot, Vadodara, Bengaluru — again, places where <a href="https://www.indiatvnews.com/news/india/33-crore-cow-dung-diyas-diwali-chinese-lights-656454">cow dung <em>diyas</em></a> were used during Diwali. .</p><p>· <a href="https://www.firstpost.com/india/covid-19-triggering-rare-deadly-fungal-infection-in-recovered-patients-claims-delhi-hospital-9112041.html">Dec15, Delhi</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.news18.com/news/buzz/rare-deadly-fungal-infection-stalking-covid-19-patients-in-india-heres-all-you-need-to-know-3178805.html">Dec 16, Delhi, Bengaluru, Ahmedabad</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/after-covid-19-another-disease-strikes-ahmedabad-44-hospitalised-9-dead-1750549-2020-12-17">Dec 17, Ahmedabad, Gujarat</a>:</p><p>· <a href="https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/in-other-news/171220/steroids-used-in-covid-treatmet-leading-to-fungal-infections-in-few-pa.html">Dec 17, Hyderabad, Telangana</a></p><p>· <a href="https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/2020/dec/19/rare-fungal-infection-new-villain-for-those-infected-with-covid-2238262.html">Dec19, Tamil Nadu</a></p><p>· <a href="https://odishatv.in/nation/fungal-infection-mucormycosis-strikes-gujarat-ahmedabad-reports-25-rajkot-10-502504">Dec19, Ahmedabad, Rajkot, Gujarat</a>:</p><p>· <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/rajkot/two-covid-patients-die-of-mucormycosis-infection/articleshow/79829641.cms">Dec 21, Vadodara, Gujarat</a> :</p><p>· <a href="https://bangaloremirror.indiatimes.com/bangalore/others/careful-theres-a-fungal-danger-as-well/articleshow/79972017.cms">Dec 27, Bengaluru, Karnataka</a></p><p>· This was a huge surprise: to see that a peer-reviewed <a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8386807/">academic paper</a> about mucormycosis cases in India between September and December 2020 was actually headlined by a leading newspaper as “Mucormycosis recorded 46% mortality in <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/mucormycosis-recorded-46-mortality-in-post-diwali-surge-study/articleshow/83267910.cms">“post-Diwali surge”</a>! So, clearly, the journalists and doctors in India are aware of a post-Diwali surge! They simply didn’t want to look further into “why”. Interestingly, the same academic paper mentions this statistic: “We noted a 2.1-fold rise in mucormycosis during the study period compared with September–December 2019.” It is worth noting here that for the first time in India, a <a href="https://scroll.in/article/931141/interview-meet-indias-top-cow-official-he-wants-to-start-cow-tours-cow-lectures-cow-hostels">National Cow Commission</a> (Rashtriya Kamdhenu Aayog) was established by the Government of India in February, 2019. And a major initiative of this Cow Commission was to make millions of ‘<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hLfamPFBejU&amp;ab_channel=DDNews">eco-friendly cow dung diyas for Diwali’ in 2020</a>! This tradition was continued with increased vigor in <a href="https://swarajyamag.com/insta/empowering-cow-owners-kamdhenu-diwali-campaign-launched-to-enable-production-of-over-100-cr-cow-dung-based-lamps-idols">2021</a>! And, of course, in both those years, our mucormycosis cases have exploded post-Diwali!</p><p>· Other articles also mention <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/surviving-black-fungus-a-long-drawn-battle-for-many-in-gujarat/articleshow/83162405.cms">“the Diwali wave”</a> of 2020.</p><p>Most 2020 reports show that the cases started rising in the first half of December, with clustering and worrisome media reports appearing in the second half of December. So much so that <a href="https://www.firstpost.com/tech/science/fungal-infection-triggered-by-covid-19-seen-in-cities-all-over-india-all-you-need-to-know-9124011.html">Rajasthan</a>, on the15th of December, and <a href="https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/ahmedabad/health-department-issues-advisory-on-fungal-infection-with-nearly-50-pc-mortality-rate-7114109/">Gujarat</a>, on the 21st had issued advisories warning about the rising cases of mucormycosis.</p><p>In comparison, in 2021, the reported cases, seem to have started rising in the second half of November, with clustering mainly in the first half of December. In the absence of actual epidemiological studies with accurate daily counts of cases, these reports gave me a rough pointer: Diwali, which came 11 days earlier this year (Nov 4, 2021 as opposed to Nov 15 in 2020), has also given rise to clusters of mucormycosis about 11 days earlier in 2021 as compared to 2020! The 11-day difference in the festival dates is almost directly reflected in the pattern of rise of cases and clusters. Not an accurate science, but with the limited information available to me, I felt I was onto something here.</p><p>I returned to the Indian festival calendar, and realised that 2–5 weeks before all hell broke loose in India with the second COVID wave and the CAM epidemic in April-May 2021, we had another major festival celebrated with huge bonfires using cow dung: Holi, with <em>Holika Dahan</em> (burning of the Holika- an important purifying ritual held the night before Holi) on March 28th. In <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHNKdXqMn24&amp;ab_channel=OTV">recent years,<em> Holika Dahan</em></a> had started using huge <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dWcaWWo3jS8&amp;ab_channel=shahdolDiaries">piles of cow dung</a> for the bonfires. Interestingly, while COVID norms restricted public gatherings in many places in India during Holi this year, the ritual of <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/no-holi-celebrations-only-holika-dahan-allowed-gujarat-deputy-cm/articleshow/81617086.cms">Holika Dahan was mostly allowed to happen</a>. And observed <a href="https://news.abplive.com/photo-gallery/news/in-pics-people-across-india-perform-holika-dahan-amid-covid-19-restrictions-1450576">across India</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*sSc1LMVwfpm0cuh24BHJmA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Now, here is a piece of information that I think might have made things worse for the urban Indians: Because of the restriction for gatherings in open public places like parks, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zrl0WZgn9Ag&amp;ab_channel=NAVIMUMBAIULWENEWS.INDIAULWE">many housing societies</a> across India had conducted <em>Holika dahan</em> in their own premises, very close to the living quarters of people. Watching videos of the <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rucez4QqCHE&amp;ab_channel=Boldsky">flames leaping up the many levels of apartments,</a> it’s understandable why urban India suffered so much from “black fungus” during this COVID pandemic.</p><p>Though Holi is a very popular festival in most of India, the fact that parts of India — for example, cities like <a href="https://www.patrika.com/jaipur-news/holi-festival-2021-holika-dahan-6747697/">Jaipur</a>, in Rajasthan — which aggressively promoted cow dung <em>Holika dahans</em>, were subsequently particularly afflicted by <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/jaipur/27-of-admitted-mucor-patients-were-covid-positive-at-time-of-diagnosis/articleshow/83215502.cms">black fungus cases</a> needs mention here. Also that states like Kerala, where Holi is not a popular festival <a href="https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/kerala/2021/may/20/kerala-reports-15-black-fungus-cases-pinarayi-says-no-cause-for-undue-worry-2304844.html">did not have a significant caseload</a> of mucormycosis cases.</p><p>We are currently in the process of researching and testing out these potential correlations. But by now, we are aware of the difficulties involved in obtaining academic approval for unconventional ideas, especially when they might outrage religious or political sensitivities, and are not easily proven conclusively in a lab. Even as we continue the much needed efforts for academic validation, I feel what knowledge we have garnered so far needs to be out in the public domain, as visible as possible, to anyone who cares to know more about how to avoid contracting “black fungus”. That this hypothesis needs to be available to every Indian frantically trying to find answers to <em>“What is Black Fungus?</em>” online. Hence this article.</p><p>I know that medical professionals in India who have been acquainted with this hypothesis already would, in all probability, warn their own loved ones to stay away from cow dung/biomass fumes. But they would still shy away from publicly voicing these warnings and helping in the much-needed research and large-scale epidemiological studies to prove or refute our findings. The tragedy that plays out when science and logic bow to fear, sycophancy and regressive traditions.