<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Joel Miller on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Joel Miller on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@joelmiller_66981?source=rss-2f41ee545fd3------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 13:29:00 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@joelmiller_66981/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Test]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joelmiller_66981/test-2ebd62b9671c?source=rss-2f41ee545fd3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/2ebd62b9671c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joel Miller]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 09 Feb 2017 21:53:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-02-09T21:53:25.508Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Test</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=2ebd62b9671c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Free Market Argument]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@joelmiller_66981/the-free-market-argument-9443de9b1399?source=rss-2f41ee545fd3------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9443de9b1399</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Joel Miller]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2015 06:31:59 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-12-07T01:01:21.553Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>This is a writing that was inspired by a video posted by my good friend Ricky Gallardo. This may take an hour or so to go through, but I hope that you will find the time and provide feedback. Iron Sharpens Iron, the only way we learn is from intellectual discussion and debate. Thank you to all who take the time and read our thoughts. The following was our discussion that lead to this writing. It all started with the second video, the first video is also mentioned in “The Free Market Argument”.</p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/embed/0zq-2cKENOc"><em>Video #1</em></a></p><p><a href="https://youtu.be/ufpsxQwPP1Y?list=PLy7b0WAdq5oTOPIi9k21vkGO_f8WFvPcL"><em>Video #2</em></a></p><p><strong>Epilog:</strong></p><p><strong>Ricky Gallardo:</strong> I see the argument you’re making here, about free market and regulation, the problem is sometimes we do need to be protected from ourselves, and with that I include corporate interests that hinge on the bottom line as opposed to safety or ethical concerns. Even today corporations are caught padding the bottom line with cheap parts and lies. We have for profit prisons, for profit policing, and for profit medical interests in this country that are creating a rift amongst the classes and instead of protecting us from the dark side of human nature, they’re exhibiting it.</p><p><strong>Joel Miller:</strong> I disagree. One I don’t need protection from myself nor do I believe you do. I was raised by my parents and no longer need them. In a true Liberty state, corporations that cheat will enevitebly lose. Their customers will eventually learn and a competitor will offer the same product for a better price or a better product for the same price. As it is today, X operations can cheat and get away with it because we have allowed the government to impose so many regulations on every thing from hair salons to medicine that no other person can afford to compete with the existing corporations allowing them to monopolize their industry and hide behind the guise of public safety. These regulations therefore are the cause of the corporations unethical behavior with employee pay and product services. Yes a free market system isn’t perfect, but it is much quicker at fixing wrongs than a planned market. You should read Hayek’s books regarding this concept. The free market seems to be wild and uncontrolled when in fact a true free market is very orderly and safer than any planned market could hope to be.</p><p><strong>Ricky Gallardo:</strong> Corporations that cheat will inevitably lose, and how many are hurt along the way? The idea that allowing the corporations to police themselves is akin to letting the patients run the asylum. I understand that a nanny-state is unappealing and leaves the door open to the tyrrant our founding fathers feared, but the truth is too much of anything can be harmful, too much regulation, too much freedom, they both lead down roads to ruin. Balance is where the answers lay. Theoritcal free markets may be based on logically sound principles and when applied on a small scale will probably work as you stated, but theories are just that, and almost never play out as planned because the real world has the unpredictable human element to contend with. Everyone has to buy in and everyone has to hold themselves to an ethical standard that is on par with the responsibility a completly free market puts on those that participate, unfortunately, human nature and greed show us that we aren’t a society with sufficient enlightenment to be given that much freedom. I don’t advocate that our government be in total control, and like you I believe our government is the problem. Civil service should be a duty, not a lifetime paycheck. Terms should be short and limited, the pay for that service should be supplemental in nature, not primary. But much as the government is constructed so that the branches check and balance eachother, so too should corporations be checked and balanced. You say the market would do that inherently, cheaters will be pushed out by the consumers, but what if the consumers decide that as long as the price is low, the means to achieve that price are acceptable? Sociologically speaking, its easier to be corrupted en masse than individually.</p><h4><strong>The Free Market Argument by Joel Miller:</strong></h4><p>Sorry for the delay in the response. My time is little these days. So I have responded to your argument line by line.</p><p>First, however, I think we should clear up some definitions. 1.) Greed vs Self-Interest and 2.) Majority rule.</p><p>Self-Interest — Webster says is a concern only for getting what you want or need and not about what happens to other people or your own interest or advantage.</p><p>Greed — Webster says is a selfish desire to have more of something (especially money).</p><p>So…what is the difference? Adam Smith, in the Wealth of Nations, states that the invisible hand leads mankind to a better society by his own self-interest. In which case self-interest is a good thing rather than a bad. Greed, on the other hand, is noted in the bible, and other theological writings, as a mortal sin. In which case greed is a bad thing rather than good.</p><p>Self-interest is the undeniable human nature to full fill one’s own needs, wants, and desires which inherently have no limits. Self-Interest is the value in which socialist run on. They run in order to meet the self-interest of the laborers and the people. They promise, as all politicians do (including the classical liberal or libertarian), a better outcome for the self-interest of their constituents. They must, because if they argue to take from the constituents, it becomes bad politics. Therefore, they make these promises to meet the self-interest of the people in order to meet their own self-interest of being elected into office and thereby obtaining the power to change. Self-Interest is undeniable, and unbeatable. I will go into more detail later, but for now I just want to point out the difference between self-interest and greed.</p><p>Greed, then, is self-interest spun out of control. It is self-interest to the point of violating the basic rules of society in order to achieve. It is self-interest at such a high point that one is willing to lie, cheat, steal, and assault for it.</p><p>Greed thereby, is a mortal sin whereas self-interest is not. In fact self-interest is a necessity for life. Self-interest has no upper limits so long as the general societal rules are abided by. Self-interest in a free market is the limiter of greed.</p><p>When I discuss majority rule, or use the word majority in this writing, I would be remiss if I didn’t define what I mean by that word. Majority indicates that more than 50% agree to one item or idea. When given more than two people and more than two options, this “majority” rule, as described above, is almost impossible to reach. The larger the group and the more available options, the closer to impossible this concept becomes. I’ll provide a brief example. Jack, Bill, and Marry must have lunch together as a business meeting. They have no choice but to attend this lunch. They all have the same rank in the business and are on equal grounds, thereby have equal say on where to go. Jack loves the seafood place, Bill is very fond of the Mexican restaurant, and Marry frequents the hamburger joint. All the restaurants are about the same proximity from their office and none require any additional cost, transactional or otherwise. Marry though can’t stand the seafood place, she once got a bad deal there and just hates it. Jack doesn’t mind the Mexican restaurant but refuses to go to the burger joint as he is on a diet and sees fried foods as the mortal enemy to his health. Bill has no preference except he doesn’t get to have Mexican that often and it is his most absolute favorite food. So…where are they to go. They make a vote. Jack obviously votes for the seafood while Bill votes for Mexican and Marry of course votes for hamburgers. Well, we have no majority and no winner, so someone must compromise, but who? Well as our story goes, Bill is most likely to be the decision maker since his preference is the least emotional. Bill then decides with Jack and so now Marry and Bill are forced to eat seafood, apparently by “majority” vote. However, had Jack not been included hamburgers would have been the choice, and even then only by compromise.