<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by John Todaro on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by John Todaro on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@john_19547?source=rss-c50643889a04------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Fri, 20 Nov 2026 22:47:15 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@john_19547/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Finding an Appropriate Discount Rate for Crypto-currencies]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@john_19547/finding-an-appropriate-discount-rate-for-crypto-currencies-14ff6190048b?source=rss-c50643889a04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/14ff6190048b</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[startup]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Todaro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Fri, 29 Jun 2018 17:49:31 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-29T17:49:31.156Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Most valuation models incorporate a discount rate as investors are required to evaluate the future utility or cash flow of an investment. $1 dollar in the future is not worth the same as $1 today. As such, investors need to analyze the riskiness of this future dollar and other alternative investment opportunities that are available to them that could return $1 or greater in the future. To that end, various investors attempt to value the future utility or cash flow of crypto-currencies and in the process must incorporate a discount rate into their valuation model.</p><p>Currently there exists no benchmark discount rate for crypto assets. This makes it very challenging for investors to build out valuation models in the space. Most investors deem the discount rate that is used for early stage VC investing to be appropriate for crypto assets. This rate is commonly projected to be between 30–50% per annum, given the high risks associated with early stage investing. However, as the crypto space matures, it will become imperative that crypto assets have their own appropriate discount rate benchmark. As such, below I diagram a working model for discount rates for crypto assets using methods borrowed from traditional financial markets.</p><p>In traditional capital markets, the discount rate for a company is commonly viewed as equal to a company’s Weighted Avg Cost of Capital (WACC). This formula blends the cost of equity with the cost of debt (the interest rate the company pays on their loans and bonds). When a company does not have debt, the cost of equity is solely used as the discount rate. The cost of equity is often found using the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). Given that crypto networks have neither equity nor debt, a WACC cannot be used. We can, however, reimagine the CAPM formula to find a <em>cost of tokens</em> similar to a cost of equity. The CAPM formula is outlined below:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/232/0*vo7-sfhPa6mc11x9" /></figure><p>The risk free rate is the rate an investor can receive while taking on no risk of loss — this rate is typically deemed to be the yield on the US 10 year government bond. Backed by the full faith and credit of the US government, US treasury bonds are deemed to have no default risk. At the time of writing, 10 year yields reached 3% up from 2% in June of 2017 as bond prices have fallen over the year. The risk free rate, therefore, is equivalent to 3%.</p><p>Beta of the security represents the beta of our crypto asset we are analyzing — this could be with either utility tokens or security tokens. For this example, I chose Republic Protocol (REN) as the crypto asset to analyze. Beta is a measure of risk that cannot be diversified away. Beta indicates whether an investment is more or less volatile than the market as a whole. A beta &gt;1 indicates that this particular asset is more volatile than the market, and hence will have magnified gains and losses relative to a market move. A beta &lt;1 indicates the opposite is true. Mathematically we can calculate the beta of a crypto asset by comparing how the asset and an index/market move relative to each other using a covariance formula and then we can divide that result by the variance of the index/market alone. Using these formulas, I compared historical prices of the Republic Protocol token since its inception to Bitcoin (which I used as the crypto benchmark/index — note it would be equally fair to use an index of various crypto assets instead of Bitcoin) since the same time frame. Historical prices were gathered from coinmarketcap.com — the first price point for Republic Protocol was on Feb 21, 2018 and the last price point was on June 10, 2018. Using excel and the aforementioned formulas, the beta of REN was calculated to be 1.19 indicating it is slightly more volatile than Bitcoin and moves in the same direction as Bitcoin. That is to say, when Bitcoin rallies, REN should outperform, and when Bitcoin sells-off, REN should underperform and sell-off more than Bitcoin.