<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:cc="http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/rss/creativeCommonsRssModule.html">
    <channel>
        <title><![CDATA[Stories by Jonathan Newman on Medium]]></title>
        <description><![CDATA[Stories by Jonathan Newman on Medium]]></description>
        <link>https://medium.com/@jonathannewman?source=rss-44954e7c3355------2</link>
        
        <generator>Medium</generator>
        <lastBuildDate>Tue, 17 Nov 2026 12:09:50 GMT</lastBuildDate>
        <atom:link href="https://medium.com/@jonathannewman/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/>
        <webMaster><![CDATA[yourfriends@medium.com]]></webMaster>
        <atom:link href="http://medium.superfeedr.com/" rel="hub"/>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Broken Window Fallacy, Broken Down]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/jonathan-newman/the-broken-window-fallacy-broken-down-8165c6490dd?source=rss-44954e7c3355------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8165c6490dd</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Newman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 19 May 2015 20:27:35 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-05-21T13:11:05.921Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>Why is the community worse off after the window is broken? What can the community do about it?</h4><p><em>by Jonathan Newman</em></p><h4>The Broken Window Fallacy</h4><p>In a parable by Frédéric Bastiat and famously retold by Henry Hazlitt, a young hoodlum throws a rock through a baker’s window.</p><p>A crowd gathers to reflect on the incident and collectively concludes that although the window is broken, there is a bright side: a glazier will be hired to replace the window. The baker’s loss of a window is the glazier’s gain, and the glazier’s gain is the community’s gain because he can now spend his new income. This spending is somebody else’s income, and so on ad infinitum, so the broken window was the center of a rippling of benefit throughout the small economy.</p><p><strong>It’s at this point Bastiat and Hazlitt say, “Wait a minute.”</strong></p><p>The crowd forgot about someone: the tailor. You might glance back up to look for the tailor in my short summary.</p><p>He’s not there.</p><p>In fact, it is this aspect of the tailor (that he is unseen, hiding in the background) that makes this story not a story, but a parable with a lesson. The tailor comes into the light only when we consider the counterfactual, or what would have happened if the hoodlum had not thrown a rock through the baker’s window.</p><p>If the baker didn’t have to replace his window, he would have bought a new suit from the tailor with the money he handed to the glazier. So the community has not gained anything because of the hoodlum’s actions. It has actually lost something, namely, a new suit for the baker.</p><p><strong>It’s at this point I say, “Did you catch that?”</strong></p><p>Some may question the reasoning here. I’ll introduce some members of the crowd: Abigail, Bernard, Casey, and Daniel.</p><h4>The Skeptics</h4><p>Abigail pipes up first:</p><blockquote>“Why has the town lost a new suit? Couldn’t the glazier have bought one with his new income? If not the glazier, what about the next people that receive the ripple of spending, or the next? Won’t the tailor sell a suit at some point?”</blockquote><p>Bernard chimes in:</p><blockquote>“Why don’t we let the government pay for the baker’s new window? It’s not the baker’s fault, so he shouldn’t have to pay — the government should, and that would cancel out the broken window.”</blockquote><p>Casey gets a word in:</p><blockquote>“How can we be sure that the baker wasn’t just going to hoard his money and not spend it at all? Isn’t the broken window a sure way to get it out of his pocket and into somebody else’s, stimulating spending?”</blockquote><p>Daniel scratches his head:</p><blockquote>“What if we just printed some money for the baker to use to pay for the new pane of glass? This way everybody benefits and nobody is worse off, including the baker! He can have his window and a suit and the glazier gets to start the same spending chain. It’s a win-win-win-win-win-win-win…”</blockquote><p>Abigail interrupts: “We got it, Daniel. Now shut up.”</p><p>These are clever objections, but we’ll see how none of them disarm the Broken Window Fallacy, but commit some of their own errors instead.</p><p>But first, let me offer a definition:</p><h4>Economic growth, defined</h4><p><strong>Economic growth is when consumers have the ability to satisfy more and higher-ranked ends.</strong></p><p>“Gain”, “benefit”, and “better off” are all used in a similar sense and refer to which wants or desires we can satisfy and how many of our wants or desires we can satisfy. We single out consumers (and not, say, producers) for a couple of reasons: (1) everybody is a consumer, even producers when they’re not producing, and (2) all production is aimed at consumption.</p><p>Suppose Abigail wants a slice of pie and a cookie. The baker sells both for $5, and Abigail’ preference ranking (Abigail’s ends/wants/desires ranked by their importance to her) looks like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/130/1*lG79KkdMuH99fVwR50HbZw.png" /></figure><p>Abigail walks into the bakery with $5 in hand, ready for a treat. According to her preferences, $5 is too expensive for her to buy a cookie — she ranks the $5 over the cookie. The pie, however, is priced just right — she prefers the pie to the $5 and so gives up what she ranks lower in exchange for something she ranks higher.</p><p><strong>This transaction has made Abigail better off.</strong> Since the baker also voluntarily exchanged the pie for $5, the baker is better off, too. The economy has grown because everybody involved is better off.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/307/1*MrQ95StQWG5Iz4tixxJq8Q.png" /><figcaption>Blue items are what is given up. Orange items are gained. Green arrows mean things are moving up, which is indicative of all voluntary transactions.</figcaption></figure><p>The blue items are what is given up. The orange items are what is gained. Green arrows mean things are moving up, which is indicative of all voluntary transactions.</p><h4>What happened when the hoodlum broke the baker’s window?</h4><p>Back to windows and suits, how can we map the broken window story using preference rankings?</p><p>Easy as pie.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/663/1*7EtoHBew9lr6gTFVRdIIuw.png" /></figure><p>The hoodlum likes breaking stuff. The baker likes his window, unbroken, but would also like a suit. The glazier is happy to replace windows for $500 and the tailor is happy to provide new suits for $500 (these more realistic 2015 prices are 10 times Hazlitt’s 1946 prices of $50 — apparently the powers that be didn’t read his other great book, <em>What You Should Know About Inflation</em>).</p><p>Then, the hoodlum does his thing:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/343/1*e70VLxz5Ho3v6_Pq0ZdR8w.png" /><figcaption>Red means things are moving down, which is indicative of all involuntary, unwanted events.</figcaption></figure><p>He breaks the baker’s window, satisfying one of his ends, but at the detriment to the baker. The baker loses his most highly ranked end and gets something he regards as less than worthless in return, a pile of broken glass on the ground.</p><p>The baker turns around and uses his $500 to purchase a new window.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/336/1*EolchTMnu2zP5ZV2arLtFA.png" /><figcaption>Remember: blue items are given up. Orange items are gained. Green means things are moving up.