<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jonas Kyratzes on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jonas Kyratzes on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jonaskyratzes?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 18:18:26 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jonaskyratzes/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[There Is No Substitute For Politics]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/there-is-no-substitute-for-politics-12e61cfd21e7?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/12e61cfd21e7</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Sat, 22 Jan 2022 11:52:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2022-01-22T11:52:06.399Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Everybody knows that things can’t keep going this way. The global economy is deeply dysfunctional. Resources are no longer allocated with anything resembling rationality. Large nations are incapable of fixing their own infrastructure. The economy is increasingly ficticious. The gap between the rich and poor is becoming unsustainable. These are the conditions of civilizational collapse.</p><p>Everybody also knows that things aren’t changing. Nothing that happens seems to affect the mechanisms of power. No matter what we do, the system just keeps chugging along. If people got together, if the masses were convinced that change was possible, it could all be turned around. But they’re not, and nobody wants to face this simple, stark fact.</p><p>So they turn to substitutes.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1024/1*jcuVeY6WNwk6meQ-QH2QpA.png" /></figure><p>For some people, it’s identity. They tell themselves that this or that category of people is the true engine of history. If only more women were in power, everything would be different! But from Thatcher to Merkel to the women now running the military-industrial complex, it makes absolutely no difference. Because “women” are not a political group with a cohesive set of interests, and because changing the <em>face </em>of the system doesn’t change how it functions. People don’t do what they do because they have male or female ideologies, they do so for material reasons. It’s all about the money, and it always will be as long as this economic system persists.</p><p>Others turn to culture, even further away from power and government. If only people with their particular ideology could control all the stories we tell, things would change! If only more people from oppressed groups were depicted, the oppression would somehow go away! But again, nothing changes, because all they’re doing is championing the entry of a handful of middle-class representatives of those groups into the upper class, where they will faithfully serve the system that rewarded them. The mechanisms that push us towards collapse remain unchanged.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/800/1*eHkNmUhIn9mpbqIMPWvBYw.jpeg" /></figure><p>Climate change is another popular substitute for politics. Here the demand is for emergency laws, for the suspension of democracy (since you can’t convince people). Imaginary wise technocrats to the rescue! Accelerating the authoritarian trends of our society, giving more power to the very same status quo that has ignored climate change for decades despite the evidence, will surely somehow fix the problem.</p><p>(Greenpeace, I should note, is itself engaged in selling dirty fossil fuel energy. In case you were wondering where their financial interests lie.)</p><p>The election of Donald Trump, a banal huckster whose main difference to his predecessors was his crude aesthetics, provided another source of hope that the system could be changed by some external actor. For some it was Trump himself who would somehow “drain the swamp” even though he was transparently just another swamp-creature himself; for others it was the supervillain their desperate imaginations turned Trump into. A Russian puppet, a fascist, a mastermind about to bring America to its knees! Here was the threat that would suddenly convince everyone to support their cause. Centre-right liberals and alleged socialists suddenly sounded the same. Here was the man whose terrible presence would convince everyone to vote for them forever! Here was the man whose fascist takeover would spur the working class to revolution!</p><p>Except the actual response of the working class was “meh.” And Trump came and went and not a whole lot happened. His pathetic attempts to use the same playbook as his opponents by claiming the election was rigged ended up amounting to no more than a handful of clowns causing a public spectacle, an event that simply underscored just how powerless Trump was. This after weeks of reporting about how the government essentially ignored any orders the military and intelligence apparatus found inconvenient.</p><p>The obsession with that event, now far in the past, is little more than a desperate attempt to hang on to the imaginary feeling of historical importance that the Trump years had enabled. For four years, every political group had been able to claim that <em>big things are now happening</em>, this is it, <em>this is the moment</em> when people turn to us. And they didn’t. And it all passed. And it amounted to nothing.</p><p>Trump has now been superseded by Covid-19 as an imaginary agent of change. Surely now people will see that we’ve been right all along, and join us! After all, the virus has certainly accelerated the decline, and highlighted both how incapable most countries are of investing in their infrastructure, and how they reach for authoritarian measures first.</p><p>Convinced that the virus is the magic bullet for the triumph of their ideology, various groups have embraced increasingly hysterical positions in a desperate attempt to get people on their side. Some demand more and more restrictions, more lockdowns, completely failing to understand how sick people are of being isolated, how much they resent having their day-to-day civil liberties stripped away. They mock everyone who is uncomfortable with the idea of having to show their papers to be allowed to enter a shop — or to leave the house. They belittle people who struggle with the impact of an unprecedented period of isolation, of the suspension of social life, even though this has led to countless suicides, and to the horror of people not being allowed to visit their dying loved ones. Even though only a year ago they were claiming that vaccines would never be ready by December 2020, that Trump was lying and any vaccine produced while he was President would likely be fake, they disparage the people who have fallen for the anti-vaccination grifters. A recipe for political catastrophe.</p><p>The other side of the coin, meanwhile, is those who see all these problems and embrace the opposite end of the spectrum, dismissing the vaccines as evil pharmacorp products, insisting the virus is harmless and all measures are pointless, mocking people who are worried at all. But though they are more likely to gain some measure of support from a tired and alienated population, this particular set of lies is no magic bullet either, and anyone who thinks that they can attach a real political project to this mix of legitimate concerns, hoaxes, grifts, and outright claptrap is entirely deluded.</p><p>At the end of the day, a simple truth remains. If you cannot convince people that a better world is possible, give them a believable idea of what that world looks like, and convince them that your movement or your ideology <em>can actually lead to that world</em>, you will fail. Getting ordinary people on your side is the only measure of success. Nothing, and I mean nothing, can replace actual politics. Not art, not theory, not moralism. Nor can you simply <em>tell </em>people what to do. If you want a different future, and God knows we need one, you have to convince people to help you build it.