</p><p>Lastly, in order to use our formula, we need to find the expected return of our market/index. As mentioned previously, I chose to use Bitcoin as the representative “market” for this example. In traditional US blue-chip equity markets, investors will use the past one year return of the S&amp;P 500 as the expected market return. YoY, Bitcoin has returned 164% at the time of writing. We can now plug this into our formula above for Rm.</p><p>Ra = ?</p><p>Rf = 3%</p><p>Ba = 1.19</p><p>Rm = 164%</p><p>Ra = 3% + 1.19(164% — 3%) = 194%</p><p>As found above, the discount rate for Republic Protocol was found to be 194%. In other words, if we built out a Discounted Cash Flow analysis of REN, we would use 194% as our discount rate to evaluate those future cash flows. Comparatively, if one had built out a utility model for REN, he/she would once again use 194% to discount the platform’s future utility. Note that the higher the discount rate is, the more we are discounting the future utility or value of a platform. That being said, this model should be interpreted as a “working” model that I hope can further debate and exploration of discount rates for crypto assets. I remain cautious on strictly using this rate, as it is significantly higher than the rate VC’s use, while I believe crypto assets are not necessarily riskier than early stage traditional companies. Crypto assets have been shown over time to have a high sharpe ratio relative to traditional assets, indicating their gains have justified the moderately higher volatility.</p><p>Additionally, if you parse through our CAPM formula, you will realize the discount rate is so high primarily due to the fact that Bitcoin has had exceptional gains YoY. There are two pints of criticism I have for using the CAPM model. First, it assumes efficient markets. In an efficient market, if an asset has a high return, it means that the asset has a high degree of risk. After all, in an efficient market, investors are educated and rational. If an asset was a low risk/high yield investment, buyers would rush in and the asset would be immediately fairly priced. I believe, however, that crypto for the past several years has NOT been an efficient market as the space had high barriers to entry for institutional investors (lack of custody, unclear regulations, etc) and was relatively obscure and immature. My second criticism with the CAPM model is that it does not incorporate a liquidity premium or discount. Crypto assets are very advantaged relative to early stage private equity/VC transactions as crypto assets trade on highly liquid secondary markets. As such, crypto assets should have a liquidity premium baked into their discount rate given the greater liquidity and hence lower degree of risk than traditional early stage companies.</p><p>In conclusion, I hope that this working model can further the debate on crypto asset discount rates. As the space matures, I would expect the CAPM model to become more useful and utilized in finding an appropriate discount rate to value crypto assets.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=14ff6190048b" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Valuing Crypto Assets using a DCF Model]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/@john_19547/valuing-crypto-assets-using-a-dcf-model-bc6297b0bd25?source=rss-c50643889a04------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/bc6297b0bd25</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[cryptocurrency]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bitcoin]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[blockchain]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[ethereum]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[John Todaro]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 21 Jun 2018 13:55:25 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2018-06-21T17:51:25.796Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Currently there exist various models that attempt to capture a valuation framework for crypto-assets. In both traditional finance and crypto-assets, these models can be divided into relative and absolute valuation models. Relative models assume some baseline starting point which can be used as a comparison. In equities, the most commonly used relative valuation method is the price-to-earnings ratio (P/E). Investors use this to determine whether an asset is overpriced or underpriced by looking at the ratio compared to peer companies. A high P/E ratio (relative to peer companies) implies the market is paying a premium for the same earnings as a similar company. In various cases this premium may be warranted, such as earnings that are growing at a higher rate, or an innovative CEO who can push earnings higher in the long run. Many times, a high P/E is seen as the market overpaying for a company. As such, those shares appear less attractive relative to a peer company with a lower P/E multiple.