<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jim Nolan on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jim Nolan on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 08:06:31 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strat-O-Matic Hockey, Retconning 2020: Part I, The Final Rush]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-hockey-retconning-2020-part-i-the-final-rush-00b55ea05445?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/00b55ea05445</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stanley-cup]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nhl]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stratomatic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[hockey]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 Jan 2024 15:45:40 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2024-01-12T16:21:12.035Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>In this fictitious scenario, the NHL resumes play on May 1, 2020 with a sprint to the finish line</em></p><p>Originally, I wanted to get a football game.</p><p>I had an itch to go back to my youth when I played APBA Football, but I couldn’t think of a scenario I liked. The closest I got was one where I would finish the 2022 Bills-Bengals game where Damar Hamlin had his cardiac arrest as if that never happened, then playing any Week 18 games that affected the AFC playoff picture, and so on.</p><p>Then I looked at that NFL schedule, and saw not much was really affected. Anyone in contention for home-field advantage in the AFC won that week. Was it really necessary for me to play the Chiefs-Raiders game? No, it wasn’t. So that was uninspiring.</p><p>Also, football seemed difficult to manage. All the formations, schemes, and keeping track of 22 players on the field with substitutions. The sport has also evolved beyond my comprehension because I still think lining up in the shotgun on 4th and 1 from your own 40, or going for 2 when you’re down 9 points late, does not compute.</p><p>But I almost bought a game anyway. That’s how much I wanted to get back into cards and dice, nearly 11 months after <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-qualifying-round-highlights-1fe96ed12f76">Modern Champions</a> baseball was completed. I was on the Strat-O-Matic store site, ready to get football, and that’s when I saw hockey.</p><p>Just like with baseball over a year and a half earlier, I went from having a “meh…ok” idea to a “oh, this could be good” idea. This felt just like the birth of the Modern Champions Tournament.</p><p>I didn’t just work for MLB Network last decade. We took over production of NHL Network in 2015. I don’t miss editing the video or the late nights driving home on the New Jersey Turnpike; what I miss is watching the local broadcasts rehearse and prepare their sponsored elements before the games would start, and I also miss just not knowing everything that’s going on in the league.</p><p>So I’m throwing it back to when I did. I worked four full seasons cutting hockey games, and two weeks of a 5th. I returned home to Pennsylvania in November of 2019.</p><p>I got out just in time. Would have been laid off during the pandemic, probably. Ten months after I left, I watched on TV as the Stanley Cup for my fifth season was awarded to the Tampa Bay Lightning with no fans present and fake crowd noise piped in.</p><p>So, <em>that’s</em> the idea: Finishing 2020 as properly as possible and with a normal playoff structure.</p><p>I did something similar during the actual pandemic with an old college basketball game called <em>March Madness</em>, and I’ve considered that 2020 NCAA Tournament played on our dining-room table to be “what really happened.” I still catch myself thinking Gonzaga won the national championship.</p><p>I thought the NHL and NBA did the best they could in 2020, and applauded them for finishing their seasons in their respective bubbles. In retrospect, one wishes they could have played in home arenas with reduced admissions and other precautions since we all still went to stores and places we had to go, and most of us tried to take care of each other, but those pesky little things like “no available tests” and “no international travel” would be buggers for the NHL. Let’s just pretend those obstacles were cleared a lot sooner.</p><p>Because, while the NHL bubbles got the league’s mission accomplished, there were flaws and it was lacking. I didn’t like the expanded Qualifying Round, and I really disliked the round-robin seeding games. <a href="https://www.nbcsportsboston.com/nhl/boston-bruins/nhl-round-robin-qualifying-series-schedule-2020-dates-scores-for-every-game/330896/">In case you’ve forgotten</a>, the top four teams in each conference played three games against each other to determine seeds for the playoffs, mainly so those teams could stay fresh while the Qualifying Round was taking place. The Philadelphia Flyers, who finished second in their division, won a few games and got the unearned number-one seed in the East. I don’t even remember or care who did so in the West.</p><p>We’re not going to do that at all. Our structure is a scaled-down version of what the NBA did, and that’s to complete the regular season with the contending teams and then have regular playoffs. Though we’re not doing a bubble; we’re using home arenas. You could imagine it’s with limited capacity or in full buildings, whatever you choose.</p><p>But we are <em>not</em> going to pretend the pandemic didn’t exist here, and that’s because it would take about five years for me to finish the full 82-game regular season and playoffs.</p><p>In this alternative universe, the NHL comes back and wraps up the regular season on the weekend of May 1–3. The league’s intention is to equitably get it completed as soon as possible, followed by the 16-team bracket for the Stanley Cup Playoffs beginning on May 6. It should be all done at either the end of June or early July, and the following season should start relatively on time.</p><p>And again, I’ll consider it to be “what really happened” 😉.</p><p>The first step is to look at the standings when the season was suspended on March 12. I’ll explain the extra columns below.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*xU0OgGYqM3MCJ7xHrx1A1A@2x.jpeg" /><figcaption>Two points for wins, one point for overtime or shootout losses (OTL). Correction: Carolina’s playoff position should say “in”. They would win a tiebreaker over Columbus even if they get no points in their last two games.</figcaption></figure><p>A quick reminder: The top three teams in each division make the playoffs, followed by two wild cards in each conference.</p><p>No team had played more than 71 games. Qualification and seeding for the Stanley Cup Playoffs will be based on a 71-game schedule in the Western Conference. Since no Eastern Conference team that has already played 71 games is in a playoff position, the East bracket will be based on 70 regular-season games.</p><p>Note the “Playoff Position” and “End-Of-Season Opponents” columns. To get all contending teams to their target number of Games Played, the league has devised a mini-schedule of eight games to conclude the regular season. They will involve teams that are either in contention for playoff spots or those who have already qualified but whose seeding is uncertain.</p><p><strong>Regular Season Games To Play<br>Friday, May 1:</strong> NY Islanders at Carolina; Dallas at Minnesota<br><strong>Saturday, May 2: </strong>Minnesota at Nashville; Vancouver at Colorado<strong><br>Sunday, May 3: </strong>Philadelphia at Carolina; NY Islanders at Washington; Nashville at Dallas; Vancouver at Calgary</p><p>I like to think the public relations arm of the NHL office would give this weekend slate a cute name, and came up with “The Final Rush”.</p><p>Imagine it on television: “The NHL on NBC presents ‘The Final Rush’ from Capital One Arena in Washington, D.C…”</p><p><strong>Exception:</strong> The Pittsburgh Penguins have played 69 games but are locked into the #3 seed in the Metropolitan Division. Since their position would be unaffected by a 70th game, they will not participate in The Final Rush.</p><p>Any team whose playoff position is clinched does not need to play in The Final Rush. If you want to imagine the league allowed them to schedule inter-conference exhibition games to get ready for the playoffs, go ahead and imagine it. I just won’t play them.</p><p>The season is over for any team mathematically eliminated based on the new target number of Games Played. Sorry, Rangers.</p><p>I also figured out a bunch of tiebreaker scenarios because it’s very likely that after The Final Rush, there will be a tie for at least one playoff spot. There were too many possibilities to list here, but my favorite was this…</p><h4>If Minnesota beats Nashville in OT, then both beat Dallas, and Vancouver beats Colorado but loses to Calgary in OT…Dallas (82 points) is C3, Vancouver (81) is P3, Minnesota (81) is WWC1, Nashville (81) is WWC2, Calgary (81) and Winnipeg (80) are out</h4><p>…which means: Calgary is starting The Final Rush in a playoff position, <em>could win their one game</em>, but since it’s in overtime they could miss the playoffs if the other results come in which causes them to lose the tiebreaker. It’s very unlikely, but just it being possible is tremendous, I think.</p><p>A few quick notes about Strat-O-Matic Hockey before I get to the game recaps.</p><p>I had played it briefly, about 30 years ago. I liked it, but thought it could have been better. Many other people thought so as well, and I found <a href="http://strat-hockey.net/modifiers.html">this site with a bunch of rule modifications just made by regular players</a>.</p><p>Let me show you the cards, just for reference. Player cards have attribute ratings and columns for shooting, passing, and defense.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*tpzeQ9dt3qAa1ot4MqwyzA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>And here’s an action card. There are 30 action cards, and what you really need to know is each one represents 40 seconds of play. 30 cards equals 20 minutes. They are shuffled after each period.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*TjeiPXBTERieNhqjBwIchg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>I wonder if the company decades ago thought fans weren’t savvy enough to make constant shift changes because, to simplify the game, the instructions say to play a forward line for 10 <em>consecutive</em> cards in each period. That’s almost 7 minutes at a time! Sure, the gameflow is good and you would get a realistic number of shots, stats, and time on ice, but that’s just not authentic.</p><p>So, people figured out their own ways to change units on the fly. So did I. We’re changing the forwards every two cards, and the defensemen every three cards. Yes, it’s a lot to keep up with and does get confusing at times, and I get the irony for thinking hockey was an easier game to play than football. I’m just more familiar with the hockey world.</p><p>The game also doesn’t produce enough face-offs. So I added some rules to create more stoppages for offside, icing, goalies holding/covering after saves, and the puck going out of play. Plus, there’s my personal favorite: adding the three automatic time-outs per period.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7Kq-t4TzQ3MikrbVGZNMVg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Finally, in a first for me, I found it more convenient and faster to actually play <em>without</em> the board. I’m only using it for the penalty clock at the one end. Instead, I made personnel piles — four forward lines and three defense pairs a side. I put a marker by who’s on the ice.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*7npY3svOzgIaqJWNwlFW2A@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>I combed through the box scores and summaries of each team’s final games before the season was suspended to find as many true line combinations as I could, including power-play and penalty-kill units. So I control those as well as the shift changes; the rest is up to the cards and dice.</p><p><em>FRIDAY, MAY 1, 2020</em></p><p><strong>New York Islanders at Carolina Hurricanes</strong></p><p>What Happens If…<br><strong>Islanders win:</strong> They clinch a playoff spot as one of the two Eastern wild cards; Hurricanes would be unaffected for now but are also in as a wild card. Seeding would be determined by their final games on Sunday (NYI at Washington, CAR home vs. Philadelphia)<br><strong>Hurricanes regulation win:</strong> They clinch the first Eastern wild card and will play whoever wins the Metropolitan Division in the first round of the Stanley Cup Playoffs; Islanders would be forced to win their final game on Sunday<br><strong>Hurricanes overtime/shootout win:</strong> Same result as a regulation win for the Hurricanes; Islanders would then need one point in final game on Sunday to make playoffs</p><p>Let’s track the games by their box scores. My very simple running commentary is in italics. I recommend using the down-arrow one line at a time from this point on.</p><p><strong>1st Period</strong></p><p>No scoring.</p><p><em>I’m wondering now if anyone will ever score. Not just in this game, but in this whole experiment.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Islanders 9, Hurricanes 9</p><p><strong>2nd Period</strong></p><p>CAR — Aho 39 (Svechnikov 38, Teravainen 49), 2:08</p><p><em>Carolina’s TSA Line (Teuvo Teravainen, Andrei Svechnikov, Sebastian Aho) breaks through for the first goal of the restart. “That’s hockey, baby, and it’s back!” Canes broadcaster </em><a href="https://www.yahoo.com/video/hurricanes-announcer-self-isolation-staying-191107168.html"><em>John Forslund</em></a><em> might have said.</em></p><p>NYI — Pageau 27 (unassisted), 14:13</p><p>CAR — Aho 40 (Teravainen 50, Svechnikov 39), 19:57 (PP)</p><p><em>A sloppy turnover by the Islanders while shorthanded gives Aho his second goal with three seconds left in the period. 2 to 1, Carolina.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Islanders 7 (16 total), Hurricanes 11 (20)</p><p><strong>3rd Period</strong></p><p>CAR — Teravainen 16 (Svechnikov 40, Aho 29), 11:35 (PP)</p><p>NYI — Eberle 17 (unassisted), 15:36</p><p><em>Islanders not done yet, down a goal.</em></p><p>CAR — Teravainen 17 (Svechnikov 41, Aho 30), 19:40 (EN)</p><p><em>Now they’re done. They have to win in Washington on Sunday. The TSA line produces four goals.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Islanders 11 (27), Hurricanes 10 (30)</p><p><strong>Power Plays</strong></p><p>NYI — 0 for 2, CAR — 2 for 3.</p><p><strong>Goaltending</strong></p><p>NYI — Varlamov: 29 shots, 26 saves</p><p>CAR — Mrazek: 27 shots, 26 saves</p><p>I wonder what the Hurricanes would have done for a Storm Surge. Maybe a socially-distanced version of this:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FQU5onCwpEhM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DQU5onCwpEhM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FQU5onCwpEhM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0df2b72b3507ef468d3679a89509676c/href">https://medium.com/media/0df2b72b3507ef468d3679a89509676c/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Live Eastern Conference Wild Card Standings (Top 2 make playoffs):<br>x-Carolina: 83 points, 1 game remaining vs. Philadelphia<br>Columbus: 81 points, 0 games remaining<br>NY Islanders: 80 points, 1 game remaining at Washington<br>x-clinched first wild card</strong></p><p><strong>Dallas Stars at Minnesota Wild</strong></p><p>What Happens If:<br><strong>Stars regulation win:</strong> Clinch third place in Central Division and will play second-place Central team in first round of Stanley Cup Playoffs; Wild would not be dead yet, but then must win tomorrow in Nashville and get a lot of help<br><strong>Stars overtime/shootout win:</strong> Same as a regulation win for the Stars; Wild would move into the second Western wild card position but not clinch anything<br><strong>Wild regulation win: </strong>Take over the second Western wild card position by one point and with one game remaining; Stars remain third in Central with a magic number of 1 against Nashville<br><strong>Wild overtime/shootout win: </strong>Same scenario as a regulation win for the Wild; Stars clinch third in Central</p><p><strong>1st Period</strong></p><p>DAL — Pavelski 15 (Klingberg 27, Lindell 21), 0:20</p><p><em>Twenty seconds? Dallas starts their third line to give them a better chance on the opening face-off, and old veteran Joe Pavelski pots one.</em></p><p>DAL — Pavelski 16 (unassisted), 7:40</p><p>😮</p><p>Shots on goal: Stars 11, Wild 9</p><p><strong>2nd Period</strong></p><p>MIN — Parise 26 (Staal 29, Fiala 32), 0:56 (PP)</p><p><em>Minnesota on the board with a first-minute power-play goal.</em></p><p>DAL — Faksa 12 (Perry 17, Heiskanen 28), 11:45 (PP)</p><p>DAL — Hintz 20 (Heiskanen 29, Dickinson 13), 12:50</p><p><em>Two goals in 65 seconds for a 4–1 Dallas lead. Here’s where the Wild pulled Devan Dubnyk for Alex Stalock in net.</em></p><p>DAL — Hintz 21 (unassisted), 16:23</p><p><em>Sheesh.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Stars 7 (18), Wild 9 (18)</p><p><em>Three of the Stars’ seven shots of the period went in.</em></p><p><strong>3rd Period</strong></p><p>MIN — Parise 27 (Fiala 33, Suter 41), 16:27</p><p><em>I would have liked to skip the third period, but we don’t do that here. 5–2 final.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Stars 14 (32), Wild 13 (31)</p><p><strong>Power Plays</strong></p><p>DAL — 1 for 2, MIN — 1 for 2</p><p><strong>Goaltending</strong></p><p>DAL — Khudobin: 31 shots, 29 saves</p><p>MIN — Dubnyk: 15 shots, 11 saves; Stalock: 17 shots, 16 saves</p><p>Dallas has clinched third place in the Central Division. Their first-round playoff opponent will be determined by tomorrow’s Vancouver-Colorado game.</p><p><strong>Live Western Conference Wild Card Standings (Top 2 make playoffs):<br>Winnipeg: 80 points, 0 games remaining<br>Nashville: 78 points, 2 games remaining vs. Minnesota and at Dallas<br>Vancouver: 78 points, 2 games remaining at Colorado and at Calgary<br>(Nashville wins tiebreaker on regulation wins, 28 to 27)<br>Minnesota: 77 points, 1 game remaining at Nashville</strong></p><p><em>SATURDAY, MAY 2, 2020</em></p><p><strong>Minnesota Wild at Nashville Predators</strong></p><p>What Happens If…<br><strong>Wild regulation win: </strong>Move into second Western wild card position but need help to stay there; Predators out of playoff position and must win their final game tomorrow in Dallas to have a chance<br><strong>Wild overtime/shootout win: </strong>Same scenario as a regulation win for the Wild; Predators must get at least one point tomorrow in Dallas, and depending on other results they may need two points<br><strong>Predators win in any way: </strong>Remain in second Western wild card position with one game remaining but nothing is clinched; Wild eliminated</p><p><strong>1st Period</strong></p><p>No scoring.</p><p>Shots on goal: Wild 11, Predators 9</p><p><strong>2nd Period</strong></p><p>NSH — Duchene 14 (Arvidsson 14, Ekholm 26), 1:48</p><p>MIN — Galchenyuk 4 (Hunt 12), 5:36</p><p>NSH — Arvidsson 16 (Josi 50, Ellis 31), 14:09</p><p>Shots on goal: Wild 7 (18), Predators 15 (24)</p><p><strong>3rd Period</strong></p><p>MIN — Eriksson Ek 9 (Suter 42, Spurgeon 21), 18:58</p><p><em>Minnesota saving their season, at least temporarily, by scoring with the extra attacker!</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Wild 9 (27), Predators 9 (33)</p><p><strong>Overtime</strong></p><p>MIN — Hartman 10 (Suter 43, Parise 22), 1:08</p><p><em>OMG, former Predator Ryan Hartman with the OTGWG. He keeps Minnesota’s hopes alive and severely hurts his former club.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Wild 1 (28), Predators 1 (34)</p><p><strong>Power Plays</strong></p><p>MIN — None, NSH — 0 for 3</p><p><strong>Goaltending</strong></p><p>MIN — Stalock: 34 shots, 32 saves</p><p>NSH — Saros: 28 shots, 25 saves</p><p>A three-point swing of a game! Minnesota was just about a minute away from elimination, and Nashville was going to get a big two points. Instead, the Preds collapse and drop a point. Minny stays alive but needs help.</p><p><strong>Live Western Conference Wild Card Standings (Top 2 make playoffs):<br>Winnipeg: 80 points, 0 games remaining<br>Minnesota: 79 points, 0 games remaining<br>Nashville: 79 points, 1 game remaining at Dallas<br>(Minnesota wins tiebreaker on regulation wins, 30 to 28)<br>Vancouver: 78 points, 2 games remaining at Colorado and at Calgary</strong></p><p><strong>Vancouver Canucks at Colorado Avalanche</strong></p><p>What Happens If…<br><strong>Canucks win in any way:</strong> Take over third place in Pacific Division with one game remaining but nothing clinched; Avalanche finish second in Central Division and play Dallas in first round of Stanley Cup Playoffs<br><strong>Avalanche regulation win: </strong>Clinch first place in Central Division and will play second Western wild card in first round; Canucks unaffected and playing a much more critical game tomorrow at Calgary, and are also unaware of the Wild-Predators result when this game starts<br><strong>Avalanche overtime/shootout win: </strong>Same result as a regulation win for Avalanche; Canucks take over third place in Pacific Division with exact same record as Calgary but with two more regulation wins, and still need to beat them tomorrow</p><p><strong>1st Period</strong></p><p>VAN — Boeser 17 (Horvat 32, Hughes 46), 0:17</p><p><em>In the fourth game of The Final Rush, we have our second first-shift-of-the-game goal.</em></p><p>VAN — Virtanen 19 (Edler 29), 6:32</p><p><em>Avs goalie change: Phillip Grubauer pulled for Pavel Francouz. Grubauer had been battling an injury before the shutdown, so it’s declared that he was still feeling the effects.</em></p><p>VAN — Boeser 18 (Horvat 33, Edler 30), 13:27</p><p><em>Holy guacamole, it’s 3–0.</em></p><p>COL — MacKinnon 36 (Landeskog 24, Girard 31), 16:55 (PP)</p><p><em>It’s still a game. Big PPG.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Canucks 11, Avalanche 15</p><p><strong>2nd Period</strong></p><p>VAN — Sutter 9 (Virtanen 19, Edler 31), 2:59</p><p>VAN — Hughes 9 (Sutter 10), 8:29</p><p>VAN — Boeser 19 (Horvat 34), 9:43</p><p><em>Neither goalie is working out for Colorado. Six goals allowed not even halfway through the game. Hat trick for Brock Boeser.</em></p><p>COL — Burakovsky 21 (unassisted), 11:08</p><p>Shots on goal: Canucks 6 (17), Avalanche 13 (28)</p><p><em>Three out of six shots in the period result in goals for the Canucks.</em></p><p><strong>3rd Period</strong></p><p>COL — MacKinnon 37 (Landeskog 25), 1:03</p><p><em>6–3 and nineteen minutes to go. It’s not over yet.</em></p><p>COL — Zadorov 5 (Compher 21), 8:20</p><p><em>Avs within two and gaining speed…</em></p><p><em>…but it’s not to be.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Canucks 8 (25), Avalanche 22 (50)</p><p><em>Look at those shot totals. Colorado doubles up, 50 to 25! A 20-save third period for Thatcher Demko.</em></p><p><em>Canucks’ leading scorer J.T. Miller left this game in the 3rd with an injury, and is also out for tomorrow’s big game in Calgary.</em></p><p><strong>Power Plays</strong></p><p>VAN — 0 for 1; COL — 1 for 1</p><p><strong>Goaltending</strong></p><p>VAN — Demko: 50 shots, 46 saves</p><p>COL — Grubauer: 6 shots, 4 saves; Francouz: 19 shots, 15 saves</p><p>The Canucks take over 3rd place in the Pacific, giving them a little wiggle room heading into tomorrow’s showdown in Calgary.</p><p>Colorado is now locked into 2nd place in the Central. They will meet Dallas in the first round. The defending Stanley Cup champion St. Louis Blues (which still seems weird to type) finish with the Western Conference’s best record.</p><p><strong>Live Pacific Division Standings (Top 3 assured of playoff berth):<br>Vegas: 86 points, 0 games remaining<br>Edmonton: 83 points, 0 games remaining<br>Vancouver: 80 points, 1 game remaining at Calgary<br>Calgary: 79 points, 1 game remaining vs. Vancouver</strong></p><p><strong>Live Western Conference Wild Card Standings (Top 2 make playoffs)<br>Winnipeg: 80 points, 0 games remaining<br>Minnesota: 79 points, 0 games remaining<br>Nashville: 79 points, 1 game remaining at Dallas<br>Calgary: 79 points, 1 game remaining vs. Vancouver<br>(Minnesota wins tiebreaker with 30 regulation wins to Nashville’s 28 and Calgary’s 25.)</strong></p><p><em>SUNDAY, MAY 3, 2020</em></p><p>It’s the last day of the regular season. There are four games today; two in the Eastern Conference, and two in the West. All four games will have repercussions for the playoffs, either for seeding or just making the playoffs altogether for several teams.</p><p>The Eastern Conference is pretty simple. All that needs to be decided there is the Metropolitan Division champion (with Washington currently leading Philadelphia by one point), and the second wild card (New York Islanders needing two points; otherwise, Columbus gets in.)</p><p>The Western Conference is complete chaos, which is kind of what I had in mind when devising The Final Rush. Nashville plays Dallas and Vancouver visits Calgary. Dallas doesn’t have to play for anything. Nashville makes the playoffs with two points, but still could with one. On the surface, it looks like the winner of Canucks-Flames will take third place in the Pacific Division and an automatic playoff spot, but actually it’s possible for the winning team to be a wild card and the losing team to be a divisional qualifier 🤔.</p><p><strong>Philadelphia Flyers at Carolina Hurricanes<br>New York Islanders at Washington Capitals</strong></p><p>For my next trick, I will attempt to play both of these games simultaneously. The first period of the Flyers game, followed by the first period of the Caps game, followed by the second period of the Flyers game, etc.</p><p><strong>Live Metropolitan Division Standings (Top 3 assured of playoff berth)<br>Washington: 90 points, 1 game remaining vs. NY Islanders<br>Philadelphia: 89 points, 1 game remaining at Carolina<br>Pittsburgh: 86 points, 0 games remaining</strong></p><p>What Happens If…<br><strong>Capitals win in any way: </strong>They clinch first place in the Metropolitan Division and play Carolina in the first round; Flyers will be second place and play Pittsburgh; Hurricanes locked into first Eastern wild card; Islanders eliminated, making Columbus the second Eastern wild card<br><strong>Flyers win in regulation or overtime and Capitals loss of any kind: </strong>Flyers take first place in Metropolitan Division, and play Carolina in first round of the Stanley Cup Playoffs; Capitals will play Pittsburgh; Hurricanes locked into first Eastern wild card; Islanders take second Eastern wild card and will play Boston<br><strong>Flyers win in shootout and Capitals loss in overtime or shootout: </strong>Capitals take first place in Metro via second tiebreaker of least shootout wins (4 to 6), to face Carolina; Flyers finish second and will face Pittsburgh; Hurricanes locked into first Eastern wild card; Islanders clinch second Eastern wild card and will play Boston<br><strong>Flyers win in shootout and Capitals lose in regulation:</strong> Flyers first in Metro to meet Carolina; Capitals second in Metro, to meet Pittsburgh; Hurricanes locked into first Eastern wild card; Islanders win second Eastern wild card and will play Boston<br><strong>Flyers overtime/shootout loss and Capitals regulation loss:</strong> Capitals take first in the Metro via the second tiebreaker of least shootout wins (4 to 5), and will play Carolina; Flyers take second place to play Pittsburgh; Hurricanes locked into first Eastern wild card; Islanders clinch second Eastern wild card</p><p><strong>1st Period (PHI-CAR)</strong></p><p>No scoring.</p><p>Shots on goal: Flyers 12, Hurricanes 14</p><p><strong>1st Period (NYI-WSH)</strong></p><p>NYI — Bailey 15 (Pageau 17), 2:21 (PP)</p><p>Shots on goal: Islanders 10, Capitals 10</p><p><strong>2nd Period (PHI-CAR)</strong></p><p>PHI — van Riemsdyk 20 (Pitlick 13, Farabee 14), 2:46</p><p>PHI — Gostisbehere 6 (unassisted), 5:13</p><p>Shots on goal: Flyers 11 (23), Hurricanes 16 (30)</p><p><em>Carter Hart with 30 saves through two periods. Flyers up, Caps down.</em></p><p><strong>2nd Period (NYI-WSH)</strong></p><p>NYI — Eberle 18 (Barzal 42), 5:36</p><p>WSH — Ovechkin 49 (Kuznetsov 34), 18:09</p><p><em>The Caps are back in the game, and Alex Ovechkin wins the “Rocket” Richard Trophy with his 49th goal of the season. The Great 8 had been tied for the league lead with Boston’s David Pastrnak when the season was suspended.</em></p><p>NYI — Pageau 28 (Mayfield 9), 19:25</p><p><em>So much for Washington’s momentum. Jean-Gabriel Pageau scoring in back-to-back Final Rush games. The Islanders’ trade-deadline acquisition of Pageau from the Ottawa Senators is looking like the move that will get the Isles into the playoffs.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Islanders 18 (28), Capitals 15 (25)</p><p><strong>3rd Period (PHI-CAR)</strong></p><p>PHI — Hagg 4 (Voracek 45, Couturier 38), 5:42</p><p><em>Caps not getting any help from the Canes.</em></p><p>PHI — Couturier 23 (Gostisbehere 8), 10:17</p><p><em>This one’s done. 2 points for Philly.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Flyers 10 (33), Hurricanes 16 (46)</p><p><strong>Power Plays</strong></p><p>PHI — 0 for 2; CAR — 0 for 1</p><p><strong>Goaltending</strong></p><p>PHI — Hart: 46 shots, 46 saves</p><p>CAR — Reimer: 33 shots, 29 saves</p><p><strong>3rd Period (NYI-WSH)</strong></p><p>WSH — Oshie 27 (Vrana 28), 17:37</p><p><em>The Caps get back within one, and get several chances in the final seconds but Semyon Varlamov hangs on to deny his former team of a division title. There will be a New York team in the playoffs.</em></p><p><strong>Power Plays</strong></p><p>NYI — 1 for 3; WSH — 0 for 2</p><p><strong>Goaltending</strong></p><p>NYI — Varlamov: 36 shots, 34 saves</p><p>WSH — Holtby: 39 shots, 36 saves</p><p><strong>Final Metropolitan Division Standings (Top 3)<br>Philadelphia: 91 points<br>Washington: 90 points<br>Pittsburgh: 86 points</strong></p><p><strong>Final Eastern Conference Wild Card Standings (Top 2 make playoffs)<br>Carolina: 83 points<br>NY Islanders: 82 points<br>Columbus: 81 points</strong></p><p>The Blue Jackets 5-overtime game against the Lightning in Round 1 of the bubble is no longer a thing.</p><p>So, now we know our Eastern Conference playoff bracket:<br>(A1) Boston Bruins vs. (EWC2) New York Islanders<br>(A2) Tampa Bay Lightning vs. (A3) Toronto Maple Leafs<br>(M1) Philadelphia Flyers vs. (EWC1) Carolina Hurricanes<br>(M2) Washington Capitals vs. (M3) Pittsburgh Penguins</p><p>Two Western Conference games remain on this Final Rush Sunday. We’re figuring they are played at different times; say the Nashville-Dallas game is a 4pm Eastern start, and then Vancouver-Calgary is at 7:15 Eastern and nationally televised in Canada.</p><p><strong>Nashville Predators at Dallas Stars</strong></p><p>Dallas is in the playoffs as the 3rd seed from the Central Division no matter the result of this game. They will reduce the playing time of their top two forward lines and top defense pair.</p><p>What Happens To Nashville If…<br><strong>They win: </strong>First wild card in the Western Conference; play Vegas in the first round of the Stanley Cup Playoffs.<br><strong>They lose in overtime or shootout and Vancouver beats Calgary in any way:</strong> Second wild card in the West; play St. Louis in the first round.<br><strong>They lose in overtime or shootout and Calgary beats Vancouver in regulation:</strong> Miss the playoffs on second tiebreaker for second wild card (regulation and overtime wins to Vancouver, 33 to 32.)<br><strong>They lose in overtime or shootout and Calgary beats Vancouver in overtime or shootout: </strong>Miss playoffs on first tiebreaker for second wild card (regulation wins to Winnipeg, 30 to 28.)<strong><br>They lose in regulation:</strong> Season’s over.</p><p>Also, any loss by the Predators means the Winnipeg Jets make the playoffs despite not participating in the The Final Rush because they had already played 71 games. Vancouver also clinches a playoff spot should Nashville lose.</p><p><strong>1st Period</strong></p><p>NSH — Johansen 15 (Josi 51, Forsberg 28), 6:12</p><p>DAL — Seguin 18 (Radulov 20, Johns 4), 7:42</p><p>NSH — Forsberg 22 (Granlund 14, Turris 23), 12:56 (PP)</p><p>Shots on goal: Predators 17, Stars 13</p><p><em>A wild period. Preds up.</em></p><p><strong>2nd Period</strong></p><p>No scoring.</p><p>Shots on goal: Predators 14 (31), Stars 8 (21)</p><p><em>The Predators have been aggressive and sharp, registering 31 shots, and lead 2–1 for the second straight game. They are twenty minutes away from the playoffs.</em></p><p><strong>3rd Period</strong></p><p>DAL — Seguin 19 (Radulov 21, Lindell 21), 6:52</p><p><em>Oh boy, here they go again.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Predators 7 (38), Stars 10 (31)</p><p><strong>Overtime</strong></p><p>No scoring.</p><p><em>During this period, the Canucks and Flames took the ice in Calgary for pregame warmups, both prepared for a must-win game.</em></p><p><em>We’re going to our first shootout of The Final Rush. The Predators badly need to win it. They don’t get eliminated if they lose, but dropping another point here would take destiny out of their hands.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Predators 1 (39), Stars 3 (34)</p><p><strong>Shootout</strong></p><p><em>This is where I would heavily suggest just pressing the down-arrow one line at a time.</em></p><p>DAL — Comeau: GOAL</p><p>NSH — Duchene: GOAL</p><p>DAL — Seguin: NO GOAL</p><p>NSH — Forsberg: NO GOAL</p><p>DAL — Pavelski: GOAL</p><p><em>Uh-oh.</em></p><p>NSH — Turris: NO GOAL</p><p><em>Oh no, Nashville.</em></p><p><em>On the other hand, Dallas! Stars! Dallas! Stars!</em></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FAf8_9NP5lyw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DAf8_9NP5lyw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FAf8_9NP5lyw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/ee81d882fdc49f7ee14aa27d5a18d3d2/href">https://medium.com/media/ee81d882fdc49f7ee14aa27d5a18d3d2/href</a></iframe><p><strong>Power Plays</strong></p><p>NSH — 1 for 3; DAL — 0 for 2</p><p><strong>Goaltending</strong></p><p>NSH — Saros: 34 shots, 32 saves</p><p>DAL — Bishop: 39 shots, 37 saves</p><p>Nashville had a 2–1 lead at the second intermission in both of their Final Rush games and ended with two OTLs. They are going to need help from the Canucks.</p><p>Congratulations, Winnipeg Jets. You have just made the playoffs by doing nothing. Well, not nothing, you earned your 80 points. Just nothing this weekend. You get my meaning; we’ll see you in a few days in either Las Vegas or St. Louis.</p><p>This result also clinches a playoff berth for the Canucks. 15 playoff spots are clinched. Calgary or Nashville will get the 16th.</p><p><strong>Live Western Conference Wild Card Standings (Top 2 make playoffs):<br>Winnipeg: 80 points, 0 games remaining<br>Nashville: 80 points, 0 games remaining<br>(Winnipeg wins tiebreaker on regulation wins, 30 to 28.)<br>Minnesota: 79 points, 0 games remaining (eliminated)<br>Calgary: 79 points, 1 game remaining vs. Vancouver</strong></p><p><strong>Live Pacific Division Standings (Top 3 assured of playoff berth):<br>Vegas: 86 points, 0 games remaining<br>Edmonton: 83 points, 0 games remaining<br>Vancouver: 80 points, 1 game remaining at Calgary<br>Calgary: 79 points, 1 game remaining vs. Vancouver</strong></p><p><strong>Vancouver Canucks at Calgary Flames (Special Edition of <em>Hockey Night In Canada</em>)</strong></p><p>This is it. The last game of the regular season. The final game of The Final Rush.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FpIlgOQxoxxQ%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DpIlgOQxoxxQ&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FpIlgOQxoxxQ%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/72fbb0789018345e84f98f7c122dc955/href">https://medium.com/media/72fbb0789018345e84f98f7c122dc955/href</a></iframe><p>What Happens If…<br><strong>Vancouver wins in any way:</strong> Canucks finish 3rd in Pacific Division and play Edmonton in first round of Stanley Cup Playoffs; Flames eliminated; Jets and Predators are wild cards<br><strong>Calgary wins in regulation: </strong>Flames are 3rd in the Pacific to set up Battle Of Alberta vs. Edmonton in first round; Canucks make playoffs as second Western wild card via the second tiebreaker over Predators (regulation and overtime wins combined, 33 to 32), and play St. Louis in first round; Winnipeg plays Vegas<br><strong>Calgary wins in overtime or shootout:</strong> Canucks win tiebreaker for 3rd in Pacific (regulation wins, 28 to 25) and play Edmonton; Flames are first Western wild card and play Vegas; Jets are second Western wild card and play St. Louis; Predators eliminated on first tiebreaker against Winnipeg (regulation wins, 30 to 28)</p><p>In simpler terms, it’s a must-win game for Calgary. Nashville’s only hope is a Vancouver win.</p><p>The Blues could open their Stanley Cup title defense against the Predators, Canucks, or Jets.</p><p>Let’s start the proceedings with my favorite national anthem performance in the league, “O Canada” by George Canyon.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FJCjBkA1QSgs%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DJCjBkA1QSgs&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FJCjBkA1QSgs%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/016677aa22610605d0b76cc6b28f7cc8/href">https://medium.com/media/016677aa22610605d0b76cc6b28f7cc8/href</a></iframe><p>Let’s go! I’m pumped now! I doubt I’ll ever be in Calgary, but I want to go be in the C Of Red at the Saddledome.</p><p><strong>1st Period</strong></p><p>VAN — Horvat 23 (Pearson 25, Boeser 30), 5:25</p><p><em>And the Flames come out totally flat, allowing the first seven shots. They do fight back to make the shots close, but it remains 1–0 after one.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Canucks 15, Flames 13</p><p><strong>2nd Period</strong></p><p>VAN — MacEwen 6 (Gaudette 22), 10:31</p><p>CGY — Jankowski 6 (unassisted), 16:15</p><p><em>Both teams getting goals from the fourth line. It’s 2–1, Vancouver.</em></p><p>CGY — Monahan 23 (Hanifin 18, Gaudreau 41), 19:44</p><p><em>Sean Monahan ties the game with 16 seconds left in the period. We’re going to the 3rd tied at 2. Remember, the Flames have to win or they go home.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Canucks 8 (23), Flames 12 (25)</p><p><strong>3rd Period</strong></p><p>VAN — Edler 6 (unassisted), 2:23</p><p>VAN — Gaudette 13 (Myers 16), 4:20</p><p><em>Every time these teams have come out of the dressing room in this game, the Canucks looked like the team ready to play and the Flames looked like the team just putting on their uniforms as the period started. Surprising, considering how urgent the game is for the Flames and how the Canucks know by now they are in the playoffs. Maybe it’s something to be said for playing looser.</em></p><p><em>Right about here is where an NHL Network highlight producer might be asked to “send” what he or she has edited so they can air the highlight as soon as the game ends. “They’ll cross-roll dejected Flames at the end (from the control room),” that person might be advised.</em></p><p>CGY — Dube 7 (unassisted), 13:08</p><p><em>Not so fast. Just under 7 minutes left. Calgary within one.</em></p><p><em>And then, the Canucks take the game’s first penalty with five minutes to go.</em></p><p>CGY — Tkachuk 24 (Monahan 27, Gaudreau 42), 15:18 (PP)</p><p><em>The Flames immediately take advantage with their top power-play unit. They have come back from two goals down for the second time in the game.</em></p><p><em>The Canucks had a late flurry with Elias Pettersson getting two shots that David Rittich stopped, but injured himself in the process. He had to leave the game and Cam Talbot came in cold, though he did not have to face any shots in regulation.</em></p><p><em>This is the Game Of The Year, considering the stakes.</em></p><p><em>That highlight editor has now feverishly cut the two late goals by the Flames, plus the Rittich injury, and re-published the highlight to be ready for air. “They’ll cross-roll the winner,” would be the likely instruction.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Canucks 13 (36), Flames 9 (34)</p><p><strong>Overtime</strong></p><p>CGY — Mangiapane 18 (Giordano 27), 4:10 (PP)</p><p><em>Flames win! Flames make the playoffs! Andrew Mangiapane will be the guest on “After Hours” with Scott Oake. And after that, they’re going to Vegas!</em></p><p><em>It’s another power play goal, this one 4 on 3. Vancouver with two late penalties at terrible times, enabling Calgary to tie and win the game. The Canucks’ penalty kill was 0 for 3 in their two games, and now they get to face the best power-play in the league when they meet Edmonton (29.5 percent conversion rate) in the first round.</em></p><p>Shots on goal: Canucks 3 (39), Flames 3 (37)</p><p><strong>Power Plays</strong></p><p>VAN — None; CGY — 2 for 2</p><p><em>The Flames were sloppy at times, but committed no penalties in this all-or-nothing game. Good discipline.</em></p><p><strong>Goaltending</strong></p><p>VAN — Markstrom: 37 shots, 32 saves</p><p>CGY — Rittich: 36 shots, 32 saves; Talbot: 3 shots, 3 saves</p><p>Holy jumpin’!</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FbNpSbLN33q8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DbNpSbLN33q8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FbNpSbLN33q8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/0c833ac70a34b9fe8805a9d3f5eb110e/href">https://medium.com/media/0c833ac70a34b9fe8805a9d3f5eb110e/href</a></iframe><p>I’m amazed, again, at the incredible endings that are produced by the cards, dice, game directions, lineups, and the scenarios that I devise. Both for baseball and now hockey.</p><p>And it happened: Calgary was one point behind Vancouver, beat them, and didn’t jump them in the standings.</p><p><strong>Final Pacific Division Standings (Top 3 assured of playoff berth)<br>Vegas: 86 points<br>Edmonton: 83 points<br>Vancouver: 81 points<br>Calgary: 81 points<br>(Vancouver takes 3rd place on regulation wins tiebreaker, 28 to 25)</strong></p><p><strong>Final Western Conference Wild Card Standings (Top 2 make playoffs)</strong><br><strong>Calgary: 81 points<br>Winnipeg: 80 points<br>Nashville: 80 points<br>(Winnipeg wins tiebreaker on regulation wins, 30 to 28)</strong></p><p><strong>Western Conference Bracket For Stanley Cup Playoffs<br></strong>(C1) St. Louis Blues vs. (WWC2) Winnipeg Jets<br>(C2) Colorado Avalanche vs. (C3) Dallas Stars<br>(P1) Vegas Golden Knights vs. (WWC1) Calgary Flames<br>(P2) Edmonton Oilers vs. (P3) Vancouver Canucks</p><p>So many questions heading into the 2020 Stanley Cup Playoffs:<br>Will the Blues repeat? Will the Bruins get back to the Stanley Cup Final and finish the job this time? Will Edmonton finally break through with their dynamic young scorers? Will the Lightning bounce back after last year’s epic disappointment? Will Toronto win a series? Will Washington make it two Cups in three years, or will Vegas win their first? Which wild card team will knock off a division champ? Will none of these things happen?</p><p>I’ll find out and report back to you.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=00b55ea05445" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strat-O-Matic Modern Champions Tournament, Director’s Supercut Edition]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-directors-supercut-edition-d2bf01cff14?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/d2bf01cff14</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stratomatic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-series]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 26 Feb 2023 21:07:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-06-14T16:14:21.086Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>22 World Series championship teams converge for baseball’s greatest tournament</em></p><p><strong><em>(What follows is the combination and slight revising of a series of articles I wrote while playing a tournament of World Series champions using Strat-O-Matic Baseball. The individual articles </em></strong><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719"><strong><em>still exist in six parts</em></strong></a><strong><em>; the first one described the games in a bullet-point format so I did re-write that part, but mostly everything else remains as it was originally written. I just wanted to bring it all together because it’s probably the closest I’ll get to writing a book. If you’ve landed here via a search long after this was posted on February 26, 2023, welcome and enjoy.)</em></strong></p><p><strong>CHAPTER ONE: FROM ONE IDEA FORMS A MUCH BETTER IDEA — INTRODUCTION OF TOURNAMENT FORMAT<br>(Original publish date: July 15, 2022)</strong></p><p>I always loved to play sports board games since I was introduced to them by my father and cousins at an early age. I always thought it was cool to play a short season, or draft a whole new league. My favorite sport to play for these games was baseball, and my favorite baseball game was Strat-O-Matic.</p><p>In January of 2020, two months after I had left MLB Network where I was a highlight producer for nine seasons, my lovely then-girlfriend-now-wife Rose took me to Cooperstown for my birthday. She noticed me gushing about Strat-O-Matic, which I hadn’t played since the 90s, in the Hall Of Fame gift shop. Didn’t buy it then because I had just moved in with her, returning to my hometown of Scranton, and had more life-uprooting matters to deal with. Plus, I was still playing NHL18 from EA Sports, deep into a career with my created player Jimmy Highlights of the New Jersey Devils. Naturally, I played many sports video games over the years as they evolved. (For those, hockey was always my favorite.)</p><p>Then the pandemic brought back board games. We wound up getting about ten of them — Life, Monopoly, Pay Day, etc. One day while looking through old stuff in my childhood home, I found a college basketball board game called March Madness from 1990, produced by Avalon Hill. I used a formula in that game to create new teams and play the 2020 NCAA Tournament that was unplayed in real life. Here’s the bracket, but the whole thing is a story for another forum.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*d42GBV3nLPbDr5fToA0JVA.jpeg" /><figcaption>I used an online simulator to get the results for the conference tournament games that were canceled, then selected and seeded the teams following the normal bracketing priniciples, and played all 67 games. Gonzaga dominated, but there were dramatic games throughout the rest of the field.</figcaption></figure><p>For Christmas of 2020, 11 months after our trip to Cooperstown and seemingly eleventy-seven years into the pandemic, Rose surprised me with…Strat-O-Matic baseball! I was so excited. Similar to what I did in the 90s, I drafted a new league with 8 teams, using cards from the 2018 season. I named the teams after London soccer clubs: Arsenal, Chelsea, Tottenham, etc.</p><p>I got about one-third through the intended season of my league, and realized the changes that had happened in real baseball had a negative effect on the fun of Strat-O-Matic. There were way more strikeouts and less hitting. Stolen bases were almost extinct; this league had so many dominant pitchers and fielders, scoring single runs was like drawing blood from a stone unless it was a solo home run. The league batting average was .223. So I put that on hold.</p><p>The itch for the game came back to me in the spring of 2022. My original idea was to buy a special set Strat-O-Matic made of all Hall Of Fame players. An entire league of Hall of Famers — what would happen? Hopefully not the same thing with the pitching, but I was too curious to not buy the set.</p><p>More players were elected to the Hall after that set was published. I wanted to include them, and discovered Strat had updated the set on their app. Then I found out that on said app, you can digitally see <em>every card for every season</em> and set they have made (subscription required but worth it for this).</p><p>You can also match up a batter’s card against a pitcher’s card. Here’s an example:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FdFC5I9dv5_VpopDJh4Fjw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I was originally going to get the app for a one-time use just to get the new Hall Of Fame cards, but I got to thinking: I can play anybody against anybody here.</p><p>Half an hour later I had an idea and a framework for a tournament: World Series championship teams since 1980 with each franchise represented only once by either their best or more interesting team. A Modern Champions Tournament. Why 1980? That’s the year I really learned of baseball and started paying attention to it, so it’s essentially a tournament of my fandom.</p><p>40-plus years seemed like an appropriate era to draw from, especially in modern times — it’s hard to articulate why but it feels like 1980 to 2019 works better for something like this than, say, 1950 to 1989. Maybe it’s just about when I grew up. Or maybe it’s that baseball’s presence on television expanded in the 80s and continues to this day, or that you could look at the athletes who played back then and easily imagine them being dropped into today’s game.</p><p>It turns out that since 1980, 11 American League and 11 National League teams have won at least one World Series. I figured out who should represent each franchise, and then seeded the teams by league. Seeds are mostly based on regular-season win totals. Here are the lists, in order of their seeds:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*2VDXolfYDFgo2LoxoT3wVg.jpeg" /></figure><p>We will play an American League and National League bracket, with the winners to meet in a Grand World Series. The teams over the line in the above photo are placed into the Round of 16. The teams under the line need to play in the Qualifying Round, which is a best-of-3 series. The matchups are:</p><p><strong>A.L.:</strong> White Sox vs. Royals, Angels vs. Twins, Orioles vs. Blue Jays<br><strong>N.L.:</strong> Nationals vs. Cardinals, Diamondbacks vs. Marlins, Phillies vs. Reds</p><p>After the Qualifying Round, 16 teams will remain and they will be re-seeded in each league. The Tournament Executive Committee (me) reserves the right to a change a matchup from its natural seeding in order to avoid a series with the same player on both teams, also known as The Jack Morris Rule since he is on 3 different teams. Some others duplicate as well, such as David Cone and Chuck Knoblauch.</p><p>Starting with the Round of 16, the intention is to do a straight bracket with these rounds, but again the Committee can make changes if necessary:</p><p><strong>Round of 16:</strong> Best-of-5<br><strong>Division Series:</strong> Best-of-5<br><strong>League Championship Series:</strong> Best-of-7<br><strong>Grand World Series:</strong> Best-of-7</p><p>A few weeks after I came up with this, Rose and I visited the city of Pittsburgh and went to a Pirates game on a tremendous Saturday afternoon. I briefly felt bad for not including the 1979 Bucs in the tournament, but that would have unbalanced the field, so I got over it.</p><p>Here is my set-up to play the games. I’m using the bar in our spare room, throwing the dice into the box in the opposite chair from where I sit. That way, I can play in small increments at almost any time instead of dragging it out to the dining room table where I’d have to finish a whole game at once. Gameplay isn’t fast when you have to navigate the Strat app for the cards.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z0NGi3v7oG6N0uemfoGiRw.jpeg" /><figcaption>The dice land in the March Madness box, using my two favorite games.</figcaption></figure><p><strong>We’re going to imagine this tournament is broadcast nationally, attended by fans, and the teams will “travel” as if these are normal baseball playoff series. </strong>Like I did with the basketball tournament I played, I’m making a “TV Schedule” and playing the games in that order. There will be a certain number of games each day, and games on the west coast will be played after ones on the east coast.</p><p><strong>We get to use Strat-O-Matic’s </strong><a href="https://www.strat-o-matic.com/baseball/ballpark-and-weather-effect-charts/"><strong>Ballpark Effects</strong></a><strong> for all of our home venues, from Baltimore’s Memorial Stadium in 1983 to Nationals Park in D.C. for 2019.</strong> Strat updates the ballpark effects each year for singles and home runs, making it easier to hit a ball out of, say, Philadelphia’s Citizens Bank Park than St. Louis’ Busch Stadium. These effects may have an impact on how starting pitching rotations are built, such as not using a pitcher who gives up a lot of home runs if the game is in a small yard.</p><p><strong>We will use authentic postseason rosters and starting lineups.</strong> I use baseball-reference.com to find those. Teams in the 80s had smaller pitching staffs than those in the 2010s; we may have matchups where one team has three more pitchers than the other, but that’s just going to be part of the game. The team with less pitchers will have a deeper bench and more substitution options. If you’re like me and think baseball was just fine with less pitchers in the 80s and 90s, and that we have too many now which kills the pace-of-play, makes games longer, and just puts more mediocre arms in the league, this will be an interesting aspect of the tournament to follow.</p><p>Batting lineups will be what these teams used during their World Series or LCS, and dependent on the situation of facing a left-handed or right-handed starter, and if a designated hitter was to be used. I’ll make minor tweaks if it makes sense for the matchup, such as playing a fast runner against a pitcher who struggles to hold runners on.</p><p>The designated hitter is used in the American League bracket. Pitchers hit in the National League, and it’s convenient for us that no National League team after 2019 was selected, so the universal DH does not apply here. For the Grand World Series, the DH will be used in games played at the American League champion. That’s another way this champions tournament is “modern”.</p><p><strong>There will not be analytic-based lineups if the team didn’t use them in real life.</strong> Albert Pujols hit third for the Cardinals; he will not lead-off or hit anywhere else in this tournament.</p><p><strong>There will be no long-term injuries, though in-game injuries are a part of baseball and are possible in the Strat-O-Matic game.</strong> A play resulting in an injury will lead to another roll of a single die to determine the severity, with a maximum length of 2 games. There’s a 50 percent chance that dice roll will reveal that the player is just fine after being checked by the trainer, and can remain in that game.</p><p><strong>Injury Severity Die Roll Chart<br>1:</strong> Player must leave game and miss next game<br><strong>2:</strong> Player must leave game and miss next 2 games<br><strong>3:</strong> Player must leave current game only<br><strong>4–6:</strong> Player is fine to remain in the game</p><p>Kyle Schwarber of the 2016 Cubs will only be able to pinch-hit, or serve as the DH should the Cubs make the Grand World Series and play in an American League park, since that’s all he could do in the real World Series that year.</p><p><strong>There will be none of the supposed time-saving post-pandemic rules MLB has implemented.</strong> No three-batter-minimum rule for pitchers, no blasphemous “ghost runner” on second in extra innings. I might have used them if the 2021 Braves were selected, but the Committee went with the 1995 team.</p><p>Enough talk, let’s get to the “highlights”, which I was best known for in my years at MLBN, of the Qualifying Round.</p><p><strong>CHAPTER TWO: LET’S SEE IF THIS THING WORKS — QUALIFYING ROUND<br>(Revised from original publish date of July 15, 2022)</strong></p><p><strong>Day 1</strong> (3 games)</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-9 1990 Reds (Tom Browning) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Jamie Moyer)</em></p><p>In this best-of-three series, both teams here chose to save their ace pitchers (Jose Rijo and Cole Hamels, respectively, both of whom were World Series Most Valuable Player) for Game 2. The thinking is if you win the first game then your top pitcher can clinch the series, and if you lose the first game then your ace can get back in the series.</p><p>Tom Browning has immediate struggles as Jimmy Rollins singles to start the bottom of the 1st inning, followed by Jayson Werth hitting the tournament’s first home run. The Phillies quickly lead, 2–0, and their home fans are thinking easy win. However, Paul O’Neill, the only left-handed batter in the Cincinnati lineup, leads off the 2nd with a home run to cut the Phillies’ lead in half.</p><p>The Phillies threaten again when they come up, but the old-school National League lineup (“old-school” meaning from baseball’s inception to 2019 with pitchers also batting) helps the Reds. With runners on 2nd and 3rd and no outs, 8th-hitter Carlos Ruiz grounds out to second and the runners have to hold. 9th-hitter Jamie Moyer strikes out, then Rollins lines out to second and the Phillies do not score.</p><p>In the 3rd, Werth nearly hits his second home run but flies out to the warning track. Reds manager Lou Piniella decides he really would not like Werth, who has a great card against left-handed pitching, to face Browning a third time, so he takes Browning out after 4 innings and brings in Rob Dibble for the 5th when Werth is due up third. If this were a regular season game, it would be way too early to bring in Dibble, who normally pitched in late innings, but he is the best option here in a short tournament series. Werth draws a 2-out walk but is thrown out attempting to steal by Joe Oliver.</p><p>Chris Sabo doubles with one out in the top of the 6th, and then Phillies manager Charlie Manuel elects to intentionally walk Eric Davis to bring up O’Neill, basically daring O’Neill to do more damage. He singles and Sabo scores, Davis going to 3rd. Game is tied, 2–2. The right-fielders, O’Neill and Werth, are the offensive production so far in this game. It’s O’Neill’s best moment in Philadelphia since he kicked baseball’s first field goal.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FSqLMrSKLsak%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DSqLMrSKLsak&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FSqLMrSKLsak%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/8e51a4b9f6a3d7ad5510a9b61ed91a35/href">https://medium.com/media/8e51a4b9f6a3d7ad5510a9b61ed91a35/href</a></iframe><p>Moyer is then removed for right-hander Chad Durbin. With two outs, Piniella could use Hal Morris to pinch-hit for starting first baseman Todd Benzinger, but chooses to save Morris for later. Benzinger hits a grounder to second that is misplayed by Chase Utley for an error. Davis scores and the Reds take a 3–2 lead.</p><p>With lefty Norm Charlton pitching in the 8th, pinch-hitter Chris Coste leads off with a single. Rollins flies out, and once again Piniella does not want Werth facing a southpaw. He brings in Scott Scudder, a former first-round draft pick who’s now a reliever and spot-starter with a 4.90 ERA in 1990. He gets Werth to ground into an inning-ending 4–6–3 double play.</p><p>Still with the one-run lead, closer Randy Myers comes in for the 9th to face the sluggers Utley, Ryan Howard, and Pat Burrell. Howard walks with one out and reaches second on a wild pitch. Burrell lines out to third, and Shane Victorino grounds out to third to end it. The Reds have taken the Modern Champions Tournament’s first game, 3–2. The Phillies’ first two batters of the game scored, and the team never scored again. Game 2 will be in Cincinnati in two days, and that will be Rijo vs. Hamels.</p><p>What a delight to play! Sure, it took over two and a half hours because I trying to figure out how to best use the Strat-O-Matic app for the cards while managing both teams in a tight game with tons of strategy, plus I had spread out the game on our dining-room table where I had to finish the whole thing at once. I was days away from moving everything into the bar-room. I also knew I was on to something.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at AL-8 1983 Orioles (Scott McGregor)</em></p><p>Imagine this is a day similar to the Wild Card Series round that was put into Major League Baseball’s postseason in 2022, or even the first round of the NBA Playoffs, where each game is on national TV. So, Philadelphia was the site of the first game which can we picture was a day game, followed by this late-afternoon/early-evening game in Baltimore, then our third game later tonight will be in Arizona.</p><p><strong><em>(Note: I wish I could say I had the foresight to think of that before the first game, but I knew I wanted the first game to be Reds-Phillies and played that right away before I thought of anything else. The “TV schedule” was figured out in between that game and this one. Would I have made Toronto-Baltimore semi-primetime on Day 1 with more planning? Unlikely, but it worked out fine.)</em></strong></p><p>John Olerud suffered the tournament’s first injury when he grounded out in the top of the 2nd inning. The severity roll was a 1, so the Blue Jays’ first baseman was out for the rest of this game and the next one. That takes a big bat and a good glove out of the Jays’ lineup in this short series.</p><p>Jimmy Key was only 13–13 in 1992, but had a low number of walks, a good WHIP (Walks plus Hits divided by Innings Pitched) of 1.218, and the ability to go deep into games. He got the ball here for Game 1, with 21-game winner Jack Morris and major August trade-deadline acquisition David Cone set for Games 2 and 3. The Orioles got two on base with 1 out in the bottom of the 3rd before Key got out of it by striking out Dan Ford and getting Cal Ripken to ground out.</p><p>Kelly Gruber reached on an error by fellow third baseman Todd Cruz in the top of the 5th to give the Blue Jays first and second with no outs. Two batters later, Manny Lee grounded out to advance the runners on what would have been the third out of the inning. Devon White then singled to give the Blue Jays a 2–0 lead on a pair of unearned runs.</p><p>Ripken singled to give the Orioles baserunners on the corners with two outs in the 7th. Key is left in to face Eddie Murray, and he gets the strikeout to keep the Orioles scoreless.</p><p>Key does get removed after a Rich Dauer 2-out single in the bottom of the 8th. Duane Ward allows a single to pinch-hitter John Lowenstein, but Rick Dempsey strikes out to end that threat. Another frustrating missed chance by the O’s.</p><p>Tom Henke allows a 1-out single to Ford, but gets Ripken to ground out and Murray to fly out to end the game. The Orioles leave 12 on base, and the Blue Jays win 2–0 on those unearned runs in the 5th.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-10 2003 Marlins (Josh Beckett) at NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Randy Johnson)</em></p><p>The aces get the ball here in Game 1 for both teams, who each could consider their Game 2 pitcher to be a second ace (Dontrelle Willis and Curt Schilling).</p><p>The Marlins have a pair of scoring chances in the first three innings, though both begin with two outs. They loaded the bases in the 1st, but Johnson struck out Mike Lowell for the third out. Two innings later, they had Ivan Rodriguez on third base after a double by rookie Miguel Cabrera, but Jeff Conine grounded out to end that threat.</p><p>Damian Miller hit a 2-run home run off Beckett in the bottom of the 3rd for the game’s first runs.</p><p>Rodriguez doubles after a Luis Castillo 1-out double in the 5th to put the Marlins on the board. Cabrera singles Rodriguez to 3rd, but then Johnson recovers to strike out Conine and Lowell to keep the Diamondbacks ahead, 2–1.</p><p>Danny Bautista homers to lead-off the bottom of the 5th, making the score 3–1.</p><p>Rodriguez doubles with 1 out in the 7th, then Johnson is replaced by Bobby Witt. Cabrera greets him with another double for his fourth hit of the game, scoring Rodriguez to make it 3–2. Rodriguez had walked in the first inning, so he and Cabrera were a combined 7-for-7 at this point.</p><p>Witt recovered to get Conine and Lowell to fly out to end the inning, and once again the D’Backs answered immediately. With Mark Redman pitching, Miller’s RBI single with 2 outs brought home Bautista.</p><p>Juan Pierre doubled off Greg Swindell with 2 outs in the 8th, which advanced Derrek Lee to third. The Marlins had the tying runs in scoring position, so D’Backs manager Bob Brenly brought in his closer Byung-hyun Kim. He got Castillo to ground out to short to end the inning.</p><p>Rodriguez singled to lead-off the 9th for his fourth hit. The Marlins now had 12 hits: 4 by Rodriguez, 4 by Cabrera, and 4 by the rest of the lineup. But the 8-for-8 hitting streak of Rodriguez and Cabrera ended when Cabrera struck out next. Conine grounded to third, and Lowell flied out to center to wrap it up. Arizona wins, 4–2, to finish the tournament’s first day. They’re also the first home team to win a game.</p><p><strong>Day 2 </strong>(3 games)</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Jaime Garcia) at NL-6 2019 Nationals (Stephen Strasburg)</em></p><p>The following names are going to make Nationals fans upset today, but Juan Soto’s double in the bottom of the 3rd brought home Trea Turner to give the Nats a 1–0 lead.</p><p>Matt Holliday’s two-run double in the 4th put the Cardinals ahead, 2–1. However, Washington gets RBI singles in the bottom half from Michael A. Taylor and then Turner. Turner steals second and goes to third on Yadier Molina’s throwing error, then scores on Adam Eaton’s double. The Nationals lead, 4–2, after four.</p><p>Albert Pujols ties the game 4–4 on a 2-run shot off Strasburg in the 6th. Lance Berkman then reaches on an error by first baseman Ryan Zimmerman. Holliday strikes out for what should have been the third out, then David Freese hits another 2-run homer. Cardinals lead, 6–4.</p><p>Eaton flies out to the wall in left for the third out of the bottom of the 6th. A few more feet and the ball would have been gone, and the game tied again.</p><p>The Nats’ weakness in 2019 was their bullpen, and the Cardinals take advantage of that in the late innings. Molina singles in Holliday in the top of the 8th to make it 7–4. The Nats do get that run back when they come up as pinch-hitter Brian Dozier and Turner hit back-to-back doubles with 2 outs. Mark Rzepczynski comes in to strike out Eaton to end the inning at 7–5.</p><p>Rafael Furcal homers off Sean Doolittle to start the 9th, and Allen Craig hits a 2-run shot off Wander Suero later in the inning. The Cardinals take the first game 10–5, and road teams have won three of the first four tournament games.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-11 1985 Royals (Charlie Leibrandt) at AL-6 2005 White Sox (Jon Garland)</em></p><p>The Royals look like they may be another feisty 11-seed from the state of Missouri when this game is scoreless through 5 innings, and then George Brett hits a solo home run in the top of the 6th.</p><p>Charlie Leibrandt allowed just one hit until the 6th when Scott Podsednik led off with a single, then Tadahito Iguchi fortunately, for him, got a bunt single when he was actually trying to sacrifice. Jermaine Dye walked to load the bases with nobody out. Paul Konerko followed that with the tournament’s first grand slam to put the White Sox up, 4–1. The Royals’ feistiness might only go so far.</p><p>Steve Balboni hit a solo shot in the top of the 7th, but the White Sox countered with another run in the bottom half. Steve Farr’s wild pitch allowed Podsednik to reach scoring position, and he would score on a Dye single.</p><p>Jon Garland pitched into the 9th inning, really only throwing two bad pitches for solo home runs to Brett and Balboni. He retired Brett and Hal McRae to start the 9th, appearing on track for the tournament’s first complete game. Pat Sheridan singled with two outs, then Balboni hit his second home run of the game and suddenly it was 5–4. Ozzie Guillen then made the move to bring in closer Bobby Jenks.</p><h3>Rob Friedman on Twitter: &quot;Ozzie Guillén&#39;s Mound Visit to bring in Bobby Jenks. 🤣 pic.twitter.com/ZVNWpAuVnG / Twitter&quot;</h3><p>Ozzie Guillén&#39;s Mound Visit to bring in Bobby Jenks. 🤣 pic.twitter.com/ZVNWpAuVnG</p><p>It wouldn’t quite be as funny ha-ha between these two guys a few years later…</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FULgTvcd0xU8%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DULgTvcd0xU8&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FULgTvcd0xU8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a4ceccd1788c74e2b5175fc52706c80e/href">https://medium.com/media/a4ceccd1788c74e2b5175fc52706c80e/href</a></iframe><p>…but here Jenks strikes out pinch-hitter Darryl Motley to end the game. The White Sox take the series lead, 5–4.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-10 1991 Twins (Jack Morris) at AL-7 2002 Angels (Jarrod Washburn)</em></p><p>OK, here’s the first appearance of Jack Morris in this tournament. We’ll be seeing him a lot. His team gets a 1–0 lead here in the top of the 1st, but in the bottom Tim Salmon hits a 2-run home run after a Darin Erstad triple.</p><p>Shane Mack homers leading off the 2nd for the Twins to tie the game 2–2. It stays that way until the 6th when Kent Hrbek doubles with two on and two outs. Brian Harper scores but Mack, a fast runner, is thrown out at home. The Twins do take the lead, 3–2, but it could’ve been a bigger inning.</p><p>Angels slugger Troy Glaus is injured when he grounds out in the bottom of the 6th. He’s unfortunately out for two games, so we have seen the last of Glaus in this short series.</p><p>Salmon singles with two outs in the bottom of the 7th, and Morris is taken out for Carl Willis. Garret Anderson greets Willis with a double. Salmon is sent home and again there’s a play at the plate, but Salmon is safe. We’re tied again, 3–3. Anderson advances to 3rd on the throw, but Alex Ochoa, the substitute who came in for Glaus, lines out to end the inning.</p><p>One of the strongest parts of the 2002 Angels was their bullpen, and they do a great job shutting down the Twins in late innings. Francisco Rodriguez strikes out Harper and Mack with a runner on second in the top of the 8th.</p><p>We wind up with the tournament’s first extra-inning game. The Twins’ other threat is in the 11th with runners on first and second with one out, but Brendan Donnelly gets Mike Pagliarulo to hit into a 4–6–3 double play.</p><p>Scott Spiezio leads off the bottom of the 11th with a single off Rick Aguilera, and he’s bunted to second by Bengie Molina. Adam Kennedy, who hit .312 for the ’02 Angels while primarily hitting 9th in the lineup, singled to bring home Spiezio for the tournament’s first walk-off win. 4–3 Angels in 11 innings.</p><p><strong>Day 3</strong> (3 games)</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-8 1983 Orioles (Mike Boddicker) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris), Blue Jays lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Facing elimination, the Orioles scored their first tournament run went Ripken went deep in the top of the 1st.</p><p>Mike Boddicker’s first full big-league season was 1983, and the rookie was Baltimore’s best pitcher. He won 16 games with a 2.77 ERA, then was MVP of the American League Championship Series in their 3-game sweep of Chicago. He also won his start against the Phillies in the World Series, and pitched complete games in both of those postseason starts.</p><p>That’s why it was a major disappointment when the first batter he faced, Devon White, hit a comeback line drive that injured Boddicker and forced him out of the game. Storm Davis, who the O’s were planning on starting Game 3, had to suddenly come in and he allowed a single to Roberto Alomar and an RBI double to Joe Carter.</p><p>Toronto got 2 more runs in the 3rd when Alomar walked and the next four batters hit singles. The fourth of those was by Ed Sprague, who had started at first base in place of John Olerud. Sprague’s knock made it a 3–1 game.</p><p>The Orioles didn’t fold, even though the loss of Boddicker was a demoralizing blow. They came back to tie the score in the top of the 5th, but the Blue Jays bounced back right away with Candy Maldonado’s 2-run home run off Jim Palmer.</p><p>Blue Jay pitching shut it down from there. Mark Eichhorn came on to retire Ripken for the first time all game, ending the 7th inning with a runner on first. Duane Ward and Tom Henke went the 8th and 9th, respectively, and 5–3 was the final score. The Blue Jays became the first team to win a series and advance into the Round of 16.</p><p>Toronto’s next opponent will be the 2-seed in the A.L., the 2018 Boston Red Sox. Even though the other A.L. series are incomplete, the Executive Decision was made to match the Blue Jays against the Red Sox due to player duplications with the other two possible opponents — the 1998 Yankees (David Cone and David Wells) and 1984 Tigers (Jack Morris).</p><p>The poor Orioles get a rough break when the line drive hit Boddicker to start Game 2, as they were counting on him to get back in the series. Instead, they are the first team eliminated. Their lineup after Ripken and Murray didn’t seem very formidable, perhaps the most “these guys won the World Series?” lineup of the tournament. However, the Blue Jays can say they were without Olerud for most of the series, which compromised them both offensively and on defense. They simply got more clutch hits. The Blue Jays will be tough to beat if they get a lead with top-notch Ward and Henke in the bullpen.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Curt Schilling) at NL-10 2003 Marlins (Dontrelle Willis), Diamondbacks lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Matt Williams reached on an error by Marlins shortstop Alex Gonzalez in the top of 2nd. After a Reggie Sanders walk, Jay Bell doubled in the two runners to give Arizona a 2–0 lead.</p><p>Schilling retired the first 11 batters he faced. Rodriguez and Cabrera then singled, as those two guys were very hard to get out even for the D’Backs pair of aces. However, Schilling struck out Jeff Conine to end that 4th inning. He had 5 strikeouts through four.</p><p>Willis was removed after a 1-out double by Greg Colbrunn in the 5th. Chad Fox came in and surrendered an RBI double to Williams. Arizona led, 3–0.</p><p>Schilling pitched into the 8th when Gonzalez and Juan Encarnacion singled to put runners on the corners, then Juan Pierre hit into a double play which brought home Florida’s first run. Luis Castillo singled, which led to Bobby Witt coming in to face Rodriguez. Castillo stole second base, but Rodriguez flied out to right.</p><p>Kim got three strikeouts in the 9th after a lead-off double by Cabrera, and the Diamondbacks had a 3–1 win to complete the 2-game sweep.</p><p>In a short series, it was going to be extremely tough to beat Johnson and Schilling. Rodriguez and Cabrera (who was 20 years old in 2003, and will be retiring this year after a no-doubt Hall of Fame career) tried their best, going a combined 12-for-17. Arizona’s next opponent will be determined by the outcome of the Nationals-Cardinals series.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Cole Hamels) at NL-9 1990 Reds (Jose Rijo), Reds lead series 1–0</em></p><p>The Committee moved this game to primetime, mainly due to the matchup of World Series MVP starting pitchers.</p><p>Barry Larkin and Billy Hatcher start the bottom of the 1st inning with singles. A sacrifice fly by Chris Sabo scores Larkin and the Reds lead, 1–0.</p><p>Jimmy Rollins homers in the 3rd to tie it 1–1. It’s the Phillies’ first run since Jayson Werth’s first-inning home run in Game 1.</p><p>It becomes the pitchers’ duel everyone expected, remaining 1–1 into the 7th when Cincinnati gets a bad break. Rijo is injured on a pitch to Shane Victorino, who flies out on it, but Rijo has to leave the game. Dibble comes in to replace him.</p><p>Mariano Duncan doubles with two outs in the bottom of the 7th. Todd Benzinger reaches on an error by Rollins, with Duncan reaching third, but Joe Oliver lines out to 3rd to end the inning. Still tied headed to the 8th.</p><p>With two outs, Rollins singles. Dibble’s poor hold rating enables Rollins to steal both 2nd and 3rd, then he’s driven in by a Werth RBI single. The Phillies take a 2–1 lead mainly thanks to Rollins’ speed. Dibble is taken out for Norm Charlton with Philly’s big lefty bats up next. Chase Utley singles, and Ryan Howard doubles in Werth and Utley. A two-out rally by the Phillies produces 3 runs and a 4–1 lead.</p><p>Rijo had been cruising. One would think he’d still have been in the game had he not been injured, though that’s no guarantee he’d have continued to hold the Phillies down.</p><p>Chris Sabo hits a 2-out 2-run home run in the bottom of the 8th to bring the Reds within a run. Hamels is lifted for Ryan Madson, who gets Eric Davis to fly out to left. The Phillies lead 4–3 going to the 9th.</p><p>Naturally, that means the Phillies are going to their lights-out closer of 2008, Brad Lidge. He ends up facing all left-handed batters. With one out, Ron Oester pinch-hits for Duncan and walks. Pinch-runner Billy Bates then steals second. Hal Morris pinch-hits for Benzinger — he strikes out. The tying run remains on second base.