</p><p>Majority rule only gets more complicated as we add more people and options to the mix, thereby making it a façade of Majority Rule. This is why it has been so difficult in the American political system to enter a third party. A third party ads a third option and therefore no one majority would be awarded an election win. There would never be a larger than 50% vote, the winner would be determined by who had the most votes, not the majority votes. This concept is actually a mathematical equation, therefore it is an irrefutable fact. This concept is very important when arguing for a free market society as the free market generally excludes the need for the majority rule façade.</p><p>On to the arguments:</p><p><em>“Corporation[s] that cheat will inevitably lose, and how many are hurt along the way?” </em>— Well, very much less in a free market as opposed to a planned one. Entrepreneurs in a free market are present to correct errors. That is, if a corporation begins to act in ways that are not consistent with its customers’ wants and desires, or, it begins to “hurt” them, an entrepreneur will be at the ready to take the said corporation’s customers as his own in order to make his own profit. He will, in return, correct the error that the original corporation made. If the original corporation does not respond to correct their own errors, they will then go out of business. The entrepreneur will then have to maintain his superior service to the customers or be threatened by another entrepreneur who will correct his mistakes in the same manner that he corrected the original corporation. This all happens automatically, there is no select group of “experts” to determine this action. There are no court proceedings, no committee hearings, or public petitions to fix this error as in a planned market. Therefore the error is corrected much quicker and with less public cost than in a planned market. In the case of physical injury or broken contracts, these issues would have to be presented in a civil court process as I will discuss in detail later in this writing.</p><p><em>“The idea that allowing corporations to police themselves is akin to letting the patients run the asylum.”</em> — I totally agree. Where I think we differ is what constitutes corporations policing themselves. It appears that you believe the policing of corporations is the duty of government. I will argue that the government, as so pointed out by the pretty girl in the video, is controlled by the corporations through campaign contributions and the like. She is very correct. In a planned market, the few elected officials, that being 543 federally elected officials, do not have the technical knowledge to control the corporations. Though a few may have come from a private field they are just a single voice of the 543 people. So what are they to do? Well….what they have done is appoint industry professionals to regulate, or police, those industries and the corporations that operate within them. These professionals usually come from the very industries that are supposed to be policed. Even on the occasions in which the appointed regulatory agency is presided over by long time public officials, who will also face the same dilemma as the elected officials of not having the needed technical knowledge, they are advised by staffers who always come from the prospective industries. Who else can tell us how to build bridges other than bridge builders, tell us who good doctors are who are not doctors, advise us on banking policy who are not bankers. The current regulators, just to name a few, are Tom Wheeler of the FCC who was previously the “CEO of several high tech companies, including the first company to offer high speed delivery of data to home computers and the first digital video satellite service.” — FCC Website. The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission Chairman Timothy G Massad was previously “a partner in the law firm of Cravath, Swaine &amp; Moore, LLP. Mr. Massad had a broad corporate practice with a focus on corporate finance and financial markets.” — USCFTC website. Farm Credit Administration Board Member Dallas P. Tonsager “in partnership with his brother, he [Tonsager] owns Plainview Farm in Oldham, a family farming operation that includes corn, soybeans, wheat, and hay.” — FCA website. I could go on, and yes I just looked these up, it was that easy. Almost all of the directors or board members of these “corporate police” agencies are from the very corporations they are appointed to police. It is also not uncommon, in particular with the financial agencies like the Federal Reserve Bank, for the directors and board members to return to these corporations after their federal tenure, with hefty salaries attached.</p><p>In a free market, the corporations do not police themselves. There are no federally appointed, unelected regulators. In fact there are no limiting regulations at all. This allows the entrepreneur discussed in the first paragraph the ability to open competitive businesses without the need of impossibly high capitol in order to meet the regulatory standards as set by the very people whom the entrepreneur would be competing against. In a free market, the entrepreneur and the consumers are much more likely to do real policing rather than allowing the patients to run the asylum under the guise of “public safety.” Just to be clear, public safety is important, and would be addressed in a free market by the entrepreneur, consumers, and the civil court system as I will discuss later.</p><p><em>“I understand that a nanny-state is unappealing and leaves the door open to the tyrant our founding fathers feared, but the truth is too much of anything can be harmful, too much regulation, too much freedom, they both lead down roads to ruin. Balance is where the answers lay.” </em>— Again I agree, however, the U.S. is unbalanced today in the way of regulation and socialism rather than the way of free markets and liberty. The 2015 Index of Economic Freedom as found on heritage.org of The Heritage Foundation, shows the U.S. to be 12th in the world of free nations. This index is computed by counting the number of regulations and laws that each country has passed. It regards economic performance, Government Spending, and Fiscal Policy to name a few. “The regulatory burden has been mounting. Since 2009, over 150 new major regulations have been imposed at an annual cost of more than $70 billion. As of 2014, 125 new regulations were in the pipeline. The labor market primarily regulated at the state level, remains feasible. Subsides for agriculture, heath care, and renewable energy have bred economic distortions” — The Heritage Foundation study.</p><p>Now, I’m not big on studies either, and I am fully aware that they can often times be cherry picked and different variables can be left out or not considered, and often times in order to achieve a political stronghold. However, it seems to me that The Heritage Foundation just simply looks at the numbers and compares them to other nations.</p><p>The 113th congress passed 108 laws, and that was a slow year. 108 laws to be added to what is believed to be a total of at least 3,000 criminal offenses and an unknown amount of other legislation that encompasses 50 titles and at least 23,000 pages of federal law in the U.S. Code as off the 1980’s. Why have I not more precisely demonstrated the amount of laws in existence? “Trying to tally this number [of total federal enforceable laws] is nearly impossible” — Library of Congress (blogs.loc.gov).</p><p>Milton Friedman once stated to a hall full of business men, and I roughly quote, “If ignorance to the law is no excuse, then we are all felons.” This is because no one, not even the library of congress, knows all of the written laws, any of which, if found by some lawyer, or self-interested DOJ Attorney General, could be enforced and prosecuted. FA Hayek made a great insight when he separated Law from Legislation. In today’s world we have combined the two words into one, which we call Law. Hayek separated them by calling them “Rules” and “Commands.”</p><p>Hayek argued that “Rules”, or Law, are spontaneous and organic. They are self-made. The rules are ideas of how society works and discovered by society itself rather than invented by any one person, committee, or elected body. They consist of three elements, 1.) They are known and certain, not retroactive, 2.) They apply to everyone equally, and 3.) They retain a private sphere. He argues that in the beginning there were small hunter-gather groups of people. These small societies learned that killing each other was not conducive to their society. They learned that stealing each other’s property, primarily when dealing with their neighboring societies, forged war and unhappiness amongst all. They learned that trade amongst the various small societies went well when both parties obtained something they desired. They experimented with these rules. Rules that worked lasted, the ones that didn’t fell away. The small hunter-gathering societies who had the best rules lived and expanded, while the other’s fell apart and died off along with their bad rules. Rules are still, to this day, a living entity, therefore are still being discovered as our population grows and adapts. Deadly pollution could be an example. It is a violation of life and liberty for one person to poison the drinking water of another, as a more modern example.