</p><p><strong>Relative Valuation Models</strong></p><p>In the crypto-asset world, experts say the most similar ratio to the P/E multiple is the Network Value to Transactions multiple (NVT). Willy Woo and Chris Burniske first pioneered this metric in September of 2017 (Woo’s Forbes article: <a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/wwoo/2017/09/29/is-bitcoin-in-a-bubble-check-the-nvt-ratio/).">https://www.forbes.com/sites/wwoo/2017/09/29/is-bitcoin-in-a-bubble-check-the-nvt-ratio/).</a> When a crypto-asset has a high NVT, it indicates that its network valuation is outstripping the value being transmitted on its payment network. Similar to equities, this can happen when the network is in high growth and the market is pricing this in, or when the asset price is in a fever pitch and is irrationally overvalued. Willy Woo described in his September 2017 Forbes article how Bitcoin had two major bubbles as shown by elevated NVT ratios (see graphic below).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/480/0*Nl6NL1lG7dJdr2xO" /></figure><p>As Willy describes, this metric cannot predict a bubble before it happens but after the asset sells off, the NVT ratio then spikes indicating that the asset was previously in a bubble. This is what we are currently witnessing (June 2018) as the NVT ratio is reaching a several year high as the Bitcoin price continues its free fall (see chart below). The reason being for this, is that a crypto-asset’s payment network is usually highly used during periods of hysteria as speculators move these tokens to different addresses and through other avenues for trading. This increase in on-chain transaction volume for Bitcoin is compounded as Bitcoin serves as the most used trading pair for the exchange of all other crypto-assets as well. These moves are then recorded as use of the payment network when in reality they are just being used by speculators to move assets around as trading volumes pick up during moments of elevated hysteria. Thus, during a fever pitch, while market prices are elevated, the number of transactions are likely more elevated. As such, a low NVT ratio does not necessarily mean the asset is cheap, it could be that the payment network is simply being overused by speculators (in December of 2017 the NVT ratio actually reached a localized low).</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/509/0*m7MyboKUasPrg0GY" /></figure><p>This, however, is not how a P/E multiple works. If we strictly interpreted the NVT ratio similar to a P/E, we would be inclined to say Bitcoin was undervalued during its market price peak in December of 2017 as its NVT ratio reached a localized low. Similarly, as the NVT ratio reaches a high during this market correction, we would be inclined to say Bitcoin is overvalued. Thus, it is clear that the NVT ratio is not the most attractive valuation tool as it fails to act similarly to the P/E ratio and also only becomes useful after a crash has already occured. I.e. the NVT ratio is telling us now that Bitcoin was overvalued in December/Jan of 2017.</p><p>Additionally, using relative valuation models (either across assets or relative in time within the same asset) in such a novel space as cryptocurrency is a difficult case to make. If I argue that Litecoin is a higher growth network than Bitcoin, and hence should trade at say a multiple of 2x what Bitcoin’s NVT ratio is, by definition we must first accept that Bitcoin is fairly priced. In a novel space in which there are experts who insist Bitcoin should trade at $1mm a token while others insist it is worthless, it becomes hard to base the valuation of other assets on the uncertain ratio of this asset. As such, relative valuation models are less useful in novel spaces with limited past historical multiples and prices. For that reason, cryptoasset valuations may be better served by utilizing absolute valuation metrics.</p><p><strong>Absolute Valuation Models</strong></p><p>The most commonly used absolute valuation metric currently for cryptocurrencies is the popular Equation of Exchange that is taught in any introductory economics course. Chris Burniske most popularly re-imagined the formula to fit a cryptocurrency model. While this method is the most appropriate that I can think of for currency tokens, it fails when applied to crypto-assets that are not used as a currency or medium of exchange. Many crypto-assets function more as equity instruments or bonds. Many crypto-assets now record a transaction fee for usage on their platform. This fee is then paid out to token holders who perform “work” on the network. The cost of this work is varied, but in many instances the work often requires as little as a high speed internet connection to run a simple process. For these fee incentivized networks, I believe it is most appropriate to use a DCF method to reach a valuation. Most crypto experts do not use DCF analyses to value crypto-assets, as they argue such assets do not generate a traditional cash flow. While true, these crypto-assets often pay fees out to token holders in Ether, or an ERC-20 token or Bitcoin. So while not a “cash” flow, we can call this an <em>Ether flow</em>.