</p><p>With 2 down, Jeff Reed pinch-hits for Oliver. He flies out to deep right, and the Phillies have held on to force a decisive Game 3 back in Philadelphia in two days. So, we’ll have at least one series in the Qualifying Round that goes the distance.</p><p><strong>Day 4</strong> (3 games)</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-6 2005 White Sox (Mark Buehrle) at AL-11 1985 Royals (Bret Saberhagen), White Sox lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Chicago scores a first-inning run, but allows three. Willie Wilson drove in Lonnie Smith with an RBI double, and Hal McRae homered two batters later.</p><p>Carl Everett led off the top of the 2nd with a single, and then Bret Saberhagen didn&#39;t allow a baserunner until the 7th. He retired 14 straight White Sox hitters. Darryl Motley homered in the 4th to put the Royals up 4–1.</p><p>Tadahito Iguchi ended Saberhagen’s streak with a lead-off double in the 7th. Two batters later, Paul Konerko doubled Iguchi in to make it 4–2. Everett then singled again to put runners on the corners and bring a potential go-ahead run to the plate. Saberhagen was taken out for Steve Farr, who struck out both Aaron Rowand and A.J. Pierzynski to end the inning.</p><p>Scott Podsednik singled with two outs in the 8th off Joe Beckwith, but was thrown out attempting to steal second by Jim Sundberg.</p><p>K.C. got a strange insurance run in the bottom of the 8th without a hit. McRae drew a lead-off walk, and Onix Concepcion pinch-ran. He would end up scoring when Dustin Hermanson threw consecutive wild pitches, allowing Concepcion to go from second to home without the ball being put in play. The Royals led, 5–2.</p><p>Dan Quisenberry pitched a perfect 9th, and the series was tied. Game 3 will be tomorrow in Chicago because the Executive Committee (me) removed the travel day from this series since the trip was only from Kansas City to Chicago. This allows us to have two games tomorrow for TV and to finish the Qualifying Round a day sooner, enabling the Round of 16 to also start a day sooner. This was decided before Game 2 so the managers could use their bullpens accordingly.</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-7 2002 Angels (John Lackey) at AL-10 1991 Twins (Kevin Tapani), Angels lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Minnesota scores a first-inning run for the second straight game. Dan Gladden drew a lead-off walk, went to third on Kirby Puckett’s double, and scored on a groundout by Kent Hrbek.</p><p>Darin Erstad singled and stole second to start the Angels’ 4th. He would advance to 3rd and then score on back-to-back 4–3 groundouts by Tim Salmon and Garret Anderson. Game tied, 1–1.</p><p>In the bottom of the 5th, Scott Leius singled and took advantage of John Lackey’s poor hold rating to steal second. Chuck Knoblauch’s RBI single gave the lead back to the Twins, 2–1.</p><p>Garret Anderson became the second Angels player in the series to suffer an injury when he grounded out in the top of the 6th. He’ll miss the Halos’ next game, and so will Troy Glaus. The Angels will be without their 4th and 5th hitters in the lineup for either Game 3 of this series or Game 1 of the Round of 16.</p><p>Hrbek hit a lead-off home run in the bottom of the 6th to make it 3–1. The Angels got their first two batters on base in the 7th to knock Tapani out of the game, but Carl Willis got Alex Ochoa to line out and Bengie Molina to ground into a double play. All the momentum is with the Twins.</p><p>Tim Salmon’s RBI double off David West scored David Eckstein to make it 3–2 in the 8th. With two outs, West’s wild pitch moved Salmon to 3rd, but Anderson’s replacement, Shawn Wooten, replacing Anderson, lined out to 3rd. The inning ended with the Twins holding a 3–2 lead.</p><p>Francisco Rodriguez got out a jam in the bottom of the 8th when he came in after singles by Knoblauch and Puckett. Hrbek and Chili Davis struck out. Shane Mack singled to load the bases, but Brian Harper lined out on a great play by Eckstein at short. No runs score. Still 3–2 headed to the 9th with closer Rick Aguilera coming in.</p><p>Scott Spiezio led off with a single. Pinch-runner Chone Figgins stole second. Brad Fullmer doubled, and just like that Figgins scored to tie the game and deflate the Metrodome crowd. Molina doubled two batters later to give the Angels their first lead of the game at 4–3. Tom Kelly took Aguilera out and brought in Steve Bedrosian.</p><p>It didn’t help. Adam Kennedy doubled to score Molina. Two batters later, Darin Erstad homered. It was a 5-run inning in the top of the 9th for the Angels. They now led 7–3, and that would be the final. A devastating blown save for the Twins to knock them out.</p><p>It will go down as a 2-game mini-sweep, but both games were close until the Twins’ bullpen implosion in the 9th of Game 2. One of the three “Jack Morrises” is out of the tournament now. After seeing the ’91 Twins bullpen cards, you can really understand why <a href="https://www.google.com/search?client=safari&amp;rls=en&amp;q=1991+world+series+game+7&amp;ie=UTF-8&amp;oe=UTF-8">Morris went 10 innings in Game 7 against the Braves</a>.</p><p>Like their counterpart 7-seed Diamondbacks in the N.L., the Angels next opponent depends on the outcome of the 6–11 series. If the White Sox beat the Royals, the Angels will play the 1998 Yankees. If the Royals win, Anaheim plays the 1984 Tigers. Not exactly a handsome reward either way.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-6 2019 Nationals (Max Scherzer) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Chris Carpenter), Cardinals lead series 1–0</em></p><p>The Nationals decided to go with Max Scherzer in the one game of the series taking place in his home area of St. Louis, and it worked as he didn’t allow any Cardinal to reach 3rd base in the first six innings.</p><p>However, Chris Carpenter did not allow any National to reach 3rd base in the first six innings. It takes a double by Scherzer himself to get Yan Gomes to 3rd with two outs in the top of the 7th, but Trea Turner pops out to end that inning. The game is still scoreless going into the 7th-inning stretch.</p><p>David Freese starts the bottom of the 7th with a double, then Yadier Molina singles him to 3rd. Scherzer rebounds to strike out Nick Punto. With the pitcher’s spot up next, Tony LaRussa decides to pinch-hit for Carpenter despite his great outing. The Cards have barely been able to touch Scherzer, so they have take the chance here.</p><p>Jon Jay is the pinch-hitter and he doubles to score Freese. Molina gets to 3rd. That’s it for Scherzer. Javy Guerra comes in to get Rafael Furcal on a tapper to the mound and a strikeout of Skip Schumaker. Still, the Cardinals have broken through and lead 1–0, two innings away from finishing the series.</p><p>Mark Rzepczynski pitched a perfect 8th, retiring Adam Eaton, Anthony Rendon, and Juan Soto. Closer Jason Motte started the 9th for St. Louis. Ryan Zimmerman singled with one out, and Michael A. Taylor pinch-runs for him. Victor Robles then hits a fly to deep right-center which Jay, who remained in the game to play center field, runs down. Taylor has to retreat to first base instead of possibly scoring. Jay has both the biggest hit and the biggest defensive play of this game that he didn’t even start.</p><p>Now there’s two outs. The next pitch could end the series and the Nationals tournament life. Asdrubal Cabrera is sent up to pinch-hit for Gomes, and the Cardinals don’t get lucky twice in a row. Cabrera rips a hit down the right-field line and to the corner. Taylor scores from first on Cabrera’s double. The Nationals have finally gotten a run in, tying the score.</p><p>It remains tied going into the 11th. Edwin Jackson, who normally was a starter, comes in to pitch. Soto leads off with a walk, but Howie Kendrick grounds into a 5–4–3 double play. Up next was former Cardinal slugger Matt Adams, who was on the 2019 Nats and entered the game to play first when Zimmerman was taken out for a pinch-runner. Adams drew another walk, but this time there were no options left to pinch-run. Robles hit one to deep right-center for the second straight time, and this one landed. Adams was waved home, but Jay’s throw in to second baseman Punto was then relayed home in time to get Adams for the third out.</p><p>A game that had no one reach 3rd base for the first six innings now has had scoring chances galore since, but still just one run for both teams. Edwin Jackson pitched to four batters in that 11th inning, only got one batter out, and escaped with no runs allowed.</p><p>Tanner Rainey started the bottom of the 11th for the Nats. Freese singled with one out, followed by a Molina double to make it 2nd and 3rd. Sean Doolittle came in to pitch for Washington as they could no longer wait for a save situation. Doolittle struck out Punto and got Jay to fly out to left. Inning over and still tied, 1–1, going to the 12th. This has by far been the most dramatic tournament game to date.</p><p>Jackson ended up pitching a much cleaner top of the 12th. Now it was the Nats’ turn to bring in a regular starter to pitch, and it was Anibal Sanchez. They were still banking on winning this game and using Patrick Corbin in Game 3 at home.</p><p>Adron Chambers, the Cardinals’ 25th man, had pinch-run back in the 10th inning and stayed in to play center field. He got a base hit with one out. Albert Pujols followed with a walk, so the Cards have a runner in scoring position for the third straight inning. Because of an earlier double-switch, Jackson’s spot was due up behind Pujols. Ryan Theriot pinch-hit and flied out to left. Matt Holliday then walked to load the bases with 2 outs, as the tension rises with every batter.</p><p>Daniel Descalso had pinch-run for Freese in the previous inning, and he too stayed in the game. Now he’s up, and in a series with such iconic names on both sides, it’s Daniel Descalso singling off Anibal Sanchez to score Adron Chambers in the 12th inning and make Edwin Jackson the winning pitcher.</p><p>2–1 Cardinals, in 12 innings. They advance to play the National League’s top seed, the 1986 New York Mets.</p><p>Wow, what a Game 2! Scherzer was brilliant in his homecoming to St. Louis, but he couldn’t save the Nats. A classic old-school National League game with double-switching, pinch-running, and using almost your whole roster in extra innings. The Cardinals are just like they were in 2011, hard to kill. The ’86 Mets await. Will Yadier Molina have another heroic moment at Shea Stadium?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FVdfKY9b6Nxo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DVdfKY9b6Nxo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FVdfKY9b6Nxo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3b19f62bfb1eaccd77a841b17cfb28a7/href">https://medium.com/media/3b19f62bfb1eaccd77a841b17cfb28a7/href</a></iframe><p><strong><em>(Note: By the way, after I found that clip, the next thing to come up on YouTube for me was the Mike And The Mad Dog open the following day. This is the greatness that sports radio used to be.)</em></strong></p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FnpNnet5bQqE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DnpNnet5bQqE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FnpNnet5bQqE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/13d518b1be03c2701afc838eabec7e77/href">https://medium.com/media/13d518b1be03c2701afc838eabec7e77/href</a></iframe><p>Getting back to our tournament here, this win by the Cardinals also means the Diamondbacks will face the 1995 Braves in the Round of 16. The winner of Phillies-Reds will get the 2016 Cubs.</p><p>One more day to go in the Qualifying Round. Four of our six series ended in 2-game sweeps. We have two deciding games tomorrow.</p><p><strong>Day 5</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-9 1990 Reds (Jack Armstrong) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Joe Blanton), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>Jack Armstrong, the <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/allstar/1990-allstar-game.shtml">starting pitcher for the National League in the 1990 All-Star Game</a>, tap-danced through the first two innings to keep the game scoreless. The Phillies went from bases empty with outs in the bottom of the 1st to bases loaded, but Shane Victorino flied out.</p><p>Armstrong bunted Mariano Duncan into scoring position in the top of the 3rd, and Duncan would later score on Billy Hatcher’s double. The Reds led, 1–0.</p><p>It looks like Armstrong will get out of trouble again in the 3rd when he strikes out Ryan Howard and gets Pat Burrell to hit a grounder to short. There are runners on 1st and 2nd, and Barry Larkin has a chance to start an inning-ending double play, but instead he commits an error and the bases are loaded again for the Phillies.</p><p>With Victorino up again, Armstrong throws a wild pitch that scores Jayson Werth to tie the game and the other runners move to 2nd and 3rd. Victorino is then intentionally walked to reload the bases. Pedro Feliz hits a grounder to second, another double play chance, and this one is booted by Duncan for the second error of the inning. Chase Utley scores and the Phillies lead, 2–1. The Phillies only got one hit in the inning, Werth’s lead-off single.</p><p>The Reds quickly bounce back as Joe Oliver’s 2-out double scores Chris Sabo from first. Game is tied, 2–2.</p><p>Sabo doubles with 1 out in the 6th, leading to Charlie Manuel taking Blanton out and bringing in Chad Durbin. He gets Oliver to fly out to center and Duncan to ground out to third. The pitcher’s spot was due up third for the Phillies in the bottom of the 6th, and Durbin remains in the game to hit after the first two batters ground out.</p><p>The Reds also somewhat surprisingly have their pitcher bat in the top of the 7th with the game still tied. Armstrong flies out to center, Durbin pitches a perfect inning, and the Phillies come up in the bottom half.</p><p>Werth draws a 1-out walk, ending Armstrong’s streak of 12 straight batters retired. Lou Piniella makes the move to bring in Dibble, who was great in Game 1 and took the loss in Game 2. Piniella thought Dibble had the better chance against the heart of the Phillies’ order.</p><p>Werth got a good jump and stole second, as the Phillies again used Dibble’s poor hold rating to their advantage. Utley then got a weakly-hit infield single to get Werth to 3rd. Howard fanned for the second out.</p><p>Dibble then misplaced the strike zone, walking Burrell to load the bases and then walking Victorino to force in a run. Phillies lead, 3–2. Just like in the 3rd inning, the Reds are hurt by repeatedly gifting the Phillies free 90 feet.</p><p>J.C. Romero retires Paul O’Neill and Eric Davis to start the 8th. Glenn Braggs pinch-hits for Hal Morris, and Philly brings in Ryan Madson. Braggs doubles, but then Sabo grounds out. The Phillies are three outs away from advancing, and remember <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/gl.fcgi?id=lidgebr01&amp;t=p&amp;year=2008">Brad Lidge was a dominant closer in 2008</a>.</p><p>Lefty Norm Charlton allowed two baserunners with one out in the bottom of the 8th. Right-hander Scott Scudder got Werth to ground out, but advanced the runners to 2nd and 3rd. With Chase Utley up, and Ryan Howard on deck, Piniella brought in his left-handed closer, Randy Myers. Utley lined a 3-run home run into the seats in right field. A nip-and-tuck game was suddenly blown open. Phillies lead, 6–2.</p><p>The Reds scored a meaningless run in the 9th, but Lidge finished them off. The Phillies won, 6–3, to take the series and advance to meet the 2016 Chicago Cubs.</p><p>Like Twins-Angels, this series was as evenly matched as it gets until the last inning of the last game. Both teams made the other pay for fielding mistakes. The Reds “Nasty Boys” bullpen (Dibble, Charlton, and Myers) got the job done when they were tasked to go 5 innings in Game 1, but couldn’t come through in the next two, which was one reason why the Reds tried to stick with Armstrong as long as possible. Dibble was too easy to run on, and Rollins’ two stolen bases after the unfortunate Jose Rijo injury in Game 2 started the rally which turned the series around for the Phillies. They will have to hold Cole Hamels back until Game 2 against the Cubs, but could use him again if that series goes 5.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-11 1985 Royals (Danny Jackson) at AL-6 2005 White Sox (Jose Contreras), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>The White Sox had an early chance when Scott Podsednik led off with a double, but Jermaine Dye would line into a double play to end that threat.</p><p>Dye, the White Sox right-fielder, would make his own great defensive play in the top of the 2nd when he robbed Steve Balboni of a home run. However, Balboni would clear the fence in the top of the 5th to put the Royals ahead, 1–0. Up until then, Contreras had retired the first 13 Kansas City hitters.</p><p>In Balboni’s last four at-bats in the games played in Chicago, he’s hit three home runs and been robbed of a 4th.</p><p>Danny Jackson continues to put the 0s on the scoreboard. He retires 9 in a row from the 5th to the 8th innings, including making a nice grab of a Podsednik comebacker. It remains a 1–0 game going to the 9th.</p><p>The Royals’ have one of <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/q/quiseda01.shtml">baseball history’s greatest closers in Dan Quisenberry</a>, but Jackson is left in since he’s doing so well. In 1985, Jackson had 4 complete games and 3 shutouts, so this is not unfamiliar territory. He starts the 9th with Quisenberry ready for the call.</p><p>The call was never needed. Paul Konerko struck out. Carl Everett popped out to 2nd. A.J. Pierzynski grounded out to short. The Royals have defeated the White Sox, 1–0, in Game 3. Up next for them is the 1998 New York Yankees, the tournament’s overall number-one seed.</p><p>Upset City for both 11-seeds from Missouri, but this win by the Royals where they only recorded 2 hits felt more like a surprise than the Cardinals. Danny Jackson’s 4-hit shutout is the best-pitched game of the tournament so far, and the only complete game. The 91-win Royals will take on the 114-win Yankees next, but due to the short turnaround Bret Saberhagen won’t be able to pitch until Game 3.</p><p>By the way, did you notice the spoiler above for this game? It was in the picture of my set-up on the bar. The scoresheet shows the completed 1–0 win for K.C.</p><p>So, that was the very exciting and fun Qualifying Round and now it’s on to the Round of 16. The matchups for the best-of-5 series are as follows:</p><p><strong>American League<br></strong>(1) 1998 Yankees vs. (11) 1985 Royals<br>(4) 2017 Astros vs. (5) 1989 Athletics<br>(3) 1984 Tigers vs. (7) 2002 Angels<br>(2) 2018 Red Sox vs. (9) 1992 Blue Jays</p><p><strong>National League<br></strong>(1) 1986 Mets vs. (11) 2011 Cardinals<br>(4) 1988 Dodgers vs. (5) 2012 Giants<br>(3) 1995 Braves vs. (7) 2001 Diamondbacks<br>(2) 2016 Cubs vs. (8) 2008 Phillies</p><p>Again, the hope is to do a straight bracket from here, but we’ll see. The victory by the Royals did mean that the Blue Jays fell into their natural seeding against the Red Sox anyway, so the Committee’s decision was rendered moot.</p><p>The next round will have a maximum of 40 games to be played, so it could take a while.</p><p><strong>CHAPTER THREE: EVERYONE’S HERE, NOW IT’S A PARTY — ROUND OF 16 BEGINS</strong><br><strong>(Original publish date: August 22, 2022)</strong></p><p>The top 5 seeds in each league now join the tournament, which means we’ll be having games in New York, Los Angeles, Boston, Detroit, Houston, Atlanta, and San Francisco/Oakland. Also, we lost one Chicago team in the last round but we’re gaining another.</p><p><strong>Day 6 (</strong>4 games<strong>)</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone) at AL-2 2018 Red Sox (Chris Sale)</em></p><p>The Round of 16 gets off to a fast start as the Blue Jays score twice in the first inning, one of those runs unearned due to a Xander Bogaerts throwing error. Dave Winfield’s sacrifice fly and John Olerud’s RBI single made the score 2–0. However, the Red Sox answer with one in the bottom half on a J.D. Martinez RBI double.</p><p>In an ironic development very similar to real life, Chris Sale is injured in the 2nd inning and has to leave the game. Sale is replaced<em> </em>by projected Game 4 starter Nathan Eovaldi.</p><p>The Jays can’t touch Eovaldi for over 5 innings until a harmless Candy Maldonado solo home run in the 7th. Harmless because the Red Sox score 6 runs in the 4th, chasing David Cone out of the game. 8 of the first 9 batters in the inning reached base, with 4 extra-base hits including Ian Kinsler and Rafael Devers with back-to-back triples.</p><p>The Red Sox tack on another run in the 5th and 3 more in the 8th, where Bogaerts hit a 2-run home run. Red Sox win 11–3. They’ll move Eduardo Rodriguez into the probable start for Game 4, and Sale can come back in the if-necessary Game 5.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-5 1989 Athletics (Mike Moore) at AL-4 2017 Astros (Justin Verlander)</em></p><p>A pitchers’ duel for 4 innings, with Moore not allowing any hits and Verlander just giving up piddly singles. Houston breaks through in the 5th — Josh Reddick doubles, followed by an Evan Gattis RBI single. Later in the inning, Alex Bregman draws a bases-loaded walk.</p><p>It remains 2–0 in the 7th when Oakland’s bullpen falters. Gene Nelson walks the 8th and 9th batters in the lineup to start the inning, then George Springer hits a 3-run shot. Todd Burns proceeds to allow 3 more runs over the remaider of the 7th and 8th, not helped by Dave Henderson dropping a fly ball.</p><p>The Bash Brothers only offense is a two-run homer by…Walt Weiss? Yep. 8–2 Astros.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Kyle Lohse) at NL-1 1986 Mets (Dwight Gooden)</em></p><p>A weird first inning puts the Mets in a bind early. Skip Schumaker and Albert Pujols collect one-out singles to put runners on the corners. Then Dwight Gooden commits a balk (!) and a run scores. Lance Berkman then singles Pujols to 3rd, and a Matt Holliday sac fly makes it 2–0.</p><p>And the Mets cannot do a thing against Kyle Lohse. He retires the first 13 batters he faces until a Darryl Strawberry single, but that’s immediately followed by Ray Knight grounding into a 6–4–3 double play.</p><p>Gooden settles down. He gets a break when Holliday lines into a double play after a Berkman lead-off double in the 4th. He winds up going 6 because the Mets have to pinch-hit for him.</p><p>Lenny Dykstra singles home Mookie Wilson with 2 outs in the 6th, but that’s all the Mets can get. The Cardinals bullpen of Mark Rzepczynski, Fernando Salas, and Jason Motte shut down the top N.L. seed over the last three innings. The Cardinals don’t score again after their stunning top of the 1st, but don’t need to. They win 2–1 to become the first road team to win in this round.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain) at NL-4 1988 Dodgers (Orel Hershiser)</em></p><p>That’s <em>the </em>Orel Hershiser, who set the MLB record with 59 straights scoreless innings in 1988, against <em>the </em>Matt Cain, who pitched a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-IGSh3LLUZ8">perfect game</a> with 14 strikeouts on June 13, 2012.</p><p>The matchup lives up to the billing. Hershiser allows no hits for the first six-and-two-thirds innings. Buster Posey’s single breaks up the no-hitter.</p><p>In the Dodger 4th, Mike Marshall singles with one out. John Shelby grounds into a force play at 2nd, now putting the faster Shelby on first. Shelby steals second base and scores on Mike Scioscia’s single.</p><p>Still 1–0 Dodgers in the 9th, Angel Pagan triples with one out. It’s just the second hit for the Giants. But Marco Scutaro grounds out to short and Pagan must hold. Pablo Sandoval grounds out to second to end the game.</p><p>It’s a double complete game for Hershiser and Cain. The Giants just get two hits and one runner in scoring position all night.</p><p><strong>Day 7 (</strong>8 games<strong>)</strong></p><p><em>Game 2: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at AL-2 2018 Red Sox (Rick Porcello), Red Sox lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Another quick start for the Blue Jays as Winfield hits a 2-run HR in the first. This time the Red Sox do not answer.</p><p>Toronto tacks on more in the 4th. Maldonado doubles to put runners on 2nd and 3rd, then Kelly Gruber singles in one and a Pat Borders sac fly makes it 4–0. They finally chase Porcello in the 6th, but a Gruber 2-run single off Ryan Brasier makes it 6–0. Gruber adds a solo home run in the 8th for his 4th RBI.</p><p>Jimmy Key is dominant, even more so than he was in the Qualifying Round against the 1983 Orioles. He goes eight shutout innings. Cito Gaston gives him the 9th off with the 7–0 lead, but that gets a little hairy.</p><p>Mark Eichhorn allows a double to Martinez and a triple to Bogaerts, then a Manny Lee error makes it 7–2. After a Brock Holt single, Duane Ward has to come in to finish. Eduardo Nunez hits a sacrifice fly for the second out, then Christian Vazquez grounds out. Toronto wins 7–3 and ties the series.</p><p>Jimmy Key has pitched 15.2 innings in the tournament without allowing any runs.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Randy Johnson) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux)</em></p><p>Hands down, the most-anticipated pitching matchup of the early games in this round. It had a lot of live up to after Cain-Hershiser the night before, but it came close.</p><p>No scoring through 6 innings, and really nobody even close to scoring. That changed when Luis Gonzalez (57 home runs in 2001) led off the 7th with a solo shot, and that’s when the fun starts.</p><p>Matt Williams followed with a double. Two batters later, Danny Bautista singled in Williams and it was 2–0. Maddux walked Mark Grace, and stunningly he was out of the game. It’s like he didn’t just hit the wall; he drove into it full-speed.</p><p>And then…the same thing happened to Randy Johnson, only worse! He didn’t even record an out in the 7th inning. Chipper Jones and Fred McGriff led off with singles, and David Justice walked to load the bases. Mike Devereaux doubled to tie the game. Due up next was Charlie O’Brien, but he was only catching because Maddux was pitching. Jeff Blauser went up to pinch-hit, but with runners on 2nd and 3rd, he was intentionally walked. Now the Braves were bringing up their regular catcher, Javy Lopez, to pinch-hit for light-hitting shortstop Rafael Belliard.</p><p>Arizona brought in Bobby Witt, who got Lopez to bounce into the 1–2–3 double play. But that did not end the inning; there were only two outs, and the game still tied. Dwight Smith pinch-hit for Alejandro Pena, but again was intentionally walked. That set up a righty-righty matchup for Witt against Marquis Grissom, but that’s when Witt threw a wild pitch and Devereaux scored from 3rd to put the Braves ahead 3–2. A crazy 7th inning.</p><p>Mark Wohlers came on to pitch the 9th. Blauser, now playing shortstop, committed an error to let lead-off hitter Matt Williams reach. Steve Finley grounded into a force at second, but Finley ended up stealing second and scoring the tying run on another Bautista RBI single. After a wild pitch advanced Bautista to second, Wohlers got out of trouble by striking out Grace, intentionally walking pinch-hitter Erubiel Durazo, and getting Reggie Sanders to fly out.</p><p>Blauser led off the bottom of the 9th with a single off Mike Morgan. Lopez singled Blauser to 3rd, and Byung-Hyun Kim came in to pitch with the winning run at 3rd and no outs. Pinch-hitter Ryan Klesko struck out. Grissom grounded into a fielders’ choice, cutting down Blauser trying to score. Now it was 1st and 2nd with two outs, and it appeared Kim might pull off the escape and get the game to extra innings.</p><p>Mark Lemke singled to right-center, driving in Lopez from 2nd. One of the best games of the tournament to date went to Atlanta, 4–3.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-7 2002 Angels (Jarrod Washburn) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Jack Morris)</em></p><p>In a very odd circumstance only possible in a tournament like this, Jarrod Washburn was pitching against Jack Morris in two different rounds. This was the same matchup in the Qualifying Round when the Angels met the 1991 Twins.</p><p>In that QR series, the Angels were the hard-luck team when it came to injuries. Troy Glaus and Garret Anderson remained unavailable for this first game against the Tigers, and to top it off Tim Salmon was hit by a pitch in the first inning here and lost for this game and the next one. The Angels played almost the entirety of Game 1 without their regular 3–4–5 hitters.</p><p>And it showed. The closest they came to scoring was in the 3rd with bases loaded and one out, but Alex Ochoa, replacing Salmon, grounded into a force at home.</p><p>Washburn went the distance for the Angels but allowed 4 hits and 2 runs in the 4th inning. It was his only bad frame. Morris went 6.2, Bill Scherrer 1.1, and 1984 A.L. MVP Willie Hernandez closed it in the 9th. Final score: 2–0 Tigers.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Lance Lynn) at NL-1 1986 Mets (Bob Ojeda), Cardinals lead series 1–0</em></p><p>The Cardinals send another jolt into the Shea Stadium crowd with a Berkman solo home run in the 2nd, but that’s answered by one from Gary Carter in the bottom half.</p><p>Lance Lynn, who was used out of the bullpen in the Qualifying Round, did well over 5 innings. The Cardinals lifted him for a pinch-hitter in the 6th with runners on 2nd and 3rd and two outs, but Nick Punto was intentionally walked to face the struggling Rafael Furcal. Furcal flew out to end the inning. Furcal is 1 for 18 in the tournament, and may be replaced as the lead-off hitter by Ryan Theriot, who was 4-for-4 in this game batting 8th.</p><p>Mark Rzepczynski, who has been almost perfect so far in the tournament, started the 7th inning with a 1–1 tie. He walked pinch-hitter Kevin Mitchell and Keith Hernandez. Mitchell Boggs came in and walked Carter. Arthur Rhodes came in to face Strawberry, who doubled in two and the Mets had their first lead of the series. Mookie Wilson later singled in Carter and Strawberry and the Mets had a 4-run lead.</p><p>David Freese homered in the top of the 8th, and the Cardinals then got two more runners on. Roger McDowell came in with pinch-hitter Allen Craig representing the tying run. Craig grounded out and Furcal flied out again. Jesse Orosco pitched the 9th for the save. Mets tie the series with a 5–2 win and they head to St. Louis.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-11 1985 Royals (Charlie Leibrandt) at AL-1 1998 Yankees (David Cone)</em></p><p>The underdog Royals tried a bold here-we-are move in the first as Willie Wilson attempted a straight steal of home. He had a 30 percent chance of being safe. It didn’t work; he was out. Hal McRae then struck out to end the inning.</p><p>The Yankees immediately jumped on the misfire and scored 2 runs themselves in the bottom of the 1st. Derek Jeter tripled with one out, then Paul O’Neill doubled. Chili Davis knocked in O’Neill.</p><p>The Royals got one across in the 4th, but otherwise Cone struck out 11 over 7 innings. Leibrandt got in his own groove for K.C. and pitched into the 6th. Steve Farr was also effective for 1.2 innings, and there was no more scoring.</p><p>Graeme Lloyd and Mariano Rivera finished the 2–1 win for the Yanks.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Jamie Moyer) at NL-2 2016 Cubs (Kyle Hendricks)</em></p><p>The Cubs touched Moyer for two runs in the 1st and it could have been more. Kris Bryant and Anthony Rizzo walked with one out. Ben Zobrist brought home Bryant with a single. With two outs, Willson Contreras doubled to left to score Rizzo, but Zobrist was thrown out at the plate to end the inning.</p><p>The Phillies countered with a Ryan Howard home run leading off the 2nd, but gave the run back right away. Kyle Hendricks sacrificed Addison Russell to second base, then Dexter Fowler delivered an RBI single. When Moyer hit Bryant with a pitch, that was the end of the night for him and in came rookie J.A. Happ.</p><p>Over 3.1 innings, Happ allowed just one hit and that runner would be erased on a double play. The Cubs’ 3–1 lead lasted into the 5th, and the rally started when Happ himself singled with one out. Javier Baez made a critical error with two outs to load the bases, which were subsequently cleared by a Howard double and the Phillies led 4–3. All three runs unearned.</p><p>With two outs in the 6th and a runner on 3rd, Greg Dobbs was announced to pinch-hit for Happ. The Cubs brought in lefty Mike Montgomery to replace Hendricks, and then the Phillies substituted Eric Bruntlett to hit for Dobbs. Bruntlett, normally a defensive replacement, doubled in the run and it was 5–3.</p><p>Scott Eyre started the bottom of the 6th and allowed a run to score. With Contreras on 3rd and one out, Jason Heyward grounded out to first and the runner held. Russell flew out to end the threat. It was now 5–4.</p><p>That’s how it stayed. The Phillies used a total of 7 pitchers, a tournament-high for any team, and got the 5–4 win. J.C. Romero, Ryan Madson, and Brad Lidge set the Cubs down the final three innings, but not without peril. The final batter of the game was Kyle Schwarber, relegated to pinch-hitting duty in this tournament due to his real-life injury and usage in 2016. Lidge struck out Schwarber to end the game but rolled the dreaded 6–12. Triple boxcars: a 6 on the white die, and two 6s on the reds. That means a pitcher injury.</p><p>Lidge then rolled a 2, meaning a 2-game injury. It’s incredible how hard it is to roll the injury numbers in the first place, and then roll the most-severe case on the next roll, but it just happened to the Phillies closer and later on it will happen to another big-time player. The Phillies now hope their 2008 postseason MVP Cole Hamels can go deep in Game 2.</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-5 1989 Athletics (Dave Stewart) at AL-4 2017 Astros (Dallas Keuchel), Astros lead series 1–0</em></p><p>One of the greatest pitchers in A’s history, Dave Stewart, never had a chance. I’ve never thought the sign-stealing trashcan-banging of the 2017 Astros was the baseball crime of the century it was made out to be, but I’m wondering if these guys can be beat with this juggernaut offense. The results of their scheme is certainly reflected in the cards.</p><p>Carlos Correa started it with a 2-run double after a pair of walks and one out. Jose Altuve beat the throw to the plate for the 2nd run, enabling Correa to advance to 3rd. Already down 2–0, the A’s played the infield in and Yuli Gurriel blooped a single over the infield to score Correa.</p><p>An Alex Bregman RBI single in the 2nd made it 4–0 and sent Stewart to an early shower. A sacrifice fly by Altuve put Houston up 5–0 after two.</p><p>Then the A’s got back in the game. Rickey Henderson hit a 2-run HR in the 3rd, and Dave Parker hit a three-run shot in the 4th to tie it 5–5. Both rallies started with two outs and the bases empty.</p><p>It didn’t last. The Astros grinded out three runs in the 5th. Oakland got one back in the top of the 6th to make the score a manageable 8–6. Still a game. Until the Astros mashed for 7 runs in the 6th, the biggest inning of the tournament so far. The first 5 batters of the 6th all got hits, including three straight doubles by Correa, Gurriel, and Reddick. The inning was capped by a Bregman grand slam and it was 15–6.</p><p>The A’s registered the tournament’s second-biggest offensive output in a single game to this point. Unfortunately for them, they gave up the biggest in the very same game. 4 runs in the last 3 innings for the A’s turned out meaningless and the final score was 15–10.</p><p>There are going to be entire series in this round that don’t get to 25 combined runs, and it was done here in one game. Add Game 1 to the total and these teams have scored 35 runs. Oakland’s heading home one loss away from extinction.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner) at NL-4 1988 Dodgers (Tim Belcher), Dodgers lead series 1–0</em></p><p>On the other hand, we have the anemic offenses of these two clubs, or at least anemic in this series.</p><p>The Dodgers lost Belcher to an injury in the 2nd inning. It was very similar to Game 1 of the Blue Jays-Red Sox series where the starter had to leave but the long reliever effectively went over 5 innings. The role of Nathan Eovaldi in this case was played by Brian Holton.</p><p>Madison Bumgarner was every bit as good, if not better, than Orel Hershiser in Game 1. He took a no-hitter into the 8th, where Mike Scioscia broke it up with a 2-out single. The game was still scoreless heading to the 10th.</p><p>Jay Howell pitched the 10th for the Dodgers. Pagan walked with one out, and Scutaro singled him to 3rd. Joaquin Arias was due up next, since he had pinch-ran for Sandoval back in the 8th. Arias hit a shin burger off of Howell, which caromed to Steve Sax to get the out at first, but Pagan scored and the Giants led 1–0. Howell was checked but remained in the game to strike out Buster Posey for the third out.</p><p>Bumgarner started the bottom of the 10th. Kirk Gibson lined out on a nice play by Scutaro for the second out. Marshall singled, Mike Davis pinch-ran, and Shelby singled Davis to 3rd. A tiring Bumgarner was then lifted for closer Sergio Romo. Shelby stole second to put the winning run in scoring position, but Scioscia popped out to second for the final out.</p><p>Two games, two 1–0 final scores. Series tied 1–1.</p><p><strong>Total runs scored in series with Bay Area teams</strong><br>Oakland-Houston: 35<br>San Francisco-Los Angeles: 2</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*r2-pAqIByH0pLkSf.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Day 8 (</strong>4 games<strong>)</strong></p><p><em>Game 2: AL-7 2002 Angels (Kevin Appier) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Dan Petry), Tigers lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Glaus and Anderson were back for the Halos, but Salmon was still out. Petry started sharp, striking out 5 in the first two innings.</p><p>Lou Whitaker’s RBI single brought home Chet Lemon in the 3rd for the game’s first run. Lemon had led off the inning with a double.</p><p>Kirk Gibson lost a Brad Fullmer fly ball in the sun and had it go off his glove starting the 5th. Fullmer reached second on the error. He would score on a two-out double by Adam Kennedy, tying the game.</p><p>Dave Bergman tripled with one out in the 5th, but was stranded there after Appier retired Whitaker and Alan Trammell.</p><p>David Eckstein singled with one out in the 8th. Darin Erstad doubled to center, but Eckstein was thrown out at home. Glaus then flied out to the warning track in left, and the Angels did not score.</p><p>Francisco Rodriguez started the 9th for the Angels with the score still 1–1. Howard Johnson singled with one out and stole second. Rodriguez struck out Lemon for the second out. Bergman then singled to right and Johnson beat Ochoa’s throw home. Tigers win 2–1, and lead the series 2–0.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Curt Schilling) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Braves lead series 1–0</em></p><p>It was hopeful that Curt Schilling and Tom Glavine could produce close to the same pitchers’ duel that Johnson and Maddux did in Game 1.</p><p>Glavine held up his end but had one flaw, a Gonzalez solo home run in the 1st for a 1–0 Arizona lead.</p><p>Here’s the first four batters for the Braves in the 2nd inning:<br>Fred McGriff walk<br>David Justice home run<br>Ryan Klesko single<br>Javy Lopez home run</p><p>Just like that, 4–1 Atlanta. They put another run on the board in the 3rd. Schilling lasted only 4 innings and was lifted for a pinch-hitter in the 5th. The Diamondbacks never threatened as Glavine went the distance and the Braves took a 2–0 series lead with John Smoltz ready to start Game 3. The D-Backs will likely bring back Johnson on three days rest for Game 4, if they can get to a Game 4.</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-11 1985 Royals (Bud Black) at AL-1 1998 Yankees (Orlando Hernandez), Yankees lead series 1–0</em></p><p>The Royals would have definitely preferred to use Bret Saberhagen or Danny Jackson here, but they hadn’t had enough rest from their heroics in the Qualifying Round against the White Sox. They hoped Black could get them through 5 or 6 innings.</p><p>Willie Wilson reached third base in the first inning again, this time with a triple. The Royals were not trying to steal home now. George Brett singled in Wilson for a 1–0 lead, then Hal McRae grounded into a double play.</p><p>It was still 1–0 in the 3rd. Chuck Knoblauch drew a one-out walk. Up came Jeter. The roll was a white 2 and red snake-eyes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*dpmvQecyp-wHAfwW.jpeg" /></figure><p>“HBP plus injury”. The chances of rolling 2–2 are slim, but it happened and then it was time to roll the die for severity.</p><p>It was a 2. Jeter is out for this game, and the next two.</p><p>As if he was personally enraged at this development, next batter Paul O’Neill blasted a three-run homer. 3–1 Yankees.</p><p>Shane Spencer led off the 4th with a home run, and Black gave up two hits and a walk before he was removed for Mark Gubicza. It was 5–1 after four.</p><p>The Royals cut it to 5–3 in the top of the 7th, but Wilson popped out to end the inning with Brett on deck. Jorge Posada then had 5 RBI in the 7th and 8th innings, three of them on a homer in the 7th. The Yankees cruised home, 10–3.</p><p>So, Jeter is out for the next two. It didn’t hurt them in this game. We’ll see what happens. Saberhagen and Jackson are due to pitch Games 3 and 4 in Kansas City, so it’s not over yet. Of course, there’s also a chance that the second game of Jeter’s injury is the first game of the next series.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Cole Hamels) at NL-2 2016 Cubs (Jon Lester), Phillies lead series 1–0</em></p><p>The Cubs threatened in the first with two runners in scoring position with one out, but Cole Hamels struck out Zobrist and got Baez to fly out.</p><p>It remained scoreless into the 4th. After Chase Utley grounded into a double play, Howard singled and scored from first on Pat Burrell’s double. Burrell had been 0 for 12 in the tournament entering this game.</p><p>The Cubs answered in the 4th with two hits and a sac fly, then took the lead in the 5th on a Kris Bryant triple. Jon Lester had singled earlier and scored the run, similar to J.A. Happ in Game 1 for the Phillies.</p><p>It all caved in on Lester in the 7th. Howard walked and Burrell homered. It was 3–2 Phillies, and they have been a team that has collected back-breaking, stadium-quieting clutch hits on the road throughout the whole tournament so far. All 5 of their games have been either tied or had a 1-run margin entering the 7th inning.</p><p>They weren’t done. With one out, Pedro Feliz walked and Carlos Ruiz homered. Ruiz had been 0 for 14 entering this game. Now it was 5–2 and Lester was pulled. Jimmy Rollins added the third home run of the inning for the Phillies, a solo shot off Pedro Strop. Suddenly it was 6–2 Phillies.</p><p>Hamels gave them the length they needed without Lidge, and then some. A complete game to give the Phillies a 2–0 series lead headed home.</p><p>5 of the 8 series in this round are 2–0; the Phillies are the only lower seed to be ahead.</p><p><strong>CHAPTER FOUR: BALKING AND BRAWLING — ROUND OF 16 CONCLUSION <br>(Original publish date: September 30, 2022)</strong></p><p><strong>Day 9 (</strong>4 games<strong>)<br></strong> <br>Again, I’m summarizing the games in the order in which they were played, which is based on a hypothetical national TV schedule.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-2 2018 Red Sox (David Price) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Juan Guzman), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>Here’s how I can best describe how this went:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*Tdm6ZtQIk3wy8N5h.jpeg" /></figure><p>David Price allowed a grand slam to Candy Maldonado in the 1st, and was taken out after immediately re-loading the bases. Joe Kelly got the 3rd out, but then he walked three batters who all scored in the next inning. Ryan Brasier gave up three more runs in the 3rd. Toronto cruised, 12–5. Maldonado had a tournament-high 7 RBI.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-4 2017 Astros (Charlie Morton) at AL-5 1989 Athletics (Storm Davis), Astros lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Trailing 1–0 in the 6th, Houston ties it when George Springer scores from 1st on a Alex Bregman double. Springer beat the throw home, and Bregman advanced to 3rd on the throw. That would be a huge 90 feet since Bregman scored on a passed ball by Terry Steinbach with the next batter up. The Astros took a stunning 2–1 lead.</p><p>They added a big insurance run in the top of the 9th with Dennis Eckersley pitching in a non-save situation. Carlos Correa singled in Bregman to make it 3–1 with still no outs, but Yuli Gurriel flied out and Josh Reddick bounced back to the mound for a double play.</p><p>Oakland made it interesting against wild closer Ken Giles, who walked the first two batters in the bottom of the 9th. Unfortunately for the A’s, the heart of their lineup was nowhere near due up. Walt Weiss sacrificed them to 2nd and 3rd, so the tying runs were in scoring position with one out. Ron Hassey grounded out to score one run and advance the tying run to 3rd. Mike Gallego grounded out on a difficult play by Bregman at 3rd to end the game. 3–2, Houston. They are the first team to advance to the Division Series, and will have several days off to line up their pitching again.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-1 1986 Mets (Ron Darling) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Chris Carpenter), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>One important note to this game was the Cardinals dropping Rafael Furcal to the 8th spot in the lineup, and the Mets having so little respect for Furcal’s offense that they intentionally walked Yadier Molina ahead of him <em>twice. </em>After the second one, the Cardinals countered with Nick Punto as a pinch-hitter that stayed in the game to play shortstop.</p><p>The closest anyone came to scoring in the first six innings was Matt Holliday being thrown out at the plate on a David Freese double.</p><p>Chris Carpenter was brilliant but he rolled the injury numbers on the first batter of the 7th, and he had to leave the game. Mark Rzepczynski came in to retire Darryl Strawberry and Ray Knight to end the inning, the game still scoreless.</p><p>Mookie Wilson leads off the 8th with a triple off Fernando Salas. Danny Heep pinch-hits for Rafael Santana and hits a sacrifice fly to score Wilson. 1–0, Mets. Their bats have been extremely quiet except for the 7th inning of Game 2, but things are now looking up for the top seed in the N.L.</p><p>Roger McDowell was pitching the bottom of the 8th, after coming on to get the last out of the 7th with two on base. McDowell allowed one-out singles to Holliday and Freese, setting up a sac fly by Yadier Molina to tie the game.</p><p>That brought up Punto. His offensive card is a little better than Furcal’s, but still not overwhelming…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*HkcCcmOrkQaUlhKL.jpeg" /></figure><p>…until he rolls the 3–6 with the go-ahead run on base in the 8th inning of a tied game and tied series! So now we have to roll the 20-sided die, but no matter what the Cardinals are taking the lead here.</p><p>Punto rolled a home run! He had one home run in real life in 2011. A shocker in St. Louis. The Cardinals lead 3–1. Punto was only in the game because Furcal was in a giant slump, and he just hit the biggest home run by a Cardinal shortstop since Jack Buck told everyone to go crazy.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FL4PB0XoLbm8&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DL4PB0XoLbm8&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FL4PB0XoLbm8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c5ee08929e466ad6b2e658cbbfea2327/href">https://medium.com/media/c5ee08929e466ad6b2e658cbbfea2327/href</a></iframe><p>Jason Motte mowed down Keith Hernandez, Gary Carter, and Strawberry for the save. The Mets are a loss away from elimination because they can’t hit a lick in this series.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-4 1988 Dodgers (Tim Leary) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Ryan Vogelsong), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>Quick reminder: this is the series that had two 1–0 games at Dodger Stadium.</p><p>The Dodgers scored 3 runs in the top of the 1st here. They also got 3 more in the 4th. Then 2 in the 5th, 2 in the 6th, 2 in the 7th, and 2 in the 8th. 14 runs for L.A., with a tournament-high <em>23 hits</em>.</p><p>With the game out of hand, the Giants used their deep bullpen to eat up innings but still had to use Barry Zito in the 9th so they could save their normal late-inning relievers for the next day’s Game 4. Zito was the projected Game 4 starter, but now the Giants will go with Matt Cain on three days rest, trailing in the series 2–1.</p><p>Another quirk that happened came in the bottom of the 9th when the Giants scored 3 runs to make the score 14–4, but since every position player had been used, Zito had to bat for the final out of the game.</p><p>The Dodgers announce later that to match up against Cain in Game 4, they will also bring back Orel Hershiser on three days rest instead of saving him for Game 5. It’s also believed this move could enable the Dodgers to start Hershiser twice in the next series should they advance.</p><p><strong>Day 10 (</strong>8 games scheduled, 7 played<strong>)</strong></p><p>A funny thing happened in real life around this time. Strat-O-Matic’s website and app went down for days.</p><p>I thought I had taken a picture of it to show you, but I guess not because I can’t find it now. But the point is, I wanted to play for about 2 1/2 days, and couldn’t.</p><p>Wanting to play but not being able to. That sounds like a rainout.</p><p>I declared the next game would be a rainout, and the schedule would be adjusted. Throw a wrench into the works, for fun. One problem: the next game was indoors, Boston at Toronto.</p><p>Alright then, the next scheduled <em>outdoor</em> game will be a rainout. Until then, let’s play this one and it turned out to be a thriller…</p><p><em>Game 4: AL-2 2018 Red Sox (Eduardo Rodriguez) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris), Blue Jays lead series 2–1</em></p><p>The Red Sox going with Rodriguez in place of original starter Nathan Eovaldi, who had to emergency-relieve the injured Chris Sale in Game 1. Rodriguez was brilliant for five innings, just allowing an unearned run on a Mitch Moreland 3rd-inning error.</p><p>Boston still trailed 1–0 going in the 6th. Andrew Benintendi doubled Mookie Betts to 3rd with nobody out. J.D. Martinez struck out. Xander Bogaerts was then intentionally walked to bring up Moreland, who had a decent chance of grounding into an inning-ending double play.</p><p>Instead, Moreland blasted a grand slam for a 4–1 Red Sox lead. Moreland with a huge home run in Game 4 of a 2018 postseason series on the road…seen that before.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*YXDppyFC7i0QJAmS.jpeg" /><figcaption>Game 4, 2018 World Series</figcaption></figure><p>Ah, but the Red Sox still had miles to go before they could sleep. Remember it’s only the 6th inning. Roberto Alomar led off the bottom half with a single, and then Joe Carter homered. It was 4–3.</p><p>With one out, John Olerud hit a grounder behind 3rd that Rafael Devers should have ate, but instead threw away. Olerud ended up on 3rd with a single and a two-base error. He scored on a Maldonado single. Just like that, the game was tied 4–4 with seven combined runs in the 6th inning.</p><p>Boston loaded the bases with no outs in the top of the 7th. Duane Ward struck out Benintendi and Martinez, but allowed a 2-run single to Bogaerts. 6–4, Red Sox.</p><p>Toronto had first and second with no outs in their half, but Ryan Brasier came in and got three fly outs by Alomar, Carter, and Dave Winfield. Alex Cora decided Craig Kimbrel (to this point, unused in the series) was going for a 2-inning save.</p><p>Kimbrel walked three batters in the 8th, but got Devon White to pop up to end the inning. The clutch symbol on White’s card got him; it turns hits into outs, and vice versa, in situations with runners in scoring position and two outs and if the rolled dice hit that number. It remained 6–4. Kimbrel pitched a clean 9th to finish the game and send the series back to Fenway Park for a decisive Game 5.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-2 2016 Cubs (Jake Arrieta) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Joe Blanton), Phillies lead series 2–0</em></p><p>POSTPONED — RAIN.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*BD9R97LeHXWTtfUwDgOAIA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Remember, I said the next outdoor game is a rainout due to the Strat-O-Matic app outage.</p><p>This changes things for this series. The if-necessary travel day between Games 4 and 5 is now gone. Game 4 is rescheduled as a day game so the teams can get to Chicago for a night start in Game 5. It also enables the Cubs to use top pitcher Kyle Hendricks in Game 4 on normal rest, again, if necessary.</p><p>The 2016 Cubs needing to win three straight games and getting some advantageous rain — <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/postseason/2016_WS.shtml">we’ve seen that before, too</a>.</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-1 1986 Mets (Dwight Gooden) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Jaime Garcia), Cardinals lead series 2–1</em></p><p>The Mets are bringing back Doctor K on three days rest. Original starter Sid Fernandez will be available out of the bullpen. Bob Ojeda is scheduled to pitch Game 5 at Shea Stadium if the Mets can win this one.</p><p>But again, they can’t hit. Shut out for the first four innings by Garcia with only one batter reaching. Yadier Molina’s RBI single gives the Cardinals a 1–0 lead in the 4th.</p><p>Is this is how the 1986 bad-boy swagger-ific Mets lose? With a whimper?</p><p>Well, not exactly. We saw in real life how they, too, came back from the brink:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FgOssdTBigbo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DgOssdTBigbo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FgOssdTBigbo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e4bb35d00a63e8ad90496fd4727c138d/href">https://medium.com/media/e4bb35d00a63e8ad90496fd4727c138d/href</a></iframe><p>4 straight singles to start the 5th gives the Mets a 2–1 lead, then a safety squeeze by Gooden scores the 3rd run. It’s starting to look good for them.</p><p>Molina hits a solo home run in the 6th to make it 3–2. He’s really starting to get on the nerves of Mets fans again. However, Gooden picked off David Freese just before that homer, so without that the game would be tied.</p><p>Punto and pinch-hitter Allen Craig followed with singles to knock the tired Gooden out of the game. Rick Aguilera comes in to strike out Ryan Theriot to end the threat and preserve the Mets lead.</p><p>New York plates two runs in the 8th, and it could have been more. After a bases-loaded walk to Strawberry made it 5–2 with no outs, Cardinal relievers struck out Knight, Lenny Dykstra, and Aguilera. Aguilera batted because Davey Johnson decided to stick with the hot hand who had retired all four batters he had faced and struck out three of those. He was hoping for one more clean inning, and to get the ball to Jesse Orosco in the 9th.</p><p>Holliday led off the 8th with a double, and Freese tripled (again, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UEEOZpdp9bo">seen that before in real life</a>). It was 5–3 with the tying run at the plate. So that grand idea didn’t work out for the Mets, and Orosco got the ball right now.</p><p>Molina grounded out to first, which enabled Freese to score. Punto flied out to center. Pinch-hitter Jon Jay singled, Theriot got hit by a pitch, and Skip Schumaker singled in Jay. Albert Pujols flew out to end the inning, but the Cardinals had amazingly tied this game at 5–5.</p><p>We jump ahead to the 10th. Fernandez had worked the 9th for the Mets, and began the 10th with his 4th strikeout. Furcal came up to pinch-hit; he was 1 for 19 in the tournament to this point, and had been benched. Of course, he hit a double. Fernandez was removed for McDowell, to face Theriot.</p><p>Base hit to center…Furcal’s coming home to win the game and the series…the throw by Dykstra…in time! Furcal is out. The game continues, but it’s just the second out of the inning, and Theriot advanced to 2nd on the throw.</p><p>Skip Schumaker then singled, but Theriot could only reach 3rd. Up next: Albert Pujols. As I write this, the real-life Pujols has just hit his 700th career home run. He’s probably the third-greatest Cardinal of all-time, and here he was with a chance to send these upstart Cardinals past the National League’s top seed and into the Division Series (quarterfinals).</p><p>Roll #1: a 2 showed up on the 20-sided die, which means this could be a passed ball or a balk (!)</p><p>Roll #2 to determine which one: it’s a possible balk. Now it’s time to see if Roll #3 lands with McDowell’s balk range.</p><p>Roll #3: it landed within McDowell’s balk range.</p><p>A balk. With a runner on 3rd base. In the bottom of the 10th inning of a tie game. To win it for the Cardinals and eliminate the Mets.</p><p>This is when I asked myself…should I count it? No one else is here watching me play. Nobody’s auditing this thing. My wife rolls her eyes when she hears me rolling the dice. <em>(Note: if I didn’t love my wife very much, I would’ve played this round in about half the time, but I like spending time with her more. I usually play when she’s not around.)</em></p><p>Nobody needs to know this was a balk. I could just throw a do-over.</p><p>But, no I couldn’t. Every single roll of the dice in this tournament that legitimately landed in the box has counted. This has to count. It’s a balk; Theriot scores. The Cardinals win, 6–5.</p><p>Let me also explain how rare it is to get a balk in this game. I mentioned Roll #1 — that only has a 5 percent chance of happening. Roll #2 is a 50 percent chance of either passed ball or balk. So those both have to hit to even get to Roll #3, where Roger McDowell’s range for a balk on his 1986 card was 1 to 7, out of 20. That’s a 35 percent chance of it even being a balk and a 65 percent chance of It’s Nothing, Re-Roll From The Top. (I think Roll #3 was a 5.)</p><p>There have been 3 balks in this entire tournament to date. One was harmless in the Angels-Twins Qualifying Round series. <em>The other two</em> were by the Mets in this series (Dwight Gooden in the first inning of Game 1 was the other), and both directly brought in runs for the Cardinals in games the Mets lost by one.</p><p>Games don’t really end on balks, do they? Well, yes. I looked. I had to look. It’s happened 23 times in MLB history (also the exact same number of <em>perfect games </em>in MLB history). The most recent one was this year on <a href="https://www.mlb.com/news/reds-secure-walk-off-win-on-10th-inning-balk">July 8 in Cincinnati</a>.</p><p>I’m sorry, Mets fans. I didn’t want it to end this way. But…maybe don’t blow a 5–2 lead in the 8th.</p><p>Another aspect of this series is the battle between a short pitching staff of the 80s versus a team from 25 years later with a long bullpen. The deeper bullpen outclassed the shorter one in this series.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-1 1998 Yankees (David Wells) at AL-11 1985 Royals (Bret Saberhagen), Yankees lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Playing without Derek Jeter, who is injured for this and New York’s next game, the Yanks score single runs in the 1st and 2nd innings. Then it becomes a pitchers’ duel.</p><p>Saberhagen goes the distance for the Royals (<a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/KCA/KCA198510270.shtml">seen it</a>). Wells lasts into the 8th, when he allows three straight singles and a run. Graeme Lloyd comes in to face George Brett with runners on the corners in a 2–1 game. Brett grounds out to first.</p><p>Mariano Rivera allows a lead-off single to Hal McRae in the bottom of the 9th, but Frank White hits into a double play. Steve Balboni singles. Pinch-hitter Pat Sheridan flies out to the warning track in right, a would-be walk-off home run but instead the Yankees win the game 2–1 and the series 3–0. Kudos to the Royals for fighting the good fight, but it wasn’t meant to be for both 11-seeds from Missouri.</p><p>The Tournament Executive Committee (myself) could invoke “The Jack Morris Rule” to determine matchups for the tournament’s next round, a 5-game Division Series. So named for the player who is on 3 teams in this tournament, the rule is in place to avoid the same player being on both teams in a series for as long as possible. That means we may not have a straight bracket, so while it may look like the Yankees will meet the Astros in a Division Series as the 1 and 4 seeds in the A.L., that’s far from certain. If Toronto wins against Boston, they cannot play either the Yankees or Tigers in the next round; instead the Jays would have to face Houston. So everything is TBD.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz) at NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Miguel Batista), Braves lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Arizona is in deep trouble, being unable to win either game started by Randy Johnson or Curt Schilling.</p><p>Batista was gone in the 2nd inning, allowing a 2-run home run to Jeff Blauser, and then three more runs. Atlanta got two more in the 3rd, and cruised to an easy 7–2 win for the sweep.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Milt Wilcox) at AL-7 2002 Angels (John Lackey), Tigers lead series 2–0</em></p><p>There have been three sweeps in this round, and the Tigers were looking like they could make it four when they loaded the bases in the 1st with nobody out. Lance Parrish grounded into a double play that got a run home, but killed the rally.</p><p>Wilcox was wild, walking three in the bottom of the 2nd. David Eckstein’s 2-run single made it 3–1 Angels. Wilcox would be chased next inning when the Angels scored three more. One of those runs scored on a single by Jose Molina, who had replaced his brother Bengie due to injury. The Angels, who had been the most-injured team in the tournament so far, had started the game at full strength for the first time since the Qualifying Round. Bengie Molina was now out for the rest of this series, which would continue after the Halos took this game, 9–2. That could hurt the Angels since Bengie has the better arm.</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-4 1988 Dodgers (Orel Hershiser) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain), Dodgers lead series 2–1</em></p><p>Ok, here we go, the Three Day Rest Game. It’s the only time in this tournament both starting pitchers are going on short rest. Hershiser bested Cain 1–0 in Game 1 of this series.</p><p>Both pitchers made their managers look good. It was 1–1 starting the 8th. With two outs, Steve Sax singled and stole second. Mickey Hatcher singled to bring in Sax for a 2–1 Dodgers lead and the end of the night for Cain.</p><p>The Giants matched. Angel Pagan led off with a single and he stole second. Marco Scutaro singled to tie it again, and to end the night for Hershiser. Alejandro Pena came in and retired Pablo Sandoval, Buster Posey, and Hunter Pence, with Pence flying out to the wall in left.</p><p>John Shelby led off the 9th with a walk and was bunted to second, but Santiago Casilla came in to get two ground outs.</p><p>In the bottom of the 10th, the Giants had 2nd and 3rd with after a single, walk, and bunt. With the Dodgers infield in, Sandoval grounded out to second. Posey walked to load the bases, but Pence flied out to center.</p><p>After Kirk Gibson was stranded at second in the top of the 11th, Brandon Belt drew a lead-off walk in the bottom half. Gregor Blanco hit one to short for an infield hit, but Alfredo Griffin committed a throwing error on the play to make it 2nd and 3rd with no outs. Jay Howell got Brandon Crawford to line out and Joaquin Arias to strike out.</p><p>Next up was Pagan, who had reached base in all five of his plate appearances with three hits and two walks. Pagan was also having a good series, so he was intentionally walked to load the bases for Scutaro. The “clutch symbol”, that worked against Devon White in the Toronto-Boston game earlier in the day, worked for Scutaro and turned an out into a hit. Belt scored the winning run, and the Giants had tied the series. Of the four games in this series, three were decided by one run and two of those went extra innings.</p><p><strong>Day 11 (</strong>2 games<strong>)</strong></p><p><em>Game 3: NL-2 2016 Cubs (Jake Arrieta) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Joe Blanton), Phillies lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Now the weather is clear, and the Phillies could finally attempt to finish the series after their two wins at Wrigley Field. A poor start for them, however, as Ben Zobrist hits a 2-run home run in the 1st, but that’s quickly answered by 2-run shot from Ryan Howard.</p><p>The Cubs get another pair of runs in the 2nd inning, due to errors by Howard and Jimmy Rollins. Addison Russell’s solo home run in the 3rd made it 5–2.</p><p>The Phillies use their speed, and Jake Arrieta’s poor hold rating, to score in the 3rd and 4th. Rollins and Shane Victorino led off those respective innings by reaching base and then stealing second to be driven in. Already a crazy game through 4 innings was 5–4 Cubs.</p><p>Facing left-hander Mike Montgomery, Howard flied out deep to left in the 5th. Javier Baez followed with a solo shot in the top of the 6th. Baez had a huge game, going 4 for 4 with 4 runs scored. Dexter Fowler also had 4 hits.</p><p>A key play occurred in the bottom of the 8th with the Cubs up 7–4. Pat Burrell doubled with two outs; Howard tried to score from 1st, but was thrown out at the plate. Had there been just one out, Howard likely would have been held at third. With two outs, he’s sent home and nailed. Instead of 7–5 with the tying run coming up, the inning was over at 7–4.</p><p>The Cubs tacked on 3 runs in the 9th, with the Phillies holding back Ryan Madson and unable to use Brad Lidge. The final was 10–4, with the Cubs feeling good about their chances.</p><p><em>Game 4: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Juan Berenguer) at AL-7 2002 Angels (Ramon Ortiz), Tigers lead series 2–1</em></p><p>Lou Whitaker led off with a triple, and then Kirk Gibson was intentionally walked with one out. The Angels were hoping Lance Parrish would hit into a double play, but instead he struck out. 5th batter Darrell Evans connected on a three-run homer for an early 3–0 Detroit lead.</p><p>Garret Anderson’s two-run shot in the bottom of the 1st made the score 3–2 before Evans collected his 4th RBI in the 3rd inning.</p><p>Scott Schoeneweis replaced Ortiz in the top of the 4th, but an error by him loaded the bases. Whitaker’s infield hit scored another run, and with their chances in the series about to be extinguished, the Angels brought in their normal 8th-inning pitcher Francisco Rodriguez in the hopes he could get some strikeouts. Instead, Alan Trammell singled in two more runs and it was 7–2. A Parrish double and Johnny Grubb single made it 9–2.</p><p>The final would be 11–3, and the Tigers become the third A.L. team to advance. That led to some big decisions by the Executive Committee.</p><p>The A.L. “bracket”, as it were, was being jammed up by the Toronto-Boston series and the Jack Morris Rule. The Yankees and Astros have been waiting around to find out their next opponents, and we want to minimize their days off and avoid any idle days in the tournament if we can.</p><p>The Committee has decided that any team that wins this tournament is going to have to beat 4, and possibly 5, other great championship teams to do it and the order in which those teams line up doesn’t matter much. The idea of a straight bracket is gone. Seeds only matter for home-field advantage now.</p><p>Since the Blue Jays cannot play the Yankees or Tigers in the next round, the Committee declared the Yankees and Tigers will just face each other in the Division Series no matter what happens between the Blue Jays and Red Sox. The winner of Toronto-Boston Game 5 will take on the Astros. If Toronto wins, how will we handle the ALCS against New York or Detroit with the duplicated players? The Committee hasn’t decided yet — everything’s in flux.</p><p>The National League is jammed up too, mostly by the Cubs and Phillies who could still have 2 games remaining, as well as the Dodgers and Giants going the distance plus some other “Jack Morris” potential scenarios. The Committee wants to avoid a Braves-Dodgers matchup (Alejandro Pena) and Cardinals-Giants (Ryan Theriot). It’s decided one NLDS will be the Cardinals against the Braves, and the other will be between the winners of the Cubs-Phillies and Dodgers-Giants series.</p><p>This allows us to schedule games for Day 13, where the Division Series will begin in New York and Atlanta. Before that, we have three major games on Day 12.</p><p><strong>Day 12 (</strong>3 games<strong>)</strong></p><p><em>Game 4: NL-2 2016 Cubs (Kyle Hendricks) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Brett Myers), Phillies lead series 2–1</em></p><p>The Cubs began the day very confident with their ace pitcher on the mound, but that confidence was abruptly snuffed out with Jayson Werth and Pat Burrell hitting 1st-inning home runs to put the Phillies ahead 3–0.</p><p>The Cubs got their first two batters on in the top of the 2nd, but Jason Heyward struck out with runners on 2nd and 3rd with 1 out. Baez was then intentionally walked with Hendricks on deck. Joe Maddon considered already pinch-hitting for Hendricks with this scoring chance, but stuck with him and the inning ended on a groundout to first.</p><p>Hendricks hit Jimmy Rollins with a pitch to lead off the 3rd, already the second Phillies hit batsman of the game (Chase Utley took one in the 1st, and would score on Burrell’s homer). Hendricks would be pulled after Werth singled and Rollins advanced to 3rd. With the game and the series quickly getting away from the Cubs, they brought in closer Aroldis Chapman, hoping he could get some strikeouts against the heart of the Phillies order. The Cubs would worry about how they could finish the game later if they could just get out of this jam now.</p><p>It didn’t work. Chase Utley doubled to score Rollins. Ryan Howard singled to bring in both Werth and Utley. Burrell walked, and Shane Victorino hit a 3-run homer. Suddenly, and shockingly, the Phillies led 9–0. Chapman never retired a batter.</p><p>Remember that two Phillies batters had been hit by pitches in the first 3 innings. Ben Zobrist was plunked leading off the top of the 4th. I decided that’s when the umpires would give warnings to both dugouts.</p><p>Next batter Willson Contreras grounded into a fielders’ choice, and that’s when I wondered: would this be a brawl when Zobrist slid hard into second base, already angry about being down 9–0 and thinking he was hit on purpose? I decided no, it wouldn’t escalate to that, but there would be words exchanged and posturing with the teams all stepping out on to the field and the crowd booing.</p><p>With the score 10–0 after an Utley home run, Anthony Rizzo became the second Cub to be hit by a pitch as he led off the 6th. OK, I decided, now <em>that’s</em>a brawl. We ejected Myers, manager Charlie Manuel, Rizzo, Zobrist (who was on deck and would also charge toward Myers), and third baseman Pedro Feliz for intercepting Zobrist and wrestling to the ground with him.</p><p>In the bottom of the 6th, Pedro Strop and Maddon would be ejected for plunking pinch-hitter Chris Coste. The intent appeared borderline, but the warnings had been issued long earlier.</p><p>After what seemed like a week, the game mercifully ended with the Phillies winning 11–0 and taking the series in 4. No need for a rematch of Cole Hamels and Jon Lester the next night in Chicago. The Phillies, who are 5–2 overall in tournament play, will meet the winner of Dodgers-Giants. Hamels will be able to pitch the opener.</p><p>What a weird series, which had the Phillies using 7 pitchers and winning Game 1 with three unearned runs scored, then the Phillies scrambling to manage their short-handed bullpen, a rainout and extra day off, the Cubs using a closer in the 3rd inning, and a 5-HBP basebrawl.</p><p>Also, the ball is absolutely flying out of Citizens Bank Park. Most of the ballparks in this tournament are pitchers’ parks, but Philadelphia is a glaring exception. In the 4 tournament games at CBP, there’s been 11 home runs.</p><p><em>Game 5: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at AL-2 2018 Red Sox (Chris Sale), Series tied 2–2</em></p><p>The Blue Jays bypassed David Cone, who was rocked in Game 1. Jimmy Key had thrown 15.2 scoreless innings in the tournament, including 8 in Game 2, so it was an easy move.</p><p>Key and Sale were expectedly dominant, and it took an extreme oddity for Key to allow his first run. Steve Pearce hit a fly to right, and the dice rolled a 2-base error on Joe Carter. Next batter Rafael Devers singled, and Pearce scored to give the Red Sox a 1–0 lead.</p><p>Now, I felt bad about this one. I think it’s a tiny flaw in the game that gives an average-at-best defensive outfielder a higher probability to make an error than it should. Do I think that in a big game like this Joe Carter would drop a fly ball? No, I don’t. Not in a million years. But it’s not impossible. He could lose it in the lights, he could collide with an infielder backing up, or he could pull a Wil Myers in the 2013 playoffs and just not catch the ball.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgfycat.com%2Fifr%2Fhilariousheartfeltamericancrocodile&amp;display_name=Gfycat&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgfycat.com%2Fhilariousheartfeltamericancrocodile&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fthumbs.gfycat.com%2FHilariousHeartfeltAmericancrocodile-size_restricted.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=gfycat" width="450" height="250" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/03f8ce82943f3be0b895e920ea5c0a6d/href">https://medium.com/media/03f8ce82943f3be0b895e920ea5c0a6d/href</a></iframe><p>So I thought it was a very chintzy run for the Red Sox, and I didn’t want to count it but it’s what appeared on the dice that landed properly in the box. Even for a few minutes as I continued playing, I considered just pretending Pearce flied out and the game was still scoreless.</p><p>Ian Kinsler hit a solo wall-scraper home run over the Green Monster in the bottom of the 7th to make it 2–0 (or maybe 1–0, I still wasn’t sure) Red Sox. It was Key’s first earned run allowed in 3 starts.</p><p>To this point, Chris Sale had allowed just one hit over 7 innings. He had struck out Carter, Winfield, and Olerud in the top of the 7th. He was rolling. Until Candy Maldonado led off the 8th with a walk. Kelly Gruber then doubled, and suddenly the Blue Jays had 2nd and 3rd with no outs.</p><p>Rance Mulliniks pinch-hit for Pat Borders. He flew out to shallow center and Maldonado could not score. Next was Pat Tabler pinch-hitting for Manny Lee, and he drew a walk to load the bases with 1 out. A tiring Sale was then lifted for Boston’s most consistent middle relief pitcher, Ryan Brasier.</p><p>Devon White hits another shallow fly to center, again not deep enough for Maldonado to score from 3rd. So it was still a 2-run game, with bases loaded and 2 outs for Roberto Alomar. A sharp single advanced the runners 90 feet and finally got the Blue Jays on the scoreboard.</p><p>Next up: Joe Carter. The man whose error earlier in the game cost the Blue Jays a run now delivered a 2-run single which silenced the crowd at Fenway Park, as the home team now trailed 3–2 in the 8th!</p><p>So much for that chintzy run. But is that baseball, or what? Carter commits the big error, then he makes up for it with the clutch hit. Similar to Mitch Moreland in Game 4.</p><p>Duane Ward came in for the bottom of the 8th to face Betts, Benintendi, and Martinez. It was three up, three down.</p><p>Tom Henke got the ball for the 9th. Bogaerts led off with a single. Moreland sent one to deep right that off the bat sounded like a walk-off series-winning home run, but Fenway’s deep right field held the ball in the park.</p><p>Up next was Brock Holt pinch-hitting for Eduardo Nunez, who came in as a defensive replacement for Devers in the 8th. Holt hit a sharp grounder to first baseman Olerud, who threw to 2nd for the first out and got the return throw in time for the game-ending double play!</p><p>The Blue Jays jump and dance on the Fenway infield. One big inning, a 3-run 8th, won them the game and the series. Chris Sale took a hard-luck loss by allowing the three runners to reach base who all scored after he was taken out. Jimmy Key collected his third win of the tournament with just two runs allowed, and one earned, in 22.2 innings.</p><p>Toronto advances to meet the 2017 Astros in two days. Both 2-seeds, the Cubs and Red Sox, were eliminated in the same day and there was still one more dramatic game to go.