<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Joan Garfield on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Joan Garfield on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@joangarfield?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 09:39:05 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@joangarfield/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Journey Continues]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/the-journey-continues-43298f66fc17?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/43298f66fc17</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[camino]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 11 Apr 2021 01:10:42 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-04-12T21:38:05.736Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is the final installment of my blog series <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/561/1*p3_imJ-NBnRngp0xbyRhjA.png" /></figure><p>And so we reach the end of this blog series, but not (I hope) the end of my journey! I know I will continue to follow the path illuminated by my inner vision and I look forward to seeing where it takes me. I am learning to focus on the journey itself, and not the destination.</p><p><strong>New Low Vision Tools</strong></p><p>As my vision has continued to stay fairly stable, I have worn the same glasses and magnifier necklace. A few years ago on a trip to New York, my magnifier necklace broke and I lost the magnifier as I went through airport security. I was terrified. How would I survive in New York without my trusty necklace magnifier?</p><p>Then I realized I might find a replacement, and started searching on my phone. I found a large electronics store about six blocks from my hotel. So after I had settled into my room, I set off to find this store. It was enormous, and seemed to be run by Orthodox Jewish men wearing black hats and coats. I asked the first person I saw where I might find magnifiers and was directed to a counter further back in the store. The man there showed me a small black magnifier that needed batteries. He was not very helpful, even when I told him I had low vision. So I took the magnifier to the long checkout counter and found a woman there who was more helpful. She pointed me to the batteries, and I bought the magnifier along with the batteries. I asked if she could help me load the batteries, but she said she was not allowed to, and directed me to a tech help desk of sorts. There, another kind person opened the package for me and inserted the three tiny batteries correctly, making sure the magnifier worked. I was elated. Although this new tool did not dangle from a chain on my neck, I could keep it handy in my purse. And it worked so well that I now have several around the house. I use them all the time, as they work even better than the magnifier necklace (which I replaced as soon as I returned home).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/464/1*wIt6xdm-hXCsrdlPacOpoQ.png" /></figure><p>Prior to my last trip (before COVID), I went to the low-vision optometrist at the Phillips Eye Institute, where I learned about some new devices that I purchased and have found very helpful. Both are electronic video magnifiers (and expensive, but worth it). One is small enough to put in my purse and use to read a menu. It has even helped me read and fill out the immigration form required for entering Mexico, which I had to do when I traveled alone. A second, larger, magnifier fits nicely over parts of a cookbook to read a recipe or over part of <em>The New York Times Book Review</em>. Although it is inconvenient to keep these devices charged, they allow for different levels of magnification, can freeze a frame as needed, and even change background color for more contrast.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/470/1*D7zjvIkBrMHIhlB45XE7uA.png" /></figure><p>Also, before COVID, I treated myself to a larger, brand new iPad. I use it to watch movies from my lap, which works really well. It also allows me to do a little reading on Kindle when I cannot find audio versions, although I can’t do more than a few pages at a time. During the pandemic this iPad was invaluable, allowing me to take Zoom yoga and fitness classes, as well as enjoy Zoom happy hours and gatherings with friends all over the world. Recently I upgraded to the newest, largest iPhone. It allows me to use an enlarged, dark font to more easily read text and email messages. I rely on ‘Siri’ to dictate most messages, but if I don’t review them carefully, there are many errors and sometimes even inadvertent profanity. All these devices require me to make sure I have room to carry them when I travel, along with the appropriate chargers. I am no longer a person who is able to travel with a light load. But I need to acknowledge how fortunate I am to be able to afford all these different tools and devices, which make my life so much easier.</p><p><strong>The Camino: Finding My Way on “The Way”</strong></p><p>Michael and I have continued to take hiking trips around the world, making new friends and exploring beautiful areas of wilderness. One particular trip that facilitated my continued inner journey was two years ago, when we hiked the last 100 miles of the Camino de Santiago, also known as St. James’ Way, the ancient pilgrimage route in Spain. After doing much research and reading several books about hiking the Camino, we felt ready to try at least part of the walk.</p><p>Most people walk this path alone, staying in hostels each night (as shown in the classic movie, <em>The Way</em>). We were not so adventurous. Actually, we were nervous about losing our way and not being able to sleep in the shared quarters of hostels. We also doubted our ability to travel with all we needed in our backpacks. So we decided to join a hiking group of 20 with an excellent and experienced guide. We stayed in nice hotels, and had rest days to do laundry, take a cooking class, or visit interesting historical sites. Over the 12 days of the trip we made wonderful friends to whom we are still connected.</p><p><strong>The Scallop Shell</strong></p><p>The symbol of the Camino is the scallop shell, which all pilgrims wear, usually on their backpacks. We had been given our own scallop shells at the blessing ceremony in Minneapolis, and they were attached to our backpacks and swung from a little red string as we walked.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/544/1*Qmcp6OCuWGxE4uqzhiDK5w.png" /></figure><p>The scallop shell is also represented in yellow on the many signs along the Path. It is understood to represent the Camino de Santiago itself, that is, the many paths leading to Santiago de Compostela. There are also numerous myths regarding the scallop shell and St. James.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*BvbMPsAuswBmlVJD-HPmxg.png" /></figure><p>On the first day of our walk, Michael bought me a little silver scallop shell to place on my magnifier necklace chain. The previous year he had bought me a bell, the symbol of the island of Capri when we hiked there, now also on the chain. I had later added a small silver charm of the Aztec calendar, symbolizing my love of Mexico. Now all three charms embellish my chain and remind me of these three places. But the scallop shell reminds me of that spiritual journey, and that it continues in my life today. It also beckons me to return and walk more of the Way.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/426/1*08fLIbYXv1fZn8EvKf7oYg.png" /></figure><p><strong>My Spiritual Journey</strong></p><p>For many people, the Camino is a sacred, religious pilgrimage. A few months before we departed, we attended a ceremony in Minneapolis where we were given a blessing and were inspired to learn and grow from our experience on the Camino. So above and beyond the great friends and beautiful hikes, I took the opportunity to explore my own spiritual journey as I walked the pilgrimage route.</p><p>Having recently read Viktor Frankl’s iconic book, <em>Man’s Search for Meaning</em>, I tried to look inward. I challenged myself to ponder what life wanted from me, and what my true purpose was. Many different thoughts washed over me, and I kept a small journal to (mostly illegibly) jot down my ideas. And one day, the answer came to me.</p><p>Walking this religious path that was particularly sacred to Catholics, I experienced the power and depth of my Jewish heritage. I felt a deep connection to my religion, and a call to do my part to keep the Jewish people alive. I had already raised Jewish children who were now raising my grandchildren as Jews. But I vowed to support them even more in their connection to our religion by providing financial support for all five grandchildren to attend Jewish summer camps and to travel to Israel, as my children had done. Michael felt as strongly as I did, and also agreed that we should try to be diplomats for our faith so that others could learn about our Jewish lives and beliefs. The goal was not to proselytize or convert, but rather to help people understand what it is like to be Jewish, and to see that we are not so different from them.</p><p>Over the years we have often been the “only Jewish friend” of people we know, who are surprised that we don’t keep kosher or follow Orthodox rules. Now we felt even more strongly that we needed to promote understanding and connection, talking openly with our friends and inviting them to observe Jewish holidays with us. A third commitment we made on the Camino was to explore the history of the Jewish people in each country we traveled to, to feel a connection to our people and their experiences as part of the diaspora. Since returning from the Camino, I find that I host the celebration of Jewish holidays with greater spirit and joy, making these observances special and memorable for our grandchildren and guests.</p><p><strong>Reaching the End of The Way</strong></p><p>Although we only walked the last 100 miles of a 500-mile pilgrimage route, we all felt jubilant when we reached the Church of St. James in Santiago. We felt stronger from the long daily hikes, enriched by the experience of the journey, and warmed by the friendships and memories created along the way. It was hard to say goodbye, and Michael and I immediately vowed to return the next year and hike the first 100 miles of the Camino. But COVID prevented that from happening.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*Q0U6l2ZdP4KmOrcSIyrbAQ.png" /></figure><p>However, the real end of the route extends farther, to the coast of Spain. This place used to be thought of as the end of the world — literally ‘Finisterre’ — and many pilgrims throw their clothes or boots into the water, symbolizing the end of their journey. We took a bus to this spot and Michael carried a bag with his worn hiking boots to throw in the water. It was a cold and windy day but we were thrilled to be at this end point.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*jdyEHChsAsXcrgkA0O84Bw.png" /></figure><p><strong>My Place on the Journey Today</strong></p><p>I feel very fortunate that I am comfortably retired, and am able to live a rich and full life, even without central vision. I cannot drive, but before COVID I became adept at taking buses, plotting bus routes on my computer and iPhone apps, and calling Uber quite often. I developed a walking practice as well, walking the 2.5 miles to and from my yoga classes three times a week. Of course, all of this changed in March 2020. But until then, I did become quite a bit more independent than in my early years of vision loss.</p><p>I have described the ways that experiencing vision loss has provided some gifts and silver linings. In addition, I think it has also helped me feel more compassion for others who suffer, whether from a physical or other type of disability. And when I go to religious services, or a study group at my synagogue, I no longer try to read along. Instead, I usually listen, and I find I am actually more engaged and focused this way, able to concentrate on the meaning.</p><p>It is still frustrating not being able to read, unless print is large and dark and written in block letters. Most handwriting is too difficult for me to read, even when enlarged, as are fonts like italic. It amazes me how many items come in the mail like invitations or handwritten cards that I cannot read. Most of the time I have Michael read them out loud to me. My sister is the only person who writes cards to me using print, in a dark black sharpie.</p><p>Finally, as my journey continues, I have been practicing the Jewish spiritual curriculum Mussar. Mussar involves the study and practice of soul traits such as humility, compassion, gratitude, and lovingkindness. It builds on the work I did at Esalen, and gives me a framework to continue examining my life as I work on improving my responses to people and events. I am forced to practice humility as I recognize that I cannot do all I once did, and all I want to do, because of my limited eyesight. I am better at practicing compassion, as I have a deeper understanding of many forms of suffering, loss, and disability.</p><p>Gratitude is something I practice daily, as I am reminded of all the gifts and blessings that have come my way, and lessons learned from my vision loss. And lovingkindness is a trait I try to use on myself and others, allowing me to practice radiating warmth, good will, and acceptance to all of us as imperfect humans struggling to overcome challenges in life. I think practicing Mussar helps me as I strive to strengthen and clarify my inner vision. Although “practice makes perfect” in skills such as musical performance, Mussar is an ongoing journey. I am repeatedly reminded each time I reflect on a situation or a reaction that reflected the need for more work on a particular soul trait. I hope it will be a practice that I can work on for the rest of my life, or at least as long as I have my cognitive faculties.</p><p>When walking the Camino, fellow pilgrims call out “Buen Camino!”