</p><p><strong>And finally, a word about real, on the ground implications for the near future:</strong></p><p><strong>In mid-January 2022, India will celebrate </strong><a href="https://www.freepressjournal.in/indore/madhya-pradesh-indores-sindhi-community-to-celebrate-eco-friendly-lal-loi-on-january-13"><strong>Lohri</strong></a><strong>/ </strong><a href="https://www.worldreligionnews.com/religion-news/hindus-prepare-thai-pongal-celebration"><strong>Pongal</strong></a><strong>/ </strong><a href="https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/andhra-pradesh/2021/jan/11/pollution-free-bhogi-with-dung-cakes-2248445.html"><strong>Sankranti</strong></a><strong>/ </strong><a href="https://www.republicworld.com/lifestyle/festivals/bhogi-2021-all-about-the-history-significance-and-celebration-on-this-auspicious-occasion.html"><strong>Bhogi</strong></a><strong> — in different parts of the country, all festivals involving </strong><a href="https://www.thehansindia.com/news/cities/visakhapatnam/visakhapatnam-bhogi-mantalu-incomplete-without-sun-dried-patties-666648"><strong>fires that use dried cow dung</strong></a><strong> or other biomasses as fuel. In line with my previous observations, this year, in </strong><a href="https://www.timesnownews.com/hyderabad/article/hyderabad-covid-treated-patients-witness-increase-in-mucormycosis-cases/720766"><strong>February, 2021</strong></a><strong>, 2–5 weeks after these festivals on January 13–16, 2021, there were </strong><a href="https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/life-threatening-fungal-infection-reported-several-covid-19-patients-india-142777"><strong>reports</strong></a><strong> of </strong><a href="https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/mumbai-news/fungal-infection-on-rise-among-those-who-recovered-from-covid-19-docs-101612718809060.html"><strong>rising</strong></a><strong> numbers of mucormycosis cases — from places as diverse and far-flung as Delhi, Mumbai, Hyderabad and Madurai.</strong></p><p><strong>In February 2022, I fervently hope to not see more fellow Indians unnecessarily suffering from this most dreaded of infections. For that, I firmly believe they should not breathe in fumes of burning cow dung. In the coming year, let our people to be aware of the hidden dangers of ‘black fungus’ spreading in smoke— awareness that would lead them to avoid the use of cow/herbivore dung as fuel, and to take care to avoid exposure to such fumes — in </strong><a href="https://www.astroved.com/articles/significance-of-cow-dung-in-hinduism"><strong>domestic/ritual fires or festive bonfires</strong></a><strong>. I am aware that this change might take time, but sincerely hope the delay is at least not due to lack of awareness and education about the risks.</strong></p><p>It was heartening to see the <a href="https://twitter.com/JessySkaria/status/1472810775349809152?s=20">first instance</a> in December, after months of our campaigning, where an Indian doctor was quoted in the media advising people to avoid smoke to prevent black fungus. Yes, it was still only in a regional paper. But a hopeful sign nevertheless — that the change will happen, slowly but surely.</p><p>Meanwhile, I would like to challenge our scientists to test out this hypothesis. Measuring environmental Mucorales spore loads before, during and after a cow dung festive fire should be done wherever such bonfires are lit. And those readings compared with samples taken at the same time from areas in India where the practice of such bonfires is not observed. Scientific bodies like ICMR, medical organisations like the Indian Medical Association (IMA) and expert mycologists in India are sure to have the resources to obtain these measurements without much difficulty.</p><p>Let honest science prove or disprove this hypothesis. Even as we wait patiently for conclusive results one way or the other, may our festivals and celebrations always bring joy, health, peace and prosperity, but never the hidden ‘black fungus’. Let us reduce our exposure to animal dung, especially the fumes of burning dung. We owe that much to ourselves and our loved ones.</p><p>Take care, India. Together, as we gingerly — yet hopefully — step into 2022, let us try and defeat this terrible scourge of “black fungus”.</p><p>P.S: What validates that pre-COVID estimate of 900000 prevalence annually by LIFE mentioned earlier?</p><ul><li>Possibly the fact that <a href="https://en.gaonconnection.com/cooking-gas-lpg-firewood-ujjwala-scheme-rural-india-women-health-risks-air-pollution/">54% households in India</a> use solid fuels (including wood and animal dung). Which could translate to millions of Indians breathing in aerosolized Mucorales spores every day. Elevating the common wisdom of “Mucor in every breath we take” to a very different level in India!</li><li>A <a href="https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/alarming-rise-in-fungal-infection-cases-pgimer-study--43222">2014 study from the eminent PGIMER, Chandigarh</a> with these damning statistics: “Seven out of every 1,000 patients admitted in ICUs across India are affected with fungal infection.” “At 39.55 per 1,000 patients, Global Hospitals of Hyderabad recorded the highest rate of infection. Delhi’s Safdarjung Hospital was second worst with 32.75 people per every 1,000 affected with fungal infection.” “Nearly 10 per cent of farmers and agricultural workers going blind can be attributed to fungal infection.”</li><li><em>Update (May, 28, 2022): After following the epidemiology more closely, and over a longer period, and having tracked the rise of ‘reported cases’ following more cow dung burning and throwing festivals like Holi and Pidakala (Ugadi), I am of the impression that the incubation period for ROCM can vary from 2–8 weeks, depending on the patient’s immune status. Still so many questions waiting to be answered. Hope researchers do whatever is necessary to test out the hypothesis, and to keep our people safe.</em></li></ul><p>. <em>Update (March 12, 2023 ): A </em><a href="https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/myc.13578#.Y_T2IYNKBvc.twitter"><strong><em>new study </em></strong></a><em>by international authors,</em> <em>done in</em> <em>the reputed Vallabhbhai Patel Chest Institute (VPCI) and National Centre of Respiratory Allergy, Asthma and Immunology (NCRAAI), and published in the Journal </em><strong><em>Mycoses </em></strong><em>shows that the environmental fungal spore-load in the Delhi NCR region peaked in the 3–4 weeks (from </em><strong><em>March 29- April 26, 2021</em></strong><em>), preceding the surge of CAM cases in their institution.</em></p><p><em>Incidentally, March 29 was the day after Holika Dahan (observed on March 28, 2021) - a fact that further validates this hypothesis that the smoke from burning cow dung piles on the night of the festival likely dispersed viable fungal spores far and wide, thus accounting for the measured increase in spore load in the following weeks. This likely resulted in the causation of mucormycosis in the vulnerable.</em></p><p><em>Holika Dahan 2021 clearly marks a crucial event preceding the CAM epidemic of India, 2021.</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3de0a672b3d1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How Unique Regional Factors Collided to Create the Mucormycosis Crisis in India — A Hypothesis]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jessyskaria/how-unique-regional-factors-collided-to-create-the-mucormycosis-crisis-in-india-a-hypothesis-5e95f8248e29?source=rss-41bcf97dda06------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/5e95f8248e29</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jessy Skaria]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 21 Sep 2021 04:39:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-09T00:06:57.527Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3><strong>How Unique Regional Factors Collided to Create the Mucormycosis Crisis in India — A Hypothesis</strong></h3><h3>A Preface to the Reader</h3><p><strong><em>“When something is important enough, you do it even if the odds are not in your favor.” Elon Musk</em></strong></p><p><em>Since taking a keen interest in the mucormycosis epidemic in India , I have been convinced of one fact: India’s ongoing mucormycosis problem cannot be explained away by simple general host factors like immunosuppression and diabetes, despite the repeated and emphatic pronouncements of most expert mycologists to this effect. There had to be unique regional factors that singled out Indians for such a fate. The more I read and researched about it, the more the facts seemed to zero in on one factor as the prime potential culprit: Cow dung. And the mode of transmission most likely causing the disproportionately high environmental count of Mucorales in India — fumes from the burning of dung.</em></p><p><em>I had my hypothesis. To take it further, I needed to have it researched and proven in the Indian setting — an arduous undertaking considering I am based in the United States. To get expert researchers and the medical fraternity seriously interested in the hypothesis, I also needed to present it in an academic format. Publication would then hopefully elicit discussions amongst experts, and could culminate in urgent warnings educating the general population about the safe use of cow dung, as a way of reducing the incidence of mucormycosis.