</p><p><em>Game 5: NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner) at NL-4 1988 Dodgers (John Tudor), Series tied 2–2</em></p><p>Bumgarner delivered the best-pitched game of the tournament in Game 2, where he took a no-hitter into the 8th, struck out 11, and went nine-and-two-thirds in the Giants’ 1–0 win. John Tudor was making his first appearance, having been passed over for Hershiser in Game 4.</p><p>This time the Dodgers got to MadBum for single runs in the 3rd and 5th. It could have been worse, with Kirk Gibson flying out to the wall in right for a sacrifice fly instead of a grand slam.</p><p>Bumgarner was removed after John Shelby’s lead-off single in the 6th. With Bumgarner’s poor hold rating, he was vulnerable to a stolen base and putting another runner in scoring position already down 2–0 in this elimination game. However, Jeff Hamilton tripled against George Kontos to make it 3–0.</p><p>Brandon Crawford stepped to the plate with two outs and the bases empty in the top of the 7th. Crawford hit a double. Joaquin Arias, pinch-hitting for Bumgarner, singled Crawford to third. Still no harm, no foul. Runners on the corners, 2 outs.</p><p>Angel Pagan, already 2 for 3 and having a great series, hit a grounder to short. Alfredo Griffin then committed his third error of the series, allowing Crawford to score. It was now 3–1, and the inning should have been over. Tudor was then taken out for right-hander Brian Holton, who countered Bumgarner with 5.1 shutout innings in Game 2 when pressed into emergency relief and had a 1.70 ERA in 1988.</p><p>When Arias on 2nd and Pagan on 1st, Marco Scutaro singled to load the bases. Up next was Pablo Sandoval, who like almost all of the Giants was struggling offensively. He was 0 for 3 in the game, and hitting .200 for the series with no RBI and no clutch hits.</p><p>In the words of Giants broadcaster Jon Miller, “Adios, pelota!”</p><p>A jaw-dropping grand slam. A Panda Slam. Giants 5, Dodgers 3. Instantly, the highest run total for the Giants in any game of the series.</p><p>Steve Sax led off the 7th with a walk and a stolen base against Santiago Casilla. Mickey Hatcher then singled, and Sax was waved home with an 80 percent chance of being safe. It was easy to assume this would become a 5–4 game, but not only did Hunter Pence throw home, Hatcher held at first to avoid a cutoff play. Sax was surprisingly thrown out, and the Dodgers rally was extinct a minute later when Gibson lined into a double play. The Giants ran off the field like they had stolen a bag of money.</p><p>It was a formality after that. Jeremy Affeldt pitched a perfect 8th, and Sergio Romo got the save. In stunning fashion, the Giants went from down 3 runs with the bases empty and two outs in the 7th to winning the series.</p><p>The Giants were another team that took advantage of having a longer bullpen than their opponent from the 80s, which is discouraging to those of us who don’t like the bloated pitching staffs of today.</p><p><strong><em>(Note: Well, now we don’t have to worry about what to do with Kirk Gibson if the Dodgers made the Grand World Series (he probably would have been limited to just one at-bat), especially if they were to face the Tigers.)</em></strong></p><p>So we started with 22 teams and now it’s down to 8. The pairings for the Division Series (best-of-5):</p><p><strong>ALDS:</strong> 1998 Yankees vs. 1984 Tigers, 2017 Astros vs. 1992 Blue Jays<br><strong>NLDS:</strong> 1995 Braves vs. 2011 Cardinals, 2012 Giants vs. 2008 Phillies</p><p>Interesting clump of teams from ’08, ’11, and ’12 in the N.L., while the A.L. survivors are very spread out across several eras. Also, Giants-Phillies will be at the ballparks with the highest and lowest home-run probability.</p><p><strong>CHAPTER FIVE: I DON’T BELIEVE WHAT I JUST ROLLED — DIVISION SERIES<br>(Original publish date: November 21, 2022)</strong></p><p><strong><em>It’s Game 5 of the National League Division Series in San Francisco. We’re in the bottom of the 14th inning, and Cole Hamels is coming in to pitch for the Phillies…</em></strong></p><p>Cole Hamels? He didn’t start Game 5? Is he in for the save? The 14th inning?</p><p>(Shout out to one of my favorite shows, Secret Base’s <a href="https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUXSZMIiUfFT6WwhB2Sk2gqz7agE9FlLg">Rewinder</a>, where I lifted that idea from.)</p><p>We’ll get there, but I’ll just say it was so jaw-dropping I feel the need to hook you in right away. I don’t even care if you skim the other games and just read about that series. But if you would like the details of the rest of the tournament and how we got down to the League Championship Series matchups, thanks and read on.</p><p><strong>Day 13</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Kyle Lohse) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux)</em></p><p><strong>How They Got Here: </strong>Cardinals defeated 2019 Nationals 2 games to 0 in the Qualifying Round, defeated 1986 Mets 3 games to 1 in Round of 16; Braves defeated 2001 Diamondbacks 3 games to 0 in Round of 16</p><p>Kyle Lohse was brilliant and outpitched Dwight Gooden in Game 1 of the Cards’ Round of 16 upset of the N.L.’s top-seeded 1986 Mets. They were asking him to do it again, this time against Greg Maddux.</p><p>The Strat-O-Matic app which is used to match up the batter’s card against a pitcher’s card also calculates the odds for various outcomes. It had Braves second baseman Mark Lemke with an 0.8 percent chance to hit a triple against Lohse. Lemke then hit 2 triples in his first 2 at-bats. He scored both times, and also drove in another run. All that plus a Ryan Klesko solo home run in the 2nd inning added up to a 4–0 Braves lead in the 3rd and an early shower for Lohse.</p><p>Maddux pitched a 3-hitter, all singles. It was no contest. 5–0 Braves was the final with Chipper Jones adding a late solo shot.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Jack Morris) at AL-1 1998 Yankees (David Cone)</em></p><p><strong>How They Got Here: </strong>Tigers defeated 2002 Angels 3 games to 1 in Round of 16; Yankees defeated 1985 Royals 3 games to 0 in Round of 16</p><p>Two batters into the game at the old Yankee Stadium and the visitors had a 1–0 lead. Lou Whitaker doubled and scored on Alan Trammell’s single.</p><p>Paul O’Neill hit a 2-run homer in the bottom half of the 1st to give the Yankees a 2–1 lead and this was quickly not shaping up to be a pitchers’ duel. The Tigers tied it in the top of the 2nd, then the Yankees plated 2 in the bottom of the 3rd to lead 4–2.</p><p>In the top of 5th, David Cone misplaced the strike zone. Trammell and Kirk Gibson walked after Whitaker’s one-out double. Cone threw a wild pitch that scored Whitaker to make it 4–3. Lance Parrish then drew Cone’s third consecutive walk to reload the bases.</p><p>Darrell Evans struck out for the second out of the inning. Manager Sparky Anderson then played a hunch and sent up Ruppert Jones to pinch-hit for Larry Herndon, who had struck out twice previously. Jones had been playing semi-regularly as the starting left-fielder against right-handed pitching, though Herndon got the start here.</p><p>What Jones had was pop, and he made Sparky’s hunch pay off with a stunning grand slam to put Detroit ahead 7–4 and knock Cone out of the game.</p><p>Jack Morris scratched and clawed his way through six innings with 5 runs allowed, but got two key double plays in the 5th and 6th. Detroit’s rock-solid bullpen of Bill Scherrer, Aurelio Lopez, and Willie Hernandez went the final three frames to send the Yankee fans home bewildered. The Tigers take Game 1, 7–5.</p><p><strong>Day 14 </strong>(4 games)</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Chris Carpenter) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Braves lead series 1–0</em></p><p>We’re going right back to Atlanta to start a 4-game day with the others taking place later in Houston, New York, and San Francisco. This tournament does follow a “TV schedule” that closely resembles what happens in real life during the postseason.</p><p>The Cardinals were counting on their ace, Chris Carpenter, to go deep into the game after the prior day’s short start by Lohse. However, those plans took a big hit in the bottom of the 2nd when Klesko homered again, this time a 3-run shot after Fred McGriff and David Justice reached.</p><p>Javy Lopez followed the Klesko blast with a single, and then the Braves used some unconventional strategy. 8th-hitter Rafael Belliard sacrificed Lopez to 2nd with pitcher Tom Glavine due up next. One of the stronger hitting pitchers of his day, Glavine singled to score Lopez and it was 4–0 Braves in the early innings for the second straight game.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4ltD21rYWVw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4ltD21rYWVw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4ltD21rYWVw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/590a8c89084eff7b650069fdc5df5b3d/href">https://medium.com/media/590a8c89084eff7b650069fdc5df5b3d/href</a></iframe><p>Carpenter had to be removed for a pinch-hitter in the top of the 5th, meaning the Cardinals’ starting pitchers only went a combined 6 innings in the first two games of the series.</p><p>David Justice hit a 3-run home run in the 8th. The Braves won 9–4 for their fifth straight win of the tournament without a loss.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone) at AL-4 2017 Astros (Justin Verlander)</em></p><p><strong>How They Got Here: </strong>Blue Jays defeated 1983 Orioles 2 games to 0 in Qualifying Round, defeated 2018 Red Sox 3 games to 2 in Round of 16; Astros defeated 1989 Athletics 3 games to 0 in Round of 16</p><p>An RBI triple by Evan Gattis and a subsequent passed ball gave the Astros a 2–0 lead in the 2nd, but Toronto’s second time through the lineup against Justin Verlander produced a big rally. With a run already in, a 2-run double by Pat Borders gave the Jays a 3–2 lead. Manny Lee then singled in two more, and the Blue Jays had a 5-run inning in the 4th with 4 of those runs driven in by the 8th and 9th hitters.</p><p>Verlander would go 6 innings, but the Blue Jays feasted against the Astros’ bullpen. Borders, Dave Winfield, and Kelly Gruber all homered. Toronto cleared their bench in the 9th inning and still scored two more runs to build up their lead to 11–2. Cone went the distance with 9 strikeouts. It’s the Astros’ first loss of the tournament, making the Braves the only team yet to lose.</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Dan Petry) at AL-1 1998 Yankees (Andy Pettitte), Tigers lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Andy Pettitte pitched plenty of Game 2s in postseason series over his Yankee career. None worse than this one.</p><p>Lance Parrish hit a 3-run home run in the top of the first, and three batters later it was Chet Lemon going deep for two more. Pettitte was done after recording a mere two outs. The Tigers led 5–0 before the Yankees ever came to bat.</p><p>Perhaps you’ve noticed a trend of 5-run innings. They have occurred in four straight games, two of them by the Tigers. Kirk Gibson added a 2-run shot in the 5th to make it 7–0. The Yankees put up 3 in the 6th, two of them on a Derek Jeter home run, but the rest of the game was a formality. The final was 8–3 Tigers, and they were one win away from eliminating the favored 114-win Yankees after taking the first two in the Bronx.</p><p>Jeter was asked how they remain confident despite the 0–2 hole. “Duque and Boomer,” said the captain. With Orlando Hernandez and David Wells slated to start Games 3 and 4 in Detroit, the Yanks did have a perceived pitching advantage.<br><em>(Author’s Note: OK, a little embellishment there by me with the quote.)</em></p><p><em>Game 1: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Cole Hamels) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Ryan Vogelsong)</em></p><p><strong>How They Got Here: </strong>Phillies defeated 1990 Reds 2 games to 1 in the Qualifying Round, defeated 2016 Cubs 3 games to 1 in the Round of 16; Giants defeated 1988 Dodgers 3 games to 2 in Round of 16</p><p>This series got crazy, from the first game on. For starters, the Tournament Executive Committee (me) suspended Brett Myers 5 games for his role in the brawl in the Phillies’ clinching game against the Cubs. In other words, Myers is out for the series and the Phillies are down a pitcher.</p><p>Ryan Vogelsong was starting for the Giants because they had to use Matt Cain and Madison Bumgarner four times in their 5-game series with the Dodgers. Hamels singles and scores a run himself in the top of the 3rd, which made it 2–0 Phillies at the time. Unfortunately, disaster strikes in the bottom of the inning when Vogelsong nails Hamels in the leg with a comeback line drive. Hamels recovers to get the out, but is forced to leave the game after just 2.2 innings. So now the Phils have to piece together another long night from the bullpen, which they have done before successfully.</p><p>It goes fine until the bottom of the 5th, now with the Phillies ahead 4–0. With bases loaded and one out, Aubrey Huff is announced to pinch-hit for Vogelsong. Philadelphia counters by removing Chad Durbin for lefty Scott Eyre. The Giants counter that counter with Joaquin Arias becoming the new pinch-hitter, and he doubles in two runs to cut the deficit in half. Marco Scutaro comes through with another RBI single and it’s 4–3.</p><p>Ryan Madson pitches a scoreless 6th and 7th. Then the Phillies bring in J.C. Romero in the 8th, still leading by a run. Romero has to face right-handed batters, so it’s not an ideal situation for him, but the Phillies were low on options with their high-leverage relievers. Closer Brad Lidge was warming up, though the Phillies were hoping not to need him for a 2-inning save since he’d likely also have to pitch tomorrow at some point.</p><p>Scutaro led off with a single. Romero has a terrible hold rating, so Scutaro attempted to steal second but was thrown out by Carlos Ruiz. That out appeared to be big when Pablo Sandoval doubled. Charlie Manuel decided it had to be time for Lidge now, with 2012 National League MVP Buster Posey coming to the plate. Leaving a left-hander in for Posey with the tying run in scoring position would be detrimental to winning.</p><p>But, Posey was MVP because he could hit righties too. He singled to score Sandoval and tie the game, meaning 2008 Brad Lidge had just blown his first save (albeit with an inherited runner on 2nd and the MVP batting) after going 41 for 41 in that season and staying perfect in the postseason.</p><p>I could imagine the Phillies broadcasters getting frustrated. “If Cole Hamels doesn’t get hit by that liner, we’re back at the hotel already with a 1–0 lead,” Larry Andersen might say on the radio. “Absolutely,” Scott Franzke would probably say in agreement.</p><p>Lidge gets out of the 8th, and also pitches a scoreless 9th despite Brandon Crawford’s lead-off double.</p><p>Due to some earlier lineup changes, the pitcher’s spot, then occupied by Lidge, was on deck when the top of the 10th ended with Shane Victorino flying out. So the Phillies make a double switch, removing Victorino, moving Jayson Werth to center field, and inserting Geoff Jenkins in right field. J.A. Happ came in to pitch, taking Victorino’s lineup slot so Jenkins would lead-off an 11th inning. Jenkins had not played in the entire tournament to date. You know that old saying about how when you come off the bench in baseball, the ball will find you?</p><p>Sandoval led off with a single. Happ threw a wild pitch. Posey was then intentionally walked. Hunter Pence walked. Bases loaded, nobody out. Brandon Belt then strikes out. Now the pitcher’s spot is due up for the Giants, and they have to go to their last position player, backup catcher Hector Sanchez.</p><p>Sanchez hits a fly to right, the type of fly where you have to roll again and check the charts to see if the defender made the play. The defender is Geoff Jenkins. The dice came up as an error on a dropped ball. The winning run scores from third. The Giants take the series lead after being down 4–0 earlier in the game.</p><p>I mentioned in the last round that I dislike outfielder errors, especially dropped fly balls, because I think the charts make them a little easier to happen than they would in real life. However, in this case, I can see it and I’ll explain.</p><p>At the time, and for a long time, San Francisco had open bullpens in foul territory. I took a tour of what was then called AT&amp;T Park in 2014, and I asked the tour guide about them and he said what I had always heard: they <em>forgot </em>bullpens when they built the place, so they shoe-horned them on to the field, old-school style.</p><p>Here’s a photo I took from a game I attended there in 2017. You’ll see the bullpen mound is right against the foul line.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*8BDUzbEUcw34_0CY.jpeg" /></figure><p>I also remember editing a highlight of a game from 2011 when Washington Nationals right-fielder Jayson Werth tripped over the bullpen mound and missed a catch. It was a random play in a random June game from 11 years ago, and was also a foul ball, so I can’t find video and <a href="https://mlb.nbcsports.com/2011/06/08/jayson-werth-to-miss-his-second-straight-game/">this blurb</a> is the only reference I could find to it online.</p><p>All this is to say, could Geoff Jenkins enter a game cold after sitting for weeks, playing an unfamiliar right field, maybe even with seagulls flying overhead as they do there late at night, being a below-average defensive outfielder anyway, trip over a bullpen mound that is right up against the foul line, drop the ball which lands in fair territory so the winning run can score? I can see it. It’s not impossible.</p><p>I don’t like that’s how the game ends, but that’s what the dice rolls produced. Every roll that cleanly lands in the box counts, no matter what, just like the Cardinals eliminating the Mets on a balk. The Giants win, 5–4 in ten innings. Phillies fans were worried now that this series could be over quickly, since they will be facing Cain and Bumgarner in Games 2 and 3.</p><p>But for now, let’s end this game with another tease: Hamels will see Vogelsong again soon.</p><p><strong>Day 15</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Juan Guzman) at AL-4 2017 Astros (Dallas Keuchel), Blue Jays lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Houston gets a 1st-inning run when Jose Altuve drives in George Springer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*IaHxVLmCQzfTJXsT.gif" /></figure><p>Toronto did load the bases with no outs in the 5th, but Roberto Alomar lined out to second and Joe Carter hit into a 1–2–3 double play to end the inning. Their next threat came in the 8th, but John Olerud hit into an inning-ending DP there.</p><p>Houston’s single run held up for the 1–0 win to tie the series.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Jamie Moyer) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain), Giants lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Jamie Moyer had a short night’s work in his last appearance, getting removed in the 2nd inning in Game 1 against the Cubs in the Round of 16. He was lifted after facing 11 batters.</p><p>In this outing, Moyer retired the first 13 Giants’ hitters of the game. Hunter Pence singled for their first hit, but next batter Brandon Belt grounded into a double play so Moyer faced the minimum through five innings. The game was still scoreless as Cain had only allowed one harmless single himself.</p><p>Gregor Blanco led off the bottom of the 6th with a single, and then stole second. Brandon Crawford struck out to bring up Cain. Instead of bunting, the trend of pitchers having an impact while batting in this series continued as Cain singled to score Blanco with the game’s first run.</p><p>Cain immediately gave it back by allowing a Werth home run to lead-off the 7th.</p><p>Moyer started the bottom of the 7th but was taken out after walking Sandoval with one out. Madson came in to face Posey, and walked him. Pence followed with an RBI single and it was 2–1 Giants.</p><p>Cain started the top of the 9th with that one-run lead. The pitcher’s spot was due to start the inning, and most of the Phillies bench had been used. Charlie Manuel decided now was Redemption Time for Geoff Jenkins. The left-handed batter hit a lead-off double, and now it was Bruce Bochy’s turn to use his closer with the tying run in scoring position. In came Sergio Romo.</p><p>Jimmy Rollins greeted Romo with another double, and suddenly the game was tied. Like in Game 2 of the Qualifying Round series against Cincinnati, Rollins used his feet and speed to get the Phillies another run as he stole third and would score on Chase Utley’s sacrifice fly. The crowd was shocked to see the visitors go ahead 3–2. Rollins was making a strong case for Tournament MVP.</p><p>Now Lidge was brought into a normal save situation, but Scutaro led off with a single. However, Ryan Theriot pinch-ran and was thrown out stealing. Sandoval struck out to set up Lidge vs. Posey for the second night in a row. For the second straight game, a fly ball to right was the last play. This one was caught by Werth for the Phillies win.</p><p>How baseball is it that Geoff Jenkins made the error to lose Game 1 and started the rally that won Game 2? How baseball is it that both games ended on flies to right field?</p><p>How could these two games in San Francisco be topped? You’ll see.</p><p><strong>Day 16</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-3 1995 Braves (Steve Avery) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Jaime Garcia), Braves lead series 2–0</em></p><p>With the 2–0 lead, the Braves decide to give Steve Avery his first tournament start. John Smoltz gets pushed back to Game 4.</p><p>It starts to look like a Braves sweep when Chipper Jones hits a solo homer in the top of the 1st, but Yadier Molina answers that with one of his own in the 2nd.</p><p>Fred McGriff reaches on a two-out two-base error by Albert Pujols in the 4th. He scores on a single by Mike Devereaux, who was replacing an injured David Justice for the remainder of the game. But Molina re-ties it with his second solo shot in the 5th.</p><p>The Cardinals score an unearned run of their own in the next inning. Javy Lopez threw away a swinging bunt by Jon Jay, allowing runners to reach 2nd and 3rd with no outs. Atlanta brought in Alejandro Pena for Avery after that play, but Ryan Theriot scored on Matt Holliday’s sac fly to give the Cardinals their first lead of the series, 3–2. St. Louis added a single run for the third straight inning on Skip Schumaker’s RBI double off Greg McMichael in the 7th.</p><p>Avery pitched decently, but not great. Jaime Garcia went seven strong innings for the Cardinals, and Fernando Salas and Jason Motte closed it out. Atlanta got the tying run to the plate in the 9th, but Klesko struck out and Lopez grounded out to end it. The hard-to-kill Cardinals live for another day, but Smoltz is looming with the Cardinals unsure of their pitching plans for Game 4 since Lance Lynn and Edwin Jackson both had to be used in relief earlier in the series when Lohse had a poor Game 1.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-1 1998 Yankees (Orlando Hernandez) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Milt Wilcox), Tigers lead series 2–0</em></p><p>The Yankees had reason to feel confident in the pitching matchup since Wilcox struggled against the Angels in his one tournament start. They would strike first on Scott Brosius’ RBI double in the top of the 2nd.</p><p>Kirk Gibson homered off “El Duque” after Whitaker led off the 3rd inning with a walk. The Tigers went ahead, 2–1. Tino Martinez tied it with a solo shot in the 4th, then Paul O’Neill would single in Jorge Posada after the Yanks loaded the bases. 3–2, Bombers.</p><p>With one out in the bottom of the 4th, the Tigers did this:</p><p>Ruppert Jones single<br>Johnny Grubb single<br>Chet Lemon single<br>Dave Bergman single<br>Lou Whitaker single</p><p>Death by a thousand paper cuts. That rally produced three runs for the Tigers and a 5–3 lead. It could have been worse, but Hernandez rebounded to strike out Trammell and Gibson.</p><p>Derek Jeter doubled in Chuck Knoblauch with two outs in the 6th, but then O’Neill’s fly out ended the inning with the score 5–4.</p><p>Most teams that win the World Series and advance in this tournament of champions have a strong bullpen that can shut the game down. It’s helped underdog teams like the Cardinals and Blue Jays advance. The Tigers obviously had a great reliever corps, led by the Cy Young and A.L. MVP Willie Hernandez, a pitcher who looked like Richard Pryor and was <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/h/hernawi01.shtml">mainly a middle reliever prior to 1984 when he became unhittable.</a></p><p>With Hernandez rested because he wasn’t needed in the lopsided Game 2 followed by a day off, and with the Tigers holding a one-run lead with a chance to end the series, and with the Yankees lineup flipping back to the top in the 8th inning, Hernandez was brought in for a 2-inning save. It wasn’t anything new for him; Hernandez pitched 140.1 innings in 80 appearances in 1984.</p><p>Chuck Knoblauch was hit by a pitch with one out, but Jeter flied out and O’Neill struck out. In the 9th, Bernie Williams led off with a single. Chili Davis struck out. Martinez didn’t make good contact, and Hernandez got off the mound to field the ball and throw him out at first. Williams advanced to second with the tying run, but with two outs. Posada grounded out to Whitaker.</p><p>The 114-win Yankees just got swept out of the Division Series, though by the 104-win Tigers. I explained in the previous chapter that the Yankees-Tigers matchup maybe happened a round too early because of the Jack Morris Rule, where we’re trying to keep teams who have the same player apart from each other as long as possible. If Jack Morris himself wasn’t on the 1992 Blue Jays, or if the Blue Jays had lost to the Red Sox, we might have had different matchups and maybe Yankees-Tigers wouldn’t have happened until the 7-game ALCS. So what, though? The Tigers pummeled them. If it had been a 7-game series, it would have been Tigers in 4 or 5. In this tournament, you’ll have to beat at least four other championship teams to win it, so the order of those teams doesn’t matter very much. The Yankees can’t have any complaints.</p><p>Now, if Toronto beats Houston and we have Jack Morris on both teams in the ALCS, what will we do? Not sure yet. Let’s see if it happens first.</p><p><strong>Day 17</strong> (3 games)</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-4 2017 Astros (Charlie Morton) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>There were some oddities in this game, and one happened in the 3rd inning when both teams had their 9th-hitters (Brian McCann/Manny Lee) lead off and reach base, then score when the 3rd-hitters (Jose Altuve/Joe Carter) ground into a double play. After those matching runs, the Blue Jays led 2–1.</p><p>Jimmy Key has been the best pitcher of the tournament so far. He’s 3–0 with a 0.40 ERA, with all three starts coming on the road and two of those at Fenway Park against the 108-win Red Sox in the previous round. This was his first start at home, and it was fine but not dominant. George Springer hit a 2-run homer in the 5th to put the Astros ahead, 3–2. Key went 6 and allowed the 3 runs, a so-called “quality start”, but not many guys can keep up that level of excellence against all these championship teams.</p><p>The next oddity, which turned out be a big one, occurred in the 8th when Yuli Gurriel seemingly scored on a sacrifice fly but was called out on an appeal play for leaving the base too soon. That would have been a very big insurance run for Houston.</p><p>Ken Giles came in to pitch the 9th with the 3–2 lead. Giles is the most inconsistent closer in this tournament, but he hasn’t had any disasters yet. In real life, he was dreadful in the 2017 World Series and was only used 2 times. He did not get the honor of pitching the final inning of the deciding game as closers often do (but not always, as Chris Sale got the final outs the next year for the Red Sox instead of shaky Craig Kimbrel), even though that game was not in doubt.</p><p>Giles pitched to 5 batters here. He got one out. Carter led off with a single. Dave Winfield walked. John Olerud struck out. Candy Maldonado walked to load the bases. Kelly Gruber singled to score two, and the Blue Jays went from losing on the last pitch of the game to winning, 4–3. They are one win away from advancing.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Joe Blanton), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>Remember how Phillie fans were worried about being down 1–0 in the series and looking at facing Cain and Bumgarner in the next two games? They won the Cain game, and here they scored 4 runs off MadBum in the first. Jimmy Rollins led off with a triple and scored on a groundout. With two outs and one on, Pat Burrell reached on a seeing-eye single that could have ended the inning. Next batter Shane Victorino followed with a three-run homer. It was reminiscent of <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/PHI/PHI200810020.shtml">Victorino’s grand slam in the 2008 Division Series against Milwaukee’s CC Sabathia after pitcher Brett Myers had walked with two outs.</a></p><p>In the top of the 2nd, with two on and two outs, Giants manager Bruce Bochy considered pinch-hitting for Bumgarner but chose not to. He was the greatest hitting pitcher of his day, which isn’t saying a lot, but his 19 career home runs and 65 RBI in 633 at-bats would be a decent season for many position players. Bochy decided to take the slim chances here of getting a run-scoring hit, rather than go into his thin bench for a pinch-hitter and turn this into a bullpen game.</p><p>Bumgarner hit a bouncer back to Joe Blanton for an easy third out, but it kept him in the game. He settled down after the rocky and somewhat-unlucky first, retiring all but two batters he faced in the 2nd through 6th innings.</p><p>The Giants started pecking away at the deficit. Angel Pagan led off the 3rd with a walk. Marco Scutaro singled. After a strikeout of Sandoval, the Giants went Posey RBI single, Pence RBI single, Belt sac fly. 3 runs were in. Brand new game, 4–3 Phillies.</p><p>In the 5th, Charlie Manuel had Scott Eyre warming up in case the Giants got their left-handed bats of Belt, Blanco, and Crawford up. But after Posey singled again to put runners on the corners, Manuel went to Eyre one batter earlier than he would’ve liked, but still felt Eyre had a better chance than Blanton against Hunter Pence.</p><p>Turns out he didn’t. Pence blasted a three-run shot to give the Giants a 6–4 lead. For the second time in three games, the Phillies had blown a 4–0 lead.</p><p>The Phillies’ long relievers struggled all night, and the Giants got two more in the 6th when Pagan doubled in Crawford and later scored on a Chad Durbin wild pitch. Philly got one back on a Rollins RBI double in the 7th which finally knocked Bumgarner out of the game.</p><p>It remained 8–5 going to the 9th. The Giants chose not to use Sergio Romo since the lower end of the Phillies lineup was due up, and the possible need for multiple innings from Romo in Game 4. Santiago Casilla got the first two outs easily but gave up a double to Chris Coste, who pinch-hit for Carlos Ruiz in the 7th and stayed in to catch. The pitcher’s spot was up next, and the only bats left on Philly’s bench were Jenkins or Greg Dobbs, both left-handed hitters who struggle mightily against left-handed pitchers. After Dobbs was announced, the Giants brought in southpaw Javier Lopez, but the Phillies had no counter-move to make.</p><p>“Come on Dobber, one time. Get on base, get Jimmy to the plate,” Larry Andersen might have said on radio. Rollins was in the on-deck circle as the tying run, just a home run shy of the cycle.</p><p>Dobber couldn’t do it one time. He hit a tapper back to the mound for the final out. Two 4–0 leads for the Phillies in the series, two losses.</p><p>Earlier in the day, both teams were unsure of their Game 4 starters. The Giants had to use Barry Zito in relief during Game 1. Brett Myers was suspended for the Phillies. Down 2–1 in the series, they decide it has to be Hamels on three days rest. He was recovered from the liner he took in Game 1 and hadn’t even pitched three full innings in that game, so he should be good to go.</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Edwin Jackson), Braves lead series 2–1</em></p><p>The Cardinals were also in scramble mode to find a starter for Game 4 because for a while it looked like they may not even make it that far. They go with Edwin Jackson for the spot-start since he had the least usage to date. They were hoping to get 3 or 4 innings out of him, then piece the rest of the game together. Kyle Lohse on three days rest would likely be used somewhere.</p><p>Jackson retired the first 9 Braves hitters, even pitching more efficiently than John Smoltz, who had walked three, though it was still scoreless. To get five innings out of Jackson seemed like a pipe dream before the game began, though now it appeared possible.</p><p>Atlanta started getting to Jackson the second time through. Marquis Grissom led off the 4th with a single, then Mark Lemke doubled to make it 2nd and 3rd with no outs. Suddenly, that was it for Jackson. St. Louis brought in lefty Mark Rzepczynski, whose nickname for this tournament should have been “Every Day”. The strategy here was to turn Chipper Jones around to the right-handed batters’ box, then face lefties Fred McGriff, David Justice, and Ryan Klesko.</p><p>Jones walked and McGriff grounded into a double play, but Grissom scored and it was 1–0 Braves. Every Day Mark kept the Braves at bay.</p><p>Unfortunately for the Cards, Smoltz got stronger and even in shaky innings he could get out of them. Albert Pujols ended the 5th with a 5–4–3 double play. With 2nd and 3rd and 1 out in the 6th, Smoltz struck out Molina and got Nick Punto to ground out.</p><p>Bobby Cox saw no need to pull Smoltz for the 9th. Punto walked with one out, but pinch-hitter Jon Jay hit into a game-ending DP.</p><p>The entire Braves offensive output, 1 run on 2 hits and the run scoring on a double play, happened in that 4th inning against hard-luck loser Edwin Jackson. That’s all it took for the Braves to win and move on.</p><p>A tip of the cap to these plucky 2011 Cardinals. Remember, in real life they made the playoffs on the last night of the season, then beat some favored teams in October. They played some of this tournament’s most exciting games and were hard to kill all the way until Maddux, Glavine, and Smoltz could finally finish them.</p><p><strong>Day 18</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 4: AL-4 2017 Astros (Lance McCullers, Jr.) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris), Blue Jays lead series 2–1</em></p><p>OK, a funny thing happened right before this game was played by me: the 2022 Astros won the World Series. Congratulations to them.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FbzsGLPE_zvU%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DbzsGLPE_zvU&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FbzsGLPE_zvU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/a4a77126c1c68f086baece8c5b71229c/href">https://medium.com/media/a4a77126c1c68f086baece8c5b71229c/href</a></iframe><p>This tournament has been great fun, but it’s taken a lot longer to play than I originally thought it would. I thought it might take until September, and that turned out to be a gross underestimation. Now I’ll be happy if it’s done by next spring training.</p><p>As soon as the ’22 Astros got their final out, I had no more taste for the 2017 Astros. I wish I could include the ’22 team somehow without blowing up the American League bracket and starting over.<br><strong><em>(Note: I would later decide I didn’t feel that strongly about it.)</em></strong></p><p>One thing that made the ’22 Astros better than ’17 was Justin Verlander. He was a unanimous Cy Young winner in 2022. He was still very good in 2017, but also allowed 27 home runs that year and pitching him in a good home-run park in Toronto on three days rest didn’t seem optimal, especially after losing the first game to the Blue Jays.</p><p>So, the Astros went with Lance McCullers, the same Lance McCullers who in real life allowed 5 home runs to the Phillies in Game 3 of the 2022 World Series.</p><p>This one was worse. Even though he allowed no Blue Jay homers, he did allow this:</p><p>Devon White triple<br>Roberto Alomar single and stolen base<br>Joe Carter strikeout<br>Dave Winfield single<br>John Olerud walk<br>Candy Maldonado 2-run single</p><p>In came Joe Musgrove, who gave up a 2-run single to Manny Lee and the Blue Jays had a first-inning 5-spot. McCullers: 0.1 IP, 5 runs.</p><p>It was 7–1 Blue Jays in the 5th when the Astros made it a game. Gurriel’s 2-out 2-run single made it 7–4 and brought up the tying run but Josh Reddick lined out to 3rd. Have to wonder what Kyle Tucker would have done.</p><p>It did get a little dicey in the 9th, with it still 7–4. Tom Henke has been a dominant closer so far, but he allowed a single and two walks around a couple of outs. The bases were loaded for Carlos Correa, who was 0 for 4 in the game and 0 for 16 in the series. He flied out to center to end it. <em>Really </em>have to wonder what Jeremy Pena would have done.</p><p>By the way, Verlander pitched the last four innings with no runs allowed. Should have started him. 😞</p><p>After they swept Oakland last round, I thought the Astros might win this whole thing. Now, goodbye. No one will miss them. I never cared terribly much about the trash cans, but another reason the ’22 Astros team was more appealing was the lack of stink on them.</p><p>This sets up our American League Championship Series: 1984 Detroit with Jack Morris vs. 1992 Toronto with Jack Morris.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Ftenor.com%2Fembed%2F15735153&amp;display_name=Tenor&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Ftenor.com%2Fview%2Fcharlie-brown-christmas-charlie-brown-mad-upset-rats-gif-15735153&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.tenor.com%2FPDNNTlWgZ1oAAAAC%2Fcharlie-brown-christmas-charlie-brown.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=tenor" width="600" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/46a290576c27b692c25dab8971c4c62b/href">https://medium.com/media/46a290576c27b692c25dab8971c4c62b/href</a></iframe><p>This is what we were kicking the can to avoid, but now it’s here. I guess we’ll just have to rule that Morris can pitch for both teams but not ever in the same game.</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-5 2012 Giants (Tim Lincecum) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Cole Hamels), Giants lead series 2–1</em></p><p>Tim Lincecum was lousy in 2012, and it came out of nowhere. He had won the Cy Young in ’08 and ’09, then finished in the top ten in 2010 and ’11. Then in 2012, his ERA soared to 5.18. It was his worst year with the Giants.</p><p>They found a role for him right as the postseason started. He was great as a super-reliever who could go multiple innings in the middle of the game. However, that doesn’t do much good for our purposes, since the player cards are based on the regular season, and Lincecum’s card isn’t great.</p><p>But the Giants went with him for the short start here, since they had used Barry Zito in the 10th inning of Game 1. Their hope was Lincecum could eat a few early innings, followed by Zito for 2 or 3, and then to use the bullpen normally after that.</p><p>Bochy makes an interesting call in the 2nd inning with a runner on 2nd and 1 out. He gives Shane Victorino the intentional walk with the lesser offensive threats of Pedro Feliz, Carlos Ruiz, and Cole Hamels to follow.</p><p>Unfortunately for the Giants, Lincecum then walked Feliz to load the bases. They still had the opportunity to get out unscathed considering Ruiz was 2 for 32 in the tournament, but Chooch hit a sacrifice fly to right to give the Phillies a 1–0 lead without recording a hit.</p><p>With the top of the Phillies order due up in the 3rd, Bochy pinch-hit for Lincecum and brought in Zito. Rollins walked, but the inning ended when Chase Utley hit into a double play.</p><p>Hamels, going on the three days rest, kept getting out of tight spots. He got Posey to ground into a 6–4–3 in the first inning with two runners on. Pagan doubled with one out in the 3rd but was stranded there. Posey led off the 4th with a single, and then he was erased on a double play off the bat of Pence, right before Belt doubled.</p><p>In the bottom of the 5th, all hell broke loose. Ruiz doubled for the Phillies’ first hit of the game. That brought up Hamels with one out. Even though Hamels got a base hit in Game 1, that was against the right-handed Ryan Vogelsong. Against the lefty Zito, the Phillies decide their best play is a bunt, and Hamels gets Ruiz to 3rd. Rollins singles to score Ruiz, and he would not have scored had he been on 2nd. The Phillies led 2–0.</p><p>Since Jayson Werth has the ability to crush left-handed pitching, the Giants lifted Zito for George Kontos to face one batter and possibly get out of the inning. Javier Lopez was warming up to face Utley and Ryan Howard if necessary.</p><p>Rollins was a pest on first base. An obvious distraction for any pitcher, as he stole second and then reached 3rd on a wild pitch. That led to Werth going deep for his 4th home run of the tournament, and a 4–0 lead for the Phillies for the third time in the series.</p><p>They would not blow it this time. In fact, they sent Citizens Bank Park into bedlam when Utley and Howard both homered off Lopez for the first instance of back-to-back-to-back home runs in the tournament.</p><p>Victorino homered in the 6th, and Howard hit his second of the game in the 7th. Hamels went 6 innings in the 8–2 win. J.A. Happ got the three-inning save to give the overused Phillies bullpen the night off and set them up to work overtime if necessary in Game 5.</p><p>It would be necessary.</p><p><strong>Day 19</strong></p><p>Idle, no games. The Phillies and Giants are traveling back across the country. The other three LCS spots are decided.</p><p><strong>Day 20</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 5: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Jamie Moyer) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain), Series tied 2–2</em></p><p>Posey doubled and scored on a Belt single in the bottom of the 2nd. Those were the only two hits Moyer allowed in six innings.</p><p>Werth led off the 4th with a single. Utley then flied out to the wall in right. “In Citizens Bank Park, that’s a home run,” Scott Franzke might have said on the air. “Ryan’s just gonna have to hit one into the Cove, that’s all,” Andersen probably would have said in repsonse.</p><p>Then Howard did, crushing a no-doubter for his tournament-best 5th home run and a 2–1 lead for the Phillies.</p><p>It was still 2–1 at the 7th-inning stretch, with Posey and Pence due up. Two guys who are dangerous against left-handed pitching, so the Phillies decided that was a job well done by Moyer and brought in Ryan Madson. The intention was two innings from Madson and one from Lidge. Madson pitched a clean 7th, striking out Posey and Belt.</p><p>With 7–8–9 due up for the Giants in the 8th, the Phillies had to feel good. It was looking like the game would come down to Lidge vs. Posey again in the 9th.</p><p>The 7th spot in the lineup was occupied by Xavier Nady, because Gregor Blanco left the game after being hit by a pitch in the 5th. Aubrey Huff was chosen to pinch-hit for Nady, and had a 16.7 percent chance of walking against a right-handed pitcher. If the Phillies had gone to J.C. Romero here, the Giants would have countered with a right-handed bat so they stuck with Madson. The only lefty bat Romero would have faced in this inning was Brandon Crawford, who is currently on deck.</p><p>Madson walked Huff. Ryan Theriot pinch-ran, reducing the Giants’ bench to just two position players left.</p><p>Crawford up next. And the dice then produced a very rare reading: triple 1s. A white 1, and two red 1s. A 1–2.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*uju-0bTcBBO8bPPj.jpeg" /></figure><p>Hit by the pitch. The Giants have runners on first and second with no outs.</p><p>Cain’s spot is up next. Entering the inning, it was thought to be automatic that Cain would have to be pinch-hit for, but 1st and 2nd with no outs in a one-run game changes things. He had a great game on the mound, only having the one blemish in the 4th that right now was the difference in the ballgame.</p><p>Cain was sent up to bunt the runners over. It was a risky move, surrendering one of the six outs you have left for the chance to put the go-ahead run in scoring position. The dice were rolled and the result was 1 AND 2, meaning a ball and two strikes and giving the offensive team the option to take the bunt off. Another reading of 1 AND 2 would mean a bunted foul for a third strike.</p><p>The Giants left the bunt on, and the next roll showed SPEED, which is also rare to get and it meant the bunt is great so the batter has a chance to beat it out! Which Cain does. The bases are loaded with nobody out.</p><p>The bunt single also triggered Madson’s fatigue rating, leaving him extra vulnerable to a 2-run single, so Lidge has to come in now. It’s another near-impossible save situation, but if anyone can pull it off it’s either 2008 Lidge or Mariano Rivera anytime.</p><p>Angel Pagan is the next hitter. The Phillies decide they would take a tie here if they could get two outs, so they play the infield back because giving up a bloop hit would be disastrous. And it works. Pagan grounds into a 6–4–3. Theriot does score and the game is tied 2–2. Scutaro flies out to end the inning.</p><p>Cain struck out Werth to start the 9th, then Romo came in and retired Utley and Howard. Lidge allowed a single to Sandoval to lead off the bottom of the 9th. Joaquin Arias pinch-ran for Sandoval, leaving the Giants with one non-pitcher on the bench, but that move proved to be a waste when Posey grounded into a double play. Pence walked and stole second, so Belt was intentionally walked with Theriot coming up. He grounded out to 3rd to send the game to extra innings. It’s the Giants’ fourth extra-inning game of the tournament.</p><p>Romo pitched a clean 10th. The Phillies left Lidge in to pitch a 3rd inning, just like Rivera in Game 7 of the 2003 ALCS. Lidge struck out the side. The second of those batters was Madison Bumgarner pinch-hitting for Romo.</p><p>Chad Durbin pitched the 11th. After a Scutaro single, Arias grounded into the Giants’ third double play in 4 innings. Posey then crushed one to deep left that sounded like a series-ending walk-off home run, but the park held it and Pat Burrell caught it at the wall. It would have been out of CBP, but here all it meant was we were going 12.</p><p>Santiago Casilla pitched the 11th and 12th for the Giants and only allowed a mere 1-out single to Utley in the 12th. Howard then struck out, and Burrell flied to center. J.C. Romero walked Theriot with two outs in the bottom half, and Theriot stole second but Crawford flied out to left.</p><p>We were now in the longest game of the tournament. One other had gone 12 innings — Game 2 of the Cardinals-Nationals Qualifying Round series.</p><p>The last available Giants’ position player, Hector Sanchez, led off the bottom of the 13th as a pinch-hitter. In Game 1, Sanchez hit the fly ball down the right-field line that Geoff Jenkins mishandled to allow the winning run to score. Here, Romero struck him out. Pagan also struck out. Scutaro singled, then Arias singled and Scutaro reached third.</p><p>The Phillies brought in Clay Condrey to intentionally walk Posey, and then face Pence in a righty-righty matchup with bases loaded and 2 outs. Pence grounded out to third.</p><p>Left-hander Jeremy Affeldt started the top of the 14th. Eric Bruntlett and Jimmy Rollins grounded out. Rollins was now 0 for 6, a major reason why the Phillies offense struggled all night. The next batter was Jayson Werth, and Bruce Bochy didn’t want Werth facing a lefty. He brought in his Game 1 starter, Ryan Vogelsong, likely only for one batter with Utley and Howard looming. Jose Mijares was available to face those guys if need be.</p><p>Werth grounded out to short. The Phillies were retired in order for the fifth time in six innings.</p><p>Ryan Theriot hit a double off Condrey with 1 out. Crawford was up next. If there had been 2 outs, he certainly would have been intentionally walked because the Giants had no more pinch-hitters and had also used their best hitting pitcher in Bumgarner.</p><p>The Phillies had another card to play. Their ace.</p><p><strong><em>It’s Game 5 of the National League Division Series in San Francisco. We’re in the bottom of the 14th inning, and Cole Hamels is coming in to pitch for the Phillies…</em></strong></p><p>Because Hamels left Game 1 early with an injury, he had only thrown 8.2 innings in the series. That injury wasn’t to his left arm. His arm was fine. Sure, he went 6 innings just two days ago in Game 4. All the Phillies wanted was two outs. Get two outs, and be removed for a pinch-hitter in the top of the 15th with the pitcher’s spot due up third. That’s all. Give them your best 2001 Randy Johnson. This is an if-not-now-when situation.</p><p>Hamels started out ineffective. Crawford walked. First and second, 1 out.</p><p>Pitcher’s spot up next, and the Giants have no more pinch-hitters. Ryan Vogelsong is normally a starter, so he does know how to use the bat but not well. It appears the Giants’ best chance to get anything valuable out of this plate appearance is to bunt. That could get the winning run to 3rd with 2 outs presumably, and anything can happen from there. Pagan would be batting.</p><p>The Phillies were playing for the bunt. You would imagine if Vogelsong squared around on the first pitch or two of the at-bat, the Phillies wouldn’t expect anything else.</p><p>In the 2012 NLCS, the Giants had two unexpectedly fortunate outcomes on bunt plays by their pitchers. Barry Zito got an RBI on a 2-out bunt down the third-base line that he beat out in Game 5, likely similar to Cain’s bunt single in this game. Then in Game 6, <a href="https://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/big-league-stew/contact-ryan-vogelsong-slashes-burns-cards-bat-arm-102616553--mlb.html">Vogelsong executed the rarely-seen “butcher-boy” play</a>, where the batter squares to bunt and then pulls the bat back and swings away. The result was an error by the shortstop, but Vogelsong got an RBI when a runner on third took off on contact and scored.</p><p>I’m pretty sure I edited highlights for both of those games at MLB Network. I know I did the Zito one. Maybe that’s why I confused the two and thought Zito had done the butcher-boy when I was shaking the dice in my hand, said “Butcher-boy, he’s swinging” for Vogelsong, and threw the dice.</p><p>It came up 3–7. The one spot on the pitcher’s batting card where the ball bloops over a drawn-in infield.</p><p>“NOOO!!” Larry Andersen probably would have screamed into his mic.</p><p>Runners advance two bases.</p><p>Theriot scores. RBI single for Vogelsong. Giants 3, Phillies 2, 14 innings. Giants win series 3–2.</p><p>I was so stunned I wrote down the wrong score:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*_Fl3GUrJsc7jhAZ-.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Giants won Game 1 on a dropped fly ball by an okay outfielder who just entered the game and tripped on the bullpen mound. They won Game 5 on a butcher-boy by a starting pitcher who had to come in for emergency relief in the 14th inning with no pinch-hitters available, against another starting pitcher who had to come in for emergency relief.</p><p>Ryan Vogelsong batted twice against Cole Hamels in the series. The first one was a line drive that unfortunately forced Hamels from the game and probably cost the Phillies a win, the second was a butcher-boy walk-off RBI single. In real life, Vogelsong batted .093 in 2012 with no RBI.</p><p>Would all these crazy endings really happen? Well, sure, I mean they could. Crazy is built into baseball, I guess even in board games and tournaments that only exist within the walls of our house here. Outfielders trip over bullpen mounds, butcher-boys have happened, game-ending balks have happened. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gw7XqUly9ic">Hits by pitchers to win games in extra innings have happened, but they probably won’t anymore.</a> Game 3 of the 2013 World Series ended on an obstruction call at third base…</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FdOlihOEDXgE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DdOlihOEDXgE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FdOlihOEDXgE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/99caf3e54371b5b0e9b4e011aae5cac1/href">https://medium.com/media/99caf3e54371b5b0e9b4e011aae5cac1/href</a></iframe><p>…and Game 4 ended on a pick-off.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FeQnHJwIabBU%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DeQnHJwIabBU&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FeQnHJwIabBU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/86d19cb699e9afd481d50e59ec642f3e/href">https://medium.com/media/86d19cb699e9afd481d50e59ec642f3e/href</a></iframe><p>Even though the Phillies have lost here on bloopers and comedy plays, I have to say they did play valiantly and I’ll be sorry to see them go. Now it seems silly that I debated for quite a while on whether to use the 2008 Phillies or the 1980 Phillies (there are many similarities: Howard-Mike Schmidt, Utley-Pete Rose, Hamels-Steve Carlton, Lidge-Tug McGraw, Ruiz-Bob Boone, Burrell-Greg Luzinski, Victorino-Garry Maddox).</p><p>They were the tournament’s Most Interesting Team since Day 1. Maybe the Giants will take that title from them in the NLCS, but this is why I said you could skim the other games and just read about the Phillies. Their 12 games in this tournament could be its own volume.</p><p>Jimmy Rollins was dynamic until this game when he went 0 for 6 at the worst time. The Phillies only scored in one of the 14 innings when Howard hit the 2-run homer into McCovey Cove in the 4th.</p><p>The Giants have played their maximum of 10 games, defeating the Dodgers and Phillies in 5. They allowed 14 runs and 23 hits in Game 3 against the Dodgers to fall behind 2–1, then won Game 4 in extra innings and scored 5 runs in the 7th inning on the road in Game 5 of that series (see <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">Part III</a>).</p><p>In this series, they won two extra-inning games at home and came back from a 4–0 deficit in Game 3 on the road. They also blew a save in Game 2 and allowed 5 home runs in Game 4. They have six wins and four losses, and are moving on to face the Braves, who are 6–1. Madison Bumgarner will oppose Greg Maddux in Game 1 in Atlanta.</p><p>One final note about wild coincidences that happen in baseball. The two craziest endings of the tournament were the Vogelsong butcher-boy and Roger McDowell’s 10th-inning balk with a runner on third in the Cardinals-Mets Round of 16 series.</p><p>Ryan Theriot scored the winning run both times.</p><p><strong>CHAPTER SIX: THE FINAL FOUR — LEAGUE CHAMPIONSHIP SERIES<br>(Original publish date: December 21, 2022)</strong></p><p>We have reached the final four of the Modern Champions Tournament, after starting with 22 World Series championship teams since 1980. Like most NCAA basketball tournaments and NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs, we have some matchups and seed combinations that were totally unforeseen when the event started.</p><p>It’s the 3 and 9 seeds in the American League: the 1984 Tigers vs. the 1992 Blue Jays. The National League has 3 against 5: the 1995 Braves vs. the 2012 Giants.</p><p>Here we go with the ALCS and NLCS, and like in real life the series length will increase to 7 games. We will soon know the matchup for the Grand World Series, and the end is finally in sight after many months of playing a few innings at a time whenever I get the chance.</p><p><strong>Day 21 (</strong>1 game<strong>)</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Juan Berenguer)</em></p><p>The Tigers make the interesting decision to stay on their pitching rotation with Berenguer, opting to use Jack Morris in Game 2 and Dan Petry in Game 3. Since the Tigers swept the 1998 Yankees in 3 games, Berenguer hasn’t pitched in 10 days, when he won the clinching game of the Round of 16 against the 2002 Angels. He would have to pitch one of the first 4 games of this ALCS anyway, and Detroit figured it was best to use him now, rather than in a later game with possibly more pressure and up to 2 weeks rest by that point.</p><p>Since Jack Morris is on both teams, the first time there has been a duplicate player in any series, the Tournament Executive Committee (me) declared the following:</p><p>(a) Morris cannot pitch for both teams in the same game<br>(b) prior to the start of the series, both teams must declare which 2 games Morris will be eligible for them to use. The higher-seeded Tigers had first choice, and picked Games 2 and 6. The Blue Jays picked 4 and 7, with the possibility of Morris pitching in relief or a short-rest start in Game 7. The Tigers also held the right to use Morris on three days rest for Game 5.</p><p>So, that meant Juan Berenguer was up, and the guy was not a bad pitcher. He would later go on to be an effective middle-reliever for the Twins and was part of their World Series winning team in 1987. He had a career ERA of 3.90 and a 67–62 record. He did more good than harm for his teams. He won a career-high 11 games in 1984.</p><p>Berenguer got out of a first-inning jam by striking out Joe Carter and getting Dave Winfield to ground into a double play. Then in the top of the 2nd, he had a chance for another escape when he struck out Manny Lee with bases loaded and 1 out. Next batter Devon White drew the third walk of the inning to forced in a run, which some in the Tiger Stadium crowd booed. 1–0, Toronto. Berenguer also allowed a career-high 79 walks in 1984.</p><p>Roberto Alomar then grounded to short for a would-be third out, but it was booted by the normally solid Alan Trammell. Another run scored, unearned. 2–0, Toronto. Bases still loaded. Slightly louder boos.</p><p>With Carter up, Berenguer then threw a wild pitch. 3–0, Toronto. Significant boos. Two runners still on.</p><p>Carter has been one of the tournament’s best players. He delivered the clutch hit at Fenway Park for the deciding run in the deciding game of that Round of 16 series. He started the rally in the bottom of the 9th of Game 3 in the Division Series against the 2017 Astros, leading to a comeback win which turned that series in the Blue Jays’ favor. And here, he blasted a 3-run home run to give Toronto a 6-run inning, pump the volume of the boos <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KOO5S4vxi0o">up to 11</a>, and send Berenguer to an early shower. Welp, that didn’t work.</p><p>6 runs in the 2nd inning, 5 unearned. Welcome to the American League Championship Series.</p><p>Pat Borders led off the 4th with a home run, and later Carter doubled in Alomar for his 4th RBI. In the next inning, a second surprising error by Trammell brought in Candy Maldonado, who had tripled, for another unearned run. Trammell had an uncharacteristically miserable game with his two errors in the field and three strikeouts at the plate.</p><p>Even in garbage time, the Blue Jays unbelievably got <em>four</em> more unearned runs after a 2-out error by pitcher Aurelio Lopez and subsequent hits.</p><p>The Tigers were coming off a thorough beating of the tournament’s top-seeded ’98 Yankees, but that meant nothing in this 13–1 drubbing on their home field in the tournament’s most lopsided game. <em>Ten</em> of the Blue Jays’ runs were unearned, and I’ve never seen that in my life.</p><p><strong>Day 22</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Jack Morris), Blue Jays lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Maybe you thought the next game would be the opener of Giants-Braves, but we’re playing the games in order of the “TV Schedule”, imagining the tournament is shown on MLB’s national broadcast carriers. We’re basically simulating a typical LCS structure, so we have two games on this day starting with Detroit at a probable 4:30 P.M. Eastern start, followed by Game 1 of the NLCS in Atlanta around 8:00 P.M.</p><p>Jimmy Key has been the tournament’s best pitcher to date, especially on the road where he is 3–0 with only two runs allowed. Until he gave up 4 in the 2nd inning of this one.</p><p>The stunning hit was a 3-run homer by 9th-place hitter Marty Castillo, a player whose existence I completely forgot about until it was time to look up the Tigers roster before their first tournament game. He was a backup catcher who could also play third base, and started against some left-handed pitchers. He came up with two on and two out and a run in, the Blue Jays thinking they would be getting out of the inning just down one. But Castillo went deep, and suddenly it felt like yesterday’s blowout was just a blip for the Tigers and the series would turn back around.</p><p>Carter hit a solo home run in the 4th to make it 4–1. The Blue Jays were far from beaten.</p><p>With one out and one on in the 5th, Pat Borders reached on an error by Morris. It’s ironic the ’84 Tigers were having fielding problems by pitchers, considering the next Tigers team to make the World Series in 2006 had <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/sports/2006/10/28/the-errors-of-their-ways-span-classbankheadtigers-undone-by-pitchers-miscuesspan/3fa88457-c909-48a2-b518-53ba8c08cd1c/">famously bad pitcher fielding</a> in that Series loss.</p><p>Manny Lee followed the error with an RBI single, so the Blue Jays were within two and had the tying runs on base. Devon White singled in Borders to make it 4–3. Alomar’s would-be-third-out sacrifice fly brought in Lee to tie the game with another unearned run, the 7–8–9 hitters for Toronto all scoring the runs in the inning.</p><p>Castillo led off the bottom of the 8th with a single for his third hit of the game. Lou Whitaker lined out. Key was removed for Duane Ward, and Detroit countered by bringing in Howard Johnson to pinch-run for Castillo. Johnson was a fast runner and Ward struggled to hold runners, but Johnson couldn’t get a good lead. Trammell then hit into a 4–6–3 double play to end the inning.</p><p>Willie Hernandez pitched a perfect 9th inning and retired the first two batters of the 10th. This was the sixth appearance of the tournament for the 1984 American League Cy Young and MVP; the previous five were all scoreless.</p><p>With two outs, Roberto Alomar came up and lifted a fly that carried deep to right and landed in the seats. Blue Jays lead, 5–4. From yesterday’s thundering boos with Berenguer walking the ballpark and Trammell’s poor fielding to today’s stunned silence except for the celebrating in the Blue Jays dugout.</p><p>Tom Henke got the save, ending it with Darrell Evans hitting into a 4–6–3 double play (of course the ball was hit to Alomar, maybe the greatest defensive second baseman of all-time), and the Blue Jays had themselves a what-just-happened, 10-inning, 5–4 win and a 2–0 lead in the ALCS against a team that had cruised through the last two rounds.</p><p>Some sport, eh?</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux)</em></p><p>The Giants were less than 48 hours removed from their incredibly dramatic, 14-inning, butcher-boy walk-off in Game 5 of the Division Series against the Phillies. Would the start of the NLCS be a let-down, or do they keep the momentum rolling?</p><p>Greg Maddux is normally not good for keeping your momentum rolling, except he walked Buster Posey and Hunter Pence to start the 2nd inning. Brandon Belt’s single loaded the bases. That brought up Ryan Theriot, who was starting because Gregor Blanco was injured when he was hit by a pitch in the Giants’ last game. Theriot has been a good role player throughout the tournament for the 2011 Cardinals and the 2012 Giants, and he’s made some big contributions in major moments.</p><p>Theriot singles to bring home 2 runs and advance Belt to third base, and then Belt would score on Brandon Crawford’s sacrifice fly. An early and surprising 3–0 lead for the Giants. They make it 4–0 next inning on a Posey RBI single.</p><p>It’s 4–1 in the bottom of the 6th when Fred McGriff and David Justice start the frame with singles. After Ryan Klesko strikes out, Bobby Cox starts making some moves.</p><p>The batter due up is Charlie O’Brien, who was the catcher for Maddux. Atlanta’s regular and offensively-much-better catcher, Javy Lopez, very rarely caught when Maddux was pitching. The role of a “personal catcher” seems to be a lot less prevalent now than in the 90s and early 2000s, but during Maddux’s tenure with the Braves, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2002/10/05/sports/baseball-if-maddux-is-pitching-lopez-isn-t-catching.html">his personal catcher seemed to be Anybody But Lopez.</a></p><p>Down 4–1 here, with two runners on and Madison Bumgarner starting to tire, Cox could figure both O’Brien <em>and</em> Maddux would be pinch-hit for in this inning. He sends up Lopez for O’Brien, and Bumgarner walks him to load the bases. Giants’ manager Bruce Bochy then lifts MadBum for George Kontos.</p><p>Jeff Blauser pinch-hits for light-hitting shortstop Rafael Belliard, and doubles to score two runs. The slow Lopez has to hold at third. Second and third, 1 out, for the Braves. It’s a 4–3 game, and the Braves have to feel they will tie or take the lead here.</p><p>Maddux’s spot is next, and he’s removed for Mike Mordecai. If the Braves can get these runners home, Maddux would still be in line for the win despite this being his shortest outing of the tournament.</p><p>With the Giants playing the corner infielders in, Mordecai sharply lines out to Pablo Sandoval at third. Sandoval is able to beat the retreating Lopez to third base, doubling him off and ending the inning. The Giants maintain their one-run lead thanks to that stunning play.</p><p>Sandoval’s heroics continue in the top of the 8th when he hits a solo home run off Alejandro Pena. 5–3, Giants.</p><p>The insurance run was big because Atlanta did score in the bottom of the 9th when McGriff singled in Marquis Grissom with two outs. However, Justice grounded to second for the final out. The Giants hold on to take Game 1, 5–4. Banking a win over Greg Maddux feels like an early huge step forward.</p><p><strong><em>(Note: I completely forgot Javy Lopez was supposed to be injured for this game. In the clinching game of the Braves’ Division Series win, Lopez was injured for the next 2 games; I even remember thinking at the time “well, it’s more like one game because Maddux will pitch one of those two.” I had played five other tournament games and written a very long Part IV of this since the last Braves game, so I didn’t remember. To fix this, I decided Lopez would obviously miss Game 2 and then he would be scratched for the next game Maddux starts, which will probably be Game 5. In the unlikely event the Braves get swept and Lopez only misses one game, then the mistake I made won’t have given them any advantage.</em></strong></p><p><strong><em>We can pretend that Lopez has one of those nagging “day-to-day” injuries, which is common enough in baseball.)</em></strong></p><p><strong>Day 23</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-5 2012 Giants (Ryan Vogelsong) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Giants lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Welcome back, Ryan Vogelsong! He was the hero in Game 5 of the NLDS with his “butcher-boy” RBI bloop single in the bottom of the 14th. The two reasons Vogelsong was even batting to begin with were that he came on to get the final out in the top of the 14th and the Giants were out of pinch-hitters.</p><p>That base hit was greater than anything Vogelsong had done in the tournament at his real job of pitching. In two starts, he had given up 9 runs in 8.1 innings. He was particularly hit hard by the 1988 Dodgers in the Round of 16.</p><p>The Braves made contact against Vogelsong all night. They did not strike out even once against him, but unfortunately for the Braves most of their batted balls ended up in Giant gloves.</p><p>The Giants took a 1–0 lead in the top of the 2nd on a pair of singles and a Gregor Blanco sacrifice fly, and that score held up into the bottom of the 7th. David Justice drew a 2-out walk, and with power-hitting left-handed batter Ryan Klesko up next, Bruce Bochy lifted Vogelsong for lefty Jose Mijares. Klesko hit one high and deep to right, but it died at the warning track for the third out of the inning.</p><p>Vogelsong’s only hit allowed was a harmless single by Eddie Perez leading off the 3rd inning. Perez would be stranded on second base, and ended up being the only Brave to reach scoring position all game. Vogelsong was brilliant, and he’s had quite the week. It was just three days ago that he had the butcher-boy hit.</p><p>The Giants scored single runs in the 8th and 9th. The 8th-inning run was unearned since Blanco reached on an error by Tom Glavine (as pitcher errors have now become a tournament trend), and later scored on a Angel Pagan sac fly. Pablo Sandoval led off the 9th with a home run, and the final score was 3–0. The Giants take Games 1 and 2 in Atlanta by beating Greg Maddux and Tom Glavine, just like anyone would have obviously predicted.</p><p>Four Giants pitchers combined to 1-hit the Braves.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FY9myYc8Pn8o%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DY9myYc8Pn8o&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FY9myYc8Pn8o%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/3d3db3d437154ed546acc66a5a6379be/href">https://medium.com/media/3d3db3d437154ed546acc66a5a6379be/href</a></iframe><p>Blue Jays lead Tigers 2–0. Giants lead Braves 2–0. Every time I think I have a favored team in this tournament, they immediately cease to do anything right.</p><p>Four League Championship Series games, four wins by the road teams. Major League Baseball expanded the LCS round from 5 games to 7 in 1985. How many years has the road teams won the first two games in both series since then? Let’s find out.</p><p><em>:::looking:::</em></p><p><em>:::seeing a lot of years where road teams won 3 games, but not 4:::</em></p><p><em>:::still looking:::</em></p><p>Zero. Zero times.</p><p>This tournament is incredible. The results these dice and cards produce amaze me.</p><p><strong>Day 24</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Dan Petry) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Juan Guzman), Blue Jays lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Here’s the game the Tigers badly need, and they get off to a good start by scoring a run three batters in.</p><p>Things change on the 4th batter of the game. Lance Parrish rolled the injury number on his card, and the second roll to determine the severity came up as a 2-game injury. It’s essentially a three-game injury since he got hurt in the first inning here. The series would have to return to Detroit before Parrish can get back on the field.</p><p>It feels like a crippling loss for the Tigers, even though Parrish was struggling offensively in the tournament. He was 3 for 33 with a home run and 13 strikeouts, but you never want to lose a cleanup hitter with pop, and his absence would come into play later in this game.</p><p>Dan Petry has been great in his first two tournament starts, and he retired the Jays in order in the 1st. Dave Winfield led off the 2nd with a double. John Olerud singled to put runners on the corners. Candy Maldonado singled for his tournament-best 18th RBI to tie the game, and Olerud went first to third. Kelly Gruber singled to score Olerud and advance Maldonado to third as the Blue Jays were treating the basepaths like their own personal merry-go-round.</p><p>The Tigers played at double-play depth with runners on 1st and 3rd with no outs, even with 2 runs already in. Pat Borders grounded into a double play which scored Maldonado. Detroit got out of the inning down 3–1. Not great, but not dead. Long way to go.</p><p>Then the first five batters reached base in the bottom of the 3rd. Petry was yanked after Olerud’s RBI single made it 5–1. A massive disappointment for the Tigers to have one of their top pitchers get bombed in a must-win game.</p><p>Howard Johnson hit a solo home run in the 5th, to which the Blue Jays immediately responded with three more runs in the bottom half. Winfield and Olerud both had RBI doubles, as the middle of the Toronto lineup was just bludgeoning Tigers pitching.</p><p>The Blue Jays were cruising to a dominant 3–0 series lead and an all-but-assured spot in the Grand World Series. Juan Guzman started the 8th, ahead 8–2. Whitaker singled to lead-off, followed by a Trammell double to put runners on 2nd and 3rd. Kirk Gibson was up next, and even though he was having a miserable game at the plate and grounded into an inning-ending double play in the 5th when the game was still close, Cito Gaston decided to walk Gibson intentionally to set up a double-play opportunity.</p><p>The next batter was Marty Castillo, the backup catcher who came in to replace Parrish. Would Gaston have walked Gibson if Parrish was still in the game? Probably not. Despite Castillo’s good performance in Game 2, he was a still a light-hitting reserve that usually just played against left-handed pitchers, and the Tigers could not pinch-hit for him here because there was no other catcher.</p><p>Castillo hit a grounder to Gruber at third, and the Blue Jays went around the horn for the double play. Whitaker scored to make it 8–3, now with two outs in the 8th. Darrell Evans then singled in Trammell and advanced all the way to 3rd on Joe Carter’s third tournament error, which is a lot for a right fielder in 14 games.</p><p>Duane Ward came in to pitch and walked Chet Lemon to bring up Ruppert Jones with two on. Jones hadn’t hit well in the tournament, but he had some power against right-handed pitching and cranked a huge pinch-hit grand slam off David Cone in Game 1 of the Division Series against the 1998 Yankees.</p><p>Jones homered again here, and suddenly we had a one-run game at 8–7. Jones now led the Tigers with 7 RBI in the tournament, all of which came on a grand slam and a 3-run shot. The Tigers scored five runs in the 8th. The only batter not to reach base was Castillo, until Dave Bergman struck out after the Jones blast.</p><p>But whenever the Tigers scored in this game, the Blue Jays quickly countered. Winfield walked with two outs to move Roberto Alomar to second base. With the red-hot Olerud up next, Sparky Anderson brought in his left-handed Cy Young and MVP Willie Hernandez. Welp, that didn’t work again—Olerud singled to score Alomar. Olerud was 4 for 5 with three RBI and making a case for MVP of the series. The Blue Jays led, 9–7.</p><p>After Trammell drew a 2-out walk in the top of the 9th, Gibson bounced one back to closer Tom Henke for the game’s final play. The Blue Jays win a wild one, 9–7, to go up three games to none. They can clinch their spot in the Grand World Series tomorrow.</p><p><strong>Day 25</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 4: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Milt Wilcox) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris), Blue Jays lead series 3–0</em></p><p>With two outs in the bottom of the 1st, Winfield singled to extend the inning and get Olerud to the plate. Olerud doubled in 2 runs. Game over. Series over.</p><p>Well, ok, not really, but it sure felt that way. Trailing 3–0 after a Kelly Gruber home run in the 2nd, the Tigers had two runners on in the 4th and 5th, but hit into inning-ending double plays both times.</p><p>Those double plays had an effect on Sparky Anderson’s strategy in the 7th. Kirk Gibson walked and stole second. Ruppert Jones, batting cleanup with Parrish injured, reached on an Olerud error. With men on first and third, Howard Johnson pinch-ran for Jones. To take the double play out of the question, Johnson attempted to steal but was thrown out. It was the second time in the series that a Johnson pinch-running appearance was a total bust.</p><p>Gibson scored on a 2-out Barbaro Garbey single to make it 3–1, but the Blue Jays immediately answered like they had in Game 3. Roberto Alomar broke the game open with a 2-run single in the bottom of the 7th, followed by a Joe Carter RBI double.</p><p>The final was 6–2. The sweep was complete. The 1992 Toronto Blue Jays are the Modern Champions Tournament American League winners. Please rise for the singing of the Canadian national anthem:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FAbC1_vFgj6k%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DAbC1_vFgj6k&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FAbC1_vFgj6k%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/d6c5a7ebc335ea042bac90088eee161b/href">https://medium.com/media/d6c5a7ebc335ea042bac90088eee161b/href</a></iframe><p>Don’t be fooled by the Blue Jays 9-seed because there were much more gaudy win totals by the A.L. teams in the field. If the Blue Jays had been in the National League, their seed would have been 4. The Jays will have home-field advantage in the Grand World Series if the Giants win the NLCS because Toronto had 96 wins to the Giants’ 94.