</p><p>According to <a href="https://www.huffpost.com/entry/buen-camino-walking-the-way-to-santiago-de-compostela_b_596c8dffe4b09e26b6d76953">Alan Singer</a>:</p><p>As you walk you say “Buen Camino” to everyone you see. “Buen Camino” literally means good road in Spanish, but it can also mean good path, path being both physical and spiritual. It is the greeting shared by pilgrims, hikers, and bicyclers on the Camino and also with local people who wish you well.</p><p>While hiking in Wicklow, Ireland a few months after returning from Spain, I heard a woman call out to me, ‘Buen Camino.” She had seen the scallop shell dangling from my backpack. As someone who had also walked the Camino, she wanted to share the memory and joy of that experience by greeting me in the traditional way. I like to think that as I continue my life journey, that greeting will stay with me and help illuminate my inner compass and keep me walking and finding my way.</p><p><strong>Thank You!</strong></p><p>So we have come to the end of my story. I appreciate all who have read about my experiences with low vision and my journey to learn from it and find my way in life. I am grateful for the warm and supportive comments many of you have sent or posted. When I set out to write this blog series I had no idea what I would say and how it would evolve, but evolve it did. And now, as it is ending, I feel a sense of relief and completion. I am also deeply grateful for the excellent editing efforts of my husband Michael, my friend Deborah, and my brother Stan.</p><p><strong>Final Note: Helping Others Who Have Low Vision</strong></p><p>I am aware that other people suffer vision loss and may not be aware of all the resources I have discovered and used. For example, each state has services for the blind; you can also access the National Library for the Blind and Print Disabled <a href="https://www.loc.gov/nls/">here</a>. This library allows free downloads of hundreds of thousands of recorded books, right to your smartphone. I love this service, and usually have three books that I am reading concurrently, each on a different device. People suffering a new vision loss also may not be aware of the resources offered by low-vision optometry centers and occupational therapists. I discovered that I could also obtain reduced-rate transit passes due to my disability. Most of these things I learned on my own, and found that I had to advocate for myself. If you know someone who is losing vision, please share these resources with them.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=43298f66fc17" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Developing My Inner Vision at Esalen]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/developing-my-inner-vision-at-esalen-485e41c9ea6?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/485e41c9ea6</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[low-vision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[esalen]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eyesight]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 26 Mar 2021 13:40:33 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-29T21:47:46.228Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Fstep</h3><p>This is number 15 in my blog series <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/869/1*xJm0Yp7XIVZdXLCH9OKwwg.png" /></figure><p><a href="https://www.esalen.org/">Esalen Institute</a> in Big Sur, California, is a unique place where people have been going for over fifty years to explore their lives, learn about themselves, improve themselves, and participate in a unique community. I used to think of it as the place shown in the film <em>Bob and Ted and Carol and Alice</em>. I knew that my aunt and uncle had gone there in the 60s, and that it was where you had to participate in Sensitivity Groups. It seemed to attract hippies and people who embraced drugs and free love. I never had any interest in going to Esalen.</p><p>Today, their home page states: <em>We’re a holistic learning and retreat center. With a playful spirit and fierce intellectual honesty, we ask big questions about the world and our role in it in a spirit of optimism and with a tenacious belief in human potential.</em></p><p>My husband, Michael, first went to Esalen in December of 1989. As a student of psychology, he had always wanted to visit the place where Fritz Perls created Gestalt Therapy, and where so many great writers, thinkers and artists had spent time. He loved being at Esalen and returned every few years to take different workshops. Michael told me about the great (mostly vegetarian) food, the beautiful ocean and gardens, the early morning movement or dance sessions, and of course, the famous natural hot baths that overlook the Pacific Ocean. He also told me about the optional use of clothing in the baths, pool, and massage areas. Despite his frequent invitations, I was not interested in joining him.</p><p>But in 2013, Michael made a bargain with me. He would come to a yoga retreat in Mexico with me (Mar de Jade, in Chacala) if I would come to Esalen with him. I agreed to take a hiking “workshop” there with him, one he had taken before. Now that we were avid hikers, it seemed like the most feasible activity for me, as I was nervous about all the New Age, touchy-feely, free-spirited activities I had heard and read about.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/854/1*kLZwIBXwuzMvIqmLaqVgOg.png" /></figure><p>I did not know that on that first visit I would also fall in love with everything about the Institute and its beautiful surroundings, and that it would affect me in deep and profound ways. We tried to return every year after that, taking the same hiking workshop as well as dance classes and other seminars. Now, looking back, I can see that my experiences over those visits to Esalen have helped me develop my inner vision.</p><p><strong>First Day at Esalen</strong></p><p>I was nervous and wary. The people I saw on the grounds and by the pool and the main lodge seemed young and very much like my hippie stereotype. They were talking, playing music, and laughing. Were they stoned? I now know that they were most likely the staff, called “work study scholars,” taking a break after lunch. They would be there to study with a particular teacher for a month or more, and would work as staff at the same time. They were probably on break when I saw them lounging outside.</p><p>Seeing these young people made me acutely aware of my senior status at age 63. At that time, I was still a hard-working professor from Minnesota. I was skeptical that I would fit in at this New Age paradise. We received keys to our “luxury” accommodations, and moved in. It was a simple room in a plain unit of six rooms. It was considered “luxury” because it did not have bunkbeds, we did not have to share with other people, and because we had a balcony with two chairs overlooking the ocean. We stay in one of these rooms every time we return. They are now our Esalen home, and quite comfortable despite the sparse amenities!</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/486/1*a-_Ypz-MQagQvMNeqPzcGQ.png" /></figure><p>On that first day, Michael had booked a massage that ended at 6:30, half an hour after dinner began to be served in the main dining hall. Michael said he would meet me there for dinner and that I should just sit with people and introduce myself. He would find me there. This also filled me with apprehension. I was not comfortable just walking up to a table of strangers (who were already engaged in a conversation) and asking if I could sit with them.</p><p>Anytime I am in a new place I become anxious about what I can and cannot see. How would I navigate the dining hall on my own? I knew I could have waited for Michael but I was hungry, as I was still on Central Time. At 6 PM I forced myself to go to the main lodge. I joined a line of people going through a cafeteria line. I watched as they grabbed napkins and utensils from shelves on the wall. I did the same. The line approached some big tureens of soup. The signs labeling the soups were on the table. At that time, I was a strict vegan, so I needed to read the ingredients to know which soup I could safely eat. I instinctively crouched down to make the sign closer to my eye so I could read it. And then I noticed that the man in front of me in the line was doing the same thing. I waited a few minutes until we had passed to another line for salad, and asked him “Do you have low vision?” He looked at me brightly and said yes, he did. We were kindred spirits!</p><p>We sat together at a table outside with his wife and I began to feel at ease. He was a few years younger than me, but still a senior at Esalen. He had a similar type of vision disability, and we compared notes on what we did to accommodate our low vision. His name was Joe, and he was in a different workshop, but we would see each other from time to time during the week and greeted each other like old friends. Meeting Joe and feeling our common vision loss was a providential beginning to my Esalen adventure. Although he took my email address at the end of the week I never heard from him again. But I am grateful that he was there and that I met him exactly when I needed him.</p><p><strong>The Esalen Hot Baths</strong></p><p>I was intrigued but nervous about trying the hot baths that Michael loved so much and went to twice a day. He took me through the routine. Walk down the stairs to the large, communal changing room. Grab a clean towel from the shelf. Hang up your clothes on a hook and try to remember where you left them. Shower in the open shower overlooking the ocean with the Esalen lavender soap; then walk with your towel (and nothing else) to the baths. I was very aware of my 63 year old body, and held on tightly to my towel.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/501/1*0NIc7t7Phvgpq2vUUYQvzg.png" /></figure><p>But once I got to the baths, I saw that there were so many shapes, sizes and ages of people. No one looked at anyone else’s body. And no one looked like a model or movie star, although we have seen and met some TV and movie stars and other celebrities at Esalen over the years. The people seemed to be focused on enjoying the glorious hot baths and views of the waves crashing on the rocks below us. One day I noticed a woman with a mastectomy scar and I thought, if she is brave enough to be here, then so am I. No one cared what my body looked like. At Esalen, what seemed more important was what kind of person I was. And once I realized that, I could relax and enjoy the people I met in the baths. Each day we would talk, laugh, share stories, compare workshops, and sometimes even sing. Other times we relaxed in silence, just listening to the waves. At night we could look up at the huge expanse of stars. There is something deep and healing about these natural hot spring-filled baths, which are unlike any hot tubs we have ever experienced. I am so thankful I allowed myself to try them out, and now I look forward to the baths as soon as I arrive at Esalen each year.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/772/1*7T-OAmJDuclfL5zP5dQYbw.png" /></figure><p>Our hiking workshop began the evening that we arrived. It was called “A Walk on the Wild Side” and was led by Steven Harper. Michael had taken this same workshop in 1993, 10 years earlier, and was happy to be back. Steven welcomed us to the “Price House” (named after Dick Price, one of the founders of Esalen along with Michael Murphy) where we sat around a wood-burning fireplace and met the 20 or so other hikers. From the beginning, Steven encouraged us to not share the typical information with each other (name, job, where we lived, etc.). Instead we were asked to share what brought us to the workshop and what concerns we had about it. As we went around the room introducing ourselves and responding to these questions, we began to get a feeling for each other in a different and more authentic way as we opened up and shared our vulnerability.</p><p>For the rest of the week, we learned what Michael refers to as “The Zen of hiking.” The goal wasn’t to hike, but to be in the wild, to really experience nature. And of course, to learn about ourselves. We took long beautiful hikes each day, and we often met at night to share “what had heart and meaning” for us that day. What had we learned, what had touched us. Sometimes we would walk in silence, spread out from each other, as we focused on feeling the earth beneath our feet, the air or breezes around us, aware of the sounds and the smells, as well as the sights. I had told the group on the first night that I had low vision, and would appreciate them telling me their names when I saw them on the campus. I was not too worried about my low vision on the hikes because Michael tended to stay near and look out for me, and because we had already taken several hiking trips together.</p><p>At the end of our first hike, late in the afternoon, we reached a lovely creek and waterfall. Steven invited us to take a dip in the cold water. He said that any amount of clothing was ok. But we needed to be careful not to judge ourselves and not to judge others. I will never forget those words, and have heard him repeat them often over the years. Some people in the group (including Steven) stripped off their clothes and plunged into the water by the waterfall. Some of us, shyer on that first day, rolled up our pants or partially disrobed, and sat on rocks dangling our feet in the cold water. It felt comfortable and peaceful. And very nonjudgmental.</p><p>By the end of the week we would end our hike at a natural “warm pool” deep in the woods, where we would all disrobe, enter the water in silence, sitting together in this peaceful and magical setting. After four days of hiking together, we now felt like a close-knit family.</p><p><strong>What I Learned From Steven</strong></p><p>Steven was a gentle, wise, and skillful teacher. Over the six times we have hiked with him I have learned so much about myself and about how I live and interact in the world. The last time we were in his workshop he told us to try to see the world with “soft eyes.” As he described soft eyes, it seemed that he was talking about MY eyes. He said not to focus on something, to let all the periphery into our vision. To use all our senses to see, not just our eyes. I almost started to cry. He was asking people to see the world the way I saw it!