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=12e61cfd21e7" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Justice]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/justice-f0e5ba0fba68?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/f0e5ba0fba68</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 01 Sep 2021 09:40:08 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-09-01T09:50:00.341Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>You can tell a lot about a society, and a political movement, by its attitute to those citizens who have committed crimes.</p><p>Historically, a law-and-order mentality has been associated with the Right. The Right demands harsher sentences, believes criminals are inherently bad people, questions the presumption of innocence, and argues (against all evidence) that punishment works as a deterrent.</p><p>The Left, historically, has opposed this, arguing that most crimes are the result of material conditions, the vast majority of criminals are just ordinary people, and that when more extreme behaviour occurs it is the result of mental health problems, not an inherent “evil” of some kind.</p><p>It is a distressing fact of the current political landscape that much of what calls itself “the Left” no longer supports any of these notions, and instead agrees in principle with the Right, changing only the superficial characteristics of who is to be identified as The Bad People Who Threaten Us.</p><p>I remember the moral panic about Albanian rapists in 1990s Greece. It was obvious that this was racist propaganda, a typical narrative aimed at immigrants or minorities in many countries; the precise ethnic identity doesn’t really matter, it’s just a convenient way of demonizing people while making everyone afraid.</p><p>And yet now what calls itself the Left happily embraces the same trick. All the old arguments about what the statistics actually show, about how the problem isn’t evil people prowling about in the dark, no longer apply. And oddly enough, the “leftists” who act in the exact same way as the far right then claim to support restorative justice. Some of them even claim to support prison abolition!</p><p>The same people who think it’s right to fire someone for the slightest infraction of their extremely academic codes of morality, who think that there should never be any forgiveness for anyone who has been publicly shamed, claim to support the rights of prisoners.</p><p>Who do they think prisoners are? Who do they think commits crimes?</p><p>Maybe the fantasy is that they’re all gentle innocent giants played by Michael Clarke Duncan, who will be appropriately grateful for a job as a cleaner when they get out — as long as they don’t move to the wrong neighbourhood, you know, the sort where they wouldn’t fit in. Like where these people live.</p><p>Because you know that people who report Twitter accounts for ban evasion, who tweet at others to demand they stop following a person they consider a sinner, who insist people they deem bad should be fired or deplatformed— people, that is, willing to cast others out even before they’ve been charged with a crime, let alone convicted and sentenced to jail time — will never, ever countenance having to treat the majority of ex-cons as humans.</p><p>Because the majority of ex-cons fall into categories these people hate: lower-class, uneducated, uncouth. Damaged, if only by the experience of prison. They probably believe in all kinds of offensive stuff. And, get this: <em>they’ve done crimes!</em> When you can’t forgive someone for saying a bad word when they were twelve, or behaving inappropriately when drunk, or having emotionally hurt people… imagine when you find out about people <em>breaking the law!</em> Some of them may have even <em>killed </em>someone. Do you think that someone who believes that drunkenly propositioning a person you’re attracted to should mean exile from society is interested in working at the same job as someone who has actually permanently ended someone’s life?</p><p>I mean, just look at the mob of self-righteous middle-class crusaders that went after Alice Sheldon’s legacy, demanding the James Tiptree Jr. Award (named after her pseudonym/persona) be renamed because she killed her husband in what was with 99.99% likelihood a suicide pact. But even if it wasn’t, in which case it was a choice made by an old, suffering, depressed woman. She was found lying in bed with her husband, holding his hand. Imagine a person who would organize to ensure this woman’s legacy doesn’t stain their precious brand. Do you think this person, who most likely claims to believe in restorative justice, would allow a criminal into their smug little part of society?</p><p>No. At best, ex-cons should only ever get menial jobs, somewhere far away, where their existence can be morally pleasing but unthreatening. And they shouldn’t get any ideas about trying to make something of themselves, because if they ever find any level of success, they will be hounded and destroyed by champions of restorative justice. Zero forgiveness. You think they were vicious when they went after Alice Sheldon? Imagine the level of viciousness that’s reserved for an immigrant, maybe one with personal beliefs that aren’t entirely in line with what’s taught at the elite American universities he could never attend.</p><p>A core principle of a democratic society is this: when you commit a crime against that society, there is a response. We can choose, as a society, whether that response is a punishment, based on the idea that you are bad, or an attempt to help you, based on the idea that you are broken. After that period of punishment or restoration is over, however, you are an ordinary citizen like any other. That’s why we talk about a “debt to society.” You messed up, you harmed the group you are part of, and now you have to make up for it. And once you have done so, the debt is gone, and everything returns to normal.</p><p>It’s bad enough that most countries choose punishment over restoration, given that the evidence points heavily towards the latter being infinitely more effective. (We know why: prisons are a money-making machine for private interests, and the overall threat of imprisonment also keeps the population in check.) But to see people who claim to be “radical leftists” embrace an ideology that empowers the carceral system and opposes democratic rights is depressing and infuriating in equal measure.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=f0e5ba0fba68" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Lost Souls]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/lost-souls-acd029bd40c?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/acd029bd40c</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 17 Aug 2021 21:23:06 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-08-17T21:52:44.215Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/1000/1*lyRxovFq5FpD5qVkl2iabQ.jpeg" /></figure><p>There’s an old essay by Freddie deBoer that I think about a lot. It includes this paragraph:</p><blockquote>[…] we can’t simultaneously be a movement based on rehabilitation and restorative justice AND a viciously judgmental moral aristocracy. You know who thinks everybody’s guilty until proven innocent? Cops. You know who thinks people don’t deserve the right to defend themselves? Cops. You know who says those who defend basic fairness and due process are as bad as criminals themselves? Cops.</blockquote><p>I think about the people who patrol others’ Twitter accounts to make sure they don’t follow any proscribed accounts, any people who have been rendered non-beings, subhuman, cast out from human society. I try to understand that mentality, that desire for domination. It makes me sick.