</figcaption></figure><p>The baker and the glazier voluntarily exchange the $500 and the new window. The transaction is voluntary, even if the baker is miffed about the whole ordeal.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/84/1*ppfx6l7vR5MWZ85sWTG4JA.png" /><figcaption>Tailor: “No suit for you.”</figcaption></figure><p>Meanwhile, the tailor is just sitting on the sidelines twiddling his thumbs.</p><p><strong>The tailor never gives the baker a new suit.</strong> He only enters the picture when we consider the counterfactual, i.e., the alternate sequence of events had the hoodlum not committed his crime.</p><h4>The counterfactual</h4><p>What if the window were never broken?</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/279/1*WaQfGIbON4Q1PwYckRabow.png" /><figcaption>Baker: “Wow! I’m not miffed at all!”</figcaption></figure><p>The baker and the tailor trade one suit for $500. And everybody lives happily ever after. How happy, you ask? Well, compared to the scenario with the broken window, much better, which we’ll see in just a moment.</p><h4>The two scenarios compared</h4><p>A stocktaking of the two scenarios reveals that in the broken window scenario, the community has, in fact, lost a window. We’ll call the scenario that starts with the hoodlum breaking the window Scenario 1. The scenario without any vandalism is Scenario 2.</p><p>In Scenario 1, the baker loses his window at first and no amount of voluntary transactions after that can recover that loss.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/470/1*ytQ4xnhZXqfEFl_PW3pFyg.png" /><figcaption>Compare all the orange items with the blue items from Scenario 1.</figcaption></figure><p>We see that in Scenario 2, the suit enters the scene, and there’s nothing weighing down the “What is lost” side:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/371/1*susxcDJMjO2mbqCYlAlmgA.png" /><figcaption>Even though both sides have the same items, we can say as a matter of fact that the gains outweigh the losses because they were voluntarily traded.</figcaption></figure><p>This type of comparison highlights the loss of the window in Scenario 1, but Bastiat and Hazlitt stressed the importance of the suit. When you just look at the “before” and “after” snapshots of Scenario 1, you see the town has lost a window. When you compare Scenario 1 to its counterfactual, Scenario 2, you see the that the town has also lost a suit.</p><p>Let’s compare what the baker walks away with after each scenario runs its course:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/492/1*hGjncoDbIpC0raQsZGrKiw.png" /><figcaption>The difference between these two is exactly one suit.</figcaption></figure><p>If the hoodlum breaks his window, the baker can’t get the suit. If the hoodlum doesn’t break his window, the baker can have both an unbroken window in his storefront and a new suit. He spends the $500 either way. The only difference is the suit, which only appears in Scenario 2.</p><p>Any chain of spending spurred by the glazier in the broken window scenario could also be spurred by the tailor in the scenario without a broken window. Therefore, anything beyond the baker must be considered the same for both scenarios.</p><p><strong>Bastiat and Hazlitt conclude that the community is clearly better off in Scenario 2. Both represent a chain of spending, but one starts off with an “uneven” transaction, vandalism, while the other starts off with a mutually beneficial transaction.</strong></p><h4>Abigail’s objection</h4><p>We are finally ready to take on the Skeptics’ objections.</p><p>Abigail spoke up first.</p><blockquote>“Why has the town lost a new suit? Couldn’t the glazier have bought one with his new income? If not the glazier, what about the next people that receive the ripple of spending, or the next? Won’t the tailor sell a suit at some point?”</blockquote><p>Abigail said that we can’t say for sure the town has lost a new suit because the glazier or somebody else could still buy the suit in the chain of transaction enabled by the replacement of the broken window. The baker may not get the suit, but somebody else could get it.</p><p>Let’s see what this looks like:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/874/1*X4TkdtPGqPrCE3Lc1LhMIw.png" /><figcaption>Scenario 1 with the added caveat that somebody buys a suit in the chain of spending into infinity.</figcaption></figure><p>Compare this to:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/653/1*rt9DFefAY5INK2gZh3VBnA.png" /><figcaption>Scenario 2: or “Scenario Infinity-Plus-One”</figcaption></figure><p>So, Abigail is right in one sense. The choice of a suit as the opportunity cost of the broken window was arbitrary. Bastiat or Hazlitt could have chosen an encyclopedia set, a super large coffee drink, a trendy haircut, or any number of things the baker could have bought if he didn’t have to replace his window.</p><p>The point is, though, that the baker’s real wealth decreases as a result of the broken window. The wants he is able to satisfy are permanently fewer and lesser (lower ranked) than what he could have been able to satisfy without the vandalism.</p><p><strong>No amount of spending, even in after an infinite number of transactions can make up for the initial loss the baker incurs.</strong> After an infinite number of transactions for both scenarios, Scenario 2 will still have the upper hand in terms of total benefit to everybody involved.</p><h4>Bernard’s objection</h4><p>Bernard felt bad for the baker having to pay for the vandal’s crime.</p><blockquote>“Why don’t we let the government pay for the baker’s new window? It’s not the baker’s fault, so he shouldn’t have to pay — the government should, and that would cancel out the broken window.”</blockquote><p>This objection is easier to dismiss. Taxing others to pay for the new window just shifts the harm to somebody else. If it’s unfair for the baker to pay for the new window, it’s also unfair for any other innocent person. The only person we can fairly place the burden on paying up is the vandal.</p><p>Bernard could respond:</p><blockquote>“But we don’t like having people incur all the losses in a scenario like this. If we spread out the loss to a bunch of people, then situations like this don’t hurt as much.”</blockquote><p>Bernard has stumbled onto something brilliant. We like knowing that if a tragedy like this were to happen to us, we wouldn’t have to suffer too much. The technical term for this phenomenon is loss aversion, and there are a few ways to deal with it:</p><ol><li>We could tax people and put the money in a fund for “broken window” situations. The tax, though, is applied to people who don’t agree with this program. Some people don’t want to be a part of this scheme, but the government takes their money anyways.</li><li>We could have a market for insurance, where people voluntarily pay for coverage when “broken window” situations arise. Depending on how much coverage they want, they can pay more or less. The difference between this option and the previous one is that this one is completely voluntary. If somebody doesn’t want broken window insurance, they don’t have to pay in.</li><li>We could ask for voluntary, charitable donations whenever these sorts of situations happen. The town bookseller, for instance, could ask people to donate to help pay for the baker’s new window.</li></ol><p>The point is that we don’t need to apply more aggression by moving the loss onto people who aren’t involved and don’t want to pay in. <strong>Forcing people to buy into an insurance plan is just as unjustified as the vandal breaking the baker’s window because it involved taking something from somebody without their approval.