</p><p>The Braves will have home-field advantage over the Blue Jays should they come back and win the NLCS. The 1995 season was strike-shortened to 144 games; the Braves’ 90 wins gets prorated to 101 in a 162-game schedule.</p><p>The Blue Jays have gone through four rounds of the tournament without ever having home-field advantage. Now they have won six games in a row and have an astounding overall record of 12–3. Only the 2018 Red Sox won 2 games against them, which came in the Round of 16.</p><p>With such a dominant victory, it was difficult to come up with one player to be the MVP of the series. It’s hard to hit .588 and not win the award, but that’s what happened to John Olerud. <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/postseason/1992_ALCS.shtml">Just like real life in 1992</a>, the ALCS Most Valuable Player is Roberto Alomar, who hit .471 with a go-ahead 10th-inning home run in Game 2, plus 8 runs scored, 4 RBI, and his typical excellent defense which started three double plays in Game 2 alone.</p><p>So, the ALCS is over and the NLCS has a maximum of <em>five</em> games left. That’s nuts. The only similarity I can remember is when the 2007 Colorado Rockies swept the NLCS while Boston and Cleveland went the distance in the A.L. The Rockies had eight days off before Game 1 of the World Series. The most the Blue Jays will have here is six days off, but the Tournament Executive Committee (me) will start the Grand World Series earlier if the Giants finish off the Braves quickly.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain), Giants lead series 2–0</em></p><p>It sure looked like the Giants could finish off the Braves quickly when they scored 3 runs in the bottom of the 1st, capped by Brandon Belt’s two-out two-run double when he hit the weakness on John Smoltz’s card. Column 6, number 5.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OwkTVZo2WnMvxqu_fDi90g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Whenever there’s a split result, a roll of the 20-sided die determines the outcome and that’s how Belt got a double. Hunter Pence beat the relay home to score from first.</p><p>A one-out single and two walks loaded the bases for the Braves in the 3rd. David Justice singled in a pair of runs. Ryan Klesko doubled to bring home one more run, but Justice tried to score from first and was nailed at the plate. However, now the game was tied 3–3. Maybe we will have a series.</p><p>John Smoltz the TV analyst has used the term “shutdown inning” countless times, but John Smoltz the pitcher couldn’t get one here. He threw the old 6–5 <em>again, </em>this time with Pence batting and it was <a href="https://www.sfchronicle.com/sports/giants/article/Bye-Bye-Baby-still-proving-soundtrack-for-16480159.php">Bye, Bye Baby</a> (a reference that will be understood by MLB Network highlight producers and anyone who’s a fan of the Giants’ local TV broadcasts).</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fdds-AAl5wbY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Ddds-AAl5wbY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fdds-AAl5wbY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/b7a2c43406a52232524a20b1d06d7f46/href">https://medium.com/media/b7a2c43406a52232524a20b1d06d7f46/href</a></iframe><p>The 2-run home run put the Giants back in front, 5–3.</p><p>Rolling a 5 on the red dice isn’t easy to do. How many times do you throw a 5 in Monopoly? Rarely, of course. Now imagine doing it twice in one game to land on your opponent’s Marvin Gardens with three houses on it both times, when anything over a 6 would have been safe. Now imagine you have to roll a third die simultaneously and get the same number on that. 😧 As I was saying, this tournament amazes me.</p><p>Marquis Grissom led off the 4th with a triple and scored on a sac fly by Fred McGriff. This wild game was already 5–4 in the 4th inning.</p><p>The pitchers finally settle down so the score holds until the 7th. With three left-handed batters due up, the Giants brought in Javier Lopez, but McGriff led off with a double and went to 3rd on a groundout to second by Justice. Mike Devereaux, 5 for 9 in the tournament so far, was called on to pinch-hit for Klesko. Bruce Bochy countered by bringing in right-hander George Kontos. This could have been a spot for Santiago Casilla, except the pitcher’s spot was due to lead-off next inning for the Giants so Bochy figured he would use a pinch-hitter and then bring in Casilla.</p><p>Devereaux doubled to raise his tournament batting average to .600 with 4 RBI, and we had a tie game again. With two outs, Bochy intentionally walked Jeff Blauser to force Bobby Cox to pinch-hit for Smoltz. Mike Mordecai walked to load the bases, but Grissom struck out.</p><p>Casilla came out for his second inning in the top of the 9th. Seems like it wouldn’t be a Giants home game in this tournament if it wasn&#39;t tied or a one-run margin in the 9th.</p><p>Devereaux led off with a single. Javy Lopez flied out, then Blauser grounded out to second but Devereaux was able to advance. The pitcher’s spot was up again for the Braves. Cox had some options, though none of them great. He sent up light-hitting and lightly-used Eddie Perez.</p><p>Perez was the Braves’ third catcher, a rarity not just in this tournament but in most of baseball. The Braves carried three catchers with their unique Maddux/Lopez situation. Any team wants to avoid bringing their backup catcher into a game, out of fear the backup will be injured and you’re stuck without a competent receiver. I saw the consequences of losing both catchers in person in 1987 at Fenway Park when outfielder Mike Greenwell had to catch in the 10th inning because Boston had pinch-hit for both of their catchers while staging a 3-run comeback in the bottom of the 9th. <a href="https://www.upi.com/Archives/1987/07/17/Mike-Greenwell-forced-to-make-his-major-league-catching/9890553492800/">Greenwell had been the DH but he came in to catch in the 10th and it was painful</a> — one throwing error, two stolen bases against, a wild pitch, two walks, 7 runs for the Oakland A’s.</p><p>Almost all teams carry two catchers. The Braves having three gave them extra flexibility. Whenever Maddux pitched a complete game, they had a backup that wasn’t Lopez. When Maddux doesn’t go 9, they can use Lopez as a substitute and still have a backup. And, in this case, you could use Eddie Perez as a pinch-hitter in a non-Maddux game and still have Charlie O’Brien as a backup catcher.</p><p>So, that brought up Perez vs. Casilla. The Giants could have brought in Jeremy Affeldt since Perez can barely hit lefties, but knowing the Braves would make a counter-move, Bochy figured this was the best matchup for them.</p><p>Perez hit one high and deep to left, and out of the ballpark it went. A pinch-hit 2-run home run in the top of the 9th with two outs to give the Braves their first lead of the game at 7–5.</p><p>🤯</p><p>By the way, throughout this series I keep hearing Joe Buck’s voice in my head. You can easily hear him calling the Perez home run here. I’ve always said we are imagining this tournament is broadcast nationally, hence the TV Schedule for the order of the games. I had previously thought the coverage would be by Turner Sports and MLB Network, but let’s say the NLCS and Grand World Series will be on Fox with their classic long-time combination of Buck and Tim McCarver. Fox Sports carried the NLCS in even-numbered years, so Buck called the Giants’ wins in 2010, 2012, and 2014, another reason why it feels like he’s on the call here.</p><p>Pedro Borbon started the 9th since the Giants had three left-handed batters due up. After a 2-out walk to Brandon Crawford, closer Mark Wohlers came in to retire pinch-hitter Hector Sanchez on a lineout to second. The Braves get back in the series by taking Game 3, 7–5.</p><p>After this game, the Committee announces that the Grand World Series will begin in Toronto on Day 30 if the Giants were to win the NLCS in 5. That would be four days off for the Jays. Any other result and the GWS will start on its regularly-scheduled Day 32.</p><p><strong>Day 26</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-3 1995 Braves (Steve Avery) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Barry Zito), Giants lead series 2–1</em></p><p>In a series with Maddux, Glavine, Smoltz, Bumgarner, and Cain, of course it’s Steve Avery and Barry Zito who pitch the first game in this NLCS to be scoreless through a mere <em>two</em> innings.</p><p>However, Atlanta scored the first run of a game for the first time in the series on three straight singles in the top of the 3rd. Chipper Jones knocked in Grissom.</p><p>In the 5th, Mark Lemke drew a 2-out walk to bring up Jones again. The Braves had runners on first and second, and Bochy wanted a right-hander to face Chipper. The Strat-O-Matic app calculated the odds for Jones against all of the Giants’ reasonable choices, and Tim Lincecum was the clear top choice by five percent over the supposed 2nd-best option and ten percent better than Zito’s chances. The app said Lincecum had a 67 percent chance of getting Jones out to end the inning.</p><p>One swing later, it was 4–0 Braves. Chipper 4, Giants nothing. Welp. 🤷‍♂</p><p>Steve Avery, despite going 7–13 in 1995 with a 4.67 ERA, was almost flawless. It was more like his performance in the 1991 NLCS against Pittsburgh when he <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/sports/1991/10/17/braves-avery-olson-force-nlcs-to-limit-1-0/3c5df092-8c8b-4988-8c76-2fb2d2ff05a5/">won Games 2 and 6 on the road, both by 1–0 scores, earning the series MVP award</a>.</p><p>When Marco Scutaro singled with two outs in the 9th and went to second on defensive indifference with Sandoval up, he became the first Giant in scoring position the entire game. Let me say that one more time: the first Giant in scoring position the entire game with two outs in the 9th inning.</p><p>It was a three-hit complete-game shutout for Avery. The series is tied. The Braves are back.</p><p>Here’s the task ahead of the Giants: win two out of three games with Maddux, Glavine, and Smoltz pitching. They have already done it once in this series. They must do it a second time.</p><p><strong>Day 27</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 5: NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner), Series tied 2–2</em></p><p>Shut down completely by Avery the night before, of course the Giants lineup gets straight to work against Greg Maddux. Marco Scutaro doubles and Pablo Sandoval singles him to 3rd, then Buster Posey’s sacrifice fly gives the Giants a 1–0 first-inning advantage.</p><p>Brandon Belt and Gregor Blanco start the 2nd inning with singles to put runners on the corners. Brandon Crawford strikes out to bring up Bumgarner. Attempting a safety squeeze bunt is an option here, but instead Blanco steals second and then MadBum is swinging away with both runners in scoring position. He grounds out but gets a run home for an RBI and a 2–0 lead.</p><p>As I was playing the 4th inning of the game, the Strat-O-Matic app got stuck on this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*oke7xyXs1GdCjbwdxdWtzw.jpeg" /></figure><p>It doesn’t stop “calculating”, and I can’t open up the cards to see them side-by-side. This is a little bit of a problem.</p><p>Earlier in the tournament, the app went down completely for several days. Since I wanted to play and couldn’t, I declared the next outdoor game was “rained out” and adjusted the schedule.</p><p>This is a little different. I can go to another section of the app and find the cards I need; I just can’t see batter versus pitcher side-by-side, and I can’t see what the actual calculated odds are for any matchup. I had used those odds to make quite a bit of managerial decisions, including bringing Lincecum in to face Chipper Jones and give up the three-run homer in the last game. (So, maybe it’s good that feature mysteriously went away.)</p><p>So, is this a rainout? No, because I can still play even though it just takes a little longer to navigate the app. But, we can say it’s raining and have some fun with that, as you’ll see in a few seconds.</p><p>David Justice homered to lead-off the 5th to cut the Giants lead to 2–1. But just when things were looking up for the Braves, Maddux rolled the triple-boxcars, 6–12, for a pitcher injury on the last out of the bottom of the 5th. The second roll then determined the outcome: 1 to 3 means Maddux has to be taken out; if it’s 4 to 6 he can stay in. It was a 3. Maddux was unfortunately out after just 5 innings.</p><p>Greg McMichael started the 6th, perhaps a little early for him but the Giants had 3–4–5 due up. Sandoval walked and Posey doubled to put runners on 2nd and 3rd. Pence then lined out to short. Borbon came in to face the lefties Belt and Blanco. Belt struck out, and Blanco popped out to second. The Giants didn’t score. They still led 2–1.</p><p>Fred McGriff walked to start the 7th, and Justice singled to put men on 1st and 2nd. Ryan Klesko pinch-hit for Mike Devereaux, even though this set up a lefty-lefty matchup but Bobby Cox was going for some pop. What the Braves got instead of pop was a 6–4–3 double play.</p><p>Charlie O’Brien was up next, and Maddux was out of the game but with the Braves unable to use Javy Lopez due to injury, O’Brien lined out to end the inning. Both teams had big chances to score in consecutive half-innings, and both got nothing.</p><p>Marco Scutaro came up with 2 on and 1 out in the bottom of the 7th. The Braves brought in Alejandro Pena to face “The Blockbuster”. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/24/sports/baseball/giants-midseason-trade-for-marco-scutaro-keeps-getting-better.html">That’s the nickname Scutaro had in the 2012 Giants’ clubhouse</a>, as in he was their blockbuster trade in late July, a journeyman second baseman acquired from Colorado for journeyman utility player Charlie Culberson. It was a cute thing to laugh about.</p><p>The Giants also acquired Hunter Pence from the Phillies four days later, but don’t let facts get in the way of a good story.</p><p>Pena was one of the Braves’ more reliable relievers. He came in for Borbon, and Scutaro had a better chance of hitting into a double play and less chance of getting a hit against the right-hander. We don’t know the exact odds, though, since the app went on the fritz.</p><p>Scutaro rolled the one magic number on his card, 3–4, and The Blockbuster went Bye, Bye Baby. Three-run home run, 5–1 Giants.</p><p>Was it raining in San Francisco? Use your imagination, and remember this iconic moment from the real 2012 NLCS when Scutaro was the MVP.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgfycat.com%2Fifr%2Fthirdglaringfrog&amp;display_name=Gfycat&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgfycat.com%2Fthirdglaringfrog&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fthumbs.gfycat.com%2FThirdGlaringFrog-size_restricted.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=gfycat" width="502" height="276" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/99426fd83df8706f1bc8cad6fedefe3b/href">https://medium.com/media/99426fd83df8706f1bc8cad6fedefe3b/href</a></iframe><p>Greg Maddux was rightly a unanimous Cy Young Award winner in 1995, and finished third in the National League MVP vote. His record that season was 19–2.</p><p><em>And two</em>. Two losses. Now he has two losses in this series.</p><p>OK, Maddux went 3–1 in the postseason that year with a loss in Game 5 of the World Series, so he really lost three games but you know how stats work and regular-season numbers being the ones that count. Again, facts and good stories.</p><p><strong>Day 28</strong></p><p>Idle - no games. Travel day. The Blue Jays are still waiting.</p><p><strong>Day 29</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 6: NL-5 2012 Giants (Ryan Vogelsong) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Giants lead series 3–2</em></p><p>The 1995 Atlanta Braves were the team that finally broke through and won it all after three previous postseason attempts. When their longtime core’s run was over, 1995 was still the only championship. Some more disappointing losses followed, with 3 of those eliminations happening in the NLCS at home (1997 vs. Florida, 1998 vs. San Diego, 2001 vs. Arizona). Now the ’95 champions are in danger of the same fate.</p><p>The Braves were counting on Ryan Vogelsong not being as dominant as he was in Game 2. The tension was palpable early on. The Braves got runners on 2nd and 3rd with 1 out in the bottom of the 2nd, but Rafael Belliard struck out and Tom Glavine grounded out.</p><p>Brandon Crawford singled to lead-off the 3rd. Vogelsong came up intending to sacrifice, but incredibly he bunted too well and beat it out for a single. What is it with the good fortune the 2012 Giants have with pitchers bunting, both in real life and in tournament life?</p><p>Angel Pagan then walks, and the bases are loaded with nobody out. Seems like a prime situation for The Blockbuster, but Scutaro pops out to 2nd and Sandoval grounds into a 4–6–3 double play. The Giants had bases loaded and no outs, and ended up with no runs.</p><p>It’s still scoreless in the 5th, with the bottom third of the Giants lineup due. Gregor Blanco singles and steals second. Crawford singles him in. SFG leads, 1–0.</p><p>Jeff Blauser pinch-hits for Belliard to start the bottom of the 5th, and walks. Glavine bunts Blauser to second. Marquis Grissom lines out. Vogelsong is an out away from getting back to the dugout with the lead.</p><p>Mark Lemke draws a walk.</p><p>Chipper Jones draws a walk.</p><p>Fred McGriff. Draws. A. Walk. Run scores. Game is tied.</p><p>That’s the first run Vogelsong has allowed in the series. The inning oddly felt like slow torture and a lightning strike at the same time. From completely in control to out of control. You can picture the atmosphere in Atlanta with the fans doing the tomahawk chop, and the ballpark feeling like it was closing in on Vogelsong. It was time to think about whether to take him out.</p><p>Stepping out of the simulated baseball realm and into the board-game-playing realm, this is where I have to note that all four walks in this inning came off the batters’ cards. In other words, <a href="https://www.baseball-almanac.com/players/pitchinglogs.php?p=gibsobo01&amp;y=1968">Bob Gibson of 1968</a> or <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/e/eckerde01.shtml">Dennis Eckersley of 1989–1991</a> could have been pitching and the walks still would have happened.</p><p>Vogelsong was still a fresh pitcher. He wasn’t tired yet, meaning he wasn’t extra suspectible to allowing a hit. You could say he was “just missing”, or “getting squeezed” by the umpire on these pitches out of the strike zone.</p><p>Two games ago in a similar situation, again with two outs in the 5th, the Giants played the odds and pulled Barry Zito for Tim Lincecum. He gave up a 3-run shot to Chipper Jones.</p><p>Bochy is riding with Vogelsong here against David Justice. The dice are thrown. It comes up 1–6. I don’t even have to look. That’s a grand slam. 5–1, Braves. 5 runs on one hit in the inning.</p><p>Boy, it feels like a lot of pitching decisions I’m making on behalf of these teams aren’t working. 😞</p><p>Again though, it was off a batter’s card. If Justice had faced a left-handed pitcher instead, he was still 75 percent to hit a home run and 25 percent to hit a triple. The Braves still would have taken a big lead.</p><p>That was finally it for Vogelsong. He walked off the mound with the crowd chopping and chanting like crazy. From cruising to losing in no time.</p><p>It reminded me of a Braves’ home playoff game in 2018 against the Dodgers that I edited at MLB Network. There were two outs and a man on when the Braves got a hit and an error to put runners on 2nd and 3rd. An intentional walk loaded the bases with Braves pitcher Sean Newcomb up next. With the stadium getting louder with each pitch, Walker Buehler walked Newcomb to force in a run and then Ronald Acuna Jr. blasted a grand slam.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F_yqlOMW5liU%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D_yqlOMW5liU&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F_yqlOMW5liU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/fca82e070baedb79505e4b24ac52e040/href">https://medium.com/media/fca82e070baedb79505e4b24ac52e040/href</a></iframe><p>Here in Game 6, the Braves only scored in one of their eight offensive innings. It was more than enough. The Giants got one of the runs back in the top of the 6th, but never threatened again. We’re going the distance.</p><p>On top of the loss, the Giants get a terrible break when Santiago Casilla is injured covering first base on the third out of the 8th inning. The severity roll comes up as the dreaded 2, the worst possible outcome. Casilla is out 2 games, meaning the Giants will be without their top set-up reliever in Game 7 and for Game 1 of the Grand World Series should they make it.</p><p>Bruce Bochy was asked afterward if Madison Bumgarner was available tomorrow. The answer was everyone’s available.</p><p><strong>Day 30</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 7: NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain) at NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz), Series tied 3–3</em></p><p>Lemke and Jones singled with one out in the 1st. That brought up Fred McGriff, who hit a grounder to short that Brandon Crawford threw away for a two-base error. Lemke scored to put the Braves up, 1–0.</p><p>David Justice struck out, then Bochy decided to intentionally walk Ryan Klesko to set up a righty-righty matchup of Cain against Javy Lopez. Whether that was a good decision is something we’ll never know because Cain threw a wild pitch to advance the runners. Jones scored to make it 2–0, and runners were on 2nd and 3rd again. Both runs unearned. Now Lopez was intentionally walked and Rafael Belliard tapped one back to the mound to get out of the inning. A terrible start for the Giants, eerily similar to the Tigers in Game 1 of the ALCS, but they’re not dead yet.</p><p>John Smoltz led off the bottom of the 2nd, and he hit a grounder to Crawford for another error. What, does he have the yips?</p><p>This is a shocker, frankly. In my 9 years at the Network, I cut a lot of Giants games and didn’t see many players throughout the whole big leagues that were defensively better than Crawford. He would consistently make the difficult plays. He’s won four Gold Gloves at one of the sport’s most-important defensive positions. He’s made three All-Star teams.</p><p>Pardon me for a little tangent, but here’s how highly I thought of Crawford’s defense. Remember this play in 2014?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FTbI54dTaFT4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DTbI54dTaFT4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FTbI54dTaFT4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/152b351270b425decc21c48ec940f98b/href">https://medium.com/media/152b351270b425decc21c48ec940f98b/href</a></iframe><p>This was The Bumgarner Game, the game that inspired the question if MadBum is available for the Giants in this Game 7. There were 2 outs in the bottom of the 9th, the Giants leading by a run. This play sparked so much debate in and around baseball of whether Royals’ third-base coach Mike Jirschele should have sent Alex Gordon home and forced the Giants to make the potential World Series-ending play at the plate. That debate also took place among the MLB Network edit production staff. It was easy to say they should have sent Gordon since next batter Salvador Perez popped up to end the Series, but my answer was always “No way, Crawford would have thrown him out by a mile.” He made a great pick for the cut-off, too.</p><p>Don’t just take my word for it, though. <a href="https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/12485525/mlb-penultimate-play">Take the word of every person who was on the field or in the dugouts that night.</a> Gordon himself says he would have been out. So did Jirschele, so did Royals manager Ned Yost.</p><p><strong><em>(Note: Yes, I edited this game too. Had to get a 9-minute highlight on the air for our postgame show 20 minutes after the final out. I think it was 20; it felt like that, anyway. The whole thing was kind of a blur.)</em></strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*DUtigZR9jtpRyjZx3EijpA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I know I’m getting off course, so let’s get back to our game here.</p><p>Crawford was due to lead-off the 3rd, but Joaquin Arias pinch-hit and grounded out. That was a tough move to do to a good player who has found a way to get on base in some key moments throughout the tournament, despite an underwhelming batter’s card from his first full big-league season. However, one error is “ok, you’ll get ’em next time”, two errors on two chances in Game 7 is “we don’t time for this”.</p><p>Pagan and Scutaro drew 2-out walks later in the 3rd, but Sandoval popped up to second. Cain kept walking the tightrope and held the Braves to just those two runs through 5 innings, which felt like a survival test.</p><p>Mark Lemke made a diving catch of a Scutaro line drive to lead-off the 6th. Sandoval then homered for the perceived momentum shift. The Giants were within a run. This was the Kung Fu Panda’s third home run of the NLCS, all of them in Atlanta and all in big moments.</p><p>Posey then lined out on <em>another</em> diving catch by Lemke, an unsung hero of the ’95 Braves who was an incredible pest in this series. Pence struck out to end the inning, and the momentum shift was halted.</p><p>Javy Lopez tripled with one out in the bottom of the 6th. The Giants had to tell themselves that if there was ever a good time to give up a triple, it was in front of Belliard and Smoltz with one out. With the infield playing in, Belliard lined a single to left to score Lopez and make it a 3–1 game.</p><p>Brandon Belt singled to lead-off the 7th. Ryan Theriot was up next because Gregor Blanco got hit by a pitch in the 5th and had to be taken out. Theriot grounded into a 6–4–3 double play to kill that potential rally. It was getting late for San Francisco.</p><p>Pagan tripled with one out in the 8th. Another prime situation for Scutaro, but he popped up to short. Smoltz was then replaced after 7.2 solid innings. Alejandro Pena came in to face Sandoval in another clutch spot. Panda grounded out to first, and the Braves were three outs away.</p><p>Madison Bumgarner came in to pitch the bottom of the 8th. Normally this would be the inning for Santiago Casilla, though in this game a healthy Casilla might have been used in the 6th or 7th innings.</p><p>This was not 2014, or even the forgotten <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/PHI/PHI201010230.shtml">Game 6 of the 2010 NLCS when Bumgarner pitched 2 innings in relief against the Phillies</a>. With one out, Mike Mordecai singled as a pinch-hitter for Pena. Grissom hit a fly down the right-field line that Pence couldn’t get to, and then Pence bobbled the ball allowing pinch-runner Luis Polonia to score and Grissom to get to 3rd. This is the 72nd tournament game, and only the second time a team committed three errors. The other was of course the ’84 Tigers.</p><p>4–1, Braves. The Giants appeared defeated, which then was punctuated by Lemke’s 2-run home run. 3 runs allowed for Bumgarner in one-third of an inning. Welp. 🤦‍♂</p><p>Posey homered in the 9th, but it was meaningless. The final was 6–2. The 1995 Atlanta Braves are the Modern Champions Tournament National League winners. They will face the 1992 Blue Jays in the Grand World Series, starting in 2 days. It will determine The Team Of The First Half Of The 90s and/or The Team Of The Last 40 Years Since That What This Tournament Is Supposed To Be. Probably the former.</p><p>Listen to Bob Costas’ call of the Braves getting the final out in 1995. I wonder if members of the Blue Jays who had won two World Series, one of them <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/postseason/1992_WS.shtml">against the Braves in 1992</a>, heard that and thought, “Excuse me?”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fetf9rcbhfTM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Detf9rcbhfTM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fetf9rcbhfTM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/06daffbfb2327b8bb1315de06f75dc96/href">https://medium.com/media/06daffbfb2327b8bb1315de06f75dc96/href</a></iframe><p>They’ll settle it on the field in our next chapter.</p><p>It was another close call for the Most Valuable Player of the NLCS but the choice is Mark Lemke, so we have a pair of second basemen winning the MVP awards. Steve Avery was actually considered despite only pitching one game, but his Game 4 shutout gave Atlanta a huge boost when they could have gone down 3–1. Chipper Jones and David Justice hit home runs of major importance, but couldn’t match the consistency of Lemke throughout the series. Lemke hit .308 and had a .419 on-base percentage, was perfect defensively, and always seemed to be in the middle of everything. He was involved in almost every big inning the Braves had, scoring 6 runs.</p><p>A quick salute to the Giants. They are another team that I’ll miss and thank for the memories because they played so many tight, interesting, and sometimes crazy games. They went the distance in all three series they played and provided some of the tournament’s greatest moments, from the Panda Slam in Los Angeles to the 14th-inning butcher-boy to beat the Phillies in their fourth extra-inning game of this thing. It’s wild to think that they got within one game of the Grand World Series after all that, but their overall record in 17 games was 9–8.</p><p>So, we say goodbye to them as we are finally down to 2 teams from the 22 that started this tournament back in June. Here’s how they got there:</p><p><strong>1992 Toronto Blue Jays (#9 seed in American League bracket)<br></strong>Qualifying Round: Defeated 1983 Orioles 2 games to 0 (Scores: 2–0, 5–3)<br>Round of 16: Defeated 2018 Red Sox 3 games to 2 (Scores: 3–11, 7–3, 12–5, 4–6, 3–2)<br>Division Series: Defeated 2017 Astros 3 games to 1 (Scores: 11–2, 0–1, 4–3, 7–4)<br>League Championship Series: Defeated 1984 Tigers 4 games to 0 (Scores: 13–1, 5–4 (10 innings), 9–7, 6–2)</p><p><strong>1995 Atlanta Braves (#3 seed in National League bracket)<br></strong>Round of 16: Defeated 2001 Diamondbacks 3 games to 0 (Scores: 4–3, 7–1, 7–2)<br>Division Series: Defeated 2011 Cardinals 3 games to 1 (Scores: 5–0, 9–4, 2–4, 1–0)<br>League Championship Series: Defeated 2012 Giants 4 games to 3 (Scores: 4–5, 0–3, 7–5, 4–0, 1–5, 5–2, 6–2)</p><p>Success in baseball is very fragile, and both teams were in serious danger of getting bounced at some point. The Blue Jays were down 2–0 in the 8th inning of Game 5 at Fenway Park against Chris Sale. They were also one inning away from being down 2–1 to the Astros in that series before Ken Giles blew the save, and then who knows what would have happened?</p><p>The Braves just had Greg Maddux lose twice in the NLCS and still won it. It’s very hard to win 4 out of 5 games after dropping the first two at home. Plus, the Braves trailed 3–0 after the first inning in Game 3. You have to give them credit for their resilience.</p><p>Maddux is likely to start Game 1 of the GWS, but the Braves have a big decision to make about their pitching rotation. Either Glavine pitches Game 2 on three days rest, or they give Avery the ball. Doing that would push Glavine to Game 3 and Smoltz to Game 4, then they could go Maddux-Glavine-Smoltz for 5, 6, and 7 with Glavine and Smoltz on short rest. That’s how the Braves are leaning, but it’s undecided at this time.</p><p>Here’s the probable pitchers for the Grand World Series. Well, well, well, check out what we could have in Game 7: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8m1LLARdYnM">Jack Morris vs. John Smoltz</a>. Wouldn’t that be something?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T_4YO-dyfyNkPVf6aAJ1EQ.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>CHAPTER SEVEN: THESE DICE HAVE GOT TO BE KIDDING — THE GRAND WORLD SERIES<br>(Original publish date: January 12, 2023)</strong></p><p><strong>Day 32</strong></p><p>Imagine the scene on TV…</p><p>8 p.m. Eastern time. A wide shot of fans, prompted by the public-address announcer just seconds before the network went live, chanting and doing the tomahawk chop at a sold out Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium as we hear the familiar Fox Sports theme music. The Georgia skies are clear and it’s a great night for a ballgame.</p><p>Joe Buck narrates for us.</p><p>“One month ago, the greatest baseball tournament in history began with 22 World Championship teams. (<em>Lower-third match-up banner flies in to the picture)</em>. We’re down to the final two, the Grand World Series of the Modern Champions Tournament. Game 1 between the 1992 Toronto Blue Jays and the 1995 Atlanta Braves.”</p><p><em>(Dissolve to Buck booth iso)</em></p><p>“Good evening, everybody. Welcome inside the broadcast booth. I’m Joe Buck. Tim McCarver coming right up, Ken Rosenthal and Tom Verducci down on the field. The 1992 Blue Jays played, and won, on the very first day of this incredible tournament that has captivated baseball fans for weeks. I think when this all began, none of us knew what to expect. Sure, we knew we were going to see great baseball players, great baseball teams. But it’s been the crazy endings, the surprising results, the heroic performances — just one after another. This has been a baseball fan’s version of a World Cup or March Madness, and it’s been a dream come true.”</p><p><em>(Camera pans to 2-shot)</em></p><p>“It’s only fitting that as we start this Grand World Series, we bring in the man who has called more World Series games than anyone in broadcasting history: my longtime partner and dear friend, the legend Tim McCarver. Nice to see you again, buddy.”</p><p>“Good to be here. Are you sure you didn’t pass me after I left?”</p><p>“Call it 1 and 1A.”</p><p>“Alright.”</p><p>“Tim, the ’92 Blue Jays have been on fire. And they won their World Championship right here on this field. You were here.”</p><p>“Certainly was.”</p><p>“What’s different about the ’95 Braves that they’ll have to beat this time?”</p><p>“General manager John Schuerholz did a great job maintaining that young Braves core — David Justice, Mark Lemke, Tom Glavine, John Smoltz. But he had to add some pieces and the biggest one he added was the man on the mound tonight, Greg Maddux. <em>(Dissolve to Maddux warmup iso with L3 graphic)</em> They call him Mad Dog, and tonight he’s mad because he lost two games in the NLCS against the Giants. I wouldn’t want to be facing him right now. But you add Maddux, and Chipper Jones had a great rookie season in 1995, <em>(Dissolve to booth 2-shot)</em> Marquis Grissom at the top of the lineup and playing a great center field. Fred McGriff, Ryan Klesko, Javy Lopez lengthening that Braves lineup. They were a much more complete team in ’95.”</p><p>“Of course, the Braves are known for their incredible starting pitching with the three Hall of Famers. Is this Blue Jays team their toughest test?”</p><p>“I’d have to say yes. No disrespect to the Cleveland ballclub they beat in the World Series that year. But, these Blue Jays have just been raking the ball. They swept the Tigers with ease. <em>(Dissolve to shots of Blue Jays stretching)</em> John Olerud hit .588 in that series and didn’t even win MVP because Roberto Alomar was so good, and Joe Carter has been spectacular this entire tournament. It is a disadvantage, though, that they lose the designated hitter in the four games here in Atlanta. <em>(Dissolve to booth 2-shot)</em> That’s a tough decision for Cito Gaston. Tonight Dave Winfield won’t start, but of course he’ll be used at some point as a pinch-hitter. Candy Maldonado also could be in that role in this series.”</p><p>“Give me an X-factor. Is there something no one’s thought of?”</p><p>“Well, the Braves stack their left-handed bats in the middle of their lineup. McGriff, Justice, and Klesko. Also, Lemke and Chipper Jones are switch-hitters that are better from the left side of the plate. The Blue Jays only have one left-handed reliever, and that’s David Wells, who hasn’t been used much. You might see Wells quite a bit in this series, and how he does could make a big difference.”</p><p>“Gonna be fun. Right, partner?”</p><p>“Oh, you bet. Let’s go.”</p><p>“Enjoy it, folks. You won’t see anything like this again. <em>(Dissolve to dugout shots with Series logo graphic in lower-left corner, fade in bump music)</em> Game 1, The Grand World Series. First pitch coming right up, here on Fox.”</p><p><strong><em>(Note: Tim McCarver passed away five weeks after this was originally published. Any modern baseball fan heard him call the biggest games of the era. This fictitious scene of an open to a Fox broadcast is a tribute by me to an iconic announcing team. May he rest in peace.)</em></strong></p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux)</em></p><p>You heard what McCarver said — Joe Carter has been spectacular this entire tournament. He’s hitting over .400 and his production continues with a solo home run off Maddux in the first inning, his 5th longball of the tournament.</p><p>Manny Lee leads off the 3rd with a single. Known more for his defense, Lee did hit .263 in 1992 and was not an automatic out even though he may have seemed like an easier assignment after running the gauntlet of the Blue Jays’ lineup.</p><p>With Maddux’s personal catcher, Charlie O’Brien, having a poor throwing rating, Lee steals second and is bunted to third by David Cone. Devon White hits a sacrifice fly to put the Blue Jays ahead 2–0. Maddux losing three games in a row now seems like a real possibility.</p><p>Marquis Grissom leads off the bottom of the 4th with a walk and he steals second. He then scores himself on two productive outs, as Lemke grounds out to second and then Jones hits a sac fly to center. Atlanta’s on the board.</p><p>In the 5th, Cone loses it like Ryan Vogelsong suddenly lost it in Game 6 of the NLCS. Justice and Klesko start the inning with singles. O’Brien was up next, and he had been 0 for 10 in the tournament so far. Any offense he could give the Braves would be a bonus, since his primary contribution was catching for Maddux. O’Brien drew a walk to load the bases with no outs.</p><p>Jeff Blauser then singled to advance all runners two bases. The Braves take the lead, 3–2. Maddux follows with the third sacrifice fly of this game to score O’Brien and the Braves were up 4–2.</p><p>Meanwhile, Maddux had settled into his groove on the mound, retiring all batters after Lee’s single in the 3rd. Cone had been due to lead-off the 6th, so he’s removed for pinch-hitter Derek Bell. Maddux pitches another clean inning and has set down 12 in a row.</p><p>Throughout the tournament, the Blue Jays have typically not had to go their bullpen this early. Toronto’s starting pitchers went at least 6 innings in all games of the Division Series and ALCS. The last pitcher not to go that deep was Jack Morris in Game 4 of the Round of 16 series against the 2018 Red Sox, and even then Morris went 5 and a third.</p><p>That’s why McCarver mentioned that David Wells hadn’t been used much, but he was coming in here for the bottom of the 6th with Lemke, Jones, and McGriff due up, and Justice and Klesko to follow.</p><p>It didn’t work. Lemke walked, Jones singled him to 3rd, McGriff singled. 5–2, Atlanta. Wells was taken out for Todd Stottlemyre, who got out of the inning with no further damage.</p><p>Carter leads off the 7th with a single, and he steals second. John Olerud flies out to deep right, nearly hitting a home run, allowing Carter to reach third. Maldonado singles to make it 5–3. Maddux remains in the game, a spot where most pitchers would have been taken out. Kelly Gruber flies out to left. Dave Winfield then pinch-hits for Pat Borders, but he flies out to center. Maddux gets through the trouble with the 2-run lead.</p><p>With Duane Ward pitching the bottom of the 7th, Dwight Smith pinch-hits for Maddux and doubles with 1 out. Grissom hits a grounder to third for a key error on Gruber. Lemke hits yet another sacrifice fly, this one on a would-be third out for an unearned run. Braves lead, 6–3.</p><p>Alejandro Pena pitches the 8th. White singles with 2 outs. If Alomar can reach base, Carter would come up as the tying run, but Alomar lines out to second. Mark Wohlers works an easy 9th for the save. The Braves take Game 1, 6–3.</p><p>We’re just getting started here. That was tame compared to what’s upcoming in this Series.</p><p><strong>Day 33</strong></p><p><em>Game 2: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Steve Avery), Braves lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Since the Braves had to go 7 games against the 2012 Giants in the NLCS, and had only one day off before this Series began, the Braves had two choices for their pitching rotation.</p><p><strong>A:</strong> Use Tom Glavine on three days rest in Game 2, Steve Avery in Game 4, John Smoltz in Games 3 and 7.<br><strong>B:</strong> Pitch Avery here in Game 2, use Glavine on normal rest in Game 3 and short rest in Game 6, use Smoltz in Game 4 and on short rest in Game 7.</p><p>The Braves went with B, deciding to get Steve Avery’s one start done early.</p><p>Last time we saw Avery, he had a phenomenal start in Game 4 of the NLCS. He shut out the Giants on three hits and didn’t allow a runner to reach scoring position until there were 2 outs in the 9th inning, and even that was with defensive indifference after a single. It was a performance that may have saved the Braves’ chances in the tournament since they could have went down 3 games to 1. Avery was even given consideration for NLCS MVP despite just pitching the one game, though that award went to Mark Lemke.</p><p>Two batters reach against Avery in the top of the 1st, but Devon White was thrown out stealing after his lead-off single. Joe Carter’s single turned out to be harmless.</p><p>On the other side, Jimmy Key was the unexpected pitching star of the tournament. He was a very good pitcher for the Blue Jays for a long time, but was not a heralded star on this pitching staff in 1992 — not with 21-game winner Jack Morris, trade-deadline acquisition David Cone, and young All-Star Juan Guzman. Key still had a strong card, and was chosen as the Blue Jays’ Game 1 pitcher in the Qualifying Round against the 1983 Orioles where he went 7.2 scoreless innings. He was consistently great throughout the tournament, with a 4–0 record and an ERA of 2.00 to date.</p><p>Grissom was the first batter Key faced, and hit a grounder to first. Key tripped coming off the mound to cover first and was injured. The roll to determine the severity of the injury was a 3, meaning Key had to leave the game one batter in (1 to 3 on the die roll meant Key had to be taken out, 4 to 6 would have meant he could stay in.) Unbelievable.</p><p>What just happened to the Blue Jays is what happened to the Orioles in Game 2 of their Qualifying Round series when Mike Boddicker was injured on the first batter.</p><p>Well, one advantage of sweeping the ALCS against the 1984 Tigers and having six days off before the Grand World Series started is that Johnny Wholestaff is rested. The Jays decide to bring in Guzman, who was originally going to start either Game 3 or 4. They could figure Key would be able to pitch later in the Series now.</p><p>After what would be about a 10-minute delay for Guzman to warm up, the first batter he faces is Lemke. The Braves’ second batter rolls a 1–3.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*PB8F6n6nmmFDAl3G.jpeg" /></figure><p>😮…“plus injury”. This time Lemke is injured coming out of the batters’ box. The next die roll is a 1, meaning he has to leave this game and is out for Game 3.</p><p>Holy cow. Two grounders to first base, two major injures. In the first inning! Two batters later, the inning is finally over with no more damage. Sheesh.</p><p>Olerud walks to start the 2nd, followed by a Gruber single and an RBI single by Borders to give the Blue Jays a 1–0 lead. Lee grounds out to put runners on 2nd and 3rd with 1 out, and now Guzman is batting. He successfully lays down a safety squeeze bunt, so Gruber scores and it’s 2–0.</p><p>Alomar leads off the 3rd with a single. Avery has already allowed 5 hits. Add the one walk to Olerud and that means 6 of the first 11 Toronto hitters had reached base. Subtract Guzman’s bunt and 6 of the first 10 Toronto hitters intending to reach base did so. This was not the NLCS 3-hit shutout save-the-day Steve Avery; this was the 7–13 with a 4.67 ERA in 1995 Steve Avery.</p><p>With Toronto’s heavy hitters coming up, and already down 2–0, Bobby Cox decided to make a move. But who does Atlanta go to here? They also have a short bullpen; teams that win the World Series and go deep in a tournament like this usually don’t need much help from their long relievers.</p><p>The choice was Brad Clontz, who had appeared in one tournament game previously and allowed 2 runs in an inning-and-a-third. That was in Game 2 against the 2011 Cardinals in the Division Series, when he couldn’t finish the game despite having a 9–2 lead in the 9th.</p><p>Welcome to the Grand World Series, Brad Clontz. Your first assignment is Joe Carter. Clontz got the job done, though. Carter flied out left, then Winfield lined to 3rd. Alomar stole second with Olerud up, prompting Cox to intentionally walk Olerud and have Clontz face Gruber, who grounded out. No runs score, and it’s still 2–0.</p><p>Somehow, the Blue Jays that had slugged their way past the 1984 Tigers in an easy ALCS, and had games where they scored over 10 runs against both the 2018 Red Sox and 2017 Astros, couldn’t touch Brad Clontz. He retired the next six batters he faced to go 3 full innings. He even got Carter a second time, and on that play Carter’s result contained a “plus injury”. The severity roll was a 5, so Carter could stay in.</p><p>This was going to be The Brad Clontz Game if Atlanta came back.</p><p>Rafael Belliard walked with one out in bottom of the 5th. Dwight Smith pinch-hit for Clontz and singled. Guzman then threw a wild pitch to advance the runners. Grissom struck out, but a passed ball by Borders and then a Jeff Blauser (filling in for Lemke) RBI single tied the game. Chipper Jones walked, and Guzman was removed for Wells. Guzman went 4.1 innings in emergency relief. Lately the Braves have put together some long innings in the middle of their games to chase the pitcher.</p><p>Fred McGriff singled to load the bases, but David Justice tapped back to the mound for the third out so Wells got out of trouble with the game still tied, 2–2.</p><p>Duane Ward started the bottom of the 8th by walking Chipper Jones. It was the third walk Jones had drawn in the game. Pretty impressive plate discipline by the rookie.</p><p>Ward then struck out McGriff and Justice. Javy Lopez singled Jones to 3rd, but Ryan Klesko grounded out to short while pinch-hitting for Mike Devereaux. Lopez slid in hard to Roberto Alomar at second on the force play, which Alomar didn’t take kindly to. This series was getting some heat. Still 2–2 after eight.</p><p>Grissom singled with two outs in the bottom of the 9th, then stole second with Ward’s poor hold rating. Ward incredibly became the 4th player in the game to roll injury numbers when he walked Blauser next. The severity roll was 3, meaning Ward had to leave but would not miss any more games. Tom Henke came in, earlier than Cito Gaston wanted him to. The manager had to make a double-switch for this change since the 9-spot was due to lead-off the 10th inning should the Blue Jays get there. The pitchers’ spot would now bat seventh.</p><p>Henke’s first batter was Chipper Jones, and the kid walked <em>again</em> for the fourth time. Bases loaded for McGriff, who struck out to end the inning. We were going extras.</p><p>Mark Wohlers pitched a clean 10th. Toronto’s offense had only recorded two singles since Avery was pulled. Atlanta relievers had thrown 8 scoreless innings to this point.</p><p>Klesko doubled with two outs in the bottom of the 10th, then Gaston made a shrewd move. He intentionally walked the light-hitting Belliard to bring up the pitcher’s spot and force Cox to pinch-hit for Wohlers. Charlie O’Brien grounded out. (Eddie Perez and Mike Mordecai had already been used, plus Blauser and Klesko were already in the game.) Tom Glavine might have had a better chance, in retrospect.</p><p>Now, who to bring in to pitch the 11th inning for the Braves? Their last two choices were left-handers Pedro Borbon, Jr. or Kent Mercker. They went with Borbon, who has pitched in some pressure situations in the tournament but almost exclusively against left-handed batters. However, this was not the 2001 Diamondbacks with Luis Gonzalez. This was not the Giants, where you could bring in Borbon to face Brandon Belt, Gregor Blanco, and Brandon Crawford. Toronto’s lineup is very righty-heavy, except for John Olerud. 3–4–5 were due up. Still, the Braves were riding on Borbon to get to Olerud and see what happened from there.</p><p>Carter struck out to lead-off, but Winfield singled. Borbon had one of the worst hold ratings spanning all of the tournament rosters, so Gaston had Alfredo Griffin pinch-run for Winfield and he easily stole second with Olerud batting.</p><p>Olerud popped one up in front of the plate. Lopez got under it, and dropped it in fair territory! McGriff wasn’t there to <a href="https://beyondthebell.mlblogs.com/final-outs-of-the-1980-world-series-through-bob-boones-eyes-e9c1d7db8489">catch the rebound like Pete Rose did for Bob Boone in the 1980 World Series</a>. The ball landed safely and Griffin got to 3rd. There was still just one out, when there should have been two. Alomar had to be laughing on the bench.</p><p>Gruber walked to load the bases. Up next was the 7th spot occupied by Tom Henke. Gaston sent up Maldonado to pinch-hit. At this point, Maldonado led the entire tournament with 19 RBI.</p><p>Make it 20. Maldonado walked to force in a run. Blue Jays lead, 3–2. Borbon was removed for Mercker. Manny Lee hit a grounder to short which Blauser kicked for an error and another run. It was 4–2 and looking like a big inning, but Mercker recovered to get the second and third outs. Two disastrous errors in the inning by the Braves.</p><p>Now who pitches for the Blue Jays in the bottom of the 11th? Ward’s gone, Henke’s gone. Mike Timlin was also used earlier.</p><p>Mark Eichhorn had become an afterthought in this tournament for the ’92 Blue Jays for two reasons. First, similar to Clontz against the Cardinals, he was given the ball in a lopsided win over the Red Sox in the Round of 16, allowed 3 runs, and couldn’t complete the 9th inning. Second, Toronto’s starting pitching has been so stellar their games often follow the formula of Starter to Ward to Henke to handshakes and high-fives.</p><p>Here was Eichhorn to face the top of the order in the bottom of the 11th. Grissom grounded out to second. Blauser struck out. Jones then walked for an are-you-kidding-me fifth time. <a href="https://stathead.com/baseball/player-batting-game-finder.cgi?request=1&amp;match=player_game&amp;year_max=2022&amp;comp_type=post&amp;ccomp%5B1%5D=gt&amp;cval%5B1%5D=5&amp;cstat%5B1%5D=b_bb&amp;exactness=anymarked&amp;GF=anyGF&amp;location=pob&amp;locationMatch=is&amp;min_temperature=0&amp;max_temperature=120&amp;min_wind_speed=0&amp;max_wind_speed=90">I have looked</a> and did not find a single game in postseason baseball history where a player walked five times.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*bm76mX886HKUs0f5.jpeg" /><figcaption>stathead.com, via baseball-reference.com</figcaption></figure><p>McGriff was up next, representing the tying run. He had just struck out with bases loaded to end the 9th.</p><p>He strikes out again to end the game. He struck out four times and finished the night 1 for 6. McGriff, whom I believe to be a worthy Hall of Famer that I was glad to see <a href="https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/baseball-hall-of-fame-results-fred-mcgriff-voted-in-by-committee-barry-bonds-roger-clemens-kept-out/">recently voted in unanimously by the Contemporary Era Committee</a>(*), was slumping in the clutch moments and had still not hit his first tournament home run.</p><p><strong><em>(*) I can even remember editing file video of McGriff when we were prepping our Hall of Fame shows at MLB Network, and wondering why he wasn’t getting more votes on the writers’ ballot.</em></strong></p><p>Blue Jays win, 4–2 in 11 innings. The Braves left a tournament-high 14 runners on base. Fourteen!</p><p>Eichhorn got the save, just like they obviously drew it up. Gaston should get the Player Of The Game award for this one. Bringing in Guzman for Key, double-switching when Henke had to come in for Ward, pinch-running Griffin and pinch-hitting Maldonado at the right time in the 11th — it all worked out.</p><p>The Grand World Series was tied and heading north.</p><p><strong>Day 34</strong></p><p>Idle, travel day. The Blue Jays announce Jack Morris will start Game 3 tomorrow, and Jimmy Key will be back for Game 4.</p><p><strong>Day 35</strong></p><p><em>Game 3: NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>The Braves get runners on the corners in the top of the 1st, but McGriff grounds into an inning-ending double play around the horn.</p><p>Justice doubles to lead-off the 2nd, then reaches third on a passed ball. After Klesko walks, Lopez grounds into a fielder’s choice at second so Justice scores the first run of the game. Dwight Smith, who started in left field with Klesko serving as the designated hitter, singles to advance Lopez to 3rd. Belliard then hits a grounder which could be a double play, but he beats the throw to first. Lopez scores, so both runs in the inning score on fielder’s choices at second base. This is amazing sometimes.</p><p>Toronto strikes right back against Glavine in the bottom half. Olerud starts with a single, then Maldonado doubles. Olerud scores when Gruber grounds out. Manny Lee gets a 2-out single to score Maldonado, and it’s 2–2.</p><p>When Klesko walks to load the bases in the 3rd, he’s the 9th out of 15 Braves hitters to reach base. That’s why Gaston chooses to remove Morris. In comes Todd Stottlemyre with bases loaded and one out. Stottlemyre strikes out Javy Lopez, then Smith grounds out, and the Braves do not score.</p><p>A quick look at Tom Glavine’s card:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*x-Ca4z1wI84MD-DF.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the bottom of the 3rd, Glavine threw 5–9 consecutively to Alomar and Carter. The back-to-back doubles put the Blue Jays ahead, 3–2.</p><p>To the next batter, Dave Winfield, Glavine threw a 6–12. That’s a pitcher injury on the comebacker to the mound. The severity roll was a 1, so Glavine’s out. The Braves have their starter leave in the 3rd inning for the second straight game. An absolute shocking development. These injuries to pitchers are becoming an unfortunate trend.</p><p>This time it’s Kent Mercker who comes in. He allows a single to Olerud, but Carter only gets to third base. RBI Machine Maldonado strikes out, then Gruber lines out and the inning is over with a one-run margin. Game 3 of the Grand World Series is now Kent Mercker vs. Todd Stottlemyre.</p><p>Both guys pitch great through the middle innings, though, and it remains 3–2 into the 6th. Lopez doubled and Smith singled to give the Braves runners on the corners with no outs. Stottlemyre struck out Belliard. With the infield in, Grissom grounded to short and Lopez was forced to hold at third. Blauser struck out to end the inning. A squandered chance for the Braves. Tremendous job by Stottlemyre to escape.</p><p>Mercker was taken out after Gruber doubled with one out in the bottom half, then Greg McMichael walked 8th and 9th hitters Borders and Lee to load the bases. Devon White hit a sacrifice fly to center, then Alomar got an RBI hit when he rolled a number where a clutch symbol on the card changes an out to a hit when there’s 2 outs and runners in scoring position. Alomar’s 4th hit of the game scored Borders and the Blue Jays led, 5–2.</p><p>Stottlemyre was done after 3.2 innings without allowing a run. Wells started the 7th with Jones, McGriff, Justice, and Klesko due up. Jones grounded out, but McGriff and Justice singled. Klesko struck out, then Lopez reached on another Gruber error and the Braves had bases loaded. Duane Ward came in, a little earlier than Gaston wanted him to but the manager felt it was urgent. Dwight Smith hit the ball hard, but lined out to Alomar to end the inning. The Braves had left the bases loaded for the second time in the game, and had left a total of 11 men on base through 7 innings. That’s 25 LOB over their last 18 innings.</p><p>It’s stretch time in Toronto so OK, Blue Jays, Let’s Play Ball.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F-HW3Fug5h1E%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D-HW3Fug5h1E&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F-HW3Fug5h1E%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/1e95ee00483e3f9f2d167cf4e5bbdde4/href">https://medium.com/media/1e95ee00483e3f9f2d167cf4e5bbdde4/href</a></iframe><p>Blauser singled with two outs in the 8th, and then Chipper Jones hit a 2-run home run. Suddenly, we had a one-run game at 5–4. Henke came in to retire McGriff for the 3rd out of the inning.</p><p>Justice walked to start the 9th, but Klesko bounced back to the mound which Henke turned into a 1–6–3 double play. Lopez lined out to third for the final out. The Blue Jays lead the series 2 games to 1.</p><p>Morris’ poor and short outing raises a serious question about him starting Game 7, if necessary.</p><p><strong>Day 36</strong></p><p><em>Game 4: NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key), Blue Jays lead series 2–1</em></p><p>Jimmy Key is back and ready to go. He puts down the first 8 Braves hitters he faces, then Belliard singles but Grissom pops up.</p><p>John Smoltz is nearly untouchable for the first three innings himself. He strikes out 6 of the first ten batters he sees, allowing just a single to Maldonado in the 2nd.</p><p>Jones walks with 1 out in the 4th. McGriff hits into a double play, this one a 3–6–3. It’s the fifth twin-killing of the tournament that McGriff has hit.</p><p>Olerud singles to lead-off the Toronto 5th. Maldonado strikes out and Gruber hits into a DP.</p><p>Lemke grounds into a 6–4–3 after a Grissom walk in the 6th.</p><p>8–9–1 is due up for the Blue Jays in the 6th, the three lightest hitters in their lineup. However, several times throughout this tournament, just when the opposing pitcher and manager think they can breathe a little with Pat Borders and Manny Lee coming up, those guys get big hits to drive in runs, or draw a walk to extend the rally. They have played a role in many of Toronto’s big innings.</p><p>Borders walks here. Lee tries to bunt him into scoring position, because no one has reached second base against Smoltz so far, but the bunt is too good and Lee gets a single. It’s now first and second with nobody out, the Jays’ first true scoring chance of the night.</p><p>Devon White also bunts, this time a sacrifice to put runners on 2nd and 3rd with 1 out. Alomar singles to left. Borders scores, Lee is waved home and he beats the throw from Mike Devereaux. 2–0, Blue Jays. Plus, Alomar advanced to second on the throw. That would be a huge 90 feet as Carter singles him in. This pitchers’ duel has quickly become a 3–0 game, and the rally started because Borders and Lee reached base.</p><p>They got on again in the 7th, and that’s when Smoltz was taken out. He finished the game with 10 K’s in 6.1 innings. Alejandro Pena came in for the 4th straight game and got out of that jam.</p><p>DH Ryan Klesko leads off the 8th with a home run that barely gets over the fence, but is Atlanta’s first sign of life offensively in the game. It’s now 3–1. Two batters later, Devereaux doubles.</p><p>To best describe Gaston’s next move, let me cite Rule 27.64 in the instructions of How To Play Strat-O-Matic Baseball:</p><p><em>“27.64 Relief pitchers cannot be used more than two straight days. After pitching two straight days, he must rest at least one day.”</em></p><p>Gaston does not want to use both Ward and Henke here. He’d rather save one for tomorrow. So, he makes the unusual move of going straight to Henke now to relieve Key, going for the 5-out save. If the Blue Jays have a chance to clinch the Series tomorrow, he’ll ride with Ward then or hope David Cone tosses a complete game.</p><p>Henke gets the next two outs easily to end the top of the 8th. Still 3–1, Blue Jays.</p><p>In the other dugout, Bobby Cox removed Pena for closer Mark Wohlers even though it was not a save situation. Pena was now unavailable for Game 5 himself, and Cox wanted the fresher arm to face the heart of the Blue Jays’ order.</p><p>Winfield singled with one out, then Olerud homered for some big insurance runs. Gruber went deep two batters later. Cox’s gamble went bust, as it was now 6–1.</p><p>So, Henke had to feel very comfortable starting the 9th. Lemke led off with a single. Then, Jones singled. First and second.</p><p>Up next is McGriff in what looks like prime double-play conditions. The Blue Jays could be out of this soon.</p><p>Except McGriff finally blasts his long-awaited first tournament home run. Just like that, it’s 6–4. Oh, how big were those Blue Jay home runs in the 8th.</p><p>Henke hasn’t gotten an out yet in the 9th, and now his fatigue rating is triggered. This isn’t working. Gaston has to get Ward to come in now and win <em>this</em> game. Figure tomorrow out tomorrow.</p><p>The first batter is Justice. He strikes out, but then Klesko doubles. Unbelievably, the tying run is coming up and it’s Javy Lopez, who then hits one fair down the right-field line and ends up on third with an RBI triple!</p><p>It is 6–5. The tying run is on third base with one out. Luis Polonia pinch-runs for Lopez to give the Braves a better chance of scoring on a shallow fly out.</p><p>The next batter due up is Mike Devereaux. The Braves do have Dwight Smith available to pinch-hit here, and Smith has been hitting well. Examining the cards shows that the odds of Devereaux and Smith getting a hit are about the same, but Devereaux’s card has more productive outs on it. Smith’s card has a lot of strikeouts, and the last thing the Braves need here is a strikeout. A fly ball likely ties the game.</p><p>Devereaux remains in. It made sense, I swear, until he rolled the worst possible number: 1–8.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*QOJKCZnT5X0zAoOk.jpeg" /></figure><p>That’s a comebacker to the pitcher with a runner on third cut down at home when the infield is playing in. These cards and dice have got to be kidding.</p><p>How would that happen? Well, figure Devereaux hit a chopper in front of the plate, Polonia took off, and the 6&#39;4&quot; Ward who’s already standing on the raised mound jumped up to field the ball and threw home for the out.</p><p>Just a demoralizing second out. It feels over, finally, after that. Blauser lines out to Lee at short. Blue Jays win, 6–5, in a game that was scoreless after 5 and a half innings.</p><p>You don’t see 4 over X very often in the linescore:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*iWAqVE613zfuCo3Q.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Blue Jays are one win away from this Modern Champions Tournament title. The next game could be the last game, after all this time.</p><p>But there is one weakness for the Blue Jays: the bullpen is gassed. They would really love 9 innings from Cone tomorrow, or maybe Eichhorn can pull off another one.</p><p><strong>Day 37</strong></p><p><em>Game 5: NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone), Blue Jays lead series 3–1</em></p><p>Devon White walks to lead-off the bottom of the 1st, then Alomar triples. The Blue Jays have a quick 1–0 lead and their home crowd is going bananas. This could be over fast if Maddux doesn’t get it together.</p><p>Maddux gets it together. Carter strikes out, and Winfield grounds out with the infield in so Alomar has to hold at third. Olerud walks, but Maldonado strikes out. It’s still just 1–0. OK, Atlanta, you can breathe.</p><p>Another pitchers’ duel comes into form quickly. The Braves’ best early chance comes in the 4th when a passed ball by Borders moves Mark Lemke from first to second. But with one out, McGriff hits a liner to Alomar, who throws to Lee to double off Lemke and end the inning. Though this one was unconventional, McGriff has hit into a double play for the third straight game in Toronto.</p><p>Maddux walks Olerud again in the bottom of the 4th, but nothing happens from that either. The score remains 1–0 through six innings. Neither pitcher shows any sign of trouble.</p><p>Until a rookie named Larry Wayne Jones hits a 7th-inning solo shot. Chipper has tied the game, 1–1. The Braves are alive.</p><p>McGriff follows that with a single, and Justice walks. Cone has suddenly lost it again, similar to Game 1. His fatigue rating is active now, making him more susceptible to give up a hit here that would give the Braves the lead.</p><p>The Blue Jays’ bullpen options are extremely limited. Ward and Henke are down, plus Stottlemyre just went 3.2 innings two days ago and Juan Guzman is slated to start Game 6 if need be. The three choices are David Wells, Mike Timlin, and Mark Eichhorn. Having to patch this together in the late innings of a close game is not what the Blue Jays wanted.</p><p>With Klesko coming up, Cito Gaston goes with Wells. Klesko flies out to left. So does Lopez. The inning ends, game tied 1–1.</p><p>Maddux is in the zone now. He hasn’t allowed anything since the walk to Olerud in the 4th. After a clean 7th inning, he’s retired 11 straight.</p><p>Charlie O’Brien gets his first tournament hit by singling with one out in the 8th. Grissom then doubles, and it’s 2nd and 3rd for the Braves. Gaston is stuck here; Ward and Henke need today and tomorrow off.</p><p>Next up is Lemke, followed by Jones. Gaston sticks with Wells, figuring he’s got the best chance. Lemke pops up to short, a huge second out with no advancement. Jones then strikes out and the inning was over.</p><p>Borders, Lee, and White do nothing in the bottom of the 8th. Any win by the Blue Jays now will be a walk-off, and Joe Carter is due up second in the bottom of the 9th. He wouldn’t know anything about a World Series walk-off, would he?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F-F5HwiGm7lg%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D-F5HwiGm7lg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F-F5HwiGm7lg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/1b1208baa2141b8fa84f124092f408c6/href">https://medium.com/media/1b1208baa2141b8fa84f124092f408c6/href</a></iframe><p>But first, the Braves are up in the 9th. It’s McGriff-Justice-Klesko, three lefties. Wells stays in the game to face them, even though he had to walk the tightrope to get out of the 8th.</p><p>McGriff hits it deep to right, and the ball lands over the fence for a stunning home run. The former Blue Jay, who was sent to San Diego in the 1990 Winter Meetings blockbuster trade which brought Alomar and Carter to the Blue Jays, has just hit his second 9th-inning homer in consecutive games. 2–1, Braves.</p><p>Before anyone in the ballpark catches their breath, Justice hits one out for back-to-back home runs. 3–1, Braves. That’s it for Wells, and all you can say is “Sorry, nice try”. In comes Mike Timlin, who gets the next three batters out.</p><p>Alomar lines out to second. Carter grounds out to third. Winfield hits a dribbler in front of the plate that O’Brien picks up and throws to first for the final out.</p><p>“A masterpiece by Greg Maddux, and we’re going back to Atlanta,” Joe Buck says on the air.</p><p>A Madduxpiece. Mad Dog retired the last 17 batters faced. The <em>only</em> hit he allowed was Alomar’s first-inning triple. A complete game, 9-strikeout, 1-hitter by the virtuoso of pitching in the 90s.</p><p><strong>Day 38</strong></p><p>Idle for travel.</p><p><strong>Day 39</strong></p><p><em>Game 6: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Juan Guzman) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Blue Jays lead series 3–2</em></p><p>Last time the 1992 Toronto Blue Jays were in Atlanta for Game 6 of the World Series, this happened:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FU9pCrFxwjeo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DU9pCrFxwjeo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FU9pCrFxwjeo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/35d97785aa8fb5dc88c2682645126054/href">https://medium.com/media/35d97785aa8fb5dc88c2682645126054/href</a></iframe><p>They came into this game with good news. Ward and Henke were back at full strength, and they didn’t have to face Greg Maddux.</p><p>The Braves have been in this position very recently, trailing the 2012 Giants 3–2 in the NLCS with Games 6 and 7 at home, Tom Glavine and John Smoltz probable to pitch.</p><p>One difference, though. Those Braves starters were on short rest now. It shouldn’t affect Glavine too much since his start in Game 3 was cut short after just 2.1 innings. However, Carter doubles in the top of the first and then scores on Winfield’s single. The Blue Jays have had a lead in all six games.</p><p>McGriff wipes that out with a 2-run home run in the bottom of the 1st, giving him homers in two straight at-bats. The Crime Dog has suddenly become The Clutch Dog.</p><p>But it’s First Basemen Hit 2-Run Homers Night as Olerud connects off Glavine in the top of the 4th. The Blue Jays regain the lead, 3–2.</p><p>Carter and Winfield both draw walks to start the top of the 6th. With Olerud coming up again, Bobby Cox decides Glavine is done. Pena comes in and he walks Olerud to load the bases. Here’s a big chance for the Blue Jays to pad their lead, with a rested bullpen ready to go.</p><p>Pena recovers to strike out Gruber, Borders, and Lee. Bases loaded, nobody out…no runs. It remains 3–2, Toronto. A huge moment. The crowd is on its feet. They may have just seen the most-exciting, pressure-filled, half-inning in baseball history where no ball was put into play. 3 walks, 3 strikeouts.</p><p>McGriff ties it with a solo shot in the 6th. What a turnaround. He now has 3 home runs in his last 4 at-bats, and 4 home runs overall in the Series. First it was double plays, now it’s dingers.</p><p>Derek Bell pinch-hits for Guzman to lead-off the 7th, and he singles. White bunts Bell to second, but this time it’s Alomar who lines out to second. Lemke had been playing close to the bag to hold Bell close, so he was able to make the unassisted double play.</p><p>Ward came in for the 7th. Belliard reached on a Gruber error, but was thrown out stealing by Borders.</p><p>Greg McMichael pitched a clean 8th for the Braves, though he was helped by Belliard’s diving play on a Carter ground ball to start the inning.</p><p>Ward also pitched a clean 8th. Wohlers pitched a clean top of the 9th. Candy Maldonado struck out as a pinch-hitter for Lee as the third out. Gaston then made a double-switch again, bringing in Henke to bat 8th and Alfredo Griffin went to play short and possibly lead-off the 10th inning.</p><p>Henke was coming in for the bottom of the 9th despite the game being tied. The Blue Jays would need two innings from Henke, and might have to use other pitchers as well, to win this game.</p><p>McGriff was the first batter, and every Braves fan was thinking home run as they chopped and chanted very loudly. McGriff singled instead, but fair enough.</p><p>If Cox thought about pinch-running for McGriff and trying to steal, it was quickly dismissed. No way was he taking McGriff out of this game and creating a hole in the middle of the lineup in case of extra innings. Also, Pat Borders was 2 for 2 in throwing out runners tonight.</p><p>Justice struck out, and then Klesko hit into a 4–6–3 double play. Just like Game 6 in 1992, the Blue Jays would have to win it, and the Series, in extras.</p><p>Griffin led off the 10th with a single, and for the second time in a row White effectively bunted. The go-ahead run was on second for Alomar, who struck out. An uncharacteristic rough game for Robby. Carter then grounded out to second. Wohlers had just gone two very strong innings.</p><p>Henke came out for his second frame. Javy Lopez jumped on the first pitch and we will see you tomorrow night. Lopez hits the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlton_Fisk%27s_1975_World_Series_home_run">Carlton Fisk home run</a>. It was a no-doubter. Bedlam in Atlanta. Braves win, 4–3. We’re going seven.</p><p>Does it seem like all of the Braves runs anymore are scored exclusively on home runs? That’s because they are. Home runs by the Braves accounted for all four runs they got in this game, all three of their runs in Game 5, four of their five runs in Game 4, and their last two runs of Game 3.</p><p>The Modern Champions Tournament will be decided in its 79th, and final, game.</p><p>This is the first time in the whole tournament the Blue Jays have lost two straight games. Afterwards, they announce what they had known for days and kept private: Jimmy Key will start Game 7 on three days rest. John Smoltz will do likewise for the Braves.</p><p><strong>Day 40</strong></p><p><em>Game 7: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz), Series tied 3–3</em></p><p>It had to be Jimmy Key.</p><p>He pitched on Day 1 of the tournament in Baltimore, went 7.2 scoreless innings. He followed that with 8 shutout frames in Boston in Game 2 of the Round of 16, the day after the Red Sox had pasted David Cone. Because of that, the Jays passed over Cone and gave Key the ball for Game 5 back at Fenway. 7 innings, 2 runs, and another win.</p><p>He fought back from one bad inning in Game 2 of the ALCS against the Tigers, and finished that game with 7.1 innings and his 4th win. Then, Key recovered from his minor injury in Game 2 of this Grand World Series to out-duel Smoltz in Game 4. 7-and-a-third innings plus one run allowed equals 5–0 tournament record.</p><p>It’s short rest, but this is The Game. Plus, Cone’s available, Morris is available, Stottlemyre is available. Everyone is available except Guzman.</p><p>Both starting pitchers are on three days rest for just the second time in the tournament. The other was Matt Cain vs. Orel Hershiser in Game 4 of the Round of 16. They both worked into the 8th inning of that game.</p><p>Smoltz went 7.1 scoreless innings in one of the <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/MIN/MIN199110270.shtml">most famous Game 7s in World Series history, 1991 vs. Minnesota.</a> His team came out on the losing end of that one, so here’s another chance for him. Smoltz also went 7.2 in Game 7 of this tournament’s NLCS against the 2012 Giants to get the Braves into this Series.</p><p>Lemke singles in the bottom of the 1st, followed by a Jones walk. Up comes McGriff, the Braves’ hottest hitter, but he goes back to his ways of earlier in the Series and grounds into the 6–4–3 double play.</p><p>Justice leads off the Braves’ 2nd with a walk, and Lopez gets a huge ovation as he comes up next. However, the crowd quickly goes quiet when Borders throws behind Justice and picks him off first base. It’s the first pick-off by a catcher in the entire tournament.</p><p>Manny Lee leads off the 3rd with a walk. The Blue Jays hoping this would be another instance of their lower hitters starting a rally. Key bunts Lee to second, but White strikes out and Alomar grounds out to short. We’re still scoreless.</p><p>Until Marquis Grissom leads off the bottom of the 3rd with a home run, his second of the tournament. 1–0, Braves. Key <em>again</em> rolls the pitcher injury number, 6–12, with Lemke up but this time he’s fine and can stay in.</p><p>Winfield walks with one out in the 4th and reaches second on a wild pitch, but Olerud fouls out to the catcher and Gruber strikes out.</p><p>Key is due to bat third in the top of the 5th, so the bottom of the 4th is probably his last inning. Cone is warming up. Lee makes a great catch of a Jones line drive to start the bottom of the 4th, then McGriff doubles. With left-handed batting Justice up next, Gaston leaves Key in. Justice lifts a fly to deep center that White runs down, but McGriff advances to 3rd.</p><p>Something’s off. While Smoltz is dominating, Key is living on the edge. He’s only allowed one run, but hasn’t had a clean inning yet. The two outs in this inning were loud outs. The dice are hitting the weak spots on Key’s card. Even Justice’s fly out was a split result that could have been another double, which would have scored McGriff.</p><p>If it hadn’t been a winner-take-all game, Cito Gaston might not have even considered taking Key out here. Lopez was up next, and even though Key had struck out Lopez two innings earlier, Gaston had another idea.</p><p>Mike Devereaux was starting in left field and batting 7th for the Braves because the left-hander Key was pitching. If Gaston brought in Cone, he didn’t think Cox would bring in Klesko to pinch-hit this early, and especially not while winning because Devereaux was much better defensively.</p><p>Last time Devereaux was up in a clutch spot against a right-hander, he hit the chopper back to Ward in Game 4 where potential tying run Luis Polonia was thrown out at home. He hadn’t had a base hit against a right-handed pitcher since Game 3 of the NLCS (0 for 6 with one walk).</p><p>Gaston decided his team’s best chance to get out of this inning unscathed was to intentionally walk Lopez, and bring in Cone to face Devereaux. Cox did what Gaston thought — he left Devereaux in.</p><p>Of course, Devereaux ripped a double to the left-field corner. It even enabled the slow Lopez to score from first. Braves 3, Blue Jays 0.