</em></p><p><em>The stonewalling and obstruction I have faced in the above endeavors would take more than just a Medium post to cover. I am determined, however, to continue my efforts at validating the hypothesis, and to increase awareness of this issue among the academic fraternity. With a view to pursuing the latter, here I am — being a deliberate disruptor. In what is probably a first, I am publishing my hypothesis in academic format, here on Medium, hoping for a crowd-sourced peer-review process. My original submission to Elsevier’s Medical Hypotheses that was rejected for formal publication was dated July 20th. I am posting that same article here, with a few added points and updated statistics to emphasize the knowledge gained in these two months to further support my hypothesis.</em></p><p><em>I do believe in science and in humans with integrity. I believe that there are medical professionals and researchers who are focused on actual progress in science and medicine, in new ideas, and have the best interests of patients as their primary goal. I hope to catch the attention of such researchers, who will take this project to the next level of evidence-based medicine. And with that, thousands of potential patients could hopefully be saved from the unimaginable horrors of mucormycosis.</em></p><p><em>Please read this hypothesis and help — through research and republication — explore the possibilities raised herein. If the role of herbivore dung in transmitting mucormycosis to humans can be established beyond doubt, it would benefit not just Indians, but vulnerable patients everywhere.</em></p><p><em>Thank you.</em></p><p>— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —</p><p><strong>HYPOTHESIS</strong></p><p>● Title: <strong>How Unique Regional Factors Collided to Create the Mucormycosis Crisis in India — A Hypothesis.</strong></p><p>● Author: Jessy Skaria, MBBS</p><p><strong>ABSTRACT</strong></p><p>The root causes for the alarmingly disproportionate number of mucormycosis cases in India — an extant asymmetry in its global prevalence further markedly amplified during the COVID-19 pandemic — have never been fully explained. Mucorales are found abundantly in nature, in soil and organic substrates such as compost and animal excreta, and only cause opportunistic infections in a vulnerable host, commonly on a background of immunosuppression and/or hyperglycemia. While favorable conditions for mucormycosis exist relatively uniformly across the world, why was India home to more than 70% of the global cases prior to the pandemic, and a staggering 99% following its second wave in the country? This hypothesis proposes that the intersection of a slew of unique regional factors accounts for India’s disproportionate share — preeminent among them being the use of cow dung (known to harbor the “coprophilous”, or dung-loving Mucorales). The cow holds a revered, sacred status among many Indians, and cow excreta is typically incorporated in multiple facets of their everyday lives. Cow dung and urine are also considered medicinal and used habitually in the prevention and treatment of ailments ranging from common cold to cancer. Many religious rituals and prayers involve the burning of dried cow dung cakes. Dried cow dung is used as fuel for cooking in many parts of India, and also in funeral pyres which could typically burn for 2–5 hours. These practices potentially expose the Indian populace to a consistently high presence of fungal spores in their immediate environment. Unprecedented panic triggered by the COVID pandemic resulted in an escalated use of this trusted “cure-all”, and possibly contributed to the explosion in mucormycosis cases that resulted in India’s unique “black fungus” epidemic. This hypothesis posits that the Indian population — rendered vulnerable to opportunistic fungal infections by the SARS-CoV-2 infection and its corticosteroid treatment with the attendant effects of immunosuppression and hyperglycemia — succumbed readily to mucormycosis due to their unique exposure to large loads of Mucorales in their immediate environment, caused by the extensive and intimate use of products containing the fungi-rich cow excreta. The bi-annual agricultural practice of stubble-burning is also discussed as a potential cause for the widespread dispersal of the spores, and subsequently, the large Mucorales count in the Indian environment. The hypothesis also explores the possibility of fungal loads delivered through ablutions in contaminated river waters, since surface waters are known to harbor Mucorales. Additionally, the role of other untested and poorly tested medical remedies used exclusively in India during the pandemic are also scrutinized. India’s experience in eliminating neonatal tetanus — a condition that existed in the country on a similarly disproportionate scale, and also shared the use of cow dung as a causative factor — provides an uncannily similar precedent to bolster the hypothesis. Fundamentally, this paper suggests that the cultural use of cow excreta constitutes a key variable in India’s mucormycosis crisis, that burning cow dung causing the dispersion of fungal spores could possibly explain the inexplicably high Mucorales load in the Indian air, and calls for further research at the nexus of these unique regional factors.</p><p><strong>KEYWORDS</strong></p><p>Mucormycosis; Mucorales; black fungus; India; cow dung; cow urine; stubble-burning; pyroaerobiology</p><p><strong>TEXT</strong></p><p><strong><em>How Unique Regional Factors Collided to Create the Mucormycosis Crisis in India</em></strong><em> — </em><strong><em>A Hypothesis</em></strong></p><p><strong>Introduction and background</strong></p><p>The devastating effects of the second wave of the Coronavirus Disease of 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic in India [1] have been significantly amplified by an explosion of mucormycosis cases in the country, with the government declaring it an epidemic and a notifiable disease on May 20, 2021[2]. Even preceding the second wave, India was home to a disproportionate share of this comparatively rare infection. 70 percent of all global cases of mucormycosis prior to 2019 [3], and also during the first wave of the pandemic between December 2019 and April 2021[4], were reported from India. The Leading International Fungal Education (LIFE) portal has estimated the annual prevalence of mucormycosis to be around 10,000 cases in the world, not including the ones from India. Following the inclusion of Indian data, the estimate of mucormycosis rises to 910,000 cases globally [5]. The number of Indian cases is significantly and disproportionately higher even when compared to India’s subcontinental neighbours — countries with largely similar climatic, ethnic and sociocultural milieus. Further alarmingly, official statistics indicate that since the onset of the second wave of the pandemic, India’s share of mucormycosis cases has soared to 99% of all global cases and fatalities (Figure 1) [6].</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*MdrUPJ3KPmvg4H2ZKx8VFg.jpeg" /></figure><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*f1Cf3CBxq_bpkHu4Du8pCw.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 1: </strong><em>Images from an </em><a href="https://governmentstats.com/mucormycosis/index.html"><em>online dashboard</em></a><em> based on official statistics, tracking the markedly disproportionate number of cases of mucormycosis in India, in comparison to the rest of the world. The data pertains to the period following the second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in India. (</em><strong><em>Credit: Martin Roberts, PhD</em></strong><em>)</em></figcaption></figure><p>Mucormycosis, formerly known as zygomycosis and commonly alluded to as black fungus in India [7], refers to a constellation of varied conditions caused by infections with fungi belonging to the order Mucorales [8]. Mucorales are thermotolerant molds that are known to be ubiquitous in nature, widely found in the soil and on organic substrates including rotting fruits and vegetable matter, compost piles and animal excreta [9]. Due to their widespread presence in nature, most human beings are exposed to the fungus on a routine, everyday basis. The fungi are opportunistic pathogens, with mucormycosis typically only resulting in at-risk individuals, most importantly the immunocompromised and those with uncontrolled hyperglycemia. Host risk factors hence include diabetes mellitus (especially undiagnosed and those with poorly controlled blood sugar levels), neutropenia, post-infectious states, immunosuppressive therapy including corticosteroid use, transplant patients, severe malnutrition, and disruption in the integrity of the cutaneous barrier, as with trauma or burns [10]. Based on its anatomic localization, the condition can be classified into: (1) rhino-orbital-cerebral (ROCM), (2) pulmonary, (3) cutaneous, (4) gastrointestinal, (5) disseminated, and (6) uncommon presentations, including renal mucormycosis [11]. The major mode of infection is through the inhalation of the fungal spores — deposition of the spores on the nasal turbinates in a vulnerable host can result in the most common rhino-orbital-cerebral form of the disease [12], while their transport into the distal airways can cause the pulmonary form. Other modes include ingestion and traumatic inoculation leading to gastrointestinal and cutaneous presentations respectively. The condition is remarkable for its high mortality and morbidity. Mucormycosis is characterized by extensive infarction and necrosis of host tissues resulting from invasion of the vasculature by the fungal hyphae [11], and carries an overall mortality rate of 50–85%. While 50–70% of the rhinocerebral cases are lethal, pulmonary and gastrointestinal presentations carry an even higher mortality rate, since these forms are typically diagnosed late. Mortality rate in disseminated disease approaches 100% [13]. Survivors are often left with the debilitating and disfiguring sequelae of the condition and the mutilating surgeries — including orbital exenteration — that may be required for its treatment [14].