</p><p>I also think about those who make a big show of prostrating themselves before the moral authorities of the day, fully knowing the hypocrisy of what they do. Knowing they’ve sinned themselves, knowing the people they’re bowing to believe in absolutely nothing but power, knowing all of this is just a big theatrical performance.</p><p>And yet theatre comes out of religion, and I wonder if they think paying obeisance will make it true, will make them good people and give them all the things they’re hoping they’ll get by humbling themselves, even though they know on some level that these moral authorities would throw them to the wolves without even hesitating.</p><p>Is the cruelty part of the attraction? Hoping that you’ll be the special one, the one who will be singled out and treated differently, lifted up above the rest?</p><p>Is it a kind of religious ecstasy for these people, their hands trembling as they post about the latest bad person who must be castigated? Or is it secret and nasty and masturbatory, because they know that they couldn’t explain any of it to a normal person, that anyone who’s suffered the real hardship of ordinary working life would just laugh at their academic language and their obscure, incomprehensible definitions of sin?</p><p>It’s odd to think that people who grew up exposed to the same stories of injustice we all were, the same warnings about self-righteous inquisitors who know no mercy, would go on to openly celebrate every single thing the oppressed and exploited of this world have fought against, while simultaneously perceiving themselves as fighting for that very side whose history they are trampling.</p><p>What does that kind of internal contradiction do to your mind?</p><p>And how do you get there from the person you were 5 or 10 years ago, when all of this was still obvious? And what do you surrender in terms of integrity to do so?</p><p>I wonder what it’ll cost artists in particular. I know what it costs now not to participate, to stick to unfashionable democratic principles, but what will taking part cost in the long run? What will it mean to have named names, to have hounded people, to have put yourself above the processes of justice? To have supported the belief that punishment acts as deterrent when that’s the oldest conservative lie in the book <em>and that’s exactly what you were supposed to be against? </em>When the very existence of your belief system, in a way, was predicated on not thinking that way?</p><p>I believe that it’s the best in us that leads us to create art — even those of us who are more broken than others — and I will never judge anyone’s art by their personal follies.</p><p>Still, I can’t help but wonder if there isn’t a toll. There’s a difference for artists, I think, between a genuine belief, even if it’s extreme and dogmatic, and deliberate propaganda. There’s a fakeness that creeps into works created by people who don’t really believe which becomes more apparent with time. What seems perfectly in line with popular orthodoxy now will stick out like a sore thumb in twenty years, and seem downright mad in a hundred.</p><p>Of course, not everyone cares. There are artists who proudly “write for the market” — and before long nobody but the market will remember their works. But there are people who have a genuine spark, who could have created great things if only they had tried just a little harder to stick to their principles, if only they’d cared a little less about appearances and a little more about truth.</p><p>Or kindness. I’d take kindness over truth.</p><p>Consorting with sinners is never popular in the present, and yet we look back at those who did so with far more admiration than for those who sought out harsher punishments for the guilty. Who has less hope to offer the world than the person who does not believe in redemption?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=acd029bd40c" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[How To Be A Good Person While Existing Within Time]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/how-to-be-a-good-person-while-existing-within-time-7774ff309295?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/7774ff309295</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 26 Jul 2021 14:41:29 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-07-26T14:41:29.412Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Here are three simple propositions:</p><ol><li>Most of the people who have ever lived have held reactionary social views.</li><li>At the time, those views were not considered reactionary. Sometimes they were considered progressive.</li><li>If you had been born into a different time, you would also have shared these reactionary social views.</li></ol><p>It therefore follows that:</p><ol><li>Some of the views you hold now are likely reactionary, even if you think they are progressive.</li></ol><p>After all, you can’t really tell what will be considered reactionary 200 years from now. It may be things that seem entirely normal to you. It’s an annoying feeling, to realize that the present is only a moment in historical time, that you are not the culmination of all human thought. But you’re not. All of this is going to be old hat pretty soon.</p><p>It seems prudent, therefore, to have a little humility, and a little compassion too. When you look back at the people who thought they ought to be the only arbiters of public morality… they don’t look too good, do they? They look pretty conservative, even the progressive ones.</p><p>You know what’s really timeless, though? Food. Shelter. Health. Material things, that is. People always need those, and they will always need them, and making sure they have those things has never been bad. You’ll never read the biography of a dead person and suddenly go “oh no, this person supported the poor, how terrible of them.”</p><p>In fact, a funny little thing is that you don’t even need to be progressive to do progressive things while trying to accomplish universal goals. The Soviets decriminalized homosexuality in 1917; some of them held reactionary views on homosexuality, but they did it anyway, because they believed that trying to enforce personal morality was not the job of the state. (The Stalinists who brought back persecution, on the other hand, were big on morality and opposed universal goals.)</p><p>How will history judge you? You can’t know. Maybe something you believe, something everyone you know believes, will turn out to be horribly wrong. Maybe some movement or ideology you support will be remembered as disastrous and awful, and people in the future will shake their heads and wonder how you could’ve fallen for that. It’s entirely possible. I mean, it’s happened to almost every single human being who has ever lived.</p><p>Unless you think you’re perfect, you’ve figured it all out, and human history ends with you. Or you are the one exception, the one person who has discovered the perfect morality. Doesn’t seem likely, does it? Chances are there’s stuff you’ve gotten wrong. Did you believe everything you believe now ten years ago? Twenty? What would you have believed if you’d been around a century ago? Ten centuries?</p><p>You can, of course, only do the best you can with what you’re given. But since there’s no way for you to be perfect, since you’re only a human being trapped in a specific moment in time, maybe you can remember that everybody else is also only a human being, in the now and in the past. And maybe you can learn from the past, and instead of trying to fix the morality of human beings, which has literally never led to anything except bloodshed and misery and oppression, you can try to fix the material conditions in which we are forced to exist. Help make this moment in time more bearable for everyone, help people have the material security that allows them to make choices more freely, and then let every person attend to their own morality.