</p><p>Jack Morris started the bottom of the 5th, so we now had Morris vs. Smoltz in a Game 7 but in far different circumstances than what was expected. Grissom led off with a walk, and Lemke grounded into a fielder’s choice. A passed ball got Lemke to second, then Jones walked. This inning is another struggle for the Blue Jays, like it has been all night.</p><p>McGriff came up and hit a fly to left that was an X play on the pitcher’s card. That means extra rolls have to be thrown, and the player’s fielding ratings have to be consulted to determine if the play is an out, hit, error, or a combination of the last two. The left fielder is Joe Carter. He normally played right field in 1992 and Candy Maldonado would play left, but Dave Winfield started in right because Toronto could not use him as a DH for these games in Atlanta.</p><p>The rolls turned a would-be out into a two-base error. On what, a dropped fly ball? Really? That’s the second time in this tournament that has happened to Joe Carter in a game like this! <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">He had an error in Game 5 of the Round of 16 series against the 2018 Red Sox</a>, but then came back and got the game-winning hit that time.</p><p>Lemke scores on the play, and Jones advances to 3rd, McGriff to 2nd. It’s 4–0, Braves. Still one out in the inning. I cannot believe this.</p><p>I have written extensively in this series of articles about how I hate the outfielder errors in Strat-O-Matic. It’s probably the only thing I do hate. I just think they happen a little too easily. I do not think Joe Carter would drop a fly ball in a pressure game here, nor did I in the Boston game.</p><p>But it counts. It’s what showed on the dice that was legitimately thrown in the box. I’m very proud of the integrity of this tournament where every roll that properly lands in the box has counted, no matter what it is. No matter if it’s a balk that ends a series, or an error that ends a game. There hasn’t been one do-over.</p><p>I try my best to come up with plausible baseball explanations for what happens. I think I had a decent idea for Geoff Jenkins dropping one in the 10th inning of Game 1 in the Phillies-Giants Division Series.</p><p>I had nothing I could say here for Carter, except for something I was surprised to find after the game when I was recording the stats. I even said something out loud, to which my wife who was sitting right there said, “What?” She knew the tournament was near its end, and was thankful for that. 😉</p><p>“A key play in this game was an outfielder dropping a fly ball, which I think sucks but it’s what happened,” I say. “I’m looking at the previous games and he [Carter] hadn’t had a ball hit to him since the 8th inning of Game 4. So, he stood out there for nine innings in Game 5 and the ball was never hit to him. Then he stood out there for ten innings in Game 6 and the ball was never hit to him. Then the first ball that’s hit to him in the middle of Game 7, he clanks it.”</p><p>My wife Rose shrugged and gave a half-hearted “wow”.</p><p>Playing in an unfamiliar ballpark and being “cold” defensively, did he lose the ball in the lights? I don’t think I can even argue that with a straight face though, because that’s nonsense. Outfielder shag flies before games. Carter played in the National League two years earlier with the Padres, in the same division as the Braves. He had been a left-fielder before, too. He didn’t forget how to catch.</p><p>This is where a Braves fan can say that Javy Lopez dropped a pop-up in the 11th inning of Game 2, which he probably also wouldn’t have done, and likely cost the Braves that game.</p><p>The dice are just cursed for the Blue Jays at a terrible time.</p><p><strong><em>(Note: In retrospect three weeks later, I decided the ball was hit into shallow left-center and Carter bumped into Manny Lee, who was backing out. Neither one heard a call and peeled off, then the ball went off Carter’s glove. It’s the most realistic possibility. I should have thought of it at the time, but was too upset as you can tell.)</em></strong></p><p>Justice is hit by a pitch to follow, then Lopez hits a fly ball to left which is caught this time by Carter, but Jones scores on the sac fly instead of it being a third out. It’s 5–0, Braves, and kind of a bummer.</p><p>Carter comes up to bat in the top of the 6th with a shot at redemption like he had against the Red Sox. He grounds into a 6–4–3 which ends the inning. Lemke homers off Morris in the bottom of the 6th. 7–0, Braves. The first blowout of the Grand World Series. I was worried about this in between Games 6 and 7, badly hoping Game 7 would live up to the rest of the Series and tournament. But, this was unfortunately looking like the <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/postseason/1985_WS.shtml">1985 World Series</a> when the Royals beat the Cardinals 11–0 in Game 7.</p><p>Smoltz cruises into the 8th, but a two-out walk to White gets Alomar up to drive in a run. Smoltz then leaves the game to a big standing ovation and tips his cap as he approaches the dugout. McMichael gets Carter to fly out to center, and the inning ends with the score 7–1.</p><p>Mark Wohlers comes on to pitch the 9th in the almost ceremonial role of bringing in the closer for the last inning of the Series. Dave Winfield singles and goes to second on defensive indifference. John Olerud singles. First and third. Interesting.</p><p>Kelly Gruber singles. Winfield scores, Olerud to second. 7–2. Pat Borders grounds out to first, runners advance. The Blue Jays had made some earlier moves to the 8-spot in their lineup, so now it’s the 25th man on the roster, Rance Mulliniks, pinch-hitting for Alfredo Griffin. Mulliniks had a high likelihood of drawing a walk against a right-handed pitcher, but instead he grounds out to drive in a run and the score is 7–3. Everybody can take a deep breath and relax. Now there’s two outs.</p><p>Toronto has two batters left on the bench, but really the only choice to pinch-hit for the pitcher’s spot is Ed Sprague. The same Ed Sprague who hit a <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/ATL/ATL199210180.shtml">game-winning 2-run home run in the 9th inning of Game 2 in the 1992 World Series in this ballpark</a>.</p><p>Sprague hits a double to deep right, which Justice also bobbles for an error so Sprague reaches third. It is now 7–4, and in the words of Vince Lombardi:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4V0TYIO6yv4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4V0TYIO6yv4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4V0TYIO6yv4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/25c84755f75185621df4bb27b4c38d0e/href">https://medium.com/media/25c84755f75185621df4bb27b4c38d0e/href</a></iframe><p>That’s it, Wohlers is out. This is now getting serious. In comes Pena.</p><p>Oh, if Devon White can get on base here so Roberto Alomar can come to the plate as the tying run. In a future world, Alomar might be this Jays team’s lead-off hitter. Here, he’s in the on-deck circle praying for a chance. White is hitting .167 for the tournament (15 for 90), has struck out 32 times, and has been called upon to bunt more than any other position player.</p><p>White hits a fly to right. Justice is under it, makes the catch. It’s finally over. The Modern Champions Tournament Grand World Series has been won by the 1995 Atlanta Braves.</p><p>You don’t often see 3 over X in the linescore:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*cgeL-9kfK-8dH4sZ.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s the first game in the Grand World Series where the Blue Jays never had a lead.</p><p>The Braves came back from being down 3 games to 1. They were losing going into the 7th inning of Game 5, which then was tied going into the 9th. Game 6 went extra innings. The Braves were 5–0 in games when facing elimination, since they were also behind 3–2 in the NLCS against the 2012 Giants. The Braves had lost the first two games of that series at home, then won the next two in San Francisco even after falling behind 3–0 in the first inning of Game 3. They were fighting for their lives for three weeks, and never folded.</p><p>The Most Valuable Player of the Grand World Series is Fred McGriff. Also receiving votes were Chipper Jones and Greg Maddux. McGriff winning MVP seemed unfathomable with his struggles in key moments early in the Series, but he hit .387 (12 for 31) with 4 home runs and 8 RBI. All of his four homers were meaningful — there was the go-ahead shot in the 9th inning of Game 5, the two home runs in Game 6, and even his 3-run jack in the Game 4 loss had repercussions. When that happened, Cito Gaston had to bring in Duane Ward which made Ward unavailable for Game 5. Who knows what would have happened if Ward could have pitched in the late innings of Game 5? Perhaps Wells wouldn’t have been in there to give up the home runs to McGriff and Justice. One thing leads to another — kind of a dumb song, but an apt statement.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FpIe-Cj071l0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DpIe-Cj071l0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FpIe-Cj071l0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6e6507ae7d7bf591f1a4965f805f0a52/href">https://medium.com/media/6e6507ae7d7bf591f1a4965f805f0a52/href</a></iframe><p>However, you can’t say with any conviction that the Blue Jays would have won Game 5 if they had more bullpen options, because Maddux would have pitched 11 or 12 innings if he had to.</p><p>The reason the ’95 Braves won both the World Series back then and this tournament is no secret. Here’s their tournament pitching stats:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*keLeSpVDjj4H4q9r.png" /></figure><p>What can I say about the Blue Jays? I could tell they would be a tough out from their first series in the Qualifying Round against the Orioles. It’s a damn shame they got unlucky rolls in Game 7. They were just so impressive the whole way, particularly in how they beat teams that had played great in previous rounds. The 2017 Astros swept the 1989 A’s, then got shoved aside by the Blue Jays. The 1984 Tigers swept the 1998 Yankees, then <em>got swept</em> by the Blue Jays. We’re giving Joe Carter the Tournament MVP award, a baseball version of my favorite and coolest-looking postseason award, the <a href="https://www.nhl.com/news/nhl-conn-smythe-trophy-winners-complete-list/c-287709808">Conn Smythe Trophy</a> from the NHL which awards an MVP for the whole Stanley Cup Playoffs and not just the Final. It’s fitting that a player from a Canadian team wins it. As disheartening as his Game 7 error was, Carter’s impact throughout the tournament was just too great. He hit .363 and slugged .593 with 5 home runs and 18 RBI in 22 games.</p><p>Well, we have reached the end. This tournament never had a straight bracket, though I did intend to have one at the outset. I mentioned several times previously that the Tournament Executive Committee (me) had the right to maneuver teams from their natural matchup to avoid having a series where the same player was on both teams, a.k.a. The Jack Morris Rule. (That was also the main reason why I used the 1992 Blue Jays instead of 1993, because I didn’t want Rickey Henderson to be playing for two teams.) We only had a duplicate player once, and of course it was Jack Morris in the unavoidable Tigers-Blue Jays ALCS.</p><p>I do think it’s cool that, after the fact, the tournament is a symmetrical bracket. Check out the seed numbers. They’re in the same spots on both sides.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*9WlKqZM8XqEYGCvP.jpeg" /></figure><p>Now there’s only one thing left to do: cancel my subscription to the Strat-O-Matic Card Viewer app. It served us well, most of the time.</p><p><strong>Epilogue</strong></p><p>The Modern Champions Tournament was an idea I came up with on our living-room couch, and then played the first game on our dining-room table, on June 7, 2022. It was the 1990 Reds against the 2008 Phillies. The game took about the same time of a real-life baseball game to play because I was just learning how to navigate the app for the cards, plus it was a close game with tons of strategy involved. The Reds won that game, 3–2. If the Phillies had romped 8–1 or something like that, would I have continued? Maybe. I just knew I was on to something that I thought could be great.</p><p>Quickly, I realized I had to move the game away from the dining room and into our spare/bar-room where I could leave it and play a few innings at a time whenever it was convenient. I thought it might take four months to finish, and it was seven. Game 7 of the Grand World Series was completed on January 9, 2023.</p><p>Nothing was skipped. Every at-bat was played out, even in blowouts. All rolls that landed properly in the box were counted. All stats were recorded after each game.</p><p>There were 79 games played. Home teams went 44–35. There were ten extra-inning games. 30 one-run games. Ten shutouts. Ten walk-off wins, but just one on a home run.</p><p>645 runs were scored (8.16 per game). 142 home runs were hit — 26 by the Braves, 20 by the Blue Jays. The other team to hit 20 was the 2008 Phillies, which they did in just 12 games.</p><p>The Blue Jays played 22 games and went 15–7 overall. Four teams played a mere 2 games.</p><p>I have played a lot of sports games in my lifetime, board and video. I would always think up fun storylines in my head for them and by the time I thought “I should write these down because it would make a good story”, it was too late and I was too deep into it. This time I saw the chance to write these recaps after each round, and I don’t care if 10 people read them, it’s been very fulfilling to do. If you have read even a small part of this, I thank you.</p><p>It was also a hell of a lot of fun to play. Here’s my Top 8 Moments because five weren’t enough. I originally had 6, but added two more while I was editing.</p><ol><li>Ryan Vogelsong’s “butcher-boy” hit off Cole Hamels to beat the Phillies in the 14th inning of NLDS Game 5</li><li>Roger McDowell’s 10th-inning balk to bring in the series-winning run for the Cardinals in Round of 16 Game 4 (the third of 3 balks that happened in the entire tournament, 2 of those by the ’86 Mets)</li><li>Fred McGriff’s 9th-inning home run in Game 5 of the Grand World Series</li><li>Javy Lopez 10th-inning walk-off home run in Game 6 of the GWS</li><li>Pablo Sandoval’s 7th-inning grand slam against the 1988 Dodgers in Round of 16 Game 5, to go from 3–1 down to 5–3 up</li><li>Duane Ward’s play to throw out Luis Polonia at home in the 9th inning of Grand World Series Game 4, preserving a one-run lead</li><li>Joe Carter’s 2-out, 2-run, single in the 8th inning to give the Blue Jays the lead over the Red Sox in Round of 16 Game 5</li><li>Eddie Perez pinch-hit go-ahead 2-run home run in the top of the 9th of NLCS Game 3</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/0*2EICgdOD8mV7I7Rr.jpeg" /><figcaption>Me holding the 79 scoresheets. You can bet I’m saving these.</figcaption></figure><p>I also thank and salute the people at Strat-O-Matic for their great game, my wife for buying it for me ❤️, and these 22 great baseball teams that accomplished something extremely difficult in winning a World Series. It’s hard even for a heavy favorite to go all the way, in any pro sport.</p><p>My aunt and cousins got me a book for Christmas. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Grandest-Stage-History-World/dp/0385546254/ref=asc_df_0385546254/?tag=hyprod-20&amp;linkCode=df0&amp;hvadid=564687260077&amp;hvpos=&amp;hvnetw=g&amp;hvrand=11026359313139735032&amp;hvpone=&amp;hvptwo=&amp;hvqmt=&amp;hvdev=c&amp;hvdvcmdl=&amp;hvlocint=&amp;hvlocphy=9007095&amp;hvtargid=pla-1829038243832&amp;psc=1">The Grandest Stage: A History of the World Series</a> by Tyler Kepner of the New York Times. They had no idea. I’ll dig into that after I finish this.</p><p>That’s it for me in the game-playing world for a little while, unless I think of a way to do a Modern Stanley Cup Champions Playoff 🤔.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=d2bf01cff14" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strat-O-Matic Modern Champions Tournament, Highlights of the Grand World Series]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-highlights-of-the-grand-world-series-8b992a498c94?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8b992a498c94</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[world-series]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tournament-of-champions]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stratomatic]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 12 Jan 2023 20:41:12 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-03-09T16:41:45.843Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The A.L. and N.L. bracket winners face off as the 22-team tournament ends</em></p><p><em>(This is the conclusion of a series of articles recapping a tournament of World Series winning teams since 1980, which I played using Strat-O-Matic baseball. The previous installments are </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-qualifying-round-highlights-1fe96ed12f76"><em>Part I</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-round-of-16-games-1-and-2-highlights-ae174015c8a4"><em>Part II</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc"><em>Part III</em></a><em>, </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-division-series-highlights-a8931706f3c0"><em>Part IV</em></a><em>, and </em><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-league-championship-series-highlights-79104114312c"><em>Part V</em></a><em>. They will likely be edited and combined later because that’s the closest I’ll ever get to writing a book, which I’ve always wanted to do.)</em></p><p>Imagine the scene on TV…</p><p>8 p.m. Eastern time. A wide shot of fans, prompted by the public-address announcer just seconds before the network went live, chanting and doing the tomahawk chop at a sold out Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium as we hear the familiar Fox Sports theme music. The Georgia skies are clear and it’s a great night for a ballgame.</p><p>Joe Buck narrates for us.</p><p>“One month ago, the greatest baseball tournament in history began with 22 World Championship teams. (<em>Lower-third match-up banner flies in to the picture)</em>. We’re down to the final two, the Grand World Series of the Modern Champions Tournament. Game 1 between the 1992 Toronto Blue Jays and the 1995 Atlanta Braves.”</p><p><em>(Dissolve to Buck booth iso)</em></p><p>“Good evening, everybody. Welcome inside the broadcast booth. I’m Joe Buck. Tim McCarver coming right up, Ken Rosenthal and Tom Verducci down on the field. The 1992 Blue Jays played, and won, on the very first day of this incredible tournament that has captivated baseball fans for weeks. I think when this all began, none of us knew what to expect. Sure, we knew we were going to see great baseball players, great baseball teams. But it’s been the crazy endings, the surprising results, the heroic performances — just one after another. This has been a baseball fan’s version of a World Cup or March Madness, and it’s been a dream come true.”</p><p><em>(Camera pans to 2-shot)</em></p><p>“It’s only fitting that as we start this Grand World Series, we bring in the man who has called more World Series games than anyone in broadcasting history: my longtime partner and dear friend, the legend Tim McCarver. Nice to see you again, buddy.”</p><p>“Good to be here. Are you sure you didn’t pass me after I left?”</p><p>“Call it 1 and 1A.”</p><p>“Alright.”</p><p>“Tim, the ’92 Blue Jays have been on fire. And they won their World Championship right here on this field. You were here.”</p><p>“Certainly was.”</p><p>“What’s different about the ’95 Braves that they’ll have to beat this time?”</p><p>“General manager John Schuerholz did a great job maintaining that young Braves core — David Justice, Mark Lemke, Tom Glavine, John Smoltz. But he had to add some pieces and the biggest one he added was the man on the mound tonight, Greg Maddux. <em>(Dissolve to Maddux warmup iso with L3 graphic)</em> They call him Mad Dog, and tonight he’s mad because he lost two games in the NLCS against the Giants. I wouldn’t want to be facing him right now. But you add Maddux, and Chipper Jones had a great rookie season in 1995, <em>(Dissolve to booth 2-shot)</em> Marquis Grissom at the top of the lineup and playing a great center field. Fred McGriff, Ryan Klesko, Javy Lopez lengthening that Braves lineup. They were a much more complete team in ’95.”</p><p>“Of course, the Braves are known for their incredible starting pitching with the three Hall of Famers. Is this Blue Jays team their toughest test?”</p><p>“I’d have to say yes. No disrespect to the Cleveland ballclub they beat in the World Series that year. But, these Blue Jays have just been raking the ball. They swept the Tigers with ease. <em>(Dissolve to shots of Blue Jays stretching)</em> John Olerud hit .588 in that series and didn’t even win MVP because Roberto Alomar was so good, and Joe Carter has been spectacular this entire tournament. It is a disadvantage, though, that they lose the designated hitter in the four games here in Atlanta. <em>(Dissolve to booth 2-shot)</em> That’s a tough decision for Cito Gaston. Tonight Dave Winfield won’t start, but of course he’ll be used at some point as a pinch-hitter. Candy Maldonado also could be in that role in this series.”</p><p>“Give me an X-factor. Is there something no one’s thought of?”</p><p>“Well, the Braves stack their left-handed bats in the middle of their lineup. McGriff, Justice, and Klesko. Also, Lemke and Chipper Jones are switch-hitters that are better from the left side of the plate. The Blue Jays only have one left-handed reliever, and that’s David Wells, who hasn’t been used much. You might see Wells quite a bit in this series, and how he does could make a big difference.”</p><p>“Gonna be fun. Right, partner?”</p><p>“Oh, you bet. Let’s go.”</p><p>“Enjoy it, folks. You won’t see anything like this again. <em>(Dissolve to dugout shots with Series logo graphic in lower-left corner, fade in bump music)</em> Game 1, The Grand World Series. First pitch coming right up, here on Fox.”</p><p><strong>Tournament Day 32</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux)</em></p><p>You heard what McCarver said — Joe Carter has been spectacular this entire tournament. He’s hitting over .400 and his production continues with a solo home run off Maddux in the first inning, his 5th longball of the tournament.</p><p>Manny Lee leads off the 3rd with a single. Known more for his defense, Lee did hit .263 in 1992 and was not an automatic out even though he may have seemed like an easier assignment after running the gauntlet of the Blue Jays’ lineup.</p><p>With Maddux’s personal catcher, Charlie O’Brien, having a poor throwing rating, Lee steals second and is bunted to third by David Cone. Devon White hits a sacrifice fly to put the Blue Jays ahead 2–0. Maddux losing three games in a row now seems like a real possibility.</p><p>Marquis Grissom leads off the bottom of the 4th with a walk and he steals second. He then scores himself on two productive outs, as Lemke grounds out to second and then Jones hits a sac fly to center. Atlanta’s on the board.</p><p>In the 5th, Cone loses it like Ryan Vogelsong suddenly lost it in Game 6 of the NLCS. Justice and Klesko start the inning with singles. O’Brien was up next, and he had been 0 for 10 in the tournament so far. Any offense he could give the Braves would be a bonus, since his primary contribution was catching for Maddux. O’Brien drew a walk to load the bases with no outs.</p><p>Jeff Blauser then singled to advance all runners two bases. The Braves take the lead, 3–2. Maddux follows with the third sacrifice fly of this game to score O’Brien and the Braves were up 4–2.</p><p>Meanwhile, Maddux had settled into his groove on the mound, retiring all batters after Lee’s single in the 3rd. Cone had been due to lead-off the 6th, so he’s removed for pinch-hitter Derek Bell. Maddux pitches another clean inning and has set down 12 in a row.</p><p>Throughout the tournament, the Blue Jays have typically not had to go their bullpen this early. Toronto’s starting pitchers went at least 6 innings in all games of the Division Series and ALCS. The last pitcher not to go that deep was Jack Morris in Game 4 of the Round of 16 series against the 2018 Red Sox, and even then Morris went 5 and a third.</p><p>That’s why McCarver mentioned that David Wells hadn’t been used much, but he was coming in here for the bottom of the 6th with Lemke, Jones, and McGriff due up, and Justice and Klesko to follow.</p><p>It didn’t work. Lemke walked, Jones singled him to 3rd, McGriff singled. 5–2, Atlanta. Wells was taken out for Todd Stottlemyre, who got out of the inning with no further damage.</p><p>Carter leads off the 7th with a single, and he steals second. John Olerud flies out to deep right, nearly hitting a home run, allowing Carter to reach third. Maldonado singles to make it 5–3. Maddux remains in the game, a spot where most pitchers would have been taken out. Kelly Gruber flies out to left. Dave Winfield then pinch-hits for Pat Borders, but he flies out to center. Maddux gets through the trouble with the 2-run lead.</p><p>With Duane Ward pitching the bottom of the 7th, Dwight Smith pinch-hits for Maddux and doubles with 1 out. Grissom hits a grounder to third for a key error on Gruber. Lemke hits yet another sacrifice fly, this one on a would-be third out for an unearned run. Braves lead, 6–3.</p><p>Alejandro Pena pitches the 8th. White singles with 2 outs. If Alomar can reach base, Carter would come up as the tying run, but Alomar lines out to second. Mark Wohlers works an easy 9th for the save. The Braves take Game 1, 6–3.</p><p>We’re just getting started here. That was tame compared to what’s upcoming in this Series.</p><p><strong>Day 33</strong></p><p><em>Game 2: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Steve Avery), Braves lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Since the Braves had to go 7 games against the 2012 Giants in the NLCS, and had only one day off before this Series began, the Braves had two choices for their pitching rotation.</p><p><strong>A:</strong> Use Tom Glavine on three days rest in Game 2, Steve Avery in Game 4, John Smoltz in Games 3 and 7.<br><strong>B:</strong> Pitch Avery here in Game 2, use Glavine on normal rest in Game 3 and short rest in Game 6, use Smoltz in Game 4 and on short rest in Game 7.</p><p>The Braves went with B, deciding to get Steve Avery’s one start done early.</p><p>Last time we saw Avery, he had a phenomenal start in Game 4 of the NLCS. He shut out the Giants on three hits and didn’t allow a runner to reach scoring position until there were 2 outs in the 9th inning, and even that was with defensive indifference after a single. It was a performance that may have saved the Braves’ chances in the tournament since they could have went down 3 games to 1. Avery was even given consideration for NLCS MVP despite just pitching the one game, though that award went to Mark Lemke.</p><p>Two batters reach against Avery in the top of the 1st, but Devon White was thrown out stealing after his lead-off single. Joe Carter’s single turned out to be harmless.</p><p>On the other side, Jimmy Key was the unexpected pitching star of the tournament. He was a very good pitcher for the Blue Jays for a long time, but was not a heralded star on this pitching staff in 1992 — not with 21-game winner Jack Morris, trade-deadline acquisition David Cone, and young All-Star Juan Guzman. Key still had a strong card, and was chosen as the Blue Jays’ Game 1 pitcher in the Qualifying Round against the 1983 Orioles where he went 7.2 scoreless innings. He was consistently great throughout the tournament, with a 4–0 record and an ERA of 2.00 to date.</p><p>Grissom was the first batter Key faced, and hit a grounder to first. Key tripped coming off the mound to cover first and was injured. The roll to determine the severity of the injury was a 3, meaning Key had to leave the game one batter in (1 to 3 on the die roll meant Key had to be taken out, 4 to 6 would have meant he could stay in.) Unbelievable.</p><p>What just happened to the Blue Jays is what happened to the Orioles in <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-qualifying-round-highlights-1fe96ed12f76">Game 2 of their Qualifying Round series when Mike Boddicker was injured on the first batter</a>.</p><p>Well, one advantage of sweeping the ALCS against the 1984 Tigers and having six days off before the Grand World Series started is that Johnny Wholestaff is rested. The Jays decide to bring in Guzman, who was originally going to start either Game 3 or 4. They could figure Key would be able to pitch later in the Series now.</p><p>After what would be about a 10-minute delay for Guzman to warm up, the first batter he faces is Lemke. The Braves’ second batter rolls a 1–3.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*rbUko-fOZnuPmYO3WIuz_w.jpeg" /></figure><p>😮…“plus injury”. This time Lemke is injured coming out of the batters’ box. The next die roll is a 1, meaning he has to leave this game and is out for Game 3.</p><p>Holy cow. Two grounders to first base, two major injures. In the first inning! Two batters later, the inning is finally over with no more damage. Sheesh.</p><p>Olerud walks to start the 2nd, followed by a Gruber single and an RBI single by Borders to give the Blue Jays a 1–0 lead. Lee grounds out to put runners on 2nd and 3rd with 1 out, and now Guzman is batting. He successfully lays down a safety squeeze bunt, so Gruber scores and it’s 2–0.</p><p>Alomar leads off the 3rd with a single. Avery has already allowed 5 hits. Add the one walk to Olerud and that means 6 of the first 11 Toronto hitters had reached base. Subtract Guzman’s bunt and 6 of the first 10 Toronto hitters intending to reach base did so. This was not the NLCS 3-hit shutout save-the-day Steve Avery; this was the 7–13 with a 4.67 ERA in 1995 Steve Avery.</p><p>With Toronto’s heavy hitters coming up, and already down 2–0, Bobby Cox decided to make a move. But who does Atlanta go to here? They also have a short bullpen; teams that win the World Series and go deep in a tournament like this usually don’t need much help from their long relievers.</p><p>The choice was Brad Clontz, who had appeared in one tournament game previously and allowed 2 runs in an inning-and-a-third. That was in Game 2 against the 2011 Cardinals in the Division Series, when he couldn’t finish the game despite having a 9–2 lead in the 9th.</p><p>Welcome to the Grand World Series, Brad Clontz. Your first assignment is Joe Carter. Clontz got the job done, though. Carter flied out left, then Winfield lined to 3rd. Alomar stole second with Olerud up, prompting Cox to intentionally walk Olerud and have Clontz face Gruber, who grounded out. No runs score, and it’s still 2–0.</p><p>Somehow, the Blue Jays that had slugged their way past the 1984 Tigers in an easy ALCS, and had games where they scored over 10 runs against both the 2018 Red Sox and 2017 Astros, couldn’t touch Brad Clontz. He retired the next six batters he faced to go 3 full innings. He even got Carter a second time, and on that play Carter’s result contained a “plus injury”. The severity roll was a 5, so Carter could stay in.</p><p>This was going to be The Brad Clontz Game if Atlanta came back.</p><p>Rafael Belliard walked with one out in bottom of the 5th. Dwight Smith pinch-hit for Clontz and singled. Guzman then threw a wild pitch to advance the runners. Grissom struck out, but a passed ball by Borders and then a Jeff Blauser (filling in for Lemke) RBI single tied the game. Chipper Jones walked, and Guzman was removed for Wells. Guzman went 4.1 innings in emergency relief. Lately the Braves have put together some long innings in the middle of their games to chase the pitcher.</p><p>Fred McGriff singled to load the bases, but David Justice tapped back to the mound for the third out so Wells got out of trouble with the game still tied, 2–2.</p><p>Duane Ward started the bottom of the 8th by walking Chipper Jones. It was the third walk Jones had drawn in the game. Pretty impressive plate discipline by the rookie.</p><p>Ward then struck out McGriff and Justice. Javy Lopez singled Jones to 3rd, but Ryan Klesko grounded out to short while pinch-hitting for Mike Devereaux. Lopez slid in hard to Roberto Alomar at second on the force play, which Alomar didn’t take kindly to. This series was getting some heat. Still 2–2 after eight.</p><p>Grissom singled with two outs in the bottom of the 9th, then stole second with Ward’s poor hold rating. Ward incredibly became the 4th player in the game to roll injury numbers when he walked Blauser next. The severity roll was 3, meaning Ward had to leave but would not miss any more games. Tom Henke came in, earlier than Cito Gaston wanted him to. The manager had to make a double-switch for this change since the 9-spot was due to lead-off the 10th inning should the Blue Jays get there. The pitchers’ spot would now bat seventh.</p><p>Henke’s first batter was Chipper Jones, and the kid walked <em>again</em> for the fourth time. Bases loaded for McGriff, who struck out to end the inning. We were going extras.</p><p>Mark Wohlers pitched a clean 10th. Toronto’s offense had only recorded two singles since Avery was pulled. Atlanta relievers had thrown 8 scoreless innings to this point.</p><p>Klesko doubled with two outs in the bottom of the 10th, then Gaston made a shrewd move. He intentionally walked the light-hitting Belliard to bring up the pitcher’s spot and force Cox to pinch-hit for Wohlers. Charlie O’Brien grounded out. (Eddie Perez and Mike Mordecai had already been used, plus Blauser and Klesko were already in the game.) Tom Glavine might have had a better chance, in retrospect.</p><p>Now, who to bring in to pitch the 11th inning for the Braves? Their last two choices were left-handers Pedro Borbon, Jr. or Kent Mercker. They went with Borbon, who has pitched in some pressure situations in the tournament but almost exclusively against left-handed batters. However, this was not the 2001 Diamondbacks with Luis Gonzalez. This was not the Giants, where you could bring in Borbon to face Brandon Belt, Gregor Blanco, and Brandon Crawford. Toronto’s lineup is very righty-heavy, except for John Olerud. 3–4–5 were due up. Still, the Braves were riding on Borbon to get to Olerud and see what happened from there.</p><p>Carter struck out to lead-off, but Winfield singled. Borbon had one of the worst hold ratings spanning all of the tournament rosters, so Gaston had Alfredo Griffin pinch-run for Winfield and he easily stole second with Olerud batting.</p><p>Olerud popped one up in front of the plate. Lopez got under it, and dropped it in fair territory! McGriff wasn’t there to <a href="https://beyondthebell.mlblogs.com/final-outs-of-the-1980-world-series-through-bob-boones-eyes-e9c1d7db8489">catch the rebound like Pete Rose did for Bob Boone in the 1980 World Series</a>. The ball landed safely and Griffin got to 3rd. There was still just one out, when there should have been two. Alomar had to be laughing on the bench.</p><p>Gruber walked to load the bases. Up next was the 7th spot occupied by Tom Henke. Gaston sent up Maldonado to pinch-hit. At this point, Maldonado led the entire tournament with 19 RBI.</p><p>Make it 20. Maldonado walked to force in a run. Blue Jays lead, 3–2. Borbon was removed for Mercker. Manny Lee hit a grounder to short which Blauser kicked for an error and another run. It was 4–2 and looking like a big inning, but Mercker recovered to get the second and third outs. Two disastrous errors in the inning by the Braves.</p><p>Now who pitches for the Blue Jays in the bottom of the 11th? Ward’s gone, Henke’s gone. Mike Timlin was also used earlier.</p><p>Mark Eichhorn had become an afterthought in this tournament for the ’92 Blue Jays for two reasons. First, similar to Clontz against the Cardinals, he was given the ball in a lopsided win over the Red Sox in the Round of 16, allowed 3 runs, and couldn’t complete the 9th inning. Second, Toronto’s starting pitching has been so stellar their games often follow the formula of Starter to Ward to Henke to handshakes and high-fives.</p><p>Here was Eichhorn to face the top of the order in the bottom of the 11th. Grissom grounded out to second. Blauser struck out. Jones then walked for an are-you-kidding-me fifth time. <a href="https://stathead.com/baseball/player-batting-game-finder.cgi?request=1&amp;match=player_game&amp;year_max=2022&amp;comp_type=post&amp;ccomp%5B1%5D=gt&amp;cval%5B1%5D=5&amp;cstat%5B1%5D=b_bb&amp;exactness=anymarked&amp;GF=anyGF&amp;location=pob&amp;locationMatch=is&amp;min_temperature=0&amp;max_temperature=120&amp;min_wind_speed=0&amp;max_wind_speed=90">I have looked</a> and did not find a single game in postseason baseball history where a player walked five times.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OHkThPvlou-PQt71qRTQNA.jpeg" /><figcaption>stathead.com, via baseball-reference.com</figcaption></figure><p>McGriff was up next, representing the tying run. He had just struck out with bases loaded to end the 9th.</p><p>He strikes out again to end the game. He struck out four times and finished the night 1 for 6. McGriff, whom I believe to be a worthy Hall of Famer that I was glad to see <a href="https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/baseball-hall-of-fame-results-fred-mcgriff-voted-in-by-committee-barry-bonds-roger-clemens-kept-out/">recently voted in unanimously by the Contemporary Era Committee</a>(*), was slumping in the clutch moments and had still not hit his first tournament home run.</p><p><em>(*) I can even remember editing file video of McGriff when we were prepping our Hall of Fame shows at MLB Network, and wondering why he wasn&#39;t getting more votes on the writers’ ballot.</em></p><p>Blue Jays win, 4–2 in 11 innings. The Braves left a tournament-high 14 runners on base. Fourteen!</p><p>Eichhorn got the save, just like they obviously drew it up. Gaston should get the Player Of The Game award for this one. Bringing in Guzman for Key, double-switching when Henke had to come in for Ward, pinch-running Griffin and pinch-hitting Maldonado at the right time in the 11th — it all worked out.</p><p>The Grand World Series was tied and heading north.</p><p><strong>Day 34</strong></p><p>Idle, travel day. The Blue Jays announce Jack Morris will start Game 3 tomorrow, and Jimmy Key will be back for Game 4.</p><p><strong>Day 35</strong></p><p><em>Game 3: NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>The Braves get runners on the corners in the top of the 1st, but McGriff grounds into an inning-ending double play around the horn.</p><p>Justice doubles to lead-off the 2nd, then reaches third on a passed ball. After Klesko walks, Lopez grounds into a fielder’s choice at second so Justice scores the first run of the game. Dwight Smith, who started in left field with Klesko serving as the designated hitter, singles to advance Lopez to 3rd. Belliard then hits a grounder which could be a double play, but he beats the throw to first. Lopez scores, so both runs in the inning score on fielder’s choices at second base. This is amazing sometimes.</p><p>Toronto strikes right back against Glavine in the bottom half. Olerud starts with a single, then Maldonado doubles. Olerud scores when Gruber grounds out. Manny Lee gets a 2-out single to score Maldonado, and it’s 2-2.</p><p>When Klesko walks to load the bases in the 3rd, he’s the 9th out of 15 Braves hitters to reach base. That’s why Gaston chooses to remove Morris. In comes Todd Stottlemyre with bases loaded and one out. Stottlemyre strikes out Javy Lopez, then Smith grounds out, and the Braves do not score.</p><p>A quick look at Tom Glavine’s card:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*kcv-ogMH1vYbHR7lq1yHMA.jpeg" /></figure><p>In the bottom of the 3rd, Glavine threw 5–9 consecutively to Alomar and Carter. The back-to-back doubles put the Blue Jays ahead, 3–2.</p><p>To the next batter, Dave Winfield, Glavine threw a 6–12. That’s a pitcher injury on the comebacker to the mound. The severity roll was a 1, so Glavine’s out. The Braves have their starter leave in the 3rd inning for the second straight game. An absolute shocking development. These injuries to pitchers are becoming an unfortunate trend.</p><p>This time it’s Kent Mercker who comes in. He allows a single to Olerud, but Carter only gets to third base. RBI Machine Maldonado strikes out, then Gruber lines out and the inning is over with a one-run margin. Game 3 of the Grand World Series is now Kent Mercker vs. Todd Stottlemyre.</p><p>Both guys pitch great through the middle innings, though, and it remains 3–2 into the 6th. Lopez doubled and Smith singled to give the Braves runners on the corners with no outs. Stottlemyre struck out Belliard. With the infield in, Grissom grounded to short and Lopez was forced to hold at third. Blauser struck out to end the inning. A squandered chance for the Braves. Tremendous job by Stottlemyre to escape.</p><p>Mercker was taken out after Gruber doubled with one out in the bottom half, then Greg McMichael walked 8th and 9th hitters Borders and Lee to load the bases. Devon White hit a sacrifice fly to center, then Alomar got an RBI hit when he rolled a number where a clutch symbol on the card changes an out to a hit when there’s 2 outs and runners in scoring position. Alomar’s 4th hit of the game scored Borders and the Blue Jays led, 5–2.</p><p>Stottlemyre was done after 3.2 innings without allowing a run. Wells started the 7th with Jones, McGriff, Justice, and Klesko due up. Jones grounded out, but McGriff and Justice singled. Klesko struck out, then Lopez reached on another Gruber error and the Braves had bases loaded. Duane Ward came in, a little earlier than Gaston wanted him to but the manager felt it was urgent. Dwight Smith hit the ball hard, but lined out to Alomar to end the inning. The Braves had left the bases loaded for the second time in the game, and had left a total of 11 men on base through 7 innings. That’s 25 LOB over their last 18 innings.</p><p>It’s stretch time in Toronto so OK, Blue Jays, Let’s Play Ball.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FICD-adja57I%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DICD-adja57I&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FICD-adja57I%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/082b1755dd491cbe37375e2e4d25073d/href">https://medium.com/media/082b1755dd491cbe37375e2e4d25073d/href</a></iframe><p>Blauser singled with two outs in the 8th, and then Chipper Jones hit a 2-run home run. Suddenly, we had a one-run game at 5–4. Henke came in to retire McGriff for the 3rd out of the inning.</p><p>Justice walked to start the 9th, but Klesko bounced back to the mound which Henke turned into a 1–6–3 double play. Lopez lined out to third for the final out. The Blue Jays lead the series 2 games to 1.</p><p>Morris’ poor and short outing raises a serious question about him starting Game 7, if necessary.</p><p><strong>Day 36</strong></p><p><em>Game 4: NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key), Blue Jays lead series 2–1</em></p><p>Jimmy Key is back and ready to go. He puts down the first 8 Braves hitters he faces, then Belliard singles but Grissom pops up.</p><p>John Smoltz is nearly untouchable for the first three innings himself. He strikes out 6 of the first ten batters he sees, allowing just a single to Maldonado in the 2nd.</p><p>Jones walks with 1 out in the 4th. McGriff hits into a double play, this one a 3–6–3. It’s the fifth twin-killing of the tournament that McGriff has hit.</p><p>Olerud singles to lead-off the Toronto 5th. Maldonado strikes out and Gruber hits into a DP.</p><p>Lemke grounds into a 6–4–3 after a Grissom walk in the 6th.</p><p>8–9–1 is due up for the Blue Jays in the 6th, the three lightest hitters in their lineup. However, several times throughout this tournament, just when the opposing pitcher and manager think they can breathe a little with Pat Borders and Manny Lee coming up, those guys get big hits to drive in runs, or draw a walk to extend the rally. They have played a role in many of Toronto’s big innings.</p><p>Borders walks here. Lee tries to bunt him into scoring position, because no one has reached second base against Smoltz so far, but the bunt is too good and Lee gets a single. It’s now first and second with nobody out, the Jays’ first true scoring chance of the night.</p><p>Devon White also bunts, this time a sacrifice to put runners on 2nd and 3rd with 1 out. Alomar singles to left. Borders scores, Lee is waved home and he beats the throw from Mike Devereaux. 2–0, Blue Jays. Plus, Alomar advanced to second on the throw. That would be a huge 90 feet as Carter singles him in. This pitchers’ duel has quickly become a 3–0 game, and the rally started because Borders and Lee reached base.</p><p>They got on again in the 7th, and that’s when Smoltz was taken out. He finished the game with 10 K’s in 6.1 innings. Alejandro Pena came in for the 4th straight game and got out of that jam.</p><p>DH Ryan Klesko leads off the 8th with a home run that barely gets over the fence, but is Atlanta’s first sign of life offensively in the game. It’s now 3–1. Two batters later, Devereaux doubles.</p><p>To best describe Gaston’s next move, let me cite Rule 27.64 in the instructions of How To Play Strat-O-Matic Baseball:</p><p><em>“27.64 Relief pitchers cannot be used more than two straight days. After pitching two straight days, he must rest at least one day.”</em></p><p>Gaston does not want to use both Ward and Henke here. He’d rather save one for tomorrow. So, he makes the unusual move of going straight to Henke now to relieve Key, going for the 5-out save. If the Blue Jays have a chance to clinch the Series tomorrow, he’ll ride with Ward then or hope David Cone tosses a complete game.</p><p>Henke gets the next two outs easily to end the top of the 8th. Still 3–1, Blue Jays.</p><p>In the other dugout, Bobby Cox removed Pena for closer Mark Wohlers even though it was not a save situation. Pena was now unavailable for Game 5 himself, and Cox wanted the fresher arm to face the heart of the Blue Jays’ order.</p><p>Winfield singled with one out, then Olerud homered for some big insurance runs. Gruber went deep two batters later. Cox’s gamble went bust, as it was now 6–1.</p><p>So, Henke had to feel very comfortable starting the 9th. Lemke led off with a single. Then, Jones singled. First and second.</p><p>Up next is McGriff in what looks like prime double-play conditions. The Blue Jays could be out of this soon.</p><p>Except McGriff finally blasts his long-awaited first tournament home run. Just like that, it’s 6–4. Oh, how big were those Blue Jay home runs in the 8th.</p><p>Henke hasn’t gotten an out yet in the 9th, and now his fatigue rating is triggered. This isn’t working. Gaston has to get Ward to come in now and win <em>this</em> game. Figure tomorrow out tomorrow.</p><p>The first batter is Justice. He strikes out, but then Klesko doubles. Unbelievably, the tying run is coming up and it’s Javy Lopez, who then hits one fair down the right-field line and ends up on third with an RBI triple!</p><p>It is 6–5. The tying run is on third base with one out. Luis Polonia pinch-runs for Lopez to give the Braves a better chance of scoring on a shallow fly out.</p><p>The next batter due up is Mike Devereaux. The Braves do have Dwight Smith available to pinch-hit here, and Smith has been hitting well. Examining the cards shows that the odds of Devereaux and Smith getting a hit are about the same, but Devereaux’s card has more productive outs on it. Smith’s card has a lot of strikeouts, and the last thing the Braves need here is a strikeout. A fly ball likely ties the game.</p><p>Devereaux remains in. It made sense, I swear, until he rolled the worst possible number: 1–8.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gDkz0BxMBu-uXi5sqp2CBA.jpeg" /></figure><p>That’s a comebacker to the pitcher with a runner on third cut down at home when the infield is playing in. These cards and dice have got to be kidding.</p><p>How would that happen? Well, figure Devereaux hit a chopper in front of the plate, Polonia took off, and the 6&#39;4&quot; Ward who’s already standing on the raised mound jumped up to field the ball and threw home for the out.</p><p>Just a demoralizing second out. It feels over, finally, after that. Blauser lines out to Lee at short. Blue Jays win, 6–5, in a game that was scoreless after 5 and a half innings.</p><p>You don’t see 4 over X very often in the linescore:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*3Rqwjdvu5kjbzcwp4B7c8g.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Blue Jays are one win away from this Modern Champions Tournament title. The next game could be the last game, after all this time.</p><p>But there is one weakness for the Blue Jays: the bullpen is gassed. They would really love 9 innings from Cone tomorrow, or maybe Eichhorn can pull off another one.</p><p><strong>Day 37</strong></p><p><em>Game 5: NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone), Blue Jays lead series 3–1</em></p><p>Devon White walks to lead-off the bottom of the 1st, then Alomar triples. The Blue Jays have a quick 1–0 lead and their home crowd is going bananas. This could be over fast if Maddux doesn’t get it together.</p><p>Maddux gets it together. Carter strikes out, and Winfield grounds out with the infield in so Alomar has to hold at third. Olerud walks, but Maldonado strikes out. It’s still just 1–0. OK, Atlanta, you can breathe.</p><p>Another pitchers’ duel comes into form quickly. The Braves’ best early chance comes in the 4th when a passed ball by Borders moves Mark Lemke from first to second. But with one out, McGriff hits a liner to Alomar, who throws to Lee to double off Lemke and end the inning. Though this one was unconventional, McGriff has hit into a double play for the third straight game in Toronto.</p><p>Maddux walks Olerud again in the bottom of the 4th, but nothing happens from that either. The score remains 1–0 through six innings. Neither pitcher shows any sign of trouble.</p><p>Until a rookie named Larry Wayne Jones hits a 7th-inning solo shot. Chipper has tied the game, 1–1. The Braves are alive.</p><p>McGriff follows that with a single, and Justice walks. Cone has suddenly lost it again, similar to Game 1. His fatigue rating is active now, making him more susceptible to give up a hit here that would give the Braves the lead.</p><p>The Blue Jays’ bullpen options are extremely limited. Ward and Henke are down, plus Stottlemyre just went 3.2 innings two days ago and Juan Guzman is slated to start Game 6 if need be. The three choices are David Wells, Mike Timlin, and Mark Eichhorn. Having to patch this together in the late innings of a close game is not what the Blue Jays wanted.</p><p>With Klesko coming up, Cito Gaston goes with Wells. Klesko flies out to left. So does Lopez. The inning ends, game tied 1–1.</p><p>Maddux is in the zone now. He hasn’t allowed anything since the walk to Olerud in the 4th. After a clean 7th inning, he’s retired 11 straight.</p><p>Charlie O’Brien gets his first tournament hit by singling with one out in the 8th. Grissom then doubles, and it’s 2nd and 3rd for the Braves. Gaston is stuck here; Ward and Henke need today and tomorrow off.</p><p>Next up is Lemke, followed by Jones. Gaston sticks with Wells, figuring he’s got the best chance. Lemke pops up to short, a huge second out with no advancement. Jones then strikes out and the inning was over.</p><p>Borders, Lee, and White do nothing in the bottom of the 8th. Any win by the Blue Jays now will be a walk-off, and Joe Carter is due up second in the bottom of the 9th. He wouldn’t know anything about a World Series walk-off, would he?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F-F5HwiGm7lg%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D-F5HwiGm7lg&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F-F5HwiGm7lg%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/1b1208baa2141b8fa84f124092f408c6/href">https://medium.com/media/1b1208baa2141b8fa84f124092f408c6/href</a></iframe><p>But first, the Braves are up in the 9th. It’s McGriff-Justice-Klesko, three lefties. Wells stays in the game to face them, even though he had to walk the tightrope to get out of the 8th.</p><p>McGriff hits it deep to right, and the ball lands over the fence for a stunning home run. The former Blue Jay, who was sent to San Diego in the 1990 Winter Meetings blockbuster trade which brought Alomar and Carter to the Blue Jays, has just hit his second 9th-inning homer in consecutive games. 2–1, Braves.</p><p>Before anyone in the ballpark catches their breath, Justice hits one out for back-to-back home runs. 3–1, Braves. That’s it for Wells, and all you can say is “Sorry, nice try”. In comes Mike Timlin, who gets the next three batters out.</p><p>Alomar lines out to second. Carter grounds out to third. Winfield hits a dribbler in front of the plate that O’Brien picks up and throws to first for the final out.</p><p>“A masterpiece by Greg Maddux, and we’re going back to Atlanta,” Joe Buck says on the air.</p><p>A Madduxpiece. Mad Dog retired the last 17 batters faced. The <em>only</em> hit he allowed was Alomar’s first-inning triple. A complete game, 9-strikeout, 1-hitter by the virtuoso of pitching in the 90s.</p><p><strong>Day 38</strong></p><p>Idle for travel.</p><p><strong>Day 39</strong></p><p><em>Game 6: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Juan Guzman) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Blue Jays lead series 3–2</em></p><p>Last time the 1992 Toronto Blue Jays were in Atlanta for Game 6 of the World Series, this happened:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FU9pCrFxwjeo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DU9pCrFxwjeo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FU9pCrFxwjeo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/35d97785aa8fb5dc88c2682645126054/href">https://medium.com/media/35d97785aa8fb5dc88c2682645126054/href</a></iframe><p>They came into this game with good news. Ward and Henke were back at full strength, and they didn’t have to face Greg Maddux.</p><p>The Braves have been in this position very recently, trailing the 2012 Giants 3–2 in the NLCS with Games 6 and 7 at home, Tom Glavine and John Smoltz probable to pitch.</p><p>One difference, though. Those Braves starters were on short rest now. It shouldn’t affect Glavine too much since his start in Game 3 was cut short after just 2.1 innings. However, Carter doubles in the top of the first and then scores on Winfield’s single. The Blue Jays have had a lead in all six games.</p><p>McGriff wipes that out with a 2-run home run in the bottom of the 1st, giving him homers in two straight at-bats. The Crime Dog has suddenly become The Clutch Dog.</p><p>But it’s First Basemen Hit 2-Run Homers Night as Olerud connects off Glavine in the top of the 4th. The Blue Jays regain the lead, 3–2.</p><p>Carter and Winfield both draw walks to start the top of the 6th. With Olerud coming up again, Bobby Cox decides Glavine is done. Pena comes in and he walks Olerud to load the bases. Here’s a big chance for the Blue Jays to pad their lead, with a rested bullpen ready to go.</p><p>Pena recovers to strike out Gruber, Borders, and Lee. Bases loaded, nobody out…no runs. It remains 3–2, Toronto. A huge moment. The crowd is on its feet. They may have just seen the most-exciting, pressure-filled, half-inning in baseball history where no ball was put into play. 3 walks, 3 strikeouts.</p><p>McGriff ties it with a solo shot in the 6th. What a turnaround. He now has 3 home runs in his last 4 at-bats, and 4 home runs overall in the Series. First it was double plays, now it’s dingers.</p><p>Derek Bell pinch-hits for Guzman to lead-off the 7th, and he singles. White bunts Bell to second, but this time it’s Alomar who lines out to second. Lemke had been playing close to the bag to hold Bell close, so he was able to make the unassisted double play.</p><p>Ward came in for the 7th. Belliard reached on a Gruber error, but was thrown out stealing by Borders.</p><p>Greg McMichael pitched a clean 8th for the Braves, though he was helped by Belliard’s diving play on a Carter ground ball to start the inning.</p><p>Ward also pitched a clean 8th. Wohlers pitched a clean top of the 9th. Candy Maldonado struck out as a pinch-hitter for Lee as the third out. Gaston then made a double-switch again, bringing in Henke to bat 8th and Alfredo Griffin went to play short and possibly lead-off the 10th inning.</p><p>Henke was coming in for the bottom of the 9th despite the game being tied. The Blue Jays would need two innings from Henke, and might have to use other pitchers as well, to win this game.</p><p>McGriff was the first batter, and every Braves fan was thinking home run as they chopped and chanted very loudly. McGriff singled instead, but fair enough.</p><p>If Cox thought about pinch-running for McGriff and trying to steal, it was quickly dismissed. No way was he taking McGriff out of this game and creating a hole in the middle of the lineup in case of extra innings. Also, Pat Borders was 2 for 2 in throwing out runners tonight.</p><p>Justice struck out, and then Klesko hit into a 4–6–3 double play. Just like Game 6 in 1992, the Blue Jays would have to win it, and the Series, in extras.</p><p>Griffin led off the 10th with a single, and for the second time in a row White effectively bunted. The go-ahead run was on second for Alomar, who struck out. An uncharacteristic rough game for Robby. Carter then grounded out to second. Wohlers had just gone two very strong innings.</p><p>Henke came out for his second frame. Javy Lopez jumped on the first pitch and we will see you tomorrow night. Lopez hits the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlton_Fisk%27s_1975_World_Series_home_run">Carlton Fisk home run</a>. It was a no-doubter. Bedlam in Atlanta. Braves win, 4–3. We’re going seven.</p><p>Does it seem like all of the Braves runs anymore are scored exclusively on home runs? That’s because they are. Home runs by the Braves accounted for all four runs they got in this game, all three of their runs in Game 5, four of their five runs in Game 4, and their last two runs of Game 3.</p><p>The Modern Champions Tournament will be decided in its 79th, and final, game.</p><p>This is the first time in the whole tournament the Blue Jays have lost two straight games. Afterwards, they announce what they had known for days and kept private: Jimmy Key will start Game 7 on three days rest. John Smoltz will do likewise for the Braves.</p><p><strong>Day 40</strong></p><p><em>Game 7: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz), Series tied 3–3</em></p><p>It had to be Jimmy Key.</p><p>He pitched on Day 1 of the tournament in Baltimore, went 7.2 scoreless innings. He followed that with 8 shutout frames in Boston in Game 2 of the Round of 16, the day after the Red Sox had pasted David Cone. Because of that, the Jays passed over Cone and gave Key the ball for Game 5 back at Fenway. 7 innings, 2 runs, and another win.</p><p>He fought back from one bad inning in Game 2 of the ALCS against the Tigers, and finished that game with 7.1 innings and his 4th win. Then, Key recovered from his minor injury in Game 2 of this Grand World Series to out-duel Smoltz in Game 4. 7-and-a-third innings plus one run allowed equals 5–0 tournament record.</p><p>It’s short rest, but this is The Game. Plus, Cone’s available, Morris is available, Stottlemyre is available. Everyone is available except Guzman.</p><p>Both starting pitchers are on three days rest for just the second time in the tournament. The other was Matt Cain vs. Orel Hershiser in Game 4 of the Round of 16. They both worked into the 8th inning of that game.</p><p>Smoltz went 7.1 scoreless innings in one of the <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/MIN/MIN199110270.shtml">most famous Game 7s in World Series history, 1991 vs. Minnesota.</a> His team came out on the losing end of that one, so here’s another chance for him. Smoltz also went 7.2 in Game 7 of this tournament’s NLCS against the 2012 Giants to get the Braves into this Series.</p><p>Lemke singles in the bottom of the 1st, followed by a Jones walk. Up comes McGriff, the Braves’ hottest hitter, but he goes back to his ways of earlier in the Series and grounds into the 6–4–3 double play.</p><p>Justice leads off the Braves’ 2nd with a walk, and Lopez gets a huge ovation as he comes up next. However, the crowd quickly goes quiet when Borders throws behind Justice and picks him off first base. It’s the first pick-off by a catcher in the entire tournament.</p><p>Manny Lee leads off the 3rd with a walk. The Blue Jays hoping this would be another instance of their lower hitters starting a rally. Key bunts Lee to second, but White strikes out and Alomar grounds out to short. We’re still scoreless.</p><p>Until Marquis Grissom leads off the bottom of the 3rd with a home run, his second of the tournament. 1–0, Braves. Key <em>again</em> rolls the pitcher injury number, 6–12, with Lemke up but this time he’s fine and can stay in.</p><p>Winfield walks with one out in the 4th and reaches second on a wild pitch, but Olerud fouls out to the catcher and Gruber strikes out.</p><p>Key is due to bat third in the top of the 5th, so the bottom of the 4th is probably his last inning. Cone is warming up. Lee makes a great catch of a Jones line drive to start the bottom of the 4th, then McGriff doubles. With left-handed batting Justice up next, Gaston leaves Key in. Justice lifts a fly to deep center that White runs down, but McGriff advances to 3rd.</p><p>Something’s off. While Smoltz is dominating, Key is living on the edge. He’s only allowed one run, but hasn’t had a clean inning yet. The two outs in this inning were loud outs. The dice are hitting the weak spots on Key’s card. Even Justice’s fly out was a split result that could have been another double, which would have scored McGriff.</p><p>If it hadn’t been a winner-take-all game, Cito Gaston might not have even considered taking Key out here. Lopez was up next, and even though Key had struck out Lopez two innings earlier, Gaston had another idea.</p><p>Mike Devereaux was starting in left field and batting 7th for the Braves because the left-hander Key was pitching. If Gaston brought in Cone, he didn’t think Cox would bring in Klesko to pinch-hit this early, and especially not while winning because Devereaux was much better defensively.</p><p>Last time Devereaux was up in a clutch spot against a right-hander, he hit the chopper back to Ward in Game 4 where potential tying run Luis Polonia was thrown out at home. He hadn’t had a base hit against a right-handed pitcher since Game 3 of the NLCS (0 for 6 with one walk).</p><p>Gaston decided his team’s best chance to get out of this inning unscathed was to intentionally walk Lopez, and bring in Cone to face Devereaux. Cox did what Gaston thought — he left Devereaux in.</p><p>Of course, Devereaux ripped a double to the left-field corner. It even enabled the slow Lopez to score from first. Braves 3, Blue Jays 0.</p><p>Jack Morris started the bottom of the 5th, so we now had Morris vs. Smoltz in a Game 7 but in far different circumstances than what was expected. Grissom led off with a walk, and Lemke grounded into a fielder’s choice. A passed ball got Lemke to second, then Jones walked. This inning is another struggle for the Blue Jays, like it has been all night.</p><p>McGriff came up and hit a fly to left that was an X play on the pitcher’s card. That means extra rolls have to be thrown, and the player’s fielding ratings have to be consulted to determine if the play is an out, hit, error, or a combination of the last two. The left fielder is Joe Carter. He normally played right field in 1992 and Candy Maldonado would play left, but Dave Winfield started in right because Toronto could not use him as a DH for these games in Atlanta.</p><p>The rolls turned a would-be out into a two-base error. On what, a dropped fly ball? Really? That’s the second time in this tournament that has happened to Joe Carter in a game like this! <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">He had an error in Game 5 of the Round of 16 series against the 2018 Red Sox</a>, but then came back and got the game-winning hit that time.</p><p>Lemke scores on the play, and Jones advances to 3rd, McGriff to 2nd. It’s 4–0, Braves. Still one out in the inning. I cannot believe this.</p><p>I have written extensively in this series of articles about how I hate the outfielder errors in Strat-O-Matic. It’s probably the only thing I do hate. I just think they happen a little too easily. I do not think Joe Carter would drop a fly ball in a pressure game here, nor did I in the Boston game.</p><p>But it counts. It’s what showed on the dice that was legitimately thrown in the box. I’m very proud of the integrity of this tournament where every roll that properly lands in the box has counted, no matter what it is. No matter if it’s a balk that ends a series, or an error that ends a game. There hasn’t been one do-over.</p><p>I try my best to come up with plausible baseball explanations for what happens. I think I had a <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-division-series-highlights-a8931706f3c0">decent idea for Geoff Jenkins dropping one in the 10th inning of Game 1 in the Phillies-Giants Division Series</a>.</p><p>I had nothing I could say here for Carter, except for something I was surprised to find after the game when I was recording the stats. I even said something out loud, to which my wife who was sitting right there said, “What?” She knew the tournament was near its end, and was thankful for that. 😉</p><p>“A key play in this game was an outfielder dropping a fly ball, which I think sucks but it’s what happened,” I say. “I’m looking at the previous games and he [Carter] hadn’t had a ball hit to him since the 8th inning of Game 4. So, he stood out there for nine innings in Game 5 and the ball was never hit to him. Then he stood out there for ten innings in Game 6 and the ball was never hit to him. Then the first ball that’s hit to him in the middle of Game 7, he clanks it.”</p><p>My wife Rose shrugged and gave a half-hearted “wow”.</p><p>Playing in an unfamiliar ballpark and being “cold” defensively, did he lose the ball in the lights? I don’t think I can even argue that with a straight face though, because that’s nonsense. Outfielder shag flies before games. Carter played in the National League two years earlier with the Padres, in the same division as the Braves. He had been a left-fielder before, too. He didn’t forget how to catch.</p><p>This is where a Braves fan can say that Javy Lopez dropped a pop-up in the 11th inning of Game 2, which he probably also wouldn’t have done, and likely cost the Braves that game.</p><p>The dice are just cursed for the Blue Jays at a terrible time.</p><p><strong><em>(Note: In retrospect three weeks later, I decided the ball was hit into shallow left-center and Carter bumped into Manny Lee, who was backing out. Neither one heard a call and peeled off, then the ball went off Carter’s glove. It’s the most realistic possibility. I should have thought of it at the time, but was too upset as you can tell.)</em></strong></p><p>Justice is hit by a pitch to follow, then Lopez hits a fly ball to left which is caught this time by Carter, but Jones scores on the sac fly instead of it being a third out. It’s 5–0, Braves, and kind of a bummer.</p><p>Carter comes up to bat in the top of the 6th with a shot at redemption like he had against the Red Sox. He grounds into a 6–4–3 which ends the inning. Lemke homers off Morris in the bottom of the 6th. 7–0, Braves. The first blowout of the Grand World Series. I was worried about this in between Games 6 and 7, badly hoping Game 7 would live up to the rest of the Series and tournament. But, this was unfortunately looking like the <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/postseason/1985_WS.shtml">1985 World Series</a> when the Royals beat the Cardinals 11–0 in Game 7.</p><p>Smoltz cruises into the 8th, but a two-out walk to White gets Alomar up to drive in a run. Smoltz then leaves the game to a big standing ovation and tips his cap as he approaches the dugout. McMichael gets Carter to fly out to center, and the inning ends with the score 7–1.</p><p>Mark Wohlers comes on to pitch the 9th in the almost ceremonial role of bringing in the closer for the last inning of the Series. Dave Winfield singles and goes to second on defensive indifference. John Olerud singles. First and third. Interesting.</p><p>Kelly Gruber singles. Winfield scores, Olerud to second. 7–2. Pat Borders grounds out to first, runners advance. The Blue Jays had made some earlier moves to the 8-spot in their lineup, so now it’s the 25th man on the roster, Rance Mulliniks, pinch-hitting for Alfredo Griffin. Mulliniks had a high likelihood of drawing a walk against a right-handed pitcher, but instead he grounds out to drive in a run and the score is 7–3. Everybody can take a deep breath and relax. Now there’s two outs.</p><p>Toronto has two batters left on the bench, but really the only choice to pinch-hit for the pitcher’s spot is Ed Sprague. The same Ed Sprague who hit a <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/ATL/ATL199210180.shtml">game-winning 2-run home run in the 9th inning of Game 2 in the 1992 World Series in this ballpark</a>.</p><p>Sprague hits a double to deep right, which Justice also bobbles for an error so Sprague reaches third. It is now 7–4, and in the words of Vince Lombardi:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4V0TYIO6yv4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4V0TYIO6yv4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4V0TYIO6yv4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/25c84755f75185621df4bb27b4c38d0e/href">https://medium.com/media/25c84755f75185621df4bb27b4c38d0e/href</a></iframe><p>That’s it, Wohlers is out. This is now getting serious. In comes Pena.</p><p>Oh, if Devon White can get on base here so Roberto Alomar can come to the plate as the tying run. In a future world, Alomar might be this Jays team’s lead-off hitter. Here, he’s in the on-deck circle praying for a chance. White is hitting .167 for the tournament (15 for 90), has struck out 32 times, and has been called upon to bunt more than any other position player.</p><p>White hits a fly to right. Justice is under it, makes the catch. It’s finally over. The Modern Champions Tournament Grand World Series has been won by the 1995 Atlanta Braves.</p><p>You don’t often see 3 over X in the linescore:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*vZeQkVP7_XJzG_Y9cMH3_g.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s the first game in the Grand World Series where the Blue Jays never had a lead.</p><p>The Braves came back from being down 3 games to 1. They were losing going into the 7th inning of Game 5, which then was tied going into the 9th. Game 6 went extra innings. The Braves were 5–0 in games when facing elimination, since they were also behind 3–2 in the NLCS against the 2012 Giants. The Braves had lost the first two games of that series at home, then won the next two in San Francisco even after falling behind 3–0 in the first inning of Game 3. They were fighting for their lives for three weeks, and never folded.</p><p>The Most Valuable Player of the Grand World Series is Fred McGriff. Also receiving votes were Chipper Jones and Greg Maddux. McGriff winning MVP seemed unfathomable with his struggles in key moments early in the Series, but he hit .387 (12 for 31) with 4 home runs and 8 RBI. All of his four homers were meaningful — there was the go-ahead shot in the 9th inning of Game 5, the two home runs in Game 6, and even his 3-run jack in the Game 4 loss had repercussions. When that happened, Cito Gaston had to bring in Duane Ward which made Ward unavailable for Game 5. Who knows what would have happened if Ward could have pitched in the late innings of Game 5? Perhaps Wells wouldn’t have been in there to give up the home runs to McGriff and Justice. One thing leads to another — kind of a dumb song, but an apt statement.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FpIe-Cj071l0%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DpIe-Cj071l0&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FpIe-Cj071l0%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/6e6507ae7d7bf591f1a4965f805f0a52/href">https://medium.com/media/6e6507ae7d7bf591f1a4965f805f0a52/href</a></iframe><p>However, you can’t say with any conviction that the Blue Jays would have won Game 5 if they had more bullpen options, because Maddux would have pitched 11 or 12 innings if he had to.</p><p>The reason the ’95 Braves won both the World Series back then and this tournament is no secret. Here’s their tournament pitching stats:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Nvv4BinRyyV9UJnBtoMoKQ.png" /></figure><p>What can I say about the Blue Jays? I could tell they would be a tough out from their first series in the Qualifying Round against the Orioles. It’s a damn shame they got unlucky rolls in Game 7. They were just so impressive the whole way, particularly in how they beat teams that had played great in previous rounds. The 2017 Astros swept the 1989 A’s, then got shoved aside by the Blue Jays. The 1984 Tigers swept the 1998 Yankees, then <em>got swept</em> by the Blue Jays. We’re giving Joe Carter the Tournament MVP award, a baseball version of my favorite and coolest-looking postseason award, the <a href="https://www.nhl.com/news/nhl-conn-smythe-trophy-winners-complete-list/c-287709808">Conn Smythe Trophy</a> from the NHL which awards an MVP for the whole Stanley Cup Playoffs and not just the Final. It’s fitting that a player from a Canadian team wins it. As disheartening as his Game 7 error was, Carter’s impact throughout the tournament was just too great. He hit .363 and slugged .593 with 5 home runs and 18 RBI in 22 games.</p><p>Well, we have reached the end. This tournament never had a straight bracket, though I did intend to have one at the outset. I mentioned several times previously that the Tournament Executive Committee (me) had the right to maneuver teams from their natural matchup to avoid having a series where the same player was on both teams, a.k.a. The Jack Morris Rule. (That was also the main reason why I used the 1992 Blue Jays instead of 1993, because I didn&#39;t want Rickey Henderson to be playing for two teams.) We only had a duplicate player once, and of course it was Jack Morris in the unavoidable Tigers-Blue Jays ALCS.</p><p>I do think it’s cool that, after the fact, the tournament is a symmetrical bracket. Check out the seed numbers. They’re in the same spots on both sides.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*J57HdwyXe-wIwRY05cXrBA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Now there’s only one thing left to do: cancel my subscription to the Strat-O-Matic Card Viewer app. It served us well, most of the time.</p><p><strong>Epilogue</strong></p><p>The Modern Champions Tournament was an idea I came up with on our living-room couch, and then played the first game on our dining-room table, on June 7, 2022. It was the 1990 Reds against the 2008 Phillies. The game took about the same time of a real-life baseball game to play because I was just learning how to navigate the app for the cards, plus it was a close game with tons of strategy involved. The Reds won that game, 3–2. If the Phillies had romped 8–1 or something like that, would I have continued? Maybe. I just knew I was on to something that I thought could be great.</p><p>Quickly, I realized I had to move the game away from the dining room and into our spare/bar-room where I could leave it and play a few innings at a time whenever it was convenient. I thought it might take four months to finish, and it was seven. Game 7 of the Grand World Series was completed on January 9, 2023.</p><p>Nothing was skipped. Every at-bat was played out, even in blowouts. All rolls that landed properly in the box were counted. All stats were recorded after each game.</p><p>There were 79 games played. Home teams went 44–35. There were ten extra-inning games. 30 one-run games. Ten shutouts. Ten walk-off wins, but just one on a home run.</p><p>645 runs were scored (8.16 per game). 142 home runs were hit — 26 by the Braves, 20 by the Blue Jays. The other team to hit 20 was the 2008 Phillies, which they did in just 12 games.</p><p>The Blue Jays played 22 games and went 15–7 overall. Four teams played a mere 2 games.</p><p>I have played a lot of sports games in my lifetime, board and video. I would always think up fun storylines in my head for them and by the time I thought “I should write these down because it would make a good story”, it was too late and I was too deep into it. This time I saw the chance to write these recaps after each round, and I don’t care if 10 people read them, it’s been very fulfilling to do. If you have read even a small part of this, I thank you.</p><p>It was also a hell of a lot of fun to play. Here’s my Top 8 Moments because five weren’t enough. I originally had 6, but added two more while I was editing.