</p><p>I’ll provide an illustrative example, as was made on Russ Roberts’s pod cast “Econo Talk” from the School of Economics and Liberty at George Mason University. Let’s say the Texas State legislators decided, amongst all their wisdom, to take the criminal charge of murder off the books. What would happen? Would everyone start murdering everyone else? No, they would not. It would not be safe to unduly murder your neighbor, for murder is no longer a punishable act by the government. This means if you did murder your neighbor, your other neighbors, in their own self-interest, would murder you. They would do so to ensure the safety of their neighborhood. In fact I think we would see a dramatic lowering of the murder rate in the state of Texas.</p><p>So, why put it on the books to begin out with? Because of due process of law. It was arguably the Eastern Roman Empire who began writing down these unwritten and organic rules. They didn’t write them all down, but the important ones, such as the ones protecting life, liberty, and property. They did not make the rules up arbitrarily or invent them, they simply wrote down the rules that were already practiced in an unwritten manner. They figured if you can go to jail for it, we should write it down. This concept evolved into what we call today “Law”, and law provides due process. Today, if you murder your neighbor in the state of Texas, the state will find you and will murder you through Capital Punishment. It’s the same concept as mentioned in our pretend world earlier, but it is done through the due process of law. Your judge, jury and executioner is no longer your neighbors who heard about you murdering your neighbor, but rather a bona fide police force, through investigation, and trial by jury that leads to conviction.</p><p>Hayek referred to “Legislation” as “Commands”. He argued that commands are invented or made up by a single person, committee or elected body. Commands then order the public administrators, public being government, on how to run their business. These commands, unlike “Rules”, generally order a person to do something. This is in contrast to “rules” that generally order a person to not do something. The rule is, “don’t steal your neighbors stuff”, whereas the command is “you must have a license to perform medical surgery.” Command legislation is often times enacted not by the elected officials but rather an appointed agency of unelected officials. These agencies are often times headed by very few individuals, the FCC being only four board members and one Chair. These few people now have unaccountable power over entire industries of commerce. Legislation, or commands, are not always bad, but should be passed with a great deal of concern and caution. When we begin to demand that our citizens take certain actions, we need to ensure they are few, like pay taxes, conscribe to the military in time of war, issues revolving around neighborhood effects, etc.</p><p>Considering the countless amount of laws and legislation passed by the U.S. Congress mentioned earlier (of which do not even include the regulatory commands), the balance is tipped much further towards a planned society than a free society. We have way too much command legislation leading us to a “less free society” as the Heritage Foundation stated.</p><p><em>“Theoretical free markets may be based on logically sound principles and when applied on a small scale will probably work as you stated, but theories are just that, and almost never play out as planned because the real world has the unpredictable human element to contend with.” </em>— Free markets have not been fully lived since at least 1913, some might argue since the U.S. Civil War. In 1913 the U.S. enacted the Federal Reserve Bank whose primary purpose was to control the stock of money, the actual dollar bills, in the market. They were also tasked to regulate the credit system in America by setting national interest rates. There has never been such an invasion by the federal government into the free market system as this.</p><p>The control of the monetary system could be a legit act of the government, though many argue not. Money is the same as any other commodity, a thing that is worth something else. Therefore, it is subject to the same economic principals as say wheat, oil, sugar, wood, water, or gold (as in the gold standard), to name a few. It too is subject to the rules of supply and demand. Where there is too much, the value goes down, to little the value goes up. To high of a value means many poor folks and unemployment as there simply isn’t enough to go around. To low of a value means many poor people as well because they all have more dollar bills, but they’re not worth anything. Some argue for private banks to distribute their own currency. The argument proceeds that the banks would have a great self-interest of ensuring the value of their money stays in a good balance. They want as much of their money on the market as possible, but no so much that another bank’s money becomes more valuable than theirs. They would have to constantly watch the pricing system in order to know when to print more money or when to pull money out of the market. This would ensure that the currency in America has the highest values and enough is there to keep up with economic growth. This is why income inequality is not an issue when ran correctly. Income is not a zero sum game, as American income grows, so should the stock of money. Therefore the rich get richer and the poor get richer. I, however, am not completely sold on the private monetary policy. I do think the government should be the sole printer of dollar bills due to the issues of counterfeit and consumer simplicity. Yes, consumers could look at daily newspapers to see how their bank’s money is exchanging with the other’s (Bank of America’s dollars compared to Chase Bank Dollars) in order to know the true price of the products they buy. I think this would become too complicated and cause more confusion. Therefore, I agree with federal control of the dollar bill, however, I do not agree with the Federal Reserve arbitrarily printing dollar bills. There should be an algorithm that determines when and how many dollar bills are too be printed. This mathematical equation could consider many empirical facts of the economy such as unemployment, total population, bank deposits, bank withdraws, just to name a few. I am far from an economist or mathematician, so I would have to leave it to ALL of the academics to find that equation. Once it is agreed upon, the FED would then no longer print money arbitrarily, but rather under a strict threshold which could not be altered. Milton Friedman made this same type of argument in “Capitalism and Freedom”, only he suggest a flat increase rate based on total expenditures at about three to five percent per year.</p><p>The credit on the other hand, should be solely controlled by the private market. Just as dollars bills are a commodity, so is credit. Interest rates are the price of money. Ideally, when you borrow money you hope to have a return larger than the interest rate, or the cost of borrowing the money. It is beyond my comprehension why the government should have the sole monopoly on the price of money. Interest, like the dollar bill, is subject to supply and demand. If many people are wanting to borrow money then the interest rate would go up. When few want to borrow money, the interest rate would go down. If Bank of America is making many loans at 2.5%, then Chase Bank would start charging 2.7% in response. If Chase continues to make plenty of loans at this rate, BoA would naturally move their rate to 2.8%. This cycle would continue until people began to no longer apply for and obtain loans. At this point the rates would go down until they found the actual current market value for money.</p><p>This has never been tested, at least not in our time, our parent’s time, grandparents, or even perhaps our great grandparents. The government has been controlling the market since 1913. So in response to your argument, theoretical free markets have never recently been applied.</p><p>To refresh your line of argument, <em>“…when applied on a small scale will probably work as you stated, but theories are just that, and almost never play out as planned because the real world has the unpredictable human element to contend with.”</em> — Planned markets are only workable in small scale, large scale markets require either free markets or totalitarian pre planned markets. Let’s go back to the hunter and gathers. Inside their little group, usually consisting of about forty people or so, it was not uncommon for everyone to work for the whole community. There would be a person in charge and some form of hierarchy leading down. Most all decisions were made from the top-down perspective and usually things worked out well. Everyone worked because the top-down system required them to. They were easily policed and if someone refused then they would be excommunicated from the group in whatever way the group saw fit. The top man was not a tyrant because he would usually listen to the wants and desires of the whole group. Without their support, after all, he would lose his position and the group would quickly replace him. This worked well because the group was small. The top man would have time to listen to most all of the group members. The top man knew them personally like a father would know his children. Members didn’t mind sharing their hunt or gather as they knew the other members were working as well to build shelter or something that allowed the group to survive. These groups did generally well in a planned environment. In fact a free market environment may have been detrimental in such a small group.