</p><p>Helping everyone also helps people who may be bad, but really, it’s the only way to be sure.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=7774ff309295" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Necessary Hostility]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/the-necessary-hostility-ca41f23a571e?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/ca41f23a571e</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[art]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 17 Feb 2021 12:47:01 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2021-02-17T13:42:42.309Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I struggle with how terrible things are, and with the amount of hostility that I think is necessary.</p><p>I’m not talking about performatively scolding individual people, about “cancelling” whoever is the scapegoat of the day, or of constant displays of narcissism disguised as emotional fragility. No, what I think is necessary is a ruthless hostility towards <em>everything as it now is</em>. This is as true of politics as it is of art.</p><p>In politics, it’s popular to moan about things being bad, but most of the time that simply means moaning about Donald Trump’s lack of decorum. That’s irrelevant. Trump is a blip, and once he’s gone the exact same policies will continue and the media will stop caring. And that’s precisly my point. It’s not Trump. It’s not Biden. It’s not Bolsonaro or Merkel or whoever. It’s the whole damn thing. Everything is so profoundly rotten, from the press to the courts to this parody of democracy we inhabit, that even expressing that rot in the conventional language of politics is misleading.</p><p>People panicking about the rise of fascism are missing the point. Things are much worse than that. We’re looking at the slow, miserable, drawn-out collapse of modern civilization. We’re replaying the descent into the Middle Ages. It’s not dramatic, like in a film. There are no compelling villains. It’s just the gradual and moronic accumulation of the right material conditions. We worship the algorithm and the algorithm does what it does.</p><p>And the thing is, just like back then, everyone wants to believe in the half-baked solutions that don’t require fundamental change. And the system gladly sells you a vast gamut of “radical” figures that will change absolutely nothing. It sells you identity politics, in both left-wing and right-wing flavours. It sells you culture wars. It sells you a million ways of feeling emotionally entangled, because after all this person is a bigot and that person is outrageous and did you know that so-and-so lied and so-and-so cheated and and and?</p><p>And if you deviate just a little from the bland centrist nightmare of the last few decades, than you feel like a radical, because pseudo-radicalism is a heavily-marketed brand, and so you think it’s amazing that you retweeted AOC or that you listened to Jordan Peterson and there’s all these emotions and all this antagonism and you are invested in defending your values and you don’t see that it’s the same, it’s all the same shit with slightly different packaging.</p><p>Of course you want to scream no, it’s not, because these people are good, and these other people are bad! “I may not agree with all their ideas but…” And so the system gets you, because in this way you don’t notice that they’re just the same bland centrist nightmare reheated and fundamentally they all agree on how the system should be run. One of them will run a fundraiser for veterans and the other for LGBT youth but both will drop the same bombs, both will let you be exploited, and if you ever get any ideas about being free both will crush you in a second.</p><p>But one of them will pretend to be sad about it.</p><p>And that’s the thing, we need to be hostile, completely and utterly hostile to this entire circus, because there isn’t one side of the ruling class that’s for us and another that’s against us. And most of what calls itself “the Left” just wants to manage the working class in a different way than the Right. But that’s what they are: managers. Having a better manager is not freedom.</p><p>But it’s hard to talk about this. It’s exhausting, and it’s alienating. Because it’s so much easier to say oh, did you see the horrible things some conservative said about whoever is the current version of Obama or Tsipras or Corbyn or Sanders or AOC or AMLO or? I mean that’s outrageous, and if the Right hates him, that must mean he/she’s on our side, despite the political differences I have with him/her, and I can’t just let this slide, that would coarsen the discourse, so… and on and on and on.</p><p>And I don’t know how you stop this, I don’t know how you break out of that cycle of always falling for the next fucker who doesn’t give a shit about you but whose performative half-arsed “radicalism” gets a response, and then a counter-response, and so on.</p><p>And in the arts? God, in the fucking arts.</p><p>The sheer gutlessness of contemporary art is astounding. The disconnect between artists and the real world. Between artists and anything that is of aesthetic or intellectual value. The takeover of the arts by utterly narcissistic, even sociopathic middle-class liberals with no stakes in anything except their own careers has had a disastrous effect. The embrace of reactionary anti-humanist ideologies, ongoing since the 60s and culminating in postmodernism, has resulted in artists uniquely incapable of dealing with the present moment in history.</p><p>The vast majority of art produced today is insufferably banal, inhumane, and incompetent. It is adolescent garbage. And the state of criticism is even more dire, meaning that good art, when it exists, is generally dismissed, buried, or outright attacked.</p><p>“But hasn’t it always been exactly like this?”</p><p>That’s the line we’re sold, another variation of the end of history, except in this case history never even began, and any analysis can be dismissed because things have always been exactly the same.</p><p>Because God help us if we actually looked at ourselves in history, if we actually thought about things in detail instead of resorting to such pseudo-worldly platitudes, if we actually <em>demanded</em> something of ourselves.</p><p>And hostility is the only way. You can’t slowly increment yourself out of banal garbage. The fundamentals are broken. The parody of art we live with, much like the parody of democracy we’re trapped in, is built on a rejection of the very core of what art is. Talent. Vision. A drive greater and more profound than careerism or hollow moralism.</p><p>But again, it’s exhausting, and it’s alienating. Because the truth is so much worse than the half-baked criticisms we sometimes allow ourselves. Those criticisms exist to relieve pressure, to at least admit a little bit of what’s wrong and <em>in doing so preserve the existing sitution</em>. We can’t admit just how fundamentally terrible contemporary criticism is. We can’t admit that things that bear moral signifiers are actually often not just banal, but downright misanthropic. We certainly can’t talk about class and the sheer hatred of the working class present in so much art. We can’t admit how many lauded artists aren’t just “not to my taste” but utterly, irredeemably shit. We can’t even admit that most films produced nowadays are just propagandistic commercials aimed at children, more ideologically constrained even than what was produced in the Soviet Union.</p><p>What’s your favourite cinematic universe, Lockheed Martin or Northrop Grumman?