</strong></p><h4>Casey’s objection</h4><p>Casey was up next after Bernard.</p><blockquote>“How can we be sure that the baker wasn’t just going to hoard his money and not spend it at all? Isn’t the broken window a sure way to get it out of his pocket and into somebody else’s, stimulating spending?”</blockquote><p>This is another clever objection, but falls short when we consider the purpose of holding money. <strong>People save for future consumption.</strong></p><p>Casey is partially right. We can’t be sure that the baker would have spent his $500 that day, or the next for that matter. He could wait <em>years</em> before spending it, in fact.</p><p>But a time delay in consumption does not eliminate the opportunity cost of the broken window. The baker’s preference ranking, according to Casey’s objection, could look like this:</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/149/1*Z9W5PGufqrnfOv4vJrLtiA.png" /></figure><p>With this arrangement, the baker would not spend his $500 today, but next year on a vacation. <strong>So the chain of spending would begin then, instead of today.</strong></p><p>A market for loans in this economy would expand this line of reasoning even more. If there is a credit market in this small economy, then he could loan his $500 out to somebody else, maybe the barista so that she can buy a new espresso machine.</p><p>The espresso machine will allow the barista to sell more coffee drinks — if she made a good entrepreneurial judgment — and so she can pay the baker back a little more than the amount she borrowed. The baker’s savings, then, wouldn’t be a drain on the economy, but would help it grow by financing investment and increasing the amount this economy can produce.</p><p>Casey has another idea: “What if he <em>never</em> spends it? What if he goes mad and throws the $500 into the furnace that heats his oven?”</p><p><strong>Even so, the baker would just be relinquishing his claim on $500 worth of goods, and would therefore increase the purchasing power of everybody else’s money.</strong> The baker would make everybody else better off at his own expense by burning the money.</p><h4>Daniel’s objection</h4><p>This leads us to Daniel’s objection about increasing the money supply.</p><blockquote>“What if we just printed some money for the baker to use to pay for the new pane of glass? This way everybody benefits and nobody is worse off, including the baker! He can have his window and a suit and the glazier gets to start the same spending chain. It’s a win-win-win-win-win-win-win…”</blockquote><p>It is true that in the short-run, things would look great. If the money printing authority in this small economy handed the baker some fresh, crisp bills — hot off the printing press — for him to pay for his new window, the baker could then have his window and a new suit.</p><p>But, just as a decrease in the small economy’s money supply made everybody else better off (like we saw in going over Casey’s objection), an increase has the opposite effect. The new $500 has introduced new claims on goods without actually increasing the amount of real goods in the economy. The money to goods ratio has increased and so prices will increase, too.</p><p>The following diagram is more complicated than the others, but the idea is simple. Printing new money and giving it to the baker allows for two potential chains of spending: one beginning with the transaction with the glazier and the other with the tailor.</p><figure><img alt="" src="https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/822/1*1eDmh5wxjmW0QoXhH1KGPQ.png" /><figcaption>The baker is able to spend the new money without any change in the monetary unit’s purchasing power, since he is the first to spend it. Over time, however, the goods people want to buy move up in relation to the dollar amounts on their preference ranking.</figcaption></figure><p>Notice that since the goods are moving up in relation to the various dollar amounts, higher prices are charged for each good. This has two consequences: (1) people are paying more for the goods, and so have less to spend on other goods, and (2) it makes some transactions not happen at all because the price is now too high for one potential party to the transaction.</p><p>By the time the tailor gets the new money, prices have risen enough for him to value the encyclopedia set the same way the bookseller does: more than $510, but less than $520, so there is no opportunity for them to trade.</p><p>Even though I’ve “sped up” the effects of inflation so that we can see them in this small diagram, the mechanics are the same whenever there is an artificial increase in the money supply of any economy. <strong>The first people to spend the new money benefit at the expense of the last people to spend the new money.</strong></p><h4>Conclusion</h4><p>Economic growth can only happen when people are allowed to make voluntary exchanges with each other.</p><p>In the Parable of the Broken Window as told by Bastiat and Hazlitt, the townsfolk were eager to find something good in a bad situation, but were looking in the wrong places. Involuntary destruction is always bad for an economy, and further distortions like taxes and monetary inflation exacerbate the problem. The best response to broken windows is to just let people work things out voluntarily.</p><p>If any more force should be applied after a vandal breaks a window, it should be used to make the vandal pay for fixing the destruction. Taxing others to pay for repairs makes innocent people pay for somebody else’s crime. Similarly, inflating the money supply forces innocent people to “pay” for the destruction in the form of higher prices or forgone benefit.</p><p>Broken windows are all around us and happen every day. Accidents happen, bad weather comes, and bad people steal and destroy our stuff. The counterfactual to broken windows is always preferable to broken windows, as Bastiat and Hazlitt explain, and there is no way to turn time back and stop broken windows before they happen. There is no way to recover the opportunity cost of broken windows.</p><p>Going forward, then, we should allow peaceful, voluntary exchange to persist and do what it does best: make people better off.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8165c6490dd" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/jonathan-newman/the-broken-window-fallacy-broken-down-8165c6490dd">The Broken Window Fallacy, Broken Down</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/jonathan-newman">Jonathan Newman</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[A Lunch Break in an Alternate Universe]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/jonathan-newman/a-lunch-break-in-an-alternate-universe-e0466ab6fa71?source=rss-44954e7c3355------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/e0466ab6fa71</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[satire]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[bureaucracy]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[libertarian]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Newman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 29 Apr 2015 02:37:38 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-05-04T21:25:42.641Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>by Jonathan Newman</em></p><p>While I was out for lunch, I decided to get a haircut and renew the tag for my vehicle.</p><p>So I got all my paperwork together and pulled around the rear-facing Lee County Satellite Department of Haircutting and Styling Annex, Building 32.b.5 and carefully zigzagged through the tightly packed and confusingly arranged parking lot.