</p><p><strong>Hypothesis</strong></p><p>There is no evidence to suggest that the accepted risk factors for mucormycosis such as immunosuppression, diabetes and post-transplant states are prevalent at a disproportionate enough scale in India to account for its staggering share of global cases of the condition. What is it then about the country that accounts for these extraordinarily high numbers? Indeed, the question of other unknown “missing links” has been raised by well-known mycologists in India, although the query has not yet generated any scientifically validated answers [15].</p><p>This hypothesis grapples with the question, particularly as it pertains to the country’s second wave of COVID-19, and ultimately posits that multiple regional factors unique to India potentially contributed to the problem. Cow excrement is proposed as a major factor — that its reported presence in multiple rituals (including spreading dung on the body and the burning of dung), and in untested ingested or topically applied remedies for COVID-19 — ensured a heavy load of Mucorales in and around predominantly vulnerable, immunocompromised, and diabetic COVID patients, thus creating the perfect storm of mucormycosis in India.</p><p>The above conclusions are drawn from the following:</p><p>1. Cow excrement is rich in the spores of Mucorales. The fungi are often referred to as coprophilous (dung-loving) and are known to have an affinity for herbivore dung [16] [17] [18] [19] [20].</p><p>2. There is a longstanding tradition in large parts of India of incorporating cow excreta into multiple facets of daily life [21] [22] — significantly and disproportionately more so than in most other parts of the world. Hinduism, the religion practiced by 80 percent of India’s population, accords a sacred and venerated status for the cow [23]. <em>Panchagavya</em>, for instance, ingested as an Ayurvedic medicine by many Indians, contains five ingredients derived from the cow: dung, urine, milk, ghee and curd [24]. Rituals, including applying cow dung on bodies and imbibing cow urine, and the burning of cow dung in sacred ceremonies routinely, and especially so during major religious festivals like Diwali and Holi, are common practices [25]. Herbivore dung is also burnt for cooking fuel. The dispersal of viable fungal spores in biomass fires is well documented [25a, 25b]. The burning of cow dung for varied purposes — including cooking, fumigation, havans and cremations is likely to spread the fungal spores through the fumes, which might then be inhaled by those exposed to them. It would then be logical to assume that any population that engages in such practices would harbor a heavy load of Mucorales spores in their bodies and immediate environment. Topical application, inhalation and consumption of products containing cow-excreta [26] [27] could then routinely offer entry points to large loads of the fungus, and could result in mucormycosis in an at-risk host.</p><p>3. To bolster the above point, it merits note that the personal and community use of cow excreta amongst Indians increased manifold during the COVID pandemic. Under the patronage of political and religious leaders, many Indians actively utilized cow dung and urine regularly and in copious amounts, in the hopes of preventing and treating COVID, despite warnings from the scientific community [28] [29][30]. Ritual mass fumigations (<em>havans</em>) that involve the burning of cow dung cakes and ghee — and potentially facilitating large airborne spore dispersal — were claimed to have virucidal effects [31], and were conducted in the open in multiple urban and rural localities throughout India [32][33][34]. Crematoriums, unable to cope with the pace of unprecedented deaths, were encouraged to use cow dung as a substitute fuel for fast depleting wood [34a]. Gomutra Arka or Cow urine distillate is claimed to have been “used successfully” on COVID patients [35]. These practices, again, possibly paved the way for unusually large fungal loads, and, syllogistically, markedly elevated chances of systemic fungal infections amongst the Indians, especially the vulnerable, immunocompromised and diabetic COVID patients, exposed directly or indirectly to these practices. Cow dung could also potentially explain the instances of mixed fungal infections, such as concomitant mucormycosis and aspergillosis, reported in many Indian patients [35a], since dung has been shown to harbor multiple different fungal species [17].</p><p>4. In a country as large and diverse as India, a federation of 28 states and 8 centrally administered union territories, the above practices are not uniformly observed. Veneration of the cow and use of products containing cow excreta are known to be more concentrated in states that have larger rural populations with relatively lower levels of literacy and stricter adherence to religious practices. These states — collectively referred to as “cow-belt states” [36] in colloquial parlance — typically also have strict laws against cow-slaughter within their jurisdictions [37]. A review of the state-wise distribution of mucormycosis within the country shows a remarkable aggregation of the cases within the states that ban cow slaughter (and by extension, consider the cow sacred and are more likely to use cow excreta), like Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Rajasthan and Karnataka, while relatively sparing states like Kerala and West Bengal where cow slaughter is allowed (which in turn, translates as a populace less likely to use cow dung and cow urine therapies). (Figure 2). This is especially noticeable in the case of Kerala, which leads in the number of COVID positivity rates and Diabetes but has one of the smallest caseloads of mucormycosis, with 128 cases and 10 deaths [6] [37] [38] [38a].</p><p>Several striking incidents reported in the media of mass rituals involving the use of cow dung have been followed by reports of clusters of mucormycosis in the same areas. Examples include Kurnool [38b] [38c], Meerut [38d] [38e], Rohtak [32] [38f] and Belgaum (Belagavi) [34] [38g].</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*lunUY-4sYrffwj7xdoBWMQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 2: </strong><em>Comparative maps of India showing the relative clustering of cases of Mucormycosis in states that ban cow slaughter</em><strong>. </strong><em>(</em><strong><em>Credit: India Today, india.in.pixels</em></strong><em>)</em></figcaption></figure><p>While on the topic of geographical variations based on differences in the usage of cow dung within India, the rising mucormycosis cases in Iran also merit mention. Similar to the medicinal properties attributed to cow dung and its fumes in India, parts of Iran attribute therapeutic qualities to female donkey dung. Anbarnesa smoke derived by burning donkey dung is used as a traditional medicine, and was used extensively during COVID [38h]. The number of cases of mucormycosis in Iran has now crossed 500 [38i], and it would be useful to evaluate if a correlation exists between the use of anbarnesa and mucormycosis. Similarly, the higher rates of mucormycosis in countries with greater herbivore-human interactions like Iraq, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Central and South American countries are also worthy of further scrutiny.</p><p>5. Following on from the above, the role of other untested remedies in the prevention and treatment of COVID-19 cannot be discounted:</p><p>● Coronil, a purported herbal remedy has been widely used in India as an “alternative cure/prophylactic” for COVID-19 [39]and even exported as an “immunity booster” [40]. The product which has not undergone animal or human trials has been touted, in a solitary paper of dubious academic merit [41], as an immunomodulator that prevents SARS-CoV-2 S-protein mediated viral entry into animal cells. Human testing is indicated to ensure that the purported immunomodulator effects do not actually increase the predisposition of the user to opportunistic infections. Similarly, the potential presence of steroids [42]and/or cow excreta [43] [27]in various other indigenous remedies used in India, including herbal and homeopathic ones[44], and their possible role in the mucormycosis crisis [45], cannot be excluded without further studies.