</p><p>We have to be polite. We have to pretend to appreciate the garbage. We have to pretend to agree with the moralistic nonsense designed purely to serve the ruling class.</p><p>Oh, we can be angry. Anger sells, if it’s packaged in the correct language, if it’s aspirational, if it’s vague in just the right way. After all, most stuff can be sold. Che Guevara makes a great T-shirt. “I’m an angry oppressed middle-class person who speaks about the Big Issues” is a very popular brand right now. It spawns essays, podcasts, Twitter accounts, books, even some TV shows. Every now and then a politician even says “fuck” about some culture war issue that their base is invested in.</p><p>That’s why the necessary hostility to the present state of affairs must be cold, analytical, and profound. Why we must utterly reject the corporate drivel, and the performances of morality, and the quasi-religious misanthropy, and all their insipid pseudo-intellectual defense mechanisms that have infected our thinking.</p><p>But who wants to walk that path? It’s nothing but pain. It’s how you get called an arrogant asshole. It’s often how you lose the opportunity to make any art at all. It’s how you get branded a reactionary by people who call themselves progressives while advocating views that belong in the 18th century.</p><p>I don’t know. I just don’t know.</p><p>Maybe if enough people walk that path together. Maybe if enough of us aren’t just hostile to the current state of affairs, but present an alternative. Maybe if enough of us can say no, this is not the way to go. We’ve taken a wrong turn and we need to get the fuck out of here.</p><p>Maybe.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=ca41f23a571e" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Socialism Without Socialism]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/socialism-without-socialism-3ecf534deb98?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3ecf534deb98</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 06 May 2020 15:24:34 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2020-05-06T15:24:34.565Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I have a terminology problem.</p><p>I used to call myself a socialist; I picked this over communist because the latter made people think of Stalinism, which is the exact antithesis of everything I believe in. Sometimes I used the term Marxist, because that seemed more precise: class struggle, materialist conception of history, etc. Sure, some right-wingers had completely deranged ideas of what being a Marxist was, from thinking it meant “the state should control everything” to thinking it was something like Scandinavian social democracy.</p><p>These terms were already confusing back then, particularly thanks to academia. Academic liberals had long ago adopted “leftist” terms, completely draining them of their original meaning in the process. The dreadful and idiotic Theodor Adorno, for example, is considered a Marxist, which is absurd to even contemplate. We laugh at terms like “cultural Marxist” deployed at random by the Right, but honestly, even though it’s a contradiction in terms (actual Marxist analysis is about economic conditions, not culture war bullshit), there are entire generations of academics who produced rubbish as meaningless and opportunistic as any postmodernist’s drivel and called it Marxist.</p><p>Of course, even Marx thought the term Marxist was useless and derided the people who had adopted it.</p><p>But with the rise of what I can only describe as the new American pseudo-leftism, a confused sort of liberalism that’s adopted its self-image from how the Republicans see it, and which is spearheaded by grifters loyal to the Democratic Party, the terms have become even more useless. There are now masses of people who call themselves Marxist who oppose the most fundamental precepts of Marx’s thought. Who put some fetishistic conception of “Mother Nature” above humanity, who oppose growth, who think class is just one of many categories of oppression, who think ideology is what moves society, and so on.</p><p>At this point people always say “but you have so much in common! why can’t you ignore these differences? does it all have to be about purity?” Which is a silly framing: it’s not about purity, it’s about goals.</p><p>If you think growth is bad, if you think individual freedom is optional, if you think the presumption of innocence should be surrendered, if you want a world with fewer humans, less technology… then you want the <em>opposite </em>of what I want. I cannot stress this enough: <strong>I considerably prefer capitalism to most of the visions of a “leftist” or “socialist” society being promoted today.</strong> They have nothing in common with the humanistic, libertarian, Promethean socialism I embrace.</p><p>So I’m stuck. All of a sudden “socialism” and even “Marxism” has become popular, but it no longer means anything except reading Jacobin and voting for the same parties you always voted for. The very people who called me a “brocialist” and “manarchist” (even though I’m not even remotely an anarchist and not much of a “bro”) now call themselves socialists. It’s all reached a level of absurdity that’s tiresome and depressing.</p><p>How, under these ridiculous conditions, can we continue the struggle for what socialism once represented? I don’t know. But somehow rekindling or reclaiming the vision of socialism as rooted in human achievement and human liberty is one of the awful and necessary tasks of our time.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3ecf534deb98" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Sex Work: Moralism, Markets & Marxism]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/sex-work-moralism-markets-marxism-30ba3ef4d036?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/30ba3ef4d036</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[sex-work]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[feminism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[marxism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Mon, 02 Oct 2017 16:52:11 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-10-02T16:52:11.732Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>The issue of sex work and how it should be treated by society has long been controversial, particularly on the Left. While generally rejecting the conservative view that sex workers are themselves immoral (and filthy, dangerous, evil, etc.), progressives and liberals of various stripes have nevertheless struggled to find a common approach. Even in feminist circles, radically different views continue to clash on this subject. Meanwhile, as academics and activists debate morality, sex workers continue to be faced with violence and exploitation.</p><p>This is where the socialist — or more accurately, Marxist — approach to sex work becomes relevant.</p><p>It would be impossible to talk about every single political approach to sex work there is, but I think it’s fair to identify two broad streams of thought. In their extreme forms (which are common), they go like this:</p><ul><li>[The Moralistic Approach] All sex workers are inherently victims. All sex work is inherently violent. There is no difference between sex trafficking, prostitution and pornography.</li><li>[The Market Approach] There is a clear distinction between sex workers and victims of sex trafficking. Sex workers have agency and choose to do the work they do. Sex work is just another capitalist market.</li></ul><p>Proponents of the former view (frequently radical feminists) favour a variety of solutions; many support laws that criminalize sex work, some support laws that semi-decriminalize it (like the Nordic model), while a few support fully decriminalizing it. Proponents of the latter (frequently sex workers or activists) generally favour decriminalization.