</p><p>According to Steven, soft eyes enable us to take in what is important in the world around us. They give us a wider view. Not focusing on what is in front of us allows us to take in more of what is around us and see the bigger picture.</p><p>One of the exercises we did one day on the trail was particularly emotional for me. We grouped ourselves into pairs and took turns leading each other, blindfolded, on the path. Michael was my partner and I was aware of his great care and patience as he guided me with words and touch along the path. It was an exercise in trust. But for me it was also an experience of what total blindness might be like if it comes, and how I might cope with it.</p><p>Other things I learned from Steven:</p><p><strong>To be grateful.</strong> Each day we shared a picnic lunch and took time to consider with gratitude where the food came from, how it was grown and prepared. We would also take a few minutes to each share something we were feeling grateful for that day. I came to feel great gratitude for my companions on the hikes (including, of course, Michael) because they looked out for me, helped me across difficult passages over logs on the path. And on each subsequent visit I felt enormous gratitude for being back at my Esalen home.</p><p><strong>Importance of community. </strong>Although it seemed simple and effortless, Steven worked hard to help the group form a close community. I realized that I too can be a connector and community builder. I would organize a long table at dinner and invite our hiking group to join us. Sometimes I would provide a bottle or two of wine, and soon others were doing that as well. These dinners were noisy and festive, and at the end we would do our daily check-in together or what had heart and meaning for us that day. I would feel a warm glow as I climbed the hilly path to our cabin after dinner, thinking about the wonderful new friends I had made.</p><p><strong>The magic of poetry.</strong> Steven liked to read poems to us that were favorites of his, and I felt as if he were sharing friends with us. He also gave us snippets of writings by John Muir that also felt like little poems. Each of us received a different quote to read, think about, and share with the group. Inspired by his love of poetry, I began to follow his example of choosing a poem to read and reflect on throughout the year.</p><p><strong>Being authentic.</strong> We experienced first how important it is to look beyond people’s usual identifying information. We can come to know each other in deep and emotional ways in just a few days while experiencing the wilderness together and sharing our reflections and perceptions together.</p><p><strong>To focus on the journey, and not the destination.</strong> To stay in the moment, to keep learning and changing.</p><p><strong>To avoid judgment.</strong> This applies to myself and others. To accept myself and my limitations and imperfections, as well as those of others.</p><p><strong>The healing powers of being in the wilderness. </strong>Steven took us on sunlit paths by giant redwood trees near rushing waters. Or along sandy beaches lined with mysterious caves. We paused and appreciated sacred grounds once used by native Americans (the Esselens). We climbed hills and splashed in the water. And we emerged from these experiences refreshed, energized, and uplifted.</p><p><strong>Dancing the 5 Rhythms</strong></p><p>On our second visit to Esalen, we decided to stay for two weeks. After our hiking workshop ended, we took a wonderful weekend class on Yoga Nidra Meditation that was exactly what we needed. It was so restful we kept falling asleep during our meetings. But that was okay because as a result, we were rested and ready for our first dance workshop.</p><p>We had heard about the 5 Rhythms from a woman in our first hiking group and we were intrigued. It is a free-form, expressive and healing type of dance that was created at Esalen in the 1970s by Gabrielle Roth. She is no longer alive, but her son Jonathan and step-daughter Lucia teach these courses around the world and at Esalen. We signed up for a class with Jonathan.</p><p>Michael and I both like to dance, and we tried to prepare for our workshop by watching videos of Gabrielle and reading one of her books about the 5 Rhythms. We arrived at the workshop feeling a little out of place, as everyone else seemed to know each other and be experienced dancers. But once again, we soon felt at ease and enjoyed meeting the other participants and dancing with them. It was hard work, but we danced until we were exhausted, and participated in exercises with the other dancers. These gave us a respite from being on our feet all day, and were aligned with the workshop theme of Masks and Mirrors. On the final day of the workshop we were sad to say goodbye to all of our new dancing friends.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/440/1*QfDPc_wfz-etgd673er8jQ.png" /></figure><p>The following year we took a course from Lucia, and we fell in love with her. Her workshop was titled Heartbeat, and focused on our emotions and how to deal with them. We danced through joy, fear, anger, grief, and other emotions. We also learned from Lucia’s presentations. One lesson I keep with me at all times is to recognize when I am fearful, and to examine that fear from a distance, as if looking at an object in my hand — and then to replace it with courage. Many times since that lesson I have felt afraid of even small things, like asking someone for help in an airport, or what street I am on in a strange city. When I recognize the feeling of fear, I tell myself to replace it with courage, and that usually helps.</p><p>Despite being in our 60s we once again felt that no one was watching us as we danced, and we did not have to feel self-conscious. We could just let loose and express ourselves through movement. The next year we returned for another workshop with Lucia, this time on making connections. Again, we learned so much — this time, about how we connect with others. In the short time we danced together, we felt very close and connected to the many other people in our workshop.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/854/1*SgbBRUmnd9LtlWIE2wpzrQ.png" /></figure><p><strong>Inner vision</strong></p><p>Esalen has felt like an exuberant summer camp for adults, and I hope to return again when the pandemic is over. But more than the good times, I have learned so much from my visits there. We have taken other workshops over the years that have helped us learn to set intentions in our life, to follow a daily practice of movement and stretching, and to use guided meditation for calming and relaxation, and more.</p><p>As I look back on the time we spent at Esalen and all the workshops we have taken, I feel that my experiences there have helped me develop a clarity of inner vision that complements my limited physical vision.</p><p>I think that I am better able to see myself in relation to others. I have more of a sense of connection and less of feeling isolated, different, noticed, and not fitting in. I feel that the soft eyes I have been blessed with allow me to see people without focusing on what they look like, but instead, on who they are.</p><p>Esalen has helped me see what is truly important in my life and who I want to be. I think my experience there has helped me become a kinder, gentler, more accepting and compassionate person than I was before.</p><p>I learned to see beyond obstacles, to be more courageous, to trust and to be grateful.</p><p>I think Esalen also helped me work on humility. To realize that no one cared about what I looked like in the baths, or how well (or how poorly) I hiked or danced. My low vision often forced me to listen more, to focus more on the person I was talking to, and less on myself. I became more outgoing, making friends at meals or at the pool. And to my great joy, one of the friends I made at the dinner table has become one of my dearest friends. We have had wonderful zoom calls during COVID, and we can’t wait to meet at Esalen again.</p><p>Finally, learning about soft eyes as a gift, not a curse, allowed me to actually value my limited vision. That was a perspective I never expected to have!</p><p><em>Next post: The Continuing Journey</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=485e41c9ea6" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[More Eye Surgery]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/more-eye-surgery-adf6b9b8baf1?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/adf6b9b8baf1</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cataract-surgery]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eyesight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[low-vision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 12 Mar 2021 00:42:21 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-12T16:24:10.158Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is number 14 in my blog series <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><p>Life was moving along quickly, as it does when one feels busy and happy. And then, once again, I noticed a decrease in my vision. I worried that more degeneration was occurring, despite my eyes being stable for several years. Dr. Ryan, my retinal specialist, ran the usual tests and examined my eyes. He informed me that I had a small cataract growing in my left eye, the one I used for reading and navigating. He recommended an ophthalmologist at my health clinic, Dr. Blatt, to surgically remove the cataract. I was so relieved that this was a fixable problem and not an indication of more vision loss.</p><p>I made an appointment to see Dr. Blatt. Although the cataract was small — not big enough to warrant surgery in patients with normal eyesight — he concurred that in my case it might be beneficial to have it removed. He recommended that unlike in most surgeries, where the patient’s lens is replaced with a plastic lens providing 20/20 vision, I be given a lens that would keep me nearsighted. If I had central vision, it would make sense to give me a lens that provided 20/20 vision. But since I only had peripheral vision, in order to read I needed greatly magnified print. I was very nearsighted in both eyes, about -13 on my prescriptions. Dr. Ryan recommended that my new lens change my level of nearsightedness to -3. That would allow me to magnify print by holding it close to my eyes. I was booked for the procedure, yet again, at the Phillips Eye Institute. Although the surgery was quite routine, I was nervous about having another operation on the eye that already had laser surgeries and a detached retina.</p><p>All went well and after the surgery, I went home with a patch to keep on my eye until the next day. We were planning to fly to Mexico a few weeks later and, at my follow-up visit, Dr. Blatt advised me to keep my head out of the water in pools and the ocean. I also had to have my glasses prescription changed to accommodate my new, less-nearsighted vison.</p><p><strong>My New Magnifier Necklace</strong></p><p>I must have read somewhere that it might be helpful to have a small magnifier to use after my cataract surgery. I went to a shopping mall and found a magnifier that I could wear around my neck on a chain. This combination proved to be very helpful, as whenever I needed to read something, I could just lift up the magnifier from where it hung around my neck. From that day on, I have always worn my magnifier necklace. When not covered by a scarf or relegated to my handbag for dressy occasions, it shows up in photos such as the one below from a hiking trip in Ireland. Over the years I have replaced chains and magnifiers many times as they break or become damaged. But I cannot go out of the house without this special necklace.</p><p>I find that people often comment on my necklace, asking if it’s a special prism, or piece of jewelry. And when I tell them it’s a magnifier that I use to read print, they often exclaim that they would like such device as well.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/530/1*t2XKNAtATsWDnVxYZGTufQ.png" /></figure><p>A few years after my initial cataract surgery, Dr. Ryan suggested I have the same operation performed on my right eye, despite the fact that I had less usable vision in that eye. He thought that the procedure might provide a little more brightness. Dr. Blatt repeated the surgery and once again it went smoothly. Now I noticed that when I was not wearing my glasses, my decreased nearsightedness (now -3 in both eyes) made the world less blurry and easier to navigate. This has been especially helpful during the pandemic, when my glasses fog up from wearing a mask. I find I can remove them and see well enough to run or walk outside.</p><p><strong>Becoming a Grandma</strong></p><p>Our son Harlan married in 2008 and in 2010 my life changed dramatically when our first grandchild was born. My son and daughter would provide four more children over the years, all greatly loved. But this little baby was so beautiful and special; I fell deeply in love with him. In the photo below you can see my magnifier necklace, which each of my grandchildren loved to grab and put in their mouths. As they got older, they would hold it up to their eyes saying, “Hello, Hello!”</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/366/1*gDCQ6Isyqv2ABVe1M_oj6A.png" /></figure><p><strong>Venturing Across the World</strong></p><p>I started to feel more confident traveling without Michael, especially when accompanied by a good friend or colleague. In March, 2011 I was invited to Japan to give a talk and a workshop to statistics teachers at a conference in Tokyo. I did not feel comfortable presenting on my own due to my disability and asked if my colleague and research partner, Bob, could join me. Our host found the funding to bring both of us, and expanded our activities to last several days. It turned out that Bob’s wife, Rose, wanted to visit Japan, as did my friend Eileen, who agreed to come share a room with me and be my companion.