</p><p>I glanced through all of the signs posted out front about cell phone use (prohibited), accepted forms of payment, new charges for people with various hair colors, new forms required for different haircuts, etc.</p><p>I had navigated their maze of a last-updated-in-2003 website the night before, making sure I had everything I needed and knew how much I should expect to pay: $239.17 (assuming I calculated everything right).</p><p>There was one grumpy clerk stationed at the long, grey counter with a capacity for at least 5 more clerks, so I had to wait in line for a while. (No cell phones allowed, so I just had to stare at the beige floor tiles and listen to Janet Napolitano tell me over a static-y PA speaker how dangerous the private, black market haircutting organized crime rings are. “<em>Illegal private barbers are associated with lung cancer, terrorism, and global warming. Beware.</em>” and “<em>If you hear snips, open your lips!</em>” were common refrains.)</p><p>It was my turn to approach the clerk. She mumbled “Next?” with an impatient tone, like she had been waiting on me, not the other way around. She got up and left before I could say “Good afternoon”. I looked back at the other people in line, who just shrugged. A minute later, she returned with a mug of coffee.</p><p>“Good afternoon,” I said.<br>“Photo ID, Hair Style Form 4580, and proof of fashion insurance, please.” Her “please” was not very pleasing, but grating.<br>“Absolutely. Here you are.” I passed her my items.</p><p>I voted against the new requirement for universal fashion insurance, but had to get it anyway.</p><p>If for some reason I left the house with mismatched socks, uncoordinated colors, old clothes, or a bad haircut, my fashion insurance company would compensate those who happen to see my bad fashion if they just fill out the forms and take photos of my offense. I thought it was sort of contradictory to have to buy insurance for the same fashion the government provides and assures is safe and trendy. But, oh well — the people have spoken!</p><p>My daydreaming about the wonders of democracy was interrupted: “You haven’t specified your hair length.”<br>“Oh, I’m sorry. Let me fill that in really quick.” I mentally converted the length measurements because I remembered the poorly formatted sign out front that said “ALL LENGTH UNITS MUST BE IN WAHLS, NOT INCHES.” The conversion was easy enough for me. They pushed this exact kind of math problem hard in Common Core.</p><p>The clerk snatched the form back and slowly walked back to the copier to make copies of my files. She returned with a new form for me to fill out: “Public Barber Appointment and Personal Injury Waiver” (public barbers are notoriously careless in their “craft”).</p><p>“Oh, no… I was hoping to get my hair cut today.” I eyed the well-populated line in front of the empty barber chair. He must have been on break.<br>“We close at 34:67pm,” the clerk sighed. I forgot they switch to Wahl time every other Spring and Summer since the Hair Freedom Act was passed after expensive lobbying by Wahl. The new law also mandated all public barbers had to use Wahl products.</p><p>I mentally converted the time back to something I was used to and concluded that there was no way I was getting a haircut today. I took the P.B.A.P.I.W. form the clerk had placed on the counter.</p><p>She told me there’s a $5.17 fee for using the form to schedule appointments in advance. I pulled out my debit card — she pointed at a small sign taped to the glass separating us: “No cards for transactions under $5.18. Effective Wahluary 67, 20f3.”</p><p>I didn’t have any cash on me (getting cash out is harder these days), so I just walked out disappointed and without a haircut. As I left, the people behind me in line gave me an angry look for taking so long.</p><p>The tag renewal joint was just around the corner, with a bright, fun sign facing the road: “Safe Roads — Safe Drivers”. Parking was easy. I walked in and a smiling face greeted me.</p><p>“Welcome back, Jonathan! Here to renew your tags?”<br>“Yep. Oh, and thanks for fixing those potholes by my house.”</p><p>The manager walked around the corner into the front lobby area. She was wearing the same soft yellow polo as the guy at the front desk. Both had name tags and friendly smiles, too.</p><p>“You bet. Thanks for letting us know about it. We try to stay on top of all of that, so happy customers letting us know how we’re doing is a big help.”</p><p>“How much is this year’s road subscription?” I didn’t bother to look it up before coming because it’s usually so cheap.<br>“$15.”<br>I was shocked. “Whoa. Wasn’t it $25 last year?”<br>“Yeah,” the manager sighed, almost embarrassed to admit prices were higher before, “but we’ve got a few more billboard ad locations and commercial shipping subscriptions this year to help pay for new roads and maintenance.”</p><p>The guy at the front desk handed me my new sticker as I passed him my debit card.</p><p>“We’re happy to help you here at our office, but if it’s more convenient for you next time, we have a mobile app and a website that can process your subscription. Also, we have a new automatic renewal option with a discount, so be sure to check that out.”<br>“Can I sign up for that now?”<br>“Sure!” A few keyboard taps later and I was on my way out the door.</p><p>The manager held the door open for me and said, “Thanks for your business. Be sure to look at our expanded map and partnerships on the mobile app! Let us know if you see any other spots on the road that need our attention. Our app has a function for that, too.”<br>“Will do. Thank you, ma’am.”<br>“And remember: safe drivers use Safe Roads!”</p><p>I rolled my eyes. The saying is cheesy, but they did set records last year for fewest accidents and customer satisfaction surveys ranked them in the top 10 for rush hour flow in Alabama.</p><p>On my way back to work, the fashion police stopped me for having unkempt hair. I tried to explain that I just went to get a haircut but the satellite department was backed up. The officer didn’t care.</p><p>The fine was more than what I would have paid for my publicly subsidized haircut, but I didn’t want to push it because I had seen all the recent news about people dying during fashion police encounters.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=e0466ab6fa71" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/jonathan-newman/a-lunch-break-in-an-alternate-universe-e0466ab6fa71">A Lunch Break in an Alternate Universe</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/jonathan-newman">Jonathan Newman</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[The Relationship between Austrian Economics and Libertarianism]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/jonathan-newman/the-relationship-between-austrian-economics-and-libertarianism-8428977fd145?source=rss-44954e7c3355------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/8428977fd145</guid>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Newman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Wed, 22 Apr 2015 05:20:43 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-04-29T02:58:27.784Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4>How economics, politics, and rhetoric make use of positive and normative claims</h4><p><em>by Jonathan Newman</em></p><h3>First Things First</h3><p>Let’s get on the same page before we start throwing terms around.</p><h4>Austrian Economics</h4><p>Austrian economics is a specific set of claims that are/were arrived at by a specific method. <strong>The foundational claim at the center of Austrian economics is that <em>humans act </em>and the method is <em>logical deduction</em>.