</p><p>Both approaches present certain problems.</p><p>The flaws of the criminalization approach — including the Nordic model, which “only” criminalizes paying for sex — are fairly obvious: it utterly fails to protect sex workers, pushing their work underground and making them much easier to harm and exploit, stigmatizes them on a personal/cultural level, and even normalizes violence against sex workers (since it doesn’t distinguish between sex work and rape). Decriminalization allows for regulation, safety standards, legal recourse in case of violence, and has many other benefits that make a sex worker’s life safer and easier. Moralists who condemn sex work may argue that this normalizes an abusive practice, but not only do they utterly fail to account for women’s agency, they also fail to account for the fact that trying to ban sex work simply doesn’t stop it. Thus we have to ask ourselves whether the goal is to actually protect women — or to perform a ritual of public condemnation to prove one’s progressive credentials.</p><p>The second approach, while certainly far less hypocritical, does come with some flaws as well. In a capitalist economy where the basic rights of people are not guaranteed, where unemployment is high and jobs are scarce, a person’s choices are not necessarily as voluntary as they appear. When the alternatives are starvation or homelessness (for yourself or your children), freedom is an illusion. It is not a coincidence that increased austerity results in increased sex work: people need work, and when they don’t have a choice, they’ll do sex work as well. That’s not to say all people who do sex work do it for that reason; but it’s impossible to argue that it’s not a common reason. There is a danger of ignoring this aspect of the problem when (justifiably) trying to address the unjust socio-cultural treatment of sex workers.</p><p>Proponents of decriminalization disagree on another issue: legalization. It’s possible to get rid of laws that criminalize sex work without actually making new laws that control it specifically. While laws can create health and safety frameworks that make a huge difference to sex workers, some argue that this creates a two-tier system which leaves all those who don’t meet the correct criteria (such as illegal immigrants) in a vulnerable position. This is partially true, but even if sex work is treated as simply another job in the national capitalist system, without any specific regulation, that doesn’t make those particularly vulnerable groups (which, statistically speaking, are often involved in sex work) any safer. That the existing type of nation state is bad at regulating something does not mean that market-based chaos is a better or more humane alternative.</p><p>The Marxist approach to sex work is simple in its universality and humanism: the part of “sex worker” that matters to Marxists is <strong>worker</strong>. Marxism fundamentally rejects any and all attempts to impose moralistic beliefs about sexuality on people, and especially the notion that people should be categorized around such issues in political or socio-economic terms. It’s not that Marxism is pro-sex or anti-sex: it’s that it places the freedom of the individual above such concerns. As far as Marxist theory is concerned, sex workers are doing a job, and the purpose of Marxism is to end the exploitation of all workers, no matter what their jobs are. (Note, however, that “exploitation” here has a very specific meaning: not unfairness or immorality, but the capitalist’s theft of the surplus value produced by the worker. In other words, you don’t get paid for the work you do.) Whether the worker is being exploited by a factory owner or a strip club owner makes no difference — the economic mechanics are the same.</p><p>But Marxism also has no illusions in the nation state, and makes no distinction between workers from this country or that, legal or illegal. The scope of its vision is what makes it challenging to implement, but it’s also what makes it actually capable of causing meaningful change. Marxism isn’t trying to help this one group of sex workers as opposed to the rest. It’s not trying to make a moral argument to those in power that they should be nicer to sex workers. It is radically, steadfastly dedicated to the rights of workers, to organizing workers, to giving workers control over their own lives and their own jobs. Its power is precisely in refusing to exclude sex workers, much as it must refuse to exclude illegal immigrants or anyone else whose work falls into a category that makes them easier to exploit.</p><p>In the end, the needs of sex workers are the needs of all workers: self-determination, health, safety, leisure, social equality. Will people still choose to be sex workers once they have achieved these things? The Marxist answer is a shrug. Who cares? If the conditions exist for people to be able to freely choose, then it’s not up to anyone to judge them. If they don’t have that freedom, then the only correct attitude towards sex workers is the same we have towards every other worker, from the factory labourer to the programmer:<strong> unconditional solidarity</strong>.</p><p>This universalism is both goal and necessity for the socialist movement. Without rejecting divisions, it’s impossible to build a movement that can seriously challenge the fundamental structure of the global economy. But building this movement based on our common, objective needs is also our very best chance to overcome centuries of propaganda and prejudice. The fact that our lives are so defined by our work is what oppresses us, but it’s also what can free us, what can overcome the walls that have been built between us.</p><p>Any movement that calls itself socialist or Marxist that fails to embrace the full radicalism of such a universalist perspective is not only untrue to the systems of thought it claims to stand for, but also doomed to fail.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=30ba3ef4d036" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Everything You Give Them Can And Will Be Used Against You]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/everything-you-give-them-can-and-will-be-used-against-you-9f56181029d0?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/9f56181029d0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[free-speech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 28 Jun 2017 09:00:39 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-28T09:00:39.689Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>There’s a reason that unconditional support for the concept of free speech has been a defining characteristic of left-wing thought for centuries. Beyond the principle of the thing — and the principle certainly matters — there is the matter of <em>power</em>. And there’s a very simple fact about power: <strong>when power is given, power will be used.</strong></p><p>Those now making arguments against free speech, ostensibly from a “left-wing” position, are seeking to expand the authority of the system — a system they themselves on other occasions will characterize as oppressive, inherently reactionary, and so on. Yet somehow they imagine that when they give more power to that system to control speech, to prohibit “offensive” ideas, to punish verbal transgressions in a material way (such as taking away someone’s ability to make a living), that this additional authority will be used for progressive purposes only.</p><p>One is reminded of those defending President Obama’s expansion of the surveillance apparatus who were then shocked to realize said apparatus would be inherited by President Trump, desperately urging Obama in the last days of his presidency to dismantle what he’d spent years building. As it turned out, political structures that are useful to the system don’t just go away when the superficial flavour of politics changes. <strong>Systems don’t let go of power.