</p><p>● 2-Deoxy-D-Glucose (2DG) was approved for emergency use by Indian authorities in the treatment of COVID-19 in May 2021 [46], and has so far been used exclusively in India for the purpose. Several health experts have, however, questioned the approval, based on a lack of published data on the drug’s performance in human trials [47]. If its reported potential to cause hyperglycemia [48] is accurate, the drug could actually contribute to the patient developing mucormycosis, analogous to the role of steroids and Diabetes Mellitus in rendering the host vulnerable to the infection.</p><p>6. Another unique factor that needs to be considered in the Indian context is the millions of Indians who come in contact with river waters routinely, and especially during religious festivals like the Kumbh Mela [49]. In 2021, the Mela was held in April, and preceded the second wave of COVID-19 in India [50].<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7128512/"> </a>Mucorales are known to exist in surface waters [51],<a href="https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6164083/"> </a>and probably more so in polluted waters, and increased incidence of mucormycosis has been reported after natural disasters like tsunamis [52], thus pointing towards a potential water-borne route of entry. This factor gains additional importance in the Indian context since water from the River Ganga has also been touted as a ‘cure’ for COVID [53].</p><p>7. The low vaccination rates, and flouting of Covid norms in large religious and election gatherings had potentially resulted in a large cohort of Indians that was vulnerable to the SARS-CoV-2 infection <a href="https://paperpile.com/c/1fctb0/q0Fx">[54]</a>. The treatment of COVID with steroids markedly compounded the susceptibility of these patients to systemic fungal infections <a href="https://paperpile.com/c/1fctb0/XxuP">[56]</a>. Widespread overuse of steroids in the treatment of COVID in India has been reported in the Indian media [57]. The above risks were amplified manifold in a diabetic patient, due to the possibility of uncontrolled hyperglycemia caused by the combination of diabetes and steroids. The conjunction of steroid abuse with India’s enormous diabetic population [58] has been attributed as the major cause for its large numbers of mucormycosis infections [59] [60]. As host factors they remain relevant. However, as mentioned earlier, there is no evidence to suggest that the scale of steroid abuse and prevalence of diabetes in India are disproportionately high enough in comparison to the rest of the world to account for the country’s overwhelming share (99%) of global cases of mucormycosis <a href="https://paperpile.com/c/1fctb0/RXO2">[6]</a> during this particular epidemic. The above host factors do not take into account unique environmental factors, especially considering the fact that Mucorales have been isolated at disproportionately high rates in the Indian environment [60a]. This would again point to as yet unidentified factors unique to India, the ‘missing links’, working in tandem with other known and globally existent host risk factors such as diabetes and steroid use, in the causation of mucormycosis. The “environmental factor” in all likelihood , hence, provides the “missing link”. Burning of Mucorales rich substrates could potentially explain India’s increased environmental load of the fungus. In India’s case, as pointed out earlier, cow dung burnt extensively for various purposes, stands out as the most likely cause, especially during the COVID pandemic.</p><p>Stubble burning — the burning of harvested fields biannually, especially during the autumn-winter season, a common farming practice in northern India — could similarly be a cause of the high environmental load, potentially transmitting spores from both the vegetation and the manure-rich agricultural soil. This could also explain the seasonal variations — higher incidence during the autumn months — in Indian mucormycosis that have been pointed out by some mycologists [60b] [60c].</p><p><strong>Medical Precedent</strong></p><p>The natural history — and potentially the elimination — of mucormycosis has parallels to the Indian experience with neonatal tetanus.</p><p>In the 1980s, more than two hundred thousand newborns died every year in India due to neonatal tetanus [61]. This, when the preventable disease was already only of academic interest in the developed world. The World Health Organization (WHO) and the Indian government collaborated to identify and address the issues linked to the disproportionately high rates of this infection and neonatal fatalities in India, as compared to the rest of the world. Questions of a “missing link” in relation to India were raised, since the condition is caused by a spore-forming anaerobic bacterium (<em>Clostridium tetani)</em> that is present all around, especially in soil and animal manure — in India and the rest of the world. But what caused the high asymmetric prevalence of infections in India? Studies identified low antenatal vaccination rates, in conjunction with the high rates of home deliveries under unhygienic conditions, as the predominant causes [62]. In relation to the latter, the presence of cow dung in the immediate vicinity of childbirth — especially the application of cow/goat dung on the newborn’s umbilical cord stump was identified as a main factor. This finding made sense due to the abundant presence of tetanus spores in animal dung [63]. These core issues were focused on and tackled by India’s health workers, and ultimately led to the country successfully eliminating the condition in 2015 [64] [65].</p><p><strong>Evaluation of the Hypothesis</strong></p><p>The following methods of observational and experimental testing of the hypothesis are proposed:</p><p>● Further microbiological testing to confirm the presence of the fungi in cow excreta, with emphasis in evaluating whether particular species of Mucorales isolated from affected patients are also identified in cow dung and urine. The role of fungal spores spread through smoke from burning cow dung and stubble could be crucial in establishing the causative factor for the large Mucorales load in the Indian environment. Pyroaerobiology experts could play a pivotal role in establishing this connection.</p><p>● Detailed retrospective analysis of clinical histories of mucormycosis patients with emphasis on potential direct or indirect exposure to the spores — particularly the use of cow excreta in personal or communal daily use and rituals, including those involving burning of cow dung and inhaling the fumes, topical application and medications — needs to be performed. Occupational exposure — as in agriculture, manual scavenging, crematorium workers, priests — could be elucidated. History of contact with river waters, such as regular bathing or ritual dips, and the use of indigenous remedies also needs to be obtained.</p><p>● In patients with mucormycosis and known exposure to cow excreta, an attempt to correlate the mode of exposure to the form of the disease could be made. For example, if the hypothesis is accurate, those exposed to airborne spores through fumigation (<em>havan</em>) or extensive topical applications would contract rhinocerebral, pulmonary or cutaneous mucormycosis, while those who ingested them directly or through quack remedies would likely present with gastrointestinal or renal mucormycosis. Indeed, it is notable that isolated renal mucormycosis in an immunocompetent host is a clinical entity that is unique to India [3].</p><p><strong>Implications of the Hypothesis</strong></p><p>● Mucormycosis, once contracted, is a distressing, debilitating, mutilating and often lethal condition that is extremely difficult to treat. It can destroy patients and their families mentally, physically and financially. It is hard to overemphasize the importance of identifying the causes for the disproportionate prevalence of mucormycosis in India, since preventing the condition offers significantly better clinical and cost-effective outcomes for the general population.</p><p>● If the hypothesis is accurate, the reduction of risk could, in theory, be relatively simple by limiting exposure to the fungal spores. (Limiting exposure to fungal spores is known to reduce risk of systemic fungal infections, as multiple studies have shown increased risk and clustering of cases with unprotected exposure to fungus-laden dust during renovation and construction activities [66] [67], and even contaminated hospital linen [68].) While methods to achieve this in the Indian setting are potentially broader than with the aforementioned precedent of neonatal tetanus, the results of the exercise could be no less dramatic.</p><p>○ Educating the public on reducing the personal use of cow excreta in all forms, especially limiting burning of dung in open fires, would likely provide the highest clinical yield in attempts to eliminate the condition. Guidelines on precautions (protective equipment including gloves, shoes, long sleeved dress, masks) while handling animal excreta, including its agricultural use, could further help reduce the risk. The dangers of spreading the spores by burning of herbivore dung for fuel and in rituals should be made widely known to the public so that alternate, safer methods would be employed. Awareness on water-borne mucormycosis and the potential effect of polluted rivers also need to be stressed. While these attempts are likely to face resistance due to religio-cultural implications, the country’s success in achieving a similar objective with neonatal tetanus shows that it is not an impossible undertaking.