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/522/1*NQfBU0b95nV6OzuYk2h7Nw.png" /><figcaption>Our delegation to Japan</figcaption></figure><p>We had a great time exploring Tokyo, and even attended a concert that my brother David (coincidentally) gave while we were there. The presentations and workshops went well, and we were treated with kindness and generosity. At the end of a very full week it was time to return home. But at the last moment, things changed.</p><p>You may remember the earthquake that occurred in Japan, in March 2011, followed by the tsunami that damaged the Fukushima nuclear power plant. That earthquake began just as we were settling into our seats on the plane to head home. We felt helpless and scared. I wondered if the earth would open up and swallow us in flames and smoke, and if I would ever see Michael and my kids again. Fortunately, after about six nerve-racking hours sitting on the runway, our plane was one of five allowed to depart, and we headed home to Minneapolis. I have never been so happy to see Michael as he greeted us at the airport. After the trip to Japan, you would think I would not be eager to travel overseas again, but that hesitation did not last long.</p><p><strong>Six Weeks in Europe</strong></p><p>My first trip overseas took place when I was 40, so I had a late start. My appetite for international travel now seemed to be in full force. Michael did not share my wanderlust, but had usually agreed to one or two hiking trips in Europe each year. I yearned to spend more time overseas, but given my vision limitations, I did not feel I could travel on my own.</p><p>In 2010, while hiking in Ireland with Michael, I chatted with a woman from Australia who was traveling on her own in Europe (along with her golf clubs!) for three months. I was impressed and inspired. I longed to do something like that, but needed a feasible strategy.</p><p>After recovering from the trip to Japan, I started looking at travel for the summer of 2011. There were two events I wanted to attend in Europe. In mid-July my small research forum, Statistical Reasoning, Thinking and Literacy (SRTL), was meeting in the Netherlands. And in late August, my international statistical organization was meeting in Dublin. I thought I could secure funding to attend both, and wouldn’t it be perfect if I could stay in Europe for the four weeks in between the two events?</p><p>Michael agreed to join me for a few weeks of hiking in Ireland in August. I still needed someone to accompany me the rest of the time, and fly to and from Europe with me. Once again, my friend Eileen agreed to join me. We rented an apartment in Paris for the week after SRTL, and another apartment in Cork, Ireland after that. Then Michael would join me while Eileen went off on her own and Eileen would meet me back in Dublin when Michael returned home.</p><p>In preparation for the trip, I bought my first iPad. I used it to follow slides during presentations at the conferences, as my low vision prevented me from being able to view slideshows on screens. The iPad proved invaluable, as it also allowed me to use email with enlarged font, something I could not do on computers in the various countries I visited. As my trip progressed, I also used it (with great joy) to watch videos of my little grandson laughing and beginning to crawl.</p><p>I had never been away from home for so long, nor spent so much time in Europe. This trip became the adventure of my lifetime. I even luxuriated in business class flights to and from Europe, which added to the experience. I enjoyed all the places, people, food, scenery, and more.</p><p>I was 61 when I had my great European trip. I sensed that this opportunity would not happen again, so I made sure to take lots of photos and savor each moment. I was so grateful for all the people who looked out for me at each phase of the journey. For example, at SRTL, where we were all given rental bikes for the week, they arranged a tandem bike for me and my co-chair Dani, since I would not feel safe cycling on my own.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/482/1*YY0OmSGEWfco9LEnHW3QKg.png" /><figcaption>Dani and me on our tandem bike in the Netherlands</figcaption></figure><p>I did not worry about getting lost, finding my way, or being alone in an unfamiliar place. I had my monocular with me to read street signs, and even took walks in each city by myself, which felt very empowering. I returned home at the end of the summer of 2011 recharged and ready to head back to work and spend time with my family.</p><p><em>Next post: Finding my Inner Vision at Esalen</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=adf6b9b8baf1" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Finding Balance]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/finding-balance-8731f4e0fe3f?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8731f4e0fe3f</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[eyesight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 28 Feb 2021 16:37:22 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-03-01T20:36:50.798Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is number 13 in the blog series <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*qiYn0dClZnRdfB5gb09D5Q.png" /></figure><p>My sessions with Kate, my therapist, helped me in many ways. As the weeks and months progressed, I became more comfortable talking about and accepting my vision loss. Because my vision disability was invisible, and I did not use a white cane that identified me as being legally blind, Rebecca had once made me a little sign to wear (shown below). We thought this would help because it was hard for me to tell people I could not see or read what they were showing me, or to ask for help. But I never mustered the courage to actually wear this sign, so I pinned it to my bulletin board, where I recently noticed it.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/484/1*NsOHWLhhl4mzwn_SDDSGCA.png" /><figcaption>The Sign Rebecca made for me to wear as a pin</figcaption></figure><p>Early on I used to say things like “I have bad eyes,” but realized how negative that sounded. Then I began to say, “I am vision disabled” or “I have a vision disability.” On occasion, I began to ride the bus and would sit near the front, telling the driver about my vision loss and asking him or her to notify me when we reached my destination. There were still upsetting situations, such as the time Rebecca and I attended a Broadway play. I had secured second-row seats so that I could better see the stage and actors. During the show, Rebecca often whispered to me, telling me things that were happening on stage that I could not see. At one point, someone in the row ahead of us turned around and hissed at her to be quiet. Rebecca replied angrily, “She’s blind and can’t see the stage.” I appreciated her defending me, but I was also embarrassed at my needing her explanation.</p><p>At the University, I told my students about my vision disability and asked them to announce their names if they ran into me on campus, and to wave their arms in class if they wanted my attention. I seemed to be accepting my current state of low vision and those around me seemed to be acknowledging it as well.</p><p><strong>Cancelling Another Trip</strong></p><p>After missing my big International Conference on Teaching Statistics (ICOTS, 2002) in South Africa due to my new vision loss and surgeries that year, I was planning to attend the next ICOTS, which would be held in Brazil in 2006. This time I was invited to give one of the keynote talks, which was a great honor. Having missed the last conference, I was eager to attend and see my friends there from around the world. However, given my poor eyesight, I was also nervous about traveling without Michael and giving a talk to a large number of people. I gave myself a pep talk, and planned to travel with my colleague and research partner, Bob. I felt he would look after me in Michael’s absence.</p><p>Shortly before we were to fly to Brazil, two things happened. First, the Brazilian airline we would have taken for the second leg of the trip went bankrupt and was cancelling many flights. I heard stories from colleagues who tried to fly to the conference city earlier in the week about how they either had problems booking alternative flights or had turned around and come home. That certainly worried us.</p><p>Then we learned that Michael’s mother, Dorothy, had fallen and was in the hospital with a broken pelvis. She lived alone in Long Island. Michael’s brother Alan had driven to New York from Philadelphia, where he lived, and observed that she seemed to be suffering from dementia as well. After several days, Alan needed to return home, and Michael agreed to fly to New York to relieve him. I knew he was concerned and would have liked me to help out, but I had promised to give a keynote address in Brazil.</p><p>Over the next day, I pondered what to do. I realized that if I missed the conference in Brazil, I would be letting down my friends and colleagues. But if I abandoned Michael and his mother (whom I loved very much) I would be letting down my family. In the end, I chose family over profession.</p><p>Once again, I cancelled the trip, leaving the organizers to frantically fill my plenary address at the last minute. But they managed. And I flew to NY with Michael to sort out the situation with his mother. I am so glad I did. This turned out to be a turning point in Dorothy’s life, as she was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease. We stayed with her until she was moved from the hospital to a nearby rehab facility. Then Alan and his wife, Jan, found a rehab facility near them in Philadelphia, so we drove her there. Once Dorothy was settled in (although not happy about it) we flew home. Several weeks later, we returned to move her back to her home in NY, at her request. Actually, she was so distraught about living in a new place that she threatened “to jump out the window” if we did not take her home. We were worried about her safety, but did as she asked. Dorothy lived on her own again for almost a year and then agreed to move to assisted living near Michael’s brother.</p><p>Although I was sorry to miss ICOTS, I was glad I did not have to deal with the cancelled flights and last-minute airline changes my colleagues had experienced. I was able to give the talk I had prepared the following year at the U.S. version of ICOTS, which felt great. And I had stood by Michael and his family during a difficult time, which I knew was the right decision. In part, this may have been because of all the time he had spent in the waiting rooms of eye doctors and during my eye surgeries, and in general being a steady comfort to me. Now it was my turn to be there for him, especially since I had not been so comforting during his bout with cancer.</p><p><strong>Creating a Balanced Life</strong></p><p>After obtaining my disability leave and reducing my appointment to two-thirds time, I continued to go to work five days a week. Gradually I reduced my time at the office to four and, a few years later, to three days a week. Michael chauffeured me to and from work each day. Our offices were both on the Mississippi River, just a mile apart. Although it was nice to be driven, I often resented having to follow Michael’s work schedule. It meant being stuck in rush hour traffic in the morning and coming home later than I would have liked. In those days I was reluctant to take the bus (about an hour each way) or a taxi, so I was often annoyed or impatient with having to base my work hours on Michael’s activities. It was another frustration over not being independent and not being able to get myself to and from work at my preferred times. Several years later I would become adept at taking buses and Ubers on my own schedule, which made life easier.</p><p>Once I settled into my new work schedule, I began to use my days out of the office for relaxing and rebalancing. Although I also worked at home on those days, mainly reading and writing on my computer, I went for runs at the nearby lake, took walks, quilted, and worked on my creative writing project (a memoir about my life and the food I ate and prepared). These activities contributed to my mental and physical health, and gave my eyes a break from looking at computer screens all day.</p><p><strong>Feeling Better</strong></p><p>After meeting with Kate regularly for two years, my tears had stopped flowing and my spirits had improved. I felt happier and more optimistic about my life. In fact, Kate confessed that she had no reason to continue my therapy and to file an insurance claim as to why I needed to keep seeing her (as she was out of my insurance network and had to be reapproved each year).</p><p>We decided that I did not need to continue seeing Kate on a regular basis. It felt like a graduation of sorts. We said goodbye, and agreed that I would return as needed. And from time to time I did go back to Kate, including the year of my insomnia (see <a href="https://joangarfield.medium.com/chronicle-of-sleepless-nights-bdb97dbf1c6b">Chronicle of Sleepless Nights</a>).</p><p>I felt comfortable traveling around the U.S. on my own, and took several trips each year to attend conferences, give talks, or evaluate programs. I enjoyed my connections with colleagues around the country, and invited many of them to visit to give seminars at my university and meet with my students. My graduate program was growing and thriving, and now had four faculty and a great group of students. Grant funding helped support many of them, as well as their travel to conferences and workshops.</p><p>Eventually I began to recognize a gift that came with my vision disability: obtaining a partial disability leave enabled me to balance my life. I now had time for other things that renewed and energized me. I found that I relied on the days away from my office to recover from the days of intense visual work that consumed me at my job. The rest days that my disability leave provided enabled me to teach my courses with energy and enthusiasm, and to stay productive writing and running grants, working with doctoral students, and keeping active in my professional community. If I had not lost my vision and had not received a partial disability leave, I think my over-achieving, workaholic life would have prevented me from ever finding the calm and balance I craved. I probably would have not retired when I did, and might still be working full time today.