</strong></p><p>Every inch of ground you cede on the matter of free speech will come back to haunt you. Every “victory” against a despised individual will turn to ten people whose work you value being fired for views you never thought were controversial. Every protection against hate speech will be used to silence criticism of those who thrive on hate.</p><p>There are countless examples already. There will be many, many more as the world slides deeper and deeper into crises that cannot be resolved without systemic change.</p><p><strong>The structures of authority in this world are not on your side.</strong> Whether it’s the government or the university board — their interests are not your interests. Yes, they will happily go along with your campaign when it’s convenient. They’ll tell you just how much they oppose sexism and racism, and how these new regulations will make everything better while coincidentally giving them more power to clamp down on expression.</p><p>Until you say something about police violence. Or Israel. Or a pipeline. Or the latest war. Or any of the dozens of topics that have gotten left-wing people fired or punished.</p><p>And do you think the far right will stay away from the tools you’ve handed the very system that helped create them? Do you think they won’t present themselves as the victims of violence and persecution? Do you think the system won’t find some “respectable” fascists who don’t deserve your intolerant liberal abuse? What could make anyone think that, when faced with an existential crisis, an inherently right-wing system will swing towards the left? When two groups are claiming to be oppressed and persecuted, why would the system ever support the one that is critical of so many aspects of society? Why not go with the law-and-order option? Why not go with those willing to defend the absolute rule of capital?</p><p>(Did you know that Germany, a country with open censorship of the arts, has a domestic security agency called the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, which amongst other things is meant to fight Neonazis? Do you know what they actually do? They harass left-wing groups while funding and protecting Neonazis, even when they murder people. Germany, in many ways, is the perfect example of what English and American liberals want to create. Google “Alternative für Deutschland” to see how well that works.)</p><p>If you want to seize power and change the system at its core, defeat the opposition structurally, politically, and intellectually — go ahead, I’m with you. But if you think you can win by petitioning the existing system, by adding to its authority, then you are handing ammunition to the very forces that are going to destroy you.</p><p>Unless you compromise, of course. Those who oppose free speech most frequently do so because they don’t have anything to say.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=9f56181029d0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Free Speech and the Means of Communication]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/free-speech-and-the-means-of-communication-3dedd9debe0?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/3dedd9debe0</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[free-speech]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 22 Jun 2017 08:22:28 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-06-22T08:22:28.799Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>[Note: This is an older blog post, but since the topic keeps coming up, I thought it was worth putting up here. I’ve made very minor edits.]</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/566/0*ECPaDHJLTxQCY1_W.png" /></figure><p>This XKCD comic tends to pop up whenever there is another campaign to oust someone from a position because of their views (or views falsely attributed to them). There is obviously a great deal that could be written about those campaigns themselves, but what I want to talk about here is a deeper flaw in the political logic of the argument being presented.</p><p>The understanding of free speech the comic promotes is fatally undermined by the fact that <strong>the means of communication are privately owned</strong>.</p><p>Look at that first panel again. The basis of the argument is that “the right to free speech means the government can’t arrest you for what you say.” In the context of capitalism, that’s an incredibly reductionist definition. If speech is supposed to be free, we must ask: who owns the means by which speech is expressed and transmitted in the modern world? Who owns the newspapers? Who owns the TV channels? Who owns Twitter? Who owns Facebook? Who owns the film production studios? Who owns the ISPs? And so on. The answer is always the same: not the government. Not the people, either. All of these things are owned by capital. All of these things are industries.</p><p>So, in a situation where public discourse takes place in privately-owned spaces, how are the handful of people who ultimately own most of the media any different from a government? Apart from the lack of any kind of system of democratic control or a pretense of accountability, that is.</p><p>An old example of this is the Hollywood blacklist, in which people who were suspected of being leftists (or “communist sympathizers”) were prevented from working or receiving credit for their work. This is a classical example of censorship, and yet, according to the XKCD comic, it’s actually not a free speech issue at all, since it was a private initiative and not something forced onto Hollywood by the House Committee on Un-American Activities. Yes, all that happened was that some powerful people in Hollywood thought that leftists were assholes, and showed them the door.</p><p>A newer example would be anything to do with Wikileaks or the War on Terror. When Twitter “disappears” trending topics about Chelsea Manning or Julian Assange or proof of various government-committed crimes against humanity, is that censorship? Not according to XKCD, because the government isn’t forcing them to do it. It just so happens that the political interests of capital are the same as those of a capitalist government, and so they act to protect each other. Twitter just thinks that dissenters are assholes, and is showing them the door.</p><p>But where are the public alternatives to Twitter or Facebook? Sure, you can kick somebody who’s annoying you out of your garden, but what happens when your garden is also the agora? What happens when the location of public discourse is not public?</p><p>Ultimately, what this comic is selling is a strange libertarian capitalist fantasy of freedom, where freedom is defined solely as freedom from government interference, but <strong>freedom from the structures of authority produced by the accumulation of capital</strong> is never considered.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=3dedd9debe0" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Voting, Democracy, and the People]]></title>