</p><p>○ Curbing misinformation on all platforms, especially on social media, involving non-validated claims of success and usefulness of untested remedies should be undertaken alongside the above efforts.</p><p><strong>Conclusions</strong></p><p>This hypothesis proposes that the intersection of multiple causative factors unique to India account for the inordinate prevalence of mucormycosis in the country, particularly in relation to the second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic (Figure 3).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*b8334Zzhn9gkRs11tT9UQQ.jpeg" /><figcaption><strong>Figure 3: </strong><em>The intersection of multiple causative factors unique to India potentially account for the inordinate prevalence of mucormycosis in the country, particularly in relation to the second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic.</em></figcaption></figure><p>The most likely of these factors are:</p><p>● The widespread and varied use by Indians of cow excreta (especially dung) that is known to harbor Mucorales spores, thus exposing vulnerable, immunocompromised, and diabetic patients to heavy loads of the fungus in their immediate environment. The burning of cow dung as fuel and in rituals, and the practice of post-harvest stubble burning could potentially be of particular importance in the widespread dispersal of the spores, and likely contribute to the consistently high Mucorales count in the Indian environment.</p><p>● The large-scale use by Indians of untested and poorly tested remedies such as Coronil and 2-DG, that could have the potential for accentuating immunosuppression and hyperglycemia, thus increasing their susceptibility to the opportunistic fungal infection.</p><p>● Potential waterborne mucormycosis in the context of bathing in polluted rivers routinely and during rituals and festivals, and the ingestion of contaminated water, could also contribute to India’s disproportionate prevalence of the condition.</p><p>● If validated, the hypothesis that herbivore dung is linked to the causation of mucormycosis, would have global implications that can affect herbivore-human interactions across the world.</p><p><strong>REFERENCES</strong></p><p>[1] Kumar S. Second wave of COVID-19: Emergency situation in India. J Travel Med 2021. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1093/jtm/taab082">https://doi.org/10.1093/jtm/taab082</a>.</p><p>[2] Sarda R, Swain S, Ray A, Wig N. COVID-19 associated Mucormycosis: An epidemic within a pandemic. QJM 2021. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1093/qjmed/hcab165">https://doi.org/10.1093/qjmed/hcab165</a>.</p><p>[3] Prakash H, Chakrabarti A. Epidemiology of Mucormycosis in India. Microorganisms 2021;9. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3390/microorganisms9030523">https://doi.org/10.3390/microorganisms9030523</a>.</p><p>[4] Raut A, Huy NT. Rising incidence of mucormycosis in patients with COVID-19: another challenge for India amidst the second wave? Lancet Respir Med 2021. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-2600(21)00265-4">https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-2600(21)00265-4</a>.</p><p>[5] Prakash H, Chakrabarti A. Global Epidemiology of Mucormycosis. J Fungi (Basel) 2019;5. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3390/jof5010026">https://doi.org/10.3390/jof5010026</a>.</p><p>[6] [No title] n.d. <a href="https://governmentstats.com/mucormycosis/index.html%20">https://governmentstats.com/mucormycosis/index.html</a> (accessed September 3, 2021).</p><p>[7] Gandra S, Ram S, Levitz SM. The “Black Fungus” in India: The Emerging Syndemic of COVID-19-Associated Mucormycosis. Ann Intern Med 2021. <a href="https://doi.org/10.7326/M21-2354">https://doi.org/10.7326/M21-2354</a>.</p><p>[8] Kwon-Chung KJ. Taxonomy of fungi causing mucormycosis and entomophthoramycosis (zygomycosis) and nomenclature of the disease: molecular mycologic perspectives. Clin Infect Dis 2012;54 Suppl 1:S8–15. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/cir864">https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/cir864</a></p><p>[9] Richardson M. The ecology of the Zygomycetes and its impact on environmental exposure. Clin Microbiol Infect 2009;15 Suppl 5:2–9. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-0691.2009.02972.x">https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1469-0691.2009.02972.x</a></p><p>[10] Ribes JA, Vanover-Sams CL, Baker DJ. Zygomycetes in human disease. Clin Microbiol Rev 2000;13:236–301. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1128/CMR.13.2.236">https://doi.org/10.1128/CMR.13.2.236</a></p><p>[11] Petrikkos G, Skiada A, Lortholary O, Roilides E, Walsh TJ, Kontoyiannis DP. Epidemiology and clinical manifestations of mucormycosis. Clin Infect Dis 2012;54 Suppl 1:S23–34. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/cir866">https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/cir866</a></p><p>[12] Gamaletsou MN, Sipsas NV, Roilides E, Walsh TJ. Rhino-orbital-cerebral mucormycosis. Curr Infect Dis Rep 2012;14:423–34. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s11908-012-0272-6">https://doi.org/10.1007/s11908-012-0272-6</a></p><p>[13] Roden MM, Zaoutis TE, Buchanan WL, Knudsen TA, Sarkisova TA, Schaufele RL, et al. Epidemiology and outcome of zygomycosis: a review of 929 reported cases. Clin Infect Dis 2005;41:634–53. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1086/432579">https://doi.org/10.1086/432579</a></p><p>[14] Hargrove RN, Wesley RE, Klippenstein KA, Fleming JC, Haik BG. Indications for orbital exenteration in mucormycosis. Ophthal Plast Reconstr Surg 2006;22:286–91. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1097/01.iop.0000225418.50441.ee">https://doi.org/10.1097/01.iop.0000225418.50441.ee</a></p><p>[15] COVID-19: Did India read mucormycosis right? n.d. <a href="https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/health/covid-19-did-india-read-mucormycosis-right--77537%20">https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/health/covid-19-did-india-read-mucormycosis-right--77537</a> (accessed July 4, 2021).</p><p>[16] Richardson MD, Rautemaa-Richardson R. Biotic Environments Supporting the Persistence of Clinically Relevant Mucormycetes. J Fungi (Basel) 2019;6. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3390/jof6010004">https://doi.org/10.3390/jof6010004</a>.</p><p>[17] Obire O, Okigbo RN, Ojim CF, Others. Fungal population and diversity in partially digested cellulose from the abomasum of beef cows. J Agric Sci Technol 2010;6:783–92. <a href="http://www.ijat-aatsea.com/pdf/October_v6_n4_10/16-112-IJAT2009_92R.pdf">http://www.ijat-aatsea.com/pdf/October_v6_n4_10/16-112-IJAT2009_92R.pdf</a></p><p>[18]Coprophilous Mucorales (ex Zygomycota) from three areas in the semi-arid of Pernambuco, Brazil: <a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1517838216309054">https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1517838216309054</a></p><p>[19] McGranaghan P, Davies JC, Griffith GW, Davies DR, Theodorou MK. The survival of anaerobic fungi in cattle faeces. FEMS Microbiol Ecol 1999;29:293–300. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1574-6941.1999.tb00620.x">https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1574-6941.1999.tb00620.x</a></p><p>[20] Khiralla AAI. A study on the ecological group coprophilous (dung) fungi in Khartoum. UOFK, 2015.</p><p>[21] Pathak S. Cow Dung Soap Is Cleaning Up In India. NPR 2018. <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2018/10/03/653739760/cow-dung-soap-is-cleaning-up-in-india">https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2018/10/03/653739760/cow-dung-soap-is-cleaning-up-in-india</a></p><p>[22] Notermans C. Prayers of Cow Dung: Women Sculpturing Fertile Environments in Rural Rajasthan (India). Religions 2019;10:71. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3390/rel10020071">https://doi.org/10.3390/rel10020071</a></p><p>[23] Brown WN. The sanctity of the cow in Hinduism. éditeur non identifié; 1964. <a href="https://www.epw.in/system/files/pdf/1964_16/5-6-7/the_sanctity_of_the_cow_in_hinduism.pdf">https://www.epw.in/system/files/pdf/1964_16/5-6-7/the_sanctity_of_the_cow_in_hinduism.pdf</a></p><p>[24] Raut AA, Vaidya ADB. Panchgavya and cow products: A trail for the holy grail. J Ayurveda Integr Med 2018;9:64–6. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaim.2017.12.005">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jaim.2017.12.005</a></p><p>[25] Singh PK, Mohanta N. A REVIEW ON HAVAN: DRUG DELIVERY BEYOND SCIENCE. Journal of Biological &amp; Scientific Opinion 2020;8:21–5. <a href="https://doi.org/10.7897/2321-6328.082122">https://doi.org/10.7897/2321-6328.082122</a>.</p><p>[25a] Mims, Sarah &amp; Mims III, Forrest. (2004). Fungal spores are transported long distances in smoke from biomass fires. Atmospheric Environment. 38. 651–655. 