</p><p>In a large society, this pre planned system begins to break down. We have several people as the top man, the 543 elected officials, who appoint regulators and pass all those laws and legislations. Bear in mind the U.S. has all but completely centralized the political powers to the federal government, and many seem to argue for even more centralization. Given the 320 million population, the leader to citizen ratio is 0.0002%. To put that number in perspective, if we divided the nation into 543 parts, one for each elected official, and they all worked 40 hour weeks for 52 weeks of the year, they could only spend 15 seconds with each of their constituents. 15 seconds, long enough to say hi, shake hands, and move to the next person. This is a far cry from the small group as discussed earlier. I can’t see that this sort of top-down leadership of a very large planned society is anywhere near as effective or fair as a decentralized government and free market. Even when the government is further decentralized we see high leader to citizen ratios. When adding the state elected officials to the federal officials, roughly 9,693 elected officials, the ratio goes down to 0.003%. When adding the City elected officials, totaling about 500,000 elected officials the ratio is at 0.16%. I will discuss the governmental decentralization in more detail later in this writing.</p><p>The central leadership in a planned society must be small in numbers (as close to a single leader as possible). If the central leadership in a planned economic society gets to large it will as you stated, “almost never play out as planned because the real world has the unpredictable human element to contend with.” The leaders themselves are human and will inevitably disagree on what the plan is or how it should be implemented. Therefore the leadership would have to get more and more centralized so that a single plan can be made and executed. The people, as stated above, would no longer be able to express their wants and desires to the top leaders as they could in the small society. Thereby, free market and decentralized government is imperative for the large society, or a totalitarian government must be formed in order to make and execute the central plan. The smaller the society then, the more likely pre planned markets and centralized governments are to work, without the real threat of totalitarianism. Unlike the small hunter-gather group of 40 people or so, replacing the top leader of 320 million people is close to impossible. There is also an information dilemma that is faced by the centralized leaders in a planned market as I will discuss shortly.</p><p>It was also argued on Russ Roberts’s pod cast, that in fact, the smaller the unit, the more need for planned action. The family is the base unit of microeconomics which is the basis of macroeconomics. Therefore, the family unit is the base of the U.S. Economy. The family must be ran in a planned socialistic way. The parents being the top leaders and going down to the youngest aged child. The family must work towards a planned common goal. Mom and Dad go to work and make the money that buys the food. In return, little Chris and his sister Janet do their chores of cleaning the home and doing their homework in order to participate in a free market society later in life. Chris and Janet don’t have many choices as Mom and Dad make all the decisions based on their plan for the family. Mom and Dad often times allow Chris and Janet to speak their minds and express their wants and desires, but the final decisions lay with the parents. Should Mom and Dad decide to have a free market and decentralized leadership in the home, Chris and Janet would be free to do whatever they pleased, but have yet to obtain the necessary education to make proper decisions. Also, in a free market home, Mom and Dad would have to charge Chris and Janet a rent and sell them the food they needed to live. This obviously would not work. However, once Chris and Janet leave the home with the necessary education and the age to find employment in a free market, freedoms must be presented to them as described within this writing.</p><p>Here is a second refresh of your argument, <em>“[free markets] …almost never play out as planned because the real world has the unpredictable human element to contend with.”</em> — A free market is not a plan, it is just the opposite. A free market relies on society to run itself based on the basic rules as suggested earlier. It is self-regulating, and it is able to obtain all the necessary information in order to move forward and expand. Today’s society is to large and complex for any one central planning authority to obtain the necessary information required to make and execute the central plan. I will discuss the information process in more detail later in this writing.</p><p>The free market is not perfect, but is able to correct itself quickly and efficiently because of its spontaneous and organic nature. It is like a growing tree, many things are about, but no one thing is making the decisions on where or how it grows. It just does. Hayek stated it best, “economics is the study of how men attempt to create that which they cannot control.” Classical liberals (known today as libertarians) are humble. We are humble because we know that no one person, or even group of people, regardless of how smart, educated or experienced, can ever possibly gain all the knowledge of the world in order to make any one economic plan. It is too complex and too complicated. Therefore, any attempt to create a perfect society would require total domination of the masses, and even then it wouldn’t be perfect. The world is too big, and there are too many humans for any one person or group to make the perfect utopic planned society.</p><p><em>“Everyone has to buy in and everyone has to hold themselves to an ethical standard that is on par with the responsibility a completely free market puts on those that participate, unfortunately, human nature and greed show us that we aren’t a society with sufficient enlightenment to be given that much freedom.”</em> — This is very true for a planned market. In a planned market, the central leaders must create the central plan that all the citizens must buy into or be forced into, otherwise the plan would not work. The problem is very few people would buy into any one central plan because we are all so different and diverse. Hayek compared this idea to a large group of people having to take a trip but no majority deciding on where to go. The people then must accept that most of them will be taking a trip to a place they would not have wanted to go, and only a few will be satisfied. In order to decide they must elect some sort of leader who would ultimately be the deciding factor of the destination and therefore obtain power rather than leadership. In a free market, all are able to do as they please. They are able to do what suites their individual needs, wants, and desires, regardless of the majority façade. This is so long as they act within the boundaries of the rules discussed earlier and do not interfere with the other citizens in meeting their needs, wants, and desires. This freedom then excludes the need for any buy in by the masses.</p><p>The ethical standard you refer to is what I call Law or rules. It is rules of living in a society that have existed for many years and have evolved as explained earlier. The government must have a coercive power in this realm (that is they must coerce to keep others from coercing). That coercive power of the government then must be very constrained and limit itself to the Laws rather than the Legislation. They must be “do not does” rather than “must dos”. In a planned market the ethical standard is decided by few and enforced to the many. Socialist love to refer to the “fairness” of the system, and yet I can hardly see any more unfair way to run our economic and political system then to allow 543 people to control the actions of 320 million. That is in itself as unethical as one could imagine.</p><p>In a free market the only “buy in” needed is to make a profit to support you and your family to the highest level possible, while not coercing others in the process. That is, playing within the general boundaries of the game, or following the organic rules or laws as defined earlier. Yes there will be conflicts that would have to be decided by civil authorities, that being the courts in today’s world. These courts, however, would judge by the rules set by both adversaries rather than arbitrary legislations set by a very small group of unconnected and uninformed people.