</p><p>I adjusted to the new structure of my life. We began to take hiking trips in Europe in the summers. I bought my first digital camera, and with the help of my postdoctoral fellow, Ann, learned to use it and to take (and edit) great photos. I filled our house with enlargements of my photos over the next few years. Surprisingly, having no central vision seemed to enhance my ability to set up and take a good photograph!</p><p>Another friend convinced me to get an iPod and use that to download and listen to audiobooks. I joined the online audio bookstore, Audible, and was thrilled to carry dozens of books with me wherever I went, thanks to this little device. No more carrying clunky cassette players and numerous cassette tapes to listen to while traveling.</p><p>Our children had settled down on opposite coasts, and we enjoyed visiting them a few times a year. Our life at home felt full and happy. Yes, there would be more losses. But when they occurred, I realized that I had survived those first ones and was better able to face the next ones. And happily, Rebecca returned to me a few years later, and we once again enjoyed a close and loving relationship. Over time, both children would move back to Minneapolis and raise families near enough for me to walk to their homes. But that was still a few years away.</p><p><strong><em>Next post: More eye surgery</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8731f4e0fe3f" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Therapy]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/therapy-9b84c45a08a5?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9b84c45a08a5</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eyesight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-loss]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Feb 2021 15:54:54 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-18T01:28:00.815Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is number 12 in the series <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*VBwTmbN3zx4bxW5nrxv1fw.png" /></figure><p>I did not know where to even begin looking for a good therapist. So once again, Rebecca came to my aid. She found an ad in the <em>Minnesota Women’s Press</em> for a therapist (Kate) who had an office only a few blocks from my house. Even better, the first appointment was free so that we could determine if working together would feel safe and positive. Rebecca called and made an appointment for me.</p><p>Although Kate was out of my insurance network, I applied for and received an exemption, so I only had to pay a small copayment. My argument was that I could walk to her house (this was important, since I could not drive due to my impaired vision) and because, as I learned in our first conversation, she had experience working with people who had a disability. Rebecca walked with me to my first appointment, helping me find the door to Kate’s office at the back of her house.</p><p><strong>What I Gained from Therapy</strong></p><p>And so I began my relationship with Kate, a warm, compassionate and skilled therapist who helped me in profound ways. I told Kate that I had been feeling sad and depressed, and described the losses I was experiencing. I remember tearing up as I told her about my loss of central vision, of independence (needing to be chauffeured by Michael), and of the inability to read books, after having been an avid reader all my life. Then I described the experience of suddenly losing my father, the feelings of loss brought on by Michael’s cancer and treatments, and finally, the loss of a close relationship with Rebecca.</p><p>Kate began by asking me to describe my family. During those first sessions, I seemed to spend a lot of time (and became quite emotional) talking about my mother. At some point, Kate helped me realize that perhaps one of the reasons I was so driven to achieve and excel was because I was seeking the praise and affirmation my mother did not offer me. That was quite a revelation, as I had never before tried to understand why I worked so hard and was so determined to excel. Our discussions led me to ask my mother about a few incidents that had bothered me about our relationship in the past. As a result, my mother actually apologized to me, asking for my forgiveness. Instantly my feelings towards my mother changed. For the rest of her life we talked nightly on the phone and had a warm, loving connection.</p><p>Over the years I worked with Kate, she helped me understand why and how Rebecca was separating from me, and that it was ok for me to be sad and try to pull her back. Kate did reassure me that Rebecca would return at some point, and that she loved me. Rebecca even joined me for a session when she was back in town, and that was very helpful. And Kate was correct about Rebecca returning to me in time.</p><p>As I talked about my life, Kate noticed that I frequently reported how stressed I felt about my work and what I needed to do to maintain my career and productivity goals. In particular, I was trying hard to write and obtain grants to fund my research and reduce my teaching load, as well as to support my work during the summers. Like most faculty, I was on a nine-month appointment and always scrambling to find funding for the summer months. I complained about how my life was out of balance and that I was exhausted from working so hard.</p><p>These days, I better understand why I was so tired, and how everything I did took longer and was more challenging because of my vision loss. In my quest to lead a “normal” life, I had neglected to acknowledge the impact of my disability. Recently, my friend Karen shared a documentary film with me about artists who deal with vision loss. I watched it with great interest and empathy. One particular story offered me new insight. It was about a vision-disabled author, trying to give a poetry reading and having trouble despite enlarged print and bright lights. He talked about the strain of trying to act “normal.” His story helped me realize the toll that trying to keep a regular work load and job after losing my central vision had taken on me.</p><p><strong>Requesting a Disability Leave</strong></p><p>Back in 2006, Kate asked if I had thought about applying for a disability leave. I had not. I loved my work and was involved in many projects and activities. Kate suggested I explore a leave that would release me from a fulltime workload, based on my vision loss.</p><p>As a result, I applied for and received a Family Medical Leave (FML) for one semester, during which time I was released from teaching and other responsibilities. I then received a partial disability leave that reduced my appointment to 66.7 percent. I would receive two-thirds of my salary, but university insurance would cover a good amount of the remainder. I would receive full benefits, and best of all, I would be funded in the summers. From 2007 until I turned 65 in 2015, I received disability benefits and a reduced teaching load. I negotiated a load of one class per year, one of the two statistics education courses I had created for the new graduate program that had launched in 2002. I was relieved that I would not have to teach in a big lecture hall, unable to see my slides nor students’ faces.</p><p>A challenge in obtaining the disability leave was needing to have my disability certified each year. Given that my vision loss was permanent, this seemed to be an unnecessary hurdle. A doctor was required to complete a form certifying that I was unable to perform my fulltime job responsibilities. In my case, I needed the doctor to report that it was too difficult for me to have a regular teaching load of four classes a year, and that I needed to teach small classes or seminars. I felt I was capable of teaching just one course a year. The rest of my time would be spent on service to the university and to my academic community, research and grant work, and advising graduate students. I was able to negotiate this plan with my current department chair. Now I needed a doctor to certify this recommendation.</p><p>At first, I asked my primary care doctor to complete the form for me. But she refused, saying she did not know me well enough or understand the effects of my vision loss. I felt humiliated and disappointed, and never returned to her again.</p><p>After doing some research, I called the Department of Occupational Medicine at my clinic. I was able to find a very kind and sympathetic doctor who completed the first form for me. I met with her again the next year and once again, she filled out and signed the form. Then this doctor left the clinic. The following year I made an appointment with a different doctor in that department, and what a mistake that was. She treated me with coldness and skepticism. Despite all the records about my vision loss and eye surgeries, she asked me to take an eye test in front of her so she could confirm my poor eyesight. Afterwards, this doctor read the questions on the form out loud, questions such as when would I be healed and able to return to fulltime work. Hearing these questions caused me to start crying as I was confronted with the hopelessness I felt about recovering my lost vision. This woman looked at me coldly and asked, “Why are you crying?” She reluctantly completed the forms and I left her office, vowing never to ask her to help me again.</p><p>After that upsetting appointment, I found a different doctor to complete the form the following year. To my relief, this doctor was kind and compassionate. But even going through this yearly ritual elicited feelings of anxiety and sadness as I reiterated how my limited vision affected my work, and that my eye condition would not improve. I dreaded this annual appointment.</p><p>However, the disability leave brought many unforeseen benefits and eased my life considerably. I will forever be grateful to Kate for encouraging me to apply for this leave.</p><p><em>Next post: Finding Balance</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9b84c45a08a5" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Dealing With Loss]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/dealing-with-loss-4b4b26f41ef2?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/4b4b26f41ef2</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-disorder]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 13 Feb 2021 01:59:19 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-13T18:49:40.710Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is number 11 in the series <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*pADhedvbwOGpAdS0OyczZA.png" /></figure><p><strong>The Losses Begin</strong></p><p>First, in the summer of 2004, I lost my little island of central vision. Then I lost my father. He had a massive heart attack in August, 2004. It happened so quickly we were not able to see him nor say goodbye. I was not feeling very warm or loving towards him at the time, so his sudden death brought up many strong emotions.</p><p>The next year, in May of 2005, Michael was diagnosed with cancer. He had surgery followed by weeks of radiation, which caused several uncomfortable side effects. I felt that I had lost my strong, healthy, athletic husband of 25 years. I often felt annoyed at his requests for help and comfort and I would sometimes respond with anger. While it is hard to admit, I think at the time I felt (irrationally) angry with him for getting cancer.</p><p>Our 25th wedding anniversary came and went, as neither of us felt like celebrating. The good news is that by the end of the next year, Michael was back to full health and activity, side effects gone. And we celebrated our 25th anniversary a year later with a festive dinner at a historic restaurant in Paris.</p><p>But back to the summer of 2005. Once again, I had to cancel a much- anticipated trip. This one was to New Zealand with my colleague and dear friend and research partner, Bob. I was looking forward to co-chairing our SRTL research gathering at the University of Auckland. Before the meeting, Bob and I were to spend a few days in Tahiti, and then travel with my co-chair, Dani, to the North Island of New Zealand. We had excitedly planned our trip and all our hotels, rental car, and flights had been booked. This time, my eyes were not the cause of the trip cancellation. I needed to stay with Michael as he recovered from surgery and radiation treatments.</p><p><strong>An Unexpected Award</strong></p><p>Because of Michael’s treatments, I would have also cancelled my annual trip to the Joint Statistics meetings, which were always held in early August. However, this year, for the first time the conference would take place in Minneapolis. I was glad to be able to attend some sessions, but was going to skip the big awards ceremony, which was held at night. To my surprise, Michael encouraged me to attend the ceremony because my friend Beth would be made a Fellow that night, and he thought I should be there to support her. Michael even offered to attend with me. This seemed unwise because he was scheduled to receive a radiation treatment that day which usually left him fatigued.</p><p>The afternoon of the ceremony, while I was at the convention center, Michael called and told me some unexpected good news: his treatment that day had been cancelled due to an equipment malfunction. He was feeling good and was on his way to meet me. We sat together at the awards ceremony, and all of a sudden, I heard my name being called. I was being given the Founder’s award, the highest honor for service to the American Statistical Association. I was stunned. Michael walked with me to the stairs and I walked up onto the stage. I received a gift and plaque from the current president, the renowned statistician Brad Efron. Due to my vision disability, the executive director was there to guide me back down the stairs. I felt dazed and quite overcome, as I learned that my friend Chris had nominated me with support from many of my colleagues. After all I had been through, and how hard I had been working, this recognition felt wonderful and validating.