            <link>https://jonaskyratzes.medium.com/voting-democracy-and-the-people-e2603b5d8aa?source=rss-67f3865081a8------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e2603b5d8aa</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[politics]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[elections]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[democracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[voting]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[socialism]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonas Kyratzes]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Thu, 11 May 2017 16:14:30 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2017-05-11T16:14:30.952Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>Whenever another election nears, the world fills up with paeans to the power of voting and doom-filled laments about people failing to do their democratic duty. Whenever someone suggests that people should actively avoid voting, no matter how they arrived at this conclusion, they are immediately hit by an immense amount of outrage, usually expressed through various adages about apathy and “getting the governments you deserve.”</p><p>When it comes to voting, it would seem, everyone believes that democracy is sacred. (Less so, one might observe, when it comes to basic rights like privacy.)</p><p>But democracy is a lot more than voting. In fact, the name itself doesn’t directly say anything about voting; it refers to the power of the people (the <em>demos</em>). Abraham Lincoln most famously described the nature of democracy as “government of the people, by the people, for the people.” That is, a government not only controlled by the people and made up of the people, but also <em>acting in service of the people</em>.</p><p>It’s hard to argue that such a thing currently exists, or is represented by the current system of elections. In most cases, people are asked to choose between representatives of a financial elite whose interests are exactly opposed to those of the people. Frequently these candidates even form part of a political dynasty, being the second or third of fifth person by that name to rule the country. Choosing which quasi-aristocrat gets to be king is not democracy; it’s monarchy disguised as reality television.</p><p>On a fundamental structural level, the voting process is itself geared towards producing the desired results, as various complex, bizarre laws (from what is necessary for a party to be put on ballots to how votes are actually counted) give major advantages to the bigger, established parties. The details vary from country to country, but it’s rarely a clean, straightforward process.</p><p>To the degree that any democratic process exists, it is strongly distorted by the power of capital. With most of the world’s wealth owned by a minuscule fraction of the population, in a system that has profit as its core mechanism, the financial elite can push forward the candidates of its preference through mass media, tours, and direct corruption. When parties do exist that attempt to represent the interests of the people, their voices will simply not be heard, or campaigns of misinformation will portray them as dangerous or ridiculous. (Who can forget the media’s obsession with what sort of shirts Yanis Varoufakis wore?) Meanwhile, in times of crisis, when it appears that the regular political entities are not extreme enough in punishing opposition to the system, the financial elites will begin to strongly promote fascist entities, giving them airtime and slowly legitimizing their views.</p><p>Even when popular discontent is strong enough to push the establishment parties out of power, popular sovereignty is near to nonexistent. Vast swathes of policy are not determined by elected officials, but by unaccountable transnational organizations, corporate courts, trade agreements, and so on. In the EU, for example, it would be technically illegal for a government to implement any policies that fall outside of neoliberal capitalism. That is to say, not only would a change in economic system be forbidden, even if people vote for it, but even a different track within the same system (such as the various social-democratic paradigms Europe once espoused) are out of the question. The choice is only between various flavours of the same thing.</p><p>When an attempt is made to question such antidemocratic systems, the response is a mix of contempt and brutality. Voters are openly told by governing bureaucrats that they made “the wrong choice” and either blackmailed (as in the case of Greece) or just made to vote again (as in Ireland), all the while being terrorized by mass media predictions of doom should the vote not go as desired.</p><p>To describe such a process as “democracy” in any but the most superficial of senses is absurd, as is the notion that refusing to participate in this charade somehow constitutes a rejection of one’s rights as a citizen. If none of the things above were true, if there was actually such a thing as popular sovereignty, then perhaps the usual lament of “if only people voted!” would be accurate. Given the circumstances, it is not.</p><p>However, questioning the value of voting in the current system is not identical to abandoning democracy. If we keep to Lincoln’s definition of democracy — government <em>of</em> the people, <em>by</em> the people, <em>for</em> the people — then democracy can be fought for in entirely different ways. The people still run the entire machinery of industry. Everything real that is produced by our society is produced through the work of ordinary people. Financial elites, living off exploiting the labour of others, are by definition not indispensable. But without working people, nothing runs. That gives the people an incredible amount of untapped power, which can be harnessed not through voting, but through <em>organization</em>. The power of labour is the heart of democracy, and through it — through claiming power, not begging for it — the system can be changed so that it does truly become democratic.</p><p>Precisely because elites fear this power, society is regularly bombarded with a variety of misanthropic narratives. We are told repeatedly that people are stupid, that they cannot be trusted, that we should fear “the mob”. This notion, that democracy must urgently be regulated to safeguard it from ordinary people, has been repeated so often that it’s become something of a truism. In a world constantly on the brink of war, in the midst of an unending economic catastrophe and the biggest refugee crises in decades, we’re warned of the danger posed by the very people who have the least control over anything — or even better, we are told they are at fault, because they got the governments they deserve. It’s an incredible trick, to shift the blame from those wielding power to those suffering the consequences, but this profound misanthropy has been so tightly embraced, particularly in the largely middle-class world of academia and the arts, that it is rarely questioned.</p><p>(It’s not a coincidence that today’s art asks such “provocative” questions as “What if we must give up all of our principles to succeed against these horrifying but utterly fictional enemies?” and “What if everyone is secretly awful?” — these narratives are part and parcel of the decay of genuine democracy. Identity politics, with its focus on depicting oppression as something experienced by small, isolated groups of people and demonizing the broad masses of those who do not fit into these categories as the true oppressors serves to further alienate people from each other rather than realize their common democratic power. It is important to mention these two aspects, because the opposition to democracy does not come only from open reactionaries and fascists, but just as frequently from the liberal wing of capitalism.)</p><p>The current trend seems to be for political power to be transferred away from what we recognize as the classic capitalist State and towards largely opaque entities that are completely unaccountable. If voting was only a minor part of democracy before, it is increasingly not a part at all. So while it is possible that in some cases, voting will play a part in the struggle for a people’s government, genuine democracy will by definition never be given from above. It can only claimed by the actual <em>demos</em>.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e2603b5d8aa" width="1" height="1" alt="">]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>