</p><p>I will refresh the second part of this argument. <em>“…unfortunately, human nature and greed show us that we aren’t a society with sufficient enlightenment to be given that much freedom”</em> — I am assuming that this argument is stating that human nature and greed are inevitable traits that will affect our human behaviors. Human nature and greed, or I would say self-interest, are required ingredients for a free market society and a great flaw in the planned market society. You are correct, greed is a negative feature of human nature. Since greed is self-interest out of control, it is instilled in all of us. Adam Smith was one of the first to publish this idea. “It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, baker, and brewer that we expect our diner, but [rather] from a regard to their own interest.” — Adam Smith “Wealth of Nations”. We all have self-interest and in fact we need self-interest to survive. Even the most benevolent people are indeed self-interested. They know that their welfare to others will at least make them feel self-satisfied of the good deed, and at most provide a public image of greatness which will bring with it influence and power such as that of Mother Teresa. It may not be their intentions, but it does inevitably come with the good deed. Even in instances where the self-interest is to eliminate one’s self from the world such as suicide, does self-interest take part. The person committing suicide believes that the world, or their loved ones, would be better off without them, thereby making their loved ones proud of them for their sacrifice. Perhaps they want a loved one to hurt in order to exact revenge, or they feel as though their lives are so painful, rather it be from physical or emotional pain, that they would meet a better life after death. Then there is the obvious case of suicide warriors, as seen by the Japanese in WWII or more recently in the terrorist activities primarily in the Middle East. These individuals are drawn to do what they do in the expectations that their self-interest will be met, that is, their families will be well taken care of, or their names will be enshrined as a martyr, or they will receive some sort of self-interested reward in the afterlife. So even in the most hidden ways, self-interest drives the human actions and behaviors for all of us. I’ll say that again, for ALL of us. This includes the central planners of a planned market society. Without limitations of their coercive powers, their self-interest will spin out of control and turn into greed, the same as any person without limits. Today’s corporations, protected by the unlimited coercive powers of government, suffer the same demise.</p><p>In a free market, self-interest is surely to be the driving factor. The difference, however, is that the free self-interest of others is always present to keep another’s self-interest in check. The freedom to be self-interested by all people in a society spontaneously eliminates greed. Some successful people will inevitably become greedy in a free market society. Without the coercive protection from the government, however, greed will cause the successful person to fall. In a free market, others are free to go into business to compete with the successful greed driven person. Therefore, when the successful person’s greed begins to displace his employees or consumers, it won’t be long before a free entrepreneur, without the regulatory roadblocks, sees the weakness. Self-interest will then prompt him to open a competing business and take the already successful person’s employees (in the case of labor mistreatment). The entrepreneur will begin to make the same product as the successful businessman did, and have more employees to provide the product in greater numbers. This is because the employees, in their own self-interest, will leave the original employer and come to the entrepreneur’s new business. This will place the successful businessman in a self-interest dilemma. He now has two choices, go out of business, or change his practices to balance his self-interest and rid himself of greed.</p><p>This is exactly what was proven to take place in the Henry Ford story. Henry Ford became very successful and his self-interest turned to greed causing him to make poor business decisions and treat his workers in not the best of ways. The Dodge brothers, members of the Ford Motor Company executive staff, observed this taking place. Their self-interest kicked in and they found the needed capital and created the Dodge Motor Company. Their main driving power was the better treatment of laborers, safer working conditions, the freedom to assemble, etc. The laborers in a more free market (though not completely free) then left the Ford Motor Company to work with the Dodge brothers. This almost shut the Ford Motor Company down for good. Henry Ford was then forced, not by government or any central planning commission, but rather by the free market, to change his business practices and provide better and safer working environment for his employees. Henry learned the hard way, you can’t sell a product that you can’t manufacture, and you can’t manufacture without the labor. Labor is a competitive market just as the products are. The more options the laborers have in a free market, the better their pay and work conditions. Their options can only be present if entrepreneurs are free to open businesses. Entrepreneurs are able to open more businesses if they are not forced to meet highly regulated and costly requirements. Therefore, the less regulations, the more employment options, the higher the wages, the safer the work environments, and so on and so on.</p><p>In a centralized planned market, the central planners’ self-interest is almost impossible to control by the people; and human nature will spin their self-interest into greed. This greed is what leads to tyranny. In the planned market the small group of decision makers will need a strong and deceive leader. This leader will be followed by the other members of the group because it is only through single decisions in planning that anything will ever get accomplished (take the more and more recent government shut downs for example). To prevent these non-actions by the government the 543 legislators will have to give in to the decisions by the strong leader in order to keep government moving. Since the central plan controls the economy, a non-active government becomes detrimental to the whole system. This provides the strong leader with much power. The government then becomes an issue of power rather than progression. As pointed out by the pretty girl in the video, the greed of the successful decide who that leader will be, through corporate and special interest group campaign contributions. Therefore, the people no longer get to decide who this leader will be. The decision of this leader is now left to the greedy powers of the rich. They decide two leaders of which the population can choose from, either of which is guaranteed to follow their commands. If the elected leader does not follow their commands, then the money will stop flowing and they will see the end of their career, and the leader knows this. This is what creates “Crony Capitalism”, a required element of totalitarianism. Totalitarian governments must have crony capitalism in order to maintain power over the masses.</p><p>Milton Friedman once told his students that if they go to Washington after graduating, do not stay more than two years, or they will be ruined. This is very true. In a centralized planned market, even the most idealist socialist with the best of intentions will have to either become controlled by the cronies, or abandon their ideas. The crony capitalist are the only route to the top levels of government in a planned society. In a free market, the government would be stripped of all commercial legislation and coercive powers. It would rather be in the hands of local civil courts to decide disputes and then only by the rules as set out by the adversaries of each occasion. The highly successful and special interest groups will then lose their influence over the market through regulations and legislation. The central planners, whom they would want to support, will no longer have the central power. That is, power to create market manipulations benefiting the already successful by limiting their competition through high cost regulations for the startup of competing businesses. The free market, therefore, eliminates the corny capitalist, and greedy corporations. Trump’s independent wealth could be the cause of his recent rise in the current election. People are beginning to understand this dilemma and see Trump as an answer. Though I will argue his ego and past quest for power cause for more concern in this area than the answer.</p><p>Here is a second refresh of your argument, <em>“we aren’t a society with sufficient enlightenment to be given that much freedom.” </em>— Enlightenment is a good word. In fact, giving the large society we have in the U.S., and even more so on a global level, I would argue NO one has the sufficient enlightenment to plan the market. Our market and society is so diverse, so large, and so complicated no one person or group could ever obtain the necessary information in order to create a central plan. Even the best central planner cannot operate without the essential information. This Information, however, is so dispersed that the time and fiscal investment needed to effectively collect it is too great. The facts would have already changed by the time the information had been collected. The now outdated information must be analyzed and debates must be had in order to come to a decision. This drags this process even longer. Meanwhile the market is still changing the facts regarding the decision to be made (this of course unless the government has already found the strong leader, in which case the decision is not debated and this leader makes his own decision arbitrarily, usually what will benefit him and his cronies that keep him in power). The endeavor now has so much money and time invested that there is a political demand for a return on this investment. This, thereby forces the planners to make a policy regardless of the outdated information. A central decision is finally made, but by this time, the facts are so changed that when the decided policy is implemented it does more harm than good.