</p><p>The winner of the Founder’s award was never disclosed in advance (although Michael had been alerted). If the conference had not been in Minneapolis, I would have missed yet another award from my professional organization, as I did when I became a Fellow in 2002 and missed that ceremony in Atlanta due to my eye surgery. This year, there was a festive party afterwards, organized by some of my friends, and for a while, the summer sadness and feelings of loss disappeared.</p><p><strong>Another Loss</strong></p><p>In the fall of 2005, my daughter Rebecca left home to start a new life in Portland, Oregon. She had graduated from college and had chosen this city as the place to embark on the next phase of her life. Harder than the miles that would separate us was the realization that she was separating from me psychologically. She seemed to constantly question and disapprove of me, espousing her new views of feminism, class, and materialism. My darling daughter, with whom I had been so close for almost 23 years, was now cutting the apron strings, and I could not bear to let go.</p><p>As a result of all these losses, I found myself tearing up with sadness almost daily. My spirits had tumbled. I was trying to keep up my heavy work schedule, nurture Michael, and grieve my father’s death and Rebecca’s impending departure. At some point my wise daughter recommended that I see a therapist.</p><p><strong><em>Next post: Therapy</em></strong></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=4b4b26f41ef2" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Losing My Island]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/losing-my-island-c33b64a5638c?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c33b64a5638c</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[visión]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eyesight]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 04 Feb 2021 15:05:48 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-05T16:44:34.426Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is number 10 in the series <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*7TUpgQyIbWcHWxHcBMfcjA.png" /></figure><p><strong>Why I Was So Driven</strong></p><p>I want to begin by sharing some of my reflections as I look back at the early years of my vision loss. In particular, I’ve pondered why I was so driven to work hard and stay on top of my career despite the visual challenges that made my work more difficult.</p><p>Although I’ve been away from my professional work for nearly five years, I can recall the driving force which compelled me to strive hard in my professional work — namely, the desire to transform the teaching and learning of statistics. In particular, I strove to demonstrate the importance of empirical research as a foundation for better ways to teach students and assess learning.</p><p>When I was completing my doctoral research back in 1980, the field of statistics education did not exist. There were no research journals, books, or scholarly communities to support and disseminate this information. I was fortunate to be part of this new field as it emerged and grew. In the 1990s, more attention began to be paid to statistics education, and I wanted to be involved in every aspect. I was powered by a missionary type of zeal to transform the teaching of statistics. My message was how to enable students to succeed in statistics by focusing on data, activities, and visualization tools. My intention was to make statistics less of a mathematics class, and more of a literacy class. To this day, people regale me with horror stories of the terrible statistics classes they have endured (or failed). I wanted to change these experiences in order to empower students to learn and use statistics in a positive way.</p><p>Because I had a background in mathematics and educational psychology, as well as in statistics, I could communicate with professionals in all these fields. I kept extremely busy presenting at meetings, writing articles for journals, and giving workshops on teaching and assessment methods. I admit to being an overachiever, but it was more about wanting to accomplish the work than just add to my CV. I am proud to say that the students I advised and mentored are now carrying on this work (without me!), which is the best reward of all.</p><p><strong>Back To My Story</strong></p><p>Fast forward from the summer of 2002 to June, 2004.</p><p>I was invited to a special research gathering at Carnegie Mellon University. I was thrilled to participate — to share my research and hear about the cutting-edge work of others. As I sat listening to a presentation, I held up a handout to my right eye to read with my little blurry island of vision. To my surprise and concern, it was much harder to read than previously. An alarm began to sound in my brain: was there more deterioration in my right eye, the one that had begun my vision loss five years earlier?</p><p>After returning home, I went to see my retinal specialist, Dr. Terry, who ran all the usual tests. Afterwards, as we sat together in the room where I had had many laser surgeries, he informed me that he saw nothing different in my eye and that there was nothing he could do. In fact, he told me that he could never figure out why I had that island of vision in my right eye, because the scarring in both eyes looked identical. My island of vision, ironically, had never been visible in any of the pictures taken of my retina.</p><p>I was devastated. The island was disappearing. How could I continue working, reading, and writing without this little island, and why couldn’t Dr. Terry try to restore it? As I pondered this problem, I decided to try to consult with a different retinal specialist.</p><p>I reached out to a colleague in the Psychology Department at the University of Minnesota, Gordon Legge. He was also legally blind, but had less vision than I did. I had read about him in an article that described both his vision loss and his research related to vision disability. I emailed him and asked if I could meet with him for some advice.</p><p>Gordon was welcoming and helpful. I enjoyed hearing his story and telling him mine. I asked him if he had a retinal specialist he liked, and he gave me the names of two specialists whom he knew through the university. When I looked them up, one had left the area, and the other, Dr. Ryan, now worked in a local retinal surgery center. I called Dr. Ryan’s office and made an appointment.</p><p><strong>My New Retinal Specialist</strong></p><p>Dr. Ryan’s office was entirely different than Dr. Terry’s, which was in an ophthalmology center where all types of patients came in, even just for routine eye exams. In contrast, Dr. Ryan’s office served only people with retinal problems. It was smaller and quieter, with mostly elderly patients. There were shorter wait times, which I appreciated. A major difference was that the staff seemed very caring and compassionate, especially while administering tests and procedures. I felt like I had landed in a comforting and kind environment, for which I felt very grateful.</p><p>Dr. Ryan was also a comforting and kind man. After examining my tests and my eye, he told me his assessment. He saw some loose matter floating in my eye that could be blocking the tiny area of my retina that provided the island of vision. He thought it might be a sign of an impending detached retina, this time in my right eye.</p><p>This was upsetting news. I told him I was supposed to travel in a few weeks to a conference in Copenhagen. His response was, “I’m sure you will find a good retinal surgeon in Denmark.” That was not what I wanted to hear. As a result, I cancelled yet another trip overseas so that we could wait and see what might happen to my eye.</p><p>I never did have a detached retina in my right eye, nor did any of the “floating material” disappear. And so I learned to live with the new state of my eyesight. I relied more on magnifiers to enlarge print or read labels. Life went on. I took a sabbatical and used my credit from the cancelled Copenhagen ticket to later fly to Israel to work on a book with Dani, my colleague there. Dr. Ryan became my new retinal specialist and I never returned to Dr. Terry.</p><p><strong>Becoming a Research Subject</strong></p><p>When I met with Gordon and learned about some of his vision-loss research, I agreed to be a subject in his studies. Over the next few years, I participated in three studies. The first was more of a focus group, with about twenty vision-impaired people. We were asked questions about what type of navigation tools might help us find our way during everyday activities. I was interested to find out that compared to the others, I had much more usable vision. It was good emotionally and intellectually to gain that perspective.</p><p>The second study turned out to be quite distressing. It had to do with navigating through a building while blindfolded, after first learning the route I would take. I think I was also spun around on a device so that I would not know in which direction I was going. I was terrible at following the prescribed route and felt close to tears as I realized I could not find my way. I did not return to finish that experiment. I began to realize the emotional and psychological impact my vision loss was having. Eventually I would deal with this when seeing a therapist. And it would lead to an unexpected gift.</p><p><em>Next post: Dealing With Loss</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c33b64a5638c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Dark Curtain Descends]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/a-dark-curtain-descends-958ef26899d8?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/958ef26899d8</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eyesight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-loss]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 23 Jan 2021 20:57:03 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-25T02:35:35.341Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is number 9 in the series <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/609/1*OVMdEPPixiMch6w2apLoQg.png" /></figure><p>It was the spring of 2002. I was back at work full time, teaching two statistics classes, attending faculty meetings, and doing my regular academic work. My vision seemed to have stabilized. I was getting used to my new-normal way of living without central vision. However, I did have a tiny island of faint central vision in my right eye, the one that was never treated. My left eye, which had undergone multiple surgeries, had a little more usable peripheral vision. My brain combined these two types of vision, allowing me to navigate my world.</p><p><strong>Attending a Convention in New Orleans</strong></p><p>Before losing vision in my second eye, I had run for office in my special interest group (SIG) of Educational Statisticians in the American Educational Research Association (AERA). I had won the election, which meant I would serve as program chair for one year and as president for the following year. That meant that during the fall of 2001, amidst the craziness of dealing with vision loss and surgeries, I also had to send out proposals for review, and put together the program for the spring annual meeting. I remember filling every surface of my office with printed-out proposals for papers, posters and symposia, and despairing that I would ever manage the task of having them reviewed and organized into the few sessions we were allotted. There was a lot of paper work to fill out as well, reporting information back to AERA.</p><p>I had two ways of reading materials: holding them up close to my right eye (with its island of central vision) in bright light, or enlarging the font on my computer. Both ways were exhausting and I felt I never should have agreed to take on this task. Then, a miracle saved me. My colleague Mike, whose office was next to mine and who had served in this role a few years earlier, stepped in to help me. He quickly read over and sorted the proposals, and helped decide which to select and how to group them. I was immensely grateful for his help.</p><p>In early April, I set off for New Orleans, another city I had visited many times and knew the area around the convention center well. My recollection is that Michael came with me, which made it easier to travel.</p><p>When it came time for the business meeting, I needed to present the plans for the program and describe the various sessions. In a tremulous voice I told my colleagues that I had been dealing with vision loss and subsequent surgeries. I profusely thanked Mike for his help, and laid out the program. Somehow, I thought the group would think it heroic that I had done this job and come to the conference, despite what I had been going through. I waited for them to acknowledge my efforts to fulfill my job duties, despite all my challenges. To my surprise and disappointment, there were no comments, no applause, and ultimately, no one asking me how I was doing. The meeting ended and off we went to our various sessions. Looking back, I think that people were embarrassed to mention my disability, and perhaps felt it was best to just act as if nothing was out of the ordinary. But in the moment, it did hurt my feelings.</p><p><strong>Trip to France</strong></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*r655VkWYMoVzpC9PrwXZlA.png" /></figure><p>Spring semester ended, and the day arrived for us to embark on our much anticipated trip to France. This trip was to replace the one I was unable to take to South Africa for my beloved conference on teaching statistics. Rebecca, our daughter, was going to join us in France, as well as some friends and my sister and her husband. We spent a few days in Paris, then took the train to Avignon, picked up rental cars, and went to our huge rented stone house surrounded by lime trees and lavender. It was a wonderful trip filled with everything I loved: great food, wine, colors, markets, and spectacular scenery. It felt like a nice reward for making it through a difficult and challenging year.