</strong></p><p>Ludwig von Mises gave us a great definition for human action:</p><blockquote>“Human action is purposeful behavior.”</blockquote><p>It’s one of those undeniably true facts of life. You can’t argue against human action without acting purposefully. You also can’t intentionally not act, because having an intention makes it action.</p><p>Further claims that branch out from this incontrovertible center are logically deduced from this claim with the help of a few very safe corollary claims along the way, like “we prefer leisure to labor,” or “we have a variety of means capable of satisfying our desires.”</p><p>We can proceed from “humans act” like this:</p><ol><li>Humans act.</li><li>Humans act by employing means to satisfy an end.</li><li>The chosen end is necessarily preferred to forgone ends.</li><li>The means employed could have gone toward the satisfaction of another, lower ranked end.</li><li>A larger stock of means can be employed for the satisfaction of more ends.</li><li>The satisfaction of more ends is preferred to the satisfaction of fewer ends.</li><li>A larger stock of means can be employed for the satisfaction of more ends, but those ends are necessarily lower ranked than the ends that would be satisfied with a smaller stock of means.</li><li>A marginal increase in the stock of means will go toward the satisfaction of a lower ranked end.</li></ol><p>And so on, until an entire interrelated structure of claims is laid out.</p><p>Some notable claims that can be deduced along these lines involve the determination of interest rates, the effects of monetary inflation, how profit and loss signal consumer preferences, and even the causes of business cycles.</p><p>The key feature of all of these claims is that they are independent of what we like or dislike. <strong>The claims of Austrian economics are value-free, objective, or “positive”.</strong></p><h4>Libertarianism</h4><p>Libertarianism, like Austrian economics, is a set of claims. The claims of libertarianism are different than the claims of Austrian economics, in the same way that ethical claims are different than mathematical claims.</p><p><strong>At the center of libertarianism is the non-aggression principle</strong>, as all of the “extra” claims in libertarian political thought may be traced back to it.</p><p>Libertarian claims include that the initiation of violence is always illegitimate, people can only delegate authority that they already have, war is bad, and unhampered markets are better than hampered markets. Libertarians call for smaller government, less taxation, less war, more freedom, and widespread respect for property rights.</p><p>Where do these claims come from, though? In economics, the claims are generated by logical deduction from some central axiom(s). What generates claims like “we should start fewer wars”?</p><p>The answer may disappoint you. <strong>The claims of libertarianism are just statements of preferences — they are based on values, subjective, or “normative”.</strong> To say “war is bad” is to say “I don’t like war, therefore war is bad.” To say “the initiation of violence is always illegitimate” is to say “I don’t like it when people initiate violence against other people, therefore I do not regard any such action as legitimate or defensible.”</p><p>This does not mean that libertarian claims are somehow less true or that libertarianism is less suited to be adopted by society at large. All political statements are statements of preferences. All political ideologies have at their center preferences, and only preferences. Everything else is rhetoric and hand-waving.</p><p>To the left and to the right of libertarianism, you’ll find claims like “the initiation of violence is sometimes legitimate” and “taxes are a necessary and important part of society”. These, too, are statements of preference.</p><p>These sorts of statements are called <em>normative claims</em>, while the statements of economics are called <em>positive claims</em>.</p><h3>Normative vs. Positive Claims</h3><p>Normative claims can be called “should” or “ought” claims because they may be appropriately boiled down to “we should do things this way” or “you shouldn&#39;t do that.” <strong>They are statements of preference, like recommendations.</strong></p><p>If your child is about to touch a hot stove eye, you might exclaim and make use of a normative claim: “Don’t touch that!” You may not use the word “should”, but it is implied in your claim, or your recommendation. You are saying “You shouldn&#39;t touch that, because I don’t want you to, because I don’t want you to burn yourself.”</p><p>Positive claims may be called “is” claims because they may be appropriately boiled down to “this is this” or “the cause of this is that.” <strong>They are statements of equality and causal explanations, like definitions and if-then statements.</strong></p><p>If your child asks you why the sky is blue, you might make use of a positive claim: “The air molecules reflect the light from the sun as blue.” You may not use the word “is”, but it is implied in your claim, or your explanation. You are saying “The cause of the sky appearing blue is the fact that air molecules reflect blue.”</p><p>The title of this piece is “The Relationship between Austrian Economics and Libertarianism,” and at this point you might be inclined to think that there is some sort of overlap. Austrian economics is one set of claims and libertarianism is another set, but maybe there are some claims that are both, right?</p><p>No.</p><p><strong>Economics is made up of exclusively positive claims, while political positions and recommendations are only normative claims.</strong> And one claim cannot be both positive and normative. Something can’t be based on values and be independent of values at the same time.</p><p>So, although both libertarianism and Austrian economics exist as sets of claims, there can be no overlap. There is a connection between the two — a healthy, fruitful relationship — but no overlap.</p><p>I want to make something clear at this point, because a lot of people get the wrong grip on the difference between positive and normative claims. Many confuse the difference between “is” and “should” statements as <em>facts</em> versus <em>opinions</em>.</p><p>The problem with this is that both positive and normative statements can be facts and both can be opinions. Even opinions can be factual, so there’s overlap all around.</p><p>I can express an opinion, and that opinion can be a fact. “My opinion is that the sky is blue.” My opinion is correct and factual.</p><p>I can also express an opinion and be incorrect — “I think the sky is green.”</p><p>In the same way, claims in economics (positive) and politics (normative) can be correct or incorrect, but they can also be expressions of an opinion.</p><h3>Rhetoric: the Connection</h3><p>Rhetoric is the act of employing various claims, both positive and normative, to convince somebody of something. If I wanted to convince you that cheating on a test is wrong, I might employ a variety of claims:</p><ol><li>“If you get caught, you will get a zero on the test and other official consequences you do not want.”</li><li>“You will feel better if you don’t cheat.”</li><li>“Cheating is dishonest.”</li><li>“You shouldn’t be dishonest.”</li><li>“You will feel guilty for cheating.”</li><li>“If you cheat, your nose will grow to a permanently larger size.”</li><li>“A lot of people don’t like cheaters.”</li><li>“Lying and dishonoring your parents are both sinful.”