10.1016/j.atmosenv.2003.10.043. <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.atmosenv.2003.10.043">http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.atmosenv.2003.10.043</a></p><p>[25b] A deadly fungal disease on the rise in the West has experts worried (2021): <a href="https://grist.org/health/valley-fever-rising-us-west-wildfires-cocci-fungus/">https://grist.org/health/valley-fever-rising-us-west-wildfires-cocci-fungus/</a> (accessed September 20, 2021).</p><p>[26] Bhattacharya DP. Gujarat centre relies on cow urine, herbs, homeopathy to treat mild cases. Economic Times 2021. <a href="https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/gujarat-centre-relies-on-cow-urine-herbs-homeopathy-to-treat-mild-cases/articleshow/82513198.cms%20">https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/india/gujarat-centre-relies-on-cow-urine-herbs-homeopathy-to-treat-mild-cases/articleshow/82513198.cms</a> (accessed July 18, 2021).</p><p>[27] Mahajan SP, Chavan SA, Shinde SA, Narkhede MB. Miraculous Benefits of Cow Urine: A Review. Journal of Drug Delivery and Therapeutics 2020;10:275–81. <a href="https://doi.org/10.22270/jddt.v10i4-s.4267">https://doi.org/10.22270/jddt.v10i4-s.4267</a></p><p>[28] Panchagavya, Gaumutra and Yoga: Re-inventing Hinduised Medical Practices in Times of Pandemic — Asia Research Institute, NUS 2020. <a href="https://ari.nus.edu.sg/20331-38/%20">https://ari.nus.edu.sg/20331-38/</a> (accessed July 4, 2021).</p><p>[29] Indian doctors warn against cow dung as COVID cure. Reuters 2021. <a href="https://www.reuters.com/world/india/indian-doctors-warn-against-cow-dung-covid-cure-2021-05-11/">https://www.reuters.com/world/india/indian-doctors-warn-against-cow-dung-covid-cure-2021-05-11/</a></p><p>[30] As coronavirus spreads around the world, so too do the quack cures. The Guardian 2020. <a href="https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/16/as-coronavirus-spreads-around-the-world-so-too-do-the-quack-cures">https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/16/as-coronavirus-spreads-around-the-world-so-too-do-the-quack-cures</a></p><p>[31] Kumar N, Tripathi N, Kanchibotla D. Virucidal Effect of Medicinal Smoke for Mass Fumigation using Hawan Techniques during SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic: A Review. (ISSN: 2394–6539 … 2394. <a href="https://journals.indexcopernicus.com/api/file/viewByFileId/1159543.pdf">https://journals.indexcopernicus.com/api/file/viewByFileId/1159543.pdf</a></p><p>[32] Tribune News Service. Rohtak residents turn to havan to cleanse air of coronavirus. The Tribune India 2021. <a href="https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/haryana/rohtak-residents-turn-to-havan-to-cleanse-air-of-coronavirus-251403%20">https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/haryana/rohtak-residents-turn-to-havan-to-cleanse-air-of-coronavirus-251403</a> (accessed July 4, 2021).</p><p>[33] News18. BJP Leader in Jammu &amp; Kashmir Performs “Havan” to Beat Covid-19. News18 2021. <a href="https://www.news18.com/news/india/bjp-leader-in-jammu-kashmir-performs-havan-to-beat-covid-19-3742334.html%20">https://www.news18.com/news/india/bjp-leader-in-jammu-kashmir-performs-havan-to-beat-covid-19-3742334.html</a> (accessed July 4, 2021).</p><p>[34] Dwarakanath N. Fumes fill Belgaum streets as Karnataka BJP MLA carries out havan to ward off Covid-19 2021. <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/coronavirus-outbreak/story/fumes-fill-belgaum-streets-karnataka-bjp-mla-abhay-patil-carries-out-havan-ward-off-covid-19-watch-1807061-2021-05-26">https://www.indiatoday.in/coronavirus-outbreak/story/fumes-fill-belgaum-streets-karnataka-bjp-mla-abhay-patil-carries-out-havan-ward-off-covid-19-watch-1807061-2021-05-26</a> (accessed July 18, 2021).</p><p>[34a] 2 Delhi civic bodies approve use of cow dung for cremation of bodies amid surge in COVID deaths (2021). <a href="https://www.outlookindia.com/newsscroll/2-delhi-civic-bodies-approve-use-of-cow-dung-for-cremation-of-bodies-amid-surge-in-covid-deaths/2075958">https://www.outlookindia.com/newsscroll/2-delhi-civic-bodies-approve-use-of-cow-dung-for-cremation-of-bodies-amid-surge-in-covid-deaths/2075958</a> (accessed September 20, 2021).</p><p>[35] Tijare P, Ambatkar N, Tiwari V. Clinical Improvement In COVID19 Patients With Timely Intervention Of Panchagavya Medicine: A Preliminary Finding. Int J of Pharmc Res 2020;10:e5449–e5449. <a href="https://www.ssjournals.com/index.php/ijpr/article/view/5449">https://www.ssjournals.com/index.php/ijpr/article/view/5449</a></p><p>[35a] Singh V, Prasad A, Panda PK. Mixed invasive molds among COVID-19 patients. medRxiv 2021.08.09.21261555. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.08.09.21261555">https://doi.org/10.1101/2021.08.09.21261555</a></p><p>[36] Mandal DK. Buffalo nationalism and dalit aesthetics- a subaltern study of dhouli by mahasweta Devi. International Journal Of All Research Writings 2019;2:1–2. <a href="http://ijciras.com/PublishedPaper/IJCIRAS1367.pdf">http://ijciras.com/PublishedPaper/IJCIRAS1367.pdf</a></p><p>[37] ANNEX II (8) n.d. <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20131029185034/http:/www.dahd.nic.in/dahd/reports/report-of-the-national-commission-on-cattle/chapter-ii-executive-summary/annex-ii-8.aspx%20">https://web.archive.org/web/20131029185034/http://www.dahd.nic.in/dahd/reports/report-of-the-national-commission-on-cattle/chapter-ii-executive-summary/annex-ii-8.aspx</a> (accessed July 18, 2021).</p><p>[38] Chapter ii executive summary n.d. <a href="https://web.archive.org/web/20131109002416/http:/www.dahd.nic.in/dahd/reports/report-of-the-national-commission-on-cattle/chapter-ii-executive-summary.aspx%20">https://web.archive.org/web/20131109002416/http://www.dahd.nic.in/dahd/reports/report-of-the-national-commission-on-cattle/chapter-ii-executive-summary.aspx</a> (accessed July 18, 2021).</p><p>[38a] <a href="https://twitter.com/Lalitha_Ranjani/status/1421786773076643840?s=20">https://twitter.com/Lalitha_Ranjani/status/1421786773076643840?s=20</a></p><p>[38b] <a href="https://www.indiatoday.in/coronavirus-outbreak/video/flouting-covid-norms-hundreds-take-part-in-ugadi-festival-in-andhra-pradesh-1791228-2021-04-15">https://www.indiatoday.in/coronavirus-outbreak/video/flouting-covid-norms-hundreds-take-part-in-ugadi-festival-in-andhra-pradesh-1791228-2021-04-15</a></p><p>[38c] <a href="https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/in-other-news/110721/kurnool-government-general-hospital-performs-record-black-fungus-surge.html">https://www.deccanchronicle.com/nation/in-other-news/110721/kurnool-government-general-hospital-performs-record-black-fungus-surge.html</a></p><p>[38d] <a href="https://www.news18.com/news/buzz/bjp-leader-performs-mobile-hawan-blows-shankh-in-meerut-neighbourhood-to-end-coronavirus-3752657.html">https://www.news18.com/news/buzz/bjp-leader-performs-mobile-hawan-blows-shankh-in-meerut-neighbourhood-to-end-coronavirus-3752657.html</a></p><p>[38e] <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/meerut/with-86-cases-6-deaths-meerut-emerges-as-another-black-fungus-hotbed-after-lucknow/articleshow/82864062.cms">https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/meerut/with-86-cases-6-deaths-meerut-emerges-as-another-black-fungus-hotbed-after-lucknow/articleshow/82864062.cms</a></p><p>[38f] <a href="https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chandigarh/100-days-of-mucormycosis-in-haryana-1719-cases-254-deaths/articleshow/85054001.cms">https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chandigarh/100-days-of-mucormycosis-in-haryana-1719-cases-254-deaths/articleshow/85054001.cms</a></p><p>[38g]<a href="https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/karnataka/2021/jun/14/no-specialiststo-treat-black-fungus-in-belagavi-district-kin-of-patients-2315843.html">https://www.newindianexpress.com/states/karnataka/2021/jun/14/no-specialiststo-treat-black-fungus-in-belagavi-district-kin-of-patients-2315843.html</a></p><p>[38h] <a href="https://headtopics.com/mx/remedios-extranos-de-ir-n-contra-el-coronavirus-11813090">https://headtopics.com/mx/remedios-extranos-de-ir-n-contra-el-coronavirus-11813090</a></p><p>[38i] <a href="https://iranintl.com/en/iran/lethal-%E2%80%98black-fungus%E2%80%99-hits-500-iran-covid-patients">https://iranintl.com/en/iran/lethal-%E2%80%98black-fungus%E2%80%99-hits-500-iran-covid-patients</a></p><p>[39] Menon S. Coronavirus: The misleading claims about an Indian remedy. BBC 2021. <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/56172784">https://www.bbc.com/news/56172784</a></p><p>[40] Patel K. Covid-19: Fake “immunity booster” found on sale in London shops. BBC 2020. <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-55318095">https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-55318095</a></p><p>[41] Balkrishna A, Haldar S, Singh H, Roy P, Varshney A. Coronil, a Tri-Herbal Formulation, Attenuates Spike-Protein-Mediated SARS-CoV-2 Viral Entry into Human Alveolar Epithelial Cells and Pro-Inflammatory Cytokines Production by Inhibiting Spike Protein-ACE-2 Interaction. J Inflamm Res 2021;14:869–84. <a href="https://doi.org/10.2147/JIR.S298242">https://doi.org/10.2147/JIR.S298242</a></p><p>[42] Paudyal B, Thapa A, Sigdel KR, Adhikari S, Basnyat B. Adverse events with ayurvedic medicines- possible adulteration and some inherent toxicities. Wellcome Open Res 2019;4:23. <a href="https://doi.org/10.12688/wellcomeopenres.15096.3">https://doi.org/10.12688/wellcomeopenres.15096.3</a></p><p>[43] Dhillon A. Cow dung cocktails: why India can’t get enough of quack Covid-19 “cures.” South China Morning Post 2021 <a href="https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/health-environment/article/3134352/cow-dung-cocktails-why-india-cant-get-enough-quack">https://www.scmp.com/week-asia/health-environment/article/3134352/cow-dung-cocktails-why-india-cant-get-enough-quack</a> (accessed July 4, 2021).