</p><p>I fell in love with Provence and could not wait to plan another trip there. I was hardly aware of my vision loss during my time in France. Of course, it helped that Michael and Rebecca were by my side. I do remember listening to a book on my little cassette player while we were on the train, and at night. And I was still taking eye drops to keep the pressure in my eyes under control. But other than that, this trip allowed me to be more caught up in the beauty of Provence and less focused on my vision loss.</p><p><strong>The Dark Curtain</strong></p><p>A few weeks after we returned home from France, I noticed a dark brown “curtain” at the top of my left field of vision. After a few days, it seemed to be getting bigger, so I called Dr. Terry’s office. I was instructed to come in immediately. Once again, I spent a long time in his waiting room. But once Dr. Terry examined me, he told me that I had a detached retina in my left eye. He did not seem surprised, and thought it was due to the steroid shots he had injected in that eye the previous summer and fall. If untreated, I could go blind. I was booked for surgery the following day.</p><p>The next morning I checked into the Phillips Eye Institute. For the surgery, an IV was inserted to my arm to provide anesthesia to numb my eye (so I could not see out of it at all nor feel any pain) and to sedate me. I remember Dr. Terry telling me that he had to cut off my eyelashes, which made me sad, as I have always liked having long lashes. He said they would mostly grow back over time. They did, but were never as long as they once were.</p><p>I remember drifting in and out of consciousness, not feeling any pain. At some point I became aware that Dr. Terry was operating on my eye while talking to the nurse assisting him. They seemed to be talking about traveling to New Zealand. “I’ve been to New Zealand,” I piped up, attempting to join the conversation. Dr. Terry patted my shoulder and said, “Just be quiet now.” So I closed my mouth and drifted back into unconsciousness.</p><p>Back at home, Harlan arrived from the camp where he was working to be with me as I recovered. And Rebecca was on hand to nurture me in her gentle, loving way. The worst job was given to Michael. He had to open my eye a few times each day and squeeze in different drops. He is normally squeamish, and dealing with an eye that he said looked like chopped meat was a challenge for him. He steeled himself each time, gritted his teeth, and did his best. To this day, I thank him!</p><p>I had to see Dr. Terry the day after surgery so he could check on the status of his intricate reattachment of my retina. I may have had to wear a patch for a while, but I don’t recall. I just remember lying on the couch, aware of people coming and going around me. Harlan was nearby, assembling a wooden wine rack that he had given to me for my birthday. I was relieved to be home and that the ordeal was over.</p><p><strong>Summer</strong></p><p>Somehow, the days passed and my eye healed. A few weeks after the surgery, we were on a plane to New York. Michael’s grandmother had died the previous year, and we were now going to the unveiling of her gravestone. It was hard to believe all that had happened in the year since we attended her funeral.</p><p>On that visit, I remember sitting on the couch in the living room of Michael’s mother’s house, telling his brother and sister-in-law the story of my detached retina. My eye was still red and my eyelashes were gone, but other than that, I was feeling okay.</p><p><strong>Red Spots</strong></p><p>My brother Stan organized a long weekend gathering on Lake Michigan for him and his wife, my sister and her husband, and Michael and me. This was the first time we would be getting together since my vision loss and surgeries, and I looked forward to being with my family. Stan rented rooms for us in a charming guest house near the lake. We spent two relaxing days at the beach luxuriating in the sun, sand and perfect summer weather. During the drive back to Minnesota, I started scratching what seemed to be a bite on my chest. The next day I became aware that the red spot was getting more irritated and spreading. I had had a similar rash 25 years earlier, and it had lasted six weeks, turning my life upside down. No one had ever been able to determine the cause. Now it seemed another horrendous rash was settling in. I was terrified, and called to make an appointment with my doctor.</p><p>The rash was spreading all over my body in big, red, itchy blotches. My doctor gave me some topical ointment and recommended I see a specialist. I was able to make an appointment to see a dermatologist, agonizing each day I had to wait for this appointment. The doctor was puzzled by my rash, and took a skin sample to send to a lab to try to determine if the rash was caused by an organism, possibly picked up while swimming in Lake Michigan.</p><p>The lab provided no answers. Where had this mysterious rash come from? I was in extreme discomfort. The dermatologist prescribed a heavy dose of an antihistamine to take orally that made me sleepy, so I had to drink lots of coffee to get through the days. I also applied huge amounts of a very potent steroid cream. I took oatmeal baths to soothe the itching, lathered on cream, took the pills, and waited for the rash to stop spreading. The red dots had turned into a sea of red covering my entire body, except my face.</p><p>Later, I would figure out that the rash was caused by extended exposure to the sun while taking the post-surgery eye drops that contained sulfa, an antibiotic. Although no one had warned me, I later read that exposure to the sun could possibly cause a reaction which included a rash. Well, it certainly did!</p><p>The rash was getting better but still bothering me when I flew to Madison, Wisconsin for a project meeting. This was the launch of a new grant headed by my good friend Cliff. I was on the advisory board along with several other friends. I always loved visiting Madison (where I had graduated from college) and enjoyed working on projects with Cliff. However, I remember suffering itching and drowsiness during the meetings, and it was often hard to concentrate on discussions.</p><p>To my great relief, over the next few weeks the rash began to fade. Summer progressed, with three more professional trips and presentations. What was I thinking? As I look at my CV and see all the entries for 2002, I wonder why it never occurred me to say no to invitations, to cancel my attendance at conferences, and to give myself time to recover and rest. Somehow, it seemed important to me to prove I could still be peaking career-wise, continuing to excel and achieve in my professional work.</p><p>At the end of the summer, it was time to take Rebecca to college. After delaying a year, she was ready to start her studies at Earlham College in eastern Indiana. We would drive her there and help her settle in. Rebecca and I had spent so much time together during the previous summers and school year that I dreaded our separation. Now Michael and I would have an empty nest for the first time in almost 20 years. And so the next chapter of my life began.</p><p><em>Next post: Losing my island</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=958ef26899d8" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Winter to Spring, 2002]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/winter-to-spring-2002-942b475454ff?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/942b475454ff</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[vision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eyesight]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 10 Jan 2021 19:43:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-10T23:49:09.474Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is the eighth installment of my new blog, <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*uWTaOcXqna7MhCtb6qQfZg.png" /></figure><p><strong>Trip to San Diego</strong></p><p>After a stressful and challenging fall semester, I prepared to return to my fulltime responsibilities as a faculty member at the University of Minnesota. Before classes resumed in late January, I had planned to attend the Joint Mathematics Meetings in San Diego. I had been asked to serve as a discussant for a session on assessment. Also, I was going to help host a lunch for faculty who had attended workshops as part of the “Chance Project” I had worked on with my colleague Laurie. We had held several summer workshops and now had some funds to gather participants and find out what they had used from these workshops in their own teaching. Laurie was a good 25 years older than me, and somewhat of a father figure, as well as a dear friend. We agreed to meet in San Diego, stay at the same hotel, and basically have our meals together and hang out at the conference. That made it easier for me to travel there on my own.</p><p>In addition, I had been to San Diego several times for conferences and felt that I knew the area around the convention center and could find my way around fairly easily. Several of my colleagues from around the country would be there and I would enjoy seeing them (especially after missing the summer statistics meetings).</p><p>I remember flying to California to first visit my brother David, who lived in LA. I used my new monocular at the airport to read signs, and my brother met me at LAX. The next day he drove me to San Diego, where I joined my friends. I remember Laurie misplacing his hearing aids and David staying in order to help Laurie find them (in his bathroom, removed while taking a bath). Then David headed back to LA and I went out to a dinner I had organized with several friends. I felt so normal again! It was great to be back in my professional world.</p><p>I anxiously anticipated my short presentation as a discussant. How would I handle not being able to see the audience or read my slides? However, my extensive advance practice paid off and I was able to do the job. I remember how my friends came up afterwards to tell me I had done just fine. What a relief!</p><p>Throughout the conference, I would hear people call my name and say hello, but I could not see them or know who was talking to me. Once again, this felt frustrating and embarrassing. Many of my colleagues had been worried about me after hearing that I had lost sight in my second eye. But they did not really know or understand the impact this vision loss had on my ability to see and get around. My disability was invisible, and so I tried to let them know what it was like for me. At dinner, I pulled out my big magnifier to read the menu. And sometimes I hed papers up close to my eye to try to read them.</p><p>Being able to carry on my normal professional life was very important to me, and going to this conference was my first attempt to do so. Overall, I felt triumphant that I could navigate my way around the convention center and local area. I was still too nervous to ask for help, so I had to walk up to signs such as those on the restrooms and look closely to make sure I was in the right place. Later in life, I would become more at ease with asking people to point out the ladies room.</p><p><strong>Return to Teaching</strong></p><p>Back in Minneapolis, I was ready to teach my two statistics classes. One was an intro class for graduate students that I had chosen to teach in a computer classroom. This allowed me to project my slides, which were enlarged using ZoomText. I could also demonstrate activities using the statistical software. Just before the semester began, I met Ann, a new student who would be in my class. Once the class started it became clear that she was not only a bright and diligent student, but also a kind and attentive person, always willing to help me with technology issues as they arose. I later asked her to be my research assistant for a new National Science Foundation grant that would last five years. Then I created a post doc position for her when I received an extension to the grant. Since leaving the University of Minnesota, Ann has had a successful career in London, where I visit her whenever I am in the UK.</p><p><strong>Hosting a Workshop</strong></p><p>For some reason that I can no longer recall, I had organized a workshop during the winter of 2002. This would bring my colleagues Allan and Beth to town to lead activities from their new textbook, as well as Bill, who had developed the software used in the textbook. The workshop was to be all day on Saturday and would be held in the computer lab where I was teaching my statistics class. I must have applied for funding for the workshop, or perhaps the publisher covered the cost. At any rate, I filled the room with local statistics educators.</p><p>Although the day went well, we did have a rough start. Somehow, I managed to set off the security alarm when opening the door. There was a sheet of paper attached to the wall, with instructions about what to do and whom to call if the alarm went off. However, I could not read the instructions because I could not get the paper close enough to my eyes. I finally managed to get someone to read the phone number to me and I called the person in charge, who came to our rescue. After that, things improved and I enjoyed interacting with the local teachers as well as spending time with Allan and Beth.</p><p><strong>Planning Future Travel</strong></p><p>As a result of successfully navigating the conference in San Diego I decided to proceed with plans to attend more conferences that spring and summer. There would be three in the spring as well as a presentation at a local college. My professional duties began to increase as Program Chair of my special interest group (Educational Statisticians) for AERA and Chair-Elect of the ASA Section on Statistics Education. I was also serving as Vice-President of the newly formed International Association for Statics Education (IASE). If that wasn’t enough, I received a call from the chair of the United States Commission on Mathematics Instruction (USCMI), inviting me to be considered for appointment to this prestigious committee of the national Research Council. At first I tried to decline, citing my vision disability and that I would not be able to read materials. However, the chair managed to convince me to change my mind. I would not have to read many materials in advance. And they needed someone to represent statistics education as well as be a female. That would be me. Serving on this committee for the next six years meant two trips a year to meet with the group. So I was agreeing to more solo travel for the years to come.