</p><p>Enlightenment is obtained through local information regarding each situation. This is only obtained by the local players in that game. The game can only be governed though regular rules that are consistent, reliable, and local, rather than the arbitrary notions of a central planner with no current knowledge of the facts. The local players are well aware of these consistent rules and their local information. These players then have much greater “enlightenment” as compared to any central planner. When given the freedom, they can make immediate decisions that are a direct result of the ever changing market. Some will inevitably make bad decisions, and for that they will suffer, but the only person to blame here is the person who made the ill decision. It is a great downward slope when the blame of one person’s bad decision falls on the government. This blame allows the government to obtain power and so goes the cycle to complete Tyranny as described above. The reason your boss is your boss is because he is responsible. Parents are responsible for their children, etc. The responsible entity must have the authority and power over the irresponsible. Thus, every time the citizens hold the government accountable for their own ill decisions, the government obtains power and authority. So you are right, no one has the needed enlightenment which is the very reason central planning causes either market disaster or tyranny.</p><p>I’ll provide a quick real world example. I had a buyer for my town home in December of 2014. We agreed to a price that was at the top of the local market but still within the market range. My realtor was concerned that the home would not appraise for this value in which case the buyer’s bank would not finance the deal. He advised me that the federal government placed a large blame of the 2008 housing market crash on the appraisers. The argument is that the appraisers appraised homes at too high of a value and this lead to the eventual bust of the housing market. In response the Federal Government required that all licensed appraisers would now have to register with a central government employer. Neither the buyer nor the seller could pick the appraiser, or even talk to them prior to the appraisal. When an appraisal is needed for a sale, the relator calls then central employer and request an appraiser. The appraisers are then pulled at random for the job. This created a situation where the appraiser might come from a completely different market than the one in which the concerned home was located. Appraisers had no current local market information in order to provide a market accurate appraisal. They would appraise the property based on the empirical data only, without any local knowledge such as school districts, crime statistics, neighborhood qualities, tax rates, etc. This caused several areas to have under market appraisals and others to have over market appraisals. These appraisals, due to the new housing regulations, forced banks to make poor finance decisions and caused homes to sale at false prices which other appraisers would use to falsely appraise other homes. Had the federal government not been blamed for the housing market crash, thereby allowing them the coercive power to arbitrarily assign an unenlightened appraiser to make poor decisions for the unenlightened bank, the housing market could have corrected itself much quicker. Blame should have been focused on the individual home buyers and the bankers who mislead them, as they collectively made poor and uneducated decisions. The greedy bankers with governmental protections, advised the uninformed home buyers to enter into unpredictable loans such as Adjustable Rate Mortgages and Interest Only loans. This caused the home market to artificially skyrocket as more people, though not really qualified, were buying homes. Interest rates dramatically changed causing insoluble monthly mortgage payments. This in turn caused so many foreclosures that the housing market went bust, and by doing so, its affects spread to the whole economy.</p><p><em>“I don’t advocate that our government be in total control, and like you I believe our government is the problem.” </em>— I don’t advocate for no government at all. Most socialist see libertarians as anarchist, we are not. The classical liberal knows there is a need for government. I stated earlier that in order to eliminate coercion the government must have a monopoly on coercion. This power though must be greatly limited. The powers to imprison a person must be limited to the laws, or the “rules”, that protect the basic principles of freedom. These principals being the guaranteed protection of Life, Liberty, and Property. These powers must also be at the lowest levels possible.</p><p>Milton Freedmen argued in “Capitalism and Freedom” that it is better to have power at the local level rather than the state, and the state level rather than the national level. His argument continues that if a person is unhappy with the decisions made by his local government, it is rather inexpensive to change the local ideas. He only need to convince the townsmen, or county citizens, that his idea is better than the one enacted in order to effect change. If he is unsuccessful in this venture he can move to another local community with few cost. If he is unhappy with his state government, he only need to convince the citizens of his state regarding his idea. If unsuccessful he can move to another state with still an achievable cost. If he is unhappy with his federal government, however, he must convince a majority of all the citizens of the nation, now at 320 million people, of his idea. This will be an extreme cost that he will surely not be able to afford without the help of many already convinced people. If he is unsuccessful, he really has no other option, as moving to another country is very costly in both monetary and transactions cost.</p><p>These coercive powers then must be decentralized in a free market. There are some that could only be provided by the federal government such as the protection of the nation’s borders. This protection is necessary to ensure outside governments do not threaten our basic principles. The power given to the state department in diplomatic and intelligence gathering, and the defense department in militaristic actions, must be great. This security establishes the stability necessary for a free market to operate. The federal government must also, though some libertarians would argue this point (and perhaps they are correct), establish control of the monetary system as stated earlier in this writing. There could be a need for a single federal law enforcement agency if it were only limited to international and interstate crimes, and not given jurisdiction where state and local law enforcement are capable of providing this service.</p><p>The state governments should hold the internal powers of crime prevention. They are responsible for establishing a written document detailing their due process of law and the written interpretation of the general rules, or laws, as expressed earlier. So long as these laws are strictly limited to the protection of life, liberty, and property, the federal government should have almost no power to control the state governments. States should be free to establish their own laws and determine how their states are to be governed. There is a tax argument here as well, it is a bit off topic so I will only make a quick statement here. The state should be able to implement a tax that is reasonable to run their own business rather than rely on the federal government for funding. This dependence on federal government funds has, in recent years, destroyed the state’s authority to govern.</p><p>The local government is responsible for the everyday enforcement and practice of the laws set forth by the state. They must have the right to place people in jail who violate the basic rules of the game and thereby play outside the boundaries. When a person limits the life, liberty or property of another the local government must prosecute and punish him. Protection of these rights from one citizen against another is as necessary to the free market as the protection of the national borders stated earlier. In the matters of self-interest, why would any one person create a product to sale on the market if he had no reasonable assurance his interest (that is, his property rights) would be protected.