</p><p><strong>Utilizing DCF analysis on Crypto Assets</strong></p><p>A DCF is an absolute valuation metric that requires no relative multiples, but relies strictly on the cash flow paid back to holders of an asset (stock, bond, or token). As such, we can value these assets irrespective of other crypto-assets trading in the market. I would expect over the long term more crypto-assets to adopt a fee based incentivization model as it creates a much more attractive value capture for token holders than many other crypto models such as strictly governance or medium of exchange.</p><p>In our flagship report on Republic Protocol (REN), my partners and I at Blocktown Capital built out a DCF model to value the REN token. Republic Protocol is a decentralized dark pool platform in which nodes run a simple matching process and in turn for their work receive trading fees from the network. The primary incentive to own REN tokens, is to be able to stake these tokens to be eligible to run a node, and hence receive fees. We can treat these fees as a cash flow paid out to token holders. Below, we run through how a DCF model is then used to find a fair token price today for REN. Note that this type of model can be used for any fee paying network in which fees are paid out to token holders.</p><p>First, we need to assume certain growth rates of the platform which lead us to expected future cash flows. See our full report for why we used the below assumptions. Note that the assumptions below were for our bull case scenario for REN. In our full report, we also run through a base case scenario. Link here: <a href="https://medium.com/blocktown/republic-protocol-analysis-and-valuation-e73fab4c32fc">Blocktown Capital REN Report &amp; Valuation</a></p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/660/0*MFPV3nb531nd8Boo" /></figure><p>The key aspect in the above table, is the estimate of cash to be paid to nodes projected over the next five years. Using the formula for DCF, PV = [CF1 / (1+r)1] + [CF2 / (1+r)2] + … + [CFn / (1+r)n] + TV, we can discount our cash flows back to present day to arrive at a Present Value (PV) for the REN network.</p><p>PV = Present cash flow value</p><p>CF1 = Cash flow at the end of year 1</p><p>CF2 = Cash flow at the end of year 2</p><p>CFn = Cash flow at n specified year</p><p>r = Discount or required rate of return</p><p>TV = Terminal Value</p><p>In any DCF model, we must discount our cash flows back to the present day as a dollar next year is not worth the same as a dollar today. One key point to note, is that all expected cash flows are not treated equally. We must build in a risk measure. The more uncertain an expected cash flow is, the more we should discount it. Presently, there is no appropriate risk rate in the digital asset marketplace that can be used as a benchmark. As such, in our report we borrowed from other financial markets. In Series A equity funding rounds for venture capital, the generally accepted rate is between 30–50% per annum. As a digital asset platform with certain technological components that remain unproven, Republic Protocol has a relatively high risk profile so we settled on a similar discount rate of 40%.</p><p>Lastly, in our DCF model, we need to include those fees paid after the five year period. We modelled the REN platform to last into perpetuity, as is appropriate in the equity markets. To achieve this, we used the Gordon Growth Method to find a Terminal Value, TV. We conservatively projected out a sustained growth rate of 2% (g = 0.02), inline with mature company estimates and developed countries’ GDP estimates. Using the Gordon Growth formula below:</p><p>TV = [year 5 cash flow * (1+g)/(r-g)]</p><p>TV = 1,506,093,750*(1.02)/(0.4–0.02) = 4,042,672,697</p><p>Adding up our yearly cash flows and terminal value, we arrive at the below summation:</p><p>0 + 42,857,142 + 117,091,836 + 214,012,390 + 280,034,686 + 4,042,672,697 = 4,696,668,753</p><p>Finally, by dividing our total network cash value (4,696,668,753) by the number of circulating tokens (519,094,022), we arrive at a dollar price per REN of 9.05 USD. That is, with our assumptions and best case scenario forecasts, REN should be valued at 9.05 USD per token.</p><p>In conclusion, I expect absolute valuation metrics will become more commonly used when valuing crypto-assets and I also expect DCF analysis to become more utilized in the space. Currently, very few experts have looked to use a DCF to value a crypto network, in part because the majority of crypto assets still do not have fee incentivized networks and hence no cash flows. Given the attractiveness of such fee based models, I anticipate more new tokens will be structured to incorporate a stream of cash flow back to the token holders in order to create value for the token asset. My hope is that this post will shed light on how to value those crypto-assets which incorporate a cash flow.</p><p>Thanks to Joseph Todaro and James Todaro for contributing to this piece.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=bc6297b0bd25" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>