</p><p>I had been planning the research program for The International Conference on Teaching Statistics (ICOTS) to be held that summer in South Africa. Now, I realized that I could not travel there alone. It was one thing to go to San Diego on my own, meeting friends there. But South Africa involved more logistics and I did not have anyone to travel with me. Michael had no interest in going to South Africa, and my close friend and colleague at the U of M was not planning to attend. So, I reluctantly informed the program committee I would not be traveling to Durban. Again, I suffered a big disappointment, as I had regularly attended the ICOTS every 4 years since 1990, and had many friends I would see there.</p><p>Instead, Michael agreed to plan a trip with me that was not work-related. I had been pining for France. Michael and I had been to Paris in 1995 and now I wanted to travel with him to Provence. I had been dreaming of going to the land of lavender and olive groves, not to mention Rhone wines. Michael agreed to go with me on a trip to Paris and Provence, and the planning began for a trip in late spring.</p><p><strong>Creating a New Graduate Program</strong></p><p>During the previous year I had created a new graduate program that focused exclusively on Statistics Education. A unique aspect of this program was that it would offer training and experience in research on the teaching and learning of statistics. This graduate program was the first of its kind at a university, and required me to recruit students and propose and prepare new courses. I was excited to launch the program, but nervous about doing it alone, and worried about attracting students. Now with my vision disability, I was even more unsure about whether I could successfully start and run the program.</p><p>Luckily, I received a strong application and I eagerly accepted my first doctoral student, Andy, into the new program for the fall of 2002. I created three courses, submitted them for approval, and began publicizing them to attract other students so I could fill the seats and have a critical mass of students. Fast forward to 2020: The program has outlasted me! My colleague Bob now runs the program. We have had many wonderful students earn their doctorates in Statistics Education and take academic jobs around the world. I couldn’t be more proud of this program that had its beginnings during a time of life-altering changes.</p><p>And so the winter eventually turned into spring, and I became more familiar and comfortable with my “new normal” as a vision-disabled person. How I used my eyes and dealt with visual input had changed, but my workaholic and overachieving way of life had not. It would be a number of years before I admitted that I could not keep up all the projects and responsibilities I had taken on nor could accomplish as much as I did before losing my central vision.</p><p>N<em>ext post: A Dark Curtain Descends</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=942b475454ff" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Adapting and Making Changes]]></title>
            <link>https://joangarfield.medium.com/adapting-and-making-changes-c50f3e40b894?source=rss-9cef952f4167------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/c50f3e40b894</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[vision-loss]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[low-vision]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[disability]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[eyesight]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joan Garfield]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sun, 03 Jan 2021 16:50:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-01-05T03:01:47.376Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h3>Winter 2002: Adapting and Making Changes</h3><p>This is the seventh installment of my new blog, <em>Vision: A Journey</em></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/624/1*iiZ8e6LV5Zl1KfuT3hwkaw.png" /></figure><p><strong>Learning to Adapt</strong></p><p>Anyone who has lost or partially lost an ability (e.g., to see, hear, walk, etc.) has to learn (or relearn) how to live without that ability or live with reduced functionality. I think I went through three main stages of adaptation to living with a vision disability.</p><p>The first stage was learning what I could no longer do. For example, I would try to read a sign and realize with frustration that I could not see it.</p><p>The second stage was figuring out how to compensate. For example, I would search my purse for my monocular and put it to my eye to read a street sign. Or, when trying to read a menu, reach for my lighted hand magnifier. I often felt conspicuous using these tools and embarrassed for needing them.</p><p>The third stage was automatically doing what I needed to do (using a tool or asking for help) without even thinking about it. At that point, I had fully adapted and integrated these changes into my daily life.</p><p>The areas in which I needed to adapt and make changes included the following:</p><p>1. <strong>Independence.</strong> I was used to doing things on my own — traveling alone, driving myself around town. Now, I felt dependent on others, especially Michael, to give me rides and travel with me. I felt I needed someone to be my eyes, guiding me through airports, reading menus to me at dinner, and chauffeuring me to work or to stores. I felt fearful of taking buses and taxis because of having to see and handle money, keep track of where I was going, and needing to ask for help.</p><p>One of the things I had to work hard on was telling people I could not see (often saying I had “bad eyes” — later, I would say that I had low vision or I was vision-disabled) and asking for help. Many years later I would become adept at taking buses all over the Twin Cities and calling Uber. Also, as part of my new “walking practice,” I learned to walk many places instead of driving or even taking the bus. So feeling independent eventually returned.</p><p>I made appointments with both a low-vision optometrist and an occupational therapist to help me live more independently. In addition to being outfitted with the monocular and lighted hand magnifier, I bought special double-lens glasses to watch TV and a glasses attachment to use for reading.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/550/1*X1T-ITUyGv6Q2Mslb26LgA.png" /><figcaption>Some of my new low vision aids</figcaption></figure><p>I also learned about OTT lights, which have a more natural, bright light that enabled me to see better. I bought and installed several of these lights around the house. Most valuable of all was being taught to consciously change my visual focus. I found that if I looked above the object of interest (e.g., someone’s face) rather than at it (which showed only a grey blur), I could see that object with my peripheral vision. After a while, this process became automatic. Now, I always look above what I am trying to see. My brain has somehow adapted and even manages to coordinate the vision from my two eyes, which is quite different.</p><p>2. <strong>Reading.</strong> I had been an avid reader all my life. Now, although I could hold up a book close to my right eye, which had the little faint island of central vision, I could not actually read a book any more. I used to love reading magazines, but could no longer read their tiny print. To read a newspaper, I scanned the headlines. That was all I could see.</p><p>My sister Ann, a librarian, signed me up for the Library for the Blind, which sent me a big clunky cassette player and cassette tapes with recorded books. The first two recorded books I received were both memoirs written by people who were blind. I listened with interest, but after two of those I was ready for some good fiction! I was able to request and receive books of my own choice. Many were quite good, but others were read by narrators with wavering voices who sounded quite elderly. There were often pronunciation errors that irritated me.</p><p>Therefore, I started to buy commercial audio books, also on cassettes, that were read by professional narrators and actors. I would carry a portable cassette player with me whenever I traveled so I could listen to my books. Later, as technology improved, I would switch to digital downloaded books and listen to them on my iPod or phone. I was even able to subscribe to the audio version of my favorite magazine, <em>The New Yorker</em>, for several years, until they stopped producing an audio version.</p><p>The silver lining in listening to books as compared to reading them is that I developed a greater appreciation for good writing. Listening allowed me to focus on the writer’s language and style. When I read books visually, I often focused on the plot, and raced through them quickly to see how a story played out. Today, I love listening to books and magazine articles while running, walking, or lying in bed before going to sleep.</p><p>3. <strong>Shopping.</strong> I have always loved going to grocery stores and markets. Now I had trouble finding products and reading labels. I would have to hold an item close to my right eye to read a label or price, and I was often frustrated by not being able to see what items were on top shelves. When Michael came with me, I could ask him to help. But he was often in a hurry, while I wanted to linger and see what was new or interesting. Now in 2020, during the pandemic, I find it easier to order food online because I can search for items easily and read labels by enlarging the font.</p><p>4. <strong>Teaching.</strong> I was the kind of teacher who always learned my students’ names and tried to get to know them as people. Now I had to figure out how to see their faces, recognize a raised hand, and even read my own overhead slides. Fortunately, I was able to hold the textbook up close to my eye when I needed to refer to a problem. I began teaching in a computer lab where I could use ZoomText on my computer to demonstrate software activities. But when students asked me to look at their screens when something went wrong, I was often helpless. I needed an in-class TA to help me. Luckily I was able to find a good person for this job.</p><p>5. <strong>Exercise.</strong> I had been a runner for over 20 years, and had often belonged to a gym where I took exercise classes and went swimming. I had not been doing either since my vision problems began. After the winter holidays in 2001, I realized with horror that I had managed to gain over 30 pounds during the previous few years. I wanted to get back in shape but was not sure how.</p><p>My friend Kathryn had joined Curves, which she enjoyed, so Rebecca and I went to check it out and I signed us both up for a circuit training exercise program. Rebecca showed me what to do and having her there enabled me to get back into exercising again. I enjoyed Curves and shed some extra pounds, but Rebecca lost interest after a few months and stopped going (it was mostly middle-aged women). It was harder for me to go on my own, as it was about eight blocks from my house and the streets and sidewalks were full of snow and ice. I did not feel confident walking there and no one was available to give me rides. I decided to quit Curves and buy a good treadmill to use at home.</p><p>Finally, I was ready to return to running. When the weather improved, I started running outside again, and many years later joined the YWCA, where I have enjoyed many classes as well as swimming. There, my visual challenge was to determine where there was an open lane to swim, and I have learned to ask for help in identifying a free lane. In classes I have learned to tell instructors about my vision disability and to stay in the front row where I can better follow the teacher. Happily, I have a full exercise routine again.</p><p>6. <strong>Sewing and Cooking.</strong> I had been quilting for a few years and had a huge collection of fabrics, quilt books and related materials. Now it was hard for me to thread a needle or line up pieces of fabric to follow a pattern. I had to learn to change my style of quilting, to improvise more and not follow precise patterns. I also decided to buy a new machine that had a self-threading needle attachment, which worked well.</p><p>The main problem with cooking was reading recipes in cookbooks, especially looking up recipes in the index. I ended up giving away many cookbooks and searching for recipes online that I could enlarge to read or print.</p><p>7. <strong>Playing music.</strong> I had taken many years of classical violin, and later viola, lessons. I had boxes of scoresheet music, as well as my father’s violin and my own viola. Now I could no longer read music. I felt terrible about the prospect of losing all those years of training and playing. Then on a trip to Ireland, while enjoying a musical pub crawl, I talked to an Irish fiddler. He told me he had learned to play without music, just by ear. Back home, I was inspired to find a teacher who taught me to play the Irish fiddle by ear. I took lessons for several months, and was grateful to a friend who drove me to lessons and patiently waited for me. But when she stopped offering rides, I found it too difficult to take the bus on my own, so I had to end the lessons. But another pandemic silver lining is that I now play music each week on Face time with my sister, mostly playing by ear.</p><p><strong>Trip to San Diego</strong></p><p>After a stressful and challenging fall semester, I prepared to return to my fulltime responsibilities as a faculty member at the University of Minnesota. However, before classes resumed in late January, I planned to attend the Joint Mathematics Meetings in San Diego. This would be my first time traveling alone and attending a professional conference after losing my central vision. The planning and anticipation began!</p><p><em>Next post: Winter to Spring</em></p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=c50f3e40b894" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>