</li></ol><p>Some of these claims are positive, and some are normative. Some are guesses based on my perception and expectations, while others are definitionally true statements. Some are correct, some are incorrect, or could be incorrect depending on how events unfold.</p><p>Accepting my normative claims requires you to hold the same values as me. Take #4 for example: “You shouldn’t be dishonest.” In order for this claim to aid in convincing you that you shouldn’t cheat, you would have to first agree with me that dishonesty is wrong.</p><p>Accepting some of my positive claims, though, just requires external verification or introspection about the definitions of the words involved. Accepting positive claims as true, though, does not necessarily mean that they will help convince you that cheating is wrong.</p><p>You may agree with me about #7: “A lot of people don’t like cheaters.” But what if you don’t care if people like you or not? What if you want people to <em>not</em> like you?</p><p>Therefore, I would only employ a positive claim if I estimate that it would have some pull on you in the desired direction. It may seem like positive claims are risky to use in rhetoric, but actually, we can make some pretty safe assumptions about what people value.</p><h4>What people value</h4><p>You can almost universally bank on utilitarian grounds for positive claims having an effect on your audience. Almost everybody would agree that people being happier and better off is better than people being sadder and worse off, especially if they are a part of said “people”.</p><p>This is where Austrian economics and libertarianism find their connection. <strong>The claims of Austrian economics are some of the best rhetorical tools in convincing people that the claims of libertarianism should be adopted by society.</strong></p><p>Austrian economics says that when two people make a voluntary exchange, both are better off, or they wouldn’t have made the exchange. Libertarianism says voluntary exchange is good. The connection? People being better off is good (a utilitarian position).</p><p>Austrian economics says that artificially low interest rates cause business cycles that make people worse off because of an increase in unemployment and resources leave the lines of production that produce what people want and when they want it. Libertarianism says central banks are a stupid idea. The connection? Making people worse off is a stupid idea (a utilitarian position).</p><p>One more example: Austrian economics says that only profit and loss can send the signals to producers that they are producing what people want, and profit and loss can only emerge in markets to the extent they are unhampered by involuntary interventions. Libertarianism says that profits and unhampered markets are good. The connection? People being better off is good (a utilitarian position).</p><p>So it’s no surprise that Austrian economists and libertarians are such great friends and even the same people a lot of the time. The results generated by Austrian economics are great ammunition in libertarians’ rhetorical arsenal. And, if you know and understand Austrian economics, then you would have to be misanthropic or sadistic to <em>not</em> be a libertarian.</p><p>Theoretically, though, it could happen. Some horrible dictator that likes inflicting pain on his citizens may know and understand the effects of government interventions in markets, and therefore uses Austrian economics maliciously. This possibility showcases the difference between economics and politics, but also the implausibility of somebody being both an Austrian economist and a brutal dictator or the two being friends.</p><p>It would be just as preposterous to find a Keynesian libertarian, for similar reasons. The results of Keynesian economics lend themselves to government interventions with both fiscal and monetary policy, both of which are anathema to most libertarians.</p><h4>Other common ground</h4><p>Of course, utilitarianism isn’t the only rhetorical common ground for a rhetor and his audience. Finding common ground is a function of knowing your audience. Audiences can be left-leaning, right-leaning, Christian, atheist, pacifistic, militant, well-read, or new to libertarian ideas.</p><p><strong>Besides utilitarianism, appealing to natural rights and private property are other safe choices because most people would agree that we own our own bodies and the fruits of our labor</strong>.</p><p>This is common ground between Austrian economics and libertarianism because both assume the existence of a set of rights before they can make even their first few central claims.</p><p>Saying “humans act” first requires (in logical sequence) that humans have control over the means employed toward want-satisfaction. Similarly, the non-aggression principle says that aggression is against somebody’s person or property, both of which would have to be owned by the victim for it to be considered aggression.</p><h3>Conclusion</h3><p>Austrian economics and libertarianism are totally separate sets of claims. There is no overlap. One makes exclusively positive claims while the other makes normative claims.</p><p>As soon as an economist makes a normative claim, she immediately ceases being an economist (temporarily, of course — for the duration of the claim) because economics is a value-free science, even though it says a lot about value.</p><p>You could say economics is meta-value. It makes positive claims about value, but normative claims (which are based on values) are outside of its purview.</p><p>Austrian economics and libertarianism find their constructive relationship in the realm of public debate. Rhetoric is the construction site where libertarianism makes skillful use of the tools and materials provided by Austrian economics.</p><p><strong>Libertarians can use the compelling results and claims of Austrian economics to help convince people that a free society is not only practical, but moral and justified </strong>—</p><p>…certainly more practical than the confusing edifice of bureaucracies we have today,</p><p>…more moral than the perpetual warfare we are currently mired in which is financed by equally perpetual monetary inflation,</p><p>…and more justified than the arbitrary, rights-trampling whims of the powerful few who wield their weapons and “officialness” as a license to expropriate your wealth, regulate your own affairs, and crush your well-being by manipulating crucial economic mechanisms.</p><p>Now, who could argue with that?</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=8428977fd145" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/jonathan-newman/the-relationship-between-austrian-economics-and-libertarianism-8428977fd145">The Relationship between Austrian Economics and Libertarianism</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/jonathan-newman">Jonathan Newman</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
        <item>
            <title><![CDATA[Inflation and Business Cycles]]></title>
            <link>https://medium.com/jonathan-newman/inflation-and-business-cycles-19b6dcdc1c66?source=rss-44954e7c3355------2</link>
            <guid isPermaLink="false">https://medium.com/p/19b6dcdc1c66</guid>
            <category><![CDATA[inflation]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[business-cycle]]></category>
            <category><![CDATA[economics]]></category>
            <dc:creator><![CDATA[Jonathan Newman]]></dc:creator>
            <pubDate>Tue, 14 Apr 2015 02:27:32 GMT</pubDate>
            <atom:updated>2015-04-14T22:42:14.539Z</atom:updated>