</p><ol><li>Ryan Vogelsong’s “butcher-boy” hit off Cole Hamels to beat the Phillies in the 14th inning of NLDS Game 5</li><li>Roger McDowell’s 10th-inning balk to bring in the series-winning run for the Cardinals in Round of 16 Game 4 (the third of 3 balks that happened in the entire tournament, 2 of those by the ’86 Mets)</li><li>Fred McGriff’s 9th-inning home run in Game 5 of the Grand World Series</li><li>Javy Lopez 10th-inning walk-off home run in Game 6 of the GWS</li><li>Pablo Sandoval’s 7th-inning grand slam against the 1988 Dodgers in Round of 16 Game 5, to go from 3–1 down to 5–3 up</li><li>Duane Ward’s play to throw out Luis Polonia at home in the 9th inning of Grand World Series Game 4, preserving a one-run lead</li><li>Joe Carter’s 2-out, 2-run, single in the 8th inning to give the Blue Jays the lead over the Red Sox in Round of 16 Game 5</li><li>Eddie Perez pinch-hit go-ahead 2-run home run in the top of the 9th of NLCS Game 3</li></ol><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*PSCBVVMstTBrSG9vNjgiEA.jpeg" /><figcaption>Me holding the 79 scoresheets. You can bet I’m saving these.</figcaption></figure><p>I also thank and salute the people at Strat-O-Matic for their great game, my wife for buying it for me ❤️, and these 22 great baseball teams that accomplished something extremely difficult in winning a World Series. It’s hard even for a heavy favorite to go all the way, in any pro sport.</p><p>My aunt and cousins got me a book for Christmas. <a href="https://www.amazon.com/Grandest-Stage-History-World/dp/0385546254/ref=asc_df_0385546254/?tag=hyprod-20&amp;linkCode=df0&amp;hvadid=564687260077&amp;hvpos=&amp;hvnetw=g&amp;hvrand=11026359313139735032&amp;hvpone=&amp;hvptwo=&amp;hvqmt=&amp;hvdev=c&amp;hvdvcmdl=&amp;hvlocint=&amp;hvlocphy=9007095&amp;hvtargid=pla-1829038243832&amp;psc=1">The Grandest Stage: A History of the World Series</a> by Tyler Kepner of the New York Times. They had no idea. I’ll dig into that after I finish this.</p><p>That’s it for me in the game-playing world for a little while, unless I think of a way to do a Modern Stanley Cup Champions Playoff 🤔.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8b992a498c94" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strat-O-Matic Modern Champions Tournament, League Championship Series Highlights]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-league-championship-series-highlights-79104114312c?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/79104114312c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stratomatic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-series]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 21 Dec 2022 19:05:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-22T18:40:49.901Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>We have our Grand World Series, and an end in sight</em></p><p>We have reached the final four of the Modern Champions Tournament, after starting with 22 World Series championship teams since 1980. Like most NCAA basketball tournaments and NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs, we have some matchups and seed combinations that were totally unforeseen when the event started.</p><p>It’s the 3 and 9 seeds in the American League: the 1984 Tigers vs. the 1992 Blue Jays. The National League has 3 against 5: the 1995 Braves vs. the 2012 Giants.</p><p>We’re about to get into the LCS highlights, but first a quick recap:</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-qualifying-round-highlights-1fe96ed12f76">Part I</a>: An explanation of the tournament and its format, plus highlights of the Qualifying Round where almost every game was close and dramatic<br><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-round-of-16-games-1-and-2-highlights-ae174015c8a4">Part II</a>: Highlights of first two games of the eight series in the Round of 16, with the top seeds entering the field<br><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">Part III</a>: Conclusion of Round of 16 with many wild endings and scenarios<br><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-division-series-highlights-a8931706f3c0">Part IV</a>: Division Series highlights featuring the craziest ending yet which capped off the tournament’s best series</p><p>Here we go with the ALCS and NLCS, and like in real life the series length will increase to 7 games. We will soon know the matchup for the Grand World Series, and the end is finally in sight after many months of playing a few innings at a time whenever I get the chance.</p><p>Starting on <strong>Tournament Day 21…</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Juan Berenguer)</em></p><p>The Tigers make the interesting decision to stay on their pitching rotation with Berenguer, opting to use Jack Morris in Game 2 and Dan Petry in Game 3. Since the Tigers swept the 1998 Yankees in 3 games, Berenguer hasn’t pitched in 10 days, when he won the clinching game of the Round of 16 against the 2002 Angels. He would have to pitch one of the first 4 games of this ALCS anyway, and Detroit figured it was best to use him now, rather than in a later game with possibly more pressure and up to 2 weeks rest by that point.</p><p>Since Jack Morris is on both teams, the first time there has been a duplicate player in any series, the Tournament Executive Committee (me) declared the following:</p><p>(a) Morris cannot pitch for both teams in the same game<br>(b) prior to the start of the series, both teams must declare which 2 games Morris will be eligible for them to use. The higher-seeded Tigers had first choice, and picked Games 2 and 6. The Blue Jays picked 4 and 7, with the possibility of Morris pitching in relief or a short-rest start in Game 7. The Tigers also held the right to use Morris on three days rest for Game 5.</p><p>So, that meant Juan Berenguer was up, and the guy was not a bad pitcher. He would later go on to be an effective middle-reliever for the Twins and was part of their World Series winning team in 1987. He had a career ERA of 3.90 and a 67–62 record. He did more good than harm for his teams. He won a career-high 11 games in 1984.</p><p>Berenguer got out of a first-inning jam by striking out Joe Carter and getting Dave Winfield to ground into a double play. Then in the top of the 2nd, he had a chance for another escape when he struck out Manny Lee with bases loaded and 1 out. Next batter Devon White drew the third walk of the inning to forced in a run, which some in the Tiger Stadium crowd booed. 1–0, Toronto. Berenguer also allowed a career-high 79 walks in 1984.</p><p>Roberto Alomar then grounded to short for a would-be third out, but it was booted by the normally solid Alan Trammell. Another run scored, unearned. 2–0, Toronto. Bases still loaded. Slightly louder boos.</p><p>With Carter up, Berenguer then threw a wild pitch. 3–0, Toronto. Significant boos. Two runners still on.</p><p>Carter has been one of the tournament’s best players. He delivered the clutch hit at Fenway Park for the deciding run in the deciding game of that Round of 16 series. He started the rally in the bottom of the 9th of Game 3 in the Division Series against the 2017 Astros, leading to a comeback win which turned that series in the Blue Jays’ favor. And here, he blasted a 3-run home run to give Toronto a 6-run inning, pump the volume of the boos <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KOO5S4vxi0o">up to 11</a>, and send Berenguer to an early shower. Welp, that didn’t work.</p><p>6 runs in the 2nd inning, 5 unearned. Welcome to the American League Championship Series.</p><p>Pat Borders led off the 4th with a home run, and later Carter doubled in Alomar for his 4th RBI. In the next inning, a second surprising error by Trammell brought in Candy Maldonado, who had tripled, for another unearned run. Trammell had an uncharacteristically miserable game with his two errors in the field and three strikeouts at the plate.</p><p>Even in garbage time, the Blue Jays unbelievably got <em>four</em> more unearned runs after a 2-out error by pitcher Aurelio Lopez and subsequent hits.</p><p>The Tigers were coming off a thorough beating of the tournament’s top-seeded ’98 Yankees, but that meant nothing in this 13–1 drubbing on their home field in the tournament’s most lopsided game. <em>Ten</em> of the Blue Jays’ runs were unearned, and I’ve never seen that in my life.</p><p><strong>Day 22</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Jack Morris), Blue Jays lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Maybe you thought the next game would be the opener of Giants-Braves, but we’re playing the games in order of the “TV Schedule”, imagining the tournament is shown on MLB’s national broadcast carriers. We’re basically simulating a typical LCS structure, so we have two games on this day starting with Detroit at a probable 4:30 P.M. Eastern start, followed by Game 1 of the NLCS in Atlanta around 8:00 P.M.</p><p>Jimmy Key has been the tournament’s best pitcher to date, especially on the road where he is 3–0 with only two runs allowed. Until he gave up 4 in the 2nd inning of this one.</p><p>The stunning hit was a 3-run homer by 9th-place hitter Marty Castillo, a player whose existence I completely forgot about until it was time to look up the Tigers roster before their first tournament game. He was a backup catcher who could also play third base, and started against some left-handed pitchers. He came up with two on and two out and a run in, the Blue Jays thinking they would be getting out of the inning just down one. But Castillo went deep, and suddenly it felt like yesterday’s blowout was just a blip for the Tigers and the series would turn back around.</p><p>Carter hit a solo home run in the 4th to make it 4–1. The Blue Jays were far from beaten.</p><p>With one out and one on in the 5th, Pat Borders reached on an error by Morris. It’s ironic the ’84 Tigers were having fielding problems by pitchers, considering the next Tigers team to make the World Series in 2006 had <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/sports/2006/10/28/the-errors-of-their-ways-span-classbankheadtigers-undone-by-pitchers-miscuesspan/3fa88457-c909-48a2-b518-53ba8c08cd1c/">famously bad pitcher fielding</a> in that Series loss.</p><p>Manny Lee followed the error with an RBI single, so the Blue Jays were within two and had the tying runs on base. Devon White singled in Borders to make it 4–3. Alomar’s would-be-third-out sacrifice fly brought in Lee to tie the game with another unearned run, the 7–8–9 hitters for Toronto all scoring the runs in the inning.</p><p>Castillo led off the bottom of the 8th with a single for his third hit of the game. Lou Whitaker lined out. Key was removed for Duane Ward, and Detroit countered by bringing in Howard Johnson to pinch-run for Castillo. Johnson was a fast runner and Ward struggled to hold runners, but Johnson couldn’t get a good lead. Trammell then hit into a 4–6–3 double play to end the inning.</p><p>Willie Hernandez pitched a perfect 9th inning and retired the first two batters of the 10th. This was the sixth appearance of the tournament for the 1984 American League Cy Young and MVP; the previous five were all scoreless.</p><p>With two outs, Roberto Alomar came up and lifted a fly that carried deep to right and landed in the seats. Blue Jays lead, 5–4. From yesterday’s thundering boos with Berenguer walking the ballpark and Trammell’s poor fielding to today’s stunned silence except for the celebrating in the Blue Jays dugout.</p><p>Tom Henke got the save, ending it with Darrell Evans hitting into a 4–6–3 double play (of course the ball was hit to Alomar, maybe the greatest defensive second baseman of all-time), and the Blue Jays had themselves a what-just-happened, 10-inning, 5–4 win and a 2–0 lead in the ALCS against a team that had cruised through the last two rounds.</p><p>Some sport, eh?</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux)</em></p><p>The Giants were less than 48 hours removed from their incredibly dramatic, 14-inning, butcher-boy walk-off in Game 5 of the Division Series against the Phillies. Would the start of the NLCS be a let-down, or do they keep the momentum rolling?</p><p>Greg Maddux is normally not good for keeping your momentum rolling, except he walked Buster Posey and Hunter Pence to start the 2nd inning. Brandon Belt’s single loaded the bases. That brought up Ryan Theriot, who was starting because Gregor Blanco was injured when he was hit by a pitch in the Giants’ last game. Theriot has been a good role player throughout the tournament for the 2011 Cardinals and the 2012 Giants, and he’s made some big contributions in major moments.</p><p>Theriot singles to bring home 2 runs and advance Belt to third base, and then Belt would score on Brandon Crawford’s sacrifice fly. An early and surprising 3–0 lead for the Giants. They make it 4–0 next inning on a Posey RBI single.</p><p>It’s 4–1 in the bottom of the 6th when Fred McGriff and David Justice start the frame with singles. After Ryan Klesko strikes out, Bobby Cox starts making some moves.</p><p>The batter due up is Charlie O’Brien, who was the catcher for Maddux. Atlanta’s regular and offensively-much-better catcher, Javy Lopez, very rarely caught when Maddux was pitching. The role of a “personal catcher” seems to be a lot less prevalent now than in the 90s and early 2000s, but during Maddux’s tenure with the Braves, <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2002/10/05/sports/baseball-if-maddux-is-pitching-lopez-isn-t-catching.html">his personal catcher seemed to be Anybody But Lopez.</a></p><p>Down 4–1 here, with two runners on and Madison Bumgarner starting to tire, Cox could figure both O’Brien <em>and</em> Maddux would be pinch-hit for in this inning. He sends up Lopez for O’Brien, and Bumgarner walks him to load the bases. Giants’ manager Bruce Bochy then lifts MadBum for George Kontos.</p><p>Jeff Blauser pinch-hits for light-hitting shortstop Rafael Belliard, and doubles to score two runs. The slow Lopez has to hold at third. Second and third, 1 out, for the Braves. It’s a 4–3 game, and the Braves have to feel they will tie or take the lead here.</p><p>Maddux’s spot is next, and he’s removed for Mike Mordecai. If the Braves can get these runners home, Maddux would still be in line for the win despite this being his shortest outing of the tournament.</p><p>With the Giants playing the corner infielders in, Mordecai sharply lines out to Pablo Sandoval at third. Sandoval is able to beat the retreating Lopez to third base, doubling him off and ending the inning. The Giants maintain their one-run lead thanks to that stunning play.</p><p>Sandoval’s heroics continue in the top of the 8th when he hits a solo home run off Alejandro Pena. 5–3, Giants.</p><p>The insurance run was big because Atlanta did score in the bottom of the 9th when McGriff singled in Marquis Grissom with two outs. However, Justice grounded to second for the final out. The Giants hold on to take Game 1, 5–4. Banking a win over Greg Maddux feels like an early huge step forward.</p><p><em>(Note: I completely forgot Javy Lopez was supposed to be injured for this game. In the clinching game of the Braves’ Division Series win, Lopez was injured for the next 2 games; I even remember thinking at the time “well, it’s more like one game because Maddux will pitch one of those two.” I had played five other tournament games and written a very long Part IV of this since the last Braves game, so I didn’t remember. To fix this, I decided Lopez would obviously miss Game 2 and then he would be scratched for the next game Maddux starts, which will probably be Game 5. In the unlikely event the Braves get swept and Lopez only misses one game, then the mistake I made won’t have given them any advantage.</em></p><p><em>We can pretend that Lopez has one of those nagging “day-to-day” injuries, which is common enough in baseball.)</em></p><p><strong>Day 23</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-5 2012 Giants (Ryan Vogelsong) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Giants lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Welcome back, Ryan Vogelsong! He was the hero in Game 5 of the NLDS with his “butcher-boy” RBI bloop single in the bottom of the 14th. The two reasons Vogelsong was even batting to begin with were that he came on to get the final out in the top of the 14th and the Giants were out of pinch-hitters.</p><p>That base hit was greater than anything Vogelsong had done in the tournament at his real job of pitching. In two starts, he had given up 9 runs in 8.1 innings. He was particularly hit hard by the 1988 Dodgers in the Round of 16.</p><p>The Braves made contact against Vogelsong all night. They did not strike out even once against him, but unfortunately for the Braves most of their batted balls ended up in Giant gloves.</p><p>The Giants took a 1–0 lead in the top of the 2nd on a pair of singles and a Gregor Blanco sacrifice fly, and that score held up into the bottom of the 7th. David Justice drew a 2-out walk, and with power-hitting left-handed batter Ryan Klesko up next, Bruce Bochy lifted Vogelsong for lefty Jose Mijares. Klesko hit one high and deep to right, but it died at the warning track for the third out of the inning.</p><p>Vogelsong’s only hit allowed was a harmless single by Eddie Perez leading off the 3rd inning. Perez would be stranded on second base, and ended up being the only Brave to reach scoring position all game. Vogelsong was brilliant, and he’s had quite the week. It was just three days ago that he had the butcher-boy hit.</p><p>The Giants scored single runs in the 8th and 9th. The 8th-inning run was unearned since Blanco reached on an error by Tom Glavine (as pitcher errors have now become a tournament trend), and later scored on a Angel Pagan sac fly. Pablo Sandoval led off the 9th with a home run, and the final score was 3–0. The Giants take Games 1 and 2 in Atlanta by beating Greg Maddux and Tom Glavine, just like anyone would have obviously predicted.</p><p>Four Giants pitchers combined to 1-hit the Braves.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FY9myYc8Pn8o%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DY9myYc8Pn8o&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FY9myYc8Pn8o%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/38e1bb58dc97581b0f14d44572c110e5/href">https://medium.com/media/38e1bb58dc97581b0f14d44572c110e5/href</a></iframe><p>Blue Jays lead Tigers 2–0. Giants lead Braves 2–0. Every time I think I have a favored team in this tournament, they immediately cease to do anything right.</p><p>Four League Championship Series games, four wins by the road teams. Major League Baseball expanded the LCS round from 5 games to 7 in 1985. How many years has the road teams won the first two games in both series since then? Let’s find out.</p><p><em>:::looking:::</em></p><p><em>:::seeing a lot of years where road teams won 3 games, but not 4:::</em></p><p><em>:::still looking:::</em></p><p>Zero. Zero times.</p><p>This tournament is incredible. The results these dice and cards produce amaze me.</p><p><strong>Day 24</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Dan Petry) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Juan Guzman), Blue Jays lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Here’s the game the Tigers badly need, and they get off to a good start by scoring a run three batters in.</p><p>Things change on the 4th batter of the game. Lance Parrish rolled the injury number on his card, and the second roll to determine the severity came up as a 2-game injury. It’s essentially a three-game injury since he got hurt in the first inning here. The series would have to return to Detroit before Parrish can get back on the field.</p><p>It feels like a crippling loss for the Tigers, even though Parrish was struggling offensively in the tournament. He was 3 for 33 with a home run and 13 strikeouts, but you never want to lose a cleanup hitter with pop, and his absence would come into play later in this game.</p><p>Dan Petry has been great in his first two tournament starts, and he retired the Jays in order in the 1st. Dave Winfield led off the 2nd with a double. John Olerud singled to put runners on the corners. Candy Maldonado singled for his tournament-best 18th RBI to tie the game, and Olerud went first to third. Kelly Gruber singled to score Olerud and advance Maldonado to third as the Blue Jays were treating the basepaths like their own personal merry-go-round.</p><p>The Tigers played at double-play depth with runners on 1st and 3rd with no outs, even with 2 runs already in. Pat Borders grounded into a double play which scored Maldonado. Detroit got out of the inning down 3–1. Not great, but not dead. Long way to go.</p><p>Then the first five batters reached base in the bottom of the 3rd. Petry was yanked after Olerud’s RBI single made it 5–1. A massive disappointment for the Tigers to have one of their top pitchers get bombed in a must-win game.</p><p>Howard Johnson hit a solo home run in the 5th, to which the Blue Jays immediately responded with three more runs in the bottom half. Winfield and Olerud both had RBI doubles, as the middle of the Toronto lineup was just bludgeoning Tigers pitching.</p><p>The Blue Jays were cruising to a dominant 3–0 series lead and an all-but-assured spot in the Grand World Series. Juan Guzman started the 8th, ahead 8–2. Whitaker singled to lead-off, followed by a Trammell double to put runners on 2nd and 3rd. Kirk Gibson was up next, and even though he was having a miserable game at the plate and grounded into an inning-ending double play in the 5th when the game was still close, Cito Gaston decided to walk Gibson intentionally to set up a double-play opportunity.</p><p>The next batter was Marty Castillo, the backup catcher who came in to replace Parrish. Would Gaston have walked Gibson if Parrish was still in the game? Probably not. Despite Castillo’s good performance in Game 2, he was a still a light-hitting reserve that usually just played against left-handed pitchers, and the Tigers could not pinch-hit for him here because there was no other catcher.</p><p>Castillo hit a grounder to Gruber at third, and the Blue Jays went around the horn for the double play. Whitaker scored to make it 8–3, now with two outs in the 8th. Darrell Evans then singled in Trammell and advanced all the way to 3rd on Joe Carter’s third tournament error, which is a lot for a right fielder in 14 games.</p><p>Duane Ward came in to pitch and walked Chet Lemon to bring up Ruppert Jones with two on. Jones hadn’t hit well in the tournament, but he had some power against right-handed pitching and cranked a huge <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-division-series-highlights-a8931706f3c0">pinch-hit grand slam off David Cone in Game 1 of the Division Series against the 1998 Yankees.</a></p><p>Jones homered again here, and suddenly we had a one-run game at 8–7. Jones now led the Tigers with 7 RBI in the tournament, all of which came on a grand slam and a 3-run shot. The Tigers scored five runs in the 8th. The only batter not to reach base was Castillo, until Dave Bergman struck out after the Jones blast.</p><p>But whenever the Tigers scored in this game, the Blue Jays quickly countered. Winfield walked with two outs to move Roberto Alomar to second base. With the red-hot Olerud up next, Sparky Anderson brought in his left-handed Cy Young and MVP Willie Hernandez. Welp, that didn’t work again—Olerud singled to score Alomar. Olerud was 4 for 5 with three RBI and making a case for MVP of the series. The Blue Jays led, 9–7.</p><p>After Trammell drew a 2-out walk in the top of the 9th, Gibson bounced one back to closer Tom Henke for the game’s final play. The Blue Jays win a wild one, 9–7, to go up three games to none. They can clinch their spot in the Grand World Series tomorrow.</p><p><strong>Day 25</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 4: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Milt Wilcox) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris), Blue Jays lead series 3–0</em></p><p>With two outs in the bottom of the 1st, Winfield singled to extend the inning and get Olerud to the plate. Olerud doubled in 2 runs. Game over. Series over.</p><p>Well, ok, not really, but it sure felt that way. Trailing 3–0 after a Kelly Gruber home run in the 2nd, the Tigers had two runners on in the 4th and 5th, but hit into inning-ending double plays both times.</p><p>Those double plays had an effect on Sparky Anderson’s strategy in the 7th. Kirk Gibson walked and stole second. Ruppert Jones, batting cleanup with Parrish injured, reached on an Olerud error. With men on first and third, Howard Johnson pinch-ran for Jones. To take the double play out of the question, Johnson attempted to steal but was thrown out. It was the second time in the series that a Johnson pinch-running appearance was a total bust.</p><p>Gibson scored on a 2-out Barbaro Garbey single to make it 3–1, but the Blue Jays immediately answered like they had in Game 3. Roberto Alomar broke the game open with a 2-run single in the bottom of the 7th, followed by a Joe Carter RBI double.</p><p>The final was 6–2. The sweep was complete. The 1992 Toronto Blue Jays are the Modern Champions Tournament American League winners. Please rise for the singing of the Canadian national anthem:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FAbC1_vFgj6k%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DAbC1_vFgj6k&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FAbC1_vFgj6k%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/7adbb6b28a5df7e98f54e5c3c0c894ba/href">https://medium.com/media/7adbb6b28a5df7e98f54e5c3c0c894ba/href</a></iframe><p>Don’t be fooled by the Blue Jays 9-seed because there were much more gaudy win totals by the A.L. teams in the field. If the Blue Jays had been in the National League, their seed would have been 4. The Jays will have home-field advantage in the Grand World Series if the Giants win the NLCS because Toronto had 96 wins to the Giants’ 94.</p><p>The Braves will have home-field advantage over the Blue Jays should they come back and win the NLCS. The 1995 season was strike-shortened to 144 games; the Braves’ 90 wins gets prorated to 101 in a 162-game schedule.</p><p>The Blue Jays have gone through four rounds of the tournament without ever having home-field advantage. Now they have won six games in a row and have an astounding overall record of 12–3. Only the 2018 Red Sox won 2 games against them, which came in the Round of 16.</p><p>With such a dominant victory, it was difficult to come up with one player to be the MVP of the series. It’s hard to hit .588 and not win the award, but that’s what happened to John Olerud. <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/postseason/1992_ALCS.shtml">Just like real life in 1992</a>, the ALCS Most Valuable Player is Roberto Alomar, who hit .471 with a go-ahead 10th-inning home run in Game 2, plus 8 runs scored, 4 RBI, and his typical excellent defense which started three double plays in Game 2 alone.</p><p>So, the ALCS is over and the NLCS has a maximum of <em>five</em> games left. That’s nuts. The only similarity I can remember is when the 2007 Colorado Rockies swept the NLCS while Boston and Cleveland went the distance in the A.L. The Rockies had eight days off before Game 1 of the World Series. The most the Blue Jays will have here is six days off, but the Tournament Executive Committee (me) will start the Grand World Series earlier if the Giants finish off the Braves quickly.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain), Giants lead series 2–0</em></p><p>It sure looked like the Giants could finish off the Braves quickly when they scored 3 runs in the bottom of the 1st, capped by Brandon Belt’s two-out two-run double when he hit the weakness on John Smoltz’s card. Column 6, number 5.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*OwkTVZo2WnMvxqu_fDi90g.jpeg" /></figure><p>Whenever there’s a split result, a roll of the 20-sided die determines the outcome and that’s how Belt got a double. Hunter Pence beat the relay home to score from first.</p><p>A one-out single and two walks loaded the bases for the Braves in the 3rd. David Justice singled in a pair of runs. Ryan Klesko doubled to bring home one more run, but Justice tried to score from first and was nailed at the plate. However, now the game was tied 3–3. Maybe we will have a series.</p><p>John Smoltz the TV analyst has used the term “shutdown inning” countless times, but John Smoltz the pitcher couldn’t get one here. He threw the old 6–5 <em>again, </em>this time with Pence batting and it was <a href="https://www.sfchronicle.com/sports/giants/article/Bye-Bye-Baby-still-proving-soundtrack-for-16480159.php">Bye, Bye Baby</a> (a reference that will be understood by MLB Network highlight producers and anyone who’s a fan of the Giants’ local TV broadcasts).</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fdds-AAl5wbY%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Ddds-AAl5wbY&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fdds-AAl5wbY%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/f6674149ca341cbfc3433a5e57cd5005/href">https://medium.com/media/f6674149ca341cbfc3433a5e57cd5005/href</a></iframe><p>The 2-run home run put the Giants back in front, 5–3.</p><p>Rolling a 5 on the red dice isn’t easy to do. How many times do you throw a 5 in Monopoly? Rarely, of course. Now imagine doing it twice in one game to land on your opponent’s Marvin Gardens with three houses on it both times, when anything over a 6 would have been safe. Now imagine you have to roll a third die simultaneously and get the same number on that. 😧 As I was saying, this tournament amazes me.</p><p>Marquis Grissom led off the 4th with a triple and scored on a sac fly by Fred McGriff. This wild game was already 5–4 in the 4th inning.</p><p>The pitchers finally settle down so the score holds until the 7th. With three left-handed batters due up, the Giants brought in Javier Lopez, but McGriff led off with a double and went to 3rd on a groundout to second by Justice. Mike Devereaux, 5 for 9 in the tournament so far, was called on to pinch-hit for Klesko. Bruce Bochy countered by bringing in right-hander George Kontos. This could have been a spot for Santiago Casilla, except the pitcher’s spot was due to lead-off next inning for the Giants so Bochy figured he would use a pinch-hitter and then bring in Casilla.</p><p>Devereaux doubled to raise his tournament batting average to .600 with 4 RBI, and we had a tie game again. With two outs, Bochy intentionally walked Jeff Blauser to force Bobby Cox to pinch-hit for Smoltz. Mike Mordecai walked to load the bases, but Grissom struck out.</p><p>Casilla came out for his second inning in the top of the 9th. Seems like it wouldn’t be a Giants home game in this tournament if it wasn&#39;t tied or a one-run margin in the 9th.</p><p>Devereaux led off with a single. Javy Lopez flied out, then Blauser grounded out to second but Devereaux was able to advance. The pitcher’s spot was up again for the Braves. Cox had some options, though none of them great. He sent up light-hitting and lightly-used Eddie Perez.</p><p>Perez was the Braves’ third catcher, a rarity not just in this tournament but in most of baseball. The Braves carried three catchers with their unique Maddux/Lopez situation. Any team wants to avoid bringing their backup catcher into a game, out of fear the backup will be injured and you’re stuck without a competent receiver. I saw the consequences of losing both catchers in person in 1987 at Fenway Park when outfielder Mike Greenwell had to catch in the 10th inning because Boston had pinch-hit for both of their catchers while staging a 3-run comeback in the bottom of the 9th. <a href="https://www.upi.com/Archives/1987/07/17/Mike-Greenwell-forced-to-make-his-major-league-catching/9890553492800/">Greenwell had been the DH but he came in to catch in the 10th and it was painful</a> — one throwing error, two stolen bases against, a wild pitch, two walks, 7 runs for the Oakland A’s.</p><p>Almost all teams carry two catchers. The Braves having three gave them extra flexibility. Whenever Maddux pitched a complete game, they had a backup that wasn’t Lopez. When Maddux doesn’t go 9, they can use Lopez as a substitute and still have a backup. And, in this case, you could use Eddie Perez as a pinch-hitter in a non-Maddux game and still have Charlie O’Brien as a backup catcher.</p><p>So, that brought up Perez vs. Casilla. The Giants could have brought in Jeremy Affeldt since Perez can barely hit lefties, but knowing the Braves would make a counter-move, Bochy figured this was the best matchup for them.</p><p>Perez hit one high and deep to left, and out of the ballpark it went. A pinch-hit 2-run home run in the top of the 9th with two outs to give the Braves their first lead of the game at 7–5.</p><p>🤯</p><p>By the way, throughout this series I keep hearing Joe Buck’s voice in my head. You can easily hear him calling the Perez home run here. I’ve always said we are imagining this tournament is broadcast nationally, hence the TV Schedule for the order of the games. I had previously thought the coverage would be by Turner Sports and MLB Network, but let’s say the NLCS and Grand World Series will be on Fox with their classic long-time combination of Buck and Tim McCarver. Fox Sports carried the NLCS in even-numbered years, so Buck called the Giants’ wins in 2010, 2012, and 2014, another reason why it feels like he’s on the call here.</p><p>Pedro Borbon started the 9th since the Giants had three left-handed batters due up. After a 2-out walk to Brandon Crawford, closer Mark Wohlers came in to retire pinch-hitter Hector Sanchez on a lineout to second. The Braves get back in the series by taking Game 3, 7–5.</p><p>After this game, the Committee announces that the Grand World Series will begin in Toronto on Day 30 if the Giants were to win the NLCS in 5. That would be four days off for the Jays. Any other result and the GWS will start on its regularly-scheduled Day 32.</p><p><strong>Day 26</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-3 1995 Braves (Steve Avery) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Barry Zito), Giants lead series 2–1</em></p><p>In a series with Maddux, Glavine, Smoltz, Bumgarner, and Cain, of course it’s Steve Avery and Barry Zito who pitch the first game in this NLCS to be scoreless through a mere <em>two</em> innings.</p><p>However, Atlanta scored the first run of a game for the first time in the series on three straight singles in the top of the 3rd. Chipper Jones knocked in Grissom.</p><p>In the 5th, Mark Lemke drew a 2-out walk to bring up Jones again. The Braves had runners on first and second, and Bochy wanted a right-hander to face Chipper. The Strat-O-Matic app calculated the odds for Jones against all of the Giants’ reasonable choices, and Tim Lincecum was the clear top choice by five percent over the supposed 2nd-best option and ten percent better than Zito’s chances. The app said Lincecum had a 67 percent chance of getting Jones out to end the inning.</p><p>One swing later, it was 4–0 Braves. Chipper 4, Giants nothing. Welp. 🤷‍♂</p><p>Steve Avery, despite going 7–13 in 1995 with a 4.67 ERA, was almost flawless. It was more like his performance in the 1991 NLCS against Pittsburgh when he <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/sports/1991/10/17/braves-avery-olson-force-nlcs-to-limit-1-0/3c5df092-8c8b-4988-8c76-2fb2d2ff05a5/">won Games 2 and 6 on the road, both by 1–0 scores, earning the series MVP award</a>.</p><p>When Marco Scutaro singled with two outs in the 9th and went to second on defensive indifference with Sandoval up, he became the first Giant in scoring position the entire game. Let me say that one more time: the first Giant in scoring position the entire game with two outs in the 9th inning.</p><p>It was a three-hit complete-game shutout for Avery. The series is tied. The Braves are back.</p><p>Here’s the task ahead of the Giants: win two out of three games with Maddux, Glavine, and Smoltz pitching. They have already done it once in this series. They must do it a second time.</p><p><strong>Day 27</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 5: NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner), Series tied 2–2</em></p><p>Shut down completely by Avery the night before, of course the Giants lineup gets straight to work against Greg Maddux. Marco Scutaro doubles and Pablo Sandoval singles him to 3rd, then Buster Posey’s sacrifice fly gives the Giants a 1–0 first-inning advantage.</p><p>Brandon Belt and Gregor Blanco start the 2nd inning with singles to put runners on the corners. Brandon Crawford strikes out to bring up Bumgarner. Attempting a safety squeeze bunt is an option here, but instead Blanco steals second and then MadBum is swinging away with both runners in scoring position. He grounds out but gets a run home for an RBI and a 2–0 lead.</p><p>As I was playing the 4th inning of the game, the Strat-O-Matic app got stuck on this.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*oke7xyXs1GdCjbwdxdWtzw.jpeg" /></figure><p>It doesn’t stop “calculating”, and I can’t open up the cards to see them side-by-side. This is a little bit of a problem.</p><p>Earlier in the tournament, the app went down completely for several days. Since I wanted to play and couldn’t, I declared the next outdoor game was “rained out” and adjusted the schedule.</p><p>This is a little different. I can go to another section of the app and find the cards I need; I just can’t see batter versus pitcher side-by-side, and I can’t see what the actual calculated odds are for any matchup. I had used those odds to make quite a bit of managerial decisions, including bringing Lincecum in to face Chipper Jones and give up the three-run homer in the last game. (So, maybe it’s good that feature mysteriously went away.)</p><p>So, is this a rainout? No, because I can still play even though it just takes a little longer to navigate the app. But, we can say it’s raining and have some fun with that, as you’ll see in a few seconds.</p><p>David Justice homered to lead-off the 5th to cut the Giants lead to 2–1. But just when things were looking up for the Braves, Maddux rolled the triple-boxcars, 6–12, for a pitcher injury on the last out of the bottom of the 5th. The second roll then determined the outcome: 1 to 3 means Maddux has to be taken out; if it’s 4 to 6 he can stay in. It was a 3. Maddux was unfortunately out after just 5 innings.</p><p>Greg McMichael started the 6th, perhaps a little early for him but the Giants had 3–4–5 due up. Sandoval walked and Posey doubled to put runners on 2nd and 3rd. Pence then lined out to short. Borbon came in to face the lefties Belt and Blanco. Belt struck out, and Blanco popped out to second. The Giants didn’t score. They still led 2–1.</p><p>Fred McGriff walked to start the 7th, and Justice singled to put men on 1st and 2nd. Ryan Klesko pinch-hit for Mike Devereaux, even though this set up a lefty-lefty matchup but Bobby Cox was going for some pop. What the Braves got instead of pop was a 6–4–3 double play.</p><p>Charlie O’Brien was up next, and Maddux was out of the game but with the Braves unable to use Javy Lopez due to injury, O’Brien lined out to end the inning. Both teams had big chances to score in consecutive half-innings, and both got nothing.</p><p>Marco Scutaro came up with 2 on and 1 out in the bottom of the 7th. The Braves brought in Alejandro Pena to face “The Blockbuster”. <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/24/sports/baseball/giants-midseason-trade-for-marco-scutaro-keeps-getting-better.html">That’s the nickname Scutaro had in the 2012 Giants’ clubhouse</a>, as in he was their blockbuster trade in late July, a journeyman second baseman acquired from Colorado for journeyman utility player Charlie Culberson. It was a cute thing to laugh about.</p><p>The Giants also acquired Hunter Pence from the Phillies four days later, but don’t let facts get in the way of a good story.</p><p>Pena was one of the Braves’ more reliable relievers. He came in for Borbon, and Scutaro had a better chance of hitting into a double play and less chance of getting a hit against the right-hander. We don’t know the exact odds, though, since the app went on the fritz.</p><p>Scutaro rolled the one magic number on his card, 3–4, and The Blockbuster went Bye, Bye Baby. Three-run home run, 5–1 Giants.</p><p>Was it raining in San Francisco? Use your imagination, and remember this iconic moment from the real 2012 NLCS when Scutaro was the MVP.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgfycat.com%2Fifr%2Fthirdglaringfrog&amp;display_name=Gfycat&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgfycat.com%2Fthirdglaringfrog&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fthumbs.gfycat.com%2FThirdGlaringFrog-size_restricted.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=gfycat" width="502" height="276" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/99426fd83df8706f1bc8cad6fedefe3b/href">https://medium.com/media/99426fd83df8706f1bc8cad6fedefe3b/href</a></iframe><p>Greg Maddux was rightly a unanimous Cy Young Award winner in 1995, and finished third in the National League MVP vote. His record that season was 19–2.</p><p><em>And two</em>. Two losses. Now he has two losses in this series.</p><p>OK, Maddux went 3–1 in the postseason that year with a loss in Game 5 of the World Series, so he really lost three games but you know how stats work and regular-season numbers being the ones that count. Again, facts and good stories.</p><p><strong>Day 28</strong></p><p>Idle - no games. Travel day. The Blue Jays are still waiting.</p><p><strong>Day 29</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 6: NL-5 2012 Giants (Ryan Vogelsong) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Giants lead series 3–2</em></p><p>The 1995 Atlanta Braves were the team that finally broke through and won it all after three previous postseason attempts. When their longtime core’s run was over, 1995 was still the only championship. Some more disappointing losses followed, with 3 of those eliminations happening in the NLCS at home (1997 vs. Florida, 1998 vs. San Diego, 2001 vs. Arizona). Now the ’95 champions are in danger of the same fate.</p><p>The Braves were counting on Ryan Vogelsong not being as dominant as he was in Game 2. The tension was palpable early on. The Braves got runners on 2nd and 3rd with 1 out in the bottom of the 2nd, but Rafael Belliard struck out and Tom Glavine grounded out.</p><p>Brandon Crawford singled to lead-off the 3rd. Vogelsong came up intending to sacrifice, but incredibly he bunted too well and beat it out for a single. What is it with the good fortune the 2012 Giants have with pitchers bunting, both in real life and in tournament life?</p><p>Angel Pagan then walks, and the bases are loaded with nobody out. Seems like a prime situation for The Blockbuster, but Scutaro pops out to 2nd and Sandoval grounds into a 4–6–3 double play. The Giants had bases loaded and no outs, and ended up with no runs.</p><p>It’s still scoreless in the 5th, with the bottom third of the Giants lineup due. Gregor Blanco singles and steals second. Crawford singles him in. SFG leads, 1–0.</p><p>Jeff Blauser pinch-hits for Belliard to start the bottom of the 5th, and walks. Glavine bunts Blauser to second. Marquis Grissom lines out. Vogelsong is an out away from getting back to the dugout with the lead.</p><p>Mark Lemke draws a walk.</p><p>Chipper Jones draws a walk.</p><p>Fred McGriff. Draws. A. Walk. Run scores. Game is tied.</p><p>That’s the first run Vogelsong has allowed in the series. The inning oddly felt like slow torture and a lightning strike at the same time. From completely in control to out of control. You can picture the atmosphere in Atlanta with the fans doing the tomahawk chop, and the ballpark feeling like it was closing in on Vogelsong. It was time to think about whether to take him out.</p><p>Stepping out of the simulated baseball realm and into the board-game-playing realm, this is where I have to note that all four walks in this inning came off the batters’ cards. In other words, <a href="https://www.baseball-almanac.com/players/pitchinglogs.php?p=gibsobo01&amp;y=1968">Bob Gibson of 1968</a> or <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/e/eckerde01.shtml">Dennis Eckersley of 1989–1991</a> could have been pitching and the walks still would have happened.</p><p>Vogelsong was still a fresh pitcher. He wasn’t tired yet, meaning he wasn’t extra suspectible to allowing a hit. You could say he was “just missing”, or “getting squeezed” by the umpire on these pitches out of the strike zone.</p><p>Two games ago in a similar situation, again with two outs in the 5th, the Giants played the odds and pulled Barry Zito for Tim Lincecum. He gave up a 3-run shot to Chipper Jones.</p><p>Bochy is riding with Vogelsong here against David Justice. The dice are thrown. It comes up 1–6. I don’t even have to look. That’s a grand slam. 5–1, Braves. 5 runs on one hit in the inning.</p><p>Boy, it feels like a lot of pitching decisions I’m making on behalf of these teams aren’t working. 😞</p><p>Again though, it was off a batter’s card. If Justice had faced a left-handed pitcher instead, he was still 75 percent to hit a home run and 25 percent to hit a triple. The Braves still would have taken a big lead.</p><p>That was finally it for Vogelsong. He walked off the mound with the crowd chopping and chanting like crazy. From cruising to losing in no time.</p><p>It reminded me of a Braves’ home playoff game in 2018 against the Dodgers that I edited at MLB Network. There were two outs and a man on when the Braves got a hit and an error to put runners on 2nd and 3rd. An intentional walk loaded the bases with Braves pitcher Sean Newcomb up next. With the stadium getting louder with each pitch, Walker Buehler walked Newcomb to force in a run and then Ronald Acuna Jr. blasted a grand slam.</p><p><a href="https://www.mlb.com/video/must-c-acuna-s-grand-slam-c2514838083">Must C: Acuna&#39;s grand slam | 10/07/2018</a></p><p>Here in Game 6, the Braves only scored in one of their eight offensive innings. It was more than enough. The Giants got one of the runs back in the top of the 6th, but never threatened again. We’re going the distance.</p><p>On top of the loss, the Giants get a terrible break when Santiago Casilla is injured covering first base on the third out of the 8th inning. The severity roll comes up as the dreaded 2, the worst possible outcome. Casilla is out 2 games, meaning the Giants will be without their top set-up reliever in Game 7 and for Game 1 of the Grand World Series should they make it.</p><p>Bruce Bochy was asked afterward if Madison Bumgarner was available tomorrow. The answer was everyone’s available.</p><p><strong>Day 30</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 7: NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain) at NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz), Series tied 3–3</em></p><p>Lemke and Jones singled with one out in the 1st. That brought up Fred McGriff, who hit a grounder to short that Brandon Crawford threw away for a two-base error. Lemke scored to put the Braves up, 1–0.</p><p>David Justice struck out, then Bochy decided to intentionally walk Ryan Klesko to set up a righty-righty matchup of Cain against Javy Lopez. Whether that was a good decision is something we’ll never know because Cain threw a wild pitch to advance the runners. Jones scored to make it 2–0, and runners were on 2nd and 3rd again. Both runs unearned. Now Lopez was intentionally walked and Rafael Belliard tapped one back to the mound to get out of the inning. A terrible start for the Giants, eerily similar to the Tigers in Game 1 of the ALCS, but they’re not dead yet.</p><p>John Smoltz led off the bottom of the 2nd, and he hit a grounder to Crawford for another error. What, does he have the yips?</p><p>This is a shocker, frankly. In my 9 years at the Network, I cut a lot of Giants games and didn’t see many players throughout the whole big leagues that were defensively better than Crawford. He would consistently make the difficult plays. He’s won four Gold Gloves at one of the sport’s most-important defensive positions. He’s made three All-Star teams.</p><p>Pardon me for a little tangent, but here’s how highly I thought of Crawford’s defense. Remember this play in 2014?</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FTbI54dTaFT4%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DTbI54dTaFT4&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FTbI54dTaFT4%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/152b351270b425decc21c48ec940f98b/href">https://medium.com/media/152b351270b425decc21c48ec940f98b/href</a></iframe><p>This was The Bumgarner Game, the game that inspired the question if MadBum is available for the Giants in this Game 7. There were 2 outs in the bottom of the 9th, the Giants leading by a run. This play sparked so much debate in and around baseball of whether Royals’ third-base coach Mike Jirschele should have sent Alex Gordon home and forced the Giants to make the potential World Series-ending play at the plate. That debate also took place among the MLB Network edit production staff. It was easy to say they should have sent Gordon since next batter Salvador Perez popped up to end the Series, but my answer was always “No way, Crawford would have thrown him out by a mile.” He made a great pick for the cut-off, too.</p><p>Don’t just take my word for it, though. <a href="https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/12485525/mlb-penultimate-play">Take the word of every person who was on the field or in the dugouts that night.</a> Gordon himself says he would have been out. So did Jirschele, so did Royals manager Ned Yost.</p><p><em>(Side note: Yes, I edited this game too. Had to get a 9-minute highlight on the air for our postgame show 20 minutes after the final out. I think it was 20; it felt like that, anyway. The whole thing was kind of a blur.)</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*DUtigZR9jtpRyjZx3EijpA.jpeg" /></figure><p>I know I’m getting off course, so let’s get back to our game here.</p><p>Crawford was due to lead-off the 3rd, but Joaquin Arias pinch-hit and grounded out. That was a tough move to do to a good player who has found a way to get on base in some key moments throughout the tournament, despite an underwhelming batter’s card from his first full big-league season. However, one error is “ok, you’ll get ’em next time”, two errors on two chances in Game 7 is “we don’t time for this”.</p><p>Pagan and Scutaro drew 2-out walks later in the 3rd, but Sandoval popped up to second. Cain kept walking the tightrope and held the Braves to just those two runs through 5 innings, which felt like a survival test.</p><p>Mark Lemke made a diving catch of a Scutaro line drive to lead-off the 6th. Sandoval then homered for the perceived momentum shift. The Giants were within a run. This was the Kung Fu Panda’s third home run of the NLCS, all of them in Atlanta and all in big moments.</p><p>Posey then lined out on <em>another</em> diving catch by Lemke, an unsung hero of the ’95 Braves who was an incredible pest in this series. Pence struck out to end the inning, and the momentum shift was halted.</p><p>Javy Lopez tripled with one out in the bottom of the 6th. The Giants had to tell themselves that if there was ever a good time to give up a triple, it was in front of Belliard and Smoltz with one out. With the infield playing in, Belliard lined a single to left to score Lopez and make it a 3–1 game.</p><p>Brandon Belt singled to lead-off the 7th. Ryan Theriot was up next because Gregor Blanco got hit by a pitch in the 5th and had to be taken out. Theriot grounded into a 6–4–3 double play to kill that potential rally. It was getting late for San Francisco.</p><p>Pagan tripled with one out in the 8th. Another prime situation for Scutaro, but he popped up to short. Smoltz was then replaced after 7.2 solid innings. Alejandro Pena came in to face Sandoval in another clutch spot. Panda grounded out to first, and the Braves were three outs away.</p><p>Madison Bumgarner came in to pitch the bottom of the 8th. Normally this would be the inning for Santiago Casilla, though in this game a healthy Casilla might have been used in the 6th or 7th innings.</p><p>This was not 2014, or even the forgotten <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/PHI/PHI201010230.shtml">Game 6 of the 2010 NLCS when Bumgarner pitched 2 innings in relief against the Phillies</a>. With one out, Mike Mordecai singled as a pinch-hitter for Pena. Grissom hit a fly down the right-field line that Pence couldn’t get to, and then Pence bobbled the ball allowing pinch-runner Luis Polonia to score and Grissom to get to 3rd. This is the 72nd tournament game, and only the second time a team committed three errors. The other was of course the ’84 Tigers.</p><p>4–1, Braves. The Giants appeared defeated, which then was punctuated by Lemke’s 2-run home run. 3 runs allowed for Bumgarner in one-third of an inning. Welp. 🤦‍♂</p><p>Posey homered in the 9th, but it was meaningless. The final was 6–2. The 1995 Atlanta Braves are the Modern Champions Tournament National League winners. They will face the 1992 Blue Jays in the Grand World Series, starting in 2 days. It will determine The Team Of The First Half Of The 90s and/or The Team Of The Last 40 Years Since That What This Tournament Is Supposed To Be. Probably the former.</p><p>Listen to Bob Costas’ call of the Braves getting the final out in 1995. I wonder if members of the Blue Jays who had won two World Series, one of them <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/postseason/1992_WS.shtml">against the Braves in 1992</a>, heard that and thought, “Excuse me?”</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2Fetf9rcbhfTM%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3Detf9rcbhfTM&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2Fetf9rcbhfTM%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/06daffbfb2327b8bb1315de06f75dc96/href">https://medium.com/media/06daffbfb2327b8bb1315de06f75dc96/href</a></iframe><p>They’ll settle it on the field in our next chapter.</p><p>It was another close call for the Most Valuable Player of the NLCS but the choice is Mark Lemke, so we have a pair of second basemen winning the MVP awards. Steve Avery was actually considered despite only pitching one game, but his Game 4 shutout gave Atlanta a huge boost when they could have gone down 3–1. Chipper Jones and David Justice hit home runs of major importance, but couldn’t match the consistency of Lemke throughout the series. Lemke hit .308 and had a .419 on-base percentage, was perfect defensively, and always seemed to be in the middle of everything. He was involved in almost every big inning the Braves had, scoring 6 runs.</p><p>A quick salute to the Giants. They are another team that I’ll miss and thank for the memories because they played so many tight, interesting, and sometimes crazy games. They went the distance in all three series they played and provided some of the tournament’s greatest moments, from the Panda Slam in Los Angeles to the 14th-inning butcher-boy to beat the Phillies in their fourth extra-inning game of this thing. It’s wild to think that they got within one game of the Grand World Series after all that, but their overall record in 17 games was 9–8.</p><p>So, we say goodbye to them as we are finally down to 2 teams from the 22 that started this tournament back in June. Here’s how they got there:</p><p><strong>1992 Toronto Blue Jays (#9 seed in American League bracket)<br></strong>Qualifying Round: Defeated 1983 Orioles 2 games to 0 (Scores: 2–0, 5–3)<br>Round of 16: Defeated 2018 Red Sox 3 games to 2 (Scores: 3–11, 7–3, 12–5, 4–6, 3–2)<br>Division Series: Defeated 2017 Astros 3 games to 1 (Scores: 11–2, 0–1, 4–3, 7–4)<br>League Championship Series: Defeated 1984 Tigers 4 games to 0 (Scores: 13–1, 5–4 (10 innings), 9–7, 6–2)</p><p><strong>1995 Atlanta Braves (#3 seed in National League bracket)<br></strong>Round of 16: Defeated 2001 Diamondbacks 3 games to 0 (Scores: 4–3, 7–1, 7–2)<br>Division Series: Defeated 2011 Cardinals 3 games to 1 (Scores: 5–0, 9–4, 2–4, 1–0)<br>League Championship Series: Defeated 2012 Giants 4 games to 3 (Scores: 4–5, 0–3, 7–5, 4–0, 1–5, 5–2, 6–2)</p><p>Success in baseball is very fragile, and both teams were in serious danger of getting bounced at some point. The Blue Jays were down 2–0 in the 8th inning of Game 5 at Fenway Park against Chris Sale. They were also one inning away from being down 2–1 to the Astros in that series before Ken Giles blew the save, and then who knows what would have happened?</p><p>The Braves just had Greg Maddux lose twice in the NLCS and still won it. It’s very hard to win 4 out of 5 games after dropping the first two at home. Plus, the Braves trailed 3–0 after the first inning in Game 3. You have to give them credit for their resilience.</p><p>Maddux is likely to start Game 1 of the GWS, but the Braves have a big decision to make about their pitching rotation. Either Glavine pitches Game 2 on three days rest, or they give Avery the ball. Doing that would push Glavine to Game 3 and Smoltz to Game 4, then they could go Maddux-Glavine-Smoltz for 5, 6, and 7 with Glavine and Smoltz on short rest. That’s how the Braves are leaning, but it’s undecided at this time.</p><p>Here’s the probable pitchers for the Grand World Series. Well, well, well, check out what we could have in Game 7: <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8m1LLARdYnM">Jack Morris vs. John Smoltz</a>. Wouldn’t that be something?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*T_4YO-dyfyNkPVf6aAJ1EQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>We’ll be back in a few weeks to wrap this up.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=79104114312c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strat-O-Matic Modern Champions Tournament, Division Series Highlights]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-division-series-highlights-a8931706f3c0?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/a8931706f3c0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stratomatic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tournaments]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-series]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 21 Nov 2022 17:38:20 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-15T02:02:16.986Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>The wildest series and wildest ending yet</em></p><p>I’m going to start this fourth installment of the highlights from my Modern Champions Tournament, played on Strat-O-Matic baseball, with an old storytelling trick called the flash-forward tease.</p><p><strong><em>It’s Game 5 of the National League Division Series in San Francisco. We’re in the bottom of the 14th inning, and Cole Hamels is coming in to pitch for the Phillies…</em></strong></p><p>Cole Hamels? He didn’t start Game 5? Is he in for the save? The 14th inning?</p><p>(Shout out to one of my favorite shows, Secret Base’s <a href="https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUXSZMIiUfFT6WwhB2Sk2gqz7agE9FlLg">Rewinder</a>, where I lifted that idea from.)</p><p>We’ll get there, but I’ll just say it was so jaw-dropping I feel the need to hook you in right away. I don’t even care if you skim the other games and just read about that series. But if you would like the details of the rest of the tournament and how we got down to the League Championship Series matchups, thanks and read on. First, a reminder of where we left off.</p><p>Here’s <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-qualifying-round-highlights-1fe96ed12f76">Part I</a>, an explanation of the tournament format and the highlights of the Qualifying Round. (TL;DR summary: it’s a tournament of World Series champions since 1980 with each franchise only represented once, with all games played on Strat-O-Matic baseball by me)</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-round-of-16-games-1-and-2-highlights-ae174015c8a4">Part II</a> recapped the first two games in each Round of 16 series. <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">Part III</a> covered the conclusion of that round and a set-up for the Division Series. Here’s our matchups:</p><p><strong>A.L. Division Series</strong><br>(1) 1998 Yankees vs. (3) 1984 Tigers<br>(4) 2017 Astros vs. (9) 1992 Blue Jays</p><p><strong>N.L. Division Series<br></strong>(3) 1995 Braves vs. (11) 2011 Cardinals<br>(5) 2012 Giants vs. (8) 2008 Phillies<br><em>All series are best-of-5</em></p><p>Let’s start with <strong>Tournament Day 13</strong> (2 games).</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Kyle Lohse) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux)</em></p><p><strong>How They Got Here: </strong>Cardinals defeated 2019 Nationals 2 games to 0 in the Qualifying Round, defeated 1986 Mets 3 games to 1 in Round of 16; Braves defeated 2001 Diamondbacks 3 games to 0 in Round of 16</p><p>Kyle Lohse was brilliant and outpitched Dwight Gooden in Game 1 of the Cards’ Round of 16 upset of the N.L.’s top-seeded 1986 Mets. They were asking him to do it again, this time against Greg Maddux.</p><p>The Strat-O-Matic app which is used to match up the batter’s card against a pitcher’s card also calculates the odds for various outcomes. It had Braves second baseman Mark Lemke with an 0.8 percent chance to hit a triple against Lohse. Lemke then hit 2 triples in his first 2 at-bats. He scored both times, and also drove in another run. All that plus a Ryan Klesko solo home run in the 2nd inning added up to a 4–0 Braves lead in the 3rd and an early shower for Lohse.</p><p>Maddux pitched a 3-hitter, all singles. It was no contest. 5–0 Braves was the final with Chipper Jones adding a late solo shot.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Jack Morris) at AL-1 1998 Yankees (David Cone)</em></p><p><strong>How They Got Here: </strong>Tigers defeated 2002 Angels 3 games to 1 in Round of 16; Yankees defeated 1985 Royals 3 games to 0 in Round of 16</p><p>Two batters into the game at the old Yankee Stadium and the visitors had a 1–0 lead. Lou Whitaker doubled and scored on Alan Trammell’s single.</p><p>Paul O’Neill hit a 2-run homer in the bottom half of the 1st to give the Yankees a 2–1 lead and this was quickly not shaping up to be a pitchers’ duel. The Tigers tied it in the top of the 2nd, then the Yankees plated 2 in the bottom of the 3rd to lead 4–2.</p><p>In the top of 5th, David Cone misplaced the strike zone. Trammell and Kirk Gibson walked after Whitaker’s one-out double. Cone threw a wild pitch that scored Whitaker to make it 4–3. Lance Parrish then drew Cone’s third consecutive walk to reload the bases.</p><p>Darrell Evans struck out for the second out of the inning. Manager Sparky Anderson then played a hunch and sent up Ruppert Jones to pinch-hit for Larry Herndon, who had struck out twice previously. Jones had been playing semi-regularly as the starting left-fielder against right-handed pitching, though Herndon got the start here.</p><p>What Jones had was pop, and he made Sparky’s hunch pay off with a stunning grand slam to put Detroit ahead 7–4 and knock Cone out of the game.</p><p>Jack Morris scratched and clawed his way through six innings with 5 runs allowed, but got two key double plays in the 5th and 6th. Detroit’s rock-solid bullpen of Bill Scherrer, Aurelio Lopez, and Willie Hernandez went the final three frames to send the Yankee fans home bewildered. The Tigers take Game 1, 7–5.</p><p><strong>Day 14 </strong>(4 games)</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Chris Carpenter) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Braves lead series 1–0</em></p><p>We’re going right back to Atlanta to start a 4-game day with the others taking place later in Houston, New York, and San Francisco. This tournament does follow a “TV schedule” that closely resembles what happens in real life during the postseason.</p><p>The Cardinals were counting on their ace, Chris Carpenter, to go deep into the game after the prior day’s short start by Lohse. However, those plans took a big hit in the bottom of the 2nd when Klesko homered again, this time a 3-run shot after Fred McGriff and David Justice reached.</p><p>Javy Lopez followed the Klesko blast with a single, and then the Braves used some unconventional strategy. 8th hitter Rafael Belliard sacrificed Lopez to 2nd with pitcher Tom Glavine due up next. One of the stronger hitting pitchers of his day, Glavine singled to score Lopez and it was 4–0 Braves in the early innings for the second straight game.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2F4ltD21rYWVw%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3D4ltD21rYWVw&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2F4ltD21rYWVw%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/5f933c46bdc65948bd27f330b57b8af5/href">https://medium.com/media/5f933c46bdc65948bd27f330b57b8af5/href</a></iframe><p>Carpenter had to be removed for a pinch-hitter in the top of the 5th, meaning the Cardinals’ starting pitchers only went a combined 6 innings in the first two games of the series.</p><p>David Justice hit a 3-run home run in the 8th. The Braves won 9–4 for their fifth straight win of the tournament without a loss.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone) at AL-4 2017 Astros (Justin Verlander)</em></p><p><strong>How They Got Here: </strong>Blue Jays defeated 1983 Orioles 2 games to 0 in Qualifying Round, defeated 2018 Red Sox 3 games to 2 in Round of 16; Astros defeated 1989 Athletics 3 games to 0 in Round of 16</p><p>An RBI triple by Evan Gattis and a subsequent passed ball gave the Astros a 2–0 lead in the 2nd, but Toronto’s second time through the lineup against Justin Verlander produced a big rally. With a run already in, a 2-run double by Pat Borders gave the Jays a 3–2 lead. Manny Lee then singled in two more, and the Blue Jays had a 5-run inning in the 4th with 4 of those runs driven in by the 8th and 9th hitters.</p><p>Verlander would go 6 innings, but the Blue Jays feasted against the Astros’ bullpen. Borders, Dave Winfield, and Kelly Gruber all homered. Toronto cleared their bench in the 9th inning and still scored two more runs to build up their lead to 11–2. Cone went the distance with 9 strikeouts. It’s the Astros’ first loss of the tournament, making the Braves the only team yet to lose.</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Dan Petry) at AL-1 1998 Yankees (Andy Pettitte), Tigers lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Andy Pettitte pitched plenty of Game 2s in postseason series over his Yankee career. None worse than this one.</p><p>Lance Parrish hit a 3-run home run in the top of the first, and three batters later it was Chet Lemon going deep for two more. Pettitte was done after recording a mere two outs. The Tigers led 5–0 before the Yankees ever came to bat.</p><p>Perhaps you’ve noticed a trend of 5-run innings. They have occurred in four straight games, two of them by the Tigers. Kirk Gibson added a 2-run shot in the 5th to make it 7–0. The Yankees put up 3 in the 6th, two of them on a Derek Jeter home run, but the rest of the game was a formality. The final was 8–3 Tigers, and they were one win away from eliminating the favored 114-win Yankees after taking the first two in the Bronx.</p><p>Jeter was asked how they remain confident despite the 0–2 hole. “Duque and Boomer,” said the captain. With Orlando Hernandez and David Wells slated to start Games 3 and 4 in Detroit, the Yanks did have a perceived pitching advantage.<br><em>(Author’s Note: OK, a little embellishment there by me with the quote.)</em></p><p><em>Game 1: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Cole Hamels) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Ryan Vogelsong)</em></p><p><strong>How They Got Here: </strong>Phillies defeated 1990 Reds 2 games to 1 in the Qualifying Round, defeated 2016 Cubs 3 games to 1 in the Round of 16; Giants defeated 1988 Dodgers 3 games to 2 in Round of 16</p><p>This series got crazy, from the first game on. For starters, the Tournament Executive Committee (me) suspended Brett Myers 5 games for his role in the brawl in the Phillies’ clinching game against the Cubs (see <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">Part III</a>). In other words, Myers is out for the series and the Phillies are down a pitcher.</p><p>Ryan Vogelsong was starting for the Giants because they had to use Matt Cain and Madison Bumgarner four times in their 5-game series with the Dodgers. Hamels singles and scores a run himself in the top of the 3rd, which made it 2–0 Phillies at the time. Unfortunately, disaster strikes in the bottom of the inning when Vogelsong nails Hamels in the leg with a comeback line drive. Hamels recovers to get the out, but is forced to leave the game after just 2.2 innings. So now the Phils have to piece together another long night from the bullpen, which they have done before successfully.</p><p>It goes fine until the bottom of the 5th, now with the Phillies ahead 4–0. With bases loaded and one out, Aubrey Huff is announced to pinch-hit for Vogelsong. Philadelphia counters by removing Chad Durbin for lefty Scott Eyre. The Giants counter that counter with Joaquin Arias becoming the new pinch-hitter, and he doubles in two runs to cut the deficit in half. Marco Scutaro comes through with another RBI single and it’s 4–3.</p><p>Ryan Madson pitches a scoreless 6th and 7th. Then the Phillies bring in J.C. Romero in the 8th, still leading by a run. Romero has to face right-handed batters, so it’s not an ideal situation for him, but the Phillies were low on options with their high-leverage relievers. Closer Brad Lidge was warming up, though the Phillies were hoping not to need him for a 2-inning save since he’d likely also have to pitch tomorrow at some point.</p><p>Scutaro led off with a single. Romero has a terrible hold rating, so Scutaro attempted to steal second but was thrown out by Carlos Ruiz. That out appeared to be big when Pablo Sandoval doubled. Charlie Manuel decided it had to be time for Lidge now, with 2012 National League MVP Buster Posey coming to the plate. Leaving a left-hander in for Posey with the tying run in scoring position would be detrimental to winning.</p><p>But, Posey was MVP because he could hit righties too. He singled to score Sandoval and tie the game, meaning 2008 Brad Lidge had just blown his first save (albeit with an inherited runner on 2nd and the MVP batting) after going 41 for 41 in that season and staying perfect in the postseason.</p><p>I could imagine the Phillies broadcasters getting frustrated. “If Cole Hamels doesn’t get hit by that liner, we’re back at the hotel already with a 1–0 lead,” Larry Andersen might say on the radio. “Absolutely,” Scott Franzke would probably say in agreement.</p><p>Lidge gets out of the 8th, and also pitches a scoreless 9th despite Brandon Crawford’s lead-off double.</p><p>Due to some earlier lineup changes, the pitcher’s spot, then occupied by Lidge, was on deck when the top of the 10th ended with Shane Victorino flying out. So the Phillies make a double switch, removing Victorino, moving Jayson Werth to center field, and inserting Geoff Jenkins in right field. J.A. Happ came in to pitch, taking Victorino’s lineup slot so Jenkins would lead-off an 11th inning. Jenkins had not played in the entire tournament to date. You know that old saying about how when you come off the bench in baseball, the ball will find you?</p><p>Sandoval led off with a single. Happ threw a wild pitch. Posey was then intentionally walked. Hunter Pence walked. Bases loaded, nobody out. Brandon Belt then strikes out. Now the pitcher’s spot is due up for the Giants, and they have to go to their last position player, backup catcher Hector Sanchez.</p><p>Sanchez hits a fly to right, the type of fly where you have to roll again and check the charts to see if the defender made the play. The defender is Geoff Jenkins. The dice came up as an error on a dropped ball. The winning run scores from third. The Giants take the series lead after being down 4–0 earlier in the game.</p><p>I mentioned in Part III that I dislike outfielder errors, especially dropped fly balls, because I think the charts make them a little easier to happen than they would in real life. However, in this case, I can see it and I’ll explain.</p><p>At the time, and for a long time, San Francisco had open bullpens in foul territory. I took a tour of what was then called AT&amp;T Park in 2014, and I asked the tour guide about them and he said what I had always heard: they <em>forgot</em> bullpens when they built the place, so they shoe-horned them on to the field, old-school style.</p><p>Here’s a photo I took from a game I attended there in 2017. You’ll see the bullpen mound is right against the foul line.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UAzTT7wJtC9_NuzpPLcB4w.jpeg" /></figure><p>I also remember editing a highlight of a game from 2011 when Washington Nationals right-fielder Jayson Werth tripped over the bullpen mound and missed a catch. It was a random play in a random June game from 11 years ago (it might have even been a foul ball), so I can’t find video and <a href="https://mlb.nbcsports.com/2011/06/08/jayson-werth-to-miss-his-second-straight-game/">this blurb</a> is the only reference I could find to it online.</p><p>All this is to say, could Geoff Jenkins enter a game cold after sitting for weeks, playing an unfamiliar right field, maybe even with seagulls flying overhead as they do there late at night, being a below-average defensive outfielder anyway, trip over a bullpen mound that is right up against the foul line, drop the ball which lands in fair territory so the winning run can score? I can see it. It’s not impossible.</p><p>I don’t like that’s how the game ends, but that’s what the dice rolls produced. Every roll that cleanly lands in the box counts, no matter what, just like the Cardinals eliminating the Mets on a balk (again, see <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">Part III</a>). The Giants win, 5–4 in ten innings. Phillies fans were worried now that this series could be over quickly, since they will be facing Cain and Bumgarner in Games 2 and 3.</p><p>But for now, let’s end this game with another tease: Hamels will see Vogelsong again soon.</p><p><strong>Day 15</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Juan Guzman) at AL-4 2017 Astros (Dallas Keuchel), Blue Jays lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Houston gets a 1st-inning run when Jose Altuve drives in George Springer.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/1*CHk7tMi6weC_w9kicmA7tQ.gif" /></figure><p>Toronto did load the bases with no outs in the 5th, but Roberto Alomar lined out to second and Joe Carter hit into a 1–2–3 double play to end the inning. Their next threat came in the 8th, but John Olerud hit into an inning-ending DP there.</p><p>Houston’s single run held up for the 1–0 win to tie the series.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Jamie Moyer) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain), Giants lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Jamie Moyer had a short night’s work in his last appearance, getting removed in the 2nd inning in Game 1 against the Cubs in the Round of 16. He was lifted after facing 11 batters.</p><p>In this outing, Moyer retired the first 13 Giants’ hitters of the game. Hunter Pence singled for their first hit, but next batter Brandon Belt grounded into a double play so Moyer faced the minimum through five innings. The game was still scoreless as Cain had only allowed one harmless single himself.</p><p>Gregor Blanco led off the bottom of the 6th with a single, and then stole second. Brandon Crawford struck out to bring up Cain. Instead of bunting, the trend of pitchers having an impact while batting in this series continued as Cain singled to score Blanco with the game’s first run.</p><p>Cain immediately gave it back by allowing a Werth home run to lead-off the 7th.</p><p>Moyer started the bottom of the 7th but was taken out after walking Sandoval with one out. Madson came in to face Posey, and walked him. Pence followed with an RBI single and it was 2–1 Giants.</p><p>Cain started the top of the 9th with that one-run lead. The pitcher’s spot was due to start the inning, and most of the Phillies bench had been used. Charlie Manuel decided now was Redemption Time for Geoff Jenkins. The left-handed batter hit a lead-off double, and now it was Bruce Bochy’s turn to use his closer with the tying run in scoring position. In came Sergio Romo.</p><p>Jimmy Rollins greeted Romo with another double, and suddenly the game was tied. Like in Game 2 of the Qualifying Round series against Cincinnati (see <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-qualifying-round-highlights-1fe96ed12f76">Part I</a>), Rollins used his feet and speed to get the Phillies another run as he stole third and would score on Chase Utley’s sacrifice fly. The crowd was shocked to see the visitors go ahead 3–2. Rollins was making a strong case for Tournament MVP.</p><p>Now Lidge was brought into a normal save situation, but Scutaro led off with a single. However, Ryan Theriot pinch-ran and was thrown out stealing. Sandoval struck out to set up Lidge vs. Posey for the second night in a row. For the second straight game, a fly ball to right was the last play. This one was caught by Werth for the Phillies win.</p><p>How baseball is it that Geoff Jenkins made the error to lose Game 1 and started the rally that won Game 2? How baseball is it that both games ended on flies to right field?</p><p>How could these two games in San Francisco be topped? You’ll see.</p><p><strong>Day 16</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-3 1995 Braves (Steve Avery) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Jaime Garcia), Braves lead series 2–0</em></p><p>With the 2–0 lead, the Braves decide to give Steve Avery his first tournament start. John Smoltz gets pushed back to Game 4.</p><p>It starts to look like a Braves sweep when Chipper Jones hits a solo homer in the top of the 1st, but Yadier Molina answers that with one of his own in the 2nd.