</p><p>I heard not too long ago about a college professor claiming at a community meeting that the local government need not any longer arrest or prosecute petty shoplifters at the big department stores such as Walmart, Target, K-Mart, etc. His argument was that these corporations make enough dollars and they all have insurance against such losses and therefore the local police should allow the perpetrators to simply take what they want. I wonder today if this man really cares about the poor. The poor often times rely on these “big box stores” not only for employment but also their low cost goods. If the government seized their protection against theft, thereby the stores lose their property rights, they could not stay in business. No insurance company would insure them as they would be sure to fail if anyone could simply take what they wanted. The store may attempt to stay in business but soon all of their inventory would be lost and the store would close. Now the poor no longer have a place to buy low cost goods. The many who relied on what little income they had from these stores are no longer employed at all. Who would open a store to replace those gone out of business? It would no longer be profitable and no one would dare open a store only to learn that customers could just come in and take what they want without pay. This was a perfect example where libertarians fought for the role of government where, at least this one highly educated socialist, argued against the role of government.</p><p>Here is a refresh of your argument, <em>“and like you I believe our government is the problem.”</em> — If you agree our government is the problem, then I cannot understand the argument that more government is the solution to the problem. This is where we differ. The pretty girl featured in the video that prompted this discussion, was actually featured in a previous video. In the other video she demonstrated how we are already a socialist country. In this video she demonstrates the mostly factual problems our nation faces. She then argues that the solution to these problems should be solved by more socialist government. It seems to me that this solution is akin to pouring gasoline on a fire in attempt to put it out. If we agree that the government is the source of these issues then why argue for a larger and more powerful government? The answer I have heard before is “well we just need to elect the right people.” My first reply is, there are no right people. In a socialist planned society, the leaders must be tied to the money which is provided by the corporations and the highly successful. In fact the same corporations and successful people whom, agreeably so, the socialist seem to have such a resentment for. Therefore, no matter the good genuine intentions of the “right” leader, they will be forced to comply with the wishes of the corporations and aristocrats. As described earlier, there is no other way to obtain positions of power in a preplanned society. My second reply to this is, even if there was a way for the “right” person to be elected, who is he right for? He may be right for the girl in the video, but not me. He may be right for us, but not them. Since, mathematically speaking, there is no real majority when given more than two options, he most likely will not even be the right person for the majority of the people. In a free market, his central power is so little, and his ability to control local lives is so minor that he doesn’t have to be the “right” person, at least not for economic purposes. His job would mostly revolve around the national security realm, foreign relations, and the like.</p><p><em>“Civil service should be a duty, not a lifetime paycheck. Terms should be short and limited, the pay for that service should be supplemental in nature, not primary.” </em>— Here is where we would certainly agree. This idea is usually much different than the socialist view and I would contend the pretty girl in the video would whole heartedly disagree with us both. My proposed solution to this issue is a simple change in the pay policies of our elected officials. It seems that if the federal representatives’ pay was regulated not by them, but rather their respective state legislators, much would change. The states could determine their representative pay, term limits (if any at all, as I will discuss later), their pensions, benefits, and the like. This would ensure that these federal legislators are representing their states and not the federal senate or house. Like-wise, though I would not federally mandate this, I would urge state legislators to be paid under a similar process (that is their pay and benefits would be mandated by the local government bodies in which they represent). The local government official’s pay then could be decided by general vote, for instance, upon election year. This is just a proposal and beyond the federal level it would be up to each state and local office to determine the specifics. I believe this idea would go a long way to ensure that our civil servants are kept in check by their constituents. In a free market society, the powers of federal offices would be much less than they are today, and therefore less people would want those offices. The people would be able to more easily elect a federal official as they need to look at so many less issues than today. The economic situations would no longer be in the hands of the 543 officials and most of their duties would be focused on national security and very few domestic or local concerns.</p><p>As far as term limits are concerned, there are benefits and draw backs to each idea. An argument presented on Russ Roberts’s “Econo Talk” podcast, stated that term limits are dangerous because during the last term the elected official is no longer subject to his constituents. They are now free to make arbitrary decisions during their last term that mostly benefit their own self-interest and personal agendas. This becomes a two to four year slippery slope. Whereas a no term limit office, demands that the elected official continue to serve his constituents in order to be re-elected. This concept, as explained earlier, only serves its purpose in a free market where corporate and special interest monies are not available to the civil servant. The flip side to this of course, is the one we have always learned in school. Term limits ensure no one person stays in office for so long that they obtain unreasonable powers. This is a valid argument as well, therefore I’m not sure which is the better solution. This is why I would leave this decision to the state legislators regarding their own federal representatives.</p><p>I tend to lean, however, towards no term limits. I like it to Milton Friedman’s argument regarding monopolies. In “Capitalism and Freedom” he argues that there are three types of monopolies, 1.) Government Operated, 2.) Private and Government Regulated and 3.) Private. He admits that all three are bad in the since that they cause coercion by lack of other choices and therefore provide powers for arbitrary market control. He believes, however, that private monopolies are the least of all three evils. His reasoning is that in a free market, private monopolies have no coercive protection of the government and therefore are most likely to eventually fall due to changes in technologies or competitive forces that eventually measure up against the monopoly. Given this argument I would say that a no term limit political office could have the same outcome. If the elected official is constantly in jeopardy of losing reelection his self-interest must stay in balance for if he sways towards greed he would become vulnerable to a competing candidate and lose his office. This, like so many answers, lies only in the free market solution.</p><p><em>“But much as the government is constructed so that the branches check and balance each other, so too should corporations be checked and balanced.” </em>— I would agree, but again, as mentioned in the Policing of Corporations paragraph, I argue that under a free market the corporations are checked and balanced by entrepreneurs and consumers. I will also note here that the government’s constitutional designs of checks and balances only work in a free market society. In the planned market, the planners must continue to make legislations on a continuous basis, if they stop then the economic system stops, as in a government shutdown. As the executive and legislative branches enact all those commanding pieces of legislation, as discussed earlier, disputes regarding them arise. The judicial branch is now compelled to rule on such command related legislations. They must attempt to rule in favor of the central plan or risk causing more disruption in the economic system. Ruling against the central plan would risk government shutdown and stop the economic system. In the planned society the central plan must be adhered to by all, as stated in the buy in argument discussed earlier. Each citizen and public official must be commanded to do certain things as the plan requires. Everyone must take the trip to the centrally planned destination. The justices then must rule in such a way that the trip can be made period. They go with the flow, so the flow will go.</p><p><em>“You say the market would do that [cooperate checks and balances] inherently, cheaters will be pushed out by the consumers, but what if the consumers decide that as long as the price is low, the means to achieve that price are acceptable?” </em>— First I would like to identify “cheaters.” I think there are two types of cheaters. 1.) Those who do not operate or conduct business under the general rules of the game, they violate the organic law as discussed earlier, and 2.) Those who cheat by simply making bad business decisions or allow their self-interest to become greed, but yet stay within the general rules of the game. I would call the first kind of cheater a criminal, and the second a scoundrel.