            <content:encoded><![CDATA[<h4><strong>Price inflation vs. monetary inflation and the full consequences of the latter.</strong></h4><p><em>by Jonathan Newman</em></p><h3>Inflation</h3><p>The word “inflation” means different things to different people. One popular conception of inflation focuses on prices — all prices, actually. For these people, including some economists, “inflation” means a rise in the general price level, i.e., the goods and services we buy have higher price tags.</p><p>The other conception of inflation focuses on the money supply. Economists with this focus think of inflation as an increase in the amount of money in the economy. We’ll see that viewing inflation as a rise in prices can be misleading and ambiguous especially compared to viewing inflation as an increase in the money supply.</p><p><strong>First of all,</strong> <strong>prices can rise for many reasons</strong>. If the demand for something increases relative to its supply, or if the supply of something decreases relative to the demand for it, the price will increase.</p><p>The fundamental reason for this is called diminishing marginal utility — increasing our stock of some good means that it will go toward the satisfaction of a lower-ranked end. If the next “marginal unit” goes toward a lower-ranked end, then the most we are willing to pay for the next unit must be less than the previous unit. You might be willing to pay $600 for one Apple Watch, but the most you would be willing to pay for another might be $100, maybe as gift for somebody else or so that you could have one on both of your wrists!</p><p>Even though this sounds pretty limiting in terms of the reasons prices can rise, these two concepts — supply and demand — can and do channel all sorts of changes in the market.</p><p>Preferences can change, goods can go in and out of fashion, accidents can happen that reduce our supply of a certain good, we can think of new and more efficient ways of producing goods, services that at one time could only be done with human labor can be replaced or complemented with new tools and machines, and so on.</p><p>The list of things that affect supply and demand is infinite, depending on how specific you get, but the important thing to remember is that all of these sorts of changes are integrated into and channeled through our preferences and ideas and therefore supply and demand.</p><p><strong>Secondly,</strong> <strong>there is really no good way to measure a general rise in the price level</strong>. You maybe familiar with indexes like the Consumer Price Index, which are calculated and compiled based on survey data and technical mathematical methods, but by their very nature they cannot appropriately capture the price level. They cannot do so because these sorts of indexes are one number.</p><p>They try to boil the trillions of pieces of data on the prices of all goods and services in the economy down to just one piece of data. Market prices, which are a complicated phenomenon on their own, fluctuate not only year to year, but month to month, day by day, and even second to second. Also, there is no central repository of price information.</p><p>Even in one country, prices emerge in a very scattered, decentralized way, from the halls of Washington D.C. to the dark, back alleys of downtown Chicago; from the lots of car dealers with neon paint to hand-to-hand-to-pocket tips for bellhops and restaurant servers; from fleeting ones and zeroes soaring at light speed across the internet to long-term contracts for land use or film production.</p><p>One number couldn’t even begin to describe the magnitude and dynamic nature of something like the “price level”. It would be like driving out West for a camping trip and going to the remotest location at night to view the stars and a meteor shower and then the next month, when you return to civilization and cell service you text your parents what the view was like and type, “Cool.”</p><p>Price index information is delayed, incomplete, and by its very nature incapable of describing the astronomical picture of market prices. And we haven’t even mentioned the well-cited issues with surveys, government data, and the more specific issues with the particular measurements.</p><p><strong>A third issue with viewing inflation only as a rise in the price level is that it stops short of explaining the full consequences of monetary inflation.</strong> Many people correctly understand the relationship between the price level and the money supply — more money means higher prices — and they also understand that this relationship is bad for the average Joe.</p><p>Now, Dr. Salerno is not average by any measure, but we can say that if he is one of the later receivers of new money, he has to pay higher prices before his own salary increases due to inflation, however you define it.</p><p>In this way, inflation is not harmless — it represents a wealth transfer to the first users of the new money from the later users of new money as it ripples through the economy.</p><p>Even though most people know and understand this consequence of increasing the money supply, it stops short of explaining the full consequences of monetary inflation, which will be discussed in just a moment.</p><p>But to summarize, viewing inflation as a rise in the price level has at least three main problems:</p><ol><li>It is ambiguous because almost anything can change prices;</li><li>It is impractical because it can’t be appropriately measured;</li><li>And it is incomplete because it doesn&#39;t tell the whole story of increases in the money supply.</li></ol><p>Inflation is more appropriately viewed as an increase in the money supply, and this conception of inflation does not suffer the same problems as the other. Monetary inflation has a simple, well-defined cause, unlike price inflation. Monetary inflation is measureable because money is its own unit of account and can be counted up, unlike price inflation, which is not directly measureable. Monetary inflation is also the starting point for the business cycle story, instead of a stopping point for many, like price inflation.</p><h3>The business cycle</h3><p>Before we can discuss the ups and downs of the business cycle, we have to gain an understanding of two connected concepts: the interest rate and production.</p><p>The interest rate is a price, like any other price, but for present money. It seems weird that you can buy money, but if you just reverse your perspective of any regular transaction, “buying money” becomes an obvious and ubiquitous part of our day-to-day lives.</p><p>When you buy an Apple Watch (or two) you exchange money for the device. From Apple’s perspective though, they are not only selling the watch, but buying your money. The price of your $600 is one Apple Watch.</p><p><strong>The interest rate is a price for present money, in terms of future money. </strong>When you take out a loan, you are buying present money in exchange for the promise of a future payment. The relative difference between these two sums is the interest rate. And, just like any other good, the lower the price, the more people will want to buy. At lower interest rates, more people are willing to borrow.</p><p>In modern times, we&#39;ve outsourced a lot of the lending to banks, which act as financial intermediaries. Banks use our savings to lend to prospective borrowers, and so the supply of loanable present money depends on how much people save — said another way, it depends on how much people consume, since saving is the opposite of consumption.</p><p>The indirectness of borrowing and lending through banks does not complicate things too much; in fact it makes it easier for us to conceive of the supply of loans simply as savings.