</p><p>Fred McGriff reaches on a two-out two-base error by Albert Pujols in the 4th. He scores on a single by Mike Devereaux, who was replacing an injured David Justice for the remainder of the game. But Molina re-ties it with his second solo shot in the 5th.</p><p>The Cardinals score an unearned run of their own in the next inning. Javy Lopez threw away a swinging bunt by Jon Jay, allowing runners to reach 2nd and 3rd with no outs. Atlanta brought in Alejandro Pena for Avery after that play, but Ryan Theriot scored on Matt Holliday’s sac fly to give the Cardinals their first lead of the series, 3–2. St. Louis added a single run for the third straight inning on Skip Schumaker’s RBI double off Greg McMichael in the 7th.</p><p>Avery pitched decently, but not great. Jaime Garcia went seven strong innings for the Cardinals, and Fernando Salas and Jason Motte closed it out. Atlanta got the tying run to the plate in the 9th, but Klesko struck out and Lopez grounded out to end it. The hard-to-kill Cardinals live for another day, but Smoltz is looming with the Cardinals unsure of their pitching plans for Game 4 since Lance Lynn and Edwin Jackson both had to be used in relief earlier in the series when Lohse had a poor Game 1.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-1 1998 Yankees (Orlando Hernandez) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Milt Wilcox), Tigers lead series 2–0</em></p><p>The Yankees had reason to feel confident in the pitching matchup since Wilcox struggled against the Angels in his one tournament start. They would strike first on Scott Brosius’ RBI double in the top of the 2nd.</p><p>Kirk Gibson homered off “El Duque” after Whitaker led off the 3rd inning with a walk. The Tigers went ahead, 2–1. Tino Martinez tied it with a solo shot in the 4th, then Paul O’Neill would single in Jorge Posada after the Yanks loaded the bases. 3–2, Bombers.</p><p>With one out in the bottom of the 4th, the Tigers did this:</p><p>Ruppert Jones single<br>Johnny Grubb single<br>Chet Lemon single<br>Dave Bergman single<br>Lou Whitaker single</p><p>Death by a thousand paper cuts. That rally produced three runs for the Tigers and a 5–3 lead. It could have been worse, but Hernandez rebounded to strike out Trammell and Gibson.</p><p>Derek Jeter doubled in Chuck Knoblauch with two outs in the 6th, but then O’Neill’s fly out ended the inning with the score 5–4.</p><p>Most teams that win the World Series and advance in this tournament of champions have a strong bullpen that can shut the game down. It’s helped underdog teams like the Cardinals and Blue Jays advance. The Tigers obviously had a great reliever corps, led by the Cy Young and A.L. MVP Willie Hernandez, a pitcher who looked like Richard Pryor and was <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/h/hernawi01.shtml">mainly a middle reliever prior to 1984 when he became unhittable.</a></p><p>With Hernandez rested because he wasn’t needed in the lopsided Game 2 followed by a day off, and with the Tigers holding a one-run lead with a chance to end the series, and with the Yankees lineup flipping back to the top in the 8th inning, Hernandez was brought in for a 2-inning save. It wasn’t anything new for him; Hernandez pitched 140.1 innings in 80 appearances in 1984.</p><p>Chuck Knoblauch was hit by a pitch with one out, but Jeter flied out and O’Neill struck out. In the 9th, Bernie Williams led off with a single. Chili Davis struck out. Martinez didn&#39;t make good contact, and Hernandez got off the mound to field the ball and throw him out at first. Williams advanced to second with the tying run, but with two outs. Posada grounded out to Whitaker.</p><p>The 114-win Yankees just got swept out of the Division Series, though by the 104-win Tigers. I explained in <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">Part III</a> that the Yankees-Tigers matchup maybe happened a round too early because of the Jack Morris Rule, where we’re trying to keep teams who have the same player apart from each other as long as possible. If Jack Morris himself wasn’t on the 1992 Blue Jays, or if the Blue Jays had lost to the Red Sox, we might have had different matchups and maybe Yankees-Tigers wouldn’t have happened until the 7-game ALCS. So what, though? The Tigers pummeled them. If it had been a 7-game series, it would have been Tigers in 4 or 5. In this tournament, you’ll have to beat at least four other championship teams to win it, so the order of those teams doesn’t matter very much. The Yankees can’t have any complaints.</p><p>Now, if Toronto beats Houston and we have Jack Morris on both teams in the ALCS, what will we do? Not sure yet. Let’s see if it happens first.</p><p><strong>Day 17</strong> (3 games)</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-4 2017 Astros (Charlie Morton) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>There were some oddities in this game, and one happened in the 3rd inning when both teams had their 9th-hitters (Brian McCann/Manny Lee) lead off and reach base, then score when the 3rd-hitters (Jose Altuve/Joe Carter) ground into a double play. After those matching runs, the Blue Jays led 2–1.</p><p>Jimmy Key has been the best pitcher of the tournament so far. He’s 3–0 with a 0.40 ERA, with all three starts coming on the road and two of those at Fenway Park against the 108-win Red Sox in the previous round. This was his first start at home, and it was fine but not dominant. George Springer hit a 2-run homer in the 5th to put the Astros ahead, 3–2. Key went 6 and allowed the 3 runs, a so-called “quality start”, but not many guys can keep up that level of excellence against all these championship teams.</p><p>The next oddity, which turned out be a big one, occurred in the 8th when Yuli Gurriel seemingly scored on a sacrifice fly but was called out on an appeal play for leaving the base too soon. That would have been a very big insurance run for Houston.</p><p>Ken Giles came in to pitch the 9th with the 3–2 lead. Giles is the most inconsistent closer in this tournament, but he hasn’t had any disasters yet. In real life, he was dreadful in the 2017 World Series and was only used 2 times. He did not get the honor of pitching the final inning of the deciding game as closers often do (but not always, as Chris Sale got the final outs the next year for the Red Sox instead of shaky Craig Kimbrel), even though that game was not in doubt.</p><p>Giles pitched to 5 batters here. He got one out. Carter led off with a single. Dave Winfield walked. John Olerud struck out. Candy Maldonado walked to load the bases. Kelly Gruber singled to score two, and the Blue Jays went from losing on the last pitch of the game to winning, 4–3. They are one win away from advancing.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Joe Blanton), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>Remember how Phillie fans were worried about being down 1–0 in the series and looking at facing Cain and Bumgarner in the next two games? They won the Cain game, and here they scored 4 runs off MadBum in the first. Jimmy Rollins led off with a triple and scored on a groundout. With two outs and one on, Pat Burrell reached on a seeing-eye single that could have ended the inning. Next batter Shane Victorino followed with a three-run homer. It was reminiscent of <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/PHI/PHI200810020.shtml">Victorino’s grand slam in the 2008 Division Series against Milwaukee’s CC Sabathia after pitcher Brett Myers had walked with two outs.</a></p><p>In the top of the 2nd, with two on and two outs, Giants manager Bruce Bochy considered pinch-hitting for Bumgarner but chose not to. He was the greatest hitting pitcher of his day, which isn’t saying a lot, but his 19 career home runs and 65 RBI in 633 at-bats would be a decent season for many position players. Bochy decided to take the slim chances here of getting a run-scoring hit, rather than go into his thin bench for a pinch-hitter and turn this into a bullpen game.</p><p>Bumgarner hit a bouncer back to Joe Blanton for an easy third out, but it kept him in the game. He settled down after the rocky and somewhat-unlucky first, retiring all but two batters he faced in the 2nd through 6th innings.</p><p>The Giants started pecking away at the deficit. Angel Pagan led off the 3rd with a walk. Marco Scutaro singled. After a strikeout of Sandoval, the Giants went Posey RBI single, Pence RBI single, Belt sac fly. 3 runs were in. Brand new game, 4–3 Phillies.</p><p>In the 5th, Charlie Manuel had Scott Eyre warming up in case the Giants got their left-handed bats of Belt, Blanco, and Crawford up. But after Posey singled again to put runners on the corners, Manuel went to Eyre one batter earlier than he would’ve liked, but still felt Eyre had a better chance than Blanton against Hunter Pence.</p><p>Turns out he didn’t. Pence blasted a three-run shot to give the Giants a 6–4 lead. For the second time in three games, the Phillies had blown a 4–0 lead.</p><p>The Phillies’ long relievers struggled all night, and the Giants got two more in the 6th when Pagan doubled in Crawford and later scored on a Chad Durbin wild pitch. Philly got one back on a Rollins RBI double in the 7th which finally knocked Bumgarner out of the game.</p><p>It remained 8–5 going to the 9th. The Giants chose not to use Sergio Romo since the lower end of the Phillies lineup was due up, and the possible need for multiple innings from Romo in Game 4. Santiago Casilla got the first two outs easily but gave up a double to Chris Coste, who pinch-hit for Carlos Ruiz in the 7th and stayed in to catch. The pitcher’s spot was up next, and the only bats left on Philly’s bench were Jenkins or Greg Dobbs, both left-handed hitters who struggle mightily against left-handed pitchers. After Dobbs was announced, the Giants brought in southpaw Javier Lopez, but the Phillies had no counter-move to make.</p><p>“Come on Dobber, one time. Get on base, get Jimmy to the plate,” Larry Andersen might have said on radio. Rollins was in the on-deck circle as the tying run, just a home run shy of the cycle.</p><p>Dobber couldn’t do it one time. He hit a tapper back to the mound for the final out. Two 4–0 leads for the Phillies in the series, two losses.</p><p>Earlier in the day, both teams were unsure of their Game 4 starters. The Giants had to use Barry Zito in relief during Game 1. Brett Myers was suspended for the Phillies. Down 2–1 in the series, they decide it has to be Hamels on three days rest. He was recovered from the liner he took in Game 1 and hadn’t even pitched three full innings in that game, so he should be good to go.</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Edwin Jackson), Braves lead series 2–1</em></p><p>The Cardinals were also in scramble mode to find a starter for Game 4 because for a while it looked like they may not even make it that far. They go with Edwin Jackson for the spot-start since he had the least usage to date. They were hoping to get 3 or 4 innings out of him, then piece the rest of the game together. Kyle Lohse on three days rest would likely be used somewhere.</p><p>Jackson retired the first 9 Braves hitters, even pitching more efficiently than John Smoltz, who had walked three, though it was still scoreless. To get five innings out of Jackson seemed like a pipe dream before the game began, though now it appeared possible.</p><p>Atlanta started getting to Jackson the second time through. Marquis Grissom led off the 4th with a single, then Mark Lemke doubled to make it 2nd and 3rd with no outs. Suddenly, that was it for Jackson. St. Louis brought in lefty Mark Rzepczynski, whose nickname for this tournament should have been “Every Day”. The strategy here was to turn Chipper Jones around to the right-handed batters’ box, then face lefties Fred McGriff, David Justice, and Ryan Klesko.</p><p>Jones walked and McGriff grounded into a double play, but Grissom scored and it was 1–0 Braves. Every Day Mark kept the Braves at bay.</p><p>Unfortunately for the Cards, Smoltz got stronger and even in shaky innings he could get out of them. Albert Pujols ended the 5th with a 5–4–3 double play. With 2nd and 3rd and 1 out in the 6th, Smoltz struck out Molina and got Nick Punto to ground out.</p><p>Bobby Cox saw no need to pull Smoltz for the 9th. Punto walked with one out, but pinch-hitter Jon Jay hit into a game-ending DP.</p><p>The entire Braves offensive output, 1 run on 2 hits and the run scoring on a double play, happened in that 4th inning against hard-luck loser Edwin Jackson. That’s all it took for the Braves to win and move on.</p><p>A tip of the cap to these plucky 2011 Cardinals. Remember, in real life they made the playoffs on the last night of the season, then beat some favored teams in October. They played some of this tournament’s most exciting games and were hard to kill all the way until Maddux, Glavine, and Smoltz could finally finish them.</p><p><strong>Day 18</strong> (2 games)</p><p><em>Game 4: AL-4 2017 Astros (Lance McCullers, Jr.) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris), Blue Jays lead series 2–1</em></p><p>OK, a funny thing happened right before this game was played by me: the 2022 Astros won the World Series. This tournament has been great fun, but it’s taken a lot longer to play than I originally thought it would. I thought it might take until September, and that turned out to be a gross underestimation. Now I’ll be happy if it’s done by next spring training.</p><p>As soon as the ’22 Astros got their final out, I had no more taste for the 2017 Astros. I wish I could include the ’22 team somehow without blowing up the American League bracket and starting over. I still may do something with them once this is all done, but not sure what.</p><p>One thing that made the ’22 Astros better than ’17 was Justin Verlander. He was a unanimous Cy Young winner in 2022. He was still very good in 2017, but also allowed 27 home runs that year and pitching him in a good home-run park in Toronto on three days rest didn’t seem optimal, especially after losing the first game to the Blue Jays.</p><p>So, the Astros went with Lance McCullers, the same Lance McCullers who in real life allowed 5 home runs to the Phillies in Game 3 of the 2022 World Series.</p><p>This one was worse. Even though he allowed no Blue Jay homers, he did allow this:</p><p>Devon White triple<br>Roberto Alomar single and stolen base<br>Joe Carter strikeout<br>Dave Winfield single<br>John Olerud walk<br>Candy Maldonado 2-run single</p><p>In came Joe Musgrove, who gave up a 2-run single to Manny Lee and the Blue Jays had a first-inning 5-spot. McCullers: 0.1 IP, 5 runs.</p><p>It was 7–1 Blue Jays in the 5th when the Astros made it a game. Gurriel’s 2-out 2-run single made it 7–4 and brought up the tying run but Josh Reddick lined out to 3rd. Have to wonder what Kyle Tucker would have done.</p><p>It did get a little dicey in the 9th, with it still 7–4. Tom Henke has been a dominant closer so far, but he allowed a single and two walks around a couple of outs. The bases were loaded for Carlos Correa, who was 0 for 4 in the game and 0 for 16 in the series. He flied out to center to end it. <em>Really</em> have to wonder what Jeremy Pena would have done.</p><p>By the way, Verlander pitched the last four innings with no runs allowed. Should have started him. 😞</p><p>After they swept Oakland last round, I thought the Astros might win this whole thing. Now, goodbye. No one will miss them. I never cared terribly much about the trash cans, but another reason the ’22 Astros team was more appealing was the lack of stink on them.</p><p>This sets up our American League Championship Series: 1984 Detroit with Jack Morris vs. 1992 Toronto with Jack Morris.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Ftenor.com%2Fembed%2F15735153&amp;display_name=Tenor&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Ftenor.com%2Fview%2Fcharlie-brown-christmas-charlie-brown-mad-upset-rats-gif-15735153&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.tenor.com%2FPDNNTlWgZ1oAAAAC%2Fcharlie-brown-christmas-charlie-brown.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=tenor" width="600" height="400" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/46a290576c27b692c25dab8971c4c62b/href">https://medium.com/media/46a290576c27b692c25dab8971c4c62b/href</a></iframe><p>This is what we were kicking the can to avoid, but now it’s here. I guess we’ll just have to rule that Morris can pitch for both teams but not ever in the same game.</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-5 2012 Giants (Tim Lincecum) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Cole Hamels), Giants lead series 2–1</em></p><p>Tim Lincecum was lousy in 2012, and it came out of nowhere. He had won the Cy Young in ’08 and ’09, then finished in the top ten in 2010 and ’11. Then in 2012, his ERA soared to 5.18. It was his worst year with the Giants.</p><p>They found a role for him right as the postseason started. He was great as a super-reliever who could go multiple innings in the middle of the game. However, that doesn’t do much good for our purposes, since the player cards are based on the regular season, and Lincecum’s card isn’t great.</p><p>But the Giants went with him for the short start here, since they had used Barry Zito in the 10th inning of Game 1. Their hope was Lincecum could eat a few early innings, followed by Zito for 2 or 3, and then to use the bullpen normally after that.</p><p>Bochy makes an interesting call in the 2nd inning with a runner on 2nd and 1 out. He gives Shane Victorino the intentional walk with the lesser offensive threats of Pedro Feliz, Carlos Ruiz, and Cole Hamels to follow.</p><p>Unfortunately for the Giants, Lincecum then walked Feliz to load the bases. They still had the opportunity to get out unscathed considering Ruiz was 2 for 32 in the tournament, but Chooch hit a sacrifice fly to right to give the Phillies a 1–0 lead without recording a hit.</p><p>With the top of the Phillies order due up in the 3rd, Bochy pinch-hit for Lincecum and brought in Zito. Rollins walked, but the inning ended when Chase Utley hit into a double play.</p><p>Hamels, going on the three days rest, kept getting out of tight spots. He got Posey to ground into a 6–4–3 in the first inning with two runners on. Pagan doubled with one out in the 3rd but was stranded there. Posey led off the 4th with a single, and then he was erased on a double play off the bat of Pence, right before Belt doubled.</p><p>In the bottom of the 5th, all hell broke loose. Ruiz doubled for the Phillies’ first hit of the game. That brought up Hamels with one out. Even though Hamels got a base hit in Game 1, that was against the right-handed Ryan Vogelsong. Against the lefty Zito, the Phillies decide their best play is a bunt, and Hamels gets Ruiz to 3rd. Rollins singles to score Ruiz, and he would not have scored had he been on 2nd. The Phillies led 2–0.</p><p>Since Jayson Werth has the ability to crush left-handed pitching, the Giants lifted Zito for George Kontos to face one batter and possibly get out of the inning. Javier Lopez was warming up to face Utley and Ryan Howard if necessary.</p><p>Rollins was a pest on first base. An obvious distraction for any pitcher, as he stole second and then reached 3rd on a wild pitch. That led to Werth going deep for his 4th home run of the tournament, and a 4–0 lead for the Phillies for the third time in the series.</p><p>They would not blow it this time. In fact, they sent Citizens Bank Park into bedlam when Utley and Howard both homered off Lopez for the first instance of back-to-back-to-back home runs in the tournament.</p><p>Victorino homered in the 6th, and Howard hit his second of the game in the 7th. Hamels went 6 innings in the 8–2 win. J.A. Happ got the three-inning save to give the overused Phillies bullpen the night off and set them up to work overtime if necessary in Game 5.</p><p>It would be necessary.</p><p><strong>Day 19</strong></p><p>Idle, no games. The Phillies and Giants are traveling back across the country. The other three LCS spots are decided.</p><p><strong>Day 20</strong> (1 game)</p><p><em>Game 5: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Jamie Moyer) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain), Series tied 2–2</em></p><p>Posey doubled and scored on a Belt single in the bottom of the 2nd. Those were the only two hits Moyer allowed in six innings.</p><p>Werth led off the 4th with a single. Utley then flied out to the wall in right. “In Citizens Bank Park, that’s a home run,” Scott Franzke might have said on the air. “Ryan’s just gonna have to hit one into the Cove, that’s all,” Andersen probably would have said in repsonse.</p><p>Then Howard did, crushing a no-doubter for his tournament-best 5th home run and a 2–1 lead for the Phillies.</p><p>It was still 2–1 at the 7th-inning stretch, with Posey and Pence due up. Two guys who are dangerous against left-handed pitching, so the Phillies decided that was a job well done by Moyer and brought in Ryan Madson. The intention was two innings from Madson and one from Lidge. Madson pitched a clean 7th, striking out Posey and Belt.</p><p>With 7–8–9 due up for the Giants in the 8th, the Phillies had to feel good. It was looking like the game would come down to Lidge vs. Posey again in the 9th.</p><p>The 7th spot in the lineup was occupied by Xavier Nady, because Gregor Blanco left the game after being hit by a pitch in the 5th. Aubrey Huff was chosen to pinch-hit for Nady, and had a 16.7 percent chance of walking against a right-handed pitcher. If the Phillies had gone to J.C. Romero here, the Giants would have countered with a right-handed bat so they stuck with Madson. The only lefty bat Romero would have faced in this inning was Brandon Crawford, who is currently on deck.</p><p>Madson walked Huff. Ryan Theriot pinch-ran, reducing the Giants’ bench to just two position players left.</p><p>Crawford up next. And the dice then produced a very rare reading: triple 1s. A white 1, and two red 1s. A 1–2.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*NXT_fkeFC4c7cpdN7fTSDA.jpeg" /></figure><p>Hit by the pitch. The Giants have runners on first and second with no outs.</p><p>Cain’s spot is up next. Entering the inning, it was thought to be automatic that Cain would have to be pinch-hit for, but 1st and 2nd with no outs in a one-run game changes things. He had a great game on the mound, only having the one blemish in the 4th that right now was the difference in the ballgame.</p><p>Cain was sent up to bunt the runners over. It was a risky move, surrendering one of the six outs you have left for the chance to put the go-ahead run in scoring position. The dice were rolled and the result was 1 AND 2, meaning a ball and two strikes and giving the offensive team the option to take the bunt off. Another reading of 1 AND 2 would mean a bunted foul for a third strike.</p><p>The Giants left the bunt on, and the next roll showed SPEED, which is also rare to get and it meant the bunt is great so the batter has a chance to beat it out! Which Cain does. The bases are loaded with nobody out.</p><p>The bunt single also triggered Madson’s fatigue rating, leaving him extra vulnerable to a 2-run single, so Lidge has to come in now. It’s another near-impossible save situation, but if anyone can pull it off it’s either 2008 Lidge or Mariano Rivera anytime.</p><p>Angel Pagan is the next hitter. The Phillies decide they would take a tie here if they could get two outs, so they play the infield back because giving up a bloop hit would be disastrous. And it works. Pagan grounds into a 6–4–3. Theriot does score and the game is tied 2–2. Scutaro flies out to end the inning.</p><p>Cain struck out Werth to start the 9th, then Romo came in and retired Utley and Howard. Lidge allowed a single to Sandoval to lead off the bottom of the 9th. Joaquin Arias pinch-ran for Sandoval, leaving the Giants with one non-pitcher on the bench, but that move proved to be a waste when Posey grounded into a double play. Pence walked and stole second, so Belt was intentionally walked with Theriot coming up. He grounded out to 3rd to send the game to extra innings. It’s the Giants’ fourth extra-inning game of the tournament.</p><p>Romo pitched a clean 10th. The Phillies left Lidge in to pitch a 3rd inning, just like Rivera in Game 7 of the 2003 ALCS. Lidge struck out the side. The second of those batters was Madison Bumgarner pinch-hitting for Romo.</p><p>Chad Durbin pitched the 11th. After a Scutaro single, Arias grounded into the Giants’ third double play in 4 innings. Posey then crushed one to deep left that sounded like a series-ending walk-off home run, but the park held it and Pat Burrell caught it at the wall. It would have been out of CBP, but here all it meant was we were going 12.</p><p>Santiago Casilla pitched the 11th and 12th for the Giants and only allowed a mere 1-out single to Utley in the 12th. Howard then struck out, and Burrell flied to center. J.C. Romero walked Theriot with two outs in the bottom half, and Theriot stole second but Crawford flied out to left.</p><p>We were now in the longest game of the tournament. One other had gone 12 innings — Game 2 of the Cardinals-Nationals Qualifying Round series.</p><p>The last available Giants’ position player, Hector Sanchez, led off the bottom of the 13th as a pinch-hitter. In Game 1, Sanchez hit the fly ball down the right-field line that Geoff Jenkins mishandled to allow the winning run to score. Here, Romero struck him out. Pagan also struck out. Scutaro singled, then Arias singled and Scutaro reached third.</p><p>The Phillies brought in Clay Condrey to intentionally walk Posey, and then face Pence in a righty-righty matchup with bases loaded and 2 outs. Pence grounded out to third.</p><p>Left-hander Jeremy Affeldt started the top of the 14th. Eric Bruntlett and Jimmy Rollins grounded out. Rollins was now 0 for 6, a major reason why the Phillies offense struggled all night. The next batter was Jayson Werth, and Bruce Bochy didn’t want Werth facing a lefty. He brought in his Game 1 starter, Ryan Vogelsong, likely only for one batter with Utley and Howard looming. Jose Mijares was available to face those guys if need be.</p><p>Werth grounded out to short. The Phillies were retired in order for the fifth time in six innings.</p><p>Ryan Theriot hit a double off Condrey with 1 out. Crawford was up next. If there had been 2 outs, he certainly would have been intentionally walked because the Giants had no more pinch-hitters and had also used their best hitting pitcher in Bumgarner.</p><p>The Phillies had another card to play. Their ace.</p><p><strong><em>It’s Game 5 of the National League Division Series in San Francisco. We’re in the bottom of the 14th inning, and Cole Hamels is coming in to pitch for the Phillies…</em></strong></p><p>Because Hamels left Game 1 early with an injury, he had only thrown 8.2 innings in the series. That injury wasn’t to his left arm. His arm was fine. Sure, he went 6 innings just two days ago in Game 4. All the Phillies wanted was two outs. Get two outs, and be removed for a pinch-hitter in the top of the 15th with the pitcher’s spot due up third. That’s all. Give them your best 2001 Randy Johnson. This is an if-not-now-when situation.</p><p>Hamels started out ineffective. Crawford walked. First and second, 1 out.</p><p>Pitcher’s spot up next, and the Giants have no more pinch-hitters. Ryan Vogelsong is normally a starter, so he does know how to use the bat but not well. It appears the Giants’ best chance to get anything valuable out of this plate appearance is to bunt. That could get the winning run to 3rd with 2 outs presumably, and anything can happen from there. Pagan would be batting.</p><p>The Phillies were playing for the bunt. You would imagine if Vogelsong squared around on the first pitch or two of the at-bat, the Phillies wouldn’t expect anything else.</p><p>In the 2012 NLCS, the Giants had two unexpectedly fortunate outcomes on bunt plays by their pitchers. Barry Zito got an RBI on a 2-out bunt down the third-base line that he beat out in Game 5, likely similar to Cain’s bunt single in this game. Then in Game 6, <a href="https://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/big-league-stew/contact-ryan-vogelsong-slashes-burns-cards-bat-arm-102616553--mlb.html">Vogelsong executed the rarely-seen “butcher-boy” play</a>, where the batter squares to bunt and then pulls the bat back and swings away. The result was an error by the shortstop, but Vogelsong got an RBI when a runner on third took off on contact and scored.</p><p>I’m pretty sure I edited highlights for both of those games at MLB Network. I know I did the Zito one. Maybe that’s why I confused the two and thought Zito had done the butcher-boy when I was shaking the dice in my hand, said “Butcher-boy, he’s swinging” for Vogelsong, and threw the dice.</p><p>It came up 3–7. The one spot on the pitcher’s batting card where the ball bloops over a drawn-in infield.</p><p>“NOOO!!” Larry Andersen probably would have screamed into his mic.</p><p>Runners advance two bases.</p><p>Theriot scores. RBI single for Vogelsong. Giants 3, Phillies 2, 14 innings. Giants win series 3–2.</p><p>I was so stunned I wrote down the wrong score:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*uVM_EklK3wpdaL-VdnqR5A.jpeg" /></figure><p>The Giants won Game 1 on a dropped fly ball by an okay outfielder who just entered the game and tripped on the bullpen mound. They won Game 5 on a butcher-boy by a starting pitcher who had to come in for emergency relief in the 14th inning with no pinch-hitters available, against another starting pitcher who had to come in for emergency relief.</p><p>Ryan Vogelsong batted twice against Cole Hamels in the series. The first one was a line drive that unfortunately forced Hamels from the game and probably cost the Phillies a win, the second was a butcher-boy walk-off RBI single. In real life, Vogelsong batted .093 in 2012 with no RBI.</p><p>Would all these crazy endings really happen? Well, sure, I mean they could. Crazy is built into baseball, I guess even in board games and tournaments that only exist within the walls of our house here. Outfielders trip over bullpen mounds, butcher-boys have happened, game-ending balks have happened. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gw7XqUly9ic">Hits by pitchers to win games in extra innings have happened, but they probably won’t anymore.</a> Game 3 of the 2013 World Series ended on an obstruction call at third base…</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FdOlihOEDXgE%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DdOlihOEDXgE&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FdOlihOEDXgE%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/99caf3e54371b5b0e9b4e011aae5cac1/href">https://medium.com/media/99caf3e54371b5b0e9b4e011aae5cac1/href</a></iframe><p>…and Game 4 ended on a pick-off.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FeQnHJwIabBU%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DeQnHJwIabBU&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FeQnHJwIabBU%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/86d19cb699e9afd481d50e59ec642f3e/href">https://medium.com/media/86d19cb699e9afd481d50e59ec642f3e/href</a></iframe><p>Even though the Phillies have lost here on bloopers and comedy plays, I have to say they did play valiantly and I’ll be sorry to see them go. Now it seems silly that I debated for quite a while on whether to use the 2008 Phillies or the 1980 Phillies (there are many similarities: Howard-Mike Schmidt, Utley-Pete Rose, Hamels-Steve Carlton, Lidge-Tug McGraw, Ruiz-Bob Boone, Burrell-Greg Luzinski, Victorino-Garry Maddox).</p><p>They were the tournament’s Most Interesting Team since Day 1. Maybe the Giants will take that title from them in the NLCS, but this is why I said you could skim the other games and just read about the Phillies. Their 12 games in this tournament could be its own volume.</p><p>Jimmy Rollins was dynamic until this game when he went 0 for 6 at the worst time. The Phillies only scored in one of the 14 innings when Howard hit the 2-run homer into McCovey Cove in the 4th.</p><p>The Giants have played their maximum of 10 games, defeating the Dodgers and Phillies in 5. They allowed 14 runs and 23 hits in Game 3 against the Dodgers to fall behind 2–1, then won Game 4 in extra innings and scored 5 runs in the 7th inning on the road in Game 5 of that series (see <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">Part III</a>).</p><p>In this series, they won two extra-inning games at home and came back from a 4–0 deficit in Game 3 on the road. They also blew a save in Game 2 and allowed 5 home runs in Game 4. They have six wins and four losses, and are moving on to face the Braves, who are 6–1. Madison Bumgarner will oppose Greg Maddux in Game 1 in Atlanta.</p><p>One final note about wild coincidences that happen in baseball. The two craziest endings of the tournament were the Vogelsong butcher-boy and Roger McDowell’s 10th-inning balk with a runner on third in the Cardinals-Mets Round of 16 series.</p><p>Ryan Theriot scored the winning run both times.</p><p><em>(</em><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-league-championship-series-highlights-79104114312c"><em>Click here</em></a><em> for the highlights of the League Championship Series and preview of the Grand World Series.)</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=a8931706f3c0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strat-O-Matic Modern Champions Tournament, Conclusion of Round of 16 Highlights]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/fd3a8d96f3fc</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[stratomatic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-series]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 30 Sep 2022 01:29:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-11-21T17:39:43.641Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>This takes a long time to play, but it’s more than halfway over now as we’re down to 8 teams</em></p><p>It’s time for the third installment of the Modern Champions Tournament, as I have finally finished the Round of 16. 45 games have been played, with a maximum of 41 to go.</p><p>Featured in this go-round: a rainout, a brawl, a series that ended on a balk, and plenty of decisions about managing a pitching staff in a short series (some worked, some didn’t).</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-qualifying-round-highlights-1fe96ed12f76">Here is Part I</a>: an explanation of the tournament and its format, plus highlights of the Qualifying Round. (TL;DR summary: it’s a tournament of World Series champions since 1980 with each franchise only represented once, with all games played on Strat-O-Matic baseball by me)</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-round-of-16-games-1-and-2-highlights-ae174015c8a4">Here’s Part II</a>: recaps of the first two games in each Round of 16 series</p><p>These 8 series, 4 in the American League and 4 in the National League, are all best-of-5. Here’s where we left off:</p><p><strong>American League<br></strong>(1) 1998 Yankees vs. (11) 1985 Royals: <strong>Yankees lead 2–0</strong><br>(2) 2018 Red Sox vs. (9) 1992 Blue Jays: <strong>Tied 1–1</strong><br>(3) 1984 Tigers vs. (7) 2002 Angels: <strong>Tigers lead 2–0</strong><br>(4) 2017 Astros vs. (5) 1989 Athletics: <strong>Astros lead 2–0</strong></p><p><strong>National League<br></strong>(1) 1986 Mets vs. (11) 2011 Cardinals: <strong>Tied 1–1</strong><br>(2) 2016 Cubs vs. (8) 2008 Phillies: <strong>Phillies lead 2–0</strong><br>(3) 1995 Braves vs. (7) 2001 Diamondbacks: <strong>Braves lead 2–0</strong><br>(4) 1988 Dodgers vs. (5) 2012 Giants: <strong>Tied 1–1</strong></p><p>We pick it up at the start of <strong>Tournament Day 9 (4 games)</strong>. Again, I’m summarizing the games in the order in which they were played, which is based on a hypothetical national TV schedule.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-2 2018 Red Sox (David Price) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Juan Guzman), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>Here’s how I can best describe how this went:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*P8gQ4gulw31lML7LWo623g.jpeg" /></figure><p>David Price allowed a grand slam to Candy Maldonado in the 1st, and was taken out after immediately re-loading the bases. Joe Kelly got the 3rd out, but then he walked three batters who all scored in the next inning. Ryan Brasier gave up three more runs in the 3rd. Toronto cruised, 12–5. Maldonado had a tournament-high 7 RBI.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-4 2017 Astros (Charlie Morton) at AL-5 1989 Athletics (Storm Davis), Astros lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Trailing 1–0 in the 6th, Houston ties it when George Springer scores from 1st on a Alex Bregman double. Springer beat the throw home, and Bregman advanced to 3rd on the throw. That would be a huge 90 feet since Bregman scored on a passed ball by Terry Steinbach with the next batter up. The Astros took a stunning 2–1 lead.</p><p>They added a big insurance run in the top of the 9th with Dennis Eckersley pitching in a non-save situation. Carlos Correa singled in Bregman to make it 3–1 with still no outs, but Yuli Gurriel flied out and Josh Reddick bounced back to the mound for a double play.</p><p>Oakland made it interesting against wild closer Ken Giles, who walked the first two batters in the bottom of the 9th. Unfortunately for the A’s, the heart of their lineup was nowhere near due up. Walt Weiss sacrificed them to 2nd and 3rd, so the tying runs were in scoring position with one out. Ron Hassey grounded out to score one run and advance the tying run to 3rd. Mike Gallego grounded out on a difficult play by Bregman at 3rd to end the game. 3–2, Houston. They are the first team to advance to the Division Series, and will have several days off to line up their pitching again.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-1 1986 Mets (Ron Darling) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Chris Carpenter), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>One important note to this game was the Cardinals dropping Rafael Furcal to the 8th spot in the lineup, and the Mets having so little respect for Furcal’s offense that they intentionally walked Yadier Molina ahead of him <em>twice. </em>After the second one, the Cardinals countered with Nick Punto as a pinch-hitter that stayed in the game to play shortstop.</p><p>The closest anyone came to scoring in the first six innings was Matt Holliday being thrown out at the plate on a David Freese double.</p><p>Chris Carpenter was brilliant but he rolled the injury numbers on the first batter of the 7th, and he had to leave the game. Mark Rzepczynski came in to retire Darryl Strawberry and Ray Knight to end the inning, the game still scoreless.</p><p>Mookie Wilson leads off the 8th with a triple off Fernando Salas. Danny Heep pinch-hits for Rafael Santana and hits a sacrifice fly to score Wilson. 1–0, Mets. Their bats have been extremely quiet except for the 7th inning of Game 2, but things are now looking up for the top seed in the N.L.</p><p>Roger McDowell was pitching the bottom of the 8th, after coming on to get the last out of the 7th with two on base. McDowell allowed one-out singles to Holliday and Freese, setting up a sac fly by Yadier Molina to tie the game.</p><p>That brought up Punto. His offensive card is a little better than Furcal’s, but still not overwhelming…</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*Yc3gTfQ_99RXMLCfvscMng.jpeg" /></figure><p>…until he rolls the 3–6 with the go-ahead run on base in the 8th inning of a tied game and tied series! So now we have to roll the 20-sided die, but no matter what the Cardinals are taking the lead here.</p><p>Punto rolled a home run! He had one home run in real life in 2011. A shocker in St. Louis. The Cardinals lead 3–1. Punto was only in the game because Furcal was in a giant slump, and he just hit the biggest home run by a Cardinal shortstop since Jack Buck told everyone to go crazy.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FL4PB0XoLbm8&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DL4PB0XoLbm8&amp;image=http%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FL4PB0XoLbm8%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="854" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/c5ee08929e466ad6b2e658cbbfea2327/href">https://medium.com/media/c5ee08929e466ad6b2e658cbbfea2327/href</a></iframe><p>Jason Motte mowed down Keith Hernandez, Gary Carter, and Strawberry for the save. The Mets are a loss away from elimination because they can’t hit a lick in this series.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-4 1988 Dodgers (Tim Leary) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Ryan Vogelsong), Series tied 1–1</em></p><p>Quick reminder: this is the series that had two 1–0 games at Dodger Stadium.</p><p>The Dodgers scored 3 runs in the top of the 1st here. They also got 3 more in the 4th. Then 2 in the 5th, 2 in the 6th, 2 in the 7th, and 2 in the 8th. 14 runs for L.A., with a tournament-high <em>23 hits</em>.</p><p>With the game out of hand, the Giants used their deep bullpen to eat up innings but still had to use Barry Zito in the 9th so they could save their normal late-inning relievers for the next day’s Game 4. Zito was the projected Game 4 starter, but now the Giants will go with Matt Cain on three days rest, trailing in the series 2–1.</p><p>Another quirk that happened came in the bottom of the 9th when the Giants scored 3 runs to make the score 14–4, but since every position player had been used, Zito had to bat for the final out of the game.</p><p>The Dodgers announce later that to match up against Cain in Game 4, they will also bring back Orel Hershiser on three days rest instead of saving him for Game 5. It’s also believed this move could enable the Dodgers to start Hershiser twice in the next series should they advance.</p><p><strong>Day 10 (8 games scheduled, 7 played)</strong></p><p>A funny thing happened in real life around this time. Strat-O-Matic’s website and app went down for days. (I use the app to access the cards and play the games.)</p><p>I thought I had taken a picture of it to show you, but I guess not because I can’t find it now. But the point is, I wanted to play for about 2 1/2 days, and couldn’t.</p><p>Wanting to play but not being able to. That sounds like a rainout.</p><p>I declared the next game would be a rainout, and the schedule would be adjusted. Throw a wrench into the works, for fun. One problem: the next game was indoors, Boston at Toronto.</p><p>Alright then, the next scheduled <em>outdoor</em> game will be a rainout. Until then, let’s play this one and it turned out to be a thriller…</p><p><em>Game 4: AL-2 2018 Red Sox (Eduardo Rodriguez) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris), Blue Jays lead series 2–1</em></p><p>The Red Sox going with Rodriguez in place of original starter Nathan Eovaldi, who had to emergency-relieve the injured Chris Sale in Game 1. Rodriguez was brilliant for five innings, just allowing an unearned run on a Mitch Moreland 3rd-inning error.</p><p>Boston still trailed 1–0 going in the 6th. Andrew Benintendi doubled Mookie Betts to 3rd with nobody out. J.D. Martinez struck out. Xander Bogaerts was then intentionally walked to bring up Moreland, who had a decent chance of grounding into an inning-ending double play.</p><p>Instead, Moreland blasted a grand slam for a 4–1 Red Sox lead. Moreland with a huge home run in Game 4 of a 2018 postseason series on the road…seen that before.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*gGZxxOgD81mWdLQJWd6WvQ.jpeg" /><figcaption>Game 4, 2018 World Series</figcaption></figure><p>Ah, but the Red Sox still had miles to go before they could sleep. Remember it’s only the 6th inning. Roberto Alomar led off the bottom half with a single, and then Joe Carter homered. It was 4–3.</p><p>With one out, John Olerud hit a grounder behind 3rd that Rafael Devers should have ate, but instead threw away. Olerud ended up on 3rd with a single and a two-base error. He scored on a Maldonado single. Just like that, the game was tied 4–4 with seven combined runs in the 6th inning.</p><p>Boston loaded the bases with no outs in the top of the 7th. Duane Ward struck out Benintendi and Martinez, but allowed a 2-run single to Bogaerts. 6–4, Red Sox.</p><p>Toronto had first and second with no outs in their half, but Ryan Brasier came in and got three fly outs by Alomar, Carter, and Dave Winfield. Alex Cora decided Craig Kimbrel (to this point, unused in the series) was going for a 2-inning save.</p><p>Kimbrel walked three batters in the 8th, but got Devon White to pop up to end the inning. The clutch symbol on White’s card got him; it turns hits into outs, and vice versa, in situations with runners in scoring position and two outs and if the rolled dice hit that number. It remained 6–4. Kimbrel pitched a clean 9th to finish the game and send the series back to Fenway Park for a decisive Game 5.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-2 2016 Cubs (Jake Arrieta) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Joe Blanton), Phillies lead series 2–0</em></p><p>POSTPONED — RAIN.</p><p>Remember, I said the next outdoor game is a rainout due to the Strat-O-Matic app outage.</p><p>This changes things for this series. The if-necessary travel day between Games 4 and 5 is now gone. Game 4 is rescheduled as a day game so the teams can get to Chicago for a night start in Game 5. It also enables the Cubs to use top pitcher Kyle Hendricks in Game 4 on normal rest, again, if necessary.</p><p>The 2016 Cubs needing to win three straight games and getting some advantageous rain — <a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/postseason/2016_WS.shtml">we’ve seen that before, too</a>.</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-1 1986 Mets (Dwight Gooden) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Jaime Garcia), Cardinals lead series 2–1</em></p><p>The Mets are bringing back Doctor K on three days rest. Original starter Sid Fernandez will be available out of the bullpen. Bob Ojeda is scheduled to pitch Game 5 at Shea Stadium if the Mets can win this one.</p><p>But again, they can’t hit. Shut out for the first four innings by Garcia with only one batter reaching. Yadier Molina’s RBI single gives the Cardinals a 1–0 lead in the 4th.</p><p>Is this is how the 1986 bad-boy swagger-ific Mets lose? With a whimper?</p><p>Well, not exactly. We saw in real life how they, too, came back from the brink:</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fembed%2FgOssdTBigbo%3Ffeature%3Doembed&amp;display_name=YouTube&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DgOssdTBigbo&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fi.ytimg.com%2Fvi%2FgOssdTBigbo%2Fhqdefault.jpg&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=youtube" width="640" height="480" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/e4bb35d00a63e8ad90496fd4727c138d/href">https://medium.com/media/e4bb35d00a63e8ad90496fd4727c138d/href</a></iframe><p>4 straight singles to start the 5th gives the Mets a 2–1 lead, then a safety squeeze by Gooden scores the 3rd run. It’s starting to look good for them.</p><p>Molina hits a solo home run in the 6th to make it 3–2. <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdfKY9b6Nxo">He’s really starting to get on the nerves of Mets fans again</a>. However, just before that homer, Gooden picked off David Freese, so without that the game would be tied.</p><p>Punto and pinch-hitter Allen Craig followed with singles to knock the tired Gooden out of the game. Rick Aguilera comes in to strike out Ryan Theriot to end the threat and preserve the Mets lead.</p><p>New York plates two runs in the 8th, and it could have been more. After a bases-loaded walk to Strawberry made it 5–2 with no outs, Cardinal relievers struck out Knight, Lenny Dykstra, and Aguilera. Aguilera batted because Davey Johnson decided to stick with the hot hand who had retired all four batters he had faced and struck out three of those. He was hoping for one more clean inning, and to get the ball to Jesse Orosco in the 9th.</p><p>Holliday led off the 8th with a double, and Freese tripled (again, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UEEOZpdp9bo">seen that before in real life</a>). It was 5–3 with the tying run at the plate. So that grand idea didn’t work out for the Mets, and Orosco got the ball right now.</p><p>Molina grounded out to first, which enabled Freese to score. Punto flied out to center. Pinch-hitter Jon Jay singled, Theriot got hit by a pitch, and Skip Schumaker singled in Jay. Albert Pujols flew out to end the inning, but the Cardinals had amazingly tied this game at 5–5.</p><p>We jump ahead to the 10th. Fernandez had worked the 9th for the Mets, and began the 10th with his 4th strikeout. Furcal came up to pinch-hit; he was 1 for 19 in the tournament to this point, and had been benched. Of course, he hit a double. Fernandez was removed for McDowell, to face Theriot.</p><p>Base hit to center…Furcal’s coming home to win the game and the series…the throw by Dykstra…in time! Furcal is out. The game continues, but it’s just the second out of the inning, and Theriot advanced to 2nd on the throw.</p><p>Skip Schumaker then singled, but Theriot could only reach 3rd. Up next: Albert Pujols. As I write this, the real-life Pujols has just hit his 700th career home run. He’s probably the third-greatest Cardinal of all-time, and here he was with a chance to send these upstart Cardinals past the National League’s top seed and into the Division Series (quarterfinals).</p><p>Roll #1: a 2 showed up on the 20-sided die, which means this could be a passed ball or a balk (!)</p><p>Roll #2 to determine which one: it’s a possible balk. Now it’s time to see if Roll #3 lands with McDowell’s balk range.</p><p>Roll #3: it landed within McDowell’s balk range.</p><p>A balk. With a runner on 3rd base. In the bottom of the 10th inning of a tie game. To win it for the Cardinals and eliminate the Mets.</p><p>This is when I asked myself…should I count it? No one else is here watching me play. Nobody’s auditing this thing. My wife rolls her eyes when she hears me rolling the dice. <em>(Note: if I didn’t love my wife very much, I would’ve played this round in about half the time, but I like spending time with her more. I usually play when she’s not around.)</em></p><p>Nobody needs to know this was a balk. I could just throw a do-over.</p><p>But, no I couldn’t. Every single roll of the dice in this tournament that legitimately landed in the box has counted. This has to count. It’s a balk; Theriot scores. The Cardinals win, 6–5.</p><p>Let me also explain how rare it is to get a balk in this game. I mentioned Roll #1 — that only has a 5 percent chance of happening. Roll #2 is a 50 percent chance of either passed ball or balk. So those both have to hit to even get to Roll #3, where Roger McDowell’s range for a balk on his 1986 card was 1 to 7, out of 20. That’s a 35 percent chance of it even being a balk and a 65 percent chance of It’s Nothing, Re-Roll From The Top. (I think Roll #3 was a 5.)</p><p>There have been 3 balks in this entire tournament to date. One was harmless in the Angels-Twins Qualifying Round series. <em>The other two</em> were by the Mets in this series (Dwight Gooden in the first inning of Game 1 was the other), and both directly brought in runs for the Cardinals in games the Mets lost by one.</p><p>Games don’t really end on balks, do they? Well, yes. I looked. I had to look. It’s happened 23 times in MLB history (also the exact same number of <em>perfect games </em>in MLB history). The most recent one was this year on <a href="https://www.mlb.com/news/reds-secure-walk-off-win-on-10th-inning-balk">July 8 in Cincinnati</a>.</p><p>I’m sorry, Mets fans. I didn’t want it to end this way. But…maybe don’t blow a 5–2 lead in the 8th.</p><p>Another aspect of this series is the battle between a short pitching staff of the 80s versus a team from 25 years later with a long bullpen. The deeper bullpen outclassed the shorter one in this series.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-1 1998 Yankees (David Wells) at AL-11 1985 Royals (Bret Saberhagen), Yankees lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Playing without Derek Jeter, who is injured for this and New York’s next game, the Yanks score single runs in the 1st and 2nd innings. Then it becomes a pitchers’ duel.</p><p>Saberhagen goes the distance for the Royals (<a href="https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxes/KCA/KCA198510270.shtml">seen it</a>). Wells lasts into the 8th, when he allows three straight singles and a run. Graeme Lloyd comes in to face George Brett with runners on the corners in a 2–1 game. Brett grounds out to first.</p><p>Mariano Rivera allows a lead-off single to Hal McRae in the bottom of the 9th, but Frank White hits into a double play. Steve Balboni singles. Pinch-hitter Pat Sheridan flies out to the warning track in right, a would-be walk-off home run but instead the Yankees win the game 2–1 and the series 3–0. Kudos to the Royals for fighting the good fight, but it wasn’t meant to be for both 11-seeds from Missouri.</p><p>The Tournament Executive Committee (myself) could invoke “The Jack Morris Rule” to determine matchups for the tournament’s next round, a 5-game Division Series. So named for the player who is on 3 teams in this tournament, the rule is in place to avoid the same player being on both teams in a series for as long as possible. That means we may not have a straight bracket, so while it may look like the Yankees will meet the Astros in a Division Series with the 1 and 4 seeds in the A.L., that’s far from certain. If Toronto wins against Boston, they cannot play either the Yankees or Tigers in the next round; instead the Jays would have to face Houston. So everything is TBD.</p><p><em>Game 3: NL-3 1995 Braves (John Smoltz) at NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Miguel Batista), Braves lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Arizona is in deep trouble, being unable to win either game started by Randy Johnson or Curt Schilling.</p><p>Batista was gone in the 2nd inning, allowing a 2-run home run to Jeff Blauser, and then three more runs. Atlanta got two more in the 3rd, and cruised to an easy 7–2 win for the sweep.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Milt Wilcox) at AL-7 2002 Angels (John Lackey), Tigers lead series 2–0</em></p><p>There have been three sweeps in this round, and the Tigers were looking like they could make it four when they loaded the bases in the 1st with nobody out. Lance Parrish grounded into a double play that got a run home, but killed the rally.</p><p>Wilcox was wild, walking three in the bottom of the 2nd. David Eckstein’s 2-run single made it 3–1 Angels. Wilcox would be chased next inning when the Angels scored three more. One of those runs scored on a single by Jose Molina, who had replaced his brother Bengie due to injury. The Angels, who had been the most-injured team in the tournament so far, had started the game at full strength for the first time since the Qualifying Round. Bengie Molina was now out for the rest of this series, which would continue after the Halos took this game 9–2. That could hurt the Angels since Bengie has the better arm.</p><p><em>Game 4: NL-4 1988 Dodgers (Orel Hershiser) at NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain), Dodgers lead series 2–1</em></p><p>Ok, here we go, the Three Day Rest Game. It’s the only time in this tournament both starting pitchers are going on short rest. Hershiser bested Cain 1–0 in Game 1 of this series.</p><p>Both pitchers made their managers look good. It was 1–1 starting the 8th. With two outs, Steve Sax singled and stole second. Mickey Hatcher singled to bring in Sax for a 2–1 Dodgers lead and the end of the night for Cain.</p><p>The Giants matched. Angel Pagan led off with a single and he stole second. Marco Scutaro singled to tie it again, and to end the night for Hershiser. Alejandro Pena came in and retired Pablo Sandoval, Buster Posey, and Hunter Pence, with Pence flying out to the wall in left.</p><p>John Shelby led off the 9th with a walk and was bunted to second, but Santiago Casilla came in to get two ground outs.</p><p>In the bottom of the 10th, the Giants had 2nd and 3rd with after a single, walk, and bunt. With the Dodgers infield in, Sandoval grounded out to second. Posey walked to load the bases, but Pence flied out to center.</p><p>After Kirk Gibson was stranded at second in the top of the 11th, Brandon Belt drew a lead-off walk in the bottom half. Gregor Blanco hit one to short for an infield hit, but Alfredo Griffin committed a throwing error on the play to make it 2nd and 3rd with no outs. Jay Howell got Brandon Crawford to line out and Joaquin Arias to strike out.</p><p>Next up was Pagan, who had reached base in all five of his plate appearances with three hits and two walks. Pagan was also having a good series, so he was intentionally walked to load the bases for Scutaro. The “clutch symbol”, that worked against Devon White in the Toronto-Boston game earlier in the day, worked for Scutaro and turned an out into a hit. Belt scored the winning run, and the Giants had tied the series. Of the four games in this series, three were decided by one run and two of those went extra innings.</p><p><strong>Day 11 (2 games)</strong></p><p><em>Game 3: NL-2 2016 Cubs (Jake Arrieta) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Joe Blanton), Phillies lead series 2–0</em></p><p>Now the weather is clear, and the Phillies could finally attempt to finish the series after their two wins at Wrigley Field. A poor start for them, however, as Ben Zobrist hits a 2-run home run in the 1st, but that’s quickly answered by 2-run shot from Ryan Howard.</p><p>The Cubs get another pair of runs in the 2nd inning, due to errors by Howard and Jimmy Rollins. Addison Russell’s solo home run in the 3rd made it 5–2.</p><p>The Phillies use their speed, and Jake Arrieta’s poor hold rating, to score in the 3rd and 4th. Rollins and Shane Victorino led off those respective innings by reaching base and then stealing second to be driven in. Already a crazy game through 4 innings was 5–4 Cubs.</p><p>Facing left-hander Mike Montgomery, Howard flied out deep to left in the 5th. Javier Baez followed with a solo shot in the top of the 6th. Baez had a huge game, going 4 for 4 with 4 runs scored. Dexter Fowler also had 4 hits.</p><p>A key play occurred in the bottom of the 8th with the Cubs up 7–4. Pat Burrell doubled with two outs; Howard tried to score from 1st, but was thrown out at the plate. Had there been just one out, Howard likely would have been held at third. With two outs, he’s sent home and nailed. Instead of 7–5 with the tying run coming up, the inning was over at 7–4.</p><p>The Cubs tacked on 3 runs in the 9th, with the Phillies holding back Ryan Madson and unable to use Brad Lidge. The final was 10–4, with the Cubs feeling good about their chances.</p><p><em>Game 4: AL-3 1984 Tigers (Juan Berenguer) at AL-7 2002 Angels (Ramon Ortiz), Tigers lead series 2–1</em></p><p>Lou Whitaker led off with a triple, and then Kirk Gibson was intentionally walked with one out. The Angels were hoping Lance Parrish would hit into a double play, but instead he struck out. 5th batter Darrell Evans connected on a three-run homer for an early 3–0 Detroit lead.</p><p>Garret Anderson’s two-run shot in the bottom of the 1st made the score 3–2 before Evans collected his 4th RBI in the 3rd inning.</p><p>Scott Schoeneweis replaced Ortiz in the top of the 4th, but an error by him loaded the bases. Whitaker’s infield hit scored another run, and with their chances in the series about to be extinguished, the Angels brought in their normal 8th-inning pitcher Francisco Rodriguez in the hopes he could get some strikeouts. Instead, Alan Trammell singled in two more runs and it was 7–2. A Parrish double and Johnny Grubb single made it 9–2.</p><p>The final would be 11–3, and the Tigers become the third A.L. team to advance. That led to some big decisions by the Executive Committee.</p><p>The A.L. “bracket”, as it were, was being jammed up by the Toronto-Boston series and the Jack Morris Rule. The Yankees and Astros have been waiting around to find out their next opponents, and we want to minimize their days off and avoid any idle days in the tournament if we can.</p><p>The Committee has decided that any team that wins this tournament is going to have to beat 4, and possibly 5, other great championship teams to do it and the order in which those teams line up doesn’t matter much. The idea of a straight bracket is gone. Seeds only matter for home-field advantage now.</p><p>Since the Blue Jays cannot play the Yankees or Tigers in the next round, the Committee declared the Yankees and Tigers will just face each other in the Division Series no matter what happens between the Blue Jays and Red Sox. The winner of Toronto-Boston Game 5 will take on the Astros. If Toronto wins, how will we handle the ALCS against New York or Detroit with the duplicated players? The Committee hasn’t decided yet — everything’s in flux.</p><p>The National League is jammed up too, mostly by the Cubs and Phillies who could still have 2 games remaining, as well as the Dodgers and Giants going the distance plus some other “Jack Morris” potential scenarios. The Committee wants to avoid a Braves-Dodgers matchup (Alejandro Pena) and Cardinals-Giants (Ryan Theriot). It’s decided one NLDS will be the Cardinals against the Braves, and the other will be between the winners of the Cubs-Phillies and Dodgers-Giants series.</p><p>This allows us to schedule games for Day 13, where the Division Series will begin in New York and Atlanta. Before that, we have three major games on Day 12.</p><p><strong>Day 12 (3 games)</strong></p><p><em>Game 4: NL-2 2016 Cubs (Kyle Hendricks) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Brett Myers), Phillies lead series 2–1</em></p><p>The Cubs began the day very confident with their ace pitcher on the mound, but that confidence was abruptly snuffed out with Jayson Werth and Pat Burrell hitting 1st-inning home runs to put the Phillies ahead 3–0.</p><p>The Cubs got their first two batters on in the top of the 2nd, but Jason Heyward struck out with runners on 2nd and 3rd with 1 out. Baez was then intentionally walked with Hendricks on deck. Joe Maddon considered already pinch-hitting for Hendricks with this scoring chance, but stuck with him and the inning ended on a groundout to first.</p><p>Hendricks hit Jimmy Rollins with a pitch to lead off the 3rd, already the second Phillies hit batsman of the game (Chase Utley took one in the 1st, and would score on Burrell’s homer). Hendricks would be pulled after Werth singled and Rollins advanced to 3rd. With the game and the series quickly getting away from the Cubs, they brought in closer Aroldis Chapman, hoping he could get some strikeouts against the heart of the Phillies order. The Cubs would worry about how they could finish the game later if they could just get out of this jam now.</p><p>It didn’t work. Chase Utley doubled to score Rollins. Ryan Howard singled to bring in both Werth and Utley. Burrell walked, and Shane Victorino hit a 3-run homer. Suddenly, and shockingly, the Phillies led 9–0. Chapman never retired a batter.</p><p>Remember that two Phillies batters had been hit by pitches in the first 3 innings. Ben Zobrist was plunked leading off the top of the 4th. I decided that’s when the umpires would give warnings to both dugouts.</p><p>Next batter Willson Contreras grounded into a fielders’ choice, and that’s when I wondered: would this be a brawl when Zobrist slid hard into second base, already angry about being down 9–0 and thinking he was hit on purpose? I decided no, it wouldn’t escalate to that, but there would be words exchanged and posturing with the teams all stepping out on to the field and the crowd booing.</p><p>With the score 10–0 after an Utley home run, Anthony Rizzo became the second Cub to be hit by a pitch as he led off the 6th. OK, I decided, now <em>that’s</em> a brawl. We ejected Myers, manager Charlie Manuel, Rizzo, Zobrist (who was on deck and would also charge toward Myers), and third baseman Pedro Feliz for intercepting Zobrist and wrestling to the ground with him.</p><p>In the bottom of the 6th, Pedro Strop and Maddon would be ejected for plunking pinch-hitter Chris Coste. The intent appeared borderline, but the warnings had been issued long earlier.</p><p>After what seemed like a week, the game mercifully ended with the Phillies winning 11–0 and taking the series in 4. No need for a rematch of Cole Hamels and Jon Lester the next night in Chicago. The Phillies, who are 5–2 overall in tournament play, will meet the winner of Dodgers-Giants. Hamels will be able to pitch the opener.</p><p>What a weird series, which had the Phillies using 7 pitchers and winning Game 1 with three unearned runs scored, then the Phillies scrambling to manage their short-handed bullpen, a rainout and extra day off, the Cubs using a closer in the 3rd inning, and a 5-HBP basebrawl.</p><p>Also, the ball is absolutely flying out of Citizens Bank Park. Most of the ballparks in this tournament are pitchers’ parks, but Philadelphia is a glaring exception. In the 4 tournament games at CBP, there’s been 11 home runs.</p><p><em>Game 5: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at AL-2 2018 Red Sox (Chris Sale), Series tied 2–2</em></p><p>The Blue Jays bypassed David Cone, who was rocked in Game 1. Jimmy Key had thrown 15.2 scoreless innings in the tournament, including 8 in Game 2, so it was an easy move.</p><p>Key and Sale were expectedly dominant, and it took an extreme oddity for Key to allow his first run. Steve Pearce hit a fly to right, and the dice rolled a 2-base error on Joe Carter. Next batter Rafael Devers singled, and Pearce scored to give the Red Sox a 1–0 lead.</p><p>Now, I felt bad about this one. I think it’s a tiny flaw in the game that gives an average-at-best defensive outfielder a higher probability to make an error than it should. Do I think that in a big game like this Joe Carter would drop a fly ball? No, I don’t. Not in a million years. But it’s not impossible. He could lose it in the lights, he could collide with an infielder backing up, or he could pull a Wil Myers in the 2013 playoffs and just not catch the ball.</p><iframe src="https://cdn.embedly.com/widgets/media.html?src=https%3A%2F%2Fgfycat.com%2Fifr%2Fhilariousheartfeltamericancrocodile&amp;display_name=Gfycat&amp;url=https%3A%2F%2Fgfycat.com%2Fhilariousheartfeltamericancrocodile&amp;image=https%3A%2F%2Fthumbs.gfycat.com%2FHilariousHeartfeltAmericancrocodile-size_restricted.gif&amp;key=a19fcc184b9711e1b4764040d3dc5c07&amp;type=text%2Fhtml&amp;schema=gfycat" width="450" height="250" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"><a href="https://medium.com/media/03f8ce82943f3be0b895e920ea5c0a6d/href">https://medium.com/media/03f8ce82943f3be0b895e920ea5c0a6d/href</a></iframe><p>So I thought it was a very chintzy run for the Red Sox, and I didn’t want to count it but it’s what appeared on the dice that landed properly in the box. Even for a few minutes as I continued playing, I considered just pretending Pearce flied out and the game was still scoreless.</p><p>Ian Kinsler hit a solo wall-scraper home run over the Green Monster in the bottom of the 7th to make it 2–0 (or maybe 1–0, I still wasn’t sure) Red Sox. It was Key’s first earned run allowed in 3 starts.</p><p>To this point, Chris Sale had allowed just one hit over 7 innings. He had struck out Carter, Winfield, and Olerud in the top of the 7th. He was rolling. Until Candy Maldonado led off the 8th with a walk. Kelly Gruber then doubled, and suddenly the Blue Jays had 2nd and 3rd with no outs.</p><p>Rance Mulliniks pinch-hit for Pat Borders. He flew out to shallow center and Maldonado could not score. Next was Pat Tabler pinch-hitting for Manny Lee, and he drew a walk to load the bases with 1 out. A tiring Sale was then lifted for Boston’s most consistent middle relief pitcher, Ryan Brasier.</p><p>Devon White hits another shallow fly to center, again not deep enough for Maldonado to score from 3rd. So it was still a 2-run game, with bases loaded and 2 outs for Roberto Alomar. A sharp single advanced the runners 90 feet and finally got the Blue Jays on the scoreboard.</p><p>Next up: Joe Carter. The man whose error earlier in the game cost the Blue Jays a run now delivered a 2-run single which silenced the crowd at Fenway Park, as the home team now trailed 3–2 in the 8th!</p><p>So much for that chintzy run. But is that baseball, or what? Carter commits the big error, then he makes up for it with the clutch hit. Similar to Mitch Moreland in Game 4.</p><p>Duane Ward came in for the bottom of the 8th to face Betts, Benintendi, and Martinez. It was three up, three down.</p><p>Tom Henke got the ball for the 9th. Bogaerts led off with a single. Moreland sent one to deep right that off the bat sounded like a walk-off series-winning home run, but Fenway’s deep right field held the ball in the park.</p><p>Up next was Brock Holt pinch-hitting for Eduardo Nunez, who came in as a defensive replacement for Devers in the 8th. Holt hit a sharp grounder to first baseman Olerud, who threw to 2nd for the first out and got the return throw in time for the game-ending double play!</p><p>The Blue Jays jump and dance on the Fenway infield. One big inning, a 3-run 8th, won them the game and the series. Chris Sale took a hard-luck loss by allowing the three runners to reach base who all scored after he was taken out. Jimmy Key collected his third win of the tournament with just two runs allowed, and one earned, in 22.2 innings.</p><p>Toronto advances to meet the 2017 Astros in two days. Both 2-seeds, the Cubs and Red Sox, were eliminated in the same day and there was still one more dramatic game to go.</p><p><em>Game 5: NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner) at NL-4 1988 Dodgers (John Tudor), Series tied 2–2</em></p><p>Bumgarner delivered the best-pitched game of the tournament in Game 2, where he took a no-hitter into the 8th, struck out 11, and went nine-and-two-thirds in the Giants’ 1–0 win. John Tudor was making his first appearance, having been passed over for Hershiser in Game 4.</p><p>This time the Dodgers got to MadBum for single runs in the 3rd and 5th. It could have been worse, with Kirk Gibson flying out to the wall in right for a sacrifice fly instead of a grand slam.</p><p>Bumgarner was removed after John Shelby’s lead-off single in the 6th. With Bumgarner’s poor hold rating, he was vulnerable to a stolen base and putting another runner in scoring position already down 2–0 in this elimination game. However, Jeff Hamilton tripled against George Kontos to make it 3–0.</p><p>Brandon Crawford stepped to the plate with two outs and the bases empty in the top of the 7th. Crawford hit a double. Joaquin Arias, pinch-hitting for Bumgarner, singled Crawford to third. Still no harm, no foul. Runners on the corners, 2 outs.</p><p>Angel Pagan, already 2 for 3 and having a great series, hit a grounder to short. Alfredo Griffin then committed his third error of the series, allowing Crawford to score. It was now 3–1, and the inning should have been over. Tudor was then taken out for right-hander Brian Holton, who countered Bumgarner with 5.1 shutout innings in Game 2 when pressed into emergency relief and had a 1.70 ERA in 1988.</p><p>When Arias on 2nd and Pagan on 1st, Marco Scutaro singled to load the bases. Up next was Pablo Sandoval, who like almost all of the Giants was struggling offensively. He was 0 for 3 in the game, and hitting .200 for the series with no RBI and no clutch hits.</p><p>In the words of Giants broadcaster Jon Miller, “Adios, pelota!”</p><p>A jaw-dropping grand slam. A Panda Slam. Giants 5, Dodgers 3. Instantly, the highest run total for the Giants in any game of the series.</p><p>Steve Sax led off the 7th with a walk and a stolen base against Santiago Casilla. Mickey Hatcher then singled, and Sax was waved home with an 80 percent chance of being safe. It was easy to assume this would become a 5–4 game, but not only did Hunter Pence throw home, Hatcher held at first to avoid a cutoff play. Sax was surprisingly thrown out, and the Dodgers rally was extinct a minute later when Gibson lined into a double play. The Giants ran off the field like they had stolen a bag of money.</p><p>It was a formality after that. Jeremy Affeldt pitched a perfect 8th, and Sergio Romo got the save. In stunning fashion, the Giants went from down 3 runs with the bases empty and two outs in the 7th to winning the series.</p><p>The Giants were another team that took advantage of having a longer bullpen than their opponent from the 80s, which is discouraging to those of us who don’t like the bloated pitching staffs of today.</p><p><em>Side note: Well, now we don’t have to worry about what to do with Kirk Gibson if the Dodgers made the Grand World Series (he probably would have been limited to just one at-bat), especially if they were to face the Tigers.</em></p><p>So we started with 22 teams and now it’s down to 8. The pairings for the Division Series (best-of-5):</p><p><strong>ALDS:</strong> 1998 Yankees vs. 1984 Tigers, 2017 Astros vs. 1992 Blue Jays<br><strong>NLDS:</strong> 1995 Braves vs. 2011 Cardinals, 2012 Giants vs. 2008 Phillies</p><p>Interesting clump of teams from ’08, ’11, and ’12 in the N.L., while the A.L. survivors are very spread out across several eras. Also, Giants-Phillies will be at the ballparks with the highest and lowest home-run probability.</p><p>Click here for <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-division-series-highlights-a8931706f3c0">Part IV</a>, the entire Division Series and an ending even crazier than the Mets-Cardinals balk.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=fd3a8d96f3fc" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strat-O-Matic Modern Champions Tournament, Round of 16, Games 1 and 2 Highlights]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-round-of-16-games-1-and-2-highlights-ae174015c8a4?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ae174015c8a4</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stratomatic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-series]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball-history]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[tournaments]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 22 Aug 2022 18:47:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-01-04T18:27:33.095Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Summaries of the first 16 of a possible 40 games in the tournament’s largest round</em></p><p>It’s time for a Modern Champions Tournament update. <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-qualifying-round-highlights-1fe96ed12f76">Here is Part I of this sports board-game project,</a> an explanation of the tournament and its format, plus the highlights of the best-of-3 Qualifying Round.</p><p>We’re now in the Round of 16, which consists of 8 American League and 8 National League World Series champions meeting in best-of-5 series. Here are the matchups with their seeds:</p><p><strong>American League<br></strong>(1) 1998 Yankees vs. (11) 1985 Royals<br>(4) 2017 Astros vs. (5) 1989 Athletics<br>(3) 1984 Tigers vs. (7) 2002 Angels<br>(2) 2018 Red Sox vs. (9) 1992 Blue Jays</p><p><strong>National League<br></strong>(1) 1986 Mets vs. (11) 2011 Cardinals<br>(4) 1988 Dodgers vs. (5) 2012 Giants<br>(3) 1995 Braves vs. (7) 2001 Diamondbacks<br>(2) 2016 Cubs vs. (8) 2008 Phillies</p><p>Let’s get straight to the highlights, going in the order in which the games were played. Again, the schedule of games is determined by imagining this tournament is taking place in real ballparks and televised by major cable networks (I’d say TBS/TNT with some MLB Network thrown in).</p><p><strong>Tournament Day 6 (The Qualifying Round was played on days 1–5)</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (David Cone) at AL-2 2018 Red Sox (Chris Sale)</em></p><p>The Round of 16 gets off to a fast start as the Blue Jays score twice in the first inning, one of those runs unearned due to a Xander Bogaerts throwing error. Dave Winfield’s sacrifice fly and John Olerud’s RBI single made the score 2–0. However, the Red Sox answer with one in the bottom half on a J.D. Martinez RBI double.</p><p>In an ironic development very similar to real life, Chris Sale is injured in the 2nd inning and has to leave the game. <strong><em>(Note: This tournament does not have long-term injuries; the most a player can miss is 2 games, but as we’ll see, some big players got some unlucky rolls of the dice in this round.)</em></strong> Sale is replaced<em> </em>by projected Game 4 starter Nathan Eovaldi.</p><p>The Jays can’t touch Eovaldi for over 5 innings until a harmless Candy Maldonado solo home run in the 7th. Harmless because the Red Sox score 6 runs in the 4th, chasing David Cone out of the game. 8 of the first 9 batters in the inning reached base, with 4 extra-base hits including Ian Kinsler and Rafael Devers with back-to-back triples.</p><p>The Red Sox tack on another run in the 5th and 3 more in the 8th, where Bogaerts hit a 2-run home run. Red Sox win 11–3. They’ll move Eduardo Rodriguez into the probable start for Game 4, and Sale can come back in the if-necessary Game 5.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-5 1989 Athletics (Mike Moore) at AL-4 2017 Astros (Justin Verlander)</em></p><p>A pitchers’ duel for 4 innings, with Moore not allowing any hits and Verlander just giving up piddly singles. Houston breaks through in the 5th — Josh Reddick doubles, followed by an Evan Gattis RBI single. Later in the inning, Alex Bregman draws a bases-loaded walk.