</p><p>[44] Binder U, Maurer E, Lass-Flörl C. Mucormycosis — from the pathogens to the disease. Clin Microbiol Infect 2014;20 Suppl 6:60–6. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1111/1469-0691.12566">https://doi.org/10.1111/1469-0691.12566</a></p><p>[45] Bhowmick N. Indian doctors protest herbal treatments being touted for COVID-19. National Geographic 2021. <a href="https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/indian-doctors-protest-herbal-treatments-being-touted-for-covid-19">https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/indian-doctors-protest-herbal-treatments-being-touted-for-covid-19</a></p><p>[46] Borana R. India’s Drug Regulator Has Approved DRDO’s New COVID Drug on Missing Evidence — The Wire Science 2021. <a href="https://science.thewire.in/the-sciences/dcgi-drdo-2-dg-covid-19-treatment-phase-2-3-trials-shoddy-evidence/%20">https://science.thewire.in/the-sciences/dcgi-drdo-2-dg-covid-19-treatment-phase-2-3-trials-shoddy-evidence/</a> (accessed July 6, 2021).</p><p>[47] Koshy J. Questions remain on DRDO’s COVID drug. The Hindu 2021. <a href="https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/questions-remain-on-drdos-covid-drug/article34537596.ece%20">https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/questions-remain-on-drdos-covid-drug/article34537596.ece</a> (accessed July 4, 2021).</p><p>[48] Pascoe WS, Smythe GA, Storlien LH. 2-deoxy-D-glucose-induced hyperglycemia: role for direct sympathetic nervous system activation of liver glucose output. Brain Res 1989;505:23–8. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/0006-8993(89)90111-X">https://doi.org/10.1016/0006-8993(89)90111-X</a></p><p>[49] Sridhar S, Gautret P, Brouqui P. A comprehensive review of the Kumbh Mela: identifying risks for spread of infectious diseases. Clin Microbiol Infect 2015;21:128–33. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmi.2014.11.021">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmi.2014.11.021</a></p><p>[50] Pandey G. India Covid: Kumbh Mela pilgrims turn into super-spreaders. BBC 2021. <a href="https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-57005563">https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-57005563</a></p><p>[51] Novak Babič M, Zupančič J, Brandão J, Gunde-Cimerman N. Opportunistic Water-Borne Human Pathogenic Filamentous Fungi Unreported from Food. Microorganisms 2018;6. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3390/microorganisms6030079">https://doi.org/10.3390/microorganisms6030079</a>.</p><p>[52] Benedict K, Park BJ. Invasive fungal infections after natural disasters. Emerg Infect Dis 2014;20:349–55. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3201/eid2003.131230">https://doi.org/10.3201/eid2003.131230</a></p><p>[53] Mishra VN, Kumari N, Pathak A, Chaturvedi RK, Gupta AK, Chaurasia RN. Possible Role for Bacteriophages in the Treatment of SARS-CoV-2 Infection. Int J Microbiol 2020;2020:8844963. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/8844963">https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/8844963</a></p><p>[54] Frayer L. <a href="https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2021/06/29/1011022472/india-is-the-worlds-biggest-vaccine-maker-yet-only-4-of-indians-are-vaccinated#:~:text=Yet%20Only%204%25%20Of%20Indians%20Are%20Vaccinated,-Listen%C2%B7%205%3A19&amp;text=via%20Getty%20Images-,On%20June%2025%2C%20people%20queued%20up%20to%20register%20for%20a,to%20a%20shortage%20of%20doses.">India Is The World’s Biggest Vaccine Maker. Yet Only 4% Of Indians Are Vaccinated. NPR 2021</a>.</p><p>[55] Mishra GP, Mulani J. Corticosteroids for COVID-19: the search for an optimum duration of therapy. Lancet Respir Med 2021;9:e8. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/s2213-2600(20)30530-0">https://doi.org/10.1016/s2213-2600(20)30530-0</a></p><p>[56] Tandon A, Pandey L. COVID-19, steroids, and mucormycosis: What an ophthalmologist should know. Indian J Ophthalmol 2021;69:1970. <a href="https://doi.org/10.4103/ijo.ijo_1143_21">https://doi.org/10.4103/ijo.ijo_1143_21</a></p><p>[57] Use of steroids in Covid-19 treatment: What experts have warned so far. Hindustan Times 2021. <a href="https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/use-of-steroids-in-covid-19-treatment-what-experts-have-warned-so-far-101621184470534.html">https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/use-of-steroids-in-covid-19-treatment-what-experts-have-warned-so-far-101621184470534.html</a></p><p>[58] Editor. Diabetes in India 2019. <a href="https://www.diabetes.co.uk/global-diabetes/diabetes-in-india.html%20">https://www.diabetes.co.uk/global-diabetes/diabetes-in-india.html</a> (accessed July 4, 2021).</p><p>[59] Moorthy A, Gaikwad R, Krishna S, Hegde R, Tripathi KK, Kale PG, et al. SARS-CoV-2, Uncontrolled Diabetes and Corticosteroids-An Unholy Trinity in Invasive Fungal Infections of the Maxillofacial Region? A Retrospective, Multi-centric Analysis. J Maxillofac Oral Surg 2021:1–8. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s12663-021-01532-1">https://doi.org/10.1007/s12663-021-01532-1</a></p><p>[60] Patel A, Agarwal R, Rudramurthy SM, Shevkani M, Xess I, Sharma R, et al. Multicenter Epidemiologic Study of Coronavirus Disease-Associated Mucormycosis, India. Emerg Infect Dis 2021;27. <a href="https://doi.org/10.3201/eid2709.210934">https://doi.org/10.3201/eid2709.210934</a>.</p><p>[60a] Chakrabarti A. The recent mucormycosis storm over Indian sky. <em>Indian J Med Microbiol</em>. 2021;39(3):269–270. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmmb.2021.06.010">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmmb.2021.06.010</a></p><p>[60b] Muhammad Isa Abdurrahman, Sukalpaa Chaki, Gaurav Saini. Stubble burning: Effects on health &amp; environment, regulations and management practices,Environmental Advances,</p><p>Volume 2,2020,100011,ISSN 2666–7657. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envadv.2020.100011">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envadv.2020.100011</a></p><p>[60c] <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12161726/">https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12161726/</a></p><p>[61] Sokhey J, Bhargava I. Control of neonatal tetanus in India. Indian Pediatr 1984;21:515–9. <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6519778/">https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/6519778/</a></p><p>[62] Bairwa M, Sk S, Rajput M, Khanna P, Malik JS, Nagar M. India is on the way forward to maternal and neonatal tetanus elimination! Hum Vaccin Immunother 2012;8:1129–31. <a href="https://dx.doi.org/10.4161%2Fhv.20262">https://dx.doi.org/10.4161%2Fhv.20262</a></p><p>[63] Roper MH, Vandelaer JH, Gasse FL. Maternal and neonatal tetanus. Lancet 2007;370:1947–59. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(07)61261-6">https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(07)61261-6</a></p><p>[64] Annadurai K, Danasekaran R, Mani G. Elimination of Maternal and Neonatal Tetanus in India: A Triumph Tale. Int J Prev Med 2017;8:15. <a href="https://doi.org/10.4103/ijpvm.IJPVM_392_15">https://doi.org/10.4103/ijpvm.IJPVM_392_15</a></p><p>[65] editorial@tribune.com. India declared free of neonatal tetanus, Yaws. The Tribune India 2016. <a href="https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/archive/nation/india-declared-free-of-neonatal-tetanus-yaws-266162%20">https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/archive/nation/india-declared-free-of-neonatal-tetanus-yaws-266162</a> (accessed July 4, 2021).</p><p>[66] Krasinski K, Holzman RS, Hanna B, Greco MA, Graff M, Bhogal M. Nosocomial fungal infection during hospital renovation. Infect Control 1985;6:278–82. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1017/s0195941700061750">https://doi.org/10.1017/s0195941700061750</a></p><p>[67] Kanamori H, Rutala WA, Sickbert-Bennett EE, Weber DJ. Review of fungal outbreaks and infection prevention in healthcare settings during construction and renovation. Clin Infect Dis 2015;61:433–44. <a href="https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/civ297">https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/civ297</a></p><p>[68] Alexander J Sundermann, Cornelius J Clancy, A William Pasculle, et al. Remediation of Mucorales-contaminated Healthcare Linens at a Laundry Facility Following an Investigation of a Case Cluster of Hospital-acquired Mucormycosis, <em>Clinical Infectious Diseases</em>, 2021;, ciab638, <a href="https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/ciab638">https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/ciab638</a></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=5e95f8248e29" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>