</p><p>Entrepreneurs are some of the primary borrowers of present money. Entrepreneurs buy factors of production like land, labor, and capital to produce goods and services. They will only engage in production, though, if they expect to profit, that is, if their revenues exceed their costs.</p><p><strong>If they borrow money to pay for the factors of production, then the profit would also have to exceed the interest they promise to pay for the borrowed funds.</strong> For this reason, the interest rate is a vital piece of information for entrepreneurs. If interest rates are high, then only high-revenue lines of production will be undertaken. If interest rates are low, then more lines of production become profitable.</p><p>In an unhampered market, interest rates are determined by supply and demand. If people become more willing to part with their present money, or save, then the supply of loanable funds will increase relative to demand, and the interest rate will fall. At the lower interest rate, more lines of production will become profitable because now entrepreneurs can borrow more cheaply to purchase factors of production. Since this scenario started with people becoming more willing to save, it’s also clear that the entrepreneurs will be able to purchase the real resources required for production. Consumers have shown that they are willing to consume less so now, more resources can be used by producers for production.</p><p>Let’s walk through a specific example of how this works:</p><blockquote>Suppose Tim Cook has an idea for how to produce one million Apple Watches and expects revenues from his sales to exceed his costs by 10%. He doesn’t have the money to pay for the machines and the laborers and the factories required to produce the watches, so he needs to borrow. The current interest rate is 15%, unfortunately for Tim Cook, so he just holds on to his idea for the time being.</blockquote><blockquote>However, a couple months later, due to the increased willingness for people to save and invest, the interest rate falls a whopping 10%, down to just 5%. Tim Cook reevaluates his plan and his expectations of profitability and decides to go for it. He borrows the money necessary to pay for laborers, machines, and factories and starts producing Apple Watches.</blockquote><blockquote>He sells his product and gets revenue that exceeds his cost by 12% — a little more than he was expecting! He pays back his creditors the amount he promised, 5%, which left him with 7% all to himself for taking the risks and producing something consumers like.</blockquote><p>The lower interest rate in this example encouraged the entrepreneur to produce and also signaled to the entrepreneur that resources have been freed up in the economy for use in production. Now let’s see what happens when entrepreneurs get a false signal from credit markets via monetary inflation.</p><p><strong>When a central bank decides to increase the money supply, the new money enters the economy through the same markets that people borrow and lend.</strong> The new money increases the supply of present money available for lending, which, as we all know, will decrease the price, or the interest rate in this case.</p><p>To be clear, this time, the lower interest rate does not reflect people’s willingness to save or invest, but only reflects the central bankers’ intervention. This artificially low interest rate sends all of the same signals to entrepreneurs and lenders that a normal interest rate does, but is not based on people’s real preferences.</p><p>When the central bank increases the money supply and interest rates fall, it induces more borrowing and less saving. Entrepreneurs are more than happy to take out the loans at the lower interest rate, but everybody else is less willing to save at the lower interest rate. The newly printed money makes up the difference.</p><p>Less saving means more consumption, and since the interest rate is so low, consumers may even borrow to finance even more consumption. Entrepreneurs take their funds and purchase factors of production, and at the new, lower interest rate, the lines of production they undertake are the ones that weren’t as profitable before. <strong>Everybody is happy as they consume, invest, earn higher wages, start new projects, and enjoy the ride to the top.</strong></p><p><strong>This high cannot last forever, though.</strong> Even though spending is climbing on all fronts, no new resources have been created, just new green slips of paper. The economy has not allocated real resources away from consumption and toward production, it has just stretched the existing resources thin. The signals entrepreneurs rely on were falsified and based on the whims of a few powerful people, not the collective, voluntary interactions of individuals everywhere.</p><p>The boom peaks and falls into a bust when some combination of these events unfolds:</p><ol><li>When the increasingly scarce factors of production become too expensive;</li><li>When the monetary spigot gets turned off and so consumption and investment run dry;</li><li>And when people start to realize the damage that has been done.</li></ol><p>The bust is characterized by under- and unemployment, falling prices, and a readjustment of capital throughout the economy. The bust is painful, but necessary and healthy.</p><p>Capital and laborers have been misallocated, funds malinvested, and lines of production that appeared to be profitable are revealed to be unprofitable in hindsight. The correction happens during the bust.<strong> In fact, the bust is the correction.</strong> Resources need to go where they are most highly valued, and the only system capable of such a daunting task is the unhampered market economy.</p><p>In the past and up to today, the necessary correction hasn&#39;t been allowed to run its course before central banks reinflate and restart the cycle. So, it’s unfortunate that we have to call it the boom-bust “cycle”, instead of the boom-bust “event”. If it were a one-time thing, we might forgive the ones responsible and say, “Ok, that was an interesting experiment. We didn&#39;t really think it was going to work, but now everybody knows.” Like the George Clooney/Arnold Schwarzenegger Batman movie.</p><p>But as the term “business cycle” suggests, the artificial booms and the painful busts continue because some people, especially the government, stand to benefit at the expense of others and because of a general lack of understanding of even the fundamental mechanisms at work.</p><p><strong>We can avoid the mess.</strong> People are getting into and developing currencies that are not tied to our fractional reserve and central banking system. Newer technologies are being adopted for loans to be processed at rates less affected by central bank manipulation.</p><p>Many people are realizing the disastrous record of central banking and expansionary monetary policy. The same people are learning the way to real economic growth via real savings and economically sustainable uses of our resources.</p><p>Maybe one day we’ll look back at the wrecking ball swings of our current economy the same way we look at Batman &amp; Robin starring George Clooney and Arnold Schwarzenegger: laughing, but cringing and shaking our heads.</p><img src="https://medium.com/_/stat?event=post.clientViewed&referrerSource=full_rss&postId=19b6dcdc1c66" width="1" height="1" alt=""><hr><p><a href="https://medium.com/jonathan-newman/inflation-and-business-cycles-19b6dcdc1c66">Inflation and Business Cycles</a> was originally published in <a href="https://medium.com/jonathan-newman">Jonathan Newman</a> on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.</p>]]></content:encoded>
        </item>
    </channel>
</rss>