</p><p>It remains 2–0 in the 7th when Oakland’s bullpen falters. Gene Nelson walks the 8th and 9th batters in the lineup to start the inning, then George Springer hits a 3-run shot. Todd Burns proceeds to allow 3 more runs over the remaider of the 7th and 8th, not helped by Dave Henderson dropping a fly ball.</p><p>The Bash Brothers only offense is a two-run homer by…Walt Weiss? Yep. 8–2 Astros.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Kyle Lohse) at NL-1 1986 Mets (Dwight Gooden)</em></p><p>A weird first inning puts the Mets in a bind early. Skip Schumaker and Albert Pujols collect one-out singles to put runners on the corners. Then Dwight Gooden commits a balk (!) and a run scores. Lance Berkman then singles Pujols to 3rd, and a Matt Holliday sac fly makes it 2–0.</p><p>And the Mets cannot do a thing against Kyle Lohse. He retires the first 13 batters he faces until a Darryl Strawberry single, but that’s immediately followed by Ray Knight grounding into a 6–4–3 double play.</p><p>Gooden settles down. He gets a break when Holliday lines into a double play after a Berkman lead-off double in the 4th. He winds up going 6 because the Mets have to pinch-hit for him.</p><p>Lenny Dykstra singles home Mookie Wilson with 2 outs in the 6th, but that’s all the Mets can get. The Cardinals bullpen of Mark Rzepczynski, Fernando Salas, and Jason Motte shut down the top N.L. seed over the last three innings. The Cardinals don’t score again after their stunning top of the 1st, but don’t need to. These Cardinals are one hard-to-kill team. They win 2–1 to become the first road team to win in this round.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-5 2012 Giants (Matt Cain) at NL-4 1988 Dodgers (Orel Hershiser)</em></p><p>That’s <em>the </em>Orel Hershiser, who set the MLB record with 59 straights scoreless innings in 1988, against <em>the </em>Matt Cain, who pitched a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-IGSh3LLUZ8">perfect game</a> with 14 strikeouts on June 13, 2012.</p><p>The matchup lives up to the billing. Hershiser allows no hits for the first six-and-two-thirds innings. Buster Posey’s single breaks up the no-hitter.</p><p>In the Dodger 4th, Mike Marshall singles with one out. John Shelby grounds into a force play at 2nd, now putting the faster Shelby on first. Shelby steals second base and scores on Mike Scioscia’s single.</p><p>Still 1–0 Dodgers in the 9th, Angel Pagan triples with one out. It’s just the second hit for the Giants. But Marco Scutaro grounds out to short and Pagan must hold. Pablo Sandoval grounds out to second to end the game.</p><p>It’s a double complete game for Hershiser and Cain. The Giants just get two hits and one runner in scoring position all night.</p><p><strong>Tournament Day 7 (8 games)</strong></p><p><em>Game 2: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at AL-2 2018 Red Sox (Rick Porcello), Red Sox lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Another quick start for the Blue Jays as Winfield hits a 2-run HR in the first. This time the Red Sox do not answer.</p><p>Toronto tacks on more in the 4th. Maldonado doubles to put runners on 2nd and 3rd, then Kelly Gruber singles in one and a Pat Borders sac fly makes it 4–0. They finally chase Porcello in the 6th, but a Gruber 2-run single off Ryan Brasier makes it 6–0. Gruber adds a solo home run in the 8th for his 4th RBI.</p><p>Jimmy Key is dominant, even more so than he was in the Qualifying Round against the 1983 Orioles. He goes eight shutout innings. Cito Gaston gives him the 9th off with the 7–0 lead, but that gets a little hairy.</p><p>Mark Eichhorn allows a double to Martinez and a triple to Bogaerts, then a Manny Lee error makes it 7–2. After a Brock Holt single, Duane Ward has to come in to finish. Eduardo Nunez hits a sacrifice fly for the second out, then Christian Vazquez grounds out. Toronto wins 7–3 and ties the series.</p><p>Jimmy Key has pitched 15.2 innings in the tournament without allowing any runs.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Randy Johnson) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Greg Maddux)</em></p><p>Hands down, the most-anticipated pitching matchup of the early games in this round. It had a lot of live up to after Cain-Hershiser the night before, but it came close.</p><p>No scoring through 6 innings, and really nobody even close to scoring. That changed when Luis Gonzalez (57 home runs in 2001) led off the 7th with a solo shot, and that’s when the fun starts.</p><p>Matt Williams followed with a double. Two batters later, Danny Bautista singled in Williams and it was 2–0. Maddux walked Mark Grace, and stunningly he was out of the game. It’s like he didn’t just hit the wall; he drove into it full-speed.</p><p>And then…the same thing happened to Randy Johnson, only worse! He didn’t even record an out in the 7th inning. Chipper Jones and Fred McGriff led off with singles, and David Justice walked to load the bases. Mike Devereaux doubled to tie the game. Due up next was Charlie O’Brien, but he was only catching because Maddux was pitching. Jeff Blauser went up to pinch-hit, but with runners on 2nd and 3rd, he was intentionally walked. Now the Braves were bringing up their regular catcher, Javy Lopez, to pinch-hit for light-hitting shortstop Rafael Belliard.</p><p>Arizona brought in Bobby Witt, who got Lopez to bounce into the 1–2–3 double play. But that did not end the inning; there were only two outs, and the game still tied. Dwight Smith pinch-hit for Alejandro Pena, but again was intentionally walked. That set up a righty-righty matchup for Witt against Marquis Grissom, but that’s when Witt threw a wild pitch and Devereaux scored from 3rd to put the Braves ahead 3–2. A crazy 7th inning.</p><p>Mark Wohlers came on to pitch the 9th. Blauser, now playing shortstop, committed an error to let lead-off hitter Matt Williams reach. Steve Finley grounded into a force at second, but Finley ended up stealing second and scoring the tying run on another Bautista RBI single. After a wild pitch advanced Bautista to second, Wohlers got out of trouble by striking out Grace, intentionally walking pinch-hitter Erubiel Durazo, and getting Reggie Sanders to fly out.</p><p>Blauser led off the bottom of the 9th with a single off Mike Morgan. Lopez singled Blauser to 3rd, and Byung-Hyun Kim came in to pitch with the winning run at 3rd and no outs. Pinch-hitter Ryan Klesko struck out. Grissom grounded into a fielders’ choice, cutting down Blauser trying to score. Now it was 1st and 2nd with two outs, and it appeared Kim might pull off the escape and get the game to extra innings.</p><p>Mark Lemke singled to right-center, driving in Lopez from 2nd. One of the best games of the tournament to date went to Atlanta 4–3.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-7 2002 Angels (Jarrod Washburn) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Jack Morris)</em></p><p>In a very odd circumstance only possible in a tournament like this, Jarrod Washburn was pitching against Jack Morris in two different rounds. This was the same matchup in the Qualifying Round when the Angels met the 1991 Twins.</p><p>In that QR series, the Angels were the hard-luck team when it came to injuries. Troy Glaus and Garret Anderson remained unavailable for this first game against the Tigers, and to top it off Tim Salmon was hit by a pitch in the first inning here and lost for this game and the next one. The Angels played almost the entirety of Game 1 without their regular 3–4–5 hitters.</p><p>And it showed. The closest they came to scoring was in the 3rd with bases loaded and one out, but Alex Ochoa, replacing Salmon, grounded into a force at home.</p><p>Washburn went the distance for the Angels but allowed 4 hits and 2 runs in the 4th inning. It was his only bad frame. Morris went 6.2, Bill Scherrer 1.1, and 1984 A.L. MVP Willie Hernandez closed it in the 9th. Final score: 2–0 Tigers.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Lance Lynn) at NL-1 1986 Mets (Bob Ojeda), Cardinals lead series 1–0</em></p><p>The Cardinals send another jolt into the Shea Stadium crowd with a Berkman solo home run in the 2nd, but that’s answered by one from Gary Carter in the bottom half.</p><p>Lance Lynn, who was used out of the bullpen in the Qualifying Round, did well over 5 innings. The Cardinals lifted him for a pinch-hitter in the 6th with runners on 2nd and 3rd and two outs, but Nick Punto was intentionally walked to face the struggling Rafael Furcal. Furcal flew out to end the inning. Furcal is 1 for 18 in the tournament, and may be replaced as the lead-off hitter by Ryan Theriot, who was 4-for-4 in this game batting 8th.</p><p>Mark Rzepczynski, who has been almost perfect so far in the tournament, started the 7th inning with a 1–1 tie. He walked pinch-hitter Kevin Mitchell and Keith Hernandez. Mitchell Boggs came in and walked Carter. Arthur Rhodes came in to face Strawberry, who doubled in two and the Mets had their first lead of the series. Mookie Wilson later singled in Carter and Strawberry and the Mets had a 4-run lead.</p><p>David Freese homered in the top of the 8th, and the Cardinals then got two more runners on. Roger McDowell came in with pinch-hitter Allen Craig representing the tying run. Craig grounded out and Furcal flew out again. Jesse Orosco pitched the 9th for the save. Mets tie the series with a 5–2 win and they head to St. Louis.</p><p><em>Game 1: AL-11 1985 Royals (Charlie Leibrandt) at AL-1 1998 Yankees (David Cone)</em></p><p>The underdog Royals tried a bold here-we-are move in the first as Willie Wilson attempted a straight steal of home. He had a 30 percent chance of being safe. It didn’t work; he was out. Hal McRae then struck out to end the inning.</p><p>The Yankees immediately jumped on the misfire and scored 2 runs themselves in the bottom of the 1st. Derek Jeter tripled with one out, then Paul O’Neill doubled. Chili Davis knocked in O’Neill.</p><p>The Royals got one across in the 4th, but otherwise Cone struck out 11 over 7 innings. Leibrandt got in his own groove for K.C. and pitched into the 6th. Steve Farr was also effective for 1.2 innings, and there was no more scoring.</p><p>Graeme Lloyd and Mariano Rivera finished the 2–1 win for the Yanks.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Jamie Moyer) at NL-2 2016 Cubs (Kyle Hendricks)</em></p><p>The Cubs touched Moyer for two runs in the 1st and it could have been more. Kris Bryant and Anthony Rizzo walked with one out. Ben Zobrist brought home Bryant with a single. With two outs, Willson Contreras doubled to left to score Rizzo, but Zobrist was thrown out at the plate to end the inning.</p><p>The Phillies countered with a Ryan Howard home run leading off the 2nd, but gave the run back right away. Kyle Hendricks sacrificed Addison Russell to second base, then Dexter Fowler delivered an RBI single. When Moyer hit Bryant with a pitch, that was the end of the night for him and in came rookie J.A. Happ.</p><p>Over 3.1 innings, Happ allowed just one hit and that runner would be erased on a double play. The Cubs’ 3–1 lead lasted into the 5th, and the rally started when Happ himself singled with one out. Javier Baez made a critical error with two outs to load the bases, which were subsequently cleared by a Howard double and the Phillies led 4–3. All three runs unearned.</p><p>With two outs in the 6th and a runner on 3rd, Greg Dobbs was announced to pinch-hit for Happ. The Cubs brought in lefty Mike Montgomery to replace Hendricks, and then the Phillies substituted Eric Bruntlett to hit for Dobbs. Bruntlett, normally a defensive replacement, doubled in the run and it was 5–3.</p><p>Scott Eyre started the bottom of the 6th and allowed a run to score. With Contreras on 3rd and one out, Jason Heyward grounded out to first and the runner held. Russell flew out to end the threat. It was now 5–4.</p><p>That’s how it stayed. The Phillies used a total of 7 pitchers, a tournament-high for any team, and got the 5–4 win. J.C. Romero, Ryan Madson, and Brad Lidge set the Cubs down the final three innings, but not without peril. The final batter of the game was Kyle Schwarber, relegated to pinch-hitting duty in this tournament due to his real-life injury and usage in 2016. Lidge struck out Schwarber to end the game but rolled the dreaded 6–12. Triple boxcars: a 6 on the white die, and two 6s on the reds. That means a pitcher injury.</p><p>The tournament rules call for a single die roll to determine the severity of in-game injuries. A roll of 4, 5, or 6 means the player is fine. A roll of 1 means he’s out for the next game, 2 is out for the next two games, and 3 means the injured player must leave the current game but miss no more time.</p><p>Lidge rolled a 2. It’s incredible how hard it is to roll the injury numbers in the first place, and then roll the most-severe case on the next roll, but it just happened to the Phillies closer and later on it will happen to another big-time player. The Phillies now hope their 2008 postseason MVP Cole Hamels can go deep in Game 2.</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-5 1989 Athletics (Dave Stewart) at AL-4 2017 Astros (Dallas Keuchel), Astros lead series 1–0</em></p><p>One of the greatest pitchers in A’s history, Dave Stewart, never had a chance. I’ve never thought the sign-stealing trashcan-banging of the 2017 Astros was the baseball crime of the century it was made out to be, but I’m wondering if these guys can be beat with this juggernaut offense. The results of their scheme is certainly reflected in the cards.</p><p>Carlos Correa started it with a 2-run double after a pair of walks and one out. Jose Altuve beat the throw to the plate for the 2nd run, enabling Correa to advance to 3rd. Already down 2–0, the A’s played the infield in and Yuli Gurriel blooped a single over the infield to score Correa.</p><p>An Alex Bregman RBI single in the 2nd made it 4–0 and sent Stewart to an early shower. A sacrifice fly by Altuve put Houston up 5–0 after two.</p><p>Then the A’s got back in the game. Rickey Henderson hit a 2-run HR in the 3rd, and Dave Parker hit a three-run shot in the 4th to tie it 5–5. Both rallies started with two outs and the bases empty.</p><p>It didn’t last. The Astros grinded out three runs in the 5th. Oakland got one back in the top of the 6th to make the score a manageable 8–6. Still a game. Until the Astros mashed for 7 runs in the 6th, the biggest inning of the tournament so far. The first 5 batters of the 6th all got hits, including three straight doubles by Correa, Gurriel, and Reddick. The inning was capped by a Bregman grand slam and it was 15–6.</p><p>The A’s registered the tournament’s second-biggest offensive output in a single game to this point. Unfortunately for them, they gave up the biggest in the very same game. 4 runs in the last 3 innings for the A’s turned out meaningless and the final score was 15–10.</p><p>There are going to be entire series in this round that don’t get to 25 combined runs, and it was done here in one game. Add Game 1 to the total and these teams have scored 35 runs. Oakland’s heading home one loss away from extinction.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-5 2012 Giants (Madison Bumgarner) at NL-4 1988 Dodgers (Tim Belcher), Dodgers lead series 1–0</em></p><p>On the other hand, we have the anemic offenses of these two clubs, or at least anemic in this series.</p><p>The Dodgers lost Belcher to an injury in the 2nd inning. It was very similar to Game 1 of the Blue Jays-Red Sox series where the starter had to leave but the long reliever effectively went over 5 innings. The role of Nathan Eovaldi in this case was played by Brian Holton.</p><p>Madison Bumgarner was every bit as good, if not better, than Orel Hershiser in Game 1. He took a no-hitter into the 8th, where Mike Scioscia broke it up with a 2-out single. The game was still scoreless heading to the 10th.</p><p>Jay Howell pitched the 10th for the Dodgers. Pagan walked with one out, and Scutaro singled him to 3rd. Joaquin Arias was due up next, since he had pinch-ran for Sandoval back in the 8th. Arias hit a shin burger off of Howell, which caromed to Steve Sax to get the out at first, but Pagan scored and the Giants led 1–0. Howell was checked but remained in the game to strike out Buster Posey for the third out.</p><p>Bumgarner started the bottom of the 10th. Kirk Gibson lined out on a nice play by Scutaro for the second out. Marshall singled, Mike Davis pinch-ran, and Shelby singled Davis to 3rd. A tiring Bumgarner was then lifted for closer Sergio Romo. Shelby stole second to put the winning run in scoring position, but Scioscia popped out to second for the final out.</p><p>Two games, two 1–0 final scores. Series tied 1–1.</p><p><strong>Total runs scored in series with Bay Area teams</strong><br>Oakland-Houston: 35<br>San Francisco-Los Angeles: 2</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4POXsb5mgRJU5b-ps4W5Hw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>Tournament Day 8 (4 games)</strong></p><p><em>Game 2: AL-7 2002 Angels (Kevin Appier) at AL-3 1984 Tigers (Dan Petry), Tigers lead series 1–0</em></p><p>Glaus and Anderson were back for the Halos, but Salmon was still out. Petry started sharp, striking out 5 in the first two innings.</p><p>Lou Whitaker’s RBI single brought home Chet Lemon in the 3rd for the game’s first run. Lemon had led off the inning with a double.</p><p>Kirk Gibson lost a Brad Fullmer fly ball in the sun and had it go off his glove starting the 5th. Fullmer reached second on the error. He would score on a two-out double by Adam Kennedy, tying the game.</p><p>Dave Bergman tripled with one out in the 5th, but was stranded there after Appier retired Whitaker and Alan Trammell.</p><p>David Eckstein singled with one out in the 8th. Darin Erstad doubled to center, but Eckstein was thrown out at home. Glaus then flied out to the warning track in left, and the Angels did not score.</p><p>Francisco Rodriguez started the 9th for the Angels with the score still 1–1. Howard Johnson singled with one out and stole second. Rodriguez struck out Lemon for the second out. Bergman then singled to right and Johnson beat Ochoa’s throw home. Tigers win 2–1, and lead the series 2–0.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Curt Schilling) at NL-3 1995 Braves (Tom Glavine), Braves lead series 1–0</em></p><p>It was hopeful that Curt Schilling and Tom Glavine could produce close to the same pitchers’ duel that Johnson and Maddux did in Game 1.</p><p>Glavine held up his end but had one flaw, a Gonzalez solo home run in the 1st for a 1–0 Arizona lead.</p><p>Here’s the first four batters for the Braves in the 2nd inning:<br>Fred McGriff walk<br>David Justice home run<br>Ryan Klesko single<br>Javy Lopez home run</p><p>Just like that, 4–1 Atlanta. They put another run on the board in the 3rd. Schilling lasted only 4 innings and was lifted for a pinch-hitter in the 5th. The Diamondbacks never threatened as Glavine went the distance and the Braves took a 2–0 series lead with John Smoltz ready to start Game 3. The D-Backs will likely bring back Johnson on three days rest for Game 4, if they can get to a Game 4.</p><p><em>Game 2: AL-11 1985 Royals (Bud Black) at AL-1 1998 Yankees (Orlando Hernandez), Yankees lead series 1–0</em></p><p>The Royals would have definitely preferred to use Bret Saberhagen or Danny Jackson here, but they hadn’t had enough rest from their heroics in the Qualifying Round against the White Sox. They hoped Black could get them through 5 or 6 innings.</p><p>Willie Wilson reached third base in the first inning again, this time with a triple. The Royals were not trying to steal home now. George Brett singled in Wilson for a 1–0 lead, then Hal McRae grounded into a double play.</p><p>It was still 1–0 in the 3rd. Chuck Knoblauch drew a one-out walk. Up came Jeter. The roll was a white 2 and red snake-eyes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*CvGCSd3YANMYB9YzO3cRfg.jpeg" /></figure><p>“HBP plus injury”. The chances of rolling 2–2 are slim, but it happened and then it was time to roll the die for severity.</p><p>It was a 2. Jeter is out for this game, and the next two.</p><p>As if he was personally enraged at this development, next batter Paul O’Neill blasted a three-run homer. 3–1 Yankees.</p><p>Shane Spencer led off the 4th with a home run, and Black gave up two hits and a walk before he was removed for Mark Gubicza. It was 5–1 after four.</p><p>The Royals cut it to 5–3 in the top of the 7th, but Wilson popped out to end the inning with Brett on deck. Jorge Posada then had 5 RBI in the 7th and 8th innings, three of them on a homer in the 7th. The Yankees cruised home 10–3.</p><p>So, Jeter is out for the next two. It didn’t hurt in this game. We’ll see what happens. Saberhagen and Jackson are due to pitch Games 3 and 4 in Kansas City, so it’s not over yet. Of course, there’s also a chance that the second game of Jeter’s injury is the first game of the next series.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Cole Hamels) at NL-2 2016 Cubs (Jon Lester), Phillies lead series 1–0</em></p><p>The Cubs threatened in the first with two runners in scoring position with one out, but Cole Hamels struck out Zobrist and got Baez to fly out.</p><p>It remained scoreless into the 4th. After Chase Utley grounded into a double play, Howard singled and scored from first on Pat Burrell’s double. Burrell had been 0 for 12 in the tournament entering this game.</p><p>The Cubs answered in the 4th with two hits and a sac fly, then took the lead in the 5th on a Kris Bryant triple. Jon Lester had singled earlier and scored the run, similar to J.A. Happ in Game 1 for the Phillies.</p><p>It all caved in on Lester in the 7th. Howard walked and Burrell homered. It was 3–2 Phillies, and they have been a team that has collected back-breaking, stadium-quieting clutch hits on the road throughout the whole tournament so far. All 5 of their games have been either tied or had a 1-run margin entering the 7th inning.</p><p>They weren&#39;t done. With one out, Pedro Feliz walked and Carlos Ruiz homered. Ruiz had been 0 for 14 entering this game. Now it was 5–2 and Lester was pulled. Jimmy Rollins added the third home run of the inning for the Phillies, a solo shot off Pedro Strop. Suddenly it was 6–2 Phillies.</p><p>Hamels gave them the length they needed without Lidge, and then some. A complete game to give the Phillies a 2–0 series lead headed home.</p><p>5 of the 8 series in this round are 2–0; the Phillies are the only lower seed to be ahead.</p><p>Please <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-conclusion-of-round-of-16-highlights-fd3a8d96f3fc">click here for Part III</a>, the conclusion of the Round of 16.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*8OySRwW_4psIRPTK5AwA8A.jpeg" /></figure><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ae174015c8a4" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Strat-O-Matic Modern Champions Tournament, Qualifying Round Highlights]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-qualifying-round-highlights-1fe96ed12f76?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/1fe96ed12f76</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[board-games]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[world-series]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[stratomatic]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[baseball-history]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 16 Jul 2022 02:55:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2023-02-28T20:12:17.580Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>22 teams, all of them World Series winners between 1980 and present day</em></p><p>I always loved to play sports board games since I was introduced to them by my father and cousins at an early age. I always thought it was cool to play a short season, or draft a whole new league. My favorite sport to play for these games was baseball, and my favorite baseball game was Strat-O-Matic.</p><p>In January of 2020, two months after I had left MLB Network where I was a highlight producer for nine seasons, my lovely then-girlfriend-now-wife Rose took me to Cooperstown for my birthday. She noticed me gushing about Strat-O-Matic, which I hadn’t played since the 90s, in the Hall Of Fame gift shop. Didn’t buy it then because I had just moved in with her, returning to my hometown of Scranton, and had more life-uprooting matters to deal with. Plus, I was still playing NHL18 from EA Sports, deep into a career with my created player Jimmy Highlights of the New Jersey Devils. Naturally, I played many sports video games over the years as they evolved. (For those, hockey was always my favorite.)</p><p>Then the pandemic brought back board games. We wound up getting about ten of them — Life, Monopoly, Pay Day, etc. One day while looking through old stuff in my childhood home, I found a college basketball board game called March Madness from 1990, produced by Avalon Hill. I used a formula in that game to create new teams and play the 2020 NCAA Tournament that was unplayed in real life. Here’s the bracket, but the whole thing is a story for another forum.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*4iabSAJm7kYOs2GdfoyY8g.png" /></figure><p>For Christmas of 2020, 11 months after our trip to Cooperstown and seemingly eleventy-seven years into the pandemic, Rose surprised me with…Strat-O-Matic baseball! I was so excited. Similar to what I did in the 90s, I drafted a new league with 8 teams, using cards from the 2018 season. I named the teams after London soccer clubs: Arsenal, Chelsea, Tottenham, etc.</p><p>I got about one-third through the intended season of my league, and realized the changes that had happened in real baseball had a negative effect on the fun of Strat-O-Matic. There were way more strikeouts and less hitting. Stolen bases were almost extinct; this league had so many dominant pitchers and fielders, scoring single runs was like drawing blood from a stone unless it was a solo home run. The league batting average was .223. So I put that on hold.</p><p>The itch for the game came back to me in the spring of 2022. My original idea was to buy a special set Strat-O-Matic made of all Hall Of Fame players. An entire league of Hall of Famers — what would happen? Hopefully not the same thing with the pitching, but I was too curious to not buy the set.</p><p>More players were elected to the Hall after that set was published. I wanted to include them, and discovered Strat had updated the set on their app. Then I found out that on said app, you can digitally see <em>every card</em> for every season and set they have made (subscription required but worth it for this).</p><p>You can also match up a batter’s card against a pitcher’s card. Here’s an example:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*FdFC5I9dv5_VpopDJh4Fjw.jpeg" /></figure><p>I was originally going to get the app for a one-time use just to get the new Hall Of Fame cards, but I got to thinking: I can play anybody against anybody here.</p><p><strong>Half an hour later I had an idea and a framework for a tournament</strong>: World Series championship teams since 1980 with each franchise represented only once by either their best or more interesting team. A Modern Champions Tournament. Why 1980? That’s the year I really learned of baseball and started paying attention to it, so it’s essentially a tournament of my fandom.</p><p>40-plus years seemed like an appropriate era to draw from, especially in modern times — it’s hard to articulate why but it feels like 1980 to 2019 works better for something like this than, say, 1950 to 1989. Maybe it’s just about when I grew up. Or maybe it’s that baseball’s presence on television expanded in the 80s and continues to this day, or that you could look at the athletes who played back then and easily imagine them being dropped into today’s game.</p><p>It turns out that since 1980, 11 American League and 11 National League teams have won at least one World Series. I figured out who should represent each franchise, and then seeded the teams by league. <strong>Seeds are mostly based on regular-season win totals.</strong> Here are the lists, in order of their seeds:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/828/1*2VDXolfYDFgo2LoxoT3wVg.jpeg" /></figure><p>We will play an American League and National League bracket, with the winners to meet in a Grand World Series. The teams over the line in the above photo are placed into the Round of 16. The teams under the line need to play in the Qualifying Round, which is a best-of-3 series. The matchups are:</p><p><strong>A.L.:</strong> White Sox vs. Royals, Angels vs. Twins, Orioles vs. Blue Jays<br><strong>N.L.:</strong> Nationals vs. Cardinals, Diamondbacks vs. Marlins, Phillies vs. Reds</p><p>After the Qualifying Round, 16 teams will remain and they will be re-seeded in each league. The Tournament Executive Committee (me) reserves the right to a change a matchup from its natural seeding in order to avoid a series with the same player on both teams, also known as The Jack Morris Rule since he is on 3 different teams. Some others duplicate as well, such as David Cone and Chuck Knoblauch.</p><p>Starting with the Round of 16, the intention is to do a straight bracket with these rounds, but again the Committee can make changes if necessary:</p><p><strong>Round of 16:</strong> Best-of-5<br><strong>Division Series:</strong> Best-of-5<br><strong>League Championship Series:</strong> Best-of-7<br><strong>Grand World Series:</strong> Best-of-7</p><p>A few weeks after I came up with this, Rose and I visited the city of Pittsburgh and went to a Pirates game on a tremendous Saturday afternoon. I briefly felt bad for not including the 1979 Bucs in the tournament, but that would have unbalanced the field, so I got over it.</p><p>Here is my set-up to play the games. I’m using the bar in our spare room, throwing the dice into the box in the opposite chair from where I sit. That way, I can play in small increments at almost any time instead of dragging it out to the dining room table where I’d have to finish a whole game at once. Gameplay isn’t fast when you have to navigate the Strat app for the cards.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*z0NGi3v7oG6N0uemfoGiRw.jpeg" /></figure><p><strong>We’re going to imagine this tournament is broadcast nationally, attended by fans, and the teams will “travel” as if these are normal baseball playoff series.</strong> Like I did with the basketball tournament I played, I’m making a “TV Schedule” and playing the games in that order. There will be a certain number of games each day, and games on the west coast will be played after ones on the east coast.</p><p><strong>We get to use </strong><a href="https://www.strat-o-matic.com/baseball/ballpark-and-weather-effect-charts/"><strong>Strat-O-Matic’s Ballpark Effects</strong></a><strong> for all of our home venues, from Baltimore’s Memorial Stadium in 1983 to Nationals Park in D.C. for 2019. </strong>Strat updates the ballpark effects each year for singles and home runs, making it easier to hit a ball out of, say, Philadelphia’s Citizens Bank Park than St. Louis’ Busch Stadium. These effects may have an impact on how starting pitching rotations are built, such as not using a pitcher who gives up a lot of home runs if the game is in a small yard.</p><p><strong>We will use authentic postseason rosters and starting lineups.</strong> I use <a href="http://baseball-reference.com/">baseball-reference.com</a> to find those. Teams in the 80s had smaller pitching staffs than those in the 2010s; we may have matchups where one team has three more pitchers than the other, but that’s just going to be part of the game. The team with less pitchers will have a deeper bench and more substitution options. If you’re like me and think baseball was just fine with less pitchers in the 80s and 90s, and that we have too many now which kills the pace-of-play, makes games longer, and just puts more mediocre arms in the league, this will be an interesting aspect of the tournament to follow.</p><p>Batting lineups will be what these teams used during their World Series or LCS, and dependent on the situation of facing a left-handed or right-handed starter, and if a designated hitter was to be used. I’ll make minor tweaks if it makes sense for the matchup, such as playing a fast runner against a pitcher who struggles to hold runners on.</p><p>The designated hitter is used in the American League bracket. Pitchers hit in the National League.</p><p><strong>There will not be analytic-based lineups if the team didn’t use them in real life.</strong> Albert Pujols hit third for the Cardinals; he will not lead-off or hit anywhere else in this tournament.</p><p><strong>There will be no long-term injuries, though in-game injuries are a part of baseball and are possible in the Strat-O-Matic game.</strong> A play resulting in an injury will lead to another dice roll to determine the severity, with a maximum length of 2 games. There’s a 50 percent chance that dice roll will reveal that the player is just fine after being checked by the trainer, and can remain in that game.</p><p>Kyle Schwarber of the 2016 Cubs will only be able to pinch-hit, or serve as the DH should the Cubs make the Grand World Series and play in an American League park, since that’s all he could do in the real World Series that year.</p><p><strong>There will be none of the supposed time-saving post-pandemic rules MLB has implemented. </strong>No three-batter-minimum rule for pitchers, no blasphemous “ghost runner” on second in extra innings. I might have used them if the 2021 Braves were selected, but the Committee went with the 1995 team.</p><p>Enough talk, let’s get to the “highlights”, which I was best known for in my years at MLBN, of the Qualifying Round…</p><p><strong>Day 1</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: NL-9 1990 Reds (Tom Browning) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Jamie Moyer)</em></p><p>— Both teams saving their aces for Game 2 (Jose Rijo-Cole Hamels), thinking that if you win the first game your top pitcher can clinch the series, and if you lost the first game your ace can get you back in it</p><p>— Bottom 1st: Jayson Werth 2-run HR…2–0 Phillies</p><p>— Top 2nd: Paul O’Neill (only LHB in Reds lineup) solo HR…2–1 Phillies</p><p>— Bottom 2nd: 2nd and 3rd, no outs…National League lineup helps the Reds: Carlos Ruiz groundout with infield in, Moyer strikes out, Jimmy Rollins lineout…no runs score</p><p>— Bottom 3rd: Werth flies out to warning track in left, nearly missing second HR</p><p>— Bottom 5th: Reds bring in Rob Dibble with Werth due up 3rd and Lou Piniella not wanting Browning to face Werth a third time…it’s a part of the game which would be way too early in a regular season to use Dibble, but was the best option in a short tournament series…Werth walks but is later caught stealing</p><p>— Top 6th: Chris Sabo 1-out double…Eric Davis intentionally walked for Moyer to face O’Neill, daring O’Neill to do more damage…O’Neill RBI single…2–2….Moyer removed for Chad Durbin…Mariano Duncan lineout for 2nd out…Todd Benzinger reaches on Chase Utley error, Davis scores…3–2 Reds</p><p>— Bottom 7th: Norm Charlton pitching…Shane Victorino leadoff walk, but caught stealing…Pedro Feliz and Ruiz ground out</p><p>— Bottom 8th: Chris Coste pinch-hit lead-off single…Rollins fly out…Charlton removed for right-hander Scott Scudder…Werth grounds into 4–6–3 double play</p><p>— Bottom 9th: Randy Myers pitching…Ryan Howard draws 1-out walk, advances to 2nd on wild pitch…Pat Burrell lines out to 3rd…Victorino grounds out to 3rd<br> <br><strong> REDS WIN 3–2, LEAD SERIES 1–0</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jimmy Key) at AL-8 1983 Orioles (Scott McGregor)</em></p><p>— Top 2nd: John Olerud groundout and injury…out for next game</p><p>— Bottom 3rd: First and second, 1 out…Dan Ford strikeout, Cal Ripken groundout</p><p>— Top 5th: Candy Maldonado walk, Kelly Gruber reached on Todd Cruz error, Pat Borders flyout, Manny Lee groundout to 1st and runners advance to 2nd and 3rd…Devon White 2-run single…2–0 Blue Jays</p><p>— Bottom 5th: First and second, 1 out…Ford and Ripken ground out</p><p>— Top 6th: Dave Winfield and Derek Bell single…McGregor removed for Sammy Stewart…Maldonado hit by pitch to load bases with no outs…Gruber grounds into fielders’ choice force at home…Borders and Lee strike out</p><p>— Bottom 6th: First and second, 1 out…Rich Dauer strikes out, Cruz flies out</p><p>— Top 7th: First and second, 1 out…Winfield grounds into 4–6–3 double play</p><p>— Bottom 7th: With 2 outs, Ripken singles John Shelby to 3rd…Eddie Murray strikes out</p><p>— Bottom 8th: With 2 outs, Dauer single…Key removed for Duane Ward…Pinch-hitter John Lowenstein singles to Dauer to 3rd…Rick Dempsey strikes out</p><p>— Bottom 9th: Tom Henke pitching…Ford single with 1 out…Ripken groundout…Murray fly out</p><p><strong>BLUE JAYS WIN 2–0, LEAD SERIES 1–0</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: NL-10 2003 Marlins (Josh Beckett) at NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Randy Johnson)</em></p><p>— Top 1st: Marlins load bases with 2 outs, but Mike Lowell strikes out to end the inning</p><p>— Top 3rd: With 2 outs, Ivan Rodriguez single followed by Miguel Cabrera double…2nd and 3rd, but Jeff Conine grounds out</p><p>— Bottom 3rd: Damian Miller 2-run HR…2–0 Diamondbacks</p><p>— Top 5th: With 1 out, doubles by Luis Castillo and Rodriguez…Cabrera singles Rodriguez to 3rd…Johnson strikes out Conine and Lowell…2–1 Diamondbacks</p><p>— Bottom 5th: Danny Bautista solo HR…3–1 Diamondbacks</p><p>— Top 7th: With 1 out, Rodriguez double…Johnson removed for Bobby Witt…Cabrera double…Conine and Lowell fly out…3–2 Diamondbacks</p><p>— Bottom 7th: Mark Redman pitching…Miller RBI single, scoring Bautista…4–2 Diamondbacks</p><p>— Top 8th: Greg Swindell pitching…Juan Pierre doubles Derrek Lee to 3rd with 2 outs…Swindell removed for Byung-Hyun Kim…Castillo grounds out…4–2 Diamondbacks</p><p>— Top 9th: Rodriguez lead-off single (4 for 4)…Cabrera strikes out (4 for 5), Conine grounds out, Lowell flies out</p><p><strong>DIAMONDBACKS WIN 4–2, LEAD SERIES 1–0</strong></p><p><strong>Day 2</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Jaime Garcia) at NL-6 2019 Nationals (Stephen Strasburg)</em></p><p>— Bottom 3rd…Juan Soto RBI double scores Trea Turner…1–0 Nationals</p><p>— Top 4th…after Strasburg faced the minimum through 3, Matt Holliday 2-run double…2–1 Cardinals</p><p>— Bottom 4th…Michael A. Taylor RBI single scores Ryan Zimmerman…2–2… Turner RBI single scores Taylor…3–2 Nationals…Turner SB and advance to 3rd on Yadier Molina error, Adam Eaton double scores Turner…4–2 Nationals</p><p>— Top 6th: Albert Pujols 2-run HR…4–4…Lance Berkman reaches on Zimmerman error…David Freese 2-run HR with two outs (unearned runs)…Strasburg removed…6–4 Cardinals</p><p>— Bottom 6th: Eaton flies out to wall in left (HR would have tied game)</p><p>— Top 8th: Molina RBI single scores Holliday…7–4 Cardinals</p><p>— Bottom 8th: With 2 outs, doubles by pinch-hitter Brian Dozier and Turner…Mark Rzepczynski enters and strikes out Eaton…7–5 Cardinals</p><p>— Top 9th: Rafael Furcal lead-off home run…Pinch-hitter Allen Craig 2-run HR…10–5 Cardinals</p><p><strong>CARDINALS WIN 10–5, LEAD SERIES 1–0</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: AL-11 1985 Royals (Charlie Leibrandt) at AL-6 2005 White Sox (Jon Garland)</em></p><p>— Top 6th: George Brett solo home run…1–0 Royals</p><p>— Bottom 6th: Scott Podsednik single…Tadahito Iguchi bunt single despite trying to sacrifice…Jermaine Dye walk…Paul Konerko grand slam…4–1 White Sox</p><p>— Top 7th: Steve Balboni solo home run…4–2 White Sox</p><p>— Bottom 7th: Dye RBI single scores Podsednik…5–2 White Sox</p><p>— Top 9th: With two outs, Pat Sheridan single...Balboni 2-run HR…Garland removed for Bobby Jenks…Darryl Motley, pinch-hitting for Jim Sundberg, strikes out to end game…5–4 White Sox</p><p><strong>WHITE SOX WIN 5–4, LEAD SERIES 1–0</strong></p><p><em>Game 1: AL-10 1991 Twins (Jack Morris) at AL-7 2002 Angels (Jarrod Washburn)</em></p><p>— Top 1st: Dan Gladden reaches on error…Twins load bases with no outs…Gladden scores on double play hit into by Chili Davis…1–0 Twins</p><p>— Bottom 1st: Tim Salmon 2-run HR…2–1 Angels</p><p>— Top 2nd: Shane Mack solo HR…2–2</p><p>— Bottom 4th: Angels leave bases loaded</p><p>— Top 6th: With two outs, Brian Harper and Mack single…Kent Hrbek doubles, Harper scores, Mack thrown out at home…3–2 Twins</p><p>— Bottom 7th: With two outs, Salmon single…Morris removed for Carl Willis…Garret Anderson doubles, Salmon scores…3–3</p><p>— Top 11th: Runners on 1st and 2nd, 1 out…Mike Pagliarulo grounds into double play</p><p>— Bottom 11th: Scott Spiezio single, Bengie Molina sacrifice bunt, Adam Kennedy RBI single…4–3 Angels</p><p><strong>ANGELS WIN 4–3 IN 11 INNINGS, LEAD SERIES 1–0</strong></p><p><strong>Day 3</strong></p><p><em>Game 2: AL-8 1983 Orioles (Mike Boddicker) at AL-9 1992 Blue Jays (Jack Morris)</em></p><p>— Top 1st: Ripken solo home run…1–0 Orioles</p><p>— Bottom 1st: Boddicker hit by comeback line drive from White, injured and removed for Storm Davis…Joe Carter RBI double scores Roberto Alomar…1–1</p><p>— Bottom 3rd: Alomar walk, then 4 straight singles (Carter, Winfield, Maldonado, Ed Sprague)…Davis removed for Jim Palmer…3–1 Blue Jays</p><p>— Top 5th: Jim Dwyer RBI double scores Dempsey…3–2 Blue Jays…Ripken single scores Dwyer…3–3</p><p>— Bottom 5th: Maldonado 2-run HR…5–3 Blue Jays</p><p>— Top 6th: Cruz lines into inning-ending double play to Gruber</p><p>— Top 7th: With two outs, Morris removed for Mark Eichhorn…Ripken, as tying run, flies out to center</p><p>— Top 9th: Dempsey grounds into double play to Gruber for final outs</p><p><strong>BLUE JAYS WIN 5–3, WIN SERIES 2–0, ADVANCE TO PLAY RED SOX</strong></p><p><em>(Even though the other A.L. series are incomplete, the Executive Decision was made to match the Blue Jays against the Red Sox due to player duplications with the other two possible opponents — the Yankees and Tigers.)</em></p><p><strong>SERIES SUMMARY:</strong> The poor Orioles get a rough break when the line drive hits Boddicker to start Game 2, as they were counting on him to get back in the series. Their lineup after Ripken and Murray didn’t seem very formidable, perhaps the most “these guys won the World Series?” lineup of the tournament. However, the Blue Jays can say they were without Olerud for most of the series, which compromised them both offensively and on defense. They simply got more clutch hits. The Blue Jays will be tough to beat if they get a lead with top-notch Ward and Henke in the bullpen.</p><p><em>Game 1: NL-7 2001 Diamondbacks (Curt Schilling) at NL-10 2003 Marlins (Dontrelle Willis)</em></p><p>— Top 2nd: Matt Williams reaches on Alex Gonzalez error, Reggie Sanders walks, Jay Bell double scores Williams and Sanders… 2–0 Diamondbacks</p><p>— Bottom 4th: Rodriguez and Cabrera single after Schilling had retired first 11 batters…Conine strikes out to end inning</p><p>— Top 5th: Greg Colbrunn doubles…Willis removed for Chad Fox…Williams doubles, Colbrunn scores…3–0 Diamondbacks</p><p>— Bottom 8th: Gonzalez and Juan Encarnacion single to make it 1st and 3rd with no outs…Pierre grounds into 6–4–3 double play, scoring Gonzalez…Castillo singles…Schilling removed for Witt…Castillo steals second…Rodriguez flies out to right…3–1 Diamondbacks</p><p>— Bottom 9th: Kim pitching…Cabrera leadoff double, but Brian Banks, Lowell, and Lee strike out</p><p><strong>DIAMONDBACKS WIN 3–1, WIN SERIES 2–0</strong></p><p><strong>SERIES SUMMARY:</strong> In a short series, it was going to be extremely tough to beat Johnson and Schilling. Rodriguez and Cabrera (a 20-year-old rookie in 2003) tried their best. Arizona’s next opponent will be determined by the outcome of the Nationals-Cardinals series.</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-8 2008 Phillies (Cole Hamels) at NL-9 1990 Reds (Jose Rijo)</em></p><p>— Bottom 1st: Larkin and Billy Hatcher lead off with singles…Sabo sacrifice fly scores Larkin…1–0 Reds</p><p>— Top 3rd: Rollins solo home run….1–1</p><p>— Top 7th: Rijo injured on a pitch to Victorino for a fly out, removed for Dibble</p><p>— Bottom 7th: With two outs, Duncan doubles…Benzinger reaches on one-base error by Rollins…Joe Oliver lines out to 3rd to end inning</p><p>— Top 8th: With two outs, Rollins singles…Rollins steals 2nd and 3rd…Werth RBI single…2–1 Phillies…Dibble removed for Charlton…Utley singles, Howard doubles in Werth and Utley…4–1 Phillies</p><p>— Bottom 8th: Sabo 2-out 2-run home run…Hamels removed for Ryan Madson…Davis flies out…4–3 Phillies</p><p>— Bottom 9th: Brad Lidge pitching…With one out, pinch-hitter Ron Oester walks…Pinch-runner Billy Bates steals second…Pinch-hitter Hal Morris strikes out…Pinch-hitter Jeff Reed flies out to deep right</p><p><strong>PHILLIES WIN 4–3, SERIES TIED 1–1</strong></p><p><strong>Day 4</strong></p><p><em>Game 2: AL-6 2005 White Sox (Mark Buehrle) at AL-11 1985 Royals (Bret Saberhagen)</em></p><p>— Top 1st: Podsednik walks, advances to 3rd on single by Iguchi, scores on Dye 4–6–3 double play…1–0 White Sox</p><p>— Bottom 1st: Lonnie Smith walks, scores on Willie Wilson double…1–1…after Brett fly out to right, Hal McRae 2-run home run…3–1 Royals</p><p>— Middle innings: Saberhagen retires 14 straight</p><p>— Bottom 4th: Motley solo home run…4–1 Royals</p><p>— Top 7th: Iguchi leadoff double, scores on Konerko 1-out double…Carl Everett single, Konerko to 3rd…Saberhagen removed for Steve Farr…Aaron Rowand and A.J. Pierzynski strike out…4–2 Royals</p><p>— Top 8th: Podsednik caught stealing to end inning</p><p>— Bottom 8th: McRae walks, advances to 2nd on Frank White ground out…Pinch-runner Onix Concepcion advances to 3rd and scores on consecutive wild pitches by Dustin Hermanson…5–2 Royals</p><p><strong>ROYALS WIN 5–2, SERIES TIED 1–1</strong></p><p><em>Game 2: AL-7 2002 Angels (John Lackey) at AL-10 1991 Twins (Kevin Tapani)</em></p><p>— Bottom 1st: Dan Gladden lead-off walk…Puckett doubles Gladden to 3rd, and run scores on Hrbek groundout…1–0 Twins</p><p>— Top 2nd: 1st and 2nd, 0 outs…Brad Fullmer 6–4–3 double play and Alex Ochoa ground out</p><p>— Top 4th: Darin Erstad leadoff single and steals second, advances to 3rd and scores on consecutive groundouts by Salmon and Anderson…1–1</p><p>— Bottom 5th: Scott Leius leadoff single and steals second, later scores from 3rd on Knoblauch single…2–1 Twins</p><p>— Top 6th: Anderson grounds out and leaves with injury</p><p>— Bottom 6th: Hrbek solo home run…3–1 Twins</p><p>— Top 7th: Spiezio singles and Fullmer walks…Tapani removed for Willis…Ochoa lines out to short…Molina grounds into 6–4–3 double play</p><p>— Top 8th: With one out, David Eckstein singles…Willis removed for David West…Eckstein to second on Harper passed ball…Erstad grounds out to short…Salmon RBI double…West wild pitch moves Salmon to 3rd…Shawn Wooten, replacing Anderson, lines out to 3rd…3–2 Twins</p><p>— Bottom 8th: Scot Shields pitching…Knoblauch and Puckett single…Shields removed for Francisco Rodriguez…Hrbek and Davis strike out…Mack singles to load bases…Harper lines out to short on a great play by Eckstein, no runs score</p><p>— Top 9th: Rick Aguilera pitching…Spiezio leadoff single…Pinch-runner Chone Figgins steals second…Fullmer doubles to score Figgins with tying run…3–3…Ochoa grounds out…Molina doubles to score Fullmer for the lead…4–3 Angels…Aguilera removed for Steve Bedrosian…Kennedy doubles, Molina scores…5–3 Angels…Eckstein pops out…Erstad homers…7–3 Angels</p><p><strong>ANGELS WIN 7–3, WIN SERIES 2–0</strong></p><p><strong>SERIES SUMMARY:</strong> The Angels get it done despite losing Troy Glaus to injury in Game 1 and Garret Anderson in Game 2. Both players will not be available in Game 1 of the next series. As for this series, they were very close games until the Twins’ bullpen implosion in the 9th of Game 2. One of the three “Jack Morrises” is out of the tournament now. After seeing the ’91 Twins bullpen cards, you can really understand why Morris went 10 innings in Game 7 against the Braves. Like their counterpart 7-seed Diamondbacks, the Angels next opponent depends on the 6–11 outcome (White Sox-Royals).</p><p><em>Game 2: NL-6 2019 Nationals (Max Scherzer) at NL-11 2011 Cardinals (Chris Carpenter)</em></p><p>— Scoreless through six as no runner reaches 3rd base</p><p>— Top 7th: Scherzer hits a double to advance Yan Gomes to 3rd with 2 outs, but Turner pops out to second</p><p>— Bottom 7th: Freese leadoff double…Molina singles Freese to 3rd…Nick Punto strikes out…Jon Jay, pinch-hitting for Carpenter, doubles to score Freese and advance Molina to 3rd…Scherzer removed for Javy Guerra…Rafael Furcal taps back to the mound for 2nd out, runners hold…Skip Schumaker strikes out…1–0 Cardinals</p><p>— Top 9th: Jason Motte pitching…Zimmerman singles with 1 out…Taylor pinch-runs…Victor Robles flies out to center as Jay makes a running catch of a would-be double…Asdrubal Cabrera pinch-hits for Gomes with 2 outs, doubles down the right-field line, Taylor scores…1–1</p><p>— Bottom 10th: Pinch-hitter Craig singles with 2 outs…Adron Chambers pinch-runs…Pujols singles Chambers to 2nd but Berkman flies out to left</p><p>— Top 11th: Edwin Jackson, normally a starter, pitching…Matt Adams, who had replaced Zimmerman, draws 2-out walk…no suitable pinch-runner is still available…Robles doubles to center, Adams is thrown out at home to end the inning</p><p>— Bottom 11th: Tanner Rainey pitching…Freese singles with one out…Daniel Descalso pinch-runs…Molina doubles…Sean Doolittle enters with runners on 2nd and 3rd and 1 out…Punto strikes out…Jay flies out to left</p><p>— Bottom 12th: Anibal Sanchez, normally a starter, pitching…Chambers singles with 1 out…Pujols walks…Ryan Theriot, pinch-hitting for Jackson, flies out to left…Holliday walks to load bases…Descalso singles and Chambers scores…2–1 Cardinals</p><p><strong>CARDINALS WIN 2–1 IN 12 INNINGS, WIN SERIES 2–0, ADVANCE TO PLAY METS, DIAMONDBACKS TO PLAY BRAVES</strong></p><p><strong>SERIES SUMMARY: </strong>Wow, what a Game 2! Scherzer was brilliant in his homecoming to St. Louis, but he couldn’t save the Nats. Classic old-school National League game with double-switching, pinch-running, and using almost your whole roster in extra innings. The Cardinals are just like they were in 2011, hard to kill. The ’86 Mets await. Will Yadier Molina have another heroic moment at Shea Stadium?</p><p><strong>Day 5</strong></p><p><em>Game 3: NL-9 1990 Reds (Jack Armstrong) at NL-8 2008 Phillies (Joe Blanton)</em></p><p>— Top 3rd: Hatcher RBI double scores Duncan…1–0 Reds</p><p>— Bottom 3rd: 1st and 2nd, 0 outs…Howard strikes out…Burrell hits grounder to Larkin which appears to be a double-play ball to end the inning, but E-6 loads the bases…Armstrong wild pitch scores Werth…1–1…Victorino intentionally walked to reload bases….Feliz grounder to second booted by Duncan for second error of inning, Utley scores…2–1 Phillies</p><p>— Top 4th: Oliver RBI double scores Sabo from first…2–2</p><p>— Top 6th: Blanton removed for Durbin after 1-out double by Sabo…Oliver flies out to center and Duncan grounds out to third</p><p>— Bottom 6th: With 2 outs and bases empty, Durbin bats to remain in the game and grounds out to 3rd</p><p>— Top 7th: Armstrong bats to remain in the game leading off the inning, flies out to center</p><p>— Bottom 7th: Armstrong walks Werth with 1 out, ending streak of retiring 12 straight batters…Armstrong removed for Dibble…Werth steals second…Utley infield single advances Werth to 3rd…Howard strikes out…Burrell walks to load bases…Victorino walks to score Werth…3–2 Phillies</p><p>— Top 8th: With 2 outs, Glenn Braggs pinch-hits for Morris…Madson enters to pitch replacing J.C. Romero…Braggs doubles…Sabo grounds out to short to end the inning</p><p>— Bottom 8th: Charlton pitching…With 1 out, pinch-hitter Coste hit by pitch…Rollins singles, Coste to second…Charlton removed for Scudder…Werth grounds out to second, runners advance to 2nd and 3rd…Scudder removed for Myers…Utley 3-run home run…6–2 Phillies</p><p>— Top 9th: Reds score meaningless run, but Lidge finishes them off</p><p><strong>PHILLIES WIN 6–3, WIN SERIES 2–1, ADVANCE TO PLAY CUBS</strong></p><p><strong>SERIES SUMMARY: </strong>Like Twins-Angels, this series was as evenly matched as it gets until the last inning of the last game. Both teams made the other pay for fielding mistakes. The Reds “Nasty Boys” bullpen got the job done when they were tasked to go 5 innings in Game 1, but couldn’t come through in the next two, which was one reason why the Reds tried to stick with Armstrong as long as possible. Dibble was too easy to run on, and Rollins’ two stolen bases after the unfortunate Rijo injury started the rally which turned the series around for the Phillies. They will have to hold Hamels back until Game 2 against the 2016 Cubs, but could use him again if that series goes 5.</p><p><em>Game 3: AL-11 1985 Royals (Danny Jackson) at AL-6 2005 White Sox (Jose Contreras)</em></p><p><em>(To have two games on this day for TV and to finish the Qualifying Round, enabling the Round of 16 to start sooner, the Executive Committee removed the travel day from this series since the trip was only from Kansas City to Chicago. This was decided before Game 2 so the managers could use their bullpens accordingly.)</em></p><p>— Bottom 1st: Podsednik leadoff double…Iguchi strikes out…Dye lines out to second, Podsednik doubled off</p><p>— Top 2nd: Balboni hits fly to deep right, robbed of a home run by Dye snow-cone catch</p><p>— Bottom 4th: With 1 out, Dye and Konerko walk…Everett lines out to second…Pierzynski flies out to center</p><p>— Top 5th: After first 13 Royals batters retired, Balboni solo home run (4 consecutive at-bats by Balboni in games played in Chicago: 3 home runs and 1 that was robbed)…1–0 Royals</p><p>— Bottom 5th: With 2 outs, Podsednik singles Rowand to 2nd…Iguchi grounds out to 3rd to end inning and start streak of 9 straight batters retired by Jackson</p><p>— Bottom 8th: Jackson makes nice stab of Podsednik comebacker for second out…Iguchi walks…Dye lines out to short</p><p>— Bottom 9th: Jackson remains in with Dan Quisenberry warming up…Konerko strikes out…Everett pops out to second…Pierzynski grounds out to short</p><p><strong>ROYALS WIN 1–0, WIN SERIES 2–1, ADVANCE TO PLAY YANKEES, ANGELS TO PLAY TIGERS</strong></p><p><strong>SERIES SUMMARY:</strong> Upset City! Both 11-seeds advanced, but this win by the Royals where they only recorded 2 hits felt more like a surprise than the Cardinals. Danny Jackson’s 4-hit shutout is the best-pitched game of the tournament so far, and the only complete game. The 91-win Royals will take on the 114-win Yankees next, but due to the short turnaround Saberhagen won’t be able to pitch until Game 3.</p><p>By the way, did you notice the spoiler above for this game? It was in the picture of my set-up on the bar. The scoresheet shows the completed 1–0 win for K.C.</p><p>So, that was the very exciting and fun Qualifying Round and now it’s on to the Round of 16. The matchups for the best-of-5 series are as follows:</p><p><strong>American League<br></strong>(1) 1998 Yankees vs. (11) 1985 Royals<br>(4) 2017 Astros vs. (5) 1989 Athletics<br>(3) 1984 Tigers vs. (7) 2002 Angels<br>(2) 2018 Red Sox vs. (9) 1992 Blue Jays</p><p><strong>National League<br></strong>(1) 1986 Mets vs. (11) 2011 Cardinals<br>(4) 1988 Dodgers vs. (5) 2012 Giants<br>(3) 1995 Braves vs. (7) 2001 Diamondbacks<br>(2) 2016 Cubs vs. (8) 2008 Phillies</p><p>Again, the hope is to do a straight bracket from here, but we’ll see. The victory by the Royals did mean that the Blue Jays fell into their natural seeding against the Red Sox anyway, so the Committee’s decision was rendered moot.</p><p>The next round will have a maximum of 40 games to be played, so it could take a while.</p><p><a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/strat-o-matic-modern-champions-tournament-round-of-16-games-1-and-2-highlights-ae174015c8a4">Click here</a> for the next installment. Thanks!</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=1fe96ed12f76" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Random Game I Went To: Everton at West Ham]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/random-game-i-went-to-everton-at-west-ham-ce0b85f906fb?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ce0b85f906fb</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[west-ham-united]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[everton]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[london]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[premier-league]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[soccer]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 02 Apr 2020 01:23:55 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-04-02T02:34:01.921Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How I Saw A Full Game And Missed Half Of It</h4><p><em>(In the absence of sports, I started a series on my Facebook page about stories connected to random games I’ve gone to, but this one was too big for a status update</em>.)</p><p>January 13, 2015: FA Cup Third Round Replay, Everton at West Ham United</p><p>In case you don’t know what any of those words after the date mean, this is soccer in England.</p><p>There’s a lot to unpack in this one. It was during my week in London five years ago. Two days earlier I had been to an Arsenal-Stoke City match in North London and figured that would fulfill my football attendance. While planning in the prior weeks and months, I knew Chelsea and Arsenal had home games while I would be there. This Everton-West Ham match, a “replay”, wasn’t on any schedule.</p><p>I have to back up here and explain the Premier League and the FA Cup for those who don’t know. You may have already counted three London teams: Chelsea, Arsenal, and West Ham. In 2014–15, that was just half of them. London had 6 Premier League teams in a 20-team league. Imagine either six NFL teams or 30 percent of the league in New York City. For years after this trip, I’ve said London makes New York look like chump change.</p><p>Now I should tell you about the FA Cup.</p><p>Imagine if every professional and semipro hockey team in the United States and Canada played in a single-elimination tournament, as a separate competition from their regular season which is happening at the same time. Imagine the low-level juniors start the tournament with the first round, and in later rounds the NHL teams come in. Someone from a lower league might make a long run with a hot goaltender, but it’s very likely to be two NHL teams in the final. It’s not really the playoffs, but when the FA Cup gets down to the final 8 or 16, it kind of is.</p><p>Remember I said it was single-elimination. March Madness style. One loss and you’re out. Now imagine tournament games with no overtime. What if it ends up tied? Well, they do a replay, usually a week later, and the site of the game is changed: whatever team was home for the first game now goes on the road. If it’s tied a second time, then they play overtime (“extra time” in soccer) and if necessary a shootout (or “penalties”).</p><p>One week earlier, West Ham and Everton played to a draw in their Third Round match.</p><p>One of the newspapers in London is called the Evening Standard. It is free and passed out to subway (“Tube”) riders at Underground stations in the afternoons. I would always grab one and look through it. Two things I learned from the Evening Standard: Grace Dent’s hilarious restaurant reviews, and a full-page ad in the January 12 edition promoting the next night’s replay match at West Ham with all seats available for 25 pounds.</p><p>That sounded like a good deal to me, and I was excited about it even though ordering the ticket took much longer than we’re used to in the States. I had to register online with the club, then order a ticket for pickup at Will Call, and that was the only option. No print-at-home tickets. <em>(Side Note: At this time, Stubhub and the secondary market barely had a presence in England from what I saw.)</em> Very old school. I should have taken that as a sign.</p><p>What happened on game night was partially my fault because I was running late. I decided to do a big sports day, so I visited Wimbledon and Wembley Stadium for tours. Just hours before kickoff, I saw the actual FA Cup at Wembley:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*UL2EEVxEs4c3yzWEfUkxeg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Wimbledon, Wembley, and West Ham’s then-home Boleyn Ground, are nowhere near each other. I’d say imagine Wimbledon on Staten Island, Wembley in the Bronx, and Upton Park in Queens, and then remember London makes New York look like chump change.</p><p>I got off the subway at 5 to 10 minutes before kickoff, hoping Will Call wouldn’t be too bad. However, it was bloody awful. I was in a gigantic line with locals and longtime fans who were frustrated at being stuck outside the stadium as the first half was played.</p><p>I finally got up to the box office and could see their staff scrambling like crazy. I appreciated these people’s hard work, but also thought if you had just enabled fans to print their own tickets, this wouldn’t happen. I get my ticket that says enter at turnstiles 59–62. The closest turnstile to me is 12.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/960/1*hH836VqQc0p4vs6shaGEvg@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Now a few words about Boleyn Ground to try to set the scene. This was the next-to-last season West Ham would play there. They began playing there in 1904. <em>Nineteen. Oh-Four.</em></p><p>Not only did the place look its age, but have you ever heard of numbered turnstiles? So remember I was at 12 and apparently had to enter at 59. I asked a security guard where to go.</p><p>I’m paraphrasing but he said I had to go back out to the street, turn right, and keep going around the perimeter of the stadium until I got to the other side. Sort of like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*MjBNyojBhXzbiYtmV2iw3w@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>Keep in mind two things:</p><ol><li>I have no idea where I’m going.</li><li>THE GAME IS GOING ON INSIDE.</li></ol><p>Now I’m mad. Now I’m walking back to the busy street, around the corner, through an apartment complex, and I’m grumbling “I hope this team gets relegated when they move to the Olympic Stadium.”</p><p>I finally get in with under ten minutes left in the half. As I’ve told this story to people verbally I always say “Luckily, it’s soccer, so it was 0–0.”</p><p>I watched the end of the half on a monitor in the concourse that made Fenway Park look modern. I think I got a beer and drank it before entering the stands. (No beer was allowed in the seating area at either game I went to; not sure if that’s a league or national rule.) I made my way to a seat in the last row of the lower deck for the second half. The place was packed.</p><p>West Ham scored in the 51st minute to lead 1–0.</p><p>An Everton player got his second yellow card in the 56th. He was sent off, and Everton played a man down. This would be really important over an hour later.</p><p>Minute 82: Everton’s Kevin Mirallas impressively scored on a long free kick, tying the game.</p><p>Right before the 30-minute extra time started, I figured the box-office debacle was now less annoying. Now I’d get almost a full game.</p><p>Romelu Lukaku scored in the first half of extra time, set up by Mirallas dribbling swiftly around defenders. I knew Lukaku’s name not just as one of the sport’s up-and-coming stars, but as a top striker on the West Brom team I used in FIFA 13. West Bromwich Albion sounded like the most British team name ever, so that’s why I picked them. It was cooler than being Manchester United.</p><p>Kevin Mirallas appeared to draw a penalty that could have put Everton up 3–1 if converted, but it wasn’t called. Mirallas’ playmaking in this match had me convinced he was the most underrated star in the making of the Premier League. Haven’t heard much about him since. I told friends then he was the best player I saw in England. That included Arsenal’s Alexis Sanchez, who had 2 goals when I saw that team.</p><p>With Everton up 2–1 and time ticking away, West Ham was in desperation mode and sub Carlton Cole scored in Minute 113 just after being inserted. It would finish tied at 2, and remember this had been scoreless at halftime. 4 goals in 75-plus minutes, and many other scoring chances, made for one hell of a match.</p><p>Next came the penalty shootout like you have seen in World Cup play. West Ham’s fifth shooter failed to score when he could have clinched the game, and then everybody kept making their shots. After 9 rounds, the shootout was 8–8.</p><p>So it came down to the 10th shooter for Everton, and since they had a player sent off earlier, that 10th shooter was their goalkeeper, Joel Robles. He hit the crossbar.</p><p>I’m not sure what the rules are and why West Ham’s 10th shooter also had to be its goalie. He is known as Adrian with no last name. I don’t know, just go with it, it’s soccer. Anyway, Adrian provided one of the greatest moments I’ve ever seen live. <a href="https://www.facebook.com/jim.nolan.14/videos/10203508467417866/?d=n">I hope this link works</a> because I couldn’t embed video here directly from my phone.</p><p>A goalie winning the game with a penalty kick. Delirium. Music. People blew bubbles — that’s a West Ham tradition.</p><p>I missed the first half, but so what. It was incredible. Even the sportswriters and coaches, who have seen everything, commented on how awesome it was.</p><p>If I remember right, the line to get back on the Tube went way back to the marker here:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/563/1*tIzDqKX2Dj9u24ddcKyP8Q@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>It was late at night too. I barely made the connection for the last train to my hotel way across the city.</p><p><a href="https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/30705802">Here’s the BBC game report.</a></p><p>Season recap for both teams: West Ham won their next FA Cup match, but lost in the 5th round (the round of 16) to…wait for it…West Bromwich Albion, 4-nil. They finished 12th in the Premier League, officially losing a goal-differential tiebreaker by one to 11th-place Everton. So they were average clubs. West Ham made a managerial change after the season. At their final home game the next season to close Boleyn Ground, <a href="https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-3583440/amp/West-Ham-supporters-brave-rain-arrive-early-ahead-emotional-final-match-Upton-Park-against-Manchester-United.html">riots and looting broke out</a>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ce0b85f906fb" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[I Booked The Next Six…Actually, Make That Seven…Winter Classics]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/i-booked-the-next-six-actually-make-that-seven-winter-classics-37a9889c8e79?source=rss-70e5e5deede3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/37a9889c8e79</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[hockey]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[outdoors]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[nhl]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jim Nolan]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 01 Jan 2018 08:44:09 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-01-01T18:26:21.394Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Three in the Pacific time zone, two in famous college football venues, and one in a city that doesn’t have a team yet</h4><p>One year from today, on January 1, 2019, the 11th NHL Winter Classic will be played at Notre Dame Stadium in South Bend, IN. The Chicago Blackhawks will face the Boston Bruins.</p><p>I applaud the unconventional site. I think one of the best settings the event has had was the 2014 Toronto-Detroit game at Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor, which also featured the announcement of the Team USA roster for that year’s Olympics as a postgame ceremony. The attendance was 105,491.</p><p>But these teams are retreads. 2019 will be the Blackhawks’ 4th time in the Winter Classic; the 3rd for the Bruins, who already have been the home team twice, at Fenway Park (2010) and Gillette Stadium (2016). Out of a possible 22 slots through the 2019 game, only 11 teams have been used to fill them. The Penguins, Sabres, Red Wings, Flyers, Capitals, and Rangers, are also repeaters. Do you remember anything about the 2015 Chicago-Washington game at Nationals Park? Don’t worry, nobody does.</p><p>I’m going to fix this right now. I’ve booked the next six Winter Classics, starting in 2020. Since the Classic’s inception, hockey fans have liked to speculate about where the next one would be; I’m going way beyond just one here.</p><p>We need fresh new teams and sites that will open up this event to more bustling and thriving regions all over North America. If the NHL would like to save themselves a lot of time and meetings, and just adopt the ideas written below, my fee is sixty G’s — 10 per game.</p><p><strong>Wednesday, January 1, 2020: AT&amp;T Park (San Francisco, CA): San Jose Sharks vs. Edmonton Oilers</strong></p><p>A by-product of the success and popularity of the early Winter Classics was the creation of the Stadium Series, non-New Year’s outdoor games. Stadium Series games have been held on the West Coast, at Dodger Stadium (Los Angeles Kings vs. Anaheim Ducks) and at the San Francisco 49ers’ home field, Levi’s Stadium in Santa Clara (Kings vs. Sharks). Yes, an ice rink can be maintained in California. It’s about time they had the main event on New Year’s Day.</p><p>From what I hear and read, everyone hates Levi’s Stadium. There’s no need to return there when the perfect setting for a Bay Area Winter Classic is this place.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*enqvHX7DCE8jFPn5rVE-cQ@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>I would pay good money to sit in that seat again and watch a hockey game with that view. Before you say “it won’t be cold”, I will say that I was there in July and yes it will, trust me. Also, weather for the last three outdoor games (December’s NHL 100 Classic in Ottawa, USA vs. Canada in a snowstorm at the World Junior Championship in Western New York, and this year’s Winter Classic in Queens) has been so frigid it borders on torturing the fans. We will have some potentially bitter cold games later on this list, ok? But it doesn’t have to be that way every year.</p><p>As for the Sharks opponent, I chose the Oilers because we’ve got to get Connor McDavid in one of these games. Hopefully American TV won’t freak out. I understand some of the matchups I’ve picked might be pipe dreams, but for the sake of this exercise let’s pretend we live in a perfect world where the NHL and NBC do the right thing.</p><p>I would also hope to get Oilers legends like Wayne Gretzky and Mark Messier to participate somehow, and the Bay Area has plenty of legendary beloved athletes, both current and retired, that should be available.</p><p><strong>Friday, January 1, 2021: Neyland Stadium (Knoxville, TN), Nashville Predators vs. Tampa Bay Lightning</strong></p><p>We went west last year; now we’re headed south. Hat tip to my friend and colleague J.D. Lindberg because I originally had this at the Tennessee Titans’ stadium in Nashville, but he immediately suggested the University of Tennessee. That was a great call because Neyland can hold six figures so an attempt can be made to break Michigan’s attendance number. It will also be a quite a sight to see hockey fans “<a href="https://volunteerprincess.com/activities/sailgate/">sailgating</a>” in Knoxville, and performances by the numerous country musicians that follow the Predators could make for some of the better TV images the Classic has had.</p><p>With the team choices here, I’m hoping they are both still good and think they will be. They seem to be solid organizations, having great seasons this year and both have recently been a conference champion.</p><p><strong>Saturday, January 1, 2022: Target Field (Minneapolis, MN), Minnesota Wild vs. Dallas Stars</strong></p><p>There, cold weather. Let’s hope it doesn’t rain or snow too badly because this game pretty much has to be played at noon local time in order to be done before NFL wild-card playoffs later in the day.</p><p>I don’t think I need to explain why the State of Hockey needs to have one of these games. It might be unfair to have guys who live in Texas play in it, and I could be talked into another team, but I picked the Stars as the Wild’s opponent since they are the former Minnesota North Stars and I will have them wear the <a href="http://www.gettyimages.com/detail/news-photo/willi-plett-of-the-minnesota-north-stars-skates-on-the-ice-news-photo/142243496#willi-plett-of-the-minnesota-north-stars-skates-on-the-ice-during-an-picture-id142243496">timeless North Star jerseys</a>.</p><p><strong>Monday, January 2, 2023: Ohio Stadium (Columbus, OH), Columbus Blue Jackets vs. Detroit Red Wings</strong></p><p>Take note of the date. Like in 2012 and 2017, January 1 lands on a Sunday in 2023 and we’re moving away from the NFL and possible college football playoffs. Plus, I’m doing this as a night game.</p><p>It’s the only time on this list I’m using a team that has played in a previous Winter Classic, but the Ohio State-Michigan angle is too easy not to do.</p><p>Get ready. We’re getting funky with the last two…</p><p><strong>Monday, January 1, 2024: Stadium Currently Being Constructed For The Raiders, Name TBA (Las Vegas, NV): Vegas Golden Knights vs. Los Angeles Kings</strong></p><p>A Winter Classic in an NFL stadium is not easy logistically. It basically can only be done if New Year’s lands during Week 17 and you can ask your friends in football to send the local team on the road, then hustle out of there after it’s over in case they need their yard back for a home playoff game the next week.</p><p>2024 is the only year on my list where this <em>could</em> happen; in all other years New Year’s is a playoff weekend. I stress the word “could” because a Winter Classic in Las Vegas, which I really, really, want to do, is only possible if the 2023 NFL season begins on Thursday, September 7 and not August 31. If it starts September 7, then Week 17 lands on December 31, just as it did in 2017.</p><p>As for the venue, this stadium is supposed to have a roof on it, so how is it an outdoor game? Well, it also will have what I guess can be called <a href="http://lasvegasstadium.raiders.com/">retractable glass exterior walls, which can expose the place to the elements and provide views of the Las Vegas Strip. The roof will be a glass dome</a>.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/371/1*iwSUGahiym5DDpu5_RD1QA@2x.jpeg" /></figure><p>It’s not perfect, but as I was saying I really, really want to have a Las Vegas Winter Classic. It would also be an homage to the NHL’s <a href="https://www.nhl.com/news/kings-rangers-1991-las-vegas-outdoor-game-revisited/c-282158304">first-ever outdoor game, a 1991 preseason tilt between Gretzky’s L.A. Kings and the New York Rangers at Caesar’s Palace</a>.</p><p>The way the Golden Knights are going, by then they probably will have won three Stanley Cups.</p><p>Now for the surprise twist…</p><p><strong>Wednesday, January 1, 2025: New Name TBA But Currently Known As Safeco Field (Seattle, WA): Seattle Thunderbirds (expansion team) vs. Vancouver Canucks</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.google.com/amp/amp.si.com/nhl/2017/12/07/nhl-considering-seattle-expansion-proposal">The NHL has granted a Seattle ownership group the right to apply for an expansion franchise</a>, which would be the league’s 32nd team. It almost seems like getting a “Save The Date” in the mail. You’re going to be invited to the wedding; why not just send an invitation is something I don’t understand, but whatever.</p><p>Figure Seattle will have their team by 2025 if one big issue can get resolved: <strong><em>building an arena</em></strong>. It’s been kind of a problem and controversial issue out there. <a href="https://medium.com/@jimnolan_53719/warriors-cavaliers-history-deep-dive-a64e55f7d5e1">In my previous article on this site</a>, I wrote that Seattle’s arena issues were a minor and indirect reason why Kevin Durant now plays for the Golden State Warriors.</p><p>The Seattle Thunderbirds today are a major junior team in the Western Hockey League, even though they do not play in the city limits. I love that name and think the NHL Seattle group should buy it.</p><p>A WHL game can also be played during the week. It’s been common for other leagues with teams in the local area to have an outdoor game at the Winter Classic site.</p><p>The Canucks are the obvious opponent because of the geographic rivalry they will have, but again if American TV freaks out and puts their foot down this time, I could pick a U.S. team to replace them. Perhaps the Colorado Avalanche.</p><p>Oh, what the hell, one more. I just thought of it now.</p><p><strong>Thursday, January 1, 2026: Rogers Centre, With The Roof Open And Assuming It’s Still Standing (Toronto, ON): Toronto Maple Leafs vs. Philadelphia Flyers</strong></p><p>It’s the home of the Hockey Hall of Fame, so Toronto should have one of these already. I would prefer to have the Leafs play the Ottawa Senators here in an all-Ontario matchup, but even in our perfect-world scenario, I don’t expect two Canadian teams will fly with the suits.</p><p>I don’t feel that strongly about the Flyers, but by 2026 it will have been 14 years since their last Winter Classic appearance. Choose a different team from the U.S. if you want to. Anybody but the Blackhawks.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=37a9889c8e79" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>