</p><p>Criminals would be subject to criminal prosecution for committing the acts that violate the laws or basic rules of the game. Acts of fraud (that is, lying), property right violations, or violence, would be subject to criminal prosecution. The general rules of the game must be followed and everyone’s rights to life, liberty, and property must be protected. This is one of the roles of government as discussed earlier, but again, it would have to be enforced at the lowest levels possible.</p><p>Scoundrels would have to answer for their actions by either or both of two ways. 1.) By way of competition and the loss of consumers to the entrepreneur, who is always ready to do better business, or, 2.) By the way of civil court, another role of government. The civil court process under a free market would only be able to rule according to the rules as set in place by the two advisory parties, as mentioned earlier.</p><p>Scoundrels will be pushed out by the consumer and more importantly the entrepreneur (who in a free market corrects errors). It is important to note that it’s not just the consumer. The entrepreneur must provide an alternate choice for the consumer’s actions to be effective. Although I believe the free market entrepreneur is the most effective and frequent correction to the scoundrel in a free market, I will concede that there will be times the civil court will have to play referee. These civil courts would only be allowed arbitrate the rules as set forth by the parties in their contract. The contract then must be reasonably understood by the lowest educated party (the most lay person in that particular industry). Many more civil court facilities would have to be established and all cases must have time limits to be brought to trial. This civil mandate would simplify the civil court process and prevent rich corporate lawyers from manipulating the process at the other’s expense. This mandate would be a legislative one granted, though I believe it should be written by the states rather than the federal government. The only instance in which the federal government would have to intervene are the cases that cross state lines. This federal mandate would simply read, one state must recognize another’s right to civil process. That is, if a complainant lives in Ohio and the Defendant’s business is in Vermont, the Vermont business must recognize the Ohio Civil process.</p><p>I’ll provide a refresh of your argument — <em>“cheaters will be pushed out by the consumers, but what if the consumers decide that as long as the price is low, the means to achieve that price are acceptable?” </em>— Yes the consumer will decide to take the lowest price possible, just as they do in a planned economy. In fact, the free market depends on this. If the means is unacceptable to the masses, the entrepreneur will correct the error. The entrepreneur will create the same product without the negative means, and make this information very public as to drive the consumer from the immoral business to his. In fact, the entrepreneur will constantly watch for this dilemma. He hopes a competitor uses an immoral means to deliver their product, for this allows him a completive edge against the immoral competition and thereby fulfilling his self-interest. This “invisible hand”, as described by Adam Smith, will keep the corporations in check. If the means are not accepted by the masses, the immoral corporations will either have to change their means or go out of business.</p><p>In many cases the meaning of immoral is very subjective. There could be a sweat shop in China, for instance, in which the laborers are over worked in poor conditions and lack a proper pay. The American entrepreneur publicizes this fact and offers the same product produced by a more generous manufacturer. This allows the public to decide on their own merit, rather than a central arbitrary person or group, what is acceptable and what is not. If the masses have such a heart ache with the Chinese sweat shop then they will pay a small premium to obtain the product from a compassionate manufacture. This will, however, cost the Chinese sweat shop employees their jobs, taking what little bit of income they had and thereby leave them worse off than before. This is a very debatable subject and is subjective to each individual. Some would like the Chinese people to have whatever income they could gather under whatever circumstance necessary. Considering they cannot control the Chinese economy or government, they would just assume to help the Chinese people gain any kind of employment possible. Others, on the other hand, may see that the work conditions are too great a concern and the Chinese people would be better off not employed at all. This is a decision that must be made by each individual rather than the arbitrary decisions of a single central planner or group. The single planner or group will undoubtedly have different ethical beliefs than any majority of the population. Their decision will undoubtedly go against the heartfelt objections of many people, but yet, the citizens will now be forced to follow along regardless of their personal beliefs.</p><p><em>”Sociologically speaking, it’s easier to be corrupted in masse than individually.”</em> — I will say that corruption is more wide spread in masse rather than individually, however, its affects are much less than that of a single person or group. This concept goes back to the decentralization of governmental powers as discussed earlier. In a decentralized government it is likely that corruption will set in among many state and particularly local governments. The advantage is that the corruption will only affect the citizens of that particular jurisdiction and will be much easier to root out. When corruption sets in among the 543 federal officials, however, its affects are felt amongst the whole nation and rooting it out is close to impossible. So, sociologically speaking, centralized corruption not only has a more magnified and harmful effect, but it is close to impossible to exile. Local masse corruption may be more prevalent, but it has less harmful effects and is much easier to exile. This is my addition to Milton Freedmen’s argument for decentralized government, my third value so to speak.</p><p>In closing, I will note that the classical liberal argument is a hard one to make due to the fact that it lacks the dramatic appeal of socialism. The human instinct of the small hunter-gather groups designed by planned societies with the necessity of helping people in need, still thrives in us all today. I have the same emotional response, but have learned in recent years, that freedom and true capitalistic markets in large societies, provide for those people in need quicker and more efficiently than any single planned market. Then there is the blame issue. In a free market society, the blame of wrong doings belongs to no single person or institution. Human nature, when seeing hurt and turmoil, wants to blame a person for the infraction. Since a free market acknowledges the fact that society is the results of each individual’s actions, making it so complex that no one understands it, there is no one person to blame. So ultimately they blame the Government and demand some recourse or correction creating the planned society. That gives the government the power to correct the error through coercion. This leads down the slippery slope to serfdom as pointed out in FA Hayek’s book, “Road to Serfdom”. It is most impossible for people to place full trust into that which they cannot understand. The fear of the incomprehensible is so great that most would rather see more people suffer from wrong doings and slowed corrections, than to place trust in a system that no one can comprehend, even if the system provides less suffering. Though planned markets are just as incomprehensible, they are shielded by the blind faith of the intelligent central planners, who claim to understand the totality of the economic system and are willing to assign blame. This world is so complicated and complex that it is impossible to legislate a perfect world.</p><p>So there you have it. There is more to this argument that is being left unsaid. Health care, education, taxation, global economy, and more, all of which would operate more effectively and efficiently under a free market society. When the free mind is allowed to create, it will create and benefit all others in the process. If billions of free minds are free to create and benefit each other, then economic growth is limitless.</p><p>I am certain that you are emotionally connected to your ideas as most people are. I hope this response helps you understand the free market argument better than before. I only ask that if you can, take a read of Milton Freedmen, FA Hayek, and Adam Smith. Hayek in particular is an interesting case as he was a long time socialist himself and only found his way to the free market ideas by internal debate and struggle. He often stated how appreciative he was of his younger views of socialism as it forced him to debate each and every topic in order to change his thoughts. Even John Keynes and Carl Marx added to the free market ideas by providing alternative thoughts and creating the arguments.</p><p>Milton Friedman put it best during an interview with Russ Roberts when he stated “we will never make it to a full libertarian society; because anytime we get half